Lecture 4 - Resistors: Resistor Characteristics. Resistor Types. Choosing Resistors
Lecture 4 - Resistors: Resistor Characteristics. Resistor Types. Choosing Resistors
Lecture 4 - Resistors: Resistor Characteristics. Resistor Types. Choosing Resistors
1
Lecture 4 Resistors
Resistor characteristics. Resistor types. Choosing resistors.
Introduction
A resistor is not a pure resistance of exact value. A real resistor has a series
A resistor is not a
inductance and a parallel stray capacitance. These affect the behaviour of the pure resistance
4.2
Resistor Characteristics
Resistors are the most commonly used passive electronic component. The
characteristics and the features to consider when choosing a resistor are:
resistance value, tolerance on value, stability, temperature coefficient, voltage
coefficient, humidity effects, power dissipation, frequency effects, noise,
reliability, size and packaging, availability and cost. For insight into these
factors, the materials and construction of the various resistor types must be
considered.
Tolerance on value
Service variability of a resistor value is an overall, long-term value tolerance
composed of factors such as purchase tolerance, ageing, stress and short-term
excursions due to the local environment (temperature, humidity, etc). A
Component
tolerances are
tolerances at time of
purchase
resistor of, say, 10% rated tolerance can be selected to be within 1% of the
required value when installed in a circuit, but such a resistor might well drift
within (and often even outside) the rated 10% during its service. Hence, if
either a very accurate or stable resistance value is required in a circuit, choose
the right tolerance resistor when purchasing it, i.e. with a tolerance tighter than
the required end-of-life tolerance.
Preferred Values and the Decade Progression
Fundamental standardization practices require the selection of preferred values
within the ranges available. Standard values may at first sight seem to be
strangely numbered. There is, however, a beautiful logic behind them, dictated
by the tolerance ranges available.
The decade progression of preferred values is based on preferred numbers
Component values
have been
standardized by the
IEC
4.3
Recall that for a geometric progression, each individual term is given by:
(4.1)
an ar n1
where a n is the n-th term, a is the scale factor, and r is the common ratio. If
r is chosen to be the k-th root of 10, and the scale factor is set to 100, then:
an 100 k 10
(4.2)
n 1
Thus, the selection of k determines how many values of the geometric Component values
spaced
progression there are in one decade. For example, if 6 values per decade are are
equidistantly on a
desired, k 6 and the common ratio is
an 1 an1 1
an1 1
an 1
k
1
1
k
10 1
k
10 1
10
(4.3)
logarithmic scale
4.4
For k 6 , we get 18.95% . Thus, if we set the tolerance of resistors with 6
values per decade to 20% , we get values that almost certainly increase,
with minimal overlap:
100 20% = 80 to 120
E3 series, the number indicating the quantity of values per decade in that
series. For example, if resistors have a tolerance of 5%, a series of 24 values
can be assigned to a single decade multiple (e.g. 100 to 999) knowing that the
possible extreme values of each resistor overlap the extreme values of adjacent
resistors in the same series.
Any of the numbers in a series can be applied to any decade multiple set. Thus,
for instance, multiplying 220 by each decade multiple (0.1, 1, 10 100, 1000
etc.) produces values of 22, 220, 2 200, 22 000, 220 000 etc.
The E series of preferred resistor and capacitor values according to
IEC 60063 are reproduced in Table 4.1.
4.5
0.5%
E192
100
101
102
104
105
106
107
109
110
111
113
114
115
117
118
120
121
123
124
126
127
129
130
132
133
135
137
138
140
142
143
145
147
149
150
152
154
156
158
160
162
164
165
167
1% 2% 0.5% 1% 2%
E96 E48 E192 E96 E48
100 100 169
169 169
172
102
174
174
176
105 105 178
178 178
180
107
182
182
184
110 110 187
187 187
189
113
191
191
196
115 115 196
196 196
198
118
200
200
203
121 121 205
205 205
208
124
210
210
213
127 127 215
215 215
218
130
221
221
223
133 133 226
226 226
229
137
232
232
234
140 140 237
237 237
240
143
243
243
246
147 147 249
249 249
252
150
255
255
259
154 154 261
261 261
264
158
267
267
271
162 162 274
274 274
277
165
280
280
284
0.5%
E192
287
291
294
298
301
305
309
312
316
320
324
328
332
336
340
344
348
352
357
361
365
370
374
379
383
388
392
397
402
407
412
417
422
427
432
437
442
448
453
459
464
470
475
481
1% 2% 0.5% 1% 2%
E96 E48 E192 E96 E48
287 287 487
487 487
493
294
499
499
505
301 301 511
511 511
517
309
523
523
530
316 316 536
536 536
542
324
549
549
556
332 332 562
562 562
569
340
576
576
583
348 348 590
590 590
597
357
604
604
612
365 365 619
619 619
626
374
634
634
642
383 383 649
649 649
657
392
665
665
673
402 402 681
681 681
690
412
698
698
706
422 422 715
715 715
723
432
732
732
741
442 442 750
750 750
759
453
768
768
777
464 464 787
787 787
796
475
806
806
816
0.5%
E192
825
835
845
856
866
876
887
898
909
920
931
942
953
965
976
988
1%
E96
825
2%
E48
825
5%
E24
100
110
120
130
150
160
180
200
220
240
270
300
330
360
390
430
470
510
560
620
680
750
820
910
100
845
866
866
887
909
909
931
953
953
976
100
100
120
150
150
180
220
220
220
270
330
330
390
470
470
560
680
820
680
470
4.6
Marking Codes
The IEC also defines how manufacturers should mark the values of resistors
and capacitors in the standard called IEC 60062. The colours used on fixed
leaded resistors are shown below:
IEC labelling for
leaded resistors
4 bands
22 , 5%
5 bands
2200 , 1%
6 bands
silver
0.01
gold
0.1
10%
5%
black
brown
10
1%
100 ppm
red
100
2%
50 ppm
orange 3
1k
15 ppm
yellow
10k
25 ppm
green
100k
blue
1M
0.25%
10 ppm
violet
10M
0.1%
5 ppm
grey
white
200 ppm
0.5%
1 ppm
Tolerance
Multiplier
Significant Figures
Temperature
Coefficient
4.7
which the significant-figure value must be multiplied to find the actual
resistance value. (i.e. the number of zeros to be added after the significant
figures).
Whether two or three significant figures are represented depends on the
tolerance: 5% and wider require two band; 2% and tighter requires three
bands. The significant figures refer to the first two or three digits of the
resistance value of the standard series of values in a decade, in accordance with
IEC 60063 as indicated in the relevant data sheets and shown in Table 4.1.
The colours used and their basic numerical meanings are recognized
internationally for any colour coding used in electronics, not just resistors, but
some capacitors, diodes, cabling and other items.
The colours are easy to remember: Black is the absence of any colour, and
therefore represents the absence of any quantity, 0. White (light) is made up of
all colours, and so represents the largest number, 9. In between, we have the The resistor colour
code explained
colours of the rainbow: red, orange, yellow, green, blue and violet. These take
up the numbers from 2 to 7. A colour in between black and red would be
brown, which has the number 4. A colour intermediate to violet and white is
grey, which represents the number 8.
Surface mount technology (SMT) chip resistors are frequently marked with a
three-digit number, and some typical values are shown in the table below. The
first two numbers are the significant digits of the value, and the last digit is the
multiplier (the number of zeros to add to the first two digits). For example, a
chip resistor labelled 102 has a value of 1 k .
Resistor Value
0.1
0R1
1R0
22
220
3.3 k
332
100 k
104
4.5 M
155
4.8
When resistors are labelled with numbers, an additional letter is appended to
indicate the tolerance. The table below lists the letters used for the tolerance.
We use a letter to
indicate tolerance
Resistor
IEC Labelling
Tolerance
1%
2%
5%
10 %
20 %
The figure below shows the markings on a single in-line package (SIP) of
networked resistors (several resistors are in the one package) and the markings
on a chip resistor (with just a three-digit number for space reasons):
47 k 10%
pin 1
SIP network
10 k
SMC resistor
Resistor Value
IEC Labelling
0.1
0R1
1R0
22
22R
3.3 k
3K3
100 k
100K
4.5 M
4M5
4.9
Note how the decimal point is expressed, that the ohm symbol is shown as an
R, and that 1000 is shown as a capital K. Note that although capital K is called
for by the standard, a lower-case k is generally preferred because it aligns with
the SI prefix and capital K has widely become used in computing to mean 1024
(as in KB kilobytes) . The use of a letter instead of a decimal point solves a We use a letter in
place of a decimal
printing problem! The decimal point in a number may not always be printed point for labelling
clearly, and the alternative display method is intended to help misinterpretation
component values
condition or stress: high or low temperature, time (ageing), full rated power,
moisture, soldering heat, short-time overload, radiation. Wire-wound resistors
are the most stable ones, followed, in order, by metal film, chip and carbon
film.
Temperature Coefficient (Tempco)
4.10
Example
+26
+2.6%
+1.6%
R nom
-1.6%
-55
25
T (C)
-16
-2.6%
155
4.11
Voltage Coefficient (Voltco)
defined
carbon composition. The voltco is about 5 to 30 ppm / V for carbon film, and
0.05 to 10 ppm / V for metal film or chip resistors.
Humidity Effects
On the surface of a high resistance value resistor, moisture can provide a low
resistance leakage path. If moisture penetrates the coating, it can react
chemically with the resistive film and alter it. The danger is mainly when the
Humidity effects
resistors are stored or the equipment is not used, because then the resistors are
cold. The effect of prolonged humidity is also expressed in % or ppm change.
Power Dissipation
Power dissipation
power rating of a resistor is the maximum power in watts which the resistor depends on the
resistor
can dissipate. The maximum power rating is a function of resistor material, construction, and
depends on the
maximum voltage rating, resistor dimensions, and maximum allowable hot- ambient
temperature
4.12
The maximum allowable power rating as a function of the ambient temperature
is given by the derating curve. The figure below shows a typical power
derating curve for a resistor.
Power derating
curve for a resistor
full-rated power
100
Pmax
(% Prated )
50
no-load maximum
safe operating
temperature
maximum full-load
ambient temperature
0
50
70
155
100
Tamb (C)
Figure 4.4 Resistor derating curve
The derating curve is usually linearly drawn from the full-rated load
temperature to the maximum allowable no-load temperature. A resistor may be
operated at ambient temperatures above the maximum full-load ambient
temperature if operating at lower than full-rated power capacity. The maximum
allowable no-load temperature is also the maximum storage temperature for the
resistor.
Example
can
also
be
calculated
from
the
derating
curve
as
4.13
Voltage Rating
rated power = P
Voltage
or
Power
Sometimes voltage
rating, rather than
power rating, is a
limiting factor of a
resistors operation
rated voltage = V
P 1/ R
V R
Critical Value
of
Resistance
Resistance
Figure 4.5 Relationship of applied voltage and power above and below
the critical value of resistance
4.14
Frequency Effects
QUANTITY
CHIP PROPERTIES
THIN FILM
1206
THICK FILM
1206
0805
0603
R 1 k
Capacitance
0.05 pF
0.05 pF
0.09 pF
0.05 pF
Inductance
2 nH
2 nH
1 nH
0.4 nH
for a resistors
equivalent circuit
4.15
The equivalent circuit parameters are not always supplied by the
manufacturers. Instead, impedance versus frequency behaviour is given in plots
of Z R versus frequency, and phase shift versus frequency as in the figure
below:
Impedance as a
function of
frequency for a
resistor
Generally the frequency response is best for low value, small size, not spiralled
resistors (e.g. chip resistors). In Figure 4.7 one can see that a 10 k chip
resistor of size 0603 maintains its R value to about 70 MHz (a very high
frequency). The response is poorest for high value, spiralled resistors. Wirewound resistors are inductive even at audio frequencies.
Analog Electronics Spring 2012
4.16
Noise
All resistors generate a thermal (Johnson) noise voltage, caused by the random
motion of the electrons. Since this source of noise is caused by the random
motion of electrons, we expect that it is related to absolute temperature T . In
fact thermal noise is directly proportional to T and, as T approaches zero,
thermal noise also approaches zero. Since the noise is essentially random and
follows a Gaussian distribution about 0 V, we are interested in the RMS noise
voltage:
RMS thermal noise
voltage
(4.4)
Vn 4kTRB
where:
Vn = RMS thermal noise voltage
k = Boltzmanns constant ( 1.38 10 23 J K )
in RMS form as V 4 nV
Hz is used to
emphasize that the RMS noise voltage varies as the square root of the
bandwidth. This noise is bothersome when the circuit handles low-level
signals, e.g. at the input of a high-gain amplifier.
In addition to thermal noise, most resistors generate noise due to the passage of
current through the resistor. This additional noise is dependent on the amount
of current, the resistive material and the physical construction of the resistor.
Laser trimming, which cuts a groove in the resistive material, affects the
additional noise.
4.17
Typical noise levels due to current are shown below:
Typical noise levels
in a resistor due to
current
Reliability of
excellent, and is
hours of operation. A typical value, for good quality film resistors, operating at mostly affected by
an ambient temperature of 25 C, is 2 FITs. Resistors may fail catastrophically
(open or short circuit) or may drift out of specification.
Open circuits can be caused by cracked substrates, open welds, broken
resistive elements and chemical corrosion. Make sure to never stress a resistor
mechanically.
Short circuits may be caused by electrical breakdown (over-voltage), foreign
objects and silver migration. Excessive drift is due to moisture penetration,
corrosion, electrostatic discharge and transient overloading.
the environment
4.18
Derating
4.19
Resistor Types
This section briefly examines the construction method and materials used in
the manufacture of different types of resistors, and therefore shows why the
different types of resistors have such different characteristics.
Carbon Composition Resistors
Carbon composition resistors are made from a mixture of powdered carbon and
a resin binder, and are pressed to form a rod. The resistor is then coated with
epoxy. It is the oldest type of resistor, but is still used in some applications.
insulated
coating
Carbon composition
resistors
carbon
composition
colour
coding
leads embedded
into resistive
material
Figure 4.9 Carbon composition resistor
emergency situation where monitoring equipment is attached to a patient (e.g. pulse handling
ECG), it may be necessary to apply a defibrillator pulse in the case of a cardiac
arrest. In such circumstances there would not be time to disconnect all of the
sensitive monitoring equipment and therefore this equipment must be
protected.
capability
4.20
Carbon composition resistors, either mounted inside the equipment or moulded
into the leads of the monitoring equipment, provide protection. These resistors
are required to withstand all of the pulse energy typically around 30 J.
Advantages: Low price, wide range, low inductance, good surge capability.
Disadvantages: Poor tolerance (5% at best), poor stability, moisture sensitivity,
carbon, metal, or
metal oxide film
leads and
caps
spiral incised trhough
film into substrate to
increase and adjust
resistance
glass cover, or moulded
or conformal case
4.21
Unfortunately, spiralling also adds inductance to the resistor. Finally the
resistor is coated with lacquer and marked. Carbon film resistors have replaced
carbon composition resistors as general purpose, low cost resistors.
Advantages: Tighter tolerances (down to 0.5%), better stability, good high-
poor surge capability. Carbon film resistors are general purpose resistors, used
for less critical applications.
Metal Film Resistors
A film of low tempco metal alloy (Ni, Cr, Au, Al) or of metal oxide is
deposited on a ceramic body, then metal caps are added; a helical groove is cut
to trim the value (spiralling, as in Figure 4.10), then the body is lacquered and
marked.
Metal film resistors
are used in
precision
applications that
demand higher
power ratings than
surface mount
components
performance is superior.
Metal film are the resistors used in precision and high precision applications,
such as gain setting in op-amp feedback networks and frequency setting in RC
filters and oscillators.
4.22
Wire Wound Resistors
Resistive wire is wound on a ceramic rod or a glass core. Metal caps are
pressed over the ends of the rod. The resistor is coated with cement or enamel
(high power resistors).
Wire wound
resistors are the
most accurate and
stable and can
handle high powers,
but they are bulky
and expensive
leads welded
to end caps
resistance wire
resistance wire wound welded to end caps
on ceramic substrate
0.2 to 2 ppm / C.
Disadvantages: Large, expensive, very poor frequency response.
4.23
Chip Resistors
Chip resistors are surface mount components (SMC) and are made in either
thick-film or thin-film.
In thick-film technology, a paste with metal oxides is screen-printed on a
ceramic body, dried, then fired (this technology is also designated cermet).
The composition of the metal oxides determines the approximate value of the
resistor. Metallic end terminals are attached. The resistor is then laser trimmed
to the final value and coated.
Thin-film resistors are made by sputtering (a method of vacuum deposition) the
resistive material onto an insulating substrate, and then a pattern is etched into
the metal layer.
marking
resistor
layer
protective
coat
end cap
inner electrode
trim
notch
ceramic
substrate
material
Standard sizes and code designations are also shown in the table below.
SIZE
Length
Length
Width
Width
Mass
CODE
(mm)
(inches)
(mm)
(inches)
(mg)
1206
3.2
0.12
4.6
0.06
10
0805
2.0
0.08
4.2
0.05
0603
4.6
0.06
0.8
0.03
0402
4.0
0.04
0.5
0.02
0.8
0201
0.6
0.02
0.3
0.01
0.15
Sizes of chip
resistors note how
light they are too!
4.24
Advantages: Very small size; range of values, tolerances, tempco and stability
All modern circuits now make use of chip resistors, with leaded resistors
reserved for special applications. They are by far the most common type of
resistor, and were a necessary development in achieving the miniaturization of
everyday electronic devices, such as the mobile phone and MP3 player.
Thick film has the advantages of lower cost, of being able to handle more
power, and of being able to service a higher range of ohmic values.
Thin film has the advantages of tighter absolute and ratio tolerances and more
environmentally stable components with lower noise and tighter tempco than
thick film. Thin film technology is used wherever precision resistors are
needed.
Parameter
Thick-Film
Thin-Film
Resistance
3 to 20 M
10 to 100 k
Resistance Tolerance
Tempco
100ppm/C
25ppm/C
Tempco Tracking
100ppm/C
5ppm/C
Operating Temperature
-55C to +125C
-55C to +125C
100 V
50 V
Power
0.125W to 0.5W
0.1W to 0.2W
4.25
Resistor Networks
accurate voltage dividers, attenuators, feedback networks for accurate gain opamps and instrumentation amps, ladder networks for DACs and ADCs etc.
other applications are digital pull-up / pull-down terminations in logic circuits.
Resistors networks
save space but also
provide matching
component values
4.26
Choosing Resistors
The table below provides comparative data for different types of resistors.
Carbon
Composition
Carbon
Film
Metal
Film
Wire
Wound
Characteristic
Chip
(thick- and
thin-film)
Resistance
1 to
100 M
1 to
10 M
1 to
10 M
0.1 to
10 M
0.1 to
10 M
Tolerance at
purchasing
5% to
20%
0.5% to
10%
0.1% to
10%
0.01% to
1%
0.5% to
10% Th F
0.1% to
10% Tn F
Power
dissipation
1/8 W to
2W
1/10 W to
2W
1/20 W to
2W
0.1 W to
20 W
50 mW to
500 mW
Effect of
soldering
2%
0.5%
0.05%
0.01%
0.25% Th F
0.05% Tn F
Frequency
limit
1 MHz
100 MHz
400 MHz
50 kHz
100 MHz to
500 MHz
Tempco
(ppm / C)
-800 to +1600
-200 to 1000
20 to 200
20 to 200
25 to 100
Reliability
Good
Good
Good
Poor
Good
Stability
Poor
Good
Good
Very good
Good
Approx. cost
0.2 c
0.05c to 1c
1c to 4 c
50 c to $1
0.1 c to 1 c
Advantages
Low cost
Lowest cost
High reliability
Surge capacity
Good accuracy
Good stability
Small size
Highest
accuracy and
stability
Smallest size
Typical for
SMA
Disadvantages
Poor accuracy
and stability
Poor surge
capacity
Very expensive
Poor frequency
response
Relatively
large
tempco
4.27
Summary of Resistor Characteristics According to Type
Carbon composition resistors have good pulse and surge response, but poor
and stability specifications close to those of other film resistors. Chip resistors
are very small in size and are surface mount components (SMC), intended for
surface mount assembly (SMA). Usage of chip resistors is now almost
universal in all large volume electronic products. The main limitation is the
low power dissipation (to about 1/2 W).
Wire wound resistors are the most accurate and stable resistors, but are also the
largest and most expensive. They also have a very poor frequency response.
Usage is limited to very high precision or high power applications at power
(50Hz) and low frequencies.
Resistor networks are used to replace sets of chip resistors in large-volume
4.28
References
Analog Devices: Hardware Design Techniques; Section 9 of Practical Analog
Design Techniques, Analog Devices, 1996.
Becker, J.: Understanding Passive Components; viewed 6 March 2007,
<www.epemag.com>.
Pecht, M., Lall, P., Ballou, G., Sankaran, C., Angelopoulos, N.: Passive
Components; in The Electrical Engineering Handbook, CRC Press LLC, 2000
Piotech: Data Sheet: Chip Resistors with Au-Terminations; Rev. 1, viewed 6
March 2007 <www.piotech.com.tw>
Sinclair, I.R.: Passive Components a Users Guide, B&H Newnes, Oxford,
1994.
Stere, R.: Project A: Passive Components, UTS, 1997.
Whitaker, J.C., editor-in-chief: The Electronics handbook, Section II,
Properties of Materials and Components, CRC Press & IEEE Press, 1996, pp
135-182.
Yageo: Components Data Books: PA08 Fixed Resistors; PA05 Film
Capacitors; PA06 Ceramic Capacitors; PA01 Electrolytic Capacitors. Yageo,
Taiwan, 1994-1996.