Corporate Finance MG TN DLM
Corporate Finance MG TN DLM
Corporate Finance MG TN DLM
TRAINING MODULE ON
CORPORATE
FINANCE MANAGEMENT
[Non-DLM]
CONTENTS
Sl.
No.
I
Particulars
Page
No.
3-36
37-81
82-109
110-150
Capital Management : a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
Capital Structure
Capital budgeting decisions
Measurement of risk
Cost of Capital including CAP -M
Valuation of fixed Income Securities
Valuation of Bonds and Stocks
151-217
Portfolio Management
232-323
Derivatives
324-345
346-470
Note: - Each learning unit contains three portions; (1) Group Activity (2) Reading
Material and (3) Instructions to Faculty
Aim:
Value based investment or expenditure is the essence of the Financial Management.
Every suitable financial concept must be analyzed and applied from the viewpoint of
each stake holder before final decisions are taken. New financial concepts including
derivatives, portfolio management etc., are introduced in this training design in order to
enable Financial Managers and Senior Executives to arrive at better alternative
investment decisions. Analysis of financial portions of economics will also enable them
to draft legislation or improve existing legislation to protect the interest of stake holders
and to curb the speculations and malpractices.
Therefore, the aim of this training programme is to facilitate practicing Finance Managers
from the Finance Department of State Governments and Senior Executives from
Administrative Departments to understand and analyze financial statements with a view
to taking corporate finance decisions.
Training Need
There is an ever-increasing need to meet the changing scenario in the management of
government departments, local bodies, autonomous bodies and PSUs. The changes are
felt from the following angles:
Public interest
High quality and understandable documentation
Uniform internal and external accounting and financial documentation system
Uniforms internal and external financial rules and regulations
Enforceable global accounting standards.
Transparency in financial information and procedures.
Uniform financial statements from the point of view of effective comparison.
Uniformity in financial reporting system.
Introduction of enforceable penal provisions.
Consultation system to determine high quality solutions.
Quick availability of financial information, to all.
Implementation of some of the above ideas may take fairly a long time. But the felt need
is to prepare the present financial managers and the senior executives for changes in the
system with a view to orienting them to improved levels of efficiency and effectiveness.
Phases of Training
To achieve the above aims, training is designed in the following 7 Learning Units in two
phases.
Phase-I
1. Basics of Commercial Accounting System including Balance Sheets;
2. Discounted Cash Flow Technique and Internal Rate of returns.
3. Budget, cost and benefits
3.1 Performance budgeting
3.2 Zero Base Budgeting
3.3 Cost Benefit Analysis
4. Management of Capital
4.1 Capital Structure
4.2 Capital budgeting decisions
4.3 Measurement of risk
4.4 Cost of Capital, including CAP-M
4.5 Valuation of Fixed Income Securities
4.6 Valuation of Bonds and Stocks
Phase-II
5. Portfolio Management
6. Derivatives
7. International Financial Management
Duration
10 days each for each phase of training, totally 20 days.
Target Group
1. Officers from the rank of Deputy Controllers and above from the State
Accounts Department
2. Selection Scale KAS officers and IAS Officers having 6 to 9 years experience
3. Senior officers from PSUs and autonomous bodies
Guide to Facilitators/Faculty
The Facilitators/Faculty members may use the Instructions to Faculty exclusively
designed for this package.
The time for lecture is limited to the extent noted in the Instructions to Faculty. 80% of
time is meant for participants, who will learn on their own through group activities,
developed in the form questions and answers. Participants will seek solutions to
problems. There will be exercises using case studies. In addition there will be problem
solving activities. Participants will also be provided material for reading. They will be
exposed to techniques for preparing visual aids for more persuasive and effective
presentation.
The role of the facilitators will be to guide the participants during group discussion and to
moderate the presentations made by each group.
Activities/Process
10.00- 10.30
am
10.30 to
11.30 a.m.
Ice Breaking
Introductory activities.
11.30 - 11.45
am
11.45 am 12.45 pm
Tea/Coffee break
Course
Objectives
Training
techniques
Group
formation
12.45 - 1.30
pm
Visit to
library
1.30 - 2.30
pm
Learning Unit - 1
DAY 1 contd.
Learning Unit - 1
Afternoon Session:
Time &
Subject
2.30 p.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Learning unit
I
Basics of
Commercial
Accounting
and Balance
Sheet
Activities/Process
Faculty
to
use
the
'Instructions to Faculty' in
Brief presentation on the objectives of L.U -1 as guide for the
LU-1: Basics of Commercial Accounting initial presentation
and Balance Sheet.
Faculty should demonstrate
Story telling on starting of business transactions under each
with details of (i) own capital (ii) loan and sub-unit with examples.
transactions
related
to
personal
accounts, asset accounts, Nominal
accounts, trading and profit and loss
account and balance sheet summing up
of the first day proceedings.
Commencement of LU-1
DAY 2
Learning Unit - 1
9.30 to 5.30
pm
Basics of
Commercial
Accounting
and Balance
Sheet
Understanding
the contents of
reading
materials
Assignment of
frames to
groups
Group Activities:
Recap on the first day proceedings.
Before commencement of group activities Faculty to clarify doubts, if
each participant will be provided time to any, with reference to
contents
of
reading
go through the reading material on LU-1
material.
Group activities will be carried out as per
the instructions in the Handout on Group
Activity LU-1, which will be supplied to
each participant.
Frame details
Day 3
Learning Unit - 1
Forenoon and afternoon Sessions :
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Basics of
Commercial
Accounting
and Balance
Sheet
Presentations
by groups
Learning
Points
10
Moderation by faculty
Learning Unit - 2
Use the SPPWF and USPWF tables to calculate the PV of cost and returns.
11
Day -4.
Learning Unit - 2
Forenoon and Afternoon Sessions:
Time &
Subject
9.30 p.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Activities/Process
Recap on LU-1 with reference to 10 key
questions as listed in LU-2 (instructions to
faculty)
Commencement of LU-2
DCFT and
IRR
Application
of DCFT
Calculation
of IRR
12
Day 5
Learning Unit - 2
Forenoon and afternoon Sessions:
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
11.30 a.m.
Recap
DCFT and
IRR contd.
11.45 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
DCFT and
IRR contd.
Presentations
13
Learning Unit - 3
Budget
Sub-Units
A. Performance Budgeting
B. Zero Base Budgeting
C. Cost-benefit analysis
Sub Unit A
Performance Budgeting
Objectives :At the end of the learning unit, the participants will be able to:
Sub Unit B
Zero Base Budgeting
Objectives:At the end of this learning Unit, the participants will be able to:
1. List the steps to be followed for the preparation of Zero Base Budgeting
2. Identify the decision units and the decision packages
3. Identify and rename the redundant expenditure
4. Rationalize expenditure by removing repetitive expenditure items
5. Design decision packages
6. Review the necessity of continuance of on-going expenditure
7. Determine the different levels of funding
8. Use ranking methods for prioritization of decision packages.
14
Sub Unit C
Cost Benefit Analysis
Objectives:At the end of this learning Unit, the participant will be able to:
Identify and use social rate of discount for cost benefit analysis
Undertake risk and uncertainty analysis for decisions with reference to a social
projects
15
Day 6
Learning Unit - 3
Forenoon and Afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Performance
Budgeting,
Zero Base
Budgeting
and Cost
Benefit
Analysis
Designing a
responsibility
centre
Designing a
decision
package
Case study:
CBA
16
Day 7
Learning Unit - 3
Forenoon and afternoon Session
Time
& Activities/Process
Subject
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
CBA
Presentations
Learning
points
17
Learning Unit - 4
Capital Management
Objectives :At the end of this learning unit the participants will be able to:
01.
02.
03.
Value the estimated future benefits that will accrue to the firm over a series of
years.
Understand the implications of long-term investments.
04.
05.
06.
07.
08.
09.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
and
the
Modigliani-Miller
structure.
20.
Employ yield measures like current yield, yield to maturity, yield to call and
realized yield to maturity.
21.
22.
18
Day- 8.
Learning Unit - 4
Forenoon and Afternoon Session
Time & Subject
9.30 p.m. to 5.30 p.m.
Activities/Process
Recap on L.U.3
Commencement of LU-4
Faculty to preferably
use the 9 visual aids
provided in the reading
material
for
LU-4.
Details
should
be
explained
as
per
contents in the handout
on
Instructions
to
faculty
on
Capital
Management'.
Capital Management
Investment
criteria
CAPM
MM
WACC
Valuations
Risk
measurement
Capital budgeting
Faculty
to
make
a
brief
presentation to explain concepts of
investment
criteria,
CAPM
approach, MM approach, WACC,
valuations,
risk
measurement
DEMAT system and the working
of depository system in India; and
capital budgeting.
Group Activities
The existing four groups will be
converted into 3 groups
Assignment of tasks to
groups
Faculty/facilitator
to
guide the groups on the
material
Group 2: (a) Measurement of risk reading
available
for
reference.
(b) Cost of capital, including
CAPM.
Focus to be on 24
Group 3: (a) Valuation of fixed
questions listed in the
income securities, (b) Valuation of
Handout on Capital
bonds and stocks
Based on the books borrowed from Management in LU-4.
the library and the reading
materials, the groups will have Faculty to give clues to
discussion with reference to: (a) the references for the 24
conceptual clarity, (b) meaning, (c) questions.
utility or scope for application, (d)
illustrations and examples.
19
Day- 9.
Learning Unit - 4
Forenoon and Afternoon Session
Time & Subject
9.30 p.m. to 5.30 p.m.
Activities/Process
Recap on 8th day proceedings
Group activities to be continued on
Day-9.
20
Day 10
Learning Unit - 4
Forenoon & Afternoon Session
Time & Subject
Activities/Process
Valuation of Fixed
Income Securities and
Bonds and Stocks
Learning points on
Capital management
21
Phase 2
10 days
With support from
Department of Personnel & Training, Government of India
and
UNDP
22
Contents
1. Portfolio Management
2. Derivatives
3. International financial Management
{Note: The Second Phase Training is meant for the participants, who
have undergone training in the first phase}
23
Activities/Process
9.30 to
10.30 a.m.
10.30 a.m.
to
1.45 p.m.
2.30 pm to
5.30 pm
Learning Units
Visit to the Library to collect books
and journals on topics incorporated in
Phase-2 Learning Units.
24
Facilitator to analyze
the expectations of the
participants.
Facilitators to explain
the salient features of
the phase-2 training.
Facilitator to explain
how to use the reading
materials and books to
carry out the group
activities effectively.
Facilitator to assist the
participants
in
the
selection of books.
Learning Unit - 5
Portfolio Management
Objectives :
At the end of this learning unit, the participants will be able to;
Interpret the basic principles required for designing, analyzing and managing a
portfolio
Decide the proportions of the total funds that should be invested in each security.
Take decisions on asset allocation and on the choice of securities within each
broad category of asset.
25
Day - 2
Learning Unit - 5
Forenoon & Afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Portfolio
Management
Group activities
Assignment
of topics
26
Day - 3
Learning Unit - 5
Forenoon & Afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
Recap
on
the
proceedings
Group Activities on
will continue for the
day.
Summing up of the
proceedings.
27
DAY 4
Learning Unit - 5
Forenoon and afternoon Sessions:
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Firms
specific
analysis
Modern
Portfolio
theory
Asset
Allocation
and Portfolio
Design
28
Learning Unit - 6
Derivatives
At the end of this learning unit, the participants will be able to:
01.
02.
03.
04.
05.
06.
29
Day 5
Learning Unit - 6
Forenoon and Afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 p.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Derivatives
Recap on L.U.5
Commencement of LU-6
Group tasks
30
Day 6
Learning Unit - 6
Forenoon and afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Derivatives
Focus on
questions and
mini cases
31
Day 6
Learning Unit - 6
Forenoon and afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
32
Learning Unit - 7
02.
Acquire the skills of conversion rates, by bid price, ask price and spread
03.
04.
05.
06.
07.
08.
09.
33
Day 8
Learning Unit - 7
Forenoon and afternoon Session
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Recap on L.U.6.
Commencement of LU 7
International Financial Management.
International
Financial
Management
Focus on 15
problems and
two cases
Case on guns
Case on
helicopters.
develop
visual
aids
34
for
Day 9
Learning Unit - 7
Forenoon and afternoon Session
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
Recap on the proceedings of Day 8.
Group activities on L.U.7 will continue on
Day 9.
Summing up of the Day 9 proceedings.
35
Day 10
Learning Unit - 7
Forenoon and afternoon Sessions:
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
1.30 p.m.
Recap
International
Financial
Management
Presentation
2.30 p.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Conclusion
36
LEARNING UNIT - I
BASICS OF COMMERCIAL
ACCOUNTING
AND BALANCE SHEET
GROUP ACTIVITIES
37
Group Activities
Learning Unit 1
1.
1.1.
1.2.
1.3.
Participants may refer to the reading material provided and the books
borrowed from Library for the group activities.
1.4.
1.5.
Each group will be given 30 minutes for presentation. Faculty members will
moderate the presentation.
2.
2.1.
2.2.
Group Tasks
Tasks will be assigned to all four groups in the form of Frames, which follow
this section. There are a total of eight frames, each dealing with the Basics of
Commercial Accounting and Balance Sheets. The frames are in the form of
simple questions; fill in the blanks, true/false. There are also questions which
require analysis and problem solving. Groups will be asked to discuss and
solve the issues/ questions given in the different frames:
38
hostel rooms in the evening, if the class time is not sufficient. Groups which
complete their task early may assist the other groups.
2.3.
3.
Presentations will be made in the forenoon session on the next day. At the
end of the presentation each group will list important learning points for
reinforcement.
The Frames
(Questions and Problems are taken out from the book ` Fundamentals of Double entry and Book Keeping
by Prof. J.R. Batliboi)
Frame-1
Answer the following and fill in the blanks:
(1) Accounts can be classified into three. They are:
(i)
____________________________
(ii)
____________________________
(iii)
____________________________
(2) Ledger Account has two sides. The left hand side is called _________ side and
right hand side called as ________ side.
(3) The debiting and crediting procedure followed in personal accounts are
(a) ________ (b) _________
(4) The debiting and crediting procedure followed in Asset accounts are (a) _________
(b) _____________
(5) The debiting and crediting procedure followed in nominal accounts are
(i)
---------------------------
(ii)
----------------------------
(6) If Mr. A sell goods worth Rs.500/- to Mr. B on credit basis, which accounts are
affected in the books of Mr. A? How is it affected, and why? Similarly how will the
accounts be treated in the books of Mr. B?
(7) If Mr. A sells the goods worth Rs.200/- on cash payment to Mr. B, how will you treat
the accounts in the books of Mr. A and in the books of Mr. B?
39
(8) On the deposits of Mr. X, the Bank paid an interest of Rs.250/-. How will you
account for the interest in the book of Mr. X ?
Frame - 2
Answer the following questions and fill in the blanks
1) Make a list of subsidiary records and indicate the purpose for which they are
maintained in an organisation.
2) Discount is an ____________ account. Therefore, when a discount is received it
shall be__________ and when discount is given to others it shall be _________
3) When a Self Cheque is drawn, the cash column in the Bank shall be _____ and
_____ column will be credited in the cash book
4) The excess of debit over credit is _______ balance.
5) The excess of credit over debit is_______ balance.
6) The debit balance should be posted on the ______ side of its account.
7) The credit balance should be posted on the ________ side of the account.
8) The LF stands for _____________
9) The letter C in cash book stands for ___________ meaning ____________
10) The Cash Account in cash book must always show _____ balance.
11) The credit balance of Bank Account in Cash Book means _____________
True or false/ Agree or Disagree:
12) When a cheque is issued to a party debit the bank column and credit the cash
column. (True or false) If incorrect, what are the correct entries and how should they
be recorded in the Cash Book.
13) One must always go for major cash transaction in the Office, instead of going for
transactions through Bank. (Agree or disagree) Give reasons for your answer.
40
Frame 3
Theoretically, you have understood how Trial Balance is prepared.
The Faculty has also explained to you with examples how Trial Balance is prepared by
taking into account all the Ledger Account Balances.
Now with reference to the following prepare a Trial Balance in your group
41
--------------------------------
1,50,000
55,000
85,000
2,500
15,750
4,000
5,000
12,200
4,500
1,700
900
600
575
2,700
1,260
50,450
96,000
1,65,000
2,100
125
3,750
2,115
1,070
25,000
960
6,400
300
75
6,000
85,420
88,650
Frame 4
Prepare a Trading Account, with the following details.
Sales
Returns inwards
Closing Stock
Stock at commencement
Purchases
Return outwards
Carriage inwards
Duty and Clearing
---------
32,000
2,000
9,000
7,500
16,000
400
400
1,500
Frame 5
Prepare a Profit and Loss Account with the following details. The Gross Profit is Rs.1,
88,906.
Salaries
General Expenses
Carriage outwards
Insurance and taxes
Stable expenses for distribution
Discount paid
Interest and Bank charges
Old Reserve
Reserved for bad and doubtful
debts
Bad Debts
Plant and Machinery:
Depreciation
Fixtures and fittings :
Depreciation
Houses and carts
----------
31,930
16,284
4,300
8,350
4,946
1,856
950
4,000
7,814
----
2,970
---
948
2,000
Commission:
a) Works manager at 1% of Rs.1,88,906
b) General Manager at 5% of Rs.1,05,704
42
3,944
Frame : 6
Based on the Frame 5, i.e., after preparing Profit and Loss Account, prepare a Balance
Sheet with the following additional information.
Capital
Bank Loan
Creditors on open accounts
Outstanding Liabilities
Good will
Free hold works
Plant & Machinery
Fixtures and Fittings
Houses & Carts
Stock in Trade
Sundry Debtors
Reserve for doubtful debts
Expenses prepaid
Cash at Bank
Cash in hand
----------------
1,60,000
20,000
1,08,320
7,174
60,000
50,000
39,440
18,960
10,330
59,260
1,56,280
7,814
980
15,080
290
Frame 7
Liabilities
Money Subscribed by
Shareholders
Long Term Loan owed
to financial institution
Bank over draft
Total
Rs.
Assets
Rs.
21,000
Raw Materials etc.,
7,000
Total
Focus will be on reading financial health of the organisation with reference to liquidity,
profitability, stability, credibility and activity ratios.
43
The balance sheet table relates to the assets and liabilities of _________.
Balance sheet must always _______.
________ show the source of money and ________ show how the money is used.
In this balance sheet _________ is missing.
Can the skills of highly trained technicians be expressed in monetary terms and
shown in a Balance Sheet?
(f) What are the supporting documents required to read a Balance Sheet ?
Level Two:
(a) Assets can be grouped into ______ and ______
(b) Current assets can be grouped into _______ and _______
(c) Give examples for fixed assets
(d) Cash in banks and in hand are called ____ assets
(e) Inventories are quick assets (correct/incorrect)
(f) Assets intended for long term use are _____ assets
(g) Fixed assets vary on day-to-day basis (correct/Incorrect)
(h) What is an operating Cycle ? The operating cycle will normally be less
than ____ year.
(i) Assets which can be converted into cash within the operating cycle is called as
________ assets.
(j) Finished product stocks are ___________ asset.
(k) Raw materials are _______ asset
(l) Work-in-progress are _______ asset
(m) Account receivable are ____________ asset
(n) Marketable securities are _______ asset.
Level Three:
(a) Current asset are more liquid than _______ assets
(b) Cash is a _________ asset
Level Four:
(a) How do you value inventories ?
(b) How do you value the fixed assets like :
(i) Buildings
(ii) Plant and machinery
44
(iii) Vehicles
(iv)
Land
(c) If assets are over valued what are the consequences ?
Level Five
(a) The depreciation and provision for doubtful items increase/reduce the value of the
assets.
(b) Marketable securities are shown on the _____. In balance sheets they should be
indicated as _________
Level Six:
(a) Fixed assets are valued at ______ less ______
(b) Goods will be a ____ asset arising from the ______
Level Seven:
(a) _____________ liabilities shall be met within one year.
(b) Long-term liabilities are knows as ________ liabilities
(c) Debenture is a ________ term loan
Level Eight:
(a) What is the difference between the Capital Authorised and the Capital Subscribed
(b) Who are the owners of the company ?
(c) Share holders will be paid interest (Correct/incorrect)
(d) What will be paid to the share holders ?
(e) Portion of the profit retained by the Company called as _________
(f) What is the difference between the revenue reserve and capital reserve
(g) For what purpose can a company retain a portion of profits in the form of revenue
reserve ?
(h) Why is dividend to share holders not be paid from Capital Reserve ?
(i) Does shareholders funds have to be returned ? If so, when ?
(j) Profit out of sale of fixed assets is _______ reserve.
(k) What is the difference between the ordinary shares and the preference shares ?
(l) What compensation will shareholders get at the time of winding up a company?
(m) Increased value from the revaluation of fixed assets is called ____ reserve.
Level Nine:
(a) What are outside and inside liabilities?
(b) When enterprise can be called as solvent ?
(c) If assets are greater than outside liabilities; what does it reflect?
(d) How do you measure liquidity ?
45
(f) If current liabilities are less than current assets; what does it reflect?
(g) What is net working capital
(h) What is gearing? If gearing is 4:1 what does it reflects? If gearing it 1:4, what does
it reflect ?
(i) Why should the balance sheet of the current year be compared with the balance sheet
of the previous year ? What statement can be prepared from the comparison ?
(j) How can sources and uses of funds be prepared ?
(k) What are the sources of new funds ? Give examples.
(l) For what purpose can new funds be used ? Give Examples.
(m) Can money actually leave the business on account of depreciation shown in Profit
and Loss Account? Yes or No. Give reasons
Level Ten:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
Frame. 8
Calculate the following for the years 1990 and 1991 using figures in the balance sheet
and Profit and Loss Account given below:
(a) Return on Capital employed
(b) Current Ratio;
(c) Debt/Equity Ratio;
46
800
700
800
800
1,200
4,300
1,000
800
2,000
1,000
900
5,700
1,000
1,000
2,400
1,500
1,100
7,000
2,800
920
1,880
1,520
480
420
2420
4,300
3,000
1,400
1,600
2,400
500
1,200
4,100
5,700
4,000
2,000
2,000
2,800
900
1,300
5,000
7,000
Assets :
Fixed Assets :
Less: Depreciation
Stock
Debtors
Other Current Assets
Total Assets
47
(Rs in lakhs)
1990
1991
4,800
7,200
1,500
480
420
300
100
2,400
600
600
600
150
Solution to Frame 8:
Note: At the end of group discussion, this portion shall be supplied to enable the
participants to compare their answers.
1990
1991
Computation of Ratios:
(a) Return on Capital Employed:
Profit before interest, & Tax
------------------------------ X 100
Average Capital Employed
1020
1800
------ X 100 = ------- X 100
3050
4100
33.44%
4100
-----1900
5000
= -----2600
2.16
= 1.92
2000
-----1800
1.11
2400
= -----2000
= 1.20
= 43.90 %
=
=
=
=
4800
-----1740
2.76 times
7200
= ------1800
= 4.00 times
48
3300
-----1960
1.68 times
4800
= -----2600
1.85 times
300
600
------ = Rs.3 ------ = Rs.6
100
100
300
----- = Rs.3
100 times
600
----150
= Rs.4
times
(Rs. in lakhs)
1989
1990
1991
4,300
5,700
7,000
800
1,000
1,200 - 2000 900 -1900
2300 + 3800
----------------2
=
3.050
1500
1100 - 2600
3800 + 4400
---------------2
=
4,100
(2) Debt:
Secured Term Loans:
(3) Equity:
Share Capital
Reserve & Surplus
2,000
2,400
1,000
800
1,800
1,000
1,000
2,000
2,400
500
1,200
4,100
2,800
900
1,300
5,000
1,900
2,600
1,520
2,400
2,800
1520 + 2400
2400 + 2800
2
2
=
1,960
=
2,600
1,500
480
1,020
2,400
600
1,800
1,500
2,400
1,200
300
1,800
600
4,800
7,200
1,500
3,300
2,400
4,800
(9)
(10)
1880
1,600
2,000
1880 + 1600
2
1600 + 2000
2
1,740
50
1,800
LEARNING UNIT - I
BASICS OF COMMERCIAL
ACCOUNTING
AND BALANCE SHEET
READING MATERIAL
51
Learning Unit - 1
Reading Material
Basics of Commercial Accounting and Balance Sheets
1.
1.1.
2.
2.1.
Accounting Policy
An organization must have a policy regarding accounting procedure,
valuation of assets and documentation for the purpose of consistency,
transparency, uniformity and accountability.
Focus
One of the basics of Commercial Accounts is the double-entry system. The
fundamentals of double entry will focus on :
2.2.
3.
3.1.
The learner must understand the salient features of the sub-units listed above.
The objective is to enable the learner to acquire a proper foundation to skills
relating to the reading of balance sheets and thus enable the learner to take
appropriate financial decisions.
52
4.
4.1.
1.
Classification
There are 3 kinds of accounts: (i) Personal Account, (ii) Asset Account and
(iii) Nominal Account. A description is each of these is given below.
Example 1:
Personal Account:
Mr. X sold goods worth Rs.600 to Mr. Y on credit basis.
This means that Mr. Y did not pay cash immediately. In other words, for the
moment i.e., on the same day, no cash transactions have taken place. It may therefore be
noted that in case of credit transactions, personal accounts are opened to indicate to be
paid or to be received.
In the books of Mr. X the personal account of Y has to be debited. Since Y
received the benefit, it must show that Y is yet to pay X.
In the books of Mr. Y, the personal account of Mr. X has to be credited. Since
X has imparted the benefit, it must show that Y is owes money to X.
2. Asset Account: Asset Account is an all encompassing account covering cash, goods,
cash at bank, furniture, machines, buildings, plants, lands, vehicles, semi- finished goods,
raw material, etc. The principles of asset account are:
? Debit what comes in
and
? Credit what goes out
In the example given in the box above, the goods account is also affected by the
transaction. The goods account is an asset account.
Now, keeping in view the principle of debit what comes in, the books of Mr. Y will
debit the goods account since goods have come into Mr. Y's possession.
Similarly, keeping in view the principle of credit what goes out, the books of Mr. X will
credit the goods account since goods have gone out from Mr. X's possession.
53
3 Nominal Account: The nominal account is based on the following principles, namely:
? Debit all expenses or losses
? Credit all gains or income
Rent, salaries, wages, Printing, Stationery, discount, coolie charges, discount, travelling
expenses, commission etc., are some of the nominal accounts.
Example 2:
Nominal Account
Mr. X paid rent of Rs.200 to Mr. Y in cash.
In the books of Mr. 'X debit the rent account and credit the cash account
and
In the books of Mr. Y debit the cash Account and credit the rent account
Note: - In case of fully paid cash transactions personal accounts will not be affected. If
cash is due and not paid, then personal accounts will be affected.
In this example, rent account is a nominal account and the cash account is an asset
account.
5.
Accounts Book
5.1.
The following are the important accounts books that shall be maintained
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
Cash Book
Purchase Book
Purchase returns Book
Sales Book
Sales returns book
Bills Receivable Book
Bills Payable Book
Journal Proper
5.1.1.
Cash Book: There are many types of cash books, but our focus will be
on cash book with Cash, Bank and discount columns on both sides.
Both sides mean one on debit side and the other on credit side.
5.1.2.
It must be ensured that the postings in cash book are made correctly
before the cash book is signed daily. Following are the important
points to be seen.
? The receipts will be entered on the debit side
54
is allowed when
as a loss. Cash
the debit side of
being a nominal
Points to note:
? When cash is drawn from Bank for office use, debit cash account and credit bank
account. Mark C on both sides of the L.F. Column.
? Strike balance with reference to cash columns. The cash column always shows
the debit balance.
? Debit balance means cash receipts are more than cash payments. Post the debit
balance of cash to the credit side of cash column and balance it. (Similarly do it
for Bank Column separately)
55
5.1.4.
Purchases Book: The goods purchased on credit basis for resale will
be entered in the purchases book. Proper filing of invoices in
consecutive order is sufficient instead of maintaining purchases book.
5.1.5.
5.1.6.
Sales Book: Credit sales are recorded in the Sales Book i.e., goods
sold on credit basis. For each credit sale outward, invoice shall be
prepared
5.1.7.
Sales returns book: When goods sold are returned, entries will be
made in this book. Credit notes shall be issued on receipt of goods
(returned back)
5.1.8.
5.1.9.
Bills payable book: The bill accepted by the trader shall be paid by
him on the due date. The details of bills payable will be recorded in
this book.
Journal proper: If any transaction does not find place in the above said
books i.e., from cash book to bills payable book, the journal proper
book will be used. This Journal Proper Book is used for the following
purposes :-
5.1.10.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
56
6.
Balancing
6.1.
Till now, we have studied about all the Accounts Books to be maintained,
namely cash book, purchases book, purchases return book, sales book, sales
returns book, Bills receivable book, Bills payable book and journal proper.
All these books are called Books of Original Entry. From these books
Ledger Accounts will be opened. The Ledger Accounts will have two sides;
the debit side and the credit side. If the debit is more than the credit side, it
will be called as debit balance. If the credit side is more than the debit side,
it will be called as credit balances.
6.2.
The debit balance will be posted on the credit side to balance the accounts
and the credit balance will be posted on the debit side to balance the
accounts. This balancing will normally be done at the month end and also at
the end of the Accounting Year.
6.3.
The debit balance of Personal Account shows outstanding asset. The credit
balance of Personal Account, shows outstanding liability.
6.4.
The credit balance of Nominal Accounts shows gain. The debit balance of
Nominal Account shows loss or expenses
7.
7.1.
8.
Capital Account
The amount brought in to the business by a trader will be credited to Capital
Account
Drawings Account
8.1.
Amount drawn for personal use from business will be debited to drawings
account.
8.2.
8.3.
Every trader must maintain separate accounts for each personal account i.e.,
for each persons, each organization i.e., name-wise etc.
57
9.
9.1.
For every debit entry there will be a corresponding credit entry. Taking all
the ledger accounts into consideration, the total of debit balances must be
equal to the total of credit balances. Only for clerical errors it may not tally.
Otherwise it must tally.
9.2.
At the end of the accounting year all the ledger accounts will be balanced. If
it is a debit balance it will taken to debit column of trial balance. If it is a
credit balance, it will be taken to the credit column of trial balance.
9.3.
9.4.
Particulars
Ledger folio
Debit-column
Credit Column
Total of debit and credit columns
The Trading Account shows the gross profit. Gross profit means :
[A] Proceeds of the sale of goods
(Minus)
[B] Cost of the goods
10.2.
10.3.
Here the cost of the goods means expenses directly related to cost of the
goods sold. This point must be made clear in the accounting policy of
Board/ organisation/ business firm. In other the organisation/board/ business
firm must clarify which items are to be included in the cost of the goods sold.
Similarly, items that are not being included in the cost of the goods sold
should also be indicated.
10.4.
The following are to be considered on the debit side of the Trading Account:
a)
58
c)
10.5.
The following are to be considered on the credit side of the Trading Account:
a)
b) Closing stock
10.6.
The credit balance on the Trading Account i.e., excess of credit over debit
shows gross profit. This gross profit will be shown on the debit side of the
Trading Account to balance the account. The gross profit will be carried
forward to credit side of the Profit and Loss Account.
59
The unsold goods should be valued on the basis of cost price or market price
whichever is lower keeping the board policy in mind.
13. Accounting
Closing Stock
? Debit the stock account and credit the Trading Account
? Debit balance appear as asset in the Balance Sheet
Bad Debts
?
?
?
Doubtful Debts
?
?
?
Depreciation
?
?
?
?
As already explained the gross profit shown in Trading Account should bring
on the credit side of Profit and Loss Account. All types of income received
will appear on credit side of Profit and Loss Account. All expenses to
carryout business like rent, salary, insurance, printing, advertisement etc.,
will appear on the debit side of the Profit and Loss Account. In other words,
on the debit side of the account, the items of expenses coming under the
following categories will be recorded.
? Selling and Distribution expenses
? Management Expenses
60
? Financial Expenses
? Maintenance and depreciation
14.2.
The credit balance of Profit and Loss Account shows the net profit. The
debit balance on the Profit and Loss Account shows the net loss.
15.2.
15.3.
ASSETS
15.4.
The Balance Sheet to be supported by Profit and Loss Account sources and
uses of funds statement, notes to the financial statements and the auditor
certificate.
15.5.
What the business owns are assets and what it owes are liabilities. The assets
are of two groups, namely:
Fixed Assets
Current Assets
61
16. Liquidity
16.1.
Quick Assets are part of current assets. it can quickly be converted into cash.
This refers to amounts yet to be paid by the customers. These customers are
referred to as debtors or accounts receivable. This will appear on the asset
side of the balance sheet.
18.2.
Long term assets like land, buildings, plant and machinery, motor vehicles,
fixtures and fittings are the fixed assets. There will not be much variation or
fluctuation in value as far as fixed assets are concerned.
18.3.
On the other side current assets will vary much even on day-to-day basis.
All the inventories like stocks of finished products, raw materials and workin-progress are all current assets.
18.4.
Normally fixed assets will not sell to raise cash, because they are meant for
long term use. The liquidity of the fixed assets is very low.
19. Valuation
19.1.
19.2.
19.3.
19.4.
62
19.5.
20. Liabilities
20.1.
(Shareholders are different from person who has given loans to the company. People
who have given loans are not the owners of the company. Shareholders are the owners of
the company.)
20.2.
Long term loans from financial institutions are an example of fixed liability.
Short term loans and overdraft accounts payable are examples of current
liabilities.
The cost of current liabilities will be low when compared to the cost of fixed
liabilities.
Current liabilities and fixed liabilities are called outside liabilities.
Normally, the current liabilities have to be met within one year.
Fixed liabilities represent the long-term finance and the current liabilities
represent short-term finance.
Usually, long term loans are obtained on the basis of property as security.
The property offered as security may be in the form of building, plant and
machinery etc.
21.2.
The company will pay dividends to its share holders. The dividends will be
paid out of profits.
The portion of the profits retained in the business without payment to the
shareholders may form Capital reserve and revenue reserve.
21.3.
21.4.
63
21.5.
Only profit in the form of dividend will be paid to share holders. The
original amount subscribed by the share holders will not be paid up until the
company is closes down. Therefore, the funds of the share holders are a
permanent finance of a company. This is shown as liability in the Balance
Sheet, as this amount is owed by the company to its shareholders. The
company will not pay interest on the funds of the share holders, but
compensates them in the form of dividends.
21.6.
21.7.
If the company is to wound up, the ordinary share holders will get their claim
settled only after all the creditors and other investors get their claims settled.
Preferential share holders will have priority over their ordinary shareholders.
This is because the ordinary share holders are the real owners of the
company.
22.2.
Points to note:
Only in case a company is to be wound up, does the question of liability to return
shareholders funds arise. The dividends to share holders will not be paid from capital
reserve, but may be paid out from revenue reserve.
Apart form paying dividends to share holders, out of net profit, a company will try to
retain some portion of the profit arising from its normal operations. This is called
Revenue Reserve. This revenue reserve may be used for (a) future expansion plans or (b)
to pay dividend for those years, when there is less or no profit or to simply maintain
consistency in payment of dividends and thereby maintain credibility in the minds of the
shareholders.
64
23. Solvency
23.1.
If assets are more than that of out side liabilities, a company is said to be
solvent.
24. Liquidity
24.1.
If a company can meet its current liabilities out of current assets, it is called
as liquid.
CA - CL = W.C.
Where CA stands for current Assets, CL stands for current liabilities and WC
stands for Working Capital.
26. Gearing
26.1.
Gearing refers to the SHF: BM (LC) where SHF refers to the shareholders
funds and BM refer to the borrowed money or loan capital.
Example 3
Gearing
If gearing is 4:1 it means that proportionality is 4/5 and 1/5 i.e., 4/5 is SHF and 1/5 is
BM. Therefore SHF = 80% and BM = 20%. This is a situation of low gearing that is 4:1,
showing less loan capital and also indicating that there is scope to borrow more money.
The opposite 1:4 is a case of high gearing.
27. Comparison
27.1.
The balance sheet gives two sets of figures, to compare the current balance
sheet with that of previous balance sheet.
27.2.
Comparison will serve the purpose of ascertaining the cause for changes.
Such comparison will also help ascertain the sources and uses of funds.
27.3.
The net working capital is nothing but excess of current assets over current
liabilities. In other words, the net working capital shows liquidity.
65
By comparing the current balance sheet with the previous balance sheet, the
statement of sources and uses of funds can be prepared.
28.2.
Sources means, where does the money come from. Uses means, how such
new money has been used.
28.3.
28.4.
Sources of funds must always be equal to uses: to the extent that it is not
used, there will be an increase in the liquidity. There will be an increase in
the net working capital or increase in the gap between the current assets and
current liabilities.
28.6.
The sources and uses of money statement should be attached to the balance
sheet. The mere rise in companys money may not be indicative of the
health status of the company. The health of the company depends on how
the money is used. If it is used for productive operations or for the
expansion of existing plants or for purchase of new machinery or for
modernization, future production may increase. If the new money is spent,
for example, for the construction or for the renovation of the houses of
directors, it may not improve production. Therefore, to read the financial
health of a company, one has to analyze how and for what purpose has the
money been spent.
66
The portion of the shareholder funds (SHF) out of the total liabilities
determines the solvency of a company. The higher the SHF when compared
to other liabilities in total, the greater the solvency and the vice-versa.
29.2.
29.3.
High solvency ratio means that the SHF portion in the total liabilities is high
representing capacity to borrow more money from outside. Low solvency
ratio means that SHF portion in the total liabilities is low and indicates that
there is less scope to borrow money from outside. The solvency ratio is
often expressed as a percentage.
29.4.
The two measures of liquidity are (a)Current ratio and (b) Quick ratio
29.5.
CR = CA: CL
Where CR - Stands for current ratio
CA stands for current assets and
CL stands for current liabilities
29.6.
QR = QA: CL
Where QR stands for quick ratio
QA stands for quick assets and
CL stands for current liabilities
29.7.
29.8.
In business, the harsh reality is that cash is more important than profit.
Therefore, there must be a situation of higher portion of current assets when
compared to current liability, so that the current ratio will always be positive
i.e., more than one. To calculate the current ratio, the marketable securities
should always be included.
67
To measure
29.9.
Quick assets are cash and include other assets which can quickly be
converted into cash. Quick assets do not include stock or inventories.
?
?
?
?
The balance sheet must be supplemented by the Profit and Loss Account.
The Profit and Loss Account shows :
Gross Profit
Operating Profit
Profit before tax (PBT)
Net Profit after tax (NPAT)
68
The Profitability is measured on (a) Return on capital employed, (b) Return on share
holders funds (SHF) as indicated in the formulae given below:
Return on Capital Employed
PBT + Interest on fixed liabilities
= --------------------------------------Capital employed
X 100
Return on SHF
=
NPAT
---------------------- X 100
SHF
Capital employed
Capital employed means
Total Assets
Current Liabilities
69
LEARNING UNIT - I
BASICS OF COMMERCIAL
ACCOUNTING
AND BALALNCE SHEET
INSTRUCTIONS TO FACULTY
70
Learning Unit 1
Instructions to Faculty
Objectives :
1.1.
At the end of this Learning Unit the participants will be able to:
2.
3. Methodology
3.1
3.2
71
3.3
3.4
4. Reading Material:
4.1
4.2
4.3
5. Instructions to Faculty
5.1.
5.2.
It is neither intended nor possible from a course of this nature that the
participants are made experts in financial management. The objective of this
learning unit as well as the other learning units is to enable the participants to
acquire some minimum skills to read the financial pages and to enable them
to analyze the key issues recorded in the financial records, to take financial
decisions on their own.
5.3.
Therefore in this learning unit the Faculty should start on an inspiring note
clearly explaining the objectives.
5.4.
5.5.
The first two hours i.e., before the commencement of this learning unit the
faculty :
? Will introduce him/her.
? Initiate an icebreaking and introductory activities for all the participants to
get to know each, and create an environment that is cheerful, friendly,
non-formal and non-hierarchical.
72
6.
7.
Accounting Policy
Basics of Commercial Accounting and reading of Balance
Sheet
Discounted Cash Flow Technique and Internal Rate of Return
Management of Capital
Measurement of Risk
Capital Asset Pricing Model
Derivatives related to investments
Structure of Capital
Analysis of Financial Pages
Performance budgeting
Zero-base Budgeting
Cost-benefit analysis
Portfolio theory
International Finance
6.1.
After giving a brief overview of the course contents, faculty may break
participants into four groups. It is necessary to ensure that every group
has members of equal potential and experience. Faculty may ensure that
participants with commerce backgrounds or experience in the corporate
management are equally distributed in all the groups, rather than being
clustered in one group only.
6.2.
With this faculty may provide participants with any other details about the
training institution, available facilities, including library, computer centre,
recreation facilities etc.
73
Classifications
Subsidiary registers
Trial Balance
Trading Account
Profit and Loss Account
Balance Sheet
7.2.
Personal Account
Asset Account
Nominal Account
While explaining classifications, faculty must ensure that they explain (a)
each account with at least two examples, (b) the meaning of debit and
credit, (c) ledger rulings.
7.3.
Cash Book
Purchases Book
Return outwards Book
Sales Book
Return inwards Book
Bills Receivable Book
Bills payable Book
Journal Proper
The overall objective of Subsidiary Records is to maintain accuracy in
accounts and prevent fraud. While handling the portion on Subsidiary
Records, Faculty should explain (a) the importance and objectives of each
record, (b) Ledger Postings, (c) how to identify key entries in these
registers and for what purpose.
74
7.4.
Balances method
Debit Balance
Credit Balance
Capital Account
Debtors
Creditors
Errors
While explaining Trial Balance, faculty should explain (a) the meaning of
balances on accounts, (b) why Trial Balances must be prepared, before
finalizing Accounts. This should preferably be shown with a concrete
example, which indicates why and how a Trial Balance always tallies. (c)
Why certain accounts always show debit balances and other accounts
always show credit balances.
Rs.
Opening Stock
Sales
Less: returns
Purchases
Less: returns
Closing Stock
Carriage Inwards
Total Rs.
Total Rs.
7.5.
Faculty to explain :
75
Management Expenses
Rs
Gross Profit
Earned Discount
Interest on Deposits
Maintenance and
Depreciation
Net Profit
Other income
Financial Expenses
Total Rs.
Total Rs.
7.6.
Faculty should explain each item on the debit side of Profit and loss
Account with examples. Faculty may use the example given below:
Management expenses
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
o
76
Financial Expenses
o Cash discounts allowed
o Cost of discounting bills
o Interest on Capital
o Interest on borrowed Capital
o Loss in exchange
o Discount on Issue of Debentures
o Preliminary expenses written off.
Maintenance and Depreciation
o Repairs and renewals
o Depreciation of Assets
7.7.
Faculty may also explain the balancing of Profit and Loss Account and its
effect on the Balance Sheet.
Rs.
Assets
Sundry Creditors
Cash in hand
Cash in Bank
Bills Payable
Open Accounts
Wages and Salaries
Bills Receivable
Capital Accounts
Opening Balance
Plus: Profit
Minus: drawings
Sundry Debtors
Less: Reserve for
Doubtful debts
Less: Reserve for
discounts
Stock-in-Trade
Fixed assets
Minus: depreciation
Land + extensions
Pre-paid
Total Rs.
Total Rs.
77
Rs.
7.8.
7.9.
Fixed Assets
Current Assets
Quick Assets
Inventories
Operating Cycle
Valuation
Depreciation
Good will
Debenture
Capital authorized
Capital issued
Capital subscribed
Revenue Reserve
Capital Reserve
Outside liabilities
Inside liabilities
78
7.10.
Faculty should explain the meaning of each item shown in this visual aid
with simple examples.
Solvency
Liquidity
Working capital
Gearing
Sources and uses of funds
Current ratio
Quick ratio
Debt equity ratio
7.11.
Faculty should explain how to use ratios with two or three examples for
each ratio. Ensure that the participants are understanding implications of
the outcome.
7.12.
Also explain that there are different stake holders to Balance sheet,
and that ratios can be used and analysed from the viewpoints of different
stake holders. Highlight how the out come of the ratio analysis can be
used?
7.13.
Ask the participants to make their own ratio analysis during the group
activity.
Gross Profit
Operating Profit
Profit before Tax
Net Profit after Tax
Return on Capital employed
Return on SHF
Stability
Limitation
79
7.14
Faculty should explain (a) the importance of profit analysis with
reference to return on capital employed and return on shareholders funds with
two or three examples, (b) highlight what a balance sheet does not reveal, (c)
importance of stability and how does the Balance Sheet reveal the stability of
a Company.
80
8.
Group Work:
8.1.
8.2.
Faculty should act as facilitator for each group to enable the participants
to solve the problems in the group. The Faculty shall monitor the group
activities as shown in the Handout on Group Activities for Learning Unit
2.
8.3.
81
LEARNING UNIT - II
82
Learning Unit 2
Group Activity
Discounted cash flow Technique and
Internal Rate of Return
1.
This exercise will also be conducted in 4 groups. The first two groups will be
entrusted with the task of applying Discounted Cash Flow Technique. The next two
groups will calculate the Internal Rate of Return.
1.1.
Each group will be given sufficient time to discuss and to solve the problems
entrusted to them and to prepare visual aids.
1.2.
Each group will make a presentation using visual aids. Each group may be
given approximately 25 minutes for the presentation and Faculty may require
5-10 minutes for moderation and summing up.
1.3.
At the end of each presentation all groups will list out the key learning
points, which will be consolidated in the plenary.
2.
The purchase choice relates to two machines, i.e., Machine A and Machine B
The details of Machine A are as follows:
Initial cost of A
O & M expenses
Rs.3.5 Lakhs
First year
Second year
Third year
Fourth year
Fifth year
Rs.0.30 Lakhs
Rs.0.30 Lakhs
Rs.0.40 Lakhs
Rs.0.50 Lakhs
Rs.0.55 Lakhs
The life span of Machine A is 5 years. The salvage value of Machine A at the
end of the 5th year is Rs.50,000-00
83
Rs.0.50 Lakhs
Rs.0.50 Lakhs
Rs.0.60 Lakhs
Rs.0.60 Lakhs
Rs.0.50 Lakhs
O & M expenses
First year
Second year
Third year
Forth year
Fifth year
Sixth Year
Rs.5.00 Lakhs
Rs.0.20 Lakhs
Rs.0.20 Lakhs
Rs.0.30 Lakhs
Rs.0.35 Lakhs
Rs.0.40 Lakhs
Rs.0.45 Lakhs
The life span of Machine 'B' is 6 years. The salvage value at the end of the 6th
year is Rs.0.80 Lakhs.
The estimated returns on machine B are as follows.
I Year
II Year
III Year
IV Year
V Year
VI Year
0.70 Lakhs
0.70 Lakhs
0.65 Lakhs
0.60 Lakhs
0.55 Lakhs
0.50 Lakhs.
84
Year
Earning
Cost
1.
Rs.6000
Rs.2000
Rs.4000
2.
Rs.7000
Rs.2000
Rs.5000
3.
Rs.8000
Rs.2000
Rs.6000
4.
Rs.8500
Rs.2500
Rs.6000
5.
Rs.8500
Rs.2500
Rs.6000
6.
Rs.8500
Rs.2500
Rs.6000
7.
Rs.9000
Rs.3000
Rs.6000
8.
Rs.8000
Rs.3000
Rs.5000
9.
Rs.7000
Rs.3000
Rs.4000
10.
Rs.7000
Rs.3000
Rs.5000*
85
LEARNING UNIT - II
86
Learning Unit 2
Reading Material
Discounted Cash Flow Technique
1.
1.1.
DCFT is based upon the concept of time value of money. In other words,
money in hand today is more valuable than the same amount of money after
some time, because of the existence of cost of money in terms of interest.
1.2.
1.3.
Buying or hiring.
Expanding the existing plant/ business/ or to going in for a new plant/
business.
Whether to make full cash down payment or to make payments in
installments.
Whether to opt for machinery operated work or labour oriented work
Determine lead time in inventory management.
Project investments and return on such investments.
1.4
In project finance, DCFT is the most scientific technique to measure benefits and
costs associated with project.
1.5
DCFT will help assess the present value of returns and cost. This is based on the
reverse of Compound Interest formula. The compound interest formula is FV =
PV X (l + r)n
Where FV stands for Future Value,
PV stands for Present Value,
87
=
=
=
=
Rs.110
Rs.121
Rs.133.10
Rs.146.40 and so on.
By reversing the compounding interest formula, we can find the present value of
money receivable in future i.e.
1
PV = FV X
(l + r)n
1.6.
For example, if 'X' invests Rs.100 on 01.01.2001 at rate of 10% P.A. and he
expects a return of Rs.146.40 at the end of the IV year. In terms of the cost of
the money i.e., interest rate of 10 % P.A., the present value of Rs.146.40
receivable at the end of the fourth year is Rs.100 only. [It may be less than
Rs.100, if the negative aspect of inflation effect is calculated. But we are not
focusing on inflation accounting]
1.7.
Every investor will expect returns higher than the Investment + Cost of
Investment. The cost of investment is nothing but interest rate. Some
investors expect returns higher than the present returns, i.e. more than the
present opportunity. This is called opportunity cost based approach to
calculate net returns. Opportunity cost will be the cost of capital to measure
the cost of cash outflow and cash inflow. Therefore, the cost of capital to
calculate the net return varies from person to person, firm to firm and
industry to industry. The Planning Commission of Government of India
fixes the cost of capital at 12% to calculate the net returns for all government
projects, barring some Agro-based industries, like sugar Factories, where the
deficiency in returns is subsidized because of social weightages.
1.8.
The cost of capital i.e., in the form of interest rate or in the form of
opportunity cost is taken as Discount Factor to calculate the present value of
costs and the present value of returns. The difference is the net present value:
1.9.
To save time, there are ready made: SPPWF table and USPWF Table.
88
1.10.
SPPWF stands for the Single Payment Present worth Factor and USPWF
stands for the Uniform Series of Present Worth Factors. The tables are
enclosed to these reading materials.
SPPWF Table
1.11.
1.12.
1.13.
1.14.
Overall, the SPPWF table shows the returns on a single rupee receivable in
future at the end of different years (upto 50 Years) and at the different
discount factors. Therefore, there is no need to use the formula to find out
the present value of a single rupee for each year and for each discount factor.
1.15.
For example, to calculate the present value of Rs.10, 000 at the end of the 9th
year at the discount factor of 15%, we can use the SPPWF table, without
having to use the formula.
Go to 9th year in the first vertical column, go to 15 % Discount Factor on
the first horizontal column. Both straight lines will meet at 0.2843. To get
the PV of Rs.10, 000,
= Rs.10,000 X 0.2843
= Rs.2,843.
This means, that the Present Value of Rs.10, 000 receivable in future i.e., at
the end of the 9th year is Rs.2, 843.
1.16.
Where the investment amount or the return amount or both investment and
return amounts varies from time to time (i.e., not being constant from y ear to
year) the SPPWF table must be applied.
USPWF table
1.17.
1.18.
For example, if the return of Rs.10,000 is constant per year, say for 10 years
at the discount factor of 15% P.A., the use of the SPPWF table to calculate
the PV will be a long and laborious process, as is obvious from the example
below:
89
1.19.
If we use SPPWF table from 1st to 10th year and 15 % Discount Factor, it
will appear as:
I Year
0.8696
II Year
0.7561
III Year
0.6575
IV Year
0.5718
V Year
0.4972
VI Year
0.4323
VII Year
0.3759
VIII Year
0.3269
IX Year
0.2843
X Year
0.2472
Rs.5.0188
1.20.
In this example the return is Rs.10, 000 for each year: i.e. the return is
constant for each year. By using SPPWF tables we undoubtedly arrived at
the figure of Rs 5.0188. But it is a time consuming process.
1.21.
Instead if we refer to the USPWF table and look at the 10th year of 15 % D.F.
column, we will find the figure of Rs 5.0188. This is the same figure that we
got by adding the figures from 1st to 10th year in the 15% of column of
SPPWF table. But we saved considerable time required for calculation.
1.22.
To calculate the PV of Rs.10, 000 at the end of each year over 10 years
multiply.
Rs.10, 000 X 5.0188
= Rs.50, 188
In other words, the PV of Rs.1, 00,000 is Rs.50, 188.
1.23.
90
1.24.
All the equipment will serve a common purpose i.e., utility. The life span of
each equipment is 5 years.
1.25.
Equipment
Initial Cost
Year O&M
I
10,000
2
11,000
3
12,000
4
12,500
5
13,000
Salvage value at the
end of the 5th year
1.26.
A
Rs 19,00,000
Returns
800,000
800,000
700,000
600,000
500,000
B
Rs 18,00,000
O&M
Returns
12,000
800,000
13,000
700,000
14,000
600,000
14,500
500,000
15,000
400,000
200,000
100,000
C
Rs 17,00,000
O&M
Returns
14,000
700,000
14,000
700,000
14,000
600,000
14,000
500,000
14,000
300,000
50,000
Equipment A :
Present Value of estimated cash outflow is:
19,00,000 + (10,000 X 0.8333) + (11,000 X 0.6944) + (12,000 X 0.5787) +
(12,500 X 0.4823) + (13,000 X 0.4019) = Rs.19,34,169.
Present value of estimated cash inflow is:
(800,000 X 0.8333) + (800,000 X 0.6944) + (700,000 X 0.5787) + (800,000 X
0.4823) + (500,000 X 0.4019) + (200,000 X 0.4019) = Rs.21, 97,960
Net present value is equal to benefits in terms of present value minus cost in terms
of present value. That means that in this case: NPV = 2, 63,791
91
Equipment B :
Present value of estimated cash outflow is:
18, 00,000 + (12,000 X 0.8333) + (13,000 X 0.6944) + (14,000 X 0.5787)
+ (14,500 X 0.4823) + (15,000 X 0.4019) = Rs.18, 40,150
The present value of estimated cash inflow is:
(8, 00,000 X 0.8333) + (7,00,000 X 0.6944) + (6,00,000 X 0.5787) + (5,00,000 X
0.4823) + (4,00,000 X 0.4019) + (1,00,000 X 0.4019) = Rs.19,42,040
The NPV in the present case is = 1, 01,890
Equipment C :
The PV of estimated cash outflow is:
17, 00,000 + (14,000 X 2.9906) = Rs.17, 41,868
The PV of cash inflow is:
(7, 00,000 X 0.8333) + (7,00,000 x 0.6944) + (6,00,000 X 0.5787) + (6,00,000 X
0.4823) + (3,00,000 X 0.4019) + (50,000 X 0.4019) = Rs.18,46,655
The NPV in the present case = 1, 04,787
Consider the NPV of 3 equipments together.
Equipment A :
Rs.2, 63,791
Equipment B
Rs.1, 01,890
Equipment C
Rs.1, 04,787
IRR must be calculated in order to assess at what point of time in the project the
investor will fully recover his /her initial investment. This point is indicated by
percentage. If NPV = 0, the Present Value of benefits is equal to the Present Value
of costs. The time required to recover initial investment may vary from project to
project. An investor will clearly opt for a project where he/she can quickly recover
the initial investment, when compared to the other projects.
92
2.1.
The point, at which the discount factor shows the NPV as zero, is nothing but
IRR. In other words IRR exists at the point where NPV = 0 or the PV of
benefits is equal to PV of costs.
2.2.
3.
3.1.
Year
Earning
Cost
1
3,000
1,000
2
3,500
1,000
3
4,000
1,000
4
5,000
2,000
5
5,000
2,000
*includes Rs.500 as salvage value of the project.
3.2.
Here, the earnings mean cash inflow in the form of returns. Cost means
Operation and Maintenance expenses. The objective of the IRR calculation
is to ascertain discount factor (cost of capital) at which the investor recovers
the initial investment of Rs.10, 000 in terms of present value.
3.3.
Solution: The reader may note that IRR can be determined only by trial and
error. A discount factor where NPV = 0 cannot be determined all of a
sudden. Therefore two different factors must be arbitrarily selected: one
yielding positive figure (NPV > 0) and another yielding negative figure
(NPV < 0). Next by using the interpolation formula between these two, IRR
can be determined at which NPV = 0. In arriving at the following solution by
trial and error, one discount factor worked at 10% and the other discount
factor worked at 12%.
93
Year
Net
Cash
Flow
II
2000
2500
3000
3000
3000
Initial Cost =
I
1
2
3
4
5
4.
D. F at 10% NPV
10%
III
IV
0.910
1820
0.827
2068
0.752
2256
0.684
2052
0.621
1863
10059
-10000
+59
at
59
59 (-471)
= 10 + (2 X 59 )
530
= 10 + 59
265
= 10 + 0.22
= 10.22
Therefore IRR = 10.22 %
4.1.
Therefore, in this case, the investor recovers his/her initial investment at the
discount factor of 10.22%, where benefit is equal to costs.
4.2.
However, if the cost of capital in the present case were to be less than
10.22%, the investor would gain and the project would be viable. For
example, if the cost of capital were 9 %, the investor would gain to the extent
of the difference between 9% and 10.22 %. The higher the difference
between cost of capital and IRR, the higher the return.
4.3.
Conversely, if the cost of capital is more than 10.22 % (Cost > Benefits),
then the project is not viable for the investor.
4.4.
There must invariably be sufficient difference between the cost of capital and
IRR. If the cost of capital is low and the IRR is high, there will obviously be
greater difference between costs and benefits, showing the positive effect of
NPV. The higher the difference the higher the net benefit. There must be
sufficient margin of safety before considering the project as worthy of
investment.
94
5.
Graphic presentation.
5.1.
N
P
V
10.22%
9%
11%
95
n/r
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
35
40
45
50
1.0%
.9901
.9803
.9706
.9610
.9515
.9420
.9327
.9235
.9143
.9053
.8963
.8874
.8787
.8700
.8613
.8528
.8444
.8360
.8277
.8195
.8114
.8034
.7954
.7876
.7798
.7720
.7644
.7568
.7493
.7419
.7059
.6717
.6391
.6080
2.0%
.9804
.9612
.9423
.9238
.9057
.8880
.8706
.8535
.8368
.8203
.8043
.7885
.7730
.7579
.7430
.7284
.7142
.7002
.6864
.6730
.6598
.6468
.6342
.6217
.6095
.5976
.5859
.5744
.5631
.5521
.5000
.4529
.4100
.3715
3.0%
.9709
.9426
.9151
.8885
.8626
.8375
.8131
.7894
.7664
.7441
.7224
.7014
.6810
.6611
.6419
.6232
.6050
.5874
.5703
.5537
.5375
.5219
.5067
.4919
.4776
.4637
.4502
.4371
.4243
.4120
.3554
.3066
.2644
.2281
4.0%
.9615
.9246
.8890
.8548
.8219
.7903
.7599
.7307
.7026
.6756
.6496
.6246
.6006
.5775
.5553
.5339
.5134
.4936
.4746
.4564
.4388
.4220
.4057
.3901
.3751
.3607
.3468
.3335
.3207
.3083
.2534
.2083
.1713
.1407
5.0%
.9524
.9070
.8638
.8227
.7835
.7462
.7107
.6768
.6446
.6139
.5847
.5568
.5303
.5051
.4810
.4581
.4363
.4155
.3957
.3769
.3589
.3418
.3256
.3101
.2953
.2812
.2678
.2551
.2429
.2314
.1813
.1420
.1112
.0872
6%
.9434
.8900
.8396
.7921
.7473
.7050
.6651
.6274
.5919
.5584
.5268
.4970
.4688
.4423
.4173
.3936
.3714
.3503
.3305
.3118
.2942
.2775
.2618
.2470
.2330
.2198
.2074
.1956
.1846
.1741
.1301
.0972
.0727
.0543
7%
.9346
.8734
.8163
.7629
.7130
.6663
.6227
.5820
.5439
.5083
.4751
.4440
.4150
.3878
.3624
.3387
.3166
.2959
.2765
.2584
.2415
.2257
.2109
.1971
.1842
.1722
.1609
.1504
.1406
.1314
.0937
.0668
.0476
.0339
96
8%
.9259
.8573
.7938
.7350
.6806
.6302
.5835
.5403
.5002
.4632
.4289
.3971
.3677
.3405
.3152
.2919
.2703
.2502
.2317
.2145
.1987
.1839
.1703
.1577
.1460
.1352
.1252
.1159
.1073
.0994
.0676
.0460
.0313
.0213
9%
.9174
.8417
.7722
.7084
.6499
.5963
.5470
.5019
.4604
.4224
.3875
.3555
.3262
.2992
.2745
.2519
.2311
.2120
.1945
.1784
.1637
.1502
.1378
.1264
.1160
.1064
.0976
.0895
.0822
.0754
.0490
.0318
.0207
.0134
10%
.9091
.8264
.7513
.6830
.6209
.5645
.5132
.4665
.4241
.3855
.3505
.3186
.2897
.2633
.2394
.2176
.1978
.1799
.1635
.1486
.1351
.1228
.1117
.1015
.0923
.0839
.0763
.0693
.0630
.0573
.0356
.0221
.0137
.0085
11%
.9009
.8116
.7312
.6587
.5935
.5346
.4817
.4339
.3909
.3522
.3173
.2858
.2575
.2320
.2090
.1883
.1696
.1528
.1377
.1240
.1117
.1007
.0907
.0817
.0736
.0663
.0597
.0538
.0485
.0437
.0259
.0154
.0091
.0054
12%
.8929
.7972
.7118
.6355
.5674
.5066
.4523
.4039
.3606
.3220
.2875
.2567
.2292
.2046
.1827
.1631
.1456
.1300
.1161
.1037
.0926
.0826
.0738
.0659
.0588
.0525
.0469
.0419
.0374
.0334
.0189
.0107
.0061
.0035
13%
.8850
.7831
.6931
.6133
.5428
.4803
.4251
.3762
.3329
.2946
.2607
.2307
.2042
.1807
.1599
.1415
.1252
.1108
.0981
.0868
.0768
.0680
.0601
.0532
.0471
.0417
.0369
.0326
.0289
.0256
.0139
.0075
.0041
.0022
n/r
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
35
40
45
50
16%
.8621
.7432
.6407
.5523
.4761
.4104
.3538
.3050
.2630
.2267
.1954
.1685
.1452
.1252
.1079
.0930
.0802
.0691
.0596
.0514
.0443
.0382
.0329
.0284
.0245
.0211
.0182
.0157
.0135
.0116
.0055
.0026
.0013
.0006
18%
.8475
.7182
.6086
.5158
.4371
.3704
.3139
.2660
.2255
.1911
.1619
.1372
.1163
.0985
.0835
.0708
.0600
.0508
.0431
.0365
.0309
.0262
.0222
.0188
.0160
.0135
.0115
.0097
.0082
.0070
.0030
.0013
.0006
.0003
20%
.8333
.6944
.5787
.4823
.4019
.3349
.2791
.2326
.1938
.1615
.1346
.1122
.0935
.0779
.0649
.0541
.0451
.0376
.0313
.0261
.0217
.0181
.0151
.0126
.0105
.0087
.0073
.0061
.0051
.0042
.0017
.0007
.0003
.0001
22%
.8197
.6719
.5507
.4514
.3700
.3033
.2486
.2038
.1670
.1369
.1122
.0920
.0754
.0618
.0507
.0415
.0340
.0279
.0229
.0187
.0154
.0126
.0103
.0085
.0069
.0057
.0047
.0338
.0031
.0026
.0009
.0004
.0001
.0000
24%
.8065
.6504
.5245
.4230
.3411
.2751
.2218
.1789
.1443
.1164
.0938
.0757
.0610
.0492
.0397
.0320
.0258
.0208
.0168
.0135
.0109
.0088
.0071
.0057
.0046
.0037
.0030
.0024
.0020
.0016
.0005
.0002
.0001
.0000
26%
.7937
.6299
.4999
.3968
.3149
.2499
.1983
.1574
.1249
.0992
.0787
.0625
.0496
.0393
.0312
.0248
.0197
.0156
.0124
.0098
.0078
.0062
.0049
.0039
.0031
.0025
.0019
.0015
.0012
.0010
.0003
.0001
.0000
28%
.7831
.6104
.4768
.3725
.2910
.2274
.1776
.1388
.1084
.0847
.0662
.0517
.0404
.0316
.0247
.0193
.0150
.0118
.0092
.0072
.0056
.0044
.0034
.0027
.0021
.0016
.0013
.0010
.0008
.0006
.0002
.0001
.0000
97
30%
.7692
.5917
.4552
.3501
.2693
.2072
.1594
.1226
.0943
.0725
.0558
.0429
.0330
.0253
.0195
.0150
.0116
.0089
.0068
.0053
.0040
.0031
.0024
.0018
.0014
.0011
.0008
.0006
.0005
.0004
.0001
.0000
32%
.7576
.5739
.4348
.3294
.2495
.1890
.1432
.1085
.0822
.0623
.0472
.0357
.0271
.0205
.0155
.0118
.0089
.0068
.0051
.0039
.0029
.0022
.0017
.0013
.0010
.0007
.0006
.0004
.0003
.0002
.0001
.0000
34%
.7463
.5569
.4155
.3102
.2315
.1727
.1289
.0962
.0718
.0536
.0400
.0298
.0223
.0166
.0124
.0093
.0069
.0052
.0038
.0029
.0021
.0016
.0012
.0009
.0007
.0005
.0004
.0003
.0002
.0002
.0000
36%
.7353
.5407
.3975
.2923
.2149
.1580
.1162
.0854
.0628
.0462
.0340
.0250
.0184
.0135
.0099
.0073
.0054
.0039
.0029
.0021
.0016
.0012
.0008
.0006
.0005
.0003
.0002
.0002
.0001
.0001
.0000
38%
.7246
.5251
.3805
.2757
.1998
.1448
.1049
.0760
.0551
.0399
.0289
.0210
.0152
.0110
.0080
.0058
.0042
.0030
.0022
.0016
.0012
.0008
.0006
.0004
.0003
.0002
.0002
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0000
40%
.7143
.5102
.3644
.2603
.1859
.1328
.0949
.0678
.0484
.0346
.0247
.0176
.0126
.0090
.0064
.0046
.0033
.0023
.0017
.0012
.0009
.0006
.0004
.0003
.0002
.0002
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0000
45%
.6897
.4756
.3280
.2262
.1560
.1076
.0742
.0512
.0353
.0243
.0168
.0116
.0080
.0055
.0038
.0026
.0018
.0012
.0009
.0006
.0004
.0003
.0002
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0000
50%
.6667
.4444
.2963
.1975
.1317
.0878
.0585
.0390
.0260
.0173
.0116
.0077
.0051
.0034
.0023
.0015
.0010
.0007
.0005
.0003
.0002
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0000
1.0%
0.9901
1.9704
2.9410
3.9020
4.3534
5.7955
6.7282
7.6517
8.5660
9.4713
10.3676
11.2551
12.1337
13.0037
13.8650
14.7179
15.5622
16.3983
17.2250
18.0455
18.8570
19.6604
20.4558
21.2484
22.0232
22.7952
23.5596
24.3164
25.0658
2.0%
0.9804
1.9416
2.8839
3.8077
4.7135
5.6014
6.4720
7.3255
8.1622
8.9826
9.7868
10.5753
11.3484
12.1062
12.8493
13.5777
14.2919
14.9920
15.6785
16.3514
17.0112
17.6580
18.2922
18.9139
19.5235
20.1210
20.7069
21.2813
21.8444
3.0%
0.9709
1.9135
2.8286
3.7171
4.5797
5.4172
6.2303
7.0197
7.7861
8.5302
9.2526
9.9540
10.6350
11.2961
11.9379
12.5611
13.1661
13.7535
14.3238
14.8775
15.4150
15.9369
16.4436
16.9355
17.4131
17.8768
18.3270
18.7641
19.1884
4.0%
0.9615
1.8861
2.7751
3.6299
4.4518
5.2421
6.0020
6.7327
7.4353
8.1109
8.7605
9.3851
9.9856
10.5631
11.1184
11.6523
12.1657
12.6593
13.1339
13.5903
14.0292
14.4511
14.8568
15.2470
15.6221
15.9828
16.3296
16.6631
16.9837
98
5.0%
0.9524
1.8594
2.7232
3.3459
4.3295
5.0757
5.7864
6.4632
7.1078
7.7217
8.3064
8.8632
9.3936
9.8986
10.3797
10.8378
11.2741
11.6896
12.0853
12.4622
12.8211
13.1630
13.4886
13.7086
14.0939
14.3752
14.6430
14.8981
15.1481
6%
0.9434
1.8334
2.6730
3.4651
4.2124
4.9173
5.5824
6.2098
6.8017
7.3601
7.8869
8.3838
8.8527
9.2950
9.7122
10.1059
10.4773
10.8276
11.1581
11.4699
11.7641
12.0416
12.3034
12.5504
12.7834
13.0032
13.2105
13.4062
13.5907
7%
0.9346
1.8080
2.6243
3.3872
4.1002
4.7665
5.3898
5.9718
6.5152
7.0236
7.4987
7.9427
8.3577
8.7455
9.1079
9.4466
9.7632
10.0591
10.3356
10.5940
10.8355
11.0612
11.2722
11.4693
11.6536
11.8258
11.9867
12.1371
12.2777
8%
9%
10%
0.9259 0.9174 0.9091
1.7833 1.7591 1.7355
2.5771 2.5313 2.4869
3.3121 3.2397 3.1699
3.9927 3.8897 3.7908
4.6229 4.4859 4.3553
5.2064 5.0330 4.8684
5.7466 5.5348 5.3349
6.2469 5.9952 5.7590
6.7101 6.4177 6.1446
7.1390 6.8051 6.4951
7.5361 7.1607 6.8137
7.9038 7.4869 7.1034
8.2442 7.7862 7.3667
8.5595 8.0607 7.6061
8.8514 8.3126 7.8237
9.1216 8.5436 8.0216
9.3719 8.7556 8.2014
9.6036 8.9501 8.3649
9.8181 9.1285 8.5136
10.0168 9.2922 8.6487
10.2007 9.4424 8.7715
10.3711 9.5802 8.8832
10.5288 9.7066 8.9847
10.6748 9.8226 9.0770
10.8100 9.9290 9.1609
10.9352 10.0266 9.2372
11.0511 10.1161 9.3066
11.1584 10.1983 9.3696
30
31
32
33
34
35
40
45
50
25.8077
26.5423
27.2696
27.9897
28.7027
29.4086
32.8347
36.0945
39.1961
22.3965
22.9377
23.4683
23.9886
24.4986
24.9986
27.3555
29.4902
31.4236
19.6004
20.0004
20.3888
20.7658
21.1318
21.4872
23.1148
24.5187
25.7298
17.2920
17.5885
17.8735
18.1476
18.4112
18.6646
19.7928
20.7200
21.4822
99
15.3724
15.5928
15.8027
16.0025
16.1929
16.3742
17.1591
17.7741
18.2559
13.7648
13.9291
14.0840
14.2302
14.3681
14.4982
15.0463
15.4558
15.7619
12.4090
12.5318
12.6466
12.7538
12.8540
12.9477
13.3317
13.6055
13.8007
11.2578
11.3498
11.4350
11.5139
11.5869
11.6546
11.9246
12.1084
12.2335
10.2737
10.3428
10.4062
10.4644
10.5178
10.5668
10.7574
10.8812
10.9617
9.4269
9.4790
9.5264
9.5694
9.6086
9.6442
9.7791
9.8628
9.9148
n/r
16%
18%
20%
22%
24%
26%
28%
30%
32%
34%
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
0.8621
1.6052
2.2459
2.7982
3.2743
3.6847
4.0386
4.3436
4.6065
4.8332
5.0286
5.1971
5.3423
5.4675
5.5755
5.6685
5.7487
5.8178
5.8775
5.9288
5.9731
6.0113
6.0442
6.0726
6.0971
6.1182
6.1364
6.1520
6.1656
0.8475
1.5656
2.1743
2.6901
3.1272
3.4976
3.8115
4.0776
4.3030
4.4941
4.6560
4.7932
4.9095
5.0081
5.0916
5.1624
5.2223
5.2732
5.3162
5.3527
5.3837
5.4099
5.4321
5.4509
5.4669
5.4804
5.4919
5.5016
5.5098
0.8333
1.5278
2.1065
2.5887
2.9906
3.3255
3.6046
3.8372
4.0310
4.1925
4.3271
4.4392
4.5327
4.6106
4.6755
4.7296
4.7746
4.8122
4.8435
4.8696
4.8913
4.9094
4.9245
4.9371
4.9476
4.9563
4.9636
4.9697
4.9747
0.8197
1.4915
2.0422
2.4936
2.8636
3.1669
3.4155
3.6193
3.7863
3.9232
4.0354
4.1274
4.2028
4.2645
4.3152
4.3567
4.3908
4.4187
4.4415
4.4603
4.4756
4.4882
4.4985
4.5070
4.5139
4.5196
4.5243
4.5281
4.5312
0.8065
1.4568
1.9813
2.4043
2.7454
3.0205
3.2423
3.4212
3.5655
3.6819
3.7757
3.8514
3.9124
3.9616
4.0013
4.0333
4.0591
4.0799
4.0967
4.1103
4.1212
4.1300
4.1371
4.1428
4.1474
4.1511
4.1542
4.1566
4.1585
0.7937
1.4235
1.9234
2.3202
2.6351
2.8850
3.0833
3.2407
3.3657
3.4648
3.5435
3.6059
3.6555
3.6949
3.7261
3.7509
3.7705
3.7861
3.7985
3.8083
3.8161
3.8223
3.8273
3.8312
3.8342
3.8367
3.8387
3.8402
3.8414
0.7813
1.3916
1.8684
2.2410
2.5320
2.7594
2.9370
3.0758
3.1842
3.2689
3.3351
3.3868
3.4272
3.4587
3.4834
3.5026
3.5177
3.5294
3.5386
3.5458
3.5514
3.5558
3.5592
3.5619
3.5640
3.5656
3.5669
3.5679
3.5687
0.7692
1.3609
1.8161
2.1662
2.4356
2.6427
2.8021
2.9247
3.0190
3.0915
3.1473
3.1903
3.2233
3.2487
3.2682
3.2832
3.2948
3.3037
3.3105
3.3158
3.3198
3.3230
3.3253
3.3272
3.3286
3.3297
3.3305
3.3312
3.3316
0.7576
1.3315
1.7663
2.0957
2.3452
2.5342
2.6775
2.7860
2.8631
2.9304
2.9776
3.0133
3.0404
3.0609
3.0764
3.0882
3.0971
3.1039
3.1090
3.1129
3.1158
3.1180
3.1197
3.1210
3.1220
3.1227
3.1233
3.1237
3.1240
0.7463
1.3032
1.7188
2.0290
2.2604
2.4331
2.5620
2.6582
2.7300
2.7836
2.8236
2.8534
2.8757
2.8923
2.9047
2.9140
2.9209
2.9260
2.9299
2.9327
2.9349
2.9365
2.9377
2.9386
2.9392
2.9397
2.9401
2.9404
2.9406
100
36%
0.7353
1.2760
1.6735
1.9658
2.1807
2.3388
2.4550
2.5404
2.6033
2.6495
2.6834
2.7084
2.7268
2.7403
2.7502
2.7575
2.7629
2.7668
2.7697
2.7718
2.7734
2.7746
2.7754
2.7760
2.7765
2.7768
2.7771
2.7773
2.7774
30
31
32
33
34
35
40
45
50
6.1772
6.1872
6.1959
6.2034
6.2098
6.2153
6.2335
6.2421
6.2463
5.5168
5.5227
5.5277
5.5320
5.5356
5.5386
5.5482
5.5523
5.5541
4.9789
4.9824
4.9854
4.9878
4.9898
4.9915
4.9966
4.9986
4.9995
4.5338
4.5359
4.5376
4.5390
4.5402
4.5411
4.5439
4.5449
4.5452
4.1601
4.1614
4.1624
4.1632
4.1639
4.1644
4.1659
4.1664
4.1666
101
3.8424
3.8432
3.8438
3.8443
3.8447
3.8450
3.8458
3.8460
3.8461
3.5693
3.5697
3.5701
3.5704
3.5706
3.5708
3.5712
3.5714
3.5714
3.3321
3.3324
3.3326
3.3328
3.3329
3.3330
3.3332
3.3333
3.3333
3.1242
3.1244
3.1246
3.1247
3.1248
3.1248
3.1250
3.1250
3.1250
2.9407
2.9408
2.9409
2.9410
2.9410
2.9411
2.9412
2.9412
2.9412
2.7775
2.7776
2.7776
2.7777
2.7777
2.7777
2.7778
2.7778
2.7778
LEARNING UNIT - II
102
Learning Unit-2
Instructions to Faculty
Recap on Learning Unit-I
1.
Before commencement of Learning Unit II, the Faculty may spend approximately
half an hour to make a recap of the Learning Unit-I with reference to the following
10 questions:
1. What is the objective of Trading Account ?
2. What is the Objective of Profit and Loss Account ?
3. What are the differences between the (i) Authorised Capital (ii) Issued
Capital and (iii) Subscribed Capital ?
4. Who are the real owners of a company ?
5. What is the difference between the inside liabilities and the outside liabilities ?
6. What are solvency ratios ?
7. What are liquidity ratios ?
8. What is gearing ? What is low gearing and what is high gearing ?
9. What is debt equity ratio ?
10. What is an operating cycle ?
103
1.1.
Objectives :
At the end of this Learning Unit, the participants will be able to : Calculate the present value of money receivable in future
Use SPPWF and USPWF tables to calculate the PV of cost of returns
Calculate the most economical decision
Calculate the net present value (NPV)
Calculate the Internal rate of return (IRR)
2.
3.
3.1.
Instructions to Faculty :
Make a presentation in the sequence listed below, using visual aids Nos. 13 19:
Explain the time value of money and meaning of discount factor, the
advantages of using DCFT and to which situations DCFT can be
applied
Give simple examples, for example returns accruing on National Savings
Certificates, Fixed Deposits etc.,
Explain with examples the method of calculating future value of money by
using Compound Interest
Explain how present value (PV) can be calculated by reversing the
Compound Interest Formulae
Explain how discount factor can be used.
104
Explain how SPPWF and USPWF have been constructed and how it can
be used with examples.
Explain the meaning and the purpose IRR
Explain how scientific it is to use IRR to take investment decisions with
calculations and graphs
Explain the meaning of Salvage Value.
Explain how interpolation formulae can be used to determine the IRR
Explain with examples how to calculate NPV
FV = PV x (1 + r )n
1
PV=FV x ----------(1 + r )n
105
Note:- Faculty to explain the use of table with examples on the black board, instead of
using PV formula.
19,00,000
18,00,000
17,00,000
2,63,791
1,01,890
1,04,787
Note: Faculty to explain with reference to the reading materials for LU 2, why
equipment A should be purchased after calculation of NPV.
106
Year
D.F. at
10%
NPV at
10%
DF at 12% NPV at
12%
1
2
3
4
5
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,000
3,000
Initial Cost
0.910
0.827
0.752
0.684
0.621
--
1,820
2,068
2,256
2,052
1,863
10,059
(-) 10,000
(+) 59
0.893
0.798
0.712
0.636
0.568
---
= 10 + 2 x
530
= 10 + 0.22
IRR = 10.22%
107
1,786
1,995
2,136
1,908
1,704
9,529
(-)10,000
(-) 471
N
P
V
10.22%
9%
11%
4.Group exercise:
4.1.
After the faculty has made a presentation based on the above visual aids No
13 - 19, faculty may give exercise described in the Handout on Group
Activities to the participants for application of DCFT for purchase decisions
and calculation of IRR.
4.2.
The task on DCFT will be given to two groups; each group will work
separately. One hour time limit is sufficient to discuss, to workout the
application, to take decisions, and to prepare visual aids. In addition, 30
minutes will be required for group presentations for moderation.
4.3.
Similarly, the other 2 groups will be given the task of calculating the IRR to
assess the viability of the project. Each group will work separately.
4.4.
After the groups have made their presentations, the faculty should document
the critical learning points
108
Budget
A. Performance Budgeting
B. Zero Base Budgeting
C. Cost - Benefit Analysis
[ GROUP ACTIVITIES ]
109
Learning Unit-3
Budget
1. Group Activities
1.1
Each group will be given reading materials and details of group activities.
Each group should read the material supplied, discuss solutions to the
exercise given in the group activities and make presentations thereon.
1.2
Each group will be given sufficient time to discuss and to prepare visual
aids for presentation.
2. Group 1:
2.1
2.2
The group will select a responsibility centre of their choice and design the
same as per check list given in the reading materials.
2.3
2.4
After the group presentation, the participants will list out the learning
points in the plenary.
3. Group 2:
3.1
3.3
Approximately, two hours will be given for the group to discuss and to
prepare the visual aids for presentation. In addition, 30-40 minutes will be
available for presentation and moderation.
3.4
After the group presentation, the participants will list out the important
learning points in the plenary.
Note: Both the first group and second group may assume approximate financial figures
for the purpose of class-room exercise. Lack of exact financial figures cannot be assumed
110
as a major constraint. Approximate figures selected by the group for designing and
analyzing will serve the purpose.
4.Groups- 3 and 4
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
There will be sufficient time for discussion and preparation of visual aids.
Approximately 30-40 minutes will be available for presentation and
moderation.
4.5
All the groups will list out the learning points in the plenary.
111
CASE STUDY
The Damodar Valley Flood Control Scheme
(Ajit.K. Dasgupta and D.W. Pearce)
The last chapter studied the application of cost-benefit analysis to the choice of site for a
particular project. The present chapter is concerned with evaluating a project is already
in operation.
1. THE DAMODAR VALLEY SYSTEM
The Damodar river rises in the Palamau hills, Bihar (north-east India), at an elevation of
about 2000 feet. It flows eastwards for about 180 miles through Bihar and enters the
deltaic plains of West Bengal below the coal-mining centre of Raniganj (see Fig. 1). It
continues to flow east and as it reaches the boundary of Burdwan district it is joined by
the river Barakor. The enlarged river flows along the boundary of Bankura and Burdwan
districts and then into the Burdwan district, passing just south of Burdwan town. About
ten miles east of Burdwan town, the river abruptly changes its course and turns south. It
bifurcates into the rivers Mudeswari and Damodar about two miles before entering
Hooghly district. In the extreme southern part of Hooghly district, some thirty miles
below Calcutta, it joins the Hooghly river which reaches the sea shortly afterwards.
The catchments area of the river at its mouth is about 8500 square miles, of which nearly
7000 square miles is the catchments area of the upper Damodar. (The confluence with
Barakor River is regarded as separating the upper and the lower stretches of the
Damodar.)
The topography of the Domodar valley changes from hilly and forest regions in the upper
portion of the drainage area to the flat deltaic plains of the lower region. This is reflected
also in the slope of the river, which is 10 feet per mile in the first 150 miles of its course,
3 feet per mile in the next 100 miles and less than 1 foot per mile in the last 90 miles.
The Damodar is a flood-prone rive. Since at least as far back as 1730, it has been known
to overflow its banks during the rainy season, leading to devastating floods in the lower
valley.
The occurrence of floods along the Damodar River is due in the first instance to heavy
storm-rainfalls during the monsoon period, and more generally to certain characteristics
of the river regime. Thus, in the earlier part of its course the river flows very rapidly,
eroding land and collecting silt, a tendency which has been accelerated by deforestation
in the upper reaches. J In its lower reaches, the flat deltaic plains of West Bengal, it
becomes a sluggish stream and discharges its flood waters and silt along its banks.
112
Total
Storage
Capacity
*
36
179
66
496
45
185
15
975
33
45
45
16
440
40
881
73
1510
52
19
100
49
273
18
100
168
1104
15
100
148
1214
12
100
426
2911
15
100
135
140
88
363
*in thousand acre feet
Source DVC data Book (1966)
The system of dams and reservoirs designed to develop and control the waters of the
Damodar valley is administered by a public corporation- the Damodar Valley
Corporation (D.V.C.). The control system is generally referred to as the D.V.C. system.
It consists of four dams, Tilaiya and Maithon on the Barakor, and Konar and Panchet Hill
on the river Damodar (Fig. 1). Of these, Tilaiya is a concrete gravity dam while the
others are earth dams with a concrete spillway. The total storage capacity of the four
dams together amounts to 2.9 million acre-feet, which is allocated between the different
objectives as shown in Table 1.
113
In addition to the four dams, the system includes a hydro power station at each of the
dams except Konar; thermal power stations; the Durgapur barrage; and numerous
irrigation canals off the barrage. Some characteristics of the lower Damodar valley are
described in Table 2.
Table 2 Classification of Area of Some Districts in the Lower Damodar Valley
According to Some Characteristics, 1962-3 (in thousand hectares)
Characteristics
Burdwan Bankura
(a) Area irrigated by various
259.30
118.10
canals *
(b) Area available for cultivation
542.70
507.00
(c) Area sown more than once
32.80
19.40
(d) Net area sown
495.10
346.60
(e) Area not available for
139.80
39.30
cultivation
(f) Current fallows
11.80
81.50
(g) Other uncultivated land,
35.80
78.90
excluding current fallows
(h) Total area of the district
700.71
685.54
* Relates to 1960-1.
Excluding forest area.
Source: Directorate of Agriculture, West Bengal.
The capacity costs of the project are shown in Table 3.
Howrah
24.50
Hooghly
109.20
Purulia
78.10
118.30
19.50
95.30
36.80
251.10
47.70
239.10
62.60
446.20
14.10
236.20
89.30
8.70
14.30
2.60
9.40
79.10
130.90
145.08
313.92
623.42
Konar
275
Maithon
1104
Panchet
1214
97.5 *
357
179.3
162
191.4
157
114
115
The authors of the D.V.C. Data Book point out that curves establishing relations between
flood storage versus damage in the lower valley have not been worked out after a
carefully planned survey of the affected regions after the occurrence of floods, and that,
in consequence, the benefits of the moderation of floods achieved by the use of the
D.V.C. dams have not yet been assessed on a scientific basis. An approximate appraisal
of the flood-control benefits of D.V.C. is attempted in the Data Book as follows.
Firstly, the moderation of floods by the D.V.C. reservoir system since it started operating
in 1958 is described. This is shown here in Table 5
Table 5
Date
Region affected
None
Amta - Mudeswari
Amta - Mudeswari and Raina Area
Amta - Mudeswari, Raina and leftbank area
116
Thirdly, the number of occasions when the different areas would have been affected
without dams and the number of occasions when they were actually affected with dams
are listed in Table 7.
Table 7
Data
AmtaMudeswari
without
dams
23-24 July 1958
*
12-13 Aug 1958
*
16-17 Sept 1958
*
11 July 1959
*
21-22 July 1959
*
10 Sept 1959
*
13 Sept 1959
*
1-2 Oct 1959
*
25-26 Aug 1960
*
30 Aug 1960
*
27-28 Sept 1960
*
22-23 Aug 1961
*
10-11 Sept 1961
*
2-3 Oct 1961
*
25-26 July 1962
*
22-23 Sept 1962
*
28-29 Sept 1963
*
2-3 Oct 1963
*
24-25 Oct 1963
*
Total of occasions 19
* Shows area was affected;
- shows area was not affected.
Area
with
dams
*
*
*
*
4
*
1
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
8
Left
bank
without
dams
*
*
*
*
*
*
6
Area
with
dams
0
The Benefits due to flood control are considered to be two fold: (i) the saving of
crops, and (ii) the protection of property. The probable damage due to flood inundation
is estimated from the previous data together with the further assumptions that (a) the
intensity of cultivation is 80 per cent, (b) the average yield of the crop (paddy) is 25
maunds per acre (=2056 lb per acre), (c) the price of paddy is Rs.15 per maund (i.e.
Rs.0.18 per lb) and (d) flooding of the left-bank area causes damage to property to the
extent of about Rs.200 million, in addition to the damage to agricultural production.
On these assumptions, the losses due to damage in the Amta-Mudeswari area are put at
Rs. (300 X 0.8 X 640 X 25 X 15)= Rs.60 million. Similarly, the damage due to flooding
in the Raina area is put at Rs.40 million and that due to flooding of the left bank at
Rs.400 million.
117
Hence the damage that would have occurred without dams is put at Rs.(19 X 60 + 8 X 40
+ 6 X 400) million =Rs.3860 million. The damage with the dams is estimated to be Rs.
(4 X 60 + 40) million =Rs.280 million. Hence the reduction is damage due to the dams is
estimated as Rs.3580 million.
Since this refers to the period 1958-64, the corresponding average flood benefit per year
becomes Rs. 3580 million = Rs.51 million approximately.
4. AN ALTERNATIVE APPROACH TO BENEFIT ESTIMATION
The method of evaluating flood-control benefits described above is based on the
correct idea that these benefits consist in the reduction of flood damage that the project
in question makes passive. However, the method suffers from a number of inadequacies.
Firstly, in using the sample observations during 1958-64 to derive the project benefits of
flood control, the method appeals implicitly to the theory of probability; but it fails to
specify a well-defined probabilistic model which can serve as a basis for prediction.
Secondly, the sample itself is too small.
Thirdly, the method does not lend itself conveniently to an analysis of the variations in
project benefit corresponding to variations in the reservoir operation policy.
Fourthly, the inclusion of all flood discharges above 100,000 cusecs in a given year leads
to double-counting of crop damage and hence to overestimation of flood-control benefit.
Because of these defects in the method used by the authorities of D.V.C. and as the more
conventional analysis based on the stage-damage curve (which relates various flood
stages to the associated levels of flood damage) is ruled out by the shortage of date, we
shall attempt to develop an alternative approach in terms of which the date that are a
available can best be utilized.
The basis assumption underlying our approach is that flood damage is a function of the
peak flow only (cf.Maass et al.[1] pp.287-8). In fact, the level of damage depends also
on such considerations as the time of year (which, for example, affects the maturity of
crops), the velocity of flow, the physical and chemical properties of flood waters and the
depth and duration of inundation. The use of peak flow as the determinant of flood
damage only provides a convenient first approximation (By defining peak flow as the
yearly maximum of average daily flows (rather than as momentary peaks), one can
also, to some extent, implicitly take duration into account).
If flood damage can be regarded as related predominantly to the level of flood discharge,
as is often the case, the benefits of flood control per period can be written as
B = x p (x){c(x)-c(x1 )]dx
118
119
The statistical theory of extreme values, as developed by Gumbel [2] and others, was
applied to derive the probability distribution of the peak flow. The logic of the theory
can be described briefly as follows. Consider a sample containing n independent
observations on a continuous variate x. We seek the probability distribution of the
maximum value of x in the sample. Clearly, the probability distribution of x and on the
sample size. Thus, let f(x) be the probability distribution of x and let
(x) be the
probability that the value x is the largest among n independent observations.
Then
n(x) = {F(x)} n
120
As is usual in the analysis of flood data, we assume that the initial distribution of x is the
exponential type:
F(x) = e -x
It can then be shown that
Lim n (x) = e -e -y
n?
8
Where y is a transform of x such that
Y=a n (x-un),
With 1/ a n and un having the same dimension as x, so that y is a pure number.
Hence, the double exponential distribution e-e-y represents the cumulative probability
distribution of the reduced variety. The derivative of this gives the corresponding
probability distribution (probability density function) desired.
There are two possible approaches to the estimation of the theoretical distribution of the
largest value.
Firstly, if we know the functional form of the initial distribution and the values of its
parameters as well as the sample size n, then the parameters an and un , can be obtained
directly.
Secondly, if, as is more usual, the initial distribution is unknown, we can still estimate the
parameters an and un , provided we assume that the distribution is of the exponential
type. In this case, there are a number of alternative methods for estimating the
parameters an and un. We shall follow the large-sample modified least squares method
described by Gumbel ([2] pp. 35, 168-9).
As Gumbel shows, for large n, an and un can be estimated with a reasonable degree of
approximation independently of n. The estimates depend only on the sample distribution
of extreme values and are derived by the normal equations
1
Sx
---- = -----a
N
Yn
u = x - -----a
Where
Sx, x denote respectively the standard deviation and mean of observations of the
extreme values and N, Yn are functions of the number N of extreme values observed. The
values of an and Yn as functions of N have been tabulated by Gumbel ([2] p.228).
121
The parameters of the theoretical distribution are now calculated for the date of Table 8.
They are shown in Table 9. below.
Table 9: Estimation of Parameters
Peak Flow:
Maximum of average
Daily discharges
N= Number of observations of largest value
x Sample mean (thousand cusecs)
Sx= Sample standard deviation (thousand cusecs)
18
257.05
127.05
an
Yn
1.0493
0.5202
an
121.08
194.04
Having calculated the constants, we can now proceed to derive the observed and
theoretical distributions of the largest value for each of the two types of peak-flow data
considered. These are shown in Table 11
Column 1 of Table 11 shows values of the reduced variety at intervals of 0.25, the length
of the class interval being necessarily arbitrary. Column 2 gives the corresponding values
of y as calculated from Beckers tables [3]; it gives the cumulative probability of y for
each value of y tabulated in column 1. Column 3 is derived by multiplying each item in
column 2 by the sample size; it gives the theoretical cumulative frequency. Column 4
gives the first differences of successive entries in column 3 and represents the theoretical
frequencies in each class interval.
The peak flows x, equal to the yearly maximum of average daily discharges obtained by
letting y take on the values shown in column 1, are given in column
5(x=Y/a+u;a, u being found from Table 9) The cumulative observed frequencies
corresponding to these values of x are derived from Table 10 which gives the peak- flow
data of Table 8 ranked in ascending order. K These are given in column 6. Column 7 is
obtained by taking first differences of the figures in cloumn6. These shown the observed
frequencies for the same class intervals for which the theoretical frequencies were
calculated.
122
Table 10
Ranking of Peak Flows in Ascending Order
(Peak flow= yearly maximum of average daily discharges)
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Peak flow
(thousand cusecs)
61.9
120.9
121.7
153.5
168.3
174.5
229.7
230.1
245.9
251.3
258.5
259.6
266.5
313.7
347.4
375.0
422.5
625.0
The cumulative frequency distributions for theoretical and observed peak flows as
calculated above are graphically represented in Fig. 8. (Peak flow= yearly maximum of
average daily discharges). The observed and theoretical cumulative distribution show
close agreement.
This provides some justification for the use of the estimated
distribution for the assessment of flood damage in this region.
123
(2)
Theoretical
cumulative
probability
0.6599
0.12039
0.19230
0.27693
0.36788
0.45896
0.54524
0.62352
0.69220
0.75088
0.80001
0.84048
0.87342
0.89996
0.92119
0.93807
0.95143
0.96197
0.97025
0.97675
(3)
Theoretical
cumulative
frequency
1
2
4
5
7
8
10
11
13
14
14
15
16
16
17
17
17
17
18
18
(4)
Theoretical
frequency
(5)
Observed
peak flow
1
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
73
103
133
164
194
224
255
285
315
345
376
406
436
466
497
527
557
587
618
648
(6)
Observed
cumulative
frequency
1
1
3
4
6
6
10
13
14
14
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
18
(7)
Observed
frequency
1
0
2
1
2
0
4
3
1
0
2
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
124
Table12
Discharge at Rhondia
(thousand cusecs)
Area inundated
(square miles)
150
360
200
386
250
405
300
423
400
454
500
479
600
500
Source: Report of the Committee for the Augmentation of Water Resources of Damodar
Valley Corporation (Calcutta, 1959) p.52.
A linear regression y = a + x was fitted to the data by the standard least-squares method
and gave the following results :
a = 324 930
= 0.305
r2 =0.944
rv5
t = ---------- = 9.215.
v 1- r2
The function
y = 324.93 + 0.305x
Was used for calculating the area inundated, y, for a given discharge, x. (See above for
the derivation of this equation. The relationship between the theoretical and observed
values suggested that a linear regression was justified.)
To calculate the damage per unit of is inundated, we made the same assumptions that
were used by the D.V.C. in computing their own estimates of flood damage, namely:
a)
b)
c)
d)
The probability distribution of the peak flow together with the discharge/flood-damage
relationship enable the gross benefit of flood-control policies as described to be
computed. For this purpose, the maximum of average daily discharges measure of the
peak flow was used, since this appeared to be the concept of most closely related to the
data of Table 12, from which the linear regression of the area inundated on flood
discharge was computed.
125
A Summary
We shall conclude by pointing out some of the more important limitations of the method
of evaluating flood-control benefits described in this chapter.
Firstly, the estimation of the flood-damage function involves a number of serious
difficulties. Thus, the relationship between flood discharge and area inundated in this
region is likely to show an upward shift over time owing to the building of new structures
and the silting of the river bed in the lower valley. This has in fact been happening in the
deltaic regions of West Bengal, with the result that a peak flow of a given ni tensity now
tends to produce a greater extent of inundation than in the past.
Again, the damage per unit area inundated tends to increase over time because of
economic development. To the extent that such an increase in the damage factor is due to
autonomous economic development, the estimation procedure may be corrected by
appropriate statistical analysis (e.g. by taking trend factors into1 within the normal range
of rates of discount it actually makes very little difference whether the lifetime sued is
100 years or 150 years or infinity. 10 per cent has been widely sued as an accounting rate
126
of discount in public-sector projects in India. However, this rate is used here merely to
illustrate the method. The question of the appropriate social rate of discount has been
discussed in Chapter 6 above account). On the other hand, economic development may
result form the flood-control project itself. In this case, there are considerable conceptual
difficulties in evaluating project benefits. These are connected with the question: do
flood-control schemes lead to over-development in the flood basin? Such a question
cannot easily be answered within the framework of cost-benefit analysis itself (but see
Renshaw [4].
Secondly, this exercise has been confined to the flood-control component of the D.V.C
project; for this purpose, we took the allocation of storage capacity between different
objectives, e.g. flood control, irrigation and power, as given. This means in effect that we
accepted without question the constraints imposed on the system, viz., certain minimum
levels of power, flood-control storage and so on. On the other hand, one of the aims of
cost-benefit analysis of multi-purpose river-valley projects should be to examine the
opportunity costs of varying the levels of different constraints. This can provide means
of estimating the trade-offs between different objectives. However, the method described
for estimating the benefits of flood control may itself be regarded as a first step towards
making such comparisons possible. Thirdly, no attempt was made to estimate the
secondary benefits of flood control.
Finally, it must be stressed once more than the statistical calculations provided in this
chapter must be regarded as illustrative and preliminary rather than as providing a
blueprint for the project in question.
127
Budget
A. Performance Budgeting
B. Zero Base Budgeting
C. Cost - Benefit Analysis
[ READING MATERIAL ]
128
Learning Unit - 3
Reading material
Performance Budgeting
1. Definitions:
1.1.
It is an input-activity-output analysis.
2. Goal:
2.1.
3. Objectives:
To adopt concepts of economy and efficiency
To plan and budget with the mission of customers satisfaction
To set targets under each variable by following the principles of operationality
and attainability.
To measure the performance, both tangible and intangible
To match responsibility, authority and accountability
To serve the purpose of systematic monitoring and evaluation
To enable internal customers and supervisory level staff to undertake performance
inspection
To enable external evaluating agencies to conduct performance audit.
To develop an activity oriented system to fill the gap between benchmark and
defined standards in terms of quantity, quality and time.
To present performance results to board level or to the representatives of the
people, as the case may be.
129
At the macro level, the Head of the department must consolidate the
performance budget prepared for different responsibility centers. To begin
with, the mission of the organisation must be effectively marketed at all
internal managerial levels. A business survey should be conducted within
the policy frame of the government. If required, when conducting the
business survey, external customers may be involved along with other
departments and organisations to the extent that co-ordination is required
from them.
3.2
The task of business survey is both internal and external. The objective of
internal survey is to collect important data, followed with information.
For example, details regarding the budget for the ensuing year, current
year with revision, if any, and actuals of the previous three years. This
entails a study of the Annual administrative reports, Inspection Reports,
Audit Reports, Financial and appropriation accounts of previous three
years.
3.3
3.4
After the business survey is over, the next task is that the HOD lists out
the responsibility centers at macro level by involving the internal staff at
different managerial levels.
This must be done with precision and
accuracy for each responsibility center, area-wise. For example
Compulsory Primary Education is one of the responsibility centers in
the Education Department. Under this, there are a number of schools,
number of teachers, number of students in different districts, blocks,
villages through out the state. Therefore, listing out the name of each
school with address, names of teachers, numbers of students enrolled is
essential at the micro-level. Performance Budgeting must be prepared for
130
4.
Group Work:
4.1.
Prepare the Performance Budget for a responsibility center using the check
list given below; presuming that, at this stage the task of business survey is
completed.
Check List to prepare PB for Responsibility Center
1. Title:
PB of the ------------------------------------------ (Project/Office/Scheme etc.) coming under
the ---------------------------- (Organization/Department) for the financial year ---------------
2. Aim
Write down the aims of the responsibility center within the policy frame of National or
State level.
3. Objectives
Write down the number of objectives on priority basis. Again under each objective list
the variables.
131
4. Targets
Under each variable spell out the targets.
If the targets are intangible (not measurable), mention the targets in terms of positive
statement. If possible, incorporate the figures for 3 years. That means, there must be 5
columns i.e., first three columns for the previous three years, the 4th column for the
current year with two sub columns covering both the original and revised targets, and the
5th column for the ensuing year.
5. Budget
List out budgetary details separately for manpower budget and the details of non-salary
budget, both under plan and non-plan. The details of capital outlays and loans, if any,
shall also be mentioned. It shall contain the column wise details for the previous three
years, current year budget with the sub columns for original and revised estimates and the
estimates for the next year. The detailed head wise, i.e., objective classification shall be
mentioned.
6. Organisation Chart
Mention the details of organization right from the Head of the responsibility Center with
cadre wise strength. Also, mention the job chart of the staff, with the details of authority
and responsibility. Under the job chart list out the events and list out the activities under
each event. For each activity, prepare a checklist.
7. Infrastructure Facility
The existing strength of the department in terms of buildings, machines, furniture and
other equipment etc., with the details of there condition shall be mentioned.
8. Constraints
The specific constraints experienced in the past three years and the anticipated constraints
and limitations shall be mentioned. For example, the work load, lack of equipment,
support, lack of training to operate new machinery, etc.
9. Co-Ordination
The expected level and areas of co-ordination with other organisations shall be
mentioned here.
132
10.2
10.3 Under each variable indicate the achievable targets in terms of quantity,
quality and time standards. . If necessary, indicate a phasing out of such
targets, if required on a monthly, quarterly, half yearly or an annual basis.
Where it is not possible to explain the targets in measurable terms, indicate
the same in the form of statements. Under each variable, ensure that you:
List out the activities to be undertaken to fill the gap between the
bench mark and proposed standards.
133
Develop a system
performance.
of
external
evaluations
to
measure
the
Note: The design in terms of format and columns may vary from responsibility
center to responsibility center. For this purpose HOD has to involve the Heads of
responsibility center in order to evolve a common format for responsibility center.
must be
the entire
to nonseparately
b. At this stage the Performance Budget document for the entire department
will be ready for presentation and discussion by different stakeholders.
134
Learning Unit - 3
Reading material
1.2
In the case of on-going expenditure zero base budgeting helps examine the
necessity of continuance of that expenditure from various angles with a view to
enabling planners to take final decisions on whether to continue or stop that
expenditure.
1.3
In the case of recurring expenditure, zero base budgeting help view every item of
the recurring costs afresh in order to help planners decide as to whether to allow
the recurrence of the expenditure or to stop it.
1.4
If the initial examination indicates that the existing level of expenditure of any
item is inevitable, zero base budgeting will help question the incremental
expenditure of that item.
2. Methodology:
To prepare Zero Base Budgeting, it is necessary to follow the steps given below:
135
3. Decision Units:
3.1
3.2
A decision unit should not be too small or too big in size. It must be of a
meaningful size, so that cost performance ratio (financial input and output
ratio) is convincing. If the decision unit is too small, the overhead costs
may be highly disproportionate to the performance. If the decision unit is
too big, the quality of monitoring of performance may suffer. Therefore,
it may be necessary to bring about structural re-organization in a
department in order to provide for an optimum decision unit from the
point of view of economy and effective monitoring.
3.3
3.4
The objective of proper classification and size of the decision units are to:
? Define or redefine authority and responsibility
? Provide effective internal co-ordination
? Carry out analytical studies, e.g. work load study; resource-performance
ratio study; machinery-performance ratio study, etc.
? Identify redundant expenditure
? Remove duplication of expenditure
? Re-deploy surplus resources
? Resize tasks with reference to local needs; etc.,
4.2
Each subject or project would have a unique title. For example, assume
that the Deputy Director of AH&VS of a District is a decision unit. Under
this decision unit there may be the following decision packages:
Sheep rearing
136
Poultry farming
Artificial insemination centre
F & M vaccine centre
Pets health care; etc.
Questions:
What is the necessity of the decision package?
What will be the consequences if the decision package is not implemented?
What will be the tangible and intangible benefits if the decision package is
implemented?
Make a social cost-benefit analysis of the decision package
137
6.2
Evaluation must take cognizance of the needs of the people - from the point of
view of prioritization of Decision Packages and from the point of view of
allocation of resources.
The evaluated Decision Packages must to ranked based on the needs of the people
and on the Policy of the Government. Decision Packages with higher rankings
must be funded on a priority basis. Decision Packages which are lower in ranking
and cannot be funded on account of resource constraints have to be deferred.
138
Learning Unit - 3
Reading material
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
Cost-benefit analysis is based on welfare theories developed by various economists.
Here we will not be dwelling on the historical development of the welfare concept. Our
focus will be on undertaking Cost Benefit Analysis with reference to a given project.
A given project will have a definite area and definite customers.
launching a project the following points must be considered:-
In theory, before
139
Compensation policies.
Economic growth centers.
Prioritization of projects and prioritization of objectives in a given project must be
based on the principles of consumer sovereignty.
Shadow Price
(Also known as Accounting Price or Social Price)
(Definition from the Book Pocket Economist by Prof. Matthew Bishop)
1.1
1.2
2. External Effects:2.1
2.2
The effect of each of these may be either negative or positive. If the effect
is negative, the sufferer has to be compensated. If it is positive, the person
who has gained must pay for it. The effects are analyzed from the point of
view of (i) input-generated effects and (ii) output-generated effects.
140
Production also affects the consumer. Here too, the effect may be positive or negative.
If the effect is positive, the consumer must pay for it. If it is negative, the consumer has
to be compensated.
External effects are often attributed to technological advances. In addition, government
assistance, including subsidies also have an external impact.
Social time preference is based upon the assumption that (i) society
always prefers the present to the future, and (ii) the next generation will
have higher consumption levels
It is not possible to estimate the
preferences of the generation. However, the benefits to be derived by
future generations must be greater than the cost of sacrifice of the present
generation. The time gap between these is taken as base for discounting
procedure .
3.2
3.3
3.4
The Social Rate of Discount is taken as base to calculate the present value
of benefits and costs. While selecting a project on the basis of NPV
indicator, risk and uncertainty analysis must be undertaken. The major
problem is non-availability of exact/reliable data. The expected utilities
and the probabilities are the major factors of uncertainty. The driving
forces, sustaining forces, restricting forces shall be measured especially
under the key indicators. Too much of pessimistic or too much optimistic
estimations not to be considered. The calculations based on weighted
average or standard deviations may be more appropriate. In reality, it is
always safer to prepare for the marginal variations i.e., regarding the
difference between the actuals and estimations.
141
Budget
A. Performance Budgeting
B. Zero Base Budgeting
C. Cost - Benefit Analysis
[ Instructions to Faculty ]
142
Learning Unit - 3
Instructions to Faculty
A. Performance Budgeting
1. Objectives:
At the end of this learning unit, the participants will be able to
2. Instructions to Faculty:
2.1
2.2
Programme/Activity classifications
Norms, yardsticks and standards to measure performance
Accounting classification
Decentralized responsibility structure
Reporting and review of performance
Designing responsibility centers.
Faculty may use the material in visual aids Nos. 20 and 21 in order to
make the said presentation.
143
2.3
Faculty to explain:
Historical background of performance budgeting and its definition
Advantages of performance budgeting
Systems improvement that can be effected by adopting performance
budgeting
Applications in practical situations
Concepts relating to measurement and accountability.
Title
Aim
Objectives
Targets and Standards
Budget and output
Organisation Chart
Co-ordination
Measurement
Evaluation.
This will be followed by activity described for Group 1 in the section on Group
Activities for Learning Unit 3. Group activities should be carried out in
accordance with the given instructions.
144
Following are the sub units of the Learning Unit 5 to achieve the above objectives.
2. Instructions to Faculty:
2.1
2.2
2.3
145
2.5
Faculty will act as facilitator to each group, to clarify doubts during group
discussion. Each group will design the decision package using visual aids.
2.6
Faculty will explain how relevant questions can be framed for expenditure
on on-going schemes or new items of expenditure.
2.7
Faculty should explain to the individual groups how to draft objectives for
decision packages, such that the objectives are sharp and specific.
2.8
2.9
Faculty may use the visual aids Nos. 22 and 23 for making the
presentations:
Decision Units
Decision Packages
Designing of Decision Packages
Ranking
Allocation of funds.
146
2.10
2.11
2.12
Name
Account
Duration
Functions
Objectives and Targets
Events and activities.
Relevance and Questions
Measurement
Funding level
Methods
This will be followed by activity described for Group 2 in the section of Group
Activities in Learning Unit 3.
147
3.2
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
4. Instructions to faculty:
Make a presentation covering the following content areas:
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
4.1
Why ?
Social preferences
Utility and welfare
Compensation
Externalities
Social rate of discount
Valuation
Case Studies.
148
4.2
This will be followed by activities described for groups 3 and 4 analyzing case studies,
entitled and 'Damodar Valley Flood Control Scheme'. The case studies are drawn from
the book, entitled Cost Benefit analysis: theory and practice by Ajit K. Dasgupta and
D.W. Pearce. Faculty should explain how to analyze the negative and positive effects of
the case studies under the different indicators of social cost benefit analysis.
149
CAPITAL
MANAGEMENT
[ Group Activities ]
150
Learning Unit 4
Group Activities
Capital Management
1. Group Activities
1.1
1.2
Activities will be conducted in three groups. Each group will be assigned tasks in
two sub-units.
1.3
Group 1:
A. Capital structure.
B. Capital budgeting decisions.
Group 2:
C. Measurement of risk.
D. Cost of capital including CAP-M
Group 3:
Based on books borrowed from the library and the reading materials circulated,
participants will be involved in group discussion for
1.4
During group discussion, group must be guided by the questions given in the box
below. The questions are framed with a view to facilitating conceptual clarity.
Information given in the reading material will provide sufficient clues to the
solutions.
1.5
After group discussion, one or two persons from the group will make a
presentation using visual aids. Presentations will be further strengthened with
plenary discussions, moderation and listing of learning units.
151
Guiding Questions:
1. Generally individuals show a time preference for money? Give reasons.
2. Why is the consideration of time important in financial decision making ?
3. Explain the mechanics of calculating the present value of cash flows.
4. Explain the concept of valuation of securities.
5. What is the difference between the valuation of bond and of a preference
share?
6. Why are dividends important in determining the present value of a share?
7. What is the difference between the expected and the required rates of return in
context of common share?
8. What is capital budgeting? Why is it significant for a firm?
9. What are the reasons for the popularity of the payback period method, despite
its weaknesses?
10. How do you calculate the ARR? What are its limitations?
11. What is meant by the term value of money? Which capital budgeting methods
takes into consideration about this concept? How is it possible for the capital
budgeting methods that do not consider the time value of money to lead to
wrong capital budgeting decisions?
12. Distinguish between profits and cash flows? Why are cash flows important in
investment decisions?
13. What are incremental cash flows? Briefly explain effects of the following on
the calculation of incremental cash flows.
(a) Sunk costs.
(b) Allocation overheads and
(c) Opportunity costs.
14. How should depreciation be treated in capital budgeting? Do the depreciation
methods affect cash flows differently? How?
15. Explain the significance of cost of capital in financial decision making
16. How is the cost of debt computed? How does it differ from the cost of
preference capital?
17. The equity capital is cost free. Do you agree? Give reasons
18. How is the weighted average cost of capital calculated? What weights should
be used in its calculation?
19. The chairman of a rubber company stated we dont adjust our capital
budgeting calculations for inflation because the price and costs of the product
increase by the same rate Comment
20. Explain the concept of risk? How can risk be measured?
21. What is sensitivity analysis? What are its advantages and limitations?
22. What is financial risk? How does it differ from business risk? How does the
use of financial leverage result in increased financial risk?
23. Explain the assumptions and implications of the net income approach and net
operating income approach.
24. Define capital structure. What do you mean by an appropriate capital
structure? What should generally be the features of an appropriate capital
structure?
152
CAPITAL
MANAGEMENT
[ READING MATERIAL ]
153
Learning Unit 4
Reading material
Capital Management
Capital Structure
(Extract from the book Financial Management by Prof. I.M. Pandey)
1. Capital:
1.1
Capital is made up of debt and equity. Debt is borrowed money, for example
money borrowed from financial institutions, etc. Equity is shareholders' money
called equity capital. Capital is required either for new business or to expand the
existing business. Capital comes from different sources.
1.2
The debt holders do not have a share in the profit. They can only ask for return of
money borrowed with interest. Their claim is limited to fixed return.
1.3
As debt rises, capital rises; consequently interest rates rise and risks will also rise.
1.4
The capital must be a right mix of debt and equity. This is called capital structure.
The capital structure affects stock prices and the cost of capital.
1.5
1.6
If a firms capital is only from the source of equity and not from the source of
debt, its interest payments will be zero. In such situations return on invested
capital will be equal to return on equity. RoE stands for Return on Equity.
1.7
The fluctuations in RoE may depend on factors like, booms, recessions, new
products, competitors strikes, fire etc. These factors may recur in future also.
These uncertainties are business risks. The stock holders have to bear the
business risks.
1.8
The other important factors on which the business risks depend are:
154
1.9
The fixed costs normally do not fluctuate. Therefore a small fall in sales may lead
to a larger fall in RoE. In other words, business risk will be higher, if the fixed
costs are high. The higher the degree of operating leverages, the higher the
business risk.
1.10
1.11
Capital budgeting decision is based upon the initial investment and its operational
or utility cost, and not just on the initial investment alone. Therefore, some of the
higher fixed costs may lead to lower variable costs i.e. the lower operational or
utility costs.
1.12
2. Financial Leverage
2.1
A firm may finance a new plant or expand an existing plant through debt (also
called as financial leverage) or through equity.
2.2
If financed through debt, the business risk would concentrate on the existing
common stock holders because the debt holders would get fixed interest
payments; the debt holder therefore do not bear the business risk. In other words,
using financial leverage in the form of debt finance shall place the business risk
totally on the common stockholder.
2.3
In case of financing through both the sources, namely debt and equity, the capital
budgeting decision shall focus on Appropriate Ratio. The higher the debt
(financial leverage) and lower the equity, the higher the business risk on the old
stock investors plus on the new stock investors.
155
2.4
The lower the debt (financial leverage) and the higher the equity, the lower the
business risk on the part of stock investors (old + new), but the stock holder may
end up with lower percentage of dividend per share.
2.5
With a rise in debt capital and corresponding rise in returns, the earnings per share
will go up. But the question is whether in this situation, a firm will enhance debt
financing. Why not? The point is that the quantum of benefits arising out of debt
investment (financial leverage) must offset the business risk of equity investors.
2.6
To conclude, the management must plan to find out the lowest investment on
fixed assets with lowest operational or utility cost.
2.7
It the management aims at increasing debt finance, it must see that the business
risk on equity holders is offset by returns on debt.
3.2
Prof. Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller developed modern capital structure
theory. They made the assumption that a firms value will not be affected by its
capital structure that is debt versus equity. In other words, they believed that
capital structure is irrelevant. The Modigliani- Miller (MM) theory was also
based on the assumption of Zero taxes. The Zero Taxes effect means that the
return derived out of use of financial leverage will exactly offset the increase in
risk. In other words, the MM theory believes in the proportionality of returns to
risk. That means net benefit is zero. But in reality such net benefit of using
financial leverage may be positive or negative.
3.3
the tax on return on bonds encourages the finance through equity. Finally, the
relative effect of both may decide the portion of debt finance and equity finance in
the capital structure.
3.4
The shareholder may also get the return on Capital. Until the stock is sold, there
will be no capital gain and there will be no capital gains tax. The rate of capital
gains tax is always lower. This factor will have supportive effect to equity
finance.
4. Bankruptcy Costs:
4.1
The MM theory assumes the bankruptcy cost as Zero. A firm heading for
bankruptcy has to suffer from a chain of negative problems like, selling assets at
low price, difficulty in retaining customers, credit refusal, threat of move out by
key players etc. These problems may result in high legal and accounting
expenses. Mere foreseeing the threat of bankruptcy is sufficient for a firm to
avoid using financial leverage (debt finance) to excessive levels. When the return
to a firm is highly fluctuating, it always faces a threat of bankruptcy. Such firms
shall opt for lower debt finance (financial leverage).
4.2
When facing high costs or financial distress, firms must reduce the use of debt
finance (financial leverage)
5. Trade-Off
5.1
Selling in advance, the anticipated benefits of debt financing against the possible
threat of higher interest rate and bankruptcy costs is the trade-off theory. The
interest paid on debt finance is eligible for deduction benefit under corporate tax.
This benefit will raise the using of debt, which in turn, there will be rise in EBIT
and rise in the value of stock price [EBIT stands for earning before income tax or
operating income]. In MM theory this will be called as effects of corporation
taxation. Inspite of favorable situation for the use of debt finance, still a firm
may not opt to use 100% debt, because of lesser I.T. on income out of stock, threat
of financial distress and the situation of higher the interests for the higher debt.
5.2
The major problems a firm may face is that the tax benefits derived on debt
financing will be reduced or taken away by the bankruptcy related costs and rising
interest rate. Here the bankruptcy related costs means the cost entering into the
situation of probable bankruptcy in terms of prevention.
5.3
If a firm raises its use of debt, the weighted average cost of capital initially
decreases and then begins to rise after reaching the minimum.
6. Signaling Theory
157
6.1
The companys managers will have better information when compared to the
investors, regarding the prospectus of a given company. But the MM theory
assumes, both will have the same information.
6.2
6.3
If the future prospects are not good, the firm may invite new investors to purchase
stock and to share the new higher cost or losses. When new shares are issued,
normally, the share price will come down.
6.4
This signaling theory holds good for smaller firms but not for larger firms having
many financing options.
6.5
The surplus cash will normally be used for debt-servicing or to pay higher
dividends or it may be used for perquisites or it may be used for further debt
rising. Use of surplus cash for debt servicing is called bonding the free cash
flow.
6.6
The surplus cash may also be used to finance its own shares.
6.7
Higher the debt means, higher the problems for the managers in the form of risk
of bankruptcy.
6.8
Now, it is clear that, an optimal capital structure means, the level at which the
value of capital is maximized and the overall cost of capital is minimized.
6.9
6.10
Outsiders, say, lenders, and analysis made by experts may influence the financial
structure of a firm. These outsiders pressurize a firm to keep their debt activities
below the existing industrial norms. A firm will have to pay heavy interest if it
takes its debt activities beyond the existing industrial debt norms. It may even
lead to a problem of encountering financial distress.
6.11
The fired financial charges may also lead to financial distress, if the sinking fund
payments are not grossed up from time to time.
158
6.12
A firm shall not use its full debt capacity. A gap should be maintained for scope
to borrow money at any time. This will help the firm to borrow on favorable
terms. When the borrowing rate is low and when borrowing is essential, it is
better to go for debt financing because, at low cost of capital long term bonds can
be obtained. This will be controlled by the EBIT divided by the total interest
charges.
6.13
Major stock holders often attempt to takeover management from the existing
management group by way of purchasing the minimum required number shares.
Therefore, the existing management group must be careful about using equity
leverage. On the other hand, creditors may assume control, in case of default as
per debt agreement. All these factors will fix the management between the
financial layers to use the leverages to determine the capital structure.
6.14
Change in capital structure will influence the future profitability and in turn it will
have effect on other variables.
6.15
In practice, finance managers focus on identifying a level of debt, where they can
be comfortable with getting all the benefits of debt and to keep the financial risk
within these operational limits.
7.2
They argued that, it does not matter, whether the company finances its activities
by debt or by equity or with combination of both. The exemption of interest on
debt from corporate tax also does not matter. They stressed that companies
should finance their activities through debt or use their portion of profit to finance
their activities.
7.3
7.4
The capital structure has got no effect on the value of a firm and its weighted
average cost of capital (WACC)
7.5
With two companys modules, MM theory established that companies may differ
from the point of how they are financed and their respective total market values
7.6
The investors may sell the shares of the higher valued firm and may resort to
purchase shares of the lower-valued firm. This transaction will go up to a point
where both the firms will have same market value.
MM argues that
disequilibrium finally must end and cannot persist. All these arguments are based
159
upon further assumptions, that (i) EBIT is constant and (ii) earnings are paid out
of dividends
7.7
The profit motive would bring the equilibrium in the values of the two firms.
Therefore MM maintains that WACC and the firms value must be independent of
capital structure. In the cases where transactions costs are significant or in a
situation of non-identical risk, this arbitrage process of MM theory cannot be
invoked.
7.8
In 1958 MM theory assumed Zero tax and subsequently in 1963, they modified
the theory by incorporating corporate taxes. Since the interest on debt finance is
exempted from corporate tax, the leverage may have positive effect to increase a
firms value. Therefore, the value of levered firm will increase because of
leverage when compared to the value of un-unlevered firm, because the unlevered
firm will not have benefit of the value of tax savings. As the debt rises, gain from
leverage raises.
7.9
The taxes reduce the effect of cost of debt equal to interest rate. Therefore the
firms value increases as it leverages increases.
The stand-alone risk is a measure of financial risk. The stand-alone risk can be
reduced, by diversification in individual portfolios.
8.2
Robert Hamada merged CAPM and MM after-tax model, to obtain the cost
equity to a leveraged firm.
8.3
The rate of return on a stock at a particular required level can be classified in to:
The risk free rate i.e., compensation to shareholders for the time value of
money
A premium for business risk
A premium for financial risk
8.4
The premium for financial risk would be zero in the absence of financial leverage.
In such situations the shareholders gets compensation only for business risk.
8.5
The addition of debt to the existing capital structure results in new value, resulting
in a financial risk premium on the Stock. This will also add to the business risk
premium.
9. Miller Model
9.1
Prof Merton Miller designed a new model incorporating both corporate tax and
personal tax to show how leverage affects firms values.
160
9.2
In other words the Miller model explains the possibility of estimating the value of
a levered firm with both corporate and personal taxes.
9.3
The threat of debt financing is the financial distress. Financial distress includes
bankruptcy. Bankruptcy itself costs too much.
10.2
10.3
10.4
10.5
Withdrawal cost in the form of indirect loss e.g., withdrawal by customers is high.
10.6
Therefore the use of debt finance must be matched by earnings in terms of present
value. Otherwise the firm will face the threat of distress finance.
10.7
It is also very difficult for a firm to raise capital either through debt or equity at
the time of facing financial distress. Once financial distress commences or is a
probability, the current value of a firm decreases.
10.8
The effect of distress may lead to default in debt payments. The victims are the
bond holders.
A firm may try to benefit the stockholders at the cost of bond holders. Therefore
the bondholders prefer restrictive clauses in the covenants and they employ an
agency to monitor the obedience of the firm to the clauses in the covenants.
161
Prof. Gordon Donaldson of Harvard made some findings saying that, (1) Firms try
to manage with internal earnings. (2) They set targets regarding dividend share
ratios based on the future investment opportunities and returns. (3) They are
reluctant to raise dividends, because of the threat of difficulty in maintaining the
raised dividends at all time (4) they use surplus cash for servicing of debt, to
maintain dividend level, repurchase of shares, invest in other securities etc.
12.2
Equity finance will be raised in the form of earnings and new stock. First
preference will be in favour of using retained earnings. If the retained earnings
are not sufficient, a firm may go far debt financing rather than going for issuing of
new stock. This will cause debt ratio to go up.
13. Conclusions
The analysis of capital structure must focus both on market values and the book values.
But a firm can stay on either of one. But the analysis is meant to find out the capital
structure which maximizes the firms market value. The credibility lies in the stock
price. Therefore capital structure can be determined by an analysis of market values.
162
Capital budgeting means investment decisions involving fixed assets i.e., the long term
assets used in production. The budget is a financial plan pertaining to inflows and
outflows for a prescribed period. In capital budget focus will be on what is to be
included.
Investments in fixed assets are meant for long term use.
Therefore higher the
investments in fixed assts, the lower are the flexibility. The forecasting of returns must
correspond to the life of the fixed assets.
The threat of changing technology affecting the price and quality will heavily influence
the investment in long term fixed assets. Once invested in long term fixed assets, going
back may be impossible and such going back will be a costly affair.
Investment in Capital Assets (i.e., in large term assets) must be done in appropriate time.
There must be match between the demand and the marketing of the goods produced. If
these two are mismatched one cannot justify the investment in capital assets. Perhaps
even it may be disastrous.
The firm must anticipate in advance when it needs to go in for new machinery or to
change the existing one. Otherwise a firm may not be in a position to take advantage of
the demands prevalent in the market.
Because of the various complications involved in capital budgeting, a firm has to plan the
capital expenditure properly.
The proposal for capital budgeting may start from the demand for a particular new
product in the market. This will lead to obtaining customers' opinion, demand analysis,
limitations, capacity building, cost and price analysis and profit analysis, finally leading
capital budgeting project.
The changing needs of the customers in terms of change in the product in terms of
quality, quantity or for a new product or his opinion of uncomfortableness with the
existing product, his opinion on price etc., will always influence the growth or expansion
of a firm. A firm if it wants to survive must be able to be responsive to the changing
needs of the customers. This will form the base for capital budgeting proposals. A firm
must-have strategic business plan to be flexible enough to meet the changing marketing
challenges. The internal staff of a firm has to be encouraged to come up with the new
capital investment proposals. Every proposal has to be screened, before selecting or
rejecting. The analyzing of every such proposals itself, involves cost. The proposals
may be categorized as follows:
1. Replacement of worn-out or damaged equipment to maintain the existing level of
business
163
2.
3.
4.
5.
1. Payback Period
1.1
In how many years (period) can one recover the original investment? This
is the essence of payback period.
How quickly will the original
investment be recovered?
1.2
Calculate this for each capital project to rank it. The capital project with
shortest pay back period tops the list. To accept or reject proposed
projects must be mutually exclusive.
In L.U.2 the DCFT has been explained in detail. Use the DCFT technique
to convert the expected cash flows in terms of present value. The DCFT
164
will take in to account the capital cost. It may be defined as the number of
years required to recover the investment from discounted net cash flows.
2.2
The pay back and the discounted pay back methods do not consider the
returns after the payback period. Therefore ranking the projects by using
these techniques may likely to be defective.
Here also the DCFT financial concept has to be used to convert the cash
inflows (including the salvage value) as well as cash outflows in terms of
the present value of money. The difference will be the NPV. The project
showing higher NPV will be ranked over the project showing lesser NPV.
In calculating IRR as shown on LU.2, the cash inflows will not used for
reinvestment. But in MIRR the cash inflows will be shown as reinvested.
This is based upon the benefit-cost ratio. The PV of benefit per P.V. of
rupee (cost) will be determined. The higher the P.I., the higher the project
ranking. After looking into the various methods of ranking one may
prefer the NPV and IRR method to rank the capital investment projects.
IRR is even more preferable because it clearly shows the safety margin in
the form of gap between opportunity cost of firm and a discount factor at
which NPV=O. The bigger organizations or when stakes are very high, a
decision maker may like to employ all methods to reach conclusions.
165
6.2
6.3
The major problem is, in reality, the longer the duration of the project, the
higher the defectiveness of estimations. Because in the long run the
positive NPV may be erased out and market may become even more
imperfect. Above all estimations not based on inflation accounting even
more be unrealistic, because inflation rate will reduce the real value of
future returns.
6.4
Inspite of all such limitations, firms are using one or the other method/s to
take decisions.
7. Post-Audit
7.1
How far is the decision taken regarding the capital budget correct? This
requires audit i.e., by comparing the predictions with actual performance
and explaining the differences. The concurrent audit is even more
preferable, so that, the monthly reports of actual under different indicators
could be compared quickly with reference to estimations done. This will
enable the management to make corrections during the subsequent
operation process. This will improve the quality of subsequent estimates,
and improve the operations etc.
Measurement of Risk
(Source:- From the book of Financial Management by Prof. M.Y. Khan & P.K. Jain)
Investments are always exposed to different degrees of risk. Every uncertainty or the
degree of an uncertainty cannot be foreseen. Therefore a perfect prediction of cash flow
is not possible. That means risk is associated with the blind area of uncertainty.
The events that influence the forecasts may be grouped as:
Business activities will be influenced by monetary and fiscal policies, economic policies,
political situations, law and order, industrial relations, changing technologies, natural
problems, change in management, labor problems etc.,
Risk is available associated with future returns of an investment. The Government bonds
are said to be risk-free because of 100% faith in Government where the default=0. This
is not so in the case of investment in shares.
166
1.2
1.2.2
1.2.3
1.2.4
167
1.3
The variation in the discount factor reflects the investor attitude towards
risk. The higher the discount factor, the less attractive the project.
Therefore, higher rates will be used for riskier projects. The lower the
discount factor, the more attractive the project, but the returns will be
lower. Therefore lower rate will be used for less risky projects. An
investor becomes more and more negative with a project of higher
discount rate. This method shows only the degree of risk aversion.
Therefore, if IRR method is also used, an investor can clearly perceive the
risk of an investment project to accept or to reject.
2. Certainty Equivalent.
2.1
2.2
3. Sensitivity Analysis
3.1
Pessimistic
Likely
Optimistic
168
3.2
A given change in one of the variables will cause change in the NPV or
IRR of a project. Analysis of change is called as sensitivity analysis.
Only thing is we have to choose such variables which can influence NPV
or IRR.
3.3
By causing change in one of the variables like volume, price, cost etc., the
NPV or IRR of the project must be recalculated and an appropriate
decision taken. The sales volume and the unit sale price is a most
sensitive variable, because even the slightest change in them, will result in
greater change in the NPV or IRR
3.4
3.5
4. Probability assignment
4.1
The trouble is always that of forecasting future cash flows. Even if cash
flow is forecast, the second problem is that of reliability. The phrase used
is always most likely rather than exactly.
The question is how to
arrive at the "most likely" figure? This depends on the probability.
Measuring an individual's opinion about the likelihood of an event
occurring, is known as probability. Estimates of cash flows are made
under "best guess", "high guess" and "low guess" with the percentage of
probability. This probability will help us measure risk. Instead of taking
probability as Best, High or Low Guess, it is safer to take it on a large
number of points under independent, identical situations. The probability
based on this is known as objective probability.
4.2
When cash flow is estimated, one may assign risk for each level of cash
flow. In case of non-repetitive projects, apart from risk, it is associated
with the problem of high degree of uncertainty.
4.3
169
The dispersion of cash flows is the difference between the possible cash
flows that can occur and their expected value. Risk analysis can also be
made by finding out the dispersion of cash flows because such dispersion
indicates the degree of risk. Risk is measured through Standard Deviation
(SD). It measures the deviation about expected cash flow of each of the
possible cash flows. A project with higher SD is a riskier one. In case of
making a decision to choose a project by analyzing risk in absolute terms,
the risk may be measured in relative terms. Such relative measure of risk
is the coefficient of variation. Coefficient of variation is the standard
deviation of the probability distribution divided by its expected value.
5.2
5.3
6. Decision Trees
6.1
6.2
One will take a decision based upon the future expectations, say
accomplishment of events/s. The decision that we make today may
influence the various alternative decisions in the future and thereby
accomplishment of future events will also get affected. The decisions may
also lead to chance event. Even though such chance event is not known
still a probability distribution may be assigned to it. The displaying of
relationship between a present decision and future events, relationship
between a same present decision and the future decisions and their
consequences. It will be mapped out like the branches of tree. Such
graphic display is known as a decision tree.
170
6.3
6.4
7. Utility theory
7.1
Perhaps the utility theory may indicate the level of risk preference by the
investors. Putting risk and return together in different combinations, the
focus will be more on risk. The risk aversion in the form of threat is more.
As risk points rise, the marginal utility for money decreases. A graph
must be prepared from the point of Zero risk and lowest return. This will
demonstrate the point at which a rational investor will try to maximize his
utility.
The risk preferences of the decision maker are directly
incorporated in the capital budgeting analysis.
171
Cost of capital can be used to evaluate a capital expenditure decision. The cost of capital
will be used as discount factor to determine NPV or IRR of the capital invested projects.
The focus will be on the measurement techniques of cost of capital.
The cost of capital is related to the objective of wealth-maximization of an organization.
Decisions is meant to raise the wealth of the owners i.e., the share holders. For this
purpose returns must be higher than the cost of the capital. The cost of the capital serves
the purpose of acceptance or rejection of an investment proposal.
The cost of the capital has to be measured correctly. Otherwise, under-valuation of cost
of capital may result in wrong acceptance and expectations may receive a setback.
Similarly, overestimation of cost of capital may also result wrong decisions in the form of
rejection of investment proposal. The following will be taken as base for the cost of
capital:
The existing rate of interest will be used as discount factor for calculation of NPV
or IRR
Using an opportunity cost as cost of capital or the lending rate
Interest rate on borrowing
Among the above, the interest rate on borrowing is commonly used as cost of capital.
Capital Finance may be obtained from a number of sources. The cost of obtaining funds
from each source differs from each other. The total cost of these costs is called weighted
cost of capital. There are two categories of costs, viz. (i) Explicit cost, and (ii) Implicit
cost.
1. Explicit Cost
1.1
When a firm starts to raise funds for its capital requirement, a series of
cash inflow takes place. If we focus on a particular type of fund raising
and the consequent cash inflow arising from it, there will be consequent
cash out flow on account of repayment towards principal, payment of
interest, payment dividend etc. In this situation, the rate of return should
be identified at the point at which PV of cash inflow is equal to PV of cash
outflow. Such rate of return is the Explicit Cost. The company which
borrows funds has to pay IRR to the suppliers of the funds.
172
2. Implicit Cost
2.1
2.2
Debt financing
Preference share capital
Equity capital
Rights shares
Retained earnings
Convertible securities
In the following sections we will look at ways to measure the cost of the capital by taking
into account the cost of funding capital.
4. Debt Financing
4.1
In case of debt issued at par, the interest on debt i.e., before-tax shall be taken as
cost of debt. This will be taken as cost of capital. But the use of debt finance
shall not reduce the dividends to share holders. The operational efficiency must
go up along with the use of debt finance, so that the dividends to share holders
will go up. That means earnings must certainly exceed the interest. Therefore the
estimation of the project must be based upon the present values calculated on the
base interest on debt as cost of capital.
4.2
The other important point is while floating debt, a firm has to incur cost towards
floating charges. Therefore the cost of the capital is taken as interest on debt plus
floating charges.
4.3
Since interest on debt is deductible from payment of corporate tax, after-tax cost
of debt should be used.
173
4.4
In the case of debt issued at a premium, there will be a difference between the
face value and the book value of such securities. In such cases the cost of debt
will not be equal to the coupon rate of interest. If the premium is amortized for
tax, it should be considered for determining the cost.
4.5
In case of perpetual debt financing, old bonds due for payment will be replaced by
new bonds of the same value. In such a case the cost of capital will be determined
by dividing the price at which the bond is sold multiplied by the fixed interest
charges adjusted after tax-effect.
4.6
The current market yield of the debt will be used as cost of the capital, when debt
is not used.
4.7
Only in case of profits earned, can dividends be paid to the shareholders. If the
dividends are not paid up to the reasonable expectation level of the shareholders,
the credibility of a firm may come down and shareholders may exercise their
voting rights to change the management.
4.8
The dividends are payable in priority to preference shareholders and only the left
out dividends are payable to ordinary share holders.
4.9
If the dividends are not paid, the market price of the shares will come down.
Therefore, the firms always try to maintain the minimum credibility level of
dividend payment.
4.10
Irredeemable
Redeemable
4.11
4.12
4.13
The equity holders invest with an expectation of returns in the form of dividends.
The market value of shares of a company depends on the expectations of the
dividends by equity holders.
4.14
The rate of return that equates the PV of the expected dividends with the market
value of shares can be taken as cost of equity capital.
174
4.15
The EPS (Earning per Share) and the MVS (Market value of Shares) shall
not be affected because of new issue of shares. The interests of the
existing share holders shall be protected and the assets or liabilities are to
be shared on pro-rata basis by the existing and the new share holders in
case of winding up. Therefore the new shares shall not result in earning
the EPS and the MVS. In such cases, the return on new investment shall
be taken as cost of new shares, so that, the EPS or MVS will not be below
the return on new investment. The new issue of shares will often called as
external equity. The cost of this external equity can be calculated on the
basis of dividend. In such cases, the cost of equity is the dividend yield
plus the growth rate of shares. Such cost of equity must also be included
with the floatation expenses incurred towards new shares.
4.16
The earnings method will also be used to measure the cost of external equity. In
this method, the cost of equity will be computer on EPR (Earning Price Ratio)
basis.
4.17
A company may allow the existing share holders to purchase new shares at a
given price. This is known as Rights issues of shares. It will be in the same
ratio as determined in the board policy of a company. It will not be compulsory
on the part of the existing shareholders to purchase the Right Shares. The existing
shareholder will have option of selling his right share also. In case of rights
shares, the cost of capital would be equal to cost of a direct issue of shares to the
public at large.
4.18
5.2
The use of debt finance may increase risk on the part of the shareholders and in
turn this may be increase the cost of equity. On the other hand, higher the use of
equity, may lead to increasing the debt borrowing capacity. Because of this effect
of one on the other, we have to use the cost of the capital in a composite sense.
This composite mix of capital is also known as WACC. We know that capital is
raised from different sources. The cost of each source varies from each other.
Therefore, weights are attached to each source depending on its cost. Putting all
175
this together amounts to composite cost. Again the source of funds may not be
used in equal proportions to form capital structure. In such a situation application
of WACC, rather than computing simple average cost, will be more reliable.
5.3
To calculate WACC the cost of each source of funds must, firstly, be identified.
Secondly, the proportion of each source in the capital structure must be worked
out with the cost of each source. Thirdly, the weighted costs of all sources of
funds must be added. This sum is the weighted cost of capital. This shall be
obtained on the after-tax basis. While calculating WACC book-value weights or
market value weights, whichever is higher may be used.
5.4
In case of using new source of funds in a concern for the selection of a new
project, the cost of raising new funds has to be taken as the basis of calculation.
This is also known as the MCC (Marginal Cost of capital). The MCC is the cost
of raising an additional rupee of capital. The proportion of funds in capital
structure represents the marginal weights.
5.5
The proportion of funds from different sources in the capital structure is taken as
base to calculate the MCC.
5.6
The cost may increase as the level of borrowed funds increases. Up to a certain
level the cost on various sources of funds may remain constant and it may
increase after the particular level. This will give rise to average cost of capital
and the MCC will also rise.
5.7
6.2
The CAPM approach is based on the assumption of efficient security markets and
investor preferences.
Efficiency market means that the investors will have
common information about securities, including, Zero Taxes, Zero Restrictions on
Investments or No Transaction Costs. No single person can influence the market
price and all the investors will have common expectations. Preference will always
be in favour of a security that gives highest return, if risk levels are equal among
the given securities. If returns are equal, the investors will choose a low risk
security. The main assumption of CAPM is that investors are risk averse. Based
on this assumption, CAPM describes the risk required return as a trade off for
securities.
176
6.3
Risks are of two types, viz., (i) Diversifiable, and (ii) Non-diversifiable.
6.4
6.5
Factors that commonly influence risk of all firms are known as non-diversifiable
risks or systematic risks. For example, inflation, economic policy, change in
Government, changes in law, interest rate etc.
6.6
6.7
6.8
A zero co-efficient indicate zero market related risk for the investment. A beta
co-efficient equal to one indicates that the risk of a security is equal to the market
risk. If the beta co-efficient is less than one, risk of a security and a market risk
varies inversely. The required rate of market return for a given amount of
systematic risk is known as the SML (security market line).
6.9
The CAPM explains the relationship between the cost of equity and the relevant
risk of the firm as reflected in its index of non-diversifiable risk. The risk as
shown in beta to determine the cost of equity will be considered by the CAPM.
Investors are always risk averse and try to eliminate risk. The risk is known as
residual risk or alpha. This, they will do by holding a diversified portfolio of
assets. Alpha risks are specifically associated with individual assets. The
diversification of assets will reduce the risk. Certain risks like, say, recession is a
non-diversifiable risk and it is not possible to eliminate it. The investor's
expectation of returns will also be above the average of return on safer
investments. The valuation of any particular asset depends on the effect of the
177
market risk on a asset price. Beta is the change of an asset price to change in
overall market price, and a measure of relative volatility of the market risk
contribution.
7.2
Risk free assets have beta close to Zero. The investors' normal expectancy will be
over and above the return on risk free securities, in case they invest in shares,
which are risky. This is known as premium over the risk-free rate. Such expected
premium on all the assets shall be added to determine the average premium and
this is to be multiplied by the particular assets beta.
Preference Shares
Convertible Debentures
Non-convertible debentures
Indira Vikas Patras
Government Securities
Money market instruments
1. Preference Shares
1.1
2. Convertible Debentures
2.1
2.2
Conversion Ratio
178
2.2.1
2.3
Conversion Price :
2.3.1
2.4
Conversion Price is the per share price paid for equity shares, that
is by dividing the par value bond with the conversion ratio.
Conversion Timing
2.4.1
2.5
Conversion Value :
2.5.1
The conversion premium and conversion timing shall be mentioned in the prospectus.
Conversion will be optional, if it takes place between 18 to 36 months.
There must be compulsory credit rating, if the conversion period exceeds 18 months.
4. Non-Convertible Debentures:
4.1
Non convertible debentures are an instrument for raising long-term debt capital.
It is like a promissory note. The features are as follows:
179
5.1
There are two varieties of public sector undertaking (PSU) bonds, namely taxable
bonds and tax free bonds. A PSU may issue tax-free bonds with the prior
approval of the Ministry of Finance.
5.2
The features of PSU bonds are (a) no deduction of tax at source on the interest (b)
easily transferable by endorsement (c) no stamp duty on transfer (d) tradable on
stock exchanges.
The features of KVPS are as follows:The maturity period is of five and a half years. Twice the amount is paid
on maturity. Premature encashment facility is available after two and a
half years.
8. Government Securities
8.1
8.2
The maturity period ranges from 3-20 years and interest rates vary from each
other.
Money market instrument is a debt instrument with a short maturity period. For
example, treasury bills, commercial paper, and certificates of deposit:
Treasury Bills: A Treasury bill issued by the Government has a maturity period
of six months or one year issued at a discount and is repayable at par.
180
11.2
Evaluation of cash flows at different points of time through the time value of
money is, therefore, required. The details of calculating the present value of
money has been dealt with in detail in Learning Unit 2.
It carries a specific interest rate, which is also called coupon rate. It will have a
specific maturity period. The total return on bond will be calculated by using
following formula:
Total Return =
14.2
Bonds are often risk free. Bond prices vary with interest rate. Bonds may be
subjected to default risk and inflation risk. Reinvestment rate may be lower than
expected. A bond with a call feature entitles the issuer to prematurely redeem a
181
bond. This exposes the bond investor to call risk. Liquidity may be low.
14.3
Value of =
A bond
Annual
interest
Payable
present
value
annuity
factor
Redemption
+ value
Discount
factor
The rate of return that an investor receives is called yield to maturity. The rate of
return depends on the risk associated with it.
The ratings provided by
independent credit rating agencies are useful to assess the risk.
15.2
A debt rating shows the probability of timely payment of interest and principal by
a borrower. The higher the debt rating, the greater the credibility of the borrower.
It does not recommend any transactions. Its focus will be on credit risk of the
security. A debt rating has nothing to do with the performance of a firm. There
is no legal relationship between debt rating agency and an investor. A debt rating
is not an audit function. It is not enough to make a one time evaluation of risk to
take one time decision; credit rating must be undertaken periodically.
Growth rate
Industry risk characteristics
Structure of industry
Nature of competition
Competitiveness
Management quality
Earning strength
Business risks
Financial risks
Asset protection
Cash flow
Financial flexibility and
182
(m)
16.2
Accounting information
Highest Investment
Grades
Investment
Grades
Speculative
Grades
Note: CRSIL may apply + (Plus) or - (minus) signs for rating from AA to D to reflect
comparative standing within the category
Fixed Deposit Rating Symbols
FAAA
FAA
FA
FB
FC
FD
Highest Safety
High Safety
Adequate Safety
Inadequate Safety
High Risk
Default
Note: CRSIL may apply + (Plus) or - (minus) signs for rating from FAA to FC to
indicate the relative position within the rating category of the company raising fixed
deposits
Short Term Instruments Rating Symbols
P-1
Very strong Degree of safety
P-2
Strong Degree of Safety
P-3
Adequate Degree of Safety
P-4
Minimal Degree of Safety
P-5
Default Expected (or Actual)
Note: CRSIL may apply + (Plus) or - (minus) signs for rating from P-1 to P-3 to
reflect comparatively higher standing within the category.
183
Fully convertible bonds and partially convertible bonds are subjected to the following
SEBI guidelines.
The price with time shall be stated in the prospectus itself. Conversion will be optional at
the hands of the bond holder, if it takes place between 18 to 36 months. Conversion is
must with put and call options, if the conversion period is more than 36 months. If the
conversion period exceeds 18 months credit rating is compulsory.
16.3
16.4
16.5
16.6
In case of Straight Bond value the value is that of discounted value of the interest
and principal repayments receivable on it. The value of a straight bond varies
directly with the value of the firm. The maximum value of a straight bond would
be limited to the value of an equivalent risk-free bond.
16.7
The conversion value is equal to the stock price multiplied by the conversion rate.
16.8
In the case of Option value, the holder of a convertible bond cannot be compelled
to sell. He can wait and choose the most profitable alternative.
The features of Public Provident Fund (PPF) scheme from the taxation point of
view are as follows:
17.2
Benefits under sections of the Income Tax Act is limited to Rs.60, 000 i.e., a tax
rebate of 15 percent of the annual subscription. The interest on PPF is exempted
from taxes. Withdrawals are not subject to I.T.
184
Deep discount bonds having a face value will be issued at a deep discounted price
with a longer maturity period from the date of allotment. The investor as well as
the bond floating authority has the option to withdraw or redeem the bond
respectively at the end of the prescribed period.
18.2
The two important features of a Deep Discount Bond are that (i) there is no
reinvestment risk and (ii) the notional intermediate returns are not taxed.
The price of a bond and the required rate of return vary inversely.
19.2
19.3
Short term risk free interest rate is the yield on a one-year Government security.
19.4
The expected real rate of return is the rate at which society is willing to trade
current consumption for future consumption.
19.5
Price level
Money supply in
Velocity of money
The economy
in circulation
---------------------------------------------------Real out put in the economy
Hence, the expected rate of inflation is nothing but the expected change in price
level that is :
Change in the
Velocity of money in
Circulation
Expected rate of inflation = --------------------------------------------------------------Change in the real out put of the economy
185
Investors have a preference for liquidity. So they ask for a higher yield as an
inducement to hold bonds of longer maturity.
Because of the possibility that corporate bonds may default on interest and/or
principal payment, investors will ask for a default premium, in addition, of course,
to the maturity premium. The default premium is a direct function of default risk.
The credit rating agencies considers:
a)
b)
c)
22.2
Default premium tend to increase during economic recession and decrease during
economic expansion.
23.
A 'call' feature raises the interest rate because the investors are exposed to
call risk.
A 'put' feature lowers the interest rate because the investors enjoy the put
option.
A 'conversion' feature lowers the interest rate because the investors enjoy
the option to convert.
A 'floating interest rate' feature may lower the interest rate as investors are
protected against inflation risk.
A 'zero coupons' feature may lower the interest rate as investors are
protected against reinvestment risk.
Default Premium
Interest rate
Special Features
Call/put feature
Conversion feature
186
Other features
Business Risk
Financial Risk
Collateral
1.
Investors have many choices when investing in bonds, but bonds are classified in
to four main types, each of which differs with respect to the expected return and
degree of risk:
Treasury
Corporate
Municipal
Foreign
1.1
1.2.
1.3
1.4
2. Par Value
2.1
The par value is the stated face value of the bond. The par value generally
represents the amount of money the firm borrows and promises to repay on the
maturity date.
The coupon payment if divided by the par value, results in the coupon interest
rate.
187
Most corporate bonds contain a call provision, which gives the issuing
corporation the right to call the bonds for redemption. The call provision
generally states that the company must pay the bondholders an amount greater
than the par value if they are called. The additional sum, which is termed a call
premium, is typically set equal to one years interest if the bonds are called during
the first year.
4.2
However, bonds are often not callable until several years (generally five to ten)
after they are issued. This is known as deferred call, and the bonds are said to
have call protection.
4.3
Suppose a Company sold bonds when interest rates were relatively high.
Provided the issue is callable, the company could sell a new issue of low-yielding
securities if and when interest rates drop. It could then use the proceeds of the
new issue to retire the high-rate issue and thus reduce its interest expense. This
process is called a refunding operation.
4.4
4.5
Bonds that are redeemable at par at the holders option protect the holder against
a rise in interest rates. If rates rise, the price of fixed-rate bonds declines.
However, if holders have the option of turning their bonds in and having them
redeemed at par, they are protected against rising rates.
5. Sinking Funds
5.1
Some bonds include a sinking fund provision designed to facilitate the orderly
retirement of the issue. Typically, the sinking fund requires the firm to retire a
portion of the bonds each year. On rare occasions the firm may be required to
deposit money with a trustee, who invests the funds and then uses the
accumulated sum to retire the bonds when they mature. Usually, though, the
sinking fund is used to buy back a certain percentage of the issue each year. A
failure to meet the sinking fund requirement causes the bond issue to be thrown in
to default, which may force the company into bankruptcy; obviously, a sinking
fund can constitute a significant cash drain on the firm.
188
First Convertible bonds are bonds that are convertible into shares of common
stock, at a fixed price, at the option of the bondholder, Convertibles have a lower
coupon rate than non-convertible debt, but they offer investors a chance for
capital gains in exchange for the lower coupon rate. Bonds issued with warrants
are similar to convertibles. Warrants are options which permit the holder to buy
stock for a stated price, thereby providing a capital gains if the price of the stock
rises. Bonds that are issued with warrants, like convertibles, carry lower coupon
rates than straight bonds.
6.2
Another type of bond is an income bond, which pays interest only if the interest
is earned. These securities cannot bankrupt a company, but from an investors
standpoint they are riskier than regular bonds. Yet another bond is the indexed,
or purchasing power, bond. The interest rate paid on these bonds is based on
the consumer price index, so the interest paid rises automatically when the
inflation rate rises, thus protecting the bondholders against inflation.
7. Bond Valuation
7.1
The value of any financial asset is simply the present value of the cash flows the
asset is expected to produce.
7.2
The cash flows from a specific bond depend on its contractual features.
7.3
The bonds riskiness, liquidity and years to maturity, as well as supply and
demand conditions in the capital markets - all influence the interest rate on bonds.
7.4
At the time a coupon bond is issued, the coupon is generally set at a level that will
cause the market price of the bond to equal its par value.
7.5
A bond that has just been issued is known as a new issue. Once the bond has been
on the market for a while, it is classified as an outstanding bond, also called a
seasoned issue. Newly issued bonds generally sell very close to par, but the
prices of seasoned bonds often vary widely from par.
8. Key Points
Whenever the going rate of interest, is equal to the coupon rate, a fixed-rate bond will sell
at its par value. Normally, the coupon rate is set equal to the going rate when a bond is
issued, causing it to sell at par initially.
1. Interest rates do change over time, but the coupon rate remains fixed after the
bond has been issued.
Whenever the going rate of interest rises above the
coupon rate, a fixed-rate bonds price will fall below its par value. Such a bond is
called a discount bond
189
2. Whenever the going rate of interest falls below the coupon rate, a fixed-rate
bonds price will rise above its par value. Such a bond is called a premium
bond.
3. Thus, an increase in interest rates will cause the prices of outstanding bond to fall
whereas a decrease in rates will cause bond prices to rise.
4. The market value of a bond will always approach its par value as its maturity date
approaches, provided the firm does not go bankrupt.
These points are very important, for they show that bondholders may suffer capital losses
or make capital gains, depending on whether interest rates rise or fall after the bond was
purchased.
9. Bond Yields
9.1
If you examine a price sheet put out by a bond dealer, you will typically see
information regarding each bonds maturity date, price, and coupon interest rate.
You will also see the bonds reported yield. Unlike the coupon interest rate,
which is fixed, the bonds yield varies form day to day depending on current
market conditions. Moreover, the yield can be calculated in three different ways,
and three answers can be obtained. These different yields are described in the
following sections.
The interest rate generally discussed by investors when they talk about rates of
return. The yield to maturity is generally the same as the market rate of interest.
10.2
The yield to maturity can also be viewed as the bonds promised rate of return,
which is the return that investors will receive if all the promised payments are
made. However, the yield to maturity equals the expected rate of return only if
(1) the probability or default is zero and (2) the bond cannot be called. If there is
some default risk, or if the bond may be called, then the4re is some probability
that the promised payments to maturity will be called, then there is some
probability that the promised payments to maturity will not be received in which
case the calculated yield to maturity will differ from the expected return.
10.3
The YTM for a bond that sells at par consists entirely of an interest yield, but if
the bond sells at a price other than its par value, the YTM will consist of the
interest yield plus a positive or negative capital gains yield. Note also that a
bonds yield to maturity changes whenever interest rates in the economy change,
and this is almost daily. One who purchases a bond and holds it until it matures
will receive the YTM that existed on the purchase date, but the bonds calculated
YTM will change frequently between the purchase date and the maturity date.
190
If you purchased a bond that was callable and the company called it, you would
not have the option of holding it until it matured. Therefore, the yield to maturity
would not be earned.
11.2
If current interest rates are well below an outstanding bonds coupon rate, then a
callable bond is likely to be called, and investors will estimate its most likely rate
of return as the yield to call (YTC) rather than as the yield to maturity.
If you examine brokerage house reports on bonds, you will often see reference to
a bonds current yield,. The current yield is the annual interest payment divided
by the bonds current price.
12.2
Unlike the yield to maturity, the current yield does not generally repr4esent the
return that investors should expect form holding the bond. The current yield
provides information about the cash income a bond will generate in a given year,
but since it does not take account of capital gains or losses that will be realized if
the bond is held until maturity (or call), it does not provide an accurate measure of
the total expected return.
12.3
The fact that the current yield does not provide an accurate measure of the total
return can be illustrated with a zero coupon bond. Since zeros pay no annual
income, they always have a current yield of zero. This indicates that the bond
will not provide any cash interest income, but since it will appreciate in value over
time, its total return clearly exceeds zero.
12.4
Although some bonds pay interest annually, the vast majority actually pay interest
semiannually.
Interest rates go up and down over time, and an increase in interest rates leads to a
decline in the value of an outstanding bond. This risk of a decline in bond values
due to rising interest rates is called interest rate risk. Interest rates can and do
rise, and rising rates cause a loss of value for bound holders. Thus, people or
firms who invest in bonds are exposed to risk from changing interest rates.
13.2
Ones exposure to interest rate risk is higher on bonds with long maturities than
on those maturing in the near future.
13.3
The longer the maturity of the bond, the more its price changes in response to a
given change in interest rates. Even if the risk of default on two bonds is exactly
191
the same, the one with the longer maturity is typically exposed to more risk from
a rise in interest rates.
13.4
The prices of long-term bonds are more sensitive to changes in interest rates than
are short-term bonds. To induce an investor to take this extra risk, long term
bonds must have a higher expected rate of return than short-term bonds. This
additional return is the maturity risk premium (MRP).
Therefore, one might
expect to see higher yields on long-term than on short-term bonds.
13.5
The longer maturity bonds must have a higher expected rate of return to
compensate for their higher risk.
As we saw in the preceding section, an increase in interest rates will hurt bond
holders because it will lead to a decline in the value of a bond portfolio. But can a
decrease in interest rates also hurt bondholders? The answer is yes, because if
interest rates fall, a bondholder will probably suffer a reduction in his or her
income. For example, consider a retiree who has a portfolio of bonds and lives
off the income they produce. He has to replace with lower-yielding bonds and
suffer reduction in income.
14.2
14.3
Suppose two bonds have the same promised stream of cash flows, coupon rate,
maturity, liquidity, and inflation exposure, but different levels of default risk.
Investors will naturally pay less for the bond with the grater chance of default. As
a result, bond with higher default risk will have higher interest rates. If its default
risks changes, this will affect the price of a bond.
192
14.4
Default risk affected by both the financial strength of the issuer and the terms of
the bond contract, especially whether collateral has been pledged to secure the
bond.
14.5
An indenture is a legal document that spells out the rights of both bondholders
and the issuing corporation, and a trustee is an official (usually a bank) who
represents the bondholders and makes sure the terms of the indenture are carried
out. The indenture may be several hundred pages in length, and it will include
restrictive covenants that cover such points as the conditions under which the
issuer can pay off the bonds prior to maturity, the level at which the issuers
times-interest-earned ratio must be maintained if the company is to issue
additional debt, and restrictions against the payment of dividends unless earnings
meet certain specifications.
14.6
The trustee is responsible for monitoring the covenants and for taking appropriate
action if a violation does occur. What constitutes appropriate action varies with
the circumstances. It might be that to insist on immediate compliance would
result in bankruptcy and possibly large losses on the bonds. In such a case, the
trustee might decide that the bondholders would be better served by giving the
company a chance to work out its problems and thus avoid forcing it into
bankruptcy.
14.7
Under a mortgage bond, the corporation pledges certain assets as security for the
bond.
14.8
The second mortgage bonds can also be secured. In the event of liquidation, the
holders of these second mortgage bonds would have a claim against the property,
but only after the first mortgage bondholders had been paid off in full. Thus,
second mortgages are sometimes called junior mortgages, because they are junior
in priority to the claims of senior mortgages or first mortgage bonds.
14.9
These indentures are generally open ended meaning that new bonds can be issued
from time to time under the existing indenture. However, the amount of new
bonds that can be issued is virtually always limited to a specified percentage of
the firms total bondable property, which generally includes all land, plan, and
equipment.
193
subordinated either to designated notes payable (usually bank loans) or to all other
debt. In the event of liquidation or reorganization, holders of subordinated
debentures cannot be paid until all senior debt, as named in the debentures
indenture, has been paid.
14.12 Some companies may be in a position to benefit from the sale of either
development bonds or pollution control bonds. State and local governments
may se t up both industrial development agencies and pollution control agencies.
These agencies are allowed, under certain circumstances, to sell tax-exempt
bonds, then to make the proceeds available to corporations for specific uses
deemed to be in the public interest.
14.13 Municipal Bond Insurance, Municipalities can have their bonds insured, in
which an insurance company guarantees to pay the coupon and principal
payments should the issuer default. This reduces risk to investors, who will thus
accept a lower coupon rate for an insured bond vis--vis an uninsured one. Even
though the municipality must pay a fee to get its bonds insured, its savings due to
the lower coupon rate often makes insurance cost-effective.
194
10. Overseas operations: What percentage of the firms sales, assets, and profits are
from overseas operations, and what is the political climate in the host countries?
11. Environmental factors: Is the firm likely to face heavy expenditures for pollution
control equipment?
12. Product liability: Are the firms products safe? The tobacco companies today are
under pressure, and so are their bond ratings.
13. Pension liabilities: Does the firm have unfunded pension liabilities that could pose a
future problem?
14. Labor unrest: Are there potential labor problems on the horizon that could weaken
the firms position? As this is written, a number of airlines face this problem, and it
has caused their ratings to be lowered.
15. Accounting policies: If a firm uses relatively conservative accounting policies, its
reported earnings will be of higher quality than if it uses less conservative
procedures. Thus, conservative accounting policies are plus factors in bond ratings.
Importance of Bond Ratings: Bond ratings are important both to firms and to investors.
First, because a bonds rating is an indicator of its default risk, the rating has a direct,
measurable influence on the bonds interest rate and the firms cost of debt. Second,
most bonds are purchased by institutional investors rather than individuals, and many
institutions are restricted to investment-grade securities.
Corporate bonds are traded primarily in the over- the-counter market. Most bonds
are owned by and traded among the large financial institutions (for example, life
insurance companies, mutual funds, and pension funds, all of which deal in very
large blocks of securities), and it is relatively easy for the over-the-counter bond
dealers to arrange the transfer of large blocks of bonds among the relatively few
holders to arrange the transfer of large blocks of bonds among the relatively few
holders of the bonds. It would be much more difficult to conduct similar
operations in the stock market among the literally millions of large and small
stockholders, so a higher percentage of stocks trade on the exchanges.
The common stockholders are owners of a corporation, and as such they have
certain rights and privileges.
17.2
It is common that stockholders have the right to elect a firms directors, who, in
turn, elect the officers who manage the business. In a small firm, the major
stockholder typically assumes the positions of president and chairperson of the
board of directors. In a large publicly owned firm, the managers typically have
some stock, but their personal holdings are generally insufficient to give them
voting control. Thus, the management of most publicly owned firms can be
removed by the stockholders if they decide the management team is not effective.
195
17.3
State and federal laws stipulate how stockholder control is to be exercised. First
corporations must hold an election of directors periodically.
17.4
Stockholders can appear at the annual meeting and vote in person, but typically
they transfer their right to vote to a second party by means of a proxy.
Management always solicits stockholders proxies and usually gets them.
However, if earnings are poor and stockholders are dissatisfied, an outside group
may solicit the proxies in an effort to overthrow management and take control of
the business. This is known as a proxy fight.
17.5
The question of control has become a central issue in recent years. The frequency
of proxy fights has increased, as have attempts by one corporation to take over
another by purchasing a majority of the outstanding stock. This latter action is
called a takeover
17.6
Managers who do not have majority control (more than 50 percent of their firms
stock) are very much concerned about proxy fights and takeovers, and many of
tem attempt to get stockholder approval for changes in their corporate charters
that would make takeovers more difficult.
17.7
Common stockholders often have the right, called the preemptive right, to
purchase any new shares sold by the firm. In some states, the preemptive right is
automatically included in every corporate charter.
17.8
Although most firms have only one type of common stock, in some instances
classified stock is used to meet the special needs of the company, Generally,
when special classifications of stock are used, one type is designated Class A,
another Class B, and so on. Small, new companies seeking funds from outside
sources frequently use different types of common stock. For example, when
Genetic Concepts went public recently, its Class A stock was sold to the public,
and it received a dividend, but this stock had no voting rights for five years. Its
Class B stock, which was retained by the organizers of the company, had full
voting rights for five years, but the legal terms stated that dividends could not be
paid on the Class B stock until the company had established its earning power by
building up retained earnings to a designated level. The use of classified stock
thus enabled the public to take a position in a conservatively financed growth
company without sacrificing income, while the founders retained absolute control
during the crucial early stages of the firms development. At the same time,
196
Some companies are so small that their common stocks are not activity traded;
they are owned by only a few people, usually the companies managers. Such
firms are said to be privately owned, or closely held, corporations, and their
stock is called closely held stock. In contrast, the stocks of most larger
companies are owned by a large number of investors, most of whom are not
active in management. Such companies are called publicly owned corporations,
and their stock is called publicly held stock.
19.2
As we saw in Chapter 4, the stocks of smaller publicly owned firms are not listed
on an exchange; they trade in the over-the-counter (OTC) market, and the
companies and their stocks are said to be unlisted. However, larger publicly
owned companies generally apply for listing on an organized security exchange,
and they and their stocks are said to be listed.
19.3
21.2
It entitles its owner to dividends, but only if the company has earnings out of
which dividends can be paid, and only if management chooses to pay dividends
rather than retaining and reinvesting all the earnings. Whereas a bond contains a
promise to pay interest, common stock provides no such promise if you own a
stock, you may expect a dividend, but your expectations may not in fact be met.
197
21.3
Stock can be sold at some future date, hopefully at a price greater than the
purchase price. If the stock is actually sold at a price above it s purchase price,
the investor will receive a capital gain. Generally, at the time people buy
common stocks, they do expect to receive capital gains; otherwise, they would not
buy the stocks. However, after the fact, one can end up with capital losses rather
than capital gains.
21.4
Common stocks provide an expected future cash flow stream, and a stocks value
is found in the same manner as the values of other financial assets namely, as
the present value of the expected future cash flow stream. The expected cash
flows consist of two elements: (1) the dividends expected in each year and (2) the
price investors expect to receive when they sell the stock. The expected final
stock price includes the return of the original investment plus an expected capital
gain.
21.5
The managers seek to maximize the values of their firms stocks. A mangers
actins affect a both the stream of income to investors and the riskiness of that
stream.
21.6
The value of a bond is the present value of interest payments over the life of the
bond plus the present value of the bonds maturity (or par) value;
21.7
For any individual investor, the expected cash flows consist of expected dividends
plus the expected sale price of the stock. However, the sale price the current
investor receives will depend on the dividends some future investor expects.
Therefore, for all present and future investors in total, expected cash flows must
be based on expected future dividends. Put another way, unless a firm is
liquidated or sold to another concern, the cash flows it provides to its stockholders
will consist only of a stream of dividends. Therefore, the value of a share of its
stock must be established as the present value of that expected dividend stream.
21.8
A security that is expected to pay a constant amount each year forever is called
perpetuity. Therefore, a zero growth stock is perpetuity.
21.9
21.10 The earnings and dividends of most companies are expected to increase over time.
Expected growth rates vary from company to company, but dividend growth on
average is expected to continue in the foreseeable future at about the same rate as
that of the nominal gross domestic product (real GDP plus inflation). On this
basis, one might expect the dividend of an average, or normal, company to
grow at a rate of 6 to 8 percent a year.
198
21.11 Growth in dividends occurs primarily as a result of growth in earnings per share
(EPS). Earnings growth, in turn, results from a number of factors, including (1)
inflation, (2) the amount of earnings the company retains and reinvests, and (3)
the rate of return the coming years on its equity (ROE). Regarding inflation, if
output (in units) is stable, but both sales prices and input costs rise at the inflation
rate, then EPS will also grow at the inflation rate. Even without inflation, EPS
will also grow as a result of the reinvestment, or plowback, of earnings. If the
firms earnings are not all paid as dividends (that is, if some fraction of earnings
is retained), the dollars of investment behind each share will rise over time, ad
that should lead to growth in earnings and dividends.
21.12 Even though a stocks value is derived from expected dividends, this does not
necessarily mean that corporations can increase their stock prices by simply
raising the current dividend. Share holders care about all dividends, both current
and those expected in the future. Moreover, there is a trade-off between current
dividends and future dividends. Companies that pay high current dividends have
less money to retain and reinvest in the business, and that lowers the rate of
growth in earnings and dividends. So, the issue is this: Shareholders prefer to
have the company retain earnings, hence pay less current dividends, if it has
highly profitable investment opportunities, but they want the company to pay
earnings out if its investment opportunities are poor. Taxes also play a role, as
dividends and capital gains are taxed differently, so dividend policy affects
investors taxes.
21.13 Thus, we would expect to make a capital gain of $24.84 -$23.00 = $1.84 during
1999, which would provide a capital gains yield of 8 percent:
Capital gain
$1.84
----------------- = ---------- = 0.08 = 8%
Beginning price
$23.00
21.14 We could extend the analysis on out, and in each future year the expected capital
gains yield would always equal g, the expected dividend growth rate.
Continuing, the dividend yield in 2000 could be estimated as follows:
Dividend yield2000
D2000
-----------P12/3/99
$1.3414
= ----------$24.84
199
0.054 = 5.4%
Since the total company and dividend growth models give the same answer, does
it matter which model you choose? In general, it does. For example, if you were
a financial analyst estimating the values of mature companies whose dividends
are expected to grow steadily in the future, it would probably be more efficient to
use the dividend to grow steadily in the future, it would probably be more
efficient to use the dividend growth model. Here you would only need to estimate
the growth rate in dividends, not the entire set of pro forma financial statements.
Chapter 10 explains some techniques for estimating growth rates.
22.2
22.3
Even if a company is paying steady dividends, much can be learned from the
corporate value model, so many analysts today use it for all types of valuations.
The process of projecting the future financial statements can reveal quite a bit
about the companys operations and financing needs. Also, such an analysis can
provide insights in to actions that might be taken to increase the companys value.
This is called value-based management.
200
22.4
Even small changes in the size or riskiness of expected future dividends can cause
large changes in stock prices. What might cause investors to change their
expectations about future dividends? It could be new information about the
specific company, such as preliminary results for an R&D programme, initial
sales of a new product, or the discovery of harmful side effects from the use of an
existing product, or, new information that will affect many companies could
arrive. Given the existence of computers and telecommunications networks, new
information hits the market on an almost continuous basis, and it causes frequent
and sometimes large changes in stock prices. In other words, ready availability of
information causes stock prices to be volatile!
22.5
If a stocks price is stable, that probably means that little new information is
arriving. But if you think its risky to invest in a volatile stock, imagine how risky
it would be to invest in a stock which rarely released new information about its
sales or operations. It may be bad to see your stocks price jump around, but it
would be a lot worse to see a stable quoted price most of the time but then to see
huge moves on the rare days when new information was released. Fortunately, in
our economy timely information is readily available. Evidence suggests that
stocks, especially those of large companies, adjust rapidly to new information.
Consequently, equilibrium ordinarily exists for any given stock, and required and
expected returns are generally equal. Stock prices certainly change, sometimes
violently and rapidly, but this simply reflects changing conditions and
expectations. There are, of course, times when a stock appears to react for several
months to favorable or unfavorable developments, but this does not signify a long
adjustment period; rather, it simply indicates that as more new pieces of
information about the situation become available, the market adjusts to them. The
ability of the market to adjust to new information is discussed in the next section.
A body of theory called the Efficient Markets Hypothesis (EMH holds (1) that
stocks are always in equilibrium and (2) that it is impossible for an investor to
consistently eat the market.
23.1
The price of a stock will adjust almost immediately to any new development.
23.2
If markets are efficient, stock prices will rapidly reflect all available information.
This raises an important question: What types of information are available and,
therefore, incorporated into stock prices? Financial theorists have discussed three
forms, or levels, of market efficiency.
23.3
Weak-Form Efficiency. The weak form of the EMH states that al information
contained in past price movements is fully reflected in current market prices. If
this were true, then information about recent trends in stock prices would be of no
use in selecting stocks-the fact that a stock has risen for the past three days, for
example, would given us no useful clues as to what it will do today or tomorrow.
201
People who believe that weak-form efficiency exists also believe that ape
watchers ad chartists are wasting their time.
For example, after studying the past history of the stock market, a chartist might
discover the following pattern: If a stock falls three consecutive days, its price
typically rise 10 percent the following day. The technician would then conclude
that investors could make money by purchasing a stock whose price has fallen
three consecutive days.
23.4
23.5
24.
Strong-From Efficiency: The strong form of the EMH states that current
market prices reflect all pertinent information, whether publicly available or
privately held. If this form holds, even insiders would find ti impossible to earn
abnormal returns in the stock market.
What bearing does the EMH have no financial decisions? Since stock prices do
seem to reflect public information, most stocks appear to be fairly valued. This
does not mean that new developments could not cause a stocks price to soar or to
plummet, but it does mean that stocks in general are neither overvalued nor
undervalued-they are fairly priced and in equilibrium.
However, there are
certainly cases in which corporate insiders have information not known to
outsiders.
25.2
202
inside information can do better than the averages and individuals and
organizations that are especially good at digging out information on small, new
companies also seem to do consistently well. Also, some investors may be able to
analyze and react more quickly than others to releases of new information, and
these investors may have an advantage over others. However, the buy-sell actions
of those investors quickly bring market prices in to equilibrium.
203
204
debentures, warrants, bonds, units of mutual funds, rights under collective investment
schemes and venture capital funds, Commercial paper Certificate of deposit, securised
debt, Money Market instruments and unlisted securities are eligible to be admitted to the
depository for dematerialization. A depository holds the Securities in electronic form. It
can be called a Bank for Securities. It dematerializes the Securities, i.e., it converts the
physical securities into book entry securities. In the process, physical Certificates are
eliminated altogether.
When an Investor deposits his physical securities with a
depository, his account with the depository is credited for the deposit. The transfer is
affected electronically whenever he buys and sells his shares and his account will be
credited or debited accordingly. Shares in depository mode will be fungible; it means
shares will have no distinctive number in case of shares physically held. The Institution
which acts as a depository becomes the registered owner of the shares and the member
owning the shares in a Company will be treated as beneficial owner. The beneficial
owner continues to enjoy all the benefits like dividend, right shares, bonus shares, as well
as voting rights. A depository interfaces with the investors with the help of a Depository
Participant. A Depository Participant could be a public Financial Institution a defined in
Section 4 A of Cos Act, 1956, Scheduled Banks, RBI approved foreign banks operating
in India, State Financial Corporation established under Section 3 of State Financial
Corporation Act, Institutions engaged in providing financial services, promoted by any of
the institutions mentioned above, either jointly or severally, custodians of securities who
are registered with SEBI, Clearing Corporation or clearing houses of Stock Exchanges,
Stock brokers registered with SEBI, NBFCs having a net worth 50 lakhs or more,
provided they fulfill the admission criteria laid down by SEBI. A Depository Participant
is the representative of an Investor in the Depository System. He acts as an intermediary
between an Investor and the Depository.
As per the provisions of the ordinance, the holder of securities shall have an
option whether to remain in non-depository mode or shift to depository mode. Those
who would like to remain in non-depository mode shall hold the physical possession of
Certificates of Securities and the Investors who opt to hold securities under depository
mode shall open an Account with a Depository Participant. He gets an identification
number which serves as a reference point for all his transactions with that Depository
Participant. The process of dematerialization involves the following steps:
205
206
converting
owner has
concerned
shares so
207
This system will also help Company Management to maintain and update
information about shareholding pattern of Company. The issue cost will also be
drastically reduced because of dematerialization of shares. It can be inferred that
paperless trading is a boon not only for investors and brokers, but other
intermediaries and Company Management will also be benefited.
PROBLEMS OF DEPOSITORY SYSTEM
Despite the various benefits the Depository System offers, Investor especially the
retail investor is shy of Demat trading. In order to provide an investor friendly
208
209
Demat equities are allowed as good delivery in the physical trading from
April 6. An Investor purchasing shares in the physical segment may get delivery
In Demat shares and such shares will be good delivery.
In order to boost trading volume in the Demat segment, SEBI has made it
compulsory for Institutional Investors to trade in Demat form in respect of 110
scrips from October 15, 1998. Starting December 15, 1998 trades by Institutional
Investors in 235 scrips have to be settled compulsorily in Demat form.
To rope in small Investors SEBI has come up with a list of 12 companies in which
retail Investors have to compulsorily settle trades in Shares in Demat form from
January 4, 1999. With effect from February 15, 1999 nineteen Companies have
been added to the list of securities in which trading in Demat form is compulsory
for all Investors. From April 5, 1999 another 29 companies have to be traded in
Demat form compulsorily by all investors. So from April 5, 1999 investors would
have to deal in Demat form in 60 scrips compulsorily. This will cover all scrips
of BSE Sensex and CNX Nifty indices.
Depository participants are offering a number of special incentives like Waiver of
Account Opening Charges, Security Deposit, Maintenance charges and reduction
in transaction cost, etc., to woo the prospective clients.
NSDL intends to facilitate in the near future stock lending and borrowing of
Securities held in Demat form, stock lending and borrowing schemes would give
a major fillip to trading volumes in the Demat shares.
The measures taken so far indicate the eagerness of the regulatory authorities to
promote Demat trading. Since retail Investors have the key to lucidity, there is a
concerted move to reach out to small Investors by offering them various sops.
CONCLUSION
Setting up o depository is a bold step and a beginning is made towards
integrating Indian capital market with the rest of the International Markets. While
depository system by itself may not be a panacea for the antiquated forms of
trading and methods of record keeping which are manual, cumbersome and time
consuming it may definitely improve the capital market operations.
REFERENCES
Sanjiv Agarwal and Pawan Kumar Vijay, Depositories: Law Practice and
Procedure, Mashbra Industries (P) Ltd.,
Depository Act, 1996.
SEBI Guidelines.
Rajendra Kumar Garg, Depository Services for Growth of Capital Markets in
India, Journal of Accounting and Finance, August 1996.
Chartered Secretary, August 1998.
Charted Financial Analyst,, September 1998.
Management Accountant, May 1996.
Economic Times.
210
NG UNIT -IV
CAPITAL
MANAGEMENT
[ Instructions to Faculty ]
211
Learning Unit-4
Instructions to Faculty
Capital Management
First, explain the objectives of this Learning Unit.
Objectives:
At the end of this Learning Unit the participants will be able to:
1. Understand the nature of investment decisions.
2. Value the estimated future benefits that will occur to the firm over a series of years.
3. Understand the implications of long-term investments.
4. Apply the steps of investment evaluation criteria methodically.
5. Work out to accept or reject an investment proposal.
6. Use pay back period as a method of evaluating investment proposal.
7. Evaluate both the lending and borrowing type projects.
8. Build the relationship between profitability and risk.
9. Describe basic risk concepts.
10. Incorporate risk analysis in the capital budgeting proposals.
11. Apply different approaches to the calculation of cost of equity capital.
12. Adopt CAPM approach for computing the cost of equity.
13. List merits and demerits of the CAPM approach.
14. Calculate weighted average cost of capital.
15. Determine the cost of equity capital of the company.
16. Establish the relationship between leverage and the cost of capital.
17. Critically appraise the traditional approach and the Modigliani- Miller approach to the
problems of capital structure.
18. Establish the relationship between capital structure and the value of firm.
19. Define capital structure, appropriate capital structure and flexible capital structure.
20. Employ yield measures like, current yield, yield to maturity, yield to call and realized
yield to maturity.
21. Undertake s tock valuation by using dividend discount model.
22. Understand the DEMAT systems and the working of depositary system in India.
212
ty should use the visual aids given below to explain the objectives.
Capital Structure
Capital Budgeting Decisions
Measurement of Risk
Cost of Capital including CAP-M
Valuation of Fixed Income Securities
Valuation of Bonds and Stocks
Explanation: Faculty to give the salient features of each of the above units while
making the presentation. Faculty may refer to the information in the Reading Material
for Learning Unit 4.
Faculty may refer to the Reading Material in Learning Unit 4 for information on
the above topics for presentation/
Forecasting risk
Risk and returns
Risk adjusted discount rate
Sensitivity analysis
Standard deviation to measure risk
Decision Tree approach
Utility Theory
Faculty may refer to the Reading Material in Learning Unit 4 for information on the
above topics for presentation
214
Preference shares
Convertible debentures
Non-convertible debentures
SEBI guidelines
Government securities
Yield to maturity
Credit Ratings
Liquidity Preference Theory
Determinants of Interest Rate
Faculty may refer to the Reading Material in Learning Unit 4 for information on the
above topics for presentation
Faculty may refer to the Reading Material in Learning Unit 4 for information on the
above topics for presentation
215
Group Activities
After making a presentation based on the above visual aids Nos. 25 -31,
faculty should facilitate group activities as detailed in the handout on
Group Activity for Learning Unit 4. Briefly, there will be three groups;
each group will be assigned work as follows:
Group 1:
A. Capital Structure
B. Capital Budgeting decision
Group 2:
C. Measurement of Risk
D. Cost of Capital, including CAP-M
Group 3:
216
Government of Karnataka
TRAINING MODULE ON
CORPORATE
FINANCE MANAGEMENT
[Non-DLM]
Phase-II
With support from
Department of Personnel & Training
Government of India
And
UNDP
217
218
Contents
4. Portfolio Management
5. Derivatives
6. International financial Management
{Note: The Second Phase Training is meant for the participants, who
have undergone training in the first phase}
219
Activities/Process
9.30 to
10.30 a.m.
10.30 a.m.
to
1.45 p.m.
2.30 pm to
5.30 pm
220
Facilitator to analyze
the expectations of the
participants.
Facilitators to explain
the salient features of
the phase-2 training.
Facilitator to explain
how to use the reading
materials and books to
carry out the group
activities effectively.
Facilitator to assist the
participants
in
the
selection of books.
Learning Unit - 5
Portfolio Management
Objectives :
At the end of this learning unit, the participants will be able to;
Interpret the basic principles required for designing, analyzing and managing a
portfolio
Decide the proportions of the total funds that should be invested in each security.
Take decisions on asset allocation and on the choice of securities within each
broad category of asset.
221
Day - 2
Learning Unit - 5
Forenoon & Afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Portfolio
Management
Group activities
Assignment
of topics
222
Day-3
Learning Unit-5
Forenoon and Afternoon Session
Day-4
Learning Unit - 5
Forenoon and Afternoon Session:
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Firm specific
analysis
2
Modern
Portfolio
theory
Asset
Allocation
and Portfolio
Design
223
Learning Unit - 6
Derivatives
At the end of this learning unit, the participants will be able to:
07.
08.
09.
10.
11.
12.
224
Day 5
Learning Unit - 6
Forenoon and Afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Commencement of LU-6
Recap on L.U.5.
Derivatives
Faculty to make a brief presentation on the
meaning and background of derivatives as
well as option pricing models including
the black schales option pricing model and
using derivatives to reduce risk.
Group tasks
225
Day 6
Learning Unit - 6
Forenoon and Afternoon Session
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
Derivatives
Focus on
questions and
mini cases
226
Day 7
Learning Unit - 6
Forenoon and Afternoon Session
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
227
Learning Unit - 7
11.
Acquire the skills of conversion rates, by bid price, ask price and spread
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
228
Day 8
Learning Unit - 7
Forenoon and Afternoon Sessions
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Recap
International
Financial
Management
Recap on L.U. 6.
Commencement of LU 7
International Financial Management.
Faculty to make a brief presentation on
BOP, exchange rate theories, hedging and
translation exposure, currency adjustment,
IMF and IBRD functions, EMS, Foreign
exchange market, Euro currency market
and risks in international operations.
Focus on 15
problems and
two cases
Case on guns
Case on
helicopters.
Group activity:
Group work will be assigned to the
existing 4 groups.
Participants will be required to read/
study the reading materials in LU 7
and to use references to solve specific
problems.
15 problems and 2 case studies will be
supplied to the participants (the details
are available in the handout on group
activities in LU-7)
229
Day 9
Learning Unit - 7
230
Day 10
Learning Unit - 7
Forenoon and Afternoon Sessions :
Time &
Subject
Activities/Process
9.30 a.m. to
1.30 p.m.
Recap
International
Financial
Management
Presentation
2.30 p.m. to
5.30 p.m.
Conclusion
231
LEARNING UNIT V
PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
[Group Activity]
232
Group Activity
Learning Unit 5
Portfolio Management
1.
General Instructions:
1.1.
1.2.
At the beginning of this learning unit, the faculty will make an explanation
on Portfolio Management with examples. This explanation/presentation will
take approximately two hours.
1.3.
1.4.
2.
2.1.
Group Work
Four groups will be formed. Each group will consist of 5-6 members. Each
group will be assigned a separate topic as shown below :Group A : Firm specific analysis.
Group B : Modern Portfolio theory
Group C : Asset Allocation and portfolio design.
Group D : Evaluation of portfolio performance.
2.2.
2.3.
One or two members from the group may make the presentation. Each group
will be given sufficient time followed by 15 minutes discussion in the
classroom with other group members.
2.4.
233
3.
3.1.
3.2.
3.3.
The Balance Sheet is a snapshot of what the company owns, the assets, and
what the company owes, the liabilities, on a specific date. We have below
the condensed Balance Sheets as on 31.03.1990 and 31.03.1991 of Shatabdi
Industries, in the format used by the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE)
Directory. (The published Balance Sheet, from which these condensed
statements have been prepared, contains hundreds of items.)
234
C
D
E
F
Current Assets
1. Cash and Bank Balance
2. Sundry Debtors
3. Inventory
4. Misc. Current Assets
Fixed Assets (Net)
5. Gross Block
i) Plant & Machinery
ii) Others
6. Less: Depreciation
7. Investment in
Subsidiaries
8. Miscellaneous Assets
9. Intangible Assets
Total Assets
Current Liabilities
10. Loans and Advances
11. Sundry Creditors
12.Provision for Tax
13. Miscellaneous Current
Liabilities/Provisions.
Deferred Liabilities
14. Debentures
15. Long-term Loans
Total Outside Liabilities
Share capital
16. Preference Capital
17. Equity Capital
(Rs.10 paid up)
Shareholders Reserves
18. Share Premium
Reserve
19. Other Capital Reserve
20. Sinking Fund and
Redemption Reserve
21. Investment Allowance
Reserve
22. Free Reserves/Surplus
Net Worth
TOTAL LIABILITIES
Rs. In Lakhs
31.03.1990
20181
1737
6883
8135
3426
28225
48640
40228
8411
20415
31.03.1991
28437
1655
8770
9180
8833
29135
53772
44965
8812
24637
Common size
31.03.1990
42
4
14
17
7
58
100
83
17
42
31.03.1991
49
3
15
16
15
51
93
78
15
43
10
17
48432
14586
4368
6196
1534
2487
10
17
57598
13808
2008
6907
3704
1189
0
0
100
30
9
13
3
5
0
0
100
24
3
12
6
2
14565
5948
8617
29151
1863
19999
8397
11602
33807
1863
1863
1863
30
12
18
60
4
0
4
35
15
20
59
3
0
3
17418
21928
36
0
38
0
4514
560
4248
1120
9
1
7
2
5315
5765
11
10
7029
19282
48432
10795
23792
57598
15
40
100
19
41
100
235
3.4.
4.
The major categories of assets are current assets and fixed assets. Current
assets are those assets which the company intends to convert into cash in the
near future (within say less than one year). Fixed assets are those assets
which the company intends to use up over several years. The major
categories of liabilities are outside liabilities and liability towards
shareholders, know as net worth. Accountants treat a company as an entity
distinct from its shareholders whose stake in the firm is therefore treated as a
liability of the company towards its shareholders. The outside liabilities are
usually categorized into those which have to be met in the near future (say
within the next one year), which are known as current liabilities and those
liabilities which have to be met later, known as the long term liabilities.
4.1.
4.2.
The total net worth divided by the number of shares is the much talked about
book value of a share. For Shatabdi Industries, the book value turns out to be
Rs.127.70 on 31.03.1991 as against Rs.103.50 on 31.03.90. Though the
book value is often seen as an indication of the intrinsic worth of the share,
this may not be so for two major reasons. First, the market price of the share
reflects the future earnings potential of the firm which may have no
relationship with the value of its assets. Second, the book value is based
upon the historical costs of the assets of the firm and these may be gross
underestimates of the cost of the replacement or resale values of these assets.
It is not uncommon to find shares of good companies quoting five to ten
times their book value.
4.3.
We now turn to the Profit and Loss Account of Shatabdi Industries given in
Table 2.
236
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
4.4.
1. Net Sales
Cost of Goods Sold
2. Stocks Consumed
3. Wages and Salaries
4. Direct Manufacturing
Expenses
5. General Expenses
6. Gross Profit
7. Interest
8. Pre-Depreciation
Operating Profit
9. Depreciation
10. Operating Profit
11.Non-Operating Surplus/
Deficit
12. Pre-tax Profit
13. Provision for Taxes
14. Net Profit
Profit Distributed
15. Dividend on Preferred
Capital
16. Dividend on equity
17. Profit Retained
Rs. In Lakhs
Year ending
31.03.1990
51929
35105
8809
5239
21057
31.03.1991
61527
40002
9292
6182
24527
Common size
Year ending
31.03.1990
100
68
17
10
41
31.03.1991
100
65
15
10
40
6511
10313
2293
8021
7540
13985
2428
11558
13
20
4
15
12
23
4
19
3972
4049
169
4222
7335
277
8
8
0
7
12
0
4218
7612
12
728
3489
745
2170
5442
932
1
7
1
4
9
2
745
2744
932
4510
1
5
2
7
The Profit and Loss Account shows the revenues earned and the costs
incurred by the company during the years ending 31.03.1990 and
31.03.1991. The costs are classified into major heads. The Gross Profit as
defined by BSE, commonly known as Earnings Before Interest, Depreciation
and Taxes (EBIDT), is arrived at by subtracting the Cost of Goods Sold and
the General Expenses from Sales Revenues. The Operating Profit as defined
by BSE more commonly known as Profit Before Tax (PBT) is arrived at by
subtracting Interest and Depreciation Expenses from the Gross Profit. The
Net Profit or Profit After Tax (PAT) is arrived at by subtracting the Taxes
Paid from the total of Operating and Non-operating Profits. The P&L
Statement also shows the details of distribution of net profits between
dividends and retention.
237
4.5.
There are some other measures of earnings which are frequently used for
various kinds of analyses. Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT) is
obtained by subtracting depreciation from EBIDT. Cash Profits are defined
as PAT plus all non-cash expenses, primarily depreciation.
4.6.
Most investors are interested in the Earnings Per Share (EPS) which is
obtained by dividing PAT by the number of shares. In case of Shatabdi
Industries, EPS for 1991 is Rs.29.22 as compared toRs.18.73 in the previous
year.
Decrease
Asset
Use
Source
Liability
Source
Use
5.2.
While doing this we must look at the changes in the Gross Block rather than
the Net Block because this correctly captures the additions to and sale of
fixed assets.
5.3.
Once this has been done, there is only one important source of funds left.
This is the Cash Profits generated by the firm which as stated earlier is PAT
plus all non cash expenses. The Statement of Sources and Uses of Funds for
Shatabdi Industries for the year ended 31.03.1991 is contained in Table 3.
238
5434
2449
2985
9664
5442
4222
15098
Uses of Funds
Increase in Current Assets
Decrease in Current Liabilities
Increase in Gross Block
Dividends
8256
778
5132
932
15098
5.4.
One of the major uses of Funds flow Analysis is to find out whether the firm
has used short term sources of funds to finance long-term investments. Such
method of financing increases the risk of liquidity crunch for the firm, as
long-term investments, because of the gestation period involved may not
generate enough surpluses in time to meet the short-term liabilities incurred
by the firm. Many a firm has come to grief because of this mismatch
between the maturity periods of sources and uses of funds.
5.5.
It is clear from Table 3 that Shatabdi Industries has been quite prudent in its
choice of source mix. A large proportion of total funds have come from
long-term sources, which has not only been used to finance the long-term
uses but also to finance current assets and reduce current liabilities.
5.6.
The Funds Flow Analysis also reveals the extent to which a company is able
to finance its growth from Internal Generation of funds. In Table 3, we see
that in the case of Shatabdi Industries, internal generation accounts for about
two-thirds of the total requirements of funds.
6.
6.1.
239
The techniques that are used to do such proper comparative analysis are: (i)
common-sized statement, and (ii) financial ratio analysis.
6.2.
6.3.
Financial ratio analysis is perhaps the most extensively used tool for
comparative analysis. The ratios which are useful for carrying out such
comparison depend upon the purpose of the analysis. For example, shortterm creditors would be interested in monitoring ratios that reflect the ability
of the firm to meet its short-term liabilities, while long-term creditors and
share-holders would in addition be interested in ratios that measure the longterm performance of the firm. There are broadly four types of ratios that are
used for analyzing the performance of a firm :
1. Liquidity ratios measure the firms ability to fulfill its short-term
obligations.
2. Leverage/Capital structure ratios measure the firms ability to meet its
short-term as well as long-term debt obligations.
3. Turnover/Activity ratios measure how effectively the firm is using its
assets.
4. Profitability ratio measure the return on sales and assets of the firm.
5. Common stock ratios measure dividends, earnings and net worth on a per
share basis.
6.4.
240
61527
24008
37519
30184
277
7612
241
In break-even analysis, we are interested in determining the level of sales at which the
Profit before Tax (PBT) is zero. We will do this by working our way backwards in the
above table setting the last row (PBT) equal to zero.
49028
19121
29907
30184
277
0
X 100
242
The contribution margin is perhaps the more important parameter as it measures the
impact on profits of any change in sales. Shatabdi contribution margin of 61% means
that every rupee of additional sales will increase the pretax profits by 61 paisa. Equally
every rupee decline in sales will reduce pretax profits by 61 paisa. The traditional
financial ratio analysis does not provide this information at all. For example, if we were
to compute the ratio of PBT to Sales for Shatabdi, we would get 7612/61527 = 12%. An
investor will be grossly mistaken if he were to conclude from this ratio that profits will
rise only by 12 paisa for every rupee increase in sales.
The previous sections focused on the growth in demand for the industry and the firm.
Since an investor is ultimately interested only in the profits of the firm, the forecasted
demand growth has to be translated into earnings growth. The contribution analysis is
the most important tool available to the investor for this purpose. Two notes of caution
are, however, in order. First, this analysis is valid only as long as the existing capacity is
adequate to meet the forecasted demand growth. This is because if new capacity has to
be created, the cost structure (particularly the fixed costs) would change. Second, the
traditional accounting statements do not provide adequate information about variable and
fixed costs. The contribution margin, therefore, has to be assessed using the analysts
judgment about the cost structure.
Financial Analysis and Measures of Risk
Contribution analysis also leads to a measure of risk. Since an investor is ultimately
concerned with the profit, his perception of risk would be determined by the possible
variability in the profit. The variability in profits arises primarily because of variability
in sales. We then ask what will be the percentage change in profits if sales changes by
1%.
Let us see what happens to the PBT of Shatabdi Industries if its sales drop by 1% from its
current level:
Current
Level
61527
24008
37519
27756
2428
277
7612
Sales
Less Variable expenses
Contribution
Less Operating fixed costs
Less Interest
Add Non operating surplus
Profit before tax
99%
of
Current sales
60912
23768
37144
27756
2428
277
7237
Change
(1% drop)
615
240
375
0
0
0
375
The decrease in PBT from 7612 to 7237 represents a drop for 4.93% though the drop in
sales was only 1%. This amplification factor of 4.93 is known as the Degree of Total
Leverage (DTL) and measures the risk arising out of the sensitivity of profits to compute
243
the value of DTL. It is simply the ratio between the Contribution and the PBT as shown
below:
DOL = Contribution
PBT
37519
7612
= 4.93
It is customary to break up this risk into two components: (i) the Degree of Operating
Leverage (DOL) arising from the structure of operating costs of the firm,
(ii) the
Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL) arising from the capital structure of the firm.
The degree of operating leverage (DOL) measure the percentage change in EBIT for a
1% change in sales and is computed as follows:
DOL = Contribution
EBIT
37519
7612 + 2428
= 3.74
The degree of financial leverage (DFL) on the other hand measures the percentage
change in PBT for a 1% change in EBIT and is computed as follows:
DOL = EBIT =
PBT
7612 + 2428
7612
= 1.32
The degree of total leverage (DTL) is nothing but the product of DOL and DFL.
DTL = DOL X DFL = 3.74 X 1.32 = 4.93
Let us try to understand as to why changes in sales have an amplified impact on the
profits. It is the presence of fixed costs of operations that cause a 1% change in sales to
result in more than 1% change in EBIT. Similarly, since interest is also a fixed cost a 1%
change in EBIT causes profits to change by more than 1%. The net effect is that the
fixed costs acting as levers magnify the impact of changes in sales on profits.
244
investor who takes fundamental analysis seriously will find that the time that he spends
with these notes is amply rewarded.
We will illustrate the impact of accounting policies with two examples drawn from the
published annual reports of Shatabdi Industries.
1.
2.
A perusal of the notes revealed that the company had been consistently
charging depreciation on the Straight Line Method (SLM). In this
method, the cost of any asset is charged off as depreciation in equal
annual installments over the life of the asset. The alternative Written
Down Value (WDV) method charges off higher amounts in earlier years
and lower amounts in later years: the depreciation in each year is
proportional to the depreciated value of the asset. For companies which
are growing rapidly, the SLM depreciation can be below the WDV
depreciation year after year. Since, the WDV basis is followed for
Income Tax purposes; it is clear that the reported profits would then be
higher than the taxable profits. Income tax as a percentage of reported
profits would, therefore, be quite low. It will be seen from Table 2 that
the provision for tax is less than 30% of reported PBT.
In order to see the impact of these two policies, we have eliminated the
impact of revaluation and reworked the depreciation on WDV method.
The recast summarized Balance Sheet of Shatabdi Industries as on
31.03.1991 is shown in Table 4.
Current Assets
Fixed Assets (Net)
Other Assets
Total Assets
Current Liabilities
245
As Reported
As Recast
28437
29135
27
57598
13808
28437
21177
27
49640
13808
Deferred Liabilities
Net Worth
Total Liabilities
19999
23792
57598
19999
15834
49640
The impact of both of the changes is to reduce the fixed assets and to
reduce the net worth and the combined effect is indeed stunning. The net
worth falls steeply to two thirds of the reported value. The book value per
share drops from Rs.127.70 as per reported figures to Rs.85.00. Similarly,
the Profit and Loss Account also undergoes a change: the increased
depreciation charge for the year reduces the profit before tax by nearly 25%
from the reported figure of 7612 to 5773.
We should not get bogged down with the question as to which method
SLM or WDV is the correct one. The important point is that before
comparing two companies, we must recast their accounts on the basis of
uniform accounting policies: either both on SLM or both on WDV.
Otherwise, the comparison is meaningless. This point applies with equal
force to ratio analysis where we are comparing the ratios with some
industry norms. The reader would do well to recompute the ratios of
Shatabdi Industries using the recast figures and see whether it changes his
earlier assessment of the company.
Contingent liabilities disclosed in the notes is the another important thing
that we should look out for. Amounts which are in dispute, which are
indeterminate or which for other reasons the company believes it will not be
required to pay are often shown as contingent liabilities in the notes instead
of being provided for in the Balance Sheet as a liability or a provision. If
the amount is large, the investor must be careful; if for some reason, the
liability does materialize, it would erode the net worth of the company.
Business Analysis
The annual reports also contain a good deal of other information about the
lines of business of the company, the capacity utilization, trends in volume
and value of business, and some assessments about the future.
In case of Shatabdi Industries, we find that there are three major lines of
business. The percentage of sales contributed by these three lines is as
follows:
Export Business
Industrial Synthetics
Cement
25%
35%
40%
While we know the sales revenues for each business separately, we are
unable to extract from the annual report the costs and profits of each of them.
246
Some costs are of course really joint costs and not attributable to any
division, but even the costs that are relatable to each line like material costs
are not separately disclosed in the annual report. In some cases, we can, of
course, make informed guesses; for example, limestone and pozzalana could
have been used only for the cement business.
There is some information about unit volumes and capacity utilization that
we can extract from the report. Comparing 1991 and 1990 kin terms of
volume and value of sales, we found the following for the three lines of
business:
Line of Business
Growth
Volume
Export Business
Industrial Synthetics
Cement
6%
-1%
2%
in Sales Value
32%
2%
25%
Change in
Unit Price.
25%
3%
23%
The export business shows a good rise both in unit volume and in value. The
rise in unit prices is well in excess of the rate of depreciation in the value of
the rupee, so that higher prices have been realized even in dollar terms.
2.
Cement output has risen only marginally, and the growth in value is almost
entirely accounted for by price increases. The price increase is clearly much
above the general rate of inflation during the period.
3.
Industrial synthetic output has declined marginally, and price has risen
slightly to produce a marginal rise in sale value. The unit price has failed to
keep pace with the general rate of inflation and it is very likely that the
margins in this business are under pressure.
Further details on some of these can be found from the Directors report and
the Chairmans speech at the Annual General Meeting of the company.
These statements contain the managements evaluation of the past years
results and its assessment of the prospects for the next year. Since these
statements are the only place where the companys future is discussed, they
are of great value to the investor. However, in deciding what reliance to
place on these statements and how to interpret them, we must have regard for
the past track record of the management. Some Chairmen tend to be unduly
247
optimistic about the future so that their statement about excellent prospects
for the next year must be taken with more than a pinch of salt.
248
Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) is based on a few simple but fundamental insights into
investor behavior. The contribution of the theory has been to put these insights into a
coherent framework for analysis and decision making. Though the theory itself may at
first sight seem complex, the insights on which it is based are quite easy to understand.
Let us, therefore, begin by discussing these fundamental notions:
1. The Notion of Risk Suppose we evaluate two shares M and N for investment. We
have collected data on the returns earned by investors on these shares in the last five
years which are as follows:
Share M : 30%, 28%, 34%, 32% and 31%
Share N : 26%, 13%, 48%, 11% and 57%
If we have to choose only one of the two share3s for investment, which share shall we
choose? One approach would be to compute the average return for each share and choose
the one which has higher average return. If we do that, we find that both the shares have
an average return of 31%. Can there be any other criterion for choice? Most investors
would regard share N to be riskier as its return fluctuates substantially from year to year.
They would, therefore, prefer share M to N. Thus, investors appear to make their choices
based on two considerations: expected returns. Riskiness is measured by the variability
in returns.
2. The Notion of Diversification Investors seem to follow the well-known adage, Do
not keep all your eggs in one basket. They invariably invest in more than one security
so that losses in one may be offset by gains in another. In this manner, investors are able
to reduce the variability of returns.
3. The Notion of a Portfolio The set of all securities held by an investor is called his
portfolio. The portfolio may contain just one security, but we have already seen that, in
general, it will contain several securities. One of the important contributions of MPT has
been to show that we should analyze the portfolio in its entirety and not merely a security
in isolation.
4. The Notion of dominance The MPT is based on two very basic and intuitively
acceptable statements about risk and return:
a. If two portfolios have identical expected returns, then investors would choose that
portfolio which has a lower risk.
b. If two portfolios have identical risks, then investors would choose that portfolio
which has a higher expected return.
249
We shall in the
What is Risk?
Let us go back to the example at the beginning of this chapter where we looked at
the returns over the last five years on shares M and N:
Share M: 30%, 28%, 34%, 32% and 31%
Share N: 26%, 13%, 48%, 11% and 57%
We concluded intuitively that share N was riskier because its return fluctuated
much more. While both had an average return of 31%, Ns returns deviated to a
greater extent from this average than Ms did. Statisticians measure this kind of
deviation or fluctuation by either the standard deviation or the variance. In MPT,
the variability or riskiness of securities is measured by the standard deviation of
the security returns. Standard deviation is usually denoted by the Greek letter s
(pronounced sigma). The variance is nothing but the square of the standard
deviation and hence denoted by s 2 (pronounced sigma square). The mathematical
definitions of standard deviation and variance have been explained in Appendix 5,
but the average reader need not know these definitions at all. All that is important
250
Solution
In this example, if we invested in only one of the two companies, our expected
return will be 20%, with a possible deviation (risk) of 10% either way. If,
however, we split our investment between the two companies equally, so that our
investment replicates the total market in miniature, half of our investment would
certainly earn 30%, while the other half would earn 10%, so that our average
return would always be 20%, no matter what the vagaries of weather during the
year. Clearly, the diversification results in 20% return without risk, whereas
holding individual securities was yielding an expected return of 20% with risk.
In the above example, diversification eliminated all risk because the returns of the
two companies moved diametrically opposite to each other: when one return was
30%, the other was 10% and vice versa. This was because there was only one
251
source of risk in planet Delta the weather and it affected the two securities in
exactly opposite directions. Such a situation seldom occurs in real life. More
often than not, in practice, there are several sources of risk some of which affect
only one of the securities, some affect both in opposite directions and some others
affect them in the same direction. Clearly it is important to know what is the net
effect of all these multiple causes which affect the security returns. Do the
securities move in the same direction or in opposite directions? In either case, what
is the strength of the coefficient (denoted by the symbol ?) to answer these
questions? The correlation coefficient ranges from -1 to +1. If the two returns
move exactly opposite to each other, the correlation coefficient is -1, if they move
exactly in step with each other, then it is +1; if the two returns are entirely
unrelated to each other, it is zero. A positive correlation coefficient which is less
than +1 indicates that the two returns have a tendency to move in the same
direction, but are not always inexact step with each other. This kind of imperfect
correlation is most commonly observed, since two different securities belonging to
two different firms can hardly b expected to move in perfect harmony with each
other. Positive correlation between two securities implies, for example, that when
the market as a whole booms, both the securities would register a rise in prices, or
when the market crashes, both the securities would show a decline in prices.
Let us, next, move from Planet Delta to Planet Earth and consider a more realistic
example.
Consider two securities X and Y with the following attributes:
Expected return on Security X
Expected return on Security Y
s of Security X
s of Security Y
=
=
=
=
20%
30%
10%
16%
Coefficient of Correlation
Between the Returns of X and Y = -1, 0.5, +1 (three scenarios).
We shall evaluate the impact on the gains from diversification, for the three
different values of the correlation coefficients.
Let us first analyze the case where we hold a portfolio with 40% invested in X and
60% invested in Y. The expected portfolio return is nothing but the weighted
average of the expected returns from each security in the portfolio, the weights
being the proportion of investment in each security. Therefore, the expected
portfolio return will be 26% (being 20 X 0.4 + 30 X 0.6).
Is the s of portfolio return the same as the weighted average of the s s of the
security returns? That is, would the s of portfolio return be 13.6% (being 10 X 0.4
+ 16 X 0.6)? These questions cannot be answered because the variability of
252
portfolio return not only depends on the variability of the security returns, but also
on the correlation coefficient.
The s of portfolio return will be 13.6% only when the two securities X and Y
move in perfect tandem with each other, that is, when the correlation coefficient
between returns on X and returns on Y is +1. So long as X and Y have a
correlation coefficient of less than +1, the s the portfolio return will be less than
13.6%. For example, if the correlation coefficient is only 0.5, then the s of the
portfolio will be only 12.1%.
The fact that the portfolio s is only 12.1% as against the weighted average s of
13.6% implies there has been some gain from diversification. Let us see why this
is so. If we invest all our money in Y, the expected return is 30% and the risk is
16%; while if we invest all our money in X, the expected return is 20% and risk is
10%. We have assumed 6% additional risk for 10% additional return. This
implies that if there were no gains from diversification, as we move our money
from X to Y, on an average, for every 1% additional returns, we have to take 0.6%
additional risk. For example, if the correlation coefficient is +1, since the s of
portfolio return is nothing but the weighted average of the ss of security returns,
there is no gain from diversification, because every 1% increase in return is
accompanied with the average 0.6% increase in risk. It can be shown that except
in this extreme case of a correlation coefficient of +1, investing in two securities
does result in gains because the increase in risk for every 1% increase in return is
below the average increase in risk. In our illustration above, the return rose from
20% to 26% and the risk from 10% to 12.1% implying that there was only a 0.35%
increase in risk for every 1% increase in return. Gains from diversification allow
us to get additional return with less than commensurate increase in the risk level.
Let us extend our understanding of how an investor stands to gain through
diversification by investing in securities with imperfectly correlated returns, by
examining Table 1, which contains the expected return and risk for varying
composition of portfolio. The portfolios are also graphically displayed Fig 1, in
which the risk (s) is on the horizontal axis and the expected return is on the
vertical axis. The three curves in the figure are for three different degrees of
correlation between the securities.
253
In Y
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
Expected
Return
20.00
20.50
21.00
21.50
22.00
22.50
254
=-1.0
10.00
8.70
7.40
6.10
4.80
3.50
0.70
0.65
0.615
0.60
0.55
0.50
0.45
0.40
0.35
0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
0.30
0.35
0.385
0.40
0.45
0.50
0.55
0.60
0.65
0.70
0.75
0.80
0.85
0.90
0.95
1.00
23.00
23.50
23085
24.00
24.50
25.00
25.50
26.00
26.50
27.00
27.50
28.00
28.50
29.00
29.50
30.00
11.80
12.10
12.31
12.40
12.70
13.00
13.30
13.60
13.90
14.20
14.50
14.80
15.10
15.40
15.70
16.00
10.28
10.49
10.66
10.74
11.03
11.36
11.72
12.11
12.52
12.96
13.43
13.91
14.41
14.93
15.46
16.00
2.20
0.90
0.00
0.40
1.70
3.00
4.30
5.60
6.90
8.20
9.50
10.80
12.10
13.40
14.70
16.00
The tabulated values and the graphs demonstrate the impact of correlation in returns on
the variability of portfolio return.
If the return on the two securities are perfectly correlated (that is, correlation coefficient =
1.0), the portfolio return moves along the straight line joining points X and Y. as we
move from X to Y, for every 1% increase in the expected return, the risk of the portfolio
goes up by 0.6%. In effect, there is no reduction in risk on account of diversification,
when the returns across the securities are perfectly correlated, since the volatility (as
measured by s) of the portfolio return is the weighted average of the volatility of the
individual securities.
If the returns are imperfectly correlated (say, correlation coefficient = 0.5), the portfolio
return moves along a curve, reaching level of risk (s) which is below the weighted
average risk. For a given value of expected portfolio return, the risk with imperfect
correlation is always below the risk when there is perfect correlation.
If the returns are perfectly negatively correlated (that is, correlation coefficient = -1.0),
the risk can be reduced to zero. By investing about 61.5% of money in X and the rest in
security Y, an investor can derive risk-free return (s = 0.0) of 23.85%. For most other
portfolios, for a specified value of expected return, the risk in this case would be much
lower than the risk when there is perfect correlation in returns.
It is clear from the above, that whenever the two security returns are less than perfectly
correlated, an investor gains through diversification, the gains can often reduce the risk of
the portfolio below the risk of securities comprising the portfolio.
In general, an investor is likely to have many securities in his portfolio. The computation
of the expected return of the portfolio as usual is merely the weighted average of the
255
expected returns of the individual securities comprising the portfolio, the weights being
the respective proportion of each security in the portfolio.
The variance (s 2 ) of the portfolio return can be computed by repeated application of the
procedure used in the two security situation above. The portfolio of two securities can be
regarded as a single new security and combined with the third security, and the process
repeated till all n securities have been included in the portfolio.
At this stage we may ask whether the gains from diversification will continue to be
realized, till the portfolio return variance (s 2 ) reduces to zero. A little reflection will show
that this is not so. For if it was so, and then the portfolio consisting of all securities in the
market (technically called the market portfolio) which is the most diversified portfolio
imaginable would not have any risk. Yet we know that the market index does fluctuate
quite substantially though less than an individual security does. This suggests that there
is a minimum level of risk below which we cannot get by merely diversifying our
portfolio.
In general, as the number of securities in a portfolio increases, say up to 20 or 25, the
diversification reduces the portfolio risk (s 2 ) rapidly. However, soon thereafter, the
marginal reduction to portfolio risk of any further diversification becomes very small (Fig
2). Thus, a diversified portfolio of about 25 securities
256
highly correlated. Clearly, increasing the number of securities from 30 to 100 does not
necessarily improve the diversification substantially.
257
Dominant Portfolios
The notion of dominance is based on two very easily understood statements: (i) if two
portfolios have identical expected return, then investors would choose the one with lower
volatility of return (measured through s), (ii) if two portfolios have identical volatility of
return, then investors would choose the one with higher expected return. Let us once
again consider our earlier illustration of securities X and Y on planet Earth, in which the
expected returns on securities X and Y are 20% and 30% respectively and their ss are,
10% and 16% respectively, with the coefficient of correlation between the returns of X
and Y being 0.5.
Neither share dominates the other since X has lower return and Y has lower risk. If
forced to choose between X an Y, some investors may choose X and some Y, depending
on the extent of risk they are willing to assume. But the situation changes when we look
at the portfolio combining X and Y in a ratio of 9:1. In Table 7.1, we see that when we
invest 90% in share X and 10% in Share Y, the expected return is 21% and the s is
9.90%. This portfolio dominates share X which has a lower return of 20% and portfolio
dominates share X which has a lower return of 20% and a higher risk of 10%. The
dominance principle allows us to say that no investor would invest 100% in share X.
This example involved only two securities. Conceptually, the notion of dominance can
be extended to all portfolios that are possible, by combining all the risky securities
available in the market, in various proportions. The result can be shown graphically as in
Fig 3, where return is on the vertical axis and risk on the horizontal axis. The enclosed
area in the figure is the opportunity set, i.e., the set of all possible portfolios. The upper
(concave) part of the boundary of the opportunity set of portfolios is known as the
efficient set or efficient frontier. It is visually clear
258
259
260
261
Market Portfolio
Let us now examine the nature of portfolio M in reality. We may argue that if there is a
portfolio represented by point M, it can be identified by many financial analysts in the
market.
This is because the exercise thus far was quite straightforward, namely
constructing an efficient set of securities by identifying a large number of risky securities
in the market and by composing several portfolios by mixing them in various proportions,
and so on; altogether an exercise not really beyond the scope of a large computer. If
under such a scenario, the analysts recommended that a particular security, I, be left out
of the portfolio M, everybody who held security I would want to sell it off, so that the
ensuing selling pressure would bring down the price of I so that the return from it would
262
become attractive once again and the analysts would have to recommend its inclusion in
the portfolio M. hence we may say that portfolio M will be a portfolio from which none
of the risky securities from the market may be left out.
Again, if a particular security J were considered particularly attractive so that the analysts
recommended a large proportion of investors capital to be invested in J, everybody who
does not already have that proportion of J in his portfolio would rush to buy more of J till
the price of J rose to a level where its return would no longer appear attractive and one
would be forced to reduce the proportion of holding in J. Hence we may say that in
equilibrium, portfolio M would not only comprise every risky security in the market, but
the proportion of investment in each security will be proportional to the market
capitalization of that security no more, no less (market capitalization of a security is its
market price multiplied by the number of that security outstanding in the market). It can
be readily seen that the entire market taken as a whole is indeed one such portfolio!
263
individual securities. The theory asserts not only that such a relationship exists, but also
that it has a very simple form which we shall now state.
According to MPT, a part of the return on any security or portfolio is a reward for risk
and the rest is the reward for waiting, representing the time value of money. Specifically,
the risk-free return (which is earned by a security which has no risk) is the reward for
waiting and the excess of the return over the risk-free return is the risk premium or the
reward for risk. The Modern Portfolio Theory asserts that the risk premium of any
security is directly proportionate to the risk as measured by the Beta:
Risk Premium of a Security = Beta X Risk premium of market
Where
Risk premium of a security is the excess of the expected security return over the
risk-free rate of return, and
Risk premium of market is the excess of the expected market return over the riskfree rate of return.
The above relationship can also be expressed as:
Expected return on security = Risk-free return + Beta X Risk
Premium of market.
The above relationship, which is basically a simple linear relationship between risk and
return, is known as the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). The credit for developing
the arguments leading to the model goes to Sharpe, Linter and Mossin. The first author
of the model was also one of the three who shared the Nobel Prize for Economics in 1990
for the work. While CAPM is valid for all capital assets, in this chapter we have mostly
used the term securities since in this book securities are what we are primarily
concerned with.
264
Beta
We have discussed the distinction between diversifiable risk and non-diversifiable risk at
such length because from the point of view of an investor whose portfolio is well
diversified, the diversifiable risk is of no importance as it has been eliminated. What is
important to such an investor is the non-diversifiable risk arising from market wide
movements of security prices. This is one of the most important conclusions of the MPT:
the real riskiness of a security is its non-diversifiable risk.
265
The Modern Portfolio Theory, therefore, defines the riskiness of a security as its
vulnerability to market risk. This vulnerability is measured by the sensitivity of the
return of the security vis--vis the market return and is denoted by the Greek letter beta
(). A beta of 2 implies that if the market returns increases of decreases by 10% over a
period, the security return increases or decreases respectively by 20%. Thus in this case
the security return moves twice as much as the market return. A beta of 0.5 on the other
hand implies that the security return moves only half as much as the market does. Market
portfolio which refers to the portfolio consisting of all securities in the stock exchange
has a beta of 1, since such a portfolio behaves like the market index and moves in ilne
with it. A beta of zero characterizes a risk-free security like a government bond whose
return is almost insensitive to the market return.
Thus beta measures the only kind of risk (the non-diversifiable risk) which matters; the
higher the riskiness of a security, the higher the value of its beta. A security with a beta
value greater than 1 is referred to as an aggressive security and one with a beta value less
than 1 is referred to as a defensive security.
The beta of a portfolio is nothing but the weighted average of the betas of the securities
that constitute the portfolio, the weights being the proportions of investments in the
respective securities. For example, if the beta of security X is 1.5 and that of security Y
is 0.9 and 70% and 30% of our portfolio is invested in the two securities respectively, the
beta of the portfolio will be 1.32 (1.5 X 0.7 + 0.9 X 0.3).
2.
3.
Some of the factors discussed above do, at times, require some degree of judgment and
statistical analysis. For this reason, in many developed countries, there are specialized
agencies which perform all this analysis and publish their beta estimates for various
stocks at regular intervals. In India, we do not yet have these agencies. In the meantime,
we will have to do this analysis ourselves to estimate the betas that we need.
EXAMPLE 2
Let us consider the daily prices of the ITC share and the daily Bombay National Index for
the period January 1989 October 1990 (BSE data), based on the trading days. Columns
267
2 and 3 of Table 2 give the share price and the index respectively, for the period. The
intermediate values have been omitted, since objective of this example is only to illustrate
the computation of beta and the use of CAPM. We want to compute the beta () of ITC
using this data.
268
Date
1989 Jan 2
1989 Jan 4
1989 Jan 5
1989 Jan 6
1989 Jan 9
1989 Jan 10
1989 Jan 11
1989 Jan 12
1989 Jan 13
1989 Jan 16
1989 Jan 17
1989 Jan 18
1989 Jan 19
1989 Jan 20
1989 Jan 23
1989 Jan 25
1989 Jan 27
1989 Jan 30
1989 Jan 31
ITC
Price
48.00
49.00
46.00
45.00
46.00
48.00
48.00
49.00
48.00
49.00
47.00
47.00
47.00
48.00
45.00
46.00
48.00
48.00
50.00
BSE National
Index
339.10
330.21
324.32
324.20
337.06
339.52
337.78
336.86
332.62
333.30
333.12
331.82
329.53
328.73
326.68
341.15
344.43
346.71
348.95
1990 Sept. 3
1990 Sept. 4
1990 Sept. 5
1990 Sept. 6
1990 Sept. 7
1990 Sept. 10
1990 Sept. 11
1990 Sept. 12
1990 Sept. 14
1990 Sept. 18
1990 Sept. 19
1990 Sept. 20
1990 Sept. 21
1990 Sept. 25
1990 Sept. 26
1990 Sept. 27
1990 Oct. 4
1990 Oct. 9
1990 Oct. 11
1990 Oct. 12
145.00
130.00
135.00
135.00
135.00
127.50
133.75
135.00
132.50
138.00
143.00
155.00
165.00
171.25
162.50
165.00
156.25
173.75
157.50
145.00
653.79
631.78
625.06
635.69
648.14
659.32
677.60
666.65
644.82
668.34
676.30
681.27
695.83
729.69
704.81
706.94
708.68
762.72
727.41
692.60
269
Returns
ITC
Index
2.04%
6.52%
-2.22%
2.17%
4.17%
0.00%
2.04%
-2.08%
2.04%
-4.26%
0.00%
0.00%
2.08%
-6.67%
2.17%
4.17%
0.00%
4.00%
-2.69%
-1.82%
-0.04%
3.82%
0.72%
-0.52%
-0.27%
-1.27%
0.20%
-0.05%
-0.39%
-0.69%
-0.24%
-0.63%
4.24%
0.95%
0.66%
0.64%
1.38%
-11.54%
3.70%
0.00%
0.00%
-5.88%
4.67%
0.93%
-1.89%
3.99%
3.50%
7.74%
6.06%
3.65%
-5.38%
1.52%
-5.60%
10.07%
-10.32%
-8.62%
2.53%
-3.48%
-1.08%
1.67%
1.92%
1.70%
2.70%
-1.64%
-3.39%
3.52%
1.18%
0.73%
2.09%
4.64%
-3.53%
0.30%
0.25%
7.09%
-4.85%
-5.03%
1990 Oct. 15
1990 Oct. 18
1990 Oct. 22
1990 Oct. 25
1990 Oct. 26
1990 Oct. 31
142.50
142.50
135.00
140.00
141.25
142.50
638.04
655.11
615.25
646.67
640.44
640.96
-1.75%
0.00%
-5.56%
3.57%
0.88%
0.88%
-8.55%
2.61%
-6.48%
4.86%
-0.97%
0.08%
Solution
The first step is to compute the security and market returns. This is done in columns 4
and 5 of Table 7.2. We then used a spreadsheet programme on a PC to calculate the beta.
The output from the computer was as follows:
Regression Output:
Constant
0.002049
0.023574
0.362085
383
381
1.245126
0.084669
The beta is nothing but the X Coefficient in the above output. The beta of ITC for the
period is therefore 1.25.
We may also compute the expected return from the ITC share based on the above
example. During the period January 1989 October 1990, the market return was about
45% per annum, and the value of was 1.25. Assuming that the risk-free rate of return is
about 12%, we can use the CAPM equation to estimate the expected rate of return from
the ITC share. This works out to about 53% per annum. Where such a high return may
appear somewhat surprising at first glance, the fact remains that the period considered in
estimating the return includes one of the more bullish phases in the Indian capital market
history. Taking a much longer time period, say, five years or more, might have yielded a
more realistic estimate.
270
assumed that a security can be completely represented in terms of its expected return and
variance and that investors behave as if a security were a commodity with two attributes,
namely, expected return which is a desirable attribute and variance which is an
undesirable attribute. Investors are supposed to be risk averse and for every additional
unit of risk they take, they demand compensation in terms of expected return.
Again, the capital market is assumed to be efficient. An efficient market implies that all
new information which could possibly affect the share prices becomes available to all the
investors quickly and more or less simultaneously. Thus in an efficient market no single
investor has an edge over another in terms of the information possessed by him since all
investors are supposedly well informed and rational, meaning that all of them process the
available information more or less alike. And finally, in an efficient market, all investors
are price takers, i.e., no investor is so big as to affect the price of a security significantly
by virtue of his trading in that security.
The Capital Asset Pricing Model also assumes that the difference between lending and
borrowing rates are negligibly small for investors. Also, the investors are assumed to
make a single period investment decisions. The cost of transactions and information are
assumed to be negligibly small. The model also ignores the existence of taxes which may
influence the investors behavior.
The fact that some of the above assumptions are somewhat restrictive has attracted
considerable criticism of the model. This, however, need not distract us from the main
thrust of the model. The Capital Asset Pricing Model merely implies that in a reasonably
well-functioning market where a large number of knowledgeable financial analysts
operate, all securities will yield returns consistent with their risk, since if this were not so,
the knowledgeable analysts will be able to take advantage of the opportunities for
disproportionate returns and thereby reduce such opportunities. Hence, according to
CAPM, in an efficient market, returns disproportionate to risk are difficult to come by.
Assumptions concerning the investor behavior, market efficiency, lending and borrowing
rates, etc. are to be taken not in such as taxes, transaction costs, etc. can be easily
incorporated into the model for greater rigor.
271
When we talk of portfolio management, all of us think of equities. In this book too, we
have tended to focus on equities except in the last chapter.
In reality, however, with the possible exception of the growth oriented mutual funds, it is
rare to find a portfolio consisting entirely of equities. In many cases, equity is not even
the largest component of the portfolio. For example, the countrys largest and oldest
mutual fund UTIs Unit 64 has, in recent years, kept a larger fraction of its portfolio
in bonds than in shares. A substantial investment in bonds provides a stable source of
income to balance the unpredictable fortunes of the equity portfolio.
While equities and bonds constitute the bulk of most investment portfolios, it would be a
mistake to ignore the other components which though usually smaller are of vital
importance. Usually, a small percentage (5% - 10%) of the funds is kept in cash or in
highly liquid securities in the money market. The main purpose of these assets is to
provide transaction flexibility to a portfolio manager. They allow him to buy some
securities without having to sell some other scrip beforehand. Similarly, he may sell
some scrips, and keep the proceeds in money market instruments while he identifies the
scrips to buy. The investor who tries to eliminate money market instruments from his
portfolio would have to balance his purchase and sale of securities on a day-to-day basis;
this is usually utterly impractical. This transaction flexibility is not, however, the only
role of money market instruments in the overall portfolio. We shall see later that there
may be situations where an investor may keep an unusually large fraction of his funds in
the money market.
Asset Classes
The typical investment portfolio then has three distinct components which we shall call
asset classes:
1.
2.
3.
Equities
Bonds
Cash and money market instruments.
We are free to add more asset classes to this list. For some investors, bullion may be an
important asset class. In some cases, it may be useful to further divide the above asset
classes into subclasses. Individuals in high tax brackets may regard tax free PSU bonds
as a separate asset class distinct from corporate bonds. We can even think of subdividing
the equity asset class into the forward and cash list because of their different liquidity
characteristics.
In this chapter, however, we shall confine ourselves to the three asset classes listed
above.
272
2.
The most important source of risk is the changes in the interest rate. This
risk is measured by the duration.
2.
Individual bonds are also subject to default risk, but this risk is relatively
less serious at the portfolio level.
This suggests that we can define the riskiness of the overall portfolio consisting of all
asset classes by just two measures beta and duration. Asset allocation can therefore be
carried out by deciding on the target beta and target duration and then maximizing the
expected return subject to these constraints. Before we proceed to the problem of
273
deciding on the target beta and duration, let us first show how the overall portfolio beta
and duration can be computed.
The beta of bonds and of money market instruments is negligible. Thus this risk affects
only the equity portfolio. The beta of the total portfolio equals the beta of the equity
portfolio multiplied by the proportion of the portfolio which is invested in stocks. For
example, if 70% of the total portfolio is invested in an equity portfolio which has a beta
of 1.2, the beta of the total portfolio is 0.70 X 0.12 = 0.84.
Interest rate risk on the other hand, affects not only bonds but also stocks. Changes in the
interest rate do affect stock prices principally through a change in the Price/Earnings
Ratio. It can be shown that for stocks
Market Price (MP)
Duration = -----------------------------------------Dividend per share (DPS)
1
= Dividend yield
Where dividend yield equals DPS/MP. Since typically dividend yields are in the range of
3-4%, the typical duration of stocks is 25-30 years. Equity turns out to be the longest
duration asset available in the capital market with a duration exceeding that of the longterm bonds.
Money market instruments are at the other end of the spectrum their duration is
virtually zero. Some of these instruments may have a duration of 6 months or so (for
example, 182 day T-bills), but for all practical purposes, the average duration of the
money market portfolio as a whole can be taken as nearly zero.
Once again, we can compute the duration of the total portfolio as the weighted average of
the duration of its components. For example, if a portfolio is 30% equity, 5% in money
market and 65% in bonds with average durations of 25 years, 0 years and 4 years
respectively, the duration of the overall portfolio is 0.30 X 25 + 0.05 X 0 + 0.65 X 4 =
10.10 years.
274
might feel inclined to seek even higher returns by taking higher risk. In that case, we
should choose a beta well above one.
Needless to say, in making this assessment about risk, we would have to consider the
expected returns. We know that higher returns are associated with higher risk. During
the last ten years, the average return in the market has been about 10% higher than the
return on risk free securities. This means that the risk premium for a beta of one is about
10%. If our portfolio has a beta of 1.5, we can expect to earn a risk premium of 1.5 times
the market premium, i.e., 15% over and above the risk-free rate of return. If our beta is
only 0.8, the risk premium will be only 0.8 times 10%, i.e. 8%. Considering this risk
return relationship in the light of our attitude towards risk, we can decide on the desired
level of beta. This becomes the target beta as far as we are concerned.
management costs would amount to Rs.17.5 crores. Suppose that the rate of interest is
18%. What is the target duration for this mutual fund?
Solution
The target duration is the duration of the outflows calculated as follows:
Date
01.01.1992
01.01.1993
01.01.1994
01.01.1995
01.01.1996
01.01.1997
01.01.1998
Outflow
(Rs. Crores)
17.5
17.5
17.5
17.5
17.5
17.5
117.5
PV of Outflow
at 18%
14.83
12.57
10.65
9.03
7.65
6.48
36.89
98.09
Year
PV X Year
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
14.83
25.14
31.95
36.11
38.25
38.90
258.20
443.37
We would like to add, however, that duration matching is not an end in itself. It is a
powerful tool for protecting the bond portfolio from interest rate fluctuations, but some of
us will want to assume part of the interest rate risk in the hope of getting higher returns.
It is often true that assets with longer duration than our desired holding period offer
higher returns. We will then have to decide whether this additional return is worth the
extra risk that we assume. The extent of duration mismatch then becomes a measure of
risk that we are taking. The investors attitude towards risk thus plays an important role
in deciding on the extent of duration mismatch and therefore the target duration of the
overall portfolio.
276
The other way to achieve the target beta and duration is to adjust the composition of the
portfolios within each asset class. For example, we can say that while investing 90% of
our portfolio in equities, we will choose our equity portfolio in such a way as to ensure an
average beta of 1.25. This will give an overall beta of 0.9 X 1.25 = 1.125. Similarly
while saying that we will invest a certain percentage of our portfolio in bonds, we can
also say that we will choose long maturity bonds so as to obtain a duration of 5 years for
the bond portfolio.
In case of institutional investors, it is not uncommon for each of the three asset classes to
be managed by different individuals almost independently. In such cases, the asset
allocation process is the crucial stage at which their actions are coordinated by taking an
integrated view of the total portfolio. The person in charge of each asset class will be
told not only what quantum of the total funds are being allocated to him, but also what is
the average duration and beta expected from him. For example, the fact that a fraction of
the total portfolio is invested in stocks increases the average duration of the total portfolio
and allows the investor to have a lower duration for the bonds portfolio than if the entire
portfolio were invested in bonds. To control the risk better, the bond portfolio manager
needs to know the duration of the stock portfolio, and the equity portfolio manager needs
to know that his actions may be changing the duration of the total portfolio. For some
investors like pension funds and life insurance companies (which are, in India, in the
public sector), the desired duration is far longer than what is available in bond markets.
For them, the equity portfolio is the principal route to achieving high duration. We
normally think of equities as being risky, here, however, equities become an instrument
of risk reduction!
Example 2
How can an investor achieve target duration of 10 years if most corporate bonds have
duration of only 5 years?
Solution
The investor will not want to invest in government bonds and other low-yielding
securities even if they have a long duration. But he can use equities (which would have
an average duration of about 30 years) to achieve his target duration as shown in the
following asset allocation:
Asset Class
Duration
Corporate Bonds
Equities
Duration
5
30
Percentage
Allocation
80%
20%
Duration
Allocation.
4
6
10
Times
In those cases where all three asset classes are being managed by the same individual, the
process of asset allocation is not always as clearly differentiated from the second stage of
277
portfolio selection. Even here separating the process of strategic asset allocation helps in
providing a long-term perspective and an integrated view of the total portfolio.
278
This ability may allow them to invest a smaller percentage of their total portfolio in
equities and still earn their target rate of return.
Original
Percent
80
20
100
Original
Value
80
20
100
Current value
80
30
110
Current
percent
73
27
100
The average duration of bonds was 5 years and of equities 30 years. We shall assume
that the average beta of the equities was 1.0. We assume for simplicity that the boom in
share prices has not changed the duration or betas of our equity portfolio.
Original duration = 5 x 80/100 + 30 x 20/100 = 10 Years
Original beta
= 0 x 80/100 + 1 x 20/100 = 0.20
Current duration = 5 x 73/100 + 30 x 27/100 = 11.75 years
Current beta
= 0 x 73/100 + 1 x 27/100 = 0.27
279
Example 4
Consider the asset allocation of Example 2. What happens to the overall beta and
duration if there is a sharp rise in interest rates and bond prices drop by 20%?
Solution
Asset class
Bonds
Equities
Total
Original
percent
80
20
100
Original Value
Current value
80
20
100
64
30
94
Current
percent
68
32
100
The average duration of bonds was 5 years and of equities 30 years. We shall assume
that the average beta of the equities was 1.0. We assume for simplicity that the rise in
interest rates has not significantly changed the average duration of the bond portfolio.
Original duration = 5 x 80/100 + 30 x 20/100 = 10 Years
Original beta
= 0 x 80/100 + 1 x 20/100 = 0.20
Current duration = 5 x 68/100 + 30 x 32/100 = 13 years
Current beta
= 0 x 68/100 + 1 x 32/100 = 0.32
The second question is more fundamental. Does the choice of a target beta mean that we
should always maintain our portfolio beta at this target value? Not necessarily. Our
portfolio beta should hover around this target value, but, in the short run, it may deviate
quite substantially from this target value. If, for example, we feel that a slump in the
market is around the corner, we might want to temporarily switch over to a defensive
portfolio which provides us some protection in case of such a slump. A defensive
portfolio is a portfolio whose beta is low (less than one); since beta measures the
vulnerability to market risk, such a portfolio suffers less loss when the market slumps.
Obviously, when we switch over to such a defensive portfolio, our beta will be below our
target value. But this position is temporary; at the earliest opportunity, we would try to
restore it to our target value. Correspondingly, if we accept a boom in share prices, we
might temporarily switch over to an offensive portfolio. An offensive portfolio is a high
beta portfolio(beta above one) which is very sensitive to the market index and, therefore,
appreciates greatly when the market booms.
To summarize, therefore, our attitude towards risk determines our target beta, i.e. the long
run value of beta around which our portfolio beta would tend to fluctuate. Our view of
the market would determine the short run fluctuations in the portfolio betas as we switch
to offensive or defensive portfolios to exploit anticipated market movements in the short
run. In exactly the same way, our view about the likely changes in interest rates can
cause us to temporarily change the overall duration beta and duration of our total
portfolio.
280
This temporary realignment of portfolio beta and duration in response to changing market
values or to our view of the market is the province of tactical asset allocation. Since
shifts of portfolio betas are much more common than shifts of portfolio duration, we
shall, in this chapter, focus on beta shifts. But many of the same principles apply to shifts
of duration also.
Market Timing
It is obvious that switching to offensive and defensive portfolio according to our view of
the market trends is subject to a great deal of risk. If the market moves down when we
are holding an offensive portfolio because we expected the market to rise, we stand to
lose heavily. This is because an offensive portfolio drops even more rapidly than the
market. Similarly, if the market rises while we are holding a defensive portfolio in the
expectation of a slump in prices, we suffer an opportunity loss. A defensive portfolio
does not rise as fast as the market does and we lose out on the gains that we could have
made. This means that the switching of portfolio beta must be done with great care.
How far we are willing to go in moving away from our target beta depends on the degree
of confidence that we have in our forecast of market trends. Unless we are very
confident about our forecasts, we would be well advised to stick to our target beta.
From a practical point of view, the important question is how we implement the
temporary shifts in the portfolio betas. For example, suppose we want to temporarily
adopt a defensive portfolio (with say a beta of 0.6) with the intension of reverting to our
target beta (of say 1.1) in the near future. What options do we have? We could consider
the following possibilities:
1.
Switch a part of the portfolio to bonds (debentures), i.e. sell a part of our
equity portfolio and invest the proceeds in debentures.
2.
3.
Reduce the average beta of the equity portfolio by selling high beta stocks
and buying low beta stocks.
4.
All the above do succeed in creating a defensive portfolio and can be regarded as
equivalent in this sense. But in practice, there are important differences in these options:
1.
2.
3.
Short selling may be prohibited for some investors (e.g. mutual funds).
Even otherwise, it is subject to other risks (backwardation charges).
4.
Rebalancing the portfolio to reduce its beta must be done with some care;
if the portfolio becomes concentrated in a few low beta stocks it becomes
less diversified. This means that rebalancing will have to be done by
selling a broad range of high beta stocks and buying a broad range of low
beta stocks involving higher transaction costs.
For these reasons, the switch to a defensive portfolio would typically involve
simultaneous recourse to several, may be all, the above techniques of beta reduction.
Similarly, a switch to a high beta portfolio may require simultaneous recourse to several
options: switch away from bonds and money market instruments to stocks, borrow and
invest in stocks, rebalance the portfolio in favor of high beta stocks, maintain an
overbought position in the forward market.
This analysis places the money market asset class also in a new light. Since it has very
low beta and duration, this asset class can be used very effectively as an instrument for
changing the duration and beta of the total portfolio in response to changing needs. The
money market portfolio is one of the instruments for shifting temporarily to a defensive
portfolio. It can also play an important role in rebalancing the beta and duration of the
portfolio quickly in response to the change in market values discussed earlier in this
section. Here too the money market portfolio is used temporarily in a balancing role
while a more permanent rebalancing is worked out. The important point, however, is that
the money market portfolios is not seen as just as a repository of idle cash; it is market
portfolio is not seen as just as a repository of idle cash; it is an active element in the
management of the risk of the total portfolio.
Formula Plans
The management of the temporary changes in portfolio beta and duration by adjusting its
composition is known as tactical asset allocation. A number of mechanical rules have
been evolved to simplify this process. These rules seek to replace the subjective
judgment of the investor by formulas. Their principal advantage is that they are
completely unemotional; they prevent the investor from being swayed by sentiment and
thereby getting into a very risky position.
The two most popular formula plans are the Constant Ratio Plan and the Constant
Value Plan. As the name suggests, the constant ratio plan tries to keep a certain constant
percentage of the portfolio in equities. For example, the plan may specify that 60% must
be in equities and allow a 5% band for fluctuations. This means that if equity prices rise
and the equity portfolio rises to 65% of the total, then we must sell equities to bring the
ratio down to 60%. Similarly, if equity prices fall and the ratio drops to 55%, then we
282
must buy equities to bring the ratio up to 60%. The width of the band clearly determines
the extent of trading that takes place. If we set too narrow a band, we will be buying and
selling at almost every fall or rise in the market index and we will make money only for
our broker. If we set too large a band, we can stray too far away from the desired ratio.
The constant value plan on the other hand demands that a constant value be invested in
equities. We might start with a portfolio of Rs.100 with Rs.60 in equities and Rs.40 in
bonds. The constant value may say that we must have rs.60 in equities with a band of
Rs.5 to bring it up to Rs.60. this is more stringent than the earlier example of the
constant ratio plan; if equities have dropped to Rs.55 and bonds are unchanged at Rs.40,
then the total portfolio is only Rs.95 and the ratio is 55/95 = 58%. This is higher than
55% and the constant ratio plan will not be triggered.
Several modifications and combinations of these two plans are also available for those
who seek to make tactical asset allocation almost automatic. The better way of looking at
these plans is as aids to our judgment. Rather than blindly follow these plans, we should
treat the recommendation of these plans as buy and sell signals which we evaluate using
our judgment and view of the market.
Portfolio Insurance
In western capital markets, there is an alternative to defensive portfolios if one wants
protection against market slumps. Known as portfolio insurance, this technique lets the
investor protect himself against downward movements in prices while continuing to
benefit from upward movements. There are two routes to portfolio insurance:
1.
In developed economies, there are options markets where the investor can
buy put options. The put option allows the investor the right but not the
obligation to sell a security at a prespecified price at a prespecified date. If the
market goes down, the investor exercises the put option to get out of the scrip
without much loss. If the price goes up, the option is not exercised, and the
investor can obtain the benefit of the higher price. In India, organized options
markets do not exist as of now, but there is a distinct possibility of their being
permitted in the next few years. What is available in India is an informal tejimandi market in which a narrow range of very short term options are traded. This
market is unlikely to be of much use for portfolio insurance purposes.
2.
The second route to portfolio insurance does not use options markets, but
relies on a dynamic hedging strategy implemented using program trading.
This method typically involves using a computer program to generate
trades designed to artificially replicate the effect of a put option. Program
trading has come under a cloud in the United States after the crash of
October 1987. In any case, its practicability and efficacy in Indian
conditions has never been demonstrated.
283
Scrip Selection
Having determined the desired beta of our equity portfolio, the next task is that of
constructing a well-diversified portfolio with that level of beta. In theory, the most
perfectly diversified portfolio is the one which contains every security traded in the stock
market. Such perfection, however, is only an ideal, not to be achieved in real life1 . In
practice, one needs a much smaller number of securities to achieve a very high degree of
diversification: 15-20 securities may often be adequate, though large institutional
investors may use 40-100 securities. But care must be taken to ensure that the securities
one chooses are spread over several industries. Excessive dependence on any one
business group or geographic region must also be avoided. Within these limits, the
investor has considerable leeway in choosing a diversified portfolio.
In addition to diversification, there are two other factors to be considered in designing a
portfolio. First is the issue of market timing to which we have devoted a section earlier.
Market timing requires us to temporarily shift to offensive or defensive portfolios
depending on our view of the market. Second, in the chapters on fundamental and
technical analysis, we have discussed the various methods that analysts use to determine
whether a stock is under or overvalued. One expects undervalued stocks to rise and
overvalued. One expects undervalued stocks to rise and overvalued stocks to fall as the
market corrects itself. Obviously, scrip selection must use this information. The
undervalued stocks are to be sought and the overvalued one is to be shunned. But again
there is a danger: the analyst may identify two or three stocks that are very good buy and
may invest heavily in them. The resulting portfolio may be very poorly diversified. This
is a danger that portfolio theory teaches us to avoid.
To see how these two factors influence the scrip selection problem, we now look at four
types of investors and examine the portfolio design approaches suitable for each of them.
In many foreign capital markets, it is possible to buy index contracts which give
the investor the same return as what he would have got by investing in the entire market
portfolio. Index contracts are not available in India, but some investors use UTI
Mastershares and similar instruments as surrogates for an index contract.
284
285
2.
The more sophisticated approach looks at the average quality of the bond
portfolio. The overall risk aversion of the investor determines the desired
average quality of the total portfolio. But it is not necessary that all bonds
be of this quality. Some lower grade bonds may be bought if the rest of
the portfolio is of sufficiently higher grade to maintain the average quality.
286
The second approach requires greater skill and effort, but it provides the route to higher
returns. It allows the investor to choose the mix of bonds which provides the highest
YTM while still achieving the target quality level.
Thus the bond portfolio selection problem has three aspects:
1. The portfolio duration must equal the duration of the outflows.
2. The average quality of the portfolio (in terms of the credit rating) must not fall
below the acceptable level.
3. Within these two constraints, the high yielding bonds must be chosen to
maximize the YTM of the portfolio
All this does not eliminate the need for active management of the bond portfolio.
Duration matching eliminates the interest rate risk, but it is a continuous process rather
than a one shot activity. There are several reasons why the duration of a portfolio may
change:
1. Duration wandering is a phenomenon in which as time passes, the duration of
a portfolio changes slowly.
2. Large changes in interest rates can change the duration.
3. Normal trading activity in the portfolio may change its duration.
To take care of all these factors, it is necessary to recompute the portfolio duration at
frequent intervals. Whenever a substantial discrepancy is found, steps must be taken to
rebalance the portfolio to achieve the desired duration.
Finally, Just as in the case of equity portfolios we can shift the beta temporarily to exploit
our forecast of market trends, we can temporarily change the duration of our bond
portfolio to take advantage of our forecasts of interest rate trends. If we expect interest
rates to rise, we must switch towards low duration assets. Conversely, a switch to high
duration assets is mandated if we expect interest rates to fall.
287
In this book, we have, so far, discussed how to design and revise our portfolios. What
remains now is the bottom line how well has the portfolio done? This chapter deals
with the evaluation of portfolio performance.
There are a number of situations in which such an evaluation becomes necessary and
important:
1.
2.
3.
4.
While these situations differ in the objective of evaluation and in the extent of
information available, the general method of evaluation is the same for all of them. The
discussion in this chapter would be of use in all these situations. We shall use the term
portfolio manager to refer to the person responsible for taking decisions regarding the
portfolio. In the case of self evaluation discussed above, the investor should for the
purpose of this chapter be regarded as his own portfolio manager.
288
3.
We can try to evaluate the performance of the portfolio as a whole during the
period without examining the performance of individual securities within the
portfolio.
In practice, it is quite common to find people use the transaction view or the security
view while evaluating themselves or their subordinates. However, these methods though
intuitively appealing are inadequate and often misleading. Consider, for example, a
hypothetical situation where we are sitting in the training room watching two portfolio
managers place sell orders. A is selling stock X for Rs.80; he tells us that he bought the
stock a month ago at Rs.64. Mentally, we make a quick calculation: A has made a return
of 25%. Meanwhile, B is selling stock Y for Rs.72; this stock had cost him Rs.60 a
month ago. We calculate that the return is only 20%. We decide that A has done better
than B but keep our thoughts to ourselves. We come back to the trading room a month
later to find on PTI-SCAN that stock X is now selling at Rs.90 and stock Y at Rs.55. B
walks up to us and tells us how right he was to sell the stock before it started falling. We
then turn to A to remind him that stock X has risen 12.5% since he sold it. He
nonchalantly tells us that he has not been keeping his money idle and that his recent
acquisitions have appreciated even more steeply. We are left wondering whether this is
just a case of sour grapes or whether A has really been doing well.
If we think through this example carefully, we will realize that the important notion is
that of opportunity costs. The book profits that A and B made when they sold their
respective stocks is easy to calculate. The difficulty arises with opportunity costs. By
selling stock X when it was still rising, A has missed the opportunity to earn an even
higher return than he did. B, on the other hand, has avoided a large opportunity loss by
selling just before the stock fell. The opportunity cost becomes tricky when A tries to
argue that he has not suffered an opportunity loss at all because the stocks that he bought
after selling X have done equally well if not better. As argument, in fact, strikes at the
very root of the transaction view. He is telling us not to look at the transaction in
isolation, but to look at his portfolio in its entirety.
We shall shortly turn to the portfolio view, but the notion of opportunity costs is an
important one for all portfolio managers. There is a deep-rooted tendency among most
investors to ride their losses and book their profits. They feel comfortable selling a stock
on which they are making a book profit. They feel uneasy selling a stock if it means
incurring a book loss, and, therefore, tend to carry the stock in their portfolio in the hope
that it will some day appreciate in value. This argument is totally fallacious. In the
process of avoiding a book loss now, they may incur a large opportunity loss; in other
words, the stock may decline further causing an even greater loss in future.
The notion of opportunity loss has helped us realize the advantage of the portfolio view.
There is a second major reason for taking the portfolio view, and that is the issue of risk.
We know very well that higher return can be has if we are willing to accept higher risk.
When we say that A earned a return of 25% on stock X while B earned 20% on stock Y,
we need to look at the riskiness of these securities to evaluate these returns. The
289
difficulty is that risk is best defined at the portfolio level not at the security level. We
know that a large part of the riskiness of a security can be diversified away by holding it
in a well-designed portfolio. As we saw in the previous chapter on portfolio design,
however, investors who seek out underprices stocks may end up with poorly diversified
portfolios. To evaluate the return that they make, we must examine the riskiness of the
total portfolio.
290
Solution
Rs. lakhs
Portfolio Value as on 31.12.1991
Portfolio value as on 01.01.1991
28.50
25.00
------3.50
Appreciation in value
Add interest and dividends withdrawn for
Personal use
Capital withdrawn for house construction
1.50
5.00
------10.00
====
The actual return has to be evaluated by comparison to a benchmark taking risk into
account. The benchmark rate of return is that of the market as a whole which represents
the average performance of all investors taken together. Superior performance then
means performing better than the market index after adjusting for risk. The different
methods of evaluating portfolio performance that we shall discuss below differ mainly in
the method used for adjusting for risk.
The total risk of a portfolio is measured by the variance or the standard deviation. We
have seen earlier in this book that this total risk can be broken up into systematic risk and
unsystematic risk. The unsystematic risk can be eliminated by holding a diversified
portfolio. On the other hand, the systematic risk measured by the beta cannot be
diversified away because it represents the vulnerability to market fluctuations.
291
Treynor measures are quite similar in these respects; they, however, differ in their
definition of risk.
Treynor defines risk as being the unsystematic risk or beta. His measure of performance
is the risk premium per unit of systematic risk (beta). To compute this measure, we must
first estimate the beta of the portfolio. This is done in exactly the same way as for
individual securities as described earlier in this book. Then we divide the risk premium
by the beta to get the Treynor measure.
Example .2
Mr. P has been managing the portfolio of a large mutual fund for the last two years. He
found that his portfolio had earned a return of 70.60% and had a beta of 1.121. During
the same period, the return on the market as a whole was 41.40%. Assuming that the
risk-free rate was 12%, compute the Treynor measure for the portfolio and comment on
Ps performance according to this measure. Show the result graphically.
Solution
The risk premium for Ps portfolio is 70.60 12.00 = 58.60. The Treynor measure is
therefore 58.60/1.121 = 52.3%.
To comment on how well P has done, we compare this value of 52.3% with the Treynor
measure for the market. Since the market, by definition, has a beta of 1.0, its Treynor
measure is (41.40 12.00)/1.0 = 29.4%. This means that P has earned 52.3% per unit of
risk borne while the market as a whole earned only 29.4% per unit of risk borne. This
makes it clear that P has significantly outperformed the market.
292
As stated earlier, Sharpe argued that the appropriate measure of risk is not the systematic
risk (beta) but the total risk (standard deviation). The Sharpe measure of performance is,
therefore, the risk premium earned per unit of total risk. The compute this measure, we
must first compute the standard deviation of the returns and divide the risk premium of
the portfolio by its standard deviation.
293
________________________________________________________________________
Example 3
Mr. P of Example 2 finds that the standard deviation of returns on his portfolio is 41.3%
while that of the market as a whole is 19.44%. Compute the Sharpe measure for Ps
portfolio and comment on his performance according to this measure. Portray the result
graphically.
Solution
As in example 2, the risk premium earned by Mr. P is 58.60%. The Sharpe measure of
his portfolio is 58.60/41.31 = 1.418.
For the market, the Sharpe measure is 41.40 12.00)/19.44 = 1.512. The Sharpe measure
thus indicates that P has not done as well as the market.
We portray the situation graphically, plotting return on the vertical axis and total risk on
the horizontal axis. The line joining the risk-free rate to the market (M) is the Capital
Market Line discussed earlier in the book. It indicates the relationship between return
and total risk for all well-diversified portfolios. It can be seen that Ps portfolio lies
below the CML indicating that it has earned less than what is required for its level of total
risk.
294
Why do the Sharpe and Treynor measure give opposite results in the case of Mr. P? The
reason is that Ps portfolio has a disproportionate amount of unsystematic risk; it looks
like a poorly diversified portfolio. Hence a measure which uses total risk gives a result
very different from one which uses only systematic risk. What do we do in a situation
like this? Does it mean that one of the measures is wrong? The answer is that both
measures are right, but they are relevant in different contexts. In our situation where the
portfolio is a mutual fund, the appropriate measure to use depends on the type of investor.
For those investors who use Ps mutual fund as the principal vehicle for investment in
equity, there is no scope for diversifying away the large unsystematic risk. The relevant
measure is the Sharpe measure which indicates that P has not done as well a s the market.
On the other hand, consider an investor who holds a large portfolio of shares and is
considering adding some units of Ps fund to it just as if it were another security. For this
investor, the large unsystematic risk of the fund does not matter. It will be diversified
away when it is included in the investors total portfolio. For such an investor, what is
relevant is the systematic risk which cannot be diversified. The Treynor measure is
appropriate for this investor and this measure indicate that the mutual fund is very
attractive having significantly outperformed the market.
In general, we can say that to measure the performance of the total portfolio of an
investor, the Sharpe measure is always the right one. To measure the performance of a
sub-portfolio, the Treynor measure is correct provide the investor has taken reasonable
care to ensure that his total portfolio is well diversified.
In practice, however, in a large number of cases, the Sharpe and Treynor measure of
performance produce very similar rankings of portfolios; typically, therefore, they agree
on whether a particular portfolio has done better than the market or not. The situation of
disagreement which we found for Ps portfolio is the exception rather than the rule.
Excess Returns
The Sharpe and Treynor measures of performance are both ratios. This means that
though they can be used to rank portfolios, they are not readily interpretable in monetary
terms or in terms of percentage returns. Often, we would like to measure a portfolios
superior performance in terms of the extra return that it has earned beyond what was
mandated by its level of risk. If we know the size of the portfolio, we can then convert
this into a rupee amount as saying that the portfolio managers efforts were worth so
much of money in extra return earned.
This kind of performance measurement is also possible using the SML and CML
diagrams that we have shown in Examples 2 and 3 what we are now looking at is the
vertical distance of the portfolio from the SML and from the CML.
If we take beta or systematic risk as the appropriate measure of risk, then the SML
indicates the return that a portfolio should earn for any given level of risk. The difference
between that and the actual return is a measure of the excess return that has been earned
over and above what is mandated for its level of systematic risk. This performance
measure is known as Jensens measure after its originator.
295
Example 4
From fig 1 and the data in Example 2 compute the Jensen measure of Ps performance.
Solution
In Fig. 1 we see that portfolio Ps beta of 1.121 mandated a return of only 44.95% while
it actual return was 70.60%. P, therefore, lies above the SML, and the vertical distance
from the SML to P is 25.65% (i.e. 70.60 44.95). This is the excess return (Jensen
measure) that P has earned after adjusting for systematic risk.
We can compute the Jensen measure numerically without drawing a graph, as follows.
We multiply the beta of the portfolio by the risk premium of the market and add the result
to the risk-free rate to get the return mandated by the SML. For portfolio P this gives
12.00 +1.121 (41.40 12.00) = 44.95%. The Jensen measure is then found by
subtracting this return from the actual return on the portfolio: 70.60 44.95 = 25.65%.
________________________________________________________________________
The Jensen measure was based on systematic risk and therefore looked at the SML. If we
are interested in total risk we can look at the distance from the CML instead of from the
SML. The vertical distance from the portfolio to the CML is Famas measure of net
selectivity. It represents the excess return earned over and above the return required for
its level of total risk.
________________________________________________________________________
Example 5
From Fig 2 and the data in Example 3 compute the Fama measure of net selectivity for
Ps performance.
Solution
In Fig 2, we see that portfolio Ps total risk of 41.31% mandated a return of 74.47% while
its actual return was 70.60%. P, therefore, lies below the SML, and the vertical distance
from the SML to P is -3.87% (i.e. 70.60 74.47). This is the Fame measure of net
selectivity for P. Since it is negative, P has underperformed the market by 3.87%.
We can compute the Fama measure of net selectivity numerically without drawing a
graph as follows. We first compute the ratio of the standard deviation of the portfolio to
that of the market. For Ps portfolio this ratio is 41.31/19.44 = 2.125. We then multiply
this ratio by the risk premium of the market and add the result to the risk-free rate to get
the return mandated by the CML. This gives 12.00 + 2.125(41.40 12.00) = 74.47%.
296
The Fama measure of net selectivity is then found by subtracting this return from the
actual return on the portfolio:
70.60 74.47 = - 3.87%.
________________________________________________________________________
Again the two measures (Jensen and Famas net selectivity) give opposite results. The
reason for and the interpretation of this divergence is exactly the same as that for the
divergence between the Sharpe and Treynor measures. In other words, Famas net
selectivity measure is appropriate in cases where the portfolio under question is the total
portfolio of the investor. Jensens measure is appropriate when we are looking at subportfolios of a larger (well-diversified) portfolio.
The Fama approach can be used to give a complete break-up of the observed return in
terms of its various components. For Ps portfolio, this break-up will be as follows:
1. Risk-free return
2. Compensation for systematic risk(beta)
1.121 (41.40 12.00)
3. Compensation for inadequate diversification
Return mandated by CML
74.47%
Less return mandated by SML 44.95%
4. Net selectivity
12.00%
32.95%
29.52%
- 3,87%
---------Total Actual Return
70.60%
======
The Jensen measure can be recovered from this break-up by adding together the last two
elements (viz., the net selectivity and the compensation for inadequate diversification) to
give 29.52 3.87 = 25.65%.
From evaluation to Correction.
As we noted in the very beginning of this chapter, one important reason for doing
performance evaluation is to help us in correcting our errors and improving our
performance over a period of time. (If we are evaluating somebody else and not
ourselves, this is not relevant; the corrective action may simply consist of replacing the
portfolio manager). How do the performance evaluation measures discussed so far
provide us with a basis for such an exercise of self improvement?
The Fama framework provides a very convenient tool for this purpose. A simple
comparison of the return on Ps portfolio (70.60%) with that of the market (41.40%)
would indicate that P has significantly outperformed the market. Famas measure of net
selectivity indicates that, on the contrary, the return was 3.87% less than what it should
have been. The Fama analysis indicates what has gone wrong. The first two components
of the Fama decomposition specified above tell us what the position was in terms of
systematic risk. The beta of P (1.121) was a little higher than that of the market (1.00)
297
warranting a return of 12.00 + 32.95 = 44.95% marginally higher than the markets
41.40. but the actual return earned by P of 70.60 is far higher than this. The real problem
is in the third component the compensation required for Ps poor diversification is a
whopping 29.52%; this is what turns the tables on P making his performance somewhat
mediocre. The portfolio manager should now know what to do with such a portfolio: the
unsystematic risk of the portfolio needs to be brought down. Throughout this book,
particularly in the chapter on portfolio design, we have talked of the dangers of seeking
excess returns at the cost of diversification and the steps required to avoid it. The Fama
decomposition pinpoints the source of the problem and now it is up to Mr. P to correct it.
In other cases, the Fama decomposition may indicate that the problem is one of excessive
beta. The portfolio manager would then have to examine whether he has been allowing
his beta to exceed the target value decided by him on the basis of his attitude towards
risk.
In yet other cases, the analysis may show that the problem is not due to risk but to the
return itself being inadequate. Further investigation may reveal that the poor return may
have been caused by high operating costs. For example, the portfolio may have been
turned around too often leading to very high brokerage and other transaction costs. This
may indicate the need for a less active portfolio management strategy. Alternatively, the
return may have been low because of poor stock selection. This may mean that the
portfolio manager needs to revise his knowledge of fundamental and technical analysis,
firm and industry analysis, etc.
In short, with performance evaluation, the wheel has turned a full circle and we are back
to the essentials of portfolio management with which we started this book. As we
approach the end of this book at this point, we would like to remind our readers that the
wheel never stops. The path to superior performance lies in a continual refinement of
skills with regular evaluation of performance to tell us how far we have come and how
far we need to go.
298
LEARNING UNIT - V
PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
[Reading Material]
299
Learning Unit - 5
Reading Material
Introduction :
To a common man, there is little difference between investing in shares and gambling.
This is true to some extent, because of the difficulties in predicting future trends in the
stock market. Many take risk by investing in shares based on analysis and reasoning.
The present situation in India is that individual investors have to compete with
professional and organized investors like bank sponsored mutual funds. In order to enable
them to take rational decisions, it is absolutely necessary for them to understand Portfolio
Management.
The main focus of analysis of Portfolio Management will be on forecasting security
prices. For this purpose it is necessary to understand the functioning of stock exchanges
in India.
In Learning Unit 2 we have discussed the use of Discounted Cash Flow Technique
(DCFT). DCFT is used to calculate the present value of future returns on share.
A technical analyst or a chartist may analyze stock prices based on the psychological
factors i.e., on mood of the crowd rather than on the reputation, earnings per share ratio,
dividends etc., this method often called as technical analysis
Most investors invest in several securities rather than on a single security. This kind of
diversification of investments reduces the variability of returns. This is the basis of
Modern Portfolio Theory.
Bonds or debentures have a definite income when compared to shares. The only threat
for this definite income is change in the interest rate or default in payment of principal or
interest or both.
The income return will be calculated in terms of present value.
Convertible debentures are a mix of the characteristics of a share and a debenture. In
India, this is more popular as a financial resource.
For any given single security, one should estimate the return as well as the risk. But in
portfolio management the situation are as follows:
300
When profits are received on securities taxes have to be paid as per the existing laws.
After designing a portfolio, the market movements must be analyzed. The risk estimated,
must be commensurate with the movement of the market.
301
In this learning unit, group activities will be given for participants to acquire further skills
in calculating PV of returns.
Perpetuity
The cash flow at constant level at fixed periodic intervals without a time limit is called
perpetuity. For example, to get constant returns of Rs.1000 per year at interest rate of
10% one has to make one time deposit of Rs.10, 000.
Annuity
Annuity is a series of constant cash flows for a fixed time span. For example, constant
repayment in case of housing loan.
Stock Exchange
Stock Exchange is a place where securities are bought and sold. Therefore, it is also
called capital market. To raise money in the market the entrepreneurs may float the
shares, debentures or bonds in large number of small units. Any person may buy or sell
such securities in the stock exchange.
Earlier, brokers formed associations to facilitate the buying and selling of securities.
Through these associations they are undertaking their own activities, or on behalf of
others on a commission basis.
Gradually, these associations grew into corporate
agencies.
In India, we have 19 stock exchanges out of which the Bombay Stock Exchange is the
largest accounting unit for 80% of transactions in India.
The stock exchange consists of nominated members by Government of India and the
elected members among the member brokers. The President and the Executive Director
are responsible to see that the activities at stock exchange are carried out in accordance
with the rules and regulations issued by Government.
SEBI has been formed to ensure that stock exchanges function in an orderly manner.
Every company wishing to raise capital shall list their securities on at least one of the
stock exchanges in the country.
The primary market deals with the issue of new securities. The secondary market deals
with old/existing securities. On maturity, bonds or debentures can be redeemed in the
primary market. Or, before maturity bonds or debentures can be sold in the secondary
market. But the shares can be sold only in the secondary market.
New securities can only be purchased in the primary market, by using application form
with application money. In case of over subscription of shares, allotment will be made
on seniority or by lottery.
302
Market Order
An investor may place his transactions with a broker without specifying the price. Such
order of placing transaction without specifying the price is called market order. It is the
responsibility of the broker to protect the interest of the investor.
An investor may specify the minimum price level in case of selling or specify the
maximum price in case of purchasing securities. This is called limit order. If the investor
specifies that the broker must make the transaction at the days opening price, it is called
open order.
After the transaction is over, the broker will intimate the details to his client.
Lots
In Stock Exchanges the trading of securities must take place in a smooth manner.
Therefore, each company must prescribe limits in terms of the number and variety of
securities, amount and duration. Often this is called market lot. Other than market lot,
sessions will be held for trading securities, known as odd lot. Normally, it is more
beneficial for an investor to participate in a 'market lot' session, rather than in an odd lot'
session.
Ring
Collective Assessments are made in Stock Exchanges at fixed hours. Brokers make
investments on behalf of the investors or the investors themselves make the investments.
If there is healthy competition, there will be a perfect market to determine the price level
of different shares.
Trading in shares
Shares are of two categories
?
?
Specified and
Cash
The shares which are activity traded will be listed under the specified list.
Securities
like, preference shares, debentures and convertible debentures are listed under the cash
category.
Settlements
The dates for settlement of shares will be fixed by the Stock Exchange. On the first date,
all the outstanding transactions will be settled. Thereafter, securities will be traded for
cash. Alternatively, both the seller and the buyer may agree to defer the settlement of
transactions to the next settlement date. Normally this is known as settlement trading.
303
The other kind of settlement, also prevailing in our system, is called short-time
settlement, where transactions have to be settled within 48 hours.
Buying a Share
One will purchase a share at the existing market price, expecting that its price will rise in
the future. If however, one does not have enough cash to purchase these shares, one may
purchase the shares under the settlement system, described below.
The price as it exists on the settlement date, also known as settlement price. (the
price at the last hour to be considered)
Purchase price
There may be two possibilities on the settlement day, namely, (i) the settlement price is
higher than the purchase price, (ii) the settlement price is lower than the purchase price.
In the first case both the buyer and the seller may forward the transactions. The seller
accommodates the buyer to the extent of the difference between the settlement price and
the purchase price, and also provides time to make cash payment. The buyer must
compensate the seller in terms of interest. This is known as Contango or Forwardation
charge.
In the second situation, the purchase price is higher than the settlement price. In this
case, the buyer will pay the difference. The transactions price will be based on the
settlement price. The buyer shall pay the Forwardation charges.
Selling
If a share holder anticipates a fall in the price of a share, he would like to sell before the
price drops. He may even sell a share which he does not have. This may be done under
the Settlement System. When the settlement price is lower than the selling price, the
buyer has to pay the difference and the Forwardation charges. If the settlement price is
more than selling price, the difference will be paid by the seller and the seller receives the
Forwardation charges.
304
Backwardation Charge
So far we have noticed that, the Forwardation charge shall be paid by the buyer to the
seller. The other kind of situation may be possible, where the seller has to pay to the
buyer. This is called backwardation charge. When the buyer has got sufficient cash to
purchase shares, but the seller not in a position to deliver the Share Certificate, then the
seller has to pay backwardation charge on the settlement date, towards postponing the
delivery of Share Certificates.
Faceless
If shares sales and purchases are done through brokers, the sellers and purchasers may
not come into contact with each other on the settlement date, and the transaction is stated
to be 'faceless'.
Good deliveries
To consider a security as good delivery, it must have the following details:
Date of certification
305
When prospective investor applies for shares a company may ask the investor to pay
some part, say 50%, upfront, and the remaining in suitable installments. When the
company calls for payment within the stipulated date, it must be complied with
immediately. Otherwise it will amount to a bad delivery.
Kerb
Unofficial transactions that take place outside or inside the stock exchange, and are not
reported to stock exchange are called Kerb Trading. The prices quoted in such Kerb
trading are called Kerb price.
Speculation
The demand and supply theory of economics will work on the movement of the price of
the security in the market. The problem of speculation sets in where there are large scale
transactions or volatile fluctuations in purchases and sales with reference to a particular
security. Especially, take over bid i.e., one who wants to purchase large quantities of a
particular share, will cause a steep rise in share price, because the increase in the value of
the share will cause others to enter the fray and purchase the same share. Sometimes the
staff of a company, based on some inside information may resort to heavy buying of
shares with a view to manipulating the stock market.
The major stock portion of shares is generally in the hands of financial institutions and
the other controlling groups. In some cases this may as high as 80%. The remaining
portion of shares may be in the hands of the public. If such financial institutions
purchase or sell the shares in large quantities, it will add to fluctuations in the share price
and the general public will have no control over it.
Other factors, including the legal compulsion of multiple listing i.e., listing of shares in
more than one Stock Exchange, and the sudden flow of excessive money in the share
market like mutual funds, NRI funds etc., will also cause a steep rise in share prices.
Curbing of speculation
Default risk is a factor associated with excessive speculation. Stock Exchange authorities
may adopt the following measures to reduce the default risk.
306
The
A relative analysis has to be made between the earnings per share (P/E) and the market
price of share. The earnings per share to be taken into account is based on average
payment of dividend for the past fixed period. It should be compared with the current
growth rate in dividend per share. This should also be compared with the existing market
307
price of the share. The average of the past fixed period of earning per share shall not be
below the current earnings dividend per share. Again, there must be a higher gap
between the market price of a share and the current earnings of dividend per share. Any
analysis based on perfect stock exchange market may not be realistic. This is because
perfect stock exchange is based on the assumptions that information is perfect and timely,
that customers are rational, and that there are no manipulations, etc.
Assessing the future profitability of a firm is one of key factors to estimate the expected
return to shareholder.
The investor is advised to always look into the historical data of the company under
selected indicators. He should collect and analyze the market trends of shares, and list out
the strengths and weakness of the company. He should concentrate on and analyze the
circumstances under which movement of price have taken place. He should try to
anticipate situations that may repeat in the future. He should identify the impact of
changed policies at different levels, as well as the realities of competition and the effect
of changing technologies on the company's performance. In short the investor must
examine the company's activities from all sides by considering all factors.
Bonus Issue
A firm may provide a bonus issue by transferring surplus reserves (retained profits) to
share capital by book adjustment. Such a bonus issue will cause a rise in the number of
shares and reduction in Dividend Per Share.
One of the major reasons for issuing bonus issue is to reduce the extremely hiked
market price of a Share and to enable the people to purchase shares and thereby enlarge
the share capital base.
Rights Issues
Whenever fresh shares are issued, the existing shareholders have a right to subscribe to
new shares in proportion to their existing share holdings. Convertible debenture holders
also have a similar right. Such rights of existing holders are known as rights issue.
Cum-Rights Price
The cum-rights price means the price of the security before the right-issue is known.
Ex-rights price:
The ex-rights price means the price after the rights issue.
308
Capital Appreciation
The contribution made by capital appreciation to a share, sometimes, may be more than
the contribution of dividends to share.
Economics
The profitability of a firm will be influenced by the following factors.
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
g)
h)
i)
j)
All these factors, apart from influencing the profitability, also influence a firms shares.
Most of these factors will have uncertainties both in the long-run and as well as in the
short run. The investors normally focus on the uncertainties of the factors in the shortrun. Therefore technical analysts argue that the movement in share prices will be
influenced by the psychological factors rather than the economic factors. The technical
analyst use a line chart, described below.
Line Chart
A Line Chart is prepared on the following points:
The Dow Theory developed by Prof. Charles Dow depends on averages, which will
reflect the following three kinds of trends:
309
Indicators :
It is very difficult to guess the behavior of the market in the long run. To some extent
one can expect what may happen in the short-run or in the near future based on the
volume of transactions read with the price.
A. The first possibility is rising price with rising transactions
B. Falling prices with rising transactions.
C. Rising price with falling transactions.
D. Falling prices and entry of new securities
The price of the securities may always move between the support level and the
resistance level. The highest value and the lowest value will be resistance and
support level.
310
Buying may increase when price moves towards the support level and selling may
increase when the price move towards the resistance level. Sometimes over a period
newer levels may also possible.
The difference between the closing price of a share of a previous day and the opening
price of a share of a current day is called gap. The greater the gap with higher
opening price, the higher the willingness to pay. A lower opening price or a minus
opening price shows higher willingness to sell.
Whatever may be outcomes of the theoretical calculations the fate of a share
depends on the responsiveness as a unique indicator. This is because most
of the theoretical calculations have their own limitations. The major
limitation is that outcomes of the theoretical calculations may be true in
short run but not in the long run. Even in the short run, actual may vary
from the expectations at higher proportions. The assumption of market
efficiency based on perfectness by the Technical Analysis is highly
unrealistic.
311
This is know as the beta co-efficient of the security. That means, the return on a
security depends on the risk measured by this beta.
The risk of investment in each security in terms of variations may be calculated in
terms of percentage and then one security may be compared with the other. Such
comparison may help the investor to decide how much he has to invest and in which
security.
The expected return on each security may be arrived by means of weighted average.
The comparison of estimation of risk and return of each security will place an
investor in a better position to decide the purchase of each quantum of
security, or not to make a purchase etc. The important point is that inspite
of all such efforts regarding diversified investment one cannot reduce the
risk to zero. The reality is that one has to accept the margin of market risk
or non-diversifiable risk. The selected number of securities from the
different industries is sufficient to analyze a market portfolio.
The non-diversifiable risk or market risk may involve with risk associated with the
fluctuations in the market index itself. The diversification will not eliminate the
market risk.
We know that risks are of two types, (i) Diversifiable risk, and (ii) Non-diversifiable
risk
Diversification of investments within an industry and diversification across several
industries are of two different types. But the focus will on the same .ie., reduction of
risk.
The non-diversifiable risk is also called as unavoidable risk and such risks cannot be
diversified, because the entire market will be affected by one factor for e.g., common
fiscal policy.
layer and the lower layer which may be called as an opportunity zone of
portfolio.
The Zero risk securities, like gilt edged securities, will have fixed income and this
will alter the opportunity zone of a portfolio, if combined with the other risk
associated securities.
313
3) Multiply the beta of each security with the decimals (of percentage of
investment of a security)
4) Add the result on each security as obtained in step-3. the total will be the beta
of the portfolio.
The financial experts will do the beta analysis. As individuals we may find it difficult to
do the beta analysis i.e., the effect on one variable (return on a security) because change
in other variable (market return).
The financial experts, depending on the price
situations, calculate the beta estimation on daily, weekly or monthly returns. They may
use shorter periods or longer periods to estimate the beta. They will give the reason for
using the specific length of period. While doing beta estimations, the exceptional price
movements need to be ignored.
Design
The investment portion may contain many asset classes, such as, equities, bonds, bullion.
PSU bonds, cash and money market instruments. Portfolio may contain cash also and
sometimes they may contain high liquid securities to enable the portfolio manager to
have flexibility in the transactions regarding buying and selling of scrips. This will
enable him get over the problem of balancing sales to purchases on day-to-day basis.
Some of the portfolio holders may hold a higher portion of bonds when compared to
shares from the point of view of stable source of income and when compared to
variations in the fortunes on shares.
The analysis which has been dealt so far will help us decide the allocation of funds to
invest in equities, bonds and money market instruments. The investment in equities will
depend on risk and return and on the beta factor. The risk on bond depends on changes in
interest rate. Such risk will be measured by duration. The default risk is also associated
with in case of individual bonds. However, since the beta sensitivity of bonds and money
market securities is extremely less, its risk factor in portfolio may ignore. Now the focus
in portfolio will only be on the equity. Therefore, the beta of every share, if added, will
be equal to the beta of total portfolio.
The shareholders are the real owners of the company. In case the company is to be
wound up, the share holders will be the last persons to get the money, if any. Therefore,
share equity is longest source and duration asset in the capital market. The change in the
interest rate may also affect the share price through PE ratio. It may alter the portfolio
structure more in favor of bonds when compared to the equity scrips.
Fluctuations in the stock market index show how the value of each portfolio will behave,
if such portfolio had a beta of one. Based on this an investor may choose a beta below
one or very near to one, but below one or equal to one or to be aggressive investor i.e., by
taking more risk, beta more than one. The stock market index will normally be, for 10
years. The return and risk varies directly. The baseline of zero risk security will be taken
314
as base and return above such zero risk security will be taken as base to expect returns on
the risk oriented securities. This will decide the desired level of beta.
The risk in bond is that of change in interest. If one holds bond upto its duration, the
interest rate risk will be equal to zero. The investor needs cash at different points of time.
This will influence duration of the holding period. Therefore in portfolio management an
investor needs to list out the cash needs at various points of time. This will have effect
on the cash inflows and cash outflows, sales and purchases of securities in a port folio.
An investor expects higher returns for larger duration.
Now we know that the duration and beta has got its effect on holding of different kinds of
assets and with what duration in a portfolio. It must also be noted that not only the
proportion of each class of assets will be get affected, but also composition of the
portfolios within each asset class will also be get affected.
The expected rate of return on the total portfolio will be influenced by the asset allocation
i.e., bonds, equity and money market instruments. Once we decide to take the risk, the
level of risk in the form of beta is the target beta. Beta is a vulnerability of return on
security with reference to changes in market returns.
Even after the determination of a target beta with duration, changes in market values with
higher velocity may alter the weights and averages of a security/s which may necessities
a rebalancing of portfolio.
An investor must necessarily be ready against the slump or boom in the market values.
Anticipating in advance, that is the market movements and exploiting it in the short run,
is a skill rather than luck.
To make quick realignments in beta and duration,
diversification shall be made to such an extent in a portfolio, preferably with adjustable
liquidity. We must keep out portfolio beta in and around the target value to make quick
adjustments, so that we can adopt defensive or an offensive portfolio. Defensive implies
protection against slump. Offensive implies taking advantage of a rising market. To
switch over this way or that way, an investor must have a clear plan - whether to sell or
purchase, how much, in what duration, in which class etc. A pre-determined plan with
lot of options will enable an investor to run an investment in proper gear. This is often
called as tactical asset allocation.
Portfolio design depends upon the following points:
Selection of industries
315
Mutual funds is the other source for an investor i.e., investing in mutual funds
and allow the mutual fund operator to do the portfolio management for him.
In portfolio design each asset component, has to be designed properly. In each asset
component, the level of each specific security has to be determined with reference to
market risk and interest rate risk. Once the level has been determined with duration
continuous rebalancing is required in response to forecasted market trends.
This is all about designing and revision of portfolios
Insurance
An investor may opt for portfolio insurance as protection against downward movement in
prices. Just as an investor can buy put options, the investor can sell a security at a prespecified price with pre-specified date. In case of downward trend, an investor may sell
accordingly with no or little loss. By this option, one cannot compel an investor to sell
when the prices are up. That means when prices are going up an investor may make
profit without any obligation.
One cannot have all the kinds of securities in a single portfolio. An investor may select
only a few securities for diversification in a portfolio. Only a regular financial institution
may choose large number securities for portfolio design.
Evaluation
Did everything happen according to our expectations? If not, what were reasons for the
differences between the actual and the estimations. Why did our estimation go wrong?
316
Answers have to be searched for above key questions in the process of evaluation of
portfolio performance. For this purpose every transaction has to be evaluated to ascertain
whether the decision regarding the purchase, sale, timing, duration, amount and return,
was profitable or not. To assess the necessity to continue a security in a portfolio,
evaluation is required. Finally portfolio as a whole has to be evaluated. The most
important point is that the evaluation must be timely. An appropriate period for the
portfolio evaluation must be determined. Otherwise the evaluation report is likely to be
misleading.
The evaluation report shall be used for corrections and refinement of portfolio structure.
(Acknowledgements to Professors S.K.Barua, V.Raghunathan and J.R.Varma for their
Book on Portfolio Management)
317
LEARNING UNIT - V
PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
[Instructions to Faculty]
318
Learning Unit 5
Instructions to faculty
Portfolio Management
General Instructions:
The faculty must give a detailed presentation on the topic for conceptual clarity. Faculty
may use visual aids Nos. 32-40 as given in this handout.
Types of stock market orders: market lots and odd lots, and the trade ring
Trading in the stock exchanges; settlement trading in specified shares
Share purchase on settlement basis or taking a long position
Backwardation/ Forwardation charge
Faceless transactions
Book closure and record dates
Good and bad deliveries
Kerb trading
Settlement trading
Speculation detection in the market and curbing of speculation.
Ratio analysis of balance sheets
Financial analysis and measures of risk with examples.
Technical Analysis and Charting.
Asset class: (i) Equities, (ii) Bonds, (iii) Cash and money market instruments
319
Visual aids
The visual aids Nos. 32 - 40 given below will help the faculty make a presentation on
portfolio management.
Meaning
Basic principles
Designing
Price movements
Financial performance
Decision on investment quantum
Asset allocation
Evaluation of portfolio performance
This visual aid will enable the faculty to introduce the subject of Portfolio management.
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
Stock exchange
Value based investing
Economy, Industry and Firm
Technical Analysis and Charting
Capital Asset Pricing
Portfolio Design
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
320
Stock Exchanges
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
Dividend Model
Trading positions and market efficiency
Estimates of return
PE computation
Sensitivity analysis
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
Economics
Economic analysis
Industry analysis
Firm specific analysis
Inflation
Interest rate.
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
321
Types of charts:
Dow Theory
Interpreting price patterns
Decisions using data analysis
Pitfalls in the interpretation of charts.
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
Asset Allocation
Asset Classes
Beta and Duration
Target Return Approach
Tactical and Strategic Asset Allocation
Market Timing
Portfolio Selection.
Faculty may refer to the information given in the Reading Material for Learning Unit 5.
Portfolio Evaluation
Time Horizon
Risk and Return
Reward per unit of Risk
Excess Returns
Correction
322
Group presentations must focus on the examples and solutions given in the articles
referred to.
While the group presentations are in progress faculty should encourage participants to
note down learning points, which should be consolidated/ summed up in the plenary.
323
DERIVATIVES
[ Group Activities ]
324
Learning Unit - 6
Group Activities
Derivatives
General Instructions:
Participants will work in four groups.
Each group will be required to read the material circulated as well as refer to relevant
material obtained library.
At the outset Faculty will make a presentation on this subject; the presentation followed
by discussion is likely to take 30 - 45 minutes.
In the section that follows, there is a brief note on the key concepts relating to
Derivatives. The note is followed by 10 questions, which participants should attempt to
answer after they have been discussed ni the groups. The objective of this exercise is to
enable the participants to gain a basic understanding of the concept of Derivatives.
The material circulated also includes two short case studies. Each group will be required
to study and discuss the cases, and seek solutions to the issues/questions listed thereunder.
Sufficient time will be made available for the group activities. At the end of the
discussion, participants will prepare visual aids on the key points. Group representatives
will make the presentation.
Each presentation will be followed by plenary discussion, which will be moderated by the
faculty. The presentations will be followed by consolidation of learning points.
Faculty will be available to assist participants during their group discussion, in case of
any doubts or problems.
The key concepts relating to derivative securities and corporate risk management are
listed below:
There are six reasons risk management might increase the value of a firm.
Risk management allows corporations (i) to increase their use of debt, (ii)
to maintain their capital budget over time, (iii) to avoid costs associated
with financial distress, (iv) to utilize their comparative advantages in
hedging
relative to the hedging ability of individual investors, (v) to
325
reduce both the risks and costs of borrowing by using swaps, and (vi) to
reduce the higher taxes that result from fluctuating earnings.
Derivatives are securities whose values are determined by the market price
or interest rate of some other security.
A hedge is a transaction which lowers risk. A natural hedge is a
transaction between two counterparties where both parties risks are
reduced.
Options are financial instruments that (i) are created by exchanges rather
than firms, (ii) are bought and sold primarily by investors, and (iii) are of
importance to both investors and financial managers.
The two primary types of options are (i) call options, which give the
holder the right to purchase a specified asset at a given price (the exercise,
or strike, price) for a given period of time, and (ii) put options, which give
the holder the right to sell an asset at given price for a given period of
time.
A call options exercise value is defined as the current price of the stock
less the strike price.
The three steps in risk management are as follows: (i) identify the risks
faced by the company, (ii) measure the potential impacts of these risks,
and (iii) decide how each relevant risk should be dealt with.
326
In most situations, risk exposure can be dealt with by one or more of the
following techniques: (i) transfer the risk to an insurance company, (ii)
transfer the function that produces the risk to a third party, (iii) purchase
derivative contracts, (iv) reduce the probability of occurrence of an
adverse event, (v) reduce the magnitude of the loss associated with an
adverse event, and (vi) totally avoid the activity that gives rise to the risk.
A perfect hedge occurs when the gain or loss on the hedged transaction
exactly off-sets the loss or gain on the unhedged position.
Questions:
1. Explain why finance theory, combined with well-diversified investors and homemade hedging might suggest that risk management should not add much value to
a company.
2. What is a natural hedge? Give some examples of natural hedges.
3. What is an option? A call option? A put option?
4. What are some factors which affect a call options value?
5. Describe how a risk-free portfolio can be created using stocks and options. How
can such a portfolio be used to help estimate a call options value?
6. What is the purpose of the Black-Scholes option Pricing Model? Explain what a
riskless hedge is and how the riskless hedge concept is used in the BlackScholes OPM.
7. Describe the effect of a change in each of the following factors on the value of a
call option:
(i) Stock price.
327
Pure risks.
Speculative risks.
Demand risks.
Input risks.
Financial risks.
Properly risks
Personnel risks
Environmental risks.
Liability risks.
Insurable risks.
Self-insurance.
Should a firm insure itself against all of the insurable risks it faces? Explain.
10. What is a futures contract?
v Explain how a company can use the futures market to hedge against rising
interest rates.
v What is a swap? Describe the mechanics of a fixed rate to floating rate
swap.
v Explain how a company can use the futures market to hedge against rising
raw materials prices.
v How should derivatives be used in risk management? What problems can
occur?
328
returned from an Industry Corporate Executive Conference in San Francisco, and one of
the sessions he attended was on the pressing need for smaller companies to institute
corporate risk management programs. Since at one of Tropical Sweets is familiar with
the basics of derivatives and corporate risk management, Yamaguchi has asked you to
prepare a brief report that the firms executives could use to gain at least a cursory
understanding of the topics.
To begin, you gathered some outside materials on derivatives and corporate risk
management and used these materials to draft a list of pertinent questions that need to be
answered. In fact, one possible approach to the paper is to use a question and answer
format. Now that the questions have been drafted, you have to develop the answers.
a. Why might stockholders be indifferent whether or not a firm reduces the volatility
of its cash flows?
b. What are six reasons risk management might increase the value of a corporation?
c. What is an option? What is the single most important characteristic of an option ?
d. Options have a unique set of terminology. Define the following terms: (1) Call
option (2) Put option (3) Exercise price (4) Striking, or strike, price (5) Option
price (6) Expiration date (7) Exercise value (8) Covered option (9) Naked option
(10) In-the- money call (11) Out of the money call (12) LEAP
e. Consider Tropical Sweets call option with a $ 25 strike price. The following table
contains historical values for this option at different stock prices:
Stock price
$ 25
30
35
40
45
50
(1) Create a table which shows (a) stock price, (b) strike price, (c) exercise value,
(d) option price, and (e) the premium of option price over exercise value.
(2) What happens to the premium of option price over exercise value as the stock
price rises? Why?
f. In 1973, Fischer Black and Myron Scholes developed the Black-Scholes Option
Pricing Model (OPM).
(1) What assumptions underlie the OPM?
(2) Write out the three equations that constitute the model.
329
(3) What is the value of the following call option according to the OPM?
Stock Price = $ 27.00
Exercise Price = 25.00
Time to expiration = 6 months
Risk-free rate= 6.0%
Stock return variance= 0.11
g. What impact does each of the following call option parameters have on the value
of a call option?
(1) Current stock price
(2) Exercise price
(3) Options term to maturity
(4) Risk-free rate
(5) Variability of the stock price.
h. What is corporate risk management? Why is it important to all firms?
i.
What is financial risk exposure? Describe the following concepts and techniques
that can be used to reduce financial risks:
(1) Derivatives
(2) Futures markets
(3) Hedging
(4) Swaps
m. Describe how commodity futures markets can be used to reduce input price risk.
330
331
332
DERIVATIVES
[ Reading Materials ]
333
Learning Unit - 5
Reading Material
Derivatives
Introduction:
Asset/s that derives its/their value from other assets is known as derivatives. For
example, an option to buy a share is derived from the share. Derivatives allow more
precise pricing of financial risk and aim towards better risk management. It suffers from
the threat of misusing to cause, increasing volatility in asset prices. Derivatives will
focus on the following:
Forward contract
Future
Swap
Option
Over-the-counter
Exotics
Plain vanilla.
334
335
336
Forward contracts
Each day lot of futures contracts are bought and sold. This liquidity is possible only
because futures contracts are standardized and mature on a limited number of dates each
year.
Fortunately there is usually more than one way to skin a financial cat. If the terms of
futures contracts do not suit your particular needs, you may be able to buy or sell a
forward contract. Forward contracts are simply tailor-made futures contracts. The main
forward market is in foreign currency.
It is also possible to enter into a forward interest rate contract. For example, suppose that
you know that at the end of six months you are going to need a three-month loan. You
worry that interest rates will rise over the six-month period. You can lock in the interest
rate on that loan by buying a forward rate agreement (FRA) from a bank. For example,
the bank might offer to sell you a six-month forward rate agreement on three-month
LIBOR (London Inter Bank offered Rate) at 7 percent. if at the end of six months the
three month LIBOR rate is greater than 7 percent, the bank will pay you the difference; if
three-month LIBOR is less than 7 percent, you pay the bank the difference. The total
principal amount of FRAS outstanding is several trillion times.
337
year 1
100
year 2
- 90.91
--------0
--------100
-------+ 114.04
Notice that you do not have any net cash out flow today but you have contracted to pay
out money in year 1. The interest rate on this forward commitment is 14.04 percent. To
calculate this forward interest rate, we simply worked out the extra return for lending for
two years rather than one:
Forward interest rate: (1+2- year spot rate)2 -1
(1+1- year spot rate
= (1.12) 2 1 = 1404, or 14.04 %
1.0
In our example you manufactured a forward loan by borrowing short term and lending
long. But you can also run the process in reverse. If you wish to fix today the rate at
which you borrow next year; you borrow long and lend the money until you need it next
year.
Swaps:Suppose that the possum company wishes to borrow Euro to help finance its European
operations. Since possum is better known in the United States, the financial manager
believes that the company can obtain more attractive terms on a dollar loan than on a euro
loan. Therefore, the company issues
10 million of five year 8 percent notes in the
United States. At the same time possum arranges with a bank to swap its future dollar
liability for euros.
Under this arrangement the bank agrees to pay possum sufficient
dollars to service its dollar loan; in exchange possum agrees to make a series of annual
payments in euros to the bank. Possum and the bank are referred to as counterparties.
Swaps are not limited to future exchange of currency. The most common form of swap is
actually an interest rate swap, in which counterparties swap fixed interest rate loans for
floating rate loans. In this case one party promises to make a series of fixed annual
payments in return for receiving a series of payments that are linked to the level of short
term interest rates. Sometimes swaps are used to convert between floating rate loans that
338
are tied to different base rates. For example, a firm might wish to swap a series of
payments that are linked to the prime rate for a series of payments that are linked to the
Treasury bill rate.
Credit Derivatives
In recent years there has been considerable growth in the use of credit derivatives, which
protect lenders against the risk that a borrower will default. For example, bank A may be
reluctant to refuse a loan to a major customer (customer X) but may be concerned about
the total size of its exposure to that customer. Bank A can go ahead with the loan, but
use credit derivatives to shuffle off the risk to bank B.
The most common credit derivative is known as a default swap. It works as follows.
Bank A promise to pay a fixed sum each year to B as long as company X has not
defaulted on its debts. k If X defaults, B makes a large payment to A, but other wise pays
nothing. Thus you can think of B as providing A with long term insurance against
default in return for an annual insurance premium.
Earlier example of the farmer and miller showed how futures may be used to reduce
business risk. However, if you were to copy the farmer and sell wheat futures without an
offsetting holding of wheat, you would not be reducing risk; you would be speculating.
Speculators in search of large profits (and prepared to tolerate large losses) are attracted
by the leverage that derivatives provide. By this we mean that it is not necessary to lay
out much money up front and the profits or losses may be many times the initial outlay.
Speculation has an ugly ring, but a successful derivatives market needs speculators
who are prepared to take on risk and provide more cautions people like our farmer and
miller with the protection they need. For example, if an excess of farmers wish to sell
wheat futures, the price of futures will be forced down until enough speculators are
tempted to buy in the hope of a profit. If there is a surplus of millers wishing to buy
wheat futures, the reverse will happen. The price of wheat futures will be forced up until
speculators are drawn in to sell. Speculation may be necessary to a thriving derivatives
market, but it can get companies into serious trouble.
Most businesses take out insurance against a variety of risks. Insurance companies have
considerable expertise in assessing risk and may be able to pool risks by holding a
diversified portfolio. Insurance works less well when the insurance policy attracts only
the worst risks (adverse selection) or when the insured firm is tempted to skip on
maintenance and safety procedures (moral hazard).
Insurance is generally purchased from specialist insurance companies, but sometimes
firms issue specialized securities instead.
The idea behind hedging is straightforward. You find two closely related assets. You
then buy one and sell the other in proportions that minimize the risk of your net position.
If the assets are perfectly correlated, you can make the net position risk free.
339
The trick is to find the hedge ratio or delta that is the number of units of one asset that is
needed to offset changes in the value of the other asset. Sometimes the best solution is to
look at how the prices of the two assets have moved together in the past. On other
occasions a little theory can help to set up the hedge. For example, the effect of a change
in interest rates on an assets value depends on the assets durations. If two assets have the
same duration, they will be equally affected by fluctuations in interest rates. Once you
have set up the hedge, you can take a long vacation, confident that the firm is well
protected. However, some hedges, such as those that match durations, are dynamic. As
time passes and prices change, you need to rebalance your position to maintain the hedge.
Futures contracts are advance orders to buy or sell an asset. The price is fixed
today, but the final payment does not occur until the delivery date. The futures
markets allow firms to place advance orders for dozens of different commodities,
securities and currencies.
2.
Futures contracts are highly standardized and are traded in huge volumes on the
futures exchanges. Instead of buying or selling a standardized futures contract,
you may be able to arrange a tailor- made contract with a bank. These tailor made
futures contracts are called forward contracts. Firms regularly protect themselves
against exchange rate changes by buying or selling forward currency contracts.
Forward rate agreements (FRAs) provide protection against interest rate changes.
3.
4.
In recent years firms have entered into a variety of swap arrangements. For
examples a firm may arrange for the bank to make all the future payments on its
dollar debt in exchange for paying the bank the cost of servicing a euro loan.
Instead of using derivatives for hedging some companies have decided that speculation is
more fun, and this has sometimes got then into serious trouble.
(Source: Book on Corporate Finance Professor Brealey.I.Myrer)
340
DERIVATIVES
[ Instructions to Faculty ]
341
Learning Unit - 6
Instructions to Faculty
Derivatives
General Instructions:
Derivatives are a relatively new subject. Faculty should take care to ensure that basic
concepts are explained with simple examples.
Faculty may introduce the topic with a presentation on the overall objectives of the
module. This presentation may take approximately 45 minutes and may include the
objectives given below.
Objectives
At the end of this learning unit, the participants will be able to:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Presentation
The introductory presentation outlining the objectives of the module may be followed
with a more detailed presentation focusing on the following points:
342
Currency swaps.
Commodity futures and financial futures.
Faculty may use visual aids Nos. 41 - 46 to explain the objective and the points related to
derivatives.
Risk Management
Debt capacity
Maintaining the optional Capital budget over time.
Financial distress
Comparative advantage in hedging.
Borrowing costs
Tax effects.
Compensation systems.
Faculty may use the information provided in the reading material for Learning
Unit 6 in order to develop the presentation
343
Assumption
Range of values
Range of pay offs
Risk less hedged investment.
Pricing the call option.
Faculty may use the information provided in the reading material for Learning
Unit 6 in order to develop the presentation
Stock price
Exercise price
Option life
Risk-free rate
Stock price variance
Faculty may use the information provided in the reading material for Learning
Unit 6 in order to develop the presentation
344
Forward contracts
Futures contracts
Swaps
Structured notes
Inverse floater
Faculty may use the information provided in the reading material for Learning
Unit 6 in order to develop the presentation
Group activities
After the faculty has made the presentation described above and the participants are
reasonably clear about the basics concepts, participants may be given the group exercises
described in the handout on Group Activities for Learning Unit 6.
Faculty may explain how group activities should be conducted
There is a brief note entitled 'Derivatives - Key Concepts' in the handout on Group
Activities. The participants may be asked to read the note and answer the 10 questions
that follow the note.
Following this exercise, participants may be asked to read the two case studies given in
the Handout on Group Activities. The case studies relate to (i) Tropical Sweets Inc., and
(ii) Proter & Gamble & others. After reading the case studies ask participants to reflect on
and discuss the issues/ questions following the case studies.
The reading and discussion exercise will be followed by presentations. Each group will
identify a representative to make the presentation on behalf of the group.
Faculty should be available for clarifying doubts that may arise during group discussion,
moderate the group presentations and encourage participants to note down the key
learning points from the presentations, which should be consolidated in the plenary.
(Source: Principles of Corporate Finance by Professor Brealey.I.Myrer)
345
International
Financial Management
[ GROUP ACTIVITIES]
346
Learning Unit - 7
Group Activities
Group B:
Group C:
Group D:
This module also draws on two interesting case studies, entitled 'Guns' and 'Helicopters'.
All participants will be required to read the case studies in their respective groups and
make specific recommendations on the issues that the case studies raise.
As in the case of previous modules, faculty will be available for clarification of doubts
while the group discussion is in progress.
During group presentations, faculty will be available for moderation and summing up.
347
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
Problem 2:
Convert the following rates into outright rates and indicate their spreads:
Spot
1-month
3-months
6-months
Rs/$
38, 6800/15
10/15
15/20
20/30
Rs/$
53, 2400/20
30/20
40/30
45/32
Rs/DM
22, 8000/25
20/15
30/50
35/55
Work out the Bid Price, Ask Price and Spread Price in Indian rupees with reference to a)
Rupee rate of Dollar b) Rupee rate of Pound sterling, c) Rupee rate of Deutschmark..
Problem 3:
Given the following data:
Spot rate: Rs.45.0640 = $ 1
6-months forward rate: Rs.45.8490 = $ 1
Annualized interest rate on 6-months rupee: 10%
Annualized interest rate on 6-months dollar: 5%
Work out the arbitrage possibilities.
348
Problem 4:
If the $: Yen spot rate is $ 1 = Yen 130 and interest rates in Tokyo and New York
are 4 and 5 percent respectively, what is the expected dollar yen exchange rate
one year hence?
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Problem 7
An Indian exporting firm, Nadakari and Bros, would like to cover itself against a
likely depreciation of pound sterling. The following data is given:
349
Problem 8
A UK importer has to pay $ 200,000 in 2 months time. He fears an appreciation
of the dollar. What can he do with the knowledge of the following data?
2-m interest rate: US$: 3 percent
UK $: 4 percent
Spot rate: $ 1.8414/---
350
What should the company do? Assume that on 15 December, the DM future has
fallen to 89 and the Euro-DM rates are 8.1 percent.
10
8-months
10
11
9-months
11
12
-------------------------------------------------------------------Problem 15
A company will need to buy after 4 months a forward rate agreement (FRA) from
a ban to borrow for 3 months. The 4/7 FRA is quoted at 6.5. What will the
company do if after 4 months, the rate?
(a) rises to 8 percent
(b) falls to 5 percent
(c) remains at 6.5 percent
351
Requirement
1.
2.
200 guns
4 years
Proposal Number 1
1. Mitra desh had proposed sale of guns of India. The details are as under:
(a) Costs
(i) Cost per gun at factory premises
(ii) Freight and insurance charges
(iii) Training of users
$ 0.6 million
5 percent of cost
Rs.50 million
352
(i)
Cost of dollar:
D. Present rate:
(ii)
Rs.35/$
Rs.36/$
Rs.37/$
Cost of capital:
14 percent
Proposal Number 2
1. The gun can be manufactured in India. The production will be spread over tow
different plants, one for the barrels and the other for the gun carriage. Presently,
there are no facilities for manufacture of barrels, and thus a new plant will have to
be installed. For the gun carriage an existing plant can be used. However, this
plant is already working at full capacity and is engaged in manufacture of chassis
for commercial vehicles for Malaysia. If the proposal production of gun carriages
is to take place in the plant, the production of chassis will have to be stopped.
2. Some additional information is as given blow:
(a) For Barrel Factory
(i) Cost of new machinery
(Machine will have a life of 7 years and a
capacity to produce 50 barrels per year.
The machine will have an insignificant resale
Value after seven years of operation)
(ii) Production set-up costs
(iii) Working capital requirement to manufacture
barrels
(iv) Fixed overheads per year
(v) Variable costs per gun
(vi) Cost of project survey already incurred
Rs.300 million
Rs.50 million
Rs.100 million
Rs.200 million
Rs.10 million
Rs.30 million
353
Rs.50 million
50 carriages per year
7,000
Rs. 20,000 per chassis
Rs. 50 million
Rs. 5 million per gun carriage
Rs.150 million
Rs.20 million per gun
Rs.1 million per gun
Solution
Analysis of Proposal Number 1 (Imports)
Total cost of guns: 0.6 X 200
Freight and insurance charges (5 percent)
Cash outflow
(a) Immediate payment
(First installment)
(b) After one year
(Second installment)
( c) After two years
(Third installment)
(d) Cost of training
1.
2.
3.
$ 120 million
$ 6 million
$ 42 million
$ 42 million
$ 42 million
Rs.50 million
Outflow in $
(Million)
Immediate
1 year
2 years
42
42
42
Conversion
factor of $
(in Rs.)
Total
outflow
(Millions.)
35
36
37
1470
1512
1604*
PV
factor at
14 percent
Present
value
(million Rs)
1.000
0.877
0.769
1470.00
1326.02
1233.48
4029.50
Rs.300 million
Rs. 50 million
Rs.100 million
------------------Rs.450 million
------------------
Total
(b) Years (t = 1-3)
Capacity
Fixed cost
Variable cost (50 X 10) million
Total
354
Total
PV factor at
14 percent
Present value
(million Rs)
Immediate
450
1.000
450.00
1-3 year
700
2.322
1625.40
4th year
600
0.592
355.20
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------2430.00
2.Gun Carriage Factory
(a) Potential loss due to loss to existing production
(i) Number of chassis
7,000
(ii) Contribution margin per chassis
Rs.20, 000
(iii) Existing contribution (7,000 X 20,000)
Rs.140 million
(b) Cost of Gun Carriage
(i) Variable cost (50 X 5 million)
(ii) Additional fixed cost
Assembling cost (50 X 2 million)
(d) Testing/Proofing costs (50 X 1 million)
Total recurring cost (a+b+c+d)
Rs.250 million
Rs.150 million
Rs.100 million
Rs. 50 million
-----------------Rs. 690 million
------------------
0
1-4
Cash flow
(Million Rs)
PV factor at
14 percent
Total PV
(million Rs)
50.00
690.00
1.0000
2.9137
50.000
2010.453
2060.453
355
Million Rs.
Barrel factory
Gun carriage
2430.600
2060.453
------------449.053
------------
Recommendations
1. Proposal 1 related to import of guns is cheaper.
2. The following additional points may, however, be considered before taking a final
decision on the subject.
(a) There is an element of uncertainty associated with import of weapons from Mitra
Desh. The geopolitical environment expected in the next three to four years and its
likely effect on the sale of guns needs to be evaluated.
(b)Proposal 2 involves closing down an existing production of chassis for Malaysia.
Though the financial effects of this action have been evaluated, the overall effect that it
may have on further trade relations with Malaysia needs to be evaluated.
( c) There will still be a residual life of the machines set up for the barrel factory after
completion of production of 200 guns barrels. Additional orders for guns by the Indian
Army for exports may make this proposal attractive.
356
percent of the initial cost) at the end of eight years. The company tried to convince
Pharmax about profitability of the proposal and is ready to buy back the helicopter after 8
years for FFr 1.2 million.
Pharmax has some retained earnings and can also obtain adequate funds from outside
investors, if necessary, but before that it wants to be sure that the investment is
financially viable.
Current exchange rate
:
Projected exchange rate after 8 years :
Operating Parameters
Essential parameters used in the financial analysis are as follows:
(a) Existing Scenario
Hiring charges
Number of hours a month for which
Helicopter is hired
Rs.79.8 million
8 years
Rs.9 million
Annual depreciation
(Rs.79.8 Rs.9)/8
357
Rs.8.85 million
1-4 years
Rs.2.5 million
5-8 years
Rs.5.0 million
Manpower Costs
Pilots (each year for 1-4 years)
Rs.40, 000 per month (2 X 40,000 X 12)
5-8 years (Rs.44, 000 per month)
(2 X 44,000 X 12)
Assumptions: Salary is expected to increase by 10 percent after 4 years both for pilots and
ground staff.
Ground staff
1-4 years (Rs.15, 000 per months each)
(2 X 15,000 X 12
5-8 years (Rs.16, 500 per month each)
(2 X 16,500 X 12)
:
:
15 percent
Solution
Financial Analysis of Decision of Buying New Helicopter
(A) Total incremental cash outflows:
Cost of helicopter: Rs.79.8 million
(B) Total incremental cash inflows after taxes:
Cash inflow
21.6
358
4.5
-----------Gross income
26.1
Less running and maintenance costs
(2.5)
Insurance costs
(0.798)
Manpower costs
(1.32)
Depreciation
(8.85)
----------Earnings before tax
12.632
Less: Taxes (50 percent
6.316
----------Earnings after tax
6.316
Add: Depreciation
8.85
--------Incremental cash flow after tax (CFAT) 15.166
4.5
-----------26.1
(5.0)
(0.798)
(1.452)
(8.85)
----------10.00
5.00
-----------5.00
8.85
----------13.85
CFAT
(Rs. million)
1-4
5-8
8
PV Factor
Total PV
(Rs. million)
15.166
2.855
43.29893
13.85
1.632*
22.6032
9.0
0.327
2.943
(Salvage value)
Total PV
Less cash outflows
Net present value
-----------68.84513
79.80
-----------(10.95487)
* (4.487 2.855)
Recommendations
Since the NPV for the proposal of buying a new helicopter is negative, it is financially
not viable.
However, there are some qualitative aspects which merit consideration in final decision
making. There are as follows:
(i)
For the past two years, the company had been facing problems in getting a
helicopter booked for its use on appropriate days. This had been due to a
large demand for the helicopter service in the market.
359
(ii)
(iii)
360
International
Financial Management
361
Learning Unit 7
Guide for Group Activities
E. International Financial Management
This guide has been designed to enable participants to solve problems 1-15 given in the
handout on Group Activities in Learning Unit 7. The problems and solutions given in this
guide are illustrative and will enable the participant to solve the problems given in Group
Activities.
Illustration
Problem 1
You are required to find out the overall balance, showing clearly all the sub-balances
from the following data:
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
Solution 1
Sources and Uses of Funds
Sl.No.
1.
2. (a)
(b)
3.
4.
5.
6. (a)
Sources
3,00,000
3,000
5,000
Uses
Nature
Direct Foreign Investment
Goods exported
Services (invisible) rendered
Dividends paid
Goods exported
Short-term borrowing
Equipment imported
5,000
1,00,000
2,00,000
1,00,000
362
(b)
40,000
6,48,000
1,05,000
BOP Statement
A. Current Account
Goods Account
Exports
:
Rs.1, 03,000 (+)
Imports
:
Rs.1, 00,000 (-)
----------------------------------------Balance
:
Rs. 3,000 (+)
Invisible Account
Payment Received
Rs. 5,000 (+)
Payment Made
Rs. 5,000 (-)
----------------------------------------Balance
Nil
Current Account Balance:
Rs.3, 000(+)
B. Capital Account
Foreign Direct Investment
Inflow
:
Rs. 3, 00,000 (+)
Outflow
:
Nil
------------------------------------------Balance
:
Rs. 3, 00,000 (+)
Portfolio Investment
Inflow
:
Rs. 40,000 (+)
Outflow
:
Nil
--------------------------------------------Balance
:
40,000 (+)
Long-term Capital Balance: Rs.3, 40,000 (+)
(FDI + Portfolio)
Short-term Capital Account
Inflow
363
Outflow
:
Nil
------------------------------------------Balance
:
Rs.2, 00,000 (+)
Capital Accounts Balance: Rs.5, 40,000 (+)
Overall Balance
There is a net surplus of Rs.5, 43,000 in the balance of payments. This means, there will
be an increase of reserves by this amount.
Note: The transaction No.7 did not enter into the BOP Statement since this transaction
does not involve any foreign country. The entire transaction has taken place in Indian
rupees within India.
Illustration
Problem 2
Convert the following rates into outright rates and indicate their spreads:
Spot
I-month
3-months 6-months
Rs/$
35,6300/25
20/25
25/35
30/40
Rs/--
55, 2200/35
40/30
50/35
55/42
Rs/DM
23, 9000/30
30/25
40/60
45/65
Solution 2
(a) Rupee Rate of Dollar
An observation of the figures indicates that the first figure is lower than the second in all
3 forward quotes, implying dollar is being quoted at premium in the forward market.
Thus, the points will be added to the corresponding spot rates. Accordingly, the rates are:
Spot
I-month
3-months
6-months
35, 6320
35, 6325
35, 6330
35, 6350
35, 6360
35, 6365
0.0030
0.0035
0.0035
Spread (Rs)
0.0025
364
While observing figures of forward quotation, it is clear that pound sterling is at discount
in the forward market since points corresponding to the bid price are higher than those
corresponding to the ask price. Therefore, the forward points will be subtracted from the
spot rate figures. Thus, outright rates are:
Spot
I-month
3-months 6-months
55, 2160
55, 2150
55, 2145
55, 2205
55, 2200
55, 2193
0.0045
0.0050
0.0048
Spread (Rs)
0.0035
Spot
I-month
3-months
6-months
23, 8970
23, 9040
23, 9045
23, 9005
23, 9090
23, 9095
0.0035
0.0050
0.0050
Spread (Rs)
0.0030
Illustration
Problem 3
Given the following data:
Spot rate: Rs.350020 = $ 1
6-months forward rate: Rs.35, 9010 = $.1
Annualized interest rate on 6-months rupee: 12 percent
Annualized interest rate on 6-months dollar: 7 percent
Work out the arbitrage possibilities.
365
Solution 3:
It is clear from the data that 6-months forward US$ is quoting at premium, which is
calculated as below:
35.9010 35.0020
Premium = -------------------------- X 12 X 100 = 5.136 percent
35.20
6
(v)
Refund the rupee debt taken at 12 percent; the amount to be refunded is: Rs
1000 (1 + 12 X 6/12 X 1/100) = Rs.1060
Net gain = Rs.1061.5782 Rs.1060 = Rs.1.5782
366
Illustration
Problem 4
If the $: Yen spot rate is $ 1 = Yen 110 and interest rates in Tokyo and New York are 3
and 4.5 percent respectively, what is the expected dollar yen exchange rate one year
hence?
Solution 4:
According to interest rate parity, the future exchange rate is expressed by
1 + tD
CT = CO ----------1 + tE
1 + 0.03
= 110 X ------------1 + 0.045
= 108.42 or $ 1 = Yen 108.42
As US interest rates are relatively higher, dollar has undergone depreciation with respect
to yen.
Illustration
Problem 5
The US inflation rate is expected to average about 4 percent annually, while the Indian
rate of inflation is expected to average about 12 percent annually. If the current spot rate
for the rupee is $ 0.0285, what is the expected spot rate in two years?
Solution 5
According to purchasing power parity theory, the expected spot rate for the rupee in one
year would be
$ 0.0285 X (1.04/1.12)
Similarly, the spot rate for the rupee in two years is going to be
$ 0.0285 X (1.04/1.12) X 1.04/1.12)
= $ 0.0285 X (1.04/1.12)2 = $ 0.0245
367
Illustration
Problem 6
An Indian exporting firm, Rohit and Bros, would like to cover itself against a likely
depreciation of pound sterling. The following data is given:
Receivables of Rohit and Bros: ---- 500,000
Solution 6
Since no other data is available, the only thing that Rohit and Bros can do is to cover
itself in the money market. The following steps are required to be taken:
(i)
Borrow pound sterling for 3-months. The borrowing has to be such that at
the end of three months, the amount becomes $ 500,000. Say, the amount
borrowed is $D. Therefore,
3
D 1 + 0.05 X ---- = 500,000 or D = $ 493,827
12
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Convert the borrowed sum into rupees at the spot rate. This gives:
Rs.493,827 X 56 = Rs.27,654,312
The sum thus obtained is placed in the money market at 12 percent to
obtain at the end of 3-months:
3
S = 27,654,312 X [1 + 0.12 X ---- ] Rs.28, 483,941
12
The sum of $500,000 received from the client at the end of 3-months is
used to refund the loan taken earlier.
From the calculations, it is clear that the money market operation has
resulted into a net gain of Rs.483941 (=28,483,941 500,000 X 56).
If pound sterling has depreciated in the meantime, the gain would be even
bigger.
368
Illustration
Problem 7
A UK importer has to pay $ 100,000 in a months time. He fears an appreciation of the
dollar. What can he do with the knowledge of the following data?
1-m interest rate: US$: 4 percent
UK $: 5 percent
Spot rate: $ 1.5537/-$
Solution 7
Since only the money market data are available, the UK importer has to work out
possibilities that exist for him to cover himself in the money market. He can take the
following steps:
(i)
Buy S dollars at the spot rate and place them in the money market so as to
obtain $ 100,000 in a months time. That is,
1
S [1 + 0.04 X --- ]= 100,000
12
Or
S = $ 99,668.
(ii)
(iii)
Refund the sterling loan after one month. The refunded amount would be:
1
R = 64149 [1+ 0.05 X ---]
12
= $64,416.3
(iv)
In the meantime the sum of S dollars placed in the money market would
mature to $ 100,000. Use this sum to pay the payable due.
369
1.5537
In case, the dollar had appreciated and the payable was not hedged, the loss would
have been greater. Even 1 percent depreciation of pound sterling ($ 1.5382/-$)
would require a payment of $ 65,013, which means a loss of about $ 650.
370
Illustration
Problem 8
An Indian subsidiary of a UK multinational has a translation exposure of Rs.10 million.
The rates are as follows:
Spot: Rs.55, 0000/-$
One-year forward: Rs.56, 3200/-$
A 4 percent depreciation of the rupee is expected. How can the exchange risk be hedged?
Solution 8
The anticipated rate after expected depreciation would be: Rs.57.2000/-$
Suppose, no action is taken to hedge the risk. In that case, the company will suffer a
translation loss equal to:
10 million
$ [ -------------55
$ 6993
10 million
-------------]
57.2
To avoid this loss, the company will do well to buy pound sterling forward (or sell rupee
forward) such that the difference is equal to the anticipated loss. Say, it sells Rs.X.
Then,
6993
X (Forward rate
1
X [ ----------56.3200
Anticipated rate)
1
--------------- ]
57.2000
or
6993
(0.017755680 -
Rs.25, 599,974
0.017482517)
Or
This amount of rupees will give the following amount of pound sterling in the forward
market:
25,599,974
-------------- = $ 454,545.45
56, 3200
371
However, if the anticipated depreciation of the rupee (or appreciation of pound sterling)
does takes place, the company will buy the Rs.X back, with less amount of pounds
sterling. That is, for
25,599,974
-------------- =
57.2
$ 447,555.99
The difference between the two ($ 454,545.50 - $ 447,555.99) is equal to the loss ($
6989.51) that would have accrued without hedging.
Illustration
Problem 9
Total translation exposure of a company is Rs.1.5 million. This exposure is in French
francs. Interest rates are 8 and 11 percent for the franc and the rupee respectively. How
is hedging to be done? Spot rate is Rs.6 per FFr. The rupee is likely to depreciate by 6
percent.
Solution 9
Since only the interest rate data is available, the hedging operation is to be done in the
money market. The following steps are involved:
(1) Borrow Rs.1.5 million at 11 percent and convert them into French
Francs at spot rate to obtain:
Rs.1.5 million
----------------=
0.25 million FFr
6
(2) Place FFr 0.25 million in the money market for a year at 8 percent.
This would give FFr 0.27 million after a year.
(3)
(4)
Refund the rupee loan with interest. The refund amount works
out to Rs. (1.5 million X 1.11) = Rs.1.665 million.
Thus, the hedging operation would result into a net gain of Rs.52, 200 (=Rs.1.7172)
million Rs.1.665 million). The gain in French franc would be FFr 8,208.
372
Illustration
Problem 10
A French company imports in January equipment from the USA for $ 6 million. The
payment in US dollars is due in June. The importer fears an appreciation of US dollars.
The spot rate is $ 0.2/FFr. The FFr future contract for June is quoted at $ 0.19/FFr. What
should the French importer do? Assume further spot rate on settlement date is $
0.185/FFr and the future contract is likely to be quoted at $ 0.178/FFr. What is the
hedging efficiency?
Solution 9
The US dollar is likely to appreciate against the French francs. This also means that the
French franc would depreciate.
To guard against the depreciation of the French franc, the importer can sell French franc
future contracts. The amount involved is $ 6 million or FFr 30 million (=6 million/0.2).
Thus, the total number of future contracts to be sold is 60 (=30 million/0.5 million), since
the value of one future contract is FFr 500,000.
The French importer deposits the security amount with the Clearing House.
period January-June, the importer will pay margins if the FFr rises and have
credited if the FFr slips. On the due date in June the contract is
repurchased).Say, the spot rate on the due date is $ 0.18/FFr and the future
being quoted at $ 0.178/FFr.
During the
its account
closed (or
contract is
The importer makes a loss: FFr (6/0.2 6/0.185) million = FFr 2.432432 million.
However, on the future market, it makes a gain equal to $ (0.19 0.178) X 60 X 500,000
= $ 360,000 = FFr 360,000/0.185 = FFr 1,945,946.
Net loss = FFr 2,432,432 1,945,945 = FFr 486,486.
Note: The loss is not fully covered as spot rate deteriorated more than the future rate.
Hedge efficiency can be defined as the ratio between the gains made on the future market
and the loss payable due to the rate movement on spot market. It is equal to
1,945,946/2,432,432 X 100 = 80 percent.
Illustration
Problem 11
A company will receive $ 5.5 million in three months (March) from now. It will like to
place this sum for six months in Euro-dollar market. The rates are likely to go down.
The current rate is 1 percent over and above that of LIBOR, which is 9 percent. Eurodollar 3 months interest future is quoted at 90. What can the company do?
373
Solution 11
Since the company is likely to suffer the loss of opportunity if the rates go down, it buys
the interest future contract. The number of contracts to be bought should be either 5 or 6
since the value of one contract is $ 1 million.
Suppose the company buys 6 contracts, and the rates after 3 months are as follows:
LIBOR: 8.3 percent
Interest rate future: 90.5
Thus, the loss of opportunity for the company due to fall in the rates is:
9 8.3
6
5.5 X -------- X 106 X ---- =
100
12
$ 19,250
On the other hand, the gain on the future contracts is 6 X (90.5 90) X 100 X 25 = $
7,500
The net loss is $ (19,250 7,500) or $ 11,750
The loss is not covered fully because of the difference in basis as the fall in interest rate is
not totally reflected into the contract quotes, as also the amount to be covered is not in
exact multiples of the contract value of Euro-dollar rate future.
Illustration
Problem 12
A company is to borrow DM 2.5 million DM 2.5 million in December for 3 months. At
the moment (September), the December DM future is being quoted at 92.5. The market
rate of Euro-DM is 7.5 percent, which is likely to go up in months to come.
What should the company do? Assume that on 15 December, the DM future has fallen to
91.5 and the Euro-DM rates are 8.6 percent.
Solution 12
Since the DM borrowing rate is likely to go up between September and December, the
company will do well to sell DM future contracts to cover against interest rate risk.
The value of one Euro-DM future contract is DM 1 million while the sum to be hedged is
DM 2.5 million. So the company has to sell either 2 contracts or 3 contracts. Let us say,
it sells 3 of them.
374
On December 15, the company borrows at 8.6 percent. The sum that it would receive for
the face value of DM 2.5 million is found by the price yield formula:
Yield X N
Bond price
=
Face value
[1 - --------- ]
360
where N is the borrowing period in days.
0.086 X 90
So the sum realized is 2.5 [1 - ------------360
] = DM 2.44625 million.
But the sum that would have been realized at the yield rate of 7.5 percent is
0.075 X 90
2.5 [ 1 - -------------- ]
= DM 2.453125 million
360
So shortfall
Now the company buys back the future contracts. The gain is equal to 100 ticks (=
92.5 - 91.5). So the gain is
3 X 100 X 25 = DM 7,500
Thus, shortfall is more than made up through the hedging operation.
Illustration
Problem 13
A company plans to borrow $ 20 million by issuing a 90 days commercial paper in
August. The yield rate of the CP is 10.5 percent at the moment, i.e. the month of March.
Interest rates are anticipated to rise. Since no future contracts are available in CP, the
company can resort to T-bill futures. September T-bill futures are being quoted at 90.20.
Assume that on August 15, the CP yield has risen to 11 percent and T-bill future contract
is quoting at 89.60. What is the company expected to do?
Solution 13
In March, at the yield rate of 10.5 percent, the CP issue will result into a realization of
0.105 X 90
20 [ 1 - -------------] = $ 19.475 million
360
375
= $ 25,000
To hedge against the interest rate rise, the company sells 20 T-bill September future
contracts and repurchases them on August 15.
The gain on the future contract is 90.2 89.6 or 60 ticks. This is equal to 20 X 60 X 25 =
$ 30,000
Thus, the shortfall is more than compensated by hedging.
Illustration
Problem 14
A treasury manager after five months will need to borrow Rs.300,000 months.
current rates are as follows:
----------------------------------------------------------Duration
Borrowing rates
Lending rates
(Percent)
(Percent)
---------------------------------------------------------3-months
9.5
10.0
5-months
9.8
10.2
8-months
10.0
10.5
The
9-months
10.2
10.8
------------------------------------------------------------
The manager wants to ensure the rate that he would have to pay on his borrowings. What
should he do and what is the rate he can lock in?
Solution 14
Since he has to borrow after 5 months for a period of 3 months, the rates that concern him
are those corresponding to 5 months and 8 months.
He should borrow for 8 months at 10.5 percent and lend this sum immediately for 5
months at 9.8 percent. Let us say his effective rate is I.
376
5
i
3
8
[1+0.098 X --- ] [1 + ---- X --------] = [1 + 0.105 X --- ]
12
100
12
12
or
I = 11.2 percent
Thus, the treasury manager has been able to lock in an effective rate of 11.2 percent. The
interest on his borrowings would amount to:
Illustration
Problem 15
A company will need to buy after 4 months a forward rate agreement (FRA) from a bank
to borrow for 3 months. The 4/7 FRA is quoted at 6.5. What will the company do if after
4 months, the rate?
(a)
(b)
(c)
rises to 7 percent
falls to 6 percent
remains at 6.5 percent
Solution 15
(a)
Since the rate has risen, the counter-party (the bank in this case) will pay the
difference to the company. Say, the borrowings are planned for $ 1 million.
Then the counter-party is to pay to the company:
3
(0.07 0.06) X 1,000,000 X --12
= $ 2500
(b)
Since the rate has fallen to 6 percent, the company will pay to the bank, an
amount:
3
(0.065 0.06) X 1,000,000 X --12
$ 1250.
Since there has been no change in the rate, neither the bank nor the
Company pays or receives.
(Source: Book on International Financial Management by professors P.K.Jain, Josette
Peyrard and Surendra S Yadav)
377
International
Financial Management
[ READING MATERIAL ]
378
Learning Unit 7
Reading Material
International Financial Management
(Selected extracts from the Book on International Finance Management by Professors
P.K.Jain, Josette Peyrard and Surendra S Yadav)
1. General Introduction
Balance Of Payments
Balance of Payments (BOP) records commercial, financial and economic flows between
the residents of a given country and those of the rest of the world during a certain period
of time, generally a year. It measures flows rather than stock.
The resident of a country means any individual, business organization, government
agency or any other institution.
A BOP statement is kept in the form of sources (credits) and uses (debits) of funds. This
record enables us to know whether the country has/had a net surplus or deficit during the
referred period. If a country receives more funds from abroad than it spends, it has a
surplus of BOP. If expenditures abroad by residents exceed what the residents earn or
receive from abroad, the country has a deficit of BOP.
The major sources of funds for a country accrue from:
379
Obviously, sources increase the external purchasing power of a country; conversely uses
decrease its purchasing power.
380
Payments as interest and dividends, tourism payments for travel and financial charges (-)
Balance on Services Account = A(II)
Unilateral Transfers
Gifts, donations, subsidies received from foreigners (+)
Gifts, donations, subsidies made to foreigners (-)
Balance on Unilateral Transfers Account = A(III)
Current Account Balance: A(I) + A(II) + A(III)
B. Long-term Capital Account
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)
Direct investment by foreigners (+)
Direct investment abroad (-)
Balance on Direct Foreign Investment = B(I)
Portfolio Investment
Foreigners investment in the securities of the country (+)
Investment in securities abroad (-)
Balance on Portfolio Investment = B(II)
Balance on Long-term Capital Account = B(I) + B(II)
Private Short-term Capital Flows
Foreigners claim on the country (+)
Short-term claim on foreigners (-)
Balance on Short-term Private Capital Account = B(III)
Overall Balance : [A(I) + A(II) + A(III) + [B(I) + B(II) + B(III)]
C. Official Reserves Account
381
If overall balance (current plus capital) is in deficit, this implies either a reduction in
reserves or an increase in foreign debt or reduction of credits. It is important to note that,
by convention, a deficit is shown by + sign. In other words, it appears on the sources
side. As a result, sum of all sources and uses becomes equal. The reverse is true when
the overall balance (i.e., the sum of current and capital account) is in surplus.
If a country has significant deficit, it will have a tendency to take stiff measures for
diminishing is imports, exchange control.
BOP provides foresight regarding the type of exchange rates (increase/decrease) to
prevail; consistent deficit of BOP has an unfavorable effect on exchange rate/
Devaluation etc., BOP statements may be prepared in two currencies.
Adjustments between demand for and supply of foreign currency take place through the
intervention of central bank, or market, or by administrative measures.
Central bank intervenes through its regulatory stocks. This exercise is necessitated to
control the volatility of exchange rate as and when it anticipates a surplus over demand
(surplus of the BOP) or vice versa.
The national income (or product) is the sum of consumption and savings, that is;
National Income = Consumption + Savings
(2.1)
(2.2)
(2.3)
This identity says if a nations income exceeds its spending, then, savings will exceed
domestic investment, yielding surplus capital. This surplus capital must be invested
overseas. In other words, a nation that produces more than it spends, will save more than
it invests domestically and will have a net capital outflow. This capital outflow will
appear as a combination of capital account deficit and an increase in official reserves.
Conversely, a nation that spends more than it produces will invest domestically more than
it saves and have net capital inflow. This capital inflow will appear as a combination of
capital account surplus and a reduction of official reserves.
382
Fixed rates in terms of gold, but only the US dollar was convertible into gold.
A procedure for mutual international credits.
Creation of International Monetary Fund (IMF) to supervise and ensure
smooth functioning of the system. Countries were expected to pursue the
economic and monetary policies in a manner so that fluctuations of currency
remained within a permitted margin of + 1 per cent. That is, the central bank
of every country had to intervene to buy or sell foreign exchange, depending
on the need.
Devaluations or reevaluations of more than 5 per cent had to be done with the
permission of the IMF, to avoid chain devaluations.
383
Since 1970, a new instrument of reserve has been created, namely SDR (Special Drawing
Right). The value of SDR represents a weighted average of 5 currencies, that is, the US
dollar (40 per cent), German Deutschmark (21 per cent), the UK pound sterling (11 per
cent), the French franc (11 per cent), and the Japanese yen (17 per cent). These weights
reflect the relative strength of economies of these countries.
The quotas of different countries are paid to the IMF in the ratio of 25 per cent as SDRs
and 75 per cent in national currency.
Besides the quotas of member countries as explained above, the IMF can also have
recourse to loans from member states to augment its resources. These loans are drawn in
SDRs.
Also, under the General Agreement to Borrow (GAB) signed by the Group of Ten, (Paris
club) the IMF can borrow in order to have supplementary resources in convertible
currencies. This agreement allows the IMF to finance from this borrowing even those
countries which are not members of the Group of Ten. The agreement is renewed every
5 years; the last one was in 1993.
Good functioning of the international monetary system requires:
Member countries have an absolute claim on the IMF up to the amount of gold
subscriptions they have made. In operational terms, they can draw this amount (equal to
25 per cent of their quota) from the IMF any time. This is called reserve tranche (or gold
tranche) and is treated as the reserve of the country concerned. However, this sum is to
be reimbursed to the IMF within a specified period varying between 3 months to 5 years.
Beyond 25 per cent, a country can draw upon its credit tranche: the additional credit the
IMF can grant. The credit tranche consist of the amount of drawings beyond the reserve
or gold tranche that would raise the Funds total holdings of that country to 200 per cent
of the quota. Temporary increases of the credit tranche to 400 per cent of the quota have
been allowed in the past. Approval from the IMF is necessary for a country to draw on
its credit tranche. This approval usually comes with restrictions that become increasingly
tight as the drawings on this credit rise. Thus, this additional credit is used more often to
finance temporary disequilibrium in balance of payments than to provide temporary
liquidity.
Besides the reserve (or gold) and credit tranches, the IMF has three permanent credit
facilities : (i) the compensatory financing facility (established in 1963 and liberalized in
1975); (ii) the buffer stock financing facility (established in 1969); and (iii) the extended
facility (established in 1974 and expanded in 1983). There are other temporary facilities
384
created in response to specific needs such as oil price increases, and the Special
Emergency Fund created by the General Agreement to Borrow (GAB).
The IMF exercises a firm surveillance on the exchange rate policy of the member states
and adopts specific principles to guide them. In order that the system of exchange rate be
effective, the Fund recommends adoption of an anti-inflationary policy.
385
French franc
Deutschmark
Dutch guilder
Belgian franc
Irish pound
Spanish peseta
Portuguese escudo
Danish kroner
Austrian schilling
British pound
Greek drachma
Italian lira
6.53883
1.94964
2.19674
40.21223
0.808628
154.250
192.854
7.43679
13.7167
0.786749
264.513
1793.19
This pivot rate (reference rate) represents the unit of base from which the bilateral rates
are derived. For example, we have the following two rates.
386
network,
Environmental
protection
and
Loans are accorded by the EBI either directly or through another financial institution.
These can be given in several currencies or in a single currency like dollar, yen, Swiss
franc, ECU, etc.
The EBI is a financial intermediary without the goal of profit making. Its resources
essentially consist of borrowing on capital markets. It is backed up by governments of
the European Union. Therefore, it enjoys a higher credit-rating on the market (AAA).
In view of its financial standing and sound credit rating, the EBI obtains marginally
higher rates on its lendings. The EBI does not accord soft rates (subsidized rates).
The EBI finances big projects through individual loans and those of moderate size
through global loans. It also refinances banks and financial institutions, granting loans
for such projects.
It limits its financing to 50 per cent of the project cost. Co financing of projects with
other lenders is the general rule.
The duration is generally between 7 and 12 years but it may go up to 20 years or more for
the infrastructure projects. The duration as well as delay of repayments is adapted to
specific characteristics of the investments.
The setting up of EMU in 1991 has been a step towards the introduction of a common
currency in the member states of EU.
The Objectives of EMU are:
a) Adoption of an economic policy, based on a close coordination between
economic policies of the member states.
b) Fixing of irrevocable exchange rates leading to a single currency.
387
388
The Maastricht Treaty institutes an European System of Central Bank (ESCB) with
supra-national institution, called European Central Bank (ECB). It is the only ECB,
which will be authorized to issue bank notes in the European Union; it will exercise full
control on the circulation of currencies, participating in ECU and progressively replace
ancient currencies of the EU, ECU will then, become a veritable currency, i.e., a real
operational currency.
International trade;
Foreign investment; and
Lending to and borrowing from foreigners.
In order to maintain an equilibrium in the FE market, demand for foreign currency (or the
supply of home currency) should equal supply of foreign currency (or the demand for
home currency). In operational terms, the demand for all supply of home currency
should be equal. In the event of a disequilibrium situation, the monetary authority of the
concerned country normally intervenes/steps in to bring out the desired balance by:
Foreign exchange rates are quoted either for immediate delivery (spot rate) or for
delivery on a future date (forward rate). In practice, delivery in spot market is made two
days later.
A FE quotation is the price of a currency expressed in the units of another currency. The
quotation can be either direct or indirect. It is direct when quoted as so many units of
local currency per unit of foreign currency. For example, Rs.35 = US $ 1, is a direct
quotation for US dollars in India.
On the other hand, an indirect quotation is the one where exchange rate is given in terms
of variable units of foreign currency as equivalent to a fixed number of units of home
currency. For example, in India, US $ 2.857 = Rs.100 is an indirect quotation.
All quotations in India use the direct method of quotation.
A dealer usually quotes a two-way price for a given currency the price at which he is
buying (bid price) and the price at which he is selling (offer or ask price) the currency. In
either case, the currency for which the bid or ask price is given is the unit of the item
priced.
389
Spread means the difference between bankss buying (bid) and selling (offer or ask) rates
in an exchange rate quotation or an interest quotation. It fluctuates according to the level
of stability in the market, the currency in question, and the volume of the business. Thus,
if there is a degree of volatility in an exchange rate, and if business is thin and if (rumors
persist about the currency that) the current rate is rumored to be unsustainable, the dealer
will protect himself by widening the quote. That is, he will offer less currency while
selling but demand more when buying. The spread represents the gross return to the
dealer for the risks inherent in making a market.
Cash rate is the price of any currency other than home currency. In other words, it is the
direct relationship between two non-home currencies in a foreign exchange market
concerned with or used in transactions in a country to which none of the currencies
belongs.
Cash rate or Ready rate is the rate when the exchange3 of currencies takes places on the
date of the deal. If delivery is made on the day the contract is booked, it is called a
Telegraphic Transfer (TT) or cash or value-day deal.
When the exchange of currencies takes place on the next working day after the date of
deal, it is called the TQM (tomorrow) rate.
When the exchange of currencies takes place on the second working day after the date of
the deal, it is called the spot rate. This time is allowed to banks to process the necessary
paperwork and transfer the funds. Such transfers to and from banks will be effected
when their overseas currency accounts are either credited or debited, depending on
whether the bank is buying or selling. The rate of the agreed deal on telephone is called
the contract date; the value date is the one when the deposit is credited or debited.
Normally, a deal done on Tuesday will settled on Thursday and a deal done on Friday
will be settled on the following Tuesday. A business day is defined as one in which both
banks are open for business in both settlement countries. Most dealings now-a-days are
done spot.
The major currencies quoted on the forward market are given below. They are generally
in terms of the US dollar.
Deutschmark
Swiss franc
Pound sterling
Belgian franc
Dutch guilder
Japanese yen
Peseta
Canadian dollar
Australian dollar
390
391
392
There are two types of techniques to cover exchange rate risk: internal techniques,
adopted by the enterprise to limit the exchange risk, and external techniques that require a
recourse to forward market, money market and external organizations. While this chapter
discusses the internal techniques, the next one deals with the external techniques.
Multinational enterprises are subject to the following three types of risks/exposures:
Transaction Exposure
Consolidation Exposure.
393
This method is a noble one. However, an enterprise suffers under this method if the
national currency appreciates; this is likely to result into a loss of market for the products
of the company if there are other competitors.
Companies may also have recourse to invoicing in a currency whose fluctuations are less
erratic than those of the national currency. For example, in the countries of the European
Union, the use of European Currency Unit (ECU) is gaining popularity.
394
contract and payment, will be shared by the two in accordance with a certain formula, for
example, half-half or one-third, two-third, etc.
23. Bilateral
Netting may be bilateral or multilateral. It is bilateral when two companies have trade
relations and do buying and selling reciprocally. For example, a parent company sells
semi-finished products to its foreign subsidiary and then repurchases the finished product
from the latter.
24. Multilateral
Netting can equally be multilateral. This is taken recourse to when internal transactions
are numerous. Volume of transactions will be reduced because each company of the
group will pay or be paid only net amount of its debit or credit.
In the case of manufacturing companies, switching the base of manufacture may be
useful so that costs and revenues are in the same currency.
A reinvoicing centre of a multinational group does billing in respective national
currencies of subsidiary companies and receives the invoices made in foreign currency
from each one of them. It would be preferable, if possible, to locate the reinvoicing
centre in a country where exchange regulations are least constraining.
The centre itself is a subsidiary of the parent company. The principle is simple: the
invoices in foreign currencies are made in the name of the reinvoicing centre by the
subsidiaries. And, the centre, in turn, will send out equivalent sums in national currency.
Likewise, payments in foreign currencies to suppliers are made by the centre and it
receives equivalent sums in the national currencies from the subsidiaries concerned.
395
US dollar
loan
Indian
Bank
Reimbursement
In US dollars
Indian
rupee loan
Subsidiary
A
Reimbursement
in Indian rupees
Suppose, in the meantime, the exchange rate has evolved to Indian Rs 35/ US$ 1, then the
loss to the bank would be $ 0.076 million (= 35.84/35 1.1). Thus, the exchange
management risk got shifted to the Indian bank while both the American parent company
and the Indian subsidiary were dealing in their respective currencies, without any
uncertainty about the sums to be received or paid. The bank would have made a gain in
case the exchange rate had evolved in the opposite direction.
Fuji Japan
Lends in US$ to
Fuji USA
Kodak Japan
The cost of swaps will depend on the rate of interest and the exchange rate chosen by the
two parties.
396
An exporter may, agree to give discount for early payment. This discount represents a
cost for the exporter. But by doing so, he avoids the exchange rate risk, diminishes credit
risk and receives immediate cash.
28.
Basically, the strategy involves increasing hard currency (likely to appreciate) assets and
decreasing soft currency (likely to depreciate) assets, while simultaneously decreasing
hard currency liabilities and increasing soft currency liabilities.
For example, if
depreciation is likely to take place, the basic hedging strategy would be as follows:
reduce the level of cash, decrease accounts receivable by tightening credit terms, increase
local currency borrowing, delay accounts payable, and sell the weak currency forward.
If depreciation is anticipated
If appreciation is anticipated
The major techniques External techniques for covering exchange rate risk
397
Separate group exercises will be given regarding using of some of these techniques.
$ 1m
Bank
DM 1.4 m
American Company
Variable rate
Bank
Fixed rate
American Company
DM 1.4 m
Bank
$ 1m
Currency swaps are comparable to a forward exchange transaction with a difference that
the differential of rates is calculated periodically instead of being settled just once at the
end of the contract; this feature renders the swaps more efficient and more flexible than
covering in the forward market for long periods.
398
An interest rate position either on the asset side or on the liability side is subjected to
fluctuations of rates. An enterprise, a bank or an investor is said to have a long
position in the case of increase in the rate of interest. Conversely, these operators are
said to have a short position in the event of decrease in the interest rate.
When an enterprise is faced with a situation of interest rate risk, it can:
There is a close nexus between IRR and prices of financial securities. Therefore it would
be useful to know, how the prices of financial securities vary. The price of a financial
security is equal to the present value of cash inflows that it generates during its life. In
general, the price of a fixed rate financial security refundable at the end of the borrowing
period depends upon:
The coupon amount. Coupon is equal to the product of nominal value of a bond
and interest rate;
The mode of capital refund. Normally, refund is done in one lot at the end of the
life of a bond, but it can be done in installments over a period of a number of
years;
Market interest rate;
Maturity period of the borrowing.
When market interest rate increases, the price of the fixed-income security decreases and
conversely when market interest rate decreases, the price of the fixed-income security
increases.
399
On the other hand, a decrease in market yield induces a price increase that results into
capital gain if the investor liquidates his bonds. However, if the bond is held till its
maturity, there is no risk resulting from market variations.
Bond prices vary in opposite direction to that of interest rate variation. When two bonds
differ only in terms of their interest rates, the one having the lower coupon will vary more
for the same variation of market interest rate.
When two bonds differ only in terms of their maturity, the one having the longer maturity
will vary more for the same variation of the market interest rate.
For every bond, a given increase in the interest rate results into a smaller variation of
price than an identical decrease in the interest rate.
For a given percentage increase or decrease of interest rate, and everything else being the
same, price variation is higher for the security with the lower coupon.
400
In general, the sensitivity of a fixed-income bond is greater if coupon rate is smaller and
its residual period is longer.
Duration is an index of time during which an investor recovers his funds initially
invested. Duration is calculated by finding the ratio of (i) sum of the product of period
and the corresponding present value of cash flows generated by the security, and (ii)
present value of the security. It is expressed in terms of years. It enables to compare
bonds issued with different conditions.
The securities with longer duration have greater volatility than those of shorter duration.
Thus, the higher duration implies greater risk.
If the duration of the asset is higher than that of liability, the financial firm is holding a
long position and then the risk comes from the increase in rates, as decrease in the value
of assets held will be higher than the advantage accruing from a decrease in sum payable.
On the other hand, if the establishment holds a short position, i.e., the duration of the
asset is smaller than that of liability, the risk emanates from a decrease in rates.
401
Contract price reflects the anticipation of buyer and sellers regarding the interest rates. In
order to properly understand the functioning of forward operations, it is desirable to look
at the inverse relation between the prices of fixed-rate securities and the rates of interest.
The terms used in published information on futures contracts are: opening price of a
session, settlement price or closing rate, change, highest rate, lowest rate, volume traded.
Maturity date. These are four in number: March, June, September and December.
Guarantee deposits. Guarantee deposits are made with the clearing house of the
exchange. The role of the clearing house is to ensure the solvability of operators. The
guarantees are of the order of 2 to 4 per cent of the contract amount.
Everyday, during the life of the contract, gains or losses are calculated according to the
rate movements. If the rate moves unfavorable for the operator, he is called upon to
make supplementary payments (called margins). Conversely, he receives payment if the
rates have moved in his favor. This process continues up to the date of the delivery,
provided the contract is not already liquidated before that date.
402
demonstrate that the operator has money to honor his side of the bargain. As long as
interest is earned on margined securities, there is no cost of margin deposits. The
enterprises which are to take loans or place their cash on some future date may prefer to
lock in the interest rate today itself to guard against unfavorable rate movements in the
interim period.
When interest rates rise, the price of an interest rate future comes down. The risk of rise
in interest rates is covered by selling futures contracts. The enterprise that wants to cover
itself against rise of interest rates sells contracts for an amount and a duration equivalent
to the position that it wants to cover. If a rise does take place, the gain that the enterprise
would have by repurchasing at a lower price the contracts that it had sold compensates
the loss resulting from the rise in the rate.
When interest rates fall, the price of an interest rate future increases. The risk of fall in
interest rates is covered by buying futures contracts. The enterprise that wants to cover
itself against fall of interest rates buys contracts for an amount and a duration equivalent
to the position that it wants to cover. If a fall does take place, the gain that the enterprise
would have by reselling at a higher price the contracts that it had bought earlier
compensates the loss resulting from the fall of the rate.
Reduce the effect of rate variations on balance sheet items, for example, an
enterprise that has borrowed at a fixed rate and wants to benefit from a fall in
rates;
Reduce the impact of rate fluctuations on anticipated positions; this, in turn
ensures the business unit a more certain borrowing rate or a rate of return on its
fixed income securities.
Arbitrage between the future market and spot market.
In brief, future market provides a great deal of latitude and security to operators an
important feature of this market.
403
Basis risk is incurred when the maturity date of borrowing or lending does not
coincide with maturity date of a futures contract,
Risk of correlation is incurred when the rate covered is not perfectly correlated
with the rate of a futures contract;
Risk of indivisibility is incurred when the number of contracts bought or sold
does not perfectly correspond to the amount to be covered.
Contracts are standardized from the viewpoints of amounts, maturity, and period
(March, June, September, December) :
Exercise prices are given at intervals of 0.25 dollar for Euro-dollar contracts, for
example, 92.25,92.50, 92.75 etc;
Contracts are easily negotiable;
The clearing house ensures the regularity of operations.
404
This is an operation that enables an operator to fix immediately interest rates of a debt or
a loan which will be contracted at a later date. For example, an enterprise wants to
ascertain today the interest rate on debt which it will borrow after 3 months for 6 months.
This can be done by:
These two sets of transactions will enable the operator to know in advance the effective
rate of interest on 6-months borrowing, 3-months hence from today, as desired.
They are not standardized: the amount and maturity are negotiated;
Exercise price is the one defined in the contract;
Premium is expressed in terms of percentage of the amount under option.
405
Borrowing rate options. These options enable an enterprise to ensure a borrowing rate,
while letting it have all the freedom to benefit from a favorable evolution of rates.
Lending rate options. A lending rate options enables an enterprise to place its cash at a
certain minimum rate, while leaving it all freedom to benefit from a favorable movement
of rates.
406
48. Collars.
Collars are a combination of caps and floors. The purchase of a collar enables its buyer
to ensure a maximal borrowing rate (cap), while permitting him to benefit from any fall
in rates up to the floor.
Since purchase of a cap and a sale of a floor occur simultaneously, the amount of
premium to be paid is reduced. The rate guaranteed is within a certain range.
49. Swaps
An interest rate swap is a contract for exchange of rates between two companies on a
notional capital. These can be affected either directly between two organizations or
through a bank.
Swap through a bank. A bank comes between the two companies as a mediator since it
may not be easy for the companies to find counter-party. This role is played by the bank
which, of course, makes a gain in the bargain for the services rendered.
Country risk;
Sector risk;
Project risk.
407
Measures Taken for Salvaging Adverse BOP in the form of Restrictions on outgoing
capital, Restrictions on imports and Measures Aiming at a Certain Degree of Control on
Foreign Investments will act as constrains on international business.
408
dispute. However, it may be noted that these bilateral conventions only diminish political
risk but do not eliminate it completely.
These measures may reduce the flexibility of the company; this may be considered, in a
way, the cost to be paid to meet political risk.
Alternatively, a company may have recourse to external guarantees to protect itself.
There exist in many countries public and private insurances to cover these risks.
409
exporting country should specialize in the production of only those products in which it has a
comparative cost advantage. This theory was based on the hypothesis of immobility of
factors of production as opposed to the mobility of products.
According to the theories based on market structure, firms which invest abroad must have
a comparative advantage in terms of one or more of the following factors:
Cost of capital
Economics of scale
Infrastructure for research and development
Funds for advertisement, etc.
3) The firm may start producing either in the country where it was previously
exporting or in a less developed country to take advantage of lower labor costs
with a view to exporting from there to the rest of the world.
410
domestic operations. The fund raising activities on the part of multinational enterprises
just go contrary to the basic philosophy of neo-classical theory.
Hymer bases his theory on the structure of oligopolies in that oligopolistic enterprises are
in a position to fix a high price as they deal with a large mass of unorganized buyers.
In order to set up its operations abroad, a multinational should have a comparative
technological or organizational advantage over its competitors in the host country. These
advantages will translate in terms of lower costs and more efficient use of its resources.
Hymer distinguishes between the economies of scale obtained at the level of the firm and
the economies of scale obtained at the level of the sector. The first are a result of the
organization of the firm while the latter result from the division of labor.
The economies of scale at the level of a firm can be seen in production, marketing,
finance, research and development, human resources, etc.
The price of the product should be lower than that of other foreign competitors;
The quality of the product should be better and adapted to the needs of foreign
customers;
An export service should be organized.
After an analysis and selection of markets, the enterprise determines its export policy and
arranges necessary means for putting that policy in application. There are several options
available for exporters in this regard.
411
412
413
Equity capital may be brought in the form of participation in the capital or subscription to
convertible bonds. The funds may equally be brought in as loans, bonds or bonds-withwarrants.
Creation of a company with venture capital may constitute, for big groups, a means of
access to advanced technologies. Normally, participation in venture capital is not meant
to last long. As soon as the enterprise is able to develop using its own means, it is resold.
As the growth of the enterprise so financed blocks all disposable funds for the period of
participation, the investors receive neither interest nor dividend. Returns on placement
depend on the capital gain at the time of the sale.
414
projects profitability. The reason is obvious but for the investment abroad, additional
sales would not have been possible. Synergy effect accordingly, should be reckoned.
Besides, care should be taken to include the true economic cost (i.e. opportunity cost) of
any resource required for the project, irrespective of the fact whether the firm owns the
resource or is to buy it from outside. For instance, rent foregone due to the use of
factory/office space (now to be used in the proposed investment project) is the relevant
cost.
It is often customary to charge investment projects with various items such as legal
counsel, technical know-how, management costs, research and development, training of
personnel, and so on. While these are costs from the point of view of project, they are
benefits (received in the form of fees and royalties) to the parent. Prima facie, they net
out each other and therefore, warrant exclusion. However, if such costs/overheads (or
some of them) are additional on account of the project, they form part of relevant cost
data. Clearly, the list of costs and benefits which should be and which should not be
taken into account cannot be exhaustive; it may vary from one MNC to another in the
industry and may vary within the same MNC over a period of time. In carrying out an
incremental analysis exercise, the guideline is: but for the investment proposal under
consideration, these costs and benefits would not have taken place.
Both costs and benefits should be measured on a cash flow basis and not on the basis of
accounting profits. That cash flow approach is more useful and scientific as a decision
criterion than accounting profit approach, is well recognized in the literature of financial
management. The other reason under-lying superiority of cash flow approach are: (i) it
avoids the ambiguities of the accounting profit concept, (ii) it takes cognizance of the
time value of money. Above all, since investment analysis is concerned with finding out
whether future economic inflows are sufficiently large to warrant the initial investment,
only the cash flow method is appropriate for investment decision analysis.
In sum, it can be said that expected/projected incremental cash flows after taxes arising
out of the investment decision (of setting up a subsidiary abroad,
expansion/diversification of existing subsidiary) constitute the relevant data for its
evaluation.
While it is true that the principle of incremental analysis is very simple in terms of
conceptual framework, its practical appreciation is not without problems. For instance, it
is very difficult to estimate the magnitude of lost sales/accretion of sales on account of
the proposed project. However, it does not undermine the utility of incremental
exercise; it only cautions the executives responsible for such decisions.
415
416
Exchange rate risk is yet another significant variable to be considered in assessing foreign
direct investment.
This risk is very much there while undertaking investments in
underdeveloped countries. As a result, repatriable cash flows (converted into the
currency of the parent) diminish on account of periodic devaluation of local currency.
Exchange rate changes are normally preceded by relatively higher or lower local rates of
inflation than in the home country.
417
Third, a convenient unit of account should be chosen. This may be the unit of currency
in which returns from the project are measured. Both the returns and cost of funds should
be expressed in the same currency.
Fourth, the MNC should take into account the likelihood of changes in constraints, such
as borrowing restrictions, tariff and exchange controls, limitations on cash transfers and
other remittances, taxes and so on. Given the objective of the management to borrow at
the lowest possible effective rate, the finance managers of international firms should
explore the possibilities of raising funds in various financial markets/currencies.
Fifth, in the event of the firm needing more funds than available through retained
earnings, it is to raise funds from external sources (say, debt, preference shares and
equity). The cost of each of these three sources varies. In general, debt is regarded the
cheapest source of finance as interest on debt is tax deductible.
As the debt ratio rises, debt holders rightly perceive higher debt/equity (D/E) ratio as
more risky for their lendings.
For the same reason the credit rating firms may reduce its credit rating. From the equity
shareholders perspective as well, financial risk will also increase their required rate of
return. Therefore, it is apparent that debt should be used only within safe limits.
Sixth, the entire advantage of a cheap source of finance, say debt (assuming to have been
used within safe limits), should not go to one project only which happens to be financed
from that source. Likewise, one single project only which not be burdened with the
costly source of finance, say equity. Issuing equity now implies potential of raising
debt in future years; issue of debt today implies the virtual necessity to go for equity in
future years. Therefore, it is only appropriate and logical, that the firm should use
weighted average cost of these sources as a discount rate for investment decisions.
The cost of capital of multinational enterprises (like domestic corporate firms) is ideally
based on weighted average cost of long-term sources of finance.
Its overall
determination, therefore, requires separate computations of each major long-term source
of finance, namely, long-term debt, preference shares, equity and retained earnings.
Determination of cost of various sources of finance is simplified, to a marked extent, by
adopting the Porterfield approach of explicit and implicit costs. According to Porterfield,
The explicit cost of any source of capital is the discount rate that equates the present
value of the cash inflows that are incremental to the taking of the financing opportunity
with the present value of its incremental cash outflows.
In the context of international finance, cash flows should be duly adjusted for taxes,
foreign exchange risk, timing of repatriation and so on.
418
419
Conceptually, the cost of equity capital for a firm is the minimum rate of return necessary
to induce investors to buy or hold the firms stock. This required return is sum of the
basic yield covering the time value of money plus a premium for risk. In the operational
terms, it is the required rate of return of equity investors. There are two models,
commonly employed to measure the cost of equity investors. There are two models,
commonly employed to measure the cost of equity capital: (i) Model of Gordon-Shapiro
(more popularly known as dividend valuation model), and (ii) Capital asset pricing model
(CAPM).
420
421
422
accordingly the appropriate cost of equity should betake into account. If the subsidiary is
held 100 per cent by the group, the cost of equity capital of the subsidiary is equal to that
of the parent group.
Alternatively, the cost of the capital of the parent group may be adapted, commensurate
with the level of risk incurred by the subsidiary. The cost increases with increase in the
risk level and decreases with decrease in the risk level. Likewise, if the subsidiary is
located in a risky country, a higher WACC can be applies.
K0 = 129.6 million 100 = 0.12.96 per cent
1000 million
The FINANCIAL STRUCTURE OF MULTINATIONAL GROUPS reflects the
mode of financing the assets of the parent group, worldwide. The group will like to attain
optimal capital structure at which the overall cost of capital is minimum or value of the
firm is maximum.
This nature of WACC enables the multinational groups to have a certain margin of
maneuverability to attain the optimal/sound financial structure. For the purpose, they
may follow either of the two approaches: (i) adapt the financial structure of foreign
subsidiaries to the financial, economic and monetary environment of the country in which
they are located, or (ii) attempt to modify capital structures of its various subsidiaries in a
manner so that at the level of the consolidated balance sheet of the group, it tends towards
the desired structure.
In several countries, exporters have a preference for their national currency as the
currency of invoicing as it avoids the exchange rate risk.
Since exporters often have greater power than importers as far as the choice of currency
is concerned, it is the importing firms that suffer more from exchange rate risk.
423
Whenever a third currency is chosen, it is generally the American dollar (for example for
petroleum imports) that is preferred.
The mode of settlement is often chosen by the exporter. In international trade, bank
transfer as well as credit instruments serve as means of settlement. Included in this
category are drafts, letter of credit. Cheques, International bank transfer, etc. The choice
amongst these different means depends on their rapidity of conversion, cost and exchange
regulations of a given country.
424
Documents concerning the transport. They are generally bill of lading for sea
transport, a letter of transport if it is train or air or road transport.
Other documents. Other documents may be:
425
426
The letter of exchange must contain the following indications in order to be negotiable:
Cheque
In international trade, there exist two types of cheques:
427
428
machinery. Such an arrangement has attributes that make it, in effect, an alternative form
of direct investment.
Financial counter-operations can be of different types. One commonly known is
switch-trading.
Switch-trading, also called triangular compensation, involves three
countries. For example, a Western exporter delivers merchandise to an importing
country. As payment, the importing country may transfer other goods to a third country,
which then reimburses the Western exporter for the goods received. To take a concrete
case, German exports destined for Poland may be financed by the sale of Polish products
to France.
Project Financing
1. Characteristics of Projects
Project financing may be defined as financing of an economic unit, legally independent,
created with a view to setting up a big project which is commercially profitable and
financially viable. Future cash flows should be sufficient to ensure, with an adequate
margin of security, coverage of operational costs and servicing of debt as well as owners
equity.
The promoter of a project may set it up all alone or in association with other partners.
The project company is responsible for debt-servicing and should use, on priority basis,
the cash flow for repaying the debt.
Big international projects are of varied types and cut across all sectors of activity, say
construction of dams, nuclear energy plants, railway network, water treatment plants or
leisure parks. They present, however, certain common characteristics:
2. Project Financing.
There are two major methods of financing international projects.
Financing with total risk borne by lenders where only the future cash flows ensure
the reimbursement of the loan. This method of financing was used in petroleum
and gas industry in the USA and Canada. Due to increased level of risks, this
method of project financing is generally not preferred.
429
In another type of financing, the risk is shared both by the lender and promoter.
The problem sometimes encountered in this method is to decide the proportion in
which risk will be shared between the two parties.
Apart from the above major types of financing, of late, a new mode of financing has
emerged, namely, Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT). As per this method, the investor
establishes the project on behalf of the promoter; on successful commissioning he also
operates it; it eventually gets transferred to the owner after a certain number of years.
This type of financing is becoming popular particularly in developing countries for
infrastructure projects.
Sponsors are the partners in the project who bring in equity capital or risk capital. Being
so, they are keenly interested in the successful completion of the project and shoulder
major responsibilities as regards its execution. The fact that they bring in equity capital is
an indication of their interest. Further, the amount of equity they contribute has a marked
bearing on the extent of debt that can be raised for the project.
Others who bring in equity capital are the initiators of the project. Included in this
category are multinational firms, future buyers of products or services of the project, the
erectors of the project, the public or private investors, international organizations,
development banks, etc.
3. Lenders
Financing of a big project necessitates intervention of a banking pool consortium
composed of banks, national or international financial institutions, export financing
institutions, etc.
4. Guarantors
Guarantees may be provided by banks, public financing organizations, international
financial institutions, private insurance companies, etc.
5. Builders
Generally, there may be several builders who may group themselves as a consortium.
Sometimes, there may be a single project managing agency that coordinates different
tasks and directs the completion of the project.
6. Project Operators
An operating company intervenes in the correction of the project.
organizational know-how to manage the project.
430
It brings its
8. Financial Risk
In general, international projects are prone to greater financial risk as bulk of finance is in
the form of debt. The major factors affecting financial risk are degree of indebtedness,
the terms and conditions of repayment of debt, and currency used.
9. Political Risk
Political risk is another major consideration in international projects. It may emanate
from increase in the rents, increase of customs duty on the imports necessary to complete
the project, exchange control and non-convertibility of currency, limits on transfers, nonpayment of debts committed by a previous government, war, etc.
431
432
International financial markets can develop anywhere, provided that local regulations
permit the market and potential users are attracted to it.
International Capital Markets, also called Euro-markets, are the markets on which Eurocurrencies, Euro-bonds, Euro-equity and Euro-bills are exchanged.
International
financing in the form of short-, medium- or long-term securities or credits has become
necessary for the international economy. Financing techniques have diversifies, volumes
dealt have increased and the process is continuing to grow.
Euro-debt or Euro-credit is medium-term loans (with variable rate linked to Eurocurrency deposits and accorded by an international bank syndicate). The following
paragraphs give a brief description of different aspects of Euro-credit markets.
The major lending banks in Euro-credit market are Euro-banks, American, Japanese,
British, Swiss, French, German and Asian (specially that of Singapore) banks, Chemical
Bank, JP Morgan, Citicorp, Bankers Trust, Chase Manhattan Bank, First National Bank
of Chicago, Barclays Bank, National Westminster, Credit Lynonnais, BNP, etc. Among
the borrowers, there are banks, multinational groups, public utilities, government
agencies, local authorities, etc.
When a borrower approaches a bank for Euro-credit, a formal document is prepared on
behalf of potential borrowers. This document, inter-alia, contains the principal terms and
conditions of loan, objectives of loan and details about the borrower.
Before launching a syndication, the approached bank decides primarily, in consultation
with the borrower, on a strategy to be adopted, i.e., whether to approach a large market or
a restricted number of banks to form the syndicate.
Each of the banks in syndicate lends a part of the loan. The duration of this operation is
normally about 6 to 8 weeks. Several clauses as below may be introduced in the contract
of Euro-debt:
Pari-passu clause that prevents the borrower from contracting new debts that
subordinate the interest of lenders;
Exchange option clause that allows the withdrawal of a part or totality of loan in
another currency;
Negative guarantee clause that commits the borrower not to contract other debts
that subordinate the interest of lenders.
3. Characteristics of Euro-credits
A major part (more than 80 per cent) of the Euro-debts is made in US dollars. The
second (but far behind) is pound sterling followed by ECU, Deutschmark, Japanese yen,
Swiss franc and others.
433
Most of the syndicated debts are of the order of $ 50 million. As far as the upper limits
are concerned, amounts involved are of as high magnitude as $ 5 billion and more. For
instance, in 1990, Euro-tunnel borrowed $ 6.8 billion.
On an average, maturity periods are of about five years (in some cases it is about 20
years). The reimbursement of the loan may take place in one go (bullet) or in several
installments.
The interest rate on Euro-debt is calculated with respect to a rate of reference, increased
by a margin (or spread). The rates are variable and generally renewable (roll over credit)
every six months, fixed with reference to LIBOR (London Interbank Offered Rate). The
LIBOR is the rate of money market applicable to short-term credits among the banks of
London. The reference rate can equally be PIBOR at Paris and FIBOR at Frankfurt, etc.
it is revised regularly.
The margin depends on the supply and demand of the capital as also on the degree of the
risk of these credits and the rating of borrowers. Financial institutions are in vigorous
competition.
There are two types of commissions:
434
5. Euro-bond Market
As already indicated, Euro-bonds are the bonds issued in Euro-currencies and placed
simultaneously and in similar conditions in several countries through an international
bank syndicate or consortium.
These bonds represent a loan of medium- or long-term, from 5 to 15 years, and generally
carry an interest. The lender is non-resident.
Private enterprisers, for example, in France, some of them are Pechiney, Renault,
Rhone Poulenc, etc.
Public enterprises;
Financial institutions;
Governments and Central Banks;
435
7. Characteristics of Euro-bonds:
There are different types of Euro-bonds:
Straight bonds. These are most current and represent about three-fourth of the total
volume. Nominal value of bonds is minimum $ 5,000, DM 10,000, FFr 10,000, JPY
1,000,000 etc.
Floating rate bonds. The interest rate of these bonds is revised every six months. It is
based on LIBOR to which a margin is added; the margin varies and it is a function of the
risk of the borrower.
Convertible bonds. These bonds may be converted into shares of the issuing company.
The advantage of this formula for the issuer is a lower interest rate than that on straight
bonds. For the buyers of this bond the advantage is the possibility of a gain in case of
significant increases in share prices.
Floating rate bonds with collar. The rates of these bonds can fluctuate between a
certain minimum and a fixed maximum. The buyer of this type of bonds receives a yield
rate higher than the market rate but does not benefit from the increase if the market rate
exceeds the maximum fixed by the issuer.
Reverse floating rate bonds. These bonds pay a higher interest rate when the rate of
reference decreases. The coupon is fixed at a rate minus-LIBOR. So, when LIBOR
decreases, the interest rate increases. For clarity, suppose a Euro-bank offers a rate of 16
- LIBOR per cent; therefore, at LIBOR increases to 8.2 per cent, the effective rate will be
16 8.2 per cent, i.e. 7.8 per cent. It may be noted that increase in LIBOR rate has, in
effect, decreased the effective rate for the borrowers.
Bonds with warrant. These bonds resemble convertible bonds with the difference that
warrants are detached from bonds and negotiated separately. They allow their holders to
buy shares or other securities at a later date on advantageous terms.
436
Zero coupon bonds. These bonds do not pay interest. They are issued at a price lower
than their reimbursement value to take care of yield for investors. Purchasers of these
bonds pay no income tax as they do not receive interest payments. They pay taxes at a
lower rate on long-term capital gain when the bonds are refunded at face value. They are
more often issued by blue chip companies as the default risk is concentrated on the
reimbursement on maturity.
8. Importance of Euro-shares
Euro-shares present several advantages for companies taking recourse to them:
They improve the prestige of the company in the eyes of international financial
community. Such prestige is important for the groups that have a good part of
their turnover generated in foreign countries.
They facilitate the operations of external growth. A company quoted on a foreign
market may proceed to make public offers of exchange when it wants to have a
control on some enterprises quoted on the market.
They reinforce internationalization of capital. This internationalization ensures a
greater stability of capital since it allows an international diversification. Besides,
pension funds may invest in long-term international shares.
However, the fact that international investors become important participants in
this market poses numerous problems as regards control and management of the
group.
437
The IFC finances various projects in the private sector through loan and equity
participation. In contrast to IBRD or IDA, the IFC does not require government
guarantees; it emphasizes providing risk capital for manufacturing firms that have a
reasonable chance of earning adequate returns and providing economic benefits to the
community.
438
LIBOR
Euro-notes
Primary markets
Secondary markets
10. What role do development banks play in economic growth? Enumerate some of
the development banks and their functions.
439
In view of the above distinct characteristics, the finance manager engaged in international
business aims at reducing the exchange risk on the one hand and minimizing the float by
speedy transfer on the other.
Exchange rate risk may be covered or even avoided if billing is done in the national
currency. For the purpose, the finance manager may:
440
In order to reduce the float several techniques are used, for instance, telex, Swift
network, or lock-box. In the lock-box system, payments are directly addressed to a postal
box and collected each day by the bank, thus eliminating the postal as well as processing
time periods required before depositing the cheques in the bank. Lastly, the treasurer
limits the number of banks intervening in the banking circuit and addresses himself to
banks, having an international network and likely to make the transfer at the earliest.
Centralization of treasury generally permits to improve the management of foreign
currency flows. In selecting a technique, the finance manager should be guided by the
cost involved and benefits it has in terms of simplicity and speed of recovery.
The regional centre will be located preferably in a country of lower tax rates and without
exchange regulations such as Luxembourg, Bahamas, Switzerland and West Indies, etc.
441
An information system;
Planning of inflows and outflows;
A centre of decision which balances the flows and takes decisions relating to
treasury.
3. Information System
The treasurer of the regional centre or of the group should know the position of the cash
of subsidiaries on a day-to-day basis in a manner so as to be able to take appropriate
financial decisions (placement, use of short-term credit, compensation, etc.).
Centralization of the cash management at the regional level does not dispense a unit of
production or marketing from having its own treasury. The group or regional treasury
ensures coordination. It collects information based on which it could do cash planning.
Table 17.1(c) Company AM Netherlands
Forecast ($000)
January current year
Previous Balance: - 75
Day
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Receipts
200
300
250
150
200
Payments
220
350
200
160
210
Balance
-20
-50
+50
-10
-10
-40
These forecasts related to cash position of each subsidiary enable the regional centre to
effectively assess/manage the cash position.
The minimum cash required for each company may be estimated from the average cash
needed over the period. Once these needs are estimated, the regional centre should
ensure that needs are met and excess cash if any, is appropriately dealt with (i.e.
442
6. Management of receivables
The management of receivables in a multinational group should take into account several
factors, such as :
7. Intra-group Receivables
When a parent company has receivables of a subsidiary, it can use the technique of leads
and lags for advancing or delaying settlements as per its needs. For instance, in order to
finance an investment abroad it may decide to accord or make a subsidiary accord delays
longer than those accorded normally for the sale of capital equipment.
443
EUROCURRENCY MARKET
By V.K.Bhalla
INTRODUCTION
The Eurocurrency markets constitute the short-to-medium term debt part of the
international capital flow structure. The market is made by banks and other financial
institutions that accept time deposits and make loans in a currency or currencies other
than that of the country in which they are located. The latter characteristic defines the
Eurocurrency market it is a non-domestic financial intermediary. In the light of the
rapid growth of similar institutions in Hong Kong and Singapore (and to a lesser extent in
the Middle East) the market is new worldwide and is more appropriately called the
offshore or external money market. Growth of this new work of intermediaries has
been spectacular. The Eurocurrency market is extremely large and has grown rapidly in a
short interval. It has received a bad press from central banks, which continue to call it a
major cause of inflation and an obstacle to their control of domestic monetary systems. A
number of basic questions and issues crop up soon as one looks at the offshore capital
markets. First, what separates them from domestic markets? Second, why were they
needed and how could they grow so fast when sophisticated domestic capital markets
already existed? Third, is there a process of offshore money creation analogous to money
creation in a domestic banking system and what effect does this have on world inflation?
444
445
dealings in a way which they would rather forget, but which is instructive for us to
examine.
In the 1960s the European central banks were pegging exchange rates, and
absorbing growing dollar deficits. In the early 1960s these dollar deficits, which became
dollar reserves of the absorbing central banks, were matched by growth of U.S. official
obligations to foreign central banks in the U.S. balance of payments accounts. However,
in the late 1960s the European central banks were surprised to observe a growing
discrepancy between the change in U.S. official obligations to foreign central banks and
their own record of dollar reserves held. The central bankers kept getting more and more
dollars than the United States seemed to be losing on the official settlements definition of
the balance of payments. The well-known economist Fritz Machulp said of them, Most
magicians who pull rabbits out of their hats know full well that they put them there before
the beginning of the show. The magicians in . (this) story, however, are more naive,
they are just as surprised as the audience by the emergence of the rabbits from their hats.
What happened? Commonly when central banks undervalued their countries
currencies against the dollar they would take the dollars they received in pegging the
price and buy U.S. Treasury Bills with them. From an accounting viewpoint, the U.S.
deficit with Germany, say, equaled in dollar value the German surplus with the United
States. A U.S. deficit with Germany meant that more dollar cheques were written to
purchase DM and DM cheques were written to purchase dollars. The Bundesbank
became the owner of the excess U.S. demand deposits, which it used to purchase
Treasury bills. Thus the U.S. deficit was represented by these excess demand deposits
but entered the official settlements balance only when the demand deposits were
converted to bills.
Now suppose a foreign central bank decided to earn higher interest on its reserves
by converting its acquired U.S. demand deposits to Eurodollar CDs rather than Treasury
bills. As we have seen, such an action transfers the ownership of the U.S. demand
deposits representing the new foreign reserves to some private, offshore bank.
Originally, these U.S. deposits were turned into foreign exchange to create the capital
outflow that the European central bank absorbed. Subsequently they became the property
of the private foreign bank. This was not recorded on the official settlements part of the
balance of payments accounts though it certainly constituted foreign reserves created by
the deficit, just as before. This explains part of the mystery, but the best part is yet to
come.
Consider what might have happened to the Eurodollar deposits owned by the
foreign central banks. Under the fixed exchange rate system there were periodic
exchange crises, during which people would try to switch other currencies into DM or
Swiss francs in anticipation of appreciation. Frequently the offshore banks would lend
the dollar deposits of the Swiss and German central banks to speculators who convened
them into DM or Swiss francs. Under their exchange pegging policies, these tendered
dollars had to be absorbed by the central banks, who re-deposited in the offshore markets,
so that they could be lent again! This is the rabbit in the hat trick of which Machulp was
446
speaking. The central banks came to own very large Eurodollar claims by this circular
process, but these large claims were not on the United States but rather (indirectly) on the
speculators.
depositors receive better terms than they can receive onshore, and
borrowers can borrow more, possibly at lower rates, than they can
The rapid emergence in the 1960s of a world-wide Eurocurrency market that coexists and competes with traditional foreign exchange banking resulted from the
peculiarly stringent and detailed official regulations governing residents operating with
their own national currencies. These regulations contrast sharply with the relatively great
freedom of non-residents to make deposits or borrow foreign currencies from these same
constrained national banking systems. On an international scale, offshore unregulated
financial markets compete with onshore regulated ones. The differences in national
regulatory regimes and the internationsation of finance brought the birth of the Eurodollar
markets.
EURODOLLAR MARKETS
Eurodollars are bank deposit liabilities denominated in U.S.dollars but not subject
to U.s. banking regulations. For the most part, banks offering Eurodollar deposits are
located outside the United States. However since late 1981 non-U.S. residents have been
able to conduct business free of U.S. banking regulations at International Banking
Facilities (IBFs) in the United States. Eurodollar deposits may owned by individuals,
corporations, or governments from anywhere in the world, with the exception that only
non-U.S. residents can hold deposits at IBFs.
Originally, dollar-denominated deposits not subject to U.S. banking regulations
were held almost exclusively in Europe; hence, the name Eurodollars. Most such
deposits are still held in Europe, but they also are held at U.S. IBFs and in such places as
the Bahamas, Bahrain, Canada, and Cayman Islands, Hong Kong, Japan the Netherlands
Antilles, Panama, and Singapore. Regardless of where they are held, such deposits are
referred to as Eurodollars.
447
Bank in the Eurodollar market, including U.S. IBFs, compete with banks in the
United States to attract dollar-denominated funds. Since the Eurodollar market is
relatively free of regulation, banks in the Eurodollar market can operate on narrower
margins or spreads between dollar borrowing and lending rates than can banks in the
United States. This gives Eurodollar deposits an advantage relative to deposits issued by
banks operating under U.S. regulations. In short, the Eurodollar market has grown up
largely as a means of avoiding the regulatory costs involved in dollar-denominated
financial intermediation that contributed to the rise of the Eurodollar markets. Some of
the basic factors are: (i) U.S. financial regulation played a very large role in the creation
of the Eurodollar markets, especially Regulation Q.
(Restriction on currency
convertibility prevented the commercial exploitation of U.S. dollar held in Europe, while
low interest rates in the U.S. enforced by Regulation Q depressed the returns. This was
reinforced by Interest Equalization Tax in 1963.
These conditions were in part
responsible for the Eurodollar market centered in London). (ii) The U.S. balance of
payments deficits and to the accumulation of dollars stride the U.S. (iii) The U.S. dollar
was the key international currency for trading and for reserve purposes, (IV) No reserve
ratios were required in many of the countries, therefore, off-balance sheet funding outside
the regulatory controls was possible enabling the establishment of Eurodollar markets.
Within the turbulent environment the inter-bank (Eurodollar) market soon became
the central mechanism to channel international flows of funds amongst banks. This truly
international market linked the various components of the international financial system
to the corresponding domestic market.
The internationalization of finance placed international and national regulatory
systems era under further stress to liberalize financial markets and remove the long
standing barriers to trade in financial services. This trend enveloped several related
developments, most notably: some countries allowed foreign institutions a larger role in
domestic financial markets; the erosion of domestic restrictions on capital markets; and
the increasing integration of domestic and international markets.
These changes initiated national policies of liberalization and deregulation which
were designed to attract capital to these financial markets. Furthermore, they have been
characterized by a trend toward a breakdown in the segmentation of financial markets.
Distinctions among services offered by different financial institutions are blurring in
many countries, and national markets are becoming increasingly integrated
internationally. The nature and extent of these changes differ across countries, but almost
everywhere competition in financial markets has intensified.
448
currency for lending to a nonblank customer, perhaps after one or more redeposit from
one bank to another
The sum of all dollar-denominated liabilities of banks outside the United States
measures the gross size of the Eurodollar market. For some purposes, it is useful to net
some Interbank deposits out of the gross to arrive at an
Eurodollar market. For sum other purposes, such as comparing
of deposits created in the Eurodollar market with the U.S. monetary aggregates, it is
useful to further net out all banks owned Eurodollar deposits. Doing so leaves only the
nonblank portion of the net size measure, or what might be called the net-net size of the
Eurodollar market.
The most readily accessible estimates of the size of the Eurodollar market were
compiled by Morgan Guaranty Trust Company of New York and reported in the monthly
bank letter, World Financial Markets. Morgans estimates included data compiled by the
BIS. However, Morgans estimates were somewhat more comprehensive. Morgan
reported estimates of the size of the entire Eurocurrency market based roughly on all
foreign-currency liabilities of banks in major European countries, nine other market
areas, and U.S. IBFs. Morgan stopped publishing its Euromarkets data in 1988.
As of March 1988 Morgan estimated the gross size of the Eurocurrency market at
$4,561 billion; the net size was put at $2,587 billion. Morgan also reported that
Eurodollars made up 67 percent of gross Eurocurrency liabilities, putting the gross size of
the Eurodollar market at $3,056 billion. No net size for the Eurodollar market was given.
However, 67 percent of the net size of the Eurocurrency market yields $1,733 billion as
an approximate measure of the net size of the Eurodollar market.
M2 is the narrowest U.S. monetary aggregate that includes some Eurodollar
deposits. M2 includes overnight Eurodollar deposits held by U.S. residents other than
depository institutions and money market funds at branches of U.S. banks worldwide. As
of May 1991, M2 measures $3,396 billion; its Eurodollar component was $ 17.8 billion.
This comparison shows clearly that Eurodollar deposits account for a relatively small
portion of monetary assets held by U.S. residents.
449
located outside the United States or in a U.S. IBF. From their introduction in 1966, the
volume of Eurodollar CDs outstanding reached roughly $ 50 billion at the beginning of
1980. By late 1990, Eurodollar CD volume was around $ 130 billion. The 1990
elimination of the 3 percent reserve requirement on nonpersonal time deposits and CDs in
the United States has made the Eurodollar CDE market a bit less active. In 1992, volume
had fallen to around $ 116 billion.
Recently, fixed-rate, three-month Eurodollar CDs have yielded approximately 10
basis points below the three-month London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR). LIBOR is
the rate at which major international banks are willing to offer term Eurodollar deposits
to each other. An active secondary market allows investors to sell Eurodollar CDs before
the deposits mature. Secondary market makers spreads for short-term fixed-rate CDs
have been 1 to 3 basis points for European bank dollar CDs and around 5 basis points for
Japanese bank dollar CDs.
Eurodollar CDs are issued by banks to tap the market for funds and are commonly
issued in denominations of from $250,000 to $5 million. Some Eurodollar CDs, called
Tranche CDs, are issued in very large denominations but marketed in several portions in
order to satisfy investors with preferences for smaller instruments. The latter are issued
in aggregate amounts of $10 million to $30 million and are offered by banks to individual
investors in $10,000 certificates, with each certificate having the same interest rate, issue
date, interest payment dates, and maturity.
In the late 1970s Eurodollar floating-rate CDs (FRCDs) and Eurodollar floatingrate notes (FRNs) came into use as means of protecting both borrower and lender against
interest rate risk. By making their coupon payments float with market interest rates, these
floaters stabilize the principal value of the paper. The market for FRCDs is no longer
active. The volume of FRNs outstanding fell from $125 in 1986 to $ 116 in 1990.
Eurodollar FRNs have been issued in maturities from 4 to 20 years, with the
majority of issues concentrated in the five-to seven- year range. Eurodollar FRNs tend to
be seen as an alternative to straight fixed-interest bonds, but they can in principle be used
like FRCDs. Eurodollar FRNs have bee3n issued primarily by banks and sovereign
governments. FRNs issued by governments are not Eurodollars proper since they are not
bank liabilities. Strictly speaking, they should be referred to as Eurodollar instruments
together with the NIFs and Euro commercial paper discussed below.
Eurodollar FRCDs and FRN are both negotiable bearer paper. The coupon or
interest rate on these instruments is reset relative to the corresponding LIBOR every three
or six months. The rate is set below LIBOR for sovereign borrowers and above for U.S.
banks. Yields on Eurodollar FRNs range from 1/8 percent under the London Interbank
Bid Rate (LIBID) up to LIBOR. To determine LIBOR for Eurodollar FRNs, the issuer
chooses an agent bank offices of major international banks. Rates are those prevailing at
11.00 a.m. London time two business days prior to the commencement of the next
coupon period.
450
A secondary market exists in FRNs. The spread quoted on FRNs in the secondary
market is generally 10 cents per $100 face value for the liquid sovereign issues. Other
spreads are quoted on an indicative basis and are somewhat higher.
Note issuance Facilities (NIFs) became a significant Eurodollar instrument in the mid1980s. A NIF is a medium-term, usually five to seven-year arrangement between a
borrower and an underwriting bank under which the borrower can issue short-term,
usually three- to six month, paper known as Euro-notes in its own name. Under such
an arrangement, the underwriting bank is committed either to purchase any notes the
borrower cannot sell or to provide standby credit at a predetermined spread relative to
some reference rate such as LIBOR. Underwriting fees are paid on the full amount of the
line of credit, regardless of the amount currently drawn. The fees are 5 basis points for
top borrowers and ranges up to 15 basis points for worse credit risks. The notes are
issued with face amounts of $100,000, $500,000, or more.
Well-regarded borrowers can issue Euro-notes at around LIBID. Top borrowers
can issue at yields 1 / 16 or 1/8 percentage point below LIBID. Euro-notes are
comparable investments to Eurodollar CDs.
When the market initially matured around 1985, nonblank corporate borrowers
accounted for roughly 60 percent of NIFs arranged. Most borrowers were from countries
in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. As of April 1986,
about $75 billion of NIFs has been arranged, with only an estimated $10 to $ 15 billion
having been drawn. Most paper was placed with smaller, non-underwriter banks. In
1985, about one-third or more of placements may have been with nonblank investors,
including money market funds, corporations, insurance companies, wealthy individuals,
and central banks.
Since mid-1984, facilities similar to NIFs have been arranged without
underwriting commitments.
In the second half of 1985, new non-underwritten
agreements equaled new NIFs arranged. Non-underwritten become much like U.S.
commercial paper programmes: note issuance has been separated from the standby a
arrangement, notes are issued in shorter odd maturities, and notes can be marketed
quickly Under such an arrangement, a bank is simply a marketing agent. Euro-notes
issued under such conditions are known as Euro commercial paper. The volume of
newly arranged NIFs declined from $40 billion in 1985 to $4 billion in 1990, while Euro
commercial paper outstanding rose from $ 17 billion in 1986 to $ 70 billion in 1990.
Recently strengthened risk-based capital requirements have, in part, induced the shift to
Euro commercial paper because they have raised the regulatory cost associated with
NIFs. Euro commercial paper yields range from LIBID minus 25 basis points for toprated sovereigns to LIBOR plus 30 for low-rated corporations.
For most U.S. corporations, the U.S. commercial paper market probably remains a
cheaper source of funds than Euro commercial paper. For some non-U.S. corporations,
however, Euro commercial paper may be as cheap as U.S. commercial paper because of
the premium that foreign issuers pay in the U.S. commercial paper market. Like the U.S.
451
commercial paper market, the secondary market for Euro commercial paper is relatively
underdeveloped. If a client needs to sell paper before maturity he will almost always sell
it to the dealer who sold him the paper initially. Any trading usually occurs in the first
few days after the paper is issued. Trading is most frequent in the sovereign sector,
which accounts for about 20 percent of Euro commercial paper outstanding.
CREATION OF EURODOLLARS
Eurodollar markets are well organized, very efficient, and very large. They serve
a number of valuable purposes for multinational business operations. Eurodollars are a
convenient money market device for multinational firms to hold their excess liquidity.
Eurodollars are a major source of short-term loans to finance corporate working capital
needs and foreign trade. Many multinational companies and governments have learned
to employ the Eurodollar market as readily as they do the domestic or banking system.
The major sources of Eurodollars are (1) the growing dollar reserves of oil-exporting
countries, (2) foreign governments or businessmen who prefer to hold dollars outside the
United States, (3) foreign banks with dollars in excess of current needs, and (4)
multinational companies with excess cash balances. Since the 1974 oil crisis, oilexporting countries have had enough leverage on the worldwide oil supply to impose a
major price escalation. As a result, the Middle East, where more than half of the worlds
known oil reserves are located, has acquired enormous economic wealth and has become
the important source of Eurodollars. Once Eurodollars come into existence, they can
create themselves through the lending and investing activities of commercial banks. Taccounts may be used to illustrate such Eurodollar creation.
Example 1
Assume that the International Trading Company holds $1,000 on deposit in a
New York bank. If the reserve requirement is 20 percent, the $1,000 deposit will be
reflected in the books of the New York bank, the International Trading Company, and the
Federal Reserve Bank of New York as follows:
Cash flows in a commercial bank involve four major elements of information: (1)
currency, (2) institution and location, (3) maturity date, and (4) interest rate. To better
understand how bank transfers take place and how Eurodollars come into existence, let us
examine a few transactions.
Step 1. Assume that the International Trading Company decides to transfer its
$1,000 deposit from the New York bank to a London bank. Let us further assume that
the International Trading Company decides to maintain its dollars in a dollardenominated 90-day deposit account at the going rate with the London bank. This
situation will be reflected in the books of the New York bank, the London bank, the
London bank, and the International Trading Company as follows:
452
By this step, a Eurodollar deposit has been created. The London bank has now
obtained the power to deal in dollars outside the United however, that total deposit levels
in the United States have not changed; the $1,000 liability of the London bank is matched
deposit in the New York bank. The only change at the New York bank was in the name
of the depositor from the International Trading Company to the London bank.
Step 2. Because the London bank has to pay interest on its 90-day deposit
liability to the International Trading Company, it decides to extend a Eurodollar loan of
$1,000 to a Paris firm. This loan transaction will be reflected in the books of the London
bank and the Paris firm as follows:
Because the New York bank still has $1,000 deposit liability to the London bank,
its balance sheet has not changed. But the London bank has increased its deposits and
loans by $1,000. This expands the total Eurodollar deposit liabilities of non-U.S. banks
to $2,000. The International Trading Company now holds $1,000 of Eurodollars with the
London bank and the Paris firm has an additional $1,000 of Eurodollars in the London
bank.
The London bank exhausted its dollar lending capacity. Thus, if the Paris firm
had held its dollar deposit with the London bank, the multiple creations of Eurodollars
would have stopped. However, if the Paris firm withdraws its dollar deposits from the
London bank and deposits it with a Paris bank, the Eurodollar creation process could
continue.
Step 3: Assume that the Paris firm withdraws its deposit from the London bank
and deposits it in a Paris bank. The following set of T-accounts record the event.
After Step 3 the amount of Eurodollars is still $2,000, but the Paris bank has
obtained Eurodollar deposits that it can lend out. The potential expansion of Eurodollars
is infinite in the case where banks do not maintain any reserves a against their Eurodollar
deposits.
453
the immense pressures they have experienced in the 1970s, starting with the oil embargo
and the recycling of the petro-dollars. We must explain this remarkable record of
solvency. The key to any such explanation is the principle that in an unregulated banking
system the riskiness of a banks loan portfolio will be policed by depositors. They have
no choice. In a regulated system, depositors have little or no incentive to care how or to
whom their bank lends. The bank inspectors are a necessary corollary of regulation and
deposit insurance.
The two principle sources of risk for banks are:
1) bad loans, and
2) Default due to dependence on maturity transformation and the occurrence of an
unfavorable term structure.
The bad loan problem is the same for domestic as for foreign banks for the most
part. The striking thing about the Euro banking system is its restraint in the matter of
maturity transformation. Perhaps 90% or more of Euro credit its are on a floating rate
basis. Regardless of maturity, the usual adjustment being at six-month intervals. Thus
the borrower is obliged to compensate the lender for the cost of six-month money and the
only effective maturity transformation is from liabilities of less than six months maturity
to these six-month assets.
There are a number of differences between dealing in Euromarkets and dealing in
domestic money markets. Two important features characterize the Eurocurrency market:
the absence of reserve requirement and the international character of the competitive
advantage in dealing with reservable transactions that is, those involving lending to
corporations or other non-banks in comparison to its domestic counterparts. It was, of
course, from this competitive advantage that the rapid growth of the Euromarkets
originally sprang. A corollary of the absence of reserve requirements is the absence of
direct control by central banks. This means that there is at least in theory no direct
lender of last resort for the Euromarkets. Central bankers are gradually feeling their way
toward some partial solutions of this problem, but the situation is certainly not as clearcut as in each countrys domestic markets.
The international character of the Eurocurrency market means that, like the
foreign exchange market, the Euromarkets does not exist in any particular location. It
consists of participants all around the world linked together by telephones, telexes, and
increasingly by computerized information systems, such as those provided by Reuters
and Telerate. It is therefore a continuous market, starting in the Far East and running
throughout the Middle East and Europe until it comes around to San Francisco, which
over laps again with the Far East. The international nature of the market raises a number
of problems, not the least of which is language and telecommunications problems. More
important, though, there are a number of gray legal areas, such as jurisdiction, the
acceptability of a freeze on deposits in one country by another country whose currency is
being traded in the first country, the question of whether booking a loan in one centre
rather than another is merely legitimate tax planning, or tax evasion, and many other
454
questions that have not been fully resolved. Because the Euromarkets is a fluid and
evolving market, certainly the most dynamic deposit dealing market in the world, many
of these questions probably will never be finally settled; in some respects this is probably
for the best since the innovative capacity of the market has depended greatly on its
relative freedom from bureaucratic regulations.
Another important feature of the market in which it differs from domestic markets
is that it is a purely wholesale market. Although some banks in the United States allow
some individual customers to place funds through them into the Euromarkets with a view
to obtaining a better return, trading in the Euromarkets proper is typically done in blocks
of $1 million and upward. The major advantage, again, is the relative freedom from
regulation in a wholesale market compared with the retain banking market, which is
typically heavily regulated in many countries.
Finally, another significant difference between the Euromarkets and many
domestic deposit markets is that the Euromarkets is almost exclusively concerned with
matched deposit dealing. That is, each deposit (liability) of an international bank will
tend to be matched by an asset (usually a deposit in another bank) of the same currency
and of similar maturity. Deliberate mismatches might be incurred with a view to making
a profit, but the book of each bank as a whole will be matched within certain periods.
Hence loans are typically made for a specified period and funded by a deposit of a similar
period. This is very different from a domestic market where typically large amounts of
lending are done on the basis of a prime (or base) rate, with these loans being funded day
to day in the domestic overnight or short-date money market, or from normal customer
deposits.
455
TABLE -1.
Typical Eurobank Balance Sheet Components.
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Liabilities
Interbank deposits
Nonbank time deposits
London dollar and other currencies CDs
Notes and bonds
Loans from other branches
Loans from parent bank
Equity capital held by parent bank.
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Assets
Reserve balances
Liquid assets
Interbank loans
Other loans
banks. Interbank deposits, non bank time deposits, and London dollar CDs represent the
bulk of the liabilities of a Eurobank. Interbank transactions bulk particularly large and
we will shortly see why. The final depositor in the Eurocurrency market can choose
among two major financial instruments. Most funds are raised by fixed time deposits
(TDs), the other source being certificates of deposit (CDs). The maturities of time
deposits range from one day to several years but most of them are in the one week to six
months range. Negotiable certificates of two different forms: the top CDs issued in
single amounts by certificates of two different forms: the top CDs issued in single
amounts by a bank, which remain an Interbank financial instrument; and the Tranche
CDs, which are managed issues by several banks and denominated in smaller amounts, so
that they can be attractive to corporations and individual investors.
While borrowers often want to borrow for longer than five years, CDs are not
currently issued for any longer maturities. Thus there have developed forward CDs,
whereby a bank will issue and other banks will agree to contract CDs at a fixed or
floating interest rate at some given future date. This device allows banks to make
medium term loans to corporations or governments which extend beyond five years and
be certain of available resources.
Loans in a specific currency are priced according to a LIBOR plus principle.
Three parameters usually determine the cost: a commitment fee, which is per annum fee
expressed as a per cent on the undrawn, uncancelled portion of the loan; a front end fee
which is a one-time payment, expressed as a percentage of the amount of the loan,
usually paid shortly after the signing of the loan; and a spread which is the percent per
annum margin added to the banks cost of funds, which is LIBOR. The sum of these
pricing elements allows us to determine a total spread, which is annualized and represents
the total margin of the loan expressed as an annualized percentage over LIBOR. Under
this pricing procedure, the most common in the Eurocurrency market, Euro loans are
floating rate loans which depend on the value of LIBOR. The total spread over LIBOR
varies with market conditions. Historically it has varied between % to 3%. If one
compares the pricing of Euro loans with domestic loans, the principle difference are as
follows:
Euroloans do not involve compensating balances but rather involve
commitment fees on the unused part of credit lines, and the front-end fee has become of
substantial importance in the Euromarkets. Since credit standing is measured by markup
over LIBOR, there has arisen a willingness of weaker borrowers to trade larger front-end
fees for lower markups. On a present-value basis the outcome is equivalent, but a lower
markup is supposed to have cosmetic advantages.
457
458
trade rather than transactions with non-bank depositors or non-bank borrowers. The BIS
figures for the size of the Eurocurrency system net out all the Interbank transactions. The
BIS figures, which are the most commonly reported ones, treat the system only as a
financial intermediary. If the covered interest arbitrage and foreign exchange hedging
aspects of the market are considered, a good part of the inter-bank transactions represent
legitimate economic transactions and not just reshuffling of funds within the network of
intermediaries.
ILLUSTRATIVE PROBLEMS
1. XYZ Trading Co. of the United Kingdom receives $1,000,000 in payment for exports
to ABC Electronics Philadelphia, Pa. (XYZ Co., banks with Barclays- London, and ABC
banks with Philadelphia Security Bank. S0 $/ = 1.35.)
a) XYZ Trading Co. keeps amount in deposit in Philadelphia Security Bank.
b) XYZ Trading Co. asks its bank to transfer export proceeds to its account in
pounds sterling.
c) Instead of (b), XYZ Trading Co. transfers dollar proceeds from Philadelphia
Security Bank, and places it with its own bank as a time deposit denominated in
dollars.
Show the above transactions in T-accounts of Barclays and Philadelphia Security Bank.
459
Transaction (3)
Shanghai-Hong Kong Bank makes a loan of $900,000 to Nestle Co.,
(Netherlands). Nestle Co. deposits the cheques in its account with the National Bank of
the Netherlands and asks its bank to credit its account with the equivalent in Dutch
guilders. (The exchange rate on the value date of the transaction is S0 F1/$ is 2.7750.)
Transaction (4)
The National Bank of the Netherlands makes a loan of $ 750,000 to Nova
Industries (Denmark). Nova Industries uses the loan to settle an import transaction from
Bristol Myers (N.Y.). Bristol Myers maintains its accounts with Chase Manhattan Bank
(N.Y.).
(b) Total amount of Eurodollar deposits created is $1,000,000 (time deposit of Algemene
Bank with Shanghai-Hong Kong Bank denominated in U.S. dollars).
(c) The value of the Eurodollar deposit multiplier here is unity.
multiplier depends on:
460
Transaction No. 2. The German Central Bank transfers its deposits to a German
commercial bank. (Sometimes this is done as part of domestic monetary policy in which
case the Central Bank exchanges dollar deposits for deutsche marks with the commercial
banks. The objective is to reduce credit in the domestic market and give incentives for
capital outflows.)
Transaction No. 3. A French importer asks for a Euro-loan from the German
Commercial bank. Assuming that the commercial bank keeps a precautionary reserve of
10%, it can make a loan in the amount of $90.
Transaction No. 4. The French importer uses the Euro-loan to pay a debt owned to a
German exporter.
Transaction No. 5. The German Exporter deposits its dollar balances with the German
commercial bank.
Transaction No. 6. Citibank wishes to borrow Euro-dollars from the German commercial
bank to take care of anticipated loan demand.
Transaction No. 7. Citibank wishes to make a loan. In order to convert the deposit at
Chase into lendable funds it asks Chase to provide cash or deposits with the Federal
Reserve Bank. Since Chase was fully loaned-up, it has to sell some loans in order to
collect the required amount of cash.
Show these transactions in T-accounts of the banks involved in the transactions.
Ans:
The transactions described below are represented by T accounts at end.
Transaction No. 1.
Chase: There is only a change in deposit ownership from Mr. Smith to the German
central bank.
German Central Bank: There is an exchange of assets from securities to deposits.
Money supply in U.S. and Germany remains constant.
Balance of payments of each country has offsetting entries.
Transaction No. 2.
Chase: There is only a change in deposit ownership from German central bank to the
German commercial bank.
German Central Bank: An exchange of assets from claims on Chase to claims on the
German commercial banks.
461
The assets
462
Balance of payments of France and Germany has similar effects to the ones described in
Transaction 3.
Transaction No. 5.
Chase: There is only a transfer in ownership of deposits.
German Exporter: A change in type of assets.
German Commercial Banks: Another Euro-dollar deposit has been created.
Money supply in U.S. remains unaffected.
Money supply in Germany has increased by the size of the new Euro-dollar deposit.
Balance of payments of U.S. is unaffected.
Balance of payments of Germany is unaffected.
463
Transaction No. 6.
Chase: There is only a transfer of ownership in the deposits.
German Commercial Banks: Decreases its claims on Chase, but increases its claims on
Citibank by a fraction of their Euro-dollar balances.
Citibank: It has acquired a claim on chase, and a Euro-dollar debt.
Money supply of U.S. and Germany remain constant.
Balance of payments of both countries which can now be lent.
Transaction No. 7.
Chase: It has $81 of excess reserves which can now be lent.
Money supply in U.S. remains constant as the deposits created by Citibank are really at
the expense of the deposits and loans that Chase gave up.
Balance of payments remains unaffected.
3. XYZ Trading Co., of the United Kingdom receives $1,000,000 in payment for exports
to ABC Electronic of Philadelphia, Pa. (XYZ Co. banks with Barclays-London, and ABC
banks with Philadelphis Security Bank S0 $/ = 1.25.)
a) XYZ Trading Co. keeps amount in deposit in Philadelphia Security Bank.
b) XYZ Trading Co. asks its bank to transfer export proceeds to its account in
pounds sterling.
c) Instead of (b), XYZ Trading Co. transfers dollar proceeds from Philadelphia
Security Bank, and places it with its own bank as a time deposit denominated in
dollars.
Show the above transactions in T accounts of Barclays and Philadelphia Security Bank.
464
QUESTIONS
1.
Outline the major factors that have been responsible for the growth in the
Eurocurrency markets, particularly the Eurodollar component of these markets.
Which of these factors are still significant in fostering the use of these markets
by investors and borrowers?
2. Under what circumstances would a financial manager of an MNC consider using
Eurocurrency markets? What advantages or special features can these markets
offer compared to borrowing from domestic markets? Are there drawbacks?
Explain.
3. Is there a multiplier process in the placement of Eurocurrency deposits and
subsequent Eurocurrency loans granted by financial institutions which receive
these deposits? What are the major factors determining the size of the multiplier
coefficient?
4. There are several methods of measuring the size of the Eurocurrency market.
Comment on this statement and list the reasons for these different measurements.
5. Why are Eurocurrency deposit rates closely related to rates obtainable on
instruments of corresponding maturity in home money markets? For example,
why is the overnight Eurodollar rate closely aligned to the federal funds rate in
the U.S. money market? Why is the former deposit rate usually (but not always)
higher by some 25 to 50 basis points than the latter?
6. What is LIBOR? What determines the spread over LIBOR charged borrowers
for Eurocurrency credits and loans?
7. Discuss the major advantages which the syndicated Eurocurrency loan market
offers to lenders and borrowers, compared to domestic lending operations. Why
is the quoted rate (spread over LIBOR) not an accurate indicator of the cost of a
typical syndicated Eurocurrency loan?
8. List the major factors that are responsible for the growth of the international
bond market. Indicate which of these factors (or other considerations) explain
the large number of innovations in this market.
9. Distinguish between a Eurobond and a foreign bond. List the major participants
in this market. Why does the share of developing countries in this market
remain fairly modest?
10. Define (a) a multiple-currency Eurobond, (b) a dual currency convertible bond,
and (c) a floating-rate Eurocurrency note. Explain in each case the distribution
of risk (the exchange rate risk or the interest rate risk) between the lender
(investor) and the borrower (issuer).
11. How do you explain the yield differentials among Eurobonds dominated in
different currencies? Does interest parity operate in the capital market (as it does
in the international money market) to eliminate these differentials on a covered
basis? Do you except an alignment between the yield on a Eurodollar bond and a
dollar bond of the same risk grade and maturity?
465
International
Financial Management
[ Instructions to Faculty]
466
Learning Unit 7
Instructions to faculty
F. International Financial Management
General:
1. This subject may be totally new to most participants. Even persons with economics
background may feel uncomfortable. Therefore, while administering this learning
unit, faculty may ensure that they are:
a. Explicit about the objectives of the learning unit
b. Make a comprehensive presentation on the fundamental principles relating
to International Financial Management using the material provided in
visual aids Nos. 47-52 given below.
c. Ensure that they explain the concepts with simple examples; faculty may
avoid the difficult mathematical concepts while transacting the unit.
d. Make reference to the Guide to Learning Activity provided for this unit.
467
Faculty will need to refer extensively to the reading material provided for this learning
unit
Faculty will need to refer extensively to the reading material provided for this learning
unit
468
Faculty will need to refer extensively to the reading material provided for this learning
unit
Faculty will need to refer extensively to the reading material provided for this learning
unit
Faculty will need to refer extensively to the reading material provided for this learning
unit
469
Faculty will need to refer extensively to the reading material provided for this learning
unit
Group Activities
After making a comprehensive presentation based on the above points, faculty should
divide participants into four groups for group activities described in the handout on
Group Activities for Learning Unit 7.
The Group Activities include discussion and solutions to 15 specific problems, which the
groups are required to address in the following groups:
Group A:
Group B:
Group C:
Group D:
Problems 1-4
Problems 5-8
Problems 9-12
Problems 13-15
After the presentations on the problems mentioned above, all participants will be required
to study the issues raised in two case studies on Guns and Helicopters, which are also
given in the handout on Group Activities for Learning Unit 7.
470