Issueguidepa
Issueguidepa
Issueguidepa
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
Overview
INTRODUCTION
DREW MYERS
NOAH YOSKOWITZ
THEME 1
THEME 2
CLASSROOM
DAN YOSIPOVITCH
ZACH W ATKINS
CONCLUSION AND
OUTREACH
NAKUL GROVER
SPENCER W ALLACE
AMOGH KIRAN
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
STUDENTS GRADUATE UNPREPARED FOR THE WORKFORCE. As our nation looks to be the most efficient
producer of goods and services, it relies on an education system that can prepare citizens to do so. Many
Americans feel that the current education system is resulting in lost ground for the US in global
economic competition.
THE INDIVIDUAL IS NOT A FOCUS IN OUR EDUCATION. Current education systems focus on a broad scope
of knowledge that all students are required to learn. It is a known fact that every individual is better fit to
learn one subject over another based on their interests, so our education should cater to the individual
needs of each student to help all learn most effectively. The freedom of students to choose their own route
of education is something that must be addressed.
SOME STUDENTS ARE NOT GETTING THE SAME OPPORTUNITIES AS OTHERS. With the growth of private
and charter schooling options, many students from low-income areas are not being afforded the same
educational opportunities that the wealthy have. This problem of inequality is further emphasized by a
minority population that has access to a narrower scope of course selections in their respective school
districts.
These issues are only emphasized by recent controversies in attempted education reforms. The most well-known
of these reforms is the No
Child Left Behind Act of
2001. This document
required schools to assess
students and put forth
standards that must be met
by each student (Boyd).
This act created
responsibility for schools to
teach at a certain level or
risk losing federal funds. In
general, the act has led to
increased test scores and
improved teacher
accessibility, but has also
resulted in many schools in
low income areas losing a
great deal of funds thus
making it harder to teach
students. In addition to the NCBL act,
Common Core educational standards
have also seen public debate because of its highly controversial method of standardizing education. As we envision
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
the future of our K-12 educational systems, the various pros and cons of each option must be considered with great
weight. By doing so, an optimal solution of educational standards can be implemented.
THEME ONE
Preparing for the workplace
THE PRIORITY OF K-12 EDUCATION SHOULD BE TO PREPARE
STUDENTS TO BE SUCCESSFUL IN THE WORKPLACE AND HELP THE UNITED
AMERICANS THINK THAT HIGH SCHOOL GRADUATES ARE PREPARED FOR THE
WORLD OF WORK (STATE OF AMERICAS SCHOOLS). FURTHERMORE,
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
A NEW
structured and focused curriculum plan needs to be developed for these subjects across grade levels. Students
should feel like the STEM content they are learning one year builds on and connects to what they have learned in
previous years.
INDIVIDUALIZE COURSEWORK BASED ON CAREER PLANS
Attending a college or university is not the best career decision for every student so high schools should
provide alternative tracks and options for some students. In fact, there is a high demand for trade school
graduates, but most high schools give their students little exposure to this option (Kavilanz). The concept of
vocational schooling is historically a European idea, well implemented in countries like Germany and Finland
(Bidwell). While it would be unrealistic to suggest that high school completely reform and adopt a full tracking
system, students should have more options to adjust their coursework based on their potential career plans. For
example, a student that intends to take over the family business once he/she finishes school does not necessarily
benefit from having to take pre-calculus and calculus math classes. A student like that would most likely be better
off with the option to take math classes that focus on finance and economics. Even for students who intend to go to
college, a track-like system could still offer benefits. Students who are interested in STEM fields should have the
option to take programming classes instead of the typically required foreign language classes. For high schools
that are located close to community colleges or trade schools, joint programs should be emphasized that allow
high school students to pursue specific fields of interest while meeting graduation requirements. Each student
should be ready and fully informed about choosing his or her career in high school. It is also important not to
pressure high school students to make career decisions too early because some options like trade schools do not
offer the same flexibility as typical undergraduate programs in changing your area of focus.
ENHANCE PRACTICAL SKILLS AND EXPERIENCES
There has been much debate on how the K-12 education system should balance practical skills with
theoretical knowledge. With the current emphasis on standardized testing, many students graduate high school
with inadequate communication and critical thinking skills. The AARP Foundation lists problem-solving, oral and
written communication, leadership, and creativity as some of the most important skills for potential employees to
have (What Skills). Schools and teachers need to revise their curriculum plans to emphasize the development of
these skills over rote memorization and test preparation. High school English classes should also devote time to
mock interviews and resume workshops so that students are more prepared to apply for jobs. Science classes could
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
integrate more laboratory work and provide exposure to real laboratory environments and practices. Students
should also be encouraged to develop these skills outside of the classroom through real-world experiences. One
way to create students that are more prepared to succeed in the real world would be to expose them to more
workplace environments. Schools could coordinate with local businesses and nonprofit organizations to develop
workshops, internships, and jobs for high-school students that emphasize practical skills. Instead of making
students develop work-readiness on their own, schools should take the initiative and integrate these components
into their programs and curriculum. An important balance in integrating these experiences is not cutting back too
much on basic knowledge. The fundamentals are still required for standardized testing that is used in college
admissions and can impact the amount of funding a school receives.
POTENTIAL TRADE-OFFS
THEME TWO
Freedom and Individuality in the Classroom
Do we learn what we want to learn?
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
CURRENT SYSTEM
Our current educational
system utilizes a multitude
of standardized tests for the
evaluation of a students
education statewide and
nationally. In fact, from
kindergarten to the
completion of high school,
the average student takes
more than 60 standardized
tests during his education
(Bowman). This forces
FIGURE 2: AUTONOMY OF STUDENTS ACCORDING TO PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHERS
material that they will be tested on so that their classrooms will meet or exceed the national average. One
example of this type of standardized learning approach that has been getting coverage in the media lately is the
Common Core State Standards program, which includes English-language arts and mathematics standards and
addresses all grades (K-12) (Existing Guidelines). The problem with this current system of standardized
education is that especially with younger grades, children develop at different rates in different areas and what
might be a fair assessment of progress for some children at some point in time will consequently be an unfair or
inaccurate assessment of progress or aptitude for others.
supplemented with some structured learning in order to ensure proper progress. This would take the form of
lectures and textbook material. This approach could be conducted with minimal changes to current school
facilities, but class sizes would have to be reduced so that teachers could maintain the necessary level of attention
towards each individual student and his or her learning approach.
POTENTIAL TRADE-OFFS
THEME THREE
Equal Opportunity in the Classroom
Who gets more attention?
THE OPTION WE ARE FOCUSING ON INVOLVES THE CHANCE FOR EVERYONE IN AMERICA TO
RECEIVE A FAIR AND EQUAL CHANCE TO SUCCEED IN PRIMARY SCHOOL AND SET HIM OR HER
UP FOR SUCCEEDING IN COLLEGE. AS OF RIGHT NOW WHAT WE FIND IN THE EDUCATION
SYSTEM IS AN UNEVEN PLAYING FIELD FOR STUDENTS OF LOWER INCOMES, MINORITIES, AND
INNER CITY KIDS. THE CURRENT SYSTEM BASIS FUNDING OFF OF HOW WELL KIDS DO ON THE
STATE MANDATED TESTS, WHICH AT A GLANCE SEEMS FAIR AND BALANCED, BUT WHEN
LOOKING CLOSER ONE REALIZES THAT MOST FUNDING GOES TO SUBURBAN SCHOOLS WHERE
THE POPULATION IS A VAST MAJORITY WHITE AND HIGHER INCOME FAMILIES. (REVENUE
DECOMPOSITION)
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
communities are better funded because of the emphasis on school districts in suburbs rather than in the inner city
where emphasis is placed on (Disparities in District Funding) (See figure 2 below). Branching off standardized
testing one can see from looking at current models that the relationship between higher income families, who tend
to be white, and lower income families, who tend to be minorities, is that the higher income families have a better
opportunity to make better overall test scores since they can afford the expensive SAT and ACT booklets and
some of the similar classes in which a special instructor helps the kids, who can afford the class, receive higher test
scores on the ACT or SAT. Looking at the other side of school, more specifically extracurricular activities, one
would be able to see that these are used as an outlet for some for others because they simply love doing this
activity, whether it is sports, art, music, or even a book club. For young kids from impoverished areas these
activities mean everything, from the inner city kids who live in the area with the heaviest amount of gang activity
and these extracurricular activities keep them away from those type of activities and almost gives them a sense of
direction to the impoverished kids who live out in the country where they can achieve a sense of escape from
reality. Extracurriculars however are the first programs to be cut when a school lacks funding which in turn gives
most impoverished kids no where to turn except back to the streets.
part of the US have the same chance of succeeding on standardized tests. Lower income areas most likely wont
score as well on tests. Therefore, they do not receive as much funding as their wealthy or middle class suburban
counterparts.
Another approach is to balance the funding for all schools regardless of district wealth. Its preposterous
that wealthy public school districts in areas with high taxes can afford laptops for all their students while other
low income districts nearby can barely afford textbooks. Leveling and matching the academic opportunities from
any socio-economic background will help in alleviating the huge academic disparities some areas face.
Leveling the playing field is also necessary in high schools pertaining to AP and IB programs. Schools
whose population are largely made up of a low socio-economic class are not able to have as many AP and IB
classes which make them look more competitive for college. Part of this problem stems from two reasons. Students
at an impoverished school lack the proper preparation for AP and IB classes and do not have as many AP or IB
class offerings. Had these students been given the same opportunities as kids in wealthy school districts colleges
would be much more willing to consider and accept their applications. With this change, Americans could see even
bigger shift than today of lower income students having the opportunity to go to college.
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
CONCLUSION
K-12 education has been a
paramount aspect of the United States
CURRENTLY, THE UNITED STATES IS FACING SERIOUS
PROBLEMS IN REGARDS TO WORLD COMPETITION WITH OTHER
NATIONS, AND THIS STEMS FROM OUR EDUCATION SYSTEM.
students are being enrolled each year and more students are graduating high school each year. Throughout
American history, K-12 education has been key to our overall economic development and growth as a country.
Weve focused too much on the right way to do things. There is hardly any room for individualization, there is
hardly any room for creativity, and there is hardly any room for personal growth. Whats more, students are
graduating high school unprepared for the workforce. The United States is looking to take back its reign as having
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
the leading economy in the world, but the lack of preparedness from high school graduates with respect to the
workforce is detrimental to the entire system. The gap between academically advanced students and those who
struggle academically continues to increase with the implementation of programs like AP and IB classes. This
proves difficult for all students to get the education they deserve, hurting their future and societys future in the
process.
How should K-12 education help mold the society that we want? This guide touches on three options to
consider, showcasing the benefits and trade-offs of each. Please keep in mind the myriad questions that come from
weighing these options. For instance, how important is K-12 to future society? What are the costs of changing a
system that we have had in place for so long?
School boards and school principals can work towards various goals, but a movement cannot occur
without support to back it. As we think about the role of K-12 education in the future of our country, it is vital to
share ideas with fellow citizens. This guide is intended to launch that exchange of ideas.
*
REFERENCES
AARP Work Search. AARP Foundation, "What Skills Are Employers Looking For?", n.d. Web. 16 Feb. 2016.
Bidwell, Allie. "Vocational High Schools: Career Path or Kiss of Death?" U.S. News & World Report. U.S. News, 2 May 2014.
Web. 17 Feb. 2016.
Boyd, Natalia. "No Child Left Behind: Summary, Pros & Cons - Video & Lesson Transcript | Study.com." Study.com. Study.
Web. 17 Feb. 2016. <http://study.com/academy/lesson/no-child-left-behind-summary-pros-cons.html>.
Bowman, Sarah. "Number of standardized tests public-school students take exploded in Past Decade." The Island Packet. N.p.,
n.d. Web. 16 Feb. 2016. <http://www.islandpacket.com/news/local/education/article33564114.html>.
Eiss, Albert F. Individualized Learning. Science and Children 9.7 (1972): 911. Web...
Existing Guidelines for Implementing the Common Core State Standards. Implementation of the Common Core State Standards:
Recommendations for the Department of Defense Education Activity Schools. RAND Corporation, 2012. 910. Web.
Godsey, Michael. "The Inequality in Public Schools." The Atlantic. Atlantic Media Company, 15 June 2015. Web. 17 Feb. 2016.
<http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/06/inequality-public-schools/395876/>.
Kavilanz, Parija. "Nine Months in Trade School. Job Guaranteed." CNN Money. CNN, 23 July
2012. Web. 16 Feb. 2016.
Kent, Lauren. "5 Facts about Americas Students." Pew Research. Pew Research Center, 10 Aug. 2015. Web. 16 Feb. 2016.
"Historical Timeline of Public Education in the US." Race Forward. Race Forward, 2006. Web. 17 Feb. 2016
https://www.raceforward.org/research/reports/historical-timeline-public-education-us
Miller, Dr. Gerald. "Inequality of Education in the United States." Rockland University. Web. 17 Feb. 2016.
Norris, Floyd. "Fewer U.S. Graduates Opt for College After High School." New York Times. New York Times, 25 Apr. 2014.
Web. 16 Feb. 2016.
Olorunnipa, Toluse. "Obama Seeks $4.1 Billion to Expand Computer Programming Classes." Bloomberg. Bloomberg, n.d. Web.
16 Feb. 2016.
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2
The Broad Foundation, "The Broad Foundation - Education." The Broad Foundation - Education.. Web. 17 Feb. 2016
<http://broadeducation.org/about/crisis_stats.html>.
"The Link Between Education & Inequality." The Link Between Education & Inequality. Harvard University. Web. 17 Feb.
2016.
Strauss, Steven. "The Connection Between Education, Income Inequality, and Unemployment." The Huffington Post.
TheHuffingtonPost.com, 02 Jan. 2012. Web. 187 Feb. 2016. <http://www.huffingtonpost.com/steven-strauss/theconnection-between-ed_b_1066401.html>.
US Department of Education. "Fast Facts." Fast Facts. Institute of Education Sciences. Web. 17 Feb. 2016.
<https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=66>.
US Department of Education "Perceived Autonomy of Teachers." Chart. NCES., n.d. Web. 16 Feb. 2016.
State of America's Schools: The Path to Winning Again in Education. N.p.: Gallup, 2004
US Department of Labor. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Occupational Employment Projections to 2018. By T. Alan Lacey and
Benjamin Wright. Bureau of Labor Statistics. N.p., Dec 2010. Web. 16 Feb. 2016.
Washington D.C.: National Research Council Successful K-12 STEM Education., 2011. National Academies Press. Web. 16 Feb.
2016
Woessmann, Ludger. "Why Students in Some Countries Do Better." Education Next Summer 1.2 (2001). Education Next. Web.
17 Feb. 2016. <http://educationnext.org/whystudentsinsomecountriesdobetter/>.
Zhao, Yong. "Catching Up or Leading The Way." Recent Education Reform in the United States. ASCD. Web. 17 Feb. 2016.
<http://www.ascd.org/publications/books/109076/chapters/Recent-Education-Reform-in-the-UnitedStates.aspx>.
*
THE DILEMMA OF K-12 EDUCATION | FEBRUARY 27 | ROMIG HALL OF THE FAITH UNITED CHURCH, 300 E. COLLEGE AVE. |
STUDENTS OF CAS 138T | DR. VEENA RAMAN | SECTION 3 | TEAM 2