Journal of Positive School Psychology
2022, Vol. 6, No. 9, 14-25
http://journalppw.com
Psychic Experiences In Sufism And Modern Era
Mazhar Farid Chishti1 , Prof. Dr. Farooq Hassan2 , Dr. Muhammad Shahid Habib3 , Dr.
Ikram Ul Haq4 , Tahmina Iqbal5
1
Assistant Professor, Finance, Lahore Garrison University, Email:
[email protected]
Associate Professor, department of Humanities, NED University of Engineering & Technology, Karachi
3
Assistant Professor, Islamic Studies, depart Khwaja Fareed University of Engineering & IT
4
Assistant Professor, Alhamd Islamic University, Islamabad Campus
5
Assistant Professor, Punjab Education Department,
2
Abstract
There is always a spiritual element to everything we do as humans, even when we are healthy and when we
are ill. Spirituality is no longer only a religious or mystic concept; it is now universally accepted as an
important aspect in overall health and well-being. In recent years, neuroscience has been used to study
spirituality. As a result, this area of investigation has been explored since it appears to have considerable
potentiality of both understanding mental disease and expanding treatment techniques. As a prominent
Islamic spiritual tradition, Sufism is influenced by Christianity and Hinduism among other major global
religions. Many people, both Muslim and non-Muslim, have benefited greatly from its impact on their
spiritual health. It has been centuries since Sufism has been preached. There have been many important
Sufis throughout Islamic history, but it wasn't until the mediaeval period that Sufism reached its greatest
height and culminated in the development of many Sufi communities and its major proponents that it was
truly at its peak. Spiritual realization is the purpose of Sufism; the soul is considered as a conduit through
which this interaction occurs. " Those who adhere to Sufism believe that God is not only the source of all
things, but also the only source of significance in life. To comprehend religious experience and how it
impacts one's mental health, this might be an important relationship.
Keywords: Sufism, Psychoanalysis, mental health.
1. Introduction
For as long as there have been humans, there has
also been a universal curiosity about discovering
who we are, what we're doing here, and where we
fit in the grand scheme of things. The solutions
have not been found, but we have made progress
in comprehending ourselves by observing the
natural world. Existing for a long time and
providing solutions to "unresolved doubts,"
spirituality has been associated with many
different religions and non-religious groups.
Recent years have witnessed an upsurge in
interest in spiritual topics and developments in
neuroscience provide an opportunity to
comprehend it from a more scientific point of
view and to put it in appropriate context.
Spirituality is an important element of the lives of
the vast majority of people across the globe.
affects one's state of mind and knowledge of the
causes, classifications, and treatments of mental
illness. Mental health professionals, it seems,
would do well to be educated on the ways in
which spirituality influences patients' mental
health, both when they are healthy and when they
are ill. An introduction to Sufism, an Islamic
mystical tradition, its impact on its adherents'
15
Journal of Positive School Psychology
mental health, and how it interacts with
conventional psychotherapy in terms of diagnosis
and treatment will be provided in this
presentation.
1.1
The need-to-know Sufism
The collection of information and principles is
what mostly determines people's consciousness
and behaviour. Science has a lot of facts, and
ideologies like humanism and existentialism,
which are both religious and nonreligious, are
where ethics first emerged (Fulford 2013). Many
religious systems that give the majority of people
a numerical system and hence have an effect on
their wellbeing emphasize spirituality as an
essential component. In recognition of this, the
World Health Organization designated spiritual
well-being as one of the most crucial health
considerations at the 37th World Health
Assembly in 1984. This decision was made in
accordance with social and cultural norms. (Basu
1995). Many medical institutions in the West
currently include spiritual instruction in their
curricula. Fehring and others (1987). Spirituality
appears to have a significant impact on mental
health because both of these operate in the same
region of the brain, or what some could refer to as
the mind or soul. According to research cited by
Braam et al. (1997), there are both beneficial and
negative impacts of spiritual and religious beliefs
and practices on the physical and mental health of
those who follow them. is a fast-expanding
branch of spirituality that needs to be
comprehended in light of how it affects its
adherents' mental health as well as how it might
interact with mental health care facilities.
Sufism provides an opportunity, from a
philosophical standpoint, to comprehend the
origin of religious knowledge in general and
Islamic knowledge (revelation) in particular. In
Sufi culture, it is claimed that Sufis could have
the same experience as the source of religious
knowledge in the form of the Quran's (the Islamic
holy book) revelation to Muhammad (the Prophet
of Islam). The investigation of these Sufi
experiences that share the phenomenological and
prophetic foundations of revelation affords an
opportunity for the scientific investigation of
theological sources (Koenig, et al.,1998). From
day-to-day clinical practise to research, the study
of theological sources, their experiences, and
their consequences is a vital component of mental
health-related science and places mental health
science students in an advantageous position to
investigate Sufi experiences.
1.2
Sufism: The essence
The primary goal of the Sufis is to have a spiritual
relationship with God, which is founded on the
knowledge (ilm) revealed through the Qur'an and
the practise of Islam (amal). W. C. Chittick
(2010). The Sufi philosophy has been based on
God's conception and the nature of association
with Him from its inception. In describing the
idea of God as infinite, everlasting, immutable,
creator, almighty, merciful, and the reason for all
existence, the early Sufis steadfastly adhered to
the Quran. With the development of Sufi
philosophy, the idea of God shifted from being
the creator of all things to being the sole source
of reality. With the concept of wahdat-ul-wujood,
this ideology was abandoned. (Smith,1995).
According to Sufism, the soul can be used to have
a direct dialogue with the divine. The Sufis
believe that the heart (qalb), the spirit (ruh), and
the conscience (sirr) that can know God were all
created before any human existence. Many Sufis
see the gentleman as symbolic of "the secret
temple of God himself, in which everyone knows
and does not know." Reference: (Nizamie et al.,
2013). According to Sufism, the qalb (heart) is
the seat of the divine and the doorway to
enlightenment. It is a source of great joy for Sufis
that God has revealed, "I, who do not enter into
all the heavens and the earth, enter into the heart
of the loyal believer." The Masaq (covenant) as it
is mentioned in the Qur'an: "And (remember)
when your Lord saved from the children of
Mazhar Farid Chishti
Adam, from the threats of their descendants, and
testified to them (saying): Am I not your Lord?"
Absolutely, they reply. We testify. That was so
you wouldn't have to remark, "Look!," on Easter.
The words "by this we could not" constitute the
basis of Sufi philosophy and its emphasis on unity
with God. [16,27] According to the Sufis, there is
a lower soul (nafs) that stands between the
enlightened soul and God. To get back to the
truth, you have to transform your nafs from nafse ammara (lustful soul; compare Id) to nafs-e
lawwama (remorseful soul; compare ego) to nafse mutmaenna (peaceful soul; compare super-ego)
(Smith,1995).
In Sufism, the Prophet Muhammad pbuh is seen
as a remote figure. It is widely held that
Muhammad is the only person capable of
bringing about spiritual enlightenment, also
known as the ascent of the higher soul to
association with God. Muhammad's words, "the
first thing Allah created was my light, which
came from His light and came from the majesty
of His magnificence," provide the foundation for
this belief among the Sufis. According to Sufis,
one can only reach enlightenment by following
the Way (tareeqa) and preparing one's inner self
for it (Dehlvi, 2010).
1.4
Tareeqa: The Sufi way
Muhammad pbuh defined faith (iman) as "to
acknowledge with the heart, to voice with the
tongue, and to act with the limbs" in a tradition
that is transmitted to him. The three pillars of
faith—sharia (act with the limbs), tareeqa (voice
with the mouth), and haqeeqa—are thought to
correspond to the three facets of Sufi philosophy
(acknowledge with the heart). Sufis adhere to the
sharia while travelling (tareeqa) to God's
presence (haqeeqa). Three stages have been
identified as constituting the Sufi tareeqa: the
maqamat (stage of stations), the ahwal (stage of
states), and the stage of achievement (tamkin).
The first level, which is attained via selfmortification, reflects the traveler's (Salik's)
16
desire for his lord (mujahida). To get to the last
station of the first stage, love (mohabba), salikis
are required to travel through the stations of
repentance (tawba), piety (zuhd), faith in God
(tawwakul), poverty (faqr), recollection of God
(zikr), patience (sabr), thankfulness (shukr), and
contentment (rida). The states (ahwal), which
take place during or right after the first stage, are
thought to be the consequence of supernatural
favours (tajalli) flowing from God. As a matter of
religion, the ahwal are wholly reliant on God's
favour and cannot be coerced by the Sufi. At the
conclusion of the quest, the Sufi is intended to
obtain the gnosis (marifa), the knowledge of God,
and unite with Him in the last stage of
achievement (tamkin). Before achieving eternal
existence in his God (baqa), the Sufi is expected
to first destroy himself in his mentor (fana-fishaykh), then in Muhammad (fana-fi-rasul), and
ultimately in God (fana-fi-allah) (Smith, 1995).
1.5
Psychic experiences in Sufism Different perspectives
In all civilizations and religions, there is a
commonality of spiritual or psychological
experiences. Although there are no research
specifically on Sufism, surveys have shown that
between 20% and 45% of people experience
mood swings on a regular basis; the frequency
varies according on factors including time of day,
gender, and religion. Bhugra (2002) It is
astonishing how much we have in common while
having different acts, ideologies, and cultural
contexts for them. Regardless of background, a
complex cognitive experience known as a
magical experience takes place in the mental,
visual, and emotional realms. The magical
encounters, which are based in part on the
narratives of some Sufis, are brief, frequently
fleeting, indescribable, unbroken, involve close
ties with a singular individual, pass through time,
place, and person, and sound like a profound
sense of happiness. (1934 Iqbal; 1995 M Smith).
17
Historically, mystical experiences were thought
to be the consequence of heavenly experience,
demon possession, or even insanity. The
descriptions have varied according to the political
and religious spheres of the day, and have been
influenced by the complainant's social class, the
content of the experience corresponding to
existing political and religious norms, gender,
and so on. They have been translated to promote
or undermine a particular political ideology, and
have even been used to appeal to insanity. Mansur
al Hallaj and Bayazid Bastami, two great Sufis
who declare they wish to feel weird, must be told
here. Both were outstanding Sufis who were
labelled heretics and put to death for their
defiance (Lipsedge, 2018).
Psychic experiences are more supernatural in
nature, and Sufis believe that this is the source of
ultimate knowledge (marifa or gnosis).
Philosophical and scientific ideas have
questioned the likelihood that such knowledge
may produce knowledge. Kant refused to
speculate on whether it may conceivably end up
as an exit outside of human experience, which is
why its context is so illogical. Sufi thinkers have
contended that such an experience could simply
be an extension of ordinary human experience.
Sufi philosopher Fakhruddin Iraqi hypothesised
that these events could occur at distinct periods in
space (divine time and space) due to shifts in
human perception (Iqbal,1934). The subjection of
this experience, contrary to the traditional
objective of natural science, has been the biggest
impediment to the study of psychological
knowledge.
Sufi concepts may resemble "attitudes" like
deception and hallucinations (audible, physical,
etc.), according to phenomenological theory. On
the basis of these parallels, it has been questioned
whether information was provided and whether
these events were spiritual. It has been stated that
psychosis and the fundamental idea that all
psychological phenomena are aberrant serve as
Journal of Positive School Psychology
the foundation for all kinds of enigmatic
experiences, and as a result, religious beliefs. It
has been demonstrated that psychological
occurrences (false thoughts and deceptions) are
frequent in everyday life and during spiritual
experiences, which are definitely not part of
nature. All attitudes, it has been suggested, are
abnormal, and abnormalities need to be redefined
(Josephson, 2008) Given this, it would seem
important to examine the spiritual experience
outside of the context of illness.
1.6
Sufism and psychotherapy
Unfortunately, mental health experts have paid
little attention to the fact that spiritual and
religious beliefs are an important method for a
great number of individuals to cope with stress.
Religion and spirituality have been infused into
the therapeutic process with promising results in
recent years. (Lew, et al., 2022). Decriminalizing
suicide attempt in the 21st century: a critical
assessment of suicide statistics in nations that
criminalise suicide (Singh, et al., 2022).
Spirituality has been included into psychotherapy
processes as a means of enhancing a current
medical practise - spirituality. Transpersonal
psychotherapy refers to advanced psychotherapy
or the creation of new procedures with spirituality
as their foundation. Despite the fact that Sufi
ideas and practises have been included into
transpersonal psychotherapy, there is no literature
on the incorporation of these beliefs and practises
into mental health treatment approaches.
Superior Spiritual Psychological Treatments
Focusing on current concerns, additional
psychological
therapies
are
essentially
psychological therapies that involve human
beliefs, particularly spiritual beliefs. The
therapist utilises the individual's spiritual beliefs
and practises, such as meditation and prayer, in
the treatment process, but he has never attempted
to undermine his own convictions or those of the
Mazhar Farid Chishti
patient. The treatment consists of 10 to 16
sessions, each lasting 45 to 70 minutes and
occurring once each week. In controlled trials, the
treatment has demonstrated efficacy by lowering
recurrence and recurrence in the treatment group
(Singh, et al., 2022) Sufi themes of patience
(sabr), trust in God (tawwakul), contentment
(rida), and God as always forgiving may have a
profound effect on changing misunderstanding
strategies, and when combined with Sufi
practises of remembrance of the god (zikr) and
gratitude (shukr), may provide the framework for
additional spiritual psychological treatment of
Sufi believers.
Psychotherapy
that
is
transpersonal
psychotherapy is based on the notion that humans
are spiritual creatures, which is why
transpersonal psychotherapy's goals include key
spiritual-related traits (Subandi, et al., 2022). In
transpersonal psychiatry, the therapist's function
has evolved from that of a spiritual guide to that
of a "spiritual stranger." The healer does not build
any spiritual ideology and is a client who decides
on the spiritual substance of the treatment
(Knysh, 2022). Sufism in Russia: From Ideology
to Scholarship and Back Again Der Islam, vol.
99(1), pp. 187-231. Transpersonal psychotherapy
incorporates a variety of spiritual disciplines such
as Sufism, yoga, qigong, and aikodo.
Transpersonal psychotherapy has been utilised to
address persistent anxiety, spiritual issues, mental
illnesses, and substance misuse difficulties.
Transpersonal psychotherapy can serve as a
foundation for discussions about psychiatric
services with traditional healers, and given the
magnitude of the population seeking traditional
healers, this can have a considerable impact on
community health (Kanwal, et al., 2022).
1.7
Sufism and mental health care
services
In many developing nations, the great majority of
people with mental illness either receive or seek
assistance from spiritual healers. People's
18
religion systems foster a spiritually based concept
of mental illness, and mental health care services
in many rural communities are virtually
nonexistent. This is evidenced by the enormous
number of mentally sick persons who seek
treatment at the holy shrines (dargah) of the Sufi
saints. The Erwadi (India) fire in the shrine of
Saint Shaheed Valiyullah, which resulted in the
deaths of 28 mentally ill people, should serve as
a sobering reminder of the price of ignoring the
incorporation of people's religious beliefs into
mental health services. Khan and Sharan (2022).
Incorporating spiritual / Sufi artefacts into mental
health treatment services necessitates a two-step
procedure:
Inclusion of psychiatrists/Sufis in the mental
health care delivery system, which may involve
basic training in the diagnosis of mental illness
and, when needed, proper referral.
Incorporating spiritual / Sufi beliefs and practises
into a treatment process can enhance the
utilisation of mental health care by a population
with a stronger spiritual orientation.
Individual and organisational effort is necessary
for the incorporation of spiritual ideas and
practises into the mental health treatment delivery
system. Spiritual issues must be brought to the
attention of persons receiving training in mental
health care. The focus of training should be on
comprehending spirituality as an intrinsic aspect
of a person seeking assistance and
comprehending people's beliefs in the practise
field. (Subandi, et al (2022).
Inclusion of psychiatrists and Sufis in the mental
health care delivery system, which may involve
basic training in mental illness diagnosis and
appropriate referral as needed.
Incorporating spiritual / Sufi ideas and practises
into a therapeutic process has the potential to
improve the usage of mental health services by a
more spiritually inclined population.
19
The word psychiatry is associated with psyche or
soul healing. In an ironic twist, the link between
psychiatrists and religion/spirituality has
deteriorated. Psychoanalysis has had a significant
impact on relationships; Freud believed in the
religion of disease (neuroticism) and agreed with
the notions of nature. (2006) (Lerner). The
adversarial relationships that resulted from such
views lasted until the end of the twentieth
century, paving the stage for the twenty-first
century to appear ignorant to mental care.
According to some, the clash between
psychology and religion/spirituality is a logical
extension of the fundamental conflict between
science
and
religion/spirituality.
The
incorporation of a medical model into a
psychiatrist has resulted in its association with
empirical science founded on awareness as a
form of knowing. Religion, on the other hand, is
founded on "revealed" information. Sufi
experience, as previously discussed in this work,
explores prophetic moments of revelation and
may provide a tool to investigate religion
"scientifically." As a result, Sufism can provide
as a vital link between psychiatrists and religion.
From a medical point of view, psychology is
concerned with aspects of human life, governed
by scientific facts and religious values (Fulford,
2013). Psychiatry by considering both aspects of
human life can develop into a discipline with a
more complete understanding of human behavior
that can contribute to the understanding and
treatment of mental illness. Therefore, Psychiatry
needs to avoid apathy and actively participate in
religious research both from a philosophical and
medical point of view.
Clinical encounter
Sufism has recently grown in both eastern and
western countries, much like other spiritual
movements. Sufi practises, or beliefs in this
context, are an essential component of the
worldview of a sizable and expanding population
both within and outside of the Islamic world.
Journal of Positive School Psychology
More of these people will use mental health
services as a result of the persistent rise in mental
health issues in recent years (World Health
Organization, 2001). Interactions between Sufiinclined individuals and mental health services
lead to issues that demand attention on many
different levels.
Mental health providers' perspectives on patients'
belief systems: Self-healing There is proof that
mental health professionals help patients by
taking their spiritual needs into account
(Josephson, 2008). Unfortunately, even among
those in the mental-health field, there are a lot of
myths regarding religion and spirituality.
According to a recent study (Fulford, 2013), 45%
of mental health experts believe that religion can
contribute to mental health issues. Studies reveal
both beneficial and negative effects of spiritual
and religious beliefs and practises on people's
physical and mental well-being, providing
conflicting evidence for this at the moment
(Foskett, et al., 2004) It's interesting to note that
study has indicated that humans' physical and
mental health. The level of medical satisfaction
of religious individuals fluctuates according to
the physician's religion; inferiority to unbelievers
(Bhugra, 2001). (Bhugra, 2001).
Instilling in professionals a more purposeful
attitude that clearly involves keeping their beliefs
and religious practises out of the clinical setting
is an important component of current training in
health and mental health. As (D'souza, et al.,
1997) noted, whether intentionally or
unintentionally, this consideration has diverted
from keeping our religious and spiritual patients'
beliefs and needs out of the medical field, failing
the very purpose of health care - a healthy person
- to be. Since many Sufis are likely to use mental
health services in growing localities, it is
important for mental health professionals to make
an effort to understand these people's beliefs and
practises. The fact that mental health
professionals do not compel or impose their
Mazhar Farid Chishti
religious or spiritual beliefs on their patients
should be noted.
Sufi doctrines and methods: Historical research
However, a thorough examination of a mentally
ill patient may not always include a review of
their spiritual practises and beliefs. This is
perplexing, especially in the Orient where Sufi
spirituality and practises are deeply ingrained in
the local culture. The psychological medical
model utilised by mental health professionals and
a lack of training, interest, time, and discomfort
with the topic are the main causes of this neglect
(Fehring, et al., 1987).
Spirituality, including Sufism, is more than just a
collection of beliefs and practises; it seeks
answers to some of the most important questions
of human life and death, which take on added
significance during illness. Religious and
spiritual beliefs, not surprisingly, reduce the risk
of suicide in mentally ill patients (Foskett, 2004).
As a result, religious and spiritual examination,
including Sufi beliefs, should be used in the
screening of people with mental illnesses in order
to establish a patient-centered management
system that takes advantage of each patient's
spiritual strengths as well (Cox,1997).
Sufi beliefs and practises should be examined
individually for each patient. Unless Sufi's
concern contributes to the crisis, the test may be
postponed for a critically ill patient. As always, a
cursory examination should be followed by
careful consideration. A variety of short-term
testing methods for general spiritual evaluation
have been proposed, which can aid in diagnosing
patients before moving on to more in-depth
testing (Cox, 1997; Fulford, 2013). The four air
areas recommended by any psychiatry. Testing
appears to be a good starting point, but it must be
modified to test Sufi beliefs and practises.
Preliminary testing should include the following:
Faith: What role does faith play in everyday life?
Sufism's beliefs and practises are being followed
20
by an increasing number of people from religious
backgrounds other than Islam, so a mixture of
beliefs and practises is to be expected.
Influence: What is the impact of faith on life, both
past and present? Sufi self-harm practises can,
without influencing the belief system, result in
significant changes in real life, which must be
properly understood.
Are you a member of any religious or spiritual
community? Almost every Sufi believer is of one
race or another (the clan), and their beliefs and
practises may differ greatly. A genetic test can
help you understand someone else's perspective
on health and illness.
Address: Spiritual needs to be considered? A Sufi
teacher to whom a given person holds an oath of
allegiance (bay’a) may need to be included in a
medical program in order to meet spiritual needs.
An in-depth discussion, from a clinical and
psychiatric perspective, may follow this
depending on the patient's needs as expressed
during the examination (Giordano, 2006; Fulford,
2013).
Diagnostic considerations
Sufi practises and beliefs can have a significant
impact on one's mental health and general
wellbeing. Benefits may include giving life
meaning, improving quality of life, improving
physical and mental health, and hastening the
recovery from mental illness. However, these
attitudes and behaviours sometimes result in
severe harm and may be linked to mental illness
or even the symptoms of psychopathology.
The fourth text revision of the Nosology
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders (DSM-TR) offers two-dimensional
insides and outsides for those with and without
mental illness. In some cases, V-code is assigned
to religious and spiritual issues, which may have
a clinical focus. As an alternative, under the
21
DSM-IV-multiaxial TR's diagnostic programme,
axis
IV
identifies
psychological
and
environmental factors that may affect the
diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis of mental
disorders (axis I and II), where spiritual and
religious issues do not meet the V code's upper
limit. Conversion to a new religion (including
sectarianism), rejection of a previous religion or
loss of faith, strengthening of beliefs and
practises, guilt, unexplained experiences, neardeath encounters, and responses to chronic illness
are examples of religious and spiritual problems.
(Koenig, 2020; et al.)
Sufi experiences and emotional events that stand
out Sufi experiences are diverse, encompassing
thought, vision, and feeling. For two reasons,
many of these encounters will never result in
clinical care: These experiences are deeply rooted
in the spirituo-cultural context into which a
person is born, and there is little that can be done
to prevent them. Much of the clinical care
experience can be classified based on
phenomenological factors. Tradition determines
the content of the experience, which may or may
not affect the diagnosis; it is a method of
experience that distinguishes both and may result
in a diagnosis. Separating the form and content of
the experience should prevent the past from being
misinterpreted as religious madness (Hathaway,
et al., 2022). However, for phenomenological
reasons (form), events such as psychological
symptoms (delusions and hallucinations) occur
during unreasonable spiritual experiences. The
separation of these experiences raises concerns
about the legitimacy of the concepts of mental
illness and spiritual experience on the one hand.
It is not surprising, then, that extremist views on
the nature of such events have been debated - they
classify all of these as either mental or spiritual,
depending on one's inclination. A balanced
perspective suggests that the difference between
these experiences is likely to be based on your
well-being (spiritual things are generally
encouraging), a natural environment (spiritual
Journal of Positive School Psychology
experiences are less severe), a decline in
performance (spiritual experiences are rarely
ineffective), and, as explored by (Jackson, et al.,
2022). One Health should be the future of
psychiatry. Environmental Health Reviews
Discuss how the experience in question is
founded on human values and beliefs. Again,
because diversity has value, it varies across
cultures and is questionable.
Conclusion
In many developing nations, the vast majority of
those suffering from mental illness seek out or
receive spiritual healers' assistance. The causes
are found in people's belief systems, which
encourage a spiritually oriented definition of
mental illness and almost nonexistent mental
health care services in many rural areas. This is
demonstrated by the large number of mentally ill
people who seek treatment at the sacred shrines
(dargah) of the Sufi saints. A two-step procedure
is necessary to integrate spiritual / Sufi items into
mental health care services:
the integration of psychiatrists and Sufis into the
delivery system of mental health care, which may
include fundamental instruction in the diagnosis
of mental illness and necessary referrals.
Including spiritual and Sufi practices and beliefs
in therapy may encourage more spiritually astute
people to seek out mental health care.
Both organizational and individual effort are
needed for the integration of spiritual beliefs and
practises into the delivery of mental health care.
It is necessary to raise awareness of those who are
receiving training in spiritual and mental health
issues. Understanding spirituality as a crucial
component of someone seeking help and
thoroughly comprehending people's beliefs in the
area of practice should be the main foci of
training.
Mazhar Farid Chishti
22
References
1. Addas, C., & Kingsley, P. (1993). Quest
for the red sulphur: The life of Ibn'Arabi.
The Islamic Texts Society.
2. Ai, A. L., Pargament, K., Kronfol, Z.,
Tice, T. N., & Appel, H. (2010).
Pathways to postoperative hostility in
cardiac patients: Mediation of coping,
spiritual struggle and interleukin6. Journal of Health Psychology, 15(2),
186-195.
3. Arberry, A. J. (2013). Sufism: An
account of the mystics of Islam.
Routledge.
4. Attar, F. A. D. (2013). Muslim Saints and
Mystics: Episodes from the Tadhkirat alAuliya'(Memorial of the Saints).
Routledge.
5. Basu, S. (1995). How the spiritual
dimension of health was acknowledged
by the world health assembly-A
report. New Approaches Med Health, 3,
47-51.
6. Nizamie, S. H., Katshu, M. Z. U. H., &
Uvais, N. A. (2013). Sufism and mental
health. Indian
journal
of
psychiatry, 55(Suppl 2), S215.
7. Bhugra, D. (Ed.). (2001). Psychiatry and
religion. Taylor & Francis.
8. Bhugra, D. (Ed.). (2001). Psychiatry and
religion. Taylor & Francis.
9. Braam, A. W., Beekman, A. T., Deeg, D.
J., Smit, J. H., & van Tilburg, W. (1997).
Religiosity as a protective or prognostic
factor of depression in later life; results
from a community survey in The
Netherlands. Acta
Psychiatrica
Scandinavica, 96(3), 199-205.
10. Chittick, W. C. (2010). The Sufi path of
knowledge: Ibn al-Arabi's metaphysics
of imagination. Suny Press.
11. Cox, J. L. (1997). Psychiatry and
religion: Context, consensus and
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
controversies. Psychiatry and Religion.
London: Routledge, 157-166.
Dehlvi, S. (2010). Sufism: the heart of
Islam. HarperCollins Publ. India.
Fehring, R. J., Brennan, P. F., & Keller,
M. L. (1987). Psychological and spiritual
well‐being in college students. Research
in nursing & health, 10(6), 391-398.
Foskett, J., Marriott, J., & Wilson-Rudd,
F. (2004). Mental health, religion and
spirituality: Attitudes, experience and
expertise
among
mental
health
professionals and religious leaders in
Somerset. Mental Health, Religion &
Culture, 7(1), 5-22.
Fulford, K. W. M. (2013). Religion and
psychiatry: Extending the limits of
tolerance.
In Psychiatry
and
Religion (pp. 5-22). Routledge.
Hathaway, D. B., de Oliveira e Oliveira,
F. H., Mirhom, M., Moreira-Almeida, A.,
Fung, W. L. A., & Peteet, J. R. (2022).
Teaching Spiritual and Religious
Competencies to Psychiatry Residents: A
Scoping
and
Systematic
Review. Academic
Medicine, 97(2),
300-310.
Lertxundi, U., Domingo-Echaburu, S.,
Brodin, T., Medrano, J., & Orive, G.
(2022). The future of psychiatry should
be
One
Health. Reviews
on
Environmental Health.
Bhugra, D. (Ed.). (2001). Psychiatry and
religion. Taylor & Francis.
Lew, B., Lester, D., Mustapha, F. I., Yip,
P., Chen, Y. Y., Panirselvam, R. R., ... &
Siau, C. S. (2022). Decriminalizing
suicide attempt in the 21st century: an
examination of suicide rates in countries
that penalize suicide, a critical
review. BMC psychiatry, 22(1), 1-11.
Singh, B., & Sharan, P. (2022). The
contagion of mental illness: Insights
23
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
Journal of Positive School Psychology
from a Sufi shrine. Transcultural
psychiatry, 13634615221078131.
Knysh, A. (2022). Studying Sufism in
Russia: From Ideology to Scholarship
and Back. Der Islam, 99(1), 187-231.
Subandi, M. A., Chizanah, L. L., &
Subhan, S. (2022). Psychotheraputic
dimensions of an Islamic-sufi-based
rehabilitation
center:
A
case
study. Culture,
Medicine,
and
Psychiatry, 46(2), 582-601.
Afidah, I., Sholeh, N. S. M., Khuza’i, R.,
& Siddiq, A. A. (2022, April). Sufistic
Approach Psychotherapy as a MentalSpiritual Development Effort. In 4th
Social and Humanities Research
Symposium (SoRes 2021) (pp. 370-373).
Atlantis Press.
Subandi, M. A., Chizanah, L. L., &
Subhan, S. (2022). Psychotheraputic
dimensions of an Islamic-sufi-based
rehabilitation
center:
A
case
study. Culture,
Medicine,
and
Psychiatry, 46(2), 582-601.
Kanwal, F., Abbasi, K. S., Sufi, H. K.,
Junaid, K. M., Khan, S. A., & Tuasene,
A. (2022). Study of Health Care Services
at Tertiary Care Setting and Patient
Satisfaction. Pakistan Journal of Medical
& Health Sciences, 16(03), 1199-1199.
Singh, B., & Sharan, P. (2022). The
contagion of mental illness: Insights
from a Sufi shrine. Transcultural
psychiatry, 13634615221078131.
Koenig, H. G., Al-Zaben, F., &
VanderWeele, T. J. (2020). Religion and
psychiatry: Recent developments in
research. BJPsych advances, 26(5), 262272.
Fulford, K. W. M., & Jackson, M.
(1997). Spiritual experience and
psychopathology. Philosophy,
Psychiatry, & Psychology, 4(1), 41-65.
29. Giordano, J., & Engebretson, J. (2006).
Neural and cognitive basis of spiritual
experience: Biopsychosocial and ethical
implications
for
clinical
medicine. Explore, 2(3), 216-225.
30. Griffiths, R. R., Richards, W. A.,
McCann, U., & Jesse, R. (2006).
Psilocybin can occasion mystical-type
experiences having substantial and
sustained personal meaning and spiritual
significance. Psychopharmacology, 187(
3), 268-283.
31. Iqbal, M. (1934). The Reconstruction of
Religious Thought in Islam (London:
Oxford Univ. Pr.).
32. Josephson, A. M., & Peteet, J. R. (Eds.).
(2008). Handbook of spirituality and
worldview in clinical practice. American
Psychiatric Pub.
33. Karamustafa, A. T. (2007). Sufism: The
formative period. Edinburgh University
Press.
34. Keating, A. M., & Fretz, B. R. (1990).
Christians'
anticipations
about
counselors in response to counselor
descriptions. Journal of Counseling
Psychology, 37(3), 293.
35. Kendler, K. S., Liu, X. Q., Gardner, C.
O., McCullough, M. E., Larson, D., &
Prescott, C. A. (2003). Dimensions of
religiosity and their relationship to
lifetime psychiatric and substance use
disorders. American
journal
of
psychiatry, 160(3), 496-503.
36. Koenig, H. G., George, L. K., &
Peterson, B. L. (1998). Religiosity and
remission of depression in medically ill
older patients. American Journal of
Psychiatry, 155(4), 536-542.
37. Koenig, H., Koenig, H. G., King, D., &
Carson, V. B. (2012). Handbook of
religion and health. Oup Usa.
Mazhar Farid Chishti
38. Lerner, M., & Lyvers, M. (2006). Values
and beliefs of psychedelic drug users: A
cross-cultural
study. Journal
of
psychoactive drugs, 38(2), 143-147.
39. Lipsedge, M. (2018). Religion and
madness in history. In Psychiatry and
Religion (pp. 23-47). Routledge.
40. Lo, B., Quill, T., Tulsky, J., & ACPASIM End-of-Life Care Consensus
Panel. (1999). Discussing palliative care
with patients. Annals of Internal
Medicine, 130(9), 744-749.
41. Lukoff, D., & Lu, F. (2005). A
transpersonal-integrative approach to
spiritually oriented psychotherapy.
42. M. Puchalski, C., Larson, D. B., & Lu, F.
G. (2001). Spirituality in psychiatry
residency
training
programs. International
Review
of
Psychiatry, 13(2), 131-138.
43. Muramoto, O. (2004). The role of the
medial prefrontal cortex in human
religious
activity. Medical
hypotheses, 62(4), 479-485.
44. Newberg, A. B., & Iversen, J. (2003).
The neural basis of the complex mental
task of meditation: neurotransmitter and
neurochemical considerations. Medical
hypotheses, 61(2), 282-291.
45. Newberg, A. B., & Lee, B. Y. (2005).
The neuroscientific study of religious
and spiritual phenomena: Or why God
doesn't use biostatistics. Zygon®, 40(2),
469-490.
46. Nizamie, S. H., Katshu, M. Z. U. H., &
Uvais, N. A. (2013). Sufism and mental
health. Indian
journal
of
psychiatry, 55(Suppl 2), S215.
47. Pargament, K. I., Koenig, H. G.,
Tarakeshwar, N., & Hahn, J. (2001).
Religious struggle as a predictor of
mortality among medically ill elderly
patients:
A
2-year
longitudinal
24
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
study. Archives
of
internal
Medicine, 161(15), 1881-1885.
Pickthall Muhammad, M., & Pickthall,
M. W. (1996). The Glorious Qur’an:
Text and Explanatory Translation.
Propst, L. R., Ostrom, R., Watkins, P.,
Dean, T., & Mashburn, D. (1992).
Comparative efficacy of religious and
nonreligious
cognitive-behavioral
therapy for the treatment of clinical
depression
in
religious
individuals. Journal of consulting and
clinical psychology, 60(1), 94.
Rasic, D. T., Belik, S. L., Elias, B., Katz,
L. Y., Enns, M., Sareen, J., & Team, S.
C. S. P. (2009). Spirituality, religion and
suicidal behavior in a nationally
representative
sample. Journal
of
affective disorders, 114(1-3), 32-40.
Schimmel,
A.
(1975). Mystical
dimensions of Islam. Univ of North
Carolina Press.
Smith, M. (1995). Studies in early
mysticism in the Near and Middle East.
Oneworld.
Sperry, L. (2001). Spirituality in clinical
practice: Incorporating the spiritual
dimension in psychotherapy and
counseling. Psychology Press.
. Sensky, T., & Fenwick, P. (1983).
Religiosity, mystical experience and
epilepsy. Research progress in epilepsy,
214-220.
Swinton, J. (2001). Spirituality and
mental health care: Rediscovering
a'forgotten'dimension.
Tucker, D. M., Novelly, R. A., & Walker,
P. J. (1987). Hyperreligiosity in temporal
lobe
epilepsy:
redefining
the
relationship. Journal of Nervous and
Mental Disease.
Turner, R. P., Lukoff, D., Barnhouse, R.
T., & Lu, F. G. (1995). Religious or
spiritual problem: A culturally sensitive
25
diagnostic category in the DSMIV. Journal of nervous and mental
disease.
58. Turner, R. P., Lukoff, D., Barnhouse, R.
T., & Lu, F. G. (1995). Religious or
spiritual problem: A culturally sensitive
diagnostic category in the DSMIV. Journal of nervous and mental
disease.
59. Vaughan, F. (1991). Spiritual issues in
psychotherapy. Journal of Transpersonal
psychology, 23(2), 105-119.
Journal of Positive School Psychology
60. Walter, R. D. (1973). Progress in
Epilepsy. California Medicine, 119(1),
67.
61. World Health Organization. (2001). The
World Health Report 2001: Mental
health: new understanding, new hope.
62. Yogesh Hole et al 2019 J. Phys.: Conf.
Ser. 1362 012121