CRM Airtel
CRM Airtel
CRM Airtel
ON
EFFECTIVENESS OF CUSTOMER
RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT AT
AIRTEL
Declaration
I hereby declare that the project report “Effectiveness Of CRM at Airtel” is an original
2
Table of Contents:
Declaration
List of Figures
Executive Summary
Chapter 1: Introduction
- Objectives
- Research Methodology
- Origin of CRM
- CRM Defined
- Zone of Customers
- Benefits of CRM
- CRM Strategies
3
- CRM Documentation Issues
- Scope of CRM
- Company Profile
- Awards
- Vision
- Mission
- Bharti Values
- Recent Achievements
Conclusion
Limitations
Bibliography
4
Annexure
- Airtel Connects
- Questionnaire 1
- Questionnaire 2
5
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2: Selling
6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The project study is on Measuring the Effectiveness Of CRM at Airtel. The project aims at
understanding the CRM implementation at Airtel and its impact on the perception of
The initial part of the projects explains the origin of CRM, the importance of Relationship
The following chapters give a brief about Airtel’s Company Profile, Its History and
Present. This is further followed by the initiatives taken by Airtel towards Relationship
Marketing and the functioning of Customer Care Division Of Airtel in its endeavors to
Further the finding and analysis give us a view on Customers perception of Airtel’s
Services.
7
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Relationships have proved to be the central element in the success of business since time
immemorial. They are the invisible threads, which bind all business associates. To remain
competitive and to carve a niche in a global market, it has become imperative to manage
customers effectively. Organizations have realized the lifetime value of a customer. CRM
has once again acquired the highest place in every strategist’s priority list. Organizations
are redesigning their strategies and sharpening their focus on Customer Relationship
involving latest technology inputs, are being used to implement CRM programmes without
proper knowledge of their impact on customers. The biggest Challenge faced by marketers
is to know the effectiveness of their CRM programs. Keeping in view the requirements of
a great usage of CRM in the service industry, especially in the cellular services where each
service provider is trying to have an edge over the other by means of enhancing customer
satisfaction.
8
1.2 OBJECTIVES
The method used for data collection is Survey Research, which is Exploratory in nature.
Sampling Method
Sampling Unit: Personnel from the Customer Care Division were interviewed and
questionnaires were used to get information from them and also from the people
Data sources:
Primary Data : The information was obtained by means of the following tools for data
collection:
• Interview Schedule
9
• Structured Questionnaires
b. Text books
10
CHAPTER 2
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
today…
Relationships are the essence of life. It is difficult to think about any society or
organization to survive without relationships. They are the invisible threads, which
build a unique bond between individuals and organizations. On the one hand these
bonds may be as strong as iron pillars lasting for lifetime, whereas on the other hand
they are as delicate as feather which may be broken within no time. Managing
the importance of the vital role played by relationships in achieving and maintaining the
Long ago Peter F.Drucker had advocated that the purpose of any business is to create
him or her. The success of any organization primarily depends upon the sustaining the
customer advantage that is retaining the customers for lifetime. Growing complexities
and uncertainties at the market place along with intensifying global competition are
forcing the business organization to invest in building customer relationships. New and
11
sophisticated marketing tool kits are being designed to attract, satisfy and retain
CRM has recently emerged as a strategic solution to modern business problems. It has
its roots in the age old business philosophy which recognizes that all business activities
The term CRM was first coined in the early eighties by academics at various business
schools. One of the first on the scene was Dr. Jagdish Sheth who was at the Goizeta
While the CRM term is fairly recent, it grew from a combination of terms like Help
Desk, Customer Support, ERP, Data mining. It evolved because none of the previous
terms could cover the topic well enough and because some of the terms (ERP) have
grown to be met with a great deal of distaste in the mouths of the business world.
of customer relationships - DM Martin and AM Peel, The Pace Setter Group, 2001
The infrastructure that enables the delineation of and increase in customer value, and
the correct means to motivate valuable customers to remain loyal, to buy back again. -
12
CRM (Customer Relationship Management): A strategy (technology-enabled) in
response to, and in anticipation of, actual customer behavior. From a technology
analyzing and sharing all facets of the customer’s relationship with the enterprise. From
organizational resources to those activities that have the greatest return and impact on
Competition PRODUCT
FOCUS
Forces
Sharper CUSTOMER
FOCUS
Marketing
FULL
Database integrated RELATIONSHIP
MARKETING
internally and externally
Enterprise boundaries
blur, New digital ENTERPRISE
products and Services RELATIONSHIP
MARKETING
emerge
13
Stage 1: Product Focus
In the early stages of the cycle, the leading supplier has the products or services that are
significantly better than those of its competitors. Customers are happy enough to obtain
them. It gains share and profitability. No matter how the other companies try to
compensate for the product or service weakness by relationship management, they will
lose.
The high profits earned now attract competition, so several other companies begin
offering a similar product or service. Competition intensifies in the areas of features and
price. Companies try to maintain differentiation through the feature mix and through
customer training. Eventually it moves to the areas of customer care. Here the aim is to
ensure that the benefits from the product or service are delivered reliably from the first
point of contact. This is not quite customer relationship marketing, since the customer
may still be approached by the same organization in a different guise with an attempt to
After branding and customer service the suppliers must aim to manage all aspects of
that the diversity in relationships with the customer must be given due importance.
14
Stage 5: Enterprise Relationship Management
The relationship marketing approach now has to permeate everything the enterprise
does. Observing customers closely, working directly with them to address their needs
and requirements.
Conventionally, the ‘supplier/buyer interface tends to be fairly limited with the one real
contact on a continuous basis between sales person and person responsible for
purchasing within the customer’s business. It is an interface between where both parties
seek to maximize the outcome in their favour, and rarely results in a win-win situation.
This type of relationship is given in the figure below. There is a single point of contact
as two triangles that only connect to a single point. It is a relationship that is easy for
development.
15
R & D
Marketing
Logistics Operations
Customer Supplier
Information Information
Systems Systems
Figure 2: Selling
The alternative approach is shown in the following figure where there are multiple
points of contact between corresponding functions and processes within the buying and
selling companies.
16
R&D Marketing
Logistics Operations
Information Information
Systems Systems
Supplier Customer
The job of a relationship manager is to coordinate those multiple contacts and to seek
17
Customers can be divided into three zones:
1. Zone Of Defection: where customers are extremely hostile and have the lowest
level of satisfaction.
2. Zone Of Indifference: where customers are not sure. They have a medium level
CRM focuses on bringing customers from level 1 to level 3 and retaining apostle
customers.
Customers’ demands for customization are increasing with every passing day. This has
made companies shift their focus from “mass production” to “mass customization”. The
present scenario of customers using “poorly implemented” multi channel strategies for
living upto the expectations of customers is bringing both customer satisfaction and
(CRM)
A recent article by the Harvard Business Review reported that increasing customer
customer retention is the key to increasing profits. The article continued by stating that
quality customer support is one of five primary determinants of loyalty. The number
18
Customer Relationship Management is, however, even broader in scope than improving
customer service: CRM is also about increasing revenue. In years past, businesses were
were mainly about the bottom line, cutting costs by improving the flow of data and
interaction between business and customer. But understanding how technology can
Effective CRM enables sales reps, service reps, and administrative staff and often,
accounting and executive personnel, to do their job better, faster, and with less wasted
paper and time. Prospects can be followed up quickly, and sales reps have instant
access to the exact data needed for effective closing. Marketing can be analyzed for
workability and improved to create the highest return possible on the marketing dollar.
In service, customers can be handled rapidly, and the exact nature of a problem can be
The right CRM solution enables data to flow easily and quickly within an organization,
and in most cases includes the entire organization. The net result is higher sales, happier
customers and a much-improved bottom line. The reduction in costs due to improved
personnel productivity, better sales follow up, improved marketing and service, and an
The figures that corporations report of increased profits due to successful CRM
implementations range from 25% to 95%, attributable in many cases to less wasted time
and double work, and better organized schedules and data flows from staff in every
19
CRM and Executive Management
Managing the customer relationship enables a business to identify the right customers,
target them with the right offers at the right time, and deliver that information using the
right channel; for instance, via an email campaign, direct mail, phone calls, trade
shows, etc. CRM software enables a business to retain valuable information and then
use that information to increase sales, handle specific customer service issues, and
create databases of information that reflect the specific consumer traits of its public.
Many people assume CRM is all about technology. That's only part of the story: CRM
is also about the data an organization has and the wealth of information in that data, and
how an organization's people process and leverage that data. While it is true that certain
basic formulas exist for successful sales and marketing, nevertheless, the variance
between different business models can vary hugely. A guitar manufacturer and a copier
manufacturer do, indeed, share many management points in common, but the sales
cycle, the service cycle, and the customer relationships of each are quite varied.
Forethought needs be given to setting up the system in a logical and consistent method,
enabling an organizational entity to weave its own business plan into the framework of
the software application. In this way the management of the company directs the
application to do its bidding, although the application must be flexible enough to enable
it.
The phrase, "know your customer, help your business," certainly applies to
20
Without a doubt, a key component of CRM database analysis and implementation is
marketing. To be effective, one would hope to have marketing that reaches the right
customer with the right message at the right time using the right medium. But without
having the data available regarding one's public and buying patterns, marketing often
critical sales and marketing information, not only pays for itself very quickly, it
becomes a valuable resource for improving both the top (revenue) and the bottom
(profit) lines. The top line is improved by increasing sales through better data
using valuable customer information. The bottom line is improved by reducing service
times and costs, and by improving the general productivity of the staff as a direct result
of the CRM solutions of task management and contact management and, in some cases,
Customers don't want to spend hours on hold. Prospects often want a quote or invoice
on the spot. Without accurate record storage and quick access to information, sales reps
get far behind on their call lists and once "hot prospects" turn ice cold. Speed of particle
flow and speed of delivery is vital factors for survival, so access to data -- the same
data, from a variety of positions -- is a must. Sales, shipping, service, accounting and
even the executive branch must all have the same data, and often at the same time.
CRM dictates that anyone who touches a customer shares the same information and that
21
CRM and Service
Regarding service in general, the size of the organization has nothing to do with the
need to give its customers improved service. Although larger corporations do seem to
"get away" with poor service more easily than small to medium-sized businesses, most
of whom are battling stiff competition as the world becomes more automated and the
choices more plentiful, even some of the near monopolies will get the wake-up call
from smaller, more aggressive, more service-oriented companies who may wind up
People love friendly, prompt, and courteous service. It's what keeps customers coming
back year after year. And CRM software does play a significant role in not only
providing timely and effective service, but in doing so at a price that most organizations
When a service call is handled the specific problem and its solution can be added to the
database. Next time the same incident occurs the service rep can locate the item and
CRM software enables you to record each customer service as a Service Work Order,
including detailed records of how the Service Work Order was resolved. The system
provides flexible methods of billing, including by the hour, the month, the year, or by
the Work Order (service incident). Contracts can be written for service or service and
materials. Equipment can be tracked by warranty and serial number. And a flexible
service-scheduling feature enables you to easily add, view, and delete scheduled service
appointments. (For more detailed information about this product, download the
22
Service reps have easy access to sales, warranty, order, billing and inventory
information, enabling them to evaluate data and respond quickly to a customer's needs.
Purchasing a CRM application is a decision that takes some thought and consideration.
Reduce costs through an optimal mix of channels and streamlined customer service
operations.
service problems.
• Better manage the complete customer lifecycle across all touch points.
23
• Increase revenues by identifying and leveraging cross-selling opportunities that
• Enhance profitability by gaining better insights into how the client’s customer
targeting of market segments and the micro segments within them. We are now in a
through the use of technology. Powerful new technological approaches involving the
use of databases, data marts, data warehouses, data mining and one-to-one marketing
are now assisting organizations to increase customer value and their own profitability.
customers so that appropriate CRM strategies can be adopted. In addition, the use of
Given the dramatic effect that improved customer retention can have on business
24
To improve customer retention; three steps are needed:
Measurement of existing customer retention rates is the first critical step in the task of
improving loyalty. This involves measuring retention rates and profitability analysis by
related to customer retention and acquisition. These include changes in: the cost of
Besides acquisition and retention, lifetime value will need to be identified by market
segment and needs to address how to improve it. Clearly improving retention can have
a huge impact on lifetime profitability. The business will also need to consider how
they will get the greatest benefit from their acquisition activities. To facilitate improved
acquisition, retention and lifetime value, companies need to utilize the appropriate
customer management. This can dramatically improve sales force productivity and
25
In business-consumer organizations who are dealing with a large number of customers,
a critical issue will be increasing the quality of customer contact through tools such as
and then develop the appropriate information technology platform to suit their
requirements, now and in the future. This may involve a creative blending of a range of
moving towards data marts, enterprise data warehouse and integrated CRM solutions
using electronic commerce. It may also involve using approaches such as data-mining,
event-driven marketing and channel optimization. The ultimate objective of this will be
performance in CRM across the business. It is increasingly being recognized that there
corporate strategy, there is confusion about what it means in practice. Further, many
26
activities such as direct mail, help desks, call centres and loyalty cards. These activities
Where CRM is well understood as a concept, many board-level managers are still
The starting point for introducing or further developing CRM must be determined from
four broad issues: what is our core business and how will this evolve in the future; what
form of CRM is appropriate for our business now and in the future; what IT
An organization should first examine its core business and consider how will it evolve
in the future. It then needs to consider the form of CRM that is appropriate for their
business now and in the future and what organization resources does it have to support
Having identified the present and future focus of CRM, the organization then needs to
implemented. Stated simply the task is how can we exploit technology for improved
CRM.
As organizations increase their sophistication they will need to creativity integrate these
approach to building the backbone to support the relevant CRM strategy that has been
27
An essential element of achieving successful implementation is to ensure that their
capability and other appropriate commercial factors including both technological and
commercial criteria.
considerably and we will have reached much more sophisticated level of one-to-one
marketing and data mining. There is now an enormous opportunity for organisations to
activities which address all the key strategic elements of CRM. Ultimately, however,
organisations’ success in CRM will involve creating an appropriate strategic vision for
the future, making the appropriate choice of applications, creatively using appropriate
analytical techniques to exploit the data, and choosing the right vendor for supply of the
technology solution.
To ensure the success of CRM the following things need to be kept in mind:
Focus on the most pressing goals, such as reducing attrition among your most valuable
customers, or increasing revenue per customer. Only after these goals have been
28
Regardless of department, employees should clearly understand the business rationale
and desired results. Managers should include incentives, making the project a top
priority.
The most common complaint from business managers about software development is
that results – if they come at all – are not available until all the money has been
invested. The greatest complaint from developers is that business managers don’t
understand that they can’t have results until the software has been built. To maintain the
goals, with measurable results, is crucial in moving forward with the long-term goal of
Call centers
Call center telephone sales managing aspects Campaign
of customer contact management
E-commerce
Web-based Content
Field sales
self service management
Retail
Data analysis
Third-party brokers,
Field services and business
distributors, agents
and dispatch intelligence tools
29
Figure 4. Elements OF CRM
• Integrate and coordinate multiple customer touch points (e-mail, call center,
application design;
30
2.11 RELATIONSHIP MARKETING AND CUSTOMER LIFETIME VALUE
FOR CELLULARS
customers. Customers do not want that. Relationship Marketing uses the event-driven
tactics of customer retention marketing, but treats marketing as a process over time
rather than single unconnected events. By molding the marketing message and tactics to
the LifeCycle of the customer, the Relationship Marketing approach achieves very high
The relationship marketing process is usually defined as a series of stages, and there are
many different names given to these stages, depending on the marketing perspective
Suspect > Prospect > Customer > Partner > Advocate > Former Customer
Using the relationship marketing approach, you customize programs for individual
consumer groups and the stage of the process they are going through as opposed to
some forms of database marketing where everybody would get virtually the same
promotions, with perhaps a change in offer. The stage in the customer Lifecycle
31
A simple example of this would be sending new customers a "Welcome Kit", which
might have an incentive to make a second purchase. If 60 days pass and the customer
has not made a second purchase, you would follow up with an e-mailed discount. You
are using customer behavior over time (the customer LifeCycle) to trigger the
marketing approach.
We all know that today, marketing programs must include a measurable customer
calculated, and with widespread organizational buy-in, it becomes the first metric to
However the Life Time Value concept has been misunderstood over the last several
years. It may not be necessary to figure out an absolute Life Time Value for a customer
or wait "a lifetime" to find out the exact value to use the concept in managing customer
value in order to develop successful marketing campaigns that effect the bottom-line
quickly.
The obvious goal is keeping the customers with highest CLV as long as possible and
determining the attributes of those high CLV customers for use with prospects.
Basically, there are three main components to the CLV formula: revenues, customer
32
2. Tenure: Retention modeling used to understand leading indicators for customer
"churn."
customer income; it's the expense. It is difficult to determine how to apply various
Unfortunately, almost ALL of the relatively "constant" figures that help calculate CLV
in other industries literally change as soon as they are calculated when it comes to
cellular services:
1. Phone Equipment Costs and Revenue. The negotiated sales rates form the
various phone vendors changes based on supply, consumer demand and buying
2. Service Rates and Rate Plan Structures. Rates change almost monthly for
most carriers. Even the rate plan structures change as soon as you (and the
Cingular's "roll-over Minutes" rate plan structures obviously put a dent into
3. Mobile Phone Features and Usage. Everything from the amount of "Roadside
just how volatile these features can be to calculating anything resembling accurate
CLV.
33
4. Service Contract Models. Tenure based on consumer contracts that vary from
one to three years; technology that changes as soon as the contract is signed, phone
Additionally, most consumers have been affected by one of the consolidations, mergers,
corporate strategy for many organizations. CRM, also known by other terms such as
targeted customers and customer groups resulting in maximizing their total customer
life-time value.
Industry leaders are now addressing how to transform their approach to customer
management of the key marketing mix elements such as product, price, promotion and
The new CRM approach, whilst recognising these key elements still need to be
- one which emphasizes keeping as well as winning customers. Thus the focus is
34
shifting from customer acquisition to customer retention and ensuring the appropriate
amounts of time, money and managerial resources are directed at both of these key
tasks. The new CRM paradigm reflects a change from traditional marketing to what is
The adoption of CRM is being fuelled by recognition that long-term relationships with
customers are one of the most important assets of an organisation and that information-
enabled systems must be developed that will give them 'customer ownership'.
In many companies there is still confusion as to what CRM is all about. To some it is
about a loyalty scheme, to some it is about a help desk. To others it is about a relational
database for key account management and for others it is about mass profiling the
have implemented an integrated approach, which addresses all the key strategic
elements of CRM. Only a small number of businesses have a clear idea what should be
undertake relatively little marketing activity and as a result have a fragmented customer
marketing. For companies such as Virgin Atlantic, The Body Shop and First Direct,
public relations and word-of-mouth marketing have been very important to them, so
35
that despite fairly low levels of advertising spend they are highly effective in their
marketing.
activities, have achieved poor results from their marketing effects; quite a number of
financial services companies fall into this category. We call this “marketing trappings”
marketing.
Relatively few organizations have adopted relationship marketing and CRM approaches
to effectively harness the tools of marketing to deliver real increased customer value
and, with the help of technology, developing appropriate long-term relationships with
customers.
To achieve success, businesses need to have the appropriate measurement systems and
marketing metrics in place to ensure there are effective in terms of their use of
customer-focused resources. Over the past two decades businesses have developed
sufficient. CRM recognizes that marketing starts after the sale is over, not when the sale
is completed.
In future marketing will need to create much stronger metrics so that strategies can be
evaluated rigorously.
36
CHAPTER 3
ABOUT AIRTEL
Airtel comes to you from Bharti Cellular Ltd. A consortium of giants in the
telecommunication business.
Airtel launched it's services in Delhi on November 14,1995. It has at present over Six
lakh fifty thousand customers in it's seven years of pursuit of greater customer
Airtel has consistently set the benchmarks for the Indian cellular industry to follow.
Care Touch points called "Connects" and over 350 dealers in Delhi and NCR
towns.
First to expand it's network with the installation of second mobile switching
center in April, 1997 and the first in Delhi to introduce the Intelligent Network
37
First to provide roaming facility in USA. Enjoy the mobile roaming across 38
partner networks & above 700 cities Moreover roam across international
destinations in 119 countries including USA, Canada, UK etc with 284 partner
networks.
3.2 AWARDS
Consecutively for four years 1997,1998, 1999 and 2000,AirTel has been voted
as the Best Cellular Service in the country and won the coveted Techies award.
practices-2000.
ISO 9001:2000 and 1st in world certified by British Standards Institution for Mobile
Communication.
Born a leader, the first cellular service in Delhi, AirTel has maintained
services in India.
First to introduce a wide array of value added services like Smart mail, Fax
facility, Call Hold, Call waiting, Web message, Information services etc. to enhance
38
3.3 VISION
• To make mobile communications a way of life and be the customers' first choice’.
3.4 MISSION
• Cost efficiency
Innoventuring
• We will generate and implement entrepreneurial and innovative ideas, which will
Customer First
• We are committed to delivering service beyond the expectations of the customer. Our
Performance Culture
39
individual as well as the team level. Ours is a culture of inclusively where feedback,
learning and ideas are actively encouraged, sought and acted upon.
Valuing Partnership
• We are committed to building exemplary relationship with our partners, which stand
Valuing People
legal norms.
Ethical Practices
• We will uphold the highest ethical standards in all internal and external relationship.
We will deliver error free "Mobile Communication Services" through Customer Service
40
3.7 RECENT ACHIEVEMENTS
AirTel has won the prestigious Techies Award for Best Cellular Phone Service in the
“This award is a tribute to the faith that you repose in us. It is your expectations that
have encouraged us to constantly improve so that we can deliver the highest standards
41
CHAPTER 4
CRM AT AIRTEL
DEPARTMENT
On talking to the employees of the customer care department the following things were
found out:
• Regular updates.
Satisfaction.
weekly.
The customers are divided into different segments on the basis of the amount of
42
The four categories of customers are:
• VIP’s- These include the top-notch people, the ministers, actors and
• Club- These include all the general customers other than those included
in the corporates and the High profile customers with whom around 60%
The customer care cell has been divided into four departments:
• Retention- This department takes care of the churn and takes special
The CRM is implemented through the customer Care Executives. There are
43
The effectiveness of CRM is measured through CSMM (Customer Satisfaction
Special Loyalty Programs and incentive schemes are designed for the
privileged and the regular customers. Initially these programs were for the
Upper Base of Customers, Usually the one’s from whom the billing was of more
than Rs. 1500 but now these are for all the customers. One of the recent CRM
There is a special complaint handling system, The Customer Help and the
response time for handling these complaints varies depending on the nature of
the complaint. The maximum time that can be spent on handling a complaint is
10 days.
people from the Retention Department call up the customers from time to time
Also a 4-5 Day training is given to these people on using the e-CRM systems.
As a result of the CRM initiatives taken by Airtel Net Churn has gone down to
Today AirTel has 20 Customer Care Touch points called "Connects" and over
44
4.2 ANALYSIS OF CUSTOMER SURVEYS
70
60
60
50
40
30
20
20
10 10
10
0
Disagree Can't Say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
On the basis of the responses obtained from the people it was found that 60% of the
respondents agree that Airtel gives prompt services and 20% strongly agree on this
point thus indicating that in terms of service delivery, Airtel has a high rating. There are
some people i.e only 10% who disagree on this and 10% responded by not saying
45
Q 2. Employees at Airtel are always willing to help you.
80 75
70
60
50
40
30
20
10 10
10 5
0
Disagree Can't Say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
75% of the respondents agree that Employees at Airtel are always willing to help the
customers and 10% strongly agree to this point. Only a 5% of respondents disagree on
this point and 10% people did no want to say anything on this particular aspect. Thus,
we can say that the employees at Airtel are willing to help the people indicating the
46
Q 3. Your queries and complaints are handled immediately by the Customer Care
Department.
70
60
60
50
40
30
20 15
13 12
10
0
Disagree Can't Say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
About 60% of the respondents agree that the customer care department handles their
complaints immediately. 15% of the people strongly agree on this point. 12% of the
respondents can’t say anything on this aspect as they did not feel the need to complain
and only 13% of the respondents disagree on this point, probably due to some kind of
delay in their complaint being handled. Thus we can say that Airtel people are
47
Q 4. Airtel provides its services at the time it promises to do so
90 84
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
10 6
0
Disagree Can't Say Agree
Analysis:
About 84% of the respondents feel that Airtel delivers the services at the time it
promises to do so. Around 6% of them disagree on this particular aspect and only a
10% were not sure as to what could be said abut this. Thus, we can say that Airtel is a
reliable service provider and provides the services at the time it promises to do so.
48
Q 5. Airtel keeps its customers informed about all its services and how they will be
delivered.
90
78
80
70
60
50
40
30
22
20
10
0
Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
On the basis of the responses received, it was found that 22% of the people strongly
agree that Airtel keeps its customers well informed about the services it offers and 78%
of the people agree to this point. There were no respondents who disagree on this
aspect. Most of the people feel that Airtel has very good advertising and also Airtel
makes people aware of all its services from time to time by means of giving them
49
Q 6. When you have a problem, the company shows a sincere interest in solving it.
90
80
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
20
10
0
Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
On the basis of the responses, it was found that 80% of the respondents agree that the
company shows a sincere interest in solving their problems and 20% strongly agree to
this point. There were no respondents to disagree on this aspect thus indicating that the
50
Q.7 Airtel gives you individual attention.
70
60 58
50
40
30
30
20
12
10
0
Can't Say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
On being asked about whether the company gives individual attention to its customers,
we see that about 58% of the people were not in a position to say anything on this
particular aspect. 30% of the people agree to this point and 12% strong agree. Thus, we
can say that most of the people either did not feel the need for individual attention or
are not aware of it. But, nobody wanted to disagree on this aspect.
51
Q 8. The employees at Airtel understand your individual needs and offer flexibility
50
45
45
40
35
30
25
25
20 17
15 13
10
5
0
Disagree Can't Say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
The results here show that 45% of the respondents agree that the company offers
flexibility in their services as per individual needs and 25% strongly agree on this
point.25% of the people can’t say anything on this and 13% of the people disagree with
this statement. Thus, we can say that most of the people feel that there is flexibility in
52
Q 9. The web site of Airtel is interactive and user-friendly
60 56
50
40
32
30
20
12
10
0
Can't Say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
Around 56% of the people did not feel the need to visit the website of Airtel so they
could not say any thing about how interactive it was. There were 32 % respondents who
53
Q 10. Airtel uses the latest technology in its services.
45
40
40
35 32
30
24
25
20
15
10
4
5
0
Disagree Can't say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
On asking about the opinion of the people in terms of the technology being used by
Airtel 40% of the people did not want to comment on the technology aspect. 32% of the
people agreed that Airtel uses the latest technology and 24% of them strongly agreed on
this aspect. Only a small 4% of people disagreed, probably because they feel Airtel
Q 11. You feel that the employees at Airtel are courteous with you.
54
60 55
50
40
30
24
20
12
9
10
0
Disagree Can't say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
55% of the respondents agree to the statement that the employees at Airtel are
courteous and 24% of them strongly agree to it. 12% of the respondents did not say
anything about this whereas a 9% of the people disagree with it. The reason could be
some kind of bad experiences that they had with the employees.
55
Q 12. Employees at Airtel have the knowledge to answer your questions.
80
67
70
60
50
40
30
19
20 14
10
0
Disagree Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
Talking about the knowledge of the employees in handling customer queries, we can
say that most of the people agree that Airtel has the employees who are trained well to
answer the queries of the customers. 67% of the respondents agree to this and 19%
strongly agree with this. A very few people disagree with this statement. The reasons
for this could vary from individual to individual. Thus, overall we have the expression
56
Q 13. Airtel takes care of the confidentiality and the privacy of its customers.
70
63
60
50
40 34
30
20
10
3
0
Can't say Agree Strongly Agree
Analysis:
Most of the respondents agreed on the aspect that the confidentiality and privacy of
the customers is maintained. The percentage of the people who agree to this was as
high as 63%. 34% strongly agree to this point and only 3% of the people disagree
with it. Thus, we can say that the company is responsive enough and we can rely on
it.
57
Q 14. Rate the following on a scale of 1 to 5 in terms of the quality of service
1. Airtel.
2. Hutchinson Essar.
3. Idea.
4. MTNL.
AIRTEL
45 41
NO. OF RESPONDENTS
40
35
30
25 23
20 16
14
15
10 6
5
0
1 2 3 4 5
RATINGS
58
HUTCHINSON ESSAR
40 38
NO. OF RESPONDENTS
35
30
25 22 22
20 15
15
10
5 3
0
1 2 3 4 5
RATING
IDEA
50 47
NO. OF RESPONDENTS
40
30
21
18
20
10
10 4
0
1 2 3 4 5
RATING
59
MTNL
40 37
NO. OF RESPONDENTS
35
30
25 22
19
20
15 12
10
10
5
0
1 2 3 4 5
RATINGS
Analysis:
From the comparisons of the ratings given to the different service providers we find
that Airtel has got the highest number of respondents giving it a rating of 4 or 5.
In case of Idea, 47 respondents have given it a rating of 3 whereas MTNL has got a
rating of 3 by 37 respondents.
From this comparison we can conclude that Airtel has a higher rating in terms of
60
Q 15. How would you rate Airtel on a scale of 1-5 on the following parameters.
AIRTEL
50
45
40
35
NO OF RESPONDENTS
1 30
2
3 25
4
5
20
15
10
0
INSTANT CONNECTIVITY
NETWORK COVERAGE
CLARITY OF VOICE
BEHAVIOUR OF
EMPLOYEES
OFFERS
PARAMETERS
61
Analysis:
From the figure 22 we find that the Airtel has a very good rating in terms of the
coverage most of the respondents have given it a rating of 5. In terms of latest schemes,
value-added services and clarity of voice; most of the respondents have given it a high
rating of 3, 4 or 5.
In terms of activation, billing and behaviour of the employees the ratings are
comparatively lower.
62
Q 16. If given a choice, would you like to switch over to some other cellular
service.
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Yes No
Analysis:
Most of the respondents were happy with the services being provided by Airtel and
were not interested in switching over to some other service provider. 83 % of the people
wanted to continue availing the service of Airtel and only 17 % of the people wanted to
switch over to some other service providers. The reasons for this varied from cheaper
63
CONCLUSION
The initiatives taken by Airtel in CRM have helped Airtel to achieve a great
amount of success.
responsiveness, reliability, empathy, assurance and tangibles it was found that the
Born a leader, the first cellular service in Delhi, AirTel has maintained
services in India.
Airtel being the first to introduce a wide array of value added services like
Smart mail, Fax facility, Call Hold, Call waiting, Web message, Information
services etc. to enhance the convenience of its subscribers, has been able to achieve
the title of best cellular service provider for five consecutive years.
By means of relationship marketing Airtel has been able to reduce the rate of
churn. The Net Churn has gone down to 3782 people in January ‘2003 from 15,000
Airtel is making use of the latest technology and focusing on building long term
relationship with the customers as a result of which most of the people perceive
64
LIMITATIONS
The study was limited only to Delhi region due to constraint of time.
The sample size taken for the study was small as the time allotted for the study was
very less .
The employees at Airtel were not willing to disclose the details about the
At times the customers using Airtel services were not willing to respond, hence lots
65
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
Books.
Greenberg Paul (2001), “CRM At The Speed Of Light” Tata McGraw Hill
Response Books.
Jain Rajnish & Jain Sangeeta , Journal Of Service Research (0ctober ’02- March
Jaiswal M.P & Sharma Anjali, “The Business And Strategic Need”, e-Commerce
(January 2002).
www.CRMassist.com
www.adaptcrm.com
www.crmcommunity.com
www.crmguru.com
66
ANNEXURE
AIRTEL CONNECTS
QUESTIONNAIRE-1-
QUESTIONNAIRE –2-
67
ANNEXURE
AIRTEL CONNECTS
The following are the AirTel dealers in Delhi and surrounding satellite areas. The search can be simplified using
68
New Arya Nagar, 91-4732171 4736798 line.com
Meerut Road
Ghaziabad
Cellpage Communications Shop no. 1 Sikanderpur Market, 91-6357067 6224608 Rajesh Chabra 9810020848 [email protected]
Gurgaon-Mehrauli Road 91-6364057 9810259059 et.in
Gurgaon Naveen Dua 9810048495
Airphone Comm. (C) Ltd. 37, 5158389 5150088 Soami bhatia 9810020902 [email protected].
North-West Avenue 5164008 net.in
Punjabi Bagh Club Road,
Punjabi Bagh
New delhi
Challanger Computers Ltd. 23 B, 5823670/1/2 5823672 Sunil Gupta 9810118001 [email protected]
Pusa road Manoj Gupta m
New delhi 9810081292
Hitech Cellular & Paging UA-28 2946224 / 7 5799032 S K Kaul 9810069777 sumant_kaul@hotm
Services Jawahar Nagar, ail.
Ltd-k Bunglow Road, com
Kamla Nagar,
New Delhi
Sheebatel C-7, Jail Road, 5141235 Manpreet 9810022629 sheebatel@mantrao
New Delhi 5140297 Singh Baweja nline
.com
Shop no. 5,
6852424 aurotel@mantraonlin
Aurotel Communications (P) M B D A V Bldg. Sumesh
6852327 6851965 9810011119 e.
Ltd Yusuf Sarai Sekhri
6851964 com
New delhi-16
A-20, 6917750
cellcom12@hotmail.
Cell Com Lajpat nagar II 6321122 6917751 Vinod Chopra 9810059949
com
New delhi-24 6321133
69
S-5, 6433471
Madhur
Vidur & Co. Greater kailash-I 6433472 6433471 9810050965
Madhav
New delhi-48 6433473
22 Kapil Vihar
7182792 Ashok Jain 9810180346 Northwest@mantrao
North West Communication Pitampura
7182564 K P Jain 9810046034 nline.com
New Delhi
M-5 3752481
P V International Connaught Place 3752480 Vivek Nanda 9810188708
New Delhi - 110 001 3752483
A-13,
Vishal Enclave 5179394 9810069493
Air Communication 5179494 Balram Garg
Rajouri Garden 5179494 9810293940
New Delhi
Savitri Market,
91-4591427 hillne@mantraonline
Hiline-N G-26 Sector 18 Sumeet Bhalla 9810018607
91-4514344 .com
Noida
70
QUESTIONNAIRE-1
71
Q12.Employees at Airtel have the
knowledge to answer your questions.
Q14. Rate the following on a scale of 1 to 5 in terms of the quality of service offered
1. Airtel
2. Hutchinson Essar
3. Idea
4. MTNL.
Q15. How would you rate Airtel on a scale of 1-5 on the following parameters.
9. Instant connectivity.
12. Activation
13. Billing
72
Q16. If given a choice, would you like to switch over to some other cellular service. If
…………………………………………………………………………………………
……
Name: __________________________________
Age: __________________________________
Address: __________________________________
73
QUESTIONNAIRE-2
1. Do you have any CRM programs? If Yes, since when are you implementing these
programs?
i. ……………………
ii. ……………………
iii. ……………………
iv. ……………………
v. ……………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
4. List down the parameters used by you to measure the effectiveness of your
CRM programs?
(i) ……………………
(ii) ……………………
(iii) ……………………
(iv) ……………………
(v) ……………………
74
(vi) ……………………
(vii) ……………………
(viii) ……………………
(ix) ……………………
(x) ……………………
5. Do you maintain a database for your customers? What measures are taken to update
the database?
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………
6. How does this database help you in implementing the CRM programmes?
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………….
• Geographic
• Demographic
• Psychographic
• Behavioural
• Any other…………………………….
75
8. How often do you conduct a Market Research Program for identifying customer
• Within 3 Months
• Within 6 Months
• Yearly
• Never
• Any Other………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
10. What are the measures undertaken to deliver the expected level of quality?
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
76
11. How is CRM implemented in your organization?
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
12. Do you have any loyalty programs for your customers or any kind of privileges or
• Yes
• No
If yes, Elaborate
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
14. Do you have a complaint handling system for customers? If yes, what is the
77
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………
15. Is there any suitable compensation made for any kind of bad experiences of the
customers?
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………
16. Are there any efforts made to recover the lost customers? How?
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………
17. Do you incorporate the suggestions or feedback given by customers? State any
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
78
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
79
19.Is there any special training given to your employees for interacting with
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………
80