Edited Action Research
Edited Action Research
Edited Action Research
2018-2019”
I. INTRODUCTION
Technology is a blessing for man. With technology, there is a lot that we can do
which we could not do then (Corpuz and Lucido 2008, Educational Technology 1). In
fact, using technology has been the trend here in the Philippines. Many forms of modern
technologies such as computer gadgets, laptops, tablets, flash drives, printers, scanners,
phones have affected today’s schools in several different ways, creating a summit
moment in educational history across the globe. With these, changes have been served
in schools.
There is no doubt that modern technology specifically the cellphone has a great
impact in our life. It plays an important role in human life from various ways. It helps us
to operate many critical and complex processes easily and effectively especially in the
education sector wherein it strongly influenced majorly and changes the way of learning.
However, despite of the positive trends that technologies offer in Education, when not
used properly, technology becomes detriment to learning development. The abuse and
growth in popularity in the late 1990s. A nationwide survey conducted in 2010 shows
that mobile phones are the most necessary medium of communication for adolescents.
It has virtually affected the society’s accessibility, security, safety and coordination of
business and social activities and has hence become a part of culture of the whole
world.
manifestation of this is the use of mobile phones as tool in the teaching-learning process
inside the classroom. Surprisingly, research on the influence of mobile phone on our
school today has not been given much attention. There is the conflicting priority of
young people, parents and teachers in relation to the mobile phone device, with
teachers more concerned about issues such as discipline in the classroom and parents
use of mobile phone in schools is problematic. As Ling and Helmersen states, the
mobile phone is ―at cross purpose with the mission of the school. While in school
students are supposed take on their prescribed roles as student with full
concentration on their studies and free from contact with the outside world.
However, the mobile phone gives room to blending students’ roles with other
roles thus distracting and disrupting the students’ academic work. In the past
when fixed telephones were the norm in schools, there were minimum
distractions and disruptions but presently with the invasion of mobile phone and the
eagerness of parents to maintain contact with their wards, the device is becoming
part of the classroom. Thus, the mobile phone has the power to undermine the
schools’ authority and weaken their control over students as well as affects their level
of academic performances.
In the school where the researcher teaches, students had been observed to
spend more time in using their cellphone rather than scanning their books. During break
time, almost all students use their phones in different purposes. They prefer mobile
phones more than books. Most students have a mobile device, even though they’re not
permitted to have one in most schools. Research shows that nearly 90% of students
have their mobile devices with them during the school day. The presence of cell phones
presents both opportunities and challenges for today's students. Mobile phones can be a
helpful academic tool, or a hurtful academic disruption depending upon the attitude and
use pattern of the students and the policies of the schools they attend.
Anything excessive is not good and unhealthy thus, this study therefore,
attempts to find out “The Impact of the Excessive Use of Mobile Phones in the Academic
In the past one decade, Mobile phone was not as rampant among users
compared to how it is now being used; especially among secondary Schools’ students.
Recently, mobile phone which comes in different types/models each for specific
student which relatively might certainly influence such students’ academic performance.
This study therefore, seeks to address the impact of mobile phones on student
This study dealt on the utilization of puzzles in solving problem exercises in Grade 10
Null hypothesis:
10 Science when puzzles are used in solving problem exercises and the performance of
classroom for the improvement of the learners in Science. Also this study will serve as
eye opening for the teachers to improve and to innovate more classroom activities for
Students: It will help them discover their strengths and weaknesses in learning. This
study will also help them increase their level of confidence and develop higher order
curriculum. It will also use as guide for the development of the teaching-learning
particularly in solving problem exercises for the S.Y. 2018- 2019. This study was
Definition of Terms
unarticulated needs
Utilization - The action of making practical and effective use of something. 'steps to
In a puzzle, one is required to put pieces together in a logical way, in order to arrive at
the correct solution of the puzzle. There are different types of puzzles for different ages,
Puzzles are often devised as a form of entertainment but they can also arise
from serious mathematical or logistical problems. In such cases, their solution may be a
Solutions of puzzles often require the recognition of patterns and the creation of
a particular kind of order. Sometimes not because of how complicated and diagonal the
pattern can get. People with a high level of inductive reasoning aptitude may be better
at solving such puzzles than others. But puzzles based upon inquiry and discovery may
be solved more easily by those with good deduction skills. Deductive reasoning improves
with practice.
younger kids – I’m thinking any age below college, when Math is usually mandatory
every year. Those of you who, like me, remember your high school days well probably
remember
that a good percentage of the school population self-described as “just not good at
Math”. I always found that interesting, probably because Math came naturally to me.
There seems to be a perception that Math skills are intrinsic to some people – you’re
Rather than having two groups of people, or in these case children that are;
‘good at math’ and ‘not good at math’, we really have groups that could be labeled;
‘anxious about math’, ‘not anxious about math’. According to Stanford Medicine’s article,
“Even if they are good at math, many children feel anxious about doing math problems.
For some, the anxiety persists throughout life, discouraging them from pursuing
advanced math and science classes as well as careers that rely on mathematical
expertise.”
Games have been a widely utilized form of study by students and teachers alike,
across all age groups and areas of study. These methods are a desirable learning
method, as they can make studying more enjoyable (Franklin et al., 2003; Weisskirch,
2006; Crossman & Crossman, 1983). Haun (1985) reports a number of benefits to using
memorizing, and boosting students’ confidence when they get a correct response.
Due to the fact that games are a useful tool, it is not surprising how many
different types of games are used for test review and classroom teaching at the school
level. BINGO (Klepper, 2003), simulation games and role playing (Childers, 1996),
games formatted like the Olympics (Clark, 1997), Jeopardy-type games (Rotter, 2004),
web-based quizzing (Gurung& Daniel, 2006), discussion games (Franklin et al., 2003),
and crossword puzzles (Weisskirch, 2006; Franklin et al., 2003; Crossman & Crossman,
1983; Childers, 1996) have all been used by instructors to review course material. Using
these different approaches to learning can be helpful in several ways. Games can relieve
the tedium of lecture and traditional teaching methods, as well as create a more relaxed
can be done through the novel use of games instead of rote practice (Rotter, 2004).
This can increase the amount of attention students give to the material, thus increasing
retention (Klepper, 2003). Another positive outcome of using games in the classroom is
that participation in them makes learning a matter of direct experience (Dorn, 1989),
and research has shown that students prefer hands-on learning such as this (Moore
&Dettlaff, 2005). Making students’ interaction with material active rather than passive is
(Dorn, 1989, p. 5). With these benefits in mind, the puzzle stands out from the rest as a
classroom tool. Puzzles have been used successfully in many different disciplines
(Childers, 1996), showing their versatility and flexibility. They are also a useful tool as
most people are already familiar with them, which reduce the need to explain directions,
saving class time (Crossman & Crossman, 1983; Weisskirch, 2006). Additionally, these
puzzles are often perceived as being a recreational activity, therefore making them more
enjoyable and less threatening than traditional teaching techniques (Crossman &
A good puzzle should demand the exercise of our best wit and ingenuity, and
although a knowledge of mathematics and a certain familiarity with the methods of logic
are often of great service in the solution of these things, yet it sometimes happens that
a kind of natural cunning and sagacity is of considerable value. For many of the best
problems cannot be solved by any familiar scholastic methods, but must be attacked on
entirely original lines. This is why, after a long and wide experience, one finds that
particular puzzles will sometimes be solved more readily by persons possessing only
naturally alert faculties than by the better educated. The best players of such puzzle
games as chess and draughts are not mathematicians, though it is just possible that
It is extraordinary what fascination a good puzzle has for a great many people.
We know the thing to be of trivial importance, yet we are impelled to master it, and
when we have succeeded there is a pleasure and a sense of satisfaction that are a quite
sufficient reward for our trouble, even when there is no prize to be won. What is this
mysterious charm that many find irresistible? Why do we like to be puzzled? The curious
thing is that directly the enigma is solved the interest generally vanishes. We have done
it, and that is enough. But why did we ever attempt to do it?
The answer is simply that it gave us pleasure to seek the solution - that the
pleasure was all in the seeking and finding for their own sakes. A good puzzle, like
virtue, is its own reward. Man loves to be confronted by a mystery - and he is not
entirely happy until he has solved it. We never like to feel our mental inferiority to those
around us. The spirit of rivalry is innate in man; it stimulates the smallest child, in play
or education, to keep level with his fellows, and in later life it turns men into great
discoverers, inventors, orators, heroes, artists and (if they have more material aims)
perhaps millionaires.
Puzzles can be made out of almost anything, in the hands of the ingenious
person with an idea. Coins, matches, cards, counters, bits of wire or string, all come in
useful. An immense
number of puzzles have been made out of the letters of the alphabet, and from those
Children learn best when they are engaged in games. It makes them excited and
makes them want to practice and learn. (Ann Brunner, Math Teacher at St. Stephens)
the model developed by Kemmis and McTaggart (1988) in Burns (1999:32) who state
participants in social situations in order to improve the rationality and justice of their
own social or educational practices, as well as their understanding of these practices and
the situations in which these practices are carried out. This occurs through a dynamic
Research Design
This research was a classroom action research. As stated by Burn (2010), action
teaching works and to see parts of teaching that could have been better improved. The
teaching parts could be the teacher, the students and the teaching and learning
The Utilization of Puzzles in the Problem Solving Skills of Students in Grade 10 Science in
PLAN OF ACTION
A. Objectives
General Objective:
Specific Objectives:
B. Time Frame
C. Target Participants
The subject of this study were all the Grade 10 students from Grade 10-
Jasper and Grade 10- Garnet in Calmay Integrated School, Laoac, Pangasinan
who are low performers in Science particularly in solving problem exercises for
D. Activities Undertaken
The researcher sought permission from the concern school and division
authorities to conduct the said study. The following steps and procedures were
done: the researcher determined the students who are low performers in solving
problem exercises. They were taught the same concepts and procedures in
solving problem exercises but they were exposed in two different problem
solving strategies in their quizzes. First, students were given quizzes on problem
solving with the use of conventional way of solving problem exercises. Then, the
results of their quizzes served as the pretest. After that, they were given the
same type of quiz but puzzle was used in their quizzes. The results of their
E. Evaluation Criteria
The main tool in gathering pertinent information on the effect on
student’s performance in Grade 10- Science were the test questions in their
the study.
The following statistical tools were used to answer the problems of the
study: mean and standard deviation. The t- test will be used to determine the
F. Research Design
The single group experimental design was used to compare which of the
Science. This design involves a single treatment with two or more levels.
that exists between two or more quantifiable variables. The main objective of this
study is to describe the nature of the situation as it exists at the time of the study
Presentation of Data
the stated problems of the study. The statistical tools used were average
weighted means, and t-test. All data were encoded using the MS Excel Program
and computed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS),
version
Table 1. Quiz Results of G10- Jasper Students When Exposed to Conventional
Table 1 shows that the average weighted mean of G10- Jasper when exposed to
conventional way of solving problem exercises is 36.5 with an equivalent rating of poor.
Table 2. Quiz Results of G10- Jasper Students When Exposed to Unconventional Way
(With the use of Puzzles) of Solving Problem Exercises in Grade 10- Science
Posttest
Respondent No. Pretest
Unconventional
(Jasper) (Conventional)
(Puzzles)
Table 1 57 36 3.
Pretest 2 54 36 and
3 54 45
4 56 41
5 57 32
6 55 42
7 53 32
8 54 28
SD 1.511857892 5.806400409
Posttest Results of 10- Jasper Students on the use of Conventional and Unconventional
way of Solving Problem exercises in Grade 10 Science
54- 60 Outstanding
51- 53 Very Good
48- 50 Good
45- 47 Fair
44 below Poor
There are two tests shown in the table, the pretest and posttest. The mean
performance score reflected the knowledge of the students before and after the
exposure in the problem solving strategy which was the used of puzzles in solving
problem solving exercises in Grade 10 Science. The t-test for correlated means is
presented below to test the significant difference on the scores of 10- Jasper students
Unconventional(Puzzles Conventiona
) l
Mean 55 36.5
Variance 2.285714286 33.71428571
Observations 8 8
Pearson Correlation 0.065094455
Hypothesized Mean
Difference 0
Df 7
t Stat 8.862797545
P(T<=t) one-tail 2.35672E-05
t Critical one-tail 1.894578604
P(T<=t) two-tail 4.71343E-05
t Critical two-tail 2.364624251
The means were compared, analyzed and interpreted. The mean of the pretest
was 36.5 and posttest was 55.0 with a mean difference of 18.5 with a 50.68% mean
percentage increase. Since the computed t-value is greater than the tabulated value at
0.05 level of alpha and the p-value is less than 0.5 level of significance, results revealed
that the mean difference between the pretest and posttest really differ with each other
remarkably improved the problem solving skills of Grade 10 Jasper students in Science
Table 4 shows that the average weighted mean of G10- Garnet when exposed to
poor.
Table 5. Quiz Results of G10- Garnet Students When Exposed to Unconventional Way
(With the use of Puzzles) of Solving Problem Exercises in Grade 10- Science
solving problem exercises their average weighted mean is 55.75 with an equivalent
rating of outstanding.
There are two tests shown in the table, the pretest and posttest. The mean
performance score reflected the knowledge of the students before and after the
exposure
in the problem solving strategy which was the used of puzzles in solving problem solving
exercises in Grade 10 Science. The t-test for correlated means is presented below to test
the significant difference on the scores of 10- Garnet students before and after exposure
to puzzles.
Unconventional(Puzzles Conventiona
) l
Mean 55.75 38.75
Variance 5.642857143 31.92857143
Observations 8 8
Pearson Correlation 0.452326069
Hypothesized Mean Difference 0
Df 7
t Stat 9.535268655
P(T<=t) one-tail 1.4626E-05
t Critical one-tail 1.894578604
P(T<=t) two-tail 2.9252E-05
t Critical two-tail 2.364624251
The means were compared, analyzed and interpreted. The mean of the pretest
was 38.75 and posttest was 55.75 with a mean difference of 17.0 with a 43.87% mean
percentage increase. Since the computed t-value is greater than the tabulated value at
0.05 level of alpha and the p-value is less than 0.5 level of significance, results revealed
that the mean difference between the pretest and posttest really differ with each other
remarkably improved the problem solving skills of Grade 10 Garnet students in Science.
students when puzzles in solving problem exercises were utilize and the
problem exercises
B. Recommendations:
This study recommends the following:
1. The teacher should constantly find alternative ways in improving the
exercises.
2. Try other types of puzzles in developing the problem solving skills and critical
Science.
IX. BIBLIOGRAPHY
A. Unpublished Thesis
Dizon, Armida V. (March 2005). The Teaching of Integrated Science Process Skills
Among Private Schools in Tarlac City. Pangasinan State University- Graduate
School, Urdanneta City.
B. Manuals
C. Books
Calderon, Jose F., Ed. D. (2006). Methods of Research and Thesis Writing.
National Bookstote.
Mclaughin, Charles W., et. al. (1997). Glencoe Physical Science. McGraw Hill
Companies Inc.
Sevilla, Consuelo, et. al. (1998). Research Methods. Rex Bookstore. Manila
D. Internet
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puzzle
http://info.thinkfun.com/stem-education/how-can-you-address-your-childs-math-anxiety
http://www.puzzles.com/PuzzleClub/Articles/Loyd-Dudeney-GTO.htm
http://www.puzzles.com/PuzzleClub/Articles/CanterburyPuzzles.htm
http://www.puzzles.com/PuzzleClub/Articles/AhaInsight.htm
APPENDICES
Appendix A
ACTIVITIES UNDERTAKEN FROM AUGUST 15, 2013
UP TO NOVEMBER 25, 2013
Appendix B.1
Quiz 1. Conventional Way of Solving Problem Exercises
Solve the following problem exercises with solutions (2 points each). For additional 2
points, you should be able to solve all the problem exercises correctly.
A. Find the wavelength of a radio wave traveling at 3.0 x 10 8 m/s with a frequency
of 5.40 x 105 Hertz.
B. The colors of the spectrum can be measured in units of wavelength, frequency,
or energy, which are alternative ways of describing colors of light waves. The
human eye is sensitive to light with a wavelength of 5.60 x 10 -7 m, which is a
yellow green color. What is the frequency of this wavelength?
C. The wavelength of a monochromatic light source is measured to be 6 x 10 -7 m in
a diffraction experiment. What is the frequency
D. A light wave has a frequency of 4.90 x 10 14 cycles per second. What is the
wavelength?
E. What is the energy of the gamma ray photon of frequency 5 x 10 20 Hz?
F. What is the energy of a microwave photon of wavelength 1.00 mm?
G. A monochromatic light source used in a diffraction experiment has a wavelength
of 4.60 x 10-7 m. What is the energy of a photon of this light?
H. What is the energy of a photon of violet light with a frequency of 7.00 x
1014Hertz?
An electromagnetic wave with a frequency of 20.0 MHz propagates with a speed
of 1.90 x 108 m/s in a certain piece of glass. Find the wavelength of t
22
Appendix B.2
Quiz 1. Solving Problem Exercises with the Use of Puzzle (Unconventional)
Name: __________________________ Year & Sec.: ___________________Score:
__________
Quiz 1
Problem Solving on Electromagnetic Waves ( c= λ f) where c= speed of light
in vacuum, 3 x 108 m/s; E = hf ( h= Planck’s constant, 6.63 x 10-34 J.s)
A. Find the wavelength of a radio wave traveling at 3.0 x 10 8 m/s with a frequency
of 5.40 x 105 Hertz.
B. The colors of the spectrum can be measured in units of wavelength, frequency,
or energy, which are alternative ways of describing colors of light waves. The
human eye is sensitive to light with a wavelength of 5.60 x 10 -7 m, which is a
yellow green color. What is the frequency of this wavelength?
C. The wavelength of a monochromatic light source is measured to be 6 x 10 -7 m in
a diffraction experiment. What is the frequency
D. A light wave has a frequency of 4.90 x 10 14 cycles per second. What is the
wavelength?
E. What is the energy of the gamma ray photon of frequency 5 x 10 20 Hz?
F. What is the energy of a microwave photon of wavelength 1.00 mm?
G. A monochromatic light source used in a diffraction experiment has a wavelength
of 4.60 x 10-7 m. What is the energy of a photon of this light?
H. What is the energy of a photon of violet light with a frequency of 7.00 x
1014Hertz?
I. An electromagnetic wave with a frequency of 20.0 MHz propagates with a speed
of 1.90 x 108 m/s in a certain piece of glass. Find the wavelength of the wave in
the glass.
ANSWER LIST
1.) f= 5.36 x 1014 2.) 9.5 m 3.) 6.12 x 10-7 m
Hertz
4.) E= 4. 3 x 10-19 J 5.) E= 3.32 x 6.) f= 5 x 1014
10-13 J Hertz
7.) E= 1.99 x 10-22 J 8.) 2.41 x 103 m 9.)E = 4.64 x 10-
19
J
A B C
D E F
G H I
QUIZ 2
Problem Solving on Concave and Convex Mirrors. Use the equations: 1/f = 1/p +1/q;
h’/h = p/q
Solve the following problem exercises with solutions (2 points each). For additional 2
points, you should be able to solve all the problem exercises correctly.
A. What is the image distance if a 7.00 cm tall object is placed 30.0 cm from a concave
mirror having a focal length of 10.0 cm?
B. What is the image height of an object in problem A?
C. A man 1.30- m tall stands 5.20 meters from a concave mirror. If the image could be
formed on a screen 15.0 cm from the mirror. What is the size of the image?
D. What is the focal length of the concave mirror in problem C?
E. An object is kept at a distance of 15 cm from a concave mirror with a radius of
curvature of 60 cm. Find the image distance.
F. An object placed 5 cm from a concave mirror produces a real image of 20cm. find
the radius of curvature of the mirror.
G. An object is placed 33.7 cm from the convex mirror with a focal length of 10.7 cm.
Determine the image distance.
H. A 7.0 cm tall light bulb is placed a distance of 37.5 cm from a convex mirror having a
focal length of -12.5 cm. Determine the image distance
I. Determine the image size of an object in problem H.
24
Appendix C.2
Quiz 2. Solving Problem Exercises with the Use of Puzzle (Unconventional)
QUIZ 2
Problem Solving on Concave and Convex Mirrors
A. What is the image distance if a 7.00 cm tall object is placed 30.0 cm from a concave
mirror having a focal length of 10.0 cm?
B. What is the image height of an object in problem A?
C. A man 1.30- m tall stands 5.20 meters from a concave mirror. If the image could be
formed on a screen 15.0 cm from the mirror. What is the size of the image?
D. What is the focal length of the concave mirror in problem C?
E. An object is kept at a distance of 15 cm from a concave mirror with a radius of
curvature of 60 cm. Find the image distance.
F. An object placed 5 cm from a concave mirror produces a real image of 20cm. find
the radius of curvature of the mirror.
G. An object is placed 33.7 cm from the convex mirror with a focal length of 10.7 cm.
Determine the image distance.
H. A 7.0 cm tall light bulb is placed a distance of 37.5 cm from a convex mirror having a
focal length of -12.5 cm. Determine the image distance
I. Determine the image size of an object in problem H.
ANSWER LIST
1.) .) h’= 1.75 cm 2.) h’= -3.75 cm 3.) f= 7.96 cm
4.) q = 15 cm 5.) q = -15 cm 6.) q= - 9.38 cm
7.) f = 6.67 cm 8.) q = -8.12 cm 9.) h’= -3.5 cm
A B C
D E F
G H I
Quiz 3
Problem Solving on Convex and Concave lens. Use the equations: 1/f = 1/p +1/q; h’/h
= p/q
Solve the following problem exercises with solutions (2 points each). For additional 2
points, you should be able to solve all the problem exercises correctly.
A. An object is kept at a distance of 80.0 cm from a convex lens of focal length 25.0
cm. Find the distance of its image.
B. A coin is placed a distance of 25.0 cm from a concave lens that has a focal length of
-11.0 cm. Determine the image distance.
C. A converging lens with a focal length of 10.0 cm forms a real image 1.0 cm tall, 14.0
cm to the right of the lens. Determine the position of the object.
D. Determine the size of the object in problem C.
E. An object is 10.0 cm to the left of a lens. The lens forms an image 20.0 cm to the
right of the lens. What is the focal length of the lens?
F. A diverging lens forms an image of an object. The object is 20.0 cm from the lens.
The image is 5.00 cm from the lens o the same side as the object. What is the focal
length of the lens?
G. If the object is 2.00 cm tall, how tall is the image in problem F?
H. A diverging lens of focal length 4.00 cm is placed 18.0 cm to the left of the lens.
What is the position of the image?
I. An object is placed 12.5 cm to the left of the diverging lens and the image is formed
25.0 cm to the left of the lens. What is the focal length of the diverging lens?
26
Appendix D.2
Quiz 3. Solving Problem Exercises with the Use of Puzzle (Unconventional)
Quiz 3
Problem Solving on Convex and Concave lens
A. An object is kept at a distance of 80.0 cm from a convex lens of focal length 25.0
cm. Find the distance of its image.
B. A coin is placed a distance of 25.0 cm from a concave lens that has a focal
length of -11.0 cm. Determine the image distance.
C. A converging lens with a focal length of 10.0 cm forms a real image 1.0 cm tall,
14.0 cm to the right of the lens. Determine the position of the object.
D. Determine the size of the object in problem C.
E. An object is 10.0 cm to the left of a lens. The lens forms an image 20.0 cm to
the right of the lens. What is the focal length of the lens?
F. A diverging lens forms an image of an object. The object is 20.0 cm from the
lens. The image is 5.00 cm from the lens o the same side as the object. What is
the focal length of the lens?
G. If the object is 2.00 cm tall, how tall is the image in problem F?
H. A diverging lens of focal length 4.00 cm is placed 18.0 cm to the left of the lens.
What is the position of the image?
I. An object is placed 12.5 cm to the left of the diverging lens and the image is
formed 25.0 cm to the left of the lens. What is the focal length of the diverging
lens?
ANSWER LIST
1.) q = -7.64 cm 2.) h’ = 0.5 cm 3.) f = -6.67 cm
4.) f = -25 cm 5.) f= 6.67 cm 6.) q = 36.36 cm
7.) h = 2.5 cm 8.) p = 35 cm 9.) q = -5.14 cm
A B C
D E F
G H I
Educational Attainment:
Master Teacher I
Manaoag National High School
Manaoag, Pangasinan
2012- Present
Teacher III
Manaoag National High School
Manaoag, Pangasinan
2008- 2012
Teacher I
Manaoag National High School
Manaoag, Pangasinan
2004- 2008
Teacher I (Contractual)
Manaoag National High School
Manaoag, Pangasinan
December 2003- March 2004
29
CHARACTER REFERENCES:
JULIE G. DE GUZMAN
Education Program Supervisor I- Science
In- charge of Action Research
Pangasinan Division II
Binalonan, Pangasinan