Hydropower Module For Holistic Exam
Hydropower Module For Holistic Exam
Hydropower Module For Holistic Exam
WOLKITE UNIVERSITY
HYDROPOWER I and II
PREPARED BY
1 DAWIT GIRMA (B.sc)
BEDASSA DESSALEGN (M.sc)
2 GEMACHU SHUNIYE (B.sc)
3 MELKA LEMA (B.sc)
February, 2017
Wolkite, Ethiopia
HYDROPOWER ENGINEERING
Contents
1. INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................................................. 3
1.1 Sources of Energy ................................................................................................................................... 3
Energy – Physical Bases and Measuring Units ..................................................................................................... 3
2 Hydropower and Its Developemnt ................................................................................................................... 5
2.1 Advantages and Disadvantage of Hydropower .............................................................................................. 5
2.2 Hydropower Potential and Its Development in Ethiopia ................................................................................ 5
3 Estimation of Water Power Potential............................................................................................................... 6
3 1 Water Power Potential ................................................................................................................................. 6
3 3 Load Predictions and Demand Assessment ................................................................................................. 11
4.0- Classification and Types of Hydropower Development ............................................................................... 15
4.1 Classification and Basis ......................................................................................................................... 15
4.2 Site Selection, Layouts and Arrangements:.................................................................................................. 18
4 3 Storage and Pondage .................................................................................................................................. 20
5. Water Conveyance Structurer................................................................................................................... 23
5.1 Intakes and Head Race ............................................................................................................................... 23
5.2 Water Hammer, Surge Tanks and Forebays ................................................................................................. 58
5.3 PENSTOCK ............................................................................................................................................ 73
6 Hydraulic Machines (Hydraulic turbines and their selection ........................................................................... 82
6.1 General ...................................................................................................................................................... 82
6.2 Classification ........................................................................................................................................ 82
6.3 Characteristics of Turbines .................................................................................................................... 83
6.4 Procedure in preliminary selection of Turbines ..................................................................................... 86
6.5 Runaway Speed.......................................................................................................................................... 88
6.6 Turbine scroll case ................................................................................................................................ 88
6.7 Draft Tubes .......................................................................................................................................... 90
6.8 Cavitation in Turbine & Turbine Setting ...................................................................................................... 92
7. POWER PLANT STATIONS: Conventional type of Power Stations ................................................................ 95
7.1 COMPONENTS OF HYDROPOWER PROJECTS ................................................................................................ 95
7.2 POWER HOUSE ............................................................................................................................................ 96
8. UNDER GROUND POWER HOUSE .............................................................................................................. 108
8 .1 Location of underground power stations ............................................................................................. 108
8.2 Arrangements of underground power stations....................................................................................... 109
8.3 Comparing above–ground and underground power house stations (Basics for.............................................. 111
comparison of power station alternatives)........................................................................................................ 111
8.4 The functions of the powerhouse complex ............................................................................................ 112
8.5 The power House complex ................................................................................................................... 112
8.6 Overall Plant layout ............................................................................................................................. 113
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Sources of Energy
The following two major sources of power generation may be identified on the basis of present day importance:
a) Conventional sources
i) Thermal power
ii) Hydropower
iii) Thermo-nuclear power
b) Unconventional sources
i) Tidal power
ii) Solar power
iii) Geothermal power
iV)Wind power
V) Wave power
Vi) Depression (solar) power
Energy – Physical Bases and Measuring Units
Derivation:
Energy can be described as potential for work, which may be withdrawn if needed. The source for any kind of
energy on earth is the sun. This is also valid for nuclear and fossil fuel when taking into account the genesis of
the earth.
Physical Term Unit
Force = mass x acceleration kg .m
2
N (ewton)
s
force x dis tan ce N .m J (oule)
Work
power x time J
s J W .s
s
W att
kg .m m Joule
work / time .
Power s2 s s
force x velocity
K M G T P E Prefix symbol
Kilo mega Giga Tera Peta exa Prefix
103 106 109 1012 1015 1018 Factor by which the unit is
multiplied
Table 1.3 Internationally Recommended Prefixes for SI Units
According to Ministry of Mines and Energy, in 1990 the energy total requirement in Ethiopia was estimated at
177.6 TWh per year of which 76.1% from wood, 16.1% agricultural by-product, 5.3% from fuel oil and 1.1%
from electricity, 0.8% from charcoal and 0.6% through others. The energy is used in the sectors of domestic in
the town and rural areas, industry, service, agriculture and transport.
From the available stream flow data, one can obtain flow duration curve of the stream for a given site by plotting the
discharge against the percentage duration of the time for which it is available. Similarly, power duration curve can
be plotted since power is directly proportional to the discharge and available head.
Average flow
January December
Fig.3.1: Stream flow hydrograph
Discharge Q (m 3/S)
Power (Kw)
0 100%
Percent of time for flows equaled or exceeded
Figure 3.2 Flow\Power duration curve (Power scale multiplying factor = 9.81 η.H)
Potential power resources can be characterized by values according to the discharge taken as a basis of computation.
The conventional discharges are Q100, Q95, Q50, Qm. Thus we have,
i) Minimum potential power designated Pp100, computed from the minimum flow that is available for 100% of the
time (365 days or 8760 hrs.)
ii) Small potential power computed from the flow available for 95% of the time.This represented by Pp 95
iii) Median potential power is computed from the flow available for 50% of time. This is represented by Pp 50.
iv) Mean potential power is computed from the average of mean yearly flows for a period of 10 to 30 years. This is
designated as Ppm and is also known as gross power potential.
Therefore, technically available power Pa = 0.56 Pp 50. The multiplying factor depends up on the type of
development. i.e. run-of-river plant, high head plant, etc.
Nestruck also suggested that a coefficient of 2.5 to be used for estimating the potential average water power from the
95% potential water power i.e. Pp 50 = 2.5 Pp 95.
Waterpower is also characterized by annual values of potential energy in a river i.e. by quantities of work expressed
in Kilowatt hors & named as E95, E50, Em, etc.
The upper value of net power capable of being developed technically is computed from the potential waterpower by
introducing reduction factors to account for losses in conveyance & in energy conversion.
The power demand is defined as the total load, which consumers choose, at any instant of time, to connect to the
supplying power system.
Load curve
Peak Load
Average Load
Load (MW)
Base Load
0 6 12 18 24
Figure 3.3: Definition Sketch of Load Curve
Maximum demand determines the size of Time
the plant and its cost.
Highest instantaneous value of demand is, strictly speaking, the peak load or peak demand. Generally, however,
peak load is defined as that carried at intensity greater than 4/3 times the average load intensity.
Base Load is the total load continuously exceeded, where as the average load is the area under the curve divided by
the time.
Load factor is the ratio of average load to the peak load and is expressed as a daily, weakly, monthly or yearly
value. The area under a load curve is energy (KWh) and it can be plotted to obtain energy consumption curve. Thus
the load factor can also be defined as:
Load factor - gives an idea of degree of utilization of capacity. Thus an annual load factor of say 0.4 indicates that
the machines are producing only 40% of their yearly maximum production capacity.
e.g.- If a plant with capacity of 100 MW produces 6,000,000 KWh operating for 100 hrs, its capacity factor will be
The capacity factor for hydroelectric plant is generally b/n 0.25 & 0.75.
:. If the peak load = plant capacity, then capacity factor = load factor. If the plant is not used to its full capacity, then
load factor ≠ capacity factor.
Thus in the above example if the max. load was 75 MW instead of 100 MW then
Firm Power
0% 100%
Figure 3.4: Definition Sketch of Firm Power
Area under load duration curve = total energy production during the period. Thus
Firm Power: Also called primary power is the power which always ensured to a consumer at any hour of the day
and is thus completely dependable power. Such a power corresponds to the minimum stream flow and is available
for all times.
Secondary Power
Firm Power
0% 100%
(without storage)
Power is needed for a variety of purposes, such as domestic, commercial, industrial, municipal, agricultural,
public transport etc. The energy demand (local, regional, transregional) is subject to considerable temporal
fluctuations. These variations could be from hour to hour within a day, from day to day within a week/month,
from month to month within a year, etc.
These seasonal fluctuations depend on:
- Weather, season;
- Vacation times;
- Cyclical business activity.
Daily fluctuations are due to:
- Rhythm of work time and free time;
- Weather;
- Traffic.
A typical load curve, daily load curve is shown in Figure 3.7.
Load (MW)
Day-time Night-time
6 1 1 2 6
Fig. 3.8 Typical Daily Time (hrs)
2 Load Curve 8 4
At certain times the demand may reach the highest value, known as the peak-load. This maximum demand
usually determines the size of a plant. Generally, the peak-load is defined as that part of the load carried at
intensity greater than 4/3 times the mean load intensity.
To cover the fluctuating energy demand, the following types of power plants are interconnected to each others
and work together:
- Base load power stations (coal, oil, nuclear and run-of-river scheme power stations);
- Average load power stations (temporary, gas and reservoir power stations);
- Peak load power stations (pumped storage and peak load hydro power stations).
Base load power stations having high utilization times, they produce electric energy on a very economical basis.
The energy prime costs of peak load power stations are higher due to shorter utilization times; their emphasis lies
on instant availability. These differences affect considerably the price of base load and peak load power.
Load Prediction
For the installation of a new power plant or for the expansion of the existing power plant, it is necessary to
estimate the total amount of load that would be required to be met for various purposes. The economics of the
installation or expansion of a power plant calls for the correct prediction or forecasting of the power demand.
Load forecasting may be done either for short-term (< 5 years), or medium-term (around 10 years), or long-term
(> 20 years) periods. The short-term forecasting is usually done for operation planning of existing power plants,
while the medium-term forecast is the basis for expansion program of power generation facilities. The long-term
forecast helps in the formulation of the country‟s perspective plan for power generation.
Each of the forecasting methods uses a different approach to determine electricity demand during a specific year
in a particular place. Each forecasting method is distinctive in its handling of the four basic forecast ingredients:
the mathematical expressions of the relationship between power demand and the factors which influence or
affect it – the functions; the factors which actually influence the power demand (population, income, price, etc.)
– the independent variables; power demand itself – the dependent variables; and how much power demand
changes in response to population, income, price, etc., changes – the elasticities.
Trend Analysis:
Trend analysis extends past growth rates of power demand into the future. It focuses on past changes or
movements in demand and uses them to predict future changes in the demand.
The advantage of trend analysis is that it is simple, quick and inexpensive to perform. It is useful when there is
no enough data to use more sophisticated methods or when time and funding do not allow for a more elaborate
approach.
The disadvantage of trend analysis is that it produces only one result – future power demand. It doesn‟t help
analyze why power demand behaves the way it does, and it provides no means to accurately measure how
changes in energy prices or government policies, for instance, influence the demand.
End-Use Analysis:
The basic idea of end-use analysis is that the demand for power depends on what it is used for (the end-use). For
instance, by studying historical data to find out how much power is used for individual electrical appliances in
homes, then multiplying that number by the projected number of appliances in each home and multiplying again
by the projected number of homes, an estimate of how much power will be needed to run all household
appliances in a geographical area during any particular year in the future can be determined.
Using similar techniques for power used in business and industry, then adding up the totals for residential,
commercial, and industrial sectors, a total forecast of power demand can be derived.
The advantage of end-use analysis is that it identifies exactly where power goes and how much is used for each
purpose.
The disadvantage of the end-use analysis is that it assumes a constant relationship between power and end-use,
for example, power used per appliance. But, in actual case, energy saving technology or energy prices will
undoubtedly change with time, and the relationship will not remain constant. End-use analysis also requires
extensive data.
Econometric Analysis:
Econometric analysis uses economics, mathematics, and statistics to forecast power demand. It is a combination
of trend analysis and end-use analysis, but it does not make the trend analyst‟s assumption that future power
demand can be projected based on past demand. Moreover, unlike end-use method, it can allow for variations in
the relationship between power input and end-use.
Econometric analysis uses complex mathematical equations to show past relationships between demand and the
factors which influence the demand. For instance, an equation can show how power demand in the past reacted
to population growth, price changes, etc. For each influencing factor, the equation can show whether the factor
caused an increase or decrease in a power demand. The equation is then tested and fine tuned to make sure that it
is a reliable a representation as possible of the past relationships. Once this is done, projected values of demand-
influencing factors (population, income, prices) are put in to the equation to make the forecast.
The advantage of econometric analysis is that it provides detailed information on future levels of power demand,
why future power demand increases or decreases, and how power demand is affected by all the various factors.
In addition, it is flexible and useful for analyzing load growth under different scenarios.
The disadvantage of econometric forecasting is the assumption that the changes in the power demand caused by
changes in the factors influencing that demand remain the same in the forecast period as in the past. However,
this constant elasticity assumption is hard to justify in reality.
Note:
Load forecasts should be interpreted as rough indications of the reasonable range of possible outcomes of
power growth, rather than precise computations of future power consumption.
Often it is necessary to develop a range of load growth projections that reflect the uncertainty associated
with many of the factors that influence load growth. Then, the mid-range forecast will be used as the basis
for planning and the high and low growth scenarios will be utilized for sensitivity studies.
Example 1:
Given: Q=50 m³/s Find: Power, P
H=5 m Work, A for t=7,000h/year
tot=0.8
Example 2:
Given: Two stations sharing a common load
- one is base load station
- the other is stand by station
Base load station characteristics:
Installed capacity = 25 MW
Yearly output = 125*106 KWh
Take a peak of 22.5 MW
Standby station characteristics
Installed capacity = 30 MW
Yearly output = 10.5*106 KWh
Peak load taken by stand by station = 15 MW
Station works for 2500 hrs/year
Determine (1) Annual load factor for both
(2) Plant use factor for both
(3) Capacity factor for both
Hydropower
Load (MW)
Nuclear
Thermal
Time (months)
Figure 4.1: Place of hydropower in a power system.
3) Classification based on plant capacity
Classification based on plant capacity changes with time as technology improves. Thus we have the following
classification according to Mossonyi, and present day trend classification.
According to Mossonyi Present day classification
i) Midget plant up to 10 KW i) Micro hydrpower < 5 MW
ii) Low capacity < 1000KW ii) Medium plant 5 to 100 MW
iii) Medium capacity < 10,000KW iii) High capacity 100 to 1,000 MW
iv) High capacity > 10,000KW iv) Super plant above 1,000 MW
a) Block power plant b) Twin block plant c)Island plant d) pier head plant e) Submersible
plant
Figure 4.2: Run-off-River Plant Arrangement
Another way of classifying is as pure pumped storage scheme and mixed plant scheme (total
generation>pumping and higher reservoir on a natural system).
The most important basis of pumped storage plant is the relative arrangements of turbines and pumps
- four units -pump, motor, generator, turbine
- three units- pump, generator, turbine
- two units-generator, turbine>reversible pump-turbine installation
Storage is provide to balance seasonal fluctuation by building reservoir dams. Pondage is provided through
balancing reservoir or forebay for short term fluctuations (daily or hourly)
1.- Reservoir (storage) capacity
Reservoir capacity is determined by means of mass curve procedure of computing the necessary capacity
corresponding to a given inflow and demand pattern. Reservoir capacity has to be adjusted to account for the dead
storage, evaporation losses and carry over storage.
Storage (1)
Dam (2)
Diversion (6)
Dead storage
This is a storage capacity of the reservoir provided to accommodate the deposition of silt in the reservoir. It is
expected that the dead storage space will eventually fill up with sediment at which time one says the dam has served
its full purpose.The life of a reservoir is dependent on the silting capacity of the reservoir. Provisions for flushing out
silt through deep seated bottom outlets/sluices is made in most dams. However this has a limited effectiveness.
Evaporation Loss
Provision should be made for evaporation since it is an important loss item actual evaporation rate depends upon
location & meteorological factors. In arid and semi-arid regions at least 2 to 2.5m of depth should be added as a rule
of thumb.
Sometimes it may be required to carry over some of the live storage to the next year as a safety measure. This carry
over storage is determined by analyzing the storage requirement for a sequence of two or three consecutive dry
years.
2) Pondage Capacity
Pondage capacity is determination for varying inflow is similar to storage capacity determination.
If hourly inflows for a typical day are known, one can calculate the average hourly requirement and determine the
total maximum cumulative departures from the average over a 24 hour period. This will then be the pondage needed
to equalize the daily flow fluctuations
Ground/bottom flow
2. The effectiveness of the intake in preventing sediment entry increases with the sharpness of the bend.
3. Intakes from straight reaches can be made favorable by artificially forcing the water to follow a curved
[path.
Weir
Bend
Canal
Gate
v) Shaft intakes
This is a vertical shaft that carries water to the penstock tunnel. It consists of the following.
The entrance structure with trash rack and rounded inlet.
The vertical shaft followed by an elbow and transition connecting the shaft with the tunnel.
The intake gate (cylindrical) and sometimes a stop-log closure.
It can obstruct flow along the conveyance structures, interrupting power generation or causing the water
to overflow and possibly undermine the structures.
It can cause rapid deterioration of the penstock or turbine or cause a catastrophic failure, such as rupture
of the penstock through a sudden blockage of flow through the nozzle (in the case of impulse turbines)
or fracture of the runner blades (in the case of reaction turbines).
It is therefore essential that the quantity of debris which enters the conveyance system of a hydropower scheme
be minimized. This can be achieved with the help of trash racks and skimmers.
i) Trash Racks:
A trash rack intercepts the entire flow and removes any large debris, whether it is floating, suspended, or swept
along the bottom. Frequently, it is located in the intake structure to prevent debris from entering the water
conveyance system. It can also be placed just before the inlet to the penstock to remove smaller debris as well as
other trashes which may have entered the water conveyance system downstream of the intake.
A trash rack is made up of one or more panels, each generally fabricated of a series of evenly spaced parallel
metal bars. The bars are parallel and evenly spaced because a rake is commonly used to clear the debris off the
rack. In this case, it is essential that the teeth of the rake mesh into the parallel bars without binding so that the
rake can be pulled along the bars easily to scrape off accumulated debris.
Trash racks can be installed by sliding them into grooves in the concrete walls of the intake, canal, or forebay
structure. They should be removable and not permanently set in concrete.
Bars on a trash rack before the inlet to the penstock should be spaced no closer than is necessary to remove
debris which might be detrimental to the turbine‟s operation. Otherwise, head losses may be high and the rack
may fill up quickly with debris. With a Pelton turbine, the space between bars usually is not more than half the
nozzle diameter (or a quarter, if spear valve is used) to prevent the nozzle from choking. For Francis turbines, the
space between bars should not exceed the distance between the runner vanes.
The approach velocity of flow should be kept within such limits that it will not cause damage to the rack
structure. A design approach velocity of 0.5 m/s is usually used. If a trash rack is located immediately in front of
the inlet to a penstock and the penstock velocities are significantly higher than 0.5 m/s, the trash rack can be built
in a circular area to increase the area of the trash rack and correspondingly decreases velocity through it.
Cleaning of the trash racks can be performed either manually (for small schemes) using manual rake or
mechanically (for large schemes) using automatic cleaning machines. The trash rack is usually placed vertical or
near vertical (< 25o from the vertical). Placing the trash racks in an inclined position makes the cleaning easy
apart from giving less resistance to flow.
Clogging of racks is objectionable on account of the operational trouble and loss of energy production involved,
and of the unbalanced load created on the rack causing partial or total damage thereof. Allowing for partial
clogging, racks are generally designed to withstand a head ranging from 1 to 2 m under normal conditions and
from 4 to 5 m under exceptional circumstances.
ii) Skimmers:
A skimmer wall is an obstruction placed at the water surface, usually at an angle to the stream flow which skims
floating debris from the passing water. If the water level changes markedly as, for example, at the intake of
stream, the skimmer can be a floating piece of timber secured at both ends. If changes in water level are small, a
fixed skimmer can be used.
Because some debris usually passes under the skimmer, a trash rack is still necessary. However, a skimmer
reduces the frequency with which the trash rack has to be cleaned.
Skimmer walls are made, for the most part, of reinforced concrete with a service bridge on top. They are
designed usually for a horizontal pressure of 1000 kg/m2 acting on the submerged surface.
Entrance Losses
These comprises of :
a) Loss due to change in direction is given by:
2
V2 Vf
he C 5.1
2g 2g
Vf
Figure 5.8 Losses due to change of flow
direction
V
b) The losses due to sudden contraction of the area at the inlet section is given by:
V2
he K 5.2
2g
In cases of the inlet having a sill constructed with curved abutments and piers, the head loss, he, is given by:
V2
he 0.3 5.3
2g
V2 V f2
Therefore, maximum total entrance loss = 1.3 C (5.4)
2g 2g
Rack Losses:
There are numerous expressions available for predicting head loss across trash racks. One such expression (after
Kirschmer’s) is:
4/3 2
t Va
hr K t sin 5.5
b 2g
Where, Kt is trash rack loss coefficient (a function of bar shape), t is bar thickness, b is spacing between bars, Va
is approach velocity, and is angle of inclination of bars with the horizontal.
Gate Losses:
Head loss due to gates (at part gate opening) is given by:
2
1 Q
hg 5.6
2 g C d A
Where, Q is flow in the canal or conduit, A is area of gate opening, and Cd is discharge coefficient which varies
between 0.62 and 0.83.
Air entrainment is due to development of vortices and also due to partial gate opening that facilitates hydraulic
jump formation. Effects of air entrainment are: Additional head losses, reduction in discharge and drop in
efficiency of turbines. Minimizing vortex formation and avoiding hydraulic jump formation help in preventing
air entrainment.
A vortex which forms at the inlet to power conduit occasionally can cause troubles by itself. It can induce loss of
turbine efficiency, possible cavitation, surging caused by the formation and dissipation of vortices, and flow
reduction as air replaces part of the water through the inlet. It can also draw floating debris into the conduit.
Thus, it is necessary to prevent formation of vortices at intakes and air entrainment.
Designing for a low velocity into the conduit and increasing submergence of the inlet can help prevent the
formation of vortices. Flow approaching the intake asymmetrically is more prone to vortex formation than
symmetrical flow. It is therefore important that flows upstream of the inlet area be as straight and uniform as
possible.
Another remedy to vortex formation is provision of a floating raft or baffle which disrupts the angular
momentum of the water near the surface.
5.1.1.7 Inlet Aeration
Intakes normally have a bulk head gate at the front and a control gate inside on the downstream side. An air vent
is always provided just downstream of a control gate. The functions are:
i) to nullify vacuum effect, which could be created when the penstock is drained after control gate closure.
ii) Intake gates operate under conditions of balanced pressure on both sides of the gate. Thus the conduit is
required to be filled with water through a by-pass pipe. The entrapped air is therefor driven out through
the air vent.
Qa
Air vent
Control gate
Bulk head
In order to satisfy the requirement for a good hydraulic performance the basin is divided into three main zones:
inlet zone, settling zone, and outlet zone.
Inlet Zone:
The main function of the inlet is to gradually decrease the turbulence and avoid all secondary currents in the
basin. This is achieved by decreasing the flow velocity through gradually increasing the flow cross-section, i.e.,
by providing gradual expansion of the width and depth (see figure 5.12).
To achieve optimum hydraulic efficiency and effective use of the settling zone, the inlet needs to distribute the
flow uniformly over the cross-section of the basin. To achieve uniform flow distribution, the following
techniques, in addition to the provision of gradual expansion, may be adopted at the inlet zone:
Use of submerged weir
Use of baffles
Use of slotted walls
B
L
Flushing flume
A A
Power canal
W
Flushing sluice
Power canal
Flushing flume
Section A-A
W W
Collection tank
Figure 5.12: Settling basin Flushing flume
a) For continuous flushing b) For intermittent flushing
Settling Zone:
This is the main part of the basin where settling of the suspended sediment is supposed to take place. The
SectionB-B
dimensions of this zone can be determined through calculations (see sections below).
Outlet Zone:
This is a kind of transition provided following the settling zone to facilitate getting back the flow into the
conveyance system with the design velocity by gradually narrowing the width and depth. The outlet transition
may be more abrupt than the inlet transition.
Note: The cross-section of a settling basin is usually tapered at the bottom forming a sediment-collecting
flume, built with a gradient in the direction of flow.
1. Exploration of sediment conditions, involving the quantitative and qualitative analysis of sediment carried
by the river. As regards to wear of the hydraulic machinery, suspended sediment is of significance, since the
bulk of the bed-load moving along the bottom can be effectively prevented from entering the canal by a
well-designed intake.
2. On the basis of theory and practical experience, the necessary degree of removal should be determined.
Usually, the sensitivity of plant installations, particularly the hydraulic machines, requires that a marginal
(critical) grain size dcr is not exceeded. Generally, Francis and Pelton turbines are subject to greater wear and
tear ( form of blades, higher flow velocities) than Kaplan turbines with comparably bigger discharges and
lower heads. Consequently, the sand trap/settling basin must be dimensioned in such a way that grains with
diameters bigger or equal to dl (limit particle size) must be settled. It should be noted, however, that no
standard values or specifications have yet been developed
For the limit particle sizes mentioned above, the lower limits should be used if the sediment fractions contain
sharp-edged quartzite grains.
Degree of removal
100
80
% Sieve passing
40
20 dl
0
0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100
Particle size (mm) (Log scale)
Instead of using the limit particle size, the degree of removal is frequently defined by the removal ratio,
which is the ratio of concentrations after and before settling, expressed in percentages. If the concentration
of the raw water is C, and that of clarified water is specified as the permissible value Cp, the required
removal ratio is obtained as:
Cp
R 100 % 5.10
C
In the above example (Fig.5.13), the removal ratio is 60%
3. Having determined the basic data as suggested in above, one can proceed to establish settling velocity of the
smallest fraction, i.e., of the limit particle size to be removed. This can be established theoretically (Stoke's
law) or by experiments (Sudry graph).
Figure 5.14. Settling velocity in stagnant water plotted against the density of silty water and the particle
diameter (After L.Sudry)
The so-called horizontal-flow settling system is usually applied at power developments. For this system the
dimensions of the settling basin may in principle be determined by two computational methods depending
on whether to neglect or to take into account the turbulence effect.
Denoting the depth of the basin by D and its width by W, the discharge passing through the basin is:
Q W DV 5.11
Where, V is the flow-through velocity.
The second equation expressing the relation between the settling velocity , the depth of the basin D, and the
settling time t is:
t
D
5.12
Finally, the length of the basin will be governed by the consideration that water particles entering the basin and
sediment particles conveyed by them with equal horizontal velocity should only reach the end of the basin after a
period longer than the settling time. Thus, even the smallest settling particle may reach the bottom of the basin
within the settling zone. In other words, the retention period should not be shorter than the settling time. The
required length of the basin is thus:
L V t 5.13
Eliminating t from the last two equations (equation 5.12 and 5.13), two relations can be established between the
six parameters governing the hydraulic design:
Q W DV
DV (5.14)
L
Obviously a solution of the problem is not possible unless four of the six quantities are known.
The discharge Q is usually known. The settling velocity is defined by the initially specified degree of removal
and, as mentioned previously, can be established by calculation (see equation 5.19/20) or experimentally (Figure
5.14). The highest permissible flow-through velocity V should also be specified, considering that particles once
settled should not picked up again. According to Camp, the critical flow-through velocity is estimated from:
V a dl m / s 5.15
Where, d is the equivalent diameter of the smallest sediment particle to be settled in mm and a is a constant
given as:
a 0.36 , for d l 1 mm
a 0.44 , for 0.1 mm d l 1 mm
a 0.51, for d l 0.1 mm
[Modern tendency is to use V =0.4 to 0.6 m/s]
Depth of basin should be specified considering that long and/or wide basins are economical than deep ones. The
depth of settling basins in waterpower projects is generally between 1.5 and 4 m with flow-through velocities not
higher than 0.5 m/s. Hence W and L can be computed.
Check
From Q=DWV V=Q/WD
And from L=V*t V=L/t
By using a lower settling velocity , equation (5.14) obviously yields greater values for the length of the
basin. The reduction in the settling velocity is related to the flow-through velocity by:
V (m / s ) 5.16
The coefficient may be computed from:
0.132
( 5.17)
D
Accordingly, the second row of equation (5.14) can be modified for the settling length as:
D 3 / 2V
L
DV
1/ 2 (m) 5.18
V D 0.132V
This shows a larger settling basin is required, when compared with simple settling theory. In the computation if
the result provides negative value in the denominator, it indicates that no settling takes place in the basin; hence
dimension should be modified.
Theoretically, the following equation can be used to estimate the settling velocity:
1/ 2
4 gd s w
5.19
3 C d w
Where, d and s, respectively, are the diameter and specific weight of the sediment particle, w is specific weight
of water, and Cd is the coefficient of drag and is a function of particle Reynolds number R = d/, being the
kinematic viscosity of the water.
Figure 5.15: Drag coefficient of spheres as a function of particles Reynolds number (note =v)
The drag coefficient in the Stokes range (R < 0.1) is given by Cd = 24/R, and equation (5.19) can be modified for
Stokes range as:
gd 2 s w
5.20
18 w
There are different techniques for removing sediment deposits in settling basins:
Manual or mechanical removal of deposited sediments after the basin is de-watered.
Flushing of deposited sediments through an outlet provided at the bottom, often called flushing sluice.
When the water flow through the basin is halted, it will cause interruption in power generation. However, this is
not an acceptable solution, and instead a continuous power generation should be facilitated during cleaning of
settling basins. Continuous operation can be ensured by one of the following methods:
i) Providing two or more parallel basins (some can be cleaned while others are operating).
ii) Adopting continuous flushing, by admitting excess water into the basin. An inflow exceeding the water
demand by about 10 % may be admitted continuously into the basin and used for flushing the sediment
accumulating at the bottom.
The tracing of a power canal should closely follow the contour lines of the terrain. Based on the topographic
conditions, a canal may be constructed through cuts, over fills, and in cuts-and-fills as shown in Figure below.
A very important feature of an open canal is its vulnerability to damage from such sources as landslide and rock
falls, and from storm water runoff crossing its path. The cost of protection from these eventualities and their
associated repair costs must be included in an estimation of the canal cost.
Canal Lining
Power canals may be lined or unlined. The lined canals are usually lined with impervious material such as
concrete, masonry, or clay.
Concrete Lining:
This is the most extensively used material in power canal lining. It is mostly used with trapezoidal cross
sections. The excavation of a canal for a thin, unreinforced concrete lining is similar to that of an earth canal.
It should be done carefully to ensure that the lining conforms closely to the desired profile when it is
completed; otherwise, the lining will require more material than expected. The foundation should be
adequately compacted and moistened before the concrete is placed. The necessity of moistening the
foundation is to prevent the sub-grade from absorbing moisture from the freshly laid concrete making it weak
and porous.
Concrete sections of a lining can be hand-formed at the site. If the side slopes exceed 1 in 1, form works may
be necessary to hold the concrete in place until it sets. The thickness of the concrete lining may range from 10
to 20 cm, depending on the quality of the concrete and the soil conditions.
In preparing concrete for lining a canal, it is important to use the minimum amount of water needed for
workability. Excess water will cause the concrete to slump and not stay on the canal side slopes. A mixture of
a 1:3:4.5 (cement : sand : gravel) volume proportion is adequate for lining a power canal.
With masonry linings, a rectangular canal section is often used. In this case, the sides of the canals are
constructed as retaining walls to counteract the lateral forces of either the earth backfill or the water within
the canal.
In the construction of a power canal lined with masonry, the excavation must allow for the thickness of the
lining. Before the lining is placed, the canal bottom and sides should be properly compacted to avoid future
settling and cracking of the lining. They should also be wetted slightly to prevent the mortar from drying too
fast.
To reduce resistance to flow and possible seepage, the masonry surface shall be plastered.
Note:
In addition to the commonly used lining materials discussed above, other materials such as
bituminous mixtures, soil-cement, wood, clay, chemical sealant, shotcrete, and impermeable
membranes are also sometimes used to line power canals
In special circumstances where the canal alignment is through a terrain having seasonally high water
table or where the soils are not freely draining, under-drainage should be provided in order to protect
the lining from damage due to uplift pressures.
Due to temperature variations and shrinkage, cracks may be developed in canal linings and may result
in appreciable leakage from the canal. In order to minimize these effects, it is necessary to provide
contraction joints in the lining at suitable intervals (usually 3 to 8 m).
Canal Design
A Chezy's equation
V C RS
Several equations are available to determine the value of C.
87
i) Bazin's formula C Where m is roughness factor
m
1
R
1
ii) Maning's Formula C R1 / 6 Where n is Maning's roughness coefficient
n
1 2 / 3 1/ 2
The Chezy-Maning equation VR S MR 2 / 3 S 1 / 2 Use Tables for M & n.
n
0.00281 1.811
41.65
iii) Kutter Formula C S n in English units
n 0.00281
1 41.65
R S
iv) The Agroskin formula C 17.72K log R
B) Forch-Heimer Formula
1
Some designers prefer this formula for V and given by: V CR 0.7 S 0.5 , C
n
Apart from the hydraulic computations, the flow velocities in the canal or other water conduits in general are
determined according to economic point of views (investments, head losses, wear and tear of material, danger of
erosion and silting). The velocity must be high enough to prevent sedimentation. It has to be low enough to
prevent bed erosion for unlined- and wear by abrasion for lined-canals.
Lowering the velocity keeps the head loss over the length of the canal to a minimum; however, it increases the
cost necessary to construct the canal as the cross-sectional area increases when the velocity lowers.
Maximum Velocities
Critical bottom velocity (w.r.t. erosion) is given by:
Strenberg: Vb 2d for d is particle size in meters, =4.43
Maximum permisible mean velocity according to Bogardi and Yen is given by:
V 22.9d m4 / 9 S s 1
Where dm is mean particle size and Ss is specific gravity of particles.
Minimum Velocities
There are various recommendations for non silting velocity
1) According to Ludin
If Vmin >0.3 m/sec, there will be no silting (for silty sediments)
Vmin >0.3 to 0.5 m/sec, there will be no silting (for sandy sediments)
R = hydraulic radius
S = bed slope
900 RS
For approximate values: G0
0 1.25
Find the actual G (sediment load ) and compare it with G0. If G > G0 there will be deposition. If G < G0, there
will be no deposition. The formulae are valid for:
1) Canal free from aquatic growth
2) Q is between 0.2 and 150 m3/s
3) V > 0.3 m/s
4) < 10 mm/sec
A semi-circular cross-section is the most efficient profile because, for a given canal slope and cross-sectional
area, it conveys the maximum flow. However, this form is impractical to excavate. It is therefore used primarily
with materials which lend themselves to this shape. Examples are prefabricated concrete, sheet metal, and wood-
stave sections.
A trapezoidal cross-section is the most widely used profile for both lined and unlined canals excavated in earth.
If the canal is unlined, the maximum side slope is set by that slope at which the material will permanently stand
under water. The magnitude of the side slope of a lined trapezoidal canal depends on the nature of the material
on which the lining will rest, but usually steeper than unlined canals. In general, it should be nearly equal to the
angle of repose of the natural soil so that no earth pressure is exerted on the back of the lining. The banks of a
lined canal resting on almost any free-draining material requires slopes not steeper than 1:1.
For a trapezoidal canal with a given side slope, the most efficient cross-section is one in which a semi-circle can
be inscribed in the wetted area. For this section, it can be shown that the length of either sloping side of the
wetted area is half its top width.
Canal material Side slope (V:H)
Firm rock 1:1/4
Fissured and disintegrated rock 1:1/2
Clay 1:3/4
Clayey loam 1:1
Loam 1:3/2
Sandy loam 1:2
Sand 1:3
Lining 1:1
Table 5.4 Suggested side slopes for trapezoidal canals
A rectangular cross-section is often most appropriate when excavation is undertaken in firm rock. It is also
commonly used when the canal incorporates properly constructed masonry walls. Use of a rectangular canal
reduces the excavation required. For the most efficient rectangular cross-section, the width of the canal is twice
the depth of the wetted area and, like a trapezoidal section, is a section in which a semi-circle can be inscribed.
Freeboard Allowance:
Freeboard is provided above the design water level for safety purposes. For earth canal the lower limit is 35 cm
and the upper limit is 140 cm. Generally the free board = [0.35+1/4h] m. Where h is depth of flow. Allowances
should be made for bank settlements. For lined canals, the top of the lining is not usually extended for the full
height of the free board. Usually it is extended to 15cm to 70cm above the design water level.
2) B.A. Etchivery gives specific seepage coefficient based on measurements on American irrigation canals.
Higher values apply for newly constructed channels.
C
3) A.N. Kostyakov (USSR): q Q q in m³/sec-km
100
Values of C
3.4
a) for soils of high permeability, C %
Q 0.5
1.9
b) for soils of moderate permeability, C %
Q 0.4
0.7
c) for soils of low permeability, C %
Q 0.3
Exercises
1. Design a settling basin for high-head power station using the simple settling theory. The basin should
serve to remove particles greater than 0.5mm diameter from the water in which the sediment is mainly
sand. Let the design discharge be 5m³/s and assume an initial value of 3.2m for the basin depth. Take the
water sediment mixture density to be =1.064
2. A power canal with a slope of 0.0001044 and R=1.76 m is unlined with coarse sand bed material.
Determine the safe velocity in the canal if the heaviest bed load in the original canal of the course is
G=0.34kg/m³. The water carries silt with an average diameter of 0.08 mm. Assume d m=2.00 mm as size
of bed material and h=2.5m.
3. Determine the seepage loss from a power canal constructed in a sandy soil of medium fineness by the
Davis and Wilson, Etchevery and Kostyakov methods discussed. The following data are given:
5.1.3.2 Tunnels
5.1.3.2.1 General
Tunnels are underground conveyance structures constructed by special tunneling methods without disturbing the
natural surface of the ground. In many modern high head plants, tunnels form an important engineering feature.
In the headrace of water conveyance sytem, tunneling is popular because of the following reasons:
i) It provides a direct and short route for the water passage thus resulting in considerable saving in cost
ii) Tunneling work can be started simultaneously at many points thus leading to quicker completion
iii) Natural land scape is not disturbed
iv) Tunneling work has become easier with development techniques of drilling and blasting and new mechanical
equipment
v) Development of rock mechanics and experimental stress analysis has given greater confidence to engineers
regarding stability of tunnels.
45 WOLLITE UNIVERSITY, CET/HWRE
HYDROPOWER ENGINEERING MODULE 2017
Tunnels of hydropower projects fall into two categories: water carrying tunnels and service tunnels.
a) Water carrying tunnels : These include head race or power tunnels, tail race tunnels or diversion tunnels.
Flows in water tunnels are usually under pressure (pipe flow), but sometimes free-flow (open channel flow)
can be experienced, especially, in tailrace tunnels. The design of free-flow tunnels follow the same
principles as used in the design of open canals.
- Head race tunnels: are tunnels that convey water to the surge tank. These are pressure tunnels
- Tail race tunnels: could be free flowing or pressure tunnels depending on the relative position of turbine
setting and tail water level.
- Diversion tunnels: are constructed for the purpose of diverting the stream flow during construction period.
Normally they are not of high pressure but should have sufficient flood carrying capacity. Such tunnels
either plugged with concrete or converted in to some use such as spillway tunnel at the completion of the
project.
In addition to the above classification tunnels may be classified on the basis of shape, alignment and design
aspects.
Alignment: A name tunnel indicates a very small bottom slopes, i.e. tunnels are aligned nearly horizontal. Shaft
is a tunnel with vertical alignment or inclined shaft when it is steeply inclined to the horizontal. It is very crucial
to investigate in detail the geology of the strata through which a tunnel would be passing. Sound, homogenous,
isotropic, and solid rock formations are the most ideal ones for tunneling work. However, such ideal conditions
are rarely present, and rather the rock mass exhibits various peculiarities. There may be folds, faults, joint planes
dipping in a particular direction, weak strata alternating with good strata, etc. Thus, the alignment of a tunnel
should be fixed keeping in view these phenomena. The alignment, for instance, should as far as possible avoid
major fracture planes.
Design Aspects: Aspects of lining, pressure condition, etc., can be considered to identify different types of
tunnels.
Lining: Lining is a protective layer of concrete, R.C. or steel on the inner surface of the tunnel and it is an
important aspect in classification of tunnels. Thus tunnels may be lined, unlined or partially lined. Tunnels in
good, sound rock may left unlined.
Pressure tunnels: are classified according to pressure head above the soffit of the tunnel. Accordingly:
In the case of low-pressure tunnels the tunnel surface may frequently be left unlined except for visible fissures.
A watertight lining is usually required for tunnels operating under medium and high heads. Seepage is more
likely to occur as the head increases, water may leak through the smallest fissures and cracks. Moreover, under
high-pressure it may penetrate the otherwise watertight rock and render it permeable.
The permissible velocity depends upon the sediment load carried by the water. The maximum values in the
above recommendation apply when the sediment is of the silt fraction. For water carrying sharp edged sand in
significant quantity, Vmax = 2 to 2.5 m/s even in lined section.
Size of tunnels cannot be reduced arbitrarily. Requirements of pass ability limit the maximum size.
Minimum size of Tunnel: Circular, 1.8 m
Rectangular, 2m x 1.6m.
Alignment:
In aligning water tunnels, the following points should be taken in to account:
Length of the tunnel: as much as possible short route should be followed
Location of surge tanks & adits: the alignment should provide convenient points for surge tanks & adits.
Rock cover (overburden): sufficient rock cover should be available along the alignment
Discontinuities: the alignment should, if possible, avoid crossing of weakness zones, joint planes, etc. If
crossing of these features is unavoidable, suitable direction of crossing should be considered.
Rock quality: good quality of rock mass should be sought in aligning the tunnel
Geometrical Shape:
The choice of the cross-sectional profile of a tunnel depends on:
Hydraulic considerations - Circular is preferable
Stability considerations - Circular is preferable
Convenience for construction - Horseshoe is preferable
Available tunneling equipment - If drilling rigs are available, a horseshoe cross-section has to be
adopted.
Longitudinal Slope:
The minimum slope for a pressure tunnel is limited on the basis of dewatering requirements. And also the
longitudinal profile of the tunnel should be such that the roof remains below the hydraulic pressure line by 1 to 2
m. Likewise, the tunneling method and the equipment employed for transportation of the excavated material (rail
or wheel transport) can limit the maximum slope possible to provide. The usual practice is to keep the slope of
power tunnel gentle till the surge tank and then steeper (even vertical) for the pressure shaft.
Flow Velocity:
The allowable velocities in tunnels depend upon whether it is lined or unlined. In unlined tunnels, a velocity of 2
to 2.5 m/s is the upper limit, while in concrete lined tunnels 4 to 5 m/s is often employed. The velocities for the
pressure shafts, which are generally steel lined, are usually higher than that in the power tunnel. The normal
range of velocities is between 5 to 8 m/s.
In the case of unlined tunnels, the entire internal water pressure is resisted by the overburden rock pressure.
Where a steep valley side constitutes the overburden above the tunnel, the rule of thumb equation, H=(0.4 to
0.8)hr has to be modified and given by:
1 r
hw L cos
w
Where L is the shortest distance between the ground surface and the studied point of the tunnel (or shaft) and is
the average inclination of the valley side with the horizontal (see figure below).
r L cos whw
hw
hr
In the case of concrete or steel lined tunnels, the linings are usually designed to carry part or full load of the
internal water pressure, and the above equations, given for unlined tunnels, are modified accordingly in
determining the required overburden depth. For detail see section on stress analysis
Head Loss:
Head losses in tunnels can be computed using Manning‟s, Darcy-Weisbach, or Hazen-Williams formulas.
lv 2
Manning formula: hf n2 4/3
R
l v2
Darcy-Weisbach formula: hf
2 g Deq
l v1.85
Hazen-Williams formula (rarely used): h f 6.84 1.17
C 1.85 Deq
Where, hf is head loss due to friction, L is tunnel length, V is mean velocity of flow, R is hydraulic radius, Deq is
equivalent diameter ( Deq 4A / ), A is area of the tunnel x-section, n is Manning‟s roughness coefficient, is
Darcy-Weisbach friction factor (can be obtained from Moody diagram), and C is Hazen-Williams roughness
coefficient.
Optimum X-section:
The optimum x-section of a tunnel or a shaft is one for which the sum of tunnel construction cost and the
economic loss due to head loss is minimum.
Total cost
Cost
Economic Construction
loss cost
X-section
For a quick initial estimate of the diameter of pressure tunnels, the empirical formula suggested by Fahlbusch
can be used:
1 Lining deigned to resist the full internal pressure without support from the surrounding rock i.e. no
load sharing.
1m
P
D
Figure 5.18: Tunnel Section
b 2
1
r
r1
r2
st
b-c
Figure 5.19: Schematic sketch of lining and displacement
st = Radial displacement of steel
If P1 = Load transferred to the rock, then P – P1 = load carried by the steel lining
Tangential stress in an annular steel lining of radius r and thickness under load (P – P1) will be:
st
P P1 D D is internal diameter
2
Unit radial strain = 2 st st E st
st
2r r st
r
st P P1 D P P1 r 2
st E st st
r 2 E st
The radially fissured annular concrete layer is subjected to an internal pressure P2
r1
P2 = P1
r2
Theoretical investigations & experiments show that
P1 r
C r1 l n 2
EC r1
The radius of the cross-section excavated in rock expands under load P2 by an amount r
1 m 1 1 m 1
r r2 P2 r1 P1
Er m Er m
Er = modulus of elasticity of the rock
1
= , where = Poisson ratio of the rock
Since
1 b 2 r st b c
1 2 r c st
1 m 1 P1 r2 p p1 r 2
1 2 r1 p1 r1 l n .
Er m Ec 1 st
r E
P1 = P , where = load distribution factor
P1= Load carried by rock.
Now, assuming r r1,
r r r m 1 Pr 2 Pr 2
1 2 P ln 2
EC r1 E r m E st E st
Simplifying & Rearranging:
E 2
1 st 1
P r r Checking purposes
E st r2 E st m 1
1 ln
E c r r1 E r r m
This equation is useful for checking purposes for a given . For designing by trial & error, is assumed & is
computed.
For carefully executed work with grouting, 1 2 = 0.5 to 1 mm. (see examples)
In this method of tunneling is used, the main equipment used is the so-called drilling jumbo or drilling rig,
which performs the main operation. The following are the main sequences to be followed during excavation of
each round:
i) Drilling ii) Charging
iii) Blasting iv) Ventilating
vi) Scaling vi) Mucking and hauling
vii) Tunnel supporting
Drilling is carried out by the percussion method. The principle is to force a drill rod with a suitable drill bit
against the tunnel face, generate a stroke in order to obtain rock spalling, then rotate the rod before it is once
again forced against the hole and a new stroke is generated. The power for the drilling thrust and rotation is
transmitted by hydraulic systems.
In tunneling, blast hole diameters of 45 to 50 mm are most common. Medium size tunnels (about 40 m2) may
require about 60 to 70 drill holes. The length of the drill holes usually varies from 3 to 5 m.
Once the drilling operation is completed, charging of the drill holes with explosives will be performed. There
are different types of explosives, the most common one being dynamite.
If the holes close to the planned contour of the tunnel are too heavily loaded with explosives, a considerable
“over-break” and a rough, uneven contour may result. This over-break greatly increases the need for scaling and
tunnel support. If the tunnel is unlined, it will also greatly increase the head loss. In order to minimize the over-
break in the walls and roof of the tunnel, reduced charges are used close to the contour.
In rock blasting the main principle is to break the rock and push the rock fragments towards a free surface. In a
tunnel the degree of confinement of the blast volume is far higher than in a quarry. In order to obtain a
satisfactory result from a tunnel blast it is, therefore, necessary to include the so-called “cut” in the blast hole
design. These consist of holes of larger diameter than the blast holes and are usually left unloaded.
After blasting the round, ventilation has to be carried out to lower the concentration of blasting fumes to a
satisfactory level. The fans are usually started just after the explosion. It is very seldom possible to enter the
working face area until 15 minutes after the blast, but this depends on the ventilation capacity.
After each blast round, scaling (removing loose rocks from the roof and walls of the tunnel) is done for the sake
of safety. For small tunnels the scaling is made directly from the muck pile, in larger it is often carried out from
the wheel loader.
The selection of equipment for mucking and hauling largely depend on the cross-sectional area and the gradient
of the tunnel. For tunnels with cross-sections smaller than 16 m2, the only alternative for transportation is rail
transport system. In larger tunnels, wheel transport system shall be used. For wheel transport in cross-sections
between 16 and 30 m2 “niches” are required every 100 to 150 m for the purposes of loading and turning trucks.
A major restriction for the rail transport alternative is that the maximum gradient has to be less than 2%. For
wheel transport gradients up to 15% may be tolerated.
A tunnel boring machine (TBM) is a complex and very advanced piece of machinery designed to excavate the
entire cross-section in a single operation without the use of explosives. Tunnels with diameters of about 1.8 m to
more than 11 m have been excavated with tunnel boring machines.
TBM consists of a wheel cutter head fitted with teeth or rollers to cut or spall the rock. The wheel is slightly
smaller than the bore of the tunnel and is equipped with disc-cutters to produce the designed bore. The wheel is
forced against the tunnel face by hydraulic jacks and is made to rotate. As excavation proceeds, the rock-cuttings
are picked up in buckets attached around the rim of the wheel and are discharged on to a conveyor belt
incorporated with the machine as shown in Figure 5.20.
The diameter of the cutters is normally within the range of 45 to 50 cm, and the total number of cutters varies
from 20 for smallest machines to more than 70 for the largest.
Compared to conventional D & B tunneling technique, TBM tunneling has the following advantages:
For long tunnels (> 3 km) the excavation time and the costs in many cases are considerably lower due to a
higher advance rate combined with reduced requirement for tunnel support and ventilation.
The tunnel will have a circular profile with a smooth contour, which is of particular importance in reducing
head loss in unlined water tunnels.
Potential problems due to blast vibrations are eliminated, especially in populated areas.
Less number of “adits” is required.
There are, however, some limitations in connection with the use of TBM in tunneling. These include:
Initial cost of the machine is high
Requires detail geological investigation than the D & B alternative
Less flexible than Conventional D & B technique in tackling stability problems.
Tunnel Supports
A basic philosophy in tunneling is that the extent of installed tunnel support should reflect the actual rock
conditions. In good quality rock the self-supporting capacity of the rock mass should be used to its advantage,
and the amount of tunnel support kept at a minimum. In poor quality rock the design of support should be based
on a sound understanding of the character and extent of the stability problem.
The various geological factors which may influence the stability are:
Tunnel support may be installed either at the working face (immediate support), or behind the face (permanent
support). Whenever possible the design for the immediate support should be chosen which makes it possible to
act later as permanent support.
The following support methods are the most commonly used in hydropower tunneling today:
Rock bolting
Shotcreting
Grouting
Concrete lining
Rock Bolting:
A rock bolt is a steel bar, which is inserted into a hole drilled in a rock to improve the rock competency. The
distant end has a device which permits it to firmly anchored in the hole and the projecting end is fitted with a
plate which bears against the rock surface (see Figure 5.21). The bolt is placed in tension between the anchor
and the plate, thereby exerting a compressive force on the rock.
Rock bolting in tunnels is carried out according to one of the following two main principles:
Spot bolting of individual, unstable blocks
Systematic bolting of a section of the tunnel in a definite pattern
On average, the length of rock bolts in water tunnels is 1.5 to 4 m and the diameter is 16 to 25 mm. Rock bolting
is usually used for an immediate support near the tunnel face.
Shotcreting:
A shotcrete is a quick-setting concrete plaster shot at rock surfaces pneumatically. It creates the best possible
rock support condition, which makes it an economical, rapid, and effective means of providing tunnel support. In
practice the shotcrete is placed in 5 cm layers until a desired thickness is attained.
The use of steel fibres in the concrete mix has an effect of increasing the strength of the shotcrete. For an
immediate support in areas of heavily jointed rock masses or in areas of high rock stresses, steel fibre reinforced
shotcrete is commonly used.
In many cases, the shotcrete is combined with rock bolting for use as a permanent support. A combination of
steel fibre reinforced shotcreting and systematic rock bolting can replace concrete lining alternative, provided
that water inflow and active gouge material in the discontinuities are minimal or absent.
A general restriction in the use of shotcrete is in areas with water leakage. The main restriction, however, is
where weakness zones contain swelling clay (smectite). If shotcrete is applied on such zones, there will be no
room for expansion of the swelling clay, and high swelling pressure will be activated when the zones are
exposed to water. This may easily destroy the shotcrete lining.
Grouting:
A grout is a mixture of cement and water forced in to rocks around the tunnel periphery. Grouting may be
performed ahead of the tunneling face (pre-grouting) or behind the tunneling face (post-grouting). Pre-grouting
is necessary in areas where groundwater inflow makes tunnel driving difficult (see Figure 5.23). Probe holes are
drilled ahead of the tunnel face to perform permeability testing before deciding the necessity of pre-grouting.
Post-grouting is done to improve the stability of the rock mass behind the tunnel face.
A sudden change of flow rate in a large pipe line (due to value closure ) may involve a great mass of water
moving with in the pipe walls. The force resulting from changing the speed of the water mass causes a pressure
rise in the pipe with a magnitude several times greater than the normal static pressure in the pipe. This
phenomenon is commonly known as water Hammer because of the noise & vibration with which it is sometimes
accompanied. The excessive pressure only fracture the pipe water unless it is properly analyzed & accounted for
in the design of the pipe line.
The determination of Water Hammer pressure is amenable to mathematical analysis. Practical problems may,
however, be of considerable complexity owing to the many variables involved. Here, we will consider only
elementary class. In this regard the simplest procedure is to regard the water as incompressible & the pipe as
rigid (The so-called rigid Water-Column theory).
The assumption is obviously not very realistic but can lead to reasonable estimations in the certain cases. The
more realistic situation is the one that takes the elasticity of the water & the pipe in to account (The Elastic
Water Column Theory )
A
HYDROPOWER ENGINEERING MODULE 2017
hw
hw
Hs=static head
A
B
The pressure increase swings the normal HGL from CD to EF. Since the pressure the reservoir surface is
atmospheric & hence constant the positive swing results in back flow from the pipe to reservoir. As the water
flows back in to the reservoir it crates partial vacuum condition in the pipe & the pressure in the pipe swings in
the negative direction. Thus, induces the reservoir water to flow back in to the pipe . But the value being
partially closed, much of the water is again retarded giving rise to positive swing of pressure again. Thus, a valve
closure brings about pressure oscillations. The maximum additional water hammer pressure head hw can be
determined from Newton‟s 2rd law.
p . A . A. L .
t
hw g L
t
L v
hw Note:- Instantaneous Closure large pressure rise !
g t
Thus the total head @ the valve = Hs + hw
L v
= Hs
g t
Considering friction and local loss, the total head becomes
L v
2
L v
Hs k
D 2 g g t
Eg. If steady flow velocity V0 is reduced to zero @ a uniform rate during tc, then the max. pressure head @ the
value due to water hammer will be
L 0 v0 L v0
hw
g c
t g tc
Now, Considering that the pressure wave is propagated from the valve to the reservoir with a speed c, the time
required for the pressure wave to travel from B to A is L/c. In this time, the mass brought to rest is .A.L. thus:
0 v0
p. A A L
t /c
pmax c v0
p max c vo
& hwmax
g g
2l 2L
The above is sufficient for estimating pressure rise for rapid value closure i.e. when t c , when tc
c c
the reflected negative pressure reduces the pressure rise at the value. In such cases one can use
p 2L 1
.
p max c tc
This takes the effect of compressibility of the water column in the pipe & the dilation of the pipe under high
pressure in to consideration. Thus, for sudden valve closure, it is assumed that all the kinetic energy of the water
is converted to the strain energy of the water (compression) & strain energy of the pipe (tensile )
1 D2
V p . L where K p / V
K 4
D3
Pipe distended V . L . P
4 TE
D2 L 1 D
Combining Vtotal p .
4 K T .E
thus L V A
1 D
L L p 3
K T . E
p c v0 _____ Allevi expression
1
c
1 D
k
K T .E
5
where k , for pipes free to move longitudinally
4
5.2.2.1 General
The surge tank, also called the expansion chamber, is a structure which forms an essential part of the pressure
conduit conveyance system whenever such system is long. Surge tanks may be considered essentially as a
forebay close to a machine. Their primary purpose is protection of long pressure tunnel in medium and high –
head plants against high water hammer pressure arising from sudden rejection or acceptance of load, The surge
thank converts these high frequency, high pressure transients (water hammer) in to low frequency low pressure,
mass oscillation.
It is located between the almost horizontal or slightly inclined pressure conduit and the steeply sloping
penstock/pressure shaft. It is designed either as a chamber excavated in the mountain or as a tower raising high
above the surrounding terrain (see Figure 5.24).
Surge Tank
Pressure Tunnel
Power House
The hydraulic design of surge tank concerns with two main aspects.
a) Its height
b) Its cross-sectional area.
These aspects are decided up on with the view to fulfilling the following criteria:
The surge tank must be locates so that the positive & negative water hammer pressures are kept within
acceptable limits.
The tank must be stable i.e. water surface oscillation must be damped out
The tank must accommodate maximu upsurge & lowest down surge
5.2.2.5 Height
The total height of the surge tank should be such that both the maximum up-surge and down-surge is contained
within the surge tank height. Worst conditions should be considered to determine the height.
The lowest possible level of down surge must be sufficiently above the conduit top level by a certain height h
(see Figure 5.28) in order to avoid vortex formation at entrance to the penstock/pressure shaft.
In general, the total height of the surge tank would be (see Figure 5.28):
Hlive
LRWL
Z0
Z1 down
Pressure tunnel
h
In order to determine the surge height and thus necessary tank height, etc., it is necessary to carry out water
hammer analysis and determine corresponding surge heights under various closure and opening (load rejection
and acceptance) conditions.
Penstock or
L
Q1 Pressure
shaft
Continuity equation
A V Q1
1
dz dz
V At As Q1 t
dt dt As
2 gd
Denote FT L
2 gd
L dv
h FT V 2 z (Wave theory, rigid column theory)
g dt
If surge tank throttle loss is considered
. 2
L dv
FS VS2 FT V 2 z
g dt
1 & 2 could be combined to give 2nd order d.e. but not analytical solution.
If Q1 = 0 & friction is ignored, (Undamped oscillation, complete valve closure) equation (1) & (2) become.
t V 3
dz A
dt AS
dv g
Z 4
dt L
This is the deferential equation for a frictionless surge tank oscillation. The equation is a linear homogenous 2nd
order d.e. With constant coefficients undamped simple harmonic motion (SHM).
c.f. with SHM
d 2z g At
r 2Z 0 where r .
dt 2 L As
2 t 2t
Z C1 cos C 2 Sin where T is period of oscillation
T T
L AS
T = 2/r = 2 .
g At
When t = 0, V = Vo and Vo = As C 2 2
AT T
L AT .
Substituting for T, C 2 VO
g AS
L AT 2t
Z VO sin
g AS T
L AT
The maximum amplitude , Zmax, is obtained from Z mzx V0
g AS
At any time, t
2t
Z Z max sin
T
2t
V VO cos
T
No general solution of the d.e. can be given since the velocity changes its sign after every half cycle
Numerical Solution
L V
Dynamic equation: Z m FT Vm / Vm / FS VS / VS 0 1
g t
Z
Continuity equation: Vm AT As ,m Qm 2
t
Where m indicates the average value in the interval
As,m the average area of the surge chamber between Z & Z + Z
If the two values of Vm agree V is correct. Otherwise adjust V & repeat until agreement is achieved, then
proceed to next time interval.
OR
Estimate Z and proceed in a similar fashion. (Preferable if chamber has variable area)
Where Vm Vi V
2
Also (1) becomes.
L V t V
2
A
Zi Vi AT T V Qm FT Vi .
g t 2 As ,m 2 2
Fs 2 V 2 V
( AT2 Vi Vi V 2 AT Vi Q m Qm ) 0
2
As1 4 2
Rearranging
FR L AT F A Q
t FR Vi S T2 m V Z i
4 gt 4 As , m As A
2
FR FS T FT
AT Q F S
A
V i t M t FR Vi 2 S2 Qm 2Vi AT Qm 0
2 AS ,m ZAS ,m As
b b 2 4ac
a V 2 bV C 0 V
2a
V is therefore determined explicitly in each successive time step t & corresponding position Z is obtained
from (3) .
Note that if V becomes negative, (i.e. on the down surge) the negative values of FR is used. As with most F.D.
methods, t should be small (because of use of average values in interval). A 10 second time interval gives a
sufficiently accurate solution.
For sudden load rejection or demand by use of dimensionless parameters method developed by calme & Gaden
( one of several ) can be followed. This method can be summarized as:
Maximum up surge:
2
Z
max
2 K2
1 K 0 0 . for K
0 0.7 or
Z max
1
1 K 0 ; Z
max 1 0.6 K 0
3 3
where Z
Z
K 0
P0 where K o (head loss in tunnel, coefficient
Z mzx. Z mzx 2 gd
in v²)
Qo gAt
Z max r
AS r L AS
Z max 1 0.125 K 0 for K
0 0.8
Characteristic oscillation in the surge tank damped by hydraulic friction in the conduits. Amplitude of
1
oscillation .
AS
The required cross-sectional area of a surge tank is determined based on stability considerations for the surge
oscillations in the tank. Stability conditions of the surge system were established by Thoma. He stated that in
order to prevent the development of unstable oscillations the cross-section of the surge tank should exceed a
certain critical magnitude.
According to Thoma, the limiting x-sectional all for small oscillation is given by:
ASc
V02 At Lt
2 g Po H 0
m
2 where Po = hf =Zo
For large amplitude of oscillation, the Thoma formula was modified by Ch Jaeger as
L At m 2 R 4 3 At
AS * * * = non constant factor of safety =1+ 1.0482Zmax/Ho
2 g H o 2g H 0
or AS m D = 170.482 Z max
* 2 43
L At (undamped friction loss)
Z o V0
160 H o H0 g AS
5.2.7 Forebays
5.2.7.1 General
A forebay, also called a head pond, is a basin located at the end of a power canal just before the entrance to the
penstock or pressure shaft. It acts as a transition section between the power canal and the penstock. It is formed
simply by widening the power canal at the end. Figure 5.31 shows typical forebay.
The size of a forebay vary depending on the sediment content of the water conveyed in the power canal and
whether it is to serve for storage. To be most cost-effective, the forebay must be of a size adequate to fulfill its
function, neither significantly larger nor smaller. It is not advisable to design the forebay as a settling basin if the
suspended sediment is fine to cause no damage to the turbines.
A gradual transition section should be provided between the power canal and the forebay basin. In the case of
wide forebays, baffle piers are usually constructed at the basin inlet in order to ensure even distribution of flow
to the basin.
The bottom of the forebay basin should be provided with a proper slope to enable periodical flushing of the silt
deposited.
A bottom lining of the forebay basin is required in soils where large seepage is expected. As concrete lining of
large basins is very expensive, a less costly solution of clay lining is usually adopted. The smoothed bottom of
the basin is covered with plastic clay to a thickness of 20 to 50 cm. The cover is compacted in several layers and
is protected against disturbance due to soaking and wave action by a layer of gravel or crushed stone.
The spillway is usually an ogee type with stilling basin. If the discharge to be taken care of is great and if, at the
same time, prevailing conditions do not permit the construction of a long overflow weir, water surface regulation
within narrow limits can be attained by constructing a siphon type spillway.
The spillway and the bottom outlet canal should be combined immediately at the foot of the basin. Water spilling
over the spillway crest and through the bottom outlet can be either diverted into a suitable river bed (if any) in a
nearby side valley or conveyed by a special chute.
In designing a forebay tank, it is important to keep the entrance to the penstock fully submerged. This is to
prevent air being drawn in to the penstock because of a vortex which can be formed if the penstock entrance is
closer to the water surface in the basin.
The usual components of the intake such as trashracks, flow control devices (gates or valves), etc. must be
provided at the penstock inlet. It is necessary to install an air vent behind the gate to prevent damage to the
penstock if for some reason the penstock entrance is blocked or the gate is suddenly closed causing a low
pressure inside the conduit which can make it collapse inwards. The air vent can also help remove air from
inside the penstock during startup.
5.3 PENSTOCK
5.3.1 General
The penstock is high pressure pipeline between forebay ( surge tank or reservoirs ) and the turbine. The design
principle of penstocks are the same as that of pressure vessels & tanks but water hammer effect has to be
considered. For short length, a separate penstock for each turbine is preferable. For a moderate heads & long
distances a single penstock is used to find two or more turbines through a special branching pipe called
Manifold.
1) Material of construction
Factors for the choice of material are: head, topography & discharge. Various materials used are steel, R.C.,
asbestos cement, PVC, wood stave pipes, banded steel, etc. The following factors have to be considered when
deciding which material to use for a particular project:
Required operating pressure Diameter and friction loss Weight and ease of installation
Accessibility of site Cost of the penstock Design life
Availability Weather conditions
2) Method of support
A penstock may be either buried or embodied underground ( or inside dams) or exposed above ground surface &
supported on piers.
Buried penstocks: are supported on the soil in a trench at a depth of 1 to 1.5m and back filled. The general
topography of the land should be gentle sloping and of loose material.
Advantages Disadvantages
4. Number of Penstocks
The number of penstocks used at any particular installation can be single or multiple. The general trend at older
power stations was to use as many penstocks between the forebay/surge tank and the powerhouse as the number
of units installed. The recent trend is to use a single penstock, unless the size or thickness of the penstock
involves manufacturing difficulties.
When a single penstock feeds a number of turbines, special sections called manifolds are used at the lower end
of the penstock to direct flow to individual units. The design of such sections is an intricate job and has to be
analyzed carefully.
The advantages of using a single penstock over the use of multiple penstocks are:
The amount of material required to manufacture is less, making it economical.
The cost of civil engineering components such as penstock supports and anchors is less.
On the other hand, the use of a single penstock means reduced safety of operation and complete shutdown will
become necessary in case of repair. Further more, significant losses are usually experienced at the manifolds.
In general, the use of multiple penstocks is preferably employed for low-head plants with short penstocks;
whereas for high-head plants requiring long penstocks, provision of a single penstock with manifold at the end
usually proves economical.
5.3.3 Hydraulics
Permissible velocities.
3 to 5 m/s ( no abrasion property settled water) for properly settled water in exceptional cases up to 5m/s may be
tolerated.
Q D 2 Q0
Therefore: A 0 D 1.128
v0 4 v0
Head losses
2
i) Frictional head loss => h f L v
D 2g
2
v
ii) other local losses h f c k where k = local loss coefficient
2g
K
Penstock with gradual transition entrance 0.10 - 0.20
Open butterfly valve (depending on disk thickness) 0.05 - 0.25
Needle valves 0.20 - 0.25
Bends (depending on deflection angle) 0.05 - 0.15
Total cost
Cos
t
Economic Construction
loss cost
Diameter
Figure 5.33: Economical Diameter of Penstock
1) SARKARIA’S Formula
3) Donald’s formula
0.466
P
D 0.176
H
4) Fahlbusch (2982)
D 0.52 H 0.17 P H 0.43
From previous
Em 1 1 D
C Where
Em K TE
For instant closure i.e. t c 2 L
C
Cvo
h
g
For all other closure t c 2 L , the max pressure rise at the valve
C
h 2L C vo 2 L 2vo L
hmax .
C tc g C tc g tc
The value of water hammer pressure rise as computed above may be taken at the turbine gate, reducing to zero at
intake or surge tank level. Values at intermediate location may be calculated assuming a straight line variation
PD
t
2
For steel used in penstocks usually a factor of safety of 3 to 3.5 is used. Thus for material with ultimate tensile
strength of 3700 kg/cm2; a 1200 kg/cm2
For protection against coating deterioration add 1 to 3mm to the above value.
For thick welded piper where D 20 , the following formula giver sufficient accuracy
t
D a 0.07 H
t 1) (1 to 3)mm
2 a 0.13H
The ASME gives the formula for thickness as t pr
0.15
a 0.6 P
Where t in cm
p pressure in kg/cm2
r internal radius in cm
a design stress in kg/cm2
joint efficiency factor
0.15cm is allowance for corrosion
In case where the negative water column gradient falls below the penstock center line, there is danger of collapse
of the penstock due to external atmospheric pressure. The external pressure pe likely to result in collapse may be
computed from the formula by Mayer
3EI 24 EI
pe kg / cm 2
r3 D3
3
I =moment of inertia of x-section of the pipe ring t m3
12
E =modulus of elasticity of steel
3
Introducing a S.F. , Pe 1 2 t n=2 for burried pipes; n=4 for exposed pipes
D
Pe
t D3
2E
Penstock pipes are generally supplied in standard lengths, and have to be joined together on site. There are many
ways of doing this, and the following factors should be considered when choosing the best jointing system for a
particular scheme.
Flanged Joints:
Flanges are fitted to each end of individual pipes during manufacture, and each flange is then bolted to the next
during installation as shown in Figure 5.34.
Spigot and socket joints are generally used to join ductile iron, PVC, concrete, and asbestos cement pipes.
Mechanical Joints:
Mechanical joints are rarely used on penstocks because of their cost. One important application of it is for
joining pipes of different material or where a slight deflection in the penstock is required that does not warrant
installing a bend.
Welded Joints:
Welded joints are used on penstocks made of steel. Steel pipes are brought to the site in standard lengths, and
then welded together on site. One advantage of welding on site is that changes in the direction of the pipe can be
accommodated without preparation of a special bend section. It is relatively cheap method, but has the drawback
of needing skilled site personnel.
Expansion Joints:
A penstock, specially exposed ones, will change in length depending on temperature fluctuations. If it is fixed
the thermal expansion forces are substantial. It is possible to relieve these forces by incorporating special joints
called expansion joints, which allow the pipe to expand and contract freely.
For short penstocks, provision of a single expansion joint may be sufficient, but for long penstocks with a
multiple anchor blocks expansion joints should be placed below each anchor block. Another alternative to take
care of thermal expansion is to take in to account the forces that result from it in designing anchors.
Slide blocks, anchors, and thrust blocks all serve the same basic function – to constrain movement of the
penstock. Different terms are used with these structures simply to indicate which specific function they serve,
and this is discussed in the following paragraphs, see Figure 5.32 for the sketches.
Slide Blocks:
A slide block, also called supporting pier, carries the weight of pipe and water, and restrains the pipe from
upward and sideway movements, but allows it to move longitudinally. In most cases the spacing between slide
blocks are assumed equal to the length of each pipe.
If the penstock is buried, slide blocks are unnecessary, rather instead the pipe is laid in a trench on a bed of sand
or gravel of consistent quality, with no big stones which could cut into the pipe or cause stress concentrations on
the pipe wall.
Weight of the pipe and enclosed water. As slide blocks do not resist longitudinal forces, only the component of
the weight perpendicular to the pipe will be considered.
Friction forces on the blocks. This is due to the longitudinal movement of the pipe over the blocks caused by
thermal expansion and contraction.
Anchor Blocks:
An anchor block consists of a mass of reinforced concrete keyed to the penstock so that the penstock cannot
move in any way relative to the block. It is designed to withstand any load the penstock may exert on it.
Anchors are often used at bends (horizontal and vertical) and before entrance to the powerhouse (see Figure
5.32). They can also be used along long straight sections of penstock, each one next to expansion joint.
Because an anchor is keyed to the penstock pipe and is also frequently located at a bend in the pipe, more forces
act on an anchor than on a slide block. The major forces which act on anchor blocks are the following:
Thrust Blocks:
The structure should be safe against sliding. For sliding not to occur:
H V
Where, H and V, respectively, are the sum of all horizontal and vertical forces, and is the coefficient of
friction between the structure and the ground often assumed as 0.5.
The structure should be safe against overturning. For this condition to be fulfilled, the resultant force should act
within the middle third of the base. In other words,
Lbase
e
6
Where, e is eccentricity of loading and Lbase is length of the structure base.
The pressure transmitted to the foundation must be within the safe bearing capacity of the foundation material.
This can be expressed as:
Maximum pressure V 6 e Bearing capacity of
1
by the structure Abase Lbase the foundation soil
Valves are usually installed at two places in a penstock. One valve is provided at the upstream end of the
penstock, i.e., at the forebay or immediately after the surge tank, and is called penstock inlet valve, while the
second is provided at the downstream end of the conduit, immediately a head of the turbine, and is named as
turbine inlet valve. The upper valve is sometimes replaced by a gate.
The main purpose of penstock inlet valve is for dewatering of the penstock in case maintenance of the penstock
is required. But, it can be omitted for short penstocks where the closure of the power canal or power tunnel is
possible from the intake.
The main purpose of turbine inlet valve is to close the penstock while the turbine is inoperative. It can also act as
an emergency shut-off device. This valve cannot be omitted except under especial case where the penstock
supplies a single unit having installed the penstock inlet valve.
6.2 Classification
All types of turbines basically fall in to two categories impulse and reaction turbines.
Jet deflector
Jet separator
bucket
Impulse turbine: All the available potential energy is converted in to kinetic energy with the help of
contracting nozzle/s. The water after impinging on the curved vanes or bucket is discharged freely to the
downstream channel (eg. Pelton wheel)
Reaction turbines: In this type the water enters the turbine in a circumferential direction in to the scroll
case and moves into the runner through a series of guide vanes, called wicket gates. The available energy
partly converted to kinetic energy & substantial magnitude remains in the form of pressure energy (eg.
Francis, Kaplan, Propeller, Bulb, etc)
Turbines may also be classified according to the main direction of flow of water in the runner as
Tangential flow turbine ( pelton wheel)
radial flow „‟ ( Francis, Thomson, Girard)
Mixed flow „‟ ( modern Francis )
Axial flow turbine of fixed blade ( propeller ) or movable blade ( Kaplan or bulb ) type.
Furthermore, turbines may be classified based on head, discharge, speed, specific speed.
Specific speed: is useful parameter for the selection of turbine for a given condition: It is defined as the
speed at which a geometrically similar runner would rotate if it were so proportioned that it would
develop 1 Kw when operating under a head of 1m , and expressed as ( from dimensional analysis )
P
Ns N 5
4
H
where Ns = Specific speed
N = rotational speed. (rpm)
P = Power developed (kw)
H = effective head (m)
Turbine or synchronous speed: Since turbine & generator are fixed, the rated speed of the turbine is the
same as synchronous speed of the generator. The speed N, for synchronous running is given by :
N 120 f
p
Where f = frequency cycle/sec ( 50-60 Hz c/s)
p = number of poles ( divisible by 4 for head up to 200 m )
( divisible by 2 for head above 200 m )
The speed of a turbine is an important parameter of design. The higher the speed, the smaller the diameter
of the turbine runner & the cheaper the generator coupled to the turbine. High speed, however, makes a
turbine more susceptible to cavitation.
The ratio of the peripheral speed , v, of the bucket or vanes at the nominal diameter, D, to the theoretical
velocity of water under the effective head, H, acting on the turbine is called the speed factor or peripheral
coefficient , .
v r
2 gH 2 gH
Therefore, DN DN
D and H in m; N in rpm
60 2 gH 84.6 H
The following table suggests appropriate values of , which give the highest efficiencies for any turbine,
the head & specific speed ranges & the efficiencies of the three main types of turbine.
Thus in general
Pelton turbines are used for high heads & low discharges
Furthermore, turbines may be classified based on head, discharge, speed, specific speed.
Specific speed: is useful parameter for the selection of turbine for a given condition: It is defined as the
speed at which a geometrically similar runner would rotate if it were so proportioned that it would
develop 1 Kw when operating under a head of 1m , and expressed as ( from dimensional analysis )
P
Ns N 5
4
H
where Ns = Specific speed
N = rotational speed. (rpm)
P = Power developed (kw)
H = effective head (m)
Turbine or synchronous speed: Since turbine & generator are fixed, the rated speed of the turbine is the
same as synchronous speed of the generator. The speed N, for synchronous running is given by :
N 120 f
p
Where f = frequency cycle/sec ( 50-60 Hz c/s)
p = number of poles ( divisible by 4 for head up to 200 m )
( divisible by 2 for head above 200 m )
The speed of a turbine is an important parameter of design. The higher the speed, the smaller the diameter
of the turbine runner & the cheaper the generator coupled to the turbine. High speed, however, makes a
turbine more susceptible to cavitation.
The ratio of the peripheral speed , v, of the bucket or vanes at the nominal diameter, D, to the theoretical
velocity of water under the effective head, H, acting on the turbine is called the speed factor or peripheral
coefficient , .
v r
2 gH 2 gH
Therefore, DN DN
D and H in m; N in rpm
60 2 gH 84.6 H
The following table suggests appropriate values of , which give the highest efficiencies for any turbine,
the head & specific speed ranges & the efficiencies of the three main types of turbine.
Thus in general
Pelton turbines are used for high heads & low discharges
Francis types are used for medium & high head plants (has adjustable guide vanes but the runner is a
disc with fixed passage)
Propeller & Kaplan (Kaplan has adjustable blades) types are used for lows head plants with large
discharges.
suggested
DN
3. Calculate D from:
84.6 H
If D is found to be too large, either N can be increased or more units may be adopted. For approximate
calculations of runner diameter; the following empirical formula may be used (Mosony)
1
Q 3
D in m; Q in m3/s; N in rpm
D a
M
a = 4.4 for Francis & propeller; a = 4.57 for Kaplan.
H
Nominal diameter, D , of pelton wheel D 38
N
Q
dj 0.542
H
It is not uncommon to use a member of multiple jet wheels mounted on the same shaft so as to develop
the required power.
Hydraulic turbines (runner) is designed for optimum speed & maximum efficiency at design head. But in
reality, head and load conditions change during operation & it is extremely important to know the
performance of the unit at other heads. This is furnished by manufacturer‟s curve.
Figure 6.4: Variation of efficiency w.r.t. % of full load for various turbines
If the external load on the machine suddenly drops to zero (sudden rejection) and the governing
mechanism fails at the same time, the turbine will tend to race up to the maximum possible speed, known
as runaway speed. This limiting speed under no-load, maximum-flow must be considered for safe design.
Minimum Maximum
Impulse (Renton) 170 - 190 65 125
Fiancés 200 - 220 50 150
Propeller 250 - 300 50 150
Runaway speed and acceptable head variations
A scroll case is the conduit directing the water from the intake or penstock to the runner in reaction type
turbine installation ( in case of impulse wheels a casing is usually provided only to prevent splashing of
water & lead water to the tail race). A spiral shaped scroll case of the correct geometry ensures even
distribution of water around the periphery of the runner with the minimum possible eddy formations.
a) Francis turbine with steel spiral case b) Propeller turbine with partial spiral
Figure 6.5:Recommended dimensions of scroll casings (a) full spiral b) partial spiral
This kind of spiral case will generally used in medium and high head installations where discharge
requirement is low. See Figure 6.4 a). Spiral cases with 320<<340 are also considered full.
The design of the shape of the spiral case is governed by the flow requirements. Initial investigation
should be based on the following assumptions:
a) spiral case of constant height
b) an evenly distributed flow in to the turbine
c) no friction losses
Referring to Fig 6.6 (a) the discharge in section of spiral case defined by angle is
Q where Q is the total discharge to the runner.
q
2
vt
k where k 30 gH ( from the basic Euler equation for the power absorbed by the
r N
machine)
dr Q R Q
dq vt h0 dr k ho dr q r0 k ho
R
or ln
r 2 ro z k ho
This shows for given vortex strength, k, a definite relationship exist between Q & R.
The most economical design of a power station substructure and the narrowest spiral case can be obtained
by choosing a rectangular section adjoining the guide vanes (entrance ring) by step transition (
symmetrical or asymmetrical ) as shown in b.
Q dr dr
r01 h
r R
r1 H 0
2k r r
Replacing and integrating
Q r R
h0 r0 ln 1 H 0 h0 H 0 ln
2k r0 r1
Knowing r1 from H h0
r1 0
, the value of R defining the shape of the spiral case can be determined.
r0
The height H0 at any angle may be assumed to be linearly increasing from h0 at the nose towards the
entrance. Shape at various is determined by assuming existence of uniform velocity equal to entrance
velocity, v0 0.2 2 gH and qi Q i
2
qi q area of cross-section at angle i
Ai 0.18 i
v0 H
A draft tube is a conduit discharging water from the turbine runner to the tailrace. It is employed in
conjunction with reaction type turbines, and has twofold purposes:
To recover as much as possible of the velocity energy of the water leaving the runner, which
otherwise would have gone to waste as an exit loss, thus increasing the dynamic draft head.
To utilize the vertical distance between the turbine exit and the tail-water level, called the static draft
head. In other words, to allow the turbine to be set at higher elevation without losing the advantage of
elevation difference.
The most common is elbow type which minimizes the depth of substructure compared to vertical one, it
also has a desirable effect in directing the flow in the direction of the tail water.
The straight conical draft tubes are the simplest in design and the most efficient type, but they are rarely
used in actual practice. This is because, for effective recovery of velocity head, the outlet section has to be
many times the inlet section of the draft tube. For smooth eddy-free flow (flow with no separation), the
angle of flare of the tube has to be limited to 4 to 8 degrees. Hence, a considerable long tube is necessary
to achieve the desired result. This increases the depth of excavation of the substructure, making it
uneconomical, and unsuitable from cavitation view point.
The elbow-type draft tube is often adopted, because of the following advantages it offers over the conical
type:
s l
2g 2g
v2 v2
H d d 1 2
2g 2g
In order to aroid cavitation at the exit from the runner the condition P1 Pv .( Saturated vapor pressure is
around 0.3 on of water absolutes
Cavitation result is pitting, vibration & reduction in efficiency & is certainly undesirable. Cavitation may
be avoided by suitably designing, installing, and operating the turbine in such a way that the pressures
with is the units are above the vapor pressure of water.
Refering the previous Figures, Ys is the most critical factor in the installation of reaction turbines.
2
N
c 0.0432 s for Francis
100
3
Ns
c 0.28 0.0024 for propeller
100
The preliminary calculation for the elevation of the distributor above the TWL, Yt is
Francis types are used for medium & high head plants (has adjustable guide vanes but the runner is a
disc with fixed passage)
Propeller & Kaplan (Kaplan has adjustable blades) types are used for lows head plants with large
discharges.
suggested
DN
6. Calculate D from:
84.6 H
If D is found to be too large, either N can be increased or more units may be adopted. For approximate
calculations of runner diameter; the following empirical formula may be used (Mosony)
1
Q 3
D in m; Q in m3/s; N in rpm
D a
M
a = 4.4 for Francis & propeller; a = 4.57 for Kaplan.
H
Nominal diameter, D , of pelton wheel D 38
N
Q
dj 0.542
H
It is not uncommon to use a member of multiple jet wheels mounted on the same shaft so as to develop
the required power.
Hydraulic turbines (runner) is designed for optimum speed & maximum efficiency at design head. But in
reality, head and load conditions change during operation & it is extremely important to know the
performance of the unit at other heads. This is furnished by manufacturer‟s curve.
Figure 6.4: Variation of efficiency w.r.t. % of full load for various turbines
Penstock: conveys water from the intake structure to the power house and can take many
configurations, depending up on the projects layout. For multi-unit installations it is often
desirable to serve several Units with a single penstock, and manifolds or bifurcation
structures are provided to direct flow to individual units.
Surge tanks: Flow through a penstock can change rapidly during the operation of power
plants. As long as flow is steady and constant, pressure changes on the conveyance conduits
are minimal. However, pressure changes within the conduit become greater as the rate of
change of flow increases. This phenomenon is known as water hammer and is caused by a
change of momentum within the water column. When there is a rapid changes in flow water
hammer effects can become serious. Surge tanks are constructed on the conduit to reduce
momentum changes due to water hammer effects.
Surge tanks are often necessary in medium and high head hydropower projects, particularly
where there is a considerable distance between the water source and power plant. Surge tanks
or chambers can also be provided on the draft tube where discharge conduits are very long.
There are four types of power house configurations (structure), three of which are classified
according to how the main generating unit, are housed: Indoor, Semi-out door, Outdoor and
Underground.
Indoor: this type of structure encloses all of the power house components under one roof.
Semi-out door: this powerhouse has a fully enclosed generator room. The main hoisting and
transfer equipment is located on the roof of the plant and equipment is handled through
hatches located in the roof.
Outdoor: a generator room is not provided with this type of power house structure.
Generators are enclosed in a weather proof individual cubicles or enclosures and are recessed
in to the floor.
Underground: this type of powerhouse is often used in mountainous areas where there is
limited space available to locate a power plant. It is also used to minimize penstock length in
these areas since the penstock can be located directly below the reservoir. Pumped storage
powerhouses are often located underground in order to shorten the penstock and obtain deep
settings on the turbines.
The selection of powerhouse configuration and structure should be based upon both Fixed
Operation and Maintenance (O&M) costs. The lower capital cost associated with out door
and semi-out door power plants is often offset by increased equipment and Operation and
Maintenance costs. The final selection of powerhouse for any given site would be made after
a detailed cost study, usually performed in the feasibility design stage
The basic requirement of a power house is the functional utility and the aesthetic
requirements. Planning the power house should be harmonious with the surrounding.
A power house of a hydropower may be
A surface power house has no space limitation where as an Underground power house has
space limitation. The surface power houses need an architectural planning so that they fit in
with the general landscape. If a particular area is affected by landslides and if the underlying
geology is suitable, an underground powerhouse is the obvious choice. For low head power
plant and small scale developments surface power house is the economical choice
Design of the powerhouse is primarily a structural and architectural problem and the size of
the building is governed by the requirements to accommodate the generator, the spiral casing
and the outlet area of the draft tube.
For feasibility studies powerhouse layout dimensioning can be done using theoretical and
empirical relations of the power house components. For final design it so customary for the
turbine and generator manufactures to furnish dimensions for the interiors of the spiral
casing, draft tube, and generator assembly.
The following items of equipment are considered for planning and dimensioning of the
power house:
i. Hydraulic equipment:
i. Turbines
ii. Gate and gate valves
iii. Relief valves of penstocks
iv. Governors
v. Flow measuring equipment
ii. Electrical equipment:
i. Generator
ii. Excitors
iii. Transformers, pumps, cooling systems, connections, funs and plate forms
iv. Switching equipment:
a. Low tension buses
b. Switch board panels
c. Switch board equipment and instruments
d. Oil switching and
e. Reactors
a. High tension system:
a. Buses
b. Oil circuit breakers
c. Lightening arrestors
d. Out going connections
b. Auxiliaries:
a. Storage batteries
b. Station lighting
iii. Miscellaneous equipment:
i. Crane
ii. Work shops
iii. Office rooms
iv. Other facilities,( clinic, Store , etc)
The machine in the power house can be either vertical mounting or horizontal mounting. A
horizontal mounting machine requires more floor space but less height. A vertical mounting
machine requires less floor space but more height. For larger capacity installations, it is ideal
choice to have vertical mounting. In general power houses are oriented differently to
accommodate excavation and site preparation problems.
The arrangement is also advantageous for easy inspection and accessibility during
maintenance.
Legend
1. Valve
2. Governor
3. Turbine
4. Generator
5. Transformer
6. Control Panel and
switch board
Legend
1. Anchor Block
2. Switch board
3. Control Panel
4. Governor
5. Turbine
6. Man hole
7. Fly wheel
8. Generato
Legend
1. Inlet of spiral case
2. Pipe bend
3. Penstock
4. Bend to draft tube
Generally speaking, horizontal Francis turbines are unsuitable for those cases in which the
tailrace level varies greatly during flooding. Generally, a high tailrace level can be prevented
by a water proof wall of a power house, or with a special wall or dyke behind the power
house. In this case a sump wall should be properly provided.
The width of the working bay is generally equal to about one unit bay, if the unit is planned
to be major overhauled in the power house. If the unit is planned to be major overhauled
outside the power house there can be no working bay in the power house. The width of the
unit bay is so determined that the clearance between the two units or between the unit and the
wall, should be sufficient for the erection and disassembly of the unit, generally, about 2m.
The passageway, for the operators should be 1-1.5 m, and the clearance between the switch
board / control panel and other apparatus should be at least 2m, and that the switchboard and
the wall should be about 0.8m. For the side unit, its unit bay should have an additional width
(about 1m per Units).
The determination of the setting elevation of the turbine is very important for the Power
House design, taking in to consideration the minimum tailrace level and the suction head of
the turbine.
The height of the Power House is mainly determined by over head craning of the heaviest
part of the unit.
3.3.2Preliminary Dimensions Of Power House For Medium And Large Hydro (Reaction
Turbine Installation
1. Unit spacing in terms of discharge (for steel scroll case )
3 Unit spacing in m
Discharge in m /s
25 10
50 13
75 15
100 17
150 20
200 22
250 24
Capacity of unit in Height to crane rail from generator floor in meter of operating head in m
1000 KVA 25 50 100 150 200
10 16.8 12.6 11.1
20 14.8 13.1 12.3 11.5
30 14.4 13.4 12.6
40 15.8 14.4 13.8
50 16.8 15.6 14.4
60 17.8 16.4 15.1
70 18.4 17.4 15.8
80 18.0 16.4
Width and height of the power house in also calculated based on the capacity of the unit and
crane span required.
5. Other formulae
i. Unit spacing :
a. width if draft table + wall thickness
b. E + B + Wall thickness
F+ C+ 2 + 1.85 D3
D3 = discharge diameter
⎛ Ns ⎞
⎝ 200 ⎠
Ns = specific speed
Machine hall:
Length: the length of the machine hall depends on the number of units and the size of
machine. For vertical alignment machine the centre to centre distance is controlled by the
size of the scroll casing layout. Standard layout indicates a distance of 4.50 to 5.0D, where D
is the turbine out let diameter. Added to this dimension is the minimum clearance of 2 to 3m.
So, the preliminary dimension between centre to centre of two units is 5.0D + 2.5m. For
higher specific speed it can be 4.0D + 2.5 or smaller. Knowing the number of machines, the
total length of the machine hall can be worked out. The additional bay for the erection
loading can be one unit length.
Width: the width of the machine hall is determined by the size and clearance spacing
between the walls – needed as gangway. Since the gangway requirement is of the order of
2.5m, as a first approximation the width of the power house can be presumed to be at least
equal to the centre to center distance of two machines. Unnecessary increase in width will
increase the length of the Electrically Operated Trail (EOT) or Mechanically Operated Trail
(MOT) and the roof structure. In the Machine hall, the generator placing is not exactly at the
centre of the machine hall but towards one side so as to provide enough operation space for
the crane operator.
Height: the height of the Machine hall is fixed by the head room requirement (about 2 to
2.5m) of the crane operation. The hall must have a height which will enable the crane to lift
the rotor of the generator or the runner of the turbine clear of the floor without any
obstruction. To this clearance, space is to be added the depth of crane girder and the head
room for the operating cabin.
segments are also assembled on the loading bay. The size of the erection should be sufficient
to keep the larger parts like the rotor of the generating unit.
Control bay:
The control bay houses the control equipment. It can be adjacent to the unit bay as in most
power houses. Signal is sent from the control bay to the operating bay from where the
operation control is achieved. Most of the controls are operated by remote control from the
control bay.
Service crane:
The crane should be designed for such a capacity that it can lift the heaviest component in the
power house. Normally, the heaviest part is the rotor and the stator.
Switch Yard:
This is the yard with step up transformers. This should be located near the power house. In
most cases switch yards are kept out side the power house.
If there is a gorge and a valley, an underground power house may be economical. Other
factors for choosing under ground power stations are frequent seismic activities landslides
and snow avalanches. An important characteristic of the under ground power plant station is
its flexibility of layout. The shortest possible layout through various feasible alignments can
be draw up with minimum size of pressure conduits and omissions of anchors and valves.
The basic requirement for the feasibility of the underground power house is the availability
of good sound rock at the desired location and depth. Underground power house are also
safer during war attacks.
Most of the power projects that came in Europe after World War –II are underground power
houses.
Some of the underground power stations in the world:
- Portage Mountain (Canada) - 2300MW
- Komano (Canada)- 832 MW
- Vianden (Luxembourg) 920MW
- Tddiki (India)- 840MW
- Tekeze Hydropower (Ethiopia)-300MW
2. The generator may be in a pit but the super structure may be on the surface
3. Semi-Underground, here the generator may be located on the surface while other
units, such as turbines may be under groun
4. The power house may be placed in a cut where the stable rock exists, the units may be
placed in a cut in the rock
According to Mosonyi, the various characteristic types and layouts of the power station could
be described with reference to head and tail water levels as follows.
Characteristics types of under ground power development
i. Upstream Station or head development
ii. Downstream station or tail development
iii. Intermediate station development
iv. Diagonal Tunnel alignment with air cushion surge tank
The upstream station or Head development (Swedish type of development): in this type of
development, the power station is located close to the intake and thus water is directly fed
from the reservoir/forebay to the generating units.
This arrangement is suitable for low head (25-50 m) and high discharge condition in the
continuously sloping or mildly rolling terrains. A surge tank could be provided at the
entrance to the tunnel to protect it from the water hammer during sudden opening and closure
of turbines.
Figure 8.1: The upstream power station or Head development (Swedish type of development)
Downstream Development or Tail race development (Swiss type of development): this type
of Development has its characteristics in a long and nearly horizontal pressure tunnel
together with pressure shafts and a short tail race tunnel. Such a development is most suited
for a rugged terrain and where high heads of the order of several hundred meters can be
utilized.
Figure 8.2: Downstream or Tail-race development power station arrangement (Swedish type
of development)
Intermediate station Development (Italian arrangement): the characteristics of this type of
arrangement are a long head-race tunnel and a long tail race tunnel. The consequent pressure
variations due to long tunnels are taken care of by surge tank both upstream and downstream
of the power house.
8.3 Comparing above–ground and underground power house stations (Basics for
comparison of power station alternatives)
- An underground power house is more costly than a powerhouse on the surface, implying
that underground powerhouse should be considered only when this solution is the only
option available due to site topography
- In many cases a number of parameters concerning investment costs, risks, operation and
maintenance will have to be considered before a conclusion can be drawn as to
whether the optimum layout of a hydropower plant shall have powerhouse on the
surface or underground
- In some case the assessment of rock conditions will be decisive in determining whether
an underground or a surface powerhouse is the most favorable solution. However, in
general the type, head, and capacity of the power plant and the topography of the
project site provide more important parameters for the decision
Some of the main parameters to be considered in the assessment of the overall plant layout are:
The dam /Reservoir Type: the dam itself creates the head to be utilized in the power plant
and so the waterways will be short. Maximum head for a pure design of this type is restricted
today by feasible dam heights to about 250-300m.
The powerhouse is integrated as part of the dam structure, located on the surface at the foot
or adjacent to the foot of the dam or may be located underground within one of the
mountainsides/abutments. At narrow sites with favorable rock conditions and heads our
40 – 50 m, a concrete arch dam and an underground powerhouse often offer the most cost
effective solution. With less favorable rock conditions a narrow site may not be the best dam
location. In such cases wider sites allowing a surface design may offer an alternative, which
give less total costs even with significantly possible higher dam costs. In suitable topography,
which may allow a penstock and power house on the surface without excavation of excessive
open cuts, surface powerhouse may give the cheapest solution even with excellent rock
condition.
The low dam /log water way type: this type of powerhouse layout is characterized by a low
dam where most of the head is created by a long water way releasing water down stream of
natural rapids in the same river basin (Trans-basin diversion). Hydropower plants with heads
of more than 250 m will have some of these characteristics.
A powerhouse located near the intake creates layout with a long tailrace tunnel in
mountainous locations. This design requires long access tunnels and pumping of leakage
water during excavation. On the other hand there is no much risk of losing water from a
pressurized headrace tunnel. Location of the powerhouse in rock near the intake may be
dictated by topography.
i. Hydraulic system:
- Intake with trash rack
- Rock trap and stone rack
- Bypass arrangements and energy dissipaters
ii. Generating system:
- Turbines
- Switch gear
iii. Auxiliary systems:
- Power house cranes
- Cooling water system
- Drainage system
- Ventilation
iv. Operational Aspects and Emergencies:
- Emergency chambers for fire risks, floods
Operational stability:
- Due to long distance from the turbine to the surge chamber, surface plants may be
unsuited for satisfying all technical criteria for stable operation. Plants with
underground powerhouse are more stable than the surface plants.
Deference, operational Reliability and personnel safety:
- As strategic infrastructure, an underground powerhouse is less vulnerable under war
like events than surface option and easier to prefect against sabotage .
Arbaminch University, Department of Hydraulic Eng’g
Structural Design:
- Being completely fixed in its cavern, a powerhouse in the underground can be designed
very efficiently from a structural point of view, as any need for overall support will
easily be provided by the rock confinement. On the contrary, a powerhouse on the
surface may, in order to achieve appropriate safety against sliding or uplift failure,
require larger concrete volumes than what is needed for structural reasons alone.
- Steel lining embedded in rock will have similar advantage. All reactive forces from the
pipe are transferred directly through the concrete surround to the rock. The rock will
prevent any longitudinal movement of the lining and there is no need for expansion
joints.
Operation and Maintenance:
- Embedded steel linings need less maintenance than exposal penstocks on the surface,
which are subjected to deteriorating effects from changing temperature, sunshine, storm
and rain and from frost and snow in clod climates. There will be a need to maintain
external corrosion coating, expansion joints, erosion protection etc. While embedded
linings will need maintenance of the inside coating only. Further, lining in rock will be
shorter than surface options.
Conditions for Construction and Erection:
- Excavation for surface powerhouse will normally take less time than the access and
caverns for underground option. Therefore, construction of an underground powerhouse
will normally take longer time than surface alternatives. If the powerhouse including
erection works is on the critical path for project implementation, the construction
schedule may be decisive for the choice of alternatives. In cases with either very larger
dams or long waterway, powerhouse works including erection on commissioning will not
usually be on the critical path for implementation.
Environmental impacts:
- Whether located at surface or underground, the powerhouse itself will hardly cause
serious environmental concerns. It may be assumed though, that an underground plant,
occupying less surface area, will generally get higher environmental merits than a
surface development. It causes less loss of forest or other valuable surface assets than a
surface plant and gives no negative visual impact of a penstock on the hillside.
functions
iv. certain facilities on the surface
The location and alignment of the power plant will depend on the conditions of rock cover,
rock type, access roads, construction adits, (Topography and geological conditions)
- Minimum need for heavy rock support
- Adjusting the vertical alignment to follow favorable strata of sedimentary rocks or
locate the headrace as pressurized tunnel in igneous rock below weaker sedimentary
rocks
The general design criterion, which has to be satisfied at any point in an unlined pressurized
tunnel or shaft, is that the minimum principal stress in the adjacent rock mass is higher than
the maximum future water pressure.
The embedded steel lining is the most expensive part of the headrace. Therefore, the
penstock has to be designed as short as possible for the actual head in the geological
formation. The next important task is to determine a suitable location and orientation of the
powerhouse cavern in as short a distance as possible from the end of the unlined part of the
headrace. The most important objectives are to ensure the stability of the powerhouse and
adjacent tunnel system and avoiding leakage directly in to the power house. A “Design as
you go” procedure with the possibility to adjust the relative positions of the two components
after excavation has reached the powerhouse area is a recommendable approach, especially
for low head or medium head development allowing rather short penstocks. At this point a
detailed study should be made of on the system of joints around the powerhouse cavern with
special focus on any risk of intersecting faults. Therefore, the location and final elevation of
the end of the unlined tunnel can be adjusted to minimize the risk of short cut leakage in to
the cavern. To further reduce risk of leakage along the penstock a fan shaped grouting curtain
can be done to cover the cover the concrete surround at the penstock inlet and the adjacent
rock mass.
The necessary length of the steel lining will depend on the head, the rock quality and the
existence of crack systems and possible faults.