Feasibility Study and Business Plan Pearl Culture

`
FEASIBILITY STUDY & BUSINESS PLAN
FOR
PEARL CULTURE IN KILWA, MAFIA AND ZANZIBAR
Prepared for
Feasibility Study & Business Plan for Pearl Culture in Kilwa, Mafia and Zanzibar
ABSTRACT
The Study and Business Plan document provides an analysis of the economic
feasibility of several small-scale aquaculture operations on half pearl oyster farms as
way of earning income and supplemental economic activity for coastal communities in
the neighbouring villages in the Fumba peninsula in Zanzibar, Mafia district and Kilwa
district in Pwani and Lindi regions respectively. It is concerned with understanding the
obstacles and opportunities of pearl cultivators in a social, environmental and
economic context, as well as further giving an account of findings that form basis of
the business plan in the promotion of pearl culture in these communities. The villages
in these communities are characterized by artisanal fishery, fish and food vendoring
and some livestock keeping.
The market situation of the pearl industry is examined and changes in its structure are
related to new possible technologies and marketing strategies. Socio-economic
impacts are explored briefly and sources of market outlet are specified and factors
involved in the marketing of pearls are given particular attention. Most, but not
exclusive attention, is given to the experiences of some other countries like the
Australian pearl industry and that of Tahiti who are among the major global producer
of pearls.
The study analysis and associated Business Plan recommend these communities to
strengthen interventions in order to increase the participation of poor communities to
sustain their livelihoods. Extension and funding agencies, other international
organizations, private sector and the government will need to commit in the years to
come to concrete action for implementation as the study strives to collaborate with
engaged stakeholders in exploring the market potential that will induce consumer
preference. At present, absence of operating ‘market’ that would put domestic users,
tourism industry consumers and local pearl producers in touch with each other is a
serious limiting factor.
Financial projections for each small-scale pearl oyster farm using raft, spat collection
and long-line method estimates annual operating costs of US$ 7,559,210.53
(Tsh. 11,496,000.00/-) for each farm whereas an annual cash flow and enterprise
budget show that initial capital investment of US$ 18,750,000.00 (Tsh.
28,500,000.00/-) Annual operating expenses are US$ 13,397,746.71 (Tsh.
20,364,575.00) when in full operation. The main costs contributing to annual operating
expenses include Professional Fees (19%), Merchandising (14.2%), Repair and
Maintenance (14%), Training and Development (11.9%), Agent Commission (11%).
Net returns over a 5 year farm horizon based on an 8 % discount rate indicate a
positive NPV of US$ 57,000.00 (Tsh.86,639,500/) compared to the initial costs of US
$ 26,315,789.47 (Tz sh. 40,000.00/-).
The study is led by ReCoMaP as part of its mission to enhance sustainable

management and conservation of resources in coastal areas to contribute to poverty
reduction. In partnership with WWF, WIOMSA and IMS who extend research and
extension services to build the capacity of pearl farmers in these coastal
communities, successful pilot farms in several coastal villages of Tanzania were
developed. It is henceforth the right time for Pearl farming to commercial pearl oyster
cultivation and other coastal livelihoods such as management of marine
environments, oyster shells craft, jewellery making and other related products.
At global level, increasing number of pearl farming projects, pearl industry despite
significant growth in the past two decades is at present undergoing significant
transformation due to globally induced economic and environmental changes
resulting in over production and low demand hence beginners in pearl culture should
struggle to maintain high quality production in order to compete in global market that
is somehow fragmented.
The possibility to merge proactive consumer engagement with responsible forms of

pearl cultivation presents great potential. In many countries in recent decades, the
pearl industry has contributed significantly to improved coastal livelihoods and
regional economic development hence, in Tanzania, the economic viability and long-
term future of pearl farming venture is directly dependent on a healthy marine
environment; a clear economic incentive for long-term marine conservation in

ecosystems that are very vulnerable to environmental degradation. The quality of
pearl production is a direct measure of environmental management efforts to develop
local and heritage products for the tourist industry and local enterprise in order that
the local community gets equity.
AUTHORIZATION MEMORANDUM
The study pearl farming in Tanzania has been completed in accordance with the
requirements set in the terms of reference.
MANAGEMENT CERTIFICATION
__________________ The document is accepted
__________________ The document is accepted pending the changes noted
__________________ The document is not accepted
_______________________ _________________
NAME DATE
For: ICZMO
_______________________ __________________
NAME DATE
For: RCU- ReCoMaP

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The Consultant acknowledge the pleasant cooperation extended during the study
and wish to thank all those individuals, groups and institutions who have contributed
to the work by way of information, documents for literature review, advice, views,
suggestions and facilitation.
Sincere appreciation are expressed to a number of people who are key participants
and stakeholders to pearl farming in Mafia, Kilwa and Unguja including pearl farmers,
women who make oyster shells jewelry, respective institutions for their great
assistance and allowed use of facilities.
Deep thanks should go to Baraka Kalangahe of ICZM office in Tanzania, Dr

Narriman Jiddawi (IMS), Jason Ruben (WWF), Hamoud Abdulla and Ismail Juma.
(WWF-RUMAKI) and Mussa Haji (WIOMSA) who selflessly extended assistance and
comments.
Profound acknowledgements are extended to Imruh Bakari of Savannah Films and

Fatma Ali of RWSWH for their valuable technical inputs, and the various businesses
particularly the Jewelers and galleries around Stone Town, Zanzibar and Dar es
Salaam for sparing their precious time to share ideas.
The views, findings and opinions expressed herein are those of the Consultant and
wish to express great thanks to everyone. It is not possible to mention them all. The
Consultant however wishes to make no warranty of its accuracy as data and
information was received from a variety of sources.
Munira Humoud Said
RWSWH
LIST OF CONTENT
Abstract
Authorization Memorandum
Acknowledgement
Table of Content
Acronyms
Glossary
Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................................................... 1

Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Background .......................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Purpose of Study................................................................................................................................................................. 7
Methodology and Data Collection................................................................................................. 8
Scope and Limitation ................................................................................................................................................... 10
Description and Significance of Pearl Culture ........................................................................................................ 12
Pearl Industry ......................................................................................................................... 13
Outstanding Value of Pearl ....................................................................................................................................... 19
Global Trends ........................................................................................................................... 21
National Framework for Pearl Entrepreneurship ......................................................................................... 22
Existing Situation ...................................................................................................................... 25
Pearl Culture in Kilwa, Mafia and Zanzibar ...................................................................................................................... 27
Mafia......................................................................................................................................... 27
Kilwa ........................................................................................................................................ 29
Zanzibar .................................................................................................................................... 30
Acqua-culture and Conservation ............................................................................................... 32
Hatchery and Spat Collection .................................................................................................... 32
Pearl Culture and Women Empowerment ................................................................................... 33
Legal Framework ................................................................................................................... 35
Stakeholders Consultations .............................................................................................................. 36
Meeting with Extenstion Agents- WWF, WIOMSA & IMS ............................................................ 36
Meeting with Government Partners ............................................................................................ 36
Meeting with Potential Clientele ................................................................................................ 37
Summary of Findings and Recommendations............................................................................................................... 40

External Dimension ................................................................................................................... 43
Financial Dimension ................................................................................................................. 43
Artistic Partnership .................................................................................................................... 44
Government Partnership ............................................................................................................ 45
Community Partnership ........................................................................................................... 45
IT and Networking ……………………………………………………………………………………………………… 46
The Business Concept............................................................................................................................................................. 50

Mission ................................................................................................................................... 51
Values ...................................................................................................................................... 51
Scope of Activities .................................................................................................................... 52
SWOT Analysis.......................................................................................................................... 57
Some KeySuccess Factors................................................................................................................ 60
Marketing Analysis & Strategy.......................................................................................................................................... 66
Marketing Strategy ................................................................................................................... 66
Product Differentiation ............................................................................................................ 66
Sales Strategy .......................................................................................................................... 69
Price Strategy ........................................................................................................................... 70
Touch Points ............................................................................................................................. 70
Branding and IP for Pearls ...................................................................................................... 71
Promotion and Awareness Creation ........................................................................................... 73
Financial Plan ................................................................................................................................... 75
Assumptions ............................................................................................................................ 75
Projected Cash Flows ............................................................................................................... 76
Projected Profit and Loss ........................................................................................................... 79
Projected Balance Sheet ........................................................................................................... 81
Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................................................... 84
List of People Met………………………………………………………………………………………………...88
ACRONYMS
BDG Business Development Gateway

CRC Coastal Resource Center
FAST Faculty of Aquatic Science and Technology
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GNU Government of National Unity
IMCAFA Integrated Management of Coastal and Freshwater Systems
ICM Integrated Coastal Management
ICZM Integrated Coastal Zone Management
IP Intellectual Property
JCU James Cook University
IMS Institute of Marine Science
IPR Intellectual Property Right
MACEMP Marine and Coastal Environmental Management Project
MBCA Menai Bay Conservation Area

MKUKUTA Mkakati wa Kukuza Uchumi na Kupunguza Umasikini Tanzania
MKUZA Mkakati wa Kukuza Uchumi na Kupunguza Umasikini Zanzibar
MKURABITA Mkakati wa Kurasimisha Biashara Ndogo Ndogo na Rasilimali

Tanzania
MIMP Mafia Island Marine Park
MSME Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises
NGO Non Governmental Organisation
NSGPR National Strategy of Poverty Reduction
Recomap Regional Program for the Sustainable Management of the Coastal Zones
RGoZ Revolutionary Government of Zanzibar
RWSWH Reclaim Women Space in World Heritage
RUMAKI Rufiji, Mafia and Kilwa
SACCOS Savings and Credit Cooperative Societies
SME Small and Medium Enterprise
SUCCESS Sustainable Coastal Communities and Ecosystems Program
TOR Terms of Reference
UDSM University of Dar es Salaam

USAID United States Agency for International Development
WIOMSA Western Indian Ocean Marine Science Association
WIPO World Intellectual Property Organisation
WWF World Wildlife Fund for Nature
ZSGPR Zanzibar Strategy for Growth and Poverty Reduction
GLOSSARY
Brand Is a word to denote the characteristic of a particular supplier
Copyright Is a set of exclusive rights granted to the author or creator of an

original work including the right to copy, distribute and adopt the
work
Cultured pearls Any pearl grown with the influence of human interaction
Inclusions Sometimes called blemishes, are imperfections in the surface of
the pearl. These may be cracks or bumps in the surface. The
fewer imperfections, the greater the quality and value of the pearl.
Luster The brightness or radiance of light from a pearl. A high quality

pearl will be brilliant and bright, and you should be able to easily
see your own reflection in its surface.
Matching The ability of a set of pearls to resemble or harmonize with each

other is referred to as matching. The greater the matching, the
greater the value of the piece of pearl jewelry.
Mari culture Is specialized branch of acquaculture involving cultivation of

marine organisms for food and other products in the open ocean
The thickness of the pearl's coating. Is a layer of aragonite and

Nacre
conchiolin that form around the pearl’s center. The thicker the
nacre, the longer a pearl will typically last.
Size
Pearls range in size from a couple of millimeters to over 15

millimeters depending on the type. The larger the pearl, the more
rare and valuable it is
Shape Pearls come in a number of different shapes including round, off-
round, oval, baroque, and ringed. Round pearls are the most
desired and valuable.
Touch points An interaction with potential customer.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Following survey to determine socio economic status of farmers, pearl farming in

Fumba peninsula and neighbouring villages started in 2006 on pilot base as
alternative income generating activity. The initiative was first financed by USAID
through SUCCESS project.
Although it started with the site at Bweleo, additional fund from the Regional Program
for the Sustainable Management of the Coastal Zones of the Indian Ocean
(ReCoMaP) financed by the European Union, other two sites at Unguja Ukuu
and another at Nyamanzi as well as Mafia, Kilwa and some other parts of Tanzania
mainland engaged in growing oysters for pearl production. ReCoMaP in partnership
with WWF and MIMP on the mainland Tanzania and IMS and WIOMSA on the
islands of Zanzibar are exploring with coastal communities to enhance sustainable
livelihoods and address the high levels of poverty in the islands at the same time
facilitate conservation measures. In this context, pearl culture is proving to be a
valuable opportunity for income generation for coastal communities.
This feasibility study is undertaken with the main objective of establishing economic
feasibility of the pearl farming in Kilwa, Mafia and Unguja (Zanzibar) whose
traditional sources of income is fishing, coconut production and farming. ReCoMaP
has commissioned the study in the expectation of farmers setting up a profitable and
self sustaining pearl culture business, and for increased number of beneficiaries
within broader target area. Small scale production of the first cultured pearls indeed
offers opportunities for income generation for coastal communities in Tanzania and
may provide an important part of the management process for sustainable use of
coastal ecosystem.
The study review was carried out between the month of January and February 2011
and based its assessment on interviews with pearl farming groups in the above
1
mentioned areas. For the sustainability of pearl farming as a business venture and
important source of livelihood among coastal population, the initiative is also in
recognition of the need to initiate a business plan that would position pearl production
and institutionalize the venture as an accredited enterprise that is sustained through
its own related investment. The business plan attempts to give an analysis that justify
having such a venture and how activities would be accommodated.
The study assessed feasibility on the basis of four dimensions: growth, financial,
technical and operational dimensions to analyse the possibilities of innovative
revenue expansion from identified emerging opportunities. The overall assessment
indicate on continuing growth and expansion, establishing the requisite cooperative
structure to support that growth, operating safely and efficiently, and generating
balanced returns. Adequate skills in terms of timing of implanting, cleaning and
implanting of nuclei, depth of farming pearls, size of shells/mother of pearls as well
as other environmental factors and genetics have been achieved.
SCOPE OF BUSINESS PLAN
The Consultant agrees on the primary Cooperative model under process or planning.
The Cooperative manages community farms to develop business both directly and
through a professional management/marketing agent to develop links between farms
and potential markets such as individual buyers, crafts persons and resorts.
Partnership with jewelry makers should also be established to supply pearls as raw
material and gems
The Vision
Half Pearl culture through Cooperatives envision to be a benchmark in the pearl

enterprise within the next five years dedicating to set industry trend for a socially,
economically, and environmentally responsible and profitable business.
2
MAIN FINDINGS
- Production of half pearls that are of quality provide a promising opportunity for
income generation within Fumba peninsula, Mafia Island and Kilwa.
- The number of pearl farmers is extending to Unguja Ukuu in Zanzibar and
Mtwara In mainland. This can to a great extent be attributed to recent support
from development partners particularly ReCoMaP.
- Slightly less than 50% of the pearl farmers are female except for few villages
at Bweleo in and Unguja where the group is much bigger and women are
more 80% hence pearl culture supplement women empowerment in making
decisions for their economic gains
- Pearl culture has the potential to existing gemstones industry
- The absence of a strong program places pearl producers at a competitive
disadvantage. The non existence of marketing strategies among the groups of
pearl farmers could be one of the issues which can result in a lot of frustration.
- Farmers around Somanga have not made progress like their colleagues in
Songosongo or Mafia. Apparently this is attributed to deliberate destruction of
rafts by fishermen
- In spite of the persisting challenges mostly owing to resource limitations, a
number of individuals livelihoods have improved
- Creating critical positions within groups is important to nurture the
management and administrative capacity of taking care of the business
- There is undertone of reluctance from members of Chaza Njema at Bweleo to
go on existing as one large group
- Tourism will provide main market for pearls, pearl products and pearl souvenir
- Ongoing research efforts to by WWF to establish hatchery are positive
- There are no current activities to focus on traditional shell and beads craft
and little focus on community outreach. The farmers have no valid Work Plan
or Business Plan for the coming year.
- Income previously generated from sales of pearls was not reinvested
3
- Appropriate training was conducted by the local and international expertise to

orient the groups with the appropriate skills and techniques of cultivating pearl
resulting in adequate number of people trained in raft deployment and farming
techniques
- Gaps exist in capacity to improve production for better markets outlets
- Local processing capability should be developed at short-term for the sake of

value addition.
- Integration of brand theory and buying psychology is significant factor to
promote awareness of a geographical brand, and to form a well deserving
image for pearls from Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar.
KEY RECOMMENDATIONS
The business strategy is expected to address constraints of pearl production,

processing and marketing but sooner or later would need to be complemented with
the IP and product branding. Implementation of the IP and brand strategy for ongoing
pearl farming demand strategic external support offered by institution such as WIPO,
Word Bank and European Union.
In principle the Consultancy sees an integration of 4 scenarios for business

promotion and resource mobilization:
Option 1: Pursue or finalise establishment of Cooperatives which will assume

ownership of the farms, with SACCOS being the most significant forms of
participation in financial markets in rural Tanzania 1. Each Cooperative will use the
business plan as source of reference in it undertakings. Although it is agreed that this
is the most recommendable solution but it may take time to realize a new
arrangement.
Option 2: Enter into contract on commission basis with a professional

management/marketing company to promote sales and market pearl culture to better
commercialize and nurture pearl industry.
1 Report on the Survey of Rural Savings
4
Option 3 (uncertain recommendation): Find alternative avenues that include finding a

partner from the business community to invest or buy share in the business.
Option 4 (recommended): The current programmes supporting mariculture activities

should continue to provide extension support and to assist in mobilizing and
managing resources until the business plan is well underway in its execution.
With serious capacity concern and the challenges at different levels in organizing
pearl farms as venture, this may take a long time and may also lead to even more
unexpected problems which are not foreseeable at this point in time. It is imperative
then to continue coaching group members for each to start developing specific area
of specialization depending on qualifications, skills and interest.
The business shall encompass:
1. Retail outlets of small scale pearl farm products
2. Sales to resorts and high end hotels
3. Small demonstration workshops and a gift shop for tourist on excursions
4. Sales to local and tourists related businesses and fashion boutiques including
jewelry shops and galleries
5. Retailing pearls, pearl products and pearl oyster shells as raw material through
craft marketing and cooperatives outlets
6. Online and overseas sale both wholesaling and retail
7. Auctioning
5
INTRODUCTION
The Regional Program for the sustainable management of the coastal zones of
the Indian Ocean (ReCoMaP) support local communities to reduce threats of over
exploitation, habitat degradation and destructive finishing practices as key sources
to enhance better livelihood. ReCoMaP through Call for Proposal, provided grants
to WWF and WIOMSA and entered into a 3 year contract for institutional support
to expand the Fumba programme in Unguja by promoting the development of
pearl farming.
Pearl farming is increasingly recognized as sustainable alternative livelihood for

coastal population and at institutional level, ReCoMaP in Tanzania is coordinating
to ensure activities are managed at same pace. International and internal NGOs
working in the field and IMS as government research organization have taken the
responsibility to implement demonstration projects in the pilot phase. The objective
of the core funding correspond to WWF objective to implement a project tilted
Promoting Pearl Oyster Culturing in Tanzania building the capacity in two districts
of Mafia and Kilwa, and planning for sustainable future expansion in other areas
of the mainland coast
BACKGROUND 2
The ReCoMaP support to WWFand WIOMSA for promoting the development of pearl
farming in Kilwa, Mafia and Unguja Islands and planning for sustainable future
expansion in other areas of the mainland coasts, have started to show some
promising results. WWF has managed to establish a small scale hatchery in Mafia
and mobilized sensitized communities in Mafia, Somanga, Songosongo to set up
pearl farms comprising of farms targeting production of half pearls.
Half pearl oyster farming is among one of the successful proposed mariculture
activity that was initiated and is still going on in Fumba peninsular area since 2006,
as alternative livehood activitiy for Menai bay communities. Initially it was a pilot
2 Terms of Reference
6
study at Bweleo village only funded by USAID under SUCCESES project. at the
start, several trainings were carried out which involved men and women from Bweleo
and two IMS researchers who successfully continued training to the community
under supervision of IMS and financial supported by USAID. Following these initial
efforts, in 2008, WIOMSA via ReCoMap support, aimed to expand the half pearl
productions technology to other three village of Fumba peninsular including Fumba,
Unguja ukuu, Nyamanzi and Bweleo with the objective of facilitation the extension of
half-pearl farming to the community aiming at reducing poverty. Similar efforts were
extended to Mafia and Kilwa in partnership with WWF.
PURPOSE OF STUDY
During the evaluation mission held in September and October 2010, it was observed
that most projects lacked feasibility studies on the economic feasibility of the
livelihood projects and beneficiaries are constrained with marketing of their products.
It is an undisputed fact that for a livelihood intervention to be sustainable and
alleviate poverty it has to be economically feasible.
To achieve these, ReCoMaP sought the assistance of a Consultant who, in close

coordination with WWF and WIOMSA to implement the following:
1. Conduct a feasibility study that among other thing identify market bottleneck
constraining pearl marketing.
2. Assist farmers in developing a business plan.
3. Provide feedback to stakeholders on the finding of the feasibility study during
a two days feedback workshop to be organized by ReCoMaP.
Expected Outputs
1. Feasibility study.
2. Pearl Farming Business Plan.
7
Henceforth, the purpose of the study assignment was to assess feasibility according
to the main objectives of the pearl culture programme and to the degree possible
assess impact at individual and societal level seen in the light of pearl cultivation
around marine and coastal areas of Tanzanian. According to the TOR, the study will
be used by ReCoMaP to assess the overall potential for success of the program with
the view to use the established business plan as reference when mobilizing
resources and basis for the assessment of prospective interventions required to
promoting pearl cultivation as sustainable business venture.
The overall objective of the feasibility study and the business plan are critical
reference against which findings and recommendations are compared. The exercise
is an exploration of what is hoped to provide a more comprehensive view in further
expanding pearl culture as source of sustainable livelihood and poverty reduction
particularly poor women around the Fumba peninsula, Mafia Island and Kilwa.
METHODOLOGY AND DATA COLLECTION
The Consultant assessment of key results area is included in the findings and people
met are enlisted in the report. Data collection involved informal and formal interviews,
direct and participatory observation, focus group discussions and literature search.
Few persons who were not easy to meet, were interviewed through telephones and
internet.
The study was conducted in Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar between the month of
January and February 2011. The applied methodology intended to answer key study
issues as per ToR using following key action points:
 Primary data from management files and published documents

 Collecting qualitative and quantitative data
 Perspective of the community, public sector and private sector
8
In the exercise, the Consultant in close consultation with ICZM Officer met with
officers from IMS, WIOMSA, WWF and ReCoMaP as well as government officers
from the fishery department and individuals from farmers groups in Zanzibar, Mafia
and Kilwa.
It should be noted that the study took place in a period in which farmers have already
harvested pearls and shared proceeds with hardly any savings to meet critical
strategic and operational challenges on their own. Methodologically speaking this
influenced the approach when preparing the financial statements in relation to
sources of funds as it was risky to indicate members’ equity in the absence of
savings.
Desk review of pearl farming in Tanzania and globally was carried out prior to study
so as to inform on the field work. The ICZM Officer introduced to the consultant the
professional contact in Kilwa, Mafia and Zanzibar from WWF, WIOMSA and IMS
respectively. A mixture of qualitative and quantitative approaches was applied but the
main methodology was through interviews (qualitative) and documents, statistics,
files (at least partly quantitative). The framework and the approach to developing
appropriate criteria for the review were derived from the TOR and the contract
between the Consultant and ReCoMaP signed January, 2011. The review sought to
answer issues as set down in the TOR. The Consultant applied the indicator
framework set down in the contract as the main reference for reviewing progress and
achievements. The analytical framework however was organized along the four
dimensions illustrated below as main general indicators for feasibility.
It should, however, be noted that goals of commercializing pearl culture are not over
ambitious and can be expected to generate results in three and half year period.
Reaching out the prospective clientele may also be quite challenging in the current
media and competitive society. The study should not be expected to be able to
make definite conclusions on societal impact in the entire region but be limited to the
development and impact in Tanzania.
9
The Consultancy look into how Recomap positioned itself as one of the leading actor
in the region through its relations with local and international partners and networks
as they are manifested by the use of particularly environmental friendly approach in
exploring natural and coastal resources for livelihood.
This model illustrates our four-pronged approach, which focuses on continuing

growth and expansion, establishing the requisite corporate structure to support that
growth, operating safely and efficiently, and generating balanced returns.
SCOPE AND LIMITATION
For sustainability of pearl farming, ReCoMaP in partnership with WWF, WIOMSA

and IMS, the study was commissioned in recognition of the need to initiate a
business plan and work towards positioning small scale pearl farms to transform into
sustainable business entities by tapping market potential and realize significant profit.
The objective of the study is to identify constraints in the development of pearl

marketing and propose a business plan that suggest how best to address them.
Henceforth, the study summarized an assessment and analysis for increased

competitiveness and growth. In particular, the study identified emerging opportunities
within the economic potential and related challenges facing business growth.
However, due to time and resource limitation, the study was carried out basing more
on literature survey and field observation. In this context, study limitations attest to
the reality in which business environment particularly small entrepreneurs thrives in
Tanzania and small island economy like Mafia and Zanzibar.
Specifically the analysis framework applied is based on four perspectives of

performance and feasibility. It focuses on continuing growth and expansion,
operational, technical capacity and financial perspective to assess internal
management for generating balanced returns. A simplified model of this framework
can be illustrated as follows:
10
Preliminary review framework

Financial Perspective
Proper keeping of
finance records &
Accounting System
Support from various

sources
Technical Perspective
Social & Operational Income
Perspective and
finance No of Jobs Created
Planning and Program Accredited
Management Efficient GOALS, Skills Development
delivery of outputs VISION & Producers of
Relationship with MISSION -
r Half Pearls
Positive Engagement
Community
Promotion
of
Sustainable
Livelihood
Growth Perspective
Standard increase
of Pearl Farms
Satisfaction and
Future Career
Individual and
Group Wellbeing
11
DESCRIPTION AND SIGNIFICANCE OF PEARL CULTURE
Pearl farming is the industry responsible for grafting pearl molluscs – the invertebrate
having a soft body that is often protected by a shell, such as with the snail, clam,
mussel, or oyster; and producing cultured pearls - pearls formed by the insertion of a
piece of mantle tissue, with or without a nucleus, into the mother oyster or mussel.
Pearl oysters are probably the most noted source of the “natural pearl” and over the
centuries, as pearls have become highly valued and admired, the process of creating
the “cultured pearl” has developed to satisfy the consumer demand and to guarantee
a reliable and steady supply. Today, rare and very expensive natural pearls do exist,
but the global market is dominated by equally prized cultured pearls.
As one of the oldest and longest known gems, pearls have been part of the cultures
of the Middle East and Indian Ocean centuries. This region has been acknowledged
as being the home of some of the oldest known “natural” pearl formations. This was
also one the principal regions which, along with China and Japan provided the pearls
that initially established and supplied the global trade. Subsequent experimentation
and the increasing development of pearl cultivation around the world have brought
both diversity and innovation to pearl farming.
It is acknowledged that today pearl farming is a highly competitive business. The

basic method remains “simple”, but environmental conditions, technical information,
as well as the development of “secret” methods, could be identified as factors to be
noted if a new farmer is going to start and sustain a pearl farming operation. These
considerations should no doubt be made in addition to the application of the “proven
methods”. Some of these which have been noted by Maria Haws (2002) in The Basic
Methods of Pearl Farming: A Layman’s Manual 3. The knowledge and information in
this manual is “inspired by the pearl farmers of Penrhyn (Tongareva), Cook Islands,
3Maria Haws (2002) The Basic Methods of Pearl Farming: A Layman’s Manual, Center for Tropical and
Subtropical Aquaculture, Publication No. 127
12
who worked to establish pearl farms while maintaining the environmental health of
their lagoon.” 4
In framing the economic activity and environmental concerns, Haws highlights an

experience and circumstances that may be of critical significance as a point of
reference in assessing the potential of a pearl farming initiative for Mafia, kilwa and
Zanzibar; while equally supporting the Regional Programme for the Sustainable
Management of the Coastal Zones the Indian Ocean Countries (ReCoMaP)
development perspective that guides the Tanzania initiative.
It has been noted that the demise of “natural pearls” has been due largely to
“overfishing”. Equally, it is known that environmental pollution and certain extreme
conditions such as storms, excessive heat or cold are also detrimental to pearl
cultivation. Hence, the importance of the established methods and the accumulated
knowledge that currently informs the practices of the industry. Pearl farming in its
simplicity was radically transformed in the early 20th century and as Haws notes,
Japanese researchers developed methods that brought pearl production under the
control of humans in the early twentieth century. These “cultured pearls” are
generally larger and of a more consistent size and colour than natural pearls.
Producing cultured pearls depends on a surgical procedure called grafting, which
entails surgically implanting an artificial nucleus (shell bead) into the tissue of a pearl
oyster. The oyster then secretes nacre around the nucleus. After several years of
caring for the oysters, the cultured pearls are harvested 5.
PEARL INDUSTRY
4 Ibid p.1
5 Ibid p.5
13
The cultured pearls which now supply the world market are of a number of varieties.
Species vary according to the location of production, as well as the characteristics of

the gem. The following selection is listed by the Australian jewelry and gems dealers
Costellos 6:
Australian Pearls - The Australian South Sea Pearl is unquestionably the rarest and
finest cultured pearl in the world.
South Sea Pearls - There are two basic groups of South Sea cultured pearls: white
and black. Pearls from the white group are primarily cultured in the northern waters
of Australia, the Philippines and Indonesia. Pearls from the black group, among
which is the legendary black pearl of the South Pacific, are most frequently found
over a wide area stretching from the Cook Islands, eastward through Tahiti to the
Tuamotu Archipelago and the Gambier Islands in French Polynesia.
Tahitian Pearls - The cultured pearl of Tahiti is synonymous with magic . Most come
from the atolls and lagoons of the South Pacific and perfection
Akoya Pearls - Considered the classic amongst cultured pearls, Akoya Pearls are
primarily round or oval in shape and measure 2 to 10mm. They are cultured in
southwestern Japan and China. Their colours range from pinkish white to creamy
shades and silvery blue.
Keshi Pearls - Possessing a whimsical charm entirely different to the perfectly round,
large pearls, seedless keshi pearls arise spontaneously in the culture of Akoya, and
South Sea pearls. These small freeform pearls make fascinating necklaces in colours
ranging from silvery white to silvery grey.
6 See: www.costellos.com.au
14
Mabé Pearls - Mabé Pearls are attractive half pearls with beautiful, rainbow-coloured
iridescence. The pearl was named after the mabé pearl oyster which is found mainly
in the tropical seas of Southeast Asia and in the Japanese islands around Okinawa.
Since the beginning of the century, many attempts had been made to cultivate round
pearls from the mabé oyster but all had failed. However, in the 1950s hemispherical
pearls (or 'half pearls' as they are more commonly known) were successfully
cultivated. Today, most of these cultured half pearls do not come from the mabé
oyster, but rather from the South Sea's silver-lipped oyster. Mabé pearls are also
available in oval, cushion, drop and heart shapes.
Chinese Freshwater Pearls - Chinese Freshwater Pearls are grown in an amazing

variety of delicate shapes ranging from round and oval to button, drop and baroque.
Their colours vary from pure white to orange and rosy violet.
Kasumiga Pearls - The Kasumiga is a new type of pearl that comes from a lake
northeast of Tokyo. The mussels are a crossbreed between Japanese and Chinese
freshwater mussels, and are implanted with round or flat seeds. Kasumiga Pearls
glow in rosy hues of light to dark pink.
The farming of cultured pearls is a delicate and labour intensive activity. The principle
locations of cultivation are now to be found in Australia, the South Seas, and Japan
using seawater; and in China, the USA, and also Japan, where freshwater is used.
This environmentally friendly business is suited to “island areas”. Here it is most
likely to find an abundance of the “boating, diving and fishing skills” that are required.
As Haws also notes, a principal advantage of pearl production is that “the final
product is lightweight and non-perishable” and there is no need for “artificial feeds,
complicated farm structures or constant attention”. All of these factors are part of
what makes pearl farming an attractive opportunity for an Indian Ocean island such
as Zanzibar and Mafia.
In their study, “Ukulima wa Lulu, Zanzibar, Tanzania ( Nusu Lulu)” 7, Narriman et al

elaborate on the appropriateness of pearl farming for Zanzibar. The significance of
7 Harriman, Jiddawi & Soud (2010)
15
the Indian Ocean environment is noted, as well as other needs and requirements of
the industry which are available in Zanzibar. There is also the potential for jewellery
and gem products of high quality and value. In the context of “Pearl farming and
jewelry making in Zanzibar: empowering women economically” 8 involving both
supported by Western Indian Ocean Marine Science Association (WIOMSA) and
Institute of Marine Sciences (IMS), the cultivation of pearls takes on a definitive
significance in relation to national policies towards poverty reduction, wealth creation
and development.
As a precursor to outlining the “benefits” of cultivating pearls, Haws makes three

cautionary observations 9:
 Successful pearl farming requires a long-term investment of time, money and

hard work.
 Production of high quality pearls is the key to having a profitable farm.
 Production of high quality pearls is only possible under certain conditions.
Under each of these, certain factors and prerequisites are noted which contextualise
the simplicity of the process and its strategic needs and requirements. As also
implied in “Ukulima wa Lulu, Zanzibar, Tanzania (Nusu Lulu)” 10, these infrastructural
and knowledge resources are of importance to pearl farming as a business venture.
In effect, these resources together, are critical determinants for a successful industry,
which of necessity would include not solely the cultivation of pearls, but equally the
harvesting of good quality pearls and effective marketing these as valued products.
This suggests a need for consistent vigilance and quality control at each stage of the
process. As is clearly stated on the third cautionary point noted above, the starting
criteria for the production of “high quality pearls” are:
A reliable source of pearl oysters.
A suitable site.
8 ReCoMaP project #07/01/381

9 Haws (2002)
10 Harriman et al (2010)
16
Sufficient funds to establish and operate a farm.
Access to grafting technicians.
Ability to market pearls
With these in mind Haws’ handbook focuses on methods used to cultivate the “Black-
Lip pearl oysters (which) are known as black pearls or Tahitian black pearls .” These
are mostly produced in “the sheltered waters” of the Indo-Pacific area off French
Polynesia and the Cook Islands. Growing black pearl industries exist in Australia,
Indonesia, the Philippines and the Western Pacific Islands. Here, the waters are of
high salinity and with temperatures of 25 – 30 degrees centigrade. “They appear to
grow best in clear waters that are free of large amounts of sediment since pearl
oysters may have difficulty feeding in turbid water” 11. Favourably conditions are to be
found in the waters surrounding Fumba peninsula and Unguja Ukuu in Zanzibar,
Mafia, Kilwa and Mtwara on the mainland. These conditions are likely to be
favourable for considering or adapting the pearl farming methods discussed by
Haws 12, noted as: The Tahitian Longline Method, Floating rafts, and Underwater
trestles.
In the context of Tanzania including Zanzibar, about to embark on a new industry,

there are specific factors to be addressed. Some have already been considered and
may be noted under the headings check-list of: Labour; Equipment, supplies and
facilities; Location; Spat (young pearl oysters) source; Grafting/seeding (nucleus
implantation); Marketing expenses. These in addition to other infrastructural and
institutional expenses, indicate the resources and expertise required for the industry
of pearl cultivation, with both short term challenges and long term benefits in mind.
The process of pearl cultivation is designated by the following stages 13:
First step: The first step in the pearl production process is to obtain oysters to be
nucleated. In the early days of the cultured pearl industry, oysters were simply
11 Haws (2002) p.9

12 Ibid pp.23-27
13 Info adapted from: http://www.pearl-guide.com/pearl-farms.shtml
17
collected from the sea. Although some farmers continue using this method today,
many use the more modern practice of breeding their own oysters. To do this, the
pearl farmer collects oyster sperm and eggs from high-quality oysters already on the
farm. The sperm are used to fertilize the eggs, and so create a new generation of
oyster larvae.
Pearl Farming: The larvae are allowed to float freely in the water, under controlled
conditions, until they are a few weeks old. In the wild, the larvae would then attach
themselves to a rock or similar object, so the farmers provide “collectors” for this
purpose. Over a period of a few months, the larvae develop into baby oysters. They
are generally then moved into a separate "nursery" area of the farm. Here they are
tended for around 1-2 years, until they have grown sufficiently large to be nucleated.
Nucleation: The process of nucleation is a surgical procedure, whereby a foreign

object is implanted into the oyster. This object causes irritation, which the oyster
counteracts by secreting nacre to surround the object; this produces the pearl.
Saltwater oysters are generally nucleated using a "bead", prepared from mother-of-
pearl. First, the bead is surrounded by a small piece of mantle tissue taken from a
donor oyster. The bead and tissue are then implanted into the oyster's gonad. The
bead serves as a mold, or nucleus, around which the pearl develops. The resulting
pearl will contain the bead at its center and will tend to develop in the same general
shape as the original bead. The bead can be detected in the final pearl by x-rays.
Pearl growing: After nucleating, the oysters are given a few weeks to recover from
the surgery. During this time, some of the oysters may reject and expel the implanted
nuclei; others may become sick or even die. Most, however, will fully recover. The
oysters are then placed in cages or nets and moved into the oyster bed, where they
will be tended as the pearls develop. Depending on the type of oyster, this process
can require anywhere from a few additional months to several more years...
18
Harvesting: After the pearls have been allowed to develop fully, they must be
harvested. After the pearls are extracted from the oysters, they are washed, dried,
and sorted into general categories. Sometimes, the pearls are polished by tumbling
in salt and water. The pearls are then sold to jewellers, manufacturers, and pearl
dealers.
In view of the current situation of Tanzania being a newcomer to the industry of pearl
cultivation, the production of Mabé Pearls (“half-pearl”) can be regarded as a suitable
product. A relatively shorter time of 9 – 12 months is required before harvesting and
as Haws notes, “the buyer can tell you how to prepare the mabe for harvest. In some
cases, they may want you to send the entire shell without cutting out the half-pearl.
However, if you can cut them out yourself it is more profitable to you because you
can use the remaining parts of the shell for production of handicrafts” 14. Harriman et
al (2010) also note advantages which indicate the relatively easy production process
that can be mastered by everyone.
OUTSTANDING VALUE OF PEARL
Around the world high quality pearls are valued. As such, pearl farming remains an
attractive business. The product is light weight and non-perishable. In this industry
only 5-10% of the pearls harvested are likely to be “high gem quality” 15. This is
therefore a highly competitive business in which the marketing of “gems” in which
value added products are an advantage. Haws notes that, “although not as valuable
as a round pearl, it is easier to reliably produce mabe” 16. For a small start-up industry
this option also seems to offer an opportunity to develop skills and special products
that may help to establish a particular market presence or brand, in a location such
as Zanzibar, Mafia and Kilwa. These products may well find a special place in the
international market. Equally there are no doubt opportunities to be considered within
the national tourist industry as well as other sectors regionally and elsewhere, in the
14 Ibid p.62
15 Ibid p.8
16 Ibid p.59
19
craft and jewelry markets. Haws also notes that it is possible to have “face cream
made with scraps of nacre from pearl oyster shells” 17, another value added product.
In a study by Tetsu Yamamoto and Hideyuki Tanaka, “Potential of Commercial

Development of Mabe Pearl Farming in Vava’u Islands, Kingdom of Tonga” 18, it was
observed that:
“Of the total production of pearls, a ratio of the finest pearls, medium-quality pearls
and poor-quality pearls would be in general 1:1:1. This ratio of quality averages apply
in Japan, but the consultant estimates that almost similar ratio can be obtained in
Vava'u. The poor-quality pearls must be crashed. Its powder may have some
commercial value. For instance, 250,000 mother-of-pearls could produce at least
750,000 Mabe pearls. Out of these, one third, i.e. 250,000 pearls would be the best
quality pearls. If these were sold at the average price of US$30 per piece, its sale
would be of US$7.5 million. An additional revenue would be obtained from the sales
of medium-quality pearls and Mabe shells as well.
These observations provide an indication of the economy of pearl farming.

Deductions can be made with comparable figures and facts from the Mafia, Kilwa
and Zanzibar context, as to the potential and viability of producing Mabe with
favourable outcomes. As in the case of Tonga, the favourable realisation of the
industry’s potential is very much linked to an appropriate “development concept and
strategy”. Yamamoto and Tanaka indicate the following considerations:
 “Understanding of role of aquaculture development” in relation to the

management of coastal fisheries resources.
 “Economic impact” on various sectors of the economy, and in the case of
Zanzibar, Mafia and Kilwa on communities and the lives of women.
17Ibid p.65
18Tetsu Yamamoto and Hideyuki Tanaka (1997) SOUTH PACIFIC AQUACULTURE DEVELOPMENT
PROJECT (PHASE II) FOOD AND AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION OF THE UNITED NATIONS
(GCP/RAS/116/JPN), Suva, Fiji.
20
These are of particular relevance to Tanzania and the study also reiterates an
underlying requirement that, “government should understand that pearl farming
industry development requires a long-term approach. It is impossible to formulate
such industry in a short period. Time is necessary to build up a base for the future
development.” This includes the harnessing of investment, expertise and an

appropriate business model.
GLOBAL TRENDS
Today, it can be generally agreed that even as natural pearls remain a rarity, cultured
pearls have maintained the long-held fascination with pearls. Peals remain a highly
valued and very lucrative sector of the gems and jewelry market. Leading jewelers in
London’s Hatton Gardens can quote regular retail prices ranging from one hundred
to well over a thousand pounds sterling for an assortment of pearl items including
earrings, bracelets, necklaces, cuff links, pendants, broaches, rings and pendants.
From the perspective of Tanzania, there is however the concerns of a start-up

industry located in a developing country. From a location such as this, the global
trends must be considered with particular reference to prevailing economic
strategies. These as current policies indicate, are formulated within the framework of
initiatives aimed at the alleviation of poverty and other social problems.
The UN’s “Report on the World Situation 2010”, Rethinking Poverty reiterates that
since the World Summit for Social Development in 1995 “Poverty eradication has
since become the overarching objective of development, as reflected in the
internationally agreed development goals, including the Millennium Development
Goals, which set the target of halving global extreme poverty by 2015” 19 . In
reviewing these objectives it is generally agreed that poverty levels remain
“stubbornly – unacceptably – high in sub-Saharan Africa”. There is a significant
consensus that more critically, poverty in sub-Saharan Africa has been on the
19 Rethinking Poverty: Report on the World Social Situation 2010, United Nations Publication Sales No.
E.09.IV.10, ISBN 978-92-1-130278-3, United Nations, 2009, p.iii
21
increase. These views are part of an acknowledgement that, as Rethinking Poverty

underlines, there is a need for a “rethinking of poverty and its eradication”.
In effect, not only is there the need to rethink poverty and its eradication, but by
implication the whole question of “development” and the implementation of policies
and initiatives designed to serve its purpose. In arguing that “poverty reduction is not
development” 20, Rick Rowden frames a persuasive discussion within the context of
the global politics of development economics and its associated issues of “foreign
aid”, “poverty reduction”, “poverty eradication” and “development assistance”. With
reference to much that shapes the background of the UN report, Rowden notes that,
“the record has shown that by themselves markets cannot determine the direction of
development, and cannot deliver growth and redistribution, job creation and social
protection” 21. Further, the evidence also suggests that economic growth does not
necessarily mean poverty reduction or the expansion of the economy into the value-
added activities of manufacturing or services, dominant assumptions need to be
challenged. As such, the discussion therefore indicates a need to “re-examining the
definition of ‘development’ with a clearer understanding that poverty reduction is the
result of successful economic development, not a replacement of it” 22.
Rethinking Poverty 23 therefore provides a current framework for understanding global

trends that would be relevant to national policies, and provide contextual references
for the consideration of the benefits and viability of new initiatives such as “pearl
farming in Tanzania”. The critical factors involve all aspects pertaining to the
harnessing of investment, acquiring and developing expertise, and an appropriate
business model. These can be identified with the considerations of “sustainable
development and structural transformation involving sustained growth, employment
and incomes, with inclusive development which benefits people living in poverty” 24
that is recommended for current policy approaches to development initiatives.
20 Rick Rowden (2010) “Poverty reduction is not development” in Review of African Political Economy, Vol.
37 No. 126, 503 - 516.
21 Ibid p.505
22 Ibid p.514
23 Rethinking Poverty: Report on the World Social Situation 2010, UN.
24 Executive Summary - Rethinking Poverty: Report on the World Social Situation 2010, UN, p.6
22
NATIONAL FRAMEWORK ON PEARL ENTREPRENEURSHIP
In Tanzania, NSGRP II 25 (also known as MKUKUTA II) is an update of the earlier

MKUKUTA I.
The policy framework outlined in the current document has been appropriately
informed by “the global financial and economic crisis of 2008-2009 as well as studies
conducted”. The changing global environment, as well as new regional
developments, has also impacted on the perspective of the document.
NSGRP II/ MKUKUTA II include a reassessment “Poverty and the Challenges of

income Distribution”. In addressing the identified challenges, three areas – “clusters”
– of action have been delineated around: “Growth and Reduction of Income Poverty”,
“Improving Quality of Life and Social Well Being”, “Good Governance and
Accountability”. The interdependency of the three “clusters” across sectors, and state
institutions is recognized as being essential to implementation, outcome and
benefits. Overall, it is indicated that, “...initial policy should be directed towards
developing Tanzania’s economic growth through the creation of a detailed long term
growth and development plan and promoting private sector growth”.
With particular reference to the goal of reducing poverty, this is to be done “by
promoting inclusive, sustainable, and employment enhancing growth” 26. As one of
the areas of focus within context of “Growth and Reduction of Income Poverty”
(Cluster I), agriculture and “micro, small and medium enterprises” are being given
priority. “Women and youth” are also targeted as a constituency where the “creation
of productive and decent employment” needs to be ensured along with other
objectives designated by “Improvement of Quality of Life and Social Well-being” and
“Governance and Accountability”.
25National Strategy for Growth and Reduction of Poverty, United republic of Tanzania, 2010
26Summary Ch. IV: The Strategy, Goal 2, National Strategy for Growth and Reduction of Poverty, United
republic of Tanzania, 2010
23
All of the above are mirrored in “The Zanzibar Strategy for Growth and Reduction of
Poverty: 2010 - 2015” (ZSGRP II/ MKUZA II). Similarly updating the “Zanzibar
Strategy for Growth and Reduction of Poverty 2007-2010”, the specific
circumstances of the Zanzibar islands inform the perspective of the document.
Importantly, “Growth and Reduction of Income Poverty” has been defined around the
broad objective “...to achieve and sustain pro-poor growth”, and “...(T)o this end three
goals were spelt out, namely, the creation of an enabling environment for growth; the
promotion of sustainable pro-poor and broad-based growth and; the reduction of
income poverty and the attainment of overall food security” 27. Within the focus on
“agriculture”, the importance of fisheries and aquacultural activity – namely “seaweed
farming” - is recognised as important activity for “for economic and social
development in Zanzibar” 28. By extension, it is also recognised that, “...(T)he coast
and its resources are Zanzibar’s most valuable assets if used appropriately, could
help sustain the present and future generations” 29.
The potential for SMEs recognises certain “constraints” 30 but there is an expressed
commitment to address these “towards increasing Zanzibar’s industrial
competitiveness and hence exports”.
Overall, it is acknowledged that, “...(B)ecause poverty is multidimensional, income

alone cannot serve as an adequate measure for assessing poverty reduction
interventions. Improved access to education, water and health services and
reduction in maternal, child mortality and morbidity, increase in life expectancy and
an expansion of democratic space are some of the other dimensions of welfare that
are important” 31.
For Zanzibar, MKUZA II is now the principle policy framework. This provides new
perspectives for bring into being current initiatives for development and the reduction
of poverty. With the noted inter-sectorial links and interdependency, and the need for
27 MKUZA II, p, 19
28 Ibid p.25
29 Ibid p.26
30 Ibid pp.28-29
31 Ibid p.35
24
more inclusive consideration in relation to sustainability, a new significance is being

brought to bear on the role of SMEs and environmental concerns. Zanzibar already
has in place a “Small and Medium Enterprises (SME) Policy” (2009). Equally, there is
also in existence The United Republic of Tanzania “National Environmental Policy”
(1997) and the “National Micro-Finance Policy” (2000). Even as aspects of each may
resonate within MKUZA II for example, each can considered in terms of their detail in
relation to current perspectives on development and poverty reduction policy.
Another document of relevance to environmental issues is the “Strategic Action

Programme (SAP)” 32, which with its “Western Indian Ocean” focus has particular
significance for Zanzibar.
EXISTING SITUATION
MKUZA II, recognises that,
Zanzibar’s GDP at market price stands at TZS 878,403 Million and the per capita
income is estimated to be USD 557 as of 2009. The annual GDP growth rate in 2009
was 6.7 per cent. Compared to developed countries, it is clear that Zanzibar is poor
and has a relatively very small economy. The Household Budget Survey data of
2004/2005 shows that 49% of the population in Zanzibar had income that is below
the basic needs poverty line. The preliminary analysis of the 2009/2010 Household
Budget Survey data shows that the situation has only marginally improved2, with the
more significant achievement being registered in other areas of wellbeing such as
education and health. As would be expected, the low per capita GDP is also broadly
associated with low relative achievement in other dimensions of human welfare such
as life expectancy, education and health 33.
Further detail on the current situation in Tanzania may be noted in MKUKUTA II,
where it is stated for example, that;
32 SAP: Strategic Action Programme, United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)/Nairobi

Convention Secretariat, 2009).
33 MKUZA II, p.12
25
The key to expanded agricultural development lies in the empowerment of small

farmers by linking them to product chains, market information and access to methods
for improving productivity. Providing access to high-yielding seeds, fertilizer and pest
control, technological innovations, credit for purchasing modern equipment, services
of specialists in hydrology, irrigation, veterinary care and agro-mechanics and the
implementation of agro-processing will diminish post-harvest losses34. Further within
reference to the significance of SMEs, it is noted:
Unleash Micro, Small and Medium Business Enterprises (MSME’s): Twenty percent
of Tanzania’s population is employed through small and medium enterprises,
generating one third of the nation’s GDP. Yet, these businesses face growth and
income generation limitations. In recognition of MSME’s role in job creation and
economic growth, MKUKUTA II promotes the following supportive initiatives:
• Using various incentives, including MKURABITA, to ease registration and licensing

requirements so that informal MSMEs become legitimate businesses;
• Creating financing resources for entrepreneurs living in rural areas;
• Implementing skills development training with technology to increase productivity

and competitiveness;
• Improving infrastructure to support small business development, including access

to power and water as well as office and industrial parks, development and
enforcement of health standards for food service and products and marketing
information; and
• Promoting supportive incubator programs for innovators and new businesses 35.
This set a clear priority in relation which may provide a context for the initiative to
establish pearl farming cultivation in Tanzania.
34 MKUKUTA II, p. 11, Ch. IV: The Strategy

35 Ibid, p.13
26
PEARL CULTURE IN KILW A, MAFIA & ZANZIBAR
Following the adoption of Integrated Coastal Environment Strategy in 2002 36 , national

resource management in Tanzania has been decentralized as a result, interventions by local
and international NGOs and other development agencies have played substantial role to
identify critical local resource areas with high biodiversity in order to provide for their
conservation put to sustainable use of coastal and marine resources
There is an accumulated number of over 20 groups of pearl farmers around Mafia

Island Marine Park, Kilwa and Fumba peninsula most of which have been not been
registered at any time during their existence. Most of them are loosely associated
with government institutions concerned with management of acqua environment and
heavily dependent on financial and technical support of international partners
currently ReCoMaP through WWF and WIOMSA.
MAFIA
Given the physical geography of the Mafia island, aquaculture is one of the
most promising area to develop new income-generating activities. Over the past four
years, joint preliminary research have been undertaken to investigate the feasibility
of pearl culture. The pilot phase on small scale production of cultured pearls in Mafia
has been enabled through collaborative efforts in research by the Worldwide Fund
for Nature (WWF) and Australia’s James Cook University (JCU), in association with
Mafia Island Marine Park (MIMP). The collaborative research has shown that this
form of aquaculture initiative is compatible with conservation efforts and resulted in
several small scale production of the cultured pearls giving jobs to over 100 artisanal
farmers who cultivate oysters as alternative source of income. WWF Tanzania
program office is specifically promoting pearl aqua culture around Kilwa and Mafia
districts in Lindi and Pwani regions respectively.
36 (Managing Marine Protected Areas, A TOOLKIT for Western Indian Ocean)
27
Oysters from a Raft at MIMP Coral Reef of MIMP Training Session for Farmers
key Issues
 Future pearl cultivating would profit substantially if the total production double
 There are no solid plans for the pearl cultivators to learn skills on jewelry making
out of the waste oyster shells particularly for women as this can be done even at
home
 A need to have consensus within each group as to how responsibilities should be
clearly divided
 It appears that none of the group members have any basic computer literacy or
use of internet
 Pearl farmers are not well informed of the logistics and time consumed by
extension agents to find buyers for pearls hence become impatient and less
trusting when payments are overdue. Demand more transparency as to the
logistics of these transactions for them to appreciate reasons for delay.
 The groups have not succeeded in attracting local market. Need link to external
market
 Fewer cases of vandalism compared to Kilwa
 Very weak communication and marketing skills
 Inadequate working tools
 Good basics of farming
 Sell raw pearl
28
 Satisfied with price that pearls fetch.

pearl clientele has not been tapped. So far
marketing attempts are done under the
goodwill of WWF. The problems
associated with lack of proper diving gear,
working tools and pearl business
infrastructure are as grave as the software
package such as skills, awareness,
innovation and attitudinal.
Mafia has a growing number of resorts and

visitors whose potential as prospective
KILWA
Similarly to what is implemented in Mafia, WWF through partners funding has carried
out a number of programs and projects including RUMAKI sea scape program that
oversees collaborative fisheries management, awareness and training, livelihood by
facilitating access to market credit and mariculture and species protection among
other projects.
WWF in the past years (2004-2006) received funds from WWF UK and Japanese
Social Development Fund and presently Recomap to enhance livelihood among the
coastal population. Pearl cultivation in Kilwa as part of mariculture occurs in several
villages around Somanga and Songosongo where small group -based pearl farms
have been introduced mostly in less than a year ago. Whereas the rafts at
Songosongo are safer except for strong winds, most of the rafts at Somanga have
been vandalized, In such situation, it is important that village government advocate for
values that support responsible environmental care and discourage attitudes that are
not compatible with sustainable way of livelihood. On the other side, vandalism and
29
accidental destruction by fishing boats can be avoided by encouraging underwater

lines instead of rafts.
Key Issues
 Bamboo traps can be swapped off by strong wind
 Vandalism could be reduced if groups own working boats for routine checking
 Training received will help to set right price but not enough to market products
 Practicing long line instead of rafts may reduce the destruction by fishermen
 User conflict in the marine environment resulting is destruction of rafts
 Little awareness of local and external market
 Lack of jewelry making skills
 There is a feeling that the village government is not making the right efforts to control
destruction of rafts and law enforcement is not exercised.
ZANZIBAR
The villages around Fumba and Bweleo within the Menai Bay Conservation Area
(MBCA) has been implementing pearl farming since 2006, as alternative livelihood
activity for the marginalized Menai bay communities. WIOMSA in partnership with IMS
and UDSM has been assisting villagers in MBCA to apply underwater long lines, care
of juvenile pearl oysters, pearl shells jewelry and grafting skills for inducing
development of cultured pearls, maintenance of long lines and providing ongoing
support for half pearl farming.
An Assistant Business Specialist who are under the Economic Growth Manager in
Pwani Project - Head office at Bagamoyo Tanzania supported by USAID in
coordination with WIOMSA (Western Indian Ocean Marine Science Association) in
Zanzibar Office. This position held since September, 2010 pearl producers together
with women who make shell craft jewelry for delivering them entrepreneurship skills.
Other business skills especially in marketing activities, such as customer care, value
chain in order to plan price, and promotional techniques with packaging etc.
30
In the interview, most of the women who make jewelry pointed out that their main
customers are foreigners and that they are facing a problem of local market or central
place to sell their products. There is also a problem of getting some of the equipment
locally.
At the moment the groups have been Nyamanzi; and Unguja Ukuu, Kikungwi
mobilized to establish a cooperative as and Kizingo. Currently, these are also
an umbrella for all pearl & jewelry being processed to establish SACCOs
makers in Fumba and Bweleo and to the above villages.
Collaborations have resulted in

continuous training in spat collection,
raft deployment to growing pearl. Pearl
farming program has been developed
and these institutions have
continuously provided training in
business, marketing Menai Bay
Conservation Area IMS have been
involved in conducting research and
participating in community
.
empowerment projects particularly in
cultivation of half pearls and jewelry
making from pearl oyster shells
The pearl farming started as a pilot

project since 2006 by the CRC
University of Rhode island with Maria
Haws and Dr Narriman Jidawwi
Floater of pearl farm raft at a distance
introducing the farming techniques. IMS
have continuously provided training and
supply of equipment.
31
Key Issues
 Pearl farming have encouraged women to participate actively in income earning
activities that is helping their children get education and earn daily bread
 There is generally improvement in standard of living
 Weak government support for aqua culture development
 Total dependence on IMS and WIOMSA to market harvested pearls which threaten
growth and sustainability
 Increases in the water temperature
Source: IMS
The pearl oyster Pinctada margaritifera
ACQUA -CULTURE AND CONSERVATION
Tanzania an outstanding biodiversity due to diverse ecosystem, topography and

climate and is one of 14 biodiversity hotspot countries in the world 37. Acqua culture
conservation is an issue of concern as such, WWF, JCU and MIMP have done
extensive collaborative research to proving that pearl farming as one form of acqua
culture is compatible with conservation efforts. It is also an important component of the
management plan for marine protected area. The RUMAKI project has implemented
programs to undertake biodiversity actions that meet competing requirements and
sustainable use of resources. Pearl farming touch environmental issues that are best
handled with the participation of the communities and public as a whole at the relevant
levels. At each proposed site, the water quality, bottom characteristics, coastal
topography, land flora and other relevant physical elements were surveyed to assess
the technical suitability of farming sites. In addition to this, a land survey was also
made to assess land utilization, soil fertility, river features, etc
37 National Environmental Policy 1997

HATCHERY AND SPAT COLLETION
The common practice of collecting spat is from wild spat collection or buying from
individuals who simply collect spat from the wild for sale to pearl farms. Reliable
source of pearl oysters include importing of seed oysters, cross breeding and
hatchery. Oysters are dying off for various reasons thus, for sustainability and future
development of pearl culture in Tanzania, reliable sources of culture stock and
expansion of current spat collection activities and development of local hatchery
production are part of the immediate goals for the project.
Generally, no take zones have been established as well as use of spat collection
technique. There is also a hatchery from Oyster Creec Company of USA. IMS argue it
to be a very environmental friendly as it doesn’t add any feeds or chemicals. Collecting
the oysters from the wild used now may change once the hatchery starts to function.
WWF on the part of mainland is monitor no take zones. Spat collection

strategically involved in making similar techniques are also exercised.
efforts and testing wild spat collection
as well as experimenting the feasibility
of small scale hatchery operations. The
initiated hatchery breeding especially in
Mafia might seem difficult but there is a
sign of 90% success due to low
mortality exhibited. In Zanzibar
hatchery from Oyster Creec Company Spat Collection Pearls from Bweleo
of USA have been established and
PEARL CULTURE AND WOMEN EMPOWERMENT
Within gender framework, pearl farming and jewelry making ensure poor women and
men have substantial conditions for realizing their full human rights and potential to
contribute to and benefit from socio economic, cultural and political development,
32
taking into account their similarities, differences and varying roles that they play. But
besides giving focus on gender, issues of women empowerment are important
because of past policies and cultural aspects that favoured men in particular.
Henceforth, until men and women have equality of opportunities in sharing resources
and decision making, distinction between gender issues and women issues is
necessary so that resources can be set aside to meet specific needs of women.
A little less than 50% of pearl farmers within the groups are women except for one or
two groups including Chaza Njema group at Fumba where women are over 70%.
Women are natural resource managers in the society thus empowering them is critical
not only to promote gender balance but in aqua culture and marine conservation as
one significant source of poverty reduction. As far as pearl farming groups are concerned,
participation of the women in pearl farming groups is impaired by disproportionate burden of
house chores and production
100%
90% Number of some members by Gender
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
Female
30%
Male
20%
10%
0%
Key Issues
 Unclear roles and responsibilities between men and women in the farming group may
result in procedural questions at every corner. Some steps to take to make roles clearer is
to sign Code of Conduct which also should clarify the division of roles and responsibilities.
 Meetings with various members of the Chaza Njema from Bweleo and Fumba revealed
that opinions differ about the decision to form one big group instead of operating as
34
 Smaller groups under umbrella association. There is a general feeling that some of the
members are not doing their jobs and wait for the others to do it for them hence do not
deserve the share.
 There is no harm for women to learn how to swim and even if diving is assigned to men.
LEGAL FRAMEWORK
The current law on cooperatives is comprised of primary cooperatives, secondary

cooperatives and cooperative federation 38. Cooperatives are looked upon as agencies
through which production can be transformed and are perceived as appropriate micro
financing outlet for rural and poor people. For community groups that are just
beginning, primary cooperatives are of an advantage because members make all the
major decisions in a democratic manner. They are also free to affiliate to any partner
based on economic and non economic gains. They are self propelled and act without
undue government control or external influence. 39
However, cooperatives unions which can be instrumental in marketing and price negotiations
lack the capacity to perform their role40.Commodities which have considerable potential within
international markets could fetch handsome price under a fair trade label if the necessary
initiatives are taken by the unions.
On the other side, SACCOS are seen as innovative type of grass root institutions able
to secure participation of communities at local level and there is a growing interest in
SACCOS as simple form of financial institution and well suited to the socio economic
milieu of the rural setting and poor communities. SACCOS can use an integrated
approach to support cooperation among cooperatives.
38 Report on the Survey of Rural Savings and Credit Cooperatives Societies in Tanzania (2001)
39 Sam Maghimbi, Cooperatives in Tanzania Mainland (2010)
40 Ibid pg 31
35
STAKEHOLDERS CONSULTATIONS
Consultations with stakeholders have played an essential part in understanding better

the roles, prevailing situation and possibilities. The following is a brief record of
selected consultation meetings, focus group discussions and telephone conservation.
MEETINGS WITH EXTENSION AGENTS–WWF, WIOMSA AND IMS
Key Issues
 The government supports to pearl culture is limited to allowing to work in the

conservation area and at times providing their personnel for some assistance
 Opted for half pearl farming instead of round pearls which is an easier
technique. Round pearls should be surveyed in the near future for their
potential in fetching domestic market
 Annual production for each group is about 1000 pearls
 Confident of the quality
 Pearls of Zanzibar are golden compared to silvery in the mainland
 Pearls of Mafia , Kilwa and Mtwara are brought to Zanzibar for setting
 There is no formalized collaboration among pearl farmers although the Zanzibar
farmers trained people in Mbegani and Mtwara who have started to produce pearls,
Also they trained the WWF person to set underwater lines and rafts for pearl farming
 Access to nucleus, implantation tools and supplies is facilitated by extension agents.
Soon they will have to buy on their own
 Market to locals is a big problem but they can be sold to foreigners like tourists.
MEETINGS WITH GOVERNMENT PARTNERS
The new fishery policy is underway in mainland and it is expected that the new policy
from the review of Fisheries policy of 1997 will address acqua culture adequately. In
Zanzibar, following the the creation of a government of national unity (GNU) soon after
the October 31, 2010 General Elections has resulted in the restructuring of key
36
government entities. Essentially, this has meant the renegotiation of Zanzibar’s

otherwise predictable government structure. As such, the components of key sectors,
on the one hand, and the set up of ministries, on the other, continue to evolve. The
Fisheries policy of 2000 is now owned by Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries but
authority consulted is confident that wider aspects of marine culture besides sea weed
farming have been included.
Key Issues
 Destruction of rafts is partly because one side of fishermen feel they will loose
fishing area. Any new pearl farming initiative in other areas should involve local
government continuosly
 The coastal villages had no cooperatives before 2005 and the Department of
Cooperative in Kilwa had to go from village to village to mobilize. It is time high
time for pearl farmers to be mobilized to form cooperative and join SACCOS
despite the fact that politics play big role in these villages
 In Kilwa, there are plans to establish open markets where auctioning can take
place.
 The fisheries sector in recognition of the need to diversify the sector is
reviewing the fisheries policy which will take into consideration of acqua culture
and include a section of it.
MEETING WITH POTENTIAL CLIENTELE
 Jewelers
Already in some pearl farming groups, women are making jewelry but collaborations
with jewelry shops particularly Gold and Silversmith in Zanzibar Stone Town, Dar es
Salaam, Arusha and other potential regions are very minimum or non- existent.
Communication on market demand may establish partnership to share skills and
supply pearls or oyster shells as raw material. Over 70% of jewelers visited do not use
pearl. About 30% know about pearls as gems and only 5% know about the existence
37
of pearls produced in Tanzania but have never used thus, would are not sure if they
would be able to distinguish a pearl from imitation product. The few jewelers who are
aware and use pearls have only round pearl stock bought in Dubai which in turn import
from the Far East.
Jewelers particularly in Dar are suspicious of any vendor talking of pearls for lack of
information on production in Tanzania, lack of knowledge on how pearls are valued
but also due to the fact that the gem market is full of fake products. Dialogues with
jewelers will need to introduce the technicalities of pearl production and to educate on
how pearls are graded. Pearl are graded or valued in term of type, size, luster,
inclusions, shape, matching, and nacre:
Issues
 Jewelers not sure if their tools are similar to tools used in jewelry making using
pearls
 Are interested to find out more on available pearls cultivated locally
 Attracted to use of polished pearl shells
 Willing to negotiate
 Galleries
 Galleries do not have much information on pearl farming in Tanzania but quite
willing to make special efforts to buy and explore market
 Would prefer to buy directly from the farms or appointed Marketing person rather
than middlemen
 Galleries need to be educated about pearls and special efforts to be taken to
advertise
 Galleries often import relatively cheaper products from Far East and Asia.
 Tour Operators
 Some few Tour Companies are aware of local grown pearls but never dealt with
38
 Agree with the idea of making excursion subject to having a consensus and
mutual arrangements
 Public to be well informed on the pearl farming and pearl business.
39
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Because most pearl farmers hope to avoid competition by keeping their

methods secret, the pearl farming industry has traditionally been one of the
most problematic of aquaculture businesses to start from scratch 41.
This is one of the opening statements in The Basic Methods of Pearl Farming manual
and it provides a focus for assessing the contextual circumstances and the challenges
that may be considered in relation to any new pearl farming initiative in Tanzania. The
issue of the secrecy of “traditional” knowledge may no longer be a major factor, but the
reality of a competitive global industry exists. Equally, there is as much, the availability
of skills, expertise and finance, and other specialist “management” resources that
would provide the input required for producing a unique product that would gain its
own value in the market place.
As well as outlining “the basic methods of pearl farming”, the manual also makes a
number of cautionary statements. 42 Firstly, “successful pearl farming requires a long-
term investment of time, money and hard work”. This is qualified by the preparation
time required before the first harvesting, and with the initial outlay, it is estimated that a
profit will not be realised until after the second or third harvest.
Secondly, “production of high quality pearls is the key to having a profitable farm”.
Here it is recognised that the simple but delicate farming process will produce no more
that 10% high quality gems which would account for 90% of the profits.
And thirdly, “production of high quality pearls is only possible under certain conditions”.
These conditions include the application of skills and expertise at various stages of the
process. However, for the specific context of Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar, the ability to
not only sell high quality peals, but also the possibility of bringing added value to the
41 Maria Haws (2002) The Basic Methods of Pearl Farming: A Layman’s Manual, Center for Tropical and
Subtropical Aquaculture, Publication No. 127, p.3
42 Ibid pp.7-8
40
produce of a pearl harvest seems to be a necessary consideration. The Report on

Technical Assistance Visit for Pearl Farming Development to Zanzibar (2010) 43 ,
addresses the prevailing domestic context and provides an invaluable assessment
and recommendations with particular reference to the priorities for a sustainable pearl
farming and jewelry making industry in Zanzibar but adoptable in Mafia and Kilwa. As
a result of a number of activities undertaken in assessing seven objectives:
1) Collect baseline data on socioeconomics.
2) Develop a pearl farming training course to develop a core group of extension

agents and farmers.
3) Assist villagers in the establishment of their small scale farms and individual spat
collection lines demonstrating methods for establishing underwater long-lines,
maintenance of farms, collecting and care of juvenile pearl oysters and grafting skills
for half-pearls.
4) Train and provide on-going support for making half-pearl and pearl shells jewelry.
5) Provide support and help guide formation of business management units for
women’s groups.
6) Provide training in marketing skills.
7) Assist in developing policies to guide sustainable pearl farming.
The main recommendations on this objective for results to be readily linked to the
pearl farming activities are:
 Parameters such as improvement in living standards, changes in income,

conservation awareness, and involvement in the activity should be considered.
It will be important to also survey people not involved in the activity in the same
43Simon Ellis (2010) Report on Technical Assistance Visit for Pearl Farming Development to Zanzibar,
Tanzania. January 26-February 8, 2010, Pearl Oyster Specialist, Pacific Aquaculture and Coastal Resources
Center, University of Hawaii Hilo.
41
villages as a comparison. Another important factor to consider will be the

effects caused by the global recession and recent power crisis in Zanzibar on
tourism and consequent sales of pearl products.
 Improve pearl quality by: placing the nucleus more accurately on the inner shell
to improve color; testing earlier harvest times in order to keep better nucleus
definition and reduce irregularities; taking extra care to not damage the mantle
tissue during seeding as this can lead to shell deformities; obtaining a source of
better quality and differently shaped nuclei; use younger and healthier animals
obtained through spat collection.
 Position the shellcraft and pearl products separately. Pearl products, because
of their higher value and current scarcity can be placed into higher end,
specialty, or niche stores that sell well made, expensive products. Packaging
and display should be high quality. High end hotel gift shops would be an ideal
location for these products. The shell craft pieces may be positioned in lower
end stores but still those that focus on or promote locally made products. Gift
shops in tourist hotels on the north and east coasts may be more suited to
these products. Packaging should be simple but clean and easy to display.
Neither the pearls nor the shell craft products should be marketed in
competition with the majority of the other handicrafts sold on the island.
 Design and production of generic marketing materials that will promote,
separately, the shell craft and pearl products. If these products could be
designed and printed in Tanzania, or preferably Zanzibar, this would be
beneficial as it will be easier to reprint the materials. Research in Dar es
Salaam to see what packaging and display materials are available would also
be beneficial. Development of brand names and logos for each set of products
that can be reproduced on packaging and display materials would also help.
It would be fair to say that with the current pace of pearl farming development in the
Menai Bay, Mafia and Kilwa, there is little chance of over-development in the short
term. However, given the rapid rise in seaweed farming and the resource user
42
conflicts caused, there is the possibility that pearl farms could have a similar role in the
future. Part of the project is to raise awareness of the need for sound policy on pearl
farming and to hold outreach meetings with communities to discuss issues. The
document should be reviewed by relevant agencies and, once accepted, disseminated
to the communities for discussion.
EXTERNAL DIMENSION
The farming and marketing of pearls in the gems and jewelry global market is highly
organised, with well established players already well placed and protective of their
dominant positions. Entering this arena will demand, not only quality products, but
skilled marketing that will be both time consuming and costly. Profit margins can
prove to be relatively small over an average harvest. In view of this, value added
products and a niche market may be very advantageous to the sustainability of a pearl
marketing initiative.
FINANCIAL DIMENSION
The Basic Pearl Farming Methods manual offers a case study based on 2001 figures
for a “small” [3,000 pearl oysters] and a “medium” farm [6,000 pearl oysters]. With an
estimated initial outlay of US$17,000, on a small farm it is shown that US$9,000 could
be potentially recovered, after an eighteen months operational period. A profit will be
possible only at the third harvest after 4½ years of operation. This small farm will be
required to maintain 12,000 – 15,000 pearl oysters “at various stages” to keep the farm
in operation.
In an earlier study based on production in the Vava'u Islands, Kingdom of Tonga, it was
found that “250,000 mother-of-pearls could produce at least 750,000 Mabe pearls. Out
of these, one third, i.e. 250,000 pearls would be the best quality pearls. If these were
sold at the average price of US$30 per piece, its sale would be of US$7.5 million. An
43
additional revenue would be obtained from the sales of medium-quality pearls and
Mabe shells as well” 44. Together these studies and the context of the Ellis report 45,
may provide a framework for reasonably assessing the economic potential for pearl
farming in Zanzibar, Mafia and Kilwa. However, considering the reality now for
instance in Mafia, where each small group of farmers own between one 1 -2 rafts:
I raft takes 9 lines
1 line takes 12 mother of pearl oysters
1 mother of pearl oyster is planted 4 half round nuclei
Therefore annual harvest:
12 oysters x 9 lines x 4 nuclei = 432 pearls.
Assuming one third would produce the best quality at unit price 0f $30, one raft should
earn 144 x $ 30 generating revenue of $ 4,320 (approximately TZs 6,566,552.00 )
ARTISTIC PARTNERSHIP
Because selling pearls is not enough, the marketing of value added products and
establishing a specialist niche market for Tanzania pearls would be essential for its
sustainability and a long-term approach. The Ellis report notes very positive prospects
in view of existing skills and jewelry production in Zanzibar 46. However, a long-term
perspective seems to demand a move away from short “workshops” as the main
method of transferring artistic skills, to a more comprehensive arts education, where
technical and design skills could be more efficiently nurtured and perfected as part of a
mainstream educational programme.
44 Tetsu Yamamoto and Hideyuki Tanaka (1997) SOUTH PACIFIC AQUACULTURE DEVELOPMENT PROJECT
(PHASE II) FOOD AND AGRICULTURE ORGANIZATION OF THE UNITED NATIONS
(GCP/RAS/116/JPN), Suva, Fiji, p.9
45 Simon Ellis (2010) op cit
46 Ibid p.5
44
GOVERNMENT PARTNERSHIP
Pearl farmers in Tanzania are newcomers to the industry and require their government
full support. Although the technology may not be as complicated particularly half pearl,
production takes several years to establish. Further, the expertise of experienced
technicians, and the choice of reliable buyers are vital.
The inter-sectoral approach for SME underlines the prospects for pearl farming in
Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar. Equally, important to the desire to reduce poverty and
create wealth are pertinent environmental concerns. These concerns are also critical
to the factors of sustainability and the expected quality of life which wealth creation is
expected to deliver.
With the Western Indian Ocean Marine Science Association and the Institute of Marine
Sciences already involved in this initiative, the engagement of government agencies
should therefore be pursued with awareness of these concerns, and the ways in which
policies may impact upon this specific industry, both short-term and long-term.
As Ellis 47 rightly identifies, tourism is definitely a sector that offers pearl products a
market opportunity. However, this has to be won, or at least fought for, in competition
with other products including “the ubiquitous Pinctada shell jewelry made in China”.
Instructively, this seems to suggest the need for a more considered partnership with
government to assist pearl products establish a niche market presence in Tanzania as
a whole, and beyond; noting as Ellis does, “the growing globalization of the handicraft
industry” 48. This of necessity should include the encouragement and institutionalisation
of product branding, and the acquiring of “Fair Trade” status.
COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIP
Within the current culture of globalised trade the “Fair Trade” label suggest a more
ethically relationship between “disadvantaged” producers and consumers. The Fair
47 Ibid p.7
48 Ibid p.7
45
Trade Foundation defines its underlying focus around, “helping farmers and workers
improve the quality of their lives and take more control over their futures”49. In so doing
Fair Trade assist producers in countries like Tanzania to gain a market presence and
to be more actively engaged in the trading and benefits of their products. The number
of Fair Trade products is increasing at a rate of “40% per year over the last five years”50
and are rapidly being established in new markets.
Community partnerships in the broadest sense are critical to gaining a Fair Trade
certificate. This could also offer benefits in critical areas such as economic
sustainability, environment, and quality of life.
The Ellis report notes that “...there is now significant pearl farming knowledge on
Zanzibar” 51. Extending this knowledge to Mafia and Kilwa is now a priority. Equally, in
terms of providing spat for the pearl farms, there is also the need to develop, expand,
and promote the collection of spat among “villagers”. This suggests an important level
of engagement where “community partnerships” may be established as part of an
overall and comprehensive approach to pearl farming.
IT AND NETWORKING
Computer literacy and IT awareness among pearl farmers is almost non existence,
thus all the more reason to use a management company or agent that would among
other things develop a sale site that will host and advertise the business aspect of
pearl. For the company to customize a site for potential buyers to access information
and buy online, this could be an opportunity to network with good sale agents
anywhere.
The study agrees that pearl farming in Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar is succeeding
gradually to deliver on a number of its targets and even if there is still a demand to
demonstrated efficiency in resource use. The many uncertainties with regards to future
49 The Fair Trade Foundation, http://www.fairtrade.org.uk/

50 ibid
51 Simon Ellis (2010), p.3
46
direction make it necessary to recommend continued future support unless

fundamental changes are being made. In principle the Consultant sees three
scenarios for technical support and funding options:
Option 1 (recommended): Pursue or finalise establishment of Cooperatives which will

assume ownership of the farms. Each Cooperative will use the business plan as
source of reference in it undertakings. For the farming groups in each district to form
Cooperative or at least SACCOS will give the groups a more formalized structure to
ease resource mobilsation.
Given the range of challenges at community level and weak managerial capacity
within the groups, yet a number of prospects for profound changes in sight, the
Consultant does not think that continued funding can be justified. The Consultant
recommends that while it may be difficult to get immediate solution, but would at the
same time ask ReCoMaP, WWF, IMS and WIOMSA to be open for alternative
solutions through discussions with groups representatives. Discontinuation of
ReCoMaP funding does not necessarily have to lead to a breakdown of groups and
cooperatives under formulation. IMS, WWS and WIOMSA can continue its training,
capacity building and women empowerment focus through other alternative avenues
for funding.
Option 2: Make arrangements on commission basis with a professional

management/marketing company to market and promote pearl farming towards
commercialization and nurturing of pearl industry. It is proposed continue funding for
an emergency operation through the awarded management/marketing company or
agent for a specific period until Cooperatives have managed to get its acts in order.
The SACCOS network can use same management, operational and accounting
system hence reduce overhead shared costs on ICT, human resource, auditing,
promotional etc at affordable unit cost. Inter lending between surplus and deficit
spending SACCOS will assist in intra SACCOS financial needs.
47
Option 3: Find alternative avenues that include finding a partner from the business
community to invest or buy share in the business or acquiring soft loans from rural
development banks.
Option 4: The current programmes supporting mariculture activities should continue to

provide extension support and to assist in mobilizing and managing resources until the
business plan is well underway in its execution. There is a lot of opportunities but the
demands from well presented proposal and justification is required of which the
community pearl cultivators would need technical support and guidance.
48
BUSINESS PLAN
A 5 Year Plan
49
THE BUSINESS CONCEPT
Half pearl culture in Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar started between 2006 and 2009 with
the aim of providing sustainable livelihood for the coastal inhabitants.
The following proposed business plan is looking at diversification in sales of pearls and
value added products for substantial increase in income in order to sustain livelihood
and decrease dependency. Now that the initial start up phase is over, the move to
commercialise pearl farming should be able to generate good income.
The main purpose of the business plan is to develop a framework to base on in

executing a profitable and self sustaining pearl farming on the island of Unguja in
Zanzibar, Mafia Island and Kilwa in Pwani and Lindi region respectively on the
mainland Tanzania. At present it is unclear how unresolved issues are going to be
solved and there is no functional strategy thus, the business plan is proposed to
position itself as eco friendly small scale pearl farms owned by groups in the
community to be managed by village cooperatives and SACCOS. For increased sales,
the business will produce pearls, pearl shells and pearl/shells related products for
improved livelihood. Pearl farming in these poor communities should engage in the
challenge of making it commercially successful.
The business plan model looks into ‘Half Pearl Culture Cooperatives’ established by
synergized groups of pearl farmers that share profound interest in the pearl farming as
business venture. The cooperative is backed with extension agents that have
expertise in project management, corporate finance, business planning and research
with combined years of experience.
There are several possible options as business models which can be established in
compliance with prevailing laws of Tanzania and Zanzibar. The operating extension
agents seem to approve Cooperatives as the model that suit pearl farming as
enterprise in the community. Already groups in Bweleo and Fumba have completed or
are in the registration process. Half Pearl Cooperative shall be privately held
enterprise owned by its members who are in farming groups. It will be directly
50
associated with Agency/NGO/Company capable of maintaining a pool of clientele and

trading partners nationally and worldwide that enable the cooperative to build local
relationship with pearl industry participants.
The other possible option is to go into partnership but this should best be considered
after at least several years of operation when competition locally is high.
Each community cooperative is to construct a small building to serve a workshop/

showroom/gift shop. In the best scenario, it will also serve as resource centre as well
as providing space for agency work.
MISSION
Cooperatives on half pearl culture seek to provide premium pearl farming and services
to the industry; while creating livelihood and employment in the coastal pearl farming
localities, developing communities, empower women and stimulating local and
national economy.
VISION
Cultivation of Half Pearl through Cooperatives envision to be a benchmark in the pearl
enterprise within the next five years dedicating to set industry trend for a socially,
economically, and environmentally responsible and profitable business.
CORE VALUES
A Cooperative foremost believes in members well being through sustainable
livelihood. It believes in supporting the communities they serves and delivering long-
term value generation.
A Cooperative believes in integrity as the guiding principle of doing business, delivery

of high quality pearl and pearl products and strives to make sound profit out of the
business.
51
Members of the farming groups forming the Cooperative are responsible to ensure
marine conservation and preservation of natural resources while recognizing
members’ merits.
Recognize the importance of leadership and business management capacity to

engage in confidence, promote talent and market innovation while respecting
provision of fair return on equity for continued long term investment.
SCOPE OF THE ACTIVITIES
Pearl farming has a lot of potential for becoming a success story if realistic objectives
are set and activities formulated on sound strategies, plans and budgets and with the
right financial control and supervision. Unfortunately, plans need to be less sporadic
to identify and address common obstacles and develop strategies to overcome them.
Currently there is lack of a shared vision and strategy to move forward within the
farming groups. There is no doubt, however, that pearl farming remains very
important alternative livelihood in coastal daily life and for maintaining marine and
aqua culture identity and that continued possibilities for commercialization would be
central to the development of the islands.
The pearl farmers or individuals from the surrounding community may enter the
industry at a number of levels to produce oyster shells, half-pearls, or pearl cultivation
provides opportunity for the involvement of women and provides the raw materials for
local handicraft manufacture, which may include lower grade pearls or pearl shell.
The pearl farmers particularly women or women from the surrounding villages may
use the oyster shells, half-pearls, pearl shell to make jewelry or the raw materials for
local handicraft manufacture including lower grade pearls. The use of pearl oyster
shells in cosmetics and other value addition is an area that extension agents can
research on for the business community to come in.
The business encompasses:
1. Small scale pearl farm for each group to produce and sell pearls to
52
individuals. (Retail outlets)
2. Selling pearls and products to resorts and high end hotels
3. Workshop/showroom/gift shop
4. Selling of pearls to jewelers for the local market.
5. Retailing through craft marketing and cooperatives outlets
6. Sell of oyster shells and related products to galleries
7. Selling oyster shells jewelry
8. Retailing and wholesaling abroad directly and via internet
9. Excursions
10. Auctioning
11. Selling pearls and pearl shells as raw material to craft makers.
By breeding good quality half pearls, Tanzania like Japan, Fuji, Mynamar need to
secure local market just as much as the foreign market.
 Retail Outlets
Retail sales can take place at the farm site, or direct sales to jewelers, galleries,
crafts makers or tourists.
 Tourist Resorts
Pearls, pearl jewelry, and souvenir out of sea shells can be sold to the tourist
resorts in Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar and in the case of excess stock, these can
be diverted to resorts elsewhere in Tanzania.
 Workshop/Showroom/Gift Shop
A simple but well designed house to occupy a workshop, a showroom and
gift/souvenir shop is most ideal to attend to various visitors particularly the
tourists for increased sales. The workshop with adequate tools will be for live
demonstration in jewelry making by the women groups as well as exchanging
ideas, skills and craftsmanship with other crafts persons in the islands. Jewelry
53
and other related souvenir or merchandice will be put for sale and the
showroom exhibiting these local talents. The Cooperative whose role in the
building is to facilitate and coordinate the sale of pearls and jewelry items to the
targeted markets. The Cooperative operates a workshop, showroom and a gift
shop but also link with management company/agent to promote selling,
marketing and promotion.
For the Bweleo and Fumba community, part of their pipeline project through
IMS and WIOMSA is getting support to construct a Community Resource
Centre. Normally a Resource Centre is not conceived as a business, rather as
a community initiative, or even a club. However, it will stand much more chance
of success if it adopts the Business Planning process. As a new small business
should, it will need to combine that process with the proposed use of a
workshop and a gift shop to compliment the usual good practice of community
development.
 Use of Professional Marketing Person/Management Agency
Pearl farmers in the coastal areas of Mafia, Kilwa and Unguja have very limited
accessibility to market. The use of a professional person or agency to market pearls
need to be considered. The agent should facilitate market promotion and sale of pearl
and pearl products to target market.
 Selling Pearl Oyster Shells Jewelry
In general the jewelry makers of the Fumba peninsula are making good progress.
Some individuals are selling high quality products to tourists at Kwale Island and
also in Stone Town. The major recommendation at this point is to work with jewelry
makers who are already making pieces (communities of Nyamanzi, Fumba and
Bweleo) to improve their quality through accurate cutting and finishing using fine
grade sand papers and buffing compounds. One problem is the additional cost of
54
the polishing compounds and fine grade sandpapers. Once jewelry makers see the
extra revenue and increased sales.
Pearl Oyster shell earrings by women at Fumba
At Unguja Ukuu and some part of Kilwa or Mafia, where jewelry making is just getting
started some more extensive training is necessary. There are now community
members who have more than adequate skills to conduct this training and it is
recommended to use these individuals in conjunction with the extension agents to
conduct trainings in the future, rather than expatriates. Quality control can always be
provided during routine visits, by expert team members from overseas. There is
adequate shell available in Unguja Ukuu for jewelry making as women collect the
oysters to sell on a daily basis.
As shell craft jewelry becomes more integrated in daily life of communities and
income increases it may be beneficial to consider introduction of carving techniques
into the jewelry making. Produce a poster or brochure on local jewelry making
techniques, using the written text provided as a template. Use photographs taken
during the training sessions to illustrate methods.
The jewelry and pearl farming initiatives in the Menai Bay area have the potential to
greatly improve the lives of rural communities. The success of the these projects will
rely on a smooth transition to the private sector and training that provides the
communities with the skills to make, value and market their own products. Without
55
this the communities will fall into the poverty trap, which was evident in the low
prices currently being paid for such high priced commodities as sea cucumbers
and Pinctada shell. The formation of groups will play a large role in providing
training and support for starting these activities but it is likely that the success of
the industry will eventually be more dependent on individual businesses run by
families or small groups of individuals.
In looking at lessons learned from other parts of the world, and also in most
successful sustainable industry, it is unrealistic to imagine that every person who
makes jewelry will be a successful entrepreneur who can market their own product.
Many people prefer to work for a daily wage and to paid less for their product than
to worry about marketing their own products.
 Wholesaling
Increasing sales by wholesaling require establishment of links with wholesalers as

this will create a market presence which if strategically implemented will create a
brand recognition of pearls. The approach will as well reduce logistics of retailing
 Excursions
As the main targeted consumers remain to be tourists, there should be designated

tour to increase self worth and awareness to tourists. Organized tours will assist to
bring visitors to the farm sites by liasing with tour operators to organize tours at
reasonable fee.
 Auctioning
Auction is another strategy that could expand on sales. It may take some time
to produce enough pearls to hold an auction, so newcomers will probably have
to deal with a buyer on a private settlement basis. The choice of the buyers is
most important, because buyers can take advantage of a newcomer's
inexperience. Producers should have an established organization to control the
total harvest and to act as liaison to avoid any unnecessary loss to the
56
producers. In this approach, it is important to get all the producers' cooperation,

gather the total harvest, and hold one unified, controlled auction. When auction
is held on an open basis, producers are certainly able to gain higher returns. If,
however, the producers deal directly with the buyers, they would be limited in
making saleable lots, and any lack of experience would surely be
disadvantageous.
 Selling pearls and pearl shells as raw material to craft makers.

Retailing through craft marketing and cooperatives outlets enhance sales as
well as creativity.
.
SWOT ANALYSIS
Pearl farming has a valuable inventory of strengths that will help it succeed. These
strengths include knowledgeable members’ clear vision of the market needs.
Strengths are valuable, but it is also important to realize the weaknesses. These
weaknesses include a dependence on quickly changing technology.
The SWOT analysis provides us with an opportunity to examine the internal strengths
and weaknesses. It also allows us to examine the opportunities presented to pearl
farming and marketing services as well as potential threats.
 Strengths
 Reliable and good farming handling and post harvest technologies

 Good quality pearls
 First mover advantage with no direct competition
 Relatively fair pearl farming experience and knowledge
 Good Location
 Affordable Price to encourage expansion
 Cultural sensitive
 High quality professional support.
 Good alternative income opportunity
57
 Quality sea water

 Enthusiasm to expand revenue earning opportunities
 Ideal marine and terestial habitat
 High value of final products
 Weaknesses
 A dependence on fast information outlets and changing technology demand a

balance technology needs with the other needs of the business.
 Financials weakness
 Competitive weaknesses
 Inadequate resources to invest in high keep up
 Small volume of production to fulfill international market demands
 Lack of unique selling point.

 Weak communication skills
 Information gap between what is happening at the field and what is known by
potential customers
 Absence of pearl processing techniques and other value addition facilities
 Inadequate organized marketing system by farmers
 No strong association for pearl farmers
 Weak coordination among pearl farming groups
 Weak mariculture infrastructure
 Opportunities
 Growing market developments

 Technology development and innovation
 Increased usage of processed pearls
 Global influences
 World market demand for high quality pearls
 Connection and contact to markets
58
 Favorable government policies to support sub sector

 Value addition to jewelry, souvenir
 Availability of information and data
 Harmonization with other sectors and businesses
 Modernization of pearls and jewelry making industry
 Intent to improve the livelihood of poor pearl farmers
 Growing population of daily internet users and web based services
 Social bonds fostered by new internet communities
 Alternative business opportunity for coastal zone
 Growing technical and extension capacity
 Job creation
 Pearls are gaining recognition as assets
 Threats.
 Vandalism of rafts by fishermen in some of the villages

 High competition from producers in the rest of the world including India,
Indonesia, China, Australia, USA and Japan
 Changing technologies.
 High transaction costs
 Very little usage of IT facility
 Little market information
 Emerging local competitors
 No specific aqua culture policy
 Heavy winds
59
SOME KEY SUCCESS FACTORS
POLICY FRAMEWORK
In utilizing the water effectively, WWF and WIOMSA have settled pearl farming zones
in MIMP and Menai bay where fishing is restricted in these areas. The marine sub
sector as natural resource sector can go steps to improve resource management by
putting appropriate policies in place. Extension Agents have expressed concern over
the fact that the sub sector is without explicit national policy, whereas the market now
demand effective administration and regulatory arrangements. Sectoral development
plans particularly in support of small scale community based mariculture for income
generating activities are crucial for the sector to evolve in a systematic and sustainable
way.
Progressing towards pearl industry necessitate further arrangements that would

provide exclusive rights in the marked zones which can only be legalized through
cabinet. More collaboration should be settled with departments of fisheries on
coordination of pearl farming zones and licensing.
ECONOMIC IMPACT
Pearl farming industry would benefit and contribute to economy by earning foreign
currency besides improving the livelihood of people and promoting aquaculture
development in the coastal zones. As part of the fisheries sector, pearl has potential to
add to fisheries export commodity of the country. The pearl farming industry will have
an impact on the other activities such as tourism and craft making.
STRATEGY FOR FINANCIAL SUPPORT
It is assumed that out of total investment fund of TZSh 40,000,000 is required by each
farm, members are required to contribute a share capital of TZSh 5,000,000.00 and
seek support to raise the rest. A number of strategies should be applied to raise
financial assistance including:
60
- Seeking grants from existing donor schemes

- Securing soft loans
- Intervention from government poverty reduction projects and programmes
- Financial support from development partners
- Raising share capital from business community
Whereas farmers from Somanga and surrounding villages at Kilwa started late
compared to Zanzibar and Mafia and most of their rafts were vandalised thus did
not harvest nor earned any revenue, the groups of farmers from other areas hardly
managed to do any savings for investment hence all groups need to raise finance.
EFFICIENCY
Support and control of resource use has been quite effective through extension
agents. As the programme under ReCoMaP support end, and farms would be
operating in a kind of state of emergency, expenses should not go out of hand leading
to the further financial gap, it will take time for the farms or cooperatives to stand firm
and to build the right capacity to implement activities efficiently. Skills are required for
planned activities to be budgeted correctly without making oversight of the necessary
expenses.
MANAGING REVENUE
Earning money from product require proper way of managing revenue. Formalizing
business will require the services of a Company dedicated to advice on managing
revenue and pricing to give way to the many opportunities that a growing business is
likely fare on the many levels of services ranging from local to regional and
international set. There have been literally very little attempts to keep financial records
and monitor financial effects of activities and thus few lessons to be learned to guide
investment.
EFFECTIVENESS
61
Each farm as an institution in itself should have clear goals that would be merged in
the cooperative or SACCOS. The farms have not been able to set clear goals from
the beginning to effectively promote business. One problem related to effectiveness is
that goals for various sub-activities have been set without the necessary realism in
strategies and clarity in how to reach them. On the capacity side, lack of effectiveness
can largely be attributed to absence of the right roles with the right knowledge or skills.
The various trainings provided to the groups have to give lessons with regards to
effective management, sales techniques and savings for reinvestment.
PARTNERSHIP
The question of broadening the funding base should continue to be on the agenda for
now. There are several attempts to attract new donors in connection with the proposed
building to occupy the workshop/showroom/gift shop for each village cluster or
cooperative. A number of good partnerships and interrelationships can be sought with
the communities and outside. Opportunities within MKUZA and MKUKUTA framework
have not been explored to its full potential. As pearl farming requires a long term
approach and high level of investment to develop into pearl sustainable industry, the
government should be aware of the necessity to support in building a stronger base
for its future development. Small farms by small entrepreneurs require additional
capital investment for expansion and refining technology.
QUALITY OF RESULTS MANAGEMENT
Unless the farms as business start keeping records and archive valuable information
themselves based on plans, progress monitoring will be weak or not possible thus
affecting the quality and management of results. The business plan may be ambitious
and will take several years for results to be realized but most of it nevertheless is
obtainable.
CAPACITY BUILDING/COACHING
62
There is absolute necessity to exercise a bottom up approach in problem identification,

planning, implementation and monitoring. Capacity building through training, coaching
and study circles where groups share skills will help to develop some degree of
professionalism to deliver competitively. a number of technical training have taken
place for quality farming and future training has to focus more business related skills
so that groups can start applying proper ways of pricing, innovation, product
differentiation and market pearls. Skills to manage revenue should also be introduced
to give way to the opportunities for the business to operate on the many levels of
services.
SUSTAINABILITY
Sustainability can be measured along three dimensions: economic, cultural, and

educational. Economically speaking pearl farming is a long way from being able to
expand based on its own resources. The sources of income have to be expanded and
revenue reinvested instead of becoming increasingly more dependence upon
ReCoMaP or other partner. Donors may be willing to fund pearl production on a
project-to project base e.g. a particular workshop or exhibition. Few are willing to
provide funds for salaries and other running costs. Funding opportunities for exchange
programmes are shrinking.
Economic sustainability without donor support to start with is very difficult for such
cultural organisation. The administrative cost is considerably high compare to the
revenue they can generate from the existing sources of income. There should be
efforts to look at different avenues of income.
Community involvement is an important element of cultural sustainability as it is

through the interaction with communities the interest is sustained and will live on. In
creating products particularly gifts or styles, Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar each cherishes
their own culture and is a strong part of their identity apart all being Tanzanians. More
needs to be done to cultivate and expand the communities’ own interest and create
63
products that will reflect their cultures or things unique in their places of origin. These
are issues that would also be good to be consider in trademarks or branding.
The educational or knowledge part of sustainability is critical, given that pearl farming
demand specific techniques in farming, harvesting and presentation.
RISK MANAGEMENT
The risks associated with possible closing down of the farms have not been assessed.
One of the critical issues in this regard is ownership of assets which has been given by
donors such as tools and equipment.
LEADERSHIP
The business would not progress save in the presence of strong and good leadership
to keep track. Conflict of interests between the management and governance of farms
with regards to money earned, work responsibilities and the like may result in a
somewhat awkward position among members thus affecting production.
TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT
There is now significant pearl farming knowledge with the main extension agents.
Some other local farmers are acting as para extension agents and are also very
knowledgeable. For the purposes of the ReCoMaP project, this objective could be
considered complete with the exception of the production of the pearl farm training
curriculum. However, there is always a need for further training and expertise and
recommendations as per Elis report:
 Increase the number of para-extension agents in pearl farming so that there in

one in each village and include them in cross-site visits so they can see and
learn new techniques in a hands on manner.
64
 Jewelry making skills were not a major focus of this visit but further training on
making simple mabe jewelry would be useful to Mafia and Kilwa too. Ensure
that the women para-extension agents also know these techniques.
 See if there are any existing pearl farm training curricula available that can be
used as a guide for developing the one for East Africa.
 Facilitate the para-extension agents through cross-site visits where possible so
that they gain a thorough understanding of the processes, especially seeding
and harvest.
 Spat collection still needs to be promoted more vigorously. Without this, the
industry will be limited by lack of animals and use of older animals that produce
poorer pearls.
 Establish a better source of nuclei for the farmers than the buttons being used.
While there is a need to source material as much as possible locally, the mabe
nuclei available overseas produce better pearls. A better solution would be to
work with one of the local jewelers who sell jewelry making equipment to stock
and sell mabe nuclei thereby transferring the process into the private sector.
 Finding or establishing an ethical broker, who will guarantee producers a fair
price, in these situations can help to establish markets and maximize returns to
the community members. This can be as simple as finding a local business
person who wants to support the product or as complex as establishing a
corporation or business to support the marketing of the product. Case studies
have shown that the closer these models come to an actual business,
influenced by free market factors, the more economically sustainable it is likely
to be in the long run. One scenario to consider is that the hiring of a TCMP
extension agent based at WIOMSA presents an ideal opportunity to promote
marketing of pearls and shell products through an ethical broker. The marketing
agent could consolidate product, ensure proper quality control, apply
appropriate packaging and distribute products to various retailers around the
island. Payment could be made immediately to producers using a revolving
65
fund and the organization would be allowed to put a reasonable mark up on the
product to cover the cost of marketing materials, distribution costs and
reasonable expected losses of product. This model could be used for a period
of time with a view to spinning it off to a private sector entity once marketing
channels are properly established. Producers would remain free to market their
own products also.
Also, during the first visit to Zanzibar in January-February 2009 the following
three recommendations that are still appropriate were made:
 Both shellcraft and pearl products should be differentiated from other

handicrafts and sold as a “Made in Zanzibar” and “Fair Trade” products. This
can be done using point of sales displays such as descriptive tags, brochures
and stand up displays. These materials should describe that these products
are made in Zanzibar using sustainable methods that promote alternative
livelihoods for rural communities. Mafia and Kilwa to adopt the same.
 Placing products in stores that focus on local products will also help to
differentiate them from the mass handicraft market. Taking note that most of the
jewelry made by the women are very limited in style and use. Most jewelry are
earrings and therefore should explore also on bangles, necklace, chokers in the
case of jewelry and bags, shell purse and beads in the case of souvenir.
TOURISM VALUE
Tourism and visitors are one key consumer/client group. Not surprisingly, many
businesses in the historic towns of Zanzibar, Mafia and to some extent Kilwa are
tourist favorite destinations. Tourists have access to a growing number of souvenir
shops, resorts, cultural spots, galleries and the like. This is reflected in increasing
number of tourists arrival n the in the islands and the demand for services and
consumables. Henceforth, tourism is a key way to promote sale of pearls and pearl
products and a response to diversify tourism products and the need to increase efforts
to market programs that directly touch people’s live like eco tourism.
66
MARKET ANALYSIS AND STRATEGY
The market analysis looks into the target market, proximity to the customers and the
assumptions upon which to base sales forecasts.
MARKETING STRATEGY
The marketing strategy ideally focuses on promotional efforts that generate consumer
interest for its products for the purpose of earning revenue and other forms of support
for its sustainability. The 3 Cs of marketing – Customer, Costs and Competition should
be key aspects in coming with the marketing strategy.
In order to market cost effectively, the marketing strategy is designed in such a way
that direct marketing tool are reliant on the publicity and public relations efforts the
Managing Company. Some of the marketing tools to include:
o An up to date home page that bear all important information on pearls from
Zanzibar, Mafia and Kilwa
o Regular and targeted mailings to communicate to potential clientele and
multipliers
o Press relations and managing publicity in the media
o Advertising for events and programs where necessary
PRODUCT DIFFERENTIATION
All products of pearl culture should differentiate its services to satisfy the needs of its
customers through a sustainable competitive advantage. Production of high quality
pearls will allow products to focus on value that fetches comparatively good price and
a better margin but still need to be different. The benefit of this strategy is partly
because pearl production can also give focus on its special segment of women
67
entrepreneurs in jewelry making or other related crafts as souvenir in order to target its
services and products. A disadvantage will be the extra cost that will be incurred to
create this competitive edge, but that will be offset by the increased revenues
generated by projected sale volumes. At this juncture, the Consultant would like to
urge on the need to start thinking of pearl processing in the country. Processing of
pearls is not yet developed hence product presentation is affected. As the techniques
are lacking, it would be necessary to send pearls out of the country for processing or
selling them without processing as is the case now. Ongoing efforts by WWF that will
enable pearls to be processed overseas possibly Indonesia and re-imported to
Tanzania for marketing is a move worth pursuing.
 COMPETITION
For pearls to compete, the products will have to differentiate its services to satisfy the
needs of its customers through a sustainable competitive advantage. This will allow
the business to focus on value that generates comparatively good price and better
margin. The benefit of this strategy is partly because the business can focus on its
special segment of women entrepreneurs and small business producers in order to
target its services and products. A disadvantage will be the extra cost that will be
incurred to create this competitive edge, but that will be offset by the increased
revenues generated by projected sale volumes. For the business to be successful, it
will depend on how you approach and follow –up. It is very important to deliver these
services in a clear, no non-sense method. Detail of the internet and web are still
unknown by many small women business owners, giving it the tendency to confuse
and intimidate easily. Creative and homemade products (heritage) which are of good
quality have the export potential.
 PRESENTATION
First impressions matters a lot and it is this context that product presentation is
considered an important part of selling a product to a prospective customer. It is first
introduction to the business and potentially the product. Good presentation require
proper preparation in the best light possible. Display of products sell more and the
68
quality of sell presentation will determine whether prospective buyers would buy from
your business.
Pearls and pearl products demand unique technology to positioning such that they
stand apart from other products on the market. Henceforth, merchandising of the
pearls and related products should target to maximize sales by enhancing creativity in
designing, packaging and appearance to entice consumers to buy.
The person selected to be the sale person of the cooperative need to be trained on
how to present a product not only in terms of finishing and package but how he/she
introduce and present the products to visitors and potential buyers.
SALES STRATEGY
Pearls farming groups particularly from Mafia and Kilwa face logistical challenges with
distribution and sales as they are positioned at remote locations. They have limited
distribution and outlets options. However for business to prosper and grow, they have
to strategise and make most use of sales channels.
 Sales Channels
 Direct Sales
Direct sales are potentially most profitable as the costs of for commission, agent fee
and transaction costs are avoided. In reality of their location, direct sales are limited
due to time required to go door to door and it is in this context that excursions are
encourage.
 Internet Site
With growing opportunities and developments, on the internet, new sales venues have
been created for pearls around the globe. The online market may require annual
subscription fee to sell but opportunity to sell directly to consumers. Classified ads on
the net are relatively expensive whereas if shipping is required, there would be
69
additional costs for shipping or other means of transportation. These costs can
however be minimized if the transactions are carried out by a representing
agent/company.
 Whole saling
Wholesaling may be organized directly from the farm, through the Cooperative and
Internet by Managing Company.
 Through Agents
PRICE STRATEGY
While pearl culture is transforming, pricing should be market driven taking into account
production costs, time invested, awareness level of the domestic market and targeted
clientele. Pricing structure should henceforth base on survey of similar products
elsewhere overseas and the potential brand value. To start with, profit margin should
be lower for it is very likely to pick up as sales increase and awareness enhanced. one
can always reduce production costs to cover up for increase in the percentage of
profit.
TOUCH POINTS
Regular contact with potential clients will ease accessibility and responsiveness to the
needs of clients. Communication to create dialogue with prospective clientele will
raise awareness and better understanding of the availability of pearls in Tanzania that
would save them time and resources to import abroad as raw material for souvenir
and crafts or gems for the jewelry. Pearls may not be as hard or durable as some of
mineral gems like tanzanite and diamond; nonetheless they are of high value for their
luster and scarcity.
All touch points are not created equal. Some will naturally play a larger role in
determining your company's overall customer experience. For example, if your product
70
is ice cream, taste is typically more important than package design. Both are touch
points, but each has a different effect on our customers’ experiences as a whole.
To determine the touch points driving customers' overall experience, pearl culture can
use a wide array of techniques ranging from quantitative research to institutional
knowledge. The methods to be used will depend on the complexity of the products,
commercial processes, and existing knowledge base.
Holding dialogues and interactions with jewel shops will raise awareness and better
understanding of pearls as good alternative to other gems now produced locally hence
accessible for jewelry making. A lecture on pearl production to members of the
Chamber of Commerce for instance, an exhibition inviting jewelers and craft makers or
similar occasions with other interested parties should be ongoing efforts to boost local
economy through promotion and marketing of pearls as aquaculture commodities
besides seaweed.
BRANDING AND IP OF PEARL
A brand is a living memory that exists in the mind of people because it happens that
users take a product or products into their lives, experience it and feel something
about it. A brand therefore change the way people see things, they think, feel and act.
Dominant brands are created out of powerful and often radical ideas.
Branding a product to enhance sale, results in an increase of the number of innovative

packages available for the tourism sector. Branding demand special program that will
create better linkages between the growing tourism industry and other sectors of the
local economy such as agriculture, fisheries, arts/crafts production, and
manufacturing. Should production of pearls itself brand as a network of rural and
independent cooperatives? Supporting mutual trade and shared branding among
members is definitely entry point for it enhances a feeling of solidarity among the
producers. As for the groups of women who make jewelry from pearl shells, they need
71
to begin with, form a loose affiliation to produce and brand their products to become
known for their high quality jewelry both in the country and abroad.
In the literature on product branding, significant attention need also to be paid to the
application of building brand image that has a strong effect on consumer attitude and
should therefore as much as possible highlight the origin of the product. Luckily,
Zanzibar in itself capture historical image that is a brand in itself whereas Mafia and
Kilwa are also growing eco tourism destinations with rare marine products like
mermaid attractive enough to provide trademark. Thus, pearls grown in these coastal
communities should adopt a national brand with logos or trademark that identify as
Mafia, Kilwa and Zanzibar produced. Product identification will be achieved by
applying the brand and logos in all advertising, merchandising and media promotion.
Product protection is realized through copyright and licensing.
It is worth to note that branding efforts particularly for Zanzibar have been introduced.
A study commissioned by RGoZ with the support of WIPO to brand cloves to compete
in world market has been carried out recently. There is also survey commissioned by
Zanzibar Commission for Tourism (ZCT) with the support of the World Bank/MACEMP
to identify and brand Agro products. In mainland, Board of External Trade of Tanzania
is working on branding 5 economic products with support of European Union. These
are valid reasons to start thinking of branding and relevant IP and business tools as
early as possible.
Further, Branding in reference to a legal right over the creation of the mind such as
inventions, literary and artistic works, and symbols, names, images, and designs
whereas Right is exclusive in nature and prevent third parties from exploiting the
property right without consent. Intellectual property (IP) includes Copyright, Patent,
Utility model, Industrial design, Trade mark , Certification & collective marks,
Geographical indications etc. in this case, focus should be on elements of IP that
serve as a marketing tool. There is however inadequate use and awareness of IP
despite the fact that Tanzania has a Comprehensive IP law and has membership to
international IP conventions. In the case of Zanzibar however, there is weak capacity
72
in the government to administer IP and absence of regulations to implement the 2008

IP Act despite a provision to use earlier regulations. Branding is a long process which
take years to build thus pearl culture has to begin redefining a marketing personality
now.
PROMOTION AND AWARENESS CREATION
There are several ways that could be developed to raise public awareness on pearl production
and pearl products in Tanzania.
 ADVERTISING
In modern times, successful business service depends significantly on how you

approach and follow –up. It is very important to deliver these services in a clear, no
non-sense method. Detail of the internet and web are still unknown by many small
women business owners, giving it the tendency to confuse and intimidate easily.
Creative and homemade products (heritage) which are of good quality have the export
potential.
During the first months, advertising efforts in the media and through other multipliers
such as tourists magazine should concentrate on creative ways of minimizing costs
while maintaining impact. Chartered planes operating in the coastal region may be
lobbied for their social responsibility to provide space for advertising or publishing
articles in their brochures /publicity material in its inbound flight.
While maintaining these strategies, other means of cost effective marketing will have
to be introduced to keep pearl business on the map for public preference for quality
pearls, products and oyster shells jewelry. These include popular traditional means of
advertising through public radio and television whose rates are somehow affordable
and their audience reach is quite large.
73
Further, advertising opportunities are available with the expanding mobile telephone
market through cheap unlimiting text messages packages offered by companies such
as tigo XTREME, Zantel MZUKA. KAMILI.
 PUBLIC EDUCATION
The interest action in relation to pearl culture and production must engage the interest
not only of the business community but the public as a whole. The action of public as
consumers and producers, as business operators and as policy makers are signified
at local, regional and national levels. This could be achieved by holding awareness
meetings with target population at regular interval to inform, using promotional
material, adverts and brochures.
 BROCHURES
Special brochures containing relevant and enticing information on pearl farms in Mafia,
Zanzibar and Kilwa to be developed and distributed on strategic public locations,
jewelers, hotels and other hot spots where tourists frequently visits. Local companies
can be approached to sponsor. Information can also be published in media outlets,
articles in tourist guides like the Swahili Coast or in future when pearls are well
presented, lobbying for adverts in pearl magazine to advertise globally.
74
FINANCIAL PLAN
The Payback period method was used to evaluate the feasibility of pearl culture in
order to determine recovery period of the initial investment. It involves comparing
future cash flows (5 years) to be generated by the business in comparison with the
initial cash outlay. At the same time, assumptions were made based on information
from pearl farmers, extension agents, published information and industry sources.
ASSUMPTIONS
 The financial projections are for the period of 5 years
 All financial figures are in Tanzania Shillings
 No depreciation on fixed assets is charged. Full year depreciation is charged in
the year of sale or disposal of fixed assets
 Loans have not been assumed for the forecasted period
 Members are expected to raise equity in cash or kind of about Tsh. 5,000,000/-
 No assumptions have been made for payment of dividends. The availability of
cash reserve from year 3 onwards show that there is sufficient funds for
payment of dividends
 An exchange rate 1: 1.520
INITIAL OUTLAY
 Initial outlay aggregates to Tsh. 40,000,000 is allocated for business
development, promotion and merchandising
 The Business Plan is more for expansion and marketing to commercialise pearl
farming hence, funds can be raised step by step as and when the need arises.
PRICE
Average Price from quality and lower grade pearl stand at TZSh 30,000 was used
Excursion per week was assumed to be 3 times at TZSh 5000 per person.
75
BUSINESS PLAN FOR PEARL CULTURE IN KILWA, MAFIA and ZANZIBAR
Cash Flow Projections In TZ shillings
Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Total
Beginning Cash Balance 0.00 4,000.00 1,988,000.00 8,278,000.00 15,626,500.00 29,761,925.00 55,658,425.00
Cash Inflows:
Members Equity 5,000,000.00 5,000,000.00
start up Grant/Contribution 35,000,000.00 35,000,000.00
Sales of Pearls (Retailing) 4,800,000.00 7,500,000.00 9,000,000.00 10,500,000.00 13,500,000.00 45,300,000.00
Sales of Pearls(wholesaling) 2,000,000.00 4,000,000.00 5,400,000.00 7,400,000.00 9,500,000.00 28,300,000.00
Sales of Pearl Oyster jewelry 1,600,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,400,000.00 4,000,000.00 14,500,000.00
Tours & Excursion 4,500,000.00 6,000,000.00 8,100,000.00 8,100,000.00 8,100,000.00 34,800,000.00
Sales of Pearls souvenirs + raw material 3,400,000.00 4,000,000.00 4,500,000.00 5,000,000.00 5,200,000.00 22,100,000.00
Auction - - - 1,000,000.00 4,000,000.00 5,000,000.00
Sales To Resorts 2,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,100,000.00 3,400,000.00 14,000,000.00
Total Cash Inflows 40,000,000.00 18,300,000.00 26,500,000.00 33,000,000.00 38,500,000.00 47,700,000.00 204,000,000.00
Available Cash Balance 40,000,000.00 18,304,000.00 28,488,000.00 41,278,000.00 54,126,500.00 77,461,925.00 259,658,425.00
Cash Outflows:
Bank Service Charges 96,000.00 96,000.00 120,000.00 120,000.00 140,000.00 140,000.00 712,000.00
Distribution Expenses 0.00 600,000.00 630,000.00 661,500.00 694,575.00 729,304.00 3,315,379.00

Farm Safety & Security 500,000.00 600,000.00 700,000.00 4,000,000.00
500,000.00 800,000.00 900,000.00
Agent Commission 900,000.00 770,000.00 1,400,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,350,000.00 3,100,000.00 10,520,000.00
Telephone 600,000.00 600,000.00 660,000.00 720,000.00 780,000.00 780,000.00 4,140,000.00
Repair & Maintenance 500,000.00 1,500,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,500,000.00 13,000,000.00
Utilities 800,000.00 800,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,200,000.00 1,400,000.00 1,600,000.00 6,800,000.00
Professional Fees 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 4,000,000.00 5,000,000.00 20,500,000.00
Transportation & Travelling 600,000.00 700,000.00 800,000.00 900,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,100,000.00 5,100,000.00
Tax & Levy 0.00 300,000.00 500,000.00 600,000.00 700,000.00 800,000.00 2,900,000.00
Training and Development 2,000,000.00 2,200,000.00 3,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 2,500,000.00 2,500,000.00 14,700,000.00
Merchandise 3,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 17,500,000.00
Subtotal 11,496,000.00 13,566,000.00 16,710,000.00 17,901,500.00 20,364,575.00 23,149,304.00 103,187,379.00

Other Cash Out Flows:
Capital Investment
Building 20,000,000.00 20,000,000.00

Furniture & Fitting 2,000,000.00 2,000,000.00
Raft & Other Accessories 1,500,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,000,000.00 6,000,000.00 11,500,000.00
Spat Collection 500,000.00 750,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,250,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,750,000.00 6,750,000.00
Workshop Tools & Equipment 2,000,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 1,500,000.00 9,000,000.00
Working boat 2,500,000.00 4,000,000.00 5,000,000.00 11,500,000.00
77
Subtotal 28,500,000.00 2,750,000.00 3,500,000.00 7,750,000.00 4,000,000.00 14,250,000.00 60,750,000.00
Total Cash Outflows 39,996,000.00 16,316,000.00 20,210,000.00 25,651,500.00 24,364,575.00 37,399,304.00 163,937,379.00
Ending Cash Balance 4,000.00 1,988,000.00 8,278,000.00 15,626,500.00 29,761,925.00 40,062,621.00 95,721,046.00
78
PROJECTED PROFIT AND LOSS

Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
Sales
Sales of pearls (Retail) 4,800,000.00 7,500,000.00 9,000,000.00 10,500,000.00 13,500,000.00
Sales of Pearls (wholesale) 2,000,000.00 4,000,000.00 5,400,000.00 7,400,000.00 9,500,000.00
Sales of Pears Oyster jewelry 1,600,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,400,000.00 4,000,000.00
Tours & Excursion 4,500,000.00 6,000,000.00 8,100,000.00 8,100,000.00 8,100,000.00
Sales of Pearls souvenir + raw material 3,400,000.00 4,000,000.00 4,500,000.00 5,000,000.00 5,200,000.00
Auction - - - 1,000,000.00 4,000,000.00
Sales To Resorts 2,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,100,000.00 3,400,000.00
Total Sales 18,300,000.00 26,500,000.00 33,000,000.00 38,500,000.00 47,700,000.00

Less: Operational Costs
Agency Commission 900,000.00 770,000.00 1,400,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,350,000.00 3,100,000.00
Bank charges 96,000.00 96,000.00 120,000.00 120,000.00 140,000.00 140,000.00
Distribution Expenses 600,000.00 630,000.00 661,500.00 694,575.00 729,304.00
Farm Safety Security 500,000.00 500,000.00 600,000.00 700,000.00 800,000.00 900,000.00
Merchandise 3,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00
Professional Fees 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 4,000,000.00 5,000,000.00

79
Repair and
Maintenance 500,000.00 1,500,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,000,000.00 3,500,000.00
Taxes & Levies - 300,000.00 500,000.00 600,000.00 700,000.00 800,000.00
Telephone 600,000.00 600,000.00 660,000.00 720,000.00 780,000.00 780,000.00
Transportation & Travel 600,000.00 2,200,000.00 3,000,000.00 2,500,000.00 2,500,000.00 2,500,000.00

Training and
Development 2,000,000.00 700,000.00 800,000.00 900,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,100,000.00
Utilities 800,000.00 800,000.00 1,000,000.00 1,200,000.00 1,400,000.00 1,600,000.00
Total Operational Costs 11,496,000.00 13,566,000.00 16,710,000.00 17,901,500.00 20,364,575.00 23,149,304.00
Profit (11,496,000.00) 4,734,000.00 9,790,000.00 15,098,500.00 18,135,425.00 24,550,696.00
80
PROJETED BALANCE SHEET

Amounts in TZ Shs Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
ASSETS
Non Current Assets
Building 20,000,000.00 20,000,000.00 20,000,000.00 20,000,000.00 20,000,000.00 20,000,000.00
Furniture & Fitting 2,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,000,000.00 2,000,000.00
Working boat 2,500,000.00 2,500,000.00 2,500,000.00 6,500,000.00 6,500,000.00 11,500,000.00
Workshop Tools 2,000,000.00 3,000,000.00 4,500,000.00 6,000,000.00 7,500,000.00 9,000,000.00
Raft & Other Accessories 1,500,000.00 2,500,000.00 3,500,000.00 4,500,000.00 5,500,000.00 11,500,000.00
Spat collection 500,000.00 1,250,000.00 2,250,000.00 3,500,000.00 5,000,000.00 6,750,000.00
Total Non Current Assets 28,500,000.00 31,250,000.00 34,750,000.00 42,500,000.00 46,500,000.00 60,750,000.00
Other Assets
Current Assets
Bank
Current/Savings A/C 4,000.00 1,988,000.00 8,278,000.00 15,626,500.00 29,761,925.00 40,062,621.00
4,000.00 1,988,000.00 8,278,000.00 15,626,500.00 29,761,925.00 40,062,621.00
Total Current Assets 4,000.00 1,988,000.00 8,278,000.00 15,626,500.00 29,761,925.00 40,062,621.00
NET ASSETS
TOTAL ASSETS LESS CURRENT LIABILITIES 28,504,000.00 33,238,000.00 43,028,000.00 58,126,500.00 76,261,925.00 100,812,621.00
NET ASSETS 28,504,000.00 33,238,000.00 43,028,000.00 58,126,500.00 76,261,925.00 100,812,621.00
Equity
Financed Members 5,000,000.00 5,000,000.00 5,000,000.00 5,000,000.00 5,000,000.00 5,000,000.00
Grant/Other Contribution 35,000,000.00 35,000,000.00 35,000,000.00 35,000,000.00 35,000,000.00 35,000,000.00
Total 40,000,000.00 40,000,000.00 40,000,000.00 40,000,000.00 40,000,000.00 40,000,000.00
81
Retained Earnings -11,496,000.00 -6,762,000.00 3,028,000.00 18,126,500.00 36,261,925.00

Profit/Loss -11,496,000.00 4,734,000.00 9,790,000.00 15,098,500.00 18,135,425.00 24,550,696.00
Total Equity 28,504,000.00 33,238,000.00 43,028,000.00 58,126,500.00 76,261,925.00 100,812,621.00
82
Sources of Fund Yr 0
Equity to be raised by
Members 5,000,000.00
Contribution
/Grant 35,000,000.00
Total Inflow 40,000,000.00
Application of Funds Yr 0
Civil Works (Building)
Workshop, Office and Show room 20,000,000.00
20,000,000.00
Furniture and Fittings
Workshop, Office and Show room 2,000,000.00
2,000,000.00
Rafts & other Accessories

Juvenile oyster rearing
longline 500,000.00
Pearl production long line 1,000,000.00
Spat collection 500,000.00
2,000,000.00
Workshop Tools and

Equipment
Drill 1,000,000.00
Other tools 1,000,000.00
2,000,000.00
Vessel
Local work boat 2,500,000.00
2,500,000.00
Business Development
Training & Development 2,000,000.00
Merchandise 3,000,000.00
Professional fees 2,500,000.00
Agent Fees 900,000.00
8,400,000.00
Administration fees 3,096,000.00

3,096,000.00
Total Investment 39,996,000.00
Balance Remaining for Working Capital 4,000.00

CONCLUSION
The results of the planned measures outlined in the Business Plan and Marketing
Strategy demonstrates the ability to generate substantial revenue to support running
costs and provide share of dividend. Now that pearl culture techniques have been
developed under the pilot phase as a research base, further intervention to refine
techniques should be forthcoming. The pearl business in Mafia , Kilwa and Zanzibar
should explore the various dimensions mentioned in the report to allow farmers to
invest in low risk business and jewelry making from these areas and reintroducing as
attractive returns for the members. The additional income generated through the
planned diversification outlined in this report will make pearl culture business closer to
the purpose of becoming less dependent. The plan also indicate that for each farm, a
total financial independence is not yet possible without the initial investment funds of
TZs 40,000,000 as their present revenue cannot cover all core costs. The groups
therefore though their cooperatives will need to be assisted to get funding or support
in kind.
Financial analysis indicate a Net returns over a 5 year farm horizon based on an 8 %
discount rate indicate a positive NPV of US$ 57,000.00 (Tsh.86,639,500/) compared
to the initial costs of US $ 26,315,789.47 (Tsh. 40,000.00/-) hence is an investment
worth taking.
Given the reality, the business plan should not be looked at as something that will
bring high changes with a big bang but rather a reference towards achieving goals in
smaller increments or innovations business. It is more effective to work in favour of the
set objectives by sharpening skills and adapt the market in a cost effective and
practical way. Pearl production has started on small scale -based pearl farms but is
proving to become a significant means for income generation among coastal
communities. Henceforth, in the near future, sufficient space for expansion of the
farms including the diversification of species such as round pearls to be pursued and
as such, ongoing research should investigate the potential for round pearl production
as the prospects for jewelers to purchase are high.
84
Furthermore, the pearl industry provides opportunity for the involvement of women and
provides the raw materials for local handicraft manufacture, which may include lower
grade pearls or pearl shells. As the business grows, additional pearl cultivators are on
the horizon, the existing farms will enjoy the first –move advantage in the local market.
However, pearl farmers as competitors need to be prepared for their entry into the
market.
It can be concluded that to date there is some significant experience on pearl

culture in the coastal areas of Kilwa, Mafia and Zanzibar that we can draw on. The
plan shows positive cash flow generating liquid reserve in the year 3 from sales.
However there is a greater need for change in our mindset regarding the way
business is operated and look at the Business Plan as an integral part of pearl
farming.
There are two contexts to be working on in- each pearl farm. The Managing Agent
aspect, which includes exploring opportunities for commercializing pearl cultivation
while addressing competing interests, roles, required and technical inputs, and
operational obstacles. And the context of umbrella association or a cooperative
where pearl farms in each community are members knowing government,
extension agents and development partners are interested parties in funding
Through them, a farm or group of farms would need funding in the total amount of
Tzs 40,000,000/- at the start.
With minimum possible budget to execute the business plan, pearl farming should
be carried out in an efficient and cost effective manner targeting both tourists and
domestic market. In the process, reporting and monitoring for enhanced growth is
one key way to address poverty.
85
REFERENCES
Reports & Studies
1. Dr. Tom Shipton & Prof. tom Hetch; Coastal Mariculture Assessment Mission, Final
Report 2007
2. Simon Ellis (2010) Report on Technical Assistance Visit for Pearl Farming Development to
Zanzibar,Tanzania. January 26-February 8, 2010, Pearl Oyster Specialist, Pacific
Aquaculture and Coastal Resources Center, University of Hawaii Hilo.
3. Tetsu Yamamoto and Hideyuki Tanaka, “Potential of Commercial Development of
Mabe Pearl Farming in Vava’u Islands, Kingdom of Tonga
4. Caroline Ashley, How can Governments Boosts the Local Economic Impacts of
Tourism 2006
5. Y. Hasada and T. Fukuha, Pearl Marketing Trends with Emphasis and Blacj Pearl
Market (1990)
6. Narriman S. Jiddawi and Salum S. Hamed; Pearl Farming and Jewellery Making in
Zanzibar: Empowering Women Economically
7. Managing Marine Protected Areas: A toolkit for the Western Indian Ocean
8. Rick Rick Rowden (2010) “Poverty reduction is not development” in Review of African
Political Economy, Vol. 37 No. 126, 503 - 516.
Policy Documents /Manuals
9. Maria Haws (2002), The Basic Methods of Pearl Farming: A Layman’s Manual
10. The Zanzibar Strategy for Growth and Reduction of Poverty: 2010-2015 (ZSGRP II)
11. The National Strategy for Growth and Reduction of Poverty (NSGRP 11)
12. URT, Small and Medium Enterprise Development Policy 2000
13. URT, National Environmental Policy 1997
14. The Cooperative Societies Act No. 4 of 1998 (amendment)
Websites
http://www.thedailygulf.com
http://www.samesky.com
http://pearl-education.com
86
http://www.thetravelfoundation.org.uk/
http://www.thedailygulf.com
http://www.sult.com
http://costellos.com.au
87
LIST OF PEOPLE MET
Baraka Kalangahe National ICZM Officer

Jason Rubens Program Coordinator, WWF-Tz
Dr. Narriman S. Jiddawi Head MBMR Section, IMS
Mussa Ramadhan Haji WIOMSA
Hamoud A. Abdullah Project Executant for Mafia
Ismail Juma WWF-RUMAKI Mafia
Christopher Lawrance Soka Officer, Cooperatives Society-Kilwa
Kengela O. Mashimba Officer. Fisheries – Kilwa
Moh’d C. Juma Mnemba Island Marine Conservation
Juma Shaali Mafia Lulu
Nahoda Ahmed Mafia Lulu
Salum Khamis Mafia Lulu
Zeinab Seremala Najali family, Jua Kali
Said Moh’d Chande Ukombozi gp, Somanga
Juma Bakar Jitegemee gp, Chunguluma
Abdulrazak Moh'd Tujikomboe group
Salama Suleiman Najali Family gp, Juani
Suleiman Salamal Najali Family gp, Juani
Somoe Omar Shikamaneni gp , Tegeani
Juma Ngoshani Mzalendo gp, Kaanga
Hussein Kassim Fakih Jitegemee gp, Chungurumu
Amina Khamis Mzalendo gp, kanga
Mwajuma Haji Msishangae gp, Kaanga
Makungu Sumaila Jitegemee gp, Ndagoni
Juma Khamis Turki Msishangae gp, Kaanga
Fatma Daudi Tabasam gp, Utende
Hadia Ali Shikamaneni Group, Utende
Nunu Nassor Tujikomboe gp,Bwejuu
Sakina Makame Chaza Njema, Fumba Chaleni
Jalali Juma Chaza Njema, Fumba Chaleni
Mwasiti Moh'd Chaza Njema, Fumba Chaleni
Safia Ali Jecha Nyamanzi
Mwanakhamis Abdulla Ali Chaza Njema gp, Bweleo
Ali Makame Mataka Ukombozi gp, Somanga
Maulid Mahmoud Manga Umoja gp, Njia nne
Sijali Hemed Kipundi
Yusuf Machoira
Salma Ahmada Amri Misukosuko gp, Songosongo
Njuma Khamis Misukosuko, Songosongo
Maryam Nassor Misukosuko, Songosongo
Khadija Haji Simai Jikomboe gp, Njia nne
Ali Abrahmani
Abrahman Othman
Asha Mfaume
88
Tumaini Juma
Rehema Othman Mtumbi Mikoko gp, Somanga
Ikiwa Chaza Njema, Fumba
Husna Ali Umoja gp, Njia Nne
Moh'd Ibrahim Mgeni Mikoko gp, Somanga
Mussa Ali Kombo Mzalendo Group, Kaanga village
Mwanakhamis Salhina Mambo Leo gp, Songosongo
Omar Bakari Nguwe Somanga
Zeinab galleries
Farouq Fashions
Kobe Tours
Memories of Zanzibar
S.D Jewelers
Gold Smith jewelers
Hanif Jewelry
Raudha jewelers
Al Jabir Jewelers
Firdaus jewelers
Aiman Jewelers
Al Hanai Jewelers
Al Qadria Jewelers
Marlo Jewelers
89
90

Feasibility Study and Business Plan Pearl Culture

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Feasibility Study and Business Plan Pearl Culture

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Feasibility Study and Business Plan Pearl Culture

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

What is the feasibility study about?

What is the feasibility study about?

What are some of the challenges faced by pearl cultivators?

What are some of the challenges faced by pearl cultivators?

`

FEASIBILITY STUDY & BUSINESS PLAN

PEARL CULTURE IN KILWA, MAFIA AND ZANZIBAR

and long-line method estimates annual operating costs of US$ 7,559,210.53

The study is led by ReCoMaP as part of its mission to enhance sustainable

The possibility to merge proactive consumer engagement with responsible forms of

environment; a clear economic incentive for long-term marine conservation in

__________________ The document is accepted

__________________ The document is accepted pending the changes noted

__________________ The document is not accepted

For: RCU- ReCoMaP

Deep thanks should go to Baraka Kalangahe of ICZM office in Tanzania, Dr

Profound acknowledgements are extended to Imruh Bakari of Savannah Films and

Munira Humoud Said

Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................................................... 1

Summary of Findings and Recommendations............................................................................................................... 40

The Business Concept............................................................................................................................................................. 50

BDG Business Development Gateway

MBCA Menai Bay Conservation Area

MKUZA Mkakati wa Kukuza Uchumi na Kupunguza Umasikini Zanzibar

MKURABITA Mkakati wa Kurasimisha Biashara Ndogo Ndogo na Rasilimali

UDSM University of Dar es Salaam

Brand Is a word to denote the characteristic of a particular supplier

Copyright Is a set of exclusive rights granted to the author or creator of an

Luster The brightness or radiance of light from a pearl. A high quality

Matching The ability of a set of pearls to resemble or harmonize with each

Mari culture Is specialized branch of acquaculture involving cultivation of

The thickness of the pearl's coating. Is a layer of aragonite and

Pearls range in size from a couple of millimeters to over 15

Touch points An interaction with potential customer.

Following survey to determine socio economic status of farmers, pearl farming in

SCOPE OF BUSINESS PLAN

Half Pearl culture through Cooperatives envision to be a benchmark in the pearl

- Appropriate training was conducted by the local and international expertise to

- Local processing capability should be developed at short-term for the sake of

The business strategy is expected to address constraints of pearl production,

In principle the Consultancy sees an integration of 4 scenarios for business

Option 1: Pursue or finalise establishment of Cooperatives which will assume

Option 2: Enter into contract on commission basis with a professional

1 Report on the Survey of Rural Savings

Option 3 (uncertain recommendation): Find alternative avenues that include finding a

Option 4 (recommended): The current programmes supporting mariculture activities

The business shall encompass:

1. Retail outlets of small scale pearl farm products

2. Sales to resorts and high end hotels

3. Small demonstration workshops and a gift shop for tourist on excursions

6. Online and overseas sale both wholesaling and retail

Pearl farming is increasingly recognized as sustainable alternative livelihood for

To achieve these, ReCoMaP sought the assistance of a Consultant who, in close

METHODOLOGY AND DATA COLLECTION

 Primary data from management files and published documents

This model illustrates our four-pronged approach, which focuses on continuing

SCOPE AND LIMITATION

For sustainability of pearl farming, ReCoMaP in partnership with WWF, WIOMSA

The objective of the study is to identify constraints in the development of pearl