Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 143 views

    Bernal Vs House

    Uploaded by

    Dan Anthony Barriga
    The child Purificacion Bernal died after falling into a street gutter filled with hot water coming from the Electric Ice Plant owned by J.V. House. Her mother sued for damages. The lower court denied damages, finding no liability. On appeal, the Supreme Court ruled the company was liable, as the mother and child had a right to be on the public street. While the child and mother's actions were not the sole cause, they may reduce damages owed. Only the mother was entitled to recover damages, not the acknowledged father. J.V. House, as owner at the time, was solely responsible for the hot water in the street that caused the child's death.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Bernal Vs House

    Uploaded by

    Dan Anthony Barriga
    143 views1 page
    The child Purificacion Bernal died after falling into a street gutter filled with hot water coming from the Electric Ice Plant owned by J.V. House. Her mother sued for damages. The lower court denied damages, finding no liability. On appeal, the Supreme Court ruled the company was liable, as the mother and child had a right to be on the public street. While the child and mother's actions were not the sole cause, they may reduce damages owed. Only the mother was entitled to recover damages, not the acknowledged father. J.V. House, as owner at the time, was solely responsible for the hot water in the street that caused the child's death.

    Original Title

    Bernal vs House.docx

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The child Purificacion Bernal died after falling into a street gutter filled with hot water coming from the Electric Ice Plant owned by J.V. House. Her mother sued for damages. The lower court denied damages, finding no liability. On appeal, the Supreme Court ruled the company was liable, as the mother and child had a right to be on the public street. While the child and mother's actions were not the sole cause, they may reduce damages owed. Only the mother was entitled to recover damages, not the acknowledged father. J.V. House, as owner at the time, was solely responsible for the hot water in the street that caused the child's death.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    143 views1 page

    Bernal Vs House

    Uploaded by

    Dan Anthony Barriga
    The child Purificacion Bernal died after falling into a street gutter filled with hot water coming from the Electric Ice Plant owned by J.V. House. Her mother sued for damages. The lower court denied damages, finding no liability. On appeal, the Supreme Court ruled the company was liable, as the mother and child had a right to be on the public street. While the child and mother's actions were not the sole cause, they may reduce damages owed. Only the mother was entitled to recover damages, not the acknowledged father. J.V. House, as owner at the time, was solely responsible for the hot water in the street that caused the child's death.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 1

    BERNAL V JV HOUSE (1930)

    G.R. No. L-30741 January 30, 1930


    TOMAS BERNAL and FORTUNATA ENVERSO, plaintiffs-appellants, vs. J. V. HOUSE and TACLOBAN ELECTRIC and ICE
    PLANT, LTD., defendants-appellee.

    FACTS:
    On the evening of April 10, 1925, the procession of Holy Friday was held in Tacloban, Leyte. Fortunata Enverso with her
    daughter Purificacion Bernal came from another municipality to attend the religious celebration. After the procession was
    over, the woman and her daughter, accompanied by two other persons by the names of Fausto and Elias, passed along a
    public street named Gran Capitan. The little girl was allowed to get a short distance in advance of her mother and her
    friends. When in front of the offices of the Tacloban Electric & Ice Plant, Ltd., and automobile appeared from the opposite
    direction which so frightened the child that she turned to run, with the result that she fell into the street gutter. At that
    time there was hot water in this gutter or ditch coming from the Electric Ice Plant of J.V. House. When the mother and her
    companions reached the child, they found her face downward in the hot water. Her clothes were immediately removed
    and, then covered with a garment, the girl was taken to the provincial hospital. There she was attended by the resident
    physician, Dr. Victoriano A. Benitez. Despite his efforts, the child died that same night at 11:40 o'clock.
    Defense:
    The hot water was permitted to flow down the side of the street Gran Captain with the knowledge and consent of the
    authorities; that the cause of death was other than the hot water; and that in the death the plaintiffs contributed by their
    own fault and negligence.

    DECISION OF LOWER COURTS:


    (1) Court of First Instance – Leyte: denied them P15,000 damages from J.V. House and the Tacloban Electric & Ice Plant,
    Ltd., for the death of the child as a consequence of burns alleged to have been caused by the fault and negligence of the
    defendants.

    ISSUE:
    Whether the company is liable

    RULING:
    Yes.
    The mother and her child had a perfect right to be on the principal street of Tacloban, Leyte, on the evening when the
    religious procession was held. There was nothing abnormal in allowing the child to run along a few paces in advance of
    the mother. No one could foresee the coincidence of an automobile appearing and of a frightened child running and falling
    into a ditch filled with hot water.
    The contributory negligence of the child and her mother, if any, does not operate as a bar to recovery, but in its strictest
    sense could only result in reduction of the damages.
    The plaintiffs are Tomas Bernal and Fortunata Enverso. The latter was the mother of Purificacion Bernal and the former
    was the natural

    father, who had never legally recognized his child. The daughter lived with the mother, and presumably was supported by
    her. Under these facts, recovery should be permitted the mother but not the father.
    As to the defendants, they are J.V. House and the Tacloban Electric & Ice Plant, Ltd., J.V. House was granted a franchise by
    Act No. 2700 of the Philippine Legislature approved on March 9, 1917. He only transferred this franchise formally to the
    Tacloban Electric & Ice Plant, Ltd. on March 30, 1926, that is, nearly a year after the death of the child Purificacion Bernal.
    Under these facts, J.V. House is solely responsible.

    You might also like