View
View
View
ACCOUNTANTS OF BANGLADESH
Members’ Conference
on
INTEGRATED REPORTING:
Challenges and Opportunities
Anwaruddin Chowdhury
Member Council & Past President ICAB,
Director CAPA Board and
Member IPSASB CAG
ALLAH SWT’s Revelation of the holy Quran upon Prophet Muhammad SAW
Religious, Philosophical Perceptions of Knowledge – Accounting and Reporting
GATS-WTO Regime Recognition (1996)
SAARC Islamabad Declaration (2004)
Corporate Frauds of New Millennium – (Enron) ?
Role of Auditors and Rating Agencies (Anderson) ?
Strengthening CG Practices - (Regulatory Oversight)
Recent Developments – Impact on CR and CG / FR & AP
Global Financial Crisis/Euro zone Debt Crisis
Regulatory Failure – Sub-prime Lending/Derivatives
G-20 Summit (Pittsburg 2009) Declaration – Reporting Standards
Critical Nature of Financial Markets - Role of Accountants/Rating Agencies
Convergence to Globally Harmonized High Quality Accounting/FR Standards
Important Role of Accountants - Market Confidence, Global Recovery
Lessons Learnt & Way Forward
UK Brexit Impact – Economic, Trade and Professional Implications
3
IR - BACKGROUND SCENARIO
Evolving Factors
Globalization Induced Interdependencies in Economies, supply
chains and global consumption, phenomenal levels of technological
advances and innovations
Actual and prospective resource scarcity (Energy and Food security)
Environmental concerns (climate Change, ozone, CO2 emissions )
Legal Status of Quito Protocol / Rio20+Enviornment Summit-2012
Growing policy issues/Response to financial governance and other crises
Enhanced expectations of corporate transparency and accountability
Resultant Impaction
Major changes in business models aimed at value generation
Measurement, recording and reporting of activities, reflecting
appropriate resource management for sustainable development
Provision for increased stakeholder value information GRI / IR
IR is designed to enhance & consolidate existing reporting practices
to move towards a reporting framework the provides the information
needed to assess organization sustainability /value in the 21st century.
4
CONCEPTUAL DIMENSIONS
6
6
POSITIONING INTEGRATED REPORTING
Overall
Financial International Sustainability Transparency Integrated
Performance
Performance Standards Reporting Reporting
Story
INTEGRATED THINKING
Source : IFAC
7
7
INTEGRATED REPORTING From INTEGRATED THINKING
Source : IIRC
8
IFAC VALUE GENERATION MODEL
+ > >>
Key
Public Interest Key Value- Key Key Societal
Input Resources Adding Outputs Outcomes Benefits
Activities
Source : IFAC
9
9
NON-FINANCIAL ASSETS (INTANGIBLES)—THE MOST
IMPORTANT DETERMINANTS OF VALUE
Source : IFAC
10
10
IFAC AND INTEGRATED REPORTING <IR>
IFAC<IR> IMPLEMENTATION
<IR> is a journey; it will take more than one reporting cycle
Linked to strategy- Provide momentum
<IR> should not be seen as just additional reporting
- “Embed integrated thinking in the organization”
Don’t think of the Framework as a list of requirements
- “Tell your own, unique, value generation story”
IIRC Background
Formation- August 2010, aimed at developing a globally accepted Framework
for a process that results in communications by organisations about value
generation over time. Comprises of representation from corporate,
investment, securities, regulatory, standard setting , accounting, academic
sectors and civil society.
Restructured - Nov 2011. Chair: Prof Mervin King
CEO: Paul Druckman/Richard Howitt
IIRC Vision
World in which IT is embedded within mainstream business practice in the
public and private sectors, facilitated by IR as the corporate reporting norm.
The cycle of IT and IR, resulting in efficient and productive capital allocation,
will act as a force for financial stability and sustainability.
IIRC Definition of Integrated Reporting and Integrated Report
<IR> is a process founded on integrated thinking that result in a periodic
integrated report by an organization about value generation over time and
related communications regarding aspect of value generation.
An integrated report is a concise communication about how an organization’s
strategy, governance, performance and prospects, in the context of external
environment, lead to a generation of value in the short, medium and long term.13
IIRC & INTEGRATED REPORTING
IIRC Objective
Provide framework for a new reporting model to enable organizations to
provide concise communications to broader stakeholder groups about their
values (strategies, governance) generated in the short, medium and long
term, linked to financial performance. Framework published Dec 13.
IR Framework
Provide fundamental change in the way in which organizations are managed
and report to stakeholders. IR supports “integrated thinking” and “integrated
decision making.” Integrated Thinking (IT) described as “active consideration
by an organization of the relationships between its various operating and
functional units and the capitals that the organization uses or affects”.
IR Objectives
Improve quality of information; Provide more cohesive, efficient approach to
corporate reporting; Enhance accountability and stewardship; support IT,
decision making and actions focused on value generation
IR Fundamental Concepts
Value generation for organization and for others; The Capitals (resources
and relationships); The Value generation process. 14
IR OVERVIEW - BANGLADESH POSITION
Render Holistic Meaningful Information to the Govt for the Public Interest
17
CORPORATE REPORTING MODELS
VALUE REPORTING = SR / IR
Role of IFAC (PAIB)/ GRI/ IIRC/ Other Institutions (Prince A4S Project)
MOU Between IIRC and IFAC of September 2012 – Vision for Evolution of
Corporate Reporting for 21st Century Indicating Important Role of <IR>.
Describes Role & Purpose of IR, Acknowledgment, Commitments, Consultation, Intel
Property, Confidentiality, Costs, Publicity, Institutional Arrangement, Contact, Status,
Validity, Revisions, Assignment , Governing Law and Jurisdiction Coverage
MoU Definition of <IR> = Means by which Companies Communicate with Existing
and Potential Investors and other Stakeholders about the way in which their Strategy,
Governance, Performance and Prospects Lead to Value Generation, Preservation and
Reporting over short medium and long term perspectives.
GRI Sustainability Reporting Framework - Key Features : a) Comprehensive
Scope, Covering Main Sustainability Issues, b) Continuous Development, Reflecting
User Experience, c) Multi-Stakeholder Framework & Governance Model, d) Universal
Relevance, Including for Private Sector, Public Agency and Civil Society Organizations
GRI – SAFA MOU 2011
Status on SR/IR Application in SAARC Countries
SAFA/ CAPA Member Bodies /PAOs– Status and Initiatives
Integrated Reporting – Elucidation (Diagrams)
18
18
18
SUSTAINABILITY REPORTING
Triple Bottom Line Approach
(Economic - Social – Environment)
IR = FR + SR (Environment-Social-Governance)
21
IR PERSPECTIVES -PERFORMANCE & VALUES
22
GLOBAL STATUS OF INTEGRATED REPORTING (2012)
23
GLOBAL STATUS OF INTEGRATED REPORTING (2016)
182 Businesses
in Japan do <IR>
UNITED KINGDOM:
The Strategic Report, together with the Financial Reporting Council’s Guidance,
is consistent with Integrated Reporting
<IR> should not be seen as more reporting
We use different words in the UK. Strategic Report, not Integrated Report, but
we are on the same journey with the same purpose. The principles in a UK
strategic report are consistent with an integrated report. And we look forward
to continuing to work closely with the IIRC as it pursues its mission in the
years ahead. (Stephen Haddrill, CEO, FRC, UK)
NETHERLANDS:
More than a third of Dutch listed companies are working towards <IR>
Eumedion, which represents institutional investors’ interests, called on Dutch
companies to take concrete steps towards <IR>
THE USA:
Harvard Business School research concluded that “more <IR> is associated
with a more long-term investor base”
Businesses adopting <IR> include PepsiCo, Microsoft, GE and Prudential
Larry Fink, CEO, Black Rock called for CEO’s to communicate their
strategic framework for long-term value generation
25
25
GLOBAL STATUS OF INTEGRATED REPORTING
BRAZIL:
Brazilian Stock Exchange BM&FBOVESPA encourages listed companies to produce
integrated reports on a ‘report or explain’ principle.
The <IR> network in Brazil has over 300 participants
SOUTH AFRICA:
Companies listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange have been producing
integrated Reports since 2010
The Integrated Reporting Committee of South Africa endorsed the International
<IR> Framework in 2014.
JAPAN:
Around 200 companies adopted Integrated Reporting
Japan's Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry has endorsed <IR> as a means
of communicating the long-term value creation proposition of companies.
SINGAPORE:
The Singapore Stock Exchange produces an integrated report
The Singapore Accountancy Commission is working with the Ministry of Finance
to set out a route towards Singapore’s adoption of <IR>
MALAYSIA:
Malaysian Prime Minister said, “..the Securities Commission, together with
professional bodies and other stakeholders, is exploring avenues to enhance
the quality of information available to the capital market. One of the options
being considered is the eventual introduction of <IR> 26
26
GLOBAL STATUS OF INTEGRATED REPORTING
SAARC COUNTRIES :
The Indian <IR> Lab led by the Confederation of Indian Industry and
comprised of 9 leading companies and support from ICAI, Cost Accountants
and Corp Secretaries, is engaged in <IR> research and dissemination,
leading to production of IR in industries and corporate sectors
SEBI has provided a vision and momentum is building
India - SR Mandatory for Listed Companies - Detailed National Guidelines
on Social, Environmental & Economic Responsibilities of Business Issued by
Ministry of Corporate Affairs -Elucidating on Sustainable Development and
Transparency Imperative, Overview of SR Link to GRI Framework. SR
Awards by ICAI & ICA Cost from …... IR Awards?
Pakistan - Extensive Application of SR (Not Mandatory). SR Awards Jointly
Organized by ICAP/ICMAP from 2011. IR Awards ?
Sri Lanka - Mandatory Application of SR. Increasing IR Application (Not
Mandatory). SR Awards by CA SL/CMA SL for Several Years……….
Nepal - Voluntary Application of SR . IR ? Awards Not Introduced
Bangladesh - Increasing Voluntary Application of SR (Financial Sector
Entities, Multinationals). IR - Thought Process ! (Appendices). ICAB
Initiatives for SR/ IR Awards. Green Banking/Reporting Mandatory for
Banks/CG and CSR Reports widely Published 27
27
SAFA INTEGRATED REPORTING AWARDS
SAFA has been giving Awards for Integrated Reporting category since the last
couple of years, as an integral component of SAFA annual BPA Awards.
The recipients for the SAFA Integrated Reporting Awards 2016, for Corporate
Reports 2015 are as follows:
28
28
IR IMPEDIMENTS / CHALLENGES
29
IR CHALLENGES
Bangladesh Status
30
IR CHALLENGES
32
OPPORTUNITIES AND PROSPECTS
Scope of Value Reporting Practices Orientation through PPP Between OCAG & ICAB
Aimed at Implementation of SR & IR In Public and Private Sectors of Bangladesh
34
ROLE OF ACCOUNTANCY PROFESSION / OPPORTUNITIES
35
ROLE OF ACCOUNTANCY PROFESSION / OPPORTUNITIES
36
ACCOUNTANTS – CATALYST FOR INNOVATIVE CHANGE
IN PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR REPORTING / OPPORTUNITIES
37
ICAB INITIATIVES
Albeit a late starter, the ICAB is moving in strides to position itself formidably to
develop awareness and promote the application of IR in the public & private
sectors -financial and corporate sector entities of Bangladesh.
As the custodian of corporate reporting in the country, the ICAB is taking-up its
position firmly to catalyze and encourage the development, implementation of
Integrated Reporting practices through dissemination of the opportunities,
benefits and value additions of IR, to diverse stakeholders and charting the
future dimensions of best global practices in IR. ICAB is considering
formulating Value Reporting Guidelines and develop a broad-based Business
Case as a marketing tool to promote conceptualization and understanding for
implementation of IR in the financial and corporate sectors. This will inspire the
CAG office to contemplate moving to IR in certain types of public sector
corporation and entities. ICAB is relentlessly exerting its best efforts to serve
the public interest, and for enhancement of knowledge, skills & competence,
- and thereby employment opportunities and earnings off its member .
39
POLICY ISSUES & RECOMMENDATIONS
Initiate Joint Project (Knowledge Sharing) with OCAG for Development &
Implementation of SR/IR Practices in Public & Private Sector Entities
43
WILL IR GET OFF THE GROUND ?
or Will it have a spinning effect?
Definitely Yes !
(Global Implementation Timeframe) 44
MESSAGE
THANK YOU
APPENDIX-I
46
APPENDIX-II
47
47
APPENDIX-III
48
48
APPENDIX-IV
49
APPENDIX-V
50
APPENDIX-VI