CNV Rules 1960
CNV Rules 1960
CNV Rules 1960
CHAPTER – 4
EMPLOYMENT GENERATION
PROGRAMMES IN INDIA
1
Government of India, Planning Commission, Sixth Five Year plan, 1980-85, P-207.
84
Sixth Five Year Plan Stated, "It is, therefore, necessary that a
disaggregated approach is introduced to find meaningful solution to this
complex and challenging problem".1 For this purpose, it was proposed to
organise in all the districts of the country a District Manpower Planning
and Employment Generation Council with appropriate professional staff
support. The Council was to be assisted by the District Employment
Exchange, District Industries Centre, District Agricultural Office, lead
bank and those connected with the organisation of services in preparing a
portfolio of opportunities for salaried, self and wage employment during
the plan period.
During the late 1970s and 1980s having recognised the fact that in
Indian conditions, the percolation effects of growth were not sufficient to
generate the required employment opportunities, the need for
supplemental employment opportunities and employment programmes
for specific target groups/areas was felt and under the Fifth and the Sixth
Plans, attempts were made in this direction. The Seventh Plan sticking to
the basic approach of these Plans, asserted, "The task is one of adopting a
suitable structure of investment and production, appropriate types of
technology and mix of production technique and organizational support
which would help promote growth in productive employment".2 The
Planning Commission, thus, argued that in pursuing the objective of
employment generation, the country cannot stick to a static technology.
However, it stressed that technological upgradation and modernisation
should not result in considerable dislocation of labour.
The Seventh Plan assigned a key role to the agricultural sector for
employment generation. However, it was well realised that the
agricultural sector cannot eliminate the entire unemployment backlog and
also absorb additions to the labour force. Therefore, programmes of rural
1
Government of India, Planning Commission, Sixth Five Year Plan, (1980-85), P. 207.
2
Government of India, Planning Commission, Seventh Five Year Plan, (1985-90, Vol. II),P. 112
85
1
Raj Krishna, "The Growth of Aggregate Unemployment in India", World Bank Staff Working
Papers No. 638, P. 17-18
86
employment elasticity for all sectors was around 0.68. Since then, the
employment elasticity has further declined. It has been estimated to be
0.16 for the period of 1993-94 to 1999-2000. This implies that for
generating additional employment at 3 per cent annum, GDP should
register an annual growth of 18-19 per cent which is something
impossible in the given structure of the Indian economy.1 Therefore, in
India, economic growth by itself can never solve the unemployment
problem and the government policy which gives overriding priority to
economic growth would add to unemployment backlog rather than
reducing it. Therefore, under the Eighth Plan, there was emphasis on both
the growth of the economy and restructuring of output composition of
growth. Defining its employment perspective, the Eighth Plan clearly
stated, "The employment potential of growth can be raised by readjusting
the sectoral composition of output in favour of sectors and sub-sectors
having higher employment elasticity".2 In certain sectors, where
technologies are to be upgraded to a higher level of efficiency and
international competitiveness, there is a little scope for generating
additional employment. However, in respect of certain other sectors,
some flexibility may be available in the choice of technologies and, thus,
it may not be difficult to generate considerable employment.
1
Alok Ghos, "Eighth Plan : Challenges and Possibilities – III, Employment, Core of the plan", 1991
P.198
2
Government of India, Planning Commission, Eighth Five Year Plan.(1992-97, Volume I),P.120
87
1
Government of India, Planning Commission, Eight Five Year Plan, Volume II (1992-97), P.32
88
Box 4.1
Jobless Growth in India in Recent Years ('Aam Aadmi Ko Kya Mila')
In India, the rise in unemployment has been a silent phenomenon. We have had
disguised unemployment in the past, but unemployment never reached more than 5
per cent of the population. According to the National Sample Survey's 55th round,
unemployment as a percentage of labour force rose from 5.99 per cent in 1993-94 to
7.32 per cent in 1999-2000. Perhaps we have been witnessing jobless growth in recent
years because while the GDP grew at an average rate of 6.4 per cent between 1992-93
to 2000-01, employment growth declined from 2 per cent to 1 per cent.
In the recent past, thousands of workers in agriculture and the organised sector have
been laid off. The organised sector (establishments employing 10 or more workers)
has been shrinking. The private manufacturing units within the organised sector have
been shedding labour in response to higher wages and global competition.
Retrenchment of labour has been common in other countries, but in India it is a new
phenomenon and the Voluntary Retirement Scheme (VRS) has not been painless.
Some workers have been laid off without any severance pay from loss making
enterprises. All this has led to widespread human trauma especially because there are
no social safety nets, nor facilities for re-training and skills development.
The restructuring exercise may have led to more productivity, but the
retrenchment process has thrown several families off balance. Employees lost their
jobs and houses, children's schools, healthcare and an 'address', so important in India.
In the last decade, those accepting VRS have witnessed a new phenomenon-even their
children can't find a job.In the organised sector, labour laws have blamed for keeping
millions of workers out of jobs while 'protecting' the jobs of 'permanent' staffers. The
fact is that most employers are successfully circumventing labour laws through
contractual labour whom they routinely hire and fire. Also, the lack of skills and
training among workers encourage industrialists to go for higher technology rather
than labour. The Indian labour force is among the least skilled and literate as
compared to the skill levels of workers in China or South Korea, especially in the
manufacturing sector.
1
Jay Shree Sengupta," Aam Aadmi Ko Kya Mila" Tehalka, September 25, 2004
92
The JRY completed eleven years in March 1999. The JRY was
restructured with effect from April 1999 and was renamed as
Jawahar Gram Samridhi Yojana (JGSY). In the first ten years, the
JRY generated 7,373 million mandays of employment. Thus, in
quantitative terms, the performance of the JRY was not distinctly better
than that of the NREP and RLEGP. However, in two respects, the JRY
was superior to the NREP/ RLEGP regime. First, under the JRY there
was a clear change in the priorities in favour of economically productive
investments, especially which enhance the productivity of land. Second,
the JRY approach involving Panchayats in the planning and
implementation of employment schemes was superior to the bureaucratic
approach followed under the NREP/ RLEGP.
96
With the NREG Act being passed in September, 2005, the NREGS
was implemented since February 2, 2006 in 200 identified districts of the
country with an object of providing 100 days of guaranteed unskilled
wage employment to each rural household opting for it. The ongoing
programmes of SGRY and National Food for Work Programme (NFWP)
have been subsumed undo NREGS in these districts. NREGS was
extended to 300 districts during 2007-08. The coverage was extended to
all rural districts of the country in 2008-09. As against the budgeted
outlay of Rs.39,100 crore for the year 2009-10, an amount of
Rs.24,758.50 crore has been released to the States/UTs till Secember,
2009. During the year 2009-10, 4.34 crore households have been
provided employment under the scheme. Out of the 182.88 crore person
days created under the scheme during this period, 29 per cent and 22 per
cent were in favour of SC and ST population respectively and 50 per cent
in favour of women. The NREGS, a demand-driven scheme, has its
focus on works relating to water conservation, drought proofing
(including afforestation/tree plantation), land development, flood control/
100
The wage paid under the programme should be at par with the
minimum agricultural wage prescribed for the area. The quantum of
foodgrains as part of the wage should be such as to be adequate for the
family's need. In any case, the foodgrains component should not exceed
two Kgs. per head per day. Efforts will also be made to organise mobile
fair price shops at the centres where rural works are in progress so that
the cloth, vegetable oil, salt and other essential items of consumption may
also be made available. Contractors are to be totally excluded from the
execution of rural works on which the employment is offered through
NREP. Neither will the distribution of foodgrains be entrusted to
middlemen or contractors.
Only about half the States had involved Panchayati Raj institutions
in the Food for Work Programme. Given proper technical and
administrative supervision, these institutions have the capability of
planning and executing works answering to local needs, at comparatively
low cost. It is, therefore, desirable that these institutions are involved in
planning and execution works under NREP to the extent possible,
considering local conditions and nature of the work. The educational
research and technical institutions in the block would be associated with
the Panchayati Raj Institutions in preparing a shelf of the projects which
will help to ensure that the assets created are at least equal in value to the
wages paid. Following pictures shows the beneficiaries getting training
under NREP:
104
Since the Food for Work Programme is meant for providing wage
employment in the natural calamity affected States, preference shall be
given to labour-intensive works, particularly those which would help in
drought-proofing such as moisture conservation works, watershed
development works, water harvesting, digging up village ponds/tanks and
construction of rural-link roads (Kutcha Road) etc. As far as possible, the
works to be taken up should result into durable assets.
Main Objectives:
The amounts allocated and utilised under REGP, during the last three
years are given below:
2004-05 5.30
2005-06 5.68
2006-07 5.95
New Initiatives
Fixation of targets for projects and margin money for all field
offices based on rural population of the State.
Main Findings
6. The Gram Panchayats which had utilised the funds, could provide
employment to a person, for an average number of 11.44 and 15.68
days during 1989-90 and 1990-91, respectively. This shows that
the Yojana did not provide employment to the extent expected.
116
7. It has been revealed that the illustrative list of works, as per the
JRY Manual has become exhaustive at the operational level.
8. It was observed that the quality of assets created was not upto the
mark in 56 per cent of the Gram Panchayats. Eight-nine per cent of
the selected assets created were useful. It was observed that no
adequate attention was given to the maintenance of assets.
9. At the Gram Panchayat level, it was felt that wage - material ratio
was not workable. The Panchayat Secretary was over worked and
the plan of action instead of being prepared by Gram Panchayat,
was being prepared by the block agency thereby ignoring the felt
needs of the area. In respect of technical problems at the Gram
Panchayat level, it was reported that technical guidance was not
available, measurement of works was delayed, and operational area
of the junior engineer was too big. Following pictures shows the
beneficiaries working on a field under JRY:
117
Major Suggestions
It was, however, felt that a stage has come when the development
of village infrastructure needs to be taken up in a planned manner.
Accordingly, the Government restructured the existing wage employment
programme namely Jawahar Rozgar Yojana (JRY) and Employment
Assurance Scheme (EAS). The new programme- Jawahar Gram Samridhi
Yojana (restructured JRY) is dedicated entirely to the development of
rural infrastructure at the village level and is being implemented through
village panchayats. This programme has come into effect from 1st April
1999.
Objectives of JGSY
Wage under JGSY will either be the minimum wage notified by the
State or higher wage fixed by State through the prescribed
procedure.
Works to be Taken Up
Earmarking of Resources
banks. However, there are genuine reasons for the inability of banks
to meet credit requirements of IRDP beneficiaries in full. These
include: poor recovery of IRDP loans, lack of adequate rural
banking infrastructure in certain areas and the weak financial
performance of Regional Rural Banks and Cooperative banks.
Following pictures show the women of two different Self Help Groups
(SHGs) working on their activities:
(c) The Family Credit Plan would be extended to all the districts of
the country in a phased manner. The feedback from the States
suggests that this strategy has met with reasonable success and
has raised investment levels.
Experience has shown that the IRDP has been relatively more
successful in land-based activities. In recognition of this fact,
purchase of land was made a permissible activity under the
129
Non-farm sector in the rural areas has witnessed both growth and
diversification in the past few years. Around 50 percent of the IRDP
investments are now made in the secondary and tertiary sectors,
based on local resources and local requirements. These include
processing industries, handlooms and handicrafts. Again, in most
villages, there is scope for tailoring and ready-made garments,
chemist shops, woodcraft, country tiles, general store etc. In
addition, in the villages of a reasonable size, other business/service
ventures like flour milling, motor rewinding, cycle repair etc. could
also be promoted under IRDP.
The artisans in the rural areas, despite their rich heritage and skills,
largely belong to the poverty group. The scheme for Supply of
improved toolkits to rural artisans is directed to this particular target
group.
There are certain areas in the country that have a very poor banking
infrastructure. The areas of Northeast and some parts of Jammu &
Kashmir fall under this category. Attention would be given to
evolving innovative strategies and programmes to take care of the
unbanked areas.
131
The DRDA's agenda for operation would not be limited only to the
achievement of physical targets, but also to ensure the quality of the
programme and realisation of intended benefits for the targeted poor
beneficiaries.
The scheme contains all essential features of the three schemes and
is operative since 1st December, 1997 in all urban towns in India.
Among other components of the scheme, the following are the two
components of Urban Self-Employment Programme (USEP) where
credit from banks is involved:
(vii) Income Criteria: Each member of the Group should fulfil the
urban poverty norms as per official methodology as decided
by the Planning Commission. The beneficiaries under SJSRY
will be identified on the basis of monthly per capita income
and not on the basis of annual family income.
Rate of Interest: Loans under the scheme will carry interest as per
the directives on interest rates issued by Reserve Bank of India
from time to time.
** Monthly expenditure on training per trainee, including material cost, trainer's fees, other
miscellaneous expenses to be incurred by training institution, as well as monthly stipend to trainee,
may vary depending upon the trade and duration of training, subject to the minimum stipend of
Rs.100/- per month and Rs.230/- per month as training cost respectively.
145
Objectives
Strategy
Rs. 5,000 crore has been kept to meet the cash component of wage
and material cost.
147
The balance of wages will be paid in cash so that they are assured
of the notified minimum wages.
Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) can take up works as per the felt
need of particular areas.
10% of the foodgrains allocated under the SGRY earmarked for the
Special Component, which is about 5 lakh tonnes of foodgrains.
Ban on Contractors
the works to be taken at the District level while the Panchayat Samitis
will be responsible for the preparation and approval of their own Plans. In
respect of the works to be taken up at Samiti level. The Gram Panchayats
will be responsible for preparation of their own plans, which are to be
approved by the Gram Sabha. The Gram Panchayats can take up any
work with the approval of the respective Gram Sabhas. No financial limit
has been proposed as several States have already delegated powers to the
Gram Panchayats and it would be left to the State Government to
prescribe the same in the light of prevailing delegation of powers. The
works will need to be approved and incorporated in the Annual Action
Plan, as approved by the Gram Sabha.
Works to be Taken Up
Works Prohibited
Total
Total
Release Other
Year Stream OB Available
(Centre Receipts
Funds
+State)
2001-02 Ist 822.96 596.24 1175.00 2605.54 750.43 170928 94593 16.93
Objectives
The basic object of the SGSY is to bring the assisted poor families
(Swarozgaris) above the poverty line by providing them income-
generating assets through a mix of bank credit and government subsidy.
The programme aims at establishing a large number of micro enterprises
in rural areas based on the ability of the poor and potential of each area.
Salient Features
key activity. The banks and other financial institutions have to be closely
associated and involved in preparing these project reports, so as to avoid
delay in sanctioning of loans and to ensure the adequacy of financing.
Selection of the activities has to be done with the approval of the
Panchayat Samitis at the block level and District Rural Development
Agency/Zilla Parishad at the district level These key activities should
preferably be taken up in activity clusters so that the backward and
forward linkages may effectively be established and the economies of
large scale production may be reaped. It is desired that a major share of
the assistance to be provided under the SGSY should be for activity
clusters.
Target Group
Families below the Poverty Line (BPL) in rural areas constitute the
target group of the SGSY. Within the target group, special safeguards
have been provided to vulnerable sections, by way of reserving 50%
benefits for SCs/STs, 40% for women, 15% for minorities and 3% for
disabled persons.
Financial Assistance
The SGSY also seeks to promote multiple credit rather than a one-
time credit 'injection'. The credit requirements of the Swarozgaris need to
be carefully assessed. The Swarozgaris are allowed and, in fact,
encouraged to increase credit intake, over the years.
Training of Swarozgaris
Monitoring
(i) Training.
(ii)Infrastructure.
(k) An Amount up to Rs. Five Lakh annually may be spent from the
funds available under the scheme on Management of
Professional Inputs related to marketing research, value
addition or products diversification or any other input which
would facilitate the marketing of produce.
(vi) For individual loans upto Rs.50,000 and group loans upto
Rs.5.00 lakhs, the assets created out of bank loan would be
hypothecated to the bank as primary security. In cases where
163
Utilisation of funds
Economic Upliftment
Social Upliftment
SHGs
carried out. SHGs getting active support from the NGOs and other
community-based organisations were found to be doing better in
their selected economic activities. In most of the States, especially
in Northern States, the influential persons in the village were found
to own a group.
Recommendations
Keeping in view the problems faced under the SGSY, the study calls
for certain recommendations:
Banks
Facilitating Agencies
Gram Panchayat
Marketing
(i) Women
% of Live
Live Total Register of
Year Registration Placement Register Live Woman to
of Register Total Live
Women Register
2001 1540.8 31.5 10884.8 41995.9 25.9
2002 1343.1 25.9 10649.5 41171.2 25.9
2003 1448.8 26.7 10752.3 41388.7 26.0
2004 1551.5 24.5 10711.5 40457.6 26.5
2005 1606.9 32.4 10605.6 39347.8 27.0
2006 1281.9 17.4 11305.5 40675.7 27.8
(Jan-June)
Source: Report of Task Force on Employment Opportunities, Planning Commission, Government of
India.
169
Years
Category Activity
1994 2004
Scheduled Caste Registration 7.05 7.19
Placement 0.19 0.16
Live Register 66.28 64.70
Scheduled Tribe Registration 3.47 2.78
Placement 0.08 0.08
Live Register 23.10 22.18
Other Backward Registration 9.23 9.52
Clases Placement 0.17 0.14
Live Register 82.32 82.05
Source: Report of Task Force on Employment Opportunities, Planning Commission,
Government of India.
Coaching-Cum-Guidance Centers
This scheme was started with effect from February 2004, with a
view to provide computer training to SC/ST educated job seekers
registered with employment exchanges through outsourcing training
facilities. The training of six months duration is arranged at many centres
and is coordinated by respective Centres of the DGE&T located at these
places. During 2004-05 and 2005-06, 467 and 518 SC/ST candidates
respectively were imparted training under the scheme. During the 2006-
07, 672 candidates were imparted training.
Employment Exchanges
Registration 11790
Placement 1150
Live Register 111927
Source: Report of Task Force on Employment Opportunities, Planning Commission,
Government of India.
Sl.
Description
No.
1 No. of Clients at 14 19 60 - 4 97
beginning of 2006
2 No. of Clients 1950 2829 15226 26 659 20690
Admitted during
Jan-July 2006
3 No. of Clients 1947 2758 15030 24 650 20409
Evaluated during
Jan-July 2006
4 No. of Clients who 2 29 83 - 4 118
left the Centre
without
Completing
evaluation
5 No. of Clients still 15 61 173 2 9 260
under evaluation at
the end of 2006
(Jan-July)
6 No. of Clients 462 1347 4322 11 139 6281
rehabilitated during
Jan-July 2006
Source: Report of Task Force on Employment Opportunities, Planning Commission,
Government of India.
At the end of August, 2006, there were 235 disabled soldiers and
2344 dependants awaiting employment assistance through the Ex-
Servicemen Cell.
Minorities