Sean Barrs 's Reviews > Fevre Dream
Fevre Dream
by
by
Sean Barrs 's review
bookshelves: fantasy, darkness-horror-gothic, 3-star-reads
Jan 17, 2014
bookshelves: fantasy, darkness-horror-gothic, 3-star-reads
Read 2 times. Last read December 15, 2015.
Abner March looks strangely like George R.R Martin. They are both overweight men. They both have long beards and wear sea captain’s hats. I’m not sure who came first. Perhaps Martin modelled the character off of his own appearance or perhaps he liked his creation so much that he was compelled to try the style himself. It’s a little bit weird really, though the book is still quite good even if the protagonist is somewhat laughable in his resemblance of his creator.
This is the French cover:
They just look very similar.
A tub full of blood
George R.R Martin Abner Marsh is a steamboat captain and he, quite naturally, longs for a majestic steamer that will outpace all others. But, he has no money. Conversely, Joshua York is a very, very, rich man who needs a boat to help him conduct his nocturnal lifestyle. He lacks the skills of the trade, so the two pair up. They provide the other with what he lacks though creating a mutually beneficial friendship. Abner gets his boat and Joshua gets his hideout; they both win.
Well, not entirely because Joshua has a dark past. His is a vampire. I think he is characterised superbly in this; he is strong and intense, but at the same time he is open and capable. With his dark powers he could carry out great evil, if he so chose, but he has transcended the limitations of his body and become a morally superior being in the process. He has devised a way to satisfy his thirst without harming anyone. He is a good vampire rather than the demonic blood sucking maniacs that infest this world. And when these said maniacs begin to sniff around Abner’s boat, the two friends have their dreams crushed. So much for a lovely steamboat adventure, the very walls turn red in the action.
A pointless bad guy
Now here comes the book’s massive hindrance. Its antagonist, Damien Julien, is an ancient vampire and his ethos is in direct contrast to Joshua’s. He loves blood and he doesn’t care who he tears open to get it. The man’s practically a god. He’s top of the food chain. He can have what he wants when he wants it. He is a typical vampire; he is dark and brooding, but he is also fundamentally flawed. He has no reason to exist. As he himself admits, he has no reason for anything. He just does it because he can. I think for him to be a more effective and dramatic opponent of Joshua’s, he needed to have a dark motive or a hidden evil that drove him. At the moment he has no reason to do anything.
I found him to be completely disappointing. He had no drive or passion even to do evil. He just does it. The character could have been so much more than he was. I’d rather he was just a basic evil architype than this. It would have been better if he just wanted to rule the world or something. At least that way, he would have a reason to get out of bed at night (see what I did there!) Joshua and Abner were well rounded characters whose actions actually had a reason. They saved the book in my estimation even if the final conflicts were a little bit flat. It should have been a battle of polar opposites.
A good three stars
This is the French cover:
They just look very similar.
A tub full of blood
Well, not entirely because Joshua has a dark past. His is a vampire. I think he is characterised superbly in this; he is strong and intense, but at the same time he is open and capable. With his dark powers he could carry out great evil, if he so chose, but he has transcended the limitations of his body and become a morally superior being in the process. He has devised a way to satisfy his thirst without harming anyone. He is a good vampire rather than the demonic blood sucking maniacs that infest this world. And when these said maniacs begin to sniff around Abner’s boat, the two friends have their dreams crushed. So much for a lovely steamboat adventure, the very walls turn red in the action.
A pointless bad guy
Now here comes the book’s massive hindrance. Its antagonist, Damien Julien, is an ancient vampire and his ethos is in direct contrast to Joshua’s. He loves blood and he doesn’t care who he tears open to get it. The man’s practically a god. He’s top of the food chain. He can have what he wants when he wants it. He is a typical vampire; he is dark and brooding, but he is also fundamentally flawed. He has no reason to exist. As he himself admits, he has no reason for anything. He just does it because he can. I think for him to be a more effective and dramatic opponent of Joshua’s, he needed to have a dark motive or a hidden evil that drove him. At the moment he has no reason to do anything.
I found him to be completely disappointing. He had no drive or passion even to do evil. He just does it. The character could have been so much more than he was. I’d rather he was just a basic evil architype than this. It would have been better if he just wanted to rule the world or something. At least that way, he would have a reason to get out of bed at night (see what I did there!) Joshua and Abner were well rounded characters whose actions actually had a reason. They saved the book in my estimation even if the final conflicts were a little bit flat. It should have been a battle of polar opposites.
A good three stars
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Fevre Dream.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
(Other Paperback Edition)
January 17, 2014
– Shelved
May 27, 2015
– Shelved as:
fantasy
Started Reading
December 15, 2015
– Shelved as:
comic-graphic-novel
(Other Paperback Edition)
December 15, 2015
– Shelved
(Other Paperback Edition)
December 15, 2015
–
Finished Reading
December 31, 2015
– Shelved as:
darkness-horror-gothic
March 9, 2016
– Shelved as:
3-star-reads
Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)
date
newest »
Erin (Paperbackstash) wrote: "I never compared their appearance much, but you're right.
I love that French cover...creepy. The other artwork is good too."
They are quite good. I'm half tempted to give the graphic novel a try
I love that French cover...creepy. The other artwork is good too."
They are quite good. I'm half tempted to give the graphic novel a try
I thought Damien Julian was the worst kind of evil and that he didn't need a motive. Those who do bad deeds for no other reason, except that they can will always be more terrifying than someone with a motive. They are the truly depraved ones. The antagonist in Othello is exactly like this and he is by far my favorite villain.
I thought Damon's character was very well described. You're right he had no motive, and that was pointed out when Sour Billy was running the plantation and steamboat while Damon just reclused in his library. He had lost all interest and ambition, and therefore fed on people to live on their lives. Despite his disinterest and yearning to end his own life, a beast resided deep within that would still fight to live-I found all of that made for a really good monster.
I thought by far the best thing about Julian, and probably the book overall, was his complete lack of any motivation. It made for a strangely alien figure that's terrible in every sense of the word. The descriptions probably help immensely. I think he's likened to a tsunami or hurricane at one point. He is directionless and ambitionless but he's also powerful. Truly dangerous. His existence put the lives of both races at risk. There is no arguing with him. No imprisoning him. No rationalising with him. Killing him is the only way he can be stopped which does make him a pretty good foil to York who believes in life above all else. Life with a goal and something to strive for on top of that. I don't think they would have been more polar opposite if Damien was a generic bad guy that wanted to rule the world.
Haha it's even funnier when you realize this book was written in 1982! I guess he liked the character's look. Great review! 😁
Marsh/Martin observation is an interesting one.
I have a slightly different theory on their likeness.
That perhaps, Martin was always a steamboat fan since his youth. Maybe grew up picturing himself from deck hand to captain. Kids and there imaginations. Being obsessed and noticing the style and similarities boat Captains tend to have...this influenced his personal style. Then in adulthood wrote a story using the features he was familiar with, which he undertook in his own style. So not directly imagining himself as Marsh, but both himself and Marsh styled after his observations of Ship captains of that era. Thus the similarities.
I have a slightly different theory on their likeness.
That perhaps, Martin was always a steamboat fan since his youth. Maybe grew up picturing himself from deck hand to captain. Kids and there imaginations. Being obsessed and noticing the style and similarities boat Captains tend to have...this influenced his personal style. Then in adulthood wrote a story using the features he was familiar with, which he undertook in his own style. So not directly imagining himself as Marsh, but both himself and Marsh styled after his observations of Ship captains of that era. Thus the similarities.
I love that French cover...creepy. The other artwork is good too.