From edited Sabzavari commentary, Ghurar al-Fara'id or Sharh-e Manzumeh. Glossary in the book. Arabic-English
Copyright:
Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 81
At a glance
Powered by AI
The document discusses Mulli Hadi Sabzawari, a 19th century Persian philosopher. It provides biographical details about his life, education, works, and influence.
The document is a biography of Mulli Hadi Sabzawari, discussing his life, education, major works, and influence as one of the most important Persian philosophers of the 19th century.
Some of the key terms discussed include Sharh-i Manzumah, a work by Sabzawari analyzing different schools of Islamic philosophy, and other philosophical and theological concepts referenced in his writings.
- -,
SHARH-I GHURAR AL-FARA'ID
" or SHARH-I MANZUMAH .. I H. M. H. SABZAWARI Part One METAPHYSICS. Edited bv , M. MOHAGHEGH & T. IZUTSU Third Edition Tehran , 1991
BastinaObjave Web SfraniCa 1Q promicanJe univenalnih vrl)ednosti Ob)Qvt i mlSaomh postlgnuca lovltka u oknlju Objavr SHARH-I GHURAR AL-FARA)ID or SHARH-I MANZUMAH_I H. M. H. SABZAWARI .Part One METAPHYSICS Edited by M. MOHAGHEGH & T. IZUTSU Third Edition T ehrall, 1 990 SABZAWARI, A NINETEENTH CENTURY PERSIAN PHILOSOPHER M MOHAGHEGH Mullli HAdi Sobzawad, the greatest of Persian philosophers and mystics of the nineteenth century, was born in the year 1797 in Sabzawlir. This city, situated between Tehrlin and Mashhad in the province of Khuraslin, was famous as a centre of learning and scholarship for centuries. Sabzawad began his studies when only seven years old and completed his education in Persian, Arabic grammar and rbetoric at a very early age. In order to pursue his studies in theology and j urispr udence he went to the city of Mash- had, where he remained for five years. From there, hearing of the fame of Mullli 'Ali Nod as a master of philosophy, he went to Isfahan to study under him. Isfahan, it should be noted, was at that period a maj or cenlre of Islamic studies, especially philosopby and logic. Sabzawari remai ned for eight years in Isfahin, where he com- pleled Ihe rational parI of Islamic studies. Then he returned to Sabzawnr and began to teach in a madrasah. After a few years his fame became so great that disciples from all over Irlin, as well as from India and the Arab world, came to the small city of Sabzawar t o benefit from his vast knowledge and also to benefit from his personal conduct as a !'iorl guide. Sabza- wad's life was exlremely simple; he lived in a small and humble dwelling, and bis food and clolhing were kept at the level of mere subsistence. When the Qajar king a ~ i r ai-Din Shah visited the philosopher, he was surprised by this great simplicity. Sabzawad understood the king's surprise and recited this verse: If the house is humble and dark I shall give you a place 10 sit in my bright eyes. ' 1 M. M. Chahardehi. Lift and Philosophy of Mulld Hadl Sabzawdri (TehrAn: r.huri Book,hop, 1955). p. 49. 4 Subzaworl, a Nineteenfh Century Persian Pldlosopher As a master of theoretical. philosophy and anexemplar of its practice, Sabzawari continued to teac h and to direct students for forty years. His death occurred in 1872. Sabzawad was a prolific and industrious scholar; he wrote many books, both in Arabic and in Persian, on logic, philosophy, theology and mysticism. Besides these, he wrote a volume of Persian poetry and a commentary on the Malhnawl of the great Persian mysticpoet, Jal al ai-Din Ruml. The most famous of Sabzawad's writings is the S h a r ~ i ManlrJmah. This work, written in Arabic, consists of a series of poems on the essential questions of philosophy with the author's own commentary. In a remarkable way Sabzawarl has been able to gather and analyse in this work the ideas of many differeut schools of IslAmic philosophy. The S h a r ~ i Man,amah has gained great popUlarity among students of both religion and philosophy in Iran where it is still used as a text-boole. It is noteworthy that during the past 100 years at least five important commentaries have been written on this book and several lithographed editions of it have come out. The Sharh-i Man,amah is divided into seven books, each of which is divided into several cbapters and each chapter into several sectioos. Books one and two are the most basic parts of the whole work; they deal with the problems of existence, essence, sub,tance and accident. The rest of tho boole is devoted to theology and natural philosophy. In view of the important contribution of Sabzawari to philoso phical thought, Prot. T. lzutsu of tho Institute of [slamic Studies at McGill (Montv,al, Canada) and myself decided to prepare an English translation of books one and two of tbe Sharh-i Man,amah in order to introduce a yet relatively unknown thinker to Western Icholarship. Part one of the translation has been publi shed in the Islamic . series of McGill University Press.' We also published a critical edition of the Arabk text, which is the first volume of a series called Persian Wisdom (Danish-i [rani). It was also published by the Institute of Islamic Studies at its Tehran Branch in 1969. 1 Supra, p. 39. n. 1. M. MOH AGH EGH 5 It is not possible to deal with all aspects or even a substantial part of this work in the present paper, but in accordance with the Persian proverb: "Since you cannot pour out the water of the riVer, drink at least enough to satisfy your thirst," I shall try to present a brief survey of Sabzawllri's position regard- ing the problem of existence and essence as contained in the first part of book one. He says, "Existence is self-evident and there is no definition for it, because a definition must always be more immediately known and clearer than the object defined; but nothing is more imme- diately known and clearer than existence. So all definitions of exis- tence are nothing but explant ions of the word.'" He asserts that, although the noti on of existence is self-evident, its reality lies in the inmost dept hs of hidden ness. The concept of existence, he says, is shared by all things and all things arc "degrees" of one single reali ty. This idea was in opposition to that of Ash'arite theologian., because it necessitates resemblance and cognation between tbe cause and the caused, or. in other words, between the Creator and the creatures. Sabzawad defends hi s position by asserting that the cognation of a thing and its sbadow are one of the conditions of causal relationship. In support of tbis assertion he cites tho verse of tbe Qur' an in which God says: "We sball show them Our signs in the horizons and in their souls, so tbat it may become clear to tbem that it is tbe trutb."2 Sabzawari say., "If tbe universe aod human beings are signs of God, how is it possible that they sbould be completely different from Him? How can dorknesa ever be 0 sign of sunsbine and shadow a sign of heat. "3 He accuses the Asb'arite theologians of agnosticism by asserting that when we say that God is existent we understand tbereby that the same exitence is shared by all t he creatures. If, on the contrary, we do not accept the word existence in the above sense, we have to take tbe 1 Sahzawllri. (Arabic text), Part T. ed. M. and T. Izutsu (W;sdom of Persia Series. No. h TehrAn: McGill 's In,titut. of Islamic Studies, Tebrlln Branch, 1969) , p. 39. 2 Qur'4n, 41: S3. 3 Sabzawl ri, SharltA Manziimah. Part I. p. 48. 6 Subzaworl . a Nineteenth Century Persian Philosopher opposite of that sens., which is non-.xist.nc., so tbat the world becomes devoid of an exi stent origin. Further, if we understood nothing of existence, we would be depriving our intellect of all knowledge of God; and thi s is the state of agnosticism. Finally, he relates the posi ti on of ancient Iranian philosophers, whom he calls al-Fahlawlyyun, and shows his agreement with them. They believed that existence is only a single reality baving different stages and d.gree. like the stages or degrees of richness and poverty, intensit y and weakness, priority and posteriority, just as light is of vari ous degr.cs- strong, moderate, and weak. The difference in degree of intensity between various lights is not a difference of species; rather, it is a difference of strength and weakness, for it is the basic characteristic of light that it is self-apparent and that itmakes other tbings apparent. This characteri stic is present in every degree of ligbt. Thus, a weak light is ligbt just as much as a moderate one or even a strong one is. Similar to the case of " sensible" light is that of "real" light, which is existence. Sabzawad then raises the question: Since existence is only a .ingle reality, what is the source of the multiplicity of exi stent things? For instance, one thing is abstract and anotber material, onc tbing is heaven and another is earth, one thing is man and another horse. He answers the question by saying thaI it is the eSsences which are the cause of difference and multi- plicity. The essence. are different from each other by their nature and they spread "tile dust of differ.nc." throughout .xistence. As light is a good example to cit. of .xistenc., so colour is a suitable example of essence. If existence is like sunlight, the essences are like coloured window glasses which limit the sunlight according as they 8Te clear or dark, and change the one sunlight into diffc: rent degrees of light. By means of the above .xample, Sabzawad expresses his mystical views. According to him. man must purify himself by r.moving the dust from tb. mirror of the soul in ord.r to g.t away from tho world of muItipilicity and join the worl d of unity and peac.fuln .... Thi s mystical vlow is very clearl y expressed in the followln8 ylna of hi. : M. MOHAGHEGH Love is universal p ... ce; atl else is war and struggle; lovers are united, but sects are scattered groups . The word of love was originally only one; groups of ignorant people invented all these different word,.'" , s .btftwari, D I ~ n (T. IIlAn l MlrhmAiI. Jl38 A. II . [SolarJ). p. eo. and the object qualification tr' ! T l.v if..l.,.JLl .)1l.)1 if.,.Jl..; ; I /AA .:r-;>hJl c3i"; I III 'T cr""'rl! T/" incidence I'/nl.JlS:.':ill! H/I'I the effect of the Maker rl! T I I A' ""&--llu....ii ..::.1.iJlu "':i..ll r/AA collected-ness, coll ection t. I All r\ lS)I,::<lrl ...;:,. agreement of two opposites I Iv \ .r..u; J.<- the parts H/I n
the constituent paris of a definition f' y;.i rli....J ! T In JI.,i':i1 I III n I .... I.,I-.:. ! I Tin to. T I I r \ ."" 4. moment ; unit of time .)t..jJI ,)j,,: 6""?1 ..wl.,l-" ..I .::.':i..l",.,l t) .Jt..jJl All A' I I A1 ..::.L. t...J1 moments; units of time .)t..}I....iI).1 ! vi i I r ..::.t,; UI vi i I r momentary things originated (with no preceding element) I AI I I r 1,,1-'1 1 .)..1' unity .) y; with regard to ( external ) existence unity of time I Vi" ';'1.0)1 .)b.,jl Ti l l" u;,;t;,;J11-", unity o)..,..,aJI J
of matter and form HI"
unification of the perceiver and the perceived; the unity of the subje I the of predication without predication , I AI "::''"1 ( .. -' ..:;lh_';; U C what is morc particular r /l !' ;(";.1"lr perception; cognition .!S"I).)':II "'.L....':II-'Ji.,JI LSI, LS-,"; r I Itt spherical revolutions connec ti on wi th the Maker real connection :; :;-IIj,1.J ':II r.r.-- .) representation of non -exi stences in the imagination r /vv uJi ;(;1,;':11 times II I I t ;(;..j l '-!J-,,,UI ""lS' J"'II J pl;" I",; .:;,Ii) 4 r- e ...,..)\)1-, <.y. W I 'I I I , being more and less the external parts I I Iv' 'J-"",",I., "WIci""1 the rational parts us. 4-,L ! I I 1" 'Yo--,JI <l , .. ,,"" I I/v the concrete parts ( ..JI . 1),:,':11 t i l t I LS,[,.;I the parts rJl .1),:,':11 of a real composite I I It ",:-bJl u- t.,,;-'! ':I quantitative parts 4)1..I4J1 .1),:,':11 I I V I , Yo--,JI U' I",l... bodies the highest genera 4WI ':II I 'h, .... ,JII",I-, .i ",-'-'! "'-,li.:.J1 the properties of existence -' '" t,; -' U j') -' "'.h -' J..:.. "l' Ir ";1,,-, -, rational principles 'I I 'I ",a"';":; ':1 states ! I I v. t.,.:- '-!.J'" I ;;J.r-J I 'I I ' t til t of predication )If'' ':II III I Names and Traces J-" )IJ I I II I I ..... JI.r' J...,,0"'" (Divine) Names and Attributes the assimila ting Names of God the purifying Names of God the most r I / H
,II' . I I I ,
beautiful Names of God Tr I t A images; ment al simi litude s ,-. TI l" .::....,lUI J.,;-, confusion \.. between what is by accident and what is by essence 1\ /1' 1 confusion JIJ...4J 4r."..wl between a concept and the object to. which it applies gradual increase in intensity I /vr 6,>:'::'"11 rl...il u" qualitative change vi --".,.;.JI-, -'!..I.::.JI ...,....;I ..... J Jl!.. I viI 1,1=)11 demanding
demanding without requirement I \ I\A u,...,l,.;.::..I1 <5'-":.,, .}lS absolute demandingJll::.JI ,)1 ", .... :.JlI Jj..<.JI 'Y.--' ui lS r / \\ ;;J..J I preparedness ">";;_'JI . -...::.JI ull 'u.::.J1 ;,,,; ;;,....; I r / l'\ C;.)1 !r/ l' A preparednesses A/ v \ covering the whole without leaving anything the most solid and concise (proof) Jh,! r"'>-)l1 -,..1..)14 ",......J I J,b III vr J....L.:l 1 the basic questions <-:-llk.JI';"1 \ / IT A:cl: Divine Names
I ' I. I 01 .. ;.,,)1 ....il,;...JIJ a,:.b .,rJ rl.J \ \A / v JJ l,O I 1.1 \ , / , . JJl,O>'1 '.r.<- \ '/1 VA JJl,O>'I ... I,i .:r 0">::; ;;""":'11 \ I 1 / 1 At <sjl)I.;..JIJri ' / 1 A V \ .;,.,;)JJ0.,>::;JJl,O>'IJ .... IJ....i}>J I ' /lA V .I",!>' I ifJ'! \ illumi native relation \Vh "T ' / ' V \ , / . v \ II/t. \V/ I ;Y1.;-'IJJl,OI ..,.U I A/ I AV ;(,;Irl ..,Jl"'; <oJl,.1 categorical relation 4 , I I / t. ' / 1 VA ;,;,JJi.;(il,Ol ;(iI,.I J ..:;w JO"..,...,! the points of cime ';'1.0)1;.)1>1 V / 1 I r 4J.)-I1 ",, \iUI.:r the retrogression ( or : ':"1.0)1 bringing - back) of time I I / V\ subj ective consideration I f . I ""Jli.::J1 consideration or non _ existence mentally-posited \ I A/ t r ....... "i >'J ....i r >' I v/ ., individuals ; particulars r / H tly>, I J!li.J being stronger J and weaker t / vr (WI .:r illumination ' / ' t ..,...<;J1.:r the illumination of the luminous Ideas t'T/ II' the principality or .i.ll.ool fundament a l realit y of quiddity TI / 'I \ If / 'I \ I' / Ir the principality or fundamental reality of existence II / lor \ 11 / . I ' I / Ir principl e; basis 0ts::. .. >'t...,,; \ '/A' ' /A ' rl the basis of anything being real / t I vi' . the most befitting ' / 1 I V J lj-l>'t...,,; relation individuals actualized in the external world IT / A r individuals d to -Xl'st in the external suppose , world IT / A r real ( not imaginary) division \ T/ I tA ;1 ..... )1 r""'" imaginary division .,11 rU)l1 Al,li IT / I t A reqUIrement ; requiring I ' /\A .L,;..:;':II.:r- 1"'':11 .1< J.::..':I I I r / I r ... Ii. L,;..:;t c.s'-" L,a.;:; I ':I essential requirement .j1.l)1.\..A;i)l1 J"k-J I ,} ..,..l,J 4 ""' y."} I ,j W- I v/" .wlJI <,-;.J4 requirement 1S,r.Al1 coming from something_else I . '':11 i t:., ':I ",,1.:01 I .l.,.>ii':ll u: - (j";' "" v / I . .r-"l I ...hi.:r- the most sacred ..,...u)ll I Ih ..,.....Ii':ll ...,I..,.<Y being mOre or Jess A.Ji)lI) Tt / .V l.! quiddities ..:..\:AWI being mentally posiled decisive conviction r , LU.':I I 015:.':11 u"'. t /A . non- existences I \ I / v v .,1AlI ... j, l..;J I :r--':I ' Iv y .::.ISJ..JI 1&,1. '-"l.JI! , y.l.:.. 4-,J I ..jL,<.d L. ;I,:.4! I r / " \ 11 / " accidents I A/ I rt , ,/n .6..;L., J-U':IJ u"yJI rii'':I
relative accidents r / , I\ T ... J..iJi ... c'}IJ u=-JI-, 0-<':11 1/ 1 A' ..jt.,;.....JIJ J I...ii':ll the most general thing r / l t, U"'''- ':II .:r' 4jl r permanent archetypes u-" ! T /H u'y.) I rl.JI ,L;u i A/I ' t 4 ....... )1= JLU rjl"J individuals ))11 existing in the mind JI ;:"I u; ! r I I " J.WI Lr U"WIJ r LJI ! \ 1 I . . u.iLJI" I I .. ..," u""b..JI" ifW I ! I . I I . ;.. n I l' rj" ! I I I I' Ir,WI" I V I I r . WIJI ! n / l . f""""W 11 .r:.f! I vI I' f "J)\fli.... Lr! v/ l' v J ""'J':'JJI Uf. I II I I \ J.,') I the more ..,\5:.. special possibility :c,:; ylJ;;";1 :'J1.::.1 J ",,,,JI...,..l_ 111 .. possibility through _ preparedness .<J .. .::....JI,rJIJI u.:J1 L...; ! vI I . A U "'u,.,;"II .:,lS:..'I'4 ! r / l ' A I ' / 1 4. u,riJ1 future possibility )i; -',; 1/ I I L.,,,:, U IJ"".oJ I ...,...L. I V / I I -"';,1 .... 1 .r.U u; possibility _ by.itself possibility by _ something _ el se .j\A ':'1.'1'1 rL' I Lr .... kw " I I vr .;s::,S::..:.::J I r W I Lr that which 4:S- .;.111 allows of predication r / f I 'y'"yl ...."., J mobi le extension ' I I I ' impossibility t.1.;;.. V I I V ",," Uf. ':'Is;:. impossibility - by . itself >/ \ A .r.iJ 4 t. I.;;.. 1 I /H lmposSl - bility_ in relation_to _ something _ else .r-Al l u Jl )U4 ,rJI'Y."J r-'" 'JJ,ri> 11 \ \ fact, command lSl!!l/Ar.o....,i; '-! fl I I I AI I V the command of God possibility ! I II " .;r-'JJJ,;.J I f ir I" 1t.:...! I /A . .. f I I I " u.:..JI <!. t.., .\ y ;(;Jl;.:.. .l,.:1 .:r .hl-, tl':':;l 1/ '" Ir/ oo I I / o A abstract wl,.,.;'Y I! T r / Y ".1':':; I r" .,\.;" yo -,) 1 ",I.:,:;'YI r'Yl ! / AA ",1':':; 1 .;-<1 Ir / IAI quiddity be;ng something abstract 1 ' / \' r); the aspects of non - existence rJ.&. .1..;1 J._',! rl L. I / I' Y J.WII'S::'" various )I.b.il essential possibility; possibili ty _by_itself Lr-J.r-"JI t\;;;" 'YI-, -,..yo-,JI L e""! 4,vyiJl! IT/I' Y ;,w\)! ' / 1" ! 1' / 1' A <.S,I.>...:..'YI ':'IC'Y1 Cr.!-' ..... y.J-'! I ' / I A U';"" ...,,1- rl <.S,I ..\.:..)\Jj.> 'Y\)! 1/ 1 IT/ I" i ";l, rj'Y! fl i ' general possibility ...<Ju..JI w.;-hJI u' ;J-,.r"J1 ...,..L II / I .. possibi lity in rel ation .. to _ something - else )i;.J II -' ...,.::-J I , yo -' ; JJ -"" 'Y r-'JI...,-ll aspects of existences possibili ty I / . Y "" W ... .::.lI if ...,:II subsumption C;..v".ll CJJ.i1 the perfect man 'Y . 1, 'Y I .J.>. J ';'.J.>. <.S 1..1 I 1/1 , . (two things) not being of one and the same root losses in T' / '
Icrms of the form in the sense of need ; , J .L>..J l ui , yo -, .. JI ...,; J : _ lI A / I ' V occuring possibi lity 4.f';)1 ".II
A/ I' A Jl..... general principl es .GW 1;.,..".1 I ( ontology) I t L...s 'Y I ...,; if
extraction ; the lordly lights i 4..J . I _-:or- ).J' the li ghts of Divine commandment I /A ! laJ ,,*,'1 the victorious lights .",;1.).0'11= Jl'; ,f' V I I . I is -ness o ; existence 41 1 \.. 1 f T I r , ;,,; I ""'" L .yoll J."i- "-"0;] .L"w , Yo yll ,J. ... " <s iJ 1 A/v i '''+< pl anetary positi ons fiJlt. Uo) \ / n the dimensions of reality I I I . r the First ( may He be exalt ed) .:Jr..J 0/ ' .! ;y........, IJ ... \ ' / 1 I r \ vi I 0 \ T I ' oA .J f I \ I I' A 1';') 1/ I vi i AV ;Yl,;,1 .:.[i .. preponderance preponderance and its opposite r Ivr .:r essential .yl.ill \ / 1 H affectiom>, being affected .:r f l' I I v A oL .. 8 I .:r JW;Ir-W 1 \ T / 1' T .... ,s:J1 I I I I' I if-"! J.,,; affections .r-<- .:.;.; L) 01 ;;,.. ... ........JI ul".i,SOI,f' I \ 1 I A T affective quali ties I AI" T real disjuncti on
transformation ",,)1..<; 1 \ 0/ ' I """';;1 ",,)1..;1 "'...;; ",,)1.;; 1 \ I \ 1" "'J ........ loC.i .. u ;r l 0L)by I \ 1' I f ./A T ... ""I ; .L. ",,)1.;;1 f li n f TT l Avu;liJl ""YoYI JIu'l iJI0IS:.. '11 0' \ 1\ A .r-Al40IS:..'11 'Yo ... ,Ji..\-.:; essential -I.ill ..... IS . transformation species lights . " one and the same rhyme-word ' / t' ;YUJI where (category) .:r I ' / IA' = wasted, of structed 'Y .wI 'Y . Ubi.!1 LSI ! ' / IH proof .)1; t.! ws- ' /A ' = chance and coincidence , fo '" \ 1 I ! simple ( non - composite) things .b:L .. .,Jl u ; L...-'YJ J.l<L:ll I I I rr external G. WI,WWI .. ) . simple (non _ composite) things A/ lrl' ' I v, <,;:-)I.;.,b;L.., simple ,
( non - composite) thing Al l n simple (non . composite) r eality y_1 preponderance o.,.-:;'f.Ji r/ l ., 'cfJl hJ1'Y Al l" l.:.J,<-J <,;L\OI.:r preponderance_ by-something - else .G ':II .J:'" .J' J iH'; \ r/ l" 4, I I I I., <Ii, being the first 4.r ':II J ' I I '! J"l..uIJI oj:;_ being the first and the last r/vr .:r the Divine days necessitation bringing into existence \ I A/ I H 'cfJl I I I" , being ; existence .:f...J1 \ ! / 't 'V/VI .:r .J J "...,1 01 ..,1'; 0- 1:,.,...JI.#'YIJ<WI \ ' / 1 I! I I A ,,-l 'YIJI ..,..,u1.:rJ-,I..D ..,..,u1.:rJi JluJI.; CI.,>.1 i A li l IA ' ,,- 1 'YI uJi the repetition of
u-,! ':I luI IU""UI.rJ .. ICJ':'lS"" TI / I" aITcctingand )J.:l I."JW 1 J.r.lW 1 being-affected actualized gradually 1 I - I ,I I'" J I,.,.<;':I,-, J--.i.lIJ W- posteriority J:'-W1 1/ 1 TT theosophy 4:JWI 11/ .' rL.Jlu; Ji-.,:I I <5 1 consequent JWI 1 I / ! V .u:.. (.Ii.lU Jl.4 ul l::J I Al f Aj.8 = I v / I I ! 4.<i .... AjB = I ' / I I ! essential change dl,ul Soll 0 1 .j1,iJi JJ.,.:lIJ "-! (./4 1 I / I I' ;W I;.;:.. 1; I.,; ;;,...J. homogeneousness H/I ",:.:,.,i>JI.r-AlI (\...;1 .r renewal I 1/ 1 I v "".,,,,,Ji 01 self-manifcs- tation ; thcophany I ILu w,.; . I (" .. ':I I v"<.5' ... Divine ,elf - manif stati on ; thcophuny I ,I I . , , .. v/ ln UbIJl u-i'J1 conditioned- = .p! A by-something ' / Ir I negatively_ o.)fi.,JI = A condicioned 'I I r I ;y..J1 u1 J 0" continuance .la:!1 " / 1'1 J.ili.. the area of possibility oJl; <!.>:. ..... U 1$ v /'" 0"'",JI li """ !.bi, building J .\::11 and builder difference of attributes I ' / 1 I difference Al f 4i.8 of complete separation producing an effect ; affecting .".. 1:.::.. <5.,"1., ;;.L.Ji L. ,r-tl::JI f 1/ '" ,r-tI.;JI I / I V''''''>:<I. affecting and bei ng aITected actuali zed a ll i on c ,. I rational laboring dirrerence particulari_ r . I' . r / \ . A....-.i ...
zation of preparedness infiltration of non _ existence ! I I IVA ;,1.1 _",J..<;' J.; If I I .! :i., ... JI ':',1 divesti ng ili..:)1 imagination
I I H LJ,;uJ I. UJ;:J';vil...i.; J--JJ' I I \\ t J,;';;!\! J)'.::.J 1_"" J,,>.:J i!r r successive order I' l l v r J....L.:l1 JL" J !b natural order rll t 1\ r ':'I,,,JIJ positional order I.f'''' } I rll , I I r ,:, vi .,...,;.rJ I, preponderance rll without there being a preponderant u J.. r)' 1' / 1' r i;.JIJI an active agent l"-ltiJl" <.r t;j".J' givi ng preponderance essential selr -
manifestation j essenti al thcophany self-manifestations; theophanies r ' / ov .;:.. L::.b..:J I " ' ' .... Ioy the art of using a homonymous term as a rhyme word " / !.. ..::... L.>: . J 1 J J ...v .... H movement <..-"--,,,Ij \\ 1", acquiring wha t has already been acquired ; actual - ization of ", hat has already been ac tuali zed .,-::J.jjj "' /1 r )j.-" I.) , actualization J ... ,.....uJ C-! \; J '\'JI 'Y,'...u ! ' I I I' I v 1\ n u'; ;,,14J L,;l; 4-ll adorning .u...:J1 anal ysis
r / l " ",\;. 11 .:,-- ,:,15:..'1' 1 ..,.,Jr anal p i. and J'- ... ,,) , I V/ I' , .:;.;..,J4 J;WI ' I ' / 1 rr >j u"kJ10".1",..u; "'" ".<J I ; .A,li ,1.10" I ,Jl..u; ,}, J) ;u,i, " / 1'1 ;0.1.,_,)1 / I V" I V'I' / IVI I/ \Vr f T.' ", It si milarity assimi lation
I . h . lA,) 0,,) assimilation and a loose \Va y of expression .,..1_.)1 J "';,5::II! :(".._; , / H individuation
u.;;.J\ , I' / I r, :.:", .. J I u; , Y.' , ''(' II rr r-l r-lt... 01..;')11 .j J JL , I All '! / 1 t, '..\,'1 ')I , r/ l I, ' I I I I r j,..:JI .:"!,, ',," r-:JI , I ' ul\,; JJ')I 1 u";'';;';! ' / 1 Ir"""'" .. \. / \ t 'I" o.)'y'".J w:" ' I I I r <.r..r-s- '",,:;,)1 real individuation oJl)I.I" / I! I I I , g radation
, . , ' I I . , ... composition 'pI 1/ 1 rv :i; .wl ')II 0. composition by way of unification ",_JI .A,-ll J"J J'- ;(,,:,.11 ':II 00i 1/ 1 ! I composition by way of annexation t..s::,J I J r' u'"' ;)"..,J I -' ; ,wi "" I I / I ! \ real composition - bJl <-.S -II ._ .r ':J1rl:; ! \ Q Iv, A::A::;;' .u A / n ",,"" 4-:0"1 equality infinite regress J-l-:.lI ,' I. \ 0ll"J :':!)J},..JI.j L. c:" . .j ... ,,) "'J) , \ ,t. \ .:r r),. ! \ AI .:, 1 l,,,,y uJl..; ' I' h ' Ul>JI";;(',,.u f \ vi vo .. JI ... J.&. / v. ')It.. ,Jl.i; I v .. oJl .. 1 \ 0.,,) ,, ;) u1< , \ r Js:. ..... JjJ ! 0/"" J 4.0.: ... )J.)luJI ':;:""JI (;.I,;;.. I )/..\l; ,r circular definition, , / ' t, 'J:(JI I I c.Li:!; .... :! .. \ 0"- '-1)J' literal definition J !."..J..::..li.l .... JI Lr' .)-P.""j1J.J .... .).) L. ; T / tr agllosticism J:WI J::h .... i f \ 'i f t "..,j"U...,.." J,.';J"'" JJW' \ I A/ t A,y .. rr / tA )();')1I J ..i;l .J1 dependences .;..LaJ..::JI , 1/ ' vul'L..J 4u1,y'" rational laboring c9...J1 ,,; ul .. t /:. J,. l l .:r , 1/ , rr T / determination
transformation
r lWI u u.., ..... s;:. c,.-"- '! ')1 I . / ' , . l..4i I 1 .. ,'1,,; J.< entrusting uA:JA:lI " /1 v . , .... ,,,)1 , .:r r); opposition , ' / ' or , _'..I I , r / ' , . '-!r-'JI,,--,- ,v/, .r ....... lJl u t "i; r / I' r "'O' J.; p"'orl ty aualogicit y ; analogical gradat ic'l\ ul < LoJS"r",IA. JI ' r / vrt.;..Lil ! r / vr ui.j ;O;:S;:,;:,.J I;c.,.J.JI. ' / VT "s;:,C;.;;II, . / t t J \ A/ n judgment u"'.J.J1 'po"P ul .. : ')' 6)._. v / : , primary judgment "';\;" )J.,Q; (" .Lt.! ,,-::j lJ....a."": .I., AI ' . T representation )J....:dl .::..1,: ')1 )"",J I , 'T / : A "LA, .) 1-'1 o,lA ... A/ " T ..."..c...::JI ;.:"JJI u; mutual correlat ion :.ill , ,' 1 uw':i "';,L,;..:JI u .i1d_l; J>l ... .J\JLl ... 'Iii J-l....::JI J1."",;, L,;..::! I J,b ; / ' v , T / IV T
one correspondence , T / \ V, J-l...::l1 Jh" ..:;."h::l I J,l, 1'cal definiti on ul,,,U u-:I , T / ! T ".:.' ,,:..; J ... ", \.:. c I., 0 multiplicit y r / .v 'y'">JI JI ;('>_,. JI ,i repetition r / I Av );:::11 ...,"" ,.,; ,r';)1 sharing-one_speci es ! H / I! A 4,;,.11 o",JI i WI 0" , 1,.:;'1' I r / I ,. '-!.r--'Ji ... _," A/ I r c,-l,,1 '-# >"J I> distinction
proport ionality contradiction ! 'AI ' r <I..:.?I n / I . ...,; 1.1'" 01.-) 1 sharing -one-positi on unification ; uni ty the uni ty of Divine Acts recogniti on of the unit y of God I r / r, ..ill J",.. - .J' , . ! ! . /. t L y... ..,-..,J i ..t;;;. J I , i.>.i:J I priority and .r'l:li posteriority r / I I A",-,,,..t,JIJ r""Jii*-J 01;-","1- a thing being prior to itself I . / or thing being .:..1.lJ4.o....Qj-.sk. prior to itself with regard to essence I r / VA a thing being prior to itself in terms of time I I / VA a thing ..,.;\) ... ! ' -.s,;J\ being pri or to itself by degrees v / I . conceptual priorit y .. Jlij lJ' J i.J.AJ J'fb II /I " approximat ion a:1d figurative express ion J ...,..!},JI J".. J < ,I .. '1' 1...,; I A/V V constituting being - determined determination
, . , w.lo- :v/v t viv o something being
of something r j:;-! 'J : , ; 0 A .. J c,!. JI ",,>J t j I A/ I ' t[JI';"J ld "",l:JI"".JJ the aITirm<ltion 4,-4:.1':.1\ :. <..r H of Ihe self_identit y of a thing I v / 1" lSPJ" the subsistence of a non-existent the Maker the first Maker I ' / I I . ,31 J i . JI ,\,;.:;; 1 the true Maker the world It / ' db.) I r>,iJl-,
of pure intelligences j the world of spiritual realities """..:NI ;(.;;....;:.1 j< d a...LJld ! t / r' I r / I I r :i.,1-,WI possess ion (ea tegory ) the unity of the Divine Essence ..:..I,ul..l.>- - _J' t t / t 0 ;y.J I ;;.Il .. 1 JI..l" J.<- 1"'" 'J Y = ..,:)1 Ir/ n -.,lIe-I) ",).,1 the unit y of the Divine Attributes the unity of the Divine Act ' / 1' :<'&-31 ;(1 t,.. 1 JI..lv J.<- .. '" 'J the unit y of the Divine Word ' / 1' :i.,&-Ji :iJ I", I J! ;:;':" J. c 1"',1 'J production subsistent J-,-; J.<- '-=I t; r ..l.J1 d 01 :J...lyl l , I /V t :iJ.:,:...JI I t /v IJW4 " .)I-' self - subsistent r / I t 'y'-y; -,-!J" d pre-eternal j')'l subsistents subsistence 'lI Ar mathemat ical body l'-odJ ,j A!)UI I"SJI rWI 0- ' I I I I A' r I I A I LS..,l.:! I natural body natural I r I I t A O..l,Jl! JL:..
clement al body I r I I H LSIt:.J I I J! t;.. ,j a body belonging
to the world of similitudes making
! AI AA ' .,; <->"0.J 1 J"..iJl ; 'I A A , I t i l '! .h,;)1 O ... }I simple (nOI1- - composite) making ,j A' u-,JI ' ... ,il...:.. 0lll. composi te maki ng = .rJ' r l \'ifJ,J4 " II c"ent ial making .:J,.u 4jN:J I , ' , vain act part a constituent pan elabora ted by the mind pal ticular I I / In '-Ii <.i.r.- , trl oA Ut;,J1 ,jhy. I_ JS- ... 0.>' u- JI5::.!'11 ! \ i/i ' ws- f'. u-: ';",1 -' .:,01.,,11 h 11 '1 0 1, v l;o' -u-J ! I vi' r LStSjJ..., I ",-,_ ",,>J ... C .>&.i-J :r.J u::r.J.f'rl..,;,;lu- J","'!)I! I viA I IS.>"'1 J.r.JIc." J' u..J! I t i l! r r I I t! !.l1)o'1l body rJ' r /vI rjl ... J 0-;\..1;"11 ... -:i. JI r-_A.:..."I .. -,I ,,; ;)"..,JI ... ;,WI ! I r I Ar ' 0 I I rt ,,;.1 0 , 1 ,j ... , -, I I t I -,...'r .; t l
J-JI J I..J I 0--,...' r ull ; '14 ,,4':' f 'I I v, \ v 'H / 1 r r jO",'-'i I . / I I A accidental making , r I I I r r J->-- J.,o..J I . r / lr t proximate genus I ' j v' mental substances Ai \.WI I_II ) .T' y:w non_material sUbstances substance I ! / ., ch' c:: c''!'! ...;.,l ,,-JlS:::.:;'}I ! I /., ..,.,.. J .J..:.I ! '/H' Ir/\ t,;.J I r /v . "1.0'':; , r r / HWL...i '}Ll .,i ' .",b v,J ! r /v , 'r..,J1 u""!! I/ I V\ ,I' l l A ' ..,41J )\,1; generic substance inhering su bstance mental substance , r /' l,;,Jo ' i.,l J J ts:::.:;I.r-:S' ..,...,J I r / H',!." Lj..\",! if.,.-J 1 t -*'-' malerial substance yJl
v/" .6,1)1 'r..,JkilAC. wLn . composite making qui ddity being made existence being made logical plural
genus
..t..IJ '..,::. !\/t t WI ! '/H 0.) U:JI (.I)..li l ! 0/ \ . .,JI <,..:)4 J.,o.;J1 ! \/H ....;,;.;.. ';J.,. > \/v , p'-'} r"""'- ! I r / I rt U ;I oJ.I., i..;irt.J . j'" J.W., 'u';;'JI t.,:J 0).,.. genus and differenli a 4-:- jO"! I /v I t....J..:.I_ o).".,J I., o,WI J",lJl ! ./v I ... JI.>.JI ! 'Iv I . ;1; rly J ..,...,J J.,o.lJ1c:: ,WI! I ./ArJ .... i U., .,.. 4 )4 ! I / I I c.-c. essential need non_material substance .)p.JI.J'" y.JI ;;.wId ..;"'.: ... II .. ,-\,;;)L l..' I A/'A J}.-.JI JI need of a possible trung ( . I I ,( . k:JI d ;;.wI JI nominal contingent .;.,.)WI AI I I [; I .:;.....lb.,..1 L....". contingent at the level of perpetual duration J>-,!,".>IJ LJloL.- locus_substance; a substance constituting the locus (of another substance) r I I " J .r'-D I yJJ non.material substance J )\A.JI.J'" y.JI specific substance V/ I Y' 4.:.. t,)r I.f .fl1.J'" 1y.J I ( 1/ lrt definition .w, substantiality i:. ._tl . .J'" y.w ...,.11 "t.,j !'It T "'- oJ u.."J 'y'-yl .kl! ! I' l l n ,.p,..) I .u.....d Jl..,:" ':II r I I , , essential boundary .:;.,I.lli common boundary ; "'-I J ;;.,...; .:r-: I ,) I 0.:,...; 0"s:::, L ' 1" ' I /v , explicit modes .:;.,1.v.J1 ! 'I" d J ,1.".. GJI,;dI d .!.1!J1 ! AI ' ,JJ.wlif ! ' I" c.lP, ! y I " J .. ..::J4 JWI..,. t..'Y.-J T/' ,..,......:.JlwW ' I' J."..I state JWI contingency j temporal origination ';"J..l:>J1 !I I / YtrJ.u..JIJ ,Y.-"..JI tft :i.l...1,,11 ,,,,- !lr/YI lh..b...z0L1JWI/ Ti l l' T;b.t"JI.) if t L yO ! I ' I I' .lA,JI!T/ I ' t ! TT l I ,t ..... I).:r ; I r.,..;.J1 ! Il/v! ! r I \A rJt...JLI ..;,s::JI nrrd T r I I ' T ":-\>.)\ lol " , ' I slow movcmcn t 11/ , !.::.. I:S:....JIJc:.,l,' >Jl u r..d- movement ".JI;() rJl u,,;':1 .::.. 1) yJl.:r .::..L.h-,,:.:J I ","";;'11..,_; ,V/ I A',. 1/l lrJl,h;':I 1 ',.-; j.l" ",I I v / I , , A,..hiJ 1 .)1 ! r /I " } _ill J"J ... f c / \ )y:--"JI ),;) 4 3 1 yo ! 1/ 1 I r 0J..btJ\ !V / I \ 'I' , 1/ \1 v c. relative contingency .;;., )..\:oJ1 Jil <cr ,:;.. I. \ 1/ 1 \ r .;,,:.1 0 t ... j LT' suhstantial movement 45"' rJ' real contingency .. ...w I';;" ..\:oJ 1 -.>. ) \ -.. / \ \ l' .jl JS"" .} A/ I " \c;l,hJ13 0Jo;) 1 J 4'j,: .. cutting movement "":-3 J"' 0,G u" : v / \ v, , A / \ \ r l3l:-k j ')l J I ",,;,JI A,..,; 0JoiJIj.l" ",II v / I " ' ;;.,..hi) I positional movement ...... .;,." JS" ..JI .J' .) "' / 1 T t &;'Jl the resurrecti on of the bodies portions of non_ existence conti gency Ihrough LS .r""ul .;;., )..\:oJ1 perpetual duration r' / I I pU.uIJi-JIJ,CI, ':I IJ.,,- , I.el I / I I r I'Jl,JJ essential cont ingency JI"UI';;" )..\:oJ1 II / I Ir .::..I ill '"..,J '+' "';"'p ;("i1.i.11 'r.3 \ r / \ \ T \ \ \ T temporal cont ingency JI..)I .;;., )..\:oJ1 chlt.) \ v / \ \ r c..lu:.... S l , I A/ I I r origination of the \lorld .;;.,)..A;.o 1/ 1 I v J JI,,;':II portions of existence F.)I movement til,;.. p"'" d" I 1/ ' I . '-""o.uu=JI",.)lyJ1.:r ; I ' I ! ! ;u"..:.. c,.';';; ! " / I r I , r. Jol I b,r:.., A+l1
, I . affirmative occurring in the judgment on a non_existent mind v/ H wisdom truth 0)".1::"" \ vi r A :li.J .... ll.J Lf> J..<.'I ( ,Al r A Wlc 0\...;)' 1 ,-,:......lIe}' ...:;t!'; , I ' IrA ry.... J..<.' 4 ' I I' I,-!I;,JJ ,jl!J1 Divine Wisdom , I I , I '" lAJ J..." J ) J L.o.! 1 ,-,,,,:ii theoreti cal philosophy " / r v practical philosophy I' Ir v transcendental knowledge r Ir, J>;JI r--.r. .;;.j'Y coming to inhere in a locus J..,wl <,,;..oJ 1 .,.. 4 ,j , rio r :;.;1.;:;...Ji ol"i L... IJAr ...:;..c,..Ji L' "1,,, 1 (r/A r the Truth Jw J>-ll >" ,v/o r 41.::",\-- ', / or :Or" ;(,i l .,L, ' lo r ,Y.-.,.3I.:;..,.UJ"'OI....;.r ( r /A'd-"llI0' <5.,..)'1 u....<;JI"':;l r il ! \ 'I' I oI....A;.) ...... ,;,j >,.; ';\...1-, ...,1';"> .u . lc>Ji<5r.' <5T.'!L 0.,>'Y> 01) J.i ! I I I I I r rJI >" substantial realities reality n / ll l ' ''''':; 4J ... ..JI \A..JI . .r J. .." I 010, .u...a..JI J-s' dJ 0 A ! I ' I I YA ' i,."Ji> ",I II I 'vi I rA cY. . 1i:..J1 being_inherent and J..,wl the reality of existence y; .,JI bei ng . affected I v lv , 0')L.. J+ ' Y.-.,.31 .,.,. predicati on J.r.J1 ( r' I " 'y'-.}JI ,-,i ,I",'YI >" J'" no J f.'! u-,J> 0J ...J1 J r. ! v I' r ",)1-;:,;.. 1 ( I vi' r "\ / 0 t l...lb.r.:;J ),&lL L&J ;; Jitl l1i \ % t 0\ .) I V I v ' 0' ) r.I- -,JI .. ,... IUlui t ivc j udgment \S"'.l..J1 ! ' I I v I u.>.o.::.J I JI.J I "I '" 0 1 J i, y--' ,) J ':II J.>.14 '-",..11 .:;.....,J I AI, . l:..,.J I 2 U I J.>.Jl .:;..; II ",i <,i U"""..II 0 1 ,'I". non - deriva live predication ".. , ,1, r' j 0(,,;':11 J. *1 h C:ltegorical proposi tion temporal thi ng" modes qua; the (insofar as)) t.Y"..JI : r I I r . ;;,.;:; if ':I the mode of the refusal of non-exsitence if . L}l1 :i.,:,- 00" u" :(i,i. v I " r;.,,11 the mode of necessity ..,., Yo jl'f: ... 'II' v ,y-yl ,:_> t::-. the mode oi existence J ,L";-}l1 .1-,", ' 1A/" 1.,..:.., ':I J .... i -' , 'A I, r, "-..".. J-;;I I .... _i.. ! , I , r : OJ.;,..J_JI : or/I'" , . I I " ;P;:!IJ derivati ve predication ';14- r / \ e \ primary predicati on "">'-,,"JJ'I'IJ.>.IL :L,.l.JI)J..J1 0y ,-,IJ'I' I L.; ! " I" tUL}I J1";' L-.. l::; ..I..:. ... "";;; \ 4, / 1 c 0/", primary essent ial 1l1..\J1 predication .jliJl ",1)'1'1 J.>JL ! AI" ! " 1" "-.1.0 er"-' J-,) if lj"l.! .. JI "I I , . common predi cation t U I J .... J 4 ,-_.".w I J I ... " , , _.JI lS')}I I J.,,14 :i.,.WI )J..J 10J'; ' 1'\ t J.><i L.j ! ,'1" c! U 4}1 ",,}lJ'" U""J. 1I , I '/A I &- 6:,-,", ,-,IJ}l1 \ r I I" .bi; common technical predi cation Cr' i.:.4 ! I A / V , Y." -,JI ... .".,. .}s. 1 .",1'; j-ll(JI-, """; 1,JI Cr-l .:r-.JI 0L.)1 '-,< i.:.4 ! " / VT J-!..w.}< i.:.4 ! ! I 1/ " .:f.,.JI (.t,:..1 r..,.>-JIJ); .}< ).,.JI c.fl LS; 11,,-0 0JS ,-!..w .} .. ! ' / I . r LSI.. ; I V / I .:f...J I , y'"-,J ... 1.)1-",;t:; J <.;eGJI t"yl 11r'1 LS; !.l;:';:'.J1 .wI .r."'" .}s. ! I 1/ 1' \ I / I A J",.i.:...J1 ,.$)1 the world of creation JlOJI I / 1 I .ut,; 4 J1" ')II r H< <51 crea ti on and command JlOJI V/ AI .,..')11-, -.1')11 the imaginative and animal good imagination JyJl SiJI0L...;')II! I hI',; -,:.r.J 1 ;).,...JI ; A/ ' I 0L...; ')I I ,} U""J I r / "Jt,,;JI;W-rJu-i'Jle the house of vanity 0-',1 t 00" >" Jpli-'" J-,.;:;.,...,)I 0-',11 H /V \ J-'J,JI JI'J 'y'".,..J1 the house of obstruction , I T the external T '/AI "'" lilh . rCl f .')I1 a predicate extracted J )4...J1 from its subjects < 1'/" :z..,...;J4 J-,..,._JI J /v . a judgment conformig to the external state or things a judgment confirmed by the external state of things line I.) LS; !.l,r:;,.J I .. " .. 01 I >" .6;.J I ! I T / I A U ICr' ! v / \ V. T / I A ifJ l< mathematical line .boJ1 1/ IA I LS"',Ldl il...i l 0-' particularization .,....,L,., J.,; J ;;""'-,.,..;JI .6i..l I ! / I v u,.J1 <elf .. contradi ction i)j f ir/ I' G:/J.J I J .. ..-u 0 LJ:.. ')II if -' J" U Jl".IJ ')I I J-,WI .I<i..ui.}< r \ T / ' A , I r ) -, the subjects of relations persuasive (non 'lA' apodictic) proof that which possesses an
essential property HI the source of a form 0 1' 1' . the tasting of theosophy ;OWl vI. v i,)u -)1.,.1 ... i;...l ... I,;..:.. mystical tasting r / lfrJ"".J 1 ..:;';..0 1);.01 Jl li...j matters of tasting ..:..1:5 J.ill " I A I u 4)W I j! li.. .j (it-is) possessor.of_ih mind
"l rL,iJIJ) t- L11 &JI <51 , I 1/ "'-,) Jy.=JI J <.r.J "" lilk" r<lr'l'l ' I" T '/At a[;J1 mental .;.e.ill copulative existence
' .J,:,YI<5 I ! T I' t""" .j 'I' 'r.'" ..;1 T I A\ .6 1 1)1 vicious circle " .... i Js r.Lli o.l....i.. lb r r,W1 0; y;..w J.< , T I , r I t / l . .:f...J1 perpetual duration <5f.".L.J"> fi l l ' r ;(", ... 10" ,'II I r '-!)"JI u lJ)li. U . l<JJI <5 J '!'" 0)\,..JI.JJL,.,;'I' I.J" ,.5;:JI,j< .6,...-! 0L)1 " JI 01.:""'; , I ' / 1 I r .l<J ' I / 1 T I I I r essence ..:..I.ill <51, I c.I'rYI b.il,) , I Al v t "" t,:......, I I I , ... i,,..! 1 , I ' I I T A:i.y,J IJulil I Js.::.l,i :i.,,..! I I VI TA j!,li.:..J1 essenti.al L ' I AI" u ... ,:!1 0" ' u"-JI , I TI l I v' t / ln "T/ or J1",'I' .;1.iJ1 'I T '1'..1 ...AJ.;:;., 'I' LI';I.iJ1 'HI., ';liJl . li! U I . I Ar ' J"'; LI ... essential pans lr -) .::.. 1i.JI)w.d- J-""-' r-' ' I ' ( 1 I r ' ( I A1 .jU I Y'J ",-, -'>oil , I ' (I A the time which is ';"\.0)1 at the beginning :, r Iv , .)L.......1I .r:' J ":;).JI \ r / v ", .t.j'!,.) L the time '\ hi ch is supposed to come back IT ( n imaginary ( non- existence) on the level or ti me , ( I I 1 <So .01 cS"iI-,JI .wl ..}li .J things in time )\...1 I.., L,.'L: l_J I v (I \A composit e dual ity precedence; priorit y I , I n .j L.jU .';;1 :' separabl e precedence <..;:JI )y-J ..}lWl ( .wIJ:- .J T I I I r full negation , I 1 inhering existence
tracer of non - existence pure connecti on scn<; ibit.' rank rationa l rank
T . ( v, 4';-)1 r ( I T r ( I T description; imperfect defini tion """",,,, )1 I .... H: V/ t r ......,) 4 ..... AI ! r u.;. .... ..J 4 0.., ..... '=-: rCITIO\ "a l pure connections c.!)1 .jj;.ali kl))1 r ( " 4J
11(' v time .;.,\.0 )1 " T l(vA",I",;..;:..J1 v' .JL.)lj.oJ.,)! I , (v" J J.,,;I:' :y,UI -.;). ! I I I ' r '''''JI .:r " , (" I I r ( 1 I ",I I r I v ( I I r .... J}A.J I ",\iLl I ,J' "-' 1).1 ". c.!,....! I f TI I I I r 4.r'" li,- """'<l.J I f Al l I ' 4.r'" cs-- I II I I priority in terms of ..::..ljJ4 essence .:;,IjJ4 r-Wl..r.- , ! I! ! ;("WIJ "'J) r;;1 f I vii " I All I A <:W4J priority in terms of rank 4)4 J,-lIJI !All I A ...,...",.rJ4 <5 1 f r I I I' ;;"....,JI ;y )IJ :i.,liaJ1 ;Y)4 01.,."JI J ...,...",.rJ4 l.. 0lWIJ ...,...",;Jl}"..,;.."J1...,...",;J4l...., <;.,...I I ,-,",I yL..,;;)l1 f ! I I I . /1 I I 'J.i.><..J1 priority in terms 4)4 of sensible ranks ' I I I I ).;"".) priority in terms 4)4 of rational ranks vii I IJWI priority in terms of time ule)4 Iv/ l " 0l..)4)1.:;,1jJ4 r.wl "',.. ':>1.0)4 = Jle)1 f ' I I I A 4 f l / 1T4 t41)1 t il I I 0l..)1 JI yW)lI.,.. complete cause ... Js. c:: t'"iJ " Y." -' c:: I I I . I . . 11 cause of quiddIty ' 1 IT' , 'I " 'I being-a-cause J and being - a - caused I I I I v. r y.....JIJ rL-lIJ 0LS"l,.;;... priority ... WI I / IIA ... WI separable priority priority in terms of substantiality I I I I' I! I I rJ:.ii.,.. .r.J)l1 "li ;.,.....:J 4 .6.1."J I c:kJ 4 -' ... 1". J <.;:J I ),7i --) "}c. ; , I I I . \ 1 I ! I priority in the non. metaphorical sense .:;,I.).j4 u . .' . . ' . .:r 01
I I I I! I 0,,>:l 1 .j.k.. priority at the level .. -""..ul of perpetual duration I 'Y."rl l Li.r.--- ---_._- --------------- , I , priorit y at the level .s.l.t.roll priority in tenTI." of of sempit cmit y quiddit > necessity precedi ng existence plane
r -,,-, ) ti J + o, 1',- !l.r:-JI..\,JI.,. : I I / H;;J.,<WI"" .. ,J, Lr' = "/ I A' j ....... ::-J 1.):;:t:" \.i lc. WI \ I" / \ i\ . j".;L.,.,.:.:.J 1 r' / I A,c: L .'1 ma themal ical plane
r I I A I r(JI 0-' ,j>J I) -:,..J I 4.;> = i.,S,w I) ;..J I the innermost and the hidden 4..1.'r-, 4, ... L5:::; <3"...J1 .:,.::.., 0.,(11.," .J)'., : AI I I ' I r I I rI pnon .y in terms or honor ' I I I A J ", WI ...J rJ4 = v/ ' r l .J'j-., priority in terms of J I J>- U 1 U J I >" J ".l,. 1.,J1<J! / : \ . / \ \ A ', j l r J ' priorit y in terms of nature scmpiternitr J,..rJ' precedence of nOI1- existence negation -,..1J1 causal priority : I fl l r ' .....,-"'. ;.Gt; ...,...LJI' ',/ 1 f' , ..... \1 I; 1III f' negation and affirmation priority in terms of causalit y Icpn,'nlli c priorit y
, I V mobile thing . .K:-l' a thing being .p..lJ.)\! w.,..,.- .:....bJ, J-S' I 1/ 1 I 0 mobiles .JI l.> u, -' f , / I I r "" L) f""-I Ij "" L) /')\) I r /l lo0 L j men tal similitude, image
individual
lexical explanation of a word w,r\i f I / ! r LJIL <51 f O/1 ,, (.wI 1/ ' r" condition . .rJl ";;.B L cr It / I.t JJL....l4 1 .rJ 1 tL::... 1
I r / I r J >:il .j not absolute negation I r / \ '" ;;>:i.. 11 ( .4 J! lL. .j longitudinal hierarchy #1 a...L.J1 rr / llr'lr/l lr ' r / l l r ' , ! V\ latitudinal hierarchy .1"'; .",JI .il....W1 r II I Irq ' I I Ir <t / ' Ir 'I Ph)sica
l oi n 0 l,>:i 1 c..--! u---l ' t. UI = .;,l$ll t:-" sharing the same foot ; cognation ! \ r.j t A I -' Ad-.",) I ,h; I.r:- 0 .... rlL..j f 01 \ I 1.r' rl ";'1 if I I I v I cognation .}lIJ ..rJ1 I h condition of a j, rJl j, P like that of a thing and its shadow condition .u.!.) I ";;.B L cr cognation of hy pothetical proposition quiddities (with the Maker) r "-!)\....;I part )2..:J1 negative ?ropositions rl r JL ' I I " Ir/ IH incidental t hing thing 1J1 time the thingnc" of quiddities and concepts ' I' , ...,..,WI J, lL. .j thingness d:. ' ll I / uJI:]1 t he thingness of a thing d:. " t i l n ' :J-"",", general thingncss
uGJI.j t..., w W I 'crJ1 ";1.,.,:; 1 A/1A the thingness of quiddi t y d!' . " er r / I" ' r / Og, " / 0' 'Aj !" \ 0 / \ If..' t / l.r the thingness of existence Y':" ."J\ A.' _ :., r / 0 " 1\A coll ectivcness being t an internal part I r I ' r\ J(JI .j partner of the C!Cator .s 0' t L;;..I, .r.;'! 01 ) 1..I.:il 1;1;;.J .5) . ,iJ ,",>1.;., \ v I " <5) W I lA/A I shape
the faculty of aspiration 'rt, JI ;ij"I. JI ;is" .;'<.JI ;;'WI,} ""I.li H , v/' H thing o6.:-:+o-Ji 1$1 ! T T / " 0 ,,-A.i .. -.vu i
.j j".'J \ , /V ! ' T l oA Y.JI <5 1 ":l \ ,. / v r-'J. ...... JI ! t / y 'I' ':}J J ) \ 'Iv t u- ,'JI ' , / v I ... l.!....S' \ t Iv" 41, ;" : ... J jJ ui ! oj VA "'u:.J l! oj ", YJ.$)J..;-P 4_i.:..I '1..1:.] 1,,/1 t he first erf usion; the f irst emanati on ! 1/ ' . v ' T / ' ., rJ rlL. JI I ! I ' . , A.,>IJI, 'J ! / I r ... 1'1 J I :c.;..c-J I "oil l;'Jll .. J .. "" ... -' .. forth essentially \ v 1\ A V , v . real Attribu o..llljll true (j udgment ) tes added (to the essence) ' o-<l-"":II Jl.,' ... JI rjl ... 1 u' AI \ . ! active Attributes the Attributes of the non existent lA/ VI , ... ... .u":l "'-il!JJ ! / H (rS:::!l, ) 0,t:" ... 11 ?JI .... appropnateness of ,"-"WI negation Il / , .;y,.u ,1,10-' appropri aleness of IU'gatiom , . I i t u ...:z. J1 . .J J.&. truthfulness positive (affirmative) }1.;:...uJ! '1 / Ar :;"';'iJI,"; .J,t:... attri butes f \ ! / A\" :\:-: ..4,) 1 u; f t / Ar I I 4.....=.A 1 , ) f \ Q/ Ar ;:-:;::";.dl y ./v! '-' ..... posi ti ve external attributes attribute ! \ ' / v I -",")I, til I 1.;,,)11 ci )1 \ v / v I .r.-J.s::::;.J I w) l.;;.J I l . l ,_ truthfulness and falsit y \ r / \ . \ .)l, .:.(\ -" -' .)l.,..:, -" reality in its pure simpli cit y , ' / oA t,;;L...;.;... .J-" .:r olo! J :i..JI abstracted a ttr ibute the purit y of a thing t.. ... " w ... 41 "';1,.,.;)11 Tr l v, true propositions . " \ r Iv . T / Q'" ol.:' ... J minor premise relative attributes ' I ' " . WI ;).,."l par ticul ar form .1.;: 0 I J t,;.J 1 . .\1 t,! .. d<..> bodily form 0 forms inte llectual forms 'Y ' - , "1 ))- :w.wl . AI( . ).r- r ':} :i.:.i:lh . 0..,>::; .J-:-.) ,v/ ,rv special fo rm ...... WIO))...11 intelligible fonns . <l .J4 ,j L.J ;) .. .,0.) [, t / '" J .>J 4 : I I , , liI.l< -.i,101 .J;;J ,,)\ ],1 " / " CU 4)1 c.)I.>, . Jl1 essenti al form imprinted forms u-Js:J 1 J-''':::' l general form :e.WI AI , " lil k... u-0101 ;) .. accidental form intelligible form composite form specific form -'.l)J.l 1 C h I.,! I J.;JI ...,.. 1 JLo.. ;) .. .JI u4U . ..) : rl ',' t l ' " opposite ui< -',.'..I I .JA .J.>,ih, .J1 \A , u;L...H JL-:; rj l>J u itl 1.5.0 uli.J 1 w';'Jly ! vi I' t A/ I CIA the forms whi ch arc objec ts of knowledge ,j ) .... )1 'x'" : ! ,I, t -.i ,l ' I" hi) u-al l J "' --" form If/ ' r t ';} 1.J'!! OJ)"'" J .,o. iJ l O)'>-P ! t /\ r 1 :, /' n .>ol.. 4! .. ' <::,<\-. I , ;;J l..l;;.i 4 t",l<rs::... :v/ ' t ,:c,J I, Jy.,;JI,y. .J1) l::<lloJ :, / '" -.;:,I.;.cru "lL.. J.,' : ' I' " :c. I t / ' ,., JI,,,Jl o ' I lil.UI,j r /'" 0 .. )11 .r"yJI u; t wo ( ront r;\ ri cl'l) ,I nlplr 1',11' 11' two kinds of necessi t y necessarily non_exi stent )bIJL.. _..,.::JI 01 n /, or necessaril y existent yl i$))ri' "J-,:,J J L.. _..,.::JI 0 1 n / ,or'>,:,yl natures of the world c!LbU!A/ '" G.>,:, 'JL,..l;I ;'J.L::... r I \ , \ c.. 4li. - ).J ... .!J I :i.....!...L.c. 3 - L ,j;;'" ,JI w - II . <7_ .r- A/ " A rational univer- .\..!.WI 'LkJI - - c: 0 sal natures nature
nature
Jl!..! ,r/ \t !l)J.J 1 t: J..iJ1 r / IT , J,UJI rWI .:.r ! 1/ ' A 'J' 0>';;:':..J1! , t/ " t I / ' A' ,jo1'>,:,J I....,.;.S two real opposites W!:-C,wl WI..l.aJ1 (contraries) ,t /, or 4-'c! MJI :(,l t: two contrari es as wl..l..Oll commonly understood , ' / ' 'r :(, l,,- t: 'J' contrariety ,jo! :c, .>..,;J I 1. J-' tr"".J I J ' l. ,.; '>' I
necessi ty necessit y conditioned by predication <Li;;....Ji.j l"J'J'l u ; "-i -u-:'J I W ! ! / ' 0 r ,j5:...u ! r / ' 0 , JL..J '>,:, ... JI <5)JJ'; ">,:,J JL.. n / ' 0 r , ..wI <5)J"';' )bl I I I ' y:.i.J..-.! fo!'} essential necessity nature whi ch is leCt necessity due to a .i,Ii .... yl 0 )).,I..aJ 1 free qualJl y r/ t \ ol.,;.:-. J,JI H! accidoH occurring na ture wit h a na_ to quiddit y logical gradati on , -I . ;;.,...JI v / v< accident occurring ,) Y'}I nature \\' hi ch is pushed 0 to existence "orId the world or command l.c ';} I lrij 'r / A! J) wl:.is. ! / A f .J.;.$..r';11 the natural world ! 1\' . 1,;.:- :c, , ... .,..JI :is" yJl specific n ature "-? 'pI I side , ! I ' V! c!l><-, .,j),)'-! .b_.,J1 point (unit ) of t ime ':'1.0)1..,))' ! I" r ,j-' folding up n l ' I t -""WI "--4 r-lt.. darkness ' I At ","" )\h,..1 0 L" 4lliJi the world of intellect JWI r-lWI appearance of a thing L,= 0Lil'1 ')J,""", IAl r A h . ,yl irl ..,...,J I vi A! actual world r-l WI custom r."Li<- l.J l< ,:, W l' I <_.S::.J I I \ I r AU''''! 1 r-l WJ r,. \.,<.- the world of ,)UIJ':' r-lt.. generati on and corru ption I I I H .r--AJ I;I ' the worl d of simili llldes "''; <,; 4 J",,;JI . )"..JI AI ' t , IS..;:- u )\ ... J I J.:) L....J I Jr'l'!\ I ' ' v tS.r-'l'IJ>; ul< "I.JI .5) J".;.J I .,j 1j'!J b .:::.,.J 1 IF" "'" an 0 'UlTing (accident) t non-consideration the material world sheer non-existence
' 1" Ji.J1 replacing non - existence r-AAII r " I' . , ""='; , A I ' ., ;(";;,,JI.j ";.;:.JI cS:U1 '-,_,,:--,! o-,,,:-...-J I u-',..-. 1" / ' \ r oc. l c.." baseless act number non-exist ence at the .s .,oA..u1 r..wl non_existence level of perpetual duration ! I ' , r "l u.r.--' .!>:I..J I temporal non-existence Jlo jl r..wl , \1' , ! J.!'<.II preceding non-existence r..wl '-' oW t... -' J.!1..i. " L<.:.J l oy'-'" .)" JL.-', ' 1'" u""- ..,...,!" , / ,. t u i 1 ... r.,::J, \ Ti l \ 0 ! ' / ' , non. existence at the level of sempiternity L5-'-r "'-'-, cS->"o"'-'-'Jl.j " / II r following non-existence r-AAII .j u-,J "' / ' " J I.j JL,- ! II ' . , ""WI J....,Q.::ii ! \ 'ltV :, .. ....... -'6-A.. ! \ / " ... -' tJ.lk... !,' I t v r " lVA0)1hJI cft!.L ill;.; r, 1\ \ ............ r v / AT Co-,,; c!1.::J1 u>:uJI Y.-.JJ ;l,J'! 0 t> ... J , IT / ' , , " III' = 01..<1;; r.J..s:.! \ r/I '" I '/ 1 I r 0Y.-YJ t l ; L<; '\1 " rcSJ.'J- "'" ... cS->"o"".J L<il .. j ;&..11) r..wl r..wl I \1 I or J!liJl rL..i1 u' privation and possession 4W1) r..wl , \1 I r real privat ion and possession (-"II .,41,1 I 0t> 01 '(' / ' 0 ! privati on and r..wl parall el 11 11 _ cxistence .... jO-AAJI \.... \ possession as commonly understood t affirmation in the form of negation 4.J ..wI _J y. .... "'. Ll L , j,;. ..,.-1_11 ,, (\ r accident \ , ( , ' ,,;, "':.;.;:....lI ,j J I>.J\ , \ ( ,. """r.J1 c::-:J I ",,">WI l,;f J ;.,. 1> Ocr 0>' Jt>:.!1 ,\ . / ' \ ,I" <5 1 , ! I v' l,;r ...,..J il,i , , Iv , ;,j.,s:JIJ.._ijJ.kJ.,) 1" 0 '"..l:-Jl! ' / \ VA J t 1\ " external accident accident in concreto i.J1t> 0Y- L,r.:! olH.: ... ':j \ t h T l;.. "'.,,).:r general accident accidental J.,...,... C/ '" '" I","" , \ T I , r "ll..1 I.. , \ . I " J.,..,..JI ,-""" ,,, \ . I Ar"';'f 1.. \',,,,, 1'; U..,t>:II" / v , separabl e accident accidental things ;y,..J1 <5>11 \.t/\ \! u; ljJl ' / 1' t non - existence rela ted to something \ ! I \ . "",1>.11 u ll a bsolute non_existence JlkJI t I " Jlhll CJ preceding non-existence <5>II,! 1\ \ T J,li. u; \ , / 1 \ '\" ujL)1 r,.l. .. Jl Jj \ 1 \ 'u"-ll 'Y.-> J ' non _ existence in the sense of privation \ T I \ ' \ Jlhll ...,..L.JI J,li.. ,j det ermined non_exisi:cnce t I " ..\,wl actual non - exi stence actual nOI1- existence at [he level of perpetual duration . 1\ \ t(r."II,jI..j11 (..\.I I J ,li..,j somethi ng of the nature of :.s-..uJ1 something negative ......... 11" . \ AI \ or active intellect JWlIJAolI I IT I A I Jl..il I r '1'1..,..;,; ' II ' ""-' c.!.;:.; universal intellect , I r I r vu.,.lJ 1 rl L.J.J .).",s <s.iJ1 riA l JS' r'Yl rl1"J material intellect .,L J...WI (li.. ..,; ..,..;.:.JI HI " c.'Yy; .J1 intellects JJAAlI A I ",".,1) 1 &' .:r W.h.. occurrence 'r /1 ' c. l<_";'.,.J1 u'; 01, I / H Jj.>J1 ..; L:.... , I 1V .... >. 11) ..; L,.,.' 'I' I 0 U- , . I \A' the confirmation of the predi cate I ;;"";'iJl the of the subject diversified intell ects 4:.A<i:;l1 J JAAlI intellect 1' 1' 'Jl.c-'Ylb,...,l1j:i.JIJt.. . I.,h;I nctive intellects 4lWlI J JAAlI I r I I I IJiJ 1_0-'-' .1..>- 1., JS'tJ Ir/ ltr causes .:;)I.Jl ul" J,ll .J1 ..,..'".} I ,I v J-" .}>- .,WI natural connection j - (A; 'YI I ;(,J I -II "" 1;( . u .., J . :r-J.."...., ..... v/ ll.-,.IJili connecti on of n ccssitati on and requirement ;WWI.,I ,}->JI Ji.ll 1.1 ..., "'-'J .. ::J I., J,k::JI , I ' / r v " I A I "'-'-'" )""';0 1 ) I..\:il l:.Li.J If I . .r ri A I (,(,]1., .L.(,JI ,. I AI ) L,.;-I)I., Jlh- '-"'; , I I I A I Li Jl 0" '-! 0.,r."! ..,.._,.; Ji.ll , . I I V J.,,,,JIj) J."J.::':""'1 ' I v, Lil.::.. .... ...,J <s.UI U) Li.J1 JL.;; ""-' 'y'-yl .oJ"';, A/ I I I I A V u ' l.iJ1 .;15:..1 '>':''' the all_com- prehensive simple intellect , I I " "'; ;("J.",o.l::J1 J.,i.J1 . 1.,1,,1 I ' I I ' v t t the cause of a cause D..JI & the sign of a thing final cause ... .Ii.. "I I " I T I I , It".. = ' r-.J-' I,:.." .i J....Al efficient cause D..JI ' I I" ifUI 'Y."YJ material cause D..JI T / " v pure cause I ':".,5::;':1 ","I creative cause joJl D..JI I t / lr .. ..,..,1 .l:.,.1 1 the cause of quiddity incomplete cause I ' /1 two independent .:,,!::.lA:...J1 ':"\;.WI causes '\"' I.J J}.-.J L,.,.,;IY j.J"!':I / I V I causes "", lyJ I , l:..::..1 I A/ I ' I the four causes JWI tit A if 4!i.l;i':l cause iWl ' Ir l. r J.,LWI ... .u:.. J.l , A/v v J.,LWI '-I, .. l+-.;.;. .) I 1/ , 41 t j':l J.,t.." "'-'!.r' ;' I A/I 'fo .ll,J1 Jl.. 1ft.J ;0 ":":";1 tts:: ':II, T / I " ':"I.I!':I ;(1. j.l, 1/ 1 Hd.,t...J1 ..;.".J.JL..JI ..u.:;1 , ' / I v.;"'.J""';' l&l Jj. .JI,;.;. ,,4j' t / I v 1;(l.J1.::,..u.:;1 T 1/ 1 v T ;(l.J1 ,;.;. complete cause ;(.81 iWl ,) .. ' / 1 I J}...JI ....;J.;.;' .) Jts::.!':II! I 1/1 I A J.,J.-JI U.JI u" " / I r, J.,LWI 1..,_ bodily cause
.;)l:J1 l.:;:.. , I I I" uA"l t/" , external cause internal cause ,'mal nuse G- WliWl .' ) t / I ., 1/1" t ! / I A. J..o.>. preparing causes separative knowledge; detailed knowledge '.r.l.;:.. ',.J..o::..JI .\,-:)14 1'1..11.,& H/IA' imaginative knowledge "/1" ,-!l:..J4 J..WI J empirical knowledge
\ I/IA .:JL:;..l1 <.>G rWl I / I A u.:J.J 'cr 'J.,"" empirical knowledge through imprin!ed forms <.>1) ..hi r-' J 4 Jt.:i ! / 1 A .:JL:;..l1 intuitive knowledge \ T 1/1 A t.::.lil4 rWlj G., ........ u..,,! \r / IA ' J.,t...-J 4 1'1..11 ui "'-! t; I 1/ \A. u.:J.J 'u-"ll knowl edge
pl...JIL .::. lil 4 .>x::.. <! . r."s- t.,,11 IV/ " .::.Iill, I TT /" diJ4 pWI .r-''' 1/" 11' / " L..,L--., lJ...bI., .... .! 0.,s' .::.1 >J 4 ...... ,s- V /' ! i .,t...-JliJ.,;-.r ""';1.,.- iJ \ f / \A t .::.1"i,s;JI'y'-II ! I/H , I / \ At JI.,..i1 ....... ,':' J ,t I I A t , If I I At [.",If';1 irl 0.,..s::,)1 -=-L:;.j ":JI " . /' A t cJ , t! IA' J}>JI.,..:., , ;YWJI., JI .... ;IJI J..J' If/lA' JI "I'" collective knowledge ; non.detailed knowledge " v / I ,J,.o..<::J I ...... ..:.s:::J! .r-'JJ.AiJi, "..v.::..J1 .\,-:)11 riA! 01 \ I! / 1' v ,t / , "0 natural science Divine Knowledge croW I t i) j .. WI J>-' )II I '/f' uJJI ri JI J active knowledge
..,...,.. l _ \ ' / " I t1JW4 0 1,.)11 J \ " II" . ..u H / I" ...)J.l-...,.... I '--'1 ' \, . )1 .u pWI r- ",. <,>>,:,.. - e.....Ji) .. "'II J>-,)l1\ A/n J.-.-\ I ./n I 1/1" J.U rl.J l u i 'r..,J1 passive knowledge
J_I(J I J u.,;l:JI"", " I n knowledge in the sense I r/ l' AU.;!J. , , external accidents -.)" 'I .iJ)1 ._11 kid f -- v- r nowe ge 0 a non 1;J I if ;I.,.J l.:r u..,,! , y-;; I n / lol -existent thing 'u"'.lJI ,y-yl <.5yC. J ... i extraneous (non- essential ) 4;!jJl vi> )yJl the soul' s knowledge of itself -1,>)'"' if)I.,.-J .1,.J1
inseparable accidents oi.o j )yJl "",J "u-"-JI "'" J-""'" ':l ...;J y.J I I I r/" ;(-j')IJl I' I ' ... J1 <.5,.. J..,; Jh:., mathematical sciences #1 ,j .) , ; -"',! !Y t) r'" ':l 41 "::',-- (j IA I r,L.::J I causality ;CWI individuali zing accidents 11;:-:111 ( 1 I 4,; i J) ,I I V I 4,i ;;.,.,t;J1 , A I I I r if J" c: u.,,;..JJ if ' / 1!rJ,WI causal relationship .(J .1- .11 WI .Y"""'J . .:r ;u...:...s'" ;(,;.;...JI.)I accident s of quiddity ,Yt(;' \ I ri tA ;(,J)...JIJ y.JI .b:1,r' I L.";jU u j l r -'/rvr <.5P.rP r I I r beinggeneral and vP J.,.:.;JI J r the first 'Coming_back J J ':II yJl being particular J.! i ,.u.J1 ,,1..1 j lY-J!.w J.- I .... .;.)1 '-""'-1 ' ..:Jl!JIJu'l:JI "", JJ':l I, ... .JI "'" ,j) r I n I.:.s::. J C! I) 13 the objective state of lhings goal foreknowledge .r.J1 element WI accidents
,/I'" the Divine Agent JI \J"'UI 0-' Jy.....u AI \A. u-'. ':II simple agent remote vi i" agent-by_self_ manifestation ",41 I All r I I A 4>....J 1 J.,; \rj l' I \r/ l ""'li. 1;rJ ;YWI ,p l,.J I simple goal 4: WI 'I I " J':N special goal essential goal accidental goal . ,.)\, .i,WI . _ agent-by- compulsion_ :..' --I\,. 1,,1 "I I I genera goa JI c...iJ1 , I v/ l'v "-'i.7'-' .r-;'...:.J 4 ij 4# cr-<:J.I ... .;'> u AI I' agent_by_being_forced ,,""';;0-' r 1>1, I r I I.' r/ l" ' -"0.. particular agent special agent essential agent agent-by_agreement JW' .,:;;':1 , 1. /1 " "-'ir:; I \ I I' ' I I the goal of goals .;.,\,WI.i,\t. composite goal ' I I' otherness j'1..;:U-'....;Jt;.;:JJ -' Ji 1aJ r--'... ,P:1J <,iI .JJ1 ...,.;)1>.<11 u" \ r/ l" vii .r"'" tJ; Jili::JI\ I II ,. agent \V/ l" ,,_.i:Jl u ; ... .il'-' I \ I I I I" c."h.,4 II I " ",;1...; ':1 1 ..,...,,kJ'c.,,k ... 4
.::..1-""" -' ... 1 individual , ' I' t c!LJI J ,.14 """WI I r /' t t..,) ,j <''''l. J5- .A,;. I the supposition of something impossible r l>-i 1.5'; ,,-J -."I I ry..'> .. .....;;. cil <,-:J4' ' Iv I ' j , \o ..........
'r/ lrt'>1.;:., i .. 1 1;1 0J>""Tr / lrT ,j 0)\....j u-J r t j I,,=.. '>1 L. J..s:J I , -' ' I T / I rt 0 ...... 1.., "';.r , i j l r' o.)Y:"J"j :.i.uk.... ;t.:, .. ....:z.... , I / ' n .::.L.yWl .:.!.Li 01-, l.:., -.l .... .<J.., t"':! OJ>"" ,0 /", ultimate differentia .DJ I " / I n r'- '> I.u.,.,.; t"':! 1 .. ,,<.- ,,_>.:.l 1 It / , n J I, l.',.. ...... )..,J.i o w '> I ..,; r'- '> 1 J-.J I u" '_il. W 1 v/ ln derivative differentia .j1A:";''i1 J.AliJI , T / I r. J.;. .. 0;.. LSI .u Jlii 'T / ' r 0 J .... .<JI ' / ' TO ------------------ agent-by-nature general agent v J.-"!L accidental agent .. i' .,..l4 , t /' ,A -4r.U agent-by_foreknowledge agent -by-foreknowledge in the special sense agent_ by_ foreknowledge in the general sense J"WJ proximate agent ,,:--!,.,aJ1 agent-by_being_ pushed vi' " , / " . JL.J I , IT / ' ., agent_ by- intention universal agen t , ,!, " C)\.J I I ..,..",kJ l) composite agent ...,s .,JI
, / I I V the most sacred effusion of God ..,..Ji':iI.JlI...Ai ";-1 r-I , I A/I r t 0W)'J "h.J1 ,/ \ r. J.,...iU .j u t:.,.;:J I JS"" ':;.J....)l 1 <51.1 I 1\ /,. J.,.;;-ll the sacred effusion ..,..J.i.JI.JlI...Ai actualizing differtntia J-,JI J.AAlI ,-",,,JJlrlWJJ.,=.. J""";) IT Ir v of God logical differentia
?I , t / or J....,;...JI " ). recipient I / " ,h....,:...J1 'y'"yl JIAlI I A/ ltr .)-,*,1.,., external reci pient 1.1411 <?) tJ. two recipients , / I t r .,WI Jlill 0K..}l1 <51 the powerful; the capable rJ .L.:; ;'J 01" j.J .l.z 01 <51.11.,., " / '" J"',i rational principle " / I t ..,-.;.;}I the principl e of .till presupposition 'A/ '\ u"'jJl ul,J1 ,hi Lr' , \ AI I A 0.h,...,11 <.,411.j <5r,<i}l
' / 1" rl):..}l1 J...Ul1 'I A/ I ' / I r ... .jlo:..:}l 1 di fferentiae 4 "'..,,! J.. ..rtl L:.lI.J.,! .:",.J I
act, actus Ja.<i!1 .,AJ I J.s. r.li::.., 1/ 1 ,t .-WI ;(;I,;.}l1 rWI Lr" " /1 " r .1.i;J1 .1,.;1 .;,....(J I .J!"'; Lr' 0 ' I / I v A I \ 1 I A< '"...:J I ..,.,1.1"1 Lr''' I lAY
.q.AJ1 mutual need r / I t...,..) .,.JI ljo:-}I I .J.,! heavenl y sphere \ <V U:.J4.!5:HJ) .J)\;;;.I agents , / 1< I C!LlJI u'" effusion, emanation "- ..rP'!'" real division imaginary division ) I.AW.I ifrl4 '.I..>.I-,JI .}-",.,JI T I \ A <,CiJI J, li.. ",; '" / \ ! A natural intention proposi tions proposition v I Ar I;rLiI , ,I A T Li",_ JI .61.:" ' I \ , 0! .j>- iJ.:::'" factual proposi tion
if' ' \ / 1 A",,-WI 0l! .j IT / Ar ;)",,,,-,I..::JlS':cw."Ot;.J1 external proposition , 1)1.j>- if' v I AT :cw.. GJ [;.J I ",; " r. -'411 decisive proof power HT ., \.!..).I r-lli / A' O)..\Al1 ,r.:....J I , 'I, T' 1.oJ I ') "'_. J..:.::.i , '/' T J.UlI) I""; , ! / ' T' J.Ul I.j>- ..:;.;--J I animal faculty AI' T' )J"",)\JIJ ).".>..,oJ1 ........ 'r.-A:; pre - eternity rJAlI '/ \ ' " pre - eternity and temporal origination 14-' J,j-L..j 01'; J';' L J"- L::J I." r..\i::J I T I' I A relative pre - eternit y ,;)1 <",.! 0Lj 0" ,-",".L 0",- J"-T <cr 0L.j 0" l... , . I \I T real pre-eternity - __ II JAIl ...r--- r mental .i,:A.il1 oi"MI pre _eternal in terms , ' / H .jh;.J1 01: <"", ill of time ' I AT .6.. being_pushed_back; obstruction r-AJI actual proposition oi"J...iJ1 t 1'1' 4,,:.''1':1., l:1, ':I if -,1>' ;':1 f T ' I' . T l,;'jJ;"
divisi on
sllbsistence in the mind subsistence I """ UJ i JI r / v I .;J UI., pdl cS l subsistence of issuing (s))..I...al1 power; potentiality; potent ia iij.lJ1 ' / 'A ! 1/ 1 I I 1;;.-. WI det('rmining factor .uJ1 .u-"J ;.,'J-ol,. ! I V / I I ' J..oJI ;,WI JI ' 1/1" the Di vine Book I ' /1 . JI.u; I)\JI ..,...; l,.JI power and non_power ; ii ii.,.all the composed Book 1i!)..I.::l1 strength and non-strength A/ IA wl.;'JI cSl \ .::.. 1,..,5:JI.0 the external animal facult y Book of creation I A/ I I I , .:JI C JI,;l'1 .>.,- affect ing power the internal pi;:.. LI , \ ! / I I I ... c: Book of creation multiplicity ii ;$JI .J , t / ";'}"''';I , . / l'1.::..u.. W luJi<;L;, ':II""". uJI u' wl..; l'1 '1)1 u; ! Ii \ ! ... T II " " Lr '-!r."J1 , V/I t ...... .::..lI t/ I' . <,;liJI if)yJl vcgr. tativc faculty IV/ I I 1.!.l) ..0 lr 4 c: J I.; l'I . ;., . the curves of J)j.:.lll$") descent and ascent bodi ly raculties Ii . ..s,r u.,.:.;;.i.. ! t i l" .r.:J"UI :i::!to l.:.... A/ I . \ <)],.)1 multiplicity wi thin ii..\>-)I ,j ii..PJI subsistence of inherence J"wl 'Y.-Y" 'I' n"Y.-J ifJ .J4 'Y.-J" , 't / ,n , " I, rr oj '-h..IJ ..,10)1 ,-"II "cJJ....J1 ,,_.<i ",)l L\, I})l IL'''...,,! " I, rr <;j,:")lJ '. 1' rr ,)lJ)lIL' 41 ,,4 rational universal the universals of substances substances and accidents the five universals natural universals uL,KJ4 J,....JI '--Ubi , r I H :c,.."hJ I universality 4l):l1 ' I. I, J':" yluLJ)I <,KJ1.!.<:l..... the whole-ness of a whole J>JI " 1'" .1f.-)lIJ the Divine Speech 't / " t ':"T,iJl<5 1 the perfect Word of God .(.l:)I.llI4lS' unity the numerical many)) the specific many the whole ;...IJJ.l ..., r . I ' v, alb in the sense of each individual \ \ / \ ,.., )) .'!.,; <.5 1 all " used collectively ,, ' I' , .. If.-)l1'J,:"J <5.,- oJ'J,:"J)I , r I , n "'i,.k.;;., JI c.t-"':")l1 1.1':'; universal , \' I" I,: j,:" J u..s-.>.,.IJ -ci' .:.. J' u"; L I" Iv 'Y.-J" u- J.,..,..)I" ' I, r ci>r LIJ ,,-,J, r/' t J.r.JIL' natural universal
, r I t r v",.J,JI J5=l1 JI;;" oj 'Y.-J)I , r/ n u!4)1 Ji!.. " I II' ..,.,1.;..:;)11 <5>- rl , ' I' n u--,_JI 1.r:.()\JI J)I;.;;..)lI, ,I, rT UI;JIJ ,J 'Y.-J)I discrete quantity J.aA:.J1 !.l y:.::... .h oj '1., 4....iJ I L. ; I I I I A .b;; ,",j5:, ; AI I A r II" ..,.;..,lJ (Y-- ... . ljl .... lI! ; 'I I A I ." A/IAI "jL.....)\!IJ secondary perfection ({Be! IIJII If /l> F.)I II JII WS"' = 4J F.)I II J Be! }) which is the source of existence the word Be! Uri L.., " ulL..; 4"U J}.4l1 I r I I' " .hl.., '11 the word 4)'p1 4J F. )1 II JII WS"' which is the source of existence and light I I / A I <sill 'y'"jll quantity L. , I I H c:U Il j; ;c.."J. J .L:.I J-i:.<.., J.,o.::..; r / , A j,i" ........ uI.:u 4 ; I A U"'"'I ;rl , A. 0- 0 ; I r I, , I ill I ..... 1..,"- ! I I AT ....;,s;J1
false propositions mathematical quantity being 0,1-" L.,,! ,I.rll; I ' I! r""-"".:,,!J';II 'II n'y'"jJl <s1 ;r/!, existence in the presence of the minds 1/0 A -.:.... existence in realit y; .bJ IjU-,h::.I1 el....J 1..,,-,,,1..;;) I r I \A I u',h::.I1 continuous quantity J.A:.JI ! \ '/ \ A ! t /' A Jil; ; 1 A' All ,f"", ... ,-,,1 V I I A' continuous J.A:.JI quantity which is essentially mobile I'll A.,",_)loJl.:.- existence in concreto continuous ';"loUl}i J.A:.JI <s.:ul, y." r/oA .c:... quantity which is essentially immobile I ! I I ,\ .1;..) I ... e:I.-Jlj I oj I.:.- audible quality existence in the I \ / I r t u- 4 <5 J olliJl ...,h:J1 external world mental qual it y L...AJI ' I ' (.$ ! ' 1/ ' \ 1,oW; I.i,.l rl. JI1.,-,-< p;J1 i-'", J L.,....,.... li,l .>...IJ .cr- 0-" . / . !,.;L.;'; qualities ;G.)I.AA:: ..... ":,,,L..4..sJl . . . .. through .preparedness 'Jill 1.4; ... ::11 u 1.,.i,5:J I ...,lk.. 1-, uJll5" ! , / I , I '''''';)\J I., I / I A ,;(.,..l>..P ... JI., :;"";'I.r--JIJ active ..:...u..s:J1 . J . . .. and affective ll qualities I I / I A, u L.,...w1 cYl.,l u" visual quali ties o.J..a.:-J1 " / I AY I., .1.,,;,":1 15" qualities peculiar to quantities V/ I AY . 1.:>.; '\11-, .... 1i;;..)' 1S"" gustator y qual ities 4i..i.J1 ..:...I..A.SJI J . . I I / I A, <I.,..} I tyWIS"" auditory qualities 6.P J.......JI I '/ I AY ui.r")' IS"' olfactory qualiti es A.o.,....;..J1 I ' / I AY Cz..I I., ;;"'WI (:; IJ) 15" tangible qualities .(.., I r / I AY if"....,...] I I ( L..il .:r existence in the mind .;.."jJIJ.J 1/ ' . ..,.,..; 'r.., being_inhering
r / I v A if r-JI 0-"-," quality
!, . / ' \ ""'; u ":Iy.J1 JS t!'-' <,..W I)..,.,.,J lui .. ...J;.;J..:;)\b I! r / . J !. / .,<..,....,;J4 .::,)'> .. ,. .. JI .:r !I / ., rWl ! 1/ 1 AY ......,....., !, / I
quality called t affection)) ,,<- .:;.;15'" 01 ..... u l,i,lJ1 u" r / 1 Ar J W l5" ! \\ / I AY affect ive quality ;';'_1) .;;.; 1' 01 <_.,....,...11 u l,,.i,S;:Jl u " I / 1 A r ill..J1S""! I A/ I A, quali ty by essence I , / . I q uali ty by accident . .oIL .,j.$J1 ..r'.r . . sensible quali ty l,LS -' L-,_,.. li,l .>... IJ .cr- 0 J ' . / . !,.; I_;'; HV non_power ,YJ I '" ' Iu:.. ':II u l,iS:}1 Jlk! JI -,!.<;"jl ,Iu:.. ':II : , I In ,>;)1.11) 1.11 non-existence T /v , non_existent J":' the Divine wodd )\)1 ... .:....."-1 y.,j I T I I IT' TI T' pl easure o.DJ1 ut,.;.J I J ,j 1y,>J I J ,-,,"J I r>J I ,so t the Ivhy of an affirmation vi i TA the \vhy of an objective fact why.is. it? I Til TA>"r l l. wLl ,jJ the essential proper ties jly (attributes) of the Necessary .::-J II I I t possession (ca tegory) J- 6' qualiti es belonging to the soul ; mental qualiti es ' / 1AT "I)':I IJ r l .Jl) nOll-requirement I T I IT ' -.J4 l.i. . l.;.;1 1 1c,,, .1..5" non_requirement on the part of a thing it self vii ' 'J,AllcP 0" .L,a.::i':ll ,)I,!':I non.conditioned LJ..o..i.J r / \ r r u-"';"".J U-- i Ti l the non.conditioned as a division : 'II T I uI)l:;.1 0" Til T! the non_conditioned i.$-..a.JI,J, as the source of division " J,..l IJ<6 y;. . JiJ'-i.lk.JJ r-'-' <siJ I <,hJ",)\14>IJ ...,"-i J0i.. >" , ! Iv; ,II n u,,J, uK, ' til n non - essence consequent ial property of quiddity non-thing '<s)t,;:<1
t I ' , : t I I! A .u.:J I \vhat is accidental identifying factor , _I\,\,. v"r, '" L.. .:,,0 , Y I :i.,',.! .j j 1,:,: )1 I "! L.. ri o ,,,I"''\'I common factor !.II ""lo .J , "-! L.. .r"J.r'-l1 If.! '\' I I t_ .!llr-"'\' I di stingui shing fact or common aspect what? - of- definition .\.a.Wllo matter I Y! I ,v"I.JlO , r/l r t 'J 1p.'>';"1 1; 1 "L.. ')-"" JLi, f .11 t I l,;.,lo 4,..-Z f I rl ,,_ "WI "! W rl " v matter and form l:i \ I Iv I J.,o.'l IJ li,;.L.. 41 4,,"..,...,s-.rJ If . I I rt 0 l>. I I I t I not; non_existent .:,WI \ r Iv t L.J CI.,>. l f ' / 1 I Y ..,...,J 0y::" 01 ", I; 0" "...,'JlcJ l "..,UI 0" Ji.JlcJl.: Ti l l" sheer non-existence tr,lJI0" J..,t ..u J oWl A/ I A ..,...,'\' I cJ l ,,:'''') 1 the state of non_existence .iH (nolhingness) of Ihe esscnce r}' !lJ! 6J..A,.J ! r j
\r I llY the state of essential A::-:UI non_existence (nothingness) 1_/ 1' (J...JlJ 'y'-yl ol.,.:,.;;;I 'J d' the nothingness of possibl e things "....,! 01 .,1;0" .:rUI 0-,5 -sl vi I ' _ that to which movement :is" is directed 6:.!),,:JJ'r l.!1 <LWI :;s ),..)1 :':,l<- V/ I H what is essential L.. cJ I <ft'-" 0 1 J..! 'J u. ) . J L.. J..) I. , "";),Jl, I" ,l,.:1 , 1' / _ t u\ .)J li consists what-i s-it ? , r I t r -'" t.. ",Ir. J Jt>, t.. y..J1 , r I ' T A >" rl-'" L. 0L> r-!) u; J sources;principles higher principles ...;;JI" I ' A 4-; .L,..:;'I'l iL,i t / " , principles material principles source '0';" 0>(,; W'- W-i 01)"1;1 'r.J J.l" . I " t L,il.",. vi' VA '0,.J4 the principle of numbers .J.:.o r / , t A ,.w4 .).,..I J the First Source r I , " h"...,J 1 Jd.il.l J l!.. the source of thinking t I " t .y 1'-,...;.) 4 1",\,_-; the principle of principles simple (non-composit e) matter external matter essential matter accidental matter t/'"
<.J .. c:: <-P'lI.).;. y. 01 J!.. , vi'" ;,1" intellectual (rational) matter composite matter common matter matter in the general sense <Jl..;:.J '-' t!'" y.l IJ ;,c..,.:J I ,.,J 1 J>o...0" U"'>- J...::.! ' , t I' . T I ' 'V ...,.-oJ 1 what? - of -lexical-expla- nation u; Jt>,L. ' t i t T 1""':1 1 U"" >" rl ' TA 1""':11 u"" that in which priorit y is affirmed; the subject , / oA':'j-J t) ' lS..:.J ' <.5" "" j-;; "" I,> WI <..,I"J f '/,A "-! rl"i v/ , (, JJ <.S,WI f' r/ , ,r similar Ji.o Beginner Jl!.. '>'1 r-"" f, /VA.<.5" .u.:.s u"'! , t / v A ..6.IJ j y.u. '>' t.,,; J j t.,,; two simil ar things luminous Ideas )yooJlcs" f (r / I " u; jJ b,;,. '(/ " A 401 J ,", A..:L;;)I <".WI vain (action) non-material sheer existence non - mixed; purified something made being_made ...;! 'b...J1 J,
ff /AY 4,,)1 A/AA ;(,...,JIJ 'r,yl collection J;" T 1 '\,5"::: .L.i I,) , t /l n many things taken ' / '" J>"JI,l.._1 <r the self-revealing
continuous (quantity) J-.JI '-"; if fi 01 0>:"" J.,a;:.. J-J J", f, '/ I I ..,. lA/ I t .,.,, 1;;:.. conditional proposition .u...::.J1 t\-\'O correlatives two opposites 1.. .. f ' 1/' t , / v 01.)1'-"" two contradictories finite ,L::.,. lS.l:.::..Jl, cs"L:.::..J1 .GI)I "/' v, univocal JolrJl , 'Iv! when (category) I <.i'" iflr l 0" that of which something .\.l .-1' 1,";;" " ...:iJ u" of' r , perceiver J.,.:J 4.J.><;;.. A h' ;.\ J .w I c: " [,.; I , I I " ;.\J .wJ ...,wll object perceived !f)..wl , II " \ AI" the Essence that essentializes essences I I t A the mirror of the mind .;r".iI1 .;..1 .r T' f' . the stages of the soul stage, level !, I ' n) ." r-I lW"u,,;.,i:J1 t L;;;I ' I' T' "i.:l.I':I J.,! the stage of the as a whole v/ ,vI rationally impossible; absurd Jb..JI definiendum .r-lA:i !"I ,n'J-,,..j IJ>..\oJ1 "t,j J.>JI ,,; J.,,a..i;JIJ JL.,:" ':II r I ' 0 actua)izer full (negation) " I ,r.")...".,... UL.,"",- predicate by way of adherenc,e rWI0" ' 1 .. predicate
given in answer to a simple uwhether innermost and the hidden ( of the soul) predicate -;;s-rJl J J , t j , '\ given in answer to a rational level the stage of quiddity ' V I ' T\ ,- . tl ;w -=r . .r " /A T uI.!J1 that which gives .r ((whether I I " anything that allows of predication , t I V 0 .-1' = .r.>--- J.l mixed subject of an affirmative proposi tion . / . .:.t;1 j the proof by way of unit y parti culari zer; individu- alizi ng factor \ / v I >,J I '""kJ """ <,-:J I individuali zing factors that whi ch provides things wi th thingncss To i t A the things of which J>;"}I exi stence can be predicated I / ! AU l:.:,,"I' L..,u" I,;;), l..ci"; 4"'-" that which justi- J>; }IJ- fies the predicat ion of existence " / AV I r I>, ",--<; the referent of a conept; JI..l.A.JI denotation; extension 1)\;:>.1\ I/ t \ ci I..\-.J I, To /A I something having its origin t;)..1.-=.JI ..,-.dJ ;y5J1 c!L,lJ1 ;(;JJ...a.- T T / ' T , t T preponderance to the originat ion of the worl d imprinted form A.i l,;.1 -.J I I. / I A t .:. ljJ4 cSl "/, Alifrl 4 pl .l IJI real composi te .sA:W1 ..;5 ...-JI ...,a..J1 ..j "1'6. 0>S::, 01 1/1 ! I , ' Iv 0 external composite ) L>..l 1..;5 ...-JI J l>. -,.-s-.r' " ... ;t, r ,,] I u [;, ' / ' t , external composites r li temperament ' / 'tTI" / ,, 1 . 11 C.r A/ I t 11)1 li). Cl;,- the proof by way of J!..l.a;!1 &-. judgment v/ ., ", jJl ""U L j u .1.-' u the proof by way of representation v/ "u, .AJ1 ""UI ..j the proof by IVa y of universality ' I ' \ <-<", jJl .::. UI..j the proof j.JI 4 .J" &-. by way of something being the , T/ HA the object of what-kind_of?, , T I ' T A the obj ect of how_many?" , T I ' T A the object 'of 'how? , T I ' T A the object of why?' \ 1' T A classifying factors correlation -U u-I(';':II-,; !T/IAY ).J:; 1, / IAYr) real correlation
correlation as commonly understood ', 1, AY :ut,;':I1 oY,r'!LY" the object of what? \.t two correlated things \ 1' T A 1T I' A Y )\..;-' ''''; the object of t wo different cor_ oJijUJI of_definition related things 'I'TA 't l ' the object of what? ;(,.. )W:Jl\.t two similar COI'_ oJij\.AJl _of_lexical-explanation l i fT 1'-':11 U":'Y" the obj ect of ' when? <.i" , T I , T A the object of why? of affirmation Y I I T A Ihe object of why? ..:,.. ,.; of an obj ective fact Y I I T A related things , 0/' A y"".,iJ 1-,,,,,.,iJ I., ,-"'" ':It) two correlatives ,r-All d l u-l,AJ4 rb JI!.. 'T/ ' of J;li:JlrUI.:r \, T/ \A implicit term
T I A ! "....o-J I c'"..;&lW I c'., objects of question ..,.J\h.Jl ,;".; I IS' -'-':' -,,j \ ' I' T A :i.::- 4-1 , I I IT A-,-- Jlk...J1 the object of where? '-J.<. .u!J1 "';'.,,, L .:r the subsidiary factor of a -.u..JI -..lA.o , suBsidiary factor A/ V' ,-",i ... l.r non_existent
\V/' l"l ,y-y-ll P" tI.:.:..l ;v/ l '
""4,':.:r ; I Iv t -..2. ...,..) \ f j v o \ ! j v= ;, tl:.::.. l ; I /VA .1\ , J l>... ""y-yl ""u.,.,.J4 "';L.o; I external world the object of \1 I, A the object of simple -.,..lh.. .whether-ness the obj ect of composi te (whether_ness existence in the absol ut e Jlh.. sense absolute .i.llk.JI explici t term ..+JWI I Iv . 0 iJl,j "'" ) c.,;. ':II ' I A t t""' . ..;lW I c:"J that which in ab.solutely ... J.AA.JI something .being a mani fes- non_existent tation I ' I .A liI.k, <"II .... -".lJ ;i.,1S:::JI C:LhJI ...,.",,!;, " I', an impossibl e nOn- existent C" !\ j v t .)y...J1 ""'" r 1\' a pos; iblc non-existent J.AA.JI t j \ us:::.- definiens ; definer what is supposed to come back Ir j vA o<Ll.... resurrection ,. Iv \ u ; ; \...JI meanings Jt...JI uit.......l l JJ....i. HI , subsidiary factor 'U" the caused; effect r;"" I rl 'r 'y'-y" :i. .u:.. <WI JS , A/VV J.,t .J1 r..\.J ili <WI 'r / l """,.>";, I iJ..1J r j'J'JJ.." , r I I V :c..WI <WI .r jy.< 1 'J' "t,j ! ! / I v I :iLJI "".....:;1 .....:; 1 . ! I I I v ! ill,1, :il. J I ,..\. Js- ";.,, the last caused 1 ) rr I I V! ill 0.,5: 1 'J' the first caused; the J J JjL.J1 First Effect I ! 1\ . c:;lh.JI r ,-,.,.]1 J .I".u c.)\""'4 -iL:J1 J., .lJ Jl!.. \\ / ! ! UJ"-' Jr.-JI ! I! I . v " 1. v dcfinicndum \ / t! definition of existence ) y. )1 .. :lJ"l' .,,;c1 01 <5i.J1 JI .:r--JI ""I!JIS"' r/ t! "'. being-a-definer an intelligible; - object of intell ection
one single JpJl I r I " ji.J1 c: J.>.:... caused)) primary. intell igible J J J whatever is caused by ) y.)1 J secondary intelligible J\;II existence J u-"! L. ! I I <V .y' .r-,.:jJ.-<> 'J' 1 01" ,'1"-.:.,..-' object known ; object of knowledge pJl I \ 1 I ! secondary int elligible.; W. .L..I J ' .r 0 >' .:r J ts::-" 'J' I ..,..,.. J.AJI r-WI ! \ .1. > \ A, p!..J1 extcrnal object of .r. )WI pJl kno\dedge ry..JI.:r-' <5.:.J1 I ! I lA, tf.')!;,J1 .1-"'_'_ I\J:c,,;..rJIJ ..,.,. y..J1 immaterial and aU.comprehensive intelligibles (1 __ 11 having a cause; subject to V-- causaliiy \ ! / \ \ v Jl..< JI:UI .:r '.r'J' r pure non-material )lA.J1 object-known by things essence \ t /A tJ;W4 luminous non- ",.1.:u4 rW1'rrl"cSr'-1 material things cS.:u1 Iv/. T .::.1 .:u4 r"J. .J1 c: \ 0/\ A ! !J) J.J.J oJ r. J .a.-.ij u; concepts
lA.J1 object-known by ;.r.LW1)l!... ,nI t, \ AI \ /v r accident abstracted idea the concepts of the yl..!1 J..!...r-AJ4 categories \ r I. t \ '/v t .omething inseparably J."JI concept; notion r JfA.J1 attached to something else; something j,)\;:,:. 1 , \ / t '.J 1 J..,.W 4 1 0 L:.z 1 r> ..... JlI T ' /A \ T \ IA \ .;"s- 0 r-l the concepts of Jt.o..Jl ..:;..t. anything impossible which cannot be self-subsistent \ ,In abstract '/lAt rl.JJ sophistry 4kJ\4J1 r l AT C!--::;'}I .::.11-.14 ifJ..!I! l.. .L,;:..::;I 0-' generic concept r JfA.J1 \ AI \ At what is meant by , be ;t.\:lI';'IS',)w the concept of non- r.wl r as a perfect verbe , I' t J.h,....,iI .::. l,\.&.' 1 ",; existence 01" what in meant by the concept of accident . .;, .11_.u. 1..T.r \.nr-- ((be as an imperfect verb .r" I.)<- ;;.,.; b '}I yw 1 I ' t W 1 .::.1,4J I.} ,_,;.,.;:.) 1 itV I lSI) J>- the three categories ..:..wI I r I I v A ) l,...,JI ... lS') ul.< the ten categories t I"'; o:i..ll J (.wI ... 1 categories in the intellect category ;;j J" ..:;..,,:; t? JO'i ;y.w I ;;,l5:11 t LkJ I T I_ T two categories f ' I - . .r.:J J'- ..:;..,,:; .L.l> 'ci' ( I);'; I A/H constituting differentia constituents r I VI 1_>,- rA..JI ...,..J.i .;..\..ft.JI J>- .y r,:..- y,;.. 'i I J-.J I u.:U T/ lnrl..,'il confined 4-JI . l i;:;I'i ;.,;wI .Li;:;1 '-:'rll u; 0J5:11
the Producer I I I " ...,,JI .:r \ I /_ Tcs"'lJl specific concept "ff' .p I r JtW I t / H .y .i:.1 the concept of existence Yo ylr f I I It v/,_ two opposites quantity antecedent
}..IA.JI r3IY.:r ..IA.JI r T l i t v .u::.. Jl.4 Jl::J1 sacred ..,..-..IA.J I I' 1-' u-""WI the source of division A I I v ( W'i l.:r.e II .r:-. 0 Js;:, 0 I., -'i'i .L,i rl...,;.;1 c:: 1'-,,)1...., rT dividing ;(-: ..... ;.'l,' J ...... JI f 'f Iv I 1.,>,- r>-'.Ji ...,..ll _/vi pi.'iI' ....... (non-conditioned) at the
stage of the source of division I I I <*' (WI .:r common basis the four categories Ti l T IJ,-ll (l _".) (;.;;JI .,;1.,...., I r / l VA .}I.,.::'il lSI) J>- the common basis of the nine categories ftJI t I I . r ')J>-'..)1 .u J.;. r.l " I I r L,JJI }J..J I JI -I I ' V .:ri)Jr'> J 4 ..... T I I I T .L,;,;:;I I -I I IT U-,J 0.,5:"!0 1 ",1 \,., Til' t ' I I" things that are possibly .;" subsistent ;jl} ' I I t the yardstick of distinction priority I t I-r the basis of priority possession I r I- I
positive (as offosed to negative) properti es u IS;) .... possession
the yardstick of need lhe angelic world of the .;" rr I I r0l>:..'YI.,.. Souls; Supra-sensible world the yardstick of Ir/l y"kJ1 'w..J1.:r truthfulness in a proposition mobile extensions .;,,1-J:.o.JI l IAr I v/ l l. fn / tt anything subsumed (.J..c.J1 immobile extensions ojLaJI ';"I-..I:.JI V/ H something under which (.J..c.J1 something else is subsumed the Ori ginator
I I I I- -:;,JI .1.._1 .:r impossible I v/ l I "TT/ t t ,;:....J 1 I vlv .
IS)JJJI"'-!.>':;f v/ A I E-"'1S)t,JI.!s::..".:: \ I 1'- logic ila:..J1 possible \.::
ciL!l1 Jy..IJ dl!... .oJ.;L. H / w r I t r=,'; JS" u , \ ' 1'_ IS)JJJ I .... I A/ " existents existents in the hori zons (i .e. ill the external \\ orlll) I / t J,bJI",T eXistents in the soul s l / tA .i.ab..J1 )WI J":,,,.JI actual i:l ed external exislen ts I ' /.'f o)-..l.W1 non - actual ized external existents longi tudi 11..-'1L existents latit udil l:ll existents exi stent in tlH': I ' / A r .i,J # 1 J":,,,.JI IA/ " r ..-II J":' ,..JI I v/ I I r external world (i n concrl't u) ,. 1-, i 0 l .. I...,.:; ... _I\ J existent in the mind ..;,,c,jJIJ J":' ".JI I! r J..:.r< ) ... ::L:. '-;-""':t .... .;:j ) I L, ' ryJl ) u,:".j!10 1 ,l'A".;-,J , " (hypotllcti cal) ploposition , , / vv :i.J. .... 0-" ilHpii .:;i t mode:; GJWIJ' I r / " d j,L l+", .... 6..' L. : : i 1 prud Heed i h i JI gs
L,;.,.; C.,.JI untimel y death i.S' I p:' I ..:.>".JI natural dC;1.th one \\ ho affects aftects ; the real Agell t 1-,/1 r ..ill'\' I affi rmative propositions all alfirmil tj,c propositi on in a negative form I r / l r ... J\ existent F. yJI .... )\1, : : v/ J I I.JJ. .... .. 1 fr / .: V u l="" ... uLc ...... : r I v t l-:-l f j ;-"u-::J L TI t! '-!Jl....::.. ' I t t 4,; ..!S::,.C;:.;;JI .:r ' ' / t. 'y'">!i vll .,_,11 ;f5JI)l!... f \ "i t 0 w:A:;.. r-'-,')I; vi "
It /" 1.,_,; ; I AI . h..}1 " JI ,J;.;.., I ;c,Yl!.JI J 'J ' I ')II ... ,wl U" J "::"JL<;')I ; V I . r ; .;n ""t.;.II J
f "II ' \ l.-ii J.' .. G:.:.... I ' 1" ; I ' I'A t..;},' ; I I / u J) I riA . : i f" v J .... I'o t;.i. 4 ' A/ AY 1.,;\; rl.,;,,; if ... \ ... / A
; ./,., . J-'.-G T / ", 'Y.">lt, t..)>" I I . , if J,ltp Y." >JI) , J I I ., I ..,.--><! .:,s::; ; I Ti l' .. f T/l ylr J-<- . /1 rA ,.,.11 J dill.::.I,; ; 1' 1 I I A >'I.::.-J ! I ' l l T A 'yJ C: , .. mental existents , ,/ .. \, existent in concreto .:r.J1,j J":'.,JI .. J 0:-'1-11 wi ol:._ o .... :J t / " ,r:.T -u-Z the hcing - exiHcnt of J":' J" ' luiddil y ' I i \ :i......\A:", subject; "-,,I}.JI , I /v , 'y'">J4 r-"'-' r Iv T , ; \J ...... , ; ' Iv T J.,.,..JI U';'j'JI 'y> r/ lv, " i 'r' >,;, yJ0JS::J I "---'i J if J.J I 1.,-: r>,;,yJl 1.5-; ,1 .... ;')11 , I I I VA '- Ti ll A ;:":,;;JI.:", ,-,;...oJ1 something being .,.JI 4.f-yiJ J" the subject of an affirmative proposition 'y'"yl ..::..l,i')l 6L.. ' I" u",.l.J1 quiddities , I AI t, ..::..I;S::- J ..::..lAb... "::"\;:1 1J c/ AV
quiddi ty
Ti t ,,,.,,wI ,>&i-> '-!) 1 ; ' I t , L. , u; ;;J; >-'''-' ; V I t r , Y."} I V C
,- , a bsolute (luiddity specific quiddit y distinction '....)1 J. uL...;a.;..... ! L.I d'" l4 : "IV! "'-' tlJ r-' , . / v, . " / .. II . 'I <""" I I f v r ":';'" d ... -'-.,; .J , tbe " 'orld of bodily (orms ..:.> J'"'UI , r /' , ,,1.!:(,J,klI iJ...LII 0" qualifier relations -.,....:.JI _/A ...,.. ,)I.;:. I>;"'i 4:4r. ncce."ary r elations H / A> relation ;(...JI 0';).JJ0>5:; ;iJL;')'I>.4.(J "";Jkl 0,' I A V relati on of judgment r / A r categorical rdalion wa; t:Q;JI : l' / \ T' ')1 I,.J; ',/I ! . :i.;:1.1 ... ! \ vi \ T' ... J 4'1; ,j :;' L,..",-, .J>;(""; , r / I r I 4:HAi ) l.;::...:.t! :.u....::.:o-:.:.:.. ]:i.. -' .;;.1.iJI!J 'YJI : ! / Ir! ,- l:, j ! \ viI '1"1' ... iL ,.1I .., . .., mentall y_posit ed quiddit y I / I ":U.,.,,...Ji ;c,,.. J I J, l<..j generic quiddi t y quiddi ty / t t wh;ch .i.l.A><::.J I ;,jl; . tl .r. is not actualized !/, n "ctualized lluiddity d! a-..:.JI4JI J T /1 r TleJ IJJ"1 ""; 1"";'; 1 non - mixed. quiddit y .r.s-J14:tJ1 ,j\ r \ 'i 1 ... quiddity " 'hich is v/.o fundamentall y real between necessity and possibi lit y '-/ 1' v 0\,..<.:)1> , 1.;:)1<.._,5- , . quiddit y originating fact - itself .J" procedures Wf f 0/ '" or i ::..b .:ul\.i ... J:1- J.WIY' J ,i ; IV/ Ar T/ AI J\,;II 0 0il l J l<lk.. r<1, I / "! TT / I n;(.,..,.JI""I; ; T . / At human soul spherical soul J>.I'...':.J 1L' J. .... I>JI,.J ... ,iH .. 1/ " , spreading _ oul mner logos external logos the order of the universe rational soul "LI.II . 1\ ""'''''..r- sharp deductive JlA.",)1 j,!JJI pi ; , / " :COb lJ I u-i:.J I <s I 0" jJ I J.,...iJ1 u" <.i ' l ; T / At ' J.>.iJ 1 J ",,-,WI ' /I r'0U'I'IJ,.,.;.. 'I'1 rational souls negation
the negation of the Attributes I r / l t I ",.""I..<.,.,JIJ;if)\>.'I' IJL..f" absolute negation Jlk.JI 0/ '" \ ) 1)\1 J..:..$. ... JI destructive argument j. JlJ and constructive argument rl ' Y ; "I" 0L.._; reasoning Til rr rational (theoretical) matters soul J ; v/ ., ;;";I,..!'I' 1;ol,;.'I' I T r / ., "",\,y .JI"l.. ; t i l " J cSyJl ,,} .. .;;...,, cS-,iJ I JJ-"",JI ",JI <,-;!L l,;.)4 T/ I ; T ' / 1' I C;kJb cSyJl J "'-,;'..i ;;"Il< ; t il " J.,...,JI ",T v l l;c,....;14cS-,iJl; . /1 . ... .,LoJ ;;";1, ; A I I ., .",;.....J 4 "" ')\.li 4:.!y" li 4 JJ..;;.J 1 J; Li.! I r" Y'li v" .r.-';'" c.SjJl r 1\ \ t active light .!)-WJ J. .iJ1 )..,:J4 ..:S> .. ! I \ ! I ' tpl r"'" " 1' J t -"II (.1 JO y.:J! .1 4 ",l. <-'...iJ 1.1 .r->' ':II .l.,.o.; , I , ll 1 ,\ - , ",-.>.::J l C..J:.J J,.., -" J l'q \ I ' r i J,:-:;A ...j"j..::. ;.. \ : \ "l \ "\ , ... I -, I I -, Y & )4 ..:(1; ,-,U- the :-';ccr>S,lr\' ( Being) SJ.J...l1! .0:.:;Ai' : \ ... 1 ... ... ;:::: ! ... ! V " ' " rL.,,;I , I ,I ',. .. : ! \ f : c..:; .... ...:;ll .. : "1/ \ A! /;1., 1 \ ' t \\'0 Necessary Dei ngs .. J! C':;! . -,.:.J 4, one .... , I T I: , !. /l v,J",I"JI':I I .:,,)..\.,a.;':I '/I AI .. 1>;1 the One and Unique u"""' ,h ':II J",I>JI <s ... _L. T 1\. point 4k.a:.J1 the contradictory ....... i J c. LS '::: ut)"f ! /V \.I..:. .. I ' I I T the contradictory of one thing the contradictory or existence t \\' o contradictories .II ,-,
: ... / " ":i 4", L . ::;.' ... r..\' wIJJ".JI(,j} ;;,,; , .. II cr l ."d"i) I ; T ' I ' -, '","" I r/ l n , -,II T\ light .," , ;,,1 :i....lli.JI 0.,5:, J .::. "",1 J!:: t12JI \.,.i .J .. J.. ,ri c :i.h::--;-JI ....... l' \ i :i,:;.J t i: .. lI the light of Oneness sensible light ),,:)1 real light ),,:)1 y I I! Y non_real On eil A . L,\ : : / ' t v ... I-,JI ..JY-;" I I I I ! Y indivisible (( onc non_material /lonc , l-' 10-" ,\ I I t A " ...i:J I ... J:i.l I, I ,I I t Y if ... "o.;'Jl, divl"ibl e (onen """""'jl , ' / \ 1 V 0'''' .J.,Q,p.:H: J..:,.. I.>H i Lil U' specific (IOnCI) iLiIU" ' IA/ " cS;..c.JI .r.'>J1 Cr" r / I t .,.jl _i ':!l" AI I t y,-"",lli ;... I}1 '( one)) by species the One by way of a true and real unity . ... 14 ... ",,'1 -.;.., J; l,.,JJI Til y , :;,0,.11 way of a true but shadowy unit y :\,;ocJl :;J..;,..-,H! J. :>o. 1}1 tY.l . d r I, y, DIleO' 0) by way of a numerical , limited unit y r / l ... -,J4 'o j " I tl-,I u" , I AI' .r.:5::!1 Cr" ! I I t .jIy.>.ILl, AI I ! Y -, .. 1-,11 (lone)) by genus real (c one })
:<1 .I ... JI " II ' .>...} 4 ...;t,.,.;'il.} eli..; ... .,..;.J4 ;...I ... U ' T I' I y if-,>.) I,,; Ji. 11 ; ' I I t v p ..,J 4 .>...1 ... 1. 1 ... 'ill V speciali zed (l O n e )) numerical (wne" acci dent a l (I One l , " ,t A/ ' t Y trAil, ..I. I}I t LlI 0- e/ I t ... fJ .... H! ..I.;o.I."JI (' onCl) uy accident genera li zed on e)1 Li ... ...., : i l l t ...b. l" Jj r l _ tl 0' - vI, ! .. >lI :\,11,....31 generali zed conceptual (Ion.e,) ." something-else I r/ I . v OJraJ ()' 1/1 ., necessi ty - by - something .e1se i /o", ,\ ..:. lil 4 I.i - relation. to.something-else " '/\A;eiJIJI}i:.J4 'JJ > "AJ cS_",AJI-, ",:Iiil T 1/ " J positional (<one , I . / I I v ..::- v / I !A .6i:.J IS- intermediary between the subsistent and the negated IT/V I intermediary between the existent and the non_ existent II/ V! .... .. roll ow ing neccssil Y r. mediator of subs is- .:..> J 4k...1} existence < ; T / : T ,-,'"i>-J 1 ....;! 0,.;:] I d" ..;" JJ , / : T &..:: J(J J ... I :V/ !'I'J...I "L)ll J .... l .. ......... ... ! '\ / t,. . Jl .. ." U -,v \ i/t : V / : ,. vl..,.:. ':1 1 yt> : \ "/ T ",J f \ TIt r .. ul.,;. U.)l : , r/t r .... _.;. ",; 1 ;.i.lt-o f ,v/ ! r W...! .. ..... ....
w4.,..I1 .::..L.: .6,;") \ I : /; ; ! I \ / ; T 1/ :: tenee . ur.::'.l! .} :.\.Ja_l-, IT'''=J I' / 1 n :y...J1,)1 mediator of occurrence JI._;)L ,,;, ..) 1 , ,; u .. . u """.......... "'/ . "'/ " / , r T ., ... 11 necessity ;c,.,..:JI...,'". I . / A<kJI1,,_ L. : 0 / ... v :.i.-:-.:.) 0tG .. .., Jl ! /' . v Ur. ; . / " v jL,.,i:Jl ... (,.;:)1 "'L)lI ... .o:. 1 ! vI I' v "'Ll .... J..:": ! - , '- T/ I I . necessit y-by _i (self r 0,'J4 J, I'-'J ncccssity-b)' - ",,;:All..,., r.."ll 0;"':' ! t/ v , lJ;r 'i lv , cr'; ,,4 L, -' , I v : 1 I /v , ,,) ./v . ! \ \ lv ' "': ....:; .,1 y ,,; <J y'" 'Y : " / v , .u:... "..s'" <J ,,-J ' " I v .u cI ",\i t.. ' ':..0:- IJ-::J f I 'i Iv, J..:JI.., ..J...4JI ':1-, 1'->-"1 :" / y' J..Jc.f.-')' , . Q..,.-;:," i ' Iv \ l.c..>i f T Iv \ "') )\J.i .. u t,iI, ll! 'J.!." ; ' oI. J f \ / V T I / vT i-,J.....;l., u-,J ; ' In -3..v f I A/ vw ... 1b ,t, f I O, / V ! T T l A, . d. Jj-L..", : __ / A i ... . T / ' 1 ! 1) ! T / ' 0 t::L.L ;J , ,I, 4..c. ; ' T / 1 \ J.' , "1/ ' I AIJ'='-'i J..,-;.J 4 :ck_I.,: ,I , , , \ ,;. )1 : , t / ' nu",:.'lj :(h_l.J l :(,,;.JI J I lJ" ... lJ.J ..:;.. \ jJ 4-, ,)'J 1 oL.\ I c. l...;j ' v 1\ 'i T v";;...J t:J' ... J :U"L..., ("" oIJ-; t / ' rr !r / l ! i l.,gJ.J..c.I.J :V ,' I: i. : ,. I t' ",1. )'-, -" j S'> :<.;pJ J.,. , , It' u lill;';:..JI .. ,; .Y I,,::; '. / t -,u l. iliJ l t"Jcr. h; JeiJ1 :<; I).,) 1 .... \ .\/ = i o.&.;: ... ... JJ-" ", I/! Y wS::---l \ J -' .J 1-,1 I.) r..J..) \ ,,-:-:_:A:; "' :; ; 4j : 1" / = Ar...wIJ-,t) J...,.:.:::i.i !v/ t v , / . csi< 4,;-Jl-, ; , . I . L,:., ) f" I " .u.... :>o. f \ Ie' ... U ':1., \;:+ t..}':J .. li!(.<; I: , ' I ' .j.h. JIS', , ): \ ' /" JI"'; )'\ : IA / O I d.:.... : ri c! 110 :l':;Pi J) i r/ c! ..:;.. 1.) \ ,\ / :J ! v/ c o4;L:::.....! 1 ,} 0'-(''') ; , loY u .1",;..J t, i l,i N u-J ! \ v 10 yJ.il,.;. ; ", ... ... \ "/ 0 v ;r.Y I u . ...Qj oi....o...,a. ... .J..i.Ji ": T T / 0 ... J...:. ... L" I) ,r'! ; n I" 4 l U::, ..,-i- ) 1 J i...,...e ..... .. : \ 'i i r ... "/ H 4<>! ,,-J', Iv , N '-J.- i tC 1 '. I' ,.v J .... .Ai.),W1 ,yoyl c:!'l r!L. I I It, external existence f '1 ' (;;lb.JI J Wl...a:;... WI ... "",.:ul 'r:-yl .::.1 ':"11 ,j>- ..::..L,i f V I ' I IJ,AIL I vii , A ) ... ... . " ...
I II ", .. ,J.. tJ'i ...,..."Jf" I I I "'-'-'1 G.u.::... irl ..::.....,J " I I ' if) I .... .) I.:,. comprehensive existence: exis tence which is particular existence ..,.,WI '),..,11 fundamentally real -,"" ':I 4;:.,.I' ... 0"" i.,.. yo w"s:, v/v 'SJ"-1 existence in the non-absolute sense mental existence JUtJI ... " "S::JI , ... Uly w ... s:J1 fA/ ! AU,,,,JI!U,,,.i.J1 [-ilk ... o .... 5::j ! ! ! / 0' b.JI ... v'" ':"JI, ... ... JI f A I ' . vh I "" .. the existence or accidents possi ble existence .),..,11 ,;i.iJ I .u d j .q ':I :iJ.AJi cf I ,;.iJ I ",_ I I I r subordinate and dependent existence " 1, r abstract (non-matcr ial).s,) r.-::J 1,),..,1 I copulat ive existence existence .1./1)1 ' ... <Jlh.J1 , ... .<.<"JI.::.""; <,Si 'yoYI ... "" .1.1) L..:I , f ' j \! i " .. I ,I' t sheer copulative existence T / " I) ')11 tS.>_I", the existence of a substance oL";'; J f ' I I , t u-J.:,s::J .. ....i:J J.._i:J real existence absolut e exi!ten"cc' ;r/ ,, :U., .. JI :i.,l!lIu; 'J J! "r' 'vI'" r I " u-".:.)I-, k,ljl'y'-yl determined existence .l::iJl y; .,11 r h ' J y 1.. ' the existence ; unfolded existence : J l,.; ... J -"1 <J L.J Ik_ .. ..J I, -,I GJ'; U--Jlf T I.JJ>jl.....:.:!hl u';J'>' ':J.,' ':i ; t I ' r uio..lI u""Jl, ... ,-,.H " / io sclf-"subsistent existence . u...:.i:J'l-, .') .j.k..J1 , y'-yl J'-,IJJ k, I J ' I 01 ; r I " "A inhering existence u:....l l ; r/ '! ,},-!IJ-' k, I J 'y'"y I 0 1 H ,t ,.,.wI' Y.-yl0=!-' !l y:.;:;.J1 '\.:.A the existence of an accident COllcrete (external ) JaAllIJ ",s:J1 'Y."-,JI <":;;1-," J U':il ...,.:;,; ; ' ItA u'-"iJI \ . 1-,,r;... existence in a written Y; .,11 form \ AI '" !Wl.....-i fr j ... t existence in a existenc, .. not.ill.itself -...Ai,)'J y; .,11 ' pronounced form ' I '! .,.,.,L:JI 0 lO ,li . existence material existence 'Y.-"JI "j Jli, \ ViA t "-! <u"-ll J* existence in.itself O.r.Al -...Ai,) y; .,11 existence posterior y; .,11 (to 'something else) \ ' / qifo.J1 'Y."'" ' 1\ " existence ih"itself 4..A:l y; .,11 predicative existence J Y; .,11 for.itself if.rJ1,y'"-'! i l '! ;;.;WI 0\5" ,l.iA.,. ","J ""Jler '-1-",*1 , I / I t v T / 1" 4J .,;Illl existence ., incl \lsive uni ty ._.'-. I 10'- .tl -"""" in.itself Tor_itself b)'-something-e]sc the unity of aspect i..b-J exjstence true unity c.S.J. J ! .l..P."YI J )-,:JI '..l>. .,JI u" .,:JI " / or;(W I,..l>. Y I ,..\.yl u""1 " / I t v lA/I tV true and real unity i..c...l., 01 J..,':I ..;... J,l .. JJI T / 1 V I ;(WI '..l>.Yl! true but shadowy QkJI .,II unity r / I v I ;y,.i.J1 .WI y l Ji1<-.J real unity the unity of predication J ;;"';L..:.II.::.I..l>.YI .1)) u,,;L:::J 1 J?I , AI' T unity of time numerical unity in.itself for.itself by.itself "/' t LSIl.UJ..l 1 'r"-'" particular existences vWI..:.tI:l F. .,II ' I ,T , .h., " I v .::. 1,;;..lJ .>. 1 i l!(,.1 Ihe Face of God .iill J , T / t , ,, ... 1 J..:J Iy -" l...:1 I" the Face of the One the. eigh I kinds or l1nity unity I t i t 'hYI.,,).J')J-'i 'ryl , 1/ " ''>''-Yl .r u" .,-:JI ; ' I" ",ill '-"!'yl .::.u':I '..l>.YI u . .. L """" .,:II .J' <'>';;""" '; LS:JI' TI / 'T,'rYI '-"1 ..:11 .:r , ' I I r .:y...11 u..i.i .1,.:;':11 r<1 , ' / I I' 'r."u 4::t.,t....; r-" ,1.1" ; T I ' t , !'/' I, .r-J I LSi 'y'-yl.p' ,vi ' I' .:r ,vi '" .yl GL::... , \ I I v if .,.,.,>J 4 .1.>0 YJ J lo.. numerical OJ 4!J..w1 0..\;>-.,11 particular position "",WI r:!.,11 limit.ed unity ' / 1'\ ;(WI.dt; 1r r/ l v I",,.)1 '.I.>o}1 J;l<..J container .1>-.,11 non-real unit y 0..\;>-.,11 el l \ '(' .. JY':'Y" J,...) \ II I If ,, \ .... .... perpetual d}ll'ation as a contai ner , : / \ '" the container of mobile J things ! I All tAL.;......,..., 1 wCJ.,.! 1 ' k...I ... L. t t i l t A unity wi thin multiplicit y I the unity of place j.>-.JI O..\;>-J I' 'r 0,L l<;:.J I .:r the unity of existence time -=.J.,11 1 I I ' t i ll v.::.i}k:X, '"'J.I,.)I HI ., >Y."J,JI '?J >y'"-,JI , -">.." legal guidance middle t erm 1_.,11 !, v / 0 . (( ., j'j : W.,,'? L. I t il v tJb,- formative guidance the middle and the end -.J}=JIJ.k,... JlI ' IrA '- I I vtJ-i....::Jljh,iW).JI.,Ja..,JJIj,J> is.. it_the-case? ; whether)) Y'JA qualifying a simple nesses ' 1\ t ' -WI composite whether_ nesses thing by a property of something else with which it is connected in.dicating qualit y position i t_is_i t.ness j..>JI ,. _'i. ! y ' / t .'-!"... ..wI"... ,\,.;>'1 y / 1 ' personal ipseity u::-'- .)J"':"JJI Jpl ..J .. r ' ;(!-,,,JI-, :i.;,J1 oJ.. -,II initial ips ity y I/"',l..J1 j,l..,j the ipseity which comes back one single ipseity JI""" ,-'>1-,11 t I/V\ mode of being
! V / " ,,)-,.,..JI,jl.. -,>1 I '/ I , ,J.i-, ,,\S0 immobile mode of being ojLiJ\ y / \A y ..... ,s;J1 actualized whether_ness" ;(.;:, , G :i...Lo. JI l.... . .::.:... '-".1\ .. r-'J .. , .. .. ..... A/ I. I simple whether.nessll WI,j Jr-JI"...L. f /" lfk.. f " /, t ;(j"...,11 ;w.... ,j .::.:... ;;"l"JlfV/i YA L. AI I 0 I rJ :.t.b:--1 J.J'>u.l 1 JI,;-JI if,,! '+,i ... .;All 'J..li 01.r.U>' f , , /, ., '( ' II 0 u.,; !\ viI 0 I non-actualized whether_ness)) A/'" composite whether. ness collectedness as a mode of being :<J.,...,JI J'>>> Llk- f t / " wJ.J1 ,," f V/iyA cr ... 4" ,,/ ,n.r'i matter ,-"ll! J-Ifo / I ' , ! I ' / 1 t y t fA/ I' I rJ ",,'1'1. if -,.S J lj..J1 0 "'! I I ..,.::.JI it-is-it
<"";l:J1 J-,,..JI cSl-'l'l ..,; "II! indefinite ma [tel'
one single matter ).LW.! d'r14 '''''''Yl ;(....;iJ.I J,i! 1' / lt A , I ' I I ., V .::.-':.! I, 6l; J) uJ -,,0 "";)\;;.:.1 q / l ,,,;;,k,,...JI.,WJ Jl:... r/ l v, J .. ",l,..J1 thr prime matter I' ' I f' w,l:.::.J1 ..All .'" Jl:... I - ... .. the econdary matter