RudiSetiadi 16AKJ ManagementAudit
RudiSetiadi 16AKJ ManagementAudit
RudiSetiadi 16AKJ ManagementAudit
Our review at Pasundan University showed that no standard for maximum and minimum office copier
standards allow been set by the comptroller’s office. The comptroller’s office standards allow each
academic department and each administrative division to acquire and use its own office copying
machine for any activity it so desire.
Cost in the printing department show that they can reproduce copies above 25 at a cost IDR 150 per
copy, lease cost on copiers run about IDR 3 per copy, we observed each department’s usage of its office
copier. In almost 50% of the cases, the department ran more than 25 copies.
We determined that if the comptroller’s office standards require that the individual departments and
divisions send to the printing department all request for duplications or more than 25 copies, at least IDR
25.000.000,- could be saved by the university each year.
Task Performed
1. In each of the following audit scenarios determine whether the audit is and Management Audit or
Performance Audit.
In the scenario above, the case is classified as a Management Audit because the case is talking about
how the activity at Pasundan University especially about duplicating activity in each department and
each administrative divisions.
2. State the audit objective for each of the audit scenarios. Label the condition, the criteria, the causes
and the effects for each of the audit scenarios.
Condition :
- The comptroller’s office allow each academic department and administrative division to use it
own office copying machine
Criteria :
- There is no standard maximum and minimum office copier standards allow been set by the
comptroller’s office at Pasundan University.
- Cost in the printing department is IDR 150 per copy if there is above 25 copies
- Cost of lease copiers is IDR 3 per copy
Causes :
- Each department and each division of Pasundan University used their own office copying
machine for any activity it is desire
Effects :
- Inefficiency especially in the cost of using office copying machine
- Ineffectively when one department (printing department) is not properly utilized
3. How where these audit started? How the information from the preliminary phases was used to
develop the audit objective.
It’s started from review that comptroller’s office allow each academic department and each
administrative divisions to use their own office copying machine, and also there is no standard limit for
using office copier allow by comptroller’s office. Next review is to find out how much cost in the printing
department. The case showed that in the printing department, cost of the copies where above 25 is
about IDR 150 per copy with lease cost on copier is IDR 3 per copy. In almost 50% of the case, more than
25 copies produced by each department. After further calculating the cost of using office copying
machine from each department and each administrative, if they are send a request for duplications to
the printing department and also if the comptroller’s office require that, the university could be save IDR
25.000.000,- each year. This is more effective, efficient and also economic.