Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.

9, 2011

Carbon footprint: a tool to quantify the impact of road construction on the

environment

Kirti Bhandari, Anuradha Shukla,

Scientist, Head,
Transport Planning and Environment division, Transport Planning and Environment division,
Central Road Research Institute, Central Road Research Institute,
Mathura Road, Mathura Road,
New Delhi, 110020. New Delhi, 110020.
E-mail: [email protected] E-mail:[email protected]

S. Gangopadhyay,
Director,
Central Road Research Institute,
Mathura Road,
New Delhi, 110 020.
e-mail: [email protected]

Abstract: A variety of materials are used in the construction of roads. Materials like sand,
gravel, asphalt, bituminous and crushed stone are used widely. In India, Guidelines for the
design of Flexible Pavements, published by Indian Roads Congress (IRC 2001) are followed.
Flexible pavements are considered to include the pavements which have bituminous
surfacing and granular base and sub base courses conforming to IRC Standards. Carbon
footprint is a measure of the effect of human activities on the environment, and in particular
on climate change. Here it has been used as an indicator to study the impact of the
construction material used in the building, maintenance and repair of the highway. The
objective of this paper is the calculation of the carbon footprint of a stretch of NH-228 in
Gujarat state in India. This tool can even help to choose the construction materials which will
be have lesser impact on the environment.

Key Words: Carbon footprint, CO2 emissions, road construction, flexible pavements

1. ITRODUCTIO

Much research has been done on the mobility and commuting using indicators like travel
distance, modal choice, travel time, vehicle speed etc. But while evaluating the impact of
mobility on environment or on global warming, CO2 emissions or carbon footprint appears as
a preferable measure. The carbon footprint accounts for the direct as well as for the indirect
CO2 emissions. The transportation sector consumes large amount of energy and draws upon
natural resources. In such a scenario, the carbon footprint can act as a means to measure the
amount of pressure a road, highway or an overpass would exert on the earth. This study aims
at the calculation of the carbon footprint of a national highway and the associated road works.
Such study can be integrated with the transportation planning to control the transport
activities harmful to the environment (Zuidgeest 2006).

The paper is organized as follows. The subsequent section, section 2 explains about the road

740
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

pavement types and a comparison between rigid and flexible pavements. Section 3 elaborates
about the construction material applied in road construction and their characteristics. Various
pavement layers are explained in section 4. Section 5 gives the definition of carbon footprint.
Section 6 outlines the study area along with the data and methodology applied in the study.
Section 7 gives the estimated results followed by conclusion and discussion in section 8.

2. ROAD PAVEMET
A highway pavement is designed to support the wheel loads imposed on it from traffic
moving over it. Additional stresses are also imposed by changes in the environment. It should
be strong enough to resist the stresses imposed on it and should be thick enough to distribute
the external loads on the earthen subgrade, so that the subgrade itself can safely bear it. For
satisfactorily performing the above functions, the pavement should have many desirable
characteristics. These are:
• It should be structurally sound enough to withstand the stresses imposed on it.
• It should be sufficiently thick to distribute the loads and stresses to a safe value on the
subgrade soil.
• It should provide a reasonably hard wearing surface, so that the abrading action of wheels
(pneumatic and iron typed) does not damage the surface.
• It should be dust proof so that the traffic safety is not impaired.
• Its riding quality should be good. It should be smooth enough to provide comfort to the
road users at the high speeds at which the modern vehicles are driven.
2.1. Pavement Courses

A pavement consists of one or more layers. The topmost layer is the surfacing, the purpose of
which is to provide a smooth, abrasion resistant, dust free, reasonably water proof and strong
layer. The base, which comes immediately next below, is the medium through which the
stresses imposed are distributed evenly. Additional help in distributing the loads is provided
by the sub base layer. The subgrade is the complicated natural earth immediately below the
pavement layers. The top of the subgrade is also known as the formation level.
In a concrete road, the concrete slab itself acts as the wearing surface and distributes the load.
The slab may be directly placed on the subgrade, or, in case of weak soils, a base and subbase
may be interposed between the slab and the subgrade.

2.2. Pavement Types

From the point of view of structural performance, pavements can be classified as:
1. Flexible: A flexible pavement is essentially a layered system, which has a low flexural
strength. Thus, the external load is largely transmitted to the subgrade by the lateral
distribution with increasing depth. Because of the low flexural strength, the pavement
deflects momentarily under load but rebounds to its original level on removal of load. The
pavement thickness is so designed that the stresses on the subgrade soil are kept within its
bearing power and the subgrade is prevented from excessive deformation. This implies
that in a flexible pavement, the subgrade plays an important role as it carries the vehicle
loads transmitted to it through the pavement. The strength and smoothness of the
pavement surface depends to a great extent on the permanent deformation suffered by the
subgrade and its resistance to such deformation. If the pavement itself is very strong, but it
is constructed on loose and poor subgrade, it can fail.

741
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

2. Rigid: A rigid pavement derives its capacity to withstand loads from the flexural strength
or beam strength (modulus of elasticity), permitting the slab to bridge over minor
irregularities in the subgrade, subbase or base upon which it rests. This implies that the
inherent strength of the slab itself is called upon to play a major role in resisting the wheel
load. Minor imperfections or localized weak spots in the material below the slab can be
taken care of by the slab itself. This is not to underrate the role of the subgrade soli. In
fact, a good, stable and uniform support is necessary for a rigid pavement as well. But as
long as a certain minimum requirement is met with in this regard, the performance of the
rigid pavement is more governed by the strength of the slab itself than by the subgrade
support.
3. Semi-rigid: A semi-rigid pavement represents an intermediate state between the flexible
and the rigid pavement. It has much lower flexural strength compared to concrete slab, but
it also derives support by the lateral distribution of loads through the pavement depth as in
a flexible pavement. Typical examples of the semi-rigid pavement are the lean-concrete
base, soil-cement and lime-puzzolana concrete construction.
4. Composite: A composite pavement is one which comprises of multiple, structurally
significant layers of different- sometimes heterogeneous composition. A typical example
is the brick- sandwiched concrete pavement, which has been tried in India. It consists of
top and bottom layers of cement concrete which sandwich a brick layer in the neutral axis
zone. The design of composite pavement lies outside the well established fields of flexible
or rigid pavement design.

2.3. Comparison between Rigid and Flexible Pavements

1. Life: A well designed concrete slab has a life of about 40 years whereas the life of a
flexible pavement generally varies from 10 to 20 years. Even this shorter life can be
achieved only with extra maintenance input.
2. Maintenance: A well designed cement concrete pavement needs very little maintenance.
The only maintenance needed is in respect of joints. Bituminous surfaces, on the other
hand, need great inputs in maintenance. Sealing cracks, making good potholes, resurfacing
and resealing are done very frequently.
3. Surface characteristics: A good cement concrete surface is smooth and free from rutting,
potholes and corrugations. Thus the riding quality of a cement concrete surface is always
assured. In a bituminous surface, it is only the asphaltic concrete surface that can give
comparable rideability.
4. Penetration of water: A cement concrete slab is practically impervious, except at joints. If
joints are sealed, and well maintained, water will not penetrate and soften the subgrade. A
bituminous surface is not impervious. Water can find its way into the lower layers through
cracks and pores. Such water can impair the stability of the pavement.
5. Glare and night visibility: Concrete pavements have a grey color which can cause glare
under sunlight. Colored cement can reduce the glare. Black bituminous pavements are free
from this defect. On the other hand, bituminous roads need more street lighting.
6. Traffic dislocation during construction: A cement concrete pavement requires 28 days
before it can be thrown open to traffic. On the other hand, a bituminous surface can be
thrown open to traffic shortly after it is rolled. Further traffic will facilitate its compaction.
7. Environmental considerations during construction: During construction of a flexible
pavement where bituminous layers are to be provided, the process of heating of bitumen
and aggregates and mixing them together in hot mix plants, can prove to be much more
hazardous to the environment than cement concrete construction where no heating of any
material is involved.

742
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

8. Overall economy on a life cycle basis: A good quality road is costly to construct, but once
constructed, such a road requires little maintenance and results in savings in vehicle
operating costs. Keeping these considerations in mind, various investigations carried out in
India, on the comparative economy of a flexible pavement and a rigid pavement have
proved that on overall economic considerations, a rigid pavement is far more economical
than a flexible one, in the long run.

3. Construction Material

The overall development of any country depends on a good and well connected road network.
All other infrastructure developments, in turn, get benefited by such wide spread road
network. For highway construction and maintenance world over including India, millions of
tons of mineral aggregates are used. Most of the regionally and locally occurring good quality
rocks, gravels and sands are the sources of road construction materials. However, depending
on the locale, aggregates of minor quality may also have to be used for highway construction
and maintenance some times for economic reasons, preservation of the environment and also
in order to avoid large hauling distances. (Indoria 2009)

India has diverse geographical regions with different terrains, climate, rainfall, traffic pattern
and availability of construction materials coupled with a wide range of soil types. Therefore,
a standard method of design or a uniform technique of construction cannot hold good to meet
the requirements of all areas and thus appropriate design and different technologies based on
area specific conditions are adopted. Locally occurring materials like soil, gravel, moorum,
laterite, sand, and emerging materials like mine waste, industrial slag, jute geo-textile, soil-
enzymes, etc. can be effectively used singly or in combination with other materials as an
alternative to conventional materials, with significant economy after studying their physical
and engineering properties for their suitability in road construction. (Indoria 2009).

3.1. Aggregates

Mineral material like sand, gravel and crushed stone can be collectively called as aggregates.
These constitute the major part of the pavement structure. These are generally used with
binding material to form compounds like bituminous concrete and Portland cement concrete
(Mathew 2009). These are usually prepared from natural rock. The manufactured aggregates
used are often the bye products of other industries (Mathew 2009). Road aggregates differ in
their grain size, shape, texture and their gradation. Besides being strong to tolerate the wheel
load, they should be hard and tough to resist the rubbing due to traffic. Flaky and elongated
particles have relatively lesser strength and durability in comparison to cubical, angular or
rounded particles (Khanna & Justo 1993). The Portland cement concrete should be clean and
free from clay lumps, silt and other organic matter. Similarly the bituminous mix shouldn’t
have excess of elongated pieces, clay balls, dust etc. To prevent the stripping off of the
bituminous coatings, the aggregates used in the bituminous pavements should have less
affinity with water (Mathew 2009). Aggregates should always be tested for their strength,
water absorption, hardness, toughness and shape before they are used in construction.

Different aggregates exhibit diverse properties and are used by the highway engineers in
accordingly. Gravel aggregates are obtained from river beds and are have small rounded
structure. Sand aggregate is produced from weathering of rock and is an example of fine
aggregate. Coarse aggregates can be further classified into hard and soft aggregates. The hard

743
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

aggregates are used to resist the adverse weather conditions and the abrasive action of heavy
traffic loads. Whereas the soft aggregates like moorum, kankar, laterite, brick aggregates and
slag are used for low cost road constructions (Khanna & Justo 1993).

3.2. Cement

Cement in a general sense is adhesive and cohesive material which is capable of bonding
together particles of solid matter into a compact durable mass. Cement industry is one of the
most energy intensive industries. India stands fourth in the World’s cement manufacturer.
Cement can be manufactured either from natural cement stones or artificially by using
calcareous and argillaceous materials. The Indian cement industry manufactures about 13
kinds of cements and the Ordinary Portland cement constitutes nearly 70% of the total
produce (Schumacher & Sathaye 1999). Portland cement is widely used in constructing
pavements. The cement concrete pavements are able to withstand the heavy traffic even
under adverse conditions (Khanna & Justo 1993). Some of the common varieties of this
cement which are used are-Ordinary Portland cement, Portland Pozzolana Cement and
Portland Slag Cement (Das & Kandpal 1999).

It is also used to stabilize the sub-base and base courses. It has been observed that the cement
slurry has also been used in building of roads and for filling. It holds the aggregate particles
together to form the concrete. It is a result of various chemical combinations of calcium
carbonate, silica, alumina, iron ore and small amounts of some other materials. Varied
percentages of these compounds give rise to different physical and chemical properties of the
cement (Schumacher & Sathaye 1999).

3.3. Concrete

Aggregate, cement and water are the main constituents of concrete. Often different
admixtures are also added to enhance their characteristics. The strength of the concrete is
governed by the ratio of the weight of the water and the weight of the cement (Sjunnesson
2005). It is used for various purposes. Some of them are pavement of roads, reinforcement
using concrete piles, making slabs, piers etc.

Cement Concrete is a product obtained artificially by hardening of the mixture of cement,

sand, gravel and water in predetermined proportions. Concrete has enough strength in
compression, but little strength in tension. Due to this, plain concrete is weak in bending,
shear and torsion. Hence the use of plain concrete is limited to applications where great
compressive strength and weight are the principal requirements and where tensile stresses are
either totally absent or are extremely low(Punmia & Jain 2009). The reinforced cement
concrete is the concrete with more tensile strength. With incorporation of steel the mechanical
properties of the concrete improves (Elsaigh et al. 2005). A concrete can be singly
reinforced, doubly reinforced, over reinforced or under reinforced. Plastic reinforced and
polypropylene fibre reinforced concrete is also increasingly being used for road pavements
and other road constructions (Walia 2004). Unlike steel reinforced concrete plastic reinforced
concrete is resistant against corrosion and doesn’t require an extra layer of concrete for
protection.

3.4. Steel

The Carbon dioxide emissions of the developing countries from steel production nearly

744
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

constitute 5-15 % of their total Carbon dioxide emissions. The steel production in India
broadly takes place through the integrated iron and steel plants and through numerous
secondary steel producers (Price et al. 2001). Steel is often mixed with concrete and enhances
its properties.

Steel slag is one of the by products formed during steel manufacture. It is a hard, dense and a
dark coloured material. Due to its high strength and durability, it can be used as an aggregate
for the surface layers of the pavement. It can also be used as a part of sub base material. Since
the steel slag has high frictional and abrasion resistance, it is widely used on industrial roads,
parking areas and intersections. It has a tendency to crack but it can be overlooked in
presence of its all other properties (Ahmedzade & Sengoz 2009).

3.5. Bitumen

Bitumen is defined as a viscous liquid or a solid consisting essentially of hydrocarbons and

their derivatives, which is soluble in carbon disulphide. It is substantially non-volatile and
softens gradually when heated. It is black or brown in colour and possesses waterproofing
and adhesive properties. It is obtained by a refinery process, which case it is known as
“petroleum bitumen”. It is also found as a natural deposit, in which case it is known as
“native bitumen” or “natural bitumen”.(Kadyali & Lal 2008). Today, the main use of bitumen
is in the road making industry for construction and maintenance. In road making, bitumen
products are typically applied with mineral aggregate. The strong adhesion that occurs
between the bitumen and mineral aggregate enables the bitumen to act as a binder, with the
mineral aggregate providing mechanical strength for the road). Bitumen can now be made
from non-petroleum based renewable resources such as sugar, molasses and rice, corn and
potato starches. Bitumen can also be made from waste material by fractional distillation of
used motor oils, which is sometimes disposed by burning or dumping into landfills. Non-
petroleum based bitumen binders can be made light-colored. Roads made with lighter-colored
pitch absorb less heat from solar radiation, and become less hot than darker surfaces,
reducing their contribution to the urban heat island effect

3.6. Lime

Lime is a general term used for various forms of basic chemicals produced from calcium
carbonate rocks such as limestone (CaCO3) and dolomite. Lime is made by heating limestone
(calcium carbonate) to high temperatures. This process, known as calcining, results in
quicklime, or calcium oxide. Hydrated lime (calcium hydroxide) is produced by reacting
quicklime with sufficient water to form a dry, white powder. In construction, lime's traditional
use is in mortar and plaster, because of its superior plasticity, workability and other qualities.
Its dominant construction use today is in soil stabilization for roads, airfields, building
foundations and earthen dams, where it upgrades low quality soils into usable base and
subbase materials. It is also used as an additive in asphalt, in which it improves the cohesion
of the asphalt, reduces "stripping "and retards the aging process. Dolomitic lime is also used
in the production of masonry mortar and stucco, and high calcium lime is used in the
production of aerated autoclaved concrete.

4. Pavements Layers

Given below is a list of activities and the pavement layers which form a part of the current
highway (NH-228) under study:

745
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

4.1. Site Clearance and Dismantling

Site clearance means removing all the buildings and facilities from a site. It might also
include ground remediation where soil has been contaminated radiologically or by other
agents. The area should be cleared of bushes, vegetation, grass, branches, trees and saplings.
The main purpose of site clearance is to remove existing buildings, waste, vegetation and,
most importantly, the surface layer of soil referred to as topsoil. It is necessary to remove this
layer of soil, as it is unsuitable to build on. This surface layer of soil is difficult to compact
down due to the high content of vegetable matter, which makes the composition of the soil
soft and loose. The topsoil also contains various chemicals that encourage plant growth,
which may adversely affect some structures over time. Once the site clearance is complete,
excavations for the foundations can start.

4.2. Earth Work

Under Earthwork, the subgrade soil is prepared to bring it to the desired grade. It includes
excavation of soil, transportation of soil, spreading earth, construction of embankments,
construction of earthen shoulder, preparation of subgrade and soil compaction.

4.3. Subgrade

The subgrade is the complicated natural earth immediately below the pavement layers.
Subgrades are commonly compacted before the construction of a road, pavement or railway
track, and are sometimes stabilized by the addition of asphalt, soil cement, Portland cement
or lime. It is the foundation of the pavement structure, on which the subbase is laid. The
success or failure of a pavement is more often than not dependent upon the underlying
subgrade. Preparation of the subgrade for construction usually involves digging, in order to
remove surface vegetation, topsoil and other unwanted material, and to create space for the
upper layer of the pavement. This process is known as subgrade formation or reduction to
level. Depth of water table, depth of bedrock, compaction and CBR value are the factors that
are considered while determining the suitability of the subgrade. (Pike 2005)

4.4. Granular Subbase

Granular materials such as large sized stone boulders, broken stones, brick ballast or broken
kankar are extensively used as subbase of road pavement. In the present case (Grading 1), it
is composed of 90% aggregates and 10% stone dust. The entire thickness of a flexible
pavement to withstand the superimposed load due to traffic need not consist of costly
materials such as bituminous concrete or macadam, but on going down from the surface,
cheaper and lower quality material may be substituted. This is because the stresses go on
diminishing at lower depths. Granular bases and subbases are extensively used taking
advantages of their low cost, local availability and the diminishing stresses in the lower
layers. (Kadyali and Lal, 2008)

4.5. Wet Mix Macadam Base

Wet Mix Macadam is a specification in which a well- graded aggregate is mixed with water
in a mechanical mixer and the resultant mixer is laid by pavers and compacted. The aggregate
is usually crusher-run, and includes fine also. Because of the close grading, the course will
have good interlock with excellent density and high stability. The moisture content is usually

746
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

in the range of 2-5% by weight. (Kadyali and Lal, 2008)

4.6. Bituminous Macadam

Bituminous Macadam shall consist of the construction of one or more courses of compacted
crushed aggregates, premixed with a bituminous binder, laid immediately after mixing. It is
an open graded construction suitable for base and binder courses and should not be used as
wearing course as such. It may be used as a temporary riding surface when covered with an
appropriate seal coat.
In the bituminous macadam pavement, the foundation is macadam, upon which a bituminous
material that penetrates at least 2 in (5 cm) into the foundation is poured, forming an
impervious binder. In the bituminous-mixed macadam pavement, a mixture of crushed rock,
ground glass and other additives, and bituminous binder is spread over a macadam foundation
and rolled into a compact mass.
Here in this report, we considered BM layer (grading 2) to be made of 100% aggregates and
3.5 % bitumen (by weight of total mix)

4.7. Profile Corrective Course

Most bituminous overlay works require the construction of a corrective course in order to
correct the camber of the existing structure and rectify local irregularities in the longitudinal
profile. The profile corrective course may be laid as part of the overlay/ strengthening or as a
separate layer. In the former case, the material for the profile corrective course should be the
same as that of the overlay/strengthening course. If it is laid as a separate layer, it must have a
specification at least the equivalent of the layer over which it is to be laid.( Raina’s manual)
In the present case, profile corrective course is made of bituminous macadam.

4.8. Dense Bituminous Macadam (DBM) Course

The dense bituminous macadam consists of course aggregate, fine aggregate and filler in
suitable proportions with required binder content. For compacted thickness upto 50mm,
grading 1 will only be used while for thickness greater than 50 mm, grading 2 could be used.
In the present case, a DBM course of grading 2 has been provided which consists of 98%
stone aggregate, 2% lime and 5 % bitumen(by weight of total mix).

4.9. Bituminous Concrete (BC) Wearing Course

Asphaltic concrete or Bituminous Concrete is a pavement specification composed of a

thoroughly controlled hot mixed material having graded mineral aggregate(97%), filler(lime
3%) and bitumen(5.5% by weight of total mix). The course aggregate commonly used
crushed stone, crushed slag and crushed gravel(shingle). The fine aggregate normally used is
stone dust, natural stone or a mixture of both. Durability, imperviousness, load spreading
property and good skid resistance are some of the advantages of bituminous concrete wearing
course. (Kadyali and Lal 2008)

4.10. Semi Dense Bituminous Concrete (SDBC) Course

It is used as a wearing course and contains 70% stone aggregates, 27% stone dust (sand), 3%
lime and 5% by weight of bitumen

747
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

5. Carbon footprint

Carbon footprint is a measure of the impact of our activities on the environment, and in
particular on climate change. A carbon footprint is made up of the sum of two parts, the
primary footprint and the secondary footprint. The primary footprint is a measure of direct
emissions whereas the secondary footprint is a measure of the indirect emissions from the
whole lifecycle of the products manufactured and their eventual breakdown. The direct
consequence of increased carbon footprint is global warming and climate change. Definitions
of carbon footprint from grey literature are given in table 1.

Table 1 Definitions of carbon footprint from grey literature

SOURCE DEFINITION
BP (2007) “The carbon footprint is the amount of carbon dioxide emitted due to
your daily activities- from washing a load of laundry to driving a
carload of kids to school.
British Sky The carbon footprint was calculated by “measuring the CO2
Broadcasting(Sky) equivalent emissions from its premises, company owned vehicle,
(Patel 2007) business travel and waste to landfill”. (Patel 2006)
Carbon Trust “… a methodology to estimate the total emission of greenhouse gases
(2007) (ghg) in carbon equivalents from a product across its life cycle from
the production of raw material used in its manufacture , to disposal of
the finished product(excluding in-use emissions).
“….a technique for identifying and measuring the individual
greenhouse gas emissions from each activity within a supply chain
process step and the framework for attributing these to each output
product (referred to as the product carbon footprint).”
Energetics (2007) “…. The full extent of direct and indirect CO2 emissions caused by
your business activities.”
ETAP (2007) “….the ‘carbon footprint’ is a measure of the impact human activities
have on the environment in terms of the amount of ghg’s produced,
measured in tones of carbon dioxide”.
Global Footprint “ the demand on biocapacity required to sequester (through
Network (2007) photosynthesis) the carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from the fossil
fuel combustion.” (GFN 2007)
Parliamentary “ a ‘carbon footprint’ is the total amount of CO2 and other green
office of science house gases , emitted over the full cycle of a process or product . it is
and expressed as grams of CO2 equivalent per kilowatt hour of generation
technology(POST ( GCO2eq/kWh) which accounts for the different global warming
2006) effects of other greenhouse gases.”
Source: Thomas Wiedmann and Jan Minx (2007)

At an early stage of planning process of new road projects, carbon footprint can be included
as grounds for comparison in decision making. However material and energy consumption in
open roads tunnels and bridges are poorly known in early stages of planning and there is a
need for general factors for material and energy consumption for various road elements.

6. METHODOLOGY

6.1. Study Area

748
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

National Highway 228 from Kim River to Dandi in Gujarat State

National Highway 228 (NH 228) connects Sabarmati Ashram at Ahmedabad to Dandi. The
highway covers a distance of 386 in the state of Gujarat. Starting at Sabarmati Ashram, the
national highway 228 passes through Aslali, Navagam, Matar, Nadiad, Anand, Borsad,
Kankapura, Kareli, Ankhi, Amod, Derol, Ankleshwar, Mangrol, Umrachi, Bhatgam, Delad,
Surat, Vanjh, Navsari and Kardi. The development of the Dandi Heritage Route was first
announced on the 75th anniversary of the famous Dandi Kooch or Salt March and an outlay
of about Rs 750 crore was proposed. But, now this has grown to over Rs 2,100 crore only for
construction of the national highway. The 10 metre road has a 2 metre halfway. The 386-km
route has 12 major bridges, 58 minor bridges and over 450 small bridges which either pass
over a canal or pipeline. At some places, the existing roads have been converted while for
nearly 50 km, a new road has been built. (Reporter 2010). The work on strengthening first
phase of Dandi Heritage Route was flagged off by Union minister of state for road transport,
KH Muniyappa at Dandi in Navsari on 2nd March 2009.. The first phase is the existing road
between Ahmedabad and Navsari, other than NH-8. The project is funded by Central
government and executed by the state government. (Reporter 2009)

6.2. Calculation of the Carbon footprint

The studied area consisted of many parts. It had the pavement, bridges, underpass, walkways,
road junctions, ROBs, and culverts. Carbon footprint for each of these parts has been
calculated. It was calculated as follows:
i) The detailed estimate of the construction material was gathered. It served as the baseline
dataset. Data in it was presented in different measurable units. In order to make the
calculations easy all were converted to a single measurable unit.
ii) Initially the volume of all building materials used was tabulated. Wherever it wasn’t
given, it was calculated with the help of standard formulas. E.g. for calculating the
volume of the concrete used in the pile foundation, the structure of pile was assumed as
cylindrical in shape. Likewise many assumptions were taken to carry the study further.
iii) The data on the CO2 equivalents is generally available in terms of mass i.e. the amount of
carbon dioxide which is emitted on manufacturing one tone of a material. Due to this,
densities of all materials were searched and masses were calculated.
iv) Then the net CO2 emissions were calculated in kg. This represents the carbon footprint of
the pavement.

6.3. Assumptions

Following assumptions were taken:

i) The Carbon dioxide equivalent for the Earth work was taken as nil (Barrett et al. 2002)
ii) The Carbon dioxide equivalent of Wet mix macadam has been taken as same as of
macadam.
iii) For calculating the mass of bituminous concrete, bituminous macadam, profile corrective
course, dense bituminous macadam and semi dense bituminous concrete the densities
and volumes of their constituents have been considered.
iv) The weighted average was found to estimate the CO2 emissions of bituminous concrete,
bituminous macadam, profile corrective course, dense bituminous macadam and semi
dense bituminous concrete.
v) At all other places where cement was used, the CO2 equivalent of dry ordinary Portland
cement was used.

749
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

vi) Stone aggregate has been considered as the crushed part of natural stone and all
calculations have been done accordingly
vii) Miscellaneous items like precast kerb, Jamuna sand etc. were not considered due to lack
of availability of data on them.
viii) The density of plain cement concrete and reinforced cement concrete is assumed to be
the same i.e. 2400 kg/cum.

6.4. Sources of CO2 equivalents

This section shows the data used for the calculations along with the method of estimation of
CO2 from road construction works. Table 2 lists the CO2 emission factors used in the
calculations.

Table 2 List of the CO2 emission factors of the construction materials used
S.no. Item CO2 emission factor Source
(Kg/tone)
1 Wet mix macadam 1.6 Sjunnesson 2005
2 Stone aggregate 20.82 Barrett 2002
3 Lime 750 Metz 2007
4 Bitumen .22 IPCC 2006
5 Cement 1160 Das & Kandpal 1999
6 Sand 10.94 Barrett 2002
7 Earth work Nil Barrett 2002
8 Steel 2680 Tata Steel Limited 2006
9 Reinforced cement 115 CICSF 2008
concrete
10 Plain cement concrete 95 CICSF 2008

Table 3 CO2 emissions from the pavement

S. Items Quantity CO2 CO2
o Volume Density Mass equivalen emissions
(cum) (Kg/cum) (tones) t factor (Kg)
1 Site clearance and 27,329 2400 65,589.6 nil nil
dismantling of existing
structures
2 Earthwork 31,65,67 1,442 4564903.4 Nil Nil
5
3 Granural sub base
1. Stone aggregate 3,14,550 1,602 5,03,909.1 20.82 1,04,91,387.4
2. Stone dust 62
34,950 1,602 55,989.9 10.94
6,12,529.506
4 Wet mix macadam base 3,22,900 2,350 7,58,815 1.6 12,14,104

750
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

5 Profile corrective / 12,000

regrading course
(bituminous macadam)
i) Stone 12,000 1,602 19,224 20.82 4,00,243.68
aggregate
ii) Bitumen 420 0.00102 0.0004284 0.22 0.00009425
6 Bituminous macadam 24,000
course
i) Stone 24,000 1,602 38,448 20.82 8,00,487.36
aggregate
ii) Bitumen 840 0.00102 0.0008568 0.22 0.0001885
7 Dense bituminous 1,00,000
macadam course
i) Stone 98,000 1,602 1,56,996 20.82 32,68,656.7
aggregate
ii) Lime 2,000 481 962 750 7,21,500
iii) Bitumen 5,000 0.00102 0.0051 0.22 0.001122
8 Bituminous concrete 50,000
wearing course
i) Stone 48,500 1,602 77,697 20.82 16,17,651.5
aggregate
ii) Lime 1,500 481 721.5 750 5,41,125
iii) Bitumen 2,750 0.00102 0.002805 0.22 0.0006171
9 Semi dense bituminous 1,500
concrete
i) Stone 1,050 1,602 1,682.1 20.82 3,50,21.322
aggregate
ii) Stone 405 1,602 648.81 10.94 7,097.9814
dust(sand)
iii) Lime 45 481 21.645 750 16,233.75
iv) Bitumen 75 0.00102 0.0765 0.22 0.01683
10 Dry lean cement 1,500
i) Cement 225 1,160 2,61,000
11 Pavement quality concrete 1,500
i) Cement 600 1,160 6,96,000

Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the pavement = 2,06,83,038.28 Kg
= 20,683.038 tonnes
Table 4 CO2 emissions from the culverts
S.o Items Quantity CO2 CO2
Volume Density Mass equivalent emissions
(cum) (Kg/cum) (tones) factor (Kg)
1 Earthwork 14,235 1,442 20,526.87 Nil Nil
2 Steel 994 2680 26,63,920
3 Granular 2,805 1,602 4,493.61 10.94 49,160.093
Material(sand)
4 Reinforced 7,210 2,400 17,304 115 19,89,960
cement
concrete
5 Plain cement 12,020.05 2,400 2,400 95 2,28,000

751
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

concrete

Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the culverts= 49,31,040.1
= 4,931.040 tonnes

Table 5 CO2 emissions from the bridges

S.o Items Quantity CO2 CO2
Volume Density Mass equivalent emissions
(cum) (Kg/cum) (tones) factor (Kg)
1 Earthwork 1,955 1,442 2,819.11 Nil Nil
2 Steel 851 2680 22,80,680
3 Granular 1,185 1,602 1,898.37 10.94 20,768.168
Material(sand)
4 Sand Filling 1,700 1,602 2,723.4 10.94 29,793.996
5 Reinforced 3,298.159 2,400 7,915.5816 115 9,10,291.88
cement
concrete
6 Plain cement 7,149 2,400 17,157.6 95 16,29,972
concrete

Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the bridges = 48,71,506.044 Kg
= 4,871.506 tonnes

Table 6 CO2 emissions from the underpass

S.o Items Quantity CO2 CO2
Volume Density Mass equivalent emissions
(cum) (Kg/cum) (tones) factor (Kg)
1 Earthwork 260 1,442 374.92 Nil Nil
2 Steel 85 2680 2,27,800
3 Granular 435 1,602 696.87 10.94 7,623.7578
Material(sand)
4 Reinforced 415 2,400 996 115 1,14,540
cement
concrete
5 Plain cement 445 2,400 1,068 95 1,01,460
concrete

Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the underpass = 4,51,423.7578 Kg
= 451.424 tonnes

Table 7 CO2 emissions from the Roads Over Bridges (ROBs)

S.o Items Quantity CO2 CO2
Volume Density Mass equivalent emissions
(cum) (Kg/cum) (tones) factor (Kg)
1 Earthwork 1,140 1,442 1,643.88 Nil Nil

752
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

2 Steel 565 2680 15,14,200

3 Granular 2,550 1,602 4,085.1 10.94 44,690.994
Material(sand)
4 Reinforced 653 2,400 1567.2 115 1,80,228
cement
concrete
5 Plain cement 3,750 2,400 9,000 95 8,55,000
concrete

Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the road over bridges (ROBs) =
25,94,118.994 kg = 2,594.119 tonnes

7. RESULTS:

Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the pavement = 20,683.038 tonnes
Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the culverts = 4,931.040 tonnes
Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the bridges = 4,871.506 tonnes
Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the underpass = 451.424 tonnes
Total CO2 emissions from the materials used in the road over bridges (ROBs) = 2,594.119
tonnes

Carbon Footprint 0f NH 228

Pavement
Culverts
Bridges
Underpass
ROBs

Hence, the Carbon Footprint of the National Highway 228 = 33,531.127 tonnes
The length of the highway is 386 km. Hence the Carbon Footprint of the highway can also be
taken as 86.868 tonnes/km

8. Discussion and Conclusion

The Carbon footprint is a good sustainability indicator and it gives a fair idea about the
environmental effectiveness of an activity. It is a tool which helps us to assess what to chose
and what not to such that we can take better decisions. It gives an idea about the amount of
environmental impact, a product, a city or an activity imposes. It can be very helpful for
planning and policy making. Like in the National Highway 228, it can be seen that the carbon
footprint of the highway is very high. The severity of the situation can be analyzed from here
itself. Besides, the carbon footprint of the pavement is much greater than any other road
works. This can be attributed to the fact that the pave
pavement
ment is composed of different layers,
each of which uses a large quantity of cement, aggregates and sometimes lime also. These

753
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

form the foundation of the highway and are required in huge quantities too. But at the same
time, their environmental implications are also very acute.

The construction materials form the main part of a new road, highway or a flyover and these not even
deplete the natural resources but also at times turn out to be uneconomical. The transportation of these
also adds to the emissions. To decrease these emissions, the use of locally available materials should
be encouraged. A huge proportion of the total waste generated in our country is the construction waste
which is dumped in landfills (ignoring the fact that if properly processed, it can be reused). Waste
materials like fly ash, slag, plastic, rubber should be used wherever possible. Steps should be taken to
popularize recycling of materials and their use. This will not only reduce the waste but decrease the
pressure on natural resources. Research work should be encouraged to find alternative construction
material which emits less GHGs and thus have a lower carbon footprint. Minimizing the amount of
resources used, reducing wastage and encouraging the use of renewable energy are some of the steps
that should be adopted. Concrete which require less cement and less water during mixing is also
available these days. Rocks should be crushed on site as it will reduce the need of importing
aggregates. Cut and fill should be balanced to reduce the need for import and export of fill.
Geotextiles which prolong the pavement life, reduce maintenance and decrease the amount of fill and
aggregates needed should be used. Geotextiles can eliminate the amount of undercut necessary on a
project and/or some of the aggregate base material. The use geosynthetics in road construction goes
far beyond the reduction of the carbon footprint. In addition to CO2 reduction, the use of geotextiles
significantly conserves our natural resources. Also, energy efficient instruments should be used to
decrease the emissions from machinery. Bitumen emulsions, which are fluid at ambient temperature
and require little or no heating before application should be utilized as they are easy to apply and free
of volatile organic compounds (VOC). Lack of data is a big hurdle to propel the research in this
sector. Formation of datasets and building up of inventories should be encouraged.

ACKOWLEDGEMETS

The authors would like to express their gratitude towards the contributions made by Kavita
Jain, student of B.E.(civil), BITS, Pilani, for her contributions towards the present study.

REFERECES
Ahmedzade, P. and Sengoz, B. (2009) Evaluation of steel slag coarse aggregate in hot mix
asphalt concrete. Journal of Hazardous Materials, Vol. 165, 300-305
Barrett, J, Vallack, H, Jones, A, Haq, G 2002, ‘Material Flow Analysis and Ecological
Footprint of York’, Stockholm Environment Institute, Sweden
Concrete Industry Sustainable Concrete Forum (CISCF) 2008, Embodied CO2 of Concrete
and Reinforced Concrete, viewed 24 July 2010,
<C1%20CISCF%20WG2%20Embodied%20CO2%20of%20UK%20Concrete%2027%20No
v%2008[1].pdf>
Das, A. and Kandpal, T.C. (1999) A model to estimate energy demand and CO2 emissions for
the Indian cement industry. International Journal of Energy Research, Vol 23, 563-
569
Elsaigh,W.A., Kearsley, E.P. and Robberts, J.M. (2005) Steel fibre reinforced concrete for
road pavement applications, Proceedings of the 24th Southern African Transport
Conference, Document Transformation Technologies cc, South Africa, 191-201
Indoria, R.P. (2009) Use of locally available material in road construction. Indian Highways,
viewed 13 July 2010, http://www.irc.org.in/editorials/2009/edimay09.pdf>

754
Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.9, 2011

Indian Roads Congress (2001) Guidelines for the design of flexible pavements. IRC : 37 –
2001, The Indian Roads Congress, Jamnagar House, Shahjahan Road, New Delhi-
110011.
IPCC 2006, IPCC Guidelines for ational Greenhouse Gas Inventories, Volume 2:
Energy, viewed 13 July 2010, <http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/EFDB/main.php>
Kadyali and Lal (2008) Principles and Practices of Highway Engineering, 5th edn, Khanna
publishers, Delhi-6
Khanna, S.K. and Justo, C.E.G. (1993), Highwa.y Engineering, 7th edn, Nem Chand & Bros,
Roorkee
Mathew, T.V. (2009) Pavement materials: Aggregates, Lecture notes on Transportation
Systems Engineering, 25 July 2010,
<http://www.civil.iitb.ac.in/tvm/1100_LnTse/404_lntse/plain/plain.html>
Metz, B 2007, Climate change 2007 Mitigation of Climate Change, Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change, Working group I
Price, L., Phylipsen, D. and Worrell, E. (2001) Energy Use and Carbon Dioxide Emissions
in the Steel Sector in Key Developing Countries, University of California, Berkeley
Pike, J. (2005) Subgrades and Base courses, 13 July 2010,
<(http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/policy/army/fm/5-430-00-1/CH5.htm>
Punmia, B.C. and Jain. (2009) Building Construction, 10th edn, Laxmi Pub Ltd, New Delhi
Raina, V (2009) Raina’s field manual for highway and bridge engineers. viewed 10 July 2010,
<http://books.google.co.in/books?id=o0EYonpvXDMC&pg=PA117&lpg=PA117&dq=pr
ofile+corrective+course&source=bl&ots=GX3DSBi6G3&sig=aPv2tYgyBGigfYgvhB5-
E60je6I&hl=en&ei=YilDTJ-
hJ82GcYzBxOMP&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CC0Q6AEwB
g#v=onepage&q=profile%20corrective%20course&f=false>
Reporter. (2009) Work on Dandi Heritage Route Starts. The Times of India, Posted 3 March 2009,
viewed 14 July 2010, < http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/4214609.cms >
Reporter. (2010) A Walk Down the Salt March Lane. The Times of India, Posted 13 July 2010,
viewed 14 July 2010, < http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/A-walk-down-
the-Salt-March-lane/articleshow/6160855.cms >
Schumacher,K. and Sathaye, J. (1999) India’s Cement Industry: Productivity, Energy
Efficiency and Carbon Emissions. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley
Sjunnesson, J. (2005) Life Cycle Assessment of Concrete, Master thesis, Lund University,
Sweden
Tata Steel Limited 2006, Corporate Sustainability Report 2005-06, viewed 18 July 2010,
http://www.tatasteel.com/corporatesustainability/Sustainability05-06/page-053.htm
Walia, P. (2004) Fibre Reinforced Cement Concrete for Roads and Pavements, 16 July
2010, <d.wanfangdata.com.cn/NSTLQK_NSTL_QK8160867.aspx>
Wiedmann, T. and Minx, J. (2007) A Definition of ‘Carbon Footprint’. ISA UK Research
Report.
Zuidgeest, M.H.P. (2006) Using RS and GIS in ecological transport footprint analysis : some
research ideas : abstract. In: Abstracts of the workshop on modern aspects of remote
sensing and geospatial data processing, NRSA - ITC, Hyderabad, India, 24-25
November 2006 / ed by. K.M.M. Rao, A. Stein, P.S. Roy and A.S. Manjunath.
Hyderabad : National Remote Sensing Agency (NRSA).

755