Attrition
Attrition
Attrition
REASONS AND
WAYS TO
CONTROL
ATTRITION
1
Submitted by:
Anisha Aggarwal
Anubha agarwal
Kanika Arora
Pallavi Singh
Sujata
Swarna Sharma
Group 7, section E
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We would like to thank Mrs. Netra Ray HR executive at HCL Pvt.Ltd. (BPO) sector 16,
Noida for providing us with information about the reasons for attrition and the steps that
are being followed by them and for bearing with our endless questions.
We are grateful to Professor J.R Sharma for his support and guidance and for giving us an
opportunity to work on this report.
At last we would like to thank our family and friends for their encouragement, motivation
and support.
3
CONTENTS
S.NO PARTICULARS
PAGE NO
3). Introduction
6
9). Conclusion 28
10). Recommendations
29
11). Bibliography
32
5
OBJECTIVE
To find out the rate of attrition and what are the reasons for the same
and how to cope up with it.
PURPOSE
Overall attrition rates are continuing to rise in Asia. The aggregate rate
across all markets reached 18 percent in 2007, marking a two percent
increase on 2006. Meanwhile budgeted attrition, which remained lower
than actual attrition, rose slightly from 10 to 11 percent year on year.
7
At 39 percent, overall employee turnover was highest at the
professional /supervisor/ technical level. Unsurprisingly, attrition was
lowest among senior/top management at just 0.5 percent. The Banking
and Finance sector saw the greatest employee turnover at 25 percent,
while the lowest turnover was recorded in the manufacturing industry
at 11 percent.
Introduction
8
(banking, financial services and insurance) vertical and 35 per cent in
BPO (business process outsourcing). Attracting and retaining key talent
has become one of the key drivers of overall business performance in
organizations and companies have been utilizing a diverse range of
methods to draw in new hires and ensure they stay as Attrition is an
expensive phenomenon, potentially impacting the bottom line of
businesses.
The cost of attrition is not just the loss of that employee but it includes
an array of hidden costs such as recruitment costs, selection costs,
training costs, cost of covering during the period and opportunity
costs.
The organizational costs associated with the turnover in terms of
hiring, training and productivity loss costs can add up to more than five
per cent of an organization’s operating costs.
As far as India is concerned, attrition is a serious trend, especially in
today’s knowledge-driven marketplace where people are the most
important assets. While organizations cope with attrition by devising
compelling retention strategies, it is imperative for organizations to
predict attrition early in the recruitment process to curtail loss of time,
cost and effort.
9
BACKGROUND
First of all we need to know what attrition exactly is. Attrition is the
rate of shrinkage in the size or a gradual, natural reduction in
membership or personnel, as through retirement, resignation,
or death. It is Normal and uncontrollable reduction of a work force
because of retirement, death, sickness, and relocation. It is one
method of reducing the size of a work force without management
taking any overt actions. The drawback to reduction by attrition is that
reductions are often unpredictable and can leave gaps in an
organization.
The formula for calculating attrition rate is;-
Attrition Rate% =
10
fluctuates from industry to industry and at different levels. Attrition by
Employee Group
According to the study, the overall employee turnover rate was highest
at the professional/supervisor/technical staff level, recording total and
voluntary attrition at a very high 39 percent and 33 percent
respectively. (See Figure 1)
11
We have examined two important sectors in which the attrition rate is
high i.e. BPO/IT industry and pharmaceutical industry, and we have
focused basically at middle level of employees where the rate is
highest. Lastly, this report will explain what can be done to control the
attrition in both these sectors. And what are the measures that are
taken up by other companies.
2).
12
13
BPO Industry in India
It is said that the Indian BPO Industry has come of age. This is very
true if we analyze both the past and present scenarios. Defying all the
permutations and combinations, the Indian outsourcing industry has
registered a massive growth over the years. India has remained one of
the most favorite offshore destinations for BPO/ITES activities. One of
the most prominent reasons for the same is cheap labor. Over the past
five years, the Indian BPO/ITES has been growing at a rate of about 50-
60%. As per NASSCOM, the Indian BPO/ITES registered a growth rate of
46% and clocked revenue of UD$ 3.6 billion in 2003-04 up from UD$
2.5 billion in 2002-03.This industry has contributed a great deal to the
export revenues of the country and is expected to do that in future too.
14
Pharmaceutical industry in India
The Indian Pharmaceutical Industry today is in the front rank of
India’s science-based industries with wide ranging capabilities in the
complex field of drug manufacture and technology. A highly organized
sector, the Indian Pharma Industry is estimated to be worth $ 4.5
billion, growing at about 8 to 9 percent annually. It ranks very high in
the third world, in terms of technology, quality and range of medicines
manufactured. From simple headache pills to sophisticated antibiotics
and complex cardiac compounds, almost every type of medicine is now
made indigenously.
According to the Economic Survey (2006-07), the pharmaceuticals
industry had achieved a turnover of about US$ 12 billion in 2005-06,
and is expected to grow by 13% in 2007. Its pharma export value
reached about US$ 4.7 billion during 2005-06.Pharmaceutical
industry accounts for about 2.91% of total FDI into the country. The
FDI in pharmaceutical sector is estimated to have touched US$ 172
million, thereby showing a compounded annual growth rate of about
62.6%. Drugs and pharmaceuticals sector is at 8th rank in India's
top 10 FDI attracting sectors. According to the Economic Survey for
the year 2006-07, the value of pharma output has increased ten
times over the last 15 years.
15
From Rs. 50 billion in 1990 it has grown to Rs.550 billion (US$ 12
billion) in 2005-06. Driven by growing number of pharmaceutical
units, increased knowledge skills, improved quality and increasing
national as well as international demand, India is now recognized as a
leading global pharma player.
1
Facts and figures taken from www.pharmainfo.net.
16
strong financial markets. There is already an established
international industry and business community.
d) Information & Technology: It has a good network of
world-class educational institutions and established
strengths in Information Technology.
e) Globalization: The country is committed to a free market
economy and globalization. Above all, it has a 70 million
middle class market, which is continuously growing.
f) Consolidation: For the first time in many years, the
international pharmaceutical and outsourcing industry is
finding great opportunities in India. The process of
consolidation, which has become a generalized
phenomenon in the world pharmaceutical industry, has
started taking place in India.
COST OF ATTRITION
There are a number of costs which are incurred by a BPO when they
hire any new employee. These costs can be in terms of monetary or
can be in terms of time wasted or any other intangible things. Some of
these costs can be as stated below: -
Costs Due to a Person Leaving
17
I. Recruitment Costs
18
III. Lost Productivity Costs
19
1. Calculate the revenue per employee by dividing total company
revenue by the average number of employees in a given year.
Whether an employee contributes directly or indirectly to the
generation of revenue, their purpose is to provide some defined
set of responsibilities that are necessary to the generation of
revenue. Calculate the lost revenue by multiplying the number of
weeks the position is vacant by the average weekly revenue per
employee.
Thus we can say that if a person leaves a job company has to suffer
losses as it involves many costs.
FACTORS
The main factors of attrition in both sectors are as follows:
1) External inequity of compensation
2) Work Timings
The work timings in BPO are very odd. This affects the family life of the
employee. Moreover, the male to female ratio in BPO is quiet low. The
number of females in BPO can be as large as 35%. This means that
working hour problem is quiet acute in their case especially after they
20
get married, as after marriage comes social and family pressure to
adjust work timings and take care of families.
3) Career Growth
Only 2 out of 10 employees on an average go on to be at the senior
level. This means that other employees look forward to change their
job at other places where they can get better opportunities to
progress. Also, another problem arises with the mis-match of
expectations and qualifications of the employees. Along with that,
some employees see no career growth in this sector, so they move on
to other companies in search of changing the sector.
4) Higher Education
This is a problem as most of the employees in this sector are pretty
young and aspiring. They join the firm because of lucrative salary. But
with time, they try to move on to other sectors or top management
and one of the ways to do this is higher education
5) Role stagnation
21
companies where they can play different roles and handle
responsibility.
7) Lack of recognition
When an employee feels that he is not getting due recognition for his
achievement, a feeling of demotivation creeps into him, and this can
cause him to consider leaving the organization. Employees have an
expectation that when they work well, they will get some recognition
from their managers in the form of a personal appreciation or an award
etc.
8) Under-utilization of skills
22
up the career ladder and when their skills and potential is being
overlooked they end up with leaving the job.
9) Performance assessment
Internal inequity occurs when the employee feels that the amount of
efforts he puts in to do his job are much more than what rewards he
gets in return for them. This can cause him to feel de-motivated and
nurture feelings of dissatisfaction and eventually resign from his post.
11)Business instability
23
Many a times, when the organization faces some kind of instability or
uncertainty with regards to operations, an employee might quit his job
before he is asked to leave. Many a times when employees get a whim
that the organization is going to down-size or is going to be taken over
by another company, they tend to feel safer quitting the job than
worrying about whether the organization will retain them.
Providing quality at work not only reduces attrition but also helps in
reduced absenteeism and improved job satisfaction. Not only does
QWL contribute to a company's ability to recruit quality people, but
also it enhances a company's competitiveness. Common beliefs
support the contention that QWL will positively nurture a more
flexible, loyal, and motivated workforce, which are essential in
28
determining the company's competitiveness.
29
10). Office-Tiger: A Role Model BPO to Follow
According to Office-Tiger model it tries is to instill a sense of pride
in its employees. Make the employees feel proud of doing the work
they do. Every project given to them is converted to a challenge
which drives away the monotony that creeps into the job. Every
employee is given a feel that the work given to him or her is very
important. Moreover, there should be a rigorous recruitment
process. After that the employees undergo an induction program
where they hone their various skills. Employees work on live
projects and if, during their project work, they feel that some
improvement is needed, they can go back to that stage of training.
This helps the employee continuously improve himself. Also,
employees are given encouragement to become Financial Analysts
or Research Analysts.
11) Communication
30
3). FEED BACK SYSTEM
Straight-from-the-shoulder communication is
what the employees need from their employers. Employees look
for organizations where communication and process are
transparent. Nothing is hidden and shared with the employees.
Communication mediums
32
INITIATIVES TAKEN BY OTHER COMPANIES TO
REDUCE ATTRITION
33
career choice and as these employees have young children it
becomes necessary for companies to provide adequate facilities
34
Intel Technology has a direct communication programme
running, wherein the president, Intel Technology India, is meeting
all the employees face to face in small groups. The CEO also
maintains accessibility through blogging. They have an internal
committee to ensure retention of highly qualified employees by
offering them alternative groups to work in. Also, consultants
were hired to find jobs in other organizations for the employees
who were made to leave the company.
Adobe India promotes the spirit of research by giving moral and
financial support to employees who have business ideas. The
company then decides whether or not to approve the idea. If the
idea is successful, the company absorbs it into its business; else
the employee goes back to the usual job. The programme is
extremely popular among the employees, and fresh ideas come
in daily
35
INTERPRETATION AND ANALYSIS
37
Conclusion
With the strong growth expected in the Indian economy going ahead, it
is clear that human resources will be the key competitive advantage if
the country has to sustain this robust growth. Tackling attrition is not
38
an easy task and the strategies suggested in the report are not
exhaustive to retain the human capital of BPOs. These are just the
basics and if implemented in a proper way can give good Results, but it
can only become effective when both employee & employer
understand the importance of these precautionary measures &
continuously follow them only then this emerging & growing sector
will give its proper results.
39
Recommendations
After a detailed analysis of both the industries we find that a key step
in designing an effective retention strategy is to ensure you have the
right tools to gauge employee engagement. Investing in the
measurement of employee engagement is a key element of building
the type of high-performance culture that drives business. According to
the study, regular or formal employee interaction with managers and
interaction with human resources are the two most common ways of
gauging engagement levels in organizations. We recommend the
following points to be followed:
➢ Salary structure
40
Basic (54%),
HRA (26%),
Medical Reimbursement (8%),
Management Supplement (12%),
PF Contribution (actual),
Tiffin Allowance (Rs 25-30 per day of attendance),
Attendance Bonus (Rs 500-1000 per month),
Loyalty Bonus (1 months’ salary after completion of each year in
the company),
Performance Incentives (linked to specific performance criteria),
Referral Allowance (Rs 2000-3000 per candidate referred and
recruited).
➢ The EEE-Model
Exposure, Experience and Education are three things which are vital to
any employee in any sector or industry. These needs of the employees
are needed to be taken care of for an employee to feel motivated
An employee expects the company to give him good exposure in the
kind of work he is doing. Not only this, he needs to get a good
experience working in the company from its top management and
colleagues. Monthly dinner with CEO of bonding programs with the
other employees of the BPO would be a good idea.
42
BIBLIOGRAPHY
➢ www.citeman.com
➢ www.naukrihub.com
➢ www.pharmainfo.net
➢ www.pharmaceutical-drug-manufacturer.com
➢ www.investopedia.com
➢ The Hindu 14 July 2008, Monday, business (newspaper).
➢ Hewitt’s attrition and retention report 2006...
➢ Stephens Robbins, Organizational behavior, Pearson education
( 2008) ,page 234.
43