v......

HOW TO USE
FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
A Guide to Understanding
LIBRARIES the Numbers
IPPiiMCOTftlBRARY
 About the Author ...
James Bandler is president and chief executive officer of
Joseph Bandler Corporation, a private investment management
HOW TO USE
FINANCIAL
company. Previously, he was executive vice president and
senior credit officer for City National Bank in Beverly Hills,
California. He received his MBA from Harvard University, his
BA With Distinction from Stanford University, and is a former
member of Robert Morris Associates Professional Bankers* STATEMENT^
Association. Mr. Bandler's investment opinions and research
have been published in The Wall Street Transcript and The
Wall Street Journal.
A Guide to Understanding
the Numbers
James Bandler
IRWIN
Professional Publishing
Burr Ridge, Illinois
New York, New ^
7
(^1/5:2/B28T
 Dedicated to
Scott and Laura
My thanks to Rocky Higgins for making this book possible
and for his guidance throughout its composition. Thanks also
to Steve Brown for his graphics and illustrations as well as his
RICHARD D. IRWIN, INC., 1994
suggestions. Above all. thanks to my wife. Dianne, for putting
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a up with the eccentricities of one who aspires to write.
retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic,
mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written
permission of the publisher.
This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in
regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold with the understanding that
neither the author nor the publisher is engaged in rendering legal, accounting,
or other professional service. If legal advice or other expert assistance is
required, the services of a competent professional person should be sought.
From a Declaration of Principles jointly adopted by a Committee of the
American Bar Association and a Committee of Publishers.
Editor-in-chief: Jeffrey A. Krames
Project editor: Waivah Clement
Production manager: Jon Christopher
Interior designer: Mercedes Santos
Cover designer: Tim Kaage
Art manager: Kim Meriwether
Compositor: TCSystems, Inc.
Typeface: 11/13 Times Roman
Printer: R.R. Donnelley and Sons Company
Library of Congress Catalogtng-in-Publication Data
Bandler, James.
How to use financial statements: a guide to understanding the
numbers/James Bandler.
p. cm.
Includes index.
ISBN 0-7863-0197-X
1. Financial statements. I. Title.
HF5681.B2B285 1994
657'.3dc20
Printed in the United States of America
34567890 DOC I 0 9 8 7
 Preface
Clearly you are neither a certified public accountant nor a
securities analyst. Otherwise you would have picked up a
much heavier book with lots of esoteric formulas and equa
tions. More likely you have recently decided that you would
like to learn what you really need to know about how to read
a financial statement without investing several months of
your time and getting so confused and frustrated that you
give it up. That's good, because it means that this book can
help you.
You're already a step ahead of the pack. Most people who
need to understand financial statements don't even realize
it. Maybe you just got a job or a promotion into a job in
which it would be advantageous to have some familiarity
with financial statements. Maybe you have accumulated
enough savings to begin looking at investment alternatives,
or maybe you have suffered the loss of that member of the
family who has always dealt with financial matters.
Needs such as these are common and fairly obvious, but
what about those of you who have jobs in completely nonii-
nancial areas and no interest in investments? The first com
pany whose financial statements you need to understand
may well be your own. Will it still be around in five years?
Will substantial cuts in its work force be required for it to
survive? Will you still have a job? How safe are your medi
cal and retirement benefits?
In recent times, we have seen too many instances of
people losing things they had taken for granted: job security,
benefits.assumed to be guaranteed, even opportunity. And
the same questions you would ask about your own com
pany, you need to ask about any other company that you
viii
Preface
might consider as a prospective employer. Yes, you need to
Contents
know about financial statements, but you also need instruc
tion that is quick and easy to follow.
For most of us, life is already far more complicated than it Chapter One
needs to be. We are asked to read and understand insurance WHAT ARE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
policies and income tax returns, which were most certainly AND WHAT DO THEY TELL US? 1
devised by people whose sole purpose is to confuse us.
When is the last time you bought a new issue of a stock or Chapter Two
bond and actually read the prospectus? You're lucky if you WHO USES FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
even get the thing until well after you've made the purchase. AND WHAT DO THEY LOOK FOR? 8
If you're thinking of reading the owner's manual for that Owners, 9
new computer you just bought, forget it. Find someone who
Lenders, 10
already knows how to work it. Most people, in fact, don't
Managers, 11
know how to program their VCRs. Too many features and
too many things can go wrong. Maybe you can time record Suppliers, 11
the program you want and actually get it right 50 percent of Customers, 12
the time. That's pretty good. Attorneys and Litigants, 12
In times like these, we need to focus on eliminating Employees and Job Seekers, 13
unnecessary complication from our lives. Too much of our
instructional literature takes things that ought to be easy to Chapter Three
understand and makes them more complicated. Or it takes AN INTRODUCTION TO THE
things that are complicated and explains them in compli ACCRUAL CONCEPT 14
cated ways. In either case, we are more confused than we
Cash Basis Financial Statements, 15
ought to be.
The Trouble with Cash Basis Accounting, 17
The purpose of this book is to take a subject that can seem
very complicated and make it simple. This sounds like her Accrual Accounting to the Rescue, 17
esy in this day and age, but it is my mission. Accrual Accounting and Depreciation, 19
Accrual Accounting and Cost of Goods Sold, 20
James Bandler
Chapter Four
THE STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL
POSITION OR BALANCE SHEET 22
Why We Have Balance Sheets and Why They
Balance, 23
Current Assets, 25
Noncurrent Assets, 30
 Contents Contents
Current Liabilities, 31 Sale of the Inventory, 58
Long-Term Debt, 32 Collection of Account Receivable, 60
Owners' Equity, 32
Chapter Eight
Leverage, 33
SPECIAL INVENTORY VALUATION AND
DEPRECIATION REPORTING ISSUES 61
Chapter Five
Inventory Valuation Alternatives, 62
THE PROFIT AND LOSS
Relative Merits of FIFO, LIFO, and Average
OR INCOME STATEMENT 34 Cost, 64
Revenues, 35 Depreciation Issues, 66
Costs of Goods Sold, 35
Gross Profits, 36 Chapter Nine
INTANGIBLE ASSETS
Operating Expenses, 36
AND AMORTIZATION 72
Provision for Income Taxes, 37
Net Income, 37 Amortization, 72
Intangible Assets, 72
The Income Statement's Impact on the Balance
Sheet, 37 Goodwill, 72
Statement of Changes in Shareholders' Equity, 41 Amortization of Motion Picture Film Costs, 74
Insurance Companies and Policy Acquisition
Costs, 77
Chapter Six
THE STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS 42
Chapter Ten
Conceptual Basis for Determining Cash Flow, 43 SERVICE COMPANIES 79
Calculating Cash Flow, 45
Financial Services Companies, 83
Alternative Format for Statement of Cash
Capital-Intensive Service Companies, 84
Flows, 52
People-Intensive Service Companies, 85
Using the Statement of Cash Flows, 54
Chapter Eleven
Chapter Seven WHAT ARE THE RULES THAT
FOLLOWING A TRANSACTION PREPARERS OF FINANCIAL
THROUGH THE STATEMENTS MUST PLAY BY? 87
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 56 GAAPandGAAS, 87
The Inventory Purchase, 56 Disclosures, 89
Payment for the Inventory, 58 Opinion Letters, 95
xii Contents
Chapter Twelve
Chapter One
SOME BASIC TOOLS
OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS 101
What Do We Need to Know? 101
What Are Financial
How Financial Ratios Can Help, 101
Some Useful Ratios and What They Tell Us, 105
Statements and What
Chapter Thirteen
Do They Tell Us?
APPLICATION OF FINANCIAL RATIOS
TO ANALYSIS OF THE GROWTH OF THE
EASY COMPANY 111
Strategy and Analysis, 115
Profitability and Asset Management, 116 It has been said that an accountant is one who knows the
Defensive versus Opportunistic price of everything and the value of nothing. It has also
Diversification, 119 been said that an expert is one who knows more and more
about less and less. You should therefore be thankful that
Chapter Fourteen it is not my intention to turn you into an expert accountant.
THE LIMITATIONS OF FINANCIAL It is sufficient that you come to understand the financial
STATEMENTS 121 statements that the accountants spew forth.
Appendix: 125 Financial statements are the universally accepted tool for
analysis of a business entity. Properly understood, they let
Glossary of Terms 135
us know how good a company looks and how well it has
Index 143 been doing. The financial statements of a business consist
of three separate but interrelated reports:
1. The Statement of Financial Position or Balance
Sheet.
2. The Profit and Loss or Income Statement.
3. The Statement of Cash Flows.
A complete set of financial statements for The Easy Com
pany, a manufacturer of user-friendly toothpicks, is pre
sented in Exhibit 1-1. Take a moment to look them over
because we will refer to them throughout this book.
The purpose of financial statements is to provide the user
with a set of data that, in summary form, fairly represents
 Chapter I/What Are Financial Statements and What Do They Tell Us? Chapter I/What Are Financial Statements and What Do They Tell Us?
EXHIBIT 1-1 EXHIBIT 1-1 {concluded)
THE EASY COMPANY Interest expense 200
Statement of Financial Position Income before taxes 1,000
(December 31)
Income tax expense 400
1991 1992 Changes Net profit 600
Current Assets:
Cash $2,000 $ 900 (1,100) Statement of Cash Flows
Marketable securities 1,000 1,000
Cash flow from operations:
Accounts receivable 2,000 2,500 500
Net profit 600
Inventory 2,000 2,300 300
Depreciation 200
Prepaid expenses 100 100
800
Total current assets 7,100 6,800
Changes to operating assets and liabilities:
Investment in Affiliated Co 5,000 200 200
Accounts receivable
Property, plant, and equip
Inventory
ment
Accounts payable
Cost 6,000
Accrued expenses
Accumulated depreciation 3,000 2,000 3,200 2,800 800
Net cash provided by operations
Other assets 200 200
Cash flows from investing activities:
Total assets 9,500 10,000
Additions to property, plant, and equipment
Accounts payable 300 500 200
Net cash from financing activities:
Accrued expenses 1,300 1,200 ( 100) Repayment of long-term debt
Current portion long-term 200 200
Net cash provided (used) $(1,100)
debt
Total current liabilities 1,800 1,900
Long-term debt 2,000 1,800 ( 200)
Owners' equity:
Capital stock 2,000 2,000
Retained earnings 3,700 5,700 4,300 6,300 600
the financial strength and performance of a business. Pre
Total Liabilities and
owners' equity $9,500 $10,000
pared and used properly, they reveal opportunities and pro
vide protection against financial pitfalls. The continuing pro
cess of developing and compiling the numbers to be used
Statement of Profit and Loss
in the financial presentation is called accounting. Frustrated
For the Year Ended December 31,1992
students of accounting have called it many other things,
Net sales $ $10,000
Cost of goods sold 7,000
but most of them are unprintable in a snooty book such as
Gross profit 3,000 this one.
Operating expenses: The Balance Sheet provides a snapshot of a company's
Selling, general, and administrative 1,600 financial strength as of a given point in time. It lists the
Depreciation 200 1.800
Profit from operations 1,200
 4 Chapter I/What Are Financial Statements and What Do They Tell Us? Chapter I/What Are Financial Statements and What Do They Tell Us?
company's assets and the portions of these assets financed EXHIBIT 1-2
by liabilities and owners' equity. The dollar amounts of the The Interrelationship between the Balance Sheet and income
various accounts in these categories are influenced by how Statement (The Easy Company)
efficiently the company manages them, how it finances its 1992 Sales December 31,1992
operations, and how profitable it is.
Accounts
The Income Statement shows how profitable the company Cash
Payable
December 31,1991
was over a specified period of time. It shows the company's
Accounts Payable
revenues, costs of doing business, and net profits. Accrued
The Statement of Cash Flows tells us how much cash the Accrued
C Expenses
o Marketable
company generated over the period covered by the Income Cash
Expenses
s Securities
Statement and where it went, which is usually quite different t C.P.L.T.D.*
from the amount of income (profit). (See Exhibit 1-2.) The C.P.L.T.D.*
o
f
various causes of these differences and the ways we measure Long-Term
the dollar impact of each of them will be discussed in Chap Marketable G Accounts Liabilities
Long-Term o Receivable
ters Three through Six. Exhibits 1-2 and 1-3 illustrate the Securities
Liabilities 0
relationship between the three principal reports in the fi d
s
nancial statements.
S.
Otherwise sane people often argue about which of the Accounts o
Receivable
three reports is the most important. Those addicted to the 1
O
d
Balance Sheet say that it shows where the company stands Inventory
w
n
after giving effect to everything that has happened in the e
O
Income Statement and Cash Flow Statement to date. To r
w s'
them, the Balance Sheet represents the true value of the Inventory
n
company.
e E
r
q
Fans of the Income Statement sneer at these contentions s' u
i
and regard the Balance Sheet crowd as out of touch. "Hey, E Operating t
you go into business to make money, don't you? The Income q
u
Expenses Property, y
Plant, and
Statement tells you how much you're making, so who needs i
t
Equipment
Property,
a Balance Sheet? Take that stuff and get out of here." Plant, and y
Interest and
The cash flow folks see themselves as the truly progres Equipment
Taxes
sive force in an otherwise Neanderthal system of financial
reporting. They believe that "cash is king." Know where 1992 i 1992 I
Other Net Profit Other \ Net Profit
cash comes from and where it goes, and you know all that's Assets Assets r, '
important about the business.
The cash crowd generally supports liberal causes and L 1992 Net Profit becomes
part of Owners Equity
j
tends to be a trifle elitist. "What you want from your busi-
"Current Portion of Long-Term Debt.
 6 Chapter I/What Are Financial Statements and What Do They Tell Us? Chapter I/What Are Financial Statements and What Do They Tell Us? 7
EXHIBIT 1-3 In addition to the three principal financial reports, most
Relationship between Balance Sheet, Income Statement, and financial statements include a Statement of Changes in Own
Cash Flow Statement (The Easy Company) ers' or Shareholders' Equity, which shows increases to the
value of ownership through income or ownership interests
Balance Sheet sold by the company and decreases caused by things like
Balance Sheet .
as of as of operating losses and dividends paid to shareholders. This
December 31,1991 December 31,1992
report will receive far less emphasis here, as it is fairly
straightforward at the level of sophistication we seek to
achieve.
Income Statement from January 1,1992, to December 31,1992 -
Cash Flow Statement from January 1,1992, to December 31,1992-
Financial Statement Reports:
TJte Balance Sheet states thefinancial condition of the Easy Company at a point in time.
This point happens to be each Neiv Year's Eve, December 31st.
The last day of the calendar year is the close of Easy Company's accounting period.
Other companies may choose different accounting year-ends far various business
purposes.
The Income Statement measures the profitability of the Easy Company over a period of
time. Tliis period of time begins on January 1st and ends on December 31st ofeach
accounting year.
The Cash Flow Statement explains cash generated and spent by the Easy Company
over this same period.
ness after all is said and done is cash. What good are profits
if you can't get any cash out of them? You got a problem
with that?"
In fact, each of these financial reports tells a part of a
story. Viewed together, they give the reader a complete
financial picture of the company. As you increase your un
derstanding of their interrelationship and interdependence,
you will become one of the truly enlightened and come to
scoff at those radical elements who advocate one report
over another.
 Owners *
Chapter Two EXHIBIT 2-1
Who Uses Financial Statements and What Do They Look For?
Who Uses Financial Can they pay
Statements and What Is there enough
money to pay
me on time?

me back?
Do They Look For?
Can the company
afford to pay me
more?
Am I getting a
return on my
investment?
Current employees
Conventional wisdom has it that only econonerds, masoch- Managers
ists, and the terminally boring read financial statements.
Not so. Rational and exciting people like you and me
Does this company
not only read them but also find them both interesting and have a future?
useful.
Will they be
The principal users of financial statements are proba in business
bly lenders and investors, but other users of financial state tomorrow?
Is the company
ments include owners and managers, customers, suppliers, worth suing?
Am I running the
and even plaintiffs in lawsuits and their attorneys (see company efficiently?
Exhibit 2-1). Each of these groups includes potential as
well as actual participants. (How do you know whether
you want to become a lender or investor until you look at
the financial statements? Why sue someone who can't
pay?) OWNERS
All of these groups are probably interested in all of the
financial statements, but some tend to place different empha There is a fairly clear distinction between certain interests
sis on the various components. Even within a given user of lenders to a company and those of owners of a company.
category, individuals differ with respect to where they place (Investors in a company are owners, even though their own
the most emphasis. The following are therefore somewhat ership interests may be very small.) Owners are primarily
generalized characterizations that do not apply in every interested in profitability, as that is what will ultimately add
case. value to their investments. Balance sheet strength and cash
 10 Chapter 2/Who Uses Financial Statements and What Do They Look For? Suppliers 11
flow are usually important only insofar as they are needed to meet its obligations. Ultimately, however, cash flow is what
support the continuation of the profit-generating activities. really repays debt.
An exception to this rule is a company being viewed in Lenders therefore tend to be more interested in the bal
a liquidation scenario, which is to say that the assets are to ance sheet and the statement of cash flow than they are in
be sold, the debts paid, and operations terminated. In this the income statement unless the income statement is so poor
case, the amount by which the value of the assets exceeds that it is obvious that it will soon affect each of the other
the liabilities is the critical factor, since the difference, the statements. Profits beyond a certain point become irrelevant
equity, is what is available to the owner/investor. The bal to lenders, unlike investors. Lenders don't get paid any
ance sheet therefore takes precedence over the other finan more if a company is immensely profitable than they do if
cial reports.
it is sufficiently profitable. Investor/owners, on the other
Another exception might exist in a situation where a com hand, gain from every incremental increase in profitsat
pany is being considered for acquisition by another company least theoretically.
or by large investors. The balance sheet could assume
greater importance as a means of determining liquidation
value or the value of assets to be acquired.
MANAGERS
There are also some kinds of companies for which cash
flow may be seen as a better indicator of operating perfor Managers, who are often also owners, need financial state
mance than profits due to unusually large noncash charges ments to assess the performance and strength of their busi
against profits resulting more from accounting conventions nesses. Is performance as good as they think it is, or are
than from performance issues. It is often debatable, how skyrocketing sales only generating increasing losses as costs
ever, as to where to draw the line in accepting cash flow balloon out of control and inefficiencies abound? If there
instead of profits, as we shall see. are problems, how can the financial statements be used to
None of this is to suggest that investors disregard or identify them so that they can be corrected? We will explore
should disregard balance sheets or cash flow. It is just that these subjects in some detail in Chapter Twelve.
their primary emphasis tends to be on profits, both actual
and expected. They are therefore most interested in the
income statement.
SUPPLIERS
Suppliers generally sell to their customers on terms that
LENDERS permit payment at a later date. They therefore need to be
concerned with the customer's ability to make these pay
How do lenders feel about profits? They like profits too. In ments when due, just as a lender needs to be concerned
most cases losses will make it more difficult for them to be about repayment of his debt. Both lenders and suppliers
repaid. On the other hand, a company with a very strong may therefore be called creditors of a company, and their
balance sheet can withstand small to moderate losses for a relative interests in the components of the financial state
period of time without substantially impairing its ability to ments tend to be similar.
U Chapter 2/Who Uses Financial Statements and What Do They Look For?
Employees and Job Seekers 13
Suppliers, however, may place even less emphasis on confined to the balance sheet. When in doubt, the lawyers
profit and loss since their credit tends to be very short will go after everyone in sight and hope for the best.
term. They can also generally retrieve the goods shipped if
payment is not made, and they earn far greater profits from
the sale of products than lenders do from financing their
EMPLOYEES AND JOB SEEKERS
purchase. In other words, suppliers have a greater interest
in doing the transaction and less risk of loss on it. Suppliers The importance of understanding the financial condition and
are therefore probably slightly less dependent on financial performance of an employer or potential employer has be
statements in general than are investors and lenders but are come far more critical in recent years than ever before.
nevertheless among their principal users. Whether your company is likely to grow or to shrink in
size has important implications for your opportunities for
advancement and, indeed, for the security of your job. More
CUSTOMERS to the point, it is becoming increasingly evident that many
companies that have thrived in the past will not even be
The customers of a company may not at first glance appear able to continue to be in business in the years to come.
to be as likely to be interested in the financial statements Retirement benefits, such as pensions and postretirement
of a firm from which they buy, but, if that company is a medical benefits, are only as assured as the company's abil
key supplier of a vital product or service, the customer needs ity to provide for them.-The future costs of these benefits,
to know that its supplier is of sufficient financial strength to which may or may not be fully funded today, will probably
remain in business. A company should not, for example, require continued contributions from the company's income
contract for its data processing services with another com
and cash. An employee needs to know whether the company
pany that is not likely to survive for more than a few months. at which he works or seeks to work can provide the job and
In many instances, customers will therefore at least glance retirement security he deserves for his years of effort.
at balance sheets and income statements and in some cases
Clearly there may be other users of financial statements
do a more in-depth analysis of the complete financials.
in addition to the ones named above. Government agencies,
for example, may be keenly interested in the structure and
profitability of a business for purposes of taxation, antitrust
ATTORNEYS AND LITIGANTS implications, or simply negotiating terms of government
contracts. The foregoing examples alone, however, suggest
Finally, litigants and their attorneys should have a keen
a very wide range of usage.
interest in the ability of their target defendant to pay before
they commit to the time and expense of litigation. Generally,
financial substance will help determine who will be named
in a lawsuit. Except in rare cases, financial analysis for
this purpose will be fairly superficial and perhaps largely
 Cash Basis Financial Statements 15
Chapter Three CASH BASIS FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
An Introduction to the
John Smith earns $50,000 per year and spends $45,000 of
it. (In this example, we will not worry about how he spends
it.) He owns a home worth $150,000, against which he owes
Accrual Concept a $100,000 mortgage to the bank. He has $10,000 in the
bank and no other debts. John's financial statement appears
below:
Balance Sheet
Assets:
Before we discuss financial statements in detail, it should be Cash in bank $ 10,000
helpful to introduce briefly the concept of accrual accounting Personal residence 150,000
and reporting upon which proper financial statements are Total assets $160,000
based. It is essential to the accrual concept to understand Liabilities and equity:
Mortgage on personal residence $100,000
the distinctions between recognizing revenue for financial
Total liabilities 100,000
reporting and receiving cash and between incurring an ex Equity 60,000
pense and the payment of cash. Total liabilities and equity $160,000
Simply stated, revenue can be recognized when sales are
consummated or services provided that create an obligation Income Statement
on the part of the customer to make payment for the sales Total revenue $50,000
or services. That is when the revenue is deemed to have Expenses 45,000
been earned. Net income $ 5.000
Similarly, expenses are incurred as assets are used to
Statement of Cash Flow
produce revenue or when the benefit of services received
creates an obligation to make payment. Thus, accrual ac Cash flow from net income $5,000
counting attempts to match expenses with the revenues
they generate regardless of when cash is actually paid or
received. In practice, there are numerous accounting Note that John's cash flow is simply his income. That is
guidelines that define when these obligations are cre because, like most individuals, he reports his income on a
ated and expenses incurred for different types of transac cash basis, which means that he only reports as revenue
tions. that which is received in cash during the reporting period
Accountants love accrual accounting. It's fairly compli and as expenses that which is paid in cash.
cated and, to them, just a heck of a lot of fun. Suppose John completed a $10,000 consulting job in De
Now let's take a look at a financial statement in its sim cember but hadn't been paid by year-end. John's cash basis
plest and, to most people, its most familiar form. accounts rightfully exclude this income. But if John's goal
 Accrual Accounting to the Rescue 17
16 Chapter 3/An Introduction to the Accrual Concept
is to assess what kind of year he had, might it not be reason THE TROUBLE WITH CASH
able to include the $10,000 earned but not yet received? BASIS ACCOUNTING
Indeed it would, and this is where accrual accounting
The problem with cash accounting is that revenue may be
comes in.
earned and cash payments made for all expenses needed to
Let's also assume that John has a $700 mortgage payment
generate that revenue well before the revenue is received
which was due in the last month of the year but which John
in cash. As in the case of John Smith's consulting fees,
was unable to pay until a few weeks into the following year.
not recognizing revenue when it is earned distorts the true
John's accrual basis net income would then become $14,300,
operating performance of the company.
consisting of the $5,000 in net cash received plus the $10,000
Similarly, on a cash basis, expenses could easily be dis
consulting fee earned but not received less the $700 expense
torted by the timing of cash payments for products pur
that was not paid when due. His net cash flow, however,
chased or services received. We have seen the obvious
would be unaffected since cash for the consulting job was
example where cash basis income is increased by simply
not received and the cash payment for the mortgage was
delaying the payment of bills.
not made during the accounting period. His statement of
cash flows might then appear as follows:
Cash flow from net income $14,300
ACCRUAL ACCOUNTING TO
Cash flow from increase in consulting fee receivable (10,000)
THE RESCUE
Cash flow from mortgage expense due but not paid
during period 700 Accrual accounting focuses on the economic substance of
Net cash flow
$ 5,000 the event instead ofjust the movement of cash. It recognizes
that revenue may be earned before or after cash is received
and that revenue should be reported when it is earned, not
As demonstrated above, one source of cash is not paying when cash is received. Accrual accounting also means that
expenses are incurred and recorded at the time supplies and
your bills. We will explore this and other aspects of cash
flow in Chapter Six. materials are shipped or consumed or the benefit of services
is received by a company, whether or not cash payment is
At first glance, cash accounting makes sense. It seems
made at that time.
both logical and simple. Revenue, which may be defined as
Under accrual accounting, purchases generally become
funds earned from the sale of product or performance of
expenses at the time the materials are used or consumed in
services, is measured by the amount of cash received for
the process of generating revenue. This matching of ex
these products and services. Similarly, expenses are mea
sured by the amount of cash paid. penses with the revenue they generate is, in fact, a funda
mental principle of accrual accounting.
Between the time of purchase and the recording of an
Revenue = Cash received expense, the materials acquired are added to inventory. An
Expense = Cash paid exception to this matching practice occurs when there is no
18 Chapter 3/An Introduction to the Accrual Concept Accrual Accounting and Depreciation 19
precise connection between use of the materials and the Pin Company, which must record half of the six months of
revenues generated. interest as accrued interest expense. Another would be rent
For plant and equipment, which generate revenues over that is payable monthly at the end of each month. Halfway
a period of years, the cost of their purchase is recognized through the month, the tenant has received the benefit of
over their productive (i.e., revenue-generating) life. The occupancy for half the period. He can't move out to avoid
cost of plant and equipment is therefore recorded as an paying it. He has therefore incurred an obligation for pay
asset, the value of which is gradually reduced by expense ment even though he has received no bill or invoice. If he
charges, called depreciation, over its useful life. were to prepare financial statements at this time, which is
All of this means that, when Company A ships recre unlikely, he would have to record this amount as an accrued
ational explosives to Company B, it sends an invoice, which expense both for income and expense reporting as well as
serves to record or recognize the transaction on the books for reporting the obligation to pay as a liability on his balance
of both companies. Company A records a sale (income state sheet. (If payment is made on or before the end of the
ment) and an account receivable (balance sheet), and Com month, cash will be reduced and no obligation to pay this
pany B records a purchase (income statement or balance amount will appear on the month-end statement.)
sheet increase to inventory) and an account payable (balance
sheet), even though payment may not be due for 30 days
or more. Payments of these amounts will reduce the receiv ACCRUAL ACCOUNTING
ables and increase the cash of Company A while reducing AND DEPRECIATION
the payables and reducing the cash of Company B. These
balance sheet changes have no effect on income and ex Accrual accounting requires not only that revenues be rec
penses, which are reported at the time of shipment or use ognized in the period in which they are earned but also that
of the explosives. expenses be allocated to the periods in which the revenue
Revenue and expenses are also accrued and reported for attributable to them is recognized. Examples of this process,
amounts that are earned even though no invoice is sent and which is called the matching of revenues and expenses, can
no accounts receivable or payable are set up. How can this be found in the purchase and use of property, plant, and
be so? On the income side, a common example might be a equipment. These assets may be purchased for cash or some
company that owns the bonds of the Proprietary Pin Com combination of cash and debt in the current reporting period,
pany, which pay interest every six months. Even though but they will be used in production, administration, market
the interest is not paid until the end of the six months, it is ing, and distribution for years to come. Since these assets
earned continuously over the six-month period. At the end will generate revenues and income in future periods, their
of three months, the owner or holder of the bonds should costs are matched against the revenues they generate over
show half of the six-month interest payment as income. these periods by means of charges called depreciation.
Since none of this has been received in cash, the amount Depreciation is the process by which the cost of an income
will be recorded as accrued interest receivable. producing asset is expensed over the useful life of the asset
One example of an accrued expense would, of course, instead of at the time of purchase of the asset. Charging it
be this same transaction on the books of the Proprietary as an expense at the time of the purchase would result in
20 Chapter 3/An Introduction to the Accrual Concept Accrual Accounting and Cost of Goods Sold 21
a tremendous distortion of income, since little of the revenue at the beginning of the period as well as inventory produced
the asset is expected to produce will be generated in the during the period constitute the cost of inventory available
period of the purchase. for sale. The cost of inventory on hand at the end of the
At the end of each period, the amount of depreciation period is deducted from this total to yield the cost of goods
expense is recorded and added to an accumulated deprecia actually sold during the period.
tion account, the balance of which represents the total of We will discuss these concepts in more detail in Chapters
all periodic depreciation charged against assets still owned Four through Six. It will suffice for now if you understand
and in use. This total appears as a reduction to the original that under cash accounting revenues, expenses, assets, and
purchase price of the asset in arriving at its present book equity are recorded when payments are made in cash, and
value. The book value is the value on the company's under accrual accounting they are recorded when they are
"books," or financial statements, and is based on its histori earned or incurred, regardless of when actual cash payment
cal cost, not its current market value: is made.
If you made it through this chapter with only a mild
Example headache, you're off to a good start.
Beginning Asset Accumulated Ending Asset
Period Book Value Depreciation Depreciation Book Value
1 10,000 1,000 1,000 9,000
2 9,000 1,000 2,000 8,000
3 8,000 1,000 3,000 7,000
4 7,000 1,000 4,000 6,000
5 6,000 1,000 5,000 5,000
Note that the original beginning asset book value less the
accumulated depreciation at the end of any period always
equals the ending asset book value for that period.
ACCRUAL ACCOUNTING AND COST OF
GOODS SOLD
Another important characteristic of accrual accounting and
the matching concept is that the purchase and production
costs of inventory are charged as costs of the period in
which the inventory is sold, which is not necessarily when
it is purchased or produced. All costs of inventory on hand
 Why We Have Balance Sheets and Why They Balance 23
Chapter Four Next we decide to lease a store site, but we need to
purchase $40,000 in furnishings, fixtures, and equipment to
The Statement of operate the store. Since we also know that we will need
about $20,000 in beginning inventory and some cash to meet
Financial Position or operating needs, we choose to borrow $20,000 of the $40,000
and pay the balance in cash. Our Balance Sheet is now:
Balance Sheet Cash $30,000 Bank loan $20,000
Property and equipment 40,000 Owners' equity 50,000
$70,000 $70,000
Now we buy the inventory for $20,000 in cash:
The Statement of Financial Position, more commonly re
ferred to as the Balance Sheet, lists and totals the assets,
Cash $10 ,000
liabilities, and owners' equity of a company as of the end $20 ,000
Inventory 20 ,000 Bank loan
of an operating period. The owners' equity is the estimated Property and equipment 40 ,000 Owners' equity 50 ,000
value of the company's assets after deducting all liabilities $70,000 $70,000
or, in other words, the accounting estimate of the value of
the owners' interest in the company after the creditors are
all allotted their share of its assets. The operating period In this simplified illustration, we have ignored the classi
may be one month, three months, a multiple of three months, fication of assets and liabilities into current and noncurrent
or one year.
as well as how owners' equity is increased and decreased
For example, let's assume that we have $50,000 with through profits and losses, all of which is coming up shortly.
which to start a business and that we do so by depositing We have just shown how the business has been started with
these funds in a bank account as our capital contribution. about 28.6 percent of our assets financed by means of debt
Our beginning Balance Sheet would appear as follows: and 71.4 percent by our own capital contribution, all the
while keeping the Balance Sheet in balance.
Cash 50,000 Owners' equity 50,000
WHY WE HAVE BALANCE SHEETS AND
In this instance, all of the owners* equity consists of WHY THEY BALANCE
contributed capital, which is normally only one component
of owners' equity. Once the company has had time to gener Most users of financial statements want to know things like
ate profits and losses, these amounts will be reflected what a business is worth and whether its financial condition
through the retained earnings section of owners' equity. is strong enough to withstand adversity and support its
I)
 24 Chapter 4/The Statement of Financial Position or Balance Sheet
Current Assets 25
growth. That is what the Balance Sheet is supposed to do
EXHIBIT 4-1
best, although, as we shall see in subsequent chapters, how
Balancing the Books
well it actually performs this function is subject to the accu
racy of certain estimates that are a necessary evil in financial
reporting.
Since assets are really what we need to run a business,
why do we need liabilities and owners' equity? The problem
is that we have to get the assets somehow. They must either
be purchased with funds on hand (another asset), exchanged
for other assets, or purchased with the proceeds of debt, a
liability. The only way to get cash or other assets with which
to acquire the asset we need is to have the cash contributed
in the form of capital, generated through the profits of the
company or, once again, borrowed in the form of liabilities.
Since contributed capital and retained earnings are both a
part of owners* equity, we need to have liabilities and own
ers' equity in a combined amount equal to the cost of any
assets we own.
The relationship between the three broad categories of
the Balance Sheet may be summarized as follows:
Assets - Liabilities = Owners' equity (or net worth)
Similarly, by reshuffling our equation, we can see that:
Why are total assets always equal to total liabilities plus
Assets = Liabilities + Owners' equity net worth? By definition. If you take away what I owe from
what I own, what is left is what I am worth (in strictly
It is for this reason that the Statement of Financial Position financial terms).
is usually referred to as the Balance Sheet. Since the totals
of both sections of the statement are always equal, they can
be said to be balanced (see Exhibit 4-1).' CURRENT ASSETS
Assets consist of cash, things that can easily be converted
1 To determine why this statement was never called a Balanced Sheet to cash, and things that may not be easily converted to cash
would require considerable research and is beyond the scope of this book. but are needed to enable the company to make products or
However, my own suspicion is that it was the result of a typographical error.
provide services for which it will eventually receive cash.
26 Chapter 4/The Statement of Financial Position or Balance Sheet Current Assets 27
Assets are generally listed in an order that approximates In fact, some customers never pay, either because their
how easily each item can be converted to cash, beginning own business is not so hot or because they don't like what
with cash itself. Assets that can immediately be converted you sold them (buyer's remorse). For this reason, there is an
to cash or are expected to be converted to cash within one allowance for doubtful accounts netted out of the accounts
year are subtotaled and classified as current assets. These receivable total.
may include marketable securities, accounts receivable, in The Easy Company had accounts receivable of $2,000,000
ventory, and certain prepaid expenses such as insurance or at the end of 1991 and $2,500,000 at the end of 1992. Since
taxes. sales were $10,000,000 during 1992, that amount was added
If all of these assets are converted into cash within one to receivables during the year (assuming all sales were
year, you would expect the company to have a lot of cash credit, as opposed to cash, sales). If all receivables had been
at the end of the year. Right? That's not what happens. The collected, both the $2,000,000 beginning balance and the
company just turns around and puts this cash back into the $10,000,000 in new sales would be gone from the Balance
same kinds of assets so that its business can continue making Sheet by the end of 1992. Since $2,500,000 remains on the
things or providing services. The cash flow snobs will be books, however, the company must have collected only
happy to show you how you end up with the amount of $7,500,000 of the $10,000,000 in new sales in addition to all
cash that you do, and we'll take a look at that in Chap of the receivables outstanding at the end of 1991.
ter Six. A simple formula illustrates the relationship between ac
The Easy Company had $2,000,000 in cash at the end of counts receivable (AR) outstanding, collection of receiv
1991 and $900,000 at the end of 1992. We shall see in our ables, and sales:
discussion of cash flow how it used $1,100,000 in cash in
spite of profitable operations. (In Exhibit 1-1, we can see Beginning AR + Sales - Collections = Ending AR2
under the column headed "Changes" what increases in
assets and decreases in liabilities and owners* equity con Any time sales exceed collections, accounts receivable in
tributed to this net use of cash.) crease. Cash received is then less than sales. In financial
Marketable securities are usually very short-term obliga jargon, that is a use of cash and represents a reduction
of cash flow. Any time collections exceed sales, accounts
tions of the U.S. government or large corporations. They
must be actively traded in markets that provide.public price receivable decrease. Cash received is then greater than
quotations on a continuous basis. Otherwise they're not sales. That is a source of cash and represents an increase
in cash flow.
marketable enough to be called marketable securities.
Inventory consists of products held for sale (finished
Accounts receivable are amounts due from customers for
goods), materials used in production (raw materials), and
products sold or services provided. Revenue from these
sales has been recognized and income earned in the Income
Statement, but cash has not yet been received. Remember
that revenues and expenses are recognized or accrued at
2 Write-offs of bad debts, which would also reduce ending accounts
the time a sale or a service provided creates an obligation receivable, are omitted from this illustration for the sake of simplicity.
for payment at a future date. Otherwise they would be subtracted along with collections.
28 Chapter 4/The Statement of Financial Position or Balance Sheet Current Assets 29
the value of partially completed products as determined by EXHIBIT 4-2
the amount of labor, materials, and other costs applied The Three Stages of Inventory (The Easy Company)
to them at their various stages of completion (work-in-
process). The Easy Company had $2,000,000 in inventory
at the end of 1991 and $2,300,000 at the end of 1992 (see
Exhibit 4-2).
As in the case of accounts receivable, there is a basic
1
formula that shows the effects of the production and sale
of goods on inventory and the financial statements. Inven
n
Toothpick
tory may consist of only purchases, as in the case of a Grinder
wholesaler or distributor, or of purchases plus manufactur
ing costs, as in the case of a manufacturer who purchases YY\
raw materials that go into the production process. For pur
poses of our formula, we will call this component production
instead of just purchases, with the understanding that in Raw materials Work in process Finished goods
(lumber) (toothpick shaping) (toothpicks For sale)
some companies it may consist only of purchases. We will
also use the notation CGS for the cost of goods sold, which
means that portion of beginning inventory plus production
during the period that was actually sold during the period.
production, ending inventory will be less than beginning
Therefore:
inventory. Inventory would then be a source of cash and a
boost to cash flow.
Beginning inventory + Production - CGS = Ending in The second equation is used for the calculation of cost
ventory of goods sold for the Income Statement. For The Easy
Company, it would appear as follows:
and therefore:
Beginning inventory $2,000,000
Purchases or production costs +7,300,000
CGS = Beginning inventory + Production - Ending in Cost of goods available for sale 9,300,000
ventory Less: Ending inventory -2,300,000
Cost of goods sold $7,000,000
The first equation tells us that, if production exceeds the
cost of goods sold, ending inventory will be higher than Prepaid expenses may be payments for things like insur
beginning inventory. That means that, on balance, cash went ance, where the premium is paid in advance for coverage
into inventory that was not sold, a use of cash or reduction of over a future period of time. The premium is earned by
cash flow. If, on the other hand, cost of goods sold exceeds the insurance provider evenly over the period of coverage.
30 Chapter 4/The Statement of Financial Position or Balance Sheet Current Liabilities 31
Therefore, no expense is recognized by the insured at the CURRENT LIABILITIES
time of prepayment.
Liabilities are amounts that are owed by the company in
As the expense is recognized over the period of coverage,
the form of debt, unpaid bills, and expenses that have been
however, the amount of the asset, prepaid insurance ex
incurred but are not yet payable and/or have not yet been
pense, will decrease while no further cash payments will be
paid. These accrued expenses might typically include
made. The prepaid expense will provide cash during the
amounts payable for wages and salaries earned by employ
operating period only in the sense that expenses will be
ees, interest expense on debt, and rent and utilities ex
recorded in the Income Statement that will not require cash
penses. As with assets, amounts payable within one year
outlays during this period.
are classified as current liabilities.
The Easy Company had $100,000 in prepaid expenses at
A formula that is similar to our accounts receivable for
the end of both 1991 and 1992, suggesting that prepayments
mula describes the effects of changes in accounts payable
in the same amount were made in each year.
and other accrued liabilities:
NONCURRENT ASSETS
Beginning balance + Additions - Payments = Ending
balance
Noncurrent assets typically include property and equipment
used in production, sales, or distribution of products or
services. They may also include investments in other com
If additions, or new accruals, exceed payments, cash paid
panies, most commonly companies affiliated through partial
out is less than expenses accrued. As we shall see, that is
ownership by the reporting company. These assets may
a source of cash and an increase to cash flow when it comes
provide the means to produce cash during the operating
time to adjust reported income to actual cash flow. Similarly,
period but are not themselves expected to be converted to
if payments exceed new accruals, that is a use of cash and
cash in this time frame, if at all.
represents a reduction of cash flow.
The Easy Company had $2,000,000 in property, plant,
In most companies, current assets must exceed current
and equipment at the end of 1991 and $2,800,000 at the end
liabilities by some margin dictated by the operating charac
of 1992. The company purchased $1,000,000 of new property
teristics of the particular type of business in order for the
and equipment during 1992, but gross property and equip
company to be considered sufficiently liquid. Liquidity is a
ment was reduced by $200,000 in depreciation. The net
measure of how well a company is able to pay for its short-
figure therefore increased by $800,000, calling for the use
term cash operating requirements. The more predictable the
of an equal amount of cash:
cash flow generated from the operations of a company, the
less the amount of liquidity generally seen to be required
Beginning property, plant, and equipment $2,000,000
in the Balance Sheet.
Add new acquisitions 1,000,000
The amount by which current assets exceed current liabil
Less depreciation ( 200,000)
ities is called working capital. Any deficiency in current
Ending property, plant, and equipment $2,800,000
32 Chapter 4/Thc Statement of Financial Position or Balance Sheet Leverage
assets compared to current liabilities is called negative or LEVERAGE
deficit working capital.
The current liabilities of The Easy Company increased To the extent that total liabilities are large in relation to
from $1,800,000 in 1991 to $1,900,000 in 1992, while its owners' equity, a company is said to be leveraged. Other
current assets declined from $7,000,000 to $6,800,000 in the things being equal, a company with little leverage is less
same period. It was therefore slightly less liquid at the end risky than a company that is highly leveraged. The highly
of 1992, but its liquidity was still more than adequate with leveraged company has less room to absorb operating losses
a ratio of current assets to current liabilities of over 3.5 or other reductions in its asset values and owners' equity
to 1.0. than the company with little leverage.
Leverage became a controversial subject during the
1980s, when many companies were acquired by means of
leveraged buy outs, or LBOs. The acquirer would borrow
against the assets and/or cash flow of the company to obtain
LONG-TERM DEBT
the funds with which to purchase its stock. In many cases,
Long-term debt and other long-term liabilities are obliga this left the acquired company so heavily in debt (i.e., highly
tions that are not scheduled or expected to be paid during leveraged) that it lacked the financial capacity to survive
the following year. These generally consist of the noncurrent
under conditions more adverse than originally projected
portion of debt owed to banks~or other financial institutions when the deals were put together.
The Easy Company reduced its total liabilities in 1992
and publicly traded bonds or notes representing obligations
of the company.
from $3,800,000 to $3,700,000 while increasing its owners'
equity from $5,700,000 to $6,300,000 through the retention
of $600,000 in 1992 profits. It thus became slightly less lever
aged at the end of 1992, though its leverage was quite modest
in 1991 as well.
OWNERS' EQUITY We examine the many ways in which a Balance Sheet
may be used to assess the financial health of a company in
Owners' equity, which is called shareholders' equity in the subsequent chapters.
case of a corporation, consists of both funds contributed to
the company for the purchase of ownership interests and
the accumulation of the profits of the business that have not
been paid out to the owners in the form of dividends or other
capital distributions. These accounts are called contributed
capital, or capital, and retained earnings respectively.
Owners' equity is not itself an asset. It represents the
owners' claim on assets after all liabilities are recognized.
 Cost of Goods Sold 35
Chapter Five Provision for income taxes 400,000
Net profit 600,000
The Profit and Loss or
Income Statement REVENUES
Since The Easy Company is a manufacturing company,
its revenues take the form of products sold, or sales.
Revenues, however, are not necessarily synonymous
with sales. Revenues can come from rentals, interest
The Profit and Loss Statement is intended to show how
earned, commissions, or any one of a number of services
much money a company is making or losing. It does so by
for which revenues are not commonly referred to as
subtracting all of the costs of production of goods that have
sales.
been sold during the period and other expenses of running
The Easy Company sold $10,000,000 in toothpicks during
the company from the revenues generated from sales of
1992. These sales were net of a small number of toothpicks
products or from services provided.
that were returned by dissatisfied customers, most of whom
The Profit and Loss Statement is sometimes called the
claimed they were not as "user-friendly" as advertised. Its
Income Statement. The former became the preferred termi
sales are therefore stated as net sales.
nology when it became evident that companies could lose
money as well as make it. However, the latter is probably
more commonly used because it is easier to say.
In Exhibit 1-1, we can see that The Easy Company had
sales of $10,000,000 and a net profit of $600,000 after a cost COST OF GOODS SOLD
of goods sold of $7,000,000, other operating expenses of
The cost of goods sold is made up of all costs allocated to
$1,800,000, interest expense of $200,000 and a provision for
inventory sold during the period, including labor, materials,
income taxes of $400,000:
and overhead.1 For The Easy Company, these costs con
sisted principally oflumber, depreciation of toothpick manu
Net sales $10,000,000
Cost of goods sold 7,000,000 facturing plant and equipment, and wages and salaries of
Gross profit $ 3,000,000 production workers and supervisors.
Operating expenses:
Selling, general, and administrative 1,600,000
Depreciation 200,000 1,800,000
Profit from operations 1,200,000 1 Overhead consists of periodic expenses that are incurred whether or not
Interest expense 200.000 any sales are made or product produced. Depreciation of property and
Income before taxes 1,000,000 equipment, rent, and insurance are common examples of overhead.
 37
36 Chapter 5/The Profit and Loss or Income Statement The Income Statement's Impact on the Balance Sheet
GROSS PROFITS penses. Had they been costs of production, they would have
been included in cost of goods sold.
The difference between a company's sales and its cost of
goods sold is its gross profit. It is called gross profit because
other expenses still need to be deducted in order to arrive PROVISION FOR INCOME TAXES
at net profit.
Gross profit represents the contribution revenues make The provision for income taxes, or income tax expense, is
toward coverage of expenses not tied to production and based on the company's effective income tax rate applied
toward net profit. The Easy Company had gross profit of to its net taxable income. The effective tax rate may be
$3,000,000 in 1992 with which to cover other expenses of different from the statutory rate. Differences can be caused
$2,400,000, leaving a net profit of $600,000. by various tax credits and items that may be allowable ex
penses for financial reporting but not for income taxes or
allowable for income taxes but not treated as expenses for
OPERATING EXPENSES financial reporting.
The Easy Company's taxes were 40 percent of its income
Operating expenses consist of general and administrative before taxes after allowing for these adjustments.
expenses and selling expenses. General and administrative
expenses are expenses'that are necessary just to keep the
business running from day to day even if no sales are made NET INCOME
and no products produced. These include management sala
ries, property and equipment rentals or depreciation, inter Net income is what is left over after all the costs of doing
est expense, utilities not connected with production, most business are deducted from all the revenues earned (see
research and development expenses, insurance, office sup Exhibit 5-1). That portion of net income that is not paid
plies, salaries of office workers, and numerous other items out in dividends or for other unusual things not directly
that you really don't need to hear about. related to running the business becomes a part of owners'
Selling expenses consist of all forms of advertising, the equity by way of the retained earnings account.
salaries and commissions of sales personnel, and all costs The Easy Company earned a hefty $600,000 in net profit
of supporting the sales function. These costs include many from selling toothpicks in 1992. It retained every penny
of the same items as general and administrative expenses, of it.
but only, for example, those portions of office supplies and
utilities that were allocated to the sales function.
To aid in the financial analysis of its performance, The THE INCOME STATEMENT'S IMPACT
Easy Company chose to show $200,000 in depreciation and ON THE BALANCE SHEET
$200,000 in interest expense separately from selling, general,
and administrative expenses. They might just as well have Whenever you earn income or suffer losses, it directly af
been included in the latter, since they were operating ex- fects your net worth (owners' equity). For this reason,
38 Chapter 5/The Profit and Loss or Income Statement The Income Statement's Impact on the Balance Sheet 39
EXHIBIT 5-1 EXHIBIT 5-2
Sales Breakdown by Expenses and Profit (The Easy Company) The Effect of Income Statement Items on the Balance Sheet
Income Statement Balance Sheet
Sales leads to Increase accounts
receivable
- Cost of goods sold leads to* Decrease inventory
= Gross profit
- Operating expenses leads to* Increase accrued
s expenses
or Increase accounts
A payable
or Decrease cash
L
or Decrease prepaid
E expenses
= Net profit leads to Increase retained
S
earnings (owners'
equity)
Exhibit 5-3 shows in more detail how Income Statement
results might affect a company's Balance Sheet. In this
example, the Simple Company, a manufacturer of high grade
- The "Bottom Line" sludge, had sales of $1,000,000 and a net profit of $100,000
after deducting cost of sales (inventory sold) of $600,000
and operating expenses of $300,000.
The company produced $700,000 in inventory during the
period, causing an increase in ending inventory of $100,000
profits and losses are added to or subtracted from owners' after the sale of $600,000 in inventory. It also collected only
equity and thus affect the Balance Sheet. Increases in own $800,000 of its receivables. The $200,000 difference between
ers' equity caused by operating profits may result in in sales and collections during the period caused ending ac
creases in cash and/or other assets, decreases in debt, or counts receivable to increase by this amount.
some combination of the two. Losses would, of course, Liabilities had to increase by $200,000 to fund the differ
have the opposite effects. Thus the Balance Sheet is kept in ence between the $100,000 increase in owners' equity and
balance. Exhibit 5-2 shows the relationship between major the $300,000 increase in total assets. This amount also repre
Income Statement categories and corresponding Balance sents a negative cash flow in spite of positive net profits, a
Sheet accounts. scenario we shall explore more in the next chapter.
 Statement of Changes in Shareholders* Equity 41
STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN
SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY
A Statement of Changes in Shareholders' Equity for 1992
for The Easy Company, were it to provide one, might appear
II
73
as follows:
Balance, January 1 $5,700
Add net income 600
Less dividends declared 0
Balance, December 31 $6,300
iff 8
3 w
This information becomes only slightly more exciting
1 8
u when there are sales and/or repurchases of stock or other
8
special charges or allocations between retained earnings and
o
contributed capital. We do not need this extra excitement
o
at our level of discussion, and, for companies like The Easy
Company, a Statement of Changes in Shareholders' Equity
c >
doesn't really provide any additional information.
I Ji H 3
II
1
O
H
5
c
II
o
 Conceptual Basis for Determining Cash Flow 43
Chapter Six CONCEPTUAL BASIS FOR
DETERMINING CASH FLOW
The Statement of In the case of The Easy Company, it can be seen that profits
Cash Flows for the year amounted to $600,000. Were it not for the vari
ous accruals necessary to convert profits to cash flow, cash
would have increased by the same amount. In fact, cash
decreased by $1,100,000. How is this possible?
Cash now from operations:
Net profit $ 600
The fact that all revenue is not received when it is earned Depreciation 200
and all expenses are not paid precisely as incurred is one 800
of the factors giving rise to the need for a statement of cash Changes to operating assets and liabilities:
Accounts receivable (500)
flows to reconcile the accrual income statement to net cash Inventory (300)
collected or paid. Accounts payable 200
The statement of cash flows became a required part of Accrued expenses (100)
the financial statements fairly recently. Simply put, it shows Net cash provided by operations 100
Cash flows from investing activities:
how the profits or losses during the accounting period com
Additions to property, plant, and equipment (1,000)
bine with all of the balance sheet changes to produce a Net cash from financing activities:
change in the company's cash balance. Repayment of long-term debt ( 200)
In arriving at the change in cash, changes caused by the Net cash provided (used) $(1,100)
day-to-day operations of the business are separated from
changes caused by things like investment and financing ac
tivities to reveal "cash flow from operations." This subtotal Our Cash Flow Statement begins with net income as if
in the overall derivation of cash flow has special significance all income were received in cash and all expenses paid in
for many users of financial statements for it essentially con cash during the period. It then makes numerous adjustments
verts profits or losses into cash flow. This distinction is to reflect the fact that this is not so.
important to financial statement users who believe that ac Anytime you have income that does not result in cash
tual money in the bank is more important as a measure of received, it is considered a use of cash in the conversion
business performance than some accounting contrivance of net profit from the Income Statement to cash provided
called profit. in the Cash Flow Statement. To illustrate this point, assume
Ironically, the whole accrual accounting system was de that you earned $100 during the accounting period but did
veloped in order to convert cash flow into profits, which not collect it. Your income was $100, but all of it went into
were at that time seen as a better measure of performance increasing your accounts receivable by $100. Your cash flow
than net cash received. was zero. The $100 increase in accounts receivable was
44 Chapter 6/The Statement of Cash Flows Calculating Cash Flow 45
therefore a use of cash that offset the $100 source from net CALCULATING CASH FLOW
income.
Similarly, anytime cash is received in a period other than To arrive at net profit in the Income Statement, $200,000
the one in which income was earned, you have a source of in depreciation was deducted as an expense. Remember,
cash in the period it is received. If, in the above example, however, that depreciation does not represent a cash outlay
you do nothing in the following accounting period but collect in this period. It is the amount by which long-lived income-
the $100, you will have a source of cash equal to the $100 generating assets are reduced in value to reflect a reduction
reduction in accounts receivable but no net income in this in their useful lives over time. Depreciation is therefore
period. added back into net income as the first step in determining
Anytime you have an expense that does not result in a cash flow.
cash outlay, it is considered a source of cash in the conver We can also see that accounts receivable increased by
sion of net profit from the income statement to cash provided $500,000 during the period. This increase represents an
in the Cash Flow Statement. Assume, for example, that you increase in the amount of revenues that were not re
purchase and use $50 of office supplies in an accounting ceived in cash. Since the Income Statement records all
period but have not yet paid for them by the end of the revenues regardless of whether cash has been received, the
period. Your expense during the period was $50, but all of $500,000 needs to be deducted in our derivation of cash
it went into an increase in your accounts payable. You flow.
reconcile the $50 Income Statement expense to actual cash Inventory increased by $300,000 during the period, and
that too represents a use of cash. In our calculation of cost
flow by treating the increase in accounts payable as a source
of goods sold on pages 28 and 29, beginning inventory was
of cash. Otherwise the $50, having been deducted in arriv
ing at net income, would stand as a net use of cash by de
added to the cost and ending inventory deducted. That is
fault.
because it is assumed that beginning inventory is in fact sold
Anytime payment is made in a period other than the one
during the accounting period and therefore is appropriately
in which the expense is recorded, you have a use of cash charged as a cost of sales during the period.
in the period payment is made. Again, assume that the $50 Ending inventory, on the other hand, is, by definition,
still there. It therefore cannot be charged against the sales
for the supplies is paid in the following period. Since cash
of this period and needs to be deducted from these costs in
is paid in this period but no expense is incurred, net income
arriving at cost of goods sold. As a deduction from costs, it
would have to be adjusted by showing the $50 reduction in
represents an increase in income. From a cash perspective,
accounts payable as a use of cash in the Statement of Cash
Flows. however, it is money out the door.
Beginning inventory, however, represented a cash outlay
All of these timing differences between income earned
in a prior period but a cost of sales in the current period.
and cash received, and between expenses incurred and cash
It therefore needs to be added to the cash flow of the current
paid, result in changes in accruals on the Balance Sheet.
period, so that the adjustment to profits for cash flow from
Changes in accruals therefore require corresponding adjust
ments to reported income to arrive at cash flow.
inventory changes is the beginning inventory less the ending
46 Chapter 6/The Statement of Cash Flows Calculating Cash Flow 47
inventory. An increase in inventory then represents a de If any account change shown as a source of cash above
crease in cash flow. takes place and no other account has changed, cash would
Increases in prepaid items are also uses of cash, since have to increase in order for the balance sheet to stay in
they are cash outlays of the current period for expenses of balance. If any account change shown as a use of cash took
the following period. Purchases of property and equipment place and no other account changed, cash would have to
represent uses of cash because they are cash outlays that are decrease to maintain balance.
depreciated over their lives rather than charged to current Exhibit 6-1 shows how all of this works. Six possibilities
expense. for changing cash are illustrated graphically, starting with
Since depreciation expense has already been added to net a beginning balance sheet for reference. All increases or
income in determining cash flow, accumulated depreciation decreases in cash result from the indicated changes in these
changes should not be considered as part of cash flow from categories.
operations. That would result in double counting of depreci The first scenario shows a decrease in cash caused by an
ation as a source of cash. Only changes in gross property increase in assets other than cash (a use of cash). This
and equipment are reflected in the cash flow statement. reflects the use of cash to purchase assets or fund increases
These are shown under cash flows from investing activities. in assets such as accounts receivable.
As we look at these changes in asset accounts, remember The second shows an increase in cash caused by a de
that sources of cash are decreases in noncash assets and crease in noncash assets (source). This would result from
increases in liabilities or owners' equity, including those the sale of assets such as property and equipment or the
that result from net profits. Uses are increases in assets and conversion, or net reduction, of assets such as inventory
decreases in liabilities or owners' equity, including those and accounts receivable into cash.
that result from net losses. The third scenario is a reduction in cash caused by a
These simple truths are the key to understanding cash reduction in owners' equity (use). Most commonly this
flow. All loans,.for example, are repaid from decreases in would be caused by a net operating loss that drew down
assets, increases in other liabilities or increases in owners' cash balances in the absence of any other sources of cash.
equity. Any banker who does not realize this does not really It could also be caused by cash purchases of the company's
understand his sources of repayment. stock.
The relationship between cash and other balance sheet The fourth scenario shows an increase in cash caused by
accounts is illustrated below:
an increase in owners' equity (source). This increase could
be caused by operating profits or the sale of company stock.
Cash Liabilities The fifth scenario shows an increase in cash resulting
+ Source of cash from an increase in liabilities (source). This occurs when a
Noncash Assets - Use of cash company borrows and holds the proceeds in cash, at least
+ Use of cash temporarily, or when it funds operating cash needs through
-Source of cash Owners' Equity increases in accounts payable and other accrued liabilities.
+ Source of cash The sixth scenario shows a decrease in cash caused by
-Use of cash
a decrease in liabilities (use). That would occur when a
 Calculating Cash Flow 49
EXHIBIT 6-1
How Changes in the Balance Sheet Affect Cash
company uses cash to pay down debt, accounts payable,
or other accrued liabilities.
Case 1: Case 2:
Decrease Assets (source)
Each of the foregoing possibilities shows a source or use
increase Assets (use)
Decrease Cash Increase Cash of cash resulting in an increase or decrease to the cash
Beginning Balance Sheet
balance. If these sources and uses were to partially or wholly
Cash offset one another, however, as is usually the case, there
Cash
Cash
might be little or no net change to cash balances.
Liabilities Liabilities Liabilities To demonstrate how offsetting sources or uses might not
Noncash affect cash, the six scenarios in Exhibit 6-2 show all of the
Noncash Assets
Assets Noncash offsetting combinations of changes that will result in no
Assets
Equity Equity Equity change in cash.
The first is an increase in noncash assets (use) offset by
an increase in liabilities (source). In this case, the increase
in assets is funded by debt or other liabilities instead of
Case 3: Case 4:
Decrease Equity (use) Increase Equity (source) cash.
Decrease Cash Increase Cash The second is an increase in assets (use) offset by an
Beginning Balance Sheet
increase in equity (source). In this case the asset expansion
is funded by profits or a sale of the company's stock.
Cash
Cash , Cash
The third case shows a decrease in assets (source) offset
Liabilities Liabilities by a decrease in liabilities (use). Here cash that would have
Liabilities
Noncash
Noncash resulted from the sale or conversion of assets was instead
Assets
Assets Noncash used to pay liabilities.
Assets
Equity The fourth case shows a reduction in assets (source) offset
Equity Equity
by a reduction in equity (use). That would most commonly
represent operating losses funded by the liquidation of assets
or conversion (reduction) of inventory and receivables to
I Case 5: I Case 6:
Increase Liabilities (source* I Decrease Liabilities (use) cash.
Increase Cash Decrease Cash The fifth scenario shows an increase in liabilities (source)
Beginning Balance Sheet
offset by a decrease in equity (use). Here operating losses
or repurchase of the company's stock were most likely
Cash
Cash Cash ,
funded by the use of debt and other liabilities rather than
>
Liabilities by cash.
T
Liab lities
The sixth scenario shows a reduction in liabilities (use)
Noncash
Assets Noncash Noncash offset by an increase in equity (source). Here cash provided
Assets Assets
Equity Equity
Equity by operating profits and/or sale of stock was used to reduce
liabilities.
EXHIBIT 6-2 Calculating Cash Flow 51
How Changes in the Balance Sheet Affect Noncash Items
In reality, the changes that take place in cash balances
Case 1 : Case 2: are the result of a myriad of transactions that affect assets,
Increase Assets (use) Increase Assets (use)
Increase Equity (source)
liabilities, and owners' equity during a period. By isolating
Increase Liabilities (source)
Beginning Balance Sheet them into their individual components, however, we can
see more clearly how any balance sheet change, including
Cash Cash
changes in owners' equity caused by profits and losses, will
Cash
i j
Liabilities affect cash and cash flow. We can also see how a use that
Liabilities
is offset by a noncash source or a source that is offset by
Noncash a noncash use will have no effect at all.
Assets
Equity
Noncash
Equity
Noncash
Assets
t
Equity
Hopefully these simple diagrams will serve as a reference
Assets to assist you in seeing the impact of any change in a Balance
Sheet account or net income or losses on cash flow and
cash balances.
Case 3: Case 4: Cash flow can therefore be derived purely from computing
Decrease Assets (source) Decrease Assets (source)
Decrease Liabilities (use) Decrease Equity (use)
changes in the Balance Sheet between one period and an
Beginning Balance Sheet other for all items except cash. The difference between all
sources of cash and all uses is net cash provided or used.
Cash The $1.1 million in cash used by The Easy Company, for
Cash Liabilities Cash example, is the residual after netting all other balance sheet
Liabilities
Liabilities changes against one another (see Exhibit 1-1).
Noncash Noncash Noncash
However, no adjustment is made in the Cash Flow State
T
Assets Assets
Equity ment for the change in retained earnings since it has already
Equity Equity
been taken into account by starting with the net profit or
loss in the derivation of cash flow. It is more instructive for
analytical purposes to begin with net income (instead of the
Case 5: Case 6: increase in owners* equity) and depreciation (instead of the
Increase Liabilities (source) Increase Equity (source)
Decrease Equity (use) Decrease Liabilities (use) increase in the allowance for depreciation) and then list all
Beginning Balance Sheet
other sources and uses of operating cash flow. One can then
include investment and financing sources and uses of funds
Liabilities
Cash Cash Cash that are not directly related to operating performance during
the period and should therefore be analyzed as separate
Liabilities
components of cash flow.
Noncash Noncash Noncash
Assets Assets Liabilities Assets Let's look at liabilities and other changes in owners* eq
uity. Increases in accrued liabilities provide cash because
Equity Equity
Equity they represent expenses charged to income that have not
been paid in cash. (Remember, not paying your bills is a
52 Chapter 6/Thc Statement of Cash Flows Alternative Format for Statement of Cash Flows 53
source of cash, albeit in a very short-term sense.) Decreases lected during the period, we must add in accounts receivable
mean that cash has been paid in excess of expenses charged at the beginning of the period even though they were earned
against income, a use of cash vis-a-vis reported profit. in a prior period. They are presumed to be the first monies
Increases in long-term debt provide cash proceeds quite collected. We then add revenues earned during the period
apart from anything that happens in the income statement. as if they had all been collected. We then subtract accounts
These amounts therefore need to be added to income to receivable at the end of the period as these represent the
determine cash as part of net cash from financing activities. amount of the first two items which clearly was not col
Similarly, decreases in long-term debt represent cash used lected:
to pay down debt but have no immediate effect on profit or
loss. The latter are therefore deducted from cash flow under
net cash from financing activities. Cash revenue = Accrual revenue + Beginning AR
- Ending AR
The Statement of Cash Flow on page 43 shows how op
erating performance as well as investments in plant and
equipment, and changes in long-term debt affect the State Similarly, costs of goods sold are converted to actual cash
ment of Cash Flow of The Easy Company. outlays for production. Cash paid for materials consists of
Although not present in the financial statements of The beginning accounts payable plus purchases less ending ac
Easy Company, dividends and capital distributions would counts payable. Labor and overhead costs are similarly ad
reduce owners' equity and cash as they represent cash paid justed to show only those amounts paid in cash.
out after the determination of net income. Capital contrib Operating expenses are also adjusted by adding the total
uted through the sale of ownership interests, such as public of beginning accrued expenses and deducting the total of
stock offerings, would increase cash from sources indepen ending accrued expenses. The resulting Statement of Cash
dent of income statement (operating) activities. Flows for The Easy Company would then look something
like this:
ALTERNATIVE FORMAT FOR Cash received from revenues $9,500
(7,100)
STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS Cash paid for production costs
(2,300)
Cash paid for operating expenses
100
There is another method of presentation for the Statement Cash derived from operations
Cash paid for property, plant, and equipment (1,000)
of Cash Flows. In the opinion of this author, which carries
( 200)
Cash paid for debt reduction
a lot of weight here, it is not nearly as good as the one we $(1,100)
Net cash flow
have just seen. This second method is intended to show
how much cash was generated from sales, how much was
used in production, and how much was used in other op
1 Cost of goods sold + Increase in inventory - Increase in accounts
erating expenses. At each step, revenues earned or expenses
payable.
incurred are converted into cash received or cash paid. 2 SG&A expenses + Interest expense + Inome taxes paid + Decrease in
To adjust our accrual statement revenues to cash col- accrued expenses.
54 Chapter 6/The Statement of Cash Flows
Using the Statement of Cash Flows
55
My principal objection to this format is that I'm not sure
precipitously, resulting in little being generated by way of
it tells me anything I really need to know. Our earlier format
new accounts receivable to replace receivables that were
started with net income plus noncash accounting charges
that had reduced net income but not required cash outlays.
being collected. While the resulting reduction in receivables
made bottom line cash flow look very strong, the loss of
(The total of these two numbers would represent cash flow
business was clearly not a sustainable source of cash flow.
in the absence of any other balance sheet changes.) It then
showed how Balance Sheet changes, reflecting changes in
Analysts who focus only on net cash flow also overlook
increases in accounts payable and accrued expenses, which
cash receipt and payment patterns, altered this amount to
arrive at actual cash flow from operations. Finally, it showed
are also not sustainable as sources of cash. Suppliers will
either demand payment more promptly at some point in
cash used for investments and debt payments and thereby
time or go out of business due to cash flow problems of
reconciled cash flow to the final change in the cash balance their own.
per the balance sheet.
Conversely, increases in accounts receivable or de
Personally, I like to know what amount of cash would
creases in accounts payable and accrued expenses, though
be provided by operations if receivables, payables, and in
they may adversely affect cash flow, are certainly not neces
ventory weren't fluctuating all over the place. I then like to
sarily unhealthy signs in a business. The main concern of
be able to easily spot those Balance Sheet accounts whose
cash flow analysis should be that a company not tie up its
changes have caused the major deviations in cash flow in
funds in assets that are failing to generate sufficient cash
order to determine their causes and significance.
for the company to meet its obligations and take advantage
While I don't have any actual statistics on the frequency
of future opportunities. For this purpose, cash flow should
of usage of the two formats, from my own experience I be analyzed over several years and in detail.
would venture the opinion that the former is easily the most Rapid growth also tends to consume cash and make net
widely used presentation.
cash flow look weaker than it would otherwise. Cash must
be paid out for at least that part of plant, equipment, and
inventory that is not financed. Rapid growth requires greater
USING THE STATEMENT OF outlays for these assets in order to provide for an increasing
CASH FLOWS level of sales, but the assets do not generate cash until
sales are booked and accounts receivable collected. The
The Statement of Cash Flows can be either effective or gap between the higher level of cash outlays and the higher
dangerous as a tool of financial analysis. Some analysts will level of collections can easily result in negative cash flow
focus only on the bottom line number, citing the net change during the period of accelerated growth.
in cash to support the position that a company's cash flow
is strong or weak. To be meaningful, however, cash flow
analysis should also focus on the individual components of
cash flow.
I recall one analyst who was impressed by a large positive
cash flow that was caused by a company's sales declining
 The Inventory Purchase
Chapter Seven EXHIBIT 7-1
Following Cash through the Balance Sheet (the Hypothetical
Following a Transaction Company)
After Purchase of Inventory After Payment to Vendor
through the
Beginning
Cash $100 A/P$100 Cash $100 Cash $100 A/P$100j
Financial Statements
Long-Term Accounts
Accounts Accounts
Debt $200 Receivable Receivable
Receivable Accounts
$300 $300 $300
Payable
Bank Loan
Inventory
$400
Equity
$200
Long-Term Long-Term
Debt $200 Debt $200
PP&E Inventory
$200 $600
We have examined the purpose and uses of financial state
Total = $800 Total = $800 Inventory
ments as well as their key features. We will now proceed $600 Equity Equity
$500 $500
to focus on important accounting issues and rules that give
PP&E PP&E
additional meaning to the numbers. We will also study the $200 $200
use of financial information in more detail. We will begin Total = $1,200 Total = $1,200 Total = $1,200 Total = $1,200
in this chapter by taking a look at the effects of routine
business operations on the financial statements.
To illustrate more clearly how normal business operations
After Sale to Customer After Collection of Receivable
affect cash and related accounts, the charts in Exhibit 7-1
1
Cash $100 A/PS100 A/P$100
demonstrate how a typical transaction of the Hypothetical Bank Debt = 0

Company affects its income, Balance Sheet, and cash flow Cash Long-Term
Bank $300 Debt $200
over an operating cycle. Loan
$400 Accounts
Prior to the transaction, the company's Balance Sheet is Receivable
liquid, with $600,000 in current assets compared to $100,000 $300
Long-Term 1
in current liabilities for a current ratio of six to one. It is Debt $200
Equity
Inventory $700
also lightly leveraged with only $300,000 in total liabilities $200
Accounts
compared to $500,000 in owners' equity. Receivable PP&E
$900 $200
Inventory Total = $1,000 Total = $1,000
$200
THE INVENTORY PURCHASE
PP&E Equity
$200 $700
The company then purchases $400,000 in inventory with
payment due in 30 days. It needs a source of cash equal to Total = $1,400 Total = $1,400
the $400,000 use in order for the Balance Sheet to balance.
58 Chapter 7/Following a Transaction through the Financial Statements Sale of the Inventory 59
While part of this could come from collection of accounts cash. No net cash is therefore provided, and bank debt stays
receivable, a reduction of cash balances, or bank borrowing, at $400,000. The company's liquidity has improved with the
we have assumed that the entire purchase is financed large increase in receivables and more modest reduction in
through accounts payable to the vendor. inventory. The current ratio is now greater than two to one,
The ratio of current assets to current liabilities is two to and total liabilities equal owners' equity. The company is
one after the purchase, and inventory, which is less liquid still more highly leveraged than before the transaction due
than cash or accounts receivable, is now a far larger portion to the new debt that cannot yet be repaid.
of current assets. The company is therefore less liquid. With
total liabilities of $700,000 compared to equity of $500,000,
it is also more highly leveraged. COLLECTION OF
ACCOUNT RECEIVABLE
PAYMENT FOR THE INVENTORY Thirty days after the sale, however, the company collects
the account receivable. The $600,000 reduction in the receiv
At the end of 30 days the company pays the vendor, reducing able is a source of cash. However, $400,000 of this is used
accounts payable back to $100,000. (This would not be the to pay off bank debt. The remaining $200,000, in our exam
same $100,000 it started with as that balance would have ple, is added to cash. (It could have been used to pay off
been paid and new amounts added.) Because the reduction accounts payable and long-term debt or to make some reduc
in payables was a use of cash, we need an offsetting source to tion in one or both of these accounts, with the balance added
stay in balance. In our example, the $400,000 was borrowed to cash.) Equity is unchanged at $700,000, as no new income
from the company's bank. The company's Balance Sheet is generated as a result of collection of accounts that gener
is basically unchanged, as one form of short-term debt has ated the previously recognized income.
been substituted for another. The company is extremely liquid, with a current ratio of
eight to one and most of its current assets in cash and
receivables. Leverage is at its low point, with only $300,000
SALE OF THE INVENTORY in liabilities compared to $700,000 in equity. While this trans
action therefore caused the company to become temporarily
Thirty days after payment to the vendor, the company sells less liquid and more leveraged, ultimately the profits and
the $400,000 in inventory for $600,000. The $200,000 profit collection of receivables improved its financial condition.
causes an increase in owners1 equity from $500,000 to For an overview of the cash cycle, see Exhibit 7-2.
$700,000, but no cash has been received at this point. The This example shows the effects of a transaction over a
entire $600,000 from the sale is therefore recorded as an short period of time on a business that is otherwise stagnant.
increase in accounts receivable. In Chapter Twelve, we will see how growth or decline in
The $200,000 source of cash from the increase in equity the company's business, as well as its efficiency and profit
plus the $400,000 from the reduction in inventory is equal ability, can change the impact on its Balance Sheet and cash
to the $600,000 increase in accounts receivable, a use of flow.
60 Chapter 7/FoIIowing a Transaction through the Financial Statements
EXHIBIT 7-2 Chapter Eight
The Cash Cycle
Cash
Cash peaks and begins to
Special Inventory
Valuation and
fall as expenses are paid
and new inventory built
Positive cash Depreciation Reporting
Beginning
Cash
Balance
Issues
Inventory builds
drawing down cash
The rules for reporting most financial statement accounts
are somewhat standardized so that the reader may be
Negative cash
reasonably assured that what the numbers show is a fair
representation of what is actually happening. Standard
Negative cash is cash less short-
term debt and payables
ization is also necessary in order to compare one com
pany's financial strength and performance to that of its
peers.
Time
Nevertheless, accounting standards permit some choices
between alternate methods of reporting. Fortunately, the
financial report must disclose to the reader, by way of foot
notes to the financial statements, which of several equally
acceptable accounting methods has been selected. (We dis
cuss financial statement footnotes in some detail in Chapter
Eleven.)
Two of the areas offering considerable latitude in the
manner of presentation are inventory valuation and the de
preciation of property, plant, and equipment. Since these
items appear routinely on most companies' financial state
ments, they warrant special attention.
 Inventory Valuation Alternatives
62 Chapter 8/Special Inventory Valuation and Depreciation Reporting Issues 63
Lot Units Cost per Unit Total Cost
INVENTORY VALUATION
ALTERNATIVES . . 3 3,000 10 30,000
4 2,000 10 20,000
The valuation of inventory would be quite simple and ratio 5 3,000 12 36,000
nal if each item could be valued according to its own specifi 11,000 $111,000
cally identified cost, and indeed this specific identification
method is used in instances where a relatively low volume of Assume that a total of 9,000 units are sold during the year.
high-priced and clearly differentiable items can be tracked. The choices are whether to assume these sales consisted of
Automobiles and boats sold at retail are common examples the first 9,000 units purchased, the last 9,000 units pur
of specific identification, as are houses. chased, or the average cost of all units purchased during
Most products, however, are purchased in large lots of the period. These alternatives are called first-in-first-out or
standardized product at a given cost per unit for each lot. FIFO, last-in-first-out or LIFO, and average cost respec
These products do not lend themselves easily to specific tively. See Exhibit 8-1 on the following page.
identification. It would not be practical, for example, for Some really droll financial types even came up with an
The Easy Company to track each toothpick separately acronym for inventory that the firm gets stuck with because
through the production and shipping processes for valuation it doesn't sell. It's called FIST, or first-in-still-there. Take
purposes. Instead, all units purchased in each lot receive a minute to get control of your convulsive laughter and wipe
the same value, which is equal to the total purchase price the tears from your eyes so that we can continue.
of the lot divided by the number of units purchased. (Other If the 9,000 units are allocated to cost of goods sold based
manufacturing costs are also added to the cost of purchases, on FIFO or LIFO, the cost will be:
but for simplification we will use purchases as the total cost
of goods sold in our discussion.) FIFO LIFO
The choice among alternate accounting treatments lies in
Cost per Total Cost per Total
the identification of which units are assumed to have been
Lot Units Unit Cost Lot Units Unit Cost
sold versus which remain in inventory at the end of the
period. The method selected will influence the ending inven 1 2,000 8 $16,000 5 3,000 12 $36,000
2 1,000 9 9,000 4 2,000 10 20,000
tory value as well as the cost of goods sold. It will thereby
3 3,000 10 30,000 3 3,000 10 30,000
also influence net income, total asset value and owners'
4 2,000 10 20,000 2 1,000 9 9,000
equity. For illustration, assume all goods are purchased in
5 1,000 12 12,000
five lots as follows: 9,000 $87,000 9,000 $95,000
Purchases for Year Based on the average cost, the cost of goods sold
would be:
Lot Units Cost per Unit Total Cost
$111,000/11,000 units = $10.10 per unit
2,000 $ 16,000
1,000 9,000 9,000 x $10.10 = $90,900
64 Chapter 8/SpeciaI Inventory Valuation and Depreciation Reporting Issues
Relative Merits of FIFO, LIFO, and Average Cost 65
EXHIBIT 8-1
this method is that it does not match the cost of units being
Inventory Choices
sold with the cost of replacing those units in an environment
where significant price changes are taking place. It does,
however, value the remaining inventory, the latest units
purchased, at the approximate current cost of replacing that
inventory.
LIFO, on the other hand, values the cost of units sold at
prices close to their current replacement costs. Since the
ending inventory may consist of units purchased some time
ago, however, its value in the financial statements may differ
considerably from current market costs.
The average cost method combines the best and the worst
of FIFO and LIFO in a sort of compromise. It involves a
slightly more complicated calculation but is ideal for those
who can't make up their minds between FIFO and LIFO.
Since accounting is not politics, however, the average
cost compromise is not as commonly chosen as FIFO or
LIFO.
Tax consequences can play an important role in the selec
tion of an inventory valuation policy. During periods of
The ending inventory in each of these scenarios is the rising prices, for example, FIFO will match inventory pur
total cost of all the purchases (goods available for sale) less chased at lower prices in earlier periods against sales in
the cost of goods sold: the current period, resulting in higher reported profits and
therefore higher taxes. For this reason, LIFO tends to be
FIFO UFO Average Cost
more popular during inflationary periods.
Cost of goods purchased $111,000 $111,000 $111,000 In reading financial statements, it is important to know
Cost of goods sold 87,000 95,000 90,900 which method of inventory valuation has been used. One
$ 24,000 $ 16,000 $ 20,100
Ending inventory must consider the likely effects of this selection on Balance
Sheet and Income Statement results given trends in prices.
The method of valuation should be disclosed in the footnotes
RELATIVE MERITS OF FIFO, LIFO, AND following the financial statements, and often the impact on
AVERAGE COST inventory values of using another method will also be dis
closed. The reader can easily determine the impact on cost
There is a certain intuitive logic behind the notion that the of goods sold and net profits by substituting the alternate
first unit purchased is the first unit sold (FIFO). It just seems figures for beginning and ending inventory in the cost of
to be the natural order of things. The principal objection to goods sold calculation.
66 Chapter 8/Special Inventory Valuation and Depreciation Reporting Issues Depreciation Issues
67
DEPRECIATION ISSUES ment's useful life has ended even though it may be physically
capable of production for a considerably longer period.
Selection of the method of depreciation for long-lived assets
So you can see that the determination of useful life in
presents two problems: What is the useful life of the asset, volves a lot of guess work, which, in finance, we call estimat
and in what increments does its value diminish over this ing. As a rule of thumb, equipment generally has a useful
period? In order to understand the significance of these life of five to seven years. It could be more or less, however,
questions, it is useful to re-examine the purpose of depreci given special characteristics of the industry or the
ation. equipment.
Depreciation allocates the cost of an asset over its useful If a company is too optimistic in its assessment of the
life in order to match this cost against the revenues produced useful life of its equipment, it will end up taking losses on
by the asset. To do this, the total cost of the asset is divided the sale or retirement of the equipment. That is to say, the
among the number of periods it will be used. Clearly we
equipment will become useless while it still shows a value
must estimate the useful life of the asset at the time of on the Balance Sheet. That value must be fully or partially
purchase, since the depreciation charges must begin in the removed through a charge against income in the period in
first period of usage and cannot await the final disposition which it is determined that the equipment is worthless or
of the asset for determination of what its useful life will be. of lesser value than stated.
In recent years, many companies have announced mas
sive write-down and write-off charges against income,
Useful Life of Assets
caused, at least in part, by this type of accounting adjust
The projection of useful life is complicated by the fact that ment. Few things in the world of accounting are more excit
there is more than one factor that will enter into its calcula ing than a massive write down.
tion. There is, for example, the amount of time the asset If a company is not optimistic enough about the. useful
can be expected to be physically operative at its estimated life of its equipment, it will end up generating revenue and
level of usage before the cost of repairing it is no longer income from this equipment for some time after the equip
cost effective vis-a-vis the cost of replacing it. That could ment has been fully depreciated. That is to say, there will
be termed the physical life of the asset. While its calculation be no value for the equipment stated on the Balance Sheet
would be relatively straightforward, it nevertheless involves and no cost of depreciation charged against the revenues
estimates of the level of production, durability of the asset, produced during the remaining period of service of the
future repair costs, and replacement costs. equipment. Note that the company's income is overstated
An increasingly important and far more difficult estimate during this period by the lack of any charges for the use of
in the useful life calculation, however, must take into ac its equipment, just as it was understated during the earlier
count obsolescence. How long can a piece of equipment periods by charging too much of the cost of the equipment
operate economically before a new and technologically su against these periods of service.
perior piece of equipment can do the same thing so much Buildings generally have a useful life of 20 to 30 years
more efficiently that the company cannot compete in its for depreciation purposes, though many financial analysts
industry using the old equipment? At this time, the equip- contend that they do not really depreciate at all and therefore
 69
68 Chapter 8/Spccial Inventory Valuation and Depreciation Reporting Issues Depreciation Issues
have an infinite useful life. These are the same folks who to periodic depreciation for financial reporting purposes.
say that real estate always goes up in value. Appreciation However, if a company becomes aware of a material decline
cannot be shown in the financial statements, since that in the value of land carried on its Balance Sheet for any
would not be conservative and would cause income to be reason, it should reduce the stated cost or value to current
recognized before it is realized.1 The real estate boosters market value.
must therefore settle for the argument that showing depreci
ation for buildings merely shows a cost where in fact there Straight-Line versus Accelerated Depreciation
is none. They have no problem with adding depreciation of
buildings back into income to get what they consider to be The other depreciation issue to be resolved is, given the
a true measure of income. Usually, in fact, they just add estimate of useful life, how should the total depreciation
all depreciation back on the presumption that most of it is (the total cost of the asset) be allocated to each of these pe
buildings and, in any case, they don't want to mess with riods? At first glance one would be inclined to say, "Why not
sorting it all out. Today, however, there are fewer of these equally?" If an asset costs $100,000 and has a useful life
people than there were a few years ago. of 10 years, wouldn't $10,000 of the asset be used each year?
It is true enough that buildings may deteriorate physically In many cases, this is a reasonable approach. It is widely
at a less rapid rate than the 20 or 30 years used in financial used under the name straight-line depreciation. The periodic
statements. What is now more commonly recognized, how amount of depreciation is equal to the initial cost of the
ever, is that, in an era of rapid global changes in the econom asset divided by the number of periods of its useful life.
ics of production, distribution, and communications tech Were one to draw a graph of the periodic charges over time,
nology, buildings can become economically obsolete. it would appear as a perfectly horizontal straight line. Were
Geographic areas deteriorate or become less competitive. one to graph the decline in the value of the asset over a
Space requirements dictate different design layouts. Overall period of time, it would appear as a declining straight line.
demand for certain kinds of buildings falls. These factors The rationale for calling this form of depreciation straight-
influence values and suggest that depreciation of buildings line depreciation is therefore unimpeachable.
is appropriate and that the useful life determination must Most other forms of depreciation can be lumped into a
consider some of the same factors used for other types of single category called accelerated depreciation. They share
assets. the common assumption that depreciable property and
Land is different. There is simply no physical deteriora equipment loses more of its value in its early years of deploy
tion in land, and it doesn't become obsolete by means of ment than toward the end of its life. For a personal analogy,
the discovery of a technologically superior type of land. you probably know that the day you drive your new car off
While it may decline in value due to demographics or general the lot it becomes a used car and absorbs a precipitous drop
economic trends, the direction of any change in value is in value. Accelerated depreciation doesn't work quite as
largely a matter of speculation. Land is therefore not subject abruptly, but it's that kind of a thing.
The following table illustrates the effects of accelerated
depreciation on property with a five-year useful life. The
1 Accounting rules require that revenue be "realized" through a cash
transaction or obligation before it can be recognized for reporting purposes. accompanying graph (see Exhibit 8-2) shows how the value
70 Chapter 8/Special Inventory Valuation and Depreciation Reporting Issues Depreciation Issues 71
EXHIBIT 8-2 It therefore tends to penalize income in the early years and
Straight-Line versus Accelerated DepreciationHow Net Asset
augment it in later years. It seems most appropriate where
Value Declines over Time
technological obsolescence is a concern, as it more quickly
reduces the value of the asset over its estimated useful life.
Depredation Expense and therefore, Net Asset Value,
Since accelerated depreciation also tends to reduce re
declines faster in early years, and slower in later years ported net income in the early periods following asset pur
with an Accelerated Depreciation method. Depreciation
chases, it is also popular for tax purposes. Since a company
Expense and Net Asset Value decline at an even rate
with Straight-Line Depreciation. is not required to use the same method of reporting for tax
purposes as it uses for financial reporting purposes, it may
well use straight-line for financial reporting and an acceler
ated method, known as the accelerated cost recovery system
(ACRS), for income tax reporting.
Taxes that are shown as an expense for financial reporting
but are not payable due to the lesser income reported for
income tax reporting are shown on the Balance Sheet as
2
"deferred taxes." The accounting presumption is that these
taxes will have to be paid at some future date when acceler
ated depreciation results in lower depreciation charges than
straight-line. That would produce higher income tax pay
ments to the government relative to income tax expense for
financial reporting purposes. When this reversal takes place
depends on how rapidly the company continues to acquire
new assets.
Time
Clearly the estimate of useful life, combined with the
of an asset changes under accelerated depreciation com choice of straight-line or accelerated depreciation, can have
pared to straight-line depreciation. a considerable effect on the asset values and reported in
come of a company. It is the responsibility of management
Year Depreciation Asset Value
and its independent auditors to select methods of deprecia
0 $100,000 tion and to estimate useful lives on a basis that is reasonable,
1 $33,333 66,667 and to that end the ACRS guidelines are available through
2 26,667 40,000 the Internal Revenue Service and are observed by the ac
3 20,000 20,000 counting profession at least for income tax reporting and
4 13,333 6,667
often for financial reporting as well. It is your responsibility
5 6,667 0
as a user of financial statements to understand the alterna
Accelerated depreciation increases costs in the early tives and their effects on reported income and the Balance
years of equipment usage and decreases them in later years. Sheet.
 Goodwill 73
intellectual property, as opposed to real property, and are
Chapter Nine
therefore intangible assets.
In today's high-tech environment, patent rights for every
Intangible Assets thing from new drugs to new microchip technology have
become critical assets, often resulting in litigation to deter
and Amortization mine whether one company's new product violates another
company's patents. The fortunes of companies like Intel and
Advanced Micro Devices depend heavily on their continuing
disputes over patent protection and violation.
When Intel comes out with a new chip, Advanced Micro
usually comes out with a virtually identical kind of chip and
gets sued by Intel. Billions of dollars are at stake in their
AMORTIZATION
continuous rounds of litigation over what can be patented
and what constitutes a violation of that patent.
Until now, depreciation has occupied a unique position in
Important brand names, such as Coca-Cola, are similarly
our discussions as a direct noncash charge against income
protected from unauthorized use through trademarks. A
that needs to be added back as the first step in deriving cash
McDonald's franchise has a value far beyond that of its
flow. In point of fact, however, there is another expense
equipment, furnishings, and food inventory. That extraordi
that has similar characteristics in terms of its accounting
nary value is the intangible value of the franchise itself.
treatment and its effects on cash flow. That expense is called
These assets may not even be shown on the Balance
amortization, and it has been assuming an increasingly im
Sheet, and, if they are shown, they are shown at the cost
portant role in financial reporting. While depreciation re
of their acquisition or development. Their value may there
flects the periodic allocation of the costs of acquiring tangi
fore be significantly understated.
ble assets such as real property and equipment, amortization
reflects the periodic allocation of the costs of acquiring or
developing intangible assets.
GOODWILL
Some intangible assets are lumped into a general category
INTANGIBLE ASSETS called goodwill. Goodwill frequently arises when one com
pany buys another for a price in excess of the acquired
Intangible assets are those that we can't feel or see but that
company's net asset value (owners' equity) at the time of
nevertheless have considerable value in generating reve
acquisition. The difference between the purchase price and
nues. Among the most common types of intangible assets
the net asset value is deemed to have real value to the buyer.
are patents, trademarks, copyrights, and franchises. Bugs
When this value cannot be allocated to specific assets, it is
Bunny and Donald Duck are prominent examples of intangi
called goodwill or, more descriptively, "purchase price in
ble assets, and are certainly among the author's favorites.
excess of net assets of companies acquired."
The rights to a book, a song, or a movie script are considered
74 Chapter 9/Intangible Assets and Amortization Amortization of Motion Picture Film Costs 75
What is common to all of these examples of intangible assets may be acquired for the film do not have a useful life
assets is that there is something that you just can't get your beyond the period during which the film is produced. The
hands on that nevertheless may generate huge amounts of film may take years to complete and, in any case, can only
revenue. If this asset has a finite life, its cost to the company be expected to generate a small portion of its theatrical
should be amortized over that life if it is shown on the revenues during the accounting period in which it is com
Balance Sheet. pleted. Much of its theatrical (box office) revenue and virtu
It should be noted that some companies maintain that ally all of its home video, foreign, cable, and television
certain intangible assets maintain their value indefinitely revenues can be expected to be earned in subsequent pe
and therefore choose not to amortize them. Whether that riods.
position is supportable is a matter of management judgment, It therefore makes no sense to expense these costs as
auditor review, and the scrutiny of the financial community they are incurred. To do so would result in enormous costs
(soon to include you). and no revenues during production and revenues without
Intangible assets are created in many other instances in any matching costs in subsequent periods. These costs are
which companies spend material sums of money that are therefore accumulated as an asset called unamortized film
expected to generate substantial revenues in future reporting costs until the film is released and begins to generate rev
periods. These might include expenditures for advertising enues.
or research and development. We will look at two examples Now things get tricky. The costs will be amortized over
that are prevalent in their respective industries: unamortized the period of revenue receipt through a noncash charge
film costs in the entertainment business and premium acqui called amortization offilm costs. If you thought there were
sition costs in the insurance business. problems in estimating the useful life of a depreciable asset,
think about how you would go about estimating the useful
life of a movie that is just being released for theatrical distri
AMORTIZATION OF MOTION PICTURE bution. Also, given an estimate of its useful life, which
FILM COSTS is the period during which it can be expected to generate
meaningful revenue, how much of the cost would you allo
The costs of producing a major motion picture consist cate to each period?
largely of payments for the services of actors, directors, While we know that most of the revenues will be gener
and technicians who work on the film. Additional expenses ated during the earliest periods of release, a formula such
include payments to acquire intellectual property such as as the one used for accelerated depreciation will not do.
the screen-rights to a best-selling novel or a screenplay. The timing of revenue receipts is too erratic and unpredict
Wardrobes, props, equipment and facility rentals, transpor able. So the film industry has come up with what is called
tation costs, and a host of other costs also make up the cost the individual film forecast method of allocating the costs
of the film. of the film.
These costs do not result in the acquisition of property It works like this. For each film the company estimates
or equipment subject to depreciation. Most of what real the total revenues it will generate as well as the timing and
76 Chapter 9/Intangible Assets and Amortization
Insurance Companies and Policy Acquisition Costs 77
source of these revenues. Based on all available information
INSURANCE COMPANIES AND POLICY
relative to how well the film will be received, the company
ACQUISITION COSTS
projects the level of box office revenues. Based on the per
formance of similar types of movies, it then projects the
Compared to Hollywood's problems, the insurance indus
timing of these receipts. It then does the same for home
try's policy acquisition costs treatment seems trivial. Policy
video, foreign, cable, and television.
acquisition costs is the industry's name for the costs of
The result is a pattern of revenue receipt against which
selling insurance policies. Why not just treat them as an
the amortization of costs can be matched. If 50 percent of
expense in the period during which they are incurred? The
total revenues are expected to be received in the first year
industry has developed statistics that show that a certain
of release, then 50 percent of costs will be written off in
percentage of policies will be renewed in subsequent periods
the first year. Costs are then allocated to each subsequent
with little or no additional cost or effort on their part. An
year in proportion to the revenues expected to be re
analogy can be made to magazine subscriptions, for which
ceived in those years. It is fairly common for about 80 per
a certain portion of the cost of selling the subscription may
cent of the film's cost to be written off in the first three
be allocated to projected renewals in future periods.
years.
The costs of paying insurance salespersons and direct
Sound a little crazy? Carrying this estimating stuff too mail or newspaper advertising is therefore seen as an asset
far? Well, how else would you do it? Film companies are that will generate future revenues. These costs must be
pretty good at determining how well a certain type of film amortized over the period during which they are expected
will do in foreign markets versus domestic, how much its to generate the related premiums as amortization of policy
theatrical revenues will decline from the first week of its acquisition costs.
release during each subsequent week, and what this kind While a film company's unamortized film costs can repre
of film can be expected to do in the home video, cable, and sent a large amount relative to its total assets, that should
TV markets relative to its domestic box office. All of this not normally be the case for an insurance company's policy
is based on patterns experienced with other films, perhaps acquisition costs. That is because a larger portion of a
tempered by a bit of judgment.
film company's total assets is the cost of making films,
The hard part is figuring out the amount of total revenues while insurance companies' liquid assets for servicing its
to be allocated. Who really knows how successful a film clients and paying claims should be far more substantial in
will be until it is released? A bit of limited testing through relation to marketing costs that it feels will benefit future
select audience responses may provide a clue, but it is periods.
also important to make the appropriate adjustments to the Continental Corporation and Primerica, for example, re
forecast following the first few days of domestic box of
ported deferred policy acquisition costs in 1992 equal to 3.6
fice release. Fortunately, for financial reporting pur percent and 25.8 percent of assets employed in insurance
poses, the adjustments can be made any time between
operations respectively. Generally insurance companies'
the release of the film and the end of the accounting pe
deferred policy acquisition costs fall somewhere within this
riod.
range. A filmed entertainment company, on the other hand,
78 Chapter 9/Intangible Assets and Amortization
might have unamortized film costs easily in excess of 60 Chapter Ten
percent of total assets employed in its film business.
As an emerging financial analyst, beware of unamortized
costs that seem way out of proportion to revenues being Service Companies
generated. It may be that the company is reluctant to recog
nize that its expenditures are not generating the expected
revenues because it doesn't want to have to take a charge
to current income.
Service companies have been assuming an increasingly im
portant role in our economy. Their accounting practices can
be more varied and innovative than those of product- or
merchandise-oriented companies, reflecting the diverse na
ture of their operations. They generate revenues by provid
ing services instead of selling products and as a result show
neither inventory nor costs of goods sold on their financial
statements. Instead of costs of goods sold, service compa
nies simply show the costs of services provided. The major
difference is that this presentation does not involve adjusting
for beginning and ending inventory.
There may, however, be differences in timing between
when the cost of providing a service is incurred and when
revenue for the service can be recognized. These differences
can be reconciled by capitalizing costs as assets on the
Balance Sheet and amortizing them over future periods, as
in the case of the policy acquisition costs of our insurance
company.
Exhibit 10-1 contains the financial statements of Bell-
South, a regional telephone operating company expanding
into global telecommunications, which not only provides an
example of how such statements might differ from those of
a production or distribution company but also provides an
excellent example of a company's efforts to simplify and
explain its statements for the reader.
Examples of service companies include public utilities,
financial service companies, laundries, airlines, data pro-
 Service Companies 81
80 Chapter 10/Service Companies
EXHIBIT 10-1 (continued)
EXHIBIT 10-1
TT\ Comleiu*d CoRulIdated
BALANCE SHEETS
"T Condensed Comdliitted Stitttntots of
Income
BellSouth Corporation
BellSouth Corporation
The balance sheet is considered e "snapshot" of the company's financial position el the
These statements era a summary of the company's operating performance for specific end at the yeer. Assets ere economic resources that ere expected to benefit future busi
annual periods. They show revenues and expensas that rasutt in net income. Revenues ness activities. Lisbiiities ere claims against those assets, or money that BellSouth owes.
are from the sale of services and products to BellSouth customer*. Operating expenses
include costs of services and products: depreciation: and setting, general and adminis
trative expenses. Taxes also are a major expanse category
December 31,
For the yean ended December 31, 1992 1991
1992 1991 1990
Thm rmnutt > Assets:
rtlittd U eonrwttinj Operating revenues: Cwtstate- Current assets t 3,671.0 } 3.637.5
long distant a cata
Network and related services Among tti aisata
.Property, plant and equipment, net 24^72.6 24.058.5
aeronaut* Inaa wtwsa amounts arc
Local service $ 6,236.0 f 5,846.2 I 5,664.6 Investments and advances, intangible assets,
hx our emwnara, includad hart aro
Maawred in rmnutii, Interstate access 2,945.6 2.856.1 2,841.9 caah, rectrvaWai and deferred charges and other assets 3,519.1 3.245.7
thr wit tha quivt- 866.7 911.8
Intrastate access 871.8 (ntt of thoao atti-
tont of noartf ZS3 ytirt
Total assets $31,462.7 $30,941.7
1.373.7 1,565.4 matad to b* un-
Toll 1,248.8
wonhofthtMcaRt totottiMo) and
Directory advertising and publishing 1,459.8 1,426.3 1,394.2 Wlrtta* mataritb and Liabilities and Shareholders' Equity:
Tha amount of dtW
Wireless communications ; 1,195.6 774.5 557.3 auppGaa. Current liabilities $ 5,022.2 $ 4,911.2 mituring atlai on*
Wortdwidl rtvtnuci
Other services : 1,244.0 1,300.0 1.410.2
from ctButir and Long-term debt 7.359.7 7,676.9
'Total operating revenues S 15,201.6 $14,445.5 $14,345.4 paging incrmtd Deferred credits and other liabilities 5,282.2 5.248.7
mWion in 1JS2. Tha
h*lpd BtBSooOi'i
- mor* than 5* partanl Shareholder)'equity 13,798.6 13.104.9
112,040.9 II 1.605.8 $11,318.7 evaral dttn nbo
Operating expenses in IfSZ * BtRSouth
tuipiutdth* In* Total liabilities and shareholders' equity $31,462.7 $30,941.7 impiova lo 31.0 pat'
i-Tcal Operating income 3.160.7 2,809.7 3,026.7 ctmin tS9Ifrom
ten mark in ctBulai
operating (avtnuos Interest expense 746.4 802.1 774.3 41J parcam Bit
phono custoinon,
rtichod t racord yaar bafort.
Other income, net -...177.6 252.7 156.8
in UK. outtding
tiS baton forth* Income before income taxes,
Brit dm*. extraordinary loss and >ol-Tha
cumulative effect of change majorltr 0* BrtSoothi
total iiMts tiitwi-
in method of accounting 2,591.9 2.260.3 2.409.2 '
caBy it rapraaamad
Provision for income taxes 933.5 753.4 777.7 Opttatmg bcoflM byttM'fUadattau*
Income before extraordinary bcreaud 1U ftt- That maka up and
cam In ItSZ at miinuin tha talocom-
loss and cumulative effect of
rtauK o( nvanuta municationi infra-
change in method of accounting 1.658.4 1,506.9 1,631.5 growing at a faitar IWVCttHI, With it
Extraordinary loss, net of tax (40.7) fata. S.I port ant nbat optic caMa.
than axpanaaa.
Cumulative effect of change in iwitehaaana'
wNch ineraatad etfluUr tnwafi.
method of accounting, net of tax (35.4)
ISparctnt
Net income-. t 1,617.7 t 1.471.5 S 1.631.5
Somatkna* calad 'nat
worth'o>'book valua."
In* -
thii numbar aquatt
Tta ono-tim* chirg* Thi bottom Sot"
matt minui liabtttiat,
rttultid from refinanc incraasad I.I ptrcaitt
and rapratana our
ing DM minion m bond*, in 1390. rebounding
tharahoUare' ownar-
which wtf uvi naarty from J ptrttnt
itdp in BalSouth.
1400 mitSon in intaratt datfn* In ttm
IXIMnM 0Vt( ttll livtt prior vtar.
ofthantwdabtiuuai.
 82 Chapter 10/Service Companies Financial Services Companies
83
EXHIBIT 10-1 (concluded) cessing companies, cable television providers, travel agents,
law firms, accounting offices, advertising agencies, hospi
Cash flows
>i Candemtd Consolidated Stattratds of
tals, hotels, and a host of others that we encounter regularly
in our daily lives but are too numerous to mention.
BellSouth Corporation
These statements reconcile the changes in "cash and cash equivalents" from the end
of one year to the end ot the following year. Cash and cash equivalents is included in
Current Assets on the Balance Sheets (page 29).
FINANCIAL SERVICES COMPANIES
The financial statements of service companies not only differ
For the yean ended December 31,
1992 1991 1990
from those of companies that manufacture and sell products,
Net income I 1,617.7 t 1,471.5 S 1,631.5 but they also differ considerably among one another de
priori*
'Adjustments to net Income,
primarily depreciation 3,470.1 2.985.9 3.014.8
pending on the type of service provided and the operating
A portion of thi origi
Changes in operating characteristics of the industry. Financial services compa
(141.0) (675) (119.8)
nal COSt Of MMtl Alt
win Im in um lot iev-

assets and liabilibes

nies, for example, generally show large amounts of dollar-
Cash provided by )"
trtl ytcri. weh it
operating activities 4,946.8 4,389.9 4.526.5
Thn figuro it ihown
inptrtmfttiM
denominated loans and investments on their Balance Sheets
Cash used for investing activities : (3,591.8) (3,776.4) (3,054.8)
iichHgtdnoptnt-
ing txpvflits tvtry : Cash used for financing activities (1,416.8) (576.8) (1.473.8)
b<ciusi ihtii ictiv
citi ripfntnt ctth
and relatively little owners' equity. Less equity is thought
Y*tru dtpracUtion
Increase (decrease) in
BtiSouth tp*ni to
invtfl in ititu.
to be needed due to the certainty with which they can value
: cash and cash equivalents (61.8) 36.7 (2.1)
Suttmtnu of
incanM, pigt 2tl. : Beginning cash and
Cipiul cxptflditttH
te modamin ttM
their assets and their confidence in their ability to realize
Bkiuh dtpcicit-
bonisinon-ciri
; cash equivalents 327.3 290.6 292.7
wvpnon# nitwwi
rt th Itrgltt iURl
these values.
I Ending cash and cash equivalents I 265.5 1 327.3 290.6
txpvnst, it a itcog-
niirt ti poiiovt
in this cingory.
Various types of financial service companies, however,
dtuxm#nt to ntt
have their own particular structures. Banks, for example,
have traditionally taken in deposits and have used these
deposits to finance their extension of loans. Their assets
therefore largely consist of loans and their liabilities largely
of deposits. Historically, most of their income has come
from interest earned, and most of their expense has been
interest paid. Owners' equity may be only around 6 percent
of assets, since most assets have a fixed dollar value and
are considered highly prudent and therefore collectible.
* R|VCb| BCOVflict The banking industry is currently undergoing change, and
Cain dividindi paid to
iharthoMtn {Mirty banks1 financial statements are beginning to reflect both
ji.lWttoninl832)*(i
ncludtd in this lini ! more diversity and more equity. This trend has been driven
iirttolciih.
largely by competition among financial service companies
to make greater inroads into what were once traditionally
separate markets of one or the other type of institution. To
the extent that this trend continues, the banks' financial
84 Chapter I O/Service Companies People-Intensive Service Companies 85
statements will continue to change to reflect their new lines equipment. Among the industries fitting this description
of business and new perceptions of risk. would be public utilities, airlines and other transportation
The assets of insurance companies largely reflect the vari companies, cable television companies, data processing
ous investments they feel will generate the income and offer companies, hospitals, and hotels. The Balance Sheets of
the liquidity they will need to fund policy claims. These these types of companies reflect their heavy investment in
objectives generally call for a heavy emphasis on marketable the property and equipment that generates their revenues.
securities consisting of notes and bonds of various maturities They therefore reflect substantial noncurrent assets and usu
as well as common and preferred stocks, but insurance com ally heavy debt or lease obligations with which these assets
panies may also invest to a lesser extent in real estate.. were financed. Some, such as public utilities, may reflect
The liabilities of insurance companies are heavily surprisingly little liquidity, since they are by and large cash
weighted by the various reserves and liabilities for the pay (as opposed to credit) businesses and their predictable cash
ment of claims that have been made or that statistics suggest flow from operations provides the liquidity they need.
will be made at some future time. Revenues are derived The expenses of capital-intensive companies can be ex
from policy premiums earned and from investments. Ex pected to reflect the heavy depreciation of their substantial
penses are mostly actual and projected policy claims. noncurrent assets. Profitability may be fairly steady, as in
Securities brokerage firms have a great deal of their the case of utilities, or cyclical (i.e., erratic), as in the case
assets, as one might expect, in securities. These may be held of airlines.
for their own account, in which case they are investment
securities, or for meeting the demands of customers, in
which case they are trading securities. Funds due from other PEOPLE-INTENSIVE
brokers and from clients are also significant. Liabilities may SERVICE COMPANIES
consist of various short-term financing arrangements used
to carry the securities held as assets as well as funds due A third type of service company, which can be expected to
to brokers and clients. Revenues consist of commissions show still different financial characteristics, provides profes
on securities trades, perhaps fees from investment banking sional services in a manner that is people intensive. Exam
activities, and any profits from trading securities for the ples include law firms, accounting service providers, ad
firm's own account. Commissions paid to brokers are a agencies, architectural service companies, employment and
rather large expense for securities firms. temporary help agencies, and management consulting firms.
These are the companies whose assets "walk out the door
every night."
CAPITAL-INTENSIVE Since these walking assets generate revenues, however,
SERVICE COMPANIES the Balance Sheets of their companies largely reflect the
accounts receivable they generate. The receivables are espe
Another category of services companies might best be de cially prominent because of the lack of any inventory or
scribed as capital intensive, which is to say that revenues significant amount of noncurrent assets such as plant and
are largely derived from the use of property, plant, and equipment.
86 Chapter 10/Service Companies
The greatest expense of the people companies is, of Chapter Eleven
course, their payroll. They usually have a modest amount
of debt since their lack of inventory and heavy equipment
eliminates both the need and the collateral to borrow. What Are the Rules
Service companies represent the fastest-growing segment
of the economy. In terms of accounting and reporting, they that Preparers of
seem to offer more variety and more challenges than the
traditional manufacturing, wholesale, or retail companies. Financial Statements
But then even tradition isn't what it used to be.
Must Play By?
You probably think of financial statement preparers as a
bunch of wild and crazy guys who can do whatever they
want with the numbers. That's not correct. A lot of them
are women, and they are subject to an elaborate set of rules
that have been developed and refined over the years to
assure that the reader of statements receives a "fair presen
tation." These rules are called Generally Accepted Ac
counting Principles (GAAP).
GAAP AND GAAS
Any financial statement intended for the use of anyone other
than the management of the company should be prepared
in conformity with GAAP. In addition, the independent out
side accountants who audit the statements are required to
do so in accordance with Generally Accepted Auditing Stan
dards (GAAS).
The principal requirements for a fair presentation of fi
nancial information are that they comply with GAAP and
GAAS, that they disclose all information necessary for the
88 Chapter 11 /Rules that Preparers of Financial Statements Must Play By
Disclosures 89
reader to fully understand the financial statements, and that
DISCLOSURES
the auditors express an opinion regarding the financial pre
sentation. The disclosures contained in the footnotes to the financial
The first rule is therefore that the preparer and the auditors statements are helpful in understanding a company's ac
follow the rules. The second, the disclosure requirement, counting practices. These footnotes are usually so instruc
is fulfilled by means of footnotes to the statements, which tive that many financial analysts prefer to read them before
generally follow the full set of reports. The opinion of the they read the statements themselves.
auditors (outside accountants) is contained in an opinion Some of the disclosures commonly found in footnotes to
letter, which used to precede the financial statements but the financial statements might appear as follows:
now often follows the statements and the footnotes.
Accounting and reporting standards outlined under
GAAP generally establish specific criteria for critical re General
porting issues such as when revenue can be recognized
Outlines the nature of the business or businesses in which
(recorded) for financial reporting purposes. Among different
the company is engaged and the operating characteristics
industries there may be different criteria for the recognition
of these businesses. This brief description is important be
of revenue, as the operating characteristics of an industry
cause it is difficult to understand a company's accounting
may determine what is feasible or reasonable for that in
practices and financial results without understanding the
dustry.
nature of its operations.
Within each industry or group of industries with similar
operating characteristics, however, revenue recognition is
determined according to the same criteria. It is standard Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
practice, for example, for manufacturing and distribution
Principles of consolidation. What wholly or par
companies to recognize revenue upon shipment and invoic
tially owned companies are included in the statements, and
ing (billing) the customer. Shipping and billing should there what accounting guidelines have been followed for their
fore occur simultaneously.
inclusion? This is an area where GAAP provides fairly spe
Without a common standard, companies might record cific guidelines for subsidiaries (companies where ownership
revenues based on the receipt of orders, the shipment of is substantial enough for the subject company to exercise
merchandise, or the receipt of payment. Reported results control), which ought to be consolidated. Consolidated sub
would simply not be comparable for companies using such sidiaries are those whose financial data are mixed in with the
dissimilar techniques.
data for the subject, or parent, company instead of showing
In some of the areas we have previously discussed there ownership as a separate net asset and the subsidiary's net
is not a single practice but a range of acceptable practices for profit or loss as a separate Income Statement item.
reporting financial information. In these cases, the financial
preparer should select one of the acceptable alternatives Revenue recognition. As previously stated, reve
and disclose to the reader which of the alternatives has been nue recognition criteria are well prescribed for various types
selected.
of companies. However, for companies in industries for
90 Chapter 11/Rules that Preparers of Financial Statements Must Play By Disclosures 91
which the prescribed methods may not be commonly known of government, government agencies, and high-quality cor
or that have unique revenue recognition problems, it is a porations. These are called cash equivalents on the financial
good idea to offer a description of the standards followed statement if they meet certain criteria for easy conversion
by the company in order to facilitate an understanding of into cash when cash is needed. These criteria are defined
the statements. in this section of the footnotes.
Treatment of "excess of purchase price over net assets Warranties or any other unusual terms of sale. It is
of business acquired." This is where the treatment of what important to disclose whether there are any unusual obliga
is commonly referred to as goodwill is discussed. Whether tions arising from the sale of the company's products or
it is being amortized and, if so, over what period of time is services. Warranties may give rise to significant but unpre
disclosed here. dictable future expenses or even lead to the cancellation of
sales or contracts.
Property and equipment. Breaks down property
and equipment into specific categories. Shows the useful
Description of Credit Facilities
lives and methods of depreciation for each category as well
as its accumulated depreciation and net asset value. - What agreements has the company negotiated with its lend
ers? (How much can it borrow and on what terms?)
Inventory. Tells what method of inventory valua
tion has been selected (FIFO, LIFO, or average cost). Also
Description of Terms and Funding of
may break down components of inventory into raw materi
Employee Benefit and Retirement Plans
als, work in process, and finished goods. The significance
of this breakdown will be discussed in Chapter Twelve. Describes who is eligible for benefits, current costs to the
company for benefits provided, estimated future costs of
Research and development costs. Tells whether or providing benefits, and amount of funding provided to meet
under what circumstances research and development ex future costs. This section has recently attracted consider
penses are capitalized as assets to benefit future periods or able interest as many companies, under new GAAP rules,
charged as expenses of the current period. This is one of have taken heavy charges against current income to provide
the important areas allowing some management discretion. for deficiencies in funding for future benefits.
Other things being equal, it is more conservative (offers a
less favorable financial picture relative to what is actually
Reconciliation of Income Tax Expenses
happening) to expense R&D even though it may well benefit
(Provision for Income Taxes) to Statutory
future periods. Who's to know?
Federal and State Tax Rates
Definition of cash equivalents. Instead of carrying a If there are timing differences created by the use of one
lot of cash in checking accounts that don't earn any interest, form of accounting for income tax filing and another for
most companies invest in the short-term debt instruments financial reporting, or if there are tax credits that reduce its
92 Chapter 11/Rules that Preparers of Financial Statements Must Play By Disclosures 93
income taxes, the company shows what effects these items more or less favorable at the expense of or to the benefit
have on reported income taxes, on actual amounts due or of another company or party.
paid, and on those that would have been required under the
prevailing tax rates had not all of the other nonsense taken
place. Major Customers and!or Suppliers
Discloses whether there are any customers or suppliers
Long-Term Debt Maturities which constitute such an unusually large portion of the com
pany's business that the company may be highly vulnerable
This disclosure shows how much of long-term debt must be to a loss of such customers or suppliers. Gives the percent
paid in each of the next five years and how much thereafter. of sales to or purchases from these parties but not necessar
This is useful in determining future cash flow and financing ily their names.
needs. Future lease payment obligations are also disclosed,
but probably under a separate section.
Industry Segment Information
Property and Casualty Insurance Shows the amount of sales by product line and sometimes
by geographic area. The latter is usually important when a
Discloses whether the company has sufficient insurance to
lot of the sales are to foreign countries and may be affected
protect it against the types of risks it may face and whether
by the volatility of exchange markets or their local political
its coverage meets normal and customary requirements for
developments.
its industry.
Transactions with Insiders or Related Entities Current Cost or Replacement Value of
Nonmonetary Assets
Discloses the nature and terms of any business transactions
with management or directors of the companies or entities Discloses the current cost or replacement value of assets
that are owned or controlled by members of management that are nonmonetary and are thus by their very nature
not already stated at current cost values. Monetary assets
or directors of the company. Also any transactions with
include cash, accounts receivable, and marketable securi
companies in which the subject company has an ownership
ties. Nonmonetary assets include inventory, property,
interest. Transactions might include sales to, purchases
plant, equipment, and intangibles. The latter are valued
from, or loans to or from these parties or entities. These
at historical cost on the financial statements, and there
disclosures should be accompanied by a statement to the
fore their current cost, or the cost of replacing them at
effect that the transactions were on terms no more or less
current prices, is not reflected. Many companies find it
favorable than those available through unrelated parties or
useful to disclose current replacement costs in their foot
entities. Otherwise these transactions could impair or distort
financial results by making one company temporarily look notes.
94 Chapter 11/Rules that Preparers of Financial Statements Must Play By Opinion Letters 95
Contingent Liabilities OPINION LETTERS
Discloses current developments that may give rise to future
obligations on the part of the company. The most prominent The final item, which is an integral part of the financial
of these are usually pending lawsuits or regulatory actions.
statements, is the outside auditor's opinion letter. (When it
Where possible, an assessment of the future outcome and is stated that something is "an integral part" of the financial
its impact on the company should be included. In practice, statements, it means that you can't take the statements
seriously without it.)
however, the company will always say that it doesn't have
any idea what the outcome will be or that it expects to The opinion letter for an audited statement should state
prevail and/or doesn't think that the whole thing amounts
that the audit has been performed in accordance with Gener
to a hill of beans. Were it to feel otherwise, it would have ally Accepted Auditing Standards and that the statements
had to establish an estimated liability or reserve on its bal were prepared in conformity with Generally Accepted Ac
ance sheet with a corresponding charge against its current
counting Principles or that they fairly present the financial
position, operating results, and cash flow of the company.
income.
The opinion letter will also tell whether in fact the financial
statements have been audited at all. Not all financial state
Events Subsequent to the Date of the
ments are audited. In fact, most are not. If you're not a
Financial Report
banker or a credit manager, however, you're probably used
Discloses any material developments that occur after the to seeing only the financial statements of large, publicly
rest of the report has been written, with presumably enough owned companies. These have to be audited.
information so that the reader might form an opinion In addition to audited statements, there are reviewed
as to how they might affect the company's financial perfor statements and compiled statements, also known as reviews
mance. For example, 'The Company's factory blew up and compilations. Anything other than these three is not
on March 3 ..." given any official status under GAAP and is therefore unfit
Many other kinds of disclosures may appear in the foot for human consumption. Such maverick statements can con
notes to companies' financial statements, but the preceding form to whatever rules or lack of rules the preparer wants
are among the most common. them to and should only be used for internal company pur
A particularly memorable example of a disclosure that poses or by hooligans who don't give a hoot about GAAP
comes to mind was a high-tech medical device manufactur and all it stands for.
er's revelation that it didn't carry product liability insurance The difference between the three legitimate types of state
because such insurance would have been prohibitively ex ments is in the level of assurance that each provides, or, in
pensive. Whatever the expense, it would be useful for a other words, how comfortable you ought to be with the
user of the statement to charge that amount against income notion that the company is what it purports to be. Examples
in his own analysis to approximate the cost of not having of opinion letters for each of the three are shown in Exhibit
the insurance. Risk tolerance or aversion was also an issue. 11-1.
(The company's bankers were not happy with the dis Audited statements offer the highest level of assurance.
closure.) They must be audited by independent accountants, so you
EXHIBIT 11-1
Opinion Letters 97
AUDIT
REVIEW
Report of Independent Public Accountants
We have reviewed the accompanying balance sheet of Diver
To the Stockholders and Board of Directors of Diversified
sified Consolidated Corp., the related statement of earnings,
Consolidated Corp.
and the related statement of changes in financial position
for the year ended December 31, 1989, in accordance with
We have audited the accompanying consolidated balance
standards established by the American Institute of Certified
sheets of Diversified Consolidated Corp. and subsidiaries as
Public Accountants. All information included in these finan
of December 31,1992 and 1991, and the related consolidated
cial statements is the representation of the management of
statements of income, retained earnings, and cash flows for
the Company.
each of the three years in the period ended December 31,
A review consists principally of inquiries of company
1992. These financial statements are the responsibility of the
personnel and analytical procedures applied to financial data.
Company's management. Our responsibility is to express an
It is substantially less in scope than an examination in accor
opinion on these financial statements based on our audits.
dance with Generally Accepted Auditing Standards, the ob
We conducted our audits in accordance with Generally
jective of which is the expression of an opinion regarding
Accepted Auditing Standards. Those standards require that
the financial statements taken as a whole. Accordingly, we
we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance
do not express such an opinion.
about whether the financial statements are free of material
Based on our reviews, we are not aware of any material
misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a test basis,
modifications that should be made to the accompanying fi
evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the fi
nancial statements in order for them to be in conformity
nancial statements. An audit also includes assessing the ac
with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles.
counting principles used and significant estimates made by
management, as well as evaluating the overall financial state
ment presentation. We believe that our audits provide a
know, among other things, that the guys vouching for the
reasonable basis for our opinion.
In our opinion, the financial statements referred to above
numbers don't own a piece of the company.1 While the
present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position accountants' ever-increasing and justifiable fear of lawsuits
of Diversified Consolidated Corp. and subsidiaries as of De- has caused them to emphasize of late that the financial state
cember31, 1992 and 1991, and the results of their operations ments are "the responsibility of management," at least at
and their cash flows for each of the three years in the period the audited level the accountants independently verify some
ended December 31, 1992, in conformity with Generally Ac of the things management tells them.
cepted Accounting Principles. The accountants therefore confirm bank balances with
As discussed in the accompanying notes to financial state the bank, accounts receivable balances with customers, and
ments, effective January 1,1992, the Company adopted three accounts payable balances with suppliers. They supervise
new accounting standards promulgated by the Financial Ac
counting Standards Board, changing its methods of account
ing for postretirement benefits other than pensions, income
1 The extent to which their income depends on this company (make that
taxes, and postemployment benefits.
customer) may nevertheless be a matter of concern.
98 Chapter 11/Rules that Preparers of Financial Statements Must Play By Opinion Letters 99
Reviewed financial statements must also be reviewed by
COMPLICATION independent accountants but offer a lower level of assurance
that everything is what it is supposed to be. More emphasis
Board of Directors
is placed on "the responsibility of management." (Transla
tion: "Go sue them.") The accountants really don't have
The accompanying balance sheet of Diversified Consoli
any well-defined responsibility to independently verify any
dated Corp. as at December 31, 1989, and the related op
erating statement for the twelve-month period then ended
thing unless something jumps right out at them and screams
for investigation.
have been compiled by me.
. A compilation is limited to presenting in the form of finan Review-level statements basically mean that the accoun
cial statements information that is the representation of man tants checked the procedures and presentation for confor
agement. I have not audited or reviewed the accompanying mity with GAAP and didn't see anything unusual in the
financial statements and, accordingly, do not express an numbers that would cause them to be suspicious.
opinion or any form of assurance. That's very unfortunate and dangerous because it tells
Management has elected to omit all of the disclosures and us that if everything appears to be normal no special effort
the Statement of Changes in Financial Position required by will be given to verifying management's representations,
Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. If the omitted when in fact it is the unusual occurrences disguised as nor
disclosures, were included in the financial statements, they mal that we ought to fear the most.
might influence the user's conclusion about the Company's
The review-level opinion letter says, in essence, that the
financial position, results of operations, and changes in fi
accountants think that the financial statements are OK be
nancial position. Accordingly, these financial statements are
cause management says so and nothing sticks out that would
not designed for those who are not informed about such
indicate otherwise. The accountants may provide additional
matters.
testing of the numbers, but they don't have to.
A compilation statement offers the lowest level of assur
the annual inventory count. They also determine whether ance and does not need to be prepared by an independent
reasonable methodology was used in arriving at asset values, accountant. However, if the accountant is not independent,
whether the company owns things it says it owns, and, in he is required to disclose that he is not. Presumably it is up
general, whether all accounts and statements have been to the reader of the statement to find out exactly why the
prepared properly. They also test the adequacy of the com accountant cannot be considered independent.
pany's own internal accounting and controls. Compilation statements may or may not contain the foot
The opinion letter for the audited statement says some noted disclosures required by GAAP. If they do not, they
thing to the effect that, ''We're pretty sure these statements must point out that they do not. At its worst, the compilation
are OK, and we've even done some independent checking means that the statements are "the representation of man
to assure us that they are. But if management has done agement" and may well omit so much critical information
anything really sleazy to mislead us, don't hold us responsi as to be totally misleading to anyone who doesn't already
ble for that/' know all about the company. That's pretty much what the
100 Chapter 11/Rules that Preparers of Financial Statements Must Play By
opinion letter for the compilation statement without disclo Chapter Twelve
sures required by GAAP says.
Opinion letters may also be classified as to whether the
opinions are qualified or unqualified. A qualified opinion is Some Basic Tools of
one that is given ''subject to" some irregularity being re
solved in such a way that it doesn't totally decimate the Financial Analysis
company, or at least cause it serious damage. Generally that
means that the company's financial presentation contains a
material departure from GAAP that may distort its perfor
mance or that there is a material risk that cannot be quanti
So far, we have looked at financial statements as a compila
fied but may severely affect the company's financial position
tion of isolated account balances. Sure, we know how to
or performance.
include inventory in the calculation of cost of goods sold
For companies that are really on thin ice, there is a going
and how to subtract these costs and other expenses from
concern qualification that states that asset values reflect
revenue to get net income. We also know what each account
the value to the company as a going concern and may not
represents in the company's overall financial picture.
accurately reflect liquidation value.
The user of financial statements, however, needs more
Needless to say, unqualified opinions are greatly pre
than just a knowledge of the meaning of the principal compo
ferred over qualified opinions.
nents of the statements. He needs to be able to paint a
In spite of the language in opinion letters and an occa
picture of a company's successes and failures, its strengths
sional accounting scandal here or there, the overwhelming
and weaknesses, and whether its future appears to be bright
majority of accountants do an excellent job of assuring that
or cloudy.
the financial statements fairly represent the company's fi
nancial position and performance. The opinion letters are
just worded cautiously so that we don't get too mad at the WHAT DO WE NEED TO KNOW?
accountants if they do screw up.
In order to paint such a picture, we need to understand
relationships between certain key items in the financial state
ments. We need to know how these relationships compare
to other representative companies in the same industry and
how these relationships are changing over time.
HOW FINANCIAL RATIOS CAN HELP
Relationships are analyzed by means of ratios that compare
one account or group of accounts to another at a given point
in time as well as over a period of time. Since most readers
102 Chapter 12/Some Basic Tools of Financial Analysis How Financial Ratios Can Help 103
of this book probably do not intend to become financial EXHIBIT 12-1
analysts, it is not expected that you will regularly calculate Net Worth Comparison
these ratios every time you look at a financial statement. It
Company A Company B
is, however, important that you be aware of what ratios are
critical and for what purpose.
Even if you do not perform the calculations, you should
probably get in the habit of roughly comparing certain ac
counts to others to which they have a special relationship
every time you look at a set of financial statements. In this
way, you will acquire an awareness or sense of what appears
to be reasonable and what appears to be out of line.
Mmsmsmm
To really understand the changes taking place within a Net worth
company, however, you should calculate key ratios and
study their changes over time. This is not difficult to do. In Net worth
this chapter, we discuss various ratios and what they can
tell us about a company.
Let's start with a rather simple example of why ratios Chapter Four, where we observed that too much leverage
are important. As depicted in Exhibit 12-1, Company A limits a company's options in dealing with adversity.
has a net worth, or owners' equity, or $100.0 million, while As an example of how leverage can work against a com
Company B has a net worth of only $10.0 million. Which pany, let's assume that each of our subject companies goes
is the stronger company? through some very tough economic times and suffers a 20.0
You don't know is absolutely the correct answer. Give percent decline in the value of its assets. For this illustration,
yourself an A -f, and consider the following additional infor the decline could have been caused by either operating
mation. Company A has total assets of $600.0 million, while losses that were funded by a reduction in assets or a direct
Company B has assets of only $20.0 million. What's this? write down to reflect a decline in the market value of existing
Something suspicious. Company A has 10 times the net assets. No matter. In either case, there is a reduction in net
worth of Company B but 30 times the amount of assets. worth, caused by the operating losses or the asset revalua
Since the difference between assets and net worth is liabili tion, offset by a reduction in total assets.
ties, Company A has $500.0 million in liabilities against its The difference in the impact on the companies is that 20.0
$600.0 million in assets, while Company B has only $10.0 percent of Company A's $600.0 million is $120.0 million,
million in liabilities against its assets of $20.0 million (see and Company A's entire net worth before the devaluation
Exhibit 12-2). is only $100.0 million. For Company B, on the other hand,
Company A's ratio of total liabilities to net worth is 5.0 20.0 percent of $20.0 million in total assets represents only
to 1.0, while Company B's is only 1.0 to 1.0. Why should $4.0 million compared to its net worth of $10.0 million.
we care? The ratio of total liabilities to net worth is a measure While a 40.0 percent reduction in its net worth is certainly
of a company's leverage. Leverage was discussed briefly in no laughing matter to Company B, Company A has lost all
 Some Useful Ratios and What They Tell Us 105
104 Chapter 12/Some Basic Tools of Financial Analysis
tities of debt well out of proportion to the increases in net
EXHIBIT 12-2
worth generated by its profits.
Liabilities in Relation to Net Worth
It should also be understood that leverage, while com
Company A Company B monly and appropriately associated with risk, is not neces
Net worth sarily bad. For any company, there is an optimal level of
$100 million
leverage that enables it to maximize its profits without undue
Liabilities risk. Otherwise why would any company voluntarily take
Net worth
. $10 million on any debt at all? (Some companies increase their liabilities
$10 million
involuntarily to fund operating losses.)
The whole premise behind the use of debt, or any other
liabilities, is that the company can invest the funds owed
in assets that will generate a higher rate of return (i.e.,
profits) than the cost of borrowing the funds. That's just
Liabilities
$500 million sound business, as it can substantially increase the rate of
return on owners' equity. It is therefore only the excessive
use of debt that subjects the company to undue risk.
While being lightly leveraged may therefore be a safer
course of action, it is not necessarily the most profitable
one. Just as inordinate amounts of leverage were criticized
in the 1980s and early 90s, the failure to use even reasonable
of its net worth and then some. It is, at least theoretically,
levels of leverage to take advantage of profitable opportuni
wiped out.
ties had been criticized in earlier periods.
Some analysts look at the ratio of debt to net worth instead
The whole cycle of underutilization and overutilization
of total liabilities to net worth. That calculation leaves things
of leverage can be expected to repeat itself in future years.
like accrued expenses and accounts payable out of the liabil
Ecclesiastes was probably referring to business cycles when
ity side of the ratio. This writer prefers to include all liabili
he said that there wasn't anything new under the sun.
ties in the calculation, but, in any case, some measure of
leverage is always in order when performing financial
analysis.
Leverage ratios are by no means the only measure of a SOME USEFUL RATIOS AND WHAT
company's financial health or viability, but they are among THEY TELL US
the more important ones. Leverage ratios, moreover, need
To decide what ratios to analyze, we must first decide what
to be observed over a period of time. A company with high
kind of financial information we need to know about a com
leverage may be so immensely profitable that its leverage,
pany. The following is a list of questions we might wish to
while high, is declining rapidly. Another may have lower
resolve and the financial ratios best suited to provide the
leverage but is either suffering losses funded by additions
answers:
to debt or funding growth in a profitable business with quan-
106 Chapter 12/Somc Basic Tools of Financial Analysis Some Useful Ratios and What They Tell Us 107
1. Is the value of the company's assets sufficient to cover days in period. For example, a company has annual sales
claims of creditors against these assets and still provide of $1.0 million and accounts receivable of $200,000. The
adequate equity for the owners'? collection period is: 200,000 -r 1,000,000 x 365 = 73
days.
Leverage ratio: Total liabilities divided by owners'
equity.
5. Is the company carrying the proper amount of inventory
2. Does the company have sufficient liquidity to pay its bills? to support its level of sales?
Quick or liquidity ratio: Total of cash, short-term market
Days inventory supply: Inventory divided by cost of
able securities and accounts receivable divided by current
goods sold for the period times number of days in period.
liabilities (i.e., liabilities that need to be paid within one
For example, the company with $1.0 million in sales has
year).
a cost of goods sold for the year of $700,000 and ending
Current ratio: Total current assets (convertible into cash inventory of $150,000. Its inventory supply is therefore:
within one year) divided by total current liabilities. The 150,000 -h 700,000 x 365 = 78.2 days.
major difference between the current ratio and the quick
Too much inventory increases the likelihood that the in
ratio is that the former includes inventory in current assets
ventory is not selling at the prices expected and will have
on the assumption that it can be sold and the proceeds
to be liquidated at a loss. It is also a drain on the company's
collected within one year.
resources, as increasing inventory is a use of cash.
3. Is the company's cashflow before debt payments suffi
Too little inventory increases the likelihood that the com
cient to cover debt obligations by a reasonable margin?
pany will not be able to meet the demand for its product
Debt coverage ratio: This one is calculated in many differ and will lose customers or potential customers. Securities
ent ways. Let's use the total of net income and noncash analysts worry about this problem more than bankers do,
charges divided by current maturities of long-term debt. as bankers worry far more about downside risk than upside
There are other options that analysts will argue give a potential.
better picture of debt payment capacity. They all argue Theoretically, at the current rate of sales and cost of
vigorously for their own approach, so there may be some goods sold, the company's inventory would last 78.2 days
sour grapes because we didn't choose someone's favorite if it stopped production immediately. That's fine (theoreti
method. Ours is both useful and simple, and, in any case, cally) for a distributor of completed products, but for a
the statement of cash flows gives a complete picture of manufacturer it doesn't take into account the mix among
all sources and uses of cash for those of you who want raw materials, work in process, and finished goods. It can
to play around with it. still be used as a rough estimate for comparative purposes
as long as we understand its limitations.
4. Is the company able to collect its accounts receivable
The mix of inventory can be every bit as important as
promptly? (If we're going to give the receivables credit for
the amount. A company that has a lot of raw materials and
liquidity in the liquid ratio, they ought to be liquid.)
work in process but very little finished product has probably
Accounts receivable collection period: Accounts receiv stepped up production in response to strong demand for its
able divided by sales for the period times the number of product. A company with lots of finished product and very
108 Chapter I2/Some Basic Tools of Financial Analysis
Some Useful Ratios and What They Tell Us 109
little raw materials or work in process may well be stuck
should increase its competitive advantages in future pe
with product it has completed but cannot sell. It may there
riods.
fore have cut back on additional purchases and production.
Various operating expense ratios, defined as operating
6. Are the company's assets producing sufficient income expenses divided by sales, are also most useful. Once a
relative to alternative investment opportunities? company is beyond its start-up stage, operating expenses
should not increase as fast as sales. In an efficient company,
Return on assets (ROA): Net income divided by total
a given level of property and equipment and management
assets. This number, expressed as a percentage, should
at least exceed that which is available through investment expenses (including marketing, research and development,
etc.) should generate increasing levels of sales for some time
in minimal risk alternatives, such as short-term U.S. Trea
sury securities. Otherwise the company is not receiving to come with only slight increases in these expenses relative
an adequate return on its investment in its assets. If, for to sales. Therefore, operating expense ratios should decline
as sales increase.
example, 90-day Treasury bills are yielding 5 percent and
a company's ROA is only 3 percent on more than just a If they consistently fail to do so, that means that the
temporary basis, the company would be better off in company is spending increasing amounts on operating ex
vesting in Treasury bills than operating its business. penses just to maintain a given level of sales. It is then
useful to isolate those specific categories of expenditures
7. Is the company generating sufficient income to be a
that are rising faster than sales.
worthwhile investment for its owners?
If, for example, research and development as a percent
Return on equity (ROE): Net income divided by owners' of sales is rising, that means that the company is having to
(shareholders') equity. This number, also expressed as a spend increasing amounts on research and development just
percentage, should be well in excess of the risk-free rate to stay even with its competition. If marketing is the culprit,
of return available on alternative investments to reward the company is spending too much on its sales efforts in
investors for taking the risk of investing for a profit that relation to the result they are producing. These trends are
is not assured. In the example under question 6 above, meaningful, however, only when analyzed over a period of
this return should probably be in excess of 8 per years, as operating expenses and the revenues they generate
centhopefully well in excess. Like all other financial may be erratic from one period to another.
ratios, however, the ROE would be used to measure this The foregoing analytical tools should provide a good start
company relative to its peers. without burying the reader in ratios. To get a feel for some
actual financial ratios, refer to excerpts from Robert Morris
There are many other ratios that are widely inspected
Associates Annual Statement Studies 1992 in the Appendix
with varying degrees of usefulness. As we have seen, the
at the end of this book. RMA publishes a compilation of
gross profit margin (gross profit divided by sales) measures
ratios for various industries with averages as well as 25-
the contribution the company's product makes toward all
and 75-percentile levels for each ratio for each industry. We
other expenses and to net profits. The greater the gross
have reproduced the data for Manufacturers of Electronic
profit margin, the more the company is able to spend in
Components and for Advertising Agencies as examples for
areas like marketing or research and development, which
a manufacturing and a service company.
110 Chapter 12/Some Basic Tools of Financial Analysis
There are also clear limitations to the effectiveness of
Chapter Thirteen
these ratios under different scenarios, but the best way to
understand them is to use them in an analysis of a sample
company. We can assess their usefulness and their limita Application of Financial
tions in describing what is happening to The Easy Company
in Chapter Thirteen. Ratios to Analysis of
the Growth of The
Easy Company
Let's go back to The Easy Company, our manufacturer of
user-friendly toothpicks through which we illustrated the
fundamentals of financial statements in Chapters Four
through Six. The Easy Company has been highly profitable
and is in excellent financial condition as evidenced by the
ratios for 1992 shown in the first column of Exhibit 13-1.
The company has very little leverage and far more than
adequate liquidity to meet its current obligations. Its income
and noncash charges, moreover, cover its current maturities
of long-term debt ($200,000 per year) by a margin of 4.0 to
1.0 (see Exhibit 13-2).
The only areas of weakness for The Easy Company are
its accounts receivable collection period, which at 91 days
is a bit slow, and its inventory supply, which at 120 days
is somewhat excessive.
The Easy Company can afford to be a little lax, given its
strong condition, and doesn't like to hassle its customers for
quick payment on its receivables. It is generally regarded, in
this and other respects, as being "easy" to do business
with. It also likes to carry plenty of inventory so that it
knows it can always be viewed as a dependable supplier.
EXHIBIT 13-1
The Easy Company Financial Highlights
1993 1994 1995 1996 1997
1992

$12,000,000 $15,000,000 $16,000,000 $14,000,000 $10,000,000

Sales $10,000,000
Cost of goods
8i400,000 11,100,000 12,000,000 10,500,000 8,000,000
sold 7,000,000
Gross margin
3,600,000 (30%) 3,900,000(26%) 4,000,000 (25%) 3,500,000 (25%) 2,000,000 (26%)
(%) 3,000,000 (30%)
Operating
expenses
3,000,000 (25%) 3,000,000 (20%) 3,200,000 (20%) 3,220,000 (23%) 3,000,000 (30%)
(%) 2,000,000 (20%)
Income before
600,000 900,000 800,000 280,000 (1,000,000)
taxes 1,000,000
240,000 360,000 320,000 112,000 (400,000)
Taxes (40%) 400,000
360,000 540,000 480,000 168,000 (600,000)
Net income 600,000
280,000 350,000 400,000 460,000 540,000
Depreciation 200,000
Cash flow for
debt
$640,000 $890,000 $880,000 $628,000 $(60,000)
maturities $ 800,000

Cash $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 $500,000

$ 900,000
Marketable
1,000,000 1,000,000 500,000 500,000 500,000
securities 1,000,000
Accounts
3,452,000 5,137,000 6,575,300 6,520,500 4,794,500
receivable 2,500,000
Inventory 2,991,800 4,561,600 5,260,300 5,178,100 4,383,600
2,300,000
Prepaid
100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000
expenses 100,000

Total current
8,043,800 11,298,600 12,935,600 12,798,600 10,278,100
assets 6,800,000
Investment in
200,000 200,000 200,000 200,000 200,000
affiliate 200,000
Property,
plant, and
3,500,000 4,000,000 4,600,000 5,400,000 5,400,000
equipment 2,800,000
$11,743,800 $15,498,600 $17,735,600 $18,398,600 $15,878,100
Total assets $10,000,000

Current
$3,283,800 $6,498,600 $8,255,600 $8,750,000 $6,830,100
liabilities $ 1,900,000
Long-term
1,800,000 1,800,000 1,800,000 1,800,000 1,800,000
debt 1,800,000
5,083,800 8,298,600 10,055,600 10,550,000 8,630,100
Total liabilities 3,700,000
6,660,000 7,200,000 7,680,000 7,848,000 7,248,000
Owners' equity 6,300,000
Total liability
$11,743,800 $15,498,600 $17,735,600 $18,398,600 $15,878,100
and equity $10,000,000

.8 1.2 1.3 1. 3 1.2

Leverage ratio .6
1.5 1.0 .9 9 .8
Liquid ratio 2.4
2.4 1.7 1.6 1. 5 1.5
Current ratio 3.6
Debt service
A ft 3.2 4.5 4.4 3. 1 NA
coverage 4.0

Account
receivables
collection
105 125 150 170 175
period 91
Inventory
130 150 160 180 200
supply 120

i! !'
114 Chapter 13/Application of Financial Ratios Strategy and Analysis
115
EXHIBIT 13-2 STRATEGY AND ANALYSIS
The Easy Company Financial Ratios
The Easy Company, however, is a bit uneasy about its lack
of diversification. It therefore decides to come out with a
Liquidity ratio Current ratio
new line of designer toothpicks, which it is convinced will
sell like hotcakes. (The company had previously rejected a
proposal to diversify into hotcakes as being too risky.)
Easy decides to facilitate the production and sale of its
new line through massive investments in new plant and
equipment to provide generous amounts of inventory and
by assuring its customers it will continue not to hassle them
for payment until they are convinced the new product is a
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 winner. The results in Exhibit 13-1 reflect these policies.
Sales are in line with expectations for the first three years,
although growth did weaken a bit in 1995. The fourth and
Leverage ratio Q Debt service coverage
fifth years, however, are clearly disappointing. Designer
toothpicks ultimately prove to be a fad for happy-go-lucky
yuppies, and an austere economic climate causes customers
to cut back on their purchases of luxury goods like designer
toothpicks.
Easy's gross margins, its gross profit as a percent of sales,
declined over four of the h\& years as higher production
costs of designer toothpicks exceeded any benefit the com
pany could achieve through premium pricing. Prices were
1994 1995 1996 1997
cut sharply in 1997 as an effort to stimulate lagging sales.
1992 1993
Operating expenses increased in 1993 as the company geared
up for its new product launch. The company was not very
P^| Inventory supply |A/R collection period 1
successful in cutting these expenses when sales declined.
The Easy Company slowly and reluctantly cut back on
1992
- production when sales began to decline, as they didn't
1993
"want to look like a bunch of losers." While inventory
-
1994 eventually declined, inventory supply increased, as sales
-
(at cost) showed a larger percentage decline than inventory.
1995
- Customers, who were skeptical of the product from the
1996
beginning and were therefore slow to pay the receivables,
1997 became irritated at being "hassled for payment" when their
i
50 100 150 200
Number of days
116 Chapter I3/Application of Financial Ratios Profitability and Asset Management 117
own sales turned weak. The receivables collection period ability by getting its gross profit margins back to earlier
therefore grew longer. levels and reducing its operating expenses. To restore its
Easy had funded the entire expansion program with bank gross margins, it needs to either increase prices or cut costs.
loans and increases in accounts payable for its inventory Its best bet may be to return to its former product mix,
purchases. Its bank had tried to get the company to finance which apparently yielded a very profitable level of sales at
its plant and equipment with longer-term debt to match the pricing that allowed for good profit margins.
useful lives of the assets, but Easy felt it had the resources In addition, Easy needs to manage its assets better. The
to pay off the debt quickly. Easy also decided to maintain company's carefree attitudes toward accounts receivable
at least $500,000 in cash plus an additional $500,000 in mar collection and inventory supply have hurt both its cash flow
ketable securities at all times as a safety net. and its financial position. Increases in accounts receivable
While net income plus noncash charges did not turn nega and inventory are uses of cash and, if not offset by other
tive until 1997, uses of cash for accounts receivable, inven asset reductions or increases in owners' equity (sources of
tory, and equipment exceeded sources before financing cash), require that cash be provided by increasing liabilities
in each of the first three years. Liquidity therefore de or a reduction in actual cash balances (additional sources
clined steadily over the period, but the rate of decline of cash).
slowed a bit as the company's growth slowed and then re To be sure, there are points at which tight receivables
versed. collection policies and limited inventory supplies can cause
Leverage increased sharply in the first two years, peaked a loss of customers, which would have a detrimental effect
during the next two, and declined slightly in 1997 when on the performance and financial position of the firm. The
sources of cash from asset reductions slightly exceeded cash trick is to find the optimal levels or policies for each asset
used to pay down liabilities and cover net losses. so as to maximize sales and profits without causing undue
Due to its strong financial position and profitability at risk and financial strain on the company.
the outset, Easy's miscalculations have thus far not proven For analytical purposes, there are two components of
disastrous to the company. Its financial position has deterio increases or decreases in accounts receivable and inventory,
rated significantly, but from very strong to not too bad. Its each of which says something different about management.
receivables collection period and inventory supply, how One is the amount of change caused by a change in the level
ever, are now far too high. of sales and cost of goods sold. That can be calculated
by applying the former collection period or inventory days
supply to the new level of sales or cost of goods sold. The
PROFITABILITY AND second is caused by management policies and effectiveness.
ASSET MANAGEMENT This can be measured by the difference between the calcu
lated change based on a constant collection period or inven
Whether Easy can prevent further deterioration that could tory supply and the actual change. As an example, we can
cause it more serious problems depends on the reversal of look at these calculations for The Easy Company between
a combination of adverse trends. It needs to restore profit- 1992 and 1995:
118 Chapter 13/Application of Financial Ratios
Defensive versus Opportunistic Diversification 119
1992 1995
however, as asset reduction in the face of losses should
Revenue $10,000,000 $16,000,000 never be viewed as a recurring source of cash flow.
AR collection period 91 days 150 days
1995 AR at 1992 collection period
(16MM x 91 - 365) $3,989,000
Actual 1995 AR $6,575,300 DEFENSIVE VERSUS
Increase due to management $2,586,300 OPPORTUNISTIC DIVERSIFICATION
Cost of goods sold $7,000,000 $12,000,000
Inventory supply 120 days 160 days Finally, a word about diversification. Many companies
1995 inventory at 1992 days supply speak of diversification as a way of lessening the impact
(12MM x 120 + 365) $3,945,200 of setbacks in existing businesses or as the quickest path
Actual 1995 inventory $5,260,300 to growth. One might well imagine that it is easier to
Increase due to management $1,315,100
grow faster by being in five or six markets than by being in
only one.
One can observe, however, two different motivations for
In summary, we may observe that growth is generally
diversification that are not mutually exclusive but often re
healthy for a company, but an excessive rate of growth can ceive far different emphasis. One we will call defensive
be hazardous. Whether a company can maintain its level of diversification, the other opportunistic diversification.
growth without impairing its financial position depends on The first arises more from serious problems that a com
the degree to which it can generate sources of funds or pany is facing or is about to face in its existing markets. The
control uses of funds so that its financing needs do not company may no longer be able to grow or even maintain its
become excessive. The healthiest source of funds for a grow existing market share. Whatever the reason, the company
ing company is profits. Other things being equal, companies sees diversification as a necessity. It may therefore be less
with high profit margins can sustain a higher level of growth discriminating in its selection of an acquisition or in its
than those with lower margins. development of a new service or product line. It has to make
Asset management, as we have seen, is a critical element this move, so the only requirement is to make the best
in the constraint of cash outflows, or uses of cash. To the selection available to it at the time.
extent that a company's rate of asset expansion is no greater A company that is strong and growing in its current prod
than (or even less than) its rate of sales growth, it can sustain uct or service lines has no reason for diversification other
that level of growth without incurring an excessive financing than that an opportunity with unusual profit potential has
burden to fund its asset growth. presented itself. While the company may see some prudent
In fact, companies can also improve their cash flow and diversification as healthy in the long run, it is certainly under
financial position while suffering declining sales and even no pressure to make any acquisition that does not meet its
operating losses by efficient asset management. Reductions criteria for profitability and risk aversion.
in assets can produce more cash and/or debt reduction than It is important to determine a company's underlying moti
losses consume, resulting in liabilities declining at a greater vation for diversification as well as the apparent benefits of
rate than equity. This is strictly a short-term phenomenon, the acquisition or expansion itself. Too many companies
120 Chapter 13/Application of Financial Ratios
that have diversified as a largely defensive measure have
served only to compound their problems.
Chapter Fourteen
None of this is to say that a company that needs to expand
for defensive reasons cannot hit upon a good opportunity The Limitations of
or that a strictly opportunistic company cannot make a bad
acquisition. It is just to say that it is less likely than the Financial Statements
other way around.
Many lenders and investors like to say that financial state
ments aren't importantthat it's management that counts.
These lenders and investors are missing the point.
What are financial statements if not a record of the
strengths and weaknesses of management? True, a new
management team might demonstrate different results than
prior management, so one would presumably evaluate the
results of other companies managed by the new team for
an assessment of its capabilities.
Often, however, highly regarded new management is un
able to overcome the constraints of a company that has
severe financial problems and is in a difficult competitive
environment. So consider also the economic climate, indus
try trends, and the position of previous companies at which
management established its record compared to the current
situation it is attempting to manage.
Financial statements, moreover, must be judged as
strictly historical measures of performance and as a fair
representation of current condition. Their most serious limi
tation is that, in reality, practically everything in them, ex
cepting cash and most liabilities, is based on forecasts, esti
mates, and assumptions. Some of these are just more reliable
than others.
We have discussed estimates in the form of useful lives
for equipment and forecasts of motion picture and insurance
122 Chapter 14/The Limitations of Financial Statements
The Limitations of Financial Statements
123
premium revenues. The limitations in these cases are clear.
economic environment considerably worse than that which
In the case of inventory, there are three or four ways to has immediately preceded it.
value it, so why would you believe any of them? In fact, A final concern regarding asset values is that they presume
we know that LIFO carries inventory at a cost of purchases that the company is a going concern. (Remember the outside
that may have occurred many years ago. auditors will qualify the statements if they feel this assump
In fact, one of the major problems with financial state tion is questionable.) That means that asset values are to
ments is that nonmonetary assets are carried at their histori be realized from expected future income that, in fact, may
cal costs, adjusted for depreciation and special write downs or may not ever be generated.
to reflect clear and material losses of economic value. Actual Furthermore, if a company does meet with sudden mis
losses in economic value more likely occur in increments fortune and a lender or investor expects to look to re
over a period of time before the company and its outside ported asset values as a means of recovering a loan or
accountant lump them together and decide that they had investment, that lender or investor will usually find that
better recognize them. these assets are not worth anywhere near their reported
More important, however, statements of assets at histori value when the company really needs to sell all of them
cal cost may well result in a substantial understatement of quickly. If the company's inventory were really worth
asset values since the replacement cost or current market what it said it was worth, it would be selling at its cost
value may be well in excess of historical cost adjusted for plus some amount of profit. If the company's plant and
depreciation. This is especially likely when depreciation is equipment were worth what it was said to be worth, it
calculated on an accelerated basis. The current economic would be producing things that could be manufactured
value of assets should be of far more interest to users of and sold profitably. If these kinds of things were happen
financial statements than historical cost-based figures be ing, the company would be a healthy going concern and
cause it more truly reflects what the company is worth. we wouldn't be worried about how much we could get
Even sales and accounts receivable are recorded on the by terminating its operations and selling off all of its as
presumption that there will be no unusual returns of mer sets.
chandise because it is damaged or defective or sometimes The truth is that these asset values can be thrown out
just because the buyer has changed his mind. Accounts the window in a liquidation, which is when many users of
receivable balances assume that an adequate provision has financial statements need them the most. Often companies
been made for bad debts. The amount of this provision is get into trouble precisely because the assets they have in
clearly an informed estimate. vested in no longer meet the needs of their markets. Even
Banks offer a special example of the uses and limitations accounts receivable become far more difficult to collect
of estimates in financial reporting. They are required to when the customer doesn't expect to get any more product
estimate future losses on loans currently outstanding and from this supplier.
thereby establish a "loan loss reserve." Do they have any Most of these limitations are somewhat mitigated by the
idea what these losses might be? Of course not. That's why fact that companies and their auditors continually review
banks always take special charges against income to beef estimates and assumptions and make appropriate revisions
up their loan loss reserves any time they are faced with an as needed. Through such diligence, adjustments hopefully
124 Chapter 14/The Limitations of Financial Statements
can be held to modest proportions in all but the most extreme
scenarios.
Financial statements are therefore highly useful instru
ments of analysis in spite of their limitations, as long as
Appendix
these limitations are understood. Financial reporting is not
an exact science, but it gives its users the clearest practical
picture of what a company has accomplished and where it
stands as of the reporting date. That beats following hunches
and exhilarating press releases as a guide to informed deci
sion making.
ServicesAdvertising Agencies S1C# 7311

Comparative
Historical Data Type of Statement Current Data Sorted by Sates

30 28 34 Unqualified 1 ' 1 5 7 9 11
119 113 102 Reviewed 5 37 21 24 II 4
140 127 131 Compiled 33 67 15 9 6 1
4 7 Tax Returns 4 2 1
74 95 94 Other 18 34 15 14 5 8
6/30/89- 4/1/90- 4/1/91-
3/31/90 3/31/91 3/31/92 148(4/1-9/30/91) 220(10/1/91-3/31/92)
ALL ALL ALL 0-1 MM I-3MM 3-5 MM 5-10MM 10-25 MM 25MMA
OVER
363 367 368 Number of statements 61 141 56 54 32 24

% % % Assets % % % % % %
11.5 12.4 10.5 Cash and equivalents 11.2 11.4 6.9 10.0 12.5 9.8
52.2 51.7 53.0 Trade receivables- 43.3 54.6 53.8 57.6 58.2 49.0
(nct)
4.4 4.4 4.1 Inventory 5.2 3.7 4.1 4.2 2.3 5.9
3.4 3.8 3.7 All other current 3.0 3.6 4.3 3.6 4.4 3.4
71.6 72.3 71.2 Total current 62.8 73.3 69.0 75.5 77.4 68.1
18.4 17.9 17.5 Fixed assets (net) 23.4 17.3 19.7 13.7 10.4 16.4
1.7 2.1 2.7 Intangibles (net) 3.2 1.7 2.6 2.3 4.4 5.7
8.3 7.7 8.6 All other noncurrent 10.6 7.7 8.6 8.5 7.8 9.9
100.0 100.0 100.0 Total 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0

Liabilities
9.2 8.9 9.0 Notes payable 11.8 10.6 8.2 8.6 3.4 3.3
short-term
3.3 3.4 3.4 Cur. mat-L/T/D 6.9 2.8 3.6 2.2 2.1 2.0
35.9 35.5 36.1 Trade payablcs 24.6 34.9 35.5 44.6 45.4 42.8
.9 .7 .1 Income taxes payable .5 1.1 .7 .3 .2 .5
12.3 13.1 12.8 All other current 10.9 10.9 13.5 15.3 17.6 14.7
61.5 61.5 62.0 Total current 54.7 60.2 61.5 71.0 68.7 63.3
10.4 10.5 9.0 Long-term debt 14.8 8.3 7.5 5.7 8.4 10.1
.9 .5 1.1 Deferred taxes .1 1.2 2.0 .9 .7 1.2

1.8 2.5 2.9 All other noncurrent .7 2.4 3.2 6.2 2.4
25.3 4.7
25.0 25.0 Net worth 29.7 27.9 25.8 16.1 19.8 20.6
100.0 100.0 100.0 Total liabilities and 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
net worth

Income Data
100.0 100.0 100.0 Net sales 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
Gross profit
97.4 97.4 97.6 Operating expenses 97.7 97.4 97.7 98.6 97.1 95.9
2.6 2.6 2.4 Operating profit 2.3 2.6 2.3 1.4 2.9 4.1
.3 .5 All other expenses .5 .2 .9 .5 .3 1.6
(net)
2.3 1.8 1.9 Profit before taxes 1.9 2.3 1.4 .9 2.6 2.5

Ratios
1.6 2.3 1.5 1.3 1.4 1.3
1.2 Current 1.3 1.1 I.I 1.1 1.1
.9
.9 .9 1.0 .9

1.3
1.6 1.4 1.2 1.2 I.I
1.0 Quick 1.1 1.0 1.0 1.0 .9
.9 .7

37 10.0 38 9.7 38 9.6 15.7 35 10.3 40 9.2 40 9.2 41 8.9 41

54 8.9
6.8 54 6.8 53 6.9 Sales/Receivables 8.6 54 6.7 60 6.1 49 7.4 58 6.3 74 4.9
79 4.6 72 5.1 83 4.4 5.8 83 4.4 89 4.1 72 5.1 81 4.5 192 1.9

Cost of sales/
Inventory

Cosl of sales/Payables

11.5 12.1 12.5 8.3 11.6 11.6 24.3 11.0 10.4

33.4 37.7 40.0 Sales/Working capital 31.5 35.2 42.3 57.2 55.6 114.3
84.7 -137.4 -60.4 -29.8 -557.8 -36.2 -62.4 -101.3 -23.9
 Appeadix (continued)

Comparative
Historical Data Type of Statement Current Data Sorted by Sales

10.3 10.2 8.3 6.1 12.0 7.1 6.6 19.0 5.6

(310) 3.6 (322) 3.9 (320) 3.0 EB IT/Interest (50) 1.4 (127) 4.1 (44) 2.6 (50) 2.8 (28) 4.4 (21) 2.7
1.0 1.0 .6 -2.0 .5 .6 1.4 1.8 1.3

6.1 5.8 4.3 Net profit + depr., 1.9 5.1 6.6 4.7 5.1 3.9
(162) 2.6 (159) 2.6 (150) 1.9 dtp., amort./Cur. (18) .6 (49) 1.7 (25) 1.9 (29) 2.4 (15) 2.0 (14) 2.5
1.2 .5 .4 mat. L/T/D -.6 .3 .5 .9 1.0 1.8

.3 .3 .3 .3 .3 .2 .4 .2 .4
.6 .6 .6 Fixed/Worth .9 .6 .9 .6 .4 1.3
1.9 1.9 2.6 7.4 1.8 6.8 2.5 1.8 -19.1

1.5 1.4 L5 .7 1.4 1.3 2.6 2.3 2.5

3.6 3.8 3.4 Debt/Worth 2.3 3.1 2.9 5.2 4.8 5.2
8.1 11.5 16.1 15.3 8.4 31.1 23.1 17.4 -96.1

50.9 49.0 56.9 % profit before 60.1 59.7 50.4 53.3 42.4 58.9
(311) 21.3 (316) 20.6 (310 21.8 taxes/Tangible (49) 6.1 (127) 31.4 (45) 12.2 (46) 22.2 (27) 19.3 (17) 19.8
4.4 3.2 1.6 net worth -27.5 .7 1.4 4.6 10.7 9.4

18.4 17.2 8.8 7.6 10.8 6.9

13.9 11.6 12.7
% profit before 3.3 3.7
4.8 5.0 4.2 1.3 7.1 2.8 3.1
taxes/Total assets 1.8 .2
-.9 -14.1 -.9 -.7 .3
.3 .1

42.5 56.4 52.3 57.3 106.7 34.5

61.0 61.7 54.4
Sales/Net fixed assets 18.6 28.6 20.6 28.1 43.4 11.2
27.3 28.0 25.7
8.4 13.0 11.8 18.4 16.2 7.4
12.2 13.5 13.2

5.2 5.4 5.2 4.7 5.1 5.1

4.8 4.9 5.1
Sales/Total assets 3.7 3.6 3.6 3.7 3.7 1.5
3.5 3.7 3.6
2.1 2.3 1.8 2.6 2.0 .9
2.4 2.4 2.1

I.I .7 .5 .4 .9
.7 .6 .7
% depr.. dep., .8 (22) 1.9
(321) 1.3 (322) 1.2 (47) 2.1 (125) 1.3 (49) I.I (50) .9 (29)
(315) 1.3 amort./Sales
2.4 3.1 2.1 2.6 1.4 1.8 3.5
2.8 2.3

6.2 4.9 4.4 3.5 2.1

4.8 4.6 4.3 % officers', directors',
(33) 13.2 (75) 7.0 (23) 6.5 (15) 5.3 (M) 2.9
(162) 7.2 (156) 7.4 (162) 6.9
owners' comp/Sales 15.2
10.7 11.7 12.8 23.5 11.3 9.8 6.9

36586M 252809M 2I6427M 3638S6M 548630M 1605821M

30615O6M 2747012M 3O23959M Net sales <$)
Total assets (S) 14169M 90281M I13494M I27860M 263O85M I0841I3M
1039975M 1175695M 1693002M

M = $ thousand MM = $ million
Source: Reprinted with permission, copyright Robert Morris Associates 1992.
5 ManufacturersElectronic Components and Accessories SIC# 3671 (72,74-79)

Comparative
Historical Data Type of Statement Current Data Sorted by Sales

227 Unqualified 3 15 19 47 55 88
195 180
100 Reviewed 9 26 24 28 12 1
93 93
87 80 Compiled 14 33 21 9 3
96
3 Tax returns 2 1
5
110 115 Other 8 25 15 18 28 21
105
6/30/89- 4/1/90- 4/1/91-
3/31/91 3/31/92 216(4/1-9/30/91) 309(10/1/91-3/31/92)
3/31/90
ALL ALL 0-IMM I-3MM 3-5 MM 5-10MM IO-25MM 25MM&
ALL
OVER
475 525 Number of statements 34 101 79 102 99 no .
489

% % % Assets % % % % % %
9.3 Cash and equivalents 10.9 8.9 7.8 6.6 8.4 13.4
8.1 8.6
28.0 Trade receivables- 31.1 30.1 31.2 29.4 26.1 23.3
29.2 29.4
(net)
28.1 Inventory 23.8 30.4 29.5 30.0 28.6 24.0
28.9 27.8
2.2 AD other current 1.4 1.8 1.8 1.4 2.0 4.0
2.3 2.5
68.2 67.6 Total current 67.1 71.2 70.3 67.5 65.1 64.7
68.5
25.0 Fixed assets (net) 23.5 23.4 22.6 24.1 27.6 27.0
25.1 24.7
2.1 Intangibles (net) 1.6 1.4 1.2 2.6 2.2 2.8
1.9 1.9
5.4 All other noncurrcnt 7.7 4.0 6.0 5.8 5.1 5.6
4.5 5.2
100.0 100.0 Total 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
100.0

Liabilities
9.4 Notes payable 10.6 12.5 12.8 9.5 7.8 5.2
10.6 9.8
short-term
4.3 Cur. mat-L/T/D 3.9 5.4 4.3 4.9 4.5 2.8
4.2 4.3
Trade payables 14.1 16.0 18.1 14.6 13.3 12.4
14.1 14.9 14.7
.7 Income taxes payable .4 .6 .6 .9 .6 .9
1.0 I.I
9.2 All other current 6.1 8.3 10.6 9.3 9.1 10.0
8.8 9.0
42.8 46.5 39.2 35.2 31.4
38.7 39.0 38.3 Total current 35.1
15.0 Long-term debt 21.0 14.6 14.0 11.7 17.5 15.1
15.1 15.4
.6 Deferred taxes .3 .3 .4 .6 .6 1.0
.9 .9

2.8 2.9 3.1 AD other noncurrent 8.9 2.8 1.6 3.4 2.3 3.2
42.6 41.8 43.0 Net worth 34.6 39.4 37.5 45.2 44.3 49.4
100.0 100.0 100.0 Total liabilities and 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
net worth

income Data
100.0 100.0 100.0 Net sales 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
33.4 33.3 32.7 Gross profit 40.7 37.5 32.3 30.9 28.8 31.3
27.8 28.3 27.7 Operating expenses 37.6 33.2 28.9 25.5 23.5 24.7
5.6 5.0 5.0 Operating profit 3.1 4.2 3.4 5.4 5.3 6.7
1.6 1.7 1.5 AD other expenses 1.0 1.7 1.4 1.4 1.5 1.5
(net)
4.1 3.3 3^5 Profit before taxes 2.1 2.5 2.0 4.0 3.8 5.2

Ratios
2.8 2.9 2.8 3.6 2.5 2.3 2.6 3.0 3.2
1.8 1.9 1.8 Current 2.2 1.8 1.4 1.8 1.8 2.1
1.3 1.2 1.3 1.3 1.3 I.I 1.2 1.4 1.4

1.5 1.6 1.6 2.4 1.6 1.3 1.5 1.6 1.9

1.0 1.0 1.0 Quick 1.3 .9 .8 .9 1.0 1.1
.6 .6 .6 .6 .6 .6 .6 .7 .8

41 8.9 41 9.0 39 9.4 33 11.2 37 9.9 37 9.8 38 9.6 40 9.1 45 8.1

52 7.0 51 7.2 49 7.5 Sales/Receivables 42 8.7 45 8.2 47 7.7 49 7.4 49 7.5 54 6.7
63 5.8 66 5.5 62 5.9 68 5.4 63 5.8 59 6.2 62 5.9 60 6.1 65 5.6

41 8.8 41 8.8 43 8.5 23 15.8 46 8.0 42 8.6 39 9.4 48 7.6 51 7.2

Cost of sfUcs/
79 4.6 74 4.9 76 4.8 66 5.5 78 4.7 72 5.1 70 5.2 74 4.9 81 4.5
Inventory
126 2.9 122 3.0 122 3.0 122 3.0 126 2.9 114 3.2 114 3.2 118 3.1 130 2.8

21 17.7 20 18.4 20 18.0 II 34.4 20 18.3 21 17.3 21 17.2 19 18.9 24 15.3

33 10.9 33 11.2 34 10.8 Cost of sales/Payable s 24 15.5 35 10.3 41 9.0 31 11.8 32 11.4 36 10.2
51 7.2 54 6.8 51 7.2 87 4.2 58 6.3 60 6.1 49 7.5 41 8.8 48 7.6

3.9 3.9 3.9 4.0 4.7 5.2 5.1 3.7 2.9

6.9 7.2 7.4 Sales/Working capital 8.3 8.5 9.9 8.3 6.3 4.1
15.9 18.9 16.7 25.3 17.3 30.7 18.7 15.1 9.2
 Appendix {concluded)

Comparative
Historical Data Type of Statement Current Data Sorted by Sates

8.6 6.5 6.4 3.9 6.1 5.1 6.4 6.6 9.0

(443) 3.2 (427) 2.8 (479) 3.1 EB IT/1 merest (27) |.9 (90) 2.2 (70) 1.7 (95) 3.0 (93)
1.2
3.3 (104) 4.1
1.1 1.1 .6
-.9 1.0 1.4 1.5 1.3

6.6 4.9 5.8 Net profit + Dcpr.. 4.0 3.4 7.2 3.6
(264) 2.7 12.0
(252) 2.| (276) 2.4 dcp., amort./Cur. 1.7 (42) 1.9 (56)
(48) 2.3 (49) 1.9 (75) 4.4
LI 1.0 .9 mat. L/T/D .5 1.0 1.2 .8 1.4

.3 .3 .3 .1 .2 .2 .3 .4 .3
.6 .6 .6 Fixed/Worth .7 .5 .6 .5 .7 .6
1.3 1.3 1.2 2.8 1.3 1.5 1.3 I.I I.I

.7 .6 .6 .7 .7 .8 .6 .7 .4
1.4 1.4 1.4 Debt/Worth 2.3 1.3 1.9 1.4 1.4 1.0
3.0 3.4 2.9 8.0 3.6 3.7 2.9 2.6 2.3

39.8 35.7 36.6 % profit before 81.3 38.9 39.1 32.6 37.9
(463) 19.3 32.0
(439) 16.5 (493) 16.2 taxes/Tangible (28) 17.0 (89) 12.3 (74) 11.9 (100) 16.0 (95) 17.9 (107) 17.4
3.9 2.1 2.7 net worth -4.5 -.3 1.6 5.0 6.7 3.3

21.7 14.2 10.1 13.0 14.5 16.1

17.1 14.9 14.4
% profit before 7.2 7.4
6.2 5.0 5.5 2.9 5.8
7.5 6.1 taxes/Total assets
-6.8 -1.6 .4 1.8 2.6 1.5
.4 .6

60.8 25.7 24.3 20.7 14.1 10.3

18.6 19.4 18.3
Sales/Net fixed assets 9.5 12.5 13.5 9.1 7.3 6.0
8.6 8.9 8.5
6.3 6.9 6.6 5.2 4.2 3.4
5.0 4.7 4.8

3.3 2.8 2.8 2.6 2.6 2.0

2.6 2.6 2.6
2.0 2.2 2.2 2.1 1.9 1.4
2.0 1.9 2.0 Sales/Total assets
1.5 1.7 1.7 1.6 1.3 1.1
1.5 1.4 1.4

.7 1.4 1.2 1.2 1.6 2.2

1.6 1.4 1.5 % depr.. dep..
(29) 2.2 (92) 2.1 (70) 2.4 (95) 2.5 (87) 2.6 (91) 3.5
(421) 2.8 (410) 2.7 (464) 2.6 amort./Sales
6.9 3.9 4.0 4.0 4.5 5.4
4.8 4.6 4.4

2.8 7.2 4.2 3.0 1.9 1.6

2.4 3.0 % Officers', directors',
(13) 12.3 (50) 6.9 (30) 5.6 (34) 3.4 (14) 2.1
(131) 5.3 (135) 5.1 (143) 5.3
owners' comp/Sales 9.5 7.0 3.4
9.0 10.6 9.7 23.3 11.3

Net sales (J) 20387M 204885M 3106O9M 740498M 149535IM I03I9209M

I0006586M 9480200M I3O9O939M
Total assets (S) 14474M 1O833OM 155624M 4O4949M 94682IM 7539973M
6870779M 6674078M 9I70171M

M = $ thousand MM = $ million
Source: Reprinted with permission, copyright Robert Morris Associates 1992.
 Glossary of Terms
accelerated cost recovery system (ACRS) Internal Revenue Ser
vice guidelines for accelerated depreciation for tax reporting pur
poses.
accelerated depreciation Method that charges greater amounts of
depreciation in earlier years of assets' life and lesser amounts in
later years.
accounting The process of recording all of a company's financial
transactions and developing and compiling the numbers to be used
in a company's financial reports.
accounting period The period of time covered by a company's
income statement, also the period of time between balance sheets.
accounts payable Money due to suppliers for products purchased
or services received.
accounts receivable Money due from customers for products sold
or services provided.
accounts receivable collection period Average number of days it
takes to collect a company's accounts receivable.
accrual Income that has been earned but has not yet been received
or expense that has been incurred but has not yet been paid. Also,
process by which these items are recorded in financial reports. '
accumulated depreciation Total of all periodic depreciation that
has been charged against an asset or group of assets. Shown as
a reduction to the asset's cost.
allowance for doubtful accounts Reduction in gross accounts re
ceivable to allow for amounts that will not be collectible,
amortization Accounting process by which costs of intangible
assets are charged to the periods over which they are expected
to generate income.
asset That which is owned by a company and is expected to be
used to generate future income.
136 Glossary of Terms 137
Glossary of Terms
audited financial statements Financial statements that offer the contributed capital That part of owners' equity that has been
highest level of assurance by outside independent accountants contributed by investors as opposed to retained from income
that they constitute a fair presentation of company's financial earned.
position and operating results. Management representations are cost of goods sold The cost of any inventory sold during an ac
independently verified wherever possible. counting period on the books of the selling company.
average cost Method of inventory valuation that assumes inven current assets Assets that are expected to be converted to cash
tory sold during period was purchased at the average cost of all within one year through the company's normal operations.
inventory available for sale. current liabilities Liabilities that are due for payment within one
Balance Sheet Financial report that shows a company's assets, year.
liabilities, and owners' equity as of a given date. current maturities of long-term debt Payments due within one
bond A marketable security representing long-term debt. year on debt that was originally due over a longer period of time.
book value The value of an asset on a company's books or balance current ratio The ratio of current assets to current liabilities.
sheet, which is its historical cost adjusted for depreciation or debt coverage ratio The ratio of a company's cash flow before
amortization and any special write downs. investing and financing activities to its short-term debt maturities.
cash basis Recording income and expense at the time of cash deferred taxes Taxes that have been recorded as an expense for
receipt or payment.
financial reporting purposes but that are not yet an obligation for
cash equivalents Assets that will be converted to cash in a very income tax reporting purposes.
short period of time (three months or less) with no market risk depreciation An expense that allocates the cost of assets over
of loss in value.
the period during which they are expected to generate revenues.
cash flow The net amount of cash generated by a company in an disclosure Explanation of all accounting treatments and business
accounting period.
issues necessary for a qualified reader of financial statements to
compilation financial statement Type of financial statement offer understand them.
ing the lowest level of assurance as to whether it is a fair presenta earned revenue Revenue that has met all of the requirements for
tion of a company's financial position and operations. Relies al recognition in the financial statements whether or not it has been
most entirely on the representations of management.
received in cash.
conservatism Accounting principle that dictates use of the ac
effective income tax rate The rate based on taxes the company
counting method that presents results in the least favorable light
is obligated to pay after any adjustments to the statutory tax rate.
whenever there is a choice between two otherwise acceptable
methods. expenses Charges against revenues for products purchased or
services received other than those that are a cost of the company's
consolidation Accounting for an ownership interest in another
own product sold or carried in inventory.
company by combining its financial statement accounts with that
of the company that has the ownership interest. FIFO Method of inventory valuation that assumes that the cost
of inventory sold during the period is the cost of the earliest
contingent liability Something that will become a liability if and
inventory purchased and available for sale in the period.
when a certain likely event or set of events occur. A dollar amount
cannot be placed on the potential liability because of the uncer financial statements The balance sheet, income statement, state
tainty of the outcome. ment of cash flows, and possibly statement of changes in owners'
138 Glossary of Terms
Glossary of Terms 139
equity, which together constitute a fair presentation of the com
individual film forecast Accounting method by which motion pic
pany's financial condition at the end of the accounting period and
ture firms amortize film costs by estimating the amount and timing
results of operations for the accounting period. of receipt of revenues for each film.
finished goods That part of inventory that consists of completed
insider A person who by virtue of his or her position in a company
products ready for sale.
or relationship to a company is in possession of important com
footnotes (to financial statements) The section at end of financial pany information not available to the public.
statements where all additional information necessary for a fair
intangible assets Assets like patents and franchises that cannot
presentation is disclosed.
be seen or felt but nevertheless generate revenues.
funding The providing of money for purchases of assets, pay inventory Product that is either completed or in some stage of
ments of liabilities or reductions in owners' equity.
production and is to be sold in the ordinary course of a company's
GAAP Generally Accepted Accounting Principles: The rules business.
which must be followed in the preparation of financial statements inventory supply The number of days the inventory as of a given
for use outside the company.
date would last at the rate of sales for the accounting period ending
GAAS Generally Accepted Auditing Standards: The rules which on that date.
must be followed by independent outside accountants when invoice Documentation of a sale and the terms of payment.
auditing the financial procedures and statements of a company.
LBO (leveraged buy out) A purchase of a company financed by
general and administrative expenses Periodic expenses of running heavy borrowing against the assets of the company being pur
the business as opposed to those which can be directly allocated chased.
to the cost of a product or a service provided.
leverage The amount of a company's debt in relation to its own
going concern Accounting principle which assumes for financial ers' equity.
valuation and reporting purposes that a business will continue to
liabilities The obligations for which a company has to pay money
operate.
to others as shown on its balance sheet.
goodwill The excess of the cost of acquiring assets over the book
LIFO Method of inventory valuation that assumes that sales dur
value of the assets acquired. Appears where a business is assumed ing the period consisted of the last inventory purchased or avail
to have value in excess of the asset values shown on its books. able for sale in the period.
gross margin Percentage of gross profit to sales. liquidation Sale of all of a company's assets upon termination of
gross profit Sales less cost of goods sold, representing the profits its business operations.
on product sales which are available to cover selling and general liquid ratio See quick ratio.
and administrative expenses and to provide a net profit.
long-term debt Debt that is not due for repayment for more than
historical cost The original cost of an asset unadjusted for subse one year.
quent price changes.
marketable securities Securities that have well-defined dollar val
Income Statement Financial report showing net income and how ues and that easily can be converted to cash within one year.
it is derived from revenues less all costs and expenses.
matching Accounting principle that dictates that expenses be
incurred expense An expense that represents an obligation for charged to the same accounting period as the revenues they gen
payment even though payment has not yet been made. erate.
140 Glossary of Terms
Glossary of Terms 141
net income Profits of the company after all costs and expenses
quick ratio The ratio of cash, cash equivalents, marketable securi
rf the period are subtracted from revenues.
ties, and accounts receivable to current liabilities.
noncurrent assets Assets that are expected to generate revenues
ratios Relationships between various financial data that are useful
:>ver a period exceeding one year.
in analyzing the operations and financial health of the company.
>bsolescence The state of economic uselessness caused by the
raw materials Materials that have been purchased for inventory
ievelopment of other products that can perform a task far more
but have not yet entered into the production process.
efficiently.
realization The occurrence of an economic transaction that per
>perating expense An expense of the accounting period related
mits the recognition of revenue or income.
:o conducting the ongoing business as opposed to the production
}f a specific product or service. recognition Satisfaction of the conditions required for a transac
tion to meet the accounting requirements necessary to be reported
)perations The company's regular business activities as opposed
as revenue.
:o investments, financing, or nonrecurring events.
replacement value The value of an asset at the cost of replacing
>pinion letter Letter in which accountants express their opinion it at current prices.
is to whether the financial statements constitute a fair presentation
ind, if not, what limitations they might have. retained earnings That portion of the accumulated net income of
a company that has not been paid out or otherwise reallocated.
>verhead Costs and expenses that in the short term are incurred
return on assets Net income divided by total assets, expressed
egardless of any fluctuations in the volume of businessthat
as a percentage. A measure of the profitability of a company's
s, they are "fixed" within a reasonable range of fluctuation in
assets.
/olume.
return on equity Net income divided by owners' equity, ex
wners' equity The amount of assets left over after all liabilities
pressed as a percentage. A measure of the profitability of the
ire deducted, and thus that share of the assets that is left for the
)wners.
owners' investment.
>olicy acquisition costs The costs an insurance company incurs revenue Money received or due for products sold or services
provided.
n order to sell its policies.
reviewed financial statements Financial statements for which the
>repaid expenses A current asset that represents payment for a
service or product at the beginning of an accounting period where outside independent accountants provide a moderate level of as
he benefit will be received throughout all or a remaining part of surance, having checked some accounting procedures but having
:he accounting period. relied heavily on the representations of management.
iroperty, plant, and equipment Noncurrent tangible assets of a sales Revenues derived from the exchange of products for cash
;ompany that will generate revenues for more than one year. or an obligation to pay cash.
irovision for income taxes Income tax expense for an accounting service companies Companies that receive the predominance of
>eriod derived by applying the effective income tax rate to pretax their revenues from providing services as opposed to selling
ncome. products.
nullified opinion An opinion of financial statements by indepen- shareholders' equity Owners' equity in a corporation, where the
lent outside accountants in which there is some reservation about owners are shareholders.
vhether the statements constitute a fair presentation.
short term In accounting parlance, generally less than one year.
142 Glossary of Terms
sources of cash Changes in accounts that, other things being
equal, will increase cash.
Index
specific identification Process by which each item of inventory is
tracked to determine which is sold in an accounting period and
which remains in inventory at the end of the period.
Statement of Cash Flows Financial report that shows how much
cash has been generated during the accounting period. Amortization, 72-78
of film costs, 74
Statement of Changes in Financial Position See Balance Sheet. Accelerated cost recovery system
of motion picture film costs,
(ACRS), 71
Statement of Changes in Shareholders' or Owners' Equity Finan 74-76
Accepted Auditing Standards, 95
cial report that shows the beginning shareholders' or owners' Accounting
of policy acquisition costs, 77
equity, changes occurring during the accounting period, and the accrual, 17-19
Analysis of growth, 111-20
ending shareholders' or owners' equity. Annual Statement Studies 1992,
cash basis, 17
109
statutory income tax rate The prevailing legal tax rate that would Accounting defined, 3
Appreciation, 68
be applied to net income before taxes if there were no adjustments Accounting policies, 89-91
Assets, 24
to cause pretax income for financial reporting to differ from pretax
definition of cash equivalents,
current, 25-30
90-91
income for income tax reporting. defined,26
inventory, 90
increase, 49
straight-line depreciation Depreciation that allocates the same principles of consolidation, 89
insurance company, 84
percentage of an asset's cost to each period. property and equipment, 90
intangible, 72-78
subsidiaries Companies in which another company has a sufficient purchase price over net
liquidation, 49
assets, 90
ownership interest to exercise influence or control. noncurrent, 30
research and development
unamortized film costs That portion of the cost of producing a physical life, 66-69
costs, 90
motion picture which has yet to be amortized and thus still repre reduction, 49
revenue recognition, 89-90
Assurance level, 95
sents an asset on the balance sheet. unusual terms of sale, 91
Audited statements, 95-98
warranties, 91
uses of cash Changes to accounts that, other things being equal, Auditors, opinions, 88
Accounts
will result in decreases in cash. Average cost, 63-65, 90
capital, 32
working capital Current assets less current liabilities, or what contributed capital, 32
would be left of current assets if they were used to pay current retained earning, 32
liabilities. B
Accounts receivable (AR), 26, 27,
28,60
work in process That portion of inventory that is in the production Balance Sheet, 1,3,22-33,51
Accrual accounting, 17-19, 42 impact on, 37-40
process but is not yet a finished product.
and the cost of goods sold, reasons for balancing, 23-25
20-21
and depreciation, 19-20
Accrual concept, 14-21
Accrual revenue, 53
Administrative expenses, 36 Capital, working, 31
Advanced Micro Devices, 73 Capital accounts, 32
 Index 145
144 Index
E Financial statementsCom.
Capital-intensive service Depreciation, 45
historical measures, 121
companies, 84-85 and accrual accounting, 19-20 Ecclesiastes, 105
and liquidation, 123
Cash basis accounting equipment, 61 Equity
preparers, 87-100
difficulties, 17 plant, 61 increase, 49
uses, 56-60
Cash basis financial statements, property, 61 owners', 32, 51,73
Financial statement users, 8-13
15-16 reporting issues, 61-71 reduction, 49
attorneys and litigants, 12-13
Cash equivalents defined, 91 Depreciation defined, 18 shareholders', 32
customers, 12
Cashflow Depreciation expense, 46 Expenses
calculating, 45-52
employees and job seekers, 13
Depreciation issues, 66-71 administrative, 36
lenders, 10-11
from accounting operations, 42 accelerated depreciation, 69-71 and cash flow, 45
managers, 11
derivation, 51 straight-line depreciation, defined, 14
owners, 9-10
determination, 43-44 69-71 depreciation, 46
suppliers, 11-12
Cash flow statement, 42-55 useful life of assets, 66-69 general, 36
Disclosures, 89-94 First-in-first-out (FIFO), 63-65, 90
alternative format, 52-54 operating, 36-37
contingent liabilities, 94 First-in-still-there (FIST), 63
using, 54-55 selling, 36
current cost of nonmonetary Forecast, individual film, 75
Cash revenue, 53
Coca-Cola, 73 assets, 93
Companies description of credit
financial services, 83-84 facilities, 91
service, 79-86 description of terms, 91
Financial analysis tools, 101-10 General expenses, 36
Compilations, 95 events surrounding financial
financial ratios, 101-5 Generally Accepted Accounting
Compilation statement, 99 report date, 94
leverage ratios, 104 { Principles (GAAP), 87-88, 95,
Compiled statements, 95 and federal and state tax rates,
ratio of debt to net worth, 104 ; 99, 100
Contributed capital accounts, 32 91-92
Financial ratios applications, Generally Accepted Auditing
Cost of Goods Sold (CGS), 20-21, funding of employee benefit and
111-20 . Standards (GAAS), 87-88
28,35 retirement plans, 91
defensive versus opportunistic Going concern qualification, 100
Costs general, 89
diversification, 119-20 Goodwill, 73-74, 90
amortization of film, 75 industry segment
profitability and asset Gross profits, 36
average, 63 information, 93
management, 116-19 Growth analysis, 111-20
capitalizing, 79 long-term debt maturities, 92
strategy and analysis, 115-16
motion picture film costs, major customers and/or
Financial reporting, not an exact
74-76 suppliers, 93
science, 124
policy acquisition, 77-78 property and casualty I
Financial services companies,
premium acquisition, 74 insurance, 92
83-84 Income, net, 37
unamortized film, 74 reconciliation of income tax
Financial statement limitations, Income Statement, 1, 4, 34-41,
Current assets, 25-30 expenses, 91
121-24 37-40
Current liabilities, 31-32 replacement value of
Financial statements, 1-7 Income taxes, 37
nonmonetary assets, 93
and banks, 122 Individual film forecast, 75
significant accounting policies,
cash basis, 15-16 Insurance companies
D 89-91
contents, 8-13 amortization of policy
transactions with insiders or
Debt, long-term, 32 defined, 121 acquisition costs, 77
related entities, 92
Defensive diversification, 119 and going concerns, 123 assets, 84
Diversification, 119
146 Index Index
147
Insurance companiesCont. N RatiosCont. Service companies, 79-86
liabilities, 84 return on assets (ROA), 108 capital intensive, 84-85
Net income, 37
policy acquisition costs, 77-78 return on equity (ROA), 108
Net worth, 37
people intensive, 85-86
Intel, 73 various expense, 109
Noncurrent assets, 30
Shareholders' equity,, 32, 41
Internal Revenue Service, 71 Receivable, accounts, 26 Specific identification method, 62
Inventory conversion, 49 Reports, financial, 1 Statement of Cash Flows, 1,
Inventory payment, 58 Balance Sheet, 1
O 42-55
Inventory purchases, 56-58 financial picture of company, 6 alternative format, 52-54
Inventory sale, 58-59 Obsolescence, 66 Income Statement, 1 defined,4
Inventory valuation, 61-71 Operating expenses, 36-37 Profit and Loss, 1 using, 54-55
Inventory valuation Opinion letters, 95-100 Statement of Cash Flows, 1 Statement of Changes in Owners'
alternatives, 62 Opinions, qualified, 99-100 Statement of Financial or Shareholders' Equity, 7
average cost, 63 Opportunistic diversification, 119 Position, 1 Statement of Changes in
first-in-first-out (FIFO), 63 Owners' equity, 32, 37, 51, 73 Retained earnings accounts, 32 Shareholders' Equity, 41
first-in-still-there (FIST), 63 Return on Assets (ROA) ratio, Statement of Financial Position,
last-in-first-out (LIFO), 63 108 1,22-33
Return on Equity (ROA) ratio, Statements
108 audited, 95-98
People-intensive service
Revenue compiled, 95
companies, 85-86.
Last-in-first-out (LIFO), 63, accrual, 53 income, 37-40
Policy acquisition costs, 77-78
64-65, 90, 122 cash,53 reviewed, 95
Premium acquisition costs, 74
Level of assurance, 95 Revenue defined, 14
Prepaid items increase, 46
Leverage, 33 Revenues, 35
Preparers of financial statements,
Leveraged buy outs (LBOs), 33 Reviewed statements, 95
87-100
Liabilities Reviews, 95
Production defined, 28 Taxes, income, 37
current, 31-32 Robert Morris Associates (RMA),
Profit and Loss Statement, 1,
increase, 49 109
34-41
insurance company, 84 U
Liquidation of assets, 49
Liquidation scenario, 10 Unamortized film costs, 74
Q
Liquidity defined, 31
Loan loss reserve, 122 Qualification, going concern, 100 Securities, marketable, 26
W
Loans, 46 Securities brokerage firms, 84
Long-term debt, 32 Selling expenses, 36 Working capital defined, 31
R
Ratios, useful, 105-10
M
accounts receivable collection
McDonald's, 73 period, 106
Management representation, 99 current, 106
Management responsibility, 98-99 days inventory supply, 107
Marketable securities defined, 26 debt coverage, 106
Motion picture film costs, 74-76 leverage, 106