Scientific American - April 2019

ORGAN REPAIRS DENGUE DEBACLE HOW EELS GET ELECTRIC
The forgotten compound that can A vaccination program Insights into their shocking
repair damaged tissue PAGE 56 gone wrong PAGE 38 attack mechanisms PAGE 62
MIND READER
A new brain-machine interface detects what the user wants
S
PLU
QUANTUM
GRAVITY
IN A LAB
Could new experiments APRIL 2019
pull it off? PAGE 48 © 2019 Scientific American ScientificAmerican.com
A pr il 2 0 1 9
VO LU M E 3 2 0 , N U M B E R 4
48
N E U R OT E C H PHYSIC S
24 The Intention Machine 48 Quantum Gravity
A new generation of brain-machine in the Lab
interface can deduce what a person Novel experiments could test
wants. By Richard Andersen the quantum nature of gravity
INFR A STRUC TURE
on a tabletop. By Tim Folger
32 Beyond Seawalls MEDICINE
Fortified wetlands and oyster reefs 56 A Shot at Regeneration
can protect shorelines better than A once forgotten drug compound
hard structures. By Rowan Jacobsen could rebuild damaged organs.
By Kevin Strange and Viravuth Yin
P U B L I C H E A LT H
38 The Dengue Debacle A N I M A L P H Y S I O LO G Y
In April 2016 children in the Philip- 62 Shock and Awe
pines began receiving the world’s Understanding the electric eel’s
first dengue vaccine. Almost two unusual anatomical power.
By Kenneth C. Catania ON THE C OVE R
years later new research showed Tapping into the brain’s neural circuits lets people
that the vaccine was risky for many M AT H E M AT I C S with spinal cord injuries manipulate computer
kids. The campaign ground to 70 Outsmarting cursors and robotic limbs. Early studies underline
a halt, and the public exploded a Virus with Math the need for technical advances that make
brain-machine interfaces faster and more
in outrage. What went wrong? How calculus helped to drive versatile. The latest versions may begin to realize
By Seema Yasmin and the fight against HIV. the promise of direct neural communication.
Madhusree Mukerjee By Steven Strogatz Illustration by Mark Ross.
Photograph by Mattia Balsamini April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 1
© 2019 Scientific American

3 From the Editor
4 Letters
6 Science Agenda
Has the World Health Organization taken a perilous step
by endorsing traditional Chinese medicine? By the Editors
7 Forum
Forests’ ability to sequester carbon could mitigate
climate change. By Han de Groot
8 Advances
Developing a “cochlear implant for smell.” Some forms
of bias are declining. Identifying ancient predators.
How to fail successfully. Finding the entropy in art.
10
20 The Science of Health
Treatments of just hours or days can work for OCD,
phobias and other conditions. By Claudia Wallis
22 Ventures
Keep mind reading out of neural interfaces. By Wade Roush
76 Recommended
Documentary and companion book about planet Earth.
Realism and quantum mechanics. Saving a generation
from the effects of thalidomide. By Andrea Gawrylewski
77 The Intersection
YouTube’s recommendation algorithms lead users
down rabbit holes. By Zeynep Tufekci
78 Anti Gravity
20
Arctic warming made January’s weather weird and wacky.
By Steve Mirsky
79 50, 100 & 150 Years Ago
80 Graphic Science
Introducing new words that last. By Mark Fischetti and
Valentina D’Efilippo
ON THE WEB
A New Era of Human Spaceflight

Rockets and spacecraft built by SpaceX and Boeing are set to
transport U.S. astronauts to the International Space Station.
Scientific American d
etails the rise of “New Space.”
Go to www.ScientificAmerican.com/apr2019/new-space
76
Scientific American (ISSN 0036-8733), Volume 320, Number 4, April 2019, published monthly by Scientific American, a division of Springer Nature America, Inc., 1 New York Plaza, Suite 4600, New York, N.Y. 10004-1562. Periodicals
postage paid at New York, N.Y., and at additional mailing offices. Canada Post International Publications Mail (Canadian Distribution) Sales Agreement No. 40012504. Canadian BN No. 127387652RT; TVQ1218059275 TQ0001.
Publication Mail Agreement #40012504. Return undeliverable mail to Scientific American, P.O. Box 819, Stn Main, Markham, ON L3P 8A2. Individual Subscription rates: 1 year $49.99 (USD), Canada $59.99 (USD), International
$69.99 (USD). I nstitutional Subscription rates: Schools and Public Libraries: 1 year $84 (USD), Canada $89 (USD), International $96 (USD). Businesses and Colleges/Universities: 1 year $399 (USD), Canada $405 (USD),
International $411 (USD). Postmaster: Send address changes to Scientific American, Box 3187, Harlan, Iowa 51537. Reprints inquiries: (212) 451-8415. To request single copies or back issues, call (800) 333-1199.
Subscription inquiries: U.S. and Canada (800) 333-1199; other (515) 248-7684. Send e-mail to [email protected].
Printed in U.S.A. Copyright © 2019 by Scientific American, a division of Springer Nature America, Inc. All rights reserved.
Scientific American is part of Springer Nature, which owns or has commercial relations with thousands of scientific publications (many of them can be found at www.springernature.com/us). Scientific American maintains
a strict policy of editorial independence in reporting developments in science to our readers. Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
2 Scientific American, April 2019

FROM
Mariette DiChristina is editor in chief of Scientific American. THE EDITOR
Follow her on Twitter @mdichristina
The Joy of Science

“I get goose bumps e very time I see it.” “I saw something so What was so strange a biologist had to drop other things to
strange that I had to drop everything else to investigate.” “A tale check it out? Kenneth C. Catania explains the allure of the
of shark bites at a Scottish pub has led us to some new ideas electric eel’s shocking attacks. As an eel hit a prey fish in a tank
about rebuilding broken bodies.” with high voltage, all the other nearby fish became
Those sentences appear in three of stock-still in just three milliseconds, floating like
the feature articles in this issue writ- “little statues” in the water. “I was hooked,” Catania
ten by the researchers who are doing describes in “Shock and Awe,” his fourth article
the work. As a culture, we often focus for S
cientific American. “I had to know how the
on the achievements of science. But for eel’s electric attack worked.” In a series of
me, the stories of how we got to those out- experiments, he has discovered how the
comes—including the side tracks and the eel employs electric fields to track and
bumps in the road—are not to be missed. immobilize prey. When threatened by
And you can find them in our print and digi- a potential predator, it can leap
tal editions. from the water to intensify the
What gives a neuroscientist goose bumps, current delivered. You can learn
for instance? In “The Intention Machine,” the how by turning to page 62.
issue’s cover story, Richard Andersen writes Dive into “A Shot at Regenera-
about watching a paralyzed person in a wheelchair tion,” beginning on page 56, to find
using thoughts to control a computer or a robotic out how shark bites drew the attention of inves-
limb. These brain-machine interfaces can send and tigators Kevin Strange and Viravuth Yin: not the bites them-
receive communications to and from neural circuits selves, actually, but what happened to the wounded dolphins
in the body. Whereas existing interfaces are imprecise or slug- afterward. Strange and Yin heard a story about how dolphins
gish, newer versions could be placed in brain areas that would were beset by sharks, receiving bite wounds “45 centimeters
allow them to deduce a person’s intentions to move. That would long and 12 centimeters deep. But remarkably the dolphins
make them more versatile for individuals with certain injuries. healed up in weeks, with no signs of infection.” What could heal
Andersen’s feature starts on page 24. tissue so quickly? I won’t spoil the surprise.
BOARD OF ADVISERS
Leslie C. Aiello Edward W. Felten Lene Vestergaard Hau Satyajit Mayor Daniela Rus
President, Wenner-Gren Foundation Director, Center for Information Mallinckrodt Professor Senior Professor, National Center Andrew (1956) and Erna Viterbi Professor
for Anthropological Research Technology Policy, Princeton University of Physics and of Applied Physics, for Biological Sciences, Tata Institute of Electrical Engineering and Computer
Science and Director, CSAIL, M.I.T.
Jonathan Foley Harvard University of Fundamental Research
Robin E. Bell Eugenie C. Scott
Research Professor, Lamont-Doherty Executive Director and William R. Hopi E. Hoekstra John P. Moore
Chair, Advisory Council,
Earth Observatory, Columbia University and Gretchen B. Kimball Chair, Alexander Agassiz Professor Professor of Microbiology and
National Center for Science Education
California Academy of Sciences of Zoology, Harvard University Immunology, Weill Medical
Emery N. Brown Terry Sejnowski
Jennifer Francis Ayana Elizabeth Johnson College of Cornell University
Edward Hood Taplin Professor of Professor and Laboratory
Medical Engineering and of Senior Scientist, Woods Hole Founder and CEO, Donna J. Nelson Head of Computational
Computational Neuroscience, M.I.T., Research Center Ocean Collective Professor of Chemistry, Neurobiology Laboratory,
and Warren M. Zapol Professor Kaigham J. Gabriel Christof Koch University of Oklahoma Salk Institute for Biological Studies
of Anesthesia, Harvard Medical School President and Chief Executive Officer, President and CSO, Robert E. Palazzo Meg Urry
Charles Stark Draper Laboratory Allen Institute for Brain Science Dean, University of Alabama Israel Munson Professor of Physics
Vinton G. Cerf
Harold “Skip” Garner Morten L. Kringelbach at Birmingham College and Astronomy, Yale University
Chief Internet Evangelist, Google
Executive Director and Professor, Associate Professor and Senior of Arts and Sciences
George M. Church Michael E. Webber
Primary Care Research Network Research Fellow, The Queen’s College, Rosalind Picard Co-director, Clean Energy Incubator,
Director, Center for Computational
and Center for Bioinformatics University of Oxford Professor and Director, Affective and Associate Professor,
Genetics, Harvard Medical School
and Genetics, Edward Via College Robert S. Langer Computing, M.I.T. Media Lab Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Rita Colwell of Osteopathic Medicine David H. Koch Institute Professor, Carolyn Porco University of Texas at Austin
Distinguished University Professor, Michael S. Gazzaniga Department of Chemical Leader, Cassini Imaging Science George M. Whitesides
University of Maryland College Park Director, Sage Center for the Study Engineering, M.I.T. Team, and Director, CICLOPS, Professor of Chemistry and
and Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Mind, University of California, Space Science Institute
Meg Lowman Chemical Biology, Harvard University
of Public Health Santa Barbara Senior Scientist and Lindsay Chair Lisa Randall Amie Wilkinson
COVER IMAGE BY MARK ROSS
Drew Endy Carlos Gershenson of Botany, California Academy of Professor of Physics, Professor of Mathematics,
Professor of Bioengineering, Research Professor, National Sciences, and Rachel Carson Center Harvard University University of Chicago
Stanford University Autonomous University of Mexico for Environment and Society, Ludwig Martin Rees Anton Zeilinger
Nita A. Farahany Alison Gopnik Maximilian University Munich Astronomer Royal and Professor Professor of Quantum Optics,
Professor of Law and Philosophy, Professor of Psychology and John Maeda of Cosmology and Astrophysics, Quantum Nanophysics,
Director, Duke Initiative for Affiliate Professor of Philosophy, Global Head, Computational Institute of Astronomy, Quantum Information,
Science & Society, Duke University University of California, Berkeley Design + Inclusion, Automattic, Inc. University of Cambridge University of Vienna
Illustration by Nick Higgins April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 3

LETTERS
[email protected]
“All technologies your electron to be “up” to send a “yes” re-

sponse. When it is measured, the electron,
must be evaluated not you, will “choose” with a 50 percent
in the current reality probability of whether it will be up or
down. It is no better than flipping a coin.
that anything that
can be exploited WISE TECHNOLOGIES
In “Sacred Groves,” Madhav Gadgil dis-
for a profit probably cusses the ecological benefits of areas of
will, regardless primeval forest in India protected as the
homes of deities. Gadgil illustrates how
of the dangers.” the sacred in traditional cultures can
geoff davies transmit practical wisdom distilled from
australian national university bitter experience, which we need to help
save our planet. Such perspectives make
me less sanguine about the technologies
relation of the two gloves is determined Scientific American o ften features. I ap-
the moment they are placed in their enve- preciate the lure of discovery, having had
December 2018 lopes and is an example of a “hidden vari- a 40-year career in the physics of the
able theory.” John Bell showed that any earth, but not everything we might create
such theory will not have correlations that ought to be created. All technologies must
TALES OF ENTANGLEMENT are as rich as those allowed by quantum be evaluated in the current reality that
“Spooky Action,” by Ronald Hanson and entanglement. In our experiments, once anything that can be exploited for a profit
Krister Shalm, discusses quantum entan- our particles are sent to their distant loca- probably will, regardless of the dangers.
glement, in which two particles exhibit a tions, they are randomly measured in one The greatest service to humanity at the
“spooky” connection regardless of distance. of two ways. Because the particles do not moment would be rendered not by imple-
The authors do not explain why some- know in advance how we are measuring menting technical innovations of uncer-
thing as nonspooky as the following can’t them, they cannot agree ahead of time how tain benefit but by gaining the emotional
be going on: Suppose I hide a pair of gloves to correlate their outcomes. It appears as if maturity to appreciate and act on the kind
in two different envelopes and send one measuring one particle randomly and in- of wisdom portrayed in “Sacred Groves.”
(without knowing which) to my friend on stantaneously influences its distant part- Geoff Davies R etired senior fellow,
Mars, with a note to open it on receipt. The ner, which is the spookiness that Albert Australian National University
envelopes are now “entangled” because if Einstein referred to.
my friend finds a left glove, then I will find In answer to Morrison: It is possible to OCEAN CONSERVATION
a right glove, and vice versa—before a light entangle many different particles with In “The Last of the Ocean Wilderness” [Fo-
signal has had time to travel to Earth. one another, and this is an active area of rum], Kendall Jones and James Watson
Gordon B. Hazen Professor emeritus research—for instance, for building quan- raise the point that we have depleted about
of industrial engineering and manage- tum computers. But if two particles are “90 percent of formerly important coastal
ment sciences, Northwestern University maximally entangled, there can be no en- species” and that any conservation agree-
tanglement with any other particles at the ments should set wilderness-retention tar-
The article made this old sci-fi fan’s imag- same time. In that sense, entanglement is gets. But their recommendation does not
ination run wild. Do we know that entan- indeed monogamous, which ensures a lev- go far enough. I think to be successful over
gled particles are “monogamous”? If an el of privacy that is unmatched in classi- the short and the long term, we must also
electron can be entangled with one part- cal physics and is at the heart of quantum spearhead public campaigns that identify
ner, why not multiple partners simultane- applications in secure communication. overexploited ocean species, explain what
ously? Could entanglement be a relation- Alas, faster-than-light communication classifies as pollution and how it can affect
ship among a large number of particles must remain science fiction. With entan- ocean life, and make a list of recommend-
independent of location? And if so, could glement, the outcome is random but corre- ed actions geared toward the average con-
manipulating allow for truly instant mes- lated. Let’s say you and a distant friend sumer. And we should monitor overfish-
saging across interstellar distances? share entangled electrons and have agreed ing or illegal fishing by enforcing existing
Bob Morrison A sheboro, N.C. that if they are measured to be “up,” that legislation; using nontransferable unique
means “yes,” whereas “down” means “no.” numbers to tag fishing vessels; encourag-
THE AUTHORS REPLY: R egarding Ha- Your partner will get the same result as you, ing seafood traceability through documen-
zen’s suggestion: Just as “correlation does so the electrons appear to have somehow tation; and monitoring vessels via inspec-
not imply causation,” it does not always influenced one another faster than the tion stations, drones and satellites.
imply entanglement. The nonspooky cor- speed of light. But there is no way to force Vasilios Vasilounis B rooklyn, N.Y.

ESTABLISHED 1845
EDITOR IN CHIEF AND SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT

Mariette DiChristina
Curtis Brainard Maria-Christina Keller Michael Mrak
ATTRIBUTION LEERY MANAGING EDITOR COPY DIRECTOR CREATIVE DIRECTOR
EDITORIAL
Please refrain from misattributing pop
CHIEF FEATURES EDITOR Seth Fletcher CHIEF NEWS EDITOR Dean Visser CHIEF OPINION EDITOR Michael D. Lemonick
ular sayings to celebrities. “Rethinking FEATURES
the ‘Anthropocene,’ ” by the Editors [Sci- SENIOR EDITOR, SUSTAINABILITY Mark Fischetti SENIOR EDITOR, SCIENCE AND SOCIETY Madhusree Mukerjee
SENIOR EDITOR, CHEMISTRY / POLICY / BIOLOGY Josh Fischman SENIOR EDITOR, TECHNOLOGY / MIND Jen Schwartz
ence Agenda], quotes Albert Einstein as SENIOR EDITOR, SPACE / PHYSICS Clara Moskowitz SENIOR EDITOR, EVOLUTION / ECOLOGY Kate Wong
asserting, “We cannot solve our problems NEWS

SENIOR EDITOR, MIND / BRAIN Gary Stix ASSOCIATE EDITOR, TECHNOLOGY Sophie Bushwick
with the same thinking we used when we ASSOCIATE EDITOR, SPACE / PHYSICS Lee Billings ASSOCIATE EDITOR, SUSTAINABILITY Andrea Thompson
ASSISTANT EDITOR, NEWS Tanya Lewis
created them.” There is no evidence that
DIGITAL CONTENT
Einstein said or wrote those words. The MANAGING MULTIMEDIA EDITOR Eliene Augenbraun ENGAGEMENT EDITOR Sunya Bhutta
SENIOR EDITOR, MULTIMEDIA Steve Mirsky COLLECTIONS EDITOR Andrea Gawrylewski
nearest we come seems to be a passage in
ART
a 1948 essay in which he argued that a ART DIRECTOR Jason Mischka SENIOR GRAPHICS EDITOR Jen Christiansen
“supranational organization” should be PHOTOGRAPHY EDITOR Monica Bradley ART DIRECTOR, ONLINE Ryan Reid
ASSOCIATE GRAPHICS EDITOR Amanda Montañez ASSISTANT PHOTO EDITOR Liz Tormes
given sole authority over atomic weapons:
“Our situation is not comparable to any- COPY AND PRODUC TION
SENIOR COPY EDITORS Michael Battaglia, Daniel C. Schlenoff COPY EDITOR Aaron Shattuck
thing in the past. It is impossible, there- MANAGING PRODUCTION EDITOR Richard Hunt PREPRESS AND QUALITY MANAGER Silvia De Santis
fore, to apply methods and measures D I G I TA L
which at an earlier age might have been PRODUCT MANAGER Ian Kelly WEB PRODUCER Jessica Ramirez
CONTRIBUTOR S
sufficient. We must revolutionize our
EDITORIAL David Biello, Deboki Chakravarti, Lydia Denworth, W. Wayt Gibbs, Ferris Jabr,
thinking, revolutionize our actions, and Anna Kuchment, Robin Lloyd, Melinda Wenner Moyer, George Musser,
Christie Nicholson, John Rennie, Ricki L. Rusting
must have the courage to revolutionize re- ART Edward Bell, Bryan Christie, Lawrence R. Gendron, Nick Higgins
lations among nations of the world. Cli-
EDITORIAL ADMINISTRATOR Ericka Skirpan SENIOR SECRETARY Maya Harty
chés of yesterday will no longer do today,
and will, no doubt, be hopelessly out of
date tomorrow.” PRESIDENT
Dean Sanderson
Steven Wenner C ohasset, Mass.
EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT Michael Florek
CLIENT MARKETING SOLUTIONS

THE EDITORS REPLY: We would like to VICE PRESIDENT, COMMERCIAL Andrew Douglas
thank Wenner for pointing out that this PUBLISHER AND VICE PRESIDENT Jeremy A. Abbate
MARKETING DIRECTOR, INSTITUTIONAL PARTNERSHIPS AND CUSTOMER DEVELOPMENT Jessica Cole
quote is most likely apocryphal, as is in- PROGRAMMATIC PRODUCT MANAGER Zoya Lysak
DIRECTOR, INTEGRATED MEDIA Jay Berfas
dicated by the seeming elusiveness of a DIRECTOR, INTEGRATED MEDIA Matt Bondlow
primary source and the existence of sev- SENIOR ADMINISTRATOR, EXECUTIVE SERVICES May Jung
eral variations. In the future, we will not CONSUMER MARKETING

HEAD, MARKETING AND PRODUCT MANAGEMENT Richard Zinken
allow for the inclusion of any quotes com- E-MAIL MARKETING MANAGER Chris Monello
monly attributed to famous figures unless MARKETING AND CUSTOMER SERVICE COORDINATOR Christine Kaelin
they can be fully substantiated. ANCILL ARY PRODUC TS

ASSOCIATE VICE PRESIDENT, BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT Diane McGarvey
CUSTOM PUBLISHING EDITOR Lisa Pallatroni
CLARIFICATION RIGHTS AND PERMISSIONS MANAGER Felicia Ruocco
“A Meditation on Keyboard Shortcuts,” by C O R P O R AT E

HEAD, COMMUNICATIONS, USA Rachel Scheer
David Pogue [TechnoFiles], should not
PRINT PRODUC TION
have implied that Apple was the first to use
PRODUCTION CONTROLLER Madelyn Keyes-Milch ADVERTISING PRODUCTION CONTROLLER Dan Chen
keyboard shortcuts by referring to them
as “Apple’s brilliant innovation.” The com-
pany was an early adopter of shortcuts.
LE T TER S TO THE EDITOR
Scientific American, 1 New York Plaza, Suite 4600, New York, NY 10004-1562 or [email protected]
ERRATA Letters may be edited for length and clarity. We regret that we cannot answer each one.
“Hidden Inferno,” by Shannon Hall, should Join the conversation online—visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter.
have described winds blowing potential H O W T O C O N TA C T U S
volcanic ash from the Laguna del Maule Subscriptions Reprints Permissions
region in Chile to Argentina as westerly, For new subscriptions, renewals, gifts, To order bulk reprints of articles For permission to copy or reuse material:
payments, and changes of address: Permissions Department, Scientific
not easterly. Further, it should not have de- U.S. and Canada, 800-333-1199;
(minimum of 1,000 copies):
American, 1 New York Plaza, Suite 4600,
Reprint Department,
scribed 1,200 degrees Celsius as 50 per- outside North America, 515-248-7684 or New York, NY 10004-1562; [email protected];
Scientific American,
www.ScientificAmerican.com www.ScientificAmerican.com/permissions.
cent hotter than 800 degrees C, because 1 New York Plaza, Please allow three to six weeks for processing.
Submissions
such comparisons break down at different To submit article proposals, follow the
Suite 4600,
Advertising
New York, NY
scales of temperature: in kelvins, the for- guidelines at www.ScientificAmerican.com. www.ScientificAmerican.com has electronic
Click on “Contact Us.” 10004-1562; contact information for sales representatives
mer temperature would be 37 percent hot- We cannot return and are not responsible 212-451-8415. of Scientific American in all regions of
ter than the latter. for materials delivered to our office. For single copies of back issues: 800-333-1199. the U.S. and in other countries.
April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 5

SCIENCE AGENDA
O PINI O N A N D A N A LYS I S FR OM
S C IENTIFIC A MERIC AN ’ S B OA R D O F E D ITO R S
The WHO Takes

a Reckless Step
The World Health Organization
is now promoting unproved
traditional Chinese medicine
By the Editors
For more than 2,000 years Chinese healers have used herbal
powders and tinctures, dust made from various animal parts
and strategically placed needles to treat a host of human ail-
ments. These are used in hundreds of nations globally, but the
practice in China is perhaps the most extensive, documented
and catalogued. Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) is based on
the concept of qi, a system of energy that flows along meridians
in the body to maintain health.
Over the past decade proponents of TCM have worked hard to
move it into the mainstream of global health care—and it appears
those efforts are coming to fruition. The latest (11th) version of quently make people sick rather than curing them. One particu-
the World Health Organization’s list known as the International larly troublesome ingredient, aristolochic acid, is commonly used
Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems in traditional remedies and has been linked to fatal kidney dam-
(I CD) will include these remedies for the first time. age and cancers of the urinary tract.
According to its own mandate, the WHO sets the norms and A 2018 study in the B ritish Journal of Clinical Pharmacology
standards for medical treatment around the globe and articulates tested 487 Chinese products taken by sick patients and discov-
“ethical and evidence-based policy options.” It categorizes thou- ered 1,234 hidden ingredients, including approved and banned
sands of diseases and influences how doctors treat them; how Western drugs, drug analogues and animal thyroid tissue. And in
insurers cover those treatments; and what kind of research is 2012 a team led by Megan Coghlan, then at Murdoch University
done on which ailments. More than 100 countries rely on the doc- of Australia, identified the DNA sequences in 15 samples of tradi-
ument to determine their medical agendas. tional medicines in the form of powders, tablets, capsules, bile
To include TCM in the ICD is an egregious lapse in evidence- flakes and herbal teas. The samples also contained plants that
based thinking and practice. Data supporting the effectiveness of produce toxic chemicals and animal DNA from vulnerable or
most traditional remedies are scant, at best. An extensive assess- endangered species (the Asiatic black bear and saiga antelope, for
ment was done in 2009 by researchers at the University of Mary- example) and other creatures protected by international laws.
land: they looked at 70 review papers evaluating TCM, including Thus, the proliferation of traditional medicines would have sig-
acupuncture. None of the studies proved conclusive because the nificant environmental impacts on top of the negative health
data were either too paltry or did not meet testing standards. effects. It would contribute to the destruction of ecosystems and
To be sure, many widely used and experimentally validated increase the illegal trade of wildlife. China announced last Octo-
pharmaceuticals, including aspirin, decongestants and some anti- ber that it was legalizing the controlled trade of rhinoceros horn
cancer chemotherapies, were originally derived from plants or and tiger bone. (The move was postponed in November, following
other natural sources. Those drugs have all gone through exten- a global outcry.) Both are believed by practitioners to have the
sive clinical testing of safety and efficacy, however. Giving cre- power to cure a range of ailments, from fever to impotence—
dence to treatments that have not met those standards will although no study has found any beneficial outcome of ingesting
advance their use but will also diminish the WHO’s credibility. either. Allowing even the controlled harvest of otherwise endan-
China has been pushing for wider global acceptance of tradi- gered creatures will boost illegal poaching, critics say.
tional medicines, which brings in some $50 billion in annual rev- Until they undergo rigorous testing for purity, efficacy, dosage
enue for the nation’s economy. And in 2016 Margaret Chan, then and safety, the WHO should remove traditional medicines from
the WHO director, praised China’s plans to do so. But while it’s a its list. These remedies should be given the same scrutiny as oth-
good idea to catalogue TCM and make health workers aware of er treatments before being included in standard care practices.
treatments used by millions, their inclusion in the ICD recklessly
JOIN T HE CONVERSAT ION ONLINE
equates them with medicines that have undergone clinical trials. Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
In China, traditional medicines are unregulated, and they fre- or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
6 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Christina Ung

FORUM
C OMM E N TA RY O N S C IE N C E IN
Han de Groot is CEO of the Rainforest Alliance. T H E N E W S FR OM T H E E X PE R T S
A Low-Tech of standing forests in the fight against climate change. Protecting

the world’s forests ensures they can keep performing essential
Climate Fix
functions such as producing oxygen, filtering water and support-
ing biodiversity. Not only does all the world’s population depend
on forests to provide clean air, clean water, oxygen and medicines,
Keeping forests intact can go a long way but 1.6 billion people rely on them directly for their livelihoods.
Unfortunately, a huge amount of forest continues to be con-
toward saving the planet verted into agricultural lands to produce a handful of resource-
By Han de Groot intensive commodities—despite zero-deforestation commitments
from companies and governments. So now is the time to increase
Climate change disproportionately affects the world’s most vul- forest protection and restoration. This action will also address a
nerable people, particularly poor rural communities that depend number of other pressing global issues. For example, increasing
on the land for their livelihoods and coastal populations through- tree cover can help tackle the problem of food security in many
out the tropics. We have already seen the stark asymmetry of suf- areas: trees can enhance farm productivity and give farmers an-
fering that results from extreme weather events, such as hurri- other source of revenue through the sale of fruits, nuts or timber—
canes, floods, droughts, wildfires, and more. all the while storing carbon dioxide—in a practice known as agro-
For remedies, advocates and politicians have tended to look to- forestry. It is estimated that increased investment in this area
ward cuts in fossil-fuel use or technologies to capture carbon before could help sequester up to 9.28 gigatons of carbon dioxide while
it enters the atmosphere—both of which are crucial. But this focus saving a net $709.8 billion by 2050. In productive landscapes
has overshadowed the most powerful and cost-efficient carbon cap- where it would be difficult to increase tree cover dramatically,
ture technology in the world. Recent research confirms that forests agroforestry serves as an attractive compromise.
are absolutely essential in mitigating climate change, thanks to In less developed, rural areas—especially in the tropics—com-
their ability to absorb and sequester carbon. In fact, natural climate munity-based forest-management programs can forge pathways
solutions such as conservation and restoration of forests, along out of poverty. In the Petén region of Guatemala, for instance, com-
munity-managed forests boasted a near-zero deforesta-
tion rate from 2000 through 2013, as compared with
12 percent in nearby protected areas and buffer zones.
These communities have built low-impact, sustainable
forest-based businesses that have bolstered the economy
of the region enough to fund the creation of local schools
and health services. Their success is especially poignant
in a location where, outside these community-managed
zones, deforestation rates have increased 20-fold.
Landscape restoration promises an unparalleled re-
turn on investment, in terms of ecosystem services and
carbon sequestered and stored. It could potentially se-
quester up to 1.7 gigatons of carbon dioxide every year,
according to the International Union for Conservation
of Nature. Reforestation projects can also intersect neat-
ly and positively with human systems—restored forests
supply a renewed resource base and new economic op-
portunities for communities.
The Bonn Challenge, issued by world leaders with the
goal of bringing 150 million hectares of degraded lands
with improvements in land management, can help us achieve into restoration by 2020, has been adopted by 57 governments and
37 percent of our climate target of limiting warming to a maximum other organizations. Many groups have pledged to halve global de-
of two degrees Celsius above preindustrial levels, even though they forestation by 2020 through the New York Declaration on Forests.
currently receive only 2.5 percent of public climate financing. And in an exemplary display of public-private-sector cooperation,
Forests’ power to store carbon dioxide is staggering: one tree the Cocoa and Forests Initiative in Côte d’Ivoire, Ghana and Co-
can store an average of about 48 pounds in one year. Intact forests lombia aims to end deforestation from cocoa cultivation.
could take in the CO2 emissions of some entire countries. More trees mean better lives on a more sustainable planet.
For this reason, policy makers and business leaders must cre-
ate and enforce policies to prevent deforestation; foster reforesta- Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
tion of degraded land; and promote the sustainable management or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
Illustration by Nicole Xu April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 7

ADVANCES
An implant that could restore

a sense of smell would involve
electrodes placed on the brain’s
olfactory bulb (arrows).

D I S PATC H E S FR OM T H E FR O N TIE R S O F S C IE N C E , T E C H N O LO GY A N D M E D I C IN E IN S ID E
• Coral reefs may migrate to escape

ocean warming
• World’s smallest dinosaur footprints found
• An app could detect cervical cancer from
a photograph
• Volcanic eruptions spied from space
N E U R OT E C H
Aroma
Therapy
A cochlear implant–like device
could one day restore smell
When Scott Moorehead t ells people he

cannot smell, they usually make a joke
about how lucky he is—he must not be
troubled by dirty diapers or people passing
gas. “All the jokes are hilarious,” Moore-
head says, with a hint of sarcasm. But his
lack of smell also means he is vulnerable
to natural gas leaks and burning food. He
is self-conscious about his own scent, so
he takes extra showers. And he has had to
give up one of his favorite hobbies: match-
ing wines with exotic flavors.
After a concussion left Moorehead
without a sense of smell six years ago,
these losses were all he could think about.
“Just knowing that I was never going to
be able to smell my wife again or my kids”
was hard to cope with, he says.
Although the nerves that control smell
can often regrow after an injury—they
are some of the only neurons known to
rapidly replace themselves—Moorehead’s
lesion was too severe. He now has anosmia,
which means his sense of smell is gone.
But he is participating in a nascent effort
SCIENCE SOURCE
at the Virginia Commonwealth University

(VCU) School of Medicine and Harvard
Medical School to develop a partially
J O I N T H E C O N V E R S AT I O N O N L I N E Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter

ADVANCES
implantable device that could help people that will operate somewhat like a cochlear
with brain injuries decode and interpret implant, an electronic device that partially
everyday scents. restores hearing. Cochlear implants turn
Research on smell lags decades behind sounds into electrical signals that the brain
that on vision and hearing, says Joel Main- interprets; in a similar way, the VCU-Har-
land, an olfactory neuroscientist and associ- vard team hopes to convert chemical scents
ate member of the Monell Chemical Senses into useful electrical signals. Holbrook pub-
Center in Philadelphia, who is not involved lished a study in February in the International
in the new work. Smell studies receive less Forum of Allergy & Rhinology suggesting that
funding than research on other senses does, electrical stimulation in the nasal cavity and
he says. And smell involves many sensory sinuses can make a healthy person perceive
components. Whereas vision requires inter- an odor, even if it is not present. That is a
preting input from three types of receptors, long way from restoring a sense of smell in
taste involves 40 and olfaction 400. someone who has lost it, but it is an impor-
A surprisingly large number of people tant step along the way, Holbrook says.
have an impaired sense of smell—23 percent A cochlear implant has an external
of U.S. adults age 40 and older, according sound processor worn behind the ear that
to one national survey, and 62.5 percent of includes a microphone and microcomputer.
those age 80 and older, according to anoth- That component transmits signals to an
er. Such a decline can result from injury, internal piece under the skin that stimulates
chronic sinus problems, genetics or aging, nerves in the cochlea, the organ that con-
says VCU professor Richard Costanzo, who verts sound vibrations into nerve impulses.
has studied smell for four decades and is Similarly, the VCU-Harvard team envisions
co-leading the initiative to develop the new a device that would potentially fit under the
device. Often dismissed as inconsequential, nose—or on a pair of glasses—and include
smell contributes to taste, so people who an odor sensor and a small external micro-
cannot smell are at risk for malnutrition, processor, as well as an internal part to
as well as social isolation, Costanzo says. stimulate different areas of the olfactory
Some smell-restoration treatments bulb, Costanzo says.
exist, Mainland says, including smell train- Daniel Coelho, a cochlear implant sur-
ing, in which people repeatedly expose geon at VCU who is collaborating with
themselves to certain odors and practice Costanzo, says the researchers must still
M A R I N E B I O LO G Y
identifying them. Other treatments may refine sensors so they can discriminate
uncover specific causes of smell loss, such
as chronic sinusitis. But for someone with
among enough odors to be useful. The
plan is to miniaturize and expedite smell Coral
the damage Moorehead suffered, none of
these is effective.
processing such as that carried out by so-
called electronic noses, which are used for Reefugees
Smell, like all senses, is a multistep pro- bomb detection and identification of
cess. Scents, technically called odorant spoiled food. In addition, researchers must
Ancient corals migrated to
molecules, enter through the nose or determine the optimal surgical approaches escape warming waters
mouth and pass through a layer of mucus to safely implant a device that can stimu-
before binding to olfactory receptor neu- late the brain to perceive smells. As the planet and oceans c ontinue to
rons. This binding triggers electrical signals Developing such an olfactory implant heat up, sites where coral has recently
that reach certain spots in the brain’s olfac- will take years, Coelho says, but it is not thrived are becoming less and less hab-
tory bulb. “One nerve cell may respond to impossible. “It’s a pretty straightforward itable. For instance, thanks to extreme
a brownie but not to pound cake, and its idea. We’re not inventing anything radically ocean temperatures, much of Austra-
neighbor might do the opposite,” says Eric new,” he notes. Rather the team is putting lia’s Great Barrier Reef suffered mass
Holbrook, chief of rhinology at Massachu- existing technology together in a new way. bleaching in 2016 and 2017 that turned
setts Eye and Ear Hospital and an associate Moorehead, who injured himself falling parades of colorful coral into dull,
professor at Harvard Medical School. “One off a skateboard while trying to teach his white masses.
nerve cell probably responds to multiple then six-year-old how to ride, is not opti- But paleontologists have now dis-
chemicals, but they have some specificity.” mistic about regaining his sense of smell. covered a haven to which one region’s
ETHAN DANIELS Getty Images
Holbrook, who is collaborating with the But he could not pass up the opportunity reefs might relocate—via oceanic cur-
VCU team, is now trying to find a shortcut to help others, including the researchers. rents when corals are still in their free-
to stimulate the brain’s olfactory bulb and “It just kept seeming painfully obvious,” floating larval stage—to escape over-
then trigger a sensation of smell. Ultimate- Moorehead says, “that this is what I’m heating. By studying fossils in Daya Bay,
ly the researchers plan to create a device supposed to do.” —Karen Weintraub just northeast of Hong Kong in the

Grand Canyon; Monument Valley; Visit
your National Parks with Caravan Tours.
Call Now for Choice Dates.
8-Day Tour $1495 +tax, fees

with Bryce, Zion, Sedona
See the greatest national parks
of America's Southwest on a
fully guided tour with Caravan.
Spend 4-nights in national park
lodges. Explore Grand Canyon,
Bryce, Zion, Monument Valley,
Lake Powell, and more.
Bleached leather corals in Buyat Bay, Indonesia Discover why smart shoppers and
experienced travelers have chosen
South China Sea, a team of researchers on the move is not new, but using the fossil Caravan since 1952. Let Caravan
found that during periods of warming in the record to help pinpoint such places is a rela- handle all the details. You and
distant past, coral reefs migrated away from tively novel approach, says John Pandolfi, your family enjoy a well-earned,
equatorial warm waters to the bay’s more a marine
a marine paleoecologist at the University worry-free vacation.
hospitable subtropical latitudes. of Queensland
of Queensland in Australia, who was not Happy Travels!
“We showed that the higher-latitude involved in the new work. “It’s absolutely
reefs up around China did grow during ear- fundamental to understanding the dynam-
lier warm periods,” says Tara Clark, a paleo- ics of ecological communities and their
ecologist at the University of Wollongong in
Australia. In 2015 Clark led a group of scien-
responses to ecological change,” he says.
Such change often occurs on broader time time-
“—Arthur
Brilliant, Affordable Pricing
Frommer, Travel Editor ”
tists on an expedition to Daya Bay. There scales than those of humans, and the fossil
the researchers randomly collected dead record can reveal that long-term change,
Choose Your Fully Guided Tour
corals and calculated their ages using radio- Pandolfi notes.
10 days Guatemala with Tikal
isotopic dating techniques. The ancient Although the fossil evidence suggests
9 days Costa Rica Natural Paradise
8 days Panama Canal Cruise and Tour
reefs grew between 6,850 and 5,510 years that Daya Bay could one day provide a
10 days Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Is.
ago, the scientists reported in January in ha
havven
en for corals, there are some hurdles
9 days Canadian Rockies, Glacier Park
G eology, w
Geology, which
hich coincides with a time when in the way of making the refuge an inviting
8 days Grand Canyon, Bryce, Zion
ocean temperatures around South China place, Clark says. Not all corals, for in
in-
9 days California Coast, Yosemite Park
and nearby seas were one to two degrees stance, are equally fit to trek across the
8 days Yellowstone, Mount Rushmore
Celsius warmer on average than they are ocean to a new home. And Daya Bay is
8 days New England Fall Colors
today. This trend suggests that some of now heavily polluted, which could jeopar-
today’s reefs may be able to set up shop in dize its ability to sustain reefs. But in light of
FREE Tour Catalog
places such as Daya Bay in the decades to the new discovery, Clark says, “we might
as well do the best we can to protect these
Call 1-800-CARAVAN
Caravan.com
come, as temperatures climb.
The idea of refuges for imperiled reefs areas, just in case.” —LLucas
— ucas Joel

The #1 In Value—Guided Tours Since 1952
ADVANCES
P S YC H O LO G Y
were interspersed with images or words researchers reported in a study published
Biases Aren’t that represented two categories of people,

such as blacks and whites, and participants
online in January in P sychological Science.
“It’s a really cool paper,” says Keith Payne,
Forever were asked to flag these using the same

keys. Faster reactions when, for example,
a psychologist at the University of North
Carolina at Chapel Hill, who has found sim-
Implicit prejudice against black rather than white faces shared a key ilar bias reductions in his own work. “I think
with negative words suggested a racial bias. it’s going to start a lot of conversations.”
certain groups is declining
Tessa Charlesworth and Mahzarin Charlesworth and Banaji also found,
Banaji, psychologists at Harvard Universi- however, that implicit biases about age and
Psychologists have lots o f evidence that ty, analyzed more than four million results disability did not change over time, and
implicit social biases—our unconscious, collected over a 10-year period from U.S. those against overweight people nudged
knee-jerk attitudes associated with specific adults who had taken implicit association up by 5 percent.
races, sexes and other categories—are tests for sexuality, race, skin tone (in which Several factors might explain the dis-
widespread, and many assumed they do faces differ in color but not shape), age, crepancies among categories, the research-
not evolve. The feelings are just too deep. disability and body weight. Respondents ers say. In their data set, implicit biases for
But a new study finds that over roughly the also answered questions on the screen race, skin tone and sexuality were lower to
past decade, both implicit and explicit, or asking them to explicitly rate how much begin with than those for age, disability and
conscious, attitudes toward several social they liked people in each of the categories. body weight. And the types of implicit biases
groups have grown warmer. In line with previous findings, explicit that decreased the most are also the biases
The study used data from a standard bias decreased in all six categories from that have received more societal attention.
test of implicit attitudes collected via a Web 2007 through 2016; the drop ranged from Meanwhile the stigma associated with
site called Project Implicit. Participants 49 percent (for sexuality) to 15 percent (for obesity may have increased in recent years.
were asked to quickly press a certain com- body weight). But more surprisingly, Next, the team plans to explore implicit
puter key in response to positive words, implicit bias also decreased—by 33 percent and explicit attitude change across demo-
such as “happy,” and a different key in re for sexuality, 17 percent for race and 15 per- graphics and geographical regions, as well as
sponse to negative words, such as “tragic,” cent for skin tone (graphic). Most of the whether trends have changed since the 2016
that appeared on a screen. These words reductions occurred in all generations, the U.S. presidential election. —M atthew Hutson
Implicit Bias Explicit Bias

Average monthly scores Trends with seasonal adjustments
(light lines) (bold lines) 1.0
Explicit Preference Score
More biased
Implicit Association Test Score
SOURCE: “PATTERNS OF IMPLICIT AND EXPLICIT ATTITUDES, VOL. I: LONG-TERM CHANGE AND STABILITY FROM 2007 TO 2016,”
(toward typically
preferred group) 0.5 Disability
0.9
BY TESSA E. S. CHARLESWORTH AND MAHZARIN R. BANAJI, IN PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, VOL. 30, NO. 2; FEBRUARY 2019
Body weight
0.8
Age
0.4 Test showed Test showed 0.7
images of faces images of bodies
0.6
0.3
Skin tone
0.5
Race
Sexuality 0.4
0.2
Researchers analyzed data from
4.4 million implicit bias tests 0.3
completed by U.S. participants, controlling
for factors such as the time of year the test was taken.
Higher test scores indicate stronger implicit preferences 0.2 Participants’ explicit biases were
0.1
for straight, white, light-skinned, young, nondisabled assessed by asking them to select
or thin people. Scores for the body weight test shifted 0.1 statements expressing how much they favored
around 2011, when researchers started showing one group over another, such as “I strongly prefer
silhouettes of bodies rather than faces. young people to old people.”
Neutral 0 0
2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016
12 Scientific American, April 2019 Graphic by Amanda Montañez

PA L E O N TO LO G Y
Tiny Dino
New Version!
A carnivore left the smallest

known dinosaur footprints
A series o f one-centimeter-long, 110-million-
of
year-old footprints found in South Korea were
left by what may be the tiniest nonbird dinosaur
ever discovered. “These were made by several
incredibly small raptor dinosaurs,” says Anthony
Romilio, a co-author of a study detailing the dis-
covery and a postdoctoral researcher in paleon-
tology at the University of Queensland in Aus-
tralia. “Prior to our find, there would have been
few who would have imagined that some rap-
tors were so small that two or three could have
easily fitted in your cupped hand.”
Each footprint resembles the number 11,
suggesting that these creatures walked on
two toes per foot. The only dinosaurs known to
dromaeosaurs—
match this style of prints are dromaeosaurs—
a family
family of speedy predators that included
Velociraptor mongoliensis, o f JJurassic
of urassic Park ffame.
ame.
These raptors had four toes on each foot; one
was diminutive like a cat’s dewclaw, and anoth-
er had a sickle-shaped claw and was held
above the ground while a raptor walked.
The sparrow-sized dromaeosaurs that left
these footprints would have had hips that were
only four to five centimeters high. Their tracks,
found in the South Korean city of Jinju, were
described last November in SScientific
de cientific Reports bbyy
a team led by Kyung Soo Kim of the country’s
Chinju National University of Education.
The prints look like they were left by an adult
dinosaur smaller than any known type other
than birds, Romilio says. Still, the possibility
remains that a clutch of dinosaur chicks could
have made them; similar footprints 10 times big-
ger—possibly from an adult—have been found
at a site 30 kilometers away. Skeletal fossil evi-
dence from the region is needed to pin down
which hypothesis is correct, Romilio notes.
“Most people expect dinosaur tracks to be
huge, bathtublike depressions, and some
dinosaurs did leave some pretty big holes in
the ground,” says Anthony Martin, a paleon- Over 75 New Features & Apps in Origin 2019!
tologist at Emory University who studies trace For a FREE 60-day
fossils (such as footprints and burrows) and Over 500,000 registered users worldwide in: evaluation, go to
was not involved in the study. But the new ◾ 6,000+ Companies including 20+ Fortune Global 500 OriginLab.Com/demo
finding “shows us that we also sometimes ◾ 6,500+ Colleges & Universities and enter code: 9246
need to think small.” Even if the footprints ◾ 3,000+ Government Agencies & Research Labs
were left by hatchlings, he adds, they hint that
these juvenile dinosaurs were precocious and
able to leave their nest soon after hatching,
25+ years serving the scientific & engineering community
similar to some modern birds. — —JJohn
ohn Pickrell

ADVANCES
H E A LT H T E C H
acid and visually inspect it for any white
Cervical spots that might signal abnormal cells.

Over a seven-year period nih research-
Cancer App ers routinely photographed the cervixes

of more than 9,400 women in Costa Rica.
An AI algorithm diagnoses They used these images to train an AI algo
rithm to recognize characteristics of abnor-
the disease from images
Cervical cancer cell mal tissue—and to predict later cancer
development. When the algorithm analyzed
One of the most common and cost-effec- Global Good; the latter is a joint effort by Bill new images, it performed better than a clin-
ays to detect cervical cancer is the
tive w Gates and invention firm Intellectual Ven- ical expert did by visual inspection.
pap smear, in which cells are scraped from tures. Their preliminary results, published “We were surprised to see that comput-
a woman’s cervix and sent to a laboratory online in January in the J ournal of the National ers could see much more sensitively and
for analysis. But this method requires Cancer Institute, suggest that such an ap clearly which cervixes are or are not pre-
equipment and medical expertise that are proach could significantly improve cervical cancerous,” says Mark Schiffman, a molec-
not always available in some low-income cancer diagnosis in low-resource settings. ular epidemiologist at the National Cancer
STEVE GSCHMEISSNER Science Source

countries. Now scientists are making an Cervical cancer rates are higher in Institute and senior author of the paper. “I
app they hope could use artificial intelli- countries or regions that lack the resourc- really thought [the AI was] cheating.” The
gence to identify precancerous or cancer- es to conduct pap smears. Health care scientists ultimately plan to implement their
ous cells with just a photograph. providers in these areas often use a less algorithm on mobile phones and aim to
The app is being developed by research- accurate diagnostic technique, in which train future iterations of the program with
ers at the National Institutes of Health and they swab the cervix with dilute acetic digital camera photos. —Wudan Yan
ANIMAL FORENSIC S ty, who led the team that studied the
Catching etchings. This technique, she adds,

will help researchers paint pic-
Paleo Killers
tures of what kinds of preda-
tors were active in long-van-
ished ecosystems, particu-
New technique identifies larly in areas where fossils
predators of ancient animals are scarce. “It’s really
powerful,” she says.
Nowadays detectives can use DNA analy- Terry and her team
sis to help catch a killer. But what happens used a scanning electron
when a crime scene has been exposed to microscope to examine
the elements for thousands of years? DNA the leftover bones that
does not always stay intact that long—so modern predatory birds
for a paleontologist trying to figure out regurgitate as pellets after
what kind of predator killed a long-dead a meal. They also looked at
fossil animal, the case often goes cold. the feces of carnivorous mam-
But a new method promises to help mals. “A bone that passes into
researchers identify these ancient killers. and out of a nocturnal owl is clearly
It relies on the fact that when a predator distinguishable from bones that have
gulps down the bones of its prey—say, been eaten by diurnal raptors” or mam-
when a swooping owl snatches and mals, Terry says. Patterns etched on bones
eats a small rodent in the night—the inside an owl’s stomach tend to be relative- These findings will help answer one
diner’s stomach juices leave behind ly short and close together; those from the of paleontologists’ most basic questions
microscopic etchings on the surface of stomach of a hawk or mammal tend to be about the fossils of animals they suspect
the victim’s bones. longer and more widely spaced, according were killed and eaten: “Whodunit?” As
These etchings occur in patterns that to the study, which was published last Joshua Miller, a paleobiologist at the Uni-
are unique to the type of predator that November in P ALAIOS. A
nd the patterns versity of Cincinnati, who was not involved
did the deed, making them a bit like finger- left by the modern-day owls and mam- in the new research, says, “You can actual-
prints that scientists can use to crack mals, Terry adds, were “indistinguishable” ly look at an individual bone and get some
unsolved cases, explains Rebecca Terry, from those found on fossil bones digested perspective on why that bone is where you
a paleontologist at Oregon State Universi- by similar predators long ago. found it. And that’s really neat.” —L ucas Joel
14 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Thomas Fuchs

ADVANCES
COGNITIVE SCIENCE ance—even if the latter were
Failing closer to being done. Know-

ing how to finish, in other
Successfully
words, was more important
than being close to finishing.
The researchers dubbed
Research reveals how to turn this finding “the Heming-
defeat to one’s advantage way effect,” for the author’s
building a robot, the sooner they can move self-reported tendency to stop writing only
People often say t hat “failure is the moth- forward and improve. Another confirmed when he knew what would happen next
er of success.” This cliché might have some that feedback on failures is most construc- in the story—so as to avoid writer’s block
truth to it, but it does not tell us how to tive when the giver comes across as caring, when he returned to the page. Manalo
actually turn a loss into a win, says Emman- and the receiver is prepared to weather believes that learning how to fail temporar-
uel Manalo, a professor of educational psy- negative emotions. ily can help people avoid becoming perma-
chology at Kyoto University in Japan. As a Manalo and his co-authors also contrib- nent failures at many tasks, such as com-
result, he says, “we know we shouldn’t give uted their own study focused on overcom- pleting a dissertation, learning a language
up when we fail—but in reality, we do.” ing one fundamental, everyday form of fail- or inventing a new technology.
Manalo and Manu Kapur, a professor of ure: not completing a task. They asked 131 Demystifying failure and teaching stu-
learning sciences at the Swiss Federal Insti- undergraduates to write an essay about dents not to fear it make goals more attain-
tute of Technology Zurich, put together a their school experiences. Half of the stu- able, says Stephanie Couch, executive
special issue of the journal T hinking Skills dents received instructions for structuring director of the Lemelson-MIT Program, a
and Creativity last December on benefiting their writing, and half were left to their own nonprofit organization dedicated to devel-
from failure. The issue’s 15 studies provide devices; all, however, were stopped prior to oping and supporting inventors. Couch,
teachers and educational researchers with finishing. Afterward the researchers found whose work was also featured in the spe-
a guide for achieving success. One study that those in the structured group were cial issue, adds that we “should really be
GETTY IMAGES
reported, for example, that the sooner and more motivated to complete their essays, thinking of failure as part of a process of
more often students fail at a task, such as compared with those who lacked guid- iterating toward success.” —Rachel Nuwer
APPLIED PHYSIC S “regular” the painting, the lower the entropy. ing from these patterns, the program could
Entropy
The new algorithm analyzes two-by- even be used to sort lesser-known works of
two grids of pixels within each painting art into specific artistic styles.
in Art
and scores them using the two metrics. Maximilian Schich, a professor of arts
Ribeiro and his colleagues observed that and technology at University of Texas at
shifts in the magnitude of complexity and Dallas, is in favor of the cross-disciplinary
Computer program uses physics entropy among various paintings mirror research. “One thing I think is very elegant
to find patterns in paintings stylistic shifts throughout art history. Mod- in this paper is that they look at the com-
ern art—with blended edges and loose plexity at the local level, the pixels and the
ROB KIM Getty Images

For the romantics a mong us, physicist brushstrokes—generally possesses low surrounding pixels,” Schich says. “You
Haroldo Ribeiro’s recent work might seem complexity and high entropy. Postmodern could say, ‘Yeah, that’s too simple—it
prosaic. He has developed a computer pro- art, a simpler style with recognizable doesn’t explain all of the painting.’ But it’s
gram that deconstructs works of art into objects and stark, well-defined edges (for research that is valuable.” —Jess Romeo
sets of numbers. Now Ribeiro has applied example, Andy Warhol’s
his physics-inspired metrics to nearly soup cans), has high com-
140,000 digitized paintings indexed on the plexity and low entropy. In
visual art encyclopedia WikiArt to look for the late 1960s there was a
trends in the evolution of painting styles. rapid shift from modern to
The process, described by Ribeiro and postmodern art; the algo-
his colleagues last September in the Pro- rithm is able to quantify the
ceedings of the National Academy of Sciences extremity of this shift.
USA, involves assessing the complexity and These simple metrics could
entropy, or disorder, of these digitized art- be used to better understand
works. Complexity is based on the variability how art has evolved, capture
of patterns within each image, ranging from information about various
highly variable (more complex) to uniform artistic periods and determine
(less complex). Entropy is determined by how these periods interacted,
the degree of chaos in the image; the more the researchers say. By learn- Jackson Pollock’s paintings
have a high degree of entropy.

In
SCIENCE
We
Trust
Join the nation’s
largest association of
freethinkers, atheists
Astronaut image of the Tinakula
and agnostics working
volcano on the Solomon Islands to keep religion
out of government
EARTH SCIENCE
lected ultraviolet measurements of sulfur and social policy.
Spying dioxide (SO2), a gas frequently emitted by
volcanoes. Sulfur dioxide is the easiest vol-
Volcanoes canic gas to measure because it is relatively

rare in the atmosphere, Carn says. The
For a free sample of
FFRF’s newspaper,
from Space EPIC observations provided a new view of
Earth’s surface every 68 to 110 minutes—
Freethought Today:
An orbiting observatory much more frequently than most other
Call 1-800-335-4021
ultraviolet satellite instruments. “Eruptions
monitors signs of eruptions
every one to two hours
can evolve rapidly, so the higher the fre- ffrf.us/reason
quency of observations, the better our abil-
ity to track them,” Carn says.
Scientists are zooming out tto o get a more EPIC captured SO2 measurements just
complete global view of volcanic erup- a few hours after the start of several erup-
tions—1.6 million
tions—1.6 million kilometers out, to be pre- tions; it also revealed changes other satel-
cise. That is the distance to the Deep Space lites did not detect, the researchers report-
Climate Observatory (DSCOVR), a satellite G
eophysical Research
ed last October in Geophysical
originally conceived by former vice presi- Letters. For
For instance, EPIC showed that the
dent Al Gore. Using an instrument onboard
DSCOVR that can detect gases belched by
eruption of Tinakula on the South Pacific’s
Solomon Islands on October 20, 2017, FFRF.ORG
volcanoes, researchers can now take snap- actually consisted of two separate explo-
shots of eruptions every one to two hours. sive events that released different amounts
CENTER
SPACE CENTER
Monitoring these events, which often spew of sulfur dioxide.

JOHNSON SPACE
ash that can trigger

can trigger engine failure in air- This work represents a “significant step
planes, can help scientists quickly pinpoint forward” in tracking volcanic clouds, says
NASA’S JOHNSON
potentially dangerous airspace. Andrew Hooper, a volcanologist at the

AND NASA’S
Many of Earth’s roughly 1,500 potential- University of Leeds in England, who was
ly active volcanoes are in remote areas, so not involved in the research. The observa-
LABORATORY AND
it can be difficult to regularly study ongoing tions, he states, “could ultimately help mit-
ANALYSIS LABORATORY
eruptions or identify new ones, says Simon igate the impacts of volcanic eruptions.”
Carn, a volcanologist at Michigan Techno- Currently DSCOVR transmits data to FFRF is a 501(c)(3) educational charity.
IMAGE ANALYSIS
logical University. “U.S. volcanoes are pret- Earth only when the satellite is in view of Deductible for income tax purposes.
ty well monitored, but elsewhere it’s a dif- receiver antennas in Virginia and Alaska.
Text FFRF to 52886 for
AND IMAGE
ferent story,” Carn adds. “There’s definitely Installing more receivers around the globe
legislative action alerts
SCIENCES AND
a need for satellite monitoring.” would allow scientists to collect and ana-
EARTH SCIENCES
Carn and his colleagues used DSCOVR’s lyze measurements nearly instantaneously,
Earth Polychromatic Imaging Camera Carn says, noting that “we’re a day or two
EARTH
(EPIC) to observe 16 eruptions. They col- behind real time.” — Katherine Kornei

—Katherine Kornei

17
ScientificAmerican.com 2/19/19
Untitled-2 1 4:05 PM
ADVANCES
GREENLAND
GREENLAND
GREENLAND NORTHERN IRELAND
NORTHERN IRELAND
IN THE NEWS The massive ice sheet covering Greenland Bacteria in a soil sample from Northern Ireland
Quick is melting
is melting almost four times faster than it was
in 2003, scientists have found. The gigantic
effectively
effectively halt the growth of four types of antibiotic-
resistant “superbugs,” including methicillin-resistant
Hits hunk of ice could become a major contributor

to sea-level rise in coming decades.
Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). Researchers say the
discovery is an important step in the battle against
By Jim Daley
By such resistant bacteria.
AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIA
U.S.
U.S. Overuse of water from
A 14-year-old Hawaiian the Murray-Darling River
snail named George, system sparked a massive die-
believed to be the last off
off of fish
fish in the Down Under
of its
of its species, has died. state of New South Wales.
The archipelago’s An estimated 100,000 to one
population of land million fish
fish suffocated
suffocated because
snails—which was once the river levels were too low to
incredibly diverse—has flflush runoff;; this led
ush out farm runoff
substantially declined. to algal blooms that resulted
in bacterial proliferation,
which caused a drop
a drop in oxygen.
GUYANA
GUYANA LIBERIA
LIBERIA
LIBERIA
The Guyanese government signed an agreement with the Health offiofficials
cials announced that they found the Ebola virus
European Union to curb illegal logging, improve forest in aa bat
bat in West Africa for the fifirst
rst time. Previously it
For more details, visit
www.ScientificAmerican.com/
management and expand the South American nation’s had been found only in bats in Central Africa. The discovery
apr2019/advances legal timber industry, which exports to the E.U.
the E.U. could help reveal how the virus jumps to humans.
ScientificAmerican.com 19
THE SCIENCE Claudia Wallis is an award-winning science journalist whose
OF HEALTH work has appeared in the New York Times, Time, Fortune a nd the
New Republic. She was science editor at Time a nd managing editor
of Scientific American Mind.
try a single, three-hour session. His first taker was a 35-year-old

spider-phobic woman. “She lived five hours away, so she was hap-
py,” he recalls, to be treated in one go. He later showed the effica-
cy of the approach in a clinical trial, although it took four years to
recruit 20 participants. “People with a specific phobia rarely apply
for treatment,” he explains. “They adjust their lives [say, avoiding
spiders] or think they can’t be helped.” Öst went on to work with
a team in Bergen, Norway, to test an intensive therapy for OCD
known as the Bergen four-day treatment. By the early 2000s
Ollendick was adapting brief therapies for adolescents and kids.
The details vary, but the quick treatments have some common
features. They generally begin with “psychoeducation,” in which
patients learn about their condition and the catastrophic thoughts
that keep it locked in place. In Bergen, this is done in a small group.
With children, the lessons may be more hands-on and concrete.
For instance, Ollendick might help a snake-phobic kid grasp why
the creature moves in a creepy, slithering way by having the child
lie on the floor and try to go forward without using any limbs.
A second part usually involves “exposure and response pre-
vention,” in which patients confront in incremental steps what-
ever triggers their anxiety: perhaps shopping, for agoraphobics,
or having dirty hands, for people with OCD. With support from
the therapist, they learn to tolerate it and see it as less threaten-
Psychotherapy ing. Patients leave with homework to reinforce the lessons. Par-
ents may be taught how to support a child’s progress.
in a Flash
How well do these approaches work? A 2017 meta-analysis by
Öst and Ollendick looked at 23 randomized controlled studies
and found that “brief, intensive, or concentrated” therapies for
childhood anxiety disorders were comparable to standard CBT.
Brief, intensive treatments can work With the quicker therapies, 54 percent of patients were better
for phobias, OCD, and more immediately post-treatment, and that rose to 64 percent on fol-
low-up—presumably because they continued to practice and
By Claudia Wallis
apply what they had learned. With standard therapy, 57 percent
Psychotherapy is not what most people think of as a quick fix. were better after the final session and 63 percent on follow-up.
From its early Freudian roots, it has taken the form of 50- to The severity of symptoms and whether the patient was also tak-
60-minute sessions repeated weekly (or more often) over a peri- ing antianxiety medication did not seem to impact outcomes.
od of months or even years. For modern cognitive-behavioral An obvious advantage to quick therapy is that it accelerates
therapy (CBT), 10 to 20 weekly sessions is typical. But must it be relief. Children with panic disorder, for instance, may refuse to
so? “Whoever told us that one 50-minute session a week is the leave home for fear of triggering an episode of shortness of breath,
best way to help people get over their problems?” asks Thomas a racing heart and nausea. “They start to avoid places like the
Ollendick, director of the Child Study Center at Virginia Tech. mall, the movies, the school dance,” says child psychologist Don-
For nearly 20 years Ollendick has been testing briefer, more na Pincus of Boston University. Pincus developed an eight-day
intensive forms of CBT for childhood anxiety disorders and get- treatment for the disorder as an alternative to three months of
ting results that closely match those of slower versions. His cen- CBT, which, she observes, “is a long time if you are not going to
ter often has a waiting list for treatments that include a four-day school or are avoiding doing things that are fun or healthy.”
therapy for obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and a three- Making these briefer therapies more widely available could
hour intervention for specific phobias (such as fear of flying, help address the sad fact that only about a third of patients with
heights or dogs). Around the U.S. and Europe, short-course ther- anxiety disorders get any kind of treatment. A weeklong therapy
apies for anxiety disorders have begun to catch on, creating a could be completed over a school or work vacation. Rural pa
nascent movement in both adult and child psychology. tients who cannot find CBT nearby could be treated during a
The idea originated with Swedish psychologist Lars-Göran Öst, short out-of-town stay. The intensive approach requires special
now professor emeritus at Stockholm University. Some 40 years training and a big shift for therapists—and health insurers—
ago Öst got the impression that not all his phobia patients needed accustomed to the tradition of 50-minute blocks. But is there
multiple weeks of therapy and decided to ask if they would like to really anything sacred about that?
20 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Celia Krampien

VENTURES Wade Roush is the host and producer of Soonish, a podcast
T H E B U S IN E S S O F IN N OVATI O N about technology, culture, curiosity and the future. He is
a co-founder of the podcast collective Hub & Spoke and a
freelance reporter for print, online and radio outlets, such as
MIT Technology Review, Xconomy, WBUR and WHYY.
Machines That The company’s first applications were on the whimsical side.
Visitors to the Ontario pavilion at the 2010 Winter Olympics in
Mine Your Mind

Vancouver could don a headband and use their thoughts to con
trol the lights shining on Niagara Falls and other distant Ontar
io landmarks. Later the company built thought-controlled slot
cars and S tar Wars games. “After all this thought controlling, we
How to make sure noninvasive hit upon this very important recognition,” InteraXon co-founder
neural interfaces stay that way Ariel Garten told me. “Although you could control technology with
your brain, the way that you did it was not very effective. Frankly,
By Wade Roush
you could just turn the thing with your hand much more readily.”
Sometimes a technology that’s been simmering in the labora But in 2014 the company released its Muse headband, now in
tory or the clinic for decades makes the leap to mainstream con its second iteration: it pairs with a smartphone app to help us
sumption almost overnight. ers practice mindfulness meditation. When the software detects
Take the cavity magnetron. The precursor to this curious brain waves indicating a wandering mind, wearers hear feed
form of vacuum tube was invented at General Electric around back in the form of crashing waves or thunder. These sounds cue
1920. It wasn’t until 1940 that British scientists found a magne them to return their attention to their breath. “It’s like doing a
tron design that could pump out microwave energy at unprece rep at the gym,” Garten says. “That’s you saying, ‘Okay, I have
dented power. That discovery fueled a crash program at the Mas this muscle called my attention, and I’m going to strengthen it.’”
sachusetts Institute of Technology to build airborne radar units, But it’s one thing to use EEG data to diagnose sleep disorders
an advance that helped the Allies turn back Nazi Germany in Eu or epilepsy; it’s quite another to start monitoring the brain states
rope. The conflict had barely ended when a Raytheon engineer of millions of healthy consumers. So Garten also founded the
noticed that microwaves could also melt chocolate. The “Rada Center for Responsible Brainwave Technologies, which aims to
range” debuted in 1947, and today there’s a magnetron in vir prevent privacy breaches, excessive scientific claims or other
tually every kitchen. missteps that could derail the nascent neural-interfaces in
The next old-but-new technology to pervade our dustry. “The goal is to create a set of standards to ensure
lives may be so-called neural interfaces. Thanks to that everybody’s data is kept safe at all times and that
noninvasive tools that have been around for de the technology is used appropriately,” Garten says.
cades, such as electroencephalogra Mary Lou Jepsen is onboard with that. She’s a Sil
phy (EEG) and functional mag icon Valley hardware engineer who recently
netic resonance imaging (fMRI), founded Openwater, a start-up building a
physicians and neuroscien ski-cap-shaped device that will use
tists can measure changes skull-penetrating infrared light to
in your brain without drill measure blood flow—a sign of
ing a hole in your skull. which brain areas are working
And now some of the hardest. Jepsen conceived the
problems that made technology as a low-cost sub
these tools finicky, stitute for fMRI for diagnos
expensive and hard ing brain injuries or neuro
to interpret are be degenerative diseases. But
ing ironed out, mean one day, she says, it might
ing that neural inter also be used to read thoughts.
faces are suddenly show That could be a boon for
ing up at Amazon and Target. Which presents a challenge because people with disabilities, but it is also a privacy nightmare in the
measuring brain activity isn’t like making microwave popcorn. making. “I think the mind-reading scenarios are farther out, but
There are enormous privacy and ethical issues at stake. the reason I’m talking about them early is because they do have
The story of Toronto-based InteraXon, a brain-machine inter profound ethical and legal implications,” Jepsen says. “The only
face start-up founded in 2007, shows how fast things are chang way we’re going to release something is if we have ways to define
ing. Getting reliable brain-wave measurements via EEG used to what it means to be responsible.”
mean pasting dozens of electrodes to a subject’s scalp. But Intera As with so many other technologies, consumer neural interfac
Xon built a wearable EEG device with just a few electrodes that es seem destined to reach consumers before they’re fully cooked.
rest against the forehead and behind the ears, along with soft For now they’ll be best served with a healthy side of caution.
ware to classify the brain waves they measure. Low-frequency
J O I N T H E C O N V E R S AT I O N O N L I N E
“alpha” waves indicate a relaxed state; higher-frequency “beta” Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
or “gamma” waves indicate a busy or concentrating mind. or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
22 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Wren McDonald

THE
NEUROTECH
INTENTION
MACHINE
A new generation of brain-machine
interface can deduce what a person wants
By Richard Andersen
Illustration by Mark Ross

I
Richard Andersen is James G. Boswell Professor of Neuroscience and the Tianqiao
and Chrissy Chen Brain-Machine Interface Center Leadership chair and center
director at the California Institute of Technology. He studies the neural mechanisms
of sight, hearing, balance, touch and action, and the development of neural
prostheses. Andersen is a member of the National Academy of Sciences and the
National Academy of Medicine.
get goose bumps every time I see it. A paralyzed volunteer sits in a wheelchair while
controlling a computer or robotic limb just with his or her thoughts—a demonstra-
tion of a brain-machine interface (BMI) in action.
That happened in my laboratory in 2013, when Erik Sorto, a victim of a gunshot
wound when he was 21 years old, used his thoughts alone to drink a beer without
help for the first time in more than 10 years. The BMI sent a neural message from a
high-level cortical area. An electromechanical appendage was then able to reach out
and grasp the bottle, raising it to Sorto’s lips before a sip was taken. His drink came a year after
surgery to implant electrodes in his brain to control signals that govern the thoughts that trig-
ger motor movement. My lab colleagues and I watched in wonderment as he completed this
deceptively simple task that is, in reality, intricately complex.
Witnessing such a feat immediately raises the ques- challenges of reading neural signals need to be ad
tion of how mere thoughts can control a mechanical dressed before this next-generation technology reach-
prosthesis. We move our limbs unthinkingly every day— es patients. Coarse read-out techniques already exist.
and completing these motions with ease is the goal of The electroencephalogram (EEG) records the average
any sophisticated BMI. Neuroscientists, though, have activity over centimeters of brain tissue, capturing the
tried for decades to decode neural signals that initiate activity of many millions of neurons rather than that
movements to reach out and grab objects. Limited suc- from individual neurons in a single circuit. Function-
cess in reading these signals has spurred a search for al magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) is an indirect
new ways to tap into the cacophony of electrical activi- measurement that records an increase in blood flow
ty resonating as the brain’s 86 billion neurons commu- to an active region. It can image smaller areas than
nicate. A new generation of BMI now holds the promise EEG, but its resolution is still rather low. Changes in
of creating a seamless tie between brain and prosthesis blood flow are slow, so fMRI cannot distinguish rapid
by tapping with great precision into the neural regions changes in brain activity.
IN BRIEF that formulate actions—whether the desired goal is To overcome these limitations, ideally one would
Brain-machine grasping a cup or taking a step. like to record the activity of individual neurons. Observ-
interfaces, o r ing changes in the firing rate of large numbers of single
BMIs, can send FROM BRAIN TO ROBOT neurons can provide the most complete picture of what
and receive messag-
A BMI operates by sending and receiving—“writing” and is happening in a specific brain region. In recent years
es to and from
neural circuits.
“reading”—messages to and from the brain. There are arrays of tiny electrodes implanted in the brain have
Existing BMIs two major classes of the interface technology. A “write- begun to make this type of recording possible. The
tend to provide in” BMI generally uses electrical stimulation to trans- arrays now in use are four-by-four-millimeter flat sur-
imprecise or slug- mit a signal to neural tissue. Successful clinical applica- faces with 100 electrodes. Each electrode, measuring
gish performance. tions of this technology are already in use. The cochlear one to 1.5 millimeters long, sticks out of the flat surface.
New research prosthesis stimulates the auditory nerve to enable deaf The entire array, which resembles a bed of nails, can
puts the interfaces subjects to hear. Deep-brain stimulation of an area that record activity from 100 to 200 neurons.
in brain areas that
controls motor activity, the basal ganglia, treats motor The signals recorded by these electrodes move to
formulate a person’s
intentions to move,
disorders such as Parkinson’s disease and essential “decoders” that use mathematical algorithms to trans-
making the technol- tremor. Devices that stimulate the retina are currently late varied patterns of single-neuron firing into a sig-
ogy more versatile in clinical trials to alleviate certain forms of blindness. nal that initiates a particular movement, such as con-
for those with spinal “Read-out” BMIs, in contrast, record neural activity trol of a robotic limb or a computer. These read-out
cord injuries. and are still at a developmental stage. The unique BMIs will assist patients who have sustained brain in

jury because of spinal cord lesions, stroke, multiple
sclerosis, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and Duchenne
muscular dystrophy.
Our lab has concentrated on tetraplegic subjects,
who are unable to move either their upper or lower
limbs because of upper spinal cord injuries. We make
recordings from the cerebral cortex, the approximate-
ly three-millimeter-thick surface of the brain’s two
large hemispheres. If spread flat, the cortex of each
hemisphere would measure about 80,000 square mil-
limeters. The number of cortical regions that special-
ize in controlling specific brain functions has grown
as more data have been collected and is now estimat-
ed to encompass more than 180 areas. These locations
process sensory information, communicate to other
brain regions involved with cognition, make decisions
or send commands to trigger an action.
In short, a brain-machine interface can interact
with many areas of the cortex. Among them are the
primary cortical areas, which detect sensory inputs,
such as the angle and intensity of light impinging on
the retina or the sensation triggered in a peripheral
nerve ending. Also targeted are the densely connected
association cortices between the primary areas that
are specialized for language, object recognition, emo-
tion and executive control of decision-making.
A handful of groups have begun to record popula-
tions of single neurons in paralyzed patients, allowing
them to operate a prosthesis in the controlled setting
of a lab. Major hurdles still persist before a patient can
be outfitted with a neural prosthetic device as easily as
a heart pacemaker. My group is pursuing recordings couple of hundred milliseconds, whereas figuring out INTERFACE
from the association areas instead of the motor cortex the trajectory signal from the motor cortex can take TECHNOLOGY,
targeted by other labs. Doing so, we hope, may provide more than a second. developed by
greater speed and versatility in sensing the firing of Richard Ander
neural signals that convey a patient’s intentions. FROM LAB TO PATIENT sen of Caltech
The specific association area my lab has studied is It was not easy t o go from experiments in lab animals (left) and his
the posterior parietal cortex (PPC), where plans to initi- to studies of the PPC in humans. Fifteen years elapsed team, enabled
ate movements begin. In our work with nonhuman pri- before we made the first human implant. First, we Erik Sorto (right)
mates, we found one subarea of the PPC, called the lat- inserted the same electrode arrays we planned to use to move a
eral intraparietal cortex, that discerns intentions to in humans into healthy nonhuman primates. The robotic arm.
begin eye movements. Limb-movement processing monkeys then learned to control computer cursors or
occurs elsewhere in the PPC. The parietal reach region robotic limbs.
prepares arm movements. Also, Hideo Sakata, then at We built a team of scientists, clinicians and rehabili-
the Nihon University School of Medicine in Japan, and tation professionals from the California Institute of
his colleagues found that the anterior intraparietal Technology, the University of Southern California, the
area formulates grasping movements. University of California, Los Angeles, the Rancho Los
LANCE HAYASHIDA AND CALIFORNIA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
The PPC provides several possible advantages for Amigos National Rehabilitation Center, and Casa Colina
brain control of robotics or a computer cursor. It con- Hospital and Centers for Healthcare. The team received
trols both arms, whereas the motor cortex in each a go-ahead from the Food and Drug Administration and
hemisphere, the area targeted by other labs, activates institutional review boards charged with judging the
the limb on the opposite side of the body. The PPC also safety and ethics of the procedure in the labs, hospitals
indicates the goal of a movement. When a nonhuman and rehabilitation clinics involved.
primate, for instance, is visually cued to reach for an A volunteer in this type of project is a true pioneer
object, this brain area switches on immediately, flag- because he or she may or may not benefit. Participants
ging the location of a desired object. In contrast, the ultimately join to help users of the technology who will
motor cortex sends a signal for the path the reaching seek it out once it is perfected for everyday use. The
movement should take. Knowing the goal of an intend- implant surgery for Sorto, our first volunteer, took place
ed motor action lets the BMI decode it quickly, within a in April 2013 and was performed by neurosurgeons

Charles Liu and Brian Lee. The procedure went flawless-
ly, but then came the wait for healing before we could
test the device.
My colleagues at nasa’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory,
By Thought Alone
which built and launched the Mars rovers, talk about For 15 years n euroscientists have built brain-machine interfac-
the seven minutes of terror when a rover enters the es (BMIs) that allow neural signals to move computer cursors
planet’s atmosphere before it lands. For me it was two or operate prostheses. The technology has moved forward
weeks of trepidation, wondering whether the implant slowly because translating the electrical firing of neurons into
would work. We knew in nonhuman primates how sim- commands to play a video game or move a robot arm are high-
ilar areas of the brain functioned, but a human implant ly intricate processes.
was testing uncharted waters. No one had ever tried to A group at the California Institute of Technology has tried to
record from a population of PPC neurons before. advance the neuroprosthetic field by tapping into high-level neu-
During the first day of testing we detected neural ral processing—the intent to initiate an action—and then con-
activity, and by the end of the week there were signals veying the relevant electrical signals to a robotic arm. Instead of
from enough neurons to begin to determine if Sorto sending out signals from the motor cortex to move an arm, as
could control a robot limb. Some of the neurons varied attempted by other laboratories, the Caltech researchers place
their activity when Sorto imagined rotating his hand. electrodes in the posterior parietal cortex (PPC), which trans
His first task consisted of turning the robot hand to dif- mits to a prosthesis the brain’s intent to act.
ferent orientations to shake hands with a graduate stu- Decoding neural signals remains a challenge for neuroscien-
dent. He was thrilled, as were we, because this accom- tists. But using BMI signals from the posterior parietal cortex,
plishment marked the first time since his injury he the top of the cognitive command chain, appears to result in
could interact with the world using the bodily move- faster, more versatile control of prosthetic technology.
ment of a robotic arm.
People often ask how long it takes to learn to use a
BMI. In fact, the technology worked right out of the
box. It was intuitive and easy to use the brain’s inten-
tion signals to control the robotic arm. By imagining
different actions, Sorto could watch recordings of
individual neurons from his cortex and turn them on
and off at will.
We ask participants at the beginning of a study
what they would like to achieve by controlling a robot.
For Sorto, he wanted to be able to drink a beer on his
own rather than asking someone else for help. He was
able to master this feat about one year into the study.
With the team co-led by research scientist Spencer
Kellis of Caltech, which included roboticists from the
Applied Physics Laboratory at Johns Hopkins Univer-
sity, we melded Sorto’s intention signals with the pro-
cessing power furnished by machine vision and smart
robotic technology.
The vision algorithm analyzes inputs from video
cameras, and the smart robot combines the intent sig-
nal with computer algorithms to initiate the move-
ment of the robot arm. Sorto achieved this goal after a
year’s time with cheers and shouts of joy from every-
one present. In 2015 we published in Science o ur first
results on using intention signals from the PPC to con-
trol neural prostheses.
Sorto is not the only user of our technology. Nancy
Smith, now in her fourth year in the study, became tet-
raplegic from an automobile accident about 10 years
ago. She had been a high school teacher of computer
graphics and played piano as a pastime. In our studies
with lead team members Tyson Aflalo of Caltech and
Nader Pouratian of U.C.L.A., we found a detailed rep-
resentation of the individual digits of both hands in
Smith’s PPC. Using virtual reality, she could imagine
and move 10 fingers individually on left and right
28 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by AXS Biomedical Animation Studio

The Andersen laboratory at Caltech has pursued development of BMIs that “read
out“ brain signals of an intent to take an action and send them to a robotic arm
that can pick up a glass and allow a tetraplegic patient to drink (1–6). The BMI
provides touch and limb-positioning feedback—“write-in” signals—to the
ARRAY 3 somatosensory cortex that simulates tactile sensations and allows for fine-level
Electrode adjustments to the prosthesis (6–9). The researchers are currently integrating
arrays read out the
intended movements
2 read-out and write-in capabilities to achieve a fully bidirectional BMI.
from the activity INTENTION

of PPC neurons. The PPC forms movement intentions that
Premotor areas
normally go to the premotor and then
the motor cortex. But with spinal cord Primary motor cortex (hand area)
injury, the motor cortex becomes
disconnected from
the muscles of the
body below
the injury.
Reach
Grasp (hand shape)

Saccade (rapid eye
movements)
C
PP
1
Primary somatosensory
INPUT cortex (hand area)
Signals from sensory and
memory areas of the
cerebral cortex all converge
on the PPC. 9
Primary Episodic memory ARRAY
visual cortex Electrical stimulation in
the somatosensory cortex
produces the sensations
of touch and position from
the robot hand.
4 NEURAL SIGNAL
PROCESSOR
Electronics decode the CONTROL 5 8 STIMULATOR
intention signals quickly COMPUTER The stimulator generates
and formulate commands The commands can be small electric currents
for the robotic arm. coupled with video or to the electrodes of
eye-movement signals
7 CONTROL the stimulation array.
to increase the precision COMPUTER
of the command. Sensors on the robot
fingers and hand
detect position and
touch data, which are
sent to a stimulator.
6
ACTION
The electronically processed brain
signals prod the prosthesis to pick
up a glass, bring it to the lips and hold
it steady, allowing a sip to be taken.

“avatar” hands displayed on a computer screen. Using that registered parts of a scene. The same cells also
the imagined movement of five fingers from one hand, carried eye-position information. The two signals
Smith could play simple melodies on a computer-gen- interacted by multiplying the visual response by the
erated piano keyboard. position of the eyes in the head—the product of which
is called a gain field.
HOW THE BRAIN REPRESENTS GOALS I continued to pursue this problem of understand-
We were thrilled in working with these patients to ing the brain’s representation of space when I took my
find neurons tuned to processing signals related to first faculty position at the Salk Institute for Biological
one’s intentions. The amount of information to be Studies, right across the street from the University of
gleaned from just a few hundred neurons turned out California, San Diego. Working with David Zipser, a
to be overwhelming. We could decode a range of cogni- U.C.S.D. theoretical neuroscientist developing neural
tive activity, including mental strategizing (imagined networks, we reported in N ature o n a computational
versus attempted motion), finger movements, deci- model of a neural network that combined retinotopic
sions about recalling visual stimuli, hand postures for locations with gaze direction to make maps of space
that are invariant to eye movements. During training
of the neural networks, their middle layers developed
Inserting a few tiny gain fields, just as was the case in the PPC experiments.
By mixing signals for visual inputs and eye positions
electrode arrays into

within the same neurons, as few as nine neurons could
represent the entire visual field.
Recently this idea of mixed representations—pop-
the brain enabled us to ulations of neurons responding to multiple variables

(as with the gain fields)—has attracted renewed atten-
decode much of what tion. For instance, recordings from the prefrontal cor-
tex show a mixing of two types of memory task and
a person intends to do. different visual objects.

This work, moreover, may have a direct bearing in
explaining what is happening in the PPC. We discov-
ered this when we asked Smith, using a set of written
grasping, observed actions, action verbs such as “grasp” instructions, to perform eight different combinations
or “push,” and mathematical calculations. To our sur- of a task. One of her undertakings required strategiz-
prise, inserting a few tiny electrode arrays enabled us ing to imagine or attempt an action. Another necessi-
to decode much of what a person intends to do. tated using the right and left side of the body; a third
The question of how much information can be re entailed squeezing a hand or shrugging a shoulder.
corded from a small patch of brain tissue reminded We found that PPC neurons mixed all these variables—
me of a similar scientific problem that I had encoun- and the intermingling exhibited a specific pattern,
tered early in my career. During my postdoctoral train- unlike the random interactions we and others had
ing with the late Vernon Mountcastle at the Johns reported in lab animal experiments.
Hopkins School of Medicine, we examined how visual Activity of populations of neurons for strategizing
space is represented in the PPC of monkeys. Our eyes and for controlling each body side tends to overlap. If
are like cameras, with the photosensitive retinas sig- a neuron fires to initiate the movement of the left
naling the location of visual stimuli imaged on them— hand, it will most likely also respond for an attempted
the entire image is referred to as a retinotopic map. righthand movement, whereas neuron groups that
Neurons respond to limited regions of the retina, control the shoulder and hand are more separated.
referred to as their receptive fields. In other ways, pro- We refer to this type of representation as partially
cessing visual perception is different than a video cam- mixed selectivity. We have since found similarities in
era recording. When a video camera moves around, the partially mixed representations that seem to make up
recorded image also shifts, but when we move our eyes a semantics of movement. The activity of cells tuned
the world seems stable. The retinotopic image coming for the same action type tends to overlap. A neuron
from the eyes must be converted into a visual repre- that responds to videos of a person grasping an object
sentation of space that takes into account where the will also likely become active when a person reads the
eyes are looking so that as they move, the world does word “grasp.” But cells responding to an action such
not appear as if it were sliding around. as pushing tend to get separated into their own group.
The PPC is a key processing center for high-order In general, partially mixed coding appears to underlie
visual space representation. To reach and grab an computations that are similar (movements of the left
object, the brain needs to take into account where the hand are similar to those of the right). It also sepa-
eyes are looking to pick it up. PPC lesions in humans rates those that exhibit varying forms of neural pro-
produce inaccurate reaching. In Mountcastle’s lab, we cessing (movement of the shoulder differs from move-
found individual PPC neurons had receptive fields ment of the hand).

Mixed and partially mixed coding have been found trodes for sending and receiving neural signals. We
in certain parts of the association cortex—and new have found that implants continue to function for a
studies must explore whether they appear in other lo relatively lengthy five years. But better electrodes
cations that govern language, object recognition and would ideally push the longevity of these systems even
executive control. Additionally, we would like to know further and increase the number of neurons that can
whether the primary sensory or motor cortical regions be recorded from. Another priority—an increase in
use a similar partially mixed structure. the lengths of the electrodes’ tiny spikes—would help
Another near-future goal is to find out how much access areas located within folds of the cortex.
learning new tasks can affect the performance of the Flexible electrodes, which move with the slight jos-
volunteers using the prosthesis. If learning readily takes tling of the brain—from changes in blood pressure or
place, any area of the brain might then be implanted the routine breathing cycle—will also allow for more
and trained for any conceivable BMI task. An implant in stable recordings. Existing electrodes require recali-
the primary visual cortex could learn to control nonvi- brating the decoder because the stiff electrodes change
sual tasks. But if learning is more restricted, an implant position with respect to neurons from day to day—
in, say, a motor area would be trained only for motor researchers would ultimately like to follow the activity
tasks. Early results suggest that an implant may have to of identical neurons over weeks and months.
be placed in the area that has been previously identified The implants need to be miniaturized, operate on
as controlling particular cognitive activities. low power (to avoid heating the brain), and function
wirelessly so no cables are needed to connect the de
WRITING IN SENSATIONS vice to brain tissue. All current BMI technology needs
A BMI must do more than just receive and process brain to be implanted with a surgical procedure. But one
signals—it must also send feedback from a prosthesis day, we hope, recording and stimulation interfaces
to the brain. When we reach to pick up an object, visu- will be developed that can receive and send signals
al feedback helps to direct the hand to the target. The through the skull and provide performance equal to
positioning of the hand depends on the shape of the existing surgically implanted arrays.
object to be grasped. If the hand does not receive BMIs, of course, are aimed at assisting people with
touch and limb-positioning signals once it begins to paralysis. Yet science-fiction books, movies and the
manipulate the object, performance degrades quickly. media have focused on the use of the technology for
Finding a way to correct this deficit is critical for enhancement, conferring “superhuman” abilities that
our volunteers with spinal cord lesions, who cannot might allow a person to run faster and jump higher.
move their body below the injury. They also do not But enhancement will be achieved only when noninva-
perceive the tactile sensations or positioning of their sive technologies able to detect the activities of single
body that are essential to fluid movement. An ideal neu- neurons precisely are developed.
ral prosthesis, then, must compensate through bidirec- Finally, I would like to convey the satisfaction of
tional signaling: it must transmit the intentions of the doing basic research and making it available to pa
volunteer but also detect the touch and positioning tients. Fundamental science is necessary to both ad
information arriving from sensors on a robotic limb. vance knowledge and develop medical therapies. To
Robert Gaunt and his colleagues at the University of be able to then transfer these discoveries into a clini-
Pittsburgh have addressed this issue by implanting mi cal setting brings the research endeavor to its ulti-
croelectrode arrays in the somatosensory cortex of a tet mate realization. A scientist is left with an undeniable
raplegic person—where inputs from the limbs process feeling of personal fulfillment in sharing with patients
feelings of touch. Gaunt’s lab sent small electric cur- their delight at being able to move a robotic limb to
rents through the microelectrodes, and the subject re interact again with the physical world.
ported sensations from parts of the surface of the hand.
We have also used similar implants in the arm
region of the somatosensory cortex. To our pleasant
MORE TO EXPLORE
surprise, our subject, FG, reported natural sensations
Reach and Grasp by People with Tetraplegia Using a Neurally Controlled Robotic Arm. L eigh R.
such as squeezing, tapping and vibrations on the skin, Hochberg et al. in N ature, V
ol. 485, pages 372–375; May 17, 2012.
known as cutaneous sensations. He also perceived the High-Performance Neuroprosthetic Control by an Individual with Tetraplegia. J ennifer L. Collinger
feeling that the limb was moving—a sensation re et al. in L ancet, Vol. 381, pages 557–564; February 16, 2013.
ferred to as proprioception. These experiments show Decoding Motor Imagery from the Posterior Parietal Cortex of a Tetraplegic Human. Tyson Aflalo
et al. in Science, Vol. 348, pages 906–910; May 22, 2015.
that subjects who have lost limb sensation can regain Intracortical Microstimulation of Human Somatosensory Cortex. S harlene N. Flesher et al. in
it through BMIs that write-in perceptions. The next Science Translational Medicine, V ol. 8, No. 361, Article No. 361ra141; October 19, 2016.
step is to use sensor-laden robotic hands to check if Proprioceptive and Cutaneous Sensations in Humans Elicited by Intracortical Microstimulation.
somatosensory feedback improves robotic dexterity Michelle Armenta Salas et al. in eLife, Vol. 7, Article No. e32904; April 10, 2018.
under brain control. Also, we would like to know if FROM OUR ARCHIVES
subjects detect a sense of “embodiment,” in which the Is Anybody in There? Adrian M. Owen; May 2014.
robot limb appears to become part of their body.
s c i e n t if i c a m e r i c a n . c o m /m a g a zi n e /s a
Another major challenge is to develop better elec-

OYSTERS are tested in experimental
configurations for shoring up a coastline
near Beaufort, N.C.
BEYOND
SEAWALLS
INFRASTRUCTURE
Fortified wetlands can protect shorelines

better than hard structures
By Rowan Jacobsen
Photographs by John Althouse April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 33

O
Rowan Jacobsen is author of A Geography of Oysters,
The Living Shore and other books. He wrote about
the genes of extinct flowers in our February issue.
n August 27, 2011, Hurricane Irene crashed into North Carolina,

eviscerating the Outer Banks. The storm dumped rain shin-high
and hurled three-meter storm surges against the barrier island
shores that faced the mainland, destroying roads and 1,100 homes.
After the storm, a young ecologist then at the University of to believe that “living shorelines”—natural communities of salt
North Carolina at Chapel Hill named Rachel K. Gittman decided marsh, mangrove, oyster reef, beach and coral reef—can be sur-
to survey the affected areas. Gittman had worked as an environ- prisingly effective in a battle coastal residents have been losing for
mental consultant for the U.S. Navy on a shoreline-stabilization years. U.S. shores are disintegrating as higher seas, stronger
project and had been shocked to discover how little information storms and runaway development trigger an epidemic of erosion
existed on coastal resilience. “The more I researched, the more I and flood damage. Every day waves bite off another 89 hectares of
realized that we just don’t know very much,” she explains. “So the country. Every year another $500 million of property disap-
much policy and management is being made without the under- pears. Overall, some 40 percent of the U.S. coastline is suffering
lying science.” She decided to make shorelines her specialty. ongoing erosion. In some places, the rate of loss is breathtaking.
What Gittman found was eye-opening. Along the hard-hit Go to Google Earth Engine’s Timelapse feature and watch Shack
shorelines, three quarters of the bulkheads were damaged. The leford Banks melt away like ice cream on a summer sidewalk.
walls, typically concrete and about two meters high, are the Historically, almost all money spent on coastal defense has
standard homeowner defense against the sea in many parts of gone toward “gray” infrastructure: seawalls, bulkheads, levees
the country. Yet none of the natural marsh shorelines were and rock revetments. That is beginning to c‑hange as research-
impaired. The marshes, which extended 10 to 40 meters from ers become more sophisticated in measuring the long-term im
the shore, had lost no sediment or elevation from Irene. Al pact of “green” coastal defenses. Insurance companies and gov-
though the storm initially reduced the density of their vegeta- ernments are finally taking notice and might actually turn the
tion by more than a third, a year later the greenery had bounced tide toward living defenses.
back and was as thick as ever in many cases.
Gittman’s study confirmed what many experts had begun to WETLANDS OUTPERFORM WALLS
suspect. “Armored” shorelines such as bulkheads offer less pro- Around the time t hat Hurricane Irene was barreling up the East
tection against big storms than people think. By reflecting wave Coast, Michael W. Beck, a research professor at the University of
energy instead of dispersing it, they tend to wear away at the California, Santa Cruz, and then lead marine scientist for the
base, which causes them to gradually tilt seaward. Although Nature Conservancy, was initiating a collaboration with the
they still function well in typical storms, they often backfire insurance industry that today may begin to change coastal con-
when high storm surges overtop them, causing them to breach servation. “A lot of people were saying that ecosystems worked
or collapse, releasing an entire backyard into the sea. for flood protection, but the evidence was thin,” Beck tells me at
In a later study, Gittman and other researchers surveyed 689 his Santa Cruz office. The physical mechanisms were clear: oys-
waterfront owners and found that the 37 percent of properties ter and coral reefs limited erosion and flood damage by acting
protected by bulkheads had suffered 93 percent of the damage. as natural breakwaters (offshore seawalls), dispersing wave
And bulkhead owners routinely had four times the annual energy with their corrugated surfaces. Salt marshes and man-
maintenance costs of residents who relied on nature instead. groves, with their earthen berms and friction-generating for-
Salt marshes bent but did not break. ests of stalks, could rake more than 50 percent of the energy out
In recent years more scientists and policy makers have come of storm surges in less than 15 meters of territory.
IN BRIEF
Surprising data s how that in many places marshes Scientists are perfecting t echniques for rebuilding Governments and disaster plannersare starting
protect shorelines better than walls and are cheaper tattered wetlands, creating custom configurations to give more consideration to living shorelines, and
to construct. for individual shorelines. money to restore them is rising.

DEVELOPERS survey oysters that have settled onto Oyster Catcher,
a jute-and-cement material designed to help babies and adults thrive,
protecting marshes between them and solid land.
But although scientists understood the physics, no one had returning just $1 in savings for every $4 of expense. Smaller
put it into a form that could be used easily by policy makers. levees built on land in front of many low-lying coastal communi-
Beck set out to rectify that. “If I want to change practices, I can’t ties prevented much more damage for almost the same cost.
bring my ecosystem model to fema or the U.S. Army Corps of In terms of bang for the buck, sandbags were the best invest-
Engineers,” he explains. “I have to look at their risk model and ment, saving $8.4 billion of damages for a mere $0.84 billion in
put ecosystems into that.” expense. Natural defenses ranked high as well. Wetlands restora-
Beck and his colleagues began collaborating with Lloyd’s of tion, which could prevent $18.2 billion of losses, would cost just
London, Swiss Re and others in the insurance industry, which $2 billion. Oyster-reef restoration could prevent $9.7 billion in
have some of the best data and models in the world on assets and losses for $1.3 billion. Barrier island restoration offered $5.9 bil-
risk. When he plugged data on coastal ecosystems into their risk lion of prevention for $1.2 billion. And “beach nourishment” (re
models, it became clear that living shorelines were excellent de plenishing depleted beaches with sand dredged from the sea-
fenses. And, he notes, “when I tell the Corps, fema and the devel- floor) in the eastern Gulf could save $9.3 billion for $5.5 billion.
opment banks that these are the numbers from the insurance That last one surprised many people because replacing
industry, I automatically have a different level of credibility.” beach sand year after year is often seen as a fool’s errand. “If the
The first study focused on damages from Superstorm Sandy, only choices you gave me were beach nourishment versus fully
which clobbered New York and New Jersey in 2012. Working with gray infrastructure,” Beck says, “I’d choose the former as the
Risk Management Solutions, a leading risk-modeling firm, the lesser of two evils.”
scientists showed that wetlands prevented $625 million of flood Overall, the research found that $57.4 of the $134 billion
damage from the storm, which was surprising given that the could be prevented cost-effectively, almost all of it through
coasts in the region had already lost 60 to 90 percent of their green infrastructure.
protective wetlands over time. In areas that flooded, the few re One type of restoration that was not part of the study is large-
maining wetlands lowered flood damage by 11 percent on aver- scale diversion of the Mississippi River. Diverting sediment-lad-
age. As important was the ability to buffer garden-variety floods: en water through a gap in the river’s levees and letting that sedi-
in one local study, properties behind marshes suffered 16 per- ment filter into struggling marshes can restore their health and
cent less annual flood damage than properties that had lost elevation, but the region is subsiding so quickly that not even the
their marshes. “That’s well within the range for which you could famously muddy Mississippi can save it from the encroaching
expect [insurance] premium reductions,” Beck points out. sea. “It is going to be expensive to re-create an entire ecosystem,”
He and his partners then turned their economic and risk- Beck says, “and it is better and cheaper to start earlier.”
management models on the Gulf Coast from Texas to Florida, Cost-effective restoration may be tricky on long, sandy coasts,
which is regularly battered by big storms. They did an exhaustive too. Beaches and barrier islands are by nature transient. Plant-
analysis of the annual expected benefits and costs of all types of ing grasses to rebuild dunes can help keep beaches in place but
infrastructure. The team estimated that the coast would suffer only temporarily in many cases. At some point, residents will
$134 billion of losses over 20 years if no preventive measures have to move back from the receding shoreline.
were taken. Elevating homes could prevent $39.4 billion of those Beck is quick to point out that built infrastructure is still in-
losses, but it is incredibly expensive. At an average of $83,300 per credibly important and that cost-effectiveness is not the only con-
house, it would cost $54 billion to prevent that $39 billion in sideration. “Anywhere you’ve got significant people and property,”
damages. The six-meter-high dikes being built in Louisiana were he says, natural solutions will “be used together with some form
a worse option; at $33,000 per meter, they were an absurdly of built infrastructure.” Metropolitan areas, ports and other plac-
expensive way to protect a relatively limited amount of property, es where the risk tolerance for a major flood would be extremely

low need seawalls, even if such native material called Oyster
structures are not cost-effective. Catcher that is made of jute cloth
Still, Beck says, certain populated dipped in Portland cement and
areas can benefit from a hybrid rolled into various hollow configu-
approach: “Even if you’re build- rations. It hardens with extensive
ing levees, they can be shorter if surface area to recruit larval oys-
they have marshes in front.” ters. In addition to being light and
flexible, it holds together just long
SHORELINE TRIALS enough to get a reef established,
AND ERRORS then disintegrates. The product
One reason living shorelines are received its first big test when
becoming an economically viable Hurricanes Florence and Michael
approach for coastal defense is struck North Carolina last fall.
that researchers and municipali- Michael tossed shell bags up into
ties are getting better at rebuild- the marshes, but the Oyster Catch-
ing them. Early marsh-restoration er reefs did not budge. The show-
designs, which followed forestry ing was encouraging, but Gitt-
science and gave each plant plenty man worries that conservation
of space to avoid competition, groups may oversell the potential.
were actually counterproductive. “A living shoreline can’t save your
It turns out that in bare mudflats, house from a Category 5 storm.
“when marsh plants are together, Although neither can a bulkhead.”
they share oxygen, so their growth Gittman and Beck both stress
rate is twice as high,” says Brian the need to tailor living shore-
Silliman, an ecologist at Duke Uni- lines to local conditions. One rea-
versity. Root them in large clumps, son oyster restoration is so cost-
and the growth rate of each indi- effective in the Gulf and the
vidual plant can triple. Add blue Southeast is because there have
crabs, which eat the snails that eat been plentiful wild oysters to
the salt-marsh grasses, and the seed new reefs with babies. That
ECOLOGISTS, including Rachel Gittman (in white),
plants do even better. is not the case in most of the
measure water levels and grasses at Carrot Island, N.C.
Scientists are also finding that country. Chesapeake Bay, for ex-
marshes do best when they have ample, was long the poster child
a protective sill—a linear berm that fronts the seaside edge of for futile oyster restoration. Oyster populations in the bay had
the grass and stands. Made of hard material such as shell, stone fallen to less than 1 percent of historical norms, and decades of
or concrete, its height and position are typically chosen so that effort and tens of millions of dollars barely budged the needle.
water covers it at high tide, but it is exposed during low tide. The “Conceptually, Chesapeake Bay was not our best model,”
sill takes the brunt of wave energy but also traps sediment be Beck says. “It put oyster-reef restoration back because it made it
hind it, allowing the grass to thrive and marsh floor to retain its look so difficult and expensive. Well, when you’re working in a
elevation or even rise. system where you’ve only got 1 percent left, guess what? It ain’t
Almost any hard material can make a successful sill. Large easy. When you’re in the Gulf of Mexico and you’ve still got
shoreline-stabilization projects use big boulders or stackable con- 50 percent of your reefs left, it’s a different story. If you build it,
crete blocks, a practice that has been criticized by some experts the oysters will come.”
who say that these structures are living shorelines in name only. Beck extends that lesson to coral reefs, the most underappre-
But many lower-profile restorations integrate sills more seam- ciated of natural defenses. “Coral reefs are the single most effec-
lessly into the natural habitat. In the Southeast and Gulf Coast tive ecosystem for flood-risk reduction,” he says. Corals, which
regions, marshes historically possessed a natural sill in the form have evolved to take a daily pounding that would destroy most
of an intertidal oyster reef. Many of those reefs were overharvest- other living things, form natural seawalls exactly where you
ed long ago, ruining the sill and exposing the marshes to erosion. want them—just offshore, in front of resorts, beach towns, coast-
In these warm, oyster-friendly waters, new sills can be formed al roads and other pricey assets. When healthy, they make re
by placing a hard substrate along the low-tide line at the front edge markably effective breakwaters, reducing wave energy up to
of the marsh for baby oysters to set on. Some sites with lots of wave 97 percent. They are also affordable: reef restoration averages
action have used small, hollow concrete structures or plastic mesh about $1,300 per meter versus $20,000 for artificial breakwater
“onion bags” stuffed with shell and lashed together. When success- construction. The insurance industry’s assessment for mitigat-
ful, these artificial materials are quickly covered by oysters and ing risk from climate change in the Caribbean found that reviv-
disappear into the interstices of the growing reef. But the concrete ing reefs and mangroves was an order of magnitude more cost-
often remains visible for years, and the bags have been criticized effective than seawalls or breakwaters.
for breaking and scattering plastic through the environment. Even though reefs do not line a lot of shorefronts, the annu-
Gittman, now at East Carolina University, is testing an alter- al expected benefits they generate are significant—more than $100

million a year in the U.S. alone and more than $400 million a year whose New Jersey district was devastated by Superstorm Sandy.
each in Mexico, Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines and Cuba. The bill would designate $20 million in grants a year to living-
Of course, many coral reefs are not healthy, and losing just a shoreline work. A Senate version was introduced by Chris Mur-
single meter of reef height doubles the direct damages from phy of Connecticut and Kamala Harris of California. Their pros-
flooding. For that reason alone, Beck believes reef-restoration pects in the current Congress were uncertain at press time, but
projects will multiply. Although the science of coral restoration their existence shows that living shorelines are gaining ground.
is young, the potential is enormous—so long as a reef has not North Carolina’s Coastal Resources Commission recently ap
already collapsed. “Some of these corals actually grow pretty proved a new process that will make it as easy to obtain a living-
fast,” Beck says. “For example, in places in Indonesia where shoreline permit as that for a bulkhead. Maryland has an even
there’s still good reef habitat and lots of healthy corals around stronger law in place, requiring a homeowner to prove why a
small sites that have been destroyed by blast fishing, reefs can bulkhead is needed instead of a natural shoreline. Other states
turn around pretty quickly.” may follow these leads.
The most promising indication of all may be the 2018 agree-
RISING TIDE OF SUPPORT ment made by the Nature Conservancy, the reinsurance industry
Coastal restoration may finally be getting the attention it de and the Mexican state of Quintana Roo to create a trust fund to
serves. “Things are really beginning to change,” Beck says. The protect the Mesoamerican Reef, off the coast of Cancún and Puer-
Army Corps, which for decades has favored hardscape solutions, to Morelos. The deal will include the first insurance policy ever
has launched an Engineering With Nature initiative—something taken out on a natural ecosystem. If the reef is damaged by a
many planners thought they would never see. The National Oce- storm, insurance funds are released to rebuild its natural capital.
anic and Atmospheric Administration has made living shorelines For living shorelines to become an important part of any
a centerpiece of its coastal-resilience blueprint. Hundreds of long-term coastal defense plan, policy makers in government,
projects have been completed or are underway around the coun- insurance and development will have to start improving and in
try, ranging from shoreline stabilizations in Maryland to bulk- stalling them before bad storms hit—and funding the next
head removal in Puget Sound. Most are small, community-based round of projects through postdisaster spending afterward.
efforts, but larger ventures are becoming more common. That requires good science and good economic numbers—which
Stimulus funding that flowed after the American Recovery now exist—as well as good proof in the form of demonstration
and Reinvestment Act of 2009 increased the size of some proj- projects, which are increasingly common.
ects significantly. Kilometers of oyster-reef projects now line The first significant examples of postdisaster spending on
Alabama, Texas and Louisiana. The flagship is Coffee Island, off natural infrastructure could occur as fema and other agencies
the Alabama coast. The shoreline had receded up to 100 meters. look to spend more than $100 billion in recovery funds from
The Nature Conservancy placed a three-kilometer-long line of recent hurricanes. Although fema’s traditional hazard-mitiga-
shell bags and concrete balls about 30 meters offshore, parallel- tion investments have focused on tactics such as buying out
ing the island. The reef immediately blocked wave energy, allow- damaged coastal homes or elevating them, the agency has ad
ing the marsh to rebuild. Within two years approximately 200 justed its new “benefit-cost analysis” policy to favor investment
baby oysters per square meter had colonized the structure, cov- in natural infrastructure. Beck expects this change in emphasis
ering it and attracting fish, crabs and birds. to result in federally funded projects of unprecedented scope in
Outside the Gulf Coast and the Southeast, restoration proj- Florida, Puerto Rico and the Gulf Coast. Other large-scale devel-
ects may be more challenging. California, for example, is a opment may soon follow worldwide as governments, disaster-
tough undertaking. “In San Francisco Bay,” Beck says, “we’ve risk managers, businesses, banks and insurers look to mitigate
lost more than 90 percent of the natural marshes, so you have their risk exposure as cost-effectively as possible. When that
to go in and re-create an environment wholesale in and around happens, it will mark a moment when society realizes nature is
a hell of a lot of people.” not a luxury. It is the future.
Yet where there is a will—and local money—there is a way. The
San Francisco Bay Clean Water, Pollution Prevention, and Habi- This article was produced in collaboration with the Food &
tat Restoration Measure, passed by Bay Area voters in 2016, rais- Environment Reporting Network, a nonprofit investigative
es $25 million a year for 20 years through a parcel tax. That $500 news organization.
million will be used to build 40,000 hectares of wetlands—the
largest shoreline restoration undertaken in the U.S.—using vari-
ous techniques. The most novel is horizontal levees. Instead of a MORE TO EXPLORE
high, narrow mound that lines the shore, horizontal levees are Marshes with and without Sills Protect Estuarine Shorelines from Erosion Better
broad mudflats, marshes and grasslands that gradually rise from Than Bulkheads during a Category 1 Hurricane. Rachel K. Gittman et al. in Ocean
& Coastal Management, V
ol. 102, Part A, pages 94–102; December 2014.
the water’s edge, sometimes for hundreds of meters back onto Managing Coasts with Natural Solutions: Guidelines for Measuring and Valuing the
the land. They are graded with vast amounts of earth (often re Coastal Protection Services of Mangroves and Coral Reefs. Edited by M. W. Beck
purposed from building projects) and planted with starter plugs. and G.-M. Lange. World Bank, January 2016.
They can be lower and 40 percent less costly than a traditional Living Shorelines Academy: w ww.livingshorelinesacademy.org
levee because the breadth absorbs floodwater. The configuration FROM OUR ARCHIVES
also gives marsh communities space to retreat as seas rise. Architects of the Swamp. John Carey; December 2013.
Another encouraging sign is the Living Shorelines Act, intro-
duced in the U.S. House of Representatives by Frank Pallone,

THE
P U B L I C H E A LT H
DENGUE
DEBACLE
Is a runaway immune reaction making
a dengue vaccine dangerous?
By Seema Yasmin and Madhusree Mukerjee

EDES AEGYPTI mosquito spreads several
A
dangerous viruses, including four that cause
dengue disease. Whereas a first bout of dengue
is usually mild, the second one can be lethal—
a peculiarity that may be creating problems
for the first ever licensed dengue vaccine.

IN Seema Yasmin is director of the Stanford Health
Communication Initiative at Stanford University, where she
DECEMBER
also teaches science journalism and global health storytelling.
She is an Emmy Award–winning reporter and author, medical
doctor and frequent contributor to Scientific American.
2015
Madhusree Mukerjee is Scientific American’s
senior editor for science and society.
then president Benigno

Aquino III of the Philippines and
others negotiated a deal with
pharmaceutical company Sanofi
to purchase three million doses of
Dengvaxia, the first vaccine ever
licensed for dengue. The plan was
to give a million schoolchildren,
nine years of age, three doses of the
vaccine each, sparing them from
the worst outcomes of dengue:
shock, organ failure and death. 1
The virus comes in four varieties. All are spread by female Dengue is scary enough that health practitioners in develop-
Aedes m
osquitoes, primarily A edes aegypti, w
ith a penchant for ing countries have been eagerly awaiting a vaccine for decades.
sucking blood during the day, when individuals are unprotect- Yet when internist Antonio Dans and pediatrician Leonila Dans,
ed by bed nets. In the past five decades these viruses, which are both clinical epidemiologists at the University of the Philippines
related to those that cause West Nile fever, yellow fever and Manila College of Medicine, read about Aquino’s vaccination
Zika, have spread in waves across the tropical and subtropical campaign in the Philippine Star, t he first thing that struck them
world, increasing dengue incidence 30-fold and affecting up- was the price tag. At three billion pisos ($57.5 million) for pro-
ward of 390 million people each year. curement alone, the Dengvaxia campaign would cost more than
Not everyone infected with a dengue virus gets sick: three the entire national vaccination program for 2015, which covered
out of four who get bitten will have no symptoms. The rest may pneumonia, tuberculosis, polio, diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis,
suffer one of three sets of symptoms: a fever that mimics many measles, mumps and rubella. It would reach less than 1 percent
other viral illnesses; “dengue fever,” which is accompanied by of the country’s approximately 105 million residents. And al-
headache, pain behind the eyes, aching joints and bones, and, though dengue was reported to kill an average of 750 people an-
in rare cases, internal bleeding; and severe disease encompass- nually in the Philippines, it was not even among the top 10 causes
ing dengue hemorrhagic fever and dengue shock syndrome. In of mortality. Among infectious diseases, pneumonia and tuber-
severe cases, plasma seeps out of capillaries, liquid pools culosis took a far heavier toll.
around organs, massive internal bleeding ensues, and the brain, Perusing an interim report from researchers at Sanofi Pas-
kidneys and liver begin to fail. Although swift hospitalization teur—the vaccine division of Sanofi—on Dengvaxia’s clinical tri-
and careful case management can and do save lives, more than als, Dans and Dans found further cause for concern. Among
20,000 people die of dengue every year. Many are children. Asian children two to five years old, those who had received the
PRECEDING PAGES: GETTY IMAGES
IN BRIEF
A mosquito-borne disease, d engue affects almost A controversial old theory, called antibody-enhanced The first ever vaccine licensed for dengue appears
400 million people worldwide every year. Whereas development (ADE), explains why a second dengue to mimic an initial dengue infection, possibly exac-
most of those affected barely notice a first dengue infection can be much deadlier than the first. New erbating a second one. The role of ADE in driving this
infection, a second one can kill. studies strongly support this theory. phenomenon remains contested.

2
vaccine were seven times m ore l ikely CHILD IN MANAGUA, Nicaragua, yields where 70 percent or more of a popu-
than unvaccinated children to have a blood sample (1) for an extensive study lation had already had dengue,
been hospitalized for serious dengue of dengue disease. Another child (2) looks where immunization of early adoles-
in the third year after vaccination. down his neighborhood street. cents could reduce hospitalizations
Close examination of the data re- by up to 30 percent over a period of
vealed that although the vaccine was 30 years. A subsequent position pa-
on average safer for older children, it was statistically impossi- per from the same group stated that the vaccine was safe for
ble to rule out the possibility that for some kids, Dengvaxia children age nine and older, for whom it was recommended.
made things worse. In retrospect, it did not surprise Dans and Dans that the au-
In March 2016 Dans and Dans and other medical profession- thorities chose to ignore their concerns. “It was either believe us or
als wrote to then secretary of health Janette Garin, warning that believe the WHO,” says Antonio Dans. “If I were them, I’d believe
the vaccine could be risky for some children and that the Philip- the WHO. I mean, who were we? We were just teachers in a small
pines may not possess enough trained health care workers to medical school.” Filipino authorities were apparently so confident
monitor so many of them for possible adverse effects. A poten- about Dengvaxia’s safety that they did not oblige Sanofi Pasteur to
tially safer vaccine was in the pipeline and probably worth wait- submit results from so-called pharmacovigilance trials that would
ing for, they reasoned. usually test the safety of a new drug or vaccine in local conditions.
The same month, however, the highly respected advisory The induction of a new pharmaceutical product into the national
group on vaccines at the World Health Organization—which program typically took three to five years, says Anthony Leachon,
provides guidance to countries on immunization policy—stated a former president of the Philippine College of Physicians, but the
in a briefing paper on Dengvaxia that the hospitalizations of dengue vaccination program began right away, in April 2016.
young vaccinated children, when observed over several years, Days later came the first report of a postvaccination fatality, of
were not statistically significant. “No other safety signals have a boy with congenital heart disease. Garin explained in a press
been identified in any age group” older than five, it stated. A briefing that the boy’s death was unrelated to Dengvaxia. Dans
PAOLO HARRIS PAZ (1 and 2)
“theoretical possibility” existed that the vaccine could be risky and Dans persisted for months, however, speaking to the press
for some children, and further research was necessary lest the and posting a brief video on Facebook that warned—on the basis
issue “compromise public confidence” in the vaccine. It none- of a decades-old, highly contested theory called antibody-depen-
theless “should be introduced as part of a routine immunization dent enhancement (ADE)—that if a child had never had dengue
program in appropriate settings.” These included regions before, the vaccine might actually make a dengue infection dead-

How Antibodies May Aggravate Dengue
Four related viruses t ransmitted by Aedes m osqui subsequently become quiescent, awakening after a
toes cause dengue disease. A theory called antibody- second infection to make the same antibodies. But
dependent enhancement, postulated in the 1970s by antibodies to dengue virus 1 cannot bind well with, for
Scott B. Halstead, seeks to explain why a second example, dengue virus 2. The antibodies still deliver
bout of dengue, with a different virus, is deadlier than the invaders to the macrophages but in a way that
the first. A first infection, with, say, dengue virus 1, enables them to escape destruction and instead com
prompts B cells to make antibodies that coat the mandeer the macrophages. They use the subjugated
viruses and deliver them to white blood cells such as cells’ machinery to replicate themselves, flooding the
macrophages, which trap and kill them. The B cells body with viruses. These release a protein that dam
ages blood vessels, causing serious dengue disease.
FIRST INFECTION SECOND INFECTION
Aedes aegypti
mosquito
Dengue virus 1 Dengue virus 2
On entering the body,

dengue virus often
Skin cell
attacks skin cells
B cell
Antibody
Antibodies attach Antibodies are New copies of virus

to virus, covering unable to attach are released
and disarming it well, leaving virus
partially bare
Macrophage
Virus is trapped Virus escapes

and destroyed cell defenses
and replicates
42 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Tami Tolpa

lier than it normally would have been. Garin responded with her with Murray Valley encephalitis, West Nile, Japanese encephali-
own warning: medical practitioners who engaged in “misinfor- tis or Getah viruses infected more cells when the virus was
mation” on Dengvaxia would be responsible for every death from mixed with antibodies compared with the virus alone. Hawkes
dengue that could have been prevented by the vaccine. proposed that the antibodies were stabilizing the virus and in-
There the matter rested until November 2017, when Sanofi Pas- creasing their ability to attach to cells. Independently, Halstead
teur issued its own advisory: those who had never experienced a was wondering if much the same was happening with dengue.
dengue infection should not get Dengvaxia. A month later the To understand why two different dengue infections were
WHO issued fresh guidelines, recommending the vaccine only for needed to make the second one lethal, Halstead infected 118
those with a “documented past dengue infection.” The Philippines monkeys with different combinations of the four dengue virus-
halted the vaccination program that December even as parents es and measured the amount of virus in their blood. In 1973 he
and the press responded with fury, recriminations and further re- published his results: some monkeys, which were infected a
ports of children’s deaths. More than 830,000 schoolchildren had second time and with a different dengue virus, had much high-
been vaccinated. According to the Department of Health (DOH), er viral loads. Four years later he provided a possible explana-
as of September 2018, 154 of the vaccinated children had died of tion, calling it antibody-dependent enhancement.
various illnesses. The vast majority of these fatalities were unrelat- Say your first infection is with the dengue virus called
ed to the vaccine, but clinical observations or blood tests con- DENV-1. Antibodies against that virus can linger in your blood
firmed that 19 of them had been caused by dengue. for decades, even your entire life. When you are infected a sec-
Sanofi Pasteur contends that the deaths in the Philippines ond time with a different dengue virus, say DENV-2, 3 or 4, the
could have arisen from a failure of the vaccine to protect a small antibodies against DENV-1 could paradoxically accelerate the
fraction of those vaccinated. In contrast, some experts argue, as replication of the new virus inside infected cells, precipitating a
Dans and Dans did, that Dengvaxia mimics a prior encounter potentially fatal dengue infection.
with dengue—which can prime a patient’s body to respond in a Since refined by Halstead and other researchers, the ADE
dangerous way to a second dengue infection. mechanism goes as follows: A dengue virus is a string of ribonu-
The controversy has not slowed down the rollout of Dengvax- cleic acid enclosed in a protein capsule, which features an array of
ia, which is currently licensed in more than 20 countries. In Oc- characteristic protuberances on its surface. During a first infec-
tober 2018 the U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced tion with dengue, the immune system’s B cells make an antibody
that it would prioritize review of Sanofi Pasteur’s application to called immunoglobulin G, or IgG, which latches onto one or more
approve Dengvaxia. That means it could be approved in the U.S., of these irregularities. On attachment, the antibodies can deliver
for use in dengue-endemic areas such as Puerto Rico, before the the virus to immune system cells such as macrophages. The word
Philippines completes its investigation into the deaths of vacci- “phage” derives from the Greek word meaning “to eat”: macro-
nated children—and before Sanofi Pasteur publishes its final re- phages are literally “big eaters.” They engulf the virus and digest it
port from the six-year-long clinical trials.   with enzymes. Thus, once it is bound to antibodies, the dengue vi-
rus is normally trapped and destroyed inside macrophages.
A BAFFLING DISEASE When an infection is over, some antibody-making B cells be-
For most viruses, such as measles, the second bout, if it occurs come dormant. In the event of a second infection with a different
at all, is much milder than the first. For dengue, a second bout dengue virus, these cells wake up to churn out the exact same an-
is far more likely to kill. Scientists and doctors have struggled tibodies as before. Halstead postulated that some of these anti-
for years to understand why this is so. In the 1950s and 1960s, bodies can still stick to the surface of the unfamiliar virus but of-
when epidemics of severe dengue began to rise in Asia, they ten fail to block its most lethal protrusions—its guns, so to speak.
wondered if they were dealing with an altogether new infection. The antibodies still deliver the intruder to macrophages but with-
The dengue they were familiar with kept patients bedridden out having disarmed it. That enables the virus to immobilize the
and fatigued, but this new manifestation sent them to the hos- macrophage’s own defense system and take over the cell, whose
pital or the morgue. Had the virus mutated? Or was the im- resources it then uses to churn out more copies of itself. The anti-
mune system to blame? body’s unwitting assistance helps the new dengue variety pro-
A young scientist fresh out of medical school was seeking an duce 1,000 times more copies of itself than if it were acting alone.
answer. Scott B. Halstead began to study mosquito-borne viruses Halstead’s reward for coming up with the ADE hypothesis
in 1957, while working for the U.S. Army in Japan. He confronted was a mix of indifference or disbelief from his peers, he recalls.
his first major dengue outbreak four years later, when stationed Today, at 89 years old, he is an adjunct professor at the Uni-
at a military laboratory next door to the Bangkok Children’s Hos- formed Services University of the Health Sciences in Bethesda,
pital. Doctors thought the youngsters who were carried into the Md., where he continues to argue his case. Many dengue ex-
hospital had been poisoned; almost a quarter of them died. Hal- perts describe him as the Godfather of ADE. “Back then, I was
stead led the team that identified dengue as the cause of the out- thinking I’ve made a discovery that’s very important,” he says.
break. He went on to make a second, more baffling, discovery. “Except nobody wanted to believe ADE was real.”
Children who were infected with dengue for a second time—each More than four decades later Eva Harris, a dengue expert at
time with a different dengue virus—and babies born to mothers the University of California, Berkeley, found strong evidence
who were immune to dengue were most at risk for severe dengue that ADE was not only real but that it contributed to severe den-
and death. No one could explain why. gue disease in children. Harris had not set out to prove or dis-
In 1964 R. A. Hawkes, then a researcher at Australian Na- prove ADE: she was initially skeptical of the phenomenon and
tional University in Canberra, found that cell cultures infected not all that keen on engaging in the decades-long debate. Instead

her team, including statistical mod-
eler Leah Katzelnick, was studying
the ways in which dengue sickens How Safe Is Dengvaxia?
children. That goal then led the re-
Using a newly developed test, Sanofi Pasteur researchers evaluated which of the children
searchers to help establish a lab in
in its clinical trials for Dengvaxia, the first ever licensed vaccine for dengue, had experi
Nicaragua and to begin one of the
enced a dengue infection prior to vaccination. They found that if a child had a previous
more challenging types of scientific
infection (blue lines), the vaccine was very effective in protecting him or her against hospi
projects: a long-term pediatric co-
talization for dengue. If, however, the child had no sign of a previous dengue infection
hort study. Harris and her associ-
(red lines), he or she was far more likely than unvaccinated children of the same age group
ates in Managua, Nicaragua’s capi-
to be hospitalized with serious dengue fever, years after vaccination. The effect was far
tal city, had the not so easy task of
more pronounced in younger children (top graph), who are more likely than older children
following thousands of children.
(bottom graph) to develop severe dengue in the first place.
For more than 15 years the sci-
entists working on the Nicaraguan
Pediatric Dengue Cohort Study
cared for the children if they got Ages 2−8
7
Percent of Study Participants Hospitalized for Dengue
sick and went to their homes to Vaccine, no previous infection
collect data and blood samples.
6
Out of 6,684 subjects, the research- No vaccine, previous infection
ers found 618 who had been sick
5
with dengue and nearly four dozen
who developed severe disease.
Scouring more than 41,000 blood 4
samples, taken over more than a No vaccine, no previous infection
dozen years, they made a striking 3
discovery. Children with a specific Vaccine, previous infection
concentration of antibodies—not 2
low enough to be useless, not high
enough to offer protection, but a
1
concentration of antibodies in a
middling range—were at a nearly
eight times higher risk of acquir- 0
ing dengue hemorrhagic fever and 0 1 2 3 4 5
dengue shock syndrome. Years after First Dose of Dengvaxia
ADE handily explains this find-
ing. If the antibodies are not there
Ages 9−16
to begin with or are present at very 2 Because of safety concerns in
low densities, they cannot enhance younger children, Sanofi Pasteur
a subsequent dengue infection to 1 now recommends Dengvaxia for
children older than nine who are
cause serious disease. If antibodies
documented to have experienced
are present at high densities (as 0 a previous dengue infection.
BY SARANYA SRIDHAR ET AL., IN NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, VOL. 379, NO. 4; JULY 26, 2018
happens shortly after an initial in-
0 1 2 3 4 5
fection), they somehow manage to
SOURCE: “EFFECT OF DENGUE SEROSTATUS ON DENGUE VACCINE SAFETY AND EFFICACY,”

cover any new dengue virus suffi-
ciently to disable it, enabling mac-
rophages to kill it. If, however, the
antibody concentrations are in what Harris describes as a “dan- raged Filipino parents: do not get Dengvaxia if you have not
ger zone”—not low and not high—they may facilitate the virus’s had dengue. A month later the WHO followed suit, stating that
entry into the macrophages without disarming it, thereby accel- only individuals who were proved to already have had dengue
erating virus production. should be given the vaccine.
Harris’s Science paper describing these results was, in the That was exactly what Halstead had been saying since March
words of Jean Lim, a virologist at the Icahn School of Medicine 2016, when he published an analysis in Vaccine arguing that
at Mount Sinai, a “rock star study” that swayed some of the Dengvaxia might cause harm. Perhaps in people who had never
staunchest naysayers of ADE. Her unexpected findings may had dengue, the vaccine was acting like a first dengue infection,
also have hit on the solution to the dengue vaccine mystery. priming the body with just the right quantity of Trojan-horse an-
tibodies to help a real infection turn severe. Young children were
A RED FLAG less likely to have already encountered dengue, and for them, the
Coincidentally, days after H arris’s paper was published in No- vaccine was more likely to act as a first infection. They were also
vember 2017, Sanofi Pasteur made the announcement that en- more likely than adults to develop severe dengue after a second
44 Scientific American, April 2019 Graphic by Amanda Montañez

infection (as Halstead and others observed when a second den- mendations were discussed, and the one published in 2016 was
gue virus invaded Cuba in 1981). The problem was, there was no the consensus position of the advisory committee.”
simple way to tell which children were dengue-negative before
they received Dengvaxia—because Sanofi Pasteur had not collect- O NGOING CONTROVERSY
ed those data for all of them before vaccinating them. In July 2018 S
anofi Pasteur published its reanalysis of clinical
“I hate to say I told you so,” Harris says. “But we saw this trial data using the Pittsburgh test in the New England Journal
coming.” At meetings and over long conference calls, she had of Medicine. T he review confirmed a higher risk of severe dis-
informed Sanofi Pasteur researchers that they were not collect- ease and hospitalization in “seronegative” children (those who
ing the kind of data that could gauge the vaccine’s potential to had no evidence of prior dengue infection in their blood) who
put lives at risk. Instead of testing all children for prior dengue had received the vaccine, compared with those who had not.
infection before they received Dengvaxia, Sanofi Pasteur tested The “vaccine partially mimics primary infection and increases
only 10 to 20 percent of them. The company argues that it was the risk of severe dengue during subsequent infection,” the re-
forging through unchartered territory using the best protocols searchers wrote. Although ADE advocates had predicted this
known to vaccine science. “It’s routine in many vaccine trials to finding, the paper said that the “immunopathogenic mecha-
bleed only 10 to 20 percent of participants,” says Su-Peing Ng, nisms underlying these findings remain unknown.”
global medical head at Sanofi Pasteur. Halstead contends that Sanofi Pasteur researchers are in
After the disturbing hospitalization rate came to light, the re- “denial” about the evidence from their own trials. Ng counters
searchers could not go back and bleed the thousands of children that exactly how ADE boosts infection has yet to be demonstrat-
in the clinical trials to check their dengue status prior to vacci- ed in humans. “ADE is more of a lab observation, an in vitro ob-
nation. It was too late—they had already been vaccinated. Sano- servation. We’ve not seen it clinically proven in humans,” she
fi Pasteur worked with scientists at the
University of Pittsburgh to develop a nov-
el assay that could test the vaccinated
children for evidence of prior dengue in- According to Sanofi Pasteur,
fection. That reassessment was the basis
for the company’s November 2017 warn- the vaccine “partially
ing that only those who had had dengue
before should receive Dengvaxia. mimics primary infection
The earlier recommendations had
been based on the preliminary findings and increases the risk
from the clinical trials, which showed that
Dengvaxia was safer for older children. As of severe dengue during
the new tests revealed, however, age
served in part as a proxy for prior dengue subsequent infection.”
infection. Nine-year-olds are more likely
than toddlers to have already had a den-
gue infection, especially in places where dengue is endemic, so says. “We don’t know if the underlying mechanism is ADE or
giving the vaccine to them should be, on average, safe. But nei- not.” The overall impact of Dengvaxia on public health remains
ther age nor endemicity is a surefire way of knowing whether a beneficial, Ng asserts. In children who are age nine and older
child has had dengue: the only way to know for certain is through and who already had dengue, Dengvaxia reduces the rate of se-
a blood test. “Mixed in with a group of nine-year-olds will always vere disease and hospitalization by around 80 percent, accord-
be some kids who have never had dengue,” Halstead says. ing to Sanofi Pasteur. (For reasons that remain unclear, two
Halstead had very publicly let the WHO know about his con- bouts of dengue appear to confer lifelong immunity to the dis-
cerns. In a December 2016 paper in the J ournal of Infectious Dis- ease. Strictly speaking, the vaccine is useful only for those who
eases, he stated that a claim made by the WHO’s principal adviso- have had one bout but not two.)
ry group on vaccines was wrong. The group had said that the risk Ng is not the only one who disputes that ADE is the main
of hospitalization for kids aged two to five peaks in the third year mechanism behind life-threatening dengue disease. Duane
after vaccination and then “dissipates.” Halstead argued that lon- Gubler, founding chief of the dengue branch at the Centers for
ger-term results from Sanofi Pasteur’s clinical trials refuted this Disease Control and Prevention and an emeritus professor in
assertion. Independently analyzing the clinical trial data, Dans, the Emerging Infectious Diseases Program at Duke-NUS Med-
Dans and others argued in a paper in the J ournal of Clinical Epi- ical School in Singapore, argues that DENV-2 and DENV-3
demiology that there was “no biological basis for a threshold age have historically been associated with outbreaks of severe dis-
of 9 years” beyond which Dengvaxia could be assumed to be safe. ease. As such, the type of virus could be at least as important
The WHO stands by its decision to recommend the vaccine for as ADE in determining the course of an infection. Alan Roth-
older children who live in countries hardest hit by dengue, how- man, a professor of cell and molecular biology at the Universi-
ever. “The review done was extremely thorough, transparent and ty of Rhode Island, says T cells, which recruit and activate
according to our published procedures,” says Joachim Hombach, macrophages and secrete inflammatory chemicals, are more
senior health adviser in the WHO’s department of immunization, directly involved in causing severe dengue than are antibod-
vaccines and biologicals. “Different options of possible recom- ies. Halstead, on the other hand, regards T cells primarily as

saviors. They kill dengue-infested mac- VACCINATED CHILDREN a nd their more optimistic. “There’s a really good
rophages, he says, at which time the vi- parents protest the Philippines’ 2016– vaccine out there,” he says—the nih vac-
ruses may release a protein that damag- 2017 dengue immunization program. cine, which, he wrote in a paper, “has met
es blood vessels. Doctors nonetheless virtually all of the goals needed to demon-
can save a patient by maintaining his or strate preclinical efficacy and safety for
her fluid levels, buying the T cells time to clean out the virus. humans,” even if it has yet to undergo extensive clinical trials.
The fda’s October 2018 announcement that it would expedite
T OWARD A SAFER VACCINE review of Dengvaxia has added fresh urgency to this debate. The
With dengue infecting around a million people every day and burden of dengue disease in the U.S. is in territories such as Guam,
popping up in places it has never been seen before, the need for a the U.S. Virgin Islands, Samoa and Puerto Rico, where Gubler was
safe vaccine is becoming ever more urgent. Armed with the new based as chief of the cdc’s dengue branch. He supports the use of
information from Sanofi Pasteur, novel dengue vaccine makers the vaccine in places such as Puerto Rico, where, he says, the den-
are quick to say they are doing things differently. “We’ve designed gue surveillance system is far more robust than in the Philippines.
our trial in such a way to ask the most important question—how That is, medical practitioners there should be able to keep tabs on
does it perform in dengue naives?” says Rajeev Venkayya, presi- vaccinees and ensure prompt hospitalization if they develop signs
dent of the Global Vaccine Business Unit at Takeda Pharmaceuti- of serious disease. “I’m in favor of using it in highly endemic areas
cal Company. Takeda is currently testing its dengue vaccine in without pretesting because I think with good disease surveillance
children ages four to 16 years in Latin America and Asia. “When and case management, the risk of ADE is minimal,” Gubler says.
we started this trial in 2016, we were well aware of the concern Halstead disagrees: “This is a harmful product unless adminis-
about this issue in naives,” Venkayya says. “So we made sure to tered only to proven seropositive individuals.” But proving previ-
have naives in our trial and collect baseline blood samples from ous dengue infection requires lab testing, which is not always
100 percent of participants.” In January 2019 Takeda announced available in many parts of the world with dengue epidemics. Con-
preliminary results from its clinical trials: the vaccine was effec- troversially, the WHO advised in September 2018 that although
tive. Fully assessing safety will likely take more time, however. prior screening for dengue infection was preferable, when such
At least two other dengue vaccines are being developed, one testing was not feasible, countries could nonetheless consider ad-
by the National Institutes of Health and one by GlaxoSmithKline. ministering Dengvaxia in populations with 80 percent or higher
They are years from being licensed—if they are found to be safe dengue endemicity for those age nine and older. Asked to explain
BULLIT MARQUEZ AP Photo
and effective. Gubler says that any vaccine will likely protect well the ethical rationale for this recommendation, Hombach stated
against a couple of dengue viruses but not so well against the oth- that the WHO had carefully weighed the pros and cons; it had also
ers. “And that being the case, there’s always a risk of ADE,” he noted that such a campaign should be accompanied by “full disclo-
continues. “So do we use those vaccines, or do we shelve them sure of the risks of vaccination of persons with unknown serosta-
and wait another 50 years for a perfect vaccine?” Halstead is far tus.” Effectively explaining such complex issues in ethnically di-

verse countries, where many people may not comprehend the lan- that’s what we were warning DOH about.” Virtually every death
guages that health officials speak or be able to read information in the vaccinated group was being blamed on Dengvaxia, even if
sheets could, however, be a challenge. Sanofi Pasteur takes a more it was clearly unrelated, he adds—and much of this rage and
cautious view. Spokesperson Karen Batoosingh says that “the vac- turmoil could have been avoided by accurate and timely scien-
cine should be available for people with a prior infection to prevent tific advice from trusted authorities. “So that’s the sad thing
against subsequent infections” and that the company is striving to here—that the WHO added to the confusion,” Dans concludes.
develop “a new rapid dengue test to ensure broader access to the Halstead worries that as antibody levels in the vaccinated se-
vaccine for all those who could benefit from its protective value.” ronegative wane with time, to an intermediate level where ADE
becomes more likely, they will become increasingly predisposed
L OSS OF TRUST to developing severe dengue when they do experience an actual
the repercussions from the vaccination program are still rever- infection. Using Sanofi Pasteur’s figures from the clinical trials—
berating across the Philippines. Speaking before a senate inqui- that five out of every 1,000 seronegative vaccinated children were
ry panel, Aquino explained that dengue incidence in the country hospitalized for dengue, of whom two had severe dengue—he cal-
had been increasing at an alarming rate, and he had hoped that culated that more than 4,000 children could be hospitalized for
Dengvaxia could prevent the virus from invading densely popu- vaccine-enhanced dengue disease in the Philippines. “I rub my
lated urban areas. By this past February, however, both the sen- eyes at what’s happening,” he says. “Why isn’t Sanofi spending a
ate and the house of representatives had recommended that lot of time thinking, ‘Okay, now that we’ve sensitized so many
Aquino, Garin and other senior officials be charged under an people [to ADE], how are we going to protect them?’ ” Asked this
antigraft law for irregularities in the procurement and adminis- question, Ng responded that it was unclear whether the cases of
tration of the vaccine. The families of nearly three dozen dead severe dengue in the vaccinated group arose from vaccine failure
children have brought criminal cases against Garin and other or ADE. All patients, regardless of whether they had dengue be-
Filipino officials, accusing them of reckless imprudence amount- fore or had been vaccinated or not, should guard against mosqui-
ing to homicide and torture. (Asked to comment on the circum- to bites, be monitored for early signs of dengue disease, and seek
stances in which the vaccination campaign was rolled out, Un- prompt treatment on indications of more severe disease. Asked
dersecretary of Health Enrique Domingo stated that he had when the final report from the clinical trials would be published,
stepped into the position in December 2017, after the uproar be- Sanofi Pasteur responded that the outcomes had been displayed
gan, and had no personal knowledge of what had taken place.) on a poster at a meeting of the American Society of Tropical Med-
Amid the fear and suspicion, several outbreaks of measles have icine and Hygiene in late 2018.
crept across the Philippines. In February, the country reported Vaccines have saved uncountable lives. Naturally occurring
that more than 8,400 have become sick and more than 130 have smallpox has been wiped off the face of the planet, and polio has
died. Parents were too frightened to vaccinate their kids. Accord- almost been vanquished; tetanus and rabies no longer inspire
ing to a study by the London-based Vaccine Confidence Project, terror. Despite these achievements, public fear of vaccines has
in 2018 fewer than a third of Filipinos strongly agreed that vac- been growing, placing millions of children at risk of avoidable
cines are important, down from 93 percent in 2015. In that study, disease. The increasing skepticism about vaccines is almost en-
published in Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics, Heidi Lar- tirely the result of misinformation. Even so, the twists and turns
son, the project’s director, and her co-authors argued that “biased of the Dengvaxia story complicate the usual narrative of valiant
media hype”—in particular, “false narratives aiming to vilify au- scientists battling public ignorance and prejudice in the quest to
thorities, scientists and regulators” and “senate and congress in- keep everyone safe.
quiries that resembled the inquisition”—had prompted public The dengue saga also raises difficult questions about how
panic and loss of trust in vaccines. Dans, Dans, Halstead and oth- pharmaceutical companies and regulators should proceed in the
ers teamed up to respond that several factors had contributed to context of evolving scientific knowledge and imperfect vaccines.
the decline in public confidence, not least Sanofi’s “exaggerated” Is it ethical to endanger a minority in the interest of protecting a
claims of the safety of Dengvaxia: “The outrage was a result of majority, as the WHO’s September 2018 advisory on Dengvaxia
the loss of trust rather than its cause.” implies? Who should be making these difficult decisions: global
Asked by Scientific American if he was giving ammunition to bodies of experts, national health authorities, fully informed par-
antivaxxers, Halstead responded that he had co-founded the Chil- ents and doctors, or some combination of these? And who should
dren’s Vaccine Initiative in the 1990s, which later morphed into be held accountable when things go wrong?
Gavi, a global public-private partnership that strives to improve
vaccine access for children in poor countries. “I have very strong
MORE TO EXPLORE
bona fides as a supporter of vaccines and vaccination,” he says.
Even as the scientists battle it out, the parents of the vacci- Dengue. Edited by Scott B. Halstead. T ropical Medicine: Science and Practice, V
ol. 5. Imperial
College Press, 2008.
nated children are suffering sleepless nights, according to Anto- Dengue Antibody-Dependent Enhancement: Knowns and Unknowns. S cott B. Halstead
nio Dans. “The mothers are really distressed about, Was my in Microbiology Spectrum, V ol. 2, No. 6, Article No. 0022-2014; December 2014.
child seronegative when he was vaccinated? Why weren’t we Effect of Dengue Serostatus on Dengue Vaccine Safety and Efficacy. S aranya Sridhar
told it could be harmful? They call us and say, My child has a et al. in New England Journal of Medicine, V ol. 379, No. 4, pages 327–340; July 26, 2018.
cough, should we rush him to the hospital? He seems to me FROM OUR ARCHIVES
slightly febrile, should he go to school?” he relates. “And how do Buzz Kill. Dan Strickman; July 2018.
you monitor a cold and a fever in [roughly] a million kids and
find out if it’s dengue or not? That’s a logistical nightmare, and

LEVITATING A PARTICLE o f silica, via laser beam, is a first step toward
experiments to test gravity on minuscule scales. The project is running
at Markus
48 ScientificAspelmeyer’s laboratory
American, April 2019 at the University of Vienna.
PHYSIC S
QUANTUM
GRAVITY IN
THE LAB Physicists attempting
to unify the theories of
gravity and quantum
mechanics have long thought practical experiments
were out of reach, but new proposals offer a chance
to test the quantum nature of gravity on a tabletop
By Tim Folger
IN BRIEF
To unify t he famously uncooperative theories of thought impossible, but several new proposals laboratory—they can detect effects from the inter-
quantum mechanics and general relativity, scien- stand to change that. section of gravity and quantum theory.
tists will likely have to reach down to the unimagin- Physicists are hoping t hat by making extremely The experiments aim t o show whether gravity
ably small realm of the “Planck scale.” Practical precise measurements of gravity in small-scale set- becomes quantized—that is, divisible into discrete
experiments probing this scale have long been ups—experiments that will fit onto a tabletop in a bits—on extremely tiny scales.
Photographs by Mattia Balsamini April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 49

IN
1797 Henry Cavendish, one of Great Britain’s leading
scientists, built a contraption to weigh the world.
At the time, Earth’s mass was unknown, as was its
composition. Was it mostly solid rock? Did it vary with
depth? Astronomer Edmond Halley even suggested that
Earth might be hollow. Isaac Newton had compared
Earth’s mass with that of other bodies in the solar system
and knew, for example, that Earth was more massive
than the moon. He had even suggested a way to deter-
mine Earth’s a bsolute mass: measure the gravitational
attraction between two small spherical masses with great accuracy, then
extrapolate Earth’s own mass from the result. But Newton summarily dis-
missed his own idea—he thought the attraction between the spheres would be
too small to detect, even with impractically large masses. “Nay, whole moun-
tains will not be sufficient to produce any sensible effect,” he wrote in his mas-
terpiece, the P
rincipia, which laid out his laws of motion and gravitation.
On an August day more than a century later Cav- impossible experiment, one that might transform our
endish proved Newton wrong. The device he had built understanding of gravity: he wants to use a small-scale
in a shed on his estate in southwest London consisted setup—literally on a tabletop in his lab—to find evi-
of two 1.6-pound lead balls attached to opposite ends dence that gravity might be a quantum phenomenon.
of a six-foot-long wood rod, which hung from a wire Of the four fundamental forces in the universe,
fastened to an overhead beam. Two much heavier lead gravity is the only one that cannot be described by the
spheres, each weighing nearly 350 pounds, were sus- laws of quantum mechanics, the theory that applies to
pended separately about nine inches away from the all other forces and particles known to physics. Elec-
lighter balls. Cavendish expected that the gravitation- tromagnetism; the “strong” nuclear force that binds
al pull of the heavy spheres on the smaller ones would atomic nuclei; and the “weak” nuclear force that
make the wood rod rotate ever so slightly, and he was causes radioactive decay—they are all quantum to the
right—it moved just over a tenth of an inch. core, leaving gravity as a sole, mysterious outlier.
This allowed him to directly measure the gravita- This exception has vexed physicists since Albert
tional force exerted by each of the larger spheres on Einstein’s heyday. Einstein never managed to unify
the smaller ones. Because he already knew that Earth his own theory of gravity—the general theory of rela-
exerted a gravitational force of 1.6 pounds on each of tivity—with quantum mechanics. Most physicists
the small spheres (in the English system of units, a who now work on the problem believe that the unifi-
pound is by definition a measure of force), Cavendish cation occurs when we zoom in on the cosmos to
could set up a simple ratio: the gravitational force be what is called the Planck scale, after Max Planck, one
tween the small sphere and the large sphere com- of the founders of quantum theory. Distances on the
pared with the gravitational force between the small Planck scale are so tiny—100 trillion trillion times as
sphere and Earth. Because the gravitational force is small as a hydrogen atom—that spacetime itself is
directly proportional to the masses being measured, thought to assume quantum characteristics. A quan-
he could use that ratio to solve for Earth’s unknown tum spacetime would no longer be the smooth con-
mass. Over the course of nine months he repeated the tinuum described by general relativity; it would be
experiment 17 times and found that Earth weighed coarse-grained, like a digital photograph that be
13 million billion billion pounds, a result essentially comes pixelated when magnified. That graininess is
Tim Folger is a freelance
identical to the best modern estimates. a hallmark of quantum theory, which confines the
journalist who writes
for National Geographic, “It’s an incredible story,” says Markus Aspelmeyer, energy, momentum and other properties of particles
Discover and other who has been recounting the Cavendish experiment to discrete bits, or quanta. But what exactly is a
national publications. during a Skype call. “It was the first precision tabletop quantum of spacetime? How could time or distance
He is also the series editor experiment [with gravity].” Cavendish’s 220-year-old be measured if space and time themselves are frac-
for The Best American
tour de force, though not actually conducted on a tured like broken rulers?
Science and Nature Writ-
ing, an annual anthology tabletop, is a source of inspiration for Aspelmeyer, a “All our theories of physics either explicitly or
published by Houghton physicist at the University of Vienna in Austria. Like implicitly require the existence of rods and clocks:
Mifflin Harcourt. Cavendish, he has plans for an ambitious, seemingly something occurred [here] at this time and then did

1 2
this [there] at a later time,” says Miles Blencowe, a the debris. The basic approach is not much different SUPERCONDUCTING
theoretical physicist at Dartmouth College. “Where from blowing up a safe to find out what is inside. The CIRCUITS ( 1) aid the
do you start if you don’t even have a time parameter practitioners of tabletop physics aim to replace brute levitation experiment.
or a distance parameter?” Lajos Diósi, a theoretical force with finesse, like safecrackers listening to the Researchers are also
physicist at the Wigner Research Center for Physics tumblers of a lock clicking into place. “You’re trading trying to measure the
in Budapest, sums up the conundrum this way: “We high energy for high precision is the way I look at it,” gravitational fields of
don’t know what will be there, but we know for sure says Eric Adelberger, a physicist at the University of millimeter-wide gold
that there will be a total scrambling of the spacetime Washington. “There’s the energy frontier, and there’s spheres (2) to observe
continuity if you go down to the Planck scale.” the precision frontier. If you can measure something gravity closer to the
Unfortunately for physicists, there is no way to really, r eally w
ell, you can test physics that’s going on quantum realm.
observe phenomena on the Planck scale and thus no at some really high-energy scale.” Now at least three
way to check the predictions of various theories of groups, including Aspelmeyer’s, are designing exper-
quantum gravity to see which of them might be right. iments to do just that. The scientists are optimistic
“The situation is not that we do not have theories of that these projects will finally reach the levels of pre-
quantum gravity,” says Carlo Rovelli, a theoretical cision needed to probe into the realm where gravity
physicist at Aix-Marseille University in France. “We goes quantum.
do. The problem is that we have more than one.”
In physics, the higher the energy scale of your ex A THOUGHT EXPERIMENT
periment, the smaller the distance you can probe. To understand why precision a llows physicists to
And probing the Planck scale directly would require indirectly access higher energies, and thus smaller
a machine more than 15 orders of magnitude more scales, consider a historical analogue: Brownian
powerful than CERN’s Large Hadron Collider (LHC) motion. In a paper published in 1905, Einstein
near Geneva, the largest particle accelerator ever built, showed that the puzzling random movements of pol-
with a circumference of 27 kilometers. As one physi- len grains in a jar of water could be explained by col-
cist says, such an accelerator would need to be rough- lisions with water molecules, even though the mole-
ly the size of our galaxy. Machines such as the LHC cules themselves were many orders of magnitude
bash particles together at nearly the speed of light, too small to be observed directly. Aspelmeyer and
and physicists hope something new will emerge from other physicists are betting that the unobservably

Quantum Gravity
Experiments Test mass Superposition mass
To understand whether gravity fits into quantum theory, physicists

are designing experiments to measure gravitational fields with
extreme precision to search for signs of quantum behavior. Such
behavior might include “superposition”—the ability of quantum
particles to occupy two places simultaneously—and “entangle Laser < 1 µm
beam
ment”—a kind of connection between quantum objects where their
fates become intertwined. If researchers can find evidence of gravi
tational fields displaying superposition or entanglement, they will
know that gravity has quantum properties.
Both masses in superposition
Gravitational Electromagnet
field
Gold spheres Spring
Cantilever
1 mm
ULTIMATE EXPERIMENT #1
Eventually the team will aim to put one of these spheres into a state
PRELIMINARY EXPERIMENT #1 of superposition. If this ball’s gravitational field goes into superposition,
One experiment, proposed by physicist Markus Aspelmeyer, will ultimately too, and exists in two places, then the other mass should feel the pull
attempt to put a mass into a superposition state of being in two locations of both fields and become entangled, entering superposition as well.
simultaneously and then try to see if the gravitational field of the mass
splits into two as well. A preliminary version of this trial will develop the
technology to detect gravitational fields of smaller objects than ever
before—in this case, two tiny gold spheres. An electromagnet attached
to a spring will cause one ball to vibrate, and the other, at the end of a
cantilever, should oscillate in response to the changing gravitational pull.
small things happening in the Planckian realm though, Aspelmeyer will not be weighing Earth, and
might similarly influence phenomena accessible to his milligram masses are orders of magnitude small-
tabletop experiments. And although particle acceler- er than Cavendish’s lead balls. He wants to test
ators cannot be upgraded by orders of magnitude— whether gravity interacts at all with the quantum
we are unlikely to see accelerators with 1,000-kilo- properties of small masses. Specifically, he intends to
meter circumferences—the precision of tabletop look at what kind of gravitational effects might be
experiments may well improve by a few orders of generated by an object placed in a “Schrödinger’s
magnitude in the decades ahead. cat”-like state of being both here and there at once.
Such gains might allow Aspelmeyer to test a key In the quantum world, particles have the uncanny
assumption shared by all theories of quantum gravity: ability to be in two places simultaneously—a super-
that gravity itself should display some profoundly position, as physicists call it. Scientists have observed
strange quantum properties. “If that is really true, quantum superpositions many times in laboratories,
there should be some consequences for phenomena but they are delicate states. Interactions with any
at an energy scale that is much much smaller [than nearby particles quickly cause objects in superposi-
the high energies that correspond with the Planck tion to “collapse” into a single position. But while the
scale]”—that is, at roughly the scale we inhabit, Aspel- superpositions last, Aspelmeyer wonders what prop-
meyer says. “The question is: Can we come up with erties these particles have. Do they create their own
experiments that possibly test those consequence?” minuscule gravitational fields, for instance? “Imag-
What Aspelmeyer has in mind is an experiment ine you place an object in a superposition,” he says,
that would measure the gravitational attraction “and now you ask a question: How does it gravitate?
between two spherical masses. Unlike Cavendish, That is the question we want to answer.”
52 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Ben Gilliland

sition’s gravitational fields, it would be
strong evidence that the test mass and
the superposition had become “en
tangled”—a telltale feature of quan-
tum mechanics where the properties
Falling diamond spheres in superposition of two separate particles become inex-
tricably linked. Feynman argued that
because only quantum phenomena
can become entangled, the experi-
ment would show that gravity, like all
other known forces in the universe, is
1 µm
fundamentally quantum.
Such an outcome would not in
itself validate any particular theory of
quantum gravity, but it would be indi-
rect evidence that gravity is quantized
on the Planck scale. Even more broad-
Spheres become entangled
ly, the experiment would provide com-
pelling evidence that the laws of quan-
tum mechanics hold at a ll scales, not
just in the realm of photons, atoms
and other fundamental particles.
Some physicists have clung to the idea
that quantum mechanics might break
down when it comes to describing the
macroscopic world. Roger Penrose, for
example, a physicist at the University
EXPERIMENT #2 of Oxford, and Diósi have suggested
A second experimental concept, proposed by two groups (by Sougato
Bose and his colleagues and, independently, by Chiara Marletto and Vlatko
that gravity causes superpositions
Vedral), would drop two diamond spheres side by side for a couple of above a certain size to collapse, effec-
seconds. If the spheres are just 100 microns apart, the proximity of their tively dividing the quantum world
gravitational fields should cause the spheres to become entangled, the from the so-called classical one.
physicists reason. If that happens, the experimenters will detect a “One of the areas where quantum
correlation between the direction of their spins after the drop. If the
theory is supposed to fail is when it
particles do not become entangled—presumably because gravity does not
experience this quantum phenomenon—then the spins should be random. comes to describing gravity,” says Chi-
ara Marletto, a theoretical physicist at
Oxford. “There have been a number of
eminent scientists who maintain that
The experiment Aspelmeyer hopes to carry out was gravity will be exactly the place where quantum theo-
first proposed as a Gedankenexperiment—a thought ry breaks down. So, instead of having a quantized
experiment—by the legendary physicist Richard Feyn [theory of] gravity, we should actually make quantum
man at a conference in 1957. Feynman argued that if theory classical for it to describe gravity.” In this way of
gravity is indeed a quantum phenomenon, a superpo- thinking, quantum theory might need to be modified
sition of a particle in two places at once would create to make it consistent with general relativity, rather
two separate gravitational fields. According to the than trying to fit gravity into quantum theory as it is.
general theory of relativity, gravitational fields are
distortions of space and time. Thus, in the case of a TURNING THOUGHT INTO REALITY
small mass in a quantum superposition, two differ- The technology and expertise n eeded to decide the
ent spacetimes would coexist side by side, almost issue did not exist when Feynman came up with his
like two separate mini universes, a state of affairs idea, and even now the project remains daunting. For
that should not exist in Einstein’s theory. several years now Aspelmeyer’s lab has been pushing
If that spacetime superposition arose, how would to measure the gravitational fields of ever smaller
another object—a test mass—interact with it? Would masses. It is a tricky undertaking: Earth’s enormous
the motion of the test mass indicate that it had felt gravity swamps the fields of even relatively large
the pull of two different gravitational fields? Or objects. The smallest mass for which a gravitational
would the interaction cause the superposition to col- field has been measured so far is a 700-milligram
lapse, as some physicists believe, resulting in normal tungsten sphere. That is about the mass of a paper
gravitational dynamics? If the superposition persist- clip or a raisin—a gargantuan object compared to
ed and if the test mass did interact with the superpo- quantum particles.

To realize Feynman’s thought experi-
ment, Aspelmeyer and his colleagues will
need to work with objects considerably
smaller than paper clips. They are now
developing a prototype experiment to de-
tect the gravitational fields of millimeter-
wide gold spheres (gold was chosen for its
density and purity) weighing just a few
tens of milligrams. “That’s a factor of tens
or hundreds less heavy than anything else
that has been measured so far,” Aspelmey-
er says. In the experiment, the researchers
will place two gold spheres a few millime-
ters apart, with one attached to a small,
spring-mounted magnet and the other
fixed to the end of a micromechanical can-
tilever. When the electromagnet is turned
on, the sphere on the spring will start vi-
brating, creating a changing gravitational 1
field that in turn makes the mass on the
cantilever bounce up and down like a div-
er on a board. The cantilever’s motion—tracked by la- with “optical tweezers”—tightly focused laser beams.
sers—essentially amplifies the gravitational force of “If I can detect the gravitational field of an object
the sphere attached to the spring, making it easier to over which I can obtain quantum control, then I am
detect against the background of Earth’s field. in business,” Aspelmeyer says. “This would be the
After honing their gravitational-measuring skills long-term dream—not tomorrow, not in five years.
with ordinary, nonquantum masses, Aspelmeyer’s Both from the top down and bottom up—from mak-
team would then tackle superpositions. If he could ing [the gravitational] masses smaller and making
put two small spheres into superpositions, Aspel- the [superposition] masses larger—we think we
meyer could test how their gravitational fields inter- know how to get there and bring those two domains
acted. The results could suggest that the particles together. Now we just need to work hard.”
Arndt, Aspelmeyer’s likely collaborator,
A quantum spacetime
says the experiment presents a host of
challenges: the small, spherical masses
would no longer be the

will be difficult to isolate gravitationally
and prone to interacting with any nearby
smooth continuum described

surface. “There are so many effects that
are hard to suppress,” he says. “Still, it has
to be tried, by all means. If we don’t start
by general relativity; it now, it won’t be done in 10 years.” Arndt
compares the effort that will be required
would be coarse-grained. with the search for gravitational waves, a
phenomenon predicted by Einstein’s gen-
eral theory of relativity. More than three
were entangled, supporting Feynman’s intuition years ago the giant Laser Interferometer Gravitation-
about gravity’s quantum nature. al-wave Observatory (LIGO) finally detected the first
What will it take to pull all this off? To have a real- gravitational wave, but the discovery was a long time
istic shot at creating a quantum superposition, Aspel- coming. “It was a 40-year effort to get the gravitation-
meyer will need to shrink his millimeter-size gravi- al-wave detector going,” Arndt says.
tational test masses down to fractions of a micron—
a 1,000-fold reduction. At the same time, he will THE LAST REFUGE OF QUANTUM HOLDOUTS
need superpositions of objects that are massive Aspelmeyer is not the only physicist working on the
enough to have detectable gravitational fields. For problem. In December 2017 two independent groups
that he will likely draw on the talents of a colleague simultaneously published their own very similar
at Vienna, Markus Arndt, who holds the record for takes on Feynman’s thought experiment. Sougato
the largest object ever placed in a superposition: a Bose, a physicist at University College London, and
behemoth of a molecule containing more than 800 his colleagues and Marletto and her Oxford col-
atoms. And instead of being stuck to springs and league Vlatko Vedral described a way to test for the
cantilevers, the masses would be suspended in space gravitational entanglement between superpositions

superposition principle,” Bose says.
The experiment faces many of the same
challenges that Aspelmeyer’s does: the
need for large superpositions that last
for seconds at a time and stay close
enough together so that gravity can
entangle them. “That makes the thing
very difficult,” Bose says. “But I’m sure
I’ll see it in my lifetime.”
Both experiments, if they pan out,
would give physicists their first indi-
rect evidence that gravity—and there-
fore spacetime itself—must be quan-
tized on the Planck scale. And that is
an exciting prospect for Rovelli and
other quantum-gravity theorists, who
have spent years working on theories
without any experimental feedback. “I
think it’s a game changer, this idea, the
attempt to see quantum gravity in the
lab,” Rovelli says. “As far as we know
[gravity’s quantum nature] should def-
initely be real, otherwise we haven’t
learned a thing about the world.”
A century after its birth quantum
mechanics remains the most baffling
of scientific theories. Some physicists,
most famously Einstein, doubted that it
could be the final word on the nature of
reality. Yet countless experiments have
confirmed the theory’s predictions, typ-
ically with multidecimal-point accuracy.
2
In some sense, the question of whether
VACUUM CHAMBERS isolate small masses from the outside gravity is quantum or classical repre-
world to measure their gravitational fields with minute precision. sents a last refuge for those who feel
that there must be something w rong
with quantum mechanics. If these ta-
of microscopic particles without having to measure bletop experiments succeed, that refuge will crumble.
their gravitational fields. “Quantum theory teaches us a completely different
In the proposed experiment, pairs of micron-wide way of describing what we can say about nature,”
diamond spheres would be put into superpositions Aspelmeyer says. “The rule book that we have found
and allowed to fall in a vacuum for a couple of sec- through quantum theory is a fundamental one and
onds in Earth’s gravitational field. If the spheres were has to apply in general to all the theories we have.”
close enough together—about 100 microns apart, ac
cording to Bose’s estimates—their gravitational fields
should cause the particles to become entangled.
MORE TO EXPLORE
When that happens, the properties of the entangled
A Micromechanical Proof-of-Principle Experiment for Measuring the Gravitational Force of Milligram
particles will instantaneously correlate in ways that Masses. J onas Schmöle et al. in C lassical and Quantum Gravity, V ol. 33, No. 12, Article No. 125031;
are not possible in classical physics. One particle’s June 23, 2016. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0264-9381/33/12/125031
spin, for example—whether it points up or down in a Gravitationally Induced Entanglement between Two Massive Particles Is Sufficient Evidence of Quantum
magnetic field—will flip in the opposite direction as Effects in Gravity. C . Marletto and V. Vedral in Physical Review Letters, Vol. 119, No. 24, Article No. 240402;
December 15, 2017. Preprint available at https://arxiv.org/abs/1707.06036
soon as the spin of its entangled partner is measured. Spin Entanglement Witness for Quantum Gravity. Sougato Bose et al. in P hysical Review Letters,
By tracking how often such correlations occur— Vol. 119, No. 24, Article No. 240401; December 15, 2017. Preprint available at h ttps://arxiv.org/
Bose says that 10,000 trials should yield an answer— abs/1707.06050
he, Marletto and Vedral could determine whether the F R O M O U R A R C H I V E S
falling diamonds had indeed become entangled. Once Tangled Up in Spacetime. Clara Moskowitz; January 2017.
again, entanglement would suggest that gravity itself Crossing the Quantum Divide. Tim Folger; July 2018.
must have quantum properties. “Our work will prove
that gravity is quantum in the sense that it obeys the


A Shot
MEDICINE
Re
at
gener
atıon
A once abandoned drug compound shows an ability
to rebuild organs damaged by illness and injury
By Kevin Strange and Viravuth Yin
Illustration by Sam Falconer

B iologist Kevin Strange, CEO of Novo Biosciences,
is a former president of the MDI Biological Laboratory
(MDIBL) in Bar Harbor, Me.
Viravuth Yin is the chief scientific officer at

Novo and an associate professor at MDIBL.
A tale of shark bites at a Scottish pub has led us to some new ideas
about rebuilding broken bodies. In the early 2000s American geneticist
Michael Zasloff of Georgetown University had traveled to the University
of St. Andrews to give a talk about several natural antibiotics found in
animal skin. After the lecture, he and some of the university scientists
went for a drink, and one of them, a marine biologist, began to talk
about how dolphins were frequently savaged by sharks, sustaining some
bite wounds 45 centimeters long and 12 centimeters deep. But remarkably the dolphins healed
up in weeks, with no signs of infection.
Zasloff was struck by this swift recovery from terrible inju-

ries, and he could not get the conversation out of his mind. He
spent the next several years reading reports about bitten dol-
phins and talking to marine biologists who studied these ani-
mals. In 2011 he published a letter to the J ournal of Investiga-
tive Dermatology e ntitled “Observations on the Remarkable
(and Mysterious) Wound-Healing Process of the Bottlenose
and Zasloff ) have shown that a natural antibiotic called MSI-
1436, originally identified by Zasloff in a small shark, dramatical-
ly stimulates several types of damaged organs to regrow in zebra
fish and prompts heart muscle to regenerate in mice. The com-
pound appears to release some molecular “brakes” holding back
a tissue’s natural ability to regenerate after sustaining damage. In
mice that have a condition that mimics muscular dystrophy in
Dolphin.” He noted that the dolphins did not seem like they people, it appears to slow down muscle degeneration. We are still
were simply patching torn flesh with a scar, which produces dif- experimenting in animals and have not shown these effects in
ferent kinds of cells, but instead might be actually regenerating humans, but MSI-1436 has an important advantage over the
the damaged tissue. And soon after that, he called one of us. legion of drug candidates that look good in test tubes but fail in
Strange, at the time president of the MDI Biological Laboratory, people: it has already been shown to be safe.
was pushing the institution to investigate natural and synthetic In 2007 this compound was tested in humans as a potential
compounds that stimulated regeneration, and Zasloff thought treatment for obesity and type 2 diabetes because it improves
some of the antibiotics he had found in animal skin might also cell sensitivity to insulin. The studies, regulated by the U.S. Food
foster this kind of regrowth. Anything that helped the body re and Drug Administration, demonstrated that MSI-1436 was well
place or restore cells destroyed by disease or injury would be a tolerated at high doses and did not harm patients. But because
major medical boon. the drug comes as a liquid that needs to be injected every day, it
Six years after that phone call, the three of us (Yin, Strange was unlikely to be popular with patients who already had alter-
IN BRIEF
Stem cell t reatments grab many headlines A compound called MSI-1436 m ay be more prom- The molecule, o riginally intended as a diabetes and
about healing and regrowing body parts but ising, animal experiments show. It takes the brakes obesity medicine, was successfully tested for safety
have had minimal success. off the body’s natural ability to regenerate cells. in people—a big head start in drug development.

Body Rebuilder Heart cross section
The ability of cells and organs t o regenerate after injury is limited under normal
circumstances. After a heart attack, for instance, molecules called growth factors
and cytokines go to the heart to stimulate new growth, but their signals are blocked by
an enzyme. Dead heart cells are not replaced. In tests on mice with damaged hearts,
however, an injected compound called MSI-1436 inhibits the trouble-making enzyme.
Dead tissue (after heart attack)
The result is new heart muscle, pumping away.
Hindered Healing Healing Unblocked
1 Growth factors and cytokines attach to

proteins called RTKs, which help to send
regrowth signals into a cell.
Growth factors
and cytokines
Cell membrane
Phosphate
MSI-1436
RTK
PTP1B
Nuclear 2 The enzyme PTP1B 2 MSI-1436 interferes Signaling

membrane stops RTKs by cut- with PTP1B, keep- proteins
ting away their ing the enzyme
phosphate groups, from slicing off RTK
components essen- phosphates. So
DNA tial to the signaling regrowth signals
process. So remove successfully
growth signals down a pathway
never reach the of proteins to the
cell’s DNA. cell’s DNA.
DNA
3 The signal interrup- 3 The signals kick-start

tions mean dead cell regeneration.
heart muscle cells New heart muscle
are not replaced by grows to replace the
new, healthy ones. damage and restore
A scar of dead tissue the organ’s blood
remains, weakening pumping ability.
Cell death and scarring the heart. Restored tissue
natives, such as pills, that were easier to take. Pharmaceutical which has a proved safety record, could become valuable regen-
companies did not pursue it. erative medicine for repairing the destruction from heart at-
But for regenerating damaged cells, there are currently not a tacks and potentially from other devastating diseases as well.
lot of medical options. There have been many headlines about
stem cells, unspecialized cells that can, with the right cues, give RESTORATION PROJECT
rise to the myriad highly differentiated cell types that make up Many animalshave startling regenerative capabilities. Sala-
the human body. In theory, they could repair damaged parts. manders regrow entire limbs after amputation. The lamprey,
Unfortunately, despite many years of clinical trials and other an eel-like fish, can repair a severed spinal cord. Zebra fish, a
tests, stem cell transplants remain challenged by a lack of effica- popular aquarium fish species that is also broadly used in bio-
cy and other serious concerns. The only wide use now is in bone medical research, can regenerate damaged hearts, kidneys,
marrow transplants to treat blood cell diseases. But MSI-1436, pancreases and appendages. Pick almost any tissue or organ,
Illustration by Campbell Medical Illustration April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 59

and there is probably an animal that can
readily regenerate it.
Even humans are not out of this regrow-
and-repair game completely. Our capability
appears more limited, but our skin, blood
and gut cells regenerate constantly. Muscle
can add new cells after some small injuries.
And like Prometheus of Greek legend per-
petually regenerating his liver, ours, too,
can regrow after limited injury. So our cells
have these abilities, but they get dialed
down and switched off, especially as we
grow older. Yet because they exist in the
first place, we thought it might be possible
to turn them back on with the proper
molecular signal. But of course, we first
had to find that signal. The fast-healing
animal world was the logical place to look.
Zasloff, in his prospecting for antibiot-
ics in animals, had come across a class of
molecules called aminosterols—MSI-1436
is one of them—that also had the poten-
tial to stimulate regeneration because ZEBRA FISH HEART,damaged and then dosed with the compound MSI-1436,
they could regulate cell activities such as quickly regrew muscle and regained blood-pumping ability.
growth. We decided to test their capaci-
ties using zebra fish. As vertebrates, the
fish have many of the same major organs that people do, and RTKs are embedded in cell membranes and form parts of signal-
about 70 percent of their genes have human counterparts. They ing pathways that start outside the cell and lead inside; the sig-
are transparent as embryos, making it easy to study changes in nals the path carries tell a cell to grow and divide. To become
anatomy. We wanted to see if any of the aminosterols made the active and pass those signals along, RTKs need to be bound to
fish’s ability to regrow tissue happen faster and better. another type of molecule, called a phosphate group. PTP1B gets in
We started with a simple amputation test, cutting off part of the way because it cuts phosphate groups away. No phosphate, no
the tail and adding various aminosterols to the water in the fish RTK signaling and no cell regeneration. But our compound, MSI-
tanks. Nothing happened. That changed, however, when we got 1436, disables PTP1B’s phosphate-cutting ability. And with these
some help from Helen Roberts, a recently graduated high school brakes disabled, RTKs and cell regeneration run happily along.
senior working as an intern in Yin’s laboratory. Roberts developed
methods to inject substances directly into the zebra fish rather HEART DISEASE AND HEART ATTACKS
than adding them to the water. When she did this with MSI-1436, In addition to regrowth o f the zebra fish tail fin, we found that
it stimulated the rate of tail fin regeneration by more than 300 our PTP1B blocker stimulates regeneration of the zebra fish
percent. Instead of taking 10 to 12 days to regenerate, the fin took heart. That is quite important because while humans may not
only three to four days, and there were no signs of abnormal have a tail fin, we do have a heart, and it often needs help. Cardio-
growth. We had Roberts and a lab technician independently re vascular disease is the leading cause of death worldwide, killing
peat the experiments, comparing different compounds, and made about 18 million people every year, and 85 percent of those
sure they did not know which one they were injecting into the fish. deaths are caused by heart attack and stroke. Heart muscle cells
MSI-1436 worked in each situation; other compounds did not. that die in an attack do not regenerate but instead form a scar
This was stunning and prompted some exclamations of ex that increases the chances of another attack. A 45-year search for
CHRISTINA A. DYKEMAN AND YIN LABORATORY MDI Biological Laboratory
citement in Strange’s office that are not appropriate to repeat here. treatments, including stem cell transplants, to help the heart
How did MSI-1436 stimulate regeneration in such a dramatic repair itself has failed.
fashion? Some scientists had studied its effects on cells, and after So when we saw that MSI-1436 helped fish, we moved on to
we did more experiments, the answer seemed pretty clear: MSI- test it in mice, an animal model widely used in heart disease
1436 hobbled an enzyme named protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B research. We induced heart attacks in the rodents and then
(PTP1B), which has several jobs in the body, one of which is to injected them with MSI-1436 every three days over a span of four
regulate the growth of new cells. That is an important occupation weeks. The blood-pumping ability of the organ improved by
because widespread uncontrolled growth can make an organ more than twofold, the amount of scar tissue was reduced by
malfunction or become cancerous. PTP1B is essentially a brake 50 percent, and heart muscle cells at the injury site proliferated
on cell regeneration. Our compound released that brake but only by nearly 600 percent. MSI-1436 is the only small molecule
at injury sites, in a very local, focused and controlled way. known to have this effect.
When PTP1B brakes, it does so by interfering with a crucial Recently we began testing the compound in mice with a
class of cell proteins called receptor tyrosine kinases, or RTKs. completely different kind of disease: a rodent version of Du

chenne muscular dystrophy. This is a slow, degenerative muscle- extensively. They showed no signs of overt tumor growth, which
wasting ailment, quite distinct from the sudden damage of a suggests that even long-term inhibition of PTP1B does not
heart attack. Our preliminary data indicate that MSI-1436 cause cancer. Plus, treatment using MSI-1436 to stimulate tis-
prompts enough cell regeneration to keep skeletal and heart sue regeneration would likely last only a few weeks or months.
muscles ahead of the wasting. It does not stop the disease, but it Finally, our own experiments indicate that MSI-1436 acts only
may mitigate its effects. at an injury site and does not send cells in normal tissue into a
kind of cancerous overdrive. In zebra fish and mice, we did not
ON FROM ANIMALS observe tissue overgrowth or abnormalities in tissue and organ
What bodes well for humans is that the compound stimulates shapes (a sign of growing malignancy) when injured animals
tissue regeneration in both zebra fish and adult mice. These ani- were treated with the compound. We tested this idea in one-cell
mal species are separated by approximately 450 million years of zebra fish embryos, a highly sensitive point in the development of
the fish. Embryos injected with the com-
pound for 14 straight days developed into
Perhaps animals respond well

normal adult animals. Going from a single
cell to a full-blown animal is, obviously, a
to MSI-1436 because it evolved

complex process that requires tremen-
dous cell proliferation and differentiation.
in animals in the first place. It Many drugs and environmental factors

easily send it wildly off-kilter when given
was not identified in a genetically at such an early stage. It is reassuring that

MSI-1436 does not.
engineered lab mouse or from THE NATURAL ADVANTAGE
tens of thousands of synthetic Perhaps animals respond well to the com-
pound because it evolved in animals in the
chemicals at a drug company. first place. It was not identified in a geneti-

cally engineered lab mouse or in cells
grown in a dish at a medical center or from
a screen of tens of thousands of synthetic
evolution. Because MSI-1436 works on such distinct creatures, chemicals at a drug company. Our findings came out of lessons we
the compound most likely targets cellular pathways that have learned from dolphins, sharks and zebra fish. MDIBL, where we
been strongly conserved, or reused, by evolution in organism took advantage of those lessons, was founded to do exactly that.
after organism. It increases the chances that such pathways Our institution began as a marine research station on the coast of
exist in people and can be manipulated in a like fashion. Maine in 1898, when biologists wanted an immediate connection
Testing drug candidates in a diverse population of humans, to the natural world they were trying to understand.
however, is very different from tightly controlled lab animal stud- This link is, unfortunately, something that the larger biomed-
ies. The potential for failure in clinical trials is high. And although ical research enterprise, and the pharmaceutical industry in
there are good reasons to be optimistic about MSI-1436, the real- particular, has drifted away from. There is an important role for
ity is that we will not really know if it is effective in treating heart computer-designed molecules, of course. But regenerative med-
attacks until we try it in human patients. As a first step in that icine biologist Alejandro Sánchez Alvarado of the Stowers Insti-
direction, we have begun National Institutes of Health–funded tute for Medical Research, who is not involved in our research,
tests of this drug candidate in a pig heart attack model. The pig has told us that MSI-1436 is “a great case study of what happens
heart is remarkably similar to the human heart, and the size of when scientists choose to walk away from the familiar and
the animal allows us to mimic a human heart attack and its search nature for answers to vexing biomedical problems.”
early-stage treatment much better than we can in mice. If the pig
trial results are positive, we will be well positioned to seek per-
mission from the fda to conduct clinical trials. MORE TO EXPLORE
In our studies, we are also going to be watching out for signs Observations on the Remarkable (and Mysterious) Wound-Healing Process of
of cancer. A concern in regenerative medicine is that treat- the Bottlenose Dolphin. M ichael Zasloff in Journal of Investigative Dermatology,
ments to stimulate tissue growth and repair may trigger uncon- Vol. 131, No. 12, pages 2503–2505; December 2011.
trolled cell proliferation, which is the biological hallmark of a Rethinking Differentiation: Stem Cells, Regeneration, and Plasticity. A lejandro
Sánchez Alvarado and Shinya Yamanaka in Cell, V ol. 157, No. 1, pages 110–119;
cancerous cell. We believe that this concern is lower with MSI- March 27, 2014.
1436. The extensive toxicity testing already done on the com- The Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase 1B Inhibitor MSI-1436 Stimulates Regeneration
pound during its earlier incarnation as a diabetes and obesity of Heart and Multiple Other Tissues. A shley M. Smith et al. in n pj Regenerative
drug was designed to identify problems such as cancer. None Medicine, V ol. 2, Article No. 4; March 3, 2017.
were found, and the fda deemed MSI-1436 safe to use in studies FROM OUR ARCHIVES
of human patients. Limiting the presence of PTP1B also seems A Change of Heart. Ferris Jabr; April 2013.
reasonably safe. The gene responsible for making it was first
knocked out in mice in 1999. These mice have been studied

ANIMAL PHYSIOLOGY
Investigations into how the electric eel uses

electricity have revealed astonishing insights
into the creature’s physiology and behavior
By Kenneth C. Catania
ELECTRIC EEL w ields its superpower

to great effect during both hunting
and self-defense.
62 Scientific American, April 2019 Photograph by David Liittschwager

SHOCK
&
AWE

I
Kenneth C. Catania is a professor of biological
sciences at Vanderbilt University. He studies
comparative neurobiology, with an emphasis
on animal sensory systems. This is his fourth article
for Scientific American.
t’s no secret that electric eels stun their prey—accounts of such occurrences date
back centuries. But unless you work security on the starship Enterprise, “stun” is a
vague term. What really happens when these creatures attack? Until recently, biolo-
gists knew surprisingly little about the electric eel’s superpower. I was not planning to
study this phenomenon, and I certainly never imagined I would offer an eel my arm in
the name of science, as I eventually did. But as a professor of biological sciences at
Vanderbilt University, I teach about electric fish, and when I brought some eels to my
laboratory so I could obtain new photographs and slow-motion movies to liven up my lecture,
I saw something so strange that I had to drop everything else to investigate.
When an eel attacked a prey fish with high voltage, all the S HOCK VALUE
nearby fish in the tank became completely immobile in only You might be surprised t o learn the electric eel is not a true eel
three milliseconds. It was as if they had been turned into little but rather belongs to a family of fish known as the Gymnotidae
statues; they just floated stock-still in the water. At first, I won- that live in South America. The other members of this group
dered if they had simply been killed. But if the eel missed its tar- give off very weak electric discharges that they use to sense their
get and turned off the high voltage, the fish “unfroze” and took surroundings and to communicate. The electric eel has amped
off at full speed. The eel’s effect was temporary. I was hooked; I up its power over the course of evolution. It can generate a
had to know how the eel’s electric attack worked. charge of up to 600 volts, thanks to the electric organ that spans
The most obvious analogy that came to mind was a law-en- nearly the length of their body (the animals can reach eight feet
forcement Taser, which causes neuromuscular incapacitation by in length and weigh more than 40 pounds). The organ is com-
interfering with the nervous system’s ability to control muscles. posed of thousands of special disk-shaped cells called electro-
Tasers deliver electricity along wires in short, high-voltage puls- cytes that work like batteries to discharge electricity.
es at a rate of 19 pulses a second. Electric eels do not need wires, To investigate the possibility that the electric eel operates like
because the water allows current to flow, as happens when a a Taser to incapacitate its prey, I needed to observe the animal in
hair dryer falls into a bathtub. But otherwise, the eel’s output is hunting mode. So I devised an experiment that took advantage
reminiscent of a Taser’s: it comes in brief pulses, each lasting of the eel’s insatiable appetite for earthworms. First, I placed a
only about two milliseconds. Eels can give off more than 400 dead fish that still had working nerves and muscles in the water
pulses per second during an attack volley, however—a much with the eel (but separated by an electrically permeable barrier)
higher rate than the law-enforcement devices. Could electric and attached it with a string to a device for measuring muscle
eels be souped-up, swimming Tasers? contractions. Then I fed the eel earthworms, which it happily
With this question in mind, I set out on what would become shocked and ate. This setup allowed me to conduct a series of
a three-year mission to unravel the mechanism of the eel’s attack tests on the fish muscle responses to the high-voltage pulses em-
and the effects of its shocks on both prey and would-be preda- anating from the hunting eel.
tors. I was surprised at every turn by the eel’s sophisticated use The volleys of high-voltage pulses from the eel caused mas-
of electricity and reminded that humankind’s inventions don’t sive muscle contractions in the fish that started three millisec-
hold a candle to nature’s. onds after the electric attack began—exactly the same amount of
IN BRIEF
The electric eel h as long been known to stun its A series of laboratory experiments has revealed The eel also uses its electrical powers when threat-
prey. But the mechanism of the eel’s attack and how how the creature uses electric fields to detect, track ened, leaping from the water to intensify the cur-
the shocks affect prey were a mystery. and immobilize prey. rent it delivers to potential predators.

Conductive
carbon
insert
Plastic
insert
TRACKING SYSTEM: T he eel can track prey and other conductors using high-voltage electroreception. In experiments with a spinning disk
bearing one conductive insert and multiple nonconductive inserts, the eel singled out the conductive insert with remarkable accuracy.
time that passed before the fish were seen to stop moving in the A little research into muscle physiology revealed that dou-
slow-motion movies. Apparently eels invented the Taser long be- blets—which can also be described as pairs of action poten-
fore humans. But the experiments showed much more. Eels do tials—sent from motor neurons to muscles are the best way to
not activate fish muscles directly. Instead their zaps activate the generate maximal muscle tension. Accordingly, my experiments
nerves that lead to the fish muscles. Each high-voltage pulse showed that eel doublets cause a brief, massive, whole-body
from an eel generates an action potential, or nerve impulse, in twitch in nearby prey, in contrast to the volleys, which cause
the fish’s motor nerves. sustained paralysis. The twitch, in turn, produces a strong wa-
This finding is remarkable when you consider that the eel’s ter displacement—essentially an underwater sound. Given the
electric organ is a modified muscle activated by the animal’s eel’s exquisite sensitivity to the slightest water movement, an
own motor nerves. The motor nerves are, in turn, activated by interesting possibility comes to mind. Could doublets be the
neurons in its brain. For each high-voltage pulse, the flow of eel’s way of asking, “Are you alive?” After all, wild eels hunt at
command signals starts in the eel’s brain and travels to its motor night in the Amazon, surrounded by a vast diversity of hidden
neurons, which then activate the electric organ. From there the prey—things that are far harder to find than worms and gold-
signal passes through the water to trigger the motor neurons, fish dropped into a tank.
and then muscles, in nearby fish. In other words, the eel immo- Supporting this idea: when eels in my lab hunted novel prey,
bilizes its prey using a form of high-fidelity remote control. such as crayfish, or prey hidden among plants in the tank, they
Intriguingly, this insight suggests the eel’s electric output may often gave off doublets while searching and attacked after the
have been shaped in part by what happens to the muscles of its prey twitched, as if the prey’s movement had tipped them off.
prey. With this finding in mind, I began considering the eel’s high- These were telling observations, but to provide more direct evi-
voltage volley with a new perspective. I was especially intrigued dence, I attached the dead fish to an electric stimulator that
by reports from a previous investigator, Richard Bauer, who in could be triggered by either me or the eel’s doublets. I then
KENNETH C. CATANIA
1979 showed that hunting electric eels often pause to give off pairs placed the wired fish in a ziplock bag so the eel’s own doublets
of high-voltage pulses, each separated by two milliseconds. These would have no effect on it. This setup allowed me to control
paired pulses are called doublets, and all the eels in my lab exhib- when the fish’s muscles twitched. Sure enough, the eels never
ited the same behavior. What, I wondered, are doublets for? followed a doublet with an attack unless the fish twitched. The

Attack Mode
Like a Taser, a
n electric eel on the hunt emits pulses of electricity to in located, preventing escape. The eel can also use its electricity to
capacitate prey. The eel’s zaps activate the motor neurons that control track moving prey. And it has evolved an ingenious solution to
the prey’s muscles. In this way, the eel can be said to have remote control a fundamental challenge of operating in the aquatic realm,
over prey. It uses this remote control in two ways: to reveal hidden prey where much of the electricity in its stunning strikes
by making them twitch and then to freeze the prey once they have been would typically be lost to the surrounding water.
Eel’s Voltage Output 1 2 3 4
1 Low-voltage 2 High-voltage 3 Involuntary

electroreception doublet prey movement
Focused Intensity
Eel’s electric field is what physicists term
a dipole: lines representing forces on a positive
charge originate from the positive head of the
eel and end on the negative tail. The density
of lines indicates the strength of the electric
field at any given point. Bringing the positive
pole closer to the negative pole increases the
field strength between them. The eel does
this by curling its tail around the prey
gripped in its mouth before zapping it.
+
The closer the positive
and the negative, the
stronger the field
SOURCES: “ELECTRIC EELS CONCENTRATE

THEIR ELECTRIC FIELD TO INDUCE INVOLUNTARY
FATIGUE IN STRUGGLING PREY,” BY KENNETH C. CATANIA,
–
IN C URRENT BIOLOGY, VOL. 25, NO. 22; NOVEMBER 16, 2015, AND
“THE SHOCKING PREDATORY STRIKE OF THE ELECTRIC EEL,”
BY KENNETH CATANIA, IN S CIENCE, VOL. 346; DECEMBER 5, 2014
66 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustrations by Matthew Twombly

work showed that the eels were, in fact, attacking in response to
doublet-generated fish movements.
Thus, the electric eel has two modes of remote control, which to-
Stages of a Kill
gether make for one of the most insidious hunting tactics in the an-
Eel uses both low- and high-voltage electric output to sense its
●
surroundings 1 . While searching for prey hidden among plants, imal kingdom: it can unmask hidden prey by making them move,
the eel gives off pairs of high-voltage pulses called doublets that and it can freeze moving prey once they have been discovered.
●
cause a powerful twitch in nearby prey 2 . The twitch displaces the
●
surrounding water, revealing the prey to the eel 3 . On finding a target, D OUBLING DOWN
the eel launches a high-voltage attack volley that paralyzes the prey,
Remotely controlling another animal is pretty cool, but it is not
●
which the eel then strikes at with a suction-feeding bite 4 .
the eel’s only trick. The creature also has an ingenious solution to
500
a fundamental problem with its electric output. Unlike superhe-
volts roes or wizards who can aim lightning bolts, every time the eel
gives off a high-voltage pulse, the electricity is distributed
4 High-voltage throughout the surrounding water. As a result, only a tiny fraction
attack volley of the eel’s prodigious power is transmitted to prey. English phys-
icist and chemist Michael Faraday, who coincidently worked with
electric eels in 1838, gave us a convenient way to visualize the
problem: The eel’s electric field is a so-called dipole, with lines
representing forces on a positive charge emanating from the pos-
itive head of the eel and ending on the negative tail. The density of
lines reflects the strength of the electric field at any given point; it
is strongest at the poles and falls off in strength rapidly with dis-
tance. In introductory physics, you learn that bringing a negative
pole close to the positive pole greatly increases the field strength
in between. Eels have apparently taken physics because they use
this move on difficult, struggling prey. The eel holds the victim
firmly in its jaws and curls its tail (the negative pole) around the
animal before delivering a series of high-voltage volleys.
To measure the effect of the eel’s maneuver, I designed an eel
“chew toy”—a pair of recording electrodes on a plastic holder in-
side a dead fish. The eels grabbed the apparatus, and I shook the
+ attaching wires to simulate struggling. The eels obliged, curling
around and shocking the electrodes. As expected, the field
strength more than doubled. It is a great strategy, allowing the
eel to concentrate its otherwise fixed power output on a target,
like focusing the fixed power of a flashlight to a single bright spot.
What happened to prey was predictable yet awe-inspiring.
Subsequent experiments showed that the eel’s amped-up attack
- causes muscle contractions at abnormally high rates, totally and
utterly exhausting prey in just a few seconds. It is the electric an-
alogue of a neurotoxin, allowing the eel to capture and subdue
otherwise dangerous animals, such as large, clawed crayfish.
M ORE THAN A WEAPON

During my studies o f the eel’s hunting behavior, I noticed some-
thing that made me wonder whether the shocks might function
as more than just a weapon. Typically three things happen when
electric eels go in for the kill. First, they give off a full volley of
high-voltage pulses, then they rapidly strike at the prey and suck
it into their mouth. But in my experiments, when the dead fish
was made to twitch in the insulated plastic bag, the eel’s attack
was always cut short. The eel gave off the high-voltage volley and
struck toward the fish but missed and aborted the attack with-
out the final suction-feeding bite. Why?
I had assumed the eels’ strike was ballistic—a preplanned
Voltage
experienced event that takes place without sensory feedback. But now it oc-
by prey curred to me that the animals might use high-voltage pulses as
a tracking system. This would explain why they overlooked prey
insulated in plastic. Electric eels evolved from weakly electric

fish that use electricity to probe their surroundings, and they
have retained the weak, low-voltage electric output used for
sensing. Why not use the high voltage for sensing as well? I de- The Best Defense
cided to put this possibility to a test.
Eels will jump f rom the water to electrify a perceived threat.
I took advantage of the conductive properties of prey and the
To measure the current through a human during the eel’s
eel’s aggressive hunting behavior. Submerged animals tend to be
leaping attack, the author designed an experiment that
more conductive than water, so an electric eel is especially inter-
ested in conductors because they have the “signature” of living ●
involved offering his own arm to a juvenile eel 1 . As the
eel rises, the usual current path from the eel’s head to its
things. Keep in mind, though, that the eel can and does detect con-
tail is replaced by a path via the target, and the current
ductors with its low-voltage system, which is always active until
the predator switches to high voltage during an attack. To specif- ●
intensifies 2 . At the highest point of the animal’s leap,
the current it delivered to the subject was about 43 milli
ically test for high-voltage electroreception, I needed to examine
amperes—a strongly aversive jolt that prompted the author
the eel’s behavior in slow motion during the strikes, when the low-
voltage system was off and only the high-voltage one was active. ●
to reflexively withdraw his arm 3 . A large eel would be
expected to deliver substantially more power to its target.
The first simple experiment was to add a rod made of carbon,
an inert conductor, to the aquarium near the twitching fish in the
ziplock bag. Once again, the eel attacked when it detected the wa-
ter movement from the twitch and struck toward the bag with the
insulated fish. But this time, the eel changed course midway and
tried to eat the carbon rod with a full-on suction-feeding strike.
The eel seemed to interpret the carbon rod as the fish—as one
would expect if it was using the high-voltage pulses to track prey.
It was a great start, but I needed more evidence. I developed
additional tests with carbon rods and multiple plastic rods to net with a metal rim and handle. In an instant, the eel turned and
control for vision. Each time, the eels attacked the carbon con- leaped from the water with its lower jaw pressed against the met-
ductor while giving off high-voltage volleys. The ultimate test al handle while it gave off a long volley of high-voltage pulses (for-
was to present the eels with a rapidly spinning disk that had a tunately, I was wearing a protective rubber glove). It is a daunting
single small conductor embedded in its surface, along with a se- defensive behavior exhibited by all the eels I have tested.
ries of identical-looking nonconductive control objects. The eels’ As I investigated the electric consequences of the eel’s leap
performance was incredible: they could track and attack the and accounts of Humboldt’s adventures, many pieces of the bio-
conductor during the high-voltage volley with a speed and accu- logical and historical puzzle fell into place. If eels interpret small
racy unheard of for animals that employ active electroreception. conductors as edible prey, it follows that an approaching, partly
There was no doubt—they use high voltage simultaneously as a submerged large conductor would be interpreted as a large
weapon and as part of a sensory system to track prey. My respect threatening animal—perhaps a predatory cat or crocodilian.
for electric eels was growing daily, which was fortunate because Why not swim away? During the dry season in the Amazon, elec-
their next trick was directed at me. tric eels are often trapped in small pools, where they are at risk
of predation—exactly the situation reported for Humboldt’s eels.
A STUNNING DEFENSE Add to this scenario the fact that eels cannot “aim” their electric-
In March 1800 Prussian naturalist Alexander von Humboldt hired ity when submerged, and you have the recipe for evolving an as-
villagers in the Amazon to collect some electric eels for experi- tonishing defense strategy.
ments. The result became an epic tale. They decided to fish for So is Humboldt’s dramatic story true? Although he does not
the eels using horses. They rounded up 30 wild horses and mules provide much detail in his famous account, I was able to find a
and forced them into a shallow pool full of eels, which emerged little-known illustration of the event, which appeared decades
from the mud to attack the horses, shocking them repeatedly. later in a book authored by Robert Schomburgk, a British ex-
The villagers yelled and waved branches to corral the terrified plorer and acquaintance of Humboldt’s. The central figure is a
horses in the pool until the eels were spent and could be collect- horse being shocked by an eel that has jumped out of the water
ed safely. Two horses died in the mayhem; others stumbled from to press its lower jaw against the horse’s chest. It is the spitting
the pool and collapsed on the bank. Humboldt published an ac- image of the leaping eels from my lab. As far as I am concerned,
count of the spectacle in 1807, and the story helped to propel him if Humboldt reported discovering dinosaurs in the Amazon, I
to fame. But some later scholars were skeptical about Humboldt’s would want to check it out.
claims. Why would eels go on the offensive against large animals
that they could not eat, risking injury in the process? No further B UILDING BUZZ
instances of such behavior were reported for more than 200 Some things are hard to explain to the university’s purchasing
years, until I chose the wrong net to catch a large eel in my lab. department, and severed zombie arms fall squarely in this cate-
As a rule, electric eels do not leap out of their aquarium. But gory. So I thought it best to use my own money when I needed
there is an exception: if you approach a cornered eel with a large fake arms for another set of experiments with the eels aimed at
conductor that is sticking out of the water, it will often respond further elucidating their leaping behavior. After scrubbing the
with an explosive attack. I discovered this literally shocking behav- fake blood off the arms, I filled them with light-emitting diodes
ior when I tried to transfer a large eel to a new aquarium using a strategically placed to mimic nerve tracts and presented them to

Current meter
3
Insulated wire 2
+
+
1
+
Plastic
– container –
–
Handle Conductive aluminum tape
Current Measured 2 3 50 milliamps

1
the eels. Bringing an arm close to an eel resulted in a compelling between the eel’s jaw, a living target and the surrounding water.
demonstration of the leaping defense. The lights flashed bright- It was hard to stop working on the circuit without the final
er as the eel rose farther out of the water while shocking the arm. answers. In addition, just as my first paper documenting the
But exactly how and why did this happen? eel’s leaping attack was published in 2016, a video was posted to
Getting the answers to these questions required working out the Internet showing a very large eel leaping onto a surprised
the so-called equivalent circuit and then determining the volt- fisherman in South America (he was temporarily immobilized
age, or electromotive force, of the eel’s electric organ. I would and then recovered, similar to the aftermath of being Tased).
also need to calculate how much the materials in the circuit re- Suddenly the circuit I had been studying out of curiosity had
duce the flow of electric current through it—a property known real-world consequences.
as resistance. So I designed experiments to measure each vari- There was nothing for it but to use my own arm to determine
able in succession, starting with the eel’s electric organ. At the last variable and test the predictions from all the previous
slightly more than three feet long, the largest eel in my lab had measurements. I used a very small eel with an electromotive
an electric potential of 382 volts and an internal resistance of force of 198 volts and an internal resistance of 960 ohms. I built
only 450 ohms, allowing for currents of nearly one ampere if a device that measured the current through my arm during the
there were no other resistances. That is quite an electric punch— eel’s attack, allowing me to finally solve the circuit. I can also re-
far greater than a Taser’s. port with conviction that eels are very efficient at turning up the
When an eel emerges from the water, pressing its lower jaw volume of their attack.
against a target, the usual current path for electricity from the I may have started this project thinking I would teach about
eel’s head to its tail is progressively shut down—because air is a electric eels, but in the end, it was the eels that taught me. It is
poor conductor—and is replaced by a path through the target. the same lesson I relearn every time I investigate a new species:
Remarkably it is similar to a volume-control knob—the eel pro- the animals are always far more interesting than I could possi-
SOURCE: “POWER TRANSFER TO A HUMAN DURING AN ELECTRIC EEL’S SHOCKING LEAP,”
BY KENNETH C. CATANIA, IN C URRENT BIOLOGY, VOL. 27, NO. 18; SEPTEMBER 25, 2017
gressively turns up the volume in the target as it rises from the bly imagine, in ways I could never have predicted at the outset.
water. This observation explains how the behavior could have It keeps me up at night—in a good way—to contemplate all we
gradually evolved because each increment in height provides an have yet to discover.
advantage. But how efficient is the eel at turning up the volume?
When working out the details, I ran into the most basic of
circuit problems: calculating the electric current in a circuit M O R E T O E X P L O R E
containing two resistors arranged side by side. It is a favorite The Shocking Predatory Strike of the Electric Eel. K enneth Catania in Science, Vol. 346,
pages 1231–1234; December 5, 2014.
challenge in circuit puzzles (that is, physics exams) because you Electric Eels Use High-Voltage to Track Fast-Moving Prey. K enneth C. Catania in Nature
cannot calculate the electric current in the circuit without Communications, V ol. 6, Article No. 8638; October 20, 2015.
knowing the value of both resistors. I was able to solve for one Power Transfer to a Human during an Electric Eel’s Shocking Leap. K enneth C. Catania
resistance—the path from the eel’s head to the water—by taking in Current Biology, V
ol. 27, No. 18, pages 2887–2891; September 25, 2017.
measurements from eels attacking metal plates connected to a F R O M O U R A R C H I V E S
voltmeter. The other resistance was the arm—the eel’s target. Natural-Born Killer. K enneth C. Catania; April 2011.
After collecting data for all the other variables, I could only
guess at this last value: the complex resistance that developed

How calculus helped to drive the fight against HIV
By Steven Strogatz
M AT H E M AT I C S
OUTSMARTING A
VIRUS WITH MATH
W
orking behind the scenes, calculus is an unsung hero of modern life.
By harnessing the forecasting powers of differential equations—the sooth
sayers of calculus—humans have used an arcane branch of mathematics
to change the world. Consider, for instance, the supporting role that calculus
played in the fight against HIV, the human immunodeficiency virus.
In the 1980s a mysterious disease began killing tens of thousands of people a year in the U.S. and hundreds of thousands world
wide. No one knew what it was, where it came from or what was causing it, but its effects were clear—it weakened patients’ immune
systems so severely that they became vulnerable to rare kinds of cancer, pneumonia and opportunistic infections. Death from the
disease was slow, painful and disfiguring. Doctors named it acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). No cure was in sight.
Basic research demonstrated that a retrovirus was the culprit. Its mechanism was insidious: The virus attacked and infected
white blood cells called helper T cells, a key component of the immune system. Once inside, the virus hijacked the cell’s genetic
machinery and co-opted it into making more viruses. Those new virus particles then escaped from the cell, hitched a ride in the
bloodstream and other bodily fluids, and looked for more T cells to infect. The body’s immune system responded to this invasion
by trying to flush out the virus particles from the blood and kill as many infected T cells as it could find. In so doing, the immune
system was killing an important part of itself.
The first antiretroviral drug approved to treat HIV appeared in 1987. It slowed the virus down by interfering with the hijacking
process, but it was not as effective as hoped, and HIV often became resistant to it. A different class of drugs called protease inhibi
tors appeared in 1994. They thwarted HIV by interfering with the newly produced virus particles,
keeping them from maturing and rendering them noninfectious. Though also not a cure, prote
Excerpted from I nfinite Powers: ase inhibitors were a godsend.
How Calculus Reveals the Secrets Soon after protease inhibitors became available, a team of researchers led by David Ho (a for
of the Universe, by Steven Strogatz, mer physics major at the California Institute of Technology and so, presumably, someone comfort
to be published by Houghton Mifflin able with calculus) and a mathematical immunologist named Alan Perelson collaborated on a
Harcourt on April 2, 2019. Copyright study that changed how doctors thought about HIV and revolutionized how they treated it. Before
© 2019 by Steven Strogatz. Used the work of Ho and Perelson, it was known that untreated HIV infection typically progressed
by permission. All rights reserved. through three stages: an acute primary stage of a few weeks, a chronic and paradoxically asymp

Illustration by Amy Martin April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 71

tomatic stage of up to 10 years, and a terminal stage of AIDS.
In the first stage, soon after a person becomes infected with Steven Strogatz is a professor of mathematics
HIV, he or she displays flulike symptoms of fever, rash and head at Cornell University. He has blogged about
aches, and the number of helper T cells (also known as CD4 cells) math for the New York Times and is a frequent
in the bloodstream plummets. A normal T cell count is about guest on Radiolab and Science Friday.
1,000 cells per cubic millimeter of blood; after a primary HIV in
fection, the T cell count drops to the low hundreds. Because
T cells help the body fight infections, their depletion severely
weakens the immune system. Meanwhile the number of virus
particles in the blood, known as the viral load, spikes and then
drops as the immune system begins to combat the HIV infection.
The flulike symptoms disappear, and the patient feels better.
At the end of this first stage, the viral load stabilizes at a lev The equation above is an example of a differential equation. It
el that can, puzzlingly, last for many years. Doctors refer to this relates the infinitesimal change of V (which is called the differen
level as the set point. A patient who is untreated may survive for tial of V and denoted dV) to V itself and to the differential dt of
a decade with no HIV-related symptoms and no lab findings oth the elapsed time. By applying the techniques of calculus to this
er than a persistent viral load and a low and slowly declining equation, Perelson and Ho solved for V (t ) and found it satisfied:
T cell count. Eventually, however, the asymptomatic stage ends
ln [V( t ) /V0 ] = −ct
and AIDS sets in, marked by a further decrease in the T cell
count and a sharp rise in the viral load. Once an untreated pa ere V0 is the initial viral load, and ln denotes a function called
H
tient has full-blown AIDS, opportunistic infections, cancers and the natural logarithm. Inverting this function then implied:
other complications usually cause the patient’s death within two
V( t ) = V0e −
ct
to three years.
The key to the mystery was in the decade-long asymptomatic I n this equation, e is the base of the natural logarithm, thus con
stage. What was going on then? Was HIV lying dormant in the firming that the viral load did indeed decay exponentially fast in
body? Other viruses were known to hibernate like that. The geni the model. Finally, by fitting an exponential decay curve to their
tal herpesvirus, for example, hunkers down in nerve ganglia to experimental data, Ho and Perelson estimated the previously un
evade the immune system. The chicken pox virus also does this, known value of c.
hiding out in nerve cells for years and sometimes awakening to For those who prefer derivatives (rates of change) to differ
cause shingles. For HIV, the reason for the latency was unknown. entials (infinitesimal increments of change), the model equation
In a 1995 study, Ho and Perelson gave patients a protease in can be rewritten as follows:
hibitor, not as a treatment but as a probe. Doing so nudged a pa
t= −cV
dV/d
tient’s body off its set point and allowed the researchers—for the
first time ever—to track the dynamics of the immune system as ere dV/d
H t i s the derivative of V w ith respect to t. T his derivative
it battled HIV. They found that after each patient took the pro measures how fast the virus concentration grows or declines. Pos
tease inhibitor, the number of virus particles in the bloodstream itive values signify growth; negative values indicate decline. Be
dropped exponentially fast. The rate of decay was incredible: cause the concentration V i s positive, then −cV m ust be negative.
half of all the virus particles in the bloodstream were cleared by Thus, the derivative must also be negative, which means the virus
the immune system every t wo days. concentration has to decline, as we know it does in the experiment.
Furthermore, the proportionality between d V/d
t a nd V means that
FINDING THE CLEARANCE RATE the closer V g ets to zero, the more slowly it declines.
Calculus enabled Perelson and Ho to model this exponential de This slowing decline of V i s similar to what happens if you fill
cay and extract its surprising implications. First, they represent a sink with water and then allow it to drain. The less water in the
ed the changing concentration of virus in the blood as an un sink, the more slowly it flows out because less water pressure is
known function, V(t), where t denotes the elapsed time since the pushing it down. In this analogy, the volume of water in the sink
protease inhibitor was administered. Then they hypothesized is akin to the amount of virus in the body; the drainage rate is like
how much the concentration of virus would change, d V, i n an in the outflow of the virus as it is cleared by the immune system.
finitesimally short time interval, d t. Their data indicated that a Having modeled the effect of the protease inhibitor, Perelson
constant fraction of the virus in the blood was cleared each day, and Ho modified their equation to describe the conditions b efore
so perhaps the same constancy would hold when extrapolated the drug was given. They assumed the equation would become:
ecause dV/V r epresented the fractional change in
down to dt. B
the virus concentration, their model could be translated into
t= P −
dV/d cV
symbols as the following equation: I n this equation, P refers to the uninhibited rate of production
of new virus particles, another crucial unknown in the early
dV/V = −c dt
1990s. Perelson and Ho imagined that before administration of
ere the constant of proportionality, c, is the clearance rate, a mea
H the protease inhibitor, infected cells were releasing new infec
sure of how fast the body flushes out the virus. tious virus particles at every moment, which then infected oth

er cells, and so on. This potential for a raging fire is what makes no hibernation. HIV and the body were locked in a pitched strug
HIV so devastating. gle every second of every day, and the immune system needed all
In the asymptomatic phase, however, there is evidently a bal the help it could get and as soon as possible after the critical ear
ance between the production of the virus and its clearance by ly period of infection. And now it was obvious why no single
the immune system. At this set point, the virus is produced as medication worked for very long. The virus replicated so rapidly
fast as it is cleared. That gave new insight into why the viral load and mutated so quickly, it could find a way to escape almost any
could stay the same for years. In the water-in-the-sink analogy, therapeutic drug.
it is like what happens if you turn on the faucet and open the Perelson’s mathematics gave a quantitative estimate of how
drain at the same time. The water will reach a steady-state level many drugs had to be used in combination to beat HIV down and
at which outflow equals inflow. keep it down. By taking into account the measured mutation rate
At the set point, the concentration of virus does not change, of HIV, the size of its genome and the newly estimated number
so its derivative has to be zero: d t=
V/d 0. Hence, the steady-state of virus particles that were produced daily, he demonstrated
viral load V 0 satisfies: mathematically that HIV was generating every possible muta
tion at every base in its genome many times a day. Because even
P = cV0
a single mutation could confer drug resistance, there was little
erelson and Ho used this simple equation to estimate a vitally im
P hope of success with single-drug therapy. Two drugs given at the
portant number that no one had found a way to measure before: same time would stand a better chance of working, but Perel
the number of virus particles being cleared each day by the im son’s calculations showed that a sizable fraction of all possible
mune system. It turned out to be a b illion virus particles a day. double mutations also occurred each day. Three drugs in combi
That number was unexpected and truly stunning. It indicated nation, however, would be hard for the HIV virus to overcome.
that a titanic struggle was taking place during the seemingly calm The math suggested that the odds were something like 10 million
10 years of the asymptomatic phase in a patient’s body. The im to one against HIV being able to undergo the necessary three si
mune system cleared a billion virus particles daily, and the infected multaneous mutations to escape triple-combination therapy.
cells released a billion new ones. The immune system was in a fu When Ho and his colleagues tested a three-drug cocktail on
rious, all-out war with the virus and fighting it to a near standstill. HIV-infected patients in clinical studies in 1996, the results were
remarkable. The level of virus in the blood dropped about 100-
TURNING HIBERNATION ON ITS HEAD fold in two weeks. Over the next month it became undetectable.
the following yearHo, Perelson and their colleagues conduct This is not to say that HIV was eradicated. Studies soon after
ed a follow-up study to get a better handle on something they ward showed the virus can rebound aggressively if patients take
could not resolve in 1995. This time they collected viral load a break from therapy. The problem is that HIV can hide out. It
data at shorter time intervals after the protease inhibitor was can lie low in sanctuary sites in the body that the drugs cannot
administered because they wanted to obtain more information readily penetrate or lurk in latently infected cells and rest with
about an initial lag they had observed in the medicine’s absorp out replicating, a sneaky way of evading treatment. At any time,
tion, distribution and penetration into the target cells. After the these dormant cells can wake up and start making new viruses,
drug was given, the team measured the patients’ viral load every which is why it is so important for HIV-positive people to keep
two hours until the sixth hour, then every six hours until day two taking their meds, even when their viral loads are undetectable.
and then once a day thereafter until day seven. On the mathe In 1996 Ho was named T ime magazine’s Man of the Year. In
matical side, Perelson refined the differential equation model to 2017 Perelson received a major prize for his “profound contribu
account for the lag and to track the dynamics of another impor tions to theoretical immunology.” Both are still saving lives by ap
tant variable, the changing number of infected T cells. plying calculus to medicine: Ho is analyzing viral dynamics, and
When the researchers reran the experiment, fit the data to the some of Perelson’s latest work helped to create treatments for
model’s predictions and estimated its parameters again, they ob hepatitis C that cure the infection in nearly every patient.
tained results even more staggering than before: 10 billion v irus The calculus that led to triple-combination therapy did not
particles were being produced and then cleared from the blood cure HIV. But it changed a deadly virus into a chronic condition
stream each day. Moreover, they found that infected T cells lived that could be managed—at least for those with access to treat
only about two days. The surprisingly short life span added an ment. It gave hope where almost none had existed before.
other piece to the puzzle, given that T cell depletion is the hall
mark of HIV infection and AIDS.
The discovery that HIV replication was so astonishingly rap MORE TO EXPLORE
id changed the way that doctors treated their HIV-positive pa
Rapid Turnover of Plasma Virions and CD4 Lymphocytes in HIV-1 Infection.
tients. Previously physicians waited until HIV emerged from its David D. Ho et al. in N
ature, V
ol. 373, pages 123–126; January 12, 1995.
supposed hibernation before they prescribed antiviral drugs. Modelling Viral and Immune System Dynamics. Alan S. Perelson in Nature Reviews
The idea was to conserve forces until the patient’s immune sys Immunology, V ol. 2, pages 28–36; January 2002.
tem really needed help because the virus would often become re FROM OUR ARCHIVES
sistant to the drugs. So it was generally thought wiser to wait un The Secret Spiritual History of Calculus. Amir Alexander; April 2014.
til patients were far along in their illness.
Ho and Perelson turned this picture upside down. There was

RECOMMENDED
By Andrea Gawrylewski
Our Planet
by Alastair Fothergill
and Keith Scholey,
with Fred Pearce.
Ten Speed Press,
2019 ($35)
This month t he new nature documentary series Our Planet w ill be released on Netflix, from the same team that created P lanet Earth a nd The Blue Planet.
T he companion book by co-producers Fothergill and Scholey can certainly stand on its own, with many images leaving the viewer wondering, “How’d
they get that shot?”: A lone polar bear treks along the ridge of a jagged, blue and glistening ice cap in the Russian High Arctic (above). An iridescent
turquoise European kingfisher seems frozen in time as it dives for minnows off its mossy perch. A brown bear peeks around the tree in a Slovenian forest—
its expression so humanlike, you could dare call it shy. This collection goes beyond photography, though, with a thorough discussion of the conservation
challenges facing many ecosystems on Earth. It’s not enough to merely look at the planet around us—we must understand how humans impact it.
Eating the Sun: Small Musings Einstein’s Unfinished Revolution: Frankie: H

ow One Woman
REPRINTED WITH PERMISSION FROM O UR PLANET, B Y ALASTAIR FOTHERGILL AND KEITH SCHOLEY. COPYRIGHT © 2019.
on a Vast Universe T he Search for What Lies Prevented a Pharmaceutical Disaster
PUBLISHED BY TEN SPEED PRESS, A DIVISION OF PENGUIN RANDOM HOUSE, LLC. IMAGE CREDIT: SERGEY GORSHKOV
by Ella Frances Sanders. Penguin Books, 2019 ($17) beyond the Quantum by James Essinger and Sandra Koutzenko.
by Lee Smolin. Penguin Press, 2019 ($28) Wellspring, 2019 ($24.95)
From the atoms t hat make up
our bodies to the galactic super Quantum mechanics—the On March 8, 1962, p harma
cluster that houses the Milky basis for our understanding cologist Frances (“Frankie”) O.
Way, writer and illustrator of particles and forces—is argu Kelsey, a medical reviewer at
Sanders elucidates many of the ably the most successful theory the FDA , received a most un
wonders of our world through drawings and con in all of science. But its success expected letter. The drug firm
versational explanations. While describing lunar the has come at a price: unresolved mysteries at the that had pressured her to approve the distribution
ory, for example, she compares the moon and Earth’s theory’s heart, such as the paradoxical wave-par of a sleeping pill was withdrawing its request. For
locked synchronous rotation to the movement ticle duality of quantum objects, can make modern nearly two years she had refused to accede—there
of dance partners: “How glad we can be, that we physics seem decidedly metaphysical. Simply put, was not enough evidence to prove the medication
have someone to figure out this universe business if mainstream interpretations of quantum mechan was safe. As it turned out, the drug, thalidomide,
alongside, to dance with, to gradually lengthen our ics are true, then the central, most cherished tenet which was also used to treat morning sickness in
days and keep us slow.” A star’s death, trees helping of physics—that an objective reality exists indepen pregnancy, had been linked to birth defects in
one another survive and the ways our brain rewrites dently of our mind but is still comprehensible—must Europe and elsewhere. In the end, it never pervad
memories are also among the concepts Sanders be false. Smolin, a member of the Perimeter Institute ed the U.S. market. Writers Essinger and Koutzenko
demystifies. Each inspiring snapshot feeds the cu for Theoretical Physics in Ontario, argues against unearth the story of Kelsey, who helped prevent a
riosity of anyone interested in exploring the universe this vexing status quo: “It is possible to be a realist public health tragedy by standing her ground in the
that we exist in and that exists in us. —S unya Bhutta while living in the quantum universe.” —L ee Billings name of scientific proof. —Emiliano Rodríguez Mega

Zeynep Tufekci is an associate professor at the University THE INTERSECTION
of North Carolina School of Information and Library Science W H E R E S C IE N C E A N D S O C IE T Y M E E T
and a regular contributor to the New York Times. Her book,
Twitter and Tear Gas: The Power and Fragility of Networked Protest,
was published by Yale University Press in 2017.
YouTube Has which owns YouTube, highlights videos in its search results.
“How do I” assemble that table, improve my stroke, decide if I’m
a Video for That

a feminist, choose vaccinations, highlight my cheeks, tie my shoe-
laces, research whether climate change is real...? Someone on You-
Tube has an answer. But the site has also been targeted by extrem-
But the site’s recommendation ists, conspiracy theorists and reactionaries who understand its role
as a gateway to information, especially for younger generations.
algorithms have a dark side And therein lies the dark side: YouTube makes money by
By Zeynep Tufekci keeping users on the site and showing them targeted ads. To keep
them watching, it utilizes a recommendation system powered by
It was 3 a.m., a nd the smoke alarm wouldn’t stop beeping. There top-of-the-line artificial intelligence (it’s Google, after all). Indeed,
was no fire, so I didn’t need to panic. I just had to figure out a way after Google Brain, the company’s AI division, took over You-
to quiet the darn thing and tamp down my ire. I had taken out the Tube’s recommendations in 2015, there were laudatory articles on
battery and pushed and twisted all the buttons to no avail. how it had significantly increased “engagement”: Silicon Valley–
Luckily for me, the possible solutions were all laid out in the speak for enticing you to stay on the site longer.
YouTube tutorial I found. The video helpfully walked me through These “recommended” videos play one after the other. Maybe
my options, demonstrating each step. And the fact that it had hun- you finished a tutorial on how to sharpen knives, but the next one
dreds of thousands of views reassured me that this might work. may well be about why feminists are ruining manhood, how vac-
YouTube has become the place to learn how to do anything, cinations are poisonous or why climate change is a hoax—or a
from assembling an Ikea cabinet to making a Bluetooth connec- nifty explainer “proving” the T itanic n
ever hit an iceberg.
tion with your earbuds. It is a font of tutorials, some very good, YouTube’s algorithms will push whatever they deem engaging,
some meandering, some made by individuals who have become and it appears they have figured out that wild claims, as well as
professionals at it and rake in serious sums through advertising. hate speech and outrage peddling, can be particularly so.
But many are uploaded by people who have solved something that Receiving recommendations for noxious material has become
frustrated them and want to share the answer with the world. such a common experience that there has been some loud push-
The native language of the digital world is probably video, not back. Google did ban a few of the indefensibly offensive high-pro-
text—a trend missed by the literate classes that dominated the file “creators” (though not before helping them expose their views
public dialogue in the predigital era. I’ve noticed that many young to millions of people), and recently the company announced an
people s tart their Web searches on YouTube. Besides, Google, initiative to reduce recommending “borderline content and con-
tent that could misinform users in harmful ways.” According to
Google, this content might be things like “a phony miracle cure for
a serious illness” or claims that “the earth is flat.” The change, they
say, will affect fewer than 1 percent of all videos.
While it’s good to see some response from Google, the problem
is deep and structural. The business model incentivizes whatev-
er gets watched most. YouTube’s reach is vast. Google’s cheap and
nifty Chromebooks make up more than half the computers in
the K–12 market in the U.S., and they usually come preloaded
with YouTube. Many parents and educators probably don’t real-
ize how much their children and students use it.
We can’t scream at kids to get off our lawn or ignore the fact
that children use YouTube for a r eason: t here’s stuff there they
want to watch, just like I really needed to figure out how to un
plug that beeping catastrophe at 3 a.m. We need to adjust to this
reality with regulation, self-regulation and education. People
can’t see how recommendations work—or how they’re designed
to keep eyes hooked to the screen. We could ask for no YouTube
or “no recommendations” for Chromebooks in schools.
This is just tip of the iceberg of the dangerous nexus of profit,
global scale and AI. It’s a new era, with challenges as real as that
iceberg the T itanic did h
it—no matter what the video claims.
J O I N T H E C O N V E R S AT I O N O N L I N E
Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
Illustration by Thomas Pitilli April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 77

ANTI GRAVITY
T H E O N G O IN G S E A R C H F O R Steve Mirsky h as been writing the Anti Gravity column since
FU N DA M E N TA L FA R C E S a typical tectonic plate was about 36 inches from its current location.
He also hosts the S cientific American podcast Science Talk.
we in the Deep South—by which I mean

Chicago or New York compared with
the Arctic—freeze our butts off. But less
than a week after this most recent vor
tex disruption, thanks to some warm
air coming up from the r eal S outh, I
was walking outside without a coat. On
a date when the average high tempera
ture is about 40.
Like so much else we are currently
living through, this kind of thermome
ter ride is not normal. Or it didn’t used
to be, anyway.
Of course, scientists have been
waming—sorry, warning—that warm
ing can have these very effects. Climate
change deniers may sneer, “So when
it’s warmer than usual, that’s because
of global warming. And when it’s cold
er, that’s also because of global warm
ing?” Well, yes. And anybody who just
can’t accept these kinds of seemingly
paradoxical situations needs to reflect
on the expression “freezer burn.”
Cold Comfort In the midst of this wacky weather

came Groundhog Day. And I happened on a 2010 interview with
noted climatologist Katharine Hayhoe of Texas Tech University,
A look back at winter’s wacky weather in which she pointed out: “It’s been mathematically proven that
By Steve Mirsky it’s impossible to predict the evolution of a chaotic system like
weather for more than two weeks. As everyone knows, though,
By the time you read these words, winter’s grip should have the laws of physics don’t apply to groundhogs.” She also re
mostly loosened in the Northern Hemisphere. But at its worst, marked that for groundhog weather forecasting to be truly sci
this winter was brutally cold. Here in New York City on January entific, its “findings would need to be published in scientific
31, the low temperature snuck down to two degrees Fahrenheit. journals such as the J ournal of Groundhog Predictions w here
In Chicago, it was also two degrees—but that was the high. The they would be reviewed for accuracy by other groundhogs.” How
low plummeted to –20. Which was two degrees warmer than the Hayhoe could be understood with her tongue so securely embed
low the day before. And the wind chill in the Windy City was –51 ded in her cheek is a scientific mystery.
or –52, depending on which weather station was crying out in In a completely unrelated development, alligators eat stones.
agony. As comedian Lewis Black once said of Minnesota (which As writer Jake Buehler explains in the journal Science, it’s long
was similarly afflicted in January), “That is not weather. That’s been known that the beasties dine on the rocks. Favored explana
an emergency condition.” tions have included the incidental swallowing of mineral while eat
When the forecast warned us a couple of days earlier that Arc ing animal or vegetable and the ingestion of stones to help mash
tic air was looming, the president issued a sincere and helpful up the meat in their digestive tracts—akin to what many birds do.
tweet, which ended with: “What the hell is going on with Global But a new explanation for this gastrolith activity has ap
Waming [sic]? Please come back fast, we need you!” And being peared. Tests with seven captive American alligators found that
the most powerful man on Earth, he was successful in his polite when they had taken in a bunch of rocks, they were able to hide
imploration. On February 4 the Chicago temperature reached underwater 88 percent longer. The weight appears to work
51 degrees. And the next day the Big Apple basked in a sunny 65. against the tendency to float back to the surface when the lungs
The Arctic is warming at twice the rate as the global average. are filled with air. Because if you’re going to successfully cope
This heat can help disrupt the polar vortex, a steady wind pattern with the laws of physics, it’s far better to have stones in your
that usually stays focused on circling the North Pole. A wobbly jet stomach than rocks in your head.
stream then runs into a brick wall of that Arctic air, which is still
pretty frosty by human standards, and both wind up hundreds of Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter
miles farther south than they usually belong. And for a few days or send a letter to the editor: [email protected]
78 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Matt Collins

S cienti f ic A m erican O N L I N E
FIND ORIGINAL ARTICLES AND IMAGES IN
50, 100 & 150 YEARS AGO
THE Scientific American ARCHIVES AT IN N OVATI O N A N D D I S C OV E RY A S C H R O NI C L E D IN S c ientific A meric an
scientificamerican.com/magazine/sa Compiled by Daniel C. Schlenoff
APRIL
1969 Trans
uranium
Elements
“Up to 1963 the rate of discovery
knapper can turn out 500 pounds
of blades a day from locally quar
ried nodules of flint.”
the dirigible [see illustration]
is destined to be the carrier of
passengers and goods over long
of transuranium elements had New agricultural machinery made routes, in competition with the
been high. Each step forward has this craft obsolete in the 1980s. intercontinental steamers.”
required more and more complex
apparatus and methods to increase
the number of protons in the nucle
us, while at the same time the sta
1919 Airships
for Travel
“The substitution of helium for
1969
1869 Meat on Ice “A new invention,
in the shape of machinery for
bility of the nuclei produced has hydrogen, which is one of Ameri making ice and performing the
decreased, making them difficult ca’s contributions to military avia refrigerating process, was tested
to observe and identify. Nonethe tion, removes one of the greatest on board the ship W illiam Taber,
less, heavy synthetic elements are prejudices against the lighter- lying at the foot of Nineteenth
a subject of livelier interest than than-air craft. For now that heli Street, East River, New York City,
ever because of advances in the um gas, which is non-inflammable, in the presence of a number of sci
theory of nuclear stability, which is used in place of explosive hydro entific and mechanical gentlemen,
have given rise to the possibility gen, there is no further need to 1919 to whom invitations had been
of synthetic elements beyond the think of conflagration during extended. The ship has been thor
dreams of early workers in the flight or on the ground. Engines oughly fitted with this new appa
field. Concurrently great progress can be placed anywhere, and so ratus for the preservation, during
has been made in manufacturing can the galley and stoves and transportation, of fresh beef and
in quantity the unstable elements heating plant, since the dirigible other perishable food for a long
through element 98, in enlarging is no longer a huge explosive period, and she will sail for Texas
knowledge of their properties and charge held in a silk bag, ready to some day next week. The two
in finding worthwhile applications burst into flames at the slightest great principles in the mechanism
for them.—Glenn T. Seaborg and spark. Frankly, the airplane as a 1869 of the affair seem to be, first, the
Justin L. Bloom” commercial proposition is today application of pumps to the lique
Seaborg shared the 1951 Nobel Prize but a poor second to the dirigible. faction of carbonic acid [carbon
in Chemistry for his work in this field. The airplane is to be the competi dioxide] gas; and second, the
tor of the fast railroad train, while remaking of it into gas over and
Knappers at Work over again ad infinitum.”
“The only living men who make The ship failed to make its delivery.
tools by flaking flint are usually The date of the first successful refriger-
believed to be a few primitive ated ship voyage is usually given as 1877.
tribesmen who still follow the
customs of their forebears and High Fashion in Toys
a handful of specialized craftsmen “Not the least interesting of the
who fashion the flints needed for English reports on the French
surviving flintlock firearms. Dur Exhibition is on toys. The chief
ing recent archaeological work French toy is a doll, not a repre
in Turkey, Jacques Bordaz of the sentation of an infant for a child
University of Montreal found this to fondle, but a model of a lady
belief to be in error: flint-knap attired in the height of fashion,
pers in the Turkish village of a leading manufacturer changing
Çakmak produce 500 tons of flint the costume every month to en
blades every year, enough to pro sure accuracy. As an excuse for
SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN,VOL. CXX, NO. 16; APRIL 19, 1919
vide fresh cutting edges for all the this apparently early inoculation
threshing sledges in rural Turkey. of childhood with a love for finery,
Turkish wheat-growers like to sep it is explained that these dolls
arate the grain from the stalk by serve as models to colonial and
dragging a sledge over sheaves other extra-Parisian milliners
spread on a threshing floor. Each before they are handed over to
sledge has 600 to 800 blades of 1919: Elegant dirigibles are the hope for air travel to come. their children. French dolls, un
flint, a little less than two inches Passengers relax in the stern observation salon of an airship like our wax-faced natives, have
long, set on edge in a slot. Each crossing the Atlantic Ocean. china heads.”

William Shakespeare playwright
GRAPHIC SCIENCE Walter Scott novelist
Text by Mark Fischetti | Graphic by Valentina D’Efilippo Geoffrey Chaucer poet
John Trevisa translator
First Words Today

2000 Francis Bacon
philosopher
S cientific American has brought 1800
more than 1,000 new terms to light 1600 Robert

Mannyng
historian
Words originate everywhere. A nd S
cientific American is the 1400
place to find the earliest evidence of a surprising number of
them. The venerable O xford English Dictionary investigates 1200
where each of its multitudinous terms first appears. S cientific
Year
American h as popped up as one of the dictionary’s most quot 1000 P
ed sources for new words, new meanings of existing words and
EO
PLE
exemplary uses of novel words (large graphic). Since the maga Word
zine debuted in 1845, it has provided the first record of 1,056 Source
PUB
terms (smaller graphic). We tip our hat to T he Times (Lon IC
ATI
L
ONS
don) and William Shakespeare as the top sources.
Certainly the advancement of science and tech
Jo u
nology, as reported in our pages, spawns

rn a
s e
nc
l
original language. So does sharing Ma e re s

gaz Ref work George Eliot
ines
emerging ideas. Our next new N e w s pa p ers novelist (only
word? Stay tuned. female in top
100 sources)
*
Science Encyclopædia
Nature Britannica
Top 100 Cursor Mundi
Sources of Words historical poem
Key Philosophical
*Some publications include Wycliffe Bible
Transactions
Number of Times Cited for New Words, earlier incarnations (early version) group
of the Royal Blackwood’s
New Meanings and Exemplary with different names. of bible translations
Society
Uses of Novel Words Life Span of Source Harper’s Daily Telegraph Acts of Parliament, Britain
3,000 Year born or founded
8,000 Listener New York Times
18,000
30,000 Year died or ended New Yorker The Times (London)
43,000 Pharm
Cumulative New Words, Meanings and Uses

Today Most frequently quoted
Log-on
source: 42,840 citations
First record of a new word Scientific American 5,000
First record of a new meaning The magazine is the earliest record for 208 words (red),
from “carburetor” in 1862 to “pharm” in 1994: a place
6,200 3,100 1,000 20 that raises genetically modified plants or animals to pro Fractal 4,000
duce pharmaceuticals. Even more prevalent are 848 new
SOURCE: OED ONLINE, OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, JANUARY 2019 w ww.oed.com
meanings for existing words (gold); in 1973 we used “crash”
to describe a computer that suddenly quits. Clone (animals)
3,000
Carburetor Homogenized Digital cash (money transfer)

2,000
1,000
Crash (computer)
Space tourist (pay to go to space)
1860 1880 1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000

Chassis (motor cars) A Closer Look at
Key
Number of first records of new words
5
3 Cumulative times cited for
1
Pie crimper (baking) new words, new meanings
1 and exemplary word use
3
5 Number of first records
80 Scientific American, April 2019 of new meanings

Scientific American - April 2019

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Scientific American - April 2019

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Scientific American - April 2019

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

ORGAN REPAIRS DENGUE DEBACLE HOW EELS GET ELECTRIC

Photograph by Mattia Balsamini April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 1

© 2019 Scientific American

A New Era of Human Spaceflight

2 Scientific American, April 2019

© 2019 Scientific American

The Joy of Science

Illustration by Nick Higgins April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 3

© 2019 Scientific American

“All technologies your electron to be “up” to send a “yes” re-

4 Scientific American, April 2019

© 2019 Scientific American

EDITOR IN CHIEF AND SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT

asserting, “We cannot solve our problems NEWS

fore, to apply methods and measures D I G I TA L

CLIENT MARKETING SOLUTIONS

eral variations. In the future, we will not CONSUMER MARKETING

they can be fully substantiated. ANCILL ARY PRODUC TS

“A Meditation on Keyboard Shortcuts,” by C O R P O R AT E

April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 5

© 2019 Scientific American

The WHO Takes

6 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Christina Ung

© 2019 Scientific American

A Low-Tech of standing forests in the fight against climate change. Protecting

Illustration by Nicole Xu April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 7

© 2019 Scientific American

An implant that could restore

8 Scientific American, April 2019

© 2019 Scientific American

• Coral reefs may migrate to escape

When Scott Moorehead t ells people he

at the Virginia Commonwealth University

J O I N T H E C O N V E R S AT I O N O N L I N E Visit Scientific American on Facebook and Twitter

© 2019 Scientific American

10 Scientific American, April 2019

© 2019 Scientific American

8-Day Tour $1495 +tax, fees

April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 11

Biases Aren’t that represented two categories of people,

Forever were asked to flag these using the same

Implicit Bias Explicit Bias

12 Scientific American, April 2019 Graphic by Amanda Montañez

© 2019 Scientific American

A carnivore left the smallest

April 2019, ScientificAmerican.com 13

© 2019 Scientific American

Cervical spots that might signal abnormal cells.

Cancer App ers routinely photographed the cervixes

STEVE GSCHMEISSNER Science Source

Catching etchings. This technique, she adds,

14 Scientific American, April 2019 Illustration by Thomas Fuchs

© 2019 Scientific American

COGNITIVE SCIENCE ance—even if the latter were

Failing closer to being done. Know-

ROB KIM Getty Images

16 Scientific American, April 2019

© 2019 Scientific American

Volcanoes canic gas to measure because it is relatively

Monitoring these events, which often spew of sulfur dioxide.

(EPIC) to observe 16 eruptions. They col- behind real time.” — Katherine Kornei