WartimeStatutesBooklet PDF
WartimeStatutesBooklet PDF
WartimeStatutesBooklet PDF
U.S.S.R
Moscow
North
Sea
Baltic Sea
Nor th
A t l an t i c
East
Ocean Germany Poland
Czecho- Caspian
slovakia Sea
Hungary
Romania
Black Sea
Bulgaria
Albania
M e di t e r ra ne a n Se a
0 500 Kilometers
I. Sponsorship . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
II. Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
IV. Essays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
2 wartime statutes
Sponsorship
Promote an accurate, objective understanding of the information that has helped shape major
US foreign policy decisions.
Broaden access to lessons-learned, presenting historical material that gives greater under-
standing to the scope and context of past actions.
Improve current decision-making and analysis by facilitating reflection on the impacts and
effects arising from past foreign policy decisions.
Showcase CIAs contributions to national security and provide the American public with valu-
able insight into the workings of its government.
Demonstrate the CIAs commitment to the Open Government Initiative and its three core
values: Transparency, Participation, and Collaboration.
soviet control of east It was only in 1969 that the Warsaw Pact adopted
at Soviet insistence (along with the Committee of
european military forces Defense Ministers and Military Council) a Stat-
ute on the Combined Armed Forces and Com-
New Evidence on Imposition of the bined Command of the Warsaw Pact Member
1980 Wartime Statute States (for Peacetime) that created an elaborate
Warsaw Pact military headquarters in Moscow
by A. Ross Johnson with East European deputy defense ministers
Senior Scholar, Woodrow Wilson designated as deputy Warsaw Pact commanders. 2
International Center for Scholars These institutional changes gave the Warsaw Pact
more semblance of a multinational military alli-
Soviet military planning for conflict in Europe ance and granted to the East European military
after World War II from the outset harnessed establishments a greater consultative voice in
East European military capabilities to Soviet Warsaw Pact military matters, while streamlining
military purposes and assumed operational decision-making on training and armaments in a
subordination of East European military for- manner serving Soviet interests.3
mations to higher-level Soviet commands. A
Polish command-staff exercise in 1950, for Oddly for a military alliance, the 1969 military
example, assumed subordination of a Polish statute was silent on wartime command ar-
Army (comprised of five divisions and other rangements and explicitly confined its purview
units) to a Soviet Maritime Front (tasked in the to peacetime, notwithstanding the greater
exercise with occupying Denmark).1 Following importance that East European armed forces
1
founding of the Warsaw Treaty Organization assumed in Soviet military planning in the
(Warsaw Pact) in May 1955, a supreme War- 1960s. As in World War II, Soviet coalition
saw Pact military command was established in warfare doctrine of the 1960s envisaged the
Moscow, but this institution existed largely on controlled use of military allies of questionable
paper until the 1960s. military efficiency and political reliability by
1
Recollection of Colonel Michael Sadykiewicz, who participated in the exercise, letter to the author, March 8, 2010. In Soviet
practice, a theater headquarters commanded Fronts, comprised of Armies, which were in turn comprised of divisions and other
large military units.
2
CIA document FIR-DB 312/00538-78 dated March 21, 1978 (English translation from original Russian). A full German
translation from East German military archives was published on-line by the Parallel History Project (http://www.php.isn.ethz.
ch/collections/colltopic.cfm?lng=en&id=21221&navinfo=15697)
and a partial English text is published in Vojtech Mastny and Malcolm Byrne, A Cardboard Castle? An Inside History of the
Warsaw Pact, 1955-1991 (Budapest and New York: Central European University Press, 2005), document 62. The 1969 military
structures of the Warsaw Pact are described in A. Ross Johnson, Robert W. Dean, and Alexander Alexiev, East European Military
Establishments; The Warsaw Pact Northern Tier (New York: Crane Russak, 1980), Appendix A, pp.151-156.
6 wartime statutes
subordinating East European military forma- unacceptable surrender of national sovereignty.
tions to Soviet operational commands at the The Polish General Staff raised questions along
Front level or below. The respective Soviet similar lines. In the end, the Ceausescu regime
commands were in turn subordinated not to never signed or agreed to abide by the provisions
the Warsaw Pact military headquarters but to of the wartime statute, while Polish Party chief
the Soviet General Staff and High Command Edward Gierek did. Kuklinski argued that the
in Moscow. As veteran British observer and Romanian example demonstrated it was pos-
official Malcolm Macintosh observed at the sible for an East European country to resist So-
time, the Warsaw Pact Combined Command viet pressure even within the Soviet-dominated
remained a peacetime structure, equivalent Warsaw Pact.7 While a different Polish leader-
to a traditional European war office with ad- ship might have attempted a more autonomous
ministrative duties for training, mobilization, course, Poland was not Romania. Poland, part
and armaments, but without responsibility for of the Warsaw Pact Northern Tier and with the
conduct of military operations. 4 In Ryszard largest East European military force, was central
Kuklinskis words, the banner of the so-called to Soviet military planning for conflict in Eu-
Combined Command of the Combined Armed rope; Romania was not. Soviet military forces
Forces masked Soviet control.5 had vacated Romania in 1958. Romania under
Gheorghe Gheorghiu-Dej and Ceausescu had
In the late 1970s, the USSR sought to formal- for two decades pursued an independent foreign,
ize these wartime Warsaw Pact command ar- military, and intelligence policy. Poland under
rangements in a new Statute on the Combined Wladyslaw Gomulka and Gierek had remained
Armed Forces of the Warsaw Pact Member closely aligned with Moscow in all these areas.
States and Their Command Organs for War- Poland was home to the Soviet Northern Group
time, adopted in March 1980. 6 This effort to of Forces, headquartered in Legnica, which 1 in7
fill the glaring gap highlighted by the peacetime the 1980s was also the location of the headquar-
statute was delayed by objections from Nicolae ters of the Western Theater of Military Opera-
Ceausescus Romania, which viewed it as an tions (TVD), established as the forward Soviet
3
Johnson, Dean, Alexiev, op. cit., p. 15.
4
Malcolm Macintosh, The Evolution of the Warsaw Pact, Adelphi Papers, No. 58, June 1969, pp. 11-15.
5
Interview in Kultura, Paris, April 1987, p. 54.
6
CIA document FIRDB-312/01995-80 dated July 25, 1980 (English translation from the original Russian). A full German
translation from East German military archives was published on-line by the Parallel History Project (http://www.php.isn.
ethz.ch/collections/colltopic.cfm?lng=en&id=20408&navinfo=15697 ) and a partial English text is published in Mastny and
Byrne, op. cit, document 86. Detailed comparison of Warsaw Pact peacetime and wartime command structures is provided in
Michael Sadykiewicz, The Warsaw Pact Command Structure in Peace and War (Santa Monica: R AND Corporation, 1988),
Report 3558-RC.
7
Kuklinski interview, op. cit, pp. 56-57.
8
A. Ross Johnson, East European Armed Forces and Soviet Military Planning: Factors of Change (Santa Monica: R AND
Corporation, 1989), Note N-2856-AF, declassified and released November 2006.
9
Documentation of and commentary on Shchit-88 are posted on the Woodrow Wilson Center Cold War International
History Project web site at http://www.wilsoncenter.org/index.cfm?topic_id=1409&fuseaction=topics.publications&doc_
id=600908&group_id=13349.
8 wartime statutes
and other clandestine materials, to provide a German versions on the PHP web site. Other
detailed picture of Soviet Control of Warsaw documents in the CIA release and all original
Pact Forces. A final document, released ear- Russian texts have yet to be located in East
lier, is the 1983 National Intelligence Estimate European archives. The documents released by
on East European military reliability. Both the CIA serve historians today not only as useful
CIA analysis and the Estimate stand the test translations but as valuable source material. As
of time, indicating that the intelligence reports such they complement previous CIA releases of
released here, and other materials, allowed U.S. classified Military Thought articles, classified
officials to accurately appraise Soviet-dominat- Soviet military academy course materials, and
ed mechanisms of the Warsaw Pact at the time. Polish military plans for martial law.11
It is noteworthy how quickly some of these
highly sensitive Warsaw Pact documents be-
came available in Washington. The final war-
time statute and ratification documents were
dated March 18, 1980 and April 30, 1980; they
were issued as a translated CIA intelligence re-
port on July 25, 1980.
10
Kuklinski interview, op.cit; Benjamin Weiser, A Secret Life: The Polish Officer, His Covert Mission, and the Price He Paid
to Save His Country (Public Affairs: New York, 2004); Benjamin B. Fischer, Entangled in History: The Vilification and Vindi-
cation of Colonel Kuklinski, Studies in Intelligence 9 (Summer 2000), pp. 19-34. Weisers book is based in part on interviews
with Kuklinski and on CIA reports from Kuklinski (750 pages of notes and raw files) that have not otherwise been released
(Weiser, op. cit., pp. xi-xiii).
11
Available in the CIA on-line Special Collections Archive, http://www.foia.cia.gov/special_collections_archive.asp.
1
Source protection was the prime consideration throughout the HUMINT operation, as it should be in any HUMINT case;
however, it often limited use of the information. For example, only a handful of principals received the reports from CIA, and
copying as well as dissemination of the reports beyond the Washington area was prohibited. In particular, these rules hand-
cuffed the US Army Missile Intelligence Agency (Alabama) and US Army Foreign Science and Technology (Charlottesville,
VA), at the time two of the Army Staff s most important intelligence-producing field agencies
12 wartime statutes
our new tank). Even so, the information about ligence cycle and the challenges of making of
the statute and its implementing structure the intelligence stew. In my view, however,
(new headquarters, communications systems, the heart of the collection consists of the op-
etc.) was of value to war planners, war gamers, erational field reporting by one special human
targeteers and even PSYOP strategists, who intelligence sourcethe one discussed above.
could hope to take advantage of the surrender His reports are filled with facts and his field
of national sovereignty issue during crisis or analysis, even while conveying the frustrations
war. In fact, some high officials in the Office and emotions you might expect from this patri-
of the Secretary of Defense pushed for making otic officer. We owe him a lot for his courage.
the statute reporting public immediately as a
public diplomacy weapon against the USSR;
however, this notion reportedly was vetoed by
the DCI for source-protection reasons.1
14 wartime statutes
Instruments of soviet control 15
1 61 6 w aw ra tr itmi em es ts at ta ut tu et se s
SELECTED INTELLIGENCE
18 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 19
20 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 21
22 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 23
24 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 25
26 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 27
28 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 29
30 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 31
32 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 33
34 wartime statutes
instruments of soviet control 35
freedom of information act (foia)
electronic reading room
The CIA has established this site to provide The Warsaw Pact: Treaty of Friendship,
the public with an overview of access to CIA Cooperation, and Mutual Assistance
information, including electronic access to pre-
viously released documents. Because of CIAs A collection of sensitive Soviet and Warsaw
need to comply with the national security laws Pact military journals from 1961 to 1984 that
of the United States, some documents or parts provide a view into Warsaw Pact military strat-
of documents cannot be released to the public. egy. New information was added to this site in
In particular, the CIA, like other U.S. intelli- January 2010.
gence agencies, has the responsibility to protect
intelligence sources and methods from disclo- Air America: Upholding the Airmens Bond
sure. However, a substantial amount of CIA
information has been and/or can be released A fascinating assembly of documents revealing
following review. See Your Rights for further the role that Air America, the Agencys propri-
details on the various methods of obtaining etary airline, played in the search and rescue of
this information. pilots and personnel during the Vietnam War.
The collection has personal accounts by the
rescued pilots and thank you letters as well as
special collections
commendations from various officials.
Additional document collections released by
Preparing for Martial Law: Through the Eyes
the Historical Collection Division can be
of Col. Ryszard Kuklinski
found on the FOIA Electronic Reading Room
and include:
A captivating collection of over 75 documents
concerning the planning and implementation
Strategic Warning and the Role of Intelli-
of martial law in Poland from mid-1980 to late
gence: Lessons Learned From the 1968 Soviet
1981. Colonel Ryszard Kuklinski, a member of
Invasion of Czechoslovakia
the Polish Army General Staff and the source
of the documents, provided information and
This collection consists of DI intelligence mem-
personal commentary that gave intelligence
orandums, various estimates and memos written
analysts and US policy makers invaluable in-
by the Office of National Estimates (ONE), ar-
sight into the crisis.
ticles from the Central Intelligence Bulletin (a
current intelligence daily publication), Weekly
Baptism by Fire: CIA Analysis of the
Summaries, Intelligence Information Cables,
Korean War.
and Situation Reports, which were published up
to three times a day during the crisis when ten-
This collection includes more than 1,200 docu-
sions flared.
ments consisting of national estimates, intelli-
gence memos, daily updates, and summaries of
36 wartime statutes
foreign media concerning developments on the largest single release of Helms-related informa-
Korean Peninsula during 1947-1954. This col- tion to date. The documents, historical works
lection, coinciding with the 60th anniversary and essays offer an unprecedented, wide-ranging
of the start of the war, is the largest collection look at the man and his career as the United
of CIA documents on this issue ever released. States top intelligence official and one of its
HCD and the Harry S. Truman Presidential most important diplomats during a crucial de-
Library co-hosted a conference entitled New cade of the Cold War. From mid-1966, when
Documents and New Histories: Twenty-first he became DCI, to late 1976, when he left Iran,
Century Perspectives on the Korean War that Helms dealt directly with numerous events
highlighted the document collection. whose impact remains evident today and which
are covered in the release.
Creating Global Intelligence
A-12 OXCART Reconnaissance
Discover the back story of the US intelligence Aircraft Documentation
community by exploring this collection of more
than 800 documents from the late 1940s to the This release, containing approximately 1,500
early 1950s that pertain to the establishment of pages of material, consisting of about 350 docu-
the Central Intelligence Agency. The collection ments, maps, diagrams, and photographs will
provides perspective on the complex issues that provide researchers on aviation and intelligence
senior US government officials grappled with as with significant additional detail about the de-
they considered how to establish an enduring sign and development of the A-12.
national intelligence capability.
Since the establishment of the Warsaw Pact in DVD Document CollectionThis collection in
1955, the anticipated reliability of Non-Soviet the Warsaw Pact series features a wealth of newly de-
Warsaw Pact (NSWP) forces in the event of classified Central Intelligence Agency documents.
a crisis was a topic of intense interest for the
United States and its NATO allies as well as Warsaw Pact: Wartime StatutesInstruments
for the Soviet Union. As the Soviet Union en- of Soviet Control explores evolving U.S. views
gaged in successive efforts from the late 1960s on the relationship between the Soviet Union
onwards to codify its command and control and its Non-Soviet Warsaw Pact allies.
arrangements over the armed forces of its East
European alliesfirst through a peacetime and The companion DVD will work on most com-
later a wartime statutethe U.S. Intelligence puters and the documents are in .PDF format.
Communitys collection and analytic efforts on
the subject were ongoing.
38 wartime statutes
special acknowledgements
The Historical Review Program, part of the CIA Information Management Services, identifies,
collects and produces historically relevant collections of declassified documents.
These collections, centered on a theme or event and with supporting analysis, essays, video, audio,
and photographs, are showcased in a booklet and DVD that are available to the academic realm
and the public.
All of our Historical Collections are available in the Freedom of Information Act Elec-
tronic Reading Room. Go to w w w.foia.cia.gov and click on Special Collections or contact
us at [email protected].
Thanks to the Wilson Centers Cold War International History Project (CWIHP) for hosting
and co-organizing this important event and for contributing images as well as documents from
their own collection of non-US sources for the publication.
44 00 wartime statutes
20010607011