Running Head: LIFE SENTENCE 1
Running Head: LIFE SENTENCE 1
Running Head: LIFE SENTENCE 1
Katrina A. Hughes
Abstract
Previous studies on the impact of higher prison sentencing on nonviolent drug offenders and its
correlation with prison overpopulation have shown to produce negative effects on the prisoners
as well as the community. The author focuses on the scenarios and litigation from the United
States of America. This paper aims to draw a parallel between prison overcrowding negative
As the United States enters into a new year, it is important to remember the things the
nation has learned thus far. As New York Times writer David Brooks puts it, the prison
problem is past due for a drastic change: pretty much everybody from Barack Obama to Carly
Fiorina seems to agree that far too many Americans are stuck behind bars (Brooks, 2015). Mass
incarceration, specifically of state and federal prisoners, also known as prison overcrowding or
Collins English Dictionary defines overcrowding as a state of being filled with more
the surplus of prisoners being held in a federal or state confinement that exceeds the desirable
number (Collins). Displayed in recent data and political testimonies, the issue of prison
overcrowding has reached an all time high. Prison overcrowding, although due to a multitude of
factors, can be traced back to unjust prison sentences, specifically, of nonviolent drug offenders;
in order to eradicate this problem, America must first decide to do something about it.
Advancement of Colored Peoples (NAACPs) 106th national convention, our criminal justice
system isnt as smart as it should be suggests the problems related to the American justice
system are so obvious, that the common citizen can tell there is something wrong (Obama 2015).
Further into President Obamas speech, he specifically addresses the issue of prison
2.2 million: The number of prisoners in the U.S. -- which has quadrupled from only
500,000 in 1980.
LIFE SENTENCE 4
25 percent: The share of the world's prisoners that are in the U.S., even though we're
60 percent: The share of U.S. prisoners that are either African American or Latino.
"About one in every 35 African American men, one in every 88 Latino men is serving
time right now," the President said. "Among white men, that number is one in 214."
$80 billion: The amount we spend each year to keep people incarcerated in America.
(Hudson, 2015)
President Barack Obama went on to note some of the things the nation could do if the money
amount being spent to keep those incarcerated was put to use in other ways (Hudson, 2015). If
the $80 billion currently being spent towards incarceration went to other uses, America could
provide universal preschool, double the salary of every high school teacher in America, finance
new roads, and eliminate tuition at every one of our public colleges and universities (Hudson,
2015).
Much like the President, many other politicians have come forward and spoken about the
massive issue of prison overcrowding. Of these include Senator Rand Paul who gave a statement
on March 9, 2015:
Though only five percent of the worlds population lives in the United States, it is home
to 25 percent of the worlds prison population. Not only does the current
overpopulated, underfunded system hurt those incarcerated, it also digs deeper into the
Despite both representing different political parties, and having a history of disagreements on
nearly every issue, the stance points of these two politicians regarding the topic of America's
As one of the final acts as President, Barack Obama granted full pardons to 78 prisoners
and reduced the sentence of 153 on December 19, 2019 (Korte, 2015). The majority of those
pardoned were people serving extremely long sentences for drug-related and primarily non-
violent offenses. This act sends a clear message that there is a problem with our current system
and action needs to be taken in addressing the sentencing for these types of offenses (Obama,
2016). Congress needs to take action to reform the system and ensure that fairness is maintained
by our criminal justice system and reverse sharp penalties that disproportionately impact
Hispanic and African American men. During his presidential term, Obama has given clemency
to a total of 1,324 people, including 395 with life sentences(Korte, 2015). Oxford Dictionary
One of the people pardoned by President Obama was Mr. Ismael Rosa, a 56-year-old who
had already served 21 years in prison towards his life sentence, he had been convicted in 1995
for conspiracy to distribute cocaine (Korte, 2015). Prior to his conviction, he was a salsa singer.
When notified by his lawyers, that he had been granted clemency by President Obama, Mr. Rosa
began crying while singing a gospel hymn (M., 2016). There are many people currently in our
overcrowded prisons, serving sentences that many would agree, do not fit the crime that was
committed (Hudson, 2015). The Justice is reportedly Urging the U.S Sentencing Commission to
approve a measure that would potentially make thousands of nonviolent drug offenders now
serving time in federal prison eligible for reduced sentences (Johnson, 2014). Eric Holder, the
In 1976, prior to the massive increase in incarceration rates, national magazines were
already reporting that prisons were dangerously overcrowded. Since that time, overcrowding has
continued to increase along with the negative effects on inmates . The term overcrowding
LIFE SENTENCE 6
when used in the context of prisons is measured by more than just the ratio of prisoners to rated
capacity; it also includes the extent to which a prison, or prison system, houses more prisoners
than its infrastructure can humanely accommodate(Haney, 2006). This overcrowding impacts
more than just the inmates and accommodations themselves, it also negatively impacts the
resources needed to address the medical, and mental health issues of inmates (Haney,2006).
they need. When there are more people than recourses, history has shown it creates high tension
rates, violence, and lower quality of life. This is further proven in documented animal behavior
on Australias Macquarie Island where the natural predator of the isolated island had been
removed leading to a major overpopulation of the rabbit (Marris 2009). Do t the immense
overpopulation of this species, it wiped most of the resources from the island and created a
shortage of goods such as food, shelter, and habitats for all of the other animal and insect species
on the isolated island (Marris 2009). The whole quality of life and basic tone of the island
seemed to change in the wake of these events. Like these overpopulated mammals, humans are
no different when it comes to a shortage of resources, when cluttered together, it can be quite
detrimental.
In 1976 a correctional task force was evaluating overcrowding in prisons and found that
double-celling, the placement of multiple prisoners into one cell, violates human decency.
According to legislative and departmental policy, the Department of Corrections does not
sanction double-celling inmates (Haney, 2006). The correctional task force believed that
double-celling inmates not only violated human decency, but also impacted other areas such as
physical and mental health and security. Although the task force had several concerns and
acknowledged that double-celling was undesirable, they were unable to find a viable alternative
LIFE SENTENCE 7
due to the current overcrowding and continued projections for an increasing inmate population.
The task force did recommend a gradual increases in the inmate population along with additional
correctional staff to alleviate the impact of overpopulation. Today the practice of double
celling is commonplace and accepted widely and many are pleased when they can limit the
number of inmates to only two per cell during periods of severe overcrowding (Haney, 2006).
Basic decency for inmates has deteriorated and the goal of humane treatment appears to have
been forgotten.
Research has found that overcrowding in prison negatively impacts health, behavior and
morale beliefs; some of the findings are particular vulnerabilities and inabilities to cope and
adapt can come to the fore in the prison setting, and . . . the behaviour patterns and attitudes that
emerge can take many forms, from deepening social and emotional withdrawal to extremes of
aggression and violence (Haney, 2006). These findings indicate that overcrowding results in
high stress levels, which lead to physical and psychological issues along with higher rates of
which can have long-term economic impacts (Western, 2010). In addition, large prisons impact
population numbers by the U.S. Census count which in turn impacts the distribution of federal
Local officials have contradicting views with academic studies regarding the impact of
prisons on stabilizing economies. These same local officials often credit prisons with being an
economic stabilizer since they bring jobs for probation and parole officers along with
administrative staff and health officials. In 2008, there were about 770,000 people working in
the corrections sector. According to the U.S. Labor Department, these numbers are expected to
LIFE SENTENCE 8
increase between 2008-2018 by 16% for parole officers and 9% for supervisors, staff and guards.
This number does not include the private contractors to the prisons and jails. Academic studies
from Washington State University suggested that tramped down growth in rural counties resulted
from prison construction. Evidence was not found to support that prison expansion stimulated
economic growth. In 2004, Iowa State University found higher poverty levels in rural towns that
acquired a state prisons. In 2007, Pennsylvania State University researchers found that prisons
did not have a significant economic effect on rural places and in persistently poor rural places
there was not enough evidence of structural economic change (Western, 2010).
Concerning current laws on prison overcrowding, there have been a multitude of court
cases brought to the United States Supreme Court over the issue. Most famous of these cases
include Plata v. Brown and Rhodes v. Chapman. In the court case Plata v. Brown, the Supreme
Court of the United States of America ruled that a court-mandated population limit was
necessary (Plata v. Brown, 2011). In this case brought on by a class action of prisoners, the
prisoners petitioned that their eighth amendment freedoms had been infringed upon. The
precedent of this case is the new population limit with which the courts enforced. Pre-dating
Plata v. Brown, one of the first ever cases involving prison overpopulation is Rhodes v.
Chapman. In this Supreme Court decision, holding prisoners in one cell or double celling was
found to be unconstitutional and breach the prisoner's Eighth Amendment right as unfair and
unusual punishment (Rhodes v. Chapman, 1986). As seen in today's legislation the Rhodes v.
Chapman has set the precedent of Americas double celling laws. Decisions decided in these
courts become the law that America practices day by day. These cases specifically, have set new
laws in regards to prison overcrowding; however, to fully understand and grasp these laws, one
must first know what a prison is and how it differs from all other forms of incarceration.
LIFE SENTENCE 9
According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS), the difference between jails and
prisons is:
Jails are locally-operated, short term facilities that hold inmates awaiting trial or
sentencing or both, and inmates sentenced to a term of less than 1 year, typically
misdemeanants. Prisons are long term facilities run by the state or the federal government
and typically hold felons and inmates with sentences of more than 1 year (BJS, 2016).
There are several different types of incarceration. Federal prisons hold prisoners convicted of
federal crimes and pre-trial detainees and are run by the U.S. Bureau of Prisons. State prisons
house prisoners who are serving time for felonies and is run by the state corrections departments.
Local jails hold pre-trial defendants and inmates serving short sentences, typically less than one
year, and are run by county or municipal facilities. There are also juvenile detention facilities,
military prisons, state mental hospitals, and police lockups, where prisoners are held.
Unsurprisingly, there are more people held in prisons than in jails. Todd D. Milton, with the
BJS, claims The number of inmates confined in county and city jails was an estimated 744,600
at midyear 2014. The numbers of prisoners held in state and federal correctional facilities was
estimated to be 1,561,500 at year end 2014. Half of males (50%) and more than half of females
(59%) in federal prison were serving time for drug offenses on September 30, 2014
(Carson,2015).
In an interview with Master Police Officer, Jim McElligott, when asked what one of the
Primary issues dealing with prison overcrowding, from the rhetoric which I have been
exposed to, has to do with mandatory sentencing guidelines and the number of inmates
who are serving time for drug related crimes. I think there are estimates that up 50 % of
LIFE SENTENCE 10
the people incarcerated in federal prisons involve crimes related to drugs. So, one can
infer from that fact, how vast the problem of drugs in the US really is. I believe recently
Obama has released hundreds of criminals from federal prisons who were serving time
Officer McElligott gave further details into his professional opinion on the topic of federal and
state prison overcrowding. Some potential remedies to the issue of prison overcrowding that he
mentioned were allow drug offenders to serve shorter sentences, give judges greater discretion
over sentencing, and make sure people aren't disproportionately punished (McElligott, 2016).
The courses of action that Officer Jim McElligott recommended suggest that many officers and
employees in the criminal justice field also believe the imprisonment and sentencing times of
Specifically, the current sentencing and laws pertaining to these nonviolent drug offences
is a large contributor to the prison overpopulation epidemic in America. When asked what he
recommended the average citizen or student at First Colonial High School could do to make a
positive impact on the economy, Officer McElligott said, I think you, as a citizen, have to
decide if you believe in the crime control model which basically supports laws and policies that
are tough on crime its main purpose being to reduce crime and create a safer community
(McElligott, 2016). Officer McElligott also mentioned a second way to support change in the
community, by supporting the liberal and progressive ideology which relaxes the laws and
policies which many people have fought for to protect the community (McElligott, 2016).
Essentially, Master Officer Jim McElligott is saying it is important to choose a side between
LIFE SENTENCE 11
Republicans and Democrats and follow through with that party's game plan in eliminating prison
overpopulation while making positive change in the Unites States criminal justice system.
Concerning the prison sentences on nonviolent drug offenders, statistics have found there
certain narcotics, the disproportion is found in the type of cocaine being used. Prisoners who
were caught and charged with the use of crack cocaine, were sentenced to a much harsher
sentence, than those who used the powder form of the brain altering drug to achieve their high.
When President Barack Obama signed the Fair Sentencing Act in 2010, it eliminated the five-
year-mandatory minimum prison sentence for the possession of crack cocaine (Cohen, 2005).
The Fair Sentencing Act also reduced the disparity in the amounts of powder cocaine and crack
cocaine required for the imposition of mandatory minimum sentences (Lee, 2010). This step
taken by President Barack Obama in signing this Act is one towards fixing the issue of prison
overcrowding by relaxing harsh sentences of nonviolent drug offenders. The original powder-
to-crack weight ratio was 100-to-1. The Fair Sentencing Act lowered the ratio to 18-to-1
(Cohen, 2005). Although this is a great thing for communities who primarily use crack cocaine in
contrast to the powdered form of the drug, and is a step in the direction of sentencing equalities,
evidence shows that there will still be a high ratio of nonviolent drug offenders being booked for
long prison sentences (Cohen, 2005). The more people entering prison, the more space is needed
to hold them. Unfortunately, many of the states with the highest amounts of prisoners lack
According to the American Legislative Exchange Council, on criminal justice reform and
prison overcrowding, the incarceration system in this country hold[s] more than 2.4 million
people in 1,719 state prisons, 102 federal prisons, 2,259 juvenile correctional facilities, 3,283
LIFE SENTENCE 12
local jails, and 79 Indian Country jails bringing America to the world's number one nation with
the most people incarcerated (ALEC, 2014). According to data charts provided by the American
Legislative Exchange Council regarding current and previous prison statistics, the total number
of people being held in either a federal or state prison in the United States of America is roughly
1,578,390. The distribution of these prisoners is spread across 1,719 state prisons and 102 federal
prisons; Of course, not all of those people stay in prison. Annually, 688,000 people are released
from state and federal prisons back into society (ALEC, 2014). No longer questioning if there
are too many people incarcerated, The Prison Policy Initiative has started to ask the question
does it really make sense to be imprisoning this many people? (ALEC, 2014). According to the
Prison Policy Initiative, the non-profit organization created to expose the broader harm of mass
criminalization, in the state of Virginia, there are currently 124,000 people behind bars under
the supervision of the criminal justice system and of those and 38,000 of them are locked up in
Virginias state prisons (Initiative, 2016). Graphs provided by the initiatives 50 Incarceration
Profiles provide information on every state in America. Of these graphs, includes a bar chart of
Virginia's history of incarceration. In the chart, the years displayed range from 1978 to 2011. At
the beginning of 1978, Virginia had a state prison population of only 9,000 prisoners. By 2010
that number had increased to a whopping near 38,000, the highest prison rate in Virginian
history. The 2011 prison population is seen to begin dropping, however only slightly (Wagner,
2011). This shows that the prison population has increased in recent years. This pattern is not
only shown in the prisons of the state of Virginia but also across the country nationwide.
Prison overcrowding has long been a problem in the California state prison systems in
particular (Hartney, 2011). As seen in the United States Supreme Court case, Plata v.Brown, the
court's order the state of California to reduce the size of their overpopulated prisons by 23% and
LIFE SENTENCE 13
are given a period of two years to complete this goal (Brown v. Plata, 2011). In order to reduce
their population size safely, the state looked at what other states, such as New York, New Jersey,
Michigan, Kansas, Mississippi, and Texas, had all done in order to achieve their own recent
droppage in percentage of incarcerated prisoners (Hartney, 2011). At the time, these states were
seeing prisoner cutbacks at levels of 20% in New York, 19% in New Jersey, 12% in Michigan
5% in Kansas, and 5% in Mississippi (Hartney, 2011). In order to achieve these cutbacks the
states mentioned above; New York, New Jersey, Michigan, Kansas, and Mississippi, all used a
multitude of different methods. Some of these methods included Allow more judicial discretion
opportunities for early parole for nonviolent offenders, use data-based risk assessment tools in
parole decisions, use data-based risk assessment tools in parole decisions, implement drug
courts, reform ineffective sentencing laws, and use resources for treatment and other programs
(Hartney, 2011). One of the ways California opted to use in reducing their state's prison
overcrowding epidemic was the release of nearly 3,000 inmates (OConnor, 2015). This action
spawned from Proposition 47 which allowed criminal offenders who commit certain non
serious and nonviolent drug and property crimes would be sentenced to reduced penalties (such
as shorter terms in jail) (Proposition 47, 2014). This action relates back to the ever growing
problem of so many nonviolent drug offenders being locked up in prisons for extended periods
of time.
As seen and debated by numerous political figures such as the President of the United
States of America, Barack Obama, democratic presidential nominee and former United States
Secretary of State, Hillary clinton, and former United States republican Representative, Ron
Paul, there is a common thread between all parties. Regarding prison overcrowding in the United
LIFE SENTENCE 14
states of America, it is easy to agree, regardless of political stances that prison overcrowding and
specifically, the incarceration rates and current prison sentencing laws pertaining to nonviolent
drug offenders in America need to be dealt with and changed for the better.
Going even further beyond the standard political standpoints and comments regarding
this issue, it is clearly shown in the United States Supreme Court Cases such as Plava v. Brown
in which the court ordered in favor of the prisoners in an act to reduce prison overcrowding
(Plata v. Brown, 2011). Even the local police officer, Jim McElligott of the City of Virginia
Beach Police Department is a proponent and advocate for the reduction of prison overpopulation
and harsh sentencing laws for nonviolent drug offenders in the American criminal justice system
(McElligott, 2016).
Looking back to the all new question that the Prison Policy Initiative has started to ask
its members and the rest of the world, does it really make sense to be imprisoning this many
people, the question challenges today's policies surrounding the United States current criminal
justice system and prison systems (ALEC, 2014). In order to solve this problem, like any other
problem, the first step is recognizing the issue. As Virginia Beach Police Officer, Jim McElligott
puts it, in order to solve the issue of prison overcrowding in America, the United States should
allow drug offenders to serve shorter sentences, give judges greater discretion over sentencing,
References
Hudson, D. (2015, July 15). President Obama: "Our Criminal Justice System Isn't as Smart as It
obama-our-criminal-justice-system-isnt-smart-it-should-be
Sens. Paul and Booker Re-introduce the REDEEM Act | U.S. Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky.
paul-and-booker-re-introduce-the-redeem-act
Does the United States really have 5 percent of the worlds population and one quarter of the
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2015/04/30/does-the-united-
LIFE SENTENCE 16
states-really-have-five-percent-of-worlds-population-and-one-quarter-of-the-worlds-
prisoners/?utm_term=.7b2d192d978b
Releasing the Elderly Inmate: A Solution to Prison Overcrowding Note 4 Elder Law Journal
http://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals
%2Felder4&div=10&id=&page=
Brooks, D. (2015, September 28). The Prison Problem. Retrieved December 22, 2016, from
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/29/opinion/david-brooks-the-prison-problem.html?
https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/overcrowding
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/08/07/rand-paul-democrats-enemy-1.html
The Effect of Prison Population Size on Crime Rates: Evidence From Prison Overcrowding
prison-overcrowding-315640
Jackson, D., & Korte, G. (2015, July 13). Obama's clemency grant largest since the 1960s.
men-and-women-facebook/30086127/
LIFE SENTENCE 17
https://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=173851
http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2FBF00728593?LI=true
Abuse in America's Prisons 22 Washington University Journal of Law & Policy 2006.
%2Fwajlp22&div=24&id=&page=
Prison overcrowding is a growing concern in the U.S. (n.d.). Retrieved December 22, 2016, from
http://online.ccj.pdx.edu/news-resources/articles/prison-overcrowding-is-a-growing-
concern-in-the-u-s.html
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/29/opinion/david-brooks-the-prison-problem.html?_r=0
of Harmful Effects 35 Hastings Law Journal 1983-1984. Retrieved December 22, 2016,
from http://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals
%2Fhastlj35&div=19&id=&page=
Fryklund, I. (n.d.). The Link Between Drugs And Violence. Retrieved December 22, 2016, from
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/inge-fryklund/the-link-between-drugs-
an_b_11095430.html
LIFE SENTENCE 18
Hernandez, J. (n.d.). You Serve Your Time, Earn Your Freedom, Then the Job Market Shuts the
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jason-hernandez/reentry-week-ban-the-
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/chandra-bozelko/he-needed-more-time_b_8334566.html
Liebelson, D. (n.d.). Obama Frees Dozens Of Nonviolent Federal Inmates. Retrieved December
freed_n_7786126.html
Nadelmann, E. (n.d.). Time to Make America Average When It Comes to Incarceration Rates.
nadelmann/mass-incarceration-drug-war_b_5249319.html
McElligott, J. (2016, October 15). Senior Project Paper on Prison Overcrowding [E-mail
interview].
Derek Gilna. (May, 2014). page 48 Filed under: Statistics/Trends, Overcrowding. Location:.
https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2014/may/19/report-increase-federal-prison-
population-overcrowding/
M. (2016, March 30). Obama Commutes Sentences for 61 Convicted of Drug Crimes. Retrieved
commutes-sentences-for-61-convicted-of-drug-crimes.html
Western, B. (2010). Incarceration & social inequality. Retrieved December 22, 2016, from
https://www.amacad.org/content/publications/pubContent.aspx?d=808
LIFE SENTENCE 19
Miles, K. (n.d.). Just How Much The War On Drugs Impacts Our Overcrowded Prisons, In
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/03/10/war-on-drugs-prisons-
infographic_n_4914884.html
Cohen (2005). Crack vs. Powder Cocaine: Disproportionate Penalties - Discover the Networks.
http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/viewSubCategory.asp?id=1632
http://www.lao.ca.gov/ballot/2014/prop-47-110414.aspx
Lee, J. (2010, August 03). President Obama Signs the Fair Sentencing Act. Retrieved December
https://www.prisonpolicy.org/about.html