Hpsacp Datta
Hpsacp Datta
Hpsacp Datta
in South Asian
and Comparative Politics
by
Prabhat Datta
S o u t h As i a I n s t i t u t e
D e p a r t me n t o f P o l i t i c a l S c i e n c e
H e i d e l b e r g Un i v e r s i t y
About HPSACP
This occasional paper series is run by the Department of Political Science of the
South Asia Institute at the University of Heidelberg. The main objective of the
series is to publicise ongoing research on South Asian politics in the form of
research papers, made accessible to the international community, policy makers
and the general public. HPSACP is published only on the Internet. The papers are
available in the electronic pdf-format and are designed to be downloaded at no cost
to the user.
The series draws on the research projects being conducted at the South Asia
Institute in Heidelberg, senior seminars by visiting scholars and the world-wide
network of South Asia scholarship. The opinions expressed in the series are those
of the authors, and do not represent the views of the University of Heidelberg or
the Editorial Staff.
Potential authors should consult the style sheet and list of already published papers
at the end of this article before making a submission.
Editor
Subrata K. Mitra
Deputy Editors
Clemens Spiess
Malte Pehl
Jivanta Schttli
Siegfried O. Wolf
Anja Kluge
Managing Editor
Florian Britsch
Editorial Assistant
Sergio Mukherjee
Prabhat Datta
ABSTRACT:
This paper seeks to make a critical review of the current status of the
constitionalised panchayati raj institutions (PRIs) in India as institutions of self
government and as instruments of planning for economic development and social
justice in the light of empirical evidence collected by the researchers and critical
analysis of the some of the actions of state . The background of the rise of the "new"
panchayat system has been narrated in a nut shell to enable the readers to have an
idea of the conceptual and institutional framework of the panchayat system Keeping
the central objective in mind the article focuses on the challenges faced by the third
generation PRIs in India from within and without and attempts to make an
assessment about the future of these institutions. Reference has been made to the
experience of some of the states in order to support the comments and observations.
The article argues that despite the constitutional amendment to regenerate the PRIs
there is still lack of genuine and strong political interest and bureaucratic support
to fuel the institutions. These have been manifested in the actions of the state after
the constitution has been amended. The traditional factors rooted in the socioeconomic structure and political dynamics of the rural society continue to plague
the working of these democratic institutions. It has been contended that there is
need for another round of constitutional amendment coupled with continuous
political and administrative support to ensure steady growth of the PRIs. The
author finds a ray of hope in the rise of civil society organizations which have
started acting as watchdogs in some of the states. They are working not only for
generating awareness among the stakeholders but also for organizing the villagers
to assert their rights and in this respect, the right to information has come as great
boon.
I would like to acknowledge that the comments on the paper by the anonymous referee
have been very useful in re-organising some sections of the paper. Thanks are due to the
members of the Faculty of the Department of Political Science, South Asia Institute,
Heidelberg University for their comments and observations on the presentation I made in
the Institute. I have immensely benefited from the suggestions I received from the editors.
2
The author can be contacted at [email protected]
HEIDELBERG PAPERS IN SOUTH ASIAN AND COMPARATIVE POLITICS
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
INTRODUCTION
The idea of decentralisation is to a certain extent embedded in the democratic ideal
as applied to political organisation. It is a contrivance of human wisdom in order to
promote the democratic ideal. Democracy as a form of political organisation may
be viewed as an attempt at the right ordering of peoples partnership not merely in
the sovereign power of the state but also in the day-to-day working of government.
As J.S.Mill says, the only government which can fully satisfy all the exigencies of
the social state is one in which the whole people participate.
Prabhat Datta (1998) Major Issues in the Development Debate, New Delhi : Kanishka, pp
14-19
HEIDELBERG PAPERS IN SOUTH ASIAN AND COMPARATIVE POLITICS
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
Gorkhaland movement in West Bengal, the Jharkhand movement etc.) based on
primordial loyalties like religion, ethnicity, language. It was difficult for the state
governments to handle the issues efficiently, bringing the republic under great
stress. It was then realised that power had to be shared with local communities. The
autonomous local level of self-government was considered to be a safety valve,
capable of preventing the recurrence of such incidents. The Constitution was
therefore amended in 1992 to lay the foundation stone of the third generation of the
Panchayati Raj in India.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
steadily increasing. About two thirds of India's more than one billion people live in
rural areas and almost 170 million of them are poor. Three out of 4 India's rural
poor live in large rural areas and for more than 20 per cent of them poverty is a
chronic condition.
A class of rich peasant is today consolidating itself in different states, thanks
to the support of the state. The technological and infrastructural modernization of
rural India in terms of electrification, provision of artificial irrigation, chemical
inputs, setting up of agricultural and other co-operatives and marketing institutions,
and extensive development of rural banks has meant a consolidation of the rural
rich. This land-based class captures the major benefits of the development
programmes initiated by the state and exercises social and political domination
over the villages through their economic clout and through pre-capitalist
institutions like caste coupled with the tradition of domination.
Almost 50 per cent of the farming households are indebted as per the 59th
round data of the National Sample Survey Organization. Nearly half of rural
households are landless. In 1999-2000 almost 77 per cent of the rural people ate
less than the international daily minimum of 2100 kilo calorie.
The introduction of the first generation grassroots democratic institutions in
this kind of social structure failed to bring about any noticeable change in the life
of the large mass of rural population, as they were captured by the landed gentry
and high caste people. As expected the institutions fell easy prey to the dominant
power groups in the class-caste divided society wherever they worked and
remained dormant in most of the states.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
works under the scheme and an overwhelming number (62%) agreed that the
quality of assets created was either bad or very bad.
Even in the face of widespread public criticism of the administrative and
financial mismanagement of funds under MPLADS, continued recommendations
for the abolition of MPLADS even by the Administrative Reforms Committee
(ARC) in its successive reports have failed to produce any positive impact. As
most of the MPs openly expressed their unwillingness on the floor of the
Parliament to give up the scheme, it was finally decided to continue the scheme but
with new and stringent safeguards. As a result, a set of new guidelines was framed
in the middle of November, 2005. Several legal and constitutional experts have
dubbed the new Guidelines as unconstitutional on the ground that they defy and
distort some of the basic features of the constitution such as public audit. For
instance, the attempt to do away with a CAG (Comptroller and Auditor General
)audit of the scheme accounts, as stated in the guidelines, is actually an attempt to
disempower the Parliament in exercising control over public expenditure.
Moreover, the list of permissible works under the scheme still contains items such
as roads, sanitation, drinking water, education and public health that form a part of
the Eleventh and Twelfth schedules of the constitution meant for the PRIs.6
Era Sezhiyan (2006) New Guidelines worsen MPLAD Scheme, Mainstream, April 1420, 2006
7
Report of the Task Force on Devolution of Powers and Functions upon the Panchayati
Raj Institutions, Department of Rural development (Panchayati Raj Division), Ministry of
Rural Development, GoI, 2001
HEIDELBERG PAPERS IN SOUTH ASIAN AND COMPARATIVE POLITICS
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
and bye-laws for their day-today functioning are yet to be formulated. In the
absence of necessary operational laws, the states are often found to misinterpret the
provisions of delegated legislation as a device for deferring legislation. In
Rajasthan, for example, the whole range of powers and functions that have been
legally assigned to the PRIs are either made subject to such rules as may be
prescribed or to the extent and in the manner as may be prescribed and since
then no rules have been framed or orders/ guidelines issued to this effect.
Undermining Elections
Attempts to undermine elections for panchayats continues. Some of the states have
taken years to hold elections. Postponing elections under one pretext or another has
become a routine matter. The elections to panchayats have been completed in
almost all the states after a series of legal battles and interventions by civil society
organizations. The case of Orissa is interesting. Elections to PRIs were due to be
held before February 2002. The SEC had promptly intimated the state government
its preparedness to conduct elections on time and suggested a delimitation of wards
and reservation of seats beforehand, if required. The district magistrates had in fact
done the work and the state government had ordered a limited delimitation of seats
in consonance with the Orissa Gram Panchayat Act, 1964. To cause further delay
in this regard the state government brought a bill in the monsoon session for the
reservation of seats in favour of the OBCs. The SEC chose to file a case in the
High Court. At this stage the state government decided to hold elections.8
Gujarat has recently set a unique example. The State Government has
announced incentives to the extent of Rs. 1 lakh to those panchayats, which would
be able to hold elections on the basis of consensus. The scheme called samras
gram (harmonious village) is clearly anti-democratic and is regarded as a recipe for
reward-induced guided democracy.
Interestingly, what is happening in some states in the name of achieving
unanimity is a cause of serious concern. During the panchayat elections in
Karnataka in 2000 some of the seats were auctioned. The Election Commission
8
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
could not interfere on the ground that if the voters made an arrangement among
themselves to ensure unanimous election it was beyond the legal competence of the
Commission to intervene. In order to augment the resources some of the seats were
put up for bidding in Andhra Pradesh in 2001. Even the reserved seats were not
spared. The highest amount for the post of the Sarpanch in Velpur village under
Guntur district was 10.10 lakh. Seats are auctioned in Madhya Pradesh and
Rajasthan. In 2005, auctions were held for the post of Sarpanch in at least two
gram panchayats .In Rajasthan it was the caste factor which mattered most. The
panchayat dominated by Gujjars was reserved for the SCs. Disturbed by the sudden
loss of power, some of the influential Gujjar leaders decided to extract a price for
the post. An announcement for open sale was made at the village Chaupal assuring
unanimous election of the highest bidder. The auction took place two weeks before
the day of polling. The reserved price was fixed at Rs.50, 000. One person offered
Rs.2.7 lakh and the seat was allotted to him. However, the effort proved to be
abortive due to intervention by the District Collector who got three of them
arrested.9
There was large scale distribution of gifts and allurements offered by
candidates in the UP elections held in 2005, some of them financed by non-resident
Indian relatives. There was a free flow of money and liquor in many villages. Hand
pumps were installed outside each house in one of the villages and voters in one of
the villages received silver rings and glasses. A candidate in one village called
Pratapgarh promised gold rings to each woman in the GP if he won. In several
constituencies whisky bottles were distributed liberally. There was hardly any
serious candidate who did not exceed the expenditure ceiling fixed by the SEC.
The local newspapers were splashed with advertisements by the well-to-do
candidates.10
It is interesting to note that the holding of elections at regular intervals can
bring about significant change in the socio-political profile of rural India.11 Studies
have shown that the caste system in Tamil Nadu has weakened following the
elections.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
activities in a sub-sector and activities, sub-activities/specific responsibilities under
a broad activity, with no role clarity.... In some states the line departments still
exercise the powers of supervision and control over the scheme of subjects
transferred to the panchayats The Parliamentary Committee in its 37th report
submitted in 2003 has expressed concern over the pace at which states are working
in this direction. The Report of the Task Force on the Devolution of Powers and
Functions to the PRIs brought out by the Ministry of Rural Development has
admitted that the mandatory provisions of the 73rd Amendment Act are yet to be
implemented in letter and spirit by most of the states/UTs even eight years after the
said Act came into force in April, 1993. The conformity legislations of most of
the States have not significantly altered the functional domain of gram panchayats
as is shown in the Table No.1. The studies emphasize the need for a uniform
accounting system and a uniform grant structure to ensure transparency in the
functional transfers to the rural local bodies.
Table No.1
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
States/UTs
Andhra Pradesh
Arunachal Pradesh
Assam
Bihar
Jharkhand
Goa
Gujarat
Haryana
Himachal Pradesh
Karnataka
Kerala
Madhya Pradesh
Chhattisgarh
Maharashtra
Manipur
Orissa
Punjab
Rajasthan
Sikkim
Tamil Nadu
Tripura
Uttar Pradesh
Uttranchal
West Bengal
A&N Islands
Chandigarh
D&N Haveli
a ) Funds
5
6
15
*
2
29
15
10
10
18
5
24
12
12
6
-
b) Functions
17
29
20
6
15
26
29
26
23
29
18
22
25
7
16
24
29
12
13
11
29
6
3
c) Functionaries
2
15
29
15
9
9
18
4
21
24
9
11
12
6
3
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
Prabhat Datta
28.
29.
30.
31.
5
**
-
*
**
***
3
***
-
Note: Provisions of the Constitution (73rd Amendment) Act, 1992 are not
applicable to the States of J&K, Meghalaya, Mizoram and Nagaland.
Source: Government of India (2001b)
The preambles of only three conformity legislations viz. those of Bihar, West
Bengal and Tripura unequivocally mention that the objective of the panchayat
legislations is to endow panchayats with functions and powers so as to enable them
to function as vibrant institutions of self government. The Acts of Tamil Nadu,
Kerala, Sikkim, UP and Maharastra make some commitment to self-government.
The Haryana Act spells out that the panchayat system is meant for better
administration of rural areas. Similarly, the MP Act treats janpad panchayat (
middle tier ) only as an agent of the government. Other states like Karnataka,
Punjab, Goa, Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur have carefully refrained from making
any specific commitment to self government for their panchayats.
The lack of clarity in functional allocation and absence of disaggregation into
detailed activities, as the Panchayati Raj Development Report 1995 mentions, has
led to considerable overlapping and duality of control in most cases. It has been
argued in the report that functional autonomy is rendered difficult because in
almost all states, the state governments retain the power to assign, amend or
withhold functions which, as per the 73rd Amendment of the Constitution, is a job
only the state governments are authorized to do.
More recently, however, the Government of India decided in favour of
undertaking activity mapping to ensure effective devolution of functions (as listed
in the Schedule XI) to all the three tiers of the PRIs. This is indeed a welcome
move whereby every activity can be attributed to the appropriate level of panchayat
so as to enable a more effective delivery of public services and a better quality of
life for the citizens. Devolution of powers, (as declared in the First Round Table of
Ministers- in- Charge of Panchayati Raj, Kolkata, July 2004) was to be based on
the principle of subsidiarity which means that any task that can be done at the
lower level should not move to a higher level.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
10
Prabhat Datta
Table No. 2
State/ UT
Andhra Pradesh
Details of AM (Activity
No. of
Mapping undertaken)
Subjects
transferred
Notes
17
29
Assam
29
29
Bihar
25
Chhattisgarh
29
27*
Goa
18
Gujarat
15
14
Haryana
10
Himachal Pradesh
26
Karnataka
29
29
Kerala
26
26
Madhya Pradesh
23
Maharashtra
18
No move to undertake AM
Manipur
22
22
Orissa
25
Arunachal Pradesh
AM for critical subjects like housing not done. Only 8 depts. have passed
orders for transfer of funds and functionaries.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
11
Prabhat Datta
Punjab
Draft AM prepared
Rajasthan
29
12
Sikkim
28
Tamil Nadu
29
Tripura
29
21
Uttar Pradesh
12
Uttaranchal
14
West Bengal
29
15
A & N Islands
D & N Haveli
AM completed
Lakshadweep
Chandigarh
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
12
Prabhat Datta
Transfer of Funds
The transfer of functions without corresponding transfer of funds does not make
sense but this has nevertheless, happened. Mahi Pal rightly says that before listing
the functions to be performed by the panchayats, the states have introduced certain
qualifying clauses.13 In Andhra Pradesh, Haryana and Tamil Nadu it is within the
limits of its funds. In Punjab it is to the extent its funds allow to perform. In
Madhya Pradesh and Himachal Pradesh, it is as far as the gram panchayat funds at
its disposal.
A close examination of the provisions in the Acts of the different states
regarding tax assignments, tax sharing, non- tax revenues makes it very clear that
the PRIs at the level of the samiti and parishad do not have independent taxing
powers. Most of the taxes are assigned at the GP levels.A provision for
independent budgeting by the three tiers is another prime requisite to ensure
autonomy. In some states like Andhra Pradesh and Orissa for PS, Punjab for ZP,
Rajasthan for PS and ZP, Tamil Nadu for all tiers, the preparation and presentation
of budgets is left to the executive authority rather than to elected representatives.
The Constitution provides for setting up of the State Finance Commission
(SFCs). By mid 1990s the first SFCs had submitted their reports. Referring to the
role of the SFCs the mid-term appraisal of the Ninth Plan pointed out, more
buoyant taxes like sales tax and excise are kept out of the purview of the PRIs. All
SFCs have put great emphasis on internal revenue mobilisation but none has
suggested any effective mechanism for PRIs to generate their revenue..... Indeed,
the absence of attention to the elementary principle, that expenditure assignment
must precede any tax or revenue assignment, has made most of the SFCs
recommendations suspect14 The State Governments have also been slow and
hesitant in accepting the recommendations where they are useful in terms of
improving the revenue generation capacity of the local bodies. Only two states
Karnataka and Sikkim have devolved funds to the panchayats for the 29 subjects.
In some states several of the basic services which traditionally belonged to the
panchayats like street lighting, provision of drinking water supply, sanitation and
drainage, primary health care etc. have not been entrusted to the GPs. For example,
in Haryana, GPs practically deal with only drinking water and construction and
maintenance of roads to the exclusion of all other basic services.
The balance sheets of panchayats reflect either financial scarcity or a lack of
control over budgeted finance. Except for a few states where the panchayats have
access to some funds, the financial position of the PRIs is in a bad shape.
Panchayat finances are fragile in most states where the total receipts of tax revenue
is only 3.5 per cent from 1997-98 in the 15 select states. It is about 5 per cent in
Orissa, Punjab, Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and Haryana and
between 10 per cent and 20 per cent in Assam, Goa and Kerala.15
PRIs across the states do not have any control over their own physical and
human resources. The SFCs have recommended the transfer of those powers,
which are less effective, although there has been emphasis on internal resource
mobilisation. This is a matter of concern because embedded in the question of
financial viability is the issue of self - reliance. The financial autonomy ratio
13
Mahi Pal (2004) Panchayati Raj and Rural Governance, EPW, Vol. XXXIX, January 10.
Nilkanta Rath (2004) Twelfth Finance Commission and Minimum Needs, EPW, June 4
15
The Status of PR Finances in India, PRIA New Delhi, 1999
14
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
13
Prabhat Datta
(FAR) for the selected Gram Panchayats (GPs) is below 1 per cent, indicating
almost total dependence on the grants from the higher-level governments. Even in
the states like Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Kerala, Karnataka and Maharashtra, the
FAR of the selected GPs is not more than 50 per cent. In Kerala perhaps the best
performing state in terms devolution to local bodies, the own revenue of an average
GP is only 33 per cent.
A study of 15 select states, namely, Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Kerala, Madhya
Pradesh, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Orissa, Punjab, Haryana, Assam, Goa reveals
that where middle or top tiers have been constituted, states have not endowed them
with adequate functional responsibility. Most states have granted a plethora of
functional responsibilities but no executive follow up of granting adequate powers,
staff and financial resources. Except for four major states where the intermediate
and apex bodies have adequate staff, in most other states, either the staff is not
directly relevant or inadequate. A study of panchayats in 15 states done by the
National Institute of Rural Development, Hyderabad, shows that the political
parties are reluctant to devolve powers. Jean Dreze has shown that in most States
the main responsibility of a sarpanch is to oversee the implementation of
development programmes.16
The Kolkata conference of ministers in-charge of the departments of
panchayats and rural developments in different states, held in July 2004, reaffirmed
its commitment to the best traditions of fiscal federalism in which the Union and
the states would co-operate to strengthen local government finances. It was agreed
to develop a framework of co-operation between Union Government and the state
government and to devise a mechanism, but nothing significant has emerged so far.
Transfer of Functionaries
To function effectively as institutions of self government the PRIs need to have the
power to recruit and control staff required for managing its functions. Staff is a
resource that an organization must possess to perform its activities. Strangely, Part
IX and IXA of the Indian constitution remain silent on this vital aspect of
institutional autonomy. Viewed from this perspective the state panchayat
legislations too present a gloomy picture. The state governments still have retained
for themselves the power for inspection, inquiring into the affairs of the
panchayats, the suspension of panchayat resolutions and issuing directions. Besides
in most states the key functionaries, namely, the secretaries and executive officers
at all the three levels of panchayats are state government employees who are
appointed, transferred and controlled by the state government. Being under the
direct control of the state administrative hierarchy they are often reluctant to work
under the administrative control of the elected panchayats. Moreover, provisions
for the deputation of officials from the state government to the panchayats have
been made in the state panchayat acts without consultation with the panchayats.
The tenure, transfer and the promotion of deputationists are also decided by the
state government without consulting the panchayats.
Kerala is the only state which has completely transferred the control of
functionaries to panchayats. More than 100 officials of different line departments
have been devolved to district panchayat which exercise supervisory and
administrative control over these functionaries. Only two states Karnataka and
16
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
14
Prabhat Datta
Sikkim have transferred functionaries pertaining to all the 29 subjects to the
panchayats. But in Karnataka too the panchayats have no power of recruitment,
transfer and discipline over their staff. Here, the zilla parishads and the taluka
panchayats are filled with state government officials resulting in dual loyalties and
needless friction in the day-to-day functioning of the panchayats. Although in a
few states the GPs have been given the power to recruit and control their own staff,
this power remains largely unutilized due to the weak financial position of the GPs.
States like Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Jharkhand, Goa, Gujarat, Haryana,
Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, Tripura, Andaman and Nicobar Islands,
Chandigarh and Pondicherry have not transferred any functionaries to the
panchayats. The rest of the states and Union Territories have transferred
functionaries of some departments/ subjects to the panchayats ranging from 2 in
Andhra Pradesh and 18 in Maharashtra. But even in states where the process has
just been initiated the efforts seem to be half-hearted. In Maharashtra, for instance,
this has led to role confusion as the transfer has not been made for the entire staff
of respective departments. Instead, they are being shared between the line
departments and the panchayats. Nilkant Rath has pointed out that this has
complicated the role of the Twelfth Finance Commission which has been asked to
recommend measures for the augmentation of the resources of the local bodies in
light of the recommendations of the SFCs.17
17
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
15
Prabhat Datta
growing confidence that they cannot be brow-beaten by dominant individuals
or castes, they become a force to reckon with."18
The Ashok Mehta committee observed that "the gram sabha has an important
role in activating the democratic process at the grassroot level, in inculcating
community spirit, in increasing political awareness and enabling the weaker
sections to progressively assert their point of view" Gram sabha is useful not only
as vigilance mechanism in the hands of the people but also as a tool to restore the
lost credibility of the panchayat in India.
Gram Sabha literally means village meeting a meeting of the villagers to
discuss their common problems. In many ways, it is comparable to a citizens
forum, a forum of direct democracy, which existed in Greek city states.19
While the constitution makes it mandatory to establish Gram Sabha at the village
level, it does not stipulate any details regarding the structure, powers, and functions
of this institution. In terms of Article 243G these details are to be spelt out in the
panchayati raj legislations passed in each state in compliance with the 73rd
amendment of the Constitution. Accordingly, all the state governments have
provided for the institution of gram sabha in their respective panchayat legislations.
There are variations across the states with regard to composition, functions and
other matters. In Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka the Gram Sabha has been defined
in relation to revenue village, whereas in Maharashtra and Rajasthan the unit is
much larger and coterminous with the village panchayat. In Kerala there is Gram
Sabha for every ward.
None of the State Acts empowers the GS to have control over the GP and to
take final decisions in matters of village development. Its role is only advisory. The
accountability of the GP to this body has also not been clearly spelt out in most of
the state legislations. In Kerala, however, it is obligatory on the part of the head of
the GP to explain to the GS why a particular decision or a set of decisions could
not be implemented.
In most of the states the functional domain of the GS is limited to discussions
of annual statement of accounts, administration report, and selection of
beneficiaries for anti-poverty programmes. Only in a few states like Haryana,
Punjab and Tamil Nadu the GSs enjoy the powers to approve budgets. The Gram
Sabhas are yet to take off in almost all the states.20 Reports from the states indicate
that Gram Sabha meetings are not being held regularly. The Institute of Social
Sciences team found in a village in Madhya Pradesh (MP) that by December
1995,only three meetings were held as against the legal requirement of six
meetings.
Nirmala Buch conducted a study of Gram Sabhas in 11 Gram Panchayats in
MP in December 1997 and found that far from an adequate number of GS
18
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
16
Prabhat Datta
members attending the meetings not even all the panchs were present.21 To cap it
all, there was no quorum of more than 50 per cent in the GS meetings. There is a
provision for mandatory attendance of one-tenth members in the Gram Sabha.
Women find it difficult to attend as the timing is sometime in the forenoon i.e.
between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m. Most of the women are not aware even of the
rudiments of the Gram Sabha. The issues discussed do not seem to interest a large
number of the villagers and hence, except careful and knowledgeable stakeholders,
others shy away from the Gram Sabha.
A study conducted in two Panchayats in Kerala has shown that the people are in
favour of expanding the role of the Gram Sabhas.22.They want the Gram Sabhas to
give the final seal of approval to the activities of the Gram Panchayat. The people
interviewed have suggested that the Gram Sabha will perform its duties in time
provided people are made aware of its role in development activities. Once their
felt needs are taken into consideration, they will automatically attend the meetings
in large numbers and participate effectively in the activities of the Gram
Panchayats.
In some of the States Gram Sabha meetings are generating a new atmosphere
in the countryside. Social auditing at the Gram Sabha meetings has also started
yielding desirable results. The Gram Sabha meeting in Karnataka successfully
combated the time-honoured Devdasi system, which prevailed in 167 villages of
Belgaun district.23 The UMA Research team of Bangalore had witnessed a Gram
Sabha meeting at Indore Gram Panchayat in Uttar Kanada district.24 The Sabha
witnessed uproarious scene when the people demanded an explanation from the
secretary about the activities. Only a handful of members were familiar with the
Act. The presence of the women members was very insignificant and those who
did come were passive observers. Many were hesitant to confront the elected
representatives. Most of the questions were raised by the youth. The elders hardly
opened their lips.
The Participatory Research in Asia team studied the working of the Gram
Sabhas in Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Kerala and Uttar Pradesh.25 The
team has noticed that although meetings are being held almost regularly, a quorum
is hardly achieved. Surprisingly, despite the lack of quorum, the proceedings are
prepared. The team is generally of the opinion that there is a lack of awareness on
the part of the members not only about the time and venue of the meetings but also
about the usefulness of such meetings.
The team points out that except in Kerala and Madhya Pradesh, the advice and
suggestions of the Gram Sabha are not even binding to the Gram Panchayat. In
reality, Gram Sabha meetings do not serve the purpose of either establishing
village priorities and overall policy framework for Gram Panchayat or regular
monitoring and accountability of the resources and the decisions of the Gram
Panchayats.
21
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
17
Prabhat Datta
The scholars observe that most of the heads of the panchayats lack skills in
conducting meetings in a manner that could promote wider participation and
discussion of the issues affecting the village. Issues of social justice and internal
dynamics of the village have rarely been agenda items in the Gram Sabha
meetings.
An authoritative survey of panchayati raj by NIRD reports follows: almost all
the State Acts have provided for Gram Sabha but its functions have not been spelt
out in detail. Consequently, these institutions by and large continue to function
ineffectively, though the meetings are generally held as prescribed. The purpose is
hardly served in the absence of a clear and direct mandate. More often, there is a
tendency to conduct the meetings in a formal manner and finalize the proceedings
in haste. The prescribed quorum is also not given due importance. The absence of
women folk in the meetings has been a common feature. The participation of the
people belonging to the weaker section has been marginal.
In West Bengal, the Gram Sabha created by an amendment of the West
Bengal Panchayat Act in 1992, started working well. Websters research
demonstrated that apart from the compulsory meetings of the Gram Sabha, the
informal mighty discussions in some localities, regular public meetings were other
forms of participation.26 Lieten remarked that although the boktrita culture was not
altogether absent in the Gram Sabha meetings, participation used to take place.27
In other words although the leaders used to deliver long speeches, they did not
stand in the way of active participation of the villagers in the meetings. Around
one- fourth of the males he spoke to, stated that they had participated in meetings.
In West Bengal, there is another body called Gram Sansad the geographical
location of which is the electoral constituency of the members of the GP.
According to the available information and the findings of the studies the Gram
Sansad meetings are attended by people of all age groups. In most of the meetings,
the Gram Panchayats publish the reports. There had been many occasions when the
meetings generated lot of heat. The author himself witnessed a situation where a
group of members walked out when the Pradhan refused to concede their demand.
The formation of the beneficiary committee had been more often than not an issue
of debate and discussion. This body is now replaced by the Gram Unnayan samity.
There is still a lack of awareness on the part of the Pradhan and the members about
the legal provisions relating to the Gram Sansad and Gram Sabha meetings. This
has been the finding of another study done in Gujarat.28 The officials present in the
meeting have to correct them.
The study done by the author reveals that more than one third of the villagers
are not aware of the Gram Sansad.29 The reactions of the respondents tend to show
26
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
18
Prabhat Datta
that there are three reasons for the low attendance of the members in the meetings,
namely, lack of time, the general impression that the decisions are not taken in the
meetings and the reluctance on the part of a section of the Gram Panchayat
members to listen to the suggestions generated during the meetings. The studies
done by the author indicate that the meetings have been more successful in places
where the GPs and the parties have taken an initiative in synchronising them with
the cultural programmes in tune with local traditions. It is clear from the
experience of functioning of the Gram Sansads that the modern institutional
assemblies like Gram Sabhas and Gram Sansads in traditional societies like India
need to be tuned with the natural rhythm of the rural life.
A study of the functioning of Gram Sansad in a cross-section of 20 villages in
May 1999 brings out certain important issues.30 The study shows that in analysing
the occupational category of the voters who attended the meetings, the largest
single category was agricultural labourers followed by farmers with less than two
acres of land. Those with more land or with non-farming sources of income
constituted about 16 per cent of those present. The analysis of the studys findings
tends to show that the meetings were centred upon very practical and concrete
problems within the village or cluster of villages. Proposals for road repair, where
should a tube well be installed, who should receive loan are more common issues
as opposed to broader themes which political parties, trade unions or peasant
organizations in West Bengal are concerned with, such as, economic liberalisation,
privatisation of public sector. In quite a few meetings, though not in all, the
accounts of the previous year and the budgets for the next year for the entire Gram
Sansad area were also placed. The researchers have noticed that the participants
actively voice demands for new projects, suggest how allocated funds should be
spent and debate how projects should be designed. The Pradhans and the local
representatives are not spared. They have to answer a lot of questions and often
face allegations about the misuse of funds and selection of beneficiaries. The
responses of the panchayat leaders to the criticisms indicate that they could not
take the voters present in the meetings for granted. There had been occasions when
they had to make frank admission about their errors.
Women Empowerment
In order to add a new dimension to the process of democratic decentralization,
namely, gender justice, the 73rd amendment of the Constitution provides for the
reservation of seats and the posts of chairpersons for women. All the state Acts
have incorporated this provision and elections are being held accordingly. But the
studies indicate that women elected to PRIs are yet to play their roles properly. 31
Conceptually it indicates a shift of attitude of the state towards women. Earlier
women were generally viewed as objects of development. The amendment seeks to
make women, actors in development.
This is a historic step, a sharp break from the previous practice. As many as 50
countries world over have quotas for women for their legislative bodies. Of the 20
countries with the largest number of women in parliament, 17 are using quotas in
some form or other. However, following this amendment the number of elected
30
M. Ghatak and M. Ghatak (2000) Recent Reforms in the Panchayat System in West
Bengal EPW, January 5.
31
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
19
Prabhat Datta
women at the GP level has gone up to 35.92 per cent of the total numbers of the
elected representatives. At the taluk panchayat level the figure is 40.14 per cent.
Again at the ZP level, the total number of women members elected is 39.37 per
cent. Some states elect more women than the one third mandated by the
amendment. For example, Maharashtra and Karnataka have 43.7 per cent and 43
per cent women respectively in their village councils. In 2004 there were at least
nine states where there was more than 33 per cent women in PRIs, Andhra Pradesh
( 33.04) Assam ( 50.38) , Chattisgarh ( 33.75) , Gujarat ( 49.30 ), Kerala ( 57.24 ),
Karnataka ( 43.06) Tamil Nadu ( 36.73), Uttar Pradesh ( 37.85), West Bengal
35.15) Bihar has made a provision for 50 per cent reservation. Women are getting
elected from general seats as well.
PRIA , op.cit
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
20
Prabhat Datta
among the female representatives. A sizeable section of the female representatives
perceive enhancement in their self-esteem, confidence and decision-making ability.
Becoming a member or Pradhan augments respect within the four walls of families
well as in the community at large. They also report an increased voice in decisions
on economic matters as well as other issues in their families.33
Nirmala Buch did a study on womens experience in Panchayats in three
states, namely, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh.34 The study has
indicated that the level of participation of women is very high, though not similar
to that of men. Womens attendance in the panchayat meetings ranged from 55.5
per cent to 74.4 per cent as against the mens average attendance range of 68.7 per
cent. A majority of the respondents showed good level of awareness and
knowledge about the working of the Panchayats. In order to argue their case in the
meetings many of them take others into confidence and hold informal discussions.
Empirical studies bring out both narratives of courage and narratives of
dislocation that disrupt the presumed outcomes of womens political
representation in PRIs. A field study in the five districts of MP covering 94 out of
188 sarpanches belonging to SC from the districts of Ujjain, Dewas, Ratlam,
Shajahanpur and Mandsuar show that women were elected from families who were
opinion leaders and continued to play their roles from behind the scenes. SC
members face both caste domination and male domination.
It has been argued by Kumud Sharma that that the language of state politics,
procedures of political parties for recruitment and nominations and political
socialization of men and women reflect a conflictual relationship between
womens representation and political leadership. Most of the political parties
remain institutionalized sites of patriarchal power. Women have to adjust
themselves to the imperatives of party structures if they are to survive and in doing
so some of them get co-opted in the process rather than influencing party structures
and processes.
The issues get further complicated when they are understood within the
framework of identity politics Women come in with their social and economic
disadvantages, poverty, illiteracy and dependence on wage labour.35 Women
sarpanches are prevented from completing their terms in office by using noconfidence motions. Sarkar says that whereas there are rules as to how no
confidence motions have to be handled, there is no requirement that the reasons
for seeking a no-confidence motion have to be stated in clear terms .36
Dalit Women
As we have seen above in the state-specific case studies, dalit women are facing
greater difficulties as they are targeted by the upper castes apart from other odds. It
has been difficult in states like Tamil Nadu to fill the posts of panchayats
presidents reserved for dalits for three decades. Dalits were prevented from filing
33
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
21
Prabhat Datta
nominations. The caste Hindu standpoint is that dalits cannot be panchayat
presidents because if they get elected they have to show respect to them.37
In Tamil Nadu, for example, till August, 2000 as many 96 village panchayat
Presidents were removed by district collectors, 66 of whom are women. A study
conducted by the Human Rights Advocacy and Research Foundation has revealed
that dalit women Presidents are forced to act under the control of the dominant
caste of the area. Women panchayat members are treated as non- entities. In most
cases, the Panchayat clerk proves to be a major obstacle. He is invariably male and
refuses to hand over keys for the panchayat and withholds crucial information.
There is discrimination in the seating arrangements for dalit women. For example,
in one panchayat in Haryana, all members sit in chairs while the female dalit
Sarpanch is made to sit on the floor because she belongs to the lower caste. In a
village called Gundaibhai in Madhya Pradesh the poor of the Panchayat who
belongs to the lower caste and poor agricultural labourer was not allowed to unfurl
the national flag. She was beaten up by men for polluting the sacred national
flag.38 In some election campaigns the name of the husband is displayed more
prominently than the wife's, even if she is a candidate. In one case when the wife
won the elections her husband was paraded in the victory procession and she was
nowhere to be seen.
A woman Panchayat President rarely gets the male vice-president to
countersign the cheque without some resistance from the latter. When the roles are
reversed, women vice presidents are forced to sign the cheque even if they disagree
with the expense. The socio-political dynamics in villages hamper the gender
equity in governance. The following is a case of harassment in a tribal sarpanch.
Mishri Devi of Thikri village in Dausas district in Rajasthan was elected to the post
of sarpanch. The upper class male villagers were unhappy. On August she was
stopped from saluting the national flag in a public place. The upper caste males
tried to strip her. In Rajasthan again, a women sarpanch her husband and two other
family members were abused and injured in an attack by 12 persons.
No-Confidence Motions
Ramilaben from Gujarat faced numerous no-confidence motions. She holds
masters degree in history and was advised by a state minister to join politics. She
contested the district panchayat elections. She won and became the president of the
district panchayat and as a result became an object of attack from the very
beginning because of her being female. The Vice President told her that if she
would refuse to work under his instructions he would force her to resign within 15
days. Ramilaben took it as challenge. They then initiated a series of no-confidence
motions. Each time she emerged victorious. Ultimately the High Court issued a
ruling that only one noconfidence motion could be brought against the President
during her tenure. In 1996 as many as 16 writ petitions were filed against her in the
court and she was suspended on grounds of incompetence. She moved the High
Court and was re-instated by it.
Parties are yet to accept the role of reservation as a tool of empowerment. The
interesting case of Adiamma from Karnataka is well known. She was the only
37
38
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
22
Prabhat Datta
woman of the 18 SC members GP in Madya district. The Congress (I) decided to
back her for the post of President. She got elected. Before the elections she used to
earn her livelihood by cleaning toilets of the Police Stations and worked as an
agricultural labourer. But after being elected she began to implement her agenda.
All encroachments near the local bus stand were cleared and the issue of ration
cards simplified. Many of the males were alarmed at the performance and tried to
find fault with her. They conspired against her to make her resign and resorted to
boycotting panchayat meetings. Three consecutive meetings had to be postponed
due to a lack of quorum. When nothing worked they moved a no-confidence
motion. The motion was passed with the support of Congress and Janata Dal.
39
40
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
23
Prabhat Datta
Table No. 2
SI. No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
State/Uts
Andhra Pradesh
Arunachal Pradesh
Assam
Bihar
Chhattisgarh
Goa
Gujarat
Haryana (No. of Districts :
19)
Himachal Pradesh (No. of
Districts-12)
16
17
18
19
20
21
Mizoram
Nagtaland
Orissa
Punjab
Deputy Commissioner
Minister)
Minister
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
24
Prabhat Datta
22
Rajasthan
constituted
23
Sikkim
constituted
24
Tamil Nadu
constituted
25
Tripura
Not constituted
26
Uttar Pradesh
constituted
27
Uttaranchal
constituted
28
West Bengal
constituted
No DPC in Darjeeling district. Metro Planning committee in Kolkata District.
29
A & N Islands
constituted
Government has decided not to constitute
DPCs as 90% of population is covered by
30
Chandigarh
municipalities
31
D & N Haveli
constituted
32
Daman & Diu
constituted
33
NCT of Delhi
34
Lakshadweep
constituted
35
Pondichery
Not constituted
Source: ISS Documentation and Information Centre Panchayati Raj Update July, 2003
In some states, the District Planning Committees (DPCs) are chaired by the minister of the State Government as in Madhya Pradesh,
whereas in other states, the officials head the DPC, as in Tamil Nadu where the collector is the chairman. All these practices are
inconsistent with the very spirit of the constitutional amendments on democratic decentralisation. The table below shows the composition
of the DPCs in different states:
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
25
Prabhat Datta
Composition of District Planning Committees in various States
Table No. 3
State
Total
Members
15
15-25
Nominated
Members
03
One-fifth
Chairperson
Secretary
District Collector
District Collector
One-fifth
District Collector
10-100
depending
on size of
the district
25
20
20-40
Fourfifths
One-fifth
District Magistrate
5
One-fifth
Karnataka
Fourfifths
One-fifth
Tamil Nadu
Fourfifths
One-fifth
Kerala
Madhya
Pradesh
Maharashtra 30-50
West
Bengal
Rajasthan
Uttar
Pradesh
Elected
Members
12
Fourfifths
Fourfifths
Fourfifths
Doubts have also been expressed about whether it would be possible on the part of retired or serving officials associated with the work of
the government to play their roles properly. Interestingly, the Eleventh Finance Commission observed that the appointment of serving
officers as chairman or members put a limitation on the SFC to act as an autonomous body to make recommendations in a free and
independent manner.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
26
Prabhat Datta
The Rise of Parallel Bodies
Table No. 4
Added to the above is the emergence of a series of parallel bodies in different states as shown in the chart below.
No. State
1. Uttar
Pradesh
2.
Haryana
3.
Andhra
Pradesh
4.
Gujarat
5.
6.
7.
Parallel Body
Areas of overlap/substitution
Institutional Linkage with PRIs.
Water User Group (WUG)/Site
Formulating,
developing
and Village Pradhan may be the ex-officio chairperson of the
Implementation
Committee
approving plans of the area covered SIC.
(SIC)
by the WUG
Selection of beneficiaries (farmers)
Construction,
maintenance
and
management of link and main drains
Policy decisions like decision on
rates of water charges.
Gram Vikas Samity
Supervision of construction of work out of The samity consist of 4 members of gram panchayat
the funds released by HRDF Board, Chairperson Sarpanch Elected Members one panch each
decentralised planning or any other state from SC community, BC community and a woman panch
government scheme.
Janmabhoomi
Planning and implementation of development Sarpanch and the concerned ward member finds
programmes at the local level
representation in the Habitation Level Committee of
Janmabhoomi.
Source:
Participatory
Research
in
Asia
(2002)
Parallel
Bodies
and
Panchayati
Raj
Institutions:
Experiences
from
the
States.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
27
Prabhat Datta
Broadly speaking, the functions performed by the parallel bodies can be classified
as ensuring user\beneficiary participation, convergence of programmes and
promoting\ensuring efficiency. While these are the basic functions of the PRIs, the
matters like irrigation, watershed management and development and minor forest
produce come under the purview of the Eleventh Schedule which lays down the
functions of the PRIs .The Gram Vikas Samity in Haryana and the Vigilance
Committee in Himachal Pradesh encroach upon the statutory functions of the
panchayat bodies as spelt out in the Panchayat Acts of the respective states. The
Janmabhoomi (JB) programme tends to mobilize local people, the entire state
administrative machinery and draws upon all existing central and state government
schemes as resource for development work, thus substituting the functions of the
Gram Panchayat. Although the Sarpanch is to preside over the JB Gram Sabha, the
real player is the officer which has created another problem. The Gram Sabha
meetings convened by the Gram Panchayat have become less important because of
the realization on the part of the people that fewer benefits are available through
panchayats.
There is another set of parallel bodies in states like Maharastra where
traditional panchayats exist with different legitimising sources. In Maharastra, for
example, there exist village collectives called Gavki. The 'Gavki' is constituted
by the elite upper castes, the rich and undoubtedly, only the patriarchs of the
village, women are excluded. Before the amendment of the constitution these
bodies functioned alongside the elected panchayats. Unfortunately, they continue
till today. Lele narrates an interesting case of how a Gavki defied the panchayat.
The 'Gavki' decided to auction the sand from the riverbed and the money earned
was to be a contribution to its own fund. The GP raised objections to it and a
conflict arose. The persons, who raised objection to this issue, were the more
informed active villagers, some dalits and women, associated with a local NGO
who were in favour of the panchayats. However, in the long run they failed to go
against the Gavki. The Gavki has been found to be more effective in areas
where women or dalits are in power. Thus, as Lele rightly observes reservations
which intended to empower both these marginalised sections in rural governance
are being made ineffective by the established powers in the rural areas41
The general reaction against the parallel bodies is that they represent processes
external to the constitutionally mandated role of panchayats and enable
bureaucracies to override democratic bodies. Thus they pose serious threats to the
effective functioning of local self- governing institutions.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
28
Prabhat Datta
justice. It will thus impede the process of empowerment for a large mass of
population in view of the fact there is still a chunk of population without basic
literacy.42
Another interesting case of similar nature is the constitution of the Third State
Finance Commission by the Government of Kerala under the chairmanship of a
retired IAS officer who was Chief Secretary earlier and is currently involved with
the work of the Government of Kerala. The other two members are serving officers
Secretary, Expenditure and Secretary, Local Administration. The SFCs are
modelled on the Union Finance Commission. It is intended to take an objective,
enlightened and independent view in making recommendations in order to enable
local government institutions as institutions of self government as envisaged in the
73rd and 74th Amendments of the constitution. The SFCs are required to fix the size
of the divisible pool and to design methods for inter se distribution of the share of
the local bodies on an equitable and efficient basis. It also has to evaluate the
critical gap at various levels, taking into account the tax assignment, on the one
hand and financial responsibilities on the other. It has been argued that the
appointment of serving officers as chairperson or members might make it difficult
for members to play the desired role.
The District Rural Development Agencies (DRDAs), which handle crores of
rupees, should have disappeared from the scene following the 73rd amendment of
the Constitution. However there is no such sign of this. The battle continues in
some states. The DRDAs have been constituted as late as in 2002. Some State
Governments have refused to comply with the Central Government guidelines to
ensure that DRDAs are merged with the ZPs. The Central Government has failed
to enforce this.
42
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
29
Prabhat Datta
Concluding Observations
Democratic decentralisation in rural India today faces a lot of challenges from
within and without. These are strong enough to derail the engine of rural
decentralization, if suitable steps are not taken in time by the central government
and the union parliament, the state government and the legislature, the bureaucracy
and the social structure.44 Given this background, one has reasons to express doubts
about the future of constitutionally ordained PR bodies as institutions of selfgovernment and instruments of economic development and social justice.
There is nevertheless a certain silver lining. It has been realized by the Indian
State that another round of Constitutional amendment is necessary to strengthen
PRIs and for this purpose a high-powered committee consisting of selected Chief
Ministers has already been constituted. Second, there has been an increasing
interest of the people and the press in panchayati raj. Third, civil society
organizations across the country have started taking an active interest in the
promotion of democratic decentralization. These silver linings offer a ray of hope
and, if they work well, one may envisage PRIs emerging as institutions of
democratic power and governance with some strength and vigour in the days to
come.
44
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
30
Prabhat Datta
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ahmed Rafi, (2004), A Retrograde Move by the Chhatisgarh Government,
Panchayati Raj Update, Sept.
Bandyopadhaya D. (2003) et al, 'Dependency versus Autonomy: Identity
Crisis of Indian Panchayats' Economic & Political Weekly (EPW),
September 20.
Bandyopadhaya D. (2003), Panchayat Puzzle, The Statesman, August 1.
Bardhan Pranab (2000), Decentralisation of Governance and Development,
Bookley: University of California Press.
Baviskar B.S., (2004), Empowerment of women through Panchayats : Slow
but Steady, Panchayat Update, May.
Behar A.and Aaiyer Y. (2003), 'Networks of Panchayat Women, Economic &
Political Weekly November, 22.
Bhargava B. S. (1970), Grassroots Leadership: A Study of Rural Leadership
in Panchayati Raj Institution, New Delhi.
Bhattacharya Mohit (1997), Development Administration, New Delhi :
Jawahar Publishers & Distributors.
Bose Nirmal (ed.) Selections from Gandhi, Navajiban Publishing House,
Ahmedabad Kolkata.
Buch Nirmala, (2000) Womens Experience in New Panchayats: The
Emerging Leadership of Rural Women, Occasional Paper no. 35, Centre
for Womens Development Studies, New Delhi.
Buch N., From Oppression to Assertion, A study of Panchayats and women in
M.P , Rajasthan, UP, CSDS, New Delhi.
Cohen J.M. and Uphoff N.T. "Participation's place in Rural Development:
Seeking Clarity through Specificity, World Development, Vol. 18, Pp. 213235.
Datta Prabhat (1992), The Second Generation Panchayats in India, Kolkata
Book House, Kolkata, p.2
Datta Prabhat (1997) Politicising Rural Development: Lessons from Indias
West Bengal, Asia Pacific Journal for Rural Development, December.
Datta Prabhat (1997) Politics at Blade and Grassroot, The Telegraph, July,
10.
Datta Prabhat (1998) Major Issues in the Development Debate, Kanishka,
New Delhi. Pp.14-19.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
31
Prabhat Datta
Datta Prabhat (2000) Panchayats, Rural Development and Local Autonomy:
the West Bengal Experience, Dasgupta & Co., Kolkata.
Datta Prabhat (2003), Towards Good Governance and Sustainable
Development, Das Gupta & Co. Kolkata.
Datta Prabhat (2003) Empowerment of Women through Panchayats in West
Bengal: An Exploratory Study, Dasgupta & Co., Kolkata.
Dev S.Mahendra & Mooij Jos (2002) Social Sector Spending in the 1990s
The Hindu, February 1.
Gandhi M. K. (1942) My Idea of Village Swaraj, Harijan July 26.
Ghatak M. and Ghatak M. (2000) Recent Reforms in the Panchayat System
in West Bengal EPW, January 5.
Government of India (2002) The Report of the Working Group on
Decentralised Planning and Panchayati Raj Institutions for the Tenth Five
Year Plan (2002-2007) Planning Commission, New Delhi, P.9.
Gupta S. K. (2001) New Panchayats and Subaltern Resurgence, EPW, July
21.
Issac Thomas (2000) Local Democracy and Development: People's Campaign
for Decentralised Planning, New Delhi: Left Word.
Jain L.C., Grass Without Roots, Sage ( India), 1988
Lieten G.K. (1998), Rural Development in West Bengal: Views From
Below, Journal of Contemporary Asia Vol. 24, No.4, p 328.
Lieten G.K. (1998), Development, Devolution and Democracy: Village
Discourse in West Bengal 1998, Sage, India.
Lele Medha Kotwal (2001) Local Government: Conflict of Interests and
Issues of Legitimisation, EPW, December 22.
Manor James (2001) Madhya Pradesh Experiment with Democracy, EPW,
March 3.
Mangal Rahul (1998) Local Self Government in India , Jaipur : Book enclave,
p. 184
Mathew G. (2000) Threats to Grassroots Democracy, The Hindu ; Feb.17
Menon P. (1996) Sex Slaves no more : Devdasis of Belgaum District break
free, Frontline, February, 9
Mishra S. N. (1980) Political Socialization in Rural India, Delhi pp 141-142.
Mohankumar S. (2002), From Peoples Plan to Plan sans Plan, EPW April
Oommen John, Gram Sabhas : The Live Wire in the Planning Process in
Kerala Journal of Rural Development, Vol. 18, No.2
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
32
Prabhat Datta
Omvedt Gail (2005), "Women in Governance in South Asia", EPW, October
29.
Richard L. Park & I. Tinker (ed.), Leadership and Political Institutions in
India, Princeton University Press, 1959 pp 415-426
Pal Mahi (2004) Panchayati Raj and Rural Governance, EPW, January 10.
Park Richard L. & Tinker I. (ed.), Leadership and Political Institutions in
India, Princeton University Press, 1959 pp 415-426
Participatory Research in Asia (PRIA) 1997. Strengthening PRIs in India
(unpublished)
Puri Nina, Ruling on Two Child Norm : A Step Backward The Tribune,
August 31, 2003
Rawal Vikas, "Aspects of India's Economy", Economic and Political Weekly
(EPW), No.44-46, 2008
Report on the Working of PRIs in Rajasthan, Government of Rajasthan.
Report of the Task Force on Devolution of Powers and Functions upon the
Panchayati Raj Institutions, Department of Rural development (Panchayati
Raj Division), Ministry of Rural Development, GoI, 2001
Sarkar Lolita, Annual Survey of Indian law, the Indian law Institute, 1997-98
Singh Kartar, The Role of the Gram Sabha in Village Development,
Kurukshetra, October, 1999.
Sezhiyan Era (2002) Development Directions, Frontline, March, 15.
Sezhiyan Era (2006) New Guidelines Worsen MPLAD Scheme, Mainstream,
April 14- 20, 2006
Sharma Kumud (2006) "From Representation to Presence", in. D
Bandyopadhaya /Amitava Mukherjee's, New Issues in Panchayati Raj,
Concept, New Delhi.
Sinha Dhovam Ray (1990) Panchayati and Raj Rural Organisations,
Allahabad.
Sirsiker V.M. (1970) The Rural Elites in Developing Society, New Delhi, p.
49
Smith Bryan (1996) Decentralization: The Territorial Dimension of the State,
London: George Allen & Union.
Srivastava R.
January.
Stephen F, (2001) "Empowering women through in Panchayats through
Training" in Building Womens Capacities: Interventions in Gender
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
33
Prabhat Datta
Transformations (ed) Raanjini K. Murthy, Sage Publications India Pvt.
Ltd., New Delhi.
The Status of PR Finances in India, PRIA New Delhi, 1999
The World Bank (2000), The Decentralization Thematic Team, Washington
DC
Thorlind Robert (2000), Development, Decentralisation and Democracy,
NIAS: Sweden.
Tripathi Purnima S. (2004) 'The Case Against MPLADS', Frontline,
November 5.
Upadhyay Videsh (2002), Panchayats and Paper Laws: Simmering
Discontent on 73rd Amendment, Economic and Political Weekly, July 20
Vaddiraju Anil Kumar and Mehrotra Shagun (2004) Making Panchayats
Work, EPW, September 11.
Vyasulu Poornima & Vyasulu Vinod, Women in PRIs: Grassroots Democracy
in Malgudi, EPW, Dec 25, 1999
Webster N. (1992) Panchayati Raj and Decentralisation of Development
Planning in West Bengal, Calcutta: K.P. Bagchi p.99.
http://www.hpsacp.uni-hd.de
Working Paper No. 49, September 2009
34