CH 17
CH 17
CH 17
Just like an alkene, benzene has clouds of electrons above and below its sigma bond framework.
Although the electrons are in a stable aromatic system, they are still available for reaction with strong
electrophiles.
This cation is called a sigma complex because the electrophile is joined to the benzene ring through a new sigma
bond.
The sigma complex (also called an arenium ion) is not aromatic since it contains an sp3 carbon (which disrupts the
required loop of p orbitals).
The sigma complex wishes to regain its aromaticity, and it may do so by either by a reversal of the first step (i.e.
regenerate the starting material) or by loss of the proton on the sp3 carbon (leading to a substitution product).
There are a wide variety of electrophiles that can be introduced into a benzene ring in this way, and so electrophilic
aromatic substitution is a very important method for the synthesis of substituted aromatic compounds.
The formation of the sigma complex is an endothermic and energetically unfavorable process - it is therefore the
rate determining step.
An analogous addition reaction between benzene and bromine would be endothermic by +2kcal.
The substitution of bromine for hydrogen is an overall exothermic process, but requires a catalyst to convert the
bromine molecule into a more reactive electrophile.
Iodination of Benzene
The iodination procedure requires an acidic oxidizing agent, such as nitric acid.
The nitric acid is a strong oxidizer (i.e. removes electrons, converts iodine into I+), this makes the iodine a much
stronger electrophile.
The nitric acid is consumed in the reaction, it is therefore a reagent, not a catalyst.
However, this reaction proceeds slowly, which is inconvenient (dangerous) since hot, conc. nitric acid is a
powerful oxidizer, and organic compounds are easily oxidizable. (i.e. potential for BOOM!)
The sulfuric acid behaves as a catalyst, and allows this nitration reaction to proceed at a lower temperature and
more quickly (i.e. safer).
Sulfuric acid reacts with nitric acid to generate a nitronium ion (NO2+), which is a very powerful electrophile.
After protonation, water is eliminated (good leaving group), and the nitronium ion is generated.
Sulfonation of Benzene
Benzene will react with sulfur trioxide, and in the presence of an acid, aryl sulfonic acids are produced.
The sigma complex loses a proton to regain its aromaticity, and then the oxyanion becomes protonated.
The mechanism for desulfonation is identical to the sulfonation mechanism, except in the reverse order.
After protonation has occurred, the sigma complex can lose either of the hydrogens from the sp 3 carbon to regain
its aromaticity.
To prove that reaction has actually occurred, deuterated sulfuric acid can be used.
If a large excess of deuterated reagent is used, hexadeuteriobenzene can be produced from this equilibrium
reaction.
Benzene derivatives in a general sense react in the same way that benzene does, although there are some interesting
differences.
1) Toluene reacts about 25 times faster than benzene under identical conditions. (We say toluene is activated
toward electrophilic aromatic substitution, and that the methyl group is an activating group).
2) Nitration of toluene generates a mixture of products. The major products are those with substitution at the ortho
and para positions. (This preference for o/p substitution makes the methyl group an ortho/para director).
The product ratios imply that substitution at each position is not equally likely or energetically favorable).
The distribution is not random, since if it were, there would be 40% ortho, 40% meta and 20% para.
This step is also when the electrophile binds to the ring (i.e. governs the location of substitution).
The enhanced rate and substitution pattern for toluene can be explained by considering the structures of the
intermediate sigma complexes for substitution at each of the different positions.
The RDS is highly endothermic, therefore according to Hammond's postulate (Ch 4), the energy of the TS should
resemble the energy of the product (in this case the product is actually an intermediate, the sigma complex).
Thus it is reasonable to discuss the energies of the TS in terms of the stabilities of the sigma complexes (i.e. cation
stabilities).
When benzene reacts with the nitronium ion, the resulting sigma complex has the positive charge equally
distributed over three secondary carbon atoms.
Since the sigma complexes for ortho (and para) attack have resonance forms with tertiary carbons, they are more
stable that the corresponding resonance forms for benzene's reaction with nitronium ion.
Thus toluene reacts faster than benzene at the ortho and para positions.
When reaction of toluene occurs at the meta position, then the resonance forms of the sigma complex put positive
charge over 3 secondary carbons - the same as for benzene.
Therefore meta substitution of toluene does not show any (significant) enhancement of rate relative to benzene.
This effect is pronounced in ortho and para attack since these give rise to resonance structures which contain
tertiary carbons, and are therefore more stable.
Meta substitution does not show these huge stabilizations, and is only slightly more stable then the unsubstituted
benzene case.
Any alkyl benzene will under EAS faster than benzene itself, and will generate products that are primarily ortho
and para.
The alkyl group is an activating group, and is ortho and para directing.
This is called inductive stabilization, since the alkyl group donates electron density through the bond which
attaches it to the benzene ring.
The ortho and para isomers are the two major ones, whereas the meta isomer is only present in a small amount.
Since oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, it may seem strange that methoxyl is a better activating group
than methyl for EAS.
However, the difference is that the methoxyl group has lone pairs.
The second resonance structure (next slide) is still a significant one since despite putting the positive charge on a
more electronegative element (bad) since it has more bonds than the previous structure (good) and also carbon
now has a full octet (good).
The oxygen atom is said to be resonance donating, or pi donating since it is donating electron density through a
bond in one of the resonance structures.
Just like the activating alkyl groups, anisole preferentially activates the ortho and para positions.
Again it is the non bonding electrons that provide resonance stabilization of the sigma complex when the attack is
ortho and para.
Therefore any substituent with a lone pair of electrons on the atom directly bonded to the benzene ring can
provide this resonance stabilization of the sigma complex for ortho and para attack.
Nitration of nitrobenzene requires concentrated nitric and sulfuric acids at temperatures above 100C.
This proceeds slowly, and the dinitrobenzene product produces three isomers, with the meta isomer being the
major one.
In the same way that electron donating groups activate the ortho and para positions, an electron withdrawing group
deactivates the ortho and para positions.
This selective deactivation leaves the meta position as the most reactive site for attack.
Meta directors deactivate the meta position much less than they deactivate the ortho and para positions.
O- O
N+ N+
O O-
This removal of electron density makes the ring a worse nucleophile, therefore the nitro group is deactivating for
EAS.
The deactivation is strongest for attack at the ortho and para positions since these orientations place positive charge
adjacent to the nitro group, and having identical charges on adjacent carbons is very unfavorable due to the
repulsion of like charges.
For meta attack, the positive charges are never on adjacent carbons, therefore this is relatively the most stable site
for attack.
Deactivating groups have either full or partial positive charges on the atom bound directly to the ring.
Halogen substituents are deactivating, yet are ortho and para directors.
Halogens are unusual (special/interesting) since they show an interesting dichotomy of features:
1) The halogens are very electronegative. They can powerfully withdraw electron density from the ring inductively
through the sigma bond (therefore deactivating).
2) The halogens have lone pairs of electrons that can donate electron density (resonance donation) through
bonding (therefore ortho and para directors).
These effects oppose one another and make the halogens the exceptions to the previous generalizations.
Reaction at the meta position does not allow for the positive charge to be placed adjacent to the halogen, and
therefore does not result in any stabilization.
Halogens are deactivating because of the inductive withdrawal of electron density from the ring, yet are ortho para
directors since they can use resonance donation to stabilize adjacent carbocations.
For example we can predict that xylenes (dimethyl benzenes) will be activated to EAS,
However, the relative reactivity (and directing effect) of toluic acid is less obvious.
For meta xylene, there are two sites which are ortho to one methyl group and para to the other (double
reinforcement).
Another site is doubly reinforced, yet since it is between the two methyl groups, it is sterically hindered, and is
therefore of reduced reactivity.
The nitro group also directs to this position since it is a meta director.
Both groups direct to the same site, and this reaction is very site selective.
E.g. o-xylene is activated at all positions, and so mixtures of nitrated products are observed.
Substituents can be divided into three groups, differing in the strength of their directing abilities.
If two substituents are in conflict of directing abilities, the stronger one will win.
Friedal and Craft demonstrated that benzene would react with alkyl halides in the presence of a Lewis acid (e.g.
AlCl3) to produce alkyl benzenes.
The tbutyl carbocation acts as the electrophile, and forms a sigma complex.
For secondary and tertiary halides, the reactive species probably is the free carbocation.
Whereas for primary alkyl halides (which cannot form stable carbocations) the electrophilic species is a complex of
the Lewis acid and the alkyl halide.
In this complex, the C-X bond is weakened (dashed line), and there is considerable positive charge on the carbon
(but not a free carbocation).
and also through reaction of alcohols with boron trifluoride (a good Lewis acid).
1) They only work with activated benzenes, benzene itself and halobenzenes. Strongly deactivated aromatics
cannot be used in these reactions.
Systems such as nitrobenzene, benzenesulfonic acids and phenyl ketones all fail to react.
2) Since these reactions involve carbocations (or carbocation like) species, there is the possibility of carbocation
rearrangements.
Certain alkyl groups can be introduced without rearrangement (tbutyl-, isopropyl-, ethyl-) but consider what
happens when we try to introduce an n-propyl group.
Even if only 1 equivalent of alkylating agent is added, a mixture of polysubstituted products are recovered, along
with unreacted benzene.
O
R C
acyl
In the presence of a Lewis acid, an acyl chloride reacts with benzene to produce a phenyl ketone (or acylbenzene).
This Friedal-Crafts acylation is the same as the alkylation except that an acyl chloride is used instead of an alkyl
chloride, and that an acyl group is incorporated instead of an alkyl group.
The acyl halide reacts with the Lewis acid, and loss of AlCl4- generates a resonance stabilized acylium ion.
The acylium ion is a strong electrophile, and reacts with benzene generating an acylbenzene.
The product is a ketone, and since this is a deactivating group, poly-substitution does not occur. (Advantage over
alkylation).
The acylium ion is resonance stabilized, and therefore will tend not to rearrange.
The Friedal-Crafts acylation however also still does not work with strongly deactivated systems.
All that is required is the reduction of the acyl carbonyl group to a CH2.
The reagents used are a zinc/mercury amalgam and aqueous hydrochloric acid.
Therefore to synthesize n-propyl benzene (which we could not do via direct FC alkylation), we can acylate using
propanoyl chloride, and then reduce the phenyl ketone product which gives our final product.
A high pressure mixture of carbon monoxide and HCl together with a catalyst can generate a formyl cation, which
can then react with benzene to produce formyl benzene (more often called benzaldehyde).
However, it is also possible for nucleophiles to displace halides ions (i.e. good leaving groups) from aryl halides if
there are strong electron withdrawing electron groups bound to the ring (and especially if they are located ortho
and para to the halide).
Since a nucleophile substitutes for the leaving group on the benzene ring, this is called nucleophilic aromatic
substitution.
For example 2,4-dinitrochlorobenzene will undergo reaction with nucleophiles such as ammonia and hydroxide,
where the chlorine becomes displaced.
Yet the SN1 mechanism also cannot operate since the reaction is not found to be unimolecular, and strong
nucleophiles are required. (Also we would not expect ionization of the aryl halogen bond to give an aryl cation to
proceed easily).
When the nucleophile attacks the carbon bearing the chlorine, a negatively charged sigma complex is generated.
The negative charge is delocalized over the ortho and para positions, and further delocalized into the electron
withdrawing groups (conveniently located at these positions).
However, under forcing conditions, unactivated halobenzenes can react with strong bases.
For example, phenol is produced commercially via the reaction of sodium hydroxide with chlorobenzene.
A clue to the mechanism of this type of reaction was provided by the below reaction:
The products were found to be a 50:50 mixture of meta and para substituted compounds.
These two isomers can be explained as coming from the same intermediate, a Benzyne.
The anion can expel the leaving group, thus generating a neutral species and another bond (making a triple bond).
The amide nucleophile attacks the triple bond, generating a carbanion, which then gets protonated to give the
product.
The attack on the triple bond may occur with equal probability (and energy) at either end, and thus the 50:50
mixture results.
Chlorination
For example, if benzene is treated with an excess of chlorine under conditions of heat and pressure, then 6 chlorine
atoms will add, generating 1,2,3,4,5,6-hexachlorocyclohexane.
This is believed to proceed through free radical intermediates, but the mechanism is not relevant here.
Catalytic Hydrogenation
The addition of hydrogen to benzene occurs at elevated temperatures and pressures, and requires a catalyst.
Intermediate unsaturated compounds like cyclohexene or dienes cannot be prepared because of the high pressures
involved.
The use of sodium (or lithium) in a mixture of alcohol and liquid ammonia is called the Birch reduction.
The mechanism is very similar to the sodium/liquid ammonia reduction of alkynes to trans alkenes (Ch 9).
Na Na+ and e-
An electron adds to the benzene, producing a radical anion, and the anion quickly abstracts a proton from the
solvent.
The cyclohexadienyl radical receives another electron to produce a cyclohexadienyl anion, that in turn gets
protonated to give the reduced product.
Therefore reduction occurs on the carbon atoms bound to electron withdrawing groups, and not at carbons bearing
electron donating groups.
For example, ethylbenzene reacts with bromine (or NBS) under UV irradiation to give (1-bromoethyl)benzene and
(1,1-dibromoethyl)benzene.
If a benzylic cation has more than one phenyl group as a substituent then the stabilizing effects are additive, and
these are very stable systems.
During the displacement, the p orbital that partially bonds to the nucleophile and leaving group also overlaps with
the electrons of the aromatic ring.
This conjugation lowers the energy of the TS, and so enhances reaction rate.
E.g.
The aromatic ring in phenol also gives rise to some unique phenol reactions.
However, oxidation of phenols gives conjugated 1,4-diketone products, which are called quinones.
Most commonly this is achieved with chromic acid, although some phenols will auto-oxidize in the presence of air
(oxygen).
Even silver bromide (weak oxidant) can accomplish this transformation. (The basis of black and white
photography).
The high reactivity of phenol allows the use of weak Lewis acid catalysts (e.g. HF) in alkyl-or acyl-ations which
helps prevent the possibility of over reaction.
Phenoxide anions are so strongly activated that they even undergo EAS with carbon dioxide (a weak electrophile).
E.g.