International Journal of Food Science and Nutrition

ISSN: 2455-4898
Impact Factor: RJIF 5.14
www.foodsciencejournal.com
Volume 2; Issue 5; September 2017; Page No. 133-137

Effect on Soyabean consumption on middle aged women

Kusuma Neela Bolla, Shanthi Sri KV
Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences, Acharya Nagarjuna University, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh, India

Abstract
The overall health and well- being of mid aged women has become a major public health concern around the word. Especially
during menopausal stage cardiovascular disease risk are very prominent. So best of our knowledge, we design a study to
investigate the effect of soya bean consumption on body weight, BMI, Blood pressure & Lipid profile. In this study based on the
inclusion and exclusion criteria subjects are selected in randomly, and instructed the selected subjects to follow the TLC diet with
25gms of soyabeans per day with the supply of natural estrogens which helps for the menopause women to combat their problems
during the menopausal transition period. By the final analysis it is clear that there is a significant effect on lipid profile especially
in the increasing the HDL levels.

Keywords: high density lipoprotein, low density lipoprotein, blood pressure, therapeutic lifestyle change diet

Introduction tobacco, alcohol and illegal drugs, social relationships and

Middle age is one of the turning point in one’s life as it brings stress control. Statistics about the main causes of death
many changes. Middle age in women includes the gradual indicates that 53% of the causes of death related to lifestyle
winding down of the reproductive system and ending of the and 21% of the causes of death related to environmental
child bearing years (Vijayalakshmi S, et al., 2013) [5] i.e. conditions and 16% of the causes related to genetics and 10%
menopause in women. Menopause is a natural part of the of the causes of death related to health care system. (Nosaybeh
aging process in women and is defined as occurring 12 M, et al., 2013).
months after the last menstrual period and marks the end of The hormonal changes associated with menopause, e.g: low
menstrual cycles (Lzethe govie S, et al., 2013). Menopause is plasma levels of estrogen and marked increases in follicle
a universal and physiological event in a women’s life stimulating hormone levels exert a significant effect on
occurring around the age of 50 years in most developed metabolism of plasma lipid and lipoproteins (Swapnali et al.
countries (Farahmand M, et al., 2013). It is caused by the & Kalavathiet, et al., 2000). Increase in the incidence of
aging of ovaries leading to a decline in the production of cardiovascular disease is related to many risk factors such as
ovarian gonadotrophins estrogens and progesterones. The increase in body weight, aging process, dyslipidemia, physical
deficiency of these hormone elicits various somatic, activity, mental stress, smoking and alcohol intake. As the
vasomotor, sexual and psychological symptoms that impair incidence of CAD increase in women after menopause. Their
the overall quality of life (QOL) of women (Ensiyeh J, et al., is a correlation some of the risk factors associated with CAD
2015). to the hormonal changes taking place during menopause.
India has a large population, which has already crossed the 1 Estrogen replacement therapy is well established for the relief
billion with 71 million people over 60 years of age and the of climacteric symptoms in menopausal women as well as for
number of menopausal women about 43million. Projected the prevention of osteoporosis and cardiovascular diseases.
figures in 2026 have estimated the population in Indian will be Estrogen replacement therapy during menopausal transition
1.4 billion, people over 60 years 173 million and the improves a woman’s health and quality of life. Isoflavones are
menopausal population 103 million. Average of menopause is a group of biological active compounds that have estrogenic
47.5 years in Indian women with an average life expectancy of and anti estrogenic effect depending on the target tissue.
71 years. The expert committee would like to highlight the (Kaldas Rs, et al., 1989)
problems in the country on the basis of the attitude relevant to Unfortunately majority of women are not aware of the
menopause in the Indian context. These factors have to be changes brought about by menopause. The symptoms are
borne in mind by health care workers when thy are dealing directly resulted from depletion of estrogen level as women
with menopausal women and making recommendations for approaches menopausal stages and some of these women
their health and lifestyle changes (Jyothi Unni., 2016). begin to experience these menopausal symptoms early in the
Undoudtedly, lifestyle is one of the most important factors perimenopausal phase. Clinical studies have shown that diet
affecting the health status, scientific evidence show that the with supplementation of soy isoflavone is benefical in
choices and patterns of life style have influence on the health decreasing menopausal symptoms such as hot flashes (Kyung
status and longevity, lifestyle encompasses various aspects H, et al., 2002)
that some of them include nutrition, exercise, self care, use of With the increasing life expectancy women spends almost a

133
International Journal of Food Science and Nutrition

third of her life in menopause. Health issues of menopausal pressure and determination of body weight and BMI was
women therefore would pose a significant challenges to public done.
health also considering the fact that there hasn’t been a
specific health program for such women in the country. Limitations
To compound the problem, the menopause symptoms are Present study is worked in the local area with urban
quite variable with multifactorial etiology. Studies on population. Some of the women refused to participated in the
menopausal issue and health demand priority menopausal study because of their busy and some other psychological
women and due to the growing population of menopausal problems.
women and due to varying presentation following influence of
varied social and cultural pattern (Joseph, et al., 2014). Statistical Analysis
The purpose of the study was to Evaluate the Effect of Initial and final data was collected they were coded then
soyabean consumption on lipid profile and Blood pressure analyzed. Result are expressed as numbers, percentage, mean,
changes in middle age women 40 to 50 years of age. standard deviation, chi-square and comparative test was done
to determine significance between numerical variable.
Materials and Methods
In the present study 85 dyslipidemia subjects, in the age group Results
40 to 50 years were selected from Vijayawada urban area by
stratified random sampling (purposive) method. The Table 1: Socio demographic characteristics of participants:
methodology consisted of administration of a pre tested Characteristics number %
questionnaire to the selected subjects to collect general Age
information, Nutritional status: height, weight, Body mass 40-44.12years 47 55.29
index(BMI), Blood pressure, Lipid profile. 45-50 years 38 44.71
Each participants was explained the nature and purpose of the Marital status
study and their written informed consent was obtained. All the Married 73 85.8
subjects who participated in the study ere interviewed in the Unmarried 1 1.4
ward. They were selected randomly by certain Inclusion and Widow 6 7.0
exclusion criteria. Divorced 5 5.8
Religion
Inclusion Criteria Hindu 49 57.6
In the present study the participants are recruited based in the Christian 26 30.7
inclusion criteria i.e. (i) Women with age group of 40 to 50 Muslim 10 11.7
years. (ii) having irregular cycles (amenorrhea) with showing Type of family
Nuclear 48 56.6
menopausal symptoms. (iii) Elevated Lipid profile, subjects
Extended 7 8.2
were recruited for the study.
Joint 30 35.2
Education level
Exclusion Criteria Illeturate 48 56.47
Exclusion Criteria at baseline included, if they were pregnant, Primary 6 7.05
had a history of gastrointestinal hematologic disorder or Metric 8 9.4
taking medication that could interfere with hematopoiesis or Middle 10 11.7
absorption, hyper or hypo thyroidism, hysterectomized or 2+3 7 8.23
ovariectomized women, hormone therapy, medications to PG 6 7.05
significant affect on lipid lowering or under dieting.
Material used for the study, A well qualified and experienced The mean age of the participants are 43.9 years, the number of
dietitian instructed subjects to take a Therapeutic Lifestyle participants in between 40 years to 44years 12 months are 47
changes (TLC) diet which contains of 55% of CHO, 25% of in number (55.29%) as well 45 to 50 years participants are 38
fat, 20% of protein from the total energy of TLC diet (44.7%) respectively. Above the half of women are married
containing 25gms of soyabeans. This TLC diet is advised to status 73 (85.8%), widow 6 (7.05%), divorced 5 (5.88%),
selected subjects and requested them to follow this diet unmarried 1 (1.17%) respectively.40 (57.6%) of participants
continues for 3 months without fail. are belong to religion Hindu, 26 (30.5%) are Christian and 10
At the beginning of the study baseline values for blood (117%) are Muslims where as most of the participants are in
pressure, body weight, BMI and lipid profile were recorded. nuclear family type 48 (56.47%), 30(35.29%) are joint, less
Boiled soyabeans 25 gms were administered to selected group number of 7 (8.23%) are in extended families. As well most of
respectively for 3 months. All the subjects were asked to the participants above the half are the illeturates 48(56.47%),
follow similar dietary guidelines. After completion of study primary 6 (7.05%), metric 8(9.4%), middle 10(11.71%), 2+3
period estimated of blood profile, measurement of blood are 7(8.23%) and post graduation 6(7.05%) respectively.

134
International Journal of Food Science and Nutrition

Table 2: Anthropometric Data

Parameter Study Type Initial Data Final Data Mean Change % Correlation P Value
Experiment 157.49, 7.38 157.49, 7.38
Height
Control 162.41, 5.33 162.41, 5.33
Experiment 76.18, 17.75 69.12, 12.4 9.26 0.88937 0.0006
Weight
Control 77.81, 9.48 99.15, 10.2 -27.42 0.323002 0.002
Experimental 36.86, 19.02 27.96, 5.36 24.14 0.630009 0.001
Body Mass Index
Control 28.95, 6.34 30.14, 6.79 -4.11 0.01159 0.001

Fig 1: Anthropometric data

The mean height of experimental and control group is 157.49 decrease in body weight. A mean reduction of 24.14% of body
and 162.41 respectively. A mean reduction of 9.26% of body mass index in the experimental group with a significant
weight is noticed in the experimental group and a significant decrease in BMI.

Table 3: Blood Pressure

Parameter Study type Initial data Final data Mean change % Correlation P value
Experiment 88.6, 6.70 82.82, 8.55 6.52 -0.23538 0.030
Diasystolic pressure
control 90.96, 7.19 89.35, 5.39 1.77 0.15033 0.162
Experiment 135.83, 8.03 127.69, 12.46 5.99 1.34736 0.0022
Systolic pressure
control 141.27, 7.44 144.4, 11.51 2.21 0.015594 0.585

Fig 2: Blood pressure

The mean drop of 6.52% was recorded in diasystolic blood pressure of the experimental group showed a mean reducation
pressure in the experimental group and mean fall of 1.77% in of 5.99% with a significant and mean increase of 2.21% of
the control group and is not significant. The systolic blood control group.

135
International Journal of Food Science and Nutrition

Table 4: Blood lipid profile

parameter Study type Initial data Final data Mean change % Correlation P value
Experiment 258.72, 30.5 244.7, 27.19 5.41 0.260704 0.015
Total cholesterol
control 271.89, 43.5 271.73, 44.8 0.058 0.13646 0.058
Experiment 223.02, 52.7 219.8, 45.08 1.44 0.331655 0.005
Triglycerides
control 212.96, 49.5 218.2, 49.8 2.46 0.13359 0.214
Experimental 25.91, 7.03 34.83, 11.78 34.42 0.1958150 0.005
HDL
control 26.8, 8.15 25.01, 12.4 6.67 0.0358651 0.740
Experiment 176.7, 37.2 164.6, 38.8 6.84 0.04989 0.065
LDL
control 191.4, 43.9 195.6, 44.7 2.22 0.092417 0.391
Experiment 52.12, 15.0 49.4, 17.9 5.18 0.09649 0.155
VLDL
control 50.8, 13.2 47.8, 14.1 5.74 0.339117 0.001

Fig 3: Lipid profile

Lipid profile plays a key role in the present study. There is In the present study natural estrogen present food such as
mean drop of 5.41% in total cholesterol of experimental group soyabean as isoflavone are used as a formulated food for the
and there is no significant changes in control group as well in selected subjects. We identified that there is a significant
triglycerides 1.44% of mean fall in the experimental group, reduction of LDL, total cholesterol and triglycerides and
2.46% of increases in control group. Where as in the HDL increase of HDL. The increased HDL shows the beneficial
34.42% of mean rise in the experimental group, 6.84%, 5.18% effect on lipid profile. Zeinab Nourieh, et al. showed that soy
of mean drop in LDL & VLDL respectively in the milk could reduce LDL-C without changing other serum lipid
experimental group. These shown that there is a significant indices among adult with normal lipid profile. In contrast to
effect of isoflavone consumption in the plasma lipid profile of other fats, soy milks fat did not have any adverse effect. In the
the experimental group. present study whole soya in the form of boiled soya showed
significant in lipid profile with the natural soya isoflavones.
Discussion
In the present study total selected subjects is divided into 2 Conclusion
groups as experimental and control groups. Formulated TLC The overall health and well- being of mid aged women has
diet with 25gms soyabeans is instructed to the selected become a major public health concern around the word.
experimental group for 3 months. Interventions were well Especially during menopausal stage cardiovascular disease
tolerated by subjects and the dropout rate was minimum. In risk are very prominent. So best of our knowledge, we designa
the present study consumption of soybean to dyslipidemia study to investigate the effect of soyabean consumption on
subjects resulted in a significant changes in body weight, body weight, BMI, Blood pressure & Lipid profile. By the
Body mass index, Systolic and diasystolic Blood pressure and final analysis it is clear that there is a significant effect on
finally lipid profile. lipid profile especially in the increasing the HDL levels.
According to Jousilahti P et al. and Smith DC et al., the
biological effects of estrogen replacement therapy are References
numerous, but the most likely mechanism to explain its 1. Anthony Ms, Clarkson TB, Hughes CL JR, Morgan TM,
protective effect on cardiovascular disease is its ability to alter Burke GL. Soy bean isoflavones improve cardiovascular
lipid and lipoprotein levels. But along with these benefits risk factors without affecting the reproductive system of
there are certain risk factors of estrogen replacement therapy. peri pubertal rhesus monkeys. J Nutr. 1996; 126:43-50.
High doses of estrogen for moderately long period increase 2. Aubertin - Leheudre M, Lord C, Khalil A, et al. Effect of
the risk of endometrial carcinoma. 6 months of exercise and isoflavones supplementation on

136
International Journal of Food Science and Nutrition

clinical cardiovascular risk factors in obese post-

menopausal women: a randomized, double- blind study.
Menopause. 2007; 14:624-629.
3. Appel LJ. The Effects of protein intake on Blood Pressure
and Cardiovascular disease. Curr Opin Lipidol. 2003;
14:55-59.
4. Barclay L, Lie D. Soy protein improves lipid profile in
postmenopausal women. Menopause. 2007; 14:106-14.
5. Vijayalakshmi S, Ramesh Chandrababu, Eilean Victoria
L. Menopausal Transistion among Northern Indian
women. Nitte University Journal of Health Science
(NUJHS), 2013. ISSN: 2249-7110.
6. Usoro CA, Adikwuru CC, Usoro IN, Nsonwu AC. Lipid
profile of postmenopausal women in Calabar, Nigeria.
Pak J Nutr. 2006; 5:79-82.
7. Washburn S, Burke GL, Morgan T, Anthony M. Effect of
Soy protein supplementation of Serum Lipoprotein,
Blood Pressure and Menopausal Symptoms in Peri
menopausal Women, Menopause. 1999; 6:7-13.
8. Sultan N, Nawaz M, Sultan A, Fayaz M, Baseer A. Effect
of menopause on serum HDL-cholesterol level. J Ayub
Med Coll Abbottabad. 2003; 15:24-6.
9. Swapnali RK, Kisan R, Murthy DS. Effect of menopause
on lipid profile and apolipoproteins. Al Ameen J Med Sci.
2011; 4:221-8.
10. Soy foods Association of North American Scales and
trends, 2010. Avaliable from: http://www.soyfood.org.

137