Jeffrey W. Young Jr. Complaint
Jeffrey W. Young Jr. Complaint
Jeffrey W. Young Jr. Complaint
v. No. 74895
Comes now the Plaintiffs, Richard Reitz and Dharmesh S. Patel, individually and as
derivative action plaintiffs on behalf of PreventaGenix, LCC, and for their Amended Complaint
1. Plaintiff Richard Reitz ("Mr. Reitz"), is an adult citizen and resident of Riverside County,
California,
2. Plaintiff Dhannesh S. Patel, M.D. (''Dr. Patel") is an adult citizen and resident of Shelby
County, Tennessee
3. Defendant Jeffrey Walter Young, Jr. ("Mr. Young") is an adult citizen and resident of
company ("LLC") having its principal place of business located at 162 Murray Guard Drive
#A. Jackson. Tennessee 38305, and which can be served through its registered agent for
service of process. Christopher Hayden, at 45 Murray Guard Drive, Jackson, Tennessee
38305.
5. This lawsuit arises from the membership interests and management of PreventaGenix,
6. This Court has jurisdiction of the instant case pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann.§§ 16-11-102
7. Venue in the instant case is properly found in Madison County, Tennessee, pursuant to
Tenn. Code Ann.§§ 20-4-101 & 104 and Tenn. Code Ann.§ 48-249-506.
11. FACTS
8. Mr. Reitz, Mr. Young, and Dr. Patel (collectively, the "Members") organized
Revised Limited Liability Company Act, Tenn. Code Ann. §§ 48-249-10 l et seq.
10. PreventaGenix was formed for the purpose of operating a medical clinic providing
11. The Members each contributed Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000) capital to
PreventaGenix.
12. The Members each own one-third {1/3) of the outstanding membership interests of
PreventaGenix.
13. Mr. Reitz is currently a member of PrcvcntaGenix and owns one-third ( l /3) of the
14. Dr. Patel is currently a member of PreventaGenix and owns one-third (l/3) of the
2
15. The Members did not sign an operating agreement for Preventafienix.
16. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann.§ 48-249-304(b), "If the LLC documents do not provide for
allocations of profits and losses, profits and losses shall be allocated among the members
17. The Members are entitled to share in the profits of PreventaGenix one-third each.
18. The Members each personaJiy guaranteed credit and lease obligations of PreventaGenix.
19. The Members authorized PreventaGenix to open two bank accounts at First Tennessee
Bank and Regions Bank, and all three of the Members were signatories on said bank
accounts.
21. The Members agreed that Mr. Young was to receive a salary of Seventy-Five Thousand
Dollars ($75,000.00) per year from PrevenraGenix for working full-time for PreventaGenix
as a nurse practitioner.
22. Beginning in November 2014, and continuing to the present date, Mr. Young wrongfully
23. Mr. Young wrongfully has refused to allow Mr. Reitz access to records of PreventaGenix,
{a) General. An LLC shall provide members, and their agents and
attorneys, access to its records at the LLC's principal executive office or
other reasonable location specified in the LLC documents. An LLC shall
provide former members, and their agents and attorneys, access to records
for proper purposes pertaining to the periods during which they were
members. The right of access provides the opportunity to inspect or copy
records during ordinary business hours, if the member, or its agent or
attorney, gives the LLC written notice of such demand at least five (5)
3
business days before the date on which the member, or its agent or attorney,
wishes to inspect or copy. An LLC may impose a reasonable charge, limited
to the costs of labor and material, for copies of records furnished under this
subsection (a), except that copies of the LLC documents and records
required to be maintained under § 48-249-406 shall be copied upon demand
and at the LLC's expense.
(c) Holders of financial rights. Holders of financial rights, and their agents
and attorneys, shall have a limited right of access, in order to obtain
information reasonably required to comply with the requirements of either
federal or state tax laws concerning their financial rights. The right of access
provides the opportunity to inspect or copy records for such purpose during
ordinary business hours, if the holder of financial rights, or its agent or
attorney, gives the LLC written notice of a demand to inspect or copy the
records at least five (5) business days before the date on which the holder
of financial rights, or its agent or attorney, wishes to inspect or copy. An
LLC may impose a reasonable charge, limited to the costs of labor and
material, for copies of records furnished.
(d) Remedies. If an LLC does not allow a member that complies with
subsectionra), or a holder of financial rights that complies with subsection
(c), as applicable, to inspect or copy any records required by the applicable
subsection to be available for inspection, a court in the county in which the
principal executive office of the LLC, or, if none in this state, its registered
office, is located may summarily order inspection or copying of the records
demanded, at the expense of the LLC, on application of such member or
holder of financial rights, as applicable. If the court orders inspection or
copying of the records demanded, it shall also order the LLC to pay the
costs, including reasonable attorneys fees, of the member or holder of
financial rights, as applicable, incurred to obtain the order, if the member or
holder of financial rights proves that the LLC refused inspection without a
reasonable basis for doubt regarding the right of the member or bolder of
financial rights to inspect the records demanded. If the court orders
4
inspection or copying of the records demanded, it may impose reasonable
restrictions on the use or distribution of the records by the demanding
member or holder of financial rights, as applicable.
26. On June 24, 2015, Mr. Reitz, by and through counsel, sent a Jetter to Christopher Hayden,
5
and demanding to share in the profits and management of PreventaGenix. A true and
27. Mr. Young has caused PreventaGenix to disburse money to pay Mr. Young's personal
28. Mr. Young has taken pay from PreventaGenix in excess of Mr. Young's salary authorized
by the Members.
29. Mr. Young has caused PreventaGenix to pay the personal expenses of other employees of
30. Mr. Young has allowed a debit card in the name of Mr. Reitz for PreventaGenix's first
bank account at Regions Bank to be activated, and Mr. Young or some other person, with
Mr. Young's knowledge and permission, has used said debit card in the name of Mr. Reitz
to make purchases and withdraw funds from PreventaGenix 's bank account.
31. Mr. Young has opened a new bank account in the name of PrcvcntaGcnix at Regions Bank
and set up said bank account with only himself and employee Kristie Gutgsell as
32. Mr. Young has caused PreventaGenix to improperly pay for health insurance of some of
33. Mr. Young has received cash payments for services he provided through PreventaGenix,
and such payments have not been deposited into the business.
34. Mr. Young has conducted himself in the community in a manner which has banned the
35. Upon information and belief, Mr. Young has caused PreventaGenix to fail to pay payroll
6
36. Upon information and belief, Mr. Young has caused PreventaGenix to pay individuals for
services without said individuals being employees of PrcventaGenix and without issuing
37. Mr. Young has overstaffed PreventaGenix in excess of industry norms for the type of
PreventaGenix.
38. Mr. Young has refused to provide financial accounting of PreventaGenix to Mr. Reitz.
39. Mr. Young has not disbursed their proper respective shares of the profits of PreventaGenix
40. Mr. Reitz has not received any disbursements from PreventaGenix, and Dr. Patel has
received only one Five Thousand Dollars ($5,000.00) payment from Preventafienix on
behalf of Mr. Young for money that Dr. Patel was owed from Premier Cardiovascular
Consultants, LLC, another LLC in which Dr. Patel, Mr. Reitz, and Mr. Young were
members.
41. Upon information and belief, PreventaGenix bas failed to file a year 2015 federal income
tax return.
42. PreventaGenix has failed to issue a Schedule K-1 to Mr. Reitz or to Dr. Patel for year 20 I 5
showing Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's shares of the profits or losses of PreventaGenix.
43. On April 26, 2016, Mr. Reitz, by and through counsel, sent a Jetter to Christopher Hayden,
attorney for PrevcntaGenix, inquiring if PreventaGcnix had filed a 2015 federal income tax
return and requests a copy of same, a Schedule K-1 for Mr. Reitz. and copies of the
underlying reports and financial information of Preventagenix. A true and correct copy of
7
44. To date, no 2015 federal income tax return for PreventaGenix or Schedule K-1 has been
45. Mr. Young may have committed other improper acts which are not known to Mr. Reitz
and/or Dr. Patel currently, because Mr. Young has not allowed Mr. Reitz access to the
46. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel reaJlege and incorporate Paragraphs l through 45 of this Complaint
47. The actions of Mr. Young as set forth herein constitute wrongful conversion of the assets
of PreventaGenix.
48. PreventaGenix is entitled to recover a monetary judgment against Mr. Young for the value
of the assets converted by Mr. Young, and Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel, as members owning
one-third each of the membership interests of PreventaGcnix, are entitled to receive a one-
49. In the alternative, Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled to monetary judgments against Mr.
Young for one-third each of the value of the assets converted by Mr. Young.
50. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel reallege and incorporate paragraphs l through 49 of this complaint
51. The actions of Mr. Young as set forth herein constitute improper distributions to Mr.
8
(I) The LLC would not be able to pay its debts as they become due
in the ordinary course of business; or
(2) The LLC's total assets would be less than the sum of its total
liabilities, other than liabilities for which the recourse of creditors is
limited to specified property, plus the amount that would be needed,
if the LLC were to be dissolved, wound up and terminated at the
time of the distribution, to satisfy the preferential rights upon
dissolution, winding up and termination of members and holders of
financial rights, whose preferential rights are superior to those
receiving the distribution; provided, however, that the value of
property that is subject to a liability for which the recourse of
creditors is limited shall be included in the total assets of the LLC,
only to the extent that the value of the property exceeds such
liability.
9
(f) Treatment of payments. If the indebtedness is issued as a distribution,
each payment of principal or interest on the indebtedness is treated as a
distribution, the effect of which is measured on the date the payment is
made.
54. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-307(a), Mr. Young is personally liable to
PreventaGenix for amount of the distributions that exceed the amounts that could have
10
55. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-307{b), Mr. Young is personally liable to
Preventagenix to the extent that the distribution Mr. Young received exceeded the amount
that could have been properly distributed under Tenn. Code. Ann. § 48-249-306.
56. Mr. Reitz, Dr. Patel, and/or PreventaGenix are entitled to a court order enjoining Mr.
57. PreventaGenix is entitled to recover a monetary judgment against Mr. Young for the
improper distributions made and received by Mr. Young, and Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel, as
members owning one-third each of the membership interests of PreventaGcnix, arc entitled
58. In the alternative, Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled to monetary judgments against Mr.
Young for one-third each of the improper distributions made and received by Mr. Young.
59. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel reallege and incorporate paragraphs I through 58 of this complaint
60. The actions of Mr. Young and the actions which Mr. Young has caused PrcventaGenix to
61. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann.§ 48-249-IOS(b)(l) and (b)(2) a limited liability company's
power to act may be challenged in a proceeding by a member against the limited liability
company to enjoin the act or derivatively against a member of the limited liability
company, and pursuant to subsection (c), the court may enjoin the unauthorized limited
1I
(a} Limit on power to challenge. Except as provided in subsection (b), the
validity of an LLC's action may not be challenged on the ground that the
LLC lacks or lacked the power to act.
64. Mr. Reitz and Dr .. Patel rightfully bring this proceeding individually and as derivative
plaintiffs, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann.§§ 48~249-JOS(b)(l) & (2) and 801(b).
12
A complaint in a proceeding brought in the right of an LLC shall allege with
particularity the demand made, if any, to obtain action by the directors,
managers, officers, members or other persons with the authority to act, as
applicable, and either that the demand was refused or ignored, or why the
member or holder of financial rights, as applicable, did not make the
demand.
66. Letters demanding Mr. Reitz's share of the LLC's profits, access to reports and financial
records, and participation in the management of the LLC are attached hereto as Exhibit A
and ExhibitB.
67. If Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's proceeding as derivative plaintiffs is successful in whole or
in pan, the court may grant Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel any equitable relief it considers just
and reasonable, and may award Mr. Reitz and Or. Patel their reasonable expenses,
including reasonable attorney's fees, pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-804 and 805.
13
expenses, including attorneys' fees and disbursements, to the member or
holder of financial rights, as applicable.
70. The ultra vi res actions of Mr. Young and which Mr. Young has caused PreventaGenix to
71. PreventaGenix is entitled to recover a monetary judgment against Mr. Young for all funds
disbursed or paid to Mr. Young or other persons or entities due to the ultra vires actions of
Mr. Young and which Mr. Young has caused PreventaGenix to take, and Mr. Reitz and Dr.
72. In the alternative, Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled to monetary judgments against Mr.
Young for one-third each of all funds disbursed or paid to Mr. Young or other persons or
entities due to the ultra vires actions of Mr. Young and which Mr. Young has caused
PreventaGenix to take.
73. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. §§ 48-249-804 and 805, Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled
to a monetary judgment against Mr. Young and PreventaGcnix for Mr. Reitz 's and Dr.
74. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel reallege and incorporate paragraphs 1 through 73 of this complaint
75. The actions of Mr. Young as set forth herein constitute breaches of fiduciary duty, in
14
holder of financial rights owes no duties to the LLC, or to the other members
or holders, solely by reason of being a holder of financial rights.
(d) Good faith and fair dealing. A member shall discharge the member's
duties to a member-managed LLC and its other members and holders of
financial rights under this chapter or under the LLC documents, and shall
exercise any rights with respect to the LLC consistently with the obligation
of good faith and fair dealing.
15
(2) A manager is held to the same standards of conduct prescribed
for members in subsections (b)-(f);
(3) A member that, under the LLC documents, exercises some or
all of the rights of a manager in the management and conduct of the
LLC's business is held to the standards of conduct prescribed for a
member in subsections (b )-( f) to the extent that the member
exercises the managerial authority vested in a manager by this
chapter; and
(4) A manager is relieved of liability imposed by law for violation
of the standards prescribed by subsections (b)-(f) to the extent of the
managerial authority delegated to the members by the LLC
documents.
16
( l ) One ( 1) or more officers or employees of the LLC whom the
member, manager, director or officer reasonably believes to be
reliable and competent in the matters presented;
(2) Legal counsel, public accountants or other persons as to matters
the member, manager, director or officer reasonably believes are
within the person's professional or expert competence; or
(3) In the case of a director only, a committee of the board of
directors of which the director is not a member, if the director
reasonably believes the committee merits confidence.
77. PreventaGenix is entitled to recover a monetary judgment against Mr. Young for all funds
disbursed or paid to Mr. Young or other persons or entities in breach of Mr. Young's
fiduciary duties to PrevcntaGcnix and for all damages caused to PrcventaGenix by Mr.
Young's breaches of his fiduciary duties to PreventaGenix, and Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel, as
members owning one-third each of the membership interests of PreventaGenix, are entitled
78. In the alternative, Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel entitled to monetary judgments against Mr.
Young for one-third each of a11 funds disbursed or paid to Mr. Young or other persons or
17
entities in breach of Mr. Young's fiduciary duties to PreventaGenix and for all damages
PreventaGenix.
79. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel reallege and incorporate paragraphs 1 through 78 of this complaint
80. The actions of Mr. Young as set forth herein constitute a violation of Tenn. Code Ann.§
48-249-308(a), which requires that a limited liability company provide members and their
agents and attorneys with access to the limited liability company's records, and Tenn. Code
Ann. § 48-249-406, which lists the records required to be kept at the limited liability
81. As required by Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-308(a}, Mr. Reitz, through his attorney,
records, and a true and correct copy of said letter is attached hereto as Exhibit A.
82. Mr. Young has refused to provide access to the records of PreventaGenix to Mr. Reitz.
83. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-308(d), Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled to a
court order requiring Mr. Young and PreventaGenix to allow inspection or copying of the
84. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-308(d), Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled to a
monetary judgment against Mr. Young and PreventaGenix for Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's
costs, including reasonable attorney's fees, incurred to obtain such court order due to Mr.
Young's refusal to allow Mr. Reitz to inspect the records without a reasonable basis for
doing so.
18
VIII. CAUSE OF ACTION 6 - PROFITS AND DISTRIBUTIONS
85. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel reallege and incorporate Paragraphs I through 84 of this Complaint
86. The actions of Mr. Young as set forth herein constitute a violation of Tenn. Code Ann. §
48-249-304(b), which requires that profits and losses of a limited liability company shall
87. The actions of MT. Young as set forth herein constitute a violation of Tenn. Code Ann. §
88. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled to a one-third share each of PreventaGenix 's profits
and distributions.
89. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel are entitled to monetary judgments against PreventaGenix and Mr.
Young for Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's one-third share each of PrevenraGenix's profits and
distributions.
90. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel reallege and incorporate Paragraphs l through 89 of this Complaint
19
(3) The transfer of all of the member's financial rights, unless the transfer
is for security purposes, and has not been foreclosed or is under a court order
charging the member's financial rights;
( 4) The member is expelled under the LLC documents;
(5) The member is expelled by unanimous vote of the other members
entitled to vote, if:
(A) It is unlawful to carry on the business of the LLC with the
member;
(B)
(i) The member is a corporation or an LLC;
(ii) Within ninety (90) days after the LLC notifies the
member that it will be expelled, because it has filed a
certificate of dissolution, or the equivalent, its charter or
articles of organization, or the equivalent, have been
revoked, or its right to conduct business has been suspended
by the jurisdiction of its formation; and
(iii) The member fails to obtain a revocation of the
certificate of dissolution or a reinstatement of its charter or
articles of organization, or the equivalent, or its right to
conduct business within such ninety-day period; or
(C) The member is a general or limited partnership and has been
dissolved and its business is being wound up;
( 6) On application by the LLC or another member, the member is expelled
by judicial determination, because the member:
(A) Engaged in wrongful conduct that adversely and materially
affected the LLC's business;
(B) Willfully or persistently committed a material breach of the
LLC documents, or of a duty owed under § 48-249-403 to the LLC
or to other members or to holders; or
(C} Engaged in conduct relating to the LLC's business that makes
it not reasonably practicable to carry on the business with the
member;
(7) The member:
(A) Files a petition as a debtor in bankruptcy;
(B) Executes an assignment for the benefit of creditors;
(C) Seeks, consents to, or acquiesces in the appointment of a trustee,
receiver or liquidator for or of the member, or for or of all or
substantially all of the member's property; or
(D) Fails, within ninety (90) days after the filing or appointment, to
have dismissed the filing against the member of an involuntary
petition in bankruptcy, or to have vacated or stayed the appointment
of a trustee, receiver or liquidator for or of the member, or for or of
all or substantially all of the member's property obtained without the
member's consent or acquiescence, or fails within ninety (90) days
after the expiration of a stay, to have the appointment vacated;
(8) In the case of a member who is an individual:
20
(A) The member dies;
(B) A personal representative is appointed for the member; or
(C} A judicial determination that the member has become incapable
of performing the member's duties under the LLC documents;
(9) In the case of a member that is a trust or is acting as a member by virtue
of being a trustee of a trust, the distribution of all of the trust's financial
rights, but not merely by reason of the substitution of a successor trustee;
provided, however, that a distribution to a beneficiary of a trust established
under§ 2503(c) of the Code, codified in 26 U.S.C. § 2503(c), or a trust that
is treated under § 676 of the Code, codified in 26 U.S.C. § 676, as owned
by the scttlor of the trust, shall not be considered to be a distribution of
financial rights under this subdivision (a)(9);
(I 0) In the case of a member that is an estate, or is acting as a member by
virtue of being a personal representative of an estate, distribution of all of
the estate's financial rights, but not merely the substitution of a successor
personal representative or beneficiary;
( 11) Jn the case of a custodianship under the Uniform Transfers to Minors
Act, compiled in title 35, chapter 7, part 2, or the equivalent law of any
foreign jurisdiction, a transfer of the financial rights held by the custodian,
but not a transfer to the beneficiary for whom the custodian is holding the
financial rights; or
(I 2) Termination of the existence of a member, if the member is an entity
other than an estate, or trust, other than a business trust.
21
92. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Aim.§ 48-249-503(a)(l ), a member of a limited liability company
may terminate his membership interest effective at a later date by giving notice of the
93. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel each hereby gives notice of his intent to withdraw as a member of
94. In the alternative, Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel request that the Court judicially dissolve and
wind-up Preventagenix as an equitable remedy due to the improper actions of Mr. Young
A court may grant any equitable relief it considers just and reasonable under
the circumstances, may dissolve an LLC or may direct that the dissolved
LLC be merged into another or new LLC or other entity, or otherwise be
terminated, on the terms and conditions the court deems equitable.
(a) Venue. Venue for a proceeding by the attorney general and reporter to
dissolve, wind up and terminate an LLC lies in Davidson County. Venue
for a proceeding brought by any other person lies in the county where the
LLC's principal executive office is or was last located.
22
(b) Members not necessary parties. It is not necessary to make members
parties to a proceeding to dissolve, wind up and terminate the existence of
an LLC, unless relief is sought against them individually. ·
23
such member, shall be considered merely the holder of the financial
rights owned before the termination under§ 48-249-503(a)(8);
(2) If the existence and business of the LLC are continued, for a
period of sixty (60) days following the event specified in § 48-249-
503(a)(8} that results in the suspension of governance rights under
subdivision (b )(I), the personal representative of the affected
member shall have the option, exercisable by giving written notice
to the LLC, to require the LLC to purchase the membership interest
of the member whose membership interest has terminated under
subsection (c) and§ 48-249-506. If the personal representative fails
to make such election within such period, then the LLC shall have
the option for a period of sixty ( 60) days following expiration of the
personal representative's option, or, if ear1ier, following the date of
written notice from the personal representative that such option will
not be exercised, to give written notice to the personal representative
that the LLC will purchase the membership interest in accordance
with subsection (c) and § 48-249-506. If neither the personal
representative nor the LLC elects to exercise their respective options
to cause the LLC to purchase the membership interest, the
governance rights associated with the membership interest shall be
restored, effective as of the first day following expiration of the
LLC's option period, and the personal representative shall be
automatically admitted and substituted as a member of the LLC
without further action. If either the personal representative or the
LLC elects to cause the LLC to purchase the membership interest,
the suspension of governance rights associated with such
membership interest shall continue through the time the purchase is
consummated; and
(3) If the existence and business of the LLC are not continued, the
personal representative of the member whose membership interest
has terminated retains all governance rights owned by the affected
member before the termination of the membership interest, and may
exercise those rights through the winding up and termination of the
LLC, except as otherwise provided under§ 48-249~504, in the case
of termination in contravention of the LLC documents.
(c) Purchase at fair value. If the existence and business of the LLC are
continued following the termination of a membership interest under § 48-
249-503( a}, other than terminations arising under § 48~249~503(a)(3 },
(a)(9), (a)(l 0) or (a)(l l }, then, regardless whether such termination of
membership interest was wrongful, any member whose membership
interest has so terminated, other than a member for whom a personal
representative has been automatically substituted and admitted as a member
under subdivision (b)(2), is entitled, subject to the offset provisions of§ 48-
249-504(2). to receive from the LLC the fair value of the terminated
membership interest as of the date of termination of such membership
24
interest, calculated as set forth in§ 48-249-506, in consideration for all such
membership interest.
25
proceeding. The jurisdiction of the court in which the
proceeding is commenced under this subdivision (3) is
plenary and exclusive. The court shall determine the fair
value of the membership interest, in accordance with the
standards set forth in subdivision (3 )(B) together with the
terms for payment; and
(B) In a proceeding brought to determine the fair value of a
membership interest in an LLC, the court:
(i) Shall enforce any governing terms in the LLC
documents as to the amount of fair value and other
tcnns of payment as provided in subdivision (2);
(ii) In the absence of any such governing terms in
the LLC documents, shall determine the fair value of
tbe membership interest, considering, among other
relevant evidence, the going concern value of the
LLC, any other agreement among any members
fixing the price or specifying a formula for
determining value of membership interests for any
other purpose, the recommendations of an appraiser
appointed by the court, if any, the recommendations
of any of the appraisers of the parties to the
proceeding, and any legal or financial constraints on
the ability of the LLC to purchase the membership
interest;
(iii) Shall specify the terms of the purchase,
including, if appropriate, terms for installment
payments, subordination of the purchase obligation
to the rights of the other creditors of the LLC,
security, including the purchased membership
interest, for a deferred purchase price, and a covenant
not to compete or other restriction on the member
whose membership interest has terminated;
(iv) Shall require, subject to retention ofany security
interest by the member whose membership interest
has terminated under subdivision (3)(B)(iii) the
member whose membership interest has terminated
to deliver an instrument of transfer of the
membership interest to the LLC upon receipt of the
purchase price or the first installment of the purchase
price;
(v) May award one (I) or more other parties their
reasonable expenses, including attorney's fees and
the expenses of appraisers or other experts, incurred
in the proceeding, if the court finds that a party to the
proceeding violated such party's obligations to act in
26
good faith and to engage in fair dealing set forth in §
48-249-403(d}; and
(vi) Shall order that interest, al the rate specified for
judgments under§ 47-14-121, shall be paid on such
amount, from the date such amount was determined
to be due through the date of payment, if the court
determines that all or any instaJlment of the amounts
to be paid in respect of the terminating member's
membership interest should have been paid prior to
the date of judgment.
100. Pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-505(c), Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel each is
entitled to receive from PrcventaGenix the fair value of his one-third membership interest,
calculated as provided in forth in Tenn. Code Ann. § 48-249-506 and subject to the terms
101. As part of the purchase of Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's respective membership
interests and/or the dissolution and winding up of PrcventaGenix, PrevenraGenix and Mr.
Young should be required to prepay the computer lease of PreventaGenix and any other
obligations which the Members have guaranteed or secure the release of Mr. Reitz and Dr.
I 02. Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel each is entitled to a monetary judgment against
PreventaGenix for the fair market value Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's respective one-third
I 03. Due to Mr. Young's breaches of his fiduciary duties, as set forth herein, Mr. Reitz
and Dr. Patel are entitled to monetary judgments against PreventaGenix and Mr. Young
for Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's expenses, including attorney's fees, for the determination
of the fair market value of Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's membership interest in
PreventaGenix.
27
104. In the alternative, Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel request that the Court judicially expel
A. Issue proper process to be served upon the defendants and that they be required to appear
B. Determine the amount of the bond to be posted by Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel pursuant to
C. Upon separate motion, enjoin Mr. Young and PreventaGcnix from wrongfully making
improper distributions and payments and from taking ultra vires actions, including but not
limited to personal expenses of employees, health insurance for employees, and Mr.
D. Grant Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel a court order requiring Mr. Young and PreventaGenix to
E. If the Court determines it to be appropriate, appoint a receiver or custodian pendent lite for
F. Grant PreventaGenix a monetary judgment against Mr. Young in an amount of not more
than Nine Hundred Thousand Dollars ($900,000.00) for the value of the assets converted
by Mr. Young, for the improper distributions made and received by Mr. Young, for all
funds disbursed or paid to Mr. Young other persons or entities due to the ultra vi res actions
of Mr. Young and which Mr. Young has caused Preventagenix to take, and for all funds
disbursed or paid to Mr. Young or other persons or entities in breach of Mr. Young's
fiduciary duties to PreventaGenix and for all damages caused to PreventaGenix by Mr.
28
Young's breaches of his fudiciary duties to PreventaGenix; and grant Mr. Reitz and Dr.
G. In the alternative, grant Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel monetary judgments against Mr. Young in
an amount of not more than Three Hundred Thousand Dollars ($300,000.00) each for one-
third each of the value of the assets converted by Mr. Young, for one-third each of the
improper distributions made and received by Mr. Young, for one-third each of all funds
disbursed or paid to Mr. Young other persons or entities due to the ultra vires actions of
Mr. Young and which Mr. Young has caused Preventagenix to take, for one-third each of
all funds disbursed or paid to Mr. Young or other persons or entities in breach of Mr.
Young's fiduciary duties to PreventaGenix, and for one-third each of all damages caused
H. Grant Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel monetary judgments in an amount of not more than Five
Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000.00) each against PreventaGenix and Mr. Young for
Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's one-third share each of the PreventeGenix's profits and
distributions;
J. Grant Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel monetary judgments in an amount of not more than Two
Hundred Thousand Dollars ($200,000.00) each against PreventaGenix for the fair market
values of Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's respective one-third membership interests each in
PreventaGenix;
29
K. Require PreventaGenix and Mr. Young to prepay the computer lease of PreventaGenix and
any other obligations which the Members have guaranteed or secure the release of Mr.
L. Grant Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel monetary judgments against Mr. Young and PreventaGenix
for Mr. Reitz's and Dr. Patel's reasonable attorneys' fees and expenses;
N. Grant Mr. Reitz and Dr. Patel such further and other general relief to which they may be
entitled.
Respectfully submitted,
COST BOND
)!
30
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that a true copy of the foregoing has been served on:
PreventaGenix LLC
162 Murray Guard Drive # A
Jackson, Tennessee 38305
PreventaGenix LLC
c/o Christopher Hayden
45 Murray Guard Drive
Jackson, Tennessee 38305
by placing a copy of the same in the United States Mail, postage prepaid, to the person, at the
address shown above, on this the~ day of November, 2016.
31
SEILER & HOUSTON, PLLC
Atlomeys al Law
121 A Stoncbridgc Boulevard (38305}
Post Office Box I 0455
Jarksou, Tennessee 38:108
Telephone (731 ),~00-3656 Facsimile {7.~ I )30()..3657
Dear Chris:
Following up on our telephone conversation of June 19, 2015, I'm writing on behalf of my
client, Mr. Richard Reitz, regarding Premier Cardiovascular Consultants, LLC ("PCC"), and
PreventaGenix, LLC ("PreventaGenix").
As you know, Mr. Reitz, Dr. Dharmesh Patel, and Mr. Jeffrey Young, Jr., each own one-
third membership interests in PreventaGenix. As a member, Mr. Reitz has a right to share in the
profits of the company, to access the financial records of the company, and to participate in its
management. Mr. Young has wrongfully excluded Mr. Reitz from all those rights. Please address
the following items:
2. Preventagenix uses Paychex, Inc., to process the company's payroll. Mr. Young has denied
Mr. Reitz access to the reports from Paychex. Please state the reason that Mr. Reitz's
access was terminated, and reinstate Mr. Reitz's access to Paychex.
3. PreventaGenix uses Advance Medical Billing to process its billings to insurance companies
and government payers. Mr. Young has denied Mr. Reitz access to the reports from
Advance Medical Billing. Please state the reason that Mr. Reitz's access to the bil1ing
reports was terminated, and provide copies of all billing reports to date and future reports
as received.
EXHIBIT A
4. I understand that Preventagenix may have leased space in downtown Jackson from John
H. Allen Company. 1f that is so, please provide me with a copy of the lease, any other
contracts relating to the leased location, such as construction contracts or equipment leases,
and any documents relating to payments made for the same.
5. Please provide information on how the new location in downtown Jackson will be staffed
and equipped, the projected budget for that location, and the projected patient counts and
revenues for that location.
Mr. Reitz is willing to discuss options for the sale of his membership interests in
PreventaGenix. However, unless and until an agreement is reached, Mr. Reitz remains entitled to
participate in the management of the companies, to access the reports and financial information of
the companies, and to share equally in the profits.
Sincerely,
2
SEILER& H()lJST()N, PLLC
A1101111:ys ;ti Law
12.m Sco11ch1tdgt.' Uoulcmnl (AAHO:'i)
Posl OJlkc Box l0ii5
.lad•sou, Tcnt11.·ss..'l' :-lltilOfl
. Iclcphonc (7311:-U)()..'ifi.)1) F:k·simik Oil I )300-36.'17
Dear Chris:
I'm writing on behalf of my client, Mr. Richard Reitz, regarding Preventaflenix, LLC
{''PreventaGenix"). As you know, Mr. Reitz, Dr. Dhannesh Patel, and Mr. Jeffrey Young, Jr.,
each own one-third membership interests in PreventaGenix. The deadline for Preventagenix to
provide Schedule K· l's to the members for year 2015 was March J 5, 2016. The deadline for the
LLC to file its federal income tax return for year 2015 was April J 8, 2016. To date, Mr. Reitz has
not received a K-1 from PreventaGenix. 'This has forced Mr. Reitz to request an extension for
filing his personal income tax return.
Sincerely,
EXHIBIT B