Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Unhindered car movement_ what about pedestrians

2014, The daily NEWAGE (Op-ED)

There has recently been a model around to address traffic congestion in the capital Dhaka. The model suggest stopping perpendicular movement of cars with dividers in intersections and creating internal U-turn systems for right- side moving vehicles in other roads. In this article I shared some of my comments on this proposal.

11/4/2014 Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age Print Version » Archives » E-store » Downloads » Play » Advertise » Saturday, October 25, 2014 Home Politics Business International » National Sports » Editorial » Entertainment » You are here: Home » Op-Ed Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? October 26, 2014 12:03 am·0 comments There has recently been a model around to address traffic congestion in the capital Dhaka by stopping perpendicular movement of cars with dividers in intersections and creating internal U-turn systems for rightside moving vehicles in other roads. Md Rashed Bhuyan has some points to ponder Traffic congestion on a road stretch in Dhaka. — New Age/Sanaul Haque A new model that Kamrul Hasan, an engineer, has proposed to address traffic congestion in the capita Dhaka has hogged the headlines. Many national daily newspapers (including the daily Samakal, September 12) published reports on the model that aims to do away with the deployment of traffic police or employment of traffic signals in crossroads. http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 1/8 11/4/2014 Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age The proposal ensures this claim by recommending two interventions within the existing system of roads — (1) placing a permanent divider in one direction to stop direct perpendicular movements of cars, by making the intersection virtually one way, and (2) directing the right-side moving cars to the internal U-turn systems to be created in other roads by using dividers. The proposal has an associated 3D model as well. The system, being simple and economical in its approach, has received attention and comments in online social networking sites. In my opinion, such comments simply indicate people’s concern about severe traffic congestion in the capital Dhaka. On Dhaka’s roads, it seems, we are dying frogs trapped in a slippery frying pan. The failed transport system in Dhaka affects, literally, everything within the city. People, even the ones with little technical know-how on transport engineering, seem to be desperate in seeking a solution to this problem by any possible means. In such a situation, any kind of traffic solution, faulty or full of limitations, creates interest among city dwellers. The new proposal is one such example. Here I would present some of my comments by explicating both merits and demerits of the proposal. This proposed model tries its best to intervene less in the existing roads by not proposing flamboyant flyovers and big infrastructures on the roads. The proposal is admirable in its merit for hypothetically solving the car movements, provided that enough spaces are available to construct U-turns. Several technical problems might, however, arise out of the proposal. For example, buses need a turning radius of more than 30 feet. This will require a minimum 60 feet of internal diameter for a U-turn. Considering the two lane roads, 20 feet, on the two sides, the total minimum road width for the proposal to be functional will be 100 feet, excluding the footpaths. Feasibility of such a land-demanding proposal in the narrow roads of Dhaka will pose a major question. The proposal provides no clue to this aspect. More importantly, beyond the engineering demerits, the recommended model fails to consider one of the vital elements in the streets of Dhaka — the pedestrian traffic. Evidently, the pedestrians are the main stakeholders of Dhaka’s traffic system. Spontaneous and unregulated pedestrian flow in vehicular crossings is also one of the main causes of traffic congestion on busy roads. The design mentioned above simply misses the point that pedestrians need to cross the road as urgently as cars. To encourage the creator of the proposed model to further improve his proposal, we might pose some relevant questions. The first question is — how can this model be developed to address the problems faced by humans (pedestrians) and machines (cars) simultaneously? We must remember that human factors should prevail on the streets of Dhaka rather than technical factors. How can then pedestrians be included in the proposed system? Will pedestrians use footbridges while crossing intersections with fast-moving vehicles? If the answer is yes, it is not mentioned in the proposal. What has been considered for the otherwise able people and the elderly? They certainly need proper means, such as elevators or ramps, to fulfil their right to free movement. Moreover, how can behaviours of pedestrians be regulated so that they will use the associated footbridges, if any, rather than jumping on to the vehicular road and stopping car movements? Considering such basic issues, the discussed model seems to be totally misplaced. Furthermore, media display of such simplistic model might mislead people about the complexities the road traffic system in Dhaka is riddled with. Md Rashed Bhuyan is an architect and a PhD candidate at the School of Design and Environment at the National University of Singapore. Like 0 http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 2/8 11/4/2014 Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age WHAT'S THIS? AROUND THE WEB World News Disqus The A, B, C's of Promoting Content Cracker Barrel rejects latest attempt to force a sale ALSO ON NEW AGE POS terminals may act like ATM booths 1 comment Thousands pay last respects as Piash Karim laid to rest 4 comments Cosmic Jovian – the new cosmetic nirvana Agencies being used to split party: Khaleda 2 comments 0 Comments 2 comments New Age  Sort by Oldest Login Share ⤤ Favorite ★ Start the discussion… Be the first to comment. ✉ Subscribe Search d Add Disqus to your site  Privacy Search http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 3/8 11/4/2014 Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age ONLINE POLL Do you think India breaks international law by making unilateral decision without informing Bangladesh about its projects on the trans-boundary rivers? Yes No No comment Vote View Results Most Viewed http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 4/8 11/4/2014 Most Commented Comments Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age Most Viewed 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Latif Siddique says he is ‘dead against’ hajj, Tabligh 2227 views New pay scale from January 1013 views Malala, Kailash win Nobel Peace Prize 889 views Tigers told to skip 75 meals 871 views Anisul refutes claim Piash’s family was anti-liberation 858 views Most Commented 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Mamata calls Modi a ‘donkey’ 3 comments Tangail-8 by-poll underway 3 comments Russia bashing: hatred, hysteria and humbug 3 comments Gaza operation to continue: Israel PM 2 comments Pakistanis debate VIP culture after lawmakers thrown off plane 2 comments Comments Rahman Mostafiz on Don’t create violence in name of movement Rahman Mostafiz on Political analyst, professor Piash Karim passes away Rais Uddin Ahmed Ripon on Political analyst, professor Piash Karim passes away Fareed Wakil on PCB’s BCB diplomacy bears little fruit Naim Ahamed on BotTala to organise its first int’l theatre fest Periodicals Weeklies Monthly http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 5/8 11/4/2014 Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age Special Supplements 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 11th Anniversary Special 2014 (Two) 11th Anniversary Special 2014 (One) New Age Eid Special magazine 2014 Special Supplement on Kalpana Chakma’s unresolved abduction, 18 years on... (June 12, 2014) Special Supplement on Energy Security in Bangladesh (May 25, 2014) Cartoon Gallery Photo Gallery ă Ą http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 6/8 11/4/2014 Advertisement Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age Follow Us Facebook Twitter RSS Feeds You Tube ARCHIVES October 2014 M T W T F S S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 « Sep Advertisement Advertisement http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 7/8 11/4/2014 Unhindered car movement: what about pedestrians? | New Age About Archives Privacy Policy Advertisement Rates Contact Editor: Nurul Kabir, Published by the Chairman, Editorial Board ASM Shahidullah Khan on behalf of Media New Age Ltd. 30 Tejgaon Industrial Area, Dhaka-1208 Phone: 880-2-8170450-56 (PABX), Fax: 880-2-8170457 Copyright © 2014 — New Age. All Rights Reserved Developed by ClusterBD http://newagebd.net/60832/unhindered-car-movement-what-about-pedestrians/#sthash.vTU4G9jX.dpbs 8/8