Enclave
By Ann Aguirre
4/5
()
Survival
Friendship
Post-Apocalyptic World
Trust
Self-Discovery
Found Family
Dystopian Society
Post-Apocalyptic Survival
Chosen One
Strong Female Protagonist
Unlikely Allies
Journey of Self-Discovery
Post-Apocalyptic Wasteland
Fish Out of Water
Mentor Figure
Exploration
Fear
Danger
Adventure
Courage
About this ebook
New York City has been decimated by war and plague, and most of civilization has migrated to underground enclaves, where life expectancy is no more than the early 20's. When Deuce turns 15, she takes on her role as a Huntress, and is paired with Fade, a teenage Hunter who lived Topside as a young boy. When she and Fade discover that the neighboring enclave has been decimated by the tunnel monsters--or Freaks--who seem to be growing more organized, the elders refuse to listen to warnings. And when Deuce and Fade are exiled from the enclave, the girl born in darkness must survive in daylight--guided by Fade's long-ago memories--in the ruins of a city whose population has dwindled to a few dangerous gangs.
Ann Aguirre's thrilling young adult novel is the story of two young people in an apocalyptic world--facing dangers, and feelings, unlike any they've ever known.
Ann Aguirre
Ann Aguirre is a national bestselling author with a degree in English Literature. She writes urban fantasy, romantic science fiction, paranormal romance and dystopian young adult fiction.
Read more from Ann Aguirre
The Shape of My Heart Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsHonor Among Thieves Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I Want It That Way Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsHonor Bound Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5As Long As You Love Me Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsTill The World Ends: Dawn of Eden / Thistle & Thorne / Sun Storm Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Third Mrs. Durst Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Forbidden Fruit Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratings
Related to Enclave
Related ebooks
Partials Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Sky Inside Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Article 5 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Rebel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Forget Tomorrow Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Pledge Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Blue Tide Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Tarnished Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Ruins Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Pulse Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Disruption Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Struck Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Roar and Liv Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Forsaken: The Forsaken Trilogy Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Children of Eden: A Novel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wither Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Taking Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Diabolic Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Cold Falling White Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Pulse Point Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Bone Dressing Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Sunrise Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Isolation Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Unravel Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5This Mortal Coil Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Body Institute Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Ashen Winter Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Blackout Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5
YA Science Fiction For You
Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Uglies Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Giver: A Newbery Award Winner Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Toll Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Gleanings: Stories from the Arc of a Scythe Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Last Magician Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Find Me Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Unite Me Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Thunderhead Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5See You Yesterday Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Reveal Me Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Library of Souls: The Third Novel of Miss Peregrine's Peculiar Children Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Shadow Me Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Do-Over Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Gone Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Pretties Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5InterWorld Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5I Am Number Four Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Hollow City: The Second Novel of Miss Peregrine's Peculiar Children Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Unwind Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Level Up or Die: A LitRPG Steampunk Adventure: Level Up or Die, #1 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Monkey Man Rating: 2 out of 5 stars2/5
Reviews for Enclave
759 ratings109 reviews
What our readers think
Readers find this title to be an amazing and creative dystopian series. It is a great story that is a true pleasure to read. Many readers love this world and have read the trilogy multiple times. It is considered one of the top 5 favorite dystopian series by some. Overall, this book is just amazing.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The front of the book compared Enclave to The Hunger Games. That sets the standard for quality in a teen dystopia pretty darn high...and Aguirre totally came through! I was completely pulled into this world from the first pages. The writing, the plot and the characters are all fantastic. Book two will so be mine (and I totally want to acquire a copy of this one for my personal collection).
Zombies have been done before, of course, but these feel much more terrifying. They have the speed of any other predator and are learning, like in Aftertime. What they reminded me of more than anything actually were the morlocks from The Time Machine. Super creepy! And they're not the only terror: "I had begun to throb with the desire to understand why things happened, why some people lived under the ground, like our enclave, the Freaks, and the Burrowers, and why some stayed Topside and turned into the greatest monsters of all" (173).
Speaking of figuring out why things happened, that is something I would still like to know. That explanation has yet to appear. Thankfully, this does not come across as a lame attempt to increase my interest, but as a part of Deuce's journey that has not yet come. Deuce feels so real. The comparison to The Hunger Games lies largely in Deuce. We see from her perspective and she, like Katniss, cares first and foremost about survival. She doesn't really want to be involved in politics and relationships definitely confuse her. I am digging her love triangle, but have not firmly declared support for either team (Fade vs. Stalker), as both have promise.
To sum up, I loved this and recommend it to pretty much everyone who likes reading darker stuff, like dystopias. This one rocks, especially because the characters go to a library to research in their post-catastrophe world. Now that's awesome! Ann Aguirre is officially on my watch list. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5After a somewhat disappointing encounter with Grimspace a couple of years ago, I was wary about reading anything more from Aguirre, but the concept of this book intrigued me – so I decided to take the plunge. Well, it was quite a pleasant surprise: the story drew me in immediately, to the point that I finished the book over a weekend – and I decided to give the Jax saga another try, on the chance that I might have started it on an "off" day.
The second half of Enclave seemed a little hurried, though, and somewhat... unfinished, for want of a better word, as if the author were in a hurry to move forward to the next book: it felt particularly jarring after the fascinating details of life in the tunnels and the social dynamics created by that situation. My main point of contention comes from the addition of Stalker and the quick turnaround from wild-pack leader to useful team player: it seems a little contrived and IMHO it should have evolved over a longer time-span.
On the other hand, Deuce's "voice" is quite compelling and it drew me into the story very quickly, so all things considered this was a fascinating read, that made me interested in the sequel. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5I didn't love this book as much as I expected to. Most of the time I was pretty bored and started to skim read again. :/
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5This book is less dystopia and more post-apocalypse, with zombies thrown in - though they are never given that name. Though the plot focused solely on Deuce's life inside and outside the enclave, I was much more curious about the details of the world that Deuce lived in. The answers to these questions were sadly few and far between. It quickly became apparent that it was not in Deuce's nature to be inquisitive, and I was often distracted from Deuce's single-mindedness to be a Huntress. Deuce's two closest friends come from the other two groups, but little is told about these groups or the members that populated them. I was especially curious about Deuce's Breeder friend, who fathered a baby boy, but he is unfortunately removed from the plot before much development could occur.
Many loose threads are pushed aside to make way for the character of Fade, and Deuce's relationship with him. I saw much potential in Fade's character because of the potential of his backstory, but the possibilities of what he could accomplish in the enclave are wasted. In the end, despite the title of the book, the plot seems to be more about what happens Topside than saving or reforming the enclave. Plus, I know little more about the Freaks (zombies) than I did when I started the book. While the book brimmed with potential, much of the characters' potential was unrealized, and the book ended with too many loose ends and unanswered questions. While I typically love YA literature, I think this book was too juvenile for me. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I got this book from Goodreads First Read program and at first I have some reservations about the book since it is "sci-fi" in a way and a not-so-catching title (sorry) but I was really surprised. From the 2nd or 3rd chapter the book already connected with me. It was actually pretty good. It was exciting and action-packed and I would love to see it in big screen (3D!haha) Book has a nice concept/plot and highly imaginative. However, I do wish there was a brief description of what happened to the Earth, freaks, disease/virus that killed the people, etc. I kept thinking of "I Am Legend" every time I read about the freaks (haha). I also wish that there's a sequel or at least more chapters focusing on Fade and Deuce's love story! Less action and more love! HAHA
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5This book was an amazing read(I'm already devouring the next book in the series.) I just loved the fact that Ann Aguirre mixed the 2 people most likely to never get along with each other. Fade was such a mysteries person that he never quite fit in even when people like Banner started to appreciate the way that he thinks. He never shows pain even though many of his new friends die he doesn't complain about it, just keeps going like nothing ever happened. And Deuce is the exact opposite. Deuce hates the fact that as a Hunter she must never show weakness or the slightest bit of softness, but as a Huntress she must always show that she has the upper hand. She just can't not follow the rules, its in her blood. But when she is partnered with Fade Deuce believes that Silk is trying to ruin her life. As the story continues to move along Deuce realizes that everything that she has been taught was all wrong. Join Deuce and her friends as they venture out into the real world. The world where everything can go wrong and if it can go wrong it will. Hunt...if you want to survive.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5All her life Deuce has lived underground in an enclave called College. She was born during the second holocaust and has never seen the surface. People in the enclave don't live past the age of twenty-five. They are split into three categories, Breeders, Builders & Hunters. Deuce is a huntress. Along with her partner, Fade, she patrols the tunnels and checks the traps for food. When they are assigned to travel to a nearby enclave to check if they are ok, they find something they didn't bargain for. The Freaks (zombies) have always been a threat, but now they are becoming smarter, more organized. But no one at College believes them, especially the leaders.
This is a great story, twists and turns and edge of your seat moments. I liked Deuce. She is naive in that she never questions what the leaders tell her, but how could she know better? Her partnership with Fade is great. He is the perfect mysterious stranger in a place so contained that they all know each other. He was found wandering in the tunnels. Somehow he managed to survive alone and nobody knows how. He is quiet and keeps to himself. When Deuce is paired with Fade, her life begins to take a new direction. It's obvious from the tension between them, that somehow they will end up in a relationship and the inevitable love triangle.
I'm reading the second book now and loving it. Really looking forward to the third!!
Recommended to:
Fans of young adult fiction, dystopia, zombie and apocalypse stories. Another great young adult series. Read this!! - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5This is the first in a new YA series. I found the first book to be engaging as you learn about the dystopian, future world through, Deuce.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I am absolutely fascinated about how much dystopian teen fiction is out there right now and I've been trying to read as much of as possible. A lot of it is really bad, but yet there are some that really suck me in. This is definitely part of the latter. I devoured this book and cannot wait for the next installment.
Also, I really loved Deuce and Fade so far. I liked their interaction and their relationship, issues and all. I'm rooting for them individually and as a couple. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Let me start off by saying in really enjoyed this book, but felt the author downplayed the personal interactions between the characters to the point where they were unsatisfying. Deuce is perpetually "confused" or "angry" at noticing her emotions and doesn't seem to really encounter any personal growth. This I found to be the most frustrating. Everything else was great! The descriptions of the ghosted city were chilling and the characters' interactions with "relics" from the old days which they do not recognize but the reader will are awsesomely creepy. The storytelling is visceral and fast paced, leaving you wanting to read just one more page. Aguirre's zombies are creepy on another level since they retain traces of the humans they once were. I'd love to read more about Duece's and Fade's fates and how they fare after the story is over. Hopefully there will be a sequel equally as enjoyable. :)
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5I really really enjoyed this book! So much so that I bought the next in the series before I finished this one! Ms. Aguire has created a new world full of challenges and rules! The characters are strong, proud and original! So glad I waited until the next installment to purchase this book! Otherwise I dont think I could have taken the suspense! A definite must read for all ages! Very action packed on every page and just a touch of romance!
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5For Hunger Games and Forest of Hands and Teeth fans! The world has suffered a second holocaust, and people are surviving in small groups. Deuce has just turned 15 in the Enclave, and she is being trained as a Hunter. The Enclave is built in the New York subways: dark, smelly, and full of hiding places for predator and prey alike. Hunters have two jobs: bring back meat (whatever animals they can) for the people, and kill any Freaks they find. Freaks are vicious, semi-human zombie creatures with sharp teeth and claws, whose only aim is to eat... and they eat anything and everything. Deuce is paired with Fade, a rebellious and gifted Hunter. Together, they discover that the Freaks are getting smarter and more organized, and have overrun the nearby settlement of Nassau. The leaders of the Enclave blow off their concerns, but that doesn't lessen the danger. If they continue to stand up to the leaders, they will be banished from the Enclave and forced Topside, into the wreckage that is New York City. A place of gangs, violence, sickness and death, it is terrifying to Deuce, who has lived her entire life underground. All decisions have consequences... 8th grade and up.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I’m not sure if I’m just getting burned out on dystopia, but this book didn’t grab me. It was okay, not great but not bad either. For me it felt as if the plot was a bit less complex than a book like Divergent. But that is exactly what may make it more appealing to a reluctant reader.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Talk about a kick-ass girl! I like strong female leads and I definitely got that from this book. Nice, different take on a post-apocalyptic world. The beginning of the book moves a little too slowly for me and the end moves a little too fast. I'm hoping there's a sequel because there were a lot of loose ends that I would like to see tied up on expanded on in another book.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5I want to start off by saying that I do not read any books in the whole dystopian genre. I don't know why, but I've always had a hard time getting into them. When I saw the trailer for Enclave I knew I had to read it. When I received a copy I was super excited until a friend told me it was a dystopian book. I was little thrown off, but I decided to read it anyway because of the trailer. Because of Enclave, I am now searching for my next dystopian fix LOL.Deuce was a very strong character. She grew up around all the same people, followed the rules, did what she had to do and proved herself to be a fighter for her people. She wasn't afraid to use a weapon and risk her life for those she cares about. All Deuce has ever known is the Enclave and their ways. Deuce gets partnered up with Fade and really hates this decision. Fade is treated like an outcast and doesn't really talk to anyone. He wasn't raised in the Enclave and the only reason he is allowed to stay with them is because of his knowledge of the world topside. Being around Fade for Deuce is like a whole new life. As she gets to know Fade better, she discovers so many new things and new emotions.Somewhere down the line they find themselves exiled from The Enclave and forced to live topside. Something Deuce was taught was more dangerous than living below. With Fade's knowledge and their fighting skills, it's a whole new world for Deuce and a new journey. Which makes the whole book even more exciting!It was so easy to picture the characters and the world Ann Aguirre created. I enjoyed this book so much that I went to bed thinking about it and actually had about three nightmares. To me, this is a GREAT THING lol. I went to sleep thinking about Enclave and woke up thinking about Enclave. I love it when a book does that to me! I cannot wait for a second part, if there is a second part. I really, really enjoyed this book and everything from the characters to the writing. Below you will find the book trailer and if you are a lover of action and romance mixed together, this book is definitely for you.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Tense and action packed book that would be accessible for reluctant readers
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Enclave started off with a bang but started to drag a little in the beginning. I almost abandoned the book but stuck with it until the end. It was a fabulous ending. Can't wait to read the next installment!
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5I listened to the audiobook version of Enclave, written by Ann Aguirre in her first foray into writing for young adults. I wanted to read this book due to the mainly favorable reviews, and my continued interest in dystopian and post apocalyptic books. I took a chance on the audiobook and I’m not sure this was the best decision. While I liked the story, I didn’t love the audiobook narration. Overall I think the premise is good and the fast paced, action packed story seems to be heading down an interesting path. Enclave paints a bleak world, with evolved “freaks” and hidden dangers lurking around. The protagonist Deuce is a brave huntress trying to find the right path in an uncertain world.
In this post apocalyptic world the remaining survivors are living in underground tunnels. The human life span is now very short, and only if the children (called “Brats”) make it to age fifteen do they even get an official name. Once they are named, they can then choose the title of breeder, builder or hunter. Deuce has just completed the naming ceremony and has chosen the huntress path. She now must hunt for food and fight any flesh eating zombie like “Freaks” that get in her way. Deuce is paired up with Fade, a boy who grew up topside. Once she starts exploring on her hunting missions, Deuce finds that the stories she has been told about life outside the enclave may not be as true as she thought.
The story is mysterious and suspenseful, and since Deuce has been in the dark so is the reader. There is not a lot of information about Deuce’s world and how things got to be so bad. I would expect more of the blanks to be filled in with future installments. Deuce and the others in the enclave have grown up believing they won’t live long, they have to stay underground and away from the dangers above ground. No one seems to question this before Deuce becomes a huntress.
The protagonist Deuce is the character I felt most connected to. She is a brave huntress, curious, and strong. Her life has changed overnight and she is trying to adjust with each new challenge thrown at her. It’s interesting seeing the world outside the underground through her eyes because she is like a fish out of water; everything is new to her. Fade is her friend and potential love interest. He has more knowledge of the topside world since he was born there and can fill in some of the blanks for Deuce. Fade seems to have some competition for Deuce as another suitor is introduced.
Fade and Deuce meet many new characters on their mission, and it’s hard to know who can be trusted. The freaks are another mysterious element in the story. I think they are supposed to be zombies, and some of them are smarter and evolved so they are more difficult to stop.
As I listened to this story and envisioned the Deuce character, I imagined she would sound like a brave huntress, and sound similar to the narrator of Divergent or even the narrator of Delirium. The narrator of Enclave sounds younger and more innocent than I expected for the character. I understand she does need to sound naive due to her age and experience but for me the voice doesn’t match up to how I thought the character would sound.
Overall, the story has potential and should appeal to fans of darker post apocalyptic and action-oriented YA books. It’s not my favorite audiobook, so I recommend reading the book version. Enclave is the first book in the Razorland trilogy. The second book, Outpost, is due out in September 2012. - Rating: 1 out of 5 stars1/5After receiving a copy of this book from GoodReads friend Lucy, I was immediately drawn to the Publisher’s Weekly quote declaring the book to be “for fans of The Hunger Games”. Such comparison quotes, while attention grabbing and common practice amongst publishers, immediately set up a certain level of expectations, even in the most cynical of readers. While I haven’t actually finished reading The Hunger Games yet (I’ll get round to it eventually, I swear!), I began this book with the same expectations I have for every dystopian novel – strong world-building and a real threat & sense of danger.
There are books that make me consider discarding use of the flawed star rating system for reviews. Sometimes it’s close to impossible to summarise the qualities of a book into a simple rating out of 5, 10 or however one chooses to do so. A book can be a relatively enjoyable and competently written piece of work that would otherwise deserve a solid rating, but a certain element, event, etc, can bring its rating tumbling down. This happened to me with Sarah Beth Durst’s “Ice” and it happened with “Enclave”. But before I get to why I cannot give this book anything higher than one star, I shall discuss other elements of the book that succeed and fail.
I’m sure you’re all sick of me going on and on about this but the foundations of a strong dystopian novel lie in its world-building. Unusual or disturbing events can’t just happen for shock value. They need to be rooted in the origins of the society, grounded in reason, meaning the reason of this world. This fundamental lack of reason within the world-building in “Enclave” left more than a few questions unanswered. The underground society Deuce lives in does not name its young, known as brats, until a specific age, which is never mentioned. Why? There doesn’t seem to be any specific reasoning behind this rule and seems too impractical to fit in with a world that works to prove itself as fundamentally practical. There are hints of a cult-like mentality to the ruling class of the world but it’s barely touched upon and leaves us with half-built reasoning. Children are sanctioned into one of three groups – warriors, builders or breeders – yet the reasons for specific grouping once again seem at odds with the necessary practicality & needs of this society. One breeder, Deuce’s friend, is seen as ideal for his calling because he is handsome, but I failed to see why this would be a relevant quality in a world where death & disease are rampant. Other extremely questions go unanswered – how does this enclave have clean water after generations underground? How does Deuce go from a lifetime underground to full on exposure to sunlight and only get slightly burned with no damage to her eyesight?
The writing itself is adequate, if simple, and has well-paced action scenes, although the overall pacing is erratic. Certain scenes are evident padding and clumsy plotting, which coupled with several under-developed plot points proves to be somewhat frustrating. No character other than the heroine is given adequate time to develop beyond basic tropes, although I did warm to Deuce somewhat throughout the first half of the novel. However, it is one particular character and how others react to him that soured things for me.
A little more than midway through the novel, Deuce is kidnapped by a gang who make their intentions towards her clear – they intend to use her for breeding purposes, forcefully if need be. Later we are introduced to Tegan, a fellow kidnapped woman who has been raped repeatedly and given birth to stillborn children. After altercations with the story’s main monsters, the Freaks, the head of the gang, Stalker (yes, really), decides he will go along with Deuce, Tegan and main love interest Fade in order to have a better chance of surviving. Fade and Deuce agree to this, despite Tegan’s protests that she does not feel safe around the leader of the gang of rapists who repeatedly violated her for years. Later on, Stalker pushes Deuce against a tree and kisses her.
Deuce willingly reciprocates.
I’ve made my thoughts clear on the ‘bad boy’ trope in YA; I don’t like it. I understand the fantasy behind being the one girl who changes the rebel but ultimately I think it’s a problematic trope that is all too often used as an excuse to have the love interest treat the heroine like dirt, often being rough with her and belittling her.
Patch from “Hush Hush” held his love interest against a bed and talked about how much he wanted to kill her after stalking her, harassing her and generally making her feel uncomfortable and unsafe.
Stalker is the leader of a gang of rapists. It is hinted at in the book that he has raped women before. It is also implied that he may have raped Deuce during her kidnapped period.
He is presented as a potential love interest to Deuce.
The aim of a good dystopian novel is to create a sense of dread. I have seen rape mentioned in other dystopian novels and within the constraints of this world where humans die young and need to reproduce quickly, it makes sense that a patriarchy dominated society would view women in such a manner. However, I have never seen rape used so casually and tossed aside so simply by a character and an author in a YA novel. There is a cruel lack of empathy for Tegan in “Enclave”. Even within the constraints of the novel’s world, one ruled by social Darwinism, to force Tegan to interact daily with the man who stood by & let her be raped repeatedly, possibly ordering the rapes himself or even engaging in the horrific act himself, is baffling at best and disgusting at worst. As the novel progresses, Tegan grows (lazily from a characterisation point-of-view) from a victim into a ‘strong’ young woman who can fight back, but all I could think about was how her rape was used in such a cavalier fashion. Deuce, who started off with such potential (even if she did fall into the typical romantic plot tropes with mysterious bad boy Fade), does not question Stalker or his past actions. Instead, she lays some of the blame on Tegan. The dismissive attitude she has towards a victim of multiple rapes is abhorrent. At one point she asks herself how Tegan could have been so weak as to allow the events to happen. Deuce’s general attitude is that life is tough, and if she can suck it up and get on with her life, so can Tegan. Even within the context of the novel, this felt wrong on every level. Deuce, who had previously shown moments of true empathy, becomes someone who sympathises more with a rapist than the victim of rape. I shouldn’t even have to explain why this made me sick. And that’s why I can’t give this book anything more than one star.
I don’t expect every book in the world to be a beacon of social justice and feminism; that would be stupid. What I do expect is for a book to follow the rules it sets for itself. “Enclave” fails on this thanks to its inconsistent and confusing choices in its world-building, which seem to exist more for shock value than any real sense of reason. It’s a mediocre novel that becomes disgusting when something as serious, life changing and horrific as rape is used so clumsily. Rape is NEVER the woman’s fault. She’s never ‘asking for it’ and she’s certainly never deserving of pity or scorn because she was unable to fight back. Bad boys are problematic enough, but making a rapist not only a sympathetic character, one who receives a degree of sympathy from the heroine not rewarded to the victim, but a potential love interest is flat-out inexcusable.
1/5. - Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5At first, I wasn't too sure about whether I would like this. I found it at the library and thought the cover was interesting. But the description didn't really jump out at me. I took it and finally read it. I was so surprised. It was very good. I loved how the story started and how she left it off. Can't wait to see the next book. This I could really reread easily
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5In Deuce's world, people only live until their early 20s and earn the right to a name only if they survive their first fifteen years. Decimated by war and plague, New York City's population now lives underground. 15-year-old Deuce has just become a Huntress, and is paired with fellow Hunter Fade who once lived Topside. Their neighbouring enclave is decimated by Freaks (zombies) and soon after Deuce and Fade are exiled. Fade must use his long-ago memories of Topside to navigate their way out of the city ruins, past the dangerous gangs, and north to where his father promised was another life. Welcome to a dark and savage world...
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Deuce has been raised in an underground enclave which is a highly controlled society. People have assigned roles. Deuce is a hunter whose job is to protect the enclave and bring in meat. She is partnered with Fade who wasn't born in the enclave. They are not popular and are exiled on trumped up charges. They need to go Topside. Fade was born there but it is all new to Deuce. They meet other dangers as they look for a safe place to live.
- Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5I listened to this book and at first I didn't think I was going to like it. The reader was quite young sounding and I was really sure that it worked -- and the way she voiced the male characters in the novel was somewhat distracting. But it was Aguirre's story that kept me going and eventually allowed me to just ignore whatever it was about the narrator that bothered me. While I've read a lot of series books that ended with cliffhangers and left me never wanting to read another book in the series again, Aguirre's novel did not do that. Instead, even when I finished the book I didn't realize there was going to be another. The story is self-contained and while there are plenty of unanswered questions, I didn't need to have them to feel satisfied at the ending. I am, of course, curious as to find out what happens next, but I probably won't pick up the audio book unless there's a different reader.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Great futuristic story of what life would be like if everyone disappeared from the Earth and moved Underground. Such life has always been the case with Deuce until she is banished from her underground enclave and forced to live Topside with Fade - who insists there is life Topside. What she sees and learns about Topside is more surprising, with more adventures, than she has ever had in her life.
- Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Not bad. It was enjoyable enough to finish, but it did leave me wanting more explanation in some areas ( maybe in later books?). I felt it was a rather abrupt ending too. It almost felt as if the author was trying to do too much- to use the successful aspects of other dystopian books in this one. It may have been too much. I will eventually read #2 to see if my questions are answered.
- Rating: 1 out of 5 stars1/5Gahhhhhhh I had to return this book. It was an interesting idea, and I liked a couple of the characters, but my heck, what are editors being paid to do these days? I only read through about 18%, and I noticed at least 3 different points that were repeated almost verbatim. Um...we understand. We've got it. It's not important enough that we need that much emphasis, especially this early on.
The character development was poor and the relationships were forced. The author just simply wasn't willing to give her readers enough credit, and overexplained WAY too much. So irritating. - Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Engaging characters and interesting story, however brief.
- Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5This adventure, born in the dark and thrown out into a bright and violent world, is not for the faint of heart. Grab a flashlight, a pair of sunglass and all the courage you can gather, it's going to get rough.
I loved that the inspiration for this story was history and science. The author's notes in the back of the book indicate that the idea for this story was born from researching apocalypse scenarios, the tragedies of Hurricane Katrina and the Mole People of New York. - Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Girl15 is looking forward to her Naming: she's finally become the Huntress she's been training to be, fulfilling her lifelong ambition. The newly-christened Deuce gets paired with Fade, the loner-outsider who hates everyone in the enclave. Together they patrol the tunnels of their subterranean world, searching for food and avoiding the Freaks. The freaks are mindless, hungry, savage animals, vaguely human-shaped killing and eating machines. On a recon mission to a nearby enclave, Deuce and Fade are surrounded, and they have a troubling realization: the freaks are getting smarter. They're organizing, strategizing. This is bad, and will mean trouble for their Enclave. And the trouble will get worse if the officials won't listen to them.
And then things get worse, and Deuce's underground world becomes a memory as she's forced topside for the first time in her life. Blinding bright light and a different kind of violence--but also more of the same.
There are two different books here, really: there's the dystopian civilization that Deuce has grown up in, and all the issues there of classism, work culture (AFAICT there are only three career paths: Breeders, Builders, and Hunters, so idk what you do if you'd rather be the cook or something), intellectualism and the isolation of that ivory tower, the unquestionable government that is Always Right No Matter What the Evidence Says. And then Part 2 is the topside straight-up zombie-apocalypse story, which disappointed me because it could have been so much more.
Still, it's a great dystopia/zombie apocalypse for middle schoolers, not too horrifically graphic but still with fighting and action galore. A touch of romance (WHY WHY WHY WHY WHY does every freakin' apocalypse involve a love triangle WHY WHY WHY) that, thankfully, Deuce doesn't totally realize she's involved in until it's too late.
Recommended readalikes: City of Ember for underground society and the need to explore the surface; Divergent for choosing career paths and an unapologetically ass-kicking heroine; Forest of Hands and Teeth and The Enemy for attempts to find a safe haven through zombie-infested areas.
And this is BOOK ONE of a new series, even though this ended in a perfectly good place to make this a good stand-alone book. Grumble grumble insert anti-sequel-rant here. - Rating: 1 out of 5 stars1/5Yuck! This was grossly violent (someone needs to put a zombie warning sign on books for me so I don't read them), I didn't like the world that was created, and there were so many quirks that seriously bugged me (why do they call women "sir"?...). I'm very glad it's over, although there must be a sequel coming. I won't bother.
Book preview
Enclave - Ann Aguirre
one
down below
In the windowless tomb of a blind mother, in the dead of night, under the feeble rays of a lamp in an alabaster globe, a girl came into the darkness with a wail.
—George MacDonald, The Day Boy and the Night Girl
Deuce
I was born during the second holocaust. People had told us legends of a time when human beings lived longer. I thought they were just stories. Nobody even lived to see forty in my world.
Today was my birthday. Each one added a layer of fear, and this year, it was worse. I lived in an enclave in which our oldest had seen twenty-five years. His face was withered, and his fingers shook when he attempted the smallest tasks. Some whispered it would be a kindness to kill him, but they meant they didn’t want to see their futures written in his skin.
Are you ready?
Twist stood waiting for me in the darkness.
He already wore his marks; he was two years older than me, and if he’d survived the ritual, I could. Twist was small and frail by any standards; privation had cut runnels into his cheeks, aging him. I studied the pallor of my forearms and then nodded. It was time for me to become a woman.
The tunnels were wide and laid with metal bars. We had found remnants of what might’ve been transportation, but they lay on their sides like great, dead beasts. We used them for emergency shelters sometimes. If a hunting party was attacked before it reached sanctuary, a heavy metal wall between them and hungry enemies made the difference between life and death.
I had never been outside the enclave, of course. This space comprised the only world I’d ever known, cast in darkness and curling smoke. The walls were old, built of rectangular blocks. Once they had borne color but the years had worn them gray. Splashes of brightness came from items we scavenged from deeper in the warren.
I followed Twist through the maze, my gaze touching on familiar objects. My favorite item was a picture of a girl on a white cloud. I couldn’t make out what she was holding; that part had worn away. But the words in bright red, HEAVENLY HAM, looked wonderful to me. I wasn’t sure what that was, but by her expression, it must have been very good.
The enclave assembled on naming day, everyone who had survived to be named. We lost so many when they were young that we just called all the brats Boy or Girl, along with a number. Since our enclave was small—and dwindling—I recognized each face shadowed by the half-light. It was hard not to let the expectation of pain knot my stomach, along with the fear I would wind up with a terrible name that would cling to me until I died.
Please let it be something good.
The oldest, who carried the burden of the name Whitewall, walked to the center of the circle. He stopped before the fire, and its licking flame painted his skin in terrifying shades. With one hand, he beckoned me forward.
Once I joined him, he spoke. Let each Hunter bring forth his gift.
The others carried their tokens and piled them at my feet. A mound of interesting items grew—and a few of them, I had no idea what purpose they might’ve served. Decoration, perhaps? People in the world before seemed obsessed with objects that existed simply to look pretty. I couldn’t imagine such a thing.
After they finished, Whitewall turned to me. It’s time.
Silence fell. Cries echoed through the tunnels. Somewhere close by, somebody was suffering, but he wasn’t old enough to attend my naming. We might lose another citizen before we finished here. Sickness and fever devastated us and our medicine man did more harm than good, it seemed to me. But I’d learned not to question his treatments. Here in the enclave, one didn’t prosper by demonstrating too much independent thought.
These rules permit us to survive, Whitewall would say. If you cannot abide by them, then you are free to see how you fare Topside. The eldest had a mean streak; I didn’t know if he had always been that way, or if age had made him so. And now, he stood before me, ready to take my blood.
Though I had never witnessed the ritual before, I knew what to expect. I extended my arms. The razor glinted in the firelight. It was our prized possession, and the oldest kept it clean and sharp. He made three jagged cuts on my left arm, and I held my pain until it coiled into a silent cry within me. I would not shame the enclave by weeping. He slashed my right arm before I could do more than brace. I clenched my teeth as hot blood trickled downward. Not too much. The cuts were shallow, symbolic.
Close your eyes,
he said.
I obeyed. He bent, spreading the gifts before me, and then grabbed my hand. His fingers were cold and thin. From whatever my blood struck, so would I take my name. With my eyes closed, I could hear the others breathing, but they were still and reverent. Movement rustled nearby.
Open your eyes and greet the world, Huntress. From this day forward, you will be called Deuce.
I saw the oldest held a card. It was torn and stained, yellow with age. The back had a pretty red pattern and the front had what looked like a black shovel blade on it, along with the number two. It was also speckled with my blood, which meant I must keep it with me at all times. I took it from him with a murmur of thanks.
Strange. No longer would I be known as Girl15. My new name would take some getting used to.
The enclave dispersed. People offered me nods of respect as they went about their business. Now that the naming day ceremony was complete, there was still food to be hunted and supplies to be scavenged. Our work never ended.
You were very brave,
Twist said. Now let’s take care of your arms.
It was just as well we had no audience for this part because my courage failed. I wept when he put the hot metal to my skin. Six scars to prove I was tough enough to call myself Huntress. Other citizens received less; Builders got three scars. Breeders took only one. For as long as anyone could remember, the number of marks on the arms identified what role a citizen played.
We could not permit the cuts to heal naturally for two reasons: They would not scar properly and infection might set in. Over the years, we had lost too many to the naming day ritual because they cried and begged; they couldn’t bear the white-hot conclusion. Now Twist no longer paused at the sight of tears, and I was glad he didn’t acknowledge them.
I am Deuce.
Tears spilled down my cheeks as the nerve endings died, but the scars appeared one by one, proclaiming my strength and my ability to weather whatever I found out in the tunnels. I had been training for this day my whole life; I could wield a knife or a club with equal proficiency. Every bite of food I ate that had been supplied by someone else, I consumed with the understanding it would be my turn someday to provide for the brats.
That day had come. Girl15 was dead.
Long live Deuce.
* * *
After the naming, two friends held a party for me. I found them both waiting in the common area. We’d come up together as brats, though our personalities and physical skills put us on different paths. Still, Thimble and Stone were my two closest companions. Of the three, I was the youngest, and they’d taken pleasure in calling me Girl15 after they both got their names.
Thimble was a small girl a little older than me, who served as a Builder. She had dark hair and brown eyes. Because of her pointed chin and wide gaze, people sometimes questioned if she was old enough to be out of brat training. She hated that; there was no surer way to rouse her temper.
Grime often stained her fingers because she worked with her hands, and it found its way onto her clothing and smudged her face. We’d gotten used to seeing her scratch her cheek and leave a dark streak behind. But I didn’t tease her anymore because she was sensitive. One of her legs was a touch shorter than the other, and she walked with a whisper of a limp, not from injury, but that small defect. Otherwise, she might easily have become a Breeder.
Because he was strong and handsome, but not especially bright, Stone landed as a Breeder. Whitewall figured he had good material in him, and if matched with a clever female, he should sire good, solid offspring. Only citizens with traits worth passing on were allowed to contribute to the next generation, and the elders monitored births carefully. We couldn’t allow more brats than we could provide for.
Thimble rushed up to examine my forearms. How much did it hurt?
A lot,
I said. Twice as much as yours.
I gave Stone a pointed look. "Six times as much as yours."
He always joked he had the easiest job in the enclave, and maybe that was true, but I wouldn’t want the burden of making sure our people survived to the next generation. On top of siring the young, he also shared the responsibility of looking after them. I didn’t think I could deal with so much death. Brats were unbelievably fragile. This year, he’d sired one male, and I didn’t know how he dealt with the fear. I could barely remember my dam; she’d died young even by our standards. When she was eighteen, a sickness swept through the enclave, likely carried by the trading party from Nassau. It took a lot of our people that year.
Some citizens thought the offspring of Breeders should stay in that role. There was a quiet movement among the Hunters to take their number from their own—that once a Hunter got too old for patrols, he or she could sire the next crop of Hunters. I’d fought my whole life against that thinking. From the time I could walk, I’d watched the Hunters going off into the tunnels and known it for my destiny.
It’s not my fault I’m handsome,
he said, grinning.
Stop, you two.
Thimble got out a present wrapped in faded cloth. Here.
I hadn’t expected this. Brow raised, I took the parcel from her, hefted it, and said, You made me new daggers.
She glared. I hate when you do that.
To appease her, I unfolded the fabric. "They’re beautiful."
And they were. Only a Builder could do such fine work. She’d poured these just for me. I imagined the long hours over the fire and the time in the mold and the tempering and the polishing and sharpening afterward. They gleamed in the torchlight. I tested them and found them perfectly balanced. I executed a couple of moves to show her how much I liked them, and Stone jumped as if I might hit him on accident. He could be such an idiot. A Huntress never stabbed anything she didn’t intend to.
I wanted you to have the best out there.
Me too,
Stone said.
He hadn’t bothered to wrap his gift; it was simply too big. The club wasn’t Builder quality work, but Stone had a fair hand with carving, and he’d taken a solid scrap of wood for the core. I suspected Thimble must’ve helped him with the banded metal along the top and bottom, but the fanciful figures cut into the wood came from him, no mistake. I didn’t recognize all of the animals, but it was lovely and solid, and I would feel safer with it on my back. He’d rubbed the carvings with some kind of dye, so they stood out from the grain. The decorations would actually make it harder for me to keep the weapon clean, but Stone was a Breeder, and he couldn’t be expected to think of things like that.
I smiled in appreciation. This is wonderful.
They both hugged me and then produced a treat we’d been saving for my naming day. Thimble had traded for this tin long ago—in anticipation of the occasion. The container itself offered unusual pleasure in that it shone bright red and white, brighter than most things we found down here. We didn’t know what was inside it; only that it had been sealed so thoroughly that we needed tools to pry it open.
A lovely scent drifted out. I had never smelled anything like it, but it was fresh and sweet. Inside, I saw nothing but colored dust. Impossible to tell what it might have once been, but the aroma alone made my naming day special.
What is it?
Thimble asked.
Hesitantly, I touched a fingertip to the pink dust. I think it might be to make us smell better.
Do we put it on our clothes?
Stone leaned in and gave a sniff.
Thimble considered. Only for special occasions.
Anything in there?
I stirred, until I touched bottom. There is!
Elated, I drew out a square of stiff paper. It was white with gold letters, but they had a funny shape and I couldn’t read them. Some of them looked like they were supposed to; others didn’t. They looped and dropped and curled in ways that made them confusing to my eye.
Put it back,
she said. It might be important.
It was important, if only for being one of the few complete documents we had from the time before. We should take it to the Wordkeeper.
Even though we’d traded for this tin fair and square, if it yielded a valuable enclave resource and we tried to keep it for ourselves, we could wind up in serious trouble. Trouble led to exile, and exile to unspeakable things. By mutual agreement, we replaced the paper and closed the tin. We shared a sober look, aware of the potential consequences. None of us wanted to be accused of hoarding.
Let’s take care of it now,
Stone said. I have to get back to the brats soon.
Give me a bit.
Moving at a run, I headed to look for Twist. I found him in the kitchens, not surprisingly. I still hadn’t been assigned a private living space. Now that I’d been named, I could have a room of my own. No more brat dorm.
What do you want?
he demanded.
I tried not to take offense. Just because I’d been named didn’t mean his treatment of me would improve overnight. To some, I’d be little more than a brat for a couple of years. Until I started edging toward elder territory.
Just tell me where my space is?
Twist sighed, but obligingly he led the way through the maze. Along the way, we dodged many bodies and wound through the layers of partitions and makeshift shelters. Mine sat in between two others, but it was four feet to call my own.
My room had three crude walls, constructed of old metal, and a ragged length of cloth for an illusion of privacy. Everyone had more or less the same; it only varied in terms of what trinkets people kept. I had a secret weakness for shiny things. I was always trading for something that glittered when I held it to the light.
That all?
Before I could answer, he went back toward the kitchen. Taking a deep breath, I pushed through the curtain. I had a rag pallet and a crate for my meager belongings. But nobody else had the right to come in here without my invitation. I’d earned my place.
Despite my worry, I smiled while I stowed my new weapons. Nobody would touch anything in here, and it was best not to visit the Wordkeeper armed to the teeth. Like Whitewall, he was getting on in years, and tended to be strange.
I didn’t look forward to this interrogation at all.
Trial
It didn’t take long to spill our story and show him the tin. He reached inside, letting the pink dust trail through his fingers. The card he handled carefully.
You say you’ve had this item for some time?
The Wordkeeper glared at the three of us, as if we were guilty of stupidity at least.
Stone explained, We traded for it together and agreed we’d open it on Fifteen’s … er, Deuce’s naming day.
So you had no idea of the contents before now?
No, sir,
I said.
Thimble added a timid nod. Her limp made her self-conscious, as the enclave seldom permitted such imperfections. But hers was minor and didn’t impede her performance as a Builder. In fact, I’d say she worked twice as hard, not wanting anyone to feel they’d made a mistake about her.
Are you willing to swear?
the Wordkeeper asked.
Yes,
Thimble said. None of us had any idea what it held.
They fetched Copper from the kitchens and she witnessed. The Wordkeeper growled as he took the document into evidence. Get out, all of you. I’ll let you know of my decision in due time.
I felt sick as we went back to my room. I wanted to show them where it was, anyway. Stone could enter with Thimble present as a chaperone. Like in the old days, in the brat dorm, we flopped onto the pallet together. Stone sat between us and wrapped an arm around each of us. He felt warm and familiar, and I leaned my head against his shoulder. I wouldn’t let anybody else touch me like this, but he was different. We were brat-mates, practically related.
It’ll be fine,
he said. They can’t punish us for something we didn’t do.
Looking at the pleasure in Thimble’s face as she nestled against him, I wondered if she might do better as a Breeder. But the elders wouldn’t let her, even if she’d preferred it. Nobody wanted imperfections passed on, even the small, harmless ones.
He’s right,
she agreed.
I nodded. The elders looked after us. Certainly, they had to consider the matter, but once they’d studied all the facts, no harm would come to us. We’d done the right thing and turned the paper over as soon as we found it.
Absently, Stone played with my hair; for him, it was a simple instinct. Touching wasn’t forbidden to Breeders. They hugged and patted so easily it alarmed me. Builders and Hunters had to take such care not to be accused of wrongdoing.
I have to go,
Stone said regretfully.
To make some brats or look after them?
Thimble asked with a flash of ire.
For a moment, I felt so sorry for her. To me, it was painfully obvious she wanted something she could never have. Unlike me. I had exactly what I wanted. I couldn’t wait to start work.
He grinned, taking the question at face value. If you must know—
Never mind,
I said hastily.
Her face fell. I should go too. Hope you had a good naming day, Deuce.
Apart from seeing the Wordkeeper, it was fine.
I smiled as they both left and fell back on my pallet to think about my future as a Huntress.
* * *
The first time I saw Fade, he frightened me. He had a lean, sharp face and shaggy dark hair that fell over his forehead into the blackest eyes, like a bottomless pit. And he bore so many scars, as if he’d lived through battles the rest of us couldn’t imagine. Hard as life had been here, his silent rage said he’d seen worse.
Unlike most, he hadn’t been born in the enclave. He came in through the tunnels, half grown when we found him, half starved and more than half feral. He didn’t have a number designation, or even any concept of how to behave. Still, the older citizens voted to let him stay.
Anybody who can survive out in the tunnels on his own has to be strong,
Whitewall had said. We can use him.
If he doesn’t kill us all first,
Copper had muttered back.
Copper was second oldest at twenty-four, and she served as mate to Whitewall, though it was a fluid arrangement. She was also the only one who dared to back-talk him, even a little bit. The rest of us had learned to mind. I’d seen people exiled because they refused to obey the rules.
So when Whitewall decreed the stranger stayed, we had to make it work. It was a long while before I actually set eyes on him. They tried to teach him our ways, and he spent long hours with the Wordkeeper. He already knew how to fight; he didn’t seem to know how to live with other people, or at least, he found our laws confusing.
I was just a brat at the time, so I wasn’t involved in his assimilation. I was training to become a Huntress. Since I wanted to prove myself with blade and boot, I worked tirelessly. When the strange boy got his name, I wasn’t there. He didn’t know how old he was, so they guessed when to christen him.
After that, I saw him around, but I certainly never spoke to him. Brats and Hunters didn’t mix, unless lessons were involved. Those earmarked for combat and patrol duties studied under the veteran Hunters. I’d spent most of my time training with Silk, but a few others had schooled me over the years as well. I formally met Fade much later, after my own naming. He was teaching the fundamentals of knife work when Twist delivered me to his class.
That’s all,
Fade said, as we joined them.
The brats dispersed with quiet grumbling. I remembered how sore my muscles had been when I started training. Now I took pleasure in the hardness of my arms and legs. I wanted to test myself against the dangers beyond our makeshift walls.
Twist tilted his head at me. This is your new partner. Silk ranked her as the best in her group.
Did she?
Fade’s voice sounded odd.
I met his black eyes with a lift of my chin. Can’t let him think he intimidates me. Yes. I scored ten out of ten in throws.
He raked me with a scathing look. You’re puny.
And you’re quick to judge.
What’s your name?
I had to think; I almost said Girl15. I fingered the card in my pocket, finding comfort in its edges. It was my talisman now. Deuce.
I’ll leave you two to talk,
Twist said. I have other things to do.
He did, of course. Since he was small and fragile, he couldn’t hunt. He served as a second to Whitewall, running errands for him and taking care of administrative tasks. I couldn’t remember ever seeing him just sitting still, not even at night. I lifted my hand as he went around the jagged metal partition to another section of the settlement.
I’m Fade,
he told me.
I know. Everyone knows you.
Because I’m not one of you.
You said it, not me.
His head jerked in a nod that said he didn’t want to answer any questions. Since I refused to be like everyone else, I swallowed my curiosity. If he didn’t want to talk, I didn’t care. Everyone wondered about his story, but only Whitewall had ever heard it—and maybe he didn’t even know the truth. But I was only interested in Fade as the one who guarded my back, so it didn’t matter.
He changed the subject. Silk assigns hunting parties daily. We join the rotation tomorrow. I hope you’re as good as she claims.
What happened to your last partner?
Fade smiled. He wasn’t as good as Silk claimed.
You want to find out?
I lifted my brow in a challenge.
The space had cleared of brats, so he shrugged and took a position in the center. Show me what you’ve got.
It was a clever tactic, but I wasn’t that green. The offensive fighter lost the chance to assess his opponent’s style. I shook my head at him and curled my fingers. He almost smiled; I saw it start in his eyes, but then he focused on the