Federal Reserve: A Faustian Bargain?
Federal Reserve: A Faustian Bargain?
Federal Reserve: A Faustian Bargain?
A Faustian Bargain?
By William P. Litynski
Federal Reserve: The Monopoly of Big Credits?
Current and former presidents of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York pose for a group portrait on May ! "#$% From left to
right: &illiam '% M()onough! &illiam C% )udley! *aul +% ,ol(ker! -% .erald Corrigan! and Timothy F% .eithner% +ll five men
are /or were0 mem1ers of the Coun(il on Foreign Relations and mem1ers of the Trilateral Commission%
/*hoto: Federal Reserve0
+ndrew 'a(kson
2It is to be regretted that the rich and powerful too often bend the acts of
government to their selfish purposes. )istin(tions in so(iety will always e3ist
under every 4ust government% -5uality of talents! of edu(ation! or of wealth (an not
1e produ(ed 1y human institutions% 6n the full en4oyment of the gifts of 7eaven and
the fruits of superior industry! e(onomy! and virtue! every man is e5ually entitled to
prote(tion 1y law8 but when the laws undertake to add to these natural and just
advantages artificial distinctions, to grant titles, gratuities, and exclusive
privileges, to make the rich richer and the potent more powerful, the humble
members of societythe farmers, mechanics, and laborerswho have neither
the time nor the means of securing like favors to themselves, have a right to
complain of the injustice of their Government. There are no necessary evils in
government. Its evils exist only in its abuses. 6f it would (onfine itself to e5ual
prote(tion! and! as 7eaven does its rains! shower its favors alike on the high and the
low! the ri(h and the poor! it would 1e an un5ualified 1lessing%9
: +ndrew 'a(kson! *resident of the ;nited <tates! in his ,eto Message regarding the
<e(ond Bank of the ;%<% on 'uly #! =>"
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke /right0 appears with former Federal Reserve Chairman *aul ,ol(ker /left0 and former
Federal Reserve Chairman +lan .reenspan /(enter0 after parti(ipating in the (eremonial signing of a (ertifi(ate (ommemorating the
##th anniversary of the signing of the Federal Reserve +(t at the Federal Reserve Building in &ashington! )%C% on Monday!
)e(em1er ?! "#>% Bernanke! 4oined 1y his two prede(essors! marked the ##th anniversary of the Federal Reserve 1y refle(ting on
the 1old a(tions past (hairmen have had to take in the 1est interest of the +meri(an e(onomy% /+* *hoto@*a1lo MartineA Monsivais0
2ost !mericans have no real understanding of the operation of the international moneylenders. The bankers want it
that way. &e re(ogniAe in a haAy sort of way that the Roths(hilds and the &ar1urgs of -urope and the houses of '% *% Morgan!
Buhn! Coe1 and Company! <(hiff! Cehman! and Ro(kefeller possess and (ontrol vast wealth% 7ow they a(5uired this vast
finan(ial power and employ it is a mystery to most of us% 6nternational 1ankers make money 1y e3tending (redit to
governments% The greater the de1t of the politi(al state! the larger the interest returned to the lenders% The national 1anks of
-urope are a(tually owned and (ontrolled 1y private interests% 6n the early years of the Repu1li( the ;nited <tates e3perimented
with a (entral 1anking system% 'efferson opposed +le3ander 7amiltonDs s(heme for the First Bank of the ;nited <tates! and
+ndrew 'a(kson a1olished Ni(holas BiddleEs <e(ond Bank of the ;nited <tates% The &all <treet 1anks (ontri1uted the finan(ial
mus(le to ele(t &oodrow &ilson *resident in F"% Their agent! Colonel -% M% 7ouse! 1e(ame the most powerful figure in the
&ilson administration% *aul MoritA &ar1urg! s(ion of the M% M% &ar1urg Company of 7am1urg and +msterdam! (ame to the
;%<% in F#"% -ight years later he was a partner in the 1anking house of Buhn! Coe1 of New York% "arburg was the architect
of our #ederal $eserve %ystem, creating a privately owned mechanism to control the currency and credit of the &nited
%tates. The #ederal $eserve is a bank of monetary issue. It is empowered to establish a national discount rate and to
authori'e the printing of the currency of the &nited %tates. The accounts of the #ederal $eserve %ystem have never been
audited. It operates outside the control of (ongress and through its )oard of Governors manipulates the credit of the
&nited %tates. ;nder Franklin )% Roosevelt the original term of offi(e for governors was e3tended from seven to fourteen years
: putting the 1oard 1eyond the rea(h of any *resident% The powerful -uropean 1anker +nselm Roths(hild on(e said! 2.ive me
the power to issue a nationEs money! then 6 do not (are who makes the laws%9
: ;%<% <enator Barry .oldwater! With No Apologies! page "=G"=" /written in FHF0
&illiam '% M()onough! 'ohn *% Cipsky! <tanley Fis(her! &illiam C% )udley /*resident of the Federal Reserve Bank of New
York0! and Roger &% Ferguson 'r% listen as Federal Reserve Chairman 'anet Yellen delivers a spee(h during an -(onomi( Clu1
of New York 1an5uet in New York City on +pril ?! "#$% /*hoto: -(onomi( Clu1 of New York0
&oodrow &ilson
27owever it has (ome a1out! it is more important still that the control of credit also has
become dangerously centrali'ed% 6t is the mere truth to say that the finan(ial resour(es of
the (ountry are not at the (ommand of those who do not su1mit to the dire(tion and
domination of small groups of (apitalists who wish to keep the e(onomi( development of the
(ountry under their own eye and guidan(e% The great monopoly in this country is the
monopoly of big credits. %o long as that exists, our old variety and freedom and
individual energy of development are out of the *uestion. ! great industrial nation is
controlled by its system of credit. +ur system of credit is privately concentrated. The
growth of the nation, therefore, and all our activities are in the hands of a few men who,
even if their action be honest and intended for the public interest, are necessarily
concentrated upon the great undertakings in which their own money is involved and
who necessarily, by very reason of their own limitations, chill and check and destroy
genuine economic freedom. This is the greatest 5uestion of all! and to this statesmen must
address themselves with an earnest determination to serve the long future and the true
li1erties of men% This money trust, or, as it should be more properly called, this credit
trust, of which (ongress has begun an investigation, is no myth, it is no imaginary
thing. It is not an ordinary trust like another. It doesn-t do business every day. It does
business only when there is occasion to do business. You (an sometimes do something
large when it isnIt wat(hing! 1ut when it is wat(hing! you (anIt do mu(h% !nd I have seen
men s*uee'ed by it, I have seen men who, as they themselves expressed it, were put out
of business by "all %treet, because "all %treet found them inconvenient and didn-t
want their competition.9 : ;%<% *resident &oodrow &ilson! The New Freedom /F>0!
Chapter = /Monopoly! or Jpportunity?0
#ederal $eserve . /0/1 2residential 3lection4
!n +ctober %urprise5
#rom the Grassy 6noll in ilwaukee4
7one Gunman or 2atsy5
The !ttempted !ssassination of Theodore $oosevelt on +ctober /8, /0/1
*rogressive *arty (andidate Theodore Roosevelt appears on the (ampaign trail in F"% /*hoto: Ci1rary of Congress0
*rogressive *arty (andidate Theodore Roosevelt appears on the (ampaign trail on J(to1er $! F"! ten days 1efore Theodore
Roosevelt was shot in the (hest 1y a 2lone gunman9 in Milwaukee% /*hoto: Ci1rary of Congress0
Former ;%<% *resident Theodore Roosevelt was shot in the (hest 1y a 2lone gunman9 named 'ohn F% <(hrank /=H?GF$>0! a .ermanG
1orn immigrant from Bavaria! while (ampaigning in Milwaukee! &is(onsin on J(to1er $! F"%
.ermanG1orn 2patsy9 'ohn F% <(hrank /left0 poses for a group portrait as he appears with a group of Milwaukee poli(e offi(ers
shortly after <(hrankEs arrest in Milwaukee in J(to1er F"% /*hoto: Ci1rary of Congress0
President-elect Woodrow Wilson (left), member of the Democratic Party, and outgoing President William oward !aft (right), member of the
"e#ublican Party and a member of $kull % Bones at &ale 'ni(ersity, laugh together outside the White ouse #rior to Wilson)s inauguration on
*arch +, ,-,.. !he ,/th 0mendment of the '.$. 1onstitution legali2ing the federal income ta3 was ratified on 4ebruary ., ,-,.5 the 4ederal
"eser(e 0ct was signed by President Woodrow Wilson on December 6., ,-,.. !he "ockefeller 4oundation and the 0nti-Defamation League
of B)nai B)rith were founded in ,-,.. (Photo7 Library of 1ongress)
8ncoming President Woodrow Wilson (left) shakes hands with outgoing President William oward !aft on *arch +, ,-,.. Kuhn, Loeb & Co.
banking partner Felix Warburg (a Jewish banker from Hamburg, erman!" supporte# William Howar# $aft% Kuhn, Loeb & Co.
banking partner &aul Warburg (a Jewish banker from Hamburg, erman! an# Felix Warburg's brother" supporte# Woo#row Wilson
#uring the ()(* presi#ential ele+tion.
2resident Taft . The 9ewish 7obby at the "hite :ouse4 Mem1ers of the BEnai BErith visit ;%<% *resident &illiam 7oward
Taft /(enter0 at the &hite 7ouse in &ashington! )%C%! ;%<%+% &illiam 7oward Taft was a mem1er of %kull . )ones! a se(ret
so(iety at Yale ;niversity% The +ntiG)efamation Ceague of BEnai BErith /a 'ewish politi(al organiAation0 was founded in F>%
The Federal Reserve +(t and the federal in(ome ta3 /the ?
th
+mendment0 were esta1lished in F>%
/*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress *rints and *hotographs )ivision0
F" +meri(an presidential ele(tion ele(toral map
/*residential ele(tion held on Novem1er L! F"0
/0/1 2residential 3lection $esult
*residential (andidate *arty 7ome state
*opular vote -le(toral
vote
Running mate
Count *(t ,i(eGpresidential (andidate 7ome state -le(t% vote
&oodrow &ilson )emo(rati( New 'ersey ?!"F?!"=$ $%=$M $>LThomas R% Marshall 6ndiana $>L
Theodore Roosevelt *rogressive New York $!""!H" "H%$#M ==7iram &% 'ohnson California ==
&illiam 7oward Taft Repu1li(an Jhio >!$=?!"$" ">%HM =Ni(holas Murray Butler New York =
-ugene ,% )e1s <o(ialist 6ndiana F#!LL L%FFM #-mil <eidel &is(onsin #
-ugene &% Chafin *rohi1ition 6llinois "#=!L? %>=M #+aron <% &atkins Jhio #
+rthur -% Reimer <o(ialist Ca1or Massa(husetts "F!>"$ #%FM #+ugust .illhaus New York #
Jther $!LL? #%#>M NJther N
Total L!#$=!=>$ ##M L> L>
Needed to win "?? "??
Corporate sponsors of the F" *residential ele(tions /from left to right0:
Buhn! Coe1 K Co% 1anking partners Feli3 &ar1urg! *aul &ar1urg! and 'a(o1 7% <(hiff
Federal Reserve: A Continuation of the
Bank of the United States?
!he ($econd) Bank of the 'nited $tates in Philadel#hia o#erated from ,9,/ to ,9./. !he ($econd) Bank of the 'nited $tates, which was
renamed 'nited $tates Bank of Pennsyl(ania in ,9.:, became a #ri(ate bank until the bank failed in ,9+,. President 0ndrew ;ackson (etoed
the renewal of the Bank on ;uly ,<, ,9.6. =icholas Biddle was arrested for fraud in Philadel#hia in ,9+,5 howe(er, Biddle was ne(er tried in
court and was e(entually released from #rison.
&resi#ents of the ,ank of the -nite# .tates ((/)(0(1((, (1(20(132"
$homas Willing
President of the Bank of the
'nited $tates (,:-,-,9<:)5
*ayor of Philadel#hia
(,:/.-,:/+)
William Jones
President of the Bank of the
'nited $tates (,9,/-,9,-)5
$ecretary of the =a(y
(,9,.-,9,+)
Lang#on Che4es
President of the Bank of the
'nited $tates (,9,--,966)5
$#eaker of the '.$. ouse of
"e#resentati(es (,9,+-,9,>)
5i+holas ,i##le
President of the Bank of the
'nited $tates (,96.-,9./)5
President of the 'nited $tates
Bank of Pennsyl(ania
(,9.:-,9.-)
3xcerpts of 2resident !ndrew 9ackson-s #arewell !ddress $egarding the )ank of the &nited %tates
;arch 8, /<=>?
+ndrew 'a(kson
2$ecent events have proved that the paper@money system of this country may be used as an engine to undermine your
free institutions, and that those who desire to engross all power in the hands of the few and to govern by corruption or
force are aware of its power and prepared to employ it. Your 1anks now furnish your only (ir(ulating medium! and money is
plenty or s(ar(e a((ording to the 5uantity of notes issued 1y them% &hile they have (apitals not greatly disproportioned to ea(h
other! they are (ompetitors in 1usiness! and no one of them (an e3er(ise dominion over the rest8 and although in the present state
of the (urren(y these 1anks may and do operate in4uriously upon the ha1its of 1usiness! the pe(uniary (on(erns! and the moral
tone of so(iety! yet! from their num1er and dispersed situation! they (an not (om1ine for the purposes of politi(al influen(e! and
whatever may 1e the dispositions of some of them their power of mis(hief must ne(essarily 1e (onfined to a narrow spa(e and
felt only in their immediate neigh1orhoods%
But when the (harter for the Bank of the ;nited <tates was o1tained from Congress it perfe(ted the s(hemes of the paper system
and gave to its advo(ates the position they have struggled to o1tain from the (ommen(ement of the Federal .overnment to the
present hour% The immense (apital and pe(uliar privileges 1estowed upon it ena1led it to e3er(ise despoti( sway over the other
1anks in every part of the (ountry% #rom its superior strength it could seriously injure, if not destroy, the business of any
one of them which might incur its resentment, and it openly claimed for itself the power of regulating the currency
throughout the &nited %tates. In other words, it asserted ;and it undoubtedly possessed? the power to make money plenty
or scarce at its pleasure, at any time and in any *uarter of the &nion, by controlling the issues of other banks and
permitting an expansion or compelling a general contraction of the circulating medium, according to its own will. The
other 1anking institutions were sensi1le of its strength! and they soon generally 1e(ame its o1edient instruments! ready at all
times to e3e(ute its mandates8 and with the 1anks ne(essarily went also that numerous (lass of persons in our (ommer(ial (ities
who depend altogether on 1ank (redits for their solven(y and means of 1usiness! and who are therefore o1liged! for their own
safety! to propitiate the favor of the money power 1y distinguished Aeal and devotion in its servi(e% The result of the illGadvised
legislation whi(h esta1lished this great monopoly was to (on(entrate the whole moneyed power of the ;nion! with its 1oundless
means of (orruption and its numerous dependents! under the dire(tion and (ommand of one a(knowledged head! thus organiAing
this parti(ular interest as one 1ody and se(uring to it unity and (on(ert of a(tion throughout the ;nited <tates! and ena1ling it to
1ring forward upon any o((asion its entire and undivided strength to support or defeat any measure of the .overnment% 6n the
hands of this formida1le power! thus perfe(tly organiAed! was also pla(ed unlimited dominion over the amount of the (ir(ulating
medium! giving it the power to regulate the value of property and the fruits of la1or in every 5uarter of the ;nion! and to 1estow
prosperity or 1ring ruin upon any (ity or se(tion of the (ountry as might 1est (omport with its own interest or poli(y%
&e are not left to (on4e(ture how the moneyed power! thus organiAed and with su(h a weapon in its hands! would 1e likely to
use it% The distress and alarm which pervaded and agitated the whole country when the )ank of the &nited %tates waged
war upon the people in order to compel them to submit to its demands can not yet be forgotten. The ruthless and
unsparing temper with which whole cities and communities were oppressed, individuals impoverished and ruined, and a
scene of cheerful prosperity suddenly changed into one of gloom and despondency ought to be indelibly impressed on the
memory of the people of the &nited %tates. 6f su(h was its power in a time of pea(e! what would it not have 1een in a season
of war! with an enemy at your doors? No nation 1ut the freemen of the ;nited <tates (ould have (ome out vi(torious from su(h a
(ontest8 yet! if you had not (on5uered! the .overnment would have passed from the hands of the many to the hands of the few!
and this organiAed money power from its se(ret (on(lave would have di(tated the (hoi(e of your highest offi(ers and (ompelled
you to make pea(e or war! as 1est suited their own wishes% The forms of your .overnment might for a time have remained! 1ut
its living spirit would have departed from it%
The distress and sufferings inflicted on the people by the bank are some of the fruits of that system of policy which is
continually striving to enlarge the authority of the #ederal Government beyond the limits fixed by the (onstitution. The
powers enumerated in that instrument do not confer on (ongress the right to establish such a corporation as the )ank of
the &nited %tates, and the evil conse*uences which followed may warn us of the danger of departing from the true rule of
construction and of permitting temporary circumstances or the hope of better promoting the public welfare to influence
in any degree our decisions upon the extent of the authority of the General Government. 7et us abide by the (onstitution
as it is written, or amend it in the constitutional mode if it is found to be defective.
The severe lessons of e3perien(e will! 6 dou1t not! 1e suffi(ient to prevent Congress from again (hartering su(h a monopoly!
even if the Constitution did not present an insupera1le o14e(tion to it% But you must remem1er! my fellowG(itiAens! that eternal
vigilance by the people is the price of liberty, and that you must pay the price if you wish to secure the blessing. It
behooves you, therefore, to be watchful in your %tates as well as in the #ederal Government. The power whi(h the
moneyed interest (an e3er(ise! when (on(entrated under a single head and with our present system of (urren(y! was suffi(iently
demonstrated in the struggle made 1y the Bank of the ;nited <tates% )efeated in the .eneral .overnment! the same (lass of
intriguers and politi(ians will now resort to the <tates and endeavor to o1tain there the same organiAation whi(h they failed to
perpetuate in the ;nion8 and with spe(ious and de(eitful plans of pu1li( advantages and <tate interests and <tate pride they will
endeavor to esta1lish in the different <tates one moneyed institution with overgrown (apital and e3(lusive privileges suffi(ient to
ena1le it to (ontrol the operations of the other 1anks% <u(h an institution will 1e pregnant with the same evils produ(ed 1y the
Bank of the ;nited <tates! although its sphere of a(tion is more (onfined! and in the <tate in whi(h it is (hartered the money
power will 1e a1le to em1ody its whole strength and to move together with undivided for(e to a((omplish any o14e(t it may
wish to attain% You have already had a1undant eviden(e of its power to infli(t in4ury upon the agri(ultural! me(hani(al! and
la1oring (lasses of so(iety! and over those whose engagements in trade or spe(ulation render them dependent on 1ank fa(ilities
the dominion of the <tate monopoly will 1e a1solute and their o1edien(e unlimited% &ith su(h a 1ank and a paper (urren(y the
money power would in a few years govern the <tate and (ontrol its measures! and if a suffi(ient num1er of <tates (an 1e indu(ed
to (reate su(h esta1lishments the time will soon (ome when it will again take the field against the ;nited <tates and su((eed in
perfe(ting and perpetuating its organiAation 1y a (harter from Congress%
It is one of the serious evils of our present system of banking that it enables one class of society@@and that by no means a
numerous one@@by its control over the currency, to act injuriously upon the interests of all the others and to exercise more
than its just proportion of influence in political affairs. The agri(ultural! the me(hani(al! and the la1oring (lasses have little
or no share in the dire(tion of the great moneyed (orporations! and from their ha1its and the nature of their pursuits they are
in(apa1le of forming e3tensive (om1inations to a(t together with united for(e% <u(h (on(ert of a(tion may sometimes 1e
produ(ed in a single (ity or in a small distri(t of (ountry 1y means of personal (ommuni(ations with ea(h other! 1ut they have no
regular or a(tive (orresponden(e with those who are engaged in similar pursuits in distant pla(es8 they have 1ut little patronage
to give to the press! and e3er(ise 1ut a small share of influen(e over it8 they have no (rowd of dependents a1out them who hope
to grow ri(h without la1or 1y their (ountenan(e and favor! and who are therefore always ready to e3e(ute their wishes% The
planter! the farmer! the me(hani(! and the la1orer all know that their su((ess depends upon their own industry and e(onomy! and
that they must not e3pe(t to 1e(ome suddenly ri(h 1y the fruits of their toil% Yet these (lasses of so(iety form the great 1ody of
the people of the ;nited <tates8 they are the 1one and sinew of the (ountryGGmen who love li1erty and desire nothing 1ut e5ual
rights and e5ual laws! and who! moreover! hold the great mass of our national wealth! although it is distri1uted in moderate
amounts among the millions of freemen who possess it% But with overwhelming num1ers and wealth on their side they are in
(onstant danger of losing their fair influen(e in the .overnment! and with diffi(ulty maintain their 4ust rights against the
in(essant efforts daily made to en(roa(h upon them% The mis(hief springs from the power whi(h the moneyed interest derives
from a paper (urren(y whi(h they are a1le to (ontrol! from the multitude of (orporations with e3(lusive privileges whi(h they
have su((eeded in o1taining in the different <tates! and whi(h are employed altogether for their 1enefit8 and unless you become
more watchful in your %tates and check this spirit of monopoly and thirst for exclusive privileges you will in the end find
that the most important powers of Government have been given or bartered away, and the control over your dearest
interests has passed into the hands of these corporations.9
+rti(le of the Constitution for the ;nited <tates of +meri(a /<e(tions =G#0
+rti(le ! <e(tion =% *owers of Congress
The Congress shall have *ower To lay and (olle(t Ta3es! )uties! 6mposts and -3(ises! to pay the )e1ts and provide for the (ommon
)efen(e and general &elfare of the ;nited <tates8 1ut all )uties! 6mposts and -3(ises shall 1e uniform throughout the ;nited <tates8
To borrow money on the credit of the &nited %tates,
To regulate Commer(e with foreign Nations! and among the several <tates! and with the 6ndian Tri1es8
To esta1lish an uniform Rule of NaturaliAation! and uniform Caws on the su14e(t of Bankrupt(ies throughout the ;nited <tates8
To coin oney, regulate the Aalue thereof, and of foreign (oin, and fix the %tandard of "eights and easures,
To provide for the 2unishment of counterfeiting the %ecurities and current (oin of the &nited %tates,
To esta1lish *ost Jffi(es and *ost Roads8
To promote the *rogress of <(ien(e and useful +rts! 1y se(uring for limited Times to +uthors and 6nventors the e3(lusive Right to
their respe(tive &ritings and )is(overies8
To (onstitute Tri1unals inferior to the supreme Court8
To define and punish *ira(ies and Felonies (ommitted on the high <eas! and Jffenses against the Caw of Nations8
To de(lare &ar! grant Cetters of Mar5ue and Reprisal! and make Rules (on(erning Captures on Cand and &ater8
To raise and support +rmies! 1ut no +ppropriation of Money to that ;se shall 1e for a longer Term than two Years8
To provide and maintain a Navy8
To make Rules for the .overnment and Regulation of the land and naval For(es8
To provide for (alling forth the Militia to e3e(ute the Caws of the ;nion! suppress 6nsurre(tions and repel 6nvasions8
To provide for organiAing! arming! and dis(iplining the Militia! and for governing su(h *art of them as may 1e employed in the
<ervi(e of the ;nited <tates! reserving to the <tates respe(tively! the +ppointment of the Jffi(ers! and the +uthority of training the
Militia a((ording to the dis(ipline pres(ri1ed 1y Congress8
To e3er(ise e3(lusive Cegislation in all Cases whatsoever! over su(h )istri(t /not e3(eeding ten Miles s5uare0 as may! 1y Cession of
parti(ular <tates! and the a((eptan(e of Congress! 1e(ome the <eat of the .overnment of the ;nited <tates! and to e3er(ise like
+uthority over all *la(es pur(hased 1y the Consent of the Cegislature of the <tate in whi(h the <ame shall 1e! for the -re(tion of Forts!
MagaAines! +rsenals! do(kGYards! and other needful Buildings8 +nd
To make all Caws whi(h shall 1e ne(essary and proper for (arrying into -3e(ution the foregoing *owers! and all other *owers vested
1y this Constitution in the .overnment of the ;nited <tates! or in any )epartment or Jffi(er thereof%
+rti(le ! <e(tion F%
The Migration or 6mportation of su(h *ersons as any of the <tates now e3isting shall think proper to admit! shall not 1e prohi1ited 1y
the Congress prior to the Year one thousand eight hundred and eight! 1ut a ta3 or duty may 1e imposed on su(h 6mportation! not
e3(eeding ten dollars for ea(h *erson%
The privilege of the &rit of 7a1eas Corpus shall not 1e suspended! unless when in Cases of Re1ellion or 6nvasion the pu1li( <afety
may re5uire it%
No Bill of +ttainder or e3 post fa(to Caw shall 1e passed%
/No (apitation! or other dire(t! Ta3 shall 1e laid! unless in *roportion to the Census or -numeration herein 1efore dire(ted to 1e taken%0
/<e(tion in parentheses modified 1y +mendment O,6%0
No Ta3 or )uty shall 1e laid on +rti(les e3ported from any <tate%
No *referen(e shall 1e given 1y any Regulation of Commer(e or Revenue to the *orts of one <tate over those of another: nor shall
,essels 1ound to! or from! one <tate! 1e o1liged to enter! (lear! or pay )uties in another%
Bo oney shall be drawn from the Treasury, but in (onse*uence of !ppropriations made by 7aw, and a regular %tatement
and !ccount of the $eceipts and 3xpenditures of all public oney shall be published from time to time.
No Title of No1ility shall 1e granted 1y the ;nited <tates: +nd no *erson holding any Jffi(e of *rofit or Trust under them! shall!
without the Consent of the Congress! a((ept of any present! -molument! Jffi(e! or Title! of any kind whatever! from any Bing! *rin(e
or foreign <tate%
+rti(le ! <e(tion #%
Bo %tate shall enter into any Treaty, !lliance, or (onfederation, grant 7etters of ar*ue and $eprisal, coin oney, emit )ills
of (redit, make any Thing but gold and silver (oin a Tender in 2ayment of Cebts, pass any )ill of !ttainder, ex post facto
7aw, or 7aw impairing the +bligation of (ontracts, or grant any Title of Bobility.
No <tate shall! without the Consent of the Congress! lay any 6mposts or )uties on 6mports or -3ports! e3(ept what may 1e a1solutely
ne(essary for e3e(uting itIs inspe(tion Caws: and the net *rodu(e of all )uties and 6mposts! laid 1y any <tate on 6mports or -3ports!
shall 1e for the ;se of the Treasury of the ;nited <tates8 and all su(h Caws shall 1e su14e(t to the Revision and Controul of the
Congress%
No <tate shall! without the Consent of Congress! lay any duty of Tonnage! keep Troops! or <hips of &ar in time of *ea(e! enter into
any +greement or Compa(t with another <tate! or with a foreign *ower! or engage in &ar! unless a(tually invaded! or in su(h
imminent )anger as will not admit of delay%
+meri(an National )e1t sin(e HF
'anuary ! HF G PHL!$?>!$H?%L"
'anuary ! HF" G PHH!""H!F"$%??
'anuary ! HF> G P=#!>L=!?>$%#$
'anuary ! HF$ G PH=!$"H!$#$%HH
'anuary ! HFL G P=#!H$H!L=H%>F
'anuary ! HF? G P=>!H?"!H"%#H
'anuary ! HFH G P="!#?$!$HF%>>
'anuary ! HF= G PHF!""=!L"F%"
'anuary ! HFF G PH=!$#=!??F%HH
'anuary ! =## G P="!FH?!"F$%>L
'anuary ! =# G P=>!#>=!#L#%=#
'anuary ! =#" G P=#!H"!?>"%"L
'anuary ! =#> G PHH!#L$!?=?%$#
'anuary ! =#$ G P=?!$"H!"#%==
'anuary ! =#L G P="!>"!L#%L#
'anuary ! =#? G PHL!H">!"H#%??
'anuary ! =#H G P?F!"=!>F=%?$
'anuary ! =#= G P?L!F?!>H%FH
'anuary ! =#F G PLH!#">!F"%#F
'anuary ! =# G PL>!H>!"H%L"
'anuary ! = G P$=!##L!L=H%H?
'anuary ! =" G P$L!"#F!H>H%F#
'anuary ! => G PLL!F?"!="H%LH
'anuary ! =$ G P=!$=H!=$?%"$
'anuary ! =L G PFF!=>>!??#%L
'anuary ! =? G P"H!>>$!F>>%H$
'anuary ! =H G P">!$F!F?L%?
'anuary ! == G P#>!$??!?>>%=>
'anuary ! =F G PFL!L"F!?$=%"=
'anuary ! ="# G PF!#L!L??%L
'anuary ! =" G P=F!F=H!$"H%??
'anuary ! ="" G PF>!L$?!?H?%F=
'anuary ! ="> G PF#!=HL!=HH%"=
'anuary ! ="$ G PF#!"?F!HHH%HH
'anuary ! ="L G P=>!H==!$>"%H
'anuary ! ="? G P=!#L$!#LF%FF
'anuary ! ="H G PH>!F=H!>LH%"#
'anuary ! ="= G P?H!$HL!#$>%=H
'anuary ! ="F G PL=!$"!$>%?H
'anuary ! =># G P$=!L?L!$#?%L#
'anuary ! => G P>F!">!F%?=
'anuary ! =>" G P"$!>""!">L%=
'anuary ! =>> G P H!##!?F=%=>
'anuary ! =>$ G P $!H?#!#="%#=
'anuary ! =>L G P >>!H>>%#L
'anuary ! =>? G P >H!L>%#L
'anuary ! =>H G P >>?!FLH%=>
'anuary ! =>= G P >!>#=!"$%#H
'anuary ! =>F G P#!$>$!""%$
'anuary ! =$# G P >!LH>!>$>%="
'anuary ! =$ G P L!"L#!=HL%L$
'anuary ! =$" G P>!LF$!$=#%H>
'anuary ! =$> G P"#!"#!""?%"H
'uly ! =$> G P>"!H$"!F""%##
'uly ! =$$ G P">!$?!?L"%L#
'uly ! =$L G PL!F"L!>#>%#
'uly ! =$? G PL!LL#!"#"%FH
'uly ! =$H G P>=!="?!L>$%HH
'uly ! =$= G P$H!#$$!=?"%">
'uly ! =$F G P ?>!#?!=L=%?F
'uly ! =L# G P ?>!$L"!HH>%LL
'uly ! =L G P ?=!>#$!HF?%#"
'uly ! =L" G P ??!FF!>$%H
'uly ! =L> G P LF!=#>!H%H#
'uly ! =L$ G P $"!"$"!"""%$"
'uly ! =LL G P >L!L=?!FL?%L?
'uly ! =L? G P >!FH"!L>H%F#
'uly ! =LH G P "=!?FF!=>%=L
'uly ! =L= G P $$!F!==%#>
'uly ! =LF G P L=!$F?!=>H%==
'uly ! =?# G P ?$!=$"!"=H%==
'uly ! =? G P F#!L=#!=H>%H"
'uly ! =?" G P L"$!H?!$"%>
'uly ! =?> G P!F!HH"!>=%?>
'uly ! =?L G P"!?=#!?$H!=?F%H$
'uly ! =?? G P"!HH>!">?!H>%?F
'uly ! =?H G P"!?H=!"?!#>%=H
'uly ! =?= G P"!?!?=H!=L%F
'uly ! =?F G P"!L==!$L"!">%F$
'uly ! =H# G P"!$=#!?H"!$"H%=
'uly ! =H G P"!>L>!"!>>"%>"
'uly ! =H" G P"!"L>!"L!>"=%H=
'uly ! =H> G P"!">$!$="!FF>%"#
'uly ! =H$ G P"!"L!?F#!$?=%$>
'uly ! =HL G P"!">"!"=$!L>%FL
'uly ! =H? G P"!=#!>FL!#?H%L
'uly ! =HH G P"!"#L!>#!>F"%#
'uly ! =H= G P"!"L?!"#L!=F"%L>
'uly ! =HF G P"!>$F!L?H!$="%#$
'uly ! ==# G P"!"#!$L!>H#%?>
'uly ! == G P"!#?F!#>!L?F%L=
'uly ! ==" G P!F=!>"!FF$%#>
'uly ! ==> G P!==$!H!H"=%#H
'uly ! ==$ G P!=>#!L"=!F">%LH
'uly ! ==L G P!=?>!F?$!=H>%$
'uly ! ==? G P!HHL!#?>!#>%H=
'uly ! ==H G P!?LH!?#"!LF"%?>
'uly ! === G P!?F"!=L=!F=$%L=
'uly ! ==F G P!?F!#L"!F""%">
'uly ! =F# G P!LL"!$#!"#$%H>
'uly ! =F G P!L$L!FF?!LF%?
'uly ! =F" G P!L==!$?$!$$%?>
'uly ! =F> G P!L$L!F=L!?=?%>
'uly ! =F$ G P!?>"!"L>!?>?%?=
'uly ! =FL G P!?H?!"#!F=>%"L
'uly ! =F? G P!H?F!=$#!>">%$#
'uly ! =FH G P!=H!?H"!??L%F#
'uly ! =F= G P!HF?!L>!FFL%F#
'uly ! =FF G P!FF!F"H!>#?%F"
'uly ! F## G P"!>?!F?!#F%?H
'uly ! F# G P"!$>!>"?!F>>%=F
'uly ! F#" G P"!L=!?#!$$L%=F
'uly ! F#> G P"!"#"!$?$!H=%=F
'uly ! F#$ G P"!"?$!##>!L=L%$
'uly ! F#L G P"!"H$!?L!#?>%=$
'uly ! F#? G P"!>>H!?!=>F%#$
'uly ! F#H G P"!$LH!==!#?%L$
'uly ! F#= G P"!?"?!=#?!"H%L$
'uly ! F#F G P"!?>F!L$?!"$%#$
'uly ! F# G P"!?L"!??L!=>=%#$
'uly ! F G P"!H?L!?##!?#?%?F
'uly ! F" G P"!=?=!>H>!=H$%?
'uly ! F> G P"!F?!"#$!F>%??
'uly ! F$ G P"!F"!$FF!"?F%?
'uly ! FL G P>!#L=!>?!=H>%?
'uly ! F? G P>!?#F!"$$!"?"%?
'uly ! FH G PL!HH!HH#!"HF%L"
'uly ! F= G P$!LF"!?!$$%##
'uly ! FF G P"H!>F#!FH#!>%"
'uly ! F"# G P"L!FL"!$L?!$#?%?
'une >#! F" G P">!FHH!$L#!LL"%L$
'une >#! F"" G P""!F?>!>=!H#=%>
'une >#! F"> G P""!>$F!H#H!>?L%>?
'une >#! F"$ G P"!"L#!="!F=F%$F
'une >#! F"L G P"#!L?!F>!==H%F#
'une >#! F"? G PF!?$>!"?!>L%F
'une >#! F"H G P=!L!F#?!F>%=L
'une >#! F"= G PH!?#$!"F>!"#%$>
'une "F! F"F G P?!F>!#==!$=$%#
'une >#! F># G P?!=L!>#F!=>%$>
'une >#! F> G P?!=#!"=!$F%H
'une >#! F>" G PF!$=H!##"!$$$%>
'une >#! F>> G P""!L>=!?H"!L?#%L
'une >#! F>$ G P"H!#L>!$!$$%$=
'une "F! F>L G P"=!H##!=F"!?"$%L>
'une >#! F>? G P>>!HH=!L$>!$F>%H>
'une >#! F>H G P>?!$"$!?>!H>"%"F
'une >#! F>= G P>H!?$!H$#!>L%$L
'une >#! F>F G P$#!$>F!L>"!$%
'une "F! F$# G P$"!F?H!L>!#>H%?=
'une >#! F$ G P$=!F?!$$>!L>L%H
'une >#! F$" G PH"!$""!$$L!?%""
'une >#! F$> G P>?!?F?!#F#!>"F%F#
'une >#! F$$ G P"#!##>!>=H!""%>
'une >#! F$L G P"L=!?="!=H!$#F%F>
'une "=! F$? G P"?F!$""!#FF!H>%"?
'une >#! F$H G P"L=!"=?!>=>!#=%?H
'une >#! F$= G P"L"!"F"!"$?!L"%FF
'une >#! F$F G P"L"!HH#!>LF!=?#%>>
'une >#! FL# G P"LH!>LH!>L"!>L%#$
'une "F! FL G P"LL!""!FH?!=$%F>
'une >#! FL" G P"LF!#L!H=!H=L%$>
'une >#! FL> G P"??!#H!#?!?>=%LH
'une >#! FL$ G P"H!"LF!LFF!#=%$?
'une >#! FLL G P"H$!>H$!"""!=#"%?"
'une >#! FL? G P"H"!HL#!=>!?$F%>"
'une >#! FLH G P"H#!L"H!H!=F?%$>
'une >#! FL= G P"H?!>$>!"H!H$L%=
'une >#! FLF G P"=$!H#L!F#H!#H=%""
'une >#! F?# G P"=?!>>#!H?#!=$=%>H
'une >#! F? G P"==!FH#!F>=!?#%#L
'une >#! F?" G P"F=!"##!=""!H"#%=H
'une >#! F?> G P>#L!=LF!?>"!FF?%$
'une >#! F?$ G P>!H"!=FF!"LH%>#
'une >#! F?L G P>H!"H>!=F=!F=>%?$
'une >#! F?? G P>F!F#H!#=H!HFL%$=
'une >#! F?H G P>"?!""#!F>H!HF$%L$
'une >#! F?= G P>$H!LH=!$#?!$"L%==
'une >#! F?F G P>L>!H"#!"L>!=$%$
'une >#! FH# G P>H#!F=!H#?!F$F%F>
'une >#! FH G P>F=!"F!H$$!$LL%L$
'une >#! FH" G P$"H!"?#!$?#!F$#%L#
'une >#! FH> G P$L=!$!?#L!>"%#F
'une >#! FH$ G P$HL!#LF!=L!H>%LL
'une >#! FHL G PL>>!=F!###!###%##Q
'une >#! FH? G P?"#!$>>!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! FHH G P?F=!=$#!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! FH= G PHH!L$$!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! FHF G P="?!LF!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! F=# G PF#H!H#!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! F= GPFFH!=LL!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! F=" G P!$"!#>$!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! F=> G P!>HH!"#!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! F=$ G P!LH"!"??!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! F=L G P!=">!#>!###!###%##Q
<eptem1er >#! F=? G P"!"L!>#"!??!?L=%$"
<eptem1er >#! F=H GP"!>L#!"H?!=F#!FL>%##
<eptem1er >#! F== G P"!?#"!>>H!H"!#$%?
<eptem1er "F! F=F G P"!=LH!$>#!F?#!=H%>"
<eptem1er "=! FF# G P>!">>!>>!$L!HHH%"L
<eptem1er >#! FF G P>!??L!>#>!>L!?FH%#>
<eptem1er >#! FF" G P$!#?$!?"#!?LL!L"%??
<eptem1er >#! FF> G P$!$!$==!==>!>F%>=
<eptem1er >#! FF$ G P$!?F"!H$F!F#!#>%>"
<eptem1er "F! FFL G P$!FH>!F="!F##!H#F%>F
<eptem1er >#! FF? G PL!""$!=#!F>F!>L%H>
<eptem1er >#! FFH G PL!$>!$?!#!>FH%>$
<eptem1er >#! FF= G PL!L"?!F>!##=!=FH%?"
<eptem1er >#! FFF G PL!?L?!"H#!F#!?L%$>
<eptem1er >#! "### G PL!?H$!H=!"#F!==?%=?
<eptem1er >#! "## G PL!=#H!$?>!$"!"##%#?
<eptem1er >#! "##" G P?!""=!">L!F?L!LFH%?
<eptem1er >#! "##> G P?!H=>!">!#?"!H$>%?"
<eptem1er >#! "##$ G PH!>HF!#L"!?F?!>>#%>"
<eptem1er >#! "##L G PH!F>"!H#F!??!H">%L#
<eptem1er >#! "##? G P=!L#?!FH>!=FF!"L%">
<eptem1er >#! "##H G PF!##H!?L>!>H"!"?"%$=
<eptem1er >#! "##= G P#!#"$!H"$!=F?!F"%$F
<eptem1er >#! "##F G P!F#F!="F!##>!L%HL
<eptem1er >#! "## G P>!L?!?">!#>#!=F%HF
<eptem1er >#! "# G P$!HF#!>$#!>"=!LLH%L
<eptem1er >#! "#" G P?!#??!"$!$#H!>=L%=F
'uly ! =?$ G P!=L!H=$!>H#%LH
Fe#eral 6eser4e7 Wall .treet 6obber ,arons
% 1ash 1ow for the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations?
Ceft to right: Federal Reserve ,i(e Chairman 'anet Yellen! former Federal Reserve Board Chairman *aul +dolph ,olker!
former Federal Reserve Board Chairman <ir +lan .reenspan! and outgoing Federal Reserve Board Chairman Ben Bernanke
listen to remarks during the Federal Reserve (entennial (ommemoration at the Federal Reserve 1uilding in &ashington! )%C% on
)e(em1er ?! "#>% /+((ording to the Chinese (alendar! "#> is known as Year of the <nake%0 The Federal Reserve marked its
##th anniversary with a (ommemoration (eremony featuring the past! outgoing! and in(oming (hairmen of the Federal Reserve%
9anet Dellen, 2aul !dolph Aolcker, and %ir !lan Greenspan are members of the (ouncil on #oreign $elations, a private
foreign affairs organi'ation in Bew Dork (ity. /*hoto 1y Mark &[email protected] 6mages0
Federal Reserve 1ankers pose for a group portrait at the Federal Reserve head5uarters in &ashington! )%C% on 'une ?! "#$%
From left to right: 'erome 7% *owell! Federal Reserve Chairman )r% 'anet Yellen! )r% Cael Brainard! and Federal Reserve ,i(e
Chairman )r% <tanley Fis(her% +ll four individuals are mem1ers of the Coun(il on Foreign Relations! a private organiAation in
New York City% )r% Cael Brainard and )r% <tanley Fis(her were mem1ers of the Trilateral Commission%
/*hoto: Federal Reserve0
Dr. $tanley 4ischer (right) is sworn in as a *ember of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem by 4ederal
"eser(e 1hairman Dr. ;anet &ellen on *ay 69, 6<,+. $tanley 4ischer, a dual citi2en of 0merica and 8srael, ser(ed as the
@o(ernor of the Bank of 8srael (8srael)s central bank) from 6<<> until 6<,.. (Photo7 4ederal "eser(e)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Dr. ;anet &ellen (left) swears in Dr. $tanley 4ischer as Aice 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e in
Washington, D.1. on ;une ,/, 6<,+. (Photo7 4ederal "eser(e)
1urrent and former 4ederal "eser(e Bank Presidents and current and former 4ederal "eser(e 1hairmen #ose for a grou# #ortrait on *ay ,,
6<,+. 4ront row7 William 1. Dudley (.
rd
left), ;anet L. &ellen (+
th
left), 0lan @reens#an (>
th
left), Ben Bernanke (/
th
left), B. @erald 1orrigan (far
right). Paul 0. Aolcker a##ears on the far left in the third row5 !imothy 4. @eithner a##ears .
rd
from left in the third row.
(Photo7 4ederal "eser(e)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman ;anet &ellen (center) shakes hands with 4ederal "eser(e Board @o(ernor Daniel !arullo (left) after she was sworn
in as 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman, as her husband @eorge 0kerlof (right) stands nearby, at the 4ederal "eser(e Building in Washington, D.1.
on 4ebruary ., 6<,+. ;anet &ellen re#laced Ben Bernanke as 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e. ;anet &ellen and Daniel !arullo are members
of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (Photo by *ark WilsonC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke smiles before deli(ering remarks to the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations in Washington,
D.1. on *arch ,<, 6<<-. ("euters)
Ben <halom Bernanke! Chairman of the Federal Reserve! meets with other Federal Reserve 1ankers at a Federal Reserve 1oard
meeting in "##F% *rominent Federal Reserve 1ankers attending the meeting in(lude: &illiam C% )udley /*resident of the
Federal Reserve Bank of New York0! )onald Bohn /,i(e Chairman of the Federal Reserve0! )aniel Tarullo /Mem1er of the
Federal Reserve Board0! and Bevin &arsh /Mem1er of the Federal Reserve Board0% /Federal Reserve photo0
Ben <halom Bernanke /left0! Chairman of the Federal Reserve! meets with other Federal Reserve 1ankers at a Federal Reserve
1oard meeting% Jther Federal Reserve 1ankers in(lude 'anet Yellen /"
nd
left! ,i(e Chairman of the Federal Reserve0 and )aniel
Tarullo /"
nd
right! Mem1er of the Federal Reserve Board0% 9anet Dellen and Caniel Tarullo are members of the (ouncil on
#oreign $elations, a private organi'ation in Bew Dork (ity. /'im &atson@+gen(e Fran(eG*[email protected] 6mages0
The Board of .overnors hold an open 1oard meeting on )e(em1er $! "#" to dis(uss proposed rules to implement the
enhan(ed prudential standards and early remediation re5uirements of se(tions ?L and ?? of the )oddGFrank +(t for foreign
1anking organiAations and foreign non1ank finan(ial (ompanies% /*hoto: Federal Reserve0
!he 4ederal "eser(e Board of @o(ernors hold an o#en board meeting on December ,+, 6<,6 to discuss #ro#osed rules to im#lement the
enhanced #rudential standards and early remediation reDuirements of sections ,/> and ,// of the Dodd-4rank 0ct for foreign banking
organi2ations and foreign nonbank financial com#anies. 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke and 4ederal "eser(e Aice 1hairman ;anet
&ellen #reside o(er the meeting. (Photo7 4ederal "eser(e)
4ormer 1hairmen of the 4ederal "eser(e $ir 0lan @reens#an (left) and Paul Aolcker share a laugh while #artici#ating in a #anel discussion on
ca#ital markets at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity in Washington, D.1. on *arch ,., 6<<:. .ir 8lan reenspan an# &aul 9ol+ker are members of
the Coun+il on Foreign 6elations, a pri4ate organi:ation in 5ew ;ork Cit!. (Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
8lan reenspan & Frien#s at the Fe#eral 6eser4e
(Photo7 Back From the Brink: The Greenspan Years by $te(en E. Beckner)
2In addition to these pragmatic goals, the powers of financial capitalism had another far@reaching aim, nothing less than
to create a world system of financial control in private hands able to dominate the political system of each country and
the economy of the world as a whole. This system was to be controlled in a feudalist fashion by the central banks of the
world acting in concert, by secret agreements arrived at in fre*uent private meetings and conferences. The ape3 of the
system was to 1e the Bank for 6nternational <ettlements in Basle! <witAerland! a private 1ank owned and (ontrolled 1y the
worldEs (entral 1anks whi(h were themselves private corporations% -a(h (entral 1ank! in the hands of men like Montagu
Norman of the Bank of -ngland! Ben4amin <trong of the New York Federal Reserve Bank! Charles Rist of the Bank of Fran(e!
and 74almar <(ha(ht of the Rei(hs1ank! sought to dominate its government by its ability to control Treasury loans, to
manipulate foreign exchanges, to influence the level of economic activity in the country, and to influence cooperative
politicians by subse*uent economic rewards in the business world. In each country the power of the central bank rested
largely on its control of credit and money supply. In the world as a whole the power of the central bankers rested very
largely on their control of loans and of gold flows.9 : Tragedy and Hope 1y )r% Carroll Ruigley! p% >"$
Note: )r% Carroll Ruigley was a professor of history at .eorgetown ;niversity in &ashington! )%C%8 one of )r% RuigleyEs
students was Bill Clinton! the former *resident of the ;nited <tates
($ource7 Back From the Brink: The Greenspan Years by $te(en E. Beckner)
($ource7 Back From the Brink: The Greenspan Years by $te(en E. Beckner)
Left #hoto7 @old (ault of 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork. @old bars are held in ,66 com#artments in the main and au3illary
(aults. (Photo7 htt#7CCgonyc.about.comCodC#hotogalleriesCigC4ederal-"eser(e-Bank-PicturesC*o([email protected])
"ight #hoto7 F(er G6 million in foreign gold are counted by HsittersH in the bottom most (ault, (:/ feet below the busy financial district), of the
4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork in =ew &ork 1ity on *arch ,9, ,-/9. Bach gold bar weighed between 6: and 69 #ounds and was worth
G,+,<<< (in ,-/9 dollars). F(er one Duarter of all the official monetary gold of the free world--about G,..+ billion worth--is stored in ,6<
com#artments held by o(er :< countries and watched constantly by Hsitters.H $ales occasion freDuent transfers and gold is shifted bar by bar
from one to another of the com#artments. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
2Yeah! itEs interestingSthe former head of .oldman <a(hs! 'ohn &hitehead! was also the former head of the New York Federal
Reserve% +nd 6 met with him! and he said as soon as the Fed stops 1uying all the de1t that weEre issuingNwhi(h theyEve 1een doing!
the FedEs 1uying like threeG5uarters of the de1t that +meri(a issues% 7e said! on(e thatEs over! he said weEre going to have a failed
Treasury au(tion! interest rates are going to have to go up% &eEre living in this 1orrowed fantasy world! where the government keeps
on 1orrowing money% You know! we 1orrow this e3tra trillion a year! we wonder whoEs loaning us the trillion? The Chinese arenEt
loaning us anymore% The Russians arenEt loaning it to us anymore% <o whoEs giving us the trillion? +nd the answer is weEre 4ust
making it up% The Federal Reserve is 4ust taking it and saying! 27ere! weEre giving it%E 6tEs 4ust made up money! and this does not augur
well for our e(onomi( future% You know! some of these things are (omple3 enough itEs not easy for people to understand! 1ut your
point of saying! 1ankrupt(y usually (on(entrates the mind%9
: Mitt Romney! "#" presidential (andidate for the Repu1li(an *arty! in a spee(h that was se(retly videotaped in "#" /2$HM of the
*eople ,ideo90
2There are $H per(ent of the people who will vote for the president no matter what% +ll right! there are $H per(ent who are with him!
who are dependent upon government! who 1elieve that they are vi(tims! who 1elieve the government has a responsi1ility to (are for
them! who 1elieve that they are entitled to health (are! to food! to housing! to youGnameGit GG that thatIs an entitlement% +nd the
government should give it to them% +nd they will vote for this president no matter what% %%% These are people who pay no in(ome ta3% %%%
TMUy 4o1 is not to worry a1out those people% 6Ill never (onvin(e them they should take personal responsi1ility and (are for their lives%9
: Mitt Romney! "#" presidential (andidate for the Repu1li(an *arty! in a spee(h that was se(retly videotaped in "#" /2$HM of the
*eople ,ideo90
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Ben Bernanke (>th ") chairs a meeting of the 4ederal F#en *arket 1ommittee, the 4ederal "eser(eIs
interest rate-setting body, in Washington, D.1. in this *arch ,:, 6<<- #icture released on *arch ,-, 6<<-. !he 4ederal "eser(e announced
the #urchase of longer-dated !reasury securities to hel# end a dee#ening '.$. recession.
("B'!B"$C;oe Pa(elC4ederal "eser(e BoardCandout)
0n em#loyee hauls a set of gold bars inside the gold (ault at the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork in =ew &ork 1ity on ;une 6,, 6<<9.
(J "andy FlsonC=ational @eogra#hic $ocietyC1orbis)
2The real truth of the matter is! as you and 6 know! that a finan(ial element in the large (enters has
owned the government ever sin(e the days of +ndrew 'a(kson%9
: ;%<% *resident Franklin )% Roosevelt! from a Novem1er ">! F>> letter to -dward Mandell 7ouse
=ew $eries 6<<, one dollar bill notes #ass through a #rinting #ress on =o(ember 6,, 6<<, at the Bureau of Bngra(ing and Printing in
Washington, D.1. !he new dollar bills contain the signatures of '.$. !reasury $ecretary Paul FII=eill and '.$. !reasurer "osario *arin.
(Photo by 0le3 WongC@etty 8mages)
+ Vim1a1we man named +le3 Mupondi hangs oneGdollar Federal Reserve Notes on a drying line after washing them in 7arare!
Vim1a1we on 'uly ?! "##% The washing ma(hine (y(le takes a1out $L minutes! and 2.eorge &ashington9 oneGdollar 1ills
(ome out mu(h (leaner than 1efore in Vim1a1weGstyle laundering of dirty money% Vim1a1weans suffer from hyperinflation
after the Muga1e regime massGprodu(ed their own 1ank notes8 Vim1a1weans now use +meri(an (urren(y as legal tender in an
attempt to (ur1 e(onomi( inflation in their own nation% /+* *hoto0
Co(als sell pirated C)Es from the street for ;%<% dollars in )ili! -ast Timor on <eptem1er ! "##% The ;%<% dollar is the offi(ial
(urren(y of -ast Timor% -ast Timor is a former *ortuguese (olony and a former provin(e of 6ndonesia% /.etty 6mages0
Fwen D. &oung watches Bmile *oreau (left),@o(ernor of the Bank of 4rance, shake hands with Kalmar $chacht (right), President of
the "eichsbank, in ,-6- after they acce#ted the terms of the &oung Plan. Kalmar $chacht was tried in =uremberg, @ermany for war
crimes and collaboration with the =a2is after World War 88. Fwen D. &oung was the 1hairman of the board of @eneral Blectric
1om#any (,-66-,-.-, ,-+6-,-++), <eput! Chairman of the Fe#eral 6eser4e ,ank of 5ew ;ork (()*/0()3/", Chairman of the
Fe#eral 6eser4e ,ank of 5ew ;ork (()310()=>", Director of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations (,-6:-,-+<), and !rustee of the
"ockefeller 4oundation (,-69-,-.-). (Photo7 Owen D. Young: A New Type of Inustria! "eaer by 8da *. !arbell)
680 F.2d 1239
John L. LEWIS, !ainti""#A$$%!!ant,
&.
'(I)E* S)A)ES o" A+%ri,a, *%"%ndant#A$$%!!%%.
No. 80-5905.
United States Court of Appeals,
Ninth Circuit.
Submitted March 2, 1982.
Decided April 19, 1982.
As Amended une 2!, 1982.
Cafayette C% Blair! Compton! Cal%! for plaintiff@appellant%
'ames R% <ullivan! +sst% ;% <% +tty%! Cos +ngeles! Cal%! argued! for defendant@appellee8 +ndrea <heridan Jrdin! ;% <% +tty%! Cos +ngeles!
Cal%! on 1rief%
+ppeal from the ;nited <tates )istri(t Court for the Central )istri(t of California%
Before *JJC- and BJJC7-,-R! Cir(uit 'udges! and <JCJMJN! )istri(t 'udge%Q
*JJC-! Cir(uit 'udge:
-n Ju!. 2/, 19/9, a$$%!!ant John L%0is 0as in1ur%d 2. a &%hi,!% o0n%d and o$%rat%d 2. th% Los Ang%!%s 2ran,h o" th% F%d%ra!
3%s%r&% Ban4 o" San Fran,is,o. L%0is 2rought this a,tion in distri,t ,ourt a!!%ging 1urisdi,tion und%r th% F%d%ra! )ort 5!ai+s A,t
6th% A,t7, 28 '.S.5. 8 1396627. )h% 'nit%d Stat%s +o&%d to dis+iss "or !a,4 o" su21%,t +att%r 1urisdi,tion. )h% distri,t ,ourt
dis+iss%d, ho!ding that th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 is not a "%d%ra! ag%n,. 0ithin th% +%aning o" th% A,t and that th% ,ourt
th%r%"or% !a,4%d su21%,t +att%r 1urisdi,tion. W% a""ir+.
In %na,ting th% F%d%ra! )ort 5!ai+s A,t, 5ongr%ss $ro&id%d a !i+it%d 0ai&%r o" th% so&%r%ign i++unit. o" th% 'nit%d Stat%s "or
,%rtain torts o" "%d%ra! %+$!o.%%s. 'nit%d Stat%s &. -r!%ans, 92: '.S. 80/, 813, 96 S.5t. 19/1, 19/:, 98 L.Ed.2d 390 619/67.
S$%,i"i,a!!., th% A,t ,r%at%s !ia2i!it. "or in1uri%s ;,aus%d 2. th% n%g!ig%nt or 0rong"u! a,t or o+ission; o" an %+$!o.%% o" an.
"%d%ra! ag%n,. a,ting 0ithin th% s,o$% o" his o""i,% or %+$!o.+%nt. 28 '.S.5. 88 1396627, 26/1. ;F%d%ra! ag%n,.; is d%"in%d as<
th% %=%,uti&% d%$art+%nts, th% +i!itar. d%$art+%nts, ind%$%nd%nt %sta2!ish+%nts o" th% 'nit%d Stat%s, and ,or$orations a,ting
$ri+ari!. as instru+%nta!iti%s o" th% 'nit%d Stat%s, 2ut do%s not in,!ud% an. ,ontra,tors 0ith th% 'nit%d Stat%s.
28 '.S.5. 8 26/1. )h% !ia2i!it. o" th% 'nit%d Stat%s "or th% n%g!ig%n,% o" a F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 %+$!o.%% d%$%nds, th%r%"or%, on
0h%th%r th% Ban4 is a "%d%ra! ag%n,. und%r 8 26/1.
)h%r% ar% no shar$ ,rit%ria "or d%t%r+ining 0h%th%r an %ntit. is a "%d%ra! ag%n,. 0ithin th% +%aning o" th% A,t, 2ut th% ,riti,a!
"a,tor is th% %=ist%n,% o" "%d%ra! go&%rn+%nt ,ontro! o&%r th% ;d%tai!%d $h.si,a! $%r"or+an,%; and ;da. to da. o$%ration; o" that
%ntit.. 'nit%d Stat%s &. -r!%ans, 92: '.S. 80/, 819, 96 S.5t. 19/1, 19/:, 98 L.Ed.2d 390 619/67, Logu% &. 'nit%d Stat%s, 912 '.S.
:21, :28, 93 S.5t. 221:, 2219, 3/ L.Ed.2d 121 619/37. -th%r "a,tors ,ourts ha&% ,onsid%r%d in,!ud% 0h%th%r th% %ntit. is an
ind%$%nd%nt ,or$oration, %ar! &. 'nit%d Stat%s, 230 F.2d 293 610th 5ir. 19:67, Fr%%!ing &. F%d%ra! *%$osit Insuran,%
5or$oration, 221 F.Su$$. 9:: 6W.*.-4!a.19627, a"">d $%r ,uria+, 326 F.2d 9/1 610th 5ir. 19637, 0h%th%r th% go&%rn+%nt is
in&o!&%d in th% %ntit.>s "inan,%s. ?oddard &. *istri,t o" 5o!u+2ia 3%d%&%!o$+%nt Land Ag%n,., 28/ F.2d 393, 39:
6*.5.5ir.19617, ,%rt. d%ni%d, 366 '.S. 910, 81 S.5t. 108:, 6 L.Ed.2d 23: 619617, Fr%%!ing &. F%d%ra! *%$osit Insuran,%
5or$oration, 221 F.Su$$. 9::, and 0h%th%r th% +ission o" th% %ntit. "urth%rs th% $o!i,. o" th% 'nit%d Stat%s, ?oddard &. *istri,t
o" 5o!u+2ia 3%d%&%!o$+%nt Land Ag%n,., 28/ F.2d at 39:. E=a+ining th% organi@ation and "un,tion o" th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&%
Ban4s, and a$$!.ing th% r%!%&ant "a,tors, 0% ,on,!ud% that th% 3%s%r&% Ban4s ar% not "%d%ra! instru+%nta!iti%s "or $ur$os%s o"
th% F)5A, 2ut ar% ind%$%nd%nt, $ri&at%!. o0n%d and !o,a!!. ,ontro!!%d ,or$orations.
Ea,h F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 is a s%$arat% ,or$oration o0n%d 2. ,o++%r,ia! 2an4s in its r%gion. )h% sto,4ho!ding ,o++%r,ia!
2an4s %!%,t t0o thirds o" %a,h Ban4>s nin% +%+2%r 2oard o" dir%,tors. )h% r%+aining thr%% dir%,tors ar% a$$oint%d 2. th%
F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Board. )h% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Board r%gu!at%s th% 3%s%r&% Ban4s, 2ut dir%,t su$%r&ision and ,ontro! o" %a,h Ban4
is %=%r,is%d 2. its 2oard o" dir%,tors. 12 '.S.5. 8 301. )h% dir%,tors %na,t 2.A!a0s r%gu!ating th% +ann%r o" ,ondu,ting g%n%ra!
Ban4 2usin%ss, 12 '.S.5. 8 391, and a$$oint o""i,%rs to i+$!%+%nt and su$%r&is% dai!. Ban4 a,ti&iti%s. )h%s% a,ti&iti%s in,!ud%
,o!!%,ting and ,!%aring ,h%,4s, +a4ing ad&an,%s to $ri&at% and ,o++%r,ia! %ntiti%s, ho!ding r%s%r&%s "or +%+2%r 2an4s,
dis,ounting th% not%s o" +%+2%r 2an4s, and 2u.ing and s%!!ing s%,uriti%s on th% o$%n +ar4%t. S%% 12 '.S.5. 88 391A361.
Ea,h Ban4 is statutori!. %+$o0%r%d to ,ondu,t th%s% a,ti&iti%s 0ithout da. to da. dir%,tion "ro+ th% "%d%ra! go&%rn+%nt. )hus,
"or %=a+$!%, th% int%r%st rat%s on ad&an,%s to +%+2%r 2an4s, indi&idua!s, $artn%rshi$s, and ,or$orations ar% s%t 2. %a,h 3%s%r&%
Ban4 and th%ir d%,isions r%garding th% $ur,has% and sa!% o" s%,uriti%s ar% !i4%0is% ind%$%nd%nt!. +ad%.
It is %&id%nt "ro+ th% !%gis!ati&% histor. o" th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% A,t that 5ongr%ss did not int%nd to gi&% th% "%d%ra! go&%rn+%nt
dir%,tion o&%r th% dai!. o$%ration o" th% 3%s%r&% Ban4s<
It is $ro$os%d that th% ?o&%rn+%nt sha!! r%tain su""i,i%nt $o0%r o&%r th% r%s%r&% 2an4s to %na2!% it to %=%r,is% a dir%,t authorit.
0h%n n%,%ssar. to do so, 2ut that it sha!! in no 0a. att%+$t to ,arr. on through its o0n +%,hanis+ th% routin% o$%rations and
2an4ing 0hi,h r%Buir% d%tai!%d 4no0!%dg% o" !o,a! and indi&idua! ,r%dit and 0hi,h d%t%r+in% th% "unds o" th% ,o++unit. in an.
gi&%n instan,%. In oth%r 0ords, th% r%s%r&%A2an4 $!an r%tains to th% ?o&%rn+%nt $o0%r o&%r th% %=%r,is% o" th% 2road%r 2an4ing
"un,tions, 0hi!% it !%a&%s to indi&idua!s and $ri&at%!. o0n%d institutions th% a,tua! dir%,tion o" routin%.
C.3. 3%$ort (o. 69, 63 5ong. 1st S%ss. 18A19 619137.
)h% "a,t that th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Board r%gu!at%s th% 3%s%r&% Ban4s do%s not +a4% th%+ "%d%ra! ag%n,i%s und%r th% A,t. In
'nit%d Stat%s &. -r!%ans, 92: '.S. 80/, 96 S.5t. 19/1, 98 L.Ed.2d 390 619/67, th% Su$r%+% 5ourt h%!d that a ,o++unit. a,tion
ag%n,. 0as not a "%d%ra! ag%n,. or instru+%nta!it. "or $ur$os%s o" th% A,t, %&%n though th% ag%n,. 0as organi@%d und%r "%d%ra!
r%gu!ations and h%a&i!. "und%d 2. th% "%d%ra! go&%rn+%nt. B%,aus% th% ag%n,.>s da. to da. o$%ration 0as not su$%r&is%d 2. th%
"%d%ra! go&%rn+%nt, 2ut 2. !o,a! o""i,ia!s, th% 5ourt r%"us%d to %=t%nd "%d%ra! tort !ia2i!it. "or th% n%g!ig%n,% o" th% ag%n,.>s
%+$!o.%%s. Si+i!ar!., th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4s, though h%a&i!. r%gu!at%d, ar% !o,a!!. ,ontro!!%d 2. th%ir +%+2%r 2an4s. 'n!i4%
t.$i,a! "%d%ra! ag%n,i%s, %a,h 2an4 is %+$o0%r%d to hir% and "ir% %+$!o.%%s at 0i!!. Ban4 %+$!o.%%s do not $arti,i$at% in th%
5i&i! S%r&i,% 3%tir%+%nt S.st%+. )h%. ar% ,o&%r%d 2. 0or4%r>s ,o+$%nsation insuran,%, $ur,has%d 2. th% Ban4, rath%r than th%
F%d%ra! E+$!o.%%s 5o+$%nsation A,t. E+$!o.%%s tra&%!ing on Ban4 2usin%ss ar% not su21%,t to "%d%ra! tra&%! r%gu!ations and do
not r%,%i&% go&%rn+%nt %+$!o.%% dis,ounts on !odging and s%r&i,%s.
)h% Ban4s ar% !ist%d n%ith%r as ;0ho!!. o0n%d; go&%rn+%nt ,or$orations und%r 31 '.S.5. 8 896 nor as ;+i=%d o0n%rshi$;
,or$orations und%r 31 '.S.5. 8 8:6, a "a,tor ,onsid%r%d in %ar! &. 'nit%d Stat%s, 230 F.2d 293 610th 5ir. 19:67, 0hi,h h%!d that
th% 5i&i! Air atro! is not a "%d%ra! ag%n,. und%r th% A,t. 5!os%!. r%s%+2!ing th% status o" th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4, th% 5i&i! Air
atro! is a nonA$ro"it, "%d%ra!!. ,hart%r%d ,or$oration organi@%d to s%r&% th% $u2!i, 0%!"ar%. But 2%,aus% 5ongr%ss> ,ontro! o&%r
th% 5i&i! Air atro! is !i+it%d and th% ,or$oration is not d%signat%d as a 0ho!!. o0n%d or +i=%d o0n%rshi$ go&%rn+%nt
,or$oration und%r 31 '.S.5. 88 896 and 8:6, th% ,ourt ,on,!ud%d that th% ,or$oration is a nonAgo&%rn+%nta!, ind%$%nd%nt
%ntit., not ,o&%r%d und%r th% A,t.
Additiona!!., 3%s%r&% Ban4s, as $ri&at%!. o0n%d %ntiti%s, r%,%i&% no a$$ro$riat%d "unds "ro+ 5ongr%ss. 5". ?oddard &. *istri,t o"
5o!u+2ia 3%d%&%!o$+%nt Land Ag%n,., 28/ F.2d 393, 39: 6*.5.5ir.19617, ,%rt. d%ni%d, 366 '.S. 910, 81 S.5t. 108:, 6 L.Ed.2d
23: 619617 6,ourt h%!d !and r%d%&%!o$+%nt ag%n,. 0as "%d%ra! ag%n,. "or $ur$os%s o" th% A,t in !arg% $art 2%,aus% ag%n,.
r%,%i&%d dir%,t a$$ro$riat%d "unds "ro+ 5ongr%ss.7
Fina!!., th% Ban4s ar% %+$o0%r%d to su% and 2% su%d in th%ir o0n na+%. 12 '.S.5. 8 391. )h%. ,arr. th%ir o0n !ia2i!it. insuran,%
and t.$i,a!!. $ro,%ss and hand!% th%ir o0n ,!ai+s. In th% $ast, th% Ban4s ha&% d%"%nd%d against tort ,!ai+s dir%,t!., through
$ri&at% ,ouns%!, not go&%rn+%nt attorn%.s, %.g., Ban,o *% Es$ana &. F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 o" (%0 Dor4, 119 F.2d 938 62d 5ir.
19907E Cuntington )o0%rs &. Fran4!in (ationa! Ban4, ::9 F.2d 863 62d 5ir. 19//7E Bo!!o0 &. F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 o" San
Fran,is,o, 6:0 F.2d 1093 69th 5ir. 19817, and th%. ha&% n%&%r 2%%n r%Buir%d to s%tt!% tort ,!ai+s und%r th% ad+inistrati&%
$ro,%dur% o" 28 '.S.5. 8 26/2. )h% 0ai&%r o" so&%r%ign i++unit. ,ontain%d in th% A,t 0ou!d th%r%"or% a$$%ar to 2% ina$$osit% to
th% Ban4s 0ho ha&% not histori,a!!. ,!ai+%d or r%,%i&%d g%n%ra! i++unit. "ro+ 1udi,ia! $ro,%ss.
)h% 3%s%r&% Ban4s ha&% $ro$%r!. 2%%n h%!d to 2% "%d%ra! instru+%nta!iti%s "or so+% $ur$os%s. In 'nit%d Stat%s &. Co!!ingsh%ad,
6/2 F.2d /:1 69th 5ir. 19827, this ,ourt h%!d that a F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 %+$!o.%% 0ho 0as r%s$onsi2!% "or r%,o++%nding
%=$%nditur% o" "%d%ra! "unds 0as a ;$u2!i, o""i,ia!; und%r th% F%d%ra! Bri2%r. Statut%. )hat statut% 2road!. d%"in%s $u2!i, o""i,ia!
to in,!ud% an. $%rson a,ting ;"or or on 2%ha!" o" th% ?o&%rn+%nt.; S. 3%$. (o. 2213, 8/th 5ong., 2nd S%ss. 619627, r%$rint%d in
619627 '.S. 5od% 5ong. F Ad. (%0s 38:2, 38:6. S%% 18 '.S.5. 8 2016a7. )h% t%st "or d%t%r+ining status as a $u2!i, o""i,ia! turns
on 0h%th%r th%r% is ;su2stantia! "%d%ra! in&o!&%+%nt; in th% d%"%ndant>s a,ti&iti%s. 'nit%d Stat%s &. Co!!ingsh%ad, 6/2 F.2d at
/:9. In ,ontrast, und%r th% F)5A, "%d%ra! !ia2i!it. is narro0!. 2as%d on traditiona! ag%n,. $rin,i$!%s and do%s not n%,%ssari!. !i%
0h%n th% tort"%asor si+$!. 0or4s "or an %ntit., !i4% th% 3%s%r&% Ban4s, 0hi,h $%r"or+ i+$ortant a,ti&iti%s "or th% go&%rn+%nt.
)h% 3%s%r&% Ban4s ar% d%%+%d to 2% "%d%ra! instru+%nta!iti%s "or $ur$os%s o" i++unit. "ro+ stat% ta=ation. F%d%ra! 3%s%r&%
Ban4 o" Boston &. 5o++ission%r o" 5or$orations F )a=ation, 999 F.2d 60 61st 5ir. 19/97, a"t%r r%+and, :20 F.2d 221 61st 5ir.
19/:7E F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 o" Ginn%a$o!is &. 3%gist%r o" *%%ds, 288 Gi,h. 120, 289 (.W. 66/ 619397. )h% t%st "or d%t%r+ining
0h%th%r an %ntit. is a "%d%ra! instru+%nta!it. "or $ur$os%s o" $rot%,tion "ro+ stat% or !o,a! a,tion or ta=ation, ho0%&%r, is &%r.
2road< 0h%th%r th% %ntit. $%r"or+s an i+$ortant go&%rn+%nta! "un,tion. F%d%ra! Land Ban4 &. Bis+ar,4 Lu+2%r 5o., 319 '.S.
9:, 102, 62 S.5t. 1, :, 86 L.Ed. 6: 619917E 3ust &. Johnson, :9/ F.2d 1/9, 1/8 69th 5ir. 19/97, ,%rt. d%ni%d, 999 '.S. 969, 100 S.5t.
9:0, 62 L.Ed.2d 3/6 619/97. )h% 3%s%r&% Ban4s, 0hi,h "urth%r th% nation>s "is,a! $o!i,., ,!%ar!. $%r"or+ an i+$ortant
go&%rn+%nta! "un,tion.
%r"or+an,% o" an i+$ortant go&%rn+%nta! "un,tion, ho0%&%r, is 2ut a sing!% "a,tor and not d%t%r+inati&% in tort ,!ai+s a,tions.
F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 o" St. Louis &. G%tro,%ntr% I+$ro&%+%nt *istri,t, 6:/ F.2d 183, 18: n.2 68th 5ir. 19817, 5". %ar! &. 'nit%d
Stat%s, 230 F.2d 293 610th 5ir. 19:67. Stat% ta=ation has traditiona!!. 2%%n &i%0%d as a gr%at%r o2sta,!% to an %ntit.>s a2i!it. to
$%r"or+ "%d%ra! "un,tions than %=$osur% to 1udi,ia! $ro,%ssE th%r%"or% ta= i++unit. is !i2%ra!!. a$$!i%d. F%d%ra! Land Ban4 &.
ridd., 299 '.S. 229, 23:, :: S.5t. /0:, /08, /9 L.Ed. 1908 619::7. F%d%ra! tort !ia2i!it., ho0%&%r, is 2as%d on traditiona! ag%n,.
$rin,i$!%s and thus d%$%nds u$on th% $rin,i$a!>s a2i!it. to ,ontro! th% a,tions o" his ag%nt, and not si+$!. u$on 0h%th%r th%
%ntit. $%r"or+s an i+$ortant go&%rn+%nta! "un,tion. S%% 'nit%d Stat%s &. -r!%ans, 92: '.S. 80/, 81:, 96 S.5t. 19/1, 19/6, 98
L.Ed.2d 390 619/67, 'nit%d Stat%s &. Logu%, 912 '.S. :21, :2/A28, 93 S.5t. 221:, 2219, 3/ L.Ed.2d 121 619/37.
Brin4s In,. &. Board o" ?o&%rnors o" th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% S.st%+, 966 F.Su$$. 116 6*.*.5.19/97, h%!d that a F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4
is a "%d%ra! instru+%nta!it. "or $ur$os%s o" th% S%r&i,% 5ontra,t A,t, 91 '.S.5. 8 3:1. 5iting F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 o" Boston and
F%d%ra! 3%s%r&% Ban4 o" Ginn%a$o!is, th% ,ourt a$$!i%d th% ;i+$ortant go&%rn+%nta! "un,tion; t%st and ,on,!ud%d that th% t%r+
;F%d%ra! ?o&%rn+%nt; in th% S%r&i,% 5ontra,t A,t +ust 2% ;!i2%ra!!. ,onstru%d to %""%,tuat% th% A,t>s hu+anitarian $ur$os%s o"
$ro&iding +ini+u+ 0ag% and "ring% 2%n%"it $rot%,tion to indi&idua!s $%r"or+ing ,ontra,ts 0ith th% "%d%ra! go&%rn+%nt.; Id.
288 Gi,h. at 120, 289 (.W.2d 66/.
Su,h a !i2%ra! ,onstru,tion o" th% t%r+ ;"%d%ra! ag%n,.; "or $ur$os%s o" th% A,t is un0arrant%d. 'n!i4% in Brin4s, $!ainti""s ar%
not 0ithout a "oru+ in 0hi,h to s%%4 a r%+%d., "or th%. +a. 2ring an a$$ro$riat% stat% tort ,!ai+ dir%,t!. against th% Ban4E and
i" su,,%ss"u!, th%ir $ros$%,ts o" r%,o&%r. ar% 2right sin,% th% institutions ar% 2oth high!. so!&%nt and a+$!. insur%d.
For th%s% r%asons 0% ho!d that th% 3%s%r&% Ban4s ar% not "%d%ra! ag%n,i%s "or $ur$os%s o" th% F%d%ra! )ort 5!ai+s A,t and 0%
a""ir+ th% 1udg+%nt o" th% distri,t ,ourt.
AFFI3GE*.
L )h% Conora2!% ?us J. So!o+on, S%nior *istri,t Judg% "or th% *istri,t o" -r%gon, sitting 2. d%signation
<our(e: http:@@ftp%resour(e%org@(ourts%gov@(@F"@?=#@?=#%F"d%">F%=#GLF#L%html
*residents of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York
BenKamin $trong
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,-,+-,-69)
@eorge L. arrison
B.0. &ale ,-,<
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,-69-,-+<)5
President of =ew &ork
Life 8nsurance 1o.
(,-+,-,-+9)
0llan $#roul
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,-+,-,->/)
0lfred ayes
B.0. &ale ,-.<
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,->/-,-:>)
Paul 0. Aolcker
0.B. Princeton ,-+-
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,-:>-,-:-)5
1hairman of the 4ederal
"eser(e (,-:--,-9:)
0nthony *. $olomon
B.0. '. of 1hicago ,-+,
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,-9<-,-9+)
B. @erald 1orrigan
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,-9>-,--.)
William ;. *cDonough
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (,--.-6<<.)
!imothy 4. @eithner
0.B. Dartmouth ,-9.
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (6<<.-6<<-)5
'.$. $ecretary of the
!reasury (6<<--6<,.)
William 1. Dudley
President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew
&ork (6<<--#resent)
4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork in =ew &ork 1ity (Photo7 4lickr)
*rominent )ire(tors of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York
Chairmen: *ierre 'ay! Jwen )% Young! Beardsley Ruml! *hilip )% Reed! +l1ert C% Ni(kerson! Roswell C% .ilpatri(
Chairmen: 'ohn Brademas! 'ohn R% Jpel! Cyrus ,an(e! Mauri(e R% .reen1erg! 'ohn C% &hitehead! *eter .% *eterson
Class + )ire(tors: &inthrop &% +ldri(h! )avid Ro(kefeller! Cewis T% *reston! &alter ,% <hipley! <anford 6% &eill! 'amie )imon
)ire(tors: Charles -% Mit(hell! +l1ert 7% &iggin! 7oward C% <heperd! 7enry C% +le3ander! .eorge Champion! Ri(hard <% Fuld 'r%
)ire(tors: &illiam B% Thompson! .eorge F% *ea1ody! &illiam 7% &oodin! Thomas '% &atson! 'ohn F% &el(h 'r%! .erald M% Cevin
*rominent )ire(tors of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York
Pierre ;ay 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-,+-,-6/)
1hairman of the board of 4iduciary !rust 1om#any M=ew &ork 1ityN (,-.<-,-+>)
Fwen D. &oung 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-.9-,-+<)
De#uty 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-6:-,-.:)
1hairman of the board of @eneral Blectric 1o. (,-66-,-.-, ,-+6-,-++)
Beardsley "uml 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-+,-,-+/)
!reasurer of ".. *acy % 1o. M*acy)s de#artment storeN (,-.+-,-+>)
1hairman of the board of ".. *acy % 1o. (,-+>-,-+-)
Phili# D. "eed 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-/<-,-/>)
1hairman of the board of @eneral Blectric 1o. (,-+<-,-+6, ,-+>-,->9)
0lbert L. =ickerson 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-/--,-:,)
1hairman and 1BF of $ocony-*obil Fil 1o. (later *obil Fil 1or#.) (,-/.-,-/-)
"oswell L. @il#atric 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-:6-,-:>)
Partner of 1ra(ath, $waine % *oore Mlaw firm in =ew &ork 1ityN (,-.,-,->,, ,->.-,-/,, ,-/+-,-::)
;ohn Brademas 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9.-,-9:)
President of =ew &ork 'ni(ersity (,-9,-,--,)5 '.$. 1ongressman (D-8ndiana, ,->--,-9,)
;ohn ". F#el 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9:-,-99)
1lass B Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9,-,-9/)
1lass 1 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9:-,-99)
1hairman of the board of 8nternational Business *achines 1or#. (8B*) (,-9.-,-9/)
1yrus ". Aance 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9--,--,)
Partner of $im#son, !hacher % Bartlett Mlaw firm in =ew &ork 1ityN (,->/-,-/,, ,-/:-,-::, ,-9<-,--9)
*aurice ". @reenberg 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,--+-,-->)
1lass 1 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9--,-->)
1hairman and 1BF of 0merican 8nternational @rou# (,-9--6<<>)
;ohn 1. Whitehead 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,--/-,---)
1o-1hairman of @oldman, $achs % 1o. (,-:/-,-9+)5 1hairman of 0B0 8n(estors 8nc. (,-9--,--:)
Peter @. Peterson 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (6<<<-6<<.)
1hairman and 1BF of Lehman Brothers (,-:.-,-::) and Lehman Brothers Euhn Loeb % 1o. (,-::-,-9+)
$enior 1hairman of !he Blackstone @rou# (,-9>-#resent)
1hairman of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations (,-9>-6<<:)
Winthro# W. 0ldrich 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-+:-,-+-)
1hairman of the board of 1hase =ational Bank (,-.+-,->.)
Da(id "ockefeller 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (;anuary ,, ,-:.-December .,, ,-:/)
1hairman of the board of 1hase *anhattan Bank (,-/--,-9,)
1hairman of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations (,-:<-,-9>)5 1o-4ounder of the !rilateral 1ommission (,-:.)
Lewis !. Preston 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9/-,-99)
1hairman and 1BF of ;.P. *organ % 1o. M*organ @uaranty !rust 1o. of =ew &orkN (,-9<-,-9-)
Walter A. $hi#ley 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,--9-6<<<)
1hairman of the board of 1hase *anhattan 1or#. (,--/-,---)
$anford 8. Weill 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (6<<,-6<</)
1hairman of the board of 1itigrou# (,--9-6<</)
;amie Dimon 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (6<<:-6<,6)
1hairman of the board of ;P *organ 1hase (6<<:-#resent)
1harles B. *itchell 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-69-,-.,)
1hairman of the board of =ational 1ity Bank of =ew &ork (,-6--,-..)
0lbert . Wiggin 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-.6-,-..)
1hairman of the board of 1hase =ational Bank (,-,9-,-.<)
oward 1. $he#erd 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,->/-,->9)
1hairman of the board of =ational 1ity Bank of =ew &ork Mlater 1itibankN (,->6-,->-)
enry 1. 0le3ander 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,->--,-/,)
1hairman of ;.P. *organ % 1o. (,->>-,->-)
1hairman of the board of *organ @uaranty !rust 1o. of =ew &ork (,->--,-/>)
@eorge 1ham#ion 1lass 0 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-/6-,-/+)
1hairman of the board of 1hase *anhattan Bank (,-/,-,-/-)
William B. !hom#son 1lass B Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-,+-,-,-)
@eorge 4. Peabody 1lass 1 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-,+-,-6,)
William . Woodin 1lass B Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (0#ril ,, ,-6:-*arch ., ,-..)
$ecretary of the !reasury (,-..)
!homas ;. Watson 1lass B Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-..-,-+<)
1hairman (,-+--,->/) and President (,-,+-,-+-) of 8nternational Business *achines 1or#. (8B*)
"ichard $. 4uld ;r. 1lass B Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (6<<6-6<<9)
1hairman and 1BF of Lehman Brothers (,--+-6<<9)
@erald *. Le(in 1lass 1 Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (=o(ember 6<<,-6<<.)
1hairman and 1BF of !ime Warner, 8nc. (,--.-6<<6)
;ohn 4. Welch ;r. 1lass B Director of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-9>-,--<)
1hairman and 1BF of @eneral Blectric 1o. (,-9,-6<<,)
Federal Reserve )istri(ts and Their Bran(h Territories
4ederal "eser(e chairmen Bugene *eyer (left, *ay .,, ,-.6) and *arriner $. Bccles (right, 4ebruary ,<, ,-./) a##ear on the front co(er of
Time maga2ine during the @reat De#ression.
4ederal "eser(e chairmen William *c1hesney *artin ;r. (left, $e#tember ,<, ,->/) and 0rthur 4. Burns (right, ;une ,, ,-:<) a##ear on the
front co(er of Time maga2ine.
4ederal "eser(e chairmen Paul Aolcker (left, *arch 9, ,-96) and Ben Bernanke (right, December 69, 6<<-) a##ear on the front co(er of Time
maga2ine.
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an a##ears on the front co(er of !ime maga2ine (left, =o(ember ,<, ,--:) and (with "obert B. "ubin
and Lawrence $ummers (right, 4ebruary ,>, ,---).
)h% Esta2!ish+%nt o" th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&%
!he 4ederal "eser(e $ystem headDuarters in Washington D.1.
Frigins of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem
!he Panic of ,-<: brought the 0merican economy into a recession. 8n ,-<9, members of 1ongress created a =ational *onetary 1ommission
to e3amine the Panic of ,-<:. '.$. $enator =elson 0ldrich was a##ointed as the 1hairman of the =ational *onetary 1ommission. ($enator
0ldrich)s grandsons are Da(id "ockefeller and =elson "ockefeller.) 8n =o(ember ,-,<, $enator 0ldrich, along with Paul Warburg, enry P.
Da(ison, 4rank Aanderli#, BenKamin $trong, and 0bram Piatt 0ndrew, tra(eled secretly to ;ekyll 8sland, an offshore island near $a(annah,
@eorgia, to write a bill establishing a central bank. !he si3 men de#arted from =ew ;ersey by train at night to ;ekyll 8sland on =o(ember 66,
,-,<5 the secret meeting on ;ekyll 8sland lasted a week.
8n ,-,6, $enator 0ldrich #ro#osed a bill, known as the 0ldrich Bill, establishing a central bank. !he 0ldrich Bill, a "e#ublican bill, failed to #ass
in the Democratic-dominated 1ongress5 after the election of ,-,6, the Democratic-dominated 1ongress #ro#osed an Oalternati(eP bill, known
as the Fwen-@lass Bill, establishing the 4ederal "eser(e. ;.P. *organ, ;acob $chiff, and other Wall $treet bankers financed the #residential
cam#aigns of Woodrow Wilson (Democratic Party), William oward !aft ("e#ublican Party), and !heodore "oose(elt (Progressi(e Party) in
,-,6. !he '.$. ouse of "e#resentati(es a##ro(ed the 4ederal "eser(e 0ct on December 66, ,-,. by a (ote of 6-9 in fa(or, /< against, and
:/ absent5 the '.$. $enate a##ro(ed the 4ederal "eser(e 0ct on December 6., ,-,. by a (ote of +. in fa(or, 6> against, and 6: absent.
'.$. President Woodrow Wilson signed the 4ederal "eser(e 0ct at /7<6 P.*. (Bastern standard time) on December 6., ,-,. (two days before
1hristmas) using Ofour gold #en.P
!he 4ederal "eser(e $ystem is a central bank that is owned and controlled by maKor #ri(ate banks of =ew &ork 1ity and London. !he 4ederal
"eser(e $ystem is neither owned nor controlled by the '.$. go(ernment. !he federal go(ernment)s role in the 4ederal "eser(e is limited to
a##ointments made by the President of the 'nited $tates and confirmations made by 1ongress. 0lthough the '.$. 1onstitution states that
O1ongress shall ha(e Power !o coin *oney, regulate the Aalue thereofP, it is the 4ederal "eser(e that Oha(e Power !o coin *oney, regulate
the Aalue thereofP. !he 4ederal "eser(e e3ercises its OPower !o coin *oneyP by #roducing bank notes, called O4ederal "eser(e =otesP,
which are backed by the OfaithP of the shareholders of the 4ederal "eser(e.
Federal Reserve head5uarters in &ashington! )%C%
Federal Reserve head5uarters in &ashington! )%C%
Prelude to the 4ederal "eser(e7 !he Panic of ,-<:
Wall $treet in =ew &ork 1ity during the Panic of ,-<:
;.P. *organ talks to another banker in Fctober ,-<:, Kust before the Panic.
;.P. *organ % 1o. #artner enry P. Da(ison at his desk. (Photo7 arris % Bwing 1ollectionCLibrary of 1ongress)
New York Bank Note Company protest in New York City in F>
The Godfathers of the #ederal $eserve
Paul *. Warburg (left) and 4rank 0. Aanderli# (right)
Left to right7 0bram Piatt 0ndrew, $en. =elson W. 0ldrich, BenKamin $trong, enry P. Da(ison
1o-4ounders and @odfathers of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem
Paul Warburg (OPaulP) Q Aice 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e (,-,/-,-,9)5 *ember of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal
"eser(e (,-,+-,-,9)5 Director of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations (,-6,-,-.6)5 Partner of Euhn, Loeb % 1o. M=ew &ork 1ityN
(,-<6-,-,+)5 @erman-born ;ewish banker from amburg, @ermany
4rank 0. Aanderli# (OFr(illeP) Q President of =ational 1ity Bank M=ew &ork 1ityN (,-<--,-,-)5 0ssistant $ecretary of the !reasury
(,9-:-,-<,)5 1hairman of the Bconomic 1lub of =ew &ork (,-,/-,-,9)
BenKamin $trong (OBenP) Q @o(ernor of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork (,-,+-,-69)5 President of Banker)s !rust of =ew
&ork (,-,+)5 Aice President of Banker)s !rust of =ew &ork (,-<--,-,+)5 *ember of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations
0bram Piatt 0ndrew (O0beP) Q '.$. ouse of "e#resentati(es (,-6,-,-./, "e#ublican-*assachusetts)5 0ssistant $ecretary of
the !reasury (,-,<-,-,6)5 Director of '.$. *int (,-<--,-,<)
=elson W. 0ldrich (O=elsonP) Q '.$. $enator (,99,-,-,,, "e#ublican-"hode 8sland)5 1hairman of the =ational *onetary
1ommission (,-<9-,-,6)5 Da(id "ockefeller)s grandfather5 former Aice President =elson 0. "ockefeller)s grandfather5 father of
former 1hase =ational Bank chairman Winthro# W. 0ldrich
enry P. Da(ison (OWilburP) Q Partner of ;.P. *organ % 1o. M=ew &ork 1ityN5 father of 180 agent 4. !rubee Da(ison
26n )e(em1er F#H! *aul T&ar1urgU first met +ldri(h when the latter visited Buhn! Coe1 to ask how the Rei(hs1ank issued
treasury 1illsSJn the last day of the year! while merrier souls got ready for New YearEs -ve! *aul sent +ldri(h a proposal for a
uniform (urren(y! showing how (ompetitive hoarding of reserves produ(ed (alamity in 1anking (rises% By early F#=! *aul was
giving spee(hes a1out how the *ani( (ould have 1een averted% +t the time! the Bank of -ngland! the Rei(hs1ank! and the
Ban5ue de Fran(e operated independently of government and their 5uasiGprivate (hara(ter aroused alarm in +meri(a% +lthough
a proponent of a strong (entral 1ank! *aul realiAed that any +meri(an (ounterpart would need popular (onstraints on its power%
Jn May >#! F#=! Congress ena(ted the +ldri(hG,reeland Curren(y Bill! whi(h instantly thrust *aul into the hurlyG1urly of
+meri(an politi(s! for the law mandated a National Monetary Commission to investigate foreign 1anking systems and file a
report with Congress% The (hairman would 1e <enator Nelson +ldri(h% Ca(king the re5uisite te(hni(al knowledge! the senator
(ame to lean heavily upon *aulEs e3pertise% &hen +ldri(h and other (ommission mem1ers sailed for -urope that summer!
T'a(o1U <(hiff provided introdu(tory letters to open doors in Berlin and later in Tokyo% 6n New York that fall! +ldri(h held
hearings at the Metropolitan Clu1 and asked *aul to testify% +fterward! he drew him aside for an intimate teteGaGtete at a little
ta1le% *aul was thunderstru(k to find that +ldri(h had not only read his essays 1ut now (ategori(ally endorsed a (entral 1ank%9
: The Warburgs 1y Ron Chernow! p% >"G>>
26n Novem1er F#! TNelsonU +ldri(h! *aul T&ar1urgU! and four other e3perts sneaked off to dis(uss 1ank reform at a se(ret
hideaway on 'ekyll 6sland off the .eorgia (oast% &ith )emo(rats now in (ontrol of Congress and *rogressives railing against
&all <treet! the 1ankers had to travel in(ognito! lest they 1e a((used of hat(hing a (a1al% + favorite haunt of &all <treet
ty(oons! 'ekyll 6sland was deserted in Novem1er and thus was a natural (hoi(e for a (landestine rendeAvous% 6n 'ersey City!
*aul and his (o(onspirators! outfitted as du(k hunters! 1oarded a private railroad (ar% Never having shot a 1ird! *aul had to
1orrow a rifle to parti(ipate in the mas5uerade% The men traveled 1y night! with the 1linds tightly drawn! and they (alled ea(h
other 1y their first names% /7en(e! they were (hristened The First Name Clu1%0 &hen they got off the train in Brunswi(k!
.eorgia! they spoke loudly and ostentatiously a1out sport% +pparently! they were rather amateurish a(tors! for the stationmaster
knew at on(e who they were and said suspi(ious reporters had 1een snooping a1out% For a long time! the (onspirators wouldnEt
admit the meeting had even o((urred% &riting in F"=! *aul still a1ided 1y the oath of se(re(y% 2Though eighteen years have
sin(e gone 1y! 6 do not feel free to give a des(ription of this most interesting (onferen(e (on(erning whi(h <enator +ldri(h
pledged all parti(ipants to se(re(y%9 )uring ten days at 'ekyll 6sland! *aulEs lowGkey 1ut for(eful personality stood out as the si3
men de1ated at a round ta1le% &hen a (ause engaged him! *aul was tena(ious and he semihumorously du11ed himself a
2fanati(9 a1out 1ank reform% +ldri(h wanted a (entral 1ank (ontrolled 1y 1ankers%9
: The Warburgs 1y Ron Chernow! p% >>
Left #hoto7 '.$. $enator "obert Latham Fwen (Democratic Party-Fklahoma, ,-<:-,-6>)
1enter #hoto7 William @. *c0doo, $ecretary of the !reasury (,-,.-,-,9) and President Woodrow Wilson)s son-in-law
"ight #hoto7 1arter @lass, '.$. 1ongressman (Democratic Party-Airginia, ,-<6-,-,9), $ecretary of the !reasury (,-,9-,-6<)
and '.$. $enator (Democratic Party-Airginia, ,-6<-,-+/)
1arter @lass and "obert Latham Fwen were #rimary s#onsors of the 4ederal "eser(e 0ct (formerly Fwen-@lass bill) that would
be signed by President Woodrow Wilson in December ,-,.. "obert Latham Fwen re#udiated his su##ort for the 4ederal
"eser(e later and s#ent the rest of his life condemning the 4ederal "eser(e.
?x+erpts of the arti+le @From Farm ,o! to Finan+ierA written b! Frank 8. 9an#erlip an# ,o!#en .parkes
&ublishe# on Februar! ), ()3B in the Saturday Evening Post
+ <e(ret -3pedition to 'ekyl Tsi(U 6sland
)-<*6T- my views a1out the value to so(iety of greater pu1li(ity for the affairs of (orporations! there was an o((asion! near the (lose
of F#! when 6 was as se(retive : indeed! as furtive : as any (onspirator% None of us who parti(ipated felt that we were (onspirators8
on the (ontrary! we felt we were engaged in a patrioti( work% &e were trying to plan a me(hanism that would (orre(t the weaknesses
of our 1anking system as revealed under the strains and pressures of the pani( of F#H% 6 do not feel it is any e3aggeration to speak of
our se(ret e3pedition to 'ekyl Tsi(U 6sland as the o((asion of the a(tual (on(eption of what eventually 1e(ame the Federal Reserve
<ystem%
Congress! after F#H! had realiAed that something had to 1e done to strengthen our 1anking system% To provide itself with a 1etter
understanding of the pro1lem! there had 1een appointed a 4oint (ommission of twentyGfive mem1ers of 1oth houses! under the
(hairmanship of <enator +ldri(h! who was! on the whole! the 1estGinformed and the most dominant man in Congress on finan(ial
measures% This group had gone to -urope! had interviewed 1ankers and the heads of the (entral 1anks! and then! after a pleasant
summer! they had returned to the ;nited <tates without a definite idea of what they ought to do% <enator +ldri(h did not know what
they ought to do! either! although he really had 1een working hard for two years%
For me the 1eginning of the adventure! 6 should think! was a letter that (ame from Mr% <tillman in *aris% 7e said he had 4ust had a long
(onferen(e with <enator Nelson +ldri(h : Vivil in our (ode : who was very keen to get to work on 1anking and (urren(y revision%
+ldri(h! Mr% <tillman reported! regretted that 7enry )avison! of '% *% Morgan K Co%! and 6 had 1een una1le to 4oin him in -urope
during the summer8 he felt that over there we might have had plenty of time for our dis(ussions! and 1een free from interruptions% 6n a
moment of entire (andor he would have said! 2free from reporters%9 Mr% <tillman said he had told Mr% +ldri(h that freedom from
interruptions was essential! 1ut that it (ould 1e a((omplished 1y getting )avison and me down to &arwi(k : his pla(e in Rhode 6sland
: without anyoneEs knowing of it% That was Mr% +ldri(hIs plan as he left *aris% Mr% <tillman wrote me that 6 should make everything
else su1servient to giving my whole time and thought to a thorough (onsideration of the su14e(t% 7e said that +ldri(h was persuaded
that he (ould a((omplish more 1y getting out of the <enate! so as to put the work of revision on a nonpartisan 1asis% Mr% <tillman
e3pressed to me his fear that after revision the 1anks might not 1e so well off% 7e wrote that from that time on )avison and 6 ought to
follow the matter very (losely! and keep in tou(h with +ldri(h% +ldri(h! 6 was informed! 1elieved in some sort of (entraliAation! 1ut
not in the esta1lishment of a (entral 1ank su(h as Fran(e had% Mr% <tillman also reported to me that in his talk with <enator +ldri(h he
himself had not e3pressed any views! e3(ept as he had impressed on the senator his 1elief in the ne(essity of not 1eing too mu(h
influen(ed 1y 2our &all <treet point of view%9
But would the ele(torate have 1elieved that? 6 5uestion their a1ility to do so% 'ust to give you a faint idea: <enator +ldri(h was the
fatherGinGlaw of 'ohn )% Ro(kefeller! 'r%! and himself a very ri(h man% Jn(e 6 had written to &oodrow &ilson at *rin(eton! inviting
him to speak at a dinner% &ishing to impress him with the importan(e of the o((asion! 6 had mentioned that <enator +ldri(h also had
1een invited to speak% My friend )o(tor &ilson had astonished me 1y replying that he (ould not 1ring himself to speak on the same
platform with <enator +ldri(h% 7e did (ome and make a spee(h! however! after 6 had 6 reported that Mr% +ldri(hEs health would
prevent him from appearing% Now then! fan(y what sort of headlines might have appeared over a story that +ldri(h was (onferring
a1out new money legislation with a Morgan partner and the president of the 1iggest 1ank%
Jn J(to1er "=! F#! 6 wrote to Mr% <tillman in *aris: 2<enator +ldri(h met with what (ame very near 1eing a severe! if not fatal!
automo1ile a((ident% You pro1a1ly have seen the report of it in the papers% 7e was pretty well 1ruised! having (uts on ea(h side of his
fa(e% 7e is very mu(h 1etter now! 1ut the a((ident has naturally postponed the (onferen(e that was in mind% 7e will 1e a1out in a few
days! and Mrs% 'ohn )%! 'r%! tells me that they do not think there will 1e any serious effe(t from the a((ident%9
Bankers in )isguise
+s the time for the assem1ling of Congress drew near! <enator +ldri(h 1e(ame in(reasingly (on(erned a1out the report he must write
on 1ehalf of the 4oint monetary (ommission8 likewise! there ought to 1e! he knew! a 1ill to present to the new Congress! and none had
1een drafted% This was how it happened that a group of us went with him to the 'ekyl Tsi(U 6sland Clu1 on the (oast of .eorgia%
<in(e it would 1e fatal to <enator +ldri(hEs plan to have it known that he was (alling on any1ody from &all <treet to help him in
preparing his report and 1ill! pre(autions were taken that would have delighted the heart of 'ames <tillman% Those who had 1een asked
to go were 7enry )avison! *aul &ar1urg! Ben <trong! and myself% From &ashington (ame +% *iatt +ndrew! 'r%! who was then an
+ssistant <e(retary of the Treasury! and who now is a mem1er of Congress from Massa(husetts% &e were told to leave our last names
1ehind us% &e were told! further! that we should avoid dining together on the night of our departure% &e were instru(ted to (ome one
at a time and as uno1trusively as possi1le to the railroad terminal on the New 'ersey littoral of the 7udson! where <enator +ldri(hEs
private (ar would 1e in readiness! atta(hed to the rear end of a train for the <outh%
&hen 6 (ame to that (ar! the 1linds were down and only slender threads of am1er light showed the shape of the windows% Jn(e a1oard
the private (ar we 1egan to o1serve the ta1oo that had 1een fi3ed on last names% &e addressed one another as 2Ben!9 2*aul!9
2Nelson!9 2+1e9 : it is +1ram *iatt +ndrew% )avison and 6 adopted even deeper disguises! a1andoning our own first names% Jn the
theory that we were always right! he 1e(ame &il1ur and 6 1e(ame Jrville! after those two aviation pioneers! the &right 1rothers%
6n(identally! for years afterward )avison and 6 (ontinued the pra(ti(e! in (ommuni(ations! and when we were together%
<e(ret Meeting on 'ekyl 6sland
The servants and the train (rew may have known the identities of one or two of us! 1ut they did not know all! and it was the names of
all printed together that would have made our mysterious 4ourney signifi(ant in &ashington! in &all <treet! even in Condon%
)is(overy! we knew! simply must not happen! or else all our time and! effort would 1e wasted% 6f it were to 1e e3posed pu1li(ly that
our parti(ular group had got together and written a 1anking 1ill! that 1ill would have no (han(e whatever of passage 1y Congress% Yet!
who was there in Congress who might have drafted a sound pie(e of legislation dealing with the te(hni(al 1anking pro1lem with whi(h
we were (on(erned? 6ndeed! there were surprisingly few 1ankers! 1esides those of us who had 1een (alled together! who had given the
spe(ial matters under (onsideration any thorough study whatever% Most 1ankers were relu(tant to a((ept any (hange8 .eorge Baker
was%
&e pro(eeded! in the rear room of that private (ar! to get to work as soon as the train was moving% That first dis(ussion of the 1anking
stru(ture and of what ought to 1e done a1out it produ(ed s(raps of ideas as formless as the (ontents of a rag 1ag% -veryone had some
little pie(e of a pro4e(t to throw on the ta1le for dis(ussion! and everyoneEs pet s(heme en(ountered some other fellowEs o14e(tion%
&e had traveled a good many miles ! without making mu(h progress! when 6 told my (ompanions of a pie(e of advi(e! as to the proper
way to (ondu(t a (onferen(e! that had 1een given to me 1y Frank Trum1ull! a dear friend of mine who was then the (hairman of the
1oard of the Chesapeake K Jhio Railway%
2&hat we ought to do first!9 6 said! 2is to set down those things a1out whi(h we are agreed8 then! one 1y one! we (an take up those
things a1out! whi(h we seem to disagree%9
From then on we made swift progress% 6 was appointed amanuensis and in my paleolithi( shorthand re(orded those proposals whi(h we
all were ready to e(ho as we heard them8 of (ourse! we knew that what we simply had to have was a more elasti( (urren(y through a
1ank that would hold the reserves of all 1anks%
&e were taken 1y 1oat from the mainland to 'ekyl Tsi(U 6sland and for a week or ten days were (ompletely se(luded! without any
(onta(t 1y telephone or telegraph with the outside% &e had disappeared from the world onto a deserted island% There were plenty of
(olored servants! 1ut they had no idea who Ben and *aul and Nelson were8 even ,anderlip! or )avison! or +ndrew! would have meant
less than nothing to them% There we worked in a (lu1house 1uilt for people with a taste for lu3ury% The liveGoak trees wear fantasti(
1eards of <panish moss on 'ekyl Tsi(U 6sland8 in Novem1er 1rown leaves make its forests utterly (harming% &ithout our ever stopping
to hunt! deer! turkey and 5uail appeared on the ta1le8 there were pans of oysters not an hour old when they were s(alloped8 there were
(ountry hams with that in(ompara1le flavor that is given to them in the <outh% &e were working so hard that we ate enormously% &e
worked morning! noon and night%
&e put in the most intense period of work that 6 have ever had% <ometimes )avison and <trong would 1e up at day1reak to get a
horse1a(k ride! or a swim 1efore 1reakfast! 1ut right after 1reakfast the si3 of us would gather around the ta1le and resume where our
dis(ussion had ended the previous midnight% &e stu(k to the plan of putting down on paper what we agreed upon8 there was no 1a(kG
tra(king! no wrangling% 7arry )avison was a splendid person to prevent wrangles in any (ompany% &ar1urg! the 1estGe5uipped man
there in an a(ademi( sense! was so intense and apparently felt a little antagonism toward +ldri(h that some of our moments of strain
might have developed into real hindran(e had it not 1een for )avison% +lways he (ould 1e (ounted on to (ra(k a 4oke 4ust at the right
moment to ease a strain% No telephones rang! none (ould 1other us to ask for an opinion of the market! there were no dire(torsE
meetings! no interruptions whatever% Thanksgiving o((urred during that week! and we ate wild turkey with oyster stuffing and went
right 1a(k to work% &e gave! ea(h of us! every 1it of our mental energy to the 4o1! and 6 en4oyed that period as 6 never have en4oyed
anything else% 6 lived during those days on 'ekyl Tsi(U 6sland at the highest pit(h of intelle(tual awareness that 6 have ever e3perien(ed%
6t was entirely thrilling%
Colla1orating with +ldri(h
+s we dealt with 5uestions 6 re(orded our agreements in that shorthand 6 had first pra(ti(ed with (halk on the tail sto(k of my lathe
1a(k in +urora% 6f it was to 1e a (entral 1ank! how was it to 1e owned : 1y the 1anks! 1y the .overnment! or 4ointly? &hen we had
fi3ed upon 1ank ownership and 4oint (ontrol! we took up the politi(al pro1lem of whether it should 1e a num1er of institutions or only
one% <hould the rate of interest 1e the same for the whole nation! or should it 1e higher in a (ommunity that was e3panding too fast
and lower in another that was lagging? <hould it restri(t its servi(es to 1anks? &hat openGmarket operations should 1e engaged in?
That was the sort of 5uestions we dealt with! and finally! at the end of our week! we had whipped into shape a 1ill that we felt!
pridefully! should 1e presented to Congress% +s 6 re(all it &ar1urg had some o14e(tions! 1ut we were in su1stantial agreement on the
measure we had (reated% &e returned to the North as se(retly as we had gone <outh% 6t was agreed that <enator +ldri(h would present
the 1ill we had drafted to the <enate% 6t 1e(ame known to the (ountry as the +ldri(h *lan% +ldri(h and +ndrew left us at &ashington!
and &ar1urg! )avison! <trong and 6 returned to New York%
Congress was a1out to meet! 1ut on a <aturday we got word in New York that <enator +ldri(h was ill : too ill to write an appropriate
do(ument to a((ompany his plan% Ben <trong and 6 went on to &ashington and together we prepared that report% 6f what we had done
then had 1een made known pu1li(ly! the effort would have 1een denoun(ed as a pie(e of &all <treet (hi(anery! whi(h it (ertainly was
not% +ldri(h never was a man to 1e a mere servant of the soG(alled money interests% 7e was a (ons(ientious! pu1li(Gspirited man% 7e
had (alled on the four of us who had &all <treet addresses 1e(ause he knew that we had for years 1een studying aspe(ts of the
pro1lem with whi(h it was his pu1li( duty to deal%
6 Be(ome a Millionaire
+s is now well known! the 1ill we drafted did not get through Congress% +ldri(h retired from the <enate! and then a )emo(rati(
ma4ority (ame down to &ashington along with &oodrow &ilson! who had defeated *resident Taft% The platform on whi(h he was
ele(ted (ontained a statement e3pressing the opposition of the )emo(rati( *arty to the +ldri(h *lan! or a (entral 1ank% There was a
good deal of dis(ussion a1out that% 6t was (ontended that originally the platform (ommittee had agreed upon the statement: 2&e are
opposed to the +ldri(h *lan for a (entral 1ank%9
Now! although the +ldri(h Federal Reserve plan was defeated when it 1ore the name of +ldri(h! nevertheless its essential points were
all (ontained in the plan that finally was adopted% 6t provided an organiAation to hold the reserves of all mem1er 1anks and arranged
that they would always 1e ready to relieve a mem1er 1ank under pressure 1y redis(ounting loans that it held% The law as ena(ted
provided for twelve 1anks instead of the one whi(h the +ldri(h *lan would have (reated8 1ut the intent of the law was to (oordinate the
twelve through the Federal Reserve Board in &ashington! so that in effe(t they would operate as a (entral 1ank% There (an 1e no
5uestion a1out it: +ldri(h undou1tedly laid the essential! fundamental lines whi(h finally took the form of the Federal Reserve Caw%
!he ;ekyll 8sland 1lub at ;ekyll 8sland, @eorgia, '.$.0., near $a(annah
O1olonelP Bdward *. ouse (left) stands beside '.$. President Woodrow Wilson. Bdward *. ouse was a #olitical #owerbroker from 0ustin,
!e3as, '.$.0. who su##orted the establishment of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem. Bdward *. ouse, one of the co-founders of the 1ouncil on
4oreign "elations in =ew &ork 1ity, was the author of #hi!ip Dru: Aministrator, a book in which he #romotes communism, socialism, central
bank, and income ta3 in 0merica. O1olonelP Bdward *. ouse was the son of British-born "ebel (1onfederate) blockade runner and
businessman !homas William ouse5 !homas William ouse was the mayor of ouston, !e3as in ,9/6.
Bdward *. ouse su##orted the establishment of the League of =ations while meeting with Buro#ean #olitical leaders at the Paris Peace
1onference. Woodrow Wilson once said7 @Cr. House is m! se+on# personalit!. He is m! in#epen#ent self. His thoughts an# mine are
one. Df D were in his pla+e D woul# #o Eust as he suggeste#... Df an!one thinks he is refle+ting m! opinion b! whate4er a+tion he takes,
the! are wel+ome to the +on+lusion.A (p.((=, Chapter B, 9olume (, The Intimate Papers of Colonel House"
*resident &oodrow &ilson delivers a spee(h in Congress in &ashington! )%C% on +pril =! F>% /*hoto: Ci1rary of Congress0
Ceft photo: 'ekyll 6sland Clu1 in .eorgia in the early F##s
Right photo: + F> < PL 6ndian 7ead .old 7alf -agle (oin produ(ed 1y the ;%<% Mint
/<our(e: http:@@ar(h#F%goldtent%net@"##F@#L@#=@fullgold(rownG>>=GpmGaGfewGs(atteredGthoughts@0
The signing of the Federal Reserve +(t 1y *resident &oodrow &ilson! )e(em1er ">! F>! is depi(ted in this painting 1y
&il1ur .% BurtA! <r% Commissioned 1y the Federal Reserve Bank of +tlanta in F">% The painting is presently on loan to the
Federal Reserve Board of .overnors in &ashington! )%C% from the &oodrow &ilson Birthpla(e Foundation in ,irginia% &hile
more people were present at the a(tual signing of the +(t! Mr% BurtA (hose to pi(ture the following men% Ceft to right: Cindley
M% .arrison! <e(retary of &ar8 'osephus )aniels! <e(retary of the Navy8 Franklin B% Cane! <e(retary of the 6nterior8 +%<%
Burleson! *ostmaster .eneral8 <enator Ro1ert Jwen! Chairman of the <enateEs Banking and Curren(y Committee8 Champ
Clark! <peaker of the 7ouse8 &illiam .% M(+doo! <e(retary of the Treasury8 &oodrow &ilson! *resident of the ;nited <tates8
Representative Carter .lass! Chairman of the 7ouse Committee on Banking and Curren(y8 Representative Js(ar &%
;nderwood8 and &illiam B% &ilson! <e(retary of Ca1or% /Courtesy! &oodrow &ilson Birthpla(e Foundation0
E7auds Glass and +wenF G Cecember 18, /0/= edition of The New York Times
1o#y of international banker ;acob $chiff)s letter from !reasury $ecretary William @. *c0doo (Fctober 69, ,-,.) and letter to '.$. President
Woodrow Wilson (December 6., ,-,.) ($ource7 $aco% &. 'chiff: &is "ife an "etters by 1yrus 0dler, Aolume ,, #age 69:)
2<ele(t )ire(tors For Reserve Bank9 : New York Times /May "H! F$0
*u1lished: May "H! F$8 Copyright W The New York Times
<our(e: http:@@5uery%nytimes%(om@mem@ar(hiveGfree@pdf?resXF$#)>F)>$L)>H>=)))+-#+F$))$#LB=$=)F)>
Name Class C Directors New York Times (October 1, 1914)
*u1lished: J(to1er ! F$8 Copyright W The New York Times
<our(e: http:@@5uery%nytimes%(om@mem@ar(hiveGfree@pdf?resXF=#?->)=$>--#>>+"LHL"C#+F??F)F$?LF?)?CF
2aul "arburg-s (rusade to 3stablish a (entral )ank in the &nited %tates
*aul &ar1urg was an advo(ate for a (entral 1ank in the ;nited <tates and was (hosen 1y *resident &oodrow &ilson to serve as
one of the first mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board%
Mi(hael +% &hitehouse
May F=F
Whitehouse is staff assistant in the Office of the Secretary at the oard of !o"ernors in Washington# $%&% He has written and
lectured e'tensi"ely on the early history of the Federal (eser"e System and )%S% banking%
6n paying tri1ute re(ently to 7enry &alli(h! late mem1er of the Federal Reserve Board of .overnors! Bankers MagaAine noted
that &alli(h was a su((essor! in more than one respe(t! to *aul &ar1urg% Both of these 1oard mem1ers were emigrants from
.ermanyNand from the higher (ir(les of .erman and -uropean finan(e% &ar1urg! a mem1er of the first Federal Reserve Board!
like &alli(h! was a staun(h advo(ate of sound finan(e% Both! having witnessed the strengths and weaknesses of the -uropean
1anking system during e(onomi( de1a(les as younger men! 1rought their e3perien(e to the ;nited <tates (ommitted to putting
those lessons to use%
6tIs 1een said that .overnor &alli(hIs spee(hes and essays represent one of the 1est finan(ial histories of our time% The same (an
(ertainly 1e said of &ar1urgIs writings! spee(hes and testimony for the period after the turn of the (entury% 7is lifeIs work
(onstitutes perhaps the 1est history of the development of (entral 1anking in the ;nited <tates and mirrors its (ontroversies!
struggles and the final a((omplishment%
6tIs seems fitting then! in this HLth anniversary year of the Federal Reserve <ystem! to look at the life of &ar1urg! one of the
<ystemIs ar(hite(ts and staun(hest proponents%
"arburgHs 3arly )anking 3xperience
*aul &ar1urg was 1orn in 7am1urg in =?=% The offspring of a prominent .erman 1anking family! he had 1een trained in
1anking in the -uropean finan(ial (apitals% +fter attending the university! at age = he 1egan his (areer in Condon where for two
years he worked for a 1anking and dis(ounting firm! followed 1y a short stint with a Condon sto(k1roker% +fter that he moved to
Fran(e and gained additional e3perien(e at the Russian 1ank for foreign trade! whi(h had an agen(y in *aris% 7e then traveled to
6ndia! China and 'apan 1efore returning to 7am1urg to 1e(ome a partner in M%M% &ar1urg K Co%! the family 1anking firm%
&ar1urgIs father had fully e3pe(ted that *aul would take (harge of his familyIs 1anking 1usiness along with his 1rothers +1y
and Ma3! 1ut in =FL &ar1urg married an +meri(an (itiAen! Nina Coe1! an a((omplished violinist! and 1egan to live part of the
year in New York% <i3 years later! at age >$! he left .ermany! took up permanent residen(y in the ;nited <tates! and a((epted a
position as a partner at his fatherGinGlawIs firm! Buhn! Coe1 and Co%None of &all <treetIs most important and respe(ted 1anking
houses% &hile adapting 5ui(kly to his new 1usiness! he still viewed the ;nited <tates through the eyes of a -uropean 1anker and
was literally sho(ked at what he (onsidered the primitive status of 1anking and finan(ial affairs%
6n the early F##s! the nation was suffering from periodi( li5uidity (rises% These (rises or Ypani(sY o((urred 1e(ause the 1anking
system was fettered with a rigid amount of (urren(y that (ould not meet unusual demands! and a system of reserves that
pyramided up to New York% )uring these pani(s 1usinessmen and farmers were una1le to o1tain (redit to finan(e inventories
and the produ(tion and transportation of (rops% The (rises spread a(ross the (ountry and (onverged upon &all <treet! resulting in
plunges in the sto(k market! a large num1er of 1ank and 1usiness failures! and a further shortage of (urren(y%
<u(h phenomena deeply affe(ted &ar1urg! a small unassuming man whose most o1vious physi(al (hara(teristi( was a large
drooping musta(he that gave him more the appearan(e of a tenor in a 1ar1ershop 5uartet than an important international 1anker%
&hile small in stature! however! he was hardly tame or timid in his professional assessment of (onditions then prevailing in his
new (ountry% YThe ;nited <tates!Y he said! Yis at a1out the same point that had 1een rea(hed 1y -urope at the time of the
Medi(is%Y &itnessing firstGhand a period of high interest rates N Ywhere (all money went up to "L and ## per(ent!Y he felt
(ompelled to Ywrite an arti(le on the su14e(t then and there for ThisU own 1enefit%Y
&ar1urg thought it a 1it presumptuous to attempt to edu(ate a (ountry to whi(h he was so new a resident! so when advised 1y an
asso(iate to put the paper aside! he did so and attended to duties at his firm% 7owever! when the same (onditions arose in the
1eginning of F#H! he (ould hold his tongue no longer! and he 1egan to (ir(ulate his writings for the 1enefit of others as well%
The 2anic of /0I>
-arly in F#H! New York Times +nnual Finan(ial Review pu1lished &ar1urgIs first offi(ial reform plan! entitled Y+ *lan for a
Modified Central Bank!Y in whi(h he outlined remedies that he thought might avert pani(s! like the great one that would o((ur
later that year% Furthermore! he identified what he saw as the YevilsY of the system in the ;nited <tates N the Yde(entraliAation
of reserves and the immo1iliAation of T(ommer(ialU paper%Y To remedy this! he advo(ated the development of an +meri(an
dis(ount market and a -uropeanGstyle (ommer(ial paper% This system was 1ased partly on a (on(ept known as the Yreal 1illsY
do(trine! whi(h maintained that the money supply should vary with the shortGterm YlegitimateY needs of 1usiness and (ommer(e%
By allowing 1anks to 1orrow only against shortGterm loans! the real 1ills do(trine! in theory! provided li5uidity through the
dis(ounting /or selling0 of loans and at the same time restri(ted the a1ility of a (entral 1ank to e3pand the supply of money%
&ar1urg also proposed the (reation of a Y(entral reserveY or (entral 1ank that would hold the reserve funds of mem1er 1anks so
that (olle(tive funds (ould 1e made availa1le to a 1ank in need of li5uidity% Both the dis(ounting and reserve (on(ept! he
(ontended! would help make money and (redit more elasti( and keep interest rates sta1le%
The *ani( of F#H hit full stride in J(to1er% The (rash was of su(h severity that it immediately helped fo(us pu1li( awareness on
the pro1lems with the monetary and 1anking system% +lthough the issue of a (entral 1ank was unpopular 1e(ause of its
(onnotations of powerful (entral authority! Congress was now for(ed to a(t% The +ldri(hG,reeland +(t! passed 1y Congress in
May F#=! provided for the issuan(e of emergen(y (urren(y and (reated a 1ipartisan National Monetary Commission to study
(entral 1anking and other alternatives for monetary and 1anking reform% &ar1urg would serve this (ommittee and! through his
efforts for the (ommission! a(hieve an influen(e on su1se5uent proposals for reform%
"arburg eets %en. !ldrich
<en% Nelson +ldri(h of Rhode 6sland! (hairman of the <enate Finan(e Committee! was appointed head of the National Monetary
Commission% 7e divided the (ommission into two groups: one would study the ;< 1anking system and (ompile a report! and the
other! headed 1y the senator himself! would travel to -urope and study the (entral 1anking systems in Condon! *aris and Berlin%
+ldri(h was a known advo(ate of the e3tant 1ondG1a(ked (urren(y arrangement! whi(h provided that 1ank notes (ould only 1e
issued 1y national 1anks on the 1asis of the amount of ;< government 1onds that were held to 1a(k them% 7owever! the ?HG
yearGold +ldri(h! who was (onsidered the most influential figure in Congress on finan(ial matters! was (ommitted to e3ploring
new ideas for reform% 6n F#=! he announ(ed that he would not seek offi(e again and instead would devote his full attention to
the (urren(y and 1anking 5uestion%
Meanwhile! &ar1urg 1egan to enlarge his (ir(le of professional (onta(ts and have his voi(e heard throughout the (ountry%
7owever! the .erman 1anker still didnIt have the ear of the man who mattered most N +ldri(h%
+ldri(h first met &ar1urg 1y (han(e when the senator was preparing for the -uropean trip and visited Buhn! Coe1 and Co% to
gather preliminary material a1out the .erman 1anking system% Following that meeting! the .erman native 1egan writing to
+ldri(h outlining his proposals! 1ut +ldri(h was (ool to &ar1urgIs plan and deferred his (orresponden(e to +% *iatt +ndrew! a
7arvard professor whom +ldri(h had appointed offi(ial se(retary of the National Monetary Commission% +s new ideas on
1anking reform 1egan to (rystalliAe for the senator! +ndrew 1rought the work of &ar1urg to the senatorIs attention again and
soon +ndrew was (orresponding with &ar1urg on 1ehalf of the senator% &ar1urg was asked to write a study on the Ydis(ounting
of (ommer(ial 1illsY for the National Monetary Commission! and 1e(ame an unoffi(ial advisor to the group% 7owever! the
1anker and the senator still were at loggerheads on the 5uestion of what shape the (entral 1ank should take in the ;nited <tates!
and on the issue of dis(ounting (ommer(ial paper%
6n his monograph! YThe )is(ount <ystem in -urope!Y &ar1urg de(lared that the effe(tive utiliAation of the dis(ount poli(y was
one of the most impressive vi(tories for (entral 1anks in -urope during the *ani( of F#H% The only stru(ture that is safe! he
(on(luded! is one that provides for effe(tive (on(entration of (ash reserves and their freest use in (ase of need! ena1ling 1anks!
when ne(essary! to turn into (ash a ma3imum of their assets with a minimum distur1an(e to general (onditions% 7e noted further
that a (entral 1ank is a1le to guard the (ash reserve of the (ountry and a((ommodate nonreserve 1anks 1y a((epting prime
se(urity! like 1ankGa((epted 1ills%
&ar1urg! in the meantime! (ontinued his (ampaign on other fronts% 7e had followed his first New York Times arti(le with a
spee(h at Colum1ia ;niversity on Y+meri(an and -uropean Banking Methods and Banking Cegislation Compared!Y and
privately pu1lished a new! more (omplete proposal for a ;< 1anking system! entitled Y+ Modified *lan for a Central Bank%Y
6n May F#=! the New York Times gave his revised plan prominent (overage% *rimarily! &ar1urg (ontinued to emphasiAe that
the ;nited <tates must finally develop some sort of (entral 1ank system! giving the (ountry an elasti( (urren(y 1ased on modern
(ommer(ial 1ills paya1le in gold: a system similar in prin(iple! if not e3a(tly alike in form! to those of the important -uropean
(entral 1anks% 7e 1elieved that Yno measure that 1ases (urren(y on a long term 1asis like the +ldri(hG,reeland -mergen(y
Curren(y 1ill! /whi(h allowed 1anks in regional (urren(y asso(iations to use their aggregate 1ank 1alan(es as the 1asis for the
issuan(e of (urren(y0 (an 1e a((epta1le%Y +lso! he stressed that issuing notes Ymust 1e (entraliAed into a few organs! or if
feasi1le! into one organ to ensure effe(tive e3pansion and (ontra(tion of reserves%Y The tireless reformer further stated that no
(entral 1ank (ould 1e effe(tive that Yvests the powers of a (entral 1ank in politi(al offi(ers alone% That power (learly defined!
ought to 1e vested in politi(al offi(ers and 1usinessmen (om1ined! in a way that would render impossi1le any politi(al or
finan(ial a1use%Y +ny hasty de(isions on the (omposition of the dire(tors of a (entral 1ank! he said! (ould stand in the way of the
(reation of su(h an organiAation% Better that those pra(ti(al and politi(al 5uestions (ould 1e worked out after (areful
(onsideration%
"arburgHs (ontribution
The idea of an Yelasti( (urren(y!Y whi(h would e3pand to meet the legitimate needs of 1usiness and (ommer(e! was not new% 6n
fa(t! &ar1urg himself (laimed no originality for the idea! 1ut through his writings! spee(hes and (ounsel to others he 1egan to
have a greater impa(t than anyone else% &ar1urg did! however! su((eed in in4e(ting two new ideas into the dis(ussion: first!
shifting of emphasis from the (urren(y pro1lem to the reserve pro1lem8 and se(ond! advo(a(y of the prin(iple of redis(ounting a
new kind of (ommer(ial paper%
These ideas were starting to 1e dis(ussed more seriously throughout the (ountry! and other individuals involved in the 1anking
and (urren(y reform movement 1egan to take note% &ith 1oth the 1uilding momentum of other 1anking reform advo(a(y groups
and +ldri(hIs own e3posure to the effi(ient and effe(tive (entral 1anking system in -urope! the senator finally opened to these
other ideas%
The de1ate on (entral 1anking reform was still in full swing several years after the F#H *ani(% 6ndeed! it 1egan to heat up! with
the +meri(an Bankers +sso(iation standing opposed to Yany form of (entral 1ank yet suggested 1y legislators%Y Meanwhile!
&ar1urg! +ldri(h and several other prominent figures intensified their efforts and 1egan to form an allian(e that was to last over
the (oming (ru(ial years of the 1anking reform movement%
!ldrich $econsiders :is 2osition
The -uropean interviews of the National Monetary Commission had a profound influen(e upon +ldri(h% 7e had a (lear plan for
reform when he returned from -urope! radi(ally different from his original 1eliefs% The (hange in the senatorIs thinking was so
drasti( that +ldri(hIs 1iographer e3plained it as an epiphany! saying! Y+ldri(h was (onverted on the road to )amas(us%Y
&hen +ldri(h and the National Monetary Commission returned from -urope in the fall of F#=! +ldri(h asked &ar1urg to
present his own ideas and answer 5uestions regarding the -uropean interviews at a meeting at New YorkIs Metropolitan Clu1%
+fter &ar1urgIs Metropolitan Clu1 testimony! +ldri(h pulled the 1anker aside and told him that he liked his plan for reform 1ut
he was 1eing too timid a1out it% &ar1urg was surprised to learn that +ldri(h! who 1efore his -uropean travels had not favored
(entraliAation and had advo(ated a national (urren(y 1a(ked 1y government 1onds! had (hanged his thinking and envisioned a
-uropeanGtype (entral 1ank for the ;nited <tates% &hile &ar1urg now warned the senator against attempts to esta1lish a fullG
s(ale (entral 1ank in the -uropean senseN1elieving it politi(ally unrealisti(N he was nonetheless en(ouraged%
+ parti(ular key feature of the -uropean systems persuaded the senator to re(onsider his thinking% +((ording to (ommission
mem1er <en% Theodore Burton! the (on(ept of (urren(y 1a(ked 1y (ommer(ial assets 1egan to take hold in +ldri(hIs mind in
Condon! and the interviews in Berlin finally (onvin(ed him% Commission +ssistant .eorge Reynolds (on(urred! noting that Ythe
e3perien(e and pra(ti(e of .erman 1ankers in meeting the needs of (ommer(e in their (ountry demonstrated to +ldri(h the
validity of the use of (ommer(ial assets as a 1asis for (urren(y% The idea! formerly so o1s(ure! (ame home to him in great for(e
from its demonstration in a nonGpoliti(al! pra(ti(al atmosphere%Y
&hile +ldri(hIs (onversion was a wel(ome one to &ar1urg and other progressive reformers! the very (on(ept of a -uropeanG
style (entral 1ank was still an anathema to a great many 1ankers and politi(ians% Bankers wanted reform that would make the
1anking system more effi(ient and 1etter (oordinated 1ut were fearful of government interferen(e in the management of a
(entral 1ank% &hile Reynolds! as president of the +meri(an Bankers +sso(iation! had traveled to -urope and had 1e(ome an
intimate of +ldri(h! his asso(iation was not supportive of reform% Moreover! many politi(ians 1elieved that the geographi( siAe
of the ;nited <tates and its diverse 1usiness (onditions warranted a different 1anking system than those e3isting in -urope%
Compli(ating the matter further was the fa(t that any plan to whi(h +ldri(h atta(hed himself was sure to 1e atta(ked 1y
)emo(rats and others who 1elieved the senator had only the interest of eastern 1usinessmen and 1ankers in mind% +ldri(h had
(lose ties with '% *% Morgan and other important 1ankers! and his eldest daughterIs marriage to 'ohn )% Ro(kefeller 'r% did not
help to dispel this suspi(ion%
The 9ekyll Island 3xpedition
Jne evening in early Novem1er F#! &ar1urg and a small party of men from New York 5uietly 1oarded <en% +ldri(hIs private
railway (ar! ostensi1ly for a trip south to an e3(lusive hunting (lu1 on an island off the (oast of .eorgia%
6n addition to &ar1urg and +ldri(h! the others! all highly regarded in the New York 1anking (ommunity! were: Frank ,anderlip!
president of National City Bank8 7arry *% )avison! a '%*% Morgan partner8 Ben4amin <trong! vi(e president of BankerIs Trust
Co%8 and +% *iatt +ndrew! former se(retary of the National Monetary Commission and now assistant se(retary of the Treasury%
The real purpose of this histori( Ydu(k huntY was to formulate a plan for ;< 1anking and (urren(y reform that +ldri(h (ould
present to Congress%
-ven &ar1urg at first 5uestioned the motives of this gathering! not knowing if he was in(luded 1e(ause the group knew what he
prea(hed and was interested in what he had to offer! or if he was to 1e involved as a (onspirator in order to 1e muAAled% 7e soon
saw that the 'ekyll 6sland (onferen(e was pulled together 1e(ause! as &ar1urg later wrote! +ldri(h was Y1ewildered at all that he
had a1sor1ed a1road and he was fa(ed with the diffi(ult task of writing a highly te(hni(al 1ill while 1eing harassed 1y the daily
grind of his parliamentary duties%Y
The group was se(luded on 'ekyll 6sland for a1out # days% +ll the parti(ipants (ame to the (onferen(e with strong views on the
su14e(t and did not agree on the e3a(t shape a ;< (entral 1ank should take% ,anderlip noted: YJf (ourse we knew that what we
simply had to have was a more elasti( (urren(y through a 1ank that would hold the reserves of all 1anks%Y But there were many
other 5uestions that needed to 1e answered% 6f it was to 1e a (entral 1ank! how was it to 1e owned: 1y the 1anks! 1y the
government! or 4ointly? <hould there 1e a num1er of institutions or only one? <hould the rate of interest 1e the same for the
whole nation! or would it 1e higher in a (ommunity that was e3panding too fast and lower in another that was lagging? 6n what
open market operations should the 1ank 1e engaged?
&ar1urg realiAed that he had not 1een a1le to persuade the senator that if a (entral 1anking organiAation was to 1e (reated! it had
to 1e a modified s(heme 1ased on the -uropean models% 6n fa(t! &ar1urg! Ythe 1est e5uipped man there in the a(ademi( sense!Y
a((ording to ,anderlip! Ywas so intense %%% and apparently felt a little antagonism towards +ldri(h!Y so that there were some
moments of strain that had to 1e eased 1y the others% +ldri(h had his mind set on a -uropeanGstyle (entral 1ank! Ya model he
seemed loath to a1andon!Y a((ording to &ar1urg! and the senator strongly 1elieved that the proposed (entral 1ank should 1e kept
out of politi(s% &ar1urg and the others felt that whatever the theoreti(al 4ustifi(ation for su(h a (entral 1ank! +meri(an
(onditions would re5uire some sort of (ompromise and that (on(essions should 1e made (onsidering government influen(e and
representation% +ldri(h! yielding somewhat! allowed that the government should 1e represented on the 1oard of dire(tors and
have full knowledge of the 1ankIs affairs! 1ut a ma4ority of the dire(tors were to 1e (hosen! dire(tly or indire(tly! 1y the
mem1ers of the asso(iation%
&ar1urg also didnIt agree with +ldri(hIs position on note issuan(e! (onditions of mem1ership of state 1anks and trust
(ompanies! or on the need for a uniform dis(ount rate% +ldri(h insisted! however! that a (entral 1ank should maintain a uniform
rate of dis(ount throughout the ;nited <tates% 7e thought su(h a measure politi(ally wise 1e(ause it would refute the (harges
that other Ygreat finan(ial (entresY would attempt to esta1lish favora1le rates for themselves in different regions to the
disadvantage of other lo(alities in the (ountry%
-ventually all of the individuals at the 'ekyll 6sland (onferen(e had to modify their views on a (entral 1ank plan% Nonetheless!
+ldri(h got out of the (onferen(e 4ust what he intendedNa 1anking s(heme that rested upon a (onsensus of opinion representing
the 1estGinformed 1ankers of this (ountry%
The 1anking 1ill the group 1rought north! whi(h (ame to 1e known as the Y+ldri(h *lan!Y (alled for the esta1lishment of a
(entral 1ank in &ashington! to 1e named the YNational Reserve +sso(iation!Y meaning a (entral reserve organiAation with an
elasti( note issue 1ased on gold and (ommer(ial paper% The asso(iation was to have L 1ran(hes at geographi(ally strategi(
lo(ations throughout the (ountry% The 1ank was to serve as fis(al agent for the ;< government and! 1y mo1iliAing the reserves of
its mem1er 1anks! 1e(ome a lender of last resort to the +meri(an 1anking system% The asso(iation as a whole was to serve as a
1ank of redis(ount! that is! it was empowered to dis(ount a se(ond time (ommer(ial paper that mem1ers of the asso(iation had
already dis(ounted% By redis(ounting! the asso(iation (ould issue new money that might stay in (ir(ulation so long as the paper
for whi(h it was issued was not redeemed%
No one person was responsi1le for the final draft 1ill that was written% 6t was a re(ord of their (omposite views% Yet ,anderlip
regarded &ar1urg as having made signifi(ant and important (ontri1utions to the final result: Y+s a philosophi(al student of
1anking he was first among us at that time%Y &ar1urg was satisfied that the +ldri(h *lan was not a (entral 1ank in the -uropean
sense% Y6t was stri(tly a 1ankersI 1ank with 1ran(hes under the (ontrol of separate dire(torates having supervision over the
redis(ount operations with mem1er 1anks!Y he said%
&ar1urg viewed the result of the 'ekyll 6sland meeting as pivotal: YThe period during whi(h nonpoliti(al thought held the
leadership in the 1anking reform movement may 1e (onsidered as having ended with this (onferen(e%Y ;p until then! 1ank
reform had 1een an edu(ational (ampaign (arried on 1y individuals and groups8 1ut at that point! the movement assumed a
national (hara(ter% &ar1urg saw <enator +ldri(h as 1eing the standardG1earer of a politi(al proposal for a (entral 1ank% <aid
&ar1urg: YFrom then on until the final passage of the Federal Reserve +(t! the generalship was in the hands of politi(al leaders!
while the role of 1anking reformers was to aid the movement 1y edu(ational (ampaigns and! at the same time! to do their utmost
to prevent fundamental parts of the nonpoliti(al plan from 1eing disfigured 1y (on(essions 1orn of politi(al e3pedien(y%Y
+ldri(h presented his draft plan to the pu1li( in 'anuary F% Jne year later! on 'an% F! F"! the National Monetary
Commission presented its report and endorsed the +ldri(h *lan%
The #inal (ampaign
&ar1urg playfully des(ri1ed himself as a Yfanati(Y for what he (onsidered sound finan(e% 7e was also pragmati( and sensitive to
politi(al realities! however% Thus he tempered his approa(h to a (entral 1ank in the ;nited <tates! and his (ampaign over the ne3t
several years refle(ted that position% &hen he saw the road1lo(ks that lay ahead with +ldri(h attempting to sell his plan to a
greater part of the (ountry! &ar1urg 1egan a formal edu(ational (ampaign to assist% &ar1urg 1elieved that Y1eyond dou1t!
unless pu1li( opinion all over the ;nited <tates (ould 1e edu(ated and mo1iliAed! any sound 1anking reform plan was doomed to
fail%Y
The National Board of Trade appointed &ar1urg the head of a sevenGman (ommittee to set up a national group to promote
reform% The group was (alled The National CitiAens Ceague For the *romotion of <ound Banking% 6t a((omplished mu(h of
what it set out to do: esta1lishing effe(tive organiAations in $L states! printing a vast amount of edu(ational materials for the
1usinessman and layman alike! and pu1lishing essays in pamphlets and arti(les in newspapers% &ar1urg also (ontinued to
pu1lish in important 4ournals and le(ture 1efore influential groups! doing all he (ould to help promote sound 1anking prin(iples
and (onvin(e larger audien(es of the urgen(y for reform%
The #inal 2lan The #ederal $eserve !ct
Before the +ldri(h *lan (ould 1e ena(ted into law! the )emo(rats won the &hite 7ouse and took (ontrol of the Congress in
F"% The )emo(rati( position (alled for a divisional reserve 1ank system! with a num1er of reserve 1anks or (entral 1anking
(ities% Nevertheless! *resident &oodrow &ilson 1elieved that the +ldri(h *lan was Y?#GH# per(ent (orre(t%Y +s a result! the plan
1e(ame the 1asis for (onstru(ting the Federal Reserve 1ill! whi(h 1egan to take shape in Congress with the presentation of a 1ill
proposed 1y <en% Ro1ert Catham Jwen in May F>%
&hen the +ldri(h 1ill was re4e(ted and the )emo(rats 1egan to rework the 1anking 1ill! the group of 1ankers that had worked so
hard in support of the +ldri(h *lan 1egan to split apart! and many of those 1ankers refused to (onsider an alternative plan%
&ar1urg was more (on(iliatory and remained in (onta(t with prominent )emo(rats! in(luding Carter .lass! (hairman of the
7ouse 1anking (ommittee! and 7% *arker &illis! the (ommittee e3pert! and (ontinued to write and speak on the new legislation%
&ar1urgIs reserve and dis(ounting (on(epts were em1ra(ed in the Federal Reserve plan! though the (entral 1ank gradually
a1andoned the emphasis on dis(ounting in favor of open market operations as the ma4or monetary poli(y tool% Nonetheless! his
efforts in edu(ating the (ountry! 1ringing sound 1anking te(hni5ues to the forefront of de1ate! were of tremendous importan(e in
final preparation and passage of the Federal Reserve +(t%
3pilogue
&ar1urgIs (areer didnIt end with passage of the Federal Reserve +(t% 6n a sense! the (lose of this (hapter marked the 1eginning
of his ne3t important role as a (entral 1anker% 7e was to wield a tremendous influen(e on the development of the <ystem he
worked so hard to help esta1lish% 6n spite of vehement opposition from many )emo(rats and populists! *resident &ilson asked
&ar1urg to 1e(ome a mem1er of the first Federal Reserve Board%
6t appears *resident &ilson made a wise de(ision% Jn(e &ar1urg was appointed to the 1oard! <e(retary of the Treasury &illiam
M(+doo! who often (lashed with &ar1urg over poli(y matters! e3plained &ar1urgIs appointment this way: Y6t was thought that
his te(hni(al knowledge in international finan(e would 1e useful% 6t was useful! in some respe(ts it was invalua1le%Y Ben4amin
<trong! governor of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York! went even further in his estimation of &ar1urg% +lthough &ar1urg
was appointed as a mem1er of the 1oard /not as the (hairman or vi(e (hairman0! <trong (alled &ar1urg Ythe real head of the
1oard in &ashington! so far as knowledge and a1ility goes%Y
But the fa(t that he was at all (hosen to serve on the 1oard seems to have 1een as mu(h a surprise to the -uropeanG1orn 1anker
as to those who took issue with his nomination% 6ndeed! he first de(lined the appointment 1e(ause of the Yrampant pre4udi(e in
this (ountry against a &all <treet man!Y and 1alked at testifying 1efore the <enate 1anking (ommittee 1e(ause other nominees
had not 1een asked to do so% 7owever! when &orld &ar 6 erupted in -urope! &ar1urg de(ided to waive all personal
(onsiderations Yin deferen(e to the presidentIs urgent re5uest and in view of the present urgen(y whi(h render desira1le the
promptest organiAation of the Federal Reserve Board!Y and appeared 1efore a largely antagonisti( (ommittee%
&ith &ar1urg 1efore them! rather than take advantage of his vast knowledge in (entral 1anking to learn how the (ountry would
adapt to this new system! the senators (hose instead to 5uestion the 1anker on Buhn! Coe1 and Co%Is Ymoney trustY (onne(tions%
Thus! one of the 1est opportunities for history to re(ord &ar1urgIs e3temporaneous impressions on the final .lassGJwen Federal
Reserve 1ill was lost% But when &ar1urg was 5uestioned as to his motives for making the sa(rifi(e N finan(ial and otherwise N
to 1e(ome a mem1er of the Federal Reserve Board! the nomineeIs answer was (hara(teristi(ally to the point:
Y&hen *resident &ilson asked me TagainU whether 6 would take this TonU and make the sa(rifi(e %%% 6 felt that 6 had no right to
de(line it8 and 6 will 1e glad to make the sa(rifi(e! 1e(ause 6 think there is a wonderful opportunity for 1ringing a great pie(e of
(onstru(tive work into su((essful operation! and it appeals to me to do that%Y
<our(e: The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis
http:@@www%minneapolisfed%org@pu1li(ationsZpapers@pu1Zdisplay%(fm?idX>=L
2But then the (onferen(e (losed! after a week of earnest deli1eration! the rough draft of what later 1e(ame the +ldri(h Bill had
1een agreed upon! and a plan had 1een outlined whi(h provided for a DNational Reserve +sso(iation!E meaning a (entral reserve
organiAation with an elasti( note issue 1ased on gold and (ommer(ial paper % % %The results of the conference were entirely
confidential. 3ven the fact there had been a meeting was not permitted to become public% % %Though eighteen years have
sin(e gone 1y! 6 do not feel free to give a des(ription of this most interesting (onferen(e (on(erning whi(h <enator +ldri(h
pledged all parti(ipants to se(re(y% % % The matter of a uniform dis(ount rate was dis(ussed and settled at 'ekyll 6sland%9
: *aul &ar1urg! F"=% *aul &ar1urg served as ,i(e Chairman of the Federal Reserve during &orld &ar 6%
Congressman Lin#bergh's 8rti+les of Dmpea+hment against the Fe#eral 6eser4e
&ongressional (ecord /;%<% 7ouse of Representatives0! Fe1ruary "! FH! p% >"?G>>#
;%<% Congressman Charles +% Cind1ergh <r% /=LFGF"$0
Mr% C6N)B-R.7% Mr% <peaker and the 7ouse of Representatives! 6! Charles +% Cind1ergh! the undersigned! upon my responsi1ility
as a Mem1er of the 7ouse of Representatives! do here1y impea(h &% *% .% 7arding! governor8 *aul M% &ar1urg! vi(e governor8
Frederi(k +% )elano! +dolph C% Miller! and Charles <% 7amlin! mem1ers! ea(h individually as a mem1er of the Federal Reserve
Board! and also all of them (olle(tively as the five a(tive working mem1ers of said 1oard! or high (rimes and misdemeanors%
6! upon my responsi1ility as a Mem1er of the 7ouse of Representatives! do here1y impea(h &% *% .% 7arding! governor8 *aul M%
&ar1urg! vi(e governor8 and Frederi(k +% )elano! +dolph C% Miller! and Charles <% 7amlin! mem1ers! and ea(h of them as mem1ers
of the Federal Reserve Board! and also impea(h all of them (olle(tively as the five a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve
Board! of high (rimes and misdemeanors in aiding! a1etting! and (onspiring with (ertain persons and firms hereinafter named! and
with other persons! and firms! known and unknown! in a (onspira(y to violate the Constitution and the laws of the ;nited <tates and
the 4ust and e5uita1le poli(ies of the .overnment! whi(h said (onspira(y developed and grew out of and was (onsummated from the
following fa(ts and a(ts! to wit:
First% Jn or a1out the month of 'uly! F#?! the e3a(t date 1eing unknown to the relater! the late '%*% Morgan of the firm of '% *% Morgan
K Co%! and the said firm! private 1ankers and 1rokers! with their main offi(e in New York City and doing 1usiness all over the world8
*aul M% &ar1urg! of the firm Buhn! Coe1 K Co%! and the firm of Buhn! Coe1 K Co! also private 1ankers and 1rokers! doing 1usiness
all over the world! with their main offi(e in New York City8 Cee! 7igginson! K Co%! also private 1ankers and 1rokers! doing 1usiness
all over the world with their main offi(es in Boston and New York: Bidder! *ea1ody K Co% +lso private 1ankers and 1rokers! doing
1usiness all over the world! with their main offi(es in Boston and New York! the National City Bank of New York with its offi(e in the
(ity of New York and doing a general 1anking 1usiness domesti( and foreign8 the First National Bank of New York with its offi(e in
New York (ity doing a general 1anking 1usiness domesti( and foreign8 and various other persons and firms! known unknown to the
relator ! did (onspire with ea(h other to devise a means through so(ial! politi(al! and other ways of strategy of and 1y general
(hi(anery! to de(eive the people of the ;nited <tates! the Congress! and the *resident of the ;nited <tates for the purpose and with the
o14e(t to se(ure an a(t of Congress providing for a new monetary and 1anking system to have in in a provision for a managing 1oard
vested with unusual and e3traordinary powers and to se(ure the appointment upon the 1oard of management that should 1e provided
for in the a(t persons for mem1ership on the 1oard who would 1y su1terfuge manipulation! and false administration! so manage as to
avoid the spirit and the purpose of the people of the ;nited <tates! the Congress! and the *resident aimed at in the passage of an a(t
and instead of administering the a(t to meet with the spirit and (omply with its terms! to indu(e and se(ure su(h 1oard to enter in the
(onspira(y aforesaid! to administer the a(t for the spe(ial 1enefit and advantage of all of the said (onspirators herein1efore named! and
their asso(iates and (ontrary to the letter! intent and purpose of the a(t itself and in (ontravention of the Constitution and law8 that in
order to start the (ampaign with a plan well matured to su((eed in said (onspira(y *aul M% &ar1urg! now vi(e governor of the Federal
Reserve Board! 1ut then a mem1er of the firm of Buhn! Coe1! K Co was a most a(tive parti(ipant in drafting the main features and
prin(iples whi(h should 1e em1odied into whatever 1ill might 1e put through Congress! and did also assist in a plan for a se(ond
(ampaign to 1e kept from the knowledge of the *resident with the appointing power! and from the <enate! with the (onfirming power
in the sele(tion and (onfirmation of all high Federal appointive offi(ials in order that a 1oard of administration should! when the time
(ame for its sele(tion! 1e appointed that would (arry out the designs of the (onspirators aforesaid8 that there that were many se(ret
meetings held 1y the (onspirators for this purpose whi(h under the very (ir(umstan(es would 1e s(reened and kept from the pu1li( and
made pra(ti(ally impossi1le to dis(over! 1ut nevertheless made (ertain of the fa(t 1e(ause of the a(ts whi(h point 1a(k to their
(reation8 that one of su(h meetings whi(h your relator does not undertake to verify the truth of its holding! 1ut is relia1ly informed that
it was held : is des(ri1ed in CeslieEs 6llustrated &eekly MagaAine in the J(to1er F! F?! num1er thereof! whi(h is here1y referred to
as showing the method most likely to have 1een followed for planning the then (ontemplated a(t of Congress whi(h is now the a(t
known as the Federal reserve a(t%
<e(ond% That in pursuan(e of said (onspira(y to promote the o14e(t of the (onspirators aforesaid and as part of that general s(heme to
indu(e Congress to legislate upon the monetary and 1anking system as stated herein1efore! said (onspirators (aused to 1e organiAed
the soG(alled CitiAens Ceague with head5uarters in the (ity of Chi(ago! to a(t as a mother organiAation and promoter to indu(e
organiAation of the several states of au3iliary and affiliated leagues! and 1y misrepresentation to the pu1li( and to the origin of said
mother league and its purpose to indu(e (itiAens who should have no knowledge of the said (onspira(y and would 1e inno(ent of any
wrong intention! and whose motives and intent would 1e to a(t in the (ommon interests of their (ountry! to 4oin in the formation of
au3iliary league throughout the several <tates in order to give the outward and surfa(e appearan(e of respe(ta1ility and honor! and that
in pursuan(e of that plan the (onspirators su((eeded in organiAing affiliated leagues in $L of the <tates8 that when organiAed the
(onspirators herein1efore named! themselves dire(ted who should 1e sent to these organiAations as speakers and instru(tors! and also
the kind of literature that should 1e distri1uted to the mem1ers and to the general pu1li(! the design of whi(h was to have only su(h
speakers! instru(tors! and literature as would dis(redit the then e3isting 1anking and (urren(y system and pre4udi(e the people in every
way possi1le against it8 1ut notwithstanding the then e3isting 1anking and (urren(y system was 1ad and unfitted to the demands of the
Nation and the needs of (ommer(e and trade! and su(h (ampaign was 1y its (onspirators aforesaid dire(ted not to designate to the
pu1li( what sort of a 1anking and (urren(y system would 1e adopted in its stead! 1ut the promoters of the (onspira(y should pretend
that the o14e(t of the (ampaign was to aid in every way to (reate a new monetary 1anking and (urren(y system to take the pla(e of the
then e3isting 1ad one! and! as far as it (ould 1e (one! the (onspirators should prevent the people getting together to prepare a plan of
their own to 1e presented to Congress: that the purpose of the (onspirators was simply to make the pu1li( 1elieve that a new 1anking
and (urren(y system was a1solutely ne(essary and at the same time keep the pu1li( from find out what would 1e its form and details!
all this for the reason that the (onspirators aforesaid had their own pre(on(eived plan prepared as a part of their (onspira(y! whi(h they
would se(retly manage in their own way to have presented to Congress as the plan in response to all this pu1li( sentiment whi(h the
(onspirators themselves had ingeniously worked out through the (ampaign aforesaid! and with the intent that Congress and the
*resident would legislate the (onspiratorsE said plan into effe(t8 that it was part of said plan to (reate many offi(es and positions with
lu(rative salaries! whi(h offi(es and positions would 1e e5uivalent to a 1id for the am1itious to support it! 1e(ause these offi(es and
positions would 1e filled 1y the leaders and most a(tive persons who would 4oin in the (ampaign to put the (onspira(y into effe(t and
influen(e Congress and the *resident for the purpose of se(uring the legislation%
Third% That in further pursuan(e of said (onspira(y and to 1e in (ontrol of the information and literature that should 1e distri1uted
through the Nation! the said (onspirators then having (ontrol of a large num1er of magaAines! newspapers! and pu1lishing (ompanies!
used all of these! and pro(eeded to pro(ure (ontrol of as many more as (ould 1e pur(hased or su1sidiAed to pu1lish arti(les prepared 1y
su1sidiAed writers who would (riti(iAe the e3isting 1anking and (urren(y system so as to (reate pu1li( sentiment against8 that of the
thousands of (ountry newspapers! a ma4ority of them use DsoG(alled 2patent9 arti(les not edited or even pra(ti(ally (ontrolled 1y the
owners of the papers! whi(h patent arti(les are (ommonly (alled 21oilerGpla(e9 stuff! and no responsi1ility as to the influen(e su(h
arti(les have upon the pu1li( atta(hes to any1ody8 that those writing this 21oilerGplate9 stuff so pu1lished! many of them were also
su1sidiAed and (ontrolled 1y the said (onspirators! so that the small newspapers were pra(ti(ally for(ed to (arry on a (ampaign against
the then e3isting 1anking and (urren(y system along the same lines of the others referred to herein1efore8 that readers generally do not
have the opportunity to distinguish 1etween 21oilerGplate9 arti(les and the arti(les whi(h the editors of the smaller papers write
themselves8 that the newsGdistri1uting agen(ies through the telegraph and telephone were then and still are largely (ontrolled 1y said
(onspirators! and the operators of the news agen(ies have 1een allowed to report only su(h news relating to a new 1anking and
(urren(y system as would promote said (onspira(y! and re5uired to suppress and everything in the way of information or news that
would tend to en(ourage the people to prepare for themselves a (on(rete plan for 1anking and (urren(y in the interest of all the people8
that the general play of the (onspira(y was to suppress every arti(le! statement! and thing so far as possi1le! whi(h would give any
information as to the e3isten(e of said (onspira(y all of whi(h was for the purpose of ena1ling the (onspirators aforesaid to de(eive the
people as well as Congress and the *resident! in order that said (onspirators might finally (onsummate their aforesaid (onspira(y%
Fourth% That in (onse5uen(e of the (ampaign (arried on 1y said (onspirators stated and re(ited in paragraphs named 2First!9 2<e(ond9
and 2Third9 in these impea(hment arti(les! and numerous se(ret! (landestine! and underground methods employed 1y said
(onspirators! the people of the ;nited <tates! the Congress! and the *resident were de(eived! and as the first offi(ial a(t in the
(onsummation of the o14e(ts sought 1y said (onspirators Congress did legislate and pass and a(t of Congress whi(h was signed 1y the
*resident! and is known as the Federal reserve a(t! whi(h a(t is su1stantially the plan prepared 1y said (onspirators as aforesaid%
Fifth% That immediately upon the passage of the Federal reserve a(t the said (onspirators disorganiAed the soG(alled 2CitiAensE Ceague9
and all the affiliated leagues in the $L <tates referred to in the paragraph named 9<e(ond9 herein8 that prior to su(h disorganiAation the
said (onspirators had 1y se(ret and underground methods! and for the purpose of using the same in (ompleting and perpetuating their
(onspira(y! organiAed another 2 asso(iation 2 and (alled it the 2;nited <tates Cham1er of Commer(e!9 giving it that name in order to
de(eive the pu1li( 1y making it appear that is a department of the .overnment! whi(h organiAation is administered with more intri(ate
ma(hinery for management the soG(alled 2CitiAensE Ceague9 was! and with a purpose of taking up the work of (oordinating everything
so(ial! politi(al! 1usiness and other to work for the 1enefit of the said (onspirators in (arrying out their plan to for(e the masses of
mankind into a1solute and a14e(t industrial slavery8 that the methods and the design of the 2;nited <tates Cham1er of Commer(e9 are
set forth to remarks whi(h your relator pla(ed in the CJN.R-<<6JN+C R-CJR) Mar(h #! F?! and are here1y referred to for
more spe(ifi( detail8 that the influen(e of the 2;nited <tates Cham1er of Commer(e9 is one of the agen(ies 1eing used as an aid to
further (onsummate the (onspira(y (harged in these arti(les of impea(hment%
<i3th% That the said Federal reserve a(t is so framed that it has the possi1ility and (ontains the provisions whi(h! under proper and
impartial administration! would furnish a remedy to some of the faults that e3isted in the 1anking and (urren(y system whi(h it
superseded! 1ut also (ontains provisions whi(h! under a 1ad and improper administration! makes it more dangerous to the pu1li(
welfare than ever the old 1anking and (urren(y system was8 that the main feature of the said Federal reserve a(t in giving effe(t to it is
the authority vested in the Federal Reserve Board and the dis(retion entrusted to the mem1ers thereof in its 2administration98 that the
2administration9 of said Federal reserve a(t is vested in the Federal Reserve Board! advised 1y the Federal reserve advisory (oun(il
made up of " persons! sele(ted 1y ea(h of the " Federal reserve 1anks8 that the L a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve
Board are the said &%*%.% 7arding! governor8 *aul M% &ar1urg! vi(e governor8 and Frederi(k +% )elano! +dolph C% Miller! and
Charles <% 7amlin! mem1ers8 and that the Federal reserve advisory (oun(il is formed 1y the following persons to wit: )aniel .% &ing
of Boston8 '% *% Morgan! or New York8 Cevi C% Rue! of *hiladelphia8 &%<% Rose! of Cleveland8 '% N% Norwi(h of Ri(hmond8 Charles +%
Cyerly! of +tlanta8 '%B% Forgan% of Chi(ago8 Frank J% &atts! of <t Couis8 '%R% Mit(hell! of Minneapolis8 -%F% <winney! of Bansas City8
T% '% Re(ord! of )allas8 and 7er1ert Fleish1a(ker! of <an Fran(is(o8 that the said Federal Reserve Board and the said Federal reserve
advisory (oun(il held many meetings and are now and have 1een ever sin(e the Federal reserve a(t was passed! fully advised as to
finan(ial and 1usiness (onditions! domesti( and foreign8 that the mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board and the mem1ers of the
Federal reserve advisory (oun(il are men with enormous 1usiness interests! and ea(h of them have 1een for more than L years last
past! and are now e3(essive operators and spe(ulators for individual profit and gain in the markets! and (ontrol several of the largest
1anks in the (ountry8 that '%*% Morgan 'r% is the lending mem1er of the firm of '%*% Morgan K Co%! one of the firm herein1efore
(harged with 1eing a party to the (onspira(y aforesaid8 that several of the mem1ers of the Federal reserve advisory (oun(il own sto(k
in the National City Bank of New York and the First National Bank of New York! they 1eing the two 1anks (harged herein1efore with
1eing parties to the said (onspira(y! and said mem1ers also own sto(k and are interested in 1usiness and managed and (ontrolled 1y
the parties spe(ifi(ally named as the (onspirators in the paragraph herein1efore designated as 2First98 that *aul M% &ar1urg! a mem1er
and vi(e governor of the Federal Reserve Board! was at the time of the original formation of the (onspira(y aforesaid a party to the
said (onspira(y! and a partner and mem1er of the firm of Buhn! Coe1 K Co%! one of the (onspirators8 that ea(h of the mem1ers of the
Federal Reserve Board and of the Federal reserve advisory (oun(il are asso(iated with and form a part of a group of promoters and
spe(ulators! the individual mem1ers of whi(h reside in various parts of the ;nited <tates! prin(ipally in the large (ities! and a few of
them live in -urope! whi(h said group individually and (olle(tively deal in (redits! sto(ks! 1onds! se(urities and various promoting
enterprises from whi(h they have made 1illions of dollars in profits! and still operate and propose to (ontinue their operations for the
purpose of making still greater profits upon their future dealings8 that in further pursuan(e of their said purpose! they 4oined in the
original (onspira(y aforesaid and it was planned as a part of the said original (onspira(y to (reate several great 1usiness and finan(ial
(enters in different parts of the ;nited <tates in order to fa(ilitate with (elerity a (oordination of all 1ig 1usiness and all finan(ial
(ontrol8 for the 1enefit of the said (onspirators in (arrying out their plan of personal gain in (ontravention to the pu1li( welfare8 that
said group instigated the (ampaign whi(h finally resulted in the passage of the Federal reserve a(t8 that in the administration of said a(t
1y the said five a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board! and through the influen(e e3er(ised over them 1y the mem1ers
of the Federal reserve advisory (oun(il! and (olle(tively all of the mem1ers and mem1ership of 1oth the Federal Reserve Board and of
the Federal reserve advisory (oun(il! a part of and influen(ed 1y said larger 2group9 in this paragraph designated as having 4oined in
the (onspira(y aforesaid! the said five a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board! ea(h individually and all (olle(tively! at
all times sin(e they 1e(ame mem1ers of the said Federal Reserve Board! knowingly and intentionally have 1een improperly influen(ed
1y the said 2group!9 and 1e(ause of su(h influen(e have failed to administer the Federal reserve a(t in a((ordan(e with the spirit! letter!
and intent of Congress and the *resident when the a(t was passed8 1ut! on the (ontrary! the said five a(tive working mem1ers of the
Federal Reserve Board herein1efore spe(ifi(ally named as su(h! with intent to evade and set aside 1y 2administration9 all the purposes
of Congress and of the *resident in the passage and approval of the a(t! and of the a(t itself! have administered! and are now
administering! the Federal reserve a(t with the intent to (oordinate 21ig 1usiness9 and 2spe(ulation9 for the 1enefit of the said 2group9
of operators and spe(ulators herein1efore designated as having taken part in the original (onspira(y8 that said National City Bank
herein1efore named! in whi(h many of the other (onspirators own sto(k! a(ts as the 2offi(ial mouthpie(e9 for them all! to give
te(hni(al information to ena1le them all to a(t in (on(ert8 that to fa(ilitate its distri1ution said 1ank issues a monthly 1ulletin8 that in its
Fe1ruary! FH! 1ulletin! in an arti(le dealing with the present plethora of money and (redit availa1le! among other 2tips9 intended for
the (onspirators to a(t upon! is the following : and 6 would like the 7ouse to hear it : this is what is (ontained the 1ulletin whi(h the
National City Bank issued:
&nder the circumstances money promises to be in abundant supply, but if bankers have a proper regard for their
responsibilities it will not be correspondingly cheap. (ompensatory rates for money and ample reserves should be consistently
maintained.
That said 1ulletin was sent to the Federal Reserve Board! to all the Federal reserve 1anks! to all the larger National and <tate 1anks and
trust (ompanies! in order to 2tip9 off to the (onspirators and those a(ting in (on(ert to tighten the rates of interest8 that su(h 2tips9 are a
(ommon pra(ti(e and do prevent the redu(tion of interest rates to 1orrowers for legitimate 1usiness! (ontrary to the intent and purpose
of Congress and the *resident and in (ontravention of the a(t itself and to the enormous loss of the people and in4ury to the general
welfare%
<eventh% That there are appro3imately "#!### <tate 1anks and trust (ompanies in the ;nited <tates! in(orporated and organiAed under
the <tate laws of the respe(tive <tates in whi(h their offi(es and pla(es of 1usiness are lo(ated! and doing a general 1anking 1usiness!
<tate and interstate! many of whi(h are eligi1le to 1e(ome mem1ers of the Federal Reserve <ystem! and many not know eligi1le (ould
1e(ome so without an in(rease of their (apitaliAation8 that of those now eligi1le and that (ould 5ualify for mem1ership in the Federal
Reserve <ystem without an in(rease of their (apital! they have more than half of the (apitaliAation of all the 1anks not now in(luded in
the Federal Reserve <ystem8 that the (apitaliAation of <tate 1anks and trust (ompanies! whi(h are not mem1ers of the Federal Reserve
<ystem e3(eeds the (apital of the 1anks whi(h are mem1ers of the Federal <ystem8 that the governors and other high and
administrative offi(ials of the " Federal reserve 1anks! through their influen(e with mem1er 1anks! wittingly or unwittingly! 1ut most
of them wittingly! 1e(ame a((essories to the said (onspira(y of the said persons and parties named in these arti(les of impea(hment in
the paragraph herein designated as 2First9 and have (aused a 1oy(ott of all 1anks not mem1ers of the Federal Reserve <ystem 1y
influen(ing the mem1er 1anks to hamper! in(onvenien(e! and annoy the patrons of the nonmem1er 1anks 1y dis(rimination against
them in the (learing of (he(ks drawn upon them and otherwise! that they threaten and seek to (a4ole the nonmem1er 1anks in an
attempt to for(e them to 1e(ome mem1ers of the Federal Reserve <ystem8 that the said five a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal
Reserve Board are (ogniAant of the same8 that the intent! purpose! and aim of ea(h and all of the said (onspirators aforesaid is to
(ompel the <tate 1anks to 4oin the Federal Reserve <ystem for the purpose of 1ringing the said 1anks under the 4urisdi(tion of the
Federal Reserve Board in order that all of the 1anks! National and <tate! may 1e(ome one giganti( (om1ination with an a1solute and
(omplete monopoly and have the power of e3ploiting the people for the 1enefit of the (onspirators aforesaid%
-ighth% That Congress in (reating the Federal Reserve Board had in mind! and it is the spirit of the Federal reserve a(t! that the said
1oard should keep a guardian wat(h over the operations of the 1anking and (urren(y system and report to Congress and the (ountry8
from time to time su(h fa(ts and o((urren(es relating to 1anking and (urren(y as affe(t the 1usiness of the people in trade and
(ommer(e e3(hanges! domesti( and foreign! so that Congress should re(eive information that would give to Congress the fa(ts upon
whi(h to 1ase any ne(essary amendments to the a(t in order to make it responsive to the general welfare8 that (ontrary to the spirit of
the Federal Reserve a(t! the aforesaid five a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board have willfully failed to keep the
pu1li( and Congress informed of the inflation of 1ank (redits and the effe(t of it that has taken pla(e under the 2administration9 of the
said a(t! and in violation of the spirit thereof said mem1ers have (onspired with the mem1ers of the Federal reserve advisory (oun(il
and their 1usiness asso(iates herein1efore named and have aided and a1etted in a (onspira(y to a systemati( inflation of 1ank (redits
for the 1enefit of the said (onspirators and against the pu1li( welfare8 that in (onse5uen(e of said unlawful a(ts and misfeasan(e in
offi(e of the said mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board the 1ank have! for private gain! in(reased the 1ank (redits of the (ountry sin(e
the passage of said a(t appro3imately seven thousand millions of dollars and without effe(ting a (orresponding redu(tion in the interest
rate! thus in(reasing the aggregate amount of interest paid 1y the people to the said 1anks e5ual to that (harged upon said sum8 that the
effe(t of the inflation of 1ank (redits has 1een and is to also in(rease spe(ulative (redits enormously more than e5ual to the inflation of
1ank (redits! and that su(h in(rease sin(e the Federal reserve a(t took effe(t has 1een 1illions of dollars that the in(rease in the
aggregate sum of interest paid to the 1anks upon the said inflated 1ank (redits and the in(rease (aused 1y the said inflation in the
spe(ulative values upon (ommodities re5uired to supply the ne(essities of life for the people has 1een many 1illions of dollars! whi(h
have 1een added to the (ost of living for the people to pay8 that said in(rease in the (ost of living is mainly the profits that the
(onspirators have added to their individual fortunes to the e5uivalent loss of the people generally and to the .overnment as well%
Ninth% That as part of the said (onspira(y and in furtheran(e of the same the said aforesaid (onspirators! in violation of the NationEs
heretofore esta1lished e(onomi( poli(y of (onservation of material and natural resour(es! (onspired -uropean spe(ulators to draw
upon the material resour(es of this Nation for e3port with no (orrelation 1etween value of the materials e3ported and the value of the
materials imported8 that in (onse5uen(e of the (onspira(y to affe(t said e3port of material resour(es 1elonging to this Nation and to the
people of it appro3imately eight thousand millions of dollars in value of the material resour(es have 1een e3ported sin(e the war in
-urope 1egan8 that as a result thereof the said (onspirators a(ted with the said five mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board in
manipulating 1ank (redits! and through (redits the markets in(reased the (ost to +meri(an (onsumers in the same period
appro3imately si3teen thousand millions of dollars in e3(ess of the real values! whi(h e3tra (ost has mainly 1een the profits that have
1een added to the fortunes of the aforesaid (onspirators8 that as an additional and future loss to the people of this Nation in
(onse5uen(e of the fa(ts aforesaid! the natural material resour(es of the Nation are forever less! and the (osts made forever higher than
they would 1e if trade and (ommer(e were not manipulated through a false administration of finan(es%
Tenth% That to further (arry out the said (onspira(y the aforesaid (onspirators have! ever sin(e the Federal reserve a(t took effe(t!
sought to influen(e! and in fa(t have influen(ed! said five mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board in an attempt to further de(eive
Congress to se(ure legislation granting to the said 1oard enlarged powers of 2administration98 that in the <i3tyGthird Congress the said
1oard! (on(ealing the real purpose to aid said (onspirators! de(eived the <enate Banking and Curren(y Committee to get it to report for
passage the then <enate 1ill ?L#L and it passed the <enate and su1se5uently (ame 1efore the 7ouse Banking and Curren(y Committee
and was favora1ly reported! your relator! however! filing a minority report in opposition% Cater! on the floor of the 7ouse! the (hairman
of the Banking and Curren(y Committee withdrew a(tion on the 1ill8 that the aim of said 1ill was to give the Federal Reserve Board
greater 2administrative9 power over the gold supply! so that it (ould! whenever the (onspirators aforesaid wished it! inflate still further
the 1anking (redit 1y an issue of the FederalGreserve notes for the 1enefit of said (onspirators8 that again in this <i3tyGfourth Congress
said a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board alleged! repeatedly sought the 7ouse Banking and Curren(y Committee to
report a 1ill giving greater 2administrative9 powers to said 1oard than is authoriAed 1y the original a(t8 in fa(t! to give said 1oard
power to for(e from 1anks all over the (ountry the gold in their vaults and into the " Federal reserve 1anks! there to form a 1asis upon
whi(h to issue still more FederalGreserve notes and further inflate (redit without (ausing a redu(tion of interests that in the aggregate
would e5ual the (harge made on the inflated (urren(y! 1ut serving mainly as a guaranty to reinfor(e the (onspirators herein1efore
named in e3ploiting of the people for private gain%
-leventh% That the Federal reserve a(t o1ligates the ;nited <tates to redeem in gold at the ;nited <tates Treasury all Federal reserve
notes! and as a part of the said (onspira(y and in furtheran(e of the same! and to e3tend the spe(ulation of the operators and
perpetrators of the said (onspira(y to in(lude -urope and other foreign territory! they! most of them 1eing international as well as
domesti( 1ankers! seek to dominate the relations of the ;nited <tates with foreign (ountries and to selfishly influen(e the same 1y
means of the (ontrol of finan(es! and in furtheran(e of said 1ran(h of their spe(ulations have (onspired with the said five a(tive
working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board to se(ure aid from the Federal Reserve <ystem for said selfish purposes and not in the
interest of the pu1li(! the (onspirators in (onnivan(e with the said five a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board had the
said 1oard sele(t and appoint! through the Federal reserve 1ank of New York! the soG(alled Bank of -ngland as its agent! thus putting
the (redit of the .overnment of the ;nited <tates 1a(k of this foreign (orporation! organiAed for private gain! whi(h is no longer a1le
to make payments in gold and fails to give a statement of its true (onditions8 that said Federal Reserve Board is threatening to permit
and also to render aid to the international 1ankers in +meri(a who dominate the 1anking system! to enter into further entangling
allian(es with 1ankrupt (ountries of -urope at the very time this .overnment (ontemplates issuing hundreds of millions of dollars of
interestG1earing 1onds upon the (redit of the people of the Nation to meet the .overnment e3penses%
Twelfth% That during the Civil &ar the .overnment of the ;nited <tates issued money (ommonly (alled 2green1a(ks9 8 the same
1eing issued upon the (redit of the people of the Nation8 that of said 2green1a(ks9 so issued there have 1een ever sin(e their issue and
now are outstanding and in general (ir(ulation 1ased upon the (redit of the people of the ;nited <tates P>$?!?=!#?! for whi(h a
reserve of PL#!###!### in gold is held 1y the .overnment to guarantee their redemption if demanded8 that said (ir(ulating
2green1a(ks9 have already saved the .overnment from paying appro3imately P!###!###!### interest during the time they have 1een
in (ir(ulation and are now saving the .overnment appro3imately P?!###!### annually8 that in furtheran(e of said (onspira(y in these
arti(les of impea(hment alleged and as part thereof! the (onspirators have sought and 1y se(ret (onnivan(e new seek to have the said
2green1a(ks9 retired and the PL#!###!### of gold guarantee pla(ed in the Federal reserve 1anks on whi(h to 1ase the loaning of
21ank (redits9 as a su1stitute for the money owned 1y the people8 that if the Federal reserve 1anks are allowed to se(ure possession of
said gold! when the time (omes that the (onspirators aforesaid shall 1e a1le to use additional 1ank (redits to their advantages in
e3ploiting the people! the same would 1e(ome the 1asis for additional 1ank inflation! dire(tly and indire(tly! to the e3tent of over a
1illion dollars upon whi(h the 1anks would (olle(t a great sum of interest! and the spe(ulators would s(alp even greater profits from
additional manipulation of the markets! all of whi(h would 1e added to the (ost of living for the people to pay%
Thirteenth% That in furtheran(e of the said aforesaid (onspira(y and as a part of the same the said five a(tive working mem1ers of the
Federal Reserve Board! in their (apa(ity as mem1ers! have ar1itrarily at all times and with intent to prevent the legitimate 1usiness
interests of the (ountry se(uring the advantages that Congress sought to give 1y the passage of the Federal reserve a(t! and in
(onnivan(e with the 1ig reserve and (entral reserve 1anks (ontrolled 1y the (onspirators aforesaid! esta1lished redis(ount rates for
mem1er 1anks desiring to 1orrow from Federal reserve 1anks a1ove the rates (harged 1y the reserve and (entral reserve 1anks! whi(h
(reates an e3(use for the mem1er 1anks in the (ountry to (harge higher rates of interest to legitimate 1orrowers than they otherwise
would8 that the interest rates (harged 1y the reserve and (entral reserve 1anks! on the one hand! and the higher rates (harged 1y the
Federal reserve 1anks on the other hand! is maintained at (ertain times when the (onspirators aforesaid desire to draw the reserves of
the (ountry 1anks to the reserve and (entral reserve (ities for the interest that these reserve 1anks pay on deposit 1alan(es and in
anti(ipation of times when the (ountry 1anks may wish to redis(ount paper with said 1anks8 that 1y following the ar1itrary pra(ti(e of
redis(ounts aforesaid the said (onspirators are ena1led to and do go on with their spe(ulations! manipulate the markets! and e3ploit the
people! and whenever they find themselves in finan(ial stress they (an raise the rates of interest in the reserve and (entral reserve
1anks! whi(h they (ontrol! a1ove the Federal reserve 1ank dis(ount rates! thus for(ing the (ountry 1anks! whi(h may have redis(ounted
with reserve 1anks in order to give a((ommodations to their 1orrowers! to redis(ount with the Federal reserve 1anks to ena1le them to
repay the reserve and (entral reserve 1anks! in order to (reate free money and (redit for said (onspirators to (arry on their spe(ulations8
that the Federal reserve a(t (ontains several provisions whi(h when applied under the 2administrative9 power of the Federal Reserve
Board serve as a means of taking or imposing a toll in the nature of dis(riminatory interest rates in order to for(e a shift of money and
(redits from one se(tion of the (ountry to another! or out of the (ountry and to foreign (ountries8 that this dis(riminatory power vested
in the Federal Reserve Board is willfully a1used 1y the said five a(tive working mem1ers of the said 1oard for the 1enefit and in the
interest of the said aforesaid (onspirators8 that the people of the ;nited <tates have 1een in4ured to the e3tent of several 1illions of
dollars 1y reason thereof%
Fourteenth% That in furtheran(e of said aforesaid (onspira(y and to give the said aforesaid (onspirators (omplete pra(ti(al power to
(arry out and put into effe(t their purpose of making the masses of mankind a1solutely dependent upon 21ig 1usiness!9 and in order to
(reate industrial slaves of the masses the said aforesaid (onspirators did (onspire and now (onspire to have the Federal reserve a(t
2administered9 so as to ena1le the (onspirators to (oordinate all kinds of 21ig 1usinessE and to keep themselves in (ontrol of 21ig
1usiness!9 in order to amalgamate all of the 2trusts9 into one great trust in restraint and (ontrol of trade and (ommer(e! and thus 1e
a1le to e3ploit the masses and take from them their earnings! e3(ept what they would re5uire for 1are su1sisten(e8 that to that end and
to give them power to a((omplish the same said (onspirators have marshaled all of the different kinds of 21ig 1usiness9 and indu(ed
those in (ontrol to use their means and whatever kind of patronage and favors they have to give in su(h way as to promote the o14e(ts
and purposes of said (onspirators and to enslave the masses of humanity8 that at the same time that the said (onspirators marshal their
own 21ig 1usiness9 supporters 1y a (oordination of all their interests they have use every tri(k and su1terfuge possi1le to (reate
fri(tion among the masses and divide them into hostile (ontending fa(tions! thus keeping the masses from (oordinating their affairs to
promote the general welfare that the said aforesaid five a(tive working mem1ers of the Federal Reserve Board have all the time! 1y a
willful and wrongful 2administration9 of the Federal reserve a(t! aided and a1etted the said aforesaid (onspirators in promoting and
(arrying out the o14e(ts of their said (onspira(y and have refused and failed to so administer the Federal reserve a(t as to have the
same promote and operate in favor of the general welfare%
Fifteenth% That the Federal reserve a(t is void and un(onstitutional! 1ut that notwithstanding! the (onspirators aforesaid have so
manipulated things as to prevent the 5uestion of (onstitutionality of the a(t from 1eing 1rought 1efore the (ourts%
C7+RC-< +% C6N)B-R.7
Mr% <7-R&JJ)% Mr% <peaker! 6 would like to ask the gentleman a 5uestion%
Mr% C6N)B-R.7% 6 suppose my privilege stops now! does it?
The <*-+B-R% 6t does%
Mr% C6N)B-R.7% 6 ask for five minutes in whi(h to answer the 5uestion of the gentleman%
The <*-+B-R% The gentleman asks five minutes% 6s there o14e(tion? There was no o14e(tion%
Mr% <7-R&JJ)% 6n (ase the <enate should sit as an impea(hment (ourt! you have eviden(e to esta1lish that (harge?
Mr% C6N)B-R.7% 6 want to say this: 6 have spent enough time and made enough investigation of this (ase to know that 6 (an
demonstrate : a((urately! 6 may say! 1ut to a mathemati(al (ertainty : that the (harges in this impea(hment are su1stantially true% 6
may not 1e a1le to esta1lish 1y dire(t proof that that some of these meetings to whi(h the impea(hment refers were held! 1ut that the
(harges are su1stantially true! 6 will (ertainly show%
Mr% <7-R&JJ)% That is! 1y su1stantial eviden(e?
Mr% C6N)B-R.7% By su1stantial eviden(e! and 1y effe(ts whi(h the 1usiness of this (ountry demonstrates 1eyond 5uestion% Now!
Mr% <peaker! 6 ask leave to insert! following the reading of these arti(les! my remarks upon them and the 5uestions that are in(identally
involved in the impea(hment arti(les%
The <*-+B-R% The gentleman from Minnesota asks unanimous (onsent to e3tend his remarks in the R-CJR)% 6s there o14e(tion?
Mr% <6-.-C% 6 o14e(t%
The <*-+B-R% The gentleman from New York o14e(ts%
Mr% B6TC76N% Mr% Chairman! 6 move that the impea(hment arti(les 1e referred to the Committee on the 'udi(iary! and on that 6
demand the previous 5uestion%
The <*-+B-R% The gentleman from North Carolina moves that the impea(hment arti(les 1e referred to the Committee on the
'udi(iary! and on that he demands the previous 5uestion% The previous 5uestion was ordered%
The <*-+B-R% The 5uestion is on agreeing to the motion to refer% The 5uestion was taken! and the motion was agreed to%
Note: Charles +% Cind1ergh <r% /Repu1li(an *artyGMinnesota0 was a Mem1er of the ;%<% 7ouse of Representatives from Mar(h
$! F#H to Mar(h >! FH%
Congressman Couis T% M(FaddenEs <pee(h
6n the ;%<% 7ouse of Representatives
# 'une F>"
Mr% Chairman! at the present session of Congress we have 1een dealing with emergen(y situations% &e have 1een dealing with
the effe(t of things rather than with the (ause of things% 6n this parti(ular dis(ussion 6 shall deal with some of the (auses that lead
up to these proposals% There are underlying prin(iples whi(h are responsi1le for (onditions su(h as we have at the present time
and 6 shall deal with one of these in parti(ular whi(h is tremendously important in the (onsideration that you are now giving to
this 1ill%
r. (hairman, we have in this country one of the most corrupt institutions the world has ever known. I refer to the
#ederal $eserve )oard and the #ederal $eserve )anks. The #ederal $eserve )oard, a Government board, has cheated
the Government of the &nited %tates and the people of the &nited %tates out of enough money to pay the national debt.
The depredations and ini*uities of the #ederal $eserve )oard has cost this country enough money to pay the national
debt several times over. This evil institution has impoverished and ruined the people of the &nited %tates, has
bankrupted itself, and has practically bankrupted our Government. It has done this through the defects of the law under
which it operates, through the maladministration of that law by the #ederal $eserve )oard, and through the corrupt
practices of the moneyed vultures who control it.
%ome people think the #ederal $eserve banks are &nited %tates Government institutions. They are not Government
institutions. They are private credit monopolies which prey upon the people of the &nited %tates for the benefit of
themselves and their foreign customers, foreign and domestic speculators and swindlers, and rich and predatory money
lenders. In that dark crew of financial pirates there are those who would cut a manHs throat to get a dollar out of his
pocket, there are those who send money into %tates to buy votes to control our legislation, and there are those who
maintain international propaganda for the purpose of deceiving us and of wheedling us into the granting of new
concessions which will permit them to cover up their past misdeeds and set again in motion their gigantic train of crime.
These twelve private credit monopolies were deceitfully and disloyally foisted upon this country by the bankers who
came here from 3urope and repaid us for our hospitality by undermining our !merican institutions. Those 1ankers took
money out of this (ountry to finan(e 'apan in a war against Russia% They (reated a reign of terror in Russia with our money in
order to help that war along% They instigated the separate pea(e 1etween .ermany and Russia and thus drove a wedge 1etween
the +llies in the &orld &ar% They finan(ed TrotskyIs passage from New York to Russia so that he might assist in the destru(tion
of the Russian -mpire% They fomented and instigated the Russian revolution and they pla(ed a large fund of +meri(an dollars at
TrotskyIs disposal in one of their 1ran(h 1anks in <weden so that through him Russian homes might 1e thoroughly 1roken up
and Russian (hildren flung far and wide from their natural prote(tors% They have sin(e 1egun the 1reaking up of +meri(an
homes and the dispersal of +meri(an (hildren%
6t has 1een said that *resident &ilson was de(eived 1y the attentions of these 1ankers and 1y the philanthropi( poses they
assumed% 6t has 1een said that when he dis(overed the manner in whi(h he had 1een misled 1y Colonel 7ouse! he turned against
that 1usy1ody! that Yholy monkY of the finan(ial empire! and showed him the door% 7e had the gra(e to do that! and in my
opinion he deserves great (redit for it%
*resident &ilson died a vi(tim of de(eption% &hen he (ame to the *residen(y! he had (ertain 5ualities of mind and heart
whi(h entitled him to a high pla(e in the (oun(ils of this Nation8 1ut there was one thing he was not and whi(h he never aspired
to 1e8 he was not a 1anker% 7e said that he knew very little a1out 1anking% 6t was! therefore! on the advi(e of others that the
ini5uitous Federal Reserve a(t! the death warrant of +meri(an li1erty! 1e(ame law in his administration%
Mr% Chairman! there should 1e no partisanship in matters (on(erning the 1anking and (urren(y affairs of this (ountry! and 6
do not speak with any%
6n F" the National Monetary +sso(iation! under the (hairmanship of the late <enator Nelson &% +ldri(h! made a report
and presented a vi(ious 1ill (alled the National Reserve +sso(iation 1ill% This 1ill is usually spoken of as the +ldri(h 1ill%
<enator +ldri(h did not write the +ldri(h 1ill% 7e was the tool! 1ut not the a((ompli(e! of the -uropeanG1orn 1ankers who for
nearly twenty years had 1een s(heming to set up a (entral 1ank in this (ountry and who in F" had spent and were (ontinuing
to spend vast sums of money to a((omplish their purpose%
The +ldri(h 1ill was (ondemned in the platform upon whi(h Theodore Roosevelt was nominated in the year F"! and in
that same year! when &oodrow &ilson was nominated! the )emo(rati( platform! as adopted at the Baltimore (onvention!
e3pressly stated: Y&e are opposed to the +ldri(h plan for a (entral 1ank%Y This was plain language% The men who ruled the
)emo(rati( *arty then promised the people that if they were returned to power there would 1e no (entral 1ank esta1lished here
while they held the reigns of government% Thirteen months later that promise was 1roken! and the &ilson administration! under
the tutelage of those sinister &all <treet figures who stood 1ehind Colonel 7ouse! esta1lished here in our free (ountry the wormG
eaten monar(hi(al institution of the YkingIs 1ankY to (ontrol us from the top downward! and to sha(kle us from the (radle to the
grave% The Federal Reserve a(t destroyed our old and (hara(teristi( way of doing 1usiness8 it dis(riminated against our oneG
name (ommer(ial paper! the finest in the world8 it set up the anti5uated twoGname paper! whi(h is the present (urse of this
(ountry! and whi(h wre(ked every (ountry whi(h has ever given it s(ope8 it fastened down upon this (ountry the very tyranny
from whi(h the framers of the &onstitution sought to save us%
Jne of the greatest 1attles for the preservation of this Repu1li( was fought out here in 'a(ksonIs day! when the <e(ond
Bank of the ;nited <tates! whi(h was founded upon the same false prin(iples as those whi(h are here e3emplified in the Federal
Reserve a(t! was hurled out of e3isten(e% +fter the downfall of the <e(ond Bank of the ;nited <tates in =>H! the (ountry was
warned against the dangers that might ensue if the predatory interests! after 1eing (ast out! should (ome 1a(k in disguise and
unite themselves to the -3e(utive! and through him a(5uire (ontrol of the .overnment% That is what the predatory interests did
when they (ame 1a(k in the livery of hypo(risy and under false pretenses o1tained the passage of the Federal Reserve a(t%
The danger that the (ountry was warned against (ame upon us and is shown in the long train of horrors attendant upon the
affairs of the traitorous and dishonest Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks are fully lia1le% This is an era of
finan(ed (rime and in the finan(ing of (rime! the Federal Reserve Board does not play the part of a disinterested spe(tator%
6t has 1een said that the draughtsman who was employed to write the te3t of the Federal Reserve 1ill used a te3t of the
+ldri(h 1ill for his purpose% 6t has 1een said that the language of the +ldri(h 1ill was used 1e(ause the +ldri(h 1ill had 1een
drawn up 1y e3pert lawyers and seemed to 1e appropriate% 6t was indeed drawn up 1y lawyers% The +ldri(h 1ill was (reated 1y
a((eptan(e 1ankers of -uropean origin in New York City% 6t was a (opy and in general a translation of the statutes of the
Rei(hs1ank and other -uropean (entral 1anks%
7alf a million dollars was spent one part of the propaganda organiAed 1y those same -uropean 1ankers for the purpose of
misleading pu1li( opinion in regard to it! and for the purpose of giving Congress the impression that there was an overwhelming
popular demand for that kind of 1anking legislation and the kind of (urren(y that goes with it! namely! an asset (urren(y 1ased
on human de1ts and o1ligations instead of an honest (urren(y 1ased on gold and silver values% )r% 7% *arker &illis had 1een
employed 1y the &all <treet 1ankers and propagandists and when the +ldri(h measure (ame to naught and he o1tained
employment with Carter .lass to assist in drawing a 1anking 1ill for the &ilson administration! he appropriated the te3t of the
+ldri(h 1ill for his purpose% There is no se(ret a1out it% The te3t of the Federal Reserve a(t was tainted from the 1eginning%
Not all of the )emo(rati( Mem1ers of the <i3tyGthird Congress voted for this great de(eption% <ome of them remem1ered
the tea(hings of 'efferson8 and! through the years! there had 1een no (riti(isms of the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal
Reserve 1anks so honest! so outGspoken! and so unsparingly as those whi(h have 1een voi(ed here 1y )emo(rats% +gain!
although a num1er of Repu1li(ans voted for the Federal Reserve a(t! the wisest and most (onservative mem1ers of the
Repu1li(an *arty would have nothing to do with it and voted against it% + few days 1efore the 1ill (ame to a vote! <enator 7enry
Ca1ot Codge! of Massa(husetts! wrote to <enator 'ohn &% &eeks as follows:
New York City, December 17, 1913
My Dear Senator Weeks:
Throuhout my !ub"ic "i#e $ ha%e su!!orte& a"" measures &esine& to take the 'o%ernment out o#
the bankin business(((( This bi"" !uts the 'o%ernment into the bankin business as ne%er
be#ore in our history an& makes, as $ un&erstan& it, a"" notes 'o%ernment notes when they
shou"& be bank notes(
The !owers %este& in the )e&era" *eser%e +oar& seem to me hih"y &anerous,
es!ecia""y where there is !o"itica" contro" o# the +oar&( $ shou"& be sorry to ho"& stock in a
bank sub,ect to such &omination( The bi"" as it stan&s seems to me to o!en the way to a %ast
in#"ation o# the currency( There is no necessity o# &we""in u!on this !oint a#ter the
remarkab"e an& most !ower#u" arument o# the senior Senator #rom New York( $ can be content
here to #o""ow the e-am!"e o# the .n"ish can&i&ate #or /ar"iament who thouht it enouh 0to
say &itto to Mr( +urke(0 $ wi"" mere"y a&& that $ &o not "ike to think that any "aw can be
!asse& which wi"" make it !ossib"e to submere the o"& stan&ar& in a #"oo& o# irre&eemab"e
!a!er currency(
$ ha& ho!e& to su!!ort this bi"", but $ can not %ote #or it as it stan&s, because it
seems to me to contain #eatures an& to rest u!on !rinci!"es in the hihest &eree menacin to
our !ros!erity, to stabi"ity in business, an& to the enera" we"#are o# the !eo!"e o# the
1nite& States(
2ery sincere"y yours,
3enry Cabot 4o&e
6n eighteen years that have passed sin(e <enator Codge wrote that letter of warning all of his predi(tions have (ome true% The
.overnment is in the 1anking 1usiness as never 1efore% +gainst its will it has 1een made the 1a(ker of horsethieves and (ard
sharps! 1ootleggers! smugglers! spe(ulators! and swindlers in all parts of the world% Through the Federal Reserve Board and the
Federal Reserve 1anks the riffraff of every (ountry is operating on the pu1li( (redit of this ;nited <tates .overnment%
Meanwhile! and on a((ount of it! we ourselves are in the midst of the greatest depression we have ever known% Thus the mena(e
to our prosperity! so feared 1y <enator Codge! has indeed stru(k home% From the +tlanti( to the *a(ifi( our (ountry has 1een
ravaged and laid waste 1y the evil pra(ti(es of the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks and the interests whi(h
(ontrol them% +t no time in our history has the general welfare of the people of the ;nited <tates 1een at a lower level or the
mind of the people so filled with despair%
Re(ently in one of our <tates ?#!### dwelling houses and farms were 1rought under the hammer in a single day% +((ording
to the Rev% Father Charles -% Coughlin! who has lately testified 1efore a (ommittee of this 7ouse! H!### houses and farms in
Jakland County! Mi(higan! have 1een sold and their erstwhile owners dispossessed% <imilar o((urren(es have pro1a1ly taken
pla(e in every (ounty in the ;nited <tates% The people who have thus 1een driven out are the wastage of the Federal Reserve a(t%
They are the vi(tims of the dishonest and uns(rupulous Federal Reserve Board and Federal Reserve 1anks% Their (hildren are the
new slaves of the au(tion 1lo(ks in the revival here of the institution of human slavery%
6n F>! 1efore the <enate Banking and Curren(y Committee! Mr% +le3ander Cassen made the following statement:
+ut the who"e scheme o# the )e&era" *eser%e bank with its commercia"5!a!er basis is an
im!ractica", cumbersome machinery, is sim!"y a co%er, to #in& a way to secure the !ri%i"ee o#
issuin money an& to e%a&e !ayment o# as much ta- u!on circu"ation as !ossib"e, an& then
contro" the issue an& maintain, instea& o# re&uce, interest rates( $t is a system that, i#
inauurate&, wi"" !ro%e to the a&%antae o# the #ew an& the &etriment o# the !eo!"e o# the
1nite& States( $t wi"" mean continue& shortae o# actua" money an& #urther e-tension o#
cre&its6 #or when there is a "ack o# rea" money !eo!"e ha%e to borrow cre&it to their cost(
+ few days 1efore the Federal Reserve a(t was passed <enator -lihu Root denoun(ed the Federal Reserve 1ill as an outrage on
our li1erties and made the following predi(tion: YCong 1efore we wake up from our dreams of prosperity through an inflated
(urren(y! our gold! whi(h alone (ould have kept us from (atastrophe! will have vanished and no rate of interest will tempt it to
return%Y
6f ever a prophe(y (ame true! that one did% 6t was impossi1le! however! for those luminous and instru(ted thinkers to
(ontrol the (ourse of events% Jn )e(em1er ">! F>! the Federal Reserve 1ill 1e(ame law! and that night Colonel 7ouse wrote to
his hidden master in &all <treet as follows:
$ want to say a wor& o# a!!reciation to you #or the si"ent but no &oubt e##ecti%e work you
ha%e &one in the interest o# currency "eis"ation an& to conratu"ate you that the measure has
#ina""y been enacte& into "aw( We a"" know that an entire"y !er#ect bi"", satis#actory to
e%erybo&y, wou"& ha%e been an im!ossibi"ity, an& $ #ee" 7uite certain that un"ess the
/resi&ent ha& stoo& as #irm as he &i& we shou"& "ike"y ha%e ha& no "eis"ation at a""( The
bi"" is a oo& one in many res!ects6 anyhow oo& enouh to start with an& to "et e-!erience
teach us in what &irection it nee&s !er#ection, which in &ue time we sha"" then et( $n any
e%ent you ha%e !ersona""y oo& reason to #ee" rati#ie& with what has been accom!"ishe&(
The words Yunless the *resident had stood as firm as he did we should likely have had no legislation at all!Y were a gentle
reminder that it was Colonel 7ouse himself! the Yholy monk!Y who had kept the *resident firm%
The foregoing letter affords striking eviden(e of the manner in whi(h the predatory interests then sought to (ontrol the
.overnment of the ;nited <tates 1y surrounding the -3e(utive with the personality and the influen(e of a finan(ial 'udas% Ceft
to itself and to the (ondu(t of its own legislative fun(tions without pressure from the -3e(utive! the Congress would not have
passed the Federal Reserve a(t% +((ording to Colonel 7ouse! and sin(e this was his report to his master! we may 1elieve it to 1e
true! the Federal Reserve a(t was passed 1e(ause &ilson stood firm8 in other words 1e(ause &ilson was under the guidan(e and
(ontrol of the most fero(ious usurers in New York through their hireling! 7ouse% The Federal Reserve a(t 1e(ame law the day
1efore Christmas -ve in the year F>! and shortly afterwards the .erman international 1ankers! Buhn! Coe1 and Co%! sent one
of their partners here to run it%
6n F>! when the Federal Reserve 1ill was su1mitted to the )emo(rati( (au(us! there was a dis(ussion in regard to the
form the proposed paper (urren(y should take% The proponents of the Federal Reserve a(t! in their determination to (reate a new
kind of paper money! had not needed to go outside of the +ldri(h 1ill for a model% By the terms of the +ldri(h 1ill! 1ank notes
were to 1e issued 1y the National Reserve +sso(iation and were to 1e se(ured partly 1y gold or lawful money and partly 1y
(ir(ulating eviden(es of de1t% The first draft of the Federal Reserve 1ill presented the same general plan! that is! for 1ank notes as
opposed to .overnment notes! 1ut with (ertain differen(es of regulation%
&hen the provision for the issuan(e of Federal Reserve notes was pla(ed 1efore *resident &ilson he approved of it! 1ut
other )emo(rats were more mindful of )emo(rati( prin(iples and a great protest greeted the plan% Foremost amongst those who
denoun(ed it was &illiam 'ennings Bryan! the <e(retary of <tate% Bryan wished to have the Federal Reserve notes issued as
.overnment o1ligations% *resident &ilson had an interview with him and found him adamant% +t the (on(lusion of the interview
Bryan left with the understanding that he would resign if the notes were made 1ank notes% The *resident then sent for his
<e(retary and e3plained the matter to him% Mr% Tumulty went to see Bryan and Bryan took from his li1rary shelves a 1ook
(ontaining all the )emo(rati( platforms and read e3tra(ts from them 1earing on the matter of the pu1li( (urren(y% Returning to
the *resident! Mr% Tumulty told him what had happened and ventured the opinion that Mr% Bryan was right and that Mr% &ilson
was wrong% The *resident then asked Mr% Tumulty to show him where the )emo(rati( *arty in its national platforms had ever
taken the view indi(ated 1y Bryan% Mr% Tumulty gave him the 1ook! whi(h he had 1rought from BryanIs house! and the *resident
read very (arefully plank after plank on the (urren(y% 7e then said! Y6 am (onvin(ed there is a great deal in what Mr% Bryan
says!Y and thereupon it was arranged that Mr% Tumulty should see the proponents of the Federal Reserve 1ill in an effort to 1ring
a1out an ad4ustment of the matter%
The remainder of this story may 1e told in the words of <enator .lass% Con(erning BryanIs opposition to the plan of
allowing the proposed Federal Reserve notes to take the form of 1ank notes and the manner in whi(h *resident &ilson and the
proponents of the Federal Reserve 1ill yielded to Bryan in return for his support of the measure! <enator .lass makes the
following statement:
The on"y other #eature o# the currency bi"" aroun& which a con#"ict rae& at this time was the
note5issue !ro%ision( 4on be#ore $ knew it, the /resi&ent was &es!erate"y worrie& o%er it(
3is economic oo& sense to"& him the notes shou"& be issue& by the banks an& not by the
'o%ernment6 but some o# his a&%isers to"& him Mr( +ryan cou"& not be in&uce& to i%e his
su!!ort to any bi"" that &i& not !ro%i&e #or a 0'o%ernment note(0 There was in the Senate an&
3ouse a "are +ryan #o""owin which, unite& with a natura""y a&%ersary !arty %ote, cou"&
!re%ent "eis"ation( Certain o%ercon#i&ent ent"emen !ro##ere& their ser%ices in the task o#
0manain +ryan(0 They &i& not bu&e him(((( When a &ecision cou"& no "oner be !ost!one& the
/resi&ent summone& me to the White 3ouse to say he wante& )e&era" *eser%e notes to 0be
ob"iations o# the 1nite& States(0 $ was #or an instant s!eech"ess( With a"" the earnestness
o# my bein $ remonstrate&, !ointin out the unscienti#ic nature o# such a thin, as we"" as
the e%i&ent inconsistency o# it(
0There is not, in truth, any 'o%ernment ob"iation here, Mr( /resi&ent,0 $ e-c"aime&(
0$t wou"& be a !retense on its #ace( Was there e%er a 'o%ernment note base& !rimari"y on the
!ro!erty o# bankin institutions8 Was there e%er a 'o%ernment issue not one &o""ar o# which
cou"& be !ut out e-ce!t by &eman& o# a bank8 The sueste& 'o%ernment ob"iation is so remote
it cou"& ne%er be &iscerne&,0 $ conc"u&e&, out o# breath(
0.-act"y so, '"ass,0 earnest"y sai& the /resi&ent( 0.%ery wor& you say is true6 the
'o%ernment "iabi"ity is a mere thouht( 9n& so, i# we can ho"& to the substance o# the thin
an& i%e the other #e""ow the sha&ow, why not &o it, i# thereby we may sa%e our bi""80
<hadow and su1stan(e[ Jne (an see from this how little *resident &ilson knew a1out 1anking% ;nknowingly! he gave the
su1stan(e to the international 1anker and the shadow to the (ommon man% Thus was Bryan (ir(umvented in his efforts to uphold
the )emo(rati( do(trine of the rights of the people% Thus the Yuns(ientifi( 1lurY upon the 1ill was perpetrated% The Yuns(ientifi(
1lur!Y however! was not the fa(t that the ;nited <tates .overnment! 1y the terms of BryanIs edi(t! was o1liged to assume as an
o1ligation whatever (urren(y was issued% Mr% Bryan was right when he insisted that the ;nited <tates should preserve its
sovereignty over the pu1li( (urren(y% The Yuns(ientifi( 1lurY was the nature of the (urren(y itself! a nature whi(h makes it unfit
to 1e assumed as an o1ligation of the ;nited <tates .overnment% 6t is the worst (urren(y and the most dangerous this (ountry has
ever known% &hen the proponents of the a(t saw that the )emo(rati( do(trine would not permit them to let the proposed 1anks
issue the new (urren(y as 1ank notes! they should have stopped at that% They should not have foisted that kind of (urren(y!
namely! an asset (urren(y! on the ;nited <tates .overnment% They should not have made the .overnment lia1le on the private
de1ts of individuals and (orporations and! least of all! on the private de1ts of foreigners%
The Federal Reserve note is essentially unsound% +s Bemmerer says: YThe Federal Reserve notes! therefore! in form have
some of the 5ualities of .overnment paper money! 1ut! in su1stan(e! are almost a pure asset (urren(y possessing a .overnment
guaranty against whi(h (ontingen(y the .overnment has made no provision whatever%Y 7on% -%'% 7ill! a former Mem1er of the
7ouse! said! and truly: YThey are o1ligations of the .overnment for whi(h the ;nited <tates has re(eived nothing and for the
payment of whi(h at any time it assumes the responsi1ility looking to the Federal Reserve to re(oup itself%Y
6f the ;nited <tates .overnment is to redeem the Federal Reserve notes when the general pu1li( finds out what it (osts to
deliver this flood of paper money to the twelve Federal Reserve 1anks! and if the .overnment has made no provision for
redeeming them! the first element of unsoundness is not far to seek%
Before the Banking and Curren(y Committee! when the Federal Reserve 1ill was under dis(ussion! Mr% CroAier! of
Cin(innati! said:
$n other wor&s, the im!eria" !ower o# e"asticity o# the !ub"ic currency is wie"&e& e-c"usi%e"y
by these centra" cor!orations owne& by the banks( This is a "i#e an& &eath !ower o%er a""
"oca" banks an& a"" business( $t can be use& to create or &estroy !ros!erity, to war& o## or
cause strinencies an& !anics( +y makin money arti#icia""y scarce, interest rates throuhout
the country can be arbitrari"y raise& an& the bank ta- on a"" business an& cost o# "i%in
increase& #or the !ro#it o# the banks ownin these reiona" centra" banks, an& without the
s"ihtest bene#it to the !eo!"e( These twe"%e cor!orations toether co%er the who"e country
an& mono!o"i:e an& use #or !ri%ate ain e%ery &o""ar o# the !ub"ic currency an& a"" !ub"ic
re%enue o# the 1nite& States( Not a &o""ar can be !ut into circu"ation amon the !eo!"e by
their 'o%ernment without the consent o# an& on terms #i-e& by these twe"%e !ri%ate money
trusts(
6n defian(e of this and all other warnings! the proponents of the Federal Reserve a(t (reated the twelve private (redit
(orporations and gave them an a1solute monopoly of the (urren(y of the ;nited <tates! not of the Federal Reserve notes alone!
1ut of all the (urren(y! the Federal Reserve a(t providing ways 1y means of whi(h the gold and general (urren(y in the hands of
the +meri(an people (ould 1e o1tained 1y the Federal Reserve 1anks in e3(hange for Federal Reserve notes! whi(h are not
money! 1ut merely promises to pay money% <in(e the evil day when this was done the initial monopoly has 1een e3tended 1y
vi(ious amendments to the Federal Reserve a(t and 1y the unlawful and treasona1le pra(ti(es of the Federal Reserve Board and
the Federal Reserve 1anks%
Mr% Chairman! when a Chinese mer(hant sells human hair to a *aris wigmaker and 1ills him in dollars! the Federal Reserve
1anks (an 1uy his 1ill against the wigmaker and then use that 1ill as (ollateral for the Federal Reserve notes% The ;nited <tates
.overnment thus pays the Chinese mer(hant the de1t of the wigmaker and gets nothing in return e3(ept a shady title to the
Chinese hair%
Mr% Chairman! if a <(ottish distiller wishes to send a (argo of <(ot(h whiskey to the ;nited <tates! he (an draw his 1ill
against the pur(hasing 1ootlegger in dollars8 and after the 1ootlegger has a((epted it 1y writing his name a(ross the fa(e of it! the
<(ot(h distiller (an send that 1ill to the nefarious open dis(ount market in New York City! where the Federal Reserve Board and
the Federal Reserve 1anks will 1uy it and use it as (ollateral for a new issue of Federal Reserve notes% Thus the .overnment of
the ;nited <tates pays the <(ot(h distiller for the whiskey 1efore it is shipped8 and if it is lost on the way! or if the Coast .uard
seiAes it and destroys it! the Federal Reserve 1anks simply write off the loss and the .overnment never re(overs the money that
was paid to the <(ot(h distiller% &hile we are attempting to enfor(e prohi1ition here! the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal
Reserve 1anks are finan(ing the distillery 1usiness in -urope and paying 1ootleggersI 1ills with the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited
<tates .overnment%
Mr% Chairman! if a .erman 1rewer ships 1eer to this (ountry or anywhere else in the world and draws his 1ill for it in
dollars! the Federal Reserve 1anks will 1uy that 1ill and use it as (ollateral for Federal Reserve notes% Thus! they (ompel our
.overnment to pay the .erman 1rewer for his 1eer% &hy should the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks 1e
permitted to finan(e the 1rewing industry in .ermany! either in this way or as they do 1y (ompelling small and fearful ;nited
<tates 1anks to take sto(k in the 6sen1e(k 1rewery and in the .erman 1ank for 1rewing industries?
Mr% Chairman! if )ynamit No1el of .ermany wishes to sell dynamite to 'apan to use in Man(huria or elsewhere! it (an
draw its 1ill against the 'apanese (ustomers in dollars and send that 1ill to the nefarious open dis(ount market in New York City!
where the Federal Reserve Board and Federal Reserve 1anks will 1uy it and use it as (ollateral for a new issue of Federal
Reserve notes! while at the same time the Federal Reserve Board will 1e helping )ynamit No1el 1y stuffing its sto(k into the
;nited <tates 1anking system% &hy should we send our representatives to the disarmament (onferen(e at .eneva while the
Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks are making our .overnment pay 'apanese de1ts to .erman munition
makers?
Mr% Chairman! if a 1ean grower of Chile wishes to raise a (rop of 1eans and sell them to a 'apanese (ustomer! he (an draw
a 1ill against his prospe(tive 'apanese (ustomer in dollars and have it pur(hased 1y the Federal Reserve Board and Federal
Reserve 1anks and get the money out of this (ountry at the e3pense of the +meri(an people 1efore he has even planted the 1eans
in the ground%
Mr% Chairman! if a .erman in .ermany wishes to e3port goods to <outh +meri(a or anywhere else! he (an draw his 1ill
against his (ustomer and send it to the ;nited <tates and get the money out of this (ountry 1efore he ships or even manufa(tures
the goods%
Mr% Chairman! why should the (urren(y of the ;nited <tates 1e issued on the strength of Chinese human hair? &hy should
it 1e issued on the trade whims of a wigmaker? &hy should it 1e issued on the strength of .erman 1eer? &hy should it 1e
issued on the (rop of unplanted 1eans to 1e grown in Chile for 'apanese (onsumption? &hy should the .overnment of the
;nited <tates 1e (ompelled to issue many 1illions of dollars every year to pay the de1ts of one foreigner to another foreigner?
&as it for this that our nationalG1ank depositors had their money taken out of our 1anks and shipped a1road? &as it for this that
they had to lose it? &hy should the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment and likewise money 1elonging to our
nationalG1ank depositors 1e used to support foreign 1rewers! nar(oti( drug vendors! whiskey distillers! wigmakers! humanGhair
mer(hants! Chilean 1ean growers! and the like? &hy should our nationalG1ank depositors and our .overnment 1e for(ed to
finan(e the munition fa(tories of .ermany and <oviet Russia?
Mr% Chairman! if a .erman in .ermany! wishes to sell wheel1arrows to another .erman! he (an draw a 1ill in dollars and
get the money out of the Federal Reserve 1anks 1efore an +meri(an farmer (ould e3plain his re5uest for a loan to move his (rop
to market% 6n .ermany! when (redit instruments are 1eing given! the (reditors say! Y<ee you! it must 1e of a kind that 6 (an (ash
at the reserve%Y Jther foreigners feel the same way% The reserve to whi(h these gentry refer is our reserve! whi(h! as you know!
is entirely made up of money 1elonging to +meri(an 1ank depositors% 6 think foreigners should (ash their own trade paper and
not send it over here to 1ankers who use it to fish (ash out of the po(kets of the +meri(an people%
Mr% Chairman! there is nothing like the Federal Reserve pool of (onfis(ated 1ank deposits in the world% 6t is a pu1li( trough
of +meri(an wealth in whi(h foreigners (laim rights e5ual to or greater than those of +meri(ans% The Federal Reserve 1anks are
agents of the foreign (entral 1anks% They use our 1ank depositorsI money for the 1enefit of their foreign prin(ipals% They 1arter
the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment and hire it out to foreigners at a profit to themselves%
+ll this is done at the e3pense of the ;nited <tates .overnment! and at a si(kening loss to the +meri(an people% Jnly our
great wealth ena1led us to stand the drain of it as long as we did%
6 1elieve that the nations of the world would have settled down after the &orld &ar more pea(efully if we had not had this
standing temptation here GG this pool of our 1ank depositorsI money given to private interests and used 1y them in (onne(tion
with illimita1le drafts upon the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment% The Federal Reserve Board invited the world to
(ome in and to (arry away (ash! (redit! goods! and everything else of value that was mova1le% ,alues amounting to many
1illions of dollars have 1een taken out of this (ountry 1y the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks for the
1enefit of their foreign prin(ipals% The ;nited <tates has 1een ransa(ked and pillaged% Jur stru(tures have 1een gutted and only
the walls are left standing% &hile this (rime was 1eing perpetrated everything the world (ould rake up to sell us was 1rought in
here at our own e3pense 1y the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks until our markets were swamped with
unneeded and unwanted imported goods pri(ed far a1ove their value and made to e5ual the dollar volume of our honest e3ports
and to kill or redu(e our favora1le 1alan(e of trade% +s agents of the foreign (entral 1anks! the Federal Reserve Board and the
Federal Reserve 1anks try 1y every means within their power to redu(e our favora1le 1alan(e of trade% They a(t for their foreign
prin(ipals and they a((ept fees from foreigners for a(ting against the 1est interests of the ;nited <tates% Naturally there has 1een
great (ompetition among foreigners for the favors of the Federal Reserve Board%
&hat we need to do is to send the reserves of our national 1anks home to the people who earned and produ(ed them and
who still own them and to the 1anks whi(h were (ompelled to surrender them to predatory interests% &e need to destroy the
Federal Reserve pool! wherein our nationalG1ank reserves are impounded for the 1enefit of the foreigners% &e need to make it
very diffi(ult for outlanders to draw money away from us% &e need to save +meri(a for +meri(ans%
Mr% Chairman! when you hold a P# Federal Reserve note in your hand you are holding a pie(e of paper whi(h sooner or
later is going to (ost the ;nited <tates .overnment P# in gold! unless the .overnment is o1liged to give up the gold standard% 6t
is prote(ted 1y a reserve of $# per (ent% or P$ in gold% 6t is 1ased on Cim1urger (heese! reputed to 1e in foreign warehouses8 or
on (ans purported to (ontain peas 1ut whi(h may (ontain salt water instead8 or on horse meat8 illi(it drugs8 1ootleggersI fan(ies8
rags and 1ones from <oviet Russia of whi(h the ;nited <tates imported over a million dollarsI worth last year8 on wines!
whiskey! natural gas! on goat or dog fur! garli( on the string! or Bom1ay du(ks% 6f you like to have paper money whi(h is se(ured
1y su(h (ommodities! you have it in the Federal Reserve note% 6f you desire to o1tain the thing of value upon whi(h this paper
(urren(y is 1ased GG that is! the Cim1urger (heese! the whiskey! the illi(it drugs! or any of the other staples GG you will have a
very hard time finding them% Many of these worshipful (ommodities are in foreign (ountries% +re you going to .ermany to
inspe(t her warehouses to see if the spe(ified things of value are there? 6 think not% +nd what is more! 6 do not think you would
find them there if you did go%
6mmense sums 1elonging to our nationalG1ank depositors have 1een given to .ermany on no (ollateral se(urity whatever%
The Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks have issued ;nited <tates (urren(y on mere finan(e drafts drawn 1y
.ermans% Billions upon 1illions of our money has 1een pumped into .ermany and money is still 1eing pumped into .ermany 1y
the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% 7er worthless paper is still 1eing negotiated here and renewed here
on the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment and at the e3pense of the +meri(an people% Jn +pril "H! F>"! the Federal
Reserve outfit sent PHL#!###! 1elonging to +meri(an 1ank depositors! in gold to .ermany% + week later! another P>##!### in
gold was shipped to .ermany in the same way% +1out the middle of May P"!###!### in gold was shipped to .ermany 1y the
Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% +lmost every week there is a shipment of gold to .ermany% These
shipments are not made for profit on the e3(hange sin(e the .erman marks are 1elow parity with the dollar%
Mr% Chairman! 6 1elieve that the nationalG1ank depositors of the ;nited <tates are entitled to know what the Federal
Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks are doing with their money% There are millions of nationalG1ank depositors in this
(ountry who do not know that a per(entage of every dollar they deposit in a mem1er 1ank of the Federal Reserve system goes
automati(ally to +meri(an agents of the foreign 1anks and that all their deposits (an 1e paid away to foreigners without their
knowledge or (onsent 1y the (rooked ma(hinery of the Federal Reserve a(t and the 5uestiona1le pra(ti(es of the Federal Reserve
Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% Mr% Chairman! the +meri(an people should 1e told the truth 1y their servants in offi(e%
6n F># we had over half a 1illion dollars outstanding daily to finan(e foreign goods stored in or shipped 1etween
(ountries% 6n its yearly total! this item amounts to several 1illion dollars% &hat goods are those on whi(h the Federal Reserve
1anks yearly pledge several 1illions of dollars of the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates? &hat goods are those whi(h are hidden
in -uropean and +siati( storehouses and whi(h have never 1een seen 1y any offi(er of this .overnment! 1ut whi(h are 1eing
finan(ed on the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment? &hat goods are those upon whi(h the ;nited <tates .overnment
is 1eing o1ligated 1y the Federal Reserve 1anks to issue Federal Reserve notes to the e3tent of several 1illions of dollars a year?
The Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks have 1een international 1ankers from the 1eginning! with the
;nited <tates .overnment as their enfor(ed 1anker and supplier of (urren(y% But it is none the less e3traordinary to see those
twelve private (redit monopolies 1uying the de1ts of foreigners against foreigners in all parts of the world and asking the
.overnment of the ;nited <tates for new issues of Federal Reserve notes in e3(hange for them%
6 see no reason why the +meri(an ta3payers should 1e hewers of wood and drawers of water for the -uropean and +siati(
(ustomers of the Federal Reserve 1anks% 6 see no reason why a worthless a((eptan(e drawn 1y a foreign swindler as a means of
getting gold out of this (ountry should re(eive the lowest and (hoi(est rate from the Federal Reserve Board and 1e treated as
1etter se(urity than the note of an +meri(an farmer living on +meri(an land%
The magnitude of the a((eptan(e ra(ket! as it has 1een developed 1y the Federal Reserve 1anks! their foreign
(orrespondents! and the predatory -uropeanG1orn 1ankers who set up the Federal Reserve institution here and taught our own
1rand of pirates how to loot the people GG 6 say the magnitude of this ra(ket is estimated to 1e in the neigh1orhood of
PF!###!###!### a year% 6n the past ten years it is said to have amounted to PF#!###!###!###% 6n my opinion! it has amounted to
several times as mu(h% Coupled with this you have! to the e3tent of 1illions of dollars! the gam1ling in the ;nited <tates
se(urities! whi(h takes pla(e in the same open dis(ount market GG a gam1ling upon whi(h the Federal Reserve Board is now
spending P##!###!### per week%
Federal Reserve notes are taken from the ;nited <tates .overnment in unlimited 5uantities% 6s it strange that the 1urden of
supplying these immense sums of money to the gam1ling fraternity has at last proved too heavy for the +meri(an people to
endure? &ould it not 1e a national (alamity if the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks should again 1ind this
1urden down on the 1a(ks of the +meri(an people and! 1y means of the long rawhide whips of the (redit masters! (ompel them
to enter another seventeen years of slavery? They are trying to do that now% They are taking P##!###!### of the pu1li( (redit of
the ;nited <tates .overnment every week in addition to all their other seiAures! and they are spending that money in the
nefarious open market in New York City in a desperate gam1le to reesta1lish their graft as a going (on(ern%
They are putting the ;nited <tates .overnment in de1t to the e3tent of P##!###!### a week! and with the money they are
1uying up our .overnment se(urities for themselves and their foreign prin(ipals% Jur people are disgusted with the e3periments
of the Federal Reserve Board% The Federal Reserve Board is not produ(ing a loaf of 1read! a yard of (loth! a 1ushel of (orn! or a
pile of (ordwood 1y its (he(kGkiting operations in the money market%
+ fortnight or so ago great aid and (omfort was given to 'apan 1y the firm of +% .erli K <ons! of New York! an importing
firm! whi(h 1ought P?!###!### worth of raw silk from the 'apanese .overnment% Federal Reserve notes will 1e issued to pay
that amount to the 'apanese .overnment! and these notes will 1e se(ured 1y money 1elonging to our nationalG1ank depositors%
&hy should ;nited <tates (urren(y 1e issued on this de1t? &hy should ;nited <tates (urren(y 1e issued to pay the de1t of
.erli K <ons to the 'apanese .overnment? The Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks think more of the
silkworms of 'apan than they do of +meri(an (itiAens% &e do not need P?!###!### work of silk in this (ountry at the present
time! not even to furnish work to dyers and finishers% &e need to wear homeGgrown and +meri(anGmade (lothes and to use our
own money for our own goods and staples% &e (ould spend P?!###!### in the ;nited <tates of +meri(a on +meri(an (hildren
and that would 1e a 1etter investment for us than 'apanese silk pur(hased on the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment%
Mr% <peaker! on the >th of 'anuary of this year 6 addressed the 7ouse on the su14e(t of the Re(onstru(tion Finan(e
Corporation% 6n the (ourse of my remarks 6 made the following statement:
$n 19;< the member banks o# the )e&era" *eser%e system borrowe& =>?,@9<,>9?,??? #rom the
)e&era" *eser%e banks on their #i#teen5&ay !romissory notes( Think o# itA Si-ty bi""ion
&o""ars !ayab"e u!on &eman& in o"& in the course o# one sin"e year( The actua" !ayment o#
such ob"iations ca""s #or si- times as much monetary o"& as there is in the entire wor"&(
Such transactions re!resent a rant in the course o# one sin"e year o# about =7,???,??? to
e%ery member bank o# the )e&era" *eser%e system( $s it any won&er that there is a &e!ression
in this country8 $s it any won&er that 9merican "abor, which u"timate"y !ays the cost o# a""
bankin o!erations o# this country, has at "ast !ro%e& une7ua" to the task o# su!!"yin this
hue tota" o# cash an& cre&it #or the bene#it o# the stock5market mani!u"ators an& #orein
swin&"ers8
Mr% Chairman! some of my (olleagues have asked for more spe(ifi( information (on(erning this stupendous graft! this frightful
1urden whi(h has 1een pla(ed on the wage earners and ta3payers of the ;nited <tates for the 1enefit of the Federal Reserve
Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% They were surprised to learn that mem1er 1anks of the Federal Reserve system had
re(eived the enormous sum of P?#!LF=!?F#!### from the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks on their
promissory notes in the (ourse of one single year! namely! F"=% +nother Mem1er of this 7ouse! Mr% Beedy! the honora1le
gentleman from Maine! has 5uestioned the a((ura(y of my statement and has informed me that the Federal Reserve Board denies
a1solutely that these figures are (orre(t% This Mem1er has said to me that the thing is unthinka1le! that it (an not 1e! that it is
1eyond all reason to think that the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks should have so su1sidiAed and
endowed their favorite 1anks of the Federal Reserve system% This Mem1er is horrified at the thought of a graft so great! a 1ounty
so detrimental to the pu1li( welfare as si3ty and a half 1illion dollars a year and more shoveled out to favored 1anks of the
Federal Reserve system%
6n F>#! while the spe(ulating 1anks were getting out of the sto(k market at the e3pense of the general pu1li(! the Federal
Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks advan(ed them P>!#""!H="!###% This shows that when the 1anks were gam1ling
on the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment as represented 1y the Federal Reserve (urren(y! they were su1sidiAed to
any amount they re5uired 1y the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% &hen the swindle 1egan to fall! the
1ankers knew it in advan(e and withdrew from the market% They got out with whole skins and left the people of the ;nited
<tates to pay the piper%
Jn Novem1er "! F>! 6 addressed a letter to the Federal Reserve Board asking for the aggregate total of mem1er 1ank
1orrowing in the years F"=! F"F! F>#% 6n due (ourse! 6 re(eived a reply from the Federal Reserve Board! dated Novem1er F!
F>! the pertinent part of whi(h reads as follows:
My Dear Conressman:
$n re!"y to your "etter o# No%ember ;, you are a&%ise& that the areate amount o# #i#teen5
&ay !romissory notes o# member banks &urin each o# the !ast three ca"en&er years has been as
#o""ows:
19;< ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( =>?,@9<,>9?,???
19;9 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( @<,?B>,>97,???
193? ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 13,?;;,7<;,???
This will show the gentleman from Maine the a((ura(y of my statement% +s for the denial of these fa(ts made to him 1y the
Federal Reserve Board! 6 (an only say that it must have 1een prompted 1y fright! sin(e hanging is too good for a .overnment
1oard whi(h permitted su(h a misuse of .overnment funds and (redit%
My friend from Bansas! Mr% M(.ugin! has stated that he thought the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks
lent money 1y redis(ounting% <o they do! 1ut they lend (omparatively little that way% The real redis(ounting that they do has
1een (alled a mere penny in the slot 1usiness% 6t is too slow for genuine high flyers% They dis(ourage it% They prefer to su1sidiAe
their favorite 1anks 1y making these P?#!###!###!### advan(es! and they prefer to a(5uire a((eptan(es in the notorious open
dis(ount market in New York! where they (an use them to (ontrol the pri(es of sto(ks and 1onds on the e3(hanges% For every
dollar they advan(ed on redis(ounts in F"= they lent P>> to their favorite 1anks for gam1ling purposes% 6n other words! their
redis(ounts in F"= amounted to P!=$!"H!###! while their loans to mem1er 1anks amounted to P?#!LF=!?F#!###% +s for their
openGmarket operations! these are on a stupendous s(ale! and no ta3 is paid on the a((eptan(es they handle8 and their foreign
prin(ipals! for whom they do a 1usiness of several 1illion dollars every year! pay no in(ome ta3 on their profits to the ;nited
<tates .overnment%
This is the 'ohn Caw swindle all over again% The theft of Teapot )ome was trifling (ompared to it% &hat king ever ro11ed
his su14e(ts to su(h an e3tent as the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks have ro11ed us? 6s it any wonder that
there have lately 1een ninety (ases of starvation in one of the New York hospitals? 6s there any wonder that the (hildren of this
(ountry are 1eing dispersed and a1andoned?
The .overnment and the people of the ;nited <tates have 1een swindled 1y swindlers delu3e to whom the a(5uisition of
+meri(an gold or a par(el of Federal Reserve notes presented no more diffi(ulty than the drawing up of a worthless a((eptan(e
in a (ountry not su14e(t to the laws of the ;nited <tates! 1y sharpers not su14e(t to the 4urisdi(tion of the ;nited <tates (ourts!
sharpers with a strong 1anking Yfen(eY on this side of the water GG a Yfen(eY a(ting as a re(eiver of the worthless paper (oming
from a1road! endorsing it and getting the (urren(y out of the Federal Reserve 1anks for it as 5ui(kly as possi1le! e3(hanging that
(urren(y for gold! and in turn transmitting the gold to its foreign (onfederates%
<u(h were the e3ploits of 6var Breuger! Mr% 7ooverIs friend! and his hidden &all <treet 1a(kers% -very dollar of the
1illions Breuger and his gang drew out of this (ountry on a((eptan(es was drawn from the .overnment and the people of the
;nited <tates through the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% The (redit of the ;nited <tates .overnment
was peddled to him 1y the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks for their own private gain% That is what the
Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks have 1een doing for many years% They have 1een peddling the (redit of
this .overnment and the signature of this .overnment to the swindlers and spe(ulators of all nations% That is what happens when
a (ountry forsakes its &onstitution and gives its sovereignty over the pu1li( (urren(y to private interests% .ive them the flag and
they will sell it%
The nature of BreugerIs organiAed swindle and the 1ankrupt (ondition of BreugerIs (om1ine was known here last 'une
when 7oover sought to e3empt BreugerIs loan to .ermany of P"L!###!### from the operation of the 7oover moratorium% The
1ankrupt (ondition of BreugerIs swindle was known here last summer when P>#!###!### was taken from the +meri(an
ta3payers 1y (ertain 1ankers in New York for the ostensi1le purpose of permitting Breuger to make a loan to Colom1ia%
Colom1ia never saw that money% The nature of BreugerIs swindle and the 1ankrupt (ondition of Breuger was known here in
'anuary when he visited his friend! Mr% 7oover! at the &hite 7ouse% 6t was known here in Mar(h 1efore he went to *aris and
(ommitted sui(ide there%
Mr% Chairman! 6 think the people of the ;nited <tates are entitled to know how many 1illions of dollars were pla(ed at the
disposal of Breuger and his giganti( (om1ine 1y the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks and to know how
mu(h of our .overnment (urren(y was issued and lost in the finan(ing of that great swindle in the years during whi(h the
Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks took (are of BreugerIs re5uirements%
Mr% Chairman! 6 1elieve there should 1e a (ongressional investigation of the operations of Breuger and Toll in the ;nited
<tates and that <wedish Mat(h! 6nternational Mat(h! the <wedishG+meri(an 6nvestment Corporation! and all related enterprises!
in(luding the su1sidiary (ompanies of Breuger and Toll! should 1e investigated and that the issuan(e of ;nited <tates (urren(y
in (onne(tion with those enterprises and the use of our nationalG1ank depositorsI money for BreugerIs 1enefit should 1e made
known to the general pu1li(% 6 am referring! not only to the se(urities whi(h were floated and sold in this (ountry! 1ut also to the
(ommer(ial loans to BreugerIs enterprises and the mass finan(ing of BreugerIs (ompanies 1y the Federal Reserve Board and the
Federal Reserve 1anks and the predatory institutions whi(h the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks shield and
har1or%
+ few days ago! the *resident of the ;nited <tates! with a white fa(e and shaking hands! went 1efore the <enate on 1ehalf
of the moneyed interests and asked the <enate to levy a ta3 on the people so that foreigners might know that the ;nited <tates
would pay its de1t to them% Most +meri(ans thought it was the other way around% &hat do the ;nited <tates owe to foreigners?
&hen and 1y whom was the de1t in(urred? 6t was in(urred 1y the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks when
they peddled the signature of this .overnment to foreigners for a pri(e% 6t is what the ;nited <tates .overnment has to pay to
redeem the o1ligations of the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% +re you going to let those thieves get off
s(ot free? 6s there one law for the looter who drives up to the door of the ;nited <tates Treasury in his limousine and another for
the ;nited <tates veterans who are sleeping on the floor of a dilapidated house on the outskirts of &ashington?
The Baltimore K Jhio Railroad is here asking for a large loan from the people and the wage earners and the ta3payers of
the ;nited <tates% 6t is 1egging for a handGout from the .overnment% 6t is standing! (ap in hand! at the door of the Re(onstru(tion
Finan(e Corporation! where all the other 4a(kals have gathered to the feast% 6t is asking for money that was raised from the
people 1y ta3ation! and wants this money of the poor for the 1enefit of Buhn! Coe1! K Co%! the .erman international 1ankers% 6s
there one law for the Baltimore K Jhio Railroad and another for the needy veterans it threw off its freight (ars the other day? 6s
there one law for sleek and prosperous swindlers who (all themselves 1ankers and another law for the soldiers who defended the
;nited <tates flag?
Mr% Chairman! some people are horrified 1e(ause the (ollateral 1ehind Breuger and Toll de1entures was removed and
worthless (ollateral su1stituted for it% &hat is this 1ut what is 1eing done daily 1y the Federal Reserve 1anks? &hen the Federal
Reserve a(t was passed! the Federal Reserve 1anks were allowed to su1stitute Yother like (ollateralY for (ollateral 1ehind Federal
Reserve notes 1ut 1y an amendment o1tained at the re5uest of the (orrupt and dishonest Federal Reserve Board! the a(t was
(hanged so that the word YlikeY was stri(ken out% +ll that immense trou1le was taken here in Congress so that the law would
permit the Federal Reserve 1anks to swit(h (ollateral% +t the present time 1ehind the s(enes in the Federal Reserve 1anks there is
a nightGandGday movement of (ollateral% + visiting -nglishman! leaving the ;nited <tates a few weeks ago! said that things
would look 1etter here after Ythey (leaned up the mess at &ashington%Y Cleaning up the mess (onsists in fooling the people and
making them pay a se(ond time for the 1ad foreign investments of the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% 6t
(onsists in moving that heavy load of du1ious and worthless foreign paper GG the 1ills of wigmakers! 1rewers! distillers! nar(oti(G
drug vendors! munition makers! illegal finan(e drafts! and worthless foreign se(urities! out of the 1anks and putting it on the
1a(k of +meri(an la1or% That is what the Re(onstru(tion Finan(e Corporation is doing now% They talk a1out loans to 1anks and
railroads 1ut they say very little a1out that other 1usiness of theirs whi(h (onsists in relieving the swindlers who promoted
investment trusts in this (ountry and dumped worthless foreign se(urities into them and then resold that mess of pottage to
+meri(an investors under (over of their own (orporate titles% The Re(onstru(tion Finan(e Corporation is taking over those
worthless se(urities from those investment trusts with ;nited <tates Treasury money at the e3pense of the +meri(an ta3payer
and the wage earner%
6t will take us twenty years to redeem our .overnment% Twenty years of penal servitude to pay off the gam1ling de1ts of
the traitorous Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks and to earn again that vast flood of +meri(an wages and
savings! 1ank deposits! and ;nited <tates .overnment (redit whi(h the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks
e3ported out of this (ountry to their foreign prin(ipals%
The Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks lately (ondu(ted an antiGhoarding (ampaign here% Then they
took that e3tra money whi(h they had persuaded the +meri(an people to put into the 1anks and they sent it to -urope along with
the rest% 6n the last several months! they have sent P!>##!###!### in gold to their foreign employers! their foreign masters! and
every dollar of that gold 1elonged to the people of the ;nited <tates and was unlawfully taken from them%
6s not it high time that we had an audit of the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks and an e3amination of
all our .overnment 1onds and se(urities and pu1li( moneys instead of allowing the (orrupt and dishonest Federal Reserve Board
and the Federal Reserve 1anks to spe(ulate with those se(urities and this (ash in the notorious open dis(ount market of New
York City?
Mr% Chairman! within the limits of the time allowed me! 6 (an not enter into a parti(ulariAed dis(ussion of the Federal
Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% 6 have singled out the Federal Reserve (urren(y for a few remarks 1e(ause there
has lately 1een some talk here of Yfiat money%Y &hat kind of money is 1eing pumped into the open dis(ount market and through
it into foreign (hannels and sto(k e3(hanges? Mr% Mills of the Treasury has spoken here of his horror of the printing presses and
his horror of dishonest money% 7e has no horror of dishonest money% 6f he had! he would 1e no party to the present gam1ling of
the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks in the nefarious open dis(ount market of New York! a market in whi(h
the sellers are represented 1y ten great dis(ount dealer (orporations owned and organiAed 1y the very 1anks whi(h own and
(ontrol the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% Fiat money! indeed[
+fter the several raids on the Treasury Mr% Mills 1orrows the spee(h of those who protested against those raids and speaks
now with pretended horror of a raid on the Treasury% &here was Mr% Mills last J(to1er when the ;nited <tates Treasury needed
PLF=!###!### of the ta3payersI money whi(h was supposed to 1e in the safeGkeeping of +ndrew &% Mellon in the designated
depositories of Treasury funds! and whi(h was not in those depositories when the Treasury needed it? Mr% Mills was the
+ssistant <e(retary of the Treasury then! and he was at &ashington throughout J(to1er! with the e3(eption of a very signifi(ant
week he spent at &hite <ulphur <prings (loseted with international 1ankers! while the 6talian minister! <ignor .randi! was 1eing
entertained GG and 1argained with GG at &ashington%
&hat Mr% Mills is fighting for is the preservation whole and entire of the 1ankerIs monopoly of all the (urren(y of the
;nited <tates .overnment% &hat Mr% *atman proposes is that the .overnment shall e3er(ise its sovereignty to the e3tent of
issuing some (urren(y for itself% This (onfli(t of opinion 1etween Mr% Mills as the spokesman of the 1ankers and Mr% *atman as
the spokesman of the people 1rings the (urren(y situation here into the open% Mr% *atman and the veterans are (onfronted 1y a
stone wall GG the wall that fen(es in the 1ankers with their spe(ial privileges% Thus! the issue is 4oined 1etween the host of
demo(ra(y! of whi(h the veterans are a part! and the men of the kingIs 1ank! the wouldG1e aristo(rats! who deflated +meri(an
agri(ulture and ro11ed this (ountry for the 1enefit of their foreign prin(ipals%
Mr% Chairman! last )e(em1er! 6 introdu(ed a resolution here asking for an e3amination and an audit of the Federal Reserve
Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks and all related matters% 6f the 7ouse sees fit to make su(h an investigation! the people of
the ;nited <tates will o1tain information of great value% This is a Government of the people, by the people, for the people.
(onse*uently, nothing should be concealed from the people. The man who deceives the people is a traitor to the &nited
%tates. The man who knows or suspects that a crime has been committed and who conceals or covers up that crime is an
accessory to it. r. %peaker, it is a monstrous thing for this great Bation of people to have its destinies presided over by a
traitorous Government board acting in secret concert with international usurers. 3very effort has been made by the
#ederal $eserve )oard to conceal its power but the truth is the #ederal $eserve )oard has usurped the Government of
the &nited %tates. It controls everything here and it controls all our foreign relations. It makes and breaks governments
at will. Bo man and no body of men is more entrenched in power than the arrogant credit monopoly which operates the
#ederal $eserve )oard and the #ederal $eserve banks. These evil@doers have robbed this country of more than enough
money to pay the national debt. "hat the Bational Government has permitted the #ederal $eserve )oard to steal from
the people should now be restored to the people. The people have a valid claim against the #ederal $eserve )oard and
the #ederal $eserve banks. If that claim is enforced, !mericans will not need to stand in the breadlines or to suffer and
die of starvation in the streets. :omes will be saved, families will be kept together, and !merican children will not be
dispersed and abandoned. The #ederal $eserve )oard and the #ederal $eserve banks owe the &nited %tates Government
an immense sum of money. "e ought to find out the exact amount of the peopleHs claim. "e should know the amount of
the indebtedness of the #ederal $eserve )oard and the #ederal $eserve banks to the people and we should investigate
this treacherous and disloyal conduct of the #ederal $eserve )oard and the #ederal $eserve banks.
7ere is a Federal Reserve note% 6mmense num1ers of these notes are now held a1road% 6 am told that they amount to
upwards of a 1illion dollars% They (onstitute a (laim against our .overnment and likewise a (laim against the money our people
have deposited in the mem1er 1anks of the Federal Reserve system% Jur peopleIs money to the e3tent of P!>##!###!### whi(h
has within the last few months 1een shipped a1road to redeem Federal Reserve notes and to pay other gam1ling de1ts of the
traitorous Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks% The greater part of our monetary sto(k has 1een shipped to
foreigners% &hy should we promise to pay the de1ts of foreigners to foreigners? &hy should our .overnment 1e put into the
position of supplying money to foreigners? &hy should the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks 1e permitted
to finan(e our (ompetitors in all parts of the world? )o you know why the tariff was raised? 6t was raised to shut out the flood of
Federal Reserve goods pouring in here from every 5uarter of the glo1e GG (heap goods! produ(ed 1y (heaply paid foreign la1or
on unlimited supplies of money and (redit sent out of this (ountry 1y the dishonest and uns(rupulous Federal Reserve Board and
the Federal Reserve 1anks% .o out in &ashington to 1uy an ele(tri( light 1ul1 and you will pro1a1ly 1e offered one that was
made in 'apan on +meri(an money% .o out to 1uy a pair of fa1ri( gloves and in(onspi(uously written on the inside of the gloves
that will 1e offered to you will 1e found the words Ymade in .ermanyY and that means Ymade on the pu1li( (redit of the ;nited
<tates .overnment paid to .erman firms in +meri(an gold taken from the (onfis(ated 1ank deposits of the +meri(an people%Y
The Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks are spending P##!###!### a week 1uying .overnment
se(urities in the open market and are making a great 1id for foreign 1usiness% They are trying to make rates so attra(tive that the
humanGhair mer(hants and distillers and other 1usiness entities in foreign lands will (ome here and hire more of the pu1li( (redit
of the ;nited <tates .overnment and pay the Federal Reserve outfit for getting it for them%
Mr% Chairman! when the Federal Reserve a(t was passed! the people of the ;nited <tates did not per(eive that a world
system was 1eing set up here whi(h would make the savings of an +meri(an s(hoolGtea(her availa1le to a nar(oti(Gdrug vendor
in Ma(ao% They did not per(eive that the ;nited <tates were to 1e lowered to the position of a (oolie (ountry whi(h has nothing
1ut raw materials and heavy goods for e3port8 that Russia was destined to supply the man power and that this (ountry was to
supply finan(ial power to an international superstate GG a superstate (ontrolled 1y international 1ankers and international
industrialists a(ting together to enslave the world for their own pleasure%
The people of the ;nited <tates are 1eing greatly wronged% 6f they are not! then 6 do not know what Ywronging the peopleY
means% They have 1een driven from their employments% They have 1een dispossessed of their homes% They have 1een evi(ted
from their rented 5uarters% They have lost their (hildren% They have 1een left to suffer and to die for la(k of shelter! food!
(lothing! and medi(ine%
The wealth of the ;nited <tates and the working (apital of the ;nited <tates has 1een taken away from them and has either
1een lo(ked in the vaults of (ertain 1anks and the great (orporations or e3ported to foreign (ountries for the 1enefit of the
foreign (ustomers of those 1anks and (orporations% <o far as the people of the ;nited <tates are (on(erned! the (up1oard is 1are%
6t is true that the warehouses and (oal yards and grain elevators are full! 1ut the warehouses and (oal yards and grain elevators
are padlo(ked and the great 1anks and (orporations hold the keys% The sa(k of the ;nited <tates 1y the Federal Reserve Board
and the Federal Reserve 1anks is the greatest (rime in history%
Mr% Chairman! a serious situation (onfronts the 7ouse of Representatives toGday% &e are trustees of the people and the
rights of the people are 1eing taken away from them% Through the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve 1anks! the
people are losing the rights guaranteed to them 1y the &onstitution% Their property has 1een taken from them without due
pro(ess of law% Mr% Chairman! (ommon de(en(y re5uires us to e3amine the pu1li( a((ounts of the .overnment and see what
(rimes against the pu1li( welfare have and are 1eing (ommitted%
&hat is needed here is a return to the &onstitution of the ;nited <tates% &e need to have a (omplete divor(e of Bank and
<tate% The old struggle that was fought out here in 'a(ksonIs day must 1e fought over again% The independent ;nited <tates
Treasury should 1e reGesta1lished and the .overnment should keep its own money under lo(k and key in the 1uilding the people
provided for that purpose% +sset (urren(y! the devi(e of the swindler! should 1e done away with% The .overnment should 1uy
gold and issue ;nited <tates (urren(y on it% The 1usiness of the independent 1ankers should 1e restored to them% The <tate
1anking systems should 1e freed from (oer(ion The Federal Reserve distri(ts should 1e a1olished and the <tate 1oundaries
should 1e respe(ted% Bank reserves should 1e kept within the 1orders of the <tates whose people own them! and this reserve
money of the people should 1e prote(ted so that the international 1ankers and a((eptan(e 1ankers and dis(ount dealers (an not
draw it away from them% The e3(hanges should 1e (losed while we are putting our finan(ial affairs in order% The Federal
Reserve a(t should 1e repealed and the Federal Reserve 1anks! having violated their (harters! should 1e li5uidated immediately%
Faithless .overnment offi(ers who have violated their oaths of offi(e should 1e impea(hed and 1rought to trial% ;nless this is
done 1y us! 6 predi(t that the +meri(an people! outraged! ro11ed! pillaged! insulted! and 1etrayed as they are in their own land!
will rise in their wrath and send a *resident here who will sweep the money (hangers out of the temple%
<our(e: http:@@www%afn%org@\govern@m(faddenZspee(hZF>"%html
;%<% Congressman Couis T% M(Fadden /Ci1rary of Congress0
FJR-&JR) to *oney &reators
1y former <enator Ro1ert C% Jwen
To the +meri(an *eople:
6t gives me spe(ial pleasure to have the opportunity to e3plain the prin(iples and purposes of this 1ook! written 1y Miss .ertrude
M% Coogan of Chi(ago%
The fa(ts that Miss Coogan was awarded a MasterIs )egree in -(onomi(s and Finan(e 1y Northwestern ;niversity8 was for
eight years a <e(urity +nalyst for The Northern Trust Company of Chi(ago8 that from the 1eginning she had a deep desire to
understand the fan(ied enigma of money! have given her great insight into monetary s(ien(e%
The 1asi( prin(iples of monetary s(ien(e are simple% ] Bnowledge of the s(ien(e has 1een made diffi(ult 1y those who have
(onverted these simple prin(iples into an enigma% They have done so with ponderous volumes written on pri(es and on the
pro(esses of produ(tion! transportation! distri1ution and allied topi(s8 weaving into the su14e(t matter de(eptive terms so that the
pu1li( has 1een grossly misled 1y the use of words whi(h (ontain a((epted false premises% %%%
The purpose of this 1ook is to 1ring 1efore the +meri(an people the knowledge that they must have regarding the nature and
manipulations of their money system% 6n my opinion! +meri(a fa(es a (risis whi(h may result in the loss of our Representative
Constitutional .overnment unless every man and woman! ri(h or poor! young or old8 do(tor! lawyer! mer(hant la1orer! edu(ator!
(lergyman! so(ial worker! so(iety leader8 will 1estir himself or herself toward the pro1lem of 1ringing the fundamental truths of
monetary s(ien(e to every fireside%
6t is time for intelligent +meri(ans to e3amine their money system %%%% Those who own insuran(e poli(ies and savings a((ounts
must 1estir themselves to prote(t those a((umulations% %%%
%%% The truths themselves are very simple! 1ut many of the newspapers and pu1lishing (ompanies allow themselves to 1e used to
(arry misinformation to the +meri(an pu1li(! while negle(ting to print the truths% 7onest money prin(iples are understanda1le to
every one when the money su14e(t is presented in its true light%
6t re5uired the assistan(e of every loyal +meri(an to help win the &orld &ar% 6n my opinion! the +meri(an people have more at
stake today than they had at the time of the &orld &ar% 6 1elieve the future of our nation and the prin(iples for whi(h it has
stood! were less in 4eopardy then than they are today% %%%
The solution of the pro1lem to prote(t our homes does not rest with a few leaders in a distant (ity% 6t is ne(essary that every man
and woman appoint himself and herself a leader% 7onest Money .roups must 1e formed in every 1lo(k! in every pre(in(t
throughout the ;nited <tates! and in every rural (ommunity% The rural (ommunity (enters and s(hoolhouses (an 1e most
profita1ly employed this winter in showing the +meri(an farmers how simply they (an solve all of their own pro1lems% Their
grave trou1les have 1een (aused not 1y overprodu(tion! 1ut 1y money manipulations fre5uently e3e(uted upon foreign advi(e
and to harmoniAe with foreign Ypoli(ies%Y The result has 1een the e3tra(tion of dollars of a distorted pur(hasing power from the
+meri(an farmer% Colle(ting dollars of su(h unfair pur(hasing power has deprived many +meri(an farmers of their homes! and
all farmers of their share in the industrial produ(ts whi(h this nation is so well e5uipped to manufa(ture and distri1ute%
The prin(ipal reason for endorsing this 1ook is that 6 feel it is an intelligent vehi(le for the dissemination of the truths whi(h
must 1e understood in every home %%%%
%%% 6 am glad to (ommend it8 to give the 1ook my 1lessings in its prin(iples and purposes %%% 6t (ontains s(ientifi( truths GG not
5ua(kery% %%%
This writer is informed% The information is sound% %%% it is written in an attra(tive way with an engaging style! and it (onveys to
the +meri(an people truths of the very first magnitude%
&hen these truths are known! and the +meri(an people demand their (onstitutional right of an honest money system! this
(ountry will enter upon an era of material and physi(al prosperity8 of opportunity! and spiritual and (ultural advan(ement that
will not only (harm and delight its own people 1ut will 1e(ome a model for the rest of the human ra(e%
Ro1ert C% Jwen! New York City! J(to1er "F! F>$%
<our(e: http:@@www%sonnet%(om@usr@kidogo@(oogan%html
2The 2monetary reform9 plan prepared at 'ekyll 6sland was to 1e presented to Congress as the (ompleted work of the National
Monetary Commission% 6t was imperative that the real authors of the 1ill remain hidden% <o great was popular resentment against
1ankers sin(e the *ani( of F#H that no Congressman would dare to vote for a 1ill 1earing the &all <treet taint! no matter who
had (ontri1uted to his (ampaign e3penses% The 'ekyll 6sland plan was a (entral 1ank plan! and in this (ountry there was a long
tradition of struggle against infli(ting a (entral 1ank on the +meri(an people% 6t had 1egun with Thomas 'effersonEs fight against
+le3ander 7amiltonEs s(heme for the First Bank of the ;nited <tates! 1a(ked 1y 'ames Roths(hild% 6t had (ontinued with
*resident +ndrew 'a(ksonEs su((essful war against +le3ander 7amiltonEs s(heme for the <e(ond Bank of the ;nited <tates! in
whi(h Ni(holas Biddle was a(ting as the agent for 'ames Roths(hild of *aris% The result of that struggle was the (reation of the
6ndependent <u1GTreasury <ystem! whi(h supposedly had served to keep the funds of the ;nited <tates out of the hands of the
finan(iers% + study of the pani(s of =H>! =F>! and F#H indi(ates that these pani(s were the result of the international 1ankersE
operations in Condon% The pu1li( was demanding in F#= that Congress ena(t legislation to prevent the re(urren(e of artifi(ially
indu(ed money pani(s% <u(h monetary reform now seemed inevita1le% 6t was to head off and (ontrol su(h reform that the
National Monetary Commission had 1een set up with Nelson +ldri(h at its head! sin(e he was ma4ority leader of the <enate%
The main pro1lem! as *aul &ar1urg informed his (olleagues! was to avoid the name 2Central Bank9% For that reason! he had
de(ided upon the designation of 2Federal Reserve <ystem9% This would de(eive the people into thinking it was not a (entral
1ank% 7owever! the 'ekyll 6sland plan would 1e a (entral 1ank plan! fulfilling the main fun(tions of a (entral 1ank8 it would 1e
owned 1y private individuals who would profit from ownership of shares% +s a 1ank of issue! it would (ontrol the nationEs
money and (redit%9 : Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter
2The *residential (ampaign of F" re(ords one of the more interesting politi(al upsets in +meri(an history% The in(um1ent!
&illiam 7oward Taft! was a popular president! and the Repu1li(ans! in a period of general prosperity! were firmly in (ontrol of
the government through a Repu1li(an ma4ority in 1oth houses% The )emo(rati( (hallenger! &oodrow &ilson! .overnor of New
'ersey! had no national re(ognition! and was a stiff! austere man who e3(ited little pu1li( support% Both parties in(luded a
monetary reform 1ill in their platforms: The Repu1li(ans were (ommitted to the +ldri(h *lan! whi(h had 1een denoun(ed as a
&all <treet plan! and the )emo(rats had the Federal Reserve +(t% Neither party 1othered to inform the pu1li( that the 1ills were
almost identi(al e3(ept for the names% 6n retrospe(t! it seems o1vious that the money (reators de(ided to dump Taft and go with
&ilson% 7ow do we know this? Taft seemed (ertain of reele(tion! and &ilson would return to o1s(urity% <uddenly! Theodore
Roosevelt 2threw his hat into the ring%9 7e announ(ed that he was running as a third party (andidate! the 2Bull Moose9% 7is
(andida(y would have 1een ludi(rous had it not 1een for the fa(t that he was e3(eptionally wellGfinan(ed% Moreover! he was
given unlimited press (overage! more than Taft and &ilson (om1ined% +s a Repu1li(an e3Gpresident! it was o1vious that
Roosevelt would (ut deeply into TaftEs vote% This proved the (ase! and &ilson won the ele(tion% To this day! no one (an say
what Theodore RooseveltEs program was! or why he would sa1otage his own party% <in(e the 1ankers were finan(ing all three
(andidates! they would win regardless of the out(ome% Cater Congressional testimony showed that in the firm of Buhn Coe1
Company! Feli3 &ar1urg was supporting Taft! *aul &ar1urg and 'a(o1 <(hiff were supporting &ilson! and Jtto Bahn was
supporting Roosevelt% The result was that a )emo(rati( Congress and a )emo(rati( *resident were ele(ted in F" to get the
(entral 1ank legislation passed% 6t seems pro1a1le that the identifi(ation of the +ldri(h *lan as a &all <treet operation predi(ted
that it would have a diffi(ult passage through Congress! as the )emo(rats would solidly oppose it! whereas a su((essful
)emo(rati( (andidate! supported 1y a )emo(rati( Congress! would 1e a1le to pass the (entral 1ank plan% Taft was thrown
over1oard 1e(ause the 1ankers dou1ted he (ould deliver on the +ldri(h *lan! and Roosevelt was the instrument of his demise%
The final ele(toral vote in F" was &ilson G $#F8 Roosevelt G ?H8 and Taft G L%9
: Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter >
2Col% T-lisha -lyU .arrison! an agent of Brown Brothers 1ankers! later Brown Brothers 7arriman! had entree everywhere in the
finan(ial (ommunity% 7e writes of Col% 7ouse! 2Col% 7ouse agreed entirely with the early writing of Mr% &ar1urg%9 T-lisha -ly
.arrison! Roosevelt! &ilson and the Federal Reserve Caw! Christopher *u1li(ations! Boston! F> *age >>H!U he 5uotes Col%
7ouse: 26 am also suggesting that the Central Board 1e in(reased from four mem1ers to five and their terms lengthened from
eight to ten years% This would give sta1ility and would take away the power of a *resident to (hange the personnel of the 1oard
during a single term of offi(e%9 7ouseEs phrase! 2take away the power of a *resident9 is signifi(ant! 1e(ause later *residents
found themselves helpless to (hange the dire(tion of the government 1e(ause they did not have the power to (hange the
(omposition of the Federal Reserve Board to attain a ma4ority on it during that *residentEs term of offi(e% .arrison also wrote in
this 1ook! 2*aul &ar1urg is the man who got the Federal Reserve +(t together after the +ldri(h *lan aroused su(h nationwide
resentment and opposition% The mastermind of 1oth plans was Baron +lfred Roths(hild of Condon%99
: Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter >
Colonel -dward Mandell 7ouse was referred to 1y Ra11i <tephen &ise in his auto1iography! Challenging Years as 2the
unoffi(ial <e(retary of <tate9% 7ouse noted that he and &ilson knew that in passing the Federal Reserve +(t! they had (reated an
instrument more powerful than the <upreme Court% The Federal Reserve Board of .overnors a(tually (omprised a <upreme
Court of Finan(e! and there was no appeal from any of their rulings% 6n F! prior to &ilsonEs taking offi(e as *resident! 7ouse
had returned to his home in Te3as and (ompleted a 1ook (alled +hilip $ru# Administrator% Jstensi1ly a novel! it was a(tually a
detailed plan for the future government of the ;nited <tates! 2whi(h would esta1lish <o(ialism as dreamed 1y Barl Mar39!
a((ording to 7ouse% This 2novel9 predi(ted the ena(tment of the graduated in(ome ta3! e3(ess profits ta3! unemployment
insuran(e! so(ial se(urity! and a fle3i1le (urren(y system% 6n short! it was the 1lueprint whi(h was later followed 1y the
&oodrow &ilson and Franklin )% Roosevelt administrations% 6t was pu1lished 2anonymously9 1y B% &% 7ue1s(h of New York!
and widely (ir(ulated among government offi(ials! who were left in no dou1t as to its authorship% .eorge <ylvester ,iere(k!
who knew 7ouse for years! later wrote an a((ount of the &ilsonG7ouse relationship! The <trangest Friendship in 7istory%$ 6n
FLL! &est1rook *egler! the 7earst (olumnist from F>" to FL?! heard of the *hilip )ru 1ook and (alled ,iere(k to ask if he
had a (opy% ,iere(k sent *egler his (opy of the 1ook! and *egler wrote a (olumn a1out it! stating: 2Jne of the institutions
outlined in *hilip )ru is the Federal Reserve <ystem% The <(hiffs! the &ar1urgs! the Bahns! the Ro(kefellers and Morgans put
their faith in 7ouse% The <(hiff! &ar1urg! Ro(kefeller and Morgan interests were personally represented in the mysterious
(onferen(e at 'ekyll 6sland%9
: Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter >
The .lass Bill /the 7ouse version of the final Federal Reserve +(t0 had passed the 7ouse on <eptem1er =! F> 1y "=H to =L%
Jn )e(em1er F! F>! the <enate passed their version 1y a vote of L$G>$% More than forty important differen(es in the 7ouse
and <enate versions remained to 1e settled! and the opponents of the 1ill in 1oth houses of Congress were led to 1elieve that
many weeks would yet elapse 1efore the Conferen(e 1ill would 1e ready for (onsideration% The Congressmen prepared to leave
&ashington for the annual Christmas re(ess! assured that the Conferen(e 1ill would not 1e 1rought up until the following year%
Now the money (reators prepared and e3e(uted the most 1rilliant stroke of their plan% 6n a single day! they ironed out all forty of
the disputed passages in the 1ill and 5ui(kly 1rought it to a vote% Jn Monday! )e(em1er ""! F>! the 1ill was passed 1y the
7ouse "="G?# and the <enate $>G">% Jn )e(em1er "! F>! The New York Times (ommented editorially on the a(t! 2New
York will 1e on a firmer 1asis of finan(ial growth! and we shall soon see her the money (entre of the world%9
: Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter >
These developments following the passing of the Federal Reserve +(t proved every one of the allegations Thomas 'efferson had
made against a (entral 1ank in HF: that the su1s(ri1ers to the Federal Reserve Bank sto(k had formed a (orporation! whose
sto(k (ould 1e and was held 1y aliens8 that this sto(k would 1e transmitted to a (ertain line of su((essors8 that it would 1e pla(ed
1eyond forfeiture and es(heat8 that they would re(eive a monopoly of 1anking! whi(h was against the laws of monopoly8 and
that they now had the power to make laws! paramount to the laws of the states% No state legislature (an (ountermand any of the
laws laid down 1y the Federal Reserve Board of .overnors for the 1enefit of their private sto(kholders% This 1oard issues laws
as to what the interest rate shall 1e! what the 5uantity of money shall 1e and what the pri(e of money shall 1e% +ll of these
powers a1rogate the powers of the state legislatures and their responsi1ility to the (itiAens of those states%
: Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter >
The true purposes of the Federal Reserve +(t soon 1egan to disillusion many who had at first 1elieved in its (laims% &% 7% +llen
wrote in MoodyEs MagaAine! F?! 2The purpose of the Federal Reserve +(t was to prevent (on(entration of money in the New
York 1anks 1y making it profita1le for (ountry 1ankers to use their funds at home! 1ut the movement of (urren(y shows that the
New York 1anks gained from the interior in every month e3(ept )e(em1er! FL! sin(e the +(t went into effe(t% The
sta1iliAation of rates has taken pla(e in New York alone% 6n other parts! high rates (ontinue% The +(t! whi(h was to deprive &all
<treet of its funds for spe(ulation! has really given the 1ulls and the 1ears su(h a supply as they have never had 1efore% The truth
is that far from having (logged the (hannel to &all <treet! as Mr% .lass so (onfidently 1oasted! it a(tually widened the old
(hannels and opened up two new ones% The first of these leads dire(tly to &ashington and gives &all <treet a string on all the
surplus (ash in the ;nited <tates Treasury% Besides! in the power to issue 1ankGnote (urren(y! it furnishes an ine3hausti1le
supply of (redit money8 the se(ond (hannel leads to the great (entral 1anks of -urope! where1y! through the sale of a((eptan(es!
virtually guaranteed 1y the ;nited <tates .overnment! &all <treet is granted immunity from foreign demands for gold whi(h
have pre(ipitated every great (risis in our history%9
: Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter >
2For many years! there has 1een (onsidera1le mystery a1out who a(tually owns the sto(k of the Federal Reserve Banks%
Congressman &right *atman! leading (riti( of the <ystem! tried to find out who the sto(kholders were% The sto(k in the original
twelve regional Federal Reserve Banks was pur(hased 1y national 1anks in those twelve regions% Be(ause the Federal Reserve
Bank of New York was to set the interest rates and dire(t open market operations! thus (ontrolling the daily supply and pri(e of
money throughout the ;nited <tates! it is the sto(kholders of that 1ank who are the real dire(tors of the entire system% For the
first time! it (an 1e revealed who those sto(kholders are% This writer has the original organiAation (ertifi(ates of the twelve
Federal Reserve Banks! giving the ownership of shares 1y the national 1anks in ea(h distri(t% The Federal Reserve Bank of New
York issued "#>!#L> shares! and! as filed with the Comptroller of the Curren(y May F! F$! the large New York City 1anks
took more than half of the outstanding shares% The Ro(kefeller Buhn! Coe1G(ontrolled National City Bank took the largest
num1er of shares of any 1ank! >#!### shares% '%*% MorganEs First National Bank took L!### shares% &hen these two 1anks
merged in FLL! they owned in one 1lo(k almost one fourth of the shares in the Federal Reserve Bank of New York! whi(h
(ontrolled the entire system! and thus they (ould name *aul ,ol(ker or anyone else they (hose to 1e Chairman of the Federal
Reserve Board of .overnors% Chase National Bank took ?!### shares% The Marine Nation Bank of Buffalo! later known as
Marine Midland! took ?!### shares% This 1ank was owned 1y the <(hoellkopf family! whi(h (ontrolled Niagara *ower Company
and other large interests% National Bank of Commer(e of New York City took "!### shares% The shareholders of these 1anks
whi(h own the sto(k of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York are the people who have (ontrolled our politi(al and e(onomi(
destinies sin(e F$% They are the Roths(hilds! of -urope! CaAard Freres /-ugene Meyer0! Buhn Coe1 Company! &ar1urg
Company! Cehman Brothers! .oldman <a(hs! the Ro(kefeller family! and the '%*% Morgan interests% These interests have merged
and (onsolidated in re(ent years! so that the (ontrol is mu(h more (on(entrated% National Bank of Commer(e is now Morgan
.uaranty Trust Company% Cehman Brothers has merged with Buhn! Coe1 Company! First National Bank has merged with the
National City Bank! and in the other eleven Federal Reserve )istri(ts! these same shareholders indire(tly own or (ontrol shares
in those 1anks! with the other shares owned 1y the leading families in those areas who own or (ontrol the prin(ipal industries in
these regions%9 : Secrets of the Federal (eser"e 1y -usta(e Mullins! Chapter >
2T&Ue have in this (ountry one of the most (orrupt institutions the world has ever known% 6 refer to the Federal Reserve Board
and the Federal Reserve Banks% The Federal Reserve Board! a .overnment 1oard! has (heated the .overnment of the ;nited
<tates and the people of the ;nited <tates out of enough money to pay the national de1t% The depredations and ini5uities of the
Federal Reserve Board has (ost this (ountry enough money to pay the national de1t several times over% This evil institution has
impoverished and ruined the people of the ;nited <tates! has 1ankrupted itself! and has pra(ti(ally 1ankrupted our .overnment%
6t has done this through the defe(ts of the law under whi(h it operates! through the maladministration of that law 1y the Federal
Reserve Board! and through the (orrupt pra(ti(es of the moneyed vultures who (ontrol it% <ome people think the Federal
Reserve 1anks are ;nited <tates .overnment institutions% They are not .overnment institutions% They are private (redit
monopolies whi(h prey upon the people of the ;nited <tates for the 1enefit of themselves and their foreign (ustomers8 foreign
and domesti( spe(ulators and swindlers8 and ri(h and predatory money lenders% 6n that dark (rew of finan(ial pirates there are
those who would (ut a manIs throat to get a dollar out of his po(ket8 there are those who send money into <tates to 1uy votes to
(ontrol our legislation8 and there are those who maintain international propaganda for the purpose of de(eiving us and of
wheedling us into the granting of new (on(essions whi(h will permit them to (over up their past misdeeds and set again in
motion their giganti( train of (rime%9
: ;%<% Congressman Couis Thomas M(Fadden /Repu1li(an *artyG*ennsylvania0! in a spee(h to the ;%<% 7ouse of
Representatives on 'une #! F>"% TNote: M(Fadden was a Congressman from Mar(h $! FL to 'anuary >! F>L8 M(Fadden
died on J(to1er ! F>? while on a visit in New York City%U
2Jur finan(ial system is a false one and a huge 1urden on the people % % % This TFederal ReserveU +(t esta1lishes the most
giganti( trust on earth% &hen the *resident signs this 1ill! the invisi1le government 1y the Monetary *ower will 1e legaliAed%
The people may not know it immediately! 1ut the day of re(koning is only a few years removed% The trusts will soon realiAe that
they have gone too far even for their own good% The people must make a de(laration of independen(e to relieve themselves
from the Monetary *ower% This they will 1e a1le to do 1y taking (ontrol of Congress% &all <treeters (ould not (heat us if you
<enators and Representatives did not make a hum1ug of Congress % % % 6f we had a peopleEs Congress! there would 1e sta1ility%
The greatest (rime of Congress is its (urren(y system% The worst legislative (rime of the ages is perpetrated 1y this 1anking 1ill%
The (au(us and the party 1osses have again operated and prevented the people from getting the 1enefit of their own
governmentS From now on! depressions will 1e s(ientifi(ally planned and (reated%9
: ;%<% Congressman Charles +% Cind1ergh! <r%! in a spee(h to the ;%<% 7ouse of Representatives on )e(em1er ""! F>
2The finan(ial system has 1een turned over to the Federal Reserve Board% That Board administers the finan(e system 1y
authority of a purely profiteering group% The system is private! (ondu(ted for the sole purpose of o1taining the greatest possi1le
profits from the use of other peopleEs money%9 : Charles +% Cind1ergh! <r%! F">
!he 4ederal 8ncome !a3 (enforced by the 8nternal "e(enue $er(ice) and the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem were established in ,-,..
(Photo7 4lickr)
.ignifi+ant Histori+al ?4ents in ()(3
!he "ockefeller 4oundation was founded in ,-,..
!he 0nti-Defamation League of B)nai B)rith was founded in ,-,..
!he ,/th 0mendment of the '.$. 1onstitution establishing the federal income ta3 was ratified on 4ebruary ., ,-,..
!he ,:th 0mendment of the '.$. 1onstitution recogni2ing #o#ular election of '.$. $enators was ratified on 0#ril 9, ,-,..
!he '.$. De#artment of Labor was established on *arch +, ,-,..
'.$. President Woodrow Wilson signed the 4ederal "eser(e 0ct into law on December 6., ,-,..
4rancisco 8. *adero, former President of *e3ico, was assassinated in *e3ico on 4ebruary 66, ,-,..
Woodrow Wilson was inaugurated President of the 'nited $tates on *arch +, ,-,..
Eing @eorge 8 of @reece was assassinated in !hessaloniki, @reece on *arch ,9, ,-,.
0merican international banker ;ohn Pier#ont *organ $r. died in "ome, 8taly on *arch .,, ,-,..
!he !reaty of London ending the 4irst Balkan War was signed on *ay .<, ,-,..
!he !reaty of Bucharest ending the $econd Balkan War was signed on 0ugust ,<, ,-,..
Fe#eral 6eser4e earne# F=B billion in *>>)
By Neil 6rwin
&ashington *ost <taff &riter
Tuesday! 'anuary "! "##
&all <treet firms arenEt the only 1anks that had a 1anner year% The #ederal $eserve made record profits in 1II0! as its un(onventional efforts to
prop up the e(onomy (reated a windfall for the government%
The Fed will return a1out P$L 1illion to the ;%<% Treasury for "##F! a((ording to (al(ulations 1y The &ashington *ost 1ased on pu1li( do(uments%
That refle(ts the highest earnings in the F?Gyear history of the (entral 1ank% The Fed! unlike most government agen(ies! funds itself from its own
operations and returns its profits to the Treasury%
The num1ers are good news for the federal 1udget and a sign that the Fed has 1een su((essful! at least so far! in prote(ting ta3payers as it intervenes
in the e(onomy GG though there remains a risk of signifi(ant losses in the future if the Fed sells some of its investments or loses money on its stakes in
1ailedGout firms%
This turn of events (omes as the 1anks that 1enefited from the FedIs a(tions are under the mi(ros(ope% <tarting at the end of the week! ma4or 1anks
are e3pe(ted to announ(e signifi(ant earnings and employee 1onuses% +nger in &ashington is at su(h a high 1oil that the J1ama administration will
pro1a1ly propose a fee on finan(ial firms to re(oup the (ost of their 1ailout! offi(ials (onfirmed Monday%
+s it happens! the FedEs earnings for the year will dwarf those of the large 1anks! easily topping the e3pe(ted profits of Bank of +meri(a! .oldman
<a(hs and '%*% Morgan Chase (om1ined%
Mu(h of the higher earnings (ame a1out 1e(ause of the FedIs aggressive program of 1uying 1onds! aiming to push interest rates down a(ross the
e(onomy and thus stimulate growth% By the end of "##F! the Fed owned P%= trillion in ;%<% government de1t and mortgageGrelated se(urities! up
from P$FH 1illion a year earlier% The interest in(ome on those investments was a ma4or sour(e of Fed profits GG though that in(ome (omes with risks!
as the (entral 1ank (ould lose money if it later sells those se(urities to redu(e the money supply%
The Fed also made money on its emergen(y loans to 1anks and other firms and on spe(ial programs to prop up lending! su(h as one that supports
(redit (ards! auto loans! and other (onsumer and 1usiness lending% Those programs impose interest and fees on parti(ipants! with the aim of ensuring
that the Fed does not lose money%
+nd while the (entral 1ank in its most re(ent finan(ial report had re(orded a P>%= 1illion de(line in the value of loans it made in 1ailing out the
investment 1ank Bear <tearns and the insurer +meri(an 6nternational .roup! the Fed also logged P$%H 1illion in interest payments from those loans%
Further losses GG or gains GG on the two 1ailouts are possi1le as time goes 1y% The Fed also (harges fees for operating the plum1ing of the finan(ial
system! su(h as (learing (he(ks and ele(troni( payments 1etween 1anks%
From its revenue! the Fed dedu(ts operating e3penses! su(h as employee salaries! then returns to the Treasury almost all of the earnings that remain%
The largest previous refund to the Treasury was P>$%? 1illion! in "##H%
2This shows that (entral 1anking is a great 1usiness to 1e in! espe(ially in a (risis!9 said ,in(ent Reinhart! a resident s(holar at the +meri(an
-nterprise 6nstitute and a former Fed offi(ial% 2You 1uy assets that have a ni(e yield! and your (ost of funds is very low% The differen(e is profit%9
The Fed plans to release its estimate of "##F earnings Tuesday% The *ostIs (al(ulation is 1ased on (om1ining data through <eptem1er from the FedIs
monthly 1alan(e sheet report with more re(ent data from the TreasuryIs daily 1udget statement%
Fed offi(ials do not make poli(y with an eye toward ma3imiAing profits% They are (harged 1y law with managing the nationIs money supply to keep
employment high and pri(es sta1le! and earnings flu(tuate depending on a wide range of fa(tors as they pursue that goal% 6n the (risis! the (entral
1ankIs poli(y has 1een to (reate money and use it to 1uy a wide variety of assets! whi(h in turn pay interest%
6n effe(t! the unpre(edented range of a(tions taken to address the (risis has made the FedIs 1alan(e sheet more like that of a private 1ank% + firm su(h
as Bank of +meri(a takes money from depositors! whom it pays little or nothing in interest! and lends it out at signifi(antly higher rates% The Fed!
similarly! takes money that 1anks keep on deposit! at a rate of #%"L per(ent! and lends it to the ;%<% government 1y 1uying Treasury se(urities and!
lately! to home 1uyers and other private 1orrowers though more e3oti( investments%
&hile that resulted in higher earnings in "##F! it e3poses the Fed to more risks down the road% YTheyIve moved up the riskGreturn (urve! as they have
more longGterm assets and more things that involve (redit risk!Y said )iane <wonk! (hief e(onomist at Mesirow Finan(ial%
6f the pri(e of Treasury 1onds or mortgageGrelated se(urities issued 1y Fannie Mae and Freddie Ma( were to fall in the years ahead! and Fed leaders
de(ided they need to drain money from the finan(ial system 1y selling off some of their portfolio! the (entral 1ank would lose money% 26f they do
enough asset sales and rates go high enough! that (ould eat into future profits pretty su1stantially!9 said Mi(hael Feroli! an e(onomist at '%*% Morgan
Chase%
-ven as the Fed (omes to resem1le private 1anks in terms of its 1alan(e sheet and its earnings power! there remains one 1ig differen(e% The C-J of
the Federal Reserve! Chairman Ben <% Bernanke! re(eived a modest (ostGofGliving raise for "##! despite the re(ord earnings: 7e now makes
PFF!H##! with no 1onus at all%
<our(e: The Washington +ost8 http:@@www%washingtonpost%(om@wpGdyn@(ontent@arti(le@"##@#@@+R"####>=F"%html
)-C-MB-R "#! "##= : -ssay
6s the Medi(ine &orse Than the 6llness?
The world ran out of trust in "##= GG 1ut there is no shortage of money 1e(ause the Fed is printing like mad% 6tIs the wrong
approa(h! with potentially dire (onse5uen(es! says 'ames .rant%
By '+M-< .R+NT
8t is a sorry #lace at which we 0mericans find oursel(es this none-too-festi(e holiday season. !he biggest names on Wall $treet ha(e
gone to their rewards or into #artnershi# with the '.$. !reasury. 4oreigners stare wide-eyed from across the waters. 0 G>< billion Pon2i
scheme (baited with, of all things in this age of e3cess, the #romise of low, s#uriously #redictable returns)? 8nterest rates o(er which
tiny ;a#anese rates fairly tower? "egulatory #olicy seemingly set by a weather (ane? 0 4ederal "eser(e that canIt make u# its mind7 8s
it in the business of central banking or of central #lanning? 0nd to think -- our disa##ointed foreign friends mutter -- all of these
enormities taking #lace under a "e#ublican administration.
!rust itself entered a bear market in 6<<9, com#lementing and #erha#s sur#assing the selloffs in stocks, mortgages and commodities.
=e(er to be confused with angels, we humans seem to outdo oursel(es when money is on the line. $o it is that Bernard *adoff,
su##osed #illar of the community, stands accused of #er#etrating one of the greatest hoa3es since ;ohn Law disco(ered the
inflationary #ossibilities of #a#er money in the early ,9th century.
Barely nudging *r. *adoff out of the to# of the news was the 4ederal "eser(eIs announcement last !uesday that it intends to debase
its own #a#er money. !he year Kust ending has been a time of confusion as much as it has been of loss. But here, at least, was the
bright beam of clarity. $#ecifically, the 4ed #ledged to #rint dollars in unlimited (olume and to trim its funds rate, if necessary, all the
way to 2ero. =or would it rest on its laurels e(en at an interest rate low enough to dri(e the creditor class back to work. 8t would, on the
contrary, Hcontinue to consider ways of using its balance sheet to further su##ort credit markets and economic acti(ity.H
Wall $treet that day did hands#rings. B(en go(ernment securities #rices raced higher, as if, somehow, !reasury bonds were not
denominated in the currency with which the 4ed had announced its intention to #a#er the face of the earth. Bconomic commentators
#raised the central bankIs determination to fight deflation -- that is, to reinstate inflation. 0ll hands, including President-elect Fbama,
seemed to agree that wholesale money-#rinting was the answer to the nationIs #rayers.
Fne market, only, registered a #rotest. !he 4edIs declaration of inflationary intent knocked the dollar for a loo# against gold and foreign
currencies. 8n many different languages and from many time 2ones came the Duestion, H!ell me, again, now that the dollar yields so
little, why do we own it?H
8t was on Fct. /, ,-:-, that then-4ed 1hairman Paul 0. Aolcker (owed to #rint less money to bring down inflation. $o doing, he closed
one monetary era and o#ened another. With !uesdayIs #romise to #rint much more money, the 4ederal "eser(e of Ben $. Bernanke
has o#ened its own new era. Whether *r. BernankeIs #olicy of debasement will lead to as ha##y an outcome as that which crowned
the Aolcker anti-inflation initiati(e is, howe(er, doubtful. Whate(er the road to riches might be #a(ed with, it isnIt little green #ieces of
#a#er stam#ed Hlegal tender.H
Fur troubles, o(er which we will certainly #re(ail, stem from a basic contradiction. !he dollar is the worldIs currency, yet the 4ed is
0mericaIs central bank. *r. BernankeIs remit is to #romote low inflation, high em#loyment and sol(ent finance -- in the >< states. e
wishes the 1hinese well, of course, and the 4rench and the $inga#oreans and all the rest besides, but they donIt #ay his salary.
!hey do, howe(er, buy the '.$. !reasuryIs bonds, which frames the emerging 0merican dilemma. 8f the 4ed is going to create
boatloads of de#reciating, non-yielding dollar bills, who will absorb them? Who will finance the Fbama administrationIs looming titanic
fiscal deficits? Who will finance 0mericaIs annual sur#lus of consum#tion o(er #roduction (after 6> more or less continuous years,
almost a national trait)? 8nflation is a kind of go(ernmentally sanctioned white-collar crime. B(ery crime needs a du#e. =ow that the 4ed
has announced its #lan to decei(e, where will it find its (ictims?
*r. Bernanke has good reason to worry about the economy. We all do. 8n the boom, a su#erabundance of mis#riced debt led countless
#eo#le down innumerable blind in(estment alleys. B-R credit financed bubbles in real estate, commodities, mortgage-backed securities
and a myriad of other assets. 8t #unished sa(ing and encouraged s#eculation. 8magine a man at the to# of a ste#ladder. e is u# on his
toes reaching for something. 1all that something Hyield.H 1all the ste#ladder Hle(erage.H =ow kick the ladder away. !he man falls,
#ieces of debt crashing to the floor around him. !he 4ed, watching this #re(entable accident unfold, rushes to the scene too late. =ot
only did Bernanke et al. not see it coming, but they actually egged the man higher. &ou will recall the ultra-low interest rates of the early
6<<<s. !he 4ed im#osed them to s#eed reco(ery from an earlier accident, this one in(ol(ing a man u# on a ste#ladder reaching for
technology stocks.
!he underlying cause of these misha#s is the dollar and the central bank that mani#ulates it. 8n ages #ast, it was so sim#le. 0 central
banker had one Kob only, and that was to assure that the currency under his care was e3changeable into gold at the lawfully sti#ulated
rate. 8t was his office to make the #ublic indifferent between currency or gold. 8n a crisis, the bankerIs Kob descri#tion e3#anded to
#ermit emergency lending against good collateral at a high rate of interest. But no self-res#ecting central banker did much more.
1ertainly, none arrogated to himself the Kob of steering the economy by fi3ing an interest rate. =one, 8 belie(e, had an economist on the
#ayroll. =one facilitated deficit s#ending by buying u# his go(ernmentIs bonds. =one cared about the a(erage le(el of #rices, which
rose in wartime and sank in #eacetime. 8t sank in #eacetime because technological #rogress and the o#ening of new regions to
agricultural #roduction made merchandise and commodities chea#er and more abundant.
=ot e(eryone agreed that these arrangements were hea(en-sent. 8n com#arison to the rigor of the gold standard, #a#er money
seemed, to many, an intelligent and forgi(ing alternati(e. 8n ,9:9, a committee of the ouse of "e#resentati(es was formed to
in(estigate the causes of the suffering of working #eo#le in the de#ression that was fi(e years old and counting. =ot a few witnesses
#leaded for the creation of more greenbacks. !hey asked that the go(ernment not go through with its #lan to return to the gold
standard in ,9:-. But the nation did return to gold -- it had financed the 1i(il War with #a#er money -- and the de#ression ended in the
(ery same year.
@old is a hard master, and a ca#ricious one, too, insofar as growth in the worldIs monetary base de#ends on the enter#rise of mining
engineers. But, as we ha(e seen lately, there is no ca#rice like the ca#rice of slee#-de#ri(ed *andarins im#ro(ising a monetary
solution to a credit crisis (or, for that matter, of fully rested *andarins setting interest rates by the lights of their econometric models).
!he times were hard in the ,9:<s and, for that matter, again in the ,9-<s, but 0mericans re#eatedly s#urned the Po#ulist cries for a
dollar you didnIt ha(e to dig out of the ground but could rather #rint u# by the Kob lot. H8f the @o(ernment can create money,H as a hard-
money #ro#agandist #ut it in an ,9-6 broadside entitled H1hea# *oney,H Hwhy should not it create all that e(erybody wants? Why
should anybody work for a li(ing?H 0nd -- in a most #rescient rhetorical Duestion -- he went on to ask, HWhy should we ha(e any limit
#ut to the (olume of our currency?H
0 cou#le of #anics later, the 4ederal "eser(e came along -- the year was ,-,.. Promoters of the legislation to establish 0mericaIs new
central bank #rotested that they wanted no soft currency. !he dollar would continue to be e3changeable into gold at the customary rate
of G6<./: an ounce. But, they added, under the 4edIs enlightened stewardshi#, the currency would become He3#ansi(e.H 0ccordion-
fashion, the number of dollars in circulation would e3#and or contract according to the needs of commerce and agriculture.
?lihu 6oot, 6epubli+an senator from 5ew ;ork, thought he smelle# a rat. 8nti+ipating the +re#it inflations of the future an#
re+alling the #isturban+es of the past, Cr. 6oot atta+ke# the bill in this fashion7 GLittle b! little, business is enlarge# with eas!
mone!. With the exhaustless reser4oir of the o4ernment of the -nite# .tates furnishing eas! mone!, the sales in+rease, the
businesses enlarge, more new enterprises are starte#, the spirit of optimism per4a#es the +ommunit!.
G,ankers are not free from it,G Cr. 6oot went on. G$he! are human. $he members of the Fe#eral 6eser4e boar# will not be free
of it. $he! are human....?4er!one is making mone!. ?4er!one is growing ri+h. Dt goes up an# up, the margin between +osts
an# sales +ontinuall! growing smaller as a result of the operation of ine4itable laws, until finall! someone whose Eu#gment
was ba#, someone whose +apa+it! for business was small, breaks% an# as he falls he hits the next bri+k in the row, an# then
another, an# then another, an# #own +omes the whole stru+ture.
G$hat, sir,G Cr. 6oot +on+lu#e#, Gis no #ream. $hat is the histor! of e4er! mo4ement of inflation sin+e the worl#Hs business
began, an# it is the histor! of man! a perio# in our own +ountr!. $hat is what happene# to greater or less #egree before the
pani+ of (13/, of (1B/, of (1/3, of (1)3 an# of ()>/. $he pre+ise formula whi+h the stu#ents of e+onomi+ mo4ements ha4e
e4ol4e# to #es+ribe the reason for the +rash following the uni4ersal pro+ess is that when +re#it ex+ee#s the legitimate
#eman#s of the +ountr! the +urren+! be+omes suspe+te# an# gol# lea4es the +ountr!.G
Little did *r. "oot sus#ect that the dollar would lose its gold backing altogether -- that, starting in ,-:,, there would be nothing behind it
more than the good intentions of the '.$. go(ernment and (somewhat more substanti(ely) the demonstrated strength of the '.$.
economy. $till less could he ha(e guessed that the world would nonetheless fall in lo(e with that uncollaterali2ed #iece of #a#er or --
e(en more astoundingly -- that the 'nited $tates would enKoy so great a reser(oir of good will that it would be allowed to borrow its way
to a net international in(estment #osition of minus G6.++ trillion (G,:./+ trillion of foreign assets held by 0mericans (s. G6<.<9 trillion of
0merican assets held by foreigners). H8t goes u# and u#,H *r. "oot said of the inflationary cycle, but Kust how high he could not ha(e
dreamt.
Enowledge of the #rece#ts of classical central banking #re#ared no one to understand, much less to antici#ate, the 4edIs conduct in
this credit cracku#. !he central bank is lending freely, all right, but not at the sti#ulated HhighH interest rate. 0s a matter of fact, it is
starting to lend at a rate below which there is no #ositi(e rate. !he gold standard was obKecti(e. *odern monetary management is
subKecti(e (under 0lan @reens#an, it was intuiti(e). !he gold standard was rules-based. !he 6,st century 4ed goes with what works --
or seems to work. What it ho#es is going to work for the fellow who fell off the ste#ladder is more debt and more dollars. ;ust how much
of each can be found e(ery !hursday e(ening on the 4edIs own Web site. F#en u# form +., and #re#are to be ama2ed. $ince Labor
Day, the 4edIs assets ha(e 2oomed to G6.., trillion from G-<>.: billion. 0nd what is the significance of this stunning rate of asset
growth? $im#ly this7 !he 4ed #ays for its assets with freshly made dollars. 8t conKures them into e3istence on a com#uter5 H#rintingH is a
figure of s#eech.
8n this crisis, the 4edIs assets ha(e grown much faster than its ca#ital. !he truth is that the 4ederal "eser(e is itself a highly le(eraged
financial institution. !he flagshi# branch of the ,6-bank system, the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork, shows assets of G,.. trillion
and ca#ital of Kust G,6.6 billion. 8ts le(erage ratio, a mere <.-S, is less than one-third of that #rescribed for banks in the #ri(ate sector.
$uch a thin film of #rotection would #resent no s#ecial risk if the bank managed by !imothy 4. @eithner, the !reasury secretary-
designate, owned only short-dated !reasurys. owe(er, the mystery meat acDuired from Bear $tearns and 08@ foots to G//./ billion. 0
writedown of Kust ,9..S in the (alue of those risky #ortfolios would erase the =ew &ork 4edIs ca#ital account. Dn +ongressional
testimon! eight !ears ago, Lauren+e Ce!er, then a Fe# go4ernor, trie# to alla! an! su+h +on+erns (whi+h then must ha4e
seeme# remote, in#ee#". GCre#itors of +entral banks...are at no risk of a loss be+ause the +entral bank +an alwa!s +reate
a##itional +urren+! to meet an! obligation #enominate# in that +urren+!,G he soothingl! remin#e# his listeners.
&es, todayIs #olicy makers allow, there are risks to HcreatingH a trillion or so of new currency e(ery few months, but that is tomorrowIs
worry. Fn todayIs agenda is a deflationary abyss. 4rostbite (ictims tend not to dwell on the summertime #erils of heatstroke.
But the seasons of finance are un#redictable. Prescience is rare enough in the #ri(ate sector. 8t is almost unheard of in Washington.
!he credit troubles took the 4ed unawares. $o, likely, will the outbreak of the ne3t inflation. 0lready the stars are aligned for a doo2y.
=ot only the 4ed, but also the other leading central banks are frantically ram#ing u# money #roduction. $imultaneously, miners and oil
#roducers are ram#ing down commodity #roduction -- as is, for instance, is "io !into, the hea(ily encumbered mining giant, which the
other day disclosed ,+,<<< layoffs and a G> billion cutback in ca#ital e3#enditure. 1ome the economic reco(ery, resource #roducers
will certainly increase out#ut. But it is far less certain that, once the cycle turns, the central banks will #unctually tighten.
!he #ublic has been slow to anger in this costliest and scariest of #ost World War 88 financial crises. Wall $treet and the debt ratings
agencies ha(e come in for well-deser(ed castigation. But #ointing fingers rarely find the 4ederal "eser(e, whose low, low interest rates
hel#ed to set house #rices le(itating in the first #lace.
0fter *r. Bernanke gets a good nightIs slee#, he should be called to account for once again cutting interest rates at the e3#ense of the
long-suffering (and #ossibly hungry) sa(ers. e should be asked to e3#lain how the central-banking methods of the #a#er-dollar era
re#resent any im#ro(ement, either in #ractice or theory, o(er the rigor, elegance, sim#licity and #redictability of the gold standard. e
should be directed to read aloud the te3t of critiDue by Blihu "oot and e3#lain where, if at all, the old gentleman went wrong. 4inally, he
should be directed to #ut himself into the shoes of a foreign holder of '.$. dollars. H!ell us, *r. Bernanke,H a congressman might
consider asking him, Hif you had the choice, would you hold dollars? 0nd may 8 remind you, *r. 1hairman, that you are under oath?H
;ames @rant, the editor of @rantIs 8nterest "ate Fbser(er, is the author most recently of H*r. *arket *iscalculates.H
#rinte in The (a!! 'treet $ourna!) page (*
<our(e: The Wall Street ,ournal! http:@@online%ws4%(om@arti(le@<B""FH>$>L"LL">"L%html
2Cittle 1y little! 1usiness is enlarged with easy money% &ith the e3haustless reservoir of the .overnment of the ;nited <tates
furnishing easy money! the sales in(rease! the 1usinesses enlarge! more new enterprises are started! the spirit of optimism
pervades the (ommunity% Bankers are not free from it% They are human% The mem1ers of the Federal reserve 1oard will not 1e
free of it% They are human% Regional 1ankers will not 1e free from it% They are human% +ll the world moves along upon a
growing tide of optimism% -veryone is making money% -veryone is growing ri(h% 6t goes up and up! the margin 1etween (ost
and sales (ontinually growing smaller as a result of the operation of inevita1le laws! until finally someone whose 4udgment was
1ad! some one whose (apa(ity for 1usiness was small! 1reaks8 and as he falls he hits the ne3t 1ri(k in the row! and then another!
and then another! and down (omes the whole stru(ture% That! sir! is no dream% That is the history of every movement of inflation
sin(e the worldIs 1usiness 1egan! and it is the history of many a period in our own (ountry% That is what happened to greater or
less degree 1efore the pani( of =>H! of =LH! of =H>! of =F>! and of F#H% <o! sir! 6 (an see in this 1ill itself! in the dis(harge
of our duty! no influen(e interposed 1y us against the o((urren(e of one of those periods of false and delusive prosperity whi(h
inevita1ly end in ruin and suffering% For! Mr% *resident! the most direful results of the awakening of the people from su(h a
dream are not to 1e found in the 1anking houses : no8 not even in the 1usiness houses% They are to 1e found among the millions
who have lost the means of earning their daily 1read%9
: Former ;%<% <enator -lihu Root! in a spee(h he delivered in the ;%<% <enate on )e(em1er >! F>! from Addresses on
!o"ernment and &iti-enship /F?0! p% >>HG>>=
2ST.Uold always leaves a (ountry in whi(h the amount of (urren(y e3(eeds the demands of legitimate 1usiness%9
: Former ;%<% <enator -lihu Root! in a spee(h he delivered in the ;%<% <enate on )e(em1er >! F>! from Addresses on
!o"ernment and &iti-enship /F?0! p% >LL
I!!ustrat%d Cistor. o" th% F%d%ra! 3%s%r&%
!he 4ederal "eser(e Board in ,-,+. !he se(en original members of the 4ederal "eser(e Board sit for a grou# #ortrait on 0ugust ,<, ,-,+,
shortly after being sworn in. $tanding, left to right7 Paul *. Warburg, ;ohn $kelton Williams (1om#troller of the 1urrency), W.P.@. arding,
and 0dol#h 1. *iller5 seated, left to right7 1harles amlin (@o(ernor), William @. *c0doo (1hairman and $ecretary of the !reasury), and
4rederic 0. Delano. 4rederic 0. Delano was the son of "ussell % 1om#any M1hina o#ium syndicateN #artner Warren Delano ;r. and '.$.
President 4ranklin Delano "oose(elt)s uncle. *c0doo is wearing a mourning armband to commemorate the death, four days earlier, of his
mother-in-law, Bllen 03son Wilson, the former 4irst Lady and wife of President Woodrow Wilson. William @. *c0doo had married Woodrow
Wilson)s daughter Bleanor "andol#h Wilson in *ay ,-,+. (Photo7 @eorge @rantham Bain 1ollectionCLibrary of 1ongress)
4ederal "eser(e bankers #ose for a grou# #ortrait in ,-,+. 4ront row, left to right7 Paul Warburg, ;ohn $kelton Williams, 1harles amlin, and
4rederic 0. Delano. 8n the rear is a large grou# of @o(ernors and *embers of the (arious branches of the 4ederal "eser(e banks.
(Photo7 arris % Bwing 1ollectionCLibrary of 1ongress)
*embers of the "ed 1ross War 1ouncil meet with President Woodrow Wilson during World War 8. 4ront row, left to right7 "obert W. De4orest,
President Woodrow Wilson, former President William oward !aft, unidentified. Back row, left to right7 enry P. Da(ison, unidentified, 1harles
D. =orton, and Bdward =. urley. Fne of the unidentified #erson in this #hoto is 1ol. @rayson *.P. *ur#hy. 1harles D. =orton, Bdward =.
urley, and "obert W. De4orest were members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. enry P. Da(ison went to ;ekyll 8sland in ,-,< along
with Paul Warburg and $enator =elson 0ldrich to create a legislation that would establish the 4ederal "eser(e.
+ group portrait of the )istri(t .overnors of the Federal Reserve in (ir(a Novem1er F$: -% R% FR+NC7-R! Cleveland!
)istri(t $8 .-JR.- '% <-+Y! Ri(hmond! )istri(t L8 'J<-*7 +% M(CJR)! +tlanta! )istri(t ?8 T7-J)JR- &JC)!
Minneapolis! )istri(t F8 C7+RC-< M% <+&Y-R! Topeka! )istri(t #% B+CB RJ&: C7+RC-< '% R7J+)<! *hiladelphia!
)istri(t >8 J<C+R &-CC<! 7ouston! )istri(t 8 +CFR-) C% +6B-N! Boston! )istri(t 8 B-N'+M6N <TRJN.! New York!
)istri(t "8 +RC76B+C) B+6N<! <an Fran(is(o! )istri(t "%
/Repository: Ci1rary of Congress *rints and *hotographs )ivision0
/<our(e: http:@@www%lo(%gov@pi(tures@item@he("##=##>$F>@?sidX>#H1?dHde(>FL(eeF>"f?ea(1?(=f$0
+ group portrait of the Chairmen of the Federal Reserve )istri(ts in (ir(a Novem1er F$: Front row: FR-)-R6CB 7%
C;RT6<<! Boston! )istri(t 8 *6-RR- '+Y! New York City! )istri(t "8 R6C7+R) C% +;<T6N! *hiladelphia! )istri(t >8 )%C%
&6CC<! Bellevue! *ennsylvania! )istri(t $8 &6CC6+M 6N.C-! Baltimore! )istri(t L8 M%B% &6CCBJRN! +nniston! +la1ama!
)istri(t ?8 Ba(k row: C%7% BJ<&JRT7! Chi(ago! )istri(t H8 +%-% R+M<-Y! Muskogee! Jklahoma! )istri(t #8 -%J%
T-NN6<JN! )allas! )istri(t 8 'J7N *-RR6N! <an Fran(is(o! )istri(t "% *ierre 'ay and 'ohn *errin were mem1ers of <kull
K Bones at Yale ;niversity% /Repository: Ci1rary of Congress *rints and *hotographs )ivision0
/<our(e: http:@@www%lo(%gov@pi(tures@item@he("##=##>$F"@resour(e@he(%#$=?@?sidX?("FL"#e#?fL(d?>"(#?L>$=LeF("F0
Federal Reserve Board mem1er *aul M% &ar1urg /wearing a top hat and a mousta(he0 attends the First *an +meri(an Finan(ial
Conferen(e in &ashington! )%C% in May FL% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
*hotograph of a Federal Reserve Board meeting in (ir(a FH% Clo(kwise! 1eginning from left: &illiam .% M(+doo /<e(retary
of the Treasury0! 'ohn <kelton &illiams /Comptroller of the Curren(y0! +dolph C% Miller! Frederi( +% )elano! unknown! &%*%.%
7arding /.overnor of the Federal Reserve0! *aul &ar1urg /,i(e .overnor of the Federal Reserve0! and Charles <% 7amlin%
/*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
4ederal "eser(e Board members #ose for a grou# #ortrait during World War 8. 1lockwise, from left7 unidentified, W.P.@. arding, Paul
Warburg, William @. *c0doo (1hairman and $ecretary of the !reasury), 1harles amlin, ;ohn $kelton Williams (1om#troller of the 1urrency),
0dol#h 1. *iller, and 4rederic 0. Delano. (Photo7 arris % Bwing 1ollectionCLibrary of 1ongress)
Paul Warburg stands on the far left in the rear as a member of the 4ederal "eser(e Board. Paul Warburg was one of the founders of the
4ederal "eser(e. Paul Warburg was a @erman citi2en at the time he attended a secret meeting in ;ekyll 8sland, @eorgia in =o(ember ,-,<5
he became an 0merican citi2en on *arch 6,, ,-,,. Paul Warburg ser(ed as Aice 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e during World War 85 he
ser(ed as director of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations from ,-6, until his death in ,-.6.
William Boyce !hom#son (bottom left, seated) was a Class , <ire+tor of the Fe#eral 6eser4e ,ank of 5ew ;ork from ()(=
to ()() and one of the original 6,, members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. e is seen with se(eral "ussian Bolshe(iks.
+ photo of a Federal Reserve Board .overnorEs meeting in the early F"#s% Federal Reserve 1ankers in the (onferen(e room
in(lude *ierre 'ay /third from right! Chairman of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York0 and 'ohn *errin /se(ond from right!
Chairman of the Federal Reserve Bank of <an Fran(is(o0% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
Take BoticeJ Federal Reserve Board mem1ers pose for a group portrait in )e(em1er F"% From left to right: +ndrew &%
Mellon /<e(retary of the Treasury0! &%*%.% 7arding /.overnor TChairmanU of the Federal Reserve0! -dmund *latt /,i(e
.overnor of the Federal Reserve0! Charles <% 7amlin! +dolph C% Miller! )aniel R% Crissinger /Comptroller of the Curren(y0! and
'%R% Mit(hell% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
Federal Reserve Board mem1ers pose for a group portrait on May ?! F">% From left to right! +dolph C% Miller! 7enry M%
)awes /Comptroller of the Curren(y0! unidentified! +ndrew &% Mellon /<e(retary of the Treasury0! -dmund *latt /,i(e
.overnor of the Federal Reserve0! unidentified! )aniel R% Crissinger /.overnor TChairmanU of the Federal Reserve0! and Charles
<% 7amlin% The two unidentified men are Federal Reserve Board mem1ers .eorge R% 'ames /appointed on May $! F">0 and
-dward 7% Cunningham /appointed on May $! F">0% /*hoto: National *hoto Company Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
*embers of the 4ederal "eser(e Board #ose for a grou# #ortrait in December ,-6,, with 0ndrew W. *ellon, $ecretary of the !reasury, as its
1hairman. 4rom left to right, 0ndrew W. *ellon, 1hairman, W.P.@. arding, @o(ernor, Bdmund Platt, Aice @o(ernor, 1harles $. amlin,
0dol#h 1. *iller, Daniel ". 1rissinger, 1om#troller of the 1urrency, and ;.". *itchell. (J 'nderwood % 'nderwoodC1F"B8$)
'.$. President 4ranklin D. "oose(elt signs the @old Bill in Washington, D.1. on ;anuary .<, ,-.+. Witnesses standing in the rear include
!reasury $ecretary enry *orgenthau ;r. (second from left) and @eorge L. arrison (second from right), the President of the 4ederal "eser(e
Bank of =ew &ork. (J BettmannC1F"B8$)
*resident Franklin )% Roosevelt signs the .old Bill in &ashington! )%C% on 'anuary >#! F>$% &itnesses standing in the rear
in(lude Treasury <e(retary 7enry Morgenthau 'r% /se(ond from left0 and .eorge C% 7arrison /se(ond from right0! the *resident
of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York%
/*hoto Credit: ;nderwood K ;nderwood@Franklin )% Roosevelt *residential Ci1rary and Museum0
*resident Franklin )elano Roosevelt smiles as he signs The Banking +(t of F>L on +ugust ">! F>L! (ompleted the
restru(turing of the Federal Reserve and finan(ial system 1egun during the 7oover administration and (ontinued during the
Roosevelt administration% <tanding 1ehind Roosevelt is Treasury <e(retary 7enry Morgenthau 'r%
/*hoto Credit: 7arris K -wing0 http:@@www%fli(kr%(om@photos@federalreserve@"#=$F=LL@
New home of Federal Reserve Board in (ir(a F>H% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
The governmentEs e3perts on money matters met with <enate and 7ouse leaders in &ashington! )%C% on 'anuary H! F>H to
dis(uss legislation to 1e su1mitted to the HLth session of Congress% + dis(ussion was made at the (onferen(e to e3tend the life of
important federal monetary lending agen(ies! and also! to move in giving the *resident authority to dis(ontinue the R%F%C% at
anytime the (onditions warrant% 6n the photograph! from left to right: 'esse 7% 'ones! ;%<% <enator Carter .lass /)emo(ratG
,irginia0! Chairman of the <enate Finan(e Committee ;%<% <enator *at 7arrison /)emo(ratGMississippi0! and Marriner -((les!
Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
Marriner -((les /right0! Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board! gestures with his middle finger as he drives home a point to
;%<% <enator *at 7arrison! Chairman of the <enate Finan(e Committee! during a private (onversation in &ashington! )%C% on
'anuary H! F>H% They were snapped while attending a (onferen(e 1etween the administration fis(al e3perts and <enate and
7ouse leaders to dis(uss legislation to 1e su1mitted to the HLth session of Congress%
/*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman *arriner Bccles, seen with both of his hands on his face, urges a##ro(al of administrationIs lending #rogram
during a $enate Banking and 1urrency 1ommittee hearing in Washington, D.1., ;uly ,-, ,-.-. Bccles told the $enate Banking and 1urrency
1ommittee that the President)s lending #rogram is the only immediately #racticable means of stimulating business and em#loyment u# to
#ros#erity le(els. (Photo7 arris % Bwing 1ollectionCLibrary of 1ongress)
!homas ;. Watson (sitting to itler)s left), the President of 8nternational Business *achines 1or#. (also known as 8B*), meets with =a2i
@ermany)s dictator 0dolf itler in ,-.:. $homas J. Watson was a Class , <ire+tor of the Fe#eral 6eser4e ,ank of 5ew ;ork from ()33
to ()=> and a member of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. !homas ;. Watson and his 8B* #ro(ided 0dolf itler and the =a2is with #unch-
card machines. !he =a2i @erman go(ernment, military, and cor#orations used #unch-card machines to create and assign serial numbers for
#risoners working as sla(e laborers in the concentration cam#s.
+ppearing 1efore the <pe(ial <enate Committee on unemployment in &ashington! )%C% on 'anuary $! F>=! Federal Reserve
Board Chairman Marriner -((les de(lared that payment of the soldiers 1onus in F>? helped (reate pri(e distortion that pushed
re(overy out of 1alan(e and led toward the (urrent 1usiness re(ession% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
Marriner -((les /left0! Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board! and -%+% .oldeneiser! )ire(tor of the BoardEs )ivision of
Resear(h and <tatisti(s! putting their heads together to find an answer during the (ommittee meeting of the <pe(ial <enate <ilver
Committee in &ashington! )%C% on Mar(h ">! F>F% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
+n impe((a1ly dressed Marriner -((les! Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board! attends a party in &ashington! )%C% on
)e(em1er ! F>F% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
Marriner <% -((les! Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board! appears 1efore the <enate Banking and Curren(y <u1(ommittee in
&ashington! )%C% on 'une >! F$# and e3presses his opposition to a 1ill li1eraliAing provisions of the Federal 7ome Coan +(t%
7e said that ena(tment of the a(t! sponsored 1y <enator &agner! would e3pand operations of the 7ome Coan Bank <ystem far
1eyond the s(ope of its original purposes% /*hoto: 7arris K -wing Colle(tion@Ci1rary of Congress0
.roup portrait of +meri(an delegation to international monetary (onferen(e to plan for postwar re(onstru(tion at Bretton
&oods! New 7ampshire /;%<%+%0 on 'uly "! F$$% <eated /left to right0: <enator Ro1ert F% &agner! Congressman Brent <pen(e!
<e(retary of the Treasury 7enry Morgenthau 'r% and <enator Charles &% To1ey8 <tanding /left to right0: 7enry )e3ter &hite!
Fred ,inson! )ean +(heson! -dward -% Brown! Federal Reserve Chairman Marriner <% -((les and Congressman 'esse &ol(ott%
/Time Cife photo 1y +lfred -isenstaedt0
*edestrians walk down Nassau <treet past the Federal Reserve Bank of New York Building /left0 in F$$ during &orld &ar 66%
The New York <to(k -3(hange (an 1e glimpsed at the foot of the image%
/+ndreas Feininger@Time K Cife *i([email protected] 6mages0
Federal Reserve Chairman Thomas M(Ca1e leaves the &hite 7ouse after visiting with *resident 7arry <% Truman in )e(em1er
F$=% Thomas M(Ca1e was a mem1er of the Coun(il on Foreign Relations% /Cife MagaAine photo 1y Thomas )% M(+voy0
William *c1hesney *artin ;r. Bra (,->,-,-:<)
President Lyndon B. ;ohnson meets with !reasury $ecretary enry 4owler (left, front), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman William *c1. *artin ;r.
(left, rear), 1ouncil of Bconomic 0d(isers 1hairman @ardner 0ckley, and ;ames Duesenberry. 4owler and *artin were members of the
1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
'nder $ecretary of !reasury Paul Aolcker (") a##ears before the $enate Banking subcommittee on $e#tember ,<, ,-/- to testify against a
bill to regulate ma3imum interest rates in loans charged by federally su#er(ised banks, which was introduced after the #rime rate rose to a
record 9.> #ercent. 0##earing with him are from left to right7 Preston *artin, 1hairman of 4ederal ome Loan Bank Board5 Eenneth "andall,
1hairman of 4ederal De#osit 8nsurance 1or#.5 William *c1hesney *artin, 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e5 and Aolcker.
(BettmannC1F"B8$)
Aice President "ichard =i3on chats with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman William *c1. *artin ;r. (second from right) at a dinner in =ew &ork 1ity in
,->>. "udol#h $mutny stands on the far left, and *organ @renfell #artner Aiscount William arcourt stands on the far right. "ichard =i3on
and William *c1. *artin ;r. were members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
Aice President ubert um#hrey, $ecretary of 1ommerce ;ohn !. 1onnor, 0ndrew Brimmer, and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman William
*c1hesney *artin ;r. a##ear at the White ouse on *arch -, ,-//. Brimmer was sworn in as a @o(ernor of the 4ederal "eser(e Board that
day. 0ll four men are or were members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
(Photo7 &oichi ". Fkamoto, Lyndon B. ;ohnson Presidential Library)
President Lyndon Baines ;ohnson (left) meets with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman William *c1hesney *artin ;r. (right) and 1ouncil
of Bconomic 0d(isers chairman Walter eller (center) at the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on ;anuary ,<, ,-/+. William
*c1hesney *artin ;r. was a member of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations, a #ri(ate organi2ation in =ew &ork 1ity. (0P Photo)
*embers of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem #ose for a grou# #ortrait in Washington, D.1. on *ay 9,
,-/:. 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman William *c1hesney *artin ;r. a##ears in the foreground. Fther members, from left to right,
are7 seated Q ;.L. "obertson, Aice 1hairman5 ;. Dewey Daane5 and @eorge W. *itchell5 standing Q $herman ;. *aisel, 0ndrew
4. Brimmer, and William W. $herrill. (0P Photo)
President Lyndon B. ;ohnson watches 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman William *c1hesney *artin ;r. administer the oath of office to 0ndrew
Brimmer, the incoming member of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem, at the White ouse on *arch -, ,-//. !he woman
is *rs. Brimmer, and the child is Bsther Brimmer. William *c1hesney *artin ;r. was a member of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
(Photo7 "obert EnudsenCLyndon B. ;ohnson Library)
0rthur 4. Burns Bra (,-:<-,-:9)
"e#ublican Party #residential candidate "ichard =i3on (center) meets with 0rthur 4. Burns (6
nd
right) and economics #rofessor *ilton
4riedman (second from left) on Fctober ,,, ,-/9. '.$. President "ichard =i3on a##ointed 0rthur 4. Burns as the 1hairman of the 4ederal
"eser(e in ,-:<.
Futgoing 4ederal "eser(e chairman 0rthur 4. Burns (left), '.$. President ;immy 1arter (6
nd
left), and incoming 4ederal "eser(e chairman @.
William *iller (6
nd
right) #ose for a #ortrait. (0ssociated Press5 Photogra#her7 Barry !humma)
President @erald 4ord meets with international bankers at the White ouse in ,-:> to discuss the Ofiscal crisisP of =ew &ork 1ity. 4rom left to
right7 L. William $eidman, ;.P. *organ 1hairman Bllmore 1. Patterson, 1iticor# 1hairman Walter Wriston, !reasury $ecretary William $imon,
@erald 4ord, 1hase *anhattan Bank 1hairman and 1BF Da(id "ockefeller, and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0rthur Burns. B(eryone in this
#hoto e3ce#t for L. William $eidman is or was a member of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. Da(id "ockefeller was a director of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew &ork at the time this #hoto was taken in ,-:>.
President ;immy 1arter signs the Windfall Profits !a3 Bill in Washington, D.1. on 0#ril 6, ,-9< as $enators and "e#resentati(es who hel#ed it
#ass look on. 0lso #resent is !reasury $ecretary and former 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman @. William *iller (far left). (Wally *c=ameeC1F"B8$)
/<our(e: !reenspan. The *an ehind *oney 1y 'ustin Martin0
*embers of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem #ose for a #ortrait in Washington, D.1. on *ay 6,, ,-:<. @rou#ings are
as follows7 4oreground7 1hairman 0rthur Burns5 background (left to right)7 ;.L. "obertson, (ice chairman5 $herman ;. *aisel5 ;. Dewey Daane5
0ndrew 4. Brimmer5 @eorge *itchell5 and *itchell W. $herrill. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
0rthur 4. Burns (left), 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, meets with former !e3as @o(ernor ;ohn 1onnally at a @eneral
0ssembly of the 8nternational *onetary 4und (8*4) in Washington, D.1. on $e#tember 6:, ,-:,. President "ichard =i3on
a##ointed ;ohn 1onnally as $ecretary of the !reasury the day after the meeting. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
Paul 0. Aolcker (left), the 'nder $ecretary of the !reasury for *onetary 0ffairs, $ecretary of the !reasury @eorge P. $hult2 (center),
and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0rthur 4. Burns (right) attend the international monetary meeting at Paris 1hateau de la *uette
on *arch ,/, ,-:., called in by the western worldIs wealthiest countries to sol(e the monetary crisis. 0ll three men are (or were)
members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
President @erald 4ord faces a formidable array of economic ad(isers during a meeting in the 1abinet "oom of the White ouse on 0ugust 6:,
,-:+. 0t the economic meeting are (left to right)7 L. William $eidman, chief #lanner for a economic summit conference held in $e#tember
,-:+5 ousing $ecretary ;ames !. Lynn5 0lan @reens#an, chairman of the 1ouncil of Bconomic 0d(isers5 !reasury $ecretary William $imon5
1ounselor Eenneth "ush5 Budget Director "oy 0sh5 0rthur Burns, 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem5 and President 4ord.
(BettmannC1F"B8$)
President @erald 4ord meets with his ad(isers in a secret meeting in the 1abinet "oom on 0#ril 69, ,-:>. 1lockwise from left to right7 4ederal
"eser(e Board 1hairman 0rthur Burns, !reasury $ecretary William $imon, Aice President =elson "ockefeller, F*B Director ;ames !. Lynn,
Domestic 1ouncil Director ;ames 1annon, Domestic 1ouncil De#uty Director "ichard Dunham, De#uty 0ssistant Dick 1heney, BPB Director
Bill $eidman, 1ommerce $ecretary "ogers 1.B. *orton, @erald 4ord, F*B 0ssociate Director 4rank Rarb, and 1B0 1hairman 0lan
@reens#an. B(eryone e3ce#t for *orton, $eidman, and Dunham is or was a 14" member. (Photo7 @erald ". 4ord Library)
+ugust L! FH: 2Ni3on <ho(k9
*embers of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem #ose for a #ortrait in Washington, D.1. on *ay 6,, ,-:<. @rou#ings are
as follows7 4oreground7 1hairman 0rthur Burns5 background (left to right)7 ;.L. "obertson, (ice chairman5 $herman ;. *aisel5 ;. Dewey Daane5
0ndrew 4. Brimmer5 @eorge *itchell5 and *itchell W. $herrill. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
0rthur Burns (L), 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, meets with 4ormer !e3as @o(ernor ;ohn 1onnally at a @eneral 0ssembly of the
8nternational *onetary 4und (8*4) in Washington, D.1. on $e#tember 6:, ,-:,. President "ichard =i3on a##ointed ;ohn 1onnally as
$ecretary of the !reasury the day after the meeting. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
President "ichard =i3on meets with $ecretary of $tate William P. "ogers (left) and =ational $ecurity 0d(isor enry Eissinger (right) aboard 0ir
4orce Fne on ;uly ,9, ,-:,. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
President "ichard =i3on began a series of budget meetings at the White ouse on ;uly 6., ,-:,. 4rom left to right7 1as#er Weinberger,
De#uty Director of the Fffice of *anagement and Budget5 Paul *c1racken, 1hairman of the 1ouncil of Bconomic 0d(isors5 and !reasury
$ecretary ;ohn B. 1onnally, "ichard =i3on, and =ational $ecurity 0d(isor enry Eissinger. President "ichard =i3on and his financial ad(isors
Oclosed the gold windowP on 0ugust ,>, ,-:, by ending the con(ersion between the '.$. Dollar (O4ederal "eser(e =oteP) and gold.
(BettmannC1F"B8$)
!rading on the floor of the 0merican $tock B3change in =ew &ork 1ity on 0ugust ,/, ,-:, was at a record #ace following President "ichard
=i3onIs announcement on 0ugust ,>t, ,-:, of a new Oeconomic courseP for the nation to combat inflation. =i3on)s included a -<-day free2e on
wages and #rices, ta3 benefits and what amounted to an unofficial de(aluation of the dollar. (J BettmannC1F"B8$)
0n 0merican em#loyee re(iews co#ies of the O4ederal "eser(e =oteP at the Bureau of Bngra(ing and Printing in Washington, D.1. on Fctober
,9, ,-:,. Fn $unday 0ugust ,>, ,-:,, '.$. President "ichard =i3on scra##ed the gold e3change standard, in effect cancelling the ,-++
Bretton Woods agreement that set u# the 8nternational *onetary 4und (8*4), leading to the introduction of a ,<S ta3 on im#orts and a free2e
on #rices and 0merican salaries for three months. 0s a result, the #rinting of dollar notes accelerated at the Bureau of Bngra(ing and Printing
(BBP), em#loying .<<< #eo#le. Bach #late #asses a strict (isual control test and any faulty dollar #lates are subseDuently withdrawn and sent
to the basement to be burned under the su#er(ision of ins#ectors. (J ;P LaffontC$ygmaC1orbis)
President "ichard =i3on (third from right) meets with (left to right) retired '.$. 0rmy @eneral Lucius 1lay, !homas Dewey (former @o(ernor of
=ew &ork), Dean 0cheson (former '.$. $ecretary of $tate), ;ohn *c1loy (former 1hairman and 1BF of 1hase *anhattan Bank), and
=ational $ecurity 0d(isor enry Eissinger at the White ouse on December :, ,-:<. 1lay, Dewey, 0cheson, *c1loy, and Eissinger were
members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations in ,-:<. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
@eorge .W. Bush shares a light moment after he is sworn-in as the 'nited $tates "e#resentati(e to the 'nited =ations at the White ouse in
Washington, D.1. on 4ebruary 6/, ,-:,. 4rom left to right7 '.$. $u#reme 1ourt ;ustice Potter $tewart, Barbara Bush, @eorge .W. Bush, and
'.$. President "ichard *. =i3on. @eorge .W. Bush, Potter $tewart, and "ichard =i3on are (or were) members of the Bohemian @ro(e in
1alifornia. @eorge .W. Bush and Potter $tewart were members of $kull % Bones at &ale 'ni(ersity. @eorge .W. Bush)s father Prescott
$heldon Bush was a #artner of Brown Brothers arriman % 1o., an international banking firm in =ew &ork 1ity, in ,-:,.
(J "on $achsC1=PC1orbis)
West @ermany)s 1hancellor Willy Brandt (second from left) chats with Da(id "ockefeller (second from right), 1hairman and 1BF of 1hase
*anhattan Bank and 1hairman of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations, after a meeting was held at the arold Pratt ouse, headDuarters of the
1ouncil on 4oreign "elations, in =ew &ork 1ity on ;une ,9, ,-:,. 4rankfurt (am *ain) was the financial ca#ital of West @ermany in ,-:,5
4rankfurt continues to ser(e as @ermany)s banking city. Buro#ean 1entral Bank is located in 4rankfurt. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
Baron @uy de "othschild, President of the BanDue "othschild, is one of fi(e of the foremost figures in Buro#ean finance and industry to s#eak
and gi(e to# 0merican cor#orate leaders an insight into o##ortunities in Buro#e during a meeting at the Waldorf-0storia otel in =ew &ork 1ity
on December 6, ,-:<. !he theme of the s#eakers was H!he 1hallenge of Buro#e.H 0##ro3imately ,,<<< 0merican e3ecuti(es were e3#ected
to attend. !he gathering was s#onsored by The Financia! Times of "onon. (J BettmannC1F"B8$)
Paul Aolcker Bra (,-:--,-9:)
Aice President @eorge .W. Bush (1), a former director of the 1entral 8ntelligence 0gency, gi(es a thumbs-u# sign while meeting with
!reasury $ecretary Donald "egan (L) and 4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Paul Aolcker at the White ouse on ;anuary .,, ,-9+ to ratify
their agreement on a swee#ing #ro#osal to reorgani2e commercial bank regulating agencies. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
President "onald "eagan arri(es at the De#artment of the !reasury in Washington, D.1. on ;anuary 6., ,-9, for a luncheon with $ecretary of
the !reasury Donald "egan (center), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker (right), and other economic ad(isors. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker (left) and 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations chairman Peter @. Peterson eat at the arold
Pratt ouse. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker (left), *argaret Fsmer-*cTuade (center), and former President ;immy 1arter ha(e a
dinner at the arold Pratt ouse in c. ,-96. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker, left, confers with ;ohn 0shcroft, the @o(ernor of *issouri, before the o#ening general session of the
$outhern @o(ernors 0ssociation meeting in *iami, 4lorida on $e#tember -, ,-9>. (BettmannC1F"B8$)
4inance ministers of the maKor industriali2ed nations meet in the 'nited $tates of 0merica to discuss the international economy on $e#tember
66, ,-9>. 0ttending are from left to right7 4inance *inister @erhard $toltenberg of West @ermany, 4inance *inister Pierre Berego(oy of
4rance, '.$. !reasury $ecretary ;ames 0. Baker 888, '.$. 4ederal "eser(e Bank 1hairman Paul Aolcker, 4inance *inister =igel Lawson of
@reat Britain, and 4inance *inister =oboru !akeshita of ;a#an. Aolcker, $toltenberg, Berego(oy, and Lawson ha(e attended the Bilderberg
*eetings in the #ast. (J BettmannC1F"B8$)
0lan @reens#an Bra (,-9:-6<</)
President "onald "eagan a##ears with (left to right) 0lan @reens#an, 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker, and $ecretary of the !reasury
;ames 0. Baker 888 in the Press "oom at the White ouse on ;une 6, ,-9: as he announces the nomination of 0lan @reens#an as 1hairman
of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e Board. @reens#an, Aolcker, and Baker are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
(Photo7 "onald "eagan Presidential Library)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an is gi(en his honorary knighthood from Tueen Bli2abeth 88 of the 'nited Eingdom of @reat Britain
(left) at Balmoral castle in the $cottish ighlands on !hursday, $e#tember 6/, 6<<6 as 0lan @reens#an)s wife 0ndrea *itchell, a Kournalist for
=B1, stands at his side. $ir 0lan @reens#an and 0ndrea *itchell are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations5 $ir 0lan @reens#an and
0ndrea *itchell attended the 6<<6 Bilderberg *eetings in 1hantilly, Airginia together in *ay-;une 6<<6. (0P PhotoC Da(id 1heskin)
+lan .reenspan shakes hands with *resident Ronald Reagan at the &hite 7ouse as outgoing Federal Reserve Chairman *aul
,ol(ker stands ne3t to .reenspan% /*hoto: Ronald Reagan *residential Ci1rary0
/<our(e: !reenspan. The *an ehind *oney 1y 'ustin Martin0
President "onald "eagan holds an economic briefing with !reasury $ecretary ;ames 0. Baker 888, 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan
@reens#an, 1ouncil of Bconomic 0d(isers 1hairman Beryl $#rinkel, White ouse 1hief of $taff oward Baker, and Dan 1ri##en in the F(al
Fffice on 4ebruary ,<, ,-99. (Photo7 "onald "eagan Presidential Library)
(0PCWide World Photos5 $ource7 Back From the Brink: The Greenspan Years by $te(en E. Beckner)
President "onald "eagan attends an economic meeting with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an, White ouse 1hief of $taff oward
Baker, and !reasury $ecretary ;ames 0. Baker 888 in the West $itting all on Fctober 6<, ,-9:, a day after OBlack *ondayP, when the stock
markets crashed. 0lan @reens#an, oward Baker, and ;ames 0. Baker 888 are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
(Photo7 "onald "eagan Presidential Library)
=B1 Kournalist 0ndrea *itchell watches Aice President Dick 1heney (right) administer the oath of office to her husband $ir 0lan
@reens#an, the 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, in the home of former President @erald 4ord in Bea(er 1reek, 1olorado on
;une ,-, 6<<+. (Photo by Da(id BohrerCWhite ouse)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) shakes hands with '.$. President @eorge .W. Bush. eorge H.W. ,ush's gran#father
(an# former -... .enator &res+ott ,ush's father" .amuel &. ,ush was a Class , <ire+tor of the Fe#eral 6eser4e ,ank of Cle4elan#
from ()*/ to ()3>. (Photo7 Greenspan: The +an Behin +oney by ;ustin *artinC@eorge Bush Presidential Library)
$o(iet 1ommissar *ikhail @orbache(, President @eorge .W. Bush, and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an a##ear in a recei(ing
line at a state dinner in Washington, D.1. on *ay .,, ,--<. !his #hoto a##ears in the book The Age of Tur%u!ence: A,entures in a New
(or! by 0lan @reens#an. (Photo7 @eorge .W. Bush Presidential Library)
President Bill 1linton a##ears with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an at the White ouse.
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an, right, shakes hands with $enator illary "odham 1linton (D-=&) #rior to testifying
before the $enate Budget 1ommittee on 1a#itol ill on ;anuary 6>, 6<<,. (Photo by 0le3 WongC=ewsmakers)
'.$. $ecretary of the !reasury Lawrence $ummers (left), '.$. President Bill 1linton (center), and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an
meet at the White ouse on =o(ember ,6, ,--- after a new financial law was #assed by 1ongress. (J "on $achsC1=PC$ygmaC1orbis)
'.$. !reasury $ecretary ;ohn $now (1), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (L), and $ecurities and B3change 1hairman William
Donaldson confer during at a meeting of the PresidentIs Working @rou# on 4inancial *arkets at the !reasury De#artment in Washington, D.1.
on =o(ember ,+, 6<<.. (J '.$. !reasury De#artment andoutC"eutersC1orbis)
/<our(e: !reenspan. The *an ehind *oney 1y 'ustin Martin0
+lan .reenspan! the Federal Reserve Chairman! appears with Treasury <e(retary Ro1ert -% Ru1in! left! at a 7ouse hearing in
FFL% Both men were mem1ers of the Coun(il on Foreign Relations at the time this photo was taken%
President Bill 1linton meets with (from left to right) 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an, @ene $#erling, *artin =. Baily,
!reasury $ecretary Lawrence $ummers, and ;ohn Podesta on ;anuary +, 6<<<.
President @eorge W. Bush (left) and Aice President Dick 1heney listen to 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an. Dick
1heney and 0lan @reens#an are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (Washington PostCWhite ouseC0P Photo)
=ational Bconomic 1ouncil Director $te#hen 4riedman (right) watches President @eorge W. Bush talk with 4ederal "eser(e
Board 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) in the F(al Fffice on *ay ,9, 6<<+.
!reasury $ecretary ;ohn $now, $en. Lindsey @raham ("-$1), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an, and $en. 1harles
$chumer (D-=&) discuss #olicy on "ed 1hina trade during a meeting on 1a#itol ill on ;une .<, 6<<>.
(Photo by 0le3 WongC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman 0lan @reens#an discusses his #ending testimony with '.$. $enator illary "odham 1linton (D-=ew &ork)
and '.$. $enator Eit Bond ("-*issouri) before the '.$. $enate Budget 1ommittee meeting in Washington, D.1. on ;anuary 6>, 6<<,.
(J "on $achsC1=PC1orbis)
0lan @reens#an, 1hairman and Board of @o(ernors of 4ederal "eser(e $ystem, chats with 1hairman Paul $arbanes (D-*aryland), center,
and '$ $enator Bill =elson (D-4lorida) following @reens#anIs testimony before the '$ $enate Banking, ousing, 'rban 0ffairs 1ommittee in
Washington, D.1. on ;uly ,/, 6<<6. !he hearing focused on the 4ederal "eser(e BoardIs monetary #olicy re#ort.
(J "on $achsC1=PC1orbis $ygma)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an talks with $en. 1harles $chumer (D-=&) before a $enate Banking, ousing and
'rban 0ffairs 1ommittee hearing on 1a#itol ill on ;uly 6,, 6<<>. 0lan @reens#an is a member of the 1ouncil on 4oreign
"elations (14")5 1harles $chumer is a former 14" member. (Photo by *ark WilsonC@etty 8mages)
!reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin (left) and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an arri(e for hearings on 1a#itol ill on
*ay 6,, ,--9. (;amal 0. WilsonC04PC@etty 8mages)
/<our(e: !reenspan. The *an ehind *oney 1y 'ustin Martin0
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman 0lan @reens#an s#eaks during a luncheon meeting held by the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations
in Washington, D.1. on =o(ember ,-, 6<<6. (Photo by 0le3 WongC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an talks to !reasury $ecretary =icholas Brady in ,--<.
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an listens to !reasury $ecretary Lloyd Bentsen.
($ource7 Back From the Brink: The Greenspan Years by $te(en E. Beckner)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an Kokes with 1ongressman ;im Leach (left) and !reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin
(center) in ,---. 0ll three men are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
/<our(e: ack From the rink. The !reenspan Years 1y <teven B% Be(kner0
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (center) and *er(yn Eing (right), @o(ernor of !he Bank of Bngland, #ose with
1hancellor of the B3cheDuer @ordon Brown after collecting their honorary doctorate degrees in the #resence of !he Duke of
Bdinburgh on 4ebruary :, 6<<> in Bdinburgh, $cotland. @reens#an, Eing, and Brown ha(e attended the Bilderberg *eetings in
the #ast. (Photo by 1hristo#her 4urlongC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman 0lan @reens#an testifies as !reasury $ecretary Lawrence . $ummers looks on before the
Banking, ousing and 'rban 0ffairs 1ommittee in Washington D.1. on ;une 6,, 6<<<. (Photo by *ichael $mithC=ewsmakers)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (right) recei(es an honorary Doctor of 1ommercial $cience degree from =ew &ork
'ni(ersity President ;ohn $e3ton in =ew &ork 1ity on December ,+, 6<<>. @reens#an and $e3ton are members of the 1ouncil
on 4oreign "elations. (Photo by *ario !amaC@etty 8mages)
$ir 0lan @reens#an (left), the 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, shakes hands with @ordon Brown, 1hancellor of the B3cheDuer
of the 'nited Eingdom, after recei(ing honorary degrees from =ew &ork 'ni(ersity in =ew &ork 1ity on December ,+, 6<<>.
(Photo by *ario !amaC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an talks to Buro#ean 1entral Bank President ;ean-1laude !richet at the beginning of
the @6< finance ministers and central bank go(ernorsI meeting in Berlin, @ermany on =o(ember ,-, 6<<+. @reens#an and
!richet attended the 6<<6 Bilderberg *eetings in 1hantilly, Airginia, '.$.0. together in 6<<6.
(Photo by $ean @allu#C@etty 8mages)
4rom left to right7 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an, '.$. !reasury $ecretary ;ohn $now, (unidentified), Buro#ean
'nion 1entral Bank @o(ernor ;ean-1laude !richet, 8nternational *onetary 4und *anaging Director "odrigo de "ato, and World
Bank President ;ames D. Wolfensohn a##ear at the beginning of the @-: ministerial meeting on 0#ril ,/, 6<<> in Washington,
D.1. @reens#an, !richet, "odrigo de "ato, and Wolfensohn ha(e attended the Bilderberg *eetings in the #ast. (0P Photo)
!reasury $ecretary ;ames 0. Baker 888 (left) watches outgoing 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker shake hands with incoming 4ederal
"eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (right) in ;uly ,-9:.
"oger 4erguson (left), Aice 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, s#eaks with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an during a meeting of the
8nternational *onetary and 4inancial 1ommittee Board of @o(ernors at the 8nternational *onetary 4und Building in Washington, D.1. on
Fctober 6, 6<<+. (Photo by Brendan $mialowskiC@etty 8mages)
Left #hoto7 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an and 4ederal "eser(e Aice 1hairman "oger W. 4erguson #re#are for a
meeting.
"ight #hoto7 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an a##ears with President @eorge W. Bush.
4rench 4inance *inister =icolas $arko2y (right) meets with '$ 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Board 0lan @reens#an (L) at the
8nternational *onetary 4und building in Washington, D.1. on 0#ril 6+, 6<<+ !he leaders met during the 8*4 and World Bank @rou# 6<<+
$#ring *eetings. (=icholas "obertsC04PC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman 0lan @reens#an s#eaks to the #ress at the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on ;uly ,<, ,--, after being
rea##ointed by President Bush (") to a second four-year term. (J BettmannC1F"B8$)
($ource7 Back From the Brink: The Greenspan Years by $te(en E. Beckner)
1ongressman Dick @e#hardt and William ;. *cDonough, the President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork, are seen
laughing during a 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations meeting on *arch ., ,--9. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
($ource7 The Age of Tur%u!ence: A,entures in a New (or! by 0lan @reens#an)
;anet L. &ellen, the President of 4ederal "eser(e Bank of $an 4rancisco, and *ichael . *oskow, the President of 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of 1hicago, a##ear at the arold Pratt ouse in =ew &ork 1ity.
(Photo7 6<</ 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
!he 4ederal "eser(e Board in ,--/. 4ront row7 0lice "i(lin, 0lan @reens#an, ;anet &ellen. Back row7 Laurence . *eyer, $usan *. Philli#s,
Bdward O*ikeP Eelley ;r., and Lawrence B. Lindsay. "i(lin, @reens#an, and &ellen are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
Left #hoto7 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) and World Bank President ;ames Wolfensohn a##ear at a #arty together in ;une
6<<+. (Photo7 htt#7CCwww.washingtonlife.comCissuesC6<<+-</CbloombergC)
"ight #hoto7 Washington Post Kournalist ;im oagland and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an a##ear at a #arty in $e#tember 6<<>.
(0##eared in7 ;ane $tanton itchcock Book Partys on $e#tember 6<<>)
htt#7CCwww.washingtonlife.comCdirectoriesC#hotosC?letterU;%nameU;im-oagland
($ource7 Back From the Brink: The Greenspan Years by $te(en E. Beckner)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (right) shakes hands with 1ommunist 1hina)s President ;iang Remin as '.$.
President Bill 1linton is seen engaging in a con(ersation with ;iang during a White ouse state dinner in Washington, D.1. in
Fctober ,--:. (Photo7 !he =ew &ork !imesC"euters)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an listens to "ichard D. Parsons (left) as he s#eaks to 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations
members at the arold Pratt ouse on December /, ,--<. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
;essica !. *athews (left), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (center), and 4ranklin D. "aines a##ear at a 1ouncil on
4oreign "elations meeting on $e#tember ,:, ,--/. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
President of 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork B. @erald 1orrigan (left), 0lan @reens#an (center), and 8sidor "abi meet
#ri(ately at a 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations meeting. (1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
*artin 4eldstein (left) and 0lan @reens#an walk u# the stairs at the arold Pratt ouse.
(Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
Left #hoto7 0lan @reens#an and "obert A. "oosa sign their names in a ledger. "obert A. "oosa was a #artner of Brown
Brothers arriman % 1om#any, a banking firm in =ew &ork 1ity. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
"ight #hoto7 Da(id "ockefeller listens to enry 1. Wallich, *ember of the @o(ernor of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem, during a
meeting held at the arold Pratt ouse. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
elene D. @ayle, President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of 1hicago *ichael *oskow (center), and =orthwestern 'ni(ersity
President enry $. Bienen a##ear at a 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations meeting. 0ll three indi(iduals are members of the 1ouncil
on 4oreign "elations. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
William ;. *cDonough (left) was the President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork at the time this #hoto was taken.
0dmiral Aern 1lark was the 1hief of =a(al F#erations at the time this #hoto was taken.
(Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
Left #hoto7 B. @erald 1orrigan (left), the President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork, and 0ir 4orce 1hief of $taff @en.
Larry D. Welch smile for the camera at the arold Pratt ouse in =ew &ork 1ity on December :, ,-9-.
(Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
"ight #hoto7 1itibank 1hairman Walter Wriston (left) and 0lan @reens#an are seen laughing during a 1ouncil on 4oreign
"elations meeting. (Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left), 0ndrea *itchell (center), and !reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin laugh together in ,--/.
Left #hoto7 Paula Dobriansky talks to 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an at a meeting on ;anuary ,-, ,---.
"ight #hoto7 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an listens to 0merican 8nternational @rou# 1hairman and 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations
Aice 1hairman *aurice @reenberg at a 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations meeting in ;uly 6<<<.
(Both #hotos from the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
enry Eissinger (left) s#eaks with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an in Philadel#hia on *ay 6<, 6<<+.
(Photo by William !homas 1ainC@etty 8mages)
4irst De#uty *anaging Director of the 8nternational *onetary 4und $tanley 4ischer (left), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan
@reens#an (center), and 8nternational *onetary 4und *anaging Director *ichel 1amdessus ha(e a #ri(ate con(ersation at a
meeting on $e#tember 6/, ,---. 0lan @reens#an and $tanley 4ischer are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
$tanley 4ischer is currently the @o(ernor of the Bank of 8srael.
@erman 1hancellor 0ngela *erkel (1) with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) and former '.$. $ecretary of $tate 1olin Powell
(right) during a rece#tion at the @erman Bmbassy in Washington, D.1. on ;anuary ,6, 6<</. (J @'8DF BB"@*0== CPFFLCBP0C1orbis)
;a#anese Prime *inister ;unichiro Eoi2umi (") shakes hands with '.$. 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an before their talks at the
#rime ministerIs official residence in !okyo, ;a#an on Fctober ,:, 6<<>. Eoi2umi and @reens#an discussed macroeconomic and financial
issues on *onday, a senior finance ministry official said. (J Ea2uhiro =ogiCPoolC"eutersC1orbis)
'.$. 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (L) meets with Bank of ;a#an (BF;) @o(ernor !oshihiko 4ukui at BF; headDuarters in
!okyo, ;a#an on Fctober ,:, 6<<>. @reens#an was in !okyo for a two-day (isit. (J 8$$B8 E0!FC"eutersC1orbis)
'.$. 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (L) s#eaks with Peo#leIs Bank of 1hina @o(ernor Rhou Viaochuan during a @-6< finance
ministers and central bank go(ernors meeting in Vianghe, 1ommunist 1hina in ebei #ro(ince, about ,<< kms (/6 miles) east of BeiKing on
Fctober ,>, 6<<>. 1ommunist 1hina)s President u ;intao, under #ressure from Washington to let the yuan rise faster, said on $aturday
during the o#ening ceremony of the meeting that maKor countries had an obligation to kee# their currencies reasonably steady for the sake of
the world economy. (J 0lfred 1heng ;inC"eutersC1orbis)
!reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin (left), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (center), and 1ommunist 1hina)s Premier Rhu "ongKi
#ose for #ress #hotogra#hers at Blair ouse in Washington, D.1. on 0#ril -, ,---. (Photo7 0le3 WongC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) shakes hands with "ed 1hina)s 1ommissar u ;intao during a meeting with leaders
of the :th @-6< 4inance *inisters and 1entral Bank @o(ernors inside the @reat all of the Peo#le in BeiKing, 1ommunist 1hina on Fctober >,
6<<>. (Photo by ;ason Lee-PoolC@etty 8mages)
!his #hoto a##ears in the book The Age of Tur%u!ence: A,entures in a New (or! by 0lan @reens#an.
;iang Remin (left), the 1ommissar of 1ommunist 1hina, entertains Aice 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e 0lice "i(lin (wearing a
red dress) and !reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin (right) at a tem#le in BeiKing on $e#tember 6/, ,--:. Both 0lice "i(lin and
"obert "ubin were members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations at the time this #hoto was taken on $e#tember 6/, ,--:.
(Photo by *ike 4iala)
4ormer 1hairman of 1hase *anhattan Bank Da(id "ockefeller (left), former !reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin (center), and
President of 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork William ;. *cDonough meet #ri(ately at the arold Pratt ouse. !his #hoto
a##ears on the back co(er of the 6<<< 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort.
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an has a meeting with 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 1hairman Peter @. Peterson.
(Photo7 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort)
World Bank President ;ames Wolfensohn (left) greets 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an before their meeting at the
World Bank in Washington D.1 on 0#ril 6-, ,---. (;oyce =altchayanC04PC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left), 4ederal "eser(e Aice 1hairman 0lice "i(lin (center), and World Bank
President ;ames Wolfensohn talk together before the start of 8nternational *onetary 4und (8*4) 8nterim 1ommittee meetings at
the 8*4 in Washington, D.1. on 0#ril 69, ,---. (*ario !amaC04PC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an leans o(er to chat with '.$. Labor $ecretary Blaine 1hao before he addressed the =ational
$ummit on "etirement $a(ings at a Washington D.1. hotel on 4ebruary 69, 6<<6. President @eorge W. Bush addressed the summit following
@reens#an. ("B'!B"$CEe(in LamarDue)
!reasury $ecretary ;ohn $now (L) and 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e 0lan @reens#an ha(e a laugh during the un(eiling of the new G6<
bills at the '.$. Bureau of Bngra(ing and Printing in Washington, D.1. on *ay ,., 6<<.. !he new bill, to be issued this autumn, has enhanced
security features and subtle background colors as #art of an ongoing effort to stay ahead of the counterfeiting of '.$. currency.
("B'!B"$CEe(in LamarDue)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) and ;ean-1laude !richet, President of the Buro#ean 1entral Bank (B1B),
attend the,+th 4rankfurt Buro#ean Banking 1ongress (BB1) in 4rankfurt, @ermany on =o(ember ,-, 6<<+.
(Photo by "al#h FrlowskiC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (center) meets with Buro#ean 1entral Bank President ;ean-1laude !richet (right)
and Bank of Bngland @o(ernor *er(yn Eing at the beginning of the @6< finance ministers and central bank go(ernorsI meeting
in Berlin on =o(ember ,-, 6<<+. 0ll three men ha(e attended the Bilderberg *eetings at least once.
(Photo by $ean @allu#C@etty 8mages)
1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e 0lan @reens#an (L) and @reat BritainIs Duke of Bdinburgh stand outside the *cBwan all in Bdinburgh,
$cotland, @reat Britain after attending an award ceremony on 4ebruary :, 6<<>. @reens#an recei(ed a onorary Degree from the 'ni(ersity of
Bdinburgh. (J ;B44 ; *8!1BLLC"eutersC1orbis)
Lawrence $ummers (far left) watches 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an shake hands with $ecretary of the !reasury "obert "ubin
at a conference held in Washington, D.1. in $e#tember ,--9. (J *ark PetersonC1F"B8$)
'.$. President @eorge W. Bush (") awards his Presidential *edal of 4reedom to former 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e 0lan @reens#an at
a ceremony in the Bast "oom of the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on =o(ember -, 6<<>. Bush #resented the highest ci(il award
recogni2ing e3ce#tional meritorious ser(ice to ,+ honorees from the s#ort, entertainment and #olitical world at the ceremony.
(J ;0$F= "BBDC"eutersC1orbis)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (L) and World Bank President Paul Wolfowit2 attend a @: ministers working lunch at the !reasury
De#artment in Washington, D.1. on $e#tember 6., 6<<>. (J &'"8 @"8P0$C"eutersC1orbis)
$ecretary of Defense Donald . "umsfeld (right) congratulates 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) after awarding
him the De#artment of Defense *edal for Distinguished Public $er(ice at the Pentagon in 0rlington, Airginia on ;anuary 6.,
6<</. (Photo7 '.$. De#artment of DefenseCPetty Ffficer ,st 1lass 1had ;. *c=eeley, '.$. =a(y)
Ben Bernanke Bra (6<</-6<,+)
President Barack Fbama meets with !reasury $ecretary !imothy @eithner (left) and 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Ben Bernanke (right) in
the "oose(elt "oom of the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on ;une ,:, 6<<-. ("euters)
'.$. President Barack Fbama shakes hands with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (left) after nominating Bernanke for a second term
in Fak Bluffs, *assachusetts on the island of *arthaIs Aineyard on 0ugust 6>, 6<<-. ("euters)
President Barack Fbama (center) s#eaks during an economic daily meeting in the 1abinet "oom of the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on
*arch 6., 6<<-. L-" with the President are7 Larry $ummers, head of the White ouse Bconomic 1ouncil, 1ouncil of Bconomic 0d(isers 1hief
1hristina "omer, !reasury $ecretary !imothy @eihtner, Fbama, 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke and 4D81 1hairman $heila 1. Bair.
(@etty 8mages)
Ffficials listen as '.$. President Barack Fbama s#eaks at the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on ;une ,:, 6<<-. 4rom left to right7
1ongressman Barney 4rank (D-*0), $enator Dick Durbin (D-8L), $enator 1hris Dodd (D-1!), Director of the Fffice of *anagement and
Budget Peter Frs2ag, !reasury $ecretary !im @eithner, Director of the =ational Bconomic 1ouncil Lawrence $ummers and 4ederal "eser(e
Board 1hairman Ben Bernanke. Barney 4rank, 1hris Dodd, Peter Frs2ag, !im @eithner, and Lawrence $ummers are (or were) members of
the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. ("euters)
Lawrence $ummers (left), Director of =ational Bconomic 1ouncil, s#eaks with Ben Bernanke, 1hairman of the Board of
@o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e, before President Barack Fbama s#eaks on the economy and com#rehensi(e #lan for
financial regulations in the Bast "oom at the White ouse in Washington, D.1., on ;une ,:, 6<<-. Lawrence $ummers and Ben
Bernanke attended the Bilderberg *eetings in 1hantilly, Airginia in ;une 6<<9. (@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Ben $. Bernanke (left) shakes hands with 4ederal "eser(e Board @o(ernor Daniel E. !arullo, as his wife
Louisa B. !arullo looks on during the swearing-in ceremony in Washington, D.1. on ;anuary 69, 6<<-. !arullo on Wednesday took the oath of
office as a member of the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem to fill an une3#ired term ending ;anuary .,, 6<66. ("euters)
President-elect Barack Fbama shakes hands with Daniel !arullo after introducing him as his selection to the 4ederal "eser(e Board of
@o(ernors during a #ress conference at the Drake otel in 1hicago, 8llinois on December ,9, 6<<9. Daniel !arullo is a member of the 1ouncil
on 4oreign "elations. (@etty 8mages)
'$ President @eorge W. Bush (6nd left) looks at the 1hairman of the President)s Working @rou# on 4inancial *arkets, !reasury
$ecretary enry Paulson (6nd right), as he s#eaks following a meeting with the @rou# in the "oose(elt "oom of the White
ouse in Washington, D.1. on ;anuary +, 6<<9. Looking on from left are Aice President Dick 1heney and 4ederal "eser(e
1hairman Ben Bernanke. (04PC@etty 8mages)
'.$. !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (left), 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (center) and President and 1BF of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of =ew &ork !imothy 4. @eithner listen as 4D81 1hairman $heila Bair (not #ictured) s#eaks at the !reasury De#artment 1ash
"oom in Washington, D.1. on Fctober ,+, 6<<9. Paulson announced the !reasury De#artmentIs #lan to take eDuity stakes in #otentially
thousands of banks totaling about G6>< billion. 0ll three men attended the 6<<9 Bilderberg *eetings in 1hantilly, Airginia in ;une 6<<9.
("euters)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (right) s#eaks with committee chairman '.$. 1ongressman Barney 4rank before gi(ing testimony to
the ouse 4inancial 1ommittee on 1a#itol ill in Washington, D.1. on ;uly 6,, 6<<-. (@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (center) s#eaks to the $enate Banking, ousing and 'rban 0ffairs 1ommittee 1hairman $en.
1hristo#her Dodd (left) and "anking *ember $en. "ichard $helby as he arri(es to testify before the committee on 1a#itol ill in Washington,
D.1. on ;uly 66, 6<<-. ("euters)
President @eorge W. Bush (left) looks on as 4ederal "eser(e Aice 1hairman "oger W. 4erguson, ;r. (center) administers the oath of office,
during the swearing-in ceremony for Ben Bernanke (right) as the new 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, while BernankeIs wife, 0nna
Bernanke, holds a bible at the 4ederal "eser(e in Washington, D.1. on 4ebruary /, 6<</. (Photo by ;ay L. 1lendenin-PoolC@etty 8mages)
President @eorge W. Bush (left) looks on as 4ederal "eser(e Aice 1hairman "oger W. 4erguson, ;r., (6nd left) administers the oath of office,
during the swearing-in ceremony for Ben Bernanke, (6nd right) as the new 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank , while BernankeIs wife,
0nna holds a bible, at the 4ederal "eser(e Bank in Washington, D.1. on 4ebruary /, 6<</. 4ormer 1hairman of 4ederal "eser(e Board 0lan
@reens#an (right) looks on during the ceremony. (Photo by ;ay L. 1lendenin-PoolC@etty 8mages)
President @eorge W. Bush nominates Ben Bernanke (right) to succeed 0lan @reens#an (left) as 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman on
Fctober 6+, 6<<>. (Photo by *ark WilsonC@etty 8mages)
'.$. President @eorge W. Bush (1), flanked by '.$. !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (right) and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke
(left) and also followed by $B1 1hairman 1hristo#her 1o3, arri(e for a statement in the "ose @arden at the White ouse for an
announcement on a federal go(ernment #lan to try and shore u# failing financial markets on $e#tember ,-, 6<<9. !he #lan would attem#t to
stabili2e money market mutual funds, absorb bad debt held by mortgage com#anies, and ban short selling of financial com#any stocks.
(@etty 8mages)
'.$. President @eorge W. Bush (6nd left), flanked by (left to right) 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke, '.$. !reasury
$ecretary enry Paulson and $B1 1hairman 1hristo#her 1o3, announces a #lan by the federal go(ernment to try and shore u#
failing financial markets in Washington, D.1. on $e#tember ,-, 6<<9. !he #lan would attem#t to stabili2e money market mutual
funds, absorb bad debt held by mortgage com#anies, and ban short selling of financial com#any stocks. (@etty 8mages)
President @eorge W. Bush s#eaks about the economy in the "ose @arden of the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on
$e#tember ,-, 6<<9. 4rom left to right are7 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Ben Bernanke, Bush, '.$. $ecretary of the
!reasury enry Paulson, and $B1 1hairman 1hristo#her 1o3. ("euters)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (center) s#eaks ne3t to !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (left) and ouse $#eaker
=ancy Pelosi after their meeting with other congressional leaders in the '.$. 1a#itol in Washington, D.1. on $e#tember ,9,
6<<9. ("euters)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (.rd left) and !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (+th left) attend a closed meeting
with '.$. ouse $#eaker =ancy Pelosi (Democrat-1alifornia) (.rd right), '.$. 1ongressman "ahm Bmanuel (left, Democrat-
8llinois), '.$. $enator 1hristo#her Dodd (/
th
left), and other congressional leaders in the '.$. 1a#itol in Washington, D.1. on
$e#tember ,9, 6<<9. ("euters)
!reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (left) talks to 4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Ben Bernanke before testifying with
$ecurities and B3change 1ommission 1hairman 1hristo#her 1o3 (right) at the $enate Banking, ousing and 'rban 0ffairs
1ommittee on 1a#itol ill in Washington, D.1. on ;uly ,>, 6<<9. 8n light of recent bank failures and the housing crisis, the
financial leaders testified about the rescue of 4annie *ae and 4reddie *ac, the nationIs largest mortgage buyers, and #ro#osed
regulatory res#onses. (@etty 8mages)
'.$. !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (left) rubs his eyes as he and 4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Ben Bernanke (right)
testify at a hearing of the ouse 4inancial $er(ices 1ommittee on 1a#itol ill in Washington, D.1. on ;uly ,<, 6<<9. enry
Paulson and Ben Bernanke attended the 6<<9 Bilderberg *eetings conference held in 1hantilly, Airginia in ;une 6<<9. ("euters)
!imothy @eithner (left), President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork, and 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke
(right) use na#kins during lunch at the Bconomic 1lub of =ew &ork in =ew &ork 1ity on Fctober ,>, 6<<9.
(0ssociated PressC*ark Lennihan)
Left #hoto7 !his #hoto, #ro(ided by the 4ederal "eser(e, shows Ben Bernanke, right, sworn in as the ,+th 1hairman of the
4ederal "eser(e Board by Aice 1hairman "oger 4erguson ;r. (Britt Leckman C 4ederal "eser(e $ystem (ia 0P)
"ight #hoto7 ;ohn Li#sky (left), the 1hief Bconomist of ;P *organ 1hase, listen to ;anet &ellen, the President of the 4ederal
"eser(e Bank of $an 4rancisco. ;ohn Li#sky and ;anet &ellen are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (left), !im @eithner (center), the President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork,
and 4ederal "eser(e Aice 1hairman Donald Eohn take a walk for a #hoto o##ortunity during the 0nnual Bconomic $ym#osium
in ;ackson ole on Wyoming on 0ugust 66, 6<<9. ("euters)
=ew &ork 4ederal "eser(e President !im @eithner (left), 4ederal "eser(e Aice 1hairman Donald Eohn (center), and 4ederal
"eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke take a walk during the 0nnual Bconomic $ym#osium in ;ackson ole, Wyoming on 0ugust
66, 6<<9. @eithner and Bernanke attended the 6<<9 Bilderberg *eetings conference held in 1hantilly, Airginia near
Washington, D.1. from ;une >-9, 6<<9. ("euters)
$ecurities and B3change 1ommission 1hairman 1hristo#her 1o3 (left) and !imothy @eithner (right), the President of the 4ederal "eser(e
Bank of =ew &ork, listen during a hearing before the ouse 4inancial $er(ices 1ommittee on 1a#itol ill in Washington, D.1. on ;uly 6+,
6<<9. !he hearing was focused on H4inancial *arket "egulatory "estructuring.H (@etty 8mages)
0lan @reens#an ("), former 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, shakes hands with current 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben
Bernanke at a rece#tion to celebrate the 6<th anni(ersary of !he 8nternational Bconomy maga2ine at the ay-0dams otel in
Washington, D.1. on Fctober ,9, 6<<:. ;ean-1laude !richet, President of the Buro#ean 1entral Bank, was honored as 6<<:
#olicymaker of the year. (@etty 8mages)
President of the Buro#ean 1entral Bank ;ean-1laude !richet (center) stands with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke
(right) and former 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (left) during a #arty in !richetIs honor at the ay 0dams otel in
Washington, D.1. on Fctober ,9, 6<<:. (!im $loanC04PC@etty 8mages)
Buro#ean 1entral Bank 1hairman ;ean-1laude !richet (left), former 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul 0. Aolcker (center), and
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke attend the 8nternational Banking $eminar on *onday, Fctober 66, 6<<:.
($ource7 @rou# of !hirty)
8nternational bankers #artici#ate in the 8nternational Banking $eminar meeting on *onday, Fctober 66, 6<<:. 4ederal "eser(e
1hairman Ben Bernanke is seated on the far right. (Photo7 @rou# of !hirty)
!imothy @eithner, President of the =ew &ork 4ederal "eser(e Bank, s#eaks at the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations in =ew &ork
1ity on ;anuary ,,, 6<<:. (Photogra#her7 Daniel 0ckerCBloomberg =ews)
!imothy 4. @eithner (left) was the President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork at the time this #hoto was taken. B.
@erald 1orrigan is a former President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork. !his #hoto was #ublished in the 6<<: 1ouncil
on 4oreign "elations 0nnual "e#ort.
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (left) recei(es the 1olumbia Business $chool Distinguished Leader in @o(ernment
award at the Waldorf-0storia in =ew &ork 1ity on *ay >, 6<<9. ("euters)
Prime *inister of @reat Britain @ordon Brown meets with Ben Bernanke, 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, before a breakfast
meeting at the British Bmbassy in Washington, D.1. on 0#ril ,9, 6<<9. (1rown co#yrightC4lickr)
Britain)s Prime *inister @ordon Brown (left) greets 4ederal "eser(e Bank 1hairman Ben Bernanke at ,< Downing $treet in
London on ;anuary ,., 6<<-. ("euters)
Britain)s Prime *inister @ordon Brown (L) greets 4ederal "eser(e chairman Ben Bernanke at ,< Downing $treet, in London on
;anuary ,., 6<<-. (04PC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (left) greets 1ommunist 1hina)s Aice Premier Wang Tishan in Washington, D.1. on ;uly 6-, 6<<-.
("euters)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (left) shakes hands with Rhou Viaochuan (right), @o(ernor of the Peo#le)s Bank of 1hina, before a
meeting with 1ommunist 1hinaIs Aice Premier Wang Tishan (center) at the conclusion of the '.$.-1hina $trategic and Bconomic Dialogue, in
Washington, D.1. on ;uly 6-, 6<<-. (0P Photo)
!he @-: central bank go(ernors stand together for a #ortrait in Washington D.1. on 0#ril ,., 6<<:. 4rom left to right7 Da(id
Dodge of 1anada, 1hristian =oyer of 4rance, 03el Weber of @ermany, 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke of the 'nited
$tates, *ario Draghi of 8taly, !oshihiko 4ukui of ;a#an, *er(yn Eing of the 'nited Eingdom, and ;ean-1laude !richet of the
Buro#ean 1entral Bank, and World Bank President Paul Wolfowit2. (Photo by Brendan $mialowskiC@etty 8mages)
4rom left to right7 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke, $ecurities and B3change 1ommission ($B1) 1hairman
1hristo#her 1o3, 'nder $ecretary of !reasury for Domestic 4inance "obert $teel, and the President of the 4ederal "eser(e
Bank of =ew &ork !imothy @eithner testify before the $enate Banking 1ommittee hearing on the go(ernment bailout of Bear
$tearns on 1a#itol ill in Washington, D.1. on 0#ril ., 6<<9. '.$. senators e3#ressed concern that billions of dollars in ta3#ayer
funds has been #ut on the line to back last monthIs emergency takeo(er of troubled in(estment bank Bear $tearns.
(04PC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Ben Bernanke (left) talks to ;ean-1laude !richet, President of the Buro#ean 1entral Bank (B1B), during the
@: summit in Bssen, @ermany on 4ebruary ,<, 6<<:. !he @: finance ministers and central bank go(ernors discussed the de(elo#ment of
global economy for 6<<:. (Photo by "al#h FrlowskiC@etty 8mages)
Buro#ean 1entral Bank President ;ean-1laude !richet (L) s#eaks alongside ;acob 4renkel from the 0merican 8nternational @rou# (6nd L),
Deutsche Bundesbank 1hairman 03el Weber (6nd ") and '.$. 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke, at a rece#tion where !richet was
#resented with the H6<<: Policymaker of the &earH award, gi(en out by an international economy maga2ine, in Washington, D.1. on Fctober
,9, 6<<:. ("euters)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben $. Bernanke is seen lea(ing the 6<<9 Bilderberg *eetings at the Westfields *arriott otel in
1hantilly, Airginia, '.$.0., located near the Dulles 8nternational 0ir#ort, on $unday, ;une 9, 6<<9.
Donald Eohn, Aice 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, reacts to a Duestion during a s#eech at the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations
in =ew &ork 1ity on =o(ember 69, 6<<:. Eohn said that recent financial turbulence has re(ersed some of the im#ro(ement seen
in markets in #re(ious weeks, and could sDuee2e credit for households and businesses. (0ssociated PressC*ark Lennihan)
4ormer Bconomic 1lub of =ew &ork 1hairmen William ;. *cDonough (left) and Peter @. Peterson (center) #ose with @uest of onor !imothy
4. @eithner at the @rand yatt otel in =ew &ork 1ity on ;une -, 6<<9. William ;. *cDonough ser(ed as President of the 4ederal "eser(e
Bank of =ew &ork from ,--. to 6<<.. !imothy 4. @eithner ser(ed as President of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork from 6<<. to 6<<-.
Peter @. Peterson ser(ed as the 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork from 6<<< to 6<<.. (Photo7 Bconomic 1lub of =ew &ork)
!he 4ederal "eser(e Fne-4inger $alute7 4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Ben Bernanke testifies before the $enate Banking 1ommittee on
1a#itol ill in Washington, D.1. on ;uly 66, 6<<-. (@etty 8mages)
President @eorge W. Bush (6nd ") laughs with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke ("), $ecretary of the !reasury enry
Paulson (1), $ecurities and B3change 1ommission 1hairman 1hristo#her 1o3 (6nd L) and others during a meeting with the
PresidentIs Working @rou# on 4inancial *arkets at the White ouse on *arch ,:, 6<<9. enry Paulson is a member of the
1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (04PC@etty 8mages)
Ben Bernanke (1), 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, #oses for a #hoto with *er(yn Eing (L), @o(ernor of the Bank of Bngland,
and ;ean-1laude !richet, President of the Buro#ean 1entral Bank, during the @: meeting in !okyo, ;a#an on 4ebruary -, 6<<9.
("euters)
!reasury $ecretary !imothy @eithner (L) looks at his watch at the beginning of his meeting with 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke in
the $ecretary)s office at the !reasury De#artment in Washington, D.1. on *ay :, 6<<-. ("euters)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (L) testifies with Paul Aolcker, 1hairman of the PresidentIs Bconomic "eco(ery 0d(isory Board,
during a ouse 4inancial $er(ices 1ommittee hearing on 1a#itol ill in Washington, D.1. on *arch ,:, 6<,<. (@etty 8mages)
'.$. President Barack Fbama (1) s#eaks alongside 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (L) and !reasury $ecretary !imothy @eithner
(") during the Bconomic Daily Briefing in the F(al Fffice of the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on ;une 6-, 6<,<. (@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Ben Bernanke (1) #oses with board members at a two-day meeting of the 4ederal F#en *arket 1ommittee,
the 4ederal "eser(eIs interest rate-setting body, in Washington, D.1. in this *arch ,:, 6<<- #icture released on *arch ,-, 6<<-. !he 4ederal
"eser(e on Wednesday announced the #urchase of longer-dated !reasury securities to hel# end a dee#ening '.$. "ecession. 4ront row (left
to right)7 @o(ernor Bli2abeth Duke, @o(ernor Ee(in Warsh, 1hairman Bernanke, Aice 1hairman Donald Eohn, @o(ernor Daniel !arullo. Back
row (left to right)7 =ew &ork 4ed President William Dudley, Boston 4ed President Bric "osengren, $t. Louis 4ed President ;ames Bullard,
1hicago 4ed President 1harles B(ans, Eansas 1ity 4ed President !homas oenig, Dallas 4ed President "ichard 4isher, *innea#olis 4ed
President @ary $tern, 1le(eland 4ed President $andra Pianalto, 0tlanta 4ed President Dennis Lockhart, Philadel#hia 4ed President 1harles
Plosser, "ichmond 4ed President ;effrey Lacker, and $an 4rancisco 4ed President ;anet &ellen. <aniel $arullo, <ennis Lo+khart, 6i+har#
Fisher, an# Janet ;ellen are members of the Coun+il on Foreign 6elations. (J oC"eutersC1orbis)
William 1. Dudley, President and 1hief B3ecuti(e Ffficer of the 4ederal "eser(e Bank of =ew &ork, s#eaks at the 1ouncil on 4oreign
"elations in =ew &ork 1ity on *ay 6+, 6<,6. ("euters)
With the !eton *ountains behind them, 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke (left) and Bank of 8srael @o(ernor $tanley 4ischer (right)
walk together outside of the ;ackson ole Bconomic $ym#osium at @rand !eton =ational Park near ;ackson ole, Wyoming, '.$.0. on 4riday
0ugust .,, 6<,6. (Photo7 !ed $. WarrenC0P)
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben <% Bernanke /left0 appears with Timothy F% .eithner! *resident of the Federal Reserve Bank of
New York% /+ndrew 7arrer@Bloom1erg News0
President Barack Fbama (left) a##lauds after announcing his nomination of ;anet &ellen (center) to ser(e as the ne3t chairman of the 4ederal
"eser(e as outgoing 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Ben Bernanke stands by at the White ouse in Washington, D.1. on Fctober -, 6<,..
(Pablo *artine2 *onsi(aisC0ssociated Press)
President Barack Fbama shakes hands with ;anet &ellen (left), Aice 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, in the $tate Dining "oom of the White
ouse in Washington, D.1. on Fctober -, 6<,.. Fbama a##ointed &ellen to ser(e as the ne3t 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, succeeding
Ben Bernanke. ;anet &ellen is a member of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (Photo7 1harles Dhara#akC0ssociated Press)
Ben $. Bernanke lea(es the Board of @o(ernors of the 4ederal "eser(e $ystem on ;anuary .,, 6<,+ after eight years as its
1hairman. (Photo7 4ederal "eser(e)
E=tra hotos o" au! Ho!,4%r F A!an ?r%%ns$an
$ir 0lan @reens#an (left) and Paul Aolcker (right) share a laugh while #artici#ating in a #anel discussion on ca#ital markets at
@eorgetown 'ni(ersity in Washington, D.1. on *arch ,., 6<<:. Both men once ser(ed as 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e.
@reens#an and Aolcker are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Ben Bernanke (L) talks with former chairman of the 4ederal "eser(e 0lan @reens#an (") at a cocktail #arty
hosted by 8nternational Bconomy *aga2ine, in Washington, D.1. on Fctober ,9, 6<<:. (J $tefan RaklinCBP0C1orbis)
Left to right7 4ormer 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an, former '.$. $u#reme 1ourt ;ustice $andra Day F)1onnor, '.$. $u#reme
1ourt ;ustice Da(id $outer, $te#hen Breyer, @eorgetown 'ni(ersity President ;ohn ;. De@ioia, and @eorgetown Law Dean 0le3 0leinikoff
stand together for a grou# #ortrait at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity Law 1enter in Washington, D.1. on Fctober 6, 6<<9.
(Photo7 @eorgetown 'ni(ersity Law 1enter)
B. @erald 1orrigan (left) and ;ames Wolfensohn (right) celebrate as Paul Aolcker holds a #laDue. 0ll three men are members of
the Bretton Woods 1ommittee.
Paul Aolcker (left), $tanley 4ischer (center, red tie), and William ;. *cDonough (right) ha(e attended the Bilderberg *eetings in
the #ast.
Paul Aolcker shakes hands with 'nited =ations $ecretary-@eneral Eofi 0nnan.
!rilateral 1ommission members Peter $utherland, $adako Fgata, Rbigniew Br2e2inski, Paul Aolcker, and Da(id "ockefeller
smile for the camera at a #arty on December ,, ,--9.
Left to right7 !reasury $ecretary ;ames 0. Baker 888, retiring 4ederal "eser(e Board 1hairman Paul 0. Aolcker, and '.$. $ecretary of $tate
@eorge P. $hult2 #ose for a #hoto in ;uly ,-9:. (Photo by 1ynthia ;ohnsonCC!ime Life PicturesC@etty 8mages)
'.$. $enator ;udd @regg (of =ew am#shire) recei(es the 1oncord 1oalitionIs Paul B. !songas Bconomic Patriot 0ward on =o(ember ,9,
6<<-. Pictured left to right are7 4ormer '.$. 1om#troller @eneral Da(id *. Walker, $enator @regg, 1oncord 1oalition President Peter @.
Peterson, and former 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e Paul Aolcker. Peter @. Peterson and Paul Aolcker are members of the 1ouncil on
4oreign "elations. (Photo7 Fffice of '.$. $enator ;udd @reggChtt#7CCgregg.senate.go(CaboutCawardsC)
4ormer 1hairman of 4ederal "eser(e 0lan @reens#an (left) smiles as his wife, =B1 1hief 4oreign 0ffairs 1orres#ondent,
0ndrea *itchell (right) s#eaks during a ta#ing of H!ake !woH segment of H*eet the PressH at the =B1 studios on $e#tember 6.,
6<<: in Washington, D.1. 0lan @reens#an and his wife 0ndrea *itchell attended the 6<<6 Bilderberg *eetings in 1hantilly,
Airginia together in 6<<6. 0lan @reens#an and his wife 0ndrea *itchell are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
(Photo by 0le3 WongC@etty 8mages for *eet the Press)
Left to right7 4rank 1arlucci, Paul Aolcker, and Donna $halala testify before 1ongress.
Left to right7 !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson, former 4ederal "eser(e $ystem chairmen 0lan @reens#an and Paul Aolcker,
0rthur Le(itt, senior ad(iser to !he 1arlyle @rou# and former 1hairman of the $ecurities and B3change 1ommission ($B1), and
$B1 1hairman 1hristo#her 1o3 meet at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity in Washington, D.1. on *arch ,., 6<<:.
(Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
Left to right7 =ew &ork 1ity *ayor *ichael Bloomberg, former 4ederal "eser(e $ystem 1hairman 0lan @reens#an, and former
4ederal "eser(e $ystem 1hairman Paul Aolcker #artici#ate in a #anel discussion on ca#ital markets at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity
in Washington, D.1. on *arch ,., 6<<:. 0ll three men are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
(Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
=ew &ork 1ity *ayor *ichael Bloomberg (left) listens as former 4ederal "eser(e $ystem 1hairman 0lan @reens#an talk about
the economy at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity in Washington, D.1. on *arch ,., 6<<:. (Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
!reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (left), =ew &ork 1ity *ayor *ichael Bloomberg (center), and former 4ederal "eser(e
1hairman 0lan @reens#an #artici#ate in a discussion on ca#ital markets at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity in Washington, D.1. on
*arch ,., 6<<:. Paulson, Bloomberg, and @reens#an are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations.
(Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
Left #hoto7 !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson and former 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an a##ear at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity in
Washington, D.1. on *arch ,., 6<<:. $ecretary Paulson hosted the H!reasury 1onference on '.$. 1a#ital *arkets 1om#etiti(eness,H a day-
long #rogram to focus on ca#ital market issues like regulation, com#etition and other related to#ics. (Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
"ight #hoto7 Paul 0. Aolcker, the 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, #oses for a #ortrait in front of the 4ederal "eser(e building in Washington,
D.1. in ;anuary ,-9/. (J Wally *c=ameeC1F"B8$)
;ohn Deutch (left), former Director of 1entral 8ntelligence 0gency, and former 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker smile for the camera at
a 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations meeting on *arch ,., ,--:.
4ormer 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an talks to former !reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin (left) at @eorgetown
'ni(ersity on *arch ,., 6<<:. (Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
4ormer 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman Paul Aolcker (left), 0rthur Le(itt (center), senior ad(iser to !he 1arlyle @rou# and former
1hairman of the $ecurities and B3change 1ommission, and former !reasury $ecretary "obert "ubin #artici#ate in a #anel
discussion called O4raming the 8ssues7 *arkets Pers#ecti(esP at @eorgetown 'ni(ersity in Washington, D.1. on *arch ,., 6<<:.
0ll three men in this #hoto are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (Photo by 1hi# $omode(illaC@etty 8mages)
Bconomists ;ohn Eenneth @albraith (L) and 0lan @reens#an a##ears before a ;oint Bconomic 1ommittee in Washington, D.1. on Fctober .<,
,-:- in obser(ance of the ><th anni(ersary of the H1rash of I6-.H @albraith #ro#osed a G> a gallon H#enalty le(elH federal gasoline ta3 aimed at
cutting oil im#orts before the committee. (J Larry DowningCBettmannC1F"B8$)
*illion dollar newscaster Barbara Walters, escorted by her date, 0lan @reens#an, arri(es at the s#ecial screening of #roducer 0llen EleinIs
The Greek Tycoon at the Pla2a !heatre on *ay ,,, ,-:9. !he film, an o#ulent look at the li(es of the su#er rich, was followed by an e(ening of
disco dancing and a la(ish dinner at "egineIs, the society discotheDue. (J BettmannC1F"B8$)
0lan @reens#an (center) a##ears with his mother "ose @oldsmith (far left), his mentor 0yn "and (second from right), 0yn "and)s husband
4rank F)1onnor (far right), and President @erald ". 4ord (second from left) at the White ouse in ,-:+. 0yn "and, who was born 0lisa
Rino(Iye(na "osenbaum, was a "ussian-born ;ewish economic #hiloso#her. (Da(id ume EennerlyC@erald ". 4ord Library)
President "ichard =i3on (left) a##oints 0lan @reens#an as the new 1hairman of the 1ouncil of Bconomic 0d(isers during a meeting in $an
1lemente, 1alifornia, '.$.0. on ;uly 6., ,-:+. @reens#an was an economist from =ew &ork 1ity and President of !ownsend and @reens#an,
a #ri(ate consulting firm. (J BettmannC1F"B8$)
4ormer 4ederal "eser(e chairman 0lan @reens#an a##ears with his wife 0ndrea *itchell and '.$. $u#reme 1ourt ;ustice $te#hen Breyer at
the 6<</ 0s#en 8nstitute 8deas 4esti(al in 0s#en, 1olorado, '.$.0. on ;uly -, 6<</. !hey #resented their ideas on current issues at the 0s#en
8deas 4esti(al. 0ll three indi(iduals are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations. (J Lynn @oldsmithC1orbis)
0lan @reens#an, former 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, a##ears with Democratic '.$. $enator Dianne 4einstein (Democrat-1alifornia) at
the 6<</ 0s#en 8nstitute 8deas 4esti(al in 0s#en, 1olorado, '.$.0. on ;uly >, 6<</. !hey were s#eaking on current issues at the 0s#en 8deas
4esti(al in 0s#en, 1olorado. (J Lynn @oldsmithC1orbis)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an testifies during a $enate Banking, ousing and 'rban 0ffairs 1ommittee hearing on
1a#itol ill on ;uly 6,, 6<<>. @reens#an commented on "ed 1hinaIs #lan to use a more fle3ible currency system, stating it is Ha
good start.H (Photo by *ark WilsonC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an testifies during a $enate Banking, ousing and 'rban 0ffairs 1ommittee hearing on
1a#itol ill on 4ebruary ,/, 6<<>. (Photo by *ark WilsonC@etty 8mages)
0lan @reens#an, former 1hairman of the 4ederal "eser(e, s#eaks about his new memoir The Age of Tur%u!ence: A,entures in
a New (or! at Barnes % =oble in =ew &ork 1ity on $e#tember ,:, 6<<:. 0lan @reens#an is a member of the 1ouncil on
4oreign "elations and a former member of the !rilateral 1ommission. 0lan @reens#an attended the 6<<6 Bilderberg *eetings
in 1hantilly, Airginia in 6<<6. (Photo by $#encer PlattC@etty 8mages)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an smiles as he is welcomed at the $enate Banking, ousing and 'rban 0ffairs
1ommittee in Washington, 4ebruary 6+, 6<<+. @reens#an s#oke about im#ro(ing the regulation of the housing go(ernment
s#onsored enter#rises such as 4annie *ae. (J ;F=0!0= B"=$!C"eutersC1orbis)
4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an (1), his wife, =B1 Kournalist 0ndrea *itchell (L), and 1== anchor ;udy Woodruff enter the annual
White ouse 1orres#ondentsI 0ssociation dinner in Washington, D.1. on 0#ril 6/, 6<<.. 0ll three indi(iduals in this #hoto are members of the
1ouncil on 4oreign "elations, an internationalist organi2ation in =ew &ork 1ity. ("eutersCBrendan *cDermid)
4ormer '.$. !reasury $ecretary enry Paulson (left) and former 4ederal "eser(e 1hairman 0lan @reens#an a##ear on O*eet the PressP in
Washington, D.1. on 4ebruary :, 6<,<. enry Paulson and 0lan @reens#an are members of the 1ouncil on 4oreign "elations, an
internationalist organi2ation in =ew &ork 1ity. ("euters) htt#7CCwww.daylife.comC#hotoC<:t(fA8eEc,=w?DU#aulsonWgreens#an
embership of the )oard of Governors
of the #ederal $eserve %ystem, /0/8@2resent
+ppointive Mem1ers
Mem1ers ^ Chairmen ^ ,i(e Chairmen
-3GJffi(io Mem1ers
<e(retaries of the Treasury ^ Comptrollers of the Curren(y
7istori(al Notes
!ppointive embers
Bame
and Cistrict
Cate of
initial
oath of office
+ther dates and information relating to membership
Charles <% 7amlin
Boston
+ug% #! F$ Reappointed in F? and F"?% <erved until Fe1% >! F>?%
*aul M% &ar1urg
New York
+ug% #! F$ Term e3pired +ug% F! F=%
Frederi( +% )elano
Chi(ago
+ug% #! F$ Resigned 'uly "! F=%
&%*%.% 7arding
+tlanta
+ug% #! F$ Term e3pired +ug% F! F""%
+dolph C% Miller
<an Fran(is(o
+ug% #! F$
Reappointed in F"$% Reappointed in F>$ from the
Ri(hmond )istri(t% <erved until Fe1% >! F>?%
+l1ert <trauss
New York
J(t% "?! F= Resigned Mar% L! F"#%
7enry +% Moehlenpah
Chi(ago
Nov% #! FF Term e3pired +ug% F! F"#%
-dmund *latt
New York
'une =! F"# Reappointed in F"=% Resigned <ept% $! F>#%
)avid C% &ills
Cleveland
<ept% "F! F"# Term e3pired Mar% $! F"%
'ohn R% Mit(hell
Minneapolis
May "! F" Resigned May "! F">%
Milo )% Camp1ell
Chi(ago
Mar% $! F"> )ied Mar% ""! F">%
)aniel R% Crissinger
Cleveland
May ! F"> Resigned <ept% L! F"H%
.eorge R% 'ames
<t% Couis
May $! F"> Reappointed in F>% <erved until Fe1% >! F>?%
-dward 7% Cunningham
Chi(ago
May $! F"> )ied Nov% "=! F>#%
Roy +% Young
Minneapolis
J(t% $! F"H Resigned +ug% >! F>#%
-ugene Meyer
New York
<ept% ?! F># Resigned May #! F>>%
&ayland &% Magee
Bansas City
May =! F> Term e3pired 'an% "$! F>>%
-ugene R% Bla(k May F! F>> Resigned +ug% L! F>$%
+tlanta
M%<% <Aym(Aak
Chi(ago
'une $! F>> Reappointed in F>? and F$=% Resigned May >! F?%
'%'% Thomas
Bansas City
'une $! F>> <erved until Fe1% #! F>?%
Marriner <% -((les
<an Fran(is(o
Nov% L! F>$
Reappointed in F>?! F$#! and F$$% Resigned
'uly $! FL%
'oseph +% Broderi(k
New York
Fe1% >! F>? Resigned <ept% >#! F>H%
'ohn B% M(Bee
Cleveland
Fe1% >! F>? <erved until +pr% $! F$?%
Ronald Ransom
+tlanta
Fe1% >! F>? Reappointed in F$"% )ied )e(% "! F$H%
Ralph &% Morrison
)allas
Fe1% #! F>? Resigned 'uly F! F>?%
Chester C% )avis
Ri(hmond
'une "L! F>? Reappointed in F$#% Resigned +pr% L! F$%
-rnest .% )raper
New York
Mar% >#! F>= <erved until <ept% ! FL#%
Rudolph M% -vans
Ri(hmond
Mar% $! F$" <erved until +ug% >! FL$%
'ames B% ,ardaman! 'r%
<t% Couis
+pr% $! F$? Resigned Nov% >#! FL=%
Cawren(e Clayton
Boston
Fe1% $! F$H )ied )e(% $! F$F%
Thomas B% M(Ca1e
*hiladelphia
+pr% L! F$= Resigned Mar% >! FL%
-dward C% Norton
+tlanta
<ept% ! FL# Resigned 'an% >! FL"%
Jliver <% *owell
Minneapolis
<ept% ! FL# Resigned 'une >#! FL"%
&m% M(C% Martin! 'r%
New York
+pr% "! FL Reappointed in FL?% Term e3pired 'an% >! FH#%
+%C% Mills! 'r%
<an Fran(is(o
Fe1% =! FL" Reappointed in FL=% Resigned Fe1% "=! F?L%
'%C% Ro1ertson
Bansas City
Fe1% =! FL" Reappointed in F?$% Resigned +pr% >#! FH>%
C% Can1y Balderston
*hiladelphia
+ug% "! FL$ <erved through Fe1% "=! F??%
*aul -% Miller
Minneapolis
+ug% >! FL$ )ied J(t% "! FL$%
Chas% N% <hepardson
)allas
Mar% H! FLL Retired +pr% >#! F?H%
.%7% Bing! 'r%
+tlanta
Mar% "L! FLF Reappointed in F?#% Resigned <ept% =! F?>%
.eorge &% Mit(hell
Chi(ago
+ug% >! F? Reappointed in F?"% <erved until Fe1% >! FH?%
'% )ewey )aane
Ri(hmond
Nov% "F! F?> <erved until Mar% =! FH$%
<herman '% Maisel
<an Fran(is(o
+pr% >#! F?L <erved through May >! FH"%
+ndrew F% Brimmer
*hiladelphia
Mar% F! F?? Resigned +ug% >! FH$%
&illiam &% <herrill
)allas
May ! F?H Reappointed in F?=% Resigned Nov% L! FH%
+rthur F% Burns
New York
'an% >! FH# Term 1egan Fe1% ! FH#% Resigned Mar% >! FH=%
'ohn -% <heehan
<t% Couis
'an% $! FH" Resigned 'une ! FHL%
'effrey M% Bu(her
<an Fran(is(o
'une L! FH" Resigned 'an% "! FH?%
Ro1ert C% 7olland
Bansas City
'une ! FH> Resigned May L! FH?%
7enry C% &alli(h
Boston
%Mar% =! FH$ Resigned )e(% L! F=?%
*hilip -% Coldwell
)allas
J(t% "F! FH$ <erved through Fe1% "F! F=#%
*hilip C% 'a(kson! 'r%
+tlanta
'uly $! FHL Resigned Nov% H! FH=%
'% Charles *artee
Ri(hmond
'an% L! FH? <erved until Fe1% H! F=?%
<tephen <% .ardner
*hiladelphia
Fe1% >! FH? )ied Nov% F! FH=%
)avid M% Cilly
Minneapolis
'une ! FH? Resigned Fe1% "$! FH=%
.% &illiam Miller
<an Fran(is(o
Mar% =! FH= Resigned +ug% ?! FHF%
Nan(y 7% Teeters
Chi(ago
<ept% =! FH= <erved through 'une "H! F=$%
-mmett '% Ri(e
New York
'une "#! FHF Resigned )e(% >! F=?%
Frederi(k 7% <(hultA
+tlanta
'uly "H! FHF <erved through Fe1% ! F="%
*aul +% ,ol(ker
*hiladelphia
+ug% ?! FHF Resigned +ugust ! F=H%
Cyle -% .ramley
Bansas City
May "=! F=# Resigned <ept% ! F=L%
*reston Martin
<an Fran(is(o
Mar% >! F=" Resigned +pril >#! F=?%
Martha R% <eger
Chi(ago
'uly "! F=$ Resigned Mar(h ! FF%
&ayne )% +ngell
Bansas City
Fe1% H! F=? <erved through Fe1% F! FF$%
Manuel 7% 'ohnson
Ri(hmond
Fe1% H! F=? Resigned +ugust >! FF#%
7% Ro1ert 7eller
<an Fran(is(o
+ug% F! F=? Resigned 'uly >! F=F%
-dward &% Belley! 'r%
)allas
May "?! F=H Reappointed in FF#8 resigned )e(% >! "##%
+lan .reenspan
New York
+ug% ! F=H Reappointed in FF"8 term e3pired 'an% >! "##?%
'ohn *% Ca&are
Boston
+ug% L! F== Resigned +pril >#! FFL%
)avid &% Mullins! 'r%
<t% Couis
May " FF# Resigned Fe1% $! FF$%
Cawren(e B% Cindsey
Ri(hmond
Nov% "?! FF Resigned Fe1% L! FFH%
<usan M% *hillips
Chi(ago
)e(% "! FF <erved through 'une >#! FF=%
+lan <% Blinder
*hiladelphia
'une "H! FF$ Term e3pired 'an% >! FF?%
'anet C% Yellen
<an Fran(is(o
+ug% "! FF$ Resigned Fe1% H! FFH8 reappointed J(t% $! "##%
Cauren(e 7% Meyer
<t% Couis
'une "$! FF? Term e3pired 'an% >! "##"%
+li(e M% Rivlin
*hiladelphia
'une "L! FF? Resigned 'uly ?! FFF%
Roger &% Ferguson! 'r%
Boston
Nov% L! FFH Reappointed in "##8 resigned +pril "=! "##?
-dward M% .ramli(h
Ri(hmond
Nov% L! FFH Resigned +ugust >! "##L%
<usan <% Bies
Chi(ago
)e(% H! "## Resigned Mar(h >#! "##H%
Mark &% Jlson
Minneapolis
)e(% H! "## Resigned 'une >#! "##?%
Ben <% Bernanke
+tlanta
+ug% L! "##" Resigned 'une "! "##L8 reappointed Fe1% ! "##?%
)onald C% Bohn
Bansas City
+ug% L! "##" Resigned <eptem1er ! "##%
Bevin M% &arsh
New York
Fe1% "$! "##? Resigned +pril "! "#%
Randall <% BrosAner
Ri(hmond
Mar% ! "##? Resigned 'anuary "! "##F%
Frederi( <% Mishkin
Boston
<ept% L! "##? Resigned +ugust >! "##=%
-liAa1eth +% )uke
*hiladelphia
+ug% L! "##= Resigned +ugust >! "#>%
)aniel B% Tarullo
Boston
'an% "=! "##F
<arah Bloom Raskin
Ri(hmond
J(t% $! "## Resigned Mar(h >! "#$%
'erome 7% *owell
New York
May "L! "#"
'eremy C% <tein
Chi(ago
May >#! "#" Resigned May "=! "#$%
<tanley Fis(her
New York
May "=! "#$
Cael Brainard
Ri(hmond
'une ?! "#$
(hairmen Cate of term
Charles <% 7amlin +ug% #! F$G+ug% F! F?
&%*%.% 7arding +ug% #! F?G+ug% F! F""
)aniel R% Crissinger May ! F">G<ept% L! F"H
Roy +% Young J(t% $! F"HG+ug% >! F>#
-ugene Meyer <ept% ?! F>#GMay #! F>>
-ugene R% Bla(k May F! F>>G+ug% L! F>$
Marriner <% -((les Nov% L! F>$G'an% >! F$=