Synthesis Matrix

How to Use a Concept Matrix
Contributor: Aaron Smale
For research papers, literature reviews, or longer essays, a concept matrix can be an effective resource
in organizing research. A concept matrix is an organizational tool that presents connections between
available research articles and specific aspects of a chosen topic by having articles on one side and the
specific parts of a topic on the other side. Each cell in the matrix is a visual representation of potential
intersections between different parts of the larger topic.
For example, a concept matrix for a literature review on sustainability may look something like this:
Concept Matrix for Sustainability Literature Review
Aspect of Topic
Natural
Economic
Resource Biodiversity Pollution Urbanization
Impacts
Levels
Ochoa & Mayer
(1983) X X X
Douglas (1997) X X X
Article
Yamamoto et al.
(2009) X X X
Chambers, Burton, &
Kennedy (2012) X X
Baker & Jackson
(2015) X X X X
How Topics Come Together
For the purposes of this literature review, this concept matrix demonstrates several options for an initial
draft. If we wanted to discuss issues of our topic like biodiversity and pollution, for example, we would
want to use the articles from Douglas, Yamamoto et al., and Baker and Jackson. However, if we wanted
to extend the conversation to include urbanization, our matrix shows us that Douglas may not be an
effective option because urbanization is not discussed in his article. A concept matrix also highlights
gaps in your research, demonstrating where you may need additional support. Especially for literature
reviews, a single source is not enough to substantiate a claim.
How a Concept Matrix Strengthens Synthesis
A concept matrix is helpful to identify opportunities for synthesis, which can be described as the “bigger
picture” of your topic revealed by overlapping claims in individual sources. For example, four out of the
five articles in the example concept matrix discuss natural resource levels, which indicate this is a critical
aspect to discuss.
Even though each of these authors may be discussing natural resource levels, they may not be saying
the same things about it. Ochoa and Mayer (1983) may comment that natural resource levels are solely
impacted by urbanization, while the research conducted by Baker and Jackson (2015) may indicate that
natural resource levels have a significant causal relationship to biodiversity. The overlap here builds a
larger picture of how natural resource levels, urbanization, and biodiversity all relate, even though not
all of the authors discuss all of these subjects.
Synthesis occurs between these two articles when we can see how they present a bigger picture. Since
both of these articles discuss natural resource levels and urbanization, we can think of this as a
“conversation starter” where we can ask questions such as:
 What do these authors agree on related to these aspects of sustainability?
 How do they disagree about these common aspects?
 How is it significant that some aspects are discussed in certain articles and not in others?
o For example, how is it significant that Baker and Jackson (2015) discuss biodiversity and
pollution while Ochoa and Mayer (1983) do not?
o Are Baker and Jackson filling in gaps in the previous research conducted by Ochoa and
Mayer?
 Between the publications of different articles, how has previous research been changed, added
to, or disproven by recent literature?
o Given that Baker and Jackson’s work is more current than Ochoa and Mayer’s research,
how has the earlier discussion about natural resource levels or urbanization changed?
What new questions have been raised in the last thirty years?
o If the previous research by Ochoa and Mayer was important in the field at the time, do
Baker and Jackson reference it or comment on it in their own work?
These are all effective types of questions to ask to work toward synthesis. A concept matrix helps you
identify gaps in research and opportunities for synthesis.

Synthesis Matrix

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Synthesis Matrix

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Synthesis Matrix

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

How to Use a Concept Matrix

Contributor: Aaron Smale

You might also like