Psy Co Spiritual
Psy Co Spiritual
Psy Co Spiritual
com
The Effectiveness of Religious Module in Improving Psyco-Spiritual Health for Women Inmates in Prison
Khairul Hamimah Mohamad Jodi1, Mohd Afifuddin Bin Mohamad 2, Wirdati Mohd Radzi3 , Azizi Che Seman4,
Naemah Abd Rahman4, Nurhanisah Senin4, Siti Fairuz Ramlan4 , and Fuadah Johari5
1
School of Foundation and General Studies, UNITAR International University, 3-01A Level 11, Tierra Crest, Jln
SS6/3, Kelana Jaya 47301, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia.
2
Advance Medical and Dental Institute (AMDI), Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kepala Batas, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia.
3
Department of Sport Management, Sport Centre, University of Malaya, 51603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
4
Academy of Islamic Studies, University of Malaya, 51603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
5
Faculty of Economics and Muamalat, Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia (USIM), 71800 Nilai, Negeri Sembilan,
Malaysia.
[email protected]
Abstract: The implementation of religiosity and psycho-spiritual health through the module instrumentation is
deemed significant to the inmates. Both entities are found to be effective in producing positive result. It is also
believed to be able to train and treat patients’ mental state and behavioral state, thus from recurring bad behaviors.
Several methods have been applied including: Cross survey, interview and questionnaire survey, which involves 40
inmates in the prison for various delinquencies. This research is going to analyze the effectiveness of the psycho-
spiritual module on the prison inmates before and after treatment. Due to the respondents’ location, this research
conducted at the Kajang Women prison in Malaysia. This article also evaluates the influence of religiousness
inculcated in the treatment of inmates, which promotes changes in positive attitude, daily lifestyle, mental health and
self-management. The result illustrates positive outcome from the implemented module before and after the psycho-
spiritual treatment. As conclusion, the study findings give strong support for the effectiveness of religious approach
in improving spiritual health for women inmates in prison. Thus, religious approach is recommended as an
alternative to the current allopathic treatment method in dealing with the problem especially for women inmates in
prison.
[Mohamad Jodi K.H., Mohamad M.A., Radzi W.M., Seman A.C., Rahman N.A., Senin N., Ramlan S. F., Johari F.
The Effectiveness of Religious Module in Improving Psyco-Spiritual Health for Women Inmates in Prison.
Life Sci J 2014;11(3):146-153]. (ISSN:1097-8135). http://www.lifesciencesite.com. 20
1. Introduction http://www.youthandreligion.org/news/
The implementation of religious elements preliminary.html, Accessed March 2, 2012).
proved to be effective to treat human inner wellness. By passing the time, it signifies that spiritual
The wellness itself encompasses three elements. First, health is an important element in psycho-physical
the physical health, second the mental health and the studies due to its ability to cure illness and produce
spiritual health (World Health Organization, 2011) positive results and its notable impacts on the
(Burke et.al, 2005). Most of studies in domain of physical health, besides various clinical treatments
health sciences encompass physical and mental (Burke et al, 2005). This fact was supported by the
aspects of human being. But there is still the dearth of result from a survey conducted by ‘National Cancer
research on spiritual health due to the difficulty of Centre’ in 2004 on 31000 respondents. It is found
measurement. Scholars discovered religious and that more than 45% of the respondents have used
spiritual elements have surged through the medical prayer as a therapy for various reason, 43% has
field, being its capability to influence physical health undergone the prayer therapy for recuperation from
(Ahmad Hisham et al., 2009) (Timothy, 2001). For cancer, 25% request a third party to pray for the cure
instance, in America religion is perceived as an and 10% involved in the prayer congregation for
essential element among local communities. health (Burke et al, 2005) (Barnes et al, 2004). (Jonas
Researchers reported that 95 % of people believe in et al, 2003) has also discovered some patients
God, 80% among them state the significance of diagnosed with serious illness wish to perform
religion in their lives, 80% uses the power of prayer spiritual therapy through praying to God, in the hope
for the purpose of well-being, and more than 50% of to lighten the burden whenever they face
attended in monthly religious and divine difficulties. Furthermore, it justified the ability of
congregation (Smith et al., 2002), spiritual therapy for the prospective of the latest
treatment medium for the patient and prison inmates.
146
Life Science Journal 2014;11(3) http://www.lifesciencesite.com
147
Life Science Journal 2014;11(3) http://www.lifesciencesite.com
life). Most of the inmates in the second phase aged qualified up to secondary education (70%), six of
between twenty six to thirty years old (nine of them; them up to primary education (15%), two of them
(22.5%); twenty one to thirty five years old (seven of qualified as diploma holder (5%), one of them as a
them; (17.5%), twenty one to twenty five years old degree holder (2.5%) and three of them have never
(six of them; (15%), thirty six to forty years old (six attended schools (7.5%). Majority of the inmates was
of them ;( 15%), forty six to fifty nine years old (six imprisoned for the first time (twenty seven inmates,
of the; (15%), forty one to forty five years old; (67.5%), six of them was imprisoned between two to
(10%), fifty one to fifty five years old (one of them; three times (15%), two of them between four to 6
(2.5%) and sixty years and above (one of them; times (5%) and the remaining five is more than ten
(2.5%). times (12.5%). The types of delinquencies are
In reference to the racial background, thirty of recognized as drug Trafficking (nineteen inmates,
them are Malay (77.5%), four of them are India (47.5%), breach of trust (five inmates, (12.5%),
(10%), four of them are Chinese (10%) and the rest bribery (three inmates, (7.5%), more than one
are from other races (2.5%). In addition, fourteen of delinquency (three inmates, (7.5%)), conspiracy (2,
them are married (35%), thirteen are divorced (5%), impersonification dan threatening, extramarital
(32.5%), 11 unmarried (27.5%) and the remaining pregnancy, killing attempt, abuse, kidnapping,
acquired other marital status (5%). In regard to the robbery, owning robbed items and other
educational qualification, twenty eight of them delinquencies that is represented by one (2.5%).
Based on the above figure 1 flow chart, the The last phase is to uproot the learning during
prison’s nurturing phase is segmented to three phase. the previous phase, where inmates are directed
In the first phase (the orientation phase), the inmates towards building skills and entrepreneurship for the
are thought on basic subjects such as belief towards upcoming new life outside. Here, the religious
God, the religious practices: obligation and teachings are being implemented but in various style
prohibitions. They are also educated on basic such as Qur’anic recitation, sermon, lecture and so
religious law such as prayer, business transaction, on. Usually, this phase are attended by inmates who
matrimony, pilgrimage and so on. are imprisoned for two years and above; it means all
In the following phase, the religious teachings is of them will not have the chance to undergo the
imparted further in depth. The difference between period.
this phase and the former is that the teaching does not
only remain in the theoretical aspect, but it is also 6. Finding
transferred to the practical life in prison. In addition, After the coding and consensus process, the
the phase also emphasize on the character building, inmates are segregated according to four main
where attitude and discipline teaching is enforced in categories (i.e. based on the questionnaires): (1)
the aim of amending the previous bad lifestyle. Every Religious belief; (2) Positive Intentionality, (3)
past time is filled up with the Qur’anic recitation slot, Positive self development (4) Agency. Each of these
supplications, and complimentary prayers and so categories is discussed in verbatim which has been
forth. coded from the inmates’ response.
148
Life Science Journal 2014;11(3) http://www.lifesciencesite.com
Table 1. The category of questions on spiritual health and its influence on religious and societal belief
Religious belief (Core belief)
The end result is solely for Allah S.W.T
The resolution to devote to Allah
Performing the five compulsory prayers
Agency
The Halaqah program
The Community Therapy program
The prison nurturing method
The period of rehibilitation
The counseling for inmates
149
Life Science Journal 2014;11(3) http://www.lifesciencesite.com
prison will be utilized optimally to find compatible believe it.” (Respondent 3, inmates. Interview on 15
jobs with their status as the ex-inmates. January 2011)
Agency
Positive Changes Post-Program Agency plays an important role in transforming
The program held by the prison management attitudes of the inmates. Through exercises, methods,
brings about changing the inmates’ attitude from programs, modules, planning and social aids from
negative to a more positive one. For instance, they peers and staffs will speed up the efforts of
are more motivated after joining the programs such as rejuvenating their morals and self-confidence. The
seminars, skill development workshops and others. Halaqah program, for example, use 100% religious
Besides, they have also eliminate their unpleasant elements to cure the inmates’ morals. Their hearts are
habits such as wasting time, unhygienic, attempts on soften and revived with learning religion, the
committing suicide and violating the law. Through importance of religion in life, application of the
participating in the phase two for a period of six religious obligations and the consequences of not
months, they have successfully educated the inmates practicing it. Quoted by the respondent:
to be more patient, hygienic and thinking more “I feel more calm and spend more time in
maturely before making decisions. performing the sunnah prayers and reciting the
“While at my house, I was not as clean as I’ve Qur’an” (Respondent 4, inmates. Interview on 20
been in the prison. All house chores were done by my January 2011)
mother. If my mother sees me now, surely she won’t The process of statistic data codification can be
referred to the table obtained below:
Table 2. Qualitative Report Result of the Competency Test on the Program Applied
Mean
Mean (After Mean Differences
(Before Correlation(sig.)
treatment) (sig.)
treatment)
E1l – Being Here is an Amanah 2.87 3.75 -0.069 (0.677) 0.949 (0)
E2al – Attempted Suicide 4.00 4.23 0.611 (0) 0.231 (0.13)
E2bl – Attempted Escaping 4.23 4.20 0.475 (0.002) -0.025 (0.85)
E2cl – Pretend to be Sick 4.08 4.05 0.784 (0) -0.025 (0.812)
E3l – Ultimate Goal is Allah 3.13 4.08 0.207 (0.201) 0.95 (0)
E4l – Reluctant to Perform Obligatory
3.53 3.78 0.549 (0) 0.25 (0.151)
Prayers
E5l – Promise Not to Break Family’s Trust 2.82 3.55 0.65 (0) 0.684 (0)
E6l – Enroll in the Center Voluntarily 2.69 3.73 0.445 (0.004) 1 (0)
E7l – Performing Tasks Without Hoping for
3.77 3.85 0.708 (0) 0.051 (0.675)
Appraisals
E8l – Ready to Change Attitude for Oneself
2.79 2.58 -0.102 (0.536) -0.179 (0.514)
and Family
E9l – Have Violated the Laws Here 3.51 3.70 0.319 (0.048) 0.231 (0.193)
E10l – Give the Best in Each Task 3.72 4.05 0.491 (0.002) 0.308 (0.032)
E11l – Like to Seek Knowledge and Skills 3.51 4.10 0.483 (0.002) 0.564 (0.001)
E12l – Determine to Obey Allah 3.69 4.38 0.323 (0.045) 0.667 (0.001)
E13l – More Motivated After the Program 3.16 3.85 0.357 (0.028) 0.658 (0.002)
E14l – Practice Hygiene in Life 3.85 4.05 0.474 (0.002) 0.179 (0.228)
E15l – Emotional in Making Decisions 3.05 3.20 0.569 (0) 0.205 (0.16)
E16al – Like to Waste Time 3.68 3.98 0.483 (0.002) 0.3 (0.032)
E16bl – Hard to Fulfill Promise 3.73 3.83 0.679 (0) 0.1 (0.352)
E17l – Rigid by the Design Timetable 3.51 3.43 0.583 (0) -0.128 (0.442)
E18l – Like to Help Peers 3.92 4.05 0.894 (0) 0.103 (0.044)
E19l – Avoid Conflicts Between Peers 3.82 3.90 0.763 (0) 0.053 (0.571)
E20l - Do Not Mind to Partake in Fights 3.90 4.03 0.747 (0) 0.125 (0.303)
E21l – Selfish 4.13 4.13 0.695 (0) 0 (1)
E22l – Life in Prison is Suffering 2.50 2.83 0.628 (0) 0.325 (0.074)
E23l – To be a Contributive Individual 3.58 4.38 0.364 (0.021) 0.8 (0)
The tables above illustrate the output from the item is to get the responds from respondents
paired sample t-test. Test was conducted among the regarding certain items before and after the program
paired items (before and after) in E Section of the participation. Items with negative statements are
questionnaire form. The purpose of the questioned recoded to show the same direction with other
150
Life Science Journal 2014;11(3) http://www.lifesciencesite.com
151
Life Science Journal 2014;11(3) http://www.lifesciencesite.com
RELIGIOUS BELIEF
HEALTH
Figure 2. Source is a modification from the Religious Model and Bio-Psycho-Social Health by Koenig et al. (2001)
Based on the created model above, there is a effective method of module application which is
close relation between the application of religious embodied with religious and spiritual elements found
belief, execution of religious practices and its to have produced positive results and become the
correlation with the society. This model further alternative to the current allopathic treatment method
supports that the instillation of religious values and in dealing with the problem.
the internalisation which were incorporated within
the psycho-spiritual model of the prison has Corresponding Author:
promoted towards the betterment or the inmates. Dr. Khairul Hamimah Mohamad Jodi
Moreover, by obeying and practicing religious School of Foundation and General Studies, UNITAR
values, it influences individuals’ health, both physical International University,
and spiritual. 3-01A Level 11, Tierra Crest, Jln SS6/3,
Rizzuto (2005) mentions, through exercising Kelana Jaya 47301, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia.
towards the religious obligations will eventually lead Tel: +60133025397. Fax: +60376277486.
to serenity, happiness and will escalate the quality of E-mail: [email protected]
life. On top of that, Furnham (1994) found that the
element of spiritual belief which is embedded, References
manage to increase one’s confidence to recover from 1. Abdussalam O.I, Johari F., Alias M.H.,
the suffering of the illness. Therefore, the integration “Managing Immediate Action For Women and
of religious spiritual elements into the modules used Poverty Reduction in Nigeria: an Explanation
by the institution of prison was found to be successful From the Generic Theory”, Asian Journal Of
in decreasing mental and emotional pressure of the Management Sciences & Education, 2013 ;3
inmates. (1):78-88.
Evidently, this finding is added support by 2. Ahmad Hisham & Che Zarrina Sa’ari, ”Terapi
researches such as Ganzini et al (1998). He explains Solat dalam menangani Penyakit Gelisah
that high spiritual belief capable of promoting (Anxiety) menurut perspektif Psikoterapi
positive clinical influence towards patient’s attitude Islam”, Jurnal Usuluddin, 2009 : 29: 1-45
and actions. Next, it will decrease the risk of getting 3. Barnes, P., Powell-Griner, E., McFann, K., &
ill (Donahue et al, 1995), (Lammer, et al, 2000), Nahin, R.. Complementary and alternative
(Wallance and Foreman, 1998) and at the same time medicine use among adults: United States. CDC
helping the individual to reduce emotional pressure Advance Data Report #343. Retrieved March,
and anxieties (Ahmad Hisham, 2009). The 2012, from
application of spiritual elements based on religion in http://nccam.nih.gov/news/camstats/2002/report
the module was seen to be significant as it manage to . pdf.
change and assert individual’s apprehension of his 4. Batson, Charles Daniel; Schoenrade, Patricia;
life (Jonas and Crawford, 2003) (Mary et al, 2008) Ventis, W. Larry, Religion and the individual: A
.This research is supported eminently with previous social-psychological perspective. New York,
scholars’ findings which proved that psycho-spiritual US: Oxford University Press, 1993.
modules implemented in Kajang Women Prison was 5. Breitbart W., “Spirituality and meaning in
relevant to be practiced and need to be supervised and supportive care:spirituality-and-meaning-
furbished from time to time. In summary, the centered group psychotherapy interventionsin
152
Life Science Journal 2014;11(3) http://www.lifesciencesite.com
advanced cancer”. Support Care Cancer 17. Mary Thomas Burke, Jane C. Chauvin, Judith
2002;20 : 272-280. G.Miranti, Religious and spiritual issues in
6. Burke, Mary Thomas et.al, Religious and counseling : applications across diverse
spiritual issues in counseling: applications populations, USA: Taylor & Francis Group,
across diverse populations USA: Taylor & 2005.
Francis Group, 2005. 18. Medical dictionary 2011, http://medical-
7. Donahue MJ & Benson, PL (1995) , ”Religion dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Spiritual ,
and wellbeing adolescents”, Journal of Social diakses pada 14 Mei 2011.
Issues, 1995; 51 :145-160 19. Megat Daud M.A.K, Radzi W. M., Abdullah R.,
8. Dunn, L.L et al, Spiritual Well Being, Anxiety Johari F. The Participation of Women Managers
and Depression in antepartal women on Bedrest. in Managing Sport: Challenges and Reality. Life
Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 2007 ;28 Sci J 2013;10(3):870-878
:1235-1246 20. National Center for Complementary and
9. Furnham, A. “Explaining health and illness: Lay Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). Information
perception on current and future health, the retrieved March, 2012, from
causes of illness, and the nature of recovery”. http://nccam.nih.gov/health/
Social science and medicine, 1994; 39 :715-725 21. National Study of Youth and Religion.
10. Ganzini , L., Johnson, W.S, McFarlann B.H, http://www.youthandreligion.
Tolle, S.W, Lee, M.A.”Attitude of patient with org/news/preliminary.html. Accessed March 2,
amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and their 2012.
caregivers toward assisted sucide”. New 22. Olsen Steggink, "Study in Spirituality in
England Journal of Medicine, 1998; 339 : 967- Retrospect", Studies in Spirituality, 1991; 1 (1) :
973 21.
11. Jonas, W., & Crawford, C. Healing, intention, 23. Patton, M. Q. Qualitative evaluation and
and energy medicine: Science, research research methods (2nd ed.). Newbury Park, CA:
methods, and clinical implications. New York: Sage, 1990.
Churchill Livingstone, 2003. 24. Rizzuto, Psychonaltic consideration abaout
12. Jones J.W., “Religion, Health And The Spiritually oriented psycoteraphy. In L. Speerry
Psycology Of Religion: How Research On & E.P. Shafranske (eds.), Spritually orinted
Religion And Health Helps Understand psychotherapy. Washinton D.C: America
Religion”, Journal Religion and Health, 2004 ; Psyhological Association, 2005.
43 (4) :318 25. Sa’id Hawwa (2010), Pendidikan Spiritual, (ter)
13. Koeing G.H et.al, Link Between Religion and Siddiq Fadzil, Kuala Lumpur; Mutiara ilmu
Health : Psychoneuroimmunology and the Faith selekta, h.47
Factor, Oxford University Press, 2002. 26. Smith C, Denton ML, Faris R, et al. Mapping
14. Koenig, H.G. et.al. Handbook of Religion and American adolescent religious participation. J
Health. New York: Oxford University Press, Sci St Rel 2002;41:597– 612.
2001. 27. Timothy, P. D et al., ”Spirituality and well
15. Lammer C, Ireland M, Resnick M et al., being: an exploratory study of patient
”Influence of Adolescent desion to pospone perspective”, Social Science & medicine, 2001;
onset sexual intercouse: A survival Anaysis of 53 :1503-1511.
virginity among youth ages 13 to 18 years, 28. Wallance JM, Foreman TA., ”Religion’s roles
Journal of adolesent health, 2000 ; 26 : 42-48 in promoting health and reducing risk among
16. Mary L. S. Vachon, Meaning, Spirituality, And america youth”, Health education Behaviour,
Wellness In Cancer Survivors” , Seminars In 1998 ;25 :721-741
Oncology Nursing, 2008 ; 24 (3) : 218-225. 29. World Health Organization (WHO),
http://www.who.int/en/, 7 April 2011
2/3/2014
153