RP 5 P 3 Energy Transfer Lessons Planning
RP 5 P 3 Energy Transfer Lessons Planning
RP 5 P 3 Energy Transfer Lessons Planning
Essential Standard:
5.P.3 Explain how the properties of some materials change as a result of heating and cooling
5.P.3.1 Explain the effects of the transfer of heat (either by direct contact or at a distance) that occurs
between objects at different temperatures. (conduction, convection or radiation).
5.P.3.2 Explain how heating and cooling affect some materials and how this relates to their purpose
and practical applications.
defines the equilibrium positions and spacing of the atomic nuclei in a molecule or an extended solid and the
form of their combined electron charge distributions (e.g., chemical bonds, metals).
Energy stored in fields within a system can also be described as potential energy. For any system where the
stored energy depends only on the spatial configuration of the system and not on its history, potential energy is
a useful concept (e.g., a massive object above Earths surface, a compressed or stretched spring). It is defined as
a difference in energy compared to some arbitrary reference configuration of a system. For example, lifting an
object increases the stored energy in the gravitational field between that object and Earth (gravitational potential
energy) compared to that for the object at Earths surface; when the object falls, the stored energy decreases and
the objects kinetic energy increases. When a pendulum swings, some stored energy is transformed into kinetic
energy and back again into stored energy during each swing. (In both examples energy is transferred out of the
system due to collisions with air and for the pendulum also by friction in its support.)
Any change in potential energy is accompanied by changes in other forms of energy within the system, or by
energy transfers into or out of the system.
Electromagnetic radiation (such as light and X-rays) can be modeled as a wave of changing electric and
magnetic fields. At the subatomic scale (i.e., in quantum theory), many phenomena involving electromagnetic
radiation (e.g., photoelectric effect) are best modeled as a stream of particles called photons.
Electromagnetic radiation from the sun is a major source of energy for life on Earth.
The idea that there are different forms of energy, such as thermal energy, mechanical energy, and chemical
energy, is misleading, as it implies that the nature of the energy in each of these manifestations is distinct when
in fact they all are ultimately, at the atomic scale, some mixture of kinetic energy, stored energy, and radiation.
It is likewise misleading to call sound or light a form of energy; they are phenomena that, among their other
properties, transfer energy from place to place and between objects.
Grade Band Endpoints for PS3.A
By the end of grade 2. [Intentionally left blank.]
By the end of grade 5. The faster a given object is moving, the more energy it possesses. Energy can be moved
from place to place by moving objects or through sound, light, or electric currents. (Boundary: At this grade
level, no attempt is made to give a precise or complete definition of energy.)
By the end of grade 8. Motion energy is properly called kinetic energy; it is proportional to the mass of the
moving object and grows with the square of its speed. A system of objects may also contain stored (potential)
energy, depending on their relative positions. For example, energy is stored in gravitational interaction with
Earth when an object is raised, and energy is released when the object falls or is lowered. Energy is also
stored in the electric fields between charged particles and the magnetic fields between magnets, and it changes
when these objects are moved relative to one another. Stored energy is decreased in some chemical reactions
and increased in others. The term heat as used in everyday language refers both to thermal energy (the motion
of atoms or molecules within a substance) and energy transfers by convection, conduction, and radiation
(particularly infrared and light). In science, heat is used only for this second meaning; it refers to energy
transferred when two objects or systems are at different temperatures. Temperature is a measure of the average
kinetic energy of particles of matter. The relationship between the temperature and the total energy of a system
depends on the types, states, and amounts of matter present.
separation of mutually attracting masses; the energy stored in mechanical strains involves the separation
of mutually attracting electric charges. Although the various forms appear very different, each can be
measured in a way that makes it possible to keep track of how much of one form is converted into
another. Whenever the amount of energy in one place or form diminishes, the amount in another place or
form increases by an equivalent amount. Thus, if no energy leaks in or out across the boundaries of a
system, the total energy of all the different forms in the system will not change, no matter what kinds of
gradual or violent changes actually occur within the system.
But energy does tend to leak across boundaries. In particular, transformations of energy usually result
in producing some energy in the form of heat, which leaks away by radiation or conduction (such as from
engines, electrical wires, hot-water tanks, our bodies, and stereo systems). Further, when heat is
conducted or radiated into a fluid, currents are set up that usually enhance the transfer of heat. Although
materials that conduct or radiate heat very poorly can be used to reduce heat loss, it can never be
prevented completely.
Therefore the total amount of energy available for transformation is almost always decreasing. For
example, almost all of the energy stored in the molecules of gasoline used during an automobile trip goes,
by way of friction and exhaust, into producing a slightly warmer car, road, and air. But even if such
diffused energy is prevented from leaking away, it tends to distribute itself evenly and thus may no
longer be useful to us. This is because energy can accomplish transformations only when it is
concentrated more in some places than in others (such as in falling water, in high-energy molecules in
fuels and food, in unstable nuclei, and in radiation from the intensely hot sun). When energy is
transformed into heat energy that diffuses all over, further transformations are less likely.
The reason that heat tends always to diffuse from warmer places to cooler places is a matter of
probability. Heat energy in a material consists of the disordered motions of its perpetually colliding
atoms or molecules. As very large numbers of atoms or molecules in one region of a material repeatedly
and randomly collide with those of a neighboring region, there are far more ways in which their energy of
random motion can end up shared about equally throughout both regions than there are ways in which it
can end up more concentrated in one region. The disordered sharing of heat energy all over is therefore
far more likely to occur than any more orderly concentration of heat energy in any one place. More
generally, in any interactions of atoms or molecules, the statistical odds are that they will end up in more
disorder than they began with.
It is, however, entirely possible for some systems to increase in orderlinessas long as systems
connected to them increase even more in disorderliness. The cells of a human organism, for example, are
always busy increasing order, as in building complex molecules and body structures. But this occurs at
the cost of increasing the disorder around us even moreas in breaking down the molecular structure of
food we eat and in warming up our surroundings. The point is that the total amount of disorder always
tends to increase.
light so as not to "waste energy"may be imprecise but are reasonably consistent with ideas about energy that
we want students to learn.
Three energy-related ideas may be more important than the idea of energy itself. One is energy transformation.
All physical events involve transferring energy or changing one form of energy into anotherradiant to
electrical, chemical to mechanical, and so on. A second idea is the conservation of energy. Whenever energy is
reduced in one place, it is increased somewhere else by exactly the same amount. A third idea is that whenever
there is a transformation of energy, some of it is likely to go into heat, which spreads around and is therefore not
available for use.
Heat energy itself is a surprisingly difficult idea for students, who thoroughly confound it with the idea of
temperature. A great deal of work is required for students to make the distinction successfully, and the
heat/temperature distinction may join mass/weight, speed/acceleration, and power/energy distinctions as topics
that, for purposes of literacy, are not worth the extraordinary time required to learn them. Because dissipated
heat energy is at a lower temperature, some students' confusion about heat and temperature leads them to infer
that the amount of energy has been reduced. On the other hand, some students' idea that dissipated heat energy
has been "exhausted" or "expended" may be tolerably close to the truth.
Similarly, units and formulas for kinetic and potential energy are more difficult than they are worth for the
semi-quantitative understanding that we seek here. But the notion of potential energy is still useful for some
situations in which motion might occur (for example, gravitational energy in water behind a dam, mechanical
energy in a cocked mousetrap, or chemical energy in a flashlight battery or sugar molecule).
Work, in the specialized sense used in physics, is often considered a useful, even necessary, concept for dealing
with ideas of energy. These benchmarks propose to do without a technical definition of work for purposes of
basic literacy, because it is so greatly confused with the common English-language meaning of the word. The
calculation of work as force times distance is not essential to understanding many important ideas about energy.
Running makes you tired; rubbing your hands together makes them warmer; coming out of water makes you
feel cool.
Older students can grasp these ideas in a general way, but even they should not be expected to understand them
deeply. For young students, it may be enough at first to convince them that energy is needed to get physical
things to happen and that they should get in the habit of wondering where the energy came from. Then, as they
study physical, chemical, and biological systems, many opportunities arise for them to see the many different
forms energy takes and to find out how useful the energy concepts are.
Teachers have to decide what constitutes a sufficient understanding of energy and its transformations and
conservation. As the benchmarks below indicate, in harmony with Science for All Americans, qualitative
approximations are more important and should have priority. Much time can be invested in having students
memorize definitions-for heat, temperature, system, transformation, entropy, and the likewith little to show
for it in the way of understanding.
K- Grade 2:
No effort to introduce energy as a scientific idea ought to be organized in these first years. If children use the
term energy to indicate how much pep they have, that is perfectly all right, in that the meaning is clear and no
technical mischief has been done. By the end of the 2nd grade, students should be familiar with a variety of
ways of making things go and should consider "What makes it go?" to be an interesting question to ask. Once
they learn that batteries wear down and cars run out of gasoline, turning off unneeded appliances can be said to
"save on batteries" and "save on gas." The idea that is accessible at this age is that keeping anything going uses
up some resource. (Little is gained by having children answer, "Energy.")
By the end of the 2nd grade, students should know that
The sun warms the land, air, and water.
Grades 3-5
Investing much time and effort in developing formal energy concepts can wait. The importance of energy, after
all, is that it is a useful idea. It helps make sense out of a very large number of things that go on in the physical
and biological and engineering worlds. But until students have reached a certain point in their understanding of
bits and pieces of the world, they gain little by having such a tool. It is a matter of timing.
The one aspect of the energy story in which students of this age can make some headway is heat, which is
produced almost everywhere. In their science and technology activities during these years, students should be
alerted to look for things and processes that give off heatlights, radios, television sets, the sun, sawing wood,
polishing surfaces, bending things, running motors, people, animals, etc.and then for those that seem not to
give off heat. Also, the time is appropriate to explore how heat spreads from one place to another and what can
be done to contain it or shield things from it.
Students' ideas of heat have many wrinkles. In some situations, cold is thought to be transferred rather than heat.
Some materials may be thought to be intrinsically warm (blankets) or cold (metals). Objects that keep things
warmsuch as a sweater or mittensmay be thought to be sources of heat. Only a continuing mix of
experiment and discussion is likely to dispel these ideas.
Students need not come out of this grade span understanding heat or its difference from temperature. In this
spirit, there is little to be gained by having youngsters refer to heat as heat energy. More important, students
should become familiar with the warming of objects that start out cooler than their environment, and vice versa.
Computer labware probes and graphic displays that detect small changes in temperature and plot them can be
used by students to examine many instances of heat exchange. Because many students think of cold as a
substance that spreads like heat, there may be some advantage in translating descriptions of transfer of cold into
terms of transfer of heat.
By the end of the 5th grade, students should know that
When two objects are rubbed against each other, they both get warmer. In addition, many mechanical
and electrical devices get warmer when they are used. 4E/E1*
When warmer things are put with cooler ones, the warmer things get cooler and the cooler things get
warmer until they all are the same temperature. 4E/E2a*
When warmer things are put with cooler ones, heat is transferred from the warmer ones to the cooler
ones. 4E/E2b*
A warmer object can warm a cooler one by contact or at a distance. 4E/E2c
Grades 6 - 8
At this level, students should be introduced to energy primarily through energy transformations. Students
should trace where energy comes from (and goes next) in examples that involve several different forms of
energy along the way: heat, light, motion of objects, chemical, and elastically distorted materials. To change
something's speed, to bend or stretch things, to heat or cool them, to push things together or tear them apart
all require transfers (and some transformations) of energy.
At this early stage, there may be some confusion in students' minds between energy and energy sources.
Focusing on energy transformations may get around this somewhat. Food, gasoline, and batteries obviously get
used up. But the energy they contain does not disappear; it is changed into other forms of energy.
The most primitive idea is that the energy needed for an event must come from somewhere. That should trigger
children's interest in asking, for any situation, where the energy comes from and (later) asking where it goes.
Where it comes from is usually much more evident than where it goes, because some usually diffuses away as
radiation and random molecular motion.
A slightly more sophisticated proposition is the semiquantitative one that whenever some energy seems to show
up in one place, some will be found to disappear from another. Eventually, the energy idea can become
quantitative: If we can keep track of how much energy of each kind increases and decreases, we find that
whenever the energy in one place decreases, the energy in other places increases by just the same amount. This
energy-cannot-be-created-or-destroyed way of stating conservation fully may be more intuitive than the
abstraction of a constant energy total within an isolated system. The quantitative (equal amounts) idea should
probably wait until high school.
Convection is not so much an independent means of heat transfer as it is an aid to transfer of heat by conduction
and radiation. Convection currents appear spontaneously when density differences caused by heating
(conduction and radiation) are acted on by a gravitational field. (Though not in space stations, unless they are
rotating.) But these subtleties are not appropriate for most 8th graders.
PLANNING RESOURCES
Big Ideas:
Energy transfers when it moves in the same form.
Heat is a form of energy. Heat energy can be transferred.
Heat energy is a property of many substances and many processes give off heat energy.
Essential Questions:
What is heat? How can heat change the properties of a substance? Does heat energy behave in
predictable ways? How does heat move from one place to another? How do we explain conduction?
How do we explain convection? How do we explain radiation? What are some natural examples of each
type of heat transfer? How do matter and energy interact?
What is temperature?
Enduring Understandings:
Heat energy is a property of many substances and many processes give off heat energy.
Heat energy moves in predictable ways.
When two objects are rubbed against each other, they both get warmer. In addition, many mechanical
and electrical devices get warmer when they are used.
When warmer things are put with cooler ones, the warmer things get cooler and the cooler things get
warmer until they all are the same temperature.
When warmer things are put with cooler ones, heat is transferred from the warmer ones to the cooler
ones.
A warmer object can warm a cooler one by contact or at a distance.
Identify Misconceptions:
Use formative probes: Uncovering Student ideas in Science, Volumes 1-4, by Page Keeley
(I) Volume 1 The Mitten Problem p. 103 (II) Volume 1 Objects and temperature p. 109 (III)
Volume 2 Turning the Dial p. 47 (IV) Volume 2 Boiling Time and Temperature p. 53 (V) Volume 2
Freezing Ice p. 59 (VI) Volume 2 Ice Cold lemonade p. 78 (VII) Volume 2 Mixing water p. 83
(VIII) Volume 3 Where did the water come from? P. 163 (IX) Volume 4 Iron Bar p. 17 (X) Volume
4 Ice Water p. 45 (XI) Volume 4 Warming Water p. 53
Formative Assessment Probes (articles, how-to, free-online) by Page Keeley, et al
http://pal.lternet.edu/docs/outreach/educators/education_pedagogy_research/assessment_probes_unc
overing_student_ideas.pdf
http://www.ode.state.or.us/teachlearn/subjects/science/resources/msef2010
formative_assessment_probes.pdf
Video Resources:
Teachers Domain
http://www.teachersdomain.org/
Free digital media for educational use.
Bill Nye
http://www.teachertube.com/viewVideo.php?video_id=186099
Text Resources:
http://www.eschooltoday.com/energy/kinds-of-energy/what-is-thermal-energy.html
http://www.physics4kids.com/files/thermo_transfer.html
http://www.explainthatstuff.com/heat.html
http://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/ks2/science/materials/heat/read/1/
http://www.srh.noaa.gov/jetstream/atmos/heat.htm
https://www.ck12.org/physics/Heat-Temperature-and-Thermal-Energy-Transfer/
Terminology:
conduction
convection
radiation
temperature
Writing Prompts:
1. Write an essay describing what happens to the heat energy from a gas stove when you boil an egg
in a pot of water.
2. It is freezing outside! Describe how you will dress in order to stay warm as you hike to the park a
half mile away.
3. You have just made yourself a nice hot cup of tea. You are blowing on the top of the tea so you will
not burn your mouth. Write an essay explaining why the blowing will cool off the tea so that it is
safe to drink.
4. There is a need to conserve energy; if we are to make our natural resources last as long as
possible. Some people do this by lowering their thermostat in the winter months, and their homes
feel a little cool inside. Often, they have to wear sweaters indoors to stay warm. Do you think
people should be required to conserve heat energy this way? Explain your position.
5. In North Carolina, we experience four seasons. This doesnt happen everywhere on earth. Some
places stay hot year round, while others stay cold year round. If you had to relocate to such a
place, and you had to choose between them, which would you choose hot or cold? Explain the
reasons for your choice.