Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 5K views

    Panel Discussion Rubric

    Uploaded by

    A-r Samsico
    This rubric evaluates panelists on five criteria for an oral panel discussion presentation: content, preparation, voice, posture and eye contact, and interaction with other panel members. For content, the panelist would be rated on their understanding of the topic and ability to answer questions. For preparation, they would be rated on how prepared and rehearsed they seem. For voice, they would be rated on clarity, pronunciation, and volume. For posture and eye contact, they would be rated on how they present themselves and engage their audience. Finally, for interaction, they would be rated on how they collaborate with other panel members. Panelists could receive scores from 1-10 on each criterion, with higher scores indicating stronger performance in that

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Panel Discussion Rubric

    Uploaded by

    A-r Samsico
    5K views2 pages
    This rubric evaluates panelists on five criteria for an oral panel discussion presentation: content, preparation, voice, posture and eye contact, and interaction with other panel members. For content, the panelist would be rated on their understanding of the topic and ability to answer questions. For preparation, they would be rated on how prepared and rehearsed they seem. For voice, they would be rated on clarity, pronunciation, and volume. For posture and eye contact, they would be rated on how they present themselves and engage their audience. Finally, for interaction, they would be rated on how they collaborate with other panel members. Panelists could receive scores from 1-10 on each criterion, with higher scores indicating stronger performance in that

    Original Description:

    Panel Discussion Rubric, wherein the panel can see the discussions with the rubrics specified.

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    This rubric evaluates panelists on five criteria for an oral panel discussion presentation: content, preparation, voice, posture and eye contact, and interaction with other panel members. For content, the panelist would be rated on their understanding of the topic and ability to answer questions. For preparation, they would be rated on how prepared and rehearsed they seem. For voice, they would be rated on clarity, pronunciation, and volume. For posture and eye contact, they would be rated on how they present themselves and engage their audience. Finally, for interaction, they would be rated on how they collaborate with other panel members. Panelists could receive scores from 1-10 on each criterion, with higher scores indicating stronger performance in that

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    5K views2 pages

    Panel Discussion Rubric

    Uploaded by

    A-r Samsico
    This rubric evaluates panelists on five criteria for an oral panel discussion presentation: content, preparation, voice, posture and eye contact, and interaction with other panel members. For content, the panelist would be rated on their understanding of the topic and ability to answer questions. For preparation, they would be rated on how prepared and rehearsed they seem. For voice, they would be rated on clarity, pronunciation, and volume. For posture and eye contact, they would be rated on how they present themselves and engage their audience. Finally, for interaction, they would be rated on how they collaborate with other panel members. Panelists could receive scores from 1-10 on each criterion, with higher scores indicating stronger performance in that

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 2

    ORAL PRESENTATION RUBRIC: PANEL DISCUSSION

    CATEGORY

    CONTENT

    PREPARATION

    VOICE

    POSTURE AND EYE


    CONTACT

    INTERACTION WITH
    OTHER PANEL
    MEMBERS

    LEVEL 4 (8-10 pts.)

    LEVEL 3 (5-7 pts.)

    LEVEL 2 (3-2 pts.)

    LEVEL 1 (1-2 pts.)

    Shows a good understanding of parts of


    the topic and accurately answers a few
    questions posed by classmates about the
    topic.
    somewhat prepared, but it is clear that
    rehearsal was lacking. Stays on topic some
    (89%-75%) of the time.

    Does not seem to understand the topic


    very well and unable to answer questions
    posed by classmates about the topic.

    Speaks clearly and distinctly all (100-95%) the


    time, but mispronounces one word. Volume of
    voice is loud enough to be heard by all audience
    members at least 90% of the time.

    Speaks clearly and distinctly most ( 9485%) of the time. Mispronounces no more
    than one word. Volume of voice is loud
    enough to be heard by all audience
    members at least 80% of the time.

    Often mumbles or can not be understood


    OR mispronounces more than one word.
    Volume of voice is often too soft to be
    heard by all audience members.

    Stands up straight and establishes eye contact


    with everyone in the room during the
    presentation. Facial expressions and body
    language sometimes generate a strong interest
    and enthusiasm about the topic in others.

    Sometimes stands up straight and


    establishes eye contact. Facial expressions
    and body language are used to try to
    generate enthusiasm, but seem somewhat
    faked.

    Slouches and/or does not look at people


    during the presentation. Very little use of
    facial expressions or body language. Did
    not generate much interest in topic being
    presented.

    Often listens to, but shares little with


    others in the group.

    Rarely listens to, shares with, and


    supports the efforts of others in the
    group. Sometimes plays with items that
    distract the attention from the speaker.

    Shows a full understanding of the topic


    and accurately answers almost all
    questions posed by classmates about
    the topic.
    Completely prepared and has obviously
    rehearsed. Stays on topic all (100%) of
    the time.

    Shows a good understanding of the topic and


    accurately answers most questions posed by
    classmates about the topic.

    Speaks clearly and distinctly all (10095%) the time, and mispronounces no
    words. Volume of voice is loud enough
    to be heard by all audience members
    throught the presentation.
    Stands up straight, looks relaxed and
    confident. Establishes eye contact with
    everyone in the room during the
    presentation. Facial expressions and
    body language generate a strong
    interest and enthusiasm about the
    topic.

    Seems pretty prepared but might have needed a


    couple more rehearsals. Stays on topic most (9990%) of the time.

    Almost always listens to, shares with, Usually listens to, shares with, and supports the
    and supports the efforts of others in
    efforts of others in the group
    the group. Tries to keep the discussion
    going.

    Does not seem at all prepared to present.


    It was hard to tell what the topic was.

    Group #: _________
    Topic: ______________________________________________
    CATEGORY

    Content

    Preparation

    Voice

    Posture & Eye Contact

    Interaction with Panelists

    MEMBERS
    1. ________________________________________

    __________

    ___________

    ________

    _________

    ___________

    2. ________________________________________

    __________

    ___________

    ________

    _________

    ___________

    3. ________________________________________

    __________

    ___________

    ________

    _________

    ___________

    4. ________________________________________

    __________

    ___________

    ________

    _________

    ___________

    5. ________________________________________

    __________

    ___________

    ________

    _________

    ___________

    6. ________________________________________

    __________

    ___________

    ________

    _________

    ___________

    Comments:

    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    You might also like