Draft Delhi Equality Bill 2016 Khaitan
Draft Delhi Equality Bill 2016 Khaitan
Draft Delhi Equality Bill 2016 Khaitan
Statement of Objects
Whereas the Constitution of India promises justice, liberty, equality and fraternity,
Whereas discrimination denies these constitutional promises to those subject to it,
Noting numerous reports of cases of discrimination in all spheres of social, economic
and political life, especially against dalits, Muslims, women, gays and lesbians,
hijras, disabled persons, persons from North-Eastern states, unmarried couples and
non-vegetarians,
Recognising the need to protect everyone subject to all forms of unfair discrimination
under a single comprehensive legislation,
Recognising that although normally minorities suffer discrimination, the law is more
likely to be successful if it, in general, protects minorities as well as majorities,
Recognising the need for the law to reduce the social salience of group membership
that exacerbates group disadvantage, while celebrating difference and pluralism,
Recognising the need to encourage diversity and affirmative action until these groupbased identities remain salient,
Recognising that the constitutional protections against discrimination in Articles 14,
15, 16 and 17 are necessary but not sufficient, and therefore need to be buttressed by
additional statutory protections,
Recognising the need to focus on the effects of discrimination on those subject to it
rather than on the guilt of the discriminator,
Recognising the particularly pernicious effects of aggravated forms of discrimination,
Noting that India has become an exception among liberal democracies for not
enacting a comprehensive antidiscrimination law covering the public and the private
sector,
Recognising the need to prevent a persons membership of a protected group from
having a detrimental impact on the success of his or her life,
Recognising the need to celebrate unity in diversity,
It is hereby enacted:
A. Preliminaries
1. Short title, Scope etc
(1) This Act may be called the Delhi Equality Act 2016.
(2) It extends to the whole of the National Capital Territory of Delhi.
(3) All provisions of this Act, except those contained in Parts E and F, shall come into
force at once.
(4) Parts E and F of this Act shall come into force on the sixtieth day of its enactment,
or on the date appointed by the Government of Delhi, whichever is earlier.
(x) Government of Delhi means the executive government of the National Territory
of Delhi headed by the Lieutenant Governor, who shall exercise any powers or
functions under this Act in accordance with the advice given by the Council of
Ministers for the National Capital Territory of Delhi;
(xi) High Court means the High Court of Delhi;
(xii) landlord includes, but is not limited to, any person who is a landholder, seller,
lessor, proprietor, housing society, hotel, motel, innkeeper, owner, estate or letting
agency, board and lodgings provider, or any other person providing residential,
commercial, agricultural, or industrial property, for sale, lease or rent for temporary or
permanent occupation or use;
(xiii) law in force means any law, other than the Constitution of India, which is or
can be enforced by any court, tribunal, regulator or any other adjudicatory or
administrative body in Delhi and which relates to a subject over which the Legislative
Assembly has legislative competence;
(xiv) Legislative Assembly means the Legislative Assembly of the National Capital
Territory of Delhi;
(xv) person includes, but is not limited to, a company, business, authority,
institution, organisation, venture, undertaking, enterprise, institution, establishment,
panchayat, personal law board, elders council, jamaat, political party, club, society,
trustee, non-governmental organisation, department, office, branch or unit, whether
governmental or private, whether incorporated or registered or not, whether formal or
informal, and whether for a profit motive or not;
(xvi) private person performing a public function relates to functions of the
Government of Delhi and includes, but is not limited to, public contractors, special
purpose vehicles formed in relation to public-private partnerships, and businesses in
receipt of any special subsidy, grant or benefit from the state that is not ordinarily
available to other businesses;
(xvii) protected characteristic has the meaning prescribed in section 3;
(xviii) protected group has the meaning prescribed in section 4;
(xix) public authority means any authority or body or institution that is under the
jurisdiction, competence, control or supervision of the National Capital Territory of
Delhi and
(a) is established or constituted by or under the Constitution, or by any law
made by Parliament, or by any law made by the Legislative Assembly, or
(b) is a body owned, controlled or substantially financed, directly or indirectly
by funds provided by the Government of Delhi, or
(c) is registered as a political party under the Representation of People Act
1951;
(xx) purchaser includes, but is not limited to, any person who is a transferee of a
property, whether or not he or she has paid any consideration;
(xxi) religion and belief includes, but is not limited to, recognised or unrecognised
sects within a religion, the religion of an individuals parent, an individuals religion
before or after a conversion or reconversion, atheism and agnosticism, and any
political or philosophical belief that is compatible with the objectives of this Act;
(xxii) service provider means any person who is a provider of any service, including
hospitality, entertainment, education (including primary, secondary and university
education), healthcare, advertising, insurance, banking, consultancy, commercial,
voluntary, charitable, professional, vocational, legal, transport, cultural, religious,
industrial and financial services;
(xxiii) tenant includes, but is not limited to, any person who is a sub-tenant, lessee,
paying guest, occupier or resident;
(xxiv) trader includes, but is not limited to, any person who is a seller, distributor,
letter, supplier, provider, manufacturer, packer, shopkeeper, retailer or wholesaler of
any goods;
(xxv) workplace includes, but is not limited to, (a) any department, organisation,
undertaking, establishment, enterprise, institution, office, branch or unit which is
established, owned, controlled or wholly or substantially financed by funds provided
directly or indirectly by any Government or the local authority or a government
company or a corporation or a co-operative society; (b) any private sector
organisation or a private venture, undertaking, enterprise, institution, establishment,
society, trust, non-governmental organisation, unit or service provider carrying on
commercial, professional, vocational, educational, entertainment, industrial, health
services or financial activities including production, supply, sale, distribution or
service; (c) hospitals or nursing homes; (d) any sports institute, stadium, sports
complex or competition or games venue, whether residential or not used for training,
sports or other activities relating thereto; (e) any place visited by the employee arising
out of or during the course of employment including transportation provided by the
employer for undertaking such journey.
(2) Examples provided in this Act may be used as interpretive aids for its substantive
provisions, but may not be used to reduce the scope of protection against
discrimination offered by any substantive provision.
(3) The provisions of this Act shall be interpreted purposively, in order to achieve an
equal, liberal and pluralistic society that is in keeping with our constitutional morality.
(i) caste, race, ethnicity, descent, sex, gender identity, pregnancy, sexual orientation,
religion and belief, tribe, disability, linguistic identity, HIV-status, nationality, marital
status, food preference, skin tone, place of residence, place of birth, age or
(ii) any other personal characteristic which:
(a)
is either outside a persons effective control, or constitutes a
fundamental choice, or both, and
(b)
defines at least one group that suffers or is in danger of suffering
widespread and substantial disadvantage, when compared with other
groups defined by the same characteristic, or
(iii) a combination of any of the above.
4. Protected Groups
(1) Subject to other provisions in this section, a protected group is a group defined by
a protected characteristic.
Examples:
1. Men constitute a protected group defined by the protected characteristic sex.
So do women.
2. Muslim women are a protected group defined by a combination of two
protected characteristics: sex and religion.
(2) In relation to the protected characteristics of pregnancy, the only relevant
protected group is persons who are, or are likely to become, pregnant, or a sub-group
thereof.
(3) In relation to the protected characteristic of disability, the only relevant protected
group is persons living with a disability, or a sub-group thereof.
(4) A protected group shall be deemed to include persons who are (correctly or
incorrectly) perceived to be members of that group and persons who are associated
with the members of that group.
Examples:
1. A person harassed because he is thought to be gay is protected from sexual
orientation discrimination even if he is not in fact gay.
2. An person without disability who has caring responsibilities for her disabled
son is protected from disability discrimination.
(5) A protected group includes any sub-group within it.
Example: Dalits include dalits living in a particular geographical area, or those
working in a particular establishment, or dalits who have a university degree, or dalits
converts to religions other than Hinduism, or any other sub-group within dalits.
C. Prohibited Acts
5. Direct Discrimination
(1) A conduct, law, policy, criterion, practice or structure is prima facie directly
discriminatory if is satisfies any of the sub-sections (2), (3), (4), (5) or (6) of this
section.
(2) It is intended to harm, injure, cause a detriment or adversely affect a protected
group.
Example: An employer refuses to interview a candidate because he is a dalit. This is
prima facie direct discrimination in relation to caste.
(3) It is motivated by prejudice against or stereotypical assumptions about members
of a protected group.
Examples:
1. A doctor administers conversion therapy to cure a lesbian of her same-sex
attraction. This prejudicial act is direct discrimination in relation to sexual
orientation.
2. An employer fires a female employee after her marriage because he makes a
stereotypical assumption that married women do not make efficient workers.
This is prima facie direct discrimination in relation to sex.
3. A college bans female students from wearing jeans based on stereotypical
assumptions about how women should dress. This is prima facie direct
discrimination in relation to sex.
4. A hospital hires only female nurses based on the stereotypical assumption that
women are more caring than men. This is prima facie direct discrimination in
relation to sex.
(4) It includes a reference to a protected characteristic, whether on its own or in
combination with any other criteria.
Example: A advertises to sell his house, and the advert says that only non-Muslims
shall be accepted as potential buyers. This is prima facie direct discrimination in
relation to religion.
(5) It is applied to a member or members of a protected group but not to a member or
members of any other group defined by the same protected characteristic.
Example: An employer administers a discretionary travel fund, which in practice is
usually disbursed to any employee, except to employees who originate from NorthEastern states. This is prima facie direct discrimination in relation to race and
ethnicity.
(6) Although applied generally,
(a)
it adversely affects or would adversely affect all members of a
protected group to whom it is or would be applied, and
(b)
does not or would adversely affect all members of any other group
defined by the same protected characteristic to whom it is or would
be applied.
(i)
(ii)
Examples:
1. An employer pays part-time workers at a lower hourly rate than full-time
workers, for doing the same work. A majority of part-time workers in his
establishment are women but a majority of full-time workers are men. This is
prima facie indirect discrimination in relation to sex.
2. A housing society only lets apartments to persons with a Masters degree. In
the relevant geographical area, dalits are substantially less likely to have
Masters degrees than non-dalits. This is prima facie indirect discrimination in
relation to caste.
3. A law school administers an entrance test for its admissions. Of those who sit
the test, 55% candidates are ordinarily resident in rural areas. However, only
10% of those who pass the test are ordinarily resident in rural areas. This is
prima facie indirect discrimination in relation to place of residence.
4. A milk delivery company has a policy of not supplying milk to butchers. Most
butchers in that locality are Muslims. This is prima facie indirect
discrimination in relation to religion.
(2) The satisfaction of sub-section (1) of this section is sufficient to constitute indirect
discrimination unless the respondent shows that the conduct, law, policy, criterion,
practice or structure
(i) is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate objective, and
(ii) was adopted in good faith.
Examples:
1. In Example 1 to sub-section (1) of this section, the objective of encouraging
and rewarding full-time workers in order to retain them is legitimate.
However, the means of differential pay for the same value of work is not
proportionate. This is indirect discrimination in relation to sex.
2. In Example 2 to sub-section (2) of this section, if the rule was adopted by the
housing society with the intention to exclude dalits, it would lack good faith.
In any case, the requirement of a Masters degree for tenants is unlikely to
serve any legitimate objective of the housing society. This is indirect
discrimination in relation to caste.
(3) A conduct, law, policy, criterion, practice or structure shall not be proportionate if
its objective can be substantially achieved through non-discriminatory or less
discriminatory means.
Example: In Example 3 to sub-section (1) of this section, it is found that rural
candidates particularly underperform in the part of the entrance test that examines
prior knowledge of law. It is shown that prior knowledge of law has no correlation
with an aptitude to study law. Continued testing of prior knowledge of law will not be
a proportionate means of achieving the legitimate objective (in this case, of selecting
10
candidates with the best aptitude to study law). This is indirect discrimination in
relation to place of residence.
7. Harassment
(1) Harassment is any communication or conduct related to a protected characteristic
that has the purpose or effect of creating an intimidating, hostile or bullying
environment for a person belonging to a protected group.
Examples:
1. A schoolboy who refuses to play sports is called a sissy by his teacher. This
is harassment in relation to gender identity.
2. A co-worker sprinkles holy water on a machine previously operated by a
dalit colleague to purify it. This is harassment in relation to caste.
(2) For the purposes of this section, whether a communication or conduct has the
purpose or effect of creating an intimidating, hostile or bullying environment for a
person belonging to a protected group shall be determined from the point of view of a
reasonable person belonging to that protected group, and in light of any relevant
historical or social context.
8. Boycott
Boycott means any overt or implicit abetment, support, encouragement, facilitation,
or practice of any social, economic, political, cultural or other form of avoidance,
ostracism, excommunication or exclusion that is targeted against or likely to
adversely affect members of a protected group.
Example: A khap panchayat orders villagers to stop all interaction with the families of
a couple who belong to different religions. This is boycott in relation to religion-cummarital status.
9. Segregation
(1) Segregation means any overt or implicit abetment, support, encouragement,
facilitation of, or use of force, coercion or manipulation, or the threat thereof with the
objective of preventing a person from interacting with, relating to, marrying, eating
with, living with, socialising with, becoming friends with, visiting, working with, or
contracting with another either because they belong to different protected groups
defined by the same protected characteristic, or because they belong to the same
protected group.
Examples: The following acts amount to segregation:
1. An employer operates separate canteens for upper-caste Hindus and all others.
2. A Hindu boy is threatened with violence unless he breaks off his romantic
relationship with a Muslim girl.
3. An adult consenting couple, walking hand in hand in a park, is set upon by a
mob which, on discovering that they are not married, forces the woman to tie a
rakhi on the mans wrist.
4. A young woman has her movements restricted and monitored by her family
because she is seen at a cinema hall in the company of a young man belonging
to the same gotra as herself.
11
(2) Whoever files a false complaint under section 366 of the Indian Penal Code 1860
or any other criminal law in order to frustrate or with the likely effect of frustrating a
persons free choice with respect to any friendship, relationship, cohabitation or
marriage has committed segregation.
(3) For the purposes of sub-section (2) of this section, a reliable statement made by
the person falsely alleged to have been kidnapped or otherwise affected shall be
sufficient, although not necessary, to prove that the complaint was false, even if he or
she later retracts from that statement.
10. Discriminatory Violence
(1) Discriminatory violence means any overt or implicit abetment, support,
encouragement, facilitation or use of violence or coercion that is targeted against
members of a protected group.
Example: A dalit woman is stripped and paraded around a village. This is an act of
discriminatory violence in relation to caste and sex.
(2) A public servant
(i) who has the duty or ability to protect the public from violence or coercion, and
(ii) fails to make, or causes or attempts to cause others to fail to make sufficient
efforts to protect members of a protected group from such violence or coercion
has committed discriminatory violence.
11. Victimisation
(1) Victimisation means subjecting to a detriment or adverse effect any person for
(i)
bringing a complaint under this Act, or
(ii)
seeking a protection order under this Act, or
(iii)
giving evidence in a proceeding or inquiry under this Act, or
(iv)
making an allegation concerning the contravention of this Act, or
(v)
seeking information in relation to this Act, or
(vi)
doing anything else in connection with the purposes or provisions of this
Act, or
(vii) providing financial, logistical or other support to anyone who does any of
these things.
(2) Victimisation includes subjecting to a detriment or adverse effect any person who
intends to do, or is believed to have done, or is believed to be likely to do, or is
believed to have the intention of doing any of the acts mentioned in sub-section (1) of
this section.
(3) Victimisation also includes subjecting to a detriment or adverse effect any person
who is associated with any person protected under sub-section (1) or (2) of this
section.
12. Antidiscrimination Duty
(1) A, or a representative of A, shall not directly or indirectly discriminate or use
discriminatory violence against, or harass, boycott, segregate or victimise:
(i) B, or
(ii) any person who seeks to, or would seek to, become B, or
(iii) any person who was B.
12
employer
landlord
trader
service provider
public authority
private persons performing
public functions
employees
purchaser, tenant
consumer
consumer
any affected person
any person affected by
their public function
13
14
15
16
(4) The Equality Commission may order any public authority to require its personnel
to undergo diversity training courses.
19. Affirmative Action
(1) Direct affirmative action is the adoption of a conduct, law, policy, criterion,
practice or structure that:
(i) includes a reference to a protected characteristic, whether on its own or in
combination with any other criteria, and
(ii) is designed to extend certain benefits, privileges or preferences to one or more
disadvantaged groups, and
(iii) is a proportionate means of extending such benefits, privileges or preferences.
Example: A private medical school awards an extra 5% marks in its entrance
examination to any Scheduled Caste candidates whose parent(s) do not have a
graduation degree. The policy includes a reference to the protected characteristic
caste.
(2) Indirect affirmative action is the adoption of a conduct, law, policy, criterion,
practice or structure that:
(i) does not include any reference to any protected characteristic, and
(ii) is designed such that its benefits, privileges or preferences shall mainly benefit
one or more disadvantaged groups, and
(iii) is a rational means of extending such benefits, privileges or preferences.
Example: A university has a fee waiver policy for any first generation university
entrant. In the relevant geographical area, Scheduled Caste students are likely to be
the main beneficiaries of this policy. The policy does not include any reference to any
protected characteristic but is a rational means of benefiting a disadvantaged group.
20. Disadvantaged Groups
(1) Disadvantaged group means, with respect to:
(i) caste: the scheduled castes recognised under Article 341 of the Constitution of
India, any other group that has been or continues to be a target of the practice of
untouchability;
(ii) race, ethnicity or descent: any racial and ethnic minorities in the relevant
geographical area, including persons who originate from North-Eastern states of
India, persons of Tibetan origin and persons of African origin;
(iii) sex: women and intersex persons;
(iv) gender identity: transgendered persons, hijras and gender-non-conforming
persons;
(v) pregnancy: those who are or likely to become pregnant;
(vi) sexual orientation: gays, lesbians, bisexuals, kothis and other sexual minorities;
(vii) religion and belief: religious minorities in the relevant geographical area, atheists
and agnostics;
(viii) tribe: the scheduled tribes recognised in Article 342 of the Constitution of India;
(ix) disability: persons living with any disability;
(x) linguistic identity: linguistic minorities in the relevant geographical area;
(xi) HIV-status: persons living with HIV/AIDS;
(xii) nationality: foreign nationals (including persons of Indian origin who hold a
foreign nationality), naturalised citizens;
17
E. Equality Commission
22. Equality Commission: Composition
(1) The Government of Delhi shall, by notification in the Official Gazette within sixty
days of the enactment of this Act, constitute a permanent and independent body called
the Equality Commission to exercise the powers conferred on, and to perform the
functions assigned to, it under this Act.
(2) The Equality Commission shall consist of
(i)
the Chief Equality Commissioner, and
(ii)
up to ten Equality Commissioners, including
a. at least two legal members, who shall be advocates of at least ten
years standing before the High Court or the Supreme Court, or retired
judges of the High Court, who have a proven track record of working
to achieve the purposes of this Act,
b. at least two academic members, who shall be experts with doctoral
degrees in the social sciences and have academic appointments at a
university with academic expertise in areas related to the purposes of
this Act, and who shall be granted leave without prejudice by their
employing universities for the duration of their term in the Equality
18
19
(8) The salaries, allowances and other terms and conditions of service of the Chief
Equality Commissioner and the Equality Commissioners shall not be varied to their
disadvantage after their appointment, and:
(i) for the Chief Equality Commissioner shall be the same as that of an Election
Commissioner,
(ii) for the Equality Commissioner shall be the same as that of the Chief Secretary to
the Government of Delhi.
(9) An Equality Commissioner is eligible for appointment as the Chief Equality
Commission during or after the end of his or her term, as long as he or she satisfies all
other requirements specified in this section.
(10) The Chief Equality Commissioner or an Equality Commissioner may, at any
time, by writing under his or her hand addressed to the Lieutenant Governor, resign
from his or her office.
(11) The Lieutenant Governor may, on the advice of the Chief Minister, by order
remove from office the Chief Equality Commissioner or an Equality Commissioner if
he or she:
(i) is adjudged an insolvent, or
(ii) has been convicted of an offence which involves moral turpitude, or
(iii) is unfit to continue in office by reason of infirmity of mind or body, or
(iv) has acquired such financial or other interest as is likely to affect prejudicially his
or her functions as the Chief Equality Commissioner or an Equality Commissioner.
(12) The Government of Delhi shall, in consultation with the Chief Equality
Commissioner, provide the Chief Equality Commissioner and the Equality
Commissioners with such funds, officers and employees as may be necessary for the
efficient performance of their functions and exercise of their powers under this Act:
Provided that any reduction in funds, officers and employees of the Equality
Commission shall require a Resolution to that effect of the Legislative Assembly,
passed by a majority of the total number of members of the Assembly present and
voting,
Provided further that the Equality Commission may seek additional funds from other
sources in order to better fulfil its duties under this Act, without prejudice to the
funding it receives from the Government of Delhi.
(13) The salaries and allowances payable to and the terms and conditions of service of
the officers and other employees appointed under sub-section (12) of this section shall
be such as may be prescribed by the Government of Delhi in consultation with the
Chief Equality Commissioner.
(13) In addition to the employees and officers appointed under sub-section (12) of this
section, the Equality Commission may employ up to ten recent university graduates,
preferably in the social sciences and law, for internships lasting up to a period of two
years.
(14) The Government of Delhi shall make provision for reasonable living and
maintenance costs of any interns employed by the Equality Commission.
20
21
(7) The Equality Commission shall organise an annual seminar, in conjunction with a
law university or the law department of a public university, to discuss its Equality
Report with academics, lawyers, judges, legislators, civil society, media and all
persons mentioned in sub-section (6) of section 22.
F. Civil Enforcement
24. Jurisdiction: Equality Courts and High Court
(1) The Government of Delhi shall, in consultation with the Chief Justice of the High
Court and within sixty days of the enactment of this Act, by notification in the
Official Gazette, designate for each district, one or more District Courts as Equality
Courts for the purposes of this Act:
Provided that if at any time the total number of pending cases under this Act before an
Equality Court exceeds five hundred, the Government of Delhi shall, within sixty
days, require such Equality Court to adjudicate upon these pending cases on all days
of the working week to the exclusion of all other matters,
Provided further that any order issued under the first proviso of this sub-section shall
not be withdrawn as long as there are any cases pending under this Act before that
Equality Court.
(2) The Equality Court shall have original jurisdiction with regard to any breach of
this Actother than the breach of the diversification duty or the due regard duty, or a
breach by a law in forceif, within its local limits,
(i)
the person aggrieved temporarily or permanently resides or carries on
business or is employed, or
(ii)
the respondent temporarily or permanently resides or carries out business
or is employed, or
(iii)
the cause of action has arisen.
(3) The High Court shall have original jurisdiction with regard to any incompatibility
between this Act and any other law in force and with regard to the breach of the due
regard duty.
(4) The reliefs available under this Act may also be sought in any legal proceeding
before any court affecting the parties to such proceedings, in addition to any other
relief that may be sought in such proceedings.
(5) A person subject to any order of the Equality Court or the Equality Commission
may appeal against such order to the High Court within thirty days from the date on
which the order was served upon him or her.
(6) Any order made under this Act by the Equality Commission, an Equality Court or
the High Court shall be enforceable at any place, even if that place is outside the
jurisdiction of the court that made such order.
25. Right to information
(1) B has a right to any information, as defined under section 2 of the Right to
Information Act 2005 and subject to the exemptions prescribed in that Act, in
22
possession of A that may be relevant for the purposes of this Act, including for
bringing any proceedings under this Act.
(2) With respect to persons covered by the Right to Information Act 2005, the
mechanism prescribed under that Act may be used to exercise the right to information
guaranteed under this section.
(3) With respect to any other person, As refusal or failure to provide the information
sought within thirty days of the request shall be a ground for B to complain to the
Equality Commission.
(4) On receipt of such complaint, if the Equality Commission is satisfied that B has
the right to the said information, it shall order A to provide it.
(5) The Equality Commission shall not make any order until it has sought As
response to Bs complaint, and at least one of its legal members has duly considered
any response provided within thirty days of such response being sought.
26. Proof
(1) In any judicial proceeding under this Act, the plaintiff has the burden of
establishing a prima facie breach of any duty under this Act on the balance of
probabilities:
Provided that, unless specifically permitted under this Act, proof of an intentional
reliance on or explicit reference to a protected characteristic by the respondent shall
be sufficient, although not necessary, to establish a prima facie breach;
Provided further that if any information is or is likely to be in the possession of the
respondent or sought from the respondent under section 25, the respondents failure to
produce such information within thirty days from the date the request was made shall
require the court to draw an adverse inference against the respondent, unless, for
reasons to be recorded in writing, the court decides that doing so will cause
substantial injustice.
(2) The respondent has the burden of refuting the prima facie case or of proving that
the prima facie case does not amount to a substantive breach of the duty on balance of
probabilities.
27. Interim Relief
(1) If a prima facie case of the breach of any duty imposed by this Act is made out in
the submissions of the plaintiff, appropriate interim relief that does not cause serious
prejudice to the respondent may be ordered in favour of the plaintiff by the Equality
Court or the High Court.
(2) Interim relief may be granted ex parte if warranted by the circumstances of the
case.
(3) Interim relief may include a protection order of the nature specified in sub-section
(7) of section 30 of this Act.
28. In Camera Proceedings
A court may, on the request of the aggrieved person, give directions to protect the
anonymity of any person and may conduct any proceedings under this Act in camera:
Provided that, at the request of the aggrieved person, up to two persons supporting
him or her shall be permitted to be present during the proceedings.
23
G. Protection Orders
30. Protection Order for Aggravated Discrimination
(1) Without prejudice to the civil jurisdiction of the Equality Court or the High Court
under this Act, an aggrieved person alleging aggravated discrimination, or any other
person acting on behalf of such person, may seek a protection order from the court of
Judicial Magistrate of the first class or the Metropolitan Magistrate, as the case may
be, within the local limits of which:
(i)
the person aggrieved temporarily or permanently resides or carries on
business or is employed, or
(ii)
the alleged discriminator temporarily or permanently resides or operates or
carries out business or is employed or is headquartered, or
(iii)
the cause of action has arisen.
(2) The Magistrate shall issue a protection order after being satisfied that the
application made by the aggrieved person or by any other person acting on behalf of
the aggrieved person prima facie provides a reasonable basis to suspect that an act of
aggravated discrimination has been committed, is threatened to be committed, is
likely to be committed, is being committed, or is likely to continue being committed
against such person.
(3) A failure to identify particular persons responsible for the alleged discriminatory
act shall not be a ground for refusing to issue a protection order.
(4) A protection order may be addressed to any identified or unidentified persons and
their formal or informal members, affiliates, volunteers and representatives, as well as
to persons who may have supported, justified, provoked, encouraged or facilitated the
alleged discriminatory act even if they have not committed or threatened to commit it
themselves.
(5) The fact that the case could be pursued, is being pursued, or has been pursued, in
civil proceedings before an Equality Court or the High Court shall not be a ground for
refusing to issue a protection order.
(6) A protection order may be granted ex parte:
Provided that the Magistrate may, for reasons to be recorded in writing, modify or
revoke the order on the application of the addressee of such order if he or she allays
the suspicion that was the basis of the order and shows that the continuing operation
of the order, or a part thereof, shall cause him or her substantial injustice.
(7) A protection order may
(i)
order particular persons (and their formal or informal members,
affiliates, volunteers and representatives) to refrain from:
24
25
(2) The offence under sub-section (1) of this section shall be tried, as far as is
practicable, by the Magistrate who had passed the protection order, the breach of
which is alleged to have been caused by the accused.
(3) The offence under sub-section (1) of this section shall be cognizable and nonbailable.
H. Miscellaneous
32. Existing Rights Unaffected
Nothing in this Act shall reduce or take away any right, interest or privilege that an
aggrieved person has or may have under any other law.
Schedule
(Exceptions to the Antidiscrimination Duty under section 12, sub-section 4)
1. Provision for a same-sex service provider for personally intimate services, such as
nursing or personal hygiene.
2. Requirement of a same-sex tenant for a shared dwelling where the landlord and the
tenant share a kitchen, bathroom, living room, or bedroom.
3. Restriction of food menus to certain cuisines, to the exclusion of other food
preferences.
4. Political boycott of any government, organisation or company, or a representative
of such government, organisation or company.
5. Restriction of membership of an association, whose primary objective is to
facilitate social interaction between members of a protected group, to persons
belonging to that protected group.
6. Discrimination in relation to religion by a place of religious worship, with respect
to activities that are essentially religious.
26
27