Slagment As CO Slagment As CO Resistant Resistant System System System System
Slagment As CO Slagment As CO Resistant Resistant System System System System
Slagment As CO Slagment As CO Resistant Resistant System System System System
System
Presentation Outline
• Introduction
• Characteristics of Slagment
• Carbonation
• Sulfate Attack
• Slagment Slurry Designs
• Applications
• Case Histories
• The Way Forward
• The Summary
Introduction
• BFS
– Glass-
Glass-like nonmetallic calcium
calcium--magnesium silicate-
silicate-
aluminosilicate
– Formed during iron manufacturing process
– When discharged from blast furnace, quickly
quenched with H2O to form granulated glass
– ground to a fineness close to Portland cement’s
cement’s
– consists of Silica (SiO2), Alumina (Al2O3), Magnesia
(MgO) and Calcia (CaO)
– More consistent than Portland cement
– Cheaper than Portland cement
Introduction
Introduction
Typical Composition:
– CaO: 37.7%
– SiO2: 37%
– Al2O3: 8.4%
– MgO: 10.8%
– Fe2O3: 2.6%
– SO3: 0.1%
– Insolubles: 0.85%
Introduction
Percent
Constituent 1949a. 1957a. 1968a. 1985a.
Mean Range Mean Range Mean Range Mean Range
Calcium Oxide (CaO) 41 34-48 41 31-47 39 32-44 39 34-43
Silicon Dioxide (SiO2) 36 31-45 36 31-44 36 32-40 36 27-38
Aluminum Oxide (Al2O3) 13 10-17 13 8-18 12 8-20 10 7-12
Magnesium Oxide (MgO) 7 1-15 7 2-16 11 2-19 12 7-15
Iron
0.5 0.1-1.0 0.5 0.2-0.9 0.4 0.2-0.9 0.5 0.2-1.6
(FeO or Fe2O3)
Manganese Oxide
0.8 0.1-1.4 0.8 0.2-2.3 0.5 0.2-2.0 0.44 0.15-0.76
(MnO)
Sulfur
1.5 0.9-2.3 1.6 0.7-2.3 1.4 0.6-2.3 1.4 1.0-1.9
(S)
a. Data source is the National Slag Association data: 1949 (22 sources); 1957 (29 sources); 1968 (30 sources) and 1985 (18
sources).
Introduction
• BFS Blaine fineness is higher than
Portland cement’s
– ~ 400 – 500 m2/kg for BFS
– ~ 280 – 350 m2/kg for G cement
• Specific Gravity:
– BFS 2.9
– PC 3.2
Introduction
• BFS blended with Cement to form
Slagment
• Typically Slagment blends:
– 60% : 40% (BFS : Cement)
– Ratios range from (20% : 80%) to (80% : 20%)
Characteristics of Slagment
• Denser CSH microstructure
• Lower permeability
• Better fluid loss control
• Higher gas migration control
• Higher long
long--term strength/durability
• Lower early strength
• Lower heat of hydration
• Lower water demand
• Higher sulfate resistance
• Higher resistance to carbonation
• More consistent response with lignosulfonate
retarder (R
(R--15LS, R-
R-21LS)
Characteristics of Slagment
OPC 75% OPC 50% OPC 25% OPC
(Ref.) 25% BFS 50% BFS 75% BFS
Water demand (%)* 26.25 25.25 25.00 26.50
Setting times (min.)
- initial 180 185 210 220
- final 230 255 270 295
Compressive strength (psi)
- at 2 days 3582 2872 1856 899
- at 7 days 5700 5250 4322 3437
- at 28 days 7629 7310 7469 6990
- at 56 days 7977 8224 8644 7847
- at 90 days 8586 8760 9355 8383
Pore size distribution at 28 days*
- total porosity (%) 14 14.4 13.6 13.9
- spec. pore surface (m2/g) 5.1 5.9 7 9.4
- average pore radius (nm) 49 41 30 19
* expressed in % of the OPC
Characteristics of Slagment
Characteristics of Slagment
Carbonation
• CO2 dissolves in H2O to form carbonic
acid
• C3S and C2S in Portland cement react
with water to form CSH and Ca(OH)2
• Carbonic acid reacts with Ca(OH)2 to
form CaCO3
• Carbonic acid reacts with CSH to form
weak and porous silica gel
• Above reactions reduces pH
Carbonation
Carbonation
• Casing exposed to hydrating cement
slurry rapidly forms a thin passivity layer
of oxide
• Passivation is state of steel which has
passivity layer of oxide protecting steel
from reaction with oxygen and water
• Reduction in pH destroys “passivation”
on casing
Carbonation
• End Results:
– Deteriorating strengths of cement
– Higher cement permeability
– Gas migration likelihood increased
– Corroded and pitted casings
– Interzonal communication effected
– Burst or collapsed casings
Carbonation
• Slagment helps reduce carbonation by:
– Forming denser CSH microstructure
– Reducing cement permeability
– Reducing the formation of Ca(OH)2
– Increasing silica content of cement
– Preventing reduction in pH
Sulfate Attack
• Sulfates attack Ca(OH)2, CSH and calcium
aluminate hydrate
– Produces weak and expansive gypsum
– Causes disruptive expansion
– Destroys CSH
– Causes cracking
– Causes loss of cohesion
• Severity of Attack:
– <150 ppm Mild
– 150 – 1500 ppm Moderate
– 1500 – 10000 ppm Severe
– >10000 ppm Very Severe
Sulfate Attack
• Slagment helps reduce sulfate attack by:
– Reducing formation of Ca(OH)2
– Reducing ingress of sulfates into cement
• Dense microstructure
• Low permeability
– Reducing the availability of C3A
• C3A reacts with gypsum to form ettringite,
resulting in disruptive expansion
– Increasing silica content of cement
• Improves strength
Slagment Slurry Design
• Better strength development when
BFS used with:
– finer cement (Class C)
– High C3A content cement (Class A & C)
• For highest medium-
medium-term strength,
use 50:50 ratio
• For highest long
long--term strength, use
60 to 70% BFS content
Slagment Slurry Design
• Replace 65% of cement with BFS
– Reduces resultant Ca(OH)2 formed
– BFS hydrates without forming Ca(OH)2
– BFS has ~ 35% silica (22.75% from total cementitious
material)
• Add another 12.25% to get 35% total silica