Ester Reactions of Fatty Acids PDF
Ester Reactions of Fatty Acids PDF
Ester Reactions of Fatty Acids PDF
31
retical principles of liquid t h e r m a l diffusion have not 3. Kis$1er, g . E., 3]£uckerheide, V. J., ~/[yers, L. D., J. Am. Oil
Chemists' Soc., 23, 146-150 ( I 9 4 6 ) .
been fully developed. Factors which affect the degree 4. Myers, L. D., 2¢Iuckerheide, ~r. j., U . S . Pat. 2,293,676 (1942)
a n d U . S . Pat. 2,421,157 (1947).
of separation in the t h e r m a l diffusion process are 5. Brown, A. C., U . S . Pat. 2,352,160 (1944).
u n i f o r m i t y of size of the a n n u l a r space, t e m p e r a t u r e 6. Schlenk, H., Holman, R. T., Science, 112, 19-20 (1950).
7. Newey, I t . A., Sho.kol, E. 0., ~Iueller, A. C., Bradley, T. F., and
differential, and time required for diffusion. I t ap- Fetterly, L. 0., Ind. Eng. Chem., 42, 2538-2541 (1950).
8. Jones, A. L., and Foreman, 1~. W., Ind. Eng. Chem., 44, 2249-
pears that this method m a y be adapted for continuous 2253 (1952).
operation. 9. Pool, W. 0., U . S . Pat. 2,543,055 (1951).
REFERENCES 10. Eckey, E. W., Ind. Eng. Chem:, 40, 1183-1190 (1948).
11. Nicholsen, R., and Formo, M. W., g. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc.,
1. Stingley, Dale, Chem. Industries, 48, 50-52 (1941). 26, 329-331 ( 1 9 4 9 ) .
2. Eoster Wheeler Corporation Bulletin 1D-46-10 and :F'otfus, R. tt., 12. Swern, Daniel, and Parker, W. E., J. Am. 0il Chemists' See.,
and Whit~ F, B., J. Am. 0il Chemists' See., 30, 49-53 (1953). 29, 431-434 (1952).
E A C T I O N S involving ester linkages of fats and R C O O R ' -~- R " C O O H ~ ' R " C O O R ' -1- R C 0 0 H
R oils are among the most i m p o r t a n t in the chemis-
t r y of f a t t y acid derivatives. Hydrolysis of esters 4. Interesterification, sometimes termed ester inter-
under alkaline conditions, the familiar saponification change or trans-esterification, is the exchange of acyl
of fats and oils, has been practiced for centuries. This and alkyl groups between a p a i r of esters.
p a p e r will cover the non- RCOOR' q- R " C O O R ' " ~ ' R C O O R ' " -~- R " C O O R '
hydrolytic ester reactions:
esterification, a l c o h o l y s i s , There has been some confusion in the literature
acidolysis, and interesteri- regarding the nomenclature of these related reactions.
fication. These reactions are Some authors use fhe terminology, "trans-esterifica-
of f a r more recent origin tion reactions," broadly to describe a]coholysis, acid-
and have been recognized olysis, and interesterification. Others use the t e r m
for a p p r o x i m a t e l y one cen- "interesterifieation r e a c t i o n s " in a similar broad sense
tury. t t o w e v e r it has only ( G e r m a n " U m e s t e r u n g " ) . I t is becoming more com-
been within the past few mon practice to use the term "trans-esterification" as
decades that they have a synonym for interesterification or ester-interchange
a s s u m e d t e c h n i c a l impor- to describe the exchange of acy] and alky] groups
tance. Alkyd resins, rub- between a p a i r of esters. Such terminology will be
b e r - l i k e , polyesters., im- adhered to in this discussion.
proved lard for shortening, The close relationship between esterification, aleo-
and nonionic surface active holysis, and interesterification is illustrated b y com-
agents, to improve shorten- parison of the equilibrium constants for homogeneous
i n g efficiency a n d s o f t e n reaction. Normally we do not have sufficient data to
bread, represent only a few calculate all equilibrima constants, b u t theoretically
of the products dependent the point of equilibrium in both alcoholysis and inter-
M. W. Formo upon these ester reactions. esterifieation reactions can be calculated f r o m the sim-
ple esterifieation constants.
General Scope and Chemistry of S t u d y of esterifieation and hydrolysis provided some
the Ester Reactions of the earliest classical examples of reversible equilib-
ria. A t equilibrium in a homogeneous reaction the
There are f o u r closely allied reversible reactions ,relationship between concentrations of reactants and
involving addition or interchange of alkyl radicals on products is represented b y the familiar esterifieation
the earboxyl residue of f a t t y acids. These reactions, constant.
which have much in common, are as follows :
1. Esterifieation is the condensation ~f an acid and Acid -[- Alcohol , ~ Ester .4- W a t e r
an alcohol to give an ester and water; the reverse [Ester] X [Water]
reaction is hydrolysis. [Acid] X [Alcohol] ---~K esterification
RCOOH @ R'OH , ' RCOOR' @ IIOH Table I illustrates tile relationship of the esterifiea-
tion equilibrium constant to the aleoholysis and inter-
2. Alcoholysis involves the replacement of the alkyl esterifieation equilibria. Knowledge of esterification
group of an ester b y another through interaction of constants would p e r m i t calculation of the equilibria
the ester and an alcohol. The reaction is frequently in both alcoholysis and interesterification reactions.
described in terms of the added alcohol, e.g. methan- Several reviews are available covering the ester
olysis, glycerolysis, etc. reactions (1, 2, 3, 4, 5).
I~COOR' @ R " O H ~ ~ R C O O R " -~- R ' O H Esterification Reactions
3. Acido]ysis, in an analogous way, is the substitu- There are f o u r p r i m a r y methods for direct prep-
tion or exchange of aeyl groups of esters through the aration of esters:
reaction of an ester and an acid. 1. reaction of an alcohol and an acid with elimina-
~ T e c h n i c ~ l P~per No. 130 from the Areher-Daniels-SIidland Company. tion of w a t e r ;
NOVEMBER 1954 FORMO: ESTER ]{EACTIONS 549
sulfonie acid type have been used to catalyze esterifi= ling is used for collection of water. Measurement of
cation of oleic acid by n-butyl alcohol b u t offer no the water distilled during reaction offers a convenient
advantage over conventional acid catalysts (24). method for following the course of the reaction. The
Methyl and n-butyl esters of unsaturated acids are temperature of azeotropie esterifieation can be closely
used as lubricating oil additives in the form of sul- regulated b y control of solvent quantity (36). Com-
furized esters (25, 26). mereially azeotropie esterification is used, particularly
for alkyd resin production. Phthalie anhydride sub-
Esters of Higher Monohydric Alcohols limes readily at esterification temperature, and the
azeotropie solvent (usually xylene) tends to dissolve
Esterification of higher alcohols from hexyl u p w a r d
and flush the sublimate back into the reaction kettle.
can be carried out conveniently, using stociometric
2. Esterification using an inert gas sparge. Rate and
quantities of alcohol and f a t t y acid u n d e r azeotrope
degree of esterifieation with polyols is. improved by
conditions with benzene, toluene, or xylene as a sol-
blowing an inert gas, such as carbon dioxide or nitro-
vent. Direct esterification of higher f a t t y alcohols is
gen, through the reaction mixture (37, 38). Water
practical, using a stream of inert gas such as carbon
is carried off b y the gas stream, b u t losses of both
dioxide, nitrogen, or even steam to sweep out the lib-
polyol and f a t t y acid occur.
erated water, or alternatively a partial vacuum may
3. Vacuum. esterification. Esterification under re-
be used to remove water while retaining the acid and
duced pressure offers the most efficient and practical
alcohol. Higher f a t t y alcohol esters of saturated acids
method for esterification with polyhydric alcohols (39,
are waxy solids.
40). A moderately rapid reaction is maintained at a
lower temperature than for the other processes with
Other Monohydric Esters
good preservation of Color. Glycerol, which is prob-
Vinyl esters are p r e p a r e d in an unusual manner. ably the most important polyol used for esterification,
Vinyl alcohol is unknown, but vinyl esters can be is moderately volatile at vacuum esterification tem-
prepared by direct addition of acetylene to f a t t y acids peratures. Partial condensers help minimize glycerol
at high temperatures, usually in the presence of a losses. A combination of vacuum esterification and
basic catalyst, such as zinc oxide (27, 28). sparging with CO2 or even steam gives the most prac-
1%COOH -}- HC ~ CH > RCOOH = CH2 tical reaction from the standpoints of rate, complete-
ness, and product color.
An alternative process more suitable for laboratory Catalysts can be used for speeding up esterification
preparation involves acidolysis of vinyl acetate with b u t usually to the detriment of color. Konen (41) in
f a t t y acids in the presence of a mercury salt (29, 30, a study of the esterification of unsaturated acids with
31, 32). a series of polyols concluded that, in " q u i t e an ex-
Copolymerization of vinyl esters of saturated acids tensive study of catalysts, none was found that gave
with vinyl acetate has been suggested for preparation sufficiently good results to w a r r a n t use either com-
of internally plasticized resins (33). mercially or in the laboratory. In all cases the use of
Teeter and Cowan prepared allyl, methallyl, and a catalyst increased the initial esterification rate; but
chloro-allyl esters by direct esterification and also b y if a low final acid value (2-5) was desired, the time
aleoholysis (34). necessary to arrive at this acid value was the same
T e t r a h y d r o f u r f u r y l and cyclohexyl esters have been with or without catalyst." There is an extremely volu-
prepared azeotropieally, using benzene as a solvent minous literature on catalysis of the esteriflcation re-
(35). T e t r a h y d r o f u r f u r y l oleate is marketed as a vinyl action. Among catalysts which have been described
plasticizer. are a variety of acidic materials, such as sulfuric
acid, hydrochloric acid, p h o s p h o r i c acid, sulfonic
Esters of Polyhydric Alcohols acids, Twitchell reagent, trifluoroacetic acid, boron
Commercially the esters of polyhydric alcohols are trifluoride, alkyl acid phosphates, etc. Catalytic ac-
f a r more important than the monohydric esters. In tivity has been ascribed to practically all metals, in
the case of monohydric alcohols it is possible to use a the periodic table in the form of acetates, abietates,
large excess of the esterifying alcohol, removing it alkoxides, carbonates, chlorides, fluorides, hydroxides,
at the conclusion of the reaction. With polyhydric oxides, naphthenates, and soaps of f a t t y acids. Metal-
alcohols this is impossible. With an excess of polyol lic salts mentioned most commonly are lead, zinc, and
the f a t t y acid residues are distributed randomly, leav- calcium. Many of these esterification catalysts are
ing some free hydroxyl g r o u p s and giving a product also catalysts for alcoholysis, interesterification, and
containing all possible mono-, di-, tri-, etc., esters to- acidolysis reactions.
gether with the fully esterified polyol. In order to Good agitation during large scale esterifieation is of
carry esterifieation to completion it is necessary to use great importance. Paddle agitators are not normally
only the theoretical amount or a slight excess of the satisfactory, and propeller or turbine types are needed
alcohol, using reaction conditions u n d e r which water to draw the heavy, f a t t y acid immiscible polyol from
is efficiently removed. Esterification by use of heat the bottom of the reaction vessel. This is particularly
alone without special provisions for removal of water important in order to avoid charring with high melt-
gives poor results, both with respect to the rate and ing polyols, such as pentaerythritol (42).
extent of esterifieation. Several methods are used for
water removal : Esterification with Glycerol
1. Azeotropic esterification. The theoretical amounts F a r more work has been devoted to the study o f
of polyol and f a t t y acid are heated in the presence of esterification of f a t t y acids with glycerol than with
refluxing xylene which carries away the water formed any other alcohol, either monohydric or polyhydric.
during the reaction. F o r laboratory preparations a Lower molecular weight f a t t y esters are f a r l e ~
simple trap such as the Dean-Stark or Bidwell-Ster- important than the higher f a t t y acid esters. Reac-
NOVEMBER 1954 F O ~ O : EST~a R~ACTm~S 551
lion of acetic anhydride with glycerol to form tri- using nitrogen sweeping and standardized agitation
acetin is used as a basis for the familiar " a c e t i n " at various temperatures (49). The rate of esterifica-
method for determination of this important polyol lion increases sharply with temperature (Figure 1).
(43). Reaction of acetic anhydride with hydroxyl The reaction was found to be bimoleeular but pro-
groups is used as an analytical determinatio~ l o r ceeded in two stages with heats of activation of 12,300
hydroxyl content (% hydroxyl, acetyl value, or pref- and 10,800 cal. per mole respectively.
erably hydroxyl value) in oils and fats as well as in Experimental evidence indicates that the esterifica-
polyols (44). lion of f a t t y acids gives a statistical or random dis-
Reaction of monoglycerides with acetic anhydride tribution of f a t t y acids among the glyceride types.
gives " a c e t o stearins," non-greasy, highly flexible I n the simplest sense, fats may be c o n s i d e r e d as
f a t t y m a t e r i a l s having promise as plasticizers, coat- composed of two acids, saturated and unsaturated.
ings for food products, and temperature-resistant Figure 2 gives the composition of component tri-
spreads (45, 46, 47). glycerides having s mole-fraction of saturated acids,
Esterification of glycerol is a stepwise process. S, and u mole-fraction of unsaturated acids, U.
CH~OH /
GHOH
CHoOH
.[
CH~O0(~R CH~O'GOR.
I
9o
(/1
~l-I0'001~ ~1 80
RC'00H + °HOH
CHeOH \
l
I
tt a
n,-
td 7 lU NSATURATED TRISATURAT
~HOCOR - - - ~ C:HOCOR
I /
C'H20H CH~0H
a a n d fl M o n o g l y c e r i d e s Diglycerides Triglyceride
° ,0'2
I-
~l• MONOSATURATED DISATURATED
1, 3 a n d 1, 2 0
Z 40~ rIU~T~AT[D
~ MON(~N,~rUR
D.
2
The p r i m a r y initial product is the a monoglyceride 0
although some fl isomer also is formed but probably
rearranges to the a-form. Similarly, the 1,3-dig]ycer-
ide is the principal form on continued esterification
leading finally to the completely esterified triglyceride.
o
The first comprehensive classical study of esterifi-
cation of glycerol was carried out 100 years, ago by
Berthelot, who. systematically prepared mono-, di-, and MOLE-% OF SATURATED
triglycerides from practically all f a t t y acids known at FATTY ACIDS
that time (48). Such esterifieation of f a t t y acids with FIG. 2. C o m p o n e n t g]ycerldes a t s t a t i s t i c a l d i s t r i b u t i o n .
glycerol is sometimes termed re-esterification since it
gives the glyecrides from which the acids, and glycerol
were originally derived. The composition of glyceride types is given b y the
Feuge, Kraemer, and Bailey studied the esterifica- following equations (49) ~
lion of p e a n u t oil acids with glycerol at 20 ram.,
T r i s a t u r a t e d , GS~ = s~ X 100, m o l e - p e r c e n t a g e .
D i s a t u r a t e d - m o n o u n s a t u r a t e d , GS~U = 3s~u X 100, mole-
IO0- l percentage.
M o n o s a t u r a t e d - d i u n s a t u r a t e d , GSU2 = 3su 2 X 100, mole-
9
percentage.
Triunsaturated, GUs = us X 100, mole-percentage.
8
Bhattacharya and IIilditch esterified various com-
b i n a t i o n s of saturated and unsaturated acids (50).
The trisaturated glyceride co~ltent b y permanganate
oxidation fell very close to the trisaturated glyceride
curve of F i g u r e 2. Other studies involving interesteri-
fication of glycerides in homogeneous systems indicate
that within experimental error the content of fully
saturated glycerides corresponds to the amount cal-
culated for r a n d o m distribution (51, 52, 53).
Esterification of f a t t y acids with an excess of glyc-
erol gives a mixture of mono-, di-, and triglycerides.
U. The composition of the reaction mixture has been
calculated on the basis of homogeneous reaction and
The a.bove distribution is a special case of the generalized random
distribution theory. With a mole-fraction of acid A, b mole-fraction o.f
B, c mole-fraction of C, d mole-fraction of D, etc., glyceride types are
I ¢' 5 4 5 6 T 8 as follows :
aR (All values as mote-percentage.)
Single component acid glycerides:
GAz~----as X 100; G B z : b s X 100, etc.
T w o component ucid glycerides:
T I M E (HOURS) GArB = 3 ~ b X 100; GAeC ---- 3 a~c X 100; GABz = 3 ab.~ X 100,
etc.
FIG. 1. Esterifieation of equivalent quantities of peanut oil Three component acid glycerides:
GAB0 ---- 6 abc X 100; GABD ---- 6 abd X 100; GBCD = 6 bad X
acids and glycerol a.t various temperatures. 100, etc.
552 TItE JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN OIL CHEMISTS' SOCIETY VOL. 31
50
40 J
~30 J
J
o o~ I ].s ~ 15 $ 3.S 4 iI5 ° I0
MOLES OF ADDED ELYCEROL REACTING WITH ONE MOLE OFFATOF M.W. 8?0
5.2 10~57 21.14 31.71 42,28 52,85 105,,7
WEIGHT-% OF GLYCEROL AOD[O TO I MOLE OF FAT
esterified to give surface-active monoesters and, using :FIG. 6. Esterifieation of linseed fatty acids with stoichiomet-
low molecular weight f a t t y acids, they give diesters tic quantities of glycerol, pentaerythritol and dipentaerythritol
which are vinyl plasticizers. Saturated esters mar- at 232°C. and with sorbitol doillg a 4:1 molar ratio of fatty
keted as polyoxyethylene stearate haxe been used as acid to polyol.
bread softeners, b u t their application for this pur-
pose has been currently banned, pending accumula- esterification of pentaerythritol (42), dipentaerythri-
tion of additional toxicity information. Although the tol (62), and sorbitol (63). Both sorbitol monoesters
monoestcrs may be prepared b y direct esterification, and sorbitol monoesters reacted f u r t h e r with ethylene
a more elegant synthesis involves direct addition of oxide are marketed as nonionic surface-active agents.
ethylene oxide to the f a t t y acid in the presence of an The esterification of erythritol (41, 42, 64), trimeth-
alkaline catalyst (61). ylol propane (42), and inositol (64, 65) have been
I~COOH -~- CH2-CH2 , RC:OOC!H2CIt~OIt - - - - - - --> considered in papers dealing primarily with other
\/ polyols. Tetramethylol eyclohexanol (TMC), a penta-
O h y d r o x y alcohol derived from reaction of formalde-
RC!O,OCH~CH~(O CIt..CH~)nOH
hyde with cyclohexanone, shows an initial rate of
A mixture of mono-, di-, tri-, tetra-, etc., ethylene esterification similar to glycerol during the stage of
glycol monoesters are formed, the mean chain length p r i m a r y h y d r o x y l reaction. D u r i n g later stages of
is determined by the molar ratio of f a t t y acid to reaction the secondary h y d r o x y l of glycerol esterifies
ethylene oxide. more rapidly than the hindered secondary h y d r o x y l
H i g h e r polyol esters of unsaturated f a t t y acids are of TMC (66).
of particular importance in drying oil technology. Xylitol (67, 68), alpha methyl D-glucoside (65),
The principal polyhydric alcohol is pentaerythrit~l, and the hexitols, inositol (69), pinitol, and quebrach-
but a wide range of polyols has been considered. itol (64), have all been esterified with drying oil acids.
When highly unsaturated f a t t y acids are esterified The latter paper (64) compares esterification of a
with polyhydric alcohols, especially alcohols having number of polyols, using xylene as an azeotrope.
more than three reactive hydroxyl groups, the result- Sugar esters cannot be prepared by direct esterifi-
ant ester will polymerize if temperatures are too high. cation because of earamelization of sugar at normal
The polymerization can lead to high viscos~kv or even esterification temperatures. Fatty acid chlorides in
gelation before an adequate reduction in acidity is tertiary amines have been used for preparation of
attained. Konen, Clocker, and Cox (41) esterified lin- such esters (70).
seed acids with a group of polyols and selected 232°C. Polyvinyl alcohol esters cannot be prepared di-
(450°F.) as an optimum temperature. A t higher tem- rectly because of the insolubility of the polyol in
peratures the rate of polymerization increased quite f a t t y acids. Rheineck used phenol as a mutual sol-
sharply without appreciable increase in the rate of vent for esterification (71). Polyvinyl esters have
esterification. Figure 6 illustrates the esterification also been prepared by interesterification of methyl
of linseed acids with several polyols, using vacuum- esters and vinyl acetate (72).
processing at 232°C. with a stoichiometric amount of Phosphite esters have been described as catalysts
polyol. The rate of esterifieamtion is a function of the for esterification of phenolic resins with f a t t y acids
type of hydroxyl groups. Pentaerythritol and dipen- (73). Similar catalysts have been claimed as color-
taerythritol having only p r i m a r y hydroxyls esterify stabilizers in esterifieation of dibasic acids (74). Ki-
most rapidly. Glycerol having two p r i m a r y and one netics of esterification of poly-alcoholic resins with
secondary hydroxyl esterifies more slowly. Sorbitol f a t t y acids have been reviewed b y Rubin (75).
has six hydroxyls, two p r i m a r y and four secondary, Esterification of tall oil presents a difficult problem
b u t u n d e r esterification conditions internal dehydra- because of the drastic conditions required to accom-
tion occurs and from a practical standpoint only four plish reaction of the rosin acids. Dunlap investigated
hydroxyls are available, one p r i m a r y and three sec- the selective esterification of tall oil, using glycerol
ondary. In line with the hydroxyl type this polyol and pentaerythritol (76). B o t h f a t t y acid acidity and
esterifies still more slowly. Specific papers cover rosin acid acidity were determined during the esteri-
554 THE JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN OIL CHEMISTS' SOCIETY VOL. 31
In the methanolysis of oils at moderately low tem- Feuge and Bailey demonstrated that the glycerolysis
peratures smaller proportions of methyl alcohol give of triglyeerides in the presence of sodium hydroxide
higher conversions to methyl ester because of the fa- as a catalyst gave essentially statistical distribution
vorable effect of glycerol precipitation, which would of mono-, di-, and triglyeeride (54). Figure 3 illus-
remain in solution using higher proportions of methyl trates such composition. As was pointed out in the
alcohol (91). discussion of esterifieation of fatty acids by glycerol,
W r i g h t studied alcoho]ysis of methyl ester by the limiting factor in determining the composition of
higher alcohols, such as furfuryl, tetrahydrofurfuryl, the reaction mixture is the solubility of glycerol at
benzyl and methyl cellosolve, removing the liberated reaction temperature. Dioxane and tertiary amines
methyl alcohol by distillation (4). Using lead soaps have been used as a mutual solvent to permit higher
as catalysts, relatively high temperatures of 200°C. monoglyceride yields (58, 59).
were required in alcoholysis of glycerides, which pro- If the homogeneous aleoholysis mixture containing
ceeds readily even at room temperature with alkali alkaline catalyst is cooled slowly, glycerol separates,
metal hydroxides. upsetting the equilibrium composition. Re-equilibra-
The aleoholysis procedure is normally much sim- tion occurs to give a new distribution of partial esters
pler than esterifieation for preparation of lower alkyl corresponding to the amount of glycerol remaining in
esters. In some eases it permits ester formation which the solution phase. During gradual cooling in the
could not be accomplished by direct esterification. presence of catalyst the quantity of monoglyceride
For instance, furfuryl alcohol cannot be esterified di- can be seriously .reduced. It was pointed out that
rectly in the presence of acid catalysts because under addition of strong phosphoric acid at the optimum
these conditions rapid polymerization of the alcohol alcoholysis temperature destroys the alkaline catalyst
takes place. Aleoholysis of oils with furfuryl alcohol and permits maintenance of maximum monoglyceride
proceeded readily, using 0.5% of sodium metal as a content during cooling (99, 59).
catalyst (92). At high temperatures monoglycerides decompose to
Methanolysis of triglycerides, using an anion ex- give glycerol, and under vacuum steam-distillation
change resin, has been suggested (93), and cation conditions glycerol can be removed nearly completely,
exchange resins have also been checked but found to leaving a still residue of triglyeeride. The deeompo-
be relatively ineffective (94). sition is accelerated by traces of alkaline catalysts and
The alcoholysis of fats and oils with low molecular to a lesser extent by acids. Arrowsmith and Ross
weight alcohols, followed by distillation of the ester report that, if an aleoholysis mixture is carefully
fraction, has been suggested for concentration or puri- adjusted to a pH of 6-7, the monoglycerides in a
fication of vitamins and sterols (95). Alkyl esters technical monoglyceride (approximately 50% mono-
have been suggested as intermediates in soap making glyceride content) can be distilled under vacuum
(96). The a]eohotysis procedure permits relatively (100, 101). Distillation using normal high vacuum
simple recovery of glycerol in high6r concentrations technique has been extended commercially to molecu-
than are obtained in regular aqueous saponification. lar distillation (102). Starting with a technical prod-
uet containing 40-50% of monoglyceride, distillates
Alcoholysis by Polyhydric Alcohols of 90-97% monoglyceride content can be obtained at
Alcoholysis of fats and oils with polyhydric alcohols sufficiently low t e m p e r a t u r e s and in a sufficiently
is far more important technically than reaction with r a p i d time to limit decomposition. By use of three
monohydric alcohols. Acidic materials are quite in- stages of centrifugal short-path distillation Kuhrt re-
effective as catalysts, and reaction in the absence of ports that almost instantaneous removal of monoglyc-
catalyst is inappreciable at practical operating tem- eride is observed with limited decomposition (103).
peratures. For instance, alcoholysis of soybean oil The time factor is important since it was indicated
with pentaerythritol in the absence of catalyst re- that at 100°C. a 10% loss in monoglyceride content
quired a temperature of 280°C. (42). Alkali metal required a heating period of more than 8 hours
hydroxides, carbonates, and alkoxides are very effec- whereas at 230°C. 10% reversion will occur in as
tive as catalysts, and the oxides and oil-soluble soaps little as 5 rain.
o f calcium, barium, lead, lithium, zinc, cadmium, and Alcoholysis of glycerides by other polyols utilizes
strontium are somewhat less effective but may present essentially the same procedures developed for glyc-
some advantages in color of products. Because of the erol. Burrell (42) studied the pentaerythritolysis of
relative insolubility of higher polyol in fats it is. nec- linseed and soybean oils. A variety of metal salts as
essary to operate at relatively high temperatures of naphthenates, stearates, or abietates were examined as
200-230°C. in order to maintain homogeneous reaction catalysts at a 1% level in the alcoholysis of soybean
conditions. oil with 24% of pentaerythritol at 230°C.
Alcoholysis with glycerine is an important indus- The solution of pentaerythritol in the reaction mix-
trial reaction for preparation of a variety of partial ture was taken as an end-point to indicate alcoholysis
esters. ~ Sodium hydroxide has been a favored cata- and was found to correspond closely to the familiar
lyst for alcoholysis to give edible products (97, 98) alcohol solubility test. Calcium naphthenate was par-
whereas calcium o.xide and litharge, which give cal- tieularly effective, giving clarity in 5 rain. with bet-
cium and lead soaps, are favored for alcoholysis dur- ter color than could be obtained using lead naphthen-
ing manufacture of alkyd resins and modified drying ate or litharge. Burrell then compared the reactivity
oils. As alcoholysis proceeds to give a mixture of of various polyols in the alcoholysis of soybean oil at
glycerol and mono-, di-, and triglycerides, the prod- 230°C., using 1% of calcium naphthenate.
uct becomes progressively more soluble in polar sol- The speed of aleoholysis appears to be partially a
vents. Solubility in 4 to 5 volumes of methyl or ethyl function of type of hydroxyls; the primary reacts
alcohol is frequently used as a criterion for complete- more rapidly than the secondary. The rate is also
ness. of alcoholysis. undoubtedly a function of polyol solubility in oil.
556 THE JOURNAL OF THE AMEI~ICAN OIL CHEMISTS' SOCIETY VOL. 31
ably reacting with free hydroxyl groups in fats to s a t u r a t e d g l y c e r i d e , crystallizes from the reaction
form complex alkoxides. With such catalysts random mass. This removal of an insoluble component upsets
distribution is obtained in a matter of minutes at low the equilibrium, and more trisaturated glyceride is
temperatures of 50-60°C. Appreciable catalytic ae- formed in an attempt to reproduce statistical distri-
tivity is even observed at sub-zero temperatures. bution in the homogeneous liquid phase. Precipita-
The r e a c t a n t s in esterification, alcoholysis, a n d tion continues as determined b y the solubility of the
acidolysis reactions are all catalysts for interesteri- fully saturated glyeerides at the final reaction tem-
fication although they are relatively inefficient and perature. F o r oils such as cottonseed and menhaden,
function only at relatively high temperatures. A small containing approximately 25'% of saturated acids, as
amount of water (125) hydrolyzes triglycerides to much as 18 to 24% of the total acids of the oil can be
give f a t t y aeid and diglyceride. If re-esterifieation separated as trisaturated glycerides in an interesteri-
occurs, involving a different f a t t y acid f r o m t h e one fieation period of approximately one week at gradu-
originally split off, a new ester is formed together ally lowered temperatures down to 10°C. I f such an
with water, which can go through the hydr<>lysis- interesterified product is warmed in the presence of
esterification cycle. Volatility of water under atmos- the catalyst to a t e m p e r a t u r e above the melting
pheric pressure limits the potential of this reaction, point, the mixture reverts to statistical distribution.
but in an autoclave at high temperature it repre- In order to retain the directed distribution =with high
sents an effective method for interesterifieation. The content of fully saturated glycerides, the catalyst is
alcohol split off (a diglyeeride in the case of fat hy- destroyed at low temperature by addition of acids or
drolysis) may react with a triglyeeride by way of the water. Subsequent washing, crystallization (with or
aleoholysis reaction to form a different triglyceride without solvent), and filtration separates the inter-
and a new diglyceride. Use of monoglycerides for esterified oil into a solid fraction, having a high satu-
catalysis of interesterification, p a r t i c u l a r l y in the rated acid content and low iodine value, and a liquid
presence of alkaline catalysts., has been described b y fraction, having a lower saturated acid content and a
several investigators (126, 127, 128). Similarly, the higher iodine value.
acid may displace a different f a t t y acid from a tri- Application of this directed interesterification with
glyceride to form a new gtyeeride molecule, liberating subsequent separation of solid glycerides has potential
a different f a t t y acid to continue the interchange value for upgrading of drying oils. Soybean oil, for
reaction. instance, contains about 14-16% of saturated acids,
Such interesterifieation through the aeidolysis reac- which are held almost without exception on glyeer-
tion is of particular importance during heat bodying ides containing two unsaturated acids (136). On a
of oils. F a t t y acids are liberated partially through mole % basis about 45-50% of soybean oil consists of
hydrolysis and partially through eracking and ther- these monosaturated-diunsaturated glycerides, which
mal breakdown. Simultaneously the p o l y e t h e n o i d during drying can form only linear polymers, if it is
acids undergo polymerization chiefly to give dimers assumed that each unsaturated acid has. a function-
although higher polymers are also formed. Inter- ality of only one. By removal of all of the. saturated
change of acyl groups between glyeerides and liber- acids the iodine value of soybean oil would be raised
ated acids produces new esters and new acids until from an average value of approximately 135 up to
ultimately a random or statistical distribution of sat- appro.ximately 160. In practice the maximum iodine
urated acids, unpolymerized unsaturated acids, and value practically attainable is about 148 to 154. This
polymerized acids is obtained on glyceride molecules requires appreciable removal of saturated acids and
(126, 129, 130, 131). results in an oil of improved drying potential.
In another modification of the same principle of in-
Directed Interesterification
teresterification with precipitation of glyceride, alka-
In the absence of a directing influence, interesteri- line catalyst is added to chilled oils containing a
fication can give only a statistical glyceride distribu- solid crystalline grain (137, 138). In the ease of most
tion. This reaction is commercially important in the oils the crystals present i n the chilled product con-
case of lard. L a r d has a narrow plastic range, that tain a preponderance of disaturated-monounsaturated
is, there is a relatively short temperature range in glyeerides, and these act as crystal nuelei or seed in-
which lard has good working properties as a shorten- ftneneing subsequent interesterifieation to give contin-
ing. Above this range the consistency is too soft and uing separation of the disaturated-mononnsaturated
below, lard is too firm. L a r d creams poorly and gives glycerides. With long storage there is gradual re-solu-
poor cake volume (132). Interesterification of lard tion of the disaturated glycerides and precipitation
widens the plastic range, increases creaming and cake of the less. soluble trisaturated glyeerides. The method
volume and improves appearance (133, 134, 135). The has potential value in the edible oil field for produe-
rearrangement of lard coupled with application of tion of margarine oils and puff pastes, b u t there is
butylated hydroxyanisole as an antioxidant makes only limited potentiality in the drying oil field since
lard more competitive with hydrogenated vegetable the conversion of saturated acids to insoluble glycer-
shortenings. ide forms does not proceed to a sufficient extent to
Several methods have been described for obtaining remove a large proportion of the saturated acids.
non-statistical orientation. The "Directed Rearrange- A closely allied reaction involves aleoholysis under
m e n t " process of Eekey (51, 123), in which interes- conditions similar to those used in the directed inter-
terification takes place with simultaneous crystalliza- esterification. I f glycerol is added to an oil which is
tion, represents a partieular!y valuable extension of undergoing interesterification, the process becomes a
the interesterification reaction. If a liquid reaction mixed one of aleoholysis and interesterification since
mixture of a glyceride and an alkaline catalyst (so- the same catalysts are active for both reactions (139,
dium alkoxide, sodium metal, sodimn hydride, etc.) 140, 141). This ester-alcohol exehange produces an
is gradually cooled, the least soluble component, tri- equili.brimn mixture containing glycerol, monoglycer-
558 THE JOURNAL OF TI-IE A M E R I C A N 0IL CHEMISTS' SOCIETY VOL. 31
ide, diglyceride, and triglyceride. At lower levels of modification of fats and oils. Very real potential ex-
glycerol up to 5% selective crystallization of diglyc- ists for more widespread industrial application of this
eride takes place, and at higher glycerol levels of method.
10% quite pure monoglyceride precipitates. At an REFERENOES
intermediate level both partial esters separate. This 1. Eckey, E. W., "Vegetable Fats and Oils," pp. 134-149, Reinhold
selective precipitation of partial glycerol esters is Publishing Corporation, New York (1954).
2. Markley, K. S., "]t~atty Acids," pp. 254-313, Intorscience Publish-
mpre nearly complete than the triglyceride precipita: ers Inc., New York (1947).
3. Norris, F. A., Oil and Soap, 17, 257 ( 1 9 4 0 ) .
ti0n and permits removal of virtually all saturated 4. Wright, H. J., Segur, J. B., Clark, H. V., C'oburn, S. K., Lang-
acids from the rearranging fat. don, E. E., and DuPuis, R. N., Oil and Soal~, $0, 145 (1944).
5. Van Loon, C., Chem. Weekblad., 47, 494 (1951).
Directed interesterification reactions can also be 6. Alexander, E. R., " I o n i c Organic Reactions," p. 224, John Wiley
and Sons, New York (1950).
effected by removal of a volatile component. Trieleo- 7. Remick, A. E., "Electronic Interpretation of Organic Chemistry,"
stearin cannot be prepared by" direct esterification of 2nd ed., pp. 408-419, John Wiley and So,ns, New York, (1949).
8. Smith, H. A., and Reichardt, C. H., J. Am. Chem. So c., 63, 605
the acid with glycerol since polymerization occurs (1941).
9. Hinshelwood, C. N., and Legard, A. R., J. Chem. Soc., 1935, 587.
simultaneously with esterification. The glycerol ester 10. Fairclougb, t¢. A., and ttinshelwood, C. N., J. Chem. Soc., 1989,
can be prepared by interesterification of methyl eleo- 593.
11. Thomas, E. R., and Sudborough, J. J., J. Cllem. Soc., 101, 317
stearate and triacetin in the presence of sodium me- (1912).
12. Youngs, C. G., and Craig, B. M., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc.,
thoxide l:lnder vacuum (41). As methyl acetate is 28, 521 (1951).
formed by the interchange, it is removed, ultimately 13. Longenecker, H. E., Oil and Soap, 17, 53 (1940).
14. Hilditch, T. P., "The Chemical Constitution of Natural Pats,"
giving relatively pure trieleostearin. In an analogous 2nd ed., pp. 474-512, John Wiley and Sons, New York (1947).
15. Wyman, F. W., and Barkenbus, C., Ind. Eng'. Chem., Anal. Ed.,
way Eckey prepares fatty polyvinyl esters by inter- 12, 658 (1940).
esterification between polyvinyl acetate and methyl 16. Norris, F. A., and Terry, D. E., Oil and Soap, 22, 41 (1945).
17. McNicoll, D., J. Soe. Chem. Ind., 40, 124T (1921).
esters of fatty acids (72). 18. Anderson, R. H., and Wheeler, D. H., Oil and Soap, 22, 137
(1945).
A somewhat related displacement is obtained when 19. American Oil Chemists' Society, Official :Method D~ 12-48.
methyl esters of higher molecular weight acids arc 20. Gloyer, S. W., Ind. Eng. Ohem., 40, 228 (1948).
21. Butts, D. C., U. S. Pat. 1,979,671 (1934).
heated with glycerides of lower average molecular 22. Karser, H. E., U. S. Pat. 2,074,963 (1937).
23. Johnston, A. C., U. S. Pat. 1,840,395 (1932).
weight in the presence of an interesterification cata- 24. Lovesgue, C. L., and Craig, A. :M., Ind. Eng. Chem., 40, 96
lyst (142, 143). Lower molecular weight methyl es- (1948).
25. :Musselman, J. M., U. S. Pat. 2,399,243 (1946).
ters are removed by vacuum-distillation, leaving a 26. :Morway, A. J., and Zimmer, J. C., U. S. Pat. 2,217,764 (1940).
27. Reppe, W., Ger. Pat. 588,352 ( 1 9 3 3 ) ; U. S. Pat. 2,066,075
glyceride of changed composition. (1936).
Interesting possibilities exist for interesterification 28. Powers, P. O., Ind. Eng. Chem., 38, 837 (1946).
29. Swern, Daniel, a.nd Jordan, E. F., J. Am. Chem. Soc., 70, 2334
involving combinations of fats or combinations of fats (1948).
30. Jordan, E. F., and Swern, Daniel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 71, 2377
with simple esters. Tung oil is subject to crazing and (1949).
wrinkling during film drying unless it has been heat 31. Barnitz, E. S., J. Am. 0ii Chemists' Soc., 26, 104 (1949).
32. Port, W. S., Hansen, J. E., Jordan, E. F., Dietz, T. J., and
treated partially to isomerize and polymerize the eleo- Swern, Daniel, J. Polymer Sci., 7, 207 (1951).
33. Port, W. S., Jordan, E. F., H~ansen, J. E., and Swern, Dwniel,
stearic acid. This drying defect is probably caused J. Polymer Sci., 9, 493 (1953).
by trieleostearin, which would statistically be present 34. Teeter, I-I. M., and Cowan, J. C!., 0il and Soap, 22, 177 (1945).
35. Van Sehaack, 1~. H., U. S. P a t 1,820,623 ( 1 9 3 1 ) ; U. S. Pat.
to an extent of not less than 60%. Simple blends of 1,697,295 (1929).
36. Earh~art, K. A., and Rubin, B. U., U. S. Pat. 2,308,498' (1943).
tung oil and soybean oil which might be used in house 37. Seheij, L. T. C., l%e,c, tray. chim., 18, 169 ( ] 8 7 9 ) .
paints also showed this deficiency in the dried films. 38. Gaerner, T. L., J. Soc. Chem. Ind., 47, 278T ( ] 9 2 8 ) .
39. Bellueci, I., Gazz. chim. itaI., 42, I I , 283 ( ] 9 1 2 ) .
By interesterification to give a redistribution of tung 40. Long, J. S., Kittelberger, W. S., Scott, L. K., and Egge, W. S.,
Ind. Eng. Chem., 21, 950 (1929).
acids and soybean acids, "gas-proofing" can be at- 41. Konen, J. C., Clocker, E. T., and Cox, R. P., Oil and Soap, 22,
tained at low temperatures. A simple blend, for in- 57 (1945).
42. Burrell, H., 0il and Soap, 20, 206 (1944).
stance, of 1 part of tung oil and 2 parts of soybean 43. American Oil Chemists' Society, Official Method Ea 4-38.
44. Mehlenhaeher, V. (~., Determination of Hydroxyl Groups, "Or-
oil, would contain approximately 20% of trieleoste- ganic Analysis," voh I, 1-65, Interscience Publishers Inc., New York
arin. An interesterified mixture of the same compo- (~953).
45. Feuge, R. O., Vieknair, E. J., and Lovegran, N. V., J. Am. Oil
sition would contain only 2.3% of trieleostearin, an Chemists' See., 29, 11 (1952).
46. Baur, F. J., J. Am. Oil Chemists, Soc., 31, 196 (1954).
amount insufficient to affect film characteristics. Such 47. Baur, F. J., U. S. Pat. 2,615,160 (1952).
interesterified tung-soybean combinations were mar- 48. Bertheh)t, M., Compt. rend., 36, 27 ( 1 8 5 3 ) ; 88, 668 ( 1 8 5 4 ) ;
Ann. chim. phys., 41, 216 (1854).
keted for house paint use when both tung and soybean 49. Feuge, R. 0., Kraemer, E. A , and Bailey, A. E., Oil and Soap,
22, 202 (1945).
oils were lower in cost than linseed oil. Calcium soaps 50. Bhattaeharya, R., and Hilditch, T. P., Proc. Royal Soc. (Lon-
have been preferred catalysts for such reactions, and den), A1~9, 472 (1930).
51. Eckey, E. W., Ind. Eng. Chem., 40, 1183 (1948).
Reutenauer suggested interesterification of linseed oil 52. Nerris, F. A., and :Mattil, K. F., Oil and Soap ~3, 289 (1946).
53. Kawai, S., J. Soc. Chem. Ind. Japan, 44, Suppl. Bind., 244
with rape and safflower oils as a means of extending ( 1 9 4 1 ) ; C. A. 44, 8137 (1950).
linseed oil supply during periods of shortage or high 54. Feuge, R. 0., and Bailey, A. E., Oil and Soap, 23, 2 5 9 (1946).
55. Hilditch, T. P., and l~igg, J. G., J. Chem. Soc., 1935, 1774
cost (144). 56. Petit, J., Am. P a i n t Journal, 38, 82 ( ] 9 4 8 ) .
Fats can be interesterified with simple esters such 57. Savary, P., Oleagine~ux, 4, 155 (1949).
58. Eckey, E. W., and Richardson, A. S., U. S. Pat. 2,251,693
as acetates, butyrates, etc., to give mixed glycerides. (1941).
59. Mattil, K. F., and Sims, R. J., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc., 29,
There is both industrial and edible significance for 59 (1952).
such modifications. Interesterification between fat tri- 60. Goldsmith, H. A., Chem. Rev., 33, 257-349 (1943).
61. Scholler, C., and Witwer, M., Get. Pat. 694,178 (1940).
glycerides and triacetin may be used for preparation 62. Burrell, H., Ind. Eng. C~hem., 37, 86 (1945).
63. Brandner, J. D., Hunter, R. H., Brewstor, :M. D., and Bonner,
of acetoglycerides (46, 47). Use of a large excess R. E., Ind. Eng. Chem., 37, 809 (1945).
of triacetin (0.5 parts per part of fat) gives prima- 64. ]~heineck, A. E., and Brice, R. M., "Pinitol and Quebrachitol
Esters of Linseed Patty Acids," presented at 27th Fall Meeting of the
rily diaceto g]ycerides, waxy, translucent fats having American Oil Chemists' Society, Nov. (1953).
pronlise as plasticizers, high temperature spreads, and 65. Gibbons, J. P., and Janke, R. A., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc., 28,
456 (1951).
edible protective coatings for foods. 66. Wittcoff, I-I., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc., 26, 157 (1949).
67. Carson, J. P., and :Maclay, W. D., J. Am. Chem. Soe., 66, 1609
Although interesterifieation was recognized long (1944).
ago, it has only been in recent years that intensive 68. Teeter, I-I. :M., Bell, E. W., and Cowan, J. C., J. Am. Oil Ohem-
ists' Soe., 28, 299 (1951).
study has been given to the reaction as a means of 69. Bolley, D. S., Ind. Eng. Chem., 41, 287 (1949).
NOVEMBER 1954 FORMO.' ESTER REACTIONS 559
70. Rheineck, A. E., Rabin, B., and Long, J. S., U. S. Pat. 2,077,- 106. Barkenbus, C., Roswell, C. A., and Mitts, A . E . , J. Am. C.hem.
371 (1937). Soe., 62, 1251 (1940).
71. P~heine~k, A. E., J. Am. 0il Chemists' Soc., 28, 456 (1951). 107. Schwartz, G. L., U. S. Pat.. 1,558,299 ( 1 9 2 5 ) .
72'. Eckey, E. W , [L S. Pat. 2,558,518 (1951). 108. Norman, W., Gor. Pat. 407,180 (1929).
73. Harrison, S. A., U. S. Pat. 2,622,071 (1952). 109. Eckey, E. W., U. S. Pat. 2,378,006 (1945).
74. Jundson, B. E., U. S. Pat. 2,612,515 (1952). 110. Kuempfe, G-., Farben-Ztg., 40, 1009 (1935).
75. l~ubin, W., J. 0il and Colour Chem. Assn., 35, No. 386, 418 111. Powers, P. O. Ind. Eng. Chem., 42, 146 ( ! 9 5 0 ) .
(1952). 112. Albert, K., Ger. Pat.. 555,812 (1932).
76. Dunlap, L. I-I., Hassel, L. V., and Maxwell, J., J. Am. Oil Chem- 1 1 3 . Greth, A., and Lemmer, F., U. S. Pat. 2,217,363 (1940).
ists' Soc., 27, 361 (1950). 114. Scheiber, J., Farbe u. Lack, 1929, 393, 404, 418.
77. Gourley, S., J. Oil and Colour Chem. Assn., 33, No. 358, 175 115. Friedel, C., and Crafts, J. R., Ann., 133, 207 (1865).
(1950). 116. Van Loon, C., Dutch Pat. 16,703 (1924).
78. Mueller, E. R., Eness, P. L., and ~[cSweeney, E. E., Ind. Eng. 117. Normann, W., Gex. Pat. 417,215 (1925).
Chem., 42, 1532 (1950). 118. Hilditch, T. P., "The Chemical Constitution of Natural Fats,"
79. Clocker, E. T., U. S. Pats. 2,188,882 to 890 (1940). 2nd ed., p. 15, John Wiley and Sons, New Ym-k (1947).
80. Teeter, H. M., Geerts, M. J., and Cowan, J. C., J. Am. Oil 119. Karth~, A. R. S., "Studies on the Natural Fats," vols. I and I [ ,
Chemists' Soc., 25, 158 (1948). Ernaeulum, I n d i a (1951).
81. Bickford, W. G., Krauczunas, P., a n d Wheeler, R. H., Oil and 120. I)esnuelle, P., and Naudet, M., Bull. Soc. chem., 1946, 90, 595;
Soap, 19, 23 (1942). 1947, 323.
82. Schwarcman, A., U. S. Pats. 2,412,176; 2,412,177,(1946). 121. Van Loon, C., U. S. Pat. 1,873,513 (1932).
83. Rochleder, F., Ann. 59, 260 (1861). 122. Barker, C., Crawford, R. V., and Hilditch, T. P., J. Chem.
84. :Hailer, A., Obmpt. rend., 143, 657 (1906). S~c., 1951, 1194.
85. Jones, M., and Lapworth, A., Proc. C~em. Soe., London, 36, 123. Eekey, E. W., U. S. Pats. 2,442,531, 2,442,532, 2,442,533,
141 (1914). 2,442,536, 2,442,537 (1948).
86. Belier, E. M., Compt. rend., 193, 1020 (1931) ; 194, 1655 (1932). 124. Eckey, E. W., U. S. PaL 2,558,547 (1951).
87. Re~d, E. E., Am. Chem. J., 45, 506 (1911). 125. Eckey, E. W., U. S. P a t 2,378,005 (1945).
88. Pardee, A. M., and Reid, E. E., Ind. Eng. Chem., 12, 129 126. Royce, I{. I)., U. S. Pat. 2,015,606 (1935).
(1920). 127. Bailey, A. E., Oil and Soap, 20, 132 (1943).
89. Anderson, E., and Pierce, I~. B., J. Phys. Ohem., 22, 44 (1918). 128. Gooding, C. M., U. S. Pat. 2,309,94.9 (1943).
90. Feuge, R. O., and Gros, A. T., J. Am. 0il Chemists' Soe., 26, 129. Cowan, J. C., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc., 27, 492 ( ] 9 5 0 ) .
97 (1949). 130. Pasehke, R. F., and Wheeler, I). H., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc.,
91. Bradshaw, G. B., and Meuly, W. C., U. S. Pat. 2,360,844 (1944). 31, 208 (1954).
92. Norris, ]~. A., and Terry, I) E., 0il and Soap, 20, 193 (1944). 131. Anderson, L. ~J., and Porter, J. V., Ind. Eng. C:hem., 41, 741
93. Schlenk, H., and Holman, R. T., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc., 30, (1949).
103 (1953). 132. Bailey, A. E., " I n d u s t r i a l 0il and F a t Products," 1st ed., pp.
94. Sussman, S., Ind. Eng. Chem., 38, 1228 (1946). 280-284, Interseience Publishers I n c . , New York (1945).
95. Trent, R. T., U. S. Pat. 2,432,181 (1945). 133. Ibid., p. 682.
96. Holmberg, J., Acta Polytech., 45 (1949). 134. Mattil, K. F., and Nelson, I)., U. S. Pat. 2,625,483 (1953).
97. Edelev, A., and P~ichardson, A. S., Can. Pats. 340,803-05 (1934). 135. Vanderwal, R. J., and Akkeren, L. A., U. S. Pat. Reissue
98. Christ~nson, C. W., U. S. Pat. 2,022,493 (1935). 23,499 (1952).
99. Eckey, E. W., and Clark, C. C., U S. Pat. 2,065,520 (1936). 136. ~Iilditch, T. P., Meara, M. L., and Holmberg, J., J. Am. Oil
100. Arrowsmith, ~. J., and P~oss, J., U. S. Pat. 2,383,581 (1945). Chemists' See., 24, 321 (1947).
IOl. l~oss~ J., Bell, A. C., Arrowsmith, C. J., and Gebhart, H. tI., 137. Abbott, A. I)., U. S. Pat. 2,442,538 (1948).
Oil and Soap, 23, 257 (1946). 138. Eckoy, E. W., U. S. Pat. 2,442,535 (1948).
102. Kuhrt, N. H., Welch, E. A., and Kovarik, F. J., J. Am. Oil 139. Eckey, E. W., and l~ormo, M. W., J. Am. Oil C.hemists' Soc.,
Chemists~ Soe., 27, 310 (1950).
26, 207 (1949).
140. Eckey, E. W., U. S. Pat. 2,442,534 (1948).
103. K a h r t , N. H., U. S. Pat. 2,634,278 (1953). 141. B a u r , F. J., and Lunge, W., J'. Am. Chem. Soc., 73, 3926
104. Chipault, J., and Lundberg, W. O., Ann. R ep. Hormel Inst. (1951).
1946-47, 42. 142. Eckey, E. W., U. S. Pats. 2.378,005 and 2,378,007 (1945).
105. Gros, A. T., and Feuge, R. 0., J. Am. Oil Chemists' Soc., 26, 143. Naudet, M., I)esnuelle, P., Oleagineaux, 7, 335 (1952).
704 (1949). 144. Reutenauer, G., and Sisley, J. P., Oleagineaux, 3, 305 (1948).