A Project Report On: A Study On Service Quality of Hotel Industry in Rourkela
A Project Report On: A Study On Service Quality of Hotel Industry in Rourkela
A Project Report On: A Study On Service Quality of Hotel Industry in Rourkela
On
“A Study on Service Quality of Hotel Industry in Rourkela ”
By
JIM MAHADEV
313SM1003
Faculty Advisor
Prof.S.H Uzma
Assistant Professor
School of Management
NIT Rourkela
SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, ROURKELA
April, 2015
DECLARATION
Place: Rourkela
Jim Mahadev
Date:
CERTIFICATE
This to certify that the project entitled ― “A Study on Service Quality of
Hotel Industry in Rourkela” submitted by Jim Mahadev bearing roll
number 313sm1003 for the partial fulfillment of the requirements for the
degree of Master of Business Administration embodies the genuine work
done under his supervision.
Date:
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Successful completion of any project is incomplete without the
mention of those whose continuous support and help was always needed
to complete the project. At the very outset I take this opportunity to
Last, but not the least I would like to thank all the employees of different
hotels of Rourkela for their cooperative nature and supportive behaviour
throughout this project and also my parents, friends whose valuable
guidance, motivation, encouragement and trust made me to complete this
project.
Summary
This project attempts to study the service quality of hotel industry in Rourkela. Service
quality is the degree and direction of discrepancy between consumers' perceptions and
expectations in terms of different but relatively important dimensions of service
quality. A 26-question SERVQUAL scale measuring five basic dimensions i.e.,
Tangibles, Reliability, Responsiveness, Assurance and Empathy of service quality was
used to understand the service quality of hotel industry. Population for the study
consisted of customers of 15 Hotels of Rourkela. In all 230 customers were
surveyed.The findings were very surprising as. The important finding of our study is
that ,in case of realibility,the customers are satisfied the maximum considering the five
factors of service quality model, but in case of assurance customers are least
satisfied.The sequence of satisfaction is reliability,responsiveness then tangibles then
empathy finally assurance.From these findings we conclude that in terms of realiability
the hotels of Rourkela are in a good position when customer satisfaction is
concerned.Hotels of Rourkela have to concentrate on empathy as well as on assuranve
because in terms of assurance all the hotels of Rourkela have a poor rating. On the
whole the industry did not match the expectations of customers.To minimize this gap
between customers' perceptions and expectations customers suggested introduction of
wi-fi, entertainment facilities, swimming pool, trained reliable staff, better equipment,
better food, prompt service etc.
ENTS
TOPIC PAGE-NO
CHAPTER 1:INTRODUCTION 1
CHAPTER 8:CONCLUSION 43
QUESTIONNAIRE 45
REFERENCE 48
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1
INTRODUCTION
All administration associations attempt and give the best conceivable and brilliant
administrations to their clients yet they frequently miss the mark regarding the
clients' desires following the clients have gotten to be more mindful of their
prerequisites and interest higher principles of administrations. Their observations
and desires are constantly advancing, making it troublesome for the administration
suppliers to gauge and deal with the administrations successfully. The idea of
administration quality has been investigated by numerous scientists however
because of its tricky, undefined and dynamic nature it had been hard to delimit and
measure it. Thus just a modest bunch of analysts have operationalized the idea like
Gronroos in 1984, Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry in 1988, Brown and Swartz in
1989, Carman in 1990 and Cronin and Taylor in 1992. Administration quality in its
least complex structure is a result of the exertion that each individual from the
association puts resources into fulfilling its clients. It additionally alludes to the
conveyance of amazing or better administration relative than client
expectations.Zeithaml et al in 1988 characterized administration quality as the
degree and heading of error between shoppers' discernments and desires regarding
diverse however moderately critical measurements of administration quality, which
can influence their future conduct. Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry's (1988)
conceptualization of five measurements: tangibles, reliability, responsiveness,
assurance and empathy, in the long run prompted the advancement of SERVQUAL,
a model for measuring administration quality.
SERVQUAL
2
Tangibles: The presence of the physical facilities,equipment, correspondence
material and work force.
Reliability: The capacity to perform a guaranteed administration constantly and
precisely.
Responsiveness: The ability to help clients and to give brief administrations.
Assurance: The learning and obligingness of representatives and their capacity
to move trust and trust in the clients.
Empathy: The minding, individualized consideration a firm gives its clients.
Lodgings assume the part of giving visitors a home far from home. Furthermore, it
is this office that encourages the further fascination of visitors towards a spot in
light of the fact that it makes their visit more helpful. An inn alludes to a business
foundation giving cabin and dinners on makeshift premise to its clients. In 1902 the
"Indian inns organization" was consolidated by the organizer of the Tata bunch Mr.
Jamshedji Nusserwanji Tata and the organization opened up its first property The
Taj Mahal Palace and Tower, Mumbai. After this there was an upsurge in the Indian
lodging industry the same number of other Indians took after the strides of Mr. Tata
like Mr. Mohan Singh Oberoi who began by taking once again the excellent inn
Calcutta and extended his business. Later organizations like ITC and Air India
likewise wandered into this field. In the most recent couple of years the inn business
has changed and grown extensively as far as the administrations it gives. India is an
appealing destination for visitors on account of its rich legacy, which incorporates
3
the well known Taj Mahal, different sanctuaries and caverns and numerous different
popular landmarks. Likewise there are a ton of representatives and authorities who
visit India for business purposes on account of the exchange relations that our nation
has with the world. Additionally inside our nation likewise there are individuals who
make a trip starting with one state then onto the next or starting with one city then
onto the next for business or recreation. Ludhiana otherwise called the Manchester
of India is additionally a major mechanical city with commercial enterprises like
hosiery, materials, bike and bike parts, hand devices and so forth. It is home to some
huge organizations like Hero Cycles, Oswal, Trident, Vardhaman and so forth. Due
to it being a mechanical city it has a great deal of business explorers from
everywhere throughout the world. Also, hence it requires a decent number of inns as
well as great quality lodgings to oblige these
explorers (Thapar, 2007). All these inns shift in the kind and degree of
administrations they give like convenience, sustenance and refreshment
administrations, stimulation, entertainment, correspondence, transportation, room
administration, clothing administration, gathering and meeting game plans,
emergency treatment, and so forth.
Taking a gander at the significance that Rourkela has as a modern city it is vital to
know where its hotel industry remains as far as its administration quality.
4
CHAPTER 2
5
HISTORY OF HOTEL INDUSTRY
The hotel industry is a mature industry marked by intense competition. Market share
increases typically comes at a competitor‟s expense. Industry-wide, most growth
occurs in the international, rather than the domestic, arena.Common American hotel
classifications are as follows:
Commercial Hotels cater mainly to business clients and usually offer room service,
coffee-shop, dining room, cocktail lounge, laundry and valet service as well as
access to computers and fax services.
Airport Hotels are located near airports and are a conveniently located to provide
any level of service from just a clean room to room service and they may provide
bus or limousine service to the air lines.
Conference Centers are designed to specifically provide meeting space from
groups; they provide all services and equipment necessary to handle conventions.
Economy Hotels provide a limited service and are known for clean rooms at low
prices meeting just the basic needs of travelers.
Suite or All-Suite Hotels are hotels which offer spacious layout and design.
Business people like the setting which provides space to work and entertain separate
from the bedroom.
Residential Hotels used to be very popular. The typical residential hotel offers long
term accommodations.
Casino Hotels are often quite luxurious. Their main purpose is in support of the
gambling operation. Casino hotels often offer top name entertainment and excellent
restaurants.
Resort Hotels are the planned destination of guests, usually vacationers. This is
because resorts are located at the ocean or in the mountains away from inner cities.
Resort hotels may offer any form of entertainment to keep their guests happy and
busy.
A summary of key events in the history of the industry would include the following:
While the practice of renting space to travelers stretches back to antiquity, what
could be considered the modern concept of a hotel derives from 1794, when the City
Hotel opened in New York City. While the practice of renting space was not new,
6
the City Hotel was purported to be the first building devoted exclusively to hotel
operations. For it‟s time, the building was quite large and possessed 73 rooms.
Similar operations soon appeared in such nearby cities as Baltimore, Boston and
Philadelphia. Interestingly, New York City‟s first skyscraper was a hotel - the six
story Adelphi Hotel.
Hotels took a distinct step up in style and class when the Tremont House opened in
Boston in 1829. This hotel was considered by many to be the beginning of what was
regarded as first class service. With 170 rooms, the Tremont House was a large
facility. In addition, the hotel offered features which, for the time, were amazing.
Private single and double rooms were available, which offered not only privacy, but
also security. In addition to water pitchers and a washing bowl, free soap was
provided in each room. The Tremont House offered French cuisine and, reportedly,
was the first hotel to have a Bellboy.
In 1908, the Buffalo Statler opened, marking the beginning of the modern
commercial hotel era. Many services now considered standard were introduced by
the Statler, including such amenities as a light switch next to the door, private bathe,
ice water and a morning newspaper. The Statler set the standard of the day by being
clean, comfortable and affordable. The Statler served as the pattern for hotel design
and operation for many years.
In the 1920‟s, hotel building entered a boom phase and many famous hotels were
opened, including the Waldorf Astoria, New York‟s Hotel Pennsylvania, and the
Chicago Hilton and Towers, which was originally named the Stevens.
In the 1950‟s and 1960‟s, the practice of franchising appeared within the industry.
Franchising enabled entrepreneurs to expand their operations without the use of
substantial capital.
7
For much of their history, hotels were owned and operated by individuals. However,
as franchises and chains began to appear, individually owned hotels found
themselves increasingly at a competitive disadvantage. By the 1960‟s, independent
prospects began to improve as the result referral organizations such as Quality
Courts, Best Western, Master Host and Best Eastern. From the 1980‟s forward,
mergers and acquisitions became common within the industry, and brands become
hotly traded commodities.Recently, use of management companies has entered the
mainstream. As a result, many chains are more involved in management than in
ownership. These chains realize a much more predictable and steady income stream
than had normally been yielded by ownership.
TRENDS
In the 1980's there was extensive merger and acquisition activity between hotel
and non-hotel companies. Many companies are now selling specific brands in an
effort to get back to their core business.
Another trend in the hotel and beverage industry is paperless inventory systems.
Improvements in scanning equipment have made this possible. In many instances,
ordering, delivery, payment and stocking are all initiated and accomplished by
software prompted by information captured by scanning equipment with very little
human involvement.Some chains have sold ownership in their hotels to foreign
investors while still maintaining control. This provided the capital that was needed
for further expansion.REIT‟s (Real Estate Investment Trusts) have been created to
allow smaller investors to participate in mortgages and equities.Product
segmentation has become more popular. Luxury and first class hotels have created
more amenities and products for their customers while economy and budget motels
have cut back services in order to maintain lower prices. Also specialized extended
stay and suite hotels have become more popular. Hotels with indoor water parks are
one of the newest trends. Timeshares is another segment that many hotel companies
are involved with recently. The development, sale, and management of timeshares
have become particularly popular with the large chains. Franchising continues to
flourish in the hotel industry.
8
Audit issues cover a variety of areas, as would be expected. In addition to matters
such as cost segregation, which impact numerous industries, hotel companies have
undertaken such activities as donating used bedding as they upgrade their
equipment, using trusts to defer income, delaying recognition of last day of the year
receipts, franchising, condo conversion, and so forth.Several years ago, customers
generally called a toll-free number to make room reservations. In 2006, about 50%
of hotel rooms were booked through the internet. The number of domestic hotel
rooms reserved for smokers is declining as major hotel chains are beginning to
decrease their total number of smoking rooms or becoming non-smoking facilities
altogether. Other recent trends in the industry include luxury mattresses,
complimentary breakfast, high definition TV, high speed internet access, Wi-Fi
(wireless internet access), and room suites.A recent 2006 trend is hotels re-imaging
their lobbies to destination places. For example part of the lobby may be used for a
breakfast area in the morning and a bar at night. This may include sliding walls,
decorative lighting, and music. One reason for this is to generate more income per
square foot. A July 2005 article from Knight Ridder Newspapers highlights what the
major chains are upgrading in the sleep department. The article provided the
following information:
Marriott International has been replacing mattresses at its Marriott and Renaissance
hotels for several years and is adding new bedding at its 2,400 hotels, including
higher thread count sheets, down comforters and duvet covers at a cost of $190
million.
Hilton Hotels is introducing new bedding across its brand, including Hilton,
Doubletree and Embassy Suites. There will be higher thread count sheets, plush top
mattresses, extra pillows and user friendly clocks.
Crown Plaza replaced some 50,000 beds and bedding in 2004, hired a sleep doctor for
advice on relaxation, and tossed in a sleep kit for guests.
Radisson in 2004 began moving in custom-designed Sleep Number beds at 230 of its
hotels and resorts, with most of its 90,000 beds to be replaced by 2006. New
bedding is also included in the makeover.
Hyatt recently rolled out its Grand Bed, a 13 ½ inch pillow-top mattress, and added
more luxurious linens and decorative pillows.
Starwood Hotels announced the debut of a new bed at its moderately priced brand,
Four Points by Sheraton. The Four Comfort Bed, a $13 million investment, joins
the Heavenly Bed and Sheraton Hotel‟s Sweet Sleeper Bed in Starwood‟s lineup.
9
Red Roof Inns will offer pillow top mattress pads, 230 thread count sheets and
hypoallergenic pillows at select hotels
10
Industry Term Definition or Explanation
sold. Measures management's ability to use the
lodging facilities.
AVERAGE ROOM A ratio that indicates average room rate, and to
RATE what extent rooms are being up-sold or
discounted; calculated by dividing rooms‟
revenue by number of rooms sold. Also called
average daily rate or ADR.
BANQUET A meal prepared for a particular group, for which
the number of guests and the menu are
predetermined. Most properties offering banquet
service have special facilities for banquet food
production and service.
BARTER The trading of merchandise instead of paying
cash. (e.g. advertising)
BED & A small inn or lodge that provides a room and a
BREAKFAST (B&B) breakfast. Often a B&B is in a residential home
setting and/or a historic building converted to a
quaint lodging facility.
BILLING CLERK The person responsible for charging to hotel
guests all vouchers representing food, beverages,
room service, and merchandise purchases.
CALL A system that is part of the telephone equipment
ACCOUNTING that prices telephone calls made by hotel guests
SYSTEM and sends the information to the property
management system (PMS) for billing.
CASINO HOTEL A hotel that features legal gambling, with the
hotel operation subordinate to the gambling
operation.
CENTRAL Part of an affiliate reservation network. A central
RESERVATION reservation office typically deals directly with the
OFFICE public, advertises a central (usually toll-free)
telephone number, provides participating
properties with necessary communications
11
Industry Term Definition or Explanation
equipment, and bills properties for handling their
reservations.
CHAIN A firm that operates several properties, such as
OPERATING Holiday Inn Worldwide or Hilton Hotels
COMPANY Corporation. Such an operator provides both a
trademark and a reservation system as an integral
part of the management of its managed
properties.
CHECK-IN The procedures for a guest's arrival and
registration.
CHECK-OUT (1) The procedures for a guest's departure and the
settling of his or her account.
(2) A room status term indicating that the guest
has settled his or her account, returned the room
keys, and left the property.
COMMERCIAL A property, usually located in a downtown or
HOTEL business district, that caters primarily to business
clients.
COMPLIMENT- A complimentary or "comp" room is an occupied
ARY ROOM room for which the guest is not charged. A hotel
may offer comp rooms to a group in ratio to the
total number of rooms the group occupies. One
comp room may be offered for each fifty rooms
occupied, for example.
CONDOMINIUM A hotel in which an investor takes title to a
HOTEL specific hotel room, which remains in the pool to
be rented to transient guests whenever the
investor is not using the room. The investor
expects to receive a gain from the increase in
value of the hotel over time, as well as receive
ongoing income from the rental of his or her
room.
Cooperative Any arrangement by which a product or service
12
Industry Term Definition or Explanation
advertising is brought to public notice over the names of both
the supplier and any intermediary who comes
between that supplier and the ultimate purchaser.
The intermediary may be a retailer who buys a
product for resale, a distributor who sells to
retailers or other form of intermediaries. This
arrangement results in consumer advertising as
well as other forms of promotion. The cost of
the promotion may be shared by the supplier and
the intermediary, or the supplier may pay all
costs. The process commonly involves
reimbursing retailers for advertising they create
and place.
CORPORATE Hotel organization that has its own brand or
HOTEL CHAIN brands, which may be managed by the corporate
chain or by a conglomerate.
GENERAL The chief operating officer of a hotel.
MANAGER
HOSPITALITY Lodging and food service businesses that provide
INDUSTRY short-term or transitional lodging and/or food.
HOTEL A large lodging facility, generally a hotel is full
service and a multi-story building with interior
entrance guest rooms.
INDEPENDENT A hotel with no chain or franchise affiliation. It
HOTEL may be owned by an individual proprietor or a
group of investors.
LATE CHARGE Charged purchase made by a guest that is posted
to the guest's folio after the guest has settled his
or her account.
MID-PRICE/ Hotel that caters mostly to persons who must be
EXTENDED-STAY in an area for a week or longer. The guestrooms
HOTELS of mid-price/extended-stay hotels have more
living space than regular hotel guestrooms, and
13
Industry Term Definition or Explanation
may also have cooking facilities. Guestrooms in
these hotels tend to be less expensive than
guestrooms in full-service or all-suite hotels.
Occupancy The percentage of available rooms occupied for a
given period.
POINT OF SALE Computerized systems that retail outlets such as
SYSTEM (POS) restaurants, gift shops, etc, enter orders and
maintain various accounting information. The
POS generally interfaces with the property
management system (PMS).
PROPERTY A computerized front desk system that manages
MANAGEMENT hotel room inventory, guest billing and interfaces
SYSTEM (PMS) with various other systems such as telephone, call
accounting, point of sale (POS), entertainment,
etc.
PROPRIETARY A internet reservation system that is owned and
BOOKING ENGINE operated by an individual hotel or group of hotels
to allow them to take reservation on their own
website without paying a fee to the GDS, third
party booking engines or franchise reservation
systems.
RACK RATE The current public rate quoted for each
accommodation as established by the property's
management. However, most rooms are
discounted. (i.e. rented at less than the rate rack)
RESERVATIONS A guestroom that being held under an individual
or business' name at a particular hotel for a
specific date or range of dates.
RESORT HOTEL A hotel, usually located in a desirable vacation
spot, that offers fine dining, exceptional service,
activities unavailable at most other properties,
and many amenities.
ROOM A device that uses infrared light or ultrasonic
14
Industry Term Definition or Explanation
OCCUPANCY sound waves to sense the physical occupancy of a
SENSOR room. Sensors have the ability to turn on devices
and appliances such as lights, air conditioning,
and heating whenever a guest enters a space, and
to turn these devices and appliances off when the
guest leaves.
ROOM RACK A card index system that is constantly updated to
reflect occupied and vacant rooms. In the
evening, the room rack contains forms for only
those registered guests remaining for the night
who are to be charged for rooms. A daily room
report can be prepared from the room rack.
ROOMS A front office application of a computer-based
MANAGEMENT property management system. The module (a)
MODULE maintains up-to-date information on the status of
rooms, (b) assists in the assignment of rooms
during registration, and (c) helps coordinate
various guest services.
SERVICE CHARGE A percentage of the bill (usually 15% to 20%)
added to the guest charge for distribution to
service employees in lieu of direct tipping.
THIRD PARTY An internet site that provides a booking engine
BOOKING where a traveler can search a large number of
ENGINE lodging facilities for availability and reserve a
room. The lodging facilities are not affiliated
with the site and pay a fee for the business that
the third party site generates. Examples of third
party sites include: hotels.com, priceline.com.
Transient Occupancy City or County tax added to the price of a hotel
Tax room.
WATERPARK A hotel that offers large recreational water
HOTEL elements such large pools, multiple pools, slides
or other water related venues.
15
ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES
The lodging industry was reportedly one of the first industries to develop “definitive
standards to provide specific guidance to accountants and operators. The standards
evolved because uniformity of layout and presentation were, and are, still not
stressed under U.S.Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP).”; Those
standards were and are contained in the Uniform System of Accounts for the
Lodging Industry (USALI), which is published by the American Hotel and Motel
.
Association While the accounting profession may not have seen fit to develop
GAAP standards specifically applicable to the lodging industry, the USALI has
been widely adopted within the industry. Although there is no requirement that a
lodging operator use the USALI, the degree of compliance with this time-tested,
turnkey system is substantial. The primary reason for widespread adoption of the
USALI has been comparability. Lodging operators tend to use financial statement
data generated by competitors as a benchmark against which to measure their own
operations. If comparability is lacking, then there are no benchmarks.Additionally,
while the system was developed for use within the United States, many hotel
operators around the world have adopted the USALI. Financial statements prepared
for external users, are based on GAAP. In addition to other items commonly found
in most financial statements, lodging industry financials are likely to report on such
items as China, Glassware, Silver, Linen, and Uniforms (CGSLU), and the House
Bank.The USALI is a highly departmentalized system of accounting, and includes
Departmental Statements of Income. There are two main department classifications
in a hotel: operating and overhead. The operating (revenue-producing) departments
include rooms, food and beverage, telecommunications, and similar departments.
The overhead departments include administrative and general, data processing,
human resources, transportation, marketing, guest entertainment, energy costs, and
property operation and maintenance.
16
• Commercial Hotel
• Airport Hotel
• Conference Center
• Economy Hotel
• Suite or All-Suite Hotel
• Residential Hotel or Apartment Hotel
• Casino Hotel
• Resort Hotel
Commercial Hotel:
A chain of hotels which have standardized service and amenity structures
Airport Hotel:
Hotel near the airport but it does not have to be connected or adjacent to the airport
(although some are); it could be located up to five miles away. Most airport hotels
have a shuttle to and from the terminals (Charlyn Keating Chisholm, about.com.
guide)
Conference Center:
A specialized hotel (usually in a less busy but easily accessible location) designed
and built almost exclusively to host conferences, exhibitions, large meetings,
seminars, training sessions, etc. A conference center often also provides office
facilities and a range of leisure activities
Economy Hotel:
A hotel offering few amenities (J.K. Krishan, “Dictionary of Tourism”, Gyan
Books, 2005)
Suite or All-Suite Hotel:
A hotel in which every rooms has an attached living room and/or kitchen
Residential Hotel or Apartment Hotel:
A serviced apartment complex uses a hotel-style booking system. It is similar to
renting an apartment, but with no fixed contracts and occupants can 'check-out'
whenever they wish.
Casino Hotel:
A business establishment combines a casino and a hotel or a building that houses
both a hotel and a casino.
Resort Hotel:
A hotel caters primarily to vacationers and tourist and typically offers more
recreational amenities and services in a more aesthetically pleasing setting, than
17
other hotels. These hotels are located in attractive and natural tourism destinations
and their clientele are groups and couples that like adventure with sophistication and
comfort. The attractions vary depending on the region and some might offer golf,
tennis, scuba diving and, depending on the natural surroundings, may also arrange
other recreational activities.
By Star Ratings, hotel has been classified into several types as follows:
• Five Star Hotel
• Four Star Hotel
• Three Star Hotel
• Two Star Hotel
• One Star Hotel
• No Category Hotels
18
CHAPTER 3
LITERATURE REVIEW
19
LITERATURE REVIEW
20
uncovered the positive relationship between saw quality and an association's
budgetary execution (Berry, 1991). The extraordinary Profit Impact of Marketing
Strategy project of the foundation has reasoned that organizations with saw amazing
merchandise and administrations regularly had higher piece of the pie, higher
quantifiable profit and resource turnover than organizations with saw low quality.
This prompted the conclusion that in the long haul, the most imperative element
influencing business execution is the nature of merchandise and administrations
offered by the association, in respect to its rivals (Juran and Gryna, 1993).
Regardless of the expanding significance of the administration part and of the
criticalness of value as a focused variable, administration quality ideas are not all
around created (Ghobadian et al., 1994). Since administration quality is a slippery
idea, there is extensive level headed discussion in the pertinent writing about how
best to conceptualize this sensation. In spite of the fact that an allembracing
meaning of administration quality is unrealistic yet, meanings of administration
quality proposed via scientists spin around the thought that it is the aftereffect of the
examination clients make between their desires about an administration and their
view of the way the administration has been performed (Lewis and Booms, 1983;
Gro¨ nroos, 1984; Parasuraman et al., 1985, 1988). This imparted point achieves a
wide agreement that administration quality must be characterized from the client's
viewpoint. In this manner, an awesome greater part of examination spotlights on the
topic of how administration quality saw by clients and how seen administration
quality can be measured (Stauss and Weinlich, 1997). Administration quality can't
be impartially measured as can produced merchandise and thusly it remains a
moderately subtle and theoretical build (Zeithaml et al., 1990). The assessment of
value for administrations is more unpredictable than for items as a result of their
inborn nature of heterogeneity, intertwined state of creation and utilization,
perishability and impalpability (Frochot and Hughes, 2000). These recognizing
qualities of administrations make it hard to characterize and measure administration
quality. In the lodging business, different traits, for example, uncertain gauges, short
dispersion channel,dependability and consistency, up close and personal cooperation
and data trade, and fluctuating interest have been distinguished and further confuse
the assignment of characterizing, conveying and measuring administration quality.
In addition, interest for administration in the inn business is for the most part
bunched around crest times of the day, week or year, for example, registration,
registration times or Christmas season and these top periods make a situation which
21
makes it hard to give reliable administration quality (Barrington and Olsen, 1987;
Mei et al., 1999).
25
CHAPTER 4
26
OBJECTIVE AND SCOPE
Hotels play the role of providing guests a home away from home. And it is this
facility that facilitates the further attraction of guests towards a place because it
makes their visit more convenient. A hotel refers to a commercial establishment
providing lodging and meals on temporary basis to its customers. In 1902 the
"Indian hotels company" was incorporated by the founder of the Tata group Mr.
Jamshedji Nusserwanji Tata and the company opened up its first property The Taj
Mahal Palace and Tower, Mumbai. After this there was an upsurge in the Indian
hotel industry as many otherIndians followed the footsteps of Mr. Tata like Mr.
Mohan Singh Oberoi who started by taking over the grand hotel Calcutta and
expanded his business. Later companies like ITC and Air India also ventured into
this field. In the last few years the hotel industry has changed and developed
considerably in terms of the services it provides.India is an attractive destination for
tourists because of its rich heritage, which includes the famous Taj Mahal, various
temples and caves and many other famous monuments. Also there are a lot of
businessmen and officials who visit India for business purposes because of the trade
relations that our country has with the world. Similarly within our country also there
are people who travel from one state to another or from one city to another for
business or leisure. Rourkela also known as the steel city. It is home to some
bigcompanies like RSP, Adhunik Metals, L&T etc. Because of it being an industrial
city it has a lot of business travelers from all over the world.And thus it requires not
only a good number of hotels but also good quality hotels to accommodate these
travelers (Thapar, 2007). All these hotels vary in the kind and extent of services they
provide like accommodation, food and beverage services, entertainment, recreation,
communication, transportation, room service, laundry service, conference and
meeting arrangements, first aid, etc. Looking at the importance that Ludhiana has as
an industrial city it is important to know where its hotel industry stands in terms of
its service quality. The present study was aimed at achieving the following specific
objectives:
1 To find the importance of service quality dimensions of hotel services.
2 To find customers' satisfaction w.r.t hotel services.
3 suggest various measures for minimizing gaps between customers' perceptions
and expectations.
27
CHAPTER 5
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
28
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The research design of the study is descriptive in nature. The target population
consists of the customers of those hotels of Rourkela. There are 15 hotels given in
the list. All the hotels in the list were placed for a better result. So a total of 15
hotels were selected on the basis of single room rent. The customers from these
selected hotels were selected on the basis of convenience sampling. Out of all the
selected hotels in each category fifteen customers from every hotel i.e., 230
customers in all were selected. Primary data was collected using the structured and
non-disguised questionnaire which was administered personally. In all 230
customers who had availed the services of these hotels were asked to fill the
questionnaire on the tangibility, reliability, responsiveness, assurance and empathy
parameters. These parameters have been derived from the SERVQUAL model
suggested by Parasuraman, Ziethaml and Berry (1988).The statements in the model
were adapted as per the hotel industry. The respondents were first asked to give
weightage to the service quality dimensions like tangibility, reliability,
responsiveness, assurance and empathy based on how important each of these
factors was to them.
HYPOTHESIS
Overview of approach
A questionnaire for the hotel guests has been developed based on the components of
the service quality in the hotel industry. Moreover, it is supported by the marketing
elements SERQUAL (Parasuraman, 1988) approach has been the most popular
method for choosing because it is quite complete measure for all the service
29
industry. It covers all ten factors of quality of the hotel services. Therefore, the
LODGING QUALITY INDEX (Getty and Thompson, 1994) has been chosen to
develop the questionnaire. LODGING QUALITY INDEX not only solved some
weakness of SERQUAL but also very specific for the hotel industry.The
questionnaire is a complete survey of 26 questions . At the end of questionnaire are
the questions about likeness of the service and suggestions from the customers.
Characteristic of survey
Sample size 230,Method of information gathering Personal interview,Online survey.
In order to identify important quality attributes for the hotel services and the
different expectation of customers, a total 230 respondents were asked to participate.
. Most of respondents have had experiences with the
hotel services, they would provide an evaluable respond regarding to the services.
Moreover, the response rate was quite high, so this survey method was chosen.
The participants answered the questionnaire. Then the results was gathered from the
all survey and computed for interpretation.
30
measured using the following question: „„Overall, how would you rate the quality
of service you received in this hotel?‟‟
A test was undertaken to assess the reliability of the attributes, and to ensure that the
wordings of the questionnaire were clear. Twenty six questionnaires were completed
by the guests in accompaniment of researcher. Some problems were identified with
the wordings and implications of some questions, so some minor revisions were
made to avoid confusion. Reliability analysis was also applied to test the internal
consistency of each of the expectation and perception attributes.
Hotel guests who checked-out from the hotel and about to leave were approached.
The Software Package for the research which was used was spss used to analyze the
data. Descriptive statistics analysis was used to measure guests‟ expectation and
perception scores. To explore the dimensionality of the 29-attribute scale, a
factor analysis was performed. Validity tests how well an instrument that I
developed measures the particular concept it is supposed to measure. Reliability of a
scale on the other hand indicates the stability and consistency with which the
instrument measures the concept and helps to assess the goodness of a measure
(Sekaran, 2000). To have an idea on the internal consistency among the items and
on the convergent validity of the overall scale, a reliability analysis was employed.
Within-scale factor analyses were used to ensure that all indicators in the scale
measure the same construct. This process is known as construct validity (Flynn et
al., 1995). To test the internal consistency of each factor, a reliability analysis was
employed. Based on the new factors derived from the factor analysis, a multiple
regression analysis was used to identify the relative importance of the factors in
predicting the overall customer satisfaction with the service quality provided.
Although, the scope of study is vast in nature, but limited persons interviewed on
random sampling basis and in some cases, selective persons interviewed as per the
requirement. However, such study is completed within a specified period of time and
many points might have been omitted for the scope of study in advertently. Adequate
precautions have been adopted to make the study work free from bias and prejudices
as far as possible.
31
CHAPTER 6
32
DATA ANALYSIS & INTERPRETATION
Reliability statistics
It has been found that Cronbach's alpha is 0.924, which indicates strong internal
consistency among factors. This means that 92% of the variability in composite score is
considered to be internally reliable variance. The result shows that the alpha value is
which suggests the internal validity of the instrument is highly satisfactory.
Reliability Statistics
.924 26
FACTOR ANALYSIS
Factor analysis of responses was used for data reduction in order to identify correlations
among variables in complex sets of data (Mitchel more and Rowley, 2013) used to
gauge the industrial relations. Cronbach alpha was found to be 0.924, which was well
above the acceptable value of 0.70 for demonstrating internal consistency of the
established scale (Nunnally, 1988). Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO>0.6) and Bartlett‟s test
of sphericity (p<0.05) were used to test empirically whether the data were likely to
factor well (Bikker and Thompson, 2006; Kaiser, 1974; Kline, 1994).In this study KMO
measure was 0.885 indicating that the data was adequate for factor analysis. Also,
Bartlett‟s test of sphericity (sig. = 0.000) indicated the significance of the study,
thereby showing the validity and suitability of the responses collected . Therefore, the
statistical test showed that the dimensions of instruments were likely to factor well and
the questionnaire was multidimensional.
33
KMO and Bartlett's Test
Kaiser- .885
Meyer-Olkin
Measure of
Sampling
Adequacy.
Ba Ap 30
rtl pr 47
ett' ox .2
s . 44
Te Ch
st i-
of Sq
Sp ua
he re
ric
ity
Df 435
Sig. .000
The data gathered from the main survey were analyzed through principal
components factor analysis followed by varimax rotation. It basically partitions the
total variance of all original variables by finding the first linear combination of
variables that accounts for the maximum variance. The communalities represent the
total amount of variance an original variable shares with all other variables included
in the analysis. The purpose of viewing communalities is to assess whether the
variables meet acceptable levels of explanation.6 out of 30 variables had
communalities less than 0.50 indicating they didn‟t have sufficient explanation and
hence were not considered for further analysis. Below table shows the information
regarding the remaining variables and their relative explanatory powers. The six
factors extracted captures 70.317 %., which can be deemed sufficient in terms of
34
explained total variance. The six extracted factors were named
reliability,responsiveness,empathy,tangibles,assurance.
Next, varimax rotational method was employed to achieve simpler and theoretically
more meaningful factor solutions. This orthogonal rotation tries to maximize the
variance of each of the factors in such a way that the total amount of variance
accounted for is redistributed over the six extracted factors. Table exhibits the factor
loadings of the extracted factors after varimax rotation.
35
36
Regression
A stepwise multiple regression analysis was conducted to determine the “A Study
on Service Quality of Hotel Industry in Rourkela”. The five variables as
reliability,responsiveness,empathy,tangibles,assurance were specified as the
independent variable. with output as the dependent variable. Preliminary analyses
were conducted to examine the assumptions underlying a regression model.
37
Model Summary
a
1 .749 .561 .551 .45392
a. Predictors: (Constant), assurance, empathy, reliability, tangibles, responsiveness
ANOVA
a
ANOVA
b
Regression 58.923 5 11.785 57.195 .000
38
Coefficients
a
Coefficients
CUSTOMERSATISFACTION=
Constant(.138)+reliability(.417)+responsiveness(.318)+tangibles(.188)+empathy(.0
09)+assurance(.028)
39
CHAPTER 7
FINDINGS & SUGGESTIONS
40
Finding of the Study
The important finding of our study is that ,in case of realibility,the customers are satisfied the
maximum considering the five factors of service quality model where beta value is maximum ie-
.373 but in case of assurance customers are least satisfied as the beta value is .209.The sequence of
satisfaction is responsiveness then tangibles then empathy.
• Some of the high category hotels don't have wi-fiwhich is a very important
facility today. So this must be introduced especially in the high category hotels.
• All the hotels in this category are not providing very good entertainment
services therefore these should be introduced. E.g. indoor games like pool, table
tennis, video games etc. and outdoor games like badminton, basketball etc.
• The high category hotels must introduce swimming pool and health club.
• The food should be paid special attention to by selecting good cooks and
having efficiently trained kitchen staff.
• Staff should smile and be polite while serving.
• Privilege discount card should be introduced.
The hotels should have reliable and dependable staff that is honest and diligent.
• More entertainment facilities should be introduced.
• The hotels must make promises which it knows it can easily achieve and
must perform all its services at the promised time.
• Some hotels lack in terms of the privacy they provide. Care should be taken
to make sure that the guests don't get disturbed and are given proper privacy.
41
• The staff should be kept aware about the latest developments in and around
the hotel so that they have enough knowledge to be able to answer their
guests' queries.
• The hotel staff should be regularly made to realize what the hotel's main aim is.
They must be told about the importance a customer holds for their hotel so that
the staff is more willing to serve the guests well.
• The food should be improved Care must be taken to avoid unnecessary delays
in delivering a service.
• The staff should be encouraged to serve with a smile and be polite with
the customers.
• The staff should be kept aware about the latest developments in and around the hotel
so that they have enough knowledge to be able to answer their guests' queries.
• The hotel should try and focus on the specific demands of its customers. This
will help it to differentiate itself from the others and will provide customers with
better satisfaction.
• More variety should be introduced in the food items
42
CHAPTER 8
CONCLUSION
43
CONCLUSION
The study concludes that the hotel industry of Rourkelais not performing as per the
customers' expectations on any of the service quality dimensions. There is a lot more that
the customers expect from the hotels. Since Rourkela is a major industrial city therefore it
must have good quality hotels. To improve their performance, the hotels need to focus
more on tangibles e.g. they must introduce wi-fi facility which is a necessity today,
swimming pool, health club, more entertainment facilities etc. Also they must have well
trained, groomed and reliable staff. This will help the hotels to to focus better on the other
dimensions. The hotel industry is witnessing a boom in Odisha in both the five star and
budget hotels. The state has emerged as a favourite
destination for visitors. Rourkela is emerging as one of the most preferred cities for the
hospitality industry. The arrival of big-ticket hotel brands (both luxury and budget) could
yield a slew of spin-off benefits for the city's hospitality fortunes, by improving the service
quality. And this may further spark a chain reaction for the present hospitality players to
improve upon their service quality. The important finding of our study is that ,in case of
realibility,the customers are satisfied the maximum considering the five factors of service
quality model where beta value is maximum ie-.373 but in case of assurance customers are
least satisfied as the beta value is .209.The sequence of satisfaction is responsiveness then
tangibles then empathy.From these findings we conclude that in terms of realiability the
hotels of Rourkela are in a good position when customer satisfaction is concerned.Hotels
of Rourkela have to concentrate on empathy as well as on assuranve because in terms of
assurance all the hotels of Rourkela have a poor rating.
44
QUESTIONNAIRE
This survey is part of the research on the Service quality and customer satisfaction in the
hotel industry. Through this survey I wish to analyze these determinants from a customer’s
perspective. The survey is anonymous and all the information provided will be kept
confidential and will not be shared with any other party in any case. I greatly appreciated
your help for completing the survey!
DIMENSION QUESTIONS Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly
agree Disagree
5 4 3 2 1
45
Responsive Employees responded
ness promptly to my
requests
Informative literature
about the hotel was
provided
Employees were
willing to answer my
questions
Employees responded
quickly to solve my
problems
Room service was
prompt
Assurance Employees knew
about local places of
interest
Employees treated me
with respect
Employees were
polite when
answering my
questions
The facilities were
conveniently located
Empathy Charges on my
account were clearly
explained
I received undivided
attention at the front
desk
Reservationists tried
to find out my
46
particular needs
Employees
anticipated my needs
Overall I am satisfied with the
Aspect service quality
Suggestions:
47
LIST OF HOTELS IN ROURKELA USED FOR SURVEY PURPOSE
Mayfair Hotel
Hotel Anurag
Hotel Brindaban
Hotel Shubham
Hotel MN International
Hotel Aastha
Paantha Nivas
Hotel Solace
Hotel Sukhsagar
Hotel Disha
48
References
Babakus C and Mangold G W (1992) Adapting the SERVQUAL scale to hospital
services: An empirical investigation. Health Services Research26: 767-86.
Bouman M and Vander W T (1992) Measuring service quality in the car service
industry: Building and testing an instrument. International Journal of Services
Industry Management 3: 4-16.
Brown S W and Swartz T A (1989) A gap analysis of professional service quality.
Journal of Marketing 53: 92-8.
Carman J M (1990) Consumer perception of service quality: An assessment of the
SERVQUAL dimensions. Journal of Retailing 66: 33-35.
Cronin J, Joseph Jr and Taylor S A (1992) Measuring service quality: A re-
examination and extension.Journal of Marketing 56: 55-68.
Davidson M C G a (2003) An Integrated Approach to Service Quality in Hotels. J
Quality Assurance in Hospitality and Tourism 4: 71-85.
Davidson M C G b (2003) Does organizational climate add to service quality in
hotels? International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management 15: 206-13.
El-Farra (1996) A comparative study of managers vs consumers opinion on factors
influencing patronage of hotels. Journal of Coll University Food Services 31: 52-5.
Fernandez M C L, Ana M and Bedia S (2004) Is the Hotel Classification System a
Good Indicator of Hotel Quality? An Application in Spain. Tourism Management
25: 771-75.
Fick G R and Ritchie J R B (1991) Marketing service quality in the travel and
tourism industry. Journal of Travel Research 30: 2-9.
Gronroos (1984) A service quality model and its marketing implications. European
Journal of Marketing 18: 36-44.
Juwaheer T D (2004) Exploring international tourists' perceptions of hotel
operations by using a modified SERVQUAL approach - A case study of Mauritius.
Managing Service Quality 14: 350-64.
Knutson B, Stevens P, Wullaert C, Patton M and Yokoyama R (1991) LODGSERV:
A service quality index for the lodging industry. Hospitality Research Journal 15:
277-84.
McElwee G and Redman T (1993) Upward appraisal in practice: An illustrative
example using the QUALED scale. Education Ttraining 35: 27-31.
49
Parasuraman A Zeithaml V A and Berry L L (1988) SERVQUAL: A multiple-item
scale for measuring consumer perception of service quality. Journal of
Retailing 64: 12-40.
Pitt L F, Waston R T and Kaven C B (1995) Service quality: A measure of
information system effectiveness. MIS Quarterly 26: 173-85.
Reuland R, Coudrey J and Fagel A (1985) Research in the field of hospitality. Int J
Hospitality Management 4: 141-6.
Rigotti S and Pitt L (1992) SERVQUAL as a measuring instrument for service
provider gaps in business school. Management Research News 15: 9-17.
Saleh F and Ryan C (1992) Analysis sevice quality in the hospitality industry using
the SERVQUAL model. Services Industries Journal 11: 324-43.
Shergill G (2004) Tourists perceptions towards hotel services in New Zealand.
International J ournal of Hospitality Tourism Administration 5: 1-29.
Thomson E L and Thomson S C (1995) Quality issues in nine New Zealand hotels:
A research study. TQM Magazine 7: 16-20.
Zeithaml V A, Berry L L and Parasuraman A (1988) Communication and control
processes in the delivery of service quality. Journal of Marketing 52:35-38.
Zeithaml V A, Berry L L and Parasuraman A (1996) The behavioural consequences
of service quality. Journal of Marketing (April), pp. 31-46
Akan, P., 1995. Dimensions of service quality: a study in Istanbul. Managing Service
Quality 5 (6), 39–43.
Armstrong, R.W., Mok, C., Go, F.M., Chan, A., 1997. The importance of cross-
cultural expectations in the measurement of service quality perceptions in the
hotel industry. International Journal of Hospitality Management 16 (2), 181–190.
Asubonteng, P., McCleary, K.J., Swan, J.E., 1996. Servqual revisited: a critical
review of service quality. The Journal of Services Marketing 10 (6), 62–81.
Babakus, E., Boller, G.W., 1992. An empirical assessment of the SERVQUAL
scale. Journal of Business Research 24 (3), 253–268.
50
51