Analysis of Marketing Communication of Amway and Tupper Ware
Analysis of Marketing Communication of Amway and Tupper Ware
Analysis of Marketing Communication of Amway and Tupper Ware
2. To inform.
3. To persuade.
4. To remind.
1. Creative integrity.
2. Consistency of message.
6. Operational efficiency.
7. Cost saving.
Tools Of IMC:
There are various tools for Integrated Marketing communication. These are
as follows:
PEOPLE
Amway has more than 6000 employees worldwide. In addition, Amway has
more than 3.6 million Independent Business Owners (IBOs) around the
world. In China, Amway products are sold by Amway sales representatives.
PRODUCTS AND SERVICES
Over 450 unique, high-quality products carry the Amway name in the areas
of nutrition, wellness, beauty and home, as well as commercial products and
a variety of services. In addition, Amway independent business owners in
selected markets sell additional brand-name goods through local
merchandise catalogues, plus a variety of services and educational products.
All products are backed by a customer satisfaction guarantee.
Doug DeVos is the President of Amway and Steve Van Andel is the
chairman.
FACILITIES
COMMUNITY SERVICES
Amway is a prominent and active member of the regional and national direct
selling associations worldwide. Doug DeVos is a member of the U.S. Direct
Selling Association Board of Directors. Former Alticor President Dick
DeVos is the current Chairman of the World Federation of Direct Selling
Associations (WFDSA). Globally, direct selling is an industry with
approximately $80 billion in sales and more than 30 million salespeople.
The History of Amway
AWARDS
Rich DeVos and Jay Van Andel's friendship actually began with a business
proposition, when Rich struck a deal with Jay for a ride to school for 25
cents a week. After high school they entered the military, but they planned to
start a business together after separate tours of duty. A friendship formed
and became a business relationship that has lasted to this day.
As vowed by Jay Van Andel the night of the 1969 disaster, Amway rebuilt
the aerosol plant and went on. The '70s began with sales of more than $100
million at estimated retail, and kept going strong. After a lengthy
investigation, the FTC verified that Amway is a genuine business
opportunity and not a "pyramid."
THE BILLION-DOLLAR DECADE
The '80s will be remembered for the first Billion Dollar Year at estimated
retail in 1980. Building expansion at Amway World Headquarters continued
at breakneck speed as Amway scrambled to keep pace with demand, opening
its new cosmetics plant in Ada, Michigan.
As carefully planned by Rich and Jay, the second generation Van Andel and
DeVos families took the helm during the ' 90s. The Policy Board was
formed and Steve Van Andel and Dick DeVos succeeded their fathers as
Chairman and President. Distributors witnessed a similar trend, with the
second generation of many distributor families taking on important
leadership roles.,
NEW HORIZONS
In 2000, Amway prepared for a new century and a new exciting era.
Almost 50 years after Amway began, the DeVos and Van Andel families
created a new structure to meet the challenges of this new century. A parent
company, Alticor, was established with subsidiaries Amway, Quixtar and
Access Business Group—the latter to consolidate manufacturing and
distribution for the enterprise. At the helm of Alticor are Steve Van Andel
(Chairman) and Doug DeVos (President), jointly holding the Office of the
Chief Executive. Today each area of the business, including Amway, has the
freedom to build on its strengths.
Founder's Fundamental
Rich DeVos and Jay Van Andel built the Amway business on the following
principles, which they and their families believe constitute a sound
foundation for a meaningful life.
Freedom
Family
The family is our primary social structure, providing love, heritage and
legacy. The Amway business respects and supports the family, as evidenced
by the Amway Board of Directors and the prominence of “family” in
Amway business. Amway provides the opportunity to build a family-owned
business which can be passed on to generations.
Hope
Hope gives us the power to transform our lives in positive ways. It is a force
that allows us to envision dreams, establish goals, and achieve great things.
By offering hope, we open windows of possibility for others, irrespective of
social status, profession or educational background.
Reward
Reward involves the shared action of giving and receiving. Reward helps us
grow, either as the giver or the recipient, and there are many ways we are
rewarded. Reward is integral to the Amway business as we help each other
grow as people and as entrepreneurs. Hard work is followed by high
rewards.
Amway India Factsheet
Amway promotes individual entrepreneurship through its innovative direct
selling approach of world class consumer products. Amway India is the
country’s leading direct selling FMCG-company which manufactures and
sells world-class consumer products. Its business opportunity and all its
products are covered by 100% Money Back Guarantee. Amway sources all
its products from within India, thereby providing stimulus to the local
manufacturing industry.
CORPORATE CREDENTIALS
• Amway India has 400 full time employees and has generated indirect
employment for 1,650 persons at all the contract manufacturer
locations.
• Amway India recorded a sales turnover of over Rs. 800 crore during
January’07 –December’07.
MANUFACTURING
Almost all Amway India products are manufactured in the country through 7
third party contract manufacturers. To bring the identified contract
manufacturers’ production facilities and skills to international standard,
Amway has invested in excess of US$ 4 million (approx. Rs. 17 crore). The
transfer of this state-of-the-art, world-class technology, has been free of cost.
PRODUCTS
Mission
Our Values
Amway has established some simple shared values that unite the entire
company, and all of the Business Owners that are associated with Amway.
We believe that these values guide our actions and help us to achieve
everything we are capable of without compromise or harm.
Integrity
Trust
Service Orientation
Partnership
Recognition
The company's introductory product range comprised four home care and
two personal care products, made available to distributors at the Amway
Distribution Centers (ADCs) or through tele-service. A significant portion of
Amway's investment was on transferring state-of-the-art technology and
processes to third-party manufacturers from the small and medium-scale
sectors for the indigenous production of its product range. Amway assisted
its three manufacturing partners, the ISO 9001-certified Jejuplast at Pune,
Naisa Industries at Daman, and the Hyderabad-based Sarvotham Care, to
achieve benchmarking levels of product development, engineering and
quality. These facilities were equipped with advanced machinery and world
class technologies for production, packaging, and water filtration. Amway
scientists and engineers at the India Technical Centre provided assistance in
the processes of technology transfer and quality control. The company
supported its independent distributors with five full service ADCs at New
Delhi, Bangalore, Chennai, Calcutta and Mumbai. ADCs operated as
product selection centers for Amway's entire product range and as training
centers for distributors. Amway appointed Sembawang Shriram Integrated
Logistics, and Mumbai-based First Flight Couriers as its total logistics
partners for home delivery of Amway products across 151 cities in the
country.
Amway's domestic operations fell into five areas - personal care, homecare,
nutrition, cosmetics and home tech. The company introduced India-specific
products, in pursuance of its go ‘glocal ' philosophy. Also, for the first time
in its history, Amway utilized media advertising to promote its products.
In the beginning, Amway had to deal with the negative attitude of many
Indians to direct selling. Direct selling was typically seen as unwelcome, an
intrusion into one's privacy. This was true to a certain extent. Sales people
often used a ‘hard sell', the product quality was sometimes poor and most
importantly, the salespeople were poorly trained and lacking in motivation.
However, Amway changed all this radically and a significant change was
brought in the field.
Amway was able to break the time tested and traditional distribution set-up
of manufacturer-distributor-retailer-consumer. Within 11 months, Amway
became the country's largest direct selling company and after two years of
the commercial launch, Amway's distributor base crossed the 200,000 mark.
Its strengths were clearly manifested in the aggressive product launch plans,
its products which claimed to exceed consumer expectations, the ‘money
back’ policy, and a distribution network spread across 26 cities servicing
more than 306 locations. In 1999, Amway reported a sales figure of Rs 100
crore. Reacting to reports stating this as a ‘below-expectations’ figure,
company sources commented that the concept of network marketing had not
been a constraint for Amway. The then CEO & MD Bill Pinckney
commented, “The direct selling model is not new to India. What's new is the
structure. And while it's true that consumers do not rush in to buy an Amway
product, network marketing works as a low-key approach and evolves over
time.”
Amway soon woke up to the reality that it had to take steps to put its MLM
machinery back to the track. For this, it had to first identify where it had
gone wrong. Amway realized that like most direct marketing networks, it
had hoped to leverage the global promise of the lucrative business
opportunity for its distributors. Though this made sense in the developed
consumer markets of the West, in India, distributors also needed to know the
value of the products they were selling, this aspect was overlooked by the
company.
One of the first ‘corrective' measures it took was putting stickers on its
products, which clearly indicated the number of usages very clearly. For
instance, it introduced stickers on the packs of its car-wash solution to
emphasize the number of washes that a consumer could get per bottle. The
idea was to firmly establish the fact of Amway's products being highly
concentrated and with very low per usage cost. This practice was later
expanded to other products as well.
Amway also decided to focus on the market in the smaller towns. Quick
expansion of the distribution network to smaller towns was identified as a
major tool to offset the impact of attrition. The game plan was to reach
consumer homes all over directly by making the current distribution system
more effective and decentralized. In early 1999, Amway realized that
servicing distributors in 160 cities through its 13 locations was curbing
growth due to unavailability of critical infrastructure like networked banks,
toll-free phones and multi-service courier companies. The cost of making
long-distance calls, the courier companies’ refusal to accept cash and the
time taken to deliver products were the three major hurdles that Amway
faced. The typical direct selling system comprised a central warehouse
located close to the manufacturing locations, which sent the products to
regional hubs like the metros and then on to the branch offices. As opposed
to the traditional FMCG delivery setup, where the distributors or retailers
carried inventory, here it was taken care of by the company warehouses and
their region-specific distribution centers. Long distance calls and courier
companies took care of distribution in cities where the company had no
presence. However, with these facilities not being upto the mark, Amway
decided that it had to effectively handle these issues and rapidly expand its
offices in order to capture the growing direct selling clientele in the country.
The company also decided to give incentives to cost and freight agents
(C&FAs) who could deliver parcels in the same city within 48 hours outside,
in about 72 hours.
Even as Amway was establishing its roots in India, it was already facing
troubles abroad. The very concept of network marketing was being
threatened by the growing popularity of e-commerce and the Internet.
Through the World Wide Web, manufacturers had the opportunity of
engaging in one-on-one direct selling in an even simpler way. This posed a
major threat to multilevel marketers. However, the real threat seemed to be
the merging of telecom networks with the cable television operators. This
brought the customer directly in touch with the company through
telemarketing tools. This would naturally make the salesperson obsolete. Of
course, given the pace of developments on the Indian telecommunications
front, network marketers could take it easy for least some more years.
Typically direct marketing firms faces issues of reach and cost. Since the
sales depend entirely on the independent distributors , the company has to
pay huge commission. This results in the increased cost of the product.
Hence the products become expensive resulting in lower sales.
Amway also faces this issue. The products of Amway are excellent but very
expensive. For example, the Persona brand of soaps cost Rs 30 which is
almost double the rate of an ordinary soap. Persona is one of the best soaps
in terms of quality but price is definitely a dampener. Another example is the
range of cosmetics under the brands Attitude and Artistery . Artistery is
targeted at the premium class and Attitude at the middleclass. But the prices
of these brands make the consumer think twice before buying it. Hence the
ABOs have a tough time convincing the value proposition.
Amway uses the slogan “We are listening “. The idea revolves round the
theme that Amway understands the Indian consumers and the products are
derived from this understanding. The purpose of the campaign is two fold:
a. The Company wants to build equity around the corporate brand which will
enable the ABOs to tide over the initial customer resistance.
b. The enhanced corporate image will also attract people to join Amway as
independent business owners.
Along with this, the company is also rationalizing the pricing strategies. The
company is launching a new range of value products like coconut oil,
shaving creams. But here again the company will face certain issues. For
lower priced products, the commission payout will be less and hence the
ABO will have to sell more volume to get higher commission. Amway had
introduced sachets for most of the products, but the low commission payout
for sachets has prompted ABOs to try and sell high value items.
Another significant change that the company made was rationalizing the
entry cost for new ABOs. Earlier, a person had to shell out Rs 5000 to join
the firm. The cost was to buy the Amway business kit which consists of
various Amway products and brochures. The ABO can recover the money
by selling these products. Now the company has introduced a starter pack for
Rs 995 which does not have Amway products but brochures. This will be a
big relief for the existing ABO since the higher joining costs turned away
most of the potential ABOs.
Amway has understood that doing business in India will require a new
business model. The company has started to take steps in the right direction.
It had tried to rationalize prices and bring in new value products. But to
balance the price, cost, quality and higher commission is no easy task.
Tupperware Corporation:
After the war, the company turned its attention to manufacturing plastic
products for the growing consumer market. Its first consumer products were
a bell shaped flexible container called the Bell Tumbler and the Wonderlier
Bowl (a round bottomed bowl with a lid).
These products were superior to the traditional glass and crockery as they
were unbreakable. Tupperware products were durable and were also easy to
handle. They came in various attractive colors and shapes. At a time when
Americans used glass and crockery to store and serve food items,
Tupperware provided a more durable and reliable alternative.
Tupperware also designed the renowned air-tight, liquid proof lid in 1946. It
was modeled on the inverted rim of a paint can. This lid prevented spillage
and wastage of the stored items and kept them fresh for a longer time. From
its inception, Tupperware faced challenges in marketing its products. In
1946, though the Tupperware plastic products were introduced in hardware
and department stores, they failed to generate demand.
It became clear that the company needed to educate the consumers about the
quality and properties of the products. In the late 1940s, Brownie Wise, who
was selling household products for Stanley Home Products was hired by
Tupperware.
She gave Tupperware its unique "Party Plan" method of marketing. In 1948
Tupperware's first Home Party was conducted. Here, Tupperware products
and their uses were demonstrated to consumers.
Tupperware in India
Future Outlook
Tupperware was gaining fast recognition in the Indian market. Its 'Party
Plan' worked well because it fitted in the urban and semi urban culture of
'kittie party. By 2002, the company expanded its operations to more than 35
cities in the country.
The company did not face any major competition from other plastic wares in
India, as the quality of Tupperware goods was much better. However,
Tupperware India competed with manufacturers of steel containers as Indian
consumers used steel containers to store and carry food...
While the familiarity of this story dates back since inception, sticking to the
market which has made Tupperware successful, they are reinventing
themselves again and again in countries all across the world. Women, in
particular, have taken upon this opportunity to really brand themselves.
Thus, without seeing the importance of this need, the Tupperware parties
would not be as popular as it is today.