Galvanizado Entender Triple Spot
Galvanizado Entender Triple Spot
Galvanizado Entender Triple Spot
GalvInfoNote
1.1
Introduction
One of the most confusing aspects of coated steel sheet products are coating weight designations and
what they mean, particularly with respect to product performance. This article is intended to clarify this
issue.
Weight is a measure of the pull of the force of gravity (Weight/Force = Mass x Acceleration of gravity)
Mass is a fundamental property the same everywhere
3
For the purpose of measuring metallic coatings, mass and weight are equivalent everywhere on earth
2
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
1
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
coating thickness gauges. There are weigh-strip-weigh procedures that can be used for all zinc-based
coatings in commercial production today. For the most common products, these procedures are defined
in ASTM Standard A90/A90M, and cover galvanized and galvannealed sheet, 55% aluminum-zinc alloycoated sheet, zinc-5% aluminum alloy-coated sheet, and zinc-aluminum-magnesium alloy-coated sheet.
There are special procedures required for other types of alloy coatings such as aluminized, and zincnickel alloy electroplated sheet. These are covered by other ASTM standards.
Table 1 Example G90 Coating Weight Results - Illustrating Passing and Failing the Requirements
2
of A653/A653M (Table 1) values in oz/ft
Requirements of A653 (Table 1):
2
Minimum Triple Spot Test average (TST), Total Both Sides (TBS) 0.90 oz/ft
2
Minimum Single Spot Test (SST), Total Both Sides (TBS) 0.80 oz/ft
2
Minimum One Side (OS), Triple Spot Test average (TST) 0.32 oz/ft (per Footnote A of A653 Table 1)
Example
Test
E1
E2
E3
TST
Comments
TBS
0.92
0.93
0.96
0.94
TBS
0.85
0.93
0.96
0.91
TBS
0.85
0.87
0.96
0.89
TBS
0.78
0.95
0.96
0.90
OS-Top
0.30
0.31
0.40
0.34
OS-Bot
0.55
0.62
0.47
0.54
TBS
0.85
0.93
0.96
0.91
OS-Top
0.30
0.31
0.31
0.31
OS-Bot
0.55
0.62
0.65
0.60
TBS
0.85
0.93
0.96
0.91
These values meet the specification, since the One Side, Triple Spot Test average is above 0.32 oz/ft
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
2
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
G40
G60
G90
G115
These designations specify the minimum average TST, total-both-sides, tested per ASTM A924/A924M,
2
e.g., G90 requires a minimum average TST of 0.90 oz/ft total-both-sides. The specification stipulates
that TST samples shall be taken from defined positions at the edge-center-edge of the as-coated sheet.
There are designations for heavier coatings, such as G165 and G210, but these products are used for
very specialized applications and are generally not available on thinner gauge sheet.
In SI units (ordered as A653M or A1063M), the comparable coating mass designations for galvanized
2
sheet are, in g/m :
Z90
Z120
Z180
Z275
Z350
These designations specify the minimum average TST, total-both-sides, tested per A924/A924M, e.g.,
2
Z275 requires a minimum average TST of 275 g/m total-both-sides.
In 2007 ASTM added the option of ordering single side, single spot test (SST) coating designations to
A653/A653M. These are SI designations only (ordered to A653M) and specify the minimum and
maximum allowable coating mass per side for any SST. They take the familiar form of automotive coating
designations (numeric characters first signifying a per side requirement). No inch-pound designations
are used since single side coatings are traditionally ordered in SI units only. Examples are:
60G
70G
90G
These designations specify the minimum and maximum SST value on each surface, e.g., 60G requires a
2
2
minimum of 60 g/m and a maximum of 110 g/m of zinc on each surface for any SST.
When specifying single side single spot coatings, the designation for each surface must be shown, e.g.,
60G60G.
Coating weight [mass] versus coating life For galvanized coatings in most applications
and environments, the corrosion performance is an approximate linear function of coating
weight (thickness). For instance, a G60 coating has twice the thickness of a G30 coating, and
the life of the product (defined, perhaps, as the time to 5% red rust) in a given environment is
approximately twice as long. Similarly, a G90 coating is approximately 50% thicker than a
G60 coating, and thus would be expected to perform 50% better (in terms of time to 5% red
rust). For a more thorough discussion on service life, see GalvInfoNote 3.1. Limits on
maximum acceptable coating weights for an application are usually determined by other
factors such as cost or formability. For a more thorough discussion of this topic see
GalvInfoNotes 1.6 and 2.5.
For other metallic-coated sheet products, the life versus coating thickness is typically not
linear; thus determining the coating weight [mass] to use is not as simple as it is for
galvanized coatings. Also, when these products are painted, the behaviour is even more
complex. The subject of painted hot-dip products is addressed in GalvInfoNotes 4.1 and 4.2.
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
3
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
Zinc-Iron (Galvanneal) The common inch-pound coating weight designations (ordered as A653) for
2
galvannealed sheet (zinc-iron alloy-coated) are, in oz/ft :
A25
A40
A60
As with galvanized product designators, A40 for example, requires a minimum average TST coating
2
weight of 0.40 oz/ft , total-both-sides. While the coating contains approximately 8 to 10% iron, resulting in
the density being slightly higher than a zinc coating and the coating thickness being slightly less than a
G40 galvanize coating, the difference is too small to be of concern. The effect of density is discussed in
the section on 55% Al-Zn coatings, and in GalvInfoNote 1.10. Also, see GalvInfoNote 1.3 for a full
explanation of hot-dip galvanneal coatings.
2
The SI equivalent coating mass designations (ordered as A653M) for galvannealed sheet are, in g/m :
ZF75
ZF120
ZF180
2
ZF120, for example, requires a minimum average TST of 120 g/m total-both-sides.
As with galvanize, the option of ordering zinc-iron coatings to single side, SST coating designations has
been added to A653/A653M. Again, these are SI designations only (ordered to A653M), specifying the
minimum and maximum allowable coating mass per side for any single spot, and taking the familiar form
of automotive coating designations (numeric characters first signifying a per side requirement). No
inch-pound designations are used since single side coatings are traditionally ordered in SI units only.
Examples are:
45A
50A
These designations relate to the minimum and maximum SST value on each surface, e.g., 45A requires a
2
2
minimum of 45 g/m and a maximum of 75 g/m of zinc-iron alloy on each surface for any SST.
When specifying single side, SST coatings, the designation for each surface must be shown, e.g.,
45A45A.
For galvanized and galvannealed sheet, the three-significant figure relationship between coating weight
3
3
[mass] and thickness (based on zinc density of 446 lb/ft [7140 kg/m ]) is:
(1)
For electroplated coatings (pure zinc and zinc-based alloy coatings), SI system (g/m ) designators are
most commonly used, although ASTM Standard A879/A879M for electrogalvanize includes the inch2
pound [oz/ft ] designator system. The reason for the initial use of SI designators is that many
electroplated products were and still are used for automotive applications. Automobile producers, who
implemented worldwide coated sheet specifications many years ago, use only SI units.
For electrogalvanized sheet, common inch-pound coating weight designations (ordered as A879) are, in
2
oz/ft :
08Z
13Z
30Z
These designations relate to the minimum and maximum SST value on each surface, as defined in ASTM
2
A879/A879M, e.g., 13Z requires a minimum of 0.13 and a maximum of 0.23 oz/ft of zinc on each surface
for any SST. Again, the numeric characters come first, signifying per side requirements.
When specifying, the designation for each surface must be shown, e.g., 13Z13Z.
2
For electrogalvanized sheet, common SI coating weight designations (ordered as A879M) are, in g/m :
24G
40G
GalvInfo Center
90G
email: [email protected]
4
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
These designations relate to the minimum and maximum SST value on each surface, as defined in ASTM
2
A879/A879M, e.g., 40G requires a minimum of 40 and a maximum of 90 g/m of zinc on each surface for
any SST.
Again, the designation for each surface must be shown, e.g., 40G40G.
See GalvInfoNote 2.2 for an explanation of the electrogalvanizing process.
A653 Table 1
A653M Table 1
A653 Table 1
A653M Table 1
nnZnnZ
A879
nnGnnG
A879M
nnGnnG
nnAnnA
nnGnnG
nnAnnA
Notes:
Auto (typical) 1
Auto (typical) 2
Coating
Units
Zinc - HD
SST
TST
SST
TST
NONE
Min
Min
Min
NONE
Min
Min
Min
NONE
Min
Min
Min
NONE
Min
Min
Min
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE
NONE *
NONE
NONE
g/m
Zinc-iron - HD
oz/ft
Zinc-iron - HD
g/m
Zinc - EG
oz/ft
Zinc - EG
g/m
Zinc - HD
g/m
Zinc-iron - HD
g/m
Zinc - HD & EG
g/m
Zinc-iron - HD & EG
oz/ft
Zinc - HD
Single Side
g/m
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
5
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
For additional clarification, see Table 3 below, which provides the requirements of selected coating weight
[mass] examples for galvanized sheet made to ASTM specifications.
It is not easy to keep the terminology straight. Users should be aware that both units are in common use
today, and are advised to pay close attention when ordering, knowing precisely what is meant by the
terminology being used. See the Table 4 at the end of this article, which summarizes the designations
used for most hot-dip products, and may be useful in keeping terminology clear.
Example Designation
Requirement
G90
(A653, Table 1, in-lb)
Z275
(A653M, Table 1, SI)
60G60G
c
(A653M, Table S2.1, SI)
A40
(A653, Table 1, in-lb)
ZF120
(A653M, Table 1, SI)
45A45A
(A 53M, Table S2.1, SI)
13Z13Z
(A879, Table 1, in-lb)
40G40G
(A879M, Table 1, SI)
Hot-Dip Galvanize
(A653/A653M)
Hot-Dip Galvanneal
(A653/A653M)
Electrogalvanize
(A879/A879M)
For information purposes, Table S2.1 in A 653M shows inch-pound values for the SI coating designations
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
6
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
Figure 1 is a guideline only for estimating coating thickness in terms of the two systems and is not meant
to suggest equivalency. Also, the values shown are specified minimums. Actual coatings are always a
few percent thicker in order to guarantee the minimums.
Figure 1
HOT-DIP GALVANIZED SHEET
COATING THICKNESS ILLUSTRATOR
(Information only - not for determining equivalency)
G115
2.0
ASTM A653 - Table 1
Coating Weight Designations
Displayed as
Minimum Coating Thickness (mils)
Triple Spot Test (TST)
Total Both Sides
(Each side not necessarily equal)
1.8
1.6
1.4
G90
1.2
G60
1.0
100G100G (98G98G)
G40
0.8
90G90G
G30
0.6
70G70G
60G60G
0.4
50G50G
40G40G
0.2
30G30G
20G20G
0.0
0
10
20
30
40
50
AZ55
AZ60
AZ70
These designations specify the minimum average of a TST, total-both-sides, tested per A924/A924M,
2
e.g., AZ50 requires a minimum average TST of 0.50 oz/ft total-both-sides.
These designators are comparable to those used for galvanized sheet in that the dimensions are oz/ft2.
Be aware, however, that the designation AZ60 is not equivalent to a G60 coating with respect to the
thickness of the coating. Here is where the issue of density comes into play. The coating on 55% Al-Zn
alloy coated sheet has 55% aluminum and about 45% zinc. Actually, the coating has a small addition of
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
7
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
silicon, but for purposes of this discussion the silicon is not important. Since aluminum is less dense than
zinc (a given volume weighs less than the same volume of zinc), an AZ60 coating is thicker than a G60
galvanize coating. See the section on theoretical weight [mass] in GalvInfoNote 1.10 to understand how
differences in coating density affect coated sheet.
Because 55% Al-Zn alloy coating and a galvanize coating behave quite differently with respect to
corrosion processes, drawing a performance equivalency curve is not possible. There is no answer,
therefore, to the question: What 55% Al-Zn alloy coating is equivalent in performance to a G90 coating?
The major use of 55% Al-Zn alloy coated sheet is for construction industry building panels, and for this
application the most common coating weights are AZ50 [AZM150] and AZ55 [AZM165]. As the
differences in performance between these two designators are subtle, ask your supplier which coating
thickness is recommended for your application.
For 55% Al-Zn alloy-coated sheet there is also a SI coating mass designator system (ordered as A792M).
2
The SI equivalents to AZ50, AZ55, AZ60 and AZ70 are, in g/m :
AZM150
AZM165
AZM180
AZM210
These designations specify the minimum average of a TST, total-both-sides, per A924/A924M, e.g.,
2
AZM150 requires a minimum TST of 150 g/m total-both-sides.
Since 55% Al-Zn alloy-coated sheet is produced only by the hot-dip process, there is no additional
terminology or specification related to the manufacture of an electroplated product. Also, there are no
SST, single side designations for this product.
For 55% Al-Zn alloy-coated sheet, the three-significant figure relationship between coating weight [mass]
3
3
and thickness (based on an alloy density of 234 lb/ft [3750 kg/m ]) is:
(2)
See GalvInfoNote 1.4 for a complete description of 55% Al-Zn alloy-coated sheet.
GF45
GF60
GF75
GF90
These designations specify the minimum average of a TST, total-both-sides, tested per A924/A924M,
2
e.g., GF60 requires a minimum average TST of 0.60 oz/ft total-both-sides.
For Zn-5% Al alloy-coated sheet, since the coating contains about 95% zinc, and thus has nearly the
same density as zinc, a GF90 coating is approximately equivalent in thickness to a G90 galvanized
coating.
2
The equivalent SI coating mass designations (ordered as A875M) are, in g/m :
ZGF90
ZGF135
ZGF180
ZGF225
ZGF275
These designations specify the minimum average of a TST, total-both-sides, per A924/A924M, e.g.,
2
ZGF180 requires a minimum TST of 180 g/m total-both-sides.
As with 55% Al-Zn alloy-coated sheet, Zn-5% Al alloy-coated sheet is made only by the hot-dip process
so there are no designator systems that involve per side terminology.
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
8
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
For Zn-5% Al alloy-coated sheet, the three-significant figure relationship between coating weight [mass]
3
3
and thickness (based on an alloy density of 427 lb/ft [6840 kg/m ]) is:
(3)
ZM40
ZM60
ZM75
ZM90
These designations specify the minimum average of a TST, total-both-sides, tested per A924/A924M,
2
e.g., ZM60 requires a minimum average TST of 0.60 oz/ft total-both-sides.
2
The equivalent SI coating mass designations (ordered as A1046M) are, in g/m :
ZMM90
ZMM120
ZMM180
ZMM220
ZMM275
These designations specify the minimum average of a TST, total-both-sides, per A924/A924M, e.g.,
2
ZMM180 requires a minimum TST of 180 g/m total-both-sides.
As with 55% Al-Zn alloy-coated sheet, Zn-Al-Mg alloy-coated sheet is made only by the hot-dip process
so there are no designator systems that involve per side terminology.
For Zn-Al-Mg alloy-coated sheet, the three-significant figure relationship between coating weight [mass]
3
3
3
and thickness (based on a density of 375 lb/ft [6004 kg/m ] for 5-9% Al alloy; and 357 lb/ft [5720
3
kg/m ] for 9-13% Al alloy) is:
(4)
(5)
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
9
GalvInfoNote 1.1
Rev 2.2 Apr 2014
Summary
This article explains the complexities of coating designation systems and hopefully provides a better
understanding of why it is important to be sure that you and your supplier are speaking the same
language. Table 4 gives examples of some of the designators discussed above. See GalvInfoNote 1.10
for an explanation of how coatings affect the metrics of coated steel sheet products.
Coating Weight
inch-pound
2
oz/ft
Coating Mass
SI
2
g/m
G90
Z275
0.90
275
ASTM A653/A653M
Galvanneal
A40
ZF120
0.40
120
ASTM A792/A792M
55% Al-Zn alloy-coated
AZ55
AZM165
0.55
165
ASTM A875/A875M
Zn-5% Al alloy-coated
GF75
ZGF225
0.75
225
ASTM A1046/A1046M
Zn-Al-Mg alloy-coated
ZM90
ZMM275
0.90
275
N/A*
60G
0.20
60
N/A*
45A
0.15
45
ASTM A879/A879M
Electrogalvanize
13Z
40G
0.13
40
Automotive Specified
Galvanize
N/A*
100G
N/A*
100
Automotive Specified
Galvanneal
N/A*
45A
N/A*
45
ASTM A653M
Galvanneal (Table S2.1)
* Not Applicable
++
Single side designators are used to specify the coating mass for each side and are written, for example, 60G60G, or in the
case of differential coating masses, 90G60G.
Disclaimer:
Articles, research reports, and technical data are provided for information purposes only. Although the publishers endeavor to
provide accurate, timely information, the International Zinc Association does not warrant the research results or information reported
in this communication and disclaims all liability for damages arising from reliance on the research results or other information
contained in this communication, including, but not limited to, incidental or consequential damages.
GalvInfo Center
email: [email protected]
10