2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines: Section I
2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines: Section I
2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines: Section I
Section I
Question Answer
1 C
2 A
3 A
4 D
5 D
6 B
7 A
8 C
9 A
10 D
11 D
12 C
13 B
14 C
15 B
16 D
17 B
18 B
19 C
20 C
Page 1 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Section II
Question 21 (a)
Criteria Marks
• Sketches in general terms why wage growth has recently been low in
2
Australia
• Correctly identifies ONE reason for low wage growth 1
Sample answer:
After the GFC there were increased levels of cyclical unemployment in Australia. Increased
competition amongst job seekers reduces wage growth.
Question 21 (b)
Criteria Marks
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of how a low unemployment rate can
4
co-exist with a high level of underemployment
• Defines the unemployment rate AND underemployment 3
• Defines unemployment OR underemployment 2
• Makes a relevant statement about unemployment OR underemployment 1
Sample answer:
The unemployment rate measures those who are out of work and actively seeking work
whereas the underemployed are employed but would like to work more hours. So an
underemployed worker is not counted as unemployed.
Page 2 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 21 (c)
Criteria Marks
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of the effects of low wage growth on
4
the Australian economy
• Demonstrates an understanding of the effects of low wage growth on the
3
Australian economy
• Sketches in general terms the effects of low wage growth on the
Australian economy
OR 2
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of an effect of low wage growth on
the Australian economy
• Makes a relevant statement about low wage growth in the Australian
1
economy
Sample answer:
Low wage growth will reduce real household income which is likely to lead to lower
consumption by households. This will reduce aggregate demand. Reduced household
spending may also discourage production and investment by firms. This will reduce
aggregate demand even further.
Question 22 (a)
Criteria Marks
• Correctly defines efficiency 1
Sample answer:
Efficiency is producing more output with a given level of inputs.
Page 3 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 22 (b)
Criteria Marks
• Sketches in general terms why reform of a single factor market is likely to
have a larger impact on the economy than reform of a single product 2
market
• Makes a relevant statement about factor and/or product markets 1
Sample answer:
Reforms that improve efficiency in a single factor market should also improve efficiency in all
product markets that use that factor of production. On the other hand, reforms in a single
product market should typically only affect that market.
Question 22 (c)
Criteria Marks
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of why it might be difficult to
3
implement microeconomic reform during a period of low economic growth
• Sketches in general terms why it might be difficult to implement
2
microeconomic reform during a period of low economic growth
• Makes a relevant statement about microeconomic reform OR low
1
economic growth
Sample answer:
Microeconomic reform typically involves long-term benefits and short run costs (higher
structural unemployment). During periods of low economic growth the newly unemployed will
find it harder to find jobs. Governments may therefore be reluctant to undertake such
reforms.
Page 4 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 22 (d)
Criteria Marks
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of how labour market reforms can
help government achieve the objectives of full employment AND price 4
stability in the long term
• Demonstrates an understanding of how labour market reforms can help
government achieve the objectives of full employment AND price stability
in the long term
OR 3
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of how labour market reforms can
help government achieve the objective of full employment OR price
stability in the long term AND sketches in general terms the other
• Sketches in general terms how labour market reforms can help
government achieve the objectives of full employment AND price stability
in the long term
OR 2
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of how labour market reforms can
help government achieve the objective of full employment OR price
stability
• Makes a relevant statement about labour market reform AND/OR full
1
employment and/or price stability
Sample answer:
Reforms such as deregulation of the labour market should help achieve full employment by
making workers more affordable to firms and more mobile, ensuring that they can easily be
re-allocated from declining to growing industries. Deregulation of the labour market can also
help price stability by reducing the bargaining power of workers in negotiating wages and
conditions. This reduces the pressure on firms to raise product prices.
Page 5 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 23 (a)
Criteria Marks
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of a cost AND a benefit of
4
globalisation
• Demonstrates an understanding of a cost OR a benefit of globalisation
3
AND sketches in general terms the other
• Demonstrates an understanding of a cost OR a benefit of globalisation
OR 2
• Sketches in general terms a cost AND a benefit of globalisation
• Makes a relevant statement about globalisation 1
Sample answer:
One potential cost of globalisation is the increased exposure of the economy to the
international business cycle. This means that governments have less control over achieving
their economic objectives.
One potential benefit of globalisation is the greater choice of products and services that
consumers have as a result of increased international trade.
Page 6 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 23 (b)
Criteria Marks
• Demonstrates a comprehensive understanding of how Australia has
6
contributed to the process of globalisation
• Demonstrates a sound understanding of how Australia has contributed to
5
the process of globalisation
• Demonstrates some understanding of how Australia has contributed to
4
the process of globalisation
• Sketches in general terms how Australia has contributed to the process of
3
globalisation
• Makes a relevant statement about Australia and the process of
2
globalisation
• Makes a relevant statement about globalisation 1
Sample answer:
Globalisation involves the increased integration of national economies into the global
marketplace. Australia has contributed to this process by following a free trade agenda with
other countries including unilaterally reducing its own import tariffs as well as establishing
free trade agreements with countries such as China and the US. This has resulted in
increased bilateral trade flows between Australia and its trading partners.
Australia has also contributed to increased financial flows around the world by deregulating
financial markets and permitting foreign banks to operate in the domestic market.
Page 7 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 24 (a)
Criteria Marks
• Correctly calculates the unemployment rate in 2016 2
• Provides some relevant working to calculate the unemployment rate 1
Sample answer:
Number of unemployed in 2016
Unemployment rate in 2016 = × 100 = 5%
Labour force in 2016
600
Unemployment rate in 2016 = × 100
600 + 11 400
Question 24 (b)
Criteria Marks
• Correctly calculates the rate of growth in real GDP from 2016 to 2017 2
• Provides some relevant working to calculate the rate of growth in real
1
GDP from 2016 to 2017
Sample answer:
Rate of growth in real GDP from 2016 to 2017
1000 – 1000
Rate of growth in real GDP from 2016 to 2017 = × 100 = 0%
1000
Page 8 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 24 (c)
Criteria Marks
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of the relationship between net
2
foreign debt and net foreign liabilities
• Makes a relevant statement about net foreign debt OR net foreign
liabilities
OR 1
• Identifies the relationship between net foreign debt and net foreign
liabilities
Sample answer:
Net foreign liabilities are the sum of net foreign debt and net foreign equity. Other things
being equal, an increase in net foreign debt will increase net foreign liabilities.
Page 9 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 24 (d)
Criteria Marks
• Provides an argument that strongly supports the claim that the
hypothetical economy in the table is likely to have experienced a 4
depreciation of its currency between 2016 and 2017
• Provides an argument that supports the claim that the hypothetical
economy in the table is likely to have experienced a depreciation of its 3
currency between 2016 and 2017
• Sketches in general terms why the hypothetical economy in the table is
likely to have experienced a depreciation of its currency between 2016 2
and 2017
• Makes a correct statement about the hypothetical economy’s
1
performance between 2016 and 2017
Sample answer:
The increase in net foreign debt from 2016 to 2017 is likely to have depreciated the currency
due to the increased servicing costs associated with this higher level of debt. Moreover, a
depreciation of the hypothetical economy’s currency will increase the value of this economy’s
debt in domestic currency terms.
Page 10 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Section III
Question 25
Criteria Marks
• Synthesises own knowledge and understanding with the information
provided, to develop a sustained, logical and cohesive response
• Integrates relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates a clear and comprehensive understanding of the extent to 17–20
which free trade restricts the Australian Government’s ability to achieve
its economic objectives of full employment, distribution of income and
external stability
• Synthesises own knowledge and understanding with the information
provided, to develop a logical and cohesive response
• Applies relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates a comprehensive understanding of how free trade impacts
the Australian Government’s ability to achieve its economic objectives of
full employment, distribution of income and external stability
OR
• Demonstrates a sound understanding of the extent to which free trade 13–16
restricts the Australian Government’s ability to achieve its economic
objectives of full employment, distribution of income and external stability
OR
• Demonstrates a clear and comprehensive understanding of the extent to
which free trade restricts the Australian Government’s ability to achieve
ANY TWO of the economic objectives of full employment, distribution of
income and external stability
• Uses own knowledge and understanding with the information provided, to
develop a coherent response
• Uses relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Sketches in general terms how free trade impacts the Australian
Government’s ability to achieve its economic objectives of full
employment, distribution of income and external stability
OR
• Demonstrates a sound understanding of how free trade impacts the 9–12
Australian Government’s ability to achieve ANY TWO of the economic
objectives of full employment, distribution of income and external stability
OR
• Demonstrates a clear and comprehensive understanding of the extent to
which free trade restricts the Australian Government’s ability to achieve
ONE of the economic objectives of full employment, distribution of income
and external stability
• Presents a generalised response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts
• Sketches in general terms some aspects of the impact of free trade on 5–8
the Australian Government’s policy objectives of full employment
AND/OR distribution of income AND/OR external stability
• Presents a limited response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts 1–4
• Lists some aspects of free trade OR government policy objectives
Page 11 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Page 12 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 26
Criteria Marks
• Synthesises own knowledge and understanding with the information
provided, to develop a sustained, logical and cohesive response
• Integrates relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates a clear and comprehensive understanding of the extent to 17–20
which Australia’s economic growth since the last recession can be
attributed to macroeconomic policy decisions made by the Australian
Government
• Synthesises own knowledge and understanding with the information
provided, to develop a logical and cohesive response
• Applies relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates an understanding of the extent to which Australia’s
economic growth since the last recession can be attributed to
13–16
macroeconomic policy decisions made by the Australian Government
OR
• Demonstrates a sound understanding of how macroeconomic policy
decisions made by the Australian Government have contributed to
Australia’s economic growth since the last recession
• Uses own knowledge and understanding with the information provided, to
develop a coherent response
• Uses relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Sketches in general terms the extent to which Australia’s economic
growth since the last recession can be attributed to macroeconomic policy
9–12
decisions by the Australian Government
OR
• Demonstrates some understanding of how macroeconomic policy
decisions made by the Australian Government have contributed to
Australia’s economic growth since the last recession
• Presents a generalised response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts
5–8
• Sketches in general terms some aspects of Australia’s economic growth
or economic policies since the last recession
• Presents a limited response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts 1–4
• Lists some aspects of Australia’s economic growth OR economic policies
Page 13 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
– reduction in trade barriers and labour market reforms increased productivity and
reduced inflation ensuring business-friendly conditions. Also ensured that during GFC
unemployment didn’t increase as much as might otherwise have been expected.
• Other policies that have supported growth:
– increased immigration.
• Reduced inflationary expectations (since adoption of inflation targeting) provided more
scope to reduce interest rates when GFC hit.
Page 14 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Section IV
Question 27
Criteria Marks
• Provides a sustained, logical and cohesive response
• Integrates relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates a clear and comprehensive understanding of government
policies that are designed to achieve environmental sustainability in 17–20
Australia
• Develops arguments to judge the success of government policies
designed to achieve environmental sustainability in Australia
• Provides a logical and cohesive response
• Applies relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates a sound understanding of government policies that are
13–16
designed to achieve environmental sustainability in Australia
• States arguments regarding the success of government policies designed
to achieve environmental sustainability in Australia
• Provides a coherent response
• Uses relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
9–12
• Demonstrates an understanding of government policies that are designed
to achieve environmental sustainability in Australia
• Provides a generalised response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts
5–8
• Sketches in general terms some aspects of environmental policy AND
environmental sustainability in Australia
• Provides a limited response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts
1–4
• Identifies some aspects of environmental policy OR environmental
sustainability
– environmental targets
– global environmental agreements
• Environmental issues:
– climate change
– depletion of natural resources
– pollution
• Disagreement about extent of issues
• Criteria by which to evaluate success of policies:
– too early to judge success
Page 15 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Page 16 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Question 28
Criteria Marks
• Provides a sustained, logical and cohesive response
• Integrates relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates a clear and comprehensive understanding of the factors 17–20
that determine the size and composition of Australia’s current account
and a sound understanding of their relative importance
• Provides a logical and cohesive response
• Applies relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates a sound understanding of the factors that determine the
size and composition of Australia’s current account and some
13–16
understanding of their relative importance
OR
• Demonstrates a clear and comprehensive understanding of the factors
that determine the size and composition of Australia’s current account
• Provides a coherent response
• Uses relevant economic terms, concepts, relationships and theories
• Demonstrates some understanding of the factors that determine the size
and composition of Australia’s current account AND/OR sketches in
general terms the importance of factors that determine the size and 9–12
composition of Australia’s current account
OR
• Demonstrates a clear understanding of factors that determine the size OR
composition of Australia’s current account
• Provides a generalised response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts
5–8
• Sketches in general terms some aspects of the factors that determine the
size OR composition of Australia’s current account
• Provides a limited response
• Uses some economic terms and concepts 1–4
• Identifies some aspects of Australia’s current account
Page 17 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
– fiscal and monetary policy; other government policies (eg bans on live animal exports,
gas export restrictions)
– domestic vs foreign economic growth
– changes in demand for exports (education, mining) and imports
– interest rates and debt servicing
– terms of trade
– foreign investment
– trade policies
– capacity constraints in production
– savings and investment gap
– narrow export base
– structural change.
Page 18 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Section II
Page 19 of 20
NESA 2018 HSC Economics Marking Guidelines
Section III
Topic 2 and Topic 4 — trade policy and economic H1, H2, H4, H7, H8,
25 20
objectives H9, H10
Topic 1, Topic 3 and Topic 4 — sources of H1, H2, H4, H5, H9,
26 20
economic growth and economic policy H10
Section IV
Page 20 of 20