Salt and Obesity
Salt and Obesity
Salt and Obesity
Wohlam, along with an NYC cardiologist and a cancer researcher from buffalo,
defended salt on behalf of the Potato Chip and Snack Foods Association. They warned
that salt restricting guidelines would be dangerous. That “The risks associated with too
little salt in the diet, were particularly high among infants and children, diabetics,
pregnant women and women using estrogen-based contraceptives.”[1]
Now, as Mark Antony said, “I have come to bury Caesar, not to praise him.” Potato
Chips, Snack Foods and Processed Foods are the last thing someone should eat,
unless they are literally starving. Even if they are defending it, having someone
affiliated with such food products speak on salt’s behalf probably worsens its reputation.
However, just because someone is associated with something nefarious doesn’t always
mean they’re wrong - even if we really don’t want to trust them.
It was said that salt restriction would be dangerous for pregnant women, infants and
children, and diabetics.
I mentioned in my last video that studies have shown that pregnant women develop a
marked craving for salt, and that women on a low salt diet compared to a high salt diet,
caused more miscarriages, stillbirths and premature babies.[2] Salt is critical for proper
growth in general. As this article from the Journal of Biomedical Science points out, salt
restriction impedes fetal growth and specifically stunts development of cardiovascular
organs or decreases the number of nephron in the kidney, predisposing the baby to
hypertension in adulthood. It also says that “salt restriction is associated with a
decrease in insulin sensitivity.”[3]
As diabetes is a state of insulin resistance, this overlaps with the notion that salt
restriction could be dangerous for diabetics. But what could salt possibly have to do with
diabetes?
Well, it actually relates to why people sometimes feel sick on a very low carbohydrate or
ketogenic diet. This sick feeling, better known as the keto-flu, involves headache,
fatigue, nausea and muscle weakness. These symptoms also match those of sodium
depletion. This happens because a higher level of ketones, greater release of glucagon,
and in particular lower levels of insulin - all things that occur during carbohydrate
restriction, increase the body’s excretion of sodium.[4]
This is because one of insulin’s functions is to have your kidneys hold onto more
sodium.[5] So, if you lower your insulin levels by decreasing carbohydrate, you will lose
a lot of sodium. A lot of people talk about the “keto flu” like it’s an unavoidable phase of
the ketogenic diet, but you can avoid this by simply replacing the sodium that you lose.
The flip side of this, is that when you are on a low salt diet, the body will actually use
insulin as a tool for preserving and holding on to the salt that it has.
This study, done on 147 people with normal weight and blood pressure found that “With
dietary salt restriction serum total- and LDL-cholesterol as well as serum insulin and uric
acid concentrations increased significantly.”[6] The effect on insulin seems to be so
significant that, a study published in the Metabolism Journal, found that just one week
on a low sodium diet caused onset of insulin resistance in a group of healthy
volunteers. In fact, doctors have known that diuretics, which deplete salt, can also
promote insulin resistance and diabetes.[n] As the study says: “Low-salt (LS) diet
activates the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone and sympathetic nervous systems, both of
which can increase insulin resistance (IR).”[7]
And, As mentioned last in my last video, a study in the New England Journal of
medicine shows that when salt intake drops below just 1.5 teaspoons per day, a
significant increase in renin occurs, indicating the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system
is being activated.[8] The WHO, by the way, recommends getting no more than one
teaspoon of salt per day.[9]
Another study specifically implicates increased aldosterone as a pathway for low salt’s
causing of Insulin resistance. Aldosterone is a key hormone that is secreted as part of
the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system. [10] In fact, aldosterone blocking drugs -
Angiotensin Converting Enzyme inhibitors or ACE inhibitors are being explored as a
treatment for insulin resistance. As this study says: “The positive effects of ACE inhibitor
drugs, particularly on hypertriglyceridemia and insulin resistance, might bring them
forth as first-line drugs in the treatment of obese and hypertensive children.”[11]
Other than insulin resistance, aldosterone is better known for raising blood pressure.
ACE inhibitors are frequently prescribed for the treatment of hypertension. Let me point
out again that you can also keep aldosterone levels low by simply getting enough salt.
Now there’s a different white crystal that you do want to avoid. Cardiovascular research
scientist, James DiNicolantonio points out in his book “The Salt Fix” several of the
uncanny ways in which salt and sugar have almost directly opposite effects. Not only do
both a high sugar intake and low salt intake provoke insulin resistance and therefore
diabetes, the pathways by which this occurs are remarkably similar.
Table sugar, sucrose, is one part glucose and one part fructose. About a year ago I put
out a video explaining the biochemistry behind why fructose is particularly fattening,
damaging to the liver and how it provokes insulin resistance. It was based on the work
of Robert Lustig, Andrew Bremer and Michele Snyder. I’ll spare you the explanation of
all the reactions here, but there’s just one thing I want to point out. This diagram is
showing that during fructose metabolism, this enzyme JNK-1 is activated leading to
insulin receptor IRS-1 phosphorylation. Just remember that: JNK-1 activation leads to
IRS-1 phosphorylation. Simply put, this insulin receptor IRS-1 is being deactivated.
Now, for insulin to work properly, the insulin secreted from the pancreas needs to bind
to this receptor. Due to fructose’s deactivating of this insulin receptor, the pancreas has
to work harder and pump out more insulin to get its job done, leading to insulin
resistance.[12]
So that’s sugar, but what happens with low salt? As this study says: “In summary, the
insulin resistance, induced by LS, is tissue-specific and is accompanied by activation
of JNK and IRS-1(ser307) phosphorylation.” (Sound familiar?) The article continues,
to say: “The impairment of the insulin signaling in these tissues, but not in adipose
tissue, may lead to increased adiposity and insulin resistance in LS rats.”[13] Increased
adiposity simply means increased fatness.
The idea that low salt could make someone fat and put them on a path to diabetes may
sound dubious, especially to certain people because, ironically, the people who are
putting themselves on a low salt diet are already probably very health conscious in
general and far from being fat. That said, it is possible for people to be very lean and
still have insulin resistance. [14] Low salt is more likely to be a contributing factor to,
rather than the sole factor in insulin resistance. Insufficient salt intake could be one
factor in the that little bit of stubborn fat you haven’t gotten rid of, or maybe the weight
loss plateau you’ve hit.
Now, there’s just a little bit more to be explained about how else low salt could make it
easier to gain weight and even worsen insulin resistance.
In his book "The Fat Switch," physician and researcher at the University of Colorado,
Richard Johnson makes the case that there is some sort of “switch” that activates
weight gain. While it’s something we humans all want to avoid, In the animal world,
weight gain is a very strategic move.
Animals have essentially learned how to become obese so they can survive. As
Johnson says: “While Darwin emphasized the principle of the survival of the fittest, there
is an equally important concept of survival of the fattest."
“The 13-lined ground squirrel routinely doubles its fat content in the late summer in
preparation for hibernation during winter. The Emperor penguin also doubles its weight
in fat prior to protecting and warming its eggs during the fierce Antarctic winter. The
bar-tailed dogwit markedly increases its fat in its liver and blood prior to migrating
thousands of miles to its winter home.”[15]
Johnson explains in a 2013 paper of his that these animals aren’t just making
themselves fat, they are essentially inducing metabolic syndrome in themselves. They
get fatty liver, insulin resistance and accumulate visceral fat.[16] For us, this is a
diseased state, but for these animals, it’s a damn good way to store fat for the winter.
So, what is causing this insulin resistance and fat storage? What is flipping the fat
switch?
Johnson says that the key factor is increased production of uric acid. Uric acid is
commonly viewed as a simple waste product and most physicians are only concerned
with it in the context of gout and kidney stones. However, as Johnson points out: “an
elevated serum uric acid is extremely common in people who are obese, especially if
they have fatty liver or are insulin resistant.“[15]
If you look at a person with gout, a disease characterized by elevated levels of uric acid,
you commonly see: Abdominal obesity, fatty liver, elevated triglycerides, hypertension,
and… insulin resistance and diabetes. For a while, it was thought that elevated uric acid
was not a cause, but simply a consequence of obesity, fatty liver and insulin resistance.
However, this study in the Journal of Biological Chemistry found that if you put uric acid
on liver cells, they will begin to produce fat. The conclusion was very straightforward:
“Rather than a consequence, uric acid induces fatty liver. “[17]
The way this works is quite interesting. Uric acid induces oxidative stress in the cells’
mitochondria. This specifically inhibits an enzyme called Aconitase in the citric acid
cycle, leading a build up of citrate. Citrate is a substance that stimulates fat production.
Uric acid also inhibits another enzyme required for the burning of fatty acids, leading to
less ATP being produced. This all means: more fat synthesis, less fat burning, and less
energy production. If you’re a human with things to do and places to be, this isn’t so
great, but it’s perfect for an animal trying to prepare for the winter.
When animals have used up their fat stores and need to start foraging for more food,
there is a marked rise in uric acid to help store that food as fat. But there’s another way
to increase uric acid and that’s by consuming fructose.
Every spring tropical rains fall heavily on the Amazon basin, causing the forest to flood.
When this happens, as many as 200 different types of fruit eating fish come in to eat the
ripe sweet fruit that the trees are dropping. One of these fish is the Pacu, which looks
like a piranha but is larger and doesn’t have sharp teeth. The Pacu eats as much sweet,
fructose containing fruit as it can and converts it to fat, which it stores as oils in its liver
and tissues. In one study, the average fat content of the Pacu went from 10 to 28
percent. After the flood waters recede, the Pacu returns to the low water where food is
scarce. Luckily, the Pacu has stored so much fat that it can go without eating for as long
as six months.[15, 18]
Humans have always liked fructose, and especially since 1820, consumption of it began
to rise dramatically.[19] Of course this wasn’t fructose from fruit, but from table sugar.
John Yudkin, British physiologist and author of the 1972 book “Pure, White and Deadly,”
was able to show multiple times that just a few weeks on a high-sugar diet, would result
in elevated insulin and uric acid.[20, 21]” If we go back to Robert Lustig’s paper, we can
see a pathway through which fructose causes this production of uric acid. [12]
And, of course all this ties back to low salt diets. As shown in the earlier mentioned
1991 study, “With dietary salt restriction ... serum insulin and uric acid concentrations
increased significantly.”[6] Another 2017 study shows that “Serum uric acid fell
significantly in both the moderate and high [sodium] interventions compared to the low
sodium intervention.”[22] Keep in mind that high uric acid means higher insulin and
worsened insulin resistance.
One study even found that when diabetic patients were placed on a higher-sodium diet,
their insulin response improved. The authors even suggested that some people should
even supplement with sodium, stating that “an abundant sodium intake may improve
glucose tolerance and insulin resistance, especially in diabetic, salt-sensitive, or
medicated essential hypertensive subjects.”[23] As Dr. DiNicolantonio writes in the Salt
Fix: “We're finding that increasing your salt intake, even above what's generally
considered a normal intake, may help improve your insulin sensitivity."[24]
However, hypertension is a very common complication of diabetes. Unfortunately, as
per common practice, diabetic patients are very likely to be prescribed a low-salt diet in
order to attempt to deal with their blood pressure.
As mentioned last time Around 12 grams of salt per day (which contains about 4.5
grams of sodium) seems to be the optimal intake for most people. However, if you drink
more than 3 cups of coffee a day, or you’re on a low carbohydrate diet or you are
sweating alot from exercise or heat exposure, you may want to try and see how you feel
on a few more grams of salt. Also, everyone’s situation is of course different, so if you
do have insulin resistance, you may want to look further into this topic before ramping
up your salt intake.
I started this video off talking about Frito Lay, but snack foods and processed foods
should not be your source of sodium. Where you get your sodium does matter. Most
salts have anti-caking agents in them, which you definitely want to avoid. There’s all
kinds of higher quality salts from celtic sea salt to the recently popular pink himalayan
salt. There’s all kinds of healthy sources of sodium than what is sitting in most salt
shakers. Just leave tortoises alone, they already have enough trouble with butterflies
harassing them and drinking their salty tears.