Gabriel Faure SLa Bonne Chanson AJourney of Love and Rebirth
Gabriel Faure SLa Bonne Chanson AJourney of Love and Rebirth
Gabriel Faure SLa Bonne Chanson AJourney of Love and Rebirth
by
Department of Music
2019
ii
_______________________________________
Alexandra Nguyen
_______________________________________
Yonatan Malin
_______________________________________
Mutsumi Moteki
Date_________________
The final copy of this thesis has been examined by the signatories, and we
find that both the content and the form meet acceptable presentation standards
of scholarly work in the above mentioned discipline.
iii
Gabriel Fauré’s La bonne chanson, Op. 61 is a song cycle of nine songs. The cycle
was composed between 1892 and 1894, while Fauré was having an affair with an amateur
singer, Emma Bardac. Fauré’s selection of Paul Verlaine’s poems reflects his own emotional
journey at the time. Musically, Fauré utilized several recurring elements to bring coherence to
the cycle. However, while many sources focus on the occurrences of these themes, they do
not examine whether or not these musical elements have a connection to the overall story
Therefore, I was motivated to analyze this cycle with two goals. The first goal is to
uncover the hidden story suggested by Fauré’s selection and order of Verlaine’s poems. The
second goal is to investigate connections between the recurring musical themes and the story.
I have identified two central ideas that define the hidden story of La bonne
chanson. The first central idea is the narrator’s hope to be guided by his beloved. The second
central idea is his hope of new life. In the music, there are six recurring musical elements
that depict and support these two central ideas. In other words, under Fauré’s organization of
song sequence and the recurring musical elements, one can see that the narrator’s hopes of
In this paper, I will first examine how the two central ideas stem from the lives of
Verlaine and Fauré. Next, I will introduce the six recurring musical elements that support
these central ideas. Then, in my analysis, I will examine how these six elements depict the
two central ideas that drive the development of the story. In the end, I will provide
performance insights for musicians who are preparing or teaching this cycle. In conclusion,
this paper aims to provide collaborative pianists and vocalists with a better appreciation of
iv
the cycle’s overall structure and musical elements in order to inspire them to give a more
meaningful performance.
v
CONTENT
CHAPTER
I. Introduction 1
III. Analysis 11
3. La lune blanche 14
8. N’est-ce pas? 26
9. L’hiver a cessé 28
V. Conclusion 43
References 44
vi
MUSIC EXAMPLES
Example
4. Fauré, “J’allais par des chemins perfides,” La bonne chanson, mm. 13-18 16
6. Fauré, “J’allais par des chemins perfides,” La bonne chanson, mm. 46-33 18
10. Fauré, “Avant que tu ne t’en ailles,” La bonne chanson, mm. 9-11 23
11. Fauré, “Avant que tu ne t’en ailles,” La bonne chanson, mm. 72-79 24
12. Fauré, “Donc, ce sera par un clair jour d’été,” La bonne chanson, mm. 4-5 25
13. Fauré, “Donc, ce sera par un clair jour d’été,” La bonne chanson, mm. 26-30 25
TABLES
Table
2. Summary of the story arc, stage of story, central ideas, musical elements and key areas of
La bonne chanson 35
1
CHAPTER I
Introduction
preparing this work for my degree recital, I was fascinated by the complexity of its harmonic
language, thematic organization and structure. La bonne chanson has already been the subject
of a lot of research, which will be cited below. The basic background information about this
cycle is well understood. La bonne chanson is based on nine poems from Paul Verlaine’s
collection of the same name. Fauré intentionally selected specific poems from the collection
in order to reflect his own emotional journey. In addition, Fauré uses several musical
elements throughout the cycle to bring musical coherence. However, while other studies have
shown the occurrences of these musical elements, not many have investigated whether or not
poems and the recurring musical elements. After examining the content of the poems, I have
discovered two central ideas that are interwoven throughout the entire cycle. The first central
idea is the desire to be guided by a loved one. The second idea is the hope of a new life.
These two ideas seem to reflect the life experience of both Fauré and Verlaine. These ideas
are paramount because they are prevalent throughout the cycle. In addition, they appear to
govern the development of the story. In the poems and the music, one can see that the main
character’s wishes are fulfilled, and he receives the guidance and new life that he so desires
On a practical level, this paper hopes to assist musicians through deepening their
appreciation of the music and enriching their performances by understanding the role of
significant musical elements in the cycle. Beyond the practical implications for musicians,
my thesis aims to show that Fauré’s organization of recurring musical elements all work to
2
depict the two central ideas that drive the core story forwards. My research has uncovered
what I believe to be connections, both obvious and subtle, in the music and the poems that
contribute not only to the development of the story but also to the musical symbolization of
CHAPTER II
In La bonne chanson, one can find two central ideas that frame the structure of the
story. The first idea is the hope of being guided by someone you love. The second idea is the
hope of new life. Both ideas stem from the life experiences of Fauré and Verlaine at the time
Before Verlaine met his wife, Mathilde Mauté, his life was on a self-destructive
downward path. He “was already a potential alcoholic, was bisexual, and reacted with
violence at the least provocation.”1 When he met Mathilde, he fell in love at first sight. For
him, she was like “a goddess who would save him from himself.”2 He wanted Mathilde to be
the leader in their relationship and “to inspire him, she was to cleanse him of his past and
relieve him of his moral responsibilities.”3 To express his love for Mathilde, he composed
twenty one poems as a wedding gift to her. These poems became known as La bonne
chanson.
Fauré’s life before he met Emma bears some similarities to Verlaine’s. His life in his
30s was filled with stagnation. His engagement with Marianne Viardot was broken in 1877.
He eventually married Marie Fremiet in 1883 but the marriage was loveless. His work as
maître de chapelle and composer was not financially rewarding.4 Fauré had gone through a
period of depression and a drought of inspiration until he met Emma in 1892. Their
friendship blossomed into a passionate affair that led Fauré into an era of creativity and
originality in his music. It was at this time Fauré started to compose songs using poems from
Verlaine’s La bonne chanson. Emma had a charming light soprano voice and was an
1
Wallace David Weber, “A Comparative Analysis of Text and Music in Gabriel Fauré’s ‘La Bonne Chanson’
and ‘Le Jardin Clos,’” (D.M.A. diss., University of Missouri, 1988), 19, accessed February 21, 2019, ProQuest
Dissertations & Theses.
2
Ibid., 19.
3
Ibid., 19-20.
4
Jean-Michel Nectoux, Gabriel Fauré: A Musical Life. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1991), 24-37.
4
accomplished sight-reader.5 Therefore, she was not only his muse but in addition was
There is a similarity between Verlaine’s and Fauré’s lives at the time when they
composed their work. Both of them were unhappy with their lives before they met the women
they love. They both hoped that their beloved would lead them into a new chapter in their
lives.
Fauré’s selection and ordering of Verlaine’s poems outline a story that closely mirrors
Fauré’s emotional journey with Emma Bardac. More importantly, the development of this
While the central ideas are referenced frequently throughout the cycle, the first song
does not mention either of the central ideas. It merely provides the narrator’s impression of
the woman. In other words, this song functions as a prologue to the main narrative of the
story.
The second, third and fourth songs should be grouped together as they outline the next
stage of the story. The second song is the first to reveal the two central ideas of the cycle.
Therefore, it can be seen as the true beginning of the story. While the third song does not
specifically mention any of the central ideas, there is evidence to suggest that the actual union
of the two characters takes place in this song. Next, the fourth song provides confirmation
that both characters are united as one thus rounding off the first half of the cycle. These three
songs depict the narrator’s wish and fulfilment of the first central idea.
The fifth song is a transitional point of the cycle. The narrator admits his love and
this signifies that after the fulfilment of the first central idea, the narrator has achieved true
love.
5
Ibid., 180.
5
From this point forward, the second half of the cycle begins. The sixth, seventh and
eighth songs belong together as they are all about the character’s new life in the future. To
start this new stage of the story, the sixth song depicts scenes of dawn and the symbolic
arrival of the sun. It connects back to the second song and confirms that the narrator’s new
life has arrived. After this new beginning, the seventh song is about his future wedding.
Following on from that, the eighth song expresses the narrator’s hope of his future life with
his beloved and thus brings closure to the second half of the story. These three songs depict
Fittingly, the ninth song functions as the epilogue of the story. Spring is a metaphor
for new life and rebirth and the characters, despite all the difficulties in their past lives, have
The below table reflects a symmetry within the structure of the story outlined by La
bonne chanson. Central to the story is the concept of the journey of love that leads to rebirth.
The first and last songs function as the prologue and epilogue respectively. The second, third
and fourth songs develop the story arc that is governed by the first central idea. The fifth song
in the middle of the cycle is the transition from the first to the second central idea. The sixth,
seventh and eighth songs are governed by the second central idea and depict the narrator’s
future life.
In many ways, the song cycle La bonne chanson is a mirror reflection of the journey
Fauré took at this time in his life. The central ideas expressed in the music reflect his need to
be led into a new life. Musically, there are many linkages that refer to these ideas.
Understanding these references, no matter how subtle, would be beneficial for any
When analyzing this song cycle, I have discovered that Fauré’s organization of six
recurring musical elements can be interpreted as the realization of the two central ideas in the
work. While some elements are more obvious, others are more subtle and open to
interpretation. However, all these elements work cohesively to convey the story.
Among these six elements, the 1st, 2nd, 4th, 5th and 6th elements have been identified by
scholars such as Jean-Michel Nectoux6 and Robert Orledge.7 In addition, the 3rd element has
been identified by Dan Howard Kinsinger.8 Robert Orledge, in his book, Gabriel Fauré,
states that the function of these elements “is purely musical, for they are not linked with
recurring poetic images or ideas, and thus have no similarity with Wagnerian leitmotifs.”9
However, in my analysis, I have found that these elements are intrinsically connected with
the two central ideas mentioned above and help outline the emotional journey of the narrator.
Each of these elements has its own meaning and function within the cycle.
6
Nectoux, Gabriel Fauré: A Musical Life, 184.
7
Robert Orledge, Gabriel Fauré (London: Eulenberg Books, 1979), 83.
8
Dan Howard Kinsinger, The Seven Song Collections of Gabriel Fauré (D.M.A. Thesis: University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign, 1971), 97.
9
Orledge, Gabriel Fauré, 81.
7
This element is a meandering melody that first occurs in the first song. It is
commonly referred to as the “Carlovingien” element in reference to the last line of the song.
The shape of this element is based on a descending second interval followed by a larger
descending interval. (The specific intervals in the example above vary in other instances.) It
is a core element that will recur in many subsequent songs and functions as a connecting
thread for La bonne chanson. In this paper, this element will be labelled as the
“Carlovingien” element.
This element is named after a quote from the composer’s earlier song, Lydia, Op. 4,
no. 1. It has three noticeable features. First, it is built on a Lydian mode (major scale with
#4). Second, the first three notes are in stepwise motion of a major 3rd interval. Third, there
is a five-note ascending figure at the end of the element.10 Fauré would later create variations
of this element using the above features. In this paper, this element will be labelled as the
“Lydia” element.
10
Orledge, Gabriel Fauré, 84.
8
This element is associated with any broken-chord texture in the piano that is based on
16th triplet rhythm. While the other five recurring elements are easy to recognize, this element
occurs as the accompaniment in the piano. Kinsinger, in his thesis, The Seven Song
Collections of Gabriel Fauré, named this element as motive 2.11 His thesis, however, focuses
purely on the structural function of this recurring material in the cycle. In my analysis, I find
that this element and its variations are associated with the second central idea in the cycle. In
This element is commonly known as the “Que je vous aime” (That I love you)
element. It first appears in the 5th song, in the vocal line, “Que je vous aime,” to express the
narrator’s feelings to his love interest. This element recurs in the piano part of the seventh
and eighth songs. In both instances, it symbolizes the love between the two characters.
This element is commonly referred to as the “birdsong” element. It first appears in the
sixth song as a text painting of the quails’ and larks’ song at dawn. Symbolically, quails are
the birds of love and lust, and larks are associated with lovers and daybreak. This element
will reappear in the ninth song, which is about springtime, as one of the core musical
11
Kinsinger, The Seven Song Collections of Gabriel Fauré, 97.
9
elements. Musically, this element is a combination of two voices singing to each other. This
duality can also be interpreted as the two main characters of the love story.
This element is known as the “sun” element. It appears at the end of the sixth song as
a text painting of the golden sun and the arrival of light. It symbolizes the narrator’s new
phase of life after his union with his beloved. Therefore, this element reappears in the
seventh and ninth songs as one of the core elements. In this paper, this element will be
Among the six musical elements, “Carlovingien” and “Lydia” are the most important
elements because they represent the narrator and his beloved respectively. In other words,
these two elements represent Fauré and Emma Bardac. The fact that the “Lydia” element
represents Emma Bardac is obvious as the cycle is inspired by Fauré’s affair with her. In
addition, in an 1902 interview, when questioned by a young critic, Louis Aguettant, Fauré
admitted that this element refers to the singer. This singer very likely refers to Emma.12
During their affair, the composer would bring the manuscripts of the songs and ask Emma to
sing them. The musical setting of its first occurrence also seems to support this assumption.
In the third song, after the “Lydia” element appears in m. 9, it is followed by the vocal line
singing “Oh beloved,” which suggests that the “Lydia” element is a musical symbol of the
narrator’s love interest. If the “Lydia” element represents Emma, then one can assume that
12
Orledge, Gabriel Fauré, 83.
10
Throughout the cycle, there are many instances where both elements appear next to
each other, with the “Lydia” element followed by “Carlovingien.” If one assumes that the
“Carlovingien” element represent Fauré, then this feature would perfectly depict the first
central idea, that the narrator wishes to be led by his love interest. The close association of
CHAPTER III
Analysis
In La bonne chanson, the nine songs individually express different aspects of happiness
and love. On a deeper level, two central ideas are interwoven with six recurring elements to
outline an emotional journey that reflects Verlaine’s and Faure’s lives. In the following
analysis, we will demonstrate how these musical elements reflect the central ideas of the work.
Une Sainte en son auréole acts as the beginning of the love story. This song introduces the
narrator as the primary character in the story. The two main ideas of this cycle will revolve
around this narrator and his emotional journey. The song expresses the narrator’s impressions
and feelings for a woman through the first element (the “Carlovingien” element).
Example 1: Fauré, “Une Sainte en son auréole,” La bonne chanson, mm. 1-9.
This element expresses a sweet, gentle and lovely aura. When Fauré introduces this
element at the very beginning of the first song, the audience will sense the narrator’s feelings
12
for the woman. This element repeats many times in variation throughout this song. These
repetitions can be interpreted as the narrator’s obsession with her. The element’s emotion
changes too as it cycles through different variations. While the original element expresses
sweetness, its variations can convey heartache (mm. 44 - 47) and bliss (m. 48).
In addition, this element will represent the main character in the rest of the cycle. In
the subsequent songs, it will join with the second element (the “Lydia” element) to depict the
first central idea. Therefore, it is heavily interconnected throughout the rest of the cycle.
Consequently, this element also functions as a connecting thread that brings coherence to the
cycle.
Puisque l’aube grandit is a significant point of the story, as it reveals the first and
second central ideas of the cycle, namely the narrator’s hope that his love interest will lead him
along the path to a new life. The woman’s guidance and the hope of a new life will remain a
core idea for the rest of the cycle. Musically, Fauré introduces the second and third elements
that are associated with the second central idea, namely the hope of new life that is symbolized
by dawn.
13
Fauré uses the third element to begin this song that takes place in dawn. It depicts the
narrator’s excitement and anticipation of true love and happiness. Because of this
characteristic, Fauré employs this texture in songs that are associated with dawn and with
new life and hence are also connected with the second central idea. As the narrator’s new life
arrives in the sixth song, one can see this texture blossom in the second half of the cycle.
Therefore, this accompaniment pattern serves as a connection between the first and second
The second musical element in this song is the vocal phrase at mm. 2-4 (see example
2). It contains the five-note ascending figure of the “Lydia” element. Under the context of
14
this song, the five-note figure is paired with the word l’aurore (dawn), which is associated
with the second central idea as its rising contour can be seen as a text-painting of the rising
sun. This can be interpreted as a metaphor for new life. As this figure is a fragment of the
“Lydia” element, its appearance here can be interpreted as a prequel or introduction for the
“Lydia” element, which will appear in the next song. In addition, this figure also serves as
the motive in the third and fourth songs that Fauré uses to depict the first central idea.
This vocal phrase will reappear almost identically in the ninth song. As this phrase
only has one reappearance in the cycle, it is not categorized with the six recurring elements.
However, it is still a significant element because it connects the first half of the cycle to the
3. La lune blanche
The poem describes the scenery in the wood at night time, at an exquisite hour, which
implies sensuality. On the surface, this song doesn’t seem to contribute to the development of
the story. Consequently, Nectoux states that this song functions as an interlude between songs
2 and 4.13 However, the context of this song and its musical elements might suggest otherwise.
Fauré introduces the complete second element in m. 9 and connects it to a variation of the first
element in m. 12 that reflects the woman’s guidance (see example 3 below). 14 As this
connection is a symbol of the two character’s union one can assume that both characters have
become one in this song. As their union has been realised, another step has been taken on their
13
Nectoux, Gabriel Fauré: A Musical Life, 183-184.
14
Kinsinger, The Seven Song Collections of Gabriel Fauré, 106.
15
The next song, J’allais par des chemins perfides, functions as a reflection of the
narrator’s past life and the confirmation of the union between the two characters. The musical
setting of this song is significant. Fauré repeatedly uses variations of both the first and second
elements to reinforce the first central idea. He depicts the idea that his beloved has led him out
of his past and into their new union. This song is a significant point of the cycle because it is
a musical affirmation of their union which expresses the narrator’s joy of leaving his difficult
past behind.
16
Example 4: Fauré, “J’allais par des chemins perfides,” La bonne chanson, mm. 13-18.
enactment of the woman leading the narrator out of his past life (the first central idea). Fauré
first uses the five-note figure of the second element to depict the woman’s guidance in the
piano at m. 13. He then expands this figure into longer ascending scales in the LH (m. 14)
and RH (mm. 15-16). In m. 17, the scale eventually leads to the two-note walking motive,
which is taken from the first two notes of the “Carlovingien” element. This passage is paired
that the third song is also part of the story arc. Comparing mm. 13-14 of fourth song
(example 4) to mm. 38-39 of the third song (example 5), one can see that they are almost
In m. 13 of the fourth song (example 4), the second element is a half-step lower than
in the third song (example 5). In a way, this texture in the fourth song is like a continuing
development of the same texture from the third song. Therefore, this connection contradicts
Nectoux’s theory that the third song is an interlude between the second and the fourth songs
and does not contribute to the overall story.15 Fauré’s development of the music here
indicates that the fourth song is actually a continuation of third song. Both the musical
structure and the development of the story arc support this connection.
Fauré uses the first and second elements to again depict the union of the two
characters at the coda of this song. After the narrator has walked out of his past, he announces
that he and the woman have united (“love has reunited us in joy”). The elements-
combination again begins with the second element’s five-note figure in the RH of m. 46 (see
15
Nectoux, Gabriel Fauré: A Musical Life, p. 184.
18
example 6). It then expands into a long ascending scale starting in the LH in m. 47.16 It is
followed by the first element in the RH of the piano in m. 48, as the key modulates from F#
minor to F# major. Notice that the elements move in contrary motion. The first elements
moves downward as the scales moves upward. Both elements eventually meet in m. 52. This
juxtaposition of both elements’ material and their intersection is also a musical symbol of the
union. In m. 61, both elements join again into one chord under the word “joy”. In addition to
contour, the transformation from F# Lydian to F# major scale also plays a role in this text
painting. It should be noted that B# in mm. 46-54 suggests the use of F# Lydian scale. After
the union at m. 61, the B# is replaced by B and the F# major ascending scale (m. 61) lead to
Example 6: Fauré, “J’allais par des chemins perfides,” La bonne chanson, m. 46-53.
16
Orledge, Gabriel Fauré, 85.
19
As this song is a musical affirmation of the union of the two characters, it contains the
most instances in which both “Carlovingien” and “Lydia” elements appear together. This
J’ai presque peur, en vérité presents the narrator’s further reflection on his own state
of mind after his union with his beloved. He expresses fear of losing his newfound
happiness. Despite his insecurity, he assures himself that he loves her. The main element of
this song is a variation of the “Carlovingien” element. At the end of the song, Fauré introduces
the “Que je vous aime” element, which will become the musical symbol of the love between
the two characters. The change of focus away from the idea of the woman’s guidance into a
The combination of the “Carlovingien” and “Lydia” elements appear again in mm.
19-24 (example 7). In m. 19, the “Lydia” element appears in the LH of the piano part. It is
followed by the song’s main element, which is a variation of the “Carlovingien” element, in
the RH of the piano part at the last beat of m. 21. In addition to representing the first central
idea, both elements carry meaning in this context with the vocal line “This heart anxious
solely to love you and to please you.” Notice that the “Lydia” element enters right under the
word “vous” (you), suggesting that “Lydia” refers to the narrator’s love interest. For Fauré,
as he secretly uses “Lydia” to refer to Emma Bardac, this setting can be seen as his method to
confess his love to her. Moreover, the “Carlovingien” element can be interpreted as the text
Example 7: Fauré, “J’ai presque peur, en vérité,” La bonne chanson, mm. 16-23.
At the end of this song, Fauré introduces the “Que je vous aime” (That I love you)
element (example 8). In m. 42, the narrator’s fear has subsided. From m. 42 to the end, the
main element of the song becomes very prominent. The recurring main element in RH from
mm. 52-64 depicts the underlying emotion of the narrator. This emotion eventually bursts out
in the vocal line, “que je vous aime.” This affirmation of love is significant because it is the
first time that the narrator admits that he loves her. Fauré composed a declarative and
dramatic melody that would become the third recurring element that connects the rest of the
cycle and is also associated with the second central idea. For the more intimate “que je
t’aime,” Fauré set “t’aime” over G-A-B, a major 3rd that is the same as the beginning of the
“Lydia” element. The melody ends on E of E major, which is the same beginning note and
key of the first appearance of the “Lydia” element in the third song (refer to example 2).
21
Example 8: Fauré: “J’ai presque peur, en vérité, La bonne chanson, mm. 64-77.
Avant que tu ne t’en ailles represents a new chapter in the narrator’s life. The long
awaited dawn has finally arrived and is depicted brilliantly by the music. The song describes
several scenes at dawn and the narrator’s wish that his thoughts will travel into the dream of
his beloved. The arrival of the sun at the end of the song signifies the new life of the narrator
with his beloved (the second central idea). Fauré introduces the “birdsong” and “sun” elements,
In this song, the “Carlovingien” and “Lydia” elements appear at mm. 44, 48 and 52.
However, this time Fauré fuses them into one element to reference their union. The
beginning of the element is built on major 3rd, which is a “Lydia” feature; while the next
three notes are in the same intervals of “Carlovingien” (see example 9).17
Example 9: Fauré, “Avant que tu ne t’en ailles,” La bonne chanson, mm. 44-55.
Once again, the “Lydia” material comes before the “Carlovingien.” This refers to the
first central idea that the narrator is led by his love interest. Their fusion into one element is
also a symbol of their union. This octave melody is repeated three times and each time is
17
Orledge, Gabriel Fauré, 84.
23
higher than before. This ascending sequence depicts the rising sun and also implies that that
both of the characters are going into their new life which is musically symbolized by the
“sun” element.
Fauré uses the “bird-song” element to depict the quails and larks (mm. 8-14, and mm.
21-27). This element has two important features. First, it is a combination of two voices
singing to each other. This duality can be interpreted as the two main characters of the love
story. In the eighth song, there is a metaphor of the two lovers as nightingales singing
together. This element can be seen as a musical prequel of that metaphor. Second, the “bird-
song” element is accompanied by 16th-note broken chord figure that is related to the third
element in the second song. This 16th-note arpeggio accompaniment is related to the image
of dawn. In this song, Fauré fuses this accompaniment with the bird song to musically
Example 10: Fauré, “Avant que tu ne t’en ailles,” La bonne chanson, mm. 9-11.
The song eventually builds up to a climax at the end, where the “sun” element occurs
in the piano at m. 72. It is a text painting for the “golden sun” that is mentioned in the vocal
line. This element will become a significant music element in the seventh and ninth songs
24
because it is also associated with the second central idea. The arrival of the sun marks an
important point of the cycle as it represents the arrival of the narrator’s new life.
Example 11: Fauré, “Avant que tu ne t’en ailles,” La bonne chanson, mm. 72-79.
Donc, ce sera par un clair jour d’été opens on a description of the wedding day and
evening of the two characters. This song acts as the climax of the overall story arc as this is
what the story has been gradually building towards. The “sun” and arpeggio element both
represent the daytime and generate immense excitement. For the wedding night, the use of the
“que je vous aime” element is suggestive and reaffirms the union of the two characters.
Fauré incorporates the “sun” and the 16th arpeggio elements to depict the shining sun
(“Le grand soleil”) of the wedding day (example 12). The repetition of this element in the
first section of the song depicts the constant shining of the sun during the day and the
Example 12: Fauré, “Donc, ce sera par un clair jour d’été,” La bonne chanson, mm. 4-5.
Notice the shape of the arpeggio is a diminutive version of the one from the second
song. This similarity of shape connects this song back to the second song. Fauré varies this
accompaniment as the scene transitions from day to night. He slows down the rhythmic
value and also lowers its contour to depict the sunset (example 13).
Example 13: Fauré, “Donc, ce sera par un clair jour d’été,” La bonne chanson, mm. 26-30.
26
The “que je vous aime” (That I love you) element played only on the piano implies
that the evening air is filled with love. In addition, the music can be interpreted as a
declaration of love between the wedded couple. Musically, this element is lyrical and sits in
the lower register of the piano. It acts as a counterpart (intimacy; evening) to the “sun”
8. N’est-ce pas?
N’est-ce pas? is a hopeful episode in which the narrator reflects upon his ideal
married life in the future. He and his wife will walk along their path hand in hand together
and not worry about any obstacles. Fauré uses the “que je vous aime” element to symbolize
the two character’s love and union in their new life. This element first appears in the alto
voice of the piano in m. 14 to reflect the text “isolated in the wood with love.”
Later on, Fauré uses the “Que je vous aime” and “Lydia” elements in mm. 28-33 to
express his love to Emma Bardac. The “Que je vous aime” element enters in octaves in m.
the “Lydia” represents Emma Bardac. This particular order of the two elements can be
interpreted as a musical statement: I love you, Emma. Both elements represent the love and
In the epilogue, the arrangement of the “que je vous aime” element plays out the last
line “of those who love one another unreservedly.” The element appears in the tenor line in
the piano in m. 61 to represent the narrator (male). It then appears in the soprano line in the
piano in m. 63 to represent the woman (female). These two appearances can be interpreted as
the two characters singing “I love you” to each other. Finally, the element appears in octaves
m. 65, depicting them singing “I love you” at the same time. The expression of the
18
Orledge, Gabriel Fauré, 84.
28
characters love for each other starts to wind down the overall story arc and to bring fulfilment
to their lives.
9. L'hiver a cessé
L'hiver a cessé is the final episode of the story. As winter has ended and spring has
come, it signals the rebirth of the narrator and that he has emerged into a new life of joy and
happiness. This brings the second central idea into completion. Now that he is with his wife,
all of the seasons have become charming to him. Both musically and poetically, all elements
appear to bring closure to the cycle. Fauré brings back all the main musical elements as well
as multiple sections from previous songs to fully conclude the story and the cycle.
This song contains musical elements that are associated with both central ideas. This
song begins with the “birdsong” element and builds up to a high point, which is the arrival of
the “sun” element (example 16). This piano introduction is a text painting for the arrival of
spring. Accompanying the “sun” element is the arpeggio element, which is again associated
with light.
29
A fragment of the “Que je vous aime” element appears in the vocal phrases in mm.
15-16 (example 17).19 Although it is a subtle reoccurrence of this element, the vocalist should
still be sensitive to it. The shape of this phrase is a text painting of the light is dancing from
the ground to the heaven (“Et danse, du sol au firmament”). This ascending contour parallels
the text paintings of the rising sun from the second and sixth songs.
19
Orledge, Gabriel Fauré, 84.
30
The “Carlovingien” and “Lydia” elements make their final appearance in the ninth
song. The “Lydia” element appears in the vocal line from m. 26 (last eighth-note) to m. 28
piano (accented note) from m. 28 to m. 34. The order of the two elements once again refers to
the image of the woman leading the narrator through life into the future.
20
Nectoux, Gabriel Fauré: A Musical Life, p. 185.
31
From m. 44 to the end is a montage of various sections from previous songs (example
19). It is as if the narrator is reminiscing about the memories of his emotional journey. The
vocal phrase at mm. 44-47 closely resembles the first phrase of the second song at mm. 2-4
(refer to example 2). This phrase not only bring back the similar shape of the melody but it
also modulates to G major, a significant key in this cycle. The beginning of the story, the
32
second song, is set in G major. The end of the story, the eight song, is also set in G major.
This occurrence of G major in this song signifies the end narrator’s wishes are fulfilled and
The coda of this song in mm. 50-59 (example 20), contains music that is similar to the
ending of the previous songs. Measures 52-53 is similar to the ending of the first song.
33
Likewise mm. 54-55 is similar to the ending of the fourth song. Measures 56-59 are also similar
to the end of the seventh song. In addition, Fauré interweaves several fragments of the recurring
elements. The major 2nd figure (C-Bb) in mm. 56, 57 and 58 is from the “Carlovingien”
element. The Db-Eb-F melody in mm. 56-57 is from the “Lydia” element. The dotted rhythm
figure is from the “birdsong” element. Notice that both “Carlovingien” and “Lydia” elements
are closely intertwined together. They eventually join and became Bb major root position
chord, a symbol that both characters are united in harmony. This coda creates a fulfilling yet
CHAPTER IV
By understanding the relationship between the two central ideas and recurring musical
elements, performers can make artistic decisions that reflects the emotional journey of the cycle.
The following table provides the organization of the songs, stage of story, distribution of the
musical elements and key areas of each song. This information aims to provide a guideline for
Song Story arc Stage of story 1st central 2nd central idea Key
idea (1st, 2nd (3rd, 4th, 5th
elements) and 6th
elements)
4 Reflection and 1, 2 F#
confirmation on his minor
union
9 Epilogue Rebirth 1, 2 3, 4, 5, 6 Bb
Table 2. Summary of the story arc, stage of story, central ideas, musical elements and key areas of La
bonne chanson
36
First, pianists and vocalists who are preparing the performance of the entire cycle need
to group the songs in a manner that reflects the development of the story. In other words, they
will need to determine the length of pauses between each song. Second, they need to shape the
musical elements that reflects the development of the story. Considering the central ideas
Performers should take longer pauses between pivotal points in the cycle. Namely,
between the prologue (song 1), development (songs 2-3-4), transition (song 5), future (songs
6-7-8), and epilogue (song 9) sections. Within the songs of the same section, pauses should be
shorter. Next, performers should pay attention to the relationship of these recurring elements
The first song serves as the prologue of the story. Even though it doesn’t contain any
central ideas, musically it introduces the first element, the “Carlovingien” element, which
represents the main character. Because of its significance, pianists should bring out this
element whenever it appears. Particularly, pianists should pay attention to the first two intervals
of this element because they are integral to it. During its first appearance, the first interval is a
major second followed by a minor third. It expresses a sweet, gentle and lovely aura. This
element repeats many times in variation throughout this song. Variation 1 occurs in m. 16. It
contains a major 2nd followed by a tritone and expresses longing. Variation 2 occurs in m. 44.
Within the first song, these variations reflect the narrator’s obsessive feelings towards
his beloved. Pianists should alter their touch to suit the different moods that these variations
represent within the element. Even though vocalists only partially sing this element, they
should be sensitive to it because this element is a musical symbol of the narrator. Vocalists
should listen to the moods suggested by these elements intently in order to accurately portray
The second, third and fourth songs continue the development of the story. Performers
should take less time between these three songs because they are interconnected by the first
central idea. In addition, they should be aware of how the first and second musical elements
As the second song introduces both the first and second central ideas, it is considered
the beginning of the love story. Therefore, more time should be taken in between the first and
second songs. Musically, this song introduces the 5-note figure of the second element, the
“Lydia” element, which represents the main character’s love interest (refer to musical example
2). This 5-note figure is sung by the vocalist in m. 4 over the word “l’aurore”. Here, this
ascending figure (B-C#-D-E-F#) depicts sunrise. Vocalist should be aware that F#5 is an
important note that will appear in the next two songs to highlight significant words. The song
also introduces the third element, which is the 16th triplet arpeggio. As this element is
associated with the second central idea, pianists should apply more shape and color into this
figure.
The third song does not contain any central idea, however, the combination of both first
and second elements, the “Carlovingien-Lydia” sequence, and the context of the poem suggests
that both characters are united (refer to example 3). While the “Lydia” element is easy to
recognize, the variation of the “Carlovingien” element is not obvious as the element is
embedded within the octave passage. Therefore, pianists should not rush this passage. Instead,
they might like to apply a slight rubato to bring out this element. Vocalists should be aware
that as they are singing “O bien-aimée” (O beloved), the F#5 is a response to the characters’
union. In mm. 38-44, Fauré uses the five-note figure of the second element to construct a
contrapuntal texture (refer to example 5). Pianists should create an intimate atmosphere to set
up the mood for “C’est l’heure exquise” (It is the exquisite hour). Vocalists should be aware
that the high note of this phrase is again in F#5. They should use a seductive tone to reflect the
38
intimacy union. In addition, this section will reappear in variation in the next song. Therefore,
although Fauré marks pp, pianists should not play too softly. They should shape the 5-note
figure by using a slight crescendo so that audiences can recognize the similarity between the
In the fourth song, the narrator confirms that he has united with his love interest. One
can see the “Carlovingien-Lydia” sequence throughout the song. The passage in mm. 13-17 is
a variation from the coda of the third song (refer to example 4). Therefore, pianists might like
to use a gentle and intimate sound to play the 5-note figure as it represents the love interest. As
the figure extends into longer ascending scale, pianists should also bring out this scale as it
represents the guidance of the woman. Vocalists should be aware that this is the text painting
for their line “Vos chères mains furent mes guides” (Your dear hand were my guides).
In the coda, Fauré composed a fulfilling ending for the union of the two characters. The
complete “Carlovingien” element recurs again in joining the second element to represent the
characters’ union (refer to example 6). In m. 48, pianists should take time to change the mood
from F# minor to F# major. The element should express a longing that is similar to the one in
the first song. This will prepare the atmosphere for the vocalists to sing “L’amour, délicieux
vainqueur, nous a réunis dans la joie” (Love, that delightful conqueror, has reunited us in joy).
Note that Fauré once again sets an important word on the note F#5 (“L’amour,” m. 51). As this
song functions as the fulfilment of the first central idea, performers should take a longer pause
The fifth song stands as a turning point of the story. In it, after his union with his
beloved, the narrator achieves his true love. Musically, the “Carlovingien-Lydia” sequence
occurs only once (refer to example 7). At the end of the song, Fauré introduces the fourth
element, “Que je vous aime” to represent the narrator’s achievement of true love through their
union (refer to example 8). Leading into the arrival of the fourth element is a passage
39
containing multiple repetitions of first element (mm. 53-63). Although Fauré only marks pp,
pianists should create an undercurrent to depict the narrator’s bubbling emotions. It will set up
the atmosphere for the vocalists’ outburst of the passionate “Que je vous aime” element.
Vocalists should be aware that the more intimate “Que je t’aime” line ends on E4 and in E
major, the same note and key that appear in the first instances of the “Lydia” element in the
third song (refer to example 3). They should use a warmer tone as they are reaching the final
E4. Performers should take a longer pause after this song because the next song marks the
The sixth, seventh and eighth songs depict the narrator’s future. In addition, they are
interconnected by recurring elements. Therefore, performers should take less time in between
these songs.
In the sixth song, the daybreak signifies the beginning of narrator’s new phase of life.
Fauré uses the 5th element, birdsong, to foreshadow daybreak (refer to example 10). In addition,
Fauré brings back the third element to accompany the birdsong. Both elements represent the
narrator’s excitement of his new life. Therefore, transitioning from the slower section into the
faster section in mm. 8, 21 and 34, pianists should be able to alternate the mood immediately
to highlight these elements. The “Carlovingien-Lydia” sequence appears three times in mm.
44-54 suggesting that both characters are heading to a new phase of life that is represented by
the sun (refer to example 9). Pianists should be aware that each time this sequence occurs, it is
a third higher than before. This ascending motion can be seen as a depiction of the rising sun.
Therefore, each time the sequence occurs (mm. 44, 48 and 54), pianists should play its melody
and harmony with increasing intensity. The sixth element, the “sun,” arrives in the piano part
in m. 72 (refer to example 11). In response, vocalists sing “Car voici le soleil d’or” (For here
is the golden sun). Both performers should be aware that this is the representation of the
narrator’s new life. At the downbeat of m. 76, Fauré finally brings the song into the home key,
40
Db major. In addition, vocalists are singing her “d’or” (golden) in her high note F5 while
pianists are matching it with a brilliant Db major chord underneath. Therefore they should
In the seventh song, the characters get married. The song describes the wedding day
and night. Performers should be aware that this song is connected to the sixth song not only
chronologically, but also by the image of the sun and its corresponding musical elements. The
sun arrives at the end of the previous song. Then, in the beginning of the seventh song, the
narrator describes that his wedding will be on a summer day with a grand sun in the sky.
Musically, the “sun” element appears in the piano postlude and the music fades towards the
end. Interestingly, Fauré begins this song by using the third element in pp. Therefore, pianists
should make the transition between the sixth and seventh songs as seamless as possible. In the
first half of the seventh song (mm. 1-26), the “sun” element is dominant and descriptive.
Performers should be sensitive to this and bring out the colourful harmony that depicts the blue
sky and the narrator’s immense happiness. Pianists should also be attentive to the LH
accompaniment, which is a variation of the third element. Together with the “sun” element,
they depict the bright summer day and the buoyancy of the narrator’s mood (refer to example
12). The fourth element, “Que je vous aime” enters in m. 28 (refer to example 13). It suggests
that the characters are united on their wedding night. Therefore, pianists should use the warmest
and most intimate tone to play this element. It will set the mood for the vocalists to sing about
the wedding night in m. 29, “Et quand le soir viendra, l’air sera doux” (And when the evening
After their wedding, the narrator states in the eighth song that he and his beloved will
walk the path of their future life together. Performers should notice that the LH of the piano
part contains two voices. It can be seen as a musical symbol of the two characters walking.
41
Therefore, pianists should bring out the interaction of the two voices rather than playing them
like chords. In m. 14, the 4 element, “Que je vous aime” appears in the alto voice in the piano
th
(refer to example 14). Pianists should highlight this element as vocalists will respond to it by
singing “Isolés dans l’amour ainsi qu’en un bois noir” (Isolated in love as in a dark wood). In
mm. 29-35, pianists should bring out both the “Que je vous aime” and “Lydia” elements as
they represent the hidden message from Fauré to Emma Bardac: I love you, Emma. (refer to
example 15). This song functions as the end of the story as both central ideas are fulfilled at
this point. For such an important moment, performers should take a longer pause after the
eighth song. Both performers should be aware that this song is in G major, the same key as the
second song at the beginning of the story. This creates a symmetry within the structure of the
cycle.
The last song does not contain any central ideas. However, the waning of winter and
arrival of spring is a metaphor for the rebirth of the narrator’s spirituality. Musically it is the
accumulation of all the recurring elements of the cycle. The song begins with the “bird song”
element, leading to the “sun” element that is accompanied by the third element (refer to
example 16). These three elements work together to depict the arrival of spring. Pianists should
start as quietly as possible. Then they should perform an eruptive crescendo to match the arrival
of the “sun” element in m. 6. This would establish the mood for the narrator to declare “L’hiver
a cessé” (Winter has ended). Vocalists should be aware that a fragment of “Que je vous aime”
appears in the line “au firmament” in m. 15 (refer to example 17). The “Carlovingien-Lydia”
sequence occurs in mm. 26-31 (refer to example 18). Vocalists should recognize that they are
singing the “Lydia” element in the line “Ainsi qu’une flamme entoure une flamme” and they
should internally pass the music line to the pianists. Pianists will then play the “Carlovingien”
element in the accented notes in the piano. Pianists should bring out this element even though
the score is marked pp. From m. 44 to the end is a montage-like sequence of sections from
42
previous songs. It is as if the narrator is reminiscing about his memories of his emotional
journey. In m. 44, the song modulates to G major, the key of the second and eighth songs. In
addition, the vocal phrase here is almost identical to the first vocal phrase of the second song
(refer to example 19). Performers should emphasize the arrival of the G major and this phrase
to make the connection to the second song very clear. At the coda (mm. 50-59), pianists should
imitate the return of previous songs (refer to example 20). Measures 52-53 comes from the first
song. Measures 54-55 comes from the fourth song. The last four measures of the song are
similar to the end of the seventh song. The RH of the piano contains fragments of the “Lydia,”
“Carlovingien” and “birdsong” elements. Pianists should particularly sensitive to and bring out
the voicing of the “Lydia” and “Carlovingien” fragments. As two elements once again
intertwined together and resolve into Bb major, they symbolize the characters union in
harmony.
Both pianists and vocalists should be sensitive to the integral musical elements of the
cycle. They should pay attention to the relationship between these musical elements and the
poem as well as the two central elements that connect the whole cycle. Their performance
should reflect a knowledge of Fauré’s emotional journey and his organization of the musical
elements.
43
Chapter V
Conclusion
La bonne chanson is a significant French song cycle for several reasons. The first is
Fauré’s ability to draw on his own life for inspiration and to reflect this within his music.
This unique background inspired him to create a very personal work that stands as a
monument to his love affair. His selection and arrangement of nine of Verlaine’s poems
effectively mirrored his own emotional journey and expressed his love and affection for
Emma Bardac. On the surface, the songs express feelings of joy and happiness in different
scenarios. However, when considering Verlaine’s and Fauré’s lives as they composed their
work, one can uncover two central ideas that govern the development of the main character’s
love story. Through these two central ideas, the main character expresses his wish that his
love interest guide him toward a new phase of life. In the music, Fauré brilliantly uses six
recurring elements to play out the evolution of these two central ideas. By observing the
relationship between the two central ideas and Fauré’s organization of the musical elements
throughout the cycle, one can see that the main character’s wish is eventually fulfilled. An
understanding of this story provides the perspective and context to inspire rich and
meaningful performances.
44
References:
Kinsinger, Dan Howard. “The seven song collections of Gabriel Fauré.” D.M.A. thesis,
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1971.
Weber, Wallace David. “A Comparative Analysis of Text and Music in Gabriel Faure’s
‘La Bonne Chanson’ and ‘Le Jardin Clos.’” D.M.A. diss. University of Missouri-
Kansas City, 1988. Accessed February 21, 2019, ProQuest Dissertations & Theses.