Discover new books on Goodreads
Meet your next favorite book
James's Reviews > War Is a Racket
War Is a Racket
by
by
James's review
bookshelves: culture-and-politics, economics, history, memoirs, military, literature
Feb 18, 2008
bookshelves: culture-and-politics, economics, history, memoirs, military, literature
A scathing condemnation of the corporate-military complex by a quirky retired general who was one of the biggest legends and role models in the U.S. Marine Corps; Smedley Butler, nicknamed "Old Gimlet Eye," had a tattoo of the USMC emblem that covered his chest and was the only Marine officer to win the Medal of Honor twice, America's highest decoration for both effectiveness and outrageous courage in combat (a high percentage of Medals of Honor must be awarded posthumously; you can't do something that will win this medal and have any realistic expectation of living through it even once.)
However, after retiring, he came to the conclusion that much of the fighting he had done had ultimately served the interests not of the American people or the people of the countries where he fought, but those of big businesses such as the United Fruit Company. He refers to it as a racket in the sense that the corporate world that pulls the strings of the U.S. government uses the American military as muscle essentially the same way as organized crime uses its low-ranking members.
Butler was not a pacifist - he advocated a true department of defense, staffed, organized, stationed, and equipped so as to protect America but not to create or maintain an empire.
He showed his integrity once again in retirement, when a group of industrialists, concerned by the Depression and outraged by FDR's New Deal programs, planned to carry out a coup, overthrow the government, and put a puppet "president" in office. They asked Butler to lead their coup and be that puppet president. Instead, he immediately turned them in, pointing out that he had sworn a lifelong oath to support and defend the Constitution. One of my heroes.
I encourage anyone contemplating military service to read this, to see another side than they've probably been shown - we do need armed forces, so the right thing to do may indeed be to enter or stay in the military. But it should be an informed decision.
However, after retiring, he came to the conclusion that much of the fighting he had done had ultimately served the interests not of the American people or the people of the countries where he fought, but those of big businesses such as the United Fruit Company. He refers to it as a racket in the sense that the corporate world that pulls the strings of the U.S. government uses the American military as muscle essentially the same way as organized crime uses its low-ranking members.
Butler was not a pacifist - he advocated a true department of defense, staffed, organized, stationed, and equipped so as to protect America but not to create or maintain an empire.
He showed his integrity once again in retirement, when a group of industrialists, concerned by the Depression and outraged by FDR's New Deal programs, planned to carry out a coup, overthrow the government, and put a puppet "president" in office. They asked Butler to lead their coup and be that puppet president. Instead, he immediately turned them in, pointing out that he had sworn a lifelong oath to support and defend the Constitution. One of my heroes.
I encourage anyone contemplating military service to read this, to see another side than they've probably been shown - we do need armed forces, so the right thing to do may indeed be to enter or stay in the military. But it should be an informed decision.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
War Is a Racket.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
January 1, 2003
–
Finished Reading
February 18, 2008
– Shelved
February 18, 2008
– Shelved as:
culture-and-politics
February 18, 2008
– Shelved as:
economics
February 18, 2008
– Shelved as:
history
February 18, 2008
– Shelved as:
memoirs
February 18, 2008
– Shelved as:
military
April 17, 2009
– Shelved as:
literature
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)
date
newest »
Yeah. It's just a good thing that conspiracy didn't go to MacArthur instead, because he'd have jumped at it.
Thanks for the biographical details of this very interesting individual. Is there a biography that you would recommend?
I saw a reenactment of his famous speech in front of the American Bund in NYC with the George Washington flag. They interposed the real speech at the end. Shocking. Let me ponder what movie. Was good.
Amsterdam is a 2022 period mystery comedy thriller film directed, written, and co-produced by David O. Russell and starring Christian Bale (who also co-produced), Margot Robbie, and John David Washington alongside an ensemble supporting cast including Chris Rock, Anya Taylor-Joy, Zoe Saldaña, Mike Myers, Michael ...
Along with the bonus marchers. And countless other examples of what he wrote about.