A sustainable use of ochre from mine water

treatment plants for phosphorus removal and

recycling

Kate Heal1, Paul Younger2, Keith Smith1, Paul Quinn2, Stephanie

Glendinning2, Jonathan Aumônier2, Karen Dobbie1, Heather McHaffie1,
Dimitris Dimoliatis1, Amber Bush1, Eleni Bozika1, Eirini Tatsi1, Andrea
Simpson1 and Ryan Sweetman2
1
School of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh, Mayfield Road,
Edinburgh EH9 3JU, UK.
Tel: (44) 131.650.5420 Fax: (44) 131.662.0478
e-mail address: [email protected]
2
School of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, University of Newcastle
upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 7RU, UK.

Abstract

Treatment of discharges from abandoned mines is producing large

quantities of ochre (hydrous iron (III) hydroxides) that require disposal. At
the same time, phosphorus pollution from agricultural runoff and sewage
effluent is a serious threat to the water environment in industrialised
countries. Ochre has the potential to be used in novel technologies for the
removal of phosphorus from wastewater, due to its high sorption capacity
for phosphorus (up to 30 g P kg-1). Newcastle and Edinburgh Universities
are currently conducting research to develop and test field-scale methods
to use ochre for phosphorus removal from agricultural runoff and sewage
effluent and to recycle the phosphorus-saturated ochre to agriculture.
Short-term studies in a Scottish river affected by agricultural runoff
have demonstrated that in-stream filter units and barriers can reduce
phosphorus concentrations. Longer-term field investigations comparing the
effectiveness of different forms of ochre for phosphorus removal from
agricultural runoff are under way at two farms. Ongoing trials at sewage
treatment works, investigating the effectiveness of ochre-filled reaction
vessels in removing phosphorus, show good reductions (from 3.04 to 0.33
mg P l-1) if the hydraulics are satisfactory. To develop a total use cycle for
ochre, pot experiments and field trials were conducted in which barley and
grass were grown in soils amended with phosphorus-saturated ochre. The
results showed that phosphorus-saturated ochre can be used as a slow-
release fertiliser with no adverse effects on the environment or crop yields.

Introduction

The flooding of abandoned mines frequently results in the formation of

acidic, ferruginous water due to the oxidation of pyrite in the mine
workings. To prevent the pollution of surface watercourses, mine water
treatment plants (MWTPs) are employed to treat the most serious
discharges. In MWTPs, the oxidation and precipitation of iron is enhanced
either by the addition of chemicals (e.g., oxidising reagents, alkalis to raise
pH and increase the rate of Fe (II) oxidation, and flocculants to assist floc
formation and sedimentation) and/or by atmospheric oxidation in storage
ponds or constructed wetlands with long retention times. MWTPs
therefore accumulate large quantities of Fe(OH)3 and FeO.OH precipitate,
collectively known as “ochre” (of the order of tens of tonnes per annum at
a single site). Typically, this is stockpiled and, although a number of
possible end-uses have been considered (e.g., colouring bricks/cement and
in synthesizing coagulants for drinking water), no single end-use has yet
been identified which could consume the projected future production.
Our work demonstrates the potential of a novel environmental
application of ochre, due to its high sorption capacity for phosphorus.
Phosphorus pollution from point and diffuse sources is a serious threat to
the water environment in the UK and other industrialized countries
(D’Arcy et al. 2000). The transfer of phosphorus to rivers and lakes from
sewage treatment works, septic tanks and agricultural runoff causes
eutrophication, frequently resulting in algal blooms, fish kills and loss of
water resources.
Phosphorus sorption onto iron and aluminium oxides and hydroxides
and calcium carbonate (all components of ochre) in natural soils and
sediments is well-understood (Barrow 1983; Parfitt 1989; Reddy et al.
1999). Phosphorus removal may also occur by precipitation, although this
is believed to be less significant than removal by sorption. Heal et al.
(2004) have discussed the removal mechanisms in more detail.
Previous work to examine the use of ferruginous materials for
phosphorus removal from wastewater has been piecemeal. In the USA,
Webster and Wieder (1997) found that the addition of ochre from acid
mine drainage to fertilized soils reduced phosphorus concentrations in
runoff. In Northern Ireland, Wood and McAtamney (1996) showed that the
use of laterite as a substrate in experimental constructed wetlands removed
95% of phosphorus from landfill leachate. The treatment of dairy farm
wastewater has also been investigated in bucket-scale subsurface flow
constructed wetlands with an iron ore substrate (Grüneberg and Kern
2001). Other ferruginous media, such as peat doped with bauxite red
(Roberge et al. 1999) and sand and olivine coated with iron aluminium
hydroxyoxides (Ayoub et al. 2001), have been investigated for phosphorus
removal from wastewater but few trials have been conducted at the field
scale, and attempts to design novel treatment systems are limited. This
paper demonstrates the potential of ochre for phosphorus removal and
discusses current research on this topic in three main settings:
1. Removal of phosphorus from sewage effluent by ochre, either in
constructed wetland systems or in dosing systems for tanks of sewage
effluent;
2. Removal of phosphorus from agricultural runoff by ochre in-stream
filter units or dosing systems in rivers and drainage ditches;
3. Recycling of ochre saturated with phosphorus from applications (2) and
(3) as a slow-release fertilizer in agriculture.

Demonstration of the potential of ochre for phosphorus

removal: laboratory results

Ochre extracted from MWTPs has a very high water content (80-95%)
unless it has been stored in drying beds in good weather conditions. If it
has not been air-dried, it is difficult to handle and transport, and
consequently most investigations of its phosphorus-removal properties
have used the air-dried form. Dried ochres from different MWTPs have
similar chemical properties but may have different physical properties.
Those from two MWTPs in Scotland, Polkemmet and Minto, have a
similar chemical composition and mineralogy (identified by x-ray
diffraction as a mixture of ferrihydrite and goethite, α-FeO.OH) but very
different particle-size distributions (Fig. 1). Polkemmet ochre dries into
clods that are readily crushed to a coarse, granular texture which has a high
saturated hydraulic conductivity (26-32 m day-1, equivalent to coarse
sand). In contrast, Minto ochre dries to a fine powder with a considerably
lower saturated hydraulic conductivity (0.7-1.7 m day-1). The cause of the
different physical properties of the two materials is unclear but is thought
to be related to differences in the operation of the MWTPs. At Polkemmet,
hydrogen peroxide and a polymer are added to the mine water to
encourage oxidation and flocculation of iron, whilst at Minto, the mine
water is unamended.
 30
25

20
Polkemmet
% 15
Minto
10
5
0
0.002 0.006
0.02 0.063
0.212 0.6
1 2 5
Upper particle size diameter (mm)

Fig. 1. Particle-size distribution of air-dried ochres from two MWTPs, Scotland

The maximum phosphorus adsorption capacities for Polkemmet and

Minto ochres are orders of magnitude higher than those measured in other
sorbents (Table 1). Solution pH was found not to affect the removal rate of
phosphorus due to the buffering capacity of the ochre (8-11% CaO and 8%
MgO content). Laboratory batch experiments with sewage effluent
(containing 5.28, 3.50, and 1.77 mg l-1 total, inorganic, and organic
phosphorus, respectively) showed that all phosphorus forms are removed
rapidly (<1 to 15 minutes) by both ochre types.

Table 1. Maximum phosphorus adsorption capacities (mg P (g substrate)-1) of

different materials (after Drizo (1998) and Mann (1997))
Material Adsorption capacity
Gravel 0.03-0.05
Bottom ash 0.06
Steel slag 0.38
Blast furnace slag 0.40-0.45
Fly ash 0.62
Shale 0.75
Laterite 0.75
Zeolite 1
Polkemmet ochre 26
Minto ochre 30.5

The physical properties of ochres influence their suitability for different

phosphorus removal applications (Table 2). Coarse-grained forms are more
suitable for phosphorus removal in filter units or in the substrate of
constructed wetlands. Fine-grained forms are difficult to contain and easily
clog filter units, but rapidly remove phosphorus from wastewater because
of the larger surface area of the particles. Such materials are more suitable
for dosing applications, as long as adequate sedimentation is provided.
Laboratory dosing experiments with 10-litre columns of sewage effluent
and agricultural runoff showed that a single addition of ochre settled
completely within eight hours and removed up to 80% of phosphorus from
the water column. A method for producing robust, spherical granules (2-12
mm diameter) of fine-grained ochre by the addition of Portland cement, a
surfactant and water has been developed by Newcastle University to
facilitate the handling and use of this form of the material.

Table 2. Uses of different types of ochre to reduce phosphorus concentrations in

agricultural runoff and sewage effluent
Ochre type Agricultural runoff Sewage effluent
Coarse-grained In-stream barrier Reaction vessel
Filters on field drains Wetland substrate
Fine-grained Dosing agent in powder Dosing agent in powder
form, then settlement form, then settlement
Granules in in-stream Granules in reaction vessel
barrier/filter Granules in wetland substrate

Field demonstrations of phosphorus removal by ochre

Treatment of agricultural runoff with ochre

Approximately 40% of agricultural land in the UK (excluding rough

grazing) is underlain by subsurface field drains, which have been shown to
be a major conduit of soluble and particulate phosphorus export to
watercourses in storm events, even when best management practices are
implemented (Dils and Heathwaite 1996). Although it is not feasible to
install treatment works or constructed wetlands for every field drain,
treatment with ochre may form a cheap, low-maintenance means of
reducing phosphorus exports from field drains. Treatment at the field scale
could take the form of in-stream filters containing coarse-grained dried
material or fabricated granules. Alternatively, dosing with fine-grained
ochre, followed by settlement, has already been demonstrated in laboratory
experiments to reduce phosphorus concentrations in simulated agricultural
runoff.
 Short-term studies in a Scottish river affected by agricultural runoff
have demonstrated that in-stream barriers, containing coarse-grained
ochre, can reduce phosphorus concentrations. In-stream filter units,
containing 6 kg of ochre, reduced phosphorus concentrations (from 0.18 to
0.06 mg P l-1) and altered the algal community, from one dominated by
algae typical of eutrophic conditions to one dominated by algae typical of
mesotrophic conditions. In a separate study of an in-stream barrier
containing five different ochre-grit mixtures, those containing 100% and
50% ochre reduced phosphorus concentrations to less than half the inflow
value over a one-month period. Longer-term field investigations
comparing the effectiveness of coarse-grained and granular ochre for
phosphorus removal from agricultural runoff are being conducted at two
UK farms.

Treatment of sewage effluent with ochre

With stricter controls on sewage discharge into receiving waters (e.g., the
EU Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive (Farmer 2001)), the
development of new methods for phosphorus removal are required.
Currently, phosphorus removal at wastewater treatment works (WWTWs)
is often achieved by the addition of costly dosing agents such as iron (III)
chloride and iron (III) sulphate. Fine-grained ochre is an alternative dosing
agent as it has a high capacity for phosphorus adsorption. Laboratory-scale
experiments show that it compares favourably with other dosing agents,
apart from the generation of larger volumes of sludge for disposal (Table 3).

Table 3. Comparison of fine-grained ochre with other dosing agents used for
phosphorus removal in wastewater treatment works
Reagent Dosage P removal Comments
[mg l-1] [%]
FeCl3 10 90 Most often employed
Al2(SO4).16H2O 200-250 95 High cost
Ca(OH)2 500-700 80 Precipitation occurs at high pH
Fine-grained 2700 94-95 Not pH dependent. Use of
ochre waste material, but larger
sludge quantities.

Field trials at WWTWs are investigating the effectiveness of reaction

vessels containing coarse-grained ochre or ochre granules in removing
phosphorus. Preliminary results from Leitholm WWTW, Berwickshire,
Scotland, in which a tank containing ~1200 kg of the coarse-grained
material was installed at the inflow to a tertiary treatment wetland in
November 2003, show that although phosphorus removal did not increase,
there was no release of potentially toxic metals that could have adsorbed
onto the ochre in the MWTP (no significant differences between before
and after concentrations at P<0.05 (2-sample t-test)). More detailed spatial
sampling and analysis of surface waters in the tank and the tank overflow
showed that the reason for the limited phosphorus removal in the tank is
short-circuiting of flow so that the full phosphorus removal capacity of the
ochre is not utilised (Fig. 2). The theoretical contact time of the mean
inflow with ochre in the tank is 15 minutes, sufficient for removal of 90%
of the phosphorus, if the flow is distributed throughout the tank.
3.04
Wetland inlet

Tank surface water

1.97 0.33
1.93 1.41

Tank overflow

1.94 2.99 1.79

Fig. 2. Soluble reactive phosphorus concentrations (mg l-1) in water samples from
different locations in the ochre-filled tank, Leitholm WWTW, 25 November 2003

Constructed wetlands are effective in removing nitrogen from sewage

effluent but are less efficient in removing phosphorus (Cooper et al. 1996).
From the phosphorus removal capacity measured in pilot filter experiments
(Heal et al. 2003), the operational lifetimes of ochre-based wetlands for
wastewater treatment were estimated to be decades longer than for other
wetland substrates that have been tested for phosphorus removal (Table 4).

Table 4. Estimated operational lifetimes for constructed wetlands using 3 or 5 m2

wetland area per person with shale or Polkemmet ochre as a substrate with three
concentrations of sewage effluent. Substrate assumed to be 0.6 m deep
Substrate Operational lifetime [years]
3 m2 per persona 5 m2 per persona
-1 -1 -1
20 mg l 5 mg l 3 mg l 20 mg l-1 5 mg l-1 3 mg l-1
b
Shale 1.6 6.5 10.7 2.7 10.7 17.8
Ochre 18.8 75 125 33.5 134 224
a 3 -1 b
Each person assumed to produce 0.2 m sewage day . Data from Drizo (1998).
Recycling of phosphorus-saturated ochre as a fertiliser

When the phosphorus removal capacity of ochre is finally exhausted, the

‘spent’ material will require removal and disposal. A more sustainable
alternative to landfill disposal is to recycle the phosphorus as a fertilizer.
Pot experiments and field trials comparing barley and grass grown in soils
amended with phosphorus-saturated ochre with plants grown with
conventional phosphorus fertiliser showed that ochre additions improved
soil fertility and increased soil pH, while maintaining the same crop yields
as conventional fertiliser. At the end of the growing season, there was
more available phosphorus in the ochre-amended soil than in soil treated
with conventional fertiliser, indicating that phosphorus-saturated ochre has
the further desirable property of acting as a slow-release fertilizer,
reducing the need for future phosphorus fertilizer applications.
A possible concern about applying ochre to land is the accumulation of
potentially toxic metals. UK regulations permit the application of wastes to
agricultural land providing they do not contaminate the soil or plants
growing on that soil (Waste Management Licensing Regulations 1994).
The most relevant guidelines for assessing soil contamination arising from
ochre applications relate to the application of sewage sludge to agricultural
land (MAFF 1998). Mean metal concentrations in ochre-amended soils at
the end of the field trial were well below guideline values, and annual
additions of metals associated with the application would not exceed those
allowable for sewage sludge (Table 5).

Table 5. Maximum permissible soil metal concentrations (mg kg-1 dry soil) and
annual metal addition rates (kg ha-1 y-1) over 10 years for sewage sludge
application (MAFF 1998) compared with values arising from ochre addition

Metal Max. permissible Concentrationb in Max. permiss- Addition

soil conc.a ochre-treated soil ible addition in ochrec
Zn 200 85 ± 21 15 3.5
Cu 100 16 ± 2 7.5 0.6
Ni 60 70 ± 11 3 2.8
Cd 3 < 1.6 0.15 < 0.06
Pb 300 52 ± 10 15 0.3
Cr 400 156 ± 70 15 6.7
As 50 0.13 in P-sat ochre 0.7 0.004
a
Soil pH 5.5-6.0. b Mean ± 1 st. dev. c Addition of 40 t dry ochre ha-1 y-1,
equivalent to recommended fertiliser application for barley of 85 kg P2O5 ha-1 y-1
Conclusions

Laboratory experiments have demonstrated that ochre, formed as a by-

product from mine water treatment, has a high capacity for phosphorus
removal from agricultural runoff and sewage effluent, as a result of
sorption to the high concentration of iron oxides and hydroxides contained
within the material. Potential applications of phosphorus removal by ochre
are widespread, including sewage effluent treatment in constructed
wetlands and by dosing systems, and treatment of agricultural runoff by in-
stream filter units and/or dosing and settlement systems. A total use cycle
of ochre has also been demonstrated; after phosphorus saturation, it can be
used as a slow-release fertilizer with no adverse effect on soil quality and
crop yield. Field-scale testing of ochre within sewage treatment works
showed that although there is no mobilization of potentially toxic metals,
further work is required on the hydraulic design of the filter systems to
maximise phosphorus removal capacity. The use of ochre for removal of
excess phosphorus in the aquatic environment is particularly attractive, not
only because treatment costs are potentially lower than more traditional
methods, but also due to the sustainability advantage of using a by-product
of treating mine water discharges to address another water problem
(eutrophication).

Acknowledgements

The authors are grateful to the Coal Authority, Northumbrian Water

Limited and the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council
(grants GR/R73522/01, GR/R73539/01) for funding and to Scottish Water
for access to the Leitholm WWTW and for water sample analysis. The
technical support of Andrew Gray, Rab Howard, and John Morman is
acknowledged.

References

Ayoub GM, Koopman B, Pandya N (2001) Iron and aluminium hydroxy (oxide)
coated filter media for low-concentration phosphorus removal. Wat Env Res
73: 478-485
Barrow NJ (1983) A mechanistic model for describing the sorption and desorption
of phosphate by soil. J Soil Sci 34: 751-758
Cooper PF, Job GD, Green MB, Shutes RBE (1996) Reed beds and constructed
wetlands for wastewater treatment, Water Research Centre, Swindon, UK
D'Arcy BJ, Ellis JB, Ferrier RC, Jenkins A (2000) The environmental and
economic impacts of diffuse pollution in the UK. Terence Dalton, Lavenham,
UK
Dils RM, Heathwaite AL (1996) Phosphorus fractionation in hillslope
hydrological pathways contributing to agricultural runoff. In: Anderson MG,
Brookes S (eds), Advances in hillslope processes. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.,
Chichester, UK, pp 229-252
Drizo A (1998) Phosphate and ammonium removal from waste water, using
constructed wetland systems. PhD thesis, University of Edinburgh
Farmer AM (2001) Reducing phosphate discharges: the role of the 1991 EC urban
wastewater treatment directive. Wat Sci Tech 44(1): 41-48
Grüneberg B, Kern J (2001) Phosphorus retention capacity of iron-ore and blast
furnace slag in subsurface flow constructed wetlands. Wat Sci Tech 44(11-
12): 69-75
Heal KV, Younger PL, Smith KA, Glendinning S, Quinn P, Dobbie KE (2003)
Novel use of ochre from mine water treatment plants to reduce point and
diffuse phosphorus pollution. Land Contamination & Reclamation 11: 145-
152
Heal KV, Younger PL, Smith KA, McHaffie H, Batty LC (2004) Removing
phosphorus from sewage effluent and agricultural runoff using ochre
recovered from mine water treatment. In: Valsami-Jones E (ed) Phosphorus in
environmental technology: removal, recovery and applications. IWA
Publishing, London, pp 320-334
MAFF (1998) The soil code – code of good agricultural practice for the protection
of soil. MAFF/WOAD, MAFF Publications, London
Mann RA (1997) Phosphorus adsorption and desorption characteristics of
constructed wetland gravels and steelworks by-products. Aust J Soil Res 35:
375-384
Parfitt RL (1989) Phosphate reactions with natural allophane, ferrihydrite and
goethite. J Soil Sci 40: 359-369
Reddy KR, Cadillac RH, Flag E, Gale PM (1999) Phosphorus retention in streams
and wetlands: a review. Crit Rev Env Sci Technol 29: 83-146
Roberge G, Blais JF, Mercier G (1999) Phosphorus removal from wastewater
treated with red mud-doped peat. Can J Chem Eng 77: 1185-1194
Waste Management Licensing Regulations (1994) SI 1994/1056, HMSO, London
Webster AK, Wieder RK (1997) Reduction of phosphate losses from fertilized
soils using acid mine drainage sludge. J Conf Abs 2(2), Biogeomon `97: 323
Wood RB, McAtamney CF (1996) Constructed wetlands for waste water
treatment; the use of laterite in the bed medium in phosphorus and heavy
metal removal. Hydrobiologia 340: 323-331