Ultra Urban Green Infrastructure Guidelines Manual PDF
Ultra Urban Green Infrastructure Guidelines Manual PDF
Ultra Urban Green Infrastructure Guidelines Manual PDF
a n
b ide
r
-U ture
li n e s
lt ra Gu
U In tr uc
f ra s
re e n
G
Acknowledgments
The Ultra-Urban Green Infrastructure Guidelines manual was a partnership between City and County of Denver (CCD) and Urban
Drainage and Flood Control District (UDFCD). CCD and UDFCD specifically acknowledges the following individuals who contributed to
the publication of these guidelines:
Project Leads
Sarah Anderson, Denver Public Works
Holly Piza, Urban Drainage and Flood Control District
1. Introduction 1
1.1 Project Purpose 1
1.2 Audience 1
1.3 Regional Considerations 1
3. References 16
Each practice within these guidelines has been chosen for its 1.3 REGIONAL CONSIDERATIONS
suitability in Denver’s ultra-urban environment and in particular Special consideration has been given to providing guidance
for use in the right-of-way (ROW). Treating street runoff is suitable for Denver’s semi-arid climate and unique system of
critical to improving the health of Denver’s urban waterways. administering surface water rights.
Not only are streets a major source of stormwater runoff, they
also represent the largest source of urban pollutants including SEMI ARID CLIMATE
sediment, heavy metals, automotive fluids, nutrients, and Denver’s semi-arid climate requires modifying green
trash. As part of the stormwater conveyance system, roads infrastructure practices adopted from other U.S. locations.
collect and carry runoff directly to the underground storm drain Stormwater controls typically must be xeriscaped with a focus
on native plants, because they use less water and perform better
in the semi-arid environment. A mix of North American natives
can be utilized to develop a plant palette that will tolerate both
periodic flooding and drought. Though native species will likely
need supplemental irrigation during establishment, nonnative
plants generally will not survive without irrigation (WEF 2014).
permeable pavement system or in the bottom of an otherwise construction plans including existing utilities, spot elevations,
dry facility such as an extended detention basin). Groundwater and structural reinforcement for each installation. Plan review
quality protection is an issue that should be considered for checklists provided in Appendix A should also be used to assist
infiltration-based practices. with the design.
Infiltration practices may not be appropriate for land uses that 2.2.1 SIZING
involve storage or use of materials that have the potential to WATER QUALITY CAPTURE VOLUME AND
contaminate groundwater underlying a site (i.e., “hot spot” PEAK FLOW RATE
runoff from fueling stations, materials storage areas, etc.). The required WQCV for the upstream area draining to a green
If groundwater or soil contamination exists on a site (i.e., a infrastructure BMP shall be computed using the procedures in
brownfield), and the contamination will not be remediated or Urban Drainage and Flood Control District’s (UDFCD) Urban
removed as a part of construction, it may be necessary to avoid Storm Drainage Criteria Manual, Volume 3 (USDCM Vol. 3).
infiltration based practices or use a durable liner to prevent Additionally, the filter surface area for streetside stormwater
infiltration into areas contaminated with pollutants that could be planters, bumpouts and green gutters shall be sized at no less
mobilized by stormwater. than 2% of the tributary area. When it is beneficial to estimate a
peak flow rate associated with the water quality event for sizing
WATERSHED DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES hydraulic components, the rational method should be used as
When development in the watershed is phased or when erosive described in USDCM Volume 1 using the following parameters:
conditions (steep slopes, sparse vegetation, or sandy soils) Time of concentration, Tc = 5 minutes
exist in the watershed, a treatment train approach may be Water quality rainfall intensity at a Tc of 5 minutes =
appropriate. A treatment train approach uses BMPs in a 2.04 inches per hour (iph)
series and treats runoff by physical, chemical, and biological Runoff coefficient for impervious surfaces, Cwq= 0.84
processes. By including as many removal mechanisms as
possible in each BMP train, the ability to remove particular INLET SIZING
pollutants is increased. Inlet design is a critical component of many of the green
infrastructure BMPs. The street inlet must be located at the
Practices that use filtration should follow other measures upstream end of the BMP, must convey runoff from the curb
to collect sediment loads (e.g., a forebay). For phased and gutter across the step-out zone, and be sized to convey the
developments, these measures must be in place until the water quality event assuming an appropriate amount of debris
watershed is completely stabilized. When naturally erosive blockage. The inlet must also be designed to function in concert
conditions exist in the watershed, these measures should be with a forebay or pretreatment filter, which is intended to capture
permanent. The designer should consider existing, interim and the majority of litter, debris, and sediment entering the BMP.
future conditions to select the most appropriate practices.
Inlet layout is illustrated in plan and section in the fact sheet
2.2 DESIGN CRITERIA details. The inlet features a 2-inch depression in the flow line
These criteria are provided to assist the design team. Details of the gutter to help direct runoff into the opening and reduce
provided in this manual are not intended for construction plans. bypass flow. The inlet is shown as a chase type structure with
The design team must consider site-specific conditions a cover plate. The interior portion of the inlet box (bottom slab
and constraints and add an appropriate level of detail to the of the chase drain) should be sloped as indicated in the details
and a drop off should be provided from the invert of the chase 2.2.2 PEDESTRIAN CONSIDERATIONS AND
drain to the sediment collection pad or filter surface (for tree GEOMETRY
trenches), which should be at least 4 inches below the water
All of the water quality practices provided in this manual are
quality water surface. This allows for some amount of debris
designed for an urban setting and require design considerations
and sediment buildup without reducing stormwater conveyance
for the safety of the public. Considerations specific to individual
through the inlet.
BMPs are included in the fact sheets. The following pertain to
multiple green infrastructure practices.
The opening length of inlet required will vary depending on flow
rate and longitudinal slope. Figure 1 can be used to determine
the length of inlet required for a given upstream area (assumed PLANTER EDGE BARRIER
to be fully impervious). This figure is based on Equation 3 Edge barriers are applicable for various types of planters
from the Technical Memorandum, Hydraulic Efficiency of that include open landscape areas and are depressed below
Inlets Common to the UDFCD Region (UDFCD, 2011) for pedestrian areas. A visual and physical barrier along the
continuous grade applications. A debris factor of 10 percent perimeter of a planter is necessary to discourage deliberate
(as recommended in the Technical Memorandum ) is built in. or inadvertent entry by pedestrians because the top of the
planting media in the planters is depressed below the elevation
Pedestrian safety must also be kept in mind when establishing PLANTER LENGTH
the maximum depth of the planter, as measured from the adjacent
Planter length is set as necessary to:
pavement/walking surface to the top of the bioretention media.
1. Provide periodic access from one side of a planter to the
This depth should generally not exceed 16 inches. In general,
other;
it is recommended that the top of the bioretention media be
2. Provide required treatment volume; and
flat, regardless of street slope. This reduces longitudinal flow
3. Contain stormwater in the planter on sloping streets.
velocities and the potential for erosion of the media. The depth
from the sidewalk to the top of the media will decrease as the The maximum length of streetside and bumpout stormwater
street slopes in a downstream direction, “raising” vegetation planters based on pedestrian access is 40 feet. Denver street
relative to pedestrians. standards associated with raised objects call for an access
path every 40 feet to provide reasonable access for pedestrians
SIDEWALK DRAINAGE to exit a vehicle and get to the sidewalk. All access points
Small openings or gaps in the edge barrier opposite the street adjacent to streetside and bumpout stormwater planters shall
are typically provided in planters to provide drainage from the provide a minimum of 4 feet clear. This means that if signage or
sidewalk into the planter. These are typically openings 1 to 2 any other object is placed in the access path, distance between
inches high and 4 to 6 inches long or gaps in the sidewall 1 to planters must increase to provide a minimum clear width of 4
2 inches wide. Openings are recommended at approximately feet. Although these points are not part of the ADA accessible
10 feet intervals and the furthest downstream opening should route, it is recommended that (when required) reserved
be at least 10 feet from the downstream end of the planter accessible parking spots be located adjacent to access points.
to reduce outflows from the opening in events exceeding the In highly active areas it may be appropriate to provide more
water quality event. frequent or wider access points. Existing utilities may also limit
the length of the planter. Access points for green gutters should the maximum length the planter can be and still contain the
be evaluated for each site. Access points within green gutters water quality volume without spilling out of the sidewalk drains.
should not invite a pedestrian to cross at an inappropriate In rainstorms greater than the water quality event, runoff will
location. Where green gutters are located adjacent to parallel overflow back to the curb and gutter through a spillway, as
parking, a maximum spacing of 40 feet is appropriate and described below.
access points should be at grade with the parking space and at
least five feet wide. Where green gutters are located adjacent On streets with steeper slopes (greater than 2 percent), or
to a travel lane, a length of 40 feet may be exceeded as long as if sidewall drains are not used to provide drainage into the
consideration is given to the required length to retain the water planter, the top of the walls can be designed to be horizontal
quality water surface based on street slope. Alternatively, drops and parallel to the top of the media for the whole length of the
can be used to “stairstep” the WQCV as shown in the details, planter. In this case, the water quality water surface can be
providing a long continuous green gutter while maximizing retained within the planter even with steeper street slopes and
capture volume. a planter length up to 40 feet can be used rather than limiting
length based on Figure 4. A spillway should still be provided as
The maximum length of streetside and bumpout stormwater described below, with the crest at or above the water quality
planters based on street slope is shown in Figure 4, assuming water surface, to direct flows in excess of a water quality event
sidewalk drains are provided as shown in the details. This is back to the curb and gutter.
35
Maximum Planter Length, feet
30
25
(Source: Muller Engineering. 2015.)
20
15
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6%
Street Slope, %
Aged 6 months
Landscape mulch (where
Shredded mulch (minimum). No
applicable)
weed fabric allowed.
Class B Class C
CDOT filter 37.5 mm (1.5") 100
19.0 mm (0.75") 100
material Particle size
Underdrain 4.75 mm (No.4) 20-60 60-100
(Class B or distribution
aggregate 1.18 um (No. 16) 10-30
C as 300 um (No. 50) 0-10 10-30 required.
specified) 150 um (No. 100) 0-10
75 um (No. 200) 0-3 0-3
Pipe must conform to
Maximum requirements of ASTM
Minimum open area (per designation F949.There
Pipe diameter and type slot width
foot) shall be no evidence of
(inches)
Contech A-2000
splitting, cracking, or
Underdrain Pipe Required slotted pipe (or
4-inch slotted PVC 0.032 1.90 in.² breaking when the pipe is
equal)
tested per ASTM test
method D2412 in
accordance with F949
6-inch slotted PVC 0.032 1.98 in.² section 7.5 and ASTM F794
Thickness section 8.5.
0.76 mm
(30 mil) Test method
Thickness, % Tolerance +/-5 ASTM D 1593
Tensile strength, kN/m (lb/in) 12.25 (70) ASTM D8 82, method B Thermal welding required for
Modulus at 100% elongation, kN/m (lbs/in) 5.25 (30) ASTM D8 82, method B fully lined facilities (not a
Impermeable liner Ultimate elongation, % 350 ASTM D8 82, method A Required
cutain). Leak testing in the
Tear resistance, N(lbs) 38 (8.5) ASTM D 1004 field required.
Low temperature impact, ° C (° F) -29 (-20) ASTM D 1790
Volatile loss, % maximum 0.7 ASTM D8 82, method A
Pinholes, no. per 8 m² (no. per 10 yd.²) 1 (max) N/A
Bonded seam strength, % of tensile strength 80 N/A
to ward off infestation. In most instances weeds will need BMPs. Ideally, sediment and debris is removed from
to be extracted and physically removed from the site, not sediment collection pads prior to entering the vegetated
sprayed or pulled and left to wither (and scatter seeds). area. Removal of sediment from the vegetated area is much
• In addition to weed management, planters will require more disruptive and may require replacement of vegetation.
removal of leafy debris each fall (October) and cutting
back of perennials and grasses in late winter/early spring In some areas, additional consideration to facilitate maintenance
(March). may be achieved. Denver has success with forebays that can
be maintained as part of the street sweeping program.
TREE SPECIES AND PLACEMENT
Trees are encouraged and can be included in Streetside Forebays that can be cleaned as part of the street sweeping
Stormwater Planters, Bumpouts, and Tree Trenches. All program require a depression at the location of the BMP. This
tree species planted in Denver street rights-of-way must be will ensure capture of the volume to be treated while slowing
approved by the City Forester. A list of recommended species entry into the vegetated portion. This concept is effective by
is included in Appendix D. Trees are typically centered in the restricting entry and forcing some sedimentation to occur in
amenity zone between the step-out zone and the sidewalk. the forebay area. This can be achieved by using a curb with
Consideration needs to be given to width requirements for the several small orifices as shown in Figure 5 rather than one
sidewalk when placing trees. Per City Forester, trees may only large inlet opening. When located on a street sweeping route,
be placed in areas with a minimum width of 5 feet. In general, it this will ensure routine removal of sediment and debris from
is recommended that trees be placed 4 to 6 feet from the back the forebay. See Appendix B for maintenance and operation
of curb. Tree spacing along the street is discussed further in checklists relevant to the BMPs included in this manual.
the Tree Trench Fact Sheet.
2.4 ACCOMMODATING UTILITIES
2.3 DESIGNING FOR MAINTENANCE Utility conflicts may be the greatest physical constraint for
All of the BMPs in this manual have been designed with implementation of ultra-urban green infrastructure. Proper
consideration for maintenance. Sediment collection pads investigation of utilities during the planning and design
and forebays have been included to facilitate proactive and phase can save both time and money in construction. In
routine maintenance. These types of treatment facilities addition to locating and accommodating existing utilities, the
allow for routine maintenance to be done frequently and design of green infrastructure facilities must also consider
by personnel with limited expertise in green infrastructure future repair and replacement of all utilities in the area. It
should be determined during the planning and design phase Step 4: Replacement
what party is responsible for repairing damage to the green In order to have the green infrastructure facility work, the
infrastructure facility during maintenance on other utilities. utility lines must be replaced and/or relocated. This is the
most complex, cost-prohibitive and difficult design option to
Denver has adopted a 4-step approach to accommodating implement. However, in some cases, the age or pipe material
utilities. This approach begins with solutions that are both cost- of the utility line is a factor in selecting the solution. It might be
effective and easily implemented.As the steps progress, solutions more advantageous to plan on replacing an aging utility line
become both more costly and more difficult to implement. This during water quality improvements than to wait and replace it
approach was adapted from the San Mateo County Sustainable at a later date.
Green Streets and Parking Lots Guidebook (San Mateo, 2009). Potential Utility Conflicts
• Water mains and services
4-Step Approach for Accomodating Utilities: • Gas lines
Step 1: Avoidance • Underground power lines
Where possible, locate green infrastructure facilities clear of all • Above ground power and telephone poles
utility conflicts. This may dictate the type of green infrastructure • Light poles and street signals
design strategy due to space limitations and could require an • Fiber optic and telecommunication cables
approach that is more expensive in an effort to avoid utilities. • Steam lines
Avoidance can also mean a change in the facilities’ dimensions • Valves and vaults for assorted utilities
in order to provide adequate setback from existing utilities.
• Service lines 3 inches and over may not be placed under replacement of planter walls, joints between sidewalk and
streetside or bumpout stormwater planters or tree pits/tree walls, sidewalk drains, inlets, sediment collection pads,
• All new taps and modified services require approval and water control structures (i.e., cleanouts, underdrains, PVC
inspection by Denver Water. pipes tied to storm drain system), tree trench forebays, and
replacement of the media. The adjacent property owners
Water service lines of any size may be placed under green will be responsible for the ‘soft’ infrastructure or more
gutters where the width of the green gutter does not exceed 3 routine maintenance activities. This includes removal of
feet. Sleeves are not required in this scenario. trash and debris to minimize clogging of the system and
media. It also includes maintenance of vegetation (i.e.,
2.5 MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITY trees, shrubs, and perennials) and the irrigation system.
In order for ultra-urban green infrastructure practices to be Most common vegetation practices will include pruning,
effective, proper maintenance is necessary. Maintenance weeding, redistribution of mulch/ media after a rain event,
needs should be considered and addressed during the and watering during dry periods. Ensuring long-term
design phase. The maintenance program begins as soon maintenance of the soft infrastructure will likely require a
as construction is complete. Routine maintenance, such as mechanism, such as the establishment of a business or
sediment and trash removal and weed control, occurs at regular maintenance improvement district, be put in place. The
intervals throughout the year. There will also be maintenance contractor who installs the facility will be responsible for the
activities that are determined based on inspection, such as warranty period as stated in the construction contract.
plant replacement and erosion repair. Restorative maintenance
activities include structural repair, filter media replacement, or 2. Private Projects: Private development assumes all
other significant repairs which should only happen near the maintenance responsibility for green infrastructure assets
end of the expected life of the facility. Maintenance activities on private property. City inspectors will ensure projects
will vary from site to site and are dependent on site specific are completed per plans and inspect yearly to ensure
factors such as runoff volume and pollutant loads (sediment, facilities that are built to meet permit requirements and are
litter), seasonal variations, and adjacent land uses. functioning properly.
C. Installation of underdrain tie-in pipelines, water supply F. Provision and placement of planting media (where
pipelines, and electrical applicable)
• laying out horizontal alignments and vertical grade • providing specified mix of planting media, including
of pipeline leading from green infrastructure BMP amendments
underdrain outlet to downstream outfalls or tie-in points • placing planting media and watering to consolidate to
and water supply pipeline/electrical for irrigation system (if design thickness
used) • placing sedimentation pad
• excavation, placement of bedding, installation of pipe,
joints,fittings, and tie-ins G. Provision and placement of permeable pavement
• placement and compaction of backfill section (where applicable)
• providing specified aggregate layers under pavers
D. Construction of walls and inlets • placing concrete edgers
• placing formwork, reinforcing steel, and concrete, curing • placing permeable pavers
and finishing concrete (for cast-in-place walls, if applicable)
• placing masonry block or brick and mortar (for masonry H. Provision and placement of structural media
walls, if applicable) • providing specified mix of bioretention media, including
• placing and fastening wall units (for precast walls, if amendments
applicable) • mixing structural media
• placing and compacting backfill material outside walls • placing structural media and watering in to consolidate to
• forming, placing steel, and concrete placement and design thickness
• finishing for inlet (if applicable) • placing upper layer materials
• installing inlet grate or plate (if applicable)
• installing PICP I. Installation of irrigation system and seeding/planting
• placing and finishing concrete flatwork for stepout/splash • installing irrigation system and connecting to water supply
• zone and sidewalk adjacent to BMP (where applicable), line
constructing pavement adjacent green infrastructure BMP • completing electrical/control for irrigation system
• (where applicable) and constructing concrete and/ • seeding and planting of specified vegetation
4.1 DESCRIPTION
A streetside stormwater planter is a type of bioretention facility Except as noted, a streetside stormwater planter follows the
located within the street right-of-way (ROW) in the amenity zone design guidance provided in the Bioretention Fact Sheet in
between the street and the sidewalk. A streetside stormwater Urban Drainage and Flood Control District’s (UDFCD) Urban
planter is intended to provide water quality treatment of runoff Storm Drainage Criteria Manual, Volume 3 (USDCM Vol. 3). This
from the street and adjacent pedestrian zone and may also fact sheet provides specific design guidance for the application
be designed to treat runoff from adjacent private development. of bioretention to a streetside stormwater planter. Detailed
Stormwater runoff enters the streetside planter through a curb drawings and notes are provided at the end of this fact sheet to
opening and chase type inlet, spreads over the planting media, further illustrate the design of streetside stormwater planters.
infiltrates vertically downward, and exits through an underdrain.
Treatment processes include filtration, absorption and Figure 7 illustrates how a streetside stormwater planter can be
adsorption, and plant uptake. A variety of vegetation can be integrated into the amenity zone of a typical street section. The
established in streetside stormwater planters including grasses, figure shows the basic elements of the planter in cross section
PLANTER and in perspective. Figure 8 represents an isometric diagram of
perennials,Illustrative
shrubs, and a limited number of trees.
Section
a streetside stormwater planter.
CONCRETE WALK
SIDE WALL
PLANT MATERIAL
STANDARD CURB & GUTTER
BIORETENTION MEDIA*
*Shown 36” depth for tree STEP OUT ZONE
FILTER MATERIAL plantings. 18” depth without SIDE WALL
SUBGRADE trees. STRUCTURAL BACKFILL
STORMWATER PLANTER
Illustrative Isometric
SS
5 C CE LK
7 A A 4’
W IN
4 M
0’
X4
3 MA
H
2 NGT
LE
1 ER
ANT
PL
1 PLANTER INLET
FIGURE 8. Streetside Stormwater Planter
2 COVERED DRAINAGE CHASE (INLET TO FOREBAY) Isometric Diagram (Source: Stream Design.2015.)
3 FOREBAY (SEDIMENT COLLECTION)
4 STEP-OUT ZONE 6 ACCESS WALK
5 PLANTING AREA (IRRIGATED) 7 PEDESTRIAN SIDEWALK
4.2 USES AND RECOMMENDATIONS typical city block) by 30 to 34 feet (street crown to ROW) for
Streetside stormwater planters can be created in mid-block Denver’s local and collector street classifications. Five to seven
locations or near corners on streets that do not receive a streetside stormwater planters this size would be necessary to
deleterious amount of deicing salts. Sizing and locating serve the water quality needs of a city block (crown to ROW)
planters requires a determination of the area draining to the of Denver’s four lane and six lane arterial classifications. If a
planter. There is a specific drainage area associated with a portion of the adjacent private development is also served,
certain size of planter and it is necessary to place the planter additional planters would be necessary. If the planter length
in a location that has this upstream area draining to it. As such, was limited based on steeper street slope to less than 40
the upstream end of a block is generally not an effective place feet, a greater number of planters would be necessary.
to install a planter, while mid-block or the downstream end of a
block is usually conducive. Adjustments can be made to Figure 9 illustrates the layout of streetside stormwater planters
locations and planter sizes to arrive at a properly sized facility measuring 6 by 40 feet (outside dimensions) for the drainage
in a desirable location. Siting streetside stormwater planters area shown in orange. This is based on a street crown to ROW
is also influenced by the presence of a storm drain system; distance of 40 feet.
ideally, a nearby inlet or manhole provides a convenient
location in which to discharge a planter underdrain. If serving Streetside stormwater planters can be implemented in various
just the public right-of-way (ROW; the street and pedestrian combinations with the other types of green infrastructure
zone), three to four streetside stormwater planters measuring described in these fact sheets. Table 1 in the Introduction
6 by 40 feet (outside dimensions) can satisfy the water quality provides information on approximate drainage areas that can
requirements for an impervious area measuring 420 feet (a be treated by various types of green infrastructure BMPs.
Streetside Stormwater
Planter
0 25
Scale 1”=50’
50 100
FIGURE 10. Streetside Stormwater in Urban Landscape
(Source: Tetra Tech.2015.)
4.3 PLANTER AESTHETICS AND URBAN Manual as well as the Public Works Transportation Standards
DESIGN and Details. In the event of conflicting criteria, these criteria
supersede when constructing BMPs included in this manual.
Streetside stormwater planters can be valuable amenities to the
urban landscape if designed properly. Designers should take
4.4 GEOMETRY
design cues from the surrounding streetscape (if improved)
The conceptual design details included in this fact sheet
and/or special district urban design elements and materials.
illustrate the geometry and design features of a streetside
Planters should match or complement the larger urban context,
stormwater planter. The details are intended to provide a basis
as well as add value to the adjacent properties. Since planters
for the designer’s final construction documents, although a
are located within the public right-of-way, it is imperative that
site-specific design will be necessary addressing geotechnical
the design detailing for the planters is uniform within each
issues, structural design, utility protection and relocation, tying
block and preferably within each district or neighborhood.
in underdrain to a downstream storm drain or outfall, irrigation
Figure 10 illustrates how streetside stormwater planters can
design, vegetation plan, and associated final design and
be integrated into the urban landscape. Pedestrian access
construction document preparation tasks.
and safety considerations are discussed in the Design Criteria
section of the Introduction. Use of sidewalls and end walls
are recommended to discourage the deliberate or inadvertent WIDTH
entry by pedestrians, because the top of the planting media in Normally, planters should be made as wide as possible
the planters is depressed below the elevation of the sidewalk. within the available ROW based on desired widths of the
While concrete curbs and walls and standard steel railings step-out zone and sidewalk. Although these dimensions may
are part of a typical design palette, designers may explore the vary, especially in older built-out areas, a typical width for a
use of other materials, such as stone, railings, etc. All designs streetside stormwater planter with a stepout zone of 2.5 feet is
should comply with the City of Denver Streetscape Design six feet. Planters that have a minimum inside width of 5 feet can
incorporate trees. For situations where less ROW is available, elevation. For this reason, the top of media will typically be set
the width may need to be reduced; however, there is a practical 6 inches to 9 inches below the water quality water surface. The
minimum below which it may not make sense to incorporate a details at the end of this fact sheet illustrate the critical flow line
streetside stormwater planter. elevation that defines the water quality water surface.
Outlet
Typical planting plans specific for a streetside stormwater
planter are described in this section. Trees are optional in Step-Out Zone Inlet
these planters but may be used to meet tree right-of-way tree
Curb and Gutter
requirements where applicable. If trees are utilized the depth
FIGURE 11. Basic Grass Cover Planting Plan (Source: Stream Design. 2015.)
of media shall be increased to 36 inches. If trees that create Scale: 1” = 10’
dense shade are utilized, designers may opt to use more shade
tolerant grass species. A recommended plant list is provided in
Appendix C; a list of suitable trees is provided in Appendix D. PLANT LEGEND
Outlet
Step-Out Zone Inlet Step-Out Zone Inlet
Curb and Gutter Curb and Gutter
FIGURE 12. Western Prairie Planting Plan (Source: Stream Design. 2015.) FIGURE 13. Modern Matrix Planting Plan (Source: Stream Design. 2015.)
Scale: 1” = 10’ Scale: 1” = 10’
The Western Prairie typical planting plan illustrated in Figure The Modern Matrix plan uses drought tolerant native materials
12 is intended to present an image of a “natural” prairie. and groups them in regular clusters and groupings to create a
Primarily native grasses and herbaceous perennials, this plan more organic, urban garden. A typical plan is shown in Figure
is arranged in a naturalistic style that allows for the planting to 13. While individual plant species are chosen for drought
change with time as certain species thrive and others recede. tolerance and hardiness, the more ordered approach may
While all streetside stormwater planters will require a significant require slightly more maintenance to maintain its character and
amount of maintenance to keep them weed free and healthy, look attractive versus the other approaches illustrated.
this planting plan can be more forgiving and will require less
maintenance than more formal approaches.
DESIGN NOTES
CONVEYED DOWN THE GUTTER. THIS ELEVATION IS 13. PROVIDE A GAP IN THE SIDEWALL OR DEPRESSED
EQUAL TO THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE AND SECTION (SPILLWAY) AT THE DOWNSTREAM END OF
IS THE TOP OF THE WATER QUALITY CAPTURE VOLUME. THE STREETSIDE PLANTER WALL AT LEAST 2 FEET
7. THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE IS COMPRISED OF LONG TO ENSURE THAT OVERFLOWS FROM PLANTER
AN INCLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS WILL EXIT ON THE STREETSIDE. THE CREST OF THE
SHOWN IN THE DETAILS. THIS STRUCTURE HOUSES A SPILLWAY SHALL BE SET AT THE WQCV WATER SURFACE
CONTROL ORIFICE DESIGNED TO RELEASE THE WQCV IN ELEVATION.
12 HOURS AND A WEIR SET WITHIN 2 INCHES BELOW TO 14. STRUCTURAL BACKFILL SHALL CONSIST OF CDOT CLASS
2 INCHES ABOVE THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE. 1 OR 2 STRUCTURE BACKFILL, AS DETERMINED BY
THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE SHALL BE AN AGRI ENGINEER AND COMPACTED TO AT LEAST 95 PERCENT
DRAIN INLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS OF MAXIMUM DENSITY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
MANUFACTURED BY AGRI DRAIN CORPORATION, OR D698.
APPROVED EQUIVALENT.
8. THE UNDERDRAIN SHALL MEET THE MATERIAL AND SLOT
SPECIFICATIONS IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. THE
MINIMUM LENGTH OF SLOTTED UNDERDRAIN SHALL BE
4 FEET.
9. THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE IS THE TOP OF
THE WQCV AND IS EQUAL TO THE ELEVATION OF THE
FLOW LINE AT POINT A FOR STREET SLOPES LESS THAN
5.5 PERCENT AND AT POINT B FOR STREET SLOPES
GREATER THAN 5.5 PERCENT.
10. BIORETENTION MEDIA SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS
IDENTIFIED IN THE DESIGN CRITERIA SECTION OF THE
INTRODUCTION. TOP OF MEDIA SHALL BE PER PLAN AND
A MINIMUM OF 6 INCHES AND A MAXIMUM OF 9INCHES
BELOW THE WQCV WATER SURFACE ELEVATION.
11. FILTER MATERIAL SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS
IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. FILTER MATERIAL (NOT
BIORETENTION MEDIA) SHALL BE COMPACTED TO A
DENSITY OF NOT LESS THAN 70 PERCENT OF RELATIVE
DENSITY DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
D4253 AND D4254 (FOR FINES CONTENT LESS THAN 5
PERCENT).
12. THE UNDERDRAIN CLEANOUT SHALL CONSIST OF 4 INCH
POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVC) PIPE WITH TWO 45 DEGREE
BENDS AND A THREADED CAP SET 2 INCHES ABOVE THE
TOP OF THE BIORETENTION MEDIA.
29
WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE DETAILS
5. BUMPOUT STORMWATER PLANTER
5.1 DESCRIPTION
A bumpout stormwater planter is a type of bioretention facility Treatment processes include filtration, soil adsorption, and plant
located within street right-of-way (ROW) in an enlarged uptake. A variety of vegetation can be established in bumpout
amenity zone between the street and the sidewalk created stormwater planters including grasses, flowers, shrubs, and
when the curb and gutter is moved out into the portion of trees. Except as noted, a bumpout stormwater planter follows
the roadway normally reserved for parking. Bumpouts are the design guidance provided in the Bioretention Fact Sheet in
becoming more prevalent as a means of calming traffic and Urban Drainage and Flood Control District’s (UDFCD) Urban
providing expanded areas of vegetation and interest within Storm Drainage Criteria Manual, Volume 3 (USDCM Vol. 3) This
the road ROW. A bumpout stormwater planter is intended to fact sheet provides specific design guidance for the application
provide water quality treatment of runoff from the street and of bioretention to a bumpout stormwater planter. Detailed
adjacent pedestrian zone and may also be designed to treat drawings and notes are provided at the back of this fact sheet
runoff from adjacent private development. Stormwater runoff to further illustrate the design of bumpout stormwater planters.
enters the bumpout planter through a curb opening and chase Figure 15 illustrates how a bumpout stormwater planter can be
PLANTER
type inlet, spreads overSHOWING
the plantingBUMPOUT
media, infiltrates vertically integrated into the amenity zone of a typical street section. The
downward,Illustrative Sectionan underdrain.
and exits through figure shows the basic elements of the planter in cross section
and in perspective. Figure 16 provides an isometric view of a
bumpout stormwater planter.
CONCRETE WALK
PLANT MATERIAL
REMOVABLE COVER
INLET AT FOREBAY
SPLASH ZONE
STRUCTURAL BACKFILL
STANDARD CURB SIDE WALL
& GUTTER
BIORETENTION MEDIA*
SIDE WALL
FILTER MATERIAL
SUBGRADE
*Shown 36” depth for tree
plantings. 18” depth without
FIGURE 15: Bumpout Stormwater Planter trees.
(Source: Stream Design. 2015.)
3
5 2 1
7
4
6 40’
TH MAX
RLENG
NTE
PLA
4 STEP-OUT ZONE
1 PLANTER INLET 5 PLANTING AREA (IRRIGATED)
2 COVERED DRAINAGE CHASE (INLET TO FOREBAY) 6 ACCESS WALK
ESS 3 FOREBAY (SEDIMENT COLLECTION) 7 PEDESTRIAN SIDEWALK
ACC ’ MIN
K 4
WAL
FIGURE 16. Bumpout Stormwater Planter Isometric Diagram (Source: Stream Design. 2015.)
FIGURE 17. Bumpout Stormwater Planter City Block Diagram (Source: Stream Design. 2015.) FIGURE 18. Bumpout Stormwater Planter in Urban
Landscape (Source: Tetra Tech. 2015.)
5.3 PLANTER AESTHETICS AND URBAN of Denver Streetscape Design Manual, as well as the Public
DESIGN Works Transportation Standards and Details. In the event of
Bumpout stormwater planters can be valuable amenities conflicting criteria, these criteria supersede when constructing
to the urban landscape if designed properly. Designers BMPs included in this manual.
should take design cues from the surrounding streetscape
(if improved) and/or special district urban design element 5.4 GEOMETRY
and materials. Planters should match or complement the The conceptual design details at the back of this fact sheet
larger urban context, as well as adding value to the adjacent illustrate the geometry and design features of a bumpout
properties. Since planters are located within the public ROW stormwater planter. The details are intended to provide a
it is imperative that the design detailing for the planters is basis for the designer’s final construction documents, although
uniform within each block, preferably within each district or a site-specific design will be necessary for addressing
neighborhood. Figure 18 illustrates how bumpout stormwater geotechnical issues, structural design, utility protection and
planters can be integrated into the urban landscape. relocation, tying in underdrain to a downstream storm drain
or outfall, irrigation design, vegetation plan, and associated
Pedestrian access and safety considerations are discussed in final design and construction document preparation tasks.
the Section 2.2 Design Criteria. Use of sidewalls and end walls
are recommended to discourage the deliberate or inadvertent WIDTH
entry by pedestrians because the top of the planting media Since the bumpout provides additional amenity zone between
in the planters is depressed below the elevation of the the curb and sidewalk, bumpout planters have a greater width
sidewalk. While concrete curbs and walls and standard steel than streetside stormwater planters. This increase width can
railings are part of a typical design palette, designers may be as much as 7 feet: approximately 6 feet by occupying the
explore the use of other materials, such as stone, oversized parking lane and one additional foot by reducing the step-out
railings, etc. However, all designs should comply with the City zone for no parking. Assuming a streetside planter typically has
an inside width of 5 feet, the bumpout stormwater planter could The details at the end of this fact sheet illustrate the critical flow
be up to 12 feet in width. Areas that have a minimum width of 5 line elevation that defines the water quality water surface.
feet can incorporate trees. In addition to the surface volume extending from the top of
the media up to the water quality water surface, the volume
LENGTH of the pore spaces in the media equivalent to 14 percent of
Section 2.2 Design Criteria provides a discussion of design the media and filter material volume can be counted toward
considerations associated with planter length. Those the required WQCV in the ultra-urban green infrastructure
considerations translate into a typical range of lengths from BMPs documented in this manual. This pore space volume
about 20 feet to a maximum of 40 feet with adjacent access was selected based on testing of media approximately 24
points on the ends at least four feet wide. hours after saturation. As stated in the Section 2.2 Design
Criteria, the required WQCV for the upstream area draining
PROFILE to a bumpout stormwater planter shall be computed using the
As mentioned in Section 2.2 Design Criteria, it is recommended procedures in USDCM Vol. 3. It is important to ensure that the
that the top of the bioretention media be horizontal in longitudinal area of the filter (the flat surface of the bioretention media) is
profile, and that the top of the side walls be configured to be sized appropriately for the tributary area. The filter area shall
parallel to the sidewalk at a height of 6 inches or greater, as be no less than 2 percent of the upstream area draining to the
shown in the details. planter.
If openings in the sidewall along the sidewalk are not used to INLET AND SEDIMENT COLLECTION PAD
provide drainage into the planter, the top of the walls can be A concrete sediment collection pad is recommended
designed to be horizontal, parallel to the top of the media, for immediately downstream of the inlet to dissipate energy and
the whole length of the planter. In this case, the water quality collect a portion of the sediment and debris entering the planter
water surface can be retained within the planter even with for subsequent removal during maintenance operations.
steeper street slopes, as discussed in Section 2.2 Design Additional information on inlet layout and sizing is provided in
Criteria. Section 2.2 Design Criteria.
of dense vegetation is recommended adjacent to the concrete 30” - 48” tall accent plant (native grass or
sedimentation pad to help dissipate the energy of incoming approved perennial or shrub)
Inlet Inlet
The Western Prairie typical planting plan illustrated in Figure The Modern Matrix plan uses drought tolerant native materials
20 is intended to present an image of a “natural” prairie. and groups them in regular clusters and groupings to create a
Primarily native grasses and herbaceous perennials, this plan more organic, urban garden. A typical plan is shown in Figure
is arranged in a naturalistic style that allows for the planting to 21. While individual plant species are chosen for drought
change with time as certain species thrive and others recede. tolerance and hardiness, the more ordered approach may
While all bumpout stormwater planters will require a significant require slightly more maintenance to maintain its character and
amount of maintenance to keep them weed free and healthy, look attractive versus the other approaches illustrated.
this planting plan can be more forgiving and will require less
maintenance than more formal approaches.
THIS ELEVATION IS EQUAL TO THE WATER QUALITY 13. PROVIDE A GAP IN THE SIDEWALL OR DEPRESSED
WATER SURFACE AND IS THE TOP OF THE WATER SECTION (SPILLWAY) AT THE DOWNSTREAM END OF THE
QUALITY CAPTURE VOLUME. STREETSIDE PLANTER WALL AT LEAST 2 FEET LONG TO
7. THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE IS COMPRISED OF ENSURE THAT OVERFLOWS FROM PLANTER WILL EXIT ON
AN INCLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS THE STREETSIDE. THE CREST OF THE SPILLWAY SHALL
SHOWN IN THE DETAILS. THIS STRUCTURE HOUSES A BE SET AT THE WQCV WATER SURFACE ELEVATION.
CONTROL ORIFICE DESIGNED TO RELEASE THE WQCV IN 14. STRUCTURAL BACKFILL SHALL CONSIST OF CDOT CLASS
12 HOURS AND A WEIR SET WITHIN 2 INCHES BELOW TO 1 OR 2 STRUCTURE BACKFILL, AS DETERMINED BY
2 INCHES ABOVE THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE. ENGINEER AND COMPACTED TO AT LEAST 95 PERCENT
THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE SHALL BE AN AGRI OF MAXIMUM DENSITY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
DRAIN INLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS D698.
MANUFACTURED BY AGRI DRAIN CORPORATION, OR
APPROVED EQUIVALENT.
8. THE UNDERDRAIN SHALL MEET THE MATERIAL AND SLOT
SPECIFICATIONS IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. THE
MINIMUM LENGTH OF SLOTTED UNDERDRAIN SHALL BE
4 FEET.
9. THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE IS THE TOP OF
THE WQCV AND IS EQUAL TO THE ELEVATION OF THE
FLOW LINE AT POINT A FOR STREET SLOPES LESS THAN
5.5 PERCENT AND AT POINT B FOR STREET SLOPES
GREATER THAN 5.5 PERCENT.
10. BIORETENTION MEDIA SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS
IDENTIFIED IN THE DESIGN CRITERIA SECTION OF THE
INTRODUCTION. TOP OF MEDIA SHALL BE PER PLAN AND
A MINIMUM OF 6 INCHES AND A MAXIMUM OF 9 INCHES
BELOW THE WQCV WATER SURFACE ELEVATION.
11. FILTER MATERIAL SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS
IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. FILTER MATERIAL (NOT
BIORETENTION MEDIA) SHALL BE COMPACTED TO A
DENSITY OF NOT LESS THAN 70 PERCENT OF RELATIVE
DENSITY DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
D4253 AND D4254 (FOR FINES CONTENT LESS THAN 5
PERCENT).
12. THE UNDERDRAIN CLEANOUT SHALL CONSIST OF 4 INCH
POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVC) PIPE WITH TWO 45 DEGREE
BENDS AND A THREADED CAP SET 2 INCHES ABOVE THE
TOP OF THE BIORETENTION MEDIA.
Planter Details
FIGURE 22. Bumpout Stormwater
5. BUMPOUT STORMWATER
WATER PLANTER
6.1 DESCRIPTION
A green gutter is a type of bioretention facility located within a thrive in these green gutters, a neat clean appearance is
street section near the gutter line. This fact sheet illustrates the recommended by using a simple palette that primarily includes
use of a green gutter between the vehicular lanes of a roadway native grasses. Except as noted, a green gutter follows the
and a bike lane. A green gutter is intended to provide water design guidance provided in the Bioretention Fact Sheet in
quality treatment of runoff from the street and adjacent bike Urban Drainage and Flood Control District’s (UDFCD) Urban
lane and pedestrian zone if the bike lane slopes toward the Storm Drainage Criteria Manual, Volume 3 (USDCM Vol.
green gutter. If the bike lane drains toward the sidewalk (as 3). This fact sheet provides specific design guidance for the
might be the case in a retrofit condition), the green gutter drains application of bioretention to a green gutter. Detailed drawings
the vehicular lanes. Stormwater runoff enters the green gutter and notes are provided at the back of this fact sheet to further
through a curb opening and chase-type inlet, spreads over the illustrate the design of green gutters.
planting media, infiltrates vertically downward, and exits
GREEN
through GUTTERTreatment processes include filtration,
an underdrain. Figure 23 illustrates how a green gutter can be integrated into
Illustrative Section
soil adsorption, and plant uptake. a typical street section. The figure shows the basic elements of
the green gutter in cross section and in perspective. Figure 24
Green gutters should be well vegetated to maximize functionality represents an isometric diagram of a green gutter stormwater
and attractiveness. While a variety of vegetation can potentially planter.
CONCRETE WALK
BIKE LANE
3
4 7
2
40’
TH MAX
1 LENG
6 TER
PLAN 4 PLANTING AREA (IRRIGATED)
5
1 ACCESS WALK 5 INLET
SS 2 BIKE LANE 6 SEDIMENT COLLECTION PAD
ACCE MIN
4 ’ 3 PEDESTRIAN SIDEWALK 7 DRIVE LANE
WALK
FIGURE 24. Green Gutter (Source: Stream Design. 2015.)
Other types of green infrastructure described in these fact In addition, green gutters should be planned and designed to
sheets can be implemented in combination with green gutter accommodate necessary pedestrian cross traffic, and their
stormwater planters. Table 1 in the Introduction provides length should be determined to assure smooth pedestrian flow
information on approximate drainage areas that can be treated through a district or neighborhood. As green gutters are intended
by various types of green infrastructure BMPs. to be installed within street ROWs, all requirements for vehicular
safety per the City of Denver Public Works standards must be available roadway section based on desired widths of the
maintained, including the maintaining of proper sight distance at vehicular lanes and bike lane. A recommended minimum width
intersections. In addition, green gutter design must comply with is 3 feet from inside of curb to inside of curb.
the Denver Public Works Transportation Standards and Details.
LENGTH AND GUTTER PROFILE
6.4 GEOMETRY
The length of a green gutter is established based on the need
The conceptual design details at the back of this fact sheet
to provide periodic pedestrian access and also based on the
illustrate the geometry and design features of a green gutter.
length and width necessary to obtain a specific water quality
The details are intended to provide a basis for the designer’s
capture volume (WQCV) associated with the upstream drainage
final construction documents, although a site specific design
area to be treated. Since the top of the bioretention media will
will be necessary addressing geotechnical issues, structural
be horizontal in longitudinal profile while the street and top of
design, utility protection and relocation, tying in underdrain to a
curbs will slope, periodic drops may be necessary as shown
downstream storm drain or outfall, irrigation design, vegetation
in the details to “stairstep” the media and water quality water
plan, and associated final design and construction document
surface down in a downstream direction.
preparation tasks.
Figure 25 provides guidance on maximum length of each green
WIDTH
gutter section based upon the longitudinal slope of the roadway
Green gutters should be made as wide as possible within the and the vertical drop across the bioretention media.
FIGURE 25. Maximum length of green gutter section based on roadway longitudinal slope and vertical drop across bioretention media.
40
35
30
Distance from End Wall to Drop Wall (ft)
25
20
15
(Source: Muller Engineering. 2015.)
10
0
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6%
Street Slope
6.5 GREEN GUTTER DESIGN Additional information on inlet layout and sizing is provided in
CONSIDERATIONS Section 2.2 Design Criteria.
WQCV ZONE
In keeping with USDCM Vol. 3 criteria for bioretention facilities, OTHER PLANTER COMPONENTS
a WQCV zone is required above the planting media. This zone Section 2.2 Design Criteria provides information regarding the
is measured from the top of the media to the elevation of the following components of a green gutter stormwater planter:
flow line at the inlet that controls when water will start to flow • bioretention media
out of the planter and down the gutter. Although it is possible • underdrain system
to design green gutters with a water quality depth as great as • flow control structure
12 inches, from an aesthetic standpoint it is desirable to keep • walls
the top of the media as high as possible relative to the adjacent • spillway
pavement elevation. For this reason, the top of the media will • liner
typically be set 5 inches to 9 inches below the water quality
water surface. The details at the end of the fact sheet illustrate 6.6 VEGETATION
the critical flow line elevation that defines the water quality BASIC GRASS COVER PLANTING
water surface.
Given the limited width of the green gutter and the relatively
challenging growing conditions created by the surrounding
In addition to the surface volume extending from the top of the
hardscape, the planting plan recommended for most green
media up to the water quality water surface, a portion of the
gutter applications is the “Basic Grass Cover” concept. This
volume of the pore spaces in the media equivalent to 14 percent
concept consists of a simple arrangement of primarily native
of the media and filter material volume can be counted toward
grasses to create full coverage of the bioretention media. This
the required WQCV in the ultra-urban green infrastructure
planting scheme is intended to create a “wall to wall” planting of
BMPs documented in this manual. This pore space volume
low to mid height native grasses. Variety can be created within
was selected based on testing of media approximately 24
the planter by alternating masses of grass species, or inserting
hours after saturation. As stated in Section 2.2 Design Criteria
clusters of accent grasses that contrast from the main species
of the Introduction, the required WQCV for the upstream area
in size, color, or texture (all plant heights should be below 30
draining to a green gutter stormwater planter shall be computed
inches). While regular maintenance is required, the simple
using the procedures UDSCM Vol. 3. It is also important
design of the Basic Grass Cover allows easier identification
to ensure that the area of the filter (the flat surface area of
of weeds by maintenance staff. Designers should take into
the bioretention media) is sized appropriately for the tributary
account mature sizes of plant material when developing
area. The filter area shall be no less than the 2 percent of the
planting layout plans to assure that the established plant
upstream area draining to the green gutter.
material is not planted so close to planter edges that plants
significantly exceed the limits of the planting area and create
INLET AND SEDIMENTATION COLLECTION
hazards for adjoining use areas. Information on sizes and
PAD
spacing of recommended species is provided in Appendix C. `
A concrete sediment collection pad is recommended
immediately downstream of the inlet to dissipate energy and
collect a portion of the sediment and debris entering the planter
for subsequent removal during maintenance operations.
CONVEYED DOWN THE GUTTER. THIS ELEVATION IS 13. PROVIDE A GAP IN THE SIDEWALL OR DEPRESSED
EQUAL TO THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE AND SECTION (SPILLWAY) AT THE DOWNSTREAM END OF
IS THE TOP OF THE WATER QUALITY CAPTURE VOLUME. THE STREETSIDE PLANTER WALL AT LEAST 2 FEET
7. THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE IS COMPRISED OF LONG TO ENSURE THAT OVERFLOWS FROM PLANTER
AN INCLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS WILL EXIT ON THE STREETSIDE. THE CREST OF THE
SHOWN IN THE DETAILS. THIS STRUCTURE HOUSES A SPILLWAY SHALL BE SET AT THE WQCV WATER SURFACE
CONTROL ORIFICE DESIGNED TO RELEASE THE WQCV IN ELEVATION.
12 HOURS AND A WEIR SET WITHIN 2 INCHES BELOW TO 14. STRUCTURAL BACKFILL SHALL CONSIST OF CDOT CLASS
2 INCHES ABOVE THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE. 1 OR 2 STRUCTURE BACKFILL, AS DETERMINED BY
THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE SHALL BE AN AGRI ENGINEER AND COMPACTED TO AT LEAST 95 PERCENT
DRAIN INLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS OF MAXIMUM DENSITY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
MANUFACTURED BY AGRI DRAIN CORPORATION, OR D698.
APPROVED EQUIVALENT.
8. THE UNDERDRAIN SHALL MEET THE MATERIAL AND SLOT
SPECIFICATIONS IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. THE
MINIMUM LENGTH OF SLOTTED UNDERDRAIN SHALL BE
4 FEET.
9. THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE IS THE TOP OF
THE WQCV AND IS EQUAL TO THE ELEVATION OF THE
FLOW LINE AT POINT A FOR STREET SLOPES LESS THAN
5.5 PERCENT AND AT POINT B FOR STREET SLOPES
GREATER THAN 5.5 PERCENT.
10. BIORETENTION MEDIA SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS
IDENTIFIED IN THE DESIGN CRITERIA SECTION OF THE
INTRODUCTION. TOP OF MEDIA SHALL BE PER PLAN AND
A MINIMUM OF 6 INCHES AND A MAXIMUM OF 9 INCHES
BELOW THE WQCV WATER SURFACE ELEVATION.
11. FILTER MATERIAL SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS
IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. FILTER MATERIAL (NOT
BIORETENTION MEDIA) SHALL BE COMPACTED TO A
DENSITY OF NOT LESS THAN 70 PERCENT OF RELATIVE
DENSITY DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
D4253 AND D4254 (FOR FINES CONTENT LESS THAN 5
PERCENT).
12. THE UNDERDRAIN CLEANOUT SHALL CONSIST OF 4 INCH
POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVC) PIPE WITH TWO 45 DEGREE
BENDS AND A THREADED CAP SET 2 INCHES ABOVE THE
TOP OF THE BIORETENTION MEDIA.
LENGTH VARIES
GUTTER
6. GREEN GUTTER
7.1 DESCRIPTION
A green alley is a type of stormwater quality facility applied the design guidance provided in the Permeable Pavement
to alleys. A green alley is intended to provide water quality Fact Sheet in in Urban Drainage and Flood Control District’s
treatment of runoff from the alley though the use of permeable (UDFCD) Urban Storm Drainage Criteria Manual, Volume
pavement, although may be modified to provide some level of 3 (USDCM Vol. 3). This fact sheet provides specific design
water quality treatment for adjoining development. This fact guidance for the application of permeable pavement to a green
sheet illustrates the configuration of a green alley serving the alley. Detailed drawings and notes are provided at the back of
water quality needs of the alley itself. The alley slopes toward a this fact sheet to further illustrate the design of green
central permeable pavement section. Stormwater runoff flows alleys.
off standard pavement into the permeable section, infiltrates
vertically downward, and exits through an underdrain. The main Figure 27 illustrates how permeable pavements can be
treatment process consists of filtration through the permeable integrated into a typical urban alley. The figure shows the basic
GREEN ALLEY
pavement media. Except as noted, a green alley follows elements of the green alley in cross section and in perspective.
Illustrative Section
CONCRETE PAVEMENT
SUBGRADE
PERMEABLE PAVEMENT
SECTION PER STRUCTURAL BACKFILL
UDFCD VOLUME 3 PERIMETER BARRIER
SLOTTED
UNDERDRAIN PICP
DESIGN NOTES
1. PICP AND UNDERLYING MATERIALS SHALL BE DESIGNED WITH THE USDCM VOLUME 3 PERMEABLE PAVEMENT
FOR HS-20 LOADING CONDITIONS AND SHALL MEET THE SYSTEMS CRITERIA.
REQUIREMENTS OF USDCM VOLUME 3. 6. STRUCTURAL BACKFILL SHALL CONSIST OF CDOT CLASS
2. THE UNDERDRAIN SHALL MEET THE MATERIAL AND SLOT 1 OR 2 STRUCTURE BACKFILL, AS DETERMINED BY
SPECIFICATIONS IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. ENGINEER AND COMPACTED TO AT LEAST 95 PERCENT
3. FILTER MATERIAL SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS OF MAXIMUM DENSITY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM
IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. FILTER MATERIAL D698.
SHALL BE COMPACTED TO A DENSITY OF NOT LESS 7. STRUCTURAL ENGINEER, WITH INPUT FROM
THAN 70 PERCENT OF RELATIVE DENSITY DETERMINED GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEER, SHALL DESIGN WALL
IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM D4253 AND D4254 (FOR DIMENSIONS, REINFORCING, ANY FOUNDATION
FINES CONTENT LESS THAN 5 PERCENT). COMPONENTS SUCH AS FOOTINGS OR BOTTOM SLAB,
4. THE UNDERDRAIN CLEANOUT SHALL CONSIST OF 4 INCH AND SUBGRADE/BEDDING/BACKFILL SPECIFICATIONS.
POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVC) PIPE WITH TWO 45 DEGREE 8. COVER SHALL SUPPORT HS-20 LOADING AND
BENDS AND A THREADED CAP SET 2 INCHES BELOW THE CONSIST OF NEENAH R-4999 HEAVY DUTY BOLTED
TOP OF THE PAVEMENT. PVC CLEANOUT SHOULD BE TRENCH GRATE TYPE D (SOLID) OR APPROVED
LOCATED IN A VALVE BOX SET WITHIN THE PICP AREA. EQUIVALENT – CATALOGUE NO. R-4999-HX FOR SPAN
FILTER MATERIAL SHOULD BE PLACED INSIDE THE OF 2 FEET AND R-4999-MX FOR SPAN OF 3 FEET. THE
VALVE BOX AROUND THE CLEANOUT. THE VALVE BOX LENGTH OF THE INLET COVER SHOULD BE FIELD
SHALL HAVE A REMOVABLE PLATE OR GRATE FLUSH CUT TO FIT OUTLET BOX.
WITH PAVEMENT AND SHALL BE DESIGNED FOR HS-20 9. LINER (IF SPECIFIED) SHALL BE A MINIMUM OF 30
LOADING. MIL THICK PVC GEOMEMBRANE AND SHALL BE
5. THE UNDERDRAIN OUTLET SHALL BE IN ACCORDANCE THERMALLY WELDED.
8.1 DESCRIPTION
A tree trench is a type of bioretention facility located within through a water level control structure. Treatment processes
street right-of-way (ROW) in the amenity zone between the include filtration, absorption and adsorption, and uptake by
street and the sidewalk. A tree trench that features a single tree the roots of the trees. This fact sheet provides specific design
is also called a tree pit. For the purposes of this fact sheet, guidance for the application of bioretention to a tree trench,
it is assumed that multiple trees are included and so the as described in Urban Drainage and Flood Control District’s
terminology “tree trench” will generally be used. A tree trench (UDFCD) Urban Storm Drainage Criteria Manual, Volume 3
provides water quality treatment of runoff from the street and (USDCM Vol. 3). Detailed drawings and notes are included in
adjacent pedestrian zone and may also be designed to treat this fact sheet to further illustrate the design of tree trenches.
runoff from adjacent private development. Stormwater runoff
enters the tree trench through a curb opening and chase- Figure 29 illustrates how a tree trench can be integrated into
type inlet, passes through a fine-gravel filter for pretreatment, the amenity zone of a typical street section. The figure shows
is TREE TRENCH
conveyed through an underdrain to one or more tree the basic elements of the tree trench in cross section and in
Illustrative
plantings, fills Section
pore space around the tree roots, and exits perspective. Figure 30 provides a profile view of a tree trench.
PICP
CONCRETE WALK
STANDARD CURB & GUTTER
CONCRETE FRAME FOR GRATE
ASTM NO. 57 OR NO. 67
STRUCTURAL SUPPORT
TREE GRATE
BIORETENTION MEDIA
SLOTTED UNDERDRAIN
FILTER MATERIAL
SUBGRADE
FIGURE 29. Tree Trench/Pit
(Source: Stream Design. 2015.)
TREE TRENCH
Illustrative Profile
8
1 7
2
6 5
3 4
25’-35’ BETWEEN TREES
DEPENDING ON SPECIES
1 FILTER COVER 4 SLOTTED UNDERDRAIN IN FILTER MATERIAL 7 TREE GRATE AND PICP
2 PRE-TREATMENT FILTER 5 WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE 8 PEDESTRIAN SIDEWALK
3 CLEANOUT 6 STRUCTURAL SUPPORT
FIGURE 30 . Tree Trench/Pit Profile View (Source: Stream Design. 2015.)
8.2 USES AND RECOMMENDATIONS If serving just the public ROW (street and pedestrian zone),
Tree trenches can be used along streets that do not receive three tree trenches with three trees each can satisfy the water
a deleterious amount of deicing salts and when they can be quality requirements for an impervious area measuring 400
placed to receive adequate tributary area. Sizing and locating feet (a typical city block) by 30 to 34 feet (street crown to
tree trenches requires a determination of the area draining to the ROW) for Denver’s local and collector street classifications. If
tree trench. There is a specific drainage area associated with a a portion of the adjacent private development is also served
certain size of tree trench and it is necessary to place the tree or the street has a significantly wider ROW, additional tree
trench in a location that has this upstream area draining to it. As trenches would be necessary. Figure 31 illustrates the layout
such, the upstream end of a block is generally not an effective of tree trenches for the drainage area shown in orange.
place to install a tree trench, while the middle or downstream This requires three tree trenches with three trees each
end of a block is usually conducive. Adjustments can be made and is based on a street crown to ROW distance of 40 feet.
to locations and tree trench sizes to arrive at a properly sized
facility in a desirable location. Siting tree trenches is also Other types of green infrastructure described in these fact
influenced by the presence of a storm drain system; ideally, sheets can be implemented in combination with tree trenches.
a nearby inlet or manhole provides a convenient location for Table 1 in the Introduction provides information on approximate
discharge of the underdrain. drainage areas that can be treated by various types of green
infrastructure BMPs.
TREE TRENCH
City Block Diagram
Slope
FIGURE 31 . Tree Trench/Pit City Block Diagram 0 25 50 100 FIGURE 32 . Tree Trench/Pit in Urban Landscape
(Source: Stream Design. 2015.) (Source: Tetra Tech. 2015.)
Scale 1”=50’
8.3 TREE TRENCH/PIT AESTHETICS AND also allows for the area surrounding the tree to be planted
URBAN DESIGN with other vegetation. CCD staff has observed that trees
From an urban design perspective, tree trenches have the same surrounded by other vegetation are more frequently watered
applications as urban street tree plantings and can be used by nearby residents. Additionally, tree grates can damage the
interchangeably. Trees are typically located 4 to 6 feet from the tree when not properly maintained.
back of curb. The amenity strip in which the tree trench is located
should be continuously paved with permeable pavement, When tree grates are used, a minimum separation of 4 inches
contributing to an attractive urban environment by adding between the grate and the tree trunk should be maintained.
color and texture and providing an attractive counterpoint to Grates shall be easily maintainable and need to be inspected
the surrounding concrete paving. Permeable pavement in this on an annual basis. Another option is to use permeable
location also benefits tree health by providing air and rainwater interlocking concrete pavement (PICP) on top of the tree
to the root system. As with any elements in the public ROW trench and continuing this to within 6 to 12 inches of the tree
the visible components of tree trenches (grates and permeable trunk. Examples of tree grates are shown in Figures 33-35. All
pavement) should match or complement the larger urban designs should comply with the City of Denver Streetscape
context, as well as add value to the adjacent properties. Design Design Manual, as well as the Public Works Transportation
detailing should be uniform within each block, and preferably, Standards and Details. In the event of conflicting criteria, these
within each district or neighborhood. Figure 32 illustrates how criteria supersede when constructing BMPs included in this
tree trenches can be integrated into the urban landscape. manual. Cover plates meeting ADA accessibility requirements
are necessary over the pre-treatment filter. The cover over the
8.4 USE OF GRATES filter may consist of multiple sections that must be able to be
The preferred treatment surrounding the tree is a 4 inch curb lifted and slid to the side by maintenance staff to allow access to
with no tree grate. This allows the soil surrounding the tree the filter media for cleaning. Additional information is provided
to be visible while protecting the soil from compaction. This in the design notes preceding the details.
8.5 GEOMETRY
The conceptual design details at the back of this fact sheet
illustrate the geometry and design features of a tree trench.
The details are intended to provide a basis for the designer’s
final construction documents, although a site-specific design
will be necessary addressing geotechnical issues, structural
design, utility protection and relocation, tying in underdrain to a
downstream storm drain or outfall, irrigation design, vegetation
plan, and associated final design and construction document
preparation tasks. Trees in this type of application require an
uncompacted rooting volume of 750 to 1000 cubic feet per tree.
FIGURE 33. Tree Trench Example A (Source: Starburst tree grate unfinished.
http://www.ironsmith.cc/PROJECTS-TREEGRATES.html. 2015)
WIDTH
The tree trench is typically centered approximately 4 to 6 feet
behind the back of curb in a manner that preserves the step-out
zone on the curb side of the trees and the sidewalk on the other.
The width of excavation for the tree trench is approximately
nine feet, and final tree planting areas must be a minimum of
5 feet in width.
FIGURE 35. Tree Trench Example C. (Source: Pervious Pavers over Silva
Cells. http://www.deeproot.com/blog/blog entries/advantages-pf-using-
pervious-pavers-over-silva-cells. 2015.)
8.6 TREE TRENCH / PIT DESIGN In addition to sizing a tree trench to contain the WQCV, a
CONSIDERATION tree trench must be designed to capture the peak discharge
WQCV ZONE expected during the water quality storm event, neglecting the
In accordance with USDCM Vol. 3 criteria for bioretention backwater effects of the water control structure. This capacity
facilities, a tree trench is designed to capture the WQCV based is intended to allow the pore volume in the tree trench to fill.
on a 12-hour drain time. The required WQCV for the upstream The peak discharge during the water quality event is to be
area draining to a tree trench shall be computed using the calculated using the Rational Method as described in Section
procedures in USDCM Vol. 3. 2.2 Design Criteria.
For steep street slopes, the media depth below the water
control structure weir crest may be substantially less at the
upstream end of the tree trench than at the downstream
end; this needs to be taken into account when estimating the
average media depth below the weir crest. It is possible that for
very steep streets and long tree trenches, the elevation of the
water control structure weir crest may be below the bottom of
the media at the upstream end of the tree trench; in this case
the length of media below the weir crest must be adjusted to be
less than the total length of the facility.
20
PRE-TREATMENT FILTER AREA (SF)
15
10
0
0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000
DRAINAGE AREA (ASSUMED TO BE FULLY IMPERVIOUS) (SF)
TREE FORM
When selecting shade trees for use in urban situations,
designers should specify trees with strong central leaders that
can be trained over time to branch out 6 feet high or higher
to avoid creating barriers and hazards to pedestrians. Smaller
ornamental trees (from approved list) may be planted in areas
with overhead power lines, or potentially in areas with low
pedestrian traffic, however these are not recommended in high
pedestrian volume, ultra-urban conditions. Proposed trees
in the city ROW must be approved by the Office of the City
Forester and right-of-way tree planting permits are required.
DESIGN NOTES
1. INLET WIDTH VARIES BASED ON UPSTREAM IMPERVIOUS IN THE INLET FILTER WOULD START TO FLOW OUT AND
AREA AND STREET SLOPE, WITH A MINIMUM WIDTH OF 2 BE CONVEYED DOWN THE GUTTER. THIS ELEVATION IS
FEET AND A MAXIMUM WIDTH OF 3 FEET. SEE CRITERIA EQUAL TO THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE AND
FOR SIZING INLET WIDTH. IS THE TOP OF THE WATER QUALITY CAPTURE VOLUME.
2. INLET COVER SHALL MEET ADA ACCESSIBILITY 6. THE PRE-TREATMENT FILTER SIZE IS TO BE SPECIFIED
REQUIREMENTS AND CONSIST OF NEENAH R-4999 BY THE DESIGNER BASED ON THE MINIMUM SURFACE
HEAVY DUTY BOLTED TRENCH GRATE TYPE D (SOLID) AREA SHOWN IN FIGURE 3. PRETREATMENT FILTER
OR APPROVED EQUIVALENT – CATALOGUE NO. R-4999- MEDIA SHALL BE ASTM NO. 8 AGGREGATE.
HX FOR SPAN OF 2 FEET AND R-4999-MX FOR SPAN OF 7. THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE IS COMPRISED OF
3 FEET. THE LENGTH OF THE INLET COVER SHOULD BE AN INLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS
FIELD CUT TO EXTEND CONTINUOUSLY FROM THE FACE SHOWN IN THE DETAILS. THIS STRUCTURE HOUSES A
OF CURB TO BACK OF PLANTER WALL AND SHOULD BE CONTROL ORIFICE DESIGNED TO RELEASE THE WQCV IN
RECESSED FROM THE FACE OF THE CURB SO THAT THE 12 HOURS AND A WEIR SET WITHIN 2 INCHES BELOW TO
CORNERS OF THE PLATE DO NOT PROTRUDE BEYOND 0 INCHES ABOVE THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE.
THE TOP OF CURB. THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE SHALL BE AN AGRI
3. FILTER COVER SHALL MEET ADA ACCESSIBILITY AND DRAIN
CONSIST OF NEENAH R-4999 HEAVY DUTY BOLTED INLINE WATER LEVEL CONTROL STRUCTURE AS
TRENCH GRATE TYPE D (SOLID) OR APPROVED MANUFACTURED BY AGRI DRAIN CORPORATION, OR
EQUIVALENT – CATALOGUE NO. R-4999-HX FOR SPAN APPROVED EQUIVALENT.
OF 2 FEET, R-4999-MX FOR SPAN OF 3 FEET, AND 8. THE UNDERDRAIN SHALL MEET THE MATERIAL AND SLOT
R-4999- OX FOR SPAN OF 4 FEET. COVER MAY BE MADE SPECIFICATIONS IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3.
UP OF SEPARATE PANELS AND EACH PANEL SHALL BE 9. THE TREE GRATE, WHEN USED, IS TO BE SPECIFIED BY
REMOVABLE. LENGTH AND WIDTH OF CONCRETE FILTER THE DESIGNER AND MAY NEED TO CONSIDER LOCAL
BOX SHALL BE ADJUSTED TO ALLOW STANDARD SIZE AREA DESIGN GUIDELINES IF APPLICABLE.
GRATES AND FRAME TO BE USED WHILE MAINTAINING 10. THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE IS THE TOP OF
REQUIRED SURFACE AREA. INDIVIDUAL GRATE SIZE THE WQCV AND IS EQUAL TO THE ELEVATION OF THE
SHALL BE NO GREATER THAN 8 SQUARE FEET. WEIR CREST OF THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE (6
4. FOR STREET SLOPES LESS THAN 5.5 PERCENT, THE TO 8 INCHES BELOW THE ELEVATION OF THE SIDEWALK
ELEVATION OF THE FLOW LINE AT POINT A REPRESENTS AT THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE). THE WQCV
THE WATER SURFACE ELEVATION ABOVE WHICH WATER IS COMPRISED OF THE PORE VOLUME OF THE MEDIA
IN THE INLET FILTER WOULD START TO FLOW OUT AND BELOW THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE BASED
BE CONVEYED DOWN THE GUTTER. THIS ELEVATION IS ON AN OVERALL POROSITY OF 13 PERCENT (ACCOUNTS
EQUAL TO THE WATER QUALITY WATER SURFACE AND FOR VOLUME OCCUPIED BY STRUCTURAL SUPPORTS).
IS THE TOP OF THE WATER QUALITY CAPTURE VOLUME IN ADDITION, SIZING OF TREE TRENCH IS BASED ON
(WQCV). PROVIDING A FLOW-THROUGH CAPACITY THROUGH
5. FOR STREET SLOPES GREATER THAN 5.5 PERCENT, THE THE PRE-TREATMENT FILTER AND UNDERDRAIN AT
ELEVATION OF THE FLOW LINE AT POINT B REPRESENTS LEAST AS GREAT AS THE PEAK DISCHARGE OF THE
THE WATER SURFACE ELEVATION ABOVE WHICH WATER WATER QUALITY EVENT (NEGLECTING THE BACKWATER
EFFECTS OF THE WATER CONTROL STRUCTURE. 17. STRUCTURAL SUPPORTS SHALL BE SILVA CELL
11. BIORETENTION MEDIA SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS 2 AS MANUFACTURED BY DEEPROOT GREEN
IDENTIFIED IN THE DESIGN CRITERIA SECTION OF THE INFRASTRUCTURE OR APPROVED EQUIVALENT,
INTRODUCTION. THE ROOTBALL SHALL BE PLACED ON INSTALLED ACCORDING TO MANUFACTURER’S
NATIVE SOIL OR BIORETENTION MEDIA, AS SPECIFIED RECOMMENDATIONS.
BY DESIGNER, COMPACTED TO 85 TO 90 PERCENT OF 18. STRUCTURAL ENGINEER, WITH INPUT FROM
MAXIMUM DENSITY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM D698 GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEER, SHALL DESIGN WALL
TO REDUCE THE LIKELIHOOD OF SETTLEMENT UNDER DIMENSIONS, REINFORCING, ANY FOUNDATION
THE TREE. COMPONENTS SUCH AS FOOTINGS OR BOTTOM SLAB,
12. GEOGRID SHOWN ON DETAILS SHALL BE BX1100 AND SUBGRADE/BEDDING/BACKFILL SPECIFICATIONS.
AS MANUFACTURED BY TENSAR INTERNATIONAL 19. TREES SHALL BE STAKED WITH THREE GUY LINES. GUY
CORPORATION, INC. OR APPROVED EQUIVALENT. AN LINES SHALL BE FASTENED TO TREE GRATE OR TO
ADDITIONAL LAYER OF MICROGRID AS MANUFACTURED EYEBOLTS INSTALLED IN CONCRETE TREE RING.
BY STRATA SYSTEMS SHALL BE PLACED ON TOP OF THE
HORIZONTAL LAYER OF GEOGRID ON THE TOP OF THE
STRUCTURAL SUPPORTS AND BELOW THE LAYER OF
ASTM NO. 2 AGGREGATE.
13. FILTER MATERIAL SHALL MEET THE SPECIFICATIONS
IDENTIFIED IN USDCM VOLUME 3. FILTER MATERIAL
SHALL BE COMPACTED TO A DENSITY OF NOT LESS THAN
70 PERCENT OF RELATIVE DENSITY DETERMINED IN
ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM D4253 AND D4254 (FOR FINES
CONTENT LESS THAN 5 PERCENT). THE UNDERDRAIN
CLEANOUT SHALL CONSIST OF 4 INCH POLYVINYL
CHLORIDE (PVC) PIPE WITH TWO 45 DEGREE BENDS AND
A THREADED CAP SET 2 INCHES ABOVE THE TOP OF THE
BIORETENTION MEDIA. A REMOVABLE PLATE OR GRATE
FLUSH WITH PAVEMENT SHALL BE PROVIDED ABOVE
THE CLEANOUT.
14. CDOT CLASS 1 OR 2 STRUCTURE BACKFILL, AS
DETERMINED BY ENGINEER AND COMPACTED TO
AT LEAST 95 PERCENT OF MAXIMUM DENSITY IN
ACCORDANCE WITH ASTM D698.
15. PICP AND UNDERLYING MATERIALS SHALL MEET THE
REQUIREMENTS OF USDCM VOLUME 3.
16. LINER AS SPECIFIED BY GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEER
SHALL BE MINIMUM 30 MIL THICK PVC GEOMEMBRANE
FABRICATED IN ONE PIECE.
This section presents an overview of basic components every project development plan containing green infrastructure should
incorporate. These components help identify items that would be helpful for City Staff performing the plan review for green infrastructure
designs.
BASIC COMPONENTS
Vicinity map showing project boundary, adjacent streets and nearby hydrologic features (streams, reservoirs, etc.) and FEMA
floodplain delineations (if applicable), and depth to groundwater (if applicable).
Total project area within the site boundary in acres or square feet.
Description of existing site drainage, including conveyance network; discharge locations, size, and capacity for each discharge
point; contributing drainage area and design flow; and off-site drainage areas, design flows, and locations.
Description of proposed project site drainage including conveyance network; discharge locations, size, and capacity for each
discharge point; contributing drainage area and design flow; and off-site drainage areas, design flows, and locations.
Increase or decrease in impervious area in the proposed condition as compared to the pre-project condition.
Total planned impervious area within the site boundary, expressed in acres or square feet and as a percentage of the total
project area.
Receiving waters to which the project site discharges, whether the waters are listed as impaired on the EPA-approved 303(d)
list, or if an EPA-approved TMDL applies to the waterbodies.
Identification and description of all source control measures implemented on the project site.
Sizing calculation for each proposed practice, including water quality design flow, design volume, outlet design, overflow design,
drawdown, ponding depth, etc.
Map or source identifying justification for rainfall data selection.
Studies or findings from environmental conditions reports within project area.
Details of planned slope protection measures to improve geotechnical stability and mitigate potential erosion.
Downspout disconnections with standard detail.
Areas of active landscaping that will require irrigation.
Invert elevation and opening width for curb cuts.
Invert elevation and overflow elevation for each identified treatment control, flow control practice, and low-flow diversion practice.
Invert elevation and outlet elevation for each pretreatment facility, if applicable.
Sufficient grading details so that runoff is properly directed to the design inflow location.
Bioretention is an engineered, depressed landscape area designed to capture and filter or infiltrate the water quality capture volume
(WQCV). Bioretention areas typically consist of a flow regulating structure, a pretreatment element, an engineered soil mix planting
bed, vegetation, and an outflow regulating structure. Bioretention areas are designed to hold and remove stormwater pollutants through
a variety of chemical, physical and biological processes in a manner similar to natural ecosystems. Bioretention systems are flexible,
adaptable and versatile stormwater management facilities that can fit readily into parking lot islands, street medians, residential,
commercial and industrial campus landscaping, and urban and suburban green spaces and corridors. Bioretention is a type of green
infrastructure that can be configured as streetside stormwater planters, bumpout stormwater planters, and green gutters to fit in ultra-
urban settings. Technical guidance is provided in green text below, including references to the Urban Drainage and Flood Control
District (UDFCD) Urban Storm Drainage Criteria Manual Volume 3, which is available online at www.udfcd.org.
Pedestrian Considerations
Is the site location and size reasonable for the drainage area
to be treated? For example, a green gutter is appropriate
for treating runoff from public ROW only; inclusion of runoff
from adjacent development would require a stormwater
planter.
Maximum depth of bioretention does not exceed 20 inches.
A tree trench provides stormwater quality treatment for streets and adjacent pedestrian zones. Stormwater enters the tree trench
through a curb opening, passes through a pea gravel filter for pretreatment and is conveyed through an underdrain to one or more
tree plantings. Treatment processes include filtration, soil adsorption, and uptake by the roots of the trees. A tree trench that features
a single tree is called a tree pit. Technical guidance is provided in green text below. Note that the Urban Drainage and Flood Control
District (UDFCD) Urban Storm Drainage Criteria Manual Volume 3 does not contain a practice description for infiltration trenches.
Specifications on this Plan Review Checklist were obtained from the Colorado Department of Transportation’s Drainage Design Manual
(see (http://www.coloradodot.info/programs/environmental/water-quality/documents/drainage-design-manual).
Permeable pavement allows streets, parking lots, sidewalks, and other impervious covers to maintain their structural and functional
features while restoring natural infiltration capacity. Permeable pavement contains small voids that allow rainfall and runoff to drain
through the pavement and eventually into the underlying soils. It can be used at various sites with low traffic frequency such as parking
lots, sidewalks, and driveways. Many permeable pavement surfaces are available, including pervious concrete, porous asphalt and
permeable interlocking concrete pavers. A green alley is designed to provide water quality treatment and infiltration of runoff though
the use of permeable pavement. The following plan review checklist is intended for reviewing green alleys where permeable pavement
is the primary green infrastructure reviewed. Green alleys may include other green infrastructure applications. Technical guidance is
provided in green text below, including references to the Urban Drainage and Flood Control District (UDFCD) Urban Storm Drainage
Criteria Manual Volume 3, which is available online at www.udfcd.org.
Plan Review Checklist for Permeable Pavement
An inspector undertaking a post-construction inspection evaluates the ability of a newly installed green infrastructure practice to perform
effectively and as planned. The inspector evaluates the constructed green infrastructure practice against approved design drawings and
plans. The post-construction inspection checklist provided in Appendix B can be used to ensure that green infrastructure is properly
constructed as designed and that stormwater management will be effective.
Ongoing maintenance of green infrastructure includes both routinely scheduled activities (e.g., landscape maintenance) and non-routine
activities that may be required after large storms (e.g., sediment removal and redistribution of mulch). Urban Drainage and Flood Control
District (UDFCD) presents maintenance considerations, in addition to specifications and standards, in Urban Storm Drainage Criteria
Manual (USDCM) Volume 3 (UDFCD 2013). A summary of maintenance considerations, maintenance activities and their frequency is
presented in Section 2, and a maintenance checklist is provided in Appendix B.
BIORETENTION
The primary maintenance requirement for bioretention is regular plant, soil, and mulch layer (if applicable) maintenance to ensure a
healthy vegetation system that promotes infiltration, storage, and pollutant removal. A healthy and densely vegetated system should be
free of excess sediment and trash, and the system typically should drain within 12 hours of a storm. Replacement of vegetation may be
necessary to maintain optimal performance. Bioretention maintenance requirements are applicable to all forms of bioretention.
Maintenance is typical of general landscape care and consists of the following:
Sediment removal. Sweep or shovel sediment from the sediment collection pad/forebay after each storm event, approximately
two times per year or as needed after storm events. Dispose of sediment outside the planter.
Watering. Vegetation must be drought-tolerant and generally should not require watering after a 2- to 3-year establishment
period. Watering could be required during prolonged dry periods after vegetation has been established.
Debris and litter removal. Remove debris and litter from the infiltration surface to minimize clogging of the media. If applicable,
remove debris and litter from the overflow structure. The degree of debris and litter accumulation is variable and is influenced by
surrounding land uses, pedestrian traffic or activities, and the presence of trees.
Landscaping. Mow grasses as desired or needed for weed control. Native or drought-tolerant grasses should be maintained at
a height of at least 6 inches; mowing may not be necessary. Occasional pruning or removal of dead plant or tree material (e.g.,
leaf litter) and periodic weeding may be necessary depending on the plants chosen. Periodic weeding may be necessary during
the establishment period until the soil media is covered with mulch or dense vegetation.
Mulch. In areas where heavy metal deposition is likely (e.g., contributing areas that include industrial and auto-related businesses,
parking lots, and roads) replace mulch annually. In areas where metal deposition is not a concern, add mulch as needed to
maintain a mulch depth of up to 3 inches. Mulch should be replaced every 2 to 5 years where metal deposition is not a concern.
Nutrients and pesticides. Bioretention soil mix and plants are selected for optimum fertility, plant establishment, and growth.
Nutrients and pesticides should not be applied, as they can degrade the pollutant removal capability of the bioretention system
and contribute pollutant loads to receiving waters.
Inlet. Inlets should be inspected for sediment accumulation and signs of erosion. Excess sediment can accumulate at inlets
where curb cuts or bypass structures are used and should be inspected regularly. Any accumulated sediment that impedes flow
into the bioretention area should be removed and properly disposed (not placed elsewhere in the planter). When the system is
first installed, inlets should be inspected after each storm event to identify any potential inflow and sediment issues that require
design modifications. Subsequently inlets should be inspected after the first storm of the season and then monthly during the
rainy season.
Overflow and underdrains. Sediment accumulation in the overflow device or underdrain system can cause prolonged ponding
and potential flooding. Excess ponding can damage vegetation and create mosquito-breeding habitat. Overflow and underdrain
systems should be inspected to ensure that cleanouts are watertight and there is no visible debris inside the overflow structure.
Inspection of bioretention practices should occur at least twice annually following runoff-generating storms to determine if the practice
is providing acceptable infiltration. If standing water persists for more than 24 hours after runoff has ceased, clogging should be
investigated and remedied. Areas where erosion has occurred should be inspected, as these are potential sources of sediment if not
repaired.
Debris and litter removal. Remove debris and litter from the infiltration surface to minimize clogging of the media. The degree
of debris and litter accumulation is variable and is influenced by surrounding land uses, pedestrian traffic or activities and season
(tree litter is expected each fall).
Landscaping. Occasional pruning, removal of dead tree material (e.g., leaf litter) and periodic weeding may be necessary.
Inlet. Inlets should be inspected for sediment accumulation and signs of erosion. Excess sediment can accumulate at inlets
where curb cuts or bypass structures are used and should be inspected regularly. Any accumulated sediment that impedes flow
into the tree trench or tree pit should be removed and properly disposed (not placed elsewhere in the planter). When the system
is first installed, inlets should be inspected after each storm event to identify any potential inflow and sediment issues that require
design modifications. Subsequently inlets should be inspected after the first storm of the season and then monthly during the
rainy season.
Forebay. The aggregate in the forebay should be vacuumed regularly (monthly during the wet season is recommended) and
replaced routinely (when significant clogging is observed). Maintenance frequency is dependent on the rate the media clogs.
Media clogging is a function of drainage area size, presence or amount of construction activity, and the pollutant loads in the
runoff. Inspections are recommended once or twice per year to detect early visual signs of clogging.
Overflow and underdrains. Sediment accumulation in the overflow device or underdrain system can cause prolonged
ponding and potential flooding. Excess ponding can damage the soil media and create mosquito-breeding habitat. Overflow
and underdrain systems should be inspected to ensure that cleanouts are watertight and there is no visible debris inside the
overflow structure.
Inspection of tree trenches or tree pits should occur at least twice annually following runoff-generating storms to determine if runoff
is flowing through the system properly. If standing water persists for more than 24 hours after runoff has ceased, clogging should be
investigated and remedied. Areas where erosion has occurred should be inspected, as these are potential sources of sediment if not
repaired.
PERMEABLE PAVEMENT
The key maintenance objective for permeable pavement systems is to prevent void spaces from becoming clogged or requiring
sediment removal. Infiltration issues can be identified when runoff ponds on the surface or is no longer infiltrating into the surface
rapidly. Key maintenance considerations and procedures consist of the following (refer to USDCM Volume 3 for further details regarding
specific permeable pavement types):
Debris removal, sweeping, and vacuuming. Debris should be removed routinely as a source control measure. Sweeping
with a regenerative air sweeper (not a broom sweeper) should be performed approximately two times per year. Frequency can
be adjusted according to the run-on ratio and deposition rate on the permeable pavement surface. Frequent sweeping is an
excellent measure to prevent clogging, and sweeping with a vacuum sweeper has shown to be effective for removing solids and
debris from the void space of permeable pavement.
Weed control. Weed control applications should be used on any weeds that grow in permeable pavement. Where underdrains
provide a hard connection to a storm drain, weeds should be spot-treated with an herbicide not containing polyethoxylated amine
(POEA). Weeds should not be pulled, as doing so can damage the fill media.
Snow removal. Plowing is a recommended snow removal process. Conventional liquid treatments (deicers) will not stay at the
surface of a permeable pavement as needed to be effective. Sand should never be applied to a permeable pavement, as it will
reduce infiltration.
Inspection of pavement condition and verification of infiltration should be performed at least annually, either during a rain event or with
a garden hose to ensure that water infiltrates into the surface.
REFERENCE
UDFCD (Urban Drainage and Flood Control District). 2013, August. Urban Storm Drainage Criteria Manual Volume 3. Accessed July
7, 2014. http://www.udfcd.org/downloads/down_critmanual_volIII.htm.
BIORETENTION
Streetside Stormwater Planters, Bumpout Stormwater Planters, and Green Gutters
Inspection Item Yes No N/A Corrective Action (if “no”)
1. Will site runoff enter the practice as intended?
2. Will flow be evenly dispersed following the inlet? Are
there signs of or potential for concentrated flow?
3. Will site runoff enter the practice as intended?
4. Do the bioretention dimensions match those specified in
the construction drawings?
5. Are step-out zone dimensions (if applicable) according to
plans?
6. Are pedestrian barriers in place and sized according to
plans?
7. Are underdrains installed? If so, are the slots oriented and
sized according to the plans?
8. If applicable, are underdrain cleanouts visible and
sealed? If in a valve box, ensure filter material has also
been placed between the valve box and cleanout.
11. Is the distance from the surface of the filter area to the
outflow (spillway and top of the weir inside the water
control structure) appropriate to provide the ponding
depth per the construction drawing?
12. Is the outlet control weir set to the elevation shown on
the construction drawings?
13. Does the bioretention media match the description of the
media provided in the submittal?
14. Has the bioretention media infiltration rate been tested
according to the plans and specifications? Verify
infiltration rate test records.
PERMEABLE PAVEMENT
Common Elements
Inspection Item Yes No N/A Corrective Action (if “no”)
1. Does the alley drainage area appear to drain centrally
towards the permeable pavement (away from buildings)?
FACILITY INFORMATION
PROPERTY OWNER: INSPECTION DATE:
Other:_________________________
TYPE(S) PRESENT:
Recommended
Exposure Size
Scientific Name Common Name Water Needs Container Size Maintenance Comments
Sun/Shade Height + Spread
+ Spacing
GRASSES
Andropogon gerardii Dancing Wind 4’ in bloom; plug or qt; 2-3’ cut back in red fall color;
Drought Tolerant Sun
‘Dancing Wind’ Big Bluestem rhizomatous spacing late winter CN
Winter Andropogon Windwalker 4’ in bloom; plug or qt; 4’ cut back in Powder blue
gerardii ‘P003S’ Big Bluestem Drought Tolerant Sun foliage; CN
rhizomatous spacing late winter
Winter Calamagrostis x Feather Reed Grass Sun, filtered plug or qt; 2-3’ cut back in Greens up early
Drought Tolerant 3-4’ height
96
acutiflora ‘Karl Forester’ shade spacing late winter sping; NON
2-4’ height; 18” - plug or qt; 6” - cut back in Shade tolerant;
Deschampsia caespitosa Tufted Hair Grass Mesic Sun, shade 2’ spread 18” spacing late winter CN
Bouteloua gracilis ‘Blonde Blonde Ambition plug or qt; 6” - cut back in Straw yellow seed
Xeric Sun 18” in bloom
Ambition’ Grama Grass 18” spacing late winter heads; CN
Panicum virgatum ‘Hot Hot Rod plug or qt; 4’ cut back in reddish summer
Rod’ Switchgrass Drought Tolerant Sun 4-5’ in bloom
spacing late winter and fall foliage; CN
Panicum virgatum plug or qt; 2-3’ cut back in formal upright
’Northwind’ Northwind Switchgrass Drought Tolerant Sun 4-5’ in bloom
spacing late winter foliage; CN
Panicum virgatum ‘Prairie plug or qt; 2-3’ cut back in steel blue fine-
Prairie Sky Drought Tolerant Sun 4-5’ in bloom
Sky’ spacing late winter textured foliage; CN
Schizachirium scoparium Prairie Blues plug or qt; 6” - cut back in blue summer foliage,
Drought Tolerant Sun 3’ in bloom red winter foliage,
‘Prairie Blues’ Lttle Bluestem 18” spacing late winter
CN
Muhlenbergia reverchoni foliage looks good
Undaunted Ruby Drought Tolerant Sun 3’ in bloom plug or qt; 6” - cut back in year round; red fall
‘Undaunted’ Muhly 18” spacing late winter flowers, N
Key:
CN - Colorado Native Native
N - North American NON - Non-Native
Sporobolus lush green foliage;
Sun, partial plug or qt; 6” - cut back in tidy mounded habit;
heterolepis Prairie dropseed Drought Tolerant 3’ in bloom shade tolerant, CN
shade 18” spacing late winter
HERBACEOUS PERENNIALS
plug or qt; 1.5 - 2’ long lasting silvery blooks
Sun, partial cut back in
Anaphalis margaritacea Pearly Everlasting Drought Tolerant 2-3’ tall and wide contrast with bushy green
shade spacing late winter foliage; shade tolerant, CN
8-10” from a tufted plug or qt; 6” cut back in allow to self sow; N
Anaphalis margaritacea Prairie Bluebell Drought Tolerant Sun late winter
rosette spacing
Helianthus maximiliani Dakota Sunshine 5’ tall by 4’ wide, plug or qt; 6” cut back in seed attracts
Drought Tolerant Sun spacing late winter goldfinches, CN
‘Dakota Sunshine’ Sunflower spreading
APPENDIX C: PLANT LISTS
97
shade late winter tolerant, CN
Key:
CN - Colorado Native Native
N - North American NON - Non-Native
BULBS
Camassia leichtlinii bulb with showy
Blue Danube Wild Sun,or 12-18” tall, Bulbs, clustered in cut back after blue flowers mid
‘Blue Danube’ Drought Tolerant clumping groups 9 bulbs/SF spring bloom spring; shade
Hyacinth shade tolerant NON
SHRUBS
Sun, partial #1 or #5 container; prune to shape silver foliage; orange
Amorpha Canescens Leadplant Drought Tolerant 2-3’ tall and wide 1-2’ spacing and purple summer
in late winter
shade bloom; CN
Dasiphora (Potentilla)
‘Praire Snow’ #1 or #5 container prune to shape long blooming
APPENDIX C: PLANT LISTS
98
Buttes’ Sand Cherry in late winter fruit for wildlife, CN
Key:
CN - Colorado Native Native
N - North American NON - Non-Native
APPENDIX D: FORESTRY MEMO
The following list of tree species are approved for planting in green infrastructure stormwater facilities within Denver
rights-of-way.
Please note that this list may change overtime based on experience and species performance.
City Forester issued planting and removal permits are required prior to the removal or planting of trees within Denver
rights-of-way.
Please contact the Office of the City Forester for more information on planting trees within stormwater facilities or to
request tree permits.
The following are standard spacing requirements for street trees in Denver:
• 35’ between shade trees
• 25’ between ornamental trees
• 30’ from curb at intersections
• 20’ from street lights
• 10’ from alleys, driveways & fire hydrants
Shading indicates species suitable for planting under overhead utilities. These varieties should only be planted in
situations where overhead growth restrictions exist.
Celtis laevigata All Seasons Sugar Hackberry 5 Xeric to Min Tolerant 60 Rounded to broad rounded with slightly
40 pendulous branching in maturity; simple Can be cold sensitive,
and lanceolate to narrow ovate glossy borderline zone rating
and green to dull yellow in fall.
Pyramidal when young, irregular-rounded Very susceptible to Nipple
Gall, aesthetic problem
Celtis occidentalis Common Hackberry 3 Xeric to Min Tolerant 60 45 when mature; light to medium green in unless major and repeated
summer, yellow in fall
APPENDIX D: FORESTRY MEMO
infestation
Rounded canopy with showy, exfoliating Has the occasional small
Crataegus ambigua Russian Hawthorn 4 Xeric Unknown 20 20 bark; small, finely cut medium-green thorn but is essentially
leaves thornless
Shape makes maintaining
Crataegus crus-galli Thornless Cockspur Round with strongly horizontal branching;
100
Ginko biloba Autumn Gold broad spreading with age; unique Male clone, fruitless. Slow
Ginko 4 Mod Intermediate 45 35 fan-shaped leaves with excellent gold grower
fall color
Broadly rounded, good horizontal
Gleditsia triacanthos Thornless branching angles; compound ovate Essentially fruitless; over-
Imperial 4 Xeric Tolerant 60 40 leaflets green to yellow in fall. Skyline
used in landscape design
inermis Honeylocust best structure of group.
Gleditsia triacanthos Moraine, Northern Acclaim, Thornless Vase shaped, rounded, flat topped with
Tolerant 35 maturity; compound ovate leaflets green Essentially fruitless; over-
4 Xeric 45 used in landscape design
inermis Shademaster, Skyline Honeylocust to yellow in fall. Skyline best structure
of group.
Malus cv Any 1/2” or smaller-fruiting Min to Mod 20 25 Pruning for street use
Crabapple Variable by cultivar; variable leaves
non-pendulous variety
Platanus Pyramidal to rounded; large leaves, Large root system. Fruit
American Sycamore Mod Intermediate 75 50 litter. Requires a tree lawn
4 green in summer to yellow in autumn
occidentalis at least 8 ft. wide
101
Syringa pekinesis Brandon; New Harmony; 25 20
Spreading rounded vase; green leaves, trunk; leafs out early and
3 Xeric to Min Intermediate no autumn color; showy, white flowers in frequently suffer frost
Princeton; Valley Forge Lilac early summer damage in spring
Japanese Mod Unknown 30 Similar in outline to American elm; dark DED and ELB resistant
Ulmus japonica Discovery 3 35 green summer foliage; yellow in fall
Elm