Transformer Faults Part-A Notes
Transformer Faults Part-A Notes
Transformer Faults Part-A Notes
Introduction:-
The transformers are electrical devices used for energy transfer by electromagnetic induction
between two or more circuits. Like all devices, fault also happens in the transformer which
causes failures. Any damage to the transformer results in complete loss of power to one system.
The transformer should be protected from the faults to avoid break down of the transformer
which may lead to major interruption in power transformation. To protect it from the fault the
typical faults in the fault should be known.
Faults in the transformers are classified as the faults during manufacturing & faults during
operation.
Reason of development of fault during manufacturing is due to quality of material & process
problems.
Faulty design
Poor quality of material
Bad workmanship
Improper transportation
Sharp edges of conductor
Incomplete drying
Bad insulation covering on conductor
Improper joints or connection
ii) Faults during winding of LV& HV coils:- Insulation poor quality, damage or scratching
results in turn to turn or layer to layer short circuits.
iii) Faults during placement & interconnection of LV & HV coils:- Due to wrong placement
and interconnection of coils result in magnetic imbalance in the transformer.
iv) Faults during core-coil assembly:- Due to wrong core-coil assembly in transformer results
in magnetic imbalance, wrong placement of coil on winding.
v) Faults during core-yoke assembly:- Loose, wrong, insufficient stacking of core due to this
transformer has excessive vibrations.
vi) Fault due to bad insulation of conductor: - Various types of insulation are used as
coverings of conductors. The type of covering depends upon the type of use and basic insulation
of the transformer. It is very common to see a conductor with lost wrapping. Also, the
conductors have single covering instead of double covering. The quality of paper is also one of
the causes of failure.
The workmen should be properly trained for proper insulation of winding – and identify bad
material of insulation during the process of coil making.
vii) Improper joints or connections:- The local heating generated by improper joints or
connections may slowly lead to a deterioration of the oil – if the joints are oil immersed. The oil
temperature indicator and/or winding temperature indicator (both with alarm contacts) can be
used to insulate such problems. Gas operated relay, can also be used to sound an alarm – and
actuate the trip circuit if the condition calls for it.
Deterioration of Insulation
Overloading
Lightening
Line Surges
Moisture
Vibration
High Operating Temperature
Inadequate Maintenance
Loose Connections
Misapplication
Care of Control Equipment
Lack of Cleanliness
Care of Idle or Spare Equipment
Improper Lubrication
Careless or Negligent Operation
Faults in the transformer are classified as internal faults and external faults.
I) Internal Faults
These are the faults which occur internal to the transformer which may seriously damage the
insulation of the transformer and causes break down in transformer. So the transformer should be
immediately protected from these faults.
These faults are divided as electrical and mechanical faults.
Electrical Faults:-
The principle faults which occurs inside a power transformer are categorized as,
The various internal faults occurring in power transformers and their remedies are explained as
follows,
The impulse voltage or the deterioration of the insulation can cause a short circuit to the
grounding of the winding or of its terminal to the core or to the tank. The mentioned defects
can be detected easily through an external diagnosis or an electrical monitoring.
The terminals of the spooled suffer damages by an excess of current (external short circuit,
etc.) or by a lighting strike. Also, the short circuit accidents of the system that accumulate
cause damages on the supports of the windings, by their repetitive mechanical destructive
force, that finally break the terminals.
Oil in addition to serving as insulating means serves to transfer the heat generated in the
windings and the core toward the walls of the tank and the radiators. Due to this it has:
High dielectric breakdown
Low viscosity
If the oil leaks from the transformer tank due to some reason, the oil level in the tank will
drop. In the worst case, the connections to bushings and parts of the winding will get
exposed to air. This will increase the temperature of the windings. This in turn, would
damage the insulation of the winding. Apart from this moisture can get in through the
leak, and degrade the transformer oil leading to an overheated transformer.
In power transformer, the conservator tank is provided with an oil level indicator having
an alarm facility. If the oil level drops below a predetermined level, the alarm will ring. It
allows the operator to initiate necessary actions.
But in distribution transformer, oil level indicator with alarm facility is not provided.
Only a small transparent window (gauge) placed on conservator tank to see the oil level
is provided. It shows the level of the oil directly, being able to see from the outside.
When the crystal is dirty, you can wipe it off with a rag. Periodic checking of this
window is not done in India. So, many of small transformers fail due to decrease in oil
level.
Oil leaks from transformer gasket, if it has aged, lost elasticity and cracked as it cooled
much further than its normal operating range. This is often a slow weeping rather than a
catastrophic failure; however, over a time, the weeping can cause a serious amount of oil
loss.
It is better to use the gasket without a joint, but it is not possible as the gasket is too large.
There are round, square, rectangular and oval-shaped gaskets, but in any case try to join
the gaskets by using a flat portion of the gasket. If this is not done, then there are more
chances of gasket failure. If the element (or a component to seal that) adopted for the
gasket, is not of thin layer or not dried with air – than the oil can leak through the gasket.
Many times even after correct adjustment, the gasket oil leak is not stopped, then the
gasket will have to be replaced with a new one. A gasket with low elasticity such as lead
type must always be changed with a new. Do not use the old one again.
Radiator fins are a common area for oil leaks. Fins are made from thin metal to aid heat
transfer. The downside of that thinness is that internal corrosion due to water ingress and
separation or external environmental corrosion can quickly penetrate and spill the oil.
This leakage must be repaired by welding, to make sure that the heat from the welding is
not going to produce an explosive gas mixture. (There is no need to take any cautionary
steps in the case of nonflammable oil).
Deterioration of the insulating oil
The insulating oil deteriorates gradually with use. The main cause is the absorption of the
moisture in the oil. Each time the moisture is doubled in a transformer, the life of the insulation
is cut by one-half. Failures due to moisture are the most common causes of transformer failures.
Reasons for moisture influx
Moisture can be in the insulation when it is delivered from the factory. If the transformer
is opened for inspection, the insulation can absorb moisture from the atmosphere
If there is a leak, moisture can enter in the form of water or humidity in air. Small oil
leaks, especially in the oil cooling piping, will also allow moisture ingress
Moisture is also formed by the degradation of insulation as the transformer ages
Most water penetration is flow of wet air through poor gasket seals due to pressure
difference caused by transformer cooling. The most common moisture ingress points are
gaskets between bushing bottoms and the transformer top and the pressure relief device
gasket
If in breather the moist silica is not replaced by dry silica gel. Then moisture can enter
from atmosphere.
Effect of moisture
Paper insulation has a much greater affinity for water than does the oil. The water will
distribute itself unequally, with much more water being in the paper than in the oil. The
paper will partially dry the oil by absorbing water out of the oil. Moisture and oxygen
cause the paper insulation to decay much faster than normal.
Due to moisture oxidation takes place. Oxidation results in the formation of acids in the
insulating oil, which in turn, contributes to the formation of sludge.
The rate of oxidation also depends on the temperature of the oil; the higher the
temperature, faster is the oxidative breakdown. Sludge settles on windings and inside the
structure, causing transformer cooling to be less efficient, and slowly over time
temperature rises.
Lightning strikes
System overload
Short circuit
External faults are things that happen outside the transformer, and cannot generally be prevented
by maintenance. The transformers are subject to things like lightning strikes, or other damage
from the outside that cannot be prevented. Since these things cannot be predicted, it is important
to have a plan in place to make repairs as fast as possible. These can also be fairly minor in
nature, but can cause damage to the insulation and cause problems over time to the inside of the
transformer. The greater concern is when something happens outside that shuts the transformer
down immediately.
Those devices that are attached directly to the transformer, and detect failures
mechanically:
Buchholz relay,
Pressure relay,
Oil Level monitor.
Winding thermometer
Those devices that are indirectly joined to the control cabinet which detect failures
electrically:
Differential relay,
Overcurrent relay,
Ground current relay.
1. Buchholz (Gas) Relay
The Buchholz protection is a mechanical fault detector for electrical faults in oil-
immersed transformers. The Buchholz (gas) relay is placed in the piping between the
transformer main tank and the oil conservator. The conservator pipe must be inclined
slightly for reliable operation.
The Buchholz protection is a fast and sensitive fault detector. It works independent of
the number of transformer windings, tap changer position and instrument transformers.
If the tap changer is of the on-tank (container) type, having its own oil enclosure with
oil conservator, there is a dedicated Buchholz relay for the tap changer.
A typical Buchholz protection comprises a pivoted float (F) and a pivoted vane (V) as
shown in Figure 1. The float carries one mercury switch and the vane also carries
another mercury switch. Normally, the casing is filled with oil and the mercury
switches are open.
Here is assumed that a minor fault occurs within the transformer. Gases produced by
minor faults rise from the fault location to the top of the transformer. Then the gas
bubbles pass up the piping to the conservator. The gas bubbles will be tapped in the
casing of the Buchholz protection.
This means that the gas replaces the oil in the casing. As the oil level falls, the float (F)
will follow and the mercury switch tilts and closes an alarm circuit.
It is also assumed that a major fault, either to earth of between phases or windings,
occurs within the transformer. Such faults rapidly produce large volumes of gas (more
than 50 cm3/(kWs) and oil vapor which cannot escape.
They therefore produce a steep buildup of pressure and displace oil. This sets up a rapid
flow from the transformer towards the conservator. The vane (V) responds to high oil
and gas flow in the pipe to the conservator. In this case, the mercury switch closes a trip
circuit. The operating time of the trip contact depends on the location of the
fault and the magnitude of the fault current.
The gas accumulator relay also provides a long-term accumulation of gasses associated
with overheating of various parts of the transformer conductor and insulation systems.
This will detect fault sources in their early stages and prevent significant damage.
When the transformer is first put into service, the air trapped in the windings may
give unnecessary alarm signals. It is customary to remove the air in the power
transformers by vacuum treatment during the filling of the transformer tank with oil.
The gas accumulated without this treatment will, of course, be air, which can be
confirmed by seeing that it is not inflammable.
2. Pressure Relay
Many power transformers with an on-tank-type tap changer have a pressure protection
for the separate tap changer oil compartment. This protection detects a sudden rate-of-
increase of pressure inside the tap changer oil enclosure.
Transformers with oil conservator(s) (expansion tank) often have an oil level monitor.
Usually, the monitor has two contacts for alarm. One contact is for maximum oil level
alarm and the other contact is for minimum oil level alarm.
The top-oil thermometer has a liquid thermometer bulb in a pocket at the top of the
transformer. The thermometer measures the top-oil temperature of the transformer. The
top-oil thermometer can have one to four contacts, which sequentially close at
successively higher temperature.
With four contacts fitted, the two lowest levels are commonly used to start fans or
pumps for forced cooling, the third level to initiate an alarm and the fourth step to trip
load breakers or de-energize the transformer or both.
4. Winding Thermometer
The winding thermometer, shown in the figure below, responds to both the top-oil
temperature and the heating effect of the load current.
This current signal is taken from a current transformer located inside the bushing of that
particular winding. This current is lead to a resistor element in the main unit. This
resistor heats up, and as a result of the current flowing through it, it will in its turn heat
up the measurement bellow, resulting in an increased indicator movement.
The temperature bias is proportional to the resistance of the electric heating (resistor)
element.
The result of the heat run provides data to adjust the resistance and thereby the
temperature bias. The bias should correspond to the difference between the hot-spot
temperature and the top-oil temperature. The time constant of the heating of the pocket
should match the time constant of the heating of the winding.
The temperature sensor then measures a temperature that is equal to the winding
temperature if the bias is equal to the temperature difference and the time constants are
equal.
With four contacts fitted, the two lowest levels are commonly used to start fans or
pumps for forced cooling, the third level to initiate an alarm and the fourth step to trip
load breakers or de-energize the transformer or both.
Magnetostriction and magnetic forces are the main causes of transformer core noise and
vibration.
Transformers can get heated due to a variety of reasons. Excessive heating of the transformer
increases transformer losses, weakens the insulation and may result in reduced transformer
life. The principal reasons for transformer overheating are
Overload:-
Excessive loading can cause overheating. Transformers are rated in kVA. This kVA rating is
dependent on temperature. Some transformers have two kVA ratings. One rating is for below a
specific ambient temperature; say 45 degrees while another rating is above the ambient
temperature.
Excess current in the neutral of the transformer is usually caused by high zero sequence
harmonic components. This can be resolved by proper grounding usually through a zig zag
transformer
Malfunctioning of the cooling equipment such as blockages in the cooling oil circuit. Failure of
the cooling fans to operate in the case of Forced Air cooling systems.
High harmonic loads can also cause heating in the transformer. These loads need to be identified
and suitable remedial measures such as harmonic filters can be implemented.
Sustained Overvoltages:-
Overvoltages which exist for a long period of time can overexcite the transformer and cause
overheating.
Transformer insulation is generally rated for 220°C but may be lower for some designs
including control or encapsulated. Standards permit the temperature of the transformer
enclosure cover to be 65°C over ambient. When temperatures exceed the rating for the
insulation system or enclosure, overheating occurs.
Burned, darkened or damaged insulation may be apparent along with a burnt smell. The
hottest part of a transformer is the coil near the top of the core. Energized transformers
should not be touched. If the insulation is damaged or smoke is visible, the unit may need
to be returned for testing and replaced or repaired.
Check: Solution:
Verify total load doesn’t exceed transformer Reduce size or load or replace with larger
kVA rating. transformer. In some cases fans can be added
to increase cooling and
maximum load.
Verify ambient temperature does not exceed Relocate to area with lower ambient
transformer ratings. temperature, reduce load, reduce ambient
temperature at primary location or
replace with a low temperature rise
transformer. Transformers installed in small
rooms will need proper room
ventilation.
Verify tap connections are set up identically on
all coils.
Verify transformer is correctly rated for Reduce or remove harmonic loads or replace
harmonic load, check for high neutral currents. transformer with a larger unit or unit with the
proper k-rating.
Verify that the transformer’s ventilation Relocate the transformer to an area of better
openings are not blocked. Transformers ventilation. Move the transformer away from
purchased as core and coil walls, equipment or
units and placed in enclosures not supplied by overhead projections that may impede airflow.
HPS require that the integrator properly size Do not install fans to cool a transformer.
the enclosure and cooling Improperly installed fans may
requirements. actually impede airflow and could result in
transformer damage.
Improper Input Voltages Verify taps are correctly set for the input
voltage. Depending on the load and
transformer type, continuous overvoltages or
undervoltages as low as 5-10% may cause
overheating
As the level of oil rises and falls inside the conservator, air enters and leaves the chamber.
The air may carry moisture which may cause the oil to deteriorate. Breathers filled with
silica gels are provided to separate moisture from the aspirated air.
The silica gel is blue when it is dry. It turns pink when it is saturated with moisture
after which it needs to be replaced.