Design and Assembly Analysis
Design and Assembly Analysis
Design and Assembly Analysis
P=power
=
dp=diameter of pinion
=helix angle
BHN=brinel hardness number
E=youngs modulus
EG=youngs modulus of gear material
EP=youngs modulus of pinion material
Compressive stress =
Bending stress = a
Module =m
=
gear ratio = GR
No of teeth on gear =
Diameter of gear =
Diameter of pinion =
=
Normal pitch =
=
Normal pressure angle = N
pressure angle =
b=face width
Equivalent no of teeth on pinion =
Equivalent no of teeth on gear =
=
0 =
=
Y1 =tooth form factor
Peripheral speed = V
Dynamic tooth load =
C = deformation factor
Static tooth load =
K =load stress factor
Ww=wear load
X = over hang
Torque =T
Equivalent twisting moment =
=
ABSTRACT
Differential is used when a vehicle takes a turn, the outer wheel on a longer radius
than the inner wheel. The outer wheel turns faster than the inner wheel that is when there is a
relative movement between the two rear wheels. If the two rear wheels are rigidly fixed to a rear
axle the inner wheel will slip which cause rapid tire wear, steering difficulties and poor load
holding.
In the present work all the parts of differential are designed under static condition and
modeled. The required data is taken from journal paper. Modeling and assembly is done
in Pro/Engineer. The detailed drawings of all parts are to be furnished.
The main aim of the project is to focus on the mechanical design and contact
analysis on assembly of gears in gear box when they transmit power at different speeds at
2500 rpm, 5000 rpm. Presently used materials are Cast iron and Cast steel. For validating
design Structural Analysis is also conducted by varying the materials for gears, Cast Iron
and of Aluminum Alloy.
The analysis is conducted to verify the best material for the gears in the gear box
at higher speeds by analyzing stress, displacement and also by considering weight
reduction.
Automotive drive lines and suspension systems have changed quite a bit since the first
automobile was built. At first, automobile axles were attached directly to the main frame of the
vehicle. This caused many problems. For example, the vehicle produced a very rough ride. Also,
rigid construction did not work well on rough ground because sometimes one of the wheels
would not touch the ground. If the wheel off the ground was a drive wheel, the vehicle lost
traction and stopped. This problem proved a need for a more flexible vehicle.
The problem was corrected by using springs between the axles and the frame. The early springs
were the same type used on the horse-drawn buggy. They allowed the wheels and axles to move
up and down separate from the body. The body moved very little compared to the wheels and
axles, and the ride was much smoother.
Allowing the axles to move separate from the body also kept the wheels on the ground over
rough roads, but this caused a new problem. The old drive train between the engine and the axle
would not work. The train had to be made to move more. This was done by adding movable
joints in the drive shaft known as universal joints. Some early vehicles used only one universal
joint on the drive shaft, while later vehicles used two universal joints on the drive shaft. Drive
shafts are now usually called propeller shafts. Some long-wheel-base trucks now use as many as
four propeller shafts between the transmission
and the drive axle. These propeller shafts are connected by universal joints.
Early automobiles were made up of a body, a power plant, and a running gear. The running gear
was made up of the wheels, axles, springs, drive shaft, and transmission. The transmission was
often mounted midway between the engine and rear axle. It was connected to the engine and the
rear axle by drive shafts.
The term "running gear" is not used any more. A new term, "chassis," is now used to identify the
old running gear plus the power plant. In modern vehicles, the transmission is generally mounted
on the engine and is part of the power plant.
The chassis of modern vehicles, especially the frame, spring, and axles, must be very strong and
yet quite flexible.
3.2 INTRODUCTION TO AXLE SHAFT
An axle is a central shaft for a rotating wheel or gear. On wheeled vehicles, the axle may be
fixed to the wheels, rotating with them, or fixed to its surroundings, with the wheels rotating
around the axle. In the former case, bearings or bushings are provided at the mounting points
where the axle is supported. In the latter case, a bearing or bushing sits inside the hole in the
wheel to allow the wheel or gear to rotate around the axle.
Axles are an integral component of a wheeled vehicle. In a live-axle suspension system, the axles
serve to transmit driving torque to the wheel, as well as to maintain the position of the wheels
relative to each other and to the vehicle body. The axles in this system must also bear the weight
of the vehicle plus any cargo. A non-driving axle, such as the front beam axle in Heavy duty
trucks and some 2 wheel drive light trucks and vans, will have no shaft. It serves only as a
suspension and steering component. Conversely, many front wheel drive cars have a solid rear
beam axle.
In other types of suspension systems, the axles serve only to transmit driving torque to the
wheels; The position and angle of the wheel hubs is a function of the suspension system. This is
typical of the independent suspension found on most newer cars and SUV's, and on the front of
many light trucks. These systems still have a differential, but it will not have attached axle
housing tubes. It may be attached to the vehicle frame or body, or integral in a transaxle. The
axle shafts (usually C.V. type) then transmit driving torque to the wheels. Like a full floating
axle system, the shafts in an independent suspension system do not support and vehicle weight.
"Axle" in reference to a vehicle also has a more ambiguous definition, meaning parallel wheels
on opposing sides of the vehicle, regardless of their mechanical connection type to each other
and the vehicle frame or body.
In rear wheel drive vehicles, the rear wheels are the driving wheels, whereas in the vehicles with
front wheels drive the front wheels are the driving wheels. Almost all the rear axles in the
modern cars are live axles, which means that these axles move with the wheels, or revolve with
the wheels and are known as live axles. Dead Axles are those axles which remain stationary and
do not move with the wheels.
Rear axles / Live Axles are further classified into three types:
The Semi float axle is used in light trucks and passenger vehicle / buses. In the vehicles equipped
with Semi Float axle the shaft as well as the differential housing supports the weight of the
vehicle . The wheel hub is directly connected to the axle shaft or is an extension of the same, the
inner end of the axle shaft is splined and it is supported by the final drive unit. The outer end is
supported by a single bearing inside the axle casing / axle tube. The vehicle load is transmitted to
each of the axle shafts through the casing and the bearing, this causes a bending load and a
tendency to shear at a point. Besides the side forces also cause end thrust and bending moment in
the axle shafts, which have to take driving torque also. The semi float axle is the simplest and the
cheapest of all types, because of which it is widely used on cars. However, since axle shafts have
to support all loads, they have to be of larger diameter for the same torque transmitted to the
other types of axle supporting. The axle shafts take the stress caused by turning, skidding or
wobbling of the wheels. The axle shafts are flanged or tapered on the ends. When the tapered
axles are used, the brake , the brake drum and hub are pressed onto the shafts, using keys to
prevent the assemblies from turning on the shafts. In some cases, the outer ends of the shafts
may have serrations or splines to correspond with those on the drum and hub assembly. If
in case the axle shaft breaks on the vehicle using this type of arrangement, the wheel of the
vehicle will get separated from the vehicle.
Full Float Axle is considered as a robust one and is used for heavy vehicles / trucks meant to
carry heavy loads. The axle shaft has flanges at the outer ends, which are connected to the
flanged sleeve by means of bolts. There are two taper roller bearings supporting the axle casting
in the hub, which take up any side load. Thus in case of Full Float axles , the axle shafts carry
only the driving torque. The weight of the vehicle and the end thrust are not carried by them. The
weight of the vehicle is completely supported by the wheels and the axle casing. As the axle
shafts carry only the driving torque, their failure or removal does not effect the wheels. Thus the
axle shafts can be taken out or replaced without jacking up the vehicle. For the same reason
vehicle can be towed even with a broken half shaft. We can say that the axle shaft takes the
whole weight of the vehicle and absorbs all types of stresses or end thrust caused by turning,
skidding, and pulling. Full Float axle is considered as the most heavy and costly axle.
This is a compromise between the more robust full float axle and the simplest semi float type of
axle. In Semi Floating axle the bearing is located between the axle casing and the hub instead of
being between the axle casing and the shaft as in case of semi float axle. The axle shafts do not
have to withstand any shearing or bending actions due to the weight of the vehicle, which are
taken up by the axle casing through the hub and the bearing, provided the bearing lies in the
plane of the road wheel. However, it has to take the end loads and the driving torque. Earlier,
Three quarter floating axles were much popular for cases and lighter commercial vehicles, but
with the passage of time and with more improvements in the design, development, materials and
fabrication techniques, preference is given to the Semi Float Axles, as these are simpler in design
and cheaper to use.
4.LITERATURE SURVEY
A transmission or gearbox provides speed and torque conversions from a rotating power source
to another device using gear ratios. In British English the term transmission refers to the whole
drive train, including gearbox, clutch, prop shaft (for rear-wheel drive), differential and final
drive shafts. In American English, however, the distinction is made that a gearbox is any device
which converts speed and torque, whereas a transmission is a type of gearbox that can be
"shifted" to dynamically change the speed: torque ratio, such as in a vehicle. The most common
use is in motor vehicles, where the transmission adapts the output of the internal combustion
engine to the drive wheels. Such engines need to operate at a relatively high rotational speed,
which is inappropriate for starting, stopping, and slower travel. The transmission reduces the
higher engine speed to the slower wheel speed, increasing torque in the process. Transmissions
are also used on pedal bicycles, fixed machines, and anywhere else rotational speed and torque
needs to be adapted.
Often, a transmission will have multiple gear ratios (or simply "gears"), with the ability to switch
between them as speed varies. This switching may be done manually (by the operator), or
automatically. Directional (forward and reverse) control may also be provided. Single-ratio
transmissions also exist, which simply change the speed and torque (and sometimes direction) of
motor output.
In motor vehicle applications, the transmission will generally be connected to the crankshaft of
the engine. The output of the transmission is transmitted via driveshaft to one or more
differentials, which in turn drive the wheels. While a differential may also provide gear
reduction, its primary purpose is to change the direction of rotation.
Conventional gear/belt transmissions are not the only mechanism for speed/torque adaptation.
Alternative mechanisms include torque converters and power transformation (e.g., diesel-electric
transmission, hydraulic drive system, etc.). Hybrid configurations also exist.
4.2 Explanation
Early transmissions included the right-angle drives and other gearing in windmills, horse-
powered devices, and steam engines, in support of pumping, milling, and hoisting.
Most modern gearboxes are used to increase torque while reducing the speed of a prime mover
output shaft (e.g. a motor crankshaft). This means that the output shaft of a gearbox will rotate at
slower rate than the input shaft, and this reduction in speed will produce a mechanical advantage,
causing an increase in torque. A gearbox can be setup to do the opposite and provide an increase
in shaft speed with a reduction of torque. Some of the simplest gearboxes merely change the
physical direction in which power is transmitted.
Many typical automobile transmissions include the ability to select one of several different gear
ratios. In this case, most of the gear ratios (often simply called "gears") are used to slow down
the output speed of the engine and increase torque. However, the highest gears may be
"overdrive" types that increase the output speed.
4.3 Uses
Gearboxes have found use in a wide variety of differentoften stationaryapplications, such as
wind turbines.
Transmissions are also used in agricultural, industrial, construction, mining and automotive
equipment. In addition to ordinary transmission equipped with gears, such equipment makes
extensive use of the hydrostatic drive and electrical adjustable-speed drives.
4.4 Simple
The simplest transmissions, often called gearboxes to reflect their simplicity (although complex
systems are also called gearboxes in the vernacular), provide gear reduction (or, more rarely, an
increase in speed), sometimes in conjunction with a right-angle change in direction of the shaft
(typically in helicopters). These are often used on PTO-powered agricultural equipment, since
the axial PTO shaft is at odds with the usual need for the driven shaft, which is either vertical (as
with rotary mowers), or horizontally extending from one side of the implement to another (as
with manure spreaders, flail mowers, and forage wagons). More complex equipment, such as
silage choppers and snow blowers, have drives with outputs in more than one direction.
The gearbox in a wind turbine converts the slow, high-torque rotation of the turbine into much
faster rotation of the electrical generator. These are much larger and more complicated than the
PTO gearboxes in farm equipment. They weigh several tons and typically contain three stages to
achieve an overall gear ratio from 40:1 to over 100:1, depending on the size of the turbine. (For
aerodynamic and structural reasons, larger turbines have to turn more slowly, but the generators
all have to rotate at similar speeds of several thousand rpm.) The first stage of the gearbox is
usually a planetary gear, for compactness, and to distribute the enormous torque of the turbine
over more teeth of the low-speed shaft. Durability of these gearboxes has been a serious problem
for a long time.
Regardless of where they are used, these simple transmissions all share an important feature: the
gear ratio cannot be changed during use. It is fixed at the time the transmission is constructed.
Many applications require the availability of multiple gear ratios. Often, this is to ease the
starting and stopping of a mechanical system, though another important need is that of
maintaining good fuel efficiency.
4.6 Automotive basics
The need for a transmission in an automobile is a consequence of the characteristics of the
internal combustion engine. Engines typically operate over a range of 600 to about 7000
revolutions per minute (though this varies, and is typically less for diesel engines), while the car's
wheels rotate between 0 rpm and around 1800 rpm.
Furthermore, the engine provides its highest torque outputs approximately in the middle of its
range, while often the greatest torque is required when the vehicle is moving from rest or
traveling slowly. Therefore, a system that transforms the engine's output so that it can supply
high torque at low speeds, but also operate at highway speeds with the motor still operating
within its limits, is required. Transmissions perform this transformation.
Many transmissions and gears used in automotive and truck applications are contained in a cast
iron case, though more frequently aluminum is used for lower weight especially in cars. There
are usually three shafts: a main shaft, a countershaft, and an idler shaft.
The main shaft extends outside the case in both directions: the input shaft towards the engine,
and the output shaft towards the rear axle (on rear wheel drive cars- front wheel drives generally
have the engine and transmission mounted transversely, the differential being part of the
transmission assembly.) The shaft is suspended by the main bearings, and is split towards the
input end. At the point of the split, a pilot bearing holds the shafts together. The gears and
clutches ride on the main shaft, the gears being free to turn relative to the main shaft except when
engaged by the clutches. Types of automobile transmissions include manual, automatic or semi-
automatic transmission.
In automobiles and other wheeled vehicles, the differential allows each of the driving roadwheels
to rotate at different speeds, while for most vehicles supplying equal torque to each of them.
4.7.1 Purpose
A vehicle's wheels rotate at different speeds, mainly when turning corners. The differential is
designed to drive a pair of wheels with equal torque while allowing them to rotate at different
speeds. In vehicles without a differential, such as karts, both driving wheels are forced to rotate
at the same speed, usually on a common axle driven by a simple chain-drive mechanism. When
cornering, the inner wheel needs to travel a shorter distance than the outer wheel, so with no
differential, the result is the inner wheel spinning and/or the outer wheel dragging, and this
results in difficult and unpredictable handling, damage to tires and roads, and strain on (or
possible failure of) the entire drivetrain.
4.7.2Functional description
The following description of a differential applies to a "traditional" rear-wheel-drive car or truck
with an "open" or limited slip differential:
Torque is supplied from the engine, via the transmission, to a drive shaft (British term: 'propeller
shaft', commonly and informally abbreviated to 'prop-shaft'), which runs to the final drive unit
that contains the differential. A spiral bevel pinion gear takes its drive from the end of the
propeller shaft, and is encased within the housing of the final drive unit. This meshes with the
large spiral bevel ring gear, known as the crown wheel. The crown wheel and pinion may mesh
in hypoid orientation, not shown. The crown wheel gear is attached to the differential carrier or
cage, which contains the 'sun' and 'planet' wheels or gears, which are a cluster of four opposed
bevel gears in perpendicular plane, so each bevel gear meshes with two neighbours, and rotates
counter to the third, that it faces and does not mesh with. The two sun wheel gears are aligned on
the same axis as the crown wheel gear, and drive the axle half shafts connected to the vehicle's
driven wheels. The other two planet gears are aligned on a perpendicular axis which changes
orientation with the ring gear's rotation. In the two figures shown above, only one planet gear
(green) is illustrated, however, most automotive applications contain two opposing planet gears.
Other differential designs employ different numbers of planet gears, depending on durability
requirements. As the differential carrier rotates, the changing axis orientation of the planet gears
imparts the motion of the ring gear to the motion of the sun gears by pushing on them rather than
turning against them (that is, the same teeth stay in the same mesh or contact position), but
because the planet gears are not restricted from turning against each other, within that motion,
the sun gears can counter-rotate relative to the ring gear and to each other under the same force
(in which case the same teeth do not stay in contact).
Thus, for example, if the car is making a turn to the right, the main crown wheel may make 10
full rotations. During that time, the left wheel will make more rotations because it has further to
travel, and the right wheel will make fewer rotations as it has less distance to travel. The sun
gears (which drive the axle half-shafts) will rotate in opposite directions relative to the ring gear
by, say, 2 full turns each (4 full turns relative to each other), resulting in the left wheel making 12
rotations, and the right wheel making 8 rotations.
The rotation of the crown wheel gear is always the average of the rotations of the side sun gears.
This is why, if the driven roadwheels are lifted clear of the ground with the engine off, and the
drive shaft is held (say leaving the transmission 'in gear', preventing the ring gear from turning
inside the differential), manually rotating one driven roadwheel causes the opposite roadwheel to
rotate in the opposite direction by the same amount.
When the vehicle is traveling in a straight line, there will be no differential movement of the
planetary system of gears other than the minute movements necessary to compensate for slight
differences in wheel diameter, undulations in the road (which make for a longer or shorter wheel
path), etc.
4.7.3 Loss of traction
One undesirable side effect of a conventional differential is that it can limit traction under less
than ideal conditions. The amount of traction required to propel the vehicle at any given moment
depends on the load at that instanthow heavy the vehicle is, how much drag and friction there
is, the gradient of the road, the vehicle's momentum, and so on.
The torque applied to each driving wheel is a result of the engine, transmission and drive axles
applying a twisting force against the resistance of the traction at that roadwheel. Unless the load
is exceptionally high, the drivetrain can usually supply as much torque as necessary, so the
limiting factor is usually the traction under each wheel. It is therefore convenient to define
traction as the amount of torque that can be generated between the tire and the road surface,
before the wheel starts to slip. If the torque applied to drive wheels does not exceed the threshold
of traction, the vehicle will be propelled in the desired direction; if not, then one or more wheels
will simply spin.
With an open differential, however, where each tire is allowed to rotate at different speeds, as
soon as the tire atop the ice patch exceeds the threshold of traction available to it, it will begin to
spin or "slip". Additionally, once the traction threshold is broken and the tire experiences slip,
the traction available will also decrease in accordance to the laws of kinetic friction. Since an
open differential limits total torque applied to both drive wheels to the amount utilized by the
lower traction wheel multiplied by a factor of 2, when one wheel is on a slippery surface, the
total torque applied to the driving wheels will be lower than the minimum torque required for
vehicle propulsion. Thus, the vehicle will not be propelled.
A proposed way to distribute the power to the wheels, is to use the concept of gearless
differential, of which a review has been reported by Provatidis , but the various configurations
seem to correspond either to the "sliding pins and cams" type, such as the ZF B-70 available for
early VWs, or are a variation of the ball differential.
Many newer vehicles feature traction control, which partially mitigates the poor traction
characteristics of an open differential by using the anti-lock braking system to limit or stop the
slippage of the low traction wheel, thus transferring more torque to the wheel with good traction.
While not as effective in propelling a vehicle under poor traction conditions as a traction-aided
differential, it is better than a simple mechanical open differential with no electronic traction
assistance.
A differential gearbox is a completely mechanical device that consist of an enclosure, some gears
and shafts. It has three input/output shafts (I will call them x, y and z shaft). I said input/output
because any of these three shafts can serve as either input or output shaft but in any given
moment at least one shaft must be output and at least one shaft must be input.
Its main purpose is to sum or differentiate rotation rates (N) applied on its shafts, while
maintaining constant torque (T) ratio between shafts at any given moment. In general we can
say:
Where:
- Nx, Ny and Nz are rotation rates [rotations per second] for axes x, y and z
- Tx, Ty and Tz are torques [Newton-meter] on axes x, y and z
- A, B, and C are constants they depend on gear ratios inside the differential gearbox (note
that only two constants are actually needed, the third one is redundant)
If two shafts are used as input shafts then the gearbox will add their rotation rates (usually
weighted by some constants) and will deliver the result to third output shaft. On the other hand,
if only single shaft is used as an input shaft, the gearbox can split its rotation rate to two other
shafts (also usually weighted by some constants) but note that the percentage of this rotation
rate splitting doesnt have to have 50:50 or any other fixed ratio. Instead, this ratio is leveled to
maintain constant torque ratio between shafts (this works especially nice if applied loads have
such characteristic that increased rotation rate increases the torque).
The torque ratio between any two shafts is always maintained constant (a normal, two-shafted
gearbox behaves the same). The torque on all differential gearbox shafts can be increased or
decreased only simultaneously and proportionally. For example, if your car is driving along a
road and then one wheel steps into a mud, the increased drag will be simultaneously felt (in form
of increased torque) also by both, the other wheel and the engine. But if the mud is so slippery
that your wheel loses its grip, then reduced torque will also be felt by the other wheel and by the
engine. One wheel may spin in the mud, but the reduced torque on the other wheel will not be
enough to pull you out.
Three output shafts, together with belonging gears, are colored blue, yellow and green. The
simplest is the blue (x) shaft . It only has one gear directly attached to it.
Somewhat more complex is the yellow (y) shaft. The yellow gear attached to it drives (or is
driven by) another yellow double-gear (piggyback). The piggyback gear rotates around the green
shaft (it is not fixed to the green shaft). Otherwise there is no difference between blue gear and
yellow piggyback gear they both work symmetrically inside the differential gearbox.
The most complex one is the green (z) shaft and its two green gears. These two gears are
mounted to short stubs that go vertically from the shaft. As the shaft rotates both gears rotate all
around, carried by the stubs. In addition, every of these two gears can also rotate around the stub
it is mounted on.
The design shown below is invented to make things simpler. It is used sometimes in industry (for
small gearboxes used in servo systems).
There are (only) two gears, the blue one and the green one. The green one is special - it is
somewhat flexible. Streched by the yellow axle from inside, the flexible green gear touches
(becomes meshed with) the blue gear. The yellow axle can rotate inside the green 'ring-like' gear
causing it to touch the blue gear at different positions, 360 degrees around.
The thing is that the blue gear and the green gear don't have the same number of teeth. For
example the green could have 100, while the blue could have 101 teeth. After the yellow axle is
rotated for one revolution, the green and the blue will travel one tooth relative to each other.
(The above picture is only 2-D crossection of such differential mechanism. In reality, the green
gear must be very much extruded 'deeply into your monitor'. It looks like a cup - the bottom end
is non-deformable and its shaft is atteched there.)
Sure, there are many disadvantages of such differential gearbox mechanism. Teeth on blue and
green gears must be relatively small (there must be many of them), and the difference between
number of teeth must be small. Due to deformation of the green gear, teeth become non-idealy-
shaped. Also, heat is disipated when material is deformed.
Without the "square" set of four gears in the middle of the above diagram which yields to the
figure below, both wheels turn at the same angular velocity. This leads to problems when the car
negotiates a turn.
Now imagine the differential "square" alone, as illustrated in the following figure. It should be
apparent that turning one wheel results in the opposite wheel turning in the opposite direction at
the same rate.
One problem with an automotive differential is that if one wheel is held stationary, the
counterpart wheel turns at twice its normal speed as can be seen by examining the complete
scheme of automobile differential. This can be problematic when one wheel does not have
enough traction, such as when it is in snow or mud. The wheel without traction will spin without
providing traction and the opposite wheel will stay still so that the car does not move. This is the
reason for a device known as a "limited slip differential" or "traction control".
Gearbox casing is the shell (metal casing) in which a train of gears is sealed. The gearbox
casing houses important transmission components like gears and shafts. Thus the strength of the
gear box casing is an important parameter to be taken in to account while designing. The strength
of the gear box casing is important since the complete power is subjected to both static and
dynamic loading.
Bevel gears are gears where the axes of the two shafts intersect and the tooth-bearing faces of the
gears themselves are conically shaped. Bevel gears are most often mounted on shafts that are 90
degrees apart, but can be designed to work at other angles as well. The pitch surface of bevel
gears is a cone.
4.7.4.3.1 Applications
The bevel gear has many diverse applications such as locomotives, marine applications,
automobiles, printing presses, cooling towers, power plants, steel plants, railway track inspection
machines, etc.
For examples, see the following articles on:
Bevel gears are used in differential drives, which can transmit power to two axles
spinning at different speeds, such as those on a cornering automobile.
Bevel gears are used as the main mechanism for a hand drill. As the handle of the drill is
turned in a vertical direction, the bevel gears change the rotation of the chuck to a
horizontal rotation. The bevel gears in a hand drill have the added advantage of
increasing the speed of rotation of the chuck and this makes it possible to drill a range of
materials.
The gears in a bevel gear planer permit minor adjustment during assembly and allow for
some displacement due to deflection under operating loads without concentrating the load
on the end of the tooth.
Spiral bevel gears are important components on rotorcraft drive systems. These
components are required to operate at high speeds, high loads, and for a large number of
load cycles. In this application, spiral bevel gears are used to redirect the shaft from the
horizontal gas turbine engine to the vertical rotor.
4.7.4.3.2 Advantages
This gear makes it possible to change the operating angle.
Differing of the number of teeth (effectively diameter) on each wheel allows mechanical
advantage to be changed. By increasing or decreasing the ratio of teeth between the drive
and driven wheels one may change the ratio of rotations between the two, meaning that
the rotational drive and torque of the second wheel can be changed in relation to the first,
with speed increasing and torque decreasing, or speed decreasing and torque increasing.
4.7.4.3.3 Disadvantages
One wheel of such gear is designed to work with its complementary wheel and no other.
Must be precisely mounted.
The axes must be capable of supporting significant forces.
5. GEAR DIFFERENTIAL
A gear differential is a mechanism that is capable of adding and subtracting mechanically. To
be more precise, we should say that it adds the total revolutions of two shafts. It also
subtracts the total revolutions of one shaft from the total revolutions of another
shaftand delivers the answer by a third shaft. The gear differential will continuously and
accurately add or subtract any number of revolutions. It will produce a continuous series of
answers as the inputs change. Figure 11-8 is a cutaway drawing of a bevel gear differential
showing all of its parts and how they relate to each other. Grouped around the center of the
mechanism are four bevel gears meshed together. The two bevel gears on either side are end
gears. The two bevel gears above and below are spider gears. The long shaft running through
the end gears and the three spur gears is the spider shaft. The short shaft running through the
spider gears together with the spider gears themselves make up the spider. Each spider
gear and end gear is bearing-mounted on its shaft and is free to rotate. The spider shaft connects
with the spider cross shaft at the center block where they intersect. The ends of the spider shaft
are secured in flanges or hangers. The spider cross shaft and the spider shaft are also bearing-
mounted and are free to rotate on their axis. Therefore, since the two shafts are rigidly connected,
the spider (consisting of the spider cross shaft and the spider gears) must tumble, or spin, on the
axis of the spider shaft.
The main aim of the project is to focus on the mechanical design and contact
analysis on assembly of gears in gear box when they transmit power at different speeds at
2400 rpm, 5000 rpm. Analysis is also conducted by varying the materials for gears, Cast
Iron, and Aluminum Alloy.
The analysis is conducted to verify the best material for the gears in the gear box
at higher speeds by analyzing stress, displacement and also by considering weight
reduction.
7.2ALUMINUM ALLOY7475-T761
7.2.1 2400 rpm
7.2.1.1.1 Crown wheel
For satisfactory operation of bevel gears the number of teeth in the pinion must not be
48
Less than (vr)2
where v.r=velocity ratio
1+
48
= =7.5
1+(6.25)2
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/6.25)
=9.0
since the allowable static stresses(O) for both pinion and gear is same (i.e O=172.33 Mpa) and
y1P is less than y1G, therefore the pinion is weaker. Thus the design should be based upon the
pinion
WT = ( O x Cv).b..m. y1P((L-b)/L)
Dp NP
V=601000
=10.048m/s
Cv==3/3+10.048=0.229
475 2 80
L=( ) + ( 2 )2
2
=240.844
For satisfactory operation of the bevel gears the face width should be from 6.3m to 9.5m
So b is taken as 9.5m
b= 9.5x10=95
240.84495
WT =(172.33x0.229)x95xx10x0.04( ) = 2922.51N
240.844
DYNAMIC LOAD(WD)
The dynamic load for bevel gears may be obtained in similar manner as discussed for spur gears
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
V= pitch line velocity
b=face width
c=deformation/dynamic factor in N/mm
.
C= 1 1
+
K=0.111 for 20 full depth involute system
EP=youngs modulus for material of pinion in N/mm2=70300 N/mm2
EG=youngs modulus for material of gear in N/mm2= 70300N/mm2
e=tooth error action in mm
e value for module=10 used in precision gears is e=0.023
0.1110.023
c== 1 1 =90N/mm
+
70300 70300
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
2110.048(9590+2922.51)
WD = 2922.51+2110.048+9590+2922.5
WD =10532.23N
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
(Flexible endurance limit) e = 1.75XB.H.N = 1.75X140=245
240.84495
WS=245 95 10 0.041 ( 240.844 )
WS=18145N
For safety against tooth breakage the WS 1.25 Wd=13165.2875
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 2319.622
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= =319.622+8=1.951
+
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
es= surface endurance limit in mpa or N/mm2
=
es=(2.8B.H.N-70)N/mm 2
= (2.8517-70)=322 N/mm2
(3222 ) sin 20 1 1
K= 1.4
(70300 + 70300)=0.72
1 =cos 9 =0.987
80951.9510.72
Ww= 0.987
=10825.25N
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force 2922.51
WN= = cos 20 =3110.070N
COS
WT=480661/32.111=14968.733N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=14968.733tan 20 sin 9
=850.010N
D= DG+ DP=220
T= TG+ TP = 33
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/2.142)
=25.025
WT =( O x Cv).b..m. y1P((L-b)/L)
Cv=velocity factor =3/3+v, for teeth cut by form cutters
v=peripheral speed in m/s
b=face width
m=module=7
y1p=tooth form factor
L=slant height of pitch cone
= ( 2)2 + ( 2 )2
DG= pitch diameter of gear =150mm
Dp= pitch diameter of gear =70mm
Dp NP
V=601000
702400
= 601000
=8.792m/s
Cv==3/3+8.792=0.254
150 2 70
L=( ) + ( 2 )2
2
=82.764
The dynamic load for bevel gears may be obtained in similar manner as discussed for spur gears
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
V= pitch line velocity
b=face width
c=deformation/dynamic factor in N/mm
.
C= 1 1
+
K=0.111 for 20 full depth involute system
EP=youngs modulus for material of pinion in N/mm2
EG=youngs modulus for material of gear in N/mm2
e=tooth error action in mm
e value for module=7 used in precision gears is e=0.0186
0.1110.0186
c= 1 1 = 72.57N/mm
+
70300 70300
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+
21+.+Wt
218.792(66.572.57+1244.7)
WD = 1244.7+218.792+66.572.57+1244.7
WD = 5513.77
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
(Flexible endurance limit) e = 1.75XB.H.N = 1.75X140 =245
82.76466.5
WS= 245 66.5 7 0.099( 82.764 )
WS=6966.47N
For safety against tooth breakage the WS 1.25 Wd=6892.2125
WS > Wd
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 242.55
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= = =1.439
+ 42.55+16.554
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
(3222 ) sin 20 1 1
K= 1.4
(70300 + 70300)=0.72
1 =cos 25.025 =0.906
7066.51.4390.72
Ww= =5322.62N
0.906
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force 1244.7
WN= = =1324.582N
COS 0.939
WT=480661/20.944=22949.818N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=22949.818tan 20 sin 25.0259
=3533.340N
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/6.25)
=9.0
Since the allowable static stresses(O) for both pinion and gear is same (i.e O=172.33 Mpa) and
y1P is less than y1G, therefore the pinion is weaker. Thus the design should be based upon the
pinion
WT =( O x Cv).b..m. y1P((L-b)/L)
Cv==3/3+20.93=0.125
475 2 80
L=( ) + ( 2 )2
2
=240.844
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
0.1110.023
c= 1 1 =89.73
+
70300 70300
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
2120.933(9590+1595.225)
=1595.225+2120.933+9590+1595.225
WD =9830.39N
STATIC TOOTH LOAD (WS)
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 2319.622
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= =319.622+8=1.951
+
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
es= surface endurance limit in mpa or N/mm2
=
es=(2.8B.H.N-70)N/mm2
= (2.8140-70)=322 N/mm2
(3222 ) sin 20 1 1
K= 1.4
(70300 + 70300)=0.72
1 =cos 9 =0.987
80951.9510.72
WW= 0.987
=10825.25N
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force
WN= COS
1595.225
WN= cos 20 =1697.602N
T=480.905N-m=480905.254N-mm
WT=480905.254/32.111=22961.480N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=22961.480 tan 20 sin 25.025
=3535.424N
D= DG+ DP=220
T= TG+ TP = 33
Module = m=D/T=220/33=6.66=7(according to stds)
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/2.142)
=25.025
Since the allowable static stresses(O) for both pinion and gear is same (i.e O=172.33 Mpa) and
y1P is less than y1G, therefore the pinion is weaker. Thus the design should be based upon the
pinion
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
2118.316(66.572.57+686)
WD = 686+2118.316+66.572.57+686
WD = 4620.13N
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
(Flexible endurance limit) e = 1.75XB.H.N = 1.75X140 =245
82.76466.5
WS= 245 66.5 7 0.099( 82.764 )
WS=6966.47N
For safety against tooth breakage the WS 1.25 Wd=5775.162
WS > Wd
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 242.55
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= =42.55+16.554=1.439
+
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
es= surface endurance limit in mpa or N/mm2
=
es=(2.8B.H.N-70)N/mm 2
= (2.8140-70)=322
(3222 ) sin 20 1 1
K= 1.4
(70300 + 70300)=0.72
1 =cos 25.025 =0.906
7066.51.4390.72
Ww= =5323.347N
0.906
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force 686
WN= =cos 20=730.025N
COS
WT=480661/20.944=22961.480N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=22961.480tan 20 sin 25.0259
=3535.424N
7.3.12400 rpm
7.3.1.1.1Crown wheel
Diameter of crown wheel = DG= 475mm
Number of teeth on gear = TG = 50
Number of teeth on pinion = TP = 8
Module = m=DG/TG=475/50=9.5=10(according to stds)
Diameter of pinion = DP = mx TP= 10x8 = 80mm
For satisfactory operation of bevel gears the number odf teeth in the pinion must not be
48
Less than (vr)2
where v.r=velocity ratio
1+
48
= =7.5
1+(6.25)2
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/6.25)
=9.0
Pitch angle of gear p2=90-9=81
Since the allowable static stresses(O) for both pinion and gear is same (i.e O=196 Mpa) and
y1P is less than y1G, therefore the pinion is weaker. Thus the design should be based upon the
pinion
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
V= pitch line velocity
b=face width
c=deformation/dynamic factor in N/mm
.
C= 1 1
+
K=0.111 for 20 full depth involute system
0.1110.023
c= 1 1
+
103000 103000
=131.479N/mm
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
2110.048(95131.479+3243.079)
WD = 3243.079+2110.048+95131.479+3243.079
WD = 13110.818N
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
(Flexible endurance limit) e = 1.75XB.H.N = 1.75X300 =525N/mm2
240.84495
WS= 525 95 10 0.04( 240.844 )
WS=37933.706N
For safety against tooth breakage the WS 1.25 Wd=16388.522N
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 2319.622
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= =319.622+8=1.951
+
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
es= surface endurance limit in mpa or N/mm2
=
es=(2.8B.H.N-70)N/mm2
= (2.8300-70)=770 N/mm2
7702 sin 20 1 1
K= (103000 + 103000)
1.4
=2.812
1 =cos 9 =0.987
80951.9512.812
Ww= 0.987
=42244.388N
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force 3243.079
WN= = cos 20
COS
=3451.212N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=14968.733tan 20 sin 9
=850.010N
D= DG+ DP=220
T= TG+ TP = 33
Module = m=D/T=220/33=6.66=7(according to stds)
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/2.142)
=25.025
Since the allowable static stresses(O) for both pinion and gear is same (i.e O=126.66 Mpa) and
y1P is less than y1G, therefore the pinion is weaker. Thus the design should be based upon the
pinion
Cv==3/3+8.792=0.254
150 2 70
L=( ) + ( 2 )2
2
=82.764
The factor (L-b/L) may be called as bevel factor
For satisfactory operation of the bevel gears the face width should be from 6.3m to 9.5m
So b is taken as 9.5m
b= 9.5x7=66.5
82.76466.5
WT=(196x0.254)x66.5xx7x0.099( )
82.764
=1415.587N
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+
21+.+Wt
V= pitch line velocity
b=face width
c=deformation/dynamic factor in N/mm
.
C= 1 1
+
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
218.792(66.5106.3269+1415.587)
WD = 1415.587+218.792+66.5106.3269+1415.587
WD = 1883.579N
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
(Flexible endurance limit) e = 1.75XB.H.N = 1.75X300 =525
82.76466.5
WS= 525 66.5 7 0.099( 82.764 )
WS=14928.16N
For safety against tooth breakage the WS 1.25 Wd=2354.39
WS > Wd
WEAR LOAD (WW)
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 242.55
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= =42.55+16.554=1.439
+
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
es= surface endurance limit in mpa or N/mm2
=
es=(2.8B.H.N-70)N/mm2
= (2.8300-70)=770
(770)2 20 1 1
K= (103000 + 103000)=2.812
1.4
1 =cos 25.025 =0.906
7066.51.4392.812
Ww= =20790.62N
0.906
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force 1415.587
WN= = 0.939 =1507.54N
COS
WT=480661/20.944=22949.818N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=22949.818tan 20 sin 25.0259
=3533.340N
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/6.25)
=9.0
Since the allowable static stresses(O) for both pinion and gear is same (i.e O=196 Mpa) and
y1P is less than y1G, therefore the pinion is weaker. Thus the design should be based upon the
pinion
Cv=3/3+20.93=0.125
475 2 80
L=( ) + ( 2 )2
2
=240.844
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
0.1110.023
c= 1 1
+
103000 103000
=131.479N/mm
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
2120.933(95131.479+1770.24)
=1770.24 + 2120.933+95131.479+1770.24
WD = 11214.311N
STATIC LOAD (WS)
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
(Flexible endurance limit) e = 1.75XB.H.N = 1.75X300 =525
240.84495
=525 95 10 0.04( 240.844 )
WS=37933.706N
For safety against tooth breakage the WS 1.25 Wd=14017.88
ThereforeWS > Wd
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 2319.622
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= =319.622+8=1.951
+
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
es= surface endurance limit in mpa or N/mm2
=
es=(2.8B.H.N-70)N/mm2
= (2.8300-70)=770
7702 sin 20 1 1
K= (103000 + 103000)=2.812
1.4
1 =cos 9 =0.987
80951.9512.812
Ww= 0.987
=42244.388N
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force 1770.24
WN= = cos 20
COS
WN=1883.850N
Radial force WR= tan 20=1770.24tan 20=644.314N
WT=480905.254/32.111=22961.480N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=22961.480 tan 20 sin 25.025
=3535.424N
Since the shafts are at right angles therefore pitch angle for the pinion
p1=tan-1(1/v.r)
= tan-1(1/2.142)
=25.025
Pitch angle of gear p2=90-25.025=64.974
Cv==3/3+18.316=0.140
150 2 70
L=( ) + ( 2 )2
2
=82.764
WD= WT+ WI
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
V= pitch line velocity
b=face width
c=deformation/dynamic factor in N/mm
.
C= 1 1
+
K=0.111 for 20 full depth involute system
EP=youngs modulus for material of pinion in N/mm2=103000 N/mm2
EG=youngs modulus for material of gear in N/mm2=103000 N/mm2
e=tooth error action in mm
e value for module=7 used in precision gears is e=0.0186
0.1110.0186
c= 1 1 = 106.326N/mm
+
103000 103000
21(.+WT)
WD =WT+21+.+Wt
2118.316(66.5106.326+780.245)
WD =780.245+2118.316+66.5106.326+780.245
WD = 7161.239N
The static tooth load or endurance strength of the tooth for bevel gear is given by
WS= e.b..m. y1P( )
(Flexible endurance limit) e = 1.75XB.H.N = 1.75X300 =525
82.76466.5
WS= 525 66.5 7 0.099( 82.764 )
WS=14928.16
For safety against tooth breakage the WS 1.25 Wd=8951.548N
WS > Wd
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
Ww=
1
Dp,b,q,k have usual meanings as discussed in spur gears except that Q is based on formative or
2 242.55
equivalent no.of teeth such that ratio factor Q= =42.55+16.554=1.439
+
K= load stress factor (also known as material combination factor )in N/mm2 given by
2 1 1
K= ( + )
1.4
es= surface endurance limit in mpa or N/mm2
=
es=(2.8B.H.N-70)N/mm2
= (2.8300-70)=770
7702 sin 20 1 1
K= (103000 + 103000)=2.812
1.4
1 =cos 25.025 =0.906
7066.51.4392.812
Ww= =20790.62N
0.906
Forces acting
WT=WNCOS
WN=normal load=WT/ COS
WT=tangential force
tangential force 780.245
WN= = cos 20 =830.319N
COS
WT=480905.254/20.944=22961.480N
Axial force
WRH=WTtan sin P1
=22961.480tan 20 sin 25.0259
=3535.424N
CADD environments often involve more than just shapes. As in the manual drafting of technical
and engineering drawings, the output of CAD must convey information, such as materials,
processes, dimensions, and tolerances, according to application-specific conventions. CAD may
be used to design curves and figures in two-dimensional (2D) space; or curves, surfaces, and
solids in three-dimensional (3D) objects.
CAD is an important industrial art extensively used in many applications, including automotive,
shipbuilding, and aerospace industries, industrial and architectural design, prosthetics, and many
more. CAD is also widely used to produce computer animation for special effects in movies,
advertising and technical manuals. The modern ubiquity and power of computers means that
even perfume bottles and shampoo dispensers are designed using techniques unheard of by
engineers of the 1960s. Because of its enormous economic importance, CAD has been a major
driving force for research in computational geometry, computer graphics (both hardware and
software), and discrete differential geometry.
Current computer-aided design software packages range from 2D vector-based drafting systems
to 3D solid and surface modellers. Modern CAD packages can also frequently allow rotations in
three dimensions, allowing viewing of a designed object from any desired angle, even from the
inside looking out. Some CAD software is capable of dynamic mathematic modeling, in which
case it may be marketed as CADD computer-aided design and drafting.
CAD is used in the design of tools and machinery and in the drafting and design of all types of
buildings, from small residential types (houses) to the largest commercial and industrial
structures (hospitals and factories). CAD is mainly used for detailed engineering of 3D models
and/or 2D drawings of physical components, but it is also used throughout the engineering
process from conceptual design and layout of products, through strength and dynamic analysis of
assemblies to definition of manufacturing methods of components. It can also be used to design
objects.
CAD has become an especially important technology within the scope of computer-aided
technologies, with benefits such as lower product development costs and a greatly shortened
design cycle. CAD enables designers to lay out and develop work on screen, print it out and save
it for future editing, saving time on their drawings.
8.1 INTRODUCTION TO PRO/ENGINEER
Customer requirements may change and time pressures may continue to mount, but your product
design needs remain the same - regardless of your project's scope, you need the powerful, easy-
to-use, affordable solution that Pro/ENGINEER provides.
Part Design
Assembly
Drawing
Sheet Metal
8.2 MODEL OF DIFFERENTIAL GEAR
8.2.1CROWN
8.2.2PINION
8.2.3 PLANET
8.2.4 SUNGEAR
8.2.5 MAIN SHAFT_PINION
Finite element analysis (FEA) is a fairly recent discipline crossing the boundaries of
mathematics, physics, engineering and computer science. The method has wide application and
enjoys extensive utilization in the structural, thermal and fluid analysis areas. The finite element
method is comprised of three major phases: (1) pre-processing, in which the analyst develops a
finite element mesh to divide the subject geometry into subdomains for mathematical analysis,
and applies material properties and boundary conditions, (2) solution, during which the program
derives the governing matrix equations from the model and solves for the primary quantities, and
(3) post-processing, in which the analyst checks the validity of the solution, examines the values
of primary quantities (such as displacements and stresses), and derives and examines additional
quantities (such as specialized stresses and error indicators).
The advantages of FEA are numerous and important. A new design concept may be modeled to
determine its real world behavior under various load environments, and may therefore be refined
prior to the creation of drawings, when few dollars have been committed and changes are
inexpensive. Once a detailed CAD model has been developed, FEA can analyze the design in
detail, saving time and money by reducing the number of prototypes required. An existing
product which is experiencing a field problem, or is simply being improved, can be analyzed to
speed an engineering change and reduce its cost. In addition, FEA can be performed on
increasingly affordable computer workstations and personal computers, and professional
assistance is available.
It is also important to recognize the limitations of FEA. Commercial software packages and the
required hardware, which have seen substantial price reductions, still require a significant
investment. The method can reduce product testing, but cannot totally replace it. Probably most
important, an inexperienced user can deliver incorrect answers, upon which expensive decisions
will be based. FEA is a demanding tool, in that the analyst must be proficient not only in
elasticity or fluids, but also in mathematics, computer science, and especially the finite element
method itself.
Which FEA package to use is a subject that cannot possibly be covered in this short discussion,
and the choice involves personal preferences as well as package functionality. Where to run the
package depends on the type of analyses being performed. A typical finite element solution
requires a fast, modern disk subsystem for acceptable performance. Memory requirements are of
course dependent on the code, but in the interest of performance, the more the better, with a
representative range measured in gigabytes per user. Processing power is the final link in the
performance chain, with clock speed, cache, pipelining and multi-processing all contributing to
the bottom line. These analyses can run for hours on the fastest systems, so computing power is
of the essence.
One aspect often overlooked when entering the finite element area is education. Without
adequate training on the finite element method and the specific FEA package, a new user will not
be productive in a reasonable amount of time, and may in fact fail miserably. Expect to dedicate
one to two weeks up front, and another one to two weeks over the first year, to either classroom
or self-help education. It is also important that the user have a basic understanding of the
computer's operating system.
9.1 INTRODUCTION TO COSMOSWORKS
Cosmosworks is a useful software for design analysis in mechanical engineering. Thats an
introduction for you who would like to learn more about COSMOSWorks. COSMOSWorks is a
design analysis automation application fully integrated with SolidWorks.
This software uses the Finite Element Method (FEM) to simulate the working conditions of your
designs and predict their behavior. FEM requires the solution of large systems of equations.
Powered by fast solvers, COSMOSWorks makes it possible for designers to quickly check the
integrity of their designs and search for the optimum solution.
Model
9.2.1.1.4Units
Unit system: SI (MKS)
Length/Displacement mm
Temperature Kelvin
Angular velocity Rad/sec
Pressure/Stress N/m^2
Unit system: SI (MKS)
Length/Displacement mm
Temperature Kelvin
Angular velocity Rad/sec
Pressure/Stress N/m^2
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) 178.306 621.812 -91.4611 653.306
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
2part_assm-2400_aluminiumally_tangential_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-2400_aluminiumally_tangential_load-Displacement-Displacement1
Name Type Min Max
Strain1 ESTRN: Equivalent Strain 2.08727e-014 4.15934e-005
Element: 20859 Element: 1069
2part_assm-2400_aluminiumally_tangential_load-Strain-Strain1
9.2.1.2.5 STATIC LOAD
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) 1941.59 1881.96 -370.659 2729.27
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
Entities: 11 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 6966.47 N
Force-2
9.2.1.2.7 Study Results
2part_assm-2400_aluminiumally_static_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-2400_aluminiumally_static_load-Strain-Strain1
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) 378.494 287.568 -36.4058 476.738
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
Entities: 11 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 1415.59 N
Force-2
9.2.1.3.4 Study Results
2part_assm-2400_castiron_tangential_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-2400_castiron_tangential_load-Displacement-Displacement1
Name Type Min Max
Strain1 ESTRN: Equivalent Strain 9.90157e-013 1.69558e-005
Element: 21285 Element: 9903
2part_assm-2400_castiron_tangential_load-Strain-Strain1
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) 4230.77 3829.18 -471.957 5725.8
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
Load name Load Image Load Details
Entities: 9 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 37933.7 N
Force-1
Entities: 11 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 14928.2 N
Force-2
9.2.1.3.7 Study Results
2part_assm-2400_castiron_static_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-2400_castiron_static_load-Displacement-Displacement1
Name Type Min Max
Strain1 ESTRN: Equivalent Strain 8.223e-012 0.000198329
Element: 21285 Element: 9903
2part_assm-2400_castiron_static_load-Strain-Strain1
9.2.2 5000 RPM
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) 196.301 117.513 -15.5613 229.316
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
Entities: 11 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 780.245 N
Force-2
9.2.2.2 .3 Study Results
2part_assm-5000_aluminiumally_tangential_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-5000_aluminiumally_tangential_load-Displacement-Displacement1
Name Type Min Max
Strain1 ESTRN: Equivalent Strain 1.78999e-012 2.25582e-005
Element: 21552 Element: 9903
2part_assm-5000_aluminiumally_tangential_load-Strain-Strain1
9.2.2.2 .4 STATIC LOAD
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) -1902.68 1875.88 446.924 2709.03
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
Entities: 11 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 6966.47 N
Force-2
9.2.2.2 .6 Study Results
2part_assm-5000_aluminiumally_static_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-5000_aluminiumally_static_load-Displacement-Displacement1
Name Type Min Max
Strain1 ESTRN: Equivalent Strain 1.90385e-011 0.000274774
Element: 20187 Element: 12410
2part_assm-5000_aluminiumally_static_load-Strain-Strain1
9.2.2.3 CAST IRON
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) 195.449 153.057 -14.6943 248.682
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
Entities: 11 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 780.245 N
Force-2
9.2.2.3 .3 Study Results
2part_assm-5000_castiron_tangential_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-5000_castiron_tangential_load-Displacement-Displacement1
Name Type Min Max
Strain1 ESTRN: Equivalent Strain 5.14296e-013 9.32532e-006
Element: 18469 Element: 1069
2part_assm-5000_castiron_tangential_load-Strain-Strain1
9.2.2.3 .4 STATIC LOAD
Fixed-1
Resultant Forces
Components X Y Z Resultant
Reaction force(N) 4093.63 3829.02 -1648.28 5842.6
Reaction Moment(N-m) 0 0 0 0
Entities: 11 face(s)
Type: Apply normal force
Value: 14928.2 N
Force-2
9.2.2.3 .6 Study Results
2part_assm-5000_castiron__static_load-Stress-Stress1
2part_assm-5000_castiron__static_load-Displacement-Displacement1
Name Type Min Max
Strain1 ESTRN: Equivalent Strain 1.19677e-011 0.000199826
Element: 18466 Element: 1069
2part_assm-5000_castiron__static_load-Strain-Strain1
10. RESULTS TABLE
2part_assm-aluminiumalloy_frequency-Displacement-Displacement1
2part_assm-aluminiumalloy_frequency-Displacement-Displacement2
Name Type Min Max
Displacement3 URES: Resultant Displacement 0 mm 312.409 mm
Plot for Mode Shape: 3(Value = Node: 3106 Node: 26119
333.527 Hz)
2part_assm-aluminiumalloy_frequency-Displacement-Displacement3
2part_assm-aluminiumalloy_frequency-Displacement-Displacement5
2part_assm-c_i__frequency-Displacement-Displacement1
2part_assm-c_i__frequency-Displacement-Displacement2
Name Type Min Max
Displacement3 URES: Resultant Displacement 0 mm 186.029 mm
Plot for Mode Shape: 3(Value = Node: 3106 Node: 27613
343.648 Hz)
2part_assm-c_i__frequency-Displacement-Displacement3
2part_assm-c_i__frequency-Displacement-Displacement4
Name Type Min Max
Displacement5 URES: Resultant Displacement 0 mm 448.102 mm
Plot for Mode Shape: 5(Value = Node: 3106 Node: 2384
884.969 Hz)
2part_assm-c_i__frequency-Displacement-Displacement5
Structural and Frequency analyses are done on the differential gear box to verify the best
material by taking in to account stresses, displacements, weight etc.
By observing the structural analysis results using Aluminum alloy the stress values are within the
permissible stress value. So using Aluminum Alloy is safe for differential gear. When
comparing the stress values of the three materials for all speeds 2400rpm and 5000rpm, the
values are less for Aluminum alloy than Cast Iron.
By observing the frequency analysis, the vibrations are less for Aluminum Alloy than cast iron
since its natural frequency is less.
And also weight of the Aluminum alloy reduces almost 3 times when compared with d Cast Iron
since its density is very less. Thereby mechanical efficiency will be increased.