Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 24 views

    Plagiarism Concluded: Scheduling Note

    Uploaded by

    cindyn_46
    This document contains notes from an anthropology class on the topic of the Gujarat fishery as a human-ecological system. It discusses how development of the Gujarat fishery led to ecological and institutional problems due to inattention to other concerns besides increasing human well-being. It outlines the dynamics and effects of fisheries development, including four phases from the 1950s to the present. Specifically, it examines the ecological, socioeconomic, and institutional effects, noting issues related to scale, complexity, and lack of precautionary planning. The conclusion discusses relevant human-ecological concepts and complexity in the Gujarat fishery system. Finally, it analyzes reasons for the institutional failure in managing the fisher

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Plagiarism Concluded: Scheduling Note

    Uploaded by

    cindyn_46
    24 views4 pages
    This document contains notes from an anthropology class on the topic of the Gujarat fishery as a human-ecological system. It discusses how development of the Gujarat fishery led to ecological and institutional problems due to inattention to other concerns besides increasing human well-being. It outlines the dynamics and effects of fisheries development, including four phases from the 1950s to the present. Specifically, it examines the ecological, socioeconomic, and institutional effects, noting issues related to scale, complexity, and lack of precautionary planning. The conclusion discusses relevant human-ecological concepts and complexity in the Gujarat fishery system. Finally, it analyzes reasons for the institutional failure in managing the fisher

    Original Description:

    -

    Original Title

    130121_2430

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    This document contains notes from an anthropology class on the topic of the Gujarat fishery as a human-ecological system. It discusses how development of the Gujarat fishery led to ecological and institutional problems due to inattention to other concerns besides increasing human well-being. It outlines the dynamics and effects of fisheries development, including four phases from the 1950s to the present. Specifically, it examines the ecological, socioeconomic, and institutional effects, noting issues related to scale, complexity, and lack of precautionary planning. The conclusion discusses relevant human-ecological concepts and complexity in the Gujarat fishery system. Finally, it analyzes reasons for the institutional failure in managing the fisher

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    24 views4 pages

    Plagiarism Concluded: Scheduling Note

    Uploaded by

    cindyn_46
    This document contains notes from an anthropology class on the topic of the Gujarat fishery as a human-ecological system. It discusses how development of the Gujarat fishery led to ecological and institutional problems due to inattention to other concerns besides increasing human well-being. It outlines the dynamics and effects of fisheries development, including four phases from the 1950s to the present. Specifically, it examines the ecological, socioeconomic, and institutional effects, noting issues related to scale, complexity, and lack of precautionary planning. The conclusion discusses relevant human-ecological concepts and complexity in the Gujarat fishery system. Finally, it analyzes reasons for the institutional failure in managing the fisher

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 4

    21/01/2013

    Scheduling note

    We are one class behind For this week:


    o o

    Plagiarism concluded
    Anth2430 - Winter 2013 Instructor: Dr. Derek Johnson Monday, January 21

    Anthropology topic on Wednesday Engineering topic on Friday

    Friday and Mondays classes will be combined and given next Monday (Jan 28)

    Plagiarism and not plagiarism examples


    Original text using correct referencing: No one denies that Rapa Nui was largely deforested by the time the Europeans first arrived in 1722. (Hunt and Lipo 2009: 602)

    Plagiarism and not plagiarism examples


    Correct referencing: In the literature on the ecological impact of humans on Easter Island, [n]o one denies that Rapa Nui was largely deforested by the time the Europeans first arrived in 1722 (Hunt and Lipo 2009: 602). It is clear, rather, that the crux of the debate lies elsewhere.

    Plagiarism: Inserting the sentence into your essay without


    o o

    Quotation marks and citation With citation but without quotation marks
    3 4

    Plagiarism and not plagiarism paraphrasing


    No one denies that Rapa Nui was largely deforested by the time the Europeans first arrived in 1722. (Hunt and Lipo 2009: 602)

    Plagiarism resources
    http://umanitoba.ca/student/resource/stude nt_advocacy/AI-and-Student-ConductTutorials.html

    Paraphrasing Acceptable: Hunt and Lipo (2009: 602) note that when the first Europeans reached Easter Island in 1722, the island was almost completely denuded of trees. Unacceptable: It is undeniable that Easter Island was largely deforested by the time the Europeans arrived in 1722.
    o o

    Without citation, plagiarism With citation, borderline. If consistent through paper, plagiarism.

    21/01/2013

    The Gujarat fishery as a human-ecological system 2

    The Gujarat fishery as a humanecological system

    Gujarat fisherys HE dilemma


    o o

    Development to increase human wellbeing Inattention to other concerns

    Led to ecological and institutional problems

    Final

    final

    The Gujarat fishery as a HE system: Concepts


    Dynamics: Fisheries development


    System
    o

    Regular and irregular change normal Challenge: non-resilient dynamics


    Too much emphasis on economic growth through increased productivity 2. Failure to build management institutions
    1.

    Showed partiality of my perspective Fishery is fragmented into multiple groups and lacks institutional mechanisms for inclusion

    Diversity
    o

    E.g. gear groups; classes; castes; religious groups; gender groups

    final

    Dynamics: Fisheries development

    Dynamics: Fisheries development

    Interaction, adaptation, agency?

    Four phases
    1950s to 1980s: State-led modernisation Late 1980s to 1997: The globalised fishery 3. 1997 to c.2004: The globalised fishery in crisis 4. c.2005 to present: Recovery, variability, and erosion of state support
    1. 2.

    21/01/2013

    Fisheries development: effects


    Fisheries development: effects


    Ecological Socio-economic Institutional

    Ecological Socio-economic Institutional


    (Pauly 2005)

    final

    final

    Fisheries development: effects


    Fisheries development: effects


    Ecological Socio-economic Institutional

    Ecological Socio-economic Institutional

    final

    final

    Fisheries development: effects

    Fisheries development: effects

    Scale: local-global connections now major economic driver

    Complexity
    o

    Scale and density of connections

    final

    final

    21/01/2013

    Fisheries development: effects

    Conclusion on HE concepts and Gujarat fishery

    Complexity
    o o

    Absence of precautionary planning Path dependency

    final

    final

    Why the institutional failure?


    State side The 1950s and 1960s context The legacy of top-down approaches to development Vegetarianism and the marginal fishery Fisher side Fishery grew too fast and rewards were too great Dominant players in fishery did not identify with fishing Indigenous institutions had strong legal systems, but not for resource conservation
    final

    You might also like