General Building Defects: Causes, Symptoms and Remedial Work
General Building Defects: Causes, Symptoms and Remedial Work
General Building Defects: Causes, Symptoms and Remedial Work
(3), № 1
School of Housing, Building and Planning, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 11800, Penang
PhD (Civil Engineering), Senior Lecturer
E-mail: [email protected]
Abstract. Building defect is one of the major components of building problems that
significantly needed attention. When a building fails to function as it should, we must immediately
seek for the determination. Is the problem taking place as the result of the worker’s failure to
assemble it properly? Is it involving the nature of it? Is the proper maintenance of the building not
been performed as it should have been? The answers often depend upon a number of factors: the
age of the affected building components, the exact nature of the problem, the presence or absence
of human error, or some combination of all those three. This paper will review and discuss some of
the major building defects happen throughout the world. It contains some of the main concepts
and the definition of the terminological terms used. In addition, the causes, symptoms and
remedial work of defect also been discussed in this paper.
Keywords: building defects, dampness, erosion, building, peeling paint, failure.
1. Introduction
Building defect occurs to either the new building or the old ones. Defect within new buildings
is maybe of non-compliance with Building Code and published acceptable tolerances and
standards. Meanwhile the older buildings, or building out of warranty period, may not comply with
these standards but must be judged against the standard at the time of construction or
refurbishment. (David Hall)
Defects and deterioration are common problems in any built structures. However, various
defects are more common in an old structure (Ransom, 1981). As in BS 3811 (Code of Practice,
British Standard 1984) defects are defined as the deterioration of building features and services to
unsatisfactory quality levels of requirement of the users.
According to California Civil Code 896, common types of building defects include: structural
defects resulting in cracks or collapse; defective or faulty electrical wiring or lighting, defective or
faulty plumbing, inadequate drainage systems, faulty ventilation, cooling or heating systems,
insufficient insulation or sound proofing, and also inadequate fire protection suppression systems.
Plus, dry rot, wood rot, mold, fungus, or termite or vermin infestation may also be the result of a
building defect.
A building defect may also include damage caused by land movement or earth settlement.
Proving a building defect commonly requires the hiring and testimony of a highly trained and
experienced expert. An expert, such as an engineer or an architect, is the one who will be able to
4
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
determine the construction problem involved due to the result of improper design, material, or
workmanship.
b) Non-structural defect
According to Northern Territory Consolidated Regulation, a non-structural defect in a
residential building is described as a defect in a non-structural element of the building as a result of
defective residential building work.
According to the Engineering Encyclopedia, non-structural defect includes defect in brick
work, dampness in old structures, and defects in plaster works.
5
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
According to the construction, the occurrence of wall crack is because they are overloaded or
because the structure has settled or heaved. Vertical and angled crack are usually caused by
settlement or heaving. Nevertheless, for horizontal crack are more likely to be caused by lateral
pressure. There are varieties types of vertical crack such as:
a) Vertical crack away from corners
The crack is running along between the foundation and the top of the building. Cracks are
usually the widest at the top of the building diminishing to a hairline crack at or near the
foundation level (Figure 1). They may run through the foundation or they may only start above first
floor opening. It is obviously detected in each of the opposite elevations of the building, will be a
6
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
single crack, and may be connected by a crack in a concrete floor or a flat roof. Besides that, the
roof finishes of the pitched roof may be stretched or pulled apart. Diagonal cracks may also be
associated with the defect.
In the early life of cracking of the building may be inevitable. Cracks result from drying out or
taking up of moisture or from the initial drying out of material that cannot be avoided. Cracks also
is often exaggerated, it means a natural reaction of the owner or occupiers of the building. Besides
that, cracks may be an indication of instability of the structure, even though it is taken seriously, it
will have little or no effect on stability or other aspect of building performance apart from
appearance.
Thermal expansion also is the causes in these cases where it actually is not the true main
cause. Whichever origin of the crack will be, a convenient observation point will be provided. It is
easy to observe changes in size where a crack opens and closes, whereas changes in the overall
dimension of a wall can be measured only by using special equipment.
Besides that, slight movement also can cause cracking to large building. However, the
occurrence has nothing to do to small building. The result is shown where the large concrete roof
7
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
slabs disrupts the perimeter parapet as it expands and contract in response to temperature
variations. A temporary load or lack of support also may also be result to cracks. There is no
evidence detected when the causes of cracking are being investigated. Cracks also have subjected
influence. Maybe it is not described above, but it can probably happen if they give less maintenance
or awareness.
3.2 Peeling paint
Peeling usually occurs on building facades, mainly on plastered walls, columns and other
areas which are exposed to excessive rain and great dampness (Figure 4). Some buildings that are
located near the sea may face a much higher risk once the signs of peeling paint are visible on the
exterior walls. (Md. Kasim N.D, 2009)
Peeling paint is always the result of poor surface preparation. The majority of peeling paint
problems occurs on surfaces exposed to the rain, sun, and the variation degree of temperature.
Walls that have involved can be an unsightly mess in a home or building. It may result in
embarrassment and frustration to the homeowner. If paint peels from an interior wall, the reason
for the peeling paint is mostly often due to an improper preparation of the surface before painting.
Apart from that, the moisture surrounding the wall also seeps in through from the wall to the paint
surface. Thus, in order to repair and restore, repainting the wall that had peeling paint on it can be
made as to make it attractive again. According to Midway Industrial Supply, peeling paint is simply
other types of flaking where the amount of paint film remove is greater. Flaking is the lifting of
small-to-large sections of the paint and is due to poor adhesion and to the brittleness of the paint.
It happens when new plastered or skimmed walls or ceiling are not given enough time to
completely dry before painting. The temptation is to start painting as soon as the plasterer has left
the building but plaster takes longer to completely dry. The heating on full blast to try to speed up
the drying process also result to peeling paint. This is because the sudden rise in temperature can
cause different problems.
Another reasons that peeling paint occurs is that when the initial coat of paint on the new
plaster is bog standard silk applied undiluted directly to the plaster. For the bathroom ceiling cases,
it has been freshly painted on the new plaster which has never had a chance to dry. This is because
the bathroom is in constant use and then the shower is being used before the paint is completely
dry.
8
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
Dampness is generally defined as unwanted and excessive water or moisture. The existing of
dampness in building is one of the most damaging failures that really must be taken care of. It can
cause damage in brickwork by saturating them, decaying and breaking up of mortar joints, rotting
in the timber structures, defecting by the corrosion of iron and steel materials and also destroying
the equipment in the building. Dampness in walls has been taken in consideration in recent years.
If even the level of dampness is low, the value of the building can be highly affected.
According to Belgrade Charter (1975), dampness can be a serious matter, particularly to the
building located near water sources. Somehow, the water can enter the building bit by bit through
different routes resulting in dampness. Furthermore, prevailing wet wind and rain will due to water
penetrations that occur through walls.
Dampness also occur when water penetrate through capillaries or cracks between mortar
joints, and bricks or blocks before building up trap moisture behind hard renders. Moreover,
contribution of dampness is due to the existence of gravity. The other factor such as leaking gutters
or down pipes, defective drains, burst plumbing, and condensation due to inadequate ventilation
also can be the factors yielding to dampness occurrence. Dampness in building originated from a
number of sources such as:
a) Rain
Precipitation can be wind driven that it penetrates joints that remain watertight in normal
weather condition. The gutter overflow also can collect and be the aspects of dampness against
walls.
b) Condensation
Humid air condensation on cooler surface or within, or between, building materials also can
result to dampness. Air can become humid in several ways, including from the occupants’ water
vapours.
c) Rising damp and flooding
It may be contract with groundwater or floodwater. It also the groundwater may be absorbed
by the walls and transported up the wall by capillary action.
d) Services leaks
It may not just from pipes and tanks, but also the overflowing of condensation forming
together with ventilation systems.
e) Construction process
The construction process too can play its role in this scenario. It is where the process of
mixing water to form mixtures that dry out for the construction purpose before the building is
functioned, but sometimes by retaining moisture (sealed in by impermeable finishes) that shows
and causes problems in the completed building.
f) Use of the building
This may includes the cleaning of the building, spills, and apparatus leaking.
g) Moisture in the air
It is in contrast with condensation. Hygroscopic salts can extract moisture from the air in
condition that would not allow that moisture to undergo the process of condensation.
9
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
Dampness comes and goes according with the change of condition. Dampness also may leave
stains or traces of mould and lichens and also in certain cases, mosses.
3.4 Timber decay
Timber defect are classified into two major groups, non-biological and biological
deteriorations. Non-biological deterioration consists of physical decay, excessive moisture content,
dimensional instability and chemical deterioration. These defects are mainly caused by the timber
in service being subjected to environmental exposure. The most common and destructive timber
biological deterioration is those due to dry rot, wet rot as well as insect attraction. (N.H. Ishak)
Typically timber decay may occur at roof timber, floor timber and joinery timber such as door
frame or window frame (Figure 6 and Figure 7). This defect results whether woodworm infestation
is active or there is evidence of decay such as wet rot and dry rot. Dry rot also can be destructive
and spread considerable distance within an effected building or home. It is essential that the cause
and full extent of the attack is established. Besides that, timber decay in building or home will only
occur if the timber becomes sufficiently wet.
According to Exposure Surveying LTD, timber part of a building will display differing levels
of moisture content. Apart from that, it is indicated that wood rooting fungi will not affect the
timber with moisture content below 22% and wood boring beetles will not be successful in timber
with moisture content below 12%. This reading will change depending on the number of years.
According to Taylor (2000), timber is durable material and would last indefinitely as it does
not deteriorate spontaneously. Magnificently, atmospheric condition such as rain, frost and acids
that would normally affect other materials, however only has little effect on timber. It will
deteriorate if attracted by certain of external forces.
Timber is also subjected to biological deterioration caused by living organisms such as insect
infestation, fugal decay and marine borers. On the other hand, it is highly reliant on combination of
a suitable temperature, moisture, oxygen, and cellulose in timber. (Richardson, 2001). Generally,
the most common causes of timber decay are as follows:
a) Design
Usually proven in many older buildings, structural timbers are embedded into external walls
and encased into solid floor, which are being the common causes of timber decay.
b) Alterations
This is regularly seen when sand and cement rendering has been applied to the exterior of the
building, trapping moisture and elevating the moisture content of timber window lintels and
embedded joints, leading to their decaying.
c) Maintenance
Blocked gutters, missing roof tiles and leaking pipes will all channel the water to ingress into
the fabric of the building, which will then affect timber to decay if the problems are not noticed and
restored soon enough.
d) Wood boring insect
It is a fact to know that old building or home will somehow, have evidences of some form of
beetle activity, which will mostly be historic and will have died out years ago.
Timber that is used in the building during construction may have high sapwood (high in
nutrients) content and have been susceptible to beetle infestation. However, as the sapwood has
been depleted and the moisture levels within the timber remain stable, the beetle infestation will
10
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
die out. The beetle will only infest the heartwood section of the converted timber if it has been
modified by fungal decay.
e) Fungal decay
Fungal decay occurs when higher level of moisture that consequently leads to the
development of beetle infestation. It can be separated into two groups, white and brown rots.
White rots have a bleached, fibrous appearance and substantial loss in weight is evident in the
timber. It happened when there is high moisture content on timbers that are already decayed by
brown rots. Brown rots are synonymous with the darkening of the timber, cubical cracks and are
mainly found in softwood.
11
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
Mold and fungi are found everywhere either both indoors and outdoors all the year round
(Figure 8 and Figure 9). The terms fungi and mold are often used interchangeably, but mold is
actually a type of fungi. Concerning about indoor exposure to mold has increased along with public
awareness that exposure to mold can cause a variety of adverse health effects. There are many
thousands of species of mold and most, if not all of the mold found indoors comes from outdoor
sources. It seems likely to grow and become bigger threat only when there is water damage, high
humidity, or dampness.
Mold is addressed in specific standards for the general industry, shipyard employment, and
the construction industry. Molds live in the soil, on plants, and on dead or decaying matters.
Outdoors, molds play as a key role in the breakdown of leaves, wood, and other plant debris. Molds
belong to the kingdom of Fungi, and unlike plants, they are lack in chlorophyll and must survive by
digesting plant materials, and consequently inverting them and other organic materials as food.
Without molds, our environment would be overwhelmed with large amounts of dead plant matter.
Molds produce tiny spores to reproduce, just as same as those plants that produce seeds.
These mold spores can be found in both indoor and outdoor air, and settled on both of the surfaces.
When mold spores land on a damp spot, they may begin growing and digesting whatever they are
growing on in order to survive. Since molds gradually destroy the things they grow on, you can
prevent damage to building materials and furnishings and save money by eliminating their growth.
Molds produce and release millions of spores small enough to be in the air, water, or insect
borne. They can also produce toxic agents known as mycotoxins. Spores and mycotoxins can have
negative effects on human health.
The moisture of wall occurs due to many causes. There are water leakages, drain block, roof
leakage and so on. In addition, improper material also was used for the building. Other causes of
moisture due to DPC that is not installed correctly for the particular building. Instead of the
moisture, the high level of humidity around the building also being affected due to abundant
growth of trees and insufficient direct sunlight. Moreover, spores of mold from trees can be spread
to the building by the assist of air, water and insect borne. Molds are found everywhere inside and
outside, and can grow on almost any substances when moisture presents. Molds reproduce by
spores, which can be carried by air current. When these spores land on a moist surface that is
suitable for life, they begin to grow. There are three common causes of mold
a) Water leakage
Water leakage will happen by the plumbing that is not installed properly. Some time water
leakage also comes from the toilet. Besides that, the gutter of roof also can cause the mold that will
attach itself to the wall.
b) Moisture
Moisture of the wall can cause the faster growth of the mold. The moisture is affected due to
the improper material that was used for this environment where this building receives less of
sunlight.
12
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
c) Humidity
Higher humidity can cause the growth of mold faster. Plus, the residence was surrounded by
abundant of big trees and reduces of direct sunlight through the building. Thus the degree of
humidity around the building is high.
3.7 Defective plaster rendering
Plaster or render is like mortar coating over the block work. The coating on the inside walls
called plaster, then the coating outside the walls called render. Plaster and render is totaling
different. The render is generally richer and mostly in cement than the plaster due to weather
resistant.
The both of plaster and renders have different function. The plaster insides the walls to make
the walls smooth, easy to clean, avoid from insect, and for better appearance. Apart from that, the
plasters act as a protection against fire. The other functions are breathable for walls, abrasion
resistant, and suitable for decorating or covering with coating, wallpaper and tiles. For the renders,
is provided to protect them from the influences of weather.
Mostly the defective plaster rendering occurs on the external walls, column and ceiling.
Defective rendering are normally caused by biological attacks arising from penetrating rain,
evaporation, condensation, air pollution, dehydration and thermal stress. The mould or harmful
growth, insect, animals, and traffic vibration also will contribution causes of defective plaster
rendering. Prior to being decomposed and broken apart, rendering may crack due to either
shrinkage or movement in the substrate. (A Ghafar Ahmad). Types of defective plaster rendering
a) Cracking in Plastering
This is because of breaking away the section of the plaster. Penetration of rain to the external
surface of structural, have allowing admittance of rain to the back of the intact plaster coat. So, any
weakness in the bond between plaster and background or between renders coats will make the
further defect.
b) Holes in Plaster wall
Holes usually occur because of user or human made such as hanging family picture, shelves
or other decorative item to the wall. the is easily to be filled in with a tad of sparkling compound.
c) Plaster falling off from ceiling
Often the vibration of people going up and down by the stair for many years is cause to
plaster falling off from ceiling. The vibration will travel through the plaster and cause hairlines
cracks between the wooh lath, and plaster.
d) Shrinkage Cracking
When strong mixes of render are used on weak or bad prepared background have due to
shrinkage cracking. if the crack only in the topcoat, it caused the excessive cement in the finish coat
or excessive thickness or if the renders is too wet.
Causes of defective of plaster rendering as follows:
1. Loss of bond between coats
It means inadequate key or mineral bond, rapid loss of moisture to undercoat, swelling of
clay materials in unwashed sand, a stronger outer coat, inappropriate paint and finish used.
2. Surface cracking
High strength plaster on a weak background, clay contaminated sand and structural
movement will due to surface cracking. Normally, happen when drying shrinkage on surface.
3. Friable powdery surfaces
It means rapid drying, migration of salts (these usually follow a pattern of moisture
movement through the building)
4. Water damage
Source of water comes from overflowing tub, leakage in the toilet or shower, seep out of
plumbing or roof, storm damage, cracks around a chimney, and the list goes on. All of these will
eventually cause to the rust of nails, and some other dirt or debris.
5. Movement of structure
The settling of the house, expansion or shrinking of the wood inside the ceiling or walls is due
to movement. Besides that, the external factors such as vibration from the outside construction,
traffic or even sound wave also contribute to movement of the structure.
13
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
Roof as usually exposed to the element, particularly to the extremes of temperature degree
and change, solar radiation, and wind action. Roofs have special risk due to the design of the
building itself such as services passing through the roof covering, and internal gutters. The
consequence small defective of roof will may be greater effect of similar defect in a wall or other
element.
Roof defect are divided into structural faults and defect in the waterproofing material. The
majority of roof defect that occurs is distortion of either the roof or of the wall at roof level (Figure
10). Normally, structural defect can be identified from the visual inspection. For the defect of
waterproofing material, it will provide the building to be durable under wide range of exposure
condition. The pitch roof sagging result is from the slating or tilling that has dished appearance,
and the ridge may also have sagged. This defect is more commonly found in older pitched and tiled
or slated roof.
While there are many different types of roofing defects, most are known to be causes by:
a) Improper installation
The installation of roof will need a number of skilled workers. If the roof is not installed
properly, it wills yield to roof defect such as roof leakage and sagging. The causes of roof defect are
because the worker maybe not have a license, or certificate apart from having a low level of
experience.
14
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
b) Poor workmanships
Quality of workmanship is needed such as to maintain the roof or construction of roof. The
life expectancy will be reduced due to the poor workmanships which is can both bring to loss for
both the dealer and the buyer.
c) Defective materials
Materials themselves also may be the factors to the roof defect. The material too, may be not
suitable to weather condition. Sometimes, it is not installed correctly also due to sagging and
deformation.
3.9 Erosion of mortar joint
Mortar is a mixture of sand and cements in form of brick and block walls. The compositions
of mortar are sand, water, and cement or lime. When it dried, it became rigid aggregate that is
defined as building paste. While it was still wet, the mortar is spread along the edges of brick or
stone.
Mortar joint is function to the masonry block or brick wall. This is because of there is strong
and durable materials. Mortar joint is considering deterioration when have the sign such as:
i. They have eroded more than 1/4" from the face of the unit or beyond the depth of the
original joint.
ii. Cracks are visible within the mortar
iii. The bond between brick and mortar is broken or the mortar is soft or crumbling
iv. Any portion of mortar joint is missing
Mortar joints are not intended to be a permanent part of a masonry wall, but rather, an
expendable component that does have to be replaced at intervals. Removing deterioration of
mortar joint is having through the repointing process and replacing it with new mortar.
The causes of erosion of mortar joint as follows:
Spalling of the mortar and brick will occur due to the expansive nature of frozen water.
This happens when excessive moisture enters the wall.
Any building that are built without adequate expansion joints will be the cause for this
problem.
The cracking occurs due to movement, or from thermal expansion. Besides, uneven
settlement in building’s foundation also can produce to cracking.
Probably the mortar is unstable to be as resistant as it should be to severe weathering such
as the use of high cement content mortars can result in loss of bond between brick and mortar.
15
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
b) Faulty Design
Design is important thing before the building is constructed. Design will ensure the
foundation is suitable for supporting the building. If the design fails to fulfill the requirement
standard, it will cause the building to collapse.
c) Overloaded
The maximum load of building will be stated by the architect. The building will collapse if the
load is not suitable with the foundation. The foundation must be stable enough and suitable to
support the building and its total load. (Dead and Living Load)
d) Material
Material also will affect the stability of the foundation. The material used will affect the
strength of the concrete. It is also being a must to ensure that the foundation will last long and have
longer life expectancy. At the same times, the foundation should be made from materials that will
do well even in the presence of ground or surface water.
e) Natural Disaster
Another factor is natural disaster that is unexpected. It also happened because of human
negligence.
4. Conclusions
It should be pointed out that, entire buildings are subjected to the various forms of defects,
failures, deterioration and variation. The literature has explored a number of building defects and
its contribution factors which can be associated to the major theme of this paper. It is significant to
appraise each defect and failure in every part of building and find out the primary causes of each
individual defect and failure. Then, remedy them correctly. The contribution factors to these
defects and failures must be investigated intensely. Once founding out the possible causes of the
defects and failures, it is imperative to distinguish how to keep away from it in the future and
reduce the effect to the minimum.
5. References
1. A Ghafar Ahmad (2004) The Dilapidation Report, Journal of ‘’Majalah Arkitek”, vol. 16,
pp. 19–21.
2. A Sufian and Rozanah Abdul Rahman (2008) Quality Housing: Regulation and
Administrative Framework in Malaysia, Int. Journal of Economic and Management, pp. 141–156.
3. Burden, E. (2004) Illustrated Dictionary of Architectural Preservation: Restoration,
Renovation, Rehabilitation and Reuse. New York: McGraw Hill.
4. Blake Turner & Co Solicitor, (1969) Building Defect: The Legal Position.
5. Belgrade Charter, (1975) Conservation in Belgrade, European Commission UNESCO,
International Conference Spain.
6. Code of British Standards (BS 3811: 1964), Maintenance.
7. California Civil Code 896, Construction Defect Law.
8. David Hall (1988) Building Defect Inspection and Report.
9. F Abu Bakar (2008) Satisfaction Level on Quality of Material and Workmanship of low
cost housing in Klang Valley.
10. Ghani S. and Lee L. M. (1997), Low Cost Housing In Malaysia, Utusan Publications &
Distributors Sdn. Bhd. Kuala Lumpur.
11. Lipa A (2001) Termite species that attack buildings and timber at Similajau National
Park, Malaysia, Hornbill 5:nn-nn
12. Lee. M. (1987) Building Maintenance Management, Third Edition, Collin, London.
13. Micheal S. Poles (2013) Construction Defect.
14. Md Kasim N.D. (2009) Building Defect: Case Study at Taman Seri Indah, Permatang
Pauh.
15. Northern Territory Consolidated Regulation, (2013) Building (RBI and Fidelity Fund
Schemes) Regulation.
16. Nor Haniza Ishak, 2 Zuraini Md Ali, 3 Yacob Omar, Helena Aman Hashim, Case Studies
on Timber Defects of Selected Traditional Houses in Malacca.
17. Porteous, (1992) Improving Maintenance and Reducing Building Defect through ISO
9000, Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, Vol. 7, pp. 6–24.
16
European Journal of Technology and Design, 2014, Vol.(3), № 1
18. Ransom, W.H. (1981). Building Failures; Diagnosis and Avoidance, E &F.N Spon, New
York.
19. Richardson, B.A. (2001) Defect and Deterioration in Building.
20. Rojer E. Gold, (2005) Subterranean termites, House and Landscape Pest.
21. Ramli, (2006) Prinsip and Praktis Pengurusan Penyelenggaraan Bangunan, Pustaka
Ilmi, Batu Cave.
22. Tan Wei Cheun, (2008) Building defects on School Building.
23. Taylor, GoO, (2000) Material in Construction- An Introduction, third edition, Pearson
Education Ltd. England.
17