Urban Development Policies Programmes: Unit 13 AND
Urban Development Policies Programmes: Unit 13 AND
Urban Development Policies Programmes: Unit 13 AND
AND PROGRAMMES
13.0 Inuoduction
K3.0 INTRODUCTION
We have discussed the issues and challenges related to urban development in the
pr~xcdingUnit. But, the urban development issues and challenges can be effectively
addressed only through propzr policies and programmes of urban development. In
Intlia, the Ministry of Urban Development is responsible for formulating policies,
suppofiing and monitoring programmes and coordinating the activities of various Central
Ministries, State Governments and other nodal authorities in so far as they relate to
i~rhandevelopment in the country. Hence, in the present Unit we attempt to present to
!O J a broad picture of the policies and programmes of urban development and their
r.cl~:vanceto addressing of the issues and challengesof urban development in India.
Urban Development
13.1 OBJECTIVES
After going through this Unit, we expect you to be able to:
Explain the sigmficanceand scope of urban development policies and programmes:
Describe different policies and programmes of urban development; and
Analyse or critically examine these policies and programmes in the context of'
different challenges of urban development.
3. 8
These policies and programmes are discussed, in brief, below.
13.2.1 Urban Community Development Programme, 1958 urban Devtdopent
Policies and Pqy-amrnes
In India, the first Urban Community Development Project was initiated in 1958in Delhi
with the help of grant from Ford Foundation. It was subsequently followed by
Ahmedabad (l962), Baroda (1965) and Calcutta (1966) Projects. The Rural-Urban
Relationship Committee Report (1966) did some detailed thinking on urban community
development programme and made recommendations about the lines on which urban
community development programme could be undertaken on nation-wide scale.
During the last year of third Five Year Plan, the Union Ministry of Health initiated 20
pilot projects in selected cities with a population of 1,00,000or more. Each project
was designed to cover a population of 50,000 split into approximately t? mohalla-level
committeeswith a population of 6,000 each, to be further sub-divided into 12primary
units each consisting of a small population of 500. The scheme provided a specific
staffing pattern of a Project Officer and 8 Community Organisers supported by some
v~luntaryworkers for which a sum of Rs.50,000 per annum was allotted. Aseparate
grant of Rs. 1 5,000 was provided for local developmental activities undertaken by the
neighbourhood community on the basis of matching contribution. It was, however,
decided that the expenditure would be shared on the basis of 50% to be paid by the
Central Government and the remaining 50% to be met by the State Government and
the local body concerned. The expenditure on training, evaluation and research was to
be borne by the Central Government (Subhash Chandra, See http://
cdj.oxfordjournals.org/content/9/3/19 1.extract).
Street vendors fornm a very important component of the urban informal sector in India.
In most Indian cities, the urban poor su-vive by working in the informal sector primarily
due to poverty, lack of gainful employment in the rural areas, shrinkage of employment
in the formal sector, and low levels of ski11 and education required for the better paid
jobs in the formal sector. Street vendors are mainly those who are unsuccessful or
unable to get regular jobs. They try to solve their problems through their own meager
resources. Street vendors are regarded as public nuisance and it is said that they
encroach public spaces. The objective to be achieved through the Nation'll l'olicy for
Urban Strcet Vendors, 2004 is to provide and promote a wpportivc environment for
earning livelihoods to the vast mass of urban Strect Vendors. Street Vendors provide
vi~luablcscrvicek TO the urban population while trying to earn a livelihood and it is the
duty ot'the State ro prorcct the right of this segment of popularion to earn their livelihood.
This Policy also a i i m to ensure that this important section of the urban population finds
m recognition far iwcontribution to society, and is conceived of as a major initiative for
urbanpncny alleviation.
For the purposes of this Policy, a Street vendor is broadly defined as 'a person who
offers goods or services for sale to the public without having a permanent built-up
\tructure in a street'. This Policy recognises three basic categories of Street Vendors.
First, those Street Vendors who carry out vending on a regular basis with a specific
location; Second, those Street Vendors who carry out vending not on a regular basis
Urban Development and without a specific location, for example, Vendors who sell goods in weekly bazaars
during holidays and festivals and so on; Third, the Mobile Street Vendors. Thus, the
overarching objective to be achieved through this Policy is to 'Provide andpromote a
supportive environment for earning livelihoods to the vast mass of urban Street
Vendors while ensuring that such activity does not lead to overcrowding and
unsanitary conditions in public spaces and streets'.
2) Objectives of the Mission: The objectives of the JNNCTRM are to ensure that
the following are achieved in the urban sector.
II
c) Ensuring adequate funds to meet the deficiencies in urban infrastructural
services;.
f) Special focus on urban renewal programme for the old-city areas to reduce
congestion; and
3) Scope of the Mission: The Mission shall comprise the two following Sub-
Missions.
ii) Preparing Projects: The CDP would facilitate identification of projects. The
Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) I parastatal agencies will be required to prepare
Detailed Project Reports (DPRs) for undertaking projects in the identified
spheres. It is essential that projects are planned in a manner that optimises
the life-cycle cost of projects. The life-cycle cost of a project would cover
the capital outlays and the attendant 0 & M costs to ensure that assets are in
good working condition. Arevolving fund would be created to meet the 0 &
M requirements of assets created over the planning horizon. In order to seek
JNNURM assistance, projects would need to be developed in a manner
that would,ensureand demonstrate optirnisation of the life-cycle costs over
the planning horizon of the project.
iii) Release and Leveraging of Funds: It is expected that the JNNURM
assistance would serve to catalyse the flow of investment into the urban
infrastructure sector across the country. Funds from the Central and State
Government will flow directly to the nodal agency designated by the State,
as grants-in-aid. The funds for identified projects across cities would be
disbursed to the ULB I Parastatal agency through the designated State Level
Nodal Agency (SLNA) as soft-loan or grant-cum-loan or grant. The SLNA
IULBs in turn would leverage additional resources from other sources.
iv) Incorporating Private Sector Eficiencies: In order to optimise the life-
cycle costs over the planning horizon, private sectorefficienciescan be inducted
in development, management, implementation and financing of projects,
through Public-Private Partnership (PPP) arrangements.
5) Duration of the Mission: The duration of the Mission would be seven years
beginning from the year 2005-06.Evaluation of the experience of implementation
of the Mission would be undertaken before the commencement of Eleventh Five
Year Plan and if necessary, the programme calibrated suitably.
ii) City-wide framework for planning and governance will be established and
become operational.
iii) All urban residents will be able to obtain access to a basic level of urban
services. 43
UrbanDevelopment iv) Financially self-sustainingagencies for urban governance and servicedeliver,
will be established, through reforms to major revenue instruments.
I
Small and Medium Towns ( IDSMT)and Accelerated Urban Water Supply Programme
(AUWSP). The objejecti~.e\ol'~Iit:scheme are to:
Improve it11 ~;~\~ritctur;~l
facilities and help create durable public-assctc
and quality -oricntcd \c.t.vices in cities and towns;
Enhance pu blic-private-partnershipin infrastructural development;and
Promote planned integrated development of towns and cities.
Freight traffic.
Legal and Administrative Issues.
Capacity building.
Use of cleaner technologies.
Innovative financingmechanisms using land as a resource.
Association of the private sector.
2) The second componentof the project is capacity-building for eflective urban po.73rty
monitoring and alleviation.This component will help states and LJLBs: i) to i q w e
skills of practitioners; ii) to recognize and incorporate innovat ve programmea md
best practices; and iii) to diagnose urban poverty and prepare llleviation strate ties
in ULBs. This component will also strengthen Ministry of Housing and Urban
Poverty Alleviation's (MOHUPA's) capacity for urban poverty monitoring and
evaluation.
Reaching the Un-served and Poor: Urban poor communities as well other
residents of informal settlements have been constrained by lack of tenure, space
or economic constraints, in obtaining affordable access to safe sanitation.
In relation to "Payand Use" toilets, the issue of subsidies inadvertently reaching
the non-poor should be addressed by identifying different categories of urban
b) Check your answer with the one given at the end of this unit under
"Answers to 'CheckYour Progress' Questions."
1) List out important policies and programmes of urban development in India.
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
2) State the objectives of JNNURM.
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
- .
I
. -. - ... . - -
....
----A .- --
subordinate
- - staff
Now, we present to you, in brief, about the structure, powers and functions of different
Urban Local Bodies.
18
13.3.1 Nagar Nigams (Corporations): Structure, Powers and ~rbatlDevebme~t
Policies and Programmes
Functions
Large urban areas are governed by nagar nigams, often simply called corporations.
The area under a corporation is divided into wards. Individual wards or collections of
wards within a corporation sometimes have their own administrative body known as
ward committees.
The Mayor heads the Nagar Nigam, the President heads both Nagar Palika Parishads
and Nagar Panchayats. The elected representatives,namely, Mayors/Presidentsexercise
their powers and discharge the duties through committee of elected members, i.e.
corporators, councillors and members of Boards. Nagar Ayukts in case of Nagar
I Nigams, and Executive OfJicers in case of Nagar Palika Parishads and Nagar
Panchayats ate administrativeheads.
The ULBs execute their functions through various committees viz. Planning and
Development Committee, Educat)on Committee, Water Management Committee,
Works Committee, Health and Welfare Committee,Administrative Committee, etc,
They alsoidenhfy the beneficiaries under various schemes,e.g. housing, self-employment,
etc., based on the income criteria and social backwardness.
Councillorsact by committee, the most powerful being the Standing Committee with
its role of the steeringcommittee exercisingexecutive,supervisory,financial and personnel
powers. It is composed of elected members varying in number between seven and
sixteen through a system of proportional representation of councilors.
The Municipal Commissioner is the Chief Executive Officer and head of the executive
arm of the Municipal Corporation. The Commissioneris appointed for a fixed term as
defined by state statute.The Commissioner's term in office can be extended or reduced.
The powers of the Commissioner are those provided by statute and those delegated by
the Corporation or the Standing Committee. All executive powers are vested in the
Municipal Commissioner.Although the Municipal Corporation is the legislative body
that lays down policies for the governance of the city, it is-the Commissioner who is
responsible for the execution of the policies.
1
to three years and is not co-terminus with that of the council.
Urban Development The President has a substantiveposition in the municipal administration and enjoys
significant authority and power both in the deliberative and executive arms of the
municipality. The powers andfinctions of the Municipal Council Committees arc.
the same as those of the Municipal Corporation. In most states, the state government
appoints the Executive Officer. In some states, the council makes the appointment, but
his or her independence has been confiied by making removal from office difficult.
generally by a three-quarter majority vote.
URBAN REFORMS
- -
The 74th ConstitutionalAmendmentAct, 1992was the first step towards Urban Reforms
which mandated setting up of elected municipalities as 'institutions of self-government'
and specSied the function of Urban Local Bodies (ULBs).
11) Provision of urban amenities and facilitiessuch as parks, gardens and play grounds.
12) Promotion of cultural, educational and aesthetic aspects.
13) burials and burial-grounds, cremations, and cremation grounds, and electric
crematoriums.
14) Cattle pounds, prevention of cruelty to animals.
15) Vitalstatistics including registration of births and deaths.
16) Public amenities including street lighting, parking lots, bus-stops and public
conveniences.
17) Regulation of slaughter houses and tanneries.
These functions require finances. However, without assigning a list of local taxes to the
municipal authorities,the Constitution (74"Amendment) Act, 1 B 2 left the matter to
the State Governments. It insertedArticle 243X, which provides that a State Legislature
may, by law (Mohanty, 2005 www.cgg.gov.in/ASCII_Collectors.doc):
a) authorise a Municipality to levy, collect and appropriate such taxes, duties, tolls
and fees in accordance with such procedure and subject to such limit;
b) assign to a Municipality such taxes, duties, tolls and fees levied and collected by
the State Government for such purposes and subject to such conditions and huts;
d) provide for the constitution of such Funds for crediting all moneys received
respectively by or on behalf of the Municipalities and also for the withdrawal of
such moneys therefrom, as may be prescribed by law.
Article 243Y inserted into the Constitution through the 74&AmendmntAct makes it is
mandatory on the part of the Governor of a State for constitution of State Finance
Commission to review:
51
Urban Development a) The principles which should govern:
i) the distribution between the State and the Municipalities of the net-proceeds
of the taxes, duties, tolls and fees leviable by the State, wwch may be divided
between them and the allocation between the Municipgifiesat"al1levels of:
their respective shares of such proceeds;
jl) the determination of the taxes, duties, tolls and fees which may be assign4
to or appropriated by the Municipalities;
iii) the grants-in-aid to the Municipalities from the Consolidated Fund of the
State;
c) Any other matter referred to the Finance Commission the Governor ip the
interest of sound finance of the Municipalities.
While the 74th AmendmentAct aims at ushering in a stsong local democracy through
the establishment of key institutions, it leayes ihe issues of their ernppwement qnd
operationalisation to the wisdom of the State Governments. In fact, even in mandatory
matters such as the establishment of District and Metropolitan Planning Committees,
the 74th Amendment does not prescribe any time limit. This is presumably due to the
fact that under the country's Constitution, India is a Union of States and it is under state
laws that Municipalities are constituted. However, the spirit of the Constitution (74@
Amendment)Act calls for a critical role on the part of State Governments to create a
conducive environment to steerthe decentralizationprocess, facilitatemunicipal reforms
and enable the elected municipal councils to function effectively,undertaking planning
for economic and social development and being the custodians and champions of local
socio-economic development plans. This requires, among other things, reforms in the
municipalfinance system in the country, starting first within the civic systems. (Mohanty,
2005, See www.cgg.gov.in/ASCIT_Collectors.doc).
But, this did not necessarily meant transfer of funds and financial power.leading to
dependence on central finance for implementation of their projects, thus, undermining
the idea of decentralization which is integral to 74'hCAA. Local bodies under the
JNNURM have to implement the following reforms:
Double-entry accrual-based accounting system;
E-governance;
Property tax reforms;
Implementation of GIs;
Levying user charges;
Providing basic services for the urban poor at affordable prices; and
Other administrative and structural reforms.
Local bodies have limited resources and power to generate revenue and taxes. Thue,
under the currentreform the urban local bodies can genemw taxes ttpu&hthe followin&,
some of which has to be shared with the state:
Property tax;
Vacant-land tax;
Motor Vehicle tax; UtbanDt:v&pent
Pblieiks knd Prokrammes
Professional tax.
Local governments should, therefore, focus on generation of revenue, enhaning their
service delivery through public-private partnership and upgrading their accounting
systems. It is, thus, important for the urban local bodies to streamlineits projects, instill
accountability and match its revenue-generated with expenditures for successful
maintenance of municipal finance.
The 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1992was followed by several reforms at the
state level. Launching of JNNURM -- a programme for promoting reforms and
investment in select cities by the Government of India in 2005, has brought a paradigm
shift in urban development strategy. One of the objectives of JNNURM is to ensure
improvement in urban governanceand servicedelivery to facilitateUrban Local Bodies
to become financially sound and sustainable.
Similarly, the Government of India launched two other programmes - Urban
Mastructure Development Scheme for Small and Medium Towns (UIDSSMT) and
Integrated Housing md Slum Development Program (MSDP) -for non-mission cities.
These programmes have mandatory reform component to improve city. Thirteenth
Finance Commission also recommended severalreforms -some mandatory and others
discretionary - to improve municipal finances and to strengthen urban governance,
R e f m s like 74th ConstitutioaalAmendmentAct, reduction of stamp duty, rent control
laws, enactment of community and public disclosure laws, etc., have been implemented
in most states. But, there has been slow progress in the case of transfer of functionaries
and finances, integration of service delivery functions with the ULBs. disclosure of
information,ek. Efforts are being made by state and local governments and administrative
reforms committees in the reform of buildrng regulations, promotion of Public-Private
Partnership (PPP) projects, etc. It is through PPPs the urban growth and quality sf
urban life can be improved very much.
Check Your Progress
Notes: a) Space given below the-question is for writing your answer.
b) Check your answer with the one given at the end of this unit under
"Answers to 'Check Your Progress' Questions."
3) Name different Urban Local Bodies in India.
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
4) What are the functionsof Urban Local Bodies specified by the 7 4 Constitution
~
Amendment Act, 1992?
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
53
U * % v ~ t
13.5 DISASTER MANAGEMENT IN URBAN AREAS
Disaster can occur anywhere and it is unpredictable.Urban areas are seeing huge influx
of population in recent years. This has led to concentration of population, buildings,
infrastructure and economic activities into small areas, and the greater interplay that
exists between the different urban elements creates higher vulnerability. A multiplying
effect occurs in urban areas, creating severe loss and damage to life and property.
Thus, it is very important to focus on the issues of disaster management and urban
planning.
i) Natural disasters: These are primarily natural events. It is possible that certain
human activities could aid in some of these events, but, by and large, these are
mostly natural events such as the following.
Earthquakes.
Volcanoes.
Hoods.
Tornadoes, Typhoons, Cyclones.
ii) Man-made disasters: These are mostly caused due to certain human activities.
The disasters themselves could be unintentional, but are caused due to some
intentional activity. Most of these (barring coordinated terrorist activities) are due
to certain accidents - which could be prevented - if sufficient precautionary
measures are put in place against:
Nuclear Leaks.
cfiemical Leaks 1Spill-over.
a TerroristActivities.
StructuralCollapses.
The major effects or consequences of the disasters include the following.
a The vulnerable groups which could get most affected include women and
children.
Loss of livelihood.
a Loss of property and house.
In view of the above, among other things, it is essential that appropriate disaster-
54 mitigation measures are put in place to face any of such eventualities.
Urban Development
13.5.2 Issues and Measures of Disaster Management Policies and Progr:ammes
lJrban development plans must incorporate in them the effective measures that contain
effects or consequences of disasters in the urban areas. Urban areas could be able to
rninirnize disasters' effects by putting in place proper plans encompassing adequate
land-use regulations, building regulations and engineering works, among others.
lrloreover, sustainable communities can only be achieved by incorporating disaster
management into their economic, environmental and social programmes such as the
I
~'ollowing.
I
ID Mitigation: make policies on zoning, early-warning systems, structural-codes,
insurance, etc.
Follow systematic approach which should have long-termplanning towards disaster
identificationand mitigation.
i @ Leadership, training, readiness, exercise to provide support for vulneraifie
, comhhities.
I
The outcome of Asia's high-rate of urbanization has been the expansion of urban
populations into geographic areas which are frequently affected by disaster events. The
d result is an increased vulnerability of populations and infrastructure.
isa aster-mitiiation measures such as the following are very essential.
l:M Earthquake- and cyclone-resistant buildings and infrastructure,
I d Flood and landslide-control measures,
, Incorporation of disaster vulnerability into land-useplanning, and
Introduction of regulatory measures in industrialized zones.
But, these have rarely been attempted in most Asian countries. Cross-cutting issues
which are directly influencing the vulnerability of urban population such as rapid
urbanization, environmentaldegradation, clirnate-variations, etc., also have contributed
negatively to national economies and infrastructure (http://www.adpc.net/udrml
I
e) Scale-up delivery of civic amenities and provision of utilities with emphasis
on universal access to the urban poor;
Q Special focus on urban renewal programme for the old-city areas to reduce
congestion; and
xi) Provision of urban amenities and facilities such as parks, gardens and play-
grounds;
xii) Promotion of cultural, educational and aesthetic aspects.
xi() Burials and burial-grounds, cremations, and cremation-groundsand electric
crematoriums.
xiv) Cattle pounds, prevention of cruelty to animals; .
xv) =tal statisticsincluding registration of births and deaths;
xvii) Public amenities including street-lighting,parking lots, bus-stops and public
conveniences.
xvi) Regulation of slaughterhouses and tanneries.
2) Natural disasters: These are primarily natural events. It is possible that certain
human activities could aid in some of these events, but, by and large, these are
mostly natural events such as the following.
Earthquakes.
Floods.
Tornadoes, Typhoons, Cyclones.
Urban Development Man-made disasters: These are mostly caused due to certain human activities. T11c
disasters themselves could be unintentional, but are caused due to some intentional
activity.Most of these (barring coordinated terrorist activities) are due to certain accident.
- which could be prevented - if sufficient precautionary measures are put in placc
13.8 REFERENCES
-
http://urbanindia.nic.in/moud.htm.
http://urbanindia.nic.in/programme/~d~uids~mt~pd~~vervie~.pdf.
http://www.adpc.net/udrmludrm.html.
html.
http://www.cpiml.or~berationlyeart2009/nov~09/policy~watch.
http://www.disas~rmgmt.or~type/tYpes.html.
http://www.kudumbashree.org/?q=ihsdp.