See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: http://www.researchgate.net/publication/229039796

Coagulationflocculation processes in
water/wastewater treatment: the application of
new generation of chemical reagents
ARTICLE JANUARY 2008

CITATIONS

2 AUTHORS:
Nikos Tzoupanos

Anastasios Zouboulis

Athens School of Fine Arts

Aristotle University of Thessaloniki

12 PUBLICATIONS 120 CITATIONS

242 PUBLICATIONS 5,218 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE

SEE PROFILE

Available from: Anastasios Zouboulis

Retrieved on: 12 October 2015

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

COAGULATION-FLOCCULATION PROCESSES IN
WATER/WASTEWATER TREATMENT: THE APPLICATION OF
NEW GENERATION OF CHEMICAL REAGENTS
N. D. TZOUPANOS AND A. I. ZOUBOULIS*
Division of Chemical Technology, Department of Chemistry,
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki,
GR-54124, GREECE
* email: [email protected], tel: +302310997794
Abstract: The aim of this paper is to provide an overall description of coagulation-flocculation process and its
applications in water and wastewater treatment. The significance of coagulation flocculation in the area of
water and wastewater treatment is reviewed and evaluated, emphasizing on the series of applications employed,
including destabilization of colloids, removal of inorganic and organic matter (particulate and/or dissolved),
removal of metals and anions (arsenic, phosphate etc), as well as removal of pathogen microorganisms.
Furthermore, the latest developments in the coagulation field, regarding the evolution of the coagulation
reagents, are also under investigation. The development of simple pre-polymerized coagulants (i.e.
polyaluminium chloride,) seems no longer to be sufficient enough. The need for more effective coagulants has
lead to the development of new coagulant categories, via the introduction of various additives in the structure of
pre-polymerized coagulants. The first effort was reported 15 years ago, suggesting the use of silica in the form
of polysilicates for such a purpose. Nowadays, the range of additives has expanded, including organic
compounds, such as anionic, cationic or non-ionic polyelectrolytes, leading to new composite coagulants.
Overall, it is evident that the tendency in the coagulation field nowadays is the production of modified
composite coagulants, which they are becoming more and more complicated, regarding their composition, but
also more effective, when compared with the traditionally applied reagents.
Key-Words: Coagulation; flocculation; composite coagulants; inorganic additives; organic additives.
stage seems to be a key factor for the improvement
of the overall treatment efficiency.
The whole treatment process of coagulation
flocculation can be divided into two distinct
procedures, which should be applied consecutively.
The first one termed coagulation, is the process
whereby destabilization of a given colloidal
suspension or solution is taking place. The function
of coagulation is to overcome the factors that
promote the stability of a given system. It is
achieved with the use of appropriate chemicals,
usually aluminium or iron salts, the so-called
coagulant agents. The second sub-process, termed
flocculation, refers to the induction of destabilized
particles in order to come together, to make contact
and thereby, to form large agglomerates, which can
be separated easier usually through gravity settling
[1]. Coagulation usually completes in a very short
period of time (e.g. about 10 s), whereas
flocculation occurs usually over a period of 20 to
45 min. It is a common practice, especially in
Greece, the enhancement of particles aggregation

1. Introduction
The need for drinking water of high quality is
increasing, as the non-polluted water sources are
continuously
decreasing.
Additionally,
the
discharge criteria of wastewaters are becoming
stricter, according to the new legislation in force, in
order to prevent environmental pollution and/or
infection of drinking water sources. It is evident
that more effective water and wastewater
treatments are needed.
A very important step in water and in
wastewater treatment is the coagulationflocculation process, which is widely used, due to
its simplicity and cost-effectiveness. Regardless of
the nature of the treated sample (e.g. various types
of water or wastewater) and the overall applied
treatment scheme, coagulation-flocculation is
usually included, either as pre-, or as post-treatment
step. The efficiency of coagulation-flocculation
strongly affects the overall treatment performance;
hence, the increase of the efficiency of coagulation

ISSN: 1790-5095

309

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

Table 1. Classification of particle sizes [1].

Particle size
(mm)

10
1
10-1
10-2
10-3
10-4
10-5

Classification

Examples

Coarse dispersion
(visible to naked eye)

Gravel, coarse sand, mineral

substances, precipitated and
flocculated particles, silt,
macroplankton
Mineral substances, precipitated
and flocculated particles, silt,
bacteria, plankton, and other
organisms
Mineral substances, hydrolysis
and precipitated products,
macromolecules, biopolymers,
viruses
Inorganic simple and complex
ions, molecules and polymeric
species, polyelectrolytes,
organic molecules,
undissociated solutes

Fine particulate
dispersion (visible
under microscope)

10-6

Colloidal dispersion
(submicroscopic)

<10-6

Solution

during the 2nd step by the addition of organic

polyelectrolytes, the so-called flocculant aids, or
simply flocculants.

Time required to settle

100 mm, if specific
gravity = 2.65

6 x 10-4
6 x 10-3

0.1 s
1s

6 x 10-2

13 s

0.6
6

11 min
20 hours

60

80 days

600

2 years

6000

20 years

electrostatic repulsive forces constrain the particles

from approaching each other and the suspension is
characterized as stable; therefore, long time period
is required for settling.
In order to accelerate the settling time,
destabilization is required, denoting the importance
of coagulation. The destabilization can be achieved
with one, or a combination of two or more of the
following mechanisms, after the addition of a
coagulant agent [2, 3]:
1) Compression of the electrical double layer.
2) Adsorption and charge neutralization.
3) Adsorption and interparticle bridging.
4) Enmeshment in precipitate (by using of excess
coagulant dose, sweep flocculation).
After the destabilization, flocculation promotes
the aggregation and flocs formation, usually after
the addition of an appropriate flocculant agent.
Two general types of flocculation can be identified:
micro-flocculation (or perikinetic flocculation), in
which particles aggregation is brought about by the
thermal motion of fluid molecules (Brownian
motion) and macro-flocculation (orthokinetic
flocculation), in which particle aggregation is
brought about by inducing velocity gradients and
mixing in the suspension [3].
Coagulation-flocculation is used widely during
water or wastewater treatment. It is an integral
treatment step in the surface or underground waters
treatment, indented for human consumption.
Typical applications are the removal/separation of
colloids and suspended particles, of natural organic
matter, or of metal ions. In wastewater treatment,
additional applications include the removal of toxic
metals, anions (i.e. phosphates), color, odor etc.

2. Coagulation flocculation in water

and wastewater treatment
The suspended material in waters and in
wastewaters mostly arise from land erosion, the
dissolution of minerals, the decay of vegetation and
from several domestic and industrial waste
discharges. For a given water or wastewater, such
material may comprise suspended, dissolved
organic and/or inorganic matter, as well as several
biological organisms, such as bacteria, algae or
viruses. This material has to be removed, as it
causes deterioration of water quality by reducing
the clarity (e.g. causing turbidity or colour),
causing infection, and eventually carrying toxic
compounds, adsorbed on their surfaces. In addition,
organic matter is the main precursor to the
formation of disinfection by-products, when
chlorine is applied as disinfection agent.
Table 1 [1] classifies according to the size the
common materials present in waters or
wastewaters. Particles smaller than around 10-5 mm
may be referred as colloids and particles smaller
than 10-6 mm as solutions. It can be noticed that
with decreasing size, the time required for settling
increases, up to several years for certain solutions
ingredients. Due to the very small size, the only
way for settling and the subsequent separation is to
come closer, to make contacts and to form larger
particles, which can be settle easier. This procedure
however, is hindered due to the homonymous
negative charge this material carries. The

ISSN: 1790-5095

Total surface
area
(m2/cm3)

310

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

3.

Coagulation reagents

3.1

Metal coagulants

or polyaluminium chloro-sulfates (PACS), with

variable degrees of polymerization. These products
and especially the first one (PACl) are used
extensively worldwide during the last decades, with
an ever increasing demand. Their properties were
intensively examined and have proved to be more
efficient in lower dosages, in wider pH,
temperature and colloids concentration ranges, than
the conventional simpler ones, leading to cost and
operative more effective treatment [3, 4].
Their superiority is related to the different
aluminium species distribution in the polymerized,
as compared with the non-polymerized solutions.
Aluminium exists in water solutions and at pH
values < 3 as six-coordinated Al3+ ion. With
increase of pH value, the aluminium ion begins to
hydrolyze, and various products can be formed.
The hydrolyzation of Al ion is extremely
complicated,
involving
hydrolysis
and
polymerization reactions, thus leading apart from
various monomeric, also to several polymeric
species formation [5]. With conventional
coagulants,
these
reactions
are
entirely
uncontrolled, and the coagulation efficiency is
based more to Al(OH)3 formation (around the pH
6.5-7) and less to charge neutralization, as the
hydrolysis reactions are proceeding fast and hence,
the concentration of positively charged Al ions is
restricted. In the case of PACl, the prepolymerization aims to control up to a certain
extent the aforementioned reactions.
With the partial neutralization of Al solution by
adding a base solution and then by aging, these
reactions may take place at some extent and various
Al species can be formed. The most important
reaction is supposed to be that leading to Al(OH)4formation. This aluminium anionic form is claimed
to be the precursor for the polymeric Al13 creation
[6]. Al13 (AlO4Al12(OH)24(H2O)126+,7+) with Keggin structure is one of many possible PACl
polymeric compounds, like dimmers (e.g.
Al2(OH)24+), trimers (e.g. Al3(OH)45+) among
several others, even larger than Al13 i.e. with more
than
13
aluminium
atoms
(e.g.
Al30O8(OH)56(H2O)2418+),
which
transform
continuously from one form to another [7].
However, Al13 is claimed to be the most stable
aluminium specie in a partially neutralized
aluminium solution [8] and the improved
coagulation properties of PACl are thought to be
due to its existence, i.e. increased charge
neutralization
capability
(coagulation)
and
increased molecular size and aggregation ability
(flocculation). Further on, the decrease of
monomeric Al in favor of Al13 and of the other

The commonly used metal coagulants fall into

two general categories: those based on aluminium
and those based on iron. This paper deals with the
aluminium based coagulants, hence these will be
described further.
The most widely used metal coagulant is
probably the aluminium sulfate (alum), which
has been used for water treatment during the past
decades. It is commonly manufactured from the
reaction of bauxite ores with sulfuric acid.
Evaporation of water in the process results in a dry
product, having the approximate formula
Al2(SO4)3.14-18H2O, and with an Al content
ranging from 7.4 to 9.5%. It is supplied as powder
or in liquid form and its applications include water
or wastewater treatment.
A product prepared from alum and sulfuric acid
is acidified aluminium sulfate (acid alum). It is
supplied as a liquid and is used mainly in papermaking industry. Other Al coagulants are the
aluminium chloride (AlCl3.6H2O) and the sodium
aluminate (NaAlO2). The first one is supplied as
liquid (containing 10.5% Al) and is used widely for
sludge conditioning. The latter is usually supplied
as a viscous, strongly alkaline and corrosive liquid
(containing 13% Al). It is rarely used alone, but
generally with alum to obtain some specific results,
i.e. in the treatment of highly colored waters [1, 3].
The application of simple metal coagulants
(conventional) is widespread, especially due to the
relatively low cost and the simpler application
route. However, they exhibit several disadvantages,
such as the need for pH adjustment before or after
treatment, the sensitivity to temperature changes,
the need for higher dosages because the charge
neutralization is not usually sufficient, the
sensitivity to sample specific characteristics and
composition, as well as the excessive sludge
production.

3.2

Pre-polymerized coagulants

Several research efforts have been devoted

to improve the efficiency of coagulationflocculation process. After studying the aquatic
chemistry and the behavior of simple Al salts, the
way for improvement seemed to be their (partial)
polymerization. The result of these efforts was the
production of a range of pre-polymerized
aluminium solutions, referred as polyaluminium
chlorides (PACl), polyaluminium sulfates (PAS),

ISSN: 1790-5095

311

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

polymeric compounds eliminates the hydrolysis

reactions and therefore, results in a minor impact of
pH value after treatment.
The production of pre-polymerized coagulants
involves the partial neutralization of an Al solution
with a base solution. Many parameters can affect
the properties of the final product, i.e. the base
addition rate, the stirring speed, the synthesis
temperature, the presence of other anions (e.g. Cl-,
SO4-, CO32-), the aging time etc. The most
important parameter however, is claimed to be the
molar ratio of bound hydroxide to the concentration
of metal cations (i.e. the OH/Al molar ratio). It is
referred as basicity and is also used to describe
conveniently the polymerization degree of
coagulant agents.

4.
New
reagents

generation

silica. Hasegawa et al. [10] noticed that by

introducing metal ions into polymerized silicic acid
solution, the molecular weight of the product
increased and the respective stability and
coagulation performance were improved. In this
case, the product was rather an inorganic metalpolysilicate flocculant, where silica was the main
component, than a pre-polymerized inorganic
coagulant. More recently, research has focused in
the incorporation of silica within the prepolymerized metal solutions, aiming to products
with larger molecular weight by the application of
two techniques; i.e. either by introducing
polymerized silica in the pre-polymerized metal
solution, or by introducing polymerized silica in the
metal solution, followed by polymerization. The
first method is referred as composite
polymerization, whereas the latter one as copolymerization.
Polymerized silica can be obtained when the
concentration of monosilicic acid (Si(OH)4) in
aqueous solution exceeds the solubility limit of
amorphous silica, or otherwise by bringing the
solution temporarily into the pH-concentration
range of oversaturation with respect to amorphous
silica [11, 12]. Excess monomers in the solution
gradually disappear to form polymers. The
polymers, or polysilicic acid, consist of silica
tetrahedrons that are linked via silicon-oxygensilicon bonds (e.g. Si-OH + HO-Si Si-O-Si
+ H2O) [12]. Various species can be formed, e.g.
Si2O3(OH)42-, Si3O5(OH)53- etc., and exact nature
and the extent of their formation is affected by the
temperature, the concentration of silica, the
presence of other ions, the pH value and the aging
time. Soluble, internally hydrated, polymeric silicic
acids of colloidal dimensions, or discrete particles
of colloidal size, can be present. The most
important parameter that affects the kinetics of
silica polymerization is the pH value. Particularly,
the polymerization is thought to be catalyzed by
hydroxyl anions and is very fast at neutral or
slightly alkaline pH range. Over pH value 9, the
reaction rate decreases. Furthermore, by aging the
polymerization can lead to the formation of bigger
aggregates and finally, to gel formation
(amorphous (SiO)n). In order to avoid gelation and
to preserve the polysilicates at soluble form, the
solution has to be brought outside the insolubility
range. This can be achieved by acidifying the
solution to pH values 23. Particularly, at pH
around 2 the polymerization rate is retarded enough
and the polysilicates are stable in soluble form for
several days [11-13].

coagulation

In spite of their improved properties, the prepolymerized coagulants performance still remains
inferior, when compared to the performance of
organic polyelectrolytes, e.g. when used in water
treatment [9]. In recent years, the relevant research
in the coagulation-flocculation field has focused
mainly in understanding the behaviour and aquatic
chemistry of pre-polymerized coagulants, such as
polyaluminium chloride, and to the further
improvement of their properties. The main reason
for the higher efficiency of organic polymers is
their higher molecular weight (MW), which implies
better flocculation properties. Thus, the increase of
molecular weight and size of the pre-polymerized
coagulants is thought to be the way for further
improvement.
The general concept followed is, the
introduction of various additives in the structure of
a pre-polymerized coagulant, in order to produce a
homogenous, stable product with higher MW and
improved coagulation-flocculation performance,
than the initial reagent. The challenge to confront is
the desirable combination of higher efficiency and
cost-effectiveness, which are the basic prerequisites
for the development of new products. Various
additives were examined, which can be classified
into two main categories; inorganic and organic.
These compounds and the respective products
derived, based on aluminium coagulants, will be
described in the following.

4.1

Inorganic additives

A suitable additive for the improvement of

flocculation properties is thought to be polymerized

ISSN: 1790-5095

312

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

Based on these observations and the use of a

suitable silicic acid source, i.e. the sodium silicate
solution or water glass, several efforts have been
made for the introduction of acidified polysilicates
into the structure of pre-polymerized coagulants.
The mixed product in the case of aluminium is
called polyaluminium silicate chloride, though it
should be rather referred as a category of
coagulation reagents, because with different
combinations of OH/Al or Al/Si molar ratios,
various reagents can be produced. Polyaluminium
silicate chloride has shown superior coagulation
performance, than the conventional or simple prepolymerized coagulants in water or wastewater
treatment [9, 14, 15]. The better performance can
be attributed to the alteration in a specific degree of
the coagulants composition. Specifically, it has
been proved that the introduction of silica chains
into the structure of PACl increases the molecular
weight of the coagulants components with the
formation of alumino-silicate complexes, thus
leading in enhanced aggregating power and biggerdenser flocs formation [9, 14-17].

4.2

synthesis can be manipulated to produce polymers

of varying size (MW), charge groups, number of
charge groups per polymer chain (charge density)
and varying structure (linear or branched). Many
synthetic
polyelectrolytes
are
based
on
polyacrylamide and its copolymers with
polyacrylic acid. Typical examples are the
hydrolyzed polyacrylamides (anionic, MW 104-107
g/mole), polydiallyldimethyl ammonium chloride
(poly-DADMAC, cationic, MW 104-107 g/mole)
and various polyacrylamides (nonionic, MW 105107 g/mole) [18].
Organic polymers are not generally used as
primary coagulants. Only in certain cases cationic
polyelectrolytes will be applied for the
destabilization of colloids (coagulation) and
usually, in conjunction with inorganic metal salts.
The primary use of polymers is as flocculant aids,
whereas non-ionic or anionic polyelectrolytes are
added after the addition of an inorganic coagulant
[19]. Despite their efficiency, their use is
accompanied with significant drawbacks, such as
the increased treatment cost. Considering that apart
from the product cost itself, which is higher than
inorganic salts, polymers are delivered usually in
solid form and hence, a separate dissolution set-up
is needed, which further increases the treatment
cost. Furthermore, the existence of remaining
unreacted monomers results in residual toxicity in
the treated sample.
The combination of an inorganic salt
(coagulant) and a suitable polyelectolyte
(flocculant) into one reagent is thought to improve,
apart from the treatment efficiency of the inorganic
salt, the overall cost-effectiveness. No addition of a
flocculant aid will be needed any more, whereas
the introduction of the polyelectrolyte into the
structure of the metal salt will also significantly
reduce the eventual residual toxicity.
These suggestions lead to the production of
modified inorganic coagulants with organic
additives, a field that is under investigation
nowadays. All the aforementioned charged or not
charged polyelectrolytes can be used for this
purpose, with different impact in the nature of the
new product. Particularly, by the introduction of a
cationic polyelectrolyte into the structure of a prepolymerized metal coagulant, the charge
neutralization capability is mainly expected to be
improved, and in a lower extent, the aggregating
effect as well. Moreover, the usage of an anionic
polyelectrolyte with higher molecular weight (as
compared to cationic) would further improve the
aggregating ability. In this case, however, the
anionic polymer should have weaker anionic

Organic additives

Organic polyelectrolytes are typical

hydrophilic colloids and contain certain functional
groups, which may be ionizable. When these
groups dissociate, the polymer molecules become
charged, either positively or negatively, and are
thus referred to as cationic or anionic
polyelectrolytes, respectively. If no ionizable
groups are present, the polymers are termed as nonionic [1].
They can be classified according to their origin
into two main categories, the natural and or
synthetic
polymers.
Natural
polymers
(biopolymers) have long been used as flocculants
(bioflocculants). Typical examples are starch
derivatives that are pregelatinized and watersoluble. These can be starches, anionic oxidized
starches, or amine-treated cationic starches. Other
classes include polysaccharides, such as guar gums,
tannins, chitosan and the alginates [3, 18].
Although natural polyelectrolytes have the
advantage of being toxic-free, the use of synthetic
polyelectrolytes is more widespread. They are in
general more effective as flocculants, principally
due to the possibility of controlling properties, such
as the number and type of charged units and the
molecular weight. Moreover, they are much
cheaper, than those made from natural sources.
Synthetic organic polymers are made either by
homo-polymerization of the monomer, or by copolymerization of two monomers. Polymer

ISSN: 1790-5095

313

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

charge, in order not to deteriorate extensively the

charge neutralization strength of the combined
coagulant agent. A non-ionic polyelectrolyte would
have a minor effect in the coagulants charge
density (possible negative), but would increase
significantly the flocculation ability. Key factors
affecting strongly the properties of the combined,
modified coagulant are the charge, MW and
content of the polyelectrolyte.
Some efforts have been reported, regarding the
combination of PACl with various anionic, cationic
and non ionic organic polymers [20] and the
combination of PACl with poly-DADMAC [21,
22]. Although the research in this field is in an
initial stage, promising results were obtained from
the aforementioned, publications regarding the
coagulation performance.
The introduction of the polyelectrolyte can be
accomplished by two procedures, as in the case of
silica addition, i.e. with the co-polymerization, or
the composite polymerization. The content of the
polyelectrolyte (PE) in the final product is usually
expressed as the Al/PE ratio (mg/L), can take
values between 5 and 20 and together with the
aforementioned parameters in the case of prepolymerized coagulants, designates the properties
of the final product.

biologically pre-treated landfill leachates with

coagulation-flocculation [24]. This kind of
wastewater is difficult to be further treated, mainly
due to its bio-refractory organic content (humic
substances). The performance of PASiC (OH/Al =
1, Al/Si = 15) is evaluated and compared with the
respective performance of a conventional coagulant
(alum, OH/Al = 0), as well as with two simple prepolymerized coagulants, a widely used commercial
product with slightly higher polymerization degree
(PACl-18, OH/Al = 1.2) and a laboratory prepared
PACl solution with the same polymerization degree
(PACllab, OH/Al = 1). Turbidity, UV absorbance at
254 nm (corresponding to the presence of Natural
Organic Matter / NOM) and chemical oxygen
demand (COD) were among the monitored
parameters during these experiments.
From table 1 it can be seen that the least
effective coagulant in almost all cases is alum,
whereas the most effective is PASiC. The highest
removal efficiencies for all the examined
parameters are achieved with the new composite
coagulant for the highest dosage added (300 mg/L).
Worthnoting is the fact that with the addition of
alum or PACllab over 200 mg L-1 the quality of
treated sample was deteriorated by means of
turbidity (denoted as 0% removal). Therefore, the
further increase of concentration leads to
overdosing, reversibility of coagulation phenomena
and re-stabilization of colloids. However, in the
case of silica-based coagulants, the addition of even
300 mg L-1 results in the further improvement of
treated wastewater (leachate) characteristics, thus
with these coagulants the application of higher
dosages is possible in order to obtain better
treatment results.
Nevertheless, it should be mentioned that in
order to prepare a superior novel silica-based
coagulation reagent, specific attention has to be
given to the polymerization degree, the silica
content, as well as to the preparation method,
because from these experiments it was revealed
that composite coagulants with different OH/Al and
Al/Si molar ratios or preparation methods can be
most efficient in different cases [14, 24]. As an
example, fig. 1 displays the percent (%) removals
of organic matter (by measuring the UV
absorbance at 254 nm), after treating a synthetic
wastewater
sample
(simulated
domestic
wastewater) with several polyaluminium silicates
coagulants, containing different silica content
(Al/Si 5-15, Al/Si=0 corresponds to PACl). It can
be noticed that not all composite coagulants are
more efficient than PACl, but only those with Al/Si
= 10 or 15.

4.3
Applications of the new generation
coagulants
In the 3rd IASME/WSEAS Conference
(Crete, 2007) [23], the authors presented the
superior performance of polyaluminium silicate
chloride, as compared to the performance of
conventional or simple pre-polymerized coagulants
in water treatment. Particularly, it was shown that
the incorporation of polymerized silica enhances
the aggregation ability, as the duration of flocs
growth period decreases and the size of generated
flocs increases. This enhancement compensates
efficiently the decrease in coagulants charge
neutralization capability due to silica addition, as
the coagulation performance of PASiC was clearly
better,
especially
regarding
residual
Al
concentration. The advantages of PASiC in water
treatment can be summarized in the more efficient
treatment, using lower dosages of coagulants and in
a wider pH range, whereas the Al concentration
that remains in the treated sample is significantly
lower.
A matter that has not been considered yet in
detail is the application of polyaluminium silicate
chloride in wastewater treatment. Table 2
demonstrates the results of the post-treatment of

ISSN: 1790-5095

314

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

Regarding the new composite coagulants with

organic additives, the evaluation of their
Table 2. Comparison of coagulation* performance for several Al-based coagulants when applied in waste water
treatment.
Turbidity removal
Absorbance at 254 nm
COD removal
(%)
removal
(%)
(%)
Coagulant
Coagulant dosage (mg/L)
50
100
300
65
72
0
83
88
77
84
88
0
86
90
94

Alum
PACl-18
PACllab
PASiC

Coagulant dosage (mg/L)

50
100
300
16
29
39
18
31
70
20
32
71
19
33
74

Coagulant dosage (mg/L)

50
100
300
30
51
61
31
46
73
35
49
63
32
51
77

* Initial turbidity 4.5 NTU, initial absorbance at 254nm 2.740, pH of treated sample 8.6

Table 3. Comparison of coagulation* performance for polymers-based coagulants, when applied in water
treatment.
Absorbance at 254 nm
Residual Al concentration
Turbidity removal (%)
removal (%)
(mg/L)
Coagulant
Coagulant dosage (mg/L)
2
4
6
94
97
97
95
99
99

PACllab
PACPE

Coagulant dosage (mg/L)

2
4
6
70
73
79
83
86
87

Coagulant dosage (mg/L)

2
4
6
150
172
178
155
150
158

* Initial turbidity 16.2 NTU, initial absorbance at 254nm 0.120, pH of treated sample 7.78

coagulation performance in water treatment has

started recently.

flocculant aid in the case of PACl (in

concentrations equal to 1/10 of PACl
concentrations), whereas in the case of PACPE no
flocculant aid was added. Both examined
coagulants are efficient in turbidity removal.
Significant differences can be observed in
absorbance removal, where PACPE exhibits better
performance. It can be noticed that even with
relatively low dosage of coagulants (2 mg/L), the
absorbance removal is over 80% with PACPE,
whereas with PACl the respective removal is 70%.
Moreover, the residual Al concentration is
much lower in the case of PACPE, especially for
the dosages of 4 and 6 mg/L. The most important
advantage however, is related with the amount of
PE used in both cases. Particularly, it was noticed
that with 30% less PE, the performance of PACPE
was better than the respective performance of
PACl. Not only the two treatment steps
(coagulation-flocculation) were combined in one,
but better treatment was achieved with lower
amounts of polyelectrolyte, pointing out not only
the superior coagulation performance, but also the
cost effectiveness related with the use of the new
composite coagulation agents.
The improved properties of the composite
coagulants with polyelectrolytes can be devoted to
the better flocculation properties, compared to the
conventional coagulants, similarly with the case of
PASiC. Figure 2 illustrates the results of the
examination of coagulation kinetics for the
aforementioned in the coagulation experiments prepolymerized and composite coagulants. The flocs
growth (presented as Ratio values), relatively to

70

Abs removal (%)

65

60

55

50
0

10

15

20

Al/Si molar ratio

Fig. 1. Absorbance removal after treating a

synthetic wastewater sample with PACl and several
polyaluminium
silicate
chlorides
reagents.
Concentration of coagulants 50 mg/L, initial
absorbance at 254 nm 1.38, pH 7.45.
Table 3 illustrates the comparative results of
kaolin-humic acid model suspension (simulated
surface water) treatment with laboratory prepared
PACl (OH/Al= 2) and a composite coagulant
prepared with the incorporation of a non-ionic
polyacrylamide (Magnaflock LT-20) in PACl
(OH/Al = 2). This specific polymer is used in water
treatment facilities in Greece, whereas the
respective Al/Si ratio (mg/L) in the final product
(PACPE) was 15. The coagulation experiments
were conducted with the use of the same PE as

ISSN: 1790-5095

315

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

time (sec) is presented. Two distinct effects can be

noticed, due to PE addition in the PACl reagent.
The first is related with the time needed for the
flocs to growth, the so-called lag phase. It is
evident, that in the case of the composite coagulant
the lag phase is significantly limited. The latter is
related with the extent of flocs growth, and
specifically with the respective maximum Ratio
values achieved with the two coagulants. Higher
Ratio values indicate greater flocs size [25],
therefore it can be concluded that with the
composite coagulant bigger flocs are formed.

determination of the specific properties that imply

superior coagulation performance. Coagulants with
different basicities and/or additives content may
have different applications (water/wastewater
treatment). Moreover, suggestions for the
preparation of new reagents appear in the literature
continually, i.e. different combinations of Al and
Fe in one reagent and possible addition in a second
step of an inorganic or organic compound.
Acknowledgements
Thanks are due to the Greek Ministry of
Development (General Secretariat for Research and
Technology) which supported this research through
the PENED program (25%) and to the European
Union, which co-founded this program (75%). This
research is part of the Ph.D. Thesis of N.D.
Tzoupanos.

4.0
3.5

Ratio

3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5

References:

1.0

PACl 2
PACPE

0.5

[1]
Bratby, J. (ed), Coagulants, in Coagulation
and Flocculation in Water and Wastewater
Treatment, second ed., IWA Publishing, London,
2006, pp. 50-68.
[2]
Duan, J., Gregory, J., Coagulation by
hydrolysing metal salts, Advances in Colloid &
Interface Science, Vol. 100-102, 2003, pp. 475502.
[3]
J.C. Crittenden, R.R. Trussel, D.W. Hand,
K.J. Howe, G. Tchobanoglous (eds), Coagulation,
mixing and flocculation, in: Water Treatment:
Principles and Design, second ed., John Wiley &
Sons, New Jersey, 2005, pp. 643-779.
[4]
S. Sinha, Y. Yoon, G. Amy, J. Yoon,
Determining the effectiveness of conventional and
alternative
coagulants
through
effective
characterization schemes, Chemosphere, Vol. 57,
2004, pp. 1115-1122.
[5]
Z. Jia, F. He, Z. Liu, Synthesis of
polyaluminium chloride with a membrane reactor:
operating parameter effects and reaction pathways,
Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research,
Vol. 43, 2004, pp. 12-17.
[6]
Parker, D.R. and Bertsch, P.M., Formation
of the Al13 tridecameric polycation under diverse
synthesis conditions, Environmental Science &
Technology, Vol. 26, 2002, pp. 914-921.
[7]
Bi, S., Wang, C., Cao, Q. and Zhang, C.,
Studies on the mechanism of hydrolysis and
polymerization of aluminium salts in aqueous
solution: correlations between the Core-links model

0.0
0

200

400

600

800

time (sec)

1000

1200

1400

Figure 2. Kinetics of coagulation of the Al-based

coagulants.

5.

Conclusions

The application of the new generation of

coagulation reagents exhibits several advantages,
compared to the conventional and simple prepolymerized coagulants. The incorporation of
various additives, inorganic or organic, results in an
increment of molecular weight and components
size, which compensates efficiently the decrease of
charge neutralization capability in the new
coagulants. Overall they present better treatment
performance, lower residual metal concentration
and wider effective pH range, which are the main
advantages of the composite coagulants. In the case
of composite coagulants with polyelectrolytes, the
economical benefits should also be taken into
consideration.
However,
despite
the
aforementioned
advantages of newly prepared coagulants, the
research in the coagulation-flocculation field is
continuing. Optimalization of the preparation
conditions is needed, especially in the case of
composite coagulants with organic additives, and

ISSN: 1790-5095

316

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8

6th IASME/WSEAS International Conference on HEAT TRANSFER, THERMAL ENGINEERING and ENVIRONMENT (HTE'08)
Rhodes, Greece, August 20-22, 2008

and Cage-like keggin-Al13 model, Coordination

Chemistry Reviews, Vol. 248, 2004, pp. 441-455.
[8]
Wang, M. and Muhammed, M., Novel
synthesis of Al13-cluster based alumina materials,
NanoStructured Materials, Vol. 11, 1999, pp.
1219-1229.
[9]
Gao, B.Y., Hahn, H.H., Hoffmann, E.,
Evaluation
of
aluminum-silicate
polymer
composite as a coagulant for water treatment,
Water Research, Vol. 36, 2002, pp. 3573-3581.
[10]
Hasegawa, T., Hashimoto, K., Onitsuka,
T., Goto, K., Tambo, N., Characteristics of metalpolysilicate coagulants, Water Science &
Technology, Vol. 23, 1990, pp. 1713-1722.
[11]
Chan, S.H., A review on solubility and
polymerization of silica, Geothermics, Vol. 18,
1989, pp. 49-56.
[12]
Stumm, W., Huper, H., Champlin, L.,
Formation of polysilicates as determined by
coagulation effects, Environmental Science &
Technology, Vol. 1, 1967, pp. 221-227.
[13]
Dietzel, M., Dissolution of silicates and the
stability of polysilicic acid, Geochimica et
Cosmochimica Acta, Vol. 64, 2000, pp. 3275-3281.
[14]
Zouboulis A.I. and Tzoupanos, N.D.,
Polyaluminium Silicate Chloride a systematic
study for the preparation and application of an
efficient coagulant for water or wastewater
treatment, Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2008,
in press.
[15]
Cheng, P.C., Chi, F.G., Yu, R.F., Shi, P.Z.,
Evaluating the coagulants of polyaluminium
silicate chlorides on turbidity removal, Separation
Science & Technology, Vol. 41, 2005, pp. 297-309.
[16]
B.Y. Gao, Q.Y. Yue, B.J. Wang, The
chemical species distribution and transformation of
polyaluminium silicate chloride coagulant,
Chemosphere, Vol. 46, 2002, pp. 809-813.
[17]
Song, Y.H., Luan, Z.K., Tang, H.X.,
Preparation and characterisation of polyaluminium
silicate
chloride
coagulant,
Environmental
Technology, Vol. 24, 2003, pp. 319-327.

ISSN: 1790-5095

[18]
Bache, D.B. and Gregory, R. (eds) Flocs in
Water Treatment, IWA Publishing, 2007, London,
UK.
[19]
Kim, Y.H. (ed.), Coagulants and
Flocculants; Theory and Practice, Tall Oaks
Publishing, 1995, Littleton, USA.
[20]
Tang, H., Shi, B., The characteristics of
composite flocculants synthesized with inorganic
polyaluminum and organic polymers, in Hahn, H.,
Hoffmann, E., Odegaard, H. (eds) Chemical Water
and Wastewater Treatment VII, Proc. of the 10th
Gothenburg Symposium 2002, IWA Publishing,
Gothenburg, Sweden, 2002, pp. 17-28.
[21]
Gao B-Y., Wang Y., Yue Q-Y., The
chemical species distribution of aluminiumin
composite flocculants prepared from polyaluminum
chloride (PAC) and Polydimethyldiallylammonium
chloride (PDMDAAC), Acta Hydrochimica et
Hydrobiologica, Vol. 33, No 4, 2005, pp. 365-371.
[22]
Gao, B.-Y., Wang, Y., Yue, Q.-Y., Wei, J.C., Li, Q., Color removal from simulated dye water
and actual textile wastewater using a composite
coagulant prepared by polyferric chloride and polydimethyldiallylammonium chloride, Separation
and Purification Technology, Vol. 54, 2007, pp.
157-163.
[23]
Zouboulis, A.I., Tzoupanos .D., Moussas,
P.A., Inorganic Pre-Polymerised Coagulants:
Current Status and Future Trends, 3rd
IASME/WSEAS International Conference, S.
Nikolaos, Greece, 24-26 July 2007, pp. 292-300.
[24]
Tzoupanos, N.D., Zouboulis A.I., Zhao Y.C., The application of novel coagulant reagent
(polyaluminium silicate chloride) for the posttreatment of landfill leachates. Chemosphere, 2008,
in press.
[25]
Zouboulis, A.I., G. Traskas, Comparable
evaluation of various commercially available
aluminum-based coagulants for the treatment of
surface water and for the post-treatment of urban
wastewater, Journal of Chemical Technology &
Biotechnology, Vol. 80, 2005, pp. 1136-1147.

317

ISBN: 978-960-6766-97-8