Insights Imaging (2012) 3 (Suppl 1):S135 3– S363
DOI 10.1007/s13244-012-0158-z
%
6FLHQWLÀF6HVVLRQV
6HVVLRQQXPEHUVDUHSUHÀ[HGE\66
3UHVHQWDWLRQQXPEHUVDUHSUHÀ[HGE\
WKHOHWWHU%
6HVVLRQVDQGDEVWUDFWVDUHOLVWHGE\
GD\V
3UHVHQWDWLRQVIRUZKLFKWKHDXWKRU V
KDYHVXEPLWWHGDGGLWLRQDOPDWHULDODQG
LPDJHVWR(326DUHPDUNHGZLWK
LFRQ
WKH
7KXUVGD\
)ULGD\
6DWXUGD\
6XQGD\
0RQGD\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
7KXUVGD\0DUFK
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP%
1HXUR
66D
1HXURYDVFXODU05,
0RGHUDWRUV
**XDUQLHUL1DSOHV,7
=0HUKHPLF6DUDMHYR%$
%
1RQLQYDVLYH&95DVVHVVPHQWXVLQJ$6/DQG%2/'
$3RUWHOR,6RXVD39LOHOD3)LJXHLUHGR/LVERQ37 IHUURYLOHOD#VDSRSW
3XUSRVH:HDLPHGWRGHYHORSDUHSURGXFLEOHSURWRFROIRUQRQLQYDVLYHDVVHVV
PHQWRIFHUHEURYDVFXODUUHDFWLYLW\ &95 FRPELQLQJDEUHDWKKROG %+ FKDOOHQJH
ZLWK&%)PHDVXUHPHQWVXVLQJ$6/LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKDPDWFKLQJ%2/'SURWRFRO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$JURXSRIKHDOWK\VXEMHFWVZDVVWXGLHGRYHUVHVVLRQV
RQD705,%2/'LPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJ*((3,VHTXHQFHDQG$6/LPDJHV
ZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJ47,363,&25(VHTXHQFHIURPFRQWLJXRXVVOLFHV7KH%+
SURWRFROFRQVLVWHGRQ %2/' $6/ F\FOHVRIV%+DOWHUQDWHGZLWKQRUPDO
EUHDWKLQJ7KHGDWDZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJ)6/LQFOXGLQJVWDQGDUGSUHSURFHVVLQJ
VWHSVDQGJHQHUDOOLQHDUPRGHOVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV%RWK%2/'DQG&%)PDSVRI
&95ZHUHREWDLQHGIRUHDFKVXEMHFWDQGVHVVLRQVKRZLQJVLJQLÀFDQWUHVSRQVHV
WR%+HVSHFLDOO\LQJUH\PDWWHU&95PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHREWDLQHGDVSHUFHQW
VLJQDOFKDQJHVDYHUDJHGDFURVVWKHDFWLYDWLRQPDSVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKH%2/'
DQG&%)UHVSRQVHV,QWUDDQGLQWHUVXEMHFWYDULDELOLW\ZDVPHDVXUHGLQWHUPVRI
WKHUHVSHFWLYHFRHIÀFLHQWVRIYDULDWLRQ &9
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQSHUFHQWVLJQDOFKDQJHDYHUDJHGDFURVVWKH&95PDSVZDV
DQG IRU %2/' VHVVLRQV DQG DQG
IRU%2/'$6/VHVVLRQVDQGDQGDQGIRU&%)VHVVLRQVDQG
7KHLQWUDDQGLQWHUVXEMHFWYDULDELOLW\ZDV&9LQWUD DQG&9LQWHU IRU
%2/' &9LQWUD DQG &9LQWHU IRU %2/'$6/ DQG &9LQWUD DQG
&9LQWHU IRU&%)
&RQFOXVLRQ1RQLQYDVLYH&95DVVHVVHGE\I05,E\PHDVXULQJWKH%2/'DQG
&%)UHVSRQVHVWREUHDWKKROG %+ FKDOOHQJHVLVDUHSURGXFLEOHPHWKRG
%
$FXWHRQVHWPLJUDLQRXVDXUDPLPLFNLQJDFXWHVWURNH05SHUIXVLRQ
LPDJLQJIHDWXUHV
')ORHU\059RVNR)$)HOOQHU)*UXEHU&*LQWKRHU
*5DQVPD\U08GHU:*%UDGOH\&)HOOQHU/LQ]$7(UODQJHQ'(
6DQ'LHJR&$865HJHQVEXUJ'( GDQLHOÁRHU\#DNKOLQ]DW
3XUSRVH,QDYHU\OLPLWHGQXPEHURIFDVHVDFXWHPLJUDLQRXVDXUDPD\SUHVHQW
FOLQLFDOO\DVDFXWHEUDLQLQIDUFWLRQ6LQFHWKHVHSDWLHQWVLQFUHDVLQJO\XQGHUJRVWURNH
05WKHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHSDWWHUQVRI05SHUIXVLRQDEQRUPDOLWLHV
LQDFXWHPLJUDLQRXVDXUD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDUHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLV05VWXGLHVSHUIRUPHG
IRU WKH VXVSLFLRQ RI DFXWH EUDLQ LQIDUFWLRQ ZHUH DQDO\VHG IRU SDWLHQWV VXIIHULQJ
IURPDFXWHPLJUDLQRXVDXUDDQGQRWIURPVWURNH FOLQLFDOO\DQGLPDJLQJEDVHG
$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGFOLQLFDOO\E\WZRQHXURORJLVWVDQGXQGHUZHQWDVWURNH
05 SURWRFRO LQFOXGLQJ SHUIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ 7ZR UDGLRORJLVWV UHYLHZHG
SHUIXVLRQPDSVYLVXDOO\DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHIRUSUHVHQFHYDVFXODUWHUULWRU\DQGJUDGH
RISHUIXVLRQDEQRUPDOLW\
5HVXOWV$PRQJ05VWXGLHV SDWLHQWVZHUHIRXQGZKRUHFHLYHG
DFXWHPLJUDLQRXVDXUDDVWKHÀQDOGLDJQRVLVDIWHUFRPSOHWHFOLQLFDODQGLPDJLQJ
ZRUNXS+\SRSHUIXVLRQZDVIRXQGLQRISDWLHQWV ZLWKGHOD\HGU077
DQG773DQGGHFUHDVHGU&%9DQGU&%)QRWFRQÀQHGWRDVLQJOHYDVFXODUWHUULWRU\
%LODWHUDOK\SRSHUIXVLRQZDVVHHQLQFDVHVLQFDVHVK\SRSHUIXVLRQZLWK
DSRVWHULRUSUHGRPLQDQFHZDVIRXQG773DQGU077ZHUHWKHEHVWPDSVWRGHSLFW
SHUIXVLRQFKDQJHVDWYLVXDODVVHVVPHQWEXWDOVRU&%)PDSVGHPRQVWUDWHGVLJ
QLÀFDQWK\SRSHUIXVLRQDWTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLV,QDOOSDWLHQWVFOLQLFDODQGLPDJLQJ
IROORZXSZDVQHJDWLYHIRUVWURNH
&RQFOXVLRQ$FXWHPLJUDLQRXVDXUDLVDUDUHEXWLPSRUWDQWGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLV
DPRQJSDWLHQWVUHIHUUHGIRU05XQGHUWKHVXVSLFLRQRIDFXWHEUDLQLQIDUFWLRQ&KDU
DFWHULVWLFSHUIXVLRQDEQRUPDOLWLHVFDQEHVHHQLQWKHPDMRULW\RIFDVHV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
5HPLVVLRQRIGLIIXVLRQOHVLRQVLQDFXWHVWURNH05LPDJLQJD
IROORZXSVWXG\ZLWKFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV
')ORHU\&*LQWKRHU5:XQQ)$)HOOQHU/LQ]$7 GDQLHOÁRHU\#DNKOLQ]DW
3XUSRVH7KHPLVPDWFKFRQFHSWLQVWURNH05LVEDVHGRQWKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDW
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ LQGLFDWHV LQIDUFW FRUH UHSUHVHQWLQJ LUUHYHUVLEO\ GDP
DJHGWLVVXH+RZHYHUWKLVWKHVLVKDVQRW\HWEHHQSURYHQLQDODUJHSDWLHQWFRKRUW
ZLWKDGHTXDWH05IROORZXS7KXVWKHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDQDO\VHWHPSRUDO
HYROXWLRQRIUHVWULFWHGGLIIXVLRQDWIROORZXS05ZLWKLQKRXUV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH VWURNH SDWLHQWV ZLWKLQ PRQWKV
GHPRQVWUDWLQJUHVWULFWHGGLIIXVLRQDWLQLWLDO05H[DPLQDWLRQZHUHHYDOXDWHG([WHQ
VLRQRIGLIIXVLRQUHVWULFWLRQZDVMXGJHGERWKRQLQLWLDO05DVZHOODVRQIROORZXS
DIWHUKRXUV&KDQJHVLQOHVLRQH[WHQVLRQZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWV
LQGHSHQGHQWO\DVZHOODVRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\ WLHUVFDOH
5HVXOWV([WHQVLRQRIOHVLRQVZLWKUHVWULFWHGGLIIXVLRQDWIROORZXS05ZDVLGHQWL
FDOWRWKHLQLWLDOVFDQLQ DQGLQFUHDVHGLQ 7KH
OHVLRQVZHUHGHFUHDVHG PHDQLQJSDUWLDOLQYROXWLRQRIWKHOHVLRQ LQ
DQGFRPSOHWHO\UHVROYHGLQ 0HDQUDWLQJRILPDJHTXDOLW\ZDV
IRULQLWLDO05,DQGIRUIROORZXS7KDWPHDQVLQWKHLQLWLDOOHVLRQZLWK
UHVWULFWHGGLIIXVLRQSURYHGWREHWKHLQIDUFWLRQFRUHLQGHHGZKHUHDVLQSDUWLDO
UHVROXWLRQZDVVHHQ2QO\LQRIDOOSDWLHQWVWKHLQLWLDOOHVLRQGLGQRWUHVXOWLQ
FRPSOHWHLQIDUFWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUÀQGLQJVSURYHWKHH[LVWLQJDVVXPSWLRQWKDWGLIIXVLRQUHVWULFWLRQ
UHSUHVHQWVLQIDUFWFRUHZKLFKPD\UHPDLQXQFKDQJHGRULQFUHDVHLQYROXPHRYHU
WLPH LQGLFDWLQJ DQ DFFXUDF\ RI DOPRVW 3DUWLDO RU FRPSOHWH UHVROXWLRQ RI
GLIIXVLRQUHVWULFWLRQLVH[WUHPHO\UDUH
%
$UWHULDOK\SHUWHQVLRQLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKURVWUDOYHQWURODWHUDOPHGXOOD
QHXURYDVFXODUFRPSUHVVLRQ
0+DUWHO0:yMFLN05XG]LĸVND$6]F]XGOLN(.OXF]HZVND
=DEU]H3/.UDNyZ3/.DWRZLFH3/ KDUWHO#YR[HOSO
3XUSRVH9HQWURODWHUDOPHGXOOD 9/0 LVWKHYDVRPRWRUFHQWUHFRPSULVLQJQHX
URQVZKLFKFRQWUROEORRGSUHVVXUHWKURXJKHIIHUHQWSDUDV\PSDWKHWLFFRQQHFWLRQV
3UHYLRXVVWXGLHVVXJJHVWWKDWK\SHUWHQVLRQLQKHPLIDFLDOVSDVP +)6 SDWLHQWVLV
FDXVHGE\9/0YDVFXODUFRPSUHVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV+)6SDWLHQWVDQGFRQWUROV PDWFKHGDFFRUGLQJWR
DJHDQGVH[ ZHUHVFDQQHGZLWK05,+\SHUWHQVLRQZDVFRQÀUPHGDFFRUGLQJWR
:+2FULWHULD7KHFRPSUHVVLRQZDVJUDGHGIURPWR ODFNRIYHVVHOFRQWDFW
ZLWKEUDLQVWHPYHVVHOFRQWDFWZLWKQRVWHPFRPSUHVVLRQYHVVHOFRQWDFWZLWK
PRGHUDWHVWHPFRPSUHVVLRQYHVVHOFRQWDFWZLWKPDUNHGEUDLQVWHPFRPSUHV
VLRQDQGLWVGHIRUPDWLRQGLVSODFHPHQW 6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVFDUULHGRXWXVLQJ
&KLVTXDUHGWHVW
5HVXOWV9/0YDVFXODUFRPSUHVVLRQZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHIUHTXHQWDPRQJSDU
WLFLSDQWVZLWKYVZLWKRXWK\SHUWHQVLRQLQ+)6 YVѯò S
DVZHOODVLQFRQWUROJURXS YVѯò S 7KHRFFXUUHQFHRI
9/0FRPSUHVVLRQZDVQRWUHODWHGWRWKHERG\VLGH0DUNHGFRPSUHVVLRQJUDGHG
DVDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWKDUWHULDOK\SHUWHQVLRQLQ+)6SDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ+\SHUWHQVLRQLQERWKJURXSVZLWKDQGZLWKRXW+)6LVSUHVHQWVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\RIWHQLQSDWLHQWVZLWK9/0FRPSUHVVLRQRQWKHULJKWRUWKHOHIWVLGH ZLWKRXW
ODWHUDOL]DWLRQ +\SHUWHQVLRQLVSUHVHQWPRUHRIWHQZLWKQGDQGUGJUDGH9/0
YDVFXODUFRPSUHVVLRQFRPSDULQJWRJUDGHDQG7KHVWXG\FRQÀUPHGFRUUHOD
WLRQEHWZHHQRFFXUUHQFHRIK\SHUWHQVLRQDQG9/0YDVFXODUFRPSUHVVLRQQRWRQO\
LQ+)6EXWDOVRLQSDWLHQWVUHIHUUHGIRU05,GXHWRRWKHUGLVHDVHV7KHFHQWUDO
PHFKDQLVPRIK\SHUWHQVLRQVKRXOGEHIXUWKHUHYDOXDWHG
%
&DURWLGDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHPRUSKRORJ\DQGLVFKDHPLFYDVFXODU
EUDLQGLVHDVHRQ05,
4-$YDQGHQ%RXZKXLMVHQ0:9HUQRRLM*3.UHVWLQ:-1LHVVHQ
0$,NUDP$+RIPDQ-&0:LWWHPDQ$YDQGHU/XJW5RWWHUGDP1/
TYDQGHQERXZKXLMVHQ#HUDVPXVPFQO
3XUSRVH9XOQHUDEOHSODTXHFRPSRQHQWVLQFDURWLGDUWHULHVFDQEHGHWHFWHGQRQ
LQYDVLYHO\ZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, ,QDV\PSWRPDWLFSHUVRQVWKH
UHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ FDURWLG SODTXH FRPSRVLWLRQ DQG YDVFXODU EUDLQ GLVHDVH LV QRW
ZHOOVWXGLHG:HVWXGLHGWKHDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQFDURWLGDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXH
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGLVFKDHPLFEUDLQGLVHDVHRQ05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URPWKHSRSXODWLRQEDVHG5RWWHUGDP6WXG\SDUWLFL
SDQWVZLWKFDURWLGZDOOWKLFNHQLQJRQXOWUDVRXQG!PPXQGHUZHQWERWKFDURWLG
05, DQG EUDLQ 05, 0D[LPXP FDURWLG ZDOO WKLFNHQLQJ GHJUHH RI VWHQRVLV DQG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
3URJUHVVLRQRIWKHPXOWLSOHK\SRLQWHQVHYHVVHOVLJQRQWKH
VXVFHSWLELOLW\ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDIWHUUHFDQDOLVDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
K\SHUDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
<:.LP6%DLN-<-DQJ6$KQ<DQJVDQ.5 YLPJV#KDQPDLOQHW
3XUSRVH7KH PXOWLSOH K\SRLQWHQVH YHVVHO VLJQ 0+96 RQ WKH 6:, KDV EHHQ
UHSRUWHGWRLGHQWLI\WKHLVFKDHPLFWHUULWRU\LQSWVZLWKK\SHUDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
:HHYDOXDWHGWKHSURJUHVVLRQRIWKLV0+96RQWKHLPPHGLDWH6:,DIWHUUHFDQDOLVD
WLRQDQGLWVFOLQLFDOLPSOLFDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVK\SHUDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNHSWVZKRZHUHWUHDWHG
ZLWKLQWUDDUWHULDORULQWUDYHQRXVWKURPERO\VLVZLWKLQKRXUVRI6[RQVHWDQGZKR
XQGHUZHQW LPPHGLDWH 05, DIWHU UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ ZHUH HQUROOHG LQ WKLV VWXG\ 7KH
UHFDQDOLVDWLRQVWDWXVZDVHYDOXDWHGLQFHUHEUDOLQIDUFWLRQ 7,&, VFRUHEHIRUHDQG
DIWHU WKURPERO\VLV7KH 6:,V ZHUH HYDOXDWHG IRU WKH SUHVHQFH RI 0+96 LQ WKH
LVFKDHPLFWHUULWRU\7KHYHLQVLQWKHLVFKDHPLFWHUULWRU\ZHUHFODVVLÀHGLQWRJUDGHV
5HVXOWV7KHLQLWLDO7,&,JUDGHVZHUHLQFDVHVDQGELQFDVHV$IWHUWKURP
ERO\VLVWKH7,&,JUDGHVZHUHLQDOOFDVHV7KH6:,VVKRZHGWKH0+96RYHUWKH
DIIHFWHGVLGHLQDOOSWVEHIRUHUHFDQDOLVDWLRQ $IWHUUHFDQDOLVDWLRQDOOSWV
GLGQRWVKRZWKH0+96RQ6:,7KHREVHUYHGYHLQVLQWKHDIIHFWHGDUHDZHUH
HTXDOLQSWVOHVVLQSWVDQGHTXDODQGOHVVWRJHWKHULQRQHSW
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH0+96RQ6:,FDQEHLQGLFDWLYHRIDFXWHWKURPERHPEROLFRF
FOXVLRQ DQG LWV FKDQJH LPPHGLDWHO\ DIWHU UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ FDQ EH XVHG WR SUHGLFW
WKHVWDWXVRIWKHÀQDOLQIDUFWLRQ$IWHUUHFDQDOLVDWLRQWKHDSSHDUDQFHRIWKHHTXDO
FRUWLFDOYHVVHOVLJQ UHWXUQWRQRUPDO RQ6:,ZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDIDYRXUDEOH
FOLQLFDORXWFRPHDQGHVFDSHGLQIDUFWLRQLQRXUVPDOOVHULHVVWXG\
%
8WLOLW\RIVXVFHSWLELOLW\ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJIRUGHWHFWLRQRIFDURWLG
FDYHUQRXVÀVWXODDFDVHFRQWUROVWXG\
+-.DPEOH5-%DVWL&-.HVDYDGDV%-7KRPDV7KLUXYDQDQWKSXUDP,1
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH XWLOLW\ DQG DFFXUDF\ RI VXVFHSWLELOLW\ZHLJKWHG 05,
6:, IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIFDURWLGFDYHUQRXVÀVWXOD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\LGHQWLÀHGSDWLHQWV JURXS RI'6$
SURYHGFDURWLGFDYHUQRXVÀVWXOD &&) >FDVHJURXS@SDWLHQWV JURXS '6$
QHJDWLYHIRU&&)>FRQWUROJURXS@DQGSDWLHQWVRIFDYHUQRXVVLQXVWKURPERVLV
ZLWKSURPLQHQW629 JURXS )RUDOOSDWLHQWV6:,VHTXHQFHZDVDYDLODEOH8VLQJ
XQLIRUPUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW 52, VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ZLWKLQVXSHULRURSKWKDOPLFYHLQ
629 DQGVXSHULRUVDJLWWDOVLQXV 666 ZHUHPHDVXUHGLQPDJQLWXGHLPDJH629
666VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\UDWLRZDVFDOFXODWHGLQHDFKSDWLHQWPHDQYDOXHVRIWKHWKUHH
JURXSVZHUHFRPSDUHGIRUDFFXUDF\
5HVXOWV629666VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\UDWLRVLQJURXSLQJURXSDQGLQ
JURXSZHUHLQFOXGHG0HDQVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRI629666UDWLRVIRUJURXS
JURXSJURXSLQGLUHFWW\SHDQGGLUHFWW\SHZHUH
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\0DQQ:KLWQH\ WDLOHG
WHVWEHWZHHQJURXSDQGDQGJURXSDQGZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWZLWK
3 3VLJQLÀFDQW $OOFDVHVDQGFRQWUROVZHUHUHOLDEO\GLVWLQJXLVKHG
ZLWK629666VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\UDWLRRIDVFXWRII7KLVLQFUHDVHGVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\
UDWLRZDVEHFDXVHRIDUWHULDOLVHGÁRZLQ629VHFRQGDU\WR&&)
&RQFOXVLRQ6:,LVIHDVLEOHDVZHOODVDFFXUDWHIRUGHWHFWLRQRIERWKGLUHFWDQG
LQGLUHFWFDURWLGFDYHUQRXVÀVWXODDQGQRQLQYDVLYHIROORZXSRIWUHDWHGSDWLHQWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
3UHVHUYHGUHJXODWLRQRILQWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUHLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
FHUHEUDODUWHULRYHQRXVPDOIRUPDWLRQV
)*0HLQHO-)LVFKHU1:RHKUOH,.RHUWH'6WHIÀQJHU53/DXEHQGHU
0)5HLVHU1$OSHULQ%(UWO:DJQHU0XQLFK'(0LDPL)/86
IHOL[PHLQHO#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH&HUHEUDODUWHULRYHQRXVPDOIRUPDWLRQV F$90V PD\OHDGWRDVLJQLÀFDQW
PDVVHIIHFW7RLGHQWLI\SDWLHQWVDWULVNZHQRQLQYDVLYHO\HYDOXDWHGLQWUDFUDQLDO
SUHVVXUH ,&3 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKF$90VDQGFRUUHODWHGLWZLWKQLGXVYROXPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHF$90SDWLHQWVDQGFRQWUROVPDWFKHG
IRUDJHDQGJHQGHUZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGZLWKD7HVOD05,VFDQQHU1LGXVYROXPH
ZDVTXDQWLÀHGE\05DQJLRJUDSK\7RWDODUWHULDOFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ W&%) YH
QRXVRXWÁRZDQGDTXHGXFWDODQGFUDQLRVSLQDO&6)VWURNHYROXPHVZHUHREWDLQHG
XVLQJYHORFLW\HQFRGHGFLQHSKDVHFRQWUDVW05,,&3ZDVGHULYHGIURPV\VWROLF
LQWUDFUDQLDOYROXPHFKDQJH ,&9& DQGSXOVHSUHVVXUHJUDGLHQW
5HVXOWVW&%)ZDVIRXQGWREHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQF$90SDWLHQWV PHGLDQQLGXV
YROXPHFPUDQJHFP DVFRPSDUHGWRFRQWUROV PHGLDQYV
P/PLQS 7KHPDMRUSURSRUWLRQRILQFUHDVHGYHQRXVRXWÁRZZDVIRXQG
LQWKHLSVLODWHUDOLQWHUQDOMXJXODUYHLQ ,-9YVP/PLQS ZKLOHWKHUH
ZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHLQVHFRQGDU\YHQRXVRXWÁRZ HSLGXUDOYHUWHEUDODQG
GHHSFHUYLFDOYHLQVYVP/PLQS 7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
LQPHGLDQ,&3EHWZHHQF$90SDWLHQWVDQGKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV YVPP+J
S DQG,&3GLGQRWFRUUHODWHZLWKQLGXVYROXPHLQF$90SDWLHQWV 6SHDUPDQ V
UKR :HGLGQRWREVHUYHVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQSDWLHQWVDQGFRQWUROV
UHJDUGLQJ,&9&FUDQLRVSLQDORUDTXHGXFWDOVWURNHYROXPH
&RQFOXVLRQ,&3LVNHSWZLWKLQQRUPDOOLPLWVHYHQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKODUJHF$90V
QLGXVYROXPHXSWRFP (OHYDWHGYHQRXVRXWÁRZLVPRVWO\IRXQGLQWKH
LSVLODWHUDOMXJXODUYHLQV
%
,QWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUHDFURVVWKHOLIHVSDQDVWXG\ZLWKSKDVH
FRQWUDVWLPDJLQJ
,.RHUWH$3RPVFKDU53/DXEHQGHU'6WHIÀQJHU)+HLQHQ05HLVHU
1$OSHULQ%(UWO:DJQHU0XQLFK'(0LDPL)/86
3XUSRVH,QWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUH ,&3 LVDQLPSRUWDQWFOLQLFDOSDUDPHWHUIRUGLDJ
QRVWLFDQGWKHUDSHXWLFGHFLVLRQPDNLQJDQGIROORZXSIRUH[DPSOHLQK\GURFHSKD
OXV WUDXPDWLF EUDLQ LQMXU\ QRUPDO SUHVVXUH K\GURFHSKDOXV 13+ RU LGLRSDWKLF
LQWUDFUDQLDOK\SHUWHQVLRQ ,,+ +RZHYHUQRUPDWLYHGDWDDFURVVWKHOLIHVSDQDUH
QRW DYDLODEOH XQWLO SUHVHQW :H DLPHG WR QRQLQYDVLYHO\ DVVHVV WKH LQWUDFUDQLDO
SUHVVXUHLQKHDOWK\VXEMHFWVDFURVVWKHOLIHVSDQXVLQJ05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$IWHULQIRUPHGFRQVHQWKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV PDOHV
IHPDOHVDJHWR\HDUV ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGRQD705,&LQHSKDVHFRQWUDVW
VHTXHQFHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGWRTXDQWLI\DUWHULDOLQÁRZYHQRXVRXWÁRZDQGFUDQLRV
SLQDO&6)ÁRZWRGHULYHDQ05HVWLPDWHRILQWUDFUDQLDOFRPSOLDQFHIURPWKHUDWLR
RIWKHPD[LPDOYROXPHDQGSUHVVXUHFKDQJHVWKDWRFFXUGXULQJWKHFDUGLDFF\FOH
,QWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUH 05,&3 ZDVHVWLPDWHGEDVHGRQWKHLQYHUVHUHODWLRQVKLS
EHWZHHQFRPSOLDQFHDQGSUHVVXUH'DWDZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQ
5HVXOWV$QLQFUHDVHRIDJHE\RQH\HDUSUHGLFWHGDGHFOLQHE\XQLWVRI
VTXDUHURRWHG05,&3 S KROGLQJJHQGHUFRQVWDQW:RPHQVKRZHGD
PP+J FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDOS KLJKHU05,&3ZKHQ
FRPSDUHGWRPHQKROGLQJDJHFRQVWDQW
&RQFOXVLRQ 1RQLQYDVLYHO\ PHDVXUHG 05,&3 GHFUHDVHV ZLWK DJH ZLWK D
JHQGHUGHSHQGHQFH7KHVHDJHDQGJHQGHUUHODWHGFKDQJHVQHHGWREHWDNHQ
LQWRFRQVLGHUDWLRQZKHQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGSDWKRORJ\DUHHYDOXDWHG
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
SUHVHQFHRILQWUDSODTXHKDHPRUUKDJHOLSLGFRUHDQGFDOFLÀFDWLRQZHUHDVVHVVHGLQ
ERWKFDURWLGDUWHULHV$VVRFLDWLRQVEHWZHHQSODTXHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGZKLWHPDWWHU
OHVLRQV :0/V ODFXQDUDQGFRUWLFDOLQIDUFWVZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGSHUSDUWLFLSDQWDQG
DGGLWLRQDOO\SHUFDURWLGDUWHU\$QDO\VLVZHUHDGMXVWHGIRUFDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNIDFWRUV
5HVXOWV&DURWLGVWHQRVLV 25SHUVWHQRVLVLQFUHDVH FRQÀGHQFH
LQWHUYDO PD[LPXPFDURWLGZDOOWKLFNQHVV SHUPPLQFUHDVH
LQ WKH SUHVHQFH RI LQWUDSODTXH KDHPRUUKDJH ZHUH DOO IRXQG WR EH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHSUHVHQFHRIFRUWLFDOLQIDUFWVERWKLQWKHSDUWLFLSDQW
EDVHGDQDO\VLVDQGLQWKHFDURWLGDUWHU\EDVHGDQDO\VLV7KHUHZHUHQRDVVRFLDWLRQV
EHWZHHQDQ\SODTXHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGSUHVHQFHRIODFXQDULQIDUFWV,QWKHVXEMHFW
EDVHGDQDO\VLVPD[LPXPSODTXHWKLFNQHVVSUHVHQFHRILQWUDSODTXHKDHPRUUKDJH
DQGFDOFLÀFDWLRQZHUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWK:0/YROXPH,QWKHDUWHU\EDVHGDQDO\VLV
RQO\WKHDVVRFLDWLRQIRUFDOFLÀFDWLRQVUHPDLQHG
&RQFOXVLRQ 3UHVHQFH RI FDURWLG LQWUDSODTXH KDHPRUUKDJH DQG PHDVXUHV RI
FDURWLG SODTXH VL]H DUH LQGHSHQGHQWO\ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK FRUWLFDO LQIDUFWV EXW QRW
ZLWKODFXQDULQIDUFWV3ODTXHFDOFLÀFDWLRQEXWQRWYXOQHUDEOHSODTXHFRPSRQHQWV
LVUHODWHGWR:0/YROXPH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP&
2QFRORJLF,PDJLQJ
66
7XPRXUELRORJ\UHVSRQVHDQGSURJQRVLV
0RGHUDWRUV
*%URZQ6XWWRQ8.
13RZHU:DWHUIRUG,(
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJDQLPSHUIHFWELRPDUNHUIRUWKH
PDOLJQDQF\RIEUHDVWWXPRXUV
+%LFNHO.3LQNHU'RPHQLJ:%RJQHU6*UXEHU0:HEHU7+HOELFK
9LHQQD$7 KXEHUWELFNHO#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHGLIIHUHQFHVLQDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHVRI
GLIIHUHQWW\SHVDQGJUDGHVRIPDOLJQDQWEUHDVWWXPRXUVDQGWKHLQÁXHQFHRIWKHVH
GLIIHUHQFHVRQWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG ':, 05,DW7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKSUHGHWHFWHGIRFDOEUHDVWOHVLRQV
ZHUHLQFOXGHG$OOVFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD705LPDJHUEHIRUHWKHDSSOLFD
WLRQRIDQ\WKHUDS\$7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHDGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGVLQJOHVKRWHFKR
SODQDU LPDJLQJ GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG VHTXHQFH ZLWK EYDOXHV VHFP DQG
DG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG '&( 7VHTXHQFHZHUHDSSOLHG/HVLRQVZHUH
LGHQWLÀHG RQ WKH '&(VHTXHQFH DQG$'& ZDV PHDVXUHG LQ WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ
$'&PDSV XVLQJ GLPHQVLRQDO UHJLRQV RI LQWHUHVW$Q$'&WKUHVKROG RI
ðPPòVZDVXVHGWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHQLJQIURPPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV$OOOHVLRQV
ZHUHELRSVLHGDQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\FODVVLÀHGXVLQJWKH710V\VWHP
5HVXOWV:KLOH$'&YDOXHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQDOOVXEW\SHVRIPDOLJQDQW
WXPRXUVWKDQLQEHQLJQOHVLRQV$'&YDOXHVRIQRQLQYDVLYHOHVLRQVZHUHVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKRVHRILQYDVLYHRQHV7XPRXUJUDGHVLQYHUVHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK
$'&YDOXHVEXWWKHGLIIHUHQFHZDVRQO\VLJQLÀFDQWEHWZHHQJUDGH,DQGJUDGH,,,
OHVLRQV:KLOHWKHRYHUDOOVHQVLWLYLW\ DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ RI':,ZHUH
JRRGDQDO\VLVRIWKHGLIIHUHQWWXPRXUVXEW\SHVUHYHDOHGDVHQVLWLYLW\RIRQO\
IRUQRQLQYDVLYHWXPRXUVZKLOHIRULQYDVLYHWXPRXUV LQYDVLYHGXFWDO DQG
LQYDVLYHOREXODU FRXOGEHREWDLQHG
&RQFOXVLRQ1RQLQYDVLYHEUHDVWWXPRXUVPD\SUHVHQWVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU$'&
YDOXHVWKDQLQYDVLYHRQHV7KLVPD\OHDGWRPDQ\IDOVHQHJDWLYHUHVXOWVZKLFK
KDVWREHFRQVLGHUHGZKHQXVLQJ':,DVDGLDJQRVWLFWRRO
%
$QHZGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJDSSURDFKIRUHYDOXDWLQJ
UHVSRQVHWRVRUDIHQLEWUHDWPHQWLQDGYDQFHGKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD
0/HZLQ/)DUWRX[$9LJQDXG/$UULYH<0HQX25RVPRUGXF
9LOOHMXLI)53DULV)56DLQW'HQLV)5 PDLWHOHZLQ#SEUDSKSIU
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& WKH
SXUHGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW ' DQGWKHSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ I LQDGYDQFHGKHSDWRFHO
OXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& SDWLHQWVUHFHLYLQJVRUDIHQLE
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ
SDWLHQWVXVLQJEYDOXHVRIDQGVPP7ZRWXPRXUVZHUHDQDO\VHG
LQHDFKSDWLHQWDWEDVHOLQHZHHNVDQGPRQWKVWUHDWPHQW$'&'DQGIZHUH
FDOFXODWHGE\VWDWLVWLFDOUHJUHVVLRQ
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQV RI OHVLRQ VL]H$'& DQG ' YDOXHV GLG QRW FKDQJH XQGHU
WUHDWPHQW UHVSHFWLYHO\PP[PPVDQG
[PPV +RZHYHUDWZHHNVDQGPRQWKVLQVHYHQUHVSRQGHUSDWLHQWV
I YDOXHV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ LQFUHDVHG 3 DQG 3 UH
VSHFWLYHO\ ZKHUHDVLQÀYHQRQUHVSRQGHUSDWLHQWVIYDOXHVGHFUHDVHG
3 DQG3 UHVSHFWLYHO\ )XUWKHUPRUHIYDOXHVZHUHLQYHUVHO\
FRUUHODWHG ZLWK њ)3 OHYHOV 3 DQG UHVSRQGHU SDWLHQWV VKRZHG D KLJKHU
RYHUDOO VXUYLYDO 26 WKDQ QRQUHVSRQGHU SDWLHQWV YV
PRQWKV 7KHUHODWLYHYDULDWLRQRIIRYHUEDVHOLQHDWPRQWKWUHDWPHQWZDVKLJKO\
FRUUHODWHGZLWK26 3 DQGV\PSWRPDWLFWLPHWRSURJUHVVLRQ 3
&RQFOXVLRQ,QFRQWUDVWWR$'&DQG'WKHSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQILVVLJQLÀFDQWO\DI
IHFWHGE\VRUDIHQLEDQGFRXOGEHDSRWHQWLDOPDUNHURIHDUO\UHVSRQVHWRWUHDWPHQW
%
0XOWL]RQHWXPRXUPRGHOH[SRVHGE\PXOWLSDUDPHWULFG\QDPLF
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGDQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ
.+RO]DSIHO&*DQWHU06HWWOHV6/RUHQ]HQ$-%HHU(-5XPPHQ\
60HW]0XQLFK'( KRO]DSIHO#URHPHGWXPGH
3XUSRVH7RFRUUHODWHNLQHWLFSDUDPHWHUVGHULYHGIURPG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
05LPDJLQJ '&(05, ZLWKDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHVGHWHUPLQHG
E\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ ':, LQDVSDWLDOO\UHVROYHGPXOWLSDUDPHWULF
LPDJLQJDSSURDFKIRUSKHQRW\SLQJRIWXPRXUELRORJ\LQOLYLQJRUJDQLVPV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q FKHPRQDLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK KLVWRORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ
DGHQRFDUFLQRPDVRIWKHOXQJRUWKHJDVWURLQWHVWLQDOWUDFWOHVLRQVZHUHLPDJHG
':, '&(05, 7UDQVIHU FRQVWDQW .WUDQV UDWH FRQVWDQW NHS DQG IUDFWLRQDO
H[WUDYDVFXODU H[WUDFHOOXODU VSDFH YH ZHUH FDOFXODWHG IRU HDFK SL[HO 7LVVXH '
VRIWZDUH 6LHPHQV DQG FRUUHODWHG ZLWK$'& YDOXHV :KROH WXPRXU UHJLRQV RI
LQWHUHVW 52,V ZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJWKH6SHDUPDQҋVUDQNFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
$GGLWLRQDOO\SDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRUUHODWHGRQDSL[HOE\SL[HOEDVLVDQGWRUHÁHFW
VSDWLDOKHWHURJHQHLW\DOOWXPRXUVHFWLRQVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRSL[HOULQJV SHULSKHU\
WRFHQWUH
5HVXOWV)RUZKROHWXPRXU52,VQRVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ$'&YDOXHV
DQG NLQHWLF SDUDPHWHUV FRXOG EH GHPRQVWUDWHG +RZHYHU SL[HOZLVH DQDO\VLV RI
$'&DQGNLQHWLFSDUDPHWHUVUHYHDOHGDGLVWLQFWSDWWHUQLQVSDWLDOGLVWULEXWLRQRI
WKHSDUDPHWHUVUHVWULFWHG$'&KLJKHVW.WUDQVDQGYHYDOXHVLQWKHWXPRXUULP
YHU\KLJK$'&YDOXHVDQGEUHDNGRZQLQSHUIXVLRQLQWKHFHQWUHLQFUHDVLQJ$'&
YDOXHVFRQVWDQW.WUDQVDQGLQFUHDVLQJNHSLQDWUDQVLWLRQDO]RQHZKHQDSSURDFK
LQJIURPSHULSKHUDOO\WRFHQWUDOO\
&RQFOXVLRQ1RQLQYDVLYHPXOWLSDUDPHWULFDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHVSDWLDOKHWHURJHQHLW\
RIWXPRXUELRORJ\LVIHDVLEOHXVLQJ'&(05,DQG':,&RPELQLQJERWKIXQFWLRQDO
LPDJLQJPHWKRGVLGHQWLÀHVWXPRXUUHJLRQVZLWKGLIIHUHQWELRORJLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFV
H[SRVLQJDPXOWL]RQHWXPRXUPRGHO
%
3HUIXVLRQ&7VXEFODVVLÀHV)'*3(7PHWDEROLFUHVSRQGHUVLQ
RHVRSKDJRJDVWULFDGHQRFDUFLQRPD
76$KHDUQ53HWW\*%DLQ$'HQLVRQ$:HOVFK9&XQQLQJKDP
/6FKZHLJHU)*LOEHUW$EHUGHHQ8. IMJLOEHUW#DEGQDFXN
3XUSRVH ,GHQWLI\LQJ SUHGLFWLYH ELRPDUNHUV WR RSWLPLVH WUHDWPHQW VHOHFWLRQ LQ
RHVRSKDJRJDVWULF DGHQRFDUFLQRPD 2*& DQG WR DYRLG LQHIIHFWLYH WUHDWPHQW LV
LPSRUWDQW$URXQG RI RHVRSKDJHDO FDQFHU SDWLHQWV WKDW KDYH D PHWDEROLF
UHVSRQVH 05 WRFKHPRWKHUDS\ZLWK)'*3(7DWGD\VJRRQWRUHVSRQGWRWKH
IXOOFRXUVHRIWUHDWPHQW$VSDUWRIDODUJHUVWXG\ZHLQYHVWLJDWHGWKHSUHGLFWLYHDF
FXUDF\RIFRPELQLQJSHUIXVLRQ&7 3&7 ZLWK)'*3(7IRUFKHPRWKHUDS\UHVSRQVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV/RFDOO\DGYDQFHGPHWDVWDWLF2*&SDWLHQWVZHUHUHFUXLWHG
LQWRWKH3&7DUPRIWKHVWXG\ Q ,PDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGRQGD\VDQG
DIWHUFKHPRWKHUDS\ )'*3(7DQG3&7 3DWLHQWVZHUHFODVVLÀHG05LIVWDQGDUG
XSWDNHYDOXHV 689 GHFUHDVHZDV!3&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKIUDPHV
.9S P$V PO RI 2PQLSDTXH ZDV LQIXVHG DW IUDPH ,PDJHV
ZHUHDQDO\VHGRIÁLQHXVLQJLQKRXVHVRIWZDUH3HUIXVLRQDQGEORRGYROXPHZHUH
FDOFXODWHGXVLQJWKHPD[LPXPVORSHPRGHO3&7SDWLHQWVKDYHEHHQDQDO\VHG
5DGLRORJLFDOUHVSRQVH 55 ZDVDVVHVVHGE\5(&,67Y DVVHVVPHQWVZHUH
EDVHGRQDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHSULPDU\WXPRXU
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVPHWDEROLFUHVSRQGHUVZHUHDOVR
UDGLRORJLFUHVSRQGHUV7XPRXUSHUIXVLRQZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHG S LQ
)'*3(705V PHDQLQFUHDVH WKDWGRJRRQWRKDYHD55DVFRPSDUHGWR
WKRVHWKDWGRQRWKDYHD55 PHDQLQFUHDVH
&RQFOXVLRQ3&7SRWHQWLDOO\VXEFODVVLÀHV)'*3(7PHWDEROLFUHVSRQGHUVLQWR
SDWLHQWVWKDWZLOODQGZLOOQRWJRRQWRWRKDYHDUDGLRORJLFDOUHVSRQVH3&7PD\KDYH
FOLQLFDOXWLOLW\LQFRPELQDWLRQZLWK)'*3(7DVDSUHGLFWLYHELRPDUNHUWRRSWLPLVH
WUHDWPHQWVHOHFWLRQLQ2*&
%
,QWUDYR[HOLQFRKHUHQWPRWLRQ ,9,0 DQDO\VLVRIEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDVD
SLORWVWXG\
$0&KRZ9$L36<&KHXQJ.0&KDQ6.<X**/R+DSS\9DOOH\+.
DSULOFPN#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R FKDUDFWHULVH FKDQJHV LQ GLIIXVLRQ DQG SHUIXVLRQ HIIHFWV LQ EUHDVW
FDUFLQRPDVXVLQJLQWUDYR[HOLQFRKHUHQWPRWLRQ ,9,0 DQDO\VLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVIHPDOHSDWLHQWVZLWKELRSV\SURYHQEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDV
ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG$OO05,H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD705,
VFDQQHU 0$*1(7207ULR6LHPHQV XVLQJDGHGLFDWHGFKDQQHOSKDVHGDUUD\
FRLO$ VLQJOHVKRW HFKRSODQDU LPDJLQJ ':, SURWRFRO ZDV SHUIRUPHG WR REWDLQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
(DUO\DVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUUHVSRQVHWRVRUDIHQLELQXYHDO
PHODQRPDZLWKOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVXVLQJVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH'&(05,
)1HQVD-6WDWWDXV%1RND\%7KLHULQJ+*/LSLQVNL
0)RUVWLQJ06FKHXOHQ-.DONPDQQ(VVHQ'(
'RUWPXQG'( IHOL[QHQVD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH (YDOXDWLRQ RI VHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH G\QDPLF FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 05,
'&(05, WRDVVHVVWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVRIXYHDO
PHODQRPD 80 WUHDWHGZLWK6RUDIHQLE
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KLV VWXG\ ZDV DSSURYHG E\ RXU ORFDO LQVWLWXWLRQDO
UHYLHZERDUG6HYHQWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVRI80ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWK
6RUDIHQLEDQGH[DPLQHGE\'&(05, 7$YDQWR6LHPHQV DWEDVHOLQHDQGIRU
IROORZXSVFDQVHYHU\ZHHNV7KHOHVLRQZLWKWKHORQJHVWGLDPHWHUZDVVHOHFWHG
DVWDUJHW0HDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGSDUDFRURQDOO\IRUVHFXVLQJD7
)ODVKVHTXHQFH PPVOLFHWKLFNQHVVWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQVHF DQG*DGREXWURO
PPRONJÁRZPOVHF $XWRPDWHGUHVSLUDWRU\PRWLRQFRUUHFWLRQZDVDSSOLHG
WRWKHLPDJHVHULHVWKHUHDIWHUWKHWDUJHWOHVLRQZDVPDQXDOO\GHOLQHDWHGE\DUHJLRQ
RILQWHUHVW&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWWLPHFXUYHVZHUHÀWWHGXVLQJVPRRWKLQJVSOLQH
LQWHUSRODWLRQDQGVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVZHUHFDOFXODWHGPD[LPXPVORSH
GXULQJLQLWLDOFRQWUDVWDJHQWXSWDNH L6ORSHPD[ DQGLQLWLDODUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH
WR L$8& DQGVHFRQGV L$8& DIWHUWKHRQVHWWLPH7KHUDS\UHVSRQVH
ZDVDVVHVVHGDFFRUGLQJWRUHVSRQVHHYDOXDWLRQFULWHULDLQVROLGWXPRUV 5(&,67
ZLWKDPHDQWLPHWRSURJUHVVLRQRIGD\V
5HVXOWV$IWHU ZHHNV L6ORSHPD[ L$8& DQG L$8& VKRZHG D VWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQWPHDQGHFUHDVHRI DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ HDFKS EHIRUHVXEVHTXHQWO\HQWHULQJVWHDG\VWDWH
$GHFUHDVHLQ'&(05,SDUDPHWHUVZDVQRWDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHUDS\UHVSRQVH
RUWLPHWRSURJUHVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 5HVSLUDWRU\ PRWLRQ FRUUHFWHG VHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH '&(05, VKRZV
DUDSLGDQGVLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHLQOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVRI80XQGHUWUHDWPHQWZLWK
VRUDIHQLEEXWDFRUUHODWLRQWRFOLQLFDORXWFRPHFRXOGQRWEHREVHUYHG
%
&RPELQHGTXDOLWDWLYHDQGTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRI':,LQHDUO\
DVVHVVPHQWRISRRUUHVSRQGHUVDIWHUFKHPRUDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\
SUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVLQORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDOFDQFHU
/0RQJX]]L',SSROLWR&&DSUDUR&7DOHL)UDQ]HVL6*DOLPEHUWL66LURQL
0RQ]D,7 OHWL]LDPRQJX]]L#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDOUROHRI':,%6DQG$'&PDSLQLGHQWLI\LQJSRRU
UHVSRQGHUVWRQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRUDGLDWLRQWUHDWPHQW &57 IRU/$5&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH ZLWKELRSV\SURYHQGLDJQRVLV
RIUHFWDOFDQFHUZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGLQRXUVWXG\05H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUH
SHUIRUPHGSULRUWRWKHUDS\ 77RU1VWDJH DQGDIWHU&57 ZHHNVDIWHUWKH
FRPSOHWLRQRIWUHDWPHQW RQD7HVOD $FKLHYD3KLOLSV VFDQQHUZLWKDSHOYLF
SKDVHG DUUD\ PXOWLFRLO PXOWLSODQDU 7 DQG 776( DQG ':,%6 VHTXHQFHV E
IDFWRUDQGPPVHF ZHUHDFTXLUHG)RUTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVPHDQ$'&
YDOXHVRIWKHWXPRXUUHJLRQVZHUHPHDVXUHGE\UDGLRORJLVWVE\PDQXDOO\GUDZLQJ
52, FRYHULQJHQWLUHWXPRXUUHJLRQVRQ$'&PDSV 0HDQSUHDQGSRVW&57$'&
YDOXHVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQUHVSRQGHUVDQGQRQUHVSRQGHUVEHLQJWKHKLV
WRSDWKRORJLFUHVSRQVH DFFRUGLQJWR0DQGDUGҋVFULWHULD DVWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
5HVXOWV$IWHUVXUJLFDOUHVHFWLRQLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKSDWKRORJLFDO
UHVXOWV7ZHQW\VHYHQSDWLHQWV VKRZHGFRPSOHWH 75* RUVXEWRWDOUHJUHV
VLRQ 75* DQGZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDVUHVSRQGHUVZKLOH ZHUHFODVVLÀHG
DVSRRUUHVSRQGHUV 75* 7KHPHDQSRVW&57$'&YDOXHRISRRUUHVSRQGHUV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
[PPVHF ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S ORZHUWKDQWKDWRIUHVSRQGHU
JURXS [ PPVHF 7KH EHVW FXWRII$'& YDOXH LQ GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ
UHVSRQGHUVIURPQRQUHVSRQGHUVZDV[PPVRQWKHEDVLVRISRVW&57
$'&\LHOGHGDJRRGVSHFLÀFLW\ FRPELQLQJTXDOLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRI':,WR
PRUSKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVZHFRXOGOHDGWRPRUHDFFXUDWHUHVXOWV
&RQFOXVLRQ':05,UHSUHVHQWVDSRZHUIXODQGHIIHFWLYHWRROWRPRQLWRUWKHUD
SHXWLFUHVSRQVHLQ/$5&EHLQJDEOHWRGHWHFWFHOOXODUFKDQJHVLQWUHDWHGWXPRXUV
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIWXPRUKHWHURJHQHLW\&7WH[WXUHDVDELRPDUNHURI
RYHUDOOVXUYLYDOLQSULPDU\FRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
).+1J%*DQHVKDQ5.R]DUVNL.0LOHV9*RK1RUWKZRRG8.
%ULJKWRQ8.+HUWIRUGVKLUH8./RQGRQ8.
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH LI &7 WH[WXUH LV UHODWHG WR RYHUDOO VXUYLYDO LQ SULPDU\
FRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)ROORZLQJ,5%DSSURYDOSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHV
PHDQ\HDUV XQGHUZHQWVWDJLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7 N9P$V
URWDWLRQWLPHPPVOLFHFROOLPDWLRQP/PJPOLRGLQDWHGFRQWUDVWDWP/V
VHFRQGGHOD\ 7KHHQWLUHFRORUHFWDOWXPRXUWH[WXUHIHDWXUHVZHUHDVVHVVHG
XVLQJ SURSULHWDU\ LPDJH WH[WXUH DQDO\VLV VRIWZDUH 7H[5$' GHULYLQJ HQWURS\
( XQLIRUPLW\ 8 NXUWRVLV . VNHZQHVV 6 DQGVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ 6' IURP
WKH&7LPDJHVZLWKRXWÀOWUDWLRQDQGZLWKÀOWHUYDOXHVFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRÀQH
PHGLXP DQGFRDUVH WH[WXUHV3DWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHGXSWLOOGHDWK
RUFHQVRUHGDW\HDUVLIDOLYH52&DQG.DSODQ0HLHUDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
WRGHWHUPLQHWKHUHODWLRQVKLSLIDQ\EHWZHHQ&7WH[WXUHDQG\URYHUDOOVXUYLYDO
5HVXOWV'DWDZHUHDYDLODEOHIURPSDWLHQWV7KHUHZHUHVWDJH,VWDJH,,
VWDJH,,,DQGVWDJH,9FDQFHUV)LQHWH[WXUH.DSODQ0HLHUVXUYLYDOSORWVIRU
(8.6DQG6'ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW S S S S
DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\ IRUWKUHVKROGVRI ( ! 8 .
! 6 DQG 6' UHVSHFWLYHO\&R[UHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKHVH
SDUDPHWHUVZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUVRIRYHUDOOVXUYLYDOZLWKVWDJH
&RQFOXVLRQ/RZHUHQWURS\NXUWRVLVDQG6'DQGKLJKHUXQLIRUPLW\DQGVNHZQHVV
DWÀQHWH[WXUHVDUHSUHGLFWRUVRISRRUHU\HDURYHUDOOVXUYLYDOLQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIUDGLRORJLFDOSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVRIKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVHV
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFQHXURHQGRFULQHQHRSODVPV
&,KP$%DXU,*6WHIIHQ(%7LVFKHU03DYHO7'HQHFNH
%HUOLQ'( DOH[DQGHUEDXU#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH3DQFUHDWLFQHXURHQGRFULQHQHRSODVPV S1(1 DUHUDUHWXPRXUVDQG
RIWHQGLDJQRVHGDWDQDGYDQFHGVWDJHRIGLVHDVH7KHOLYHULVWKHPRVWIUHTXHQWVLWH
RIPHWDVWDVHVDQGSURJUHVVLRQRIKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVHVRIWHQGHWHUPLQHVSURJQRVLV
7KLVVWXG\DLPHGWRHYDOXDWHWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVRIS1(1LQ
PXOWLSKDVLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7RU05,GHWHUPLQLQJULVNIDFWRUVIRUSURJUHVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGWKH&7DQG05,DSSHDU
DQFHRIOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQZHOOGLIIHUHQWLDWHG
* S1(1IRUFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWQHFURVLVYDVFXODULQÀOWUDWLRQDVZHOODV
WKHQXPEHURIPHWDVWDVHVDQGWXPRXUEXUGHQ3URJUHVVLRQRIOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV
ZDVMXGJHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKH5(&,67FULWHULD
5HVXOWV 'XULQJ VXUYHLOODQFH SDWLHQWV UHFHLYHG ELRWKHUDS\ RFWUHRWLGH /$5
DQGSDWLHQWVREWDLQHGQRDQWLWXPRUDOWKHUDS\0HGLDQWLPHWRSURJUHVVLRQRI
SDWLHQWVZLWKELRWKHUDS\DQGSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWWKHUDS\ZDVDQGPRQWKV
UHVSHFWLYHO\ +5&,S 7KHRQO\VLJQLÀFDQWUDGLRORJLFDO
IDFWRUVKRZQWRKDYHDOHVVIDYRXUDEOHLQGHSHQGHQWSURJQRVWLFVLJQLÀFDQFHLVWKH
K\SRYDVFXODULVDWLRQ GHÀQHGDVK\SRHQKDQFHPHQWGXULQJWKHHDUO\DUWHULDODQGSRU
WDOYHQRXVSKDVHV RIKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVHV +5&,S 7KLV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\SUHGLFWHGHDUO\SURJUHVVLRQLQWKHVXEJURXSZLWKRXWRFWUHRWLGHWKHUDS\
\HDU SURJUHVVLRQ UDWH ZLWK K\SHUYDVFXODULVDWLRQ K\SRYDVFXODULVDWLRQ
S ZKLOHELRWKHUDS\PDVNHGWKLVSUHGLFWRU DOOSDWLHQWVS
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKRFWUHRWLGH/$5KDGDVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORQJHUWLPH
WRWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQ+\SRYDVFXODULVHGPHWDVWDVHVPLJKWEHDQHDV\DFFHVVLEOH
ULVNIDFWRUIRUWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQDQGWKHUHIRUHLPSRUWDQWWRWDNHLQWRDFFRXQWZKHQ
GHFLGLQJRQWKHUDSHXWLFDSSURDFK
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
LPDJHVD[LDOO\ZLWKEYDOXHV VPP $
FLUFXODU52,ZDVGHÀQHGLQWKH':LPDJHVRYHUWKHEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDVDQGQRUPDO
ÀEURJODQGXODU WLVVXH IRU ,9,0 PHDVXUHPHQWV 7UXH GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW 'WUXH
SVHXGRGLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW 'SVHXGR DQG SHUIXVLRQ IUDFWLRQ 3IUDFWLRQ ZHUH
HVWLPDWHGE\ÀWWLQJWKH':VLJQDOGHFD\LQWKH52,WRWKH,9,0ELFRPSDUWPHQWDO
PRGHO6,6, 3IUDFWLRQ [H[S E'WUXH 3IUDFWLRQ[H[S E'SVHXGR
5HVXOWV'WUXHRIEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDV [PPV ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
ORZHU SWZRWDLOHG:LOFR[RQPDWFKHGSDLUVWHVW WKDQWKDWRIÀEURJODQGX
ODUWLVVXH [PPV 0RUHRYHUVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S
LQ3IUDFWLRQZDVREVHUYHGLQEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDV DQGÀEURJODQGXODU
WLVVXH ZKLOHVLPLODU'SVHXGRLQEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDV [
PPV DQGÀEURJODQGXODUWLVVXH [PPV ZHUHREVHUYHG
&RQFOXVLRQ,9,0DQDO\VLVUHYHDOHGGHFUHDVHG'WUXHDQG3IUDFWLRQLQEUHDVWFDU
FLQRPDVVKRZLQJWKDWDOWHUDWLRQVLQERWKFHOOXODULW\DQGSHUIXVLRQHIIHFWVFRQWULEXWH
WRWKHFKDQJHVLQDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQXVLQJ':,,9,0DQDO\VLVPD\EHYDOXDEOHIRU
FKDUDFWHULVLQJEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDVDQGPRQLWRULQJLWVSURJUHVVLRQQRQLQYDVLYHO\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
3XUSRVH'XDOHQHUJ\&7 '(&7 DOORZVWKHDVVHVVPHQWRILRGLQHGLVWULEXWLRQLQ
WXPRXUV7KLVPD\EHFRQVLGHUHGDVDVXUURJDWHPDUNHUIRUSHUIXVLRQDQGWXPRXU
YDVFXODULW\7KLVVWXG\HYDOXDWHGZKHWKHU'(&7DOORZVDEHWWHUSUHGLFWLRQRIVXUYLYDO
WKDQHVWDEOLVKHGUHVSRQVHFULWHULD 5(&,67DQG&KRLFULWHULD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKDGYDQFHG*,67WUHDWHGZLWK
W\URVLQNLQDVHLQKLELWRUVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG'(&7DIWHUDQG
PRQWKVIROORZXS5HVSRQVHZDVUDWHGDFFRUGLQJWR5(&,67&KRLFULWHULDDQG
'(&7DQDO\VLVRILRGLQHUHODWHGDWWHQXDWLRQ3URJUHVVLYHGLVHDVHZDVGHÀQHGDV
DLQFUHDVHRIWXPRXUVL]H 5(&,67 DQGWXPRXUGHQVLW\ &KRL RUHLWKHUDQ
LQFUHDVHJUHDWHUWKDQRIWXPRXUVL]HRULRGLQHUHODWHGDWWHQXDWLRQRQ'(&7
3URJUHVVLRQIUHH VXUYLYDO 3)6 DQG RYHUDOO VXUYLYDO 26 ZHUH FDOFXODWHG E\
.DSODQ0HLHUDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV,QGHSHQGHQWIURPWKHXVHGUHVSRQVHFULWHULDSDWLHQWVZLWKSDUWLDOUHVSRQVH
RUVWDEOHGLVHDVHKDGDVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORQJHUPHGLDQ3)6WKDQSDWLHQWVZLWKSURJUHV
VLYHGLVHDVH PHGLDQPRQWKVYVPRQWKVS 2QO\'(&7DW
PRQWKVDOORZHGDYDOLGGLVFULPLQDWLRQRISDWLHQWVZLWKJRRGRUSRRU26 PHGLDQ
YVPRQWKVS
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLV VWXG\ LQGLFDWHV WKDW '(&7 LV D SURPLVLQJ SUHGLFWLYH LPDJLQJ
ELRPDUNHURIUHVSRQVHLIFRPSDUHGWRHVWDEOLVKHGUHVSRQVHFULWHULDDVLWDOORZHG
WKHEHVWSUHGLFWLRQRIVXUYLYDO
&KHVW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIVLQJOHVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\&7IRUGLI
IHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQDWHOHFWDVLVDQGWXPRXULQFHQWUDOOXQJFDQFHU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KH VWXG\ FRPSULVHV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK
FRQÀUPHGFHQWUDOOXQJFDQFHUDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDWHOHFWDVLVRQVLQJOHVRXUFHGXDO
HQHUJ\&77KHRSWLPLVHGPRQRFKURYPDWLFLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGE\VHOHFWLQJ
WKHEHVW&15DQGWKHLRGLQHEDVHGPDWHULDOGHFRPSRVHGLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHG
ZLWKLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQPHDVXUHG,PDJHVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWV
ZRUNLQJ LQ FRQVHQVXV IRU WKH GLVSOD\PHQW RI WXPRXUDWHOHFWDVLV LQWHUIDFH 7KH
LRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVEHWZHHQWXPRXUDQGDWHOHFWDVLVZDVFRPSDUHGE\SDLUHG
WWHVWZLWK6366
5HVXOWV7KHRSWLPDOHQHUJ\OHYHOZDVLQWKHUDQJHRINH9 PHGLDQNH9
IRUGLVSOD\LQJWXPRXUDWHOHFWDVLVLQWHUIDFHDWVGHOD\HGVFDQQLQJSKDVHDQGLQ
WKHUDQJHRINH9 PHGLDQNH9 DWVGHOD\HGVFDQQLQJSKDVH7XPRXU
DWHOHFWDVLVLQWHUIDFHFRXOGEHGHÀQHGLQ DQG SDWLHQWVXVLQJ
FRPELQDWLRQRIWKHRSWLPLVHGPRQRFKURYPDWLFLPDJHVZLWKLRGLQHEDVHGPDWH
ULDOGHFRPSRVHGLPDJHVDWVDQGVGHOD\HGSKDVHUHVSHFWLYHO\PRUHWKDQ
DQG XVLQJWKHRSWLPLVHGPRQRFKURYPDWLFLPDJHVDORQHZLWK
S DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVRIDWHOHFWDVLVZDV
PXFKKLJKHUWKDQWXPRXUSDQGWKHLRGLQHEDVHGPDWHULDOGHFRPSRVHG
LPDJHVHQDEOHGGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQDWHOHFWDVLVDQGWXPRXULQPRUHSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH VLQJOH VRXUFH GXDO HQHUJ\ &7 FRXOG LPSURYH GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ
EHWZHHQDWHOHFWDVLVDQGWXPRXULQFHQWUDOOXQJFDQFHUZLWKWKHRSWLPLVHG&15
WHFKQLTXHDQGPDWHULDOGHFRPSRVLWLRQWHFKQLTXH7KLVPRGDOLW\PDQLIHVWHGDVD
SRWHQWLDOO\XVHIXOUDGLRORJLFWRROIRUURXWLQHFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVLV
66
%
&7EDVHGUHVSRQVHDVVHVVPHQWRIDGYDQFHGJDVWURLQWHVWLQDO
VWURPDOWXPRXULVGXDOHQHUJ\&7DPRUHSUHGLFWLYHLPDJLQJ
ELRPDUNHURIUHVSRQVHWKDQ5(&,67RU&KRLFULWHULD"
00H\HU3$SIDOWUHU7+HQ]OHU'-'LQWHU3+RKHQEHUJHU626FK|QEHUJ
&)LQN0DQQKHLP'( PUPH\HUPDWKLDV#JPDLOFRP
5RRP'
1HRSODVPVVWDJLQJULVNDQGVXUJHU\
0RGHUDWRUV
6/H\7RURQWR21&$
.0DODJDUL$WKHQV*5
%
7KHSUHVXUJLFDO7VWDJLQJRIQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHUHIÀFDF\
FRPSDULVRQRI06&7YHUVXV705LPDJLQJ
7:7DQJ:1:X2+2X\DQJ+<+XDQJ///LX/0/L:<:DQJ
;;;X%HLMLQJ&1 QLFN\#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH SURVSHFWLYHO\ WKH GLDJQRVWLF HIÀFDFLHV RI 0'&7 DQG
705,IRUGHWHUPLQLQJ7VWDJLQJLQ16&/&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYDODQGLQIRUPHGFRQ
VHQWZHUHREWDLQHGSDWLHQWVZLWK16&/&SURYHGE\SDWKRORJ\ZHUHHQUROOHG
LQWKHVWXG\7RWDOO\SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWQRQHQKDQFHG 05,HQKDQFHG05,
DQGHQKDQFHG0'&77VWDJLQJZHUHSUHOLPLQDULO\HYDOXDWHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHVH
LPDJLQJPDQLIHVWDWLRQVDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKDWRISDWKRORJ\XVLQJWKH.DSSDWHVW
'LDJQRVWLFHIÀFDFLHVIRU7VWDJLQJRI16&/&RQQRQHQKDQFHG05,HQKDQFHG05,
DQGHQKDQFHG&7LPDJLQJZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJWKH0F1HPDUWHVWUHVSHFWLYHO\
5HVXOWV'LDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\IRU7VWDJLQJRI16&/&ZDVRQQRQHQKDQFHG
05,RQHQKDQFHG05,DQGWKDWRQHQKDQFHG&7ZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\
7KHUH ZDV QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH DPRQJ WKHVH GLIIHUHQW SURWRFROV RQ WKH
GLDJQRVWLF HIÀFDF\ IRU7 VWDJLQJ RI 16&/& 3 ! $OWKRXJK WKHUH ZHUH QR
VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV IRU WKH 16&/& ZLWK7a VWDJLQJ GLDJQRVWLF HIÀFDF\ RI
HQKDQFHG&7ZDVVOLJKWO\VXSHULRUWRWKDWRIQRQHQKDQFHG05,DQGHQKDQFHG
05,IRUWKH16&/&ZLWK7aVWDJLQJGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\RIHQKDQFHG05,ZDV
VOLJKWO\VXSHULRUWRWKDWRIHQKDQFHG&7DQGQRQHQKDQFHG05,
&RQFOXVLRQ &RPSDUHG WR 0'&7 QRQHQKDQFHG 05, DQG HQKDQFHG 05, SUR
YLGHGVOLJKWO\VXSHULRUGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\IRUWKHSUHVXUJLFDO7VWDJLQJRI16&/&
HVSHFLDOO\ IRU WKH 7a WXPRXU )RU SDWLHQWV ZKR FDQQRW VWDQG ZLWK HQKDQFHG
0'&7VFDQ705,ZRXOGEHDVXEVWLWXWHGH[DPLQDWLRQIRUWKHSUHVXUJLFDO7
VWDJLQJRI16&/&
6LQJOHVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\&7LPSURYLQJGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQ
DWHOHFWDVLVDQGWXPRXULQFHQWUDOOXQJFDQFHUFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFHRID
QRYHOWHFKQLTXH
<&KHQ/7DQJ;7/L/34L<//L;<=KDQJ<&XL<66XQ
;3=KDQJ%HLMLQJ&1 WDQJOHL#EMFDQFHURUJ
3UHGLFWLYHIHDWXUHVRI)'*3(7&7DQG&7LQGLDJQRVLQJQRGDO
PHWDVWDVLVRI7QRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHUVPDQLIHVWLQJDVSDUW
VROLGQRGXOHV
+.LP&03DUN60/HH-&3DHQJ-0*RR+-/HH6HRXO.5
NKMVQXK#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\LQYHVWLJDWHWKHSUHGLFWLYHIDFWRUVRI)'*3(7&7DQG
&7IRU/1PHWDVWDVLVLQ716&/&VPDQLIHVWLQJDVSDUWVROLGQRGXOHV 361V
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYHGWKLVVWXG\DQG
ZDLYHG LQIRUPHG FRQVHQW )URP -DQXDU\ WR 0D\ SDWLHQWV ZLWK
SDWKRORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ 7 16&/&V PDQLIHVWLQJ DV 361V ZLWK /1 VWDJLQJ ZHUH
LQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\689PD[DQG&7IHDWXUHVRISULPDU\WXPRXUVZHUHHYDOX
DWHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHSUHGLFWLYHIDFWRUVIRU/1PHWDVWDVLV,QDGGLWLRQRSWLPDOFXWRII
YDOXHVIRUHDFKSUHGLFWRUZHUHGHWHUPLQHGDQGWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIWKH
SUHGLFWLRQPRGHOXVLQJWKHSUHGLFWRUVZDVHYDOXDWHGXVLQJDUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJ
FKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV/1PHWDVWDVHVZHUHIRXQGLQRISDWLHQWV 1R/1PHWDV
WDVLVZDVSUHVHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVROLGSURSRUWLRQ7KHUHZHUHVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHVLQ689PD[VROLGSURSRUWLRQDQGOHVLRQORFDWLRQRIWKHSULPDU\WXPRXU
EHWZHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXW/1PHWDVWDVLV 3 0XOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLV
UHYHDOHG WKDW KLJKHU 689PD[ >RGGV UDWLR 25 3 @ ODUJHU VROLG
SURSRUWLRQ>253 @DQGFHQWUDOORFDWLRQ>253 @ZHUH
LQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUVIRU/1PHWDVWDVLV7KHRSWLPDOFXWRIIYDOXHVRI689PD[
DQGVROLGSURSRUWLRQZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHDUHDXQGHUWKH52&
FXUYHRIWKHSUHGLFWLYHPRGHOXVLQJDOOWKUHHYDULDEOHVZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKHU689PD[ODUJHUVROLGSURSRUWLRQDQGFHQWUDOORFDWLRQRIWKH
SULPDU\ WXPRXU DUH VLJQLÀFDQW LQGHSHQGHQW SUHGLFWRUV IRU /1 PHWDVWDVLV LQ 7
16&/&VPDQLIHVWLQJDV361VZKLFKFDQHQDEOHDYHU\DFFXUDWHSUHRSHUDWLYH
SUHGLFWLRQRI/1VWDWXVLQWKHVHFDQFHUV
%
3UHYDOHQFHFOLQLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHDQGGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIH[WUDSOHXUDO
DQGFDUGLRSKUHQLFO\PSKQRGHV
&0DQWLQL%)HUDJDOOL1&LYLWDUHDOH53ROYHURVL$7DUWDUR$&RWURQHR
&KLHWL,7
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSUHYDOHQFHFOLQLFDOPHDQLQJDQGGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRI
H[WUDSOHXUDODQGFDUGLRSKUHQLFQRGHVRFFDVLRQDOO\REVHUYHGRQ&7VFDQVRIWKH
FKHVW7RGHÀQHD&7GLPHQVLRQDOFXWRIIYDOXHIRUH[WUDSOHXUDODQGFDUGLRSKUHQLF
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJDGGGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHWR05,LQ
GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJWKRUDFRPHGLDVWLQLFOHVLRQVFRPSDULVRQZLWK3(7&7
)%XHPL)7RQGR*6WUDQJLR$6WHFFR$&DUULHUR1RYDUD,7
IUDQEXHPL#YLUJLOLRLW
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHG05,VHTXHQFHVYHUVXV3(7&7LQWKHGHWHFWLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI
WKRUDFRPHGLDVWLQDOGLVWULFWOHVLRQVXVLQJWKHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDO ÀQGLQJVDVJROG
VWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKWKRUDFLFPHGLDVWLQDOOHVLRQVXQGHUZHQW
3(7&7 DQG 05, VWDQGDUG DQG GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG VHTXHQFHV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG
DQG$'& PDSV ZHUH JHQHUDWHG7R RSWLPLVH WKH FRPSDULVRQ EHWZHHQ 3(7&7
DQG 05, LQ GLVFULPLQDWLQJ EHQLJQ IURP PDOLJQDQW OHVLRQV DQ$'& FXWRII YDOXH
ZDVVWDWHG [PPV &RQVLGHULQJWKHÀQGLQJVRIKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOOHVLRQV
DV´JROGVWDQGDUGµUHIHUHQFHYDOXHVRIVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339 DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 RI05,DQG
&73(7ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV7KHREWDLQHGYDOXHVVKRZHGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,KDYLQJDVHQVLWLY
LW\FRPSDUDEOHWR&73(7 YV DQGJUHDWHUVSHFLÀFLW\ YV
2YHUDOOWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,UHWXUQHGDYDOXHRI
FRPSDUHGWRRI3(7&77KH339REWDLQHGZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHV
ZDVVLPLODUWRWKHRQHREWDLQHGZLWK3(7&7 YV ZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
139VHTXHQFHVEHLQJPRUHDFFXUDWHWKDQ3(7&7 YV 1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\
UHOHYDQWGLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJWKHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\YDOXHVRIWKHWZRPHWKRGV
ZHUHIRXQGDIWHUDFRPSDULVRQZLWKWKH0F1HPDUҋVWHVW
&RQFOXVLRQ&DOFXODWLRQRIWKH$'&ZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,KDVSURYHGWR
EH H[WUHPHO\ VHQVLWLYH LQ WKH WKRUDFRPHGLDVWLQDO PDVVHV GLVFULPLQDWLRQ DQG LW
PD\EHDQLPSRUWDQWWHFKQLFDOIHDWXUHWRFRPSOHWHEDVLF05,VHTXHQFHVZLWKRU
ZLWKRXWFRQWUDVWPHGLD
%
'RSOHXUDOSODTXHVFDUU\DQH[FHVVRIULVNRIOXQJFDQFHULQ
DVEHVWRVH[SRVHGZRUNHUV"
5%DUERW&/H0DUTXDQG-&3DLURQ&3DULV3%URFKDUG)/DXUHQW
9LOOHQDYHGҋ2UQRQ)5&ODPDUW)5&UHWHLO)59DQGRHXYUHOHV1DQF\)5
%RUGHDX[)53HVVDF)5 UHPLEDUERW#IUHHIU
3XUSRVH 0RVW VWXGLHV HYDOXDWLQJ UHODWLRQVKLSV EHWZHHQ SOHXUDO SODTXHV DQG
OXQJFDQFHUKDYHEHHQEDVHGRQFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKVDQGGXHWRWKHORZVHQVLWLYLW\
DQG VSHFLÀFLW\ RI FKHVW UDGLRJUDSK WR LGHQWLI\ SOHXUDO SODTXHV WKHLU UHVXOWV DUH
VWLOOFRQWURYHUVLDO7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUWKHSUHVHQFHRI
SOHXUDOSODTXHVGHWHFWHGXVLQJORZGRVHFKHVW&7OHDGVWRDQDGGLWLRQDOULVNRI
OXQJFDQFHUWRWKDWSURYLGHGE\DVEHVWRVH[SRVXUHZLWKRXWSUHVHQFHRISODTXHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$ ODUJH VFUHHQLQJ SURJUDPPH IRU IRUPHUO\ DVEHVWRV
H[SRVHGZRUNHUVZDVRUJDQLVHGLQ)UDQFHIURPWRLQFOXGLQJH[SRVXUH
DVVHVVPHQWPHDVXUHGE\DFXPXODWLYHH[SRVXUHLQGH[DQGGHWHFWLRQRISOHXUDO
DQGOXQJDEQRUPDOLWLHVE\ORZGRVHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\5HDGLQJZDVSHUIRUPHG
EOLQGO\LQGHSHQGHQWO\E\UHDGHUV&DVHVRILQFLGHQWOXQJFDQFHULQWKLVSRSXOD
WLRQZHUHFRXQWHGXSWR-DQXDU\5HODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQSUHVHQFHRISOHXUDO
SODTXHVDQGRFFXUUHQFHRIOXQJFDQFHUZDVDVVHVVHGE\DGMXVWHGRGGVUDWLRV 25
IRUDJHVH[VPRNLQJVWDWXVDQGDVEHVWRVH[SRVXUH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5HVXOWV 7KH VWXG\ SRSXODWLRQ LQFOXGHG VXEMHFWV 7KH PHDQ GXUDWLRQ RI
IROORZXSZDV\HDUV'DWDUHJDUGLQJWKHSUHVHQFHRISOHXUDOSODTXHVZHUH
DYDLODEOHLQVXEMHFWVDPRQJWKHFDVHVRIOXQJFDQFHULGHQWLÀHG$GMXVWHG
25HVWLPDWLQJWKHULVNRIOXQJFDQFHUDVVRFLDWHGZLWKSOHXUDOSODTXHVZDV
FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDOWR
&RQFOXVLRQ$PRQJ D SRSXODWLRQ RI IRUPHUO\ DVEHVWRVH[SRVHG ZRUNHUV WKH
SUHVHQFHRISOHXUDOSODTXHVGRHVQRWOHDGWRDQH[FHVVULVNRIOXQJFDQFHU
%
,QFLGHQWDOÀQGLQJVLQDVWXG\VFUHHQLQJDVEHVWRVH[SRVHGZRUNHUV
IRUOXQJFDQFHUDQGPHVRWKHOLRPDXVLQJORZGRVHFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ /'&7 ZKDW\RXFDQÀQGZKHQ\RXDUHQRWORRNLQJ
(7DUXOOL+5REHUWV0GH3HUURW%26XOOLYDQ*'RQJ163DXO
'3DWVLRV.LQJVWRQ21&$7RURQWR21&$ HDW#TXHHQVXFD
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\LVWRDVVHVVWKHIUHTXHQF\RILQFLGHQWDOÀQG
LQJV ,)V DQGWKHLUSRWHQWLDOLPSDFWLQDQDVEHVWRVH[SRVHGSRSXODWLRQVFUHHQHG
IRUOXQJFDQFHUDQGPHVRWKHOLRPDXVLQJ/'&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHQ VFUHHQHGEHWZHHQ0DUFK
DQGXVLQJ/'&7,)VZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDQ\ÀQGLQJVQRWUHODWHGWRWKH
SULPDU\SXUSRVHRIWKHVFUHHQLQJVWXG\LQGHWHFWLQJSXOPRQDU\DQGSOHXUDOIRFDO
DQGGLIIXVHDEQRUPDOLWLHVVHFRQGDU\WRDVEHVWRVH[SRVXUHFDWHJRULVHGDQDWRPL
FDOO\1HFHVVLW\IRUIROORZXSZDVGHFLGHGEDVHGRQWKHÀQGLQJVE\WKHUHDGLQJ
UDGLRORJLVW7KHFRVWVRIWKHDVVRFLDWHGIROORZXSZHUHFDOFXODWHGEDVHGRQWKH
6FKHGXOHRI%HQHÀWVSXEOLVKHGE\WKH0LQLVWU\RI+HDOWKDQG/RQJ7HUP&DUHRI
WKHSURYLQFHRI2QWDULR&$
5HVXOWV7KHDYHUDJHDJHZDV\HDUVSDUWLFLSDQWVZHUHFXUUHQWVPRN
HUVIRUPHUVPRNHUVDQGQRQVPRNHUV7KHDYHUDJHQXPEHURISDFN
\HDUVLQWKHVPRNLQJSRSXODWLRQZDVDQGDVEHVWRVH[SRVXUHZDVLQWKH
HQWLUHVFUHHQHGSRSXODWLRQ&OLQLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW,)VUHTXLULQJIROORZXSZHUHIRXQG
LQRI RIEDVHOLQHVFUHHQLQJVWXGLHV7KHPRVWFRPPRQLQFLGHQWDO
ÀQGLQJV ZHUH FDUGLDF KHSDWLF KLDWDO KHUQLDV ELOLDU\
UHQDO VSOHQLF DQGWKRVHUHODWHGWRWKHWK\URLG 7KHWRWDOFRVWRI
LQYHVWLJDWLQJ,)VZDVHVWLPDWHGDWDSSUR[LPDWHO\&$1ZKHUHDVWKHWRWDO
FRVWRIWKHEDVHOLQHVFUHHQLQJVWXGLHVLVHVWLPDWHGDW&$1
&RQFOXVLRQ,)VLQVFUHHQLQJVWXGLHVDUHERWKFOLQLFDOO\DQGÀQDQFLDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
7KHLU LPSDFW VKRXOG EH FRQVLGHUHG ZKHQ GHWHUPLQLQJ WKH LPSOHPHQWDWLRQ DQG
YDOLGDWLRQRIQHZVFUHHQLQJWHVWV
%
/XQJFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJE\PRUSKRORJLFDO05,LQFRPSDULVRQWR
ORZGRVH&7
-7UHPSHU03XGHUEDFK%6WLHOWMHV0(LFKLQJHU+36FKOHPPHU
6'HORUPH+HLGHOEHUJ'( MWUHPSHU#GNI]GH
3XUSRVH/XQJFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJZLWK&7DSSOLHVLRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQ7KLVLVSURE
OHPDWLFLQORQJWHUPIROORZXSZLWKDFFXPXODWLQJGRVHV7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDV
WRH[DPLQHWKHSRWHQWLDORIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQ
RIVXVSHFWHGOXQJOHVLRQVLQFRPSDULVRQWRORZGRVH&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDUWLFLSDQWVRIWKH+HLGHOEHUJOXQJFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJ
WULDO /86, VKRZLQJDVXVSLFLRXVOXQJOHVLRQLQ&7EHFDXVHRIVL]H !PP
RUVLJQLÀFDQWJURZWK GD\VGRXEOLQJWLPH WKDWUHTXLUHVLPPHGLDWHZRUNXS
LQYDVLYHSURFHGXUHVRUVKRUWWHUPIROORZXS UHFHLYHGDQRQFRQWUDVWOXQJ05,
+$67(9,%(7UX)LVSLQFRURQDODQGWUDQVYHUVDORULHQWDWLRQ 7KHVWXG\WLPH
ZDVDSSUR[PLQXWHV7KH05GDWDZHUHFKHFNHGIRUVXVSLFLRXVOHVLRQV7KH
UHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGWR&7
5HVXOWVRIWKHVXVSLFLRXVOHVLRQVFRXOGEHLGHQWLÀHGE\05,FRPSDUDEOH
WR&7OXQJOHVLRQVFRXOGQRWEHHQLGHQWLÀHGLQ05, RIWKHPEHLQJVPDOOHU
WKDQPPOHVLRQVKDGSUREDEO\DOUHDG\UHVROYHGE\WKHWLPH WKH05,ZDV
SHUIRUPHGIHVPDOOLQÀOWUDWHVRUDWHOHFWDVHV ,Q)LVKHUҋVH[DFWWHVWLQGHSHQG
HQFHFDQEHUHMHFWHG S SURYLQJ05,EHLQJDVDFFXUDWHDV&7LQGHWHFWLQJ
UHOHYDQWOXQJOHVLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHUHVXOWVVKRZWKDWVXVSLFLRXVOXQJOHVLRQVRQORZGRVH&7DUH
GHSLFWHGLQDOVRRQPRUSKRORJLFDO05,RIWKHOXQJ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
QRGHV7RHYDOXDWHWKHIUHTXHQF\RIWKHVHQRGHVLQGLIIHUHQWGLVHDVHVSDUWLFXODUO\
LQSULPDU\RUVHFRQGDU\PDOLJQDQWSOHXUDOGLVHDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HLQFOXGHGFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQW
0'&7 RI WKH FKHVW IRU GLIIHUHQW FOLQLFDO SXUSRVHV QRQQHRSODVWLF SDWLHQWV
ZLWK H[WUDWKRUDFLF QHRSODVP ZLWK LQWUDWKRUDFLF QHRSODVP DQG ZLWK
SOHXUDO PHWDVWDVLV DQG SDWLHQWV ZLWK KLVWRORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ PDOLJQDQW SOHXUDO
PHVRWKHOLRPD 030 )RUHDFKJURXSRISDWLHQWVZHDQDO\VHGWKHSUHVHQFHRI
H[WUDSOHXUDODQGFDUGLRSKUHQLFQRGHVWKHLUQXPEHU VLQJOHRUPXOWLSOH DQGWKHLU
VL]H PPEHWZHHQDQGPPDQG!PP
5HVXOWV 7KH SUHYDOHQFH RI H[WUDSOHXUDO QRGHV LQGHSHQGHQWO\ IURP WKHLU VL]H
UHVXOWHG OHVV WKDQ LQ DOO JURXSV RI SDWLHQWV H[FHSW IRU SDWLHQWV ZLWK 030
7KHSUHYDOHQFHRIFDUGLRSKUHQLFQRGHV!PPZDV
LQSDWLHQWVZLWK030 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSOHXUDOPHWDVWDVLVDQGOHVVWKDQ
LQDOORWKHUJURXSVRISDWLHQWV1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHSUHYDOHQFHRI
FDUGLRSKUHQLFQRGHVPPLQDOOJURXSVRISDWLHQWV S! ZHUHIRXQG
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQFHRIH[WUDSOHXUDOQRGHVRIDQ\VL]HDQGFDUGLRSKUHQLF
QRGHVJUHDWHUWKDQPPKDYHDVLJQLÀFDQWGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHLQPDOLJQDQWSOHXUDO
GLVHDVHHLWKHUSULPDU\RUVHFRQGDU\ZKLOHWKH\DUHH[WUHPHO\UDUHLQRWKHUGLV
HDVHVQHRSODVWLFRUQRW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
/XQJYROXPHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSHFWXVH[FDYDWXPTXDQWLI\LQJWKH
SXOPRQDU\LQYROYHPHQW"
-9DOOHMRV&&DSXQD\3&DUUDVFRVD00DUWLQH])HUUR-&DUUDVFRVD
9LFHQWH/RSH]$5%XHQRV$LUHV$5 MDYVV#\DKRRFRPDU
3XUSRVH7RTXDQWLI\WKHOXQJYROXPHRISHFWXVH[FDYDWXP 3( SDWLHQWVXVLQJ
FKHVW PXOWLVOLFH FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7 DQG WR FRPSDUH WKHVH ZLWK D
FRQWUROJURXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\VL[SDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUROG ZLWK3(
DQG FRQWUROV XQGHUZHQW ORZ GRVH FKHVW 0'&7 7KH YROXPH RI OXQJ SDUHQ
FK\PDLQHDFKH[DPLQDWLRQZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\SHUIRUPLQJDWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDO
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ:HGHWHUPLQHGYDOXHVIRUWKHYROXPHRIWKHULJKWOXQJOHIWOXQJ
DQGWKHSXOPRQDU\YROXPHLQGH[ 39,ULJKWOHIW 6HYHULW\LQGLFHVRIWKHGHIRUPLW\
XVLQJWKHVWDQGDUG+DOOHULQGH[ +, FKHVWZDOODV\PPHWU\LQGH[ &:$, FDUGLDF
FRPSUHVVLRQ LQGH[ &&, FDUGLDF DV\PPHWU\ LQGH[ &$, DQG VWHUQDO WLOW DQJOH
ZHUHDOVRFDOFXODWHGIURP&7VFDQV6WDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHVRIPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUH
FDOFXODWHGXVLQJWKH6WXGHQWWDQG.UXVNDOO:DOOLVWHVWV
5HVXOWV:HIRXQGHYLGHQFH S RIDORZHU39,LQ3(SDWLHQWV LQ
FRPSDULVRQZLWKFRQWUROSDWLHQWV 7KH39,ZDVGLUHFWO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK
WKH+, U S DQGZLWKWKH&&, U S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVSUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\VKRZHGGLIIHUHQFHVLQOXQJYROXPHVEHWZHHQ
3( SDWLHQWV DQG FRQWURO JURXS 7KHUHIRUH 39, FRUUHODWHG ZLWK VHYHULW\ LQGLFHV
7KHVHÀQGLQJVVXJJHVWWKDWOXQJYROXPHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQPD\EHDVHYHULW\LQGH[
RISXOPRQDU\LQYROYHPHQW
%
3UHGLFWLRQRISRVWRSHUDWLYHSXOPRQDU\IXQFWLRQE\VLQJOHEUHDWK
GXDOHQHUJ\[HQRQ&7DSUHOLPLQDU\UHSRUW
+<DQDJLWD::DWDQDEH<6KLPL]X72NDGD+2KQR+2VDGD1+RQGD
01DND\DPD.DZDJRH6DLWDPD-3 K\DQDJLW#VDLWDPDPHGDFMS
3XUSRVH&KURQLFREVWUXFWLYHSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVH &23' LVFRPPRQDQGOXQJ
FDQFHULVVWLOORQHRIWKHOHDGLQJFDXVHVRIGHDWKZRUOGZLGH6RLWLVLPSRUWDQWWR
DVFHUWDLQRSHUDELOLW\RISDWLHQWVKDYLQJERWK&23'DQGOXQJFDQFHU7KHSXUSRVH
ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHDELOLW\RI[HQRQGXDOHQHUJ\&7WRSUHGLFWSRVWRSHUDWLYHSXO
PRQDU\IXQFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(LJKWSDWLHQWVZLWKOXQJFDQFHUSODQQHGIRUUHVHFWLRQZHUH
HQUROOHGLQWKLVVWXG\,QVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYHGWKLVVWXG\DQGZULWWHQ
LQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZDVREWDLQHGIURPDOOSDWLHQWV7KH\ZHUHVFDQQHGZLWKDGXDO
VRXUFH&7VFDQQHULQGXDOHQHUJ\PRGH N96QN9 GXULQJDEUHDWKKROG
DIWHUVLQJOHYLWDOFDSDFLW\EUHDWKRIDPL[WXUHRI[HQRQDQGR[\JHQLQWKHUDWLRRI
[HQRQ ;HQRQLPDJHV ;HLPDJHV ZHUHFDOFXODWHGE\WKUHHPDWHULDO
GHFRPSRVLWLRQ7KHVXPRIWKHSL[HOYDOXHVRIWKH;HLPDJHVZLWKLQWKHSDUWRI
WKHOXQJWREHUHPDLQHGDIWHUUHVHFWLRQ $ DQGWKDWRIWKHZKROHOXQJ % ZHUH
HQXPHUDWHG:HPXOWLSOLHG$%DQGSUHRSHUDWLYHIRUFHGH[SLUDWRU\YROXPHLQRQH
VHFRQG )(9 RUIRUFHGYLWDOFDSDFLW\ )9& WRSUHGLFWSRVWRSHUDWLYH)(9RU)9&
3UHGLFWHG)(9DQG)9&ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKPHDVXUHGSRVWRSHUDWLYH)(9DQG
)9&DQGUHJUHVVLRQZDVWHVWHGE\WVWDWLVWLFV
5HVXOWV7KHSUHGLFWHGYDOXHVRI)(9DQG)9&IURP;HLPDJHVFRUUHODWHGWRWKH
SRVWRSHUDWLYHPHDVXUHPHQWV 5 DQGWKHUHJUHVVLRQZDVVLJQLÀFDQW
IRU)9& S
&RQFOXVLRQ3UHGLFWHGSRVWRSHUDWLYH)(9DQG)9&ZLWKWKH;HLPDJHVFRUUHODWHG
WRWKHSRVWRSHUDWLYH)(9DQG)9&
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
*HQLWRXULQDU\JDVWURLQWHVWLQDODQGELOLDU\
LQWHUYHQWLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
0*LYHQ'XEOLQ,(
7-DUJLHOOR/XEOLQ3/
%
8WHULQHDUWHU\HPEROLVDWLRQSUHLQWHUYHQWLRQDOSUHGLFWLRQRIWKH
EHVWWXEHDQJOHREOLTXLW\IRUYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHXWHULQHDUWHU\RULJLQ
XVLQJ'UHFRQVWUXFWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05DQJLRJUDSK\
1111DJXLE1($1RXU(OGLQ%6FKHOO7*UXEHU5RXK7/HKQHUW
7-9RJO)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'( QDJ\QQQ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RWHVWWKHDFFXUDF\RI'UHFRQVWUXFWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05DQJL
RJUDSK\ '&(05$ LQSUHGLFWLQJWKHEHVWWXEHDQJOHREOLTXLW\WRYLVXDOLVHWKH
XWHULQHDUWHU\RULJLQ 8$2 EHIRUHXWHULQHDUWHU\HPEROLVDWLRQ 8$(
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFOXGHGIHPDOHV PHDQDJH
\HDUV WRZKRP8$(ZDVSHUIRUPHG&(05$ZDVSHUIRUPHGEHIRUH8$(
DQG'LPDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJ,QVSDFHDSSOLFDWLRQ7KH'ÀJXUHZDV
URWDWHGLQDOOGLUHFWLRQVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHEHVWDQJOHIRUYLVXDOLVLQJWKH8$2E\WZR
UDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXV7KHVXJJHVWHGDQJOHZDVSURYLGHGWRWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQLVW
IRURSWLRQDOXVDJH$IWHU8$(WKHDFWXDODQJOHXVHGIRUYLVXDOLVDWLRQZDVUHFRUGHG
DQGFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHVXJJHVWHGDQJOH&RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHVXJJHVWHGDQJOH
DQGDFWXDODQJOHZDVWHVWHGXVLQJ6SHDUPDQҋVFRUUHODWLRQWHVW
5HVXOWV)RUYLVXDOLVLQJWKHOHIW8$WKHVXJJHVWHGDQJOHLQWKHVLGHWRVLGHGLUHF
WLRQVKRZHGDPHDQRIULJKWWKHDFWXDODQJOHZDVULJKW
,QWKHFHSKDORFDXGDOGLUHFWLRQWKHVXJJHVWHGDQJOHZDVFDXGDOWKH
DFWXDODQJOHZDVFDXGDO$VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWVWURQJSRVLWLYHFRU
UHODWLRQZDVGHWHFWHGEHWZHHQWKHVXJJHVWHGDQGDFWXDODQJOHVLQWKHVLGHWRVLGH
UKR S DQGFHSKDORFDXGDOGLUHFWLRQV UKR S )RUWKH
ULJKW8$WKHVXJJHVWHGDQJOHLQWKHVLGHWRVLGHGLUHFWLRQZDVOHIWWKH
DFWXDODQJOHZDVOHIW,QWKHFHSKDORFDXGDOGLUHFWLRQWKHVXJJHVWHGDQ
JOHZDVFDXGDOWKHDFWXDODQJOHZDVFDXGDO$VWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQWVWURQJSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZDVGHWHFWHGLQWKHVLGHWRVLGH UKR
S DQGFHSKDORFDXGDOGLUHFWLRQV UKR S
&RQFOXVLRQ3UHLQWHUYHQWLRQDO'&(05$FDQDFFXUDWHO\SUHGLFWWKHEHVWWXEH
DQJOHREOLTXLW\IRUYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHXWHULQHDUWHU\RULJLQEHIRUH8$(
%
$GYDQWDJHVRIWKHEUDFKLDODSSURDFKLQXWHULQHDUWHULHVHPEROLVDWLRQ
351HFKLIRU%'RUREDW%XFKDUHVW52 RIÀFH#GUQHFKLIRUUR
3XUSRVH'HVFULSWLRQRIDGYDQWDJHVRIWKHEUDFKLDODSSURDFKLQXWHULQHDUWHULHV
HPEROLVDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHFDVHVRIXWHULQHÀEURLGVHPEROLVDWLRQ
XVLQJEUDFKLDODSSURDFK6RPHSDUDPHWHUVWKDWSHUPLWWKHHVWLPDWLRQRIWKLVWHFK
QLTXHҋVUHVXOWVWKHFRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGWKHSRVWSURFHGXUHTXDOLW\RIOLIHZHUHIROORZHG
5HVXOWV7KHFDWKHWHULVDWLRQRIELODWHUDOXWHULQHDUWHULHVZDVSRVVLEOHLQRI
FDVHV7KHPHDQWLPHRIWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQZDVPLQ 6'PLQ 5DGLRVFRS\
WLPHUDQJHGEHWZHHQPLQXWHVDQGPLQXWHVZLWKDPHDQWLPHRIPLQXWHV
6'PLQXWHV 7KHFRPSOLFDWLRQVDWWKHSXQFWXUHVLWHZHUHEUDFKLDODUWHU\
VSDVPLQRIFDVHVORFDOKDHPDWRPDLQRIFDVHVEUDFKLDODUWHU\WKURP
ERVLVLQRIFDVHVDQGFDVHRIWHJXPHQWDGKHUHQFHWRWKHGHHSHUOD\HUV
5HDGPLVVLRQIRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVZDVQHFHVVDU\LQFDVHV7KHSRVWHPEROLVDWLRQ
SDLQZDVSHUFHSWHGOHVVLQWHQVH PHDQRQDVFDOH RIWKHSDWLHQWV
DSSUHFLDWHGWKHDEVHQFHRIDQ\FRQVWUDLQWWRUHVWDVDQLPSRUWDQWDGYDQWDJH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHEUDFKLDODSSURDFKLVDVXFFHVVIXOWHFKQLTXHVXSHULRUWRIHPXUDO
DSSURDFK WKDW SHUPLWV D VLJQLÀFDQW UHGXFWLRQ LQ UDGLRVFRS\ WLPH DQG UDGLDWLRQ
GRVH&RPSOLFDWLRQVDWWKHSXQFWXUHVLWHDUHYHU\UDUHVLQGLUHFWUHODWLRQZLWKRS
HUDWRUҋVH[SHULHQFH7KHSDWLHQWҋVFRPIRUWGXULQJÀUVWKRXUVDIWHULQWHUYHQWLRQLV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHG7KHSRVWHPEROLVDWLRQSDLQLVOHVVLQWHQVH0LFURFDWKHWHUV
ZHUHQRWQHFHVVDU\DVGLDJQRVWLFFDWKHWHUVZHUHXVHGLQDOOWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQVWKXV
OHDGLQJWRFRVWUHGXFWLRQV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
$UWHULDOHPEROLVDWLRQIRUFHUYLFDOOHLRP\RPDVKRXOGZHWUHDWLWDV
DGHQRP\RVLV"
-.RK0.LP0/HH'-XQJ63DUN0/HH-:RQ'/HH./HH
6HRXO.5 TKVR#\XKVDF
%
7UDQVFDWKHWHUSHOYLFDUWHULDOHPEROLVDWLRQIRUFRQWURORIREVWHWULF
KDHPRUUKDJH
0)HUUHU3XFKRO&/DQFLHJR((VWHEDQ-&LDPSL0(GR
6(*RQ]OH]6(*RQ]OH]$O]LUD(67ROHGR(6 OROHVIHUUHU#RQRFRP
3XUSRVH([FHVVLYHEORRGORVVLVFRQVLGHUHGWREHJUHDWHUWKDQPOLQYDJLQDO
GHOLYHU\RUPODIWHUFDHVDUHDQVHFWLRQ7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVZRUNLVWRSUHVHQW
RXUH[SHULHQFHLQHPHUJHQF\VHOHFWLYHDUWHULDOHPEROLVDWLRQLQWZRKRVSLWDOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSUHVHQWZRPHQZKRXQGHUZHQWLQWUDFWDEOHRE
VWHWULFEOHHGLQJ0HDQSDWLHQWDJHZDV\HDUV,QERWKKRVSLWDOVWKHUHZDVD
WUDLQHGWHDPRQFDOOIRULQWHUYHQWLRQDOSURFHGXUHV,QGLFDWLRQIRUVHOHFWLYHDUWHULDO
HPEROLVDWLRQZDVPDGHE\J\QDHFRORJLVWVDQGDQDHVWKHWLVWV1RQVHOHFWLYHSHOYLF
DUWHULRJUDSK\ZDVSHUIRUPHGYLDWUDQVIHPRUDODSSURDFKWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKHDQDWRP\
DQG SRLQWV RI EOHHGLQJ :H SHUIRUPHG LQWUDDUWHULDO HPEROLVDWLRQ XVLQJ JHODWLQH
VSRQJHSDUWLFOHVRUFRLOVGHSHQGLQJRQEOHHGLQJVRXUFH
5HVXOWVZHUHSULPDU\KDHPRUUKDJHVDQGZHUHVHFRQGDU\&DXVHV
ZHUHDIWHUYDJLQDOGHOLYHULHVSODFHQWDDFFUHWDFHUYLFDOWHDUDQGXWHULQH
DWRQ\DIWHUFDHVDUHDQVHFWLRQDUWHULDOWHDUVXWHULQHDWRQ\DQGSVHXGRDQ
HXU\VPDIWHUDERUWLRQSVHGRDQHXU\VPDIWHUHFWRSLFFHUYLFDOSUHJQDQF\7KH
WZRVHFRQGDU\KDHPRUUKDJHVZHUHGXHWRSVHXGRDQHXU\VPV&DWKHWHULVDWLRQRI
ERWKXWHULQHDUWHULHVZDVSHUIRUPHGLQSDWLHQWV(PEROLVDWLRQPDWHULDO
ZHHPSOR\HGJHODWLQHVSRQJHXVLQJ39$SDUWLFOHVDQGSDWLHQWZLWKFRLOV
:HKDGQRWFRPSOLFDWLRQVUHODWHGWRSURFHGXUH7KHUHVXOWZDVVDWLVIDFWRU\LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKFRPSOHWHFHVVDWLRQRIEOHHGLQJEXWWZRFDVHVSUHVHQWHGVRPHKRXUV
ODWHUHPEROLVDWLRQDQHSLVRGHRIUHEOHHGLQJWKDWXQGHUZHQWHPHUJHQWK\VWHUHFWRP\
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWUDDUWHULDOHPEROLVDWLRQLVDQDOWHUQDWLYHWRVXUJLFDOPHDVXUHVRIIHUV
JRRGUHVXOWVLVVDIHDQGSUHVHUYHVIHUWLOLW\RIZRPHQ
%
$QRYHOWHFKQLTXHRISHUFXWDQHRXVFORVXUHRIHQWHURFXWDQHRXVÀVWXOD
%6HNRYVNL/&DPEM6DSXQDU6SOLW+5 EXGLPLU#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH3DWLHQWVZLWKDSRVWRSHUDWLYHHQWHURFXWDQHRXVÀVWXODKDYHVLJQLÀFDQWO\
UHGXFHGTXDOLW\RIOLIH5HFHQWO\VHYHUDOPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHPHWKRGVZHUHGHYHORSHG
DVDQDOWHUQDWLYHWRVXUJLFDOWKHUDS\IRUWKLVFRQGLWLRQ:HSUHVHQWRXUWHFKQLTXH
RISHUFXWDQHRXVFORVXUHRIHQWHURFXWDQHRXVÀVWXODXQGHUÁXRURVFRS\JXLGDQFH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LYHSDWLHQWVZKRKDYHGHYHORSHGORZRXWSXWHQWHUR
FXWDQHRXVÀVWXODVLQFH0DUFKZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\(QWHURFXWDQHRXV
ÀVWXODRFFXUUHGDVDSRVWRSHUDWLYHFRPSOLFDWLRQRIFRORUHFWDOFDUFLQRPDLQIRXU
SDWLHQWVDQGLQRQHSDWLHQWÀVWXODZDVDSRVWVXUJHU\FRPSOLFDWLRQRIDSHUIRUDWHG
GLYHUWLFXOLWLV1EXW\OF\DQRDFULOLFJOXHPL[HGZLWKOLSLRGRODVDQHPEROLVDWLRQPDWH
ULDOZDVGHSOR\HGLQDÀVWXODWKURXJK)K\GURSKLOLFFDWKHWHUXQGHUÁXRURVFRS\
JXLGDQFH3URFHGXUHWDNHVOHVVWKDQPLQXWHVDQGUHTXLUHVDSSUR[LPDWHO\
VHFRQGVRIÁXRURVFRS\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
)OXRURVFRSLFDOO\JXLGHGGLODWDWLRQVRIRHVRSKDJHDOVWULFWXUHVGXHWR
HSLGHUPRO\VLVEXOORVDG\VWURSKLFDORQJWHUPUHVXOWVIURPDVLQJOH
FHQWUHVWXG\
6&6SLOLRSRXORV5,QFKLQJROR0.URNLGLV3*NRXW]LRV$0F*DUWK
,$KPHG1.DUXQDQLWK\56DOWHU76DEKDUZDO/RQGRQ8.
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHLPPHGLDWHDQGORQJWHUPUHVXOWVIROORZLQJWKHÁXRUR
VFRSLFDOO\JXLGHGRHVRSKDJHDOEDOORRQGLODWDWLRQVIRUWKHPDQDJHPHQWRIG\VSKDJLD
LQDVHULHVRISDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPHSLGHUPRO\VLVEXOORVDG\VWURSKLFD '(%
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHPHGLFDOUHFRUGVRIDOOSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKÁXRUR
VFRSLFDOO\JXLGHGEDOORRQGLODWDWLRQRIRHVRSKDJHDOVWULFWXUHVDQG'(%EHWZHHQ
DQG ZHUH LQFOXGHG LQ WKH VWXG\ DQG UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ DQDO\VHG 7KH
LQGLFDWLRQIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWZDVG\VSKDJLDDWWULEXWHGWRDWOHDVWRQHUDGLRORJLFDOO\
YHULÀHGRHVRSKDJHDOVWULFWXUH7KHVWXG\ҋVSULPDU\HQGSRLQWVLQFOXGHGSURFHGXUDO
WHFKQLFDO VXFFHVV FOLQLFDO LPSURYHPHQW DVVHVVHG E\ D WR G\VSKDJLD VFRUH
DQGPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVUDWH6HFRQGDU\HQGSRLQWVLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVXUYLYDODQG
UHLQWHUYHQWLRQUDWHV
5HVXOWV,QWRWDOFRQVHFXWLYH'(%SDWLHQWV PHDQDJHUDQJH
\HDUV VXIIHULQJIURPG\VSKDJLDGXHWRRHVRSKDJHDOVWULFWXUHVZHUHWUHDWHGZLWK
ÁXRURVFRSLFDOO\JXLGHGEDOORRQGLODWDWLRQV,QWRWDOSURFHGXUHVDQGGLODWD
WLRQVLQOHVLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHG7KHEDOORRQGLDPHWHUVUDQJHGIURPWRPP
0HDQWLPHIROORZXSZDVUDQJHPRQWKV7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVV
UDWHZDV SURFHGXUHV 7KHUHZHUHQRPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQV0HDQ
UHLQWHUYHQWLRQIUHHLQWHUYDOUDWHZDVPRQWKVZKLOHSRVWSURFHGXUDOG\VSKDJLD
VFRUH ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU FRPSDUHG WR EDVHOLQH &, YV
&,UHVSHFWLYHO\S
&RQFOXVLRQ )OXRURVFRSLFDOO\ JXLGHG EDOORRQ GLODWDWLRQ IRU WKH PDQDJHPHQW RI
G\VSKDJLDFDXVHGE\RHVRSKDJHDOVWULFWXUHVRZLQJWR'(%LVVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYH
7KHVSHFLÀFPHWKRGGHPRQVWUDWHGDVLJQLÀFDQWFOLQLFDOLPSURYHPHQWRIG\VSKDJLD
DQG ORQJWHUP VDWLVIDFWRU\ UHLQWHUYHQWLRQ UDWHV ZKLOH QR PDMRU FRPSOLFDWLRQV
ZHUHQRWHG
%
(IIHFWLYHQHVVRISHUFXWDQHRXVELOLDU\VWRQHUHPRYDODVSULPDU\
WUHDWPHQWFRPSDUHGZLWKHQGRVFRSLFUHWURJUDGHWHFKQLTXHLQFDVHV
RI,+%'VWRQHVPPELOHGXFWVWRQHVKLVWRU\RI*,E\SDVVVXUJHU\
6&KRL<+DQ6/HH+<X-HRQMXVL.5 PDXP]RD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRISHUFXWDQHRXVELOLDU\VWRQHUHPRYDODV
SULPDU\WUHDWPHQWFRPSDUHGZLWKHQGRVFRSLFUHWURJUDGHWHFKQLTXHLQFDVHVRI
,+%'VWRQHVPPELOHGXFWVWRQHVKLVWRU\RI*,E\SDVVVXUJHU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP0DUFKWR0D\DWRWDORIFRQVHFXWLYH
SDWLHQWVZLWKELOLDU\VWRQHVXQGHUZHQWSHUFXWDQHRXVELOLDU\VWRQHUHPRYDODVSUL
PDU\WUHDWPHQW JURXS,Q RUVHFRQGDU\WUHDWPHQWDIWHUHQGRVFRSLFUHWURJUDGH
WHFKQLTXHVKDGIDLOHG JURXS,,Q ,QWZRJURXSVWKHRQHVZKRVDWLVÀHGWKH
LQFOXVLRQFULWHULDZHUH JURXS,ҋ0) 0HDQDJH\HDUV DQG JURXS
,,ҋ0) 0HDQDJH\HDUV UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHLQFOXVLRQFULWHULDZHUHDV
IROORZVSDWLHQWVZKRL KDG,+%'VWRQHVLL KDGPPELOHGXFWVWRQHVLLL KDG
KLVWRU\RISUHYLRXV*,E\SDVVVXUJHU\ HJVXEWRWDOJDVWUHFWRP\ZLWK%LOORWK,,RS
WRWDOJDVWUHFWRP\S\ORUXVSUHVHUYLQJSDQFUHDWLFRGXRGHQHFWRP\333'5HQ<
FKROHGRFKRMHMXQRVWRP\ :HDQDO\VHGVXFFHVVUDWHVDQGOHQJWKRISRVWSURFHGXUDO
KRVSLWDOVWD\RIWKHWZRJURXSV
5HVXOWV 7KHUH ZDV QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH LQ VXFFHVV UDWH EHWZHHQ WKH WZR
JURXSV LQJURXS,ҋDQG LQJURXS,,ҋ 3 $QGWKH
OHQJWKRISRVWSURFHGXUDOKRVSLWDOVWD\ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGLQJURXS,,ҋ PHDQ
GD\VJURXS,ҋPHDQGD\V3 $P\ODVHDQGOLSDVHOHYHOEHWZHHQSUH
DQGSRVWSURFHGXUHZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW 3 DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
7KHUHZDVQRSURFHGXUDOFRPSOLFDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHIRUHLQFDVHVRIDERYHPHQWLRQHGSDWLHQWVSULPDU\SHUFXWDQH
RXVELOLDU\VWRQHUHPRYDOFDQEHPRUHHIÀFLHQW
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRFRPSDUHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIXWHULQHDUWHU\
HPEROLVDWLRQ 8$( LQWUHDWLQJV\PSWRPDWLFÀEURLGVLQWKHXWHULQHFHUYL[WRWKDWLQ
WKHXWHULQHERG\RUIXQGXV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )URP WKH GDWD IRU SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW 8$(
EHWZHHQDQGZHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGWKHGDWDIRUSDWLHQWVZLWK
ÀEURLGVORFDWHGLQWKHXWHULQHFHUYL[6HYHQRIWKHSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWHGDWRWDORI
ÀEURLGVLQWKHXWHULQHERG\RUIXQGXVDVZHOODVLQWKHXWHULQHFHUYL[7KHHIIHFWV
RI8$(DQGYDVFXODULWLHVRQDQJLRJUDSKLFÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQÀEURLGV
LQWKHFHUYL[DQGÀEURLGVLQWKHXWHULQHERG\RUIXQGXV1HFURVLVRIÀEURLGVZDV
DVVHVVHGE\05,PRQWKVDIWHU8$(6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJ
WKH0DQQ:KLWQH\WHVWDQG)LVKHUҋVH[DFWWHVW
5HVXOWV&RPSOHWHQHFURVLVRIOHLRP\RPDVLQWKHXWHULQHFHUYL[ZDVVHHQLQRQO\
SDWLHQWVRIWKHZKLOHDOOÀEURLGVLQWKHXWHULQHERG\RUIXQGXVZHUHFRPSOHWHO\
LQIDUFWHG S 3DUWLDOQHFURVLVZDVVHHQLQDQGQRQHFURVLVLQ2QH
SDWLHQWXQGHUZHQWK\VWHURVFRSLFUHVHFWLRQIRUUHPRYDORILQFRPSOHWHO\LQIDUFWHG
ÀEURLG3RRUYDVFXODULWLHVZHUHQRWHGLQRISDWLHQWV ZLWKFHUYLFDOÀEURLGV
EXWLQQRQHRIWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKÀEURLGVLQWKHXWHULQHERG\RUIXQGXV S
&RQFOXVLRQ3RRUYDVFXODULWLHVZHUHIUHTXHQWÀQGLQJLQFHUYLFDOOHLR\RPDVDQG
RXWFRPHVRI8$(IRUFHUYLFDOOHLRP\RPDVZHUHGLVDSSRLQWLQJDQGLQGLFDWHFDXWLRQ
LQVHOHFWLQJDQGFRXQVHOOLQJSDWLHQWVIRUWKLVWUHDWPHQW
5HVXOWV ,Q DOO ÀYH SDWLHQWV ÀVWXOD ZDV LPPHGLDWHO\ FORVHG DQG WKHUH ZHUH QR
FRPSOLFDWLRQVFRQVLGHULQJRXUSURFHGXUH,QRQHSDWLHQWORFDOFDQFHUUHFXUUHQFH
RFFXUUHGPRQWKVDIWHUWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQDQGLQWKHSDWLHQWZLWKGLYHUWLFXORVLV
PRQWKVODWHUWKHQHZHSLVRGHRIGLYHUWLFXOLWLVFDXVHGDEVFHVVIRUPDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 3HUFXWDQHRXV FORVXUH RI ORZRXWSXW HQWHURFXWDQHRXV ÀVWXODV ZLWK
F\DQRDFULODWHJOXHXQGHUÁXRURVFRS\JXLGDQFHLVDVLPSOHDQGHIIHFWLYHPHWKRG
WKDWUHSUHVHQWVDJRRGDOWHUQDWLYHWRVXUJLFDOWKHUDS\$GYDQWDJHRIWKLVPHWKRGLV
WKDWWKHJOXLQJRIWKHÀVWXODFRXOGEHHDVLO\GHWHFWHGXQGHUÁXRURVFRS\VLQFHOLSLRGRO
PDNHVWKHJOXHYLVLEOH6KRUWWHUPUHVXOWVRIWKLVQRYHOWHFKQLTXHDUHH[FHOOHQWEXW
IXUWKHUHYDOXDWLRQRIORQJWHUPUHVXOWVLVUHTXLUHG
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
7KHFRPSDULVRQRIYLVXDOLVDWLRQDPRQJEDOORRQRFFOXGHGUHWURJUDGH
WUDQVYHQRXVYHQRJUDSK\XVLQJLRGLQHFRQWUDVWDQGFDUERQGLR[LGH
JDVDQGWKHVXEVHTXHQWREOLWHUDWLRQE\IRDPVFOHURVDQWVIRUJDVWULF
YDULFHVXQGHU'6$
-.RL]XPL7+DVKLPRWR.0\RMLQ&,WRX7+DUD76HNLJXFKL7,FKLNDZD
7.DJDZD1:DWDQDEH,VHKDUD-3 MNRL]XPL#LVLFFXWRNDLDFMS
3XUSRVH 3UHYLRXVO\ ZH DSSOLHG FDUERQ GLR[LGH JDV '6$ IRU EDOORRQRFFOXGHG
UHWURJUDGH WUDQVYHQRXV YHQRJUDSK\ %579 SULRU WR REOLWHUDWLRQ %572 XVLQJ
IRDPVFOHURVDQWVDQGFODULÀHG&2GHPRQVWUDWHGJDVWULFYDULFHV *9 PRUHFOHDUO\
WKDQLRGLQHFRQWUDVW+RZHYHUWKHSK\VLRORJLFDOSURSHUWLHVRI&2DQGIRDPDUH
GLIIHUHQW7KXVZHFRPSDUHGWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHPXQGHU'6$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUÀIWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWK*9%579XVLQJLRGLQHFRQWUDVW
ZDV SHUIRUPHG ÀUVW DQG WKHQ &2 VHFRQG 7KHVH %579 ZHUH UHSHDWHG DIWHU
FKDQJLQJ SDWLHQWҋV KDELWXV WKH FDWKHWHU SRVLWLRQV RU GRZQJUDGLQJV :KHQ *9
ZHUHRSDFLÀHGRQ&2%579IRDPVFOHURVDQWVZHUHLQMHFWHG(DFKYLVXDOLVDWLRQ
JUDGHRI*9 JUDGH*9RQO\*9!FROODWHUDOV*9FROODWHUDOVFROODWHUDOV
RQO\ ZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\WZRREVHUYHUV&DUP&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGWRFRQÀUPWKH
UHDFKRIDLULQWR*9
5HVXOWV7KLUW\IRXUSDLUVRI%579ZHUHSHUIRUPHGIRUÀIWHHQSDWLHQWV7KHJUDGHV
RQ&2%579 ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S VPDOOHUWKDQWKHJUDGHVRQ
LRGLQH%579 2QWKHRWKHUKDQGVWKHJUDGHVRQIRDP%572
DUHVLPLODUWRWKHODVWJUDGHVRQ&2%579 ZKLOHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S
GLIIHUHQWIURPWKHODVWJUDGHVRQLRGLQH%579 ,QDOOSDWLHQWV*9ZHUH
RSDFLÀHG E\ IRDP RQ &DUP &7 DQG FRPSOHWH WKURPERVLV RI *9 ZDV REWDLQHG
ZLWKRXWDQ\FRPSOLFDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&2%579YLVXDOLVHG*9EHWWHUWKDQLRGLQH%579DQGSURYLGHGD
JRRGVLPXODWLRQRI%572XVLQJIRDPVFOHURVDQWVOHDGLQJVXFFHVVIXOWKURPERVLV
RI*9
%
5HWULHYDEOHFRYHUHGVWHQWLQWKHWUHDWPHQWRIEHQLJQELOLDU\
VWULFWXUHVLQWHUPHGLDWHWHUPRXWFRPHV
&.LP'*ZRQ*<.R.%6XQJ+.<RRQ-6KLQ-.LP+<6RQJ
6HRXO.5 FKHUU\NLP#GUHDPZL]FRP
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHLQWHUPHGLDWHWHUPRXWFRPHVRIDUHWULHYDEOHFRYHUHG
VWHQWLQWKHWUHDWPHQWRIEHQLJQELOLDU\VWULFWXUHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )URP$SULO WR )HEUXDU\ SDWLHQWV ZLWK
EHQLJQELOLDU\VWULFWXUHVZHUHHQUROOHGLQWKLVVWXG\6HYHQWHHQSDWLHQWVKDGQRW
SUHYLRXVO\XQGHUJRQHLQWHUYHQWLRQDOWUHDWPHQW6L[WHHQSDWLHQWVKDGUHFXUUHQWRU
UHIUDFWRU\VWULFWXUHVGHVSLWHSURORQJHGFDWKHWHULQWHUSRVLWLRQDIWHUEDOORRQGLODWLRQ
SURFHGXUHV7KHUHWULHYDEOHVWHQWZDVIXOO\37)( SRO\WHWUDÁXRURHWK\OHQH FRYHUHG
VHOIH[SDQGDEOHQLWLQROVWHQW7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVFOLQLFDOVXFFHVV GUDLQDJHFDWK
HWHUUHPRYDODIWHUSHUFXWDQHRXVWUHDWPHQWXVLQJDUHWULHYDEOHVWHQW DQGSULPDU\
SDWHQF\UDWHZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV$WRWDORIUHWULHYDEOHFRYHUHGVWHQWVZHUHSODFHGGXHWRVWHQWPLJUDWLRQ
Q RUSHUVLVWHQWVWULFWXUH Q DIWHUVHVVLRQVRIVWHQWUHPRYDO
SURFHGXUHV7KHVWHQWVZHUHVXFFHVVIXOO\SODFHGDQGUHPRYHGLQDOOFDVHV7KH
PHDQVWHQWLQGZHOOLQJSHULRGZDVPRQWKV UDQJHPRQWKV &OLQLFDOVXFFHVV
ZDV DFKLHYHG LQ SDWLHQWV 'XULQJ WKH PHDQ IROORZXS RI PRQWKV
UDQJHPRQWKV WKUHHRISDWLHQWVKDGUHFXUUHQFHRIFOLQLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
VWULFWXUHV7KHSULPDU\SDWHQF\UDWHVDWDQG\HDUVZHUHDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWHUPHGLDWHWHUPRXWFRPHVLQGLFDWHWKDWSHUFXWDQHRXVWUHDWPHQWRI
EHQLJQELOLDU\VWULFWXUHVXVLQJDUHWULHYDEOHFRYHUHGVWHQWDSSHDUVWREHIHDVLEOH
DQGFOLQLFDOO\HIIHFWLYHPHWKRG
%
3HUFXWDQHRXV<FRQÀJXUHGFRYHUHGVWHQWSODFHPHQWIRUPDOLJQDQW
KLODUELOLDU\REVWUXFWLRQDSURVSHFWLYHSLORWVWXG\
16HR'*ZRQ*<.R.%6XQJ+.<RRQ-6KLQ-.LP+<6RQJ
6HRXO.5 VOGPVGO#KDQPDLOQHW
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHWHFKQLFDODQGFOLQLFDOVDIHW\DQGHIÀFDF\RISHUFXWDQH
RXV<FRQÀJXUHGFRYHUHGVWHQWSODFHPHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQWKLODUELOLDU\
REVWUXFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVLVDSURVSHFWLYHSLORWVWXG\WKDWHQUROOHGFRQ
VHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK PDOLJQDQW KLODU ELOLDU\ REVWUXFWLRQV IURP 2FWREHU WR
'HFHPEHU7KLVVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\WKH,QVWLWXWLRQDO5HYLHZ%RDUGRIRXU
,QVWLWXWLRQDQGLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZDVREWDLQHGIURPHDFKSDWLHQW$OOSDWLHQWVZHUH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
WUHDWHGZLWKSHUFXWDQHRXVWUDQVKHSDWLFSODFHPHQWRISDUWLDOO\H37)( H[SDQGHG
SRO\WHWUDÁXRURHWK\OHQH FRYHUHGVWHQWVLQD<FRQÀJXUDWLRQ
5HVXOWV%LODWHUDO<FRQÀJXUHGFRYHUHGVWHQWGHSOR\PHQWZDVWHFKQLFDOO\VXFFHVV
IXOLQDOOSDWLHQWV0LQRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVLQFOXGLQJSURFHGXUHUHODWHGFRPSOLFDWLRQV
VHOIOLPLWLQJKDHPRELOLD>Q @DQGUDSLGO\UHVROYLQJFKRODQJLWLV>Q @ RFFXUUHGLQ
IRXUSDWLHQWV %LOLUXELQOHYHOGHFUHDVHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\IROORZLQJVWHQWSODFH
PHQW S 0HGLDQSDWLHQWVXUYLYDODQGVWHQWSDWHQF\WLPHVZHUHGD\V
FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO>&,@GD\V DQGGD\V &,GD\V
UHVSHFWLYHO\6HYHQSDWLHQWV SUHVHQWHGZLWKVWHQWRFFOXVLRQGXHWRVOXGJH
LQFUXVWDWLRQ Q DQG WXPRXU RYHUJURZWK Q DQG UHTXLUHG UHSHDWHG 37%'
7XPRXULQJURZWKDFXWHFKROHF\VWLWLVRUVWHQWPLJUDWLRQZDVQRWREVHUYHGLQDQ\
RIWKHVHSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVRISHUFXWDQHRXVSDOOLDWLYHWUHDWPHQWRIPD
OLJQDQWKLODUELOLDU\REVWUXFWLRQZLWK<FRQÀJXUHGFRYHUHGVWHQWVVXJJHVWWKDWWKH\
DUHVDIHDQGFOLQLFDOO\HIIHFWLYH
5RRP(
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
66
2VWHRSRURVLVDQGERQHPDUURZ
0RGHUDWRUV
-($GDPV0DQFKHVWHU8.
09O\FKRX/DULVVD*5
%
,PSDFWRIH[HUFLVHRQERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLW\
,$EEDV+(OJKDZDEL:<RXQDQ$6DERXU0*REULDO&DLUR(*
LPDQDEEDV#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHLPSDFWRIFDORULFUHVWULFWLRQGLHWYHUVXVFDORULFUHVWULFWLRQ
GLHWLQDGGLWLRQWRDHURELFH[HUFLVHVRQERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLW\LQREHVHZRPHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\REHVHZRPHQZHUHFODVVLÀHGUDQGRPO\LQWRWZR
JURXSVRIHTXDOLQQXPEHU7KHÀUVWJURXSUHFHLYHGFDORULFUHVWULFWLRQGLHWZKLOH
WKH VHFRQG UHFHLYHG FDORULF UHVWULFWLRQ GLHW LQ DGGLWLRQ WR D SURJUDP RI DHURELF
H[HUFLVHVRYHUPRQWKV7KHYDULDEOHVPHDVXUHGLQFOXGHGERG\PDVVLQGH[IDW
ZHLJKWOHDQPDVVEDVDOPHWDEROLFUDWHDQGERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLW\
5HVXOWV &RPSDULVRQ EHWZHHQ ERWK JURXSV VKRZHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU SRVW
WUHDWPHQWOHDQPDVVEDVDOPHWDEROLFUDWHDQGERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLW\LQZHLJKW
EHDULQJERQHV OXPEDUVSLQHDQGKLS LQWKHVHFRQGJURXSFRPSDUHGWRWKHÀUVW
RQH2QWKHRWKHUKDQGWKHERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLW\RIWKHUDGLXVVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQW
GHFUHDVH EHWZHHQ WKH SUH DQG SRVWWUHDWPHQW UHVXOWV LQ ERWK JURXSV ZLWK QR
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSV
&RQFOXVLRQ6LJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHLQWKHERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLW\RIWKHZHLJKWEHDULQJ
ERQHV ZDV QRWHG LQ REHVH ZRPHQ XQGHUJRLQJ FDORULF UHVWULFWLRQ LQ DGGLWLRQ WR
DHURELFH[HUFLVHVWKDQLQWKRVHQRWXQGHUJRLQJH[HUFLVHV$HURELFH[HUFLVHVVKRXOG
EHDGGHGWRZHLJKWORVVSURJUDPVIRUREHVHZRPHQWRUHGXFHWKHDGYHUVHHIIHFWV
RIFDORULFUHVWULFWLRQGLHWRQERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLW\
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHXOWUDVRXQGDWWKHSKDODQJHVLQDFRKRUWRIWZLQVRI
GLIIHUHQWDJHV
**XJOLHOPL)'H7HUOL]]L$&DULQL/6LQLEDOGL50LQJDUHOOL)%UDQFDWL
)RJJLD,7&DUSL,75RPH,7 JJXJOLHOPL#XQLIJLW
3XUSRVH3UHOLPLQDU\VWXG\RIERQHWLVVXHTXDOLW\E\TXDQWLWDWLYHXOWUDVRXQG 486
DWWKHSKDODQJHVLQWZLQFKLOGUHQDQGDGXOWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVWZLQFRXSOHVRIKHDOWK\FKLOGUHQXQGHU\HDUVRI
DJH 1 DQGRIDGXOWV 1 LQWKHDJHUDQJH\HDUVZHUHUHFUXLWHGIRU
486PHDVXUHPHQWDWWKHSKDODQJHV$QWKURSRPHWULFGDWD VH[DJHKHLJKWDQG
ZHLJKW ZHUHUHFRUGHGWRJHWKHUZLWKDPSOLWXGHGHSHQGHQWVSHHGRIVRXQG $'
6R6 DQGERQHWUDQVPLVVLRQWLPH %77
5HVXOWV0HDQDJHLQFKLOGUHQJURXSZDV\UVKHLJKWFPZHLJKW
NJ0HDQDJHLQDGXOWJURXSZDV\UVKHLJKWFPZHLJKW
NJ,QFKLOGUHQ$'6R6DQG%77ZHUHSRVLWLYHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKDJH U
U KHLJKW U U DQGZHLJKW U U LQDGXOWV$'6R6ZDV
QHJDWLYHO\UHODWHGWRDJH U $'6R6DQG%77ZHUHSRVLWLYHO\UHODWHGWRKHLJKW
U U &RUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVIRU$'6R6DQG8%3,EHWZHHQFRXSOHGRI
WZLQVDUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUIRUFKLOGUHQ U IRU$'6R6DQGU IRU%77
WKDQIRUDGXOWV U IRU$'6R6DQGU IRU%77 7KHDEVROXWHYDOXHRIWKH
GLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWZLQVIRU$'6R6DQG%77LVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQDGXOWWZLQV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
WKDQLQFKLOGUHQ$'6R6GLIIFKLOGUHQDGXOWVWWHVW
%77GLIIFKLOGUHQDGXOWVWWHVW$EVROXWHGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQWZLQVLQFUHDVHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKDJH U SIRU$'6R6
DQGU SIRU%77
&RQFOXVLRQ'LIIHUHQWLDWLRQLQERQHWLVVXHTXDOLW\LQWZLQVLVLQFUHDVLQJZLWKDJH
DPRQJ WZLQV FRXSOHV DQG WKLV SUREDEO\ UHÁHFWV GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ LQ OLIHVW\OH OLIH
KDELWVDQGGLHW
%
%DULDWULFVXUJHU\DQGUDGLRORJLVWVEHVLGHVFRPSOLFDWLRQVDQ
LPSRUWDQWUROHLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWUHDWPHQWHIÀFDF\DQGHIIHFWV
''LDQR)3RQWL&6DVVL**DU]LOOR**XJOLHOPL(6DOL]]RQL
*%DWWLVWD$%D]]RFFKL%RORJQD,76DQ*LRYDQQL5RWRQGR)RJJLD,7
GDQLGG#OLEHURLW
%
)DWIUDFWLRQDQG7 YDOXHVRIYHUWHEUDOERQHPDUURZXWLOLVLQJDQHZ
IDWVHSDUDWLRQ05WHFKQLTXHLQSHULPHQRSDXVDOZRPHQFRPSDULVRQ
ZLWKERQHPLQHUDOGHQVLWRPHWU\
)%(UJHQ*<LOGLULP$&HOLN$(<LOGL]-.DUDND\D8$\GLQJR]
$QNDUD75,VWDQEXO75 DHOFLQGU#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RXVHIDWIUDFWLRQDQG7 YDOXHVWRLQYHVWLJDWHERQHPLQHUDOLVDWLRQOHYHO
XVLQJDQHZ05WHFKQLTXHFDOOHG´LWHUDWLYHGHFRPSRVLWLRQRIZDWHUDQGIDWZLWKHFKR
DV\PPHWU\DQGOHDVWVTXDUHVHVWLPDWLRQTXDQWLÀFDWLRQµLQSHULPHQRSDXVDOZRPHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQ2FWREHUDQG'HFHPEHU PHDQDJH
\HDUVPD[PLQ FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZKRDJUHHGWRXQGHUJR05,
DQG ZKR KDG D VSLQDO GXDO HQHUJ\ [UD\ DEVRUSWLRPHWU\ '(;$ H[DPLQDWLRQ
FRQVWLWXWHG WKH VWXG\ SRSXODWLRQ ' IDVW JUDGLHQW UHFDOOHG HFKR )*5( SXOVH
VHTXHQFHZLWKVL[DV\PPHWULFHFKRHVZDVXVHG)DWIUDFWLRQDQG7 YDOXHVZHUH
PHDVXUHGIURP//YHUWHEUDHE\SODFLQJ52,V'HSHQGLQJRQWVFRUHVGHULYHG
IURP%0'YHUWHEUDHZHUHFODVVLÀHGLQWRJURXSV QRUPDORVWHRSDHQLD
RVWHRSRURVLV 2QHZD\$129$RU:HOFK$129$ZDVSHUIRUPHGWRFRPSDUHWKH
GLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJJURXSV7KHDELOLW\RIIDWIUDFWLRQIRUWKHSUHGLFWLRQRIRVWHRSRUR
VLVRVWHRSDHQLDZDVHYDOXDWHGE\52&DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV)RUIDWIUDFWLRQWKHPHDQYDOXHVZHUHIRXQGWREHGLIIHUHQWLQWKUHHJURXSV
3 *URXSYHUWHEUDHZHUHGLIIHUHQWIURPJURXSVDQG 3 7KH
DUHDXQGHU52&FXUYHIRUIDWIUDFWLRQZDV &, 7KHRSWLPDO
FXWRIISRLQWZDVREWDLQHGDV)RUWKLVVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIIDWIUDF
WLRQZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\)RU7 WKHUHZDVQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHJURXSV 3
&RQFOXVLRQ,WLVSRVVLEOHWRHVWLPDWHWKHOHYHORIERQHPLQHUDOLVDWLRQE\TXDQWLÀ
FDWLRQRIWKHIDWIUDFWLRQZLWKWKHQHZ05WHFKQLTXHZLWKDQDFFHSWDEOHVHQVLWLYLW\
DQGVSHFLÀFLW\OHYHOV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FDOLQJUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQWUDEHFXODUERQHPDVVDQG'
PLFURVWUXFWXUHLQWZRORFDWLRQVRIWKHKXPDQIHPXU
7%DXP-6%DXHU,6LGRUHQNR50RQHWWL)(FNVWHLQ00DWVXXUD
(0/RFKPXHOOHU3.=\VVHW&5DHWK0XQLFK'(*DUFKLQJ'(
6DO]EXUJ$79LHQQD$7 WKEDXP#JP[GH
3XUSRVH 7R LQYHVWLJDWH SRVVLEOH VLWHGLIIHUHQFHV RI ERQH PDVVPLFURVWUXFWXUH
VFDOLQJUHODWLRQVWKDWPD\EHUHODWHGWRGLIIHUHQWORDGLQJFRQGLWLRQVDFFRUGLQJWR
:ROIIҋVODZRIERQHUHPRGHOOLQJ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV &\OLQGULFDO ERQH VSHFLPHQV ZLWK D GLDPHWHU RI PP
ZHUHKDUYHVWHGIURPKXPDQIHPRUD(LJKW\HLJKWVSHFLPHQVZHUHWDNHQIURPWKH
IHPRUDOQHFNDQGVSHFLPHQVIURPWKHJUHDWHUWURFKDQWHU'PLFUR&7LP
DJHVZLWKLVRWURSLFVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQRIPLFURPHWUHZHUHREWDLQHG%RQHPDVV
%979 RIHDFKVSHFLPHQZDVFDOFXODWHG7RGHWHUPLQHWKHORFDOVWUXFWXUHRIWKH
WUDEHFXODUQHWZRUNDVZHOODVLWVDOLJQPHQWZLWKWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKHH[WHUQDOIRUFH
DFWLQJRQWKHERQHLVRWURSLF DOSKD DQGDQLVRWURSLFVFDOLQJLQGLFHV DOSKD] ZHUH
FRPSXWHG7KHQWKHPRPHQWVRIWKHGLVWULEXWLRQ PHDQ>@YDULDQFHYDU RIWKH
LVRWURSLFDQGDQLVRWURSLFVFDOLQJLQGLFHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG6FDOLQJH[SRQHQWVZHUH
GHWHUPLQHGDVWKHVORSHRIDOLQHDUÀWLQWKHGRXEOHORJDULWKPLFUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKH
FRUUHODWLRQVRI%979DJDLQVWWKHPRPHQWVRIWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHVFDOLQJLQGLFHV
5HVXOWV$OOFRUUHODWLRQVREH\HGYHU\DFFXUDWHO\SRZHUODZVZLWKVFDOLQJH[SRQHQWV
RIDQG >DOSKD@ DQG YDU DOSKD DQG >DOSKD]@
DQGDQG YDU DOSKD] QHFNDQGWURFKDQWHUUHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KXVERQH
PDVVPLFURVWUXFWXUHVFDOLQJUHODWLRQVRIWKHERQHSUREHVWDNHQIURPWZRGLIIHUHQW
VLWHVRIWKHIHPXUVKRZHGVXUSULVLQJO\VPDOOYDULDWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKHIHPXUWUDEHFXODUERQHPDVVPLFURVWUXFWXUHVFDOLQJUHODWLRQV
PD\KDYHDUDWKHUXQLYHUVDOFKDUDFWHUDQGGRQRWGHSHQGVRPXFKRQWKHW\SHRI
H[WHUQDOPHFKDQLFDOIRUFHV
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRISHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVLQRVWHRSRURWLF
SDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHYHUWHEUDOIUDFWXUHXVLQJG\QDPLFFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG05,
*36FKPLGW$%LIIDU2'LHWULFK66RXUEURQ0'Ҋ$QDVWDVL
.1LNRODRX0)5HLVHU$%DXU0HOQ\N0XQLFK'(/HHGV8.
JHUZLQVFKPLGW#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORITXDQWLWDWLYHG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,
'&(05, LQYHUWHEUDOERQHPDUURZ Y%0 RISDWLHQWVZLWKRVWHRSRURVLVDQGDFXWH
YHUWHEUDOFRPSUHVVLRQIUDFWXUHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHIUDFWXUHV IHPDOHVPDOHV
PHGLDQDJHUDQJH DQGVXEMHFWVZLWKRXWNQRZQKLVWRU\RIRVWHRSRURVLV
IHPDOHV PDOHV PHGLDQ ZHUH H[DPLQHG XVLQJ WZRGLPHQVLRQDO
'&(05,52,'DWDLQIUDFWXUHG Q DQGQRUPDODSSHDULQJYHUWHEUDH Q
ZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWKDWZRFRPSDUWPHQWWUDFHUNLQHWLFPRGHOSURYLGLQJHVWLPDWHV
RIDWOHDVWLQGHSHQGHQWSDUDPHWHUVSODVPDÁRZ 3) SODVPDYROXPH 39 DQG
H[WUDFWLRQÁRZ () 3DUDPHWHUVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKGXDO[UD\DEVRUSWLRPHWU\
';$ Q DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 4&7 GHQVLWRPHWU\ Q
5HVXOWV0HDQ3)ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQIUDFWXUHVWKDQLQQRUPDODSSHDULQJ
YHUWHEUDH YVP/P/PLQS 6LPLODUO\PHDQ39DQG()
GLIIHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ YVP/P/DQGYVP/P/
PLQ 0HDQ 3) ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GHFUHDVHG LQ QRUPDO DSSHDULQJ Y%0 RI RVWH
RSRURWLFSDWLHQWVFRPSDUHGWRWKHFRQWUROJURXS YVP/P/PLQ
S 0HDQ YDOXHV RI 3) DQG 39 ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GHFUHDVHG LQ OXPEDU
FRPSDUHG WR WKRUDFLF YHUWHEUDH S 39 VKRZHG D VLJQLÀFDQW FRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWK4&7 S
&RQFOXVLRQ'&(05,LVXVHIXOWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHQRUPDODSSHDULQJY%0LQRVWH
RSRURWLF SDWLHQWV IURP KHDOWK\ VXEMHFWV DV ZHOO DV DFXWH FRPSUHVVLRQ IUDFWXUH
)XUWKHUPRUHLWPD\VHUYHDVDWRROWRJUDGHRVWHRSRURVLV
%
5ROHRIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGZKROHERG\05,ZLWKEDFNJURXQGERG\
VLJQDOVXSSUHVVLRQ ':,%6 IRUGLVHDVHGHWHFWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
PXOWLSOHP\HORPDSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
3$%RQDIÀQL',SSROLWR,0DFFKL)5RVVLQL$'L/HOLR66LURQL0RQ]D,7
SDERQDIÀQL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH RYHUDOO GLDJQRVWLF FDSDELOLW\ RI ZKROH ERG\ 05, ZLWK
':,%6WHFKQLTXHFRPELQHGZLWKVWDQGDUG7DQG67,57VHTXHQFHVIRUGHWHF
WLRQRIERQHPDUURZOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHP\HORPD 00
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK00XQGHUZHQW7 $FKLHYD3KLOLSV
:%05, VWXG\ IURP VNXOO YHUWH[ WR IHHW XVLQJ D EXLOWLQERG\ FRLO DQG VWHSSLQJ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH%DULDWULFVXUJHU\LVWKHPRVWHIIHFWLYHZD\RIFRQWUROOLQJVHYHUHREHVLW\
DQGLWVPHGLFDOFRPRUELGLWLHV2XUDLPZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHLPSDFWRIEDULDWULF
WUHDWPHQWRQERG\FRPSRVLWLRQ %& DQGERQHPHWDEROLVPRYHUDSHULRGRI
PRQWKVIROORZLQJWKHVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQDQGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHUROHRIGXDOHQHUJ\
[UD\DEVRUSWLRPHWU\ ';$ LQWKHPDQDJHPHQWRIREHVLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGIHPDOHSDWLHQWV
\HDUROG.JP GLUHFWHGWREDULDWULFVXUJHU\ 5RX[HQ<JDVWULFE\SDVV
RQYHUWLFDOEDQGHGJDVWURSODVW\ $OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWZKROHERG\DQGOXPEDU
VSLQH';$VFDQVEHIRUHWUHDWPHQWDQGDIWHUDQGPRQWKV%&SDUDPHWHUV
ZHUHDVVHVVHG IDWPDVV)0QRQERQHOHDQPDVV/0ERQHPLQHUDOFRQWHQWDQG
GHQVLW\%0' RQZKROHERG\DQGUHJLRQDOEDVLV7KXVGLIIHUHQWLDOUDWHVRIPDVV
DQG%0'FKDQJHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGWRGHÀQHWKHWUHQGLQWKHRYHUDOOZHLJKWORVV
5HVXOWV %RG\ PDVV LQGH[ GHFUHDVHG LQ WKH ÀUVW PRQWKV DQG JUHZ VWHDG\
EHWZHHQDQGPRQWKV S $GHFUHDVHRI)0/0UDWLRZDVREVHUYHG
LQERWKWRWDODQGDQGURLGUHJLRQDWPRQWKV )0 /0 ZKLOHVOLJKWO\LQFUHDVHG
EHWZHHQDQGPRQWKV )0 /0 6LPLODUWUHQGZDVREVHUYHGIRUFHQWUDODQG
SHULSKHUDOIDWGLVWULEXWLRQUDWLR у DQGу UHVSHFWLYHO\
S $UHGXFWLRQRIWRWDODQGOXPEDU%0'ZDVREVHUYHGDWPRQWKVHYHQ
VWURQJHU DW PRQWKV FRPSDUHG WR SUHWUHDWPHQW YDOXHV у DQG
у UHVSHFWLYHO\S
&RQFOXVLRQ %& DQG ERQH PHWDEROLVP DUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ PRGLÀHG DIWHU EDULDWULF
VXUJHU\';$LVIXQGDPHQWDOLQWKHLQYHVWLJDWLRQRISDWLHQWVVXEPLWWHGWRVXUJLFDO
WUHDWPHQWIRUPRUELGREHVLW\DQGLQWKHLUFOLQLFDOPDQDJHPHQW
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
WDEOHWHFKQLTXH7KHSURWRFROFRQVLVWHGRIFRURQDODQGVDJLWWDOVKRUWWDXLQYHUVLRQ
UHFRYHU\ 67,5 7776(DQGD[LDO':,%6VHTXHQFHVLQRUGHUWRFKDUDFWHULVH
ERQHLQYROYHPHQWLQWHUPVRISDWWHUQVL]HDQGGLVWULEXWLRQ':,%6LPDJHVZHUH
FRPSDUHGZLWK7DQG67,5LPDJHVLQÀYHGLVWULFWV VNXOOVSLQHVWHUQXPDQGULEV
SHOYLVXSSHUDQGORZHUOLPEV LQSDWLHQWVZLWKIRFDO GLIIXVH RUFRPELQHG
GLVHDVH$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHFOLQLFDOO\VWDJHGDFFRUGLQJWR'XULHDQG6DORPRQ6\VWHP
5HVXOWV,QIRFDODQGFRPELQHGGLVHDVHIRFDOERQHOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHG
ZHUH FRUUHFWO\ LGHQWLÀHG ZLWK 77 VHTXHQFHV DQG ZLWK
':,%6DORQH,QSDWLHQWVZLWKGLIIXVHGLVHDVH':,%6DOZD\VVKRZHGKRPRJHQH
RXVLQFUHDVHGVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ZLWKLQWKHERQHVLQYROYHGZLWKJUHDWHUVHQVLWLYLW\LQ
GHPRQVWUDWLQJZLGHVSUHDGLQYROYHPHQWRIERQHPDUURZWKDQ77VHTXHQFHV
GXHWRWKHLULQKRPRJHQHRXVDOWHUDWLRQRILQWHQVLW\VLJQDOSDWLHQWVZHUHFRUUHFWO\
VWDJHGDVGLIIXVHGLVHDVHZLWK':,%6ZKLOH7DQG7VHTXHQFHVVKRZHGIRFDO
RUFRPELQHGGLVHDVH
&RQFOXVLRQ :%05, ZLWK ':,%6 VHTXHQFHV LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK 00 DSSHDUV WR
EHWHFKQLFDOO\IHDVLEOHDQGDSURPLVLQJQRQLQYDVLYHWRROIRUHDUO\GHWHFWLRQDQG
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIERQHPDUURZOHVLRQVSDUWLFXODUO\LQZLGHVSUHDGIRUP
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWV2&'OHVLRQVZHUHFOHDUO\YLVLEOHRQWKH$8&PDSVDQG
VKRZHG VWURQJO\ HOHYDWHG SHUIXVLRQ DQG SHUPHDELOLW\ 0HDQ YDOXHV 6' ZHUH
3) PO POPLQ 39 36 PO POPLQ DQG
9(( 7KHIROORZXSVFDQVLQGLFDWHGDGHFUHDVHRIWKHPHGLDQ39
IURPWR
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUVWXG\VKRZVWKHIHDVLELOLW\RI'&(05,WR, GHWHFW2&'OHVLRQV
,, TXDQWLI\SHUIXVLRQDQGSHUPHDELOLW\XVLQJDFRPSDUWPHQWPRGHODQG,,, UHYHDO
FKDQJHVRI39LQGLIIHUHQWGLVHDVHVWDJHV7KLVTXDQWLWDWLYHDSSURDFKSURYLGHV
DGGLWLRQDO LQIRUPDWLRQ RQ WKH SDWKRSK\VLRORJ\ RI WKH FRQGLWLRQ PLJKW LQÁXHQFH
GLVHDVHPDQDJHPHQWDQGFRXOGRIIHUDQRQLQYDVLYHPHDQVRIWKHUDS\PRQLWRULQJ
%
0RGHUDWRUV
$*XSWD/RQGRQ8.
65RPDQR1DSOHV,7
'LDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIZKROHERG\ORZGRVHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
:%/'&7 LQWKHVWDJLQJRISDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHP\HORPD
9%HVRVWUL',SSROLWR0&ULYHOODUR(03RJOLDQL$'L/HOLR66LURQL
0LODQ,70RQ]D,7 YDOHULDEHVRVWUL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH UROH RI ZKROH ERG\ ORZGRVH FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\
:%/'&7 LQ WKH GLDJQRVLV DQG VWDJLQJ RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK VXVSLFLRQ RI PXOWLSOH
P\HORPD 00
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZLWKHDUO\PXOWLSOHP\HORPDXQ
GHUZHQWXQHQKDQFHGZKROHERG\ORZGRVH&7SURWRFROVWXG\SHUIRUPHGRQVOLFH
VFDQQHU 3KLOLSV%ULOOLDQFH3 WXEHYROWDJH.9WXEHFXUUHQWWLPHSURGXFW
P$VFROOLPDWLRQ[$OOWKHSDWLHQWVZHUHFOLQLFDOO\VWDJHGDFFRUGLQJWR
'XULHDQG6DOPRQ6\VWHP'LDJQRVLVRIRVWHRO\WLFOHVLRQVZDVSHUIRUPHGRQWKH
EDVLV RI D[LDO DQG PXOWLSODQDU UHIRUPDWWHG LPDJHV ZKHUHDV WKH DVVHVVPHQW RI
VSLQDOPLVDOLJQPHQWDQGIUDFWXUHZDVGRQHXVLQJPXOWLSODQDUUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJHV
5HVXOWV ,Q DOO SDWLHQWV LPDJH UHVROXWLRQ ZDV GLDJQRVWLF HQDEOLQJ FRUUHFW
FODVVLÀFDWLRQRIPXOWLSOHP\HORPDSDWLHQWV:%/'&7VKRZHGDWRWDORISDWKR
ORJLFERQHÀQGLQJVLQSDWLHQWV&7VFDQQLQJUHVXOWHGLQFRPSOHWHHYDOXDWLRQRI
WKHERQHOHVLRQVLQWKHVHDUHDVRIWKHVNHOHWRQVNXOO KXPHUXV IHPXU
ULEV VFDSXODH SHOYLV FODYLFOH VWHUQXP FHUYLFDO
GRUVDO OXPEDU DQGVDFUDOUDFKLV ,QSDWLHQWVWKH&7GHWHFWLRQ
RIERQHLQYROYHPHQWZDVWKHRQO\FULWHULRQIRUWKHWUHDWPHQW)XUWKHUPRUHLQ
SDWLHQWV:%/'&7VFDQQLQJGHPRQVWUDWHGSXOPRQDU\RUSOHXUDOOHVLRQV FDVHV
GXHWRLQIHFWLYHVRXUFHDQGFDVHVGXHWRPXOWLSOHP\HORPDORFDOLVDWLRQV DQG
FDVHRIUHQDOQHRSODVLDDVDUHODWHGSDWKRORJ\7KHRYHUDOOGRVHGHOLYHUHGWRHDFK
SDWLHQWZDVP6Y
&RQFOXVLRQ :KROH ERG\ ORZGRVH &7 LQYHVWLJDWLRQDO SURWRFRO LV D UHOLDEOH
LPDJLQJEDVHGPHWKRGIRUWKHGLUHFWPDQDJHPHQWRISDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHP\
HORPD:%/'&7KDVDVXSHULRUUHSURGXFLELOLW\DQGLWLVIDVWHUWKDQFRQYHQWLRQDO
UDGLRJUDSK\EHLQJIXUWKHUPRUHDEOHWRGHPRQVWUDWHH[WUDRVVHRXVÀQGLQJV
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRISHUIXVLRQDQGSHUPHDELOLW\LQ
RVWHRFKURQGULWLVGLVVHFDQVOHVLRQVIHDVLELOLW\DQGLQLWLDOUHVXOWV
$3$UQROGL0,QJULVFK68W]VFKQHLGHU0)5HLVHU6:HFNEDFK
0XQLFK'( DQGUHDVDUQROGL#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH:KLOHWKHH[DFWSDWKRSK\VLRORJ\RIRVWHRFKRQGULWLVGLVVHFDQV 2&'
KDVQRW\HWEHHQFOHDUO\XQGHUVWRRGGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHEHVWPDQDJHPHQWRIWKH
FRQGLWLRQVWLOOUHPDLQVFRQWLQXRXVO\GLVFXVVHG>2/RXJKOLQ@>.RFKHU@
3XUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RI, GHWHFWLRQ,, TXDQWLWDWLYH
DVVHVVPHQW,,, PRQLWRULQJRISHUIXVLRQDQGSHUPHDELOLW\LQ2&'OHVLRQVE\'
'&(05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV PHDQDJH\ SDWLHQWVZLWK2&'RIWKHPHGLDOIHPX
UDOFRQG\OHWKHPHGLDOWDODUGRPH Q XQGHUZHQW'&(05,DW7 0DJQHWRP
9HULR6LHPHQV0HGLFDO6ROXWLRQV*HUPDQ\ XVLQJDYLHZVKDULQJ'*(VHTXHQFH
7(75 PVÁLSDQJOH VSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ [[PPóPDWUL[
VL]H WHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQ V DIWHUEROXVLQMHFWLRQRIPPRONJ
*G'73$SDWLHQWVREWDLQHGIROORZXSVFDQDIWHUDQDYHUDJHRIPRQWKV7KH
$,)ZDVPHDVXUHGLQWKHSRSOLWHDODUWHU\ NQHH LQWKHDQWHULRUWLELDODUWHU\ DQNOH
52,VLQ2&'OHVLRQVZHUHGUDZQRQ$8&PDSVKDHPRG\QDPLFSDUDPHWHUVLQ
WKHVHUHJLRQVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGXVLQJDFRPSDUWPHQWH[FKDQJHPRGHO\LHOGLQJ
HVWLPDWHVRISODVPDÁRZ 3) SODVPDYROXPH 39 SHUPHDELOLW\VXUIDFHSURGXFW
36 DQGLQWHUVWLWLDOYROXPH 9(( >6RXUEURQ@
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP(
*,7UDFW
66D
&URKQҋVGLVHDVHDQGLQWHVWLQDOLQÁDPPDWLRQ
%
05SHUIXVLRQRIQRUPDOVPDOOERZHO
-+<DFRXE&=LQL;)DQ$<RXVXI'75XELQ$2WR&KLFDJR,/86
]LQLFKLDUD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RITXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRIVPDOOERZHOSHU
IXVLRQXVLQJG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, '&(05, DQGFRPSDUHSHUIXVLRQ
SDWWHUQVRIMHMXQXPDQGLOHXP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[QRUPDOVXEMHFWVZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGWRXQ
GHUJR05HQWHURJUDSK\5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVWZHUHGUDZQRYHUWKHMHMXQXPLOHXP
DQG WHUPLQDO LOHXP 7, WR FDOFXODWH WKH YROXPH WUDQVIHU FRQVWDQW .WUDQV DQG
H[WUDYDVFXODUH[WUDFHOOXODUVSDFH 9H 7KHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHVPDOOERZHO
UHJLRQVZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJSDLUHGWWHVW
5HVXOWV7KHMHMXQXPGHPRQVWUDWHVHDUOLHUDQGPRUHLQWHQVHHQKDQFHPHQWFRP
SDUHGWRWKHLOHXPDQG7,7KHPHDQ.WUDQV PLQ DWWKHMHMXQXPLOHXPDQG7,
UHVSHFWLYHO\ZHUHDQG7KHPHDQ9H DWWKH
MHMXQXPLOHXPDQG7,UHVSHFWLYHO\ZHUHDQG7KH
.WUDQVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHMHMXQXPFRPSDUHGWRWKHLOHXP 3
DQG7, 3 7KH9HZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHMHMXQXPFRPSDUHGWRWKH
LOHXP 3 DQG7, 3 7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ
WKHLOHXPDQG7,LQ.WUDQVDQG9H 3 DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ '&(05, LV D IHDVLEOH PHWKRG IRU TXDQWLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV RI VPDOO
ERZHOSHUIXVLRQ7KHMHMXQXPGHPRQVWUDWHVHDUOLHUDQGPRUHLQWHQVHHQKDQFHPHQW
FRPSDUHGWRWKHLOHXP%HWWHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIVPDOOERZHOSHUIXVLRQLVLPSRUWDQW
IRUDFFXUDWHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIGLVHDVHGVHJPHQWV
%
'DUNOXPHQERZHO05LQSDWLHQWVZLWK&URKQҋVGLVHDVHWZRVWHS
ZKROHLQWHVWLQDOSUHSDUDWLRQZLWKSROLHWLOHQJOLFRO
,6DQVRQL&/3LFFROR)3LWRFFR5'HO9HVFRYR0&LFDOD
%%HRPRQWH=REHO5RPH,7
3XUSRVH7KH GDUN OXPHQ WHFKQLTXH 05( DQG 05& LV DQ H[FHOOHQW PRGDOLW\
IRUVPDOOERZHODVVHVVPHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWK,%'EXWLWFDQFDXVHGLVFRPIRUWIRU
SDWLHQWV:HSURSRVHDQDOWHUQDWLYHPHWKRGWRGLVWHQGDQGHYDOXDWHERWKVPDOO
DQG ODUJH ERZHO E\ DSSO\LQJ WKH GDUN OXPHQ WHFKQLTXH WLPH SROLHWLOHQJOLFROH
3(* DGPLQLVWUDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQ&'ZHUHDVNHGWRGULQNWZLFH
/RI3(*VROXWLRQKRXUVDQGGXULQJPLQXWHVEHIRUH05H[DPLQDWLRQ
$ELSKDVLFOXPHQ05 7VFDQQHU H[DPLQDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGRQD[LDODQG
FRURQDOSODQHVZHREWDLQHG7ZDQG7UXH),63VHTXHQFHVDQG7ZIDWVDWVH
TXHQFHVEHIRUHDQGDIWHULYG\QDPLFDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIJDGROLQLXP6FDQQHU7LPH
ZDVaPLQ UDQJHPLQ *UDGLQJRIERZHOGLVWHQVLRQFOHDQVLQJDQGSDULHWDO
LQÁDPPDWLRQ DFWLYHLQDFWLYHQRQH ZDVHYDOXDWHGXVLQJFRQYHQWLRQDOFRORQRVFRS\
&& DQGSRVWELRSV\KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOUHVXOWVDVJROGVWDQGDUGLQDOOSDWLHQWV
5HVXOWV:LWKUHVSHFWWR&& DFKLHYHGLQSWV LQVLFNVHJPHQWV05
VKRZHGDFRPSOHWHFRUUHODWLRQRIWKHSUHVHQFHDQGORFDOLVDWLRQRIÁRJRVLVDQG
JRRGFRUUHODWLRQRIÁRJRVLVJUDGLQJ 339193 2QO\RIFRORQLF
VHJPHQWVZHUHKLQGHUHGE\IDHFHVPDNLQJDQDGHTXDWHLQWUDOXPLQDOGLDJQRVLV
LPSUDFWLFDEOH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHFRPELQDWLRQRI05(DQG05&DOORZVDFRPSOHWHDVVHVVPHQW
RILQÁDPPDWLRQLQVPDOODQGODUJHERZHOLQSDWLHQWVZLWK&'UHTXLULQJPLQLPDO
HIIRUWWRSDWLHQW6RZKROHERZHODVVHVVPHQWZLWK´VWHSVµGLVWHQVLRQLVIHDVLEOH
VDWLVI\LQJGRHVQRWUHTXLUHDQ\SDUWLFXODUSUHSDUDWLRQRUUHWURJUDGHPDQXDOFRORQ
GLVWHQVLRQDQGLWODFNVRILRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQ
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJRIDFXWHDSSHQGLFLWLVLQSDHGLDWULF
SDWLHQWVFRPSDULVRQZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO05,DQGVXUJLFDOÀQGLQJV
8%D\UDNWXWDQ0.DQWDUFL(U]XUXP75 DNNDQUDG#KRWPDLOFRP
%
05,GHULYHGVPDOOERZHOPRWLOLW\DVDPDUNHURIGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\LQ
&URKQҋVGLVHDVHXVLQJDKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
$0HQ\V'$WNLQVRQ63XQZDQL,3URFWRU01RYHOOL05RGULJXH]-XVWR
'+DZNHV6+DOOLJDQ67D\ORU/RQGRQ8. DOH[PHQ\V#XFODFXN
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQVRIWZDUHGHULYHGVPDOOERZHO
PRWLOLW\LQGH[DQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOJUDGLQJRI&URKQҋVGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VRIWZDUHVROXWLRQGHVLJQHGWRTXDQWLI\ERZHOZDOOPRWLRQ
ZDVDSSOLHGWRFRURQDOEUHDWKKROGFLQH),63VHTXHQFH VHFRQGEUHDWKKROG75
PV7(PVVOLFHWKLFNQHVVPPVOLFHVHF WKURXJKWKHWHUPLQDOLOHXP
7, LQ&URKQҋVGLVHDVHSDWLHQWV IHPDOHVPHDQDJH XQGHUJRLQJVWDQGDUG
05HQWHURJUDSK\7KHSUHYLRXVO\YDOLGDWHGVRIWZDUHXVHVQRQULJLGUHJLVWUDWLRQWR
WUDFNLQWHQVLW\FKDQJHVRYHUWLPHXVLQJDPDQXDOO\SODFHGOLQHDUUHJLRQRILQWHU
HVWZLWKLQWKHERZHOSURYLGLQJDXWRPDWHGHVWLPDWLRQRIERZHOZDOOGLVSODFHPHQW
H[SUHVVHGDVWKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRIMDFRELDQGHWHUPLQDQW PRWLOLW\LQGH[ $OO
SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW VXEVHTXHQW FRORQRVFRS\ DQG7, ELRSV\ ZLWKLQ D PHDQ RI
GD\V+LVWRSDWKRORJLFDOJUDGLQJRI7,DFWLYLW\ZDVXQGHUWDNHQE\WZRH[SHULHQFHG
SDWKRORJLVWVZKRGHULYHGDHQGRVFRSLFDFXWHLQÁDPPDWRU\VFRUH H$,6 EDVHGRQ
WKHSUHVHQFHRIXOFHUDWLRQQHXWURSKLOVLQWKHODPLQDSURSULDFU\SWLWLVFU\SWDEVFHVV
IRUPDWLRQ LQÁDPPDWRU\ H[XGDWHV DQG JUDQXORPDV SUHVHQW DEVFHQW 7KH
05,PRWLOLW\LQGH[ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHH$,6XVLQJ.HQGDOOҋVUDQNFRUUHODWLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQPRWLOLW\LQGH[DQGSDWKRORJ\VFRUHZDV UDQJH
DQG UDQJH UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHZDVDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWQHJDWLYHFRU
UHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHPRWLOLW\LQGH[DQGDFWLYLW\VFRUH .HQGDOOWDXS
&RQFOXVLRQ4XDQWLÀHGVPDOOERZHOPRWLOLW\LVQHJDWLYHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKKLVWRSDWKR
ORJLFDO PDUNHUV RI GLVHDVH DFWLYLW\ VXJJHVWLQJ LW PD\ EH XVHG DV D TXDQWLWDWLYH
PDUNHURILQÁDPPDWLRQ
%
3URSRVDORIDTXDOLWDWLYH05,DFWLYLW\LQGH[IRU&URKQҋVGLVHDVH
)0DFFLRQL9%XRQRFRUH,6WDOWDUL$3LQR*%HOOD9'H0DUFR00DULQL
5RPH,7 IUDQFHVFDPDFFLRQL#XQLURPDLW
3XUSRVH7RSURSRVHD05,DFWLYLW\LQGH[IRU&URKQҋVGLVHDVH &'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK&'XQGHUZHQWLOHRFRORQRVFRS\ JROG
VWDQGDUG DQG05(QWHURJUDSK\(QGRVFRSLF &'(,6 ELRORJLFDO %$ DQGFOLQL
FDODFWLYLW\ &'$, ZHUHDVVHVVHGDQGVFRUHG DEVHQWORZGHÀQLWHO\SUHVHQW
PDUNHG DFWLYLW\ 7KUHH DFWLYLW\ 05, SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH TXDOLWDWLYHO\ VFRUHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
05DFWLYLW\DVVHVVPHQWLQ&URKQҋVGLVHDVHRIWKHWHUPLQDOLOHXP
IUHHEUHDWKLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, DQGG\QDPLF
PRWLOLW\HYDOXDWLRQDVDSRVVLEOHDOWHUQDWLYHWR05ZLWKLQWUDYHQRXV
FRQWUDVWDJHQW
,6DQVRQL&/3LFFROR)3LWRFFR5'HO9HVFRYR0&LFDOD
%%HRPRQWH=REHO5RPH,7
3XUSRVH &RQWUDVWHGHQKDQFHG G\QDPLF 05HQWHURJUDSK\ '&(05( LV DQ
DFFHSWHGPHWKRGWRDVVHVV&URKQҋVGLVHDVH &' DFWLYLW\LWQHHGVIRUJDGROLQLXP
FRQWUDVWPDWHULDOV5HFHQWO\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ ':, DQGLWVUHODWHG
$'&PDSKDYHEHHQXVHGLQPXOWLSOHFOLQLFDOFRQGLWLRQLQFOXGLQJERZHOVWXG\DQG
&URKQҋVGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\2XUDLPLVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHYDOXHRIIUHHEUHDWKLQJ':,
05LPDJLQJLQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIVPDOOERZHO&'DFWLYLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKWHUPLQDOLOHXP&'XQGHUZHQW05H[
DPLQDWLRQDIWHUERZHORUDOGLVWHQVLRQZLWKSRO\HWK\OHQJO\FROVROXWLRQ:HEDVHG
05DVVHVVPHQWRIGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\RQPRUSKRORJ\DQGPRWLOLW\RIVPDOOERZHODQG
SHULYLVFHUDOVWUXFWXUHV WUXH),63FLQHWUXH),63+$67(7:VHTXHQFHV SDULHWDO
VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQ':,DQGG\QDPLFDVVHVVPHQWRISDULHWDOFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQW
)/$6+7:VHTXHQFH 3DWLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWKUHHFDWHJRULHV QHJDWLYH
LQDFWLYHDFWLYHGLVHDVH EDVLQJRQHQGRVFRSLFELRSV\DVWKHVWDQGDUGUHIHUHQFH
FDVHV ZKROHRIFOLQLFDOÀQGLQJVDQG05VHTXHQFHV FDVHV
5HVXOWV2Q':,,QÁDPPDWRU\ERZHOWUDFWVVKRZHGKLJKHUVLJQDOFRPSDUHGWR
QRUPDOVHJPHQWV DFFXUDF\VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\339
139 $'&YDOXHLQDFWLYHGLVHDVHZDVORZHUWKDQLQLQDFWLYHGLVHDVH
QHJDWLYH[[PPVLQDFWLYH[[PPVDFWLYH
[[PPV ,QDOOSDWLHQWVDFRPSOHWH05H[DPLQDWLRQDOORZHG
WRSHUIRUPDGHWDLOHGDQGSDQRUDPLFHYDOXDWLRQRIVPDOOERZHO
&RQFOXVLRQ&LQH05PRGHDGGVVXLWDEOHIXQFWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWPRWLOLW\
RIDIIHFWHGORRSVDQGFRQGLWLRQRISUR[LPDOORRSV)UHHEUHDWKLQJ':,LVXVHIXOLQ
YLVXDODVVHVVPHQWRI&'DFWLYLW\$'&YDOXHVPD\IDFLOLWDWHTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLV
RIGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\GHFUHDVLQJLQLQÁDPHGERZHOVHJPHQWVEHFDXVHRIUHVWULFWHG
GLIIXVLRQ
%
1RQLQYDVLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIERZHOZDOOÀEURVLVLQ&URKQҋVGLVHDVH
UROHRIWKHTXDOLWDWLYHHODVWRJUDSKLFLPDJLQJ ,( DQGFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKEDVHOLQH 86 FRORXU'RSSOHU &'86 DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
XOWUDVRXQG &(86 SDWWHUQV
90LJDOHGGX*9LUJLOLR$6FDQX0'RUH$3RUFX00DU]R'6LULJX
'6FDQX6DVVDUL,7 PLJDOHGGX#VPLUJRUJ
3XUSRVH7RFRUUHODWHWKHXOWUDVRQRJUDSKLFVFRUHVIRUPRUSKRORJLF 86 YDVFXODU
&'86 DQGSHUIXVLRQ &(86 SDWWHUQVZLWKDQHZTXDOLWDWLYHHODVWRJUDSKLFHYDOX
DWLRQ (, IRUGHÀQLQJÀEURVWHQRWLFYHUVXVLQÁDPPDWRU\ERZHOZDOOLQYROYHPHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&'SDWLHQWV IHPDOHVPDOHV ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQ
WKHVWXG\SDWLHQWVKDGLQÁDPPDWRU\VWULFWXULQJDQGSHQHWUDWLQJGLVHDVH
LOHDOFRORQLFDQGLOHRFRORQLF :HSHUIRUPHGWUDQVDEGRPLQDOXOWUD
VRXQGH[DPLQDWLRQVLQFOXGLQJEDVHOLQH86&'86&(86DIWHUHQGRYDVFXODU
FRQWUDVWDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ 6RQR9XH ZLWK6LHPHQV$FXVRQ6HTXRLD +0]
OLQHDUSUREH DQG6LHPHQV$FXVRQ6 0+]OLQHDUSUREH 7KHODVWRQH
ZDVXVHGIRUTXDOLWDWLYHHODVWRJUDSKLFHYDOXDWLRQWKURXJKDUHFHQW(,VRIWZDUH
WKHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGVRQRJUDSKLFSHUIXVLRQZDVREWDLQHGXV
LQJ4RQWUDVWVRIWZDUH %UDFFR 7KHIROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUV3($.WLPHWRSHDN
773 UHJLRQDOEORRGYROXPH 5%9 ZHUHFRQVLGHUHG86&'86DQG&(86
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH7KH DLP RI WKLV VWXG\ LV WR GHWHUPLQH WKH YDOXH RI GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDFXWHDSSHQGLFLWLVLQSDHGLDWULF
SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\ÀYHFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKDFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVLV
RIDFXWHDSSHQGLFLWLVXQGHUZHQWDEGRPLQDO05,ZHUHRSHUDWHGRQIRUDFXWH
DSSHQGLFLWLV )LUVW WKH ':, DORQH ZDV UHYLHZHG IROORZHG E\ FRQYHQWLRQDO 05,
DORQHDQGWKHQFRQYHQWLRQDO05,DQG':,ZHUHUHYLHZHGE\WZRREVHUYHUV7KH
VXUJLFDOÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKH05,UHVXOWV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQG
DFFXUDF\ ZHUH FDOFXODWHG IRU ':, FRQYHQWLRQDO 05, DQG FRPELQHG ':, DQG
FRQYHQWLRQDO05,IRUWKHGHSLFWLRQRIDFXWHDSSHQGLFLWLV
5HVXOWV$FRPELQDWLRQRI':,DQGFRQYHQWLRQDO05,ZDVWKHPRVWVHQVLWLYHDQG
WKHPRVWDFFXUDWHZLWKFRUUHVSRQGLQJVHQVLWLYLW\DQGDFFXUDF\IRUREVHUYHUVDQG
VHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\DFFXUDF\RIUHVSHFWLYHO\
8VLQJ':,DORQHWKHVHQVLWLYLW\ZDVIRXQGWREHDQGDQGDFFXUDF\RI
DQGIRUREVHUYHUVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\8VLQJFRQYHQWLRQDO05,DORQH
VHQVLWLYLW\RIIRUERWKDQGDFFXUDF\RIDQGZDVIRXQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
IRU WKH WZR REVHUYHUV7KH DFFXUDF\ RI WKH GHSLFWLRQ RI DFXWH DSSHQGLFLWLV ZDV
VXSHULRUXVLQJWKHFRPELQDWLRQRI':,DQGFRQYHQWLRQDO05,IRUERWKREVHUYHUV
DFFXUDF\RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRIFRPELQDWLRQRI':,DQGFRQYHQWLRQDO05,LVDYDOXDEOH
WHFKQLTXHLQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDFXWHDSSHQGLFLWLVHVSHFLDOO\LQFKLOGUHQDIWHUVXE
RSWLPDORUQRQGLDJQRVWLFVRQRJUDSK\
ZDOORHGHPD D PHVHQWHULFRHGHPD E RQ7ZLPDJHV*GHQKDQFHPHQWRQ
7ZHLJWKHGLPDJHV F 7ZRTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVZHUHDVVHVVHGSUHVHQFH
DQGQXPEHU RIO\PSKQRGHV G ZDOOWKLFNHQLQJ PPPP
!PP H 7KHVHSDUDPHWHUVSURGXFHGDEDVLFDFWLYLW\VFRUHUDQJLQJEHWZHHQ
DQGVXJJHVWLQJLQDFWLYLW\ORZDFWLYLW\DFWLYLW\KLJKDFWLYLW\
7KLVVFRUHZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWK&'(,6%$DQG&'$,,WZDVIXUWKHUPXOWLSOLHGIRU
DIDFWRURUDFFRUGLQJWRWKHOHQJWKRIWKHDIIHFWHGVHJPHQW OHQJWK!FP
RU!FP REWDLQLQJDOHQJWKDFWLYLW\VFRUH % WKHQIRUDIDFWRUWRLQWKH
SUHVHQFHRIÀVWXODVDEVFHVVHVRUSHULDQDOGLVHDVHLQUHODWLRQWRWKHLUH[WHQWDQG
VHYHULW\SURYLGLQJDFRPSOLFDWLRQDFWLYLW\VFRUH & $ÀQDOLQWHJUDWHG05,VFRUH
' UDQJHG
5HVXOWV6LJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQEDVLFVFRUHDQG&'$, U &'(,6
U DQG%$ U SZDVREWDLQHG+LJKFRUUHODWLRQ U ZDV
REWDLQHG EHWZHHQ FRPSOLFDWLRQDFWLYLW\ VFRUH DQG % JRRG FRUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ
OHQJWKDFWLYLW\VFRUHDQG&'(,6 U
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHEDVLF05,DFWLYLW\LQGH[FRUUHODWHGZLWKFOLQLFDODQGHQGRVFRSLF
DFWLYLW\,QWHJUDWHGVFRUHV %&' FRUUHODWHGZLWK%$RUHQGRVFRS\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
VFRUHVWRDVVHVVOD\HU YDVFXODULVDWLRQ LQWUDSDULHWDORUWUDQVSDULHWDO
HQKDQFHPHQW FKDUDFWHULVWLFVUHVSHFWLYHO\ZHUHXVHG:HGHÀQHGDQHZ
VFRUHRIÀEURVLVFRPSDULQJDEGRPLQDODQGERZHOZDOOVWLIIQHVV &RUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQ(,VFRUHDQG86&'86&(86VFRUHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWKWKHQRQ
SDUDPHWULF6SHDUPDQUDQNWHVW
5HVXOWV(ODVWRJUDSKLFVFRUHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK86VFRUH S
DQGTXDOLWDWLYH&(86VFRUH S 6LJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQQHLWKHUZLWK&'
86QRUZLWK3($.773DQG5%9ZHUHREWDLQHGZLWK4RQWUDVW
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHLQWURGXFWLRQRIGHGLFDWHG86VRIWZDUHIRUHODVWRJUDSKLFDVVHVV
PHQWRIÀEURVLVFDQLPSURYHWKH86GLDJQRVLVLQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIÀEURWLFYHUVXV
LQÁDPPDWRU\LQYROYHPHQWLQ&'
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJLVFRUUHODWHGZLWKIDHFDOFDOSURWHFWLQ
OHYHOLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIVPDOOERZHODQGFRORQLF&URKQҋVGLVHDVH
-0DNDQ\DQJD'3HQGVH($WNLQV06WHZDUG6%ORRP60F&DUWQH\
63XQZDQL6+DOOLJDQ67D\ORU/RQGRQ8. FPDNDQ\DQJD#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7KHUDSHXWLFVWUDWHJ\LQ&URKQҋVGLVHDVHUHTXLUHVNQRZOHGJHRIWKHRYHUDOO
GLVHDVHEXUGHQ$QHZ05,VFRUHRIDFWLYLW\ZDVWHVWHGDJDLQVWYDOLGDWHGFOLQLFDO
UHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGVUHÁHFWLQJJOREDODFWLYLW\+DUYH\%UDGVKDZLQGH[ +%, DQG
IDHFDOFDOSURWHFWLQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PDOHV PHGLDQDJH UDQJH ZLWK
NQRZQRUVXVSHFWHG&URKQҋVGLVHDVHXQGHUZHQWVWDQGDUG705HQWHURJUDSK\
D[LDODQGFRURQDO+$67(7UXH)LVSDQGSRVWJDGROLQLXPFRURQDO9,%( FRPSOHWHG
D+%,TXHVWLRQQDLUHDQGSURYLGHGDVWRROVDPSOHIRUIDHFDOFDOSURWHFWLQ7ZRREVHUY
HUVTXDOLWDWLYHO\JUDGHGERZHOZDOOWKLFNQHVVPXUDO7VLJQDOPHVHQWHULFRHGHPD
7HQKDQFHPHQWKDXVWUDOORVV FRORQ IURP QRUPDO WR PRVWDEQRUPDO IRU
MHMXQXPSUR[LPDOLOHXPWHUPLQDOLOHXPDQGFRORQ GLYLGHGLQWRVHJPHQWV 7KH
OHQJWKRIGLVHDVHLQHDFKVHJPHQWZDVPHDVXUHGDQGWKHLQGLYLGXDOVHJPHQWDO
VFRUHPXOWLSOLHGDVIROORZVFP[FP[DQGFP[$VFRUHRI
ZDVDGGHGIRUHDFKRIWKHIROORZLQJLISUHVHQWO\PSKDGHQRSDWK\FRPEVLJQ
DEVFHVVHVDQGÀVWXODH.HQGDOO VUDQNFRUUHODWLRQZDVXVHGWRHYDOXDWHWKHUHOD
WLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ05,VFRUHIDHFDOFDOSURWHFWLQDQG+%,
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ05,DFWLYLW\VFRUHZDV UDQJH $SRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQ
ZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQWKH05,VFRUHDQGFDOSURWHFWLQ.HQGDOOҋVWDXE
&,WR S 1RFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ05,DQG+%,.HQGDOOҋV
WDXE S
&RQFOXVLRQ*OREDO&URKQҋVGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\PHDVXUHGXVLQJDVLPSOHFOLQLFDO05,
VFRUHLVFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHIDHFDOFDOSURWHFWLQOHYHO05,LVXVHIXOIRUWKHJOREDO
DVVHVVPHQWRIGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\LQ&URKQҋVGLVHDVH
%
7KHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIVPDOOERZHOZDOOYDVFXODULW\DIWHUVXOSKXU
KH[DÁXRULGHÀOOHGPLFUREXEEOHLQMHFWLRQLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRI
LQÁDPPDWRU\DQGÀEURWLFVWHQRVHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK&URKQҋVGLVHDVH
(4XDLD/'H3DROL%&DELEER)'HJUDVVL0&RYD7ULHVWH,7
TXDLD#XQLWVLW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIVPDOOERZHOZDOOYDVFXODULW\DIWHUPLFUREXEEOH
FRQWUDVW DJHQW LQMHFWLRQ WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH LQÁDPPDWRU\ IURP ÀEURWLF VWHQRVHV LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWK&URKQҋVGLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIWHHQSDWLHQWV PDOHVDQGIHPDOHVPHDQDJH6'
\HDUV ZLWKDELRSV\SURYHQGLDJQRVLVRI&URKQ VGLVHDVH&URKQ VGLVHDVH
DFWLYLW\LQGH[ &'$, ! Q SDWLHQWV RU Q LQYROYLQJDWOHDVWRQH
LOHDOORRS ZDOOWKLFNQHVVPHDVXUHGE\XQHQKDQFHG86!PP ZHUHLQFOXGHG
,QHDFKSDWLHQWWKHWHUPLQDOORRSZDVVFDQQHGE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG
&(86 DIWHUVXOSKXUKH[DÁXRULGHÀOOHGPLFUREXEEOHLQMHFWLRQDQGGLJLWDOFLQHFOLSV
VHFRQGV ZHUHVWRUHGLQ',&20IRUPDW7KHYDVFXODULW\RIWKHWHUPLQDOORRS
ZDVTXDQWLÀHGLQJUH\VFDOHOHYHOV E\DPDQXDOO\GUDZQ52,HQFRPSDVV
LQJWKHWKLFNHQHGERZHOZDOODQGLWZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWK&'$,7KHSHUFHQWDJHRI
HQKDQFHPHQWFRPSDUHGWREDVHOLQHWKHWLPHWRSHDNHQKDQFHPHQWDQGWKHDUHD
XQGHUFXUYHZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV$OO SDWLHQWV UHYHDOHG GLIIXVH WUDQVSDULHWDO FRQWUDVW HQKDQFHPHQW DIWHU
PLFUREXEEOH LQMHFWLRQ H[FHSW IRU SDWLHQWV ZLWK ÀEURWLF VWHQRVLV ZKR UHYHDOHG
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWOLPLWHGWRWKHVXEPXFRVD,QÁDPPDWRU\YVÀEURWLFVWHQRVHV
GLGQRWGLIIHULQWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIHQKDQFHPHQW YV
DQGLQWKHWLPHWRSHDNHQKDQFHPHQW YVVHFV3! ZKLOH
GLIIHUHQFHLQWKHDUHDXQGHUWKHHQKDQFHPHQWFXUYHZDVIRXQG YV
3 ZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKH&'$,VFRUH ѩ
3
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRIERZHOZDOOK\SHUYDVFXODULW\RQ&(86PD\
GLIIHUHQWLDWHLQÁDPPDWRU\IURPÀEURWLFVWHQRVHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK&URKQҋVGLVHDVH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
/RZGRVH&7LQLQLWLDOHYDOXDWLRQRI&URKQҋVGLVHDVHLQWKH
HPHUJHQF\VHWWLQJ"7RZDUGUHSODFLQJWKH3)$
6%2ҋ1HLOO)2ҋ1HLOO$0F*DUULJOH)6KDQDKDQ000DKHU&RUN,(
VLREKDQ[[#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH&URKQҋVGLVHDVH &' SDWLHQWVDUH´DWULVNµIRUH[SRVXUHWRVLJQLÀFDQW
FXPXODWLYHHIIHFWLYHGRVHVRIUDGLDWLRQIURPGLDJQRVWLFLPDJLQJVWXGLHV7KHSXUSRVH
RIWKLVVWXG\LVWRFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLF\LHOGRIORZGRVH&7 /'&7 ZLWKLWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQWRWKDWRIFRQYHQWLRQDOSODLQÀOPRIDEGRPHQ 3)$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)ROORZLQJHWKLFDODSSURYDOSDWLHQWVZLWK&'UHIHUUHG
IRUFOLQLFDOO\LQGLFDWHG&7DEGRPHQSHOYLV &7$3 ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\UHFUXLWHGWR
XQGHUJRDGGLWLRQDO/'&7DWWLPHRI&7$32IWKHVHSDWLHQWVKDGDFRQWHPSR
UDQHRXV3)$ ZLWKLQKUVRI&7 PDOHIHPDOHPHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH
PHDQ%0,NJPUDQJH 7KHHIIHFWLYHGRVH (' LQP6YIRU
HDFK/'&7ZDVFDOFXODWHGUDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXVUHYLHZHGWKH/'&7LPDJHV
DQGWKH3)$V PRQWKVODWHU ZLWKDYDOLGDWHG&URKQҋVVSHFLÀFFRGLQJV\VWHP
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQ (' IRU /'&7 ZDV P6Y UDQJH P6Y
S DPHDQGRVHUHGXFWLRQRIIURPFRQYHQWLRQDO&7ZLWKRXWORVV
RI GLDJQRVWLF XWLOLW\ 7KH PHDQ (' IRU %0, .JP ZDV P6Y DQG IRU
%0,!.JPZDVP6Y7KHDSSUR[LPDWHPHDQ('RID3)$LVP6Y
7KHUHZDVDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ3)$DQG/'&7LQSDWLHQWVRQO\ QRDEQRUPDO
ÀQGLQJV )LQGLQJVRQ/'&7PLVVHGRQ3)$LQFOXGHGDEVFHVVHV Q REVWUXFWLRQ
Q FROLWLV Q DQGHQWHULWLV Q /'&7GHWHFWHGPRUHFOLQLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
LQFLGHQWDOÀQGLQJV
&RQFOXVLRQ /'&7 ZLWK LWHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ \LHOGHG IDU VXSHULRU GLDJQRVWLF
LQIRUPDWLRQWKDQ3)$DWDQ('WKDWDSSUR[LPDWHVWR3)$V/'&7PD\UHSUH
VHQWDIHDVLEOHUHSODFHPHQWIRULQLWLDO3)$LPSDUWLQJYHU\OLWWOHDGGLWLRQDOUDGLDWLRQ
H[SRVXUH
5RRP)
*HQLWRXULQDU\
66
3URVWDWH05LPDJLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
--)WWHUHU1LMPHJHQ1/
-5LFKHQEHUJ%ULJKWRQ8.
%
)XQFWLRQDOSURVWDWH05,HYDOXDWLRQRIDVFRULQJV\VWHP
65RHKOHQ&$UVRY'%ORQGLQ-.ODVHQ5/DQ]PDQ*$QWRFK3$OEHUV
04XHQWLQ'VVHOGRUI'( PLFKDHOTXHQWLQ#PHGXQLGXHVVHOGRUIGH
3XUSRVH)XQFWLRQDOSURVWDWH05,LVSHUIRUPHGLQYDU\LQJFRPELQDWLRQVRI7
ZHLJKWHG LPDJHV ZLWK GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ ':, G\QDPLF FRQWUDVWHQ
KDQFHG05, '&(05, DQGVSHFWURVFRSLFLPDJLQJ 056, 5HFHQWO\D(XURSHDQ
FRQVHQVXVPHHWLQJSURSRVHGWKHXVHRIDVLPSOHSRLQWVFDOHIRUHVWLPDWLQJWKH
SUREDELOLW\RIDOHVLRQWREHPDOLJQDQW7KLVUHFRPPHQGDWLRQKDVQRWEHHQYDOLGDWHG
VRIDUZKLFKLVWKHDLPRIWKHSUHVHQWVWXG\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHDSSHDUDQFHRISUHGHÀQHGOHVLRQVLQWKUHHGLI
IHUHQW05VHTXHQFHV 7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHV':,DQG'&(05, LQIXQFWLRQDO
SURVWDWH 05, H[DPLQDWLRQV KDYH EHHQ UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ VFRUHG E\ WKUHH EOLQGHG
UDGLRORJLVWVXVLQJWKHSRLQWVFDOHIRUHDFK05VHTXHQFH$IWHUVFRULQJ7':,DQG
7':,'&(05,HYHU\OHVLRQZDVJUDGHGEDVHGRQLWVSUREDELOLW\IRUPDOLJQDQF\
,QWHUREVHUYHUUHOLDELOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHGXVLQJ.DSSDVWDWLVWLFV N
5HVXOWV :LWK UHVSHFW WR 7ZHLJKWHG LPDJHV ':, DQG '&(05, N ZHUH
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\&RPELQHGVFRULQJRI7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDQG':,
GHPRQVWUDWHGFRUUHFWWXPRXUGLDJQRVLV WUXHSRVLWLYH LQ GHSHQGLQJRQ
UHDGHU RIFDVHV N 7KHDFFXUDF\ZDVIXUWKHULPSURYHGWRDIWHU
VFRULQJDOOWKUHH05VHTXHQFHVLQFOXGLQJ'&(05, N
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRIDVLPSOHSRLQWVFRULQJV\VWHPIRU7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHV
':,DQG'&(05,LVIHDVLEOHLQIXQFWLRQDOSURVWDWH05,DQGFRPHVDORQJZLWKD
KLJKLQWHUREVHUYHUUHOLDELOLW\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
3URVWDWHFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJWKHUROHRISUHELRSV\05,RIWKHSURVWDWH
LQUXOLQJRXWSURVWDWHFDQFHU
7)UDQLHO+$9DUJDV<0D]DKHUL6%RHKPHU++ULFDN2$NLQ
'%H\HUVGRUII%HUOLQ'(1HZ<RUN1<86 WRELDVIUDQLHO#FKDULWHGH
%
3URVWDWHFDQFHUUROHRISUHWUHDWPHQWPXOWLSDUDPHWULF05,LQ
SUHGLFWLQJELRFKHPLFDOUHFXUUHQFHIROORZLQJUDGLFDOSURVWDWHFWRP\
-3DUN&.LP%3DUN+/HH6-HRQ66HR+&KRL6HRXO.5
MXQJMDHVPFSDUN#VDPVXQJFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\GHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUSUHWUHDWPHQWPXOWLSDUDPHWULF05,
ÀQGLQJVFDQSUHGLFWELRFKHPLFDOUHFXUUHQFH %&5 LQSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUJRUDGLFDO
SURVWDWHFWRP\ 53 IRUSURVWDWHFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHGLDQDJH\HDUVDJHUDQJH
\HDUV ZLWKELRSV\SURYHQSURVWDWHFDQFHUZKRUHFHLYHG53XQGHUZHQWSUHWUHDW
PHQWPXOWLSDUDPHWULF05,DW7LQFOXGLQJ7ZHLJKWHG 7:, GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
':, DQGG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGLPDJLQJ '&(, 05,YDULDEOHVGHULYHGIURP
UHWURVSHFWLYHFRQVHQVXVDVVHVVPHQWVE\WZRUHDGHUVLQFOXGHGDSSDUHQWWXPRXU
SUHVHQFHDW7:,':,7:,'&(,DQG7:,':,'&(,H[WUDFDSVXODU
H[WHQVLRQVHPLQDOYHVLFOHLQYDVLRQDQGWXPRXUVL]HDW':,RU'&(,&OLQLFDOYDUL
DEOHVLQFOXGHGSUHWUHDWPHQWSURVWDWHVSHFLÀFDQWLJHQ 36$ FOLQLFDO7VWDJHDQG
*OHDVRQVFRUH8QLYDULDWHDQGPXOWLYDULDWH&R[UHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VHVLQYHVWLJDWHG
WKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQFOLQLFDODQGLPDJLQJYDULDEOHVDQG%&5
5HVXOWV$IWHUDPHGLDQIROORZXSRIPRQWKV%&5GHYHORSHGLQSDWLHQWV
8QLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVUHYHDOHGWKDW05,DQGFOLQLFDOYDULDEOHVZHUHDOOVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\UHODWHGWR%&5 3 0XOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVUHYHDOHGWKDWSUHWUHDWPHQW
36$>KD]DUGUDWLR +5 3 @DQG*OHDVRQVFRUH +53
ZHUHWKHRQO\VLJQLÀFDQWLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUVIRU%&5$SSDUHQWWXPRXUSUHV
HQFHDW7:,':,'&(,ZDVDQLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRURIERUGHUOLQHVLJQLÀFDQFH
IRU%&5RQPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLV +53
&RQFOXVLRQ$SSDUHQWWXPRXUSUHVHQFHDWFRPELQHG7:,':,DQG'&(,DSSHDUV
WREHDQLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRURIERUGHUOLQHVLJQLÀFDQFHIRU%&5IROORZLQJ53
DQGSUHWUHDWPHQW36$DQG*OHDVRQVFRUHDUHVLJQLÀFDQWLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUV
IRUWKLVHQGSRLQW
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIDJJUHVVLYHQHVVDQGWXPRXUYROXPHRISURVWDWH
FDQFHUFRUUHODWLRQRI$'&ZLWKKLVWRORJLFJUDGHDQGSDWKRORJLFDO
WXPRXUYROXPH
*.KRXU\'(LVV)%HXYRQ1%'HORQJFKDPSV)&RUQXG3DULV)5
NKRXU\JDE#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRUUHODWHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHVWXPRXUYROXPH
79 ZLWK*OHDVRQVFRUH *6 DQGSDWKRORJLFDOYROXPHRISURVWDWHFDQFHU 3&D
RQZKROHPRXQWUDGLFDOSURVWDWHFWRP\ 53 VSHFLPHQV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
0XOWLSDUDPHWULF05LPDJLQJIRUGHWHFWLRQDQGORFDOLVDWLRQRI
WUDQVLWLRQ]RQHSURVWDWHFDQFHU
&0$+RHNV7+DPEURFN'<DNDU&+XOVEHUJHQYDQGH.DD$-:LWMHV
--)XWWHUHU-2%DUHQWV]1LMPHJHQ1/ &+RHNV#UDGXPFQQO
3XUSRVH 7R UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ GHWHUPLQH GHWHFWLRQ DQG ORFDOLVDWLRQ DFFXUDF\ IRU
*OHDVRQJUDGH ** DQG**WUDQVLWLRQ]RQH 7= FDQFHURI7ZHLJKWHG
7:, 05LPDJLQJ 05, YHUVXVPXOWLSDUDPHWULF05LPDJLQJ 0305, XVLQJ
UDGLFDOSURVWDWHFWRP\VSHFLPHQV 53 DVJROGVWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QFOXVLRQFULWHULDZHUH7=FDQFHU!FPXSRQ53
DQG7HQGRUHFWDO0305, 7:,GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQWPDSV $'& DQGG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, '&(05, )URP
53SDWLHQWVZLWK7=FDQFHUVZHUHLQFOXGHG7ZHQW\WZRSDWLHQWVZLWKRXW
7=ZLWKSHULSKHUDO]RQH 3= FDQFHUZHUHUDQGRPO\VHOHFWHGDVFRQWUROJURXS
)RXU UDGLRORJLVWV UDQGRPO\ VFRUHG 7:, 7:,$'& 7:,'&(05, DQG
7:,$'&'&(05,ZLWKDWZRZHHNLQWHUYDO7=FDQFHUVXVSLFLRQZDVUDWHG
RQDSRLQWVFDOHLQ7=UHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, $VFRUHZDVDSRVLWLYH
GHWHFWLRQ DFFXUDF\ UHVXOW /RFDOLVDWLRQ DFFXUDF\ ZDV DQDO\VHG XVLQJ 52,52&
ZLWKJHQHUDOLVHGHVWLPDWLRQHTXDWLRQV
5HVXOWV6LJQLÀFDQWO\PRUH** YHUVXV** 7=FDQFHUV
ZHUHGHWHFWHG S 2QO\IRU**7=FDQFHUVGHWHFWLRQDFFXUDF\ZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGE\0305,FRPSDUHGWR7:, YHUVXVS
8VLQJ0305,ORFDOLVDWLRQDFFXUDF\ZDVLPSURYHGIRU**7=FDQFHUVRQO\
$8&IRU0305,YHUVXVIRU7:,S
&RQFOXVLRQ'HWHFWLRQUDWHVRI**7=FDQFHUVDUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQ
WKRVHRI**7=FDQFHUV0305,FRPSDUHGWR7:,LPSURYHVGHWHFWLRQDF
FXUDF\IRU**7=FDQFHUVRQO\0305,VOLJKWO\LPSURYHV7=FDQFHUORFDOLVDWLRQ
DFFXUDF\FRPSDUHGWR7:,
%
5HWURVSHFWLYHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSDWKRORJLFDOVSHFLPHQVDQG
PXOWLSDUDPHWULF05,IRUGHWHFWLRQRISURVWDWHFDQFHU
)5XVVR($UPDQGR60D]]HWWL,%HUWRWWR(%ROOLWR)3RUSLJOLD
'5HJJH&DQGLROR,72UEDVVDQR,7 ÀOLSSRUXVVR#LUFFLW
3XUSRVH7RXQGHUVWDQGFDXVHVRIIDLOXUHWRLGHQWLI\FDQFHUOHVLRQV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK ELRSWLF GLDJQRVLV RI SURVWDWH FDQFHU
3&D XQGHUZHQW05,H[DPLQDWLRQDW77':,DQG'&(05,LPDJHVZHUH
DQDO\VHGIRUWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRI3&D2QWKHEDVLVRISDWKRORJLFH[DPLQDWLRQDIWHU
VXUJHU\05,ÀQGLQJVZHUHUHDQDO\VHGE\DQH[SHUWUDGLRORJLVWWRHYDOXDWH05,
IHDWXUHVRI3&DPLVVHGDWWKHÀUVWDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV3DWKRORJLFDQDO\VLVIRXQG3&DKDGDSDWKRORJLFDOYROXPH!PO
%HIRUH SURVWDWHFWRP\ 05, GHWHFWHG OHVLRQV ! PO VHQV
VHQVPHDQ$'& LQWKHSHULSKHUDO]RQH 3= DQG VHQVPHDQ
$'& LQWKHWUDQVLWLRQDO]RQH 7= 3DWKRORJ\EDVHG05,UHDQDO\VLVDOORZHG
WRUHFRJQLVH3&DLQ3=DQGLQ7=7KHPLVVHGOHVLRQVLQ3=
KDGVPDOOHUYROXPHV YVPO $PRQJPLVVHGOHVLRQVRQO\
RQHORFDOLVHGLQ3=KDGDQ$'&!KDGDQG$'&YDOXHVDQGDQ
$'&RI$PLOGK\SRLQWHQVHOHVLRQLQWHUSUHWHGDVSURVWDWLWLVKDGDW\SH7,
FXUYHDQGDQ$'&RIOHVLRQVRI3=DQG7=ZHUHK\SRYDVFXODULVHG $'&
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRISURVWDWHPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGSURVWDWHFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(WKLFVERDUGDSSURYDOZDVUHFHLYHGIRUWKLVUHWURVSHFWLYH
DQDO\VLVRISURVSHFWLYHO\DFTXLUHGGDWD1LQHW\PHQ PHGLDQDJH\HDUVPHGLDQ
36$QJPO XQGHUZHQWFRPELQHGHQGRUHFWDOERG\SKDVHGDUUD\FRLO7HVOD
05,EHIRUHWKHLUÀUVWV\VWHPDWLFFRUHELRSV\ZLWKWUDQVUHFWDOXOWUDVRXQG 7586
JXLGDQFH05LPDJHVZHUHDQDO\VHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\E\WKUHHUDGLRORJLVWV7KHUD
GLRORJLVWVGLYLGHGWKHSURVWDWHLQWRUHJLRQVFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRWKHELRSV\VFKHPH
DQGHYDOXDWHGHDFKUHJLRQIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIFDQFHULQDVWDQGDUGLVHGPDQQHU
XVLQJDSRLQWVFDOH$WVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVVFRUHVZHUHGLFKRWRPLVHGDVEHQLJQ
YVPDOLJQDQW 5HVXOWVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\VH[WDQW5HFHLYHURSHUDWLQJ
FKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLVZDVGRQHDQGGHVFULSWLYHVWDWLVWLFVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV6\VWHPDWLF7586JXLGHGFRUHELRSV\IRXQGFDQFHULQSDWLHQWV
ORZJUDGHFDQFHU *OHDVRQVFRUH KLJKJUDGHFDQFHU *OHDVRQVFRUH
DQGFRUHV ORZJUDGHFDQFHUKLJKJUDGHFDQFHU $UHDV
XQGHU52&FXUYHVZHUHIRUWKHWKUHHUHDGHUVE\VH[WDQWVIRURYHUDOO
SURVWDWHFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQDQGIRUGHWHFWLRQRIKLJKJUDGHFDQFHU'H
VFULSWLYHVWDWLVWLFVIRUGHWHFWLRQRIDOOFDQFHUVKLJKJUDGHFDQFHUVE\VH[WDQWZHUH
DV IROORZV QHJDWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH VSHFLÀFLW\
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGSRVLWLYH
SUHGLFWLYHYDOXH
&RQFOXVLRQ,QSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGSURVWDWHFDQFHUQHJDWLYH05,ÀQGLQJV
UXOHRXWKLJKJUDGHSURVWDWHFDQFHURQVXEVHTXHQW7586JXLGHGFRUHELRSV\
ZLWKDKLJKSUREDELOLW\+RZHYHUVHQVLWLYLW\LVORZDQGSDWLHQWVVKRXOGXQGHUJR
FORVHIROORZXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3&DLQWKH3=DQGLQWKH7=ZHUHHYDOXDWHGLQ
SDWLHQWVE\HQGRUHFWDOSURVWDWH05,DW7LQFOXGLQJ7ZHLJKWHGDQGGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHG05,EHIRUH5305,WXPRXUYROXPHZDVFRPSDUHGWRSDWKRORJLFDOÀQG
LQJVRIGLJLWLVHGVOLGHVRIZKROHPRXQW53&RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ$'&YDOXHVDQG
*6ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQWKH3=DQGWKH7=IRUWXPRXUVZLWKQRKLJK*OHDVRQJUDGH
JURXS YHUVXVWXPRXUVZLWK JURXS JURXS DQGPRUHWKDQ
RIKLJK*OHDVRQJUDGHV JURXS 79ZHUHFRPSDUHGE\WKH%ODQG$OWPDQWHVW
5HVXOWV$'&YDOXHVZHUHQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQJURXSVDQGDQG
EHWZHHQJURXSVDQG:KHQJURXSVYHUVXVJURXSVZHUHFRPSDUHG
$'&YDOXHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQJURXS YVLQWKH3=
DQGYVS 'LVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRJURXSVZDV
DFKLHYHGZLWKDVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGDQGDVSHFLÀFLW\RIDQGUH
VSHFWLYHO\&RPSDULVRQRISDWKRORJLFDOZLWK7:05,DQG':05,WXPRXUYROXPH
VKRZHGDPHDQGLIIHUHQFHRI UDQJH DQGRI UDQJH
UHVSHFWLYHO\:KHQERWKVHTXHQFHVSUHGLFWHGD79FFFRQFRUGDQFHZLWKWKH
SDWKRORJLFDOYROXPHZDVREVHUYHGLQFDVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7XPRXUVZLWKPRUHWKDQRIKLJK*OHDVRQJUDGHVFDQEHSUH
GLFWHGE\PHDVXUHPHQWRIWKH$'&YDOXH&RQFRUGDQFHEHWZHHQ79RQ05,DQG
SDWKRORJLFDOYROXPHZDVKLJKIRUWXPRXUVFF
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ $3=OHVLRQZDVPLVVHGIRULWVOLQHDUVKDSH $'&
7=OHVLRQVZLWKORZ$'&V PHDQ ZHUHLQWHUSUHWHGDVVWURPDODGHQRPDV
&RQFOXVLRQ:HIRXQGPDQ\FDXVHVRIGLDJQRVWLFIDLOXUHK\SRYDVFXODULVHGOHVLRQV
LQ3=DQG7=WKLQOHVLRQVLQ3=JODQGLQKRPRJHQHLW\HVSHFLDOO\LQ7=OHVLRQV
VL]HLQWHUPHGLDWH$'&YDOXHV05,UHDQDO\VLVLGHQWLÀHVLQ$'&YDOXHVWKHPRVW
DFFXUDWHPHWKRGWRLGHQWLI\SURVWDWHFDQFHU
%
%
3XUSRVH$ UHOHYDQW QXPEHU RI SDWLHQWV VXIIHULQJ IURP SURVWDWH FDQFHU UHPDLQ
XQGHWHFWHGDIWHUXOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGELRSV\3URVWDWH05,DQG05JXLGHGELRSV\
PLJKWRYHUFRPHWKLVGLDJQRVWLFJDS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VDUHVXOWRIDGLDJQRVWLFSURVWDWH05, 3KLOLSV,QWHUD
$FKLHYD7 SHUIRUPHGDWSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQWXOWUDVRXQGEDVHGELRSV\RI
WKHSURVWDWHJODQGZLWKDQHJDWLYHUHVXOWOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGWREHVXVSLFLRXV
GXHWRSDWKRORJLFDOFRQWUDVWXSWDNH !LQLWLDOXSWDNHG\QDPLFVHULHVV
VHULHV DQGVXVSLFLRXVGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW7KHVHOHVLRQVZHUHELRSVLHG05JXLGHG
XVLQJ&$'FDOFXODWLRQIRUDFFHVV '\QD&$'IRUSURVWDWH,QYLYR3KLOLSV1/ DQGUH
ODWHGKDUGZDUH '\QD75,0 ,QWHUYHQWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKD*ELRSV\QHHGOH
5HVXOWVKLVWRORJLFDOO\YHULÀHGOHVLRQVZHUHSURYHQWREHPDOLJQDQWSUHPD
OLJQDQW ,QVDPSOHVQRSURVWDWLFWLVVXHZDVIRXQG $PRQJ
WKHYHULÀHGLQYDVLYHPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVZHUHVXPPDULVHGDVKLJKJUDGH
LQWHUPHGLDWHDQGORZJUDGHPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVZHUHKLVWRORJLFDOO\FRQÀUPHG
DV7DVDDQGDVE0HDQ*OHDVRQVFRUHZDVOHVLRQVZHUHYHULÀHG
DVKLJKULVN$6$3OHVLRQVZHUHRIRWKHUEHQLJQKLVWRORJ\$PRQJWKHEHQLJQ
HQWLWLHVSURVWDWLWLVZDVFRPPRQO\REVHUYHGLQFDVHVK\SHUSODVLDLQIXUWKHU
FDVHVDQGDWURSKLFJODQGXODUWLVVXHLQFDVHV 2QO\PDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV
ZHUHORFDWHGLQWKHSHULSKHUDO]RQHLQWKHFHQWUDO]RQHH[FOXVLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ05JXLGHGSURVWDWHELRSV\LVDSUHFLVHWHFKQRORJ\ZLWKDKLJKGHWHF
WLRQUDWHRISURVWDWHFDQFHUWREHUHFRPPHQGHGDVWKHPHWKRGRIFKRLFHDIWHUD
QHJDWLYHVRQRJUDSKLFDOELRSV\ZLWKVXVSLFLRXVGLDJQRVWLFSURVWDWH05,
,VLWSRVVLEOHWRPRGHOWKHULVNRIPDOLJQDQF\RIIRFDODEQRUPDOLWLHV
IRXQGDWSURVWDWHPXOWLSDUDPHWULF05,"
25RXYLHUH03DSLOODUG1*LURXLQ5%RXWLHU05DELOORXG
%5LFKH)0HJH/HFKHYDOOLHU0&RORPEHO$*HOHW/\RQ)5
ROLYLHUURXYLHUH#FKXO\RQIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUIRFDODEQRUPDOLWLHV )$V GHSLFWHGE\SURVWDWH05,
FRXOGEHFKDUDFWHULVHGXVLQJVLPSOHVHPLRORJLFDOIHDWXUHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW 7ZHLJKWHG GLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHG DQG G\QDPLF FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 05, DW 7 EHIRUH SURVWDWH ELRSV\
ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHG)$VYLVLEOHDW05,ZHUHFKDUDFWHULVHGE\H[SHULHQFHG
XURUDGLRORJLVWV XVLQJ WKHLU VKDSH WKH GHJUHH RI VLJQDO DEQRUPDOLW\ QRUPDO
WR PDUNHGO\ DEQRUPDO RQ LQGLYLGXDO 05 VHTXHQFHV DQG D VXEMHFWLYH VFRUH
66 SUREDEO\ EHQLJQ WR 66 SUREDEO\ PDOLJQDQW )$V ZHUH WKHQ ELRSVLHG
XQGHU86JXLGDQFH
5HVXOWV)$VZHUHSRVLWLYHDWELRSV\7KHVXEMHFWLYHVFRUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\
SUHGLFWHGELRSV\UHVXOWV S $VFRPSDUHGWR66)$VWKHRGGVUDWLRV 25
RIPDOLJQDQF\RI66DQG66)$VZHUH DQG
7KHVKDSHRI)$VZDVQRWDVLJQLÀFDQWSUHGLFWRURIELRSV\UHVXOWVLQWKHSHULSKHUDO
]RQH 3= LWV SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH ZDV QRW WHVWHG LQ WKH WUDQVLWLRQ ]RQH GXH WR WKH
VPDOOQXPEHURIFDVHV,QFRQWUDVWDVLPSOHFRPELQDWLRQRI05VLJQDODEQRUPDOL
WLHV LQWR´ORZULVNµ´LQWHUPHGLDWHµDQG´KLJKULVNµJURXSV VLJQLÀFDQWO\SUHGLFWHG
ELRSV\UHVXOWV S $VFRPSDUHGWRORZULVN)$VWKH25RIPDOLJQDQF\
RILQWHUPHGLDWHDQGKLJKULVN)$VZHUH DQG LQWKH
RYHUDOOSRSXODWLRQDQG DQG LQ3=
&RQFOXVLRQ$VLPSOHFRPELQDWLRQRIVLJQDODEQRUPDOLWLHVRILQGLYLGXDO05VH
TXHQFHVFDQVLJQLÀFDQWO\VWUDWLI\WKHULVNRIPDOLJQDQF\RI)$VDQGJLYHVLPLODU
UHVXOWVWRDVXEMHFWLYHVFRUHDVVLJQHGE\H[SHUWXURUDGLRORJLVWV7KLVKROGVSURPLVH
RIDPRUHVWDQGDUGLVHGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRI05,E\UHDGHUVZLWKYDU\LQJH[SHULHQFH
%
$FFXUDF\RIXOWUDKLJKEYDOXHV E WRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHQLJQIURP
PDOLJQDQWSURVWDWLFQRGXOHVRQHQGRUHFWDOGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
40RQ]DQL$6FKXOO1%'HORQJVFKDPSV)%HXYRQ3/HJPDQQ)&RUQXG
3DULV)5 TPRQ]DQL#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHDFFXUDF\RIHQGRUHFWDOGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, HU':,
05, DW7HVODZLWKXOWUDKLJKEYDOXHVWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHQLJQIURPPDOLJQDQW
SURVWDWLFQRGXOHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKQRSUHYLRXVELRSV\DQRUPDO
GLJLWDOUHFWDOH[DPLQDWLRQDQGD36$OHYHORIQJPOZHUHUHIHUUHGXQGHUZHQW
HU05,7ZHLJKWHGDQG':,05, EYDOXHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'&
PDSSLQJDQGELPDJHV ZDVSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHVH[WDQWDQG758605,LPDJH
IXVLRQJXLGHG ELRSVLHV 2Q E':, VLJQDO LQWHQVLW\ 6, ZDV SURVSHFWLYHO\
PHDVXUHGRQK\SHULQWHQVHQRGXOHVRULJLQDWLQJLQWKHSHULSKHUDODQGWUDQVLWLRQ]RQH
3=DQG7= DQGRQWKHUHPDLQLQJVXUIDFHRQWKHVDPHVOLFH6,RIWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ
DUHDVRQ$'&DQGELPDJHVZDVPHDVXUHG1RGXOHSURVWDWH6,UDWLRVZHUH
FDOFXODWHGIRUEDQGEDQGEUDWLREUDWLRZDVWKHQFDOFXODWHG
$UHDVXQGHUWKHFXUYHV $8& RI$'&PDSSLQJDQGEUDWLREUDWLRZHUH
FRPSDUHGWRELRSV\UHVXOWV
5HVXOWV05,H[DPLQDWLRQVKRZHGQRGXOHVLQSDWLHQWV LQWKH3=DQG
LQ WKH 7= 7ZHQW\QLQH QRGXOHV ZHUH PDOLJQDQW EUDWLR
EUDWLR YDOXH ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU LQ PDOLJQDQW QRGXOHV WKDQ LQ EHQLJQ
QRGXOHV S $8&YDOXHRIWKHEUDWLREUDWLRZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHUWKDQWKDWRI$'& YVS 6HQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUH
YVDQGYVUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ EUDWLREUDWLR 6, YDOXH KHOSV WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH EHQLJQ IURP
PDOLJQDQWSURVWDWLFQRGXOHVLQERWK3=DQG7=$OWKRXJKSHUIRUPDQFHZDVEHWWHU
WKDQWKDWRI$'&PDSSLQJWKHGLIIHUHQFHRQO\DSSURDFKHGVLJQLÀFDQFH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
)HDVLELOLW\DQGUHOLDELOLW\RI05JXLGHGELRSV\RIWKHSURVWDWHJODQG
FRPSDULVRQWRKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDORXWFRPH
$0DOLFK$.RWW$8OULFK-)HJHU5&KHODUX
1RUGKDXVHQ'( FKHODUXBUREHUW#\DKRRFRP
%
05,DQGXOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGSURVWDWHELRSV\XVLQJUHDOWLPHVRIW
LPDJHIXVLRQ .RHOLV DSLORWVWXG\
(5XG(%DFR'.ORW]$6YLQGODQG+%(JJHVER2VOR12
SHUXG#PHGLVLQXLRQR
3XUSRVH7UDQVUHFWDOXOWUDVRXQG 7586 JXLGHGELRSVLHVDUHWKHJROGVWDQGDUG
ZKHQGLDJQRVLQJSURVWDWHFDQFHU+RZHYHUH[DFWELRSV\ORFDWLRQVFDQQRWEHYHUL
ÀHGDQGWKHUHLVDKLJKUDWHRIIDOVHQHJDWLYHELRSVLHV0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
05, FDQLGHQWLI\WXPRXUVEXWLWLVVWLOOQRWSRVVLEOHWRGRFXPHQWELRSV\SRVLWLRQV
XVLQJ7586$QHZ'JXLGHG7586ELRSV\PHWKRG .RHOLV FDQGRFXPHQWH[DFW
ELRSV\ORFDWLRQVDQGZLWKUHDOWLPHVRIWLPDJH05,IXVLRQWDUJHWHGELRSVLHVFDQ
EHSHUIRUPHG7KHDLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWH.RHOLV'XOWUDVRXQGDQG
05,IXVLRQJXLGHGELRSV\WHFKQLTXH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHW\SDWLHQWV \UVPHDQ\UVPHDQ36$QJ
PO XQGHUZHQW05,SULRUWRSURVWDWHELRSVLHV6XEJURXSVSULPDU\ELRSV\SWVVW
WKUHELRSVLHVSWVDQGELRFKHPLFDOUHFXUUHQFH %&5 DIWHUUDGLRWKHUDS\SWV
05,7$YDQWR 6LHPHQV(UODQJHQ DQGERG\DUUD\FRLO6HTXHQFHVD['7
DQG':,3RVWLPDJLQJSURFHVVLQJ1RUGLF,&(7XPRXUVZHUHKLJKOLJKWHGRQD[LDO
7LPDJHVDQGFODVVLÀHGDVKLJKPRGHUDWHRUORZGHJUHHRIVXVSLFLRQ%LRSVLHV
'$FFXYL[9 0HGLVRQ.RUHD QDYLJDWLRQV\VWHP.RHOLV*UHQREOH)UDQFH
5HVXOWVQRGXOHVZHUHELRSVLHG3RVLWLYHELRSVLHVDFFRUGLQJWRGHJUHHRIVXV
SLFLRQKLJK PHGLXP DQGORZ 5DQGRPELRSVLHV
ZHUHDQGSRVLWLYHLQ %LRSV\SRVLWLYHVXEJURXSVSULPDU\ELRSV\SRVLWLYH
VWWKUHELRSV\ %&5DIWHUUDGLRWKHUDS\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH.RHOLVPHWKRGLVIHDVLEOHDQGDOORZVDFFXUDWHWDUJHWHGELRSVLHV
+HQFHIDOVHQHJDWLYHELRSVLHVDQGWKHXVHRIUDQGRPELRSVLHVFDQEHUHGXFHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP)
%UHDVW
66
05,7XQHQKDQFHGDQGPRUH
0RGHUDWRUV
$/LQGD8GLQH,7
&/RR$PVWHUGDP1/
%
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKHF\FOLFDOFKDQJHVLQWKHKRUPRQDOOHYHOVDIIHFW
TXDQWLWDWLYHYDOXHVRIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& DQGWUDQVYHUVHUHOD[DWLRQ
WLPH 7 IRUJODQGXODUWLVVXHVLQKHDOWK\SUHPHQRSDXVDOZRPHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJD705,3KLOLSV6FDQQHU
DQGDGHGLFDWHGELODWHUDOFKDQQHOSKDVHGDUUD\EUHDVWFRLO3DUWLFLSDQWVZHUH
VFDQQHGIRXUWLPHVGXULQJWKHPHQVWUXDOF\FOH$'&PDSZDVJHQHUDWHGIURPD
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, SXOVHVHTXHQFHZLWKIRXUEYDOXHV
DQG VPP 7 PDS ZDV JHQHUDWHG IURP D PXOWLSOH VSLQ HFKR 6( SXOVH
VHTXHQFHZLWKIRXUHFKRWLPHV 7( DQGPV 5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVW
52, ZHUHSODFHGLQWKHJODQGXODUWLVVXHDWWKHHDFKRIWKHIRXUGLIIHUHQWSKDVHV
RIWKHPHQVWUXDOF\FOHLQHDFKEUHDVW
5HVXOWV4XDQWLWDWLYHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHREWDLQHGLQKHDOWK\SDUWLFLSDQWV
\HDUVROG ZLWKUHJXODUPHQVWUXDOF\FOH7KHUHVXOWVRIWKH$'& ðPPV
GXULQJVWQGUGDQGWKZHHNZHUH DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ DQG7YDOXHV PV ZHUH DQGUH
VSHFWLYHO\ $129$WHVWVKRZVWKDWWKHUHZDVQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWLQÁXHQFH
RIPHQVWUXDOF\FOHRQPHDQ$'&RU7YDOXHV+RZHYHUWKHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQW
DJHE\ZHHNRIF\FOHLQWHUDFWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KHUH ZDV QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH LQ PHDQ$'& DQG 7 YDOXHV
DFURVV WKH ZHHNV RI WKH PHQVWUXDO F\FOH +RZHYHU DJH FDQ EH FRQVLGHUHG DV
LQÁXHQFLQJIDFWRU
%
(IIHFWVRILQKRPRJHQHRXVUDGLRIUHTXHQF\SRZHUGHSRVLWLRQRQWKH
DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWRIWKHQRUPDOEUHDVWDW7
5*LURPHWWL00DLHURQ0%D]]RFFKL53DGRYDQL&=XLDQL8GLQH,7
UJLURPHWWL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHZKHWKHUWKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& TXDQ
WLÀFDWLRQLQWKHEUHDVWLVDIIHFWHGE\WKHLQKRPRJHQHLW\RIUDGLRIUHTXHQF\SRZHU
GHSRVLWLRQ 53' LQKHUHQWWR7V\VWHPV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HHQUROOHGSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWHYLGHQFHRIEUHDVWOH
VLRQVDWELODWHUDOEUHDVWPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJSHUIRUPHGRQD7PDJ
QHW%HIRUHFRQWUDVWDGPLQLVWUDWLRQWZRVHTXHQFHVZHUHFRQVHFXWLYHO\DFTXLUHG
D DWUDQVPLWPDJQHWLFÀHOG % PDSSLQJVHTXHQFHJHQHUDWLQJD%PDSE D
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGHFKRSODQDUVHTXHQFHJHQHUDWLQJE DQGVHFPP
LPDJHVWRJHWKHUZLWKDQ$'&PDS,QHDFKSDWLHQWEUHDVWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRIRXU
SHUVLGHV\PPHWULFDOUHJLRQV ,,9 RQWKHD[LDOVOLFHSDVVLQJWKURXJKWKHQLSSOHV
LQRUGHUWRFDOFXODWHRQDSHUUHJLRQEDVLVD WKHSHUFHQWRI53'ÁLSDQJOHIURP
%PDSE WKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& RIÀEURJODQGXODUWLVVXH ),7
$QDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKD.UXVNDO:DOOLVWHVWDQGWKHX0DQQ:KLWQH\WHVW
5HVXOWV53'ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQOHIWEUHDVWUHJLRQVDVFRPSDUHGWRWKH
ULJKWRQHV S /RZHVW53'ZDVIRXQGLQWKHULJKWLQWHUQDOUHJLRQ U,,,
7KHVDPHWUHQGZDVREVHUYHGIRUWKH),7$'&YDOXHDOWKRXJK
GLIIHUHQFHVZHUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW DYHUDJH$'&RI[PP
VHFDWWKHUHJLRQU,,,
&RQFOXVLRQ,QKRPRJHQHLW\LQ53'DW7DIIHFWHGWKHULJKWEUHDVW$OWKRXJK
QRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWUHODWHGGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQULJKWDQGOHIWEUHDVW),7$'&
VXJJHVWVWKDW$'&TXDQWLÀFDWLRQLVSRWHQWLDOO\XQUHOLDEOHDW7XQOHVVV\VWHPV
WRKRPRJHQLVH53'DUHXVHG
$FFXUDF\RI7PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJZLWKDKLJKUHOD[LYLW\
FRQWUDVWDJHQWLQDVVHVVLQJWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHLQSDWLHQWV
XQGHUJRLQJQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\
07HOHVFD)3HGLFRQL0/XFLDQL)9DVVHOOL9&DVDOL(0LJOLR&&DWDODQR
5RPH,7 PDULDQQDWHOHVFD#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHDFFXUDF\RIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJDW7 705,
LQHYDOXDWLQJUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHDIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\ 1$& LQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKDGYDQFHGEUHDVWFDQFHU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %HWZHHQ 0DUFK DQG -XO\ ZRPHQ ZLWK
DGYDQFHGEUHDVWFDQFHUVXQGHUZHQWG\QDPLF705,EHIRUHDQGDIWHU1$&7KH
05,SURWRFROFRPSULVHGSUHFRQWUDVW)6(7Z,'($/VHTXHQFHDQG9,%5$17'
7ZVHTXHQFHDFTXLUHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHUDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOX
PLQH 0XOWL+DQFH DWPPRONJERG\ZHLJKW$GHGLFDWHGELODWHUDOEUHDVWFRLO
ZDVXVHG)RUHDFKSDWLHQWWXPRXUVL]HZDVGHWHUPLQHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHU1$&,I
ELODWHUDOPXOWLIRFDORUPXOWLFHQWULFGLVHDVHZDVSUHVHQWRQO\WKHPDMRUOHVLRQZDV
FRQVLGHUHG7KH05,HYDOXDWLRQRIWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHZDVFODVVLÀHGEDVHGRQ
5(&,67FULWHULD5HVLGXDOWXPRXUVL]HVREWDLQHGXVLQJ05,ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK
SDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV
5HVXOWV$WRWDOQXPEHURIOHVLRQVZHUHHYDOXDWHG7KHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQG
DFFXUDF\RI05,LQGHWHFWLQJUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHZDVDQGUHVSHF
WLYHO\ DUHDXQGHU52&FXUYH 05,RYHUHVWLPDWHGWKHSUHVHQFHRIUHVLGXDO
WXPRXULQFDVHV7KHPHDQRIWKHODUJHVWGLDPHWHUVPHDVXUHGDWEDVHOLQH05,
SRVWWUHDWPHQW05,DQGKLVWRORJ\ZHUHDQGPPUHVSHFWLYHO\7KH
WXPRXUVL]HGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ05,DQGKLVWRORJ\ZDVQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
3YDOXH :HIRXQGDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ05,DQG
SDWKRORJ\PHDVXUHPHQWV 6SHDUPDQU 3YDOXH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQFHDQGVL]HRIUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHLQEUHDVWSDWLHQWVWUHDWHG
ZLWK1$&FRXOGEHDFFXUDWHO\HYDOXDWHGXVLQJ705,DQGKLJKUHOD[LYLW\FRQWUDVW
DJHQW
%
05PDPPRJUDSK\DW7LQFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFHSURVSHFWLYHVLQJOH
FHQWUHH[SHULHQFH
3$7%DOW]HU:$.DLVHU+3%XUPHLVWHU0'LHW]HO
-HQD'( SDVFDOEDOW]HU#PHGXQLMHQDGH
3XUSRVH+LJKHUPDJQHWLFÀHOGVWUHQJWKOHDGVWRKLJKHUVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRZKLFK
PD\EHLQYHVWHGLQKLJKHUVSDWLDORUWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQIRUEUHDVWLPDJLQJ:KLOH
VWURQJHUFKHPLFDOVKLIWEHWZHHQIDWDQGZDWHUPD\EHXVHIXOLQIDWVDWXUDWHG'
JUDGLHQWHFKRLPDJLQJ%DQG%LQKRPRJHQHLWLHVPD\QHJDWLYHO\DIIHFWLPDJLQJ
:HUHSRUWRQRXUSURVSHFWLYHH[SHULHQFHXVLQJ705PDPPRJUDSK\ 050 LQ
FOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV &RQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW 050 7 5DSLG
FKDQHO EUHDVW FRLO DFFRUGLQJ WR (XURSHDQ UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV G\QDPLF 7Z
IDWVDWXUDWHG'9,%(PPRONJ2PQLVFDQ7Z76(67,5DFTXLVLWLRQWLPH
PLQ 5HIHUHQFH VWDQGDUG ZDV KLVWRSDWKRORJ\ RU IROORZXS ! PRQWKV
5HVXOWVIURPGRXEOHUHDGLQJE\WZRH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVLQFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
ZHUHUHFRUGHGSURVSHFWLYHO\5HVXOWVSHUEUHDVWZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHUHIHUHQFH
VWDQGDUGXVLQJFRQWLQJHQF\WDEOHV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYH
OLNHOLKRRGUDWLR /5/5 ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWVEUHDVWVLQSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHG,QGLFDWLRQVIRU050ZHUHXQ
FOHDU Q RUVXVSLFLRXV Q UHVXOWVLQFRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJDIWHUFDUH Q
FOLQLFDOÀQGLQJV Q IROORZXSRIEHQLJQOHVLRQV Q DQGFRQWUDODWHUDOÀQGLQJV
Q 6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\/5XQG/5RIXQGZHUH
REVHUYHG 5HJXODUO\ LQKRPRJHQHRXV IDW VDWXUDWLRQ GXH WR % LQKRPRJHQHLWLHV
ZDVREVHUYHGZKLFKGLGQRWKDYHDGHWULPHQWDOLQÁXHQFHRQGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
$OOIDOVHSRVLWLYHÀQGLQJVSUHVHQWHGDVQRQPDVVHQKDQFHPHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ050DWWHVODVKRZHGH[FHOOHQWGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\6LPLODUWR050
DW7QRQPDVVOLNHHQKDQFHPHQWVZHUHGLDJQRVWLFDOO\FKDOOHQJLQJ7W\SLFDO
DUWHIDFWVGLGQRWKDYHDGHWULPHQWDOHIIHFWRQGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
%
%DFNWRWKHIXWXUHQRQFRQWUDVWEUHDVW05, QF%05, XVLQJD
FRPELQDWLRQRI7ZHLJKWHGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGDQG67,5LPDJLQJ
507ULPEROL19HUDUGL/$&DUERQDUR)&DUWLD*'L/HR)6DUGDQHOOL
6DQ'RQDWR0LODQHVH,7&RUXQQD,7
3XUSRVH2XUDLPZDVWRDVVHVVSHUEUHDVWVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIQF%05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$FRQVHFXWLYHVHULHVRIZRPHQZKRXQGHUZHQWEUHDVW
05,DWRXULQVWLWXWLRQIURP1RYHPEHUWR'HFHPEHUZDV LQFOXGHGLQ
WKLV UHWURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ 7ZR EOLQGHG UHDGHUV ZLWK 5 DQG \HDU 5 RI
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
7KHLQÁXHQFHRIKRUPRQDOÁXFWXDWLRQVRQTXDQWLWDWLYHGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ ':05, RIWKHJODQGXODU
EUHDVWWLVVXHLQKHDOWK\SUHPHQRSDXVDOSDUWLFLSDQWVDW7
1005$O5DVKLGL*:DLWHU7$KHDUQ)-*LOEHUW7:5HGSDWK
$EHUGHHQ8. QDOUDVKLGL#DEHUGHHQDFXN
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%05,H[SHULHQFHHYDOXDWHGQF%05,VWXGLHVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJJUDGLHQWHFKR7
ZHLJKWHG7ZHLJKWHG67,5DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ E DQG
VPP DVVLJQLQJD%,5$'6VFRUHIRUHDFKEUHDVW5HDGHUVZHUHEOLQGHGWR
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG &( %05,DQGÀQDOGLDJQRVLV%UHDVWVDVVLJQHG%,5$'6
ZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDVQHJDWLYHVDQGWKRVHDVVLJQHG%,5$'6DVSRVLWLYHV6HQ
VLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\ZHUHHVWLPDWHG$FRPELQDWLRQRIPDPPRJUDSK\
XOWUDVRXQG&(%05, PPRONJRIJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH DQGSDWKRORJ\
ZDVFRQVLGHUHGDVDVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVHVWLPDWHG
XVLQJ&RKHQNDSSDVWDWLVWLFV
5HVXOWV$ WRWDO RI EUHDVWV LQ SDWLHQWV DJHG \HDUV UDQJH
\HDUV ZHUH DQDO\VHG 3HUEUHDVW FDQFHU SUHYDOHQFH ZDV ,'&
Q ,/& Q '&,6 Q FDQFHUV QRW RWKHUZLVH VSHFLÀHG Q 5 KDG
VHQVLWLYLW\ RI VSHFLÀFLW\ RI DQG DFFXUDF\ RI
5KDGVHQVLWLYLW\RI VSHFLÀFLW\RI DQGDFFXUDF\
RI )RU5IDOVHQHJDWLYHVZHUHIRXU,'&RQH'&,6DQGRQH,/&
RQHFDQFHUVQRWRWKHUZLVHVSHFLÀHG)RU5IDOVHQHJDWLYHVZHUHIRXU,'&RQH
'&,6DQGRQH,/&RQHFDQFHUVQRWRWKHUZLVHVSHFLÀHG,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQW
ZDVDOPRVWSHUIHFW N
&RQFOXVLRQ$FRPELQDWLRQRI7ZHLJKWHGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGDQG67,5LPDJLQJ
DOORZHGIRUDJRRGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHZLWKKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\
%
%UHDVW05,DW7DSLORWVWXG\HVWLPDWLQJVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
RIXQHQKDQFHG05, ':,FRPELQHGZLWK7,'($/VHTXHQFH YV&(
05,LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIUHVSRQVHWRQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\
)3HGLFRQL07HOHVFD0/XFLDQL)9DVVHOOL9&DVDOL(0LJOLR&&DWDODQR
5RPH,7 IHGHULFDSHGLFRQL#XQLURPDLW
3XUSRVH7RLGHQWLI\VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIDFRQWUDVWDJHQWIUHHGLDJQRVWLF
DSSURDFKFRPELQLQJRQO\':,ZLWK7,'($/LPDJHV XH05, DQGFRPSDUHWKH
UHVXOWVZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, &(050 LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIUHVSRQVHWR
QHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\XVLQJD70DJQHW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&RQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPR
WKHUDS\IRUELRSV\SURYHGEUHDVWFDQFHU!FPXQGHUZHQW705SULRUWRFKHPR
WKHUDS\ HYHU\WZRF\FOHV DQGEHIRUHVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQ05SURWRFROFRPSULVHG
DQ)6(7,'($/DQG':,VHTXHQFHVDQG9LEUDQW'7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFH
DFTXLUHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHUDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWPHGLD7XPRXUUHVSRQVHZDV
FODVVLÀHGXVLQJ5(&,67FULWHULDXVLQJWXPRXUVL]HDW05,7XPRXUUHVSRQVHDW
05, DIWHU FKHPRWKHUDS\ ZDV FRPSDUHG WR KLVWRORJLFDO VSHFLPHQ DIWHU VXUJHU\
7ZREOLQGHGREVHUYHUVUDWHGXH05,DQGWKHQ&(05,IRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWXPRXU
UHVSRQVH/HVLRQVL]H$'&YDOXHVDQG)6(,'($/GHVFULSWRUVZHUHDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUHHQUROOHG6HQVLWLYLW\RIXH05,ZDV REVHUYHU DQG
REVHUYHU 6HQVLWLYLW\RI&(05,ZDVIRUERWKREVHUYHUV6SHFLÀFLW\
ZDV XH05, DQG &(05, IRUERWKREVHUYHUV7KHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ
ERWKPHWKRGVDQGREVHUYHUVZHUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW 3 /HVLRQVL]H
PHDVXUHPHQWVGLGQRWGLIIHUVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWZHHQDOOVHTXHQFHVDQDO\VHG7XPRXU
$'&YDOXHVGHPRQVWUDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQUHVSRQGHUVDQGQRQ
UHVSRQGHUVDIWHUWKHÀUVW,,F\FOHVRIWUHDWPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPELQDWLRQRI':,DQG7,'($/DOORZWRREWDLQVLPLODUYDOXHRI
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI&(05,LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWXPRXUUHVSRQVHWRQHR
DGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\$'&YDOXHVFRXOGEHXVHIXOIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJUHVSRQGHUV
IURPQRQUHVSRQGHUVHDUOLHUGXULQJWKHWUHDWPHQW
%
7RFRQWUDVWRUQRWWRFRQWUDVW"$QHZDSSURDFKWRXQHQKDQFHG05
PDPPRJUDSK\
0/RUHQ]RQ&=XLDQL$/LQGD6'H6WHIDQL00DLHURQ5*LURPHWWL
0%D]]RFFKL8GLQH,7 PLFKHOHORUHQ]RQ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH
339139 RIXQHQKDQFHG 8( 05PDPPRJUDSK\ 050
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVZHHQUROOHGDOOSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
&( 050 LQ RXU LQVWLWXWLRQ EHWZHHQ )HEUXDU\ DQG 0D\ ZLWK KLVWRORJLFDO
GLDJQRVLVRURQH\HDUIROORZXS3DWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\
ZHUHH[FOXGHG8VLQJD7VFDQQHU67,57:':DQG7:LPDJHVEHIRUHDQG
DIWHU*DGROLQLXPLQMHFWLRQZHUHDFTXLUHG7ZRUHDGHUVLQFRQVHQVXVSURVSHFWLYHO\
DVVHVVHGXH050 LH7:':DQG7:LPDJHVDFTXLUHGEHIRUH*DGROLQLXP
LQMHFWLRQ ZLWKRXW WKH NQRZOHGJH RI FOLQLFDO PDPPRJUDSK\ XOWUDVRXQG DQG
SDWKRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLV%DVHGRQPRUSKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHV DV\PPHWU\DUFKLWHFWXUDO
GLVWRUWLRQRUPDVVIRUPDVVHVVKDSHPDUJLQVVLJQDOIHDWXUHV DQG$'&YDOXHV
FXWRII PPV UHDGHUVUHSRUWHGZKHWKHUWKH\ZHUHFRQÀGHQWLQH[FOXG
LQJDQXQGHUO\LQJPDOLJQDQF\RUQRWK\SRWKHWLFDOO\DGGUHVVLQJSDWLHQWVWRFRQWUDVW
DJHQW LQMHFWLRQ RQO\ LQ WKH VHFRQG FDVH &OLQLFDO PDPPRJUDSK\ XOWUDVRXQG
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
FH050SDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVDQGIROORZXSGDWDZHUHFRQVLGHUHGWKHUHIHUHQFH
VWDQGDUG 56 6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\339DQG139RIXH050ZHUHDVVHVVHG$
&KLVTXDUHWHVWZDVXVHGWRDVVHVVDQ\VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ
XH050DQGWKH56
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVIXOÀOOHGRXUVHOHFWLRQFULWHULDZHUHDIIHFWHGE\GLIIHUHQW
OHVLRQV PDOLJQDQFLHV ZHUH GLDJQRVHG$IWHU XH050 RI PDOLJQDQFLHV
ZHUH QRW K\SRWKHWLFDOO\ DGGUHVVHG WR FH050 DQG ZHUH FRQVLGHUHG DV IDOVH
QHJDWLYH6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\339DQG139RIXH050ZHUH S
S S UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSDUHGWRWKH56XH050VHQVLWLYLW\DQG139ZHUHQRWVWDWLVWL
FDOO\GLIIHUHQW,QSDWLHQWVZKRFDQQRWUHFHLYH*DGROLQLXPLQMHFWLRQXH050FRXOG
EHDVDIHKLJKO\LQIRUPDWLYHWHFKQLTXH
%
$FRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQ)$67WHFKQLTXHDQGVWDQGDUGEUHDVW05,DUH
ZHUHDG\IRU05VFUHHQLQJ"
&&DERUQL&/RVLR33DQL]]D(9HQWXULQL)'H&REHOOL$'HO0DVFKLR
0LODQ,7
3XUSRVH%UHDVW05,RIIHUVDGYDQWDJHVRYHUPDPPRJUDSK\LQVFUHHQLQJEUHDVW
FDQFHUDPRQJ\RXQJZRPHQEXWVSHFLÀFLW\VKRXOGEHLPSURYHGWRUHGXFHH[SHQ
VLYHIROORZXS'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, FDQLQFUHDVHSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXHRIG\QDPLF05,:HFRPSDUHGWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRID)$67WHFK
QLTXH LQFOXGLQJ':, ZLWKVWDQGDUGH[DPLQDWLRQLQWKLVVHWWLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\VHOHFWHGEUHDVW05, 7':,
G\QDPLFVWXG\ VKRZLQJHQKDQFLQJOHVLRQV!PPZKLFKQDWXUHZDVDVVHVVHG
F\WRKLVWRORJLFDOO\RUZLWKIROORZXS7ZRWUDLQHGUDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXVUHYLHZHG
HDFKH[DPLQDWLRQFRQVLGHULQJWKHLQIRUPDWLRQVGHULYHGIURPDVKRUWG\QDPLF
VWXG\ VWSRVWFRQWUDVWVXEWUDFWLRQRQO\ SOXV':, )$6705, VHSDUDWHO\IURP
VWDQGDUGH[DPLQDWLRQ 7DQGSRVWFRQWUDVWVXEWUDFWLRQ DQGFRPSDULQJWKHLU
GLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
5HVXOWV)$6705,GHSLFWHG HQKDQFLQJOHVLRQVLGHQWLÀHGZLWK
VWDQGDUG H[DP QR FDQFHU ZDV PLVVHG 4XDQWLWDWLYH ':, ZLWK DVVHVVPHQW RI
$'& DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW ZDVSRVVLEOHLQVKRZLQJORZHU$'&
YDOXHVLQPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVWKDQEHQLJQ YV3 ,Q
VWDQGDUGH[DPLQDWLRQWKHNLQHWLFDQDO\VLVVKRZHGOLPLWHGYDOXHZLWKRQO\RI
FDQFHUVH[KLELWLQJDW\SHFXUYHDQGPRVW DQLQGHWHUPLQDWHFXUYH$'&
ZDVPRUHSUHGLFWLYHRIEHQLJQRUPDOLJQDQWQDWXUHXVLQJDFXWRIIRIPPV
52&DQDO\VLV )$6705,DFFXUDF\ZDVVXSHULRUWKDQVWDQGDUG05, YV
ZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH YV DQGFRQWULEXWLRQ
IRU%,5$'6OHVLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QRXUH[SHULHQFH)$6705,VKRZHGDEHWWHUDFFXUDF\WKDQVWDQG
DUGH[DPLQDWLRQGXHWRWKHVXSHULRULW\RI$'&RYHUG\QDPLFFULWHULD7KHKLJKHU
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQGWKHVKRUWHUH[DPLQDWLRQWLPHFRXOGSRWHQWLDOO\H[WHQG
WKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI05,LQDVFUHHQLQJFRQWH[W
%
6XEJURXSDQDO\VLVRIWKHÀQDOUHVXOWVRIWKH$XVWULDQVFUHHQLQJWULDO
IRUIDPLOLDOEUHDVWFDQFHU
&&5LHGO1/XIW&%%HUQKDUW*+HLQ]3HHU.3LQNHU7++HOELFK
9LHQQD$7 FKULVWRSKHUULHGO#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIPDPPRJUDSK\XOWUDVRXQGDQG05,RIWKHEUHDVW
LQWKHVXUYHLOODQFHRIYDULRXVVXEJURXSVRIZRPHQDWKLJKULVNIRUEUHDVWFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDSURVSHFWLYHWULDOZRPHQDWKLJKULVNIRUEUHDVWFDQFHU
ZHUHRIIHUHGDQQXDOVXUYHLOODQFHH[DPLQDWLRQVFRQVLVWLQJRIPDPPRJUDSK\XOWUD
VRXQGDQG05,6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXHSRVLWLYHOLNHOLKRRGUDWLRDQGQHJDWLYHOLNHOLKRRGUDWLRRIWKHWKUHHVXUYHLOODQFH
PRGDOLWLHVZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUYDULRXVVXEJURXSVRISDUWLFLSDQWVGLFKRWRPLVHGE\
PXWDWLRQVWDWXVDJHPHQRSDXVDOVWDWXVDQGSHUVRQDOKLVWRU\RIEUHDVWFDQFHU
5HVXOWV,QSDWLHQWVFRPSOHWHLPDJLQJURXQGVZHUHSHUIRUPHG$WRWDO
QXPEHURIFDQFHUVZHUHGHWHFWHGZLWKVHQVLWLYLWLHVIRUPDPPRJUDSK\XOWUD
VRXQGDQG05,RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ S 2IFDQFHUV
ZHUH'&,6)RUWKHVHPDPPRJUDSK\XOWUDVRXQGDQG05,GHPRQVWUDWHG
VHQVLWLYLWLHVRIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ S 0DPPRJUDSK\XOWUD
VRXQGDQG05,OHGWRDQGIDOVHSRVLWLYHÀQGLQJVZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQ
VSHFLÀFLWLHVRIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ S 2IWKHVHZHUHDW\SL
FDOGXFWDOK\SHUSODVLDV2IWKHVHSUHPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVPDPPRJUDSK\XOWUDVRXQG
DQG05,GHWHFWHG S &RPSUHKHQVLYHVXEJURXSDQDO\VHV
UHYHDOHGDKLJKHUVSHFLÀFLW\RI05,LQWKHVXEJURXSRIPXWDWLRQFDUULHUV DQG
SRVWPHQRSDXVDOZRPHQ FRPSDUHGWRQRQPXWDWLRQFDUULHUV DQGSUH
SHULPHQRSDXVDOZRPHQ ZLWK3
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRI05,LPSURYHVWKHGHWHFWLRQRILQYDVLYHDQGSUHLQYDVLYH
FDQFHUVDVZHOODVRIKLJKULVNOHVLRQV6SHFLÀFLWLHVIRU05,DUHKLJKHVWIRUPXWD
WLRQFDUULHUVDQGSRVWPHQRSDXVDOZRPHQ
%
7UHDWPHQWRILQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDQFHULQLWLDOFOLQLFDOH[SHULHQFH
XVLQJKLJKLQWHQVLW\IRFXVHGXOWUDVRXQGWKHUDS\ZLWK7PDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHJXLGDQFH
$1DSROL)3HGLFRQL0$Q]LGHL/'L0DUH*&DUWRFFL/%HUWDFFLQL)%RQL
91RFH&&DWDODQR5RPH,7 DOHVVDQGURQDSROL#XQLURPDLW
5RRP*+
1HXUR
66E
:KLWHPDWWHUGLVHDVHV
0RGHUDWRUV
&$XJHU$FRVWD%DUFHORQD(6
03:DWWMHV$PVWHUGDP1/
%
&RPSDULVRQRI7DQG7VFDQQHUVIRUHYDOXDWLQJP\HOLQDWLRQLQ
QHRQDWDOEUDLQV
'7RUWRUD93DQDUD66DOLFH3$0DWWHL&%ULJDQWL$5&RWURQHR
$7DUWDUR0&DXOR&KLHWL,7 GRPHQLFRWRUWRUD#KRWPDLOLW
3XUSRVH 05 LPDJLQJ LV SUHVHQWO\ WKH PRVW VHQVLWLYH PHWKRG IRU WKH LQYLYR
HYDOXDWLRQRIZKLWHPDWWHUPDWXUDWLRQLQQHRQDWDOEUDLQV(YDOXDWLQJP\HOLQDWLRQ
LV WHFKQLFDOO\ FRQGLWLRQHG E\ WKH VHTXHQFH DQG WKH VFDQQHU ÀHOG LQWHQVLW\7KH
REMHFWLYHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRUHWURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHWKHOHYHORIP\HOLQDWLRQRI
YDULRXVFHUHEUDOVWUXFWXUHVLQWZRJURXSVRIWHUPDQGSUHWHUPQHRQDWHVHYDOXDWHG
ZLWKHLWKHUDRU7VFDQQHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5RXWLQHEUDLQ05RIQHRQDWHVZDVUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
HYDOXDWHG SUHWHUP$IWHU LQIRUPHG FRQVHQW ZDV REWDLQHG IURP OHJDO JXDUG
LDQVDOOQHRQDWHVZHUHVHGDWHGDQGXQGHUZHQW05H[DPVDWDJHVWDWLRQDODJH
EHWZHHQDQGZHHNV HTXLYDOHQWFRUUHFWHGDJHIRUSUHWHUPV 7VFDQQHU
ZDVXVHGLQ SUHWHUP DQG7LQ SUHWHUP QHRQDWHV7ZREOLQGHG
QHXURUDGLRORJLVWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\HYDOXDWHGP\HOLQDWLRQRQ76(7ZHLJKWHGD[LDO
LPDJHVLQWKHEUDLQVWHPLQIHULRUFHUHEHOODUSHGXQFOHLQIHULRUFROOLFXOXVFHUHEHOODU
YHUPLVJOREXVSDOOLGXVYHQWURSRVWHURODWHUDOWKDODPLFQXFOHXVLQWHUQDOFDSVXOH
RSWLFUDGLDWLRQFRURQDUDGLDWDDQGSUHFHQWUDOJ\UXV6WDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHVZHUH
HYDOXDWHGXVLQJD3HDUVRQҋV&KLVTXDUHGWHVWS
5HVXOWV0\HOLQDWLRQRIWKHFHUHEHOODUYHUPLV S JOREXVSDOOLGXV S
LQWHUQDOFDSVXOH S DQGRSWLFUDGLDWLRQ S ZDVLGHQWLÀHGZLWKDKLJKHU
IUHTXHQF\ZLWK7LQERWKWKHSUHWHUPDQGIXOOWHUPQHRQDWHV
&RQFOXVLRQ76(7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHVREWDLQHGZLWKD7FRPSDUHGZLWKD
7VFDQQHUSUHVHQWDKLJKHUVHQVLWLYLW\IRUP\HOLQDWHGEUDLQVWUXFWXUHLQQHRQDWHV
7KLVUHVXOWDQGWKHORVVRIFRQWUDVWLQ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVHQFRXUDJHWKHXVHRI
7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHDW7WRHYDOXDWHWKHSURFHVVRIP\HOLQDWLRQLQQHZERUQV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
,PDJLQJRIPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLVDW7LQFUHDVHGGLDJQRVWLF\LHOGXVLQJ
VXEWUDFWLRQLPDJLQJ
6/DQJQHU56HLSHO%0HQVHO62WWR$'UHVVHO1+RVWHQ0.LUVFK
*UHLIVZDOG'( VRHQNHODQJQHU#XQLJUHLIVZDOGGH
3XUSRVH 7KH GHWHFWLRQ RI FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG *G GHP\HOLQDWLQJ OHVLRQV LV
LPSRUWDQW IRU WKH GLDJQRVLV DQG WUHDWPHQW RI PXOWLSOH VFOHURVLV 7KH DLP RI RXU
VWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHDSSOLFDELOLW\RIVXEWUDFWLRQ05LPDJHVIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQ
RIDFWLYH06OHVLRQDW7HVODXVLQJDFKDQQHOKHDGFRLO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHGSDWLHQWV IHPDOHVPHDQ
DJH\HDUV ZLWKSURYHQPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV05LPDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHG
DW7HVODXVLQJDFKDQQHOKHDGFRLO$OOSDWLHQWVUHFHLYHGLQWUDYHQRXVFRQWUDVW
PHGLD *DGRYLVW%D\HU6FKHULQJ3KDUPD%HUOLQ ZLWKDGRVHRIPPRO
*GNJERG\ZHLJKW)ROORZXS05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGDIWHUPRQWKV,QDOOSDWLHQWV
ZHDFTXLUHGD[LDO7ZDQG7ZÁGLPDJHVEHIRUHDQGPLQXWHVDIWHUDGPLQLV
WUDWLRQRI*DGREXWURO3UHFRQWUDVWLPDJHVZHUHVXEWUDFWHGIURPWKHSRVWFRQWUDVW
(QKDQFLQJOHVLRQVZHUHFRXQWHGRQSUHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVWLPDJHV/HVLRQFRXQW
ZDVHYDOXDWHGE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWQHXURUDGLRORJLVWV
5HVXOWV/HVLRQORDGRQ7ZLPDJHVZDV8VLQJXQVXEWUDFWHGSRVW
FRQWUDVWLPDJHV*GOHVLRQV PHDQ LQSDWLHQWVZHUHLGHQWLÀHG
2QVXEWUDFWLRQLPDJHV*GOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZHUHGHWHFWHG,QRIWKHVH
SDWLHQWV*GOHVLRQVZHUHQRWLGHQWLÀHGRQXQVXEWUDFWHGLPDJHV,QSDWLHQWV
DGGLWLRQDO*GOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGDQGLQSDWLHQWVWKHVL]HRIWKHOHVLRQV
LQFUHDVHG7KHUHZDVJRRGLQWHUUHDGHUDJUHHPHQW ѣ
&RQFOXVLRQ8VLQJDFKDQQHOKHDGFRLODQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG'VXEWUDFWLRQ
05LPDJHVLPSURYHWKHGLDJQRVWLF\LHOGRI05,DW7HVODIRUGHWHFWLRQRIDFWLYH
06OHVLRQ
%
9DOXHRI',505VHTXHQFHVLQFRPSDULVRQWR)/$,5DQG'37ZKHQ
LGHQWLI\LQJFRUWLFDODQGMX[WDFRUWLFDOOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOH
VFOHURVLV
09HUD&DUWDV96FKRQVWHGW*HOGUHV&$XJHU$FRVWD50LWMDQD3HQHOOD
$5RYLUD&DxHOODV%DUFHORQD(6 PDUWDYHUD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHGHWHFWLRQE\05RIFRUWLFDOMX[WDFRUWLFDOOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKWKH
GLDJQRVWLF VXVSLFLRQ RI PXOWLSOH VFOHURVLV LV RI JUHDW UHOHYDQFH7KH SXUSRVH RI
WKLVZRUNLVWRFRPSDUHWKHVHQVLELOLW\RI´GRXEOHLQYHUVLRQUHFXSHUDWLRQµVHTXHQFH
',5 LQFRPSDULVRQWR´ÁXLGDWWHQXDWHGLQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\µ )/$,5 DQGSURWRQLF
GHQVLW\VHTXHQFH '37 LQLGHQWLI\LQJGHP\HOLQDWLQJFRUWLFRMX[WDFRUWLFDOOHVLRQV
LQWKLVSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZHUH LQFOXGHG ZRPHQ PLG
GOH DJH ZLWK WKH GLDJQRVLV RI D VLQJOH QHXURORJLF V\QGURPH RU PXOWLSOH
VFOHURVLV$OOWKHVWXGLHVZHUHPDGHLQD7HTXLSPHQWDQGLQFOXGHGVHTXHQFHV
',5)/$,5DQG'37REWDLQHGLQDQD[LDOVKRWZLWKFRQWLJXRXVLPDJHVPP
ZLGWK2QHREVHUYHULGHQWLÀHGWKHFRUWLFDOMX[WDFRUWLFDOOHVLRQVLQHDFKVHTXHQFH
LQGHSHQGHQWO\DQGDVDZKROH
5HVXOWV2IDWRWDORIOHVLRQVGHWHFWHGLQWKHWKUHHVHTXHQFHVDVDZKROH
)/$,5LGHQWLÀHGE\LWVHOIRIWKHP'37DQG',57KHFRP
SDULVRQEHWZHHQWKH',5VHTXHQFHDQGWKH)/$,5DQG'37VKRZVDJDLQLQWKH
QXPEHURIGHWHFWHGOHVLRQVRIDZKHQFRPSDULQJ',5WR)/$,5DQGRID
ZKHQFRPSDULQJ',5WR'37:KHQFRPSDULQJ)/$,5DQG'37DVDZKROHWR
',5VHTXHQFHE\LWVHOIWKHJDLQLVRID S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH',5VHTXHQFHLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHVHQVLEOHLQGHWHFWLQJGHP\
HOLQDWLQJ FRUWLFRMX[WDFRUWLFDO OHVLRQV WKDQ )/$,5 DQG '37 1HYHUWKHOHVV WKH
FRPELQDWLRQ RI WKH WKUHH VHTXHQFHV RIIHUV D KLJKHU VHQVLELOLW\ LQ GHWHFWLQJ WKLV
OHVLRQVZKLFKLVUHOHYDQWWRFRQÀUPWKHGLDJQRVLVRIPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV
%
,QIUDWHQWRULDOOHVLRQVLQPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLVLPSURYHGGHWHFWLRQZLWK
77,5005LPDJLQJDW7PDJQHW
2.LULWVL.7VLWDV*1RXVVLRV*.LULWVLV7KHVVDORQLNL*5$WKHQV*5
NLUROJD#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHWKHGHSLFWLRQRILQIUDWHQWRULDOOHVLRQVXVLQJ
ÁXLGDWWHQXDWHG LQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\ )/$,5 DQG 77,50 PDJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH
05 LPDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV/RFDOHWKLFVUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYDODQGLQIRUPHGFRQ
VHQWZHUHREWDLQHG&RQYHQWLRQDO)/$,5LQD[LDOSODQHDQG77,50LPDJHVLQ
VDJLWWDOSODQH PPWKLFN ZHUHDFTXLUHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV
ZRPHQPHQ DQGDJHPDWFKHGKHDOWK\FRQWUROVXEMHFWV ZRPHQ
PHQ 0HDQDJHZDV\HDUV UDQJH\HDUV LQSDWLHQWVDQG\HDUV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH HIÀFDF\ RI QRQLQYDVLYH KLJKLQWHQVLW\ 05JXLGHG
IRFXVHGXOWUDVRXQG 05J)86 WUHDWPHQWIRUELRSV\SURYHQLQYDVLYHGXFWDOEUHDVW
FDQFHU ,'& VWDJH701 VFKHGXOHGWRVXUJLFDOUHVHFWLRQDQGVHQWLQHOO\PSK
QRGHELRSV\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8QGHUWKH,5%DSSURYDOSDWLHQWVZLWKXQLIRFDOELRSV\
SURYHQ,'&OHVVWKDQFPLQVL]HVFKHGXOHGDQGFRQVHQWHGWRVXUJLFDO OXPSHFWRP\
RUPDVWHFWRP\ UHVHFWLRQDQGVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHELRSV\DQGLQZKLFKEUHDVW
05,FRQÀUPHGDQHQKDQFLQJOHVLRQLQDWUHDWDEOHORFDWLRQXQGHUZHQW05J)86
WUHDWPHQW XVLQJ WKH ([$EODWH V\VWHP ,Q6LJKWHF 7UHDWPHQWV ZHUH GRQH
LQDVLQJOHVHVVLRQLQDQDPEXODWRU\VHWWLQJ(IIHFWLYHQHVVRIWKHWUHDWPHQWZDV
HYDOXDWHGDWSDWKRORJ\DIWHUVXUJHU\
5HVXOWV$OO OHVLRQV ZHUH WUHDWHG 1R HQKDQFHPHQW ZDV VHHQ DW EUHDVW 05,
DIWHUWUHDWPHQWLQDOOSDWLHQWV,QDOOFDVHVSDWKRORJ\GHPRQVWUDWHGWKHDEVHQFHRI
UHVLGXDOFDQFHUDIWHUVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQ:HIRXQGRQO\QHFURWLFWLVVXHZLWKDWOHDVW
PPPDUJLQVRIQRUPDOEUHDVWWLVVXHDURXQGWKHQHFURVLV:HREWDLQHGH[FHOOHQW
DJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ05,SRVWWUHDWPHQWDQGSDWKRORJ\
&RQFOXVLRQ05J)86LVDSURPLVLQJQRQLQYDVLYHWUHDWPHQWPRGDOLW\IRUXQLIRFDO
EUHDVWFDQFHU
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
UDQJH\HDUV LQFRQWUROVXEMHFWV2QO\LQIUDWHQWRULDOOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHG
DQGUHSRUWHG7KHQXPEHUVRIOHVLRQVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQWHFKQLTXHV
5HVXOWV7RWDOQXPEHURIOHVLRQVGLIIHUEHWZHHQ77,50DQG)/$,56HTXHQFHV
77,50LPDJHVGHSLFWHGPRUHLQIUDWHQWRULDOOHVLRQV OHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWV
WKDQ)/$,5 OHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWV LPDJHV>W6WXGHQWS @2QDYHUDJH
77,50LPDJLQJGHSLFWHGPRUH,QIUDWHQWRULDOOHVLRQVSHUSDWLHQWWKDQGLG
)/$,5LPDJLQJ2QO\LQIUDWHQWRULDOOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGLQFRQWUROVXEMHFWV
ZLWK77,50VHTXHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ 05 LPDJLQJ ZLWK77,50 HQDEOHV LQFUHDVHG LQIUDWHQWRULDO OHVLRQ
GHWHFWLRQLQWKHPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLVEUDLQ
%
9HLQGHQVLW\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLVDW7DSLORWVWXG\
6*RHG$'DO%LDQFR**UDEQHU06FKHUQWKDQHU.9DVV67UDWWQLJ
9LHQQD$7 VDELQHJRHG#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH ,QWUDOHVLRQDO YHLQV DQG SHULYHQRXV LQÁDPPDWLRQ DUH NQRZQ WR EH D
SDWKRKLVWRORJLFDO KDOOPDUN RI PXOWLSOH VFOHURVLV 06 6XVFHSWLELOLW\ZHLJKWHG
LPDJLQJ 6:, DW7DOORZVWKHLPDJLQJRIYHLQVDVVPDOODVPPLQGLDPHWHU
7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRILQWUDOHVLRQDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRI
YHLQVLQ06SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV PHDQ DJHG \HDUV ZLWK UHODSVLQJ
UHPLWWLQJ06 5506Q DQGVHFRQGDU\SURJUHVVLYH06 6306Q ZLWKDQ
H[SDQGHGGLVDELOLW\VWDWXVVFDOH ('66 ZHUHLQFOXGHG7KH05SURWRFRODW
7 FRPSULVHG D )/$,5)6(VHTXHQFH DQG D 6:,VHTXHQFH 757( PV
YR[HOVL]H[[PP 7KHH[DPLQDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGDWEDVHOLQHDQG
\HDUDIWHU'DWDIURPSDWLHQWV 5506Q 6306Q FRXOGÀQDOO\EHDQDO\VHG
SODTXHVDQGLWVFRUUHVSRQGLQJQRUPDODSSHDULQJZKLWHPDWWHU 1$:0 ZHUH
DVVHVVHGIRUOHVLRQYROXPHDQGYHLQYROXPHZLWKD'6RIWZDUH
5HVXOWV3DWLHQWVZLWKDUHODSVLQJUHPLWWLQJFRXUVHVKRZHGDPHDQLQWUDOHVLRQDO
YHLQGHQVLW\ RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK VHFRQGDU\SURJUHVVLYH PXOWLSOH VFOHURVLV D
PHDQ RI 7KLV LQGLFDWHV D WZRIROG KLJKHU YHLQGHQVLW\ LQ 5506SODTXHV
9HLQGHQVLW\ LQ 1$:0 FRQVWDQWO\ DFFRXQWHG IRU D PHDQ RI LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWK5506DQG6306&RPSDUHGWRWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ1$:05506
SODTXHVVKRZDWKUHHIROGKLJKHUYHLQGHQVLW\DQG6306SODTXHVDWZRIROGKLJKHU
YHLQGHQVLW\:HFRXOGIXUWKHUSUHFLVHO\GLVSOD\LQWUDOHVLRQDOVPDOOYHLQVSDUWLDOO\
VKRZLQJDVWUDLJKWOLQHGFRXUVH$GGLWLRQDOO\ZHFRXOGGHSLFWWKUHHQHZO\GHYHORSHG
YHLQDVVRFLDWHG06SODTXHVZLWKLQ\HDU
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWLHQWVZLWKDUHODSVLQJUHPLWWLQJFRXUVHRIPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLVUHSUH
VHQWDKLJKHULQWUDOHVLRQDOYHLQGHQVLW\WKDQSDWLHQWVZLWKDVHFRQGDU\SURJUHVVLYH
FRXUVHRIPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV
%
8OWUDKLJKÀHOG05,GHWHFWHGLURQDFFXPXODWLRQLQPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV
SODTXHVDSLORWVWXG\
6*RHG$'DO%LDQFR**UDEQHU06FKHUQWKDQHU.9DVV+/DVVPDQQ
67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7 VDELQHJRHG#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH)UHHLURQLVGLVFXVVHGWRFRQWULEXWHDVDQHXURWR[LFDJHQWWRQHXURLQ
ÁDPPDWLRQDQGQHXURGHJHQHUDWLRQLQPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV 06 7KHSXUSRVHRIRXU
VWXG\ZDVWRYLVXDOLVHDQGDQDO\VHIRFDOLURQDFFXPXODWLRQVZLWKLQ06SODTXHV
DQGSHUIRUPDIROORZXSDIWHURQH\HDU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVPHDQDJHG\HDUVZLWKUHODSVLQJUHPLWWLQJ
06 5506Q DQGVHFRQGDU\SURJUHVVLYH06 6306Q ZLWKDQ([SDQGHG
'LVDELOLW\6WDWXV6FDOH ('66 ZHUHH[DPLQHGRQD705VFDQQHU 6LHPHQV
+HDOWKFDUH(UODQJHQ*HUPDQ\ DWEDVHOLQHDQG\HDUDIWHU7KHSURWRFROFRP
SULVHGD)/$,5)6(VHTXHQFHDQGD6:,VHTXHQFH 757(PVYR[HOVL]H
[[PP 4XDOLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGWRDVVHVVLURQDFFXPXODWLRQ
LQ06SODTXHVZLWKLQ\HDU
5HVXOWV,QRXWRISDWLHQWVDWRWDORILURQORDGHG06SODTXHVZHUHGHWHFWHG
ZLWKLQ\HDU,URQDFFXPXODWLRQVZHUHRQO\REVHUYHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWK5506
,Q5506SDWLHQWVLURQFRQWDLQLQJOHVLRQVGRPLQDWHGOHVLRQVKRZHGLQFUHDVHG
LURQORDGOHVLRQUHGXFHGLURQORDGDQGOHVLRQDFKDQJHGVKDSH,QOHVLRQV
LQLWLDOO\LVRODWHGLURQGHSRVLWVDWWDLQHGFRQÁXHQFHDQGIXUWKHUOHVLRQVVKRZHGQR
FKDQJHRILURQDFFXPXODWLRQ)XUWKHUPRUHWKHVL]HRI06SODTXHVZLWKLQFUHDVHG
RUFRQÁXHQWLURQDFFXPXODWLRQZDVUHGXFHG
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKLVSLORWVWXG\LURQDFFXPXODWLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
UHODSVLQJUHPLWWLQJ PXOWLSOH VFOHURVLV DQG VKRZHG G\QDPLFV LQ VKDSH DQG VL]H
ZLWKLQ\HDU
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
'LVUXSWHGZKLWHPDWWHUVWUXFWXUDOQHWZRUNVLQFOLQLFDOO\LVRODWHG
V\QGURPHVVXJJHVWLYHRI06
</LX16KX<'XDQ<+H./L%HLMLQJ&1
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHWRSRORJLFDORUJDQLVDWLRQRIWKHZKLWHPDWWHUVWUXFWXUDO
QHWZRUNVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOO\LVRODWHGV\QGURPH &,6 DQGUHODSVLQJUHPPLWLQJ
PXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV 5506 E\'7,WUDFWRJUDSK\DQGJUDSKWKHRUHWLFDODSSURDFKHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\HLJKWSDWLHQWVZLWK&,6SDWLHQWVZLWK5506
DQGKHDOWK\FRQWUROV +& ZHUHLQFOXGHG$OOSDUWLFLSDQWVZHUHVFDQQHGZLWKD
705,VFDQQHU7DQG'7,LPDJHVZHUHDFTXLUHG:HFRQVWUXFWHGWKHZKLWH
PDWWHUVWUXFWXUDOQHWZRUNIRUHDFKSDUWLFLSDQW%DVHGRQWKH)1ZHLJKWHGQHWZRUN
IRUHDFKVXEMHFWZHFDOFXODWHGWKHQHWZRUNSURSHUWLHVLQFOXGLQJWKHVWUHQJWKJOREDO
HIÀFLHQF\DQGORFDOHIÀFLHQF\DWWKHJOREDOOHYHODQGWKHUHJLRQDOHIÀFLHQF\DWWKH
QRGDOOHYHO$PXOWLSOHOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGRQHDFKQHWZRUN
PHWULFEHWZHHQDQ\WZRJURXSV3 FRUUHFWHG ZDVUHJDUGHGDVVLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV6PDOOZRUOGFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKH:0VWUXFWXUDOQHWZRUNVZHUHLGHQWLÀHG
LQERWKWKHFRQWUROVDQGWKHSDWLHQWV$PRQJWKHWKUHHJURXSVZHIRXQGWKH06
SDWLHQWVKDYHWKHORZHVWQHWZRUNHIÀFLHQF\&RPSDUHGZLWK+&WKH&,6SDWLHQWV
H[KLELWHGVLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHVLQWKHVWUHQJWKDQGJOREDOHIÀFLHQF\RIWKHLU:0
VWUXFWXUDO QHWZRUNV )RU DOO WKH QHWZRUN SURSHUWLHV WKH &,6 QHWZRUN H[KLELWHG
LQWHUPHGLDWHGYDOXHV&RPSDUHGZLWK+&WKH&,6SDWLHQWVH[KLELWHGDUHGXFWLRQ
LQWKHQRGDOHIÀFLHQF\LQELODWHUDOSUHFHQWUDOJ\UXVDQGOHIWSRVWFHQWUDOJ\UXVZKLOH
WKH06SDWLHQWVKDYHZLGHVSUHDGHIÀFLHQF\UHGXFWLRQLQPDQ\EUDLQUHJLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ 'LVUXSWHG WRSRORJLFDO RUJDQLVDWLRQ LQ WKH ZKLWH PDWWHU QHWZRUN LV
DOUHDG\IRXQGDWWKH&,67KHPRVWVLJQLÀFDQWUHJLRQDOFKDQJHVZHUHORFDWHGDW
WKHSULPDU\VHQVRULPRWRUV\VWHPLQ&,6
%
5HYLVHG0F'RQDOGҋVFULWHULDIRUGLVVHPLQDWLRQLQVSDFHDFFXUDF\LQ
GLDJQRVLVRIPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLVIURP1HXUREHKFHWҋVGLVHDVH
66HÀGEDNKW0%DEDLQH]KDG$%RUKDQL+DJKLJKL5-DOOL==DUH6KLUD],5
VHSLGHKVHÀGEDNKW#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\GHWHUPLQHDFFXUDF\RIPRGLÀHG0F'RQDOGҋVFULWHULDIRU
GLVVHPLQDWLRQLQVSDFHLQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV 06 IURP1HXUREHKFHW
GLVHDVH 1%' LQDKLJKSUHYDOHQFHDUHDRIERWKGLVHDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGEUDLQ05,V
EHORQJLQJWRSDWLHQWVZLWK06DQGSDWLHQWVZLWK1%'EOLQGHGWRWKHFOLQLFDO
GLDJQRVLV$FFXUDF\RI0F'RQDOGFULWHULDLQGLDJQRVLQJ06ZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJ
3RVHUFULWHULDDVWKHJROGVWDQGDUG
5HVXOWV2XWRIDOO0F'RQDOGFULWHULDIRUGLVVHPLQDWLRQLQVSDFHRQO\LQIUDWHQWRULDO
OHVLRQVZHUHQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHSUHYDOHQWLQ06&RUSXVFDOORVDOOHVLRQVZHUH
WKH PRVW VLJQLÀFDQW GLVFULPLQDWLQJ IDFWRU EHWZHHQ WKH WZR GLVHDVHV VL[ WLPHV
PRUHSUHYDOHQWLQ06 6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RI0F'RQDOGFULWHULD
ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHWZRÀQGLQJVPRUHSUHYDOHQWLQ1%'
SDWLHQWV ZHUH PHVRGLHQFHSKDOLF LQYROYHPHQW DQG H[WHQVLRQ RI WKH OHVLRQ IURP
RQH DQDWRPLF VLWH WR WKH QHLJKERXULQJ VLWH ,QWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW ZDV QHDU
SHUIHFWLQGLDJQRVLQJ06XVLQJPRGLÀHG0F'RQDOGVFULWHULDIRUGLVVHPLQDWLRQLQ
VSDFH NDSSDRI
&RQFOXVLRQ6SHFLÀFLW\RI0F'RQDOGҋVFULWHULDDVDVWDQGDORQHWHVWLQGLIIHUHQWLDW
LQJ06IURP1%'LVVXERSWLPDOZLWKDSRVVLEOHKLJKUDWHRIIDOVHSRVLWLYHVWXGLHV
05,VVKRXOGEHLQWHUSUHWHGLQWKHSURSHUFOLQLFDOEDFNJURXQGWRDYRLGPLVODEHOOLQJ
SDWLHQWVZLWKDOWHUQDWHGLDJQRVHVDV06
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIPHWDEROLFSHUIXVLRQDQGPLFURVWUXFWXUDOFHUHEUDO
DOWHUDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKV\VWHPLFOXSXVHU\WKHPDWRVXVXVLQJ05
VSHFWURVFRS\SHUIXVLRQDQGGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ
36]HZF]\N$=LPQ\-%ODGRZVND06]P\UND.DF]PDUHN06DVLDGHN
:URFODZ3/ DEHUQDF#ZSSO
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHPHWDEROLFSHUIXVLRQDQGPLFURVWUXF
WXUDOFHUHEUDODOWHUDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKV\VWHPLFOXSXVHU\WKHPDWRVXV 6/( DQG
QRUPDODSSHDULQJEUDLQRQSODLQ05XVLQJDGYDQFHGWHFKQLTXHV05VSHFWURVFRS\
056 SHUIXVLRQZHLJKWHGDQGGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ 3:,DQG'7,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\WZR6/(SDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\UV ZLWKQRUPDO
DSSHDULQJEUDLQRQSODLQ05DQGDJHPDWFKHGFRQWUROVXEMHFWVXQGHUZHQWVLQJOH
YR[HO056G\QDPLFVXVFHSWLELOLW\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG3:,DQG'7,LQGLUHFWLRQV
RQ705XQLW0HWDEROLWHUDWLRV 1$$&U&KR&UP,&U ZHUHFDOFXODWHGIURP
SRVWHULRUFLQJXODWHFRUWH[DQGOHIWSDULHWDOZKLWHPDWWHU9DOXHVRIFHUHEUDOEORRG
YROXPH UHODWHG WR FHUHEHOOXP U&%9 ZHUH DVVHVVHG IURP UHJLRQV LQFOXGLQJ
GLIIHUHQW FRUWLFDO ORFDWLRQV EDVDO JDQJOLD DQG IURQWRSDULHWDO ZKLWH PDWWHU )UDF
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
WLRQDODQLVRWURS\ )$ YDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHGIURPZKLWHPDWWHUWUDFWVLQFOXGLQJ
SURMHFWLRQFRPPLVVXUDODQGDVVRFLDWLRQÀEUHV
5HVXOWV&RPSDUHGWRFRQWUROV6/(SDWLHQWVVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S ORZHU
1$$&UUDWLRVZLWKLQERWKHYDOXDWHGUHJLRQVORZHUU&%9YDOXHVRQO\ZLWKLQULJKW
SDULHWDOFRUWH[DQGGHFUHDVHGYDOXHVRI)$LQPXOWLSOHZKLWHPDWWHUWUDFWVULJKW
PLGGOH FHUHEHOODU SHGXQFOH JHQX RI FRUSXV FDOORVXP OHIW VXSHULRU DQG LQIHULRU
ORQJLWXGLQDOIDVFLFOHVOHIWLQIHULRUIURQWRRFFLSLWDOIDVFLFOHDQGERWKFLQJXOD
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVRIDGYDQFHG05WHFKQLTXHVUHÁHFWQHXURQDOORVVZLWKLQ
JUH\DQGZKLWHPDWWHUDQGGLVLQWHJULW\ZLWKLQPXOWLSOHZKLWHPDWWHUWUDFWVLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK6/(056DQG'7,VHHPWREHHVSHFLDOO\SURPLVLQJQRQLQYDVLYHQHXURLPDJ
LQJELRPDUNHUVIRUDVVHVVLQJWKHVHYHULW\RIPLFURVWUXFWXUDOFKDQJHVLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK6/(
%
3XUSRVH7RLOOXVWUDWHHDUO\DQGSURJUHVVLYHVLJQVRQ05LPDJHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
SURJUHVVLYHPXOWLIRFDOOHXNRHQFHSKDORSDWK\ 30/
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05LPDJHVRIVHYHQSDWLHQWVZLWK30/ZHUHUHYLHZHG
7KHGLDJQRVLVRI30/ZDVHVWDEOLVKHGE\FOLQLFDOODERUDWRU\ &6)3&5IRU-&
YLUXV DQG05LPDJHVLQDOOSDWLHQWV2QHSDWLHQWZDVDOVRXQGHUZHQWEUDLQELRSV\
$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWUHSHDWHG05H[DPLQDWLRQVRQRUWHVOD05XQLWVIRU
WKHLQLWLDOGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXSDQGWUHDWPHQWFRQWURO
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWV05LPDJHVVKRZHGZRUVHQLQJRIÀQGLQJV'XUDWLRQRI
IROORZXSVWXGLHVZDVWRPRQWKV1HZHUPDUJLQVLQVSUHDGLQJOHVLRQVVKRZHG
KHWHURJHQHRXVPLOGK\SHULQWHQVHZLWKQXPHURXVGRWVRIVHYHUHK\SHULQWHQVHRQ
7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHV ´0LON\ZD\DSSHDUDQFHµ KHWHURJHQHRXVPLOGVOLJKWK\SRLQ
WHQVLW\RQ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDQGK\SHULQWHVHRQGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJHVZLWK
PLOGGHFUHDVHGRULQFUHDVHGGLIIXVLRQ:LWKWKHSURJUHVVVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RIWKHVH
OHVLRQVJUDGXDOO\LQFUHDVHGRQ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDQGLQYHUVHO\GHFUHDVHGRQ7
ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVZLWKLQFUHDVHRIGLIIXVLRQÀQDOO\QHDU&6)LQWHQVLW\ZLWKDWURSK\
7KHVHÀQGLQJVVHHPHGWRFRUUHVSRQGWKHSDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVRIQXPHURXVIRFL
ZLWKP\HOLQDQGD[RQORVVWKDWPHUJHWRJHWKHUWREHODUJHGHP\HOLQDWLQJOHVLRQ
DQGÀQDOO\WREHVHYHUHDWURSK\DQGFDYLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ ´0LON\ ZD\ DSSHDUDQFHµ RQ 7ZHLJKWHG LPDJHV DQG K\SHULQWHVH
DUHDVRQGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJHVPD\EHHDUO\DQGSURJUHVVLYHVLJQVLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK30/
5RRP,.
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
66E
%LOLDU\WUDFW
0RGHUDWRUV
7'HQHFNH%HUOLQ'(
**.DUPD]DQRYVN\0RVFRZ58
%
*DGR[HWLFDFLGHQKDQFHG7ZHLJKWHG05FKRODQJLRJUDSK\LQ
SULPDU\VFOHURVLQJFKRODQJLWLV
$)U\GU\FKRZLF]$5-HG\QDN).HOF]6.1DJOH6%5HHGHU
0DGLVRQ:,86/EHFN'(0DGLVRQ:,86 DOH[IU\GU\FKRZLF]#XNVKGH
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH YDOXH RI JDGR[HWLF DFLGHQKDQFHG GLPHQVLRQDO
7ZHLJKWHG05FKRODQJLRJUDSK\ 7Z05& LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKGLPHQVLRQDO
7ZHLJKWHG05FKRODQJLRSDQFUHDWLFRJUDSK\ 7Z05&3 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\
VFOHURVLQJFKRODQJLWLV 36&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG05H[DPVLQSDWLHQWV
\HDUV NJ NJ PHQZRPHQ 6FDQV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGDW7ZLWKDQHLJKWFKDQQHOSKDVHGDUUD\WRUVRFRLO'7Z
05&3ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKDVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQRI[[PPLQWHUSRODWHG
WR[[PPWKURXJK]HURÀOOLQJ7Z05&ZDVDFKLHYHGPLQDIWHU
LQMHFWLRQRIPPRONJJDGR[HWLFZLWKDQDYLJDWRUJDWHG'VSRLOHGJUDGLHQWUH
FDOOHGHFKR 63*5 VHTXHQFHZLWKLQWHUPLWWHQWVSHFWUDOO\VHOHFWLYHSDUWLDOLQYHUVLRQ
UHFRYHU\IDWVXSSUHVVLRQ /$9$ 7KHVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQRI[[PPZDV
LQWHUSRODWHGWR[[PP,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHGLQDEOLQGHGIDVKLRQ
UHJDUGLQJLPDJHFRQWUDVWLPDJHTXDOLW\GHJUDGDWLRQGXHWRDUWHIDFWVDQGYLVXDOLVD
WLRQTXDOLW\RIGXFWVE\WZRDEGRPLQDOUDGLRORJLVWV5HDGHUSUHIHUHQFHWRZDUGVDQG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
%LOLDU\HQWHULFDQDVWRPRVHVXVHIXOQHVVRI*G(2%'73$HQKDQFHG
05FKRODQJLRJUDSK\
3%RUDVFKL)'RQDWL66DOHPL5*LJRQL&%DUWROR]]L))DODVFKL3LVD,7
SERUDVFKL#GRPHGXQLSLLW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHXVHIXOQHVVRI*G(2%'73$HQKDQFHG05FKRODQJLRJ
UDSK\ 05& LQSDWLHQWVZLWKELOLDU\HQWHULFDQDVWRPRVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\IRXUSDWLHQWVZLWKSUHH[LVWLQJELOLDU\HQWHULFDQDV
WRPRVHV DQG FOLQLFDOHFKRJUDSKLFDO VXVSHFW RI ELOLDU\ SDWKRORJ\ XQGHUZHQW 05
LPDJLQJDW7GHYLFH$IWHUDFTXLVLWLRQRI7Z7ZLPDJHVFRQYHQWLRQDO05&
ZDVSHUIRUPHGWKURXJKWKLQVODE')5)6(DQGWKLFNVODE66)6(7ZVHTXHQFHV
,QHDFKSDWLHQWD'IDWVXSSUHVVHG/$9$VHTXHQFHZDVSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHDQG
PLQXWHVDIWHULQWUDYHQRXVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIPO*G(2%'73$
3ULPRYLVW%D\HU+HDOWK&DUH IROORZHGE\LQMHFWLRQRILVRWRQLFVDOLQH PO
7ZVHTXHQFHZDVDOVRREWDLQHGDIWHUPLQXWHVLQFDVHV9LVXDOLVD
WLRQRIHDFKVHJPHQWRIWKHELOLDU\WUHHDQGDQDVWRPRWLFERZHOZDVJUDGHGE\WZR
UDGLRORJLVWV LQ FRQIHUHQFH RQ D IRXUSRLQW VFDOH DEVHQW SRRU JRRG
H[FHOOHQW$OOVHJPHQWVZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIGXFWDOGLODWDWLRQVWULF
WXUHELOHOHDNDJHLQWUDGXFWDOÀOOLQJGHIHFWVDQGRWKHUDEQRUPDOLWLHV05,ÀQGLQJV
ZHUHFRPSDUHGWRVXUJLFDOÀQGLQJVZKHQVFKHGXOHGDQGRUDVL[PRQWKODVWLQJ
FOLQLFDOUDGLRORJLFDOIROORZXS
5HVXOWV*G(2%'73$HQKDQFHG05&VLJQLÀFDQWO\RXWSHUIRUPHGFRQYHQWLRQDO
05&LQWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHH[WUDKHSDWLFELOLDU\V\VWHPDQGDQDVWRPRWLFUHJLRQ
DQGLQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIDQDVWRPRWLFVWULFWXUHVDQGSQHXPRELOLD S 7KH
JUDGLQJ RI YLVXDOLVDWLRQ DQG GHSLFWLRQ RI GLODWLRQ RI WKH VHFRQG DQG WKLUG RUGHU
LQWUDKHSDWLF ELOH GXFWV ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ VXSHULRU RQ 7Z 05& S 1R
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVLGHQWLÀHGEHWZHHQWKHWZRWHFKQLTXHVLQWKHGHWHFWLRQ
RIELOLDU\VWRQHV
&RQFOXVLRQ&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05&XVLQJ*G(2%'73$FDQLPSURYHWKHGL
DJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIFRQYHQWLRQDO7Z05&LQWKHSRVWRSHUDWLYHDVVHVVPHQW
RI ELOLDU\HQWHULF DQDVWRPRVHV VLQFH LW SURYLGHV ERWK DQDWRPLFDO DQG IXQFWLRQDO
LQIRUPDWLRQRIWKHELOLDU\WUDFW
%
&KDUDFWHULVDWLRQDQGVWDJLQJRIKLODUFKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPD .ODWVNLQ
7XPRXU HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHKHSDWRF\WHVSHFLÀFFRQWUDVWDJHQW
JDGR[HWDWHGLVRGLXP
.,5LQJH+%HNWDV%35LQJH3-2SKHUN
$5HLFKHOW):DFNHU-/RW]%&0H\HU+DQQRYHU'(
*|WWLQJHQ'( ULQJHNULVWLQD#PKKDQQRYHUGH
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIJDGR[HWDWHGLVRGLXPIRUFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQDQG
VWDJLQJRIKLODUFKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPD K&&&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSURVSHFWLYH+,3$$FRPSOLDQWVWXG\ZDV,5%DS
SURYHGSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHV\ ZLWKFOLQLFDOVXVSLFLRQRIFHQWUDO
ELOHGXFWVWHQRVLV &%'6 XQGHUZHQWSUHRSHUDWLYH05,,PDJHVZHUHDVVHVVHG
IRUDHWLRORJ\RI&%'6$PRGLÀHG%LVPXWKFODVVLÀFDWLRQZDVDSSOLHGIRUWXPRXU
H[WHQVLRQ7RHVWLPDWHWKHYDOXHRIKHSDWRF\WHSKDVHLPDJHVRQO\7ZLPDJHV
7 RQO\SRVWFRQWUDVWLPDJHV &0 RUERWKLPDJHGDWDVHWVZHUHDVVHVVHGLQ
WKUHH UHDGLQJ VHVVLRQV E\ UHDGHUV WZR ZHHNV LQWHUYDO $JUHHPHQW RI HDFK
UHDGLQJVHVVLRQZLWKWKHLQWUDRSHUDWLYHÀQGLQJVLQWHUPVRI&%'6DHWLRORJ\DQG
WXPRXUH[WHQVLRQ ZHLJKWHGNDSSDVWDWLVWLF ZDVFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV &%'6 ZDV FDXVHG E\ K&&& Q JDOOEODGGHU FDUFLQRPD Q DQG
SDQFUHDWLFFDUFLQRPD Q &KDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI&%'6DHWLRORJ\ZDVFRUUHFWE\
XVHRI7ZLPDJHVLQDQGE\XVHRI&0LPDJHVLQDQG
E\FRPELQDWLRQRIERWKLQDQG$JUHHPHQWFRPSDULQJUHDG
LQJVHVVLRQVDQGLQWUDRSHUDWLYHÀQGLQJVUHJDUGLQJWXPRXUH[WHQVLRQZDVIDLUXSWR
PRGHUDWH ѣ 7 &0 ERWK DVDUHVXOWRIFRPPRQXQGHUVWDJ
LQJ,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRUWXPRXUH[WHQVLRQZDVIDLU ѣUDQJH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
(DUO\DQGSURJUHVVLYHVLJQVRQ05,LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSURJUHVVLYH
PXOWLIRFDOOHXNRHQFHSKDORSDWK\
06DNDL.1DNDQLVKL<7RPLWD<<DPDVKLWD..XUL\DPD2VDND-3
[LDRKXPHL[X#JPDLOFRP
QXPEHURIRUGHUVRIYLVXDOLVHGELOLDU\WUHHEUDQFKHVZHUHUHFRUGHG$KHOSIXOQHVV
VFRULQJRIJDGR[HWLFDFLGHQKDQFHG7Z05&ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQFRQVHQVXV
5HVXOWV,PDJHTXDOLW\RI7Z05&DQG7Z05&3ZDVJUDGHGJRRGWRH[FHOOHQW
LQDOOFDVHV7KHUHZHUHDGYDQWDJHVIRUERWK7Z05& IXQFWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQ
OHVVDUWHIDFWGHJUDGDWLRQ DQG7Z05&3 KLJKHURUGHURIYLVXDOLVHGEUDQFKHV
EHWWHUEUDQFKGHSLFWLRQ %RWKUHDGHUVVKRZHGSUHIHUHQFHIRU7Z05&3 UHDGHU
UHDGHU KRZHYHULQWKHPDMRULW\RIFDVHV FDVHV
ERWKUHDGHUVDJUHHGWKDWJDGR[HWLFDFLGHQKDQFHG7Z05&ZDVKHOSIXO
&RQFOXVLRQ*DGR[HWLFDFLGHQKDQFHG7Z05&LVFRPSOHPHQWDU\WREXWVKRXOG
QRWUHSODFH7Z05&37Z05&LVDXVHIXODGMXQFWIRUPRUSKRORJLFHYDOXDWLRQ
DQGSURYLGHVDGGLWLRQDOGLDJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ %\ PHDQV RI FRPELQHG HYDOXDWLRQ RI 7Z VHTXHQFHV DQG SRVW
FRQWUDVWLPDJHVDIWHULQMHFWLRQRIJDGR[HWDWHGLVRGLXPDPRUHUHOLDEOHFKDUDF
WHULVDWLRQRI&%'6ZDVSRVVLEOH(YHQWKRXJK&%'6WHQGHGWREHXQGHUVWDJHG
EHIRUHDVZHOODVDIWHUFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQDVVHVVPHQWRIH[DFWWXPRXUH[WHQVLRQ
ZDVLPSURYHGE\FRQWUDVWDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
%
5HODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQELOLDU\FRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGKHSDWLFDUWHULDO
EXIIHUUHVSRQVHDIWHUOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQEDVHGRQXOWUDVRXQGGDWD
$'RURV(+DUWPDQQ$1HPHWK9.R]PD$3'HDN6.XGUQRYD
-)D]DNDV/.RERUL%XGDSHVW+8 GRUDWWLOD#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH %LOLDU\ VWULFWXUH DQG OHDNDJH DUH FRPPRQ FRPSOLFDWLRQV DIWHU OLYHU
WUDQVSODQWDWLRQV /7 2QHRIWKHPDLQFDXVHLVDUWHULDOLVFKDHPLD7KHUHODWLRQVKLS
EHWZHHQDUWHULDODQGSRUWDOYHLQÁRZ KHSDWLFDUWHULDOEXIIHUUHVSRQVH FRQFHUQLQJ
ODWHELOLDU\FRPSOLFDWLRQVDUHQRWIUHTXHQWO\DQDO\VHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYH/7VLQWUDDQGSRVWRSHUDWLYHXOWUDVRXQG
H[DPLQDWLRQV ZHUH UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ DQDO\VHG DQG FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKH RQH\HDU
IROORZXSFOLQLFDOUHVXOWVIRFXVLQJRQELOLDU\VWULFWXUHVDQGOHDNDJH7KHXOWUDVRXQG
GDWDZHUHFRPSRVHGRIWKHURXWLQHFRQWUROVDUWHULDOUHVLVWLYHLQGH[ 5, KHSDWLF
YHLQYHORFLW\FXUYHVDQGSRUWDOYHLQYHORFLWLHV
5HVXOWV$OWRJHWKHUPLQRU V\PSWRPIUHH DQGPDMRU WUHDWPHQWUHTXLUHGDQG
SHUIRUPHG ELOLDU\FRPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHGLDJQRVHG,QFDVHVORZ5,VXJJHVWLQJ
DUWHULDOVWHQRVLVZHUHQRWLFHGZKLOHWKHUHPDLQLQJFDVHVVKRZHGFRQVHTXHQWKLJK
!FPV SRUWDOYHQRXVYHORFLWLHVDQG5,YDOXHV ! 2QWKHFRQWUDU\FDVHV
ZHUHIRXQGZLWKWKHVDPHÁRZSDWWHUQVZLWKRXWDQ\VLJQVRIELOLDU\FRPSOLFDWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHKLJKSRUWDOYHORFLW\DQGKLJK5,PD\RQO\URXJKO\UHSUHVHQWWKH
KHSDWLF DUWHULDO EXIIHU UHVSRQVH KRZHYHU WKHVH YDOXHV DUH PHDVXUHG URXWLQHO\
DIWHU/7+DOIRIRXUSDWLHQWV VKRZHGWKLVÁRZFRPELQDWLRQEXWRQO\
GHYHORSHGELOLDU\FRPSOLFDWLRQVRIDQ\VHYHULW\7KHURXWLQHO\PHDVXUHGSDUDPHWHUV
DUHQRWVXIÀFLHQWHQRXJKWRSUHGLFWODWHELOLDU\FRPSOLFDWLRQVDOWKRXJKPHGLFDO
VXUJLFDORULQWHUYHQWLRQDOWUHDWPHQWRIH[FHVVLYHO\KLJKSRUWDOÁRZFRPELQHGZLWK
KLJK5,DUWHULDOÁRZPD\EHEHQHÀFLDO7KHGHFLVLRQRISRWHQWLDOWUHDWPHQWVKRXOG
EHPDGHLQGLYLGXDOO\
%
6WHDG\VWDWHIUHHSUHFHVVLRQVHTXHQFHVFDQDGGYDOXDEOHGLDJQRVWLF
GHWDLOVWRFRQYHQWLRQDO05FKRODQJLRJUDSK\
$,R]]HOOL/2QFLQL0DFHUDWD,7 DLR]]HOOL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH$GGLQJ D VWHDG\VWDWH IUHH SUHFHVVLRQ VHTXHQFH 66)3 WR WKH FRQ
YHQWLRQDO'7ZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHFKRODQJLRJUDSK\VHTXHQFH '&
SURYLGHVDGGLWLRQDOGLDJQRVWLFGDWD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVWKDWXQGHUZHQW05FKRODQ
JLRJUDSK\H[DPLQDWLRQDORQJ\HDUVIRUVXVSHFWHGELOLDU\REVWUXFWLRQRUELOLDU\
GLVHDVHVUHFHLYHGQRQEUHDWKKROGFRURQDOREOLTXH66)3VHTXHQFHVDIWHUWKH
FRQYHQWLRQDO'&VHTXHQFH7KH66)3VHTXHQFHVLQDOOWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUH
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\H[DPLQHGE\RQHH[SHUWUHDGHUWRFRQÀUPWKH'&VHTXHQFHGLDJ
QRVLVDQGVHDUFKIRUDGGLWLRQDOGHWDLOVWKDWFRXOGFRQWULEXWHWRWKHPDLQGLDJQRVLV
5HVXOWV,QDOOWKHFDVHV WKHEUHDWKLQJDUWHIDFWVZHUHQRWLQÁXHQFLQJWKH
GLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\RIWKHVHTXHQFHV,Q FDVHVWKH'&GLDJQRVLV
ZDVFRQÀUPHGE\66)3LQWKHUHPDLQLQJ FDVHV66)3LGHQWLÀHG
WKHFRUUHFWGLDJQRVLVWKDWZDVQRWFOHDUZLWK'&DORQH,Q FDVHV
DGGHGVRPHGHWDLOVWKDWZHUHQRWYLVLEOHLQWKH'&
&RQFOXVLRQ66)3LVDXVHIXOVHTXHQFHWKDWFDQDGGGHWDLOVWRWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO
'&VHTXHQFHGXHWREHWWHUUHVROXWLRQKLJKH[WUDOXPLQDODQGELOLDU\ZDOOGHWDLOV
ORZHUVHQVLWLYLW\WREUHDWKLQJDUWHIDFWVDQGGRHVQRWDGGVLJQLÀFDQWWLPHWRFRPSOHWH
WKHH[DPLQDWLRQ
%
)XQFWLRQDOLPDJLQJXVLQJ*DGR[HWDWHGLVRGLXPHQKDQFHG705
FKRODQJLRJUDSK\YHUVXVFRQYHQWLRQDO705FKRODQJLRJUDSK\
FRPSDULVRQZLWK(5&3LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\VFOHURWLFFKRODQJLWLV
51RO]$:LEPHU+(LQVSLHOHU8$VHQEDXP60DJQDOGL
03HFN5DGRVDYOMHYLF$%D6VDODPDK9LHQQD$7
ULFKDUGQRO]#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH GLDJQRVWLF YDOXH RI *DGR[HWDWH GLVRGLXPHQKDQFHG
705FKRODQJLRJUDSK\GHOD\HGKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHYHUVXVFRQYHQWLRQDO
705FKRODQJLRJUDSK\LQFRPSDULVRQWR(5&3LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\VFOHURWLF
FKRODQJLWLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\VFOHURWLFFKRODQJLWLVFRQÀUPHG
E\(5&3FOLQLFDOSUHVHQWDWLRQDQGODERUDWRU\WHVWVDVVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFHZKR
XQGHUZHQW*DGR[HWDWH 3ULPRYLVW%D\HU+HDOWK&DUH%HUOLQ*HUPDQ\ HQKDQFHG
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
7 05 FKRODQJLRJUDSK\ ZHUH UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWHG &RQYHQWLRQDO 7
ZHLJKWHG05FKRODQJLRJUDSK\DQG*DGR[HWDWHHQKDQFHG05FKRODQJLRJUDSK\LQ
GHOD\HGKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHLQFRURQDODQGD[LDOSODQHVZHUHVHSDUDWHO\DVVHVVHG
DQGWKHQFRPSDUHGWR(5&37KHSUHVHQFHRISHULSKHUDODQGFHQWUDOVWHQRVLV
GLODWDWLRQ DQG FRQWRXU LUUHJXODULWLHV IRU FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ RI 36& ZDV HYDOXDWHG
XVLQJDSRLQWVFRULQJV\VWHP
5HVXOWV7KHVWXG\FRKRUWFRQVLVWHGRISDWLHQWV IHPDOHV ZLWKDPHDQDJH
RI\HDUV UDQJH\HDUV 0HDQWLPHEHWZHHQ(5&3DQG05LPDJLQJ
ZDVGD\V,QSDWLHQWVZLWK36&IHDWXUHVGHOD\HGKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHVKRZHG
DQ H[FHOOHQW FRUUHODWLRQ ZLWK (5&3 ѣ ѩ ZKHUHDV FRUUHODWLRQ RI
7ZHLJKWHG05ZDVRQO\PRGHUDWH ѣ ѩ )XUWKHUPRUHGHOD\HG
KHSDWRELOLDU\ SKDVH GHPRQVWUDWHG D VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW EHWWHU GHWHFWLRQ RI
REVWUXFWLYHFHQWUDOVWHQRVLVLQFRPSDULVRQWRFRQYHQWLRQDO05&3 S 7KH
FRUUHVSRQGLQJ$8&VZHUHYHUVXVLQFRPSDULVRQZLWK(5&3
&RQFOXVLRQ'HOD\HGKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHRI*DGR[HWDWHHQKDQFHG05LQFUHDVHV
DFFXUDF\ IRU HDUO\ GHSLFWLRQ RI 36& IHDWXUHV DQG SURYLGHV DGGLWLRQDO IXQFWLRQDO
LQIRUPDWLRQRIELOHGXFWVZKLFKDOORZVDSSURSULDWHWUHDWPHQWRI36&DVVRFLDWHG
FOLQLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFHQWUDOVWHQRVLV
%
5ROHRI*'(2%'73$HQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
FKRODQJLRJUDSK\ 05& LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIELOLDU\VWULFWXUHVDIWHU
RUWKRWRSLFOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ 2/7 SUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
$3HFFKL0*LEHUWLQL0'H6DQWLV)'L%HQHGHWWR37RUULFHOOL0RGHQD,7
DQQDBSHFFKL#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH7RGHVFULEHWKHUROHRI*'(2%'73$HQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
FKRODQJLRJUDSK\ 05& LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIELOLDU\VWULFWXUHVLQOLYHUWUDQVSODQWHG
SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %HWZHHQ -XO\ DQG 6HSWHPEHU OLYHU
WUDQVSODQWHGSDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOVXVSHFWHGELOLDU\VWULFWXUHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWK
*'(2%'73$HQKDQFHG 05&$[LDO DQG FRURQDO 7Z DQG 7Z VHTXHQFHV
UDGLDO'66)6(FRURQDO'7Z)6(VHTXHQFHVZHUHDFTXLUHGLQSUHFRQWUDVWR
JUDSKLFSKDVH7Z'*5(VHTXHQFHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHULQMHFWLRQ
RI*'(2%'73$ PONJ LQFOXGLQJG\QDPLFDQGGHOD\HGKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHV
DFTXLUHGPLQXWHVDIWHU*'(2%'73$DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ'LDJQRVWLFFRQ
ÀUPDWLRQZDVREWDLQHGZLWKKHSDWRELOLDU\VFLQWLJUDSK\ +%6 DQGSHUFXWDQHRXV
WUDQVKHSDWLFFKRODQJLRJUDSK\ 37&
5HVXOWV,QDOOFDVHV*'(2%'73$HQKDQFHG05&GHSLFWHGELOLDU\VWULFWXUHV
LQWUDKHSDWLFRQHELOLRHQWHULFDQDVWRPRWLFVWULFWXUH $W*'(2%'73$HQKDQFHG
05&ZKHQLQWUDKHSDWLFVWULFWXUHVZHUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDUHDVRIOLYHUSDUHQFK\PD
ZLWKRXW*'(2%'73$H[FUHWLRQIRUGLPLQLVKHGKHSDWRELOLDU\IXQFWLRQFDXVHGE\
ELOLDU\REVWUXFWLRQVWULFWXUHVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGUHOHYDQW,QRQHFDVHGLODWDWLRQRI
XSVWUHDP ELOLDU\ WUHH DQG ODFN RI *'(2%'73$ H[FUHWLRQ LQWR WKH ELOLRHQWHULF
DQDVWRPRVHVZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKELOLRHQWHULF DQDVWRPRWLFVWULFWXUH+%6FRQ
ÀUPHG DUHDV RI OLYHU SDUHQFK\PD ZLWK XQKRPRJHQHRXV DQG GHOD\HG XSWDNH RI
UDGLRWUDFHUDVGHSLFWHGDW05&$OOLQWUDKHSDWLFVWULFWXUHVGHWHFWHGDW*'(2%
'73$HQKDQFHG 05& ZHUH FRQÀUPHG DW 37& 7KUHH LQWUDKHSDWLF VWULFWXUHV
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKSDUHQFK\PDODUHDVRIQR*'(2%'73$H[FUHWLRQZHUHWUHDWHG
ZLWK37&ZLWKQRUPDOLVDWLRQRIELOLDU\WUHH2QHELOLRHQWHULFDQDVWRPRWLFVWULFWXUH
UHFHLYHGQRFRQÀUPDWLRQDW+%6
&RQFOXVLRQ*'(2%'73$HQKDQFHG05&LVDXVHIXOWHFKQLTXHLQWKHHYDOXD
WLRQRIELOLDU\VWULFWXUHVDIWHU2/7DVLWDOORZVWKHVHOHFWLRQRIVWULFWXUHVDVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKDEQRUPDOSDUHQFK\PDOIXQFWLRQ
%
8OWUDVRXQGVFRULQJV\VWHPIRUSUHRSHUDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRI
FKROHOLWKLDVLVKRZDFFXUDWHLWLVIRUSUHRSHUDWLYHSUHGLFWLRQRI
GLIÀFXOWODSDURVFRSLFFKROHF\VWHFWRP\
0$6LGGLTXL,$KPDG6$$5L]YL(8OODK$OLJDUK,1
GUD]IDUVLGGLTXL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH/DSDURVFRSLFFKROHF\VWHFWRP\ /& KDVEHFRPHWUHDWPHQWRIFKRLFH
IRU FKROHOLWKLDVLV EXW WKHUH DUH VWLOO VRPH SDWLHQWV UHTXLULQJ FRQYHUVLRQ WR RSHQ
FKROHF\VWHFWRP\ 2& PDLQO\ EHFDXVH RI WHFKQLFDO GLIÀFXOW\ 2XU DLP ZDV WR
GHYHORSDVWDQGDUGLVHGXOWUDVRXQGEDVHGVFRULQJV\VWHPIRUSUHRSHUDWLYHSUHGLF
WLRQRIGLIÀFXOW/&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8OWUDVRXQGÀQGLQJVRISDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQW/&
ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHG)RXUSDUDPHWHUV WLPHWDNHQELOLDU\OHDNDJHLQMXU\
WRGXFWRUDUWHU\DQGFRQYHUVLRQWR2& ZHUHDQDO\VHGWRFODVVLI\/&DVHDV\RU
GLIÀFXOW8OWUDVRXQGÀQGLQJVZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWKHPSKDVLVRQ*%ZDOOWKLFNQHVV
SHULFKROHF\VWLFFROOHFWLRQGLVWHQGHG*%LPSDFWHGVWRQHVPXOWLSOHVWRQHV&%'
GLDPHWHUDQGOLYHUVL]H$VFRUHRIWZRZDVDVVLJQHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIHDFKÀQGLQJ
ZLWKDWRWDOVFRUHRI$FXWRIIYDOXHRIZDVWDNHQWRSUHGLFWHDV\DQGGLIÀFXOW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ODSDURVFRSLFFKROHF\VWHFWRP\6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DORQJZLWKSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXHVIRUSUHGLFWLQJHDV\DQGGLIÀFXOWFDVHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWVRXWRIFDVHVRIGLIÀFXOW/&DQGRXWRIFDVHVRIHDV\/&
ZHUHFRUUHFWO\SUHGLFWHGRQWKHEDVLVRIWKLVVFRULQJV\VWHP$VFRUHRIKDGD
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUFRUUHFWO\LGHQWLI\LQJGLIÀFXOW/&3UHGLF
WLRQFDPHWUXHLQIRUHDV\DQGGLIÀFXOWFDVHV8OWUDVRXQGÀQGLQJVRI
*%ZDOOWKLFNQHVVGLVWHQGHG*%LPSDFWHGVWRQHVDQGGLODWHG&%'ZHUHIRXQG
VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVFRULQJV\VWHPLVYHU\HIIHFWLYHLQSUHGLFWLQJFRQYHUVLRQULVNRI
/&WR2&3DWLHQWVKDYLQJKLJKULVNPD\EHLQIRUPHGDQGVFKHGXOHGDSSURSULDWHO\
%
%
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHKHSDWRELOLDU\H[FUHWLRQRI*G(2%'73$LQWRGLIIHUHQWVHJ
PHQWVRIWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\V\VWHPLQSDWLHQWVZLWK36&DQGWRDVVHVVSRVVLEOH
FRUUHODWLRQZLWKOLYHUIXQFWLRQWHVWV /)7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDV,5%DSSURYHGSDWLHQWV
IHPDOHVPDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV ZLWKFRQÀUPHGGLDJQRVLVRI36&
ZKRXQGHUZHQWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGKHSDWLF05,DIWHULQMHFWLRQRIP/NJERG\
ZHLJKWZHUHLQFOXGHG'HOD\HGSKDVHLPDJHVDFTXLUHGEHWZHHQDQGPLQXWHV
DIWHUFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIFRQWUDVWDJHQWLQWKH
LQWUDKHSDWLFELOHGXFWV ,%' FRPPRQELOHGXFW &%' JDOOEODGGHUDQGGXRGHQXP
$.UXVNDO:DOOLVWHVWZDVSHUIRUPHGWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUH[FUHWLRQZDVDIIHFWHG
E\/)7+HSDWRELOLDU\H[FUHWLRQZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKGDWDFROOHFWHGLQDSUHYLRXV
VWXG\IURPSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWOLYHUGLVHDVHE\PHDQVRID0DQQ:KLWQH\8WHVW
5HVXOWVPLQXWHVDIWHUFRQWUDVWLQLWLDWLRQ*G(2%'73$FRXOGEHGHWHFWHGLQWKH
,%'LQ&%'LQJDOOEODGGHULQGXRGHQXPLQUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQWUDVWH[FUHWLRQLQWRWKH,%'&%'DQGJDOOEODGGHUZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\DIIHFWHG
E\VHUXPELOLUXELQOHYHOVEXWQRWE\DONDOLQHSKRVSKDWDVHќJOXWDP\OWUDQVIHUDVH
SDWLHQWVH[RUDJH
&RQFOXVLRQ &RQWUDVW H[FUHWLRQ LQWR DOO KHSDWRELOLDU\ VHJPHQWV LV VLJQLÀFDQWO\
UHGXFHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWK36&FRPSDUHGWRSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWOLYHUGLVHDVHDQGLV
IXUWKHUGHSHQGHQWRQVHUXPELOLUXELQOHYHO:LWKLQPLQXWHVSRVWFRQWUDVWLQLWLDWLRQ
*G(2%'73$FDQEHH[SHFWHGLQWKH,%'DQG&%'LQRQO\DERXWRISDWLHQWV
'HOD\HGSKDVHLPDJLQJWKHUHIRUHQHHGVWREHFDUULHGRXWVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORQJHULQ
36&SDWLHQWVLQRUGHUWRDVVHVVIXQFWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQ
3XUSRVH'HYHORSLQJLQYLYRPROHFXODU05,IRUGHWHFWLQJHVWURJHQUHFHSWRU (5
H[SUHVVLRQLQDEUHDVWFDQFHUDQLPDOPRGHOXWLOLVLQJDQRYHO(5WDUJHWHGFRQWUDVW
DJHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(5WDUJHWHGFRQWUDVWDJHQWEDVHGRQS\ULGLQLXPWHWUD
DFHWDH*G ,,, FKHODWH 37$*G FRQMXJDWHG WR ћHVWUDGLRO (37$*G ZDV
V\QWKHVLVHGDQGFKDUDFWHULVHGLQVROXWLRQDQGLQVWDEO\WUDQVIHFWHGZLWK(5 (5
SRVLWLYH DQGZLOGW\SH0'$0% (5QHJDWLYH KXPDQEUHDVWFDQFHUFHOOVDV
ZHOODVWXPRXUVLPSODQWHGRUWKRWRSLFDOO\LQWKHVDPHPRXVH,QYLYRSKDUPDFRNL
QHWLFVDQG'&(05,VWXGLHVZHUHFRQGXFWHGRQ7VFDQQHU,PDJHSURFHVVLQJ
LQFOXGHGPRGHOEDVHGDQGPRGHOIUHHDQDO\VHV
5HVXOWV7KHDIÀQLW\RI(37$*GWR(5ZDVIRXQGWREHLQWKHPLFURPRODUUDQJH
7KH7UHOD[LYLW\LQVROXWLRQZDV P0V DQGLQFUHDVHGWR P0V
LQ(5SRVLWLYHEUHDVWFDQFHUFHOOV,QYLYR'&(05,XVLQJDORZGRVHRI(37$*G
PPRONJ GHPRQVWUDWHGKLJKHQKDQFHPHQWLQ(5SRVLWLYHEUHDVWFDQFHU
WXPRXUVDVFRPSDUHGWRWKHHQKDQFHPHQWLQ(5QHJDWLYHWXPRXUVDQGLQQRUPDO
PXVFOHWLVVXH,QFRQWUDVWERWKWXPRXUVVKRZHGVLPLODUHQKDQFHPHQWDQGKHQFH
YDVFXODUSHUIXVLRQLQ'&(RIQRQWDUJHWHGGLIIXVLEOHFRQWUDVWDJHQW *G'73$DQG
37$*G )XUWKHUPRUHVSHFLÀFLQWHUDFWLRQRI(37$*GZLWK(5ZDVYDOLGDWHGE\
LQYLYRFRPSHWLWLRQ'&(05,H[SHULPHQWVZLWKWDPR[LIHQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVLQWKHEUHDVWFDQFHUDQLPDOPRGHOSURYLGHDSURRIRISULQ
FLSOHRIWKHDELOLW\RI(37$*GWREHWDUJHWHGLQYLYRWR(5DQGLGHQWLI\(5SRVLWLYH
WXPRXUV,QDGGLWLRQWKHVHUHVXOWVSURYLGHDEDVLVIRUWKHFOLQLFDOWUDQVODWLRQDVD
PHDQVIRUGHWHFWLQJORFDOLVLQJDQGPRQLWRULQJ(5QRQLQYDVLYHO\
%
%
6HFUHWLQVWLPXODWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHFKRODQJLR
SDQFUHDWLFRJUDSK\VDIHW\UHOLDELOLW\DQGDVVHVVPHQWRISDQFUHDWLF
H[RFULQHIXQFWLRQ
30HVVQHU-3.XHKQ7,WWHUPDQQ%0HQVHO.+HJHQVFKHLG+9RHO]NH
-0D\HUOH1+RVWHQ53XOV*UHLIVZDOG'( SKLOVHEDPHV#\DKRRGH
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHVDIHW\UHOLDELOLW\RIVHFUHWLQVWLPXODWHGPDJQHWLFUHV
RQDQFHFKRODQJLRSDQFUHDWLFRJUDSK\ 6605&3 DQGDVVHVVPHQWRISDQFUHDWLF
H[RFULQHIXQFWLRQ 3() LQYROXQWHHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\ZDV,5%DSSURYHGYROXQWHHUV PHQ
PHDQDJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQWQDYLJDWRUWULJJHUHG7ZHLJKWHG'05&3V
EHIRUHDQGDIWHUVHFUHWLQVWLPXODWLRQ 8(NJ%: XVLQJD705V\VWHP $YDQWR
6LHPHQV 7KHPHDQWLPHEHWZHHQLQWUDYHQRXVVHFUHWLQLQMHFWLRQDQGWKH6605&3
ZDVPLQ)RUKRXUVDIWHULQMHFWLRQRIVHFUHWLQDGYHUVHUHDFWLRQVZHUH
HYDOXDWHG,PSURYHPHQWRIGXFWYLVXDOLVDWLRQDIWHUVHFUHWLQVWLPXODWLRQZDVREVHUYHG
E\ WZR UHDGHUV UU VXEMHFWLYHO\ DQG TXDQWLWDWLYHO\ WKURXJK PHDVXUHPHQW RI
GXFWVL]HGLDPHWHUV3()ZDVDVVHVVHGVXEMHFWLYHO\XVLQJ0DWRVFULWHULD VE\WZR
UHDGHUVDQGTXDQWLÀHGZLWKFDOLEUDWHGYROXPHWULFPHDVXUHPHQWRIWRWDOH[FUHWHG
YROXPH 7(9 DQGSDQFUHDWLFÁRZRXWSXW 3)2
5HVXOWV0LQRUDGYHUVHUHDFWLRQVZHUHREVHUYHGLQRQO\FDVHV FRQVLVWLQJ
RIÁXVKLQJDQGQRPDMRUUHDFWLRQVZHUHREVHUYHG6XEMHFWLYHO\GXFWYLVXDOLVD
WLRQDIWHUVHFUHWLQVWLPXODWLRQZDVLPSURYHGLQUUXQFKDQJHGLQUU
DQG ZRUVH LQ UU LQWHUUDWHUDJUHHPHQW NDSSD 'XFW
GLDPHWHUVLQFUHDVHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\DIWHUVHFUHWLQVWLPXODWLRQ KHDGPPERG\
PPWDLOPPS 3()HYDOXDWHGXVLQJ0DWRVFULWHULDҋVZDV
UHVWULFWHGLQ0DWRVUU0DWRVUU0DWRVUUDQG
0DWRVUU NDSSD 7KHPHDQ7(9ZDVPODQGWKH
PHDQ3)2ZDVPOPLQXWH$FFRUGLQJWRWKHWLPHQRUPDOYDOXHVRI7(9
3)2ZHUHUHJUHVVHGWRDORJDULWKPLFIXQFWLRQ 57(9 53)2
&RQFOXVLRQ6605&3SURYLGHVDQLPSURYHPHQWLQPDLQSDQFUHDWLFGXFWYLVXDOL
VDWLRQDQGDQRQLQYDVLYHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRI3()ZLWKQHJOLJLEOHULVNRIVLGHHIIHFWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
66
$GYDQFHGWRSLFV
0RGHUDWRUV
,&DUULy%DUFHORQD(6
7'+HQQLQJ&RORJQH'(
,QYLYRPROHFXODU05,RIWKHHVWURJHQUHFHSWRULQEUHDVWFDQFHU
XVLQJDWDUJHWHGFRQWUDVWDJHQW
$3DLV50DUJDOLW,(%LWRQ$<RVHSRYLWFK+'HJDQL5HKRYRW,/
7HO+DVRPHU,/ $GLSDLV#ZHL]PDQQDFLO
3(7LPDJLQJRIWKHUDS\LQGXFHGSURVWDWHFDQFHUFHOOGHDWKE\
WDUJHWLQJWKHLQWHUQDOHSLWRSHRISURVWDWHVSHFLÀFPHPEUDQHDQWLJHQ
$5XJJLHUR-3+ROODQG7+XGROLQ-6/HZLV-*ULPP5RWWHUGDP1/
1HZ<RUN1<86 DUXJJLHUR#HUDVPXVPFQO
3XUSRVH:HUHSRUWWKHSUHSDUDWLRQDQGXVHRI=UGHVIHUULR[DPLQH% ')2
( D QRYHO =UODEHOHG PRQRFORQDO DQWLERG\ P$E FRQVWUXFW IRU WDUJHWHG
LPPXQRSRVLWURQ HPLVVLRQ WRPRJUDSK\ RI SURVWDWHVSHFLÀF PHPEUDQH DQWLJHQ
360$ DSURWRW\SLFDOFHOOVXUIDFHPDUNHUKLJKO\RYHUH[SUHVVHGLQSURVWDWHFDQFHU
3& :HSUHVHQWDQDSSURDFKWRPRQLWRU3&WKHUDS\XVLQJWKH=U')2(DV
DPDUNHURIUHVSRQVH(UHFRJQLVHVDQLQWUDFHOOXODUHSLWRSHRI360$DQGWKXV
FDQRQO\ELQGLWVFRJQDWHDQWLJHQLFHSLWRSHZKHQWKHFHOOPHPEUDQHLVGLVUXSWHG
DVLQGHDGRUG\LQJFHOOV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ( DV D PDUNHU RI G\LQJ FHOOV ZDV VWXGLHG E\ ÁRZ
F\WRPHWU\DQGPLFURVFRS\RIFHOOVDIWHUDQWLDQGURJHQUDGLRDQGFKHPRWKHUDS\
WUHDWPHQW LQ /1&D3 DQG 3&360$ SRVLWLYH FHOOV 7KH LQ YLYR EHKDYLRXU RI
=U')2( ZDV FKDUDFWHULVHG LQ PLFH EHDULQJ VXEFXWDQHRXV /1&D3
360$SRVLWLYH E\ELRGLVWULEXWLRQVWXGLHVLPPXQR3(7DQGRSWLFDOLPDJLQJ7KH
SRWHQWLDORIDVVHVVLQJWXPRXUUHVSRQVHZDVHYDOXDWHGLQYLYRDIWHUUDGLRWKHUDS\
DQGFKHPRWKHUDS\WUHDWPHQW
5HVXOWV ,Q YLWUR VWXGLHV FRUUHODWHG ( ELQGLQJ ZLWK PDUNHUV RI QHFURVLV
DSRSWRVLV ,Q YLYR ELRGLVWULEXWLRQ H[SHULPHQWV UHYHDOHG KLJK WDUJHWVSHFLILF
XSWDNHRI=U')2(LQ/1&D3WXPRXUVDIWHUK ,'J
K ,'J K ,'J DQG K ,'J
([FHOOHQWLPDJHFRQWUDVWZDVREVHUYHGZLWKLPPXQR3(7(XSWDNHZDVVWD
WLVWLFDOO\LQFUHDVHGLQWUHDWHGYHUVXVFRQWUROWXPRXUDVPHDVXUHGE\LPPXQR3(7
DQGELRGLVWULEXWLRQVWXGLHV%ORFNLQJVWXGLHVDWKFRQÀUPHGELQGLQJVSHFLÀFLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ=U')2(GLVSOD\VKLJKWXPRXUWREDFNJURXQGWLVVXHFRQWUDVW
LQ LPPXQR3(7 DQG FDQ EH XVHG DV D WRRO WR PRQLWRU WKH WXPRXU UHVSRQVH LQ
360$SRVLWLYH3&
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
+HSDWRELOLDU\H[FUHWLRQRIJDGR[HWDWHGLVRGLXP 3ULPRYLVW LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\VFOHURVLQJFKRODQJLWLV 36&
.,5LQJH-+LQULFKV(00HUNOH):DFNHU%&0H\HU+DQQRYHU'(
'XUKDP1&86 ULQJHNULVWLQD#PKKDQQRYHUGH
5RRP/0
0ROHFXODU,PDJLQJ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWH$QQH[LQ9WDUJHWHGPROHFXODULPDJLQJRIFDUGLRP\RF\WH
DSRSWRVLVLQWKHHDUO\FRXUVHDIWHUPXULQHP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV0\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQ 0, ZDVLQGXFHGLQ&%/-PLFH
E\PLQXWHVOLJDWLRQRIWKHOHIWDQWHULRUGHVFHQGLQJDUWHU\ /$' ZLWKVXEVHTXHQW
UHSHUIXVLRQ0LFHZHUHLQMHFWHGZLWKWKH$QQH[LQ9WDUJHWHGPROHFXODULPDJLQJ
SUREH$QQH[LQ9LYRKRXUVSULRUWRLPDJLQJ$GGLWLRQDOO\PLFHZHUHLQMHFWHG
ZLWKDORQJFLUFXODWLQJLRGLQHEDVHGFRQWUDVWDJHQW ([LWURQ SULRUWRLPDJ
LQJIRUEHWWHUYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIFDUGLDFDQDWRP\ZLWKVXEVHTXHQWIDFLOLWDWHGRUJDQ
VHJPHQWDWLRQ+\EULG)07;&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGKRXUVKRXUVDQGGD\VDIWHU
LQGXFWLRQRILVFKDHPLFLQMXU\0ROHFXODULPDJLQJVLJQDOIRU$QQH[LQ9LYRZDV
YDOLGDWHGE\H[YLYRLPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLVWU\DQGÁRZF\WRPHWU\
5HVXOWV 6XFFHVVIXO LPDJH DFTXLVLWLRQ RI ERWK )07 DQG &7 DQJLRJUDSK\ ZDV
DFKLHYHG LQ DOO PLFH 0ROHFXODU LPDJLQJ VLJQDO IRU$QQH[LQ9LYR FRXOG EH
ORFDOLVHGWRWKHDQWHULRUODWHUDOZDOORIWKHOHIWYHQWULFOHDWWKHVLWHRIP\RFDUGLDO
LQIDUFWLRQ)07VLJQDOIRU$QQH[LQ9SHDNHGDWKRXUVDIWHUP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQ
ZLWKVXEVHTXHQWGHFUHDVHDWKRXUVDQGGD\VDIWHURQVHWRILVFKDHPLFLQMXU\
)07VLJQDOIRU$QQH[LQ9FRORFDOLVHGZLWKDSRSWRVLVVWDLQLQJ &DVSDVH XVLQJ
LPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLVWU\DQGÁRZF\WRPHWU\+\EULGDFTXLVLWLRQRI[UD\FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\DOORZVH[DFWORFDOLVDWLRQRIWKH)07VLJQDOWRWKHOHIWYHQWULFOHDQG
IDFLOLWDWHVRUJDQVHJPHQWDWLRQDQGDWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ+\EULG)07;&7WDUJHWLQJ$QQH[LQ9HQDEOHVDFFXUDWHLQYLYRDV
VHVVPHQWRIDSRSWRVLVLQWKHHDUO\FRXUVHDIWHUP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQLQDPXULQH
LVFKDHPLDUHSHUIXVLRQPRGHO
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHLIPXOWLSDUDPHWULFDVVHVVPHQWRIEUHDVWOHVLRQVZLWKSURWRQ
05 VSHFWURVFRS\ '+056, GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG 05 LPDJLQJ ':, DQG
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG &(05, REYLDWHVXQQHFHVVDU\EUHDVWELRSVLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKEUHDVWOHVLRQVGHWHFWHGE\PDPPRJUD
SK\RUXOWUDVRXQGDQGFODVVLÀHGDV%,5$'6ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLV,5%DSSURYHG
SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGPXOWLSDUDPHWULF05,RIWKHEUHDVW
DW705,SURWRFROLQFOXGHG'+056,EHIRUHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWDJHQWWR
DYRLGFRQWDPLQDWLRQRIVSHFWUDD':,D7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHDQGDFRPELQHG
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGKLJKWHPSRUDODQGVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ'7ZVHTXHQFHEHIRUH
DQGDIWHUDSSOLFDWLRQRIDVWDQGDUGGRVH*G'27$05,ZDVDVVHVVHGIRUOHVLRQ
PRUSKRORJ\DQG(+NLQHWLFVDFFRUGLQJWRWKH%,5$'6FODVVLÀFDWLRQUHVWULFWHGGLI
IXVLYLW\DQGLQFUHDVHG&KROLQH &KR OHYHOV$Q$'&WKUHVKROG[PPV
DQGDVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRRIWKH&KRUHVRQDQFHSHDN!ZHUHGHÀQHGDVD
PDUNHURIPDOLJQDQF\$SUHGHÀQHGHYDOXDWLRQDOJRULWKPZDVXVHGIRUDVVLJQPHQW
RIDÀQDO%,5$'6FODVVLÀFDWLRQ$OOOHVLRQVZHUHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\YHULÀHG
5HVXOWV'+056,KDGDVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGDVSHFLÀFLW\RI':,KDG
DVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGDVSHFLÀFLW\RI&(05,GHPRQVWUDWHGDVHQVLWLYLW\
RI DQG D VSHFLÀFLW\ RI 0XOWLSDUDPHWULF 05, LQFUHDVHG VHQVLWLYLW\ WR
VSHFLÀFLW\WRDQGKDGDYHU\JRRGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI%UHDVW
ELRSVLHVFRXOGKDYHEHHQREYLDWHGLQRIEHQLJQOHVLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ0XOWLSDUDPHWULF05,RIWKHEUHDVWDW7LPSURYHVGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEH
WZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWEUHDVWOHVLRQVREYLDWLQJXQQHFHVVDU\EUHDVWELRSVLHV
0ROHFXODULPDJLQJRIDSRSWRVLVLQWKHHDUO\FRXUVHDIWHUP\RFDUGLDO
LQIDUFWLRQXVLQJK\EULGÁXRUHVFHQFHPROHFXODUWRPRJUDSK\[UD\
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\)07;&7WDUJHWLQJ$QQH[LQ9
0:LOGJUXEHU$$OH..RVDQNH(5XPPHQ\91W]LDFKULVWRV
0XQLFK'( PRULW]ZLOGJUXEHU#WXPGH
%
)LUVWSDUDOOHOVSHFLÀFYLVXDOLVDWLRQRILQÁDPPDWRU\DFWLYLW\DQG
FRQVHFXWLYHGHP\HOLQDWLRQLQH[SHULPHQWDOPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV 06
LQYLYRXVLQJGXDOFKDQQHORSWLFDOPROHFXODULPDJLQJ
0(LVHQEODHWWHU6$OEUHFKW/:DFKVPXWK:+HLQGHO79RJO7.XKOPDQQ
&%UHPHU0QVWHU'( HLVHQEODHWWHU#XQLPXHQVWHUGH
3XUSRVH$PHWKRGIRUFRQWLQXRXVVXUYHLOODQFHRIFHQWUDOQHUYRXVLQÁDPPDWRU\
SURFHVVHVDQGXQGHUO\LQJSDWKRSK\VLRORJ\ZDVGHVLUHGIRUH[DPLQDWLRQRIPXULQH
PRGHOVRIGLVHDVH$FWLYDWHGPDFURSKDJHVKDYHEHHQVKRZQWRSOD\DFUXFLDOUROH
LQLQLWLDOLVDWLRQDQGPDLQWHQDQFHRILQÁDPPDWLRQ3UHYLRXVZRUNSURYHGH[SUHV
VLRQRIPDFURSKDJHUHODWHGSURWHLQ6$WREHFRUUHODWHGZLWKORFDOGLVHDVH
DFWLYLW\ DQG RSWLFDO LPDJLQJ 2, RI 6$ KDV VXFFHVVIXOO\ EHHQ SHUIRUPHG
1HDULQIUDUHG ÁXRUHVFHQW ҋGLHWK\OWKLDWULFDUERF\DQLQHLRGLGH '%7 KDV EHHQ
VKRZQWRVHOHFWLYHO\ELQGP\HOLQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV06HTXLYDOHQWOHVLRQVZHUHLQGXFHGLQ&%/PLFHE\
&XSUL]RQDSSOLFDWLRQRYHUGD\V+HDOWK\PLFHVHUYHGDVFRQWURO$QWL6$
RU,PPXQRJOREXOLQ* ,J*FRQWUROIRUQRQVSHFLÀFODEHOGLVWULEXWLRQ ZHUHODEHOOHG
ZLWK&\IRU2,7UDFHUGRVHVSHUDQLPDOZHUHJDQWL6$&\K
DQGJ'%7PLQSULRUWRÁXRUHVFHQFHPHGLDWHGWRPRJUDSK\ZLWKH[FLWDWLRQ
HPLVVLRQRIQP &\ DQGQP '%7 )RUFRUUHODWLRQRILQYLYR
2,PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHWRPRJUDSK\ 05, IRUOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQDQGLPPXQRKLVWR
FKHPLVWU\ZHUHSHUIRUPHG6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVVWXGHQWWWHVW
5HVXOWV,Q&XSUL]RQWUHDWHGDQLPDOVLQMHFWLRQRIDQWL6$&\UHVXOWHGLQ
WKUHHIROGKLJKHUWUDFHUDFFXPXODWLRQWKDQLQKHDOWK\DQLPDOV SPROYVSPRO
S ZKHUHDVXQVSHFLÀF,J*&\DFFXPXODWHGWRDVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUVFDOH
SPROYVSPROS 0\HOLQDVVRFLDWHG'%7DFFXPXODWLRQGURSSHGIURP
SPRO KHDOWK\ WRSPRO &XSUL]RQ UHÁHFWLQJVLJQLÀFDQWGHP\HOLQDWLRQ)RU
DOOPHDVXUHPHQWVD52,DQDO\VLVRIWKHFRUSXVFDOORVXPUHJLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
ZKHUHKLVWRORJ\DQG05,SURYHGOHVLRQORFDWLRQDQGVHYHULW\DVGHSLFWHGE\2,
&RQFOXVLRQ$QWL6$&\LQFRPELQDWLRQZLWK'%7PD\VHUYHIRUVSHFLÀF
YLVXDOLVDWLRQRIFHQWUDOQHUYRXVLQÁDPPDWLRQOLNH06DQGDOORZVIRUJUDGLQJDF
FRUGLQJWRLPPXQHFHOODFWLYLW\DQGGHP\HOLQDWLRQ
&DQPROHFXODULPDJLQJRIEUHDVWWXPRXUVZLWKKLJKÀHOG
PXWOLSDUDPHWULF05,REYLDWHXQQHFHVVDU\EUHDVWELRSVLHV"
.3LQNHU'RPHQLJ+%LFNHO+0DJRPHWVFKQLJJ%%UXHFN6*UXEHU
:%RJQHU06FKHUQWKDQHU'%HU]DF]\7++HOELFK9LHQQD$7
NDWMDSLQNHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
%
(IIHFWRIF\FORSDPLQHRQ))'*XSWDNHRISDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU
[HQRJUDIVLQQXGHPLFHHYDOXDWLRQE\FOLQLFDOO\LPSOHPHQWHGKLJK
UHVROXWLRQ3(7&7
+.D\HG30H\HU%.UDHQ]OLQ1*UHW]&)LQN626FK|QEHUJ06DGLFN
0DQQKHLP'( KDQ\ND\HG#XPPGH
3XUSRVH :H TXDQWLWDWLYHO\ DQDO\VHG WKH HIIHFWV RI F\FORSDPLQH RQ WKH )
)'*XSWDNHRISDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU[HQRJUDIWV 3&; XVLQJDFOLQLFDOO\LPSOHPHQWHG
3(7&7VFDQQHUZLWKKLJKUHVROXWLRQUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3&;IURPWZRSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUFHOOOLQHVZHUHLQGXFHG
VXEFXWDQHRXVO\LQWKHKLSDQGVKRXOGHURIQXGHPLFH3&;ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKWKH
DQWLKHGJHKRJVLJQDOOLQJDJHQWF\FORSDPLQHLQWUDSHULWRQHDOO\IRURQHZHHN0LFH
ZHUHLQMHFWHGLQWUDYHQRXVO\ZLWK0%T))'*DQGVFDQQHGZLWKDGH
WHFWRUP&7VFDQQHU 6LHPHQV+HDOWKFDUH6HFWRU(UODQJHQ*HUPDQ\ 7RDGDSW
IRUWKHVPDOOVL]HRIPLFHZHFKDQJHGWKH]RRPWRLQVWHDGRIWKHVFDQWLPH
SUREHGSRVLWLRQWRPLQXWHVLQVWHDGRIPLQXWHVDQGZHXVHGPP*DXVVLDQ
)LOWHULQVWHDGRIPP7KHGDWDVHWZDVUHFRQVWUXFWHGDQGTXDQWLÀHGXVLQJWKH
7UXH;DQG7UXH'VRIWZDUHV
5HVXOWV 0LD3D&D FHOOV ZKLFK UHVSRQG WR F\FORSDPLQH VKRZHG GHFUHDVHG
))'*XSWDNH ZLWKRXW FKDQJHV LQ WXPRXU VL]H 7KH KLS WXPRXUV VKRZHG D
UHGXFWLRQRIWKH689PD[E\WKH689DYJE\DQG68
9PLQE\ S 7KHVKRXOGHUWXPRXUVVKRZHGUHGXFWLRQRIWKH
689PD[E\689DYJE\DQG689PLQE\
S &DSDQ FHOOV ZKLFK GR QRW UHVSRQG WR F\FORSDPLQH GLG QRW VKRZ
VLJQLÀFDQW689FKDQJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH FOLQLFDOO\ LPSOHPHQWHG 3(7&7 VFDQQHU ZLWK KLJKUHVROXWLRQ
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ FDQ GHWHFW PLQLPDO FKDQJHV LQ UHVSRQVH WR ORZGRVH VKRUWWHUP
WKHUDS\RISDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU[HQRJUDIWVHYHQZLWKRXWFKDQJHVLQWXPRXUVL]HDQG
WKXVRIIHUVWKHSRWHQWLDOIRUWUDQVODWLRQDOUHVHDUFKLQDQWLWXPRXUWKHUDS\
%
,PSDFWRIQRUPDOWLVVXHXSWDNHXVLQJ*D'27$72&3(7&7LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKQHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUDIROORZXSVWXG\
06WHIDQRYD&.UDWRFKZLO/6FKZDUW]8+DEHUNRUQ)/*LHVHO
6WLS0.+HLGHOEHUJ'(1HZ<RUN1<86 IJLHVHO#GNI]GH
3XUSRVH,PDJLQJZLWKVRPDWRVWDWLQDQDORJXHVVXFKDV*D'27$ 3KH
7\U RFWUHRWLGH '27$72& EHFDPH D VWDQGDUG DSSURDFK IRU VWDJLQJ DQG
UHVWDJLQJ WKH QHXURHQGRFULQH WXPRXUV 7KH DLP RI WKLV VWXG\ LV WR DVVHVV WKH
LPSDFWRIWKHQRUPDOWLVVXHXSWDNHXVLQJ*D'27$72&3(7&7LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
QHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUSULRUDQGDIWHUF\FOHVRISHSWLGHUHFHSWRUUDGLRQXFOLGH
WKHUDS\ 3557 ZLWK<'27$72&DQG/X'27$72&
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
3UHFOLQLFDODVVHVVPHQWRIDQWLDQJLRJHQLFHIIHFWVRQPLFHZLWK
PDPPDU\FDUFLQRPDXVLQJG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPLFUR&7
)(LVD5%UDXZHLOHU0+XSIHU71RZDN5'LWWULFK0:%HFNPDQQ
:$.DOHQGHU(UODQJHQ'( )DELDQ(LVD#LPSXQLHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORILQYLYRG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG '&(
PLFUR&7IRUWKHSUHFOLQLFDODVVHVVPHQWRIDQWLDQJLRJHQLFGUXJWKHUDS\UHVSRQVH
RQPLFHZLWKPDPPDU\FDUFLQRPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$PRQJIHPDOHPLFHZLWKLPSODQWHG0&)WXPRXUVLQ
WKHIRXUWKLQJXLQDOPDPPDU\JODQGZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKDQDQWLDQJLRJHQLFGUXJDQG
VHUYHGDVFRQWUROJURXS)RXUZHHNVDIWHUWXPRXULPSODQWDWLRQDOOPLFHXQGHUZHQW
'&(PLFUR&7 N9$ 7KHVFDQFRQVLVWHGRIJDQWU\URWDWLRQVZLWKD
WRWDOVFDQWLPHRIV2YHUODSSLQJUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKDQLVRWURSLFYR[HO
VL]HRIPZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQVLQWHUYDOV,QD'DQDO\VLVWKHUHODWLYHEORRG
YROXPH U%9 YDVFXODUSHUPHDELOLW\ . DUHDXQGHUWKHWLPHFRQFHQWUDWLRQFXUYH
$8& DQGWKHPRUSKRORJ\RIWKHWXPRXUVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQWKHUDS\DQG
FRQWUROJURXS$OOSDUDPHWHUVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGIRUDWRWDOSHULSKHUDODQGFHQWUDO
WXPRXUYROXPHRILQWHUHVW 92, 0RUHRYHULPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLVWU\ZDVSHUIRUPHG
WRFKDUDFWHULVHWKHWXPRXUYDVFXODULVDWLRQ
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQ$8&V ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU LQ WKHUDS\ ZLWK SYDOXHV RI
DQGIRUWRWDOSHULSKHUDODQGFHQWUDOWXPRXU92,UHVSHFWLYHO\
.DQG U%9VKRZHG VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV IRUWKH SHULSKHUDO 92, S.SHU
SU%9SHU EXW QRW IRU WKH WRWDO DQG FHQWUDO WXPRXU 92,V S.WRWDO
S.FHQWUDO SU%9WRWDO SU%9FHQWUDO 0HDQWXPRXUYROXPHZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\VPDOOHULQWKHUDS\ SLQYLYR SH[YLYR +LVWRORJ\UHYHDOHG
KLJKHUYDVFXODULVDWLRQLQWKHFRQWUROJURXSDQGVKRZHGFHQWUDOWXPRXUQHFURVLV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLV VWXG\ LQGLFDWHV WKH KLJK SRWHQWLDO RI '&( PLFUR&7 IRU HDUO\
LQYLYRDVVHVVPHQWRIDQWLDQJLRJHQLFGUXJWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHLQPLFH
%
&RPSDULVRQRI$'&PHDVXUHPHQWVDQG863,2XSWDNHLQWRGLIIHUHQW
KXPDQ[HQRJUDIWWXPRXUPRGHOVDW705,
15DDEH7(UQVW0+HLQH6&6DOPHQ0.DXO&+DEHUPDQQ*$GDP
+,WWULFK+DPEXUJ'( QUDDEH#XNHXQLKDPEXUJGH
3XUSRVH7KHHYDOXDWLRQRIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWPHDVXUHPHQWV $'&
DVDGLDJQRVWLFPDUNHUIRUWKHXSWDNHRI63,2LQGLIIHUHQWKXPDQ[HQRJUDIWWXPRXU
PRGHOVLQPLFHDW705,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LYHPLFHHDFKZLWKGLIIHUHQWKXPDQ[HQRJUDIWWXPRXUV
2+VPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHU/2;PDOLJQDQWPHODQRPD'8EUHDVWFDQFHU
ZHUHPHDVXUHGRQD7VPDOODQLPDO05VFDQQHU &OLQ6FDQ%UXNHU*HUPDQ\
ZKHUHDVRQHVHUYHGDVFRQWURO QR863,2LQMHFWHG 'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
':, ZDVSHUIRUPHGSULRUWRWKHLQWUDYHQRXVLQMHFWLRQRIJ3(*\ODWHGVXSHU
SDUDPDJQHWLFLURQR[LGHQDQRSDUWLFOHV 863,2FRUHVL]HQP ':,PHDVXUH
PHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGXVLQJVL[GLIIHUHQWEIDFWRUV DQG
VPP $'&PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGWKUHHWLPHVLQDKRPRJHQHRXVDUHD
RIWKHWXPRXU0HDQ$'&YDOXHVRIWXPRXUW\SHVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\FRPSDUHGWR
HDFKRWKHUYLDDQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFH7ZHLJKWHGDQG7 UHOD[RPHWULFVHTXHQFHV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGWRHYDOXDWHWKHXSWDNHRI63,2LQWKHWXPRXUV
5HVXOWV$OOWKUHHWXPRXUW\SHVGLIIHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S LQ$'&YDOXHV LQ
[PPòV ZLWKKLJKHVWYDOXHVLQWKH/2;WXPRXU IROORZHGE\
WKH'8WXPRXU DQGWKH2+WXPRXUPRGHO $Q
LQKRPRJHQHRXVVLJQDODOWHUDWLRQGXHWR63,2XSWDNHRQ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDQG
UHOD[RPHWULFPHDVXUHPHQWVFRXOGRQO\EHGHWHFWHGLQWKH/2;WXPRXU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
&RQFOXVLRQ$'& PHDVXUHPHQWV FDQ KHOS WR GLVWLQJXLVK EHWZHHQ GLIIHUHQW WX
PRXUW\SHVDQGFRXOGVHUYHDVDSURJQRVWLFPDUNHUIRUWKHXSWDNHRIPROHFXOHV
LQWRWXPRXUV
%
&RPSDULVRQRIFRQVHFXWLYHEROXVWUDFNLQJDQGÁDVKUHSOHQLVKPHQW
PHDVXUHPHQWVIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIWLVVXHKDHPRG\QDPLFVXVLQJ
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG &(86 LQDQH[SHULPHQWDOVTXDPRXV
FHOOFDUFLQRPDPRGHO
303DSURWWND0,QJULVFK3=HQJHO&&&\UDQ.1LNRODRX0)5HLVHU
'$&OHYHUW0XQLFK'( SKLOLSSSDSURWWND#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWH´EROXVWUDFNLQJµ %7 DQG´ÁDVKUHSOHQLVKPHQWµ )5 IRUWKH
DVVHVVPHQWRIWLVVXHKDHPRG\QDPLFVE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG &(86 LQ
DQH[SHULPHQWDOVPDOODQLPDOVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPDPRGHO6LQFHWKHXQGHUO\
LQJWLVVXHLVWKHVDPHVWURQJFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQSDUDPHWHURXWFRPHVRIERWK
WHFKQLTXHVDUHH[SHFWHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV+XPDQK\SRSKDU\Q[FDUFLQRPDFHOOVZHUHVXEFXWDQH
RXVO\LQMHFWHGLQWRWKHOHIWÁDQNRIIHPDOHDWK\PLFQXGHUDWV$IWHUGD\VRI
VXEFXWDQHRXVWXPRXUJURZWK%7DQG)5PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQHDFKUDW
DIWHUEROXVLQMHFWLRQRI6RQR9XHYLDWKHODWHUDOWDLOYHLQXVLQJDKLJKHQGXOWUDVRXQG
V\VWHPZLWKD0+]SUREH9LGHRVHTXHQFHVZHUHH[SRUWHGERWKPRGDOLWLHVZHUH
DQDO\VHGZLWK9XH%R[ %UDFFR6XLVVH %7\LHOGVWKHSDUDPHWHUVSHDNHQKDQFH
PHQW 3( DUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& ULVHWLPH 57 PHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 077E
ZDVKLQUDWH ZL5E DQG SHUIXVLRQLQGH[ 3,E )5 \LHOGV UHODWLYHEORRGYROXPH
U%9 077I3,IDQGZL5I
5HVXOWV +LJKO\ VLJQLÀFDQW FRUUHODWLRQV ZHUH REVHUYHG EHWZHHQ U%9 DQG 3(
U S U%9 DQG$8& U S U%9 DQG P77E U
S P77EDQGP77I U S 3,IDQG3( U S 3,
DQG$8& U S DQG3,DQGZL5I U S
&RQFOXVLRQ:KHUHDVEROXVWUDFNLQJFDQEHXVHGLQDZLGHUDQJHRIPRGDOLWLHV
LQFOXGLQJ &(86 &7 DQG 05 )5 DV D WHFKQLTXH IRU WKH DVVHVVPHQW RI WLVVXH
KDHPRG\QDPLFVLVXQLTXHWR&(86$OWKRXJK%7DQG)5\LHOGGLIIHUHQWSDUDP
HWHUVWKHXQGHUO\LQJWLVVXHKDHPRG\QDPLFVDUHHTXDO,QWKLVZRUNZHZHUHDEOH
WRGHPRQVWUDWHVWURQJFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQGLIIHUHQWSDUDPHWHUVRIERWKPRGDOL
WLHVLQDVPDOODQLPDOWXPRXUPRGHOLQGLFDWLQJWKDWÁDVKUHSOHQLVKPHQWLVDYDOLG
DOWHUQDWLYHWRWKHPRUHHVWDEOLVKHGEROXVWUDFNLQJWHFKQLTXH$OWKRXJKWKHODFNRI
DEVROXWHTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVKLQGHUVDGLUHFWFRPSDULVRQRIERWKPRGDOLWLHV
)5DQG%7VKRXOGERWKEHVXLWDEOHIRUDUHODWLYHFRPSDULVRQHJEHWZHHQEDVHOLQH
DQGIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQV
5RRP12
9DVFXODU
66
7KRUDFLFDQGDEGRPLQDODRUWD
0RGHUDWRUV
$0LVKUD1HZ'HOKL,1
,39XOHY%UDWLVODYD6.
%
7ULSKDVLFPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7IRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRILQWUDPXUDO
KDHPDWRPDRIWKHDRUWDDQGWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\
06LPRQ)'UXHVFKOHU$.RYDFV3+XQROG.0D\-%DUNKDXVHQ)9RJW
/XHEHFN'( PDUWLQVLPRQ#XNVKGH
3XUSRVH 7KLV VWXG\ DLPHG WR HYDOXDWH WKH GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ RI D WULSKDVLF
PXOWLGHWHFWRU&7 0'&7 SURWRFROIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIDRUWLFGLVVHFWLRQVLQWUDPXUDO
KDHPDWRPD ,0+ DQGYDVFXODUFRPSOLFDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSLFLRQRIDFXWH
DRUWLFV\QGURPH $$6
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDO :LWKLQ PRQWKV SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW D WULSKDVLF
ZLWKRXW FRQWUDVW DUWHULDO DQG YHQRXV SKDVH 0'&7 RI WKH HQWLUH DRUWD 2QH
PLOOLPHWHUVOLFHVRIDOOGDWDVHWVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWUDGLRORJLVWV
XVLQJPXOWLSODQDUUHIRUPDWLRQVRQDGHGLFDWHGZRUNVWDWLRQ7KHHYDOXDWLRQLQFOXGHG
WKHGHWHFWLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI$$6DVZHOODVWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIFOLQLFDOO\
UHOHYDQWFRQFRPLWDQWYDVFXODUÀQGLQJV)ROORZXS0'&7VFDQVDVZHOODVLQWUD
RSHUDWLYHÀQGLQJVVHUYHGDVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV0'&7FRQÀUPHGWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDQDFXWHDRUWLFV\QGURPHLQSDWLHQWV
FODVVLÀHGDV7\SH$GLVVHFWLRQ Q W\SH%GLVVHFWLRQ Q DQGLQWUDPXUDO
KDHPDWRPD Q 7KHFRQFRPLWDQWUHOHYDQWYDVFXODUÀQGLQJVLQFOXGHGGLVVHF
WLRQRIVXSUDDRUWDOYHVVHOV Q GLVVHFWLRQRIDEGRPLQDOYLVFHUDODUWHULHV Q
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[WHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOFRQÀUPHGPHWDVWDWLF
QHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUVZHUHHQUROOHGLQWKLVVWXG\,QHDFKSDWLHQW*D'27$
72&3(7&7H[DPLQDWLRQVSULRUDQGDIWHUF\FOHVRI3557 PHDQDGPLQLVWHUHG
DFWLYLW\*%T</X ZHUHHYDOXDWHG7KHPD[LPXPVWDQGDUGLVHG
XSWDNHYDOXH 689PD[ RIWKHIROORZLQJQRUPDOWDUJHWWLVVXHVSLWXLWDU\JODQGWK\
URLGJODQGVSOHHQOLYHUEDFNJURXQGKHDGRIWKHSDQFUHDVNLGQH\VDQGVXSUDUHQDO
JODQGVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGSULRUDQGDIWHUWKHUDS\
5HVXOWV689PD[EHIRUHDQGDIWHU3557ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGDVSLWXLWDU\JODQG
WK\URLGJODQG VSOHHQ
OLYHU SDUHQFK\PD KHDG RI WKH SDQFUHDV
NLGQH\V DQGVXSUDUHQDOJODQGV
7KHUHIRUHQRVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHIRXQG
S! IRUDOORUJDQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXSWDNHRI*D'27$72&LQQRUPDOWLVVXHLVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\
DIIHFWHGE\3557'HVSLWHWKHQRQLPSDFWRIQHXURHQGRFULQHVLGHHIIHFWVWKLVPLJKW
DOVREHUHOHYDQWZLWKUHJDUGWRWXPRXUWRQRQWXPRXUUDWLRVIRUIROORZXSDVVHVV
PHQWSDUWLFXODUO\OLYHUSDUHQFK\PDXSWDNHGHPRQVWUDWHGWREHUREXVW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
SHULFDUGLDOHIIXVLRQKDHPDWRPD Q DQGLQWUDPXUDOKDHPDWRPDRIWKHSXOPRQDU\
DUWHULHV Q 7KH,0+RIWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHVZHUHFRPELQHGZLWKDQ,0+
RIWKHDRUWDLQWKUHHDQGDGLVVHFWLRQRIDVFHQGLQJDRUWDLQFDVHV$OOLQWUDPXUDO
KDHPDWRPDZHUHGHWHFWHGDWEHVWRQWKHQRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGVFDQV
&RQFOXVLRQ1RQHQKDQFHG&7VFDQVDUHDSUHUHTXLVLWHIRUWKHDFFXUDWHGHWHF
WLRQRILQWUDPXUDOKDHPDWRPDLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSLFLRQRIDFXWHDRUWLFV\QGURPH
2XU GLUHFWHG DQDO\VLV RI KLJKUHVROXWLRQ 0'&7 VFDQV VKRZHG WKDW LQWUDPXUDO
KDHPDWRPDRIWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\DUHPRUHIUHTXHQWWKDQH[SHFWHG
%
0HDVXULQJDRUWLFDQGSXOPRQDU\WUXQNGLDPHWHUVLQHSLGHPLRORJLF
UHVHDUFKGRZHQHHGJDGROLQLXPDQGRUWKRJRQDOVOLFHV"
%0HQVHO-3.KQ6/DQJQHU1+RVWHQ53XOV
*UHLIVZDOG'( ELUJHUPHQVHO#XQLJUHLIVZDOGGH
3XUSRVH&DUGLRYDVFXODUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJKDVEHFRPHLQFUHDVLQJO\
SRSXODULQSRSXODWLRQEDVHGUHVHDUFK2XUVWXG\HYDOXDWHVWKHYDOLGLW\DQGUHOLDELOLW\
RIPHDVXULQJWKHGLDPHWHUVRIWKHDRUWDDQGSXOPRQDU\WUXQNIURPSODLQD[LDO9,%(
YROXPHLQWHUSRODWHGEUHDWKKROGH[DPLQDWLRQ LPDJHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\LQFOXGHGPDOHVXEMHFWVIURPWKHSRSXODWLRQ
EDVHG6WXG\RI+HDOWKLQ3RPHUDQLD 6+,3 ,QWKHVHVXEMHFWVWKHWKRUDFLFDQG
DEGRPLQDODRUWDDQGSXOPRQDU\WUXQNZHUHLPDJHGDW7HVODXVLQJDSODLQ9,%(
VHTXHQFHDQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ &(05$
'LDPHWHUVZHUHPHDVXUHGDWSUHGHÀQHGDQDWRPLFVLWHVIURPD[LDO9,%(LPDJHV
DQGUHIRUPDWWHGRUWKRJRQDO&(05$LPDJHV7KHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHYDOLGDWHG
XVLQJ3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQDQG%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLV5HOLDELOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHG
XVLQJWKH%ODQG$OWPDQPHWKRG
5HVXOWV&RPSDULVRQRIWKHGLDPHWHUVUHYHDOHGVWURQJFRUUHODWLRQIRUWKHDVFHQGLQJ
DQGGHVFHQGLQJDRUWDZLWKU S DQG S UHVSHFWLYHO\
0RGHUDWHFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGIRUWKHDRUWLFDUFKDQGSXOPRQDU\WUXQNZLWKU
S DQGU S UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHDEGRPLQDODRUWDVKRZHG
VWURQJ FRUUHODWLRQ DV ZHOO ZLWK U S DQG U S IRU
WKH LQIUDGLDSKUDJPDO DQG VXSUDUHQDO DRUWD DQG U S DQG U
S IRUWKHLQIUDUHQDODRUWDDQGDRUWLFELIXUFDWLRQ0HDQELDVZDVOHVVWKDQ
RUHTXDOWRFP OLPLWVRIDJUHHPHQWZHUHOHVVWKDQFP
,QWUDDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVH[FHOOHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ$[LDOPHDVXUHPHQWRIWKHGLDPHWHUVRIWKHWKRUDFRDEGRPLQDODRUWD
DQGSXOPRQDU\WUXQNXVLQJSODLQ9,%(LPDJHVLVKLJKO\YDOLGDQGUHOLDEOH
%
,QWUDREVHUYHUDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\RI&7EDVHGYROXPHWU\
DQGGLDPHWHUPHDVXUHPHQWVRIDEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VPVDIWHU
HQGRYDVFXODUDQHXU\VPUHSDLU
:+6RPPHU0+DDFN)0HLQHO0)5HLVHU5:HLGHQKDJHQ
0XQLFK'( ZLHODQGVRPPHU#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH PRVW UHSURGXFLEOH DQG VXLWDEOH PHDVXUHPHQWV IRU
FKDQJHV RI DEGRPLQDO DRUWLF DQHXU\VPV DIWHU HQGRYDVFXODU DQHXU\VP UHSDLU
(9$5
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVVXFFHVVIXOO\WUHDWHGE\(9$5
XQGHUZHQW URZ IROORZXS &7$ LQ PP FROOLPDWLRQ 0DQXDO GLDPHWHU DQG
YROXPHWULFPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGWZLFHE\WZREOLQGHGDQGH[SHULHQFHG
UHDGHUVZLWKDWOHDVWDZHHNLQWHUYDOEHWZHHQUHDGLQJV0D[LPXPD[LDODQGRU
WKRJRQDODRUWLFGLDPHWHUVDVZHOODVYROXPHWU\RIWKHDEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VP
ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJ2VLUL[VRIWZDUH,QWUDDQGLQWHUUHDGHUYDULDELOLWLHVZHUHGHWHU
PLQHGE\FRQFRUGDQFHFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV &&& 0HDQWLPHIRUVHPLDXWRPDWHG
YROXPHWU\RIWKHDRUWLFDQHXU\VPDQGIRUGLDPHWHUPHDVXUHPHQWVZDVUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV,QWHUUHDGHUDJUHHPHQWZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUIRUYROXPHWU\ &&&
&, WKDQIRUWKHD[LDOGLDPHWHU &&& &,
DQG WKH RUWKRJRQDO GLDPHWHU PHDVXUHPHQW &&& &,
S %RWKIRUUHDGHUVDQGLQWUDUHDGHUDJUHHPHQWZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
IRU YROXPHWU\ &&& &, FRPSDUHG WR WKH RUWKRJRQDO
GLDPHWHU &&& &, DQGWKHD[LDOGLDPHWHU &&&
&, 7KHPHDQWLPHIRUDRUWLFYROXPHWU\ZDVPLQZKLOH
LWZDVPLQDQGPLQIRURUWKRJRQDODQGD[LDODRUWLFGLDPHWHUUH
VSHFWLYHO\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHOLDELOLW\RIDQHXU\VPDOYROXPHWU\XVLQJ&7$LVH[FHOOHQWIRUVH
ULDOPHDVXUHPHQWVE\LQGLYLGXDOUHDGHUVDQGEHWZHHQGLIIHUHQWUHDGHUV$OWKRXJK
LWLVWLPHFRQVXPLQJWKLVPHWKRGLVWKHPRVWVXLWDEOHWRGHWHFWVPDOOFKDQJHVLQ
DQHXU\VPDOVL]H
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
6FUHHQLQJIRUDRUWLFURRWDQHXU\VPVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGRU
NQRZQ0DUIDQV\QGURPHLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOFRPSDULVRQRIHQKDQFHG
DQGXQHQKDQFHG05DQJLRJUDSK\ZLWKHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\
3%DQQDV0*URWK05\EF]\QVNL66KHLNK]DGHK
<YRQ.RGROLWVFK-*UDVVQHU*/XQG*$GDP&+DEHUPDQQ
+DPEXUJ'( SEDQQDV#XNHGH
3XUSRVH3DWLHQWVZLWK0DUIDQV\QGURPHKDYHWREHVFUHHQHGIRULQLWLDODVVHVVPHQW
DQGIROORZXSRIDRUWLFURRWGLODWDWLRQ2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRHYDOXDWHLQWUDLQGLYLGX
DOO\WKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIXQHQKDQFHG '66)305$ ZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG '
&(05$ PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\IRUDRUWLFURRWGLDPHWHUPHDVXUHPHQWV
DQGWRFRPSDUHWKHUHVXOWVZLWKURXWLQHO\SHUIRUPHGHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\LQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK0DUIDQV\QGURPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$RUWLFURRWVZHUHH[DPLQHGSURVSHFWLYHO\LQFRQVHFX
WLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGRUNQRZQ0DUIDQV\QGURPHXVLQJD'66)305$
DQGD'&(05$DW7HVOD7ZRUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\PHDVXUHGDRUWLFURRW
GLDPHWHUV DW WKH DQQXOXV VLQXVHV RI 9DOVDOYD DQG VLQXWXEXODU MXQFWLRQ LQ ERWK
GDWDVHWVDQGFRPSDUHGUHVXOWVZLWKHFKRFDUGLRJUDSKLFGDWD,QWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQW3HDUVRQҋVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW%ODQG$OWPDQDQGWZRVLGHGWWHVW
ZHUHXVHGWRDVVHVVDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQREVHUYHUVDQGPHWKRGV
5HVXOWV RIWKHLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUV KDG
0DUIDQV\QGURPHWKHUHPDLQLQJZHUHKHDOWK\LQGLYLGXDOV %RWK66)3
05$DQG&(05$PHDVXUHPHQWVRIWKHVLQXVHVRI9DOVDOYDUHYHDOHGDVWURQJ
FRUUHODWLRQZLWKHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ U DQGU UHVSHFWLYHO\ ,QWUDFODVV
FRUUHODWLRQZDVPDUNHGO\EHWWHUIRU66)305$ U ZKHQFRPSDUHGWR&(
05$ U ,PDJHTXDOLW\DVZHOODVLQWUDDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWRI
PHDVXUHPHQWVRIWKHVLQXVHVRI9DOVDOYDZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUIRU66)305$
WKDQIRU&(05$
&RQFOXVLRQ'66)305$PHDVXUHPHQWVRIWKHDRUWLFURRWDUHVXSHULRUWR'
&(05$PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGVKRXOGEHXVHGIRUHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDRUWLF
LQYROYHPHQWLQ0DUIDQV\QGURPHDQGPRQLWRULQJWKHFRXUVHRIDRUWLFHQODUJHPHQW
%
)HDVLELOLW\RIWLPHUHVROYHG05DQJLRJUDSK\ZLWKLQWHUOHDYHG
VWRFKDVWLFWUDMHFWRULHV 7:,67 IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIWKRUDFLFRXWOHW
V\QGURPH
7&/DXHQVWHLQ/8PXWOX$)LVFKHU&.ORHWHUV$4XLQVWHQ6.LQQHU
(VVHQ'( WKRPDVODXHQVWHLQ#XQLGXHGH
3XUSRVH7KHWKRUDFLFRXWOHWV\QGURPH 726 LVGHÀQHGDVDSRVLWLRQDOFRPSUHV
VLRQRIWKHYHUWHEUDODQGVXEFODYLDQDUWHU\726FDQEHGLDJQRVHGE\PDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFH DQJLRJUDSK\ 05$ LQ FRQMXQFWLRQ ZLWK SRVWXUDO PDQRHXYUHV 7KLV
WHFKQLTXHUHTXLUHVKLJKDPRXQWVRIJDGROLQLXPDQGH[DFWWLPLQJRIFRQWUDVWGHOD\V
$QHZWLPHUHVROYHG05$WHFKQLTXH 7:,67 FRPELQHVSDUDOOHOLPDJLQJZLWKD
'YLHZVKDULQJLPSOHPHQWDWLRQ+HQFH'GDWDVHWVFDQEHFROOHFWHGZLWKRQO\
OLWWOHLQWUDYHQRXVJDGROLQLXPEXWKLJKWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQ:HDLPHGWRDVVHVV
ZKHWKHU726FDQEHGLDJQRVHGZLWK7:,6705$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG726ZHUHVWXGLHG([DPLQD
WLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD7V\VWHP 0$*1(720$YDQWR6LHPHQV $%RG\
0DWUL[5)VXUIDFHFRLOZDVXVHGIRUVLJQDOUHFHSWLRQRIWKHXSSHUWKRUD[)ROORZLQJ
WKHLYDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIFFJDGREXWURO *DGRYLVW%D\HU DWDÁRZUDWHRIFFV
FRQVHFXWLYHFRURQDO7ZHLJKWHG'GDWDVHWVZHUHDFTXLUHGXVLQJD7:,67
SURWRFRO 757(ÁLS PV PV PDWUL[ [ VOLFHV WHPSRUDO
UHVROXWLRQV 7KHDFTXLVLWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGWZLFHZLWKWKHDUPVDORQJVLGH
WKHERG\DQGDIWHUHOHYDWLRQ,PDJHVZHUHDQDO\VHGFRQFHUQLQJVWHQRWLFFKDQJHV
RIWKHVXEFODYLDQDUWHULHV5HVXOWVRIVXEVHTXHQW%PRGHDQGFRORXUGXSOH[XOWUD
VRQRJUDSK\ZHUHXVHGDVVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVGLGQRWUHYHDODVWHQRVLVRIWKHULJKWRUOHIWVXEFODYLDQDUWHU\,Q
SDWLHQWVDFRPSUHVVLRQRIWKHVXEFODYLDQDUWHU\ZDVREVHUYHGDIWHUDUPHOHYDWLRQ
XQLODWHUDOQ ELODWHUDOQ )LQGLQJVZHUHFRQÀUPHGE\WKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ7:,6705$LVDIDVWDQGUREXVWWHFKQLTXHWRLGHQWLI\SDWLHQWVZLWK
726
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIPLFURYDVFXODUYHVVHOZDOOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRI
DEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VPVZLWK05,IHDVLELOLW\UHSURGXFLELOLW\DQG
LQLWLDOH[SHULHQFH
9/1JX\HQ:+%DFNHV(0.RRL0&-:LVKDXSW
)$09+HOOHQWKDO0(+%RVERRP5-9DQGHU*HHVW*:+6FKXULQN
7/HLQHU0DDVWULFKW1/(LQGKRYHQ1//HLGHQ1/8WUHFKW1/
YOQJX\HQ#PDDVWULFKWXQLYHUVLW\QO
%
8VLQJHQJLQHHULQJPDWKHPDWLFDOPRGHOVDQG&7'LPDJLQJWR
XQGHUVWDQGWKHKDHPRG\QDPLFDIWHUDRUWLFSURVWKHVLVLQVHUWLRQ
/9)RU]HQLJR3%LRQGHWWL0'RPDQLQ&9HUJDUD%%DUEHULV0LODQ,7
5DQLFD,7 SLELRQGH#WLQLW
3XUSRVH7KHPDLQJRDORIWKLVVWXG\LVWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIPDWKHPDWL
FDOPRGHOOLQJRIWKHEORRGÁRZLQFDUGLRYDVFXODUSDWKRORJLHVVXFKDV$$$ERWK
EHIRUHDQGDIWHUHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQW(9$ XVLQJG\QDPLF'
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 6LQFH WLOO ZH HQUROOHG ZKR XQGHUZHQW
HQGRSURVWKHVLVLQVHUWLRQEHFDXVHRI$$$(DFKSDWLHQWZDVVWXGLHGEHIRUHDQG
DIWHU LQWHUYHQWLRQ ZLWK 'RSSOHU 8OWUDVRXQG DQG 'RXEOH 6RXUFH (&*JDWHG
5RZV&7$QJLRJUDSK\&7',&20GDWDZHUHIRU'PRGHOJHRPHWU\H[WUDFWLRQ
DQG 0HVK JHQHUDWLRQ DQG IRUPDWKHPDWLFDO PRGHOOLQJ RIDRUWLF KDHPRG\QDPLF
EHIRUHDQGDIWHUSURVWKHVLVLQVHUWLRQ)URPWKHVHGDWDPDSVRISHDNZDOOVWUHVVRI
ÁRZYHORFLW\SURÀOHVDQGRILQZDUGRXWZDUGZDOOGLVSODFHPHQWGXULQJRQHFDUGLDF
F\FOHZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVVKRZWKDWLQWKHQDWLYH$$$WKHV\VWROLFRXWZDUGZDOO
GLVSODFHPHQWLVFRUUHODWHGZLWKORZYHORFLW\KLJKSUHVVXUHDQGÁRZYHORFLW\SURÀOHV
$IWHUHQGRSURVWKHVLVLQVHUWLRQWKHUHLVDQLQFUHDVHRILQWUDSURVWKHVLVÁRZYHORFLW\
ZLWKDGHFUHDVHRIODWHUDOSUHVVXUH'HIRUPDWLRQDQGSXOVDWLRQRIWKHPHWDOOLFVWHQW
VWUXFWXUHKDSSHQHGDIWHUWKHÀUVW\HDURIIROORZXS7KHPLGVWHQWORFDWLRQRIWKH
GHIRUPDWLRQZHOOFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHORFDWLRQRIWKHPD[LPXPYHORFLW\FKDQJHGXU
LQJFDUGLDFSXOVDWLRQ7KHULJLGSURVWKHVLVLQWHUUXSWVWKHSUHVVXUHZDYHRULJLQDWHG
E\WKHFDUGLDFSXOVDWLRQZLWKJHQHUDWLRQRIEDFNZDUGFRPSRQHQWVZLWKSRVVLEOH
ORQJWHUPQHJDWLYHHIIHFWVRQWKHFDUGLDFIXQFWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSXWDWLRQDOEORRGÁRZG\QDPLFVXVLQJ'&7GDWDFRXOGSUHGLFW
WKH ULVN RI DQHXULVPDO UXSWXUH /DWH GHIRUPDWLRQ RI (9$5 FDQ EH H[SODLQHG E\
FKDQJHVLQEORRGÁRZG\QDPLFV
%
'\QDPLF G&7$ YHUVXVVWDWLF V&7$ FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
DQJLRJUDSK\DIWHUDEGRPLQDODRUWLFHQGRYDVFXODUDQHXU\VPUHSDLU
(9$5 LQÁXHQFHRIHQKDQFHPHQWSDWWHUQVDQGRSWLPDOEROXVWLPLQJ
RQHQGROHDNGHWHFWLRQ
&$QGUHV&/XHFNH%)ROG\QD0*URWKRII61LW]VFKH
$6FKPLGW'6FKHLQHUW0*XWEHUOHW//HKPNXKO
/HLS]LJ'( FODXGLDDQGUHVPDLO#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVGLIIHUHQFHVRIDRUWLFDQGHQGROHDNHQKDQFHPHQWLQSDWLHQWV
DIWHU (9$5 XVLQJ WKH UHFHQWO\ LQWURGXFHG G&7$ YHUVXV V&7$ WR HYDOXDWH WKH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
2QH\HDUDIWHUHQGRYDVFXODUDEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VPUHSDLU
(9$5 RQHWKLUGRIWKHDQHXU\VPVDFVWLOOFRQVLVWVRIXQRUJDQLVHG
WKURPEXVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWGHWHFWDEOHHQGROHDN
6$&RUQHOLVVHQ(-9RQNHQ-9DQ3UHKQ+-09HUKDJHQ
)/0ROO/:%DUWHOV$PHUVIRRUW1/8WUHFKW1/5RWWHUGDP1/
VDSFRUQHOLVVHQ#PHDQGHUPFQO
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRPRQLWRUWKURPEXVRUJDQLVDWLRQGXULQJ
WKHÀUVW\HDUDIWHU(9$5ZLWK05,
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q WKLV ,5%DSSURYHG SURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ SDWLHQWV
XQGHUZHQW 05,H[DPV SUHRSHUDWLYHO\ ZHHNV SRVWRSHUDWLYHO\ PRQWKV
DQG\HDUDIWHU(9$53UHFRQWUDVW77DQGSRVWFRQWUDVW7ZLPDJHVZHUH
DFTXLUHG$QH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVXEGLYLGHGWKHDQHXU\VPVDFLQWRUHJLRQVRI
HQGROHDNXQRUJDQLVHGDQGRUJDQLVHGWKURPEXVEDVHGRQWKHVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVRQ
WKHGLIIHUHQWO\ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVXVLQJFXVWRPZULWWHQVRIWZDUH
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQ XQRUJDQLVHG WKURPEXV YROXPH SUHRSHUDWLYHO\ ZDV
PO &,PO SRVWRSHUDWLYHO\PO &,PO DIWHUPRQWKV
PO &,PO DQGDIWHU\HDUPO PO 7KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQW
LQFUHDVH LQ XQRUJDQLVHG WKURPEXV YROXPH SRVWRSHUDWLYHO\ FRPSDUHG ZLWK SUH
RSHUDWLYHO\ SDLUHGWWHVWS DIWHUZKLFKWKHXQRUJDQLVHGWKURPEXVYROXPH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\GHFUHDVHGDIWHURQH\HDU SDLUHGWWHVWS SDWLHQWVKDGD
W\SH,,HQGROHDNRQWKHSRVWRSHUDWLYH&7H[DP,QWKHVHSDWLHQWVDODUJHUSDUWRIWKH
DQHXU\VPVDFFRQVLVWHGRIXQRUJDQLVHGWKURPEXVDIWHUPRQWKVWKDQLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKRXWDW\SH,,HQGROHDN PHDQRIDQHXU\VPVDFYROXPH&,YV
PHDQRIDQHXU\VPVDFYROXPH&,LQGHSHQGHQWWWHVWS
&RQFOXVLRQ0HDVXUHPHQWRIWKHGHJUHHRIWKURPEXVRUJDQLVDWLRQRIWKHLQWUD
DQHXU\VPDOWKURPEXVDIWHU(9$5LVSRVVLEOHZLWK05,$IWHU(9$5WKHXQRUJDQLVHG
WKURPEXVYROXPHGHFUHDVHVLQWLPHKRZHYHUERWKLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXW
HQGROHDN RQH \HDU DIWHU (9$5 VWLOO RQHWKLUG RI WKH DQHXU\VP VDF FRQVLVWV RI
XQRUJDQLVHGWKURPEXVRIXQNQRZQDHWLRORJ\
%
9DOLGDWLRQRIUDGLDOO\XQGHUVDPSOHGSRLQWHQFRGHG'ÁRZ05
3&9,35 LQWKRUDFLFDRUWDDQGPDLQSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\
$)U\GU\FKRZLF](1LHVSRG]DQ\6%5HHGHU2:LHEHQ
.0-RKQVRQ&-)UDQFRLV0DGLVRQ:,86/EHFN'(0DGLVRQ:,86
DOH[IU\GU\FKRZLF]#XNVKGH
3XUSRVH7RYDOLGDWHUDGLDOO\XQGHUVDPSOHGSRLQWYHORFLW\HQFRGHG'ÁRZ05
3&9,35 IRU TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI DRUWLF $$2 DQG PDLQ SXOPRQDU\ DUWHU\ 03$
ÁRZV LQ FRPSDULVRQ WR FDUGLDF 05 YROXPHWU\ DQG ' SKDVH FRQWUDVW LPDJLQJ
'3&05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFDUGLRYDVFXODUKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV \HDUV
%0, ZHUH VFDQQHG DW 7 ZLWK HOHPHQWV RI D
FKDQQHOFRLO/HIWDQGULJKWYHQWULFXODUYROXPHWU\XVLQJ&,1(E66)3LQFRQWLJX
RXVVKRUWD[LVVOLFHVDQG'3&05,LQ$$2DQG03$VHUYHGDVUHIHUHQFHV$OO
'3&05,H[DPVDQG3&9,35H[DPVZHUHSKDQWRPFRUUHFWHGDFFRUGLQJ
WR&KHUQREHOVN\HWDO3&9,35ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKYHQF FPVUHFRQVWUXFWHG
WRWLPHIUDPHV3&9,35GDWDZHUHDXWRPDWLFDOO\FRUUHFWHGIRUHGG\FXUUHQWV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH$SURPLQHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIWKHDEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VP $$$ YHV
VHOZDOOLVQHRYDVFXODULVDWLRQZKLFKKDVEHHQOLQNHGZLWK$$$SURJUHVVLRQDQG
UXSWXUH7KHDLPRIWKHSUHVHQWVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORIG\QDPLF
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, '&(05, WRFKDUDFWHULVH$$$YHVVHOZDOOQHRYDVFXODWXUH
E\TXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIWKHHQKDQFHPHQWG\QDPLFV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW'&(05,RIWKHDEGRPLQDODRUWD
DW7HVOD(QKDQFHPHQWG\QDPLFVZHUHTXDQWLÀHGE\FDOFXODWLQJWKHWUDQVIHU
FRQVWDQW .WUDQV XVLQJ SKDUPDFRNLQHWLF PRGHOOLQJ DQG WKH DUHDXQGHUFXUYH
$8& 7HQSDWLHQWVZHUHLPDJHGWZLFHRQGLIIHUHQWRFFDVLRQV,QWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQWV ,&& ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHLQWHUVFDQLQWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHU
YDULDELOLW\$VVRFLDWLRQVEHWZHHQ.WUDQV$8&DQGPD[LPDOGLDPHWHUZHUHFRPSXWHG
DVD3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW U
5HVXOWV,QWRWDORIWKH05,H[DPLQDWLRQVFRXOGEHLQFOXGHGIRUSKDUPDFRNL
QHWLFDQDO\VHV,QWHUVFDQLQWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\IRU.WUDQVDQG$8&
PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHH[FHOOHQW ,&&! 7KHPD[LPDOGLDPHWHU PHDQ6'
PP ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK.WUDQV PLQ U
S EXWQRWZLWK$8&PHDVXUHPHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ4XDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRIHQKDQFHPHQWG\QDPLFVRIWKH$$$YHVVHO
ZDOOZKLFKPD\UHÁHFWWKHH[WHQWRIQHRYDVFXODULVDWLRQLVIHDVLEOHDQGUHSURGXFLEOH
7KHUHLVDPRGHUDWHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHDRUWLFDQHXU\VPZDOOHQKDQFHPHQW
.WUDQV DQG$$$PD[LPDOGLDPHWHU7KLVVWXG\ZDVIXQGHGE\WKH'XWFK+HDUW
)RXQGDWLRQ %
LPSDFWRIHQKDQFHPHQWSDWWHUQVRQWKHHQGROHDNGHWHFWLRQUDWHDQGWRGHÀQHWKH
RSWLPDOVFDQWLPLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQW\RQHSDWLHQWV \HDUV DIWHU(9$5RIWKH
DEGRPLQDODRUWDZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWG&7$ZLWK
XQLGLUHFWLRQDOVFDQSKDVHVRQDVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQGXDOVRXUFH&7 N9
5HIP$V])29 PPWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQVHFPO>POVHF@FRQWUDVW
> PJ LRGLQHPO@ EROXV WUDFNLQJ +8 IROORZHG E\ D YHQRXV SKDVH DQG D
SUHOLPLQDU\ELSKDVLFV&7$(QKDQFHPHQWZDVDVVHVVHGIRUDOOVFDQSKDVHVE\
52,PHDVXUHPHQWVLQDRUWDDQGGHWHFWDEOHHQGROHDNV,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVUDWHG
E\DSRLQWFRQÀGHQFHVFDOH
5HVXOWV,QG&7$WKHKLJKHVWPHDQDRUWLFHQKDQFHPHQWFRXOGEHDFKLHYHGVHF
SRVWWKUHVKROG SW WKHKLJKHVWPHDQHQGROHDNHQKDQFHPHQWFRQVLGHUDEO\ODWHU
DWVHFSW:LWKLQDWRWDORIHQGROHDNV ZHUHQHZO\GHWHFWHGQRW
YLVLEOHLQSUHOLPLQDU\V&7$'HWHFWLRQUDWHVGLIIHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQEHWZHHQWKH
G&7$SKDVHV S 7KHKLJKHVWGHWHFWLRQUDWH Q ZDVREWDLQHGVHFSW
ZKHQWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQDRUWLFDQGHQGROHDNHQKDQFHPHQWDQGWKHUHIRUH
WKHFRQWUDVWUHDFKHGLWVPD[LPXP7KHPHDQGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFWGLIIHUHGE\
G&7$P*\ FPV&7$P*\ FPS
&RQFOXVLRQ '\QDPLF &7$ LQ WKH SRVW(9$5 IROORZXS UHYHDOHG WKDW WKH SHDN
HQKDQFHPHQWRIHQGROHDNVDQGDRUWDDUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWDQGQRWFRYHUHG
VXIÀFLHQWO\E\FRQYHQWLRQDOELSKDVLFV&7$SURWRFROV7KHXVHRIG&7$LVDVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGGHWHFWLRQUDWHRIHQGROHDNV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DQG0D[ZHOOWHUPV&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05$XVLQJPPRONJJDGRIRVYHVHW
WULVRGLXPZDVSHUIRUPHGWRIDFLOLWDWH'SODQHSODFHPHQWVLPXOWDQHRXVO\SURYLGLQJ
FRQVWDQWO\KLJKVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRWKURXJKRXWWKHH[DP%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLV
DYHUDJHGLIIHUHQFH6' DQGFRUUHODWLRQZHUHDSSOLHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDOWHVWLQJ
5HVXOWV%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLVVKRZVDPDUNHGELDVEHWZHHQQRQFRUUHFWHG3&
9,35DQG&,1(E66)3 $$2P/ %$ZLQGRZWR 03$P/
WR DQG EHWZHHQ QRQFRUUHFWHG 3&9,35 DQG SKDQWRPFRUUHFWHG
'3&05, $$2 WR 03$P/ WR 3KDQWRP
FRUUHFWLRQRI3&9,35GDWDLPSURYHGWKHELDVWRZDUGVERWK&,1(E66)3DQG'
3&05,7KHEHVWFRUUHODWLRQZDVUHDFKHGEHWZHHQSKDQWRPFRUUHFWHG3&9,35
DQG'3&05, 5
&RQFOXVLRQ3&9,35ZLWKSRLQWYHORFLW\HQFRGLQJSHUPLWVWKHPHDVXUHPHQWRI
EORRGÁRZLQWKHWKRUDFLFDRUWDDQGSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\VLPXOWDQHRXVO\WRPRUSKRORJLF
DQGKDHPRG\QDPLFLQIRUPDWLRQ7KLVRQJRLQJHYDOXDWLRQLVOLPLWHGE\WKHYDULDELOLW\
RIWKHUHIHUHQFHPHWKRGVDQGRXWOLHUVLQÁXHQFLQJWKHUHVXOWVGLVSURSRUWLRQDOO\
ZLWKUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPD 5&& DQGNQRZQWXPRXUPLFURYDVFXODUGHQVLW\ 09'
ZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWKDOOPRGHOVDQGUHVXOWVFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV6LPXODWLRQ)RULQMHFWLRQWLPHVVKRUWHUWKDQWXPRXU077%) 06 DJUHHV
SHUIHFWO\ZLWK%) LQSXW IRULQMHFWLRQWLPHVQRWORQJHUWKDQWZLFHWKHWXPRXU077
%) 06 XQGHUHVWLPDWHV%) LQSXW E\QRWPRUHWKDQ%9 3/ ZDVW\SLFDOO\
ORZHUWKDQ%9 LQSXW $V%9 LQSXW ( DJUHHGZLWKLQZLWK%9 3/ WKLV
DSSHDUVWREHUDWKHUDGLIIHUHQFHLQ%9GHÀQLWLRQ ÀUVWSDVVGLVWULEXWLRQYVFDSLO
ODU\YROXPH 5&&VWXG\%)DQG%9IURPDOOPRGHOVFRUUHODWHGHTXDOO\ZHOOZLWK
09' UWRS $VSUHGLFWHG LQMHFWLRQWLPHV077V
DJUHHPHQW EHWZHHQ %) 06 DQG %) '& ZDV H[FHOOHQW VORSH U
%9 3/ ZDVORZHUWKDQ%9 '& VORSHU ,IFRUUHFWHGZLWK (
WKHGLIIHUHQFHUHGXFHGWR
&RQFOXVLRQ6LPSOLÀHGPRGHOVFDQEHXVHIXODOWHUQDWLYHVLIUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHDQG
RUWHPSRUDOVDPSOLQJQHHGWREHOLPLWHG6\VWHPDWLFGLIIHUHQFHVFDQEHFRUUHFWHG
IRUDOORZLQJFRPSDULVRQZLWKRWKHUVWXGLHV
%
5RRP3
3K\VLFVLQ5DGLRORJ\
66
)XQFWLRQDOLPDJLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
&/HLGHFNHU)RUFKKHLP'(
02QX%XFKDUHVW52
%
0HWDODUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQLQGXDOVRXUFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\XVLQJ
PRQRHQHUJHWLFH[WUDSRODWLRQDV\VWHPDWLFDOO\RSWLPLVHGSURWRFRO
)*0HLQHO4=KDQJ)%DPEHUJ%%LVFKRII
0)5HLVHU75&-RKQVRQ0XQLFK'(+DQJ]KRX&1
IHOL[PHLQHO#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH 0RQRHQHUJHWLF H[WUDSRODWLRQ LV D SURPLVLQJ VWUDWHJ\ WR UHGXFH PHWDO
DUWHIDFWVLQGXDOVRXUFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ '6&7 :HSHUIRUPHGWKLVVWXG\
WR V\VWHPDWLFDOO\ RSWLPLVH LPDJH DFTXLVLWLRQ DQG UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ SDUDPHWHUV IRU
WKLVDSSURDFK
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VWDQGDUGKLSSKDQWRPZDVORDGHGZLWKWLWDQLXPDQG
FREDOWFKURPLXPPRGHOVRIKLSSURVWKHVHVDQGVFDQQHGRQD'6&7VFDQQHU 6R
PDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ)ODVK6LHPHQV)RUFKKHLP*HUPDQ\ 7XEHVSHFWUDWXEHFXUUHQW
UDWLRFROOLPDWLRQSLWFKURWDWLRQWLPHDQGH[WUDSRODWHGHQHUJLHVZHUHRSWLPLVHG
LQDVWHSZLVHSURFHVV$UWHIDFWVDQGLPDJHQRLVHZHUHTXDQWLÀHGE\PHDVXULQJ
WKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ 6' RIWKH&7GHQVLW\LQDFLUFXODUUHJLRQRILQWHUHVWSODFHG
DURXQGWKHSURVWKHVLVDQGFRQWUDODWHUDOO\UHVSHFWLYHO\
5HVXOWV6QN9SSURYHGVXSHULRUWR6QN9SDQGN9SHV
SHFLDOO\IRUWKLFNFREDOWFKURPLXPHOHPHQWV 6'+8YV+8 7KHUHZDVD
EHQHÀWIRULQFUHDVLQJWXEHFXUUHQWUDWLRIURPWREXWQRWEH\RQGLQIDYRXU
RIWKH6QN9SVSHFWUXP 6'+8YV+8IRUFREDOWFKURPLXP $UWHIDFWV
ZHUHOHVVVHYHUHIRUDFROOLPDWLRQRI[DVFRPSDUHGWR[ 6'+8YV
+8IRUFREDOWFKURPLXP $SLWFKRIDWDURWDWLRQWLPHRIZDVFKRVHQDV
RSWLPDOZKHQFRPSDULQJGLIIHUHQWFRPELQDWLRQVZLWKFRPSDUDEOHVFDQQLQJWLPHV
7KHRSWLPDOH[WUDSRODWHGSKRWRQHQHUJLHVZHUHNH9IRUWLWDQLXPDQG
NH9IRUFREDOWFKURPLXP
&RQFOXVLRQ 6Q N9S ZLWK D WXEH FXUUHQW UDWLR RI D FROOLPDWLRQ RI
[ DQG H[WUDSRODWHG HQHUJLHV RI NH9 DUH RSWLPDO SDUDPHWHUV IRU D
GHGLFDWHG'6&7SURWRFROWKDWHIIHFWLYHO\UHGXFHVPHWDODUWHIDFWVE\PRQRHQHUJHWLF
H[WUDSRODWLRQ
%
0RGHOGHSHQGHQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQ&7
(.ORW]0-XHUJHQV9*RK+$ONDGKL)RUFKKHLP'(/RQGRQ8.
=XULFK&+
3XUSRVH6LPSOLÀHGPRGHOVVXFKDVPD[LPXPVORSH 06 DQG3DWODN 3/ KDYH
WKHUHSXWDWLRQWREHOHVVDFFXUDWHWKDQGHFRQYROXWLRQ '& DSSURDFKHV2XUJRDO
ZDVWRTXDQWLI\WKHGLIIHUHQFHVDQGDVVHVVWKHLUUHOHYDQFHIRUFOLQLFDOVWXGLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HJHQHUDWHGHQKDQFHPHQWFXUYHVIURPSDWLHQWDUWHULDO
LQSXWIXQFWLRQVE\FRQYROXWLRQZLWKSDUDPHWULFLPSXOVHUHVLGXHIXQFWLRQVYDU\LQJ
EORRGÁRZ %) EORRGYROXPH %9 PHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 077 DQGH[WUDFWLRQIUDFWLRQ
( RYHUWKHUDQJHW\SLFDOO\IRXQGIRUWXPRXUV6LPXODWHGFXUYHVZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWK
06DQG3/DQGWKHUHVXOWVFRPSDUHGWRWKHLQSXW'\QDPLFGDWDIURPSDWLHQWV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5HGXFHGWLPH&7SHUIXVLRQDFTXLVLWLRQVDUHVXIÀFLHQWWRPHDVXUH
WKHSHUPHDELOLW\VXUIDFHDUHDSURGXFWZLWKDGHFRQYROXWLRQPHWKRG
0$0D]]HL(6DQL6*XHUULQL1&LRIÀ6TXLWLHUL()RGHUDҋ
&GH0DXUR)*0D]]HL/9ROWHUUDQL6LHQD,7)ORUHQFH,7
PPD]]HL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7KHDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHLQ&7SHUIXVLRQVWXGLHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\DIIHFWVSDWLHQWҋV
GRVHH[SRVXUH,QRUGHUWRUHGXFHWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFHGWLPH&7SHUIXVLRQ
DFTXLVLWLRQVDUHWHVWHGWRPHDVXUH36ZLWKDGHFRQYROXWLRQPHWKRG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV36ZDVFDOFXODWHGZLWKUHSHDWHGPHDVXUHPHQWV Q
ZKLOHWUXQFDWLQJWKHWLPHGHQVLW\FXUYHDWGLIIHUHQWWLPHYDOXHVLQ&7SHUIXVLRQ
VWXGLHVFRQGXFWHGIRUOXQJFDQFHU Q +RGJNLQO\PSKRPD Q DQGUHQDOFHOO
FDUFLQRPD Q XVLQJ&7SHUIXVLRQ'VRIWZDUH *(+HDOWKFDUH 7KHPHGLDQ
DFTXLVLWLRQWLPHRI&7SHUIXVLRQVWXGLHVZDVVHF UDQJHVHF 7RYHULI\WKH
DFFXUDF\RIWKHGHFRQYROXWLRQDOJRULWKPDYDULDWLRQRIWKHWUXQFDWHG36ZLWKLQWKH
HUURUPHDVXUHPHQWVZDVVHDUFKHGLHZLWKLQVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQVIURPWKHPHDQ
QRPLQDOHUURUSURYLGHGE\WKHVRIWZDUH$VDVDQLW\FKHFNWKHWHVWZDVSHUIRUPHG
IRUDOOWKHSDUDPHWHUVPHDVXUHGXVLQJ&73HUIXVLRQ'VRIWZDUH
5HVXOWV36ZDVFRQVLVWHQWZLWKLQLQaWRaVHFRQGVDQGZLWKLQLQ
aWRaVHFRQGV36ZDVFRQVWDQWDIWHUWRVHF$FRQVLVWHQWUHVXOWODVWHG
IRUDOOWKHREVHUYHGSDUDPHWHUV 077%9%) DVH[SHFWHGIURPWKHLUDQDO\WLFDO
GHSHQGHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KLUW\ÀYH VHFRQGV DUH HQRXJK WR REWDLQ D UHOLDEOH ,5) LPSXOVH
UHVLGXDOIXQFWLRQ )RUDQDFFXUDWHPHDVXUHPHQWRIWKH36DVHFDFTXLVLWLRQ
WLPHVKRXOGEHDQRSWLPDOFRPSURPLVHWRREWDLQUHOLDEOH36PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGD
UHDVRQDEOHGRVHH[SRVXUH1RDGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQFDQEHSURYLGHGZLWKORQJHU
SHUIXVLRQDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHV
%
,PSURYLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\RIYROXPHWULFKHOLFDOSHUIXVLRQ&7DWN9
XVLQJVSDWLRWHPSRUDOÀOWHULQJDVWUDWHJ\IRUGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
$5DGKDNULVKQDQ,6LPFRFN-6WLUOLQJ$.KDQ5*O\QQH-RQHV9-*RK
/RQGRQ8.
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHFKDQJHLQLPDJHTXDOLW\RISHOYLFYROXPHWULFKHOLFDOSHU
IXVLRQ&7WHFKQLTXHVZLWKWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIDVSDWLRWHPSRUDOÀOWHU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )ROORZLQJ HWKLFDO DSSURYDO DQG LQIRUPHG FRQVHQW
SDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHV ZLWKSHOYLFFDQFHUVXQGHUZHQWDYROXPHWULFKHOLFDO
SHUIXVLRQ&7VWXG\ 6RPDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ6LHPHQV XVLQJWKHIROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUV
N9P$V'DGDSWLYHVSLUDOVF\FOHWLPHFP]D[LVP/
PJP/,RYHUVRO,9DWP/VHF )ROORZLQJPRWLRQFRUUHFWLRQLPDJHVZHUH
UHFRQVWUXFWHGDWPPDQGPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWDSSOLFDWLRQRID
VSDWLRWHPSRUDOÀOWHU 'QRLVHUHGXFWLRQ ,PDJHQRLVHZDVDVVHVVHGE\SODFHPHQW
RIDUHJLRQRILQWHUHVWZLWKLQPXVFOHDQGWXPRXUDWDQGPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV
UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRIWKH52,HTXLYDOHQWWRҊQRLVHҋZDVUHFRUGHG
7KHWXPRXUFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 ZDVFDOFXODWHGE\GLYLGLQJWXPRXUHQ
KDQFHPHQWE\QRLVH&15EHIRUHDQGDIWHUÀOWHUDSSOLFDWLRQZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJ
SDLUHGWWHVWLQJZLWKVLJQLÀFDQFHDW
5HVXOWV0HDQQRLVHGHFUHDVHGIROORZLQJÀOWHUDSSOLFDWLRQIURPWRDW
PPDQGWRDWPPIRUPXVFOHDQGIURPWRDWPPDQG
WRDWPPIRUWXPRXU&RQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLRLQFUHDVHGIURPWR
DWPP S DQGWR DWPP S
&RQFOXVLRQ$SSOLFDWLRQRIDVSDWLRWHPSRUDOÀOWHUGHFUHDVHVQRLVHDQGVLJQLÀFDQWO\
LQFUHDVHVWKHFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLRDWPP7KLVKDVWKHHIIHFWRILQFUHDVLQJWKH
&15DWPPWRDQHTXLYDOHQWPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
)XQFWLRQDOLPDJLQJRQDQLQWHUYHQWLRQDO&DUPÁDWGHWHFWRU&7V\VWHP
5%UDXZHLOHU)(LVD0+XSIHU71RZDN'.ROGLW]:$.DOHQGHU
(UODQJHQ'( 5REHUW%UDXZHLOHU#LPSXQLHUODQJHQGH
%
9LUWXDOQRQFRQWUDVWLQVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQGXDOHQHUJ\FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\UHOLDELOLW\RIDWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHV
07RHSNHU70RULW]0:HEHU%.UDXVV70DQJ
*(XOOHU):ROI&-+HUROG+5LQJO9LHQQD$7
)RUFKKHLP'( PLFKDHOWRHSNHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUHOLDELOLW\RIDWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHVLQYLUWXDOQRQFRQWUDVW
LPDJHV 91& UHFRQVWUXFWHGIURPFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGGXDOHQHUJ\VFDQVSHUIRUPHG
RQDVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQGXDOHQHUJ\&7FRPSDUHGWRVLQJOHHQHUJ\QRQFRQWUDVW
LPDJHV 71&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYHGWKLVUHVHDUFK
DQGZDLYHGLQIRUPHGFRQVHQW6L[WHHQSKDQWRPVFRQWDLQLQJDPL[WXUHRIFRQWUDVW
DJHQW DQG ZDWHU DW GLIIHUHQW DWWHQXDWLRQV +8 ZHUH LQYHVWLJDWHG RQ D
'HÀQLWLRQ)ODVK&7VFDQQHUXVLQJDVLQJOHHQHUJ\VFDQDWN9DQGD'(&7
SURWRFRO N961N9 )RUFOLQLFDODVVHVVPHQWSDWLHQWV IHPDOHV ZKR
UHFHLYHGDGXDOSKDVH&7FRQWDLQLQJDQXQHQKDQFHGVLQJOHHQHUJ\VFDQDWN9
DQGDFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG PO,RPHURQPJPOPOVHF '(&7 N9
61N9 LQDQDUWHULDO Q RUDYHQRXVSKDVHZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHG
0HDQDWWHQXDWLRQZDVPHDVXUHGZLWKLQUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWRIWKHSKDQWRPVDQG
LQGLIIHUHQWWLVVXHW\SHVRIWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKLQWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ91&DQG71&
LPDJHV3DLUHGWWHVWVDQG3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQZHUHXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV )RU DOO SKDQWRPV PHDQ DWWHQXDWLRQ LQ 91& ZDV +8 ,Q
SDWLHQWVRYHUDOOUHJLRQVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQ71&DQG91&LPDJHVZLWKD
PHDQGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ71&DQG91&RI+8,Q Q RI
DOOFDVHVDEVROXWHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ71&DQG91&ZHUHXQGHU+8DQGLQ
Q GLIIHUHQFHVZHUHXQGHU+8
&RQFOXVLRQ6HFRQGJHQHUDWLRQGXDOHQHUJ\&7EDVHG91&LPDJHVSURYLGHDW
WHQXDWLRQYDOXHVFORVHWRWKRVHRI71&7RXVH91&DVDQDOWHUQDWLYHWR71&LQ
GDLO\FOLQLFDOURXWLQHDVDIHW\PDUJLQRI+8VKRXOGEHDSSOLHG
%
&KDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIWKHELRJUDSKP05
6)UVW*'HOVR%:-DNRE\5/DGHEHFN&*DQWHU6*1HNROOD
(-5XPPHQ\06FKZDLJHU6,=LHJOHU0XQLFK'(.QR[YLOOH7186
(UODQJHQ'( VHEDVWLDQIXHUVW#WXPGH
3XUSRVH7KHSK\VLFDOSHUIRUPDQFHRIWKHÀUVWIXOO\LQWHJUDWHGZKROHERG\05
3(7VFDQQHUWKHELRJUDSKP05 P05 ZDVVWXGLHGDQGFRPSDUHGWRFXUUHQW
05DQG3(7&7V\VWHPVWKH0DJQHWRP9HULR7DQGWKHELRJUDSKP&7 P&7
UHVSHFWLYHO\6LPXOWDQHRXVRSHUDWLRQDQGLWVHIIHFWVZHUHDOVRFRQVLGHUHG
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KH NH\ FRPSRQHQWV RI WKH P05 DUH D 7 PDJQHW
DQG$3'/62EORFNGHWHFWRUV0HDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSUHSDUHGDQGSHUIRUPHGDV
GHVFULEHGLQWKH1(0$18SURWRFRO 3(7 DQGLQWKH$&5TXDOLW\FRQWURO
PDQXDO 05, 3(7VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQZHUHDVVHVVHGERWKZLWKDQG
ZLWKRXWDQ05,9,%(VHTXHQFHUXQQLQJ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&RPSDULVRQRI63$&(DQG'76(05&3UHJDUGLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\
DQGGLDJQRVWLFFHUWDLQW\LQSDWLHQWVLQDURXWLQHFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ
36XGKROW&8ULJR*%RQJDUW]-+RKPDQQ%DVOH&+/RQGRQ8.
VXGKROWS#XKEVFK
3XUSRVH:HFRPSDUHG'63$&( VDPSOLQJSHUIHFWLRQZLWKDSSOLFDWLRQRSWLPLVHG
FRQWUDVW 05&3ZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO'76(05&3LQDURXWLQHFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ$LP
ZDVWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHURUQRWWKH'63$&(05&3DOORZVEHWWHULPDJHTXDOLW\
LQSDWLHQWVDQGLIWKLVWUDQVODWHVDOVRWRDKLJKHUOHYHORIFRQÀGHQFHUHJDUGLQJWKH
GLDJQRVLVRIFKROHGRFKROLWKLDVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'76(DQG'63$&(VHTXHQFHVZHUHFRQVHFXWLYHO\
REWDLQHG IURP SDWLHQWV XQGHUJRLQJ 05&3 DW RXU LQVWLWXWLRQ )RU HYDOXDWLRQ
WKHSDQFUHDWLFRELOLDU\WUHHZDVVXEGLYLGHGLQWRVHJPHQWVZKLFKZHUHVFRUHG
VHSDUDWHO\IRUYLVLELOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFFHUWDLQW\RQDÀYHSRLQWVFDOHHDFKE\WKUHH
H[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWV
5HVXOWV,QWRWDOVHJPHQWVZHUHUHYLHZHGLQERWKVHTXHQFHV7KHDYHUDJH
LPDJH TXDOLW\ ZDV UDWHG JRRG LQ ERWK VHTXHQFHV EXW KLJKHU IRU 63$&(05&3
WKDQIRU'76( YHUVXVQ S ,QRIVHJPHQWVLP
DJHTXDOLW\LQ'63$&(ZDVVXSHULRUWR'76(ZKLOHLPDJHTXDOLW\LQ'76(
ZDVEHWWHULQRQO\VHJPHQWV VHJPHQWVZKHUHUDWHGDVHTXDO 'LDJQRVWLF
FHUWDLQW\ZDVHYDOXDWHGEHWWHUIRU'63$&(WKDQ'76(LQRIVHJPHQWV
ZKLOH'76(KDGDKLJKHUGLDJQRVWLFFHUWDLQW\LQRQO\VHJPHQWV VHJPHQWV
ZKHUHUDWHGDVHTXDO
&RQFOXVLRQ'63$&(05&3DOORZVVXSHULRULPDJHTXDOLW\DQGRIIHUVDKLJKHU
GLDJQRVWLFFHUWDLQW\FRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDO'76(05&3,WVKRXOGEHXVHG
DVWKH05&3VHTXHQFHRIFKRLFHLQDFOLQLFDOURXWLQHVHWWLQJ
%
'HYHORSPHQWRIDWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWSKDQWRPIRUVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQRI
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,
*:ROI0/DQLDGR1$EROPDDOL73DXOXV'UHVGHQ'(
3XUSRVH:LGHVSUHDGDSSOLFDWLRQRIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, ':05, LQRQFRORJ\
LVFXUUHQWO\LPSDLUHGGXHWROLPLWHGVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQDFURVVLQVWUXPHQWV7KHUHIRUH
ZHDLPHGWRGHYHORSDSKDQWRPZLWKWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQW05,SURSHUWLHV $'&5
5 IRU':05,VWDQGDUGLVDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHLQÁXHQFHVRILQGLYLGXDOSKDQWRPFRPSRQHQWVDJDURVH
JHO FRQFHQWUDWLRQ VXFURVH *G'73$ P0 63,2 P0
DQG SUHVHUYDWLYH VRGLXP D]LGH RQ 05, SURSHUWLHV ZHUH V\VWHPDWLFDOO\
HYDOXDWHG %DVHG RQ D OLQHDU FRPELQDWLRQ PRGHO RI VLQJOH FRPSRQHQWV HIIHFWV
WKHWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWSKDQWRPZDVFRPSRVHGWRUHVHPEOHLQYLYR05,SURSHUWLHV
RIYDULRXVQRUPDODQGQHRSODVWLFWLVVXHVDFFRUGLQJWROLWHUDWXUHYDOXHV$'&5
DQG 5 RI WLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWV ZHUH PHDVXUHG E\ GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG VSLQHFKR
(3, EYDOXHV VPP PXOWLFRQWUDVW LQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\ 76( 7,
YDOXHV PV DQG PXOWLFRQWUDVW 6( 7(YDOXHV PV XVLQJ D
7VFDQQHU $YDQWR6LHPHQV ,QWUDDQGLQWHUVHULHVYDULDELOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHG
DFURVVPXOWLSOHDFTXLVLWLRQVZLWKLQWKHVDPHDQGDOOLPDJLQJVHVVLRQVUHVSHFWLYHO\
5HVXOWV,QGLYLGXDOFRPSRQHQWVVKRZLQYHUVHOLQHDUVFDOLQJZLWKFRQFHQWUDWLRQV
IRU$'&DQGOLQHDUVFDOLQJIRU5DQG57KHWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWSKDQWRP\LHOGHG
VWDEOH05,SDUDPHWHUVRYHUDWOHDVWGD\VDWURRPWHPSHUDWXUHVWRUDJH([SHUL
PHQWDODQGUHIHUHQFH$'&YDOXHVRIWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\FRUUHODWHG
U S +RZHYHU5DQG5ZHUHOHVVDGHTXDWHO\LPLWDWHG S!
,QWUDDQGLQWHUVHULHV$'&YDULDELOLW\ZDVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWSKDQWRPSHUPLWVUHSHDWHGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQVRI
05,SDUDPHWHUVLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWKHDV\SUHSDUDWLRQDQGORQJWLPHVWDELOLW\DV
ZHOODVVLPSOHKDQGOLQJDQGSRVLWLRQLQJ,WPD\EHXVHIXOLQTXDOLW\DVVXUDQFHDQG
V\VWHPVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQSURFHGXUHV':05,VKRZVH[FHOOHQWUHSHDWDELOLW\ZLWKLQ
WKHVDPHVFDQQHU
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORIG\QDPLF&DUP&7WRDVVHVVIXQFWLRQDO
SDUDPHWHUVIURPDWLPHUHVROYHGVHTXHQFHRIYROXPHWULFLPDJHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV0HDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQDQH[SHULPHQWDOURERWLF
&DUPÁDWGHWHFWRU&7V\VWHPDOORZLQJIRUDVFDQWLPHRIVDQGIRUYDOLGD
WLRQSXUSRVHRQDFOLQLFDO&7VFDQQHU)RUKDOIVFDQUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVWKHUHVXOWLQJ
WHPSRUDOVDPSOLQJZDVVIRUIXOOVFDQUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVV2QWKHFOLQLFDO&7
ZHSHUIRUPHGVFDQVDWDQGVWHPSRUDOVDPSOLQJ:HXVHGDSHUIXVLRQ
SKDQWRPZKLFKSURYLGHVUHSURGXFLEOHFRQWUDVWFXUYHV7KUHHGLIIHUHQWZDWHUÁRZ
UDWHVZHUHXWLOLVHGWRVLPXODWHGLIIHUHQWIXQFWLRQDOEHKDYLRXU6FDQVZHUHUHSHDWHG
WKUHHWLPHVDQGSRVWSURFHVVHGXVLQJWKHPD[LPXPVORSHPHWKRGWRDVVHVVWKH
IXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVEORRGYROXPH %9 EORRGÁRZ %) PHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 077
DQGWLPHWRSHDN 773
5HVXOWV)RUHDFKVDPSOLQJUDWHDQGDOOIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVUHSURGXFLELOLW\HUURUV
GLGQRWH[FHHGIRUERWKFOLQLFDO&7DQG&DUP&7)RUVWHPSRUDOVDPSOLQJ
LQWHUYHQWLRQDO&DUP&7DQGFOLQLFDO&7ZHUHLQDJUHHPHQWZLWKGHYLDWLRQVEHORZ
IRU%)%9DQG773DQGEHORZIRU077)RUORZHUWHPSRUDOVDPSOLQJV
RIVDQGVIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVGHYLDWHGE\XSWRFRPSDUHGWRWKH
VVDPSOLQJFDVH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDVVHVVPHQWRIIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVE\&DUP&7VKRZVSURPLV
LQJUHVXOWVDQGPD\VDYHYDOXDEOHWLPHLQSDWLHQWWUHDWPHQWZKHQQRDGGLWLRQDO&7
RU05,VFDQLVUHTXLUHGEHIRUHRUGXULQJWKHUDSHXWLFLQWHUYHQWLRQ
5HVXOWV%DVHGRQLWVJHRPHWU\WKHP05KDVDQLQFUHDVHGVHQVLWLYLW\RINFSV
0%T LQ DQG NFSV0%T RII WKH )29 FHQWUH P&7 NFSV0%T 7KH DYHUDJH
VSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQYDOXHVRIWKHP05DQGWKHP&7DUHFRPSDUDEOH PPPP
QHDU WKH )29 FHQWUH 7KHVH ÀQGLQJV ZHUH XQDIIHFWHG E\ SDUDOOHO 05, VFDQV
7KHQRLVHHTXLYDOHQWFRXQWUDWHRIWKHP05SHDNVDWN%TPOZLWKNFSV
P&7NFSV#N%TPO 7KHVFDWWHUIUDFWLRQZDVPHDVXUHGWREH
P&7 7KHLPDJHFRQWUDVWLQFUHDVHVIURPWRZKHUHDVWKH
EDFNJURXQGYDULDELOLW\GHFUHDVHVIURPWRZLWKLQFUHDVLQJGLDPHWHUVRI
DFWLYHVSKHUHV VSKHUHEDFNJURXQG 0HDVXUHPHQWRI%KRPRJHQHLW\ SSP
LQDFPVSKHUH %ÀHOGGLVWULEXWLRQDQG5)QRLVHVKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHU
HQFHVWRWKHUHIHUHQFH05V\VWHP6LPXOWDQHRXV3(7DFTXLVLWLRQVKDGQRHIIHFW
&RQFOXVLRQ3URSHULQWHJUDWLRQRI$3'3(7WHFKQRORJ\DQG705,GRHVQRW
OLPLWWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIHLWKHUFRPSRQHQWLQFRPSDULVRQWRVWDWHRIWKHDUWVWDQG
DORQHLQVWUXPHQWDWLRQ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
7RZDUGVVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQRIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,VWDWXVVXUYH\
DFURVVLQVWUXPHQWVXVLQJDWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWSKDQWRP
*:ROI)'H.H\]HU73DXOXV5+HUPDQV1$EROPDDOL'UHVGHQ'(
/HXYHQ%(
3XUSRVH:LGHVSUHDGDSSOLFDWLRQRIRQFRORJLFGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, ':05,
LVFXUUHQWO\LPSDLUHGGXHWROLPLWHGVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQDFURVVLQVWUXPHQWVDQGLPDJLQJ
SDUDPHWHUV:HWKHUHIRUHDLPHGWRSHUIRUPDVWDWXVVXUYH\RI':05,DWGLIIHUHQW
VFDQQHUVXVLQJDWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWSKDQWRP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHSKDQWRPZDVSUHSDUHGIURPDJDURVHJHOVXFURVH
DQG*G'73$WRUHVHPEOHLQYLYR05,SURSHUWLHV $'&55 RIYDULRXVQRUPDO
DQGQHRSODVWLFWLVVXHVDFFRUGLQJWROLWHUDWXUHYDOXHV$'&RIWLVVXHHTXLYDOHQWV
ZDV PHDVXUHG E\ GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG VSLQHFKR (3, EYDOXHV VPP
7( PV75 PVSDUDOOHOLPDJLQJIDFWRU 3,) RQVHYHUDO
VFDQQHUV 7$YDQWR76RQDWDDQG77ULR6LHPHQV 0HGLDQLQWUDDQG
LQWHUVFDQQHUYDULDELOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHGDFURVVPXOWLSOHLPDJHDFTXLVLWLRQVHVVLRQV
ZLWKLQWKHVDPHDQGDOOVFDQQHUVUHVSHFWLYHO\
5HVXOWV:LWKJURZLQJ7(ZHREVHUYHGDPDUNHGHDUO\$'&GHFUHDVHIRU6RQDWD
GRZQWRUHODWLYHWR7( PLQLPDO DQGPRGHUDWHODWHGHFUHDVHVIRU$YDQWRDQG
7ULR DQG $YDQWR$'&ZDVORZHUWKDQRQ7ULR у PV LQGHSHQG
HQWRI7(ZKHUHDVLWZDVKLJKHUWKDQRQ6RQDWD у PV LQFUHDVLQJ
ZLWK7(&RUUHVSRQGLQJO\LQWHUVFDQQHUYDULDELOLW\LQFUHDVHGZLWK7( $W
RXURSWLPDOVHWWLQJV 7( PLQLPDO75 PV3,) LQWUDVFDQQHUYDULDELOLWLHV
ZHUH $YDQWR 6RQDWD DQG 7ULR ZKLOHLQWHUVFDQQHUYDULDELOLW\
ZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ $'& TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ DQG YDULDELOLW\ VWURQJO\ GHSHQG RQ LPDJLQJ
SDUDPHWHUV,QJHQHUDO':05,UHYHDOVVXEVWDQWLDOYDULDELOLW\DFURVVVFDQQHUV
ZKLFKODUJHO\FRPSOLFDWHVVHWXSRIPXOWLFHQWUHVWXGLHVDQGFRPSDULVRQRIUHVXOWV
1HYHUWKHOHVVDWRSWLPDOVHWWLQJV':05,SURYLGHVH[FHOOHQWUHSHDWDELOLW\DWWKH
VDPHVFDQQHU+RZHYHUIXWXUHHIIRUWVDUHQHHGHGWREULQJVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQLQWR
FOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
5RRP4
&DUGLDF
66
$FXWHFRURQDU\V\QGURPHVYLDELOLW\
0RGHUDWRUV
*+DGMLGHNRY6RILD%*
*$.URPEDFK*LHVVHQ'(
%
6HQVLWLYLW\RIFDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHYDULHVZLWKFOLQLFDO
SUHVHQWDWLRQRIELRSV\SURYHQDFXWHP\RFDUGLWLV
*&DQQDYDOH0)UDQFRQH,,DPSLHUL%&RQWL$)UXVWDFL&&DWDODQR
5RPH,7
3XUSRVH5HFHQWO\7ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJDOORZHGGHSLFWLRQRIP\RFDUGLDORHGHPD
DVDVSHFLÀFPDUNHURIGLVHDVHLQDFXWHFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ,WVVHQVLWLYLW\KRZHYHU
YDULHVLQDFXWHDQGFKURQLFPDQLIHVWDWLRQV:HUHSRUWJUHDWVHQVLWLYLW\YDULDWLRQV
RI05LQDFXWHP\RFDUGLWLVGHSHQGLQJRQFOLQLFDOSUHVHQWDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWHG 05 VHQVLWLYLW\ LQ FRP
SDULVRQZLWKFOLQLFDOSUHVHQWDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZKRKDGLQWKHODVWWZR\HDUVDQ
HQGRP\RFDUGLDOELRSV\GLDJQRVLVRIDFWLYHP\RFDUGLWLVDQGDFOLQLFDOKLVWRU\
PRQWKV$OO VXEMHFWV XQGHUZHQW DW WLPH RI GLDJQRVLV D FDUGLDF 05 &05 DQG
LQYDVLYHFDUGLDFH[DPLQDWLRQ
5HVXOWV7KUHHW\SHVRIFOLQLFDOSDWWHUQVRIP\RFDUGLWLVZHUHUHFRJQLVHG LQIDUFW
OLNH IHYHUFKHVWSDLQ67VHJPHQWGHÁHFWLRQDW(&*DQGVHUXP7URSRQLQ,HOHYD
WLRQ &DUGLRP\RSDWK\ OHIWYHQWULFXODUG\VIXQFWLRQLQDEVHQFHRI(&*VHURORJLF
RUV\VWHPLFDEQRUPDOLWLHV $UUK\WKPLF VXGGHQRFFXUUHQFHRIVXSUDYHQWULFXODU
DQGRUYHQWULFXODUDUUK\WKPLDVLQDEVHQFHRIV\VWHPLFHYLGHQFHRILQÁDPPDWLRQ
'HOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQWDW&05VXJJHVWLQJDP\RFDUGLWLVZDVGRFXPHQWHGLQ
RISDWLHQWV Q RISDWWHUQ Q RISDWWHUQDQG Q
RI SDWWHUQ 7LVVXH RHGHPD ZDV REVHUYHG LQ Q RI SDWWHUQ
Q LQ SDWWHUQ DQG Q LQ SDWWHUQ (DUO\ HQKDQFHPHQW ZDV
SRVLWLYHLQ RIWKHFDVHVZLWKSDWWHUQ ZLWKSDWWHUQDQG
ZLWKSDWWHUQ
&RQFOXVLRQ6HQVLWLYLW\RIFDUGLDF05LVKLJKIRULQIDUFWOLNHP\RFDUGLWLVORZIRU
FDUGLRP\RSDWK\DQGYHU\ORZIRUDUUK\WKPLFSDWWHUQ$PRUHH[WHQVLYHYDVFXODU
LQYROYHPHQWLQSDWWHUQFRPSDUHGZLWKIRFDOP\RF\WHDQGFRQGXFWLRQWLVVXHGDP
DJHRISDWWHUQDQGDUHWKHPRVWOLNHO\H[SODQDWLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
+\EULG3(705,LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIFDUGLDFYLDELOLW\DGGHGYDOXH
FRPSDUHGWR3(7&7
25DWLE51NRXORX0*9LQFHQWL$4XHUFLROL6+HLQ]HU''LGLHU
06WXEHU7+6FKLQGOHU-39DOOHH*HQHYD&+/DXVDQQH&+
5HQH1NRXORX#KFXJHFK
3XUSRVH :H HYDOXDWHG WKH SRWHQWLDO IRU K\EULG 3(705, GHYLFHV WR SURYLGH
LQWHJUDWHG PHWDEROLF IXQFWLRQDO DQG DQDWRPLF FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK
VXVSHFWHGFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7HQSDWLHQWV ZLWKVXVSHFWHGKLEHUQDWLQJP\RFDUGLXP
DQGKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV SHUIRUPHGDQLPDJLQJVWXG\XVLQJDK\EULG3(705,
3KLOLSV 9LDELOLW\ DVVHVVHG E\ ))'* ZDV SHUIRUPHG LQ GLVHDVHG SDWLHQWV
DORQJZLWK05,DQDWRPLFDQGIXQFWLRQDOVWXG\DQGUHDVVHVVHGZLWKLQPLQXWHV
E\FRQYHQWLRQDO3(7&71RQFRQWUDVWULJKWFRURQDU\DUWHU\ 5&$ WDUJHWHGDQG
ZKROHKHDUW'FRURQDU\DQJLR05,XVLQJ(&*JDWLQJDQGUHVSLUDWRU\QDYLJDWRU
ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVZLWKUHFRQVWUXFWLRQSHUIRUPHGXVLQJ035DQG
YROXPHUHQGHULQJ7KHH[WHQWRIPHWDEROLFGHIHFW 0' XVLQJ3(705,DQG3(7&7
ZDVFRPSDUHGLQSDWLHQWVDQGFRURQDU\WHUULWRULHV /$'&;5&$ $VVHVVDELOLW\
RIFRURQDU\OXPHQZDVMXGJHGDVJRRGVXERSWLPDORUQRQDVVHVVDEOHXVLQJD
VHJPHQWVFRURQDU\PRGHO
5HVXOWV0HWDEROLFDVVHVVPHQWZDVVXFFHVVIXOLQDOOSDWLHQWVZLWK0'EHLQJ
YVXVLQJ3(705,DQG3(7&7UHVSHFWLYHO\ 3 QV 7KH0'ZDV
DQGYVDQGIRU/$'&;DQG5&$WHUULWRULHVUHVSHFWLYHO\
3 QV &RURQDU\DQJLR05,ZDVVXFFHVVIXOLQDOOYROXQWHHUVZLWKFRURQDU\
VHJPHQWVYLVXDOLVHGRYHUDOO7KH5&$ZDVIXOO\YLVXDOLVHGLQYROXQWHHUVDQG
WKHOHIWFRURQDU\DUWHULHVLQYROXQWHHUV$VVHVVDELOLW\LQYLVXDOLVHGVHJPHQWV
ZDVJRRGVXERSWLPDODQGQRQDVVHVVDEOHLQDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ+\EULG3(705,GHYLFHVPD\HQDEOHPHWDEROLFHYDOXDWLRQFRPSD
UDEOHWR3(7&7ZLWKDGGLWLRQDOYDOXHRZLQJWRDFFXUDWHIXQFWLRQDODQGDQDWRPLFDO
LQIRUPDWLRQLQFOXGLQJFRURQDU\DVVHVVPHQW
%
,VDQJLRJUDSKLFSHUIXVLRQVFRUHDVVHVVHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWH
P\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQFRUUHODWHGZLWKFDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
LQIDUFWVL]HDQG1WHUPLQDOSUREUDLQQDWULXUHWLFSHSWLGHLQPRQWK
IROORZXS
$$%U]R]RZVND&]DUQHN$8UEDQLN75DNRZVNL.UDNRZ3/
3XUSRVH$LPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRDQDO\VHWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ$36DQG&05
LQIDUFWVL]HDQG/)IXQFWLRQSDUDPHWHUVLQPRQWKIROORZXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDFRKRUWRISDWLHQWVZLWK67(0,WUHDWHGZLWK3&,
$36ZDVFDOFXODWHGIRULQIDUFWUHODWHGDUWHU\EDVHGRQDQJLRJUDSKLFSDUDPHWHUVDQG
ZDVGHÀQHGDVWKHVXPRIWKH7,0,ÁRZJUDGH SRLQWV DQGWKH7,0,P\RFDUGLDO
SHUIXVLRQJUDGH SRLQWV EHIRUHDQGDIWHU3&, UDQJHRISRLQWVIURPWR )XOO
SHUIXVLRQZDVGHÀQHGDV$36%DUHPHWDOVWHQWVZHUHXVHGGXULQJSULPDU\
3&,,QSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLYHVVHOGLVHDVH3&,ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQWKHLQIDUFWUHODWHG
DUWHU\&05SDUDPHWHUVDQG17SUR%13ZHUHDVVHVVHGDWPRQWKV
5HVXOWV0HGLDQ$36ZDVSRLQWV$36ZDVSUHVHQWLQRISDWLHQWV
7KHVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ$36DQG&05LQIDUFWVL]H U
3 &05OHIWYHQWULFXODU /9 HMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ U 3
/9HQGGLDVWROLFYROXPHLQGH[ U 3 /9HQGV\VWROLFYROXPHLQGH[
U 3 17SUR%13 U 3 3DWLHQWVZLWK$36
KDGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQIDUFWVL]H/9YROXPHVKLJKHU()DQGORZHU17SUR%13
&RQFOXVLRQ$36DVVHVVHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWK67(0,WUHDWHGZLWK3&,LVDJRRGSUH
GLFWRURILQIDUFWVL]HDQGOHIWYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQLQPRQWKIROORZXS7KHUHZDVD
VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQRI$36DQG&05SDUDPHWHUVDQG17SUR%13DIWHUPRQWKV
%
,QYLYR05,FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIWKHP\RFDUGLXPZLWKDGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHLQ7
$$OEHULFK%D\DUUL68ULEH-6DQFKH]*RQ]OH]56DQ]5HTXHQD
6&RVWD/0DUWL%RQPDWL9DOHQFLD(66DQWLDJRGH&KLOH&/0DGULG(6
DDOEHULFKYDO#TXLURQHV
3XUSRVH+HDUWPRWLRQOLPLWVWKHXVHRI05GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG 05': VHTXHQFHV
LQURXWLQHO\FDUGLDFH[DPLQDWLRQGXHWRWKHWLPHUHTXLUHGE\WKHSDLURIJUDGLHQW
SXOVHV 2XU REMHFWLYH ZDV WR GHÀQH DQ 05 VHTXHQFH ZKLFK FRXOG EH XVHG WR
TXDQWLWDWLYHO\DQDO\VHLQYLYRP\RFDUGLXPWLVVXHGLIIXVLRQLQKXPDQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QYLYRFDUGLDF05GLIIXVLRQLPDJHVZHUHDFTXLUHGLQ
DSRSXODWLRQRIKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV DJH\HDUV XVLQJD705V\VWHP
$FKLHYD7;3KLOLSV+HDOWKFDUH DQGDVXUIDFHFRLOZLWKFKDQQHOV7KHSXOVH
VHTXHQFHZDVDVSLQHFKRHFKRSODQDULPDJLQJ 6((3, ZLWKD7(RIPVWKH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
75V\QFKURQLVHGZLWKHYHU\RWKHU(&*SXOVH7KHVHOHFWHGEYDOXHVZHUHDQG
VPP)DWZDVVXSSUHVVHGE\D63$,5FRQÀJXUDWLRQLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWK
JUDGLHQWUHYHUVDOSXOVHV7KHDFTXLVLWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGLQGLDVWROHDQGWKHGHOD\LQ
WKH55SHULRGZDVFDOFXODWHGIURPDKLJKWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQVHTXHQFHSHUIRUPHG
LPPHGLDWHO\EHIRUHWKHGLIIXVLRQDFTXLVLWLRQ6OLFHVZHUHDFTXLUHGLQEUHDWKKROGV
RIV7KHVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQZDVRI[[PPLQVKRUWD[LVVOLFHVDORQJWKH
OHIWYHQWULFOH$IWHUFRUHJLVWHULQJWKHLPDJHVWRWKHORZHVWEYDOXHWKHP\RFDUGLXP
ZDVVHJPHQWHGDQGWKH$'&FDOFXODWHGYR[HOE\YR[HO
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHVREWDLQHGLQWKHP\RFDUGLXPRIWKHVXEMHFWVZHUH
>PPV@,PDJHVSUHVHQWHGDJRRG615DQGDEVHQFHRIJHRPHWU\
GLVWRUWLRQDUWHIDFWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH05':GHVFULEHGWHFKQLTXHFDQEHSHUIRUPHGHIÀFLHQWO\ZLWK
DQDFFXUDWHV\QFKURQLVDWLRQRIWKHDFTXLVLWLRQWRWKH55F\FOHDQGPD\KHOSWR
DQDO\VHP\RFDUGLDOVWUXFWXUHLQGLIIHUHQWGLVHDVHV
$FXWHFRURQDU\V\QGURPHZLWKQRUPDOFRURQDU\DUWHULHVDQGSRVLWLYH
HQ]\PHVGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVZLWKFDUGLDF05,
0'DQWL66EDUEDWL*&DPDVWUD1$OVDGL)0DUFRQL6:'HOOD6DOD
5RPH,7 PDVVLPLOLDQRGDQWL#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R GHPRQVWUDWH WKH UROH RI FDUGLDF 05, LQ WKH GLIIHUHQWLDO GLDJQRVLV
RIP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQZLWKQRUPDOFRURQDU\DUWHULHVDQGRWKHUIRUPVRIKHDUW
GLVHDVHZLWKLQIDUFWOLNHSUHVHQWDWLRQ P\RFDUGLWLV7DNRWVXERHWF 6WXG\GHVLJQ
SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\SHUIRUPHGLQDVLQJOHFHQWUHRQSDWLHQWVDGPLWWHGWRRXU87,&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKFKHVWSDLQHOHFWURFDUGLR
JUDSKLFFKDQJHVVLPLODULQW\SHLQIDUFWHOHYDWHG7URSRQLQDQGFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
ZLWKHYLGHQFHRIQRUPDOFRURQDU\DUWHULHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKLQRQHZHHNRIRQVHW
RIV\PSWRPVDFDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHZLWKFRQWUDVWDJHQW ,17(5$7
3KLOLSV0HGLFDO6\VWHPV%HVW7KH1HWKHUODQGV
5HVXOWV 0DJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH LPDJLQJ VKRZHG LQ SDWLHQWV WKH SUHVHQFH RI
VLJQLÀFDQWPRUSKRIXQFWLRQDODOWHUDWLRQVLQWHUPVRIGLDJQRVWLFLQSDWLHQWVQR
SDWKRORJLFDOFKDQJHVZHUHREVHUYHG,QSDWLHQWVZDVIRXQGODWHHQKDQFHPHQW
LQ SDWLHQWV WKH ORFDOLVDWLRQ ZDV FRPSDWLEOH ZLWK P\RFDUGLDO LQIDUFWLRQ LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKP\RFDUGLWLV,QSDWLHQWVZKLFKZDVQRWSUHVHQWODWHHQKDQFHPHQW
WKHUHZDVDVHYHUHFDUGLDFDNLQHVLDLQWKHDSLFDOVHJPHQWVDYHUDJHIUDPHZRUN
FRPSDWLEOHZLWK7DNRWVXERV\QGURPH
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH FDUGLDF 05, PD\ KDYH NH\ UROH LQ WKH GLIIHUHQWLDO GLDJQR
VLV RI DFXWH FRURQDU\ V\QGURPHV ZLWK QRUPDO FRURQDU\ DUWHULHV DQG RU RWKHU
FDUGLRP\RSDWKLHV
%
,PSURYHGDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQH[SHULHQFHGDQGLQH[SHULHQFHG
REVHUYHUVXVLQJDVWDQGDUGLVHGHYDOXDWLRQSURWRFROIRUFDUGLDF
YROXPHWU\DQGLQIDUFWVL]HPHDVXUHPHQW
*./XQG.0OOHUOHLOH0*URWK'6ULQJ7.OLQLN6+DODM*)ROZDUVNL
0.DXO*$GDP+DPEXUJ'( JOXQG#XNHGH
3XUSRVH 7R VWXG\ WKH DJUHHPHQW EHWZHHQ H[SHULHQFHG DQG LQH[SHULHQFHG
REVHUYHUVEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWUDLQLQJXVLQJDVWDQGDUGLVHGHYDOXDWLRQSURWRFROIRU
FDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ &05 PHDVXUHPHQWVRIOHIWYHQWULFXODU /9
YROXPHVPDVVDQGLQIDUFWVL]H
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&05VWXGLHVIURPSDWLHQWVZLWKP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUF
WLRQZHUHHYDOXDWHG)LUVW&05VWXGLHVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\H[SHULHQFHGDQG
LQH[SHULHQFHGREVHUYHUVZLWKUHVSHFWWRHQGGLDVWROLFYROXPH ('9 HQGV\VWROLF
YROXPH (69 HMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ () /9PDVVDQGLQIDUFWVL]H3ODQLPHWULFPHDV
XUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQVKRUWD[LVVOLFHV 6LPSVRQVPHWKRG XVLQJDKHDUW
DQDO\VLVWRRO +H$7 6XEVHTXHQWO\WKHLQH[SHULHQFHGREVHUYHUVZHUHWUDLQHGXVLQJ
DVWDQGDUGLVHGHYDOXDWLRQSURWRFRO7KHUHDIWHUDOOREVHUYHUVDQDO\VHGDQRWKHU
&05VWXGLHV$JUHHPHQWDQGYDULDQFHZDVFRPSDUHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWUDLQLQJ
XVLQJ%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV %HIRUH WUDLQLQJ WKH UHODWLYH GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ H[SHULHQFHG DQG LQH[
SHULHQFHGREVHUYHUVZDVIRU('9IRU(69
IRU()IRU/9PDVVDQGIRULQIDUFWVL]H$IWHUWUDLQLQJ
DJUHHPHQWVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGWRIRU('9 3 IRU(69
3 IRU() 3 DQGIRULQIDUFWVL]H 3
6OLFHEDVHG DQDO\VLV VKRZHG WKDW LQFOXVLRQ RI WKH PRVW EDVDO DQG DSLFDO VOLFHV
ZHUHPDLQO\UHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHLQLWLDOORZDJUHHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ7UDLQLQJDQGDGKHUHQFHWRWKHSURSRVHGHYDOXDWLRQSURWRFROVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\LPSURYHGWKHDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQH[SHULHQFHGDQGLQH[SHULHQFHGREVHUYHUV
IRU/9YROXPHV()DQGLQIDUFWVL]H7KHSURSRVHGHYDOXDWLRQSURWRFROFDQEHXVHG
DVDJXLGHOLQHIRUWHDFKLQJRIQRYHO&05H[DPLQHUV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH7PDSSLQJLQDFXWHP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQ
IURPFRUHWRSHULSKHU\
.8%DXQHU'7KHLVHQ76DQGQHU0)5HLVHU%:LQWHUVSHUJHU
0XQLFK'( GDQLHOWKHLVHQ#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH 7 FKDUDFWHULVWLFV RI DFXWH P\RFDUGLDO LQIDUFWLRQ $0,
DQGWRGHOLQHDWH$0,LQSUHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGP\RFDUGLDO7PDSSLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHDQDJHIHPDOHV ZLWK$0,
G XQGHUZHQW FDUGLDF 05, DIWHU DFXWH SHUFXWDQHRXV FRURQDU\ LQWHUYHQWLRQ RQ D
7VFDQQHU 0DJQHWRP$YDQWR ZLWKHOHPHQWFRLO)RU7PDSSLQJSXUSRVHV
DPRGLÀHG/RRN/RFNHULQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\ 02//, VHTXHQFHZDVDSSOLHGSUHDQG
PLQSRVWFRQWUDVW PPRONJ*DGREXWURO DWWKUHHVKRUWD[LVVOLFHSRVLWLRQV
7HYDOXDWLRQZDVEDVHGRQPHDVXUHPHQWVZLWKGLIIHUHQW7,WLPHVFOXVWHUHGLQ
JURXSVGXULQJ7UHOD[DWLRQ3UHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVW7PDSVZHUHFDOFXODWHGDQG
$0,ZDVGHÀQHGKDYLQJDFXWRIIRI!VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQV 6' DVFRPSDUHGWR
7YDOXHVRIQRUPDOP\RFDUGLXP 0<2 52,EDVHGPHDVXUHPHQWVRI7YDOXHV
RI$0, QRUPDO P\RFDUGLXP 0<2 DQG RI P\RFDUGLDOYDVFXODUREVWUXFWLRQ LI
SUHVHQW LQWKH$0,FRUH 092 ZHUHSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV 7KH FRPSDULVRQ RI 7 YDOXHV RI$0, DQG 0<2 UHYHDOHG VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHV LQ SUHFRQWUDVW VFDQV PV YV PV S
7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHRI092 PV FRPSDUHGWR$0,RU
0<23RVWFRQWUDVW7YDOXHVRI$0,0<2DQG092GURSSHGE\DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHGLIIHUHQFHVRI7YDOXHVLQ$0,DQG0<2ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQW
PVYVPVS 7YDOXHVRI092ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
FRPSDUHGWR$0, PVS KRZHYHUWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHU
HQFHEHWZHHQ092DQG0<2
&RQFOXVLRQ7 YDOXHV RI DFXWH P\RFDUGLDO LQIDUFWLRQ DUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHQW
FRPSDUHGWRQRUPDOP\RFDUGLXPLQERWKSUHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVWLPDJLQJ
%
5LJKWYHQWULFXODULQYROYHPHQWLQDFXWHOHIWYHQWULFXODUP\RFDUGLDO
LQIDUFWLRQSURJQRVWLFLPSOLFDWLRQVRIFDUGLDF05,ÀQGLQJV
76FKORVVHU&-HQVHQ2%UXGHU.1DVVHQVWHLQ
(VVHQ'( WKRPDVVFKORVVHU#XQLGXHGH
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSUHYDOHQFHDQGSURJQRV
WLFLPSRUWDQFHRIWKHFDUGLDF05,ÀQGLQJRIULJKWYHQWULFXODULQYROYHPHQWLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKDFXWH67VHJPHQWHOHYDWLRQP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQ 0,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIW\SDWLHQWVZLWKÀUVW67VHJPHQWHOHYDWLRQ0,XQGHUZHQW
7FDUGLDF05,LPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUVXFFHVVIXOSHUFXWDQHRXVFRURQDU\LQWHUYHQ
WLRQ7KH05,SURWRFROLQFOXGHGLQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\)/$6+GHOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQW
VHTXHQFHV DIWHU FRQWUDVW DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ IRU WKH TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI P\RFDUGLDO
GDPDJH7KHSUHYDOHQFHRIULJKWYHQWULFXODULQYROYHPHQWGHWHFWHGZLWK(&*DQG
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHSUHYDOHQFHGHWHFWHGZLWKFDUGLDF05,
ZKLFKZDVWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG3DWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWIROORZXSIRUPRQWKV
5HVXOWV 5LJKW YHQWULFXODU LQYROYHPHQW ZDV GLDJQRVHG ZLWK FDUGLDF 05, LQ
SDWLHQWV RISDWLHQWV ZLWKLQIHULRU67VHJPHQWHOHYDWLRQ0,DQG
RISDWLHQWV ZLWKDQWHULRU67VHJPHQWHOHYDWLRQ0,3DWLHQWVZLWKULJKW
YHQWULFXODU LQYROYHPHQW LQ DQWHULRU 67VHJPHQW HOHYDWLRQ 0, KDG ODUJHU LQIDUFWV
GHOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQWYVS ORZHUOHIW
YHQWULFXODUHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ YVS DQGORZHU
ULJKWYHQWULFXODUHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ YVS WKDQ
WKRVH ZLWKRXW ULJKW YHQWULFXODU LQYROYHPHQW ,Q D PXOWLYDULDWH ORJLVWLF UHJUHVVLRQ
PRGHO ULJKW YHQWULFXODU LQYROYHPHQW ZDV D VWURQJ LQGHSHQGHQW SUHGLFWRU RGGV
UDWLR&, RIPDMRUFDUGLDFDGYHUVHHYHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ5LJKWYHQWULFXODULQYROYHPHQWLQ67VHJPHQWHOHYDWLRQ0,LVGHWHFWHG
PRUHIUHTXHQWO\ZLWKFDUGLDF05,WKDQZLWK(&*DQGHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DQGLVDQ
LQGHSHQGHQWSURJQRVWLFLQGLFDWRU
%
9DOXHRIFDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWH
FKHVWSDLQHOHYDWHGFDUGLDFHQ]\PHVDQGDQHJDWLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDP
7(PULFK.(PULFK1$EHJXQHZDUGHQH.2EHUKRO]HU70XHQ]HO
&'XHEHU.).UHLWQHU0DLQ]'( HPULFK#UDGLRORJLHNOLQLNXQLPDLQ]GH
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIFDUGLDF05,LQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHFKHVWSDLQ
HOHYDWHGFDUGLDFHQ]\PHVDQGDQHJDWLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDPDQGDQDO\VHIDFWRUV
RILQÁXHQFHRQWKHDFFXUDF\RIWKHGLDJQRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDPRQWKSHULRGSDWLHQWVIURPWKHFKHVWSDLQ
XQLWFRXOGEHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\7KH05LPDJLQJSURWRFROZDVNHSWDVVLPSOHDV
SRVVLEOHDQGFRQVLVWHGRIFLQHRHGHPDVHQVLWLYHDQGODWHJDGROLQLXPHQKDQFHPHQW
LPDJLQJ&OLQLFDOIROORZXSDQGWKHV\QRSVLVRIDOOFOLQLFDOODERUDWRU\DQGLPDJLQJ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
%
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
GDWDZHUHWKHEDVLVIRUHVWDEOLVKLQJDFRQVHQVXVEDVHGGLDJQRVLV7KLVGLDJQRVLV
VHUYHGDVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV %HVLGHV WKH ÀYH PDLQ GLDJQRVHV LVFKDHPLF FDUGLRP\RSDWK\ GLODWLYH
FDUGLRP\RSDWK\P\RFDUGLWLV7DNR7VXERFDUGLRP\RSDWK\DQGK\SHUWHQVLYHFDUGLR
P\RSDWK\Q WKHUHZHUHPLVFHOODQHRXVFDUGLDFGLDJQRVHV HJK\SHUWURSKLF
FDUGLRP\RSDWK\FDUGLDFDP\ORLGRVLVRUQRQFRPSDFWLRQFDUGLRP\RSDWK\Q
&RPSDUHGZLWKWKHÀQDOVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFHGLDJQRVLVF05,HQDEOHGHVWDEOLVKLQJ
WKHÀQDOGLDJQRVLVLQSDWLHQWV 2QO\LQSDWLHQWVF05,FRXOGQRW
GHWHFWWKHÀQDOGLDJQRVLV)XUWKHUDQDO\VLVVKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEH
WZHHQDJHVH[DQGWLPHWRF05,H[DPLQDWLRQDQGWKHFRUUHFWQHVVRIWKHGLDJQRVLV
S! 7KHRQO\LPSRUWDQWIDFWRUZDVWKHNLQGRIGLDJQRVLVLWVHOI
&RQFOXVLRQ F05, KHOSV HVWDEOLVKLQJ WKH ÀQDO GLDJQRVLV LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK DFXWH
FKHVWSDLQHOHYDWHGFDUGLDFHQ]\PHVDQGDQHJDWLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDPLQWKH
YDVWPDMRULW\RIFDVHV$JHVH[DQGWLPHWRH[DPLQDWLRQKDGQRLQÁXHQFHRQWKH
DFFXUDF\RIWKHGLDJQRVLV
%
3DUWLWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWIRUJDGROLQLXPFKHODWHVLQWKHQRUPDO
P\RFDUGLXPFRPSDULVRQRIJDGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQHDQG
JDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH
1.DZHO01DFLI)6DQWLQL6/LX-%UHPHULFK$$UDL'%OXHPNH
%HWKHVGD0'86%DVOH&+ QDGLQHNDZHO#JP[GH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHLQÁXHQFHRIFRQWUDVWDJHQWVZLWKGLIIHUHQWUHOD[LYLW\RQ
WKHSDUWLWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW Ѥ DQGWLPLQJRIHTXLOLEUDWLRQXVLQJDPRGLÀHGORRNORFNHU
LQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\ 02//, VHTXHQFHLQFDUGLDF05,
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 02//, ZDV DFTXLUHG LQ KHDOWK\ VXEMHFWV 7 DW
PLGYHQWULFXODUVKRUWD[LVSUHFRQWUDVWDQGDQGPLQDIWHULQWUDYH
QRXVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIDEROXVRIHLWKHUPPRONJ*DGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH
*G%237$ Q RU*DGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQH *G'73$ Q XVLQJWKH
IROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUV7(75PVÁLSDQJOHEDQGZLGWK+]3[
VOLFHWKLFNQHVVPP7WLPHVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQP\RFDUGLXPDQGEORRGSRRO
Ѥ ZDV DSSUR[LPDWHG E\ 70\RFDUGLXP SUHFRQWUDVW 70\RFDUGLXP SRVW
FRQWUDVW 7%ORRGSRROSUHFRQWUDVW7%ORRGSRROSRVWFRQWUDVW 9DOXHVIRU
*G%237$DQG*G'73$ZHUHFRPSDUHG WWHVW ,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDV
HYDOXDWHG LQWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW>,&&@
5HVXOWV 2YHUDOO VFDQV SUHFRQWUDVW DQG DW WLPHSRLQWV SRVWFRQWUDVW
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQLQVXEMHFWVZHUHHYDOXDWHG7WLPHVRIP\RFDUGLXPDQGEORRG
SRRO S DQGѤ DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\SH[FOXG
LQJPLQIRU*G%237$ ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRU*G%237$WKDQ*G'73$
Ѥ *G'73$ VKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWYDULDWLRQEHWZHHQDQGPLQѤ *G%237$
YDOXHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUDWPLQFRPSDUHGWRRWKHUWLPHV YV
S ,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRUѤYDOXHVZDVH[FHOOHQWZLWK*G%237$
,&& DQGJRRGIRU*G'73$ ,&&
&RQFOXVLRQѤ *G%237$ YDOXHVDUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUFRPSDUHGWRѤ *G'73$
DWWKHVDPHDGPLQLVWHUHGGRVH8VLQJ*G%237$WKHHTXLOLEULXPEHWZHHQP\R
FDUGLXPDQGEORRGSRROLVQRWDFKLHYHGXQWLOPLQSRVWFRQWUDVW
5RRP=
&RPSXWHU$SSOLFDWLRQV
66
,PDJHSURFHVVLQJ SDUW
0RGHUDWRUV
3%DGXUD*OLZLFH3/
(.RWWHU)UHLEXUJ'(
%
$XWRPDWHGGHWHFWLRQDQGYROXPHWULFVHJPHQWDWLRQRIWKHVSOHHQLQ
&7VFDQVRISDWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQWO\PSKRPD
0+DPPRQ5-DQND66HLIHUW0.UDPHU08GHU$&DYDOODUR
(UODQJHQ'( PDWWKLDVKDPPRQ#XNHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH:HLQWURGXFHDQDXWRPDWHGGHWHFWLRQDQGYROXPHWULFVHJPHQWDWLRQRI
WKHVSOHHQLQVSLUDO&7VFDQV&RUUHODWLRQDQDO\VLVRIDXWRPDWHGYROXPHWU\ D9
HVWLPDWHG YROXPH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ H9 DQG PDQXDO YROXPH VHJPHQWDWLRQ P9
ZDVSHUIRUPHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGWKH7+(6(860(',&2
&$'V\VWHPRQVSLUDO&7VFDQVRIFRQVHFXWLYHO\PSKRPDSDWLHQWVDWWKUHH
FRQVHFXWLYHWLPHSRLQWV'HWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHH9 VSOHQLFYROXPH FPó FPó
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
:[/[7K DQGP9DVWKHJROGVWDQGDUGZHUHSHUIRUPHGE\DQH[SHUL
HQFHGUDGLRORJLVW
5HVXOWV7KHDXWRPDWHGYROXPHWU\ D9 FRXOGEHSHUIRUPHGLQDOO&7VFDQVZLWKLQ
DSSUR[LPDWHO\ VHFRQGV 7KH DYHUDJH VSOHQLF YROXPH PHDVXUHG E\ D9 ZDV
FPóFRPSDUHGWRFPóLQPDQXDOYROXPHVHJPHQWDWLRQ P9 DQG
FPóLQHVWLPDWHGYROXPHGHWHUPLQDWLRQ H9 7KHFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWRI
D9DQGP9ZDVRIP9DQGH9DQGRID9DQGH97KHUHZDVDQ
DOPRVW SHUIHFW FRUUHODWLRQ RI WKH FKDQJHV LQ VSOHQLF YROXPH PHDVXUHG ZLWK WKH
QHZD9DQGP9 P9DQGH9 DQGD9DQGH9 EHWZHHQWZRWLPH
SRLQWV$OOYDOXHVDUHVLJQLÀFDQW S
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUDXWRPDWHGGHWHFWLRQDQGYROXPHWULFVHJPHQWDWLRQVRIWZDUHUDS
LGO\SURYLGHVREMHFWLYHDQGUHDGHULQGHSHQGHQWPHDVXUHPHQWRIWKHVSOHQLFYROXPH
LQ&7VFDQV7KHDXWRPDWHGYROXPHWU\LVQRWDVWLPHFRQVXPLQJDVPDQXDOYRO
XPHWU\6SOHQLFYROXPHFKDQJHVFDQSURYLGHHYLGHQFHRIWKHFRXUVHRIO\PSKRPD
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIDQHZ'YLVXDOLVDWLRQWHFKQLTXHLQ&7
FRORQRJUDSK\WKH)XQQHOYLHZFRPSDUHGWRVWDQGDUGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQ
VWUDWHJLHVDQGRWKHUUHFHQW'UHQGHULQJWHFKQRORJLHV
)&KDQGHOLHU/6WHLQ7&DEUHUD*UDQE\4&&$0RQWUHDO4&&$
3XUSRVH7KHVWXG\REMHFWLYHLVWRDVVHVVWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQHZ'UHQGHU
LQJWHFKQLTXHDSSOLHGWR&7FRORQRJUDSK\ &7& QDPHO\WKH)XQQHOYLHZ )9 ,W
DLPVDWDGGUHVVLQJFXUUHQWUHYLHZLQJVKRUWFRPLQJVGXULQJXQLDQGELGLUHFWLRQDO
VWDQGDUG UHYLHZV 869 %69 VXFK DV OLPLWHG FRORQLF VXUIDFH FRYHUDJH GH
VSLWH ORQJ UHYLHZLQJWLPH >(XU5DGLRO @ DQG WKH KLJKHU GHJUHH
RI GLVWRUWLRQV DQG UHGXFHG ´SRO\S GLVSOD\ WLPHµ RI QHZ UHQGHULQJ WHFKQLTXHV
>(XU5DGLRO @
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HGHVLJQHGDXQLTXH'YLUWXDOOHQVDUUDQJLQJUD\V
WUDQVPLVVLRQEDVHGRQWKHEHVWUD\FDVWLQJVWUDWHJ\RSWLPLVLQJWKHUHVSHFWLYHÀHOG
RIYLHZ,WDOORZVIRUGLVWRUWLRQOLPLWHGYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIDUHDVEHKLQGIROGVZLWKLQD
WUDGLWLRQDOSHUVSHFWLYHUHQGHULQJHQGRVFRS\YDOLGDWHG&7&GDWDVHWVZLWKJRRG
FRORQLF GLVWHQVLRQV ZHUH LQYROYHG LQ WKLV UHWURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ WR FRPSDUH 869
%69DQG)9'PDQXDOÁ\WKURXJKZDVGHHPHGUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGE\PDQXDOO\
DVVHVVLQJWKHFRPSOHWHFRORQLFVXUIDFHYLVLEOH)XUWKHUPRUH)9ZLOOEHLQYROYHG
LQ DQ DFDGHPLF SURWRFRO 0F*LOO 8QLYHUVLW\ 4XHEHF &DQDGD WR SURVSHFWLYHO\
LQYHVWLJDWHLWVFRQWULEXWLRQWR&7&UHYLHZV
5HVXOWV$VLQJOHÁ\WKURXJKZLWK)9UHQGHUHGRIWKHYLVLEOHFRORQLFPXFRVD
FRPSDUHGWRDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\IRUWKH869DQG%'9,QDGGLWLRQLW
VLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGWKHGLVSOD\WLPHFORVHUWRWKHGLVSOD\SHULSKHU\UHTXLUHGIRU
TXDOLW\DVVHVVPHQWRISRWHQWLDOOHVLRQVZLWKRXWLQGXFLQJPDMRUGLVWRUWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ)XQQHOYLHZIRU&7&SURYLGHVDWLPHHIÀFLHQWLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVWUDWHJ\
WRDVVHVVWKHHQWLUHFRORQLFPXFRVDZLWKDVLQJOHDXWRPDWLFÁ\WKURXJKLQFUHDVLQJ
SRWHQWLDOOHVLRQFRQVSLFXLW\DQGGLVSOD\WLPH,WKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRVLJQLÀFDQWO\
UHGXFHUHYLHZLQJWLPHZKLOHPDLQWDLQLQJVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
%
&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ZLWKN9WXEHYROWDJHDQGDORZQRLVH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQÀOWHULQQRQREHVHSDWLHQWVHYDOXDWLRQRIUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHDQGGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\RI'DQG'LPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
XVLQJRSHQVRXUFHVRIWZDUH 2VLUL;
/)DJJLRQL0%LDQFKL30DUUDFFLQL/'ҋ(UULFR(1HUL'&DUDPHOOD
&%DUWROR]]L3LVD,7 OIDJJLRQL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\RI'DQG'LPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
IURP&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7&$ VWXGLHVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDWXEHYROWDJHRI
N9DQGDORZQRLVHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQÀOWHU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )LIW\ QRQREHVH SDWLHQWV ZLWK FRPSDUDEOH ERG\PDVV
LQGH[ %0, XQGHUZHQW&7&$XVLQJDURZ&7VFDQQHU2XWRIWKHPZHUH
LPDJHGXVLQJDWXEHYROWDJHRIN9DQGDORZQRLVH 6RIW UHFRQVWUXFWLRQÀOWHU
ZKLOHLQWKHUHPDLQLQJSDWLHQWVDWXEHYROWDJHRIN9DQGDVWDQGDUGUHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQNHUQHOZHUHVHOHFWHG0D[LPXPLQWHQVLW\SURMHFWLRQ 0,3 FXUYHGSODQDU
UHIRUPDWLRQ &35 DQGYROXPHUHQGHULQJ 95 YLHZVZHUHJHQHUDWHGXVLQJRSHQ
VRXUFHVRIWZDUH 2VLUL;ZZZRVLUL[YLHZHUFRP DQGWKHLUGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\
ZDVDVVHVVHGYLVXDOO\XVLQJDWKUHHSRLQWVFRUH SRRUJRRGH[FHOOHQW
5HVXOWV (IIHFWLYH GRVH ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU ZLWK WKH N9 WKDQ ZLWK WKH
N9SURWRFRO P6YYVP6YS ,PDJHTXDOLW\RIDOO
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZDVJRRGWRH[FHOOHQWERWKDWN9DQGN9ZLWKDVWDWLVWLFDO
WUHQGWRZDUGVEHWWHUTXDOLW\RI&35YLHZVZLWKWKHN9ORZQRLVHÀOWHUSURWRFRO
0,3YVS 95YVS
&35YVS UHVSHFWLYHO\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSDUHGZLWKDVWDQGDUGWXEHYROWDJHRIN9XVDJHRIN9
DQGDORZQRLVHÀOWHUOHDGVWRDVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQRIUDGLDWLRQGRVHZLWKHTXLYDOHQW
GLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\RI0,395DQG&35UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVLQQRQREHVHSDWLHQWV
%
,PDJHUHJLVWUDWLRQEH\RQG3(7&7DGYDQFHGUHJLVWUDWLRQRI[UD\
DQG05PDPPRJUDPVLVIHDVLEOHDQGSURYLGHVPRUSKRORJLFDODQG
IXQFWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQDWDJODQFH
0'LHW]HO7+RSS195XLWHU:$.DLVHU3$7%DOW]HU-HQD'(
.DUOVUXKH'(
%
7UDEHFXODUGLUHFWLRQDQGGHIRUPDWLRQGLVWULEXWLRQLQOXQJWUDQVSODQW
SDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHRVWHRSRURVLVULVN
/)LVFKHU-3DWVFK$9DOHQWLQLWVFK&6FKXHOOHU:HLGHNDPP
%=ZH\WLFN).DLQEHUJHU*/DQJV9LHQQD$76DQ)UDQFLVFR&$86
OXNDVDÀVFKHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH1HZRQVHWRVWHRSRURVLVRUSURJUHVVLRQRIDSUHH[LVWLQJGLVHDVHZLWK
ERQHIUDFWXUHVZLWKLQWKHÀUVW\HDUVDIWHUOXQJWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ /X7; LVDVHYHUH
EXWSRRUO\XQGHUVWRRGSUREOHP+LJKUHVROXWLRQSHULSKHUDOTXDQWLWDWLYHFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ +5S4&7 RIIHUVQRYHORSWLRQVIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIGLVHDVHSURJUHV
VLRQ,WSURYLGHVYROXPHWULF%0'GHWDLOHGFRUWLFDOERQHJHRPHWU\DQGWUDEHFXODU
PLFURDUFKLWHFWXUH:HSURSRVHDQGHYDOXDWHDQRYHORSWLFDOÁRZEDVHGUHJLVWUDWLRQ
DSSURDFKWRFDSWXUHWUDEHFXODUUHRUJDQLVDWLRQDQGREVHUYHVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQ/X7;LQGLFDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV LQGLFDWLRQJURXSV D YDVFXODUGLVHDVHV E
F\VWLFÀEURVLV F SDUHQFK\PDOGLVHDVHV ZHUHVFDQQHGZLWK+5S4&7DWEDVHOLQH
DQGPRQWKVDIWHU/X7;7RFDSWXUHWUDEHFXODUUHRUJDQLVDWLRQWKHYROXPHVZHUH
ULJLGO\ UHJLVWHUHG 6XEVHTXHQWO\ WUDEHFXODU GHIRUPDWLRQ ZDV PHDVXUHG XVLQJ
RSWLFDOÁRZ:HREWDLQHGGHIRUPDWLRQÀHOGPDSVIRUHDFKFDVHDQGTXDQWLÀHGWKH
LQFUHDVHRIWUDEHFXODUWKLFNQHVVWRJHWKHUZLWKWUDEHFXODUGLUHFWLRQ(QWURS\ZDV
XVHGWRTXDQWLI\GLUHFWLRQDOGRPLQDQFH.XOOEDFN/HLEOHU ./ GLYHUJHQFHEHWZHHQ
GLUHFWLRQDQGFKDQJHGLVWULEXWLRQWRTXDQWLI\WKHUHODWLRQVKLSRIWZRPHDVXUHPHQWV
5HVXOWV1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ/X7;LQGLFDWLRQJURXSVZHUHREVHUYHG
ZKHQ FRPSDULQJ GLUHFWLRQDO GRPLQDQFH DW D VLQJOH WLPH SRLQW +RZHYHU ZKHQ
LQFOXGLQJUHRUJDQLVDWLRQLQIRUPDWLRQE\FRPELQLQJWUDEHFXODUGLUHFWLRQDQGWKLFN
QHVVFKDQJHVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV SIGUFRUUHFWHG ZHUHIRXQGEHWZHHQ
LQGLFDWLRQJURXSV D E DQG E F PHDQ./ D E F
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSXWHUEDVHGDQDO\VLVRIERQHPLFURDUFKLWHFWXUHGHWHFWHGVLJ
QLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV LQ RVWHRSRURVLV SURJUHVVLRQ DPRQJ GLIIHUHQW /X7; JURXSV
ZKLOHPLFURDUFKLWHFWXUHDVVHVVPHQWDWDVLQJOHWLPHSRLQWGRHVQRW7UDEHFXODU
UHRUJDQLVDWLRQ FDQ EH PHDVXUHG TXDQWLWDWLYHO\ LQ +5S4&7 GDWD DQG UHYHDOV
GLVHDVHVSHFLÀFSDWWHUQV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
'RHV-3(*ORVV\FRPSUHVVLRQGLVJXLVHFUDQLDOIUDFWXUHV"
0)0F(QWHH,1LNRORYVNL5%RXUQH03LHWU]\N
0(YDQRII3%UHQQDQ.7D\6\GQH\$87XVFRQ$=86
PDUNPFHQWHH#V\GQH\HGXDX
3XUSRVH7KHFXUUHQWVWXG\DLPVWRHVWDEOLVKZKHWKHUGHWHFWLRQRIFUDQLDOYDXOW
IUDFWXUHVLVDIIHFWHGE\-3(*ðDQGðORVV\FRPSUHVVLRQZKHQFRPSDUHG
WR-3(*ORVVOHVVFRPSUHVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7LPDJHVZLWKWKUHHOHYHOVRI-3(*FRPSUHV
VLRQ ORVVOHVV[ [ ZHUHSUHVHQWHGWRVHQLRUUDGLRORJLVWV,PDJHV
FRQWDLQHGDVLQJOHVNXOOIUDFWXUHZKLOHZHUHQRUPDO2EVHUYHUVZHUHDVNHGWR
LGHQWLI\WKHSUHVHQFHRUDEVHQFHRIDIUDFWXUHDQGZKHUHDIUDFWXUHZDVSUHVHQW
WRORFDWHDQGUDWHWKHLUFRQÀGHQFHLQLWVSUHVHQFH$-$)52&DQG52&PHWKRGRO
RJ\ZDVHPSOR\HGDQGWKH'%0050&PHWKRGZDVXVHGWRH[SORUHGLIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQWKHORVVOHVVDQGORVV\FRPSUHVVHGLPDJHV
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ-$)52&)20DQG52&$8&VFRUHVZLWKORVVOHVV-3(*
FRPSUHVVLRQZHUHFRPSDUHGWRIRU[ORVV\DQG
ZLWK[ORVV\6LJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHVHHQRQO\EHWZHHQ-3(*/RVV\
[DQG[ S $QRYHUDOOWUHQGRIGHFUHDVHGSHUIRUPDQFHZLWK[ORVV\
FRPSUHVVLRQZDVVHHQZKLOH-3(*ORVVOHVVDQG-3(*/RVV\[ZHUH
VHHQWRSHUIRUPHTXDOO\ S $VLJQLÀFDQWWUHQGRILQFUHDVHGFRQÀGHQFHLQ
WUXHDQGIDOVHSRVLWLYHVFRUHVZDVVHHQZLWK-3(*/RVV\[FRPSUHVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVZRUNGHPRQVWUDWHVWKDW-3(*[ORVV\FRPSUHVVLRQGH
JUDGHVWKHGHWHFWLRQRIVNXOOIUDFWXUHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZKLOHLQFUHDVLQJWKHFRQÀGHQFH
ZLWKZKLFKUHDGHUVUDWHIUDFWXUHV-3(*ORVV\FRPSUHVVLRQDW[GRHVQRW
VLJQLÀFDQWO\FKDQJHSHUIRUPDQFHZKHQFRPSDUHGWR-3(*ORVVOHVVFRPSUHV
VLRQIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIVNXOOIUDFWXUHVLQ&7
%
,QWUDRSHUDWRUYDULDELOLW\RIOLYHUVHJPHQWYROXPHWU\XVLQJYHVVHO
EDVHGDQGSODQHEDVHGWHFKQLTXHV
,0DWHND/5XVNR=9DUDGL$.ULVWRQ$3HUHQ\L=%HUHQ\L93HWURYV]NL
2'HPMHQ$3DONR6]HJHG+8 PDWHNDLORQD#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RPHDVXUHWKHLQWUDRSHUDWRUYDULDELOLW\RIOLYHUVHJPHQWYROXPHWU\7ZR
DSSURDFKHVZHUHFRPSDUHGLQSRLQWRIGLIÀFXOW\YDULDELOLW\DQGGXUDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\RUPHWDVWDWLFOLYHUWXPRXUZHUH
VHOHFWHGIURPDSXEOLFGDWDVHW KWWSVOLYHURUJ 2QHUDGLRORJLVWVHSDUDWHGWKH
&RLQDXGVHJPHQWVRQSRUWDOYHQRXV&7VFDQVXVLQJDUHVHDUFKSURWRW\SH6WDUWLQJ
IURPJROGVWDQGDUGOLYHUFRQWRXUWKHUDGLRORJLVWDSSOLHGWZRGLIIHUHQWWHFKQLTXHV,Q
WKHYHVVHOEDVHGDSSURDFKSRUWDOYHLQ 39 ZDVVHJPHQWHGIURPPDQXDOO\GHÀQHG
URRWSRLQW7KHQQRQ39VWUXFWXUHVZHUHUHPRYHGDQGWKHPDLQ39EUDQFKHV
ZHUHODEHOOHGLQGLPHQVLRQDOYLHZPDQXDOO\)LQDOO\WKHYDVFXODUWHUULWRU\EH
ORQJLQJWRHDFKODEHOOHG39EUDQFKZDVFRPSXWHG,QWKHSODQHEDVHGDSSURDFK
GLPHQVLRQDOYLHZVZHUHXVHGWRGUDZWUDFHVDORQJWKHPDLQYHLQEUDQFKHVOHIW
PLGGOHDQGULJKWKHSDWLFYHLQULJKW39DQGEUDQFKHVRIOHIW39IHHGLQJVHJPHQWV
,,DQG,,,8VLQJWKHVHWUDFHVVPRRWKVXUIDFHVZHUHFRPSXWHGZKLFKZHUHXVHG
LQDKLHUDUFKLFDORUGHUWRVHSDUDWHWKHOLYHU$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHSURFHVVHGWLPHVZLWK
ERWKPHWKRGVWKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRIYROXPHIRUHDFKVHJPHQWZDVFRPSXWHG
LQRIWKHWRWDOOLYHU DQGSURFHVVLQJWLPHZDVPHDVXUHG
5HVXOWV7KH DYHUDJH VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ LQ VHJPHQW YROXPHWU\ ZDV DQG
ZKLOHWKHSURFHVVLQJWLPHZDVDQGVHFRQGVIRUYHVVHODQGSODQH
EDVHGDSSURDFKUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHLQWUDRSHUDWRUYDULDELOLW\RIVHJPHQWYROXPHWU\GLGQRWSURYHG
WR EH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHQW IRU WKH WHFKQLTXHV 9HVVHOEDVHG DSSURDFK WDNHV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORQJHUGXHWRGLIÀFXOWLHVRIODEHOOLQJWKHULJKW39
%
)DVWDXWRPDWLFFRPSXWDWLRQRISDWKSURSRVDOVIRU&7JXLGHG
UDGLRIUHTXHQF\ 5) DEODWLRQRIPDOLJQDQWOLYHUWXPRXUVLQLWLDO
FOLQLFDOH[SHULHQFH
'6FKPLGW-%LHEHUVWHLQ&6FKXPDQQ&7UXPP6&ODVHQ
&'&ODXVVHQ3/3HUHLUD=XULFK&+%UHPHQ'(0XQLFK'(
7ELQJHQ'(+HLOEURQQ'( GLHWKDUGVFKPLGW#XV]FK
3XUSRVH7RGHPRQVWUDWHIHDVLELOLW\DQGHIIHFWLYLW\RIDIDVWDXWRPDWLFSK\VLFLDQ
LQGHSHQGHQWPHWKRGWKDWFRPSXWHVDOLVWRISDWKSURSRVDOVIRUFRPSXWHUWRPR
JUDSKLF &7 JXLGHGUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ 5)$ RIPDOLJQDQWOLYHUWXPRXUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7GDWDVHWVRISDWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQWOLYHUWXPRXUV
WUHDWHGE\&7JXLGHGKHSDWLF5)$ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG2SWLPDODFFHVV
SDWKVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGIURPWKUHHH[SHULHQFHGLQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJLVWVFRQVLGHU
LQJIROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUVGLVWDQFHWXPRXUWRVNLQDWULVNVWUXFWXUHV OXQJHSLJDVWULF
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH,PDJHUHJLVWUDWLRQRI[UD\DQG05,PDPPRJUDPV ;0DQG00 ZRXOG
DOORZFRPELQLQJPRUSKRORJLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQRI;0 HJPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQ ZLWKWRSR
JUDSKLFDQGIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVRI'00 GLIIXVLRQSHUIXVLRQHWF <HWWKHIHZ
SUHYLRXVUHVHDUFKRQWKLVWRSLFLQYHVWLJDWHGVROHO\WKHWRSRJUDSKLFUHJLVWUDWLRQRI
;0ZLWK00$FFRUGLQJO\ZH>@GHYHORSHGDVRIWZDUHDOORZLQJERWKWRSRJUDSKLF
PDWFKLQJRIEUHDVWOHVLRQDVZHOODVIXVLRQRIWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJIXQFWLRQDO05,
GDWDDQG>@HYDOXDWHGRYHUDOOUDGLRORJLFDOTXDOLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RIWKLVDSSURDFK
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVZLWKYLVLEOHPDVVOHVLRQVERWKLQ;0DQG00
ZHUHHQUROOHG%DVHGRQWKH00D´YLUWXDO;0µZDVFDOFXODWHGXVLQJRXULQKRXVH
GHYHORSHGVRIWZDUH%DVHGRQG\QDPLFHQKDQFHPHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKH00D
FRORXUFRGHGRYHUOD\ZDVFDOFXODWHGWRFKDUDFWHULVHWXPRXUYDVFXODULVDWLRQ7KLV
RYHUOD\ZDVUHJLVWHUHGZLWKWKH´YLUWXDO;0µ2YHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RI
WKHUHJLVWUDWLRQDQGIXUWKHUWLVVXHSDUDPHWHUVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WZRH[SHULHQFHG
UHDGHUVLQFRQVHQVXV
5HVXOWV SDWLHQWV ZHUH HQUROOHG UDQJH \HDUV PHDQ \HDUV ,Q DOO
SDWLHQWVIXVLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGVXFFHVVIXOO\2YHUDOODFFXUDF\ZDVGHÀQHGDVGLV
SODFHPHQWRIWKHFHQWUHVRIWKHOHVLRQEHWZHHQ;0DQG00GLYLGHGE\WKHOHVLRQ
VL]H,WUHDFKHG PHDQ 7KHFRORXUFRGHGRYHUOD\DOORZHGLGHQWLÀFDWLRQDQG
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIDOOFDVHV Q
&RQFOXVLRQ&OLQLFDOIHDVLELOLW\RIDGYDQFHG[UD\DQG05PDPPRJUDPVUHJLVWUD
WLRQFRXOGEHGHPRQVWUDWHG$VLWDOORZVFRPELQDWLRQRIWRSRJUDSKLFPRUSKRORJLF
DQGIXQFWLRQDOGDWDLQWRRQHVLQJOHLPDJHLWLVDSURPLVLQJWRROWRIXUWKHUHQKDQFH
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\DQGFOLQLFDOZRUNÁRZLQEUHDVWLPDJLQJ
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
YHVVHOVERZHO DQGDQJXODWLRQ7KHSODQQLQJVRIWZDUH 0H9LVODE&7,SURWRW\SH
)UDXQKRIHU0(9,6 %UHPHQ ZDV HYDOXDWHG ZLWK IRFXV RQ FOLQLFDOO\ XVDELOLW\ E\
PDUNV YHU\ JRRG JRRG VDWLVIDFWRU\ VXIÀFLHQW LQVXIÀFLHQW
IDLO WRGHWHUPLQHWKHEHVWSURSRVDO7KHEHVWSURSRVDOVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK
WKRVHRIWKUHHH[SHUWVE\DVFRUH EHWWHU WKHVDPHTXDOLW\ OHVVJRRG
QRWXVHIXO )RUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVWKHEHVWSURSRVDORIWKHDXWRPDWLFPHWKRG
ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHH[SHUWSURSRVDOV QRQSDUDPHWULF6SHDUPDQCV-03,1
6$6,QVWLWXWH&DU\86$
5HVXOWV$XWRPDWLF SDWK SURSRVDO FRPSXWDWLRQ ZDV VXFFHVVIXO LQ DOO FDVHV
,PDJHSURFHVVLQJWLPHZDVDSSUR[LPDWHO\VHF VHF 7KHPHDQ
PDUNRIWKHDXWRPDWLFSDWKSURSRVDOZDVGHPRQVWUDWLQJDFOLQLFDOXVDELOLW\
7KH DXWRPDWLF PHWKRG FRUUHODWHG ZHOO ZLWK WKH WKUHH H[SHUW SURSRVDOV U
U U
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH DXWRPDWLF SDWK SURSRVDO FRPSXWDWLRQ IRU &7JXLGHG 5)$ RI
PDOLJQDQWOLYHUWXPRXUVLVIHDVLEOHDQGHIIHFWLYHZLWKDJRRGFRUUHODWLRQWRH[SHUW
SURSRVDOVXVHGLQFOLQLFDOURXWLQHZRUN
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIKHSDWLFIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\VSHFWUDO&7
3/Y;/LQ-/L-*DR0.H=KHQJ]KRX&16KDQJKDL&1
%HLMLQJ&1 /YSHLMLH#FRP
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHDFFXUDF\DQGVHQVLWLYLW\RIWKHGXDOHQHUJ\VSHFWUDO
&7LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWDQGFODVVLÀFDWLRQRIIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQLQOLYHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDS
SURYHGDQGZULWWHQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZDVREWDLQHGIURPDOOSDWLHQWV7KHDXWKRUV
H[DPLQHGSDWLHQWV PHQZRPHQ ZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\VSHFWUDO&7LPDJLQJ
GXULQJWKHSODLQ&7VFDQ7KHUHZHUHKHSDWLFSDWLHQWVZLWKPLOG PRGHUDWH
DQG VHYHUH IDWW\ LQÀOWUDWLRQ UHVSHFWLYHO\ DV WKH VWXG\ JURXS QRUPDO
KHSDWLFSDWLHQWVDVWKHFRQWUROJURXS7KHGHJUHHRIIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQZDVFODVVLÀHG
DFFRUGLQJWRWKHPHDVXUHGOLYHUWRVSOHHQDWWHQXDWLRQUDWLR)DWFRQFHQWUDWLRQVLQ
WKHOLYHUZHUHGHULYHGIURPIDWEDVHGPDWHULDOGHFRPSRVLWLRQVSHFWUDO&7LPDJHV
7KHTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUEHWZHHQWKHFRQWURODQGVWXG\JURXSDQGDPRQJWKH
WKUHHKHSDWLFIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQJURXSVZHUHFRPSDUHGUHVSHFWLYHO\ WZRVDPSOHW
WHVWWKHDQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFH
5HVXOWV)DWFRQFHQWUDWLRQVLQQRUPDOKHSDWLFSDWLHQWV PJP/ GLI
IHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\IURPWKRVHSDWLHQWVZLWKKHSDWLFIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQV
3 ZLWKWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI6LJQLÀFDQWGLIIHU
HQFHVZHUHDOVRIRXQGDPRQJWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKPLOG PJP/ PRG
HUDWH PJP/ DQGVHYHUH PJP/ IDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQV
LQOLYHUUHVSHFWLYHO\ 3
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHIDWFRQFHQWUDWLRQVGHULYHGIURPWKHIDWEDVHGPDWHULDOGHFRP
SRVLWLRQLQWKHGXDOHQHUJ\VSHFWUDO&7ZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\GLIIHUHQWDPRQJSDWLHQWV
ZLWKGLIIHUHQWGHJUHHVRIIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQDQGPD\SURYLGHDTXDQWLWDWLYHPHWKRGWR
DVVHVVDQGFODVVLI\WKHKHSDWLFIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQ
%
,PSDFWRIUREXVWLPDJHSURFHVVLQJWRUHGXFHHUURULQFRPSXWDWLRQDO
KDHPRG\QDPLFV
$--RDR$0*DPEDUXWR$6HTXHLUD/LVERQ37 DQDMRDR#LVWXWOSW
3XUSRVH&DUGLRYDVFXODUGLVHDVHVDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQXPEHURIIDFWRUVWKDW
LQFOXGHELRFKHPLVWU\KDHPRG\QDPLFVDQGJHQHWLFSUHGLVSRVLWLRQ7KHVHIDFWRUV
DUHVSHFLÀFWRHDFKLQGLYLGXDODQGLWLVLPSRUWDQWWRDFFXUDWHO\UHSUHVHQWSDWLHQW
VSHFLÀFLQIRUPDWLRQLQRUGHUWRDVVHVVSDWLHQWVWDWHDWGLDJQRVLVDQGSURJQRVLV
VWDJHV+HUHZHIRFXVRQWKHHIIHFWVRIXQFHUWDLQW\LQFOLQLFDOO\DFTXLUHGPHGLFDO
LPDJLQJWRYDULDELOLW\LQWKHUHFRQVWUXFWHGYHVVHOJHRPHWU\DQGWKLVHUURUSURSDJD
WLRQWRWKHFRPSXWHGKDHPRG\QDPLFV
0HWKRGVDQGV0DWHULDOV7KHHIIHFWVRIÀOWHULQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWDQGVHJ
PHQWDWLRQRIPHGLFDOLPDJHVDUHH[DPLQHGZLWKUHODWLRQWRFKDQJHVLQWKHUHFRQ
VWUXFWHGJHRPHWU\7KHLPDJHVXVHGLQFOXGH05,DQG&7GDWDVHWVODUJHO\IRFXVHG
RQWKHFHUHEUDOYDVFXODWXUH'LIIHUHQWLPDJHSURFHVVLQJPHWKRGVDUHFKRVHQDQG
WHVWHGDQGWKHPRVWVXLWDEOHFRPELQDWLRQRIDSSURDFKHVLVGLVFXVVHG1XPHULFDO
VLPXODWLRQVRIWKHKDHPRG\QDPLFVDUHSHUIRUPHGDQGWKHLPSDFWRIYDULDELOLW\LQ
WKHYHVVHOJHRPHWU\LVFRQVLGHUHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRÁRZSDUDPHWHUVFRPPRQO\DV
VRFLDWHGZLWKGLVHDVHWUDQVSRUWDQGVWUHVVHVRQWKHYHVVHOZDOO7KHGLVFXVVLRQ
LVWKHUHIRUHZLWKDFOLQLFDOUHOHYDQFH
5HVXOWV 5HVXOWV LQGLFDWH WKDW LPDJH SUHSURFHVVLQJ FDQ VXEVWDQWLDOO\ DOWHU WKH
TXDOLW\ RI WKH LPDJH WR LPSURYH YHVVHO H[WUDFWLRQ7KLV UHPRYHV D FHUWDLQ OHYHO
RIXQFHUWDLQW\LQWKHVHJPHQWDWLRQSURFHVV1HYHUWKHOHVVFDUHPXVWEHWDNHQWR
FKRRVHDSSURSULDWHDQGUREXVWVFKHPHV5HVXOWVRIFRPSXWDWLRQDOKDHPRG\QDPLFV
DUHSUHVHQWHGZLWKHUURUEDUV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
&RQFOXVLRQ$XWRPDWLFSURFHGXUHVIRUPHGLFDOLPDJHSURFHVVLQJDQGJHRPHWU\
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQDUHLPSRUWDQWLQDQDO\VLQJFOLQLFDOGDWD5REXVWVFKHPHVDUHSUR
SRVHGUHGXFLQJWKHHIIHFWRIHUURUVLQVXEVHTXHQWDQDO\VLVDQGSRVWSURFHVVLQJ
5RRP&
2QFRORJLF,PDJLQJ
66
&RORUHFWDOFDQFHUDVVHVVLQJWXPRXUEHKDYLRXU
0RGHUDWRUV
5*+%HHWV7DQ0DDVWULFKW1/
3$%RQDIÀQL0RQ]D,7
%
5HFWDOFDQFHUDVVHVVPHQWRIUHVSRQVHWRQHRDGMXYDQW
FKHPRUDGLDWLRQE\G\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJ
.2EHUKRO]HU$/ROOHUW7-XQJLQJHU$+HLQW]$.UHIW7+DQVHQ&'XHEHU
0DLQ]'( OROOHUW#UDGLRORJLHNOLQLNXQLPDLQ]GH
3XUSRVH 3UHWUHDWPHQW DVVHVVPHQW RI IXQFWLRQDO DQG PRUSKRORJLFDO WXPRXU
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, LQORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDO
FDUFLQRPDDQGLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIIDFWRUVZKLFKLQÁXHQFHUHVSRQVHWRQHRDGMXYDQW
FKHPRUDGLDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\QLQHW\ÀYHSDWLHQWVZLWKDGYDQFHG
PU7DQGPU7FDUFLQRPDVXQGHUZHQWG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, '&(05,
EHIRUHDQGDIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRUDGLDWLRQ *\ 4XDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUV
ZHUHGHULYHGIURPDSKDUPDFRNLQHWLFWZRFRPSDUWPHQWPRGHO FRQWUDVWPHGLXP
H[FKDQJHUDWHN>PLQ@UHODWHVWRPLFURFLUFXODWLRQDQGDPSOLWXGH$UHSUHVHQWV
WKHLQWHUVWLWLDOVSDFH 7XPRXUVZHUHDOVRFKDUDFWHULVHGZLWKUHJDUGWRPRUSKRORJ\
DVQRQPXFLQRXVRUPXFLQRXVDWSUHWUHDWPHQWKLJKUHVROXWLRQ05,5HVSRQVHWR
WUHDWPHQWZDVGHÀQHGDVGRZQVKLIWLQWKH8,&&VWDJH
5HVXOWV ,Q QRQPXFLQRXV FDUFLQRPDV FRQWUDVW PHGLXP H[FKDQJH UDWH
ZDV KLJKHU DW SUHWUHDWPHQW 05, FRPSDUHG ZLWK PXFLQRXV FDUFLQRPDV
S (IIHFWRIFKHPRUDGLDWLRQRQG\QDPLF05SDUDPHWHUVZDVKLJKHULQ
QRQPXFLQRXVFDUFLQRPDVWKDQLQZLWKLQWKHPXFLQRXVVXEW\SH S $GRZQ
VKLIWLQWKH8,&&VWDJHZDVVHHQLQSDWLHQWVDFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHLQ
$KLJKHUUDWHRIUHVSRQVHWRWUHDWPHQWZDVOLQNHGZLWKDQRQPXFLQRXVPRUSKRO
RJ\ S /RJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQUHYHDOHGDQDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQPXFLQRXV
WXPRXUPRUSKRORJ\DQGSRRUUHVSRQVH RGGVUDWLR>FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO@
>@S DVZHOODVDQDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQDKLJKSHUFHQWLOHRI
WKHFRQWUDVWPHGLXPH[FKDQJHUDWHDQGDKLJKHUUHVSRQVHUDWH RGGVUDWLR
>@S
&RQFOXVLRQ)XQFWLRQDODQGPRUSKRORJLFDOSDUDPHWHUVRISUHWUHDWPHQW05,FDQ
DVVHVVWXPRXUFKDUDFWHULVWLFVZKLFKDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIFKHPR
UDGLDWLRQEHIRUHWUHDWPHQWLVLQLWLDWHG
%
$FFXUDF\RIJDGRIRVYHVHWHQKDQFHG'7:05,IRUVHOHFWLRQRI
\S7DIWHUFKHPRUDGLDWLRQIRUUHFWDOFDQFHU
00DDV'0-/DPEUHJWV8/DOML0-/DKD\H*/%HHWV
5*+%HHWV7DQ0DDVWULFKW1/ PRQLTXHPDDV#OLYHQO
3XUSRVH6HOHFWLRQRI\S7WXPRXUVDIWHU&57DOORZVIRUORFDOH[FLVLRQDIWHU&57
3XUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHDWJDGRIRVYHVHW
HQKDQFHG7:05,IRUVHOHFWLQJ\S7WXPRXUVZLWKWKDWRI7:05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDOFDQFHUXQGHUZHQW
'7:)6(05, SODQHV DQG D[LDO JDGRIRVYHVHWHQKDQFHG '7:*5(
05, EHIRUH DQG DIWHU ZHHNV DIWHU &577ZR DEGRPLQDO UDGLRORJLVWV H[SHUW
DQGQRQH[SHUW SUHGLFWHG\7VWDJHDW7:05,DWFH7:05, DIWHUDZHHN
LQWHUYDO $IWHUDQRWKHUZHHNLQWHUYDOWKH7:DQGFH7:LPDJHVZHUHVFRUHG
VLPXOWDQHRXVO\:LWKFH7:UHDGLQJPXOWLSODQDUUHIRUPDWWLQJZDVXVHG3DWLHQW
RUGHUZDVUDQGRPLVHGEHWZHHQHDFKUHDGLQJ/LNHOLKRRGRID\7ZDVVFRUHG
XVLQJDFRQÀGHQFHOHYHOVFRUH GHÀQLWHO\RXWJURZLQJZDOOWR GHÀQLWHO\FRQÀQHG
WRZDOO +LVWRORJ\ZDVJROGVWDQGDUG52&DQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGWRFRPSDUH
GLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
5HVXOWV)RUWKHH[SHUW$8&VZHUH 7: FH7: DQG FH77:
&RUUHVSRQGLQJVHQVLWLYLWLHVDQGVSHFLÀFLWLHVZHUHDQG 7: DQG
FH7: DQGDQG 77: )RUWKHQRQH[SHUW$8&VZHUH 7:
FH7: DQG FH77: &RUUHVSRQGLQJVHQVLWLYLWLHVDQGVSHFLÀFLWLHV
ZHUHDQG 7: DQG FH7: DQGDQGIRU FH77:
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
,QWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW NDSSD ZDV FH77: FH7: DQG
7:
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRIJDGRIRVYHVHWHQKDQFHG7:05,LPSURYHGVHQVLWLYLW\LQ
WKHQRQH[SHUWDQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQWKHH[SHUWUHDGHUIRUVHOHFWLQJ\S7WXPRXUVDIWHU
&57,QWHUHVWLQJO\7:LPDJLQJDORQHVKRZHGHTXDOGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHDV
7:LPDJLQJDORQH,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVKLJKHUZKHQ7:LPDJLQJZDV
DGGHGWR7:LPDJLQJ*DGRIRVYHVHW05,PLJKWKHOSERWKH[SHUWDQGQRQH[SHUW
UHDGHUVLQPRUHDFFXUDWHVHOHFWLRQRIWXPRXUVFRQÀQHGWRWKHUHFWDOZDOODIWHU&57
%
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ '&(05, DQGFOLQLFRSDWKRORJLFDOGDWDDVZHOODVLPPXQRVWDLQ
LQJRIWKHPDUNHUVRIDQJLRJHQHVLV(*)5DQG&;&5LQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHFWDOFDQFHU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 3UHVXUJLFDO '&(05, ZDV SHUIRUPHG LQ SDWLHQWV
DFFRUGLQJWRDVWDQGDUGLVHGLPDJLQJSURWRFRO 7V\VWHP7ZHLJKWHGUDSLG
WXUER)/$6+VHTXHQFH)R9PPPDWUL[[VOLFHWKLFNQHVVPP
757(7,PVÁLSDQJOH+]S[EDQGZLGWKYR[HOVL]H
[ [ PP 7ZR TXDQWLWDWLYH SDUDPHWHUV N$ ZHUH GHULYHG IURP D
SKDUPDFRNLQHWLFWZRFRPSDUWPHQWPRGHORQHVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHU 773
ZDV DVVHVVHG 6WDQGDUGLVHG VXUJHU\ DQG KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDO H[DPLQDWLRQ ZHUH
DSSOLHGIRUWKHZKROHSDWLHQWSRSXODWLRQ,PPXQRVWDLQLQJIRU(*)5DQG&;&5
ZDV SHUIRUPHG XVLQJ WKH DYLGLQELRWLQ FRPSOH[ PHWKRG DQG HYDOXDWHG ZLWK D
VWDQGDUGLVHGVFRULQJV\VWHP
5HVXOWV '&(05, SDUDPHWHU $ FRUUHODWHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ZLWK WKH 1FDWHJRU\
S DQGNZLWKWKHRFFXUUHQFHRIV\QFKURQRXVDQGPHWDFKURQRXVGLVWDQW
PHWDVWDVHV S $VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ'&(05,GDWD 773 DQG
WKHH[SUHVVLRQRI(*)5ZDVIRXQG S $WUHQGWRDFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQN
DQG(*)5H[SUHVVLRQFRXOGEHVKRZQ S '&(05,GDWDGLGQRWFRUUHODWH
ZLWK&;&5H[SUHVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ'&(05,LVDQRQLQYDVLYHPHWKRGZKLFKFDQFKDUDFWHULVHDQJLRJHQ
HVLVLQUHFWDOFDQFHUDQGFRUUHODWHVZLWK(*)5H[SUHVVLRQ'XHWRWKHUHODWLRQVKLS
EHWZHHQWKHG\QDPLFSDUDPHWHUVDQGFOLQLFRSDWKRORJLFDOGDWD'&(05,PLJKW
EHDSURJQRVWLFLQGLFDWRUIRUO\PSKQRGHVWDWXVDQGGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHVLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKUHFWDOFDQFHU
%
+LJKEYDOXHGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJZLWKEDFNJURXQGERG\
VLJQDOVXSSUHVVLRQDSLYRWDOUROHIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIFRPSOHWH
UHVSRQVHWRQHRDGMXYDQWWUHDWPHQWVLQUHFWDOFDQFHU
/0RQJX]]L',SSROLWR0&RORPER3$%RQDIÀQL66LURQL0RQ]D,7
OHWL]LDPRQJX]]L#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH HIÀFDF\ RI ':, TXDOLWDWLYH DQG TXDQWLWDWLYH WRRO LQ
FRPELQDWLRQZLWK7ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJLQDVVHVVLQJWXPRXUUHVSRQVHWR&57DV
FRPSDUHGWR7:,DORQHE\FRUUHODWLQJKLVWRORJLFGRZQVWDJLQJDVWKHUHIHUHQFH
VWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV/$5&SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWSUHDQGSRVW&5705,H[
DPLQDWLRQ ZHHNVDIWHUWKHFRPSOHWLRQRIWUHDWPHQW RQD7VFDQQHU $FKLHYD
3KLOLSV ZLWKIROORZLQJSURWRFROPXOWLSODQDU7DQG776(LPDJHVDQG':,%6
VHTXHQFHV EIDFWRUDQGPPVHF $IWHUWRWDOPHVRUHFWDOH[FLVLRQWKH
KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOUHVSRQVHZDVFODVVLÀHGDVWXPRXUUHJUHVVLRQJUDGH DFFRUGLQJ
WR0DQGDUGҋVFULWHULD75*UHVSRQGHUVQRQUHVSRQGHUV 7ZRUHDGHUVLQ
FRQVHQVXVEOLQGHGWRWKHUHVXOWVHYDOXDWHG7:,ZLWKRXWDQGZLWK':,WRGHWHFW
WKHSUHVHQFHRIFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHE\DIRXUSRLQWVFDOHDVIROORZV GHÀQLWHO\
DEVHQWSUREDEO\DEVHQWSUREDEO\SUHVHQWGHÀQLWHO\SUHVHQW 0HDQYDOXH
RI$'&RISUHDQGSRVW&57':,ZHUHPHDVXUHGDQGFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQUHVSRQG
HUVDQGQRQUHVSRQGHUV
5HVXOWV2QWKHEDVLVRISDWKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHVDFFRUGLQJWR0DQGDUGҋVFULWHULD
SDWLHQWV ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVUHVSRQGHUVVKRZLQJFRPSOHWHRUVXEWRWDO
UHJUHVVLRQDQG ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVQRQUHVSRQGHUV0HDQ$'&YDOXHLQ
05H[DPLQDWLRQZDV[PPòVHFZKHUHDVPHDQYDOXHVDIWHU&57
ZHUH[PPòVHF2Q7:LPDJHVERWKUHDGHUVFRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHG
SDWLHQWV ZLWK FRPSOHWH UHVSRQVH VSHFLÀFLW\ ZKLOH DIWHU DGGLWLRQ RI
':, WKH UHDGHUV FRUUHFWO\ LGHQWLÀHG RI &5 VSHF 2XU SUHOLPLQDU\
UHVXOWVVKRZHGWKDWWKHWZRUHDGHUVDFKLHYHGPRUHDFFXUDWHUHVXOWVFRPELQLQJ
WKHDQDO\VLVRI':LPDJHVZLWK7:,WKDQ7:LPDJHVDORQH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
/RQJWHUPRXWFRPHRI05,EDVHGLQGLYLGXDOLVHGWUHDWPHQWIRUUHFWDO
FDQFHUDPXOWLFHQWUHVWXG\
00DDV60(QJHOHQ0/DKD\H'/DPEUHJWV-:/HLMWHQV&/9DQ%HUOR
+9HUNRRLMHQ*/%HHWV5*+%HHWV7DQ0DDVWULFKW1/
3XUSRVH$ GLIIHUHQWLDWHG WUHDWPHQW DFFRUGLQJ WR HDFK LQGLYLGXDO ULVN SURÀOH LQ
UHFWDOFDQFHUSDWLHQWVZDVLQWURGXFHGRYHUWKHODVWGHFDGH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLV
VWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHU05,EDVHGLQGLYLGXDOLVHGWUHDWPHQWFDQLPSURYH
ORQJWHUPRXWFRPHRIUHFWDOFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URPXQWLOSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQD
PXOWLFHQWUHSURVSHFWLYHFRKRUWVWXG\ZLWKH[SHUWDQGQRQH[SHUWUHFWDO05,UHDG
HUV$OOXQGHUZHQWSUHRSHUDWLYH05,XVLQJDO\PSKQRGHVSHFLÀFFRQWUDVWDJHQWWR
SUHGLFW&507DQG1VWDJH%DVHGRQWKH05,SDWLHQWVZHUHVWUDWLÀHGLQGLIIHUHQW
ULVNJURXSVIRUORFDOUHFXUUHQFH D HDUO\WXPRXU ZLGH&50 1 E QRQORFDOO\
DGYDQFHGWXPRXUDQG F ORFDOO\DGYDQFHGWXPRXU FORVHLQYROYHG&501VWDWXV
GLVWDOWXPRXUV *URXS D XQGHUZHQWVXUJHU\ E SUHRSHUDWLYH[*\IROORZHGE\
LPPHGLDWHVXUJHU\DQG F DORQJFRXUVHRIFKHPRUDGLDWLRQZLWKVXUJHU\DIWHUD
ZHHNLQWHUYDO.DSODQ0HLHUFXUYHVZHUHXVHGWRHVWLPDWHORQJWHUPRXWFRPH
5HVXOWV$IWHU D PHGLDQ IROORZXS RI PRQWKV WKH \HDU ORFDO UHFXUUHQFH
GLVHDVHIUHHVXUYLYDODQGRYHUDOOVXUYLYDODUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ05,EDVHGLQGLYLGXDOLVHGWUHDWPHQWRIUHFWDOFDQFHUOHDGVWRH[FHO
OHQW ORQJWHUP RXWFRPH VSHFLÀFDOO\ UHJDUGLQJ ORFDO FRQWURO ERWK LQ H[SHUW DQG
QRQH[SHUWFHQWUHV7KHUHVXOWVFRPSDUHIDYRXUDEO\WRRWKHUSXEOLVKHGUHSRUWV
7KHUHVXOWVFRQÀUPWKDW05,LVPDQGDWRU\LQWKHVWDJLQJRIUHFWDOFDQFHUDQGVKRZ
WKDWJRRGORFDOFRQWUROLVDFKLHYHGZKLOHQRZGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHVGHWHUPLQHRYHUDOO
VXUYLYDO7KHUHIRUHUDGLRORJLVWVVKRXOGIRFXVRQHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIPHWDVWDVHVZLWK
WKHDLPWRLPSURYHRYHUDOOVXUYLYDO
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJIRUSUHGLFWLRQRIHDUO\UHVSRQVHRI
ORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDOFDQFHUWRFKHPRUDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\
5&LDQFL$)LOLSSRQH(3DFH9%LDQFR*(VSRVLWR$7DUWDUR
$5&RWURQHR&KLHWL,7 UFLDQFL#UDGXQLFKLW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWH':,IRUDVVHVVPHQWRIHDUO\WUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHRIORFDOO\
DGYDQFHGUHFWDOFDQFHU /$5& ZHHNVDIWHUFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\ &57
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\HLJKWSDWLHQWVZLWK/$5&XQGHUZHQW05,SULRU
WRDQGZHHNVDIWHU&57LQFOXGLQJ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDQGHFKRSODQDU':,
ZLWKEYDOXHV WRVHFPP $'&YDOXHVZHUHPHDVXUHG,PDJLQJZDV
FRUUHODWHGWRSRVWVXUJLFDOKLVWRSDWKRORJLFWXPRXUUHJUHVVLRQJUDGHDFFRUGLQJWR
0DQGDUGҋVFODVVLÀFDWLRQ7ZRDQGZHHNSRVWWUHDWPHQW$'&FKDQJHVUHVSHFW
WREDVHOLQH у$'& LQWKHJURXSZLWKFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVH &5 ZHUHFRPSDUHG
ZLWKWKRVHLQWKHQRQFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHJURXS QRQ&5 0RUHRYHUDQGZHHN
SRVWWUHDWPHQW$'&FKDQJHVZHUHFRPSDUHGHLWKHULQ&5RULQQRQ&5JURXS
5HVXOWV$WZHHNVWKHPHGLDQу$'&RI&5JURXS ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHUFRPSDUHGWRWKDWRIQRQ&5JURXS S 6LPLODUO\DWZHHNV
WKH PHGLDQ у$'& RI &5 JURXS ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU WKDQ WKDW RI
QRQ&5 JURXS S 7KH EHVW у$'& FXWRII WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH &5
IURPQRQ&5DWZHHNVZDV S ZKLFK\LHOGHGDVHQVLWLYLW\RID
VSHFLÀFLW\RIDQGDQ$]YDOXHRIDWZHHNVLWZDV S ZLWK
DVHQVLWLYLW\RIDVSHFLÀFLW\RIDQGDQ$]YDOXH:KHQFRPSDULQJ
PHGLDQу$'&REWDLQHGDWDQGZHHNVDIWHU&57QRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
ZHUHIRXQGHLWKHUIRU&5RUIRUQRQ&5JURXS S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHPHGLDQу$'&DWZHHNVDIWHU&57UHSUHVHQWVDQHDUO\DQG
UHOLDEOHSUHGLFWRURISUHRSHUDWLYHWUHDWPHQWRXWFRPH
%
9DVFXODUPDSSLQJXVLQJDQ05,EORRGSRROFRQWUDVWDJHQWUHYHDOV
YDVFXODUDV\PPHWU\DQGFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\LQGXFHGYDVFXODU
UHPRGHOOLQJLQWKHPHVRUHFWXPRIUHFWDOFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
(.OX]D-3.OHLMQHQ00DDV&-HXNHQV:%DFNHV*%HHWV
5%HHWV7DQ0DDVWULFKW1/
3XUSRVH,QUHFWDOFDQFHUSDWLHQWVWKHWXPRXUVXUURXQGLQJPHVRUHFWXPH[KLELWV
WKHHQKDQFHGYDVFXODWXUHDQGGHVPRSODVWLFSDWWHUQ2XUDLPZDVWRGHWHUPLQHWKH
YDVFXODUFKDQJHVLQWKHPHVRUHFWXPUHODWHGWRWKHWXPRXUJURZWKDQGWKHLQÁXHQFH
RIQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\RQWKHVWUXFWXUHRIPHVRUHFWDOYDVFXODWXUHXVLQJ
05,YDVFXODUPDSSLQJZLWKDEORRGSRROFRQWUDVWDJHQW
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
5HFWDOFDQFHUG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,FRUUHODWHVZLWK
O\PSKQRGHVWDWXVGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHVDQG(*)5H[SUHVVLRQ
$/ROOHUW.2EHUKRO]HU7-XQJLQJHU6%LHVWHUIHOG
&6FKLPDQVNL30LOGHQEHUJHU&'XHEHU0DLQ]'(
'VVHOGRUI'( OROOHUW#UDGLRORJLHNOLQLNXQLPDLQ]GH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH IXQFWLRQDO ':05, SOD\V D FUXFLDO UROH LQ GHWHFWLQJ WKH FRP
SOHWHUHVSRQVHLQ/$5&SDWLHQWVE\DGGLQJLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWFKDQJHVLQWXPRXU
SDWKRSK\VLRORJ\XVHIXOIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIYLDELOLW\RIWKHWXPRXUDIWHU&57
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWDJLQJDQGUHVWDJLQJ05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGIRUVL[
SDWLHQWVRQD7VFDQQHUXVLQJDSKDVHGDUUD\FRLO$URXWLQHLPDJLQJSURWRFRO
ZDVFRPSOHPHQWHGZLWKDG\QDPLF7ZHLJKWHGVFDQ 7(75 PVњ
WLPHUHVROXWLRQ VPDWUL[ ð PPRONJRIJDGRIRVYHVHWZDVDGPLQ
LVWHUHGGXULQJWKHDFTXLVLWLRQ0D[LPDOLQWHQVLW\SURMHFWLRQVZHUHGHULYHGIURPWKH
GLIIHUHQFHLPDJHVREWDLQHGE\VXEWUDFWLQJWKHSUHFRQWUDVWEDVHOLQHIURPPLQ
SRVWFRQWUDVWLPDJHV7KHQXPEHURIYDVFXODUEUDQFKHVZDVGHWHUPLQHGLQWKH
WXPRXUQHLJKERXULQJDQGWXPRXUGLVWDQWPHVRUHFWXPXVLQJWKHSULPDU\VWDJLQJ
GDWD7KHSUHDQGSRVWFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\YDVFXODUPDSVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK
UHVSHFWWRWKHQXPEHURIYDVFXODUEUDQFKHVWKHLUOHQJWKDQGGLDPHWHUXVLQJ2VLUL;
5HVXOWV $ VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU QXPEHU RI YHVVHOV ZDV IRXQG LQ WKH WXPRXU
QHLJKERXULQJPHVRUHFWXPFRPSDUHGWRWXPRXUGLVWDQWPHVRUHFWXP S 7KH
GLIIHUHQFHZDVEHWZHHQWZRDQGHLJKWIROGIRUGLIIHUHQWSDWLHQWV7KHFRPSDULVRQ
RISUHDQGSRVWFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\PDSVUHYHDOHGDORZHUYHVVHOEUDQFK
LQJDIWHUWUHDWPHQW S 0RUHRYHUWKHYDVFXODUGLDPHWHURIPPDW
WKHSULPDU\VWDJLQJZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GHFUHDVHGWRPPDIWHUWKHWKHUDS\
S 1RGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGLQWKHYHVVHOOHQJWK
&RQFOXVLRQ 9DVFXODU PDSSLQJ RI WKH PHVRUHFWXP RI UHFWDO FDQFHU SDWLHQWV
UHYHDOHGWKHHQKDQFHGYDVFXODWXUHDURXQGWKHWXPRXUDQGYDVFXODUUHPRGHOOLQJ
DIWHUFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\
%
$VVHVVPHQWRISUHRSHUDWLYHUDGLRFKHPRWKHUDS\ S&57 DQRYHO
QXPHULFDOVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH'&(05,SDUDPHWHUFRPSDUHGZLWK
PRUSKRORJLF05, P05, DQGTXDOLWDWLYHWLPHLQWHQVLW\FXUYHV W05,
03HWULOOR5)XVFR9*UDQDWD2&DWDODQR06DQVRQH$5RWRQGR
5*UDVVL$3HWULOOR1DSOHV,7 PDULRSHWULOOR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVHP05,HYDOXDWLRQLVFRQVLGHUHGWKHEHVWDYDLODEOHWRROIRU/$5&VWDJ
LQJDIWHUS&577RFRPSDUHWKHDFFXUDF\RIDQRYHOVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHQXPHULFDO
SDUDPHWHUEDVHGRQSDWWHUQDQDO\VLV 6,6 ZLWKP05,DQG'&(05,EDVHGRQ
TXDOLWDWLYHW05,LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQUHVSRQGHUV 575*RU75* DQGQRW
UHVSRQGHUV 1575*RU75* DIWHUS&57
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW '&(05, H[DPLQDWLRQ EHIRUH
DQGDIWHUS&573UHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVW7ZVFDQVZHUHDFTXLUHGDIWHU*G'27$
LQMHFWLRQ5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUHGUDZQLQVLGHWKHWXPRXUUHVSHFWLYHO\
7,&HYDOXDWLRQDQG6,6DQDO\VLVZHUHFRPSXWHGIRUHDFK52,P05,W05,DQG
6,6EDVHGHYDOXDWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWVP05,HYDOXDWLRQJDYHVHQVLWLYLW\ 6(1 VSHFLÀFLW\ 63(
SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339 DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139
3HUIRUPLQJW705,HYDOXDWLRQ6(163(339DQG139
ZHUHREWDLQHGZKLOVWXVLQJDFXWRIIYDOXHRILQ6,6FKDQJH6(1
63(339DQG139ZHUHREWDLQHG3HUIRUPLQJD6,6EDVHG
HYDOXDWLRQDUHOHYDQWJDLQUHVSHFWWRP05,DORQH DQG DQGW05,
DQG ZDVREWDLQHG
&RQFOXVLRQ 6WDQGDUGLVHG LQGH[ RI VKDSH 6,6 EDVLQJ RQ D QXPHULFDO VHPL
TXDQWLWDWLYH '&(05, SDUDPHWHU REWDLQHG WKURXJK SDWWHUQ DQDO\VLV UHVXOWV DQ
DFFXUDWHWRROWRSUHGLFWWXPRXUDFWLYLW\RIS&57LQ/$5&SDWLHQWVWKURXJKDZHOO
GHÀQHGFXWRII WRGLIIHUHQWLDWH5E\15
7UHDWPHQWPRQLWRULQJLQ/$5&UROHRIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
DQG)'*3(7&7LQHYDOXDWLRQRIWXPRXUUHJUHVVLRQJUDGHGXULQJ
DQGDIWHU&57
/0RQJX]]L',SSROLWR/*XHUUD('H3RQWL&0HVVD66LURQL0RQ]D,7
OHWL]LDPRQJX]]L#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHUROHRI$'&YDOXHV ':05, LQFRPSDULVRQZLWK689PD[
YDOXHV )'*3(77& EHIRUHGXULQJDQGDIWHUFKHPRUDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\LQSDWLHQW
ZLWK/$5&EHLQJWKHKLVWRORJLFH[DPLQDWLRQDVUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KUHHVHTXHQWLDO))'*3(7&7VWXGLHVZHUHSHU
IRUPHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKELRSV\SURYHQSULPDU\UHFWDOFDUFLQRPDDVIROORZVEHIRUH
VWDUWLQJ&57 3(7&7 GXULQJ&57 3(7&7 DQGDIWHUFRPSOHWLRQRIWUHDWPHQW
3(7&7 05VFDQQLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGEHIRUH 05 DQGDIWHU&57 05 RQ
7PDJQHW 3KLOLSV$FKLHYD DQGFRPSULVHG776(PXOWLSODQDUVHTXHQFHVDQG
':,%6 EIDFWRUDQGPPVHF 7KHSHUFHQWDJHGHFUHDVHRI689PD[
у689DQG DQG$'& у$'& YDOXHVIURPEDVHOLQHWRSUHVXUJLFDOVFDQZHUH
DVVHVVHGDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWKSDWKRORJLFUHVSRQVHFODVVLÀHGDVWXPRXUUHJUHVVLRQ
JUDGH 0DQGDUGҋVFULWHULD75* FRPSOHWHUHJUHVVLRQ75* QRUHJUHVVLRQ
5HVXOWV7XPRXUZDVGHWHFWHGLQDOOSDWLHQWVDWERWK05LPDJLQJDQG)'*3(7&7
DQGDIWHU&57DOOSDWLHQWVZHUHVXEPLWWHGWRVXUJHU\$FFRUGLQJWRWKH0DQGDUGҋV
FULWHULD VKRZHGFRPSOHWH 75* RUVXEWRWDOUHJUHVVLRQ 75* DQGZHUH
FODVVLÀHGDVUHVSRQGHUVQLQH ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVQRQUHVSRQGHUV 75*
$
%
&
%
/\PSKQRGHVWDJLQJLQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHUE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7
GHYHORSPHQWRIDQHZUHSRUWLQJPRGHOIRUKLJKHUGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
$%DUWHOV(2HYHUPDQQ6+ROOPDQQ-+0DU[VHQ)09RJW$.RYDFV
3+XQROG/EHFN'( $QWRQLDEDUWHOV#JP[GH
3XUSRVH/\PSKQRGH /1 VWDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVZLWKFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU &5& LV
LPSRUWDQWIRURSWLPDOWUHDWPHQWSODQQLQJ+RZHYHULWLVGLIÀFXOWE\&7EDVHGRQ
VLPSOH FULWHULD 3XUSRVH RI WKLV VWXG\ ZDV WR HVWDEOLVK D UHSRUWLQJ PRGHO WR DF
FXUDWHO\ GLVWLQJXLVK KLVWRORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ /1 QHJDWLYH 1 IURP SRVLWLYH 1
&5&SDWLHQWVE\&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWKSURYHQ
&5& DQG SUHRSHUDWLYH FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG &7 IURP DQ LQWHUGLVFLSOLQDU\ WXPRXU
ERDUGGDWDEDVH,QDEOLQGHGPDQQHUWKHIROORZLQJ/1IHDWXUHVZHUHHYDOXDWHG
GLIIHUHQWPHWULFWUDLWVWRWDO/1FRXQWIRUPVWUXFWXUHGHQVLW\SUHVHQFHRIDKLOXP
FRQWUDVWPHGLXPHQKDQFHPHQW7KHDFFXUDF\RIWKRVHFULWHULDLQFRPELQDWLRQZDV
H[DPLQHG E\ ORJLVWLF UHJUHVVLRQ$OO FROOHFWHG SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH FRUUHODWHG ZLWK
SRVWRSHUDWLYHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV 1YV1
5HVXOWV 6RPH SDUDPHWHUV UHDFKHG VLJQLÀFDQFH IRU SUHGLFWLQJ /1PHWDVWDVHV
KRZHYHURQO\LQWHUPHGLDWHDFFXUDFLHV/DUJHVW/1!PP VHQVVSHF
DFFXUDF\ 6'RIORQJHVW/1GLDPHWHUV!PP
Q!ORFRUHJLRQDO/1!PP 7KHFRPELQDWLRQRIWKHIROORZLQJ
FULWHULDVLJQLÀFDQWO\SUHGLFWHG/1PHWDVWDVHV3UHVHQFHRIDPRUSKRXV/1V6'
RI/1ORQJLWXGLQDOGLDPHWHUV!PPPHDQRIWKH/1FURVVGLDPHWHU!PP
DQG6'RIWKHFURVVGLDPHWHUORQJLWXGLQDOGLDPHWHUUDWLR!,IRIWKHVH
IRXUFULWHULDZHUHIXOÀOOHG/1PHWDVWDVHVZHUHSUHGLFWDEOHZLWKDVOLJKWO\KLJKHU
DFFXUDF\ $UHSRUWLQJPRGHOZDVGHYHORSHGIRUFOLQLFDOGHFLVLRQ
PDNLQJRQ/1PDOLJQDQF\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHGHYHORSHGUHSRUWLQJPRGHO GHFLVLRQWUHH PLJKWIDFLOLWDWHDQG
LPSURYH/1VWDJLQJE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7LQ&5&SDWLHQWV3URVSHFWLYHVWXGLHV
KDYHWRFRQÀUPWKLVVXJJHVWLRQ
5RRP'
&KHVW
66
3XOPRQDU\QRGXOHV
%
6
DQG ,QDOOSDWLHQWVWKHPHDQYDOXHVRI689PD[LQ3(7ZHUHKLJKHUWKDQWKH
PHDQYDOXHRI689PD[LQ3(7DQG3(7 S ZKHUHDVWKHPHDQ$'&
YDOXHVZHUHORZHULQ50WKDQ50 S ZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWSHUFHQWDJH
GHFUHDVHRIYDOXHVDIWHUWKHWUHDWPHQW S 7KHEHVWSUHGLFWRUVIRU75*
UHVSRQVHZHUH689 WKUHVKROGRI DQG$'& [PPVHF ZLWKVHQ
VLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQGSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH
RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\$VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQ
OLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQ EHWZHHQ$'&YDOXHVDQG75*ҋVGDWDZDVDOVRIRXQG S
&RQFOXVLRQ':05,DQG)'*3(7&7KDYHDFRPSOHPHQWDU\GLDJQRVWLFUROHLQ
WKHIROORZXSRISDWLHQWVZLWK/$5&E\GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJÀEURVLVIURPYLDEOHWXPRXU
WLVVXHDIWHU&57
'
(
)
*
+
0RGHUDWRUV
0'DV0DDVWULFKW1/
%)HUDJDOOL&KLHWL,7
%
,RGLQHXSWDNHUDWLR ,85 DQRYHODSSURDFKWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQ
PDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOXQJOHVLRQV
**/R(8HQR:+<HXQJ5.3:RQJ$0&KRZ6.<X
+DSS\9DOOH\+.7RN\R-3 FZK\#KNVKFRP
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RILRGLQHXSWDNHUDWLR ,85 IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ
PDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOXQJOHVLRQVXVLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7VSHFWUDOLPDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQELRSV\SURYHQOHVLRQVZHUHSUR
VSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG$OO&7H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQDKLJKGHÀQLWLRQ&7
VFDQQHU 'LVFRYHU\&7+'*( )RUHDFKLPDJLQJVHVVLRQP/RILRGLQDWHG
FRQWUDVWDJHQW PJ,P/ ZDVLQMHFWHGLQWUDYHQRXVO\DWP/V$IWHUDGHOD\
WLPHRIVVSHFWUDOLPDJHVZHUHDFTXLUHGZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\DWN9S0DWH
ULDOGHFRPSRVLWLRQLRGLQHLPDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG&LUFXODU52,ZHUHGHÀQHG
LQWKHLRGLQHGHQVLW\LPDJHVRYHUWKHOXQJOHVLRQVZLWKPD[LPXPHQKDQFHPHQW
DQGQRUPDOOXQJSDUHQFK\PDIRULRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQPHDVXUHPHQWV,85ZDV
GHÀQHGDVWKHUDWLREHWZHHQLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQRIWKHOHVLRQDQGWKDWRIQRUPDO
OXQJSDUHQFK\PD
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV 3DWKRORJLFDO UHVXOWV VKRZHG WKDW OHVLRQV ZHUH PDOLJQDQW OHVLRQV
ZKLOHOHVLRQVZHUHEHQLJQ,85RIPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV ZDVVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\KLJKHU SWZRWDLOHG0DQQ:KLWQH\WHVW WKDQWKDWRIEHQLJQOHVLRQV
7KHDUHDXQGHUUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFFXUYHZDV
LQGLFDWLQJWKHSRWHQWLDOFDSDELOLW\RI,85LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOXQJ
OHVLRQV$Q,85WKUHVKROGYDOXHRIZDVGHWHUPLQHGDOORZLQJGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ
EHWZHHQPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOXQJOHVLRQVZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\
RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ,85LVÀUVWGHPRQVWUDWHGDVDQRYHODSSURDFKWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQ
PDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOXQJOHVLRQVVXJJHVWLQJLWVSRWHQWLDODSSOLFDWLRQVLQPRQLWRU
LQJGLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQVDQGWKHUDSHXWLFLQWHUYHQWLRQV
%
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHGLDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLWLHVDPRQJQHZO\GHYHORSHGDQGSUHYL
RXVO\XWLOLVHGPDWKHPDWLFDOPRGHOVRQÀUVWSDVVSHUIXVLRQGHWHFWRUURZ&7
DQG)'*3(7&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKQRGXOHVXQGHUZHQWÀUVW
SDVVSHUIXVLRQ&7XVLQJDGHWHFWRUURZ&73(7&7DQGPLFUREDFWHULDODQGRU
SDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQVQRGXOHVZHUHFODVVLÀHGLQWRWZRJURXSVEDVHGRQWKH
ÀQDOGLDJQRVHVPDOLJQDQW Q DQGEHQLJQQRGXOHV Q )URPSHUIXVLRQ&7
GDWDLQHDFKQRGXOHWRWDOEORRGÁRZ 7) ZDVFDOFXODWHGIURPSXOPRQDU\DUWHULDO
ÁRZDQGEURQFKLDODUWHULDOÁRZE\GXDOLQSXWPD[LPXPVORSHPRGHO,QDGGLWLRQ
EORRGÁRZZLWKLQWKHQRGXOH %) HMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ () DQGGLVWULEXWLRQYROXPH
'9 ZHUHDOVRFDOFXODWHGE\VLQJOHLQSXWPD[LPXPVORSHRU3DWODNSORWPRGHV
2Q3(7&7689PD[ZLWKLQHDFKQRGXOHZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\52,PHDVXUHPHQW
7RFRPSDUHGLDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLW\DPRQJDOOLQGH[HV52&WHVWVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
)LQDOO\ VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ DQG DFFXUDF\ ZHUH FRPSDUHG HDFK RWKHU XVLQJ
0F1HPDUҋVWHVW
5HVXOWV$UHDXQGHUWKHFXUYHRI7) $] S ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ODUJHU
WKDQWKDWRI() $] '9 $] S DQG689PD[ $] :KHQ
IHDVLEOHFXWRIIYDOXHVZHUHDGRSWHGVSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RI7)ZHUHVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKRVHRI%) S () S DQG689PD[ S
,QDGGLWLRQVHQVLWLYLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RI7)ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKRVHRI
'9 S
&RQFOXVLRQ1HZO\GHYHORSHGPRGHOIRUÀUVWSDVVSHUIXVLRQ&7RQGHWHFWRU
URZ&7ZDVPRUHDFFXUDWHWKDQSUHYLRXVO\XWLOLVHGPRGHOVDQGFDQSOD\DVPRUH
VSHFLÀFDQGDFFXUDWHUROHIRUGLDJQRVLVRISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHWKDQ3(7&7
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIDGDSWLYHLWHUDWLYHGRVHUHGXFWLRQ $,'5 IRUOXQJ
QRGXOHGHWHFWLRQLQXOWUDORZGRVHWKRUDFLF&7
163DXO+0HKUH]0+DVKHPL6$OKXPD\\G*0XUSK\5&REEROG
7RURQWR21&$ QDULQGHUSDXO#XKQRQFD
3XUSRVH7RGHPRQVWUDWHWKHDFFXUDF\RIXOWUDORZGRVH&7 8/'&7 ZLWK$,'5
LPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRUOXQJQRGXOHGHWHFWLRQFRPSDUHGWR8/'&7DQG/'&7
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 LPDJHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 5DZ GDWD IURP /'&7 [ PP N9S DQG
P$V GRVHaP6Y ZHUHVHOHFWHGVRWKDWVWXGLHVFRQWDLQHGDVLQJOHOXQJQRG
XOHPHDQGLDPHWHUPP PP PHDQGHQVLW\+8 +8WR+8
ZLWKYDULDEOHORFDWLRQIURPDSLFHVWREDVHV/'&7LPDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWK
)%3 JURXS$ DQGWDNHQDVWKHFOLQLFDOUHIHUHQFH1RLVHZDVDSSOLHGWRWKHUDZ
GDWDWRJHQHUDWHVLPXODWHG8/'&7DWP$V GRVHaP6Y DQGUHFRQVWUXFWHG
LPDJHVZLWK)%3 JURXS% DQG$,'5 JURXS& DWPP7ZRFKHVWIHOORZV
55 UHDGDOOLPDJHVLQUDQGRPLVHGEOLQGHGVWXG\DQGSHUIRUPHGDSRLQW
52&DQDO\VLVIRUOXQJQRGXOHGHWHFWLRQDQGDSRLQWVFDOHIRULPDJHTXDOLW\ ,4
SRRU JRRG H[FHOOHQW
5HVXOWV4XDOLWDWLYHDQDO\VLV,4UDWLQJIRUJURXSV$%DQG&IRUHDFKUHDGHUZHUH
5 DQGDQG5 DQG4XDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVQRGXOH
GHWHFWLRQE\ 55 IRUDOOLPDJHVHWVZHUHJURXS$VHQVLWLYLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\ DFFXUDF\ $8& JURXS
% VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ DFFXUDF\
$8& JURXS&VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\
DFFXUDF\ $8& 5HVXOWVRIJURXS& 8/'&7$,'5
ZHUHVXSHULRUWRJURXS% 8/'&7)%3 DQGFRPSDUDEOHWRJURXS$ /'&7)%3
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
6PDOOSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVOHVVWKDQPPKRZWRGLVWLQJXLVK
PDOLJQDQF\DQGEHQLJQLW\"
.<RRQ*-LQ<+DQ</HH-HRXQMX.5 VKLQJKD#SDUDQFRP
3XUSRVH :H LQYHVWLJDWHG UDGLRORJLFSDWKRORJLF FRUUHODWLRQ RI VPDOO SXOPRQDU\
QRGXOHVOHVVWKDQPPWRHYDOXDWHWKHPDMRUGLIIHUHQFHVRIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQW
QRGXOHVRQ&7ÀQGLQJV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KH VWXG\ LQFOXGHG SDWLHQWV 0) PHDQ
DJH ZLWKVPDOOSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVOHVVWKDQPP7LVVXHGLDJQRVLVZDVPDGH
LQDOOSDWLHQWVZLWKVXUJLFDOUHVHFWLRQ7KHKLVWRORJLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKHQRGXOH
ZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKUDGLRORJLFÀQGLQJVVXFKDVVKDSHPDUJLQDQGGHQVLW\:HDOVR
HYDOXDWHGWKHPDMRUGLIIHUHQFHVRIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWQRGXOHVOHVVWKDQPP
5HVXOWV0HDQGLDPHWHURIQRGXOHVRQ&7ZDVFP,QWKHQRGXOHVPDOLJ
QDQWQRGXOHVZHUH DQGEHQLJQ 0DMRUGLIIHUHQFHVRIEHQLJQ
DQGPDOLJQDQWQRGXOHVZHUHVKDSHGHQVLW\DQGPDUJLQ,QPDUJLQVSLFXODWLRQDQG
OREXODWLRQRFFXUUHGZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUIUHTXHQF\DPRQJPDOLJQDQWQRGXOHV
S ,QVXEVROLGQRGXOHVPDOLJQDQF\UDWHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQ
VROLGQRGXOHV S ,QVXEVROLGQRGXOHVDOREXODWHGRUVSLFXODWHGPDUJLQ
ZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDKLJKHUULVNRIPDOLJQDQF\ S ,PSRUWDQWSUHGLFWLYH
ÀQGLQJVRIÀEURWLFQRGXOHVDQGDQWKUDFRWLFSLJPHQWDWLRQV RIEHQLJQQRGXOHV
FRPSDUHGWRPDOLJQDQWQRGXOHVZHUHDVIROORZVVPRRWKPDUJLQDQGVROLGDWWHQX
DWLRQ(VSHFLDOO\LQQRGXOHVOHVVWKDQPPVPRRWKERUGHUDQGVROLGDWWHQXDWLRQ
ZHUH SURYHG DV LQGHSHQGHQW PRUSKRORJLFDO SUHGLFWRUV RI EHQLJQLW\ SUHGLFWLYH
YDOXH
&RQFOXVLRQ0DOLJQDQWSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVOHVVWKDQPPVKRZVSLFXODWHGPDU
JLQ**2RUPL[HG**2ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWO\JUHDWHUIUHTXHQF\(VSHFLDOO\VPRRWK
ERUGHUDQGVROLGDWWHQXDWLRQZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUVRIEHQLJQLW\LQOHVVWKDQ
PPQRGXOHV
%
'LIIHUHQWLDWLQJVXEVROLGDQGVROLGSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVRQ&7LQWHU
DQGLQWUDREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWDPRQJH[SHULHQFHGWKRUDFLFUDGLRORJLVWV
$<LOGLULP&$5LGJH30%RLVHOOH7)UDQTXHW3$*HYHQRLV
&06FKDHIHU3URNRS'7DFN$$%DQNLHU.D\VHUL75
%RVWRQ0$86%DUFHORQD(6%UXVVHOV%($PHUVIRRUW1/%DXGRXU%(
DIUDB\LOGLULP#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHUHFRPPHQGHG&7VXUYHLOODQFHSHULRGLVORQJHUIRUVXEVROLGWKDQ
IRU VROLG SXOPRQDU\ QRGXOHV GXH WR WKH VORZHU JURZWK UDWH RI EURQFKRDOYHRODU
FDUFLQRPDFRPSDUHGWRRWKHUOXQJFDQFHUV7KLVVWXG\WHVWVWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDW
LQWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZKHWKHUDSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHLVVXEVROLGLV´JRRGµ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 6L[ WKRUDFLF UDGLRORJLVWV IURP ÀYH LQVWLWXWLRQV ZLWK DQ
DYHUDJHRI\HDUҋV&7H[SHULHQFHVXEPLWWHGLPDJHVRIVXEVROLGDQGVROLG
QRGXOHVHDFKWRFRQVWUXFWDGDWDEDVHRISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHV,QGLYLGXDOQRGXOH
VHOHFWLRQVZHUHVHWDVWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG7ZHOYHUDQGRPO\DUUDQJHGLPDJH
GDWDEDVHVZHUHFUHDWHG(DFKEOLQGHGUDGLRORJLVWUHDGWZRGLIIHUHQWYHUVLRQVZLWKLQ
DSHULRGRIGD\VLQGLFDWLQJZKHWKHURUQRWHDFKQRGXOHZDVVXEVROLG$FRUUHFW
DQVZHUZDVGHÀQHGE\WKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG6HOHFWLRQVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWK
QRGXOH VL]H ,QWHUDQG LQWUDREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW ZDV DVVHVVHG XVLQJ WKH NDSSD
VWDWLVWLF N DVVXPLQJ´JRRGµDJUHHPHQWOLHVZLWKLQWKHNDSSDUDQJHRI
5HVXOWV)RUUHDGLQJVDQGDQGRISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVZHUHFRU
UHFWO\LGHQWLÀHGDVHLWKHUVXEVROLGRUVROLG7KHUHZDVQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
FRUUHODWLRQZLWKQRGXOHVL]H UV 3 UV 3 DQGUV
3 UV 3 ,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVDWWKHORZHUUDQJHRI
´JRRGµIRUUHDGLQJVDQG N DQGN ,QWUDREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDV
DOVR´JRRGµ N
&RQFOXVLRQ5DGLRORJLVWLQWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWLQWKHGHFLVLRQZKHWKHU
RUQRWDSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHLVVXEVROLGLVLQWKHORZHUUDQJHRI´JRRGµ1RGXOHVL]H
LVQRWDFRQWULEXWRUWRREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQW
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
1HZO\GHYHORSHGPDWKHPDWLFDOPRGHOIRUSHUIXVLRQ&7XVLQJ
GHWHFWRUURZ&7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHV
FRPSDULVRQRIGLDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLW\ZLWKSUHYLRXVO\XWLOLVHGPRGHOV
IRUÀUVWSDVVSHUIXVLRQ&7DQG)'*3(7&7
<2KQR01LVKLR+.R\DPD'7DNHQDND7<RVKLNDZD60DWVXPRWR
<)XMLVDZD.6XJLPXUD.REH-32KWDZDUD-3 \RVLUDG#NREHXDFMS
6SHDUPDQҋVUDQNFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWEHWZHHQJURXSV&DQG$ZHUH5
DQG5 S
&RQFOXVLRQ8OWUDORZGRVH&7ZLWK$,'5KDVFRPSDUDEOHFOLQLFDOSHUIRUPDQFH
WRFRQYHQWLRQDO/'&7IRUOXQJQRGXOHGHWHFWLRQDQGDFKLHYHVGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
:KLFKVROLWDU\JURXQGJODVVRSDFLW\SXOPRQDU\OHVLRQQHFHVVLWDWHV
LQYDVLYHLQYHVWLJDWLRQ"
55R]HQEHUJ,.RJDQ0/HLGHUPDQ$(QJHO/*XUDOQLN+DLID,/
UBUR]HQEHUJ#UDPEDPKHDOWKJRYLO
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHKLVWRORJLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHRIVROLWDU\JURXQGJODVVRSDF
LW\ **2 LQRUGHUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHFDVHVLQZKLFK&7JXLGHG)1$VKRXOGEHWKH
QH[WVWHSLQHYDOXDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ UHYLHZHG &7JXLGH )1$ RI
SXOPRQDU\OHVLRQVDVDSULPDU\GLDJQRVWLFZRUNXSSHUIRUPHGDWRXULQVWLWXWLRQ
EHWZHHQDQG2XUVWXG\LQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVWKDWKDGDVROLWDU\**2
SXOPRQDU\OHVLRQZLWKDPHDQDJHRI\HDUV7KHOHVLRQVZHUHLQWKH58/LQ
50/LQ5//LQ/8/LQDQG///LQRISDWLHQWV
7KHPHDQGLDPHWHURIWKH**2OHVLRQZDVFPZLWKDUDQJHIURPWRFP
(DFKFDVHZDVUHYLHZHGIRUGLDJQRVWLF\LHOGDQGFRPSOLFDWLRQV
5HVXOWV$IWHUF\WRORJLFDO H[DPLQDWLRQ PDOLJQDQF\ ZDV GLDJQRVHG LQ RI
SDWLHQWVLQDGHQRFDUFLQRPD16&/&DQGXQVSHFLÀHGPDOLJ
QDQF\$QHJDWLYHUHVXOWZDVREWDLQHGLQSDWLHQWVDPRQJWKHPFDVHVUHYHDOHG
PDOLJQDQF\DIWHUVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ0RVWRIWKHVROLWDU\**2SXOPRQDU\OHVLRQVWXUQHGRXWWREHPDOLJQDQW
(YHQWKRXJKKLVWRORJLFDOO\PRVWRIWKHPDUHVORZJURZLQJDGHQRFDUFLQRPDVIRU
WKRVHOHVLRQVZLWKPDOLJQDQWDSSHDUDQFHVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQVKRXOGIROORZWKH&7
GLDJQRVWLF:HUHFRPPHQG&7JXLGHG)1$LQFDVHVRIHTXLYRFDO**2OHVLRQV
RULQSDWLHQWVWKDWDUHQRWDEOHWRXQGHUJRDVXUJLFDOSURFHGXUHDQGDGLDJQRVLVLV
PDQGDWRU\IRUIXUWKHUWUHDWPHQW
%
&RPSXWHUDLGHGGHWHFWLRQRIJURXQGJODVVQRGXOHVLQOXQJFDQFHU
VFUHHQLQJUHWURVSHFWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRISRWHQWLDOEHQHÀW
&-DFREV(76FKROWHQ6&6DXU77ZHOOPDQQ3$GH-RQJ
%YDQ*LQQHNHQ%UHPHQ'(+DDUOHP1/8WUHFKW1/1LMPHJHQ1/
FROLQMDFREV#PHYLVIUDXQKRIHUGH
3XUSRVH*URXQGJODVVQRGXOHV **1V KDYHDKLJKSUREDELOLW\RIEHLQJPDOLJQDQW
:H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ LQYHVWLJDWHG WKH XVHIXOQHVV RI D GHGLFDWHG FRPSXWHUDLGHG
GHWHFWLRQ &$' V\VWHPIRU**1VLQDFOLQLFDOVFUHHQLQJVHWWLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VHWRI ORZGRVH FKHVW &7VFDQV [ PP
N9SP$V ZHUHUDQGRPO\VHOHFWHGIURPDOXQJFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJWULDO
$OOVFDQVZHUHSURFHVVHGZLWKDUHVHDUFKSURWRW\SH&$'V\VWHPIRU**1V 'L
DJQRVWLF,PDJH$QDO\VLV*URXS1LMPHJHQ7KH1HWKHUODQGV)UDXQKRIHU0(9,6
%UHPHQ*HUPDQ\ 7ZRFKHVWUDGLRORJLVWVLQVSHFWHGDOO&$'PDUNVDQGFODVVLÀHG
WKHPDV**1RWKHUOHVLRQRUIDOVHSRVLWLYH)LQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKH
DQQRWDWLRQVUHFRUGHGLQWKHVFUHHQLQJWULDOGDWDEDVHZKLFKZHUHREWDLQHGZLWKRXW
WKHVXSSRUWRI&$'
5HVXOWV**1&$'IRXQGPDUNV SHUVFDQ 5DGLRORJLVWFODVVLÀHG
PDUNVDV**1DVRWKHUOHVLRQVDQGDVIDOVHSRVLWLYHV)RUUDGLRORJLVW
WKHVHQXPEHUVZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\)LIWHHQÀQGLQJVZHUHFRQ
VLGHUHGWREH**1VE\ERWKUDGLRORJLVWV2IWKHVHRQO\KDGEHHQDQQRWDWHG
LQWKHVFUHHQLQJWULDO&$'PDUNVWKDWZHUHFODVVLÀHGE\WKHUDGLRORJLVWVDVRWKHU
OHVLRQVLQYROYHGPDLQO\VFDUVDQGDUHDVRILQÁDPPDWLRQ$FRPPRQVRXUFHRI&$'
IDOVHSRVLWLYHVZHUHKD]\RSDFLWLHVFDXVHGE\FDUGLDFPRWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$WOHVVWKDQIDOVHSRVLWLYHVSHUVFDQWKH&$'V\VWHPFDQVXE
VWDQWLDOO\LQFUHDVHWKHQXPEHURI**1VLGHQWLÀHGLQDOXQJFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJWULDO
DWDIDOVHSRVLWLYHUDWHWKDWGRHVQRWLPSRVHDEXUGHQRQWKHUHDGLQJSURFHVV
%
1HZJROGVWDQGDUGIRUGHVLJQLQJD&;5&$'DOJRULWKPIRUOXQJ
QRGXOHVDQGDVVHVVLQJLWVSHUIRUPDQFH
'6KDKDP,/HLFKWHU$0DQHYLWFK1%RJRW5/HGHUPDQ-HUXVDOHP,/
GVKDKDP#KDGDVVDKRUJLO
3XUSRVH&XUUHQWO\UHDGHUVDUHUHOXFWDQWWRDFFHSWORZFRQVSLFXLW\OXQJQRGXOHV
GHWHFWHGE\&$'RQFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKVHYHQZKHQWKH\DUH&7FRQÀUPHG7KLV
VWXG\GHVFULEHVDQHZ&$'DOJRULWKPGHVLJQHGWRGHWHFWOXQJQRGXOHVFRQVLGHUHG
UHSRUWDEOHE\H[SHUWUDGLRORJLVWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHQHZSURWRW\SH&;5&$'DOJRULWKP 6LHPHQV ZDV
WUDLQHGRQGLJLWDOIURQWDOFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKVIURPYHQGRUVFXOOHGIURPVLWHV
DQGUHYLHZHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\E\LQGHSHQGHQWH[SHUWUDGLRORJLVWV7RHVWDEOLVK
WKHQHZJROGVWDQGDUGDQRGXOHUHSRUWHGE\DWOHDVWUHDGHUVZDVFRQVLGHUHG
UHSRUWDEOHVXFKQRGXOHV PP ZHUHIRXQG7KHSHUIRUPDQFHRI&$'
XVLQJWKHQHZJROGVWDQGDUGZDVWHVWHGRQDGLIIHUHQWVHWFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKV
UHYLHZHGIRUQRGXOHVE\LQGHSHQGHQWUHDGHUV&$'VHQVLWLYLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHG
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
E\WKHSHUFHQWDJHRIUHDGHUVZKRFRQFXUUHG&$'PDUNVIRUÀQGLQJVUHSRUWHGE\
IHZHUWKDQUHDGHUVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGIDOVH
5HVXOWV2QWKHFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKVQRGXOHVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGUHSRUWDEOH
&$'VHQVLWLYLW\IRUQRGXOHVZLWKFRQFXUUHQFHZDVDQGLWGHFUHDVHG
WRDQGZLWKDQGFRQFXUUHQFHUH
VSHFWLYHO\7KHUHDGHUVҋSHUFHQWDJHFRQFXUUHQFHDQG&$'VHQVLWLYLW\ZHUHKLJKO\
FRUUHODWHG 5 7KH&$'IDOVHPDUNUDWHZDVZKLOHWKHUHDGHUVҋIDOVH
PDUNUDWHUDQJHGIURPWR PHDQRI
&RQFOXVLRQ&;5&$'GHVLJQHGWRPLPLFWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIH[SHUWVUDWKHUWKDQ
WR GHWHFW &7FRQÀUPHG QRGXOHV VKRXOG LPSURYH WKH XVHIXOQHVV RI &$' LQ WKH
FOLQLFDOVHWWLQJDVLWZLOOLQFUHDVHWKHZLOOLQJQHVVRIJHQHUDOUDGLRORJLVWVWRDFFHSW
WKH&$'SURPSWVRQFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKV
%
&RPSXWHUDLGHGOXQJQRGXOHYROXPHWU\FDQ0'&7EHUHSODFHGE\
KLJKÀHOG05,DW7"
05HJLHU6.DQGHO+%ROWH%+RIIPDQQ*$GDP-%LHGHUHU
+DPEXUJ'(%HUOLQ'(.LHO'( PUHJLHU#XNHGH
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHDFFXUDF\RIFRPSXWHUDLGHGYROXPHWU\RIDUWLÀFLDOSXO
PRQDU\QRGXOHVLQKLJKÀHOG05,DW7LQDQLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOFRPSDULVRQWR0'&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%\LQMHFWLQJPORIDQDJDURVHVROXWLRQQRGXOHV
RIGLDPHWHUVUDQJLQJPPZHUHLPSOHPHQWHGLQWRSRUFLQHOXQJVZLWKLQD
GHGLFDWHG FKHVW SKDQWRP 6LJQDO RQ7ZHLJKWHG LPDJHV DQG UDGLRSDFLW\ ZHUH
DGMXVWHGE\DGGLQJPPROO*G'73$DQGJORILRGLQH$7ZHLJKWHG
WKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOJUDGLHQWHFKRVHTXHQFH 7'*5(757(PVVOLFH
PP)29PPPDWUL[[)OLSDQJOH ZDVDSSOLHGLQD[LDORULHQWD
WLRQIROORZHGE\0'&7 [PPUHFRQVWUXFWHGVOLFHWKLFNQHVVPPLQFUHPHQW
PP ZKLFKVHUYHGDVWKHUHIHUHQFH&RPSXWHUDLGHGYROXPHWU\ZDVSHUIRUPHG
XVLQJDFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOHVRIWZDUHWRRO 2QFRWUHDW0H9LV*HUPDQ\ $IWHU
WKH H[SHULPHQWV DOO VSHFLPHQV ZHUH KDUYHVWHG DQG WUXH OHVLRQ VL]H DQG VKDSH
ZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUDOOQRGXOHV6WDWLVWLFVLQFOXGHGFRPSDULVRQRIPHDQYDOXHVDQG
ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV&RPSDUHGWRWKH0'&7GDWDXVLQJ05,PHDQOHVLRQYROXPHZDVRYHU
HVWLPDWHGE\&RQVHTXHQWO\WKHVORSHRIWKHUHJUHVVLRQOLQHZDVIRUWKH
05,GDWDDQGZDVVXERUGLQDWHWRWKHLGHQWLW\OLQH
&RQFOXVLRQ'XHWRWKHORZHUVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQWKHDFFXUDF\RIFRPSXWHUDLGHG
YROXPHWU\ZDVORZHUIRUWKH05,EDVHGGDWDVHWVWKDQIRU0'&7GDWD1HYHUWKH
OHVVDYDULDQFHLQYROXPHDVVHVVPHQWRILPSOLHVWKDW05,FDQVXIÀFLHQWO\
EHXVHGWRPRQLWRUWKHYROXPHRIVPDOOSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVDQGWRGHWHFWGRXEOLQJ
RIQRGXOHYROXPHLQGLFDWLQJPDOLJQDQF\
%
3RVLWURQHPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\DQGOXQJQRGXOHVSURJQRVWLFYDOXH
RIVWDQGDUGXSWDNHYDOXH
$%D]]RFFKL6%URFFKL)3RQWL9$PEURVLQL*)DFFKLQL6)DQWL
%RORJQD,7 VWHIDQREURFFKL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH2XUDLPZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSURJQRVWLFYDOXHRIVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNH
YDOXH 689 LQ SDWLHQWV VXEPLWWHG WR SRVLWURQ HPLVVLRQ WRPRJUDSK\ 3(7 IRU
VROLWDU\OXQJQRGXOH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ DQDO\VHG WKH FOLQLFDO KLVWRU\ RI
SDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHV\HDUROG ZKRXQGHUZHQW3(7&7IRU
OXQJQRGXOHVLQDVLQJOHFHQWUHH[SHULHQFH7KHDQDO\VLVLQFOXGHGHYDOXDWLRQRI
LPDJHV DQG SK\VLFLDQV UHSRUWV RI 3(7&7 H[DPV DQDPQHVLV RI SDWLHQWV DQG
VXEVHTXHQWGLDJQRVWLFH[DPLQDWLRQVLQWKHLUIROORZXS LPDJLQJELRSV\VSHFLPHQ
DQGRUSDWKRORJLFDODQDO\VLVDIWHUVXUJLFDOUHVHFWLRQ )ROORZXSRIDOOSDWLHQWVHQGHG
ZLWKVXUYLYDOFRQWUROLQ6HSWHPEHU5HFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFFXUYHV
DQG.DSODQ0HLHUPHWKRGZHUHXVHG
5HVXOWV0HDQIROORZXSZDVPRQWKV7KUHHRXWRI SDWLHQWV
ZHUH DIIHFWHG E\ OXQJ PHWDVWDVHV DQG ZHUH H[FOXGHG IURP IXUWKHU DQDO\VLV ,Q
VXEMHFWVDQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHUZDVGLDJQRVHG DGHQR
FDUFLQRPDVDQGVTXDPRXVFDUFLQRPDV SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
VXUJHU\,QDOORWKHUSDWLHQWV OHVLRQVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVQRQRQFRORJLF
GLVHDVHVRUEHQLJQ7KHEHVWFRPELQDWLRQWRSURSHUO\FKDUDFWHULVHWKHQHRSODVWLF
QDWXUHRIQRGXOHVIRXQGD689PD[FXWRIIYDOXHRIUHVXOWLQJLQDQG
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\UHVSHFWLYHO\1RGXOHVZLWKKLJKHU689PD[YDOXH
! ZHUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKORZHUVXUYLYDOUDWH S LQGHSHQGHQWO\IURPVXUJL
FDOQRQVXUJLFDODSSURDFK)RU689!DQGWKHVXUYLYDOUDWHV\HDUDIWHU
3(7LPDJLQJZHUHDQGZKLOHVXUYLYDOH[SHFWDQFLHVDIWHU\HDUV
ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ ,Q FRQFOXVLRQ SURJQRVWLF YDOXH RI 689PD[ YDOXH ZDV SURYHG D
FXWRIIYDOXHRIVHHPVWRRIIHUJRRGUHOLDELOLW\DQGDFFXUDF\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
$EODWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
5)'RQGHOLQJHU/LqJH%(
')LOLSSLDGLV$WKHQV*5
%
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH PRUSKRORJLFDO FKDQJHV RI DOGRVWHURQHSURGXFLQJ
DGHQRPD $3$ RQFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\VFDQEHIRUHDQGDIWHUUDGLRIUHTXHQF\
DEODWLRQ 5)$ DQGWRLGHQWLI\IDFWRUVWKDWDUHLPSRUWDQWLQGHWHUPLQLQJVXFFHVVIXO
FRPSOHWHDEODWLRQRIWKHVHWXPRUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQ$XJXVWDQG$XJXVWFRQVHFX
WLYHSDWLHQWVZLWK$3$XQGHUJRLQJ&7JXLGHGSHUFXWDQHRXV5)$ZHUHLGHQWLÀHG
IURPRXUSURVSHFWLYHGDWDEDVH7KHSUH5)$DQGSRVW5)$&7DSSHDUDQFHVRI
WKHVH$3$ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGIRUWKHLUWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOVL]HWXPRU
YROXPHDQG+RXQVÀHOGXQLWV +8 &RPSDULVRQRIWKHVHSDUDPHWHUVEHIRUHDQG
DIWHU5)$ZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV,QWKLVVWXG\WKHUHZHUH$3$WKDWVKRZHGELRFKHPLFDOFXUHRISULPDU\
DOGRVWHURQLVPDIWHU5)$&RPSDULQJSRVW5)$WRSUH5)$&7VFDQVWKHUHZDV
QRVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHLQWXPRUVL]H DQWHULRUSRVWHULRUGLPHQVLRQPPYHUVXV
PP3 PHGLDOODWHUDOGLPHQVLRQPPYHUVXVPP3
FUDQLDOFDXGDOGLPHQVLRQPPYHUVXVPP3 DQGWXPRXUYROXPH
FPYHUVXVFP3 DIWHU5)$,QQRQHQKDQFHG&7LPDJHVWKHUH
ZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQLQ+8IURPSUH5)$WRSRVW5)$PHDVXUHPHQWV
YHUVXV3 ,QFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7VFDQVWKHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWGURS
LQ+8DIWHU5)$ IURPWR3 1RQHRIWKHLQFOXGHGFDVHVVKRZHG
IRFDOUHJLRQRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWWRVXJJHVWUHVLGXDOWXPRXU
&RQFOXVLRQ&KDQJHLQWXPRXUVL]HWXPRXUYROXPHDQG+8LQQRQHQKDQFHG&7
ZHUHXQUHOLDEOHLQGHÀQLQJUDGLRORJLFDOWUHDWPHQWVXFFHVV2QO\FKDQJHLQ+8LQ
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7VFDQZDVXVHIXOLQFRQÀUPLQJSRVLWLYHWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVH
DIWHU5)$IRU$3$
%
5DGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQRIKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVHVDIWHUFXUDWLYH
UHVHFWLRQRIH[WUDKHSDWLFFKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPD
6<3DUN-.LP+:RQ<6KLQ3.LP6HRXO.5 VXQ\SDUN#QDYHUFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHORFDOFRQWURODQGVXUYLYDODIWHUUDGLRIUHTXHQF\
DEODWLRQ 5)$ LQSDWLHQWVZLWKOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVDULVLQJIURPH[WUDKHSDWLFFKRODQJL
RFDUFLQRPD (&& ZKRKDGSUHYLRXVO\XQGHUJRQHFXUDWLYHUHVHFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP0D\WR0D\5)$XVLQJDQLQWHUQDOO\
FRROHGHOHFWURGHZDVSHUIRUPHGRQPHWDFKURQRXVOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV WXPRXU
SHUSDWLHQW DULVLQJIURP(&&LQSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUV 7XPRXUVL]H
UDQJHGIURPFPWRFPLQPD[LPXPGLPHQVLRQ PHDQFP $VKLVWRULFDO
FRPSDULVRQVZHLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVGLDJQRVHGZLWKUHFXUUHQWPHWDVWDVLVOLPLWHG
WRWKHOLYHUEHWZHHQ)HEUXDU\DQG$SULODQGZKRPHWWKHLQFOXVLRQFULWHULD
IRU5)$SDWLHQWVUHFHLYHGVXSSRUWLYHWKHUDS\RQO\ZKLOHSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
FKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\
5HVXOWV)LYHSDWLHQWVKDGPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQV IRXUZLWKOLYHUDEVFHVVDQGRQH
ZLWK ELOLDU\ VWULFWXUH SHU WUHDWPHQW EXW WKHUH ZHUH QR SURFHGXUHUHODWHG
GHDWKV&RPSOHWHWXPRXUQHFURVLVZDVDFKLHYHGLQDOOWXPRXUVDIWHURQHVHV
VLRQRI5)$7KHORFDOWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQUDWHZDV PHGLDQWLPHWRGHWHF
WLRQPRQWKV )URPWKHÀUVWGLDJQRVLVRIOLYHUPHWDVWDVLVWKHPHGLDQRYHUDOO
VXUYLYDOZDVPRQWKVDQGWKH\HDUVXUYLYDOUDWHZDV3DWLHQWVXUYLYDO
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORQJHULQSDWLHQWVZKRUHFHLYHG5)$WKDQLQWKRVHZKRUHFHLYHG
FKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\ PHGLDQVXUYLYDOPRQWKV RUVXSSRUWLYHWUHDWPHQW PHGLDQ
VXUYLYDOPRQWKV 3
&RQFOXVLRQ 3HUFXWDQHRXV 5)$ UHVXOWV LQ HIIHFWLYH ORFDO WXPRXU FRQWURO DQG
PD\SURORQJVXUYLYDOLQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHFXUUHQWKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVHVDIWHUFXUDWLYH
UHVHFWLRQIRU(&&
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG &(86 LPSURYHVUHDOWLPHLPDJLQJRI
DEODWLRQUHJLRQGXULQJUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ 5)$ SUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
3:LJJHUPDQQ(0-XQJ&6WURV]F]\QVNL
5HJHQVEXUJ'( SKLOLSSZLJJHUPDQQ#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHDGGHGYDOXHRIGHSLFWLQJWXPRXUPLFURYDVFXODULVDWLRQ
XVLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG &(86 GXULQJ5)$DVDPHDQVRIDFKLHYLQJ
DFRPSOHWHDEODWLRQ &$ RIPDOLJQDQWOLYHUOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV IHPDOHVPDOHVDJHUDQJH
\HDUV PHDQ \HDUV ZLWK KLVWRORJLFDOO\ FRQÀUPHG KHSDWLF
PDOLJQDQFLHV +&& Q OLYHU PHWDVWDVHV Q XQGHUZHQW 5)$ %HIRUH
5)$FRQYHQWLRQDO86&(86DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7 FH&7 RIWKHOLYHUZHUH
SHUIRUPHG'XULQJWKH&7JXLGHG5)$SURFHGXUH&(86ZDVSHUIRUPHGWRDVVHV
WKHDEODWLRQGHIHFW,QFDVHRISDUWLDODEODWLRQDVXEVHTXHQWDEODWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
ZLWKDFRUUHFWHGHOHFWURGHSRVLWLRQDQGHYDOXDWHGDJDLQXVLQJ&(867KLVSURFHGXUH
ZDVUHSHDWHGXQWLOD&$ZDVDFKLHYHG7KHQXPEHURIDEODWLRQVSHUSDWLHQWZDV
UHFRUGHG6HFRQGDU\HIÀFDF\SDUDPHWHUVDVVHVVHGZHUHOHVLRQGHWHFWDELOLW\LQWKH
GLIIHUHQWLPDJLQJPRGDOLWLHVDQGFRQWUDVWSKDVHV
5HVXOWV2YHUDOOLQWUDSURFHGXUDO&(86OHGWRDFKDQJHLQWKHUDSHXWLFPDQDJHPHQW
LQRIFDVHVUHVXOWLQJLQDGGLWLRQDODEODWLRQV/HVLRQGHWHFWDELOLW\GXULQJ
&7ÁXRURVFRS\ZDVWKHVROHVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQWSUHGLFWRURILQFRPSOHWHDEODWLRQV
S 7KHPHDQQXPEHURIDEODWLRQVIRUGHWHFWDEOHOHVLRQVZDVYV
DEODWLRQVIRUQRWGHWHFWDEOHOHVLRQV S 7KHFRPELQHG&7DQG&(865)$
SURFHGXUHOHGWRD&$IRUDOOWUHDWHGOHVLRQVLQIROORZXSPRQWKSRVWLQWHUYHQWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&(86GRHVDOORZDUHOLDEOHLPPHGLDWHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHUDSHXWLF
HIÀFDF\RISHUFXWDQHRXV5)$SURFHGXUHVRIPDOLJQDQWOLYHUOHVLRQV
%
3HUFXWDQHRXV86JXLGHGLQWHUVWLWLDOODVHUDEODWLRQRIPHWDVWDWLF
O\PSKQRGHVLQWKHQHFNIURPSDSLOODU\WK\URLGFDUFLQRPDIROORZLQJ
WK\URLGHFWRP\DQGO\PSKDGHQHFWRP\
*0DXUL/&RYD7,HUDFH77RQGROR*/RPXVFLR$%DUROL/6ROELDWL
0LODQ,7%XVWR$UVL]LR,7 JLRPDXUL#WLVFDOLLW
3XUSRVH :H UHSRUW RXU H[SHULHQFH ZLWK SHUFXWDQHRXV 86JXLGHG LQWHUVWLWLDO
ODVHUDEODWLRQIRUPHWDFKURQRXVFHUYLFDOQRGDOPHWDVWDVHVIURPSDSLOODU\WK\URLG
FDUFLQRPDIROORZLQJWRWDOWK\URLGHFWRP\DQGFHQWUDOODWHURFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHQW\WKUHH PHWDFKURQRXV PHWDVWDWLF QRGHV PHDQ
VL]HFPUDQJHFP LQSDWLHQWVZHUHWUHDWHG$QP1G<$*
ODVHU (FKR/DVHU;(VDRWH*HQRD,WDO\ ZDVXVHG$OOFDVHVZHUHQHJDWLYHDW
,ZKROHERG\VFDQEXWKDGSRVLWLYH))'*3(7DQGHOHYDWHGVHUXPOHYHOV
RIWK\URJOREXOLQ8QGHUORFDODQDHVWKHVLDDѥPTXDUW]ÀEHURSWLFJXLGHZDV
SODFHGLQWRWKHQRGHWKURXJKD*QHHGOH1RGHVZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKRQH FDVHV
RUWZR ÀEHULQVHUWLRQVHDFKRQHZLWK:SRZHUIRUVHF WRWDOHQHUJ\
MRXOHV $OOFDVHVZHUHIROORZHGDWDQGPRQWKVZLWK%PRGH86
&(86))'*3(7DQGDVVHVVPHQWRIVHUXPOHYHOVRI7J
5HVXOWV/DVHUDEODWLRQZDVWHFKQLFDOO\IHDVLEOHDQGZHOOWROHUDWHGLQDOOSDWLHQWV
ZLWK HLWKHU LPPHGLDWH RU ODWH FRPSOLFDWLRQV ,Q QRGHV FRPSOHWH
DEODWLRQ ODFNRIHQKDQFHPHQWDW&(86QHJDWLYH))'*3(7ZLWKQRUPDOLVD
WLRQRI689DQG!GHFUHDVHRI7JVHUXPOHYHOV ZDVDFKLHYHG,QFDVHV
UHVLGXDOXSWDNHDW))'*3(7ZLWKDEQRUPDO689ZDVIRXQGDQGODVHUDEODWLRQ
ZDVUHSHDWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ3HUFXWDQHRXV86JXLGHGLQWHUVWLWLDOODVHUDEODWLRQVHHPVWREHDQ
HIIHFWLYHORZFRVWDQGVDIHWKHUDSHXWLFWRROIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRIPHWDFKURQRXVQRGDO
PHWDVWDVHVIURPSDSLOODU\WK\URLGFDUFLQRPDLQWKHQHFNZKLFKZRXOGRWKHUZLVH
UHTXLUHRIWHQFKDOOHQJLQJIXUWKHUUHVHFWLRQV
%
7KHFUXFLDOUROHRIÀGXFLDOPDUNHUVRQDVVHVVPHQWRIDEODWLYHPDUJLQ
07UDN\PDV$8O\V9LOQLXV/7 PDQWDVWUDN\PDV#YXRLOW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHEHQHÀWRILPSODQWHGÀGXFLDOPDUNHUVRQH[DFWGHWHFWLRQ
RIDEODWLYHPDUJLQDQGRQORFDOWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQUDWH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(DFKRIPHWDVWDWLFOLYHUWXPRXUV PPPHGLDQ
PP ZDVPDUNHGZLWKWKUHHWLWDQLXPÀGXFLDOVEHIRUHUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ
)LGXFLDOVZHUHLPSODQWHGQHDUWKHWXPRXUXQGHUXOWUDVRXQGJXLGDQFH7KHWKUHH
SKDVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG0'&7VFDQZDVSHUIRUPHGIRUHDFKSDWLHQWDIWHUWKH
LPSODQWDWLRQRIÀGXFLDOV$OOWKHWXPRXUVZHUHWUHDWHGE\86JXLGHG5)$XVLQJ
SHUIXVHGDQGPXOWLSRODULQWHUQDOO\FRROHGHOHFWURGHV7KHFRQWUROFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
0'&7 VFDQ ZDV SHUIRUPHG QH[W GD\ DIWHU DEODWLRQ 7KH HYDOXDWLRQ RI DEODWLYH
PDUJLQZDVPDGHE\IXVLQJ&7VFDQVDFFRUGLQJWRHDFKÀGXFLDO
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
&7PRUSKRORJLFDOFKDQJHRIDOGRVWHURQHSURGXFLQJDGHQRPDDIWHU
UDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ
.//HH<6/LX6&7RQJ(.1J$7$KXMD+RQJ.RQJ+.
OHHNDORN#\DKRRFRPKN
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV 5)$ ZDV WHFKQLFDOO\ VXFFHVVIXO LQ DOO FDVHV 7KH GHWHFWHG PLQLPDO
DEODWLYHPDUJLQUDQJHGIURPWR!PPDQGWKHDFFXUDWHGHWHFWLRQRIDEODWLYH
PDUJLQZDVSRVVLEOHIRUDOOWKHWXPRXUV,QIRXUFDVHVWKHUHSHDWHGDEODWLRQZDV
SHUIRUPHGVLQFHWKHDEODWLRQPDUJLQZDVOHVVWKDQPPDQGDODJHUDEODWLRQRI
SDUWLFXODU UHJLRQ ZDV IHDVLEOH 2Q IROORZXS PRQWKV PHGLDQ PRQWKV
RQO\RQHORFDOWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQZDVGHWHFWHG,QWKLVFDVHWKHDEODWLYHPDUJLQ
ZDVPPDQGWKHUHDEODWLRQZDVQRWIHDVLEOHGXHWRWKHSUR[LPLW\RIWKHWXPRXU
WRDODUJHSRUWDOYHLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH XVH RI ÀGXFLDO PDUNHUV IRU DEODWLRQ WUHDWPHQW JLYHV XV QHZ
SRVVLELOLWLHVIRUUDGLFDOWUHDWPHQWRSWLRQVHQDEOHVGLUHFWDVVHVVPHQWRIDEODWLYH
PDUJLQDQGUDLVHVWKHDEODWLRQWRDKLJKHUTXDOLWDWLYHOHYHO
%
7KHVLJQLÀFDQFHRISHUVLVWHQWLQWUDOHVLRQDOHQKDQFHPHQWRIUHQDO
WXPRXUVIROORZLQJSHUFXWDQHRXVFU\RDEODWLRQ
%6KHSKHUG3.XPDU7-&%U\DQW'-%UHHQ6RXWKDPSWRQ8.
EHWKBVKHS#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH :H HYDOXDWHG WKH RFFXUUHQFH RI ҊWKUHDGOLNHҋ LQWUDWXPRUDO HQKDQFH
PHQWRQLQLWLDOFURVVVHFWLRQDOLPDJLQJLQUHQDOWXPRXUVWUHDWHGE\SHUFXWDQHRXV
FU\RDEODWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSHUIRUPHGDUHWURVSHFWLYHUHYLHZRIWKHSRVWSURFH
GXUDOLPDJLQJRIDOOVROLGUHQDOWXPRXUVWUHDWHGZLWKSHUFXWDQHRXVFU\RDEODWLRQIURP
0D\WR-XQH:HUHFRUGHGDOOSDWLHQWVZLWKLQWUDWXPRUDOHQKDQFHPHQW
VHHQRQWKHLQLWLDO&7RU05SHUIRUPHGZLWKLQZHHNV
5HVXOWVWXPRXUVLQSDWLHQWVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGRXWRIWKHWXPRXUV
VKRZHGLQLWLDOҊWKUHDGOLNHҋLQWUDWXPRXUDOHQKDQFHPHQW2IWKHVHWX
PRXUVQRQHKDGHYLGHQFHRIUHVLGXDORUUHFXUUHQWGLVHDVHDWDPHDQUDGLRORJLFDO
IROORZXSRIPRQWKV2IWKHWXPRXUVZHUHFRQÀUPHGUHQDOFHOOFDUFL
QRPDRQFRF\WRPDVDQGZHUHLQGHWHUPLQDQW7KLVZDVSURSRUWLRQDOZLWKWKH
SDWKRORJLFDOGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHODUJHUFRKRUW
&RQFOXVLRQ$VPDOOEXWVLJQLÀFDQWPLQRULW\RIVROLGUHQDOFHOOWXPRXUVGHPRQVWUDWH
VHHPLQJO\EHQLJQLQWUDOHVLRQDOҊWKUHDGOLNHҋHQKDQFHPHQWSRVWFU\RDEODWLRQ,WLV
LPSRUWDQWWREHDZDUHRIWKLVSKHQRPHQRQDVWRDYRLGWKHVHTXHODHRIPLVUHSRUWLQJ
WKLVDVUHVLGXDOGLVHDVH
%
0LFURZDYHDEODWLRQ 0:$ YHUVXVUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ 5)$ IRU
VPDOOOLYHUPDOLJQDQFLHVUDWHVRIWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVV
*0DXUL77RQGROR/&RYD7,HUDFH/6ROELDWL%XVWR$UVL]LR,7
YDQQLPDXUL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHSULPDU\WHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVRI0:$DQG5)$IRUWKHWUHDW
PHQWRIVPDOOOLYHUWXPRXUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVOLYHUPDOLJQDQFLHV +&&VDQGPHWDVWDVHV
VPDOOHUWKDQFPLQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRQH86JXLGHGWKHUPDODEODWLRQZLWK
0:$ Q RU5)$ Q EHWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG-XQHZHUHUHWUR
VSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG$VLQJOHQHHGOHLQVHUWLRQZDVSUHRSHUDWLYHSODQQHG3ULPDU\
WHFKQLFDOVXFFHVV FRPSOHWHFRYHUDJHRIWKHWXPRXUDIWHURQHDEODWLRQ DFKLHYHG
LQWKH0:$JURXSDQGLQWKH5)$JURXSZDVGLVWLQFWO\DVVHVVHGE\LQWUDRSHUDWLYH
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG86 &(86 )XUWKHUDEODWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGGXULQJWKHVDPH
VHVVLRQZKHQ&(86VKRZHGUHVLGXDOOHVLRQDOHQKDQFHPHQWXQWLODFKLHYHPHQW
RIFRPSOHWHODFNRIHQKDQFHPHQWKRXU&7RU05,ZHUHSHUIRUPHGWRDVVHVV
WKHÀQDOWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVV
5HVXOWV 3ULPDU\ WHFKQLFDO VXFFHVV ZDV DFKLHYHG LQ WXPRXUV
LQWKH0:$JURXSDQGLQ LQWKH5)$JURXS S LQ
+&&VLQWKH0:$JURXSDQG+&&V LQWKH5)$JURXS
S LQPHWDVWDVHV LQWKH0:$JURXSDQGLQPHWDVWDVHV
LQWKH5)$JURXS S &RPSOHWHDEODWLRQDWKRXUVZDVDFKLHYHG
LQ WXPRXUV WXPRXUV LQ WKH 0:$ JURXS DQG
LQWKH5)$JURXS S
&RQFOXVLRQ0:$SURYLGHVDVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUSULPDU\WHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVWKDQ
5)$LQOLYHUWXPRXUVVPDOOHUWKDQFPDQGSDUWLFXODUO\LQ+&&V$IWHUPXOWLSOH
DEODWLRQVWHFKQLFDOHIIHFWLYHQHVVLVVLPLODUEHWZHHQ0:$DQG5)$0:$VKRXOG
EHFRQVLGHUHGWKHÀUVWFKRLFHWUHDWPHQWIRUVPDOO+&&V
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
5HQDOUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ 5)$ HIIHFWRISULPDU\WKHUPDO
DEODWLRQRQWKHPHGLXPWHUPVXUYLYDO
&0LJOLRULVL)%DUERVD&7LFFD01LFKHODWWL'0D]]RQH
59HUFHOOL06ROFLD$5DPSROGL*&RUQDOED0LODQ,7
FDUPHORPLJOLRULVL#RVSHGDOHQLJXDUGDLW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIIHFWRISULPDU\WKHUPDODEODWLRQ FRPSOHWHRULQFRP
SOHWH RQWKHVXUYLYDO3UHYDOHQFHRIV\QFKURQRXVPHWDFKURQRXVOHVLRQVUHODSVH
PHWDVWDVLVORFDOWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQDVZHOOFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHVZHUHUHSRUWHG
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )LIW\WZR SDWLHQWV UHQDO OHVLRQV XQGHUZHQW 5)$
ZHUH UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ VHOHFWHG 7KH DYHUDJH IROORZXS WLPH ZDV PRQWKV
PRQWKV 0HDQDJHZDV\HDUV \HDUV PDOHVIHPDOHV
7KHPHDQWXPRXUVL]HRI650VZDVPP PP 5)$ZHUHFDUULHGRXW
XQGHUXOWUDVRXQGRU&7JXLGDQFH&KLVTXDUHGWHVW)LVKHUҋVH[DFWWHVW.DSODQ
0H\HUDQG&R[VHPLSDUDPHWULFUHJUHVVLRQZHUHXVHG
5HVXOWV5)$ZDVVXFFHVVIXOO\SHUIRUPHGLQ RIOHVLRQV 650V
UHVLGXDO OHVLRQV DQG UHODSVH GLVHDVH &RPSOHWH SULPDU\ WKHUPDO DEODWLRQ
37$ RI650VZDVRIUHVLGXDOOHVLRQVDQGRIUHODSVHGLVHDVH
&RPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHREVHUYHGLQ RIWUHDWHGOHVLRQVPLQLPXPJURXQG
EORRG KDHPDWRPD KDHPDWRPDDQGLQIHFWLRQ DQGOLYHUGDPDJH
QRQUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSURFHGXUHFRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGSULPDU\WKHUPDODEODWLRQ
ZDVREVHUYHG6\QFKURQRXVOHVLRQVZDVSUHVHQWLQSDWLHQWV 'XU
LQJIROORZXS SDWLHQWVGHYHORSHGPHWDFURQRXVOHVLRQVDQG
UHODSVH SUHVHQWHGPHWDVWDWLFGLVHDVHRIWKHVH DOUHDG\
KDGPHWDVWDVLVEHIRUHWUHDWPHQW/RFDOWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQZHUHSUHVHQWLQ
SDWLHQWVRIWKHVH GLHG
&RQFOXVLRQ5)$SURYLGHDQIHDVLEOHVDIHW\DQGHIIHFWLYHPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHWUHDW
PHQWRIUHQDOOHVLRQVLQVHOHFWHGSDWLHQWVZLWKORZUDWHRIUHFXUUHQFH
%
3HUFXWDQHRXVPLFURZDYHDEODWLRQ 0:$ ZLWKDKLJKHQHUJ\
DQWHQQDHV\VWHPRISXOPRQDU\PDOLJQDQFLHVWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVV
VDIHW\DQGLPDJLQJIROORZXS
'<)&KXQJ0/LWWOH3%RDUGPDQ)9*OHHVRQ(0$QGHUVRQ2[IRUG8.
3XUSRVH (YDOXDWLRQ RI WKH WHFKQLFDO VXFFHVV VDIHW\ DQG LPDJLQJ IROORZXS RI
PDOLJQDQWSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVWUHDWHGZLWKKLJKHQHUJ\SHUFXWDQHRXV0:$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-XO\WR6HSWHPEHUSDWLHQWV IH
PDOHVPHDQDJH ZLWKSXOPRQDU\PDOLJQDQFLHVRIPHGLDQGLDPHWHUPP
UDQJHPP ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKSHUFXWDQHRXV0:$XQGHU&7JXLGDQFH$*
PLFURZDYHQHHGOHDQWHQQD 0LFURVXOLV3RUWVPRXWK8. ZDVXVHGZLWKSRZHUXS
WR:7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVRIDEODWLRQZDVGHÀQHGDV!PPJURXQGJODVVRU
VROLGRSDFLÀFDWLRQPDUJLQDURXQGWKHDEODWHGOHVLRQDWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7GD\
SRVWSURFHGXUH/RFDOWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHZDVDVVHVVHGDWDQGPRQWKV
SRVWDEODWLRQ 0HDVXUHPHQWV DQG DVVHVVPHQW RI ORFDO WXPRXU UHFXUUHQFH ZHUH
XQGHUWDNHQE\WKHUDGLRORJLVWSHUIRUPLQJWKHSURFHGXUHDQGDVHFRQGUDGLRORJLVW
QRW LQYROYHG LQ WKH SDWLHQW V FDUH &RPSOLFDWLRQV ZHUH UHFRUGHG DW WKH WLPH RI
SURFHGXUHDQGDWIROORZXS
5HVXOWV0HGLDQDEODWLRQWLPHZDVPLQ UDQJHPLQ 7KHSURFHGXUHZDV
WHFKQLFDOO\ VXFFHVVIXO LQ OHVLRQV SDWLHQWV GHYHORSHG SQHX
PRWKRUD[GXULQJWKHSURFHGXUHRIZKLFKUHTXLUHGDFKHVWGUDLQRISDWLHQWV
ZHUHGLVFKDUJHGGD\SRVWSURFHGXUH1RSDWLHQWVGLHGDVDGLUHFWUHVXOWRIWKH
SURFHGXUH$WPRQWKIROORZXSORFDOUHFXUUHQFHZDVLGHQWLÀHGLQSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ0:$XVLQJDQRYHOKLJKSRZHUDQWHQQDRIOXQJOHVLRQVLVDVDIH
VXFFHVVIXOWHFKQLTXHWKDWDOORZVVKRUWHUDEODWLRQWLPHVFRPSDUHGWRUDGLRIUHTXHQF\
DEODWLRQ 5)$ 7KHFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHVDUHFRPSDUDEOHWR5)$
%
/RFDOFRQWURORIIRFDOKHSDWLFPDOLJQDQFLHVWUHDWHGZLWKPLFURZDYH
DEODWLRQZLWKDKLJKSRZHUDSSOLFDWRUV\VWHPLQSDWLHQWV
*0DXUL/&RYD7,HUDFH77RQGROR61*ROGEHUJ/6ROELDWL
%XVWR$UVL]LR,7-HUXVDOHP,/ YDQQLPDXUL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIÀFDF\DQGVDIHW\RIPLFURZDYHDEODWLRQIRUWKHWUHDWPHQW
RIKHSDWLFPDOLJQDQFLHVXVLQJDKLJKSRZHUDSSOLFDWRUV\VWHP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2YHUDPRQWKSHULRGKHSDWLFPDOLJQDQFLHV
+&&FKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPDDQGPHWDVWDVHV LQSDWLHQWVZHUHSHUFXWD
QHRXVO\ WUHDWHG XQGHU 86 JXLGDQFH XVLQJ D KLJKSRZHU :DWW *+]
PLFURZDYHV\VWHP $0,&$3UREH+RVSLWDO6HUYLFH$SULOLD,WDO\ 2QH Q
RUWZR Q DQWHQQDLQVHUWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHG3RZHUDQGWLPHRIDSSOLFDWLRQ
UDQJHGIURPWR:DWWDQGIURPWRPLQUHVSHFWLYHO\,PDJLQJ HLWKHU
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG0'&7RU05, DWPRQWKVZDVXVHGIRUSRVWDEODWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
IROORZXS5HVXOWVZHUHDVVHVVHGDIWHUDPLQLPXPPRQWKIROORZXSIRUDWRWDO
RIPDOLJQDQFLHV +&&VDQGPHWDVWDVHVVL]HUDQJHFPPHDQ
LQSDWLHQWV
5HVXOWV ,PPHGLDWH FRPSOHWH DEODWLRQ ZDV DFKLHYHG LQ PDOLJQDQFLHV
RI +&&V DQG PHWDVWDVHV /RFDO WXPRXU
SURJUHVVLRQ RFFXUUHG LQ PDOLJQDQFLHV ZLWK VL]HV
FP IRUWXPRXUVUDQJLQJFPDQG IRUWXPRXUV
!FP$OOORFDOSURJUHVVLRQZDVVXFFHVVIXOO\UHWUHDWHGZLWKLQPRQWKVXVLQJ
WKHVDPHPHWKRG0LQRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVRFFXUUHGLQ SDWLHQWV2QO\
RQHGHOD\HGPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQZDVQRWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ,QRXUVHULHVYDOXDEOHORFDOFRQWURORIKHSDWLFPDOLJQDQFLHVZLWKRXW
VLJQLÀFDQWFRPSOLFDWLRQVZDVDFKLHYHG(YHQOHVLRQVELJJHUWKDQFPZHUHVXF
FHVVIXOO\WUHDWHGZLWKIHZDQWHQQDLQVHUWLRQVDQGLQDVKRUWWLPH
5RRP(
66
05,RIOLJDPHQWVWHQGRQVDQGPXVFOHV
0RGHUDWRUV
05HLMQLHUVH/HLGHQ1/
9=XEOHU=XULFK&+
%
7KHXVHRIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGDQGG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,
IRUTXDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHWLELDOWXQQHODIWHUDQWHULRUFUXFLDWH
OLJDPHQWUHFRQVWUXFWLRQZLWKLQWUDRSHUDWLYHO\DGPLQLVWHUHGSODWHOHW
ULFKSODVPDJHO
05XSUHKW09RJULQ0-HYVHN,6HUVD9-HYWLĀ0DULERU6,
/MXEOMDQD6, PLWMDUXSUHKW#JXHVWDUQHVVL
3XUSRVH7RTXDQWLWDWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWRISODWHOHWULFKSODVPDJHO 353*
ORFDOO\ DGPLQLVWHUHG GXULQJ WKH DQWHULRU FUXFLDWH OLJDPHQW $&/ UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
7KH SUR[LPDO WLELDO WXQQHO ZDV DVVHVVHG ZLWK GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ ':,
DQGZLWKG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGLPDJLQJ '&(,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QÀIW\SDWLHQWVDUWKURVFRSLF$&/UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZHUH
SHUIRUPHG7KHSDWLHQWVLQWKH353*JURXS Q UHFHLYHGDORFDODSSOLFDWLRQRI
353*LQWRWKHERQHWXQQHOVDQGLQWRWKHJUDIWLWVHOI':,DQG'&(,ZHUHXWLOLVHGWR
H[DPLQHWKHSUR[LPDOWLELDOWXQQHOZLWKVXEVHTXHQWFDOFXODWLRQRIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHVDVZHOODVWKHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWJUDGLHQW *HQK
DQGHQKDQFHPHQWIDFWRU )HQK YDOXHV
5HVXOWV$WRQHPRQWKWKH$'&YDOXHLQWKH353*JURXS PPV
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQLQWKHFRQWURO PPV JURXS S
$WWZRDQGDKDOIDQGDWVL[PRQWKVWKHGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKH$'&YDOXHVZHUHQRW
VLJQLÀFDQW$WWKHÀUVWDQGVHFRQGFRQWURO*HQKZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKH
353* VDQGV WKDQLQWKHFRQWURO VDQGV JURXS
S DQG $WVL[PRQWKVWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQ*HQK
YDOXHV7KHUHZHUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQ)HQKEHWZHHQWKHJURXSVDWDQ\
FRQWUROH[DPLQDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ':,DQG'&(,PHDVXUHPHQWVLQGLFDWHDUHGXFHGH[WHQWRIRHGHPD
GXULQJWKHÀUVWSRVWRSHUDWLYHPRQWKDVZHOODVDQLQFUHDVHGYDVFXODUGHQVLW\DQG
PLFURYHVVHOSHUPHDELOLW\LQWKHSUR[LPDOWLELDOWXQQHODWRQHDQGWZRDQGDKDOI
SRVWRSHUDWLYHPRQWKVDVWKHHIIHFWRIWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI353*
%
'HGLFDWHG705YVZKROHERG\705LQWKHGLDJQRVLVRI
PHQLVFDOOHVLRQVZLWKDUWKURVFRSLFFRUUHODWLRQ
'&DUDPHOOD$3DROLFFKL)5XVFKL69LWDOL,&DVWHOOLQL33DUFKL0/LVDQWL
3LVD,7 GDYLGHFDUDPHOOD#PHGXQLSLLW
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIDGHGLFDWHG05V\VWHP 7
DQGDKLJKÀHOGZKROHERG\05VFDQQHU 7 LQWKHVWXG\RIPHQLVFL
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7KLUW\VHYHQ SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW WZR VXEVHTXHQW 05
H[DPLQDWLRQVZLWKWKHGHGLFDWHG05V\VWHPDQGWKHKLJKÀHOGWUDGLWLRQDOVFDQQHU
,QFOXVLRQFULWHULDZHUHDJHEHWZHHQDQG\HDUVFOLQLFDOVXVSLFLRQRIPHQLVFDO
OHVLRQQRKLVWRU\RIVXUJHU\RQWKHDIIHFWHGNQHH6HTXHQFHVXVHGZHUHVDJLW
WDO6(7)6(3'67,5LQERWKVFDQQHUV2QWKHFRURQDOSODQH;%21(ZDV
XVHGDW7DQG*(7IDWVDWDW77KLUW\RQHSDWLHQWV ZLWKSRVLWLYH05,
XQGHUZHQWDUWKURVFRS\ZKLOH ZLWKQHJDWLYH05, ZHUHIROORZHGXSFOLQLFDOO\7ZR
H[SHUWUDGLRORJLVWVSHUIRUPHGDGRXEOHEOLQGUHDGLQJZLWKDUWKURVFRS\DVWKHJROG
VWDQGDUG)RUHDFKPHQLVFXVDQWHULRUDQGSRVWHULRUKRUQVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGZLWKWKH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
6RGLXP 1D 05,RI$FKLOOHVWHQGRQGLVHDVHDW7HVODSUHOLPLQDU\
UHVXOWV
9-XUDV&3UHVVO6=E\Q6$SSULFK36]RPRODQ\L-:LPPHU6'RPD\HU
67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7 YODGLPLUMXUDV#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH ,W KDV EHHQ UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH JO\FRVDPLQRJO\FDQ *$* FRQWHQW LQ
FUHDVHVLQFKURQLF$FKLOORWHQGLQRSDWK\FRPSDUHGWRKHDOWK\$FKLOOHVWHQGRQ $7
7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRXWLOLVHVRGLXP05,DW7HVODWRYLVXDOLVHDQGTXDQWLI\
ELRFKHPLFDOFRPSRVLWLRQFKDQJHVZLWKLQWKHWHQGRQEHWZHHQKHDOWK\WHQGRQDQG
FKURQLF$FKLOORWHQGLQRSDWK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\KHDOWK\VXEMHFWVDQGHLJKWSDWLHQWVZLWKFKURQLF
$FKLOORWHQGLQRSDWK\GLDJQRVHGRQVWDQGDUG05,DW7ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\
$OOVRGLXP05PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD7ZKROHERG\05V\VWHP
XVLQJDFLUFXODUO\SRODULVHG1DWUDQVPLWUHFHLYHNQHHFRLO'*5(VHTXHQFH
RSWLPLVHGIRUVRGLXPLPDJLQJZDVXVHGZLWKWKHIROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUV7( PV
75 PVDYHUDJHV PDWUL[ [ÁLSDQJOH )29 [DQGVOLFH
WKLFNQHVV PP6LJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRUWKUHHGLIIHUHQWUHJLRQV
RIVHJPHQWHG$FKLOOHVWHQGRQ LQVHUWLRQPLGGOHSRUWLRQDQGWHQGRQPXVFOHMXQF
WLRQ 7KHGLIIHUHQFHRIVRGLXPVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLREHWZHHQKHDOWK\VXEMHFWVDQG
SDWLHQWVZDVFDOFXODWHGXVLQJWZRVDPSOHXQHTXDOYDULDQFH77HVW
5HVXOWV0HDQEXON615RI$7LQKHDOWK\VXEMHFWVZDVDQGLQSDWLHQWV
,QUHVSHFWLYHUHJLRQV KHDOWK\!SDWLHQW WKHIROORZLQJPHDQ615YDOXHV
ZHUHREVHUYHG ! LQLQVHUWLRQ ! LQ
PLGGOHSRUWLRQDQG ! LQWHQGRQPXVFOHMXQFWLRQ6WDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVRIVRGLXP615ZHUHREVHUYHGLQLQVHUWLRQ S PLGGOH
SRUWLRQ S DQGWHQGRQPXVFOHLQWHUIDFH S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVRIWKHVWXG\FOHDUO\GHPRQVWUDWHGWKHDELOLW\RIVRGLXP
05 LPDJLQJ WR GHWHFW DQG TXDQWLI\ FKDQJHV LQ FKURQLF$FKLOOHV WHQGLQRSDWK\
7KRVHÀQGLQJVFRXOGOHDGWRQHZDSSURDFKHVFRQFHUQLQJHDUO\RQVHWGLDJQRVLV
DQGLQGLYLGXDOLVHGWUHDWPHQWPRQLWRULQJ
%
$QNOHFDUWLODJHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ7YDOXHDQGOLJDPHQWLQMXU\
6/HH<<RRQ6HRXO.5 RGG#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHGLIIHUHQFHVLQ7YDOXHVLQDQNOHFDUWLODJHDWPDJQHWLFUHVR
QDQFH 05 LPDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVZLWKLQMXU\RIDQWHULRUWDORÀEXODUOLJDPHQW $7)/
FRPSDUHGZLWKKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$QNOHFDUWLODJHZDVHYDOXDWHGLQVXEMHFWVZLWKDQNOH
SDLQZKRZHUHFDWHJRULVHGDVKDYLQJQRUPDO$7)/ Q PHDQDJH SDUWLDO
WHDU 37 Q PHDQDJH RUFRPSOHWHWHDU &7 RI$7)/ Q PHDQDJH
XVLQJPXOWLHFKRVSLQHFKR7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHV7URFKOHDUFDUWLODJHUHJLRQV
RI WKH WDOXV ZHUH GLYLGHG LQWR VL[ FRPSDUWPHQWV DQWHURPHGLDO PHGLDO FHQWUH
SRVWHURPHGLDO DQWHURODWHUDO ODWHUDO FHQWUH DQG SRVWHURODWHUDO 0HDQ YDOXH RI
FRPSDUWPHQWDOUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW7PHDVXUHPHQWVZDVREWDLQHGLQWKUHHJURXSV
6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFHZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV0HDQYDOXHRIFRPSDUWPHQWDO7YDOXHVVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQQRUPDO37DQG&7 3 7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHEHWZHHQWKUHHOLJD
PHQWJURXSVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWLQWKHFRPSDUWPHQWRIDQWHURPHGLDOPHGLDO
FHQWUHDQWHURODWHUDODQGODWHUDOFHQWUHFDUWLODJH 3
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQQRUPDODQG$7)/LQMXU\
JURXSVLQSRVWHURPHGLDODQGSRVWHURODWHUDOFRPSDUWPHQW&7JURXSKDGKLJKHU7
YDOXHVFRPSDUHGZLWKQRUPDOLQDQWHURPHGLDOPHGLDOFHQWUHDQWHURODWHUDODQG
ODWHUDOFHQWUH37JURXSKDGKLJKHU7YDOXHVFRPSDUHGZLWKQRUPDOLQDQWHURPHGLDO
DQGDQWHURODWHUDOFRPSDUWPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ$7)/LQMXU\LVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQLQFUHDVHLQ7YDOXHRIWKHDUWLFXODU
FDUWLODJHRIWKHWURFKOHDRIWKHWDOXVLQDQNOHHVSHFLDOO\LQDQWHULRUDQGSRVWHULRU
FRPSDUWPHQW
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
IROORZLQJVFRUHVDEVHQFHRIOHVLRQXQFHUWDLQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQDGHJHQHUDWLYH
OHVLRQEFRPSOHWHIUDFWXUHDQGRUSDUDPHQLVFDOF\VWDQGRUEXFNHWKDQGOHOHVLRQ
5HVXOWV5HDGHU$VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ 7
7 GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ UHVSHFWLYHO\ 5HDGHU % VHQVLWLYLW\
DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ 7 7 GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
IRUERWKV\VWHPV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHWZR05V\VWHPVKDYHVLPLODUGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQGHWHFWLQJ
DQGFODVVLI\LQJPHQLVFDOOHVLRQVWKXVVXJJHVWLQJWKDWDOHVVH[SHQVLYHGHGLFDWHG
05FDQEHHPSOR\HGLQWKLVGLDJQRVWLFGRPDLQDYRLGLQJWKHLQFRQYHQLHQFHIRU
WKHSDWLHQWWREHVFDQQHGLQDZKROHERG\V\VWHP
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
5KDEGRP\RO\VLVUHYLVLWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05 LPDJLQJ
ÀQGLQJLQGHWDLO
6&KR<.LP6&KR.+/HH%.LP5.LP6&KRL6.RK
0./LP,QFKHRQ.5$Q\DQJ.5 MRVXQJHKQ#QDYHUFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05 LPDJLQJÀQGLQJ
RIUKDEGRP\RO\VLVLQGHWDLO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(LJKWHHQSDWLHQWV PDOHVDQGZRPHQDJHUDQJH
\HDUVPHDQDJH\HDUV ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\6LJQDOLQWHQVLW\
RQ7DQG7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVSUHVHQFHRILQWUDPXVFXODUKDHPRUUKDJHSUHV
HQFH RI VWLSSOH VLJQ SUHVHQFH RI QRQHQKDQFLQJ SRUWLRQ LQ PXVFOH LQFUHDVHG
YROXPHRIPXVFOHDEQRUPDOVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQVXEFXWDQHRXVIDWOD\HUDQGGHHS
IDVFLDDUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV2Q7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHSDWLHQWV VKRZHGKRPRJHQHRXV
LVRVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\DQG SDWLHQWVVKRZHGKHWHURJHQHRXVPL[HG
KLJKDQGLVRVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\2Q7ZHLJKWHGLPDJH SDWLHQWVVKRZHG
KHWHURJHQHRXVVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\FRPELQHGKLJKDQGORZVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\7HQSDWLHQWV
KDG 7 KLJK RU 7 GDUN VLJQDO LQWHQVLW\ LQ PXVFOH UHSUHVHQWLQJ
KDHPRUUKDJH7ZHOYHSDWLHQWV KDGVWLSSOHGVLJQ6HYHQSDWLHQWV
KDGIRFDORUGLIIXVHQRQHQKDQFLQJSRUWLRQLQLQYROYHGPXVFOH)LIWHHQ
SDWLHQWV VKRZHGLQFUHDVHGYROXPHRIPXVFOH1LQHSDWLHQWV
KDG7KLJKVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RHGHPDLQVXEFXWDQHRXVIDWOD\HU7KLJKVLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\LQIDFLDOSODQHLVVHHQSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ ,QFUHDVHG YROXPH RI PXVFOH LV PRVW FRPPRQ LPDJLQJ ÀQGLQJ LQ
UKDEGRP\RO\VLVRQ05,2WKHUFRPPRQLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVZHUHVWLSSOHGVLJQ7
KLJKVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQIDFLDOSODQHLQWUDPXVFXODUKDHPRUUKDJH7KLJKVLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\RHGHPDLQVXEFXWDQHRXVIDWOD\HUDQGIRFDORUGLIIXVHQRQHQKDQFLQJ
SRUWLRQLQLQYROYHGPXVFOH
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHTXDQWLWDWLYHPRQLWRULQJRIPXVFOHKHDOLQJ
WKURXJKGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ '7, DQG7PDSSLQJDVVHVVPHQW
$(VSRVLWR)'H&REHOOL$3DOPLVDQR7&DQX/&DPSDQD
*3H]]HWWL$0DQIUHGL35RYHUH4XHULQL$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,7
HVSRVLWRDQWRQLR#KVULW
3XUSRVH 7R SURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWH D PXOWLSDUDPHWULF 05, SURWRFRO DV D QRQ
LQYDVLYH DQG TXDQWLWDWLYH WRRO IRU PRQLWRULQJ PXVFOH GDPDJHKHDOLQJ SURFHVV
REWDLQLQJG\QDPLFLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWLQÁDPPDWRU\LQÀOWUDWHDQGÀEUHVUHJHQHUDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$FXWHPXVFOHLQMXU\ZDVREWDLQHGE\FDUGLRWR[LQ &7;
LQMHFWLRQLQWRWLELDOLVDQWHULRU 7$ RI&%/PLFH$Q05,VWXG\LQFOXGLQJ7
PDSSLQJ GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ DQG GLIIXVLRQWHQVRU LPDJLQJ '7, ZDV
SHUIRUPHGEHIRUHDQGDQGGD\VDIWHULQMXU\$WHDFKWLPHSRLQW
DQLPDOVXQGHUZHQW05,DQGZHUHVDFULÀFHGLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHULPDJLQJWRREWDLQ
WLVVXHҋVVDPSOHVIRUKLVWRORJLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV7UHOD[DWLRQWLPH 7UW VLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGDIWHULQMXU\UHDFKLQJWKH
WRS DW GD\V VXEVHTXHQWO\ 7UW SURJUHVVLYHO\ GHFUHDVH IURP UG WR WK GD\
UHFRYHULQJ D FRPSOHWH QRUPDOLVDWLRQ$ JHQHUDO LQFUHDVH RI PXVFOH GLIIXVLYLW\
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQLPSRUWDQWORVVRIIUDFWLRQDODQLVRWURS\ )$ ZDVREVHUYHG
KRXUVDIWHULQMXU\$IWHUZDUG)$SURJUHVVLYHO\LQFUHDVHGIURPGD\WRGD\XSWR
YDOXHVDERYHWKHQRUPDOOHYHO)URPGD\IRUZDUG)$VKRZHGDYHU\VORZSURJUHV
VLYHGHFUHDVHWRZDUGVEDVDOOHYHO3HDUVRQWHVWUHYHDOHGJRRGFRUUHODWLRQVRI7UW
ZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOGDPDJHVFRUH U S DQGHVSHFLDOO\ZLWKQXPEHURI
LQÀOWUDWLQJOHXFRF\WHV U S )$FRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHKLVWRORJLFDOFRXQW
RIFHQWUHQXFOHDWHGUHJHQHUDWLQJÀEUHV U S
&RQFOXVLRQ 05, ZLWK 7PDSSLQJ DQG '7, FRXOG EH FRQVLGHUHG DQ HIIHFWLYH
QRQLQYDVLYHWRROWRREWDLQSDQRUDPLFPRQLWRULQJRIPXVFOHGDPDJHDQGUHSDLU
LQJSURFHVVZLWKTXDQWLWDWLYHUHDGRXWDERXWOHXFRF\WHVLQÀOWUDWLRQDQGWKHÀEUHV
UHJHQHUDWLRQ
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJRIWKHORZHUOLPEPXVFOHV
LQ'XFKHQQHPXVFXODUG\VWURSK\DQHZDSSURDFKIRUPRQLWRULQJ
WKHGLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQDQGUHVSRQVHWRWKHUDS\
&*RGL6*HUHYLQL61DSROLWDQR)&LFHUL*&RVVX<7RUUHQWH*6FRWWL
/63ROLWL0LODQ,7 FODXGLDJRGL#FROOHJLRGLPLODQRLW
3XUSRVH 7RGHWHUPLQHWKURXJKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, WKHSDWWHUQ
RIORZHUOLPELQYROYHPHQWLQ'XFKHQQHPXVFXODUG\VWURSK\ '0' WRFRPSDUH
TXDQWLWDWLYH05,SDUDPHWHUVZLWKIXQFWLRQDOPHDVXUHVLQ'0'SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHQW\VL[ WR \HDUROG '0' SDWLHQWV DQG
PDWFKHG KHDOWK\ FRQWUROV XQGHUZHQW 7 05, H[DPLQDWLRQV RI WKH ORZHU OLPEV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
ZLWKRXW VHGDWLRQ DW EDVHOLQH DQG DIWHU QLQH PRQWKV$[LDO DQG FRURQDO 6( 7
PXOWLHFKR767,5)6(7ZHLJKWHG Z DQG'7+5,9(LPDJHVRIWKHOHJVDQG
WKLJKVZHUHDFTXLUHG$IWHUWKUHVKROGVHJPHQWDWLRQRQ7ZLPDJHVWKHPXVFOH
YROXPHV 09 ZHUHPHDVXUHGDQGQRUPDOLVHGWRWKHHQWLUHOLPEYROXPH0XVFOH
VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\GHULYHGIURP7ZLPDJHVZDVQRUPDOLVHGWRQHDUE\IDWLQWHQVLW\
WRREWDLQPXVFXODUVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\UDWLRV 6,5V DVPDUNHUVRIIDWW\GHJHQHUDWLRQ
09VDQG6,5VZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKFOLQLFDOPHDVXUHVDQGWHVWVLQFOXGLQJ1RUWK
6WDU6FRUHDQG.LQ&RP6L[SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWIXUWKHU05,H[DPLQDWLRQVHYHU\
PRQWKVEHIRUHEHLQJWUHDWHGZLWKLQWUDDUWHULDOLQMHFWLRQRIPHVRDQJLREODVWV
5HVXOWV'0'SDWLHQWVҋ09ZDVORZHUWKDQKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV([FHSWIRUVDUWRULXV
DQGJUDFLOLVSDWLHQWVҋ6,5VZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQFRQWUROVҋRQHV'XULQJ
IROORZXSSDWLHQWVVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWWKLJK09GHFUHDVHDQGOHJ09LQFUHDVH
ZKLOH6,5VZHUHVWDEOHRULQFUHDVHGRYHUWLPH6LJQLÀFDQW6SHDUPDQFRUUHODWLRQV
EHWZHHQ6,5VIXQFWLRQDOPHDVXUHVDQGWKLJK09VZHUHIRXQG,QVRPHSDWLHQWV
ZLWK VXVSHFWHG EDG FRPSOLDQFH 05, GLVFRQÀUPHG WKH SRRU FOLQLFDO UHVXOWV
)ROORZXSDIWHUPHVRDQJLREODVWWUDQVSODQWDWLRQLVRQJRLQJ
&RQFOXVLRQ05,FRXOGSURYLGHUHOLDEOHPDUNHUVRIPXVFOHGHJHQHUDWLRQZKLFK
FRUUHODWHWRQHXURORJLFDOIXQFWLRQDOSHUIRUPDQFHVDQGVKRXOGEHHPSOR\HGLQFOLQLFDO
WULDOVDVRXWFRPHPHDVXUHV
%
,QYLYRDVVHVVPHQWRIVNHOHWDOPXVFOHLVFKDHPLDLQGLDEHWLFUDWVE\
05DQJLRJUDSK\05LPDJLQJDQGSURWRQ05VSHFWURVFRS\
6'HOOL3L]]L50DGRQQD$*LDPPDULQL*/5RPDQL5'H&DWHULQD
$7DUWDUR&KLHWL,7 VGHOOLSL]]L#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIXVLQJ05WHFKQLTXHVIRULQYLYRLQYHVWLJDWLQJ
DUDWGLDEHWLFPRGHORIKLQGOLPELVFKDHPLD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV([SHULPHQWVZDVDSSURYHGE\RXU,QVWLWXWLRQDO(WKLFV
&RPPLWWHHIRUDQLPDOUHVHDUFK8QLODWHUDOKLQGOLPELVFKDHPLDZDVLQGXFHGE\
OLJDWLRQRIWKHIHPRUDODUWHU\LQPDOHVWUHSWR]RWRFLQ 67= WUHDWHG EORRGJOXFRVH
PJG/ DQGKHDOWK\QRQGLDEHWLFFRQWUROUDWV)RXUZHHNVDIWHUOLJDWLRQUDWV
XQGHUZHQW'WLPHRIÁLJKW 72) 05DQJLRJUDSK\ 05$ 7ZHLJKWHG 7:
DQGVKRUWWLPHLQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\ 67,5 VHTXHQFHVDQGPXVFOHSURWRQ05VSHF
WURVFRS\ +056 RQERWKKLQGOLPEV$IWHU05H[DPLQDWLRQVLPPXQREORWWLQJ
DQGLPPXQRÁXRUHVFHQFHDQDO\VLVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV05$VKRZHGDVLJQDOYRLGGXHWRÁRZGLVFRQWLQXDWLRQGLVWDOWRWKHOLJD
WLRQRIFRPPRQLOLDFIHPRUDODUWHU\05,VKRZHGWKHSUHVHQFHRIWLVVXHVZHOOLQJ
S IRUQRQGLDEHWLFS IRUGLDEHWLFUDWV DQGVLJQDOK\SHULQWHQVLW\LQ
WLVVXHDIIHFWHGE\RFFOXVLRQ+056VKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQRIWRWDOFUHD
WLQHZDWHULQRFFOXGHGYVQRQRFFOXGHGOLPEV S IRUQRQGLDEHWLFS
IRUGLDEHWLFUDWV 05,DQG+056FKDQJHVZHUHPRUHSURQRXQFHGLQGLDEHWLF
WKDQLQQRQGLDEHWLFRFFOXGHGOLPEV S 05ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRQÀUPHGXVLQJ
KLVWRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPELQHG05WHFKQLTXHVFDQEHXVHGWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKHSUHVHQFH
RIVWUXFWXUDODQGPHWDEROLFFKDQJHVSURGXFHGLQDUDWGLDEHWLFPRGHORIOLPELVFKDH
PLD7KLV05SURWRFROFRXSOHGZLWKDQH[SHULPHQWDOUDWPRGHORISHULSKHUDODUWHU\
RFFOXVLRQPD\EHXVHIXOIRUHYDOXDWLQJLQYLYRWKHHIÀFDF\RIQRYHOSKDUPDFRORJLFDO
DVZHOODVJHQHDQGFHOOEDVHGWKHUDSLHV
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIIDWLQÀOWUDWLRQLQWKHURWDWRUFXIIPXVFOHV
XVLQJ05,
/1DUGR-&DUEDOOLGR*DPLR'.DUDPSLQRV+$OL]DL%&0D70/LQN
5.UXJ6DQ)UDQFLVFR&$86
3XUSRVH7RYDOLGDWHWKHHVWDEOLVKHGTXDOLWDWLYH*RXWDOOLHUҋVFODVVLÀFDWLRQ *&
RIIDWW\LQÀOWUDWLRQ ), ZLWKLQWKHURWDWRUFXII 5& PXVFOHVXVLQJDQRYHOFKHPLFDO
VKLIWEDVHG05,WHFKQLTXH ,'($/ DQGWRHVWDEOLVKWKHUHSURGXFLELOLW\RI,'($/
LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRI),
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK5&WHDUV\PSWRPV PDOHVIHPDOHV
DJHG\HDUV ZDVXVHGDQGRIWKHVHSDWLHQWVZHUHVFDQQHGWZLFH6KRXOGHU
05H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGDW7HVODZLWKDQFKDQQHOVKRXOGHUVXUIDFH
FRLO XVLQJ VDJLWWDO SODQ 3')6( DQG ,'($/ )29 67 PP IRU ERWK )DW
IUDFWLRQPDSVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGRQOLQHZLWK7 FRUUHFWLRQDQGDPXOWLSHDNIDW
VSHFWUXP),IRUHDFKRIWKHURWDWRUFXIIPXVFOHZDVVFRUHGLQWKHSURWRQGHQVLW\
ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVXVLQJ*&6SHDUPDQҋVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWFRPSDUHG,'($/
IDWIUDFWLRQYDOXHVZLWK*&IRUHDFK5&PXVFOHUHSURGXFLELOLW\RI,'($/WHFKQLTXH
ZDVGHWHUPLQHGXVLQJDEVROXWHSUHFLVLRQHUURULQWKHGRXEOHGVFDQQHGSDWLHQWV
5HVXOWV6SHDUPDQҋVFRHIÀFLHQWEHWZHHQ,'($/DQG*&ZDV S
8VLQJ,'($/PHDVXUHPHQWVWKHDPRXQWRI),UDQJHGIRU*RXWDOOLHUJUDGHIURP
WRIRUJUDGHIURPWRIRUJUDGHIURPWRIURPJUDGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
IURPWRDQGIRUJUDGHIURPWR7KHSUHFLVLRQHUURURIWKH
,'($/IDWIUDFWLRQYDOXHUDQJHGIURPWRIRUHDFK5&PXVFOH
&RQFOXVLRQ5&TXDOLWDWLYHFOLQLFDOJUDGLQJRI),XVLQJWKH*&DQGTXDQWLWDWLYH
IDWIUDFWLRQYDOXHVGHULYHGXVLQJ,'($/ZHUHVWURQJO\DVVRFLDWHG,'($/SHUPLWWHG
DTXDQWLWDWLYHDQGZHOOUHSURGXFLEOHPHDVXUHPHQWRI),
%
/HVLRQVRIWKHELFHSVSXOOH\GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI05
DUWKURJUDSK\RIWKHVKRXOGHUDQGHYDOXDWLRQRIQHZDQGHVWDEOLVKHG
GLDJQRVWLFFULWHULD
&6FKDHIIHOHU6:DOGW.+RO]DSIHO&.LUFKKRII3-XQJPDQQ3:ROI
(-5XPPHQ\$%,PKRII.:RHUWOHU0XQLFK'( VFKDHIIHOHU#PHFRP
5RRP(
*,7UDFW
66D
*,WUDFWVWUXFWXUHDQGIXQFWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
6-DFNVRQ3O\PRXWK8.
%/XFH\*DOZD\,(
%
'\QDPLF05,GHIHFRJUDSK\YVHQWHURFROSRF\VWRGHIHFRJUDSK\LQ
WKHHYDOXDWLRQRIPLGOLQHSHOYLFÁRRUKHUQLDVLQIHPDOHSHOYLFÁRRU
GLVRUGHUV
*'L*UH]LD**DWWD5/LHWR),DFREHOOLV/8UFLXROL93DUODWR5*UDVVL
$5RWRQGR1DSOHV,7 JUD]LHOODGLJUH]LD#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\RIG\QDPLF
05 GHIHFRJUDSK\ 05' ZLWK HQWHURFROSRF\VWRGHIHFRJUDSK\ (&&' LQ WKH
DVVHVVPHQWRIPLGOLQHSHOYLFÁRRUKHUQLDV 03+ LQIHPDOHSHOYLFÁRRUGLVRUGHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP$XJXVWWR$XJXVWIHPDOHSDWLHQWV
ZKRUHTXLUHG(&&'IRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRISHOYLFÁRRUGLVRUGHUVZHUHHQUROOHGLQWKLV
VWXG\$OOWKHSDWLHQWVZLWK(&&'ÀQGLQJVRI03+ZHUHDVNHGWRXQGHUJR
05'DFFHSWHGWRXQGHUJR05'DQGFRQVWLWXWHGWKHREMHFWRIDQDO\VLV
7KLVVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\WKH,QVWLWXWLRQDO(WKLFDO&RPPLWWHH$OOWKHSDWLHQWV
JDYHWKHLUZULWWHQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWWRWDNHSDUWLQWKHVWXG\
5HVXOWV 2YHUDOO WKH SUHYDOHQFH RI 03+ DW (&&' ZDV KLJKHU LI FRPSDUHG
ZLWKWKDWDW05'&RQFHUQLQJWKHKHUQLDFRQWHQWWKHUHZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUH
HQWHURFHOHVDQGVLJPRLGRFHOHVRQ(&&'WKDQRQ05'ZKHUHDVLQUHODWLRQWR
WKHKHUQLDGHYHORSPHQWPRGDOLWLHVWKHSUHYDOHQFHRIHO\WURFHOHVHGURFHOHVDQG
'RXJODVҋ KHUQLDV DW (&&' ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU WKDQ WKDW DW 05' ,Q VSLWH
RIDVSHFLÀFLW\WKHVHQVLELOLW\RI05'LQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIDQRPHQWRFHOH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
,PSURYLQJDQRUHFWDODQJOHPHDVXUHPHQWUHSURGXFLELOLW\E\DVHPL
DXWRPDWHGPHWKRG
0$$ONXEH\\HU%-(ULFNVRQ-*)OHWFKHU5L\DGK6$5RFKHVWHU0186
GUPHWDE#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 0XFK KDV EHHQ ZULWWHQ DERXW SRRU UHSURGXFLELOLW\ RI DQRUHFWDO DQJOH
$5$ PHDVXUHPHQWLQGHIHFRJUDSK\$5$LVRIWHQGHWHUPLQHGE\HVWLPDWLQJD
VWUDLJKWOLQHDORQJWKHSRVWHULRUERUGHURIWKHUHFWXPDQGWKHDQDOFDQDO$VHPL
DXWRPDWHGPHWKRGIRU$5$PHDVXUHPHQWLVLQWURGXFHGWRHQKDQFHUHSURGXFLELOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHFDVHVRIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHGHIHFRJ
UDSK\ZLWKYDULDEOHHYDFXDWRU\GLVRUGHUVZHUHUHFUXLWHG$IWHUDGGLQJP/RI
XOWUDVRXQGJHOWRWKHUHFWXPPLGVDJLWWDOLPDJHVRIWKHSHOYLVDWUHVWVTXHH]H
DQGVWUDLQZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJ7ZHLJKWHGVWHDG\VWDWHIUHHSUHFHVVLRQ 66)3
VHTXHQFH7ZRUHDGHUV0. IHOORZVKLSWUDLQHGUDGLRORJLVW DQG=. 0'3K'VWX
GHQW KDYHPHDVXUHG$5$PDQXDOO\DQGVHPLDXWRPDWLFDOO\LQWZRVHVVLRQZLWK
RQHZHHNLQWHUYDO0DQXDOPHDVXUHPHQWKDVEHHQGRQHE\SORWWLQJDOLQHWKURXJK
WKHDQDOD[LVDQGWKURXJKWKHSRVWHULRUDVSHFWRIWKHORZHUUHFWXP6HPLDXWRPDWLF
PHDVXUHPHQWKDVEHHQGRQHE\FOLFNLQJDORQJWKHSUR[LPDODQGWKHGLVWDOHQGRI
WKHDQDOFDQDODQGWKHSURJUDPZLOODXWRPDWLFDOO\HVWLPDWHWKH$5$E\WKUHVKROGLQJ
WKHORZHUUHFWXPWKHQDSSO\LQJDFRQYROXWLRQÀOWHUIROORZHGE\RYDOÀWWLQJWRWKH
ODUJHVWÀOWHUHGSRVWHULRUVHJPHQWRIWKHUHFWXP
5HVXOWV%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLVVKRZHGKLJKUHSURGXFLELOLW\RI$5$PHDVXUHPHQWV
XVLQJWKHVHPLDXWRPDWHGPHWKRGFRPSDUHGWRPDQXDOPHWKRGZLWKELDVVWDQGDUG
GHYLDWLRQOLPLWVRIDJUHHPHQWRI>@DQG
>@UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ$VHPLDXWRPDWHGPHWKRGFDQGHFUHDVHWKHLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\
RI$5$PHDVXUHPHQWIRUZKLFKIXWXUHGHIHFRJUDSK\FRPSDUDWLYHVWXGLHVEHFRPH
PRUHIHDVLEOHDQGUHSURGXFLEOH
%
6FDWWHUHGUDGLDWLRQGRVHVWRRSHUDWRUVSHUIRUPLQJÁXRURVFRSLF
VWXGLHVRQEDULDWULFSDWLHQWV
0$$UVKDG$6HUJRW'%OXQW/0RUULV/RQGRQ8.
PXEDULN#GRFWRUVRUJXN
3XUSRVH)OXRURVFRS\LVIUHTXHQWO\XVHGIRUDVVHVVLQJSRVWRSHUDWLYHFRPSOLFD
WLRQVDQGVXUYHLOODQFHDIWHUEDULDWULFVXUJHU\,QWKLVVWXG\WKHDPRXQWRIVFDWWHUHG
UDGLDWLRQHQFRXQWHUHGZDVPHDVXUHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQYROYLQJSRVWRSHUDWLYHEDULDWULF
VXUJHU\ SDWLHQWV DQG FRQWUROV ZDV XQGHUWDNHQ 7KH VFDWWHUHG UDGLDWLRQ ZDV
PHDVXUHG ZKLOVW SHUIRUPLQJ XSSHU JDVWURLQWHVWLQDO ÁXRURVFRSLF VWXGLHV XVLQJ D
EDGJHGRVLPHWHUZRUQRYHUWKHSURWHFWLYHOHDGVKLHOGLQJ7KHERG\PDVVLQGH[
%0, VFUHHQLQJWLPHDQGGRVHDUHDSURGXFW '$3 ZHUHDOVRPHDVXUHG
5HVXOWV,QWKHEDULDWULFJURXSWKHPHDQ%0,ZDV &,
FRQWUROJURXSRI S )RUWKHEDULDWULFJURXSWKHDYHUDJH
VFUHHQLQJWLPHZDVDQGIRUWKHFRQWURO S 7KH'$3PHDVXUHG
*\FP LQWKHEDULDWULFJURXSFRQWUROJURXS S
7KHDYHUDJHGHHSGRVHVFDWWHUUHDGLQJIRUHDFKEDULDWULFSDWLHQWZDVP6Y
FRPSDUHGZLWKIRUHDFKFRQWURODQGWKHDYHUDJHVXUIDFHUHDGLQJGRVHIRUD
EDULDWULFSDWLHQWZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKIRUQRQEDULDWULFSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVFUHHQLQJWLPHVZHUHVLPLODUGXHWRDFRPELQDWLRQRIFDUHIXO
FROOLPDWLRQDQGXVLQJODVWLPDJHKROGLQWKHEDULDWULFJURXS7KHUHZDVKRZHYHU
DWRWLPHLQFUHDVHLQWKHDPRXQWRIVFDWWHUHGUDGLDWLRQZKLOVWVFUHHQLQJEDUL
DWULFSDWLHQWV7KLVVWXG\KLJKOLJKWVWKHLQFUHDVHGUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHWRRSHUDWRUV
SURYLGLQJEDULDWULFÁXRURVFRSLFVHUYLFHV7KHLPSOLFDWLRQVRIWKLVDUHGLVFXVVHG
ZLWKUHIHUHQFHWRWKHLQFUHDVLQJYROXPHRIEDULDWULFVXUJLFDOSURFHGXUHVDQGWKHLU
LPSDFWRQUDGLRORJ\GHSDUWPHQWV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\GHWHUPLQHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIPDJQHWLFUHVR
QDQFHDUWKURJUDSK\ 05$ RIWKHVKRXOGHULQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIOHVLRQVRIWKHELFHSV
SXOOH\DQGWRHYDOXDWHHVWDEOLVKHGDQGQHZGLDJQRVWLFFULWHULD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05DUWKURJUDPVRIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH
\HDUVPDOHIHPDOH ZLWKDUWKURVFRSLFDOO\SURYHQHLWKHULQWDFWRUWRUQ
SXOOH\V\VWHPVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WKUHHUDGLRORJLVWV(YDOXDWHGGLDJQRVWLFFULWHULD
ZHUHGLVSODFHPHQWRIWKHORQJKHDGRIWKHELFHSVWHQGRQ /+%7 UHODWLYHWRWKH
VXEVFDSXODULVPXVFOHWHQGRQRQSDUDVDJLWWDOLPDJHV GLVSODFHPHQWVLJQ PHGLDO
VXE OX[DWLRQRIWKH/+%7RQWUDQVYHUVHLPDJHVGLVFRQWLQXLW\RULQYLVLELOLW\RIWKH
VXSHULRUJOHQRKXPHUDOOLJDPHQW 6*+/ SUHVHQFHRIWHQGLQRSDWK\RIWKH/+%7RQ
WUDQVYHUVHRUSDUDVDJLWWDOLPDJHVURWDWRUFXIIWHDUVDGMDFHQWWRWKHURWDWRULQWHUYDO
,QWHUUDWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\ZDVFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV 2Q DUWKURVFRS\ SXOOH\ OHVLRQV ZHUH GLDJQRVHG 05$ VKRZHG
D VHQVLWLYLW\ RI UHDGHU UHDGHU UHDGHU DQG D VSHFLÀ
FLW\ RI ,QWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW ZDV VXEVWDQWLDO ѣ
$VVHVVPHQW RI WKH 6*+/ VKRZHG D VHQVLWLYLW\ RI DQG D
VSHFLÀFLW\ RI :LWK WKH GLVSODFHPHQW VLJQ VHQVLWLYLW\ ZDV
VSHFLILFLW\ ZDV 7HQGLQRSDWK\ RI
WKH /+%7 RQ SDUDVDJLWWDO LPDJHV VKRZHG D VHQVLWLYLW\ RI
VSHFLÀFLW\ ZDV 6XEOX[DWLRQ RI WKH /+%7 ZDV LQVHQVLWLYH
EXWVSHFLÀF
&RQFOXVLRQ05$LVDFFXUDWHLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHELFHSVSXOOH\7KHGLVSODFH
PHQWVLJQLQYLVLELOLW\RUGLVFRQWLQXLW\RIWKH6*+/DQGVLJQVRIWHQGLQRSDWK\RI
WKH/+%7RQSDUDVDJLWWDOLPDJHVDUHWKHPRVWDFFXUDWHFULWHULDLQWKHGHWHFWLRQ
RISXOOH\OHVLRQV
VLJPRLGRFHOHDQGHQWHURFHOHZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\DQGVKRZLQJDQ
LQIHULRUGLDJQRVWLFFDSDFLW\LIFRPSDUHGZLWKWKDWRI(&&'
&RQFOXVLRQ05'VKRZVORZHUVHQVLWLYLW\WKDQ(&&'LQWKHGHWHFWLRQRI03+
GHYHORSPHQW7KHOHVVLQYDVLYH05'PD\KDYHDUROHLQDEHWWHUHYDOXDWLRQRI
WKHHQWLUHSHOYLFDQDWRP\DQGSHOYLFRUJDQLQWHUDFWLRQHVSHFLDOO\LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
PXOWLFRPSDUWPHQWDOGHIHFWVSODQQHGIRUVXUJHU\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
0XOWLSOHVZDOORZLQJGLVRUGHUVRIRURRHVRSKDJHDOWUDFWDQGJDVWUR
RHVRSKDJHDOMXQFWLRQUROHRI05ÁXRURVFRS\ZLWKKLJKVSHHG
NLQHWLFVHTXHQFHV
,6DQVRQL&/3LFFROR)3LWRFFR5/$OORQL5'HO9HVFRYR5&RSSROD
%%HRPRQWH=REHO5RPH,7
3XUSRVH7RGHÀQHXSSHUDQGORZHUVZDOORZLQJGLVRUGHUVWHVWLQJWKHIHDVLELOLW\RI
KLJKVSHHGNLQHWLF05VHTXHQFHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PDOHDQGIHPDOH ZLWKRURRHVRSKDJHDO
DQGJDVWURRHVRSKDJHDOGLVRUGHUVXQGHUZHQW05H[DPLQDWLRQRQD7HVODVFDQ
QHU:HDFTXLUHG%+*5(XQVSRLOHG7ZDQG+$67(7ZVHTXHQFHVRQPXOWLSOH
SODQHVLQRUGHUWRGHÀQHWKHDQDWRPLFGHWDLOV IH1LVVHQIXQGRSOLFDWLRQSRVLWLRQ
DERYHRUEHORZGLDSKUDJPDWLFSODQH 9LVXDOLVDWLRQRIRHVRSKDJHDOEROXVWUDQVLW
EROXVWUDQVLWWLPHSHULVWDOVLVJDVWURRHVRSKDJHDOMXQFWLRQSDWHQF\DQGFRPSHWHQF\
GXULQJRUDODGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWHG\RJXUWZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV05ÁXRURVFRS\UHYHDOHGWREHDUHOLDEOHWRROWRHYDOXDWHEROXVSURSXOVLRQ
IURPRHVRSKDJXVWRVWRPDFK05ÁXRURVFRS\VKRZHGVZDOORZLQJDEQRUPDOLWLHVLQ
SDWLHQWVXSSHUPRWLOLW\GLVRUGHUDFKDODVLDPHJDRHVRSKDJXVSDUD
RHVRSKDJHDO+MDWDO+HUQLDJDVWURRHVRSKDJHDOUHÁX[ RIWKRVHZLWKVOLGLQJ
+MDWDO+HUQLD DIWHU1LVVHQIXQGRSOLFDWLRQDIWHUJDVWUHFWRP\05ÀQGLQJVZHOO
FRUUHODWHGZLWKRWKHUGLIIHUHQWLQVWUXPHQWDOH[DPLQDWLRQÀQGLQJV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QV\PSWRPDWLFVXEMHFWVDIWHU1LVVHQIXQGRSOLFDWLRQ05ÁXRURVFRS\
FDQ GHWHFW PRWLOLW\ DOWHUDWLRQV SURYLGLQJ DGGLWLRQDO LQIRUPDWLRQ IRU GLDJQRVWLF
ZRUNXS)LQDOO\05)OXRURVFRS\LVDUDGLDWLRQIUHHDQGQRQLQYDVLYHWRRODEOHWR
HYLGHQFHVZDOORZLQJGLVRUGHULWLVVLPSOHQRQLQYDVLYHUDSLGDQGZHOOWROHUDWHG
IRUGLDJQRVLQJ*(UHÁX[RUPRWLOLW\GLVRUGHUV
%
05,VLQRJUDSK\ÀVWXORJUDSK\LVDQHZHUDQGOHVVXVHGWHFKQLTXHIRU
LPDJLQJSDWLHQWVZLWKVLQXVÀVWXODVZKHQFRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDO
VLQRJUDSK\ÀVWXORJUDSK\EXWPRUHKHOSIXODQGDFFXUDWHZLWKRXWUDGLDWLRQ
+33DUHNK18%DKUL'39DVDYDGD-DPQDJDU,1
3XUSRVH05,VLQRJUDSK\ÀVWXORJUDSK\LVFRQVLGHUHGDQHZHUDQGOHVVXVHGWHFK
QLTXHIRULPDJLQJSDWLHQWVZLWKSHULDQDOVLQXVÀVWXODV7RHYDOXDWHVWHULOHOLJQRFDLQH
MHOO\DVDFRQWUDVWDJHQWIRU05,DVDFKHDSHUDOWHUQDWLYHWRJDGROLQLXPEDVHG
FRQWUDVWIRUOHVLRQVZKHUHQRYDVFXODUFRPPXQLFDWLRQLVSUREDEOH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVDUHVWXGLHGWRGDWHWRFRPSDUHWKHLQIRUPDWLRQ
SURYLGHGE\FRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJYHUVXV05,SDWLHQWVLQZKRPWKHH[WHUQDO
RSHQLQJZDVYLVLEOHVWHULOHOLJQRFDLQHMHOO\ZDVLQMHFWHGDQG05,ZDVGRQH
SDWLHQWVLQZKRPWKHH[WHUQDORSHQLQJZDVQRWYLVLEOH+HDYLO\7:,LPDJHVZHUH
WDNHQZLWKRXWLQMHFWLQJOLJQRFDLQH$OOWKHLPDJHVVWXGLHGIRUH[DFWORFDWLRQWUDFN
RSHQLQJVERWKLQWHUQDODQGH[WHUQDODQGDQ\YLVFHUDOFRPPXQLFDWLRQ5HVXOWVZHUH
DQDO\VHGDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHÀQGLQJVRIFRQYHQWLRQDOVWXG\
5HVXOWV ,Q WKH SDWLHQWV VWXGLHG SDWLHQWV KDG WKH VDPH ÀQGLQJV RQ ERWK
PRGDOLWLHV SDWLHQWV KDG DGGLWLRQDO LQIRUPDWLRQ RQ 05, LQWHUFRPPXQLFDWLQJ
RUPRUHWUDFNVV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVKDGQRQFRQFOXVLYHFRQYHQWLRQDOVWXG\
ZKHUH05,GHOLQHDWHGGHWDLOHGSDWKRORJ\6WHULOHOLJQRFDLQHMHOO\SURYLGHGDGHTXDWH
FRQWUDVWDORQJZLWKKHDYLO\7ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJSURYLGHGGLDJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQ
DQGQRDGYHUVHUHDFWLRQVZHUHQRWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ05VLQRJUDSK\EHLQJDQHZHUDQGDGYDQFHGWHFKQLTXHVKRXOGEH
DSSOLHGLQDOOV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVZKHUHWKHFRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVDUH
QRWVDWLVIDFWRU\,QDGGLWLRQV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWYLVLEOHH[WHUQDORSHQLQJ
05,LVPRVWXVHIXOIRUGHWHFWLRQDQGVXUJLFDOJXLGDQFH6WHULOHOLJQRFDLQHMHOO\LV
FKHDSHUHDVLO\DYDLODEOHDQGVXLWDEOHFRQWUDVWPDWHULDOIRUWKLVVWXG\ZLWKJRRG
SDWLHQWFRPSOLDQFH
%
6DQGZLFKVLJQRI%RUUPDQQW\SHJDVWULFFDQFHURQGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
/7DQJ;3=KDQJ<66XQ=</L-)-L;7/L<4/LX4:X
%HLMLQJ&1 WDQJOHL#EMFDQFHURUJ
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH DSSHDUDQFH RI %RUPDQQ W\SH %7 JDVWULF FDQFHU
RQGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ ':, DQGWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKH
SRWHQWLDORITXDOLWDWLYHDQGTXDQWLWDWLYH':LPDJHVDQDO\VLVWRGLIIHUHQWLDWH%7
JDVWULFFDQFHUIURPSRRUO\GLVWHQGHGQRUPDOVWRPDFKZDOO
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ':, ZDV SHUIRUPHG RQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK %7 JDVWULF
FDQFHU DQG KHDOWK\ YROXQWHHUV 7KH VLJQDO FKDUDFWHULVWLFV DQG FRUUHODWHG
KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOEDVLVRIWKHFDQFHUVRQ':,ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHG7KHFRQWUDVWWR
QRLVHUDWLRV &15 RIFDQFHUZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQ':,DQG7:,7:,7KH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
WKLFNQHVVDQGDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& RIFDQFHUDQGQRUPDOVWRPDFK
ZDOOZHUHFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV$OORIWKHJDVWULFFDQFHUVGLVSOD\HGK\SHULQWHQVLW\FRPSDUHGWRWKHQHDUE\
QRUPDOJDVWULFZDOORQ':,$WKUHHOD\HUVDQGZLFKVLJQWKDWGHPRQVWUDWHGKLJK
VLJQDOVLQWKHLQQHUDQGRXWHUOD\HUDQGORZVLJQDOLQWKHLQWHUPHGLDWHOD\HUZDV
REVHUYHGLQRIFDQFHUVRQ':,7KHORZVLJQDOUHSUHVHQWVWKHPXVFXODULV
SURSULD WKURXJK WKH FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK SDWKRORJ\ DQG LW LV SRVWXODWHG VFDWWHULQJ
GLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHFDQFHUFHOOVLQWKLVOD\HUFDXVHVOHVVGDPDJHDQGVXEVHTXHQWO\
OHVVUHVWULFWLRQRIZDWHUPRYHPHQWZKLFKFDXVHVWKHORZVLJQDORQ':,7KHPHDQ
$'&YDOXHRI%7JDVWULFFDQFHUZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQWKHSRRUO\GLVWHQGHG
QRUPDOVWRPDFKZDOO ðPPVYV[PPV3
&RQFOXVLRQ ':, FDQ KLJKOLJKW WKH VLJQDOV RI %7 JDVWULF FDQFHU ZKLFK PD\
SUHVHQWDFKDUDFWHULVWLFWKUHHOD\HUVDQGZLFKVLJQDQG$'&YDOXHVDUHKHOSIXOLQ
WKHGLVFULPLQDWLRQRIJDVWULFFDQFHUIURPSRRUO\GLVWHQGHGVWRPDFKZDOO
%
$FXWHPHVHQWHULFLVFKDHPLDGRGLIIHUHQWÀQGLQJVVXJJHVWGLIIHUHQW
DHWLRORJ\"705,RQDUDWPRGHO
'%HUULWWR)6RPPD),DFREHOOLV0%HOÀRUH6&DSSDELDQFD$5RWRQGR
5*UDVVL1DSOHV,7 GDQLHODEHUULWWR#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH 7KH VLJQV RI DFXWH PHVHQWHULF LVFKDHPLD $0, YDU\ GHSHQGLQJ RQ
WKH FDXVH DQG XQGHUO\LQJ SDWKRSK\VLRORJ\ 0DJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH 05 ÀQGLQJV
LQWHVWLQDOPRUSKRG\QDPLVPDQGKLVWRORJLFDOSDWWHUQRI$0,GXHWRYDULRXVSULPDU\
FDXVHVDUHGLVFXVVHG
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHOYH 6SUDJXH'DZOH\ UDWV ZHUH GLYLGHG LQWR WKUHH
JURXSV Q 7ZRUDWVRIHDFKJURXSXQGHUZHQWVXSHULRUPHVHQWHULFDUWHU\ 60$
JURXSVDQG RUYHLQ 609 JURXS OLJDWLRQ([WHUQDOLVHGERZHOXQGHUZHQW
PDFURVFRSLFPRQLWRULQJ7KHUHPDLQLQJWZRUDWVRIHDFKJURXSKDGDQRQRFFOXGLQJ
ORRSWLHGDURXQG609RU60$DQGWKUHHGD\VDIWHUVXUJHU\YHVVHOVZHUHRFFOXGHG
E\VTXHH]LQJ WKHWLSVWXQQHOOHG WRWKHSRVWHULRUFHUYLFDO DUHD6HYHQ7HVOD 05
%UXNHU%LRVSHF86 VFDQV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG$OO UDWV RI JURXSV DQG
ZHUHPRQLWRUHGXQWLOKRXULQJURXSWKHOLJDWLRQZDVORRVHQDIWHUKRXUDQG
UHSHUIXVLRQZDVREVHUYHGXQWLOKRXUV7KHERZHOZDVUHPRYHGIRUKLVWRORJLFDO
DQDO\VLVDWWKHHQGRIREVHUYDWLRQ
5HVXOWV,QDOOW\SHRI$0,WKHPHVHQWHU\LVWKHÀUVWWRUHDFW,QWKHDUWHULDOLVFKDH
PLDLWDSSHDUVWKHFRQWUDFWLRQRIERZHOZDOOIROORZHGE\K\SRWRQ\DQGDERZHO
ZDOO WKLQQLQJ LV GLVWLQFWLYH ,Q FDVH RI 609 OLJDWLRQ WKH VSDVP LV DEVHQW GXH WR
ERZHOZDOOFRQJHVWLRQEXWWKLFNHQLQJDQGHDUO\FKURPDWLFFKDQJHRIWKHLQWHVWLQDO
ZDOOPHVHQWHULFXOFHUVDQGWKXPESULQWLQJDUHW\SLFDO,QFDVHRIUHSHUIXVLRQWKH
DSSHDUDQFHVWHHUWKHFRXUVHRI609OLJDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVDQLPDOPRGHOGHWHFWHGPRUSKRIXQFWLRQDODOWHUDWLRQVRILVFKDHPLF
ERZHODQGLGHQWLI\WKHVSHFLÀFSDWWHUQRIOHVLRQVRI$0,
%
(DUO\05,ÀQGLQJVRIVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQDQH[SHULPHQWDOVWXG\
),DFREHOOLV'%HUULWWR)6RPPD03%HOÀRUH6&DSSDELDQFD$5RWRQGR
5*UDVVL1DSOHV,7 IUDQFHVFDLDFREHOOLV#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRGRFXPHQWWKHHDUO\7PLFUR05,ÀQGLQJV
RIVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQDQGWKHLUHYROXWLRQLQWKHWLPHFRUUHODWLQJWKHPWRWKH
DQDWRPRSDWKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$GXOW 6SUDJXH 'DZOH\ UDWV Q ZHUH GLYLGHG LQWR
JURXSVLQWKHÀUVW Q UDWVXQGHUZHQWDVXUJLFDOSURFHGXUHRIVPDOOERZHOOLJD
WLRQIROORZHGE\KUVPDFURVFRSLFDOPRQLWRULQJLQWKHODWWHU Q 7PLFUR05
VFDQQLQJVZHUHSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHUOLJDWLRQ,QERWKFDVHVLQMXUHGERZHO
ZDVSURFHVVHGIRUKLVWRORJLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV3DWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVJRWHYLGHQWDOUHDG\PLQDIWHUVPDOOERZHOOLJD
WLRQ ZKHQ D VSDVWLF UHÁH[ LOHXV DQG D FKURPDWLF FKDQJH RI WKH LQMXUHG ERZHO
ZHUH IRXQG 7 PLFUR05 LPDJLQJ JDYH HDUO\ HYLGHQFH PLQ RI ERZHO ZDOO
K\SHULQWHQVLW\DQGPXUDOWKLFNQHVVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKOLWWOHDPRXQWRISHULWRQHDOIUHH
ÁXLG7KHVHÀQGLQJVJRWZRUVHQDQGZRUVHQWLOOWKHHQGRIWKHPRQLWRULQJSHULRG
ZKHQDQLQFUHDVHRIK\SHULQWHQVLW\ERZHOZDOOWKLFNQHVVLQLWLDOORRSFDOLEUHGLOD
WLRQDQGSHULWRQHDOIUHHÁXLGZHUHIRXQG7KHVHÀQGLQJVZHUHFRQÀUPHGDWWKH
DQDWRPRSDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\DOORZVWRGHÀQHWKHHDUO\05,IHDWXUHVRIERZHORFFOXVLRQ
DQGWKHLUFKURQRORJLFDOHYROXWLRQDOVRFRQÀUPHGE\DQDWRPRSDWKRORJLFDOH[DP
2XUGDWDVXJJHVWDUHOHYDQWUROHRI05LPDJLQJLQWKHHDUO\GLDJQRVWLFDVVHVV
PHQWDQGPDQDJHPHQWRISDWLHQWVZLWKVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQ7KHFKDQFHWR
DFKLHYHDQHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIERZHOLQMXU\DQGWRFRUUHODWHWKHKLVWRORJLFDOSDWWHUQ
ZLWKLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVFRXOGDGGUHVVWRZDUGVDÀQHUDQGHDUOLHUGLDJQRVLVDQGD
PRUHHIIHFWLYHWUHDWPHQW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGIRUGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRI
VXVSHFWHG*Y+'LQSDWLHQWVDIWHUDOORJHQHLFWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
/0'HQGO./DQGIULHG(0-XQJ13ODW]%DWLVWDGD6LOYD
&)ULHGULFK&6WURV]F]\QVNL$*6FKUH\HU
5HJHQVEXUJ'( OHQDBPDULHBGHQGO#\DKRRGH
&7YLUWXDOK\VWHURVDOSLQJRJUDSK\H[SHULHQFHLQFDVHV
-9DOOHMRV3&DUUDVFRVD&&DSXQD\$9DVFRQFHORV0%DURQLR
63DSLHU9LFHQWH/RSH]$5%XHQRV$LUHV$5 MDYVV#\DKRRFRPDU
3XUSRVH7RLOOXVWUDWHWKHVSHFWUXPRIÀQGLQJVDQGWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVZLWK
RWKHU SDWKRORJLHV LQ FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ YLUWXDO K\VWHURVDOSLQJRJUDSK\ &7
9+6* VWXGLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG&79+6*VWXGLHV
SHUIRUPHGLQRXULQVWLWXWLRQIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRILQIHUWLOLW\7KHH[DPVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
XVLQJDURZDQGURZ&7VFDQQHUV6FDQVSDUDPHWHUVZHUHPPVOLFH
WKLFNQHVVPPUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQWHUYDON9DQGP$V$WRWDOYROXPH
RIPOLRGLQHFRQWUDVWGLOXWLRQ PORILRGLQHFRQWUDVWDQGPORIVDOLQHVROX
WLRQ ZHUHDGPLQLVWHUHGLQWRWKHXWHULQHFDYLW\XVLQJDVHPLULJLGSODVWLFFDQQXOD
5HVXOWV,QWKHFHUYLFDOUHJLRQ&79+6*GHPRQVWUDWHGZDOOLUUHJXODULWLHV
IROGVWKLFNHQLQJ FHUYLFDOSRO\SV GLYHUWLFXODHV FHUYLFDOVWHQRVLV
FHUYLFDOV\QHFKLDHV 8WHULQHFDYLW\ÀQGLQJVZHUHSRO\SV VXE
PXFRXV P\RPDV V\QHFKLDHV 8WHULQH ZDOO DEQRUPDOLWLHV LQFOXGHG
LQWUDPXUDODQGVXEVHURXVP\RPDV XWHULQHPDOIRUPDWLRQV DGHQRP\RVLV
\&VHFWLRQVFDU )DOORSLDQWXEHVÀQGLQJVLQFOXGHGXQLODWHUDOK\GURV
DOSLQ[ DQGELODWHUDOK\GURVDOSLQ[ WXEDOREVWUXFWLRQ 7KHRIWKH
IDOORSLDQWXEHVZHUHSDUWLDOO\YLVXDOLVHGLQWKH&79+6*VWXGLHV7KHVFDQWLPH
ZDVVHF7KHHIIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHZDVP6Y7KHRI
WKHSDWLHQWVUHIHUUHGRQO\PLOGRUQRGLVFRPIRUW
&RQFOXVLRQ&79+6*DOORZHGDQDGHTXDWHDQGDFFXUDWHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHIHPDOH
LQWHUQDOJHQLWDORUJDQVSURYLGLQJFRPSUHKHQVLYHGLDJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKLQIHUWLOLW\7KLVLVPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHORZUDGLDWLRQGRVHWHFKQLTXHZHOOWROHUDWHG
IRUWKHYDVWPDMRULW\RIWKHSDWLHQWV
%
5RRP)
*HQLWRXULQDU\
66
*HQLWRXULQDU\&7
0RGHUDWRUV
21LNROLF1RYL6DG56
-6WRNHU$PVWHUGDP1/
%
,PSDFWRIWKJHQHUDWLRQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHVRQ
LPDJHTXDOLW\LQORZGRVHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\RIWKHXSSHUXULQDU\WUDFW
05HJLHU$/DTPDQL+&YRQ6FKXOW]HQGRUII'+DPPHUOH)2+HQHV
0*URWK+'1DJHO*$GDP-+%XKN+DPEXUJ'( PUHJLHU#XNHGH
3XUSRVH7RLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHDQGHYDOXDWHWKHLQÁXHQFHRIWKHWKJHQ
HUDWLRQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ,5 WHFKQLTXHL'RVH70RQORZGRVH0'&7RIWKH
XSSHUXULQDU\WUDFWZLWKUHJDUGWRDQDWRPLFDOGHOLQHDWLRQDQGDUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPXUROLWKLDVLVWKH
UDZGDWDRIXQHQKDQFHG0'&7VFDQV N9PHDQ&7',YROP*\ ZHUH
UHFRQVWUXFWHG XVLQJ D SURWRW\SLF UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ SURFHVVRU IHDWXULQJ L'RVH70
VRIWZDUH 3KLOLSV%HVWWKH1HWKHUODQGV L'RVH70OHYHOVYDULHGEHWZHHQ
DQG)RUHDFKVHWWLQJWZRGLIIHUHQWNHUQHOVZHUHDSSOLHG VWDQGDUG %VKDUS &
$OO LPDJHV ZHUH UHFRQVWUXFWHG ZLWK D VOLFH WKLFNQHVV RI PP %OLQGHG LPDJH
DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGE\WKUHHUDGLRORJLVWV$SRLQWJUDGLQJVFDOHZDVDSSOLHG
UHJDUGLQJ WKH GHSLFWLRQ RI DQDWRPLFDO GHWDLOV DQG GHJUHH RI DUWHIDFWV ZRUVW
H[FHOOHQW 7KHVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 ZDVDVVHVVHG6WDWLVWLFVLQFOXGHG
NDSSDDQDO\VLVDQG:LOFR[RQWHVW
5HVXOWV 7KH KLJKHVW LPDJH TXDOLW\ ZDV DVVHVVHG DSSO\LQJ DQ L'RVH70 OHYHO
RI(YHQDWWKHORZHUL'RVH70OHYHORIWKHUDWLQJVZHUHVXSHULRUWRVWDQGDUG
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ L'RVH70OHYHO ,IWKHFRPSDULVRQZDVPDGHDWDOPRVW
LGHQWLFDOLPDJHQRLVHWKHUHZDVDWUHQGWRZDUGVWKHVXSHULRULW\RIÀOWHU&RYHU
%2YHUDOOLQWHUUDWHUUHOLDELOLW\ZDVH[FHOOHQW щ! :LWKLQFUHDVLQJL'RVH70
OHYHOVUHGXFWLRQRIVWUHDNDUWHIDFWVZDVVXFFHVVIXOO\TXDQWLÀHGE\DGHFUHDVHRI
WKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQDWFRQVWDQWPHDQDWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHV
&RQFOXVLRQ,WHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVHHPVWREHDSRZHUIXOWRROIRUWKHLPSURYH
PHQWRILPDJHTXDOLW\LQORZGRVH0'&7RIWKHXSSHUXULQDU\WUDFW(YHQDWUHODWLYHO\
ORZL'RVH70OHYHOVKLJKHULPDJHTXDOLW\FRPSDUHGWRÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQFDQ
EHDFKLHYHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
'HWHFWDELOLW\RIVPDOOXULQDU\VWRQHVRQYLUWXDOQRQHQKDQFHGLPDJHV
ZLWKGLIIHUHQWVOLFHWKLFNQHVVJHQHUDWHGDWS\HORJUDSKLFSKDVHGXDO
HQHUJ\&7
6/LP</HH60RRQ'.DQJ6:HH0.LP,NVDQ.5
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGHWHFWDELOLWLHVRIVPDOOXULQDU\VWRQHVE\PPPP
PPVOLFHWKLFNQHVVYLUWXDOQRQHQKDQFHG 91( LPDJHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZKR KDG XQGHUJRQH DEGRPLQRSHOYLF &7
VFDQVZKLFKFRQVLVWHGRIWUXHQRQHQKDQFHG 71( DQGS\HORJUDSKLFSKDVHGXDO
VRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\&7VFDQVZHUHHQUROOHGSDWLHQWVZKRKDYHXULQDU\VWRQHV
OHVVWKDQPPLQGLDPHWHUZHUHHQUROOHGUDQGRPO\DQGSDWLHQWVZKRKDYHQR
XULQDU\VWRQHZHUHHQUROOHGIRUFRQWUROJURXS7RWDOVWRQHVZHUHHQUROOHG7ZR
UDGLRORJLVWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\HYDOXDWHGWKH91(LPDJHVIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIVWRQH
VL]HDQGORFDWLRQ,QDGGLWLRQWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\DUWHIDFWVDVVRFLDWHGUHQDODEQRU
PDOLWLHVDQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHZHUHDOVRFDOFXODWHG6HQVLWLYLWLHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRU
VWRQHVZLWKGLDPHWHURIPPPPDQGRYHUDOO6SHFLÀFLWLHVDFFXUDFLHV
DQGSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVZHUHDOVRFDOFXODWHG7KH71(LPDJHZDVFRQVLGHUHG
WKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQ RYHUDOO VHQVLWLYLWLHV RI WZR REVHUYHUV IRU GHWHFWLQJ VWRQHV
DWPPPPPP91(LPDJHVZHUH7KHVHQVLWLYLWLHVIRU
GHWHFWLQJPPVL]HGVWRQHVZHUH7KHVHQVLWLYLWLHV
IRUPPVL]HGVWRQHVZHUH7KHRYHUDOOVSHFLÀFLWLHV
ZHUH$FFXUDFLHVZHUH339
ZHUH,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWVKRZHGJRRG N
RIWRWDOUDGLDWLRQGRVHFRXOGKDYHEHHQUHGXFHGLI71(LPDJHVZHUHQRW
WDNHQ6\PSWRPDWLFXUHWHUDODQGXUHWHURYHVLFDOMXQFWLRQVWRQHV RIVWRQHV
ZHUHGHWHFWDEOHLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ91(LPDJHLVXVHIXOHYHQIRUGHWHFWLQJVPDOOXULQDU\VWRQHVDQG
GHWHFWDELOLW\RIVPDOOVWRQHVFDQEHHQKDQFHGZLWKPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV91(LPDJH
%
&7LQXURUROLWKLDVLVSRWHQWLDORIGRVHUHGXFWLRQDQGLPSDFWRQLPDJH
TXDOLW\XVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
-+DQVPDQQ*06FKRHSSOHU7+HQ]OHU++DXEHQUHLVVHU
05HLFKHUW8,$WWHQEHUJHU626FK|QEHUJ&)LQN
0DQQKHLP'( MDQKDQVPDQQ#PHGPDXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHSRWHQWLDORIGRVHUHGXFWLRQDQGLPSDFWRQLPDJHTXDOLW\
XVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRU&7RIXUROLWKLDVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$[PPXULFDFLGXUHWHUDOVWRQHZDVSODFHGLQVLGH
DQDQWKURSRPRUSKLF$OGHUVRQSKDQWRPDWWKHSHOYLFOHYHO0HDVXUHPHQWVZHUH
SHUIRUPHGRQDFKDQQHO0'&7V\VWHPXVLQJGLIIHUHQWN9 N9 DQG
P$V VHWWLQJV)RUHDFKN9DQGP$VVHWWLQJPPGDWDVHWVZHUH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH(DUO\GLDJQRVLVRI*Y+' JUDIWYHUVXVKRVWGLVHDVH DIWHUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ
IURPRWKHUFDXVHVOHDGLQJWRWKHVDPHV\PSWRPVVXFKDVYLUDORUEDFWHULDOHQWHULWLV
LVLPSRUWDQWEHFDXVHWKHWLPHQHHGHGIRUGLDJQRVLQJ*Y+'LVGLUHFWO\FRUUHODWHGWR
DZRUVHQLQJRIWKHRXWFRPH:HHYDOXDWHWKHYDOXHRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG
&(86 IRUWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRI*Y+'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HH[DPLQHGSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJZLWKWKHDEGRPL
QDOV\PSWRPVRI*Y+'$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW&(86ZLWKSDUWLFXODUDWWHQWLRQWR
SHQHWUDWLRQRIWKHLQWUDYHQRXVO\DSSOLHGPLFUREXEEOHVLQWKHERZHOOXPHQ,QWKH
SDWLHQWVKDYLQJDOOR6&7LQWKHLUKLVWRU\ZHKDGKLVWRORJLFDOFRQÀUPDWLRQRI*Y+'
7KHUHVXOWLQJH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHGRFXPHQWHGGLJLWDOO\
5HVXOWV2XWRISDWLHQWVZLWKFRQÀUPHG*Y+'RIWKH*,WUDFWVKRZHGSHQ
HWUDWLRQRIWKHLQWUDYHQRXVO\DSSOLHGPLFUREXEEOHVLQWRWKHERZHOOXPHQOHDGLQJ
WRDVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIDQGIRUWUDQVPXUDOEXEEOHSHQHWUDWLRQ
IRU*Y+'RIWKH*,7UDFWVLQFHWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKRXW*Y+'RIWKH*,WUDFWVKRZHG
QRWUDQVPXUDOEXEEOHSHQHWUDWLRQ,QSDWLHQWVZLWKYLUDORUEDFWHULDOLQIHFWLRQVRI
WKH*,WUDFWQRWUDQVPXUDOSHQHWUDWLRQRIWKHPLFUREXEEOHVLQWRWKHERZHOOXPHQ
ZDVREVHUYHG)RUPLFUREXEEOHSHQHWUDWLRQDVDFULWHULRQIRU*Y+'RIWKH*,7UDFW
WKLVOHDGVWRDQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 RIDQGDSRVLWLYHSUHGLFDWLYH
YDOXH 339 RI
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUVWXG\VWUHQJWKHQVWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDWWUDQVPXUDOEXEEOHSHQ
HWUDWLRQPD\EHDKLJKO\VSHFLÀFDQGDGHTXDWHO\VHQVLWLYHQRQLQYDVLYHGLDJQRVWLF
FULWHULRQIRU*Y+'RIWKH*,WUDFW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
UHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJVWDQGDUGÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQDQGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
VRIWWLVVXHNHUQHOV %DQG, 7KHUHVXOWLQJVFDQVZHUHUDQGRPLVHGLQWR
JURXSVDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DVVHVVHGE\WZREOLQGHGUHDGHUV7KH
EHVWWZRVFDQVRIHDFKJURXSZHUHDJDLQUDQGRPLVHGDQGSLWWHGDJDLQVWHDFKRWKHU
XQWLOWKHEHVWVFDQVZHUHGHWHUPLQHG(IIHFWLYHGRVH (' ZDVHVWLPDWHGIRUHDFK
GDWDVHWIURPGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFWDQGDFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRU1RLVHPHDVXUHPHQWV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQDQDGGLWLRQDOZDWHUSKDQWRPXVHGZLWKHDFKVFDQ
5HVXOWV/RZGRVHLPDJHVXVLQJDP$VVHWWLQJRIZHUHQRWGLDJQRVWLFDQGFRXOG
QRWYLVXDOLVHWKHVWRQH$PRQJWKHEHVWGDWDVHWVZHUHEDVHGRQLWHUDWLYHUH
FRQVWUXFWLRQV,PDJHTXDOLW\XVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDWWKHKLJKHVWGRVHZHUH
UDWHGWRKDYHWKHEHVWLPDJHTXDOLW\ NYP$V(' 1RLVHOHYHO
/RZHU GRVH VHWWLQJV N9 P$V (' 1RLVH OHYHO DOORZHG IRU
GLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\ZLWKDGRVHVDYLQJVSRWHQWLDORI
&RQFOXVLRQ,WHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOORZVIRUDSRWHQWLDOGRVHVDYLQJRIXSWR
ZKLOHVWLOO\LHOGLQJGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\LQ&7RIXUROLWKLDVLV
%
'XDOHQHUJ\VSOLWEROXV&7IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIXULQDU\VWRQHGLVHDVH
2QHSKDVHDFTXLVLWLRQWKUHHIROGLQIRUPDWLRQ
36WRO]PDQQ5*QDQQW$:LQNOHKQHU0)LVFKHU+$ONDGKL&.DUOR
=XULFK&+ SDXOVWRO]PDQQ#XV]FK
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\DVVHVVLPDJHTXDOLW\GLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHDQGUDGLD
WLRQGRVHRIGXDOHQHUJ\VSOLWEROXV&7IRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIXULQDU\VWRQHGLVHDVH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )LIW\ FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZRPHQ \UV
UHIHUUHGIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIXULQDU\VWRQHGLVHDVHDQGXULQDU\WUDFWREVWUXFWLRQ
XQGHUZHQW&7ZLWKDVWDQGDUGXQHQKDQFHGDQGGXDOHQHUJ\ GXDOVRXUFH&7
N9SZWLQÀOWHU FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGSKDVH&RQWUDVWPHGLD PJ,RGLQHPO
ZDVDGPLQLVWHUHGLQDVSOLWEROXVIDVKLRQ VWEROXVPOQGEROXVPODIWHU
PLQ 'XDOHQHUJ\GDWDZHUHDFTXLUHGPLQDIWHULQLWLDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQ
9LUWXDOQRQHQKDQFHG 91& LPDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGE\LRGLQHVXEWUDFWLRQ7ZR
EOLQGHGUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DVVHVVHGLPDJHTXDOLW\6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQG
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIXULQDU\VWRQHGLVHDVHZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRU
91&LPDJHVXVLQJVWDQGDUGXQHQKDQFHGLPDJHVDVWKHUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV,PDJHTXDOLW\RIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGGXDOHQHUJ\DQG91&LPDJHVZHUH
UDWHGGLDJQRVWLFLQDOOSDWLHQWV ,PDJHQRLVHRI91&LPDJHVZDVORZ
+8+8 6WDQGDUGXQHQKDQFHG&7UHYHDOHGXULQDU\VWRQHVLQ
SDWLHQWV 91&GHPRQVWUDWHGXUROLWKVLQSDWLHQWV 7KHWZR
PLVVHGVWRQHV PP ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S VPDOOHUWKDQWKHGHWHFWHG
RQHV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ZHUHDQG
RQDSHUXUROLWKDQGDQGRQDSHUSDWLHQWEDVLVUHVSHFWLYHO\7KH
HIIHFWLYHGRVHRIGXDOHQHUJ\VSOLWEROXV&7ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S ORZHUWKDQ
WKDWRIVWDQGDUGELSKDVLFSURWRFRO
&RQFOXVLRQ6SOLWEROXVGXDOHQHUJ\&7DOORZVIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIXULQDU\VWRQHV
QHSKURJUDSKLF DQG H[FUHWRU\ SKDVHV LQ D VLQJOH DFTXLVLWLRQ WKXV LW IDFLOLWDWHV
FRPSUHKHQVLYH&7HYDOXDWLRQRIXULQDU\VWRQHGLVHDVHDWDFRQVLGHUDEO\UHGXFHG
UDGLDWLRQGRVH
%
&DQYLUWXDOQRQFRQWUDVWLPDJHVRIGXDOHQHUJ\&7UHSODFHWUXHQRQ
FRQWUDVWLPDJHVLQHYDOXDWLRQRIUHQDOSDWKRORJLHV
+67HK616KLNKDUH0,2WKPDQ..<HRZ6LQJDSRUH6*
F\EHUB[UD\#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIÀFDF\RIWKHYLUWXDOQRQFRQWUDVW&7 91& LQHYDOXDW
LQJWKHUHQDOOHVLRQVFRPSDUHGWRWUXHQRQFRQWUDVW&7 71& DQGLWVFDSDELOLW\WR
UHGXFHWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWWULSOHEROXV&7XURJUDSK\XVLQJ
'(&7VFDQQHU91&LPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJFRPPHUFLDOGXDOHQHUJ\VRIWZDUH
7ZRUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DQGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGUDWHGDQGFRPSDUHG91&
LPDJHVZLWK71&FRQWUROLPDJHVXVLQJPHDQ+8YDOXHVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615
LPDJHTXDOLW\OHVLRQGHWHFWDELOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHVDVSDUDPHWHUV6WDWLVWLFDO
DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV2IWKHFDVHVVWXGLHGZHUHQRUPDOVLPSOHF\VWV UHQDOFDU
FLQRPD FRPSOLFDWHGF\VWV DQGUHQDOFDOFXOL 7KHPHDQ+8YDOXHVDQG
615RIWKHVHOHVLRQVZHUHFRPSDUDEOHLQ91&LPDJHVDQGFRUUHVSRQGLQJ71&
LPDJHV7KHLPDJHTXDOLW\RI91&LPDJHVZDVFRPSDUDEOHDQGGLDJQRVWLF91&
LPDJHVZHUHHTXDOO\HIÀFLHQWDV71&LPDJHVLQGHWHFWLQJVROLGIRFDOOHVLRQVDQG
F\VWV+RZHYHURI FDOFXOLZHUHGHWHFWHGXVLQJ91&LPDJHVZKHUHDV
DOOZHUHYLVXDOLVHGRQ71&LPDJHV:LWKWKLVQHZWHFKQLTXHFDOFXODWHGUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHZDVP*\YVP*\UHFHLYHGXVLQJFRQYHQWLRQDOWHFKQLTXH
&RQFOXVLRQ 2EWDLQLQJ 91& LPDJHV RI WKH NLGQH\V DQG WKH XULQDU\ WUDFW XVLQJ
'(&7VRIWZDUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHVHIIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHZLWKRXWFRPSURPLVLQJ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
615LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGOHVLRQGHWHFWDELOLW\7KLVFDQSRWHQWLDOO\REYLDWHWKHQHHG
WRREWDLQ71&LPDJHVLQ&7XURJUDSK\
%
7ULSOHEROXVWHFKQLTXHZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\0'&7DQHZSHUVSHFWLYHLQ
&7XURJUDSK\
+67HK616KLNKDUH33/6HH..<HRZ6LQJDSRUH6*
F\EHUB[UD\#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHDQGFRPSDUHUHQDOYDVFXODUDQGXULQDU\WUDFW
YLVXDOLVDWLRQDVZHOODVUDGLDWLRQGRVHHIÀFLHQF\IROORZLQJWULSOHEROXVLQMHFWLRQVLQ
DVLQJOHDFTXLVLWLRQZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOWULSKDVLF&7XURJUDSK\WHFKQLTXH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW WULSOH EROXV &7 XURJUDSK\ XV
LQJGXDOVRXUFH&7VFDQQHU7KHSURWRFROIROORZHGZDVP/RILYFRQWUDVWDW
P/VHFDWDQGVHFRQGVDQGP/DWP/VHFDWVHFRQGVZLWKWRWDO
VFDQQLQJWLPHRIVHFRQGV9LUWXDOQRQHQKDQFHGLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJ
FRPPHUFLDOGXDOHQHUJ\VRIWZDUH7ZRUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DQGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
UHYLHZHGDQGUDWHGWKHLPDJHVIRUFRQWUDVWRSDFLÀFDWLRQRIWKHUHQDOSDUHQFK\PD
YDVFXODWXUHDQGXULQDU\WUDFWGLVWHQVLRQDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOWULSKDVLF
&7XURJUDSK\ F&78 LPDJHV
5HVXOWV&RPSOHWHRSDFLÀFDWLRQRIWKHLQWUDUHQDOFROOHFWLQJV\VWHPDQGSUR[LPDO
XUHWHUZDVDFKLHYHGLQRIVHJPHQWVUHVSHFWLYHO\ F&78DQG 7KH
GLVWDOXUHWHUDQGEODGGHUZDVQRWRSDFLÀHGLQDQGRIFDVHVUHVSHFWLYHO\
F&78DQGS! ,PDJHTXDOLW\RIUHQDOSDUHQFK\PDOHQKDQFHPHQW
ZDVH[FHOOHQWLQFDVHV FRQYHQWLRQDO&78S! 9DVFXODULPDJH
TXDOLW\ZDVH[FHOOHQWLQRIFDVHV F&78S! :LWKWKLVQHZVWXG\
FDOFXODWHGUDGLDWLRQGRVHZDVP*\PXFKOHVVWKDQWKHFRQYHQWLRQDOWULSKDVLF
&7XURJUDSK\ P*\
&RQFOXVLRQ7ULSOHEROXV&7XURJUDSK\WHFKQLTXHXVLQJGXDOHQHUJ\&7LVDGRVH
HIÀFLHQWSURWRFROSHUPLWWLQJFRPSUHKHQVLYHVWXG\RIWKHXULQDU\V\VWHPLQDVLQJOH
DFTXLVLWLRQDQGFDQEHSRWHQWLDOO\XVHGDVVWDQGDUGSURWRFROIRU&7XURJUDSK\
%
7KHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIPXOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
ZLWKPXOWLSODQDUUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJLQJDQGYLUWXDOF\VWRVFRS\LQWKH
HDUO\GHWHFWLRQDQGHYDOXDWLRQRIEODGGHUFDUFLQRPD
0)$PLQ$$$EG(O.DI\(OPLQ\D(* 0RKDPPHGBDPLQ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ RI PXOWLGHWHFWRU FRPSXWHG WR
PRJUDSK\ZLWKPXOWLSODQDUUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJLQJDQGYLUWXDOF\VWRVFRS\LQHDUO\
GHWHFWLRQ DQG HYDOXDWLRQ RIEODGGHU PDVVHVZLWK FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK FRQYHQWLRQDO
F\VWRVFRSLFÀQGLQJV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFOXGHGWKLUW\ÀYHSDWLHQWVZLWK
VXVSHFWHGEODGGHUFDQFHUZHUHVWXGLHGE\ FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSKLFF\VWRJUDSK\
&7& DQGYLUWXDOF\VWRJUDSK\ 9& LQERWKWKHVXSLQHDQGSURQHSRVLWLRQVDIWHU
GLVWHQGLQJWKHEODGGHUZLWKDLU7KHSDWLHQWSRSXODWLRQZDVGLYLGHGLQWRWKUHHJURXSV
EDVHGRQOHVLRQVL]HDWFRQYHQWLRQDOF\VWRVFRS\5HVXOWVRIWKH&7VWXG\ZHUH
FRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHRIFRQYHQWLRQDOF\VWRVFRS\ && 0DLQRXWFRPHPHDVXUHV
VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHZDVXVHGWRVWXG\WKH
DVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQ9&DQG&&DVUHJDUGLQJOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHVL]HRIWKHWXPRXUVYDULHGIURPPPWRRFFXS\LQJPRUHWKDQWKUHH
TXDUWHUVRIWKHEODGGHU2IWKHOHVLRQVGHWHFWHGRQ&&OHVLRQVZHUHSRVLWLYH
LQKLVWRSDWKRORJ\ZHUHPPZHUHGHWHFWHGE\9&DQGRIPP7KH
ORFDWLRQVRIDOOZHUHFRUUHFWO\GHVFULEHGDW9&ZKHQFRPSDUHGZLWK&&7KHRYHUDOO
VHQVLWLYLW\RI9&YHUVXV&&ZDVVSHFLÀFLW\339ZDVDQG
139ZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ&\VWRVFRS\UHPDLQVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFHIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI
WKHXULQDU\EODGGHUEXW0'&7LVLQGLFDWHGIRUH[DPLQDWLRQRISDWLHQWVRQZKRP
FRQYHQWLRQDOF\VWRVFRS\LVFRQWUDLQGLFDWHGGLIÀFXOWWRSHUIRUPXQVDWLVIDFWRU\LQ
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQDQGDVDQDGMXYDQWWRROLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIDUHDVGLIÀFXOWWRDVVHVV
ZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOF\VWRVFRS\
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIGLDJQRVWLFVWUDWHJLHVIRUGLDJQRVLQJEODGGHUFDQFHU
XVLQJ&7XURJUDSK\ÁH[LEOHF\VWRVFRS\DQGYRLGHGXULQHF\WRORJ\
UHVXOWVIRUSDWLHQWV
-06WHGPDQ&*7%OLFN6$1D]LU60DOOHWW%:7XUQH\
112QZX,6'5REHUWV-3&UHZ1&&RZDQ2[IRUG8.
MRQDWKDQVWHGPDQ#GRFWRUVRUJXN
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHGLDJQRVWLFVWUDWHJLHVIRUGLDJQRVLQJEODGGHUFDQFHU %&D
XVLQJ&7XURJUDSK\ &78 DVDGGLWLRQDOUHSODFHPHQWRUWULDJHWHVWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP)
%UHDVW
66D
1HZWHFKQRORJLHV
0RGHUDWRUV
33DQL]]D0LODQ,7
(6]DEy6]HJHG+8
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGVSHFWUDOPDPPRJUDSK\YHUVXV05,LQWXPRXU
VL]HDVVHVVPHQWLQLWLDOUHVXOWV
(0)DOOHQEHUJ0.URKQ-)RHUVWHU+:LHEH-06LQJK)'LHNPDQQ
8%LFN%HUOLQ'( HYDIDOOHQEHUJ#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGVSHFWUDOPDPPRJUDSK\ &(60 WRPDP
PRJUDSK\ 0; DQG05,LQGHWHFWLRQDQGVL]HHVWLPDWLRQRIKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ
EUHDVWFDQFHUVXVLQJSRVWRSHUDWLYHKLVWRORJ\DVJROGVWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\KHDOWKDXWKRULWLHVDQGLQVWL
WXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDQGDOOSDWLHQWVHQUROOHGSURYLGHGZULWWHQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQW
$OOH[DPLQDWLRQVDQGÀQDOKLVWRORJLFDOUHVXOWVZHUHDYDLODEOHIRUSDWLHQWV&(60
H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHELODWHUDOFUDQLRFDXGDODQGPHGLRODWHUDOYLHZVZLWKH[SRVXUHV
VWDUWLQJPLQXWHVDIWHU,9LQMHFWLRQRIPOLRGLQDWHGFRQWUDVWDJHQWSHUNJRI
ERG\ZHLJKWZLWKDÁRZRIPOVHF05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJD7V\VWHPDQGD
GHGLFDWHGFKDQQHOEUHDVWFRLO'\QDPLF'7ZHLJKWHGJUDGLHQWHFKRVHTXHQFHV
ZHUHDFTXLUHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHULQMHFWLRQRIPPRONJ%:JDGROLQLXPFRQWUDVW
DJHQW05,0;DQG&(60LPDJHVZHUHUHDGE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWUDGLRORJLVWV
5HVXOWV7KHWXPRXUZDVYLVLEOHLQ0;&(60DQG05,H[DPLQDWLRQV
:KHQ YLVLEOH WKH DYHUDJH OHVLRQ VL]H ODUJHVW GLPHQVLRQ ZDV PP 6'
LQ0;PP 6' LQ&(60DQGPP 6' LQ05,YHUVXV
PP 6' IURP SRVWRSHUDWLYH KLVWRORJ\ %UHDVW GHQVLW\ FODVVHV ZHUH
$&5 $&5 $&5 $&5 'LIIHUHQFH LQ OHVLRQ VL]H PHDVXUHPHQWV
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWEHWZHHQ&(60DQG0; S DQGQRWVLJQLÀFDQWEHWZHHQ
&(60DQG05, S
&RQFOXVLRQ&(60VKRZHGDEHWWHUOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQDQGVL]HHVWLPDWLRQFRP
SDUHG WR PDPPRJUDSK\ ,QLWLDO UHVXOWV VKRZHG QR GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ &(60
DQG05,LQWXPRXUGHWHFWLRQDQGVL]HDVVHVVPHQWERWKLQJRRGFRUUHODWLRQZLWK
SRVWRSHUDWLYHKLVWRORJ\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
'LIIHUHQWLDOSKDVHFRQWUDVWPDPPRJUDSK\DQHZWRROIRUEUHDVWLPDJLQJ
06WDPSDQRQL=:DQJ&'DYLG(5RHVVO07ULSSHO*6LQJHU
5$.XELN+XFK0.+RKO1+DXVHU9LOOLJHQ&++DPEXUJ'(
%DGHQ&+ PDUFRVWDPSDQRQL#SVLFK
3XUSRVH3KDVHFRQWUDVWDQGVFDWWHULQJEDVHG[UD\LPDJLQJDUHNQRZQWRSURYLGH
DGGLWLRQDODQGFRPSOHPHQWDU\LQIRUPDWLRQWRFRQYHQWLRQDODEVRUSWLRQEDVHGPHWK
RGV:HUHSRUWRQWKHÀUVWPDPPRJUDSKLFLQYHVWLJDWLRQRIQDWLYHWKDWLVIUHVKO\
GLVVHFWHGEUHDVWVFDUULHGRXWZLWKDJUDWLQJLQWHUIHURPHWHUDQGDFRQYHQWLRQDO[UD\
WXEHVRXUFH)RXUSDWLHQWVLQWKLVVWXG\KDGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHQLQYDVLYH
EUHDVWFDQFHU2QHPDOHSDWLHQWZLWKRXWWKHSUHVHQFHRIDQ\PDOLJQDQWIRUPDWLRQV
ZLWKLQWKHUHVHFWHGEUHDVWZDVLQFOXGHGDVDFRQWUROVSHFLPHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HXVHGD7DOERW/DXLQWHUIHURPHWHULQVWDOOHGRQDORZ
EULOOLDQFH[UD\VRXUFHWKHLQWHUIHURPHWHUZDVRSHUDWHGDWWKHÀIWK7DOERWGLVWDQFH
WXEHYROWDJHRIN9SZLWKPHDQHQHUJ\RINH9DQGFXUUHQWRIP$7KHGHYLFH
VLPXOWDQHRXVO\UHFRUGHGDEVRUSWLRQGLIIHUHQWLDOSKDVHDQGVPDOODQJOHVFDWWHULQJ
7KHVHTXDQWLWLHVZHUHFRPELQHGLQWRQRYHOFRORXUDQGKLJKIUHTXHQF\HQKDQFHG
UDGLRJUDSKLF LPDJHV 3UHVXUJLFDO LPDJHV FRQYHQWLRQDO PDPPRJUDSK\ XOWUD
VRQRJUDSK\DQG05, VXSSRUWHGWKHÀQGLQJVDQGFOLQLFDOUHOHYDQFHZDVYHULÀHG
5HVXOWV2XUDSSURDFK\LHOGVFRPSOHPHQWDU\DQGRWKHUZLVHLQDFFHVVLEOHLQIRUPD
WLRQRQHOHFWURQGHQVLW\GLVWULEXWLRQDQGVPDOODQJOHVFDWWHULQJSRZHURIWKHVDPSOH
DWPLFURVFRSLFVFDOH7KLVLQIRUPDWLRQFDQEHXVHGWRDQVZHUFOLQLFDOO\UHOHYDQW
\HWXQUHVROYHGTXHVWLRQVVXFKDVXQHTXLYRFDOO\GLVFHUQLQJEHWZHHQPDOLJQDQW
SUHPDOLJQDQWFKDQJHVDQGSRVWRSHUDWLYHVFDUVDQGGLVWLQJXLVKLQJFDQFHULQYDGHG
UHJLRQVZLWKLQKHDOWK\WLVVXH
&RQFOXVLRQ :H SUHVHQW WKH ÀUVW H[ YLYR LPDJHV RI IUHVK QDWLYH EUHDVW WLVVXH
REWDLQHGIURPPDVWHFWRP\VSHFLPHQVXVLQJJUDWLQJLQWHUIHURPHWU\7KLVWHFKQLTXH
\LHOGVLPSURYHGGLDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLWLHVZKHQFRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOPDP
PRJUDSK\HVSHFLDOO\ZKHQGLVFHUQLQJWKHW\SHRIPDOLJQDQWFRQYHUVLRQVDQGWKHLU
EUHDGWKZLWKLQQRUPDOEUHDVWWLVVXH
%
3LORWVWXG\IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIVLPXODWHGOHVLRQVDWD'UHVS'
GLJLWDOIXOOÀHOGGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\V\VWHPZLWKDQHZGHYHORSHG
KLJKUHVROXWLRQGHWHFWRURQWKHEDVHRIWZRVKLIWVRID6H
56FKXO]:HQGWODQG00HLHU0HLWLQJHU0+HLQ]%$GDPLHW]08GHU
66FKZDE(UODQJHQ'( UXHGLJHUVFKXO]ZHQGWODQG#XNHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH ([SHULPHQWDO VWXG\ DW D QHZ V\VWHP IRU GLJLWDO ' UHVS ' IXOOÀHOG
PDPPRJUDSK\ZLWKDKLJKUHVROXWLRQGHWHFWRURQWKHEDVHRIWZRVKLIWVRID6H
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHDFTXLUHGDWDQHZ))'0V\VWHP
$PXOHW )XML)LOP-DSDQ D6HGHWHFWRU UHFHSWRU[FPSL[HOVL]HP
PHPRU\ GHSWK ELW VSDWLDO UHVROXWLRQ OSPP '4( ! ,QWHJUDWHG LQ
WKHGHWHFWRUWKHUHLVDQHZPHWKRGIRUGDWDWUDQVIHUEDVHGRQWKHRSWLFDOVZLWFK
WHFKQRORJ\7KHREMHFWRILQYHVWLJDWLRQZDVWKH:LVFRQVLQPDPPRJUDSKLFUDQGRP
SKDQWRPPRGHO$XVLQJWKHVDPHSDUDPHWHUVDQGH[SRVXUHGDWD 7XQJVWHQ
P$VN9 :HDFTXLUHGGLIIHUHQWLPDJHVLQFFDQGREOLTXHSODQH '
UHVSLQFFDQGFFSODQHZLWKDQDQJOHRIGHJUHH ' )LYHLQPDPPRJUDSK\
H[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVUHDGWKHLPDJHV 0RQLWRU UDQGRPO\HQFRGHG UDQGRP
JHQHUDWRU ZLWKUHJDUGWRUHFRJQLVDELOLW\RIGHWDLOVOLNHVSHFNVRIDOXPLQLXPR[LGH
WRPLFURPHWHUV ÀEUHVRIQ\ORQ WRPP DQGURXQGOHVLRQVPDVVHV
GLDPHWHUVWRPP IRUGHFLVLRQDQGFRPSDUHGWKHVHUHVXOWV
5HVXOWVULJKWSRVLWLYHGHFLVLRQVZHUHSRVVLEOHWRGHWHFWZHIRXQGIRU'DQG
'LQHDFKFDVH ULJKWSRVLWLYHUHVXOWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVRIWKLVSKDQWRPVWXG\GHPRQVWUDWHIRU'DVZHOODV'
IXOOÀHOGGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\WKHVDPHGHWHFWLRQUDWH7KLVPXVWEHSURYHQLQ
IXUWKHUFOLQLFDOWULDOV
%
'LJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\ZLWKDQHZQHHGOHEDVHGGHWHFWRUV\VWHP
FOLQLFDOUHVXOWVDIWHUDRQH\HDUWULDO
&3:DOOQHU0+LWWLQJHU0.RHUQHU8/LQVHQPDLHU05HLVHU
0XQLFK'( FZDOOQHU#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\RIGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\ZLWKDQHZ
QHHGOHEDVHGGHWHFWRUV\VWHPZLWKUHVSHFWWRDGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HFRPSDUHGPDPPRJUDSKLHVZLWKVWDQGDUGGRVH
Q DQG GRVH UHGXFWLRQ Q SHUIRUPHG RQ D *( 6HQRJUDSKH '05
UXQQLQJWKHQHZ$JID';0QHHGOHEDVHGLPDJLQJSODWHV\VWHP 1,3 WRWKHLUFRU
UHVSRQGLQJSUHOLPLQDU\H[DPLQDWLRQV PHDQLQWHUYDO\ ZKLFKZHUHDFTXLUHG
RQWKHVDPH*(PDPPRJUDSK\V\VWHPZLWKWKH$JID&5;VWDQGDUGVWRUDJH
SKRVSKRULPDJLQJSODWHV\VWHP 3,3 )RUGRVHUHGXFWLRQWKHDXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KH FOLQLFDO FRKRUW ZDV D FRQVHFXWLYH VHULHV RI
SDWLHQWVUHIHUUHGWRDKDHPDWXULDFOLQLFZLWKYLVLEOHKDHPDWXULDDJHRYHU\HDUV
ZLWK XULQDU\ WUDFW LQIHFWLRQ H[FOXGHG$OO SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW &78 DQG ÁH[LEOH
F\VWRVFRS\ )& VFRUHG XVLQJ SRLQW V\VWHPV DQG XULQH PLFURVFRS\ 5HIHU
HQFHVWDQGDUGFRQVLVWHGRIUHYLHZRILPDJLQJKLVWRSDWKRORJ\DQGPHGLFDOQRWHV
)ROORZXSZDVPRQWKV
5HVXOWV7KHSUHYDOHQFHRI%&DLQWKHFRKRUW Q )RU&78DVDQ
ҊDGGLWLRQDOWHVWҋWR)&VHQVLWLYLW\ 6H &, VSHFLÀFLW\ 6S
&, SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339 &, DQG
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 &, )RU&78DVDҊUHSODFHPHQW
WHVWҋIRU)&6H &, 6S &, 339
&, DQG139 &, )RU)&IRUGLDJQRVLQJ%&D
6H &, 6S &, 339 &,
DQG 139 &, )RU &78 DQG )& DV D ҊWULDJHWHVWҋ IRU
ULJLG F\VWRVFRS\ 5& DQG IROORZXS QRUPDO DQG HTXLYRFDOVFRUHV UHIHUUHG IRU
)& RSWLRQ 6H &, 6S &, 339
&, 139 &, )RU&78DQG)&DVDҊWULDJHWHVWҋ
IRU 5& DQG IROORZXS QRUPDOVFRUH UHIHUUHG IRU IROORZXS RSWLRQ 6H
&, 6S &, 339 &,
139 &,
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHRSWLPXPҊGLDJQRVWLFVWUDWHJ\ҋIRUGLDJQRVLQJ%&DXVHV&78DQG
)&DVDҊWULDJHWHVWҋIRU5&DQGIROORZXS RSWLRQ 3DWLHQWVZLWKSRVLWLYH&78
VFRUHVIRU%&DJRGLUHFWIRU5&DQGQRUPDODQGHTXLYRFDOVFRUHVXQGHUJR)&
'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LVWKHVDPHDVWKHDGGLWLRQDOWHVWVWUDWHJ\ZLWKWKHDGYDQWDJH
RIDUHGXFWLRQRIWKHQXPEHURI)&VSHUIRUPHG
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
FRQWURO $(& VHWWLQJVZHUHPRGLÀHGGRVLPHWU\SURYHGDGRVHUHGXFWLRQRI
$FFRUGLQJWRWKH$&5%UHDVW,PDJLQJ5HSRUWLQJDQG'DWD6\VWHP %,5$'6 WKH
PDPPRJUDPVZHUHFDWHJRU\EUHDVWWLVVXHGHQVLW\ZDV$&5OHYHO7KH
PDPPRJUDPVZHUHUHDGWZLFHE\H[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVZLWKDSRLQWVFRUH
RQ GLDJQRVWLF LPDJH TXDOLW\ DQG WKH YLVXDOLVDWLRQ RI SDUHQFK\PD FXWLV EHQLJQ
OHVLRQVDVZHOODVFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
5HVXOWV1,3FRPSDUHGWR3,3DWVWDQGDUGGRVHVKRZHGDEHWWHURYHUDOOLPDJH
TXDOLW\DW$&5ZKLFKZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUDW$&5 S $W$&5
LPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVVLPLODUZLWKVWDQGDUGDQGUHGXFHGGRVHRQ1,3DQG3,3:LWK
GRVHUHGXFWLRQZHIRXQGQRVLJQLÀFDQWORVVRILPDJHTXDOLW\ZLWKLQWKH1,3
H[DPLQDWLRQV 7KH UHDGLQJ VKRZHG D JRRG LQWUD DQG LQWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW
U
&RQFOXVLRQ:LWKWKHQHZQHHGOHEDVHGLPDJLQJSODWH 1,3 WHFKQRORJ\LQGLJLWDO
PDPPRJUDSK\GRVHUHGXFWLRQRILVSRVVLEOHZLWKRXWORVVRIGLDJQRVWLFLP
DJHTXDOLW\
%
0DPPRJUDSKLFWH[WXUHUHVHPEODQFHJHQHUDOLVHVDVDQLQGHSHQGHQW
ULVNIDFWRURIEUHDVWFDQFHU
.&KHUQRII6&KULVWRSKHU*.DUHPRUH1.DUVVHPHLMHU&9DFKRQ
01LHOVHQ&RSHQKDJHQ'.5RFKHVWHU01861LMPHJHQ1/
3XUSRVH%UHDVWGHQVLW\LVDQHVWDEOLVKHGULVNIDFWRURIEUHDVWFDQFHU0DPPR
JUDSKLFWH[WXUHUHVHPEODQFH 075 ZDVVKRZQWREHDGHQVLW\LQGHSHQGHQWULVN
IDFWRUEXWRQO\RQDVLQJOHVWXG\:HVKRZWKDW075JHQHUDOLVHVDFURVVGLIIHUHQW
FRKRUWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV075ZDVFRPSXWHGIURPGLJLWDOLVHGPDPPRJUDPVRID
\HDUSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ 6'XWFKVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPFDQFHUVPDWFKHG
FRQWUROVFDQFHUVZHUHDVFHUWDLQHG\HDUVSULRUWRGLDJQRVLV DQGIURPDQ
LQGHSHQGHQWFRKRUWVWXG\ 60D\R0DPPRJUDSK\+HDOWK6WXG\FRKRUW
FDQFHUDJHPDWFKHGFRQWUROV 0DPPRJUDSKLFSHUFHQWDJHGHQVLW\ 3' DQGRWKHU
PDMRUULVNIDFWRUVZHUHDVFHUWDLQHGLQ6)LQDOO\6ZDV075VFRUHGEDVHGRQ
WH[WXUHVIURP6DQG6LQDOHDYHWZRRXWIDVKLRQ6FRUHVRQ6ZHUHUHODWHGWR
IXWXUHEUHDVWFDQFHULQFLGHQFHE\DQDO\VLQJ$8&DQGTXDUWLOHVDGMXVWHGIRU%0,
PHQRSDXVHVWDWXVDQGSRVWPHQRSDXVDOKRUPRQH 30+ XVH
5HVXOWV075VFRUHVRQ6VKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWFDSDELOLW\WRVHSDUDWHFDQFHUV
IURPFRQWUROV $8& S $JHRI6DQG6ZDVDQG
\HDUVUHVSHFWLYHO\'LIIHUHQFHVLQ%0,PHQRSDXVHVWDWXVDQG30+
EHWZHHQFDVHVDQGPDWFKHGFRQWUROVLQ6ZHUHLQVLJQLÀFDQW6VKRZHGDQ$8&
RIDQGEDVHGRQSHUFHQWDJHGHQVLW\075VFRUHVWUDLQHGRQ6
DQG6UHVSHFWLYHO\$GMXVWHGIRU3'075VFRUHVRI6WUDLQHGRQ6VKRZHG25
LQTXDUWLOHVRIUHI UHVSHFWLYHO\
DQGDFRPELQHG$8&RI
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHKHWHURJHQHLWLHVWKDWFKDUDFWHULVHGEUHDVWFDQFHUULVNLQ6ZHUH
DOVRGHQVLW\LQGHSHQGHQWULVNIDFWRUVLQ6+HQFHWKH075SUHGLFWHGULVNSHUVLVWHG
XQGHUGLIIHUHQFHVLQ[UD\WHFKQRORJ\SRSXODWLRQGHPRJUDSKLFVDQGJHRJUDSK\
%
7RPRV\QWKHVLVHODVWRJUDSK\HYDOXDWLRQRIDQRYHOHODVWRJUDSK\
WHFKQLTXHRQVLPXODWHGWXPRXUVLQEUHDVWPLPLFNLQJSKDQWRPV
)(QJHONHQ,6DFN'.ODWW7)LVFKHU()DOOHQEHUJ)'LHNPDQQ
%HUOLQ'( ÁRULDQHQJHONHQ#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUPHDVXUHPHQWRIVWUDLQXQGHUVWDWLFFRPSUHVVLRQLQ
WRPRV\QWKHVLVRIEUHDVWPLPLFNLQJSKDQWRPVFDQEHXVHGWRGLVWLQJXLVKWXPRXU
VLPXODWLQJLQFOXVLRQVRIGLIIHUHQWHODVWLFLWLHV7RFRPSDUHWKHUHVXOWVRIWKLVWHFKQLTXH
WRXOWUDVRXQGHODVWRJUDSK\DVZHOODVYDOXHVSUHGLFWHGE\UKHRPHWULFDQDO\VLV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H SUHSDUHG WKUHH VRIW EUHDVWPLPLFNLQJ SKDQWRPV
FRQWDLQLQJVLPXODWHGWXPRXUVRIGLIIHUHQWHODVWLFLWLHVYDU\LQJZLWKLQDUDQJHW\SLFDO
IRUEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV7KHSKDQWRPVZHUHLPDJHGXVLQJDZLGHDQJOH
WRPRV\QWKHVLVV\VWHPZLWKFRPSUHVVLRQVHWWLQJVUDQJLQJIURP11LQVWHSV
RI16WUDLQRIWKHLQFOXVLRQVZDVPHDVXUHGLQWZRSODQHV8OWUDVRXQGHODVWRJ
UDSK\RIWKHLQFOXVLRQVZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJWZRGLIIHUHQWXOWUDVRXQGHODVWRJUDSK\
DOJRULWKPV ,Q D VHSDUDWH H[SHULPHQW WKH HODVWLFLW\ RI WKH SKDQWRP PDWUL[ DQG
LQFOXVLRQPDWHULDOZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\UKHRPHWU\
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQVWUDLQUDWLRVREWDLQHGIRUWKHVRIWLQWHUPHGLDWHDQGÀUPLQFOX
VLRQVZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\IRUWRPRV\QWKHVLV
HODVWRJUDSK\DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\IRUXOWUDVRXQGWLVVXHVWUDLQLPDJ
LQJDQGDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\IRUXOWUDVRXQGUHDOWLPHHODVWRJUDSK\
7KH VWUDLQ UDWLRV SUHGLFWHG E\ UKHRPHWU\ ZHUH DQG IRU WKH VRIW
LQWHUPHGLDWHDQGÀUPLQFOXVLRQVUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ7RPRV\QWKHVLV HODVWRJUDSK\ LV D QRYHO HODVWRJUDSK\ PHWKRG WKDW
DOORZV GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ RI WXPRXUVLPXODWLQJ LQFOXVLRQV LQ EUHDVWPLPLFNLQJ SKDQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
WRPVE\HODVWLFLW\7KHUHVXOWVDUHVLPLODUWRXOWUDVRXQGHODVWRJUDSK\DQGWRWKH
JROGVWDQGDUGUKHRPHWU\7KLVWHFKQLTXHPD\LQIXWXUHEHXVHIXOIRUDVVHVVLQJ
HODVWLFLW\RIEUHDVWOHVLRQV,QLWLDOUHVXOWVIURPFOLQLFDOH[SHULPHQWVDSSHDUSURPLV
LQJH[DPSOHVZLOOEHVKRZQ
%
)XQFWLRQDOLQIUDUHGLPDJLQJRIWKHEUHDVWDXWRPDWLFEUHDVWFDQFHU
GHWHFWLRQXVLQJPXOWLSDUDPHWULFFRPSXWHUDQDO\VLV
06NODLU/HY\76HOOD0&RKHQ05RVLQ7$OOZHLV
06KDSLUR(/LEVRQ',]KDN\5DPDW*DQ,/-HUXVDOHP,/
3HWDFK7LTYD,/7HO$YLY,/5HKRYRW,/.IDU6DYD,/$LU3RUW&LW\,/
0LUL6NODLU/HY\#VKHEDKHDOWKJRYLO
3XUSRVH$QRYHOSURWRW\SHV\VWHPSHUIRUPLQJIXQFWLRQDOWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDO '
LQIUDUHGLPDJLQJ 587+ FRXSOHGZLWKPXOWLSDUDPHWULFFRPSXWHUDQDO\VLV 0,5$
ZDVHYDOXDWHGIRUQRQLQYDVLYHGHWHFWLRQRIEUHDVWFDQFHU7KHWHFKQLTXHXWLOL]HV
QRQLRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQDQGDXWRPDWLFDOO\SURYLGHVULVNDVVHVVPHQWEDVHGRQSD
UDPHWHUVGHULYHGIURPDFOLQLFDOO\NQRZQWUDLQLQJVHW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)ROORZLQJ,5%DSSURYDODSURVSHFWLYHPXOWLFHQWUHWZR
DUPHGEOLQGHGVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQZRPHQZKLFKLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWV
ZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQEUHDVWFDQFHUDQGZRPHQZLWKDQRUPDO %,5$'6
PDPPRJUDP 587+ LPDJLQJ 5HDO ,PDJLQJ /WG ,VUDHO ZDV DFTXLUHG RQ D
FRQWLQXRXVWHPSRUDOWLPHOLQHIRUPLQXWHDW+]$FTXLUHGGDWDZHUHDQDO\VHG
XVLQJPXOWLSOHFRPSXWHGDOJRULWKPV 0,5$ ZKLFKZHUHFRPELQHGWRGHYHORSD
PDVWHUDOJRULWKPIRUULVNDVVHVVPHQWRIEUHDVWFDQFHU$QDO\VLVZDVEOLQGHGWR
WKHSDWKRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLVDQGPDPPRJUDSK\3HUIRUPDQFHZDVHYDOXDWHGXVLQJ
52&DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV)LIW\HLJKWRIFDQFHUV ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGXVLQJWKLVWHFKQRORJ\
7KHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI587+LPDJHUFRXSOHGZLWK0,5$IRUGHWHFWLQJ
EUHDVWFDQFHUZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\52&$8&ZDV'HWHFWHG
WXPRXUVUDQJHGPPPP PHDQPP LQVL]H
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVSUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\VKRZVKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIWKH
QRYHOWHFKQRORJ\H[DPLQHGIRUGHWHFWLQJEUHDVWFDQFHU3HUIRUPDQFHZDVEHWWHU
WKDQWKHSXEOLVKHGVHQVLWLYLW\RIPDPPRJUDSK\DQGFRPSDUDEOHWRWKHUHSRUWHG
SHUIRUPDQFHRIQHZDGMXQFWLYHEUHDVWLPDJLQJWHFKQRORJLHV2XUUHVXOWVZDUUDQW
IXUWKHUHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH587+LPDJHULQGHWHFWLQJDQGFKDUDFWHULVLQJEUHDVWFDQFHU
%
0ROHFXODUEUHDVWLPDJLQJ 0%, GRVHORZHUHGWRPDWFK
PDPPRJUDSK\SRWHQWLDOIRUVFUHHQLQJGHQVHEUHDVWV
-:+XJJ0.2ҋ&RQQRU&%+UXVND$/:HLQPDQQ$/&RQQHUV
'-5KRGHV)3'L)LOLSSR%(3DWW1RUWKULGJH&$86
5RFKHVWHU0186&OHYHODQG2+86 MDPHVKXJJ#JDPPDPHGLFDFRP
3XUSRVH0ROHFXODUEUHDVWLPDJLQJ 0%, XVHVVLQJOHJDPPDSKRWRQVWRYLVXDOLVH
EUHDVWWXPRXUVWKDWDUHRIWHQRFFXOWRQPDPPRJUDSK\RIUDGLRJUDSKLFDOO\GHQVH
EUHDVWV2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRUHGXFHWKH0%,GRVHDQGHYDOXDWHLWVSRWHQWLDOIRU
IXWXUHVFUHHQLQJRIZRPHQZLWKGHQVHEUHDVWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HRSWLPLVHGWKHLPDJLQJSK\VLFVIRUWKH/XPD*(0
0%,VFDQQHU *DPPD0HGLFD WKDWXVHVWZRGHWHFWRUKHDGVZLWKSL[HOODWHG&=7
JDPPDGHWHFWRUVZLWKPPVTXDUHSL[HOV:HGHVLJQHGDORZGRVHFROOLPDWRU
ZLWK WXQJVWHQ VHSWD DQG VTXDUH KROHV WKDW PDWFK WKH &=7 GHWHFWRU SL[HOV :H
GHYHORSHGZLWKDEUHDVWOHVLRQSKDQWRPWKDWIDFLOLWDWHVPHDVXUHPHQWRIFRQWUDVW
UHFRYHU\FXUYHVXVHIXOIRUFRPSDULVRQRIYDULRXV0%,V\VWHPVDQGIRUSUHGLFWLQJ
OHVLRQGHWHFWDELOLW\
5HVXOWV,QFOLQLFDOWULDOVDW0D\R&OLQLFZHKDYHGHPRQVWUDWHGORZGRVH0%,ZLWK
P7F6HVWDPLELDWDZKROHERG\GRVHHTXLYDOHQWWRVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\
:HDUHFRQGXFWLQJDFOLQLFDOWULDOWRHYDOXDWH0%,VFUHHQLQJRIDERXWZRPHQ
ZLWKGHQVHEUHDVWV0%,KDVSURYHQIDUPRUHVHQVLWLYHDQGVSHFLÀFDWGHWHFWLQJ
ELRSV\SURYHQFDQFHUVWKDQPDPPRJUDSK\LQGHQVHEUHDVWV7KHEUHDVWOHVLRQ
SKDQWRPGHPRQVWUDWHVWKDWRXUPPSL[HOVL]HLVRSWLPDOIRU0%,HQDEOLQJWKH
ORZHVWGRVHFRPSDUHGWRV\VWHPVXVLQJPPRUPPSL[HOV
&RQFOXVLRQ'RVHKDVEHHQHIIHFWLYHO\PLWLJDWHGDVDQREVWDFOHWR0%,VFUHHQLQJ
RIUDGLRJUDSKLFDOO\GHQVHEUHDVWV$QRQJRLQJFOLQLFDOWULDOVXJJHVWVWKDW0%,FRXOG
EHDYHU\HIIHFWLYHVFUHHQLQJWRROLQWKHGHQVHEUHDVWSRSXODWLRQ XSWRRI
(XURSHDQDQG$PHULFDQZRPHQPRUHWKDQRI$VLDQZRPHQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
1RQLQYDVLYHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIVPDOOEUHDVWOHVLRQVYLD'07LPDJLQJ
*=RJUDIRV'.RXORFKHUL3/LDNRX3*ULJRURSRXORV06RIUDV
6+DGMLDJDSLV90DUPDUHOLV$WKHQV*5/RV$QJHOHV&$86
PDUPDUHOLV#KRWPDLOFRP
%
)XVLRQRI86DQG)'*3(7&7LPDJHIRUHYDOXDWLRQRIORFRUHJLRQDO
UHFXUUHQFHRIEUHDVWFDQFHUXVLQJUHDOWLPHYLUWXDOVRQRJUDSK\
596 ÀUVWH[SHULHQFH
61DNDQR.)XMLL.<RUR]X\D0<RVKLGD-.RXVDND<6KLRPL
7)XNXWRPL7,VKLJXFKL2$UDL$LFKLJXQ-3 VQDNDQR#DLFKLPHGXDFMS
3XUSRVH)ÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVH )'* SRVLWURQHPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\&7 3(7
&7 LVPRUHVHQVLWLYHWKDQFRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJLQGHWHFWLQJPHWDVWDWLFRUUHFXU
UHQWGLVHDVHRIWKHEUHDVW:KHQLQFLGHQWDO)'*XSWDNHZLWKKLJKVWDQGDUGXSWDNH
YDOXH 689 LV GHWHFWHG LQ ORFRUHJLRQDO OHVLRQ E\ )'*3(7&7 VRQRJUDSKLF
FRQÀUPDWLRQQHHGVWREHGRQHLPPHGLDWHO\:HUHFHQWO\GHYHORSHGDUHDOWLPH
YLUWXDOVRQRJUDSK\ 596 V\VWHPWKDWHQDEOHVVLPXOWDQHRXVGLVSOD\RIERWKD86
DQGWKH&7LPDJHVRIWKHVDPHVLWHLQUHDOWLPHXVLQJPDJQHWLFSRVLWLRQWUDFNLQJ
V\VWHP7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRI596LQWKHVRQRJUDSKLF
ORFDOLVDWLRQRI)'*DFWLYLW\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %HWZHHQ 0DUFK DQG -XQH ZH SHUIRUPHG
)'*3(7&7IRUVXVSHFWHGUHFXUUHQWEUHDVWFDQFHULQSDWLHQWV7KHVRQRJUDSKLF
GHWHFWLRQUDWHZDVGHWHUPLQHGIRU)'*XSWDNHLQORFRUHJLRQDOUHFXUUHQFHZLWK
RUZLWKRXW596
5HVXOWV2IWKHSDWLHQWVDWRWDORI)'*XSWDNHOHVLRQVLQVHYHQSDWLHQWVZHUH
GHWHFWHGDVORFRUHJLRQDOUHFXUUHQFH7KHPHGLDQWXPRXUVL]HZDVPP UDQJH
PP 2IWKHOHVLRQV FRXOGEHLGHQWLÀHGLQWDUJHWHG86ZLWKRXW
596EXW ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGLQWDUJHWHG86ZLWK596 S 7KH596
ZDVDEOHWRFRUUHFWO\SURMHFW)'*XSWDNHLQIRUPDWLRQRQWRDERG\VXUIDFHZLWKRXW
RSHUDWRUҋVVNLOODVZHFKHFNHGVRQRJUDSK\IRUPLPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDW596FDQVRQRJUDSKLFDOO\LGHQWLI\)'*XSWDNH
OHVLRQVZLWKH[FHOOHQWDFFXUDF\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5RRP*+
%UHDVW
66E
05,FRQWUDVWPHGLDDQGFOLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
500DQQ1LMPHJHQ1/
-/5D\D3RYHGDQR&yUGRED(6
%
,QÁXHQFHRIEUHDVWSDUHQFK\PDGHQVLW\RQPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQ
GHWHFWLRQZLWKJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,FRPSDUHGWR
JDGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,PDPPRJUDSK\DQGXOWUDVRXQG
)-*LOEHUW+&YDQGHQ%RVFK$3HWULOOR.6LHJPDQQ-7+HYHUKDJHQ
6&RUFLRQH0)DLYUH3LHUUHW&0=HFKPDQQ/0DUWLQFLFK$EHUGHHQ8.
(LQGKRYHQ1/1DSOHV,77ELQJHQ'(0DUEXUJ'()HUUDUD,7/LOOH)5
+HLGHOEHUJ'(&DQGLROR,7 IMJLOEHUW#DEGQDFXN
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHLQÁXHQFHRIEUHDVWSDUHQFK\PDGHQVLW\RQPDOLJQDQW
OHVLRQGHWHFWLRQLQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,
JDGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,PDPPRJUDSK\DQGXOWUDVRXQG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QHKXQGUHGDQGHLJKWZRPHQ \HDUV WKDW
XQGHUZHQWPDPPRJUDSK\DQGZKRKDG%,5$'6ÀQGLQJVRQPDPPRJUDSK\
DQGRUXOWUDVRXQGXQGHUZHQWWZRLGHQWLFDOEUHDVW05,H[DPVLQUDQGRPLVHGRUGHU
RQHZLWKJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHDQGWKHRWKHUZLWKJDGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQH
HDFKDWDGRVHRIPPRONJ%:05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGDW7XVLQJ7ZDQG'
VSRLOHG7Z*5(VHTXHQFHVZLWKDWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQRIPLQ,PDJHVZHUH
HYDOXDWHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\E\WKUHHXQDIÀOLDWHGEOLQGHGUDGLRORJLVWVIRUFDQFHUGHWHF
WLRQ,PDJLQJÀQGLQJVZHUHPDWFKHGZLWKKLVWRORJ\GDWDE\DIRXUWKLQGHSHQGHQW
EOLQGHGUDGLRORJLVW0DOLJQDQWOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQUDWHVZHUHFRPSDUHG 0F1HPDU V
WHVW DFURVVGLIIHUHQWFDWHJRULHVRIEUHDVWWLVVXHGHQVLW\
5HVXOWVPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVZHUHFRQÀUPHGDWKLVWRORJ\LQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJR
LQJ 05, DQG PDPPRJUDSK\XOWUDVRXQG ,Q SUHGRPLQDQWO\ IDWW\ EUHDVWV
JODQGXODU HDFKUHDGHUGHWHFWHG PDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVRQJDGREHQDWH
GLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG 05, FRPSDUHG ZLWK OHVLRQV RQ
JDGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,DQG OHVLRQVRQPDP
PRJUDSK\XOWUDVRXQG ,Q KHWHURJHQHRXVO\ GHQVH DQG H[WUHPHO\ GHQVH EUHDVWV
!JODQGXODU WKHWKUHHUHDGHUVGHWHFWHG PDOLJQDQW
OHVLRQVRQJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,FRPSDUHGZLWK
OHVLRQVRQJDGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,DQG
OHVLRQVRQPDPPRJUDSK\XOWUDVRXQG*DGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG05,
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S VXSHULRUIRUPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQSDUWLFXODUO\LQ
KHWHURJHQHRXVO\GHQVHEUHDVWV
&RQFOXVLRQ*DGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHGEUHDVW05,SHUPLWVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
LPSURYHGFDQFHUQRGXOHGHWHFWLRQUHJDUGOHVVRIEUHDVWWLVVXHGHQVLW\
%
,QWUDLQGLYLGXDOUDQGRPLVHGFRPSDULVRQRIWKH05,FRQWUDVWDJHQWV
*DGRYLVWYHUVXV0XOWL+DQFHIRUSUHRSHUDWLYHEUHDVW05
LPDJLQJHYDOXDWHGLQDEOLQGHGUHDG
)3HGLFRQL5.XELN%&KLOOD&6FKZHQNH..LQNHO5RPH,7
%DGHQ&+%HUOLQ'(&KrQH%RXJHULHV&+ NDUHQNLQNHOWUXJOL#ZDQDGRRIU
3XUSRVH7RLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHPPRONJ*DGRYLVW JDGREXWURO
DQG0XOWL+DQFH JDGREHQDWH E\SURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWLQJWKHDJUHHPHQWUDWH
LQEUHDVWOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQDWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGEUHDVW05
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZREUHDVW05,VZHUHSHUIRUPHGIRUVWDJLQJLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKELRSV\SURYHQEUHDVWFDQFHUZLWKDQLQWHUYDORIKRXUVDQGGD\VEHWZHHQ
WKHH[DPLQDWLRQV0*DGRYLVWRU00XOWL+DQFHZDVDGPLQLVWHUHGLQ
DUDQGRPLVHGRUGHU/HVLRQGHWHFWLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGE\WZR
LQGHSHQGHQWEOLQGHGUHDGHUV/HVLRQWUDFNLQJFRPSDUHGWRRQVLWHUHDGLQJVDQG
WRKLVWRORJ\IURPVXUJHU\RUELRSV\ZDVSHUIRUPHGE\DWKLUGUHDGHU'LIIHUHQFHV
LQOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQIRUWKHNQRZQFDQFHUDQGIRUDOOOHVLRQVZLWKSDWKRORJ\OHVLRQ
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQDQGEDFNJURXQGHQKDQFHPHQWLQERWKEUHDVWVZHUHFRPSDUHG
EHWZHHQWKHWZRFRQWUDVWDJHQWV
5HVXOWV$PRQJOHVLRQVKDGSDWKRORJ\ PDOLJQDQWEHQLJQ 7KH
DJUHHPHQWUDWHIRUOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQE\WKHEOLQGHGUHDGHUVVKRZHGQRGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQERWKFRQWUDVWDJHQWVIRUWKHLQGH[OHVLRQ DQGDOOOHVLRQV
IRU*DGRYLVWIRU00XOWL+DQFH 6HQVLWLYLW\LQOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVD
WLRQDFURVVUHDGHUVVKRZHGQRGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ*DGRYLVW DQG
0XOWL+DQFH 7KHUHZDVQRGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQFRQWUDVWDJHQWVLQWKH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH7KH'QRQLRQLVLQJGLDJQRVWLFLPDJLQJWHFKQRORJ\RIPXOWLPRGDOWRP
RJUDSK\ 07 ZDVLQWURGXFHGLQ(&507ZDVUHFHQWO\VKRZQWRGLIIHUHQWLDWH
EUHDVWOHVLRQV GRZQWRPPLQVL]H LQ%,5$'6YROXQWHHUV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KH 07 FOLQLFDO SURWRW\SH SHUIRUPV ' WRPRJUDSKLF
VFDQ RI WKH SHQGXODQW EUHDVW LQ ZDWHUEDWK XVLQJ WUDQVPLVVLRQ XOWUDVRXQG LQ D
À[HGFRRUGLQDWHV\VWHP'HVLJQGHWDLOVZHUHSUHVHQWHGLQWKH(,%,5:RUNVKRS
RI(&507UHFRQVWUXFWVPXOWLSOHLPDJHVIRUHDFKFRURQDOVOLFHXVLQJPHDV
XUHPHQWVRIUHIUDFWLYLW\DQGIUHTXHQF\GHSHQGHQWDWWHQXDWLRQDQGGLVSHUVLRQ07
GHWHFWVDQGGLIIHUHQWLDWHVOHVLRQVXVLQJIXVLRQRIWKHVHPXOWLPRGDOLPDJHV7KLV
\HDU07UHVXOWVIURP%,5$'6IHPDOHYROXQWHHUV DJHVDYHUDJH
\HDUV ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJ\UHVXOWVIURPELRSV\RIWKHVXVSLFLRXV
OHVLRQV VL]HVPPDYHUDJHPP WDNHQE\PLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHFRUHELRSV\
)1$)LVFKHU0DPPRWRPHDQG%/(67KHK\SRWKHVLVWKDW07FDQGHWHFWDQG
FODVVLI\FRUUHFWO\PDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVGRZQWRPPLQVL]HZDVWHVWHG
5HVXOWV07GHWHFWHGDQGFRUUHFWO\FODVVLÀHGRXWRIPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV
VHQVLWLYLW\ LQWKHELRSV\VDPSOHV$PRQJWKHGHWHFWHGPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV
KDGPD[LPXPGLPHQVLRQ PP PRVWO\'&,6 7KHVPDOOHVWGHWHFWHG
PDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV '&,6 KDGPD[LPXPGLPHQVLRQRIPP7KHUHZDVRQO\RQH
IDOVHSRVLWLYH07UHVXOWLQWKHELRSVLHGOHVLRQV VSHFLÀFLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ,QLWLDOFOLQLFDOUHVXOWVFRQÀUPHGWKHDELOLW\RI07WHFKQRORJ\WRGHWHFW
DQGFODVVLI\EUHDVWOHVLRQV GRZQWRPPLQVL]H DPRQJ%,5$'6IHPDOH
YROXQWHHUVZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DVVHVVPHQWRI%,5$'VOHVLRQHQKDQFHPHQWFXUYHRUEDFNJURXQGHQKDQFHPHQW
0RUSKRORJ\DVVHVVPHQWGLIIHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWZHHQWKHUHDGHUV S DQG
ERWKFRQWUDVWDJHQWV S ZLWKPRUHQRQIRFDOHQKDQFHPHQWIRU*DGRYLVW
WKDQIRU0XOWL+DQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ%RWKFRQWUDVWPHGLDVKRZHGQRGLIIHUHQFHLQEUHDVWOHVLRQVGHWHF
WLRQDQGVHQVLWLYLW\LQOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQDWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGEUHDVW05,
%
%
3XUSRVH+LVWRSDWKRORJLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIEUHDVWWXPRXUVFKDQJHGXULQJWKHLU
FRXUVHRIJURZWK+RZHYHULQUDGLRORJLFDOSUDFWLFHOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDUHDS
SOLHGLUUHVSHFWLYHRIWXPRXUVWDJH:HDLPHGWRLGHQWLI\PRUSKRORJLFDQGG\QDPLF
SURÀOHVRIEUHDVWWXPRXUVLQFRUUHODWLRQWRWKH76WDJHDQGWRHYDOXDWHWKHLPSDFW
RQRYHUDOOGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIEUHDVW05, E05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%DVLVRIWKLVLQYHVWLJDWLRQZDVDFURVVVHFWLRQDOGDWDEDVH
RIFRQVHFXWLYHKLVWRORJLFDOO\YHULÀHGEUHDVWOHVLRQVLPDJHGE\E05, VWDQGDUGLVHG
SURWRFROVHWKLFDOERDUGDSSURYDO $OOOHVLRQVZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGE\WZR
UDGLRORJLVWLQFRQVHQVXV !E05,H[DPV XVLQJVWDQGDUGLVHGPRUSKRORJL
FDODQGG\QDPLFGHVFULSWRUV$FFRUGLQJWRWKH710V\VWHPVVL]HRIHDFKOHVLRQ
ZDVFDWHJRULVHGDV, FPQ ,, FPQ DQG,,, FPQ
6WDWLVWLFVDGGUHVVHGDFFXUDF\RILQGLYLGXDOGHVFULSWRUVLQDVVRFLDWLRQZLWKHDFKVL]H
VXEJURXS FRQWLQJHQF\WDEOHV&KLVTXDUHWHVWV 7KHQGHVFULSWRUVZHUHFRPELQHG
LQWRDPXOWLYDULDWHPRGHOWRLGHQWLI\RYHUDOODFFXUDF\RIE05,LQDVVRFLDWLRQZLWK
WKH76WDJH ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQKLVWRORJ\WDUJHWYDULDEOHEHQLJQYVPDOLJQDQW
)LQDOO\UHVXOWVEHWZHHQHDFKVXEJURXSZHUHFRPSDUHG $8&FRPSDULVRQ>DUHD
XQGHUWKHUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFVFXUYH@
5HVXOWV 0DMRULW\ RI E05, GHVFULSWRUV ZHUH DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK 76WDJH
3 UHVXOWLQJLQGLIIHUHQWDFFXUDF\RIVXFKIHDWXUHVDFFRUGLQJWRWXPRXU
VL]H7KLVFRQWULEXWHGWRWKHKLJKHUSHUIRUPDQFHRIE05,LQDGYDQFHG76WDJHV ,,
$8& ,,,$8& FRPSDUHGWRVPDOOHUWXPRXUV ,$8& 3
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU UHVXOWV VXJJHVW WKDW OHVLRQV FKDUDFWHULVWLFV LQ E05, FKDQJH
GXULQJWKHWXPRXUVFRXUVHRIJURZWK7KLVFDXVHVFKDUDFWHULVWLFPRUSKRORJLFDQG
G\QDPLFSURÀOHVLQFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKH76WDJHDQGIXUWKHULQFUHDVHVGLDJQRVWLF
DFFXUDF\RIE05,LQODUJHUOHVLRQV
'RHVSUHRSHUDWLYH05,LQEUHDVWFDQFHULQFUHDVHWKHUDWHRIPDVWHFWRP\"
$*DUFLDODOODQD*9LWHUL,6LPRQ,$QWRQ$(OL]DOGH/3LQD3DPSORQD(6
JYLWHUL#XQDYHV
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUSUHRSHUDWLYH05,LQIHPDOHSDWLHQWVGLDJQRVHGZLWK
EUHDVWFDQFHULQFUHDVHVWKHUDWHRIPDVWHFWRP\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZRVHULHVRIFRQVHFXWLYHZRPHQVXUJLFDOO\WUHDWHGIRU
EUHDVWFDQFHUZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHG*URXSSDWLHQWVZLWKSUHRSHUD
WLYH05,*URXSSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWSUHRSHUDWLYH05,3DWLHQWDJHPHQRSDXVDO
VWDWXVWXPRXUVL]HVWDJLQJVXUJLFDOWUHDWPHQWQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\DQG
UHLQWHUYHQWLRQVGXHWRDIIHFWHGPDUJLQVZHUHHYDOXDWHG6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDV
SHUIRUPHGZLWK6WXGHQWҋVWDQG&KLVTXDUHWHVWV 6366
5HVXOWV%RWKJURXSVZHUHVLPLODULQDJH DQG\HDUVS
DQGPHQRSDXVDOVWDWXV DQGZRPHQS 7KHDYHUDJHSDWKRORJLFDO
WXPRXUVL]HZDVVPDOOHULQJURXS PPYVPPS
0XOWLIRFDOPXOWLFHQWULFWXPRXUVZHUHPRUHIUHTXHQWLQJURXS YV
S %LODWHUDOWXPRXUVZHUHGLDJQRVHGRQO\LQJURXS 7KHUDWHRI
PDVWHFWRP\ZDVORZHULQJURXS YVS 2QFRSODVWLF DQG
ELODWHUDOVXUJHULHV ZHUHRQO\SHUIRUPHGLQJURXS7KHUDWHRIQHRDGMXYDQW
FKHPRWKHUDS\ZDVKLJKHULQJURXS YVS 5HLQWHUYHQWLRQVGXH
WRPDUJLQLQÀOWUDWLRQZHUHDOVRPRUHIUHTXHQWLQJURXS YVS
&RQFOXVLRQ 'HVSLWH GLDJQRVLQJ PRUH PXOWLIRFDOPXOWLFHQWULF FDVHV LQ JURXS
SUHRSHUDWLYH05, RXUVWXG\VKRZVDGHFUHDVHLQWKHUDWHRIPDVWHFWRP\ IURP
WR ZKHQRQFRSODVWLFVXUJHU\DQGQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\DUHDYDLO
DEOH+RZHYHUWKHLQFUHDVHRIWXPRUHFWRPLHVKDVOHGWRPRUHUHLQWHUYHQWLRQVGXH
WRDIIHFWHGPDUJLQV IURPWR
%
7KHUROHRISUHRSHUDWLYH05,LQEUHDVWFDQFHULVWKHPHQRSDXVDO
VWDWXVRIUHOHYDQFH"
$*DUFLD/DOODQD,6LPRQ<DU]D*9LWHUL,$QWRQ$(OL]DOGH/3LQD
3DPSORQD(6 PV\DU]D#XQDYHV
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRI05,LQWKHSUHRSHUDWLYHVHWWLQJRIEUHDVWFDQFHU
DFFRUGLQJWRWKHSUHPHQRSDXVDOYVPHQRSDXVDOVWDWXV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVEUHDVW05,H[DPVRISDWLHQWVZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHU
GLDJQRVHGE\SHUFXWDQHRXVELRSV\ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG7KH\ZHUHGL
YLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVSUHPHQRSDXVDO JURXS DQGPHQRSDXVDO JURXS
&KDQJHVLQVXUJLFDOPDQDJHPHQWLQGXFHGE\05,ÀQGLQJVVXUJLFDOWUHDWPHQW05,
VWDJLQJ VL]H ELODWHUDOLW\ PXOWLFHQWULFLW\ DQG PXOWLIRFDOLW\ IUHH WXPRUDO PDUJLQV
DQG UHTXLUHPHQW RI QHRDGMXYDQW FKHPRWKHUDS\ 1$4 ZHUH HYDOXDWHG 6WDWLVWL
FDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWK6WXGHQWҋV7DQG&KLVTXDUHWHVWV 6366
5HVXOWV,QLWLDOO\SODQQHGVXUJHU\ZDVPRGLÀHGLQRIWKHSDWLHQWVGXHWR
05,ÀQGLQJVZLWKQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQJURXSV S 7KLVDG
GLWLRQDO LQIRUPDWLRQ JLYHQ E\ 05, ZDV SURYHG WR EH PDOLJQDQW LQ RI WKH
FDVHVELODWHUDOVXUJHULHVPDVWHFWRPLHVRQFRSODVWLFVXUJHULHVDQG
WXPRUHFWRPLHV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG ZLWK PRUH PDVWHFWRPLHV FDUULHG RXW LQ *URXS
YVS 05,GHWHFWHGELODWHUDOFDQFHUV XQVXVSHFWHG
ZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOWHFKQLTXHVPXOWLFHQWULF DQGPXOWLIRFDOLW\
ZLWKQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQJURXSV S 0HDQVL]HRIWKHWXPRXUV
ZDVVLPLODULQERWKJURXSV S )UHHPDUJLQVZHUHREWDLQHGLQZLWKQR
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV S 0RUHZRPHQXQGHUZHQW1$4LQJURXS
YVS
&RQFOXVLRQ05,LVPRUHVHQVLWLYHWKDQFRQYHQWLRQDOWHFKQLTXHVIRUVWDJLQJEUHDVW
FDQFHUFKDQJLQJLQLWLDOSODQQHGWUHDWPHQWLQXSWRRQHWKLUGRIWKHSDWLHQWV%RWK
PHQRSDXVDO DQG SUHPHQRSDXVDO SDWLHQWV PD\ EHQHÀW IURP SUHRSHUDWLYH 05,
3UHPHQRSDXVDOZRPHQXQGHUJRPRUHPDVWHFWRPLHVDQG1$4
,PSDFWRI7VWDJHRQOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGRYHUDOOGLDJQRVWLF
DFFXUDF\RIEUHDVW05,GRHVVL]HUHDOO\PDWWHU"
0'LHW]HO+3%XUPHLVWHU5=RXEL7*URHVFKHO
05*DMGD,%5XQQHEDXP:$.DLVHU3$7%DOW]HU
-HQD'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
%
%UHDVW05,DQGGXFWDOFDUFLQRPDLQVLWXZKHQFDQZHH[SHFWWR
KDYHQRHQKDQFHPHQW"
6'H6WHIDQL&0ROLQDUL3&ODXVHU$'DO&RO9/RQGHUR5*LURPHWWL
&=XLDQL0%D]]RFFKL8GLQH,7 VLOYLDGHVWHIDQL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIGXFWDOFDUFLQRPDLQVLWXQRWLGHQWLÀHG
RQG\QDPLF05,H[DPLQDWLRQSHUIRUPHGIRUEUHDVWFDQFHUVWDJLQJ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZR H[SHULHQFHG EUHDVW UDGLRORJLVWV UHWURVSHFWLYHO\
HYDOXDWHGLPDJHVRISDWLHQWVZLWKGXFWDOFDUFLQRPDLQVLWX '&,6 KLVWRSDWKRORJL
FDOO\SURYHQRQVXUJLFDOVSHFLPHQZKRKDGDOVRSHUIRUPHGDG\QDPLFEUHDVW05,
LQYHVWLJDWLRQEHIRUHVXUJHU\LQPRQWKV:HGLYLGHGWKHSDWLHQWVZLWK'&,6LQWR
WZRJURXSVGHSHQGLQJRQWKHUHVXOWRIG\QDPLF05,LQYHVWLJDWLRQWKHDEVHQFHRI
VXVSLFLRXVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWLQFOXGLQJLQWKHODWHSKDVHZDVFRQVLGHUHGWR
EHDIDOVHQHJDWLYHH[DPLQDWLRQ7KHSUHVHQFHRIHQKDQFHPHQWZDVFRQVLGHUHG
SRVLWLYH)LVKHUH[DFWWHVWVZDVXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
SYDOXH
5HVXOWV 05, FRUUHFWO\ GHPRQVWUDWHG WKH SUHVHQFH RI '&,6 VHQVLELOLW\
,QSDWLHQWVQRHQKDQFHPHQWZDVLGHQWLÀHGLQWKHDUHDRIQHRSODVP
&',6VPDOOHUWKDQRUHTXDOWRPPRQPDPPRJUDSK\GLGQRWSUHVHQWHQKDQFH
PHQW GXULQJ 05, LQYHVWLJDWLRQ PRUH RIWHQ WKDQ WKRVH RYHU PP S
7KH DEVHQFH RI VXVSLFLRXV FRQWUDVW HQKDQFHPHQW DW 05, ZDV PRUH IUHTXHQWO\
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKORZRULQWHUPHGLDWHKLVWRORJLFDOJUDGHFRPSDUHGZLWKKLJKJUDGH
S 0DPPRJUDSKLFSUHVHQWDWLRQZDVQRWDVLJQLÀFDQWSUHGLFWRURIDEVHQFH
RIVXVSLFLRXVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWDWEUHDVW05,
&RQFOXVLRQ 05, GHPRQVWUDWHG KLJK VHQVLWLYLW\ LQ WKH LGHQWLÀFDWLRQ RI EUHDVW
FDQFHUHYHQZLWKRXWLQYDVLYHIHDWXUHV0DOLJQDQWOHVLRQVLQVLWXWKDWGRQRWVKRZ
HQKDQFHPHQWDUHPRUHRIWHQVPDOODQGORZJUDGH
%
9DOLGDWLRQRI(8620$FULWHULDIRUVHOHFWLQJWR05,SUHRSHUDWLYH
VWDJLQJSDWLHQWVHOLJLEOHIRUFRQVHUYDWLYHVXUJHU\DWFRQYHQWLRQDOVWDJLQJ
6&LDWWR'%HUQDUGL03HOOHJULQL7UHQWR,7 VWHIDQRFLDWWR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RYHULI\WKHYDOLGLW\RI(8620$FULWHULDSURPSWLQJ05,SUHRSHUDWLYHVWDJ
LQJE\PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05, LQVXEMHFWVHOLJLEOHIRUEUHDVWFRQVHUYLQJWKHUDS\
%&7 OREXODUKLVWRORJLFDOW\SHVL]HGLVFUHSDQF\!FPEHWZHHQPDPPRJUDSK\
DQGXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\KLJKHUHGRIDPLOLDOULVNDQGSODQQHGSDUWLDOEUHDVWLUUDGLDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDO :H UHYLHZHG DQ XQVHOHFWHG VHULHV RI VXEMHFWV HOLJLEOH
IRU%&7DQGFRQVHFXWLYHO\XQGHUJRLQJ05,VWDJLQJDW7UHQWR%UHDVW&OLQLF:H
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\VLPXODWHGKRZPDQ\05,SURFHGXUHVZRXOGKDYHEHHQVSDUHGDQG
KRZPDQ\%&7ZRXOGQRWKDYHEHHQFRQYHUWHGWRPDVWHFWRP\ 0; LQGLFDWLRQKDG
05,VWDJLQJEHHQSHUIRUPHGRQO\LQFDVHVIXOÀOOLQJ(8620$FULWHULD
5HVXOWV05,LQGLFDWLRQIRU0;ZDVREVHUYHGLQRIFDVHV LQWKH
WRWDOVHULHV%DVHGRQ(8620$FULWHULD05,VWDJLQJZRXOGKDYHEHHQLQGLFDWHG
RQO\LQFDVHV JHQHUDWLQJ 0;LQGLFDWLRQV05,ZRXOGKDYH
EHHQVSDUHGLQVXEMHFWVLQZKRPLWGLGDFWXDOO\JHQHUDWH0;LQGLFDWLRQV
RIWRWDO0;LQGLFDWLRQV (8620$FULWHULDVLQJOHRUFRPELQHGZHUHQRW
HIÀFLHQWLQVHOHFWLQJVXEMHFWVDWKLJKHUULVNRI05,LQGLFDWLRQWR0;LQSDUWLFXODU
OREXODUKLVWRORJLFDOW\SHZKLFKLQWKHSUHVHQFHVHULHVZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKORZHU
ULVN$SSO\LQJ (8620$ FULWHULD ZRXOG RQO\ UHGXFH 05, VWDJLQJ SURFHGXUHV E\
DQGLQGLFDWLRQWR0;ZLWKDFRPSDUDEOHUDWH E\
&RQFOXVLRQ:HTXHVWLRQWKHYDOLGLW\RI(8620$FULWHULDIRUVHOHFWLQJSDWLHQWVWR
05,VWDJLQJSULRUWR%&77KH\VKRXOGEHYDOLGDWHGLQFRQWUROOHGVWXGLHVRIJUHDWHU
VWDWLVWLFDOSRZHUEHIRUHEHLQJDGRSWHGLQFXUUHQWSUDFWLFH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSKDUPDFRNLQHWLFSDUDPHWHUVRI'&(05,DVDSUHGLFWLYH
DQGVXUURJDWHPDUNHUIRUSDWLHQWVUHFHLYLQJQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\ 1$& IRU
ORFDOO\DGYDQFHGEUHDVWFDQFHU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$ UHWURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ RI SDWLHQWV ZDV SHUIRUPHG
ZKHUHDOOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWWZR'&(05,H[DPLQDWLRQVEHIRUH (; DQGGXU
LQJ 1$& (; 0D[LPXP GLDPHWHU 'PD[ DQG SKDUPDFRNLQHWLF SDUDPHWHUV
IURP'&(05,VXFKDV.WUDQV.HS9HDQG9SZHUHFRQFHUQHG3RVWRSHUDWLYH
SDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQZDVXVHGDVWKHJROGHQVWDQGDUGZLWKDELQDU\UHVSRQVH
UHVSRQGHUVSDWLHQWVVKRZLQJFRPSOHWHUHPLVVLRQRU´LQVLWXµUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHDQG
QRQUHVSRQGHUVIRUWKHUHVWRIWKHSDWLHQWV:LOFR[RQWHVW52&FXUYHVFRPSDULVRQ
RI52&ZHUHHPSOR\HGIRUWKHVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV)URPWKHSDWLHQWVZHUHQRQUHVSRQGHUV DQG
VKRZHGFRPSOHWHSDWKRORJLFDOUHVSRQVH$W(;DVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQG
EHWZHHQWKHUHVSRQVHJURXSVRQO\IRUWKH.WUDQV(; S DQGDW(;IRU
'PD[ S DQGDOOSKDUPDFRNLQHWLFSDUDPHWHUV.WUDQV S .HS
S 9H S DQG9S S 0RUHRYHUDVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
ZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHUHVSRQVHJURXSVIRUWKHDEVROXWHFKDQJHVRI.WUDQV9H
DQG9SDQGIRUWKHSHUFHQWDJHFKDQJHVRI'PD[.WUDQVDQG9HDQG9SEHWZHHQ
(;DQG(;7KH52&FXUYHDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKHEHVWSHUIRUPDQFHIRU.WUDQVDW
(; IRU'PD[DW(;DQGIRUGHFUHDVHRI9HEHWZHHQWKHWZRH[DPLQDWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ'&(05,SKDUPDFRNLQHWLFSDUDPHWHUVFRXOGEHDSRWHQWLDOSUHGLFWLYH
DQGVXUURJDWHPDUNHURIQHRDGMXYDQWWUHDWPHQWLQORFDOO\DGYDQFHGEUHDVWFDQFHU
%
&RQYHQWLRQDODQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
LQSUHGLFWLQJUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHDIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHU
)3ULROR*3HWUDOLD/%RQHOOR65DLPRQGL5'L)LOLSSL0&ROOHRQL
(&DVVDQR0%HOORPL0LODQ,7 IUDQFHVFDSULROR#LHRLW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRIFRQYHQWLRQDOPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05,
DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG ': 05,LQSUHGLFWLQJUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHDIWHUQHRDGMXYDQW
FKHPRWKHUDS\ 1$&7 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKORFDOO\DGYDQFHGEUHDVWFDQFHU /$%&
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ZH HQUROOHG SDWLHQWV ZLWK /$%& ZKR XQGHUZHQW FRQ
YHQWLRQDO 05, DQG ':05, DW EDVHOLQH GXULQJ DQG DIWHU FRPSOHWLRQ RI 1$&7
7ZRUHDGHUVFDUULHGRXWDTXDOLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVIRUFRQYHQWLRQDO05,DQG':05,
SHUIRUPHGDIWHUFRPSOHWLRQRI1$&7DORQHDQGLQFRPELQDWLRQLQRUGHUWRHYDOX
DWHWKHSUHVHQFHRIUHVLGXDOGLVHDVH:HHYDOXDWHGWKHSRWHQWLDORIWKHEDVHOLQH
DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& DQGLWVFKDQJHVDIWHUZHHNVWRSUHGLFW
UHVLGXDOGLVHDVH
5HVXOWV:HHQUROOHGSDWLHQWVRIZKRPSDWLHQWVZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHUV
XQGHUZHQWVXUJHU\7KHTXDOLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRIFRQYHQWLRQDO05,DORQH':05,
DORQH DQG RI FRQYHQWLRQDO 05, DQG ':05, LQ FRPELQDWLRQ ZDV SHUIRUPHG LQ
WXPRXUVVKRZLQJDGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ '$ IRUSUHGLFWLQJUHVLGXDOGLVHDVH
RI DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\ 3DWLHQWV ZLWK SDWKRORJLFDO FRPSOHWH
UHVSRQVH S&5 VKRZHG D ORZHU EDVHOLQH$'& S ZKHQ FRPSDUHG WR
WKRVH ZLWK UHVLGXDO GLVHDVH7KH FKDQJH LQ$'& DIWHU ZHHNV RI 1$&7 ZDV
VLJQLÀFDQW S LQSDWLHQWVZLWKS&5QRVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHZDVREVHUYHGLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKUHVLGXDOGLVHDVH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, DVDPDPPDFDUFLQRPD
FKDUDFWHULVWLFDVVRFLDWLRQRIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'&
DQGSDWKRORJLFDORXWFRPHLQSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKQHRDGMXYDQW
FKHPRWKHUDS\
9+37UDQ09ROPHULQN$,PKRO]0/RXZHQ5YDQ'LMN'HYHQWHU1/
3XUSRVH 7KH UROH RI ':, LV FXUUHQWO\ XQGHU LQYHVWLJDWLRQ LQ WXPRXU UHVSRQVH
HYDOXDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKQHRDGMXYDQWO\WUHDWHGPDPPDFDUFLQRPD+RZHYHUWKH
UROHRI':,SULRUWRWUHDWPHQWDVDWXPRXUFKDUDFWHULVWLFLQUHODWLRQWRSDWKRORJLFDO
RXWFRPHLVVWLOOXQFOHDU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZHÀUVWLQYHVWLJDWHGWKHDVVR
FLDWLRQEHWZHHQEDVHOLQH$'&DQGSDWKRORJLFDORXWFRPH HLWKHUFRPSOHWHRULQFRP
SOHWHUHVSRQVH E\ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQLQFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKQHRDGMXYDQWO\
WUHDWHGPDPPDFDUFLQRPDLQRXUKRVSLWDOEHWZHHQDQG6HFRQGZH
LQYHVWLJDWHGLIFKDQJHRI$'&DQGFKDQJHRIWXPRXUVL]HZHUHPHGLDWLQJIDFWRUV
5HVXOWV +LJK EDVHOLQH$'& EYDOXH ZDV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK SDWKRORJLFDO
FRPSOHWHUHVSRQVH RGGVUDWLR ð&, ððS
0HDQ$'&LQUHVSRQGHUVZDVðPPVHFDQGLQLQFRPSOHWHUHVSRQGHUV
ð PPVHF XQSDLUHG 6WXGHQWҋV WWHVW S 7KLV DVVRFLDWLRQ ZDV
LQGHSHQGHQWRIFKDQJHVLQWXPRXUVL]H 5(6,67ZDVKRXW DQGFKDQJHVLQ$'&
DIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKEDVHOLQH$'&ZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKFRPSOHWHSDWKRORJLFDOUH
VSRQVHLQGHSHQGHQWRIFKDQJHVLQ$'&DQGWXPRXUJHRPHWU\GXULQJWKHFRXUVH
RIQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\7KHUHIRUHWKHUHLVDSRWHQWLDOUROHIRU$'&DVD
WXPRXUFKDUDFWHULVWLFLQSUHGLFWLQJSDWKRORJLFDORXWFRPH
5RRP,.
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
66E
&7WHFKQLTXH
0RGHUDWRUV
$$OFDOi*DOLDQR0DGULG(6
66WRMDQRYLF1RYL6DG56
%
9DULDELOLW\RI&7FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWLQWKHSDQFUHDVDFDXVHIRU
FRQFHUQ"
/'HOUXH3%ODQFNDHUW'0HUWHQV3'X\FN*HQW%(%UXVVHOV%(
ORXNHGHOUXH#X]JHQWEH
3XUSRVH0XOWLGHWHFWRU&7LVDYDOXDEOHWHFKQLTXHIRUGLDJQRVLVVWDJLQJLQVHYHUDO
SDQFUHDWLFSDWKRORJLHV'LDJQRVLVLVXVXDOO\EDVHGRQWLVVXHGHQVLW\PHDVXUHPHQWV
5HFHQWO\QHZHUIXQFWLRQDO&7WHFKQLTXHVZHUHLQWURGXFHG7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\
ZDVWRDVVHVVYDULDELOLW\RQSHUIXVLRQDQGGXDOHQHUJ\&7GDWDDQGWRFRPSDUH
WKHVHGDWDZLWKGHQVLW\PHDVXUHPHQWVLQWKHSDQFUHDVRIDKHDOWK\SRSXODWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZRJURXSVZHUHLQFOXGHGWZHQW\SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
SHUIXVLRQ&7LPDJLQJWHQSDWLHQWVZHUHVFDQQHGXVLQJDGXDOHQHUJ\SURWRFRO,Q
ERWKJURXSVWLVVXHGHQVLW\ +RXQVÀHOGXQLWV ZDVPHDVXUHGLQSDQFUHDWLFKHDG
ERG\ DQG WDLO )XQFWLRQDO GDWD ZHUH FDOFXODWHG EORRG ÁRZEORRG YROXPH LQ WKH
SHUIXVLRQ&7JURXSLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQLQWKHGXDOHQHUJ\JURXS DQGYDULDELOLW\
ZDVDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV'HQVLW\PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHFRPSDUDEOHIRUWKHSHUIXVLRQDQGGXDOHQ
HUJ\&7JURXSVDQGUDQJHGIURPWR+80D[LPDOHQKDQFHPHQWGLIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQKHDGERG\WDLORIWKHSDQFUHDVUDQJHGEHWZHHQDQG+8&RQVLGHU
DEOHYDULDELOLW\ZDVREVHUYHGERWKRQGHQVLW\PHDVXUHPHQWV UDQJLQJIURPWR
DQGRQIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV PHDQYDULDELOLW\RQSHUIXVLRQ&7SDUDPHWHUV
EORRGÁRZDQGEORRGYROXPHZDVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\PHDQYDULDELOLW\
RQGXDOHQHUJ\LRGLQHPDSSLQJUHVXOWVZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\GHPRQVWUDWHGWKHSUHVHQFHRILPSRUWDQWLQWUDLQGLYLGXDO
YDULDELOLW\LQSDQFUHDWLFWLVVXHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWUHJDUGOHVVRIWKH&7WHFKQLTXH
XVHG&RQVLGHULQJWKHYDULDELOLW\REVHUYHGLQWKLVVWXG\WKHXVHRIFXWRIIYDOXHVWR
FKDUDFWHULVHSDQFUHDWLFSDWKRORJLHVVHHPVWURXEOHVRPHDQGPRUSKRORJLFSULPDU\
DQGVHFRQGDU\FKDQJHVZLOOUHPDLQLPSRUWDQWHYHQZKHQXVLQJQRYHOIXQFWLRQDO
LPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
%
'\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQW05,DVDSUHGLFWLYHDQGVXUURJDWH
PDUNHURISDWKRORJLFDOFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHRIQHRDGMXYDQWWUHDWPHQW
IRUORFDOO\DGYDQFHGEUHDVWFDQFHU
6'ULVLV0&DSHODQ6O&KDR03DHVPDQV0/HPRUW%UXVVHOV%(
VWHOLRVGULVLV#\DKRRFRP
&RQFOXVLRQFRQYHQWLRQDO05,DQG':05,VKRZHGFRPSDUDEOH'$LQSUHGLFW
LQJUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHDIWHU1$&7%DVHOLQH$'&DQGLWVFKDQJHVDIWHUZHHNV
SUHGLFWHGUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHLQRXUFRKRUW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
0HDVXUHPHQWRIWUDQVSODQWHGSDQFUHDWLFYROXPHE\FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\UHOLDELOLW\E\LQWUDDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\
(/XQGTYLVW$5%LJODUQLD06HJHOVMR$0DJQXVVRQ8SSVDOD6(
HYDOXQGTYLVW#VWXGHQWXXVH
3XUSRVH7KH DLP RI WKLV VWXG\ ZDV WR HYDOXDWH WKH UHOLDELOLW\ RI PHDVXUHPHQW
RISDQFUHDWLFYROXPHE\&7LQWUDQVSODQWHGSDWLHQWV7RGD\WKHUHLVQRVXIÀFLHQW
SURJQRVWLFPHWKRGIRUSUHGLFWLQJIDLOXUHRIWUDQVSODQWHGSDQFUHDV7KHK\SRWKHVLV
LV WKDW PHDVXUHPHQW RI SDQFUHDWLF YROXPH E\ &7 YROXPHWU\ FRXOG EH D XVHIXO
PHWKRGIRUFOLQLFDOSXUSRVHDVDSURJQRVWLFPHWKRGDQGWRIROORZWKHQDWXUDOFDXVH
RISDQFUHDWLFWUDQVSODQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7H[DPLQDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGRQWZHQW\RQHFRQVHFX
WLYHSDWLHQWVWKDWKDGXQGHUJRQHSDQFUHDVWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ9ROXPHPHDVXUHPHQWV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGE\WZRREVHUYHUVZKRWUDFHGWKHSDQFUHDWLFFRQWRXUVLQDOOVOLFHV
7KHFRUUHVSRQGLQJYROXPHZDVWKHQDXWRPDWLFDOO\FDOFXODWHG2EVHUYHUSHUIRUPHG
PHDVXUHPHQW IRUHDFK SDWLHQW WZLFH 2EVHUYHU SUHIRUPHG WKH PHDVXUHPHQWV
RQFHIRUHDFKSDWLHQW'LIIHUHQFHVLQYROXPHPHDVXUHPHQWZHUHXVHGWRHYDOXDWH
LQWUDDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\
5HVXOWV ,QWUDREVHUYHU YDULDELOLW\ RI SDQFUHDWLF YROXPH PHDVXUHPHQW RQ &7
ZDVIRXQGWRKDYHDQDOPRVWSHUIHFWDJUHHPHQWZLWK,&&7KHLQWHUREVHUYHU
YDULDELOLW\ZDVDOVRIRXQGWRKDYHDQDOPRVWSHUIHFWDJUHHPHQW,&&IRUWKHÀUVW
PHDVXUHPHQWVRIREVHUYHUYHUVXVWKHPHDVXUHPHQWVRIREVHUYHUZDVIRXQG
WREH,&&IRUWKHVHFRQGPHDVXUHPHQWVRIREVHUYHUYHUVXVWKHPHDVXUH
PHQWVRIREVHUYHUZDVIRXQGWREH
&RQFOXVLRQ ,QWUD DQG LQWHUREVHUYHU YDULDELOLWLHV RI WUDQVSODQWHG SDQFUHDWLF
YROXPHPHDVXUHPHQWKDYHEHHQHYDOXDWHGFRQFOXGLQJWKHPHWKRGLVUHOLDEOHDQG
UHSURGXFLEOHZLWKDOPRVWSHUIHFWLQWUDDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\DJUHHPHQW
7KHUHE\ &7 YROXPHWU\ FRXOG EH FRQVLGHUHG D SURSHU PHWKRG IRU IROORZLQJ DQG
HYDOXDWLQJVL]HYROXPHGHYHORSPHQWRISDQFUHDWLFWUDQVSODQWV
%
(YDOXDWLRQRITXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQPDSZLWK&7SHUIXVLRQ
WHFKQLTXHDVDQHDUO\SUHGLFWRUIRUWXPRXUUHVSRQVHWR
UDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWK+&&OHVLRQVLQLWLDOUHVXOWV
',SSROLWR3%RQDIÀQL&&DSUDUR00HORQL66LURQL0RQ]D,7
GDYLGHDWHQD#WLVFDOLQHWLW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHUROHRI&7SHUIXVLRQ &7S WHFKQLTXHLQGHWHFWLRQRIEORRG
ÁRZFKDQJHVUHODWHGWRWKHWKHUDSHXWLFHIIHFWVLQ+&&OHVLRQWUHDWHGZLWK5)$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQFLUUKRWLFOLYHUGLVHDVH
DQGELRSV\SURYHQGLDJQRVLVRI+&&OHVLRQWKDWXQGHUZHQW5)$WUHDWPHQWZHUH
SURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGLQRXUVWXG\3HUIXVLRQVWXG\RIKHSDWLFSDUHQFK\PDDQG
RIWUHDWHGOHVLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGDERXWPRQWKDIWHUWUHDWPHQWRQDPXOWLGHWHFWRU
VOLFH&7 3KLOLSV %ULOOLDQFH S 1/ &RQWUDVW PHGLXPHQKDQFHG G\QDPLF
&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKVWDWLFWDEOHSRVLWLRQDFTXLULQJG\QDPLFVOLFHVFDQIRUD
WRWDORIVFDQVDIWHULQWUDYHQRXVLQMHFWLRQRIPORIFRQWUDVWPHGLXP7UHDWHG
OHVLRQDQGVXUURXQGLQJSDUHQFK\PDZHUHHYDOXDWHGXVLQJDGHGLFDWHGSHUIXVLRQ
VRIWZDUH &73HUIXVLRQ3KLOLSV 7KHIROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRQVLGHUHG
KHSDWLFSHUIXVLRQ +3 DUWHULDOSHUIXVLRQ $3 EORRGYROXPH %9 KHSDWLFSHUIXVLRQ
LQGH[ +3, DQGWLPHWRSHDN 773 8QLYDULDWHSDLUHG:LOFR[RQVLJQHGUDQNHGWHVW
ZDVXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV3HUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVRIWUHDWHGOHVLRQVFRXOGEHTXDQWLWDWLYHDVVHVVHG
XVLQJ&7SDQDO\VLV6HYHQRXWRISDWLHQWVKDGDUHVLGXDOGLVHDVHDQGYDOXHV
RISHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVPHDVXUHGZLWKLQWXPRXUWLVVXHZHUH+3PO
VHF JU$3 POPLQ 773 VHF %9 PO PJ
+3, 7KH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ SHUIXVLRQ YDOXHV FDOFXODWHG LQ SDWLHQWV
ZLWKRXWUHVLGXDOWXPRXUZHUH+3POVHFJU$3POPLQ773
VHF%9POPJ+3,$VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
S ZDV REVHUYHG LQ PHDQ YDOXH RI DOO SDUDPHWHUV FDOFXODWHG EHWZHHQ
WUHDWHGOHVLRQVZLWKUHVLGXDOWXPRXUDQGWKRVHVXFFHVVIXOO\WUHDWHG&7SWHFKQLTXH
KDVGHPRQVWUDWHGKLJKO\SHUIXVHGDUHDVUHODWHGWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIUHVLGXDODUWHULDO
YHVVHOVZLWKLQWKHYLDEOHSRUWLRQRIWUHDWHG+&&OHVLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ 3HUIXVLRQ&7 LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK KHSDWRFHOOXODU FDUFLQRPD HQDEOHV
DVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUYDVFXODULW\DIWHU5)$E\DGGLQJTXDQWLWDWLYHLQIRUPDWLRQ
DERXWYLDEOHWXPRXUWLVVXH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
+\SHUYDVFXODUOLYHUOHVLRQDWGXDOHQHUJ\&7HQKDQFHPHQW
HYDOXDWLRQDWGLIIHUHQWWXEHYROWDJHV
$&ROOHRQL$6FULPLHUL50DUROGL3&DEDVVD%UHVFLD,7 SDRORFDE#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH DWWHQXDWLRQ YDOXHV RI K\SHUYDVFXODU OLYHU OHVLRQ ZLWK
NYSLPDJHV NYSLPDJHV DQG ZLWK ZHLJKWHGDYHUDJH :$ VLPXODWHG
NYSLPDJHVXVLQJGXDOHQHUJ\&7 '(&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\WKLUW\ÀYHSDWLHQWV PDOHV
DJHUDQJH XQGHUZHQW LQDWZRPRQWKSHULRG DEGRPLQDO'(&7VFDQQLQJIRU
VXVSHFWHGRUNQRZQK\SHUYDVFXODUOHVLRQV$QRQHQKDQFHGVHTXHQFHDQDUWHULDO
SKDVHZLWK'(WHFKQLTXH .YS.YSDQG:$ DQGDYHQRXVDFTXLVLWLRQ
NYS ZHUHSHUIRUPHG$UWHULDOLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGDIWHUDVWDQGDUGWULJJHUHG
WKUHVKROG7KHDWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJ52,VSODFHGLQDUWHULDO
'(LPDJHVRQGLIIHUHQWDUHDVOHVLRQDRUWDSVRDVPXVFOHVXEFXWDQHRXVIDW
KHDOWK\ULJKWDQGOHIWOLYHU7KH//5 OHVLRQWROLYHUUDWLR DQGWKH&15 FRQWUDVWWR
QRLVHUDWLR ZHUHFDOFXODWHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\E\WZRUDGLRORJLVWV7KH&15E\ 52,
OHVLRQ52,ULJKWOLYHUOREH 6'VXEFXWDQHRXVIDW DQGWKH//5E\PHDQYDOXH
RIWKHOHVLRQPHDQYDOXHRIKHDOWK\ULJKWOLYHUOREH$WVWXGHQWWHVWZDVXVHGIRU
VWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV )LIWHHQ OHVLRQV ZHUH GHWHFWHG 7KH PHDQ DWWHQXDWLRQ YDOXHV RI WKH
OHVLRQV ZHUH +8 IRU NYLPDJHV +8 IRU NY
LPDJHV+8LQ:$LPDJHV//5ZDVLQNYLPDJHVLQ
NYLPDJHVDQGLQ:$LPDJHV S 7KHPHDQ&15ZDVLQ
NYLPDJHVLQNYLPDJHVDQGLQ:$LPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQNYSDFTXLVLWLRQLPDJHVRIK\SHUYDVFXODUOHVLRQVGHPRQVWUDWHGD
KLJKHU//5WKDQDFTXLUHGLPDJHVDWNYSDQGDW:$.Y37KHN9SLPDJHV
FRXOGEHXVHGLQFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFHWREHWWHUHYDOXDWHK\SHUYDVFXODUOLYHUOHVLRQV
%
0XOWLRUJDQSHUIXVLRQ&7LQWKHDEGRPHQXVLQJDGHWHFWRUURZ
&7VFDQQHUSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVRISHUIXVLRQFKDQJHVLQWKHOLYHU
VSOHHQDQGSDQFUHDVRIFLUUKRWLFSDWLHQWV
.6DQR80RWRVXJL+0RULVDND+6RX7,FKLNDZD7$UDNL&KXR-3
VQNWKU#\DKRRFRMS
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHSHUIXVLRQRIPXOWLSOHDEGRPLQDORUJDQVEHWZHHQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKDQGZLWKRXWOLYHUFLUUKRVLVXVLQJSHUIXVLRQ&7ZLWKGHWHFWRUURZ&7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7KLV VWXG\ LQFOXGHG SDWLHQWV ZLWK FLUUKRVLV DQG
ZLWKRXWFLUUKRVLV7KHGHWHFWRUURZ&7VFDQQHUHQDEOHGPXOWLRUJDQSHUIXVLRQ
&7 ZLWKRXW UHTXLULQJ WKH VFDQQHU WDEOH WR EH PRYHG 3HUIXVLRQ ZDV FDOFXODWHG
XVLQJWKHPD[LPXPVORSHPRGHOIRUWKHDRUWDWKHSRUWDOYHLQWKHULJKWDQGOHIW
OREHVRIWKHOLYHUWKHKHDGDQGERG\RIWKHSDQFUHDVWKHVSOHHQDQGWKHFRUSXV
DQGDQWUXPRIWKHVWRPDFK3HUIXVLRQLQHDFKRUJDQRISDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXW
FLUUKRVLVZDVFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV3RUWDOYHQRXVSHUIXVLRQRIWKHULJKWDQGOHIWOREHVRIWKHOLYHULQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK FLUUKRVLV DQG P/ÃPLQÃ P/ UHVSHFWLYHO\ ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\
OHVVWKDQWKDWLQSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWFLUUKRVLV DQGP/ÃPLQÃP/UH
VSHFWLYHO\S DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ $UWHULDOSHUIXVLRQRIWKHVSOHHQ
P/ÃPLQÃP/ DQGWKHERG\RIWKHSDQFUHDV P/ÃPLQÃP/
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKFLUUKRVLVZDVDOVRVLJQLÀFDQWO\GHFUHDVHGFRPSDUHGZLWKWKDWLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKRXWFLUUKRVLV VSOHHQP/ÃPLQÃP/S ERG\RI
SDQFUHDVP/ÃPLQÃP/S
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH UHVXOWV RI WKH SHUIXVLRQ &7 VXJJHVW WKDW DUWHULDO SHUIXVLRQ RI
WKHVSOHHQDQGWKHERG\RIWKHSDQFUHDVDVZHOODVSRUWDOSHUIXVLRQRIWKHOLYHU
LQFLUUKRWLFSDWLHQWVZDVGHFUHDVHGFRPSDUHGZLWKWKDWLQQRQFLUUKRWLFSDWLHQWV
%
,QÁXHQFHRIGLIIHUHQWLWHUDWLRQOHYHOVLQIRXUWKJHQHUDWLRQLWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHRQLPDJHQRLVHLQ&7H[DPLQDWLRQVRIWKH
DEGRPHQ
36WXPSS0)HUQDX.YDQ'DDO'*RVFK+'1DJHO7.DKQ
/HLS]LJ'(%XFKKRO]'( SDWULFNVWXPSS#PHGL]LQXQLOHLS]LJGH
3XUSRVH7KHREMHFWLYHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWRIWKHIRXUWKJHQ
HUDWLRQUDZGDWDEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXH ,57 L'RVH 3KLOLSV
+HDOWKFDUH FRPSDUHG WR WUDGLWLRQDO UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ZLWK ÀOWHUHG EDFNSURMHFWLRQ
)%3 RQLPDJHQRLVHLQDUHSUHVHQWDWLYHJURXSRISDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJDEGRPLQDO
&7H[DPLQDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVXQ
GHUZHQWURXWLQH&7H[DPLQDWLRQVRIWKHDEGRPHQ IPPHDQDJH\UV
PHDQ%0, 3DWLHQWVZHUHVFDQQHGRQD3KLOLSV%ULOOLDQFHZLWKWKHXVHRI
DQDXWRPDWLFGRVHFRQWUROV\VWHP N9SURWRFROP$V 5DZGDWDZHUH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
UHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJ)%3DVZHOODV,57ZLWKGLIIHUHQWLWHUDWLRQOHYHOVZLWKDSURWR
W\SHLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV\VWHP5HVXOWLQJLPDJHVZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWKREMHFWLYH
QRLVHPHDVXUHPHQWVGHÀQHGDVVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRIDYHUDJHGHQVLW\YDOXHVLQ
WKHOLYHUDVDKRPRJHQRXVRUJDQ
5HVXOWV$EVROXWHQRLVHOHYHOVLQLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKÀOWHU%ZHUHUHGXFHG
IURP )%3 WR+8 KLJKHVWOHYHO ,57 5HODWLYH QRLVH LQ,57LPDJHV
FRPSDUHG WR )%3 LPDJHV ZDV UHGXFHG E\ ZLWK RQO\ PLQLPDO HIIHFWV RQ
VXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ%\WKHXVHRIDIRXUWKJHQHUDWLRQ,57IRU&7H[DPLQDWLRQVRIWKH
DEGRPHQDUHGXFWLRQRILPDJHQRLVHRIXSWRFDQEHDFKLHYHG
%
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIUHGXFLQJ&7[UD\GRVHLQOLYHUSHUIXVLRQ
XVLQJDUHOD[HGWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQ 75 LQD[LDOVFDQPRGH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW&7SHUIXVLRQVFDQVIRUVXVSLFLRQ
RIWXPRXUV7KHÀUVWSDWLHQWV JURXS XQGHUZHQWPPSHUIXVLRQVFDQVZLWK
V75IRUVDPSOHVZKLOHWKHVHFRQGSDWLHQWV JURXS XQGHUZHQWPP
SHUIXVLRQ VFDQV ZLWK V 75 IRU VDPSOHV 7XEH FXUUHQWV ZHUH P$V DQG
P$VIRUJURXSVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHJLRQDOFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ U&%)
UHJLRQDOFHUHEUDOEORRGYROXPH U&%9 PHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 077 DQGWKHUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHIURPWKHWZRJURXSVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\WWHVW,QDGGLWLRQWKHGHWHFWLRQUDWHV
IRUQRGXOHVZLWKULFKDUWHULDOEORRGVXSSO\ZHUHFRPSDUHGDQGYHULÀHGE\SDWKRORJ\
5HVXOWV7KHUH ZHUH V+&& 51 &+ DQG OLYHU DEVFHVV SDWLHQWV7KH
PP VFDQV GHWHFWHG PRUH V+&& IRFXVHV DQG PRUH &+ FDVHV 7KH
U&%) POÃ JÃPLQ U&%9 POÃ J DQG 077 V IRU JURXSV DQG
ZHUH DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ZLWKQRVWDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHVHSDUDPHWHUV
S! 7KHUDGLDWLRQGRVHIURPJURXSZLWKPPFRYHUDJHZDVVLPLODUWR
JURXSZLWKPPFRYHUDJH
&RQFOXVLRQ:LWKWKHXVHRIDQDSSURSULDWH75 XSWRV WKHPPFRYHUDJH
D[LDOSHUIXVLRQVFDQVSURYLGHGKLJKHUQRGXOHGHWHFWLRQUDWHZLWKRXWGRVHLQFUHDVH
FRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDOPPFRYHUDJH0'&7SHUIXVLRQVFDQV
%
$EGRPLQDO&7ZLWKPRGHOEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
FRPSDULVRQZLWKDGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHDQGÀOWHUHGEDFN
SURMHFWLRQUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
&6X]XNL01DJDWD..LWDJDZD60XUDVKLPD11DJDVDZD+6DNXPD
7VX0LH-3 FKVX]XNL#FOLQPHGLFPLHXDFMS
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHLIPRGHOEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 0%,5 FDQLPSURYH
WKHTXDOLW\RIDEGRPLQDO&7LPDJHVDQGYROXPHUHQGHUHG 95 &7SRUWRJUDSK\
LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKDGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6,5 DQGÀOWHUHG
EDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\SDWLHQWV \HDUV XQGHUZHQWWKUHHSKDVH
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGVOLFH&7RIWKHOLYHU,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWK0%,5
9HR $6,5DQG)%37KHFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 UHODWLYHWRPXVFOH
ZDVFDOFXODWHGIRUWKHOLYHUDQGSRUWDOYHLQRQPPWKLFNLPDJHVDFTXLUHGLQ
SRUWDOYHQRXVSKDVH7KHLPDJHTXDOLW\RIWKEUDQFKHVRIWKHSRUWDOYHLQRQ95
LPDJHVZDVDVVHVVHGE\WZRREVHUYHUVXVLQJDSRLQWVFDOH SRRUIDLU
JRRGH[FHOOHQWZLWKFOHDUGHOLQHDWLRQRIWKEUDQFKHV
5HVXOWV0%,5VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHG&15RIWKHOLYHU LQFRP
SDULVRQZLWKWKRVHE\$6,5 S E\0DQQ:KLWQH\8WHVW DQG)%3
S 7KH&15RISRUWDOYHLQZDVEHLQJVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
WKDQWKRVHE\$6,5 S DQG)%3 S 2QTXDOLWD
WLYHDQDO\VLVWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\VFRUHRISRUWDOYHLQEUDQFKHVRQ95SRUWRJUDSK\
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGXVLQJ0%,5 DVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHE\$6,5
SE\:LOFR[RQVLJQHGUDQNVWHVW DQG)%3 S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHQHZ0%,5DOJRULWKPVLJQLÀFDQWO\HQKDQFHV&15VRIDEGRPLQDO
&7DQGFDQSURYLGHVXEVWDQWLDOO\LPSURYHGYLVXDOLVDWLRQRISRUWDOYHQRXVEUDQFKHV
ZKHQFRPSDUHGZLWK$6,5DQG)%3
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
,VLWDYDLODEOHE\LRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQRIWKHDFWLYHSDUWRIUHQDO
PDVVIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQUHQDODQJLROHLRP\ROLSRPDDQG
UHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPD"
-6XQ;7/L&<RQJ;<=KDQJ6<*DR=/:DQJ<66XQ
;3=KDQJ%HLMLQJ&1 [QTLXTLX#FRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORILRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQRIWKHDFWLYHSDUWRI
WKH UHQDO PDVV DV D WRRO WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH DQJLRP\ROLSRPD $0/ DQG UHQDO FHOO
FDUFLQRPD 5&&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2IWKHVHWZHQW\WZRSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKO\VXVSHFWHGUHQDO
GLVHDVHZKRXQGHUZHQWVLQJOHVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\&7VFDQQLQJEHWZHHQ-XO\
DQG$SULOVHYHQWHHQ HLJKWSDWLHQWVKDG$0/QLQH5&& XQGHUZHQWFRUWL
FRPHGXOODU\QHSKURJUDSKLFDQGH[FUHWRU\SKDVHHQKDQFHGVFDQQLQJ7KHUHJLRQV
RILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUHPDQXDOO\SODFHGRQWKHDFWLYHSDUWRIWKHUHQDOPDVVDQG
WKHDEGRPLQDODRUWD7KHDYHUDJHLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVRI 52, VDQGDEGRPLQDO
DRUWDZHUHREWDLQHG5HSHDWHGPHDVXUHDQDO\VLVZDVFRQGXFWHGZLWK6366DQG
%RQIHUURQLDGMXVWHGSZDVXVHGIRUPXOWLSOHFRPSDULVRQV
5HVXOWV 7KH DYHUDJH LRGLQH FRQFHQWUDWLRQV RI WKH DFWLYH SDUW RI$0/ LQ WKUHH
HQKDQFHG SKDVHV ZHUH PJFF PJFF DQG PJ
FFUHVSHFWLYHO\$QGWKRVHRI5&&ZHUHPJFFPJFFDQG
PJFF7KHDYHUDJHLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW
EHWZHHQ$0/ DQG 5&& LQ DOO HQKDQFHG SKDVHV S S S
HVSHFLDOO\LQFRUWLFRPHGXOODU\SKDVH7KHLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQFKDQJHSDWWHUQV
RIWKUHHSKDVHVEHWZHHQ$0/DQG5&&ZHUHDOVRVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVH SUHOLPLQDU\ UHVXOWV VXJJHVW WKDW LRGLQH FRQFHQWUDWLRQ FRXOG
SURYLGH DQRWKHU KHOSIXO PHWKRG WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH $0/ DQG 5&& LQ DGGLWLRQ WR
FRQYHQWLRQDO &7 ,I WKHVH UHVXOWV DUH FRQÀUPHG WKLV DSSURDFK FRXOG SRWHQWLDOO\
GLIIHUHQWLDWH$0/DQG5&&ZLWKWKHDFWLYHSDUWRIWKHPDVVQRPDWWHUWKHIDWLQ
$0/DUHPLQLPDORUPXFK
%
/RZGRVHXQHQKDQFHG0'&7ZLWKUDGLDWLRQGRVHHTXLYDOHQWWR
DEGRPLQDOUDGLRJUDSKLQHYDOXDWLRQRIDFXWHÁDQNSDLQ
6*RHO$7DQGRQ*0HKURWUD6.%KDUJDYD6%KDWW,6LQJK
$6ULYDVWDYD1HZ'HOKL,1 GRFVDQGHHSJRHO#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\RIORZGRVHXQHQKDQFHG0'&7
GHOLYHULQJ UDGLDWLRQ GRVH HTXLYDOHQW WR DEGRPLQDO UDGLRJUDSK LQ HYDOXDWLRQ RI
SDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHÁDQNSDLQLQFRPSDULVRQWRVWDQGDUGGRVH&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVFRQGXFWHGLQSDWLHQWVSUHVHQW
LQJZLWKDFXWHÁDQNSDLQDIWHUHWKLFDOFRPPLWWHHFOHDUDQFHDQGLQIRUPHGFRQVHQW
$OO SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW XQHQKDQFHG ORZ GRVH &7 /'&7 HIIHFWLYH P$V
DQGIROORZHGE\XOWUDVRXQGDQGVWDQGDUGGRVH&7 6'&7 HIIHFWLYHP$V
7KUHH UHYLHZHUV ZKR ZHUH EOLQGHG WR FOLQLFDO ÀQGLQJV LQGHSHQGHQWO\ UHYLHZHG
/'&7XOWUDVRXQGDQG6'&7IRUSDWKRORJ\DQGLPDJHTXDOLW\ JUDGHGDVJRRG
DFFHSWDEOHRUSRRU
5HVXOWVRISDWLHQWVKDGFDOFXOXVGLVHDVHZKLOHKDGQRQFDOFXOXVXUR
ORJLFDOFDXVHVDQGKDGH[WUDXULQDU\FDXVHVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUSDLQ1RFDXVH
ZDVIRXQGLQSDWLHQWV&DOFXOXVGHWHFWLRQUDWHZDVIRU/'&7IRU
6'&7DQGIRUXOWUDVRXQG7KHPHDQVL]HRIFDOFXOXVPLVVHGRQ/'&7ZDV
PP,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWLQFDOFXOXVGHWHFWLRQDPRQJVWWKUHHUHYLHZHUV
ZDVH[FHOOHQW7KHVHQVLWLYLW\IRUGHWHFWLRQRIQRQFDOFXOXVFDXVHVZDVIRU
/'&7IRU6'&7DQGIRUXOWUDVRXQG0HDQUDGLDWLRQGRVHLQ/'&7
DQG6'&7ZDVP6YDQGP6YUHVSHFWLYHO\2QO\RIORZGRVHVFDQV
ZHUHUDWHGDVRISRRUTXDOLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ/RZGRVHXQHQKDQFHG0'&7UHYHDOHGDKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\IRUXUROLWKL
DVLVDQGPRGHUDWHVHQVLWLYLW\IRUGLDJQRVLQJDOWHUQDWHFDXVHVRIDFXWHÁDQNSDLQ
7KXVLWKDVSRWHQWLDOWREHXVHGDVDÀUVWOLQHPRGDOLW\LQHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHVHSDWLHQWV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
5HGXFLQJ[UD\GRVHIRUOLYHUSHUIXVLRQRQDQH[WHQGHGFRYHUDJH
PXOWLVOLFH&7ZLWKDUHOD[HGWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQ
<*H==KRX7&KHQJ<*XR;6X-/L=KHQJ]KRX&1%HLMLQJ&1
FMUJH\LQJKXL#YLSFRP
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP/0
&DUGLDF
66D
3HUIXVLRQ&7DQG05,
0RGHUDWRUV
0)UDQFRQH5RPH,7
0*DUGDUVGRWWLU5H\NMDYtN,6
%
4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIUHJLRQDOP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQDWGLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRI
FRURQDU\ÁRZLQDODUJHDQLPDOPRGHOXVLQJG\QDPLFSHUIXVLRQ&7
$5RVVL(.ORW]'0HUNXV$8LWWHUGLMN10ROOHW3GH)H\WHU
''XQFNHU*3.UHVWLQ5RWWHUGDP1/)RUFKKHLP'(
3XUSRVH7RTXDQWLI\UHJLRQDOFKDQJHVRIVHYHUDOP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUV
DWGLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRIFRURQDU\ÁRZXVLQJ(&*WULJJHUHGG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
&7 '&(&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QVHYHQSLJVDQDGMXVWDEOHK\GUDXOLFRFFOXGHUZDVSODFHG
DURXQGWKH/$'WRLQGXFHYDULRXVGHJUHHVRIFRURQDU\ÁRZUHGXFWLRQVFDQV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGXQGHUPD[LPXPDGHQRVLQHYDVRGLODWDWLRQ QRREVWUXFWLRQDQGÁRZ
UHGXFHGE\WR '\QDPLFGDWDZHUHDFTXLUHGIRUWKHZKROHKHDUWDIWHU
EROXVLQMHFWLRQXVLQJDGHGLFDWHG(&*WULJJHUHGVFDQPRGHRQDGXDOVRXUFH&7
8VLQJDWZRFRPSDUWPHQWGHFRQYROXWLRQWHFKQLTXH'PDSVRIP\RFDUGLDOEORRG
ÁRZ 0%) ÀUVWSDVVGLVWULEXWLRQYROXPH )3'9 SHUIXVHGFDSLOODU\EORRGYROXPH
3&%9 DQG ÁRZH[WUDFWLRQSURGXFW )( ZHUH FDOFXODWHG$OO SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH
PHDVXUHGLQWKHGRZQVWUHDP/$'DUHDDQGZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKUHODWLYHLQSXWÁRZ
5HVXOWV 0%) EDVHOLQH PO POPLQ U VORSH )3'9
EDVHOLQH PO PO U VORSH DQG 3&%9 EDVHOLQH
POPOU VORSH VLJQLÀFDQWO\GHFUHDVHGSURSRUWLRQDOWRWKH
UHGXFWLRQRIFRURQDU\ÁRZLQWKH/$' S )( EDVHOLQHPOPO
PLQ RQWKHRWKHUKDQGUHPDLQHGFRQVWDQWXQWLOFRURQDU\ÁRZZDVUHGXFHGWROHVV
WKDQ)(YDOXHVEHORZFRURQDU\ÁRZZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQ)(
YDOXHVDERYH 0DQQ:KLWQH\S 7KLVDJUHHVZLWKWKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDW
SDUHQFK\PDOÁRZGRHVQRWGHFUHDVHXQWLOWKHFRURQDU\ÁRZUHVHUYHLVH[KDXVWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ'&(&7LVVXLWDEOHIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIUHJLRQDOP\RFDUGLDOSHU
IXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVDQGFDQEHXVHGWRVWXG\PLFURFLUFXODWRU\FKDQJHVDWYDULRXV
GHJUHHVRIFOLQLFDOO\UHOHYDQWFRURQDU\ÁRZUHGXFWLRQVLQDODUJHDQLPDOPRGHO
%
0\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQ05,DW7XVLQJNW%/$67LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
FRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVHVRIXQFOHDUKDHPRG\QDPLFUHOHYDQFH
3%LVFKRII5/'XVFKND)+LPPHO.0D\3:5DGNH$.RYDFV)09RJW
-%DUNKDXVHQ3+XQROG/EHFN'(
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHKLJKÀHOGP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQ05,XVLQJNW%/$67IRULV
FKDHPLDGHWHFWLRQLQNQRZQFRURQDU\VWHQRVLVRIXQFOHDUKDHPRG\QDPLFUHOHYDQFH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHOYHSDWLHQWV DJH\UVPDOHV ZLWKNQRZQ
FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ GLVHDVH &$' DQG DQJLRJUDSKLFDOO\ FDWK SURYHQ VWHQRVLV RI
LQGHÀQLWHKDHPRG\QDPLFUHOHYDQFHZHUHLQFOXGHG)LUVWSDVVP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQ
VWUHVV05, 7$FKLHYD3KLOLSV ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQFOXGLQJ&LQH66)3LQORQJDQG
VKRUW D[HV DFFHOHUDWHG NW%/$67 SHUIXVLRQ VSDWLDO UHVROXWLRQ [ PP LQ
VKRUWD[HVGXULQJDGHQRVLQHVWUHVVDQGDWUHVWZLWKPPRONJJDGREXWURO
HDFK IROORZHG E\ ',57)( ODWH HQKDQFHPHQW LPDJLQJ 05, SHUIXVLRQ GDWD
ZHUHFRPSDUHGWRFDWKUHVXOWV VXJJHVWHGPHGLXPWRKLJKJUDGHVWHQRVLV RQD
FRURQDU\YHVVHOEDVLV
5HVXOWV,QWRWDOFRURQDU\WHUULWRULHV /$'5&$5&; ZHUHHYDOXDWHG,Q
FRURQDU\WHUULWRULHVZLWKVXJJHVWHGKLJKJUDGHVWHQRVLV05,FRUUHVSRQGHG /$'
Q 5&;Q 5&$Q 05,SHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVLQDQWLFLSDWHGORZJUDGHVWHQRVHV
ZHUHGHWHFWHGLQYDVFXODUDUHDV /$'5&$ ZKHUHDVSRVLWLYHFDWKÀQGLQJV
ZLWKRXWLVFKDHPLDZHUHGHWHFWHGLQYDVFXODUDUHDV /$'5&;5&$
,QYDVFXODUWHUULWRULHV05,DQGDQJLRJUDSK\VKRZHGQHJDWLYHUHVXOWV7KXV
05,GLVFRYHUHGGLVFUHSDQFLHVEHWZHHQYLVXDOJUDGLQJRIVWHQRVLV FDWK DQGWKH
KDHPRG\QDPLFUHOHYDQFH 05, LQSDWLHQWV YDVFXODUDUHDV
&RQFOXVLRQ0\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQ05,DW7XVLQJNW%/$67SURYLGHVUHOHYDQW
LQIRUPDWLRQIRULQGLFDWLQJFRURQDU\LQWHUYHQWLRQLQNQRZQ&$'VROYLQJPLVPDWFK
SUREOHPVEHWZHHQYLVXDOVWHQRVLVJUDGLQJ DQDWRP\ DQGSHUIXVLRQ SK\VLRORJ\
7KH FRPELQDWLRQ RI KLJKÀHOG DQG UDSLG DFTXLVLWLRQ \LHOGV LPSURYHG GLDJQRVWLF
TXDOLW\ 3URVSHFWLYH 05, VWXGLHV LQ FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK FRURQDU\ ÁRZ UHVHUYH DUH
QHHGHGWRDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFEHQHÀW
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIP\RFDUGLDOLVFKDHPLDDQGLQIDUFWVE\DGHQRVLQH
VWUHVVKLJKSLWFK'6&7
7'H=RUGR)9HJD+LJXHUD53*RHWWL$3ODVV)3ODQN$.ODXVHU
6/HVFKND+$ONDGKL*)HXFKWQHU,QQVEUXFN$7/D&RUXxD(6
=XULFK&+6W*DOOHQ&+%RVWRQ0$86
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI DGHQRVLQH P\RFDUGLDO VWUHVVUHVW &73
XVLQJDFRPELQHGKLJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&73FRURQDU\&7$SURWRFROZLWKD
QHZYROXPHWULF'SURWRW\SHVRIWZDUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$GHQRVLQHVWUHVVKLJKSLWFKVOLFHGXDOVRXUFHP\RFDU
GLDO&73 SLWFK DQG&05 7 '(ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQSDWLHQWV0\RFDUGLDO
SHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVE\&73ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVFRPSOHWHRUSDUWLDOUHYHUVLEOHDQGÀ[HG
GXULQJVWUHVVDQGUHVW$QHZSURWRW\SH 6LHPHQV70 ZDVXVHGIRUTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRI
&7GHQVLW\ +8 RIWKHP\RFDUGLXPEDVHGRQDXWRPDWHG'YROXPHVHJPHQWDWLRQ
LQWR$+$P\RFDUGLDOVHJPHQWV7KHWRWDOVXEHQGRDQGVXEHSLFDUGLDO+8ZHUH
TXDQWLÀHG,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHG VFRUH
5HVXOWV7KHWRWDODQGVXEHQGRFDUGLDO+8RIP\RFDUGLDOVHJPHQWVZLWKFRPSOHWH
Q DQGSDUWLDO Q UHYHUVLEOHLVFKDHPLDZHUHORZHUGXULQJVWUHVVDVFRP
SDUHGWRUHVW WRWDOYVVXEHQGRFDUGLDOYV+8 )RUÀ[HGSHUIXVLRQ
GHIHFWV+8ZHUHWRWDOYV+8VXEHQGRFDUGLDOYV+8GXULQJ
VWUHVVDQGUHVW Q $VFRPSDUHGWR&05'(WRWDODQGVXEHQGRFDUGLDO+8RI
VHJPHQWVZLWKP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWVZHUHVOLJKWO\ORZHUGXULQJVWUHVV DQG+8
DVFRPSDUHGWRQRUPDOP\RFDUGLXP DQG+8 'XULQJVWUHVVQRQHRI/$'
DQG/0VHJPHQWVZHUHQRQGLDJQRVWLFZKHUHDVRI&;DQGRI5&$
VHJPHQWVZHUHQRQGLDJQRVWLFDQGUHVW&7$ZDVQHHGHGIRUDVVHVVPHQW5DGLDWLRQ
GRVH&73ZDVP6Y
&RQFOXVLRQ 4XDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI LVFKDHPLF P\RFDUGLXP GXULQJ DGHQRVLQH VWUHVV
KLJKSLWFK'6&7LVSRVVLEOHDWDQXOWUDORZUDGLDWLRQGRVHRIP6Y5HVW&7$
LVUHTXLUHGWRFKDUDFWHULVHP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVDQGWRHQVXUHFRURQDU\
&7$DQG'(IRUYLDELOLW\
%
'\QDPLF&7SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJRIWKHP\RFDUGLXPXVLQJDZLGH
GHWHFWRU&7VFDQQHUÀUVWUHVXOWV
'0XHQ]HO3%1RHO95HQ]%0*UDPHU09HPEDU$$)LQJHUOH
(-5XPPHQ\$+XEHU0XQLFK'(+LJKODQG+HLJKWV2+86
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RI&7G\QDPLFP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ
03, DWDZLGHGHWHFWRU&7VFDQQHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSLJVXQGHUZHQWVWUHVV&703,DWDVOLFH0'&7
VFDQQHU,QSLJVDVWHQRVLVRIDFRURQDU\DUWHU\ /$'Q /&;Q GLDJRQDO
EUDQFKQ ZDVLQGXFHGE\VXEWRWDOEDOORRQRFFOXVLRQ VWHQRVLVJURXS SLJVZHUH
H[DPLQHGZLWKRXWLQWHUYHQWLRQ FRQWUROJURXS 7KHVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUV
WLPHWRSHDN 773 SHDNHQKDQFHPHQW 3( XSVORSH 86 DQGWKHDUHDXQGHU
WKHFXUYH $8& ZHUHFRPSDUHGLQWUDDQGLQWHULQGLYLGXDOO\LQSRVWVWHQRWLFDQG
QRUPDOP\RFDUGLXP5DGLDWLRQGRVHZDVHVWLPDWHGE\&7',YRO
5HVXOWV 7KH LQWUDLQGLYLGXDO HYDOXDWLRQ VKRZHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ S KLJKHU
PHDQYDOXHVIRU773 V DQGORZHUPHDQYDOXHVIRU3( +8
86 +8V DQG$8& +8 V LQWKHK\SRSHUIXVHGP\RFDUGLXP
FRPSDUHGWRWKHUHPRWHP\RFDUGLXPLQWKHVHSWXPDQGODWHUDOZDOO 773
V V 3( +8 +8 86 +8V +8V
$8&+8 V+8 6 7KHLQWHULQGLYLGXDOHYDOXDWLRQVKRZHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ S ORZHUPHDQYDOXHVIRU773 V DQGKLJKHUPHDQ
YDOXHVIRU3( +8 86 +8V DQG$8& +8 V LQ
WKHFRQWUROJURXS&7',YROZDVP*\
&RQFOXVLRQ'\QDPLFVWUHVV&7SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJRIIHUVWKHSRWHQWLDODVVHVVPHQW
RIWKHSK\VLRORJLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLVWKHUHE\RYHUFRPLQJ
RQHRIWKHOLPLWDWLRQVRIFDUGLDF&7
%
'\QDPLF&7SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJRIWKHP\RFDUGLXPFRPSDULVRQRI
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVIURPDQG
'0XHQ]HO3%1RHO%0*UDPHU95HQ]09HPEDU$$)LQJHUOH
(-5XPPHQ\$+XEHU0XQLFK'(+LJKODQG+HLJKWV2+86
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQG]D[LVFRYHUDJHXVLQJVWDQGDUG
DQGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDQDO\VLVIRU&7G\QDPLFP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ
03,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QSLJVFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLVZDVLQGXFHGE\EDOORRQ
RFFOXVLRQ&7G\QDPLF03,ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDVOLFH0'&7,PDJHQRLVH
DQGVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 ZHUHDVVHVVHG7KHVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUV
WLPHWRSHDN 773 SHDNHQKDQFHPHQW 3( XSVORSH 86 DQGWKHDUHDXQGHU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
$VVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQP\RFDUGLDOEORRGÁRZDVPHDVXUHG
E\G\QDPLFDGHQRVLQHPHGLDWHGVWUHVVSHUIXVLRQFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\DQGFRURQDU\DUWHU\ÁRZLQDODUJHDQLPDOPRGHO
530DUFXV)%DPEHUJ76DQGHU)6FKZDU](%DORFK
5+LQNHO'7KHLVHQ.-+LOGHEUDQGW.1LNRODRX
0XQLFK'( IDELDQEDPEHUJ#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQP\RFDUGLDOEORRGÁRZ 0%) DV
PHDVXUHGE\&7EDVHGG\QDPLFVWUHVVSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJDQGFRURQDU\DUWHU\ÁRZ
E\VHQVRUWLSSHGÁRZZLUHLQDSRUFLQHPRGHOZLWKYDULDEOHGHJUHHVRILQGXFHG
FRURQDU\VWHQRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQGRPHVWLFSLJVUHFHLYHGVWHQWVLQWKH/$'GLVWDOWR
ÀUVWGLDJRQDOEUDQFKLQZKLFKDEDOORRQFDWKHWHUZDVLQÁDWHGWRVLPXODWHOXPLQDO
QDUURZLQJ DQG GLDPHWHU VWHQRVLV ,QWUDDUWHULDO ÁRZ PHDVXUHPHQWV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGDWHDFKSHUIXVLRQVWDWH$OOPRGHOVXQGHUZHQWDGHQRVLQHPHGLDWHG
ѥJNJPLQ G\QDPLFVWUHVVDQGUHVWP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQ&7LPDJLQJXVLQJD
GXDOVRXUFH&7 VKXWWOHPRGHN9P$VPO,RSURPLGH 0%)ZDVFDOFX
ODWHGIRUHDFKP\RFDUGLDOVHJPHQWXVLQJDPRGHOEDVHGSDUDPHWULFGHFRQYROXWLRQ
PHWKRGDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWKUHVXOWVRIFRURQDU\ÁRZPHDVXUHPHQW
5HVXOWV$WUHVWPHDVXUHGFRURQDU\ÁRZLQDQGFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLV
ZHUHDQGFPVHFUHVSHFWLYHO\8QGHUVWUHVVFRQGLWLRQFRUR
QDU\ÁRZLQFUHDVHGWRFPVHFDWVWHQRVLVDQGGHFUHDVHGDW
FRURQDU\VWHQRVLVWRFPVHFVLPLODUWR0%)GHULYHGE\&7 YV
POJPLQS 7KHLQFUHDVHLQFRURQDU\ÁRZRIFPVHFDW
VWHQRVLVXQGHUVWUHVVZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQLQFUHDVHRIPOJPLQLQ0%)&7
WKHGHFUHDVHLQFRURQDU\ÁRZDWXQGHUVWUHVV POVHF ZDVDVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKDGHFUHDVHLQ0%)RIPOJPLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU UHVXOWV LQGLFDWH WKDW &7GHULYHG H0%) PHDVXUHPHQWV DW UHVW
DQGVWUHVVZLWKYDU\LQJGHJUHHVRIFRURQDU\VWHQRVLVDVVRFLDWHZHOOZLWKUHVXOWV
RIFRURQDU\ÁRZPHDVXUHPHQWVLQDODUJHDQLPDOPRGHO
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIP\RFDUGLDO&7SHUIXVLRQLQSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJZLWK
DFXWHFKHVWSDLQWRWKHHPHUJHQF\GHSDUWPHQWFRPSDULVRQZLWK
63(&703,
*)HXFKWQHU)3ODQN-%DWOOH-/HLSVLF7'H]RUGR-0LQ-=LIIHU
%.DW]HQ5&XU\,QQVEUXFN$70LDPL)/869DQFRXYHU'&&$
/RV$QJHOHV&$86 *XGUXQ)HXFKWQHU#LPHGDFDW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHUHVWLQJP\RFDUGLDO&7SHUIXVLRQ &73 IURPFRURQDU\&7
DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ GDWDVHWVLQSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJZLWKFKHVWSDLQ &3 WRWKH('
LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKP\RFDUGLDO63(&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHDQDJHIHPDOHVSULRU
FRURQDU\UHYDVFXODULVDWLRQDQGZLWKSULRU0, SUHVHQWLQJZLWK&3WRWKH('
XQGHUZHQWFRURQDU\VOLFH&7DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ 0\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWV
ZHUHHYDOXDWHGIRU&73HPSOR\LQJDQ$+$VHJPHQWPRGHO&73UHVXOWVZHUH
FRPSDUHGWRUHVWVHVWDPLEL63(&7P\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ 03, SHUSDWLHQW
DQGSHUVHJPHQW&7$ZDVDVVHVVHGIRU!VWHQRVLVSHUYHVVHODQGFRPSDUHG
WR VWUHVVUHVW 63(&7 &RPELQHG &7$&73 DSSURDFK ZDV WHVWHG XVLQJ YHVVHO
WHUULWRU\EDVHGPHWKRG
5HVXOWV&73GHPRQVWUDWHGDQVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIDQG
SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339 RIDQGDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXH 139 RIDQGRQDSHUSDWLHQWDQGSHUVHJPHQWEDVLVUHVSHFWLYHO\
7KHLQWHUPRGDOLW\DJUHHPHQWRI&73WR63(&703,ZDVNDSSD S
&7$VKRZHGDQDFFXUDF\RIVHQVLWLYLW\RIVSHFLÀFLW\RI339
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
DQG139RIDVFRPSDUHGWR63(&703,$GGLWLRQRI&73ÀQGLQJVWR
&7$LPSURYHGWKH339IURPWRSULPDULO\E\UHGXFHGIDOVHSRVLWLYHV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJWRWKH('ZLWK&3WKHHYDOXDWLRQRIUHVWP\R
FDUGLDO&73GHPRQVWUDWHVKLJKGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHDVFRPSDUHGWR63(&7
03,$GGLWLRQRI&73WR&7$LPSURYHVWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI&7$SULPDULO\
E\UHGXFLQJUDWHVRIIDOVHSRVLWLYH&7$
%
3HUIXVLRQGHÀFLWVRIWKHP\RFDUGLXPDFRPSDULVRQRIG\QDPLF&7
SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJDQGFRURQDU\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\
%0*UDPHU'0XHQ]HO3%1RHO95HQ]09HPEDU$$)LQJHUOH
(-5XPPHQ\$+XEHU0XQLFK'(+LJKODQG+HLJKWV2+86
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHSRWHQWLDORIGHWHFWLRQRIP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQGHÀFLWV
XVLQJ&7G\QDPLFP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ 03, DQG´VLQJOHVKRWµFRURQDU\&7
DQJLRJUDSK\ &&7$ IRUGHWHFWLRQRIK\SRSHUIXVHGP\RFDUGLXPLQDQDQLPDOPRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSLJVXQGHUZHQWUHVW&703, N9P$V DQG
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\(&*JDWHG&&7$ N9P$V XVLQJDVOLFHPXOWLGHWHFWRU
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\VFDQQHU 0'&7 &RPSOHWHEDOORRQRFFOXVLRQRIDFRURQDU\
DUWHU\ /$'Q /&; GLDJRQDOEUDQFKQ ZDVLQGXFHG$WWHQXDWLRQYDOXHV
RISRVWVWHQRWLFDQGQRUPDOP\RFDUGLXPZHUHFRPSDUHGLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\IRU03,
DQG&&7$,PDJHQRLVHDQGVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 IRUQRUPDOP\RFDUGLXP
DQGK\SRSHUIXVHGP\RFDUGLXPZHUHDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV 0HDQ GHQVLWLHV EHWZHHQ ERWK JURXSV ZHUH QRW VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHQW
IRU&&7$ +8 DQG03, +8 DWSHDNHQKDQFHPHQW
S +\SRSHUIXVHG WHUULWRULHV VKRZHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU +8 FRPSDUHG
WRUHPRWHP\RFDUGLXPLQWKHVHSWXPDQGODWHUDOZDOOLQ&&7$ +8
YV +8 DQG +8 UHVSHFWLYHO\ S DQG 03,
+8YV+8DQG+8UHVSHFWLYHO\S
,PDJHQRLVHZDV+8LQ&&7$DQG+8LQ03,S615
ZDVKLJKHULQ03, FRPSDUHGWR&&7$ S
&RQFOXVLRQ+\SRSHUIXVHGFRURQDU\WHUULWRULHVVXSSOLHGE\FRPSOHWHO\RFFOXGHG
DUWHULHV FDQ EH GHWHFWHG LQ ERWK VLQJOH VKRW &&7$ DW RQH WLPH SRLQW DQG ZLWK
G\QDPLF&703,
%
0\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJXVLQJDGHQRVLQHLQGXFHGVWUHVVGXDO
HQHUJ\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\RIWKHKHDUWFRPSDULVRQZLWKVLQJOH
SKRWRQHPLVVLRQFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQGFRQYHQWLRQDOFRURQDU\
DQJLRJUDSK\
62X6Q/L*P3HQJ<[*XR*XDQJ]KRX&1 OKT[[K#FRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIDGHQRVLQHVWUHVV
GXDOHQHUJ\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ '(&7 IRUGHWHFWLQJKDHPRG\QDPLFDOO\VLJQLÀ
FDQWVWHQRVLVFDXVLQJUHYHUVLEOHP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQGHIHFW 3' FRPSDUHGZLWK
63(&7P\RFDUGLDO SHUIXVLRQ LPDJLQJ 63(&703, DQGFRQYHQWLRQDO FRURQDU\
DQJLRJUDSK\ &&$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\IRXUSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVH
&$' GHWHFWHGE\GXDOVRXUFH&7 '6&7 ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
VWUHVV'(&7ZLWKKLJKDQGORZHQHUJ\[UD\VSHFWUDVHWWLQJVGXULQJDGHQRVLQH
LQIXVLRQ'XDOVRXUFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ '6&7 ZDVSHUIRUPHGDVIROORZV
VWUHVV&7FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGVFDQGXULQJDGHQRVLQHLQIXVLRQ UHVW&7FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGVFDQXVLQJSURVSHFWLYHWULJJHULQJ
5HVXOWV7KH'6&7SURWRFROZDVVXFFHVVIXOO\FRPSOHWHGIRURIVXEMHFWV
DYHUDJHDJH\HDUVPDOHERG\PDVVLQGH[NJP ZLWKDQ
DYHUDJHUDGLDWLRQGRVHRIP6Y$WRWDORIP\RFDUGLDOVHJPHQWVDQG
YDVFXODUWHUULWRULHVRISDWLHQWVZHUHDQDO\VHGVHJPHQWVDQGYDVFXODU
WHUULWRULHVLQSDWLHQWVVKRZHGUHYHUVLEOH3'VRQVWUHVV'(&76WUHVV'(&7KDG
VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\IRUGHWHFWLQJ VHJPHQWVZLWK
UHYHUVLEOH3'VVHHQRQ63(&703, Q &RPSDUHGZLWK&&$ Q VWUHVV
'(&7KDGVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRI
YDVFXODU WHUULWRULHV ZLWK UHYHUVLEOH P\RFDUGLDO 3'V WKDW KDG KDHPRG\QDPLFDOO\
UHOHYDQW&$'
&RQFOXVLRQ$GHQRVLQHVWUHVV&7FDQLGHQWLI\VWUHVVLQGXFHGP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQ
GHIHFWVZLWKGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\FRPSDUDEOHWR63(&7ZLWKVLPLODUUDGLDWLRQGRVH
DQGZLWKWKHDGYDQWDJHRISURYLGLQJLQIRUPDWLRQRQFRURQDU\VWHQRVLV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
WKHFXUYH $8& ZHUH FRPSDUHG LQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\ LQ SRVWVWHQRWLF DQG QRUPDO
P\RFDUGLXP=D[LVFRYHUDJHRIUHFRQVWUXFWHG'VFDQYROXPHVZDVHVWLPDWHG
LQFRURQDOUHIRUPDWLRQV
5HVXOWV7KHLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOHYDOXDWLRQVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S KLJKHUYDOXHV
IRU773 VHF DQGORZHUYDOXHVIRU3( +8 86 +8V
DQG$8& +8 V LQWKHK\SRSHUIXVHGP\RFDUGLXPFRPSDUHGWRWKHUHPRWH
P\RFDUGLXP 773VHFVHF3(+8+8
86 +8V +8V $8& +8 V +8 6
ÀOWHUHGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDQDO\VLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHGLPDJHQRLVHZLWK+8
FRPSDUHGWR+8LQUHFRQVWUXFWHGLPDJHV S 615ZDV
LQFUHDVHGZLWK YHUVXV S=FRYHUDJHZDV
LQFUHDVHGRIDERXWFPXVLQJUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ PPYV
PP S
&RQFOXVLRQ 5HFRQVWUXFWLRQV IURP LPSURYH LPDJH TXDOLW\ RI G\QDPLF &7
03, DQG LQFUHDVH ]D[LV FRYHUDJH RI ' LPDJLQJ YROXPHV XVLQJ D VOLFH
0'&7VFDQQHU
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%HQHÀWRIFRPELQLQJTXDQWLWDWLYHFDUGLDF&7SDUDPHWHUVZLWK
WURSRQLQ,IRUSUHGLFWLQJULJKWYHQWULFXODUG\VIXQFWLRQDQGDGYHUVH
FOLQLFDOHYHQWVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
00H\HU&)LQN65RHJHU3$SIDOWUHU'+DJKL:.DPLQVNL01HXPDLHU
626FK|QEHUJ7+HQ]OHU0DQQKHLP'( PUPH\HUPDWKLDV#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RITXDQWLWDWLYHFDUGLDF
&7SDUDPHWHUVDORQHDQGLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWKWURSRQLQ,IRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIULJKW
YHQWULFXODUG\VIXQFWLRQ 59' LQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP 3(
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7KLV SURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ KDG LQVWLWXWLRQDO ,5% DSSURYDO
DQGZDV+,3$$FRPSOLDQWFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG3(XQGHUZHQW
SXOPRQDU\ &7 DQJLRJUDSK\ ,Q WRWDO SDWLHQWV ZLWK FRQÀUPHG 3( XQGHUZHQW
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DQGWURSRQLQ,VHUXPOHYHOPHDVXUHPHQWVZLWKLQKRXUV7KUHH
HVWDEOLVKHGFDUGLDF&7PHDVXUHPHQWVIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRI59'ZHUHREWDLQHG
59/9D[LDO 59/9&+ DQG 59/9YROXPH &7 PHDVXUHPHQWV DQG WURSRQLQ ,
VHUXPOHYHOVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWK59'IRXQGRQHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DQGDGYHUVH
FOLQLFDOHYHQWVDFFRUGLQJWR0$33(7FULWHULD
5HVXOWVRISDWLHQWVZLWK3(KDGDGYHUVHFOLQLFDOHYHQWVDQGRISDWLHQWV
KDG59'RQHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\$59/9YROXPHUDWLR!VKRZHGWKHKLJKHVW
DUHD XQGHU WKH FXUYH $8& IRU WKH SUHGLFWLRQ RI DGYHUVH FOLQLFDO HYHQWV
ZKHQFRPSDUHGWR59/9D[LDO59/9&KDQGWURSRQLQ, 3DWLHQWVZLWK
59'VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S S KLJKHU59/9UDWLRVDQGWURSRQLQ,
OHYHOVFRPSDUHGWRWKRVHZLWKRXW59'7KH$8&RI59/9D[LDO59/9&K59
/9YROXPHDQGWURSRQLQ,IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRI59'ZHUHDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\$FRPELQDWLRQRI59/9D[LDO59/9&K59/9YROXPHZLWKWURSRQLQ
,LQFUHDVHGWKH$8&WRDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ$FRPELQDWLRQRIFDUGLDF&7SDUDPHWHUVDQGWURSRQLQ,PHDVXUHPHQWV
LPSURYHVWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRUGHWHFWLQJ59'DQGSUHGLFWLQJDGYHUVHFOLQLFDO
HYHQWVLIFRPSDUHGWRHLWKHUWHVWDORQH
5RRP12
9DVFXODU
66
1HZDVSHFWVLQYDVFXODULPDJLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
9&DQWLVDQL5RPH,7
39LODUHV0RUJDGR3RUWR37
%
(VWLPDWHGUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQIRUSURVSHFWLYH
HOHFWURFDUGLRJUDSK\WULJJHUHGGXDOVRXUFH&7DQJLRJUDSK\RIWKH
WKRUDFLFDRUWDXVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\
3%ODQNH6%XOOD*3DFKH%5\OVNL0/DQJHU
)UHLEXUJ'( SKLOLSSEODQNH#XQLNOLQLNIUHLEXUJGH
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\LQYHVWLJDWHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
IRU SURVSHFWLYH (&*WULJJHUHG VHTXHQWLDO GXDO VRXUFH '6 &7$ XVLQJ LWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKHWKRUDFLFDRUWDLQFRPSDULVRQWRSURVSHFWLYH(&*WULJJHUHG
VHTXHQWLDOGXDOVRXUFH '6 &7$ZLWKVWDQGDUGÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZRKXQGUHG DQG VL[W\ FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV UHIHUUHG
IRU(&*DVVLVWHG'6&7$RIWKHWKRUDFLFDRUWDZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHG7XEH
YROWDJHZDVDGMXVWHGWRERG\PDVVLQGH[ NJPN9Q NJ
PN9Q 3DWLHQWVZHUHUDQGRPO\DVVLJQHGWRD&7SURWRFROZLWKUH
GXFHGUHIHUHQFHWXEHFXUUHQWRIHLWKHURUP$VURWHPSOR\LQJLWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQDQGZHUHFRPSDUHGWRDUHIHUHQFHFRKRUWSUHYLRXVO\H[DPLQHGZLWK
RXULQVWLWXWLRQDOVWDQGDUGSURWRFRO P$VURW)%3 ,PDJHQRLVHDQGVXEMHFWLYH
LPDJH TXDOLW\ ZHUH DVVHVVHG (IIHFWLYH UDGLDWLRQ GRVH ZDV FDOFXODWHG IURP WKH
GRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW
5HVXOWV0HDQHVWLPDWHGHIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRUSURWRFROVZLWK
UHGXFHGWXEHFXUUHQW P$VURW FRPSDUHGWRWKHVWDQGDUGSURWRFRO
ZLWKP$VURW N9P6YP6YP6YYVP6Y
S N9 P6Y P6Y P6Y YV P6Y
S :LWKGHFUHDVLQJWXEHFXUUHQWLPDJHQRLVHLQFUHDVHGEXWGLGQRWUHDFK
OHYHORIWKHVWDQGDUGSURWRFRO6XEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\GHFUHDVHGZLWKGHFUHDVLQJ
WXEHFXUUHQWEXWLPDJHTXDOLW\RIWKHP$VURWVXEJURXSVZDVHTXLYDOHQWWRWKH
VWDQGDUGSURWRFRO N9YVN9YVS QV
&RQFOXVLRQ,WHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOORZVIRUUHGXFWLRQRIDSSOLHGWXEHFXUUHQW
DQGWKHUHE\IRUGRVHUHGXFWLRQRIDSSUR[LPDWHO\LQ&7$RIWKHWKRUDFLFDRUWD
ZKLOH PDLQWDLQLQJ REMHFWLYH DQG VXEMHFWLYH LPDJH TXDOLW\ ZKHQ FRPSDUHG WR D
VWDQGDUGSURWRFROZLWKÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
&OLQLFDOHYDOXDWLRQDQGSRWHQWLDOUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQRIWKH
QRYHOVLQRJUDPDIÀUPHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXH 6$),5(
LQDEGRPLQDOFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\
&6FKDEHO'.HWHOVHQ0)HQFKHO%6FKPLGW7*)ORKU$.RUQ
&7KRPDV&'&ODXVVHQ0+HXVFKPLG&6FKUDPO7ELQJHQ'(
)RUFKKHLP'(
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHQRYHOVLQRJUDPDIÀUPHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJR
ULWKP 6$),5( ZLWKUHVSHFWWRFOLQLFDOXVDELOLW\DQGSRWHQWLDOUHGXFWLRQRIUDGLDWLRQ
H[SRVXUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\VL[SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWURXWLQHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
&7IROORZXSDIWHUHQGRYDVFXODUDQHXU\VPUHSDLU7KHH[DPLQDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
ZLWKDGXDOVRXUFH&7UXQQLQJERWK[UD\WXEHGHWHFWRUV\VWHPVDWWKHVDPHYROW
DJH5DZGDWDZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJWKHSURMHFWLRQVRIERWKWXEHV )' ZLWK
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 DQGXVLQJRQO\WKHSURMHFWLRQVRIRQHWXEH +' ZLWK
)%3 DQG 6$),5( FRUUHVSRQGLQJ D V\QWKHWLF KDOIGRVH DFTXLVLWLRQ ,PDJH VHWV
ZHUHREMHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHGZLWKUHJDUGWRLPDJHQRLVHDQGHGJHVKDUSQHVV7ZR
LQGHSHQGHQWUDGLRORJLVWVDVVHVVHGDVHWRIVXEMHFWLYHFULWHULD
5HVXOWV +' 6$),5( LPDJHV VKRZHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU QRLVH WKDQ )' )%3
S DQGHTXDOHGJHVKDUSQHVV S 0RVWRIWKHVXEMHFWLYHO\DVVHVVHG
SDUDPHWHUVOLNHGLDJQRVWLFXVDELOLW\DQGGHSLFWLRQRIFRQWUDVWHGYHVVHOVZHUHUDWHG
VLPLODULQ+'6DÀUHDQG)')%3LPDJHV)')%3LPDJHVGHSLFWHGÀQHDQDWRPLF
VWUXFWXUHVPRUHFOHDUO\ S ZKLOH+'6$),5(GDWDVHWVKDGVXEMHFWLYHO\OHVV
QRLVH S +')%3LPDJHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZRUVHLQHYHU\VXEMHFWLYHDQG
REMHFWLYHFULWHULRQ S 7KHLPDJHWH[WXUHRIWKH+'6$),5(UHFRQVWUXFWHG
LPDJHVZDVUHJDUGHGHTXDOWR)')%3GDWDVHWV,QWHUUDWHUDJUHHPHQWZDVIRXQG
WREHJRRG )')%3ѣ +')%3ѣ +'6$),5(ѣ
&RQFOXVLRQ 8VLQJ WKH 6$),5( DOJRULWKP WKH UDGLDWLRQ GRVH RI KLJKFRQWUDVW
DEGRPLQDO&7$FDQEHUHGXFHGIURPDURXWLQHFOLQLFDOOHYHOE\XSWRZKLOH
PDLQWDLQLQJJRRGLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
%
+LJKHULRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQSHUPLWVGRVHUHGXFWLRQZKLOHLQFUHDVLQJ
FRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLRLQKLJKSLWFKZLGHUDQJH&7DQJLRJUDSK\
)6FKZDU].*UDQGO$$UQROGL:+6RPPHU)%DPEHUJ0)5HLVHU
&+%HFNHU0XQLFK'( ÁRULDQVFKZDU]#PHGOPXGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 DQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHDWGLIIHUHQW
LRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQLQKLJKSLWFKZLGHUDQJH&7DQJLRJUDSK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$OOVFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQDVOLFH&7V\VWHPXV
LQJDKLJKSLWFKDFTXLVLWLRQWHFKQLTXH S $VRIWZDUHDOJRULWKPRSWLPLVLQJN9
DQGP$VVHWWLQJVRQWKHEDVLVRIDGMXVWDEOHUHIHUHQFHYDOXHVDQGDWWHQXDWLRQRQ
WKHLQLWLDOWRSRJUDPZDVDSSOLHG7ZRVFDQSURWRFROVZHUHFRPSDUHG3URWRFROB$
XVHGPJ,POFRQWUDVWLQMHFWHGDWPOVHFDQGUHIHUHQFHYDOXHVIRUN9DQG
P$VVHWWRDQG3URWRFROB%XVHGPJ,POFRQWUDVWLQMHFWHGDWPO
VHFDQGUHIHUHQFHYDOXHVIRUN9DQGP$VVHWWRDQGSDWLHQWVZKR
KDG XQGHUJRQH &7DQJLRJUDSK\ RI WKH FKHVW DEGRPHQ DQG SHOYLV XVLQJ HLWKHU
SURWRFROB$ Q RUSURWRFROB% Q ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVDQDO\VLV7ZRUHDG
HUVPHDVXUHGLQWUDYDVFXODUHQKDQFHPHQWDQGVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQDWGLIIHUHQW
SRLQWV ZLWKLQ WKH DUWHULDO V\VWHP )RU GRVH HVWLPDWLRQ WKH GRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW
'/3 ZDVUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV7KHUHZHUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQVH[UDWLRRU%0, YV
S EHWZHHQERWKJURXSV$XWRPDWLFN9VHOHFWLRQXVHGN9N9DQG
N9LQDQGSDWLHQWVLQJURXS$DQGLQDQGSDWLHQWVLQJURXS%
S 2YHUDOOGDWDVHWVRIJURXS%VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUOHYHOVRIQRLVH
+8YV+8S EXWDOVRRIVLJQDO +8YV+8S
UHVXOWLQJ LQ KLJKHU &15 LQ JURXS % YV S $SSOLHG '/3 ZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQJURXS% YVP*\FPS
&RQFOXVLRQ,QKLJKSLWFKZLGHUDQJH&7DQJLRJUDSK\KLJKHULRGLQHFRQFHQWUD
WLRQSHUPLWVVLJQLÀFDQWGRVHUHGXFWLRQVZKLOHLQFUHDVLQJFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR
%
/RZGRVHPXOWLGHWHFWRUURZ&7DQJLRJUDSK\LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI
LQIUDUHQDODRUWDDQGSHULSKHUDODUWHULDORFFOXVLYHGLVHDVH
01HVWROD5,H]]L06DQWRUR50DUDQR&'L6WDVL/%RQRPR5RPH,7
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSRVVLELOLW\WRUHGXFH[UD\H[SRVXUHGXULQJ&7$RI
SHULSKHUDO DUWHULHV DQG WR HYDOXDWH WKH LPSDFW RI UDGLDWLRQ GRVH RQ GLDJQRVWLF
DFFXUDF\:HDOVRFRPSDUHGWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHDFKLHYHGE\WKUHH&7$
DFTXLVLWLRQSURWRFROVXVLQJSUHWUHDWPHQW'6$DVJROGVWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSHUIRUPHGDSURVSHFWLYHVLQJOHFHQWUHUDQGRPLVHG
FRPSDULVRQ RI GLIIHUHQW [UD\ H[SRVXUH &7DFTXLVLWLRQ SURWRFROV HQUROOLQJ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
,PDJLQJÀQGLQJVLQDGLVWLQFWOHWKDOLQKHULWHGDUWHULRSDWK\V\QGURPH
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQRYHOPXWDWLRQLQ)LEXOLQJHQH
55DMHVKNDQQDQ.0DKHVK&.XONDUQL60RRUWK\.36UHHNXPDU
$'SDHSH61DPSRRWKLUL&RFKLQ,1*HQW%( UDMHVKNU#DLPVDPULWDHGX
3XUSRVH:HSUHVHQWWKHLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVRIDQHZOHWKDOLQKHULWHGDUWHULRSDWK\
V\QGURPHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKQRYHOPXWDWLRQLQ)%/1JHQHRFFXUULQJLQDGLVWLQFW
FRPPXQLW\IURP6RXWK,QGLD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\IRXULQIDQWVIURPDGLVWLQFWSRSXODWLRQVXEJURXS
SUHVHQWLQJ ZLWK FKDUDFWHULVWLF DUWHULDO GLODWDWLRQ DQG WRUWXRVLW\ GXULQJ WKH SHULRG
$XJXVWWR$XJXVWZHUHVWXGLHG$OOLQIDQWVEHORQJHGWRXQUHODWHGIDPL
OLHVIURPDQHWKQRUHOLJLRXVJURXS 0XVOLP IURPWKHQRUWKHUQFRDVWDOEHOWRIWKH
VRXWKHUQ ,QGLDQ VWDWH RI .HUDOD$OO SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW VOLFH &7 DQJLR DQG
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\
5HVXOWV'LODWDWLRQDQGHORQJDWLRQRIDRUWLFURRWDUFKGHVFHQGLQJDRUWDDQGPDLQ
SXOPRQDU\DUWHULHVZLWKQDUURZLQJRILVWKPXVZHUHVHHQLQDOOSDWLHQWV)ROGLQJRI
WKHHORQJDWHGWKRUDFRDEGRPLQDODRUWDZDVVHHQLQDOOSDWLHQWV6WHQRVLVRIDUFK
EUDQFKHV DEGRPLQDO YLVFHUDO EUDQFKHV DQG SXOPRQDU\ DUWHU\ EUDQFKHV ZHUH
VHHQLQ DQG FDVHVUHVSHFWLYHO\&HUHEUDODUWHULDO
LQYROYHPHQWZDVVHHQLQ RXWRIFDVHVVFDQQHG,Q RXWRI
SDWLHQWV ZKR ZHUH PRUH WKDQ PRQWKV ROG VKRZHG SRRU RSDFLÀFDWLRQ RI GLVWDO
DRUWDLQWKHÀUVWUXQGXHWRVORZFLUFXODWLRQ(FKRVKRZHGYHU\VORZIRUZDUGÁRZ
LQGLODWHGDUWHULHV*HQHWLFVWXGLHVUHYHDOHGDQLGHQWLFDOF$!& S$VS$OD
PXWDWLRQLQH[RQRIWKH)%/1JHQHLQDOOSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ:HGHVFULEHLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVRIDQHZOHWKDODUWHULRSDWK\V\QGURPH
IURPDGLVWLQFWSRSXODWLRQVXEJURXS
%
3HUIXVLRQV\VWHPIRUH[YLYRLQYHVWLJDWLRQRIKXPDQYHVVHOV
*(GHOKDXVHU*(UPDQ&'RPHQLJ'%HU]DF]\03RSRYLF5%RUQ\
-/DPPHU0)XQRYLFV9LHQQD$7 JXQGXODHGHOKDXVHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH)RUWKHXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIELRORJLFDOSURFHVVHVLQWKHYHVVHOZDOODIWHU
LQWHUYHQWLRQDO SURFHGXUHV DQ H[YLYR WLVVXH FXOWXUH PRGHO RI KXPDQ YDVFXODU
VHJPHQWVDFFHVVLEOHWRLQWHUYHQWLRQDOSURFHGXUHVDQGVXIÀFLHQWFXOWLYDWLRQWLPH
WRVWXG\WKHLUHIIHFWVLVKLJKO\GHVLUDEOH:HGHYHORSHGDV\VWHPWRVXLWWKHVHUH
TXLUHPHQWVDQGDVVHVVHGPRUSKRORJLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIFXOWLYDWHGKXPDQYHVVHO
VHJPHQWVIRUXSWRGD\V
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV VDSKHQRXV YHLQ VHJPHQWV ZHUH KDUYHVWHG IURP
SDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJE\SDVVVXUJHU\RIWKHOHJ7KHYHVVHOVHJPHQWVZHUHSODFHG
LQDFXVWRPLVHGJODVVFKDPEHUFRQQHFWHGWRDUHJXODWHGUROOHUSXPS&XVWRPLVHG
FXOWXUHPHGLXPZDVSXPSHGDWDVHWÁRZUDWHDQGWUDQVPXUDOSUHVVXUH7KHYHV
VHOVHJPHQWVZHUHFXOWXUHGIRUDQGGD\V7KHVDPSOHVZHUHKLVWRORJLFDOO\
H[DPLQHGZLWKXQFXOWLYDWHGVHJPHQWVRIWKHRULJLQDOYHVVHOVHUYLQJDVFRQWUROV
0RUSKRORJ\DQGLQWHJULW\ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGDIWHUWUDQVPLVVLRQHOHFWURQPLFURVFRS\
DQGLPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLVWU\IRU&'$DQG.L
5HVXOWVVDPSOHVZHUHFXOWLYDWHGZLWKRXWGHWHFWDEOHLQIHFWLRQIRUWKHSODQQHG
WLPHSHULRG7HPSHUDWXUHPHGLXPS+DQGWUDQVPXUDOSUHVVXUHUHPDLQHGFRQVWDQW
GXULQJWKHFXOWLYDWLRQ&RPSDUHGWRWKHFRQWUROVPHGLDOWKLFNQHVVUHPDLQHGZLWKLQ
RIWKHRULJLQDOYDOXHVQRFKDQJHVLQHODVWLQFRQWHQWLQWLPDOPRUSKRORJ\RU
UHFHSWRUGLVWULEXWLRQDQGGHQVLW\ZHUHGHWHFWDEOH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
&RQFOXVLRQ$QH[YLYRWLVVXHFXOWXUHPRGHOZDVFUHDWHGWKDWFDQPDLQWDLQEDVLF
ELRPRUSKRORJ\DQGUHFHSWRUVWDWXVRIKXPDQYHQRXVVHJPHQWVLQYLWURRYHU
GD\V7KLVPRGHOSRWHQWLDOO\DOORZVIRUORQJWHUPLQYHVWLJDWLRQRIKXPDQYHVVHOVHJ
PHQWVLQFOXGLQJVWXG\LQJWKHHIIHFWVRILQWHUYHQWLRQDOSURFHGXUHVLQDFRQYHQLHQW
FRVWHIIHFWLYHFRQWUROOHGHQYLURQPHQW
%
,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWRIZKROHERG\05DQJLRJUDSK\IRUWKH
GHSLFWLRQRIDWKHURVFOHURVLV
7&/DXHQVWHLQ&2GHQKDXVHQ$4XLQVWHQ0)RUVWLQJ6/DGG
(VVHQ'( WKRPDVODXHQVWHLQ#XQLGXHGH
3XUSRVH7R HYDOXDWH WKH LQWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW IRU WKH GHSLFWLRQ RI DUWHULR
VFOHURWLFFKDQJHVLQGLIIHUHQWDQDWRPLFDODUHDVDVDPDUNHUIRUWKHTXDOLW\RI05
DQJLRJUDSK\ 05$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZHUHUHIHUUHGIRUZKROHERG\05$HLWKHUIRU
VFUHHQLQJSXUSRVHVRUIRUVXVSHFWHGDWKHURVFOHURWLFGLVHDVH,PDJLQJZDVSHU
IRUPHGRQD705V\VWHP 0DJQHWRP$YDQWR6LHPHQV )RUVLJQDOUHFHSWLRQ
DFRPELQDWLRQRIVHYHUDOVXUIDFHFRLOVZDVXVHG$IWHUWKHLQWUDYHQRXVLQMHFWLRQ
RI*DGREXWURO *DGRYLVW%D\HUZHLJKWDGMXVWHGGRVHRIPPRONJ IRXUWRÀYH
RYHUODSSLQJ'*5(7ZVDJLWWDOGDWDVHWVZHUHFROOHFWHGIURPKHDGWRWKHFDOYHV
,PDJHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\WZRUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\IRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIVWHQRWLF
OHVLRQVLQDUWHULDOVHJPHQWVXVLQJDSRLQWVFDOH QRVWHQRVLVVWHQRVLV
RIYHVVHOGLDPHWHUVWHQRVLVVWHQRVLVRFFOXVLRQ
,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVFDOFXODWHGXVLQJWKH&RKHQ VNDSSDYDOXH
5HVXOWVDUWHULDOVHJPHQWVZHUHDVVHVVHG0HDQ.DSSDYDOXHDPRXQWHG
WR/RZHVW.DSSDYDOXHVZHUHIRXQGIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHDRUWLFDUFK
DQGWKHDVFHQGLQJDRUWD +LJKHVW.DSSDYDOXHV ZHUHIRXQGIRU
WKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHLOLDFDQGIHPRUDODUWHULHV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWRI05$GLIIHUVVXEVWDQWLDOO\ZLWKLQYDULRXV
DQDWRPLFDO VHJPHQWV7KH RQO\ PRGHUDWH YDOXHV IRU WKH WKRUDFLF DRUWD PD\ EH
H[SODLQHG E\ WKH FRPSOH[ GHSLFWLRQ RI WKH YHVVHO ZDOO GXH WR FDUGLDF PRWLRQ
DUWHIDFWV +RZHYHU ODUJH DUWHULHV LQ WKH SHOYLF DQG IHPRUDO UHJLRQ SURYHG EHVW
DJUHHPHQWSUREDEO\EHFDXVHRIDQHDV\DQGUREXVWGHOLQHDWLRQ
%
,QWUDLQGLYLGXDOFRPSDULVRQRIZKROHERG\05DQJLRJUDSK\DWDQG
7HVODLQKLJKULVNSDWLHQWVZLWKKHUHGLWDU\K\SHUOLSLGDHPLD
&:HEHU-%XKN7%OH\$.)LQN:HGHO$.RRSV*$GDP3%DQQDV
+DPEXUJ'( FZHEHU#DPDOLHGH
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\DQGLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGGH
WHFWDELOLW\RIVWHQRVHVLQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGZKROHERG\05$ :%05$ DWDQG
7HVOD 7 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKKHUHGLWDU\K\SHUOLSLGDHPLD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKKHUHGLWDU\K\SHUOLSLGDHPLDUHFHLYHGD
DQG7JDGREXWUROFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG:%05$GHÀQHGDUWHULDOVHJPHQWVZHUH
DQDO\VHGUHJDUGLQJGHSLFWLRQRIWDUJHWYHVVHOVLPDJHTXDOLW\DFFRUGLQJWRDSRLQW
VFDOH ´QRWHYDOXDEOHµWR´H[FHOOHQWµ GHJUHHRIVWHQRVLV DQG
DVZHOODVYHVVHODOWHUDWLRQVVXFKDVDQHXU\VPV:LOFR[RQPDWFKHGSDLU
WHVWDQG&KLVTXDUHWHVWZHUHSHUIRUPHGIRUFRPSDULVRQRIWKHWZRÀHOGVWUHQJWKV
5HVXOWV7DQG7VFDQV\LHOGHGKLJKTXDOLW\:%05$LQDOOSDWLHQWV0HDQ
LPDJH TXDOLW\ RI DOO DUWHULDO VHJPHQWV DW 7 ZDV UDWHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU
WRLPDJHTXDOLW\DW7 S )LHOGLQKRPRJHQHLW\
DUWHIDFWVGHWHULRUDWHGLPDJHTXDOLW\DW7LQSDWLHQWVDQGYHQRXVRYHUOD\ZDV
GHVFULEHGPRUHRIWHQDW7 Q WKDQDW7 Q $OOUHOHYDQWVWHQRVHV
Q RFFOXVLRQV Q DQGDQHXU\VPV Q ZHUHHYDOXDWHGVLPLODUO\DW
ERWKÀHOGVWUHQJWKV
&RQFOXVLRQ:%05$FDQEHSHUIRUPHGDWDQG7ZLWKGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\
'XHWRWHFKQLFDOGUDZEDFNVREVHUYHGDW7RYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVUDWHGRQO\
PRGHVWO\KLJKHUIRU7H[DPLQDWLRQV,QRUGHUWRHIIHFWLYHO\WDNHDGYDQWDJHRIWKH
KLJKHUÀHOGVWUHQJWKIXUWKHURSWLPLVDWLRQRIVHTXHQFHSDUDPHWHUVDQGLQMHFWLRQ
SURWRFROVIRU:%05$DW7LVQHFHVVDU\
%
3XOVHZDYHYHORFLW\PHDVXUHPHQWVLQSRLQWYHORFLW\HQFRGHG
UDGLDOO\XQGHUVDPSOHG'SKDVHFRQWUDVW05GDWD 3&9,35
$)U\GU\FKRZLF]$/:HQWODQG.0-RKQVRQ&-)UDQFRLV
7$*ULVW2:LHEHQ0DGLVRQ:,86/EHFN'(0DGLVRQ:,86
DOH[IU\GU\FKRZLF]#XNVKGH
3XUSRVH3XOVHZDYHYHORFLW\ 3:9 LVDQRQLQYDVLYHPHDVXUHRIYDVFXODUVWLIIQHVV
DQGELRPDUNHURIDUWKHURVFOHURVLV:HFRPSDUHGIRXUGLIIHUHQWPHDVXUHPHQWVRI
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
7KXUVGD\
SDWLHQWVZLWK3$2'UHIHUUHGWRRXUGHSDUWPHQWWRXQGHUJRDORZHUOLPE0'&7
DQJLRJUDSK\ PPFROOLPDWLRQ PO ,RPHSURO PJ,P/ # POV
3DWLHQWV ZHUH UDQGRPLVHG LQWR WKUHH [UD\ H[SRVXUH DFTXLVLWLRQ SURWRFROV$
VWDQGDUGGRVH QRLVHLQGH[ 60$57P$ .9% ORZGRVH QRLVHLQGH[
60$57P$ .9& XOWUDORZGRVH QRLVHLQGH[ 60$57P$ .9
$[LDODQG'LPDJHVZHUHTXDOLWDWLYHO\DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHO\FRPSDUHG7KHWKUHH
SURWRFROV ZHUH DOVR FRPSDUHG LQ WHUPV RI GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH XVLQJ SUH
LQWHUYHQWLRQDO'6$DVJROGVWDQGDUG
5HVXOWV 6WDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU DWWHQXDWLRQ YDOXHV ZHUH PHDVXUHG LQ
WKHORZGRVHDQGXOWUDORZGRVHDFTXLVLWLRQSURWRFRO4XDOLWDWLYHO\LPDJHTXDOLW\
ZDVMXGJHGVOLJKWO\EHWWHUZLWKWKHVWDQGDUGSURWRFROWKDQZLWKWKHORZGRVHDQG
XOWUDORZGRVHSURWRFROZLWKRXWVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVRQ'LPDJHV1RVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHVZHUHIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHWKUHHSURWRFROVLQWHUPVRIFRQWUDVWWRQRLVH
UDWLR &15 1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHDOVRIRXQGDPRQJWKHWKUHHJURXSVRI
SDWLHQWVFRQFHUQLQJWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH$QRYHUDOOGRVHUHGXFWLRQRI
DQGZDVREVHUYHGIRUWKHORZGRVHDQGXOWUDORZGRVHSURWRFROUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ 8OWUDORZGRVH 0'&7DQJLRJUDSK\ RI SHULSKHUDO DUWHULHV SURYLGHV
VXEVWDQWLDOO\UHGXFHGUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHZKLOHPDLQWDLQLQJDFRQVWDQW&15JRRG
LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGDQDGHTXDWHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
3:9EDVHGRQUDGLDOO\XQGHUVDPSOHGGLPHQVLRQDOSKDVHFRQWUDVW '3& 05,
XVLQJKLJKWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQ'3&DVVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q HLJKWHHQ KHDOWK\ YROXQWHHUV PHQZRPHQ
\HDUV%0, SRLQWYHORFLW\HQFRGHG'3&9,35GDWDDQG'3&
05,ZHUHDFTXLUHGDW7ZLWKDFKDQQHOERG\FRLO.H\SDUDPHWHUVZHUH ''
WLPHIUDPHVDQG[[PP[[PPVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ
' VOLFHV ZHUH SUHVFULEHG IURP D FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 05$ XVLQJ PPRONJ
JDGRIRVYHVHWWULVRGLXP'DQG'3&GDWDZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWKD0$7/$%EDVHG
VRIWZDUH3:9ZDVFRPSXWHGXVLQJWLPHWRSHDN 773 WLPHWRIRRW 77) FURVV
FRUUHODWLRQ ;&RUU DQGWLPHWRXSVWURNH 778 %ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLVZDVXVHG
WRFRPSDUH'DQG'UHVXOWVDQGLQWUDDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ LQ
VXEMHFWV 'DWDYDULDELOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGZLWKDPRGHORIDJHGHSHQGHQFH5HVLGX
DOVRIGDWDZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKD%URZQ)RUV\WKH$129$WHVW
5HVXOWV 2YHUDOO UHVXOWV ' PV ' PV ZHUH VLPLODU 5H
VXOWV EDVHG RQ GLIIHUHQW DOJRULWKPV GLIIHUHG QRQVLJQLÀFDQWO\ ZLWK DYHUDJH EL
DVHVPV 778 PV 77) DQGPV ;&RUU 773
VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZLWKXQSK\VLRORJLFDOYDOXHV2YHUDOOLQWHUREVHUYHU
PV DQG LQWUDREVHUYHU YDULDELOLW\ PV ZHUH ORZ %URZQ
)RUV\WKHWHVWUHVXOWHGLQS IRU77877)DQG;&RUUGDWDLQGLFDWLQJHTXDO
YDULDELOLW\%LQQLQJLQWRDJHJURXSV !\HDUV UHYHDOHGWKDW778DQG;&RUU DV
RSSRVHGWR77) ZHUHDEOHWRGHWHFWWKHH[SHFWHGLQFUHDVHZLWKDJH
&RQFOXVLRQ 3:9 FDOFXODWLRQV IURP UDGLDOO\ XQGHUVDPSOHG '3&9,35 DUH
IHDVLEOHDQGPD\WKXVEHXVHIXOLQFRPSUHKHQVLYHYDVFXODUGLDJQRVLV778DQG
;&RUUZHUHWKHSUHIHUUHGDOJRULWKPV
%
,PDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHRI%0,DGMXVWHGSHULSKHUDO&7
DQJLRJUDSK\ZLWKN9SFRPSDUHGWRDVWDQGDUGSURWRFROZLWKN9
.00D\06LPRQ)09RJW3+XQROG-%DUNKDXVHQ$.RYDFV
/EHFN'( .DWKDULQDPD\#XNVKGH
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH WKH LPDJH TXDOLW\ DQG UDGLDWLRQ GRVH RI D SHULSKHUDO
&7DQJLRJUDSK\ S&7$ SHUIRUPHG ZLWK ORZN9S DQG %0,DGMXVWHG P$V WR WKH
VWDQGDUGSURWRFRO
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 5HWURVSHFWLYH DQG SURVSHFWLYH JDLQHG GDWD RI
SDWLHQWVUHFHLYLQJVOLFH&7$ZHUHDQDO\VHGSDWLHQWVDQDO\VHGUHWURVSHF
WLYHO\UHFHLYHGDVWDQGDUGS&7$ N9P$VDQG&DUH'RVH RIWKRVH
ZHUHDVVLJQHGWR%0,JURXSLNJPWR%0,JURXS,,NJPDQG
WR%0,JURXS,,,!NJPSDWLHQWVLQFOXGHGSURVSHFWLYHO\ZHUHH[DPLQHG
ZLWK D %0,DGMXVWHG SURWRFRO JURXSL Q XVLQJ N9 P$V ,, Q
N9P$VDQG,,, Q N9P$VUHVSHFWLYHO\&RQWUDVWDGPLQLVWUD
WLRQZDVLGHQWLFDOLQDOOSDWLHQWV PO,RPHSUROPO1D&OÁRZUDWH
POV 7KHDUWHULDOHQKDQFHPHQW 6, 615&15DQGWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\ 3RLQW
6FDOH ZHUHDQDO\VHGDWGHÀQHGOHYHOVRIWKHSHULSKHUDODUWHULHV7KHHIIHFWLYH
UDGLDWLRQGRVHZDVFDOFXODWHGIRUDOOVFDQV
5HVXOWV 7KH DUWHULDO HQKDQFHPHQW ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU PHDQ +8 YV
+8 DWDOOYDVFXODUOHYHOVXVLQJWKHORZN9SSURWRFROV$OWKRXJKEDFNJURXQG
QRLVHOHYHOVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHG615DQG&15ZHUHFRPSDUDEOHDQGWKHLPDJH
TXDOLW\ZDVQRQLQIHULRUWRWKHVWDQGDUGSURWRFRO7KHPRGLÀHGSURWRFROVLJQLÀFDQWO\
UHGXFHGWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHLQDOO%0,JURXSVJURXSL YVP6YS
,, YVP6YS DQGJURXS,,, YVP6YS
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHLPDJHTXDOLW\RIS&7$ZLWKORZN9SDQG%0,DGMXVWHGWXEHFXU
UHQWLVQRWFRPSURPLVHGZKHQFRPSDUHGWRDVWDQGDUGSURWRFRO+RZHYHUUDGLD
WLRQGRVHFDQVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHUHGXFHGE\GHSHQGLQJRQWKHSDWLHQWV%0,
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP4
&DUGLDF
66E
9DOYXODUDQGFRQJHQLWDOKHDUWGLVHDVHV
0RGHUDWRUV
02XGNHUN*URQLQJHQ1/
(:RR$\OHVEXU\8.
%
$RUWLFYDOYHFDOFLXPVFRULQJ $9&6 LVDSUHGLFWRURIVLJQLÀFDQW
SDUDYDOYXODUDRUWLFLQVXIÀFLHQF\LQWUDQVDSLFDODRUWLFYDOYH
LPSODQWDWLRQ 7$9,
//HKPNXKO0+DHQVLJ$-5DVWDQ-.HPSIHUW&0XNKHUMHH
'0+RO]KH\0*URWKRII):0RKU0*XWEHUOHW
/HLS]LJ'( OXNDVOHKPNXKO#PHGXQLOHLS]LJGH
3XUSRVH7UDQVDSLFDODRUWLFYDOYHLPSODQWDWLRQ 7$$9, KDVHYROYHGDVDURXWLQHIRU
VHOHFWHGKLJKULVNSDWLHQWV+RZHYHUSDUDYDOYXODUOHDNVUHPDLQDQXQVROYHGLVVXH
XVLQJFXUUHQWJHQHUDWLRQVRIWUDQVFDWKHWHUYDOYHGHYLFHV7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\
ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHLPSDFWRIQDWLYHDRUWLFYDOYHFDOFLÀFDWLRQRQSDUDYDOYXODUOHDNV
DQGRXWFRPHXVLQJWKH(GZDUGV6$3,(170SURVWKHVLVDQGWUDQVDSLFDODSSURDFK
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV RXW RI 7$$9,V ZLWK
SUHRSHUDWLYH FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ DJH \HDUV IHPDOH ZHUH
LQFOXGHG,PSODQWHGSURVWKHWLFYDOYHVL]HVZHUHPP Q DQGPP Q
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 0HDQ ORJLVWLF (XUR6&25( ZDV DQG PHDQ 6766FRUH
(&*JDWHGFDUGLDF&7DOORZHGWRTXDQWLI\WKHDPRXQWRIFDOFLÀFDWLRQRI
DRUWLFYDOYHOHDÁHWVXVLQJDVFRULQJDQDORJRXVWRWKH$JDWVWRQFDOFLXPVFRULQJRI
FRURQDU\DUWHULHV $9&6 3DUDYDOYXODUOHDNVZHUHDVVHVVHGLQWUDRSHUDWLYHO\E\
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DQGURRWDQJLRJUDSK\
5HVXOWV$OOYDOYHVZHUHLPSODQWHGVXFFHVVIXOO\0HDQ$9&6LQSDWLHQWVZLWKRXW
SDUDYDOYXODU OHDNV Q ZDV ZLWK PLOG SDUDYDOYXODU OHDNV Q
S DQG ZLWK PRGHUDWH SDUDYDOYXODU OHDNV Q
S 7KHUH ZDV D VLJQLÀFDQW FRUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ$9&6 DQG SDUDYDOYXODU
OHDNV U S DQGDWUHQGWRZDUGVDKLJKHULQFLGHQFHRIQHZSDFHPDNHU
LPSODQWDWLRQ U S 1R FRUUHODWLRQ ZDV IRXQG WR GD\ PRUWDOLW\
PDMRUFDUGLDFHYHQWVDQGVWURNHUDWH U S U S DQG
U S
&RQFOXVLRQ 6HYHUH QDWLYH YDOYH FDOFLÀFDWLRQV DUH SUHGLFWLYH IRU SRVWRSHUDWLYH
UHOHYDQWSDUDYDOYXODUOHDN$9&6SULRUWR7$$9,PLJKWVHUYHDVDQDGGLWLRQDOWRRO
WRUHFRQVLGHUWKH7$9,LQGLFDWLRQWRUHGXFHWKHULVNRISDUDYDOYXODUOHDNVHVSHFLDOO\
LQVRFDOOHGRSHUDEOHSDWLHQWV
%
0RUSKRORJLFDODVVHVVPHQWRIWKHDRUWLFYDOYHXVLQJFDUGLRYDVFXODU
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQGFDUGLRYDVFXODUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHDRUWLFVWHQRVLVFRPSDULVRQZLWKLQWUDRSHUDWLYH
ÀQGLQJ
6%DN6.R-&KRL06RQJ-6KLQ+-L6HRXO.5 #NXKDFNU
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHDFFXUDF\RIFDUGLRYDVFXODU&7 &9&7 DQGFDUGLRYDVFX
ODU05 &05 IRUWKHPRUSKRORJLFDODVVHVVPHQWVRIWKHDRUWLFYDOYH $9 LQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK VHYHUH DRUWLF VWHQRVLV $6 DQG WR DVVHVV DFFXUDF\ RI WKH &9&7 IHDWXUHV
GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQELFXVSLG$9 %$9 DQGWULFXVSLG$9 7$9
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHW\IRXUSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUH$6XQGHUZHQW&9&7DQG
&05EHIRUHVXUJHU\7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVDVVHVVHGPRUSKRORJLFSDWWHUQDVGHÀQLWH
%$9GHÀQLWH7$9DQGERUGHUOLQHW\SH,QERUGHUOLQHW\SHRQ&9&7XQHYHQFXVS
VL]HURXQGVKDSHGRSHQLQJPLGOLQHFDOFLÀFDWLRQDQGOHQJWKRIFXVSIXVLRQZHUH
DQDO\VHG'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI&9&7DQG&05IRUGLVFULPLQDWLQJ%$9IURP7$9
ZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKVXUJLFDOÀQGLQJ
5HVXOWV$WVXUJHU\SDWLHQWVKDG7$9DQGSDWLHQWVKDG%$9'HÀQLWH%$9
GHÀQLWH7$9RUERUGHUOLQHW\SHZDVSUHVHQWLQDQGSDWLHQWVRQ&9&7
DQGDQGSDWLHQWVRQ&05,QERUGHUOLQHW\SHRQ&9&7 %$97$9
RQO\URXQGVKDSHGRSHQLQJZDVVWURQJO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK%$9V 3
6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVIRUDVVHVVPHQWRI
$9PRUSKRORJ\ZHUHUHVSHFWLYHO\RQ&9&7DQG
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\RQ&05
&RQFOXVLRQ&9&7DQG&05DUHDFFXUDWHIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQ%$9DQG7$9
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUH$6)XUWKHUVWXGLHVDUHQHHGHGIRUDVVHVVPHQWRI&9&7
IHDWXUHVGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQ%$9DQG7$9LQERUGHUOLQH$9W\SH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&DUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHIRUHYDOXDWLRQRIELFXVSLGDRUWLFYDOYH
PRUSKRORJ\
5)DOHWWL*6FKLYD]DSSD$3DROLQR)$QJHOLQR)&HVDUDQL**DQGLQL
7XULQ,7$VWL,7 ULFFDUGRBIDOHWWL#\DKRRLW
%
05DVVHVVPHQWRISXOPRQDU\ 43 WRV\VWHPLF 46 ÁRZXVLQJ'
SKDVHFRQWUDVWWHFKQLTXHFRPSDULVRQZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOWKURXJK
SODQH'SKDVHFRQWUDVWWHFKQLTXH
%-:LQWHUVSHUJHU06LYDJQDQDP163DXO''LYD(1JX\HQ
$0&UHDQ/-LPHQH]-XDQ50:DOG6/H\7RURQWR21&$
%HUQG:LQWHUVSHUJHU#XKQFD
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH ' SKDVH FRQWUDVW 3& 05, LQ DVVHVVPHQW RI SRVVLEOH
LQWUDFDUGLDFVKXQWVE\VLPXOWDQHRXVDVVHVVPHQWRISXOPRQDU\ 4S DQGV\VWHPLF
4V ÁRZ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSLFLRQRILQWUDFDUGLDFVKXQWVXQGHU
ZHQWFDUGLDF05,DW7HVOD$VVHVVPHQWRI4SDQG4VZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJ
IUHHEUHDWKLQJUHWURJDWHG'3&*5( [[PP75PV LPDJLQJZLWK'
WKURXJKSODQHYHORFLW\HQFRGLQJJUDGLHQW YHQF FPV LQFRQVHFXWLYHPHDVXUH
PHQWVIRUWKHPDLQSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\ 03$ DQGDVFHQGLQJDRUWD $$ UHVSHFWLYHO\
,QDGGLWLRQDSURVSHFWLYHO\WULJJHUHG'3&*5(WHFKQLTXH [[PP75
PV ZLWKWKUHHRUWKRJRQDOYHQFGLUHFWLRQVZDVHPSOR\HGZLWKYROXPHFRYHUDJH
RI03$DQG$$'3&*5(ZDVSRVWSURFHVVHGXVLQJDFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOH
VRIWZDUHDOJRULWKPDQG'3&*5(ZDVDQDO\VHGXVLQJFXVWRPEXLOWVRIWZDUH
%RWKDSSURDFKHVZHUHFRPSDUHGIRUDEVROXWH4SDQG4VYDOXHVDQG4S4VUDWLR
5HVXOWV +HDUW UDWHV GXULQJ ' 3& PHDVXUHPHQWV IRU $$ DQG 03$ ZHUH
ESPDQGESPUHVSHFWLYHO\ 3 ZKLOHKHDUWUDWHGXU
LQJ'3&ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHU ESP3 4SDVVHVVHGE\
'3&FRUUHODWHGKLJKO\ZLWKWKH'3& 5 3 EXWGHPRQVWUDWHG
DVLJQLÀFDQWV\VWHPDWLFDQGUDQGRPHUURU PO3 '3&4
YDOXHVDOVRGHPRQVWUDWHGKLJKFRUUHODWLRQ 5 3 ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQW
V\VWHPLFDQGUDQGRPHUURU PO3 5HVXOWLQJ4S4VUDWLRVRI
'DQG'3&DFTXLVLWLRQVVKRZHGKLJKFRUUHODWLRQ 5 3 DQGQR
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV YV3
&RQFOXVLRQ'YROXPHWULF3&ÁRZDVVHVVPHQWDOORZVIRUDFFXUDWHDVVHVVPHQW
RI4S4VUDWLRVLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRISRVVLEOHLQWUDFDUGLDFVKXQWV)XUWKHULQYHVWLJD
WLRQVRIWKHDFFXUDF\RILQGLYLGXDOÁRZYROXPHVDUHZDUUDQWHG
%
&RPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\HYDOXDWLRQRISRVVLEOHLQWUDSURFHGXUDO
REVWUXFWLRQRIWKHFRURQDU\RVWLDE\WKHDRUWLFYDOYHOHDÁHWVGXULQJ
WUDQVDSLFDODRUWLFYDOYHLPSODQWDWLRQ
//HKPNXKO%)ROG\QD.YRQ$VSHUQ0+DHQVLJ
&/XHFNH&$QGUHV61LW]VFKH0*URWKRII0*XWEHUOHW
/HLS]LJ'( OXNDVOHKPNXKO#PHGXQLOHLS]LJGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLVWDQFHRIWKHFRURQDU\RVWLDIURPWKHEDVDODWWDFKPHQW
RIWKHDRUWLFYDOYHOHDÁHWVDQGWKHOHQJWKRIWKHDRUWLFYDOYHOHDÁHWVSULRUWRWUDQVDSL
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
7KXUVGD\
3XUSRVH7KHPRVWFRPPRQDRUWLFYDOYHDEQRUPDOLW\LVWKHELFXVSLGDRUWLFYDOYH
%$9 7KHUROHRI&05WRHYDOXDWHDRUWLFYDOYHPRUSKRORJ\GLDPHWHUVRIWKH
DVFHQGLQJDRUWDDQGWKHDUUDQJHPHQWRIWKHVLQXVHVRI9DOVDOYDZDVLQYHVWLJDWHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\WZRRIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKDRUWLFGLVHDVHV
ZKRXQGHUZHQW&05SUHVHQWHGZLWK%$9%$9ZHUHSUHVHQWHGZLWKGLIIHUHQWSKH
QRW\SHV%$9ZLWKRXWUDSKHDQG%$9ZLWKUDSKH:LWKLQWKHVHVXEJURXSVGLIIHUHQW
SKHQRW\SHVDUHLGHQWLÀHG%$9ZLWKRXWUDIHLVVXEGLYLGHGLQWR$3 DQWHURSRVWHULRU
DQG/$ ODWHUDODQWHULRU ,Q%$9ZLWKUDSKHZHKDYHLGHQWLÀHGSKHQRW\SHV5/
OHIWDQGULJKWFXVSIXVLRQ 51 IXVLRQRIULJKWDQGQRQFRURQDU\FXVS DQG/1
IXVLRQRIWKHOHIWDQGQRQFRURQDU\FXVS 7KHUHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKUHFHQW
OLWHUDWXUH:HDOVRHYDOXDWHWKHSRVVLEOHDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQ%$9DQGDVFHQGLQJ
DRUWDGLODWDWLRQ
5HVXOWV:HREVHUYHGSUHYDOHQFHRI%$9ZLWKUDSKH DQGZLWKLQWKLV
JURXSWKHSKHQRW\SH5/ 7KHUHVXOWVKDYHVKRZQSDUWO\LQDJUHHPHQW
ZLWKWKHVWXG\RI%XFKQHUDQGFROOHDJXHV%RWKVWXGLHVVKRZHGWKHSUHYDOHQFH
RIWKHJURXSZLWK%$9ZLWKUDSKH LQRXUVWXG\IRU%XFKQHUS
DQGWKHVXEJURXS5/ YVS ,QRXUVWXG\SUHYDOH$3
SKHQRW\SH YV/$ 7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQ S
ZLWKLQ%$9DQGDVFHQGLQJDRUWDGLODWDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&05LVFXUUHQWO\WKHPRVWFRPSOHWHLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHIRUFODVVLÀFD
WLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI%$9
FDOYDOYHLPSODQWDWLRQ 7$$9, ZLWKIRFXVRQSRVVLEOHLQWUDSURFHGXUDOREVWUXFWLRQ
RIWKHFRURQDU\RVWLDXVLQJFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7VFDQVRISDWLHQWV PZPHDQDJH\
ZLWKVHYHUH$6VFKHGXOHGIRU7$$9,ZHUHLQFOXGHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\'LVWDQFHVRI
WKHFRURQDU\RVWLDWRWKHDRUWLFDQQXOXVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQV\VWROLFDQGGLDVWROLF
SKDVHDQGFRPSDUHGWRWKHOHDÁHWOHQJWKPHDVXUHGLQGLDVWROLFSKDVH3RVVLEOH
RYHUODSGLVWDQFH 32' ZDVFDOFXODWHGXVLQJSDLUZLVHDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ32'LQGLFDWHGWKHULVNRIDSRWHQWLDORFFOXVLRQRISDUWVRIWKH
ULJKWFRURQDU\DUWHU\ 5&$ RVWLXPE\WKHULJKWOHDÁHW 32'PPS
GXHWRWKH7$$9,SURFHGXUH7KHPHDQGLVWDQFHIURPWKHPRVWEDVDODWWDFKPHQW
RIWKH/&/WRWKHOHIWFRURQDU\RVWLXPGLGQRWGLIIHUVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S IURPWKH
PHDQ/&/OHQJWKZLWKDPHDQGLIIHUHQFHRI PP
&RQFOXVLRQ5LJKWFRURQDU\OHDÁHWPD\WKHRUHWLFDOO\RYHUODSDQGRFFOXGHDODUJH
SDUWRIWKH5&$RVWLXPGXHWRWKH7$$9,SURFHGXUH
5LJKWYHQWULFXODUK\SHUWURSK\DIWHUDWULDOVZLWFKRSHUDWLRQDQGLWV
UROHLQDV\VWHPLF59QRUPDODGDSWDWLRQSURFHVVRUULVNIDFWRU"$
FDUGLRYDVFXODUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHVWXG\
0*URWKRII-+RIIPDQQ0*XWEHUOHW
/HLS]LJ'( 0DWWKLDV*URWKRII#KHU]]HQWUXPOHLS]LJGH
3XUSRVH6\VWHPLF59K\SHUWURSK\DQGLPSDLUHGV\VWROLFIXQFWLRQRFFXUDIWHUDWULDO
VZLWFK $6 LQGWUDQVSRVLWLRQRIWKHJUHDWDUWHULHV G7*$ (FKRFDUGLRJUDSK\KDV
OLPLWDWLRQLQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHULJKWYHQWULFOH 59 ,QWKLVVWXG\ZHVRXJKWWR
HYDOXDWHV\VWHPLF59P\RFDUGLDOPDVVDQGIXQFWLRQDIWHU$6IRUG7*$DQGWR
DQDO\VHWKHUROHRIH[FHVVLYHK\SHUWURSK\IRUYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQXQGHUVSHFLDO
FRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHLQWHUYHQWULFXODUVHSWDO ,96 PRYHPHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\VHYHQSDWLHQWVDIWHU$6ZHUHVWXGLHGDWD7
VFDQQHU ,QWHUD &9 3KLOLSV XVLQJ D GHGLFDWHG FKDQHOSKDVHDUUD\ VXUIDFH
FDUGLDFFRLO&LQHVWHDG\VWDWHIUHHSUHFHVVLRQVHTXHQFHVZHUHDFTXLUHGWRREWDLQ
ELYHQWULFXODUP\RFDUGLDOPDVVHVDQGIXQFWLRQ7KHV\VWROLFPRYHPHQWRIWKH,96
ZDVGHÀQHGDVSRVLWLYH 360 ZKHQPRYLQJWRZDUGVWKHFHQWURLGRIWKH59RU
HOVHDVQRQSRVLWLYH3DWLHQWSDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRDJHPDWFKHGFRQWUROV
5HVXOWV6\VWHPLF59VZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ODUJHU S WKDQ/9VRIWKHFRQWURO
JURXSV\VWROLFIXQFWLRQVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSDLUHG S DQGP\RFDUGLDOPDVVLQGH[
00, ZDV FRPSDUDEOH S QV 5900, DQG 59() GHPRQVWUDWHG D TXDGUDWLF
FRUUHODWLRQ U S PHDQLQJWKDWSDWLHQWVZLWK5900,EHORZJPò
DQGDERYHJPòKDGDUHGXFHGV\VWROLFIXQFWLRQ3DWLHQWVZLWK360KDGDEHWWHU
59IXQFWLRQFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHQRQ360VXEJURXS S
&RQFOXVLRQ$FHUWDLQDPRXQWRI59K\SHUWURSK\DIWHU$6LVDQRUPDODGDSWDWLRQ
SURFHVVDIWHU$6DQGDVXIÀFLHQW59()FDQEHH[SHFWHGZLWKLQDUDQJHRIJ
Pò360LVSUREDEO\WKHUHVXOWRIK\SHUWURSKLFVHSWDO59ÀEUHVZKLFKLVEHQHÀFLDO
IRU59IXQFWLRQDQGPLJKWEHUHJDUGHGDVWKHSK\VLRORJLFDOFRQWUDFWLRQSDWWHUQ
%
&DUGLRYDVFXODU06&7DQJLRJUDSK\LQQHZERUQVZLWKNQRZQRU
VXVSHFWHGFRQJHQLWDOKHDUWGLVHDVHDSSO\LQJPHDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHV
RIP6Y
7.OLQN*0OOHU-:HLO*$GDP7$%OH\
+DPEXUJ'( WNOLQN#XNHXQLKDPEXUJGH
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLW\RIFDUGLRYDVFXODU06&7DQ
JLRJUDSK\LQFDUGLRSXOPRQDU\FRPSURPLVHGQHZERUQVDQGLQIDQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG
RUNQRZQFRQJHQLWDOKHDUWGLVHDVHDQGWRFRPSDUHGLIIHUHQWVFDQSURWRFROVZLWK
UHJDUGWRUDGLDWLRQGRVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHQHZERUQVDQGLQIDQWV PHDQZHLJKWJ
DJH UDQJH GD\V WR PRQWKV ZHUH LQFOXGHG LQ WKLV UHWURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ &OLQL
FDOO\LQGLFDWHGQRQ(&*WULJJHUHGFDUGLRYDVFXODU&7$ZDVSHUIRUPHGXWLOLVLQJD
06&7VFDQQHU9HQGRUVSHFLÀFSUHVHWVFDQSURWRFROVZHUHLQLWLDOO\XVHGDQG
SURJUHVVLYHO\DGDSWHG,PDJHVZHUHDFTXLUHGZLWKKHOLFDORUDVLQJOHD[LDOURWDWLRQ
VFDQDQGWXEHYROWDJHVRIN9RUN9UHVSHFWLYHO\7ZRREVHUYHUVHYDOXDWHG
WKRUDFLFFDUGLRYDVFXODUÀQGLQJVDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\(IIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHVZHUH
HVWLPDWHGIURPGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW
5HVXOWV$OOPDMRUFDUGLRYDVFXODUGHIHFWVFRXOGEHGHWHFWHGDQGDOOLPDJHVZHUH
RIGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\7ZRVPDOODWULDOVHSWDOGHIHFWVDQGRQHSHUVLVWHQWIRUDPHQ
RYDOHZHUHVHHQRQHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\RQO\,PDJHTXDOLW\RID[LDOVFDQVFRYHULQJ
WKHHQWLUHKHDUWDQGJUHDWWKRUDFLFYHVVHOVZLWKLQDVLQJOHURWDWLRQZHUHVXSHULRUWR
LPDJHVDFTXLUHGZLWKDKHOLFDOVFDQQLQJSURWRFRO5HGXFLQJWKHWXEHYROWDJHIURP
N9WRN9UHVXOWHGLQDPHDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHRIP6Y
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ &DUGLRYDVFXODU &7 H[DPLQDWLRQV FDQ EH SHUIRUPHG LQ FDUGLR
SXOPRQDU\ FRPSURPLVHG QHZERUQV DQG LQIDQWV ZLWK UDGLDWLRQ GRVHV DV ORZ DV
P6YDQGGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\$SURWRFROXWLOLVLQJDVLQJOHVKRRWD[LDO
QRQ(&* WULJJHUHG 06&7 VFDQ LV PRVW IDYRXUDEOH7XEH YROWDJH RI N9
UHGXFHGUDGLDWLRQVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKRXWUHOHYDQWGHJUDGDWLRQRILPDJHTXDOLW\ZKHQ
VWXG\LQJWKHKHDUWDQGJUHDWWKRUDFLFYDVFXODWXUH
%
,QYLYRLPDJLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIDWUDQVFDWKHWHUKHDUWYDOYH
SURVWKHVLVZLWKPXOWLVOLFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
/0GH+HHU-+DEHWV-.OXLQ:3700DOL356WHOOD/$YDQ+HUZHUGHQ
53-%XGGH8WUHFKW1/ /0GHKHHU#XPFXWUHFKWQO
3XUSRVH7UDQVFDWKHWHUKHDUWYDOYH 7+9 SURVWKHVHVDUHH[SORUHGDVDQDOWHUQD
WLYHWRFRQYHQWLRQDODRUWLFYDOYHUHSODFHPHQW3RVWLPSODQWHFKRFDUGLRJUDSKLFIRO
ORZXSÀQGLQJVFDQEHFRPSOHPHQWHGE\PXOWLVOLFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 06&7
+RZHYHUOLWWOHLVNQRZQRQLPDJHTXDOLW\ ,4 RIWKHVHVWHQWHG7+9SURVWKHVHVWKDW
PD\EHKDPSHUHGE\PHWDOLQGXFHGDUWHIDFWV:HDVVHVVHGWKH&7LPDJHTXDOLW\RI
WKHFRPPRQO\LPSODQWHG(GZDUGV6DSLHQ7+9SURVWKHVLV ZLWKDFREDOWFKURPLXP
VWHQW LQSDWLHQWVDIWHUWUDQVFDWKHWHUDRUWLFYDOYHLPSODQWDWLRQ 7$9,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\WZRSDWLHQWVDIWHU7$9,XQGHUZHQWUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
(&*JDWHGFDUGLDF&7$RQDVOLFH&7VFDQQHU N9P$V $IWHU
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQWKUHHSHUSHQGLFXODUSODQHV7KHJHQHUDO,4DQG,4RIWKHVXSUD
SURVWKHWLF VXESURVWKHWLF SHULSURVWKHWLF LQWUDSURVWKHWLF DQG YDOYXODU UHJLRQV
ZDV VFRUHG RQ D IRXUSRLQW VFDOH QRQGLDJQRVWLF PRGHUDWH JRRG DQG
H[FHOOHQW LQWKHEHVWV\VWROLFDQGGLDVWROLFSKDVH
5HVXOWV7ZHQW\WZRSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWDFDUGLDF&7$ IHPDOHSDWLHQWVDJH
\HDUV 0HDQKHDUWUDWHGXULQJVFDQQLQJZDVEHDWVSHUPLQXWH7KH
JHQHUDO,4VFRUHZDVPRGHUDWH DQGJRRG GXULQJV\VWROHDQGPRGHU
DWH JRRG DQGH[FHOOHQW GXULQJGLDVWROH S $VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHV\VWROLFDQGGLDVWROLF,4LQWKHVXSUDSURVWKHWLF GLDVWROLF
EHWWHU S SHULSURVWKHWLF V\VWROLF EHWWHU S DQG LQWUDSURVWKHWLF
UHJLRQ V\VWROLFEHWWHUS H[LVWHG$VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHKHDUW
UDWHDQGJHQHUDOV\VWROLF,4ZDVSUHVHQW S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHFRPPRQO\LPSODQWHG(GZDUGV6DSLHQ7+9SURVWKHVLVDQGWKH
SHULSURVWKHWLFUHJLRQVFDQEHYLVXDOLVHGZLWKPRGHUDWHWRJRRGLPDJHTXDOLW\E\
06&7GHVSLWHWKHSUHVHQFHRIDFREDOWFKURPLXPVWHQWIUDPH
ERG\3XUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHHIIHFWRIFDUGLDFÁDWSDQHO&7RQ
[UD\LQGXFHG'1$GRXEOHVWUDQGEUHDNV '6%V LQEORRGO\PSKRF\WHVLQFKLOGUHQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %ORRG VDPSOHV ZHUH REWDLQHG IURP WKLUWHHQ FKLOGUHQ
EHIRUH DQG PLQXWHV DIWHU FDUGLDF ÁDWSDQHO &7 /\PSKRF\WHV ZHUH LVRODWHG
VWDLQHGDJDLQVWWKHSKRVSKRU\ODWHGKLVWRQHYDULDQW+$;DQGIRFLUHSUHVHQWLQJ
'6%VZHUHYLVXDOLVHGXVLQJÁXRUHVFHQFHPLFURVFRS\'RVHDUHDSURGXFW '$3
ZDVUHJLVWHUHGDVSURYLGHGE\WKHSDWLHQWSURWRFRO
5HVXOWV'$3UDQJHGIURPWRѥ*\PA PHGLDQ'6%FHOO '6%
OHYHOVUDQJHGIURPWRFHOO PHGLDQ'6%FHOO EHIRUHDQGIURP
WRFHOO PHGLDQ'6%FHOO DIWHUÁDWSDQHO&7WKHLQFUHDVHRI'6%VZDV
VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW S $FRUUHODWLRQZDVREWDLQHGEHWZHHQWKHLQGXFHG
'6%DQGWKH'$3 U
&RQFOXVLRQ,QHYHU\SDWLHQWDVLJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHRI'6%VZDVGHWHFWDEOHDIWHU
ÁDWSDQHO&7[UD\LQGXFHG'6%VGHSHQGRQWKHGHOLYHUHGGRVH,QFRQFOXVLRQ
LPPXQÁXRUHVFHQFHPLFURVFRS\LVDYDOLGPHWKRGWRGHWHFWGLVWLQFW'1$GDPDJHV
HYHQDIWHUUDWKHUORZGLDJQRVWLFGRVHVDQGWKHUHIRUHLWFDQEHXVHGDVDPHDVXUH
RIELRORJLFDOUDGLDWLRQHIIHFWV
%
7KHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIGXDOVRXUFH&7LQFRPSOH[FRQJHQLWDOKHDUW
GLVHDVH
6;2X'6/XR*03HQJ04LDQ*XDQJ]KRX&1 OKT[[K#FRP
3XUSRVH7RGLVFXVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOUHFRQVWUXFWHGWHFK
QLTXHZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWRIGXDOVRXUFH&7 '6&7 LQFRPSOH[FRQJHQLWDO
KHDUWGLVHDVH &&+'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KH06&7GDWDRISDWLHQWVZLWK&&+'FRQÀUPHGE\
VXUJHU\ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHG$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKWUDQVWKR
UDFLFHFKRFDUGLRJUDPV 77( DQGZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKFLQHDQJLRFDUGLRJUDPV
&$* EHIRUHVXUJHU\
5HVXOWV$WRWDORIFDUGLDFGHIRUPLWLHVZHUHIRXQGE\RSHUDWLRQ7KHDFFXUDF\
RI'6&777(DQG&$*LQGHWHFWLQJGHIRUPLWLHVZDVDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHZHUHLQWUDFDUGLDFGHIRUPLWLHVPLVVHGE\'6&7PLVVHG
E\77(DQGPLVVHGE\$*7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQFHGLIIHUHQFHLQGLDJQRVLV
DFFXUDF\ZLWKWKUHHPHWKRGV 3! 7KHUHZHUHH[WUDFDUGLDFDQRPDOLHV
7KHGHÀQLWHGLDJQRVLVUDWHRI06&777(DQG&$*IRUH[WUDFDUGLDFDQRPDOLHV
ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\06&7DQG&$*ZHUHVXSHULRUWR
77(LQWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIH[WUDFDUGLDFGHIRUPLWLHV 3 DQGWKHGLDJQRVLV
DFFXUDF\RI06&7DQG&$*VKRZHGQRGLIIHUHQFH 3! 06&7FRPELQHG
ZLWK77(FRXOGLQFUHDVHWKHGHÀQLWHGLDJQRVLVUDWHWR
&RQFOXVLRQ 06&7 PD\ EH XVHG WR FOHDUO\ GLVSOD\ WKH SDWKRORJLF DQDWRP\ RI
&&+' ZKLFK LV VXSHULRU WR77( UHPDUNDEO\ LQ WKH GLDJQRVLV RI H[WUDFDUGLDF
DQRPDOLHV 7KHUHIRUH DV D QRQLQYDVLYH WHFKQLTXH 06&7 KDV D YHU\ KLJKHU
GLDJQRVWLFYDOXHLQ&&+'
%
;UD\LQGXFHG'1$GRXEOHVWUDQGEUHDNVLQO\PSKRF\WHVRIFKLOGUHQ
XQGHUJRLQJFDUGLDFÁDWSDQHO&7DQGDQJLRJUDSK\
0%UDQG0*ORHFNOHU06RPPHU&(QJHUW08GHU0$.XHIQHU
(UODQJHQ'( PLFKDHOEUDQG#XNHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH)ODWSDQHO&7 '\QD&7 HQDEOHV&7OLNHFURVVVHFWLRQDOLPDJLQJE\
FUHDWLQJ'VRIWWLVVXHGDWDVHWVE\URWDWLRQRIWKHGHWHFWRUDURXQGWKHSDWLHQWҋV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
)ULGD\0DUFK
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP'
&KHVW
66
&73$GXDOHQHUJ\DQGGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
7)UDXHQIHOGHU=XULFK&+
%*KD\H%UXVVHOV%(
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIGXDOHQHUJ\&7OXQJSHUIXVLRQPDSVDFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWK94VFDQDQGOXQJSDUHQFK\PDOFKDQJHV
0/HIHUH0'HPHWHU)'H.H\]HU-&RROHQ-9HUVFKDNHOHQ:'H:HYHU
/HXYHQ%( PDWKLHXOHIHUH#X]OHXYHQEH
3XUSRVH 'XDO HQHUJ\ FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ '(&7 SHUIXVLRQPDSV FDQ EH
XVHG WR YLVXDOLVH SXOPRQDU\ SHUIXVLRQ LQ WKH GLDJQRVWLF ZRUNXS RI SXOPRQDU\
HPEROLVP 3( DQGRWKHUSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHV6WXG\SXUSRVHDUH WRREVHUYH
LQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\LQSHUIXVLRQPDSUHDGLQJ WRFRPSDUHSHUIXVLRQPDSV
ZLWK 94 VFDQ WR FRUUHODWH SHUIXVLRQGHIHFWV 3' ZLWK OXQJSDUHQFK\PDO
FKDQJHVRQ'(&7LPDJHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\VL[SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW'(&7DQJLRJUDSK\DQG
94VFDQWRH[FOXGH3('(&7SHUIXVLRQPDSVZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\WZRUDGLROR
JLVWV ,RGLQH GLVWULEXWLRQ SDWWHUQV ZHUH UDWHG DV KRPRJHQHRXV SHUIXVLRQ +3
ZHGJHVKDSHGGHIHFW :6' SDWFK\GHIHFW 3D' FLUFXPVFULEHGGHIHFW &' RU
DUWHIDFW'XDOHQHUJ\SHUIXVLRQÀQGLQJVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWK&7ÀQGLQJV QRUPDO
HPSK\VHPDPRVDLFSHUIXVLRQJURXQGJODVVRSDFLWLHV **2 DQGFRQVROLGDWLRQ
DQG94ÀQGLQJV QRUPDOSHUIXVLRQGHIHFW 3' ZLWKDQGZLWKRXWYHQWLODWLRQGHIHFW
9' LQSHUVHJPHQWDQDO\VHV
5HVXOWV 7KHUH ZDV D JRRG LQWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW UHDGLQJ SHUIXVLRQPDSV
NDSSD 3HUIXVLRQPDSVVKRZHG+3:6'3D'&'DUWHIDFWVLQ
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\94VKRZHG3' ZLWKRXW
DQGZLWK9' IRU+33' DOOZLWKRXW9' IRU:6'3'
ZLWKRXWDQGZLWK9' IRU3D'DQG3' ZLWKRXWDQGZLWK
9' IRU&'1RUPDOOXQJVKRZHG+3DQG3D'(PSK\VHPDWRXV
OXQJVKRZHG3D'DQG+30RVDLFSHUIXVLRQVKRZHG+3DQG
3D' **2 VKRZHG +3 DQG 3D' &RQVROLGDWLRQ VKRZHG
+3RU&'
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHLVDJRRGLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWLQUHDGLQJ'(&7SHUIXVLRQ
PDSV:6'FRUUHVSRQGZLWKUHDOSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWV3D'DQG&'FDQFRUUHVSRQG
ZLWK SHUIXVLRQ GHIHFWV KRZHYHU WKH\ DUH PRUH OLNHO\ FRUUHVSRQGLQJ ZLWK RWKHU
SDUHQFK\PDODEQRUPDOLWLHV
%
8VHIXOQHVVRIYDVFXODULRGLQHGLVWULEXWLRQPDSVLQWKHGLDJQRVLVRI
SXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
-,(%RVFR+67HK6LQJDSRUH6*
ERVFRMHURPHLH#DOH[DQGUDKHDOWKFRPVJ
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHYDOXHRIYDVFXODULRGLQHPDSV 9,' PDSVLQGXDOHQHUJ\
&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDPIRUGHWHFWLRQRISXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QHKXQGUHGDQGWZHQW\VL[FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWK
VXVSHFWHG3(XQGHUZHQW&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &73$ ZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\&7
'(&7 6LHPHQV6RPDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ)ODVK LQRXU'HSDUWPHQWVLQFH'HFHPEHU
ZHUH HYDOXDWHG 9,' PDSV ZHUH REWDLQHG IRU DOO SDWLHQWV XVLQJ VWDQGDUG
6LHPHQVVRIWZDUH&7LPDJHVZHUHDVVHVVHGDQGFRPSDUHGIRUOXQJSDWKRORJ\
DQJLRJUDSKLFÀQGLQJVDQG9,'
5HVXOWV7KLUW\WKUHHRISDWLHQWVKDG3(EDVHGRQWKH&73$ÀQGLQJV2IWKHVH
ZHUHLQLWLDOO\UHSRUWHGDVQRUPDOEXWVKRZHGHYLGHQFHRIVHJPHQWDOVXEVHJPHQ
WDOWKURPELDIWHUDQJLRJUDSKLFLPDJHVZHUHUHYLHZHGZKHQ9,'LPDJHVUHYHDOHG
:3':3'ZDVDEVHQFHLQSDWLHQWVZKRKDG3(RQ&73$8QGHUO\LQJGLIIXVH
OXQJSDWKRORJ\ZDVSUHVHQWLQWKHVHSDWLHQWVZKLFKSUREDEO\REVFXUHGWKH:3'
1LQHSDWLHQWVVKRZHG:3'EXWQHJDWLYH&73$7KUHHKDGH[WHQVLYHSDUHQFK\PD
DEQRUPDOLW\KDGSDXFLW\RISXOPRQDU\YHVVHOVLQWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJDUHDV,QWKH
UHPDLQLQJQRREYLRXVSDUHQFK\PDRUYDVFXODUDEQRUPDOLWLHVZHUHQRWHG2Q
SHUSDWLHQWEDVLVSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVVHQVLWLYLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ9,'DQDO\VLVPDGHSRVVLEOHE\'(&7ZKHQXVHGZLWKWKHDQJLRJUDSKLF
LPDJHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHVWKHDFFXUDF\RI3(GHWHFWLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
3VHXGRHPEROLFSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVLQ&23'HYDOXDWLRQZLWKGXDO
HQHUJ\&7DQJLRJUDSK\ '(&7 LQSDWLHQWV
)3RQWDQD&&KDOD\HU-%)DLYUH&)0XUSK\05pP\-DUGLQ-5HP\
/LOOH)5 IUDQFRLVSRQWDQD#FKUXOLOOHIU
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHIUHTXHQF\RISVHXGRHPEROLFSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVVHFRQG
DU\WRWKHXQGHUO\LQJEURQFKRSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHLQ&23'SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKVWDEOH&23'DQGQRKLVWRU\RIDFXWH
DQGRUFKURQLFSXOPRQDU\YDVFXODUGLVHDVHXQGHUZHQW'(&7ZLWKUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
RIGLDJQRVWLFDQGSHUIXVLRQVFDQV7KLVYROXPHWULFDFTXLVLWLRQDWGHHSLQVSLUDWLRQ
ZDV FRPSOHWHG E\ VHTXHQWLDO H[SLUDWRU\ VFDQV 7ZR UDGLRORJLVWV HYDOXDWHG E\
FRQVHQVXV WKHSUHVHQFHRISVHXGRHPEROLFSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWV LHWULDQJXODU
SOHXUDOEDVHGDQGVKDUSO\PDUJLQDWHGK\SRDWWHQXDWHGDUHDV RQOXQJSHUIXVLRQ
VFDQV ZLWKV\VWHPDWLFGHSLFWLRQRIPRUSKRORJLFDOFKDQJHVLQWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ
DUHDVRQLQVSLUDWRU\DQGH[SLUDWRU\GLDJQRVWLFLPDJHV
5HVXOWV$ WRWDO RI SVHXGRHPEROLF SHUIXVLRQ GHIHFWV ZHUH GHSLFWHG LQ
SDWLHQWV ZLWK D DSUHGRPLQDQWGLVWULEXWLRQLQWKHORZHUOREHV
E REVHUYHGZLWKWKHFRQFXUUHQWSUHVHQFHRIVPDOODLUZD\VGLVHDVHDORQH
HPSK\VHPDWRXVOHVLRQVDORQH DYDULDEOHDVVRFLD
WLRQRIVPDOODLUZD\VGLVHDVHDQGHPSK\VHPD Q RUWKHH[FOXVLYHÀQGLQJ
RIFHQWUDODLUZD\VDEQRUPDOLWLHV Q LQWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJDQDWRPLFDO]RQHV
7KH&7IHDWXUHVRIVPDOODLUZD\VGLVHDVHGHSLFWHGLQWKHDUHDVRISVHXGRHPEROLF
SHUIXVLRQ GHIHFWV LQFOXGHG DLU WUDSSLQJ IRFDO K\SRDWWHQXDWHG
DUHD PXFRLGLPSDFWLRQV DQGRUEURQFKLROHFWDVLV
1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGLQWKHIUHTXHQF\RI
SVHXGRHPEROLFGHIHFWVEHWZHHQWKH&7SKHQRW\SHVRI&23' S
&RQFOXVLRQ3VHXGRHPEROLFSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGLQRI&23'
SDWLHQWVPDLQO\VHHQLQDVVRFLDWLRQZLWK&7IHDWXUHVRIVPDOODLUZD\VGLVHDVH
%
)UHTXHQF\DQGRULJLQRIOXQJSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVRQGXDOHQHUJ\
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ '(&7 LQDQXQVHOHFWHGSDWLHQWJURXS
$(2GLQN05RVVLXV:9HUPHXOH&06FKDHIHU3URNRS,+DUWPDQQ
5RWWHUGDP1/$PHUVIRRUW1/
3XUSRVH/XQJSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVVHHQRQ'(&7DUHQRWQHFHVVDULO\FDXVHGE\
DFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP $3( DQGWKHUHIRUHPD\FDXVHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQGLIÀFXOWLHV
3XUSRVHRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVIUHTXHQF\DQGXQGHUO\LQJFDXVHRISHUIXVLRQ
GHIHFWVRQ'(&7LQDQXQVHOHFWHGSDWLHQWJURXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\JURXSFRQVLVWHGRIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV
ZKRXQGHUZHQW'(&7IRUVXVSHFWHG$3(EHWZHHQ0D\DQG)HEUXDU\
6WDWHRIWKHDUWSURWRFROVZHUHXVHGZLWKDVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ'(&7VFDQQHU$OO
VFDQVZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLVHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWVZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHSUHV
HQFHPRUSKRORJ\DQGORFDWLRQRISHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVDQGWRWKHSUHVHQFHDQGW\SH
RI DUWHIDFWV )LQGLQJV ZHUH FRUUHODWHG ZLWK WKH ÀQGLQJV DW OXQJ ZLQGRZ VHWWLQJV
DQGWKH&7$ÀQGLQJV
5HVXOWV,Q RIWKHLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVSHUIXVLRQPDSVZHUHDYDLO
DEOHIRUHYDOXDWLRQ7ZHQW\WKUHHSDWLHQWV ZHUHSRVLWLYHIRU$3(RIZKRP
KDGZHGJHVKDSHGSHUIXVLRQ,QRIWKHSDWLHQWV XQGHUO\LQJOXQJ
GLVHDVHVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGFDXVLQJSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWV7KHVHLQFOXGHGHPSK\VHPD
SOHXUDOÁXLGZLWKFRPSUHVVLRQDWHOHFWDVLVDQGRUSQHXPRQLFFRQVROLGDWLRQV
'(&7SHUIXVLRQPDSV VKRZHGVRPHW\SHRISHUIXVLRQGHIHFWV
FDXVHGE\DUWHIDFWVVXFKDVEHDPKDUGHQLQJRUSXOVDWLRQDUWHIDFWVQRQHRIWKHP
ZHUHIRXQGWRLQWHUIHUHZLWKWKHGLDJQRVLV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QDQXQVHOHFWHGVWXG\JURXSWKHPDMRULW\RISDWLHQWVVKRZSHUIXVLRQ
GHIHFWVRQ'(&7ZKLFKDUHQRWFDXVHGE\$3(DQGFRUUHFWLQWHUSUHWDWLRQUHTXLUHV
FORVHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKOXQJSDUHQFK\PDOÀQGLQJVDQG&7$ÀQGLQJV
%
,PSDFWRILRGLQHGHOLYHU\UDWHZLWKYDU\LQJÁRZUDWHVRQGXDOHQHUJ\
&7LPDJHTXDOLW\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
-+DQVPDQQ&)LQN00H\HU3$SIDOWUHU626FK|QEHUJ7+HQ]OHU
0DQQKHLP'( MDQKDQVPDQQ#PHGPDXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHGLIIHUHQWFRQWUDVWPDWHULDOLQMHFWLRQSURWRFROV
IRUGXDOHQHUJ\&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ '(&73$ LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG
SXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP 3(
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW &73$ IRU
H[FOXVLRQRI3(ZHUHUDQGRPLVHGLQWRGLIIHUHQWFRQWUDVWPDWHULDO &0 LQMHFWLRQ
SURWRFROVGHÀQHGE\GLIIHUHQWLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVDQGLRGLQHGHOLYHU\UDWHV ,'5
$PO,RSURPLGHP/V ,'5J,V %PO,RSURPLGHDWP/V
,'5J,V &PO,RSURPLGHDWP/V ,'5J,V 'PO,RSUR
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
PLGHDWP/V ,'5J,V $WWHQXDWLRQYDOXHVZHUHPHDVXUHGRQ´YLUWXDOµ
N9LPDJHVLQWKHLQÁRZWUDFW VXEFODYLDQYHLQVXSHULRUYHQDFDYDULJKWDWULXP
WDUJHWWUDFW ULJKWYHQWULFOHSXOPRQDU\WUXQNSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHV DQGRXWÁRZWUDFW
OHIWDWULXPOHIWYHQWULFOHDVFHQGLQJDRUWD DQGFRPSDUHGXVLQJWKH:LOFR[RQUDQN
VXPWHVW6XEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\RI´YLUWXDOµN9LPDJHVDQGFDOFXODWHGLRGLQH
SHUIXVLRQPDSVZDVDVVHVVHGE\WZRUHDGHUV SRLQW/LNHUWVFDOHѣVWDWLVWLFV
5HVXOWV7DUJHWWUDFWDWWHQXDWLRQZDVKLJKHVWIRUSURWRFRO$ZLWK+RXQVÀHOG
8QLWV +8 KLJKO\FRQFHQWUDWHG&0KLJK,'5 LIFRPSDUHGWRDOORWKHUSURWRFROV
DOOS 1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQSURWRFRO%
+8 SURWRFRO& +8 DQG' +8 ,PDJHTXDOLW\RISURWRFRO
$ZDVUDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUFRPSDUHGWRDOORWKHUSURWRFROVZLWKDPHGLDQVFRUH
RI S ,QWHUUHDGHUDJUHHPHQWZDVJRRGZLWKDNDSSDRI
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKO\FRQFHQWUDWHGLRGLQDWHGFRQWUDVWPDWHULDOLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWK
KLJKÁRZUDWHVSURYLGHVLPSURYHGGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGKDVWKHKLJKHVW
WDUJHWWUDFWDWWHQXDWLRQIRUD'(&73$SURWRFRO
%
3XOPRQDU\HPEROLVPDWGXDOVRXUFH&7DQJLRJUDSK\GRZHRYHUGRVH"
52FD*7DUGDJXLOD&'HOJDGR&7ULQGDG$)HUQDQGH]'HO9DOOH
)7DUGDJXLOD0RQWHUR9LJR(6
%
N9S0'&7WRGLDJQRVHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVPZLWKPLQLPLVHG
UDGLDWLRQGRVH
81\PDQ3%MRUNGDKO%*ROGPDQ0/2OVVRQ6:HWWHPDUN
7UHOOHERUJ6(0DOP|6( XOIQ\PDQ#EUHGEDQGQHW
3XUSRVH7R FRPSDUH UDGLDWLRQ GRVH DQG LPDJH TXDOLW\ RI N9S PXOWLURZ
GHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7 WRGLDJQRVHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP 3(
ZLWKWKDWRIDQGN9SZLWKDOORWKHUVFDQQLQJSDUDPHWHUVEHLQJHTXDOZKLOH
LQVWHDGRIPJ,NJZHUHXVHGDWN9SWRFRPSHQVDWHIRUWKHGHFUHDVHG
WKHRUHWLFDOFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLRQ &15
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVZLWKDQHVWLPDWHG*)5P/PLQXQGHUZHQW
PD[LPXPZHLJKWNJ DQGN9S SDWLHQWVLQHDFKJURXS 0'&7
XVLQJWKHVDPHVFDQQHUDQG4XDOLW\UHIHUHQFHHIIHFWLYHP$V3XOPRQDU\
DUWHU\DWWHQXDWLRQLPDJHQRLVH VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ DQG&15 SURYLGLQJDFORW
RI+8 ZHUHHYDOXDWHG6XEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHG&RPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\GRVHLQGH[ &7',YRO DQGGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW '/3 ZHUHUHFRUGHG
DQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHFDOFXODWHGEDVHGRQSXEOLVKHGFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUV
5HVXOWV0HGLDQSDWLHQWZHLJKWDQG%0,DWN9SZHUHNJDQG
NJP0HGLDQSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\DWWHQXDWLRQLPDJHQRLVH&15&7',YRO
'/3DQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHDWN9SZHUH+8+8
P*\P*\ FPDQGP6Y$WN9S
DOOH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHDGHTXDWHFODVVLÀHGDVH[FHOOHQWFRPSDUHGZLWK
DQGDWDQGN9S
&RQFOXVLRQ5DGLDWLRQGRVHWRSDWLHQWVPD\EHGHFUHDVHGWRDERXWRQHWKLUGE\
UHGXFLQJ[UD\WXEHSRWHQWLDOIURPWRN9SZLWKRXWGHWHULRUDWLRQRIGLDJQRV
WLFLPDJHTXDOLW\LIWKHGHFUHDVHG&15LVFRPSHQVDWHGZLWKDVOLJKWO\LQFUHDVHG
LRGLQHGRVH7KHSURWRFROPD\EHRIVSHFLDOEHQHÀWLQ\RXQJLQGLYLGXDOVNJ
ZLWKDGHTXDWH*)5
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
'RVHUHGXFWLRQLQ&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\LVLWVDIHWROLPLWVFDQ
FRYHUDJH"
-+DOSHULQ-5DMFKJRW'2GHGUD.+DQ\0+DVKHPL163DXO
7RURQWR21&$ MKDOSHULQ#TPHGFD
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHLIVFDQOHQJWKUHVWULFWLRQGXULQJ&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
&73$ UHVXOWVLQQRQGHWHFWLRQRIVLJQLÀFDQWÀQGLQJV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HWURVSHFWLYHUHYLHZVRIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV)
PHDQDJH\ KDYLQJ&73$IURPWR7ZRREVHUYHUVUHYLHZHG
DOOLPDJHVLQHDFKVWXG\ IXOOVFDQ DQGWKHQRQO\LPDJHVVXSHULRUWRWKHDRUWLF
DUFKDQGLQIHULRUWRWKHKHDUW OLPLWHGVFDQ WRGHWHFWUDGLRORJLFDODEQRUPDOLWLHV,W
ZDVGHWHUPLQHGZKHWKHUWKHDEQRUPDOLWLHVZRXOGEHPLVVHGRQOLPLWHGVFDQVDQG
LIWKH\ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWLQGHWHUPLQDWHRULQVLJQLÀFDQWEDVHGRQLPDJLQJIHDWXUHV
FKDUWUHYLHZDQGSUHYLRXVLPDJLQJ'HGLFDWHGRQOLQHVRIWZDUH 5DGLPHWULFV,QF
7RURQWR FDOFXODWHGSDWLHQWDQGRUJDQVSHFLÀFGRVHIRUIXOODQGOLPLWHGVFDQV
5HVXOWV 0HDQ VFDQ OHQJWK IXOO PP OLPLWHG PP DYHUDJH FKDQJH
PP S SDWLHQWVKDGDEQRUPDOLWLHVPLVVHGRQOLPLWHG
&73$ ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQW EXW RQO\ ZHUH QHZ 2YHUDOO
SDWLHQWV KDG QHZ VLJQLÀFDQW ÀQGLQJV PLVVHG UHQDO FDUFLQRPD
DQGSHULWRQHDOGLVHDVH /LPLWHGVFDQ&73$SURGXFHVSDWLHQWUDGLDWLRQGRVH
UHGXFWLRQRIIURPWRP6Y ,&53 DQGRUJDQGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
!NLGQH\V FRORQ WK\URLG !WHVWLFOHV
VNLQ VPDOOLQWHVWLQH !VSOHHQ VWRPDFK
RHVRSKDJXV UHGPDUURZ EUDLQ H\HOHQV DQG
EUHDVWV
&RQFOXVLRQ/LPLWHGVFDQOHQJWK&73$LVDVDIHSURFHGXUHLQRISDWLHQWV
UHVXOWVLQUHGXFWLRQLQSDWLHQWGRVHDQGVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQVLQRUJDQGRVH
WRUDGLRVHQVLWLYHWLVVXHV
%
5DZGDWDEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRUFKHVWFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ &7 DQJLRJUDSK\FRPSDULVRQRIORZGRVHORZ
N9LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ&7DQGVWDQGDUGGRVHÀOWHUHGEDFN
SURMHFWLRQ&7LQSDWLHQWV
-3DJQLH])3RQWDQD-%)DLYUH7)ORKU05pP\-DUGLQ-5HP\/LOOH)5
PDUWLQHUHP\#FKUXOLOOHIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHLPDJHQRLVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\RIDUDZGDWDEDVHGLWHUD
WLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHLQORZN9SXOPRQDU\&7DQJLRJUDPVLQFRPSDULVRQ
ZLWKVWDQGDUGGRVHÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 &7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVUHIHUUHGIRUDIROORZXSFKHVW&7
DQJLRJUDSKLFH[DPLQDWLRQXQGHUZHQWDORZGRVH&7H[DPLQDWLRQ LH7VFDQ
LQ VLPLODU WHFKQLFDO FRQGLWLRQV WRWKRVH RIWKHLQLWLDO H[DPLQDWLRQ LH7VFDQ
H[FHSWIRU D WKHNLORYROWDJHVHOHFWLRQUHGXFHGE\N9ZLWKDGDSWDWLRQRIWKH
PLOOLDPSHUDJHWRHQVXUHDUHGXFWLRQRIWKH&7',DQG E WKHUHSODFHPHQWRI
UHJXODU)%3E\LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV 6$),5(
5HVXOWV'HVSLWHDPHDQGHFUHDVHRILQWKH'/3 7P*\FP7
P*\FP 7VFDQVVKRZHG D VLJQLÀFDQWO\OHVVREMHFWLYHQRLVHPHDVXUHG
DW WKH OHYHO RI WKH WUDFKHD RQ PHGLDVWLQDO 7 7
S DQGOXQJLPDJHV 77 S E
VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUVLJQDOWRQRLVH 77 DQGFRQWUDVW
WRQRLVH 77 UDWLRV S F DVLPLODUYLVXDO
SHUFHSWLRQRIQRLVHRQPHGLDVWLQDO S DQGOXQJLPDJHV S PDLQO\
UDWHGDVPRGHUDWHDQG G DVLPLODURYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\UDWHGDVH[FHOOHQWLQ
YV7 DQGJRRGLQ 7 RI&7
H[DPLQDWLRQV S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUDZGDWDEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHDOORZHGEHWWHU
REMHFWLYHDQGVLPLODUVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\RIORZNLORYROWDJH&7DQJLRJUDPV
FRPSDUHGWRVWDQGDUGGRVH)%3&7H[DPLQDWLRQV
%
,PDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQIRUKLJKUHVROXWLRQ&7
SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\XVLQJN9SDQGDXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUHFRQWURO
6$OUDMKL6$OKXPD\\G+.DVKDQL'2GHGUD-%OREHO163DXO
7RURQWR21&$=RHWHUPHHU1/ 6XODLPDQ$OUDMKL#XKQRQFD
3XUSRVH 7R DQDO\VH SDWLHQW H[SRVXUH DQG LPDJH TXDOLW\ ,4 XQLIRUPLW\ IRU
KLJKUHVROXWLRQ PP N9S&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &73$ FRPSDULQJ
FRQVWDQWP$VWRDXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUHFRQWURO $(& YDULDEOHP$VZLWKHTXLYDOHQW
LPDJHQRLVH ,1
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZR UHDGHUV LQGHSHQGHQWO\ PHDVXUHG ,1 5
5 SXOPRQDU\DUWHU\5 DRUWLFDUFK5 SUR[LPDOGHVFHQGLQJDRUWD5 GLVWDO
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHRIGXDOVRXUFHPXOWLGHFWRU&7
'6&7 ZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7 0'&7 LQSXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRISXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP 3(
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHORFDOHWKLFVFRPPLWWHHDSSURYHGWKLVVWXG\:HUHW
URVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGSDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOVXVSLFLRQRISXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
3( XQGHUZHQW'6&7DQGXQGHUZHQW0'&7(IIHFWLYHGRVHVZHUH
FRPSDUHGZLWKHVWLPDWHVEDVHGRQWKHPRVWFRPPRQO\XVHGPHWKRGLQFOLQLFDO
OLWHUDWXUHPXOWLSO\LQJGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW '/3 E\DJHQHUDOFRQYHUVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
P6YÃP*\"ÃFP" GHWHUPLQHGIURP0RQWH&DUORVLPXODWLRQVRIFKHVW&7
5HVXOWV 7KH WZR JURXSV PDWFKHG ZHOO IRU FOLQLFDO FKDUDFWHULVWLFV WKHUH ZHUH
LQFOXGHGPHQDQGZRPHQZLWKDQDYHUDJHRIDJHRI\HDUV 7KH
SHUFHQWDJHRISDWLHQWVZLWK3(GLDJQRVLVZDVIRUHDFKJURXS0HDQHIIHF
WLYHGRVHVZLWK'6&7DQG0'&7ZHUHP6YDQGP6Y
UHVSHFWLYHO\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ 0HDQ HIIHFWLYH GRVHV GR QRW LQFUHDVH XVLQJ D GRXEOH VRXUFH &7
SURWRFROFRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7LQWKH3(VWXGLHV'HVSLWH
WKHZLGHVSUHDGLGHDWKDWGRXEOHVRXUFHVWXGLHVFRXOGLQFUHDVHUDGLDWLRQGRVHZH
IRXQGWKHUHLVQRLQFUHDVHEXWDVOLJKWUHGXFWLRQRIPHDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHZLWKGXDO
HQHUJ\ WHFKQLTXH$FFRUGLQJ WR WKH DGGLWLRQDO LQIRUPDWLRQ SURYLGHG IRU WKH GXDO
VRXUFHWHFKQLTXHV LRGLQHPDSVDQGOXQJSHUIXVLRQ ZHUHFRPPHQGXVLQJWKLV
PHWKRGURXWLQHO\LIDYDLODEOH
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
WKRUDFLFDRUWD*SFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV DJH\) VFDQQHGXVLQJ
N9SDQGP$V)RUHDFKSDWLHQWPHDQ,1ZDVDYHUDJHGIRUERWKUHDGHUV
DWHDFK52,DQGVXEVHTXHQWO\DYHUDJHGRYHUDOOSDWLHQWVIRU55*SDYHUDJHG
,1 +8*SVXEVHTXHQWSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\) KDG&73$
ZLWKN9SDQG$(&GHWHUPLQHGYDULDEOHP$VZLWKPDWFKHGWDUJHW,1 +8
PHDVXUHPHQWVWHVWHGIRUQRUPDOGLVWULEXWLRQ .ROPRJRURY6PLUQRYWHVW DQG
UHDGHUDJUHHPHQWV SDLUHG:LOFR[RQ7HVW ,155DQGSDWLHQW'/3 P*\ FP
ZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQ*SDQG*SXVLQJWKH0DQQ:KLWQH\WHVWIRU,1DJUHH
PHQWDQG%DUOHWWWHVWIRUVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ ѫ DJUHHPHQWRI,1
5HVXOWV0HDQѫERG\ZHLJKW>NJ@*S*S,1>+8@
*S5 5 5 5 *S5
5 5 5 '/3>P*\ FP@*SDQG
*S1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQSDWLHQWERG\ZHLJKW S DQG
'/3 S LQLQWHUUHDGHUUHVXOWVRI,1IRU55 S RULQ,1IRU
55 DOOS! 6LJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQѫVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ S
IRU55ZLWKѫUHGXFWLRQRIDYHUDJHG55YDOXHVLQ*S
&RQFOXVLRQ +LJKUHVROXWLRQ N9S &73$ XVLQJ$(& SURYLGHV PRUH XQLIRUP
LPDJHTXDOLW\DGDSWHGWRSDWLHQWERG\KDELWXVDFURVVWKHHQWLUHFKHVWZLWK
UHGXFWLRQLQVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ ѫ RILPDJHQRLVHFRPSDUHGZLWKDÀ[HGP$V
WHFKQLTXHDWHTXLYDOHQWSDWLHQWH[SRVXUH
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
&7DQG05JXLGHGLQWHUYHQWLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
3$OPHLGD&RLPEUD37
6.RV%DVOH&+
%
$FFXUDF\RI&7JXLGDQFHIRUOXPEDUIDFHWEORFNV
0:HLQLQJHU-0LOOV=5XPEROGW:+XGD$&LDQIRQL&KDUOHVWRQ6&86
ZHLQLQJH#PXVFHGX
3XUSRVH/XPEDUIDFHWMRLQWEORFNV )-% UHTXLUHSUHFLVHLQWUDDUWLFXODULQMHFWLRQIRU
GLDJQRVWLFVSHFLÀFLW\HIÀFDF\2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRDVVHVVWKHSURFHGXUDOVXFFHVV
SURÀOHRI)-%XQGHU&7JXLGDQFHDQGWRHVWLPDWHSHULSURFHGXUDOUDGLDWLRQGRVHV
0HWKRGV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGFOLQLFDOO\LQGLFDWHG)-%SURFHGXUHVLQ
FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PHQPHDQDJH\HDUVSURFHGXUHVWDUJHWHG
IDFHWMRLQWV 8QGHU&7JXLGDQFHDSRVWHULRUSDUDYHUWHEUDODFFHVVZDVXVHG$SUH
SURFHGXUHORFDOLVLQJVFDQZDVIROORZHGE\LQWHUPLWWHQWORZGRVH N9P$V
JXLGDQFHVFDQV VOLFHVPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVVRYHUODSPPFRYHUDJH
3UHVHQFH RI SRVWHULRU IDFHW RVWHRSK\WHV RYHUO\LQJ D GLUHFW MRLQW DFFHVV QHHGOH
GLUHFWLRQIRUMRLQWDFFHVV REOLTXHLSVLODWHUDOVWUDLJKWLVSLODWHUDOREOLTXHFRQWUDODW
HUDO DQGQXPEHURI&7JXLGDQFHVFDQVQHHGHGIRUÀQDOQHHGOHSODFHPHQWDQG
GRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW '/3 ZHUHUHFRUGHG,QWUDDUWLFXODUQHHGOHSODFHPHQWZDV
FRQÀUPHGE\MRLQWVSDFHFRQWUDVWRSDFLÀFDWLRQ
5HVXOWV)-%ZHUHWHFKQLFDOO\VXFFHVVIXOLQFDVHV$FFHVVVLGHDQGGLUHFWLRQ
ZHUHDVIROORZVLSVLODWHUDO VWUDLJKWREOLTXH FRQWUDODWHUDOREOLTXH
)-%ZHUHDW//DW/6DW//DQGDW//IDFHW
MRLQWVSUHVHQWHGSRVWHULRURVWHRSK\WHV$YHUDJHQXPEHURIJXLGLQJVFDQVQHHGHG
WRREWDLQÀQDOQHHGOHSRVLWLRQZDV$YHUDJH'/3SHU)-%ZDVHVWLPDWHGDW
P*\FPFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHRIP6Y
&RQFOXVLRQ)-%XVLQJ&7JXLGDQFHLVVDIHDQGUDSLGHQVXUHVUHOLDEOHQHHGOH
JXLGDQFHLQGLYLGXDOWRHDFKIDFHWMRLQWҋVDQDWRP\DQGDOORZVSUHFLVHLQWUDDUWLFXODU
LQMHFWLRQZLWKH[WUHPHO\KLJKSURFHGXUDODFFXUDF\7KHHIIHFWLYHGRVHLVFRPSDUDEOH
WRWKDWRIRQHPLQXWHRIÁXRURVFRS\JXLGDQFH
%
%
&7ÁXRURVFRS\JXLGHGSHUFXWDQHRXVYHUWHEURSODVW\LQVSLQDO
PDOLJQDQF\WHFKQLFDOUHVXOWV300$OHDNDJHVDQGFRPSOLFDWLRQVLQ
SDWLHQWV
&*7UXPP7.+HOPEHUJHU7)-DNREV&-=HFK56WDKO
7$6DQGQHU303DSURWWND0)5HLVHU57+RIIPDQQ0XQLFK'(
'UHVGHQ'( FKULVWRSKWUXPP#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7R UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWH WKH LQFLGHQFH DQG FOLQLFDO LPSDFW RI ORFDO
SRO\PHWK\OPHWKDFU\ODWHOHDNVDQGSXOPRQDU\FHPHQWHPEROLVPV 3&( RFFXUULQJ
XQGHU&7ÁXRURVFRS\JXLGHGYHUWHEURSODVW\RIPDOLJQDQWYHUWHEUDOFRPSUHVVLRQ
IUDFWXUHV 9&) DQGRVWHRO\VHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )URP WR FDQFHU SDWLHQWV
ZRPHQPHQDJH ZLWKSDLQIXO9&)DQGVSLQDORVWHRO\VHVXQGHUZHQW
YHUWHEURSODVW\YHUWHEUDHZHUHWUHDWHGLQVHVVLRQVXQGHU&7ÁXRURVFRS\
JXLGDQFH N9P$VLQJOHVOLFHDQGURZ&7 2VWHRO\WLF
LQYROYHPHQW LH QRQH RU RI WKH YHUWHEUDO FURVV
VHFWLRQDODUHDDQGWKHSRVWHULRUZDOOZHUHDVVHVVHGLQWKHSUHYHUWHEURSODVW\&7
/RFDO 300$ OHDNV ZHUH DQDO\VHG XVLQJ WKH SRVWYHUWHEURSODVW\ &7 3UHVHQFH
DQGORFDWLRQRI3&(ZHUHHYDOXDWHGLQDOOSDWLHQWVKDYLQJXQGHUJRQHFRQYHQWLRQDO
UDGLRJUDSK\ &5Q RU&7 Q RIWKHFKHVWDIWHUYHUWHEURSODVW\GXHWRWKHLU
XQGHUO\LQJWXPRXUGLVHDVH3DWLHQWFKDUWVZHUHUHYLHZHGUHJDUGLQJDGYHUVHHYHQWV
UHODWHGWRYHUWHEURSODVW\
5HVXOWVDQGRIWUHDWHGYHUWHEUDHVKRZHGPRUHWKDQRV
WHRO\WLFLQYROYHPHQWRIWKHYHUWHEUDOFURVVVHFWLRQDODUHDDQGWKHSRVWHULRUZDOO
UHVSHFWLYHO\/RFDO300$OHDNDJHUDWHZDV RIYHUWHEUDH 3&(
VHJPHQWDO Q FHQWUDO Q ZHUH VHHQ DIWHU RI WKH SURFHGXUHV ZLWK
IROORZXSLPDJLQJRIWKHFKHVW1RPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVRFFXUUHGZLWKLQDGD\
SHULRGDIWHUYHUWHEURSODVW\
&RQFOXVLRQ9HUWHEURSODVW\RIVSLQDOPDOLJQDQF\FDQEHVDIHO\SHUIRUPHGXQGHU
&7ÁXRURVFRS\JXLGDQFHHYHQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXEVWDQWLDORVWHRO\WLFLQYROYHPHQW
,QRXUSDWLHQWFROOHFWLYHORFDO300$OHDNVDQG3&(YLVXDOLVHGLQSRVWSURFHGXUDO
UDGLRJUDSK\DQG&7LPDJHVKDGQRFOLQLFDOLPSDFW
([WUDSOHXUDOSDUDYHUWHEUDO&7JXLGHGÀQHQHHGOHELRSV\RI
VXEFDULQDOO\PSKQRGHV
:+7DQWDZ\$6,EUDKLP0$0RKDPHG(+(O*HPHLH&DLUR(*
WDQWDZ\Z#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHSRUWRXUH[SHULHQFHLQ&7JXLGHGH[WUDSOHXUDOSDUDYHUWHEUDOVXE
FDULQDOO\PSKELRSV\XVLQJDWKLQJDXJH * WKLQQHHGOHZLWKRXWWKHQHHGRI
LQMHFWLRQRIVDOLQHWRZLGHQWKHPHGLDVWLQXP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%LRSV\ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJD*QHHGOHZKLFKZDV
DGYDQFHGODWHUDOWRWKHYHUWHEUDOERG\EHWZHHQWKHHQGRWKRUDFLFIDVFLDDQGWKH
SDULHWDO SOHXUD WR JDLQ DFFHVV WR VXEFDULQDO O\PSK QRGHV 2QH KXQGUHG DQG
IRUW\RQHSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\ IHPDOHVPDOHV 1RDUWLÀFLDO
ZLGHQLQJRIWKHPHGLDVWLQXPXVLQJVDOLQHLQMHFWLRQZDVUHTXLUHG7KHVWXG\ZDV
SHUIRUPHG LQ WKH SUHVHQFH RI D F\WRSDWKRORJLVW VHQVLWLYLW\ DQG VSHFLÀFLW\ UDWHV
ZHUH FDOFXODWHG &RPSOLFDWLRQV ZHUH GRFXPHQWHG IRU HDFK FDVH HVSHFLDOO\ IRU
SQHXPRWKRUD[DQGKDHPRUUKDJH
5HVXOWV&\WRSDWKRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLVZDVUHDFKHGLQDOOFDVHV$OOUHDVSLUDWLRQV
ZHUHGRQHLQWKHVDPHVHVVLRQWRUHDFKDSULPDU\GLDJQRVLVDWWKHWLPHRIWKHELRSV\
,PXQRSKHQRW\SLQJVWXG\ZDVGRQHLQFDVHVWRFRQÀUPWKHSULPDU\GLDJQRVLV
DQGWRFODVVLI\WKHPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV1RSQHXPRWKRUD[ZDVHQFRXQWHUHG6PDOO
KDHPDWRPDVZHUHQRWHGLQFDVHV &\WRSDWKRORJ\VKRZHGDVHQVLWLYLW\RI
DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI%\DGGLQJLPPXQRSKHQRW\SLQJDVHQVLWLYLW\
DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZDVDFKLHYHG
&RQFOXVLRQ)LQHQHHGOHDVSLUDWLRQF\WRORJ\ )1$& XVLQJDJDXJHQHHGOHIRU
VXEFDULQDOO\PSKQRGHVYLDDSHUFXWDQHRXVH[WUDSOHXUDOSDUDYHUWHEUDO&7JXLGHG
DSSURDFKLVDVDIHPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHDQGWROHUDEOHSURFHGXUH\LHOGLQJDKLJK
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\UDWHVZLWKRXWWKHQHHGRIDUWLÀFLDOZLGHQLQJ
%
,QLWLDOH[SHULHQFHRIDQRYHO&7ÁXRURVFRS\JXLGHGSHUFXWDQHRXV
JDVWURVWRP\WHFKQLTXHZLWKORRSJDVWURSH[\DQGSHHODZD\VKHDWK
WURFDUWHFKQLTXHLQDP\RWURSKLFODWHUDOVFOHURVLVSDWLHQWV
0GH%XFRXUW)&ROOHWWLQL&$OWKRII)6WUHLWSDUWK-*UHXSQHU%+DPP
87HLFKJUlEHU%HUOLQ'( PGE#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH7RUHSRUWRXULQLWLDOH[SHULHQFHRIDQRYHO&7ÁXRURVFRS\JXLGHGSHU
FXWDQHRXV JDVWURVWRP\ WHFKQLTXH ZLWK ORRS JDVWURSH[\ DQG SHHODZD\ VKHDWK
WURFDUWHFKQLTXH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$FRQVHFXWLYHVHULHVRIDP\RWURSKLFODWHUDOVFOHURVLV
SDWLHQWV LQ ZKRP HQGRVFRSLF JDVWURVWRP\ ZDV FRQVLGHUHG WRR GDQJHURXV RU
LPSRVVLEOH XQGHUZHQW &7JXLGHG SHUFXWDQHRXV JDVWURSH[\ DQG JDVWURVWRP\
DQGSURVSHFWLYHIROORZXS$OOSURFHGXUHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKD)5)UHND
3H[DFWJDVWURVWRP\NLW )UHVHQLXV.DEL%DG+RPEXUJ*HUPDQ\ URZVFDQQHU
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
$TXLOLRQ7RVKLED0HGLFDO6\VWHPV(XURSH7KH1HWKHUODQGV DQGVLQJOHVKRW
&7ÁXRURVFRS\PRGH
5HVXOWV7KHSURFHGXUHZDVSHUIRUPHGVXFFHVVIXOO\LQRISDWLHQWV PHQ
ZRPHQPHGLDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH ,QWKHUHPDLQLQJFDVHWKHVWRPDFK
ZDVSXQFWXUHGXQGHU&7ÁXRURVFRS\DQG&2LQVXIÁDWLRQZDVLQLWLDWHGWKHUHDIWHU
OHDGLQJ WR VXFFHVVIXO JDVWURVWRP\ ZLWKRXW SULRU JDVWURSH[\ DQG ZLWKRXW IXUWKHU
DGYHUVHHYHQWVGXULQJIROORZXS7ZRSDWLHQWVUHSRUWHGXQSUREOHPDWLFH[FKDQJH
RIDEDOORRQWXEHGXHWRVNLQLUULWDWLRQVZLWKQRIXUWKHUDGYHUVHHYHQWV2QHSDWLHQW
UHSRUWHGDFFLGHQWDOGLVSODFHPHQWRIDQH[FKDQJHGQHZEDOORRQWXEHLQGRPHVWLF
HQYLURQPHQWGXHWREDOORRQOHDNDJH$QHZEDOORRQWXEHZDVHDVLO\UHLQVHUWHGLQ
DKRVSLWDOWKHVDPHGD\1RVHULRXVDGYHUVHHYHQWVVXFKDVSHULWRQLWLVSHUVLVWHQW
ORFDOEOHHGLQJRUDQ\ORFDOLQIHFWLRQUHTXLULQJVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQZHUHREVHUYHG
8QWLO$XJWKIROORZXSUHVXOWHGLQFXPXODWLYHJDVWURVWRP\GD\VIURP
WKHGDWHRIÀUVWSODFHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ ,QLWLDO UHVXOWV VXJJHVW WKH RXWFRPH RI WKH GHVFULEHG WHFKQLTXH WR
EHFRPSDUDEOHWRFRQYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJLFJDVWURVWRP\DQGLWFDQEHVXFFHVVIXOO\
SHUIRUPHGZKHUHHQGRVFRSLFJDVWURVWRP\DQGVHGDWLRQDUHFRQWUDLQGLFDWHG
%
6SKHQRSDODWLQHJDQJOLRQDOFRKROQHXURO\VLVXQGHU&7JXLGDQFHLQ
WKHPDQDJHPHQWRIFUDQLRIDFLDOSDLQLQSURFHGXUHV
$.DVWOHU6$XEU\*&DGHO%.DVWOHU&OHUPRQW)HUUDQG)5
%HVDQFRQ)5
%
7DLORUHGLQWHUDFWLYHVHTXHQFHVIRUFRQWLQXRXV05LPDJHJXLGHG
IUHHKDQGELRSVLHVRIGLIIHUHQWRUJDQVLQDQRSHQV\VWHPDW7HVOD
SUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
0GH%XFRXUW)6WUHLWSDUWK87HLFKJUlEHU%HUOLQ'(
-HQD'( PGE#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVIHDVLELOLW\LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RIIUHHKDQGELRSVLHV
RIOXQJOLYHUVRIWWLVVXHDQGERQHOHVLRQVXVLQJE))( JUDGLHQWVSLQHFKR ))(
IDVWJUDGLHQWHFKR DQG76( IDVWVSLQHFKR VHTXHQFHVIRULQWHUDFWLYHFRQWLQXRXV
QDYLJDWLRQLQDQRSHQ05,V\VWHPDW7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05JXLGHGELRSVLHV OXQJOLYHUERQHVRIW
WLVVXHDQGRWKHURUJDQV ZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQD7RSHQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05
VFDQQHU 3DQRUDPD+)23KLOLSV+HDOWKFDUH%HVW7KH1HWKHUODQGV WR
JDXJH 05FRPSDWLEOH ELRSV\ VHWV 6RPDWH[ 0HGLFDO 7HOWRZ *HUPDQ\ VHPL
DXWRPDWLFELRSV\JXQV ,QYLYR6FKZHULQ*HUPDQ\ RUJDXJH05FRPSDWLEOH
ERQHPDUURZELRSV\QHHGOHV 6RPDWH[0HGLFDO7HOWRZ*HUPDQ\ ZHUHHPSOR\HG
&RPSOLFDWLRQVDQGSDWKRORJLFDOELRSV\UHSRUWVDVDQLQGLFDWRUIRUOHVLRQVKLWZHUH
UHFRUGHG$YHUDJHSDWLHQWVҋDJHZDV PLQPD[ IHPDOHDQGPDOH
SDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHG7KHPHDQLQWHUYHQWLRQWLPHZDVPLQ
5HVXOWV2XULQLWLDOUHVXOWVLQGLFDWHWKDWE))(LVSDUWLFXODUO\VXLWDEOHIRUIDVWPRYLQJ
RUJDQV SXOPRQDOSDUDFDUGLDO PRYLQJRUJDQVDUHWDUJHWHGEHWWHUZLWK7:76(
7:))( OLYHU RU7:76( DGUHQDOJODQGV DQGVWDWLFRUJDQVDUHVXFFHVVIXOO\
DSSURDFKHG ZLWK 3' VSLQH RU 7: 76( SHULSKHUDO ERQHV PXVFXORVNHOHWDO
V\VWHP 1RPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVRFFXUUHG$YHUDJHOHVLRQVL]HZDVPP PLQ
PD[
&RQFOXVLRQ$SSO\LQJ WDLORUHG LQWHUDFWLYH G\QDPLF LPDJLQJ VHTXHQFHV IRU FRQ
WLQXRXVQDYLJDWLRQZLWKDUELWUDU\VOLFHVHOHFWLRQIRUPDQHXYHULQJHYHQWRGHOLFDWH
ORFDWLRQVLPSURYHVLQWHUYHQWLRQDODFFXUDF\DQGIHDVLELOLW\RIIUHHKDQG05JXLGHG
ELRSVLHVDQGPD\KHQFHUHGXFHWKHULVNRIFRPSOLFDWLRQV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
3HUFXWDQHRXVGUDLQDJHXQGHU&7JXLGDQFHRIGHHSDEVFHVVXVLQJD
EOXQWWLSLQWURGXFHU
&GH%D]HODLUH)6DEDWLHU0&KDSHOOLHU$6FHPDPD
$3OXYLQDJH3%RXUULHU$0=DJGDQVNL(GH.HUYLOHU3DULV)5
FHGULFGHED]HODLUH#VOVDSKSIU
3XUSRVH 'HHS DEVFHVV GUDLQDJHV XQGHU &7 JXLGDQFH DUH XVXDOO\ GLIÀFXOW WR
UHDFKEHFDXVHRIYLWDOVWUXFWXUHVLQWHUYHQLQJLQWKHQHHGOHSDWKZD\2XUSXUSRVH
LVWRHYDOXDWHWKHHIÀFDF\DQGWKHVDIHW\RIGHHSGUDLQDJHVXQGHU&7JXLGDQFH
XVLQJDEOXQWWLSLQWURGXFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZRKXQGUHGDQGVHYHQFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVUHIHUUHG
IRU&7JXLGHGDEVFHVVGUDLQDJHZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\,QÀIW\
SDWLHQWVDEOXQWWLSLQWURGXFHUZDVXVHGWRUHDFKWKHDEVFHVVDQGLQDVWDQGDUG
QHHGOHZDVXVHG FRQWUROJURXS 3URFHGXUHVZHUHDQDO\VHGLQWHUPRIGXUDWLRQ
LUUDGLDWLRQVXFFHVVDQGFRPSOLFDWLRQV
5HVXOWV 7KH SURFHGXUH GXUDWLRQ ZDV ORQJHU LQ WKH EOXQWWLS JURXS PLQ YV
PLQ S +RZHYHU SDWLHQW V GRVLPHWU\ ZDV QRW VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU
LQWKHEOXQWWLSJURXS YVP*\FP 1RVLGHHIIHFWZDVREVHUYHGLQWKH
EOXQWWLSJURXSZKHUHDVKDHPDWRPDVDQGERZHOSHUIRUDWLRQVZHUHVHHQLQWKH
FRQWUROJURXS'XULQJWKHIROORZXSDVHFRQGGUDLQDJHZDVQHFHVVDU\LQLQ
WKHEOXQWWLSJURXSDQGLQWKHRWKHUJURXS S
&RQFOXVLRQ%OXQWWLSLQWURGXFHUVUHSUHVHQWDYLDEOHDVDIHDOWHUQDWLYHWRVWDQGDUG
QHHGOHVZKHQSHUIRUPLQJ&7JXLGHGSHUFXWDQHRXVGUDLQDJHVRIGHHSDEVFHVV
%
7RZDUGVFDUGLRYDVFXODULQWHUYHQWLRQVJXLGHGE\PDJQHWLFSDUWLFOH
LPDJLQJ 03, ÀUVWLQVWUXPHQWFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ
-+DHJHOH6%LHGHUHU+:RMWF]\N0*UDHVHU7.QRSS70%X]XJ
-%DUNKDXVHQ)09RJW/EHFN'( KDHJHOH#UDGLRORJLHXQLOXHEHFNGH
3XUSRVH0DJQHWLFSDUWLFOHLPDJLQJ 03, LVDQHZWRPRJUDSKLFLPDJLQJPHWKRG
DQGDYHU\SURPLVLQJDSSOLFDWLRQIRUFDUGLRYDVFXODULQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\:H
HYDOXDWHGWKH03,SHUIRUPDQFHRIYDULRXVFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOHLQVWUXPHQWVDQG
DVHOIFRDWHGFDWKHWHUXVLQJPDJQHWLFSDUWLFOHVSHFWURVFRS\ 036
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQWHHQFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOHLQWHUYHQWLRQDOGHYLFHV
ZHUHVHOHFWHGQLQHFDWKHWHUV ÀYHEUDLGHG RQHQLWLQROIRXUVWDLQOHVVVWHHO DQG
IRXU QRQEUDLGHG DQG HLJKW JXLGH ZLUHV IRXU VWDLQOHVVVWHHO WKUHH QLWLQRO RQH
SRO\HWKHUHWKHUNHWRQH3((. PPVL]HGSLHFHVZHUHWDNHQIURPWKHWLSWKHGLVWDO
SDUW PPSUR[LPDOWKHWLS DQGIURPWKHVKDIWRIHDFKGHYLFHDQGHYDOXDWHG
XVLQJ036$VDPHDVXUHRISHUIRUPDQFHWKHWRWDOKDUPRQLFGLVWRUWLRQ 7+' ZDV
GHWHUPLQHG,QDVHFRQGVWHSRQHFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOHFDWKHWHUZLWKRXWVLJQDO
UHVSRQVHLQ036ZDVH[SHULPHQWDOO\FRDWHGDWWKHWLSZLWK63,2VWRHYDOXDWHWKH
WUDFHDELOLW\RID63,2FRDWLQJ
5HVXOWV 6LJQDOJHQHUDWLQJ DQG QRQVLJQDOJHQHUDWLQJ GHYLFHV FRXOG EH GLVWLQ
JXLVKHGUHOLDEO\XVLQJ0367KH7+'RIVLJQDOJHQHUDWLQJLQVWUXPHQWVZDVVLJ
QLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQRIQRQVLJQDOJHQHUDWLQJLQVWUXPHQWV 6'G%
YV6'G%S RIVWDLQOHVVVWHHOFRQWDLQLQJGHYLFHV
JHQHUDWHG D VLJQDO UHVSRQVH ZKHUHDV QLWLQROFRQWDLQLQJ RI DQG PHWDOIUHH
LQVWUXPHQWV RI GLGQRW)XUWKHUPRUHWKH63,2FRDWHGFDWKHWHUJHQHUDWHGD
VLJQDOLQFRQWUDVWWRWKHVDPHXQFRDWHGFDWKHWHU YVG%
&RQFOXVLRQ,WLVSRVVLEOHWRUHOLDEO\GLVWLQJXLVKVLJQDOJHQHUDWLQJDQGQRQVLJQDO
JHQHUDWLQJLQVWUXPHQWVDQGWRODEHOLQVWUXPHQWVZLWK63,2VIRUDEHWWHUWUDFHDELOLW\
XVLQJ03,7KLVLVDSUHFRQGLWLRQIRUIXUWKHUGHYHORSPHQWRIVXLWDEOHLQVWUXPHQWV
%
3HUFXWDQHRXV05JXLGHGFU\RDEODWLRQRISURVWDWHFDQFHUWHFKQLFDO
IHDVLELOLW\DQGSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
*7VRXPDNLGRX+/DQJ2$EGHOOL;%X\0GH0DWKHOLQ'-DFTPLQ
$*DQJL6WUDVERXUJ)5 JWVRXPDNLGRX#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH :H KHUHLQ UHSRUW RXU LQLWLDO H[SHULHQFH DQG WHFKQLFDO IHDVLELOLW\ RI
WUDQVSHULQHDOSURVWDWHFU\RDEODWLRQXQGHUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHJXLGDQFH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-XO\WLOO-XO\SHUFXWDQHRXV05JXLGHG
FU\RDEODWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSURVWDWLFDGHQRFDUFLQRPDFRQWUDLQ
GLFDWHGIRUVXUJHU\ PHDQDJH\HDUVPHDQ*OHDVRQVFRUHPHDQ36$
QJUPO 7F10 PHDQ SURVWDWHYROXPH PO )UHHKDQG SUREH
SRVLWLRQLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGXQGHUUHDOWLPH05LPDJLQJ)RXUWRVHYHQFU\RSUREHV
ZHUHLQVHUWHGLQWKHSURVWDWHGHSHQGLQJRQWKHWRWDOJODQGYROXPH7KHLFHEDOO
ZDVPRQLWRUHGXVLQJUHDOWLPH7UXÀDQGKLJKUHVROXWLRQ7:%ODGHPXOWLSODQDU
LPDJLQJ3DWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHGDWPRQWKVDIWHUWKHSURFHGXUHZLWK
VHUXP36$OHYHODQGSRVWDEODWLRQ05,
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRGHVFULEHDQGHYDOXDWHWKHVDIHW\DQG
HIIHFWLYHQHVVRIDOFRKROQHXURO\VLVRIWKHVSKHQRSDODWLQHJDQJOLRQXQGHU&7JXLG
DQFHLQWKHPDQDJHPHQWRIIDFLDOYDULRXVSDLQV\QGURPHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\HLJKWSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVUHWURVSHFWLYH
VWXG\EHWZHHQ'HFHPEHUDQG-XQH$WRWDORIVSKHQRSDODWLQHQHX
URO\VLV 631 ZHUHSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDEVROXWHDOFRKRO7KH631ZDVFRQVLGHUHGWR
EHHIIHFWLYHZKHQSDLQUHOLHIZDVHTXDOWRRUJUHDWHUWKDQODVWLQJIRUDWOHDVW
RQHZHHN7KHPHDQSDLQUHOLHISHULRGIROORZLQJWKHSURFHGXUHIRUHDFKSDWLHQWZDV
QRWHG,QFDVHRIUHFXUULQJSDLQERWKGXUDWLRQDQGLQWHQVLW\RISDLQZHUHQRWHG$OO
SURFHGXUHVZHUHUHDOLVHGRQDQRXWSDWLHQWEDVLVXQGHUORFDODQDHVWKHVLD
5HVXOWV0HDQGXUDWLRQRIIDFLDOSDLQEHIRUHSURFHGXUHZDV\HDUV7KLUW\VL[RXW
RIWKH631 SURFHGXUHVSHUIRUPHGZHUHVXFFHVVIXO7KHRYHUDOOPHDQ
GXUDWLRQRISDLQUHOLHIZDVPRQWKVDIWHU631SURFHGXUH,QVXFFHVVIXO
631UHFXUULQJSDLQRFFXUUHGZLWKDPHDQGXUDWLRQRIPRQWKVDIWHULQLWLDOSUR
FHGXUH6XFFHVVUDWHRI631GHSHQGLQJRISDLQW\SHDUHDVIROORZVDW\SLFDOIDFLDO
SDLQ S FOXVWHUKHDGDFKH 3 WULJHPLQDOQHXUDOJLD
S FRPSUHVVLRQE\QHRSODVP S
&RQFOXVLRQ&7JXLGHGDOFRKROQHXURO\VLVRIWKHVSKHQRSDODWLQHJDQJOLRQLVDVDIH
DQGHIIHFWLYHWUHDWPHQWRIUHIUDFWRU\FKURQLFFUDQLRIDFLDOSDLQV\QGURPHVHVSHFLDOO\
LQFDVHVRIFOXVWHUKHDGDFKHVDW\SLFDOIDFLDOSDLQDQGWULJHPLQDOQHXUDOJLD
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV3URVWDWHFU\RDEODWLRQZDVWHFKQLFDOO\IHDVLEOHLQRXWRISDWLHQWV7KH
LFHEDOOZDVFOHDUO\DQGVKDUSO\YLVXDOLVHGLQDOOFDVHVDVDVLJQDOYRLGDUHD0HDQ
LFHEDOOYROXPHZDVPO0HDQIROORZXSZDVPRQWKV UDQJHPRQWKV
0HDQ36$QDGLUZDVQJUPO UDQJHQJUPO 0HDQKRVSLWDOL]DWLRQ
ZDVGD\V UDQJHGD\V &RPSOLFDWLRQVLQFOXGHGDXUHWKUDUHFWXPÀVWXOD
XULQDU\LQIHFWLRQWUDQVLHQWG\VXULDDQGVFURWDOSDLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 05JXLGHG SURVWDWH FU\RDEODWLRQ LV IHDVLEOH DQG SURPLVLQJ ZLWK
H[FHOOHQWPRQLWRULQJRIWKHLFHEDOO)XWXUHSHUVSHFWLYHVFRXOGLQFOXGHWKHXVHRI
05JXLGDQFHIRUWKHIRFDOSURVWDWHFDQFHUFU\RWKHUDS\
%
&OLQLFDOLPSRUWDQFHRI&7DVVLVWHGV\PSDWKLFRO\VLVLQSULPDU\IRFDO
SODQWDUDQGSDOPDUK\SHUKLGURVLV
)6FKHHU$:LQV3.DPXVHOOD3:LJJHUPDQQ&:LVVJRWW5$QGUHVHQ
+HLGH'(5RVWRFN'(5HJHQVEXUJ'( &:LVVJRWW#ZNNKHLGH
3XUSRVH7KHREMHFWLYHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHEHQHÀWRIWKRUDFLFDQG
OXPEDUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSKLFDVVLVWHGV\PSDWKLFRO\VLV &76\ LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
SULPDU\IRFDOK\SHUKLGURVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KRUDFLFDQGRUDOXPEDU&76\ZDVFRQGXFWHGRQ
SDWLHQWV DYHUDJHDJH\HDUV ZLWKSULPDU\IRFDOK\SHUKLGURVLVRIWKH
KDQGVDQGRUIHHWZKRH[SHULHQFHGSHUVLVWHQWV\PSWRPVDIWHUDOOFRQVHUYDWLYH
WUHDWPHQWRSWLRQVKDGEHHQH[KDXVWHG7KHSDWLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRJURXSVZLWK
SDOPDUSDOPRSODQWDUDQGSODQWDUK\SHUKLGURVLV7KHSDWLHQWVHYDOXDWHGWKHVHYHU
LW\RIWKHLUV\PSWRPVSULRUWRWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQGD\VPRQWKVDQGPRQWKV
DIWHUWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQXVLQJD'HUPDWRORJ\4XDOLW\RI/LIH,QGH[ '/4, DQGVLGH
HIIHFWVH[SHULHQFHG
5HVXOWV7KHLQWHUYHQWLRQVSHUIRUPHGOHGWRDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHLQ
WKHIROORZXSDIWHU&76\LQDOOJURXSV S 7KHWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVUDWHRIWKH
&76\ ZDV 1R PDMRU FRPSOLFDWLRQV RFFXUUHG$V WKH PRVW FRPPRQ VLGH
HIIHFWRIWKHSDWLHQWVUHSRUWHGFRPSHQVDWRU\SHUVSLUDWLRQRYHUWKHFRXUVH
RIWUHDWPHQW1HXUDOJLDH[SHULHQFHGE\DQGSDUDHVWKHVLDE\RIWKH
SDWLHQWVVXEVLGHGVSRQWDQHRXVO\LQDOORIWKRVHDIIHFWHGDIWHUDSHULRGRIZHHNV
DWPRVW7KHGLIIHUHQWLDWHGDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHVWUHQJWKRISHUVSLUDWLRQRIWKHKDQGV
DQG IHHW VKRZHG VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ WKH IRRW DQG KDQG
UHJLRQ ZKHUHE\ WKH GHFUHDVH LQ VZHDW VHFUHWLRQ RI WKH IHHW ZDV VWURQJHU DQG
PRUHODVWLQJ S
&RQFOXVLRQ$IWHUFRQVHUYDWLYHPHDVXUHVKDYHEHHQH[KDXVWHG&76\UHSUHVHQWV
DWKHUDSHXWLFRSWLRQORZLQVLGHHIIHFWVIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\IRFDOK\SHUKLGURVLV
5RRP(
66
0RGHUDWRUV
'0LNOLþ=DJUHE+5
*7XUyF]\%XGDSHVW+8
%
6RQRHODVWRJUDSK\FDQKHOSLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIVXSUDVSLQDWXV
WHQGRQGHJHQHUDWLRQ
&0DUWLQL()DEEUR*)HUUHUR'2UODQGL(6LOYHVWUL*HQRD,7
FKLDUDSLR#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH7RGHVFULEHXWLOLW\RIVRQRHODVWRJUDSK\LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIVXSUDVSLQD
WXVWHQGRQ 663 GHJHQHUDWLRQLQWZRJURXSVRI\RXQJDQGHOGHUO\DV\PSWRPDWLF
YROXQWHHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[W\DV\PSWRPDWLFVXEMHFWVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQRXUHYDOX
DWLRQ WKLUW\ \RXQJ VXEMHFWV JURXS$ PHDQ DJH UDQJH WKLUW\ HOGHUO\
VXEMHFWVJURXS%PHDQDJHUDQJH $OOVXEMHFWVZHUHVFUHHQHGE\86
0+]SUREH0\/DE;Y*(VDRWH,WDO\ 7ZR\RXQJVKRXOGHUVZHUHIRXQG
WRKDYHSDUWLDOWKLFNQHVVWHDURIWKH663ZKLOHHOGHUO\VKRXOGHUVZHUHIRXQGWR
KDYHSDUWLDOIXOOWKLFNQHVVWHDURIWKH6637KXVRXUVWXG\JURXSZDVPDGHE\
\RXQJDQGHOGHUO\VKRXOGHUV)RUHDFKVKRXOGHUZHGHWHFWHGWKHSUHVHQFHRI
VLJQVRIWHQGRQGHJHQHUDWLRQ ÀEUHLQWHUUXSWLRQIUDJPHQWDWLRQDQGFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
7KHQDOOWHQGRQVZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\VRQRHODVWRJUDSK\ZKRVHRXWFRPHZDVWUDQV
ODWHGLQWRDVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHVFDOH KDUG WRVRIW &KLVTXDUH.UXVNDO:DOOLV
DQG6SHDUPDQҋVVWDWLVWLFVZHUHXVHG
5HVXOWV,QJURXS$ZHIRXQGLQWHUUXSWLRQ Q IUDJPHQWDWLRQ Q DQGFDO
FLÀFDWLRQV Q ZKLOHLQJURXS%Q Q DQGQ UHVSHFWLYHO\ S
%
&OLQLFDOLQGLFDWLRQVIRUPXVFXORVNHOHWDOXOWUDVRXQGFRQVHQVXV
SDSHURIWKH(XURSHDQ6RFLHW\RI0XVFXORVNHOHWDO5DGLRORJ\
$.ODXVHU$7DJOLDÀFR*0$OOHQ1%RXWU\5&DPSEHOO
0&RXUW3D\HQ$-*UDLQJHU+*XHULQL(*0F1DOO\3-2ҋ&RQQRU
62VWOHUH33HHWURQV05HLMQLHUVH/06FRQÀHQ]D(6LOYHVWUL
'-:LOVRQ&0DUWLQROL,QQVEUXFN$7*HQRD,72[IRUG8./LOOH)5
/LYHUSRRO8.&RSHQKDJHQ'./HHGV8.3DULV)5%UXVVHOV%(
/HLGHQ1/0LODQ,7 DWDJOLDÀFR#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7RGHYHORSFOLQLFDOJXLGHOLQHVIRUPXVFXORVNHOHWDOXOWUDVRXQG 06.86
UHIHUUDOLQ(XURSH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 6L[WHHQ PXVFXORVNHOHWDO UDGLRORJLVWV IURP VHYHQ (X
URSHDQFRXQWULHVSDUWLFLSDWHGLQDFRQVHQVXVEDVHGLQWHUDFWLYHSURFHVV 'HOSKL
PHWKRG XVLQJFRQVHFXWLYHTXHVWLRQQDLUHVDQGFRQVHQVXVSURFHGXUHDW(XURSHDQ
PHHWLQJV)LUVWHYLGHQFHYDOLGLW\ZDVFRQÀUPHGE\OLWHUDWXUHUHVHDUFKIROORZHG
E\FRQVHQVXVRQFOLQLFDOXWLOLW\LQHYDOXDWLRQRIPXVFXORVNHOHWDOGLVHDVHVLQWKUHH
FRQVHQVXVPHHWLQJV7KLVLQYROYHGDWKRURXJKWUDQVSDUHQWLWHUDWLYHDSSURDFK
HPSOR\LQJ TXDQWLWDWLYH DQG TXDOLWDWLYH UHVHDUFK WHFKQLTXHV LQFOXGLQJ LQWHUYLHZ
TXHVWLRQQDLUH'HOSKLDQGVWDQGDUGVHWWLQJPHWKRGRORJLHV$OOUHOHYDQWVWDNHKROGHUV
ZHUHHQJDJHGLQFOXGLQJ(XURSHDQ06.H[SHUWVZLWKVSHFLDOIRFXVRQ06.86
7ZRGLIIHUHQWH[SHUWJURXSVZRUNHGRQDFRQVHQVXVLQDÀUVWDQGVHFRQGPHHWLQJ
7KHWKLUGFRQVHQVXVPHHWLQJVUHVROYHGTXHVWLRQVWKDWGLGQRWDFKLHYHFRQVHQVXV
OLPLW E\WKHÀUVWWZRTXHVWLRQQDLUHV
5HVXOWV2QJHQHUDOFRQVHQVXVPXVFXORVNHOHWDOXOWUDVRXQGLVLQGLFDWHGWRGHWHFW
MRLQWV\QRYLWLVÁXLGDQGVHSWLFHIIXVLRQIRUSRWHQWLDODVSLUDWLRQDQGSRRUO\LQGLFDWHGWR
GHWHFWORRVHERGLHV5HFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUPRVWDSSURSULDWHXVHRIPXVFXORVNHOHWDO
XOWUDVRXQGDUHUHSRUWHGLQVL[DUHDVUHOHYDQWWRPXVFXORVNHOHWDOXOWUDVRXQGKDQG
ZULVWHOERZVKRXOGHUKLSNQHHDQNOHIRRW
&RQFOXVLRQ$FRPSUHKHQVLYHHYLGHQFHEDVHGH[SHUWFRQVHQVXVGHÀQHGHGXFD
WLRQDOIUDPHZRUNLVSUHVHQWHG7KLVVKRXOGIDFLOLWDWHUHIHUUDOVIRUPXVFXORVNHOHWDO
XOWUDVRXQGWKURXJKRXW(XURSH
)DFWRUVLQÁXHQFLQJTXDQWLWDWLYHYDOXHVRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
XOWUDVRXQGDQGFRUUHODWLRQVZLWKFOLQLFDOYDOXHVLQUKHXPDWRLGDUWKULWLV
&&\WHYDO0RQWSHOOLHU)5 FF\WHYDO#FKXPRQWSHOOLHUIU
8OWUDVRXQG
$
%
%
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
6
7KHPHGLDQVRQRHODVWRJUDSK\VFRUHLQJURXS$ZDV >WKWKSHUFHQWLOH@
ZKLOHLWZDVLQJURXS% S *URXS$WHQGRQVSUHVHQWHGZLWKDUHODWLYHO\
KRPRJHQHRXVFRORXUSDWWHUQZKLOHJURXS%WHQGRQVSUHVHQWHGZLWKDUHODWLYHO\
SDWFK\FRORXUSDWWHUQ&RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ86DQGVRQRHODVWRJUDSK\ZDVKLJK
U S
&RQFOXVLRQ 6RQRHODVWRJUDSK\ ZDV DEOH WR GHWHFW GHJHQHUDWLYH FKDQJHV RI
663WHQGRQVLQHOGHUO\YROXQWHHUVZLWKJRRGFRUUHODWLRQWR86VRLWFRXOGKHOS
LQLQFUHDVLQJ86GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQGHWHFWLRQRI663WHQGRQGHJHQHUDWLRQ
&
'
(
)
*
+
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUHOLDELOLW\RITXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVRIWKHWLPHLQWHQVLW\
FXUYHVLQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG &(86 IRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIV\QRYLDO
YDVFXODULVDWLRQ LQ 5$ DQG WKHLU FRUUHODWLRQ ZLWK FOLQLFDO DQG ELRORJLFDO VLJQV RI
LQÁDPPDWLRQGXULQJWKHIROORZXSRIWKHGLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKDFWLYH5$DQGFRQWUROSDWLHQWVZHUH
UHFUXLWHG 7ZR DFTXLVLWLRQV RI D VHOHFWHG MRLQW ZLWK 'RSSOHU V\QRYLWLV ZHUH SHU
IRUPHGDWKRXULQWHUYDOIRUHDFKSDWLHQWE\WKHVDPHLQYHVWLJDWRUDIWHULQMHFWLRQ
RIPLFUREXEEOHFRQWUDVWDJHQW,QDGGLWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWK5$DWKLUGDFTXLVLWLRQ
ZDV SHUIRUPHG PRQWKV ODWHU 6\QRYLDO YDVFXODULVDWLRQ ZDV TXDQWLÀHG XVLQJ
WLPHLQWHQVLW\FXUYHSDUDPHWHUV PD[LPXPVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\$8&DUHDXQGHUWKH
FXUYH773WLPHWRSHDN &RUUHODWLRQVRIWKHFXUYHSDUDPHWHUVZLWKWKHIROORZLQJ
YDULDEOHVSDWLHQWDFTXLVLWLRQVL]HDQGORFDOLVDWLRQRI52,DVZHOODVZLWKFOLQLFDO
DQGELRORJLFDOVLJQVRILQÁDPPDWLRQZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQVDQG
3HDUVRQRU:LOFR[RQWHVWV
5HVXOWV5$SDWLHQWVSUHVHQWHGWKHIROORZLQJIHDWXUHVPHGLDQDJH
\HDUVPHGLDQGLVHDVHGXUDWLRQ \HDUV1RVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQFUHDVH
ZDVREVHUYHGLQFRQWUROSDWLHQWV PHGLDQDJH \HDUV 7KHFXUYHSDUDP
HWHUVZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWIURPWKHDFTXLVLWLRQDQGWKH52,ORFDOLVDWLRQ S
$WWKHPRQWKIROORZXSYDULDWLRQRI$8&ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWK'$6YDULDWLRQ
U >@ DQGZLWK&53YDULDWLRQ U >@
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUSUHOLPLQDU\ÀQGLQJVVKRZWKDWV\QRYLWLVPD\EHUHOLDEO\IROORZHG
XVLQJ&(86WLPHLQWHQVLW\FXUYHSDUDPHWHUVDQGVXJJHVWWKDW$8&DUHFRUUHODWHG
ZLWKWKHYDULDWLRQRIWKH'$6LQSDWLHQWVZLWK5$
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&(86HYDOXDWLRQLQWKHSVHXGDUWKURVLVEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWUHDWPHQW
ZLWKDXWRORJRXVWUDQVSODQWDWLRQRIERQHPDUURZVWHPFHOOV
SUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
63R]]D$'H0DUFKL03HWUD]'$ORM*%LLQR&)DOHWWL7XULQ,7
3DYLD,7 VLPRQDSR]]D#WLQLW
%
9LVXDOLVDWLRQRIP\RIDVFLDOWULJJHUSRLQWVLQORZEDFNPXVFOHVE\
UHDOWLPHVRQRHODVWRJUDSK\
10$EGHO5D]HN2.DWWDEHL0.1DVVLI0(O/LWKH\&DLUR(*
QDJODDEGHOUD]HN#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH0\RIDVFLDOWULJJHUSRLQWV 07U3V DUHDFRPPRQVRXUFHRISDLQDQGKDV
EHHQUHSRUWHGWRYDU\IURPWRLQPXVFXORVNHOHWDOSDLQ+RZHYHUWKHUH
LVVWLOODODFNRIREMHFWLYHPHDQVWRHLWKHUTXDQWLI\RUYLVXDOLVHWKHLUFRUHIHDWXUHV
3XUSRVHLVWRH[DPLQHWKHDELOLW\RIYLEUDWLRQVRQRHODVWURJUDSK\ (FRORXUPRGH
WRYLVXDOLVH07U3VXSHUÀFLDODVZHOODVGHHSRQHVDQGWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHWKHPIURP
WKHLULPPHGLDWHVXUURXQGLQJP\RIDVFLDOVWUXFWXUH$OVRWRFRPSDUHEHWZHHQDF
WLYHDQGODWHQW07U3VLQWKHTXDGUDWHVOXPERUPORQJLVVLPXVWKRUDFLVLOLRFRVWDOLV
OXPERUXPSLULIRUPLVDQGJOXWHXVPHGLXVPXVFOHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\HLJKW VXEMHFWVZLWKPRUHWKDQWZR 07U3V
ZHUHUDQGRPO\DVVLJQHGWRDQDFWLYH07U3JURXSDQGDODWHQW07U3JURXS07U3
LGHQWLÀFDWLRQZDVEDVHGRQWKHLUHVVHQWLDODQGFRQÀUPDWRU\FULWHULDDOVRDKDQG
KHOGGLJLWDOHOHFWURQLFDOJRPHWHUZDVXVHGWRPHDVXUH07U3VWHQGHUQHVVWKURXJK
SUHVVXUHSDLQWKUHVKROGYDOXH$KDQGKHOGYLEUDWRU +] ZDVXVHGRYHU07U3V
ZKLOHVRQRHODVWRJUDSK\UHDGLQJVZHUHWDNHQ2XWFRPHPHDVXUHVSHUFHQWDJHRI
WLVVXHVWLIIQHVVRI07U3DQGWKHLULPPHGLDWHVXUURXQGLQJP\RIDVFLDOVWUXFWXUHDV
ZHOODVWKHLUVWUDLQUDWLR
5HVXOWV9LEUDWLRQVRQRHODVWURJUDS\FOHDUO\GLIIHUHQWLDWHGZLWKVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ07U3VVWLIIQHVVDQGWKHLULPPHGLDWHVXUURXQGLQJP\RIDVFLDO
VWUXFWXUHVWLIIQHVVZLWKD39DOXH 39DOXH +RZHYHUWKHUHZDVQR
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWLVVXHVWUDLQUDWLRVRIERWKDFWLYHDQGODWHQW07U3V
ZLWKD39DOXH 39DOXH!
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVLQGLFDWHWKDWYLEUDWLRQVRQRHODVWURJUDS\FDQ
DFWXDOO\YLVXDOLVH07U3VDQGFDQGLIIHUHQWLDWHWKHPIURPLWVVXUURXQGLQJP\RIDVFLDO
VWUXFWXUHWKURXJKWLVVXHVWUDLQ+RZHYHULWFRXOGQRWGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQDFWLYH
DQGODWHQW07U3VZKHUHWLVVXHVWUDLQV\LHOGVLPLODUYDOXHV
%
6RQRJUDSKLFJXLGHGWUHDWPHQWRIURWDWRUFXIIGHODPLQDWLRQWHDUV
XVLQJDXWRORJRXVEORRGDRQH\HDUIROORZXSVWXG\DVVHVVLQJ
UDGLRORJLFDOIHDWXUHVSDLQVFRUHVDQGVKRXOGHUIXQFWLRQ
:$%DVKLU'&RQQHOO/RQGRQ8. ZDEDVKLU#GRFWRUVQHWXN
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV XOWUDVRXQGJXLGHG DXWRORJRXV EORRG LQMHFWLRQ $%, DV DQ
HIIHFWLYHWUHDWPHQWIRUURWDWRUFXIILQWHUVWLWLDOGHODPLQDWLRQWHDUVZKLFKDUHGLIÀFXOW
WRGLDJQRVHE\DUWKURVFRS\DQGDUHWKHUHIRUHSUREOHPDWLFWRWUHDW$%,RIIHUVD
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIHFKRJXLGHGDXWRORJRXVSODWHOHWJHO $3* WUHDWPHQWLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKWHQGLQRVLV
6%DWWLVWL/*UHJRUL)$UULJRQL$/D0DUUD/=XJDUR$%DULOH
&0DVFLRFFKL/ҋ$TXLOD,7 DQWRQLREDULOH#FFXQLYDTLW
3XUSRVH3XUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWRISODWHOHWJHOWUHDWPHQW
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKWHQGLQRVLVWKDWWRGD\LVQRWVXUJLFDOO\WUHDWHG7KHHYDOXDWLRQZDV
EDVHGRQREVHUYDWLRQRIFOLQLFDOLPSURYHPHQWDQG05,LPDJLQJ7KHSODWHOHWJHO
VKRZV DQWLLQÁDPPDWRU\ DQG UHJHQHUDWLYH HIIHFWV ZKLFK DOORZ UHFRYHU\ RI WKH
IXQFWLRQDOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HHYDOXDWHGSDWLHQWVZLWKWHQGLQRVLVRIVXSUDVS
LQDWXV SWV $FKLOOHVҋ SWV DQGSDWHOODUWHQGRQV SWV &OLQLFDODVZHOODV
IXQFWLRQDOHYDOXDWLRQVRIWKHSDWLHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGXVLQJWKHYLVXDODQDORJXH
VFDOH 9$6 IRUSDLQDQG&RQVWDQW6FDOH9,6$$DQG9,6$3IRUIXQFWLRQDOLW\
7KHLQVWUXPHQWDOHYDOXDWLRQZDVEDVHGRQ86DQG05,7KHSURWRFROLQFOXGHG
WKUHHLQÀOWUDWLRQVSHUIRUPHGDWDGLVWDQFHRIGD\VWKHRQHIURPWKHRWKHU7KH
FRQWURO05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHWUHDWPHQWDQGGD\VDIWHUWKHODVWLQÀOWUDWLRQ
5HVXOWV7KH9$6PHDQYDOXHRIWKHVXSUDVSLQDWXVWHQGRQDWWKHHQGRIWUHDW
PHQWLPSURYHGRYHUDOOE\DQGWKH&RQVWDQWVFDOHE\,QWKHSDWLHQWV
ZLWKWHQGLQRVLVRI$FKLOOHVWHQGRQVZHIRXQGDQLPSURYHPHQWRI 9$6 DQG
9,6$$ 7KHSDWHOODUWHQGRQ9$6YDOXHLQFUHDVHGRIDQGWKH9,6$3
YDOXH RI &RPSDUHG ZLWK WKHVH JRRG FOLQLFDO UHVXOWV WKH LPDJLQJ ÀQGLQJV
ZHUHOHVVVLJQLÀFDQW
&RQFOXVLRQ%HVLGHVSURGXFLQJYHU\VDWLVIDFWRU\UHVXOWVLQWHUPVRIV\PSWRPV
DQGIXQFWLRQDOLW\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKWHQGLQRVLVWKHXVHRISODWHOHWJHODOVRJLYHVVLJQV
RIPRUSKRORJLFDOUHFRYHU\+RZHYHUIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQVDUHQHHGHGWRFRQÀUP
FRQVLVWHQF\RIWKHVHUHVXOWV
%
&RPELQHGXOWUDVRXQG 86 JXLGHGSHUFXWDQHRXVWUHDWPHQWRI
HSLWURFKOHLWLVDUDQGRPLVHGFRQWUROOHGWULDO
'2UODQGL()DEEUR&0DUWLQL*)HUUHUR/6FRQÀHQ]D*6HUDÀQL
(6LOYHVWUL*HQRD,76DQ'RQDWR0LODQHVH,73LHWUD/LJXUH69,7
WKHDER#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH(SLWURFKOHLWLVLVDFRPPRQFDXVHRIHOERZSDLQWKDWFRXOGEHWUHDWHG
ZLWKFRQVHUYDWLYHRUVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQ7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUZRUNZDVWRFRPSDUH
SDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVHVRIHSLWURFKOHLWLVWUHDWHGZLWKDFRPELQHG86JXLGHG
SHUFXWDQHRXVDSSURDFK GU\QHHGOLQJDQGVWHURLG DQGVLPLODUSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWK
HLWKHUORFDOVWHURLGLQMHFWLRQRUGU\QHHGOLQJ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV VXIIHULQJ IURP HSLWURFKOHLWLV XQGHUZHQW WR
86JXLGHG SHUFXWDQHRXV WUHDWPHQW PDOHV DJH >PHDQVWGHY@
ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKGU\QHHGOLQJDQGORFDOVWHURLGLQMHFWLRQWRJHWKHU PDOHVDJH
ZLWKGU\QHHGOLQJRQO\DQG PDOHVDJH ZLWKORFDOVWHURLG
LQMHFWLRQRQO\$YLVXDODQDORJXHVFDOH 9$6IURPWR ZDVXVHGWRHYDOXDWH
WKHGHJUHHRISDLQDWEDVHOLQHDQGDWZHHNVDIWHUWKHSURFHGXUH
86VFDQQLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGDWEDVHOLQHZHHNV
5HVXOWV1RLPPHGLDWHRUGHOD\HGFRPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHREVHUYHG3DWLHQWVZKR
XQGHUZHQWVWHURLGLQMHFWLRQRQO\KDGDSURPSWSDLQGHFUHDVHEXWOLPLWHGHIIHFWVRQ
DORQJWHUPEDVLV EDVHOLQH9$6 ZHHNV9$6 9$6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RGHPRQVWUDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRI&(86LQHYDOXDWLQJWKHSURFHVVRI
UHSDUDWLYHERQHUHJHQHUDWLRQE\PRQLWRULQJDQJLRJHQHVLVDURXQGWKHIUDFWXUHVLWH
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSVHXGDUWKURVLVZKRZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKWUDQVSODQWDWLRQRIPDUURZ
GHULYHGPHVHQFK\PDOVWHPFHOOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHPHWKRGZDVXVHGLQSDWLHQWVRIWKH7UDXPDWRO
RJ\ &HQWUH LQ 7RULQR ,WDO\ IURP )HEUXDU\ WR 0D\ $OO SDWLHQWV ZHUH
WUHDWHGIRUGHOD\HGPXOWLIUDJPHQWDU\IUDFWXUHHYROYHGLQSVHXGDUWKURVLV$XWRORJRXV
FRQFHQWUDWHRIERQHPDUURZVWHPFHOOVZDVDSSOLHGLQWRWKHDUHDRIERQHGHIHFW
&(86H[DPLQDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHWKHJHODWLQRXVFRPSRXQGZDVDSSOLHG
DQGDWRQHIRXUDQGWZHOYHZHHNIROORZXSWLPHSRLQWVLQRUGHUWRHYDOXDWHWKH
SK\VLRORJLFDO IRUPDWLRQ RI QHZ EORRG YHVVHOV$W WKH HQG RI WKH VWXG\ DQ ;UD\
FRQÀUPVWKHSUHVHQFHRIFDOOXV
5HVXOWV(FRJUDSKLFVLJQVRIQHRYDVFXODULVDWLRQZHUHQRWHGDWRQHZHHNLQ
RISDWLHQWVDVWHDG\LQFUHDVHLQYDVFXODULW\ZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGLQSDWLHQWVLQ
VXEVHTXHQWWHVWVUHSHDWHGPHDVXUHV$129$GHPRQVWUDWHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHV LQ WKH H[WHQW RI YDVFXODULVDWLRQ DW VXEVHTXHQW IROORZXS WLPH SRLQWV
3 $WWKHHQGRIWKHVWXG\[UD\H[DPLQDWLRQUHYHDOHGLQLWLDODWWDFKPHQW
RIFDOFLÀHGFDOOXVLQWKRVHSDWLHQWVZKRGHPRQVWUDWHGDQLQFUHDVHLQYDVFXODULW\
DW&(867KHRWKHUWZRSDWLHQWVVKRZHGQRLPSURYHPHQWEHFDXVHRIWKHSUHV
HQFHRIKDHPDWRPD
&RQFOXVLRQ7UDQVSODQWDWLRQRIVWHPFHOOVLVDQHZWUHDWPHQWRISVHXGRDUWKURVLV
RXUUHVXOWVGHPRQVWUDWHWKDW&(86KDVDJRRGSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRQWKHIRUPDWLRQ
RIFDOOXVLQWKDWLWDIIRUGVWKHPRQLWRULQJRIWKHUHSDUDWLYHWLVVXHYDVFXODULW\
QHZDOWHUQDWLYHPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHWUHDWPHQWWKDWDFWXDOO\WDUJHWVSDWKRSK\VLRORJ\
RIURWDWRUFXIIWHQGRQSDWKRORJ\WKDWKDVIDLOHGWUDGLWLRQDOQRQVXUJLFDOUHPHGLHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK FOLQLFDO VXVSLFLRQ RI URWDWRU FXII WHDU
XQGHUZHQW05,H[DPLQDWLRQ:KHQHYLGHQFHRIDVXSUDVSLQDWXVORQJLWXGLQDOVSOLW
WHDUZDVFRQÀUPHGWKHSDWLHQWZDVSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGLQWKHVWXG\DQGKDG86
DVVHVVPHQWGLDJQRVLVFRQÀUPHGDFFRUGLQJWRHFKRWH[WXUHLQWHUVWLWLDOWHDULQJDQG
QHRYDVFXODULW\,QGLYLGXDOVUDQGRPLVHGLQWRJURXSVÀUVWJURXS SDWLHQWVDJH
UHFHLYHGVWDQGDUGWUHDWPHQWZLWKP/%XSLYDFDLQHDQGPJWULDPFLQRORQH
LQWRWKHVXEDFURPLDOVXEGHOWRLGEXUVD7KHVHFRQGJURXS SDWLHQWVDJH
UHFHLYHGWKHVWDQGDUGWKHUDS\DVZHOODV$%,LQWRWKHVLWHRILQWHUVWLWLDOWHDULQJDQG
ÀEULOODUGLVFRQWLQXLW\:HSHUIRUPHGWZRLQMHFWLRQVDQGPRQLWRUHGDQ\FKDQJHVLQ
WKHWHQGRQZLWKXOWUDVRXQGDQGDVVHVVHGSDLQVFRUHVDQGIXQFWLRQDOLPSURYHPHQW
XVLQJWKHYDOLGDWHG2[IRUG6KRXOGHU6FRUH 266
5HVXOWV3UHSURFHGXUDO266DQGWKRVHDWGD\VZHHNVDQGPRQWKV
SRVWSURFHGXUHZHUHFRPSDUHG'LIIHUHQFHVLQVRQRJUDSKLFHFKRJHQLFLW\QHRYDV
FXODULW\DQGLQWHUVWLWLDOWHDUVL]HQRWHG3DWLHQWVLQWKH$%,JURXSVKRZHGVWDWLVWLFDO
DQGFOLQLFDOORQJWHUPSDLQUHOLHIDQGIXQFWLRQDOLPSURYHPHQWDVDVVHVVHGE\WKH
RYHUDOO266
&RQFOXVLRQ$XWRORJRXV EORRG LQMHFWLRQ DSSHDUV WR EH D YLDEOH DOWHUQDWLYH DQG
PRUHFOLQLFDOO\HIIHFWLYHZKHQFRPSDUHGWRVWDQGDUGVWHURLGLQMHFWLRQWKHUDS\IRU
URWDWRUFXIIGHODPLQDWLRQWHDULQJ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
9$6 9$6 ZHHNV 3DWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKGU\
QHHGOLQJRQO\KDGDGHOD\HGGHFUHDVHRIV\PSWRPVEXWSHUPDQHQWORQJODVWLQJ
HIIHFWV EDVHOLQH 9$6 ZHHNV 9$6 9$6
9$6 9$6 9$6 3DWLHQWV WUHDWHG ZLWK WKH
FRPELQHG SURFHGXUH KDG D IDVWHU DQG PRUH SHUPDQHQW GHFUHDVH RI V\PSWRPV
EDVHOLQH9$6 ZHHNV9$6 9$6 9$6
9$6 9$6 SIRUDOO
&RQFOXVLRQ 3DWLHQWV WUHDWHG ZLWK WKH 86JXLGHG FRPELQHG SURFHGXUH KDG D
EHWWHURXWFRPHWKDQRWKHUJURXSVDQGSDLQUHOLHIZDVIDVWHUDQGPRUHSHUPDQHQW
%
$QHZPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHVDIHDQGUHSURGXFLEOHWHFKQLTXHIRU
PDQDJHPHQWRIFHUYLFDOUDGLFXORSDWK\XOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGFHUYLFDO
WUDQVIRUDPLQDOHSLGXUDOQHUYHURRWLQMHFWLRQV
:$%DVKLU'$&RQQHOO/RQGRQ8. ZDEDVKLU#GRFWRUVQHWXN
5RRP)
*HQLWRXULQDU\
66
*\QDHFRORJLFDO05LPDJLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
&'$OW+HLGHOEHUJ'(
6%DUWHU&DPEULGJH8.
%
05LPDJLQJRIWKHQRUPDOHQGRPHWULXPGRDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQWYDOXHVFKDQJHDPRQJWKHSRUWLRQVRIWKHXWHUXVDQGRYHU
WKHSKDVHVRIWKHPHQVWUXDOF\FOH"
))RUQDVD)3DQWDORQH$'LEHQHGHWWR16FKLR$4XDJOLD6%RQLIDFLR,7
IUDQFHVFDIRUQDVD#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH&HUYLFDOUDGLFXORSDWK\LVDFRPPRQSUREOHPOHDGLQJWRLQWROHUDEOHGH
ELOLWDWLQJSDLQ,QUHIUDFWRU\FDVHVLQYDVLYHWKHUDSLHVLQFOXGH&7DQGÁXRURJXLGHG
WUDQVIRUDPLQDOHSLGXUDOVWHURLGLQMHFWLRQV 7)(6,V DVZHOODVVXUJHU\8QIRUWX
QDWHO\WKHUHLVLQFUHDVLQJOLWHUDWXUHLOOXVWUDWLQJSRWHQWLDOIRUEUDLQDQGVSLQDOFRUGLQ
IDUFWLRQIROORZLQJLQMHFWLRQ8OWUDVRXQGDOORZVVDIHDFFXUDWHDQGUHDOWLPHLQMHFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSLORWVWXG\LQYROYHGSDWLHQWVZKRZHUHUHIHUUHG
WR WKH UDGLRORJ\ GHSDUWPHQW IROORZLQJ DSSURSULDWH DQDHVWKHWLF DQG VXUJLFDO DV
VHVVPHQW ZLWK UHTXLUHPHQW IRU FHUYLFDO7)(6,V 1RUPDOO\ SDWLHQWV ZRXOG KDYH
XQGHUJRQHÁXRURVFRSLFRU&7JXLGHGLQMHFWLRQEXWZHUHHQUROOHGLQWKLVVWXG\DIWHU
IXOO\ LQIRUPHG ZULWWHQ FRQVHQW$ JDXJH VSLQDO QHHGOH ZDV DGYDQFHG XQGHU
VRQRJUDSKLFJXLGDQFHWRDWUDQVIRUDPLQDOSRVLWLRQQHUYHURRWOHYHOVPDSSHGE\
LGHQWLI\LQJWUDQVYHUVHSURFHVVHVDQGFRXQWLQJQHUYHURRWVFUDQLDOO\7KHQHUYHURRW
XQGHU LQYHVWLJDWLRQ FOHDUO\ VKRZHG WKLFNHQLQJ DQG ZDV EDWKHG LQ FRUWLFRVWHURLG
DQGDQDHVWKHWLF
5HVXOWV3UHDQGSRVWSDLQVFRUHVSHUIRUPHGUHJXODUO\WLOOPRQWKVSRVWWKHUDS\
$OOSDWLHQWVKDGVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQLQSDLQVFRUHVDWPRQWKVZLWKVRQRJUDSKLF
HYLGHQFHRIUHGXFWLRQLQQHUYHWKLFNQHVV1RFRPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHUHSRUWHGGXULQJ
WKLVVWXG\
&RQFOXVLRQ 8OWUDVRXQG 7)(6,V DYRLG WKH ULVNV RI LRQLVLQJ UDGLDWLRQ 6RQR
JUDSKLFJXLGDQFHDOORZVDFFXUDWHUHDOWLPHYLVXDOLVDWLRQZLWKKLJKUHVROXWLRQRIORFDO
DQDWRP\DQGQHHGOHWUDMHFWRU\1HHGOHWLSSRVLWLRQLVVHHQFOHDUO\&RORXU'RSSOHU
DOORZVVFUXWLQ\RIYDVFXODUÁRZDQGWKHUHIRUHWKHLQYHVWLJDWRUFDQKDYHJUHDWHU
FRQÀGHQFHLQDYRLGLQJLQWUDYDVFXODULQMHFWLRQ&HUYLFDOQHUYHURRWLQMHFWLRQKDVEHHQ
VKRZQWREHDIHDVLEOHDQGHIIHFWLYHWKHUDS\IRUSDWLHQWVZLWKFKURQLFV\PSWRPV
3XUSRVH7RHVWDEOLVKZKHWKHUWKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& PHDVXUHG
ZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ ':, LQWKHHQGRPHWULXPRI
KHDOWK\ZRPHQVLJQLÀFDQWO\YDULHVEHWZHHQWKHIXQGXVDQGWKHLVWKPXVRIWKHXWHUXV
DQGIURPWKHHDUO\SUROLIHUDWLYHWRWKHSHULRYXODWRU\SKDVHRIWKHPHQVWUXDOF\FOH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VHULHVRIKHDOWK\IHUWLOHZRPHQ PLQLPXPHQGRPHWULDO
WKLFNQHVV PP QR HQGRPHWULDO ÁXLG XQGHUZHQW ':, 7 E YDOXHV DQG
PPVHF ,QZRPHQ WKWKURXJKWKPHQVWUXDOGD\ WKHHQGRPHWULDO
$'&VPHDVXUHGDWWKHIXQGXV DVKLJKDVSRVVLEOH ZHUHFRPSDUHGWRWKRVHWDNHQ
DWWKHLVWKPXV FPIURPWKHLQWHUQDOFHUYLFDORV 7KHIXQGDOHQGRPHWULDO$'&V
ZHUHPRUHRYHUFDOFXODWHGLQZRPHQERWKDWWKHWKGD\DIWHUWKHEHJLQQLQJ
RIWKHF\FOHDQGDWWKHWKGD\EHIRUHWKHVXEVHTXHQWF\FOH(DFK$'&YDOXH
ZDVREWDLQHGWKURXJKWKHDYHUDJHRIWKUHHGLIIHUHQWPHDVXUHPHQWV7KHVWDWLVWLFDO
VLJQLÀFDQFH RI WKH GLIIHUHQFHV IXQGDO YV LVWKPLF SUROLIHUDWLYH YV SHULRYXODWRU\
SKDVH$'&V ZDVGHWHUPLQHGXVLQJWKH6WXGHQWҋVWWHVWSHUSDLUHGGDWD
5HVXOWV7KH$'&VDWWKHIXQGXV PHDQPPVHFUDQJH ZHUH
ORZHUWKDQDWWKHLVWKPXV PHDQUDQJH 7KHIXQGDO$'&VLQ
WKH SUROLIHUDWLYH SKDVH PHDQ UDQJH ZHUH ORZHU WKDQ LQ WKH
SHULRYXODWRU\SKDVH PHDQUDQJH %RWKGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHKLJKO\
VLJQLÀFDQWDWVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV S
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH PDJQLWXGH RI WKH YDULDWLRQV LQ HQGRPHWULDO$'&V RFFXUULQJ
LQQRUPDOZRPHQVKRXOGPDNHWKHUDGLRORJLVWVFDXWLRXVZKHQLQWHUSUHWLQJ':,
H[DPLQDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKGLVHDVH
%
%
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIÀFDF\RIXOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGLQMHFWLRQVDURXQGWKHODWHUDO
IHPRUDOFXWDQHRXVQHUYH /)&1 LQSDWLHQWVFRPSODLQLQJRIPHUDOJLDSDUHVWHWLFD
QRFWXUQDDQGWRGRFXPHQWORQJWHUPUHVXOWVDWPRQWKV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLV+,33$FRPSOLDQWVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\RXUORFDO
,QVWLWXWLRQDO5HYLHZ%RDUGLQIRUPHGRUDODQGZULWWHQFRQVHQWZHUHREWDLQHG%H
WZHHQDQGVHYHQWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKV\PSWRPVRIPHUDOJLDSDUHVWKHWLFD
QRFWXUQDLQFOXGLQJPHQ PHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH\HDUV6'
DQGZRPHQ PHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH\HDUV6' ZHUHWUHDWHG
ZLWK86JXLGHGLQMHFWLRQRIVWHURLGVDORQJWKH/)&1$YLVXDODQDORJVFDOH 9$6
PHDVXUHRIV\PSWRPVEHIRUHWUHDWPHQWDQGDIWHUPRQWKVZDVFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV &RPSOHWH UHVROXWLRQ RI V\PSWRPV ZDV GRFXPHQWHG LQ SDWLHQWV
&,>@ DQGSDUWLDOUHVROXWLRQLQWKHUHPDLQLQJ7KHVHSDWLHQWV
UHPDLQHGV\PSWRPIUHHRUPDLQWDLQHGWKHLUV\PSWRPDWLFLPSURYHPHQWDWPRQWK
IROORZXS:KHQFRPSDUHGZLWKKLVWRULFDOFRQWUROV IDLOXUHRIWUHDWPHQW RXU
XOWUDVRXQGJXLGHG WHFKQLTXH UHVXOWHG LV VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW LPSURYHPHQW LQ
SDWLHQWRXWFRPH S
&RQFOXVLRQ 86JXLGHG LQMHFWLRQ RI VWHURLGV DORQJ WKH /)&1 LQ SDWLHQWV FRP
SODLQLQJRI0HUDOJLDSDUHVWKHWLFDUHVXOWVLQPRUHIUHTXHQWORQJWHUPLPSURYHPHQW
LQ V\PSWRPV DV FRPSDUHG ZLWK KLVWRULFDO FRQWUROV WUHDWHG E\ LQMHFWLRQ ZLWKRXW
XOWUDVRXQGJXLGDQFH
3XUSRVH 05JXLGHG IRFXVHG XOWUDVRXQG VXUJHU\ 05J)86 LV D QRQLQYDVLYH
WUHDWPHQWIRUV\PSWRPDWLFXWHULQHÀEURLGV3DWLHQWVHOHFWLRQLVWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQW
VWHSWRDFKLHYHJRRGUHVXOW7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRDVVHVVWKHLQLWLDOHIÀFDF\
RIVFDOHGVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ 66, RIXWHULQHÀEURLGVLQ7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJHVDVD
QHZREMHFWLYHSDUDPHWHUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHVXLWDELOLW\IRU05J)86
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\IRXU XWHULQH ÀEURLGV LQ WZHQW\ SUHPHQRSDXVDO
$VLDQ SDWLHQWV ZHUH WUHDWHG XVLQJ 05J)86 7UHDWPHQWV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG IURP
2FWREHUWR-DQXDU\DQGPHDQDJHRIWKHSDWLHQWVZDV\HDUV
66,ZDVPHDVXUHGDW7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJHVE\VWDQGDUGLVLQJ LWV PHDQSL[HO
LQWHQVLW\WRDVFDOHXVLQJUHIHUHQFHLQWHQVLWLHVRIPXVFOH DQGIDW
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 66, LQ HDFK ÀEURLG ZDV UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ DQDO\VHG DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH
QRQSHUIXVLRQYROXPH 139 UDWLR
5HVXOWV 0HDQ 139 UDWLR LQ XWHULQH ÀEURLG RI 66, OHVV WKDQ Q ZDV
,QWKHFDVHRIXWHULQHÀEURLGRI66,PRUHWKDQ Q PHDQ139
UDWLRZDV8WHULQHÀEURLGVRI66,OHVVWKDQLQ7ZHLJKWHG05LP
DJHVVKRZHGKLJKHU139UDWLRWKDQXWHULQHÀEURLGVRI66,PRUHWKDQ
&RQFOXVLRQ6FDOHGVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RIXWHULQHÀEURLGVLQ7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJHV
FDQEHVXJJHVWHGDVDQHZREMHFWLYHSDUDPHWHUIRUWKHSDWLHQWVHOHFWLRQLQ05J)86
8WHULQHÀEURLGVRI66,OHVVWKDQLVPRUHHOLJLEOHIRU05J)86
0HUDOJLDSDUHVWKHWLFDXOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGLQMHFWLRQZLWKPRQWK
IROORZXSGDWD
5)DVFKLQJEDXHU&6LHGHQWRSI*)HXFKWQHU&0DUWLQROL:-DVFKNH
$.ODXVHU,QQVEUXFN$7*HQRD,7 FKULVWLDQVLHGHQWRSI#LPHGDFDW
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6FDOHGVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RIXWHULQHÀEURLGVLQ7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJHV
QHZREMHFWLYHSDUDPHWHUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHVXLWDELOLW\IRUPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHJXLGHGIRFXVHGXOWUDVRXQGVXUJHU\RIXWHULQHÀEURLGV
6:<RRQ*\XQJJL'R.5 MDQVRQVUDG#JPDLOFRP
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'HHSO\LQÀOWUDWLQJHQGRPHWULRVLVHYDOXDWLRQRIUHWURFHUYLFDOVSDFH
RQ05,DIWHUYDJLQDORSDFLÀFDWLRQ
9)LDVFKHWWL$0HVFKLQL6&UXVFR9&DPD/'L9LWR*6LPRQHWWL5RPH,7
DPHVNR#OLEHURLW
%
05J)86WUHDWPHQWRIXWHULQHOHLRP\RPDVUHVXOWVRQTXDOLW\RIOLIH
QRQSHUIXVHGYROXPHUDWLRDQGVL]HUHGXFWLRQRYHUPRQWKV
)&LROLQD$1DSROL0$Q]LGHL)=DFFDJQD*&DUWRFFL/%HUWDFFLQL
91RFH)%RQL&&DWDODQR5RPH,7 IHGHULFDFLROLQD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHHIÀFDF\RIVRQLFDWLRQLQV\PSWRPVUHOLHIDQGYROXPH
UHGXFWLRQRYHUWLPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVOHLRP\RPDVLQZRPHQ DYHUDJHDJH\HDUV
UDQJH ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWK05,JXLGHGIRFXVHGXOWUDVRXQG 05J)86 7KH
V\VWHP ([$EODWH,Q6LJKWHF HTXLSSHG ZLWK D SKDVHGDUUD\ WUDQVGXFHU
FRPSXWHUFRQWUROOHG SRVLWLRQLQJ V\VWHP UDGLRIUHTXHQF\ DPSOLÀHU V\VWHP RSHU
DWHV LQ FRQMXQFWLRQ ZLWK D 7 05 XQLW *( :H VFRUHG VHYHULW\ RI V\PSWRPV
DVPHQRUUKDJLDXULQDU\IUHTXHQF\SHOYLFSDLQRUEXONV\PSWRPV XVLQJDWR
SRLQWVFDOHEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWUHDWPHQW:HDOVRPHDVXUHGWKHLULPSDFWRQTXDOLW\
RIOLIHXVLQJDYLVXDODQDORJVFDOHWKHFKRLFHEDVHGZDLWLQJWUDGHRIIDQGWKHWLPH
WUDGHRII3UHWUHDWPHQWLPDJLQJVHW 7Z7ZSUHDQGSRVW*G%237$LPDJHV
ZHUHREWDLQHGWRPHDVXUHOHLRP\RPDYROXPH,PPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWUHDWPHQW7Z
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGIDWVXSSUHVVHG05LPDJHVLQWKUHHSODQHVZHUHXVHGWRPHDV
XUHQRQSHUIXVHGYROXPH 139 7KHDYHUDJHYROXPHRIWUHDWHGÀEURLGVZDV
6' FP)ROORZXSLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGDQGPRQWKVDIWHUWUHDWPHQWWR
GHWHUPLQH OHLRP\RPD VKULQNDJH 4XDOLWDWLYH DQG TXDQWLWDWLYH UHODWLRQV EHWZHHQ
ÀEURLGYROXPH139UDWLRDWWUHDWPHQWDQGPRQWKVKULQNDJHZHUHPHDVXUHG
5HVXOWV$OO SDWLHQWV VKRZHG D FRPSOHWH UHOLHI RI V\PSWRPV UHODWHG WR XWHULQH
ÀEURLGVDQGDQLQFUHDVHGTXDOLW\RIOLIH7KHDYHUDJH139UDWLRZDV
LPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWUHDWPHQW$WIROORZXSWUHDWHGÀEURLGVVKRZHGYROXPHGHFUHDVH
WRFPZLWKDQDYHUDJHYROXPHUHGXFWLRQRI$OLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQ
PRGHOVKRZHGKLJKO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSRVWWUHDWPHQWQRQSHUIXVHG
YROXPHUDWLRDQGVKULQNDJHDWPRQWKV
&RQFOXVLRQ05J)86WKHUDS\RIOH\RPLRPDVKRZVDVDQRQLQYDVLYHO\DQGVDIH
PHWKRGWRREWDLQVLJQLÀFDQWUHOLHIRIV\PSWRPVJRRG139UDWLRDQGLQPLOGVKULQN
DJHDWDQGPRQWKV
%
&RPELQHGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJDQG05
O\PSKRJUDSK\UHOLDEO\GHWHFWDQGHYDOXDWHVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHLQ
FHUYLFDOFDQFHU
==KRX+<X%=KX<+RQJ-)DQJ1DQMLQJ&1 ]\]KRX#QMXHGXFQ
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHZKHWKHU':,DQG05O\PSKRJUDSK\ 05/* UHOLDEO\GHWHFW
DQGHYDOXDWHVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHV 6/16 PHWDVWDVLVLQFHUYLFDOFDQFHU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIWKHUDSHXWLFUHVSRQVHWRFRQFXUUHQW
FKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\LQFHUYLFDOFDQFHUXVLQJEORRGR[\JHQDWLRQ
OHYHOGHSHQGHQW05LPDJLQJDW7SUHOLPLQDU\H[SHULHQFH
$.LP&.LP%3DUN6+XK<&KRQJ<&KRL-3DUN6HRXO.5
DK\HRQJNLP#VDPVXQJFRP
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHFKDQJHVLQWKHUDWHRIVSLQGHSKDVLQJ 5 YDOXHVDW
EORRGR[\JHQDWLRQOHYHOGHSHQGHQW %2/' 05,LQFHUYLFDOFDQFHUSDWLHQWVUHFHLYLQJ
FRQFXUUHQWFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\ &&57 DQGWRDVVHVVWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ
WXPRXU5 YDOXHVDQGÀQDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVHVWRWUHDWPHQW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK ELRSV\SURYHQ FHUYLFDO
FDQFHUZHUHH[DPLQHGE\7ZHLJKWHGDQG%2/'05,DW7%2/'05,ZDV
SHUIRUPHGXVLQJDPXOWLSOHIDVWÀHOGHFKR P))( VHTXHQFHWRDFTXLUH7
ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVZLWKLQDVLQJOHEUHDWKKROG$OOSDWLHQWVZKRWUHDWHGZLWK&&57
SHUIRUPHGWZRVHULDO05H[DPLQDWLRQV>LHSULRUWRWKHUDS\ SUH7[ DQGPRQWK
DIWHUWKHFRPSOHWLRQRIWKHUDS\ SRVW7[ @$WHDFKWKHUDSHXWLFSRLQW5 YDOXH
VHF ZDVFDOFXODWHGLQWKHWXPRXUDQGQRUPDOP\RPHWULXP)LQDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVH
DVGHWHUPLQHGE\FKDQJHVLQWXPRXUVL]HXVLQJ05,^ SUH7[SRVW7[ SUH7[`
ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKWXPRXU5 YDOXHVDWSUH7[
5HVXOWV7KHÀQDOWXPRXUVL]HUHVSRQVHZDV7KHPHDQ5 YDOXHVRIWKH
WXPRXUVZHUHDWSUH7[DQGDWSRVW7[UHVSHFWLYHO\ZKLFK
VKRZHG D VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH 3 +RZHYHU WKH PHDQ 5 YDOXHV RI
QRUPDOP\RPHWULXPZHUHDWSUH7[DQGDWSRVW7[UHVSHF
WLYHO\ZKLFKGLGQRWVKRZDVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH 3 $WSUH7[WXPRXU5
YDOXHVVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\QHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKÀQDOWXPRXUVL]HUHVSRQVH
3 6SHDUPDQ VFRHIÀFLHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ%2/'05,DW7PD\EHKHOSIXOWRHYDOXDWHWKHUDSHXWLFUHVSRQVH
LQFHUYLFDOFDQFHUV7KHVHSRVVLELOLWLHVDZDLWIXUWKHUVWXGLHV
%
3UHRSHUDWLYHVWDJLQJRISDWLHQWVZLWKFHUYLFDOFDUFLQRPD
FRPSDULVRQRIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJDQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLF
HYDOXDWLRQ
%%DQNR50LOHQNRYLF0.UDWRYDF'XQMLF*/LOLF-'MRNLF.RYDF
50DNVLPRYLF%HOJUDGH56 ERMDQEDQNR#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, LVUHFRPPHQGHGIRUSUHRSHUDWLYH
DVVHVVPHQWRIORFDOWXPRXUH[WHQVLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWK),*2VWDJH,%RUKLJKHU
DIWHUKLVWRORJLFDOFRQÀUPDWLRQ7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHGLDJQRVWLF
YDOXHRI05LQSUHRSHUDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRISDWLHQWVZLWKFHUYLFDOWXPRXUVDQGWR
RSWLPLVHIXUWKHUWKHUDSHXWLFDSSURDFK
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWKSUHRS
HUDWLYH05,DQGFHUYLFDOELRSV\WKDWFRQÀUPHGFHUYLFDOFDUFLQRPD7KHUHIRUHWKH
SDWLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVJURXSSDWLHQWVZLWK),*2,,DZKRXQGHUJR
VXUJHU\DQGJURXS),*2EZKRGLGQRWKDYHVXUJHU\,QDGGLWLRQLQSDWLHQWV
ZKRXQGHUZHQWVXUJHU\05ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDO
UHSRUWRIWKHK\VWHUHFWRP\VSHFLPHQ
5HVXOWV$FFRUGLQJWR05,ÀQGLQJV SDWLHQWVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDV7
SDWLHQWVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDV7DSDWLHQWV DV7E DV7
DQGSDWLHQWV DV7ZKLOHRQSDWKRKLVWRORJLFDOVSHFLPHQVDIWHUVXUJHU\
ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDV7 DV7DDV7E DV7DQG
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\LQYHVWLJDWHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHDQGWROHUDELOLW\RI05,ZLWK
LQWUDYDJLQDOJHORSDFLÀFDWLRQIRUGLDJQRVLVDQGSUHRSHUDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIGHHSO\
LQÀOWUDWLQJHQGRPHWULRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QHKXQGUHGDQGVL[ZRPHQZLWKFOLQLFDOVXVSLFLRQRI
GHHSO\LQÀOWUDWLQJHQGRPHWULRVLVZHUHSUHYLRXVO\H[DPLQHGZLWKWUDQVYDJLQDOXOWUD
VRQRJUDSK\DQGZLWK05,SUHDQGSRVWDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIYDJLQDOJHO:HHYDOXDWHG
WKHWROHUDELOLW\RIWKLVSURFHGXUHZLWKDVFRULQJVFDOHIURPWR:HDOVRDVVHVVHG
ZLWKDVFRUHIURPWRWKHYLVLELOLW\RIIRXUUHJLRQV'RXJODVSRXFKXWHURVDFUDO
OLJDPHQWVSRVWHULRUYDJLQDOIRUQL[DQGUHFWRYDJLQDOVHSWXP$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
ODSDURVFRSLFVXUJHU\DIWHU05,
5HVXOWV1LQHSDWLHQWVFRQVLGHUHGSURFHGXUHLQWROHUDEOH9LVLELOLW\RIXWHURVDFUDO
OLJDPHQWVDQGSRVWHULRUYDJLQDOIRUQL[VKRZHGWREHLQFUHDVHGZLWKJHO S
,QRXWRISDWLHQWV05,KDVDOORZHGXVWRGLDJQRVHGHHSO\LQÀOWUDWLQJHQGRPH
WULRVLV7KHSHUFHQWDJHVRI05,VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQG
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHZHUHUHVSHFWLYHO\DQGZLWKRXW
JHODQGDQGZLWKJHOWUDQVYDJLQDOXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\
VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHZHUH
DQG,QHYDOXDWLRQRIXWHURVDFUDOOLJDPHQWVWUDQVYDJLQDO
XOWUDVRQRJUDSK\05,ZLWKRXWJHODQGZLWKJHOVHQVLWLYLW\ZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\
DQG IRU UHFWRYDJLQDOVHSWXP WKHVH YDOXHV ZHUH DQG
IRUSRXFKRI'RXJODVDQGIRUSRVWHULRUYDJLQDOIRUQL[
DQG
&RQFOXVLRQ05,ZLWKJHORSDFLÀFDWLRQRIYDJLQDVKRXOGEHUHFRPPHQGHGIRUVXV
SLFLRQRIGHHSLQÀOWUDWLQJHQGRPHWULRVLVLQSDUWLFXODUIRUWKHDGGHGYDOXHLQHYDOX
DWLRQRIUHFWRYDJLQDOVHSWXPXWHURVDFUDOOLJDPHQWVDQGSRVWHULRUYDJLQDOIRUQL[
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\HLJKWSDWLHQWVZLWKFHUYLFDOFDQFHUZHUHSUHRSHUD
WLYHO\XQGHUZHQWLQWHUVWLWLDO05/*ZLWK2PQLVFDQDIWHUFRPSOHWLQJWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO
05,DQG':,H[DPLQDWLRQVDQGWKHÀUVWO\PSKQRGHLQWKHO\PSKDWLFGUDLQDJH
SDWKZD\ ZDV GHÀQHG DV WKH 6/1 %OXH G\H 6/1 ELRSV\ ZDV SHUIRUPHG RQ DOO
SDWLHQWV7KHPRUSKRORJLFIHDWXUHVRIDOOWKH6/1VRQ05O\PSKRJUDSKLFLPDJHV
ZHUH DQDO\VHG 7KH UHODWLYH DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW U$'& RI HDFK 6/1
ZDVPHDVXUHG'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDFLHVRIWKHFRPELQHG05/*DQG':,DSSURDFK
FRPSDUHGZLWKRQO\05/*ZLWKRXW':,YHUVXVKLVWRSDWKRORJ\ZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV$OOORFDOLVHG6/1VFRUUHVSRQGHGZHOOZLWK6/1VLGHQWLÀHGRQ6/1ELRSV\
,QSDWLHQWVZLWKQRQPHWDVWDWLF6/1VRYDOHQKDQFHG6/1VZHUHYLVXDOLVHGE\05
/*,QSDWLHQWVZLWKPHWDVWDWLF6/1VWKHHQKDQFHG6/1VZHUHYLVXDOLVHGZLWKRU
ZLWKRXWÀOOLQJGHIHFWVLQDOOSDWLHQWVH[FHSWWKUHHLQZKLFK6/1VZHUHQRWHQKDQFHG
7KHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\DQGSRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHV
339DQG139 IRUXVLQJÀOOLQJGHIHFWVRQ05/*DVDGLDJQRVWLFFULWHULRQZHUH
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\0HDQZKLOHWKHUHZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ PHWDVWDWLF DQG QRQPHWDVWDWLF 6/16 LQ U$'&
3 :LWKWKHDGGLWLRQRI':,WKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDFLHVLQFUHDVHGVHQVLWLYLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\339139
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHFRPELQDWLRQRI':,DQG05/*ZDVXVHIXOLQGHWHFWLQJWKH6/1V
DQGLQLPSURYLQJWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI6/1PHWDVWDVHVLQFHUYLFDOFDQFHU
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
SDWLHQWVZHUHFODVVLÀHGSDWLHQWVDV77KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQ05VWDJLQJDQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVRIELRSV\VSHFLPHQV ѩ
S )XUWKHUPRUHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRU05,IRUJURXSZDVDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ZKLOHIRUJURXSZDVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ05LVDXVHIXOGLDJQRVWLFPHWKRGLQSUHRSHUDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWDQG
IXUWKHUWKHUDSHXWLFGHFLVLRQPDNLQJSURFHVVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKFHUYLFDOFDUFLQRPD
%
0RGHUDWRUV
8%LFN%HUOLQ'(
6*DQDX0DFtDV6DEDGHOO(6
'\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGLPDJLQJIRUHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHUDSHXWLF
UHVSRQVHWRFRQFXUUHQWFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\LQFHUYLFDOFDQFHU
<.LP-0LQ&.LP%3DUN6HRXO.5 \NNLP#VDPVXQJFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHFKDQJHVRITXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVRIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGLPDJLQJ '&(, LQFHUYLFDOFDQFHUVEHIRUHGXULQJDQGDIWHUFRQFXUUHQW
FKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\ &&57 DQG WR DVVHVV UHODWLRQVKLS EHWZHHQ TXDQWLWDWLYH
SDUDPHWHUVRIWKHWXPRXUVDQGÀQDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVHVWRWUHDWPHQW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK ELRSV\SURYHQ FHUYLFDO
FDQFHUZHUHHQUROOHG'&(,ZDVREWDLQHGXVLQJ7ZHLJKWHG'IDVWÀHOGHFKR
VHTXHQFHDW73KDUPDFRNLQHWLFDQDO\VLVXVLQJDQH[WHQGHG.HW\PRGHOZDV
SHUIRUPHG$OO SDWLHQWV ZKR WUHDWHG ZLWK &&57 SHUIRUPHG WKUHH VHULDO 05 H[
DPLQDWLRQV>LHSULRUWRWKHUDS\ SUH7[ DWWKHIRXUWKZHHNRIWKHUDS\ PLG7[
DQGPRQWKDIWHUWKHFRPSOHWLRQRIWKHUDS\ SRVW7[ @$WHDFKWKHUDSHXWLFSRLQW
TXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUV LH.WUDQV9HDQG.HS ZHUHFDOFXODWHGLQWKHWXPRXUV
DQGQRUPDOJOXWHXVPXVFOHV)LQDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVHVDVGHWHUPLQHGE\FKDQJHV
LQWXPRXUVL]HRUYROXPHXVLQJ05,^ SUH7[SRVW7[ SUH7[`ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWK
TXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVRIWKHWXPRXU
5HVXOWV%HWZHHQWKHUDSHXWLFSRLQWVDOOTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVRIWKHWXPRXUV
UHYHDOHGDVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH 3 ZKLOHWKRVHRIQRUPDOJOXWHXVPXV
FOHVVKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH 3! 7KHPHDQYDOXHRIÀQDOWXPRXU
UHVSRQVHIRUWKHVL]HDQGYROXPHZDVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\4XDQWLWDWLYH
SDUDPHWHUVRIWKHWXPRXUVDWSUH7[RUPLG7[ZHUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\DVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKÀQDOWXPRXUVL]HRUYROXPHUHVSRQVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ4XDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVRI'&(,UHYHDOHGWKHWKHUDSHXWLFFKDQJHV
WR&&57LQFHUYLFDOFDQFHUVFRPSDUHGZLWKQRUPDOJOXWHXVPXVFOHV+RZHYHU
WKHSDUDPHWHUVLQFHUYLFDOFDQFHUVZHUHQRWDVVRFLDWHGZLWKÀQDOWXPRXUVL]HRU
YROXPHUHVSRQVHV
%
&RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWXPRXUVL]HDQGVXUYHLOODQFHRIO\PSKQRGH
PHWDVWDVLVIRU,EDQG,,DFHUYLFDOFDQFHUE\05,
%.ZRQ6.LP%5KR($KQ'DHJX.5 UDGRUL\D#QDYHUFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHIHDVLELOLW\RISUHRSHUDWLYH05,EDVHGPHDVXUHPHQWRIWX
PRXUVL]HZLWKUHJDUGWRO\PSKQRGH /1 PHWDVWDVLVLQHDUO\XWHULQHFHUYLFDOFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$UHWURVSHFWLYHUHYLHZRISDWLHQWVZLWK),*2VWDJH,%
,,$FHUYLFDOFDQFHUZKRXQGHUZHQWO\PSKDGHQHFWRP\ZDVSHUIRUPHG'LDJQRVWLF
DFFXUDF\RI05,LQGHWHFWLQJ/1PHWDVWDVLVDQGUDWHRI/1UHFXUUHQFHLQWHUPVRI
WXPRXUVL]H FPYHUVXV!FP ZHUHDQDO\VHG52&FXUYHDQDO\VLVZDVXVHG
WR GHWHUPLQH /1 VL]H IRU GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ /1 PHWDVWDVLV LQ WHUPV RI WXPRXU VL]H
3ZDVFRQVLGHUHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV2IWKHSDWLHQWV KDG/1PHWDVWDVLV7KHUHZDVQRVWDWLVWL
FDOGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQSDWLHQWVEDVHGDQGUHJLRQVSHFLÀFDQDO\VLV7KHSDWLHQWV
ZLWKWXPRXUVL]HZLWK!FPUHYHDOHGKLJKHUGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI05,LQGH
WHFWLQJ/1PHWDVWDVLV YHUVXV3 DQGUDWHRI/1UHFXUUHQFH
YHUVXV3 LQWKDQWKRVHZLWKVL]HZLWKFPWKHGLIIHUHQFHV
ZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW'LVFULPLQDQWDQDO\VLVRI/1VL]HIRUWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ
RIPHWDVWDVLVIURPQRQPHWDVWDVLVUHVXOWHGLQFXWRIIYDOXHV PPVL]HZLWK
!FPYHUVXVPPVL]HZLWKFP DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ RIVL]H
ZLWK!FPYHUVXVRIVL]HZLWKFP
&RQFOXVLRQ05,KDVOLPLWHGVHQVLWLYLW\EXWKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\LQSUHGLFWLQJVXUYHLO
ODQFHRI/1PHWDVWDVLVLQWKHSUHRSHUDWLYHHDUO\FHUYLFDOFDQFHUHVSHFLDOO\XVHIXO
WRROIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKWXPRXUVL]HZLWK!FP
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP)
%UHDVW
66
8OWUDVRXQGQHZGHYHORSPHQWV
%
$GGLWLRQDOEUHDVWXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 86 WRQHJDWLYHPDPPRJUDSK\
LPSDFWRQFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQDQGLQYDVLYHDVVHVVPHQWUDWH
9*LUDUGL07RQHJXWWL(0DQIULQ)%RQHWWL3HVFKLHUDGHO*DUGD,7
JLUDYHUR#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHRXWFRPHRIOHVLRQVGHWHFWHGE\86LQDV\PSWRPDWLF
ZRPHQZLWKQHJDWLYHPDPPRJUDSK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2XWRIVHOIUHIHUULQJZRPHQXQGHUJRLQJWRFOLQLFDO
H[DPLQDWLRQPDPPRJUDSK\DQGXOWUDVRXQG SHULRG DV\PS
WRPDWLFZRPHQZHUHVFUHHQHGZLWKELODWHUDO8686FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQZDVEDVHG
RQ%,5$'6FULWHULD QHJDWLYHEHQLJQ%,5$'6SUREDEO\EHQLJQ%,5$'6
LQGHWHUPLQDWHVXVSLFLRXV%,5$'6 $OOLQGHWHUPLQDWHVXVSLFLRXV86ÀQGLQJV
XQGHUZHQW LQYDVLYH DVVHVVPHQW )LQH QHHGOH DVSLUDWLRQ F\WRORJ\ )1$&
JDXJHQHHGOH ZDVFXUUHQWO\WKHÀUVWVWHSIROORZHGE\QHHGOHFRUHELRSV\ 1&%
JDXJHQHHGOH 7KHPDOLJQDQWDQGDW\SLFDOOHVLRQVZHUHUHIHUUHGWRVXUJHU\7KH
SDWKRORJLFDOUHVXOWVUHSUHVHQWHGWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
5HVXOWV2YHUDOOWKHUHZHUHFDQFHUV FDQFHUVZHUHGHWHFWHGE\
PDPPRJUDSK\DQG RQO\E\862IWRWDOLQYDVLYHSURFHGXUHV
ZHUHSURPSWHGE\PDPPRJUDSK\DQG ZHUHSURPSWHGRQO\
E\86 )1$&1&% /HVLRQVGHWHFWHGE\PDPPRJUDSK\UHVXOWHGPDOLJQDQW
LQ DQGEHQLJQLQ /HVLRQVGHWHFWHGE\86UHVXOWHG
PDOLJQDQWLQ DQGEHQLJQLQ 7KHEHQLJQWRPDOLJQDQW
RSHQVXUJLFDOELRSV\UDWLRE\86ZDV EHQLJQYHUVXVPDOLJQDQW &RP
SDUHGWRPDPPRJUDSK\WKHUHODWLYHLQFUHPHQWDOEUHDVWFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQUDWHE\
86ZDV DQGWKHUHODWLYHLQFUHPHQWDOEHQLJQOHVLRQVGHWHFWLRQUDWH
E\86ZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ$GGLWLRQRI86WRQHJDWLYHPDPPRJUDSK\DOORZVIRUDVXEVWDQWLDO
FDQFHUGHWHFWLRQLQFUHDVHRI86JHQHUDWHGDPDMRULQFUHPHQWRILQYD
VLYHGLDJQRVWLFDVVHVVPHQW,WWRRNDERXW86H[DPLQDWLRQVDQGLQYDVLYH
SURFHGXUHVWRGHWHFWRQHDGGLWLRQDOFDQFHU,IWKHFRVWVZHUHVXVWDLQDEOHZRPHQ
PD\EHQHÀWIURP86VFUHHQLQJ
%
'LDJQRVWLFDVVHVVPHQWRIGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\VFUHHQLQJ
HYLGHQFHRQLQFUHPHQWDOEUHDVWFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQE\ELODWHUDO
XOWUDVRXQGH[DPLQDWLRQ
6:HLJHO:+HLQGHO&%LHVKHXYHO
0XHQVWHU'( ELHVKHXYHO#UHIHUHQ]]HQWUXPPVGH
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH FRQWULEXWLRQ RI ELODWHUDO XOWUDVRXQG 86 LQ GHWHFWLQJ
DGGLWLRQDOEUHDVWFDQFHUDWGLDJQRVWLFDVVHVVPHQWRIOHVLRQVGHWHFWHGZLWKGLJLWDO
PDPPRJUDSK\VFUHHQLQJ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ZRPHQ XQGHUZHQW DGGLWLRQDO PDPPRJUDSKLF
LPDJLQJDQGELODWHUDOZKROHEUHDVW86H[DPLQDWLRQDWRXUVFUHHQLQJDVVHVVPHQW
XQLW:HFDOFXODWHGWKHLQFUHPHQWDOEUHDVWFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQUDWHDQGDVVRFLDWHG
IDOVHSRVLWLYHUDWHIRU86DQGPDPPRJUDSK\SHUDVVHVVPHQWSDUWLFLSDQWDQGSHU
EUHDVWVLGH UHFDOODQGFRQWUDODWHUDO
5HVXOWV ZRPHQ ZHUH GLDJQRVHG ZLWK FDQFHU OHVLRQV 6HYHQ SDWLHQWV
ZHUHGLDJQRVHGZLWKDFDQFHUOHVLRQGHWHFWHGE\86RQO\\LHOGLQJDQLQFUHPHQWDO
EUHDVWFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQUDWHRISHUDVVHVVPHQWSDUWLFLSDQW)RUDQDGGLWLRQDO
WZRSDWLHQWV86FKDQJHGWKHGLDJQRVLVIURPXQLODWHUDOWRELODWHUDOEUHDVWFDQFHU
7KXVDWRWDORIQLQHFDQFHUOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGE\86RQO\IRXUZHUHGHWHFWHGLQ
UHFDOOVLGHVÀYHLQFRQWUDODWHUDOVLGHVUHVXOWLQJLQLQFUHPHQWDOEUHDVWFDQFHUGHWHF
WLRQUDWHVRIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHDVVRFLDWHGIDOVHSRVLWLYHELRSV\
UDWHVZHUH LQUHFDOOVLGHVDQG LQFRQWUDODWHUDOVLGHV
FRPSDUHGWR DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\IRUPDPPRJUDSK\RQO\
LQGLFDWHGELRSVLHV7KHSURSRUWLRQRILQYDVLYHFDQFHUVPPZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
ORZHUDPRQJ86RQO\GHWHFWHGFDQFHUV FRPSDUHGWRWKRVHGHWHFWHGZLWK
PDPPRJUDSK\RQO\ S
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ:HVKRZHGWKDWVXSSOHPHQWDOZKROHEUHDVW86GHWHFWHGDGGLWLRQDO
EUHDVWFDQFHUOHVLRQVLQERWKUHFDOODQGFRQWUDODWHUDOEUHDVWVLGHVWKDWZHUHRFFXOW
RQPDPPRJUDP7KLVH[WUDFDQFHU\LHOGVKRXOGEHZHLJKHGFDUHIXOO\DJDLQVWWKH
DVVRFLDWHGIDOVHSRVLWLYHELRSVLHVDQGVXEVWDQWLDOFRVWVRIELODWHUDO86
%
%
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGHWHFWLRQSHUIRUPDQFHRIDXWRPDWHGZKROHEUHDVWXO
WUDVRXQG $:86 LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKKDQGKHOGEUHDVWXOWUDVRXQG ++86 DQGWR
HYDOXDWHWKHLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\LQWKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRI$:86
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP2FWREHURIWR0DUFKRIELODWHUDODXWR
PDWHGZKROHEUHDVWXOWUDVRXQGZDVSHUIRUPHGLQFRQVHFXWLYHEUHDVWFDQFHU
SDWLHQWVZKRZHUHVFKHGXOHGIRUEUHDVW05,7RWDOOHVLRQVZHUHLQFOXGHG
LQGH[FDQFHUVDGGLWLRQDOPDOLJQDQFLHVDQGEHQLJQOHVLRQV7KUHHEUHDVW
UDGLRORJLVWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\UHYLHZHG$:86GDWDDQGDQDO\VHGWKHEUHDVWOHVLRQV
DFFRUGLQJWRWKH%,5$'6FODVVLÀFDWLRQ'HWHFWLRQUDWHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
RIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQVZHUHFDOFXODWHGDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDUL
DELOLWLHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJ&RKHQҋVNDSSDVWDWLVWLFV
5HVXOWV 'HWHFWLRQ UDWH RI LQGH[ OHVLRQ DQG DGGLWLRQDO PDOLJQDQF\ ZDV
LQ++86 DQG IRUWKUHHUHDGHUV
RI$:866HQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUH LQ++86
LQUHDGHU LQUHDGHU
DQG LQUHDGHU7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
LQUDGLRORJLVWVҋGHWHFWLRQSHUIRUPDQFHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\DPRQJ++86DQG
$:86 S 7KHLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVIDLUWRDOPRVWSHUIHFWDJUHHPHQW
IRU86IHDWXUHVFDWHJRULVDWLRQVL]HDQGORFDWLRQRILQGH[PDVVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ$:86 LV WKRXJKW WR EH XVHIXO IRU GHWHFWLQJ EUHDVW OHVLRQ$:86
VKRZHG QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH RI GHWHFWLRQ UDWH VHQVLWLYLW\ DQG VSHFLÀFLW\ LQ
FRPSDULVRQZLWK++86DQGWKHUHZHUHKLJKGHJUHHVRILQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQW
$GGLWLRQDOEUHDVWXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 86 LQDV\PSWRPDWLFZRPHQ
ZLWKQHJDWLYHPDPPRJUDSK\DUHWKHUHULVNFDWHJRULHVWKDWEHQHÀW
PRUHWKDQRWKHUV"
9*LUDUGL07RQHJXWWL(0DQIULQ)%RQHWWL3HVFKLHUDGHO*DUGD,7
JLUDYHUR#\DKRRLW
%
/HVLRQGHWHFWLRQLQ'86DXWRPDWHGEUHDVWYROXPHVFDQV $%96
FRUUHODWLRQZLWKEUHDVW05,
7$)DVVDHUW,-0'XEHODDU0')GH-RQJ*--DJHU0-&05XWWHQ
'HQ%RVFK1/ WIDVVDHUW#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI'86DXWRPDWHGEUHDVWYROXPH
VFDQQLQJ $%96 UHODWHGWR05EUHDVWLPDJLQJXVLQJ%,5$'6FODVVLÀFDWLRQDV
GLVFULPLQDWRU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 'XULQJ D PRQWK SHULRG DOO SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW
EUHDVW05,ZHUHUHTXHVWHGWRKDYHDGGLWLRQDO$%96FRQGXFWHGRIWKHLUEUHDVWV
3DWLHQWVXQGHU\HDUVRIDJHPDOHVSDWLHQWVXQDEOHWRXQGHUJR05,RUJLYH
LQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZHUHH[FOXGHG7LPHEHWZHHQEUHDVW05,DQG$%96ZDV
GD\V6FDQSURWRFROGHSHQGVRQEUHDVWVL]H,QFXS$&VFDQVDQGLQVL]H'
DQG'VFDQVSHUEUHDVWDUHREWDLQHG5HVXOWLQJ'86GDWDLVHYDOXDWHGRQD
GHGLFDWHGZRUNVWDWLRQE\DQH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWZKRLVEOLQGHGIRU05,ÀQGLQJV
7KH'86ÀQGLQJVDUHHYDOXDWHGXVLQJWKH%,5$'6FODVVLÀFDWLRQIRUXOWUDVRXQG
05ÀQGLQJVDUHXVHGDVJROGVWDQGDUGDQGZKHQDYDLODEOHDOVRKLVWRSDWKRORJLF
FRUUHODWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV2XWRIFRQVHFXWLYHVFDQQHGSDWLHQWVZLWK05LPDJLQJRIWKHEUHDVWV
SDWLHQWVSDUWLFLSDWHGLQRXUVWXG\,QQHDUO\DOOSDWLHQWV$%96ZDVWHFKQLFDOO\
VXFFHVVIXODQGEUHDVWWLVVXHZDVYLVLEOHIURPVNLQWRWKRUDFLFZDOO7KHD[LOODU\
UHJLRQFRXOGQRWVXIÀFLHQWO\EHYLVXDOLVHGIRUHYDOXDWLRQLQPRVWSDWLHQWV6RIDU
SDWLHQWVDUHHYDOXDWHG'86HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHEUHDVWVKRZVDVHQVLWLYLW\RI
DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIFRPSDUHGWR05LPDJLQJÀQGLQJV,QFRPLQJPRQWKV
DOOSDWLHQWVZLOOEHHYDOXDWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSDUHGWR05,'86VKRZVKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQ
WKH GHWHFWLRQ RI VXVSLFLRXV OHVLRQV$%96 VHHPV D SURPLVLQJ QHZ XOWUDVRXQG
WHFKQLTXHLQEUHDVWHYDOXDWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
:KDWLVSDWKRORJ\XQGHUO\LQJVWLIIQHVV"8OWUDVRXQGHODVWRJUDSK\RI
DKXPDQEUHDVWFDQFHUPRGHOZLWKSDWKRORJLFDOFRUUHODWLRQ
)&KDPPLQJҋV+/DWRUUH9)LWRXVVL0$/H)UHUH%HOGD/3LGLDO
-/*HQQLVVRQ&$&XHQRG2&OHPHQW/6)RXUQLHU3DULV)5
IRXFDXOGFKDPPLQJV#HJSDSKSIU
3XUSRVH7KH SXUSRVH RI WKLV VWXG\ ZDV WR DVVHVV VWLIIQHVV XVLQJ VKHDUZDYH
HODVWRJUDSK\ 6:( GXULQJWXPRXUJURZWKLQDKXPDQEUHDVWFDQFHULPSODQWHGLQ
PLFHDQGWRFRUUHODWHWKHUHVXOWVZLWKSDWKRORJ\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$KXPDQLQYDVLYHGXFWDOFDUFLQRPDZDVLPSODQWHGVXE
FXWDQHRXVO\LQDWK\PLFIHPDOHPLFH8OWUDVRXQGZDVORQJLWXGLQDOO\SHUIRUPHG
GXULQJJURZWKLQWXPRXUVXVLQJD0+]SUREHHYHU\ZHHNV0D[LPXP
GLDPHWHUDQGPHDQHODVWLFLW\YDOXHZHUHFROOHFWHG6HYHQWXPRXUVZHUHPHDVXUHG
LQ YLYR DQG H[ YLYR )RU SDWKRORJLFDO DQDO\VLV WXPRXUV RI GLIIHUHQW VL]HV ZHUH
UHPRYHG7KHIROORZLQJHOHPHQWVZHUHTXDQWLÀHGWKHSURSRUWLRQRIҊYLDEOHҋDQG
ҊQRQYLDEOHҋWLVVXHWKHҊRYHUDOOFHOOXODULW\ҋWKHҊRYHUDOOÀEURVLVUDWHҋDQGWKHҊRYHUDOO
0LFUR9DVFXODU'HQVLW\ 09' ҋ$ҊSDWKRORJLFDOVWLIIQHVVVFRUHҋ 366 FRPELQLQJ
WKHVHSDWKRORJLFDOHOHPHQWVZDVFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV$ WRWDO RI 6:( ORQJLWXGLQDO PHDVXUHPHQWV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG 7KH
PHDQHODVWLFLW\YDOXHLQFUHDVHGGXULQJWXPRXUJURZWKZLWKDQH[FHOOHQWFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKVL]H U S :HIRXQGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKH
YDOXHVRIHODVWLFLW\LQYLYRDQGH[YLYR S 7KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQHODVWLFLW\DQG09' U S DQGFHOOXODULW\ U S
EXWQRVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZLWKÀEURVLV U S 7KHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ
HODVWLFLW\DQGWKH 366 ZDVYHU\JRRG U S
&RQFOXVLRQ6:(PHDVXUHGVWLIIQHVVFKDQJHVGXULQJWXPRXUJURZWKLQDKXPDQ
EUHDVWFDQFHUPRGHOLPSODQWHGLQPLFHUHÁHFWLQJXQGHUO\LQJSDWKRORJLFDOFKDQJHV
7KHUHZDVDJRRGFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQHODVWLFLW\DQGDҊ366ҋ
%
6KHDU:DYHHODVWRJUDSK\ZRUOGZLGHEUHDVWWULDOPRGHOFDQ
DGGLWLRQDO6:(IHDWXUHVVXSSRUWGRZQJUDGLQJ%,5$'6WR%,5$'6"
).:6FKDHIHU:%HUJ'&RVJURYH-*D\06+HQU\2:ROI
&&RKHQ%DFULH,QWHUQDWLRQDO%(FROODERUDWLYHVWXG\JURXS
.LHO'( IVFKDHIHU#HPDLOXQLNLHOGH
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHDGGHGYDOXHRI6KHDU:DYH(ODVWRJUDSK\ 6:( LQ
WKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI%,5$'6EUHDVWOHVLRQVDVFRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDO
XOWUDVRXQG DORQH LQ DQ LQWHUQDWLRQDOPXOWLFHQWUHVWXG\ %(FROODERUDWLYHVWXG\
JURXS ZRUOGZLGHWULDO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVVFKHGXOHGIRUDEUHDVWXOWUDVRXQGZHUHUHFUXLWHG
WRWKH%(VWXG\ZKLFKZDVDSSURYHGE\WKH,5%RIHDFKFHQWUHOHVLRQVIURP
FHQWUHVZRUOGZLGHZHUHHQWHUHGDOOKLVWRORJLFDOF\WRORJLFDOFRQÀUPHG6LJQLÀFDQW
6:(IHDWXUHVWRDGG%,5$'6WRLPSURYHOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQTXDOLWDWLYH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH FDQFHU GHWHFWLRQ RI 86 LQ DGGLWLRQ WR QHJDWLYH PDP
PRJUDSK\LQDV\PSWRPDWLFZRPHQDQGWRFRUUHODWHZLWKDJHULVNIDFWRUVPDP
PRJUDSKLFGHQVLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'XULQJD\HDUSHULRG DVHULHVRI
VHOIUHIHUULQJZRPHQXQGHUZHQWWRFOLQLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQPDPPRJUDSK\DQGXOWUD
VRXQGDV\PSWRPDWLFZRPHQ QREUHDVWD[LOODU\VLJQ ZLWKQHJDWLYHPDP
PRJUDSK\FRQVWLWXWHGWKHSRSXODWLRQVWXG\ DJH\HDUVLQ\HDUVLQ
\HDUVLQSUHYLRXVKLVWRU\RIEUHDVWFDQFHULQ &DQFHUVGHWHFWHG
E\86ZDVDVVHVVHGLQWKHSRSXODWLRQDVZHOODVLQVXESRSXODWLRQVJURXSHGE\
DJH \HDUV\HDUV EUHDVWGHQVLW\ %,5$'6$&5FDWHJRULHVIDWW\EUHDVWV
'GHQVHEUHDVWV' SDWLHQWKLVWRU\ SUHYLRXVEUHDVWFDQFHUQRSUHYLRXV
FDQFHU KRUPRQDOVWDWXV IHUWLOHPHQRSDXVDO )LVKHU VH[DFWWHVWZDVXVHGIRU
VWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV VLJQLÀFDQWSYDOXH
5HVXOWV2YHUDOOEUHDVWFDQFHUVZHUHGLDJQRVHGFDQFHUV ZHUH
LGHQWLÀHGE\PDPPRJUDSK\7KHUHPDLQLQJFDQFHUV ZHUHGLDJQRVHGE\
86DORQH7KH86GHWHFWLRQUDWHIRUWRWDOSRSXODWLRQZDVÆ,QWKHVXEJURXSVLW
ZDVÆLQZRPHQ\HDUVYVÆLQZRPHQ!\HDUV S Æ
LQGHQVHEUHDVWVYVÆLQIDWW\EUHDVWV S ÆLQZRPHQZLWKSUHYLRXV
FDQFHUYVÆLQZRPHQZLWKRXWSUHYLRXVFDQFHU S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDGGLWLRQRIXOWUDVRXQGWRPDPPRJUDSK\UHVXOWHGLQDQLQFUHDVHRI
EUHDVWFDQFHUGHWHFWHGRI7KHDJHDQGWKHEUHDVWGHQVLW\KDYHQRVLJQLÀFDQW
HIIHFW RQ 86 SHUIRUPDQFH 0RVW 86GHWHFWHG FDQFHUV RFFXUUHG LQ ZRPHQ ZLWK
SHUVRQDOKLVWRU\RIEUHDVWFDQFHU
$XWRPDWHGZKROHEUHDVWXOWUDVRXQGUDGLRORJLVWVҋGHWHFWLRQ
SHUIRUPDQFHDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\
+.DQJ6.LP%.DQJ6HRXO.5 KHUD#FDWKROLFDFNU
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
YDULDEOHVHODVWRJUDSK\VKDSHHODVWRJUDSK\KRPRJHQHLW\TXDQWLWDWLYHYDULDEOHV
OHVLRQGLPHQVLRQPD[LPXPVWLIIQHVV N3D PHGLDQHODVWLFLW\PHDQOHVLRQIDWUDWLR
PHDQHODVWLFLW\GLDPHWHUUDWLR$OO VWDQGDUG FDOFXODWLRQV RI VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\
QHJDWLYHDQGSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQGSYDOXHZHUHSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV OHVLRQVZHUHEHQLJQ PDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV
ZHUHVFRUHG%,5$'67KHUHIHUHQFHWHVWZDV%,5$'6DQG%,5$'6
!7KHUHZHUHQRFDQFHUVLQWKH%,5$'6JURXS7KHUHIRUHWKHUHFODVVLÀFDWLRQ
RIWKHOHVLRQVFRQVLVWHGRQO\LQGRZQJUDGLQJ%,5$'6WRDQHZ%,5$'6CJURXS
ZKHQWKH6:(IHDWXUHZDVQRWVXVSLFLRXV%,5$'6DORQHKDGDVHQVLWLYLW\RI
VSHFLÀFLW\3391395RXQGVKDSHRQ6:(DSSHDUVWR
EHDKHOSIXOÀQGLQJWRDOWHUFOLQLFDOPDQDJHPHQW QRPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVS
1RPDOLJQDQFLHVZHUHIRXQGZLWKPD[LPXPVWLIIQHVVN3D JDLQRIVSHFLÀFLW\
S PHGLDQHODVWLFLW\PHDQN3D JDLQRIVSHFLÀFLW\S
OHVLRQIDWUDWLRN3D JDLQRIVSHFLÀFLW\S PHDQHODVWLFLW\GLDPHWHU
UDWLRN3D JDLQRIVSHFLÀFLW\S
&RQFOXVLRQ$OO 6:(IHDWXUHV WDNHQ VHSDUDWHO\ LQFUHDVHG VSHFLÀFLW\ RI EUHDVW
XOWUDVRXQGLQFDVHRI%,5$'6ÀQGLQJVDQGUHFODVVLÀFDWLRQLQ%,5$'6C%HVW
PRGHOZLWKKLJKHVWFOLQLFDOLPSDFW%,5$'66:(PD[LPXPVWLIIQHVVN3D
%
,VVKHDUZDYHHODVWRJUDSK\ DFRXVWLFUDGLDWLRQIRUFHLLPSXOVH DEOH
WRLPSURYHWKHDVVHVVPHQWRI%,5$'6EUHDVWVROLGOHVLRQV"
:%HQ+DVVHQ6&DQDOH39LHOK0&0DWKLHX6'HODORJH&%DOOH\JXLHU
9LOOHMXLI)5 ZDJLK#\DKRRIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIVKHDUZDYHHODVWRJUDSK\LQEUHDVWOH
VLRQVIRUWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI%,5$'6VROLGOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6ROLGPDVVOHVLRQVFDWHJRULVHGDV%,5$'6RQXOWUD
VRQRJUDSK\ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHG%PRGHLPDJHVDQGUHVXOWVRIDFRXVWLF
UDGLDWLRQIRUFH,PSXOVH $5), LPDJLQJERWKTXDOLWDWLYH VXVSLFLRXVHODVWRJUDP
LPDJH RU QRW DQG TXDQWLWDWLYH VKHDU ZDYH VSHHG PV ZHUH FRUUHODWHG ZLWK
F\WRKLVWRORJLFDOUHVXOWV )1$RUELRSV\ 9DOXHVRIWKHVKHDUZDYHYHORFLW\ZHUH
GHWHUPLQHGLQERWKWKHVROLGPDVVHVDQGQRUPDOVXUURXQGLQJWLVVXHZLWKPHDVXUH
PHQWVSHUIRUPHGDWWKHVDPHGHSWKDQGZLWKWKHVDPHSUREHSUHVVXUH3HUFHQWDJH
RIVSHHGLQFUHDVHZDVFDOFXODWHGWROLPLWWKHELDVGXHWRYDULDEOHSUHVVXUHDQG
FRUUHODWHGWRSDWKRORJ\
5HVXOWVVROLGPDVVOHVLRQVZHUHVWXGLHG EHQLJQPDOLJQDQWPHDQVL]H
PP LQSDWLHQWV7KHPHDQVKHDUZDYHYHORFLW\LQEHQLJQPDVVHVZDV
VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQLQPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV UHVSHFWLYHO\PVDQG
PV S 8VLQJWKHUHFHLYLQJRSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFFXUYHDFXWRII
OHYHOIRUVKHDUZDYHVSHHGRIPVSUHGLFWHGPDOLJQDQF\ZLWKVSHFLÀFLW\
DQGVHQVLWLYLW\ZLWKDQDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& RI$VSHHG
LQFUHDVHKDGVSHFLÀFLW\DQGVHQVLWLYLW\ZLWKDQ$8&RI,QDGGLWLRQ
DOOFDQFHUFDVHVH[KLELWHGDVXVSLFLRXVDSSHDUDQFHXVLQJ$5),TXDOLWDWLYHLPDJLQJ
&RQFOXVLRQ$5),LQFRPELQDWLRQZLWK%PRGHLPDJLQJFDQLPSURYHWKHDVVHVV
PHQWRIEUHDVWOHVLRQVHVSHFLDOO\IRUEHQLJQOHVLRQVPLVFDWHJRULVHGDV%,5$'6
DQGPLJKWKHOSGHFUHDVLQJWKHQXPEHURIEHQLJQOHVLRQVUHIHUUHGIRUELRSV\
%
/HVLRQFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOIDFWRUVDIIHFWLQJ
GLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIEUHDVWXOWUDVRXQGHODVWRJUDSK\
/&+/HRQJ/66LP60&)RRN&KRQJ$5-DUD/D]DUR3+7DQ
6LQJDSRUH6* OHVWHUOHRQJFK#VJKFRPVJ
3XUSRVH7RLGHQWLI\IDFWRUVDIIHFWLQJWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIEUHDVWXOWUD
VRXQGHODVWRJUDSK\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV VRQRJUDSKLFDOO\ YLVLEOH EUHDVW PDVVHV WKDW ZHUH
UHIHUUHG WR RXU GHSDUWPHQW IRU LPDJHJXLGHG ELRSV\ ZHUH HYDOXDWHG ZLWK XOWUD
VRXQG HODVWRJUDSK\ (ODVWRJUDSKLF DVVHVVPHQW LQWHUSUHWHG DV SUREDEO\ EHQLJQ
RUPDOLJQDQWEDVHGRQDFRPELQDWLRQRIHODVWRJUDSKLFVL]HUDWLRVDQGJUH\VFDOH
VWUDLQSDWWHUQDVVHVVPHQW8VLQJKLVWRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLVDVWKHJROGVWDQGDUGWKH
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUYDULRXVOHVLRQVZHUHDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV 7KHUH ZDV QR VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH LQ WKH VHQVLWLYLWLHV RI
ZHOOGHÀQHGYVLOOGHÀQHGOHVLRQVUHJXODUYVLUUHJXODUVKDSHGOHVLRQVDQGOHVLRQV
ZLWKDQGZLWKRXWDFRXVWLFVKDGRZLQJ6WDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVQRWHG
LQWKHVSHFLÀFLWLHVRIZHOOGHÀQHGOHVLRQV YVLOOGHÀQHGOHVLRQV
S UHJXODU YVLUUHJXODUVKDSHGOHVLRQV S
QR DFRXVWLF VKDGRZLQJ YV SRVWHULRU VKDGRZLQJ YV FRPELQHG
VKDGRZLQJ S 6HQVLWLYLW\ DQG VSHFLÀFLW\ RI OHVLRQV PHDVXULQJ
PPRUOHVVZHUHDQGYV S DQG S
UHVSHFWLYHO\IRUOHVLRQVPRUHWKDQPP7KHUHZDVQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHLQVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUOHVLRQVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
OHVLRQVRIGLIIHUHQWHFKRJHQLFLW\DQGOHVLRQVLQPDPPRJUDSKLFDOO\GHQVHRUIDWW\
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
EUHDVWV6HQVLWLYLW\RIPXFLQRXVFDUFLQRPDV DQG/&,6 ZDVORZHU
WKDQ WKH RWKHU PDOLJQDQFLHV 6SHFLÀFLW\ RI SDSLOORPDWD DQG ÀEURF\VWLF
FKDQJH ZDVORZHUWKDQIRURWKHUEHQLJQFRQGLWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ,OOGHÀQHGOHVLRQVLUUHJXODUVKDSHGOHVLRQVOHVLRQVZLWKSRVWHULRU
DFRXVWLFVKDGRZLQJVPDOOOHVLRQVPXFLQRXVFDUFLQRPDV/&,6SDSLOORPDWDDQG
ÀEURF\VWLFFKDQJHDSSHDUWREHUHODWHGWRSRRUHUXOWUDVRXQGHODVWRJUDSKLFGLDJ
QRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
%
8WLOLW\RIVHFRQGORRN86ZLWKUHDOWLPHYLUWXDOVRQRJUDSK\ 596 IRU
05,GHWHFWHGOHVLRQVRIWKHEUHDVW
61DNDQR.<RUR]X\D.)XMLL0<RVKLGD-.RXVDND<6KLRPL
7)XNXWRPL7,VKLJXFKL2$UDL$LFKLJXQ-3.DVKLZD-3
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRYHULI\WKHXWLOLW\RIVHFRQGORRN86ZLWK
XVLQJ UHDOWLPH YLUWXDO VRQRJUDSK\ 596 IRU WKH LGHQWLÀFDWLRQ RI 05,GHWHFWHG
OHVLRQVRIWKHEUHDVW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )URP EUHDVW 05, DOO 05,GHWHFWHG OHVLRQV DQG
VXEVHTXHQWELRSV\ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGEHWZHHQ)HEUXDU\DQG'HFHPEHU
$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGXVLQJ596WKDWFRXOGV\QFKURQLVHD86LPDJHDQGWKH
05,RIWKHVDPHVLWHLQUHDOWLPH,QRUGHUWRDFKLHYHWKHVDPHSRVLWLRQRISDWLHQWҋV
ERG\DVLQ8605,ZDVREWDLQHGRQD7LPDJHULQWKHVXSLQHSRVLWLRQXVLQJD
ERG\VXUIDFHFRLO:HVHDUFKHGDOOFDVHVIRU05,GHWHFWHGOHVLRQVDQGLQYHVWLJDWHG
VHFRQGORRN86ZLWKRUZLWKRXW596LQLGHQWLI\LQJWKHOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV2ISDWLHQWV05,GHWHFWHGVXVSLFLRXVOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGLQ
SDWLHQWV$WRWDORI05,GHWHFWHGOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVFRPSULVHGWKLV
DQDO\VLV2IOHVLRQV ZHUHPDOLJQDQWDQG ZHUHEHQLJQ2YHUDOO
PHDQOHVLRQVL]HZDVPP$WRWDORIPDVVOHVLRQVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGFRPSDUHG
ZLWKIRFLDQGQRQPDVVOLNHOHVLRQV OHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGLQ
VHFRQGORRN86ZLWKRXW596DQGZHUHUHYHDOHGDVFDQFHUVLQHLJKWEHQLJQOHVLRQV
LQ,QFRQWUDVW OHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGLQVHFRQGORRN86ZLWK
596DQGZHUHUHYHDOHGDVFDQFHUVLQEHQLJQOHVLRQVLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQWUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWVHFRQGORRN86ZLWK596FDQLGHQWLI\
DODUJHSDUWRI05,GHWHFWHGOHVLRQVZLWKRXWRSHUDWRUҋVVNLOO
5RRP*+
1HXUR
66
$JHLQJGHJHQHUDWLYHGLVRUGHUVDQGHSLOHSV\
0RGHUDWRUV
76WRVLF2SLQFDO%HOJUDGH56
77RXUGLDV%RUGHDX[)5
%
5HJLRQDOFRUWLFDOWKLFNQHVVGHWHULRUDWLRQLQHOGHUO\KHDOWK\SHUVRQV
IURP$,%/05,7GDWDD05,VWXG\XVLQJEUDLQVXUIDFHLQWHQVLW\
PRGHO %6,0
=/LQ.0F0LOODQ/<DQ8$YLQDVK:DXNHVKD:,86
0HQRPRQHH)DOOV:,86 ]KRQJPLQOLQ#JHFRP
3XUSRVH&RUWLFDOWKLQQLQJPD\EHDQHIIHFWLYHELRPDUNHUIRUQRUPDODJHLQJSURF
HVV7UDGLWLRQDO PHWKRGV XVHG IRU PHDVXULQJ WKLV ELRPDUNHU RQ SHRSOH RYHU
KDYHVKRZQYHU\VPDOOGHFOLQHUDWHV$QHZPHWKRGZDVGHYHORSHGWRPHDVXUH
FRUWLFDOWKLFNQHVVFRQVLVWHQWO\DQGZDVXVHGWRVWXG\FRUWLFDOGHWHULRUDWLRQUDWHV
RIQRUPDODJHLQJEHWZHHQDQG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVKHDOWK\PHQDQGKHDOWK\ZRPHQRIWKHDJHJURXSV
EHWZHHQDQGDQGDQGDQGIURP$XVWUDOLDQ,PDJLQJ%LRPDUNHUV
DQG/LIHVW\OH $,%/ VWXG\ZHUHXVHGWRPHDVXUHLQGLYLGXDODQGDYHUDJHFRUWLFDO
WKLFNQHVVLQIXQFWLRQDOEUDLQUHJLRQVXVLQJ%6,05HJLRQDOFRUWLFDOWKLFNQHVV
RILQGLYLGXDOVDQGJURXSDYHUDJHVZHUHVWXGLHGWRHYDOXDWHWKLFNQHVVGHWHULRUD
WLRQRIQRUPDODJHLQJ%6,0UHJLVWHUVEUDLQLPDJHVWRDVWDQGDUGLVHGDWODVZLWK
SUHGHÀQHG EUDLQ VXUIDFH SRLQWV )URP HDFK SRLQW D 05 LQWHQVLW\ SURÀOH
SHUSHQGLFXODUWRWKHEUDLQVXUIDFHLVH[WUDFWHGDQGPRGHOOHGWRFDOFXODWHFRUWLFDO
WKLFNQHVVDWWKHSRLQW
5HVXOWV 5HJLRQDO FRUWLFDO WKLFNQHVV ZLWKLQ DQ DJH JURXS ZDV ZLGHVSUHDG DQG
RYHUODSSHGEHWZHHQJURXSV&RPSDUHGWRSHRSOHLQWKHLUҋVWKLFNQHVVORVWDW
GLIIHUHQWUDWHVLQIXQFWLRQDOUHJLRQVPPGHFDGHLQWHPSRUDODQGPHGLDOSDULHWDO
DQGPPGHFDGHLQSRVWHULRUFLQJXODWHZHUHREVHUYHG5HVXOWVDOVRVKRZSHRSOH
LQWKHLUVORVWFRUWH[DWIDVWHUUDWHVWKDQLQWKHV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ :LGHVSUHDG FRUWLFDO WKLFNQHVV VKRZV GLYHUVLÀHG GLVWULEXWLRQ RI
FRUWLFDOWKLFNQHVVDPRQJLQGLYLGXDOKHDOWK\SHUVRQV7KHQRUPDODJHLQJGHFOLQH
UDWHVPHDVXUHGIURP$,%/7GDWDXVLQJ%6,0DUHKLJKHUWKDQZKDWKDVEHHQ
SUHYLRXVO\UHSRUWHG
%
$UWHULDOVSLQODEHOOLQJSHUIXVLRQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05 LPDJLQJ
FRQWULEXWHVWRWKHHDUO\GLDJQRVLVRIGHPHQWLD
50(6WHNHWHH62RPV0/XLMWHQ*+RXVWRQ-&YDQ6ZLHWHQ06PLWV
5RWWHUGDP1/ UVWHNHWHH#HUDVPXVPFQO
%
+056DQG':,IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRI3DUNLQVRQҋVGLVHDVH 3' IURP
SDUNLQVRQLDQV\QGURPHV 36
==5R]KNRYD06KNOLDU.LHY8$ LQYLYR#XNUQHW
3XUSRVH :H WU\ WR ÀQG GLDJQRVWLF PDUNHUV WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH 3' IURP PXOWLSOH
V\VWHP DWURSK\ 06$ DQG SURJUHVVLYH VXSUDQXFOHDU SDOV\ 363 XVLQJ$'&ҋV
DQG7YDOXHVLQWKHEDVDOJDQJOLD %* DQGLQPLGGOHFHUHEUDOSHGXQFOHV 0&3
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )RXU JURXSV RI SDWLHQWV 3'*06$*363*&* DUH
VWXGLHGZLWK76LJQD([FLWH *( 7KH3'*LQFOXGHVSDWLHQWVZLWK3'WKH
06$*LQFOXGHVSDWLHQWVZLWK06$WKH363*LQFOXGHVSDWLHQWVZLWK363
DQG&*JURXSLQFOXGHVFRQWUROV+VSHFWUDDUHREWDLQHGLQ%*DQGLQ0&3ZLWK
69667($0757( PV)URPWKHHFKRWLPHGHSHQGHQFH
RIWKHVLJQDOSHDNDUHDV$0 0 &KR&U1$$ 70DUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQYDOXHVRI70LQ%*DUHPV LQ3'*
PV LQ06$* PV LQ363* PV
&* 7KHVHGLIIHUHQFHVLQ70DOORZXVWRGLVWLQJXLVKVXEMHFWVRI&*IURPSDWLHQWV
RI3'*DQG36*EXWWKH\DUHQRWVSHFLÀFIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRI06$IURPRWKHU
SDWLHQWV7KHPHDQYDOXHVRI70LQ0&3DUHPV 3'*
PV 06$* PV 363* PV
&* 7KHVKRUWHQLQJRI70LQ0&3IRUWKHSDWLHQWVRI06$*LVH[WUHPHO\VSH
FLÀF$'&V PPV IRUWKHSDWLHQWVRI3'*06$*363*&*LQWKHUHJLRQRI
%*DUH0RUHSURQRXQFHGGLIIHUHQFHVRI$'&DUHIRXQGLQ
0&3IRU3'*06$*363*&*UHVSHFWLYHO\,QFUHDVLQJ
$'&VLQ0&3IRUWKHSDWLHQWVRI06$*DOORZVXVWRGLIIHUHQWLDWH06$IURP363
DQG3'ZLWKKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ$'&DQG70LQ0&3IRU06$LQFRPSDULVRQZLWK3'DQG363DUH
WKHLQYLYRGLDJQRVWLFPDUNHUVRI06$
%
7HVWUHWHVWUHOLDELOLW\RIUHVWLQJVWDWHQHWZRUNVLQKHDOWK\HOGHUO\
VXEMHFWVDQG0&,SDWLHQWV
-%ODXW]LN'.HHVHU$%HUPDQ03DROLQL9.LUVFK
60XHOOHU05HLVHU67HLSHO70HLQGO0XQLFK'(
5RVWRFN'( MDQXVFKEODXW]LN#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH/RQJLWXGLQDOVWXGLHVLQYHVWLJDWLQJWKHUHOLDELOLW\RIWKHEUDLQҋVUHVWLQJVWDWH
QHWZRUNV 561V KDYHIRFXVHGRQ\RXQJKHDOWK\VXEMHFWVGDWDRQKHDOWK\HOGHUO\
VXEMHFWV DQG YDULRXV SDWLHQW JURXSV ZKLFK UHSUHVHQW LQGLYLGXDOV RI FOLQLFDO DQG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
0XOWLWUDFHU3(7HDUO\IUDPHVDVDIXQFWLRQDOPDUNHULQ$O]KHLPHUҋV
GLVHDVH
9$EUHX6&DUWHU$1RUGEHUJ*HQHYD&+6WRFNKROP6(
3XUSRVH:HLQYHVWLJDWHGZKHWKHUWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRI &3LWWVEXUJKFRPSRXQG%
3,% DQG &/GHSUHQ\O '(3 LQGXDOWUDFHU3(7HDUO\IUDPHVLVÁRZGHSHQGHQW
DQGLWVSRWHQWLDOFOLQLFDOXVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'XDOWUDFHU3(7VFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQDJURXSRI
SDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVLVRI´SUREDEOH$'µ PHDQDJH6'\PHDQ
0LQL0HQWDO6WDWH([DPLQDWLRQ>006(@VFRUH6' DQGDJURXSRIDJH
PDWFKHGFRQWUROV PHDQDJH6'\PHDQ006(VFRUH6'
ERWKUHFUXLWHGIURP.DUROLQVND8QLYHUVLW\+RVSLWDO4XDQWLWDWLYHGDWDZHUHREWDLQHG
E\VXPPLQJDOOHDUO\3,%DQG'(3IUDPHVDQGDQLWHUDWLYHDOJRULWKPJHQHUDWHG
QRUPDOLVHGSHUIXVLRQLPDJHVZLWKVWDQGDUGXSWDNHYDOXHVIRUVHOHFWHGUHJLRQVRI
LQWHUHVW IURQWDOSDULHWDOWHPSRUDODQGSRVWHULRUFLQJXODWHFRUWH[ :HFDOFXODWHG
3HDUVRQ VFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWIRUWKHFRPELQHGIUDPHVLQDOOEUDLQWLVVXHYR[HOV
DQGJURXSGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWKWZRWDLOHGWWHVWV
5HVXOWV3(7IUDPHVEHWZHHQPLQXWHVSURGXFHGWKHRQO\YR[HOZLVHFRUUHODWLRQ
IRXQG 5 LQERWKJURXSV,QWKLVPLQZLQGRZZHUHWKHORZHVW3,%DQG
'(3XSWDNHYDOXHVPHDVXUHGEXWWKHELQGLQJÁRZUDWLRZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
S LQ PRVW$' SDWLHQWV Q WKDQ LQ WKH FRQWURO JURXS VXJJHVWLQJ WKDW
WUDFHUGLVWULEXWLRQPD\EHÁRZGHSHQGHQW1RFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGLQWKHRWKHU
IUDPHVVWXGLHG PLQXWHV %UDLQUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWLGHQWLÀHGDVVLJQLÀFDQW
GLVFULPLQDWRUV S RI$'GLVHDVHZHUHSRVWHULRUFLQJXODWHDQGWHPSRUDOFRUWH[
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHGLVWULEXWLRQRI3(7WUDFHUVLQWKHYHU\HDUO\IUDPHVLVOLNHO\ÁRZ
GHSHQGHQWZKLFKPD\EHXVHIXOWRGHULYHFOLQLFDOHVWLPDWHVRIFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ
DQGQHXURLQÁDPPDWLRQIURPDVLQJOHPXOWLWUDFHU3(7VFDQ
%
7UHOD[RPHWU\ RQ705 PDGHWHPSRUDOOREHHSLOHSV\GLDJQRVLVHDV\
+33DUHNK'39DVDYDGD-DPQDJDU,1
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHU7UHOD[RPHWU\PDGH
KLSSRFDPSDOSDWKRORJ\GLDJQRVLVHDV\DQGODWHUDOLVHWKHHSLOHSWLFIRFXVLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKLQWUDFWDEOHWHPSRUDOOREHHSLOHSV\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2XUVWXG\LQFOXGHVSDWLHQWVZLWKXQLODWHUDOWHPSRUDO
OREHHSLOHSV\ZKRKDGXQLODWHUDOKLSSRFDPSDODWURSK\DQGSDWLHQWVZLWKXQLODWHUDO
WHPSRUDOOREHHSLOHSV\ZKRKDGQRHYLGHQFHRIDWURSK\RQ05,2QD705
VFDQXVLQJDGXDOHFKRVHTXHQFHFRQWLJXRXVREOLTXHFRURQDOVOLFHVLQDOO
SDWLHQWVDQGLQKHDOWK\VXEMHFWVZHUHWDNHQ$YHUDJHVRIVL[VOLFHVFRQWDLQLQJ
WKHKHDGERG\DQGWDLORIWKHKLSSRFDPSXVZHUHXVHGWRFDOFXODWHKLSSRFDPSDO
7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHV
5HVXOWV$OOÀUVWSDWLHQWVZLWKKLSSRFDPSDODWURSK\DQG SDWLHQWV
ZLWKQRUPDO05,KDGDEQRUPDOO\KLJKKLSSRFDPSDO7UHOD[DWLRQLSVLODWHUDOWRWKH
HSLOHSWLFIRFXV%LODWHUDODEQRUPDOKLSSRFDPSDOUHOD[DWLRQYDOXHVZHUHIRXQGLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKXQLODWHUDOKLSSRFDPSDODWURSK\DQG SDWLHQWV
ZLWK QRUPDO 05, +RZHYHU WKLV LQFUHDVH ZDV DOZD\V JUHDWHU LSVLODWHUDO WR WKH
HSLOHSWLFIRFXV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH (DUO\ GLDJQRVLV RI GHPHQWLD LV FKDOOHQJLQJ DV EUDLQ DWURSK\ PD\ QRW
\HWEHDSSDUHQW&KDQJHVLQFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ &%) SUHFHGLQJDWURSK\PD\
EHGHWHFWHGZLWKDUWHULDOVSLQODEHOOLQJ $6/ 7KLVVWXG\DLPVWRDVVHVV$6/IRU
GLDJQRVLQJHDUO\GHPHQWLD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGGLDJQRVLVRIGHPHQWLD
PHDQDJH\PDOHVPHDQ0LQL0HQWDO6WDWH([DPLQDWLRQ DQGFRQWUROV
PHDQDJH\PDOHV XQGHUZHQW'3&$6/DQG7Z05VFDQQLQJDW7 *(
+HDOWKFDUH86 'DWDZHUHFRUHJLVWHUHGDQGQRUPDOLVHGXVLQJ630 /RQGRQ
8. 52,DQDO\VLVRIWKH&%)PDSVPDVNHGIRUJUH\PDWWHURQO\ZDVSHUIRUPHG
ZLWK0DUV%D5 0DUVHLOOHV)5 LQUHJLRQVLQYROYHGLQGHPHQWLDDQGUHJLRQVLQLWLDOO\
VSDUHG0HDQ&%)YDOXHVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQJURXSVXVLQJVDPSOHWWHVWV
5HVXOWV$JHDQGJHQGHUZHUHQRWGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQJURXSV S! 0HDQ&%)
YDOXHVLQGHPHQWLDUHODWHGEUDLQUHJLRQVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQSDWLHQWVWKDQ
FRQWUROV SULJKWOHIWPHGLDOWHPSRUDOOREHYHUVXVULJKWOHIW
SUHFXQHXVYHUVXVULJKWOHIWSRVWHULRUFLQJXOXPYHUVXVV
POJ 1RGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGLQUHJLRQVQRWLPSOLFDWHGLQGHPHQWLD ULJKW
OHIWSUHFHQWUDOJ\UXVYHUVXVULJKWOHIWRFFLSLWDOJ\ULYHUVXV
VPOJIRUSDWLHQWVDQGFRQWUROVUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWWHUQVRIK\SRSHUIXVLRQDVVHVVHGZLWK$6/LQHDUO\GHPHQWLDDUH
FRQFRUGDQWZLWKWKRVHLQHVWDEOLVKHGGHPHQWLDDQGWKRVHDVVHVVHGZLWKSRVLWURQ
HPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\LQGLFDWLQJWKHFRQWULEXWLRQRI$6/LQWKHHDUO\GLDJQRVLVRI
GHPHQWLD)XWXUHDLPVDUHWRDVVHVV$6/IRUHDUO\GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQW\SHV
RIGHPHQWLD
VFLHQWLÀFLQWHUHVWDUHODFNLQJ7KHUHIRUHZHDLPHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHWHVWUHWHVW
UHOLDELOLW\RI561VLQDPQHVWLFPLOGFRJQLWLYHLPSDLUHG D0&, SDWLHQWVDSURGURPDO
VWDJHRI$O]KHLPHUҋVGLVHDVHDQGKHDOWK\HOGHUO\FRQWUROV +&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RXUWHHQD0&,SDWLHQWVDQG+&XQGHUZHQWUHVWLQJ
VWDWHI05, UVI05, DQGQHXURSV\FKRORJLFDOWHVWLQJ &(5$'EDWWHU\ DWEDVHOLQH
DQGRQDIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQDIWHUPRQWKV5HVWLQJVWDWHI05,GDWDZHUH
GHFRPSRVHGLQWRLQGHSHQGHQWFRPSRQHQWV ,&V XVLQJ)6/ҋVWHPSRUDOFRQFDWH
QDWLRQ JURXS ,&$ 7&*,&$ DQG GXDO UHJUHVVLRQ 7KH ZLWKLQJURXS WHVWUHWHVW
UHOLDELOLW\ZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\FDOFXODWLQJVSDWLDOQRUPDOLVHGFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV
61&&V IRUWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJDYHUDJHGJURXSOHYHOFRPSRQHQWVGHULYLQJIURP
ERWK05,H[DPLQDWLRQV
5HVXOWV%RWKJURXSVUHPDLQHGFRJQLWLYHO\VWDEOHRYHUWLPH7KH7&*,&$DSSURDFK
SURGXFHG,&VFRQVLGHUHGDV561VDQG,&VFRQVLGHUHGDVDUWHIDFWV2YHUDOO
61&&VZHUHORZPRGHUDWHWRKLJKUDQJLQJIURPWRDQGGLGQRWGLIIHU
VLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWZHHQJURXSV S! *URXSOHYHOFRPSRQHQWVFRQVLGHUHGDV
561VH[SUHVVHG61&&VUDQJLQJIURPWR+LJKHVWWHVWUHWHVWUHOLDELOLW\
ZDVREVHUYHGLQWZRVXEQHWZRUNVRIWKHGHIDXOWPRGHQHWZRUNWZRVHQVRULPRWRU
QHWZRUNVDQGDYLVXDOQHWZRUN
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHORQJWHUPWHVWUHWHVWUHOLDELOLW\RI561VLVPRGHUDWHWRKLJKLQ
FRJQLWLYHO\VWDEOHKHDOWK\HOGHUO\DQGD0&,SDWLHQWV7KLVÀQGLQJLVHVVHQWLDOWR
HVWDEOLVKUVI05,DVDWRROLQWKHGLDJQRVLVDQGIROORZXSRIQHXURSV\FKLDWULFDQG
QHXURGHJHQHUDWLYHGLVRUGHUV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ+LSSRFDPSDO7PDSSLQJSURYLGHVHYLGHQFHRIKLSSRFDPSDOGDPDJH
LQWKHPDMRULW\RISDWLHQWVZLWKLQWUDFWDEOHWHPSRUDOOREHHSLOHSV\ZKRPD\RUPD\
QRWKDYHKLSSRFDPSDODWURSK\RQ05,DQGFDQFRUUHFWO\ODWHUDOLVHWKHHSLOHSWLF
IRFXVLQPRVWSDWLHQWV$GGLQJ7UHOD[RPHWU\LQ05SURWRFROIRUVXVSHFWHGWHPSRUDO
OREHHSLOHSV\KHOSVLQHVWDEOLVKLQJWKHGLDJQRVLVDQGODWHUDOLVDWLRQRIHSLOHSV\
%
%
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRÀQGRXWLIDPLFURVWUXFWXUDOGDPDJHWR
FHUHEUDOZKLWHPDWWHUFRUUHODWHVZLWKJUH\PDWWHUYROXPHFKDQJHVDQGFRJQLWLYH
V\PSWRPVLQLGLRSDWKLF3DUNLQVRQGLVHDVH 3'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKGHQRYR3'ZHUHH[DPLQHG +RHKQDQG
<DKUVWDJHV,,,,WZRDJHVXEJURXSVWR $ DQGWR % \HDUVROGZLWK
DQGZLWKRXWFRJQLWLYHLPSDLUPHQWV 7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHV JUDGLHQWHFKRYR[HO
PP GLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJHV '7, ZHUHREWDLQHG7RWDOEUDLQJUH\PDWWHU *0
ZKLWH PDWWHU :0 YROXPHV ZHUH GHÀQHG IURP 7ZHLJKWHG LPDJHV IUDFWLRQDO
DQLVRWURS\ )$ PHDQLQJVZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJ)6/
5HVXOWV3DWLHQWVRI$DJHVXEJURXSDOVRGLGQRWVKRZDQ\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
ZLWK FRQWUROV GHVSLWH WKDW GXUDWLRQ RI LOOQHVV ZDV WZLFH ORQJHU WKDQ LQ SDWLHQWV
WR\HDUV6XEJURXS%KDGVKRZQGHFUHDVHGYROXPHLQPHGLXPWHPSRUDO
J\UXVIURQWRWHPSRUDODUHDSRQV3XWDPHQWKDODPXVFDXGDWHQXFOHXVDP\JGDOD
YROXPHVGLGQRWGHPRQVWUDWHGLIIHUHQFHZLWKFRQWUROV)$PHDVXUHGLQDOOSDWLHQWV
ZDVXQDOWHUHGLQWKHPLGEUDLQORZHUHGLQWKHFRUWLFRVSLQDOWUDFWLQVSOHQLXPRI
FRUSXVFDOORVXPIURQWOREHVFHQWUXPVHPLRYDOHSRQV LQSURMHFWLRQRIVXEVWDQWLD
QLJUD 7KHUHZHUHORZHU)$PHDQLQJVLQFRUSXVFDOORVXPDQGLQWHUQDOFDSVXOHLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKFRJQLWLYHLPSDLUPHQWVDQG,,,+RHKQDQG<DKUVWDJHQRWGHSHQGLQJ
RQDJHRUGXUDWLRQRILOOQHVV
&RQFOXVLRQ&RUUHODWLRQRI)$GHFUHDVHDQGZRUVHFRJQLWLYHVWDWHLQSDWLHQWVRI
DQ\DJHZLWKRXWEUDLQVWUXFWXUHYROXPHFKDQJHVFDQEHDSURYHGWKDWZLGHVSUHDG
QHXURGHJHQHUDWLRQLVDOUHDG\SUHVHQWDWWKHWLPHRIFOLQLFDORQVHW
+LSSRFDPSDOPDOURWDWLRQQRWHYHU\WKLQJLVPHVLDOVFOHURVLV
53DVWRU7ROHGR-//HRQ*XLMDUUR,/ySH]%ODVFR63D]0D\D
/$ULxR0RQWDQHU'6RULDQR0HQD$/ODQHV5LYDGD-8FKL\DPDGD
56DQFKH]2UR9DOHQFLD(6
3XUSRVH 'HPRQVWUDWH WKH LPDJLQJ ÀQGLQJ LQ 0DJQHWLF 5HVRQDQFH ,PDJLQJ
05, LQSDWLHQWVZLWKHSLOHSV\DQGKLSSRFDPSDOPDOURWDWLRQXVLQJKLJKUHVROXWLRQ
YROXPHWULFVHTXHQFHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HYLHZRIVWXGLHVRI05,EUDLQSDWLHQWҋVZLWKHSLOHSV\RI
RXUKRVSLWDOGLDJQRVHGZLWKPHVLDOVFOHURVLVIURP-DQXDU\WKURXJK'HFHPEHU
)RUQRZZHKDYHREWDLQHGSDWLHQWV7KHVWXGLHVZHUHFRQGXFWHGRQD
KLJKÀHOG7DQG7DFFRUGLQJWRWKHSURWRFRORIHSLOHSV\LQFOXGHVDJLWWDO7
D[LDO7DQG7FRURQDO)/$,5FRURQDO7 KLJKUHVROXWLRQ DQG'YROXPHWULF
VHTXHQFHV,5 PPWKLFN
5HVXOWV:HKDYHREWHLQHGSDWLHQWVZLWKKLSSRFDPSDOPDOURWDWLRQLQZKLFKWKHUH
KDGEHHQDPLVGLDJQRVLV&RPPRQIHDWXUHVIRXQGLQKLSSRFDPSDOPDOURWDWLRQZHUH
KLSSRFDPSXVDEQRUPDOO\VLWXDWHGLQDPHGLDOORFDWLRQZKLFKKDVQRWURWDWHGWRWKH
QRUPDOGHSWKZLWKLQWKHZDOOPHGLDOWHPSRUDOOREH7KHYHUWLFDOGLDPHWHULVVLPLODU
RUJUHDWHUWKDQWKHWUDQVYHUVH7KHWHPSRUDOKRUQDSSHDUVHQODUJHGDQGFKRURLGDO
ÀVVXUHLVSURPLQHQWDQGHPSW\7KHFROODWHUDOVXOFXVLVRIWHQYHUWLFDOL]HVDOWHULQJLWV
DQJOHFDXVLQJDWHPSRUDU\LPSULQWRQWKHSROHNQRZQDVWHPSRUDOHPLQHQFH7KH
LQWHUQDOVWUXFWXUHRIWKHKLSSRFDPSDOJ\UXVLVEOXUUHGNHHSLQJWKHVL]HDQGQRUPDO
LQWHUQDOVLJQDODQGFKDQJHVLQVXUURXQGLQJVWUXFWXUHVDSSHDUDVSDUDKLSSRFDPSDO
J\UXV GHFUHDVH LQ LWV XSSHU WUDQVYHUVH WKH VXELFXOXP WKH ÀPEULD DQG IRUQL[
WKLQQLQJDQGÁRZSRVLWLRQ EXWDOOLQDWHPSRUDOOREHPDLQWDLQVLWVQRUPDOVL]H
&RQFOXVLRQ+LSSRFDPSDOPDOURWDWLRQEXLOWDPDOIRUPDWLRQWKDWVKRXOGEHFRQVLG
HUHGLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRISDWLHQWVZLWKHSLOHSV\
%
&HUHEHOODUFKDQJHVLQHVVHQWLDOWUHPRUSDWLHQWVGHWHFWHGE\
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHVSHFWURVFRS\
,/DWQHURYD-.HOOHU$5XOVHK)-LUX$6NRFK0+RVNRYFRYD(5X]LFND
-9\PD]DO3UDJXH&= LYDODWQHURYD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH(VVHQWLDOWUHPRU (7 LVRQHRIWKHPRVWFRPPRQPRYHPHQWGLVRUGHUV
LQKXPDQVFKDUDFWHULVHGE\DNLQHWLFWUHPRURIDUPVKHDGDQGHYHQWKHYRLFH
7KHSUHYDOHQFHRI(7LVGHSHQGHQWRQWKHLQFUHDVLQJDJH7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\
ZDVWRÀQGRXWLIWKHPHWDEROLWHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVPHDVXUHGLQFHUHEHOOXPDUHDOVR
DJHGHSHQGHQW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 3DWLHQWV ZLWK (7 Q 0 ) DJH DQG
KHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV Q 0)DJH ZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRDJHJURXSV
\HDUV FRQWUROV SDWLHQWV \HDUV F S \HDUV F
S !\HDUV F S :HIRFXVHGRQWKHFHUHEHOOXPDQGPHDVXUHG1
DFHW\ODVSDUWDWH 1$$ FUHDWLQH &U DQGSKRVSKRFKROLQH 3FK FRQFHQWUDWLRQV
6SHFWURVFRS\ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQ6LHPHQV$YDQWRVFDQQHUXVLQJVLQJOHVOLFH
&6,VHTXHQFH 75 PV7( PV DQGSURFHVVHGXVLQJ6LSURVRIWZDUH
SDFNDJHZLWK/&0RGHO2QO\YR[HOVZLWKORZÀWWLQJHUURUZHUHFKRVHQ'RXEOHWDLOHG
:HOFKWZRVDPSOHWWHVWZDVXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV:HIRXQG1$$ FRQWUROV SDWLHQWV SYDOXH (
DQG 3FK FRQWUROV SDWLHQWV SYDOXH UHGXFWLRQ LQ (7
SDWLHQWV QR &U UHGXFWLRQ ZDV IRXQG 7KH JUHDWHVW GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ FRQWUROV
DQGSDWLHQWVZDVIRXQGLQWKHDJHJURXS\HDUV:HIRXQGDOOFRQFHQWUDWLRQ
YDOXHVZLWKQRGURSLQLQFUHDVLQJDJH
&RQFOXVLRQ:HIRXQGWKHVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQRI1$$DQG3FKFRQFHQWUDWLRQVLQ
(7FRPSDUHGWRKHDOWK\FRQWUROVKRZHYHUWKHVHFKDQJHVZHUHQRWUHODWHGWRDJH
6XSSRUWHG IURP JUDQWV ,*$ 0= &5 16 17 0ä0
DQG0ä0,*$0=&516
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
'LIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJDQGYR[HOEDVHGPRUSKRPHWU\LQ
3DUNLQVRQGLVHDVH
$(ÀPWVHY9)RNLQ$7UXIDQRY$3DVKNRYD'.KDLPRY
6DLQW3HWHUVEXUJ58 DWUDOI#PDLOUX
%
7KHUHODWLRQRIQHXURLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVLQFDUERQLFDQK\GUDVHW\SH,,
GHÀFLHQF\V\QGURPHWRFRJQLWLYHGLVWXUEDQFHDQGYLVXDOORVV
,$$ORUDLQ\70%RVOH\0$6DOLK'72\VWUHFN6$O0DONL
$+$O6XKDLEDQL+.KLDUL..$EX$PHUR5L\DGK6$ DORUDLQ\#NVXHGXVD
3XUSRVH7KLVZRUNGHVFULEHVWKHQHXURLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVLQFDUERQLFDQK\GUDVH
W\SH,,GHÀFLHQF\V\QGURPH &$'6 DQGWKHUHODWLRQRIWKHVHÀQGLQJVWRFRJQLWLYH
GLVWXUEDQFHDQGYLVXDOORVV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIVHULDOQHXURLPDJLQJVWXGLHV
SHUIRUPHGLQLQGLYLGXDOVIURPXQUHODWHGFRQVDQJXLQHRXVIDPLOLHVZLWK&$'6
IROORZHGIRU\HDUVZDVSHUIRUPHGDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWKYLVXDOORVVDQGPHQWDO
UHWDUGDWLRQ
5HVXOWV%UDLQFDOFLÀFDWLRQZDVSUHVHQWLQSDWLHQWVDV\RXQJDVWZR\HDUVROG
EXWDEVHQWLQSDWLHQWVDVROGDVQLQH\HDUVDQGZDVJHQHUDOO\SURJUHVVLYHDQG
IROORZHGDGLVWLQFWGLVWULEXWLRQLQYROYLQJSUHGRPLQDQWO\EDVDOJDQJOLDDQGWKDODPL
DQG JUH\ZKLWH PDWWHU MXQFWLRQ LQ IURQWDO UHJLRQV PRUH WKDQ SRVWHULRU UHJLRQV
3DWLHQWVZLWKPRUHVHYHUHFRJQLWLYHGLVWXUEDQFHKDGOHVVSURIRXQGEUDLQFDOFLÀFD
WLRQV,QJHQHUDOEDVDOJDQJOLDDQGWKDODPLZHUHVSDUHGLQLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKPRUH
VHYHUHPHQWDOUHWDUGDWLRQDOWKRXJKJUH\ZKLWHMXQFWLRQFDOFLÀFDWLRQVWLOORFFXUUHG
3URJUHVVLYHFDOFLÀFDWLRQZDVQRWHGHYHQLQLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKPLQLPDORUQRFRJQLWLYH
GLVWXUEDQFH6PDOORSWLFFDQDOZDVDOZD\VDVVRFLDWHGZLWKYHU\SRRUYLVLRQZKLOH
FDQDOVL]HJUHDWHUWKDQPPZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKQRUPDORSWLFGLVNDSSHDUDQFH
2SWLFFDQDOVL]HZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKYLVXDODFXLW\ U S DQGZLWK
GHJUHHRIRSWLFDWURSK\ U S
&RQFOXVLRQ%UDLQFDOFLÀFDWLRQLQ&$'6PD\QRWEHSUHVHQWGXULQJFKLOGKRRG
:RUVHPHQWDOUHWDUGDWLRQLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKOHVVEUDLQFDOFLÀFDWLRQHVSHFLDOO\LQ
WKHGHHSJUH\PDWWHU9DULDELOLW\RIEUDLQFDOFLÀFDWLRQDQGFRJQLWLYHGLVWXUEDQFHPD\
LPSO\DGGLWLRQDOJHQHWLFRUHSLJHQHWLFLQÁXHQFHVDIIHFWLQJWKHFRXUVHRIWKHGLVHDVH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP/0
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
66
/LYHU QRQSULPDU\OHVLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
%-2SGH%HHFN$QWZHUS%(
$6LHPLDQRZLF]3LHNDU\ŊOćVNLH3/
%
3DUDGR[LFDOXSWDNHRI*G(2%'73$RQWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVH
LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVLVIURPEUHDVWFDQFHULVWKH
´WDUJHWVLJQµDFRPPRQÀQGLQJ"
-6KLP&/HH$.LP..LP-&KRL-/HH<3DUN&3DUN6HRXO.5
NLNRRNLH#KDQPDLOQHW
%
'HWHFWLRQRIFRORUHFWDOKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVHVXVLQJ*G(2%'73$
05LPDJLQJDQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, DORQHDQGLQ
FRPELQDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVDIWHUFKHPRWKHUDSLFWUHDWPHQW
$0DFHUD03HWUDFFKLQL$%DOER0XVVHWWR$)RUQDUL&/DULR7*DOOR
6&LULOOR7XULQ,7 PDFHUDDQQDOLVD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHDFFXUDF\DQGVHQVLWLYLW\RI*G(2%'73$05LPDJLQJ
DQG':,DORQHDQGLQFRPELQDWLRQIRUGHWHFWLQJFRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKPHWDVWDWLFGLVHDVHDIWHUFKHPRWKHUDSLFWUHDWPHQW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK D WRWDO RI OHVLRQV
XQGHUZHQW05LPDJLQJ2XWRIOHVLRQV ZHUHPHWDVWDVHVRQKLV
WRSDWKRORJ\DQGRULQWUDRSHUDWLYHVRQRJUDSK\7KUHHLPDJHVHWV *G(2%'73$
':,DQGFRPELQHG*G(2%'73$DQG':, ZHUHUHYLHZHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\E\WZR
REVHUYHUV6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGRQDSHUOHVLRQVEDVLV
5HVXOWV05,VFDQVHYDOXDWHGE\WKHLPDJHVHW XQHQKDQFHGVHTXHQFHVDQG
DIWHU LQWUDYHQRXV DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI *G(2%'73$ FRUUHFWO\ LGHQWLÀHG
OHVLRQVZLWKDFFXUDF\RI &, DQGPHWDVWDVHVZLWK
DVHQVLWLYLW\RI &, 05,VFDQVHYDOXDWHGE\WKHLPDJHVHW
XQHQKDQFHGVHTXHQFHVDQG':, FRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHGZLWKDFFXUDF\RI
&, DQGPHWDVWDVHVZLWKDVHQVLWLYLW\RI
&, 05,VFDQVHYDOXDWHGE\WKHLPDJHVHW XQKHQDQFHGVHTXHQFHV
DIWHU LQWUDYHQRXV DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI *G(2%'73$ DQG ':, FRUUHFWO\ LGHQWLÀHG
ZLWKDFFXUDF\RI &, DQGPHWDVWDVHVZLWK
DVHQVLWLYLW\RI &,
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RIVHWLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUWKDQERWK
VHWVDQG S 7KHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RIVHWLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
EHWWHUWKDQVHW S
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
0XOWLFHQWHUUDQGRPLVHGFRPSDULVRQVWXG\WRHYDOXDWHRXWFRPHV
DQGUHVRXUFHQHHGVRILPDJLQJDQGWUHDWPHQWIROORZLQJ*G(2%
'73$HQKDQFHG05,RIWKHOLYHULQFRPSDULVRQWRH[WUDFHOOXODU
FRQWUDVWPHGLD (&&0 HQKDQFHG05,DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
PXOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKD
KLVWRU\RIFRORUHFWDOFDQFHUDQGNQRZQRUVXVSHFWHGPHWDFKURQRXV
OLYHUPHWDVWDVHVWKHYDOXHVWXG\
&-=HFK6*VFKZHQG$%D6VDODPDK79$/8(6WXG\*URXS
0XQLFK'(%HUOLQ'(9LHQQD$7 &KULVWRSK=HFK#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHJDGR[HWLFDFLGHQKDQFHG05, *G(2%'73$05, 05,
ZLWK H[WUDFHOOXODU FRQWUDVW PHGLD (&&005, DQG FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 0'&7
&(0'&7 DVLQLWLDOGLDJQRVWLFPRGDOLWLHVLQWKHORFDOZRUNXSRISDWLHQWVZLWK
FRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVVWXG\FHQWUHVLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG
OLYHUPHWDVWDVHVIURPWR7KHLQLWLDOLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHWREHXVHG
ZDVUDQGRPLVHG7KHSULPDU\YDULDEOHZDVWKHSURSRUWLRQRISDWLHQWVIRUZKRP
IXUWKHULPDJLQJZDVUHTXLUHGDIWHULQLWLDOLPDJLQJ)RUWKLVGHFLVLRQDFRQVHQVXV
EHWZHHQDOLYHUVXUJHRQDQGUDGLRORJLVWRQVLWHZDVUHDFKHG6HFRQGDU\YDULDEOHV
LQFOXGHGFRQÀGHQFHGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\SDUDPHWHUVDQGLPSDFWRQWKHVXUJLFDOSODQ
LQWKHVXEJURXSRISDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJ\DQGRULQWUDRSHUDWLYHXOWUDVRXQG
5HVXOWV)XUWKHULPDJLQJZDVUHTXLUHGLQ DQG
FDVHV DIWHU *G(2%'73$05, (&&005, DQG &(0'&7 UHVSHF
WLYHO\ S 'LDJQRVWLF FRQÀGHQFH ZDV KLJKYHU\ KLJK LQ
DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\ ,Q WKH VXEJURXS RI SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW VXUJHU\
VHQVLWLYLW\IRUGHWHFWLRQRIPHWDVWDVHVZDVDQGIRU
*G(2%'73$05,(&&005,DQG&(0'&7UHVSHFWLYHO\6XUJLFDOSODQZDV
FKDQJHGDQGVXUJHU\WLPHLQFUHDVHGLQDQGRISDWLHQWVDIWHU
*G(2%'73$05, (&&005, DQG &(0'&7 UHVSHFWLYHO\ *G(2%'73$
05,DVVHFRQGLPDJLQJDYRLGHGXQQHFHVVDU\VXUJHULHVLQSDWLHQWV
VFKHGXOHGIRUVXUJHU\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVVKRZVXSHULRULW\RI*G(2%'73$05,RYHU&(0'&7
DQG(&&005,IRUHYDOXDWLQJSDWLHQWVIRUOLYHUVXUJHU\3DWLHQWVUDQGRPLVHGIRU
*G(2%'73$05,DVLQLWLDOVWDJLQJVWUDWHJ\QHHGHGQRIXUWKHULPDJLQJWRDVVHVV
RSHUDELOLW\ZLWKLPSOLFDWLRQVIRUZRUNÁRZDQGFRVWV7KHFRPSDULVRQRIGLDJQRVWLF
HIÀFDF\SDUDPHWHUVGHPRQVWUDWHVWKHGLDJQRVWLFEHQHÀWRI*G(2%'73$05,
%
.LQHWLFVRI*G(2%'73$LQOLYHUOHVLRQVVXVSHFWIRUPHWDVWDVHV
DV\VWHPDWLFFRPSDULVRQRIUDZGDWDZLWKDUWHULDOLQSXWIXQFWLRQ
FRUUHFWHGGDWD
3$7%DOW]HU0%HQQGRUI:$.DLVHU0'LHW]HO
-HQD'( SDVFDOEDOW]HU#PHGXQLMHQDGH
3XUSRVH *G(2%'73$ LV D OLYHUVSHFLÀF FRQWUDVW DJHQW IRU GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ RI
IRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV+HUHLQRXUDLPLVWRFRPSDUH*G(2%'73$NLQHWLFVDPRQJ
EHQLJQ DQG PDOLJQDQW OHVLRQV DQG WR DVVHVV WKH HIIHFW RI DUWHULDOLQSXWIXQFWLRQ
$,) FRUUHFWLRQRQWKLVFRPSDULVRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZREOLQGHGREVHUYHUVUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGFRQVHFX
WLYHH[DPLQDWLRQVRISDWLHQWVDQGLGHQWLÀHGIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV EHQLJQ
PDOLJQDQW 5HIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGZDVHVWDEOLVKHGRQWKHEDVLVRIKLVWRSDWKRORJ\
DQGIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQV6LJQDOLQWHQVLWLHV 6, ZHUHREWDLQHGIRUDOOLGHQWLÀHG
OHVLRQVKHDOWK\OLYHUSDUHQFK\PDDRUWDDQGQRLVH)RUHDFKOHVLRQWKHVHVLJQDO
LQWHQVLWLHV ZHUH PHDVXUHG LQ WKH SUHFRQWUDVW LPDJHV DV ZHOO DV LQ WKH DUWHULDO
SRUWDOYHQRXVYHQRXVDQGODWHSKDVH/HVLRQVLJQDOVQRZZHUHHYDOXDWHGXVLQJ
WZRGLIIHUHQWDSSURDFKHV 0DQG0 0HPSOR\HGWKHOHVLRQVҋDEVROXWH6,DQG
ZDVFRUUHFWHGIRUWKH$,)ZLWKWKHDRUWDҋV6,0HPSOR\HGWKHOHVLRQVҋFRQWUDVW
WRQRLVHUDWLRDQGZDVFRUUHFWHGIRUWKH$,)ZLWKWKHDRUWDҋVVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR
0DQG0ZHUHFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV,Q0WKHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQW
IRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQVLQWKHODWHSKDVH 3 ,Q0WKHUHZDVDGLIIHUHQFHLQ
WKHDUWHULDOSKDVH 3 1RRWKHUVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVRFFXUUHGLQ0DQG
09LVXDOFRPSDULVRQVKRZHGWKDWFRUUHFWLRQOHDGVWRPRUHVWUHDPOLQHGNLQHWLFV
DPRQJDOOOHVLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ$,)FRUUHFWLRQPD\OHDGWRIXUWKHULQIRUPDWLRQDERXWIRFDOOLYHUOH
VLRQVGHSHQGLQJRQZKDWNLQGRIFRUUHFWLRQLVSHUIRUPHG:KHWKHUWKLVLQIRUPDWLRQ
LVGLDJQRVWLFDOO\UHOHYDQWQHHGVWREHGHWHUPLQHG
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RGHVFULEH05,ÀQGLQJVRIEUHDVWFDQFHUOLYHUPHWDVWDVLVXVLQJJDGR[
HWLFDFLGZLWKDQHPSKDVLVRQWKHDGGHGYDOXHRIWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVH +%3
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHSDWLHQWVZLWKOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQ
WKHVWXG\DIWHUUHYLHZLQJWKHPHGLFDOUHFRUGVRIEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWVZKR
XQGHUZHQW*G(2%'73$HQKDQFHG05,EHWZHHQ)HEUXDU\DQG-XQH
7KHGLDJQRVHVRIOLYHUPHWDVWDVLVZHUHHVWDEOLVKHGE\SHUFXWDQHRXVOLYHUELRSV\
RU VXUJHU\ DQG RQ WKH EDVLV RI LPDJH ÀQGLQJV7ZR UDGLRORJLVWV UHWURVSHFWLYHO\
HYDOXDWHG6,DQGVL]HVRIPHWDVWDVHVDQGSDWWHUQVRIHQKDQFHPHQWLQ+%37KH6,
UDWLRZDVFDOFXODWHGDVWKH6,RIWKHFHQWUDOK\SHULQWHQVHSRUWLRQLQ´WDUJHWµOHVLRQV
GLYLGHGE\WKH6,RIQHDUE\QRUPDOOLYHUSDUHQFK\PDRQ+%3:HDOVRPHDVXUHG
$'&YDOXHVIURP':,
5HVXOWV/LYHUPHWDVWDVHVZHUHDOOK\SRLQWHQVH RQ7:,DQGPDQ\OH
VLRQVKDG´WDUJHWµDSSHDUDQFHVZLWKFHQWUDOKLJK6,DQGSHULSKHUDOORZ6,ULP
RQ7:,'\QDPLFVWXG\VKRZHGULPHQKDQFHPHQWRQDUWHULDOSKDVH DQG
´WDUJHWµDSSHDUDQFHFRQVLVWLQJRIFHQWUDOHQKDQFLQJSRUWLRQZLWKSHULSKHUDOZDVK
RXWRUK\SRLQWHQVHULPRQ+%3 7KHPHDQ6,UDWLRZDV7KHPHDQ$'&
YDOXHRI´WDUJHWµDSSHDULQJPHWDVWDVHVZDV ðóPPòV FRPSDUHG
ZLWKDPHDQYDOXHRI ðóPPòV LQKRPRJHQHRXVGHIHFWRQ+%3
7KHUHZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S
&RQFOXVLRQ%UHDVWFDQFHUOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVFRPPRQO\GHPRQVWUDWHGDVSHULSKHUDO
ULQJHQKDQFHPHQWRQDUWHULDOGRPLQDQWSKDVHDQGWDUJHWVLJQZLWKFHQWUDOURXQG
HQKDQFLQJSRUWLRQDQGSHULSKHUDOK\SRLQWHQVHULPRQ+%3
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'HWHFWLRQRIFRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVVHQVLWLYLW\RI7ZHLJKWHG
DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJXVLQJSDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQDV
PHWKRGRIUHIHUHQFHLQDUDWPRGHO
0:DJQHU/0DJJLRUL05RQRW99LOJUDLQ<3DQLV%(9DQ%HHUV
&OLFK\)5 ZDJQHUPDWKLOGH#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RI7ZHLJKWHGDQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
':, LQGHWHFWLQJFRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVLQDUDWPRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(LJKWHHQ%',;UDWVKDGVXUJHU\ZLWKLQMHFWLRQVRI
PLOOLRQ'+'.FHOOVLQWKHOHIWOLYHU05H[DPLQDWLRQLQFOXGHG5$5(7ZHLJKWHG
LPDJLQJDQG6(':, E DQGVPP 6DFULÀFHZDVSHUIRUPHGLPPH
GLDWHO\DIWHU05,SURFHGXUH,PDJHVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWUHDGHUV
3DWKRORJLFDO H[DPLQDWLRQ ZDV SHUIRUPHG DIWHU VOLFLQJ WKH ZKROH OHIW OLYHU HYHU\
PP$YHUDJHGLDPHWHURIHDFKOLYHUPHWDVWDVLVZDVFRPSXWHG&RFKUDQ4WHVW
ZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGHWHFWLRQUDWHV
5HVXOWV$WRWDORIOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGRQSDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQD
WLRQ0HDQDYHUDJHGLDPHWHUZDVPP)RUERWKUHDGHUVDVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHUQXPEHURIPHWDVWDVHVZDVGHWHFWHGRQ':,WKDQRQ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHV
YV SIRUUHDGHUDQG YV
S IRUUHDGHU $IWHUVWUDWLÀFDWLRQDFFRUGLQJWRPHWDVWDVLVDYHUDJH
GLDPHWHU':,KDGDVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUGHWHFWLRQUDWHWKDQ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
IRUPHWDVWDVHVZLWKDQDYHUDJHGLDPHWHUEHWZHHQDQGPP
YV SIRUUHDGHUDQG YV S
IRUUHDGHU 1RGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHWZRLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHVIRU
PHWDVWDVHVODUJHUWKDQPPRUVPDOOHUWKDQPP
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVH[SHULPHQWDOVWXG\ZLWK05DQGSDWKRORJLFDOFRUUHODWLRQVVKRZV
WKH EHWWHU VHQVLWLYLW\ RI ':, UHODWLYH WR 7ZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ IRU GHWHFWLQJ OLYHU
PHWDVWDVHVHVSHFLDOO\WKRVHRIVPDOOVL]H
%
,PSDFWRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGLQWUDRSHUDWLYHXOWUDVRXQGRQRSHUDWLRQ
VWUDWHJ\LQFDVHRIFRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVLV
$6FKXO]-%'RUPDJHQ$'UROVXP%$%M¡UQEHWK.-/DERUL1(.ORZ
2VOR12 DQVHOPVFKXO]#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH FXUUHQW LPSDFW RI FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG LQWUDRSHUDWLYH
XOWUDVRXQG &(,286 RQ WKH LQLWLDO VXUJLFDO VWUDWHJ\ IRU UHVHFWLRQ RI FRORUHFWDO
OLYHUPHWDVWDVLV &5/0
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(LJKW\VL[FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJRSHQOLYHU
UHVHFWLRQIRU&5/0ZHUHHYDOXDWHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\RYHUD\HDUVSHULRG7KH
SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW RSHUDWLRQV 3UHRSHUDWLYH VWDJLQJ ZDV SHUIRUPHG ZLWK
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7DQG05, RIRSHUDWLRQV $FXVRQ6HTXRLDXOWUD
VRXQGV\VWHPZDVXVHGLQDOOFDVHV&RQWUDVWDJHQWXVHGZDVPO6RQR9XH
7UDQVGXFHUVZHUHFXUYHGDUUD\&DQGOLQHDU/&(,286ZDVSHUIRUPHG
LQ DOO SDWLHQWV ZLWK VWDQGDUGLVHG H[DPLQDWLRQ WHFKQLTXH &5/0 ZHUH LGHQWLÀHG
LQYHQRXVSKDVHDVK\SRHFKRLFOHVLRQV&(,286ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK
SUHRSHUDWLYHVWDJLQJ
5HVXOWV&RPELQHG&705,LGHQWLÀHGSUHRSHUDWLYH&5/06HYHQW\WZRDG
GLWLRQDOOHVLRQVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGGXULQJWKHRSHUDWLRQ,QWUDRSHUDWLYHO\DGGLWLRQDO
&5/0ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGE\LQVSHFWLRQSDOSDWLRQDQG&(,286 DQGDQRWKHU
&5/0ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGE\&(,286DORQH $OODGGLWLRQDO&5/0GHWHFWHG
E\&(,286ZHUHFRQÀUPHGE\KLVWRORJ\&(,286FKDQJHGSODQQHGRSHUDWLRQ
VWUDWHJ\ LQ RI RSHUDWLRQV$ ODUJHU UHVHFWLRQ ZDV QHFHVVDU\ LQ RI
FDVHVUHGXFHGOLYHUUHVHFWLRQZDVIRXQGVXIÀFLHQWLQDQGDQGZDV
IRXQGLQRSHUDEOH)RUSDWLHQWVGLDJQRVHGSUHRSHUDWLYHO\VWDJHG VROLWDU\OHVLRQV
&(,286FKDQJHGRSHUDWLRQVWUDWHJ\LQ7KXVUDGLFDOWXPRXUUHVHFWLRQZRXOG
KDYHIDLOHGLQZLWKRXW&(,286
&RQFOXVLRQ&(,286LVVWLOODQHVVHQWLDOWRROWRHQVXUHRSWLPDODQGFRPSOHWH
WXPRXU UHVHFWLRQ ,Q FDVH RI D VROLWDU\ &5/0 WKH DGGLWLRQDO YDOXH RI &(,286
PLJKWEHGHEDWDEOH
%
'LIIXVHGZHLJKWHG05,IRUTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIOLYHUÀEURVLV
-0$OXVWL]D-$UHQDV0$9RQ:LFKPDQQ$&DVWLHOOD-,(PSDUDQ]D
(6DOYDGRU0*DUFLD%HQJRHFKHD(=DSDWD6DQ6HEDVWLDQ(6
0HQGDUR(6 MPDOXVWL]D#RVDWHNHV
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHDFFXUDF\RIGLIIXVHGZHLJKWHG ': 05,IRUDVVHVVLQJ
WKHGLIIHUHQWVWDJHVRIOLYHUÀEURVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJGLIIHUHQWFKURQLFOLYHU
GLVHDVHVZHUHVWXGLHGE\OLYHUELRSV\DQGE\05,3DWLHQWVZLWKGHFRPSHQVDWHG
OLYHUGLVHDVHVZHUHH[FOXGHG'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,VHTXHQFHZDVSHUIRUPHG
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
ZLWKDQGEYDOXHVDQGDQG$'& DSSDUHQWGLI
IXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW YDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHG9DULDQFHDQDO\VLVZDVDSSOLHGE\.UDXVH
:DOOLV .: IRUPXODZLWKXQLODWHUDOVLJQLÀFDWLRQIRUWKHGLIIXVLRQPHDVXUHV7KH
$852&ZHUHFDOFXODWHGZLWKD&,RIIRUVLJQLÀFDWLYHOLYHUÀEURVLVGHWHFWLRQ
0HWDYLU6FDOH!)
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUH+,9+&9+%9+%9+&9KDGDXWRLPPXQH
OLYHUGLVHDVHVDQGRWKHUFDXVHV6WDJHV0HWDYLU6FDOH)))
))7KH$'&YDOXHV ó[PPòVHJ ZHUHDVIROORZV ))
DQGZLWK.: DQGS ZLWK
.: DQGS ZLWK.: DQGS
7KH$852&IRUVLJQLÀFDWLYHOLYHUÀEURVLVGHWHFWLRQIRUWKHWKUHH$'&UHVSHFWLYHO\
ZHUHRI &,S &,S DQG
&,S
&RQFOXVLRQ ':05, ZLWK E YDOXHV RI DQG PV GR QRW DGHTXDWHO\
GLVFULPLQDWH WKH GLIIHUHQW OLYHU ÀEURVLV VWDJHV 7KLV WHFKQLTXH LV QRW XVHIXO IRU
VLJQLÀFDWLYHOLYHUÀEURVLVGHWHFWLRQ
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDVVHVVPHQWRIIXQFWLRQDOFKDQJHVLQOLYHU
SHUIXVLRQUHODWHGWRLQWUDKHSDWLFLVOHWVWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ LVOHWW[ DQG
FOLQLFDORXWFRPHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
$3DOPLVDQR$(VSRVLWR)'H&REHOOL30DIÀ7&DQX30DJLVWUHWWL
*,URQL$6HFFKL$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,7
3XUSRVH3DQFUHDWLFLVOHWWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ LVOHWW[ WKURXJKLQWUDSRUWDOYHLQLQIX
VLRQLVDSURPLVLQJWKHUDSHXWLFDSSURDFKIRU7'0EXWPRVWLVOHWVDUHORVWLQWKH
ÀUVWSKDVHVDIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ$SRWHQWLDOFUXFLDOIDFWRUIRULVOHWVHQJUDIWPHQW
VHHPVWREHYDVFXODULVDWLRQ$SUHYLRXVSUHFOLQLFDOVWXG\IRXQGDVWURQJFRUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ '&(05,
SDUDPHWHUVDQGLPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLFDOPHDVXUHVRILVOHWVQHRYDVFXODULVDWLRQ$LPRI
RXUVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHFKDQJHVLQWKHOLYHUSHUIXVLRQRFFXUULQJDWGD\VIURP
LQWUDKHSDWLFLVOHWVLQIXVLRQLQKXPDQVDQGFRUUHODWHWKLVGDWDZLWKLVOHWW[RXWFRPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVGLDEHWLFSDWLHQWV SWV UHFHLYHGLVOHWW['&(05,VWXGLHV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHLVOHWW[DQGDWZHHNIURPWUDQVSODQWDWLRQRQD7XVLQJ
D7Z'75,9(VHTXHQFH VOLFHWKLFNQHVVPPG\QDPLFVFDQVWHPSRUDO
UHVROXWLRQVHF HQFRPSDVVLQJWKHHQWLUHOLYHUGXULQJLQWUDYHQRXVJDGROLQLXP
LQMHFWLRQ'&(05,ZDVTXDQWLWDWLYHO\DQDO\VHGWRREWDLQPD[LPXPHQKDQFHPHQW
0( DQG DUHD XQGHU FXUYH $8& '&(05,SDUDPHWHUV PRGLÀFDWLRQV ZHUH
FRPSDUHGZLWKPHWDEROLFIXQFWLRQ>&SHSWLGHJO\FDWHGKDHPRJORELQ +E$F @DW
PRQWKVDIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
5HVXOWV '&(05, SDUDPHWHUV LQFUHDVHG GD\V DIWHU WUDQVSODQWDWLRQ LQ SWV
SWу0(у$8&SWу0(у$8& 7KHVHSWVVKRZHG
D JRRG JUDIW IXQFWLRQ DW PRQWKV DIWHU WUDQVSODQWDWLRQ SW&SHS QJPO
у+E$F SW&SHS QJPO у+E$F '&(05, SDUDPHWHUV
VWURQJO\GHFUHDVHGLQWKHRWKHUSWVDWZHHNDIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ SWу0(
у$8&SWу0(у$8& 7KH\ H[SHULPHQWHG JUDIW IDLOXUH
UHVSHFWLYHO\DQGPRQWKVDIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ &SHSVHFUHWLRQDIWHUDUJLQLQH
VWLPXOXVSWSW
&RQFOXVLRQ)URPRXUSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV'&(05,FKDQJHVDSSHDUWRSUHGLFW
LVOHWVW[ RXWFRPH VXSSRUWLQJ WKH K\SRWKHVLV WKDW HDUO\ LVOHWV YDVFXODULVDWLRQ LV
FUXFLDOIRUHQJUDIWPHQW
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIHIÀFLHQF\DQGLPDJHTXDOLW\EHWZHHQDPDQXDODQGD
QRYHODXWRPDWHG05VFDQQHULQWHUIDFHLQOLYHU05LPDJLQJ
&.ORHWHUV/8PXWOX&0RHQQLQJKRII0/DGG$6RPEHW]NL
*$QWRFK06FKODPDQQ0)RUVWLQJ7&/DXHQVWHLQ(VVHQ'(
'VVHOGRUI'( FKULVWLDQNORHWHUV#XNHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH SRWHQWLDO EHQHÀWV RI DQ DXWRPDWHG 05, DOJRULWKP LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGOLYHUH[DPLQDWLRQV 7 XQGHUFRQVLGHUDWLRQRI
H[DPLQDWLRQHIÀFLHQF\DQGLPDJHTXDOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQW\SDWLHQWV \HDUV ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQ
UROOHGDQGUHIHUUHGWRDFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05H[DPLQDWLRQRIWKHOLYHU3DWLHQWV
ZHUHUDQGRPLVHGWRRQHRIWKHIROORZLQJVFDQQHUV70$*1(720$HUDLQFOXGLQJ
DFRPSOHWHO\DXWRPDWHGXVHULQWHUIDFHRUD70$*1(720$YDQWRZLWKPDQX
DOO\RSHUDWHGVFDQQHUVRIWZDUH 6LHPHQV*HUPDQ\ 7ZREOLQGHGUHDGHUVUDWHG
WKHLPDJHTXDOLW\LQGLIIHUHQWFDWHJRULHV DQJXODWLRQV)29 LPDJHFRQWUDVW
LPDJHQRLVH DUWHIDFWVDQG SUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHWDUJHWRUJDQIURPH[FHOOHQW
´µ WRLQVXIÀFLHQW ´µ 7KHGHJUHHRIGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHWRGHSLFWOLYHUOHVLRQV
ZDVUDWHGIURP´FHUWDLQµ ´µ WR´XQFHUWDLQµ ´µ $ERYHQDPHGFDWHJRULHVZHUH
DVVHVVHGIRUWKHIROORZLQJVHTXHQFHV 7UXH),63 7Z76( +$67(
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
,QRSSRVHGSKDVH 05&3 'DQG')/$6+7RWDOH[DPLQDWLRQWLPHZDV
UHFRUGHG&KLVTXDUHWHVWDQG8WHVWZHUHXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQ LPDJH TXDOLW\ IRU WKH DXWRPDWHG SURFHVVHG H[DPLQDWLRQV
ZDV UDWHG KLJKHU IRU DOO FDWHJRULHV DQG VKRZHG VWDWLVWLFDO VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH
LQ DVVHVVPHQW RI LPDJH FRQWUDVW PHDQDXWRPDWHG YV PHDQPDQXDO DQG
SUHVHQWDWLRQRIWDUJHWRUJDQ PHDQDXWRPDWHGYVPHDQPDQXDO S
7KHGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHZDV S UHVSHFWLYHO\0HDQH[DPLQDWLRQ
WLPHZDVPLQLQWKHDXWRPDWLFDOO\DQGPLQLQWKHPDQXDOO\SURFHVVHG
H[DPLQDWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHFRPSOHWHO\DXWRPDWHG05VFDQQHUXVHULQWHUIDFHVKRZVDQLQ
FUHDVHLQLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFH7KHH[DPLQDWLRQWLPHZDVKLJKHU
LQWKHDXWRPDWLFDOO\SURFHVVHGH[DPLQDWLRQGXHWRORQJHUODVWLQJ05VHTXHQFHV
%0,YDOXHV 3 DWEDVHOLQHZHUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHRI
PHDQDRUWLFOXPHQDUHDLL K\SHUWHQVLRQ 3 ZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\LQFUHDVHGUDWHRISURJUHVVLRQLQPHDQ&:9LLL PDOHJHQGHU 3 ZDV
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGUDWHRISURJUHVVLRQLQPHDQ3)9DQGLY
VPRNLQJ 3 ZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGUDWHRISURJUHV
VLRQLQPHDQ7%5YDOXHV$OORWKHUGRFXPHQWHGULVNIDFWRUVZHUHQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKFKDQJHVLQDWKHURVFOHURWLFGLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$WKHURVFOHURWLF GLVHDVH SURJUHVVLRQ DV DVVHVVHG E\ ZKROH ERG\
)'*3(7&7LVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQXPEHURIIDFWRUVVXFKDVDUWHULDO)'*XSWDNH
KLJK%0,K\SHUWHQVLRQPDOHJHQGHUDQGVPRNLQJ
%
'LDJQRVLVRIODUJHYHVVHOYDVFXOLWLVZLWK))'*3(7&7VLQJOH
FHQWUHH[SHULHQFHRQSDWLHQWV
85R]]DQLJR$3HOOHJULQ0&HQWRQ]H*&DVDJUDQGD0&HWUXOR
''RQQHU7UHQWR,7 DQGUHDSHOOHJULQ#DSVVWQLW
$OYHRODUHFKLQRFRFFRVLVRIWKHOLYHUGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ
ÀQGLQJV
$3RPRQL66FKPLGW(8OGU\1+DONLF$'HQ\V50HXOL)%HFFH
/DXVDQQH&+ QSRPRQL#KRWPDLOFRP
5RRP12
9DVFXODU
66
,PDJLQJLQYDVFXODUGLVHDVHV
0RGHUDWRUV
+.$KOVWU|P8SSVDOD6(
23HOOHULQ3DULV)5
%
,PSDFWRIFDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNIDFWRUVDQGYHVVHOZDOOLQÁDPPDWLRQ
RQDWKHURVFOHURWLFGLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQD3(7&7VWXG\
76DDP$5RPLQJHU0+DEV/:DOWHU3%DUWHQVWHLQ&5LVW0)5HLVHU
0+DFNHU.1LNRODRX0XQLFK'( 7RELDV6DDP#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH:HK\SRWKHVLVHGWKDWDWKHURVFOHURWLFULVNIDFWRUVDQGYHVVHOZDOOLQÁDP
PDWLRQDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQDFFHOHUDWHGSURJUHVVLRQRIDWKHURVFOHURWLFGLVHDVH
DVDVVHVVHGE\>)@ÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVH )'* 3(7&7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV WXPRXU SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW ZKROH ERG\ )'*3(7
DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7WZLFHZLWKLQPRQWKV&OLQLFDOULVNIDFWRUVIRUDWKHUR
VFOHURVLVDQGPHGLFDWLRQVZHUHGRFXPHQWHG%ORRGSRROFRUUHFWHGVWDQGDUGLVHG
XSWDNHYDOXH 7%5 DQGFDOFLÀHGZDOOYROXPH &:9 ZHUHPHDVXUHGLQWKHDRUWD
DQGERWKLOLDFDQGFDURWLGDUWHULHV)XUWKHUPRUHSHULFDUGLDOIDWYROXPH 3)9 DQG
PHDQDRUWLFOXPHQDUHDLQWKHWKRUDFLFDRUWDZHUHPHDVXUHG7KHRQHVDPSOHWWHVW
DQGPXOWLSOHUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVZHUHXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDOFRPSDULVRQV
5HVXOWV2QDYHUDJHDRUWLFOXPHQDUHDGHFUHDVHGE\\HDU 3 3)9
LQFUHDVHGE\\HDU 3 DQG&:9LQFUHDVHGE\\HDU 3
7%5YDOXHVGLGQRWFKDQJHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKLQPRQWKV \HDU 0XOWLSOH
UHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDWL KLJKHU7%5YDOXHV 3 DQGKLJKHU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
3XUSRVH7KLVLVDUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\WKDWDLPVWRDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUP
DQFHRI))'*3(7&7LQODUJHYHVVHOYDVFXOLWLV /99 FRPSDULQJIRXUGLIIHUHQW
VWDQGDUGVRILPDJHHYDOXDWLRQDQGWDNLQJLQWRDFFRXQWFRQFRPLWDQWLPPXQRVXS
SUHVVLYHWKHUDS\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV &RQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV Q PDOH IHPDOH
PHDQDJH\RUDQJH\R VHQWZLWKFOLQLFDOVXVSLFLRQRI/99ZLWKDWOHDVW
V\PSWRPVDPRQJIHYHUZHLJKWORVVDUWKUDOJLDP\DOJLDXQGHUZHQW))'*3(7
&7H[DPLQDWLRQ$WWKHPRPHQWRI3(7&7VFDQRQSDWLHQWVZHUHXQGHU
LPPXQRVXSSUHVVLYHWKHUDS\)LQDOGLDJQRVLVRI/99ZDVREWDLQHGRQFOLQLFDOFRQ
VHQVXVLQRISDWLHQWV)RXUW\SHVRIDQDO\VLVZHUHXVHGDQGFRPSDUHGZLWK
0F1HPDUWHVW VHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHPD[LPDOVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNHYDOXH 689PD[
TXDOLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRQPD[LPXPLQWHQVLW\SURMHFWLRQ 0,3 LPDJHVZLWKD
IRXUJUDGHVFDOH WR UHSHDWHGZLWKWZRGLIIHUHQWFXWRIIV TXDOLWDWLYHHYDOXD
WLRQZLWKFROOHJLDOFOLQLFRUDGLRORJLFDOFRUUHODWLRQ FRQVLGHULQJFRQFXUUHQWYDVFXODU
SDWKRORJ\IRFDOGLVWULEXWLRQDJHFDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNIDFWRUV
5HVXOWV 4XDQWLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV ZLWK 689PD[ FXWRII YDOXH VHQV
VSHF DFF GLG QRW VKRZ VWDWLVWLFDO VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV FRP
SDUHGWRVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQZLWKKLJKHUFXWRII JUDGH VHQV
VSHF DFF 6HPLTXDQWLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV ZLWK ORZHU FXWRII JUDGH
KDGVXSHULRUVHQVLWLYLW\EXWUHGXFHGVSHFLÀFLW\ VHQVVSHF
DFF (YDOXDWLRQ ZLWK FROOHJLDO FOLQLFRUDGLRORJLFDO FRUUHODWLRQ VKRZHG
LQFUHDVHVSHFLÀFLW\ZLWKRXWDGHFUHDVHLQVHQVLELOLW\ VHQVVSHF
DFF
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQRI))'*3(7&7H[DPVLQ/99QHHGVWREHEDVHG
RQHIÀFLHQWLQWHJUDWLRQRIFOLQLFRUDGLRORJLFDOGDWDFXVWRPLVHGIRUHDFKSDWLHQW
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\LQ
PDQDJHPHQWRISXOPRQDU\DUWHULRYHQRXVPDOIRUPDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK++7 2VOHUGLVHDVH
*.6FKQHLGHU$0DVVPDQQ$%XHFNHU3)ULHV
+RPEXUJDG6DDU'( GUJXHQWKHUVFKQHLGHU#XNVHX
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ &(
05$ IRU PDQDJHPHQW RI SXOPRQDU\ DUWHULRYHQRXV PDOIRUPDWLRQV 3$90 LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKKHUHGLWDU\KDHPRUUKDJLFWHODQJLHFWDVLD ++7 DVZHOODVDVFUHHQLQJ
SURFHGXUHIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQDQGIRUIROORZXSDIWHUHPEROLVDWLRQWKHUDS\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\PDOHIHPDOH
ZLWKFRQÀUPHG++7RUWKHLUÀUVWGHJUHHUHODWLYHVXQGHUZHQWVFUHHQLQJSXOPRQDU\
&(05$ *DGROLQLXP%237$PPRONJERG\ZHLJKW IRUWKHSUHVHQFHRI3$90
3DWLHQWVZLWKDWOHDVWRQH3$90!PPRUDIHHGLQJSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\GLDPHWHU
!PPZHUHUHIHUUHGIRUFDWKHWHUDQJLRJUDSK\ '6$ IRUHPEROLVDWLRQWKHUDS\DQG
XQGHUZHQWIROORZXS05$IRUGHWHFWLRQRIUHSHUIXVHG3$90V
5HVXOWV2YHUDOO&(05$GHWHFWHG3$90LQRISDWLHQWV LQ
PHQLQZRPHQLQZRPHQRIFKLOGEHDULQJDJH 0RVW3$90VGHWHFWHG
RQ&(05$ZHUHVPDOO PP RISDWLHQWVZLWK3$90VGHWHFWHGRQ
&(05$XQGHUZHQWJOREDORUVHOHFWLYH'6$6LJQLÀFDQWO\ S IHZHU3$90V
>@ ZHUHGHPRQVWUDWHGRQJOREDO'6$RIZKLFKZHUHHPEROLVHG
)ROORZXS &(05$ VKRZHG QHZO\ GHYHORSHG 3$90 LQ SDWLHQWV LQWHUYDO
\HDUV DQGUHSHUIXVHG3$90 GXHWRUHFDQDOLVDWLRQLQVXIÀFLHQWSDFNLQJ LQ
SDWLHQWV LQWHUYDOPRQWKV\HDUV RIZKLFKSDWLHQWVZHUHHPEROLVHGHOVH
ZKHUH$OOUHSHUIXVHG3$90VZHUHFRQÀUPHGE\'6$DQGUHHPEROLVHGVXFFHVVIXOO\
&RQFOXVLRQ &(05$ VKRXOG EH WKH PHWKRG RI FKRLFH IRU WKH PDQDJHPHQW RI
3$90VLQ++7SDWLHQWV'XHWRWKHKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\DQGWKHODFNRILRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQ
05VKRXOGEHSUHIHUUHGWR&7LIDYDLODEOH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RUHSRUWWKHGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ ':, ÀQGLQJVLQKHSDWLF
DOYHRODU HFKLQRFRFFRVLV $( 7R HYDOXDWH WKH XVHIXOQHVV RI DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQWV $'&V IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJWKHW\SHVRI$(OHVLRQV DVUHSRUWHGE\
.RGDPD5DGLRORJ\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ LQFOXGHG SDWLHQWV ZRPHQ
PHDQDJH\HDUV ZLWK$(OLYHUOHVLRQV !FP WKDWKDGEHHQLQYHVWLJDWHG
E\ 7HVOD 05 LPDJLQJ EHWZHHQ 0DUFK DQG$XJXVW SHUIRUPLQJ RXU
VWDQGDUGSURWRFROLQFOXGLQJ':, EYDOXHVDQGVPP ,QFRQVHQVXV
WZR UDGLRORJLVWV DVVHVVHG OHVLRQ FKDUDFWHULVWLFV VXFK DV GLDPHWHU F\VWLF DQG
RUÀEURWLFFRPSRQHQWVLQFOXGLQJ.RGDPDFODVVLÀFDWLRQVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHPHQWFDOFLÀFDWLRQV RQ&7 DQGPHDVXUHGWKH$'&RIHDFKOHVLRQ$(
ZDVFRQÀUPHGE\VHURORJ\ELRSV\DQGRUVXUJHU\LQDOOSDWLHQWV
5HVXOWV6HYHQWHHQOHVLRQVRI.RGDPDW\SHRIW\SHRIW\SHRIW\SH
DQGRIW\SHZHUHIRXQG0HDQ 6' $'&RIDOO$(OHVLRQVZDVð
PPV0HDQ 6' $'&VRI.RGDPDW\SHDQGOHVLRQVZHUH
DQGðPPVUHVSHFWLYHO\1RVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHZDVQRWHGEHWZHHQWKHGLIIHUHQW.RGDPDW\SHV S 3UHVHQFHRI
ÀEURWLF S DQGRUFDOFLÀHG S FRPSRQHQWVRUFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQW
S RI$(OHVLRQVZHUHQRWFRUUHODWHGZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQ$'&V
&RQFOXVLRQ$'&VRI$(OHVLRQVDUHUHODWLYHO\ORZFRPSDUHGWRRWKHUF\VWLFOLYHU
OHVLRQV ZKLFK LV KHOSIXO LQ VXJJHVWLQJ WKH GLDJQRVLV +RZHYHU$'&V ZHUH QRW
IRXQGWREHXVHIXOIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ.RGDPDW\SHVRI$(OHVLRQV
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&RQFOXVLRQ:HREVHUYHGDVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQ 3 EHWZHHQWKHSUHV
HQFHRIVWHQRVLVRI&$DQGWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI3)WKDWLVDPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQRI
SDQFUHDWLFRGXRGHQHFWRP\DQGLVUHODWHGWRDPRUWDOLW\UDWHRI$VWHQRVLV
RI&$LVHDVLO\WUHDWHGGXULQJWKHVXUJHU\DQGPXVWEHWKHUHIRUHLQFOXGHGLQWKH
UHSRUWRIWKHSUHVXUJHU\&7H[DP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHQRQOLQHDUEOHQGLQJZLWKVWDQGDUGOLQHDUEOHQGLQJ YLUWXDO
N9 DQGORZN9LPDJHVRIGXDOHQHUJ\&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\IRULPSURYHG
GLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HFRPSDUHGGXDOHQHUJ\&7GDWDVHWVRIFHQWUDODQG
SHULSKHUDODFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP$QRQOLQHDUEOHQGLQJPHWKRGEDVHGRQD
PRGLÀHGVLJPRLGIXQFWLRQZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHORZN9LPDJHVHULHVDQGWKH
VWDQGDUGOLQHDUEOHQGLQJPHWKRGWKDWVLPXODWHVWKHDWWHQXDWLRQRIDN9VFDQ
)RUWKHQRQOLQHDUEOHQGLQJPHWKRGZHHYDOXDWHGGLIIHUHQWSDUDPHWHUVHWWLQJV
ZLWKGLIIHUHQWEOHQGLQJFHQWUHDQGZLGWK&RQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 ZDVFDOFX
ODWHG7ZRLQGHSHQGHQWUDGLRORJLVWVHYDOXDWHGWKHWRWDOO\LPDJHVHWVIRUWKHLU
YLVXDOSUHIHUHQFH2YHUDOOVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVUDWHGZLWKDSRLQWVFDOH
H[FHOOHQWLPDJH QRQGLDJQRVWLF
5HVXOWV:LWKHLWKHURQHRIWKHQRQOLQHDUEOHQGLQJVHWWLQJVWKH&15ZDVVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\KLJKHUFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHORZN9 &15 DQGVXEMHFWLYH
RYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\ DQGOLQHDUEOHQGLQJVHULHV &15 DQG
VXEMHFWLYHRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\ 7KHRSWLPDOEOHQGLQJFHQWUHDQGZLGWKIRUKLJKHVW
&15 &15 DQGVXEMHFWLYHRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\ UHVXOWV
VWURQJO\GHSHQGHGRQWKHOHYHORIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWLQWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHV
+RZHYHURQVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\UDWLQJWKHLPDJHVHULHVZLWKWKHKLJKHVW&15
ZDVUDWHGLQRIFDVHV DVWKHEHVWLQWHUPVRIRSWLPDOLPDJHTXDOLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ1RQOLQHDUEOHQGLQJRIGXDOHQHUJ\SXOPRQDU\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
DOORZVVLJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHRI&15DQGLPDJHTXDOLW\
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIDFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVPGHWHFWLRQXVLQJQRQOLQHDU
EOHQGLQJLQGXDOHQHUJ\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
)$O%XWPHK/.URNHU-0.HUO0&/DUVRQ%%RGHOOH%6FKHOO0%HHUHV
7-9RJO5:%DXHU)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'( )LUDV$OEXWPHK#JPDLOFRP
%
,PDJLQJÀQGLQJVLQDUWHULDOVWHQRVLVDQGPXUDOLQYROYHPHQWLQ
7DND\DVXDUWHULWLVRQ&(05$
$.66KDUPD1RLGD,1 VKRNLH#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV YHVVHO LQYROYHPHQW DQG DFWLYLW\ RI 7DND\DVX DUWHULWLV ZLWK
ZKROHERG\05$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKGLDJQRVLVRI7$ZHUHVXEMHFWHGWRZKROH
ERG\05$ZLWK*DGROLQLXPGLPHJOXPLQH$FFRUGLQJWRYDVFXOLWLVDFWLYLW\VFRUH
SDWLHQWV ZHUH FODVVLÀHG DV KDYLQJ DFWLYHSHUVLVWHQW GLVHDVH DQG SDWLHQWV DV
KDYLQJUHPLVVLYHGLVHDVH7KHDUWHULDOV\VWHPZDVGLYLGHGLQWRVHJPHQWVRI
UHJLRQV7KHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDOOWKLFNQHVVDQGZDOOVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ZHUHHYDOXDWHG
E\ WKUHH UDGLRORJLVWV ZKR ZHUH QRW NQRZLQJ FOLQLFDO GDWD 4XDOLW\ DQDO\VLV ZDV
SHUIRUPHG VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV LQ 6, YDOXHV RI$' DQG 5' ZHUH
WHVWHGRQDSHUUHJLRQEDVLV
5HVXOWV$WRWDODUWHLDOVHJPHQWVZLWKJRRGWRH[FHOOHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\ZHUH
DVVHVVHGH[WUDYDVFXODUPDQLIHVWDWLRQZHUHLGHQWLÀHG,QSDWLHQWVPRQRVWDWLRQ
FRXOGQRWGHSLFWYHVVHOLQYROYHPHQW7KHYHVVHOZDOOWKLFNQHVVRIWKH$'JURXS
ZDVWKLFNHUWKDQWKDWRI5'JURXS3RVWFRQWUDVW6,UDWLRZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW
IRUERWKWKHJURXSV3HUUHJLRQDQDO\VLVUHYHDOHGKLJKHUVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQFDURWLG
DQGVXEFODYLDQUHJLRQVLQERWKJURXSV
&RQFOXVLRQ:KROHERG\05$DOORZVDFRPSOHWHDQGFRPSKUHQVLYHGRFXPHQWDWLRQ
RIWKHYHVVHOLQYROYHPHQW05$LVYHU\XVHIXOPRGDOLW\IRU7DND\DVXDUWHULWLVVWDJLQJ
ZKHWKHUGLVHDVHLVDFWLYHRUQRWDQGLVDOVRLQIROORZXSIRUWKHUDS\PDQDJHPHQW
%
8VHIXOQHVVRI&7DQJLRJUDSK\RIFHOLDFD[LVSULRUWRSDQFUHDWLFR
GXRGHQHFWRP\
0%HOJUDQR%3HWURQLR:7RVFDQR0$&RYD7ULHVWH,7
EHOJUDQRP#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH7RSHUIRUPD&7DQJLRJUDSK\RIWKHFHOLDFD[LV &$ WRGHWHFWWKHSUHV
HQFHRIVWHQRVLVGXHWRDWKHURVFOHURVLV $6 RUWRWKHPHGLDQDUFXDWHOLJDPHQW
0$/ DQGWRFRUUHODWHLWZLWKWKHSUHYDOHQFHRIFRPSOLFDWLRQDIWHUVXUJHU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHYLVHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\SDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQW
WRSDQFUHDWLFRGXRGHQHFWRP\EHWZHHQDQGLQWKH6XUJHU\'HSDUWPHQW
RIRXU,QVWLWXWLRQ(DFKSDWLHQWXQGHUZHQWWRD&7DQJLRJUDSK\ ZLWKLQGD\V
EHIRUHWKHVXUJHU\ ZLWKDVOLFH [PPVOLFHV VFDQQHUDIWHUDGPLQLVWUD
WLRQRIPORILRGLQDWHGFRQWUDVWPHGLDWRGHWHFWWKHSUHVHQFHRIVWHQRVLVRI&$
!RIOXPHQUHGXFWLRQ 7KHSUHYDOHQFHRISDQFUHDWLFÀVWXOD 3) ZDVFROOHFWHG
IURPWKH3DWLHQW VFOLQLFDOKLVWRU\
5HVXOWV 2I WKH SDWLHQWV LQFOXGHG SUHVHQWHG D &$ VWHQRVLV GXH WR
0$/GXHWR$6 $IWHUWKHVXUJHU\SDWLHQWVGHYHORSHGD3)RIWKLVJURXS
SUHVHQWHGDVWHQRVLVRI&$
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
9DVFXODUDQRPDOLHVLQDSRSXODWLRQZLWK7XUQHUV\QGURPHUHDO
DGMXQFWLYHGLDJQRVWLFUROHDQGFOLQLFDOLPSDFWRIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
DQJLRJUDSK\ 05$ YVHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ (&+2
*5LQDOGL*0LQHR)0RQWDQDUL/0D]]DQWL'3UDQGVWUDOOHU95XVVR
)%XLD//RYDWR0=RPSDWRUL%RORJQD,7
3XUSRVH 7XUQHU V\QGURPH 76 LV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK FRQJHQLWDO KHDUW GLVHDVHV
&+' DRUWLFGLODWLRQDQGGLVVHFWLRQEXWDOVRZLWKDKLJKSUHYDOHQFHRIYDVFXODU
DQRPDOLHV QRW HDVLO\ GHSLFWHG E\ (&+2 :H WHVWHG WKH DGMXQFWLYH GLDJQRVWLF
YDOXHRI05YHUVXV(&+2WRLGHQWLI\WKHSUHYDOHQFHRIYDVFXODUDQRPDOLHVLQD76
SRSXODWLRQHFKRFDUGLRJUDSKLFDOO\SUHVHOHFWHGIRUWKHDEVHQFHRI&+'H[FHSWLQJ
ELFXVSLGDRUWLFYDOYH %$9
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 5HWURVSHFWLYH DQDO\VLV RI 05 DRUWLF VWXG\ RI 76
SDWLHQWVZDVSHUIRUPHGWRHYDOXDWHPLQRUDQGPDMRUYDVFXODUDQRPDOLHV$OO05
VWXGLHV LQFOXGHG WKRUDFLF D[LDO DQG REOLTXH VDJLWWDO VSLQHFKR VHTXHQFHV DQG
WKRUDFRDEGRPLQDO05$
5HVXOWV05VKRZHGYDVFXODUDQRPDOLHVLQSDWLHQWV WKHPRVWIUHTXHQW
LVDRUWLFDUFKHORQJDWLRQ SDWLHQWV $PRQJPDMRUDQRPDOLHVPLVGLDJQRVHG
E\(&+205DQDO\VLVLGHQWLÀHGSDUWLDODQRPDORXVSXOPRQDU\YHQRXVUHWXUQV
3$395 LQIHULRUKROORZYHLQLQWHUUXSWLRQSHULSKHUDODUWHULHVDQHXU\VPV
7KHVXEJURXSZLWK%$9 SDWLHQWV VKRZVKLJKHUSUHYDOHQFHRIPDOIRUPD
WLRQV S H[SHFLDOO\HORQJDWLRQDQG3$395 $PRQJSDWLHQWVQRW
DIIHFWHGE\%$9FRPSDUDWLYHDQDO\VLVEHWZHHQJURXSVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWYDVFXODU
PDOIRUPDWLRQV 3$395H[FOXGHG VKRZHGKLJKHUDRUWLFGLODWLRQSUHYDOHQFHLQWKH
PDOIRUPDWLRQJURXS S 05DQDO\VLVLGHQWLÀHG3$395QRWUHSRUWHGDW
ÀUVWHYDOXDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ05KDVDQDGMXQFWLYHGLDJQRVWLFSRZHUYHUVXV(&+2LGHQWLI\LQJ
VHYHUDOYDVFXODUPDOIRUPDWLRQVRWKHUZLVHPLVGLDJQRVHGDQGDSRWHQWLDOFOLQLFDO
LPSDFWRQ76QDWXUDOKLVWRU\05$PXVWDOZD\VEHSHUIRUPHGLQ76WRLQWHJUDWH
(&+2VWXG\05HYDOXDWLRQH[SHFLDOO\LQ%$9SDWLHQWVPXVWEHH[WHQGHGWRDOO
WKHWKRUDFLFYDVFXODWXUH
%
'UHFRQVWUXFWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05DQJLRJUDSK\7HVODYV
7HVODLQGHWHFWLRQRIWKHGLIIHUHQWEUDQFKHVRIWKHLQWHUQDOLOLDFDUWHU\
LQIHPDOHVVFKHGXOHGIRUXWHULQHDUWHU\HPEROLVDWLRQ
1111DJXLE1($1RXU(OGLQ7/HKQHUW7*UXEHU5RXK0+DUWK
7-9RJO)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'( QDJ\QQQ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHDELOLW\RIWKH7HVOD 7 05,YHUVXVWKH7HVOD
7 05,LQGHWHFWLQJWKHGLIIHUHQWEUDQFKHVRIWKHLQWHUQDOLOLDFDUWHU\ ,,$ EHIRUH
8$(XVLQJ'UHFRQVWUXFWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05DQJLRJUDSK\ &(05$
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 3UHHPEROLVDWLRQ &(05$ IURP IHPDOHV PHDQ
DJH\HDUV ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGE\UDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXV
6WXGLHVZHUHGRQHXVLQJD7 Q ,,$ DQG7 Q ,,$ 05,DQG
'LPDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJ6\QJR9HVVHO9LHZ$VFRULQJV\VWHPRI
*UDGHVZDVXVHGVFRUHPHDQVWKDWWKHDUWHU\ZDVQRWVHHQLQWHUUXSWHGRULWV
RULJLQZDVQRWLGHQWLÀHGVFRUHPHDQVWKDWWKHDUWHU\ZDVIDLQWO\VHHQEXWFDQ
EHWUDFHGZLWKQRPLVVLQJVHJPHQWVWLOOLWJLYHVRIILWVÀUVWEUDQFKVFRUHPHDQV
WKDWWKHDUWHU\ZDVFOHDUO\VHHQ'LIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQERWKV\VWHPVZHUHWHVWHG
XVLQJ0DQWHO+DHQVHO7HVW
5HVXOWV7KHVXSHULRUJOXWHDODUWHU\ZDVGHWHFWHGLQWKH7LQDUWHULHV VHQ
VLWLYLW\ 6 LQWKH7LQDUWHULHV 6 QRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
ZDV QRWHG EHWZHHQ ERWK V\VWHPV S ,QIHULRUJOXWHDO 7 Q 6
7 Q 6 QR GLIIHUHQFH S ,QWHUQDOSXGHQGDO 7 Q 6
7 Q 6 QR GLIIHUHQFH S 0LGGOHUHFWDO 7 Q 6
7 Q 6 QR GLIIHUHQFH S ,OLROXPEDU 7 Q 6
7 Q 6 VLJQLILFDQW GLIIHUHQFH QRWHG S /DWHUDOVDFUDO
7 Q 6 7 Q 6 VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH QRWHG S
8WHULQH7 Q 6 7 Q 6 VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHQRWHG S
2EWXUDWRU7 Q 6 7 Q 6 VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHQRWHG
S 6XSHULRUYHVLFDO7 Q 6 7 Q 6 VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHQRWHG S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH7ZDVVXSHULRUWRWKH7LQGHWHFWLQJDOO,,$EUDQFKHVH[FHSW
WKHLQWHUQDOSXGHQGDOPLGGOHUHFWDOVXSHULRUDQGLQIHULRUJOXWHDODUWHULHVLQZKLFK
ERWKV\VWHPVVKRZHGVLPLODUSHUIRUPDQFH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
/RZGRVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGWLPHUHVROYHG05DQJLRJUDSK\DW7
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRUWUHDWPHQWSODQQLQJDQGIROORZXSRIERG\
YDVFXODUPDOIRUPDWLRQV
3/XFDWHOOL0$Q]LGHL%&DYDOOR0DULQFROD$1DSROL))DQHOOL
53DVVDULHOOR5RPH,7
%
$XWRPDWHG'RSSOHUDQJOHFRUUHFWLRQLQOLYHUWUDQVSODQWXOWUDVRXQG
2.RORN\WKDV73*DXWKLHU&&XHYDV3%KDUJDYD/00LWVXPRUL
'(*UHHQ$$6DDG6HDWWOH:$86(LQGKRYHQ1/%RWKHOO:$86
RUSKHXV#XZHGX
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH FOLQLFDO IHDVLELOLW\ RI DXWRPDWLFDOO\ FRUUHFWHG 'RSSOHU
DQJOHLQKHSDWLFYHVVHOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\WKHLQVWLWXWLRQDO
UHYLHZ ERDUG DOO SDWLHQWV JDYH WKHLU ZULWWHQ FRQVHQW WR SDUWLFLSDWH KHSDWLF
YHVVHOVZHUHHYDOXDWHGLQSDWLHQWV WRWDORIDUWHULHVDQGYHLQVSHUSDWLHQW
DIWHU OLYHU WUDQVSODQW ZLWK XOWUDVRXQG XVLQJ D FXUYLOLQHDU 0+] WUDQVGXFHU
PDQXDO'RSSOHUDQJOHFRUUHFWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGDVWKHJROGVWDQGDUGIROORZHGE\
DXWRPDWHG'RSSOHUDQJOHFRUUHFWLRQERWKSHUIRUPHGE\WKHVDPHRSHUDWRUZLWK
\HDUVRIH[SHULHQFHLQDEGRPLQDO'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQGEOLQGHGWRWKHPHDVXUHPHQWV
RIWKHFRPSHWLQJPHWKRG'RSSOHUDQJOHVDQGSHDNYHORFLWLHVXVLQJPDQXDODQG
DXWRPDWHGFRUUHFWLRQRI'RSSOHUDQJOHZHUHUHFRUGHG5HVXOWVZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJ
UHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVDQGD%ODQG$OWPDQ 'LIIHUHQFH SORW&DVHE\FDVHDQDO\VLV
ZDVSHUIRUPHGIRU'RSSOHUDQJOHVGLVFUHSDQWE\PRUHWKDQGHJUHHVWRHYDOXDWH
IRUSRVVLEOHDHWLRORJLHV
5HVXOWVYHVVHOVZHUHVXFFHVVIXOO\H[DPLQHG$VWURQJFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQG
EHWZHHQWKHPDQXDOO\DGMXVWHGDQGWKHDXWRPDWHGDQJOHFRUUHFWLRQ7KHPHDQ
GLVFUHSDQF\ RI 'RSSOHU DQJOHV ZDV GHJUHHV 6' GHJUHHV FRUUHOD
WLRQFRHIÀFLHQW 7KHPHDQGLVFUHSDQF\RISHDNYHORFLWLHVZDVFPV
6' FPVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW &DXVHVIRUGLVFUHSDQWDQJOHVDERYH
GHJUHHVLQFOXGHGFXUYHGDQGELIXUFDWLQJYHVVHOVORZHFFHQWULFLW\PHUJHGYHV
VHOVXVHUҋVSUHIHUHQFHRI'RSSOHUJDWHSODFHPHQWDQGRWKHU'LVFUHSDQFLHVZHUH
GHHPHGFOLQLFDOO\QRQVLJQLÀFDQW
&RQFOXVLRQ$XWRPDWLRQRI'RSSOHUDQJOHFRUUHFWLRQLVFOLQLFDOO\IHDVLEOHLQWKH
HYDOXDWLRQRIKHSDWLFYDVFXODWXUH,WPD\HQKDQFHVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQDQGUHSURGXF
LELOLW\RI'RSSOHUPHDVXUHPHQWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5RRP3
3K\VLFVLQ5DGLRORJ\
66
,QWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\DQGPDPPRJUDSK\
0RGHUDWRUV
($WDODU$QNDUD75
<.\ULDNRX)RUFKKHLP'(
%
'HYHORSPHQWRILQKRVSLWDO[UD\UDGLRJUDSKLFV\VWHPXVLQJURWDWLQJ
FHULXPDQRGHIRUFRURQDU\DQGFHUHEUDOPLFURDQJLRJUDSK\
+0RUL&7DQDND<,NH\D7)XMLL76KL]XPD1)XNX\DPD,VHKDUD-3
3XUSRVH$VFRQYHQWLRQDODQJLRJUDSK\FDQQRWYLVXDOLVHVPDOODUWHULHVZLWKDGL
DPHWHURIѥPZHGHYHORSHGDQLQKRVSLWDOPLFURDQJLRJUDSKLFV\VWHPDQG
HYDOXDWHGLWVSHUIRUPDQFHVLQEDVLFH[SHULPHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHPLFURDQJLRJUDSKLFV\VWHPFRQVLVWVRIDURWDWLQJFH
ULXPDQRGHDQGDODUJHKHDWXQLW 0+8 [UD\JHQHUDWRU7KHTXDVLPRQRFKURPDWLF
[UD\VSHFWUDKDVDSHDNDW.H9DQGKDYHDQDUURZHQHUJ\EDQGRI.H9
LQKDOIPD[LPXPZKLFKFDQHIÀFLHQWO\GHWHFWVPDOODPRXQWRILRGLQHFRQWUDVWLQ
VPDOOYHVVHO7KHKLJK[UD\SKRWRQÁX[JHQHUDWHGE\0+8JHQHUDWRUDOORZVWR
PDLQWDLQHQRXJKSKRWRQQXPEHUDWWKHVXUIDFHRIDÁDWSDQHOGHWHFWRURIVSDWLDO
UHVROXWLRQRIѥPHYHQDIWHUSDVVLQJWKURXJKWKHDGXOWERG\&DQLQHKHDUWDQG
EUDLQRIZKLFKDUWHULDOEHGVDUHÀOOHGZLWKLRGLQHFRQWDLQLQJPLFURVSKHUHVZLWKD
GLDPHWHURIѥPZDVXVHGDVWKHWHVWVDPSOHV
5HVXOWV7KHDQJLRJUDSKLFV\VWHPYLVXDOLVHGLQWUDPXUDOVPDOOFRURQDU\DUWHULHV
HQWLUHO\ IURP WKHLU HSLFDUGLDO RULJLQ WR VXEHQGRFDUGLDO WHUPLQDO SRUWLRQV LQ WKH
H[FLVHGKHDUWDQGWKHSHUIRUDWLQJEUDQFKHVRIFHUHEUDODUWHULHVDULVLQJIURPWKH
PLGGOHFHUHEUDODUWHULHVDQGUHDFKLQJWRWKHGHHSVXEFRUWLFDOOHVLRQVLQWKHEUDLQ
PRGHO 9DVFXODU GLDPHWHU PHDVXUHPHQW UHYHDOHG D VWHSZLVH QDUURZLQJ ZLWK D
À[HGUHGXFWLRQUDWLRDVEUDQFKLQJLQWKHUDQJHRIѥP
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH SUHVHQW DQJLRJUDSKLF V\VWHP ZLOO OHDG WR EHWWHU SUHGLFWLRQ RI
WKHUDSHXWLFHIIHFWVRISHUFXWDQHRXVFRURQDU\LQWHUYHQWLRQDQGRUFRURQDU\E\SDVV
VXUJHU\ DQG EHWWHU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI FHUHEUDO ZKLWH PDWWHU GLVHDVH UHODWHG WR
YDVFXODUFRJQLWLYHLPSDLUPHQWLQFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJV
%
'*XLGDQFHLQLQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\SURWRW\SHGHYHORSPHQWDQG
IHDVLELOLW\VWXG\
-.XQW]66DZDOO06RFKHU:6HPPOHU0.DFKHOULHVV6%DUWOLQJ
+HLGHOEHUJ'((UODQJHQ'( VEDUWOLQJ#GNI]GH
3XUSRVH7RDOORZIRUYROXPHWULF 'WLPH UDGLRORJLFDOJXLGDQFHRILQWHUYHQWLRQV
DW WKH VDPH ORZ GRVH OHYHOV DV FRQYHQWLRQDO SURMHFWLRQ ÁXRURVFRS\ 'WLPH
JXLGDQFH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDO7RGD\ UDGLRORJLFDO JXLGDQFH RI LQWHUYHQWLRQV LV OLPLWHG
WRSURMHFWLRQ ÁXRURVFRS\ DQGUHSHWLWLYHIXOOGRVH YROXPHWULF&7VFDQV7KHXVH
RI FRQWLQXRXV &7 LPDJLQJ DOORZLQJ WUXH ' LQWHUYHQWLRQ JXLGDQFH VXIIHUV IURP
SURKLELWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVH7RUHGXFHLWVGRVHWRDFFHSWDEOHOHYHOVDFRPSUHVVHG
VHQVLQJ&7UHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKPXVLQJSULRULQIRUPDWLRQZDVGHYHORSHGDQG
LPSOHPHQWHG*XLGHGLQWHUYHQWLRQVZHUHVLPXODWHGLQSKDQWRPVDQGSLJPRGHOV
'XULQJLQWHUYHQWLRQVFRQWLQXRXVUDZGDWDDFTXLVLWLRQXVLQJDSURWRW\SHÁDWSDQHO
&7V\VWHPZDVSHUIRUPHG'GDWDVHWVRIWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQSURFHVVZHUHUHFRQ
VWUXFWHGZLWKYDULRXVXQGHUVDPSOLQJUDWLRVFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRYDULRXVGRVHOHYHOV
,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHGIRUWKHXVHLQ'LQWHUYHQWLRQDOJXLGDQFHE\YLVXDO
LQVSHFWLRQ;UD\GRVHVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRELSODQHÁXRURVFRS\
5HVXOWV5HFRQVWUXFWLRQUHVXOWVVKRZHGVXIÀFLHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\IRUKLJKFRQWUDVW
PDWHULDOVDOORZLQJDVIHZDVSURMHFWLRQVSHUUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ*XLGHZLUHVDQG
VWHQWVZHUHYLVLEOHLQD'VHWWLQJFRXOGEHIROORZHGZKLOHPRYLQJDQGORFDWHG
FOHDUO\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRYHVVHOVDQGWKHLUVXUURXQGLQJ5DGLDWLRQGRVHVRI'JXLG
DQFH *\V DOEHLWVOLJKWO\KLJKHUZHUHVWLOOLQWKHRUGHURIELSODQHÁXRURVFRS\
*\V
&RQFOXVLRQ'LQWHUYHQWLRQDOJXLGDQFHLVSRVVLEOHZLWKRXWH[FHHGLQJDFFHSWDEOH
[UD\GRVHYDOXHV8VLQJSULRULQIRUPDWLRQDQGFRPSUHVVHGVHQVLQJLPDJHUHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHVUHDOWLPH'JXLGDQFHDSSURDFKHVPD\EHFRPHDQDWWUDF
WLYHPHWKRGIRULQWHUYHQWLRQJXLGDQFHZLWKDJUHDWSRWHQWLDOWRPDNHLQWHUYHQWLRQV
IDVWHUVDIHUDQGWRPDNHPRUHFRPSOH[LQWHUYHQWLRQVSRVVLEOHZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQW
EHQHÀWIRUSDWLHQWKHDOWK
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHDFFXUDF\RIORZGRVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGWLPHUHVROYHG
705DQJLRJUDSK\ 05$ IRUWKHPRUSKRORJLFDODQGIXQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQWRI
YDVFXODUPDOIRUPDWLRQV 90 DQGWRHYDOXDWHLWVGLDJQRVWLFSRWHQWLDOLQSODQQLQJ
WUHDWPHQWDQGIRUWKHGHSLFWLRQRIWUHDWPHQWLQGXFHGFKDQJHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\ÀYHSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQ90XQGHUZHQW05$WR
HYDOXDWHWKHORFDWLRQDQGH[WHQWRIOHVLRQVDQGWKHLUKDHPRG\QDPLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFV
'7ZHLJKWHGWLPHUHVROYHGVHTXHQFHVZHUHDFTXLUHGIROORZLQJWKHDGPLQLVWUD
WLRQRIPPRONJRIJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH %UDFFR0LODQ,WDO\ 90ZHUH
FODVVLÀHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLUPRUSKRORJ\DQGKDHPRG\QDPLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFV KLJK
ÁRZRUORZÁRZ 7KLVOHDGWRWKHVXEVHTXHQWSDWLHQWҋVPDQDJHPHQWWUDQVDUWHULDO
HPEROLVDWLRQIRUKLJKÁRZ90SHUFXWDQHRXVVFOHURWLVDWLRQLQFDVHRIORZÁRZ90
RUFRPELQHGDSSURDFKIRUDUWHURYHQRXV90)ROORZXS05$ZDVSHUIRUPHG
GD\VDIWHUWUHDWPHQWWRDVVHVVPRUSKRORJLFDODQGIXQFWLRQDOFKDQJHV
5HVXOWV%DVHGRQKDHPRG\QDPLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFV90ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVSUHGRPL
QDQWO\DUWHULDO >@ DUWHURYHQRXV >@ RUYHQRXV >@ 7ZHQW\WKUHH
OHVLRQVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVKLJKÁRZ90DQG DVORZÁRZ90&RPSOHWH
H[FOXVLRQRIWKHQLGXVZDVREWDLQHGLQSDWLHQWV RISDWLHQWVOHDGLQJWR
DGLPHQVLRQDOUHGXFWLRQDQGUHJUHVVLRQRIDHVWKHWLFDOLPSDLUPHQWRUV\PSWRPV
&RQFOXVLRQ/RZGRVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGWLPHUHVROYHG705$FDQDFFXUDWHO\
GHÀQHPRUSKRORJLFDODQGIXQFWLRQDODVSHFWVRI90GXULQJWUHDWPHQWSODQQLQJDQG
IROORZXS DQG FDQ LGHQWLI\ SRVWWKHUDS\ FKDQJHV WKDW SRVLWLYHO\ FRUUHODWH ZLWK
WUHDWPHQWRXWFRPH0RUHRYHU05$FDQDYRLGUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHFRQVLGHULQJWKH
\RXWKDJHRIWKHVHSDWLHQW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'LQWHUYHQWLRQJXLGDQFHDWHFKQLFDOIHDVLELOLW\FRQVLGHUDWLRQ
-.XQW]66DZDOO:6HPPOHU0.DFKHOULHVV6%DUWOLQJ
+HLGHOEHUJ'((UODQJHQ'( MNXQW]#GNI]GH
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHRYHUDOOIHDVLELOLW\RI'LQWHUYHQWLRQDOJXLGDQFHXVLQJ
FXUUHQWÁDWSDQHO&7WHFKQRORJ\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HFHQWUHVHDUFKVXJJHVWVWKDW'LQWHUYHQWLRQDOJXLGDQFH
PD\EHFRPHIHDVLEOHE\WKHXVHRIQRYHOUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKPVDQGSULRULQIRU
PDWLRQ7RWKLVHQGFRQWLQXRXV'GDWDDFTXLVLWLRQXVLQJFLUFXODUWUDMHFWRULHVPLJKW
EHWKHPRVWVWUDLJKWIRUZDUGVROXWLRQ7RWDOGRVHRIXSGDWHVFDQVFDQEHGLVWULEXWHG
DPRQJYDULRXVDPRXQWVRISURMHFWLRQV0DWKHPDWLFDOVLPXODWLRQVDVZHOODVUHDO
SKDQWRPVFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHG)'.UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZHUHXVHGIRUKLJKUHVROXWLRQ
SULRU LPDJHV WHPSRUDO XSGDWHV ZHUH UHFRQVWUXFWHG XVLQJ FRPSUHVVHG VHQVLQJ
DOJRULWKPV LQFOXGLQJ3,&&6DQG$6'32&6 )RUWHPSRUDOXSGDWHUHFRQVWUXF
WLRQVYDULRXVQRLVHOHYHOVSHUSURMHFWLRQDQGGLIIHUHQWXQGHUVDPSOLQJUDWLRVZHUH
XVHGZKLOHWKHRYHUDOOGRVHIRUHYHU\UHFRQVWUXFWLRQZDVNHSWFRQVWDQW(OHFWURQLF
GHWHFWRU QRLVH ZDV QRW LQFOXGHG LQWR VLPXODWLRQV ,PDJH TXDOLW\ ZDV HYDOXDWHG
DXWRPDWLFDOO\ HJE\DPRGLÀHGXQLYHUVDOTXDOLW\LQGH[ DQGE\YLVXDOLQVSHFWLRQ
5HVXOWV,PDJHTXDOLW\YDULHGODUJHO\EHWZHHQDOJRULWKPVDQGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQSD
UDPHWHUV)RUWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHWRWDOGRVHWRYDULRXVDPRXQWVRISURMHFWLRQVD
PD[LPXPLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVIRXQGWREHUHDFKHGDWWKHRUGHURIWRSURMHF
WLRQVSHUXSGDWHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQVLPXODWLRQVRIW\SLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQDOVLWXDWLRQV
HJVWHQWSODFHPHQW$6'32&6LWHUDWLRQV %RWKPRUHDQGOHVVSURMHFWLRQV
VXIIHUHGIURPODUJHUQRLVHDQGXQGHUVDPSOLQJHIIHFWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHGDWDVXJJHVWWKDWZLWKFXUUHQWÁDWSDQHOWHFKQRORJ\ UHDGRXW
UDWHVWRISV DQGJDQWULHVURWDWLQJDWDERXWRQHWRWZRURWDWLRQVSHUVHFRQG
DVXIÀFLHQW'LQWHUYHQWLRQJXLGDQFHZLWKXSWRWKUHHXSGDWHVSHUVHFRQGFDQEH
UHDOLVHG
%
'FXUYHOHWVSDWLRWHPSRUDOÀOWHULQJDSSOLHGWR[UD\GLJLWDOÁDWSDQHO
GHWHFWRULPDJLQJ
-3HVFDWRUH&$PLRW0RLUDQV)5 MHUHPLHSHVFDWRUH#WKDOHVJURXSFRP
3XUSRVH[UD\LQWHUYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJLVSDUWLFXODUO\FKDOOHQJLQJLQWHUPVRIGRVH
UHGXFWLRQDQGGHQRLVLQJ,QGHHGFDUGLDFDQGUHVSLUDWRU\PRWLRQFRXSOHGZLWKGHQVH
DQDWRPLHVDUHDPRQJWKHPDMRUUHDVRQVIRUORZVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRLQÁXRURVFRSLF
LPDJLQJ Q*\IUDPHGHWHFWRUHQWUDQFHGRVH 2XUZRUNFRQVLVWVLQGHYHORSLQJ
DQRYHOPHWKRGWRHQKDQFHLQWHUYHQWLRQDOGHYLFHV QHHGOHVDQGFDWKHWHUV ZKLOH
SUHVHUYLQJWKHDQDWRPLFDOERXQGDULHV)RUWKLVZHGHYHORSHGDVSDWLRWHPSRUDO
ÀOWHUEDVHGRQWKH'FXUYHOHWWUDQVIRUP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHSURSRVHGPHWKRGFRQVLVWVRIWZRVWHSVDWHPSRUDO
DQGDVSDWLDOÀOWHULQJ7KHWHPSRUDOÀOWHULVEDVHGRQWKHWLPHHYROXWLRQRISL[HOҋV
YDOXH7KLVÀOWHUKDVDOLPLWHGGHQRLVLQJSRZHUWHQGVWRHUDVHWKHREMHFWVRILQWHU
HVWDQGLQWURGXFHVVSLNHQRLVHLQWKHLPDJH7KHUHIRUHRXUDSSURDFKFRPELQHV
D'FXUYHOHWVSDWLDOÀOWHUWRWKHWHPSRUDOÀOWHU7KLVVSDWLDOÀOWHULVEDVHGRQWKH
ZUDSSLQJGLVFUHWHFXUYHOHWLPSOHPHQWDWLRQ7KHFXUYHOHWFRHIÀFLHQWVVKULQNDJHLV
SHUIRUPHGDFFRUGLQJWRDVFDOHGHSHQGHQWKDUGWKUHVKROGLQJVFKHPH
5HVXOWV7KH'FXUYHOHWVSDWLRWHPSRUDOÀOWHULQJLVDSSOLHGRQ[UD\LPDJHVUHS
UHVHQWLQJJXLGHZLUHVDQGVWHQWV,QSXWFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLRLVEHWZHHQDQG
:HGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWRXUPHWKRGRXWSHUIRUPVZDYHOHWEDVHGVSDWLRWHPSRUDO
ÀOWHU7KHSURSRVHGPHWKRGUHPRYHVPRVWRIWKHJDXVVLDQQRLVHDQGOHDYHVVRPH
PLQRUVSLNHQRLVHLQGXFHGE\WKHWHPSRUDOÀOWHULQJ
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUZRUNGHPRQVWUDWHVWKDWFRPELQHGFXUYHOHWDQGWHPSRUDOÀOWHULQJ
LPSURYHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZGRVHÁXRURVFRSLFLPDJHTXDOLW\,QWHUYHQWLRQDOGHYLFHV
DQGERQHYLVLELOLW\LVLQFUHDVHGZKLOHWKHLPDJHEDFNJURXQGQRLVHLVGHFUHDVHG
%
5DGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHLQYDVFXODUDQJLRJUDSKLFSURFHGXUHV
5.ORHFNQHU&'XHEHU-6FKQHLGHU$%HUVFK&5XFNHV0%3LWWRQ
0DLQ]'( URPDQNORHFNQHU#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHLQYDVFXODUDQJLRJUDSKLFSURFHGXUHV
DQGWRVHDUFKVWUDWHJLHVIRUGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH YDVFXODU LQWHUYHQWLRQDO SURFHGXUHV
SHUIRUPHG RYHU \HDU ZHUH DQDO\VHG LQFOXGLQJ GLDJQRVWLF '6$ UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ
DQG37$VWHQWLQWKHSHOYLVDQGOHJ(9$5HPEROLVDWLRQRIOXPEDUDUWHULHV37$
VWHQWRIUHQDODUWHULHVHPEROLVDWLRQRIGLYHUVHEOHHGLQJVDQGRWKHUUDUHO\SHUIRUPHG
LQWHUYHQWLRQV7KH\ZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHÁXRURVFRS\WLPHDQGWKH
UHVXOWLQJÁXRURVFRS\UDGLDWLRQGRVHWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHRIWKHUDGLRJUDSKLFIUDPHV
DQGWKHRYHUDOOGRVH$GGLWLRQDOO\WKHLQYHVWLJDWRUVH[SHULHQFHRQWKHWRWDOGRVH
ZDVLQYHVWLJDWHG
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5HVXOWV2YHUDOORIWKHWRWDOUDGLDWLRQ GRVHZDVGXHWRWKHDFTXLVLWLRQ RI
UDGLRJUDSKLFIUDPHVOHDYLQJRQO\RIWKHWRWDOGRVHEHLQJDSSOLHGE\ÁXRURVFRS\
S 7KHLQYHVWLJDWRUVH[SHULHQFHKDGQRVLJQLÀFDQWLPSDFWRQWKHWRWDO
GRVHDSSOLHGPRVWOLNHO\VLQFHWKHUHZDVQRVWUDWLÀFDWLRQWRLQWHUYHQWLRQFRPSOH[LW\
&RQFOXVLRQ,PDJHJUDEELQJRIÁXRURVFRS\VKRXOGEHXVHGIRUGRFXPHQWDWLRQ
ZKHQHYHU SRVVLEOH ,QWHUYHQWLRQDO UDGLRORJLVWV VKRXOG EH DZDUH RI WKH UDGLDWLRQ
H[SRVXUHRIGLIIHUHQWSURFHGXUHW\SHV$UHJLVWU\RIUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHVKRXOGQRW
RQO\ FRPSULVH D VXIÀFLHQWO\ ODUJH QXPEHU RI LQWHUYHQWLRQV EXW DOVR WKH GLIIHUHQW
LQWHUYHQWLRQW\SHVLQRUGHUWRGHYHORSUHIHUHQFHOHYHOV
%
$QHZPHWKRGRIUHDOWLPHVNLQGRVHYLVXDOLVDWLRQFOLQLFDO
HYDOXDWLRQRIÁXRURVFRS\JXLGHGLQWHUYHQWLRQV
)%RXMDQ1&ODXVV&-DKQ0+DEDVK\00DQLVRU+%HQMDPHO
90DUGDNKD\HYD/0HUW]5%HDXMHX[6WUDVERXUJ)5
ID]HOERXMDQ#FKUXVWUDVERXUJIU
3XUSRVH7KHUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHLQÁXRURVFRS\JXLGHGLQWHUYHQWLRQV )*, LVD
PDMRU LVVXH IRU WKH 3XEOLF +HDOWK 7KH LQFUHDVLQJ FRPSOH[LW\ RI )*, HQKDQFHV
WKHULVNRIFUHDWLQJVLGHHIIHFWVIRUSDWLHQWVXFKDUDGLDWLRQLQGXFHGVNLQLQMXULHV
&XUUHQWO\ GRVH DUHD SURGXFW '$3 HVWLPDWH WKH SDWLHQW VNLQ GRVH 7KLV VWXG\
HYDOXDWHVDQLQQRYDWLYHDZDUHQHVVWRROWKDWGLVSOD\VGLUHFWO\WKHUHDOWLPHSHDN
VNLQGRVHLQIRUPDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H KDYH WHVWHG GXULQJ PRQWKV D QHZ PDFKLQH
SDUDPHWHUEDVHGGRVHFDOFXODWLRQVPHWKRG 0$3'2& RQSDWLHQWVSRSXODWLRQ
VFKHGXOHGIRUKHDGDQGQHFNWKRUDFLFDQGDEGRPLQDO)*,&XUUHQWO\DQJLRJUDSKLF
V\VWHPSURYLGHVDEDVLFFXPXODWLYHDLUNHUPDYDOXH0$3'2&PHWKRGSURYLGHV
DUHDOWLPHDLUNHUPDPDSSLQJRQDVSKHUHSDWLHQWPRGHO,WWDNHVLQWRDFFRXQWDOO
UHOHYDQWDFTXLVLWLRQSDUDPHWHUV WDEOHKHLJKWDQJXODWLRQFROOLPDWLRQ 7KLVPHWKRG
LVSURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHGWRUDGLRFKURPLFÀOPVIRUHYHU\SDWLHQWIRUPRQRSODQH
DQGELSODQHDQJLRJUDSKLFV\VWHPV
5HVXOWV)LQGLQJVEHWZHHQ0$3'2&DQGUDGLRFKURPLFÀOPVDUHFORVHO\FRUUHODWHG
ZLWKDFRQVWDQWFRUUHFWLRQIDFWRUGHSHQGLQJRQSURFHGXUHW\SH DYHUDJHUDWLR
IRUPRQRSODQHWKRUDFLFDQGDEGRPLQDOSURFHGXUHVIRUPRQRSODQHFHUHEUDO
SURFHGXUHVDQGIRUELSODQHFHUHEUDOSURFHGXUHV DQGSURFHGXUHSDUDPHWHUV
SDWLHQWZHLJKW&DUPDQJXODWLRQVFROOLPDWLRQ« 0DSSLQJRQDVSKHUHSDWLHQW
PRGHOLVFORVHO\FRUUHODWHGWRUDGLRFKURPLFÀOPVGRVHPDSSLQJDQGDOORZWRRSWLPLVH
VNLQGRVHUHSDUWLWLRQGXULQJ)*,
&RQFOXVLRQ0$3'2&SURYLGHVDUHOLDEOHUHDOWLPHIHHGEDFNRQSDWLHQWVNLQGRVH
DQG PDSSLQJ GXULQJ )*,7KLV LQQRYDWLYH WRRO DOORZV SK\VLFLDQ WR RSWLPLVH )*,
SURFHGXUHVDQGSUHYHQWVVNLQLQMXULHV
%
6WXG\RIDUHDOWLPHGRVLPHWU\V\VWHPDQGLWVLPSDFWRQFXUUHQW
SUDFWLFHVLQDQDQJLRJUDSK\URRP
)%RXMDQ1&ODXVV$+RUQEHFN&-DKQ/0HUW]5%HDXMHX[
6WUDVERXUJ)57RXORXVH)5 ID]HOERXMDQ#FKUXVWUDVERXUJIU
3XUSRVH7KHUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHLQÁXRURVFRS\JXLGHGLQWHUYHQWLRQV )*, LVD
PDMRULVVXHIRUWKH3XEOLF+HDOWK,QRXULQVWLWXWLRQZHVWXGLHGWKHLPSDFWRIDQHZ
UHDOWLPHGRVLPHWU\V\VWHP 3KLOLSV'RVH$ZDUH RQRSHUDWRUVҋH[SRVXUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KH'RVH$ZDUH6\VWHPDOORZVRSHUDWRUVWRVHHWKHLU
SHUVRQDOGRVHUDWHDWDJODQFHGXULQJDSURFHGXUH(DFK3HUVRQDO'RVH0HWHU
3'0 PHDVXUHV +S ZKLFK LVVHQG ZLUHOHVVO\ WRD%DVH6WDWLRQDVFUHHQ
PRXQWHGQH[WWRWKHUDGLRORJ\PRQLWRUV7KHVWXG\FRQVLVWHGRQWKHFRPSDULVRQRI
WZRPHDVXUHPHQWVSHULRGV)LUVWWKHEOLQGHGVWDJHFRQVLVWLQJUDGLDWLRQPHDVXUH
PHQWVE\FRUHODEZLWKWKHVFUHHQRIIIRURSHUDWRUV7KHQDUHJXODUVWDJHFRQVLVWLQJ
PHDVXUHPHQWVZLWKWKHVFUHHQRQ
5HVXOWV0RUHWKDQHOHPHQWVRILQIRUPDWLRQKDYHEHHQWUHDWHGGXULQJ
PRQWKV7KHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRQFHUHEUDODQJLRJUDSK\SURFHGXUHVVKRZHGDGRVHUH
GXFWLRQIRUDOORSHUDWRUVIRUSK\VLFLDQVIRUWHFKQLFLDQVDQGIRUQXUVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH 3KLOLSV 'RVH$ZDUH LV DQ LQWHUHVWLQJ RSWLPLVDWLRQ WRRO IRU WKH
RSHUDWRUVҋH[SRVXUHGXULQJFHUHEUDODQJLRJUDSK\SURFHGXUHV:HLQWHQGWRVWXG\
WKLVV\VWHPRQRWKHUV)*,SURFHGXUHV+RZHYHUWKLVV\VWHPFRXOGEHXVHGDOVR
WRHVWLPDWHRSHUDWRUVH\HOHQVH[SRVXUHHVSHFLDOO\LQWKHFRQWH[WRIQHZUHFRP
PHQGDWLRQV SURMHFW RI ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RPPLVVLRQ RI WKH 5DGLRORJLFDO 3URWHFWLRQ
,&53 WRUHGXFHWKHH\HOHQVҋH[SRVXUHOLPLW WRP6YSHU\HDU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
4XDQWUD%,5$'6VFDOHDQGEUHDVWGHQVLW\FRUUHODWLRQSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
)&DYDJQHWWR55RVDVFR0&DODEUHVH$7DJOLDÀFR*7DFFLQL
%0RQJHUR*0DVVDUL*HQRD,77XULQ,7 IUDQFHVFDFDYDJQHWWR#LVWJHLW
3XUSRVH0DQ\VWXGLHVSURYHGWKDWUDGLRORJLFDOEUHDVWGHQVLW\FDQEHDSUHGLFWLYH
HOHPHQW RI FDQFHU ULVN 5DGLRORJLVWV HYDOXDWH EUHDVW GHQVLW\ DFFRUGLQJ D YLVXDO
DQDO\VLVRIWKHLPDJHVXVLQJ%,5$'6FODVVLÀFDWLRQ$GHGLFDWHGVRIWZDUH4XDQWUD
FDQUHGXFHHUURUVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKLVTXDOLWDWLYHPHWKRG7KHVRIWZDUHPDNHV
DQXPHULFPHDVXUHRQPDPPRJUDSK\YLHZVRIEUHDVWDQGÀEURJODQGXODUWLVVXHYRO
XPHWKHQLWFDOFXODWHVWKHYROXPHWULFSHUFHQWDJHRIÀEURJODQGXODUWLVVXHRIEUHDVW
7KHDLPRIWKLVZRUNLVWRSURYLGHDFDOLEUDWLRQLQRUGHUWRFRUUHODWHWKHQXPHULFDO
UHVXOWRI4XDQWUDZLWKWKH%,5$'6VFDOHDQGWKHQZLWKWKHUHDOEUHDVWGHQVLW\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )RXU FRPSUHVVLEOH SKDQWRPV ZHUH PDGH ÀOOHG ZLWK
VXEVWDQFHV RI NQRZQ GHQVLW\ EHWZHHQ DQG JFP WR VLPXODWH W\SLFDO
GHQVLWLHVRIUHDOEUHDVWV0DPPRJUDSKLFLPDJHVRISKDQWRPVZHUHSURFHVVHGE\
WKHVRIWZDUH)LQDOO\GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPVRISDWLHQWVZDVVXEPLWWHGWR4XDQWUD
DQGWKHQWRUDGLRORJLVWVLQRUGHUWRGHULYHHVWLPDWLRQVRIEUHDVWGHQVLW\DFFRUGLQJ
WR%,5$'V\VWHP
5HVXOWV7KHQXPHULFDOHYDOXDWLRQSURYLGHGE\4XDQWUDRQSKDQWRPEUHDVWVKDV
EHHQUHODWHGZLWKNQRZQGHQVLWLHV 5 8VLQJWKLVFDOLEUDWLRQWKHEUHDVWGHQVL
WLHVRIZHUHFDOFXODWHG7KHVHYDOXHVVKRZDFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKHUDGLRORJLVWV
HYDOXDWLRQVEDVHGRQ%,5$'6VFDOH 5
&RQFOXVLRQ4XDQWUDKHOSUDGLRORJLVWVWRHVWLPDWHYROXPHWULFSHUFHQWDJHRIWKH
ÀEURJODQGXODUWLVVXHRIEUHDVWEXWLWLVQHFHVVDU\DSURSHUFDOLEUDWLRQRIWKLVVRIWZDUH
WRREWDLQWKHFRUUHFWUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ4XDQWUDUHVXOWVDQGUHDOEUHDVWGHQVLWLHV
7KLVPHWKRGHQDEOHVWRUHODWH4XDQWUDQXPEHUVZLWKTXDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQVZLWK
%,5$'6VFDOH
3K\VLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\RIUHFRQVWUXFWHGSODQHV
LQGLJLWDOEUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLV '%7 DV\VWHPFRPSDULVRQ
12EHUKRIHU%RO]DQR,7 QDGLDREHUKRIHU#DVE]LW
3XUSRVH,Q(XURSHWKHUHDUHWKUHHFRPPHUFLDOV\VWHPVIRUGLJLWDOEUHDVWWRPR
V\QWKHVLV '%7 ZKLFK GLIIHU E\ DFTXLVLWLRQ WHFKQLTXH DQJXODU UDQJH QXPEHU
DQGVSDFLQJRISURMHFWLRQV DQGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKP7KLVZRUNFRPSDUHVWKH
V\VWHPVE\FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIWKHSK\VLFDOSURSHUWLHVDQGWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\RI
WKHUHFRQVWUXFWHG'SODQHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXGLHGXQLWVDUH+RORJLF6HOHQLD'LPHQVLRQV6LH
PHQV0DPPRPDW,QVSLUDWLRQDQG,06*LRWWR%HVLGHV'07)136DQG'4(
WKHV\VWHPVKDYHEHHQFKDUDFWHULVHGLQWHUPVRIKRPRJHQHLW\VLJQDOGLIIHUHQFH
WRQRLVHUDWLR 6'15 EHKDYLRXUWKURXJKRXWWKHYROXPHLQSODQHUHVROXWLRQDQG]
UHVROXWLRQ,PDJHTXDOLW\KDVEHHQDVVHVVHGE\PHDQVRIFRQWUDVWGHWDLOHYDOXDWLRQ
ZLWKWKHSKDQWRP&'0$0DQGWKHVRIWZDUH&'0$0$QDO\VHU$YHUDJHJODQGXODU
GRVH $*' ZDVFDOFXODWHGDFFRUGLQJWR'DQFH3HUIRUPDQFHVKDYHEHHQHYDOXDWHG
IRUYDULRXV300$SKDQWRPWKLFNQHVVHVLQFOLQLFDOVHWXSXVLQJDXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUH
FRQWUROPRGDOLW\ $(&
5HVXOWV,QDOOV\VWHPVWKH$*'IRUDWRPRVFDQZDVFOHDUO\LQIHULRUWRWZLFHWKH
$*'IRUDVWDQGDUG'SURMHFWLRQWKHUDWLRUDQNLQJIURPWRGHSHQGLQJ
RQWKHFRPSUHVVHGEUHDVWWKLFNQHVV$OWKRXJKWKHVLQJOHWRPRSURMHFWLRQVZHUH
FKDUDFWHULVHGE\ORZHULPDJHTXDOLW\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRVWDQGDUG'LPDJHVDQGLQ
RQHV\VWHPE\ORZHUVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQWRRWKHUHFRQVWUXFWHGLPDJHLQWKHFHQWUDO
SODQHZDVQHYHULQIHULRUWR'LPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHPHWKRGRORJ\IRU'%7SHUIRUPDQFHDVVHVVPHQWLVQRWZHOOHVWDE
OLVKHGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKPVVHDPWRSOD\DGRPLQDQWUROHLQWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\
RIUHFRQVWUXFWHGSODQHV)XUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQDQGLQWHUQDWLRQDOKDUPRQLVDWLRQRQ
SURWRFRODQGSKDQWRPDUHGHVLUDEOH
%
%UHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLVSK\VLFDOFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQDQGFRPSDULVRQ
EHWZHHQWZRV\VWHPV
63DVHWWR3&RORPER$7RUUHVLQ07DJOLDEXH0LODQ,7
VWHIDQRSDVH#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH,QRXUZRUNVRPHLPDJHTXDOLW\SDUDPHWHUVKDYHEHHQSURSRVHGDV
D ZD\ WR FKDUDFWHULVH D WRPRV\QWKHVLV V\VWHP FRQFHUQLQJ LPDJH TXDOLW\ DQG
GRVH7KLVSURWRFROZDVDSSOLHGWRWZRGLIIHUHQWV\VWHPV0DPPRPDW,QVSLUDWLRQ
6LHPHQV H6HOHQLD'LPHQVLRQV +RORJLF
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'RVHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQDJUHHPHQWWR
DYHUDJHJODQGXODUGRVHIRUPXODWLRQSURSRVHGE\'DQFHHWDO 3K\V0HG%LRO
,PDJHTXDOLW\HYDOXDWLRQZDVFDUULHGRXWFRQVLGHULQJWKHIROORZLQJSDUDP
HWHUV VLJQDO DQG QRLVH XQLIRUPLW\ 07) 136 &15 SUHVHQFH DQG SURSDJDWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5RRP4
&DUGLDF
66
&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\VWHQRVLVDVVHVVPHQW
0RGHUDWRUV
*)HXFKWQHU,QQVEUXFN$7
1(.ORZ2VOR12
%
7KHDUHDVWHQRVLVPHDVXUHPHQWRIVLJQLÀFDQWFRURQDU\DUWHU\
OHVLRQVE\TXDQWLWDWLYHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
4&7$ FRUUHODWHVEHWWHUZLWKTXDQWLWDWLYHLQYDVLYHFRURQDU\
DQJLRJUDSK\ 4&$ WKDQGLDPHWHUVWHQRVLVPHDVXUHPHQW
%/DVNRZLF]%.UXSLQVNL70LV]DOVNL-DPND%*X]LN0$QGUHV5%DQ\V
08UEDQF]\N=DZDG]ND0.RVWNLHZLF].UDNRZ3/
3XUSRVH7RGDWHPRVWVWXGLHVHYDOXDWHGWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIFRPSXWHGWR
PRJUDSK\FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7&$ WRGHWHFWVLJQLÀFDQWGLDPHWHUFRURQDU\
DUWHU\VWHQRVHVEXWWKHUHLVSDXFLW\RIGDWDFRPSDULQJ&7&$WRLQYDVLYHFRURQDU\
DQJLRJUDSK\IRUDUHDVWHQRVLVDVVHVVPHQW7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHWKH
YDULDQFHRITXDQWLWDWLYHDUHDDQGGLDPHWHUVWHQRVLVPHDVXUHPHQWLQVLJQLÀFDQWRE
VWUXFWLYHFRURQDU\DUWHU\OHVLRQVEHWZHHQ&7&$DQGLQYDVLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIW\SDWLHQWVZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVHV
"DUHDVWHQRVLV LQGXDOVRXUFH&7&$ 6RPDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ ZHUHLQFOXGHG
DQGXQGHUZHQWLQYDVLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ ,&$ ZLWKLQPRQWKVDIWHU&7&$
$UHDDQGGLDPHWHUVWHQRVLVPLQLPDOOXPHQDUHD 0/$ DQGGLDPHWHU 0/' UHIHU
HQFHOXPHQDUHD 5/$ DQGGLDPHWHU 5/' ZHUHHYDOXDWHGLQTXDQWLWDWLYH&7&$
4&7$ DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHLQYDVLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ 4&$
5HVXOWV2ITXDQWLWDWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRWLFOHVLRQVZHUHFDOFL
ÀHGZHUHPL[HGDQGZHUHQRQFDOFLÀHG7KH6SHDUPDQҋVUDQNFRUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQ4&7$DQG4&$DUHDDQGGLDPHWHUVWHQRVLVPHDVXUHPHQWVZDVD JRRG
U S DQGPRGHUDWH U S IRUDOOOHVLRQVE YHU\JRRG
U S DQGJRRG U S IRUQRQFDOFLÀHGSODTXHVF
YHU\ JRRG U S DQG JRRG U S IRU PL[HG OHVLRQV
DQGG QRQHIRUFDOFLÀHGSODTXHV U S 16DQGU S 16 UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDUHDVWHQRVLVPHDVXUHPHQWRIVLJQLÀFDQWFRURQDU\DUWHU\OHVLRQV
SURYLGHGE\TXDQWLWDWLYH&7&$FORVHO\FRUUHODWHVZLWK4&$DQG\LHOGVKLJKHUFRU
UHODWLRQWKDQGLDPHWHUVWHQRVLVPHDVXUHPHQW7KLVFRUUHODWLRQGHSHQGVRQSODTXH
FRPSRVLWLRQDQGLVKLJKHVWIRUQRQFDOFLÀHGDQGPL[HGOHVLRQV
%
,VWKHUHDUROHIRUURZ0'&7LQWKHIROORZXSRIKHDUWWUDQVSODQWHG
SDWLHQWV"$FRPSDULVRQVWXG\ZLWKHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DQG05
SHUIRUPHGRQWKHVDPHGD\
96LOYHVWUL50DUDQR*6DYLQR%0HUOLQR*9HUULOOR$0HGXUL/1DWDOH
/%RQRPR5RPH,7 YDOHQWLQDBVLOYHVWUL#KRWPDLOLW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHDFFXUDF\RI0'&7LQWKH)8RIKHDUWWUDQVSODQWHG
SDWLHQWVDVVHVVLQJWKH/9)LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\DQG05SHU
IRUPHGRQWKHVDPHGD\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[WHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKWUDQVSODQWHGKHDUWVZHUHLQYHVWL
JDWHGE\HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\05DQG0'&77ZRLQGHSHQGHQWUHDGHUVEOLQG
HYDOXDWHG()('9(6969&2DQG0DVVRIWKH/9RQ0'&7XVLQJDGHGLFDWHG
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
%
RI DUWHIDFWV $6) UHFRQVWUXFWHG VOLFH WKLFNQHVV DQG JHRPHWULFDO GLVWRUWLRQ$
VHPLFOLQLFDOHYDOXDWLRQRQ&,56SKDQWRP 0RGHO%5' ZDVDOVRSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV7KHGRVHGHOLYHUHGE\WKHWZRV\VWHPVGRHVQRWVKRZUHPDUNDEOHGLI
IHUHQFHVQHLWKHULQLWVDEVROXWHYDOXHQRULQUHODWLRQWRWKHGRVHGHOLYHUHGE\D
VWDQGDUGPDPPRJUDSKLFSURMHFWLRQ7KHUDWLREHWZHHQWRPRV\QWKHVLVDQGVWDQGDUG
PDPPRJUDSK\KDVDPHDQYDOXHRI:LWKUHVSHFWWRSURMHFWLRQPDPPRJUDSK\
LQWRPRV\QWKHVLVZHIRXQGDVWURQJORVVLQVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQD&15LPSURYHPHQW
DVWURQJSUHVHQFHRIDUWHIDFWVHVSHFLDOO\DORQJYHUWLFDOGLUHFWLRQDJHRPHWULFGLV
WRUWLRQDWGHWHFWRUHGJHV)LQDOO\MXVWVPDOOGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHWZRV\VWHPV
KDYHHPHUJHGIURPWKHVHPLFOLQLFDOHYDOXDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$YHUDJHJODQGXODUGRVHGHOLYHUHGLQWRPRV\QWKHVLVLVVPDOOHUWKDQ
GRVH GHOLYHUHG E\ WZR VWDQGDUG SURMHFWLRQV IRU ERWK V\VWHPV 7RPRV\QWKHVLV
DGYDQWDJHZLWKUHVSHFWWRVWDQGDUGPDPPRJUDSK\OLHVLQWKHWRPRJUDSKLFUHSUH
VHQWDWLRQZKLFKHQWDLOVD&15LPSURYHPHQWSDUWLFXODUO\IRUVPDOOREMHFWVZKHUHDV
WKHGLVDGYDQWDJHLVDGHFUHDVHLQKLJKFRQWUDVWUHVROXWLRQFRUUHODWHGZLWKDUWHIDFWV
SURSDJDWLRQSDUWLFXODUO\DORQJYHUWLFDOGLUHFWLRQ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
VRIWZDUH 7HUD5HFRQ&$86$ LQFRPSDULVRQZLWK05DQG(FKRERWKSHUIRUPHG
RQ WKH VDPH GD\ 'XULQJ DOO WKH H[DPLQDWLRQV +5 KDV EHHQ UHFRUGHG 0'&7
LQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVDOVRDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV+5UHFRUGHGGXULQJWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVUHVXOWHGORZHUIRU0'&7
S () UHVXOWHG ORZHU IRU 0'&7 0'&7 05
(FKR 16 ,QFRPSDULVRQZLWK05IRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRI/9YROXPHV
0'&7VKRZHGKLJKHU('9 0'&7P/05P/S (69
0'&7P/05P/S DQG69 0'&7P/50
P/S EXWZLWKPRGHUDWHWRJRRGFRUUHODWLRQ U U
U UHVSHFWLYHO\ S WR 6OLJKWO\ KLJKHU &2 IRU 0'&7 ZDV IRXQG
0'&7/05/S ZLWKDKLJKFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWYDOXH
S 0'&7VKRZHGVOLJKWO\KLJKHUYDOXHVRI0DVV 0'&7J
P05JP S EXWZLWKDKLJKFRUUHODWLRQ U S
([FHOOHQWZDVWKH0'&7LQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQW &&&!H
&RQFOXVLRQ0'&7DOORZVWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIKHDUWWUDQVSODQWHGSDWLHQWVREWDLQ
LQJGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHVZLWKDUHODWLYHO\JRRGDJUHHPHQWDQGFRUUHODWLRQZLWK05
IRU/9)DVVHVVPHQW,WVHHPVVXIÀFLHQWO\UHSURGXFLEOHWRFRQVLGHULWVDSSOLFDWLRQ
LQWKH)8DQGWRVXSSRUWWKHUDSHXWLFVWUDWHJLHVZLWKWKHDGYDQWDJHWRSHUIRUP
/9)DVVHVVPHQWZLWKLQDJOREDOGLDJQRVWLFDSSURDFKLQFOXGLQJFRURQDU\DUWHULHV
HYDOXDWLRQLQRQHVLQJOHYHU\IDVWDFTXLVLWLRQ
%
&DQVHJPHQWHG'LPDJHVEHXVHGIRUVWHQRVLVHYDOXDWLRQLQ
FRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\"
&:DQJ$3HUVVRQ-(QJYDOO-'H*HHU:&]HNLHUGD$%MRUNKROP
6*)UDQVVRQg6PHGE\/LQN|SLQJ6(
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIFRURQDU\&7DQJL
RJUDSK\ &&7$ XVLQJVHJPHQWHG'GDWDIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&&7$GDWDVHWVIURPSDWLHQWVZHUHDFTXLUHGZLWKD
VOLFH&7VFDQQHUDQGVHJPHQWHGXVLQJWKHUHJLRQJURZLQJ 5* PHWKRGDQG
WKH´YLUWXDOFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQµ 9& PHWKRG7KUHHW\SHVRILPDJHVRIHDFKSDWLHQW
ZHUHUHYLHZHGE\GLIIHUHQWUHYLHZHUVIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIVWHQRVHVZLWKGLDPHWHU
UHGXFWLRQ RI RU PRUH )RU WKH RULJLQDO VHULHV WKH UHYLHZHU ZDV DOORZHG WR
XVH DOO WKH ' DQG ' YLVXDOLVDWLRQ WRROV DYDLODEOH FRQYHQWLRQDO PHWKRG )RU
WKHVHJPHQWHGUHVXOWV IURP5*DQG9& RQO\PD[LPXPLQWHQVLW\SURMHFWLRQZDV
XVHG(YDOXDWLRQUHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKFDWKHWHUDQJLRJUDSK\ &$ IRUHDFK
DUWHU\LQDEOLQGHGIDVKLRQ
5HVXOWV7KLUW\IRXUDUWHULHVZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGE\&$7KH
SHUFHQWDJH RI HYDOXDEOH DUWHULHV DFFXUDF\ DQG QHJDWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH IRU
GHWHFWLQJ VWHQRVLV ZHUH UHVSHFWLYHO\ DQG IRU WKH FRQYHQWLRQDO
PHWKRGDQGIRU9&DQGDQGIRU5*$FFXUDF\
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRUWKH5*PHWKRGWKDQIRUWKHRWKHUWZRPHWKRGV S
ZKHUHDVWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQDFFXUDF\EHWZHHQWKH9&PHWKRG
DQGWKHFRQYHQWLRQDOPHWKRG S
&RQFOXVLRQ'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRU5*VHJPHQWHG'GDWDZDVORZHUWKDQZLWK
DFFHVVWR'LPDJHV+RZHYHUDVDVFUHHQLQJVWHS'PHWKRGVPD\EHDXVHIXO
FRPSOHPHQWWR'UHYLHZLQJ7KH9&EDVHGPHWKRGLVPRUHSURPLVLQJIRUWKLV
SXUSRVHWKDQWKH5*EDVHGPHWKRG
%
'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\IRUVWHQRVLV
GHWHFWLRQDFFRUGLQJWRFDOFLXPVFRUHV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZDQGPHWD
DQDO\VLV
0$0GHQ'HNNHU.GH6PHW*+GH%RFN5$7LR02XGNHUN
59OLHJHQWKDUW*URQLQJHQ1/%UXVVHOV%( PDP'HNNHU#XPFJQO
3XUSRVH7KHSUHVHQFHRIFRURQDU\FDOFLÀFDWLRQLVFRQVLGHUHGWRQHJDWLYHO\LQÁX
HQFHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\ F&7D 1RFRQVHQVXVH[LVWV
RQZKHWKHUF&7DFDQDFFXUDWHO\GLDJQRVHFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHLQFDVHRIDQ
HOHYDWHGFDOFLXPVFRUH &6
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSHUIRUPHGDV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZDQGPHWDDQDO\VLV
WR DVVHVV VHQVLWLYLW\ DQG VSHFLÀFLW\ RI F&7D IRU VLJQLÀFDQW VWHQRVLV DW GLIIHUHQW
GHJUHHVRIFRURQDU\FDOFLÀFDWLRQ$OLWHUDWXUHVHDUFKZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKLQFOXVLRQ
RIVWXGLHVGHVFULELQJWHVWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIF&7DIRUVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLVSHUIRUPHG
ZLWKPLQLPDOO\0'&7E\&6,QYDVLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ZDVWKHUHIHUHQFH
VWDQGDUG3RROHGVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIF&7DE\GLIIHUHQW&6FDWHJRULHVDQG
VFDQQHUJHQHUDWLRQVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV2IDUWLFOHVRQF&7$VWXGLHVUHSRUWHGRQWKHLPSDFWRIFDOFLXP
VFRULQJRQGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIF&7DDQGFRXOGEHLQFOXGHGLQWKHV\VWHPDWLF
UHYLHZRIWKHVHVWXGLHV SDUWLFLSDQWV ZHUHVXLWDEOHIRUPHWDDQDO\VLV
,QSDWLHQWEDVHGDQDO\VLVVHQVLWLYLW\RIF&7DIRUVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLVZDV
&, DQG
IRU&6DQG!UHVSHFWLYHO\6SHFLÀFLW\ZDV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
DQG UHVSHF
WLYHO\6SHFLÀFLW\RIF&7DZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRU&6GXHWRODFNRI
SDWLHQWVZLWKRXWVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLV6HQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI0'&7ZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUFRPSDUHGWRQHZHU&7JHQHUDWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ(YHQLQFDVHRIVHYHUHFRURQDU\FDOFLÀFDWLRQVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
RIF&7DIRUVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLVLVKLJK:LWK0'&7DQGQHZHUVFDQQHUJHQHUD
WLRQVD&6FXWRIIIRUSHUIRUPLQJF&7DVHHPVQRORQJHULQGLFDWHG
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIOHIWPDLQFRURQDU\LQVWHQWUHVWHQRVLVE\GXDOVRXUFH
&7FRPSDULVRQZLWKLQYDVLYHDQJLRJUDSK\DQGLQWUDYDVFXODUXOWUDVRXQG
7$GOD-9HVHOND'=HPDQHN3&DGRYD96XFKDQHN/0LNVLN05RFHN
3UDJXH&= WKHRGRUDGOD#OIPRWROFXQLF]
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIGXDOVRXUFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7&$ FRPSDUHGWRLQYDVLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ ,&$
DQG LQWUDYDVFXODU XOWUDVRXQG ,986 IRU GHWHFWLRQ DQG TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI LQVWHQW
UHVWHQRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIW\RQHSDWLHQWVZLWKSHUFXWDQHRXVFRURQDU\LQWHUYHQ
WLRQ RI WKH /0 ZHUH SURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWHG 7KLUW\IRXU RI WKHP XQGHUZHQW
FRPSOHWHIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQV PHGLDQPRQWKVDIWHULQWHUYHQWLRQ&7&$,&$
DQG,986DVJROGVWDQGDUGH[DPLQDWLRQ WKDWIRFXVHGRQGHWHFWLRQDQGTXDQWLÀFD
WLRQRIUHVWHQRVLV
5HVXOWV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVRI,&$DQG
&7&$ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
7KHUHZDVDPRGHUDWHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHPLQLPDOOXPLQDODUHDV 0/$ PHDV
XUHGE\&7&$DQG,986 U S $%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKDWWKH
0/$PHDVXUHGE\&7&$ZDVXQGHUHVWLPDWHG PHDQGLIIHUHQFHPP
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHUHVXOWVVXJJHVWHGWKDWGXDOVRXUFH&7&$KDVDKLJKQHJD
WLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQGPLJKWEHFRQVLGHUHGDOHVVLQYDVLYHDOWHUQDWLYHWR,&$IRU
H[FOXVLRQRI/0LQVWHQWUHVWHQRVLV+RZHYHUWKHUHZDVRQO\DPRGHUDWHFRUUHOD
WLRQEHWZHHQWKHPHDVXUHPHQWVRI0/$VE\,986DQG&7&$LQWKHVWHQWHG/0V
7KHUHIRUHÀQGLQJRIDQ\UHVWHQRVLVDFFRUGLQJWR&7&$VKRXOGEHUHHYDOXDWHGE\
,&$RUEHWWHUE\VXEVHTXHQW,986
%
&RURQDU\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\IRUGHWHFWLRQRIRFFXOW
FRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHLQDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV
$+LGDOJR0'HVFDO]R5/HWD3HWUDFFD/6HJXUD63XMDGDV)&DUUHUDV
*3RQV/ODGR%DUFHORQD(6 DOKLGDOJRS#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRDVVHVVWKHDFFXUDF\RIFRURQDU\FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ IRUGHWHFWLQJVLJQLÀFDQWFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVH
&$'OXPHQUHGXFWLRQ DQGHYDOXDWHWKHLPSDFWLQWKHULVNVWUDWLÀFDWLRQRI
PLGGOHDJHGDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORIFRQVHFXWLYHPLGGOHDJHGDV\PSWRPDWLF
LQGLYLGXDOV PHQPHDQDJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQW&7$ VOLFHPXOWLGHWHFWRU
URZFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ DVSDUWRIDJHQHUDOKHDOWKVFUHHQLQJ0HGLXPIROORZXS
ZDV\HDUV \HDUV
5HVXOWV$WKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHV $3 ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGLQ LQGLYLGXDOV
LQGLYLGXDOV OXPLQDOVWHQRVLVZDVVLJQLÀFDQW $JHG GHFDGH PDOH
JHQGHU S GLDEHWHV S VHUXPFKROHVWHUROVPRNLQJDQGK\SHUWHQ
VLRQ S ZHUH UHODWHG ZLWK WKH SUHVHQFH RI DWKHURVFOHURVLV7KH SDWLHQW
JURXSZLWK$3KDGDPHGLXPRIFDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNVJUHDWHU YV
S ,QWKHPLGWHUPIROORZXSSDWLHQWGLHGEHFDXVHRIDFDUGLRYDVFXODU
FDXVHSDWLHQWKDGP\RFDUGLDODFXWHLQIDUFWDQGUHTXLUHGVWHQWLPSODQWDWLRQ%RWK
KDGQRQREVWUXFWLYH$3DW&7$SDWLHQWVKDGDW\SLFDOFKHVWSDLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH SUHYDOHQFH RI VXEFOLQLFDO DWKHURVFOHURVLV VKRZHG E\ &7$ LQ
DQDV\PSWRPDWLFSRSXODWLRQLVKLJKDQGLWZDVUHODWHGZLWKDKLJKHUQXPEHURI
FDUGLRYDVFXODU ULVNV 1HYHUWKHOHVV WKH QXPEHU RI PDMRU HYHQWV LQ WKH PLGWHUP
IROORZXSZDVORZ
%
8WLOLW\RIFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7&$ LQ
GLDJQRVLVRIFDUGLDFDOORJUDIWYDVFXORSDWK\ &$9
.(7ZHHG&/HZLV-3DUDPHVKZDU'*RSDODQ&DPEULGJH8.
NDWKDULQHWZHHG#GRFWRUVRUJXN
3XUSRVH(YDOXDWHFDUGLDFDOORJUDIWFRURQDU\DUWHU\YDVFXORSDWK\XVLQJ&7&$
&RPSDUH&7&$WRFDWKHWHUDQJLRJUDSK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIFDUGLDFWUDQVSODQWSDWLHQWV
VHOHFWHG RQ WKH EDVLV RI &7&$ SHUIRUPHG RQ VOLFH GXDO VRXUFH &7 RYHU D
IRXU\HDUSHULRGLQDWHUWLDU\FDUGLRWKRUDFLFFHQWUH&7&$DQGPDWFKHGFDWKHWHU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DQJLRJUDSK\LQSDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGXVLQJ,QWHUQDWLRQDO6RFLHW\RI+HDUWDQG
/XQJ7UDQVSODQWDWLRQ ,6+/7 FULWHULDVHJPHQWDODQDO\VLV&$9JUDGLQJRIHDFK
SDWLHQWZDVFRPSOHWHGXVLQJ,6+/7FULWHULDLQERWKPRGDOLWLHV
5HVXOWV3DWLHQWFRKRUWPHDQDJHLV\HDUVDQGDVVHVVHGDWDPHDQRI
\HDUVSRVWWUDQVSODQW7KHPHDQFRURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLXPVFRUH $JDWVWRQ ZDV
H[FOXGLQJDFRQIRXQGLQJSDWLHQWZLWKFDOFLXPVFRUHRIRISDWLHQWVKDG
&$9RQ&7&$DQGRIWKHVHKDGJUDGH&$9WKHUHPDLQGHUJUDGH&$9&$9
ZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGXVLQJ&7&$ZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIRQ
,6+/7VHJPHQWDODQDO\VLVFRPSDUHGZLWKFDWKHWHUDQJLRJUDSK\7KHUHZDV
FRQFRUGDQFHRISDWLHQW&$9JUDGLQJEHWZHHQ&7&$DQGFDWKHWHUDQJLRJUDSK\
&RQFOXVLRQ&DUGLDFDOORJUDIWYDVFXORSDWK\LVUHOLDEO\GHPRQVWUDWHGXVLQJ&7&$
FRPSDUHGZLWKFDWKHWHUDQJLRJUDSK\&RURQDU\DUWHU\YDVFXORSDWK\LVGLIIHUHQWLDWHG
IURPDWKHURVFOHURWLFGLVHDVH5RXWLQHXVHRIOHVVLQYDVLYH&7&$IRUVXUYHLOODQFH
SRVWKHDUWWUDQVSODQWPD\EHIHDVLEOHEXWQHHGVIXUWKHUVWXG\
%
,PSDFWRIGLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRIFRURQDU\FDOFLXPVFRUHRQWKH
SUHYDOHQFHRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQ
LQWHUPHGLDWHSUHWHVWOLNHOLKRRGRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVH
7+HQ]OHU19RJOHU00H\HU3$SIDOWUHU66XGDUVNL626FKRHQEHUJ
F)LQN0DQQKHLP'( WKRPDVKHQ]OHU#PHGPDXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
%
,QÁXHQFHRILQWUDFRURQDU\HQKDQFHPHQWRQSHUIRUPDQFHRIVHFRQG
JHQHUDWLRQGXDOVRXUFH&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
(0DIIHL&0DUWLQL66HLWXQ)&DGHPDUWLUL0RQDVWLHUGL7UHYLVR,7
*HQRD,7
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH HIIHFW RI LQWUDFRURQDU\ DWWHQXDWLRQ RQ GLDJQRVWLF DF
FXUDF\ XVLQJ VHFRQG JHQHUDWLRQ GXDO VRXUFH FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ FRURQDU\
DQJLRJUDSK\ &&7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK VXVSHFWHG FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ GLVHDVH
ZKR XQGHUZHQW FRQYHQWLRQDO FRURQDU\ DQJLRJUDSK\ &$ DQG &&7 ZHUH HYDOX
DWHG&&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKFROOLPDWLRQ[[PPDQGURWDWLRQWLPHPV
XVLQJPORIKLJKFRQFHQWUDWLRQFRQWUDVWPDWHULDO ,RPHSUROPJ,PO
DGPLQLVWHUHGDWPOV7KHVWXG\SRSXODWLRQZDVGLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVRI
SDWLHQWVEDVHGRQPHGLDQ +8 YDVFXODUDWWHQXDWLRQPHDVXUHGDWWKHRULJLQRI
WKHFRURQDU\DUWHULHV JURXS PHQDWWHQXDWLRQPHGLDQYDOXHJURXS DWWHQX
DWLRQ!PHGLDQYDOXH ,PDJHTXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRI
VLJQLÀFDQWFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLVZDVGHWHUPLQHGDQGFRPSDUHGIRUERWKJURXSV
5HVXOWV1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQJURXSVDQGZHUHQRWHGLQWHUPV
RIDJHJHQGHUKHDUWUDWHFRURQDU\FDOFLXPVFRUHDQGERG\PDVVLQGH[2YHUDOO
VLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLV LQJURXSDQGLQJURXS ZHUHGHWHFWHGLQ
DVVHVVDEOH FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ VHJPHQWV 7KH DYHUDJH LQWUDFRURQDU\ DWWHQXDWLRQ
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S KLJKHUIRUJURXS +8 FRPSDUHGWRJURXS
+8 ,PDJHTXDOLW\DQGFRUUHVSRQGLQJVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\YDOXHVZHUH
KLJKHUIRUJURXS DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ WKDQIRUJURXS DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
5ROHRI&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\LQVXVSHFWHGDEH[WULQVHFR
FRURQDU\FRPSUHVVLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSXOPRQDU\K\SHUWHQVLRQ
95XVVR(*REEL*5LQDOGL*0LQHR)%XLD//RYDWR1*DOLH
0=RPSDWRUL%RORJQD,7 YLUXV#IDVWZHEQHWLW
3XUSRVH 3XOPRQDU\ DUWHU\ K\SHUWHQVLRQ 3$+ LV D UDUH GLVHDVH LQ ZKLFK WKH
LQFUHDVHGEORRGSUHVVXUHFDXVHWKLFNHQLQJVWLIIHQLQJDQGWKXVWKHHQODUJHPHQW
RIWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\6XFKJURZWKRIWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\FRXOGUDUHO\FDXVH
´DEH[WULVHFRµFRPSUHVVLRQRIWKHFRURQDU\DUWHU\LQPRVWRIWKHFDVHVWKHOHIWPDLQ
7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRIFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\ &&7$
LQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIVXFKFRPSOLFDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVIURP-DQXDU\WR-XQHSWV 0DQG)
PHDQDJHDD ZLWK3$+DQGDQJLQDXQGHUZHQW&&7$
5HVXOWVLQSWV FRURQDU\DUWHU\FRPSUHVVLRQ Q RUFRURQDU\DUWHU\
GLVSODFHPHQWZLWKRXWVLJQLÀFDQWFRPSUHVVLRQ Q KDYHEHHQREVHUYHG,QSWV
RWKHUSRWHQWLDOFDXVHVRIDQJLQDKDYHEHHQGLVFRYHUHGVXFKDVFRURQDU\
DQRPDOLHV FRURQDU\ VWHQRVHV P\RFDUGLDO EULGJHV$OO RI SWV ZLWK FRURQDU\
FRPSUHVVLRQDW&&7$DQGZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWGLVSODFHPHQWZHUHIXUWKHUH[DPLQHG
ZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ZKLFKFRQÀUPHGUHVXOWVLQSWV
KDYHEHHQWUHDWHGZLWKFRURQDU\VWHQWLQJZLWKKHDUWWUDQVSODQWDQGZLWKUHPRG
HOOLQJRIWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\SWVDUHZDLWLQJIRUWUHDWPHQWDQGLWLVGHFHDVHG
&RQFOXVLRQ,QSWVZLWK3$+DQGVXVSHFWHGDEH[WULQVHFRFRURQDU\DUWHU\FRP
SUHVVLRQ&&7$LVDEOHWRLGHQWLI\WKRVHZKLFKQHHGDWUHDWPHQW
5RRP=
&RPSXWHU$SSOLFDWLRQV
66
,PDJHSURFHVVLQJ SDUW
0RGHUDWRUV
/)LVFKHU9LHQQD$7
(1HUL3LVD,7
%
6HPLDXWRPDWHGVHJPHQWDWLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIOLYHUDQGOLYHU
OHVLRQVLQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7LPDJHV
&2UVLQL''HOOD/DWWD,%HUQDUGHVFKL*'L*LURODPR03DWURQHOOL
0*XDGDJQL93RVLWDQR'&KLDSSLQR$0RQWHOHRQH0DVVD,7
RUVLQLFKLDUD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH&RPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\LVWKHPRVWFRPPRQO\XVHGLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXH
IRUWKHLQVSHFWLRQRIOLYHUOHVLRQV,WVVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQDOORZVDUHOLDEOHH[WUDFWLRQ
RIOLYHUDQGOHVLRQVIHDWXUHVVXFKDVWKHLUERXQGDULHVVL]HDQGGHQVLW\7KHKLJK
YDULDELOLW\RIWKHVHSDUDPHWHUVUHQGHUVWKHVHJPHQWDWLRQWDVNHVSHFLDOO\FKDOOHQJLQJ
$PXOWLVWDJHVHPLDXWRPDWLFKHSDWLFWXPRXUVHJPHQWDWLRQPHWKRGLVLQWURGXFHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$EGRPLQDO&7LPDJHVZLWKWKHXVHRIYHQRXVFRQWUDVW
DJHQWZHUHDFTXLUHGIURPSDWLHQWV%RWKOLYHUVHJPHQWDWLRQDQGOLYHUOHVLRQV
VHJPHQWDWLRQZHUHUHDOLVHGXVLQJLQIRUPDWLRQIURPSRUWDODQGDUWHULDOSKDVHDQG
DSSO\LQJWKUHVKROGLQJDOJRULWKPUHJLRQJURZLQJDOJRULWKPDQGPRUSKRORJLFDORSHUD
WRUV$PLQLPDOXVHULQYROYHPHQWLVUHTXLUHGWRJXLGHOLYHUVHJPHQWDWLRQDQGOHVLRQV
LGHQWLÀFDWLRQ7KHVRIWZDUHIUDPHZRUNZDVLPSOHPHQWHGLQ-DYDRQ1HW%HDQV,'(
5HVXOWV7KHVRIWZDUHGHWHFWVDOOOLYHUOHVLRQVGLDJQRVHGE\3K\VLFLDQ OHVLRQV
DQGWKHLUOLQHDUVL]H PP /HVLRQVVHJPHQWDWLRQDOORZVWKHH[WUDFWLRQRI
REMHFWLYHSDUDPHWHUV PHDQ&7QXPEHUVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQQRUPDOLVHGFRQWUDVW
DQG&15 LQWKHGLIIHUHQWFRQWUDVWSKDVHV,QDGGLWLRQWRWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI5HFLVW
SURWRFROVWDQGDUGGLPHQVLRQVOHVLRQZDVKRXWFXUYHVZHUHFRQVLGHUHG7KURXJK
OHVLRQVGHQVLW\DQG&15LVSRVVLEOHWRGLVFULPLQDWHGLIIHUHQWNLQGRIOHVLRQDQG
GHÀQHDUHFRJQLVLQJGHFLVLRQDODOJRULWKP
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHGHYHORSHGPHWKRGLVDEOHWRLGHQWLI\DOOOLYHUOHVLRQV/HVLRQV
ZDVKRXW FXUYHV DOORZ WR REWDLQ DQ DWWHQXDWLRQ SURÀOH LQ WKH WKUHH DFTXLVLWLRQ
SKDVHVVRWKDWZHFDQKDYHDUHVSRQVHWRWKHUDS\QRWRQO\LQYROXPHWHUPVEXW
DOVRLQWHUPVRIOHVLRQVGHQVLW\YDULDWLRQ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH 7R LQYHVWLJDWH WKH SUHYDOHQFH RI VLJQLÀFDQW FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ VWHQRVLV
RQ FRURQDU\ FDWKHWHUL]DWLRQ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK DQ LQWHUPHGLDWH SUHWHVW OLNHOLKRRG
RIFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHDWGLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRIFRURQDU\FDOFLXPVFRUH &&6
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV IHPDOHV\HDUV ZLWKDQLQWHU
PHGLDWHSUHWHVWOLNHOLKRRGRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHXQGHUZHQW&&6&7SULRUWR
FRURQDU\FDWKHWHUL]DWLRQ7KHSUHYDOHQFHRIVLJQLÀFDQWFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLV
! RQFRURQDU\FDWKHWHUL]DWLRQZDVFRUUHODWHGWRGLIIHUHQW&&6OHYHOVXV
LQJWKH$JDWVWRQVFRUH $6 $6!$6!$6!$6!$6!
5HVXOWV 0HDQ$6 ZDV &RURQDU\ FDWKHWHUL]DWLRQ UHYHDOHG VWHQRVLV
!LQRISDWLHQWV0HDQ$6RISDWLHQWVZLWKFRQÀUPHGVWHQRVLV!
ZDV UDQJH 7KH VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ SRVLWLYH SUHGLFWLYH
YDOXH 339 DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 WRSUHGLFWVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLVRQ
FRURQDU\FDWKHWHUL]DWLRQZDVDQGXVLQJDQ$6FXWRII
YDOXH!XVLQJDQ$6FXWRIIYDOXH!
XVLQJDQ$6FXWRIIYDOXH!XVLQJDQ$6
FXWRIIYDOXH!DQGDQGXVLQJDQ$6FXWRIIYDOXH
!UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ ,Q SDWLHQWV ZLWK DQ LQWHUPHGLDWH SUHWHVW OLNHOLKRRG RI FRURQDU\
DUWHU\GLVHDVHDQ$6EHWZHHQPDNHVDVLJQLÀFDQWFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLV
YHU\XQOLNHO\7KXV&&6&7SURYLGHVDGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWK
WUDGLWLRQDOFOLQLFDOULVNIDFWRUVHJ)UDPLQJKDPVFRUHWRDFFXUDWHO\SUHGLFWWKHULVN
RIWKRVHSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKHULQWUDFRURQDU\DWWHQXDWLRQUHVXOWVLQKLJKHULPDJHTXDOLW\DQG
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRUGHWHFWLRQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLVXVLQJVHFRQGJHQHUD
WLRQGXDOVRXUFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
$XWRPDWHGGHWHFWLRQDQGPHDVXUHPHQWRIXWHULQHSHULVWDOVLVLQFLQH
05LPDJHV
.<DQR.:DWDQDEH0<.DWDRND$.LGR.7RJDVKL2VDND-3
.\RWR-3 N\DQR#LVRLWDFMS
3XUSRVH&KDQJHVLQGLUHFWLRQDQGLQFLGHQFHRIXWHULQHSHULVWDOVLVQDPHO\ZDY\
FRQGXFWLRQ RI VXEHQGRPHWULDO P\RPHWULXP MXQFWLRQDO ]RQH DUH VXSSRVHG WR
VWURQJO\DIIHFWFRQGLWLRQVVXFKDVLQIHUWLOLW\DQGG\VPHQRUUKRHD,QWKLVVWXG\ZH
KDYHGHYHORSHGDQGHYDOXDWHGVRIWZDUHWRGHWHFWDQGTXDQWLI\WKHSHULVWDOVLVLQ
FLQH05LPDJHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORIVHULDO+$67(LPDJHVLQDPLGVDJLWWDOSODQHRI
WKHXWHUXVRIKHDOWK\IHPDOHVZHUHREWDLQHGHYHU\VHFRQGV8WHULQHSHULVWDOVLV
ZDVGHÀQHGDVUK\WKPLFFKDQJHVRIVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVDQGWKHLUSURSDJDWLRQVLQ
MXQFWLRQDO]RQH2XUVRIWZDUHÀUVWFDOFXODWHGFURVVFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWLPHFRXUVHV
RISL[HOLQWHQVLWLHVLQDVHFWLRQRIMXQFWLRQDO]RQHDQGWKRVHRIQHLJKERXULQJVHFWLRQV
7KHFURVVFRUUHODWLRQZDVKLJKZLWKDSSURSULDWHWLPHODJZKHQWUDYHOOLQJZDYHZDV
SUHVHQW)RUWKHVHFWLRQVZKHUHWKHWUDYHOOLQJZDYHVZHUHGHWHFWHGWKHVRIWZDUH
FDOFXODWHGDXWRFRUUHODWLRQRIWLPHFRXUVHRIWKHVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVDQGREWDLQHGZDYH
SHULRGVIURPSHDNLQWHUYDOVRIWKHDXWRFRUUHODWLRQ7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVPHDQZKLOH
YLVXDOO\DVVHVVHGXWHULQHSHULVWDOVLVXVLQJWKHVDPHLPDJHVHULHV
5HVXOWV7KHUHVXOWVIURPWKHDXWRPDWHGPHWKRGZHUHFRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKRVHRI
YLVXDODVVHVVPHQWVDQGKDGOHVVYDULDQFH PHDQFRXQWVE\VRIWZDUHREVHUYHUV$
DQG%ZHUH6'6'DQG6'UHVSHFWLYHO\ :HLJKWHGNDSSD
EHWZHHQVRIWZDUHDQGREVHUYHU$VRIWZDUHDQGREVHUYHU%DQGREVHUYHUV$DQG
%ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\LQGLFDWLQJYDULDWLRQVEHWZHHQVRIWZDUH
DQGKXPDQVZHUHVPDOOHUWKDQWKDWEHWZHHQKXPDQV
&RQFOXVLRQ8WHULQHSHULVWDOVLVFDQEHGHWHFWHGDQGFRXQWHGE\DXWRPDWHGHYDOX
DWLRQV2XUPHWKRGPD\EHXVHGIRUDURXWLQHIXQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQWRIXWHUXV
%
'LJLWDOSHUIXVLRQSKDQWRPVDQGWKHLUXVHLQSHUIXVLRQYDOLGDWLRQ
263LDQ\NK1HZWRQ+LJKODQGV0$86 RSLDQ\NK#ELGPFKDUYDUGHGX
3XUSRVH 'HVSLWH WKH LQFUHDVLQJO\ EURDG XVH RI SHUIXVLRQ DSSOLFDWLRQV ZH VWLOO
KDYHQRJHQHUDOO\DFFHVVLEOHPHDQVIRUWKHLUREMHFWLYHYDOLGDWLRQ7RVROYHWKLV
SUREOHPZHLQWURGXFHGLJLWDOSHUIXVLRQSKDQWRPV '33 VLPXODWHG',&20LP
DJHVVHTXHQFHVVSHFLÀFDOO\GHVLJQHGWRKDYHNQRZQSHUIXVLRQPDSVZLWKVLPSOH
YLVXDOSDWWHUQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV/HW6EHDWHPSRUDOSHUIXVLRQLPDJHVHTXHQFH6 ^,
,õ,Qõ,1`:HGHÀQHGLJLWDOSHUIXVLRQSKDQWRP '33 DVDFRPSXWHUVLPXODWHG
LPDJHVHTXHQFH6ZKHUHHDFKWHPSRUDOSL[HOYDOXH,Q [\ ,Q [\WQ LVJHQHUDWHG
WRKDYHSUHGHÀQHGYLVXDOSHUIXVLRQPDSSDWWHUQV7KDWLVJLYHQEORRGÁRZ)%
EORRGYROXPH9%DQGPHDQWUDQVLWWLPH70PDSVZHEXLOG'33LPDJHVHTXHQFH
6WRSURGXFHWKHVHPDSV:KLOHDQ\SHUIXVLRQDOJRULWKPZRUNVDQXPHULFDOVROYHU
IRUSHUIXVLRQFRQYROXWLRQHTXDWLRQ'33EHFRPHVDNQRZQVROXWLRQWRLWZKLFK
FDQEHXVHGWRYHULI\WKHDOJRULWKPFRUUHFWQHVV
5HVXOWV:HGHYHORSHGDLPDJH'33ZKHUH)%9%DQG70PDSVFRQVLVWRI
VLPSOHOLQHDUSDWWHUQV:HWKHQSURFHVVHGRXU'33ZLWKVHYHUDOSHUIXVLRQSDFN
DJHVFRPSDULQJWKHUHVXOWLQJPDSVWRWKHH[SHFWHG7KLVFRPSDULVRQSURYLGHGDQ
LQVWDQWDQHRXVDQGREMHFWLYHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRISHUIXVLRQDOJRULWKPVҋGHÀFLHQFLHVDV
ZHOODVWKHLUVHQVLWLYLW\WRQRLVHDQGVPDOOGHWDLOV'33XVHGZLWKGLIIHUHQWSHUIXVLRQ
VRIWZDUHDQGSURWRFROVFDQFOHDUO\YLVXDOLVHSURFHVVLQJHUURUVDQGGLVFUHSDQFLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ3URFHVVLQJ'33SHUIXVLRQVHTXHQFHZLWKDQ\SHUIXVLRQDOJRULWKP
VRIWZDUHRIFKRLFHDQGFRPSDULQJWKHUHVXOWVWRWKHH[SHFWHG'33SDWWHUQVSUR
YLGHVDUREXVWDQGVWUDLJKWIRUZDUGZD\WRFRQWUROWKHTXDOLW\RISHUIXVLRQDQDO\VLV
VRIWZDUHDQGSURWRFROV
%
$XWRPDWHGVHPDQWLFQDYLJDWLRQDQGV\QFKURQLVHGDOLJQPHQWLQ
EDVHOLQHDQGIROORZXSIXOOERG\&7VFDQVFOLQLFDOIHDVLELOLW\DQGDFFXUDF\
3'DQNHUO0+DPPRQ06XHKOLQJ$7V\PEDO08GHU$&DYDOODUR
(UODQJHQ'( SHWHUGDQNHUO#XNHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH&RPSDULQJÀQGLQJVIURPLQLWLDODQGIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQVLQLQFUHDVLQJ
IXOOERG\&7GDWDLVDFKDOOHQJLQJDQGWLPHFRQVXPLQJWDVNIRUUDGLRORJLVWV:H
HYDOXDWHGSUDFWLFDELOLW\DQGSHUIRUPDQFHRIDXWRPDWHGVHPDQWLFQDYLJDWLRQDQG
V\QFKURQLVHGDOLJQPHQWLQURXWLQHFOLQLFDOIROORZXS&7GDWD
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,QLWLDO DQG IROORZXS &7 VWXGLHV IURP RQFRORJLFDO
SDWLHQWV XQGHUJRLQJ URXWLQH &7 VWDJLQJ ZHUH UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ LQFRUSRUDWHG LQWR
7+(6(860(',&2VRIWZDUH *HUPDQ IHGHUDO SURMHFWQXPEHU 04
ZKLFKDXWRPDWLFDOO\GHWHFWVRUJDQVDQGDQDWRPLFDOODQGPDUNVXVHGIRUDXWRPDWLF
VHPDQWLFDOLJQPHQWDQGSUHGLFWLRQRIÀQGLQJVORFDWLRQVLQIROORZXSGDWDIURPEDVH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
OLQHÀQGLQJVORFDWLRQVUHOHYDQWUHSRUWHGÀQGLQJVHJO\PSKQRGHVRUYHVVHO
MXQFWLRQVZHUHHYDOXDWHG0DQXDOQDYLJDWLRQE\WZRH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVWR
FRUUHVSRQGLQJÀQGLQJVLQIROORZXSGDWDZDVWDNHQDVJROGVWDQGDUGDQGFRPSDUHG
WRV\VWHPEDVHGQDYLJDWLRQ(UURULQPPEHWZHHQPDQXDODQGDXWRPDWLFQDYLJDWLRQ
ZDVGRFXPHQWHGDVFUDQLRFDXGDOYHQWURGRUVDOODWHUDOOHIWRUODWHUDOULJKWGHYLD
WLRQ0HDQGHYLDWLRQVDQGLQWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW ,&& ZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQGHYLDWLRQRIWKHUHSRUWHGOHVLRQVIRUUHDGHUZDVPP
ZLWKVLPLODUGHYLDWLRQVLQDOOGLUHFWLRQV PPFUDQLDOPPFDXGDOPP
YHQWUDOPPGRUVDOPPODWHUDOOHIWPPODWHUDOULJKW DQGPPIRU
UHDGHU PPFUDQLDOPPFDXGDOPPYHQWUDOPPGRUVDOPP
ODWHUDOOHIW PP ODWHUDOULJKW ,&& ZDV )RU ERWK UHDGHUV WKHUH ZDV QR
GHYLDWLRQELDVLQWRDSDUWLFXODUGLUHFWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$XWRPDWHGVHPDQWLFQDYLJDWLRQLQ&7IROORZXSGDWDSURYLGHVFOLQLFDOO\
VXIÀFLHQWDFFXUDF\DQGUHSURGXFLELOLW\DOORZLQJDXWRPDWHGVLGHE\VLGHYLHZLQJRI
FRUUHVSRQGLQJORFDWLRQVLQEDVHOLQHDQGIROORZXSGDWD,WVKRXOGLPSURYHKDQGOLQJ
ODUJHGDWDVHWVDQGVSHHGXSUDGLRORJLFDOUHDGLQJ
%
$QDXWRPDWHGPHWKRGIRUYLVXDOLVLQJFKDQJHVLQYHVVHOZDOOG\QDPLFV
(6FKZDUW]*/DQJV-+ROIHOG0&]HUQ\9LHQQD$7,QQVEUXFN$7
%HUQH&+ (UQVW6FKZDUW]#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7KH VWXG\ RI HIIHFWV RI YDVFXODU LQWHUYHQWLRQV LV WRGD\ PRVWO\ OLPLWHG
WRVWDWLFYHVVHOPRGHOV7KLVUHSUHVHQWVDQRYHUVLPSOLÀFDWLRQLQWKHFDVHRIWKH
WKRUDFLFDRUWDZKLFKLVVWURQJO\LQÁXHQFHGE\WKHPRWLRQRIWKHP\RFDUGLXP
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q WKLV SDSHU ZH SURSRVH D IUDPHZRUN HQDEOLQJ WKH
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQDQGYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHPRWLRQRIWKHWKRUDFLFDRUWDIURP(&*JDWHG
&7$VHTXHQFHVGXULQJWKHFDUGLDFF\FOH7KHYHVVHOLVVHJPHQWHGDQGWUDFNHG
DXWRPDWLFDOO\WKURXJKDKHDUWEHDW7KHH[WUDFWHGPRWLRQRIWKHDRUWDLVGHFRPSRVHG
LQPHDVXUHVRISXOVDWLRQEHQGLQJDQGVWUHWFKLQJ:HIXUWKHUJHQHUDWHDQRYHO'
UHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHYHVVHOG\QDPLFVIRUTXLFNYLVXDODVVHVVPHQW
5HVXOWV:HXVHGWKHSURSRVHGPHWKRGWRHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWVRIVWHQWJUDIWLQJLQ
WKHDRUWLFDUFKDIWHUVXSUDDRUWLFUHURXWLQJLQFDVHV7KHREWDLQHGPHDVXUHPHQWV
DQGWKHLUYLVXDOUHSUHVHQWDWLRQJLYHGHWDLOHGLQVLJKWLQWRRISDWWHUQVRIPRYHPHQWLQ
WKHWKRUDFLFDRUWDDVZHOODVFKDQJHVLQGXFHGE\VWHQWJUDIWLQJRIWKHDRUWLFDUFK
(OHYDWHGVWUDLQGXHWRGLIIXVHPRWLRQDWWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHSURVWKHVLVFRXOGEH
REVHUYHGLQDOOFDVHV7KHLQÁXHQFHRIVWHQWOHQJWKDQGSODFHPHQWFRXOGDOVREH
TXDQWLÀHGXVLQJWKHSURSRVHGPHWKRG
&RQFOXVLRQ:HGHYHORSHGDQDXWRPDWHGPHWKRGWRDLGWKHYLVXDOLQVSHFWLRQRI
WKHHIIHFWVRIYDVFXODULQWHUYHQWLRQVLQWKHDRUWLFDUFK$VDÀUVWH[DPSOHRIWKH
DSSOLFDWLRQRIWKHSURSRVHGPHWKRGZHFRXOGGHVFULEHWKHLQÁXHQFHVRIWKHOHQJWK
DQGORFDWLRQRIDVWHQWJUDIWLQWKHDRUWLFDUFKLQFDVHV
%
7RZDUGVHIÀFLHQWVLPXOWDQHRXVPXOWLSDWLHQWDQQRWDWLRQRI'
LPDJLQJGDWD
:/DQJ5'RQQHU9LHQQD$7 H#VWXGHQWWXZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH0DQXDOVHJPHQWDWLRQVRIPHGLFDOGDWDDUHWHGLRXVDQGWLPHLQWHQVLYH
PXOWLSOHVHJPHQWDWLRQVTXLFNO\EHFRPHSURKLELWLYHO\H[SHQVLYH HVSHFLDOO\RQ'
GDWD 2EVHUYLQJ WKLVZH GHYHORSHG DQ LQWHUDFWLYH LQFUHPHQWDO DQQRWDWLRQ WRRO
IRU JHQHULF PHGLFDO LPDJH GDWD IRFXVLQJ RQ VLPXOWDQHRXV ZHDNO\ VXSHUYLVHG
FODVVLÀFDWLRQEDVHGPXOWLSDWLHQWVHJPHQWDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HXVHDQLQLWLDORYHUVHJPHQWDWLRQPHWKRGVVXFKDV
6XSHUSL[HOVWRFOXVWHUVSDWLDOO\FRKHUHQWKRPRJHQHRXVVWUXFWXUHVZKLOHUHWDLQLQJ
HGJHLQIRUPDWLRQ8VHUJXLGHGEUXVKVWURNHVPDUNUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVIRUHDFKODEHO
FODVVZLWKLQWKHLPDJHZKLFKDUHSDVVHGWRDUDQGRPIRUHVWOHDUQLQJLPSOHPHQ
WDWLRQ5HVXOWLQJSULRUVFRPELQHGZLWKORFDOGHVFULSWRUVDQGRSWLPLVHGE\D05)
VROYHUJLYHDÀUVWHVWLPDWLRQRIGHVLUHGDSSHDUDQFHVLQDOOPXOWLSDWLHQWYLHZV6XF
FHVVLYHLQWHUDFWLRQVUHÀQHWKHDQQRWDWLRQPDNLQJPD[LPDOXVHRIHDFKXVHULQSXW
5HVXOWV7KHUHVXOWLQJIUDPHZRUNSURYLGHVDPXOWLSDWLHQWYLHZDOORZLQJWRLQWHUDFW
ZLWKDOOLQGLYLGXDODQQRWDWLRQVLPXOWDQHRXVO\:HHYDOXDWHWKHVHJPHQWDWLRQUHVXOWV
RQOHIWKDQG&7VZHFDOFXODWHWKH'LFHFRHIÀFLHQWEHWZHHQRXUJURXQGWUXWK
DQGVHJPHQWDWLRQUHVXOWV:HUHDFKDQRYHUODSRILQPHWDFDUSDOV
LQ SUR[LPDO SKDODQJHV DQG LQ LQWHUPHGLDWH SKDODQJHV RQ [ SL[HO
VL]HGLPDJHVZLWKDSSUR[LPDWHO\RYHUVHJPHQWDWLRQSULPLWLYHV 6XSHUSL[HOV
&RQFOXVLRQ 8VLQJ RYHUVHJPHQWDWLRQ WURXJK 6XSHUSL[HOV FRPELQHG ZLWK ORFDO
GHVFULSWRUVPDNHVWKHODEHOOLQJSUREOHPLQPXOWLSDWLHQWVHJPHQWDWLRQVWUDFWDEOH
&RQVLVWHQW ZLWK RXU JRDO RI SURYLGLQJ ZKROH LPDJH ODEHOOLQJ DQQRWDWLRQV QRW
LQGLYLGXDOREMHFWGHOLQHDWLRQVE\ORZHULQJDFFXUDF\ GXHWRWKH6XSHUSL[HOV WKH
DQQRWDWLRQWLPHIRUDZKROHVHWRISDWLHQWGDWD HJKDQG&7V LVDIUDFWLRQRIWKH
WLPHUHTXLUHGXVLQJFXUUHQWDQQRWDWLRQWRROV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
5HWULHYLQJSRVLWLYHÀQGLQJVLQUDGLRORJLFDOLPDJHVZLWKWKHDLGRI
WH[WXDOKLQWVLQUHSRUWV
3'DXPNH.6LPRQ&6LPRQ(.RWWHU$*HUVWPDLU
)UHLEXUJ'( GDXPNH#DYHUELVGH
%
5DSLGVHPLDXWRPDWLFOLYHUVHJPHQWDWLRQXVLQJDQHZXVHUIULHQGO\
SURWRW\SLFVRIWZDUHWRROLQLWLDOH[SHULHQFH
),0DUWLQH]*DPEDUR)2+HQHV+'1DJHO*$GDP05HJLHU
6DQWLDJR&/+DPEXUJ'( IHPDUWLQH]J#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHDFFXUDF\RIDQHZVRIWZDUHWRROIRUVHPLDXWRPDWLFOLYHU
VHJPHQWDWLRQLQWKHDQDO\VLVRIOLYHUVHJPHQWVYHVVHOVDQGWXPRXUOHVLRQVDQGWR
DVVHVVLWVWKHXVHUIULHQGOLQHVV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QKHDOWK\OLYHUGRQRUVDQGSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURP
KHSDWLFWXPRXUVWKLQVOLFHG0'&7V L&73KLOLSVPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV ZHUH
DFTXLUHG %DVHG RQ D OHYHO VHW PHWKRG IRU DXWRPDWLF FRQWRXU LGHQWLÀFDWLRQ WKH
VHJPHQWDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGIROORZLQJ&RXLQDXGVDQDWRPLFDOFODVVLÀFDWLRQ7KH
YROXPHWU\RIVHJPHQWVYHVVHOVDQGOHVLRQVZDVDVVHVVHGDXWRPDWLFDOO\XVLQJD
'EDVHGYR[HOFODVVLÀFDWLRQDOJRULWKPZLWKSURSDJDWLRQDOOHDUQLQJDQGDIWHUZDUGV
PDQXDOFRUUHFWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG7KHWLPHQHFHVVLWDWHGIRUVHJPHQWDWLRQDQG
PDQXDOFRUUHFWLRQZDVUHFRUGHG7KHWLPHWRH[HFXWHDOOPHDVXUHPHQWVDQGFRU
UHFWLRQVZDVTXDQWLÀHG
5HVXOWV7KHVHPLDXWRPDWLFVHJPHQWDWLRQUDSLGO\SHUIRUPHGSUHFLVHGHWHUPLQD
WLRQ RI DOO VHJPHQWV ZLWK DYHUDJLQJ FRUUHFWQHVV RI LQ KHDOWK\ GRQRUV ,Q
WXPRXU SDWLHQWV WKH FRUUHFWQHVV IRU DOO VHJPHQWV ZDV 7KH PHDQ WLPH
IRU VHPLDXWRPDWLF OLYHU VHJPHQWDWLRQ DQG PDQXDO FRUUHFWLRQ ZDV PLQ DQG
PLQUHVSHFWLYHO\5DSLGDVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUYROXPHZDVDFKLHYHGZLWK
FRUUHFWQHVVRI7KHDFFXUDF\ZDVOLPLWHGLISULRUUHVHFWLRQRUODUJHQHFURWLF
DUHDVZHUHSUHVHQW7KHUHFRJQLWLRQRIOLYHUYHVVHOVZDVKLJKO\SUHFLVH !
XVLQJDVWDQGDUGFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQSURWRFRO
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHQHZVHPLDXWRPDWLFVRIWZDUHWRROHYDOXDWHGDOORZVIRUWKHVHJ
PHQWDWLRQRIWKHOLYHUYHVVHOVDQGWXPRXUOHVLRQVZLWKUHPDUNDEO\KLJKSUHFLVLRQ
DQG HIÀFLHQF\ )XUWKHUPRUH GXH WR LWV HDV\WRKDQGOH DSSURDFK DQG WKH UDWKHU
VKRUWWLPHIRUPDQXDOFRUUHFWLRQWKLVWRROPLJKWPHHWWKHEURDGGHPDQGVRIPRGHUQ
FURVVVHFWLRQDOLPDJLQJRIWKHOLYHULQGDLO\FOLQLFDOURXWLQH
%
,PDJHUHJLVWUDWLRQLQDK\EULGURXWLQHXVLQJ6KDQQRQ7VDOOLVHQWURS\
IRUWKHVWDWLVWLFDOSDUDPHWULFPDSSLQJ 630
+7$6$PDUDO/20XUWD-U/:LFKHUW$QD$&6DNDPRWR
30$]HYHGR0DUTXHV5LEHLUmR3UHWR%5 KHQULTXHWRPD]#XROFRPEU
3XUSRVH 7KH DXWRPDWLF FRUHJLVWUDWLRQ RI PHGLFDO LPDJHV EDVHG RQ VLPLODULW\
PHDVXUHVKDYHEHHQVXJJHVWHGLQVHYHUDOVWXGLHVXVLQJGLIIHUHQWFRVWIXQFWLRQ
DSSURDFKHVZKLFKKDYHSUHVHQWHGUHOHYDQWUHVXOWVIRUPDQ\NLQGRIELRPHGLFDO
LPDJHV%DVHGRQSUHYLRXVUHVXOWVVKRZLQJWKHFRQWULEXWLRQRIWKH7VDOOLVHQWURS\
RQWKHDOLJQPHQWRIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, DQGVLQJOHSKRWRQHPLV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
,QWHJUDWLRQRIGLIIXVLRQDQGSHUIXVLRQLPDJHVRIKXPDQEUHDVW
FDQFHUE\UHJLVWUDWLRQDQGGLVVLPLODULW\EDVHGFOXVWHULQJ
&$0pQGH])3L]]RUQL)HUUDUHVH36XPPHUV*3HWUDOLD*0HQHJD]
9HURQD,70LODQ,7 DQGUHVPHQGH]J#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RLQWURGXFHDQHZSDWLHQWVSHFLÀFSLSHOLQHIRUWKHLQWHJUDWLRQRIEUHDVW
GLIIXVLRQDQGSHUIXVLRQ05,IRUVXUJLFDOSODQQLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSURSRVHDWZRVWHSSURFHVVIRUWKHLQWHJUDWLRQRI
LQIRUPDWLRQGHULYHGIURP'&(05,DQG':05,PRGDOLWLHV)LUVWYR[HOZLVHGLV
VLPLODULW\EDVHGFOXVWHULQJLVSHUIRUPHGRQ'&(LPDJHVWRLGHQWLI\GLIIHUHQWWXPRUDO
VXEUHJLRQVZKLFKDUHWKHQSURMHFWHGWRWKH':05,IROORZLQJDSDWLHQWVSHFLÀF
UHJLVWUDWLRQSURWRFROFRQVLVWLQJRIDSUHOLPLQDU\PXOWLUHVROXWLRQULJLGWUDQVIRUPDWLRQ
IROORZHGE\DQHODVWLF%6SOLQHGHIRUPDWLRQIRFXVHGRQWKHOHVLRQDUHD7KHSURE
DELOLW\GHQVLW\IXQFWLRQVLQWKH$'&PDSRIWKHVXEUHJLRQVDUHWKHQH[WUDFWHGDQG
FRPSDUHGWKURXJKQRQSDUDPHWULFWHVWLQJ :LOFR[RQVLJQHGUDQNWHVWS 7KH
SLSHOLQHZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGXVLQJ'&(05,DQG':05,DFTXLUHGIURPSDWLHQWV
UDQJHGLQDJH PHGLDQ\HDUV DIIHFWHGE\SULPDU\GXFWDOFDUFLQRPD
5HVXOWV1RQSDUDPHWULFWHVWVVKRZWKDW$'&YDOXHVIURPWKHVXEUHJLRQVFRU
UHVSRQGLQJ WR GLIIHUHQW FOXVWHUV LQ WKH '&( YROXPH KDYH VWDWLVWLFDOO\ GLIIHUHQW
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVZKLFKLQGLFDWHVWKHFRQVLVWHQF\RIWKHLQIRUPDWLRQREWDLQHGIURP
WKHWZRPRGDOLWLHVZKLOHSURYLGLQJDSRVWHULRUYDOLGDWLRQRIWKHUHJLVWUDWLRQPHWKRG
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKLVZRUNZHKDYHHPSOR\HGGLVVLPLODULW\EDVHGUHSUHVHQWDWLRQV
LQVWHDGRIFODVVLFIHDWXUHVWRLQWHJUDWHWKHLQIRUPDWLRQSURYLGHGE\ERWKGLIIXVLRQ
DQGSHUIXVLRQ05,LPDJHVRIWKHEUHDVW3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVDUHTXLWHSURPLVLQJ
DQGVXJJHVWWKHH[SORLWDWLRQLQIXWXUHZRUNVRIWKLVFRPELQHGLQIRUPDWLRQLQWKH
UHJLVWUDWLRQSURFHVVWKURXJKWKHGHÀQLWLRQRIDQDGKRFREMHFWLYHIXQFWLRQ0RUHR
YHUDIWHUVSDWLDOUHJLVWUDWLRQWKHGLIIXVLRQLQIRUPDWLRQFDQEHLQFRUSRUDWHGLQWRWKH
FODVVLÀFDWLRQSURFHVV\LHOGLQJDWUXO\PXOWLPRGDOLW\LQWHJUDWLRQRILPDJLQJGDWD
5RRP$
1HXUR
66D
,QWHUYHQWLRQDOQHXURUDGLRORJ\
0RGHUDWRUV
%*yPH]$QVyQ%DUFHORQD(6
63XFKQHU9LHQQD$7
%
6LQJOHFHQWUHH[SHULHQFHRILQWUDFHUHEUDODUWHU\WKURPEHFWRP\XVLQJ
75(92GHYLFHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
/6DQ5RPDQ92EDFK-0DFKR-%ODVFR$/RSH]
$7RPDVHOOR-3HUDQGUHX-%UDQHUD$&KDPRUUR%DUFHORQD(6
OVUPDQ]DQHUD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHVFULEHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQGVDIHW\DQGRIDPHFKDQLFDOVWHQWOLNH
GHYLFH75(92LQWKHHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRIDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3URVSHFWLYHVLQJOHFHQWUHVWXG\RISDWLHQWVZLWKDQ
DFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNHDWWULEXWDEOHWRDODUJHFHUHEUDODUWHU\RFFOXVLRQ0HGLDQ
1DWLRQDO,QVWLWXWHVRI+HDOWK6WURNH6FDOH$UWHULDORFFOXVLRQZDVLQWKHDQWH
ULRUFLUFXODWLRQLQRIFDVHVDQGLQYHUWHEUREDVLODUWHUULWRU\0HDQWLPH
IURPV\PSWRPRQVHWWRHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWZDVPLQXWHV(QGRYDVFXODU
WUHDWPHQWZDVUXOHGRXWZKHQHVWDEOLVKHGLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVZHUHJUHDWHUWKDQ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7REXLOGDQGHYDOXDWHDUHWULHYDOV\VWHPIRU*HUPDQUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWV
HQDEOLQJLPSURYHGDFFHVVWRUDGLRORJLFDOLPDJHDQGIUHHWH[WGDWD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VFDODEOHWH[WDQDO\VLVSODWIRUPLVXVHGWRH[WUDFWUHOHYDQW
LQIRUPDWLRQIURP*HUPDQUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWVDQGWRFUHDWHVHPDQWLFOLQNVEHWZHHQ
LPDJHVDQGWH[WXDOGHVFULSWLRQV7KHSODWIRUPFRQVLVWVRIGRPDLQVSHFLÀFDQDO\VLV
FRPSRQHQWVGHDOLQJZLWKGLIIHUHQWDVSHFWVRIPHGLFDOODQJXDJHVXFKDVQHJDWLRQV
DEEUHYLDWLRQVGLPHQVLRQVSURSHUQDPHVDQGWKHPRUSKRORJLFDODQDO\VLVRIZRUG
FRPSRXQGV$GGLWLRQDOO\LWFRQWDLQVDQLPDJHUHIHUHQFHDQGFRQWH[WUHFRJQLWLRQ
FRPSRQHQWDOORZLQJWKHFUHDWLRQRIVHPDQWLFOLQNVEHWZHHQWH[WDQGLPDJHGDWD
*LYHQDQH[SOLFLWSLFWXUHUHIHUHQFHPHQWLRQHGLQDUHSRUWHJҊ,0$ҋDQGLWV
VXUURXQGLQJGHVFULSWLRQWKLVFRPSRQHQWWULHVWRGHGXFHWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ',&20
VHULHV,'EDVHGRQH[SOLFLW RULPSOLFLW KLQWVDQGORDGVWKHUHIHUHQFHG LPDJH V
IURPWKHORFDO3$&6VHUYHU)LQDOO\NH\LPDJHVDQGUHOHYDQWWH[WSDVVDJHVDUH
VXEVHTXHQWO\PDGHDYDLODEOHWRUDGLRORJLVWVLQDVHDUFKHQJLQHIRUDGKRFTXHU\LQJ
5HVXOWV2QDFRUSXVRIUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWVWKHV\VWHPZDVDEOHWRLGHQWLI\
LPDJHUHIHUHQFHVDQGVXFFHVVIXOO\UHWULHYHLPDJHVIURPWKHORFDO
3$&6 VHUYHU 5DQGRPLVHG YDOLGDWLRQV RI LGHQWLÀHG LPDJH UHIHUHQFHV VKRZHG
WKDWWKHH[WUDFWLRQFRPSRQHQWLVDEOHWRUHVROYHWKHFRUUHFWUHIHUHQFHZLWKPHDQ
DYHUDJHSUHFLVLRQRI3
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUDQDO\VLVVKRZVWKDWFRPSUHKHQVLYHV\QWDFWLFDQGVHPDQWLFWH[W
DQDO\VLVLVUHTXLUHGWRDFKLHYHKLJKTXDOLW\LQIRUPDWLRQH[WUDFWLRQIURPUDGLRORJ\
UHSRUWV,WLVWKHEDVLVIRUDQXPEHURIYDOXHDGGHGDSSOLFDWLRQVVXFKDVLPDJH
VHDUFKGDWDPLQLQJDQGGHFLVLRQVXSSRUW
VLRQFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 63(&7 WKLVSURMHFWSURSRVHVWKHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRI
DK\EULGURXWLQHXVLQJWKHFRPELQDWLRQRIWKH6KDQQRQDQGWKH7VDOOLVHQWURSLHVLQ
WKH6WDWLVWLFDO3DUDPHWULF0DSSLQJFRUHJLVWUDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05,DQG63(&7RIPRUSKRORJLFDOO\QRUPDOSDWLHQWZHUH
XVHGIRUWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIVLPXODWRUVZKLFKZHUHFRUHJLVWHUHGZLWKWKHRULJLQDO
LPDJHVXVLQJWKHSURSRVHGK\EULGURXWLQHDQGWKHLQGLYLGXDORQHV7KHFRPSDUDWLYH
DQDO\VLVEHWZHHQWKHURXWLQHVUHOLDELOLW\ZDVSHUIRUPHGEDVHGRQWKHURRWPHDQ
VTXDUH 506 HUURURIWKHURWDWLRQDQGWUDQVODWLRQSDUDPHWHUV
5HVXOWV3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVVKRZHGWKDWWKHK\EULGURXWLQHOHDGHGWRDPRUHUHOLDEOH
LQWHUPRGDOLW\FRUHJLVWUDWLRQIRUVLPXODWRUVZLWKVPDOOWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVEDVHGRQ
WKH506HUURUDVH[SHFWHG0RUHFRUHJLVWUDWLRQVDUHEHLQJSHUIRUPHGWRFRQÀUP
WKHVHUHVXOWVIRUWKHVLPXODWRUVZLWKODUJHUWUDQVIRUPDWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHLQLWLDOUHVXOWVVKRZHGVWURQJHYLGHQFHVWKDWWKHK\EULGURXWLQH
XVLQJ6KDQQRQDQG7VDOOLVHQWURSLHVMRLQWO\SHUIRUPHGPRVWUHOLDEOHLQWHUPRGDOLW\
FRUHJLVWUDWLRQXVLQJVWDWLVWLFDOSDUDPHWULFPDSSLQJDQGWKHUHIRUHFRXOGEHDQHZ
DYDLODEOHFRVWIXQFWLRQDSSURDFKLQWKHLPDJHSURFHVVLQJWRROV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
RQHWKLUGRIWKHPLGGOHFHUHEUDODUWHU\WHUULWRU\PHDVXUHGE\PXOWLPRGDOFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ &7 RUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05,
5HVXOWVRISDWLHQWVZHUHGHHPHGWRVKRZJRRGRXWFRPH PRGLÀHG5DQNLQ
6FDOHVFRUH DWGD\V2IWKHSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGXVLQJ7UHYRDVWKHVROH
WUHDWPHQW WHFKQLTXH VKRZHG FRPSOHWH WKURPERO\VLV LQ FHUHEUDO LQIDUFWLRQ
VFRUH 7,&,JUDGH RUSDUWLDO 7,&,E UHSHUIXVLRQDQGWKLVLQFUHDVHGWRLI
DGGLWLRQDOWUHDWPHQWVZHUHXVHG7KHPHDQWLPHIURPJURLQSXQFWXUHWRUHFDQDOL
VDWLRQZDVPLQ6\PSWRPDWLFLQWUDFUDQLDOKDHPRUUKDJHZDVIRXQGLQ
SDWLHQWVDQG SDWLHQWVGLHGZLWKLQWKHGD\IROORZXSSHULRG7KHUHZHUH
GLVWDOHPEROLVDWLRQVRIDSUHYLRXVXQLQYROYHGWHUULWRU\1RDUWHULDOUXSWXUHRURWKHU
PDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVRFFXUUHG
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUÀQGLQJVLQGLFDWHWKDWPHFKDQLFDOLQWUDFUDQLDOWKURPEXVH[WUDFWLRQ
XVLQJ75(92LVHIIHFWLYHDQGKDVDUHDVRQDEOHPRUELGLW\DQGPRUWDOLW\UDWHLQWKH
WUHDWPHQWRIDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
%
(QGRYDVFXODUUHSHUIXVLRQIRUDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH $,6
3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVRIDVLQJOHFHQWUHUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\
(3XJOLHOOL0)XVFKL9'L(JLGLR7HUDPR,7 HGRSXJ#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH$LPRIWKLVSUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHVDIHW\HIÀFDF\RIWKH
PXOWLSOHHQGRYDVFXODUPRGDOLWLHV SKDUPDFRORJLFPHFKDQLFDO WKDWFDQEHXVHGLQ
WKHUHSHUIXVLRQWKHUDS\IRU$,6WRLPSURYHWKHUDWHVRIUHFDQDOLVDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWK$,6 PHDQDJH\IURP
$SULOWR6HSWHPEHU RQVHWOHVVWKDQKRXUVIRUWKHDQWHULRUFLUFXODWLRQ
DQGIRUWKHYHUWHEUREDVLODURQHXQGHUZHQWWRLQWUDDUWHULDOSKDUPDFRORJLFRU
PHFKDQLFDOWKHUDS\ZLWKUHFDQDOLVDWLRQ&7&7SHUIXVLRQ05,'6$ZHUHXVHGIRU
WKHDVVHVVPHQWRILVFKDHPLFDUHDDQGFDXVHV3DWLHQWҋVDJHVH[DHWLRORJ\RI
RFFOXVLRQV\PSWRPEHIRUHDIWHUPHFKDQLFDOSKDUPDFRORJLFWUHDWPHQWVZLWKPRGL
ÀHG5DQNLQ6FDOH P56 UHFDQDOLVDWLRQUDWHVHYDOXDWHGZLWK7,&, WKURPERO\VLVLQ
FHUHEUDOLVFKDHPLD JUDGH QRÁRZ JUDGH QRUPDOÁRZ DQGKDHPRUUKDJLF
WUDQVIRUPDWLRQV +7 ZHUH UHFRUGHG DQG FRUUHODWHG XVLQJ D PXOWLSOH ORJLVWLF UH
JUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV7KH VLWHV RIDUWHULDO RFFOXVLRQ EHIRUH WUHDWPHQW ZHUH 0 SDWLHQWV
LQWUDFUDQLDO FDURWLG 0 WDQGHP RFFOXVLRQ
H[WUDFUDQLDO LQWHUQDO FDURWLG LVRODWHG RFFOXVLRQ 3
EDVLODUWUXQN 7KHUDSHXWLFLQWHUYHQWLRQVLQFOXGHGPXOWLPRGDO
WKHUDS\ SKDUPDFRORJLF FKHDS ZLWK WLVVXHSODVPLQRJHQ DFWLYDWRU
W3$ PHFKDQLFDOWKHUDS\ZLWKHPEROHFWRP\XVLQJVROLWDLUH HY
70 7KHUHFDQDOLVDWLRQUDWHZLWKPXOWLPRGDOWKHUDS\ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHU7,&,UHFDQDOLVDWLRQUDWH SDWLHQWV>@ FRPSDUHGWRSKDUPDFR
ORJLFWKHUDS\RQO\ SDWLHQWV>@ RUPHFKDQLFDORQH SDWLHQWV>@
S+DHPRUUKDJLFSHUIXVLRQRFFXUUHGLQRQHSDWLHQWZLWK0RFFOXVLRQWKDW
VSRQWDQHRXVO\UHVROYHG
&RQFOXVLRQ0XOWLPRGDOWKHUDS\VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUUHFDQDOLVDWLRQUDWHV
YVSKDUPDFRORJLFRUPHFKDQLFDORQHVZKLOHWKHSUHYDOHQFHRIKHPRUUKDJHGRHV
QRWH[FHHGWKDWZKLFKRFFXUVLQWKHQDWXUDOKLVWRU\7KHVHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVVKRZ
SRWHQWLDOIRUWKHHQGRYDVFXODUPDQDJHPHQWRI$,6
%
5HVXOWVRIPHFKDQLFDOWKURPERO\VLVIRUDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
FRPSDULVRQZLWKLQWUDDUWHULDOXURNLQDVHLQIXVLRQ
$,P6-HRQ6&KRL,NVDQ.5
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH HIÀFDF\ DQG VDIHW\ RI PHFKDQLFDO WKURPERO\VLV LQ
DFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNHFRPSDUHGZLWKUHVXOWVRILQWUDDUWHULDO ,$ SKDUPDFRORJLF
WKURPERO\VLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGSDWLHQWVZKRZHUHSHUIRUPHG
,$WKURPERO\VLVIRUDFXWHWKURPERHPEROLFRFFOXVLRQRIPDMRUYHVVHOV7RWDOSDWLHQWV
ZHUHDQGGLYLGHGLQWRJURXSVJURXS SXUHXURNLQDVH>8.@LQIXVLRQQ
JURXS PHFKDQLFDOWKURPERO\VLV>FORWGLVUXSWLRQ@XVLQJPLFURZLUHDQGPLFURFDWK
HWHUQ JURXS PHFKDQLFDOWKURPERO\VLVXVLQJDQJLRSODVW\EDOORRQUHWULHYDEOH
VHOIH[SDQGDEOHVWHQWRUDVSLUDWLRQWKURPEHFWRP\FDWKHWHUQ :HDVVHVVHG
WUHDWPHQWUHVXOWVZKLFKZHUHFRPSDUHGE\UHFDQDOLVDWLRQUDWHFOLQLFDORXWFRPH
PRUWDOLW\DQGV\PSWRPDWLFKDHPRUUKDJHUDWH
5HVXOWV 7KH UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ UDWH ZDV LQ JURXS , LQ JURXS ,, DQG
LQ JURXS ,,, 0HFKDQLFDO WKURPERO\VLV JURXSV KDG KLJKHU UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ
UDWHDQGJURXS,,,KDGWKHEHVWUHVXOWRIUHFDQDOLVDWLRQUDWH S :HDVVHVVHG
FOLQLFDORXWFRPHXVLQJPRGLÀHG5DQNLQ6FDOH P56 DIWHUPRQWKVDQGIDYRXU
DEOHRXWFRPHZDVWKHEHVWLQJURXS,,,IROORZHGE\JURXSV,,DQG, S 7KH
V\PSWRPDWLFKDHPRUUKDJHUDWHDQGPRUWDOLW\ZDVLQJURXS,
LQJURXS,,DQGLQJURXS,,,UHVSHFWLYHO\7KLVGLIIHUHQFHZDVQRW
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW S! +RZHYHUJURXS,,,KDVWHQGHQF\WKDWV\PSWRPDWLF
KDHPRUUKDJHDQGPRUWDOLW\DUHORZ
&RQFOXVLRQ0HFKDQLFDOWKURPERO\VLVKDVKLJKHUUDWHRIUHFDQDOLVDWLRQDQGJRRG
FOLQLFDO RXWFRPH WKDQ 8. WKURPERO\VLV )URP DPRQJ WZR GLIIHUHQW PHFKDQLFDO
WKURPERO\WLFWKHUDSLHVXVLQJPHFKDQLFDOGHYLFHVKDYHORZHUUDWHRIKDHPRUUKDJH
DQGPRUWDOLW\WKDQXVLQJPLFURZLUHDQGPLFURFDWKHWHU
%
0HFKDQLFDOWKURPEHFWRP\ZLWKWKHWUHYRVWHQWGHYLFHLQSUR[LPDO
LQWUDFUDQLDODUWHULDORFFOXVLRQV
00$&9DQ6DQWHQ9DQ'RRUQ59DQ'HQ%HUJ%9DQ'HU.DOOHQ
*/$1LMHKROW:9DQ=ZDP59DQ2RVWHQEUXJJH$9DQ'HU/XJW
<5RRV&%/00DMRLH$PVWHUGDP1/'HQ+DDJ1/0DDVWULFKW1/
5RWWHUGDP1/
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHVDIHW\DQGHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIDVHOIH[SDQGLQJDQGIXOO\
UHWULHYDEOH VWHQW 7UHYR &RQFHQWULF 0HGLFDO ,QF 0RXQWDLQ 9LHZ &$ 86$ LQ
UHYDVFXODULVDWLRQRISDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3URVSHFWLYHPXOWLFHQWUHFDVHVHULHVRISDWLHQWV PHDQ
DJH<0) ZLWKDQDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNHFDXVHGE\SUR[LPDOLQWUDFUDQLDO
DUWHULDORFFOXVLRQWUHDWHGZLWKDIXOO\UHWULHYDEOHVWHQWZLWKLQWKHÀUVWKRXUVIURP
V\PSWRPRQVHW PHGLDQ1DWLRQDO,QVWLWXWHVRI+HDOWK6WURNH6FDOH>UDQJH
@ 7KURPEHFWRP\ZDVXVHGDVUHVFXHWKHUDS\LQSDWLHQWVZKRZHUHUHIUDFWRU\
WRKDGFRQWUDLQGLFDWLRQVIRURUZHUHWRRODWHIRU,9UW3$7KHRFFOXVLRQVLWHZDVWKH
0&$LQWHUPLQXV,&$LQFHUYLFDO,&$0&$LQDQGEDVLODUDUWHU\LQSDWLHQWV
&RPSOLFDWLRQVUHODWHGWRWKHSURFHGXUHDQGRXWFRPHDWPRQWKVZHUHDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV 6WHQW SODFHPHQW ZDV IHDVLEOH LQ DOO SURFHGXUHV DQG VXFFHVVIXO UHFD
QDOLVDWLRQGHÀQHGDVWKURPERVLVLQFHUHEUDOLVFKDHPLD 7,&, JUDGHERUZDV
DFKLHYHG LQ RI WUHDWHG YHVVHOV 7KH PHDQ QXPEHU RI SDVVHV IRU
PD[LPDOUHFDQDOLVDWLRQZDV UDQJH 7KHPHGLDQWLPHIURPJURLQSXQFWXUHWR
UHFDQDOLVDWLRQZDV UDQJH PLQXWHV2QHVLJQLÀFDQWSURFHGXUDOHYHQW
RFFXUUHG FDURWLGDUWHU\RFFOXVLRQDIWHUVWHQWUHPRYDO )RUW\RQHRIDOOSDWLHQWV
KDGDJRRGRXWFRPH P56WR DPRGHUDWHRXWFRPH P56 DQGD
SRRURXWFRPH P56WR
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KHVH UHVXOWV VXJJHVW WKDW ZLWK WKH 7UHYR GHYLFH FORWV FDQ EH
VDIHO\DQGHIIHFWLYHO\UHPRYHGIURPLQWUDFUDQLDOODUJHYHVVHORFFOXVLRQVLQDFXWH
LVFKDHPLFVWURNH
%
&HUHEUDOYDVRVSDVP &9 DIWHUDQHXU\VPDOVXEDUDFKQRLG
KDHPRUUKDJH $6$+ LQWUDDUWHULDOPDQDJHPHQW
(3XJOLHOOL0%DÀOH0)XVFKL9'L(JLGLR00RQLQD7HUDPR,7
HGRSXJ#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVZRUNLVWRHYDOXDWHSUHGLFWRUVRIUHFDQDOLVDWLRQDQG
DIDYRXUDEOHQHXURORJLFDORXWFRPHLQSDWLHQWVZLWK&9DIWHUDFXWH$6$+
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP0D\WR6HSWHPEHUZHHPEROLVHG
DQHXU\VPLQSDWLHQWV DJHUDQJHGIURPWR\HDUVPHDQDJH ZLWK
$6$+XVLQJPHWDOGHWDFKDEOHFRLOVVWHQWLQJLQ RIWKHVHSDWLHQWVZH
UHSRUWFOLQLFDODQGRUDQJLRJUDSKLFVLJQVRI&905$&7DQG'6$KDYHEHHQXVHGWR
HYDOXDWH6$+:HGLVFXVVWKHXVHRIQHXURHQGRYDVFXODUWHFKQLTXHVDQGWKHUHFHQW
DGYDQFHVLQWKHORFDOWKHUDS\RI&9IROORZLQJ$6$+3DWLHQWҋVDJHVH[DHWLRO
RJ\SHUIXVLRQUHFDQDOLVDWLRQDQGV\PSWRPSUHDQGSRVWWUHDWPHQWZLWKPRGLÀHG
5DQNLQ6FDOH P56 ZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJDPXOWLSOHORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV,Q RIWKHSDWLHQWVZHKDYHREVHUYHGUHJXODULVDWLRQRIWKH
QDUURZHGYHVVHOXVLQJORFDOLDLQIXVLRQRISDSDYHULQH FDVHV RUQLPRGLSLQH
FDVHV DWWKHZHHNVFRQWURO,Q SDWLHQWVZHUHSRUWWKHXVHRIORFDO
LDQLPRGLSLQHEHIRUHDQGDIWHUODUJHYHVVHOSHUFXWDQHRXVWUDQVOXPLQDOEDOORRQ
DQJLRSODVW\ 37$ ZLWKUHFDQDOLVDWLRQDIWHUSURFHGXUHDQGLPSURYHPHQWRIFOLQLFDO
FRQGLWLRQDWWKHPRQWKVRIIROORZXS5HFDQDOLVDWLRQIDYRXUHGDEHWWHURXWFRPH
ZLWK D SUH DQG SRVWWUHDWPHQW P56 LPSURYHPHQW DW WR PRQWK IROORZXS
S HVSHFLDOO\LQWKRVHZKRUHFHLYHGHDUO\WUHDWPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ(DUOLHUWUHDWPHQWLVXVXDOO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKEHWWHUSDWLHQWVXUYLYDODQG
RXWFRPHEXWFRQWLQXHGHIIRUWVDUHQHFHVVDU\WRLPSURYHDQGUHÀQHHQGRYDVFXODU
VWUDWHJLHVDVZHOODVGHYHORSQHZWUHDWPHQWPRGDOLWLHV
%
$QJLRJUDSKLFRXWFRPHDIWHUHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRILQWUDFUDQLDO
DQHXU\VPVZLWKWKHVLONÁRZGLYHUWHU
$5LQJHOVWHLQ06FKODPDQQ6*ULFNH&0RHQQLQJKRII,6DQGDOFLRJOX
0)RUVWLQJ,:DQNH(VVHQ'( DGULDQULQJHOVWHLQ#XNHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH:LGHQHFNHGDQGIXVLIRUPDQHXU\VPVDUHWHFKQLFDOO\FKDOOHQJLQJ IRU
(97)'PD\RFFOXGHWKHDQHXU\VPVE\HQGROXPLQDOUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKHSDUHQW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DUWHU\DQGUHGXFLQJWKHEORRGÁRZLQWRWKHDQHXU\VPV7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\
ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHUDWHRILQWHUYHQWLRQDVVRFLDWHGFRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGWKHPLGWHUP
RXWFRPHDIWHU6LONVWHQWLPSODQWDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGSDWLHQWVZLWKXQUXSWXUHG
DQHXU\VPVWUHDWHGZLWK6LON)'EHWZHHQDQG7UHDWPHQWLQGLFD
WLRQVZHUHIXVLIRUPDQHXU\VPVFLUFXPIHUHQWLDODQHXU\VPVDQGJLDQWDQHXU\VPV
SUHVHQWHGZLWKHPEROLFHYHQWVRUDSURJUHVVLYHPDVVHIIHFW
5HVXOWV7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVZDVUHDFKHGLQSDWLHQWV7KUHHDQHXU\VPVZHUH
LPPHGLDWHO\RFFOXGHGRQHRIWKHVHZLWKDGGLWLRQDOFRLOLQJ$OODQHXU\VPVVKRZHG
LPPHGLDWHO\LQÁRZUHGXFWLRQ$IWHUWKUHHPRQWKVRFFOXVLRQZDVREVHUYHGLQDOO
FDVHVH[FHSWRQHDQHXU\VPRIWKH,&$7KHRYHUDOOFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHLQFOXGLQJWHFK
QLFDOWKURPERHPEROLFFRPSOLFDWLRQRULQVWHQWWKURPERVLVZDVRI)'
&OLQLFDORXWFRPHLQSDWLHQWVLQFOXGHGRQHZLWKQRWVHYHUHDQGZLWKVHYHUH
QHXURORJLFDOGHÀFLWV\HDUIROORZXSGLGQRWVKRZDQ\UHSHUIXVLRQRIWKHDQHXU\VP
&RQFOXVLRQ 'HVSLWH D QRW ORZ FRPSOLFDWLRQ UDWH WKH )' WUHDWPHQW RI FRPSOH[
DQHXU\VPVLVHIIHFWLYHZLWKDKLJKRFFOXVLRQUDWHRIWKHDQHXU\VPDOVRLQWKHPLG
WHUPIROORZXS7KHRYHUDOOFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHPD\EHKLJKHUWKDQLQFRQYHQWLRQDO
VWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOLQJEXWZHKDYHWRFRQVLGHUWKDWWKHDQHXU\VPVZHUHGLIÀFXOWWR
WUHDWZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOHQGRYDVFXODUPHWKRGVKDGUHFXUUHGDIWHUSUHYLRXVWUHDW
PHQWVRUVKRZHGDGLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQ
%
&RPSXWDWLRQDOÁXLGG\QDPLFVLQSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKÁRZGLYHUWHU
GHYLFHV
7%DSWLVWD3:DWWRQ(+ROODQG-3HQURVH$&KLDULQL$-%\UQH
-5HLV/LVERQ372[IRUG8.$ELQJGRQ8.&DVDOHFFKLRGL5HQR,7
MWEDSWLVWD#JPDLOFRP
%
6LOHQWLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVDIWHUVWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOLQJ
0/+DKQHPDQQ0+R06FKODPDQQ6*RHULFNH,:DQNH&0RHQLQJKRII
0)RUVWLQJ$5LQJHOVWHLQ(VVHQ'( PDULDKDKQHPDQQ#JP[GH
3XUSRVH 6WHQWDVVLVWHG FRLOLQJ KDV LPSURYHG WKH DELOLW\ WR WUHDW GLIÀFXOW DQG
FRPSOLFDWHGDQHXU\VPV7KHSUHVHQWVWXG\DLPVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHUDWHRIVLOHQW
HPEROLFOHVLRQVDIWHUVWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOLQJDQGWRGHÀQHDVVRFLDWHGSUHGLFWRUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KH VWXG\LQFOXGHV D WRWDO RI SDWLHQWVWUHDWHG ZLWK
VWHQWDVVLVWHG FRLOLQJV ':, 05 LPDJLQJ RI WKH EUDLQ ZDV SHUIRUPHG DIWHU
VWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOLQJWRGHWHFWLQWHUYHQWLRQDVVRFLDWHGVLOHQWLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQV
'HPRJUDSKLFGDWDDQHXU\VPFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGDQJLRJUDSKLFSDUDPHWHUVZHUH
FRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHIUHTXHQF\WKHGLVWULEXWLRQDQGWKHVL]HRIWKHLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV$IWHUVWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOLQJV':,05,DQDO\VHVDIWHULQWHUYHQWLRQ
UHYHDOHGEULJKWOHVLRQVLQDSDWWHUQFRQVLVWHQWZLWKHPEROLFHYHQWVOHVLRQV
ZHUHVPDOOHUWKDQPPLQGLDPHWHUZKHUHDVOHVLRQVZHUHODUJHUWKDQPP
0RUHWKDQWKHKDOIRIWKHWUHDWHGSDWLHQWV GLVSOD\HGHPEROLFHYHQWVZLWKRXW
QHZQHXURORJLFDOGHÀFLW:HSUHVXPHDFRUUHODWLRQRIWKHVHLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVZLWK
WKHGXUDWLRQRIWKHSURFHGXUHDQGZLWKWKHSDWLHQWVDJH)XUWKHUPRUHKLJKHU':,
UDWHVWHQGWRDSSHDULQWKHDQWHULRUEUDLQFLUFXODWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
1HZLVFKDHPLFEUDLQOHVLRQVRQGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,DIWHUFDURWLG
DUWHU\VWHQWLQJZLWKSURWHFWLRQDVLQJOHFHQWUHVWXG\
'$6WRMDQRY0,OLF3%RVQMDNRYLF1LV56 GUVWRMDQRY#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH&DURWLGDUWHU\VWHQWLQJ &$6 ZLWKGLVWDOSURWHFWLRQLVQRZFRQVLGHUHG
DQDOWHUQDWLYHWRFDURWLGHQGDUWHUHFWRP\'HVSLWHFHUHEUDOSURWHFWLRQWKHULVNRI
FHUHEUDOHPEROLVDWLRQVWLOOSHUVLVWGXULQJWKHSURFHGXUH'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
':, LVFRQVLGHUHGWKHPRVWVHQVLWLYHWRROIRUHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIFHUHEUDOLVFKDH
PLD7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHDSSHDUDQFHRIQHZLVFKDHPLF
FHUHEUDOOHVLRQVE\':,DIWHUSURWHFWHG&$6LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHLQWHUQDOFDURWLG
DUWHU\ ,&$ VWHQRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIW\&$6VZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKWKHXVHRIGLVWDOSURWHF
WLRQ0HDQDJHRIWKHSDWLHQWVZDV\HDUVDQGZHUHV\PSWRPDWLF
,QSDWLHQWVSURFHGXUHZDVGRQHRQDQHPHUJHQF\EDVLV$OOSDWLHQWVZHUH
XQVXLWDEOHIRU&$(':,ZDVSHUIRUPHGLPPHGLDWHO\EHIRUH&$6DQGZLWKLQ
KRXUVDIWHUWKHSURFHGXUH
5HVXOWV 7KHUH ZHUH QHZ OHVLRQV LQ SDWLHQWV PHDQ
SHUSDWLHQW ,QRIWKHP WKHUHZHUHVLQJOHOHVLRQVDQGLQ
SDWLHQWV PXOWLSOH OHVLRQV )RXU SDWLHQWV GHYHORSHG LSVLODWHUDO QHZ OH
VLRQVWZRSDWLHQWV GHYHORSHGFRQWUDODWHUDOQHZOHVLRQVDQGRQHSDWLHQW
GHYHORSHGELODWHUDOQHZOHVLRQV3DWLHQWVZLWKÀEUROLSLGSODTXHVKDGD
VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUQXPEHURIQHZOHVLRQVFRPSDUHGWRSDWLHQWVZLWKÀEURFDOFLÀHG
SODTXHV S
&RQFOXVLRQ1HZLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVZHUHREVHUYHGLQRIRXUSDWLHQWV7KHUH
ZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQSODTXHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGWKHDSSHDUDQFHRI
QHZOHVLRQV7KHORZSHUFHQWDJHRIQHZOHVLRQVXJJHVWVWKDW&$6ZLWKSURWHFWLRQ
LVVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUH,&$VWHQRVLV
5RRP%
&DUGLDF
66
&7DQG05,UHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRU\WKPVDQGGRVH
UHGXFWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
.1LNRODRX0XQLFK'(
3.9DQKRHQDFNHU$DOVW%(
%
5HFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKLGHQWLFDOÀOOLQJ 5,) RIWKHKHDUWD
SK\VLRORJLFDODSSURDFKWRLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQFRURQDU\&7
DQJLRJUDSK\
6'5HLQDUW]%6'LHIHQEDFK7$OOPHQGLQJHU&..XKO$+0DKQNHQ
$DFKHQ'((UODQJHQ'( VUHLQDUW]#XNDDFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWKHFRPSDULVRQRILPDJHTXDOLW\LQFRURQDU\
&7DQJLRJUDSK\ F&7$ EHWZHHQURXWLQHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZLWKDXWRPDWHGSKDVH
GHWHFWLRQDQG5HFRQVWUXFWLRQVFRPSXWHGZLWK,GHQWLFDO)LOOLQJRIWKHKHDUW 5,)
7KHWLPLQJLVSURYLGHG5,)IRUPXODZKLFKLVGHGXFWHGIURPFDUGLDFSK\VLRORJ\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP1RYHPEHUXQWLO-XO\SDWLHQWVXQGHU
JRLQJ(&*JDWHG'6&7ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\IRUVXVSHFWHGFRURQDU\KHDUW
GLVHDVH Q RUSODQQLQJRILQWHUYHQWLRQDODRUWLFYDOYHUHSODFHPHQW Q 5,)
IRUPXODDQGWKHPDQXIDFWXUHUVVRIWZDUH %HVW'LDVWROH ZHUHXVHGIRUFDOFXODWLQJ
WKHGDWDVHWV7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVDVVHVVHGLQFRQVHQVXVFRURQDU\DUWHU\VHJPHQWV
DFFRUGLQJWRWKHVHJPHQWV$+$PRGHO,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVVWUDWLÀHGXVLQJD
JUDGH/LNHUWVFDOH&RQWLQXRXVYDULDEOHVZHUHH[SUHVVHGDVPHDQVWDQGDUGGHYLD
WLRQFDWHJRULFDOYDULDEOHVDGGLWLRQDOO\DVIUHTXHQFLHVRUSHUFHQWDJHV'LIIHUHQFHV
LQFDWHJRUFLDOGDWDZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJWKH:LOFR[RQWHVWIRUSDLUHGYDULDEOHV
5HVXOWVPHQDQGZRPHQZLWKDQDYHUDJHDJHRI\HDUVDQG
ZLWKDPHDQKHDUWUDWHRIZHUHH[DPLQHG,QWKH%HVW'LDVWROHJURXS
VHJPHQWVDFKLHYHGGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\FRPSDUHGWRVHJPHQWVLQWKH5,)
JURXS,QFRUUHVSRQGLQJ$+$VHJPHQWV5,)ZDVVXSHULRULQVHJPHQWV
%HVW'LDVWROHVFRUHGKLJKHULQFDVHV ,QWKHDUUK\WKPLFVXEJURXSWKH
PHDQ5,)LPDJHVVFRUHGLQFRPSDULVRQWR%HVW'LDVWROHZLWK
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH)ORZGLYHUWHUGHYLFHVKDYHEHHQGHPRQVWUDWHGWREHRIKLJKHIÀFDF\
LQ WUHDWPHQW RI LQWUDFUDQLDO DQHXU\VPV HVSHFLDOO\ WKRVH ZLWK ZLGH QHFNV 7KLV
SURMHFWDWWHPSWVWRLGHQWLI\LISUHWUHDWPHQWÁRZFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDUHRIDVVLVWDQFHLQ
SUHGLFWLQJZKHWKHUDVSHFLÀFDQHXU\VPLVPRUHSURQHWRWKURPERVHDQGLIDUHWKHUH
DQ\KDHPRG\QDPLFLQGLFHVWKDWFRUUHODWHZLWKWKHUHJLRQVZKLFKWKURPERVHÀUVW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZRFDYHUQRXVDQHXU\VPVZHUHPRGHOOHGIURP'SUH
WUHDWPHQWDQJLRJUDSKLFVWXGLHV3DWLHQWVZHUHWUHDWHGXVLQJÁRZGLYHUWHUGHYLFHV
DQGZHUHIROORZHGRYHUWKHVXEVHTXHQWWRPRQWKVZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
'WLPHRIÁLJKWPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\,PDJHVZHUHVHJPHQWHGXV
LQJ#QHX)XVH76VRIWZDUH#QHX)XVHZDVDOVRXVHGWRYLUWXDOO\GHSOR\D
ÁRZGLYHUWHULQERWKDQHXU\VPV)ORZZLWKZLWKRXWWKHÁRZGLYHUWHUZDVVLPXODWHG
XVLQJ$16<6&);VRIWZDUH
5HVXOWV&RPSXWDWLRQDOÁXLGG\QDPLF &)' DQDO\VLVDQG'DQJLRJUDSKLFIRO
ORZXSVWXGLHVHQDEOHGXVWRREVHUYHWKDWWKURPEXVIRUPDWLRQZLWKLQWKHDQHXU\VP
VDFVLQLWLDWHGLQUHJLRQVRIVLJQLÀFDQWÁRZUHYHUVDOLQGLFDWHGE\KLJK2VFLOODWRU\
6KHDU,QGH[ UHDFKLQJYDOXHVQHDU DQGQHJDWLYHYDOXHVRIPLQLPXPDQHXU\VP
IRUPDWLRQLQGH[ FORVHWR
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKLVVWXG\&)'DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGRQSUHWUHDWPHQWDQHX
U\VPVJHRPHWULHVEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHYLUWXDOGHSOR\PHQWRIDÁRZGLYHUWHUGHYLFH
,WZDVREVHUYHGWKDWWKURPERVLVLVPRUHSURQHWRRFFXULQUHJLRQVRIVLJQLÀFDQW
ÁRZUHYHUVDO:HFRQFOXGHWKDW&)'PD\SURYHXVHIXOLQSUHGLFWLQJZKLFKUHJLRQV
RIDQDQHXU\VPWUHDWHGZLWKDÁRZGLYHUWHUZLOOWKURPERVHÀUVW
&RQFOXVLRQ 6LOHQW HPEROLF HYHQWV DUH PXFK PRUH IUHTXHQW WKDQ WKH DSSDUHQW
QHXURORJLFDO FRPSOLFDWLRQ UDWH DIWHU VWHQWDVVLVWHG FRLOLQJ +RZHYHU LQGLYLGXDO
DQGDQHXU\VPVSHFLÀFSDUDPHWHUVPD\SUHGLFWWKHVDIHW\RIWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQDQG
SUHVXPDEO\WKHVXEVHTXHQWUDWHRIQHXURORJLFDOFRPSOLFDWLRQV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ5,)UHFRQVWUXFWLRQLVVXSHULRUWRVWDQGDUGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQHVSHFLDOO\
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKDWULDOÀEULOODWLRQ)XUWKHUPRUH5,)SURYLGHVDWKHRU\IRUWKHRSWLPDO
LPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQSRLQW
%
&7FRURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLXPVFRULQJDQGLWHUDWLYHLPDJH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHVUHSURGXFLELOLW\DFFXUDF\DQGSRWHQWLDO
IRUUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
$6FKLQGOHU3$SIDOWUHU59OLHJHQWKDUW7$OOPHQGLQJHU
69RJW55DXSDFK)%DPEHUJ.1LNRODRX86FKRHSI
&KDUOHVWRQ6&86)RUFKKHLP'(0DOYHUQ3$86
0XQLFK'( DQGUHDVVFKLQGOHU#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7KHHIIHFWRILWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRQ&7FRURQDU\FDOFLXPVFRULQJ
&&6 KDV QRW EHHQ LQYHVWLJDWHG :H HYDOXDWHG LQYLYR DQG LQYLWUR WKH UHSUR
GXFLELOLW\ RI &&6 DFURVV GLIIHUHQW UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ PHWKRGV DQG WKH SRWHQWLDO IRU
UDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PHQ\UV XQGHU
ZHQW&&6VWXGLHVRQDQGJHQHUDWLRQGXDOVRXUFH&7 '6&7 V\VWHP,QYLWUR
GDWDZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJDPRYLQJDQWKURSRPRUSKLFFDUGLDFSKDQWRPFRQWDLQ
LQJ FDOFLXP LQVHUWV RI GLIIHUHQW VL]HV )XOOGRVH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV ZHUH EDVHG RQ
SURMHFWLRQV IURP ERWK '6&7 WXEHGHWHFWRU FRQÀJXUDWLRQV +DOIGRVH DFTXLVLWLRQ
ZDV VLPXODWHG E\ GLVFDUGLQJ UDZ GDWD IURP RQH WXEH )XOOGRVH DQG KDOIGRVH
VHULHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWKLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQLPDJHVSDFH ,5,6 DQG
VLQRJUDPDIÀUPHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 6$),5( XVLQJGHGLFDWHG&&6NHUQHOV
&DOFLXPZDVPHDVXUHGXVLQJDFRQYHQWLRQDO&&6DSSOLFDWLRQDQGFRPSDUHGZLWK
WUDGLWLRQDOÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 VHULHVE\:LOFR[RQ0DQQ:KLWQH\WHVWLQJ
5HVXOWV1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQRYHUDOO&&6ZHUHIRXQGEHWZHHQIXOOGRVH
)%3,5,6DQG6$),5( PHDQ&&6 WKWKSHUFHQWLOH >@YV>@
DQG>@S! 7KHPHDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVP6Y'LIIHUHQFHV
LQRYHUDOO&&6EHWZHHQIXOOGRVH)%3KDOIGRVH,5,6 >@ DQGKDOIGRVH
6$),5( >@ ZHUH DOVR QRW VLJQLÀFDQW S! ,Q WZR SDWLHQWV ZLWK D
&&6RI]HUREDVHGRQ)%3WKH&&6EHFDPHSRVLWLYHRQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
/LNHZLVHLQYLWURWKHVPDOOHVW PP LQVHUWZDVUHFRJQL]HGDVFDOFLXPRQO\RQ
LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQEXWQRWRQ)%3
&RQFOXVLRQ 2YHUDOO &&6 REWDLQHG E\ )%3 DQG LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ DUH
FRPSDUDEOHHYHQLIWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHLVUHGXFHGE\/LNHO\WKURXJKQRLVH
VXSSUHVVLRQ LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ PD\ HQDEOH GHWHFWLRQ RI VPDOOHU FDOFLXP
GHSRVLWVDQGWKXVRIHDUOLHUFRURQDU\DWKHURVFOHURVLV
%
+RZGLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRIWKJHQHUDWLRQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
LQÁXHQFHLPDJHTXDOLW\LQORZGRVHFDUGLDF&7
3.URHSLO+'1DJHO$+%LJGHOL3+HXVFK56/DQ]PDQ
*3HQWDQJ*$QWRFK0&RKQHQ'VVHOGRUI'(%XFKKRO]'(
1HXVV'( 3DWULF.URHSLO#PHGXQLGXHVVHOGRUIGH
3XUSRVH7R LQYHVWLJDWH HIIHFWV RI DQ DGYDQFHG WK JHQHUDWLRQ LWHUDWLYH UHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQ ,5 WHFKQLTXHRQVXEMHFWLYHDQGREMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ ,4 LQORZGRVH
FDUGLDF&7$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LYHGDWDVHWVRISURVSHFWLYHO\WULJJHUHGFRURQDU\&7$LQ
´VWHSDQGVKRRWµPRGHZHUHDFTXLUHGRQDVOLFH&7VFDQQHUZLWKRSWLPLVHG
H[SRVXUHVHWWLQJV(DFKGDWDVHWZDVSURFHVVHGWLPHVUHVXOWLQJLQQ LPDJH
VWDFNV'DWDZHUHSURFHVVHGRQDSURWRW\SH,5V\VWHPXVLQJÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHF
WLRQ )%3 DQGOHYHOVRIDQDGYDQFHG,5WHFKQLTXH ,'RVH3KLOLSV SURYLGLQJ
LQFUHPHQWDOUDWHRI,5 OHYHO LQYROYLQJERWKUDZDQGLPDJHGDWDVSDFH,PDJH
QRLVHZDVPHDVXUHGLQWKHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGDVFHQGLQJDRUWD&RQWUDVWWRQRLVH
DQGVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRV &15615 ZHUHFRPSDUHGDWFRURQDU\ORFDWLRQVLQ
DOOLPDJHVWDFNV6XEMHFWLYH,4ZDVUDWHGRQDSRLQWVFDOHZLWK´QDWXUDOµLPDJH
DSSHDUDQFHDQGQRLVHUHODWHGDUWHIDFWVDVPDLQFULWHULD
5HVXOWV0HDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHRIFDUGLDF&7$ZDVP6Y0HDQ&15DQG615
ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGZLWK,5ZKHQFRPSDUHGWR)%3DQGZLWKHYHU\LQFUHDV
LQJOHYHORI,5 UDQJH&15UDQJH615S ZLWKEHVW
REMHFWLYH,4DWKLJKHVWOHYHORI,5 ,'RVHOHYHO 6XEMHFWLYH,4KRZHYHUZDVUDWHG
EHVWDWPHGLXPOHYHORI,5 ,'RVHOHYHO ZLWKIHZHUDUWHIDFWVZKHQFRPSDUHG
WR)%3DQGPRUHQDWXUDOLPDJHDSSHDUDQFHFRPSDUHGWRKLJKHUOHYHOVRI,5
&RQFOXVLRQ2EMHFWLYH,4 &15615 LPSURYHVZLWKLQFUHDVLQJOHYHORI,5LQORZ
GRVHFDUGLDF&7$%HVWVXEMHFWLYH,4KRZHYHULVUHDFKHGDWPHGLXPOHYHOVRI,5
ZLWKPLQLPDODUWHIDFWVDQG´QDWXUDOµLPDJHDSSHDUDQFH
%
,WHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ,5 LPSURYHVLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLF
FRQÀGHQFHRI&7GHOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQWLPDJLQJIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRI
P\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
$5RVVL0YDQ6WUDWHQ$'KDUDPSDO5%RRLM%5XVVR
76SULQJHOLQJ5-YDQ*HXQV$:HXVWLQN*3.UHVWLQ5RWWHUGDP1/
DURVVL#HUDVPXVPFQO
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH HIIHFW RI LWHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ,5 RQ &7 LPDJH
TXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHRIP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQGHWHFWLRQRQGHOD\HG
HQKDQFHPHQWVFDQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKSULRUKLVWRU\RIP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUF
WLRQZHUHHQUROOHGLQWKHVWXG\3URVSHFWLYHO\WULJJHUHG&7GHOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQW
LPDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGHLJKWPLQXWHVDIWHU&7FRURQD\DQJLRJUDSK\XVLQJGXDO
VRXUFH &7 VFDQQHU 6FDQV ZHUH UHFRQVWUXFWHG XVLQJ ÀOWHUHG EDFN SURMHFWLRQ
)%3 ZLWKDVPRRWKPHGLXPNHUQHO % DQG6LQRJUDP$IÀUPHG,5 6$),5(
6LHPHQV+HDOWKFDUH DWVWUHQJWKDQGZLWKNHUQHO,DQG,6LJQDO
DQGQRLVHZHUHPHDVXUHGLQWKHGHVFHQGLQJDRUWD$WWHQXDWLRQZLWKLQWKHLQIDUFWHG
P\RFDUGLXPZDVPHDVXUHGDQGWKHFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 ZDVFDOFXODWHG
7ZREOLQGHGUHDGHUVJUDGHGWKHLPDJHVLQWHUPVRILPDJHTXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLF
FRQÀGHQFHLQLQIDUFWLRQGHWHFWLRQXVLQJDIRXUSRLQWVFDOH SRRUDQGH[FHOOHQW
05GHOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQWZDVXVHGIRUFRPSDULVRQ
5HVXOWV,QFRPSDULVRQZLWK)%3WKHXVHRI,5 VWUHQJWK UHVXOWHGLQDVLJ
QLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQRILPDJHQRLVHRIIRU,DQGIRU, S
,QFUHDVLQJWKHVWUHQJWKWRDIXUWKHUGHFUHDVHRIQRLVHZDVREVHUYHG
IRU , DQG IRU , S $Q HTXLYDOHQW LQFUHDVH RI &15 IURP
% WR , DQG , ZDVDOVRREVHUYHG
S 7KHRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGWKHGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHVLJQLÀFDQWO\
LPSURYHGXVLQJ,5
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRI,5UHGXFHVLPDJHQRLVHLPSURYLQJ&15RIWKHLQIDUFWHG
P\RFDUGLXPWKXVSURYLGLQJEHWWHULPDJHTXDOLW\DQGKDYLQJWKHSRWHQWLDOWRGH
FUHDVHUDGLDWLRQGRVH
%
7KHHIIHFWRILWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRQFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
FRURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLXPVFRUH
0&:LOOLDPV1::HLU18UHQ*0F.LOORS'(1HZE\-+5HLG
(GLQEXUJK8. PLFKHOOHZLOOLDPV#HGDFXN
3XUSRVH ,WHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ HQDEOHV WKH UHGXFWLRQ RI UDGLDWLRQ GRVH ZLWK
PDLQWDLQHG LPDJH TXDOLW\ LQ FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ &7 :H DLPHG WR DVVHVV
WKHHIIHFWRILWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRQWKHFDOFXODWLRQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLXP
VFRUH &$&6
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QHKXQGUHGSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWHOHFWURFDUGLRJUDPJDWHG
&7FRURQDU\FDOFLXPVFDQVDVSDUWRIWKH6&27+($57VWXG\XVLQJDPXOWL
GHWHFWRUVFDQQHU7XEHYROWDJHZDVN9DQGWXEHFXUUHQWZDVVHOHFWHGEDVHG
RQERG\PDVVLQGH[,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJVWDQGDUGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
DQGDQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKP $,'5 %RWK$JDWVWRQVFRUHDQGFDOFLXP
YROXPHZHUHFDOFXODWHG7KHHVWLPDWHGSHUFHQWLOHIRUDSDUWLFXODU&$&6EDVHGRQ
DJHVH[DQGHWKQLFLW\ZDVFDOFXODWHGXVLQJWKH0(6$&$&6UHIHUHQFHYDOXHV
5HVXOWV7KLUW\VHYHQSDWLHQWVKDGDFDOFLXPVFRUHRI]HURDQGZHUHH[FOXGHGIURP
IXUWKHUDQDO\VLV7KHUHZDVDVPDOOEXWVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQPHGLDQ$JDWVWRQ
VFRUHDQGFDOFLXPYROXPHEHWZHHQVWDQGDUGDQGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV YV
SDQGYVSUHVSHFWLYHO\ ,PDJHQRLVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
UHGXFHGZLWKLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ +8 &,WR YV+8 WR
S 7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQHVWLPDWHGSHUFHQWLOHZLWK
LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ YVS
&RQFOXVLRQ,WHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQUHGXFHVLPDJHQRLVHLQ&7FRURQDU\FDOFLXP
VFDQV 7KH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI$,'5 FRXOG OHDG WR VLJQLÀFDQW UHGXFWLRQ LQ UDGLDWLRQ
GRVH7KHDEVROXWHYDOXHVRIERWK$JDWVWRQVFRUHDQGFDOFLXPYROXPHDUHVOLJKWO\
UHGXFHGXVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ+RZHYHUWKHHVWLPDWHGSHUFHQWLOHIRUWKH
LQGLYLGXDOSDWLHQWLVQRWDOWHUHG
%
&RURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\FRPSDULVRQRIDQRYHOLWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQZLWKÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQIRUUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRI
ORZGRVH&7
5$37DN[86FKRHSI-:1DQFH$0RVFDULHOOR0'DV
&)LQN7+HQ]OHU0DDVWULFKW1/&KDUOHVWRQ6&865RPH,7
0DQQKHLP'( UWDN[#VWXGHQWPDDVWULFKWXQLYHUVLW\QO
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHLPDJHQRLVHEHWZHHQDQRYHOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJR
ULWKP 6$),5( DQGWUDGLWLRQDOÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHQW\ FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW FRURQDU\ &7
DQJLRJUDPV F&7$ XVLQJS(&*GXDOBVWHSVFDQSURWRFRODVFDQPRGHWKDWDSSOLHV
IXOOUDGLDWLRQDWDQDGMXVWDEOHOLPLWHGSKDVHRIWKHFDUGLDFF\FOHZKLOHORZUDGLDWLRQ
WXEHFXUUHQW LVSHUIRUPHGRYHURIWKHFDUGLDFF\FOH7KHLPDJHVZHUH
UHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWKUHJXODU)%3DWIXOOGRVH *URXSD DQGORZGRVH *URXSE
DQGZLWK6$),5(ZLWKLWHUDWLRQVDWORZGRVH *URXS 7KUHHUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW
52, ZHUHHYDOXDWHGIRUVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LPDJHQRLVHVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615
DQGFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 6XEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGRQD
SRLQWVFDOHEDVHGXSRQLPDJHVKDUSQHVVDQGQRLVH
5HVXOWV2EMHFWLYHLPDJHQRLVHZDVUHGXFHGE\ 3 RQDYHUDJH
LQ*URXSFRPSDUHGWR*URXSE7KHUHZDVDOVRDVLJQLÀFDQW 3 LP
SURYHPHQWLQRYHUDOOVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\LQ*URXSFRPSDUHGWR*URXSD
&RQFOXVLRQ,WHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQHQDEOHGVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQLQLPDJHQRLVH
ZLWKRXWORVVLQVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGKROGVSRWHQWLDOWRLPSURYHLPDJHTXDO
LW\LQORZGRVHIXQFWLRQDOF&7$DQGSRVVLEO\UHGXFHUDGLDWLRQGRVHHYHQIXUWKHU
%
6WHQRVLVTXDQWLÀFDWLRQXVLQJGLIIHUHQWN9DSKDQWRPVWXG\
FRPSDULQJYROXPH&7WRPLFUR&7
$8UVDQL+0HKUH]-%OREHO+.DVKDQL163DXO7RURQWR21&$
0DUNKDP21&$1HXVV'( DOLXUVDQL#XKQRQFD
%
$UDQGRPLVHGVWXG\WRWHVWWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIVOLFH
GXDOVRXUFH&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKYDULRXVKHDUW
UDWHVXVLQJORZGRVHVFDQSURWRFROV
$5RVVL/$1HHIMHV$6'KDUDPSDO$&:HXVWLQN*3.UHVWLQ.1LHPDQ
3-GH)H\WHU150ROOHW5RWWHUGDP1/ DOH[LDURVVL#DOLFHSRVWDLW
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI&7FRURQDU\
DQJLRJUDSK\ &7&$ SURWRFROVXVLQJDVOLFHGXDOVRXUFH&7VFDQQHU 6LHPHQV
DSURVSHFWLYHKLJKSLWFKVSLUDO +36 DSURVSHFWLYHVWHSDQGVKRRW 6$6 DQGD
UHWURVSHFWLYH 56 VFDQSURWRFRO
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H SURVSHFWLYHO\ LQFOXGHG V\PSWRPDWLF SDWLHQWV
ZLWKDUHJXODUKHDUWUDWH +5 3DWLHQWVZLWKDSUHVFDQ+5ESP JURXS$
SDWLHQWVPHQPHDQ+5ESP ZHUHUDQGRPLVHGWRKDYHD+36RU
6$6 VFDQZLQGRZRIWKH55LQWHUYDO VFDQ3DWLHQWVZLWKDSUHVFDQ+5
ESP JURXS%SDWLHQWVPHQPHDQ+5ESP ZHUHUDQGRPLVHG
WRKDYHD6$6 VFDQZLQGRZ RU56VFDQ SXOVLQJZLQGRZ 7KH
SUHVHQFHRIDVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLVZDVDVVHVVHG VHJPHQWOHYHO DQGFRPSDUHG
ZLWKTXDQWLWDWLYHFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
5HVXOWV *URXS$ VHQVLWLYLW\ ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU XVLQJ +36 WKDQ XVLQJ WKH
6$6SURWRFRO YVS 6SHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339
DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 ZHUHVLPLODU7KHHVWLPDWHGUDGLDWLRQGRVH
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUZLWKWKH+36WKDQZLWKWKH6$6SURWRFRO YV
P6YS *URXS%VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\339DQG139ZHUHQRW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&RPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7&$ UDGLDWLRQ
GRVHDV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZRIWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUV
0&:LOOLDPV'60DFODFKODQ60LUVDGUDHH'(1HZE\1::HLU
(GLQEXUJK8. PLFKHOOHZLOOLDPV#HGDFXN
3XUSRVH7LVVXHZHLJKWLQJIDFWRUVXVHGWRFDOFXODWHHIIHFWLYHGRVH ( ZHUHXS
GDWHGE\,&53LQ5HFHQWZRUNVXJJHVWVWKDWGXHWRWKHLQFUHDVHGZHLJKWLQJ
IDFWRUIRUEUHDVWWLVVXHFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUVVKRXOGEHLQFUHDVHGZKHQFDOFXODWLQJ
(IURPGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW '/3 LQ&7&$:HDLPHGWRDVVHVVWKHDSSOLFDWLRQ
RIFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUVLQ&7&$OLWHUDWXUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3HHUUHYLHZHGDUWLFOHVRQ&7&$LQ(QJOLVKRUZLWKDQ
DYDLODEOH WUDQVODWLRQ ZHUH LGHQWLÀHG RQ 0('/,1( XVLQJ DQ RQOLQH VHDUFK WRRO
3XE0HG $UWLFOHV ZHUH LQFOXGHG LI WKH\ FRPPHQWHG RQ UDGLDWLRQ GRVH LQ WLWOH
RUDEVWUDFW5HYLHZVHGLWRULDOVSKDQWRPDQGSDHGLDWULFVWXGLHVZHUHH[FOXGHG
%HWZHHQDQG6HSWHPEHUWKHUHZHUHVXLWDEOHSDSHUV
5HVXOWV&RQYHUVLRQIDFWRUZDVQRWVWDWHGLQSDSHUV ZLWKRIWKHVH
EHLQJSXEOLVKHGLQWKHÀUVWKDOIRI7KHUHLVDQRQVLJQLÀFDQWWUHQGWRZDUGV
SUHVHQWLQJ '/3 DQG FRQYHUVLRQ IDFWRUV LQ DEVWUDFWV YV
S DQG YV S UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KH PRVW IUHTXHQW
FRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUVDUH DQG +RZHYHUWKHXVHRI
LVGHFUHDVLQJ YV DQGLVLQFUHDVLQJ YV
S 7KHXVHRIVFDQQHUVSHFLÀFFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUVKDVUHFHQWO\
HPHUJHGEXWFXUUHQWO\DFFRXQWVIRURQO\RISDSHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRIWKHORZHUFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRULVLQFUHDVLQJGHVSLWH
WKHFKDQJHLQ,&53UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV$VLJQLÀFDQWSURSRUWLRQRIFXUUHQWOLWHUDWXUH
GRHVQRWUHSRUWWKHFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUPDNLQJLWLPSRVVLEOHWRFRPSDUHUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHVEHWZHHQVWXGLHV
5RRP&
1HXUR
66E
)XQFWLRQDO05,UHVWLQJVWDWHDQG'7,
0RGHUDWRUV
1%DUJDOOy%DUFHORQD(6
06PLWV5RWWHUGDP1/
%
7DUJHWPDSLQGLYLGXDOLVDWLRQIRUWKDODPXVQHXURVXUJHU\SRVVLEOH
DSSOLFDWLRQVRIGLIIXVLRQWHQVRUWUDFWRJUDSK\DQGVWDWLVWLFDOVKDSHPRGHOV
$-DNDE5%ODQF$0RUHO(/%HUHQ\L*6]HNHO\=XULFK&+
'HEUHFHQ+8 MDNDED#PHGXQLGHEKX
3XUSRVH1HXURVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQVRIWKHWKDODPXVUHO\RQWUDQVIHUULQJVWHUH
RWDFWLF'FRRUGLQDWHVIURPDQDQDWRPLFDODWODVRQWRWKHSDWLHQWҋV05EUDLQLPDJHV
:HDLPHGWRGHYHORSDVRIWZDUHDSSOLFDWLRQIRUWKDODPXVWDUJHWPDSLQGLYLGXDOLVD
WLRQWKDWIXVHVLQIRUPDWLRQIURPSDWLHQWVSHFLÀFWKDODPXVJHRPHWU\DQGGLIIXVLRQ
WHQVRUWUDFWRJUDSK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3UHYLRXVO\RXUZRUNJURXSGHYHORSHGDWKDODPXVDWODV
E\IXVLQJDQDWRPLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQIURPKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURFHVVHGWKDODPL7KHDWODV
ZDVWUDQVIHUUHGWRDVWDQGDUGQHXURLPDJLQJVSDFHDQG'7,VFDQVRIKHDOWK\
VXEMHFWVZHUHDFFHVVHGWKDODPRFRUWLFDOFRQQHFWLYLW\PDSVZHUHJHQHUDWHGXVLQJ
DSUHYLRXVO\GHVFULEHGSURFHGXUH9LVLEOHRXWOLQHVDQGFRQQHFWLYLW\EDVHGLQWHUQDO
ODQGPDUNVZHUHLQFRUSRUDWHGLQDVWDWLVWLFDOVKDSHPRGHOUHVSHFWLQJWKHLQKHUHQW
YDULDELOLW\RIWKHLQGLYLGXDOH[DPSOHV7KLVLQIRUPDWLRQZDVXVHGWRGHIRUPWKHDWODV
WRLQGLYLGXDOLPDJHV3RVWPRUWHP05,VFDQVZHUHXVHGWRTXDQWLI\WKHJHRPHWULF
DFFXUDF\RIQXFOHLSUHGLFWLRQV
5HVXOWV5HOLDEOHWUDFWRJUDSK\EDVHGPDUNHUVZHUHORFDWHGLQWKHYHQWURODWHUDO
WKDODPXVZLWKWKHVRPDWRVHQVRU\FRQQHFWLRQVFRLQFLGLQJZLWKWKH93/DDQG93/S
QXFOHLDQGPRWRUSUHPRWRUFRQQHFWLRQVZLWK9/SDQG9/DQXFOHLWKHXQFHUWDLQLW\
RIORFDOLVDWLRQZDVOHVVWKDQPP7KHHUURURISUHGLFWLQJJHRPHWU\H[SUHVVHGLQ
VXUIDFHWRVXUIDFHGLVWDQFHVZDVPPIRUWKHYLVLEOHWKDODPXVRXWOLQHVDQG
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH LPSDFW RI LQVWHQRVLV FRQWUDVW RQ DFFXUDWH OXPHQ
DVVHVVPHQW LQ FDOFLÀHG FRURQDU\ SODTXHV FRPSDULQJ WZR KLJKUHVROXWLRQ &7 D
SKDQWRPVWXG\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$ [ FP VWDWLF FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ SKDQWRP ZLWK WLV
VXHHTXLYDOHQW +8 PDWHULDOFRQWDLQHGYHVVHOVRIPP * DQGPP
* GLDPHWHUHDFK&LUFXPIHUHQWLDOOXPHQVWHQRVLVDQG
ZHUHFUHDWHGXVLQJPJFF+\GUR[\DSDWLWH +$ 7KHOXPHQFRQWDLQHGGLOXWHG
LRGLQDWHGFRQWUDVWPJPO 9LVLSDTXH UHDFKLQJ+8&7VFDQVSHUIRUPHG
XVLQJP 0LFUR&7P&7 DQGP 9ROXPH&7Y&7 VSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQZLWK
PPVOLFHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDWDQGN9S9DULHGWXEHFXUUHQWPDLQWDLQHG
LPDJHQRLVHRI+87KHPD[LPXP+8YDOXHRIWKHSODTXHDQGWKHPLQLPXP
YDOXHRIWKHYHVVHOOXPHQZHUHPHDVXUHGE\LQOLQHKLVWRJUDP +8 DQGFRQWUDVW
&>+8@ ZDVFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV &RQWUDVW +8 IRU Y&7P&7 DW N9 LQ * & &
&&DQG*&&
&&
&RQWUDVW +8 IRUY&7P&7DWN9LQ*&&
&&DQG*&&&
&
Y&7VKRZHGKLJKHUPHDQFRQWUDVWFRPSDUHGZLWKP&7IRUVWHQRVLV
SDLUHGWWHVWS (
&RQFOXVLRQ Y&7 UHOLDEO\ YLVXDOLVHV OXPHQ VWHQRVLV LQ DQG PP
DUWHULHVDQGVWHQRVLVLQPPDUWHULHVP&7YLVXDOLVHVOXPHQVWHQRVLV
LQPPYHVVHOV)RUOXPHQVWHQRVLVY&7FRQWUDVWLVKLJKHUWKDQ
P&7WKLVFDSDELOLW\SURPLVHVVXSHULRUSRWHQWLDOIRUGHWHFWLRQRIFRURQDU\SODTXH
FRPSRVLWLRQLQFOXGLQJGXDOHQHUJ\WHFKQLTXHV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWXVLQJD6$6RU56SURWRFRO7KHHVWLPDWHGUDGLDWLRQGRVH
ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU ZLWK WKH 6$6 WKDQ ZLWK WKH 56 SURWRFRO YV
P6YS
&RQFOXVLRQ$ VWHSDQGVKRRW &7&$ VFDQ SURWRFRO LV WKH SUHIHUUHG SURWRFRO LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKUHJXODUKHDUWUDWHVXVLQJVOLFHGXDOVRXUFH&7SURYLGLQJRSWLPDO
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ZLWKDQ´DVORZDVUHDVRQDEO\DFKLHYDEOHµUDGLDWLRQGRVH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
YDULHGIURPWRPPGHSHQGLQJRQWKHLQIRUPDWLRQXWLOLVHGGXULQJSUHGLFWLRQV
HJFRQQHFWLYLW\EDVHGODQGPDUNVRUWKDODPXVRXWOLQHV
&RQFOXVLRQ3UHYLRXVVWXGLHVKDYHDOUHDG\DSSOLHG'7,WRWKHWKDODPXV$VDIXU
WKHUVWHSLQWKLVGLUHFWLRQZHGHPRQVWUDWHDK\EULGDSSURDFKXVLQJVWDWLVWLFDOVKDSH
PRGHOVWKDWKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRFRSHZLWKYDULDWLRQVLQLQGLYLGXDOWKDODPXVJHRPHWU\
%
'7,WUDFWVSHFLÀFHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHFRUSXVFDOORVXPLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
GLDJQRVHGV\VWHPLFOXSXVHU\WKHPDWRVXV
33RGJRUVNL$=LPQ\36]HZF]\N-%ODGRZVND06]P\UND.DF]PDUHN
06DVLDGHN:URFODZ3/ SSRGJRUVNL#RQHWSO
3XUSRVH$VVHVVPHQWRIWKHSRWHQWLDOZKLWHPDWWHUGDPDJHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKGLDJ
QRVHGV\VWHPLFOXSXVHU\WKHPDWRVXV 6/( XVLQJGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ '7,
DQGWUDFWVSHFLÀFPRUSKRPHWU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\RQHSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\UV ZLWKGLDJQRVHG
6/(DQGQRUPDODSSHDULQJEUDLQLQFRQYHQWLRQDO05,ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\
7KHVWXG\DOVRLQFOXGHGDFRQWUROJURXSFRPSRVHGRIDJHDQGVH[PDWFKHG
KHDOWK\ YROXQWHHUV$OO VXEMHFWV XQGHUZHQW FRQYHQWLRQDO EUDLQ 05, ZLWK W\SLFDO
SURWRFROFRQVLVWLQJRI77)/$,5DQG':,LPDJHVSHUIRUPHGRQD705
VFDQQHU$OOVXEMHFWVDOVRXQGHUZHQW'7,H[DPLQDWLRQZLWKWKHIROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUV
GLIIXVLRQGLUHFWLRQVE VPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVVPPQRJDS 2EWDLQHG
'7,LPDJHVZHUHSUHSURFHVVHGE\DSSO\LQJSDUDPHWHUDIÀQHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQ
XVLQJ$L5 KWWSELVKRSZORQLXFODHGX DQG WKHQ DQDO\VHG LQ 'WL6WXGLR KWWSV
ZZZPULVWXGLRRUJ 0XOWLSOH52,DSSURDFKZDVDSSOLHGWRVHOHFWJHQXVSOHQLXP
DQGHQWLUHFRUSXVFDOORVXPWUDFWV2EWDLQHGPLQLPDOPD[LPDODQGPHDQYDOXHV
RIIUDFWLRQDODQLVRWURS\ )$ ZHUHWKHQFRPSDUHGLQSDWLHQWVDQGFRQWUROVE\XVLQJ
0DQQ:KLWQH\8DQGWWHVW
5HVXOWV&RPSDUHGWRFRQWUROV6/(SDWLHQWVVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S ORZHU
PHDQ)$YDOXHVZLWKLQJHQXDQGVSOHQLXPWUDFWVRIWKHFRUSXVFDOORVXP)$PHDQ
YDOXHVZLWKLQHQWLUHFRUSXVFDOORVXPVKRZHGORZHUYDOXHVLQ6/(SDWLHQWVFRPSDUHG
WRWKHFRQWUROJURXSEXWGLGQRWUHDFKWKHVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ7UDFWVSHFLÀF'7,VWXG\VKRZHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQRI)$
YDOXHLQWKHFRUSXVFDOORVXPVXJJHVWLQJZKLWHPDWWHUGDPDJHLQSDWLHQWVZLWK6/(
%
1HZQRQOLQHDUFRORXUORRNXSWDEOHWRYLVXDOLVHIUDFWLRQDO
DQLVRWURS\FKDQJHVGHPRQVWUDWHGRQPXOWLSOHV\VWHPDWURSK\
-.HOOHU$05XOVHK$.RPDUHN,/DWQHURYD55XVLQD.=DUXERYD
+%UR]RYD-9\PD]DO3UDJXH&= MLULNHOOHU#KRPRONDF]
3XUSRVH7RIDFLOLWDWHWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIIUDFWLRQDODQLVRWURS\ )$ LQGDLO\FOLQLFDO
SUDFWLFHE\GHÀQLQJDQHZQRQOLQHDUFRORUORRNXSWDEOH /87
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)$ZDVFDOFXODWHGIRUKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV DJH
\HDUV6'UDQJH7PPLVRWURSLFYR[HOPRWLRQSURELQJJUDGLHQWV
03* $VXEVHWRIVXEMHFWVZDVDGGLWLRQDOO\VFDQQHGXVLQJ03*)$LQ
WKHFRUSXVFDOORVXPIURQWDOJUH\PDWWHUWKDODPXVDQGLQWKHEDVDOJDQJOLDZDV
PHDVXUHGDQGDQDO\VHGXVLQJWKHUDQGRPLQWHUFHSWOLQHDUPL[HGPRGHOWRFDOFXODWH
WKHSRSXODWLRQPHDQVDQGSUHGLFWLRQLQWHUYDOVZKLFKZHUHXVHGWRFUHDWH
D QRQOLQHDU FRORXU /87 8QLTXH FRORXUV ZHUH DVVLJQHG WR LQÁHFWLRQ SRLQWV DQG
FRQWLQXRXVUDPSVZHUHJHQHUDWHGWRFUHDWHDFRORXUWUDQVLWLRQEHWZHHQWKHP7KH
/87ZDVDSSOLHGWRJURXSVRISDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHV\VWHPDWURSK\ 06$ DQG
PDWFKLQJYROXQWHHUV)RXUEOLQGHGUDGLRORJLVWVFODVVLÀHGVXEMHFWVDVQRUPV06$
7KLUWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWK3DUNLQVRQGLVHDVHZHUHWKHQDGGHGWRDQRQ\PLVHGFRKRUW
5HVXOWV7KH/87JHQHUDWHGIURP03*GDWDLVFRPSDUDEOHZLWKWKDWIURP
03*DQGSURYLGHVVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ06$VXEMHFWV
IURPKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV06$SDWLHQWVFDQEHVHSDUDWHGIURPSDUNLQVRQLDQVDQG
QRUPVZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ2XU/87EDVHGRQWKHQRUPDWLYHGDWDFDQDFFHQWXDWHDEQRUPDO)$
YDOXHVDVZHOODVDQDWRP\7KHUDGLRORJLVWFDQGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQ06$DQGQRUPV
MXVWXVLQJ/87LQIRUPDWLRQ7KHQHZ/87FDQEHSRWHQWLDOO\XVHIXODVDVFUHHQLQJ
PHWKRGIRURWKHUQHXURORJLFDOGLVRUGHUV6XSSRUWHGE\JUDQWV,*$17
16060DQG060
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIWKHGHJUDGDWLRQRIWKHVHOHFWHGSURMHFWLOH
FRPPLVVXUDODQGDVVRFLDWLRQZKLWHPDWWHUWUDFWVLQDV\PSWRPDWLF
+,9SRVLWLYHQRQWUHDWHG+,9SRVLWLYH+$$57WUHDWHGDQG+,9+&9
SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWVXVLQJGLIIXVLRQWHQVRU05LPDJLQJ
-%ODGRZVND$.ROWRZVND36]HZF]\N$=LPQ\%+HQGULFK%.Q\V]
06DVLDGHN:URFODZ3/ PEODGRZ#ZSSO
3XUSRVH+,9LQIHFWLRQPD\DIIHFWFHUHEUDOZKLWHPDWWHU7KHDLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDV
WRHYDOXDWHWKHVHOHFWHGZKLWHPDWWHUWUDFWVLQDV\PSWRPDWLF+,9SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWV
XVLQJGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ '7,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\HLJKW+,9SRVLWLYHDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV+,9
SRVLWLYH QRQWUHDWHG PHDQ DJH \UV +,9SRVLWLYH +$$57WUHDWHG PHDQ
DJH \UV +,9+&9SRVLWLYH PHDQ DJH \UV DQG QRUPDO FRQWURO
VXEMHFW PHDQDJH\UV ZHUHHQUROOHGLQWKHVWXG\'7,H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUH
SHUIRUPHGRQ705VFDQQHU)UDFWLRQDODQLVRWURS\ )$ DQGDYHUDJHGLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQW DYHUDJH'& YDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHGZLWKDVPDOO52,PHWKRGLQPLGGOH
FHUHEHOODUSHGXQFOHV 0&3 LQIHULRUORQJLWXGLQDOIDVFLFXOL ,/) LQIHULRUIURQWRRF
FLSLWDOIDVFLFXOL ,)2) JHQX *&& DQGVSOHQLXP 6&& RIWKHFRUSXVFDOORVXP
SRVWHULRUOLPEVRIWKHLQWHUQDOFDSVXOHV 3/,& VXSHULRUORQJLWXGLQDOIDVFLFXOL 6/)
DQGSRVWHULRUFLQJXOD &*
5HVXOWV6LJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHRI)$ S FRPSDUHGWRWKHQRUPDOVXEMHFWV
ZDVIRXQGLQDOO+,9SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWVLQWKHOHIW0&3ERWK,/)ERWK,)2)*&&
6&&DQGERWK6/)ZKLOHWKHUHZHUHQRVXFKGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHULJKW0&3DQG
ERWK&*6LJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQVRI)$LQERWK3/,&ZHUHREVHUYHGRQO\LQ+,9
SRVLWLYH +$$57WUHDWHG SDWLHQWV S 6LJQLÀFDQW LQFUHDVH RI DYHUDJH '&
S ZDVIRXQGRQO\LQ*&&DQGULJKW6/)LQ+,9SRVLWLYHQRQWUHDWHGDQG
+,9+&9SRVLWLYHVXEMHFWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH)$YDOXHFRXOGEHDQRQLQYDVLYHQHXURLPDJLQJELRPDUNHUIRUDV
VHVVLQJWKHPLFURVWUXFWXUDOFKDQJHVZLWKLQWKHZKLWHPDWWHUWUDFWVLQDV\PSWRPDWLF
+,9SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWV+,9SRVLWLYH+$$57WUHDWHGSDWLHQWVVHHPWRSUHVHQWWKH
PRVWVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHV
%
3DVVLYHUDQJHRIPRWLRQIXQFWLRQDO05,SDUDGLJPVDUHXVHIXOLQWKH
SUHVXUJLFDOZRUNXSRIFKLOGKRRGHSLOHSVLHV
/5.R]DN0+HJ\L3%DUVL*5XGDV%XGDSHVW+8 ONR]DN#PUNNVRWHKX
3XUSRVH3HUIRUPLQJSUHVXUJLFDOIXQFWLRQDO05, I05, LQHSLOHSWLFFKLOGUHQSRVHV
FKDOOHQJHVGXHWRWKHUHODWLYHO\\RXQJDJHRIWKHSDWLHQWVDQGRUWKHLUSRVVLEOH
PHQWDO UHWDUGDWLRQ RU SDUHVLV 3DVVLYH UDQJHRIPRWLRQ 5R0 SDUDGLJPV ZHUH
VXJJHVWHGIRUVHQVRU\PRWRUFRUWH[PDSSLQJLQWKLVSRSXODWLRQDVWKHVHSDUDGLJPV
GR QRW UHTXLUH SDWLHQW FRRSHUDWLRQ 5HWURVSHFWLYH DQDO\VLV RI RXU SDVVLYH 5R0
H[DPLQDWLRQVLVSUHVHQWHGWRHYDOXDWHWKHXWLOLW\RIWKHPHWKRGLQWKHSDHGLDWULF
HSLOHSV\SRSXODWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHI05,H[DPLQDWLRQVRIVHYHQFKLOGUHQ PHDQDJH
\UVUDQJHER\VFDVHVRIFRUWLFDOG\VJHQHVLVRIWXPRXUDQG
RISRUHQFHSKDOLFF\VWV SHUIRUPHGDW7 3KLOLSV$FKLHYD73KLOLSV+HDOWKFDUH
%HVW7KH1HWKHUODQGV LQRXULQVWLWXWHLVUHYLHZHG)RXUSDWLHQWVZHUHVFDQQHG
LQLQWUDYHQRXVSURSRIROVHGDWLRQXVLQJSDVVLYH5R0RQHRIWKHPZDVVFDQQHG
ZLWKRXW VHGDWLRQ DV ZHOO7KH UHPDLQLQJ WKUHH SDWLHQWV ZHUH H[DPLQHG ZLWKRXW
VHGDWLRQERWKZLWKDFWLYHDQGSDVVLYH5R0SDUDGLJPV
5HVXOWV:HZHUHDEOHWRFOHDUO\LGHQWLI\WKHPDLQVHQVRU\PRWRUIRFLLQDOOFDVHV
0RUHRYHUZHFRXOGVKRZYDULDEOHDPRXQWRIIXQFWLRQDOUHRUJDQL]DWLRQWRWKHKHDOWK\
KHPLVSKHUHLQWKUHHFDVHV1HYHUWKHOHVVWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIDFWLYDWLRQVREWDLQHG
ZLWKDQGZLWKRXWVHGDWLRQDQGZLWKSDVVLYHDQGDFWLYH5R0GLIIHUHGWRVRPHH[WHQW
DQGLQRQHFDVHRQJRLQJHSLOHSWLFDFWLYLW\LQWHUIHUHGZLWKI05,
&RQFOXVLRQ 3DVVLYH 5R0 I05, SDUDGLJPV DUH XVHIXO IRU WKH HYDOXDWLRQ RI
VHQVRU\PRWRUFRUWH[LQSDHGLDWULFHSLOHSV\SDWLHQWV0RUHRYHURXUUHVXOWVVKRZ
WKDWWKHVHSDUDGLJPVDUHDEOHWRGHVFULEHFRUWLFDOUHRUJDQLVDWLRQWKXVWKH\KDYH
FOHDUSURJQRVWLFYDOXHLQDSUHRSHUDWLYHVHWWLQJ
%
)05,VWXG\RIVPHOOSHUFHSWXDOFRJQLWLYHDQGVHPDQWLFFRPSRQHQW
RIFRUWLFDOHODERUDWLRQRIIRXUIDPLOLDUDURPDV
/5RPROL08NPDU)&DVDJUDQGH01DFFDUDWR3%DWWDJOLQL0&RYD
7ULHVWH,7 PDMDXNPDU#DOLFHLW
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHFKDQJHVLQFRUWLFDODFWLYDWLRQGXULQJWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
RIIRXUIDPLOLDUDURPDV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVYROXQWHHUVKDYHEHHQHQUROOHGLQWKHVWXG\$OOWKH
H[DPLQDWLRQVKDYHEHHQSHUIRUPHGRQD7PDJQHWXVLQJDQI05,(3,VHTXHQFH
757( VOLFHV G\QDPLFV VHVVLRQ GXUDWLRQ PLQ )RXU
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
VWLPXOLZHUHFKRVHQFLWUXVIUXLWFKRFRODWHFRIIHHÁRZHUSOXVQHXWUDORQH DLU
7KHH[SHULPHQWFRQVLVWHGRIVHVVLRQVDQGHDFKVHVVLRQFRQVLVWHGRIWULDOV
VWLPXODWLRQVIRUHDFKDURPDDQGIRUSXUHDLU 7LPLQJDPRXQWDQGRUGHURI
SUHVHQWDWLRQ ZHUH FRQWUROOHG E\ DQ 05, FRPSDWLEOH ROIDFWRPHU 7KH GDWD ZHUH
DQDO\VHG XVLQJ 630 SDFNDJH 7KH DQDO\VLV ZHUH FRQGXFWHG IRU HDFK DURPD
FRPSDUHGWRWKHQHXWUDOGXULQJWKHWLPLQJLQZKLFKWKHVXEMHFWVUHFHLYHGWKHDURPD
DQGWKHIHZVHFRQGVLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHU
5HVXOWV(DFKDURPDVHHPVWRVWLPXODWHGLIIHUHQWFHUHEUDOUHJLRQV,QSDUWLFXODU
FLWUXVLVFKDUDFWHULVHGE\WKHSHUFHSWXDODVSHFWHVSHFLDOO\YLVXDO %$ELODWHU
DOO\ FKRFRODWHLQYROYHVPDLQO\WKHFLQJXODWHDQGIURQWDOFRUWH[FRIIHHVHHPVWR
EHWKHPRVWUHFRJQLVDEOHRGRU RUELWDOJ\UXVPHGLDOFLQJXODWHGFRUWH[OHIWLQIHULRU
IURQWDOJ\UXV ÁRZHUVHHPVWREHWKHPRVWGLIÀFXOWVWLPXOXVWRUHFRJQLVHDQGGH
VFULEHLQYROYLQJDUHDVLPSOLFDWHGLQWKHUHFROOHFWLRQRIDXWRELRJUDSKLFDOPHPRU\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\VKRZVWKDWRGRXUVFDQDIIHFWDYDULHW\RISHUFHSWXDOPRWRU
DQGFRJQLWLYHIXQFWLRQV7KHHYDOXDWLRQRIROIDFWRU\V\VWHPLQRUGHUWRGHPRQVWUDWH
ROIDFWRU\G\VIXQFWLRQFRXOGEHXVHWRDVVHVVWKHSRVVLEOHULVNRIGHYHORSLQJQHX
URGHJHQHUDWLYHGLVRUGHUVLQKHDOWK\LQGLYLGXDOV
%
)XQFWLRQDO05,IRUQHXURVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQSODQQLQJ
UHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIH[DPLQDWLRQVSHUIRUPHGZLWKRXU
VWDQGDUGLVHGODQJXDJHWDVNSDQHO
/5.R]DN$6]DER97RWK&%RUEHO\3%DUVL*5XGDV%XGDSHVW+8
ONR]DN#PUNNVRWHKX
%
9LVXDOLVLQJKLSSRFDPSDO%2/'DFWLYLW\LQKXPDQVDWDQG7HVOD
17KH\VRKQ64LQ60DGHUZDOG%$3RVHU-07KH\VRKQ0(/DGG
(5*L]HZVNL*)HUQDQGH],7HQGRONDU(VVHQ'(1LMPHJHQ1/
*LHVVHQ'( QLQDWKH\VRKQ#XNHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH+LJKÀHOGVWUHQJWKIXQFWLRQDO05,KDVGHYHORSHGUDSLGO\GXHWRLWVDG
YDQWDJHVVXFKDVLQFUHDVLQJ615DQG%2/'FRQWUDVW1HYHUWKHOHVVLWVXIIHUVIURP
DUWHIDFWVLQEUDLQUHJLRQVFORVHWRWLVVXHDLUERXQGDULHVVXFKDVWKHPHGLRWHPSRUDO
OREH 07/ 7KHVHGHÀFLWVKDYHFKDOOHQJHGIXQFWLRQDOLPDJLQJRIWKHKLSSRFDPSXV
WKRXJKRSWLPLVHGKLJKUHVROXWLRQLPDJLQJLVSDUWLFXODUO\XVHIXOIRUWKLVUHJLRQERWK
IURPDFOLQLFDODQGFRJQLWLYHQHXURVFLHQFHSHUVSHFWLYH7KHUHIRUHZHVHWRXWWR
YLVXDOLVH07/DFWLYLW\GXULQJDQDVVRFLDWLYHPHPRU\HQFRGLQJWDVNDWDQGWHVOD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVZHUHH[DPLQHGHLWKHUZLWK7RU
ZLWK 7 ZKLOH SHUIRUPLQJ D EORFNHGGHVLJQ IDFHSURIHVVLRQDO QDPH DVVRFLDWLYH
PHPRU\HQFRGLQJWDVNDQGDYLVXDOPRWRUMXGJPHQWDVFRQWUROFRQGLWLRQ:KROH
EUDLQ(3,LPDJHVZHUHDFTXLUHG7DQG7GDWDZHUHFRPSDUHGDQGDQDO\VHG
ZLWK630
5HVXOWV(3,LPDJHVDW7ZHUHRIKLJKTXDOLW\VKRZLQJDJRRGZKLWHJUH\PDWWHU
FRQWUDVW6LJQDOGURSRXWVDQGDUWHIDFWVDWWKHORZHU07/ZHUHDFFHSWDEOHDW7
$VVHVVLQJWKHPHPRU\UHODWHGQHXUDODFWLYLW\LQERWKJURXSVWKHUHVXOWVUHYHDOHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
$FXWHHIIHFWVRIPRGDÀQLORQFRJQLWLRQDQGEUDLQUHVWLQJVWDWH
QHWZRUNDFWLYLW\LQ\RXQJKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV
5(VSRVLWR)&LOOL93LHUDPLFR$)HUUHWWL$0DFFKLD$6DJJLQR$7DUWDUR
*5RPDQL6/6HQVL&KLHWL,7 UHVSRVLWR#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7KHUH LV JURZLQJ GHEDWH RQ WKH XVH RI GUXJV WKDW SURPRWH FRJQLWLYH
HQKDQFHPHQW0RVWRIWKHFRJQLWLYHHQKDQFLQJGUXJVLQFOXGLQJDPSKHWDPLQHOLNH
GUXJVKDYHLPSRUWDQWVLGHHIIHFWVDQGVKRZWKHULVNRIDGGLFWLRQ:HLQYHVWLJDWHG
WKHXVHRIPRGDÀQLODGUXJDSSURYHGIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRIQDUFROHSV\WKDWPD\DOVR
DFWDVDFRJQLWLYHHQKDQFHUDQGDSSHDUVWRKDYHIHZHUVLGHHIIHFWVFRPSDUHGWR
RWKHUSV\FKRVWLPXODQWV7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUPRGDÀQLO
FDQLQÁXHQFHWKHFRJQLWLYHSHUIRUPDQFHDVZHOODVWKHEUDLQUHVWLQJVWDWHQHWZRUN
DFWLYLW\RIKHDOWK\\RXQJVXEMHFWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVVXEMHFWVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQDGRXEOHEOLQGSODFHER
FRQWUROOHGVWXG\LQZKLFKDVLQJOHGRVH PJ RI0RGDÀQLOZDVDGPLQLVWHUHG
%RWKJURXSVZHUHWHVWHGEHIRUHDQGWKUHHKRXUVDIWHUWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIPRGDÀQLO
RUSODFHERIRUWKHLUQHXURSV\FKRORJLFDOSHUIRUPDQFHVE\HPSOR\LQJWKH5DYHQҋV
SURJUHVVLYHPDWULFHVDQGWKH7ULDOPDNLQJWHVW:LWKI05,DOVRDIWHUWKUHHKRXUVZH
VWXGLHGWKHDFWLYLW\RIUHVWLQJVWDWHEUDLQQHWZRUNV)LQDOO\GLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ
'7, ZDVDOVRSHUIRUPHGYLDWUDFWEDVHGVSDWLDOVWDWLVWLFV 7%66
5HVXOWV2XUUHVXOWVLQGLFDWHWKDWDVLQJOHDFXWHGRVHRIPRGDÀQLOLPSURYHVÁXLG
LQWHOOLJHQFHZKLOH%2/'I05,GDWDVKRZWKDWWKHGUXJLQFUHDVHVWKHDFWLYDWLRQRI
WKHIURQWDOSDULHWDOFRQWURO )3& V\VWHPDQGRIH[WUDVWULDWHYLVXDOQHWZRUNV1R
FKDQJHVZHUHREVHUYHGDVIDUDVDQDWRPLFDOFRQQHFWLYLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ 7DNHQ WRJHWKHU RXU ÀQGLQJV VXSSRUW WKH LGHD WKDW PRGDÀQLO FDQ
LQFUHDVHFRJQLWLYHSHUIRUPDQFHPRGXODWHWKHDFWLYLW\RIUHVWLQJVWDWHQHWZRUNV
DQGEHDQHIIHFWLYHFRJQLWLYHHQKDQFHU
5RRP'
&KHVW
66
$LUZD\GLVHDVHV
0RGHUDWRUV
,+DUWPDQQ5RWWHUGDP1/
1-6FUHDWRQ&DPEULGJH8.
%
&DQ&7KHOSUHFRJQLVHDOLQNEHWZHHQOHIWDWULDOYROXPHLPSDFWLQJ
OHIWYHQWULFXODUSUHORDGDQGWKHVHYHULW\RIHPSK\VHPD"
/&DVVDJQHV($OJHUL-%)DLYUH76DQWDQJHOR-5HP\05pP\-DUGLQ
/LOOH)5 OXFLHFDVVDJQHV#DOLFHDGVOIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHOHIWDWULDO /$ YROXPHLQVPRNHUVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHVHYHULW\
RIHPSK\VHPDDQGWRWDOOXQJYROXPH 7/9
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHVPRNHUVIUHHRIFOLQLFDOFDUGLRYDVFXODU
GLVHDVH XQGHUZHQW D KLJKSLWFK DQG KLJKWHPSRUDO UHVROXWLRQ &7 DQJLRJUDSKLF
H[DPLQDWLRQRIWKHFKHVWZLWKGXDOVRXUFHVLQJOHHQHUJ\&7HQDEOLQJTXDQWLÀFD
WLRQRIHPSK\VHPDOXQJYROXPHVDQG/$YROXPHPHDVXUHPHQWVQRUPDOLVHGWR
ERG\VXUIDFHDUHD
5HVXOWV7KH&7SKHQRW\SHVRIWKHVWXGLHGSRSXODWLRQZHUHDVIROORZVHPSK\VH
PDSUHGRPLQDQW *URXSQ DLUZD\SUHGRPLQDQW *URXSQ DPL[HG
SDWWHUQRIHPSK\VHPDDQGDLUZD\VGLVHDVH JURXSQ DQGDEVHQFHRI&7
DEQRUPDOLWLHV JURXSQ $QHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHLQ
GH[HG/$YROXPHDQGWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIHPSK\VHPD D LQWKHRYHUDOOVWXG\JURXS
S U E LQJURXS S U DQG F LQJURXSVDQG
ZKHQDQDO\VHGWRJHWKHU S U ,QJURXSZHIRXQGDQHJDWLYH
FRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHLQGH[HG/$YROXPHDQGWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIHPSK\VHPD
LQWKHULJKWXSSHUDQGULJKWPLGGOHOREHV S U $QHJDWLYHFRUUHOD
WLRQZDVDOVRIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHLQGH[HG/$YROXPHDQG7/9LQWKHRYHUDOOVWXG\
JURXS S U DQGLQJURXS S U ZKLOHQRFRUUHODWLRQV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH)XQFWLRQDO05, I05, JDLQHGLPSRUWDQFHLQWKHQHXURVXUJLFDODVVHVV
PHQWRIEUDLQWXPRXUDQGHSLOHSV\SDWLHQWVGHVSLWHWKHRQJRLQJGHEDWHUHJDUGLQJLWV
FOLQLFDOXVHIXOQHVV$UHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIRXUSUHVXUJLFDOODQJXDJHPDSSLQJ
SURWRFROLVSUHVHQWHG
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %ORRGR[\JHQDWLRQ OHYHOGHSHQGHQW I05, ZLWK SLFWXUH
QDPLQJV\QRQ\PGHFLVLRQVSHHFKFRPSUHKHQVLRQDQGDXGLWRU\ZRUGQRQZRUG
GHFLVLRQWDVNVZDVDQDO\VHGIURPVHVVLRQVRIHSLOHSV\DQGEUDLQWXPRXU
SDWLHQWV IHPDOHVOHVLRQVQHDUHORTXHQWDUHDV XVLQJ6306SDWLDOQRU
PDOLVDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKWKHOHVLRQVPDVNHGIRUDQDO\VLQJDOOSDWLHQWVLQD
FRPPRQIUDPHZRUN)LUVWDQGVHFRQGOHYHOUHVXOWVDQGSUREDELOLVWLFPDSVZHUH
FDOFXODWHGIURPJHQHUDOOLQHDUPRGHOÀWV/DWHUDOLVDWLRQLQGLFHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRU
%URFD:HUQLFNHDQGZKROHKHPLVSKHUHUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52,V LQWKUHVKROG
LQGHSHQGHQWDQGWKUHVKROGHGPDQQHUV
5HVXOWV7KHSDUDGLJPVSUREHGGLIIHUHQWDVSHFWVRIODQJXDJHSURFHVVLQJWKHUH
IRUHWKHLUSHUFHLYHGGLIÀFXOW\DQGPDSSLQJSHUIRUPDQFHYDULHGDFURVVVXEMHFWV
*HQHUDOO\SLFWXUHQDPLQJUHVXOWHGLQZLGHVSUHDGELODWHUDODFWLYDWLRQVQRWUHVWULFWHG
WRFRUHODQJXDJHDUHDVZKLOHV\QRQ\PWDVNZDVWKHPRVWODWHUDOLVHGLQWKH%URFD
DQG:HUQLFNHUHJLRQV$XGLWRU\WDVNVVKRZHGWKHH[SHFWHGSUHIHUHQFHIRUWHPSRUDO
VWUXFWXUHVDQGWKH:HUQLFNHDUHD/DWHUDOLVDWLRQGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWDWWKH
JURXSOHYHO S$129$IRUIDFWRUVSDUDGLJPDQG52, EXWODWHUDOLVDWLRQLQ
GLFHVZHUHKLJKO\ U S FRUUHODWHGUHJDUGOHVVRI52,DQGSDUDGLJP
&RQFOXVLRQ'XHWRLQGLYLGXDOGLIIHUHQFHVWKHUHLVQRVLQJOH´EHVWµSDUDGLJPIRU
ODQJXDJHPDSSLQJWKXVSHUIRUPLQJPRUHWDVNVHQKDQFHVDFFXUDF\1HYHUWKHOHVV
SHUIRUPLQJWKHV\QRQ\PDQGWKHZRUGQRQZRUGWDVNVHHPVVXIÀFLHQWIRUGHWHUPLQ
LQJODQJXDJHODWHUDOLVDWLRQLQPRVWFDVHVLIWLPHDYDLODELOLW\LVOLPLWHG
UREXVW IXQFWLRQDO DFWLYDWLRQV LQ WKH ELODWHUDO 07/ DW ERWK ÀHOG VWUHQJWKV DQG D
VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUKLSSRFDPSDO%2/'VHQVLWLYLW\DW7
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDVVRFLDWLYHPHPRU\HQFRGLQJWDVNUHVXOWHGLQUREXVWIXQFWLRQDO
DFWLYLW\LQWKH07/DWERWKÀHOGVWUHQJWKVDQGKLJKHU%2/'VHQVLWLYLW\LQKLSSRFDPSDO
VWUXFWXUHVDW77KHVHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVZLOOEHXVHGIRUIXUWKHUKLJKUHVROXWLRQ
UHJLRQRILQWHUHVWDQDO\VLVFRQFHQWUDWLQJRQWKHKLSSRFDPSDOVXEVWUXFWXUHVLWVUROH
LQPHPRU\HQFRGLQJDQGLQ07/GLVRUGHUV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ZHUHIRXQGLQ*URXS S U DQGJURXS S U QRUZKHQ
JDWKHULQJSDWLHQWVIURPJURXSVDQG S U
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH /$ YROXPH LPSDFWLQJ OHIW YHQWULFXODU SUHORDG LV VLJQLÀFDQWO\
UHGXFHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHHPSK\VHPD
%
.U\SWRQYHQWLODWLRQLPDJLQJXVLQJGXDOHQHUJ\&7LQ&23'SDWLHQWV
LQLWLDOH[SHULHQFH
$/+DFKXOOD6.KXQJ/:HPHDX-)&D]DXERQ-5HP\
05pP\-DUGLQ/LOOH)5 DQQHOLVHKDFKXOOD#FKUXOLOOHIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHOHYHORIOXQJHQKDQFHPHQWDFKLHYDEOHDIWHULQKDODWLRQRI
VWDEOHNU\SWRQZKRVHDWRPLFQXPEHU DQGODFNRIDQDHVWKHWLFSURSHUWLHVPDNH
LWHOLJLEOHIRUYHQWLODWLRQLPDJLQJXVLQJGXDOHQHUJ\&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHHPSK\VHPDWRXVOHVLRQVZHUH
LQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\DLPHGDWFRPSDULQJWKHOHYHORIDWWHQXDWLRQZLWKLQQRUPDO
OXQJ SUHVXPHGWREHQRUPDOO\YHQWLODWHG ZLWKWKDWRIHPSK\VHPD SUHVXPHGWREH
SRRUO\RUQRWYHQWLODWHG DIWHULQKDODWLRQRIDPL[WXUHRINU\SWRQ DQGR[\JHQ
7KH\XQGHUZHQWDGXDOVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\FKHVW&7H[DPLQDWLRQZLWKUHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQRIGLDJQRVWLFDQGYHQWLODWLRQLPDJHV7KHVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVGHÀQHG
RQWKHIROORZLQJDVVXPSWLRQWKHOHYHORIDWWHQXDWLRQZLWKLQWKHHPSK\VHPDWRXV
OXQJZDVH[SHFWHGWREHUHGXFHGLQFRPSDULVRQWRWKHOHYHORIDWWHQXDWLRQZLWKLQ
WKHQRUPDOOXQJZKHQSUHVHQWWKLVUHVXOWZDVGHÀQHGDVD´VXFFHVVµ
5HVXOWV$OOVWXGLHVZHUHVXFFHVVIXOO\SHUIRUPHGZLWKRXWDGYHUVHHIIHFWV$QDO\
VLVRIYHQWLODWLRQLPDJHVVKRZHGGLIIHUHQFHVLQOXQJDWWHQXDWLRQEHWZHHQQRUPDO
OXQJDQGHPSK\VHPDWRXVDUHDVLQSDWLHQWV &, >@
WKXV GHPRQVWUDWLQJ WKH IHDVLELOLW\ RI OXQJ YHQWLODWLRQ ZLWK NU\SWRQ7KH PD[LPDO
OHYHORIDWWHQXDWLRQZLWKLQQRUPDOOXQJZDV+8.U\SWRQDWWHQXDWLRQGLIIHU
HQFHEHWZHHQQRUPDODQGHPSK\VHPDWRXVOXQJZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWZLWK
DPHGLDQYDOXHRI S 7KHPHDQ 6' '/3YDOXHRIWKLVSURWRFRO
ZDVP*\FP
&RQFOXVLRQ'XDOHQHUJ\&7RIWKHOXQJVDIWHULQKDODWLRQRIVWDEOHNU\SWRQZDV
IRXQGWREHWHFKQLFDOO\IHDVLEOHDQGZHOOWROHUDWHGE\DOOSDWLHQWV
%
$JHQRPHZLGHDVVRFLDWLRQVWXG\RI&23'ZLWKOXQJYROXPHWU\DQG
DLUZD\PHDVXUHPHQWXVLQJ0'&7
/.</HH..LP-/HH(.DQJ<2K%-H-&KRR$QVDQ.5
*XUR.5$QDP.5 P\QHWP\QHW#GDXPQHW
3XUSRVH 7KH UDWLR RI IRUFHG H[SLUDWRU\ YROXPH LQ RQH VHFRQG WR IRUFHG YLWDO
FDSDFLW\ )(9)9& LVDPHDVXUHXVHGWRGLDJQRVHDLUÁRZREVWUXFWLRQDQGLV
KLJKO\KHULWDEOH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRLQYHVWLJDWHJHQHWLFDVVRFLDWLRQRI613V
VLQJOHQXFOHRWLGHSRO\PRUSKLVP LQ&23'JHQHVIRUDVVRFLDWLRQZLWK'&7OXQJ
YROXPHDQGDLUZD\PHDVXUHPHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HKDYHWKH*:$6UHVXOWVIRUSDUWLFLSDQWVIRU
OXQJ IXQFWLRQUHODWHG JHQHV )$0$ 613V VLQJOH QXFOHRWLGH SRO\PRUSKLVP
RQFKURPRVRPHLQFOXGLQJUVZHUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWK)(9)9&YDOXH
2QWKH'0'&7LPDJHVWKHVRIWZDUHVHPLDXWRPDWLFDOO\FDOFXODWHVWRWDOOXQJ
YROXPH 7/9 DQGHPSK\VHPDYROXPH (9 HPSK\VHPDSHUFHQWDJH (3 PHDQ
OXQJGHQVLW\ 0/' LQFOXGLQJEURQFKLDOZDOODUHD :$ :HZLOOFRPSDUHWKH&7
SDUDPHWHUVEHWZHHQPLQRU 77&$ DQGPDMRU &&7* DOOHOHV:HGLG&7VFDQV
WDUJHWLQJDGXOWV DJHG\HDUV UHSUHVHQWDWLYHRI7DQG&DOOHOHVIRUWKH
DFTXLVLWLRQRI7/9(90/'DQGEURQFKLDO:$
5HVXOWV7KHVXEMHFWVZLWK7DOOHOHKDGVLJQLÀFDQWO\VPDOOHUHPSK\VHPDYROXPH
DQGHPSK\VHPDYROXPHWKDQWKRVHZLWK&DOOHOH+RZHYHUWRWDOOXQJYROXPH
PHDQOXQJGHQVLW\DQGEURQFKLDO:$VKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ
VXEMHFWVZLWK7DQG&DOOHOH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVXEMHFWVZLWK7DOOHOHZHUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKHPSK\VHPDYROXPH
DQGHPSK\VHPDYROXPH7KLVPLJKWEHLPSRUWDQWLPSOLFDWLRQFRQFHUQLQJWKH
SUHYHQWLRQRIFKURQLFOXQJIXQFWLRQLPSDLUPHQWFDXVHGE\LQWHUYHQWLRQVGLUHFWHGDW
ULVNIDFWRUVVXFKDVRQJRLQJ&23'VPRNLQJLQIHFWLRQDQGVRFLRHFRQRPLFIDFWRUV
%
7KHSHUIRUPDQFHRI&7VHYHULW\VFRUHVGHWHUPLQHGIURPSDLUHG
H[SLUDWRU\LQVSLUDWRU\KLJKUHVROXWLRQ&7LQSUHGLFWLQJWKHVHYHULW\RI
DLUÁRZREVWUXFWLRQ
76XZDWDQDSRQJFKHG33RUQVXUL\DVDN:6XNNDVHP65DWWDQDVLUL
%DQJNRN7+ UDWUVSRRP#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRI&7VHYHULW\VFRUHVIURPSDLUHGH[SLUDWRU\
LQVSLUDWRU\KLJKUHVROXWLRQ&7 +5&7 LQSUHGLFWLQJWKHVHYHULW\RIDLUÁRZREVWUXF
WLRQ $)2
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DVVHVVHGSDLUHGH[SLUDWRU\LQVSLUDWRU\
+5&7VFDQVRISDWLHQWV PHQDQGZRPHQPHDQDJH 6'
\HDUV KDYLQJ$)2IURPSXOPRQDU\IXQFWLRQWHVWLQJDWWKHVL[FKRVHQOHYHOV LH
ÀYHYHVVHOVDRUWLFDUFKWUDFKHDOFDULQDFPEHORZWKHULJKWEURQFKXVLQWHUPHGLXV
RULJLQULJKWLQIHULRUSXOPRQDU\YHLQDQGFPEHORZWKHULJKWKHPLGLDSKUDJPGRPH
7KHVHYHULW\JUDGLQJRIH[SLUDWRU\DLUWUDSSLQJ $7 EURQFKLDOZDOOWKLFNHQLQJ
DQG EURQFKLDO GLODWDWLRQ PXOWLSOLHG E\ LWV H[WHQW , ,,
,,,DQG,9 RILQYROYHPHQWZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDV$7EURQFKLDOZDOO
WKLFNHQLQJDQGEURQFKLDOGLODWDWLRQVFRUHVUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHVXPVRIDOOVFRUHV
ZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDV$7%UVFRUHV5HFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLV
ZDVDSSOLHGWRDVVHVVWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRI$7DQG$7%UVFRUHVLQGLVFULPLQDWLQJ
SDWLHQWVZLWKPLOG$)2 )(9SUHGLFWHG IURPWKRVHZLWKPRGHUDWHWRVHYHUH
$)2 )(9SUHGLFWHG
5HVXOWV7KHDUHDVXQGHU52&FXUYHVRI$7DQG$7%UVFRUHVZHUH &,
DQG &, UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHFXWRIIYDOXHVRI$7DQG
$7%UVFRUHVRIDQGKDGDSRZHUWRGLVFULPLQDWHSDWLHQWVZLWKPLOG$)2
IURPWKRVHZLWKPRGHUDWHWRVHYHUH$)2ZLWKDVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQG
DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH$7DQG$7%UVFRUHVGHWHUPLQHGE\RXUPHWKRGVKDGWKHDELOLW\
WRSUHGLFWWKHVHYHULW\RI$)2LQPRVWFDVHV
%
5HSURGXFLELOLW\RIDXWRPDWLFDLUZD\PHDVXUHPHQWVZLWK
PXOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7 LQLQVSLUDWRU\DQG
H[SLUDWRU\VFDQV
0$PDWR$/DULFL$GHO&LHOOR('HYLFLHQWL*&RUER69DOHQWH/%RQRPR
5RPH,7 PLFKHOHDPDWR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH6RIWZDUHIRUSRVWSURFHVVLQJ0'&7LPDJHVDOORZWRREWDLQDXWRPDWLF
PHDVXUHPHQWRIDLUZD\SDUDPHWHUVXQWLOWKHÀIWKEURQFKLDOJHQHUDWLRQ$LPRIWKH
VWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHLQWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\RIDLUZD\PHDVXUH
PHQWVXVLQJDQDXWRPDWHGFRPPHUFLDOVRIWZDUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\SDWLHQWVZLWKIXQFWLRQDOGLDJQRVLVRIFKURQLFREVWUXF
WLYHGLVHDVH PDOHVIHPDOHVDJHUDQJH\HDUV ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\
LQFOXGHG$OO WKH SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW WZR FRQVHFXWLYH URZV &7 VFDQV RI WKH
FKHVW VOLFHWKLFNQHVVLQWHUYDOPPSLWFK DWIXOOLQVSLUDWLRQDQGDWWKH
HQGRIIRUFHGH[SLUDWLRQUHVSHFWLYHO\'DWDVHWVZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWO\DQDO\VHGE\
WZRFKHVWUDGLRORJLVWVLQWZRGLVWLQFWVHVVLRQV GD\VDSDUW XVLQJDQDXWRPDWHG
FRPPHUFLDOVRIWZDUHIRUWKHDLUZD\VDQDO\VLV /XQJ9&$5*(+HDOWKFDUH 2S
HUDWRUVUHSRUWHGIRUERWKDFTXLVLWLRQVWKHYDOXHVRIOXPHQDUHD /$ DXWRPDWLFDOO\
FDOFXODWHGRQD[LDOLPDJHVUHIRUPDWWHGDORQJWKHSHUSHQGLFXODUD[LVRIWKHDLUZD\
IURPWKHOREDU VHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ WRWKHVXEVHJPHQWDOEURQFKL ÀIWKJHQHUDWLRQ
7KH LQWHU DQG LQWUDRSHUDWRU GLIIHUHQFHV ZHUH H[SUHVVHG DV SHUFHQWDJHV RYHU
PHDQV %ODQG$OWPDQ 0HDQYDOXHVRIGLIIHUHQFHV у DQGVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQV
6' ZHUHDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV $XWRPDWLF PHDVXUHPHQWV RI /$ KDV VKRZQ KLJK UHSURGXFLELOLW\
PHDQ6' RQ ERWK LQVSLUDWRU\ DQG H[SLUDWRU\ VFDQV )RU /$ ZH REVHUYHG
уLQWHULQVS6'уLQWHULQVS уLQWUDLQVS6'уLQWUDLQVS
уLQWHUH[S6'уLQWHUH[S уLQWUD
H[S6'уLQWUDH[S
&RQFOXVLRQ$XWRPDWLFPHDVXUHPHQWRIOXPHQDUHDRQ0'&7GHPRQVWUDWHGKLJK
LQWHUDQGLQWUDRSHUDWRUUHSURGXFLELOLW\LQERWKLQVSLUDWRU\DQGH[SLUDWRU\VFDQV
7KXVLWKDVWKHSRWHQWLDORIEHLQJXVHGDVDFRPSOHPHQWDU\WRROLQWKHDVVHVVPHQW
RIREVWUXFWLYHDLUZD\VGLVHDVH
%
$XWRPDWLFDLUZD\DQDO\VLVRQ0'&7LQF\VWLFÀEURVLVFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKSXOPRQDU\IXQFWLRQWHVWLQJ
02:LHOSXHW]03XGHUEDFK0(LFKLQJHU2:HLQKHLPHU6/H\
0$0DOO$%LVFKRII+8.DXF]RU&3+HXVVHO+HLGHOEHUJ'(
0DLQ]'( PDUNZLHOSXHW]#ZHEGH
3XUSRVH6RIWZDUHWRROVDOORZIRUTXDQWLWDWLYHDLUZD\DQDO\VLVRQPXOWLGHWHFWRU
FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7 RI WKH FKHVW$LP RI WKLV VWXG\ ZDV WR HYDOXDWH
JHQHUDWLRQEDVHGDLUZD\SDUDPHWHUVLQSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPF\VWLFÀEURVLV &)
OXQJGLVHDVHLQFRUUHODWLRQZLWKSUHGLFWHGIRUFHGH[SLUDWRU\FDSDFLW\LQV )(9
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV0'&7DFTXLUHGLQSDUDOOHOWR)(9 PHGLDQJDSG
UDQJHG IURPQ LQIDQW &)LQIDQW DQGQ DGXOW &)DGXOW &)SDWLHQWV
ZHUHVXEMHFWHGWRIXOO\DXWRPDWLFDLUZD\DQDO\VLV1 LQIDQWVDQGQ DGXOWVZLWK
QRUPDODLUZD\VDQG)(9VHUYHGDVFRQWUROV 1250$/LQIDQW1250$/DGXOW
7RWDOGLDPHWHU 7' OXPHQDUHD /$ DQGZDOOWKLFNQHVV :7 RISUR[LPDOWRGLVWDO
DLUZD\VZHUHVHSDUDWHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK)(9
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV1RVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQVZLWK)(9H[LVWHGIRU7'DQG:7RISUR[LPDO
DQGGLVWDODLUZD\VLQERWK1250$/ 5UDQJLQJIURPWR EXWIRU/$RI
WKHQGJHQHUDWLRQLQ1250$/DGXOW 5 ,Q&)LQIDQWPRGHUDWHLQYHUVHFRU
UHODWLRQVZHUHIRXQGIRU7'DQG/$RIQGJHQHUDWLRQDLUZD\V 5 DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ EXWQRWIRU:7,Q&)DGXOW7'DQG:7RIWKJHQHUDWLRQDLUZD\V
LQYHUVHO\ FRUUHODWHG ZLWK )(9 5 DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\ EXW QRW RI
WKHQGJHQHUDWLRQ 5 DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ /$FRUUHODWHGEHVWIRUWK
JHQHUDWLRQDLUZD\V 5
&RQFOXVLRQ7' /$ DQG :7 RI GLVWDO DLUZD\V VKRZHG VWURQJ FRUUHODWLRQV ZLWK
)(9LQDGXOW&)SDWLHQWVLQGLFDWLQJDVKLIWRIPDMRUDLUZD\UHVLVWDQFHWRGLVWDO
EURQFKLLQFKURQLF&))XOO\DXWRPDWLFVRIWZDUHWRROVFRXOGLQWURGXFHXVHULQGH
SHQGHQWTXDQWLWDWLYHSDUDPHWHUVLQWRWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIREVWUXFWLYHOXQJGLVHDVH
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, &(05, LVPRUHVHQVLWLYHWRGHWHFWVPDOO
DLUZD\VGLVHDVHWKDQSURWRQ05, 05, DFRPSDUDWLYHVWXG\LQ
F\VWLFÀEURVLV &) OXQJGLVHDVH
3&LHW3:LHORSROVNL(YDQGHU:LHO*3.UHVWLQ0+/HTXLQ
*0RUDQD+$0:7LGGHQV5RWWHUGDP1/7UHYLVR,7
SFLHW#HUDVPXVPFQO
%
$VFRULQJV\VWHPIRUWRPRV\QWKHVLVLQSXOPRQDU\F\VWLFÀEURVLV
.9XOWYRQ6WH\HUQ,%MRUNPDQ%XUWVFKHU3+RJOXQG*%R]RYLF0:LNOXQG
0*HLMHU/XQG6( NULVWLQDYXOWBYRQBVWH\HUQ#PHGOXVH
3XUSRVH1RVFRULQJV\VWHPIRUWRPRV\QWKHVLV GLJLWDOWRPRJUDSK\ LQSXOPRQDU\
F\VWLFÀEURVLV &) KDVEHHQSXEOLVKHG7KHSXUSRVHZDVWRLQWURGXFHDQGYDOLGDWH
VXFKDV\VWHP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDLUHGFKHVWUDGLRJUDSK\DQGWRPRV\QWKHVLVH[DPLQD
WLRQVRQSDWLHQWVZLWK&) FKLOGUHQDQGDGXOWV DQGSDHGLDWULFRQFRORJ\
SDWLHQWVZHUHVFRUHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\E\WKUHHUDGLRORJLVWV7RPRV\QWKHVLVVWXGLHV
ZHUHVFRUHGIRURYHULQÁDWLRQEURQFKLDOZDOOWKLFNHQLQJDWHOHFWDVLVRUFRQVROLGDWLRQ
QXPEHUDQGVHYHULW\RIEURQFKLHFWDVHVDQGODUJHDQGVPDOOPXFXVSOXJVZLWKD
PD[LPXPVFRUHRI7KH%UDVÀHOGVFRULQJV\VWHPZDVXVHGIRUUDGLRJUDSKV
5HVXOWV&RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHVFRUHIRUWRPRV\QWKHVLVDQG%UDVÀHOGVFRUHIRU
UDGLRJUDSK\ZDVJRRG .HQGDOOҋVUDQNFRUUHODWLRQWDXDQGIRUWKH
WKUHHUDWHUV 7RPRV\QWKHVLVZDVJHQHUDOO\VFRUHGKLJKHULQSHUFHQWDJHRIPD[LPXP
VFRUH2EVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWVIRUWRWDOVFRUHVZHUHKLJKLQERWKV\VWHPV ZHLJKWHG
NDSSD!IRUWKHWKUHHSDLUVRIUDGLRORJLVWUDWHUVIRUWKHWRPRV\QWKHVLVVFRUH
DQGDQGIRUWKH%UDVÀHOGVFRUH SDWLHQWV ZHUHVFRUHG
QRUPDO IRU QRGXODUF\VWLF OHVLRQV RQ UDGLRJUDSKV E\ DOO UDWHUV EXW ZHUH VFRUHG
SRVLWLYHIRUEURQFKLHFWDVHVRUPXFXVSOXJJLQJZLWKWRPRV\QWKHVLV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSURSRVHGWRPRV\QWKHVLVVFRUHFRUUHODWHVZHOOZLWKWKH%UDVÀHOG
VFRULQJV\VWHPZLWKJRRGREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWVIRUWKHWRWDOVFRUH7RPRV\QWKHVLV
LVPRUHVHQVLWLYHWR&)FKDQJHVLQSDUWLFXODUEURQFKLHFWDVHVDQGPXFXVSOXJ
JLQJDQGVKRZVWKHPLQPRUHGHWDLOWKDQUDGLRJUDSK\7KHUHIRUHWKHQHZVFRULQJ
V\VWHPKDYLQJDKLJKHUPD[LPXPVFRUHRIIHUVWKHSRVVLELOLW\IRUDPRUHDFFXUDWH
VFRULQJRIGLVHDVHVHYHULW\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6PDOODLUZD\DQGLQWHUVWLWLDOOXQJLQYROYHPHQWLQDV\PSWRPDWLF
SDWLHQWVZLWKDQWLSKRVSKROLSLGV\QGURPH
$2LNRQRPRX$7]RXYHOHNLV36NHQGURV,0LWURXOLV($SRVWROLGRX
$7KRPDLGL.5LWLV'%RXURV33UDVVRSRXORV$OH[DQGURXSROLV*5
DRLNRQRP#PHGGXWKJU
3XUSRVH$QWLSKRVSKROLSLGV\QGURPH $36 LVDV\VWHPLFDXWRLPPXQHGLVRUGHU
FKDUDFWHULVHG E\ YDVFXODU WKURPERVLV$FWLYDWLRQ RI WKH FRDJXODWLRQ FDVFDGH LV
WKRXJKWWREHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKLQGXFWLRQDQGPDLQWHQDQFHRILQÁDPPDWLRQZKLFK
OHDGVWRWLVVXHLQMXU\DQGÀEURVLV2XUDLPZDVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHSUHYDOHQFHRI
QRQWKURPERWLFOXQJPDQLIHVWDWLRQVLQDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK$36
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7HQSDWLHQWVIUHHRIUHVSLUDWRU\V\PSWRPVZKRPHWWKH
FULWHULDIRU$36 SULPDU\$36DQGVHFRQGDU\WRV\VWHPLFOXSXVHU\WKHPDWRVXV
6/( ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\LGHQWLÀHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWKLJKUHVROXWLRQFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ +5&7 RIWKHFKHVWDQGIXQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQW+5&7VFDQVZHUH
HYDOXDWHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIDLUWUDSSLQJÀEURVLVPLFURQRGXODUSDWWHUQF\VWV
HPSK\VHPD DWHOHFWDVLV FRQVROLGDWLRQ DQG SOHXUDO HIIXVLRQ7KH WRWDO H[WHQW RI
DLUWUDSSLQJZDVHVWLPDWHGEDVHGRQDVXEMHFWLYHVHPLDXWRPDWHG+5&7VFRULQJ
V\VWHP)XQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQWLQFOXGHG)9&7/&00()'/&2PLQXWH
ZDONLQJGLVWDQFHDQGV\VWROLFSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\SUHVVXUH
5HVXOWV$OOSDWLHQWVH[KLELWHGERWKDUDGLRORJLFDODQGIXQFWLRQDOSDWWHUQFRPSDWLEOH
ZLWKVPDOODLUZD\GLVHDVHLUUHVSHFWLYHRIVPRNLQJ0HDQVFRUHRIDLUWUDSSLQJZDV
UDQJH +5&7ÀQGLQJVDQGUHGXFHGOHYHOVRI00()SUHG
ZHUHQHJDWLYHO\FRUUHODWHG U S 6XESOHXUDOEDVDOUHWLFXODUSDWWHUQ
FRQVLVWHQWZLWKÀEURVLVZDVVHHQLQSDWLHQWV7KLQZDOOHGF\VWVZHUHVHHQLQ
SDWLHQWVZKLOHXSSHUOREHKD]\PLFURQRGXODUSDWWHUQZDVGHWHFWHGLQSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ$V\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK$36PD\SUHVHQWZLWKVPDOODLUZD\DQG
LQWHUVWLWLDOOXQJLQYROYHPHQWLUUHVSHFWLYHRIVPRNLQJKLVWRU\DQG6/(FRH[LVWHQFH
&KHVW+5&7DQGURXWLQHIXQFWLRQDOWHVWVPD\EHYDOXDEOHWRROVIRUSK\VLFLDQVZKHQ
HYDOXDWLQJSDWLHQWVZLWK$36
%
0'&7HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHWUDFKHREURQFKLDOWUHHDQRPDOLHVLQFKLOGUHQ
ZLWKFRQJHQLWDOKHDUWGLVHDVH
$*6KLQ=$9DNKLGRYD1,6DIRQRYD76KLQNDUHYD90DNDUHQNR
0RVFRZ58
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIPXOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHUWRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7 LQ
GLDJQRVWLFVRIDQRPDOLHVRIWKHWUDFKHREURQFKLDOWUHHLQFKLOGUHQZLWKFRQJHQLWDO
KHDUWGLVHDVH &+'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFKLOGUHQZLWK&+'UHIHUUHGIRU0'&7HYDOXDWLRQZHUH
H[DPLQHG PHDQ DJH PRQWKV UDQJH GD\V WR PRQWKV 3DWLHQWV ZHUH
H[DPLQHGXVLQJ(&*JDWHG0'&7DQJLRJUDSK\:HHPSOR\HGGLPHQVLRQDO
' LPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZKRZHUHVXVSHFWHGRIKDYLQJFRPSOLFDWLQJ
H[WHUQDOYDVFXODUFRPSUHVVLRQDVDFDXVHRIUHVSLUDWRU\V\PSWRPV7RDOOSDWLHQWV
[UD\VWXG\RIWKHFKHVWZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV/XQJDQRPDOLHVFDXVHGE\SXOPRQDU\XQGHUGHYHORSPHQWZHUHUHFRJQLVHG
LQFDVHVZKLFKKDGQRWEHHQGLDJQRVHGE\PHDQVRI[UD\H[DPLQDWLRQ7KH
OREDUHPSK\VHPDZDVLGHQWLÀHGLQSDWLHQWVDQGLWZDVWKHUHVXOWRIDFKHFN
YDOYHPHFKDQLVPDWWKHEURQFKLDOOHYHOFDXVHGE\H[WHUQDOYDVFXODUFRPSUHVVLRQ
&ULWLFDOWUDFKHDOVWHQRVLVLQRQHSDWLHQWZDVFDXVHGE\SXOPRQDU\DUWHU\VOLQJ,Q
FDVHVEURQFKLDOVWHQRVLVZDVGXHWRFRPSUHVVLRQE\WKHULJKWDRUWLFDUFKDQG
.RPPHUHOOCVGLYHUWLFXOXP7KHVWHQRVLVRIWKHOHIWPDLQEURQFKXVZDVREVHUYHG
LQFDVHVGXHWRFRPSUHVVLRQEHWZHHQWKHGHVFHQGLQJDRUWDDQGWKHOHIWXSSHU
SXOPRQDU\YHLQ$UWHULRYHQRXVPDOIRUPDWLRQVZHUHGLDJQRVHGLQSDWLHQWVRQH
RIZKLFKOHGWRFRPSUHVVLRQRIVHJPHQWDOEURQFKXVRIORZHUOREHRIWKHULJKWOXQJ
&RQFOXVLRQ 0'&7 HYDOXDWLRQ RI DQRPDOLHV RI WKH WUDFKHREURQFKLDO WUHH LQ
FKLOGUHQZLWKFRQJHQLWDOKHDUWGLVHDVH &+' LGHQWLÀHVWKHFDXVHVRIUHVSLUDWRU\
GLVRUGHUV DQG DOORZV SUHGLFWLQJ SRVVLEOH UHVSLUDWRU\ FRPSOLFDWLRQV LQ WKH HDUO\
SRVWRSHUDWLYHSHULRG
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH &KHVW&7 LV WKH PRVW VHQVLWLYH WHFKQLTXH WR PRQLWRU SURJUHVVLRQ RI
&)UHODWHGEURQFKLHFWDVLVDQGWUDSSHGDLU 7$ UHÁHFWLQJVPDOODLUZD\VGLVHDVH
&KHVW05,LVDUDGLDWLRQIUHHDOWHUQDWLYHIRU&7EXWLWVVHQVLWLYLW\IRU7$LVSRRU
+\SRSHUIXVLRQ +3 RIWHQFRLQFLGHVZLWK7$DQGWKXV&(05,PLJKWEHPRUHVHQVL
WLYHWRLGHQWLI\7$$LPV WRFRPSDUHYROXPHRI+3RQ&(05,ZLWKYROXPHRI$7
RQ05, WRFRPSDUHYROXPHRI+3DQG7$WRVSLURPHWU\SDUDPHWHUVVHQVLWLYH
WRVPDOODLUZD\GLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVVWDEOH&)SDWLHQWV 0PHDQDJH\UVUDQJH
\UV 6SLURPHWU\DQG&(05,ZHUHGRQHRQWKHVDPHGD\76FDQQHU
6LJQD *( 3URWRFRO 66)3' 3'Z D[LDO FRURQDO DQG VDJLWWDO 757(6/
PP *5('D[LDODQGFRURQDO 757(6/ PPPPRONJ ,P
DJHVZHUHDQRQ\PLVHGDQGVFRUHGLQUDQGRPRUGHUZLWK&)05,VFRUH H[SUHVVHG
DVRIPD[ 'HVFULSWLYHVWDWLVWLFV7WHVWDQG6SHDUPDQFRUUHODWLRQ U ZHUHXVHG
5HVXOWV0HDQ 6' +3DQG7$VFRUHVZHUHUHVSHFWLYHO\ DQG
&RUUHODWLRQV7$YV+3 U S +3YV)() U S +3
YV )() U S +3 YV )(9)9& U S 7$ YV )()
U S 7$YV)() QV RU)(9)9& QV
&RQFOXVLRQ+3EXWQRW7$VKRZHGKLJKO\VLJQLÀFDQWQHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQVZLWK
VSLURPHWU\SDUDPHWHUVVHQVLWLYHIRUVPDOODLUZD\GLVHDVH+3DUHDVGLGQRWDOZD\V
PDWFK7$DUHDV&(05,VHHPVWRLPSURYHWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRI05,WRGHWHFW
VPDOODLUZD\VGLVHDVH
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
9DVFXODULQWHUYHQWLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
/0DLOOL$WKHQV*5
50RUJDQ/RQGRQ8.
%
'LUHFWLRQDODWKHUHFWRP\RIFDOFLÀHGVWHQRWLFOHVLRQVRIWKHORZHU
OLPELQVHJPHQWVZLWKKLJKELRPHFKDQLFDOVWUHVV\HDUUHVXOWV
30LQNR6-DHJHU$%XHFNHU0.DWRK
+RPEXUJDG6DDU'( SHWHUPLQNR#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHORQJWHUPRXWFRPHV \HDU RISDWLHQWVZLWKSHULSKHUDO
RFFOXVLYH GLVHDVH 32' DQG FDOFLÀHG VWHQRWLF OHVLRQV LQ VHJPHQWV ZLWK KLJK
ELRPHFKDQLFDOVWUHVVDIWHUDWKHUHFWRP\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURP32' 5XWKHUIRUGWR ZHUH
WUHDWHGZLWKWKH6LOYHUKDZNDWKHUHFWRP\GHYLFH HY(QGRYDVFXODU0186$ LI
FDOFLÀHGVWHQRWLFOHVLRQVLQWKHPRVWSUR[LPDORUGLVWDOFPRIWKHVXSHUÀFLDOIHPRUDO
DUWHU\DQGRUSRSOLWHDODUWHU\ZHUHSUHVHQW2YHUDOOSDWLHQWVZLWKOHVLRQV
IHPDOHVPDOHVPHDQDJH ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWRWKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\
3DWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWFOLQLFDOUHHYDOXDWLRQHYHU\PRQWKVIRUPRQWKVLQFOXGLQJ
WKHPHDVXUHPHQWRIWKHPD[LPXPZDONLQJGLVWDQFHDQGWKHDQNOHEUDFKLDOLQGH[
$%, ,QDGGLWLRQGXSOH[VRQRJUDSK\ZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV 7KH SULPDU\ VXFFHVV UDWH RI WKH SURFHGXUH ZDV ,Q ÀYH FDVHV
DGGLWLRQDO37$DQGRUVWHQWLQJZDVQHFHVVDU\3URFHGXUHUHODWHGFRPSOLFDWLRQV
QDPHO\SHULSKHUDOHPEROLVPRFFXUUHGLQFDVHV 7KHPHDQ5XWKHUIRUGVFRUH
GHFUHDVHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\IURPWRZKLOHWKHPHDQ$%,LQFUHDVHGIURPWR
DIWHUPRQWKV7KHSULPDU\DQGDVVLVWHGSULPDU\SDWHQF\UDWHZDVDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\7DUJHWOHVLRQUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGLQÀYHSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ'LUHFWLRQDODWKHUHFWRP\VKRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGDVDQDOWHUQDWLYHIRU
WUHDWPHQWRIFDOFLÀHGVWHQRWLFOHVLRQVLQVHJPHQWVZLWKKLJKELRPHFKDQLFDOVWUHVV
DVLQPRVWFDVHVVWHQWLQJFDQEHDYRLGHG5HVXOWVDIWHUWKUHH\HDUVGHPRQVWUDWHG
DVLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHRIWKH5XWKHUIRUGVFRUHDQGDQLQFUHDVHRIWKH$%,DQGD
UHDVRQDEOHSDWHQF\UDWH
%
,QWUDDUWHULDOLQIXVLRQRIDOORJHQLFPHVHQFK\PDOVWHPFHOOVIRU
FULWLFDOOLPELVFKDHPLDDQGIRRWXOFHUVVDIHW\DQGHIÀFDF\
%--$EGXOODK66'KLOORQ$'DV$&5RVODQL.XDOD/XPSXU0<
EDVULM#XPPFHGXP\
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHVDIHW\WHFKQLFDOIHDVLELOLW\DQGFOLQLFDOHIÀFDF\RILQWUD
DUWHULDO DOORJHQLF PHVHQFK\PDO VWHP FHOOV $06& IRU FULWLFDO OLPE LVFKDHPLD
&/, DQGIRRWXOFHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$SURVSHFWLYHVLQJOHDUP3KDVH,,QRQUDQGRPLVHGVWXG\
ZDVFDUULHGRXWLQSDWLHQWVZLWKXQWUHDWDEOHORZHUOLPESHULSKHUDODUWHULDOGLVHDVH
VXUJLFDOE\SDVVRUDQJLRSODVW\ GLDJQRVHGE\&(05,8QFRQWUROOHG'0UHQDO
KHSDWLFIDLOXUHRUDQ\SUHYLRXVPDOLJQDQF\ZDVFDXVHIRUH[FOXVLRQ2QO\VLQJOH
LQMHFWLRQRIPLOOLRQFHOOVLQWRWKHFRPPRQIHPRUDODUWHU\XQGHU86JXLGDQFH1R
UHSHDWLQMHFWLRQVDOORZHG$06&LVRODWHGIURPXQUHODWHGKHDOWK\GRQRUVDQDO\VHG
XVLQJÁRZF\WRPHWU\$06&XSVFDOHGDFFRUGLQJWRF*037KHW\SHRIDGYHUVH
HYHQWV $(V QXPEHURI$(VDQGSHUFHQWDJH$(VZHUHQRWHG3ULPDU\HQGSRLQWV
ZHUH UHVW SDLQ DQG XOFHU KHDOLQJ DW HQG PRQWKV ZKLOH VHFRQGDU\ HQGSRLQWV
ZHUHLQFUHDVHGWUDQVFXWDQHRXVSDUWLDOR[\JHQVDWXUDWLRQ 7F32 DQNOHEUDFKLDO
SUHVVXUHLQGH[ $%3, YDVFXORJHQHVLV &(05, DQGOLPESUHVHUYDWLRQ$SSURYDO
REWDLQHGIURPKRVSLWDOHWKLFDOUHYLHZERDUG
5HVXOWV7RGDWHDWRWDORIOLPEVWUHDWHGSDWLHQWHDFK OLPE GLGQRWUHVSRQG
WRWUHDWPHQW SDLQSHUVLVWHQW ZLWKSDWLHQWKDYLQJ%.$SDWLHQWVGLHGIURPXQ
UHODWHGFDXVHV OLPEDWPRQWKVOLPEVDWPRQWKV $WPRQWKVSDWLHQWV
OLPEV KDYHOLPESUHVHUYDWLRQ LPSURYHG7F32DQG$%3,ZLWKLQPRQWK DQG
SHDNLQJ DW PRQWKV 1R LQFUHDVHG YDVFXORJHQHVLV VHHQ RQ &( 05, 1R$(V
GRFXPHQWHGGXULQJWKH)8SHULRG
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHSUHOLPLQDU\GDWDVKRZLQWUDDUWHULDO$06&LVDVDIHWHFKQLFDOO\
IHDVLEOHDQGHIÀFDFLRXVLQXQWUHDWDEOH&/,
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
'(%YV37$IRUPXOWLOHYHOORZHUOLPEUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQPRQWK
UHVXOWVIURPDUDQGRPLVHGWULDO
$&DQQDYDOH))DQHOOL$%UXQL0$OOHJULWWL(%RDWWD53DVVDULHOOR
5RPH,7 DOHVVDQGURFDQQDYDOH#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 'UXJHOXWLQJ EDOORRQV KDYH VKRZQ SURPLVLQJ UHVXOWV LQ UHFHQW WULDOV
LPSURYLQJ WKH SDWHQF\ UDWH LQ VWHQRREVWUXFWLYH GLVHDVH RI WKH IHPRURSRSOLWHDO
UHJLRQ:HZRXOGOLNHWRHYDOXDWHPLGWHUPSDWHQF\RISHULSKHUDODQJLRSODVW\ZLWK
SDFOLWD[HOFRDWHGEDOORRQV '(% LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOEDOORRQV 37$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIW\FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUV ZLWK
VWHQRVLV RU RFFOXVLRQ RI D IHPRURSRSOLWHDO DUWHU\ ZHUH HQUROOHG DQG UDQGRPO\
DVVLJQHGWRWUHDWPHQWZLWK'(% SWV,13$&7$PSKLULRQ,QYDWHF,WDO\
DQGWRWUHDWPHQWZLWKXQFRDWHGEDOORRQV SWVFRQWUROJURXS 3DWLHQWV
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVZHUHVLPLODULQERWKJURXSVVPRNHUVGLDEHWHVDQG
K\SHUFKROHVWHUROHPLD7KLUW\HLJKWZHUH7$6&%ZKLOHZHUH&DQG'
7KHSULPDU\HQGSRLQWZDVODWHOXPHQORVVDWPRQWKV
5HVXOWV7ZHQW\WZRSHUFHQWRIWKHOHVLRQVZHUHWRWDORFFOXVLRQVDQGZHUH
VWHQRWLFOHVLRQV7KHPHDQOHVLRQOHQJWKZDVFP7KHUHZHUHQRDGYHUVH
HYHQWVFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHSDFOLWD[HOFRDWHGEDOORRQV$WPRQWKV86&'IROORZXS
VKRZHGQHRLQWLPDOWKLFNQHVVRIPPLQWKHFRQWUROJURXSDVFRPSDUHGZLWK
PP 3 LQWKHJURXSWUHDWHGZLWK'(%7KHUDWHRIUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQ
RIWDUJHWOHVLRQVDWPRQWKVZDVRI LQWKHFRQWUROJURXSRI
LQWKH'(%JURXS 3 YVFRQWUROJURXS 7KURPERVLVUDWHZDV 37$ YV
'(% S$PSXWDWLRQUDWHZDV 37$ YV '(% S
&RQFOXVLRQ8VHRI'(%LQIHPRURSRSOLWHDOGLVHDVHLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKVLJQLÀFDQW
UHGXFWLRQVLQODWHOXPHQORVVDQGWDUJHWOHVLRQUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQ
%
&RQFRPLWDQWXVHRIHQGRYHQRXVODVHUDQGIRDPHGVFOHURVDQWLQ
WUHDWPHQWRIORZHUOLPEYDULFRVLWLHV\HDUIROORZXSUHVXOWV
0%KDOOD1%KDOOD+9DVDYDGD$KPHGDEDG,1-DPQDJDU,1
3XUSRVH 7R UHSRUW PLGWHUP UHVXOWV XSWR \HDUV RI FRQFRPLWDQW XVH RI WZR
PRGHVRIWUHDWLQJYDULFRVHYHLQVHQGRYHQRXVODVHUWUHDWPHQWIRUJUHDWVDSKHQRXV
YHLQ *69 UHÁX[DQGVFOHURWKHUDS\IRULQFRPSHWHQWSHUIRUDWRUVDQGDFFHVVRU\
YHQRXVFKDQQHOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVORZHUOLPEV OHIWULJKWELODWHUDO RI
SDWLHQWV ZRPHQPHQPHDQDJH\UV ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKFRQFRPLWDQW
XVHRIHQGRYHQRXVODVHUDQGVFOHURWKHUDS\SDWLHQWV OHJV KDGXOFHUV
*69 ZDV PDSSHG XVLQJ 0+= OLQHDU 8OWUDVRXQG 86 SUREH )ROORZLQJ ORFDO
DQDHVWKHVLDLQFK-*XLGHZLUHZDVLQWURGXFHGLQ*69IURPORZHVWSRLQWRI
UHÁX[$)VKHDWKDQGPODVHUÀEUHZDVXVHG/DVHUHQHUJ\ZDVGHOLYHUHG
LQWUDOXPLQDOO\DW:FRQWLQXRXVPRGH)LEUHZDVXQLIRUPO\ZLWKGUDZQ6FOHURVDQW
PL[HGZLWKDLUWRSURGXFHIRDPZDVLQWURGXFHGWKURXJKQHHGOHLQSHUIRUDWRUVDQG
DGGLWLRQDOYHQRXVFKDQQHOVXQGHU86JXLGDQFH$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHDGYLVHGLEXSURIHQ
DQGFODVV,,VWRFNLQJV)ROORZXSZDVGRQHDWZHHNDQGPRQWKV
5HVXOWVODVHUWUHDWHG*69UHPDLQHGDEODWHGDW\HDUIROORZXSOLPEV
LQÀUVW\HDUDQGDGGLWLRQDOOLPEVLQQH[W\HDUV LHOLPEVLQ\HDUV
UHTXLUHG RQH PRUH VFOHURWKHUDS\ VHVVLRQ IRU QHZ LQFRPSHWHQW SHUIRUDWRUV 1R
FRPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHQRWHGSDWLHQWVFRPSODLQHGRIWLJKWQHVVDORQJWKHFRXUVH
RIWUHDWHG*693DWLHQWVUHVXPHGURXWLQHDFWLYLWLHVLPPHGLDWHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ/DVHUKDVDOUHDG\SURYHQLWVXVHLQWUHDWLQJ*696FOHURWKHUDS\LV
HIIHFWLYHLQGHDOLQJZLWKSHUIRUDWRUVDQGSURYLGHVUDSLGKHDOLQJRIFKURQLFYHQRXV
XOFHUV&RQFRPLWDQWXVHRIERWKPRGHVOLPLWVWKHQHHGRIVXEVHTXHQWSURFHGXUH
%
37$WKHRWKHUZD\86JXLGHG6$)$5,WHFKQLTXH
,.RJDQ0/HLGHUPDQ55R]HQEHUJ$(QJHO$2IHU+DLID,/
UDGXURVHQEHUJ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHVFULEHWKHEHQHÀWVRIXOWUDVRXQG 86 JXLGHGVXELQWLPDODUWHULDO
ÁRVVLQJDQWHJUDGHUHWURJUDGHLQWHUYHQWLRQ 6$)$5,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGSDWLHQWVZKRZHUHWUHDWHG
ZLWKWKH6$)$5,WHFKQLTXHGXHWRIDLOXUHRIFODVVLFDODQWHJUDGH37$WRUHFDQDOLVHRF
FOXGHGIHPRUDODQGWLELDODUWHULHV%HWZHHQDQGSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
37$SURFHGXUHVLQRXUKRVSLWDOIRUWUHDWPHQWRIOLPELVFKDHPLD:HXVHGWKH
6$)$5,WHFKQLTXHRQSDWLHQWVLQZKRPDQWHJUDGH37$IDLOHGWRSURYLGHGLUHFW
ÁRZWRWKHLVFKDHPLFVLWH,QDOOSDWLHQWVWKHUHWURJUDGHSXQFWXUHZDVSHUIRUPHG
XQGHU 86 JXLGDQFH ,Q RI SDWLHQWV WKH HQVXLQJ SXQFWXUH VLWH ZDV LQ WKH
GRUVDOLVSHGLVDUWHU\DQGLQRQHSDWLHQWZHSXQFWXUHGWKHWLELDOLVDQWHULRUDUWHU\
7KHJXLGHZLUHZDVSXVKHGLQDUHWURJUDGHPDQQHUWKURXJKWKHSUHYLRXVO\LQVHUWHG
DQWHJUDGHFDWKHWHU7KHEDOORRQGLODWDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJERWKSXQFWXUHVLWHV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWVWKH86JXLGHGSXQFWXUHRIDGLVWDODUWHU\ZDVVXFFHVVIXO
&RPELQHGDQWHJUDGHDQGUHWURJUDGH 6$)$5,WHFKQLTXH 37$ZDVVXFFHVVIXOLQ
RIWKHSDWLHQWVLQZKLFKWKHDQWHJUDGH37$DORQHGLGQRWSURYLGHVDWLVIDFWRU\
UHFDQDOLVDWLRQDQGZDVFRQVLGHUHGIDLOHG$VDPLQRUFRPSOLFDWLRQWHPSRUDU\'3
DUWHU\VSDVPZDVVHHQLQRIWKHFDVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ 6$)$5, WHFKQLTXH LV XVXDOO\ XVHG ZKHQ WKH FODVVLF DQWHJUDGH
37$IDLOV7KLVSURFHGXUHQHFHVVLWDWHVDKROORZGLVWDODUWHU\DQJLRJUDSKLVWVZLWK
XOWUDVRQRJUDSKLFVNLOOVDQGLWLVWLPHFRQVXPLQJ+RZHYHULWSURYLGHVDJRRGODVW
DOWHUQDWLYHLQSDWLHQWVLQZKLFKWKHDQWHJUDGH37$KDVIDLOHG
%
6LOYHUKDZNGLUHFWLRQDODWKHUHFWRP\LQWKHWUHDWPHQWRIGHQRYR
IHPRURSRSOLWHDODWKHURVFOHURWLFVWHQRREVWUXFWLYHGLVHDVHVLQJOH
FHQWUHH[SHULHQFH
0&LWRQH05RVVL/*UHFR*09DUDQR$=RORYNLQV9'DYLG5RPH,7
PLFLWRQH#LQZLQGLW
%
(QGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRIH[WUDFUDQLDOFDURWLGDUWHU\DQHXU\VPV
.'0DWKLDV$5DQIW'RUWPXQG'( NODXVPDWKLDV#NOLQLNXPGRGH
3XUSRVH(IÀFDF\DQGGXUDELOLW\RIHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRIFDURWLGDUWHU\DQ
HXU\VPVZLWKFRYHUHGVWHQWVZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKH[WUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPVRIWKHLQWHUQDODQG
FRPPRQFDURWLGDUWHU\ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKFRYHUHGVWHQWVPHQZRPHQPHDQ
DJH\HDUV7KHSDWLHQWVVXIIHUHGIURPÀEURPXVFXODUG\VSODVLDWUDXPDWLF
DQG VSRQWDQHRXV GLVVHFWLRQ ZKLSODVK LQMXU\ WXPRXU LQYDVLRQ DWKHURVFOHURVLV
DQGGLUHFWWUDXPD7KHGLDPHWHURIWKHVPDOOHVWDQHXU\VPPHDVXUHGPPWKH
ODUJHVWPPRQDQDYHUDJHPP6HOIH[SDQGDEOHFRYHUHGVWHQWZHUHXVHG
LQDOOFDVHV7KUHHSDWLHQWVUHFHLYHGVWHQWV3ODWHOHWLQKLELWRUVZHUHDGPLQLVWHUHG
GXULQJDQGDIWHUWKHSURFHGXUH)ROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQVDUHDYDLODEOHXSWR\HDUV
5HVXOWV,QRIWKHSDWLHQWVWKHVWHQWVVHDOHGWKHDQHXU\VPV,QRQHSDWLHQW
D JLDQW DQHXU\VP FRXOG QRW EH FURVVHG 2QH SDWLHQW GHYHORSHG D PDMRU VWURNH
LPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWUHDWPHQW2QHSDWLHQWQHHGHGDVHFRQGLQWHUYHQWLRQGXHWRDQ
HQGROHDNPRQWKVODWHU,QWZRWXPRXUSDWLHQWVWKHFDURWLGDUWHU\RFFOXGHGZLWKLQ
\HDUVDIWHUWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQZLWKRXWDVWURNHEXWZLWKPLJUDWLRQRIWKHHQGRJUDIW
RIWKHSDWLHQWVKDGDJRRGORQJWHUPRXWFRPHZLWKRXWDGYHUVHHYHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ(QGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRIFDURWLGDUWHU\DQHXU\VPVLVKLJKO\HIIHFWLYH
DQGUHSODFHVRSHQVXUJLFDOUHSDLULQQHDUO\DOOFDVHVZLWKDORQJWHUPFXUHUDWHRI
DQGZLWKRXWWKHFUDQLDOQHUYHSDOVLHVVHHQDIWHUVXUJHU\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
7\SH,,HQGROHDNVDIWHUHQGRYDVFXODUDEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VP
UHSDLUIDWHRIWKHDQHXU\VPVDFGXULQJORQJWHUPIROORZXS
51RO]+7HXIHOVEDXHU'%HLW]NH0)XQRYLFV8$VHQEDXP$:LEPHU
&3ODQN-/DPPHU06FKRGHU9LHQQD$7 ULFKDUGQRO]#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHIUHTXHQF\RIW\SH,,HQGROHDNVDIWHUHQGRYDVFXODU$$$UHSDLU
DQGWRFRPSDUHVDFGLDPHWHUFKDQJHVWRHQGROHDNIUHH$$$VLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDW
OHDVWWKUHH\HDUV&7IROORZXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\FRKRUWVFRQVLVWRIDQR(/ Q(/ JURXS Q
DQGDW\SH,,(/JURXS Q $FFRUGLQJWRWKHLUFRXUVHDQGYHVVHORULJLQW\SH,,
(/VZHUHVSOLWWHGLQVXEJURXSV0D[LPXPVDFGLDPHWHUFKDQJHVZHUHPHDVXUHG
LQGHÀQHGJURXSVDQGDOVRDFFRUGLQJWRGLIIHUHQWVWHQWJUDIWGHYLFHV$GGLWLRQDOO\
UHLQWHUYHQWLRQDQGGHDWKUDWHVZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV0HDQIROORZXSZDVPRQWKV,QWKHW\SH,,(/JURXSVDFGLDP
HWHUVLQFUHDVHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFRPSDULVRQWRWKHÀUVWSRVWRSHUDWLYH&7,QWKHQ(/
WKHUHZDVDQRWVLJQLÀFDQWWHQGHQF\WRGHFUHDVLQJVDFGLDPHWHUV,QSURJUDGLHQWDQG
HTXDOW\SH,,(/VWKHPHDQGLIIHUHQFHRIVDFGLDPHWHULQFUHDVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWLQ
FRPSDULVRQWRWKHQ(/ S %\PHDQVRIWKHRYHUDOOW\SH,,(/JURXSWKHUH
ZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLDPHWHUFKDQJHLQFRPSDULVRQWRWKHQ(/$OVRWKHGLIIHUHQFHRI
GLDPHWHUFKDQJHZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWFRPSDULQJWKH(/VXEJURXSVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLU
YHVVHORULJLQ5HJDUGLQJGLIIHUHQWVWHQWJUDIWGHYLFHVWKH([FOXGHUHQGRSURVWKHVLV
VKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWPHDQGLIIHUHQFHRIVDFGLDPHWHULQFUHDVHLQFRPSDULVRQWR
WKH7DOHQWDQG=HQLWKHQGRSURVWKHVLV S 5HLQWHUYHQWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
LQ Q RISDWLHQWVDQGWKHUHZHUH Q DQHXU\VPUHODWHGGHDWKV
&RQFOXVLRQ3URJUDGLHQWDQGHTXDOW\SH,,(/VUHVXOWLQVLJQLÀFDQWDQHXU\VPVDF
HQODUJHPHQWGXULQJORQJWHUPIROORZXS%DVHGRQRXUUHVXOWVURXWLQHO\IROORZXS
RISDWLHQWVZLWKW\SH,,(/VUHPDLQVPDQGDWRU\
%
([FLPHUODVHUDWKHUHFWRP\LQDUWHULHVRIWKHORZHUOLPEZLWK7$6&&
DQG'OHVLRQV
&:LVVJRWW3.DPXVHOOD&/XHGWNH5$QGUHVHQ
+HLGH'( FZLVVJRWW#JP[GH
3XUSRVH7KH VWXG\ REMHFWLYH ZDV WR H[DPLQH WKH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI H[FLPHU ODVHU
DWKHUHFWRP\ (/$ LQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHIUDFWRU\RFFOXVLRQVLQIHPRURSRSOLWHDODUWHU
LHV ZKHUH SUHYLRXV FRQYHQWLRQDO UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ DWWHPSWV XVLQJ SHUFXWDQHRXV
WUDQVOXPLQDODQJLRSODVW\ 37$ ZHUHXQVXFFHVVIXO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHDYHUDJHDJHRIWKHSDWLHQWV PHQZRPHQ
LQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\ZDV\HDUV7KHDYHUDJHRFFOXVLRQOHQJWKZDVFP
UDQJH FP 7KH LQLWLDO UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ DWWHPSWV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG ZLWK VWLII
7HUXPRJXLGHZLUHV FXUYHGRUVWUDLJKW VXSSRUWHGE\YDULRXVFDWKHWHUV VWUDLJKW
PXOWLSXUSRVH&REUD $IWHU WKH XQVXFFHVVIXO DWWHPSW DQ H[FLPHU ODVHU FDWKHWHU
FDWKHWHU GLDPHWHUV IURP WR PP ZDV XVHG IRU UHFDQDOLVDWLRQ XVLQJ WKH
VWHSE\VWHSPHWKRGRIFURVVLQJ$IWHUVXFFHVVIXOFURVVLQJEDOORRQGLODWDWLRQZDV
SHUIRUPHGLQDOOFDVHV6WHQWLPSODQWZDVUHTXLUHGLQ RISURFHGXUHV
3DWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHGIRUPRQWKVZLWK&&'6
5HVXOWV 7KH LQLWLDO WHFKQLFDO VXFFHVV UDWH RI UHVXOWHG LQ SULPDU\
SULPDU\DVVLVWHG DQG VHFRQGDU\DVVLVWHG SDWHQF\ UDWHV RI DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\DIWHUPRQWKV1RVHULRXVFRPSOLFDWLRQVRFFXUUHGWKDWZHUH
DWWULEXWDEOHWRWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$FFRUGLQJWRWKHVHUHVXOWV(/$UHFDQDOLVDWLRQSURYLGHVDORZVWHQW
UDWHDOWHUQDWLYHWRVXUJLFDOSURFHGXUHVIRUUHIUDFWRU\RFFOXVLRQV7KLVZRXOGRIIHU
SDWLHQWVZLWKLQFUHDVHGRSHUDWLYHULVNVDSURPLVLQJDQGORZULVNWKHUDSHXWLFSUR
FHGXUH7KHRSWLRQRIDVXEVHTXHQWYDVFXODURSHUDWLRQZRXOGQRWEHFRPSURPLVHG
%
/RQJWHUPYROXPHWULFIROORZXSRIDEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VPVDIWHU
HQGRYDVFXODUDQHXU\VPUHSDLUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHHIIHFWRIHQGROHDNV
RQDQHXU\VPYROXPH
:+6RPPHU0+DDFN5:HLGHQKDJHQ)0HLQHO0)5HLVHU
0XQLFK'( ZLHODQGVRPPHU#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH HIIHFW RI GLIIHUHQW W\SHV RI HQGROHDNV RQ ORQJWHUP
FKDQJHVRIDQHXU\VPYROXPHLQSDWLHQWVDIWHUDEGRPLQDOHQGRYDVFXODUDQHXU\VP
UHSDLU (9$5
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HGHWHUPLQHGWKHYROXPHRIWKHDEGRPLQDODQHXU\VP
VL]H LQ SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW (9$5 EHWZHHQ DQG LQ DOO SUH
WKHUDSHXWLFDQGIROORZXS&7VXVLQJWKHVRIWZDUH2VLUL[0HDQLQFUHDVHRIWKH
DQHXU\VPYROXPHZDVGHWHUPLQHGIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWHQGROHDNVDQGZLWKGLIIHU
HQWW\SHVRIHQGROHDNVDWGLIIHUHQWWLPHSRLQWV PRQWKV 0 0DQG0DIWHU
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRISHUFXWDQHRXVGLUHFWLRQDODWKHUHFWRP\ '$ LQWKH
WUHDWPHQWRIIHPRURSRSOLWHDODWKHURPDVLFOHVLRQVLQV\PSWRPDWLF3$'SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQDQGSDWLHQWV PDOHVPD
ZLWK V\PSWRPDWLF 3$' LQWHUPLWWHQW FODXGLFDWLRQ FDVHV UHVW SDLQ WLVVXH
ORVV XQGHUZHQW'$ZLWK6LOYHU+DZNFDWKHWHUIRUDWKHURPDVLFOHVLRQV
REVWUXFWLRQV6)$SRSOLWHDODUWHU\
VWHQRVHV&)$6)$DQGSRSOLWHDODUWHU\ $YHUDJHDQJLRJUDSKLFOHVLRQ
OHQJWKZDVFP RFFOXVLRQDQGFP VWHQRVHV3UHSURFHGXUDO
HYDOXDWLRQ FRQVLVWHG RI &'XOWUDVRXQG DQG LQ VHOHFWHG FDVHV &7DQJLRJUDSK\
WREHWWHUFKDUDFWHULVHOHVLRQVOOOHVLRQVZHUHORZFDOFLÀHG,QFDVHVHPEROLF
SURWHFWLRQGHYLFHZDVHPSOR\HG
5HVXOWV7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVZDV SWV $GMXQFWLYHSWDZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ
FDVHV,QSWVDVVRFLDWHGWLELDOYHVVHOWUHDWPHQWZDVSHUIRUPHG1RSHULRSHUD
WLYHPRUWDOLW\ZDVREVHUYHG2QHFRPSOLFDWLRQ GLVWDOHPEROLVDWLRQ RFFXUUHG
$YHUDJH$%,LQFUHDVHGIURPWR$WGD\VFOLQLFDOVWDWXVHYDOXDWLRQ
ZDVLPSURYHPHQWLQYDULDWHDQGZRUVW$WPWVPHDQ)8 UDQJH
.DSODQ0HLHUDQDO\VLVVKRZHGSULPDU\SDWHQF\RIWUHDWHGYHVVHOVDWDQG
PRQWKVRIDQG$VVLVWHGSDWHQF\ZDVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ3HUFXWDQHRXVGLUHFWLRQDODWKHUHFWRP\LVDVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYHWHFK
QLTXHLQORZHUOLPEUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQ3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVVXSSRUWHGE\VKRUWPLG
WHUPGDWDHQFRXUDJHXVHRI'$ZLWK6LOYHU+DZNFDWKHWHULQWKHIHPRURSRSOLWHDO
VWHQRREVWUXFWLYHOHVLRQVDOVRLQWUDGLWLRQDOO\´IRUELGGHQGLVWULFWVµ/RQJWHUPGDWD
DUHPLVVLQJ
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
(9$5 3DWLHQWVZLWKORZÁRZ W\SH,, DQGZLWKKLJKÁRZ W\SH,,,,, HQGROHDNV
ZHUHDQDO\VHGVHSDUDWHO\WRGHWHUPLQHWKHHIIHFWRIHQGROHDNRQDQHXU\VPYROXPH
5HVXOWV2YHUDOO&7GDWDVHWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\YROXPHWU\ SDWLHQWDJH
\QRRIIROORZXS&7VPHDQIROORZXSWLPHPRQWKV $PRQJWKHVH
SDWLHQWVWKHUHZHUHW\SH,W\SH,,DQGW\SH,,,HQGROHDNV7KHDQHXU\VP
YROXPHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWHQGROHDNVDIWHU00DQG0ZDV
DQGRIWKHLQLWLDODQHXU\VPYROXPHUHVSHFWLYHO\/RZÁRZ W\SH,, HQGROHDNV
VKRZHGWKHIROORZLQJYROXPHV 0 0 DQG 0
+LJKÁRZ W\SH,,,, HQGROHDNVVKRZHGWKHIROORZLQJYROXPHWULHVFRPSDUHGWRWKH
LQLWLDOYROXPHWU\ 0 0 DQG 0 S
&RQFOXVLRQ %RWK ORZ DQG KLJKÁRZ HQGROHDNV KDYH D VLJQLÀFDQW LPSDFW RQ
UHJUHVVLRQRIDQHXU\VPYROXPHLQSDWLHQWVDIWHU(9$57\SH,,HQGROHDNVUDWKHU
OHDGWRVWDEOHYROXPHVRYHU\HDUVW\SH,DQG,,,HQGROHDNFRQWLQXRXVO\LQFUHDVH
DQHXU\VPVL]H
5RRP(
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
66
&DUWLODJHDQGRVWHRDUWKULWLV
0RGHUDWRUV
$3ODWNDMLV5LJD/9
*6FKHXUHFNHU/LQ]$7
%
%LRPHFKDQLFVRIKXPDQNQHHFDUWLODJHORDGLQJRINQHHGXULQJ705,
76KLRPL36]RPRODQ\L9-XUDV6=E\Q67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7
WVKLRPL#NDVRQHWQHMS
3XUSRVH$VUHSRUWHGSUHYLRXVO\05,PHDVXUHPHQWVRINQHHFDUWLODJHPRUSKRORJ\
DUHQRWVHQVLWLYHWRFKDQJHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKHDUO\VWDJHRIRVWHRDUWKULWLVGHYHORS
PHQW%LRFKHPLFDO05,SURYLGHVLQIRUPDWLRQRQFDUWLODJHFRPSRVLWLRQGRPLQDQWO\
RQSURWHRJO\FDQFRQWHQWDQGFRODJHQPDWUL[:HK\SRWKHVLVHWKDWFKDQJHVLQ7
YDOXHVRIKXPDQNQHHFDUWLODJHREVHUYHGGXULQJELRPHFKDQLFDO05,FRUUHODWHZLWK
FDUWLODJHIXQFWLRQDOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV0XOWLVOLFHPXOWLHFKRZDVSHUIRUPHGRQYROXQWHHUV
$IWHUORDGIUHHPHDVXUHPHQWVORDGRIKDOIERG\ZHLJKWZDVDSSOLHGZLWKWKH05
FRPSDWLEOHFXVWRPPDGHSQHXPDWLFFRQWUROOHGFRPSUHVVLRQGHYLFHIRU7$WWKH
HQGORDGIUHHPHDVXUHPHQWZDVUHSHDWHG2IÁLQHSRVWSURFHVVLQJZDVXVHGWR
HYDOXDWH7PDSV52,VZHUHGUDZQPDQXDOO\E\H[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWLQGHHS
DQG VXSHUÀFLDO ]RQH RI WKH ZHLJKWEHDULQJ DUHD 0HDQ VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQ DQG
SL[HOFRXQWZHUHUHFRUGHGDQGVWDWLVWLFDOO\DQDO\VHGE\7WHVW
5HVXOWV7YDOXHVRIKXPDQNQHHFDUWLODJHH[KLELWVLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHLQORDGLQJ
SKDVH PV!PVS DQGVLJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHLQXQORDGLQJ
SKDVH PV!PVS 7YDOXHVH[KLELWQRQOLQHDUG\QDPLF
FKDQJHRYHUWLPHDQGUHDFKHGVWDEOHYDOXHVDIWHUPLQXWHVRIORDGLQJXQORDGLQJ
&KDQJHVRI7YDOXHVZHUHPRUHREYLRXVLQVXSHUÀFLDOOD\HU
&RQFOXVLRQ/RDGLQJRINQHHGXULQJ05,FDQSURYLGHELRPHFKDQLFDOFKDUDFWHU
LVWLFVRIKXPDQNQHHFDUWLODJH6WDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHRIFDUWLODJH7LQ
ORDGLQJDQGXQORDGLQJSKDVHSURYLGHVLQVLJKWLQWRFDUWLODJHIXQFWLRQ7KLVFDQKHOS
LQGLDJQRVWLFVRIHDUO\VWDJHVRIRVWHRDUWKULWLVGHYHORSPHQWZKHQPRUSKRORJLFDO
FKDQJHVDQGGHJHQHUDWLRQVDUHQRWYLVLEOH1H[WVWHSZLOOEHDSSOLFDWLRQRIORDGLQJ
05,WRWKHSDWLHQWVDIWHUFDUWLODJHVXUJHU\
%
.QHHMRLQWFRQÀJXUDWLRQWKHLPSOLFDWLRQRIVHYHUHRVWHRDUWKULWLVDQG
$&/LQMXU\
(9DVVDORX30DWDOOLRWDNL.6SDQDNLV30DLGDV(0DJNDQDV
$.DUDQWDQDV,UDNOLRQ*5 YDVVDORXH#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIIHFWRIVHYHUHRVWHRDUWKULWLV 2$ DQG$&/LQMXU\RQWKH
NQHHMRLQWFRQÀJXUDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 05 LPDJHV IRU SDWLHQWV ZHUH UHYLHZHG *URXSL
FRQVLVWHG RI SDWLHQWV \ ZLWK 05, GLDJQRVLV RWKHU WKDQ VHYHUH 2$
FKRQGUDOGHIHFWVVWDJH,, DQG$&/LQMXU\*URXS,,DLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWV
\ ZLWKFRPSOHWHFKURQLFRUUHFHQW$&/WHDUDQG,,ESDWLHQWV \ ZLWK
SDUWLDOFKURQLFRUUHFHQW$&/WHDU*URXS,,,HQFRPSDVVHGSDWLHQWV \
ZLWKVHYHUH2$ FKRQGUDOGHIHFWV!VWDJH,, 7KHIHPRUDODQJOHZDVGHÀQHGLQWKH
D[LDOSODQHE\GUDZLQJDKRUL]RQWDOOLQHDQGDOLQHWDQJHQWWRWKHSRVWHULRUDVSHFW
RIWKHFRUWH[RIWKHIHPRUDOFRQG\OHVDWWKHLUPD[LPXPDQWHURSRVWHULRUGLDPHWHU
7KHWLELDODQJOHZDVPHDVXUHGVLPLODUO\RQHVOLFHDERYHWKHKHDGRIWKHÀEXOD7KH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
IHPRURWLELDODQJOH )7$ ZDVGHÀQHGDVWKHIHPRUDODQJOHPLQXVWKHWLELDODQJOH
$OOSDWLHQWV DJHVZHUHUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV 7KHUH ZDV VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH UHJDUGLQJ WKH )7$ EHWZHHQ JURXSL
DQGJURXSV,,D,,EDQG,,, LQGHSHQGHQWVDPSOHVWWHVWS DQG
RIWKHSDWLHQWVLQJURXSLDQG,,DUHVSHFWLYHO\KDGDQ)7$R1RVLJQLÀFDQW
FRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKH)7$DQGSDWLHQWV DJHZDVREVHUYHGLQDQ\RIWKHJURXSV
&RQFOXVLRQ$&/LQMXU\DQGVHYHUH2$LQGXFHDOWHUDWLRQLQWKHIHPRURWLELDODQDWRPL
FDOUHODWLRQVKLSE\PHDQVRIURWDWLRQRIWKHIHPXULQUHODWLRQWRWKHWLELD7KHDERYH
ÀQGLQJFRXOGEHRIYDOXHLQDVVHVVLQJ$&/WHDUVZLWKHTXLYRFDOGLUHFWVLJQVRQ05,
%
0XOWLSDUDPHWULF05,RIWDODUDQGWLELDOFDUWLODJHLQFDGDYHUDQNOHVDW
7FRUUHODWLRQZLWKLPPXQRKLVWRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV
6=E\Q6$SSULFK9-XUDV36]RPRODQ\L6'RPD\HU67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7
VWHIDQ]E\Q#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7R HYDOXDWH ELRFKHPLFDO 05, WHFKQLTXHV DW 7HVOD VXFK DV VRGLXP
LPDJLQJ DQG 7 PDSSLQJ DV SRWHQWLDO PDUNHUV IRU ELRFKHPLFDO FRPSRVLWLRQ RI
WDODUDQGWLELDOFDUWLODJHLQXSSHUDQNOHMRLQWE\FRUUHODWLQJ05,SDUDPHWHUVZLWK
LPPXQRKLVWRORJLFDOO\DVVHVVHGJO\FRVDPLQRJO\FDQDQGZDWHUFRQWHQWRIFDUWLODJH
LQFDGDYHUDQNOHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQIUHVKFDGDYHUDQNOHVIURPDORFDODQDWRP\GH
SDUWPHQWZHUHXVHGLQWKLVVWXG\6RGLXP05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKJUDGLHQWHFKR
VHTXHQFHRSWLPLVHGIRUDUWLFXODUFDUWLODJHXVLQJVRGLXPRQO\FKDQQHOWUDQVPLW
UHFHLYHNQHHFRLO7KH7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJDPXOWLHFKRVSLQ
HFKRWHFKQLTXHZLWKFKDQQHOWUDQVPLWUHFHLYHNQHHFRLO7DODUDQGWLELDOFDUWLODJH
RIHDFKFDGDYHUDQNOHZDVGLYLGHGLQWRODWHUDOFHQWUDODQGPHGLDOSDUWDQGUHJLRQ
RILQWHUHVW DQDO\VHV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG RQ FRUUHVSRQGLQJ 05 LPDJHV 5HVXOWDQW
VRGLXPVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 DQG7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWK
HDFK RWKHU DV ZHOO DV ZLWK LPPXQRKLVWRORJLFDOO\ DVVHVVHG JO\FRVDPLQRJO\FDQ
DQGZDWHUFRQWHQWRIWDODUDQGWLELDOFDUWLODJH
5HVXOWV6WURQJ3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQVRGLXP615
DQGJO\FRVDPLQRJO\FDQFRQWHQWLQWDODU U DQGWLELDO U FDUWLODJHDV
ZHOODVEHWZHHQ7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVDQGZDWHUFRQWHQWLQWLELDOFDUWLODJH U
/RZFRUUHODWLRQZDVREVHUYHGEHWZHHQ7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVDQGZDWHUFRQWHQWLQ
WDODUFDUWLODJH U
&RQFOXVLRQ2EWDLQHGKLJKFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ05,SDUDPHWHUVDQGLPPXQR
KLVWRORJLFDO UHVXOWV YDOLGDWHV WKH ÀQGLQJV RI SURJUHVVLYH 05, PHWKRGV DW 7$
FRQWUDVWIUHHJO\FRVDPLQRJO\FDQVSHFLÀFVRGLXPLPDJLQJDVZHOODVZDWHUDQG
FROODJHQVHQVLWLYH7PDSSLQJDUHIHDVLEOHIRUWKHQRQLQYDVLYHELRFKHPLFDOHYDOX
DWLRQRIWKHWDODUDQGWLELDOFDUWLODJHLQUHDVRQDEOHVFDQWLPHV
%
8&6)VFRUHDQRYHOTXDQWLWDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWVFRUHIRUFDUWLODJH
OHVLRQVLQHDUO\RVWHRDUWKULWLVGDWDIURPWKHRVWHRDUWKULWLVLQLWLDWLYH
+$OL]DL:9LUD\DYDQLFK*%-RVHSK/1DUGR+/LHEO3-XQJPDQQ
0&1HYLWW&(0F&XOORFK70/LQN6DQ)UDQFLVFR&$86
KDP]DDOL]DL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH ,Q WKLV VWXG\ ZH GHVFULEH D TXDQWLWDWLYH VFRULQJ V\VWHP IRU FDUWLODJH
OHVLRQVWHVWLWVUHOLDELOLW\DQGYDOLGLW\DQGFRPSDUHLWZLWKHVWDEOLVKHGVHPLTXDQ
WLWDWLYHVFRULQJV\VWHPV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\VHYHQLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWULVNIDFWRUVIRU
NQHH2$ZHUHUDQGRPO\VHOHFWHGIURPWKHRVWHRDUWKULWLVLQLWLDWLYHFRKRUW,QFOXVLRQ
FULWHULDZHUHDJH%0,NJPòQRNQHHSDLQDQGQRUDGLRJUDSKLF2$DW
EDVHOLQH%DVHOLQHDQGPRQWKIROORZXSULJKWNQHH705LPDJHVZHUHDQDO\VHG
XVLQJ:2506%/2.6DQG8&6)6FRUHZLWKDQLQWHUYDORIZHHNVEHWZHHQHDFK
DQDO\VLV3URJUHVVLRQRIFDUWLODJHOHVLRQVXVLQJHDFKVFRULQJV\VWHPZDVFDOFXODWHG
DQGFRPSDUHGXVLQJPXOWLOHYHOPL[HGHIIHFWOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOV:HLJKWHG
.DSSDYDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGWRGHWHUPLQHUHOLDELOLW\
5HVXOWV 7KH 8&6)6FRUH DVVHVVHV IHDWXUHV RI FDUWLODJH GHIHFWV GLDPHWHU
QXPEHURIVHFWLRQVVHFWLRQWKLFNQHVVGHSWKDQGVKDSHLQNQHHFRPSDUWPHQWV
7KHLQWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHUUHOLDELOLW\IRUWKHWRWDO8&6)6FRUHZHUHFDOFXODWHG
DVDQG,QWHUREVHUYHU.DSSDIRULQGLYLGXDOIHDWXUHVUDQJHGIURP
WR8&6)6FRUHKDGDVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUUDWHIRUGHWHFWLQJFDUWLODJHOHVLRQ
SURJUHVVLRQWKDQ:2506DQG%/2.6 S DQGRIWKH
OHVLRQVSURJUHVVHGZKHQDQDO\VHGZLWK8&6)6FRUH:2506DQG%/2.6UH
VSHFWLYHO\8VLQJ8&6)6FRUHWKHVXEMHFWVZLWK2$ULVNIDFWRUVKDGKLJKHURGGV
RISURJUHVVLRQWKDQVXEMHFWVZLWKRXWULVNIDFWRUV 25S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH8&6)6FRUHLVDQRYHOUHSURGXFLEOHDQGYDOLGTXDQWLWDWLYHVFRULQJ
V\VWHPIRUFDUWLODJHOHVLRQVZKLFKSURYLGHVDQLPSURYHGGHWHFWLRQUDWHIRUPRQLWRU
LQJHDUO\2$SURJUHVVLRQFRPSDUHGWRWKHVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH:2506DQG%/2.6
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHPHDVXUHPHQWVDUHOLPLWHGLQPRQLWRULQJDGYDQFHG
FDUWLODJHGHJHQHUDWLRQRIWKHNQHHORQJLWXGLQDOGDWDIURPWKH
RVWHRDUWKULWLVLQLWLDWLYH
30-XQJPDQQ+/LHEO+$OL]DL/1DUGR*-RVHSK-/\QFK
&(0F&XOORFK0&1HYLWW70/LQN6DQ)UDQFLVFR&$86
KDQVOLHEO#XFVIHGX
%
%DVHOLQHPHDQDQGKHWHURJHQHLW\RI05NQHHFDUWLODJH7DUH
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKPRUSKRORJLFGHJHQHUDWLRQRIFDUWLODJHPHQLVFXV
DQGERQHPDUURZRYHUWKUHH\HDUVGDWDIURPWKHRVWHRDUWKULWLVLQLWLDWLYH
7%DXP*%-RVHSK+$OL]DL-&DUEDOOLGR*DPLR/1DUGR:9LUD\DYDQLFK
&(0F&XOORFK60DMXPGDU70/LQN6DQ)UDQFLVFR&$86
WKEDXP#JP[GH
3XUSRVH L 7R VWXG\ WKH QDWXUDO SURJUHVVLRQ RI PRUSKRORJLF FKDQJHV RI WKH
FDUWLODJHPHQLVFXVDQGERQHPDUURZXVLQJDVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHVFRUHDQG LL WR
GHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKHPHDQDQGKHWHURJHQHLW\RI05NQHHFDUWLODJH7DWEDVHOLQH
DUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKPRUSKRORJLFGHJHQHUDWLRQRIWKHVHWLVVXHVRYHUWKUHH\HDUVLQ
VXEMHFWVZLWKULVNIDFWRUVIRUNQHHRVWHRDUWKULWLV 2$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6XEMHFWVZLWKULVNIDFWRUVIRUNQHH2$ Q ZLWKDQ
DJH UDQJH RI \HDUV ZHUH VHOHFWHG IURP WKH RVWHRDUWKULWLV LQLWLDWLYH 2$,
GDWDEDVH7HVOD05LPDJHVRIWKHULJKWNQHHDWEDVHOLQHDQG\HDUIROORZXS
ZHUH DQDO\VHG XVLQJ PRUSKRORJLFDO JUDGLQJV RI FDUWLODJH PHQLVFXV DQG ERQH
PDUURZ :2506VFRULQJ $7PDSSLQJVHTXHQFHZDVXVHGWRDVVHVVEDVHOLQH
PHDQDQGKHWHURJHQHLW\RIFDUWLODJH7 JUH\OHYHOFRRFFXUUHQFHPDWUL[ */&0
WH[WXUHDQDO\VLV 5HJUHVVLRQPRGHOVZHUHXVHGWRDVVHVVWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ
EDVHOLQH7SDUDPHWHUVDQGFKDQJHVLQPRUSKRORJLFNQHH:2506VFRUHVRYHU
WKUHH\HDUV
5HVXOWV7KHSUHYDOHQFHRINQHHDEQRUPDOLWLHVLQWKHFDUWLODJHPHQLVFXVDQG
ERQH PDUURZ VLJQLÀFDQWO\ S LQFUHDVHG IURP EDVHOLQH WR \HDUV LQ DOO
FRPSDUWPHQWVFRPELQHG7KHPHDQDQGKHWHURJHQHLW\RIEDVHOLQHFDUWLODJH7
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S HOHYDWHGLQVXEMHFWVZKRVHFDUWLODJHPHQLVFXVDQG
ERQHPDUURZ:2506VFRUHVLQFUHDVHGRYHUWKUHH\HDUVFRPSDUHGWRVXEMHFWV
ZKRVHVFRUHVGLGQRWFKDQJH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHYDOHQFHRINQHHDEQRUPDOLWLHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGRYHU
WKUHH \HDUV LQFUHDVHG FDUWLODJH 7 DW EDVHOLQH LV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK ORQJLWXGLQDO
PRUSKRORJLFGHJHQHUDWLRQLQWKHFDUWLODJHPHQLVFXVDQGERQHPDUURZRYHUWKUHH
\HDUVLQVXEMHFWVZLWKULVNIDFWRUVIRU2$
%
05EDVHGEDVHOLQH7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHSUHGLFWVSURJUHVVLRQRINQHH
RVWHRDUWKULWLV
/1DUGR$3UDVDG-6FKRROHU+/LHEO70/LQN6DQ)UDQFLVFR&$86
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHZKHWKHU7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVRINQHHFDUWLODJHGHWHUPLQHG
ZLWK705,DWEDVHOLQHSUHGLFWHGORQJLWXGLQDOSURJUHVVLRQRIFDUWLODJHGHJHQHUD
WLYHFKDQJHV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
05,EDVHGDQGFOLQLFDOORQJWHUPUHVXOWVRILVRODWHGRVWHRFKRQGUDO
WUDQVSODQWDWLRQ 2$76 RIWKHNQHHMRLQW
-6%DXHU/.RKQ-3HQ]HO38%UXFNHU$,PKRII(5XPPHQ\
.:RHUWOHU06DXHUVFKQLJ0XQLFK'( MVE#URHPHGWXPGH
3XUSRVH2$76LVDQHVWDEOLVKHGWKHUDS\IRURVWHRFKRQGUDOOHVLRQVDWWKHNQHH
MRLQW+RZHYHUORQJWHUPUHVXOWVUHJDUGLQJFOLQLFDODQGPRUSKRORJLFDORXWFRPHGR
QRWH[LVWLQDXQLIRUPSDWLHQWVHWVRIDU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H IROORZHG XS SDWLHQWV P I ¡ DJH \
LQDYHUDJH\HDUV DIWHULVRODWHG2$76WKHUDS\RIWKHPHGDORUODWHUDO
IHPRUDOFRQG\OH&OLQLFDOVFRUHV :20$&/\VKROP,.'&7HJQHUVFRUH9$6
ZHUHREWDLQHGDQG05LPDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGDW7SUHVXUJHU\DQGDW7
DWIROORZXSXVLQJVWDQGDUGPRUSKRORJLFDOVHTXHQFHV WULSODQDUIDWVDWXUDWHGLQ
WHUPHGLDWHZHLJKWHGIDVWVSLQHFKRVDJLWWDO7ZHLJKWHGIDVWVSLQHFKRVHTXHQFH
VSDWLDO UHVROXWLRQ [[ PP DQG 7PDSSLQJ PXOWLHFKR VSLQ HFKR
7( PV75 PVUHVROXWLRQ[[PP ([FOXVLRQ
FULWHULDZHUHOLJDPHQWUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZHGJHRVWHRWRPLHVPHQLVFDOUHVHFWLRQVDQG
NLVVLQJOHVLRQV3URJUHVVLRQRIRVWHRDUWKULWLVZDVTXDQWLÀHGLQ05LPDJHVXVLQJ
WKH%/2.VFRUH7UDQVSODQWLQWHJUDWLRQZDVHYDOXDWHGXVLQJWKH02&$57VFRUH
&DUWLODJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJ7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHV
5HVXOWV&RPSDULQJSUHVXUJHU\ZLWKIROORZXSVLJQLÀFDQWLPSURYHPHQWZDVIRXQG
LQFDVHRI9$6:20$&DQG/\VKROPVFRUH7KH7HJQHUVFRUHGLGQRWVKRZGLI
IHUHQFHV S! %/2.6LQFUHDVHGLQ2$DVVRFLDWHGÀQGLQJVOLNHRVWHRSK\WHV
$YHUDJH7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVRIWKH2$76F\OLQGHUV GLGQRWVKRZVLJQLÀ
FDQWGLIIHUHQFHVWRQRUPDOFDUWLODJH +RZHYHUWKHDGMDFHQWFDUWLODJHQH[W
WRWKHF\OLQGHUGHPRQVWUDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU7YDOXHV S
&RQFOXVLRQ,VRODWHG2$76WKHUDS\VKRZVJRRGORQJWHUPUHVXOWVERWKFOLQLFDOO\
DQGPRUSKRORJLFDOO\7KH7HOHYDWLRQRIWKHVXUURXQGLQJFDUWLODJHPD\VXJJHVW
DSUHH[LVWLQJGHIHFWLQFDUWLODJHXOWUDVWUXFWXUHODUJHUWKDQWKHUHSODFHGDUHDQRW
YLVLEOHIRUWKHVXUJHRQ
%
/RQJWHUPUHVXOWV\HDUVDIWHUDXWRORJRXVRVWHRFKRQGUDO
WUDQVSODQWDWLRQ7JDJ&(67DQGVRGLXPPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
LPDJLQJZLWKPRUSKRORJLFDODQGFOLQLFDOFRUUHODWLRQ
%6FKPLWW,.UXVFKH0DQGO6$SSULFK9-XUDV67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7
EHQMDPLQVFKPLWW#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH 7KH DLP RI WKH VWXG\ ZDV WR FRPSDUH PRUSKRORJLFDO 02&$57
ELRFKHPLFDO 7PDSSLQJJDJ&(67DQGVRGLXPLPDJLQJ DQGFOLQLFDOORQJWHUP
UHVXOWVDIWHUDXWRORJRXVRVWHRFKRQGUDOWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ $27
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWK$27DWWKHLUNQHHMRLQWVFRQ
VHQWHGWRSDUWLFLSDWHLQFOLQLFDO ,.'&PRGLÀHG/\VKROPDQG9$6 DQGUDGLRORJLFDO
ORQJWHUPIROORZXSDWDPHGLDQRI\HDUV ,45 0RUSKRORJLFDO05,
ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQD705XQLWDQGLQFOXGHG3'ZLPDJLQJZLWKDQGZLWKRXWIDW
VXSSUHVVLRQ7ZDQG7ZLPDJLQJIURPZKLFKWKH02&$57VFRUHZDVGHULYHG
7PDSSLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGDW7XVLQJDPXOWLHFKRVSLQHFKRDSSURDFK6RGLXP
DQG&(6705,ZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD7ZKROHERG\05VFDQQHU
5HVXOWV 7KH GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ QDWLYH DQG UHSDLU FDUWLODJH ZDV VWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQW UHJDUGLQJ PHGLDQ 7 YDOXHV PHGLDQ &(67 DV\PPHWU\ DQG PHGLDQ
VRGLXP6157KHPHGLDQ02&$57VFRUHUHYHDOHGSRLQWVWKHPHGLDQPRGLÀHG
/\VKROPVFRUHDQGWKHPHGLDQ9$6ZDV7KHVWURQJHVWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ
05,SDUDPHWHUVZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQVRGLXP615UDWLRVDQG&(67DV\PPHWU\
UDWLRV ѩ S VKRZLQJFRQVLVWHQWSURWHRJO\FDQDVVHVVPHQWDW7
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH 7R DQDO\VH WKH QDWXUDO WZR\HDU GHYHORSPHQW RI NQHH FDUWLODJH 7
UHOD[DWLRQWLPHPHDVXUHPHQWVLQUHODWLRQWRWKHH[WHQWRIPRUSKRORJLFDOFDUWLODJH
DEQRUPDOLWLHVDVVHVVHGZLWK7HVOD05LPDJHVIURPWKHRVWHRDUWKULWLVLQLWLDWLYH
LQFLGHQFHFRKRUW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5LJKWNQHH05,VRI\HDUROGLQGLYLGXDOV
PDOHVIHPDOHV ZLWKULVNIDFWRUVIRURVWHRDUWKULWLV 2$ EXWZLWKRXWUDGLRJUDSKLF
2$RUNQHHSDLQDWEDVHOLQHZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\&DUWLODJHZDVVHJPHQWHG
DQG7PDSVZHUHJHQHUDWHGLQÀYHFRPSDUWPHQWV SDWHOODPHGLDODQGODWHUDO
IHPRUDOFRQG\OHPHGLDODQGODWHUDOWLELDSODWHDX DWEDVHOLQHDQGWZR\HDUIROORZXS
7FKDQJHVRYHU\HDUVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKEDVHOLQH7YDOXHVDVZHOODVFDUWLODJH
GHJHQHUDWLYHFKDQJHVDVVHVVHGZLWKZKROHRUJDQ05LPDJLQJVFRUHV :2506
6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWK$129$DQGWZRVLGHG6WXGHQWVWWHVWV
5HVXOWV /RQJLWXGLQDO 7 FKDQJHV ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ QHJDWLYHO\ FRUUHODWHG ZLWK
ERWKEDVHOLQH 3 DQGIROORZXS 3 FDUWLODJH:25063DWLHQWVWKDW
GHYHORSHGQHZFDUWLODJHGHIHFWVKDGVLJQLÀFDQWO\VPDOOHULQFUHDVHLQ7YDOXHVWKDQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKRXWQHZOHVLRQV PV YHUVXVPV 3
)XUWKHULQGLYLGXDOVZLWKKLJKHUEDVHOLQH7VKRZHGVPDOOHU7LQFUHDVHVRYHUWLPH
LQDOOFRPSDUWPHQWV 3
&RQFOXVLRQ$Q LQYHUVH FRUUHODWLRQ RI ORQJLWXGLQDO 7 UHOD[DWLRQ WLPH FKDQJHV
YHUVXVEDVHOLQH7YDOXHVDQGPRUSKRORJLFDOFDUWLODJHDEQRUPDOLWLHVZDVIRXQG
VXJJHVWLQJWKDW7YDOXHVPD\QRWEHZHOOVXLWHGIRUPRQLWRULQJDGYDQFHGGHJHQHUD
WLYHGLVHDVH7KLVPD\EHGXHWRDWUXHQHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQLQ7PHDVXUHPHQWV
FHLOLQJHIIHFWVRUUHJUHVVLRQWRWKHPHDQ
0HWKRGV 4XDQWLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV RI FDUWLODJH ZDV SHUIRUPHG XVLQJ 7 05, ZLWK
ERWK7PDSSLQJWHFKQLTXHVLQLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKPLOG2$ .HOOHJUHQ/DZUHQFH
>./@VFRUHRI GLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVRISURJUHVVRUV VXEMHFWV DQGQRQ
SURJUHVVRUV VXEMHFWV 0RUSKRORJLFDO DEQRUPDOLWLHV RI FDUWLODJH PHQLVFL
OLJDPHQWVDQGERQHPDUURZZHUHDQDO\VHGRQVDJLWWDOIDWVDWXUDWHG7ZHLJKWHG
IDVW VSLQ HFKR )6( VHTXHQFHV DQG SURJUHVVLRQ RI GHJHQHUDWLYH GLVHDVH ZDV
DVVHVVHGRYHUDSHULRGRIWZR\HDUV'LIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHLQ
SURJUHVVLRQDQGQRQSURJUHVVLRQFRKRUWVZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJRQHZD\DQDO\VLV
RIYDULDQFH $129$ DQGWWHVWV
5HVXOWV6LJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQEDVHOLQH7YDOXHVZHUHIRXQGEHWZHHQSURJUHV
VLRQDQGQRQSURJUHVVLRQFRKRUWVLQDOOFRPSDUWPHQWV S H[FHSWWKHODWHUDO
WLELDPHGLDOIHPXU S PHGLDOWLELD S ODWHUDOIHPXU S
DQGSDWHOOD S
&RQFOXVLRQ7PDSSLQJWHFKQLTXHVGLIIHUHQWLDWHGLQGLYLGXDOVZLWKDQGZLWKRXW
SURJUHVVLRQRIGHJHQHUDWLYHDEQRUPDOLWLHVDQGPD\WKHUHIRUHEHXVHGDVSUHGLF
WRUVIRUSURJUHVVLRQRINQHH2$
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
$FRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ05,SDUDPHWHUVDQGFOLQLFDOVFRUHVZDVRQO\IRXQGEHWZHHQ
7UDWLRVDQGPRGLÀHG/\VKROP ѩ S
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUUHVXOWVLPSO\WKDWWKHK\DOLQHFKDUDFWHURI$27JUDIWVVHHPVWR
GHJHQHUDWHLQWKHORQJWHUP$27FDQVWLOOEHUHFRPPHQGHGDVDQRSWLRQIRUWKH
WUHDWPHQWRIOLPLWHGVL]HGFDUWLODJHGHIHFWVGXHWRIHZFRUUHODWLRQVIRXQGEHWZHHQ
05,DQGFOLQLFDOVFRUHV
5RRP)
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
%
66
*G(2%'73$HQKDQFHG705,IRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIKHSDWLF
PHWDVWDVLVIURPFRORUHFWDOFDQFHULVPHWDVWDVLVDOZD\VVHHQDVD
´GHIHFWµRQWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVH"
$.LP&/HH..LP-&KRL-/HH<3DUN&3DUN6HRXO.5
DUNLPUDG#JPDLOFRP
05, KLJKÀHOG
0RGHUDWRUV
.+RO]DSIHO0XQLFK'(
2/XFLGDUPH3DULV)5
%
2SWLPLVDWLRQRIOLYHULQWUDYR[HOLQFRKHUHQWPRWLRQLPDJLQJSURWRFRO
DW7IRUFKURQLFOLYHUGLVHDVHVDVVHVVPHQW
%/HSRUT)3LOOHXO2%HXI9LOOHXUEDQQH)5
EHQMDPLQOHSRUT#FUHDWLVLQVDO\RQIU
3XUSRVH7RRSWLPLVHD7DFTXLVLWLRQSURWRFROIRUOLYHULQWUDYR[HOLQFRKHUHQW
PRWLRQ ,9,0 LPDJLQJWREHLQFOXGHGLQDFOLQLFDOVWXG\IRFXVHGRQFKURQLFOLYHU
GLVHDVHV)RXUVHWRISDUDPHWHUVZHUHHYDOXDWHGRQÀIWHHQKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV
0HWKRGV,QYDULDQWSDUDPHWHUVZHUHH':,VHTXHQFHZLWKEYDOXHV
VPP PV75D[LDOVOLFHVðPPò
)29ðPDWUL[PPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV.+]EDQGZLGWK9DULDEOHSDUDPHWHUV
DFFRUGLQJWRWKHIRXUVHWWLQJVZHUHD UHVSLUDWRU\WULJJHULQJ1(;PV7(
SHUSHQGLFXODUGLIIXVLRQJUDGLHQWVDSSOLHGVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ RSWLRQ´LQµ DQGҋ
DYHUDJH VFDQ GXUDWLRQ E )UHHEUHDWKLQJ 1(; PV 7( LQ RSWLRQ DQG
ҋµVFDQGXUDWLRQF )UHHEUHDWKLQJ1(;PV7(SHUSHQGLFXODUGLIIXVLRQ
JUDGLHQWVDSSOLHGVHTXHQWLDOO\ ´DOOµRSWLRQ DQGҋµVFDQGXUDWLRQG 9DULDEOH1(;
DFFRUGLQJWREYDOXHV 1(;IURPWRVPP DGGLWLRQDO
VPPEYDOXHPV7(´DOOµGLIIXVLRQRSWLRQDQGҋµVFDQGXUDWLRQ3XUH
PROHFXODU GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW 'VORZ SHUIXVLRQUHODWHG FRHIÀFLHQW 'IDVW DQG
SHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ I ZHUHREWDLQHGE\DQRQOLQHDUOHDVWVTXDUHÀWWRWKH,9,0PRGHO
5HVXOWV 0HDQ ,9,0 SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH I DQG
'6ORZ ð PP
VHF ')DVW ð PPVHF IRU
SURWRFROD E F G UHVSHFWLYHO\%ODQG$OWPDQSORWVZHUHQRWVKRZQVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQVHWWLQJV
&RQFOXVLRQ +LJK VLJQDO DYHUDJLQJ UHVWULFWHG PRWLRQ DUWHIDFWV FDXVHG E\ IUHH
EUHDWKLQJ LPDJLQJ DQG DOORZHG IUHHEUHDWKLQJ WHFKQLTXH 7KH VPDUWDYHUDJLQJ
SURFHGXUHUHGXFHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\WKHVFDQGXUDWLRQZLWKVLPLODU615IRUWKHKLJKHVW
QXPEHUVRIEYDOXHVDQGWKUHHSHUSHQGLFXODUGLIIXVLRQJUDGLHQWVVHTXHQWLDOO\DS
SOLHG7KLVVHWWLQJLVDVXLWDEOHFRPSURPLVHWREHDGGHGLQDFOLQLFDOSURWRFROEH
WZHHQDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHPRGHOOLQJUHOLDELOLW\UHSURGXFLELOLW\DQGSDWLHQWDFFHSWDQFH
%
&DQZHGLIIHUHQWLDWHLQÀOWUDWLYHKHSDWRFHOOXDUFDUFLQRPDDQG
FRQÁXHQWÀEURVLVLQEDFNJURXQGOLYHUFLUUKRVLVZLWK*G(2%'73$
HQKDQFHG705,"
<3DUN&/HH..LP-&KRL-/HH&3DUN6HRXO.5
S\V#QDYHUFRP
3XUSRVH 7R UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ GHWHUPLQH WKH VLJQLÀFDQW 05, IHDWXUHV IRU WKH GLI
IHUHQWLDWLRQRILQÀOWUDWLYHKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& IURPFRQÁXHQWÀEURVLV
LQOLYHUFLUUKRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$IWHUVHDUFKRISDWKRORJLFDQGUDGLRORJLFGDWDEDVHVRI
LQÀOWUDWLYH+&&DQGRIFRQÁXHQWÀEURVLVHYDOXDWHGZLWK*G(2%'73$HQKDQFHG
705,IURPWRZHUHUHYLHZHG7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHG
05LPDJHVLQFRQVHQVXVIRUPRUSKRORJLFFKDQJHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\HQKDQFHPHQW
SDWWHUQDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHDQGSUHVHQFHRISRUWDOYHLQ
WKURPERVLVGXFWGLODWDWLRQDQGPHWDVWDWLFO\PSKQRGH&OLQLFDOÀQGLQJVVXFKDV
WXPRXUPDUNHUDQGV\PSWRPDOVRZHUHUHFRUGHG8QLYDULDWHDQDO\VHVZHUHXVHG
WRGLIIHUHQWLDWHWKHVHHQWLWLHV
5HVXOWV$OOLQÀOWUDWLYH+&&VKRZHGSUHVHUYDWLRQRIFRQWRXURUFRQWRXUEXOJLQJDQG
DOOFRQÁXHQWÀEURVLVVKRZHGFDSVXODUUHWUDFWLRQ,QÀOWUDWLYH+&&PDQLIHVWHGDUWHULDO
HQKDQFHPHQW DQG SRUWDO YHLQ WKURPERVLV &RQÁXHQW ÀEURVLV DS
SHDUHGGHOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQW $'&ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQLQÀOWUDWLYH+&&
6
$
%
&
WKDQLQFRQÁXHQWÀEURVLV [PPVDQG[PPV
S &RPSDUHGZLWK7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHVKRZHGPRUH
GLVFUHWHPDUJLQDQGQRGXODUFRQÀJXUDWLRQLQLQÀOWUDWLYH+&&DQGPRUHLQGLVWLQFW
DQGZHGJHVKDSHLQFRQÁXHQWÀEURVLV
&RQFOXVLRQ3UHVHUYDWLRQRIOLYHUFRQWRXURUFRQWRXUEXOJLQJSRUWDOYHLQWKURP
ERVLVDQGORZ$'&YDOXHZHUHIRXQGWREHKLJKO\VXJJHVWLYH05ÀQGLQJVIRUGLI
IHUHQWLDWLRQRILQÀOWUDWLYH+&&IURPFRQÁXHQWÀEURVLVLQOLYHUFLUUKRVLV+HSDWRELOLDU\
SKDVHLPSURYHVFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQDQGGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIH[WHQWDQGPDUJLQRIWKH
OHVLRQWRGLVWLQJXLVKWKHVHWZRHQWLWLHV
'
(
)
*
+
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH VSHFLÀF LPDJLQJ IHDWXUHV RI KHSDWLF PHWDVWDVLV IURP
FRORUHFWDOFDQFHUIRFXVLQJRQWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVH +%3 RI*G(2%'73$
HQKDQFHG05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2YHUD\HDUSHULRGKHSDWLFPHWDVWDWLFOHVLRQVZHUH
LGHQWLÀHGIURPSDWLHQWV PHQDQGZRPHQ ZKRSURYHQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
DQG XQGHUZHQW *G(2%'73$HQKDQFHG 7 05, +HSDWLF PHWDVWDVHV ZHUH
SURYHQSDWKRORJLFDOO\LQSDWLHQWVE\VXUJLFDOOLYHUUHVHFWLRQ Q DQGE\86
JXLGHGELRSV\ Q 7KHUHPDLQLQJSDWLHQWVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGWRKDYHKHSDWLF
PHWDVWDVLV EDVHG RQ LPDJLQJ VWXGLHV DQG FOLQLFDO LQIRUPDWLRQ 7ZR UDGLRORJLVWV
HYDOXDWHGWKHLPDJLQJIHDWXUHVRIHDFK05,VHTXHQFHLQFOXGLQJKLJKUHVROXWLRQ
7:,G\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWVWXG\ZLWKKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHDQGGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGLPDJH:HDOVRFRPSDUHG6,RIWKHOHVLRQVRQ7:,DQG+%3
5HVXOWV7:,VKRZHGKRPRJHQHRXVKLJK6, Q WDUJHWDSSHDUDQFH
Q UHYHUVHGWDUJHWDSSHDUDQFH Q DQGKHWHURJHQHRXVO\KLJK
6, Q 2Q+%3KRPRJHQHRXVGHIHFWZDVVHHQLQOHVLRQV
WDUJHWDSSHDUDQFHLQÀYHOHVLRQV UHYHUVHGWDUJHWDSSHDUDQFHLQWZROH
VLRQV DQGKHWHURJHQHRXVGHIHFWLQOHVLRQV LQFOXGLQJUHWLFXODU
SDUWLDOO\JOREXODU DQGGLIIXVH**2OLNH SDWWHUQV$FFRUGLQJWR
WKHLPDJLQJIHDWXUHVRQ+%3WKHKRPRJHQHRXVGHIHFWDQGKHWHURJHQHRXVGHIHFW
JURXSVKDGDPHDQ$'&YDOXHRI[DQG[PPVHFUHVSHFWLYHO\
ZLWKRXWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ +HSDWLF PHWDVWDVLV IURP FRORUHFWDO FDQFHU XVXDOO\ VKRZHG DV D
KHWHURJHQHRXVGHIHFWRQ+%3DQGDKHWHURJHQHRXVKLJK6,RQ7:,7KHJHQHU
DOO\DFFHSWHG´WUXHGHIHFWµZDVQRWDFRPPRQÀQGLQJLQKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVLVIURP
FRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
%
4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIOLYHUIDWFRQWHQWE\7HVODVSHFWURVFRS\PDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFH 7650 LQQRQDOFRKROLFIDWW\OLYHUGLVHDVHFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKVHUXPOHYHOVRIDODQLQHDPLQRWUDQVIHUDVH $/7
-/0DUWLQ5RGULJXH]---LPHQH]0ROHRQ-0DFKDGR*DOODV
051DYDUUR/DEUDW09HODVFR7RUUHV-6DQFKH]*RQ]DOH]
-/*RQ]DOH]&DOYLQ*UDQDGD(6 MRVHOXLVPDUWLQU[#KRWPDLOFRP
6HUXPOHYHOVRI$/7LVDELRPDUNHUQRQDOFRKROLFIDWW\OLYHUGLVHDVH 1$)/' 2QO\
DSURSRUWLRQRISDWLHQWVZLWK1$)/'KDYHHOHYDWHGVHUXP$/7OHYHOV
3XUSRVH7RNQRZLIWKHUHLVDUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQOLYHUIDWFRQWHQWDQGVHUXP
OHYHOVRI$/7DVZHOODVWRVWXG\LIWKHUHLVDWKUHVKROGZLWKLQGHFXUUHQWQRUPDO
$/7YDOXHVIURPZKLFKZHFRXOGVXJJHVWWKHSUHVHQFHRI1$)/'
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KLV LV D FRPPXQLW\ SURVSHFWLYH FURVVVHFWLRQDO
UDQGRPVWXG\*URXS$VXEMHFWVZLWKHOHYDWHGVHUXP$/7OHYHOV !8/
ZLWKRXWDQ\NQRZQFDXVHDOFRKROYLUDOKHSDWLWLVDXWRLPPXQHGUXJVDQGRWKHUV
ZHUHH[FOXGHG*URXS%VXEMHFWVZLWKVHUXP$/7OHYHOVEHWZHHQDQG
8/*URXS&VXEMHFWVZLWKVHUXP$/78/4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIOLYHUIDWE\
VSHFWURVFRS\+057:HXVHGDFXWRIIYDOXH!RIOLYHUIDWFRQWHQWIRUWKH
GLDJQRVLVRIKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLV
5HVXOWV7KHSURSRUWLRQZLWKKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLVZDVJURXS$JURXS%
*URXS& SIRUJURXS%RU&YVJURXS$ $VLJQLÀFDQWSRVLWLYHFRU
UHODWLRQZDVREVHUYHGEHWZHHQOLYHUIDWFRQWHQWDQG$/7VHUXPOHYHOV U
S
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUVWXG\VKRZVWKDWWKHUHLVDSRVLWLYHVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ
OLYHUIDWFRQWHQWDQGVHUXP$/7OHYHOVLQVXEMHFWVZLWK1$)/'RIVXEMHFWV
ZLWK´QRUPDOµ$/7OHYHOV 8/ KDGKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLV:HVXJJHVWWKDWVHUXP
$/7FRXOGEHDXVHIXOELRPDUNHURI1$)/'LIWKHQRUPDOWKUHVKROGLVHVWDEOLVKHG
DW$/7OHYHOV8/
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
/LYHULQWUDYR[HOLQFRKHUHQWPRWLRQLPDJLQJDW7FRPSDULVRQZLWK
FRQYHQWLRQDOGXDOEYDOXHVPHWKRG
%/HSRUT)3LOOHXO2%HXI9LOOHXUEDQQH)5
EHQMDPLQOHSRUT#FUHDWLVLQVDO\RQIU
%
$SSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWYDOXHVRIKHDOWK\SDQFUHDVIURP
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJRIXSSHUDEGRPHQDW7
&0D&3DQ+=KDQJ+:DQJ-:DQJ6&KHQ-/X6KDQJKDL&1
PHQJTLKL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R FODULI\ WKH DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHV LQ GLIIHUHQW
DQDWRPLFDOUHJLRQV KHDGQHFNERG\DQGWDLO RIQRUPDOSDQFUHDV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7KH VWXG\ VXEMHFWV FRPSULVHG SDWLHQWV ZLWK FRQ
ÀUPHGKHDOWK\SDQFUHDV(FKRSODQDUGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, RIXSSHU
DEGRPHQZDVSHUIRUPHGE\DSSO\LQJWZREYDOXHVRIDQGVPPDWD7
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, V\VWHP$'&YDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHGLQ
YDULRXVUHJLRQVRISDQFUHDV'HSHQGHQF\RI$'&RQWKHDQDWRPLFDOUHJLRQVZDV
DQDO\VHGXVLQJ.UXVNDO:DOOLVWHVWDQG:LOFR[RQVLJQUDQNWHVW
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHRIWKHZKROHKHDOWK\SDQFUHDVLVð
PPV7KHUHVXOWVRI.UXVNDO:DOOLVWHVWVKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHRIWKH
$'&YDOXHVDPRQJWKHDQDWRPLFDOUHJLRQVDQGWKHORZHVWYDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHG
LQWKHSDQFUHDWLFKHDG KHDGQHFNERG\DQGWDLO
ðPPV&KLVTXDUH 'I 3 7KHUHVXOWVRI
:LOFR[RQVLJQUDQNWHVWVKRZHGWKHPHDQ$'&VGLIIHUHGUHPDUNDEO\EHWZHHQKHDG
DQGQHFN 3 KHDGDQGERG\ 3 KHDGDQGWDLO 3
QHFNDQGWDLO 3 ERG\DQGWDLO 3 UHVSHFWLYHO\EXWWKH
PHDQ$'&VRIQHFNDQGERG\ 3 ! VKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHVRIQRUPDOSDQFUHDVYDULHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKLQ
WKHGLIIHUHQWDQDWRPLFDOUHJLRQV7KHUHIRUHLWLVQHFHVVDU\WRXWLOLVHWKHVHUHVXOWV
LQUHODWHGVWXGLHVRUFOLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQVIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQGLIIHUHQWSDQ
FUHDWLFGLVHDVHV
%
7HVODYV7HVODYHUVXV7HVODDEGRPLQDO05,WKHPRUH7HVOD
WKHEHWWHU"
/8PXWOX2.UDII$)LVFKHU0)RUVWLQJ0(/DGG60DGHUZDOG
7&/DXHQVWHLQ(VVHQ'( /DOH8PXWOX#XNHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHDQGFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLF
DELOLW\RIDQG7HVODDEGRPLQDO05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVZHUHHDFKH[DPLQHGRQD7
0DJQHWRP$HUD D7 0DJQHWRP6N\UD DQGD705V\VWHP 0DJQHWRP7
6LHPHQV 7KHIROORZLQJVHTXHQFHVZHUHREWDLQHG 7ZIV')/$6+ 7Z
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
,PSOHPHQWDWLRQRIGXDOVRXUFH5)H[FLWDWLRQWHFKQLTXHVZLWK
7LPDJLQJV\VWHPVDOORZVIRUQHDUO\LGHQWLFDO$'&YDOXHVLQ
FRPSDULVRQWR705VFDQQHUVZKHQLPDJLQJWKHDEGRPHQ
35LIIHO55DR00H\HU3.HWWQDFNHU$/HPNH6+DQHGHU
626FK|QEHUJ+-0LFKDHO\0DQQKHLP'(*DOYHVWRQ7;86
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQGSURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHI
ÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHVREWDLQHGZLWKLQFOLQLFDOO\UHOHYDQWDEGRPLQDOUHJLRQVLQD
7 V\VWHP DQG 7 V\VWHPV ZLWK DQG ZLWKRXW GXDO VRXUFH SDUDOOHO 5) H[FLWDWLRQ
WHFKQLTXHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJHVRIWKHDEGRPHQZHUHREWDLQHG
RQWKUHHGLIIHUHQW05V\VWHPV 7ÀUVWJHQHUDWLRQ7DQGVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ
7ZKLFKLQFRUSRUDWHVGXDOVRXUFHSDUDOOHO5)H[FLWDWLRQ RQSDWLHQWVUHWUR
VSHFWLYHO\DQGYROXQWHHUVSURVSHFWLYHO\6HYHQUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUH
VHOHFWHGWRUHSUHVHQWDUHDVRIFOLQLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFH
5HVXOWV,QWKHSDWLHQWSRSXODWLRQWKHGLIIHUHQFHVLQPHDQ$'&YDOXHVEHWZHHQ
ÀUVWJHQHUDWLRQ7DQGWKHRWKHUWZR05VFDQQHUVUDQJHGIURP NLGQH\V XS
WRLQWKHOHIWOREHRIWKHOLYHU 7[VPPÀUVWJHQHUDWLRQ7
[VPPVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ7[VPP 7KH$'&YDOXHV
PHDVXUHG EHWZHHQ WKH 7 DQG VHFRQG JHQHUDWLRQ 7 V\VWHPV ZHUH QHDUO\
LGHQWLFDOZLWKQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHWZRV\VWHPV,QWKHYROXQWHHU
SRSXODWLRQFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ7DQGVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ7V\VWHPVLQWKH
NLGQH\VUDQJHGIURPU DQGLQWKHUHPDLQLQJUHJLRQV EHVLGHVWKHVSOHHQ
U!7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHVIURPPRVWDQDWRPLFDOGLVWULEXWLRQVREWDLQHGZLWK
WKHÀUVWJHQHUDWLRQ7VFDQQHUGLVDJUHHGZLWKWKHRWKHUWZRVFDQQHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ$VHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ7VFDQQHUZKLFKLQFRUSRUDWHVGXDOVRXUFH
SDUDOOHO5)H[FLWDWLRQSURYLGHVQHDUO\LGHQWLFDO$'&YDOXHVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKH
7LPDJLQJV\VWHPLQDEGRPLQDOLPDJLQJ
%
(YDOXDWLRQRI77 DQG7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVLQ\RXQJDQGDJLQJUDW
OLYHUDW7
56HLGHO.0DWWKHV$0XHOOHU$%XHFNHU3)ULHV
+RPEXUJ'( GUURODQGVHLGHO#VFKODXFRP
3XUSRVH7R DVVHVV77 DQG7 UHOD[DWLRQ WLPHV LQ KHDOWK\ UDW OLYHU DW
7LQYLYRDQGWRFRUUHODWHWKHLQÁXHQFLQJHIIHFWRIDJLQJIRUGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIDQ
H[SHULPHQWDOVWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,Q:$*5LMUDWVRIGLIIHUHQWDJHJURXSV JURXS
1 DJHRIZHHNVJURXS1 DJHRI\HDUV OLYHU05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQ
D705DQLPDOVFDQQHU %UXNHU%LR6SHF*HUPDQ\ XVLQJFKDQQHOYROXPH
FRLO$5$5(VHTXHQFHZLWKIRXUGLIIHUHQWUHSHWLWLRQDQGHFKRWLPHVZDVDFTXLUHG
IRU7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHPHDVXUHPHQW7 UHOD[DWLRQWLPHZDVPHDVXUHGE\DPXOWL
JUDGLHQWHFKR 0*( VHTXHQFH$PXOWLVOLFHPXOWLSOHHFKRVHTXHQFH 060( ZDV
XVHGIRU7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHPHDVXUHPHQW7DQG7PDSSLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWK
DQLPDJHVHTXHQFHDQDO\VLVWRRO$VWXGHQWWWHVWDQG0DQQ:KLWQH\UDQNVXP
WHVWZHUHSHUIRUPHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV S
5HVXOWV7KHDQLPDOJURXSVGLIIHUHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWUHJDUGLQJDOOLQYHVWLJDWHG
UHOD[DWLRQFKDUDFWHULVWLFV0HDQ7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHIRUJURXSZDVPV 6'
DQGIRUJURXSPV 6' S 0HDQ7 UHOD[DWLRQWLPH
IRUJURXSZDVPV 6' DQGJURXSPV 6' S
0HDQ7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHIRUJURXSZDVPV 6' DQGJURXSPV
6' S
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH 7R UHSRUW RXU H[SHULHQFH DERXW LQWUDYR[HO LQFRKHUHQW PRWLRQ ,9,0
LPDJLQJRQKXPDQOLYHUDQGSKDQWRPWRFRPSDUHWKHELH[SRQHQWLDOGLIIXVLRQSDW
WHUQZLWKWKHFRQYHQWLRQDOGXDOEYDOXHV$'&PHWKRG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$FTXLVLWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGDW7LQIUHHEUHDWKLQJ
RQÀIWHHQKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVWKHQRQDGRSHGDJDUJHOSKDQWRPXVLQJH':,
VHTXHQFH *(+& 3DUDPHWHUVZHUHEYDOXHV
VPP PV75PV7(D[LDOVOLFHVðPPò)29
ðPDWUL[PPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV1(;N+]EDQGZLGWK7KUHHSHUSHQ
GLFXODUGLIIXVLRQJUDGLHQWVZHUHDSSOLHGVLPXOWDQHRXVO\3XUHPROHFXODUGLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQW 'VORZ SHUIXVLRQUHODWHGFRHIÀFLHQW 'IDVW DQGSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ I
ZHUHREWDLQHGE\DQRQOLQHDUOHDVWVTXDUHÀWWRWKHELH[SRQHQWLDO,9,0PRGHO
$'&ZDVFRPSXWHGXVLQJFRQYHQWLRQDOPRQRH[SRQHQWLDOPHWKRGZLWKWZRSDLU
RIEYDOXHVDQG
5HVXOWV 0HDQ ,9,0 SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH '6ORZ ð PPVò
')DVW ðPPVòI PHDQ$'&ZDV' ð
PPVò$VWURQJFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQDEVROXWH ''6ORZ YDOXHDQG
SHUIXVLRQ IUDFWLRQ 3HDUVRQ V FRHIÀFLHQW S %LDV EHWZHHQ ' DQG
'6ORZLQFUHDVHGZKHQ]HUREYDOXHZDVXVHGIRU$'&TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ DQG
IRU VPP DQG VPP UHVSHFWLYHO\ 4XDQWLÀFDWLRQ IURP
SKDQWRPDFTXLVLWLRQJDYHWKHVDPHYDOXHVIRU'DQG'6ORZ ðPPV
DQGGLIIXVLRQIROORZHGDVLPSOHPRQRH[SRQHQWLDOSDWWHUQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHELH[SRQHQWLDOSDWWHUQRIGLIIXVLRQHQFRXQWHUHGLQOLYHUZDVOLQNHG
WRSHUIXVLRQUHODWHGGLIIXVLRQDQGH[SODLQHGWKHELDVEHWZHHQ$'&PHDVXUHGZLWK
PRQRH[SRQHQWLDO DSSURDFK DQG SXUH PROHFXODU GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW H[WUDFWHG
IURP,9,0PRGHOLQJ'XDOEYDOXHVPHWKRGIRU$'&PHDVXUHPHQWFRXOGEHDQ
DOWHUQDWLYHPHWKRGWRDVVHVVWKH'6ORZFRPSRQHQWFKRRVLQJDSSURSULDWHSDLURI
EYDOXHV !
IV9,%( 7Z')/$6+ 7Z'LQDQGRSSRVHGSKDVH 7UXH),63DQG
7Z76(4XDOLWDWLYHLPDJHDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDIRXUSRLQWVFDOH
QRQGLDJQRVWLFWR H[FHOOHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\ UHJDUGLQJ RYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\
GHOLQHDWLRQRIDEGRPLQDOYDVFXODWXUH GHOLQHDWLRQRIWKHELOLDU\GXFWV\VWHPDV
ZHOODV LPDJHLPSDLUPHQWGXHWRDUWHIDFWV)RUFRUUHODWLRQRIVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHV
UHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWZHUHSODFHGLQSDUHQFK\PDWRXVRUJDQV)RUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
D:LOFR[RQUDQNWHVWZDVXVHG
5HVXOWV:LWKLQFUHDVLQJPDJQHWLFÀHOGVWUHQJWKDOOVHTXHQFHVFRXOGEHREWDLQHG
DW KLJKHU VSDWLDO UHVROXWLRQ DW HTXLYDOHQW DFTXLVLWLRQ WLPHV :KLOH RYHUDOO LPDJH
TXDOLW\ZDVUDWHGFRPSDUDEO\KLJKIRU7ZLPDJLQJLQDOOWKUHHÀHOGVWUHQJWKV7
7Z05,VKRZHGLWVVXSHULRULW\LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIQRQHQKDQFHGDEGRPLQDO
YDVFXODWXUH PHDQ 7 PHDQ 7 PHDQ7 4XDQWLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV
UHYHDOHGDQDYHUDJHLQFUHDVHRIWKHPHDQRUJDQVLJQDOIURP7WR7RI
DQGIURP7WR7
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUUHVXOWVGHPRQVWUDWHWKHEHQHÀWVDQGWKHOLPLWDWLRQVRIDQLQFUHDVH
RIWKHPDJQHWLFÀHOGVWUHQJWKRIIHULQJLPSURYHGDQGKLJKO\GHWDLOHGGHOLQHDWLRQRI
DQDWRPLFDODQGYDVFXODUVWUXFWXUHVLQ7ZLPDJLQJ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$W7OLYHUUHOD[DWLRQFKDUDFWHULVWLFVLQUDWOLYHUYDU\ZLWKWKHDJHRI
WKHDQLPDODVDFRQVHTXHQFHRIWLVVXHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQDQGKDYHWREHFRQVLGHUHG
LQH[SHULPHQWDOVHWWLQJV
5RRP)
%
%UHDVW
66
7KHUROHRIEUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLVFRPELQHGZLWKGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\
30DUWtQH]$*DUFLD/DOODQD56DLQ]0HQGLJXUHQ&0LQJXLOORQ/3LQD
=DUDJR]D(63DPSORQD(6 SDXODPDUWLQH]PLUDYHWH#\DKRRHV
7RPRV\QWKHVLVDQG))'0
0RGHUDWRUV
00LFKHOO/RQGRQ8.
(6LRSLV%RORJQD,7
%
6SHFLÀFLW\GLJLWDOEUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLVYHUVXVPDPPRJUDSK\
**HQQDUR(%H]]RQ(%DOGDQ5&KHUVHYDQL&GL0DJJLR
0/D*UDVVD/3HVFDULQL,3ROLFR$3URLHWWL3DGXD,7*RUL]LD,7
$YLDQR,7 JLVHOODJHQQDUR#LRYHQHWRLW
3XUSRVH 7R DQDO\VH WKH LPSDFW RI EUHDVW WRPRV\QWKHVLV '%7 RQ VSHFLÀFLW\
FRPSDUHGWRVWDQGDUGGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\ 0;
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\LQFOXGHGFRQVHQWLQJZRPHQZLWKEUHDVW
OHVLRQVFODVVLÀHGDVVXVSLFLRXVDWPDPPRJUDSK\DQGRUXOWUDVRXQG$UHDGHUVWXG\
FRPSDULQJWZRYLHZ &&0/2 PDPPRJUDSK\RQHYLHZ 0/2 WRPRV\QWKHVLV
DQGWKHFRPELQDWLRQRI'%7DQG0;&&YLHZ '%70;&& ZDVFRQGXFWHGZLWK
VL[EUHDVWUDGLRORJLVWVDQGDVDPSOHRIEUHDVWV0HDQDUHDXQGHUWKHUHFHLYHU
RSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFVFXUYHVVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFK
PRGDOLW\E\DYHUDJLQJUHVXOWVDFURVVWKHUHDGHUV6SHFLÀFLW\DQDO\VLVLVSUHVHQWHG
KHUHUHÀQHGVHSDUDWHO\IRUWKHWZRVXEVHWVRIQRUPDOEUHDVWVDQGEUHDVWV
ZLWKEHQLJQOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV2YHUDOOPHDQVSHFLÀFLW\ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUZLWK'%7WKDQ0;
YVS ZKLOHWKHFRPELQHGSURWRFROOHGWRKLJKHUVSHFLÀFLW\ QRWVLJ
QLÀFDQWO\ WKDQ0;EXWVOLJKWO\ORZHUWKDQ'%7DORQH '%70;&& 7KH
SURSRUWLRQRIEHQLJQOHVLRQVFRUUHFWO\VFRUHGZLWKWRPRV\QWKHVLVHLWKHURQHYLHZ
RUZLWKWKHDGGLWLRQRI0;&&ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQVWDQGDUGPDPPRJUD
SK\ 0;'%7'%70;&&SYDOXH '%7YV0;
SYDOXH '%70;FFYV0; 7KHSURSRUWLRQRIQRUPDOEUHDVWVFRUUHFWO\
DVVHVVHGZDVVLPLODUZLWK0;DQG'%7 YVSYDOXH ZLWK
DVPDOOGHFUHDVHZLWKWKHFRPELQHGSURWRFRO
&RQFOXVLRQ7RPRV\QWKHVLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGVSHFLÀFLW\FRPSDUHGWRGLJLWDO
PDPPRJUDSK\0RUHLQGHWDLO'%7VLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGFDSDELOLW\LQFKDUDFWHULV
LQJEHQLJQOHVLRQVUHGXFLQJWKHQXPEHURIIDOVHSRVLWLYHV
%
05,LQWKHSUHRSHUDWLYHEUHDVWFDQFHUVWDJLQJEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKH
LQWURGXFWLRQRIGLJLWDOEUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLV '%7 KDVDQ\WKLQJFKDQJHG"
-*LJOLR**KLRQH(5HJLQL0'XUDQGR$/XSDULD0&(DQGL
33&DPSDQLQR*0DULVFRWWL**DQGLQL7XULQ,7 MDFRSRJLJOLR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI05,DQGFRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJ
WHFKQLTXHV GLJLWDO PDPPRJUDSK\ >'0@ DQG XOWUDVRXQG >86@ FRPELQHG RU QRW
ZLWK'%7LQSUHRSHUDWLYHEUHDVWFDQFHUDVVHVVPHQWDQGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHHIIHFWV
RQVXUJLFDOWUHDWPHQW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ UHYLHZHG QHZO\ GLDJQRVHG
EUHDVW FDQFHU SDWLHQWV RSHUDWHG EUHDVWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW SUHRSHUDWLYH
FRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJPRGDOLWLHVDQG05,EHWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG-XQH
7KHSDWLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVWKRVHZKRKDG'%7LQDGGLWLRQWR'0
DQG 86 JURXS RSHUDWHG EUHDVWV DQG WKRVH ZKR GLG QRW XQGHUJR
'%7 JURXSRSHUDWHGEUHDVWV 6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
WRFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RILPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHVDQGWRHYDOXDWH05,
LPSDFWRQVXUJLFDOPDQDJHPHQWLQWKHWZRJURXSV
5HVXOWV ,Q JURXS 05, RYHUDOO VHQVLWLYLW\ ZDV '0'%7
'0'%786S DQGLQJURXS '0'086
S IRUPXOWLIRFDOPXOWLFHQWULFOHVLRQVZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\ '0'%7
'0'%786S! DQG '0'086S
IRU FRQWURODWHUDO OHVLRQV ZDV LQ ERWK JURXSV JURXS'0'%7
'0'%786S*URXS'0'086S ,QJURXS
05,VSHFLÀFLW\ZDV '0'%7'0'%786S! DQGLQ
JURXS '0'086S! 3UHRSHUDWLYH05,FKDQJHG
VXUJLFDOWUHDWPHQWLQ LQJURXSDQGLQ LQJURXS
ZLWKDFRQYHUVLRQIURPEUHDVWFRQVHUYDWLYHVXUJHU\LQWRPDVWHFWRP\UHVSHFWLYHO\
6
$
%
LQ DQG S 2YHUDOOSDWKRORJLFFRQÀUPDWLRQRI
PDOLJQDQF\ZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\ DQG LQVXUJLFDOVSHFLPHQV
&RQFOXVLRQ '%7 FRPELQHG ZLWK '0 DQG 86 LPSURYHG FRQYHQWLRQDO LPDJLQJ
DFFXUDF\ EXW 05, VWLOO VKRZHG WKH KLJKHVW VHQVLWLYLW\ LQ GHWHFWLQJ DQG VWDJLQJ
EUHDVWFDQFHU
&
'
(
)
*
+
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGHWHFWLRQUDWHRIEUHDVWFDQFHUXVLQJGLJLWDOWRPRV\QWKHVLV
DVDQDGGLWLRQDOWRROFRPELQHGZLWKGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\LQ$&5GHQVLW\SDWWHUQV
DQGLQDFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\)URP'HFHPEHUWR$XJXVW
&RPERVWXGLHV 'GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\SOXVWRPRV\QWKHVLV ZHUH
SHUIRUPHGLQ$&5GHQVLW\SDWWHUQVDQGWRHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRIWKHWRPRV\Q
WKHVLVLQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIDGGLWLRQDOFDQFHUV6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
FDOFXODWLQJWKH3HDUVRQ&KLVTXDUHWHVWDQGXVLQJWKH6366VRIWZDUH
5HVXOWVEUHDVWWXPRXUVZHUHGHWHFWHGRQFRQYHQWLRQDOGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\
GHWHFWLRQUDWH 7KLUW\RQHDGGLWLRQDOFDQFHUVZHUHGHWHFWHGRQWRPRV\Q
WKHVLVDQGQRWVHHQRQVWDQGDUGPDPPRJUDPVFDVHVRQ$&5 WKHGHWHFWLRQ
UDWHZDVLQFUHDVHG FDVHVLQ$&5 DQGFDVHVLQ$&5
1RVWDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHIRXQGLQWKHGHWHFWLRQUDWHDPRQJWKH
WKUHHSDWWHUQV S 7RPRV\QWKHVLVLQFUHDVHGWKHGHWHFWLRQUDWHVR
WKHWRWDOGHWHFWLRQUDWHXVLQJWKHFRPERVWXGLHVZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDGGLWLRQRIGLJLWDOWRPRV\QWKHVLVLQFUHDVHVWKHGHWHFWLRQUDWH
IURPWR7KHUHDUHQRWVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJWKHWKUHH$&5
GHQVLW\SDWWHUQVVRWRPRV\QWKHVLVFDQEHXVHIXOQRWRQO\LQGHQVHSDWWHUQVEXW
DOVRLQSDWWHUQ
%
5ROHRIEUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLVLQWKHPRUSKRORJLFDODQDO\VLVRI
EUHDVWOHVLRQV
%5DJKDYDQ05DMPRKDQ*6LYDUDPDOLQJDP&KHQQDL,1
GUEDJ\DP#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHUROHRIEUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLV E\'FRPERYLHZ YHUVXV
'IXOOÀHOGGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPDORQHLQWKHPRUSKRORJLFDODQDO\VLVRIEUHDVWOH
VLRQV7RHYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDOUROHRIWRPRV\QWKHVLVLQ%,5$'6FDWHJRULVDWLRQ
DQGÀQDOKLVWRSDWKRORJ\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVZKRZHUHUHIHUUHGWRRXUGHSDUWPHQWIRUPDP
PRJUDPIURP0D\ SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQWIXOOÀHOGGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPDQG
'WRPRV\QWKHVLV FRPELQHGYLHZ &UDQLRFDXGDODQGPHGLRODWHUDOREOLTXHYLHZVRI
ERWKEUHDVWVZHUHDFTXLUHGIRUDOOSDWLHQWV2IWKHVHRXUVWXG\SRSXODWLRQLQFOXGHV
SDWLHQWVZLWKDEQRUPDO'GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDP'GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPDQG
'WRPRV\QWKHVLVZHUHDQDO\VHGIRUWKHIROORZLQJIHDWXUHVPDVVPDUJLQVFDOFLÀ
FDWLRQDV\PPHWULFGHQVLW\IRFDODV\PPHWU\DQGDUFKLWHFWXUDOGLVWRUWLRQ)ROORZLQJ
WKHPDPPRJUDPDOOSDWLHQWVZHUHVXEMHFWHGWRXOWUDVRXQGDQGLPDJHJXLGHGIQDF
RUWUXFXWFRUHWLVVXHELRSV\IRUFRUUHODWLRQ6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVGRQHWRHYDOX
DWHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIWRPRV\QWKHVLVYHUVXV'GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPLQWHUPVRI
PRUSKRORJ\%,5$'6FDWHJRULVDWLRQDQGKLVWRSDWKRORJ\
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ'DQGWRPRIRUIHDWXUHDQDO\VLV
S DQGIRU%,5$'6VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S ZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ
'DQG86*ÀQDODQGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S ZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ'
DQG86*ÀQDO
&RQFOXVLRQ7RPRV\QWKHVLVZDVXVHIXOLQPDMRULW\RISDWLHQWVLQWHUPVRIOHVLRQ
FRQVSLFXLW\DQGIHDWXUHDQDO\VLV,WDSSUR[LPDWHGWKHÀQDO%,5$'6DIWHUXOWUDVRXQG
DQG+3(EHWWHUWKDQ'GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPDORQH
%
'RHVFRPELQLQJ'EUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLVZLWKGLJLWDO
PDPPRJUDSK\LPSURYHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\"
1+6DLG+$ERO0DJG00RNKWDU/%DVVDP6:DKHHG'6DOHP
$6HOLP&DLUR(* QRUUDQKXVVHLQ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIDGGLQJ'EUHDVWWRPRV\QWKHVLV %7 WRIXOOÀHOG
GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\ '0 IRULPSURYLQJOHVLRQYLVLELOLW\DQG%,5$'6DVVHVVPHQW
LQUHODWLRQWRSDWKRORJLFDORXWFRPHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFDVHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWK'0DQG%7LQDGHGLFDWHG
EUHDVWLPDJLQJXQLWZLWKGLDJQRVWLFDQGVFUHHQLQJVHUYLFHV%RWK'0DQG%7ZHUH
SHUIRUPHGLQFUDQLRFDXGDODQGPHGLRODWHUDOREOLTXHYLHZVLQGLIIHUHQWH[SRVXUHV
XVLQJDVLHPHQVPDPPRPDWLQVSLUDWLRQXQLW(YDOXDWLRQDQG%,5$'6VFRULQJZDV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
JLYHQWR'0IROORZHGE\%7$ÀQDO%,5$'6VFRUHFRQVLGHULQJERWKLQWHUSUHWDWLRQV
DQGDQ\DGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQE\XOWUDVRXQGZDVODWHUGHFLGHG
5HVXOWVRIFDVHVZHUHVFUHHQLQJDQGZHUHGLDJQRVWLF$FFRUGLQJ
WRWKHÀQDODVVHVVPHQWFDWHJRULHVRIFDVHV
ZHUHJLYHQD%,5$'6VFRUHRIUHVSHFWLYHO\$FFXUDF\33DQG33
RI'0DORQHZHUH2QDGGLQJ%7UHVXOWVZHUH
UHVSHFWLYHO\$JUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ%7%,5$'6DQG)LQDO%,5$'6VFRUH
ZDV NDSSD %HWZHHQ'0DQG)LQDO%,5$'6ZDV .DSSD
%HWZHHQ%7DQG'0%,5$'6ZDV .DSSD 5HJDUGLQJWKH
FDQFHUVGHWHFWHGLQYHU\GHQVHEUHDVWV PRUHWKDQJODQGXODUWLVVXH '%7
FRXOGGLDJQRVHZKLOHRQO\ZHUHGLDJQRVHGE\'0%7DGGHGQHZ
LQIRUPDWLRQLQRIFDVHVE\YLVXDOLVDWLRQRIPDUJLQVDQDO\VLVRIIRFDODV\PPHWU\
DQGGHWHFWLQJPXOWLIRFDOLW\PXOWLFHQWULFLW\RIFDQFHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ$GGLQJ%7WR'0LPSURYHVDFFXUDF\RI%,5$'6FDWHJRULVDWLRQDQG
UDGLRORJLFSDWKRORJLFFRUUHODWLRQ
%
'XWFKGLJLWDOEUHDVWFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJLPSOLFDWLRQVIRUEUHDVWFDQFHUFDUH
-7LPPHUV*GHQ+HHWHQ(0$GDQJ-'2WWHQ$/09HUEHHN
0-0%URHGHUV1LMPHJHQ1/$PVWHUGDP1/ MWLPPHUV#OUFEQO
%
'UDPDWLFLQFUHDVHLQVWHUHRWDFWLFFRUHQHHGOHELRSV\UDWHDQGGXFWDO
FDUFLQRPDLQVLWXGHWHFWLRQDIWHUFRQYHUVLRQIURPDQDORJXHWRGLJLWDO
VFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\
-1HGHUHQG$&9RRJG-+*URHQHZRXG0:-/RXZPDQ/(0'XLMP
(LQGKRYHQ1/0DDVWULFKW1/5RWWHUGDP1/ MRRVWQHGHUHQG#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHLPSDFWRILPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJPDP
PRJUDSK\RQVWHUHRWDFWLFFRUHQHHGOHELRSV\ 6&1% UDWHDQGGXFWDOFDUFLQRPD
LQVLWX '&,6 GHWHFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HLQFOXGHGDFRQVHFXWLYHVHULHVRIDQDORJXH
DQGGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPVREWDLQHGDWD'XWFKEUHDVWVFUHHQLQJ
UHJLRQEHWZHHQUHVSHFWLYHO\-DQXDU\-XO\DQG-XO\-DQXDU\
6&1%UDWHDQG'&,6GHWHFWLRQZHUHGHWHUPLQHGIRUERWKSRSXODWLRQV
5HVXOWV5HIHUUDOUDWHDQGRYHUDOOFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQUDWHDWGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJZHUH
DQG SHUVFUHHQHGZRPHQFRPSDUHGWR
S DQG S DWDQDORJXHVFUHHQ
LQJ$WGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\6&1%SURFHGXUHV SHU
VFUHHQHGZRPHQKDGEHHQSHUIRUPHGFRPSDUHGWR6&1%SURFHGXUHV
SHUDQDORJXHVFUHHQV S 3RVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI
6&1%IRUEUHDVWFDQFHUZDV DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\IRU
GLJLWDODQGDQDORJXHVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\ S '&,6ZDVGLDJQRVHGLQ
ZRPHQ SHUGLJLWDOVFUHHQVFRPSDUHGWR SHU
DQDORJXHVFUHHQV S DQG'&,6FRPSULVHGRIFDQFHUV
GHWHFWHGDWGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJDQGRIEUHDVWFDQFHUV GHWHFWHGDW
DQDORJXHVFUHHQLQJ S &RPSDUHGWR'&,6DWDQDORJXHVFUHHQLQJ'&,6
DWGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJWHQGHGWREHPRUHIUHTXHQWO\ORZJUDGH'&,6RULQWHUPHGLDWH
JUDGH'&,6 YV S
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&RQYHUVLRQIURPDQDORJXHWRGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\
UHVXOWVLQDPRUHIDYRUDEOHWXPRXUVWDJHDQGWXPRXUELRORJ\RI
VFUHHQGHWHFWHGFDQFHUV
-1HGHUHQG0:-/RXZPDQ-+*URHQHZRXG$&9RRJG/(0'XLMP
(LQGKRYHQ1/5RWWHUGDP1/0DDVWULFKW1/ MRRVWQHGHUHQG#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHLPSDFWRIFRQYHUVLRQIURPDQDORJXHWRGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJ
PDPPRJUDSK\RQWXPRXUVWDJHDQGWXPRXUELRORJ\RIVFUHHQGHWHFWHGFDQFHUV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H LQFOXGHG D FRQVHFXWLYH VHULHV RI DQDORJXH
DQGGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPVREWDLQHGDWD'XWFKEUHDVWVFUHHQLQJ
UHJLRQEHWZHHQUHVSHFWLYHO\-DQXDU\-XO\DQG-XO\-DQXDU\
7XPRXU VWDJH DQG ELRORJ\ FKDUDFWHULVWLFV ZHUH GHWHUPLQHG IRU VFUHHQGHWHFWHG
FDQFHUV
5HVXOWV7KHRYHUDOOFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQUDWHZDV SHUVFUHHQHG
ZRPHQDWGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJ LQYDVLYHFDQFHUVDQGGXFWDOFDUFLQRPDVLQVLWX
'&,6 FRPSDUHGWR DWDQDORJXHVFUHHQLQJ LQYDVLYHFDQFHUV
DQG'&,6S 7KHSURSRUWLRQRIDGYDQFHGFDQFHUV GHÀQHGDV7DQG
RUO\PSKQRGHSRVLWLYHFDQFHUV ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUDWGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJ
YHUVXVS EXWWXPRXUVL]H HLWKHU7DFRU7 RILQYDVLYHFDQFHUV
ZDVFRPSDUDEOHWRWKRVHGHWHFWHGDWDQDORJXHVFUHHQLQJ S $WGLJLWDOVFUHHQ
LQJVLJQLÀFDQWO\IHZHULQYDVLYHFDQFHUVVKRZHGO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVLV
YHUVXV S 7XPRXUKLVWRORJ\RILQYDVLYHFDQFHUV
HLWKHU GXFWDO RU OREXODU FDQFHU ZDV FRPSDUDEOH S EXW LQYDVLYH FDQFHUV
GHWHFWHG DW GLJLWDO VFUHHQLQJ VKRZHG D PRUH IDYRXUDEOH 1RWWLQJKDP JUDGDWLRQ
S 3URSRUWLRQVRIHVWURJHQUHFHSWRUSRVLWLYHRU+HU1HXUHFHSWRUSRVLWLYH
LQYDVLYHFDQFHUVZHUHVLPLODU S DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\ EXWWKHSURSRUWLRQ
RISURJHVWHURQUHFHSWRUSRVLWLYHLQYDVLYHFDQFHUVZDVODUJHUDWGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJ
YHUVXV S
&RQFOXVLRQ5HSODFHPHQWRIDQDORJXHVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\E\GLJLWDOVFUHHQ
LQJ PDPPRJUDSK\ KDG D IDYRXUDEOH LPSDFW RQ ERWK WXPRXU VWDJH DQG WXPRXU
ELRORJ\RIVFUHHQGHWHFWHGFDQFHUV
%
:KDWGRZHJDLQE\FKDQJLQJIURPVFUHHQÀOPWRIXOOÀHOGGLJLWDO
PDPPRJUDSKLFVFUHHQLQJ"
6+RIYLQG&,/HH-*(OPRUH2VOR12/RV$QJHOHV&$86
6HDWWOH:$86 VROYHLJKRIYLQG#NUHIWUHJLVWHUHWQR
3XUSRVH7RDQDO\VHWKHHIIHFWRISULRUDQGFXUUHQWXVHRIVFUHHQÀOPPDPPRJUDSK\
6)0 DQGIXOOÀHOGGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\ ))'0 RQHDUO\RXWFRPHPHDVXUHVLQ
VFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 'DWD IURP ZRPHQ DJHG \HDUV VFUHHQHG LQ WKH
1RUZHJLDQ%UHDVW&DQFHU6FUHHQLQJ3URJUDPPHEHWZHHQDQGZHUH
LQFOXGHG LQ WKH VWXG\ 5HFDOO DQG GHWHFWLRQ UDWH DQG SRVLWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH
IURPLQLWLDO6)0LQLWLDO))'06)0DIWHUDSULRU6)0
))'0DIWHUDSULRU6)0DQG))'0DIWHUDSULRU))'0ZHUH
DQDO\VHGXVLQJWZRVLGHG&KLVTXDUHWHVWV
5HVXOWV7KHUHFDOOUDWHZDVIRULQLWLDO))'0 S DQGIRULQLWLDO
6)0 S (LWKHUWKHGHWHFWLRQUDWHRI'&,6RU'&,6DQGLQYDVLYHGLIIHU
VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW E\ LQLWLDO VFUHHQLQJ WHFKQLTXH ,Q VXEVHTXHQWO\ VFUHHQHG
ZRPHQWKHUHFDOOUDWHZDVIRU6)0DIWHU6)0DQGIRU))'0DIWHU6)0
DQGIRU))'0SHUIRUPHGDIWHUDSULRU))'0 S 7KHGHWHFWLRQUDWH
RI'&,6ZDVIRU6)0DIWHU6)0IRU))'0DIWHU6)0 S
DQGIRU))'0DIWHU))'0 S 7KHUDWHRILQYDVLYHFDQFHUZDV
IRU6)0DIWHU6)0IRU))'0DIWHU6)0 S DQGIRU))'0
DIWHU))'0 S 7KHLQWHUYDOFDQFHUUDWHZDVIRU6)0DIWHU6)0
IRU))'0DIWHU6)0DQG))'0DIWHU))'0 SIRUERWK
&RQFOXVLRQ(DUO\RXWFRPHPHDVXUHVLQPDPPRJUDSKLFVFUHHQLQJVHHPWREH
LQÁXHQFHGE\WKHSULRUDQGFXUUHQWVFUHHQLQJWHFKQLTXH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH ,Q FRPSDULVRQ WR RWKHU (XURSHDQ SRSXODWLRQEDVHG EUHDVW FDQFHU
VFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPHVWKH'XWFKSURJUDPPHKDVDORZUHIHUUDOUDWHVLPLODUEUHDVW
FDQFHUGHWHFWLRQDQGDKLJKEUHDVWFDQFHUPRUWDOLW\UHGXFWLRQ7KHUHIHUUDOUDWHLQ
WKH1HWKHUODQGVKDVLQFUHDVHGRYHUWLPHDQGLVH[SHFWHGWRULVHIXUWKHUPDLQO\
IROORZLQJQDWLRQZLGHLQWURGXFWLRQRIGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\7KLVVWXG\H[SORUHVWKH
FRQVHTXHQFHVRIWKHLQWURGXFWLRQRIGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\RQWKHEDODQFHEHWZHHQ
UHIHUUDOUDWHGHWHFWLRQRIEUHDVWFDQFHUGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXSDQGDVVRFLDWHGFRVWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'HWDLOHGLQIRUPDWLRQRQGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXS FKDUWUHYLHZ
ZDVREWDLQHGIURPUHIHUUHGZRPHQ Q LQ DQDORJXHPDP
PRJUDSK\ DQG GLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\ LQ1LMPHJHQWKH1HWKHUODQGV
5HVXOWV7KHDYHUDJHUHIHUUDOUDWHLQFUHDVHGIURP WR SHU
ZRPHQVFUHHQHG7KHQXPEHURIEUHDVWFDQFHUVGHWHFWHGLQFUHDVHGIURP
WRSHUVFUHHQVZKHUHDVWKHSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHIHOOIURP
WR$VKDUSULVHLQGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXSSURFHGXUHVDQGWRWDOGLDJQRVWLFFRVWV
ZDVVHHQ2QWKHRWKHUKDQGFRVWVRIDVLQJOHZRUNXSVOLJKWO\GHFUHDVHGDVOHVV
VXUJLFDOELRSVLHVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU VWXG\ VKRZV WKDW D ORZ UHIHUUDO UDWH LQ FRPELQDWLRQ ZLWK WKH
LQWURGXFWLRQRIGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\DIIHFWVWKHEDODQFHEHWZHHQUHIHUUDOUDWHDQG
GHWHFWLRQUDWHDQGFDQVXEVWDQWLDOO\LQÁXHQFHEUHDVWFDQFHUFDUHDQGDVVRFLDWHG
FRVWV5HIHUUDOUDWHVLQWKH1HWKHUODQGVDUHQRZPRUHFRPSDUDEOHWRRWKHUFRXQWULHV
7KLVHIIHFWLVWKHUHIRUHRIYDOXHLQFRXQWULHVZKHUHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIGLJLWDOEUHDVW
FDQFHUVFUHHQLQJKDVMXVWVWDUWHGRULVVWLOOXQGHUGLVFXVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&RQYHUVLRQIURPDQDORJXHWRGLJLWDOVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\UHVXOWHG
LQDGUDPDWLFDOO\LQFUHDVHG6&1%UDWHZLWKDFRQFRPLWDQWLQFUHDVHG'&,6GHWHF
WLRQ2YHUGLDJQRVLVRIEUHDVWFDQFHULVPRUHSURIRXQGDWGLJLWDOWKDQDWDQDORJXH
VFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHGHWHFWLRQUDWHVRISXUHGXFWDOFDUFLQRPDLQVLWX '&,6 E\ÀOP
VFUHHQPDPPRJUDSK\DQGE\GLJLWDOUDGLRJUDSKLF '5 PDPPRJUDSK\LQZRPHQ
VXEPLWWHGWRDQQXDOVFUHHQLQJIRUEUHDVWFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3URVSHFWLYHVWXG\RIDV\PSWRPDWLFZRPHQVXEPLW
WHGWRDQQXDOPDPPRJUDSKLFVFUHHQLQJLQWZRFHQWUHV7HQWKRXVDQGWZRKXQGUHG
DQGQLQHW\IRXUZRPHQLQWKHÀUVWJURXSKDGÀOPVFUHHQPDPPRJUDPVDQG
ZRPHQLQWKHVHFRQGJURXSKDGGLJLWDO'5PDPPRJUDPV$OOH[DPVZHUHUHDG
E\WKHVDPHUDGLRORJLVWV$OOZRPHQRQÀUVWVFUHHQLQJH[DPLQDWLRQZHUHH[FOXGHG
%LRSV\ZDVUHFRPPHQGHGIRUOHVLRQVVXVSLFLRXVIRUPDOLJQDQF\LQDFFRUGDQFH
ZLWK%,5$'6FDWHJRULVDWLRQDQGZDVVXEPLWWHGWRSDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQ
5HVXOWV0HDQDJHZDV\HDUVLQWKHÀUVWJURXSDQG\HDUVLQWKHVHFRQG
JURXS'HQVHEUHDVWVZHUHSUHVHQWLQRIZRPHQLQWKHÀUVWJURXSDQGLQ
RIWKRVHLQWKHVHFRQGJURXS,QWKHÀOPVFUHHQJURXSRIZRPHQ
UHFRPPHQGHGIRUELRSV\ZHUHGLDJQRVHGZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHU SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWYDOXH
>339@ RIZLWKSXUH'&,6 ,QWKHGLJLWDOJURXSRIZRPHQ
UHFRPPHQGHGIRUELRSV\ZHUHGLDJQRVHGZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHU 339 RI
KDGSXUH'&,6 ZKLFKZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQZLWKÀOPVFUHHQ
PDPPRJUDSK\
&RQFOXVLRQ,QZRPHQXQGHUJRLQJDQQXDOVFUHHQLQJIRUEUHDVWFDQFHUGLJLWDO'5
PDPPRJUDSK\LPSURYHVGHWHFWLRQUDWHVRISUHLQYDVLYHVWDJHFRPSDUHGWRWKDW
DFKLHYHGE\ÀOPVFUHHQPDPPRJUDSK\
3XUSRVH7KHYDOXHRIVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHH[FLVLRQ 6/1( LQSDWLHQWVZLWKFXWDQH
RXVKHDGDQGQHFNPDOLJQDQFLHVKDVEHHQFRQWURYHUVLDOO\GLVFXVVHG:HDLPHG
WRDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFLPSDFWRISUHRSHUDWLYH63(&7&7LQGLUHFWFRPSDULVRQ
WRVWDQGDUG6/1(ZLWKRXW63(&7&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'DWDRIFOLQLFDOO\O\PSKQRGHQHJDWLYHSDWLHQWV DJH
UDQJH\HDUV ZHUHDQDO\VHG3ULPDU\WXPRXUVLQFOXGHGPDOLJQDQWPHODQRPD
Q DQGKLJKULVNFXWDQHRXVVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPD Q ,QJURXS$ Q
DO\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKHLWKHU0%TRU0%TRI7FP
QDQRFROORLGGHSHQGLQJRQWKHVFKHGXOHRIWKHVXUJLFDOSURFHGXUH,QJURXS% Q
DQDGGLWLRQDO63(&7&7VFDQ PDWUL[[IUDPHVVSHUIUDPH RIWKH
KHDGDQGQHFNUHJLRQZDVREWDLQHGLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUO\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\6/1(
ZDVSHUIRUPHGGXULQJVXUJHU\DFFRUGLQJWRWKHSUHYLRXVLPDJLQJUHVXOWV2SHUDWLQJ
WLPHVIRUERWKJURXSVZHUHFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV6/1ZHUHUHPRYHGLQSDWLHQWV7KHRSHUDWLQJWLPHLQJURXS%ZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\VKRUWHU PHGLDQPLQ WKDQLQJURXS$ PHGLDQPLQ3
'XHWRWKHH[DFWDQDWRPLFDOORFDOLVDWLRQRIWKH6/1GHWHUPLQHGE\63(&7&7WKH
VXUJLFDODSSURDFKZDVFKDQJHGLQRISDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ63(&7&7LVDQLQQRYDWLYHLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHSURYLGLQJDGGLWLRQDO
LQIRUPDWLRQWRGHWHFWDQGWRH[FLVH6/1LQSDWLHQWVZLWKKHDGDQGQHFNPDOLJQDQFLHV
,PSURYLQJGHWHFWLRQUDWHVRI'&,6ZLWKGLJLWDO'5PDPPRJUDSK\
&60DPHUL-0DPHUL)LOKR$&31D]DULR9LWRULD(6%56DR3DXOR%5
FODXGLDPDPHUL#KRWPDLOFRP
5RRP*+
+HDGDQG1HFN
66
2QFRORJ\
0RGHUDWRUV
&=.DUDPDQ$\GLQ75
5.RKOHU*HQHYD&+
%
,QFLGHQWDO))'*SRVLWLYHIRFDOWK\URLGQRGXOHVRQ3(7&7
HYDOXDWLRQDQGRXWFRPH
-%6WUDLWRQ6%HWKDSXGL):3RRQ*ODVJRZ8. MDFNVWUDLWRQ#QKVQHW
3XUSRVH)ÁXURGHR[\JOXFRVH )'* DFFXPXODWLRQZLWKLQQRUPDOWK\URLGWLVVXH
LVORZRUDEVHQWRQZKROHERG\)'*3(7&7$VDUHVXOWRILQFUHDVLQJXVHRIWKLV
K\EULGLPDJLQJPRGDOLW\LQFLGHQWDOWK\URLG)'*XSWDNHLVLQFUHDVLQJO\LGHQWLÀHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFDVHVRI)'*3(7&7SHUIRUPHGDWRXULQVWLWXWLRQ
EHWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG0D\ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGE\VHDUFKLQJ
IRU NH\ZRUG ҊWK\URLGҋ ZLWKLQ WKH FOLQLFDO LQIRUPDWLRQERG\ RI UHSRUW7KHVH FDVHV
ZHUHUHYLHZHGE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWREVHUYHUV3DWLHQWVZLWKHVWDEOLVKHGVXVSHFWHG
WK\URLGPDOLJQDQF\RUSUHYLRXVWK\URLGVXUJHU\ZHUHGLVFDUGHG&DVHVZLWKIRFDORU
GLIIXVHWK\URLG)'*XSWDNHZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKFOLQLFDOELRFKHPLFDODQGF\WRSD
WKRORJ\KLVWRSDWKRORJ\UHFRUGV8OWUDVRXQGLPDJHVIRUDOOFDVHVZLWKIRFDOXSWDNH
DQGDSDWKRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLVZHUHUHUHYLHZHGE\DQLQGHSHQGHQWKHDGDQGQHFN
UDGLRORJLVW,QWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\ZDVUHVROYHGE\LQGHSHQGHQWO\UHUHYLHZLQJ
LPDJHVDQGDUULYLQJDWFRQVHQVXV
5HVXOWV7KHSUHYDOHQFHRILQFLGHQWDOWK\URLG)'*XSWDNHZDV RI
RQ)'*3(7&72IWKHVH GHPRQVWUDWHGIRFDOXSWDNHDQG
ZHUHGLIIXVHRIFDVHVZLWKIRFDOXSWDNHKDGXOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGÀQH
QHHGOHDVSLUDWLRQ )1$ FRUHELRSV\RUSRVWVXUJLFDOSDWKRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLV
ZHUHEHQLJQQRGXOHV ZHUHPDOLJQDQW VL[SDSLOODU\FDUFLQRPDV
RQHDQDSODVWLFFDUFLQRPDRQHVTXDPRXVFHOOPHWDVWDVLV ZHUHSR
WHQWLDOO\PDOLJQDQWRQ)1$ ZHUHLQGHWHUPLQDWH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHYDOHQFHRILQFLGHQWDOWK\URLG)'*XSWDNHRQ)'*3(7&7
ZDV7KHRYHUDOOLQFLGHQFHRIPDOLJQDQF\IRUIRFDOO\)'*DYLGWK\URLGQRGXOHV
ZDV7KLVVWXG\UHLWHUDWHVWKHLPSRUWDQFHRIREWDLQLQJDWLVVXHGLDJQRVLVLQ
VXFKSDWLHQWVWRH[FOXGHV\QFKURQRXVRUFOLQLFDOO\RFFXOWPDOLJQDQF\
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
63(&7&7IRUWKHGHSLFWLRQRIVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHVLQFXWDQHRXV
KHDGDQGQHFNWXPRXUV
7&/DXHQVWHLQ&%R\73RHSSHO,6WRIIHOV'6FKDGHQGRUI$%RFNLVFK
-.ORGH(VVHQ'( WKRPDVODXHQVWHLQ#XQLGXHGH
%
'RVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\RIKLJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7IRUWKH
HYDOXDWLRQRIFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHVWDWXVFRPSDULVRQWRUHJXODU
VOLFHVLQJOHVRXUFH&7
5:%DXHU/+ROWKDXV%6FKHOO0%HHUHV)$O%XWPHK7-9RJO-0.HUO
)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'( UDOIZEDXHU#DROFRP
3XUSRVH3DWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQWO\PSKRPDUHJXODUO\XQGHUJR&7RIWKHQHFNIRU
WKHHYDOXDWLRQRIO\PSKQRGHVWDWXVZLWKUHOHYDQWGRVHH[SRVXUH:HFRPSDUHGD
QRYHOKLJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7 '6&7 SURWRFROZLWKRXUVWDQGDUGVLQJOHVRXUFH
&7SURWRFROLQWHUPVRIGRVHDQGFRQVSLFXLW\RIFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHOHYHOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(DFKSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWHLWKHUFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
KLJKSLWFK'6&7 JURXSSLWFK RUUHJXODUVLQJOHVRXUFH&7 JURXSSLWFK
RIWKHQHFNRQWKHVDPH&7GHYLFH 'HÀQLWLRQ)ODVK6LHPHQV DWN9P$V
$XWRPDWHGH[SRVXUHFRQWUROZDVXVHGLQERWKJURXSV,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG
DWPPWKLFNQHVVZLWKDPHGLXPVRIWNHUQHO %I &7',YRO'/3DQGEDFNJURXQG
QRLVH %1 ZHUHFRPSDUHG7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVUDWHGGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\DQG
DUWHIDFWEXUGHQ H[FHOOHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\QRDUWHIDFWV QRUHOLDEOHGLDJQRVLV
SRVVLEOHKHDY\DUWHIDFWV
5HVXOWV 0HDQ &7',YRO YV P*\ DQG '/3 YV
P*\FP ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S ORZHULQJURXSZKLOH%1ZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU YV+8S 7KLVGLGQRWDIIHFWGLDJQRVWLF
LPDJH TXDOLW\ VLQFH VXEMHFWLYH LPDJH TXDOLW\ YV DQG DUWHIDFW
EXUGHQ YV ZHUHQRWUDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQERWK
JURXSV S DQG
&RQFOXVLRQ +LJKSLWFK '6&7 RI WKH QHFN DOORZV IRU D VLJQLÀFDQW UHGXFWLRQ RI
GRVHZKLOHGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\LVSUHVHUYHGLQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJFHUYLFDO
O\PSKQRGHVWDJLQJIRUPDOLJQDQWO\PSKRPD(VSHFLDOO\LQ\RXQJDGXOWVUDGLDWLRQ
GHOLYHUHGWRWKHWK\URLGJODQGDQGH\HOHQVLVRILPSRUWDQWPDWWHU
%
0DQDJHPHQWRIKHDGDQGQHFNFDUFLQRPDRIXQNQRZQSULPDU\
WKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI))'*3(7&7LQGHWHFWLRQRIWKH
FOLQLFDOO\RFFXOWWXPRXU
-%6WUDLWRQ6%HWKDSXGL$0F&DOOXP6+DQ*ODVJRZ8.
MDFNVWUDLWRQ#QKVQHW
3XUSRVH &DUFLQRPD RI XQNQRZQ SULPDU\ &83 UHSUHVHQWV RI DOO KHDG
DQG QHFN PDOLJQDQFLHV DQG SRVHV VLJQLÀFDQW GHPDQGV RQ RWRUKLQRODU\QJRO
RJ\ GHSDUWPHQWV 6TXDPRXV FHOO FDUFLQRPDV DFFRXQW IRU 7UDGLWLRQDO
HYDOXDWLRQRIPHWDVWDWLFFHUYLFDOO\PSKDGHQRSDWK\LQFOXGHVFOLQLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQ
ÀEUHRSWLFODU\QJRVFRS\QDVRSKDU\QJRVFRS\ FURVVVHFWLRQDO LPDJLQJ &705,
DQGSDQHQGRVFRS\ZLWKGLUHFWHGELRSVLHVWRQVLOOHFWRP\7KHGLVHDVHIROORZVDQ
DJJUHVVLYHFRXUVHZLWKPHGLDQVXUYLYDORIPRQWKV2XUDLPZDVWRUHYLHZ
WKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI)'*3(7&7LQFDVHVRI&83LQWKH:HVWRI6FRWODQG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&OLQLFDOUHFRUGVDQGLPDJLQJUHSRUWVRIFRQVHFXWLYH
SDWLHQWV ZLWK PHWDVWDWLF FHUYLFDO O\PSKDGHQRSDWK\ DQG RFFXOW SULPDU\ WXPRXU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
GHVSLWHFOLQLFDOUDGLRORJLFDOZRUNXS SUHVHQWLQJWRRXULQVWLWXWLRQIRU)'*3(7&7
ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHG7KHUHZHUHPDOHVDQGIHPDOHVZLWKDPHDQ
DJHRI\HDUV UDQJH )'*3(7&7LPDJHVUHSRUWVZHUHLQGHSHQG
HQWO\UHYLHZHGE\WZRREVHUYHUVDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKJROGVWDQGDUGKLVWRSDWKRORJ\
5HVXOWV)'*3(7&7FRUUHFWO\GHWHFWHGRFFXOWSULPDU\WXPRXUVLQSDWLHQWV
GHWHFWLRQUDWH 7KHUHZHUHWUXHQHJDWLYHVLQZKLFKQRH[WUDQRGDOPD
OLJQDQF\ZDVSURYHQ7KHUHZHUHIDOVHQHJDWLYHVLQZKLFKDQXQGHUO\LQJSULPDU\
WXPRXUZDVHVWDEOLVKHGE\RWKHUPHWKRGVGHVSLWHQHJDWLYH3(7&77KHUHZHUH
IDOVHSRVLWLYHVLQZKLFKGLUHFWHGVHDUFKHVWDEOLVKHGQRKLVWRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLVDW
WKHVLWHRIFRQFHUQRQ)'*3(7&76HQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUHDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\3RVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH
2YHUDOODFFXUDF\
&RQFOXVLRQ)RUDPDMRULW\LQWKLVFKDOOHQJLQJVXEJURXSRISDWLHQWV)'*3(7
&7FRQWULEXWHVSRVLWLYHO\ZKHQFRQYHQWLRQDOGLDJQRVWLFSDWKZD\VKDYHIDLOHGWR
HVWDEOLVKDSULPDU\WXPRXU
%
&RPSDULVRQRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG3(7&7DQG05,LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
KHDGDQGQHFNFDQFHU
7-9RJO15RGH76WRHYHU56DGHU,%XUFN0+DUWK)*UXHQZDOG
)UDQNIXUW'( WYRJO#HPXQLIUDQNIXUWGH
%
3UHDQGLQWUDRSHUDWLYHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWXPRXUH[WHQWDQGERQH
LQÀOWUDWLRQLQWKHKHDGDQGQHFNUHJLRQDFRPSDULVRQRIPXOWLVOLFH
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 06&7 KLJKUHVROXWLRQÁDWSDQHOYROXPHWULF
&7 9&7 DQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFPHWKRGV
($OHMDQGUH/DIRQW+6FKDDI70XHOOHU02EHUW+3+RZDOGW
*.URPEDFK(*L]HZVNL*LHVVHQ'(
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVLI9&7DVDKLJKUHVROXWLRQERQHLPDJLQJPRGDOLW\FDQLQ
WUDRSHUDWLYHO\VXSSOHPHQWIUR]HQVHFWLRQDQDO\VLVWRHVWDEOLVKWKHGHSWKRIWXPRXU
LQÀOWUDWLRQ7RYDOLGDWHWKH9&7DSSURDFKZHFRPSDUHG&79&7DQGKLVWRSDWKROJ\
UHVXOWVIRUWXPRXUH[WHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV+HDGDQGQHFNWXPRXUVRISDWLHQWVZHUHSUHRSHUD
WLYHO\VWDJHGZLWK&73HULRSHUDWLYH9&7RIWKHUHVHFWHGVSHFLPHQZDVXVHGWR
VXSSOHPHQWIUR]HQVHFWLRQDQDO\VLV%RQHGHVWUXFWLRQZDVFRPSDUHGIRUWKH9&7
&7DQGIUR]HQVHFWLRQPHWKRGVEHIRUHWKHUHVXOWVZHUHUHOD\HGWRWKHVXUJHRQ
ZKRDGMXVWHGWKHUHVHFWLRQSURFHGXUHDVQHFHVVDU\6WDJLQJ&7DQGÀQDOKLVWRSD
WKRORJ\UHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGSRVWRSHUDWLYHO\SDWLHQWVZHUHQRWLQFOXGHGLQ
WKHÀQDOHYDOXDWLRQEHFDXVHHLWKHUKLVWRSDWKRORJ\RU&7UHVXOWVZHUHLQFRPSOHWH
5HVXOWV&7GHWHUPLQHGDODUJHUWXPRXUVL]HWKDQKLVWRORJ\LQFDVHV PHDQ
GLIIHUHQFHPP DVPDOOHUVL]HLQFDVHV PHDQGLIIHUHQFHPP DQGDS
SUR[LPDWHO\HTXDOVL]HVLQFDVHV,QDFRPSDULVRQRIWXPRXUH[WHQWZLWK&7
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
5DGLRFKHPRWKHUDS\LQGXFHGFKDQJHVRIORFDOWXPRXUEORRGVXSSO\
HVWLPDWHGE\'&(&7LQKHDGDQGQHFNWXPRXUV
$$EUDP\XN9+LHWVFKROG.=RHSKHO6$SSROG5YRQ.XPPHU
1$EROPDDOL'UHVGHQ'( $QGULM$EUDP\XN#8QLNOLQLNXP'UHVGHQGH
3XUSRVH5DGLRFKHPRWKHUDS\ 5&K7 LVFRQVLGHUHGVWDQGDUGWUHDWPHQWIRUQRQ
RSHUDEOHKHDGDQGQHFNWXPRXUV +17 3ULPDU\DLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWH
5&K7LQGXFHGFKDQJHVRIORFDOWXPRXUEORRGVXSSO\SDUDPHWHUVUHODWLYHWXPRXU
EORRGYROXPH U7%9 DQGWUDQVIHUFRHIÀFLHQW .WUDQV GHULYHGIURP'&(&7LQ+17
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK QRQRSHUDEOH +17 6WDJHV ,,,,9
VFKHGXOHGIRU5&K7ZHUHLQFOXGHG&KHPRWKHUDS\FRQVLVWHGRIFLVSODWLQGXULQJ
DOOZHHNVRIUDGLRWKHUDS\DQGÁXRURXUDFLOGXULQJÀUVWZHHNRQO\'&(&7ZDV
SHUIRUPHGEHIRUH5&K7LQWZRZHHNV *\ DQGÀYHZHHNV *\ XVLQJ%LRJUDSK
6LHPHQV U7%9XQG.WUDQVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGE\PRGLÀHG3DWODNDQDO\VLVXV
LQJSL[HOEDVHGVRIWZDUH 93&76LHPHQV '\QDPLFVRIU7%9DQG.WUDQVZHUH
DQDO\VHGGXULQJ5&K7DQGLQPRQWKVIROORZXS
5HVXOWV,QSDWLHQWVDQLQFUHDVHRIU7%9DQGRU.WUDQVDIWHU*\IROORZHGE\
DGHFUHDVHRIERWKSDUDPHWHUVDIWHU*\ZDVQRWHG([FHSWIRURQHSDWLHQWZLWK
ORFDOUHFXUUHQFHFRPSOHWHWXPRXUUHVSRQVHGXULQJIROORZXSZDVGLDJQRVHGLQ
SDWLHQWV,QSDWLHQWVDQLQFUHDVHRIU7%9ZLWKFRQFRPLWDQWGURSRI.WUDQVXQGHU
5&K7ZDVGHWHFWHG0RUSKRORJLFDOO\LQDOOSDWLHQWVDSDUWLDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVH
ZDVHVWDEOLVKHG,QSDWLHQWVKRZLQJDQHOHYDWLRQRIERWKU7%9DQG.WUDQVGXULQJ
5&K7ORFDOWXPRXUSURJUHVVZDVGHWHFWHGGXULQJIROORZXS
&RQFOXVLRQ(VWLPDWHGE\'&(&7UDGLRFKHPRWKHUDS\LQGXFHGFKDQJHVRIU7%9
XQG.WUDQVPD\UHSUHVHQWDPRGLÀFDWLRQRIORFDOWXPRXUEORRGVXSSO\DVDIXQFWLRQ
RILQWUDWXPRUDOR[\JHQGLVWULEXWLRQDQGFRQVHTXHQWO\UHYHDOFOLQLFDOLPSDFWDOORZLQJ
LQGLYLGXDOLVDWLRQRI5&K7VWUDWHJ\LQSDWLHQWVZLWK+17
%
'\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJWRGLVWLQJXLVK
WXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHIURPVFDUDIWHUWUHDWPHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWKKHDG
DQGQHFNQHRSODVPVDSLORWVWXG\
&*DXGLQR5&VHUQXV6+HLODQG0%HQGV]XV65RKGH
+HLGHOEHUJ'( FKLDUDJDXGLQR#PHGXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH,QIROORZXSLPDJLQJRISDWLHQWVZLWKKHDGDQGQHFNQHRSODVPVLWLVRIWHQ
GLIÀFXOWWRGLVWLQJXLVKWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHIURPVFDUDIWHUWUHDWPHQW$LPRIWKLVVWXG\
LVWRDQDO\VHLISHUIXVLRQFXUYHSDWWHUQVKHOSWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHWXPRXUIURPVFDU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05,SHUIXVLRQGDWDRISDWLHQWV PHQPHDQDJH
\HDUV ZLWKVXVSLFLRXVHQKDQFLQJOHVLRQVRIWKHRURSKDU\Q[RUWKHRUDOFDYLW\
ZHUHDQDO\VHG,QSDWLHQWVSULPDU\RUUHFXUUHQWVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPDZDV
GLDJQRVHGKLVWRORJLFDOO\LQSDWLHQWVVFDUZDVGLDJQRVHGKLVWRORJLFDOO\ Q RU
E\ORQJWHUPUDGLRORJLFDOIROORZXS !PRQWKV '\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD7HVODVFDQQHU 7LP7ULR6LHPHQV(UODQJHQ*HUPDQ\ XVLQJ
DYROXPHWULFLQWHUSRODWHGEUHDWKKROGH[DPLQDWLRQ 9,%( 7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFH
757(PVHFVOLFHPP)29PPPHDVXUHPHQWVRIVÁRZ
POV 3HUIXVLRQGDWDZHUHSRVWSURFHVVHGRQDUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW 52, EDVLV
XVLQJ WKH PHDQFXUYH VRIWZDUH 6LHPHQV (UODQJHQ*HUPDQ\ REWDLQLQJ VLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\WLPH6 W FXUYHV,QHDFKVXVSHFWOHVLRQIRXU52,VZHUHSRVLWLRQHGLQ
FRQVHQVXVRIWZRUDGLRORJLVWV)RUHDFK6 W FXUYH PD[LPDOLQWHQVLW\YDOXH
3PD[ DQG WLPHWRSHDN 773 ZHUHDQDO\VHG
5HVXOWV0HDQ6 W FXUYHVRIWKHWZRJURXSVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW7XPRXU
VKRZHGDIDVWZDVKLQ 773 V ZLWKDKLJK3PD[ UDQJH
VFDUKDGDVORZHUZDVKLQ 773 VS ZLWKDORZHU3PD[
UDQJHS
&RQFOXVLRQ3HUIXVLRQ6 W FXUYHSDWWHUQRIKHDGDQGQHFNVTXDPRXVFHOOFDU
FLQRPDVLVVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQWWRSHUIXVLRQ6 W FXUYHSDWWHUQRIVFDUIROORZLQJ
WUHDWPHQW'\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,FRXOGEHKHOSIXOLQIROORZXSRISDWLHQWV
ZLWKKHDGDQGQHFNWXPRXUV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHFRPELQHG)ÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVHSRVLWURQ
HPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ ))'* 3(7&7 WR FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, LQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIKHDGDQGQHFN
FDQFHUUHJDUGLQJGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\DQGWXPRXUYROXPHWU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:LWKLQGD\V))'*3(7&7DQG05,ZHUHSHU
IRUPHGLQRUDOFDYLW\6&& Q SULPDULHVUHFXUUHQWWXPRXUV DQGZLWKLQ
GD\VLQ+RGJNLQO\PSKRPD Q SULPDULHVUHFXUUHQWWXPRXUV (YDOXDWHG
SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH WXPRXU ORFDOLVDWLRQ WXPRXU GLDPHWHU WXPRXU YROXPH O\PSK
QRGHVGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHV
5HVXOWV ,Q RUDO FDYLW\ 6&& GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ ZDV DV IROORZV DFFRUGDQFH
RI 05, 3(7&7 05,SRVLWLYH3(7&7QHJDWLYH 05,QHJDWLYH
3(7&7SRVLWLYH 05,SRVLWLYH3(7&7XQFOHDU 05,QHJDWLYH3(7
&7XQFOHDU 3(7&7SRVLWLYH05,XQFOHDU 3(7&7QHJDWLYH05,
XQFOHDU$YHUDJHPD[LPXPVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNHYDOXHV 689PD[ LQ3(7&7
ÀQGLQJVZHUHPHDVXUHGWREH,QWXPRXUYROXPHDQGH[SDQVLRQ3(7&7YV
05,VKRZHGODUJHUYROXPHLQ05,YV3(7&7ODUJHUYROXPHLQ3(7
&7HTXDOHG05,LQ,QQRHYDOXDWLRQZDVSRVVLEOH5HJDUGLQJO\PSK
QRGHHYDOXDWLRQ05,HTXDOHG3(7&7,QGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHVZHUHGHWHFWHG
YLD))'*3(7&7,Q+RGJNLQO\PSKRPDWKHUHZDVQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRPRGDOLWLHVUHJDUGLQJSDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV&RQFHUQLQJ
O\PSKRPDH[SDQVLRQ3(7&7ZDVVXSHULRUWR05,LQ05,ZDVVXSHULRUWR
3(7&7LQDQGLQRWKHUSDWLHQWV05,HTXDOHG3(7&7&RQFHUQLQJO\PSK
QRGH QXPEHUV 05, HTXDOHG 3(7&7 LQ VL]H DQG PRUSKRORJ\ ,Q VXVSHFW
H[WUDFHUYLFDOÀQGLQJVZHUHUHYHDOHGE\))'*3(7&7
&RQFOXVLRQ,QVXPPDU\05,ZDVHTXDOWR3(7&7UHJDUGLQJDFFXUDF\&RQFHUQ
LQJYROXPHWU\05,KDGVRPHDGYDQWDJHVYV3(7&7))'*3(7&7HDVLO\
LGHQWLÀHGGLVWDQWO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHV0D[LPXPVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNHYDOXHV
689PD[! LQ3(7&7LVUHOLDEOHIRUHYDOXDWLQJO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHV
9&7DQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFPHWKRGVUHVXOWVZHUHDSSUR[LPDWHO\HTXDOLQFDVHV
DOWKRXJK9&7EHVWYLVXDOLVHGWKHH[WHQWRIERQHGHVWUXFWLRQ,QFDVHVWKH&7
UHVXOWVGLIIHUHGIURPWKRVHGHWHUPLQHGE\9&7DQGKLVWRORJ\
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\LVDVRXQGPHWKRGIRUGHWHUPLQLQJWXPRXU
H[WHQW9&7FDQDFFXUDWHO\GHWHUPLQHERQ\LQÀOWUDWLRQ,WLVWKXVDYDOLGLQWUDRSHUDWLYH
VXSSOHPHQWWRIUR]HQVHFWLRQDQDO\VLVDQGFDQDLGWKHUHVHFWLRQDQGUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
VWUDWHJ\ 6HFRQGDU\ UHFRQVWUXFWLYH VXUJHU\ FDQ EH DYRLGHG WKHUHE\ LQFUHDVLQJ
SDWLHQWVҋOLIHTXDOLW\DQGGHFUHDVLQJWRWDOWKHUDS\FRVWV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'RDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWDQGKLVWRORJLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRI
VTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPDRIWKHRUDOFDYLW\FRUUHODWH"
/%RQHOOR/3UHGD*3HWUDOLD36XPPHUV&*LDQQLWWR0%HOORPL0LODQ,7
OXNHERQHOOR#LHRLW
3XUSRVH7RFRUUHODWHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& ZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOFKDU
DFWHULVWLFVRIVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPDRIWKHRUDOFDYLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKXQWUHDWHGKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQVTXDPRXV
FHOOFDUFLQRPDXQGHUZHQWFRQYHQWLRQDO LQFOXGLQJ7ZHLJKWHGDQG7SUHDQG
SRVWFRQWUDVW DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, EYDOXHVDQGVPP
7KH$'&IRURUDOFDYLW\WXPRXUVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIURPUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWGUDZQ
PDQXDOO\RQWKHKLJKHVWEYDOXHLPDJHVXVLQJWKH,PDJH- ,PDJH-1,+ DQGIVO
IVO8QLYHUVLW\RI2[IRUG LPDJHSURFHVVLQJSDFNDJHV7KH$'&IRUWKHWXPRXU
YROXPHREWDLQHGZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFV 710*UDGLQJ
5HVXOWV2IWKHHOLJLEOHSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHVPHDQDJHUDQJH
\HDUV ZHUHVXLWDEOHIRU$'&FDOFXODWLRQ1LQHSDWLHQWVZHUHH[FOXGHGGXH
WRWKHSUHVHQFHRIDUWHIDFWVDQGGXHWRLQDELOLW\WRYLVXDOLVHWKHWXPRXURQWKH
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHV7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHZDVPPVDQG
PHDQVL]HPP$'&GLGQRWFRUUHODWHZLWKWXPRXUVWDJHRUJUDGH$'&
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHU S IRU1 Q VWDJHWXPRXUVZKHQFRPSDUHGWR
1 Q VWDJH1RRWKHUGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHREVHUYHGEHWZHHQ7VWDJHV1VWDJHV
RUWXPRXU*UDGLQJ
&RQFOXVLRQ,QRXUFRKRUWZHGLGQRWREVHUYHFOLQLFDOO\UHOHYDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQ$'&
YDOXHVLQVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPDRIWKHRUDOFDYLW\
%
0DFURELRSVLHVIRUKHDGDQGQHFNFDQFHUV
--DQVVHQV0'HOHX+DVVHOW%(7LHQHQ%(
MDDNMDQVVHQV#LQWHUYHQWLRQDORQFRORJ\VRFLHW\RUJ
3XUSRVH&RQWHPSRUDU\PHGLFDOWUHDWPHQWVIRUKHDGDQGQHFN + 1 FDQFHUV
LQFUHDVLQJO\ XVH WDUJHWHG WKHUDSLHV WKDW DUH VHOHFWHG E\ PROHFXODU ELRPDUNHUV
7RDOORZWKHVHSHUVRQDOLVHGGLDJQRVWLFVPDFURELRSVLHVDUHSUHIHUUHG7KLVVWXG\
HYDOXDWHVWKHXVHRIWKH6SLURWRPHPDFURELRSV\V\VWHPLQ+ 1FDQFHUVIRUSURYLG
LQJKLJKTXDOLW\WLVVXHVSHFLPHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKDPDVVLQWKH+ 1UHJLRQZHUHVHOHFWHG
IRUELRSV\LQUHJLRQDOKRVSLWDOV0LOGDQWLFRDJXODWLRQZDVDOORZHG7KHELRSV\
VLWHZDVVWXGLHGZLWKUHJDUGWRDFFHVVURXWHDQGFULWLFDORUJDQVE\XOWUDVRXQG&7
DQGRU05,7KH6SLURWRPH 0HG,QYHQWV19%HOJLXP ZDVXVHGDVPDFURELRSV\
V\VWHP 6DPSOH TXDOLW\ ZDV HYDOXDWHG ZLWK UHJDUG WR YROXPH OHQJWK GLDPHWHU
DQG KLVWRORJLFDOLPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLFDO GLDJQRVLV DQG PROHFXODU ELRORJ\ 3DWLHQW
WROHUDQFHDQGERWKHDUO\DQGODWHFRPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWVWKHDQWLFLSDWHGSURFHGXUHFRXOGEHSHUIRUPHGZLWKRXW
FRPSOLFDWLRQVRUPDMRUVLGHHIIHFWV7ROHUDQFHZDVJRRGZLWKRQO\PLQLPDOSDLQLQ
SDWLHQWV,QDOOFDVHVPLQLPDOEOHHGLQJFRXOGEHVWRSSHGGXULQJWKHSURFHGXUH
1RKRVSLWDOLVDWLRQRUSURORQJHGVWD\ZDVQHFHVVDU\:KHUHDSSURSULDWH Q
FRPSOHWHKLVWRORJLFDOLPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLFDODQGPROHFXODUELRORJ\FRXOGEHSHU
IRUPHG,QSDWLHQWVRQO\EHQLJQUHDFWLYHO\PSKQRGHWLVVXHFRXOGEHKDUYHVWHG
,QSDWLHQWDQDEVFHVVZDVUHFRUGHG,QSDWLHQWVDQLQFRPSOHWHSDWKRORJLFDO
SURWRFROZDVJLYHQGXHWRUHLPEXUVHPHQWUHVWULFWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH 6SLURWRPH PDFURELRSV\ SURYLGHV VXIÀFLHQW DQG KLJKTXDOLW\
WLVVXHYROXPHLQ+ 1FDQFHUVWRDOORZDOOPROHFXODUELRORJ\DQGKLVWRORJLFDOWHVWV
IRURSWLPDOGLDJQRVLVZLWKRXWKRVSLWDOLVDWLRQRUPDMRUVLGHHIIHFWV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP/0
0ROHFXODU,PDJLQJ
66
+\EULGLPDJLQJ3(7&7DQG053(7
0RGHUDWRUV
.cKOVWU|P5LNOXQG8PHn6(
/63ROLWL0LODQ,7
%
5ROHRI)'*3(7&7LQWKHIROORZXSRISDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWVZLWK
(ZLQJVDUFRPDDQGSULPLWLYHQHXURHFWRGHUPDOWXPRXU
($$ODODZL$$OVXJDLU$-DYHG$$O*DIUL$,$OPXKDLGHE$)DWKDOD
07XOL00$ERX]LHG5L\DGK6$ ]LHG#EXIIDORHGX
3XUSRVH :H DUH DLPLQJ WR HYDOXDWH WKH GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH RI ) )'*
3(7&7LQWKHIROORZXSRISDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWVZLWK(ZLQJ6DUFRPDDQGSULPLWLYH
QHXURHFWRGHUPDOWXPRXU 31(7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(LJKW\WZRFRQVHFXWLYH3(7&7VFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
LQWKLUW\QLQHSDHGLDUWULFSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOSURRIRI(ZLQJҋVVDUFRPD
LQSDWLHQWVDQG31(7LQWKUHHSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHV DYHUDJHDJHRI
\HDUV UDQJH\HDUV )'*3(7&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGWRHYDOXDWHDVXVSHFWHG
ORFDOUHFXUUHQFHDQGWRUXOHRXWGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHV+LVWRORJ\ Q RUIROORZXS
FOLQLFDOO\DQGUDGLRORJLFDOO\ Q IRUDWOHDVWPRQWKV UDQJHPRQWKV ZHUH
HPSOR\HGDVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFHIRULPDJLQJÀQGLQJV
5HVXOWV3(7&7ZDVWUXHQHJDWLYHLQSDWLHQWVLQH[FOXGLQJORFDOUHFXUUHQFH
2QO\RQHIDOVHQHJDWLYHVWXG\LQDSDWLHQWGHYHORSHGORFDOUHFXUUHQFHDWIRXUPRQWKV
SRVWVFDQQLQJZLWKDQRYHUDOOQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI2QWKHRWKHUKDQG
3(7&7ZDVWUXHSRVLWLYHLQÀYHSDWLHQWVDQGIDOVHSRVLWLYHLQRQHSDWLHQWLQZKRP
WKHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQUHYHDOHGÀEUREODVWLFSUROLIHUDWLRQJLDQWFHOOUHDF
WLRQDQGQRYLDEOHWXPRXUZLWKDQRYHUDOOSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI2YHUDOO
3(7&7KDGDQDFFXUDF\RI3(7&7GHSLFWHGGLVWDQWOXQJPHWDVWDWLFGLVHDVH
LQWHQSDWLHQWDQGERQHPHWDVWDVHVLQWZRSDWLHQWVUHTXLULQJIXUWKHUFKHPRWKHUDS\
&RQFOXVLRQ3(7&7LVDXVHIXOGLDJQRVWLFWRROLQWKHIROORZXSRISDWLHQWVZLWK(Z
LQJVDUFRPDSDUWLFXODUO\LQH[FOXGLQJORFDODQGGLVWDQWGLVHDVHZLWKKLJKGLDJQRVWLF
DFFXUDF\)DOVHSRVLWLYHÀQGLQJVPLJKWEHUHODWHGWRWKHUDS\LQGXFHGLQÁDPPDWLRQ
%
/RZGRVHQRQHQKDQFHG&7YHUVXVIXOOGRVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
&7LQLQWHJUDWHG)'*3(7&7VWXGLHVIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIRYDULDQ
FDQFHUUHFXUUHQFH
..LWDMLPD<8HQR.6X]XNL<2QLVKL0.LWD7<RVKLNDZD<2KQR
06HQGD.6XJLPXUD.REH-3 NLWDMLPD#PHGNREHXDFMS
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHORZGRVHQRQHQKDQFHG&7 OG&7 DQGIXOOGRVHFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG&7 FH&7 LQ)'*3(7&7VWXGLHVIRUUHVWDJLQJRIRYDULDQFDQFHU
0HWKRGV2QHKXQGUHGZRPHQZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHWUHDWPHQWIRURYDULDQFDQFHU
XQGHUZHQWDFRQYHQWLRQDO3(7&7VFDQVZLWKOG&7DQGWKHQFH&77ZRREVHUYHUV
LQWHUSUHWHGDQGGHFLGHGLQFRQVHQVXVRQWKH3(7OG&7DQG3(7FH&7LPDJHVE\
DSRLQWVFDOH 1QHJDWLYH(HTXLYRFDO3SRVLWLYH SHUSDWLHQWDQGOHVLRQ)LQDO
GLDJQRVHVZHUHREWDLQHGE\KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQVRUFOLQLFDOIROORZXS
IRUDWOHDVWVL[PRQWKV
5HVXOWV3DWLHQWEDVHGDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKDWWKHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDF
FXUDF\ RI 3(7FH&7 ZHUH DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ZKHUHDVWKRVHRI3(7OG&7ZHUH DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\GLGQRWVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\GLIIHUEHWZHHQWZRPHWKRGV 0F1HPDUWHVWS S DQGS
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KHUHZHUHVLWHVRIOHVLRQUHFXUUHQFHSHULWRQHXPSHOYLF
O\PSKQRGH /1 SDUDDRUWLF/1ORFDOUHFXUUHQFHOLYHUVXSUDFODYLFXODU
/1PHGLDVWLQDOKLODU/1DQGOXQJ7KHVFDOHVRIGHWHFWLQJUHFXUUHQWUHJLRQV
ZHUH1(3IRU3(7FH&7DQG1(3IRU3(7OG&7UHVSHF
WLYHO\1LQHHTXLYRFDOUHJLRQV ORFDOSHULWRQHXPSHOYLF/1SDUDDRUWLF/1
VXSUDFODYLFXODU/1DQGOLYHU DQGRQHQHJDWLYHUHJLRQV OLYHU E\3(7OG&7ZHUH
FRUUHFWO\LQWHUSUHWHGDVSRVLWLYHE\3(7FH&7
&RQFOXVLRQ3(7FH&7LVDQDFFXUDWHLPDJLQJPRGDOLW\IRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRI
RYDULDQ FDQFHU UHFXUUHQFH ZLWK FHUWDLQW\ UHGXFLQJ WKH IUHTXHQF\ RI HTXLYRFDO
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
(DUO\ERQHPDUURZ %0 PHWDVWDVHVPHWDEROLFGDWDXVLQJ
)ÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVH )'* 3(7&7YHUVXV&7LPDJLQJ
$3DQXQ]LR/(YDQJHOLVWD$5&HUYLQR0*UHJLDQLQ*6DODGLQL
3&0X]]LR53ROYHURVL3DGXD,7 DQQDORULSDQXQ]LR#OLEHURLW
%
&7SURWRFROVLQ>)@)'*3(7&7H[DPLQDWLRQVLVWKHUHDQ
DGGLWLRQDOEHQHÀWRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7LQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRI
LQFLGHQWDOJDVWURLQWHVWLQDO)'*XSWDNH"
&%UHQGOH&6FKUDPO7.UDWW05HLPROG&3IDQQHQEHUJ
7ELQJHQ'( FRUQHOLDEUHQGOH#PHGXQLWXHELQJHQGH
3XUSRVH (YDOXDWLRQ RI WKH SRVVLEOH EHQHÀW RI FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG &( &7 LQ
FRPSDULVRQWRORZGRVH ,' &7LQ>)@)'*3(7&7IRUWKHIXUWKHUHYDOXDWLRQ
RILQFLGHQWDOJDVWURLQWHVWLQDO)'*XSWDNH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URPDGDWDEDVHRISDWLHQWVZLWK)'*3(7&7
DVXEJURXSRISDWLHQWVZLWKLQFLGHQWDOO\GHWHFWHGJDVWURLQWHVWLQDO3(7OHVLRQV
DQG D 3(7&7 VFDQ LQFOXGLQJ D PXOWLSKDVH OG IRU$& &( &7 SURWRFRO ZDV
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHG7KH3(7OHVLRQVZHUHFDWHJRULVHGFRQFHUQLQJWKHLU&7
SDWWHUQV PDVVLQÁDPPDWLRQXQVSHFLÀFQRUPDO VHSDUDWHO\IRUERWK&7SURWRFROV
7KHLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHUHVXOWVRIHQGRVFRS\RUVXUJHU\
5HVXOWVLQFLGHQWDOJDVWURLQWHVWLQDO3(7OHVLRQVZHUHIRXQGLQWKHJURXSRI
SDWLHQWV7KH339IRUDFRUUHVSRQGLQJHQGRVFRSLFSDWKRORJ\LQWKHVHOHVLRQVZDV
IRU&(&7DQG,'&7$OOPDOLJQDQFLHVZHUHFRUUHFWO\GHWHFWHGE\&(&7
VHQVLWLYLW\ LQFRPSDULVRQWRRQO\GHWHFWHGPDOLJQDQFLHVE\,'&7 VHQVLWLYLW\
3UHPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVLQHQGRVFRS\ ZHUHGHWHFWHGLQE\&(&7
DQGE\,'&7WKHEHQLJQÀQGLQJV LQÁDPPDWLRQVDQGEHQLJQPDVVHV LQ
E\&(&7DQGE\,'&77KHIDOVHQHJDWLYHUDWHLQ,'&7ZDVKLJKHUWKDQLQ
&(&7 YHUVXV )DOVHSRVLWLYHUHVXOWVGXHWRSK\VLRORJLFDO)'*XSWDNH
OHVLRQV FRXOGEHH[FOXGHGQHLWKHUE\&(&7QRUE\,'&7
&RQFOXVLRQ&(&7SURYLGHVDGGLWLRQDOEHQHÀWLQGHWHFWLQJLQFLGHQWDOJDVWURLQWHV
WLQDOPDOLJQDQFLHV+RZHYHUHQGRVFRS\RILQFLGHQWDOJDVWURLQWHVWLQDO3(7OHVLRQV
FDQQRWEHVSDUHGGXHWRDVXEVWDQWLDOSHUFHQWDJHRIIDOVHQHJDWLYHUHVXOWVLQERWK
&7SURWRFROVUHJDUGLQJSUHPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOHVLRQV
%
$GGLWLRQDOYDOXHRI´GXDOSKDVHµ))'*3(7&7LQUHFXUUHQW
J\QDHFRORJLFDOPDOLJQDQFLHV
*'ҋ$QJHOR30LUN95XÀQL0&DOFDJQL$'L/HJJH$7HVWD*6FDPELD
$*LRUGDQR/%RQRPR5RPH,7 SPLUN#UPXQLFDWWLW
3XUSRVH 7R SURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWH WKH XVHIXOQHVV RI ´GXDO SKDVHµ 3(7&7 LQ
VXVSHFWHGUHFXUUHQFHVIURPJ\QDHFRORJLFDOPDOLJQDQFLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGUHFXUUHQFHVIURPSUHYLRXVO\
WUHDWHGJ\QDHFRORJLFDOFDQFHUXQGHUZHQWERWKZKROHERG\3(7&7DWKUDIWHU
))'*LQMHFWLRQ VWDQGDUG3(7&7 DQGGHOD\HG3(7&7RIWKHDEQRUPDODUHD
DWKUVSRVW))'*LQMHFWLRQ GXDOSKDVH3(7&7 %HVLGHVTXDOLWDWLYHHYDOX
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
:KROHERG\3(7&7FRPSDUHGWRZKROHERG\05,LQWKHGLDJQRVLVRI
VFOHURWLFERQHPHWDVWDVHV
606KDLNK+\GHUDEDG,1
3XUSRVH$LP RI WKH VWXG\ ZDV WR HYDOXDWH WKH GLDJQRVWLF YDOXH RI FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG3(7&7XVLQJ))'*FRPSDUHGWRZKROHERG\05, :%05, LQ
WKHGLDJQRVLVRIVFOHURWLFERQHPHWDVWDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDUHWURVSHFWLYHEOLQGHGVWXG\SDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG
VFOHURWLF VNHOHWDO PHWDVWDVHV XQGHUZHQW 3(7&7 DV ZHOO DV :%05, ZLWK WKH
XVHRISDUDOOHOLPDJLQJ3(7&7ZDVDFTXLUHGDIWHUDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRI))'*
ZKLFKIROORZHGE\ZLWKD05E\705,V\VWHPFRURQDO7ZHLJKWHGDQG67,5
VHTXHQFHVRIWKHHQWLUHERG\DQGVDJLWWDOLPDJLQJRIWKHVSLQHZHUHSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV6FOHURWLFERQHPHWDVWDVHVZHUHFRQÀUPHGLQSDWLHQWV:%05,EXW
ZDVPLVVHGLQSDWLHQWGXULQJLQLWLDO3(7&7UHDGLQJ:%05,UDWHGOHVLRQV
DVVXVSLFLRXVIRUPDOLJQDQF\RXWRIWKHPOHVLRQVWXUQHGRXWWREHPHWDVWDWLF
3(7&7 GHVFULEHG D QXPEHU RI OHVLRQV DV PHWDVWDWLF ZKLFK ZDV ORZHU DV
FRPSDUHGWR:%05,0RVWPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVPLVVHGE\3(7&7ZHUHORFDWHGLQ
WKHH[WUHPLWLHV3(7&7ZDVPRUHVHQVLWLYHLQGHWHFWLQJPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVRIWKH
OXPEDU VSLQH :%05, Q YV 3(7&7 Q 7KH OHVLRQV PLVVHG E\ :%05,
ZHUHORFDWHGLQWKHVSLQH Q DQGULEFDJH Q OHVLRQVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGDV
EHQLJQGXULQJIROORZXS3(7&7UDWHGRIWKHVHOHVLRQVFRUUHFWO\DVSUREDEO\
EHQLJQ:%05,RQO\:%05,IDOVHO\GLDJQRVHGPHWDVWDWLFERQHGLVHDVHLQ
RQHKHDOWK\SDWLHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ:%05,GHOLQHDWHVPRUHVFOHURWLFERQHPHWDVWDVHVFRPSDUHGWR
3(7&7
%
'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIYLUWXDO)'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\IRUWKH
GHWHFWLRQRIO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVLQQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
7$+HXVQHU-7UHIIHUW%*HLJHU9+DUWXQJ0+HUEULN0)RUVWLQJ
*$QWRFK'VVHOGRUI'(.QR[YLOOH71863ULQFHWRQ1-86
(VVHQ'( KHXVQHU#PHGXQLGXHVVHOGRUIGH
3XUSRVH 7KH DLP ZDV WR GHWHUPLQH D WKH GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ RI WKH )'*
3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIPHGLDVWLQDOKLODULQWHUOREDUDQGOREDU
O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVLQQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHU 16&/& SDWLHQWV E WKH
VPDOOHVWEURQFKXVGLDPHWHUDFFHVVLEOHE\YLUWXDO)'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\ F
WKHWLPHGXUDWLRQIURPVWDUWLQJWKHYLHZLQJWRROXQWLOYLUWXDO)'*3(7&7LPDJHV
ZHUHGLVSOD\HG
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 16&/& SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW )'*3(7&7 )URP
WKHVHVRXUFHGDWDYLUWXDO)'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRSLHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG7KH
WLPHGXUDWLRQIURPVWDUWLQJWKHWRROWLOOWKHGLVSOD\RIYLUWXDOEURQFKRVFRS\LPDJHV
ZDVGHWHUPLQHG7KHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI)'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\IRUWKH
GHWHFWLRQRIUHJLRQDOO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVZDVHYDOXDWHGRQDOHVLRQEDVLV$[LDO
)'*3(7&7VFDQVVHUYHGDVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH7KHVPDOOHVWEURQFKXV
GLDPHWHUDFFHVVLEOHE\)'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\ZDVPHDVXUHG
5HVXOWV 7KH VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ SRVLWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH 339 QHJDWLYH
SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH 139 DQG DFFXUDF\ RI YLUWXDO )'*3(7&7 EURQFKRVFRS\ IRU
WKHGHWHFWLRQRIO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVZDVDQG7KH
PHDQVPDOOHVWGLDPHWHURIDFFHVVLEOHEURQFKLE\)'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\ZDV
PP7KHPHDQWLPHGXUDWLRQIURPVWDUWLQJWKHYLUWXDO)'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\
WRROWLOOWKHGLVSOD\RIWKHLPDJHVZDVVHFRQGV
&RQFOXVLRQ9LUWXDO´Á\WKURXJKµ')'*3(7&7EURQFKRVFRS\LVIHDVLEOHLQFOLQL
FDOURXWLQH\LHOGVDUHODWLYHO\KLJKGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIUHJLRQDO
O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVDQGKDVDFFHVVWREURQFKLHYHQLQWKHSHULSKHU\RIWKHOXQJ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFUROHRI)'*3(7&7YV&7LQHDUO\PHWDVWDWLF
GHSRVLWLQ%0
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK OXQJ FDQFHU ZLWK EUHDVW
FDQFHUZLWKO\PSKRPDDQGZLWKPXOWLSOHP\HORPDZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
H[DPLQHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW)'*3(7&7DQG&7IRUGLVHDVHHYDOXDWLRQ$W
WKHWLPHRI3(7&7QRQHRIWKHSDWLHQWVZHUHUHFHLYLQJF\WRNLQHWKHUDS\$OOVFDQV
ZHUHUHYLHZHGE\DUDGLRORJLVWDQGDQXFOHDUPHGLFLQHSK\VLFLDQ%0PHWDVWDVHV
ZHUHFRQÀUPHGE\VHTXHQWLDO3(7&7RU05,ZKHQDYDLODEOH7KHLPDJHVRI3(7
&7DQG&7ZHUHFRPSDUHG$SDWLHQWEDVHGDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV SDWLHQWVKDGSRVLWLYHDQG QHJDWLYH&7VFDQZKHUHDV
KDGSRVLWLYHDQG QHJDWLYH3(7&7IRUERQHOHVLRQV7KHLPDJ
LQJÀQGLQJVZHUHFRQFRUGDQWLQ SDWLHQWVZKLOH KDG
GLVFRUGDQWLPDJLQJUHVXOWV &KLVTXDUHWHVWS FRQFRUGDQW
SDWLHQWVKDG%0OHVLRQVDW3(7&7ZKHUHDVRXWRI SDWLHQWVKDG%0
LQYROYHPHQW7KHUHIRUH3(7&7ZDVDEOHWRLGHQWLI\ SDWLHQWVZLWK
FRQÀUPHG%0OHVLRQV,QWKHVHODWWHUSDWLHQWVWKHVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNHYDOXHIRU
%0PHWDVWDVHVZDV UDQJH UHVXOWLQJZHDNO\KLJKHULQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKQHJDWLYHWKDQSRVLWLYH&7VFDQ YVUHVSHFWLYHO\WVWXGHQW
WHVWS
&RQFOXVLRQ3(7&7LVPRUHDFFXUDWHWKDQ&7LQGHWHFWLRQRI%0PHWDVWDVHVLWV
LQFOXVLRQLQGLDJQRVWLFDOJRULWKPVFKDQJHGWKHVWDJLQJLQDERXWRISDWLHQWV
3(7&7GHWHFWV%0OHVLRQVGLUHFWO\EDVHGRQWKHLUGHJUHHRQPHWDEROLFDFWLYLW\
HLWKHUWKDQE\DOWHUHGDQDWRP\
DWLRQVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHFULWHULDXVHGZHUHVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNHYDOXHRIHDUO\DQG
GHOD\HGLPDJHVDQGUHWHQWLRQLQGH[RIWKHOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV3HUSDWLHQWDQDO\VLVSDWLHQWVZHUHFRQÀUPHGWRKDYHUHFXUUHQFH
DQGWRKDYHEHQLJQOHVLRQV6WDQGDUG3(7&7GHWHFWHGUHFXUUHQWWXPRXULQ
SDWLHQWV ZKHUHDVGHOD\HGVFDQZDVWUXHSRVLWLYHLQ
6WDQGDUG3(7&7FRUUHFWO\H[FOXGHGPDOLJQDQF\LQSDWLHQWV DQGZDV
IDOVHSRVLWLYHLQ ZKHUHDVGHOD\HGVFDQZDVWUXHQHJDWLYHLQ
DQGIDOVHSRVLWLYHLQ 3HUOHVLRQDQDO\VLVOHVLRQVZHUHFRQ
ÀUPHGWREHPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQ6WDQGDUG3(7&7FRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHG
WXPRXUOHVLRQV ZKHUHDVDWGHOD\HGVFDQDOOOHVLRQVZHUHWUXHSRVLWLYH
6WDQGDUG3(7&7FRUUHFWO\H[FOXGHGPDOLJQDQF\LQ DQGZDV
IDOVHSRVLWLYHLQ ZKHUHDVGHOD\HGVFDQZDVWUXHQHJDWLYHLQ
OHVLRQV DQGIDOVHSRVLWLYHLQ 0HDQ5,ZDV UDQJH
LQPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVDQG UDQJH LQEHQLJQOHVLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ 'XDO SKDVH 3(7&7 LV D YDOXDEOH WRRO LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK VXVSHFWHG
UHFXUUHQFHRIJ\QDHFRORJLFDOFDQFHUDQGPD\LPSDFWRQSDWLHQWPDQDJHPHQW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'RHVVLPXOWDQHRXVLPDJHDFTXLVLWLRQE\DK\EULG053(7V\VWHP
UHVXOWLQDEHWWHUUHJLVWUDWLRQTXDOLW\RI3(7DQGPRUSKRORJLFGDWD
FRPSDUHGWRVHTXHQWLDOLPDJHDFTXLVLWLRQE\3(7&7"
&%UHQGOH&3IDQQHQEHUJ+6FKPLGW&:XHUVOLQ16FKZHQ]HU
7ELQJHQ'( FRUQHOLDEUHQGOH#PHGXQLWXHELQJHQGH
3XUSRVH5HFHQWO\HVWDEOLVKHGK\EULG053(7DOORZVIRUVLPXOWDQHRXVDFTXLVLWLRQ
RI3(7DQG05GDWDLQFRQWUDVWWRFRQYHQWLRQDOVHTXHQWLDO3(7&77KHSXUSRVH
RIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHUHJLVWUDWLRQTXDOLW\RI053(7FRPSDUHGWR3(7
&7LQDEGRPLQDORUJDQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHGDWDVHWVRISDWLHQWVZLWK05>)@)'*3(7
DQG>)@)'*3(7&7H[DPLQDWLRQVDWWKHVDPHGD\ZHUHVHSDUDWHO\IXVHGE\
DXWRPDWLFULJLGUHJLVWUDWLRQDQGWKHQGLVSOD\HGRQDYLHZLQJVWDWLRQ 7UXH'6LH
PHQV+HDOWKFDUH(UODQJHQ*HUPDQ\ 7KHH[WHULRUVOLFHSRVLWLRQVRIOLYHUVSOHHQ
NLGQH\VDQGXULQDU\EODGGHUZHUHDVVLJQHGEOLQGHGIRUWKHWZR3(7DQGWKHWZR
PRUSKRORJLFGDWDVHWVLQ[\DQG]GLUHFWLRQ&XPXODWLYHGHYLDWLRQYHFWRUVRIWKH
DOLJQPHQWZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKRUJDQDQGERWKPRGDOLWLHV6LJQLÀFDQFHZDV
WHVWHGZLWK:LOFR[RQWHVW
5HVXOWV7KHDOLJQPHQWLQ053(7DVZHOODV3(7&7LPDJHVZDVYHU\H[DFW
7KHPHDQFXPXODWLYHGHYLDWLRQ PP RI053(73(7&7ZDVIRUOLYHU S
IRUVSOHHQ S IRUULJKWNLGQH\ S IRU
OHIWNLGQH\ S DQGIRUXULQDU\EODGGHU S 3(7&7VKRZHG
GLVWLQFWO\ZRUVHDOLJQPHQWRIWKHGDWDIRURQHSDWLHQWLQWKHXSSHUDEGRPLQDORUJDQV
DQGIRUDQRWKHUSDWLHQWLQWKHXULQDU\EODGGHU
&RQFOXVLRQ,QVLQJOHFDVHV3(7&7VKRZVODUJHGHYLDWLRQVRIWKHZKROHGDWD
VHW7KHVLPXOWDQHRXVGDWDDFTXLVLWLRQRIK\EULG053(7OHDGVWRDVLJQLÀFDQWO\
LPSURYHGDOLJQPHQWRIPHWDEROLFDQGPRUSKRORJLFGDWDVHWVLQWKHOLYHUDQGXULQDU\
EODGGHUDQGFDQUHGXFHDQDWRPLFDOGHYLDWLRQVGXHWREUHDWKLQJDQGSDWLHQWPRYH
PHQWDVZHOODVGLIIHUHQWÀOOLQJVWDWHVRIWKHXULQDU\EODGGHU
%
0ROHFXODULPDJLQJRIEUHDVWWXPRXUVZLWK053(7
.3LQNHU'RPHQLJ+%LFNHO:%RJQHU6*UXEHU+0DJRPHWVFKQLJJ
%%UXHFN06FKHUQWKDQHU7++HOELFK9LHQQD$7
NDWMDSLQNHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RSURYHWKDWWKDWPROHFXODULPDJLQJRIEUHDVWWXPRXUVZLWKSURWRQ05
VSHFWURVFRS\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,DQGSRVLWURQ
HPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\LPSURYHVGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQ
FDQFHUGLDJQRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKDVXVSLFLRXVEUHDVWZHUHLQFOXGHGLQ
WKLV,5%DSSURYHGSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKGHGLFDWHG
)'*3(7&7DQG7PXOWLSDUDPHWULF05,RIWKHEUHDVW05,SURWRFROLQFOXGHG
DGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFH ':, D7ZVHTXHQFHDQGDFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
'7ZVHTXHQFH &(05, EHIRUHDQGDIWHUDSSOLFDWLRQRIDVWDQGDUGGRVH*G
'27$$IWHULQMHFWLRQRIDSSUR[0%T))'*EDVHGRQWKHSDWLHQWVZHLJKW
3(7&7ZDVDFTXLUHGLQWKHSURQHSRVLWLRQDOORZLQJWKHVDPHSDWLHQWJHRPHWU\
LQ EUHDVW 05, &7 GDWD ZHUH XVHG IRU DWWHQXDWLRQ FRUUHFWLRQ &RUHJLVWUDWLRQ RI
LPDJLQJGDWDDQGLPDJHIXVLRQZHUHSHUIRUPHG053(7ZDVDVVHVVHGIRUOHVLRQ
PRUSKRORJ\DQG(+NLQHWLFVDFFRUGLQJWR%,5$'6UHVWULFWHGGLIIXVLYLW\LQFUHDVHG
&KROLQH &KR OHYHOVDQG)'*DYLGLW\$Q$'&WKUHVKROG[PPVDQG
DVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRRIWKH&KRUHVRQDQFHSHDN!ZHUHGHÀQHGDVDPDUNHU
RIPDOLJQDQF\/HVLRQVFODVVLÀHGDVSRVLWLYHZKHQ))'*XSWDNHZDVJUHDWHU
WKDQEORRGSRRODFWLYLW\$OOOHVLRQVZHUHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\YHULÀHG
5HVXOWV0XOWLPRGDOPXOWLSDUDPHWULF053(7DFKLHYHGDQH[FHOOHQWVHQVLWLYLW\RI
DQGJRRGVSHFLÀFLW\RILQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIEUHDVWFDQFHU'LDJQRVWLF
DFFXUDF\ZDV053(7LQFUHDVHGVHQVLWLYLW\LQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIO\PSKQRGH
PHWDVWDVHVIURPWRFRPSDUHGWR05,DORQH
&RQFOXVLRQ 0ROHFXODU LPDJLQJ RI EUHDVW OHVLRQV ZLWK 053(7 LQFUHDVHV VHQ
VLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIEUHDVWFDQFHUDQG
O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHV
%
%RQHWLVVXHDQGERG\UHJLRQVSHFLÀFYDULDELOLW\RIHUURUVLQ689
YDOXHVLPSOLFDWLRQVRQDWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQPHWKRGVLQ053(7
$6DPDULQ&%XUJHU':&URRN,$%XUJHU'76FKPLG
*.YRQ6FKXOWKHVV)3.XKQ=XULFK&+ DQGUHLVDPDULQ#UHJLRQDDOKDLJODHH
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHQHHGIRUDFFXUDWHERQH
VHJPHQWDWLRQLQ05EDVHG$&IRUZKROHERG\053(7LPDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQWLQWHJUDWHGVHTXHQWLDO3(7
&7705LPDJLQJPRGLÀHG&7$&PDSVZHUHSURGXFHGE\UHSODFLQJSL[HOVZLWK
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
YDOXHV!+8UHSUHVHQWLQJPRVWO\ERQHVWUXFWXUHVE\WLVVXHZLWKDFRQVWDQW
YDOXHRI+8FRUUHVSRQGLQJWRVRIWWLVVXHWKHUHE\VLPXODWLQJFXUUHQW05GHULYHG
$&PDSV7KHHUURURIPHDQVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNHYDOXH 689PHDQ RIRVVHRXV
OHVLRQVDQGVRIWWLVVXHOHVLRQVDGMDFHQWWRERQHVIRUPRGLÀHG3(7LPDJHVZDV
FDOFXODWHGXVLQJVWDQGDUG3(7LPDJHDVUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV 6XEVWLWXWLRQ RI ERQH E\ VRIW WLVVXH YDOXHV LQ$& PDSV UHVXOWHG LQ DQ
XQGHUHVWLPDWLRQ RI 689PHDQ LQ RVVHRXV DQG VRIW WLVVXH OHVLRQV DGMDFHQW WR
ERQHVRI PLQPD[ DQG PLQPD[
UHVSHFWLYHO\$QDO\VLV RI WKH VSLQH DQG SHOYLF RVVHRXV OHVLRQV UHYHDOHG D
VXEVWDQWLDO GHSHQGHQFH RI WKH HUURU RQ OHVLRQ FRPSRVLWLRQ )RU SUHGRPLQDQWO\
VFOHURWLFDQGRVWHRO\WLFVSLQHOHVLRQVWKHDYHUDJHXQGHUHVWLPDWLRQZDV
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ&7VLPXODWLRQRIWUHDWLQJERQHDVVRIWWLVVXHLQ05$&PDSVIRU3(7
OHDGVWRDVXEVWDQWLDOXQGHUHVWLPDWLRQRIWUDFHUXSWDNHLQERQHOHVLRQVDQGGHSHQGV
RQOHVLRQFRPSRVLWLRQWKHODUJHVWHUURUEHLQJVHHQLQVFOHURWLFOHVLRQV7KHUHIRUH
GHSLFWLRQRIFRUWLFDOERQHDQGFDOFLÀHGDUHDVLQ05$&PDSVLVQHFHVVDU\IRUDF
FXUDWHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIWUDFHUXSWDNHYDOXHVLQ053(7LPDJLQJ
5RRP12
(PHUJHQF\5DGLRORJ\
66
7UDXPDDQGFKHVWSDLQ
0RGHUDWRUV
53ROYHURVL3DGXD,7
+5LQJO9LHQQD$7
%
:KROHERG\&7IRUWUDXPDVWUDWHJLHVWRMXVWLI\UDGLDWLRQGRVHXVLQJ
WKHLQMXU\VHYHULW\VFRUH
$$/HPRV5%UDPELOOD0)LUHWWR3%LRQGHWWL0LODQ,7
DOHVVDQGUROHPRV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH3DWLHQWVZKRKDYHVXVWDLQHGPXOWLSOHWUDXPDDUHRIWHQ\RXQJDQGWKH
UDGLDWLRQ GRVHV FRQIHU D OLIHWLPH FDQFHU ULVN RI XS WR 7KHVH VFDQV KDYH
WR EH IXOO\ MXVWLÀHG HLWKHU LQ WHUPV RI LPDJLQJ ÀQGLQJV RU LQ SRWHQWLDO FKDQJH LQ
PDQDJHPHQW7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUWDUJHWHGUHJLRQ
VSHFLÀF &7 IRFXVHG &7 FDQ UHSODFH ZKROH ERG\ &7 :%&7 XVLQJ WKH ,QMXU\
6HYHULW\6FRUH ,66
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VHULHVRISDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUV ZHUH
LQFOXGHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW:%&7ZLWKDVOLFHVFDQQHUHTXLSSHGZLWKDQ
DXWRPDWLFWXEHFXUUHQWPRGXODWLRQV\VWHP &DUH'RVH' 7KH,66RIHDFKSDWLHQW
ZDVUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGDQGFRPSDUHGWRWKHGLVFKDUJHGLDJQRVLV5DGLDWLRQ
GRVHZDVFDOFXODWHGXVLQJDPDWKHPDWLFDOSKDQWRP ,P3$&7&73DWLHQW'RVLPHWU\
&DOFXODWRUYHUVLRQ[
5HVXOWV7KHHIIHFWLYHGRVHDVVRFLDWHGZLWK:%&7UDQJHGIURPWRP6Y
GHSHQGLQJXSRQKRZPDQ\SKDVHVDUHLQFRUSRUDWHG7KHHIIHFWLYHGRVHIRUIRFXVHG
&7UDQJHGIURPWRP6YGHSHQGLQJXSRQKRZH[WHQGHGLVWKH)29RI
WKH:%&7VFDQVKDGDQ,66 DQGUHYHDOHGQRWUDXPDUHODWHGSDWKRORJ\
$QDO\VLVRIRXUGDWDFRQÀUPVWKDWPDQ\RIWKHVHQHJDWLYHVVFDQVZHUHFOLQLFDOO\
LQGLFDWHGEXWLQDSURSRUWLRQDPRUHIRFXVVHGVFDQDLPHGDWVSHFLÀFDUHDVRI
FOLQLFDOFRQFHUQVZRXOGKDYHEHHQPRUHDSSURSULDWH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDVVRFLDWHGUDGLDWLRQGRVHZLWK:%&7LVKLJKDQGSDWLHQWVVKRXOG
EHFDUHIXOO\VHOHFWHGXVLQJWKH,66:KHQWKH,66LV DPRUHWDUJHWHGUHJLRQ
VSHFLÀF&7LVUHFRPPHQGHG
%
3URVSHFWLYHVWXG\RQLPPHGLDWHWRWDOERG\&7LQVHYHUHWUDXPDSDWLHQWV
/)0%HHQHQ-&6LHULQN736DOW]KHUU0-$05XVVFKHQ-6./XLWVH
-&*RVOLQJV$PVWHUGDP1/ OIEHHQHQ#DPFXYDQO
3XUSRVH,QSRO\WUDXPDSDWLHQWVUDSLGDQGDGHTXDWHHYDOXDWLRQRILQMXULHVLVHVVHQ
WLDO,QUHFHQW\HDUVDWHQGHQF\WRXVHWRWDOERG\&7 7%&7 LQWUDXPDKDVEHFRPH
DSSDUHQW$QLQWHUQDWLRQDOPXOWLFHQWHUUDQGRPLVHGWULDO 5($&7 KDVEHHQLQLWLDWHG
WRGHWHUPLQHWKHHIIHFWRILPPHGLDWH7%&7LQVHYHUHWUDXPDSDWLHQWV7KHDLPRI
RXUSLORWVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHZRUNXSRILPPHGLDWH7%&7LQWUDXPDSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$OO WUDXPD SDWLHQWV PHHWLQJ WKH LQFOXVLRQ FULWHULD DQG
DGPLWWHGWRRXUKRVSLWDOLQWKHSHULRG-DQXDU\$SULOZHUHHYDOXDWHG
,QFOXVLRQFULWHULDZHUHVXVSLFLRQRIVHYHUHLQMXU\EDVHGRQSUHGHÀQHGYLWDOSDUDP
HWHUVRUFOLQLFDOO\VXVSLFLRXVGLDJQRVLV([FOXVLRQFULWHULDZHUHDJH\HDUV
NQRZQSUHJQDQF\UHIHUUDOIURPRWKHUKRVSLWDOVRU&35UHTXLUHG,QFOXGHGSDWLHQWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
XQGHUZHQWDQLPPHGLDWH7%&7IURPYHUWH[WRSXELFV\PSK\VLV)RUWKHÀUVW
SDWLHQWVGXULQJGD\WLPHVHYHUDOFOLQLFDOLPSRUWDQWWLPHSRLQWVZHUHUHJLVWHUHG
5HVXOWV,QWRWDOSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHGRIZKLFKZHUHPDOHVKDG
EOXQWWUDXPD0HGLDQDJHZDV\HDUVPHGLDQ,QMXU\6HYHULW\6FRUHZDV
$IWHU7%&7SDWLHQWVUHFHLYHGDGGLWLRQDOLPDJLQJDQGXQGHUZHQWUDGLRORJLFDO
RUVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQ0HGLDQWLPHWRLPDJLQJZDVPLQ DFTXLVLWLRQWLPH
PLQ DOOGLDJQRVHVZHUHNQRZQPLQDIWHUDGPLVVLRQ0RUWDOLW\LQWKH
SDWLHQWVZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ:LWKWKHXVHRILPPHGLDWH7%&7LQVHYHUHWUDXPDSDWLHQWVFRPSOHWH
GLDJQRVHVFDQEHDFKLHYHGZLWKLQPLQXWHV
%
8OWUDVRXQGIROORZXSRISRO\WUDXPDSDWLHQWVDIWHULQLWLDOFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\DQDQDO\VLVRIUROHDQGFRVWV
0+0DXUHU$:LQNOHU03RZHUVNL)(OJHWL%+DPP55RHWWJHQ
70DUQLW]%HUOLQ'( PDUWLQPDXUHU#FKDULWHGH
%
7KHYDOXHRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG &(86 LQWKHIROORZXS
RISRVWWUDXPDWLFDEGRPLQDOLQMXULHVVXEPLWWHGWRQRQRSHUDWLYH
PDQDJHPHQW
)3LQWR5)DULQD$3LQWR&$FDPSRUD/5RPDQR1DSOHV,7
ISLQWR#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH UROH RI FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG XOWUDVRXQG &(86 LQ WKH
IROORZXSRISRVWWUDXPDWLFDEGRPLQDOLQMXULHVQRQRSHUDWLYHO\PDQDJHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QHKXQGUHGDQGIRUW\WZRSDWLHQWV PDOHVDQG
IHPDOHVDJHUDQJH\HDUVROG ZLWKSRVWWUDXPDWLFLQMXULHVRIVROLGDEGRPLQDO
RUJDQVZHUHIROORZHGXSE\PHDQVRI&(86$OOWKHGLDJQRVWLFH[DPVZHUHSHU
IRUPHGDWYDULDEOHWLPHLQWHUYDOV LQWKHUDQJHEHWZHHQDQGGD\VIURPSDWLHQWV
KRVSLWDOLVDWLRQ GHSHQGLQJRQWKHFOLQLFDOQHHGVDQGXQWLOFRPSOHWHFOLQLFDOUHVROX
WLRQZDVUHDFKHG/RZPHFKDQLFDOLQGH[WHFKQLTXHVDQGDVXOSKXUKH[DÁXRULGH
ÀOOHGPLFUREXEEOHVFRQWUDVWDJHQWZHUHXVHG$IWHUGD\VDIWHUWUDXPDDOOWKH
HQUROOHGSDWLHQWVDOVRXQGHUZHQWDPXOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7
DEGRPLQDOH[DP
5HVXOWV$W&(86WKHDEVHQFHRIYDVFXODUFRPSOLFDWLRQZDVVHHQLQ
FDVHV XQWLO FRPSOHWH FOLQLFDO UHVROXWLRQ LQ WKHVH SDWLHQWV QRQRSHUDWLYH
PDQDJHPHQWZDVIDYRXUDEOH,Q FDVHVDQKHSDWLFSVHXGRDQHXU\VP
ZDVGHWHFWHGDW&(86VXEVHTXHQWDQJLRJUDSKLFHPEROLVDWLRQZDVVXFFHVVIXOO\
SHUIRUPHG,Q FDVHV&(86GHSLFWHGZLGHFRQWUDVWDJHQWH[WUDYD
VDWLRQ RU SRROLQJ ERWK LQ WKH VSOHQLF RUJDQ DQG RXW WKH FDSVXOH DOO RI WKHVH
SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWVXEVHTXHQWHPHUJHQWVSOHQHFWRP\)LQDOO\LQ
FDVHVDVSOHQLFDUWHURYHQRXVÀVWXODZDVVHHQDW&(86VXEVHTXHQWDQJLRJUDSKLF
HPEROLVDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
&RQFOXVLRQ&(86UHSUHVHQWVDQDFFXUDWHWHFKQLTXHLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRISRVW
WUDXPDWLF LQMXULHV RI VROLG DEGRPLQDO RUJDQV 7KH WHFKQLTXH LV QRW RQO\ DEOH WR
GHWHFW DFWLYH EOHHGLQJ DQG YDVFXODU OHVLRQV DYRLGLQJ RYHUH[SRVXUH WR LRQLVLQJ
UDGLDWLRQ EXW DOVR SURYHV SDUWLFXODUO\ XVHIXO IRU PRQLWRULQJ SDWLHQWV XQGHUJRLQJ
QRQRSHUDWLYHPDQDJHPHQW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
7KHYROXPHRIIUHHLQWUDSHULWRQHDOÁXLGLQÁXHQFHVWKHVHQVLWLYLW\
RISULPDU\IRFXVHGDVVHVVPHQWZLWKVRQRJUDSK\LQWUDXPD )$67
ZKHUHDVUDGLRORJLVWҋVH[SHULHQFHGRHVQRW
5-9/RHNNH$6FKXO]6*URYHQ&*DDUGHU3$1DHVV-%'RUPDJHQ
2VOR12
3XUSRVH)RFXVHGDVVHVVPHQWZLWKVRQRJUDSK\LQWUDXPD )$67 LVDUDSLGQRQ
LQYDVLYHPHWKRGGHVLJQHGWRGHWHFWIUHHLQWUDSHULWRQHDOÁXLGLQWUDXPDSDWLHQWV
+RZHYHULQUHFHQW\HDUVVRPHVWXGLHVRQWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RI)$67UHSRUWYDOXHV
EHORZ7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHKRZWKHYROXPHRILQWUDSHULWR
QHDOIUHHÁXLGDQGWKHUDGLRORJLVWҋVH[SHULHQFHLQÁXHQFHWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RI)$67
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2YHUDWZR\HDUSHULRGWUDXPDSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
)$67 SHUIRUPHG E\ UDGLRORJLVWV ZLWK GLIIHUHQW OHYHOV RI H[SHULHQFH WR
PRQWKVSHUIRUPLQJWRH[DPVHDFK &7YROXPHWU\GLDJQRVWLFSHULWRQHDOODY
DJHODSDURWRP\DQGFOLQLFDOREVHUYDWLRQZHUHFRQVLGHUHGWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGLQ
DQGSDWLHQWVUHVSHFWLYHO\)$67UHVXOWVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKIRXU
GLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRIEORRGYROXPH QHJOLJLEOHDQGPO DQGZLWKWKUHH
GLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRIH[SHULHQFHZLWK)$67 OHVVWKDQPRQWKVWRPRQWKV
DQGPRUHWKDQPRQWKV
5HVXOWV)$67VHQVLWLYLW\ZDVVSHFLÀFLW\ZDVSRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYH
SUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVZHUHDQGDQGDFFXUDF\ZDVIRUWKHZKROHVWXG\
SRSXODWLRQ :LWK LQFUHDVLQJ YROXPHV RI LQWUDSHULWRQHDO ÁXLG )$67 VHQVLWLYLW\ LQ
FUHDVHGVXFFHVVLYHO\WRDWPO,QWKHVXEJURXSRISDWLHQWVZLWKDYROXPH
RI PO DW &7 YROXPHWU\ VHQVLWLYLW\ ZDV DQG UHDFKHG IRU YROXPHV
RYHUPO7KHUDGLRORJLVWҋVH[SHULHQFHGLGQRWLQÁXHQFHWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RI)$67
VLJQLÀFDQWO\LUUHVSHFWLYHO\RIWKHPHDVXUHGYROXPH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHYROXPHRIIUHHLQWUDSHULWRQHDOÁXLGLQÁXHQFHVDFFXUDF\RI)$67
ZKHUHDVWKHUDGLRORJLVWҋVH[SHULHQFHGRHVQRW
%
&RURQDU\DWKHURVFOHURVLVLQFRFDLQHDEXVHUVSUHVHQWLQJZLWKDFXWH
FKHVWSDLQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQZLWKFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\
+(EHUVEHUJHU66XGDUVNL8-6FKRHSI)7ULFDULFR59OLHJHQWKDUW
*)+HDGGHQ$/HEHU(+RIIPDQQ3$SIDOWUHU&KDUOHVWRQ6&86
0XQLFK'( HEHUVEHUJHU#JP[QHW
3XUSRVH&RFDLQHDVVRFLDWHGFKHVWSDLQDFFRXQWVIRUDVXEVWDQWLDOSURSRUWLRQRI
HPHUJHQF\GHSDUWPHQW (' YLVLWV6XFKSDWLHQWVDUHNQRZQWREHDWLQFUHDVHGULVN
IRUDFXWHFRURQDU\V\QGURPH $&6 :HDLPHGWRXVHFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\
WRHYDOXDWHWKHSUHYDOHQFHH[WHQWDQGFRPSRVLWLRQRIDWKHURVFOHURWLFOHVLRQVLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHFKHVWSDLQDQGKLVWRU\RIFRFDLQHDEXVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHQ\UV ZLWKDKLVWRU\RIFRFDLQH
DEXVH XQGHUDFXWHLQÁXHQFH ZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\
IRUDFXWHFKHVWSDLQZHUHLQFOXGHG(DFKFRURQDU\DUWHU\VHJPHQWZDVHYDOXDWHG
IRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHFRPSRVLWLRQ FDOFLÀHGQRQFDOFLÀHG
PL[HG DQGWKHSUHVHQFHDQGGHJUHHRIVWHQRVLV)LQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKD
PDWFKHGFRQWUROFRKRUW PHQ\UV ZLWKRXWDKLVWRU\RIGUXJDEXVHXVLQJ
7DQG&KLVTXDUHWHVWLQJ
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWKLV
WRU\RIFRFDLQHDEXVHZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLV
YV S! +LVWRU\RIFRFDLQHXVHZDVQRWDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDKLJKHU
SUHYDOHQFHRIRYHUDOOSODTXH YV S! FDOFLÀHGSODTXH
YV S! RUQRQFDOFLÀHGSODTXH YV
S! +RZHYHUSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRU\RIFRFDLQHDEXVHKDGDKLJKHUSUHYDOHQFH
RIPL[HGSODTXH YV S
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKHUULVNIRU$&6LQSDWLHQWVZLWKDKLVWRU\RIFRFDLQHDEXVHPLJKW
EHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDKLJKHUSUHYDOHQFHRIPL[HGFRURQDU\DWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXH
7KLVDVVRFLDWLRQPD\EHH[SODLQHGE\WKHPHFKDQLFDOSURSHUWLHVRIPL[HGSODTXH
ZKLFKPD\SUHGLVSRVHWRUXSWXUHGXULQJFRFDLQHLQGXFHGYDVRVSDVP
%
6WDQGDUGYVKLJKSLWFK&7RIWKHFKHVWLQYHQWLODWHGSDWLHQWV
FRPSDULVRQRIPRWLRQDUWHIDFWVLPDJHQRLVHDQGHIIHFWLYHGRVH
)6FKZDU]7*RHO]$$UQROGL.1LNRODRX0)5HLVHU&+%HFNHU
0XQLFK'( ÁRULDQVFKZDU]#PHGOPXGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHPRWLRQDUWHIDFWVLPDJHQRLVHDQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHEHWZHHQ
DKLJKSLWFKDQGDURXWLQHFKHVW&7SURWRFROLQYHQWLODWHGSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$OO DQDO\VHG VWXGLHV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG RQ D VOLFH
&7V\VWHP FRQVHFXWLYH YHQWLODWHG SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW KLJKSLWFK FKHVW
&7 S ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVDQDO\VLV$VFRQWUROJURXSYHQWLODWHGSDWLHQWV
PDWFKHGIRUVH[DQGERG\PDVVLQGH[ %0, ZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHURXWLQHFKHVW&7
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHFRVWVDQGGLDJQRVWLFJDLQRIDEGRPLQDOXOWUDVRXQGIROORZXS
RISRO\WUDXPDSDWLHQWVLQLWLDOO\H[DPLQHGE\ZKROHERG\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISRO\WUDXPDSDWLHQWV PHQZRPHQ
DJH\HDUV ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGZLWKUHJDUGWRVXSSOHPHQWDU\
DQGQHZÀQGLQJVREWDLQHGE\XOWUDVRXQGIROORZXSFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHUHVXOWVRI
H[SORUDWRU\)$67 IRFXVHGDVVHVVPHQWZLWKVRQRJUDSK\IRUWUDXPD RQDGPLVVLRQ
DQGWKHÀQGLQJVRIZKROHERG\&7$SURFHVVPRGHOZDVXVHGWRGRFXPHQWWKH
VWDIIPDWHULDODQGWRWDOFRVWVRIWKHXOWUDVRXQGIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQV
5HVXOWV )$67 \LHOGHG DEGRPLQDO ÀQGLQJV RUJDQ LQMXU\ DQGRU IUHH LQWUD
DEGRPLQDOÁXLG LQSDWLHQWVZKLOHWKHDEGRPLQDOVFDQRIZKROHERG\&7UH
YHDOHGÀQGLQJVLQSDWLHQWV)$67KDGVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
)ROORZXSXOWUDVRXQGH[DPLQDWLRQVUHYHDOHGQHZÀQGLQJVLQWZRRIWKHSDWLHQWV
ZLWKDEGRPLQDOLQMXULHVGHWHFWHGDWLQLWLDO&7,QWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWDEGRPLQDO
LQMXULHVRQWKHLQLWLDO&7VFDQXOWUDVRXQGIROORZXS\LHOGHGQRVXSSOHPHQWDU\RU
QHZÀQGLQJV7KHWRWDOFRVWVRIDQXOWUDVRXQGIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQZHUH(85
7KHWRWDOFRVWVRIDOOIROORZXSXOWUDVRXQGH[DPLQDWLRQVSHUIRUPHGLQWKH
VWXG\SRSXODWLRQZHUH(85
&RQFOXVLRQ)ROORZXSDEGRPLQDOXOWUDVRXQGVKRZVDYHU\ORZRYHUDOOGLDJQRVWLF
JDLQLQSRO\WUDXPDSDWLHQWVLQZKRPLQLWLDO&7IDLOVWRGHWHFWDQ\DEGRPLQDOLQMX
ULHVEXWFDXVHVKLJKSHUVRQQHOH[SHQVHVIRUUDGLRORJLFGHSDUWPHQWV,QFRQWUDVW
VRQRJUDSKLFIROORZXSDSSHDUVWREHLQGLVSHQVDEOHLQSDWLHQWVGLDJQRVHGZLWKDQ
DEGRPLQDOLQMXU\RQDGPLVVLRQ
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
S ZHUHLGHQWLÀHG7ZREOLQGHGUHDGHUVDVVHVVHGDOOGDWDVHWVIRUWKHH[WHQW
RI PRWLRQ DUWHIDFWV RQ PP D[LDO OXQJ UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV$ FRPSRXQGPRWLRQ
VFRUH UDQJH ZDVFDOFXODWHGEDVHGRQVLJQVRIPRWLRQDWIRXUVWDQGDUGLVHG
SRVLWLRQV)RULPDJHQRLVHWKHDYHUDJHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQZLWKLQ52,ҋVLQDLUZDV
FDOFXODWHG7KHGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW '/3 ZDVXVHGWRHVWLPDWHDSSOLHGGRVH
5HVXOWV$OOKLJKSLWFKDFTXLVLWLRQVKDGEHHQSHUIRUPHGZLWKRXWFRPSOLFDWLRQV
DQGQRGDWDVHWKDGWREHH[FOXGHG7KHUHZHUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQ%0,RU
YHQWLODWLRQIUHTXHQF\EHWZHHQERWKJURXSV,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRUFRPSRXQG
PRWLRQVFRUHVZDVH[FHOOHQW ѣ &RPSRXQGPRWLRQVFRUHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
ORZHULQWKHKLJKSLWFKJURXS YVS 7KHKLJKHVWPRWLRQVFRUHV
REVHUYHGLQWKHKLJKSLWFKJURXSDQGFRQWUROJURXSZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
+LJKSLWFKGDWDVHWVKDGDWHQGHQF\WRZDUGVKLJKHULPDJHQRLVH +8YV+8
S DQGORZHU'/3 YVP*\FPS
&RQFOXVLRQ)RU&7VFDQVRIWKHFKHVWLQYHQWLODWHGSDWLHQWVDKLJKSLWFKDFTXL
VLWLRQ WHFKQLTXH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ UHGXFHV PRWLRQ DUWHIDFWV ZKLOH PDLQWDLQLQJ VLPLODU
GHJUHHVRILPDJHQRLVH7KLVKDVFRQVLGHUDEOHSRWHQWLDOWRLPSURYHGHWHFWLRQRI
SXOPRQDU\LQÀOWUDWHVZLWKRXWLQFUHDVHVLQDSSOLHGGRVH
%
+LJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ZLWKFFRI
FRQWUDVWPDWHULDO
-0.HUO%6FKHOO0/DUVVRQ7/HKQHUW7-9RJO5:%DXHU
)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'( PDWWKLDVNHUO#NJXGH
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH GLIIHUHQW ORZ FRQWUDVW PDWHULDO LQMHFWLRQ SURWRFROV XVLQJ
KLJKSLWFK GXDO VRXUFH &7 SXOPRQDU\ DQJLRJUDSK\ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK VXVSHFWHG
SXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'DWDRIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVUHIHUUHGIRU&73$IRU
H[FOXVLRQRI3(ZHUHHYDOXDWHG$OOVFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQDFKDQQHOGXDO
VRXUFH&7VFDQQHUZLWKDKLJKSLWFKSURWRFRO SLWFKN9P$V ,QJURXS
Q FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWZDVDFKLHYHGE\LQMHFWLQJFF&0IROORZHGE\D
VDOLQHFKDVHURIFFLQJURXS Q FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWZDVDFKLHYHGE\
FFRI&0IROORZHGE\DVDOLQHFKDVHURIFFDQGLQJURXS Q FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHPHQWZDVDFKLHYHGE\FFRI&0IROORZHGE\DVDOLQHFKDVHURIFF,Q
DOOVWXGLHVLRPHSURO PJ,FF ZDVXVHGLQMHFWHGDWDUDWHRIFFV$WWHQXDWLRQ
SURÀOHVLQWKHSXOPRQDU\WUXQNDQGRQVHJPHQWDOOHYHOZHUHPHDVXUHGWRHYDOXDWH
WKHHQKDQFHPHQWZLWKLQWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHV
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWVDQDGHTXDWHDQGKRPRJHQHRXVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWRI
PRUHWKDQ+8ZDVDFKLHYHGLQWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHV+RZHYHUDVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQWOHYHORIHQKDQFHPHQWZLWKLQWKHSXOPRQDU\V\VWHPEHWZHHQJURXSDQG
JURXSYHUVXVJURXSZDVREVHUYHG S 1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQJURXSVDQGZDVIRXQGUHJDUGLQJDWWHQXDWLRQRIWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHV
&RQFOXVLRQ$KRPRJHQHRXVRSDFLÀFDWLRQRIWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHVDQGVXIÀFLHQW
LPDJHTXDOLW\FDQEHDFKLHYHGZLWKFFRIFRQWUDVWPDWHULDOLQKLJKSLWFK'6&7
SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
%
$FFXUDF\RIPXOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\WRHYDOXDWHDFXWH
DRUWLFV\QGURPHV\HDUH[SHULHQFHLQDFDUGLRYDVFXODUFHQWHU
$50DUWLQH]+3DODGLQL0-0HOD)03HUHD0&HUGD**DQXP
0&DVWLJQROD('XOEHFR'+DEHUPDQ&DED$5 DUPDUWLQH]#IIDYDORURRUJ
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVWKHDFFXUDF\RIPXOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ 0'&7
SHUIRUPHGLQDFXWHSDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVLVRIDRUWLFV\QGURPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(PHUJHQF\0'&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQSDWLHQWVVXV
SHFWHG RI KDYLQJ DFXWH DRUWLF V\QGURPH )URP WKHVH SDWLHQWV PHW LQFOXVLRQ
FULWHULDDQGZHUHHQUROOHGIRUWKLVVWXG\)URPUHIXVHGSDWLHQWVKDGSUHYLRXVO\
NQRZQ DQG WUHDWHG DRUWLF GLVRUGHUV DQG GLG QRW XQGHUJR VXUJHU\ RU VHFRQG
FRPSDUDWLYHPHWKRG0'&7ZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKVXUJHU\ Q ,QSDWLHQWVZLWKRXW
VXUJHU\VHFRQGPHWKRGZDVXOWUDVRXQG Q GLJLWDODQJLRJUDSK\ Q ERWK
Q ,QDOOSDWLHQWVQRWRQO\VHFRQGFRPSDULVRQPHWKRGEXWDOVRFOLQLFDOIROORZXS
ZDVFRQVLGHUHG
5HVXOWV0'&7ZDVSRVLWLYHIRUDFXWHDRUWLFV\QGURPHLQRISDWLHQWV'L
DJQRVLVLQFOXGHGW\SH$GLVVHFWLRQ Q W\SH%GLVVHFWLRQ Q DRUWLFUXSWXUH
Q W\SH$ LQWUDPXUDO KDHPDWRPD Q XOFHU Q W\SH$ GLVVHFWLRQ DQG
LQWUDPXUDOKDHPDWRPD Q W\SH%GLVVHFWLRQDQGUXSWXUH Q W\SH%LQWUDPXUDO
KDHPDWRPDDQGXOFHU Q 0'&7ZDVQHJDWLYHIRUDFXWHDRUWLFV\QGURPHLQ
SDWLHQWVSDWLHQWVZLWKQRUPDODRUWDSDWLHQWVKDGXQNQRZQDQHXU\VPZLWKRXW
FRPSOLFDWLRQ6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLF
WLYHYDOXHIRUGHWHFWLRQRIDFXWHDRUWLFV\QGURPHDQGFRUUHFWFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQIRU
HDFKVXEW\SHZDVLQDOOFDVHV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
&RQFOXVLRQ0'&7GHSLFWVDQH[FHOOHQWLPDJLQJPHWKRGWRHYDOXDWHDFXWHDRUWLF
GLVHDVHV DQG UHSUHVHQWV D IXQGDPHQWDO WRRO WR SURSHUO\ VWUDWLI\ SDWLHQWV LQ WKLV
FULWLFDOVLWXDWLRQ
%
(PHUJHQF\&73$SHUIRUPHGLQRQH\HDUFOLQLFDOUHVXOWV
&0DUWLQR*$=DPERQL*6DOYDJQR53R]]L0XFHOOL9HURQD,7
J]DPERQL#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHYLHZWKH&73$VFDQVSHUIRUPHGRQSDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOVXVSLFLRQ
RIDFXWH3(LQRQH\HDUDQGDVVHVVÀQDOGLDJQRVLVDQGSUHVHQFHRIXQH[SHFWHG
ÀQGLQJV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$OOWKHHPHUJHQF\&73$VFDQVSHUIRUPHGLQPRQWKV
-DQXDU\'HFHPEHU ZHUHUHYLHZHGDQGHYDOXDWHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRISXOPR
QDU\HPEROLVPDQGRURWKHUWKRUDFLFÀQGLQJV7KHSUHVHQFHRI3(ZDVFRUUHODWHG
WR''LPHUOHYHOV:KHQWKHDEGRPHQZDVVFDQQHGWRVHDUFKIRUWKURPERVLVWKH
SUHVHQFHRIWKURPERVLVDQGRURWKHUDEGRPLQDOÀQGLQJVZDVDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV 2YHU PRQWKV HPHUJHQF\ &73$ VFDQV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG
)0PHDQDJH\HDUV SDWLHQWVKDG''LPHU!QJGO
SDWLHQWV ZHUHGLDJQRVHGZLWK3(LQYROYLQJWKHSXOPRQDU\WUXQNWKH
PDLQSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHVRUOREDUDUWHULHVSDWLHQWVKDG''LPHU!QJ
GO,QSDWLHQWVWKHDEGRPHQZDVVFDQQHGFDVHVRI'97ZHUHREVHUYHG
&ROODWHUDOÀQGLQJVLQWKHVHSDWLHQWVZLWK3(LQFOXGHGSOHXUDOHIIXVLRQ
SDUHQFK\PDOFRQVROLGDWLRQ DQGWXPRXUV VFDQVZHUHQHJDWLYH
IRU3(SDWLHQWVKDGQRVLJQLÀFDQWÀQGLQJVDW&7ZKLOHKDGSOHXUDOHI
IXVLRQ DQGRUSDUHQFK\PDOFRQVROLGDWLRQ DQGRUWXPRXUV
SDWLHQWVKDG''LPHU!QJGO,QWKHDEGRPHQZDVVFDQQHGFDVHV
RI'97ZHUHREVHUYHG
&RQFOXVLRQ(YHQLQDSRSXODWLRQZLWKDUHODWLYHO\KLJKSUHYDOHQFHRI3(PRVW
RIWKHSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUJR&73$IRUFOLQLFDOO\VXVSHFWHG3(ZLOOQRWKDYH3(
6FDQQLQJWKHDEGRPHQWRVHDUFKIRU'97VKRZVD'97SUHYDOHQFHDURXQG
ERWKLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXW3(
5RRP3
5DGLRJUDSKHUV
66
([SHULHQFLQJWKHFRPSOH[LW\RIWKHUDGLRJUDSKHUVҋ
UROH
0RGHUDWRUV
:+HLQGHO0QVWHU'(
.1pPHWK%XGDSHVW+8
%
(GXFDWLRQDOSURJUDPPHIRUUDGLRJUDSK\VWXGHQWVDW&7
.+HJJHQ(-RKDQVHQ56LONRVHW2VOR12 NBOLYHOWHQ#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH$QHGXFDWLRQDOSURJUDPZDVGHVLJQHGWRLPSURYHUHOHYDQWFRPSHWHQFHLQ
EUDLQDQDWRP\SDWKRORJ\&7WHFKQLTXHDQGSK\VLFVDPRQJUDGLRJUDSK\VWXGHQWV
WUDLQLQJDW2VOR8QLYHUVLW\+RVSLWDO8OOHYnO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHHGXFDWLRQDOSURJUDPFRQVLVWHGRIOHFWXUHVDFRP
SHQGLXPSUDFWLFDOOHVVRQVDQGFRPSHWHQFHWHVWLQJ7KHOHFWXUHVDQGFRPSHQGLXP
IRFXVHGRQEUDLQDQDWRP\SDWKRORJ\&7WHFKQLTXHDQGSK\VLFV$OOVHFRQG\HDU
UDGLRJUDSK\VWXGHQWVDWWKH8QLYHUVLW\&ROOHJHLQ2VORFRPSOHWHGWKHVDPHFRP
SHWHQFHWHVWVEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHLUKRVSLWDOWUDLQLQJ7KLVDOORZVDFRPSDULVRQRI
WKHFRPSHWHQFHLPSURYHPHQWDPRQJVWXGHQWVZKRIROORZHGWKHHGXFDWLRQDOSUR
JUDPZLWKVWXGHQWVWUDLQLQJHOVHZKHUH WKHFRQWUROJURXS 7KHVHFRQG\HDUFODVV
FRPSULVHVVWXGHQWVWRRNWKHLQLWLDOWHVW2XWRIWKLVQXPEHUSDUWLFLSDWHG
LQWKHSURMHFWZKLOHWKHUHPDLQLQJ WKHFRQWUROJURXS GLGQRWVWXGHQWVWRRN
WKHÀQDOWHVWVWXGHQWVZKRDFWXDOO\WRRNSDUWLQWKHSURMHFWRSWHGRXWRIWKHÀQDO
WHVWUHGXFLQJWKHQXPEHUWRZKLOHWKHQXPEHURIVWXGHQWVLQWKHFRQWUROJURXS
ZDVLQFUHDVHGWREHFDXVHVWXGHQWVZKRGLGQRWWDNHWKHLQLWLDOWHVWMRLQHGWKH
FRQWUROJURXSDWWKHÀQDOWHVW
5HVXOWV 5DGLRJUDSK\ VWXGHQWV ZKR SDUWLFLSDWHG LQ WKH HGXFDWLRQDO SURJUDP
LPSURYHGWKHLUWHVWVFRUHIURPWRZKLOHWKHFRQWUROJURXSLPSURYHGWKHLU
VFRUHIURPWR
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KLV VWXG\ GHPRQVWUDWHV D SURQRXQFHG LPSURYHPHQW LQ OHYHO RI
FRPSHWHQFHDPRQJVWXGHQWVZKRIROORZHGWKHHGXFDWLRQDOSURJUDP
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
,PSDFWRIDUDGLRJUDSKLFSRVLWLRQLQJGROORQGHYHORSLQJVNLOOVLQ
VNHOHWDOUDGLRORJ\DVWXG\RQUDGLRJUDSK\VWXGHQWV
5*LURPHWWL&=XLDQL6'D'DOW$0RUHWWL5)D]]LQ0%D]]RFFKL8GLQH,7
UJLURPHWWL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHVXEMHFWLYHLPSDFWRIDUDGLRJUDSKLFSRVLWLRQLQJGROO
53' LQGHYHORSLQJPDLQVNHOHWDOUDGLRORJ\ 65 VNLOOVLQUDGLRJUDSK\VWXGHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HIRUHVWDUWLQJWKHFOLQLFDOLQWHUQVKLSLQVNHOHWDOUDGLRORJ\
UDGLRJUDSK\VWXGHQWVZHUHLQYROYHGLQDSUHOLPLQDU\KRXUVWUDLQLQJSURJUDP
XVLQJDQDQWKURSRPRUSKLF53'7KHWUDLQLQJZDVVXSHUYLVHGE\WZRH[SHUWUDGL
RJUDSKHUVLQRUGHUWRGHYHORSPDLQVNLOOVLQSHUIRUPLQJD6.H[DPLQDWLRQ$IWHU
FRPSOHWLQJ WKH FOLQLFDO LQWHUQVKLS VWXGHQWV ZHUH DVNHG WR VXEMHFWLYHO\ TXDQWLI\
KRZWKHXVHRI53'LPSDFWHGRQGHYHORSLQJHDFKRIWKHHVWDEOLVKHGVNLOOVXVLQJ
DWRVFRUH QRLPSDFW PRGHUDWHLPSDFW KLJKLPSDFW :HFDOFXODWHG
WKHSURSRUWLRQRIVFRUHVIRUHDFKVNLOOE\WHVWLQJVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHZLWK
WKH&KLVTXDUHWHVW
5HVXOWV5HJDUGOHVVRIWKHVSHFLÀFVNLOOWKHODUJHPDMRULW\RIWKHVWXGHQWVVXEMHF
WLYHO\DWWULEXWHGDLPSDFWVFRUHWRWKHXVHRIWKH53' S 53'ZDV
IRXQG PRUH LPSDFWLQJ LQ GHYHORSLQJ FDSDELOLWLHV LQ SRVWSURFHVVLQJ SURFHGXUHV
&, SDWLHQW SRVLWLRQLQJ &, DQG
LQGLYLGXDWLRQRIUDGLRJUDSKLFUHIHUHQFHSRLQWV &, 53'ZDV
IRXQGOHVVXVHIXOLQWUDLQLQJWRSHUIRUPUDGLRJUDSKLFSURMHFWLRQV &,
SDWLHQWSUHSDUDWLRQ &, DQGH[SRVXUHUHJXODWLRQ
&, +LJKSURSRUWLRQRIVWXGHQWVIRXQGWKHXVHRI53'RI
YDOXHLQSUHSDULQJIRUFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH &,
&RQFOXVLRQ$WUDLQLQJZLWKD53'LVVXEMHFWLYHO\RIYDOXHLQGHYHORSLQJPDLQ6.
VNLOOVRIUDGLRJUDSK\VWXGHQWVEHIRUHWKHFOLQLFDOLQWHUQVKLS
,PDJHTXDOLW\V\VWHPIRUUDGLRJUDSKHUV
6*HHUVYDQ*HPHUHQ8WUHFKW1/ VJHHUV#QYPEUQO
3XUSRVH7KH'XWFK6RFLHW\RI0HGLFDO,PDJLQJDQG5DGLRWKHUDS\KDVGHYHORSHG
LQ FRRSHUDWLRQ ZLWK 5RJDQ 'HOIW D V\VWHP WR DQDO\VH UHMHFWHG LPDJHV UHWDNHV
LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVH7KHDLPRIWKH,PDJH4XDOLW\6\VWHP ,46 LVWR
HYDOXDWHLPSURYHDQGDXGLWSDWLHQWSRVLWLRQLQJDQGUDGLRJUDSKLFH[SRVXUHFRQGL
WLRQVLQDGLJLWDOUDGLRORJ\GHSDUWPHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDLQVWUXPHQWLVLPSOHPHQWHGIRUUDGLRJUDSKHUV
WRDQDO\VHDQGHYDOXDWHUHWDNHVLQWKHGHSDUWPHQW,QDÀUVWVWHSZDVPDGH
WRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSRVVLELOLWLHVWRFKDQJHWKHLQVWUXPHQWIURPFRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJHV
WRGLJLWDOLPDJHV,QWKH'XWFK6RFLHW\VWDUWHGZLWKDLQYHQWRU\RIWKHUHTXLUH
PHQWVIRUWKH,PDJH4XDOLW\6\VWHP$TXHVWLRQQDLUHZDVFRQVWUXFWHGDQGVHQW
RXWWRDOOWKHUDGLRORJ\GHSDUWPHQWVLQWKH1HWKHUODQGV
5HVXOWV:LWKWKHRXWFRPHRIWKHVXUYH\WKH'XWFK6RFLHW\GHYHORSHGUHTXLUHPHQWV
IRUWKH,PDJH4XDOLW\7RRO7KH,46LVWHVWHGLQGLIIHUHQWKRVSLWDOVDQGLVDYDLODEOH
RQDOLFHQF\EDVHDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQWKHGHSDUWPHQWDQGWKH'XWFK6RFLHW\
&RQFOXVLRQ,WLVSRVVLEOHLQDIXOOGLJLWDOHQYLURQPHQWWRXVHWKH,46WRHYDOX
DWHLPSURYHDQGDXGLWSDWLHQWSRVLWLRQLQJDQGUDGLRJUDSKLFH[SRVXUHFRQGLWLRQV
,QWHUQDWLRQDODJUHHPHQWVVKRXOGEHPDGHIRUVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQRIWKHLQIRUPDWLRQ
LQWKH',&20KHDGHUWRDVVXUHDKLJKTXDOLW\VHUYLFH7KH,46FDQEHXVHGLQ
TXDOLW\DVVXUDQFHSURJUDPPHLQWKHGHSDUWPHQWDVDEHQFKPDUNWRROEHWZHHQ
GHSDUWPHQWVDQGIRUFOLQLFDODXGLWVSHUIRUPHGE\WKHUDGLRJUDSKHUVRFLHW\
%
7KHHYDOXDWLRQRISDWLHQWҋVDQ[LHW\OHYHOVXQGHUJRLQJPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJH[DPLQDWLRQ
)')50HGHLURV.%$]HYHGR/395LEHLUR$)&/$EUDQWHV
65RGULJXHV&$6LOYD533$OPHLGD)DUR37
ÀOLSDBPHGHLURV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDQDO\VHSRVVLEOHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHDQ[LHW\OHYHOVRISDWLHQWV
ZKRUHFHLYHDGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKH05,VFDQDQGSDWLHQWVZKRUHFHLYH
RQO\EDVLFLQVWUXFWLRQVIURPWKHKRVSLWDODQGWRYHULI\LIWKHUHLVYDULDWLRQLQDQ[LHW\
OHYHOVRISDWLHQWVEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHH[DPLQDWLRQDQGUHODWHWKHPWRJHQGHUDJH
HGXFDWLRQOHYHODQGSUHYLRXV05,H[DPLQDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHWRWDOVDPSOHRISDWLHQWVZDVGLYLGHGLQWRDFRQ
WUROJURXSDQGDQH[SHULPHQWDOJURXSDQGHDFKRQHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRVXEJURXSV
EHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHH[DPDQGWKHQLWZDVDSSOLHG67$,IRUP<WRERWKDIWHUWKH
VRFLRGHPRJUDSKLFTXHVWLRQV
5HVXOWV$WDFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDOWKHPHDQGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHFRQWURO
JURXSEHIRUHDQGDIWHUUDQJHGIURPDQG7KHYDOXHRIWKH6WXGHQWҋV
WWHVWZDV GI DQGWDLOVLJ 7KHPHDQGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&KLOGUHQҋVDQGSDUHQWVҋSHUFHSWLRQRID05,H[DPLQDWLRQ
-*DDUGOLQJ0(GZLQVRQ0DDQVVRQ/XQG6( MHQQ\JDUGOLQJ#PHGOXVH
3XUSRVH7RGHVFULEHFKLOGUHQҋVDQGSDUHQWVҋSHUFHSWLRQRID05,H[DPLQDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&KLOGUHQDQGSDUHQWVZHUHVHOHFWHGFRQVHFXWLYHO\,Q
FOXVLRQFULWHULDZHUHWKDWWKH\FRXOGXQGHUVWDQGDQGVSHDN6ZHGLVK7KHFKLOGUHQ
VKRXOGEHRIERWKJHQGHUVDQGDJHG\HDUV,WVKRXOGEHFKLOGUHQZKRGLGD
05,H[DPLQDWLRQIRUWKHÀUVWWLPHDQGWKH\ZRXOGEHDEOHWRFDUU\RXWDQLQWHUYLHZ
RIPLQXWHV7KHSDUHQWVZKRIROORZHGZHUHDOVRLQWHUYLHZHG6HPLVWUXFWXUHG
LQWHUYLHZVZLWKFKLOGUHQJLUOVDQGER\VDQGWKHLUSDUHQWVZHUHFDUULHGRXW
7KHLQWHUYLHZVZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJDSKHQRPHQRJUDSKLFDODSSURDFK
5HVXOWV7KHFKLOGUHQSHUFHLYHGVHFXULW\WKURXJKSUHSDUDWLRQLQIRUPDWLRQSDUHQWDO
SUHVHQFHDQGWKDWLWZDVDOLJKWLQVLGHWKH05,7KHSDUHQWVSHUFHLYHGVHFXULW\
WKURXJKLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKHSURFHGXUHDQGEHLQJSUHVHQWZKLOHWKHLUFKLOGZDV
H[DPLQHG%RWKFKLOGUHQDQGSDUHQWVIHOWDVHQVHRIVHFXULW\E\WKHSRVLWLYHEH
KDYLRXUIURPKHDOWKSURIHVVLRQDOV7KHFKLOGUHQSHUFHLYHGDQ[LHW\ZKHQWRROLWWOH
SUHSDUDWLRQLQIRUPDWLRQKDGEHHQJLYHQWKHGHVLJQRIWKH05,WKHVRXQGDQGWR
REWDLQDSHULSKHUDOYHQRXVFDWKHWHU7KHSDUHQWVSHUFHLYHGDQ[LHW\IURPWKHVRXQG
DIDLOHGH[DPLQDWLRQDQGWKHLQVHUWLRQRIDSHULSKHUDOYHQRXVFDWKHWHU7KHFKLOGUHQ
WDONHGPXFKDERXWWKHGLIÀFXOW\WROLHVWLOO3DUHQWVZDQWHGPRUHLQIRUPDWLRQVRWKDW
WKH\FRXOGSUHSDUHWKHLUFKLOGUHQDQGWKHPVHOYHV
&RQFOXVLRQ$QLQIRUPDWLRQOHDÁHWEHIRUHDQ05,H[DPLQDWLRQWKDWLVSURGXFHGIRU
FKLOGUHQFRXOGFRQWULEXWHWRUHGXFHGDQ[LHW\JUHDWHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIZKDWWKH\
DUHJRLQJWKURXJKDQGOHDGWRLPSURYHGTXDOLW\RIWKHH[DPLQDWLRQ
%
,QIRUPDWLRQWRWKHSDUHQWVLQFRQQHFWLRQZLWKWKHLUFKLOGҋVGLDJQRVWLF
H[DPLQDWLRQ
20XKDUHPRYLF+YLGRYUH'. RPDUUDGLRJUDI#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RLGHQWLI\SDUHQWVҋQHHGIRULQIRUPDWLRQLQFRQQHFWLRQZLWKWKHLUFKLOGҋV
GLDJQRVWLFH[DPLQDWLRQDQGWRSUHSDUHUDGLRJUDSKHUVEHWWHUWRFRPPXQLFDWHWR
VDWLVI\WKRVHQHHGV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$TXDOLWDWLYHDSSURDFKZDVDSSOLHGDQGWKHGDWDZHUH
FROOHFWHGIURPWZHQW\SDUHQWVZKRSDUWLFLSDWHGLQWKHVHPLVWUXFWXUHGIDFHWRIDFH
RUIRFXVJURXSLQWHUYLHZV&RQVWDQWFRPSDUDWLYHWHFKQLTXHZDVXWLOLVHGWRDQDO\VH
WKHGDWDZKHUHDQVZHUVDQGFRQFOXVLRQVZHUHFDWHJRULVHGDQGWKHQFRPSDUHG
DQGUHODWHGWRRQHDQRWKHU7KHFDWHJRULHVZHUHFULWLFDOO\UHYLHZHGDQGUHYLVHG
WRLPSURYHWKHUHOLDELOLW\RIWKHDQDO\VLV$IROORZXSIRFXVJURXSZDVFUHDWHGWR
YDOLGDWHFODULI\DQGUHÀQHWKHFROOHFWHGGDWD
5HVXOWV3DUHQWVҋNQRZOHGJHDERXWGLDJQRVWLFH[DPLQDWLRQVDQGWKHULVNFRQQHFWHG
WRWKHPDUHYHU\OLPLWHG0RVWRIWKHPKDYHSUHMXGLFHVDQGWKHLUWKRXJKWVDERXW
UDGLDWLRQDUHYHU\FRQIXVHG,QIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKHULVNWKHLUFKLOGUHQDUHH[SRVHG
WRLVKLJKOLJKWHGDVWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWQHHGSDUHQWVKDYH7KH\KDYHDQHHGWREH
LQYROYHGYHUEDOO\DQGSUDFWLFDOO\LQH[DPLQDWLRQRIWKHLUFKLOGUHQ3DUWLFLSDQWVZKR
GLGQRWUHFHLYHGDGHTXDWHLQIRUPDWLRQVKRZHGVLJQVRIVWUHVV
&RQFOXVLRQ5DGLRJUDSKHUVKRXOGLQYROYHWKHSDUHQWVLQH[DPLQDWLRQXVLQJFOHDU
LQVWUXFWLYH LQIRUPDWLRQ DV WKHLU UHVRXUFHV FDQ EH YHU\ XVHIXO DV SV\FKRORJLFDO
VXSSRUWWRWKHFKLOGDQGSUDFWLFDOKHOS7KHULVNRIUDGLDWLRQVKRXOGEHH[SODLQHG
LQDZD\SDUHQWVFDQUHODWHWR0RUHGHWDLOHGLQIRUPDWLRQZLOOFRQWULEXWHWREHWWHU
SURFHGXUHXQGHUVWDQGLQJDQGFRQFHUQVZLOOEHHOLPLQDWHG%\GHÀQLQJDQGVWDQG
DUGLVLQJLQIRUPDWLRQVRPHPLQLPXPTXDOLW\VKRXOGEHJXDUDQWHHGWRWKHSDUHQWV
%
+\SQRVLVLQWKHPDQDJHPHQWRIFODXVWURSKRELF05,SDWLHQWV
1$OH[DQGUH0$)RQWDLQH%6XDUH]'0RPSRLQW-%HFFKLR
7KLDLV)5*DUFKHV)59LOOHMXLI)5 QDFKZDQDOH[DQGUH#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH&ODXVWURSKRELDLVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHFDQFHOODWLRQRIDVLJQLÀFDQWQXPEHU
RI05,H[DPLQDWLRQV:HSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGWKHXVHIXOQHVVRIK\SQRVLVLQWKH
PDQDJHPHQWRIFODXVWURSKRELFSDWLHQWVVFKHGXOHGIRUDQ05,
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
)ULGD\
%
H[SHULPHQWDOJURXSEHIRUHDQGDIWHUUDQJHGIURPDQG7KHYDOXH
RIWKH6WXGHQWҋVWWHVWZDV GI DQGWDLOVLJ 8VLQJ6SHDUPDQҋV
5R WKHUH DUH VRPH FRUUHODWLRQV EHWZHHQ WKH VRFLRGHPRJUDSKLF YDULDEOHV DQG
WKHLUOHYHOVRIDQ[LHW\7KHOHYHORIDQ[LHW\FDQEHFKDQJHGE\PDQ\UHDVRQVRQH
DQGWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWLVZKHQWKHSDWLHQWKDVDOUHDG\SHUIRUPHGD05,VFDQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH PDLQ UHVXOWV VXJJHVW D VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH LQ ERWK JURXSV
DPRQJWKHVXEJURXSEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKDWOHWXVFRQFOXGHGWKDWDIWHUWKH05,H[DP
SDWLHQWVDUHOHVVDQ[LRXV:HDOVRFRQFOXGHWKDWZKRKDVSUHYLRXVO\SHUIRUPHGDQ
05,VFDQKDVVPDOOHUYDOXHVRIDQ[LHW\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZR05,WHFKQLFLDQVDQGDUDGLRORJLVWOHDUQHGHULNVRQLDQ
K\SQRVLV2YHUDSHULRGRIWZHQW\PRQWKVSDWLHQWVZHUHH[SORUHGE\05,
)LIW\WZRSDWLHQWVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGDVFODXVWURSKRELFUHIXVLQJWKHVFKHGXOHG05,
6HYHQ SDWLHQWV H[SHULHQFHG D SDQLF DWWDFN$ EULHI VLQJOH VHVVLRQ RI K\SQRVLV
ZDVSURSRVHG
5HVXOWV$PRQJWKHLGHQWLÀHGFODXVWURSKRELFSDWLHQWVDFFHSWHGK\SQRVLV
DQGXQGHUZHQW05,)RXUSDWLHQWVGHFOLQHGWKHSURSRVHGWUHDWPHQWDQGZHUHXQ
DEOHWRZLWKVWDQGWKH05,SURFHGXUH
&RQFOXVLRQ+\SQRVLVDSSHDUVWREHDVXLWDEOHHIÀFLHQWUDSLGDQGLQH[SHQVLYHWRRO
IRUWKHFDUHRISDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPFODXVWURSKRELDGXULQJ05,:LWKWKLVGUXJIUHH
PHWKRG05,RIFODXVWURSKRELFSDWLHQWVFDQEHSHUIRUPHGLQWKHEHVWFRQGLWLRQV
%
3UDFWLFHVWRFRQWUROLQIHFWLRQUHODWHGWRFKHVWUDGLRJUDSK\LQ
LQWHQVLYHFDUHXQLW
00&35LEHLUR$/5HVHQGHV)35RGULJXHV-(*2ҋ1HLOO
-&0DXULFLR/LVERQ377RPDU37 PDUJDULGDULEHLUR#HVWHVOLSOSW
3XUSRVH7RDQDO\VHWKHSURFHVVRIFDUU\LQJRXWFKHVWUDGLRJUDSK\DWWKHLQWHQVLYH
FDUHXQLW ,&8 UHJDUGLQJWKHFRQWUROLQIHFWLRQSUDFWLFHVDSSOLHGE\UDGLRJUDSKHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\WRRNSODFHLQDSXEOLFKRVSLWDOZKLFKFDUULHVRXW
FKHVWUDGLRJUDSK\LQEHGULGGHQLQWKH,&8)LIWHHQUDGLRJUDSKHUVZHUHREVHUYHG
REVHUYDWLRQDOHPSLULFDOFRPSRQHQW DQGÀOOHGE\WKHUHVHDUFKHUVRQHFKHFNOLVW
ZLWK HOHYHQ LWHPV 7KLUWHHQ GLIIHUHQW UDGLRJUDSKHUV ÀOOHG RQH VXUYH\ ZLWK HLJKW
TXHVWLRQV H[SORUDWRU\HPSLULFDOFRPSRQHQW
5HVXOWV0RVWRIUDGLRJUDSKHUVJDYHRQO\WKUHHFRUUHFWDQVZHUVRIWKH
UDGLRJUDSKHUVSUHVHQWHGSUDFWLFHVVXVSLFLRXVWRFRQGXFWWRDQLQIHFWLRQSURFHVV
OHG WR SUDFWLFHV RI DQ HIIHFWLYH LQIHFWLRQ ZKLOH WKH UHPDLQLQJ GLG
QRWSUHVHQWDQ\ULVNEHKDYLRXUUHODWHGWRWKHGHYHORSPHQWRILQIHFWLRQ0RVWRI
UDGLRJUDSKHUVKDGPRUHWKDQ\HDUVRIZRUNH[SHULHQFHDQG\HDUV
'LVLQIHFWLRQSURFHGXUHVZHUHQRWFDUULHGRXWRQWKHLPDJHSODWHV ,SҋV RUSRUWDEOH
HTXLSPHQWLQWKH,PDJLQJ'HSDUWPHQWEHIRUHWRDUULYHRQWKH,&80RVWRIWKH
UDGLRJUDSKHUV XVHGJORYHVGLGQRWXVHDQ\SHUVRQDOXWHQVLOV RU
GLGQRWFRPHLQWRFRQWDFWZLWKWKHSDWLHQWRUWKHEHGZLWKRXWGLVLQIHFWÀUVW
GXULQJWKHSURFHGXUHVWKH,SҋVSURWHFWLRQZDVXVHGLQRIWKHFDVHV7KH
IROORZLQJSURFHGXUHVQHYHUZHUHDSSOLHGE\KDOIVDPSOHZHDULQJRIDZKLWHFRDW
LPSHUPHDEOHDSURQRUPDVNDQGGLVLQIHFWLRQRIWKH,SҋVDWWKHHQG
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVIDUIURPIROORZLQJWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVRUJXLGHOLQHV
VXJJHVWHGWKDWWKHPDWWHUDERXWSUHYHQWLRQDQGFRQWUROLQIHFWLRQDPRQJUDGLRJUD
SKHUVVKRXOGEHLPSURYHGWKURXJKWKHRUHWLFDODQGWUDLQLQJLQLWLDWLYHV
%
5DGLRJUDSKHUҋVUROHLQWHOHUDGLRORJ\
(0HWVDOD$+HQQHU+HOVLQNL),2XOX), DQMDKHQQHU#RDPNÀ
3XUSRVH7HOHUDGLRORJ\LVRQHRIWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWDUHDVRIWHOHPHGLFLQH&KDQJH
IURPFRQYHQWLRQDOÀOPVFUHHQLPDJLQJV\VWHPVWRWKHGLJLWDORQHVKDVFKDQJHG
UDGLRJUDSKHUVҋMREGHVFULSWLRQDORW6RPHWDVNVVXFKDVGHYHORSLQJLPDJHVRU
DUFKLHYLQJWKHÀOPVKDYHGLVDSSHDUHGDQGQHZZRUNDUHDVVXFKDV3$&VZRUN
KDVHPHUJHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6\VWHPDWLFOLWHUDWXUHUHYLHZZDVPDGHIURP)LQQLVKDQG
(QJOLVKODQJXDJHHOHFWURQLFKHDOWKFDUHGDWDEDVHVDQG7KHVLVGDWDEDVHRIXQLYHUVL
WLHVRIDSSOLHGVFLHQFHV9ROXPHVRI-RXUQDORI'LJLWDO,PDJLQJZHUHUHYLHZHG1R
WLPHOLPLWZDVVHWEHFDXVHSKHQRPHQRQRQWKHIRFXVRIVHDUFKLVUHODWLYHO\QHZ
,QFOXVLRQFULWHULRQZDVWKDWVHOHFWHGVWXGLHVGHVFULEHGUDGLRJUDSKHUVҋUROHDVDQ
DFWLYH DFWRU RU EHQHÀFLDU\ 6WXGLHV GHVFULELQJ UDGLRJUDSKHUVҋ UROH LQ GLDJQRVWLF
RU WKHUDSHXWLF WHOHUDGLRORJ\ ZHUH VHDUFKHG 6WXGLHV FRPSULVLQJ ÀQDO GDWD ZHUH
DQDO\VHGE\LQGXFWLYHFRQWHQWDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV0RVWFHQWUDODUHDVIRUPLQJUDGLRJUDSKHUVҋMREGHVFULSWLRQLQWHOHUDGLRO
RJ\ZHUHSDWLHQWGDWDPDQDJHPHQWDQGFRPELQLQJSDWLHQWGDWDWRLPDJLQJGDWD
UDGLRWKHUDS\DQGRULPDJHSURGXFWLRQSURFHVVLQJDQGVDYLQJLPDJHVWDNLQJFDUH
RIVDIHW\TXDOLW\DVVXUDQFHDQGGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQOLIHORQJHGXFDWLRQGHYHORSLQJ
RQHVHOIDQGRQHVҋZRUNPXOWLSURIHVVLRQDOWHDPZRUNFOLHQWFHQWUHGSDWLHQWHGXFD
WLRQDQGQXUVLQJGDWDVDIHW\DQGVHFXULW\DQGSODQQLQJDQGPDQDJLQJHFRQRP\
ZHUHSDUWRI3$&6DGPLQLVWUDWRUVZRUN
&RQFOXVLRQ5DGLRJUDSKHUVҋMREGHVFULSWLRQLQWHOHUDGLRORJ\VKRXOGEHWDNHQLQWR
DFFRXQWZKHQUDGLRJUDSKHUVҋHGXFDWLRQLVSODQQHGRQWKHÀUVWDQGVHFRQGF\FOHDQG
LQOLIHORQJHGXFDWLRQ&RPSHWHQFHVVKRXOGEHUHFRJQLVHGZKHQSODQQLQJLPDJLQJ
XQLWVҋMREGHVFULSWLRQVHYDOXDWLQJZRUNGHPDQGVDQGUHZDUGLQJ
%
$UH8.UDGLRJUDSKHUVPRUHHPRWLRQDOO\LQWHOOLJHQWWKDQDQRUPDWLYH
FRPSDULVRQJURXS"$QDJHDQGJHQGHUPDWFKHGDQDO\VLV
6-0DFND\3+RJJ*7&RRNH5'%DNHU7'DZNHV6DOIRUG8.
&KHVWHU8. VPDFND\#VDOIRUGDFXN
3XUSRVH (PRWLRQDO LQWHOOLJHQFH (, KDV EHHQ LGHQWLÀHG DV D EHQHÀFLDO SKH
QRPHQRQLQPHGLFLQHQXUVLQJUDGLRJUDSK\DQGKDVEHHQVKRZQWREHSRVLWLYHO\
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKDJUHDWHUDPRXQWRIFRPSDVVLRQDWHDQGHPSDWKLFSDWLHQWFDUH
7KLVSDSHUZLOOFRPSDUH(,GDWDIURPD8.ZLGHVXUYH\RIUDGLRJUDSKHUVZLWKD
QRUPDWLYHVDPSOHJURXSWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUUDGLRJUDSKHUVKDYHKLJKHUHPRWLRQDO
LQWHOOLJHQFHWKDQDQRUPDWLYHJURXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QD8.ZLGHVXUYH\RIUDGLRJUDSKHUWUDLWHPRWLRQDO
LQWHOOLJHQFH Q ZDVXQGHUWDNHQWRGHWHUPLQHWKHJOREDODQGIRXUIDFWRU(,
OHYHOVRIUDGLRJUDSKHUV7KLVGDWDZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKDQRUPDWLYHJURXS Q
IURPWKHQDWLRQDO7UDLW(,GDWDEDVH7KHPHDQDJHUDQJHDQGJHQGHUSURSRUWLRQRI
WKHVHWZRGDWDVHWVGLIIHUHGVRDJHDQGJHQGHUPDWFKLQJE\JURXSZDVXQGHUWDNHQ
IROORZHGE\$129$ZLWKSRVWKRF7XNH\WHVWV
5HVXOWV6WDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVREVHUYHGIRUDJHJURXSEHWZHHQ
GDWDVHWVRQJOREDOWUDLW(,DQGDOOIDFWRUV3RVWKRFWHVWVLQGLFDWHGGLIIHUHQFHVOD\
PDLQO\ZLWKDJHJURXS5DGLRJUDSKHUVVFRUHGPRUHKLJKO\WKDQQRUPDWLYH
JURXSIRUDOOEXWWKHHPRWLRQDOLW\IDFWRU+LJKO\VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
ZHUHREVHUYHGLQJHQGHUEHWZHHQGDWDVHWVIRUJOREDODQGDOOIDFWRUV3RVWKRF
WHVWVLQGLFDWHGGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQIHPDOHVDFURVVJOREDODQGDOOIDFWRUVEXWIRU
PDOHVWKLVZDVOLPLWHGWRJOREDOWUDLW(,ZHOOEHLQJDQGVHOIFRQWURO
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH8.UDGLRJUDSKHUVDPSOHVFRUHGPRUHKLJKO\LQHPRWLRQDOLQWHO
OLJHQFHWKDQDQRUPDWLYHVDPSOHJURXS
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
6DWXUGD\0DUFK
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP$
1HXUR
66
6WURNHGLDJQRVLV
0RGHUDWRUV
'5+DGL]DGHK%RQQ'(
00HFKO%UQR&=
%
'LVWLQFWLRQRIDQWHJUDGHÁRZDFURVVLQWUDYDVFXODUWKURPEXVIURP
UHWURJUDGHFROODWHUDOÁRZLQRFFOXGHGFHUHEUDODUWHULHVLQLWLDO
H[SHULHQFHXVLQJWLPHUHVROYHG&7DQJLRJUDSK\
$0-)U|OLFK56FKUDPP(.ORW]0.QDXWK36FKUDPP
*|WWLQJHQ'()RUFKKHLP'(
3XUSRVH$FXWHVWURNHSDWLHQWVZLWKLQWUDFUDQLDOYHVVHORFFOXVLRQPD\GHPRQVWUDWH
VXERFFOXVLYHWKURPEXVW\SLFDOO\FKDUDFWHULVHGE\DQWHJUDGHRSDFLÀFDWLRQGLVWDOWR
DQRFFOXVLRQRQFDWKHWHUDQJLRJUDSK\7KLVÀQGLQJKDVEHHQDVVRFLDWHGZLWKKLJKHU
UDWHVRIYHVVHOUHFDQDOLVDWLRQ:HVRXJKWWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUDQWHJUDGHÁRZFDQ
EHGHPRQVWUDWHGRQQHDUZKROHEUDLQWLPHUHVROYHGIRXUGLPHQVLRQDO&7DQJLRJUD
SK\ '&7$ DQGZKHWKHULWFDQEHGLVWLQJXLVKHGIURPUHWURJUDGHFROODWHUDOÁRZ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLQVHFWLRQ'&7$GDWDIURPFRQVHFXWLYHVWURNH
SDWLHQWV ZLWK DFXWH WHUPLQDO LQWHUQDO FDURWLG RU PLGGOH FHUHEUDO DUWHU\ RFFOXVLRQ
ZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUSUHWUHDWPHQWWKURPERO\VLVLQFHUHEUDOLQIDUFWLRQ 7,&, JUDGH
DQGWKHSUHVHQFHRIDQWHJUDGHRUUHWURJUDGHFRQWUDVWRSDFLÀFDWLRQDWWKHGLVWDO
WKURPEXV HQG 'LJLWDO VXEWUDFWLRQ DQJLRJUDPV ZHUH UHYLHZHG IRU SUHWUHDWPHQW
7,&,JUDGHSUHVHQFHRIDQWHJUDGHRSDFLÀFDWLRQGLVWDOWRWKHWKURPEXVDVZHOODV
SRVWLQWHUYHQWLRQ7,&,JUDGH
5HVXOWV 2Q '&7$ WKHUH ZDV HYLGHQFH RI DQWHJUDGH ÁRZ LQ RI FDVHV
&RPSDUHGWRDQJLRJUDSK\'&7$FRUUHFWO\FODVVLÀHGDQWHJUDGHÁRZLQ
FDVHV WKHUHZDVIDOVHSRVLWLYHDQGQRIDOVHQHJDWLYHV5HFDQDOLVDWLRQ
7,&,DRUJUHDWHU ZDVDFKLHYHGLQDOOFDVHVZLWKHYLGHQFHRIDQWHJUDGHÁRZRQ
'&7$YHUVXVRXWRIWKHFDVHV ZLWKRXWHYLGHQFHRIDQWHJUDGHÁRZ
&RQFOXVLRQ '&7$ FDQ GLVWLQJXLVK DQWHJUDGH ÁRZ DFURVV D FHUHEUDO DUWHU\
RFFOXVLRQIURPUHWURJUDGHFROODWHUDOÁRZ)XUWKHUVWXGLHVSUHIHUDEO\ZLWKDODUJHU
VDPSOHVL]HDUHQHHGHGWRFRQÀUPRXUÀQGLQJVDQGDVVHVVZKHWKHU'&7$FDQ
EHXVHGWRSUHGLFWVXFFHVVRIUHFDQDOLVDWLRQSURFHGXUHVLQVHOHFWFDVHV
%
3RRUFROODWHUDOVWDWXVRQWLPLQJLQYDULDQW&7$LVDVWURQJSUHGLFWRU
RISRRUFOLQLFDORXWFRPHLQDFXWHVWURNHSDWLHQWVZLWKODUJHYHVVHO
RFFOXVLRQ
(-6PLW(M9RQNHQ7YDQ6HHWHUV-:'DQNEDDU,&YDQGHU6FKDDI
%.9HOWKXLV%YDQ*LQQHNHQ03URNRS8WUHFKW1/1LMPHJHQ1/
HZRXGVPLW#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVZKHWKHUFROODWHUDOVWDWXVLQDFXWHVWURNHSDWLHQWVZLWKODUJH
YHVVHORFFOXVLRQSUHGLFWVFOLQLFDORXWFRPHDQGWRFRPSDUHVWDQGDUG&7DQJLRJUDSK\
&7$ WRDWLPLQJLQYDULDQW&7$IRUWKLVSXUSRVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HVHOHFWHGFRQVHFXWLYHLVFKDHPLFVWURNHSDWLHQWV
ZLWK,&$DQGRU0&$RFFOXVLRQIURPRXUFOLQLFDOGDWDEDVH&7$DQG&7SHUIXVLRQ
&73 DWDGPLVVLRQDQGFOLQLFDORXWFRPHGDWD PRGLÀHG5DQNLQ6FDOHP56 DIWHU
WKUHHPRQWKVZHUHDYDLODEOH&73VRXUFHLPDJHVZHUHXVHGWRUHFRQVWUXFWWLPLQJ
LQYDULDQW&7$ 7,&7$ DWHFKQLTXHWKDWLVLQVHQVLWLYHWRGHOD\HGFRQWUDVWDUULYDO
)RXUH[SHULHQFHGREVHUYHUVDVVHVVHGFROODWHUDOVWDWXVRQ&7$DQG7,&7$LQDQ
LQGHSHQGHQW EOLQGHG UDQGRPLVHG PDQQHU &ROODWHUDO VWDWXV ZDV UDWHG JRRG LI
RIFROODWHUDOVZHUHSUHVHQWRUSRRULIZHUHSUHVHQW&OLQLFDORXWFRPH
ZDVGHÀQHGDVJRRGIRUP56RUSRRUIRUP56!
5HVXOWV&ROODWHUDOVWDWXVZDVUDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHRIWHQDVJRRGRQ7,&7$
WKDQRQ&7$ S ,QWHUDQGLQWUDREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZHUHJRRG
IRUDVVHVVLQJFROODWHUDOVWDWXVRQ&7$DQG7,&7$ PHDQNDSSD DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 3RRUFROODWHUDOVWDWXVRQ7,&7$KDGDSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIIRU
SRRURXWFRPH7KLVQXPEHUZDVRQO\IRU&7$*RRGFROODWHUDOVWDWXVRQ&7$
RU7,&7$SUHGLFWHGJRRGRXWFRPHLQRQO\DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ3RRUFROODWHUDOVVWDWXVRQWLPLQJLQYDULDQW&7$LVDVWURQJSUHGLFWRU
RISRRUFOLQLFDORXWFRPHLQDFXWHVWURNHSDWLHQWVZLWKODUJHYHVVHORFFOXVLRQ7,
&7$GHWHFWVPRUHFROODWHUDOVWKDQVWDQGDUG&7$GXHWRLWVLQVHQVLWLYLW\WRGHOD\HG
FRQWUDVWDUULYDO
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
&7DQJLRJUDSK\´6SRW6LJQµSUHGLFWVKDHPDWRPDH[SDQVLRQLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHVSRQWDQHRXV,&+
,+DYVWHHQ/&KULVWHQVHQ$&KULVWHQVHQ-1LHOVHQ'.ULHJHU
+&KULVWHQVHQ&RSHQKDJHQ'. DQGHUVFKULVWHQVHQHPDLO#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH6SRQWDQHRXVLQWUDFHUHEUDOKDHPRUUKDJH 3,&+ H[SDQGVLQXSWR
RIFDVHVDQGVSRWVLJQGHWHFWLRQRQ&7DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ HQDEOHVSUHGLFWLRQ
RIKDHPDWRPDH[SDQVLRQZKLFKKDVEHHQOLQNHGWRGHDWKDQGEDGRXWFRPH7KH
DLPLVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHVWUHQJWKLQWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSUHVHQFHRIVSRWVLJQ
DQGKDHPDWRPDH[SDQVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[KXQGUHGDQGWZHOYHSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWVWDQGDUGLVHG
ZRUNXSIRULYWKURPERO\VLVDW%LVSHEMHUJ8QLYHUVLW\KRVSLWDO&RSHQKDJHQIURP
$SULOWR0D\ZLWKLQKRXUVDIWHUVWURNHV\PSWRPRQVHW$QRQFRQWUDVW
&7 VFDQ 1&&7 DQG &7$ ZDV SHUIRUPHG URXWLQHO\ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK ,&+ DQG
1&&7ZDVFRQWUROSODQQHGQH[WGD\ZKHQSRVVLEOH2QHUDGLRORJLVWUHYLHZHGDOO
GDWDIRUVSRWVLJQDQGHVWLPDWHGWKHKDHPDWRPDYROXPHLQWKHDFXWHDQGIROORZXS
1&&7VZLWKWKH$%&PHWKRGRIPHDVXUHPHQW6DPSOHVZHUHDVVHVVHGZLWK
WKH0DQQ:KLWQH\WHVW7KHVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\WKH'DQLVK'DWD3URWHFWLRQ
$JHQF\ÀOHQR
5HVXOWV&7$ZDVREWDLQHGLQSDWLHQWVDQGQH[WGD\1&&7ZDVREWDLQHGLQ
SDWLHQWVPDLQO\GXHWRHDUO\WUDQVIHUUDORIVWDEOHSDWLHQWV,QRISDWLHQWV
VSRWVLJQZDVREVHUYHG7KHUHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQKDHPDWRPDH[SDQVLRQ
LQJURXSVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWVSRWVLJQS 0HDQDFXWHYROXPHZDVPO
UDQJHPO LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVSRWVLJQYVPO UDQJHPO
&RQFOXVLRQ6SRWVLJQLGHQWLÀHVSDWLHQWVZLWKODWHUKDHPDWRPDH[SDQVLRQDQGPD\
EHXVHIXOLQLGHQWLI\LQJSDWLHQWVIRUSURRIRISULQFLSOHWULDOVLQDFXWHVSRQWDQHRXV
,&+DLPLQJDWSUHYHQWLQJRUVWRSSLQJHDUO\KDHPDWRPDH[SDQVLRQ
%
'XDOHQHUJ\&7IRUGHWHFWLRQRIFRQWUDVWOHDNDJHZLWKLQKLJKGHQVLW\
KDHPDWRPDLQSDWLHQWVZLWKLQWUDFUDQLDOKDHPRUUKDJHLRGLQHLPDJHV
YHUVXVFRPELQHGLPDJHV
<:DWDQDEH+7DQDND01LVKL]DZD<.XQLWRPL$7VXNDEH17RPL\DPD
6XLWD-3 ZDWDQDEH#UDGLROPHGRVDNDXDFMS
3XUSRVH7RHOXFLGDWHWKHGHWHFWDELOLW\RIFRQWUDVWOHDNDJHLQKLJKGHQVLW\KDH
PDWRPD RQ HDUO\ SKDVH GXDO HQHUJ\ &7$ DQG FRPSDUH WKH UHVXOWV ZLWK WKRVH
REWDLQHGRQGHOD\HG&7 UHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\VL[SDWLHQWVZLWKLQWUDFUDQLDOKDHPRUUKDJHZHUH
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\$OOSDWLHQWVKDGXQGHUJRQHGXDOVRXUFHGXDO
HQHUJ\&7$ N9DQGN9 DQGGHOD\HGSKDVHHQKDQFHG&7 PLQXWHVDIWHU
FRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ$SULODQG-XO\'XDOHQHUJ\&7LPDJHVZHUH
SRVWSURFHVVHGZLWKFRPPHUFLDOVRIWZDUHDSSO\LQJDWKUHHPDWHULDOGHFRPSRVLWLRQ
DOJRULWKPWRFDOFXODWHLRGLQHLPDJHVDQGYLUWXDOXQHQKDQFHGLPDJHVDQGDOVRWR
JHQHUDWHFRPELQHG&7LPDJHVWKDWFUHDWHWKHLPSUHVVLRQRIN9&7LPDJHV
2QHQHXURUDGLRORJLVWEOLQGHGWRWKHSDWLHQWҋVGDWDUHYLHZHGWKHLRGLQHLPDJHV
DQGFRPELQHGLPDJHVWRGHWHFWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWRUFRQWUDVWOHDNDJHLQWKH
KDHPDWRPD
5HVXOWV7KHSDWLHQWVҋGLDJQRVLVZDVDVIROORZVLGLRSDWKLFLQWUDFHUHEUDOKDHP
RUUKDJHWUDXPDWLFKDHPRUUKDJHVXEDUDFKQRLGKDHPRUUKDJHDQGEUDLQ
WXPRXUZLWKKDHPRUUKDJH&RQWUDVWOHDNDJHRUHQKDQFHPHQWZDVGHWHFWHGLQ
RISDWLHQWV RQGHOD\HG&7$PRQJWKHVHSDWLHQWVSDWLHQWVVKRZHG
DQHTXLYRFDOOHDNDJHRQFRPELQHGLPDJHVEXWWKHLRGLQHLPDJHVUHYHDOHGFOHDU
FRQWUDVWOHDNDJHLQWKHKDHPDWRPD,QSDWLHQWVLRGLQHOHDNDJHFRXOGEHGHWHFWHG
RQERWKLRGLQHDQGFRPELQHGLPDJHVEXWLRGLQHLPDJHZDVVXSHULRULQGHSLFWLQJ
WKHOHDNDJH(LJKWSDWLHQWVZHUHHTXDOWRGHSLFWWKHFRQWUDVWOHDNDJHLQERWKLRGLQH
DQGFRPELQHGLPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ'XDOHQHUJ\&7LVDEOHWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHLRGLQHFRQWUDVWPHGLXPIURP
KDHPDWRPDDQGIDFLOLWDWHVWKHGHWHFWLRQRIFRQWUDVWOHDNDJHHVSHFLDOO\LQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKIDLQWLRGLQHHQKDQFHPHQW
%
&HUHEUDOSHUIXVLRQ&7ITXDQWLI\LQJUHJLRQDOIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV
DWWKHRQVHWRIWKHVWURNHDQGKVDIWHULQWUDYHQRXVWKURPERO\WLFWKHUDS\
=00HWDIUDW]L($OH[LRX0)DQDULRWLV3$UJLUL$&KRYDV$.RPQRV
/DULVD*5
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHFKDQJHVLQUHJLRQDOIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV U)3V RILVFKDH
PLFDQGQRUPDOEUDLQDWWKHRQVHWRIDFXWHVWURNH $6 DQGKVDIWHUWKURPERO\WLF
WKHUDS\FRUUHODWHU)3VWR1,+66LQERWKWLPHIUDPHVDQGWRHYDOXDWHXWLOLW\RIWKH
LQLWLDOU)3VWRSUHGLFWWKHFOLQLFDORXWFRPHDWKV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQWHHQ$6SDWLHQWVZKRWKURPEROLVHGXQGHUZHQWEUDLQ
XQHQKDQFHG&7DQG&7SHUIXVLRQ &73 DWDGPLVVLRQDQGKVDIWHUWKURPERO\VLV
$OO&7VWXGLHVZHUHUHYLHZHGDQGU)3V &%)&690,77 RILVFKDHPLFDQGQRUPDO
EUDLQDWERWKWLPHIUDPHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGU)3VZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKEDVHOLQHDQG
KV1,+66UHVSHFWLYHO\$PXOWLYDULDWHOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVZDVXVHGWR
LQYHVWLJDWHWKHHIIHFWRIWKHLQLWLDOU)3VRQWKHFOLQLFDORXWFRPH
5HVXOWV1RUPDOEUDLQU)3VDWKVZHUHQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWFRPSDUHGWR
LQLWLDOU)3V&%)DQG077RIGLVHDVHGEUDLQZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHG S
DQGLQFUHDVHG S UHVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHGWRWKHFRQWUDODWHUDOKHDOWK\VLGH
U)3VRIWKHGLVHDVHGEUDLQZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGDWKV 077S
&%) S &%9 S 1,+66 ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ LPSURYHG DW KV
S &%9ZDVWKHVWURQJHVWSUHGLFWRURILPSURYHPHQWRI1,+66IROORZHG
E\077 5A S
&RQFOXVLRQU)3VDQG1,+66DUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGKVDIWHUWKURPERO\VLV
DWWKHVHWWLQJVRI$67KHFOLQLFDOVHYHULW\H[SUHVVHGE\1,+66LVVWURQJO\FRUUH
ODWHGWR&%9RIWKHGLVHDVHGEUDLQDWSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHVWURNHDQGDWKVODWHU
)XUWKHUPRUHSDWLHQWVZLWKWKHORZHU&%9YDOXHVDWDGPLVVLRQKDGDSRRUHUFOLQLFDO
RXWFRPHDVLWLVH[SUHVVHGE\KLJKHU1,+66
%
'\QDPLFSHUIXVLRQ&7 3&7 LPDJLQJDQGDOWHUDWLRQRIEORRGEUDLQ
EDUULHUSHUPHDELOLW\ %%%3 DIWHUDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH $,6
SURJQRVWLFVLJQLÀFDQFH
(3XJOLHOOL0%DÀOH0)XVFKL9'L(JLGLR00RQLQD7HUDPR,7
HGRSXJ#KRWPDLOFRP
%
&7SHUIXVLRQDQG&7DQJLRJUDSK\FDQWKH\EHWWHUSUHGLFWWKHÀQDOLQIDUFW"
0)HUQiQGH]7DUDQLOOD&5&DUDFHOD=HEDOORV,+HUUHUD(%DUFHQD
-0*DUFLD%HQDVVL5*RQ]DOH]*XWLHUUH]7ROHGR(6
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHFHUHEUDO&7SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ &&73 SUHGLFWLQJÀQDOLQI
DUFWHGFHUHEUDODUHDV ,&$ 7RUHYLHZFRUUHODWLRQRIWKHLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVEHWZHHQ
QRQHQKDQFHG&7 1(&7 DQGFHUHEUDOEORRGYROXPH &%9 PDSVLGHQWLI\LQJWKH
,&$7RDVVHVVWKHLPSDFWRIFROODWHUDODUWHULHV &$ LQWKHGHYHORSPHQWRIWKHÀQDO
LQIDUFW7RDQDO\VHWKHRXWFRPHRIWKHFHUHEUDODUHDVDWULVNLQÀEULQRO\VLVWUHDWHG
SDWLHQWV )73 YHUVXVQRQWUHDWHGSDWLHQWV 173
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHYLHZHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\LPDJLQJÀQGLQJVRIVWURNH
LQSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQW1(&7&&73DQGIROORZXS1(&7DIWHUKRXUV
XVLQJWKH$OEHUWD6WURNH3URJUDP(DUO\&76FRUH $63(&76 DVDPHDVXUHRI
FHUHEUDODUHDV&7DQJLRJUDSK\ZDVSHUIRUPHGWRHYDOXDWHWKH&$LQWKHPLGGOH
FHUHEUDODUWHU\WHUULWRU\ DEVHQWPRGHUDWHDQGHYLGHQW :HSHUIRUPHGFRUUHOD
WLRQDQGOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVEHWZHHQ$63(&76RQ1(&7&%9&%)DQG
IROORZXS&7 )&7 LQ)73DQG173
5HVXOWV7KHUHLVDVWURQJSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ$63(&7RQ&%9PDSV
DQG$63(&7RQ)&7 5 DQG$63(&7RQ1(&7DQG$63(&7RQ)&7
5 ERWKLQ173,Q)73ZHREVHUYHGDVWURQJSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQ 5
EHWZHHQFHUHEUDODUHDVDWULVNLQ&&73DQGWKRVHWKDWZHUHQRWLQIDUFWHGLQWKH)&7
/HVVLQIDUFWHGDUHDVZHUHVHHQLQ)73YHUVXV173 YHUVXV &RPSDUHG
ZLWKPRGHUDWHRUHYLGHQW&$DEVHQFHRI&$LQFUHPHQWVPRUHWKDQWKH,&$
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
$XWRPDWHGDVVHVVPHQWRIUHJLRQDO&7SHUIXVLRQLQDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
$.HPPOLQJ5.UXPP/)H\HQ71LHGHUVWDGW:/+HLQGHO
0QVWHU'( DNHPPOLQJ#ZHEGH
3XUSRVH7RSUHVHQWDQRYHODOJRULWKPIRUIXOO\DXWRPDWHGXVHULQGHSHQGHQWDV
VHVVPHQWRIUHJLRQDOUHODWLYHFHUHEUDO&7SHUIXVLRQ &73 SDUDPHWHUVLQDFXWH
LVFKDHPLFVWURNH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$FXWHVWURNHLPDJLQJ QDWLYH&7DQGG\QDPLF&73 ZDV
SHUIRUPHGLQFRQVHFXWLYHDFXWHPLGGOHFHUHEUDODUWHULDOVWURNHVRQDVOLFH
&7VFDQQHU 6RPDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ$66LHPHQV0HGLFDO6ROXWLRQV 5HJLRQDO&73
YDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHGE\DIXOO\DXWRPDWHGURXWLQH UREXVWQRQOLQHDUUHJLVWUDWLRQ
RI&73PDSVWR01,VSDFHUHJDUGOHVVRIEUDLQFRYHUDJHZDVDFFRPSOLVKHG
E\ULJLGERG\WUDQVIRUPDWLRQRIQDWLYH&7WRWKHDQDWRPLFDODYHUDJH&7SHUIXVLRQ
LPDJHIROORZHGE\LQYHUVLRQRIWKHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQPDWUL[ &73WR&7 7KHPDWUL[
&73WR&7DQGWKHQRQOLQHDUZDUSÀOHG&7WR01,ZHUHFRQFDWHQDWHG &73WR01,
7KHZDUSÀHOG&73WR01,ZDVDSSOLHGWRSHUIXVLRQPDSV $SUREDELOLVWLFDWODV
FRYHULQJVWUXFWXUHV +DUYDUG2[IRUGVWUXFWXUDODWODV ZDVXVHGWRFDOFXODWHEUDLQ
SHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVZHLJKWHGE\WKHDQDWRPLFDOSUREDELOLW\RIDUHJLRQ $Q
HUURUFRUUHFWLRQWHUPH[FOXGHGQRQVLJQLÀFDQWYR[HOVGHÀQHGE\FHUHEURVSLQDOÁXLG
DQGYHVVHOV 5HODWLYH&7SHUIXVLRQYDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG UHJLRQDOSHUIXVLRQ
RILVFKDHPLFKHPLVSKHUHGLYLGHGE\WKHFRQWUDODWHUDOVLGH $XWRPDWHGSHUIXVLRQ
YDOXHVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKVHOHFWHGPDQXDOO\WUDFHGSHUIXVLRQYDOXHVIRUUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV5HJLVWUDWLRQRISHUIXVLRQPDSVWR01,VSDFHZDVUREXVWDQGUHOL
DEOH$XWRPDWHGDQGPDQXDOO\REWDLQHGUHJLRQDOEUDLQSHUIXVLRQYDOXHVZHUHQRW
VLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW S 7KHDYHUDJHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQDXWRPDWHGDQG
PDQXDOUHJLRQDOSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVZDVOHVVWKDQ 6'
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQWHGDOJRULWKPLVUREXVWDQGUHOLDEOHIRUDXWRPDWHGFDOFXOD
WLRQRIUHJLRQDOSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUV
%
5HFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUVHOHFWLQJWKHYDVFXODULQSXWIXQFWLRQVWR
RSWLPLVHWKHYDOLGLW\LQ&7SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJLQ RUPRUH VOLFH
VFDQQHUV
-1LHVWHQ,9DQ'HU6FKDDI$5LRUGDQ+'H-RQJ:0DOL%9HOWKXLV
8WUHFKW1/ MQLHVWHQ#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RLPSURYHDFFXUDF\RITXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQPHDVXUHPHQWVDQGUHGXFH
RSHUDWRUGHSHQGHQWSRVWSURFHVVLQJVWHSVE\RSWLPLVLQJWKHVHOHFWLRQRIWKHDUWHULDO
LQSXWIXQFWLRQ $,) DQGWKHYHQRXVRXWSXWIXQFWLRQ 92) LQ&7SHUIXVLRQ &73
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\IRXUSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHPLGGOHFHUHEUDODUWHU\ 0&$
LVFKDHPLFVWURNHXQGHUZHQWQRQFRQWUDVW&7&73DQG&7DQJLRJUDSK\RQDGPLV
VLRQZLWKDVOLFH&7VFDQQHU,Q&73PHDVXUHPHQWVGLIIHUHQWDUWHULHVZHUH
VHOHFWHGDVWKH$,)DQGWKHDUHDXQGHUWKH$,)FXUYH $8&$,) ZDVFDOFXODWHG
7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKH$,)DFFXUDF\ZHFRPSDUHGWKHTXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQPHDVXUH
PHQWVLQERWKV\PSWRPDWLFDQGDV\PSWRPDWLFKHPLVSKHUH UHSHDWHG0HDVXUHVҋ
WHVW IRUHDFK$,)ORFDWLRQ7RUHGXFHRSHUDWRUVWHSVDQGLPSURYHUHSURGXFLELOLW\
ZHH[DPLQHGLIVHOHFWLRQRIWKH92)FRXOGEHUHSODFHGE\WKH$,)7KHUHVXOWLQJ
TXDQWLWDWLYHPHDVXUHPHQWVRIERWK$,)DQG92)ZHUHFRPSDUHG SDLUHGWWHVW
5HVXOWV7KH LQWHUQDO FDURWLG DUWHU\ ,&$ KDG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ WKH ODUJHVW$8&$,)
IROORZHG E\ WKH EDVLODU DUWHU\ $EDV WKH 0&$ DQG WKH DQWHULRU FHUHEUDO DUWHU\
EHWZHHQDOOJURXSVS 6HOHFWLQJWKH,&$DQG$EDVDV$,)UHVXOWHGLQ
WKHPRVWDFFXUDWHYDOXHVZLWKORZHVWTXDQWLWDWLYHPHDQ&%9DQG&%)DQGDF
FRUGLQJO\KLJKHVWTXDQWLWDWLYH077 DOOS 5HSODFHPHQWRI92)E\$,)
VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUPHDQ&%9 LHRYHUHVWLPDWLRQ RQERWKWKHKHPLVSKHUH
LSVLDQGFRQWUDODWHUDOWRWKHWKURPEXV S DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\ DQGD
VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU&%) S RQWKHLSVLODWHUDOKHPLVSKHUH
&RQFOXVLRQ7RLPSURYHYDOLGLW\RITXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQYDOXHVZHUHFRPPHQG
WRVHOHFWWKH,&$DVWKH$,)DQGDODUJHYHLQDVWKH92)
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH$LPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ%%%SHUPHDELOLW\
DOWHUDWLRQDQGWKHÀQDORXWFRPHLQ$,6
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-DQXDU\VL[W\SDWLHQWVZLWK$,6OHVVWKDQ
K IRU DQWHULRU RU K IRU YHUWHEUREDVLODU FLUFXODWLRQ PHDQ DJH \ HYDOXDWHG
E\3&7ZHUHLQFOXGHG,QFUHDVHRQPLFURYDVFXODUSHUPHDELOLW\ 03 RIWKH%%%
ZDVGHWHFWHGDQG03FRORXUPDSVZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\JHQHUDWHG7ZRH[SHUWLVH
UHDGHUVDQDO\VHGHDFKPDSE\GUDZLQJFLUFXODUPPUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWRQ
WKH IRFDO DEQRUPDOLW\7KH PHDQ RI WKHVH UHJLRQV RI LQWHUHVW UHSUHVHQWHG WKH
03RIWKHLQIDUFW 03, DQGRQWKHQRQLVFKDHPLFKHPLVSKHUH 03&FRQWURO 7KH
PRGLÀHG5DQNLQVFRUH P56 WHVWZDVSHUIRUPHG03,DQG03&ZHUHFRPSDUHG
H[DFW:LOFR[RQWHVW 03,WKDWGHYHORSHG+7RQIROORZXS 03+7 ZDVFRPSDUHG
ZLWKDOORIWKHRWKHUV 031R+7 H[DFW0DQQ:KLWQH\WHVW
5HVXOWV)LIW\IRXULQIDUFWV VKRZHGIRFDO03HOHYDWLRQLQWKHUHJLRQRILQIDUFW
&HUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ &%) POJPLQ 03,UDQJHGIURPWR PHDQ
YHUVXV03&RI PHDQ3 6L[LQIDUFWV GHYHORSHG
+7DOORIZKLFKZHUHZLWKLQWKHDUHDVRI03HOHYDWLRQ03+7UDQJHGIURPWR
PHDQ YHUVXV031R+7RI PHDQ3 )RUW\
LQIDUFWV ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKHPEROHFWRP\DQGORFDOUW3$$VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHU
HQFHEHWZHHQ03+7DQG031R+7SHUVLVWHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRORFDOWUHDWPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ3&7KDVDQLQYHUVHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKHP56ZKLOHHOHYDWHG%%%3
ZDVGLUHFWO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHRXWFRPHDQG3&7FDQSUHGLFW+7
&RQFOXVLRQ,Q173WKHÀQDO,&$FDQEHSUHGLFWHGE\FKDQJHVRQ&%9EXWDPRQJ
)73LWYDULHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\(YLGHQWDQGPRGHUDWH&$VHHPWREHDJRRGSURJQRVLV
IDFWRUUHGXFLQJWKH,&$
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
(IIHFWRIUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHRQTXDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRIFHUHEUDO
&7SHUIXVLRQPDSVUHVXOWVIURPDK\EULGGLJLWDOSKDQWRP
5YDQGHQ%RRP07+2HL/-2RVWYHHQ(-6PLW6-/DIHEUH
%YDQ*LQQHNHQ50DQQLHVLQJ03URNRS1LMPHJHQ1/8WUHFKW1/
5YDQGHQ%RRP#UDGXPFQQO
3XUSRVH7RXVHDK\EULGGLJLWDOSKDQWRPWRVWXG\WKHHIIHFWRIP$VRQTXDQWLWDWLYH
HYDOXDWLRQRIFHUHEUDO&7SHUIXVLRQVFDQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDO7KHK\EULGGLJLWDOSKDQWRPFRQVLVWVRIVFDQVRIDKRPR
JHQHRXVVNXOOSKDQWRPRQZKLFKFLUFXODUREMHFWV PP DUHGLJLWDOO\VX
SHULPSRVHG7LVVXHSHUIXVLRQFXUYHVGHULYHGIURPSDWLHQWGDWDZHUHVXSHULPSRVHG
RQWKHEDFNJURXQG ZKLWHPDWWHU DQGRQWKHREMHFWV JUH\PDWWHU :HWHVWHGD
&73VHTXHQFHXVLQJVFDQVHYHU\VRYHUV N9PPWKLFNQHVV GHULYHG
IURPDURZ&7VFDQQHU7KHP$VYDOXHVSHU&73VHTXHQFHZHUHYDULHGSHU
VFDQ P$V $V\QWKHWLFGDWDVHWZLWKRXWQRLVHZDVWKHJROGVWDQGDUG&%)
PDSVIRUHDFKP$VVHWWLQJDQGIRUWKHV\QWKHWLFGDWDVHWZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJWKH
$6,67&7SURJUDP1RLVHLQ&%)PDSVZDVPHDVXUHGLQWKHEDFNJURXQGFRQWUDVW
EHWZHHQEDFNJURXQGDQGREMHFWVZDVPHDVXUHGLQFLUFXODU52,VZLWKDGLDPHWHU
RIKDOIWKHREMHFWGLDPHWHU6L]HDQGGRVHGHSHQGHQFHRIDEVROXWHYDOXHVDQG
&15LQ&%)PDSVZDVFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV$ERYHP$VSHUVFDQWKH&%)YDOXHVIRUWKHPPREMHFWVZHUH
ZLWKLQRIWKHJROGVWDQGDUG$WP$V&%)ZDVRYHUHVWLPDWHGE\!
:LWKVPDOOHUREMHFWVWKHHVWLPDWLRQRI&%)EHFDPHOHVVSUHFLVH&15IRU&%)
LQPPGHFUHDVHGUDSLGO\&15DWP$VZDVDQGGHFUHDVHGWRDW
P$VDQGDWP$V
&RQFOXVLRQ$EVROXWH&%)YDOXHVUHTXLUHVXIÀFLHQWGRVHWREHFRUUHFWYDOXHVDW
ORZGRVHDUHRYHUHVWLPDWHG,QDGGLWLRQ&15UDSLGO\GHFUHDVHVZLWKORZHUGRVH
5RRP'
&KHVW
66
,PDJHTXDOLW\DQGGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
0%ULQN1LMPHJHQ1/
035HYHO3DULV)5
%
,PSURYLQJEUHDWKKROGGXULQJPRELOHUDGLRJUDSK\
1+RXVVHLQ'$OD]DZL0)0F(QWHH'XEOLQ,(6\GQH\$8
PDUNPFHQWHH#V\GQH\HGXDX
3XUSRVH7KHGHJUHHRILQÁDWLRQRIWKHOXQJVHHQRQDFKHVW[UD\ &;5 LVGHSHQG
HQWRQZKHQWKHUDGLRJUDSKHUH[SRVHVWKHLPDJHUHFHSWRUGXULQJWKHUHVSLUDWRU\
F\FOH([SRVLQJWKHUDGLRJUDSK\LPDJHUHFHSWRUDWWKHH[DFWSHDNRILQÁDWLRQPD\
EH TXLWH GLIÀFXOW EHFDXVH WKH LQVSLUDWRU\ SDXVH PD\ EH H[FHHGLQJO\ EULHI :H
DLPHGWRWHVWZKHWKHULPDJHVWDNHQZLWKDQGZLWKRXWDQLQFHQWLYHVSLURPHWHUVKRZ
GLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRILPDJHTXDOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVLVDSDLUHGSURVSHFWLYHVLQJOHEOLQGHGVWXG\RI
SDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJDPRELOH&;57KHUDGLRJUDSKVZHUHWDNHQZLWKDQGZLWKRXW
WKHXVHRIWKHLQFHQWLYHVSLURPHWHU ,6 ,PDJHVZHUHVFRUHGXVLQJWKH(XURSHDQ
*XLGHOLQHVRQ4XDOLW\FULWHULDIRUGLDJQRVWLFUDGLRJUDSKLFLPDJHV
5HVXOWV7KH PHDQ SDWLHQWVҋ DJH ZDV \HDUV 6L[W\ LPDJHV ZHUH WDNHQ KDOI
ZLWKWKHXVHRI,6DQGKDOIZLWKRXWWKHXVHRIWKH,63RVWOXQJOREHFWRP\ZDVWKH
PDLQLQGLFDWLRQIRUWKHPRELOH&;56FRULQJWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHVL[WKULEVSLQH
WUDFKHDDQGWKHFDUGLDFERUGHUZDVQRWDIIHFWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\E\WKHXVHRIWKH,6
:KLOHLPSURYHGYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHWHQWKULEWKHYDVFXODUSDWWHUQWKHUHWURFDUGLDF
OXQJDQGWKHFRVWRSKUHQLFDQJOHVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHXVHRIWKH
,6S S S DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\SURYLGHVDQRYHOWHFKQLTXHWRLPSURYHWKHTXDOLW\RIPRELOH
&;5 LPDJHV7KH XVH RI WKH ,6 KDV LPSURYHG WKH LQVSLUDWRU\ GHSWK DQG LPDJH
TXDOLW\ZKHQXVHGLQSDWLHQWVUHTXLULQJLQZDUGPRELOH&;5
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
'LJLWDOFKHVWWRPRV\QWKHVLVLPSDFWRQSDWLHQWPDQDJHPHQW
(4XDLD(%DUDWHOOD$/RUXVVR)&DVDJUDQGH98OFLJUDL0&RYD
7ULHVWH,7 TXDLD#XQLWVLW
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH FOLQLFDO LPSDFW RI GLJLWDO WRPRV\QWKHVLV '76 LQ WKH
PDQDJHPHQWRISDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGSXOPRQDU\OHVLRQVRQFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKLF
H[DPLQDWLRQ &5(
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KUHHKXQGUHGDQGWKLUW\QLQHSDWLHQWV PDOHV
IHPDOHVDJH\HDUV ZLWKVXVSHFWHGSXOPRQDU\OHVLRQ V RQ&5(XQ
GHUZHQW'767ZRUHDGHUV H[SHULHQFHDQG\HDUV SURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHG
&5(DQG'76LPDJHVDQGSURSRVHGDGLDJQRVLVDFFRUGLQJWRDFRQÀGHQFHVFRUH
RU GHÀQLWHRUSUREDEOHEHQLJQSXOPRQDU\RUH[WUDSXOPRQDU\OHVLRQRUSXOPR
QDU\SVHXGROHVLRQGHVHUYLQJQRIXUWKHUGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXS LQGHWHUPLQDWHRU
SUREDEOHRUGHÀQLWHSXOPRQDU\OHVLRQGHVHUYLQJIXUWKHUGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXSE\&7
0HDQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWLPHDQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHZHUHPHDVXUHGERWKIRU&5(DQG'76
5HVXOWV)LQDOGLDJQRVHVLQFOXGHGSXOPRQDU\DQGSOHXUDOOHVLRQVLQ
SDWLHQWVDQGSXOPRQDU\SVHXGROHVLRQVLQWKHUHPDLQLQJSDWLHQWV'76
UHVROYHGWKH&5(GRXEWIXOÀQGLQJZLWKRXWUHTXLULQJIXUWKHUGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXSLQ
SDWLHQWV ZKLOH SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW FKHVW &77KH
PHDQLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWLPHIRU'76 PHDQ6'VHFV ZDVKLJKHU 3
:LOFR[RQWHVW WKDQIRU&5( VHFV 0HDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVP6Y
UDQJHP6Y IRU&5(DQGP6Y UDQJHP6Y IRU'76
&RQFOXVLRQ'76DYRLGHGWKHQHHGIRUFKHVW&7LQDERXWWKUHHIRXUWKRISDWLHQWV
ZLWKVXVSHFWHGSXOPRQDU\OHVLRQVRQ&5(ZLWKDVOLJKWLQFUHDVHLQWKHLQWHUSUHWD
WLRQWLPHDQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHFRPSDUHGWR&5(
%
8OWUDORZGRVH&7IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIWKHPRVW
FRPPRQ&7SDWWHUQVRISXOPRQDU\GLVHDVH
$&KULVWH-&KDULPR7RUUHQWH39RFN-(5RRV%HUQH&+
:LQWHUWKXU&+ DQGUHDVFKULVWH#LQVHOFK
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHDFFXUDF\RIXOWUDORZGRVH&7IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQDQGFKDU
DFWHULVDWLRQRIWKHPRVWFRPPRQ&7SDWWHUQVRISXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHFRPSDUHGWR
PLGGOHGRVH&7VFDQVRIWKHFKHVW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7HQSDWLHQWVZLWKSXOPRQDU\LQIHFWLRQVZLWKLQWHUVWLWLDO
OXQJGLVHDVHVDQGZLWKOXQJQRGXOHVZHUHVFDQQHGDFFRUGLQJWRDQXOWUDORZ
GRVH [PPUHIHUHQFHP$VN9S DQGDPLGGOHGRVH UHIHUHQFH
P$VN9S FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGFKHVW&7SURWRFRO ;HQHWL[ 7ZRUDGLRORJLVWV
ZLWKDQG\HDUVRIWKRUDFLFLPDJLQJH[SHULHQFHVHDUFKHGLQGLYLGXDOO\ERWKGRVH
LPDJHVIRUWKHPRVWFRPPRQ&7SDWWHUQVFRQVLVWLQJRIGLIIHUHQWVXEJURXSVRI
JURXQGJODVVRSDFLWLHVQRGXOHVLQWHUVWLWLDODQGDLUVSDFHGLVHDVHV7KHVWDQGDUG
RIUHIHUHQFHZDVHVWDEOLVKHGE\WZRGLIIHUHQWH[SHUWUDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXV
5HVXOWV 7KH OXQJ VHJPHQWV VKRZHG QRGXOHV JURXQG JODVV
RSDFLWLHVDLUVSDFHDQGLQWHUVWLWLDOGLVHDVHVDQGQRUPDOVHJPHQWV%RWK
UHDGHUVҋ VHQVLWLYLWLHV VSHFLÀFLWLHV DQG DFFXUDFLHV RI XOWUDORZGRVH &7 GLG QRW
GURSVLJQLÀFDQWO\ 0F1HPDU IRURIWKHSDWWHUQV7KHVHQVLWLYLW\RIRQO\RQH
UHDGHUGURSSHGIRUVPDOOJURXQGJODVVQRGXOHV PP IURPWR SYDOXH
DQGVHQVLWLYLW\IRUDOOLQWHUVWLWLDOOXQJGLVHDVHVWRJHWKHUZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
ORZHUIRUERWKUHDGHUVZLWKDQDYHUDJHORVVRIVHQVLWLYLW\RIIURPWR
5HDGHU DQGIURPWR 5HDGHU UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ([FHSWIRUVPDOOJURXQGJODVVQRGXOHVDQGLQWHUVWLWLDOOXQJGLVHDVH
WKHSDWWHUQGHWHFWDELOLW\LVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSDLUHGDWXOWUDORZGRVH&7,WLVDS
SOLFDEOHIRUOXQJQRGXOHRUFRQVROLGDWLRQIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQV
%
,PSDFWRIWKJHQHUDWLRQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHRQLPDJH
TXDOLW\LQXOWUDORZGRVHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\RIWKHOXQJV
$/DTPDQL)+HQHV-+%XKN+&YRQ6FKXOW]HQGRUII'+DPPHUOH
+1DJHO*$GDP05HJLHU+DPEXUJ'( D]LHQODTPDQL#JP[GH
3XUSRVH7RLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHDQGHYDOXDWHWKHLQÁXHQFHRIWKHWKJHQ
HUDWLRQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ,5 WHFKQLTXHL'RVHRQXOWUDORZGRVH0'&7
RIWKHOXQJVZLWKUHJDUGWRDQDWRPLFDOGHOLQHDWLRQOHVLRQFRQVSLFXLW\DQGDUWHIDFW
UHGXFWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q LPPXQRFRPSURPLVHG SDWLHQWV ZLWK VXVSHFWHG
SXOPRQDU\ LQIHFWLRQ WKH UDZ GDWD RI XQHQKDQFHG 0'&7 VFDQV N9 PHDQ
&7',YROP*\PHDQ'/3P*\;FP ZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJDSURWR
W\SLFUHFRQVWUXFWLRQSURFHVVRUIHDWXULQJL'RVH 3KLOLSV%HVWWKH1HWKHUODQGV
L'RVHOHYHOVHWWLQJVYDULHGEHWZHHQDQG,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG
ZLWKDVOLFHWKLFNQHVVRIPP7KUHHUDGLRORJLVWVEOLQGHGWRWKHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
WHFKQLTXHLQGHSHQGHQWO\SHUIRUPHGLPDJHDQDO\VLV$SRLQWJUDGLQJVFDOHZDV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DSSOLHGUHJDUGLQJWKHGHSLFWLRQRIDQDWRPLFDOGHWDLOVDQGWKHGHJUHHRIDUWHIDFWV
REVHUYHG ZRUVWH[FHOOHQW 7KHVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 ZDVDVVHVVHG
IRUHDFKGDWDVHW6WDWLVWLFDOHYDOXDWLRQLQFOXGHGNDSSDDQDO\VLVDQG:LOFR[RQWHVW
5HVXOWV %HVW LPDJH TXDOLW\ ZDV DVVHVVHG ZLWK L'RVH OHYHO &RPSDUHG WR
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQWKHKLJKL'RVHOHYHORILPSURYHGWKHFRQVSLFXLW\RI
VXEWOHLQÀOWUDWLRQVJURXQGJODVVRSDFLWLHVDQGPRVDLFSHUIXVLRQ(YHQDWWKHORZHU
L'RVHOHYHORILPDJHUDWLQJVVFRUHGVXSHULRUWRÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ:LWK
LQFUHDVLQJL'RVHOHYHOVUHGXFWLRQRIVWUHDNDUWHIDFWVZDVVXFFHVVIXOO\TXDQWL
ÀHGE\DGHFUHDVHRIWKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQDWFRQVWDQWPHDQDWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHV
&RQFOXVLRQ,WHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVREWDLQHGLQXOWUDORZGRVH0'&7VXEVWDQ
WLDOO\ LPSURYH LPDJH TXDOLW\ FRQVSLFXLW\ RI VXEWOH OHVLRQV DQG GHFUHDVH LPDJH
QRLVHHYHQDWORZHUL'RVH70OHYHOV7KXVWKHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIWKLVWHFKQLTXH
LQWRFOLQLFDOURXWLQHLPDJLQJVHHPVWREHGHVLUDEOHHJIRULPPXQRFRPSURPLVHG
SDWLHQWVLQZKRPWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIVXEWOHFKDQJHVFDQEHFUXFLDO
%
8SJUDGLQJWRDGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6,5 LQ
URZFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7 RIWKHFKHVWGHWDLOHGDQDO\VLV
RIWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIGLIIHUHQW$6,5PRGHVDQGOHYHOVE\LQWUD
LQGLYLGXDOFRPSDULVRQRIGRVHUHGXFHG$6,5VFDQVWRIXOOGRVH
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQVHULHV
6:LUWK/0LFKDHO'0D[LHQ='HDN06FKHUU8/LQVHQPDLHU05HLVHU
0.|UQHU0XQLFK'( VWHIDQZLUWK#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
%
,QWUDLQGLYLGXDOFRPSDULVRQRILPDJHTXDOLW\XVLQJUHWURVSHFWLYHDQG
SURVSHFWLYHUHVSLUDWRU\JDWLQJIRUWKHDFTXLVLWLRQRIWKLQVOLFHG'
0'&7RIWKHWKRUD[
05HJLHU)2+HQHV'6FKZDU]0*URWK*5LHVHQEHUJ*$GDP
3*&%HJHPDQQ+DPEXUJ'('VVHOGRUI'( PUHJLHU#XNHGH
3XUSRVH7RLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGDQDWRPLFDOGHSLFWLRQRI
WKHOXQJDQGPHGLDVWLQXPXVLQJUHWURVSHFWLYHDVZHOODVSURVSHFWLYHUHVSLUDWRU\
JDWLQJIRUWKHDFTXLVLWLRQRI'0'&7LQDSRUFLQHPRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LYHWUDFKHDO\LQWXEDWHGSLJVXQGHUZHQWURZ0'&7
RIWKHWKRUD[)RUUHWURVSHFWLYHDQGSURVSHFWLYHJDWLQJWKHIUHTXHQF\RIWKHUHV
SLUDWRUZDVDGMXVWHGWRDQGUHVSLUDWRU\F\FOHVPLQ7KHWDEOHVSHHG
YDULHGEHWZHHQDQGPPVHF)UHHEUHDWKLQJVFDQVRIWKHOXQJVZHUH
SHUIRUPHGZLWKWKHVDPHUHVSLUDWRU\IUHTXHQFLHV$IWHUUHVSLUDWRU\FXWRIIDQDG
GLWLRQDOVFDQLQEUHDWKKROGWHFKQLTXHZDVDFTXLUHGZKLFKVHUYHGDVWKHUHIHUHQFH
7KUHHUHYLHZHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DQDO\VHGWKH&7GDWDDSSO\LQJDSRLQWJUDGLQJ
VFDOHUHJDUGLQJWKHGHJUHHRIDUWHIDFWVREVHUYHGDQGWKHDQDWRPLFDOGHSLFWLRQ
H[FHOOHQWQRQGLDJQRVWLF &RPSDULVRQRIGLIIHUHQWWHFKQLTXHVZDVSHUIRUPHG
XVLQJ:LOFR[RQPDWFKHGSDLUHGWHVW
5HVXOWV%UHDWKKROGLPDJLQJDOORZHGIRUWKHKLJKHVWLPDJHTXDOLW\ PHDQYDOXHV
WUDFKHDEURQFKLOXQJSDUHQFK\PDGLDSKUDJPSHULFDUGLXP
5HWURVSHFWLYHJDWLQJSURYHGWREHRIVXSHULRULPDJHTXDOLW\FRPSDUHGWR
SURVSHFWLYHJDWLQJIRUDOOUHVSLUDWRU\IUHTXHQFLHV S! :LWKWKHUHVSLUDWRU\
IUHTXHQF\ VHW WR PLQ DQG D WDEOH VSHHG RI PPVHF UHWURVSHFWLYH JDWLQJ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
$GDSWLYHLWHUDWLYHGRVHUHGXFWLRQXVLQJWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDO
SURFHVVLQJ $,'5' IRUUHGXFHGDQGORZGRVH&7H[DPLQDWLRQ
FRPSDULVRQZLWKVWDQGDUGGRVH&7RILPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLRORJLFDO
ÀQGLQJDVVHVVPHQWIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKYDULRXVSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHV
<2KQR01LVKLR+.R\DPD'7DNHQDND7<RVKLNDZD60DWVXPRWR
16XJLKDUD+,QRNDZD.6XJLPXUD.REH-32KWDZDUD-3
\RVLUDG#NREHXDFMS
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHLPDJHQRLVHUHGXFWLRQFDSDELOLWLHVDQGUDGLRORJLFDOÀQG
LQJVDVVHVVPHQWVIRUUHGXFHGDQGORZGRVHFKHVW&7ZLWKRXWDQGZLWKDGDSWLYH
LWHUDWLYHGRVHUHGXFWLRQXVLQJWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOSURFHVVLQJ $,'5' ZLWKWKRVH
IRUVWDQGDUGGRVH&7IRUSDWLHQWVZLWKYDULRXVSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&KHVW&7H[DPLQDWLRQVZLWKWKUHHGLIIHUHQWWXEHFXUUHQWV
DQGXVLQJDQGGHWHFWRUURZ&7ZHUHDGPLQLVWHUHGWRSDWLHQWVP$V
VWDQGDUGGRVH GDWD ZDV UHFRQVWUXFWHG DV WKLQVHFWLRQ &7 ZLWKRXW$,'5 '
DQG&7GDWDDWP$V ORZGRVH DQGP$V UHGXFHGGRVH DVWKLQVHFWLRQ
&7ZLWKRXWDQGZLWK$,'5'7RFRPSDUHLPDJHTXDOLW\LPDJHQRLVHRIDOO&7V
ZDVTXDQWLWDWLYHO\DVVHVVHGE\PHDQVRI52,PHDVXUHPHQWV)RUFRPSDULVRQRI
UDGLRORJLFDOÀQGLQJDVVHVVPHQWVSUREDELOLWLHVRIHPSK\VHPDJURXQGJODVVRSDF
LW\UHWLFXODURSDFLW\EURQFKLHFWDVLVKRQH\FRPEDQGQRGXOHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGRQD
SRLQWVFDOH7KHQLPDJHQRLVHDQGDJUHHPHQWVRIUDGLRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVEHWZHHQ
VWDQGDUGGRVH&7DQGRWKHUVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\HYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV,PDJHTXDOLWLHVRIUHGXFHGDQGORZGRVH&7VZLWKRXW$,'5'ZHUH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQWKDWRIRWKHUV S $OOLQWUDPHWKRGDJUHHPHQWVIRU
HPSK\VHPD**2EURQFKLHFWDVLVKRQH\FRPESDWWHUQDQGQRGXOHVH[FHSWIRU
WKRVHREVHUYHGRQORZGRVH&7ZLWKRXW$,'5'ZHUHDOPRVWSHUIHFW ѣ!
$JUHHPHQWV IRU UHWLFXODU RSDFLW\ RI UHGXFHGGRVH &7 ZHUH DOVR DOPRVW SHUIHFW
ZKLOHWKHUHVSHFWLYHDJUHHPHQWVRIORZGRVH&7ZLWKRXWDQGZLWK$,'5'ZHUH
PRGHUDWH ѣ DQGVXEVWDQWLDO ѣ
&RQFOXVLRQ$,'5'LVXVHIXOIRULPDJHQRLVHUHGXFWLRQDQGUDGLRORJLFDOÀQGLQJ
DVVHVVPHQWVREWDLQHGZLWKUHGXFHGDQGORZGRVH&7VIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKYDULRXV
SXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHV
%
0RGHOEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHIRUUDGLDWLRQGRVH
UHGXFWLRQLQFKHVW&7
0.DWVXUD,0DWVXGD0$NDKDQH-6DWR+$NDL$.XQLPDWVX.<DVDND
.2KWRPR7RN\R-3
3XUSRVH7RLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHLPDJHTXDOLW\FKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIORZGRVH
FKHVW &7 UHFRQVWUXFWHG ZLWK PRGHOEDVHG LWHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 0%,5 DQG
DGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6,5 DQGVWDQGDUGGRVH&7UHFRQ
VWUXFWHGZLWK$6,5
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q WKLV SURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ SDWLHQWV PDOHIHPDOH
DJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQWXQHQKDQFHGFKHVW&7VFDQDWVWDQGDUG
GRVHDQGORZGRVHZLWKDURZPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7VFDQQHUZKLFKLQYROYHGWKH
XVHRIDXWRPDWLFWXEHFXUUHQWPRGXODWLRQZLWKÀ[HGQRLVHLQGH[HV RI
PPIRUVWDQGDUGGRVHORZGRVH&7 ,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGEOHQGLQJRI
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQDQG$6,5LPDJHGDWD $6,5 IRUVWDQGDUGGRVH
DQGDW$6,5DQG0%,5IRUORZGRVH&77ZRUDGLRORJLVWVDVVHVVHGWKHLPDJHV
LQDEOLQGHGDQGUDQGRPLVHGPDQQHUIRUVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHQRLVHDUWHIDFWVFULWLFDO
UHSURGXFWLRQRIYLVXDOO\VKDUSFKHVWVWUXFWXUHVDQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFHSWDELOLW\2EMHF
WLYHLPDJHQRLVHZDVPHDVXUHGLQWKHOXQJSDUHQFK\PD'DWDZHUHDQDO\VHGE\
XVLQJWKHVLJQWHVWDQGWKHSDLUZLVHGVWXGHQWWWHVW
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVDGHFUHDVHIRUGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFWZLWKORZGRVH&7
FRPSDUHGWRVWDQGDUGGRVH&7/RZGRVH0%,5LPDJHVKDGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHU
REMHFWLYHLPDJHQRLVHLQWKHOXQJSDUHQFK\PD FRPSDUHGZLWKORZ
GRVH$6,5 3 DQGVWDQGDUGGRVH$6,5LPDJHV
3 'LDJQRVWLFDFFHSWDEOHLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGZLWKDOOORZGRVH0%,5
LPDJHV DOWKRXJK WKH\ WHQGHG WR KDYH PRWLRQ DUWHIDFWV DQG SL[LODWHG EORWFK\
DSSHDUDQFHV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QFKHVW&7LPDJHVDFTXLUHGZLWKQHDUO\UDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
0%,5VLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHVLPDJHTXDOLW\FRPSDUHGWR$6,5DQGSURYLGHVGLDJ
QRVWLF DFFHSWDEOH LPDJHV KRZHYHU LPDJH TXDOLWLHV RI ORZGRVH 0%,5 DUH QRW
FRPSOHWHO\HTXLYDOHQWWRWKRVHRIVWDQGDUGGRVH$6,5
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHLPDJHTXDOLW\LQGRVHUHGXFHGURZ&7RIWKHFKHVWDW
GLIIHUHQWOHYHOVRIDGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6,5 WRIXOOGRVH
EDVHOLQHH[DPLQDWLRQVUHFRQVWUXFWHGVROHO\ZLWKÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 LQ
DUHDOLVWLFXSJUDGHVFHQDULR
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$ZDLYHURIFRQVHQWZDVJUDQWHGE\WKH,5%%DVHOLQH
H[DPLQDWLRQV RI WKH FKHVW QRLVH LQGH[ 1, /LJKW6SHHG 9&7 ;7 *( ZHUH
LQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHGWRIROORZXSVWXGLHVRQD&7ZLWK$6,5RSWLRQ 1,
RWKHUVFDQYDULDEOHVFRQVWDQWDQGDVSURYLGHGE\WKHYHQGRU'LVFRYHU\+'
*( Q )RUWKLVLPDJHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGLQ$6,5VOLFHDQGYROXPHPRGHZLWK
$6,5EOHQGLQJVRIWRLQVWDQGDUGDQGOXQJNHUQHO7KUHHH[SHULHQFHG
UDGLRORJLVWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\FRPSDUHGLPDJHTXDOLW\RIWKHVHVHULHVWRWKHFRU
UHVSRQGLQJIXOOGRVHEDVHOLQHH[DPLQDWLRQV GLDJQRVWLFDOO\LQIHULRULQIHULRU
HTXDOVXSHULRUGLDJQRVWLFDOO\VXSHULRU 6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVXVHGWKH:LO
FR[RQWKH0DQQ:KLWQH\8WHVWDQGWKHLQWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW ,&&
5HVXOWV:LWKVWDQGDUGNHUQHOLPDJHTXDOLW\LQGRVHUHGXFHGVWXGLHVZDVFRPSDUD
EOHWRWKHEDVHOLQHDW$6,5LQYROXPHPRGH S 9ROXPHPRGH
ZDVVXSHULRUWRVOLFHPRGH VLJQLÀFDQWIRU$6,5S )RUOXQJNHUQHO
HYHU\$6,5OHYHORXWSHUIRUPHGWKHEDVHOLQHLPDJHTXDOLW\ S ZLWK$6,5
UDWHGEHVW VOLFHYROXPH 0HDQ&7',YROGHFUHDVHGIURP
)%3EDVHOLQH WRP*\ $6,5IROORZXSS ,&&ZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ9HQGRUVUHFRPPHQGDWLRQRI$6,5LVIDLU%XWIRUVWDQGDUG
NHUQHO$6,5LQYROXPHPRGHDQGIRUOXQJNHUQHO$6,5SHUIRUPHGEHVW
DOORZLQJIRUGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
HYHQHQDEOHGWKHVDPHLPDJHTXDOLW\DVEUHDWKKROGLPDJLQJ3HUIRUPLQJLPDJH
DFTXLVLWLRQ GXULQJ IUHH EUHDWKLQJ OHDG WR D PLQRU LPDJH TXDOLW\ FRPSDUHG WR DOO
RWKHUWHFKQLTXHVDSSOLHG
&RQFOXVLRQ,QDQH[SHULPHQWDOVHWWLQJUHWURVSHFWLYHJDWLQJLVVXSHULRUWRSURVSHF
WLYHJDWLQJDQGFDQHYHQEHRIHTXLYDOHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\DVVWDQGDUGEUHDWKKROG
LPDJLQJZKHQVHWWRORZHUUHVSLUDWRU\IUHTXHQFLHVDQGWDEOHVSHHG
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&DQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQUHVWRUHLPDJHTXDOLW\DWGRVH
UHGXFWLRQ"&OLQLFDOH[SHULHQFHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVLPXOWDQHRXV
DYDLODELOLW\RIORZGRVHDQGVWDQGDUGGRVHLPDJHVIURPGXDOVRXUFH
GDWDVHWV
)3RQWDQD'0RXUHDX-%)DLYUH7)ORKU05pP\-DUGLQ-5HP\
/LOOH)5 IUDQFRLVSRQWDQD#FKUXOLOOHIU
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH LPDJH TXDOLW\ RI ORZGRVH LPDJHV UHFRQVWUXFWHG ZLWK D
UDZGDWDEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXH 6$),5( ZLWKVWDQGDUGGRVH
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 &7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHGXDOVRXUFHFKHVW&7GDWDVHWVDFTXLUHG
LQ WKH FRQGLWLRQV RI URXWLQH FOLQLFDO SUDFWLFH N9S P$V ZLWK D ERWK
WXEHVVHWDWVLPLODUHQHUJ\ E WKHWRWDOUHIHUHQFHP$VVSOLWXSLQDZD\WKDW
RIWKHUHIHUHQFHP$VZDVDSSOLHGWRWXEH$ LHP$V F ZKLOHRIWKH
UHIHUHQFHP$VZDVDSSOLHGWRWXEH% LHP$V 7ZRVHULHVRILPDJHVZHUH
JHQHUDWHG D IXOOGRVHLPDJHV JHQHUDWHGIURPERWKV\VWHPV UHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWK
)%3 JURXS DQG E ORZGRVHLPDJHV JHQHUDWHGIURPWXEH$ UHFRQVWUXFWHG
ZLWK6$),5( JURXS
5HVXOWV2QJURXSLPDJHVWKHUHZDV D DVLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQLQWKHREMHFWLYH
LPDJHQRLVHPHDVXUHGDWWKHOHYHORIWKHWUDFKHDRQPHGLDVWLQDO YV
S DQGOXQJLPDJHV YV S
E DVLPLODUYLVXDOSHUFHSWLRQRIQRLVHRQPHGLDVWLQDO S DQGOXQJLPDJHV S
PDLQO\UDWHGDVPLQLPDODQG G DVLPLODURYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\UDWHGDVH[FHOOHQW
LQ RIH[DPLQDWLRQVZLWKRXWORVVRIGLDJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQDVDVVHVVHG
E\WKHFRPSDUDWLYHDQDO\VLVRILQGLYLGXDO&7IHDWXUHVRIOXQJLQÀOWUDWLRQ
&, >@
&RQFOXVLRQ 'HVSLWH GRVH UHGXFWLRQ WKH UDZGDWDEDVHG LWHUDWLYH UHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHDOORZHGEHWWHUREMHFWLYHDQGVLPLODUVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\
RIORZGRVHLPDJHVFRPSDUHGWRIXOOGRVH)%3LPDJHV
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIGRVHUHGXFWLRQDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\LQFKHVW&7VXVLQJ
DGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQZLWKWKHVDPHJURXSRI
SDWLHQWV
/4L/7DQJ;3=KDQJ</L</L%HLMLQJ&1 WDQJOHL#EMFDQFHURUJ
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHRIFKHVW&7LPDJHV
UHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWKDEOHQGRIDGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6,5
DQGÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 ZLWKLPDJHVJHQHUDWHGXVLQJFRQYHQWLRQDO)%3
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVZLWKFKHVW&7UHH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHDOWHUQDWHO\
DVVLJQHG WR WZR VFDQQHUV ZLWK GLIIHUHQW UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ WHFKQLTXHV 7KH VWXG\
JURXSVLQFOXGHGQRLVHLQGH[ 1, ZLWK$6,5 $ 1,ZLWK$6,5
$ 1,ZLWK$6,5 $ DQG1,ZLWK$6,5 $ VHTXHQWLDOO\
FKDQJHGHYHU\WZRPRQWKV7KHFRQWUROLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJ)%3DQG1,
$OODFTXLVLWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKDXWRPDWLFGRVHPRGXODWLRQ3DLUHGWDQG
QRQSDUDPHWHUVWHVWVZHUHDSSOLHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLIIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV7KHUDGLDWLRQGRVHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVXVHG
$6,5 S 7KHPHDQGRVHUHGXFWLRQUDWHIRUHDFKJURXS $ ZDV
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHLPDJHTXDOLW\RIJURXSV$$ZDV
QRWLQIHULRUWRWKRVHRIWKHFRQWUROH[DPLQDWLRQV7KHLPDJHQRLVHRIJURXS$ZDV
JUHDWHUDQGVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVLQIHULRUWRWKDWRIWKHFRQWURO
&RQFOXVLRQ$6,5HQDEOHGWKHXVHRIDKLJKHU1,ZLWKDXWRPDWLFGRVHPRGXODWLRQ
:LWK$6,5DQGD1,RIWKHHIIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHZDVUHGXFHGE\
ZLWKRXWFRPSURPLVLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
+HSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDHQGRYDVFXODU
0RGHUDWRUV
*$QWRFK'VVHOGRUI'(
5*ROÀHUL%RORJQD,7
%
3UHGLFWLYHIDFWRUVRIGRZQVWDJLQJRIKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&&
EH\RQGWKH0LODQFULWHULDWUHDWHGZLWKLQWUDDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ
9%RYD/0DUX]]HOOL50LUDJOLD*%9L]]LQL)7X]]ROLQR$/XFD
3DOHUPR,7 YDOHQWLQDERYD#LQZLQGLW
3XUSRVH7KHSUHVHQWVWXG\ZDVXQGHUWDNHQWRUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHWKHORQJ
WHUPFOLQLFDOUHVXOWVLQSDWLHQWVVXLWDEOHIRUOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQZKRXQGHUZHQW
WUDQVDUWHULDO FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( ZLWK KHSDWRFHOOXODU FDUFLQRPD +&&
ZKR H[FHHGHG WKH 0LODQ FULWHULD WR GHWHUPLQH SUHGLFWLYH IDFWRUV RI VXFFHVVIXO
GRZQVWDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG'HFHPEHUFRQ
VHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWK+&&ZHUHWUHDWHGE\UHSHDWHGO\SHUIRUPHG7$&(RIWKHP
H[FHHGLQJWKH0LODQFULWHULD3DWLHQWVZLWKLQÀOWUDWLYH+&&K\SRYDVFXODU+&&SRUWDO
YHLQWKURPERVLVZHUHH[FOXGHGZLWKDÀQDOVWXG\SRSXODWLRQRISDWLHQWV7XPRXU
UHVSRQVHWR7$&(ZDVHYDOXDWHGDWPRQWKZLWK&705DFFRUGLQJWRDPHQGHG
5HVSRQVH(YDOXDWLRQ&ULWHULDLQ6ROLG7XPRXUV 5(&,67 JXLGHOLQHV6XFFHVVIXO
GRZQVWDJLQJZDVGHÀQHGDVDUHGXFWLRQLQWKHQXPEHUDQGVL]HRIYLDEOHWXPRXUV
WRZLWKLQWKH0LODQFULWHULDDQG$)3QJPOIRUDWOHDVWPRQWKV
5HVXOWV$IWHU7$&(SDWLHQWV KDGWKHLUWXPRXUVVXFFHVVIXOO\GRZQVWDJHG
SDWLHQWV GLGQRW1RLQWHUJURXSGLIIHUHQFHVH[LVWHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRSDWLHQW
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVRUW\SHVDQGQXPEHURIWUHDWPHQWV+RZHYHUDWPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\
VLVDOSKDIHWRSURWHLQOHYHOVQJPODQG\HDUV0HWURWLFNHWZHUHVLJQLÀFDQW
LQGHSHQGHQWSURJQRVWLFYDULDEOHVRIVXFFHVVIXOGRZQVWDJLQJ SS
UHVSHFWLYHO\ .DSODQ 0H\HU SDWLHQW VXUYLYDO UDWH ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU LQ WKH
GRZQVWDJHGJURXSWKDQLQWKHQRWGRZQVWDJHGJURXS S
&RQFOXVLRQ,QSDWLHQWVZLWK+&&EH\RQGWKH0LODQFULWHULDELRORJLFDOFKDUDF
WHULVWLFVRIWKHWXPRXUPD\SUHGLFWDJRRGUHVSRQVHWRGRZQVWDJHDIWHU7$&(
%
%DOORRQRFFOXGHGSHUFXWDQHRXVUDGLRIUHTXHQF\WKHUPDODEODWLRQ
5)$ SOXVWUDQVFDWKHWHUDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( D
QHZFRPELQHGVLQJOHVWHSWKHUDS\IRUWUHDWPHQWRIVLQJOHODUJH
KHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD
01HVWROD5,H]]L06DQWRUR5'DWWHVL0/D7RUUH/%RQRPR5RPH,7
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\DQGVDIHW\RIFRPELQHGVLQJOHVWHSWKHUDS\
ZLWKEDOORRQRFFOXGHG5)$IROORZHGE\VXSHUVHOHFWLYH7$&(LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVLQJOH
XQUHVHFWDEOHKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDODUJHUWKDQFP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKVLQJOHXQUHVHFWDEOHODUJH
+&& PHDQGLDPHWHUFPUDQJHFP QRWVXLWDEOHWRWKHUPDO
DEODWLRQDORQHIRUVL]HDQGVLWHRIWKHOHVLRQZHUHHQUROOHGLQRXUVLQJOHFHQWUH
PXOWLGLVFLSOLQDU\SLORWVWXG\7KHVFKHGXOHRIWUHDWPHQWFRQVLVWHGRISHUFXWDQHRXV
5)$ VLQJOHFPPRQRSRODUQHHGOHLQVHUWLRQ RIWKHWDUJHWOHVLRQGXULQJRFFOXVLRQ
RIWKHKHSDWLFDUWHU\VXSSO\LQJWKHWXPRXUIROORZHGE\VXSHUVHOHFWLYH7$&(ZLWK
HSLUXELFLQ )DUPRUXELFLQPJ3RZGHU ORDGHG'&%HDG PLFURQ $G
YHUVHHYHQWVDVZHOODVLQWUDSHULSURFHGXUDOFRPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHFOLQLFDOO\DVVHVVHG
(DUO\ORFDOHIÀFDF\LQWDUJHWOHVLRQVLQWHUPVRISHUVLVWHQFHRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQW
DQGSUHVHQFHRIQHFURWLFGLDPHWHUZDVHYDOXDWHGRQPRQWKIROORZXSPXOWLSKDVLF
&7EDVLQJRQP5(&,67FULWHULD
5HVXOWV7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVZDVDFKLHYHGLQDOOSDWLHQWV1RPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQV
RFFXUUHG2YHUDOOWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVGHÀQHGDVFRPSOHWHGHYDVFXODULVDWLRQGXULQJ
WKHDUWHULDOSKDVHRIWKHWDUJHWOHVLRQZDVDFKLHYHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDUWLDO
UHVSRQVH SHUVLVWHQFHRIYLWDOWLVVXHOHVVWKDQ ZLWKDQRQHQKDQFLQJDUHD
FRUUHVSRQGLQJLQVKDSHWRWKHSUHYLRXVO\LGHQWLÀHG+&& PHDQQHFURWLFGLDPHWHU
FPUDQJHFP
&RQFOXVLRQ%DOORRQRFFOXGHG5)$SOXV7$&(VHHPVWREHDVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYH
FRPELQHGWKHUDS\IRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRIDGYDQFHGXQUHVHFWDEOHVLQJOHODUJH+&&
DOORZLQJWRREWDLQDKLJKFRPSOHWHORFDOUHVSRQVHUDWHDOVRLQSDWLHQWVQRWVXLWDEOH
WRWKHUPDODEODWLRQDORQH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
/RQJWHUPUHFXUUHQFHUDWHVRI+&&WUHDWHGZLWKGR[RUXELFLQHOXWLQJ
'&EHDG
(%RXPD$3RPRQL$&KDURNRSDNLV(.DUDJLDQQLV+0RVFKRXULV
03RPRQL/7KDQRV.0DODJDUL'.HOHNLV$WKHQV*5
3XUSRVH7KHREMHFWLYHZDVWRUHSRUWRQWKHORQJWHUPUHFXUUHQFHVRI+&&WKDW
SUHVHQWHG FRPSOHWH UHVSRQVH DIWHU WUHDWPHQW ZLWK VFKHGXOHG VHVVLRQV RI
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWKGR[RUXELFLQORDGHG'&EHDG
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV QRW VXLWDEOH IRU FXUDEOH WUHDWPHQWV WKDW
KDGEHHQWUHDWHGZLWK'&EHDGORDGHGZLWKGR[RUXELFLQDQGDFKLHYHGFRPSOHWH
UHVSRQVHZHUHLQFOXGHG'R[RUXELFLQORDGLQJZDVGRQHDWPJPORIUHFRQVWL
WXWHGEHDGV&KLOG3XJKFODVVZDV$% 2NXGDVWDJHZDV
5HVXOWV/RFDOUHFXUUHQFHVDQGQHZOHVLRQVFRQVLGHUHGDVUHFXUUHQWGLVHDVHZHUH
VHSDUDWHO\UHFRUGHG5HFXUUHQFHUDWHVZHUHQHZOHVLRQVLQ&KLOG$SDWLHQWVZLWK
GRPLQDQWOHVLRQFPRFFXUUHGLQZLWKGRPLQDQWOHVLRQ!FP
RFFXUUHGLQGXULQJVWUGWK\HDUUHVSHFWLYHO\/RFDOOHVLRQVLQ
&KLOG$SDWLHQWVZLWKGRPLQDQWOHVLRQFPRFFXUUHGLQZLWK
GRPLQDQWOHVLRQ!FPRFFXUUHGLQGXULQJVWUGWK\HDU
UHVSHFWLYHO\1HZOHVLRQVLQ&KLOG$SDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLQRGXODUOHVLRQVRFFXUUHGLQ
GXULQJVWDQGQG\HDUUHVSHFWLYHO\/RFDOOHVLRQVLQ&KLOG$SD
WLHQWVZLWKPXOWLQRGXODUOHVLRQVRFFXUUHGLQGXULQJVWDQGQG\HDU
UHVSHFWLYHO\1HZOHVLRQVLQ&KLOG%SDWLHQWVZLWKGRPLQDQWOHVLRQFPRFFXUUHGLQ
ZLWKGRPLQDQWOHVLRQ!FPRFFXUUHGLQGXULQJ
VWUGWK\HDUUHVSHFWLYHO\/RFDOOHVLRQVLQ&KLOG%SDWLHQWVZLWKGRPLQDQWOHVLRQ
FPRFFXUUHGLQZLWKGRPLQDQWOHVLRQ!FPRFFXUUHGLQ
GXULQJVWUGWK\HDUUHVSHFWLYHO\2YHUDOOVXUYLYDODW\U
\U\U\UDQG\UVZDVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ '(%'2; DFKLHYHV KLJK UDWHV RI \U VXUYLYDO IRU SDWLHQWV WKDW
\LHOGHG &5 DIWHU LQLWLDO VFKHGXOHG WUHDWPHQWV EXW FDQQRW EH FODVVLÀHG DPRQJ
FXUDWLYHWUHDWPHQWV
%
6LQJOHVWHSEDOORRQRFFOXGHGSHUFXWDQHRXVUDGLRIUHTXHQF\WKHUPDO
DEODWLRQ 5)$ SOXVWUDQVFDWKHWHUDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&(
IRUWUHDWPHQWRI´FRPSOH[µXQUHVHFWDEOHKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD
06DQWRUR5,H]]L5'DWWHVL0)OD7RUUH01HVWROD/%RQRPR5RPH,7
GRWWVDQWRURPDUFR#JPDLOFRP
%
5DGLRHPEROLVDWLRQRIKHSDWLFWXPRXUVKHSDWRSXOPRQDU\VKXQW
UHGXFWLRQE\DGPLQLVWUDWLRQRI6RUDIHQLE
-07KH\VRKQ-)6FKODDN-(UWOH60XHOOHU$%RFNLVFK7&/DXHQVWHLQ
(VVHQ'( MHQVWKH\VRKQ#XQLGXLVEXUJHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH$Q HPHUJLQJ WKHUDS\ RSWLRQ IRU XQUHVHFWDEOH OLYHU PDOLJQDQFLHV LV
UDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ 5( XVLQJWKHEHWDHPLWWHU<WWULXP&RQWUDLQGLFDWLRQVKRZ
HYHUPD\UHSUHVHQWKLJKKHSDWRSXOPRQDU\VKXQWIUDFWLRQV LHGXHWRWXPRURXV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
)LYH\HDUVXUYLYDORI+&&SDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKGR[RUXELFLQHOXWLQJ
'&EHDG
(%RXPD$&KDURNRSDNLV+0RVFKRXULV$3RPRQL.0DODJDUL
-.RUQH]RV67DQGHOHV97VDJRXOL03RPRQL$WKHQV*5
3XUSRVH)LYH\HDUVXUYLYDORIKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& SDWLHQWVWUHDWHG
ZLWK'&%HDGORDGHGZLWKGR[RUXELFLQ '(%'2; ZDVWKHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVQRWVXLWDEOHIRUFXUDEOHWUHDWPHQWVKDYH
EHHQ SURVSHFWLYHO\ HQUROOHG PHDQ DJH \HDUV &KLOG 3XJK FODVV ZDV
$% 2NXGDVWDJHZDV
DQGPHDQOHVLRQGLDPHWHUZDVFP/HVLRQPRUSKRORJ\ZDVRQHGRPLQDQW
FP RQHGRPLQDQW!FP PXOWLIRFDO DQGPXOWLIRFDO
! 3DWLHQWVKDGVFKHGXOHGHPEROLVDWLRQVXQWLOVHVVLRQVDQGWKHQRQ
GHPDQG VFKHGXOHGVHVVLRQVZHUHHYHU\PRQWKVLQSDWLHQWVDQGHYHU\
LQ )ROORZXSUDQJHGEHWZHHQDQGPRQWKVXQWLOWLPHRIGHDWKRUWLPHRI
WKHDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV2YHUDOOVXUYLYDODW\U\U\U\U\UVZDV
DQGZLWKKLJKHUUDWHVDFKLHYHGLQWKH&KLOG$SDWLHQWVFRPSDUHGWR
&KLOG% DQGYVDQG
0HDQRYHUDOOVXUYLYDOZDVPRQWKV &XPXODWLYHVXUYLYDOZDV
EHWWHUIRU&KLOG$FRPSDUHGWR&KLOG%SDWLHQWV S )RUGRPLQDQWOHVLRQV
FPDQG\HDUVXUYLYDOUDWHVZHUHDQG
IRU&KLOG$SDWLHQWVDQGDQGIRU
&KLOG%5HJDUGLQJ'(%'2;WUHDWPHQWPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVLGHQWLÀHGQXPEHURI
OHVLRQV S OHVLRQYDVFXODULW\ S LQLWLDOO\DFKLHYHG&5 S
DQG25 S DVVLJQLÀFDQWDQGLQGHSHQGHQWGHWHUPLQDQWVRI\HDUVXUYLYDO
&RQFOXVLRQ '(%'2; UHVXOWV ZLWK KLJK UDWHV RI \U VXUYLYDO IRU GRPLQDQW
WXPRXUVFP
%
%ORRGÁRZUHGLVWULEXWLRQLQIXVLRQVWUDWHJ\EHIRUHUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ
&6SUHDÀFR5/DQRFLWD&0RURVL(&LYHOOL00DFFDXUR
55RPLWR/))ULJHULR$0DUFKLDQz90D]]DIHUUR0LODQ,7
FDUORVSUHDÀFR#LVWLWXWRWXPRULPLLW
3XUSRVH 3UREOHPV DULVH ZKHQ SHUIRUPLQJ D <SDUWLFOH LQIXVLRQDO WKHUDS\ LQ
WXPRXUVZLWKPXOWLSOHDUWHULDOVXSSOLHV:HDLPDWGHPRQVWUDWLQJWKDWWXPRXUVFDQ
EHWUHDWHGYLDRQHPDLQIHHGLQJDUWHU\DFKLHYLQJÁRZUHGLVWULEXWLRQE\HPEROLVLQJ
DOODFFHVVRU\YHVVHOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-DQWR0DUFK<UDGLRHPERO
LVDWLRQVZHUHFDUULHGRXWRQSDWLHQWVZLWKLQWHUPHGLDWHWRDGYDQFHG+&&XVLQJ
JODVVPLFURVSKHUHV7KHUD6SKHUH,QOHVLRQVSWVPHDQGLDPHWHUPP
LQWUDH[WUDKHSDWLF DFFHVVRU\EUDQFKHVZHUHIRXQGDQGHPEROLVHG:LWKLQ
WKHQH[WZHHNVDOOSWVZHUHWUHDWHGE\<LQIXVLRQ7KHOHVLRQVZLWKÁRZ
UHGLVWULEXWLRQZHUHFKRVHQDVWDUJHWOHVLRQVDQGWKHLUUDGLRORJLFDOUHVSRQVHZDV
HYDOXDWHGDFFRUGLQJWRP5(&,67FULWHULD
5HVXOWV,QDOOSWVWKH<LQIXVLRQZDVVDWLVIDFWRU\WKHFRPSOHWHWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQ
ZDVDVVHVVHGSULRUWRUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQE\DQJLRJUDSK\LQDOOSWVDQGDIWHUWKH
<LQIXVLRQ H[SORLWLQJWKH%UHPVVWUDKOXQJHIIHFW E\63(&7&7LQSWV,Q
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\DQGVDIHW\RIVLQJOHVWHSEDOORRQRFFOXGHG
5)$IROORZHGE\7$&(LQSDWLHQWVZLWK´FRPSOH[µXQUHVHFWDEOH+&&SUHYLRXVO\
QRWVXLWDEOHWR5)$DORQHGXHWRWKHLUORFDOLVDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKVLQJOH+&& PHDQGLDPHWHU
FP DGMDFHQWWRWKHGLDSKUDJP OHVLRQV SUR[LPDOWRWKHKHSDWLFSRUWDO
*OLVVRQ VFDSVXOH RUORFDWHGRQWKHLQWUDDEGRPLQDOIUHHVXUIDFH FRQVLGHUHG
DVFRPSOH[IRUWKHLUXQIDYRXUDEOHORFDWLRQDQGQRWVXLWDEOHIRU5)$DORQHZHUH
HQUROOHGLQRXUVLQJOHFHQWUHPXOWLGLVFLSOLQDU\SLORWVWXG\7KHWUHDWPHQWZDVFRP
SRVHGE\5)$ VLQJOHFPRUFPPRQRSRODUQHHGOHLQVHUWLRQ GXULQJRFFOXVLRQ
RIWKHIHHGLQJDUWHU\IROORZHGE\VXSHUVHOHFWLYH7$&( FRQYHQWLRQDO7$&(RUZLWK
'&%($' $GYHUVHHYHQWVDQGLQWUDSHULSURFHGXUDOFRPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHFOLQLFDOO\
DVVHVVHG7XPRXUUHVSRQVHZDVHYDOXDWHGRQPRQWKIROORZXSPXOWLSKDVLF&7
EDVHGRQP5(&,67FULWHULD
5HVXOWV7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVZDVDFKLHYHGLQDOOSDWLHQWV1RPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQV
RFFXUUHG$ PHDQ WRWDO WUHDWHG GLDPHWHU QHFURWLF GLDPHWHU SOXV FLUFXPIHUHQWLDO
SHULSKHUDOOLSLRGROXSWDNHIRUFRQYHQWLRQDO7$&(PHDQQHFURWLFGLDPHWHUIRU7$&(
ZLWK'&%HDG RIZDVREWDLQHG%DVHGRQP5(&,67FULWHULDDWXPRXU
UHVSRQVHZDVREWDLQHGLQDOOSDWLHQWVZLWKDFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHDFKLHYHGLQ
RXWRISDWLHQWV ZLWKDSDUWLDOUHVSRQVHLQWKHODVWSDWLHQWV UHVLGXDO
WXPRXU ZLWKRXWDQ\SURJUHVVLYHGLVHDVH
&RQFOXVLRQ%DOORRQRFFOXGHG5)$SOXV7$&(VHHPVWREHDVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYH
WKHUDS\IRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRI´FRPSOH[µ+&&DOORZLQJWRREWDLQDKLJKFRPSOHWHORFDO
UHVSRQVHUDWHZLWKRXWFRPSOLFDWLRQVDOVRLQSDWLHQWVQRWVXLWDEOHWR5)$DORQH
$9ÀVWXODH $V\VWHPLFGUXJDSSURYHGIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRIDGYDQFHGSULPDU\OLYHU
FDQFHULVWKHSURWHLQNLQDVHLQKLELWRU6RUDIHQLE$LPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVLI
UHGXFWLRQRIWKHKHSDWRSXOPRQDU\VKXQWIUDFWLRQFDQEHDFKLHYHGE\WKHDGPLQLV
WUDWLRQRI6RUDIHQLESULRUWR5(
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDZHUH
VWXGLHG3DWLHQWVFRQVHFXWLYHO\XQGHUZHQWKHSDWLFGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWLRQDQJLRJUDSK\
'6$ ZLWK WKH DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI 7HFKQHFWLXPPODEHOOHG PDFURDJJUHJDWHG
DOEXPLQ P7F0$$ DQGD63(&7&7IURPZKLFKGDWDWKHSXOPRQDU\VKXQW
IUDFWLRQZDVFDOFXODWHG(LJKWSDWLHQWVZLWKDFRQWUDLQGLFDWLRQIRU5(GXHWRDQ
HVWLPDWHGSXOPRQDU\UDGLDWLRQGRVHRIRYHU*\UHVXOWLQJIURPKLJKVKXQWYDOXHV
ZHUHHQUROOHG7KHVHSDWLHQWVUHFHLYHG6RUDIHQLE 1H[DYDU%D\HU IRUZHHNVRQ
DYHUDJH$IWHUZDUGV'6$DQGVKXQWIUDFWLRQFDOFXODWLRQZDVUHSHDWHG
5HVXOWV,QDOOHLJKWSDWLHQWVDUHGXFWLRQRIWKHKHSDWRSXOPRQDU\VKXQWIUDFWLRQRI
0$$ZDVDFKLHYHG DYHUDJHVKXQWUHGXFWLRQRIUDQJH )ROORZLQJ
6RUDIHQLEDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ5(WKHUDS\ZDVSRVVLEOHLQSDWLHQWV,QRQHSDWLHQW
KRZHYHUUHGXFWLRQRIKHSDWRSXOPRQDU\VKXQWIUDFWLRQZDVQRWVXIÀFLHQWO\KLJKIRU
VXEVHTXHQW5(WKHUDS\
&RQFOXVLRQ 5HGXFWLRQ RI KHSDWRSXOPRQDU\ VKXQW IUDFWLRQ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK DG
YDQFHG +&& FDQ EH VXFFHVVIXOO\ LQGXFHG E\ WKH DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI 6RUDIHQLE
(YHQSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKKHSDWRSXOPRQDU\VKXQWIUDFWLRQVPD\EHFRPHHOLJLEOHIRU
UDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQWKHUDS\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
WKHDVVHVVDEOHSWVWKHPHDQIROORZXSZDVPRQWKVDQGWKHUHVSRQVHUDWHLQ
WKHLUOHVLRQVZDV&535DQG6'
&RQFOXVLRQ$OOHPEROLVDWLRQSURFHGXUHVZHUHVXFFHVVIXOO\FDUULHGRXWZLWKQR
FRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGUHVSRQVHVZHUHHQFRXUDJLQJREMHFWLYHUHVSRQVHUDWH &535
LQOHVLRQV 1RFRUUHODWLRQHPHUJHGEHWZHHQWKHUHVLGXDODFWLYHOHVLRQ
DQGWKHDFFHVVRU\DUWHU\WHUULWRU\2XUÀQGLQJVFRQÀUPHGWKHDFWXDOLQWUDWXPRUDO
ÁRZUHGLVWULEXWLRQDIWHUHPEROLVLQJWKHDFFHVVRU\DUWHULHVZKLFKPDNHVLWSRVVLEOH
WRWUHDWWKHWXPRXUWKURXJKLWVVLQJOHPDLQIHHGLQJDUWHU\
%
7UDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( ZLWKPLWRP\FLQDQG
FLVSODWLQLQKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDFXUDWLYHSDOOLDWLYHDQG
QHRDGMXYDQWWKHUDS\SURWRFRO
7-9RJO.$XHUEDFK.(QJHOV.2FKV6=DQJRV1111DJXLE
7/HKQHUW1(1RXU(OGLQ)UDQNIXUW'( WYRJO#HPXQLIUDQNIXUWGH
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH HIIHFW RI WUDQVDUWHULDO FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( RQ
ORFDOUHVSRQVHDQGVXUYLYDORISDWLHQWVZLWKKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& LQD
FXUDWLYHSDOOLDWLYHDQGQHRDGMXYDQWSURWRFRO
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q D UHWURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ SDWLHQWV PDOH
IHPDOH ZLWK KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ +&& ZHUH WUHDWHG ZLWK UHSHWLWLYH
7$&( PLWRP\FLQFLVSODWLQOLSLRGRO EHWZHHQ$SULODQG)HEUXDU\7KH
XQGHUO\LQJOLYHUSDWKRORJ\&KLOG3XJKVFRUHWXPRXUYROXPHQXPEHURIWXPRXUV
ORFDOUHVSRQVHDQGVXUYLYDOVLQFHÀUVWGLDJQRVLVDQGÀUVW7$&(ZHUHDQDO\VHG
/RFDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVHZDVHYDOXDWHGE\05,DQG&7YROXPHWULFPHDVXUHPHQWV
DQG VXUYLYDOUDWHVIURPÀUVW7$&(DQG ODVW7$&(ZHUH FDOFXODWHG DFFRUGLQJ WR
WKH5(&,67FULWHULD
5HVXOWV /RFDO WXPRXU FRQWURO VKRZHG SDUWLDO UHVSRQVH 35 LQ SDWLHQW
VWDEOHGLVHDVH 6' LQSDWLHQWV DQGSURJUHVVLYHGLVHDVH
LQSDWLHQWV /RFDOUHVSRQVHUDWHSHUSDWLHQWZDV&535
6'DQG3'7KHVXUYLYDOUDWHVRIDOOSDWLHQWVVLQFHÀUVWGLDJQRVLVDQG
ÀUVW7$&(ZHUHPRQWKV PHGLDQ DQGPRQWKV PHGLDQ UHVSHFWLYHO\
)RUQHRDGMXYDQWLQWHUYHQWLRQDQGUHVHFWLRQVXUYLYDOUDWHVVLQFHÀUVWGLDJQRVLVDQG
ÀUVW7$&(ZHUHPRQWKVDQGPRQWKVIRUQHRDGMXYDQWLQWHUYHQWLRQDQG
WUDQVSODQWDWLRQPRQWKVDQGPRQWKVDQGIRUQHRDGMXYDQWLQWHUYHQWLRQ
IROORZHG E\ GLIIHUHQW DEODWLRQ WHFKQLTXHV /,77 0: 5)$ PRQWKV DQG
PRQWKV
&RQFOXVLRQ7$&(IRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRI+&&LVDQHIIHFWLYHWKHUDS\IRUDOOWKUHH
WKHUDS\SURWRFROV,QQHRDGMXYDQWWKHUDS\LWFDQEHXVHGDVDEULGJLQJWKHUDS\LQ
SDOOLDWLYHWKHUDS\LWVWDELOLVHVWKHWXPRXUORDG
%
3UHSURFHGXUDO'&7LPDJHEOHQGLQJZLWKÁXRURVFRS\WRJXLGH
FDWKHWHULVDWLRQRISURSHUKHSDWLFDUWHU\GXULQJWUDQVDUWHULDO
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQDIHDVLELOLW\VWXG\
,%DUJHOOLQL(%R]]L$&LFRUHOOL$/XQDUGL)7XULQL5&LRQL&%DUWROR]]L
3LVD,7 LUHQHEDUJHOOLQL#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVIHDVLELOLW\RISUHSURFHGXUDOFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\'PRGHO
IXVLRQZLWKÁXRURVFRS\WRJXLGHWKHFDWKHWHULVDWLRQRIWKHSURSHUKHSDWLFDUWHU\
GXULQJWUDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( RIKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\FRQVHFXWLYHFLUUKRWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK+&&XQGHUJR
LQJ7$&(ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGLQWKHVWXG\7KHHDUO\DUWHULDOSKDVHD[LDO
LPDJHVRIWKHSUHSURFHGXUDO&7ZHUHSRVWSURFHVVHGRQDQLQGHSHQGHQWZRUNVWD
WLRQFRQQHFWHGWRWKHDQJLRJUDSKLFV\VWHP ,QQRYD*(+HDOWKFDUH REWDLQLQJ
D'YROXPHUHQGHULQJLPDJH 95 WKDWLQFOXGHGDEGRPLQDODRUWDFHOLDFWUXQN
FRPPRQSURSHUOHIWDQGULJKWKHSDWLFDUWHULHVVXSHULRUPHVHQWHULFDUWHU\RULJLQ
RIWKHUHQDODUWHULHVÀUVWDQGVHFRQGOXPEDUYHUWHEUDH7KH95LPDJHZDVPDQX
DOO\UHJLVWHUHGWRWKH'ÁXRURVFRSLFLPDJHXVLQJWKHOXPEDUVSLQHDVUHIHUHQFH
7KH95LPDJHZDVWKHQXVHGDVJXLGDQFHWRVHOHFWLYHO\FDWKHWHULVHWKHSURSHU
KHSDWLFDUWHU\XVLQJDQDGHTXDWHO\VKDSHG)UK\GURSKLOLFFDWKHWHUDQGDµ
K\GURSKLOLFJXLGHZLUH7KHSURFHGXUHZDVFRQVLGHUHGVXFFHVVIXOZKHQSHUIRUPHG
ZLWKQRQHHGIRULQWUDDUWHULDOFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQVRUDQJLRJUDSKLFDFTXLVLWLRQV
5HVXOWV7KHSURFHGXUHZDVVXFFHVVIXOLQSDWLHQWV ,QRQHSDWLHQW
FHOLDFWUXQNDQJLRJUDSK\ZDVUHTXLUHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIDVHYHUHRVWLDOVWHQRVLV
WKDWZDVXQGHUHVWLPDWHGDW&77LPHIRULPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDQGUHJLVWUDWLRQ
ZDVPLQXWHVLQDOOFDVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRISUHSURFHGXUDO&7LPDJHEOHQGLQJWRÁXRURVFRS\HQDEOHV
FRQÀGHQWDQGGLUHFWFDWKHWHULVDWLRQRIWKHSURSHUKHSDWLFDUWHU\ZLWKQRQHHGIRU
FHOLDFWUXQNDQJLRJUDSK\RURWKHUDFTXLVLWLRQVWKXVUHGXFLQJUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUH
FRQWUDVWPHGLDDGPLQLVWUDWLRQDQGSURFHGXUDOWLPH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
5DGLRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWK<JODVVPLFURVSKHUHVLQKHSDWRFHOOXODU
FDUFLQRPDVDIHW\DQGORQJWHUPVXUYLYDO
7$+HXVQHU3+LOJDUG60XHOOHU-(UWOH$%RFNLVFK*$QWRFK
'VVHOGRUI'((VVHQ'( KHXVQHU#PHGXQLGXHVVHOGRUIGH
3XUSRVH5DGLRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWKJODVVPLFURVSKHUHVDOORZVHIIHFWLYHORFRUHJLRQDO
WKHUDS\RISDWLHQWVZLWKKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& QRWHOLJLEOHIRUORFDOWKHUD
SLHV7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRYDOLGDWHHYLGHQFHRQVDIHW\DQGHIÀFDF\RIWKLV
WUHDWPHQWLQD(XURSHDQVDPSOHRISDWLHQWVZLWKDGYDQFHG+&&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKDGYDQFHG+&&ZHUHLQ
FOXGHGLQWKLVSURVSHFWLYHRSHQODEHOVWXG\<PLFURVSKHUHVZHUHDGPLQLVWHUHG
LQDOREDUIDVKLRQRYHUWKHULJKWRUOHIWEUDQFKRIWKHKHSDWLFDUWHU\5HVSRQVHWR
WUHDWPHQWZDVHYDOXDWHGE\&7LPDJLQJDSSO\LQJ5(&,67DQG:+2FULWHULDZLWK
UHFHQW ($6/1&, DPHQGPHQWV 7LPH WR SURJUHVVLRQ DQG RYHUDOO VXUYLYDO ZHUH
HVWLPDWHGE\WKH.DSODQ0H\HUPHWKRG
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVKDGXQGHUO\LQJOLYHUFLUUKRVLVZLWK&KLOG3XJKVFRUHV
EHWZHHQDQGWUHDWPHQWVHVVLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGUDQJLQJEHWZHHQDQG
WUHDWPHQWVSHUSDWLHQW7KHPHDQUDGLDWLRQGRVHSHUWUHDWPHQWZDV
*\$FFRUGLQJWR($6/FULWHULDFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGLQSDUWLDO
UHVSRQVHVLQVWDEOHGLVHDVHDQGSULPDU\SURJUHVVLRQLQ7LPHWR
SURJUHVVLRQ 773 ZDVPRQWKVWKHPHGLDQRYHUDOOVXUYLYDOZDVPRQWKV
1ROXQJRUYLVFHUDOWR[LFLW\ZDVREVHUYHG7KHPRVWIUHTXHQWDGYHUVHHYHQWZDV
DWUDQVLHQWIDWLJXHV\QGURPH
&RQFOXVLRQ5DGLRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWK<WWULXPJODVVPLFURVSKHUHVIRUSDWLHQWV
ZLWKDGYDQFHG+&&LVDVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYHWUHDWPHQWZKLFKFDQEHXWLOLVHGHYHQ
LQFDVHVZLWKFRPSURPLVHGOLYHUIXQFWLRQ
5RRP(
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
66
6SLQHDQGSHULSKHUDOQHUYHV
0RGHUDWRUV
,:0F&DOO2VZHVWU\8.
0$:HEHU+HLGHOEHUJ'(
%
7KHDVVHVVPHQWIRUWKHLQWHUYHUWHEUDOIRUDPHQLQWKHOXPEDUGLVN
KHUQLDWLRQVXVLQJVOLFHG\QDPLFYROXPH&7DSLORWVWXG\
<O6RQJ=-LD;V/L=:DQJ<7LDQ%HLMLQJ&1 \OVRQJ#VRKXFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHG\QDPLFFKDQJHVRILQWHUYHUWHEUDOIRUDPHQGXULQJOXPEDU
H[WHQVRÁH[DOPRYHPHQWLQWKHSDWLHQWVRIOXPEDUGLVNKHUQLDWLRQV /'+ XVLQJ
7RVKLED$TXLOLRQ21(VOLFHG\QDPLFYROXPH&7 $421(
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$421( ZDV XVHG WR SHUIRUP WKH VFDQQLQJ IRU WKH
FRQWLQXRXV OXPEDU VSLQH PRYHPHQW IRU SDWLHQWV JURXS ZLWK /'+ ZKR ZHUH
SRVLWLYHFDVHVIRUURXWLQH05,VWDWLFVFDQQLQJFHQWUDOW\SHRISURMHFWLQJEDFNZDUG
7KH&REEDQJOHZDVPHDVXUHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHUHIHUHQFHLPDJHRIGHJUHHLQ
WKHPRYHPHQWSURFHVV7KH/'+ /6 DQGIRUDPHQLQWHUYHUWHEUDOHLQWKHVWDWLF
DQGG\QDPLFVLWXDWLRQVZHUHPHDVXUHGDQGFRPSDUHGWKURXJK0350,3DQG95
SURFHVVLQJLQGLIIHUHQWDQJOHV7KHHIIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHLVaP6Y
5HVXOWV$PRQJ WKH SDWLHQWV WRWDOO\ GLVN SURWUXVLRQ ZHUH FODVVLÀHG E\
6SDQJOHUPHWKRG$WWKHGHJUHHRIK\SHUH[WHQVLRQSRVLWLRQWKHLQWHUYHUWHEUDO
GLVFLQJUDGH,,,DQG,9LQFUHDVHGWKDQVWDWLF&RPSDUHGZLWKWKHLPDJHVRI
URXWLQH05,WKHGLVFVLQFUHDVHGPPSHUGHJUHHH[WHQVLRQDQGGHFUHDVHG
PP SHU WHQ GHJUHHV ÁH[LRQ /'+ LQ K\SHUH[WHQVLRQ SRVLWLRQ KDG PRUH
LQÁXHQFH WKDQ K\SHUÁH[LRQ RWKHUZLVH LQWHUYHUWHEUDO IRUDPHQ VKRZHG GLIIHUHQW
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVLQK\SHUÁH[LRQSRVLWLRQ7KHIRUDPHQVGHFUHDVHGPPòSHU
GHJUHHVGXULQJOXPEDUH[WHQVLRQ$WWKHGHJUHHK\SHUÁH[LRQSRVLWLRQ
IRUDPHQVDUHUHGXFHGE\PPò1LQHW\RQHSHUFHQWIRUDPHQVRIGHJUHH
K\SHUÁH[LRQDUHODUJHUPPòWKDQWKHRQHVRIGHJUHH
&RQFOXVLRQ&7G\QDPLFOXPEHUVFDQFDQUHÁHFWWKHFRQWLQXRXVYDULDWLRQVRI/'+
GXULQJWKHPRYHPHQWZKLFKZLOOSURYLGHLPSRUWDQWLQIRUPDWLRQIRUWKHWUHDWPHQW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
6RGLXPLPDJLQJRIWKHOXPEDULQWHUYHUWHEUDOGLVFDW7HVOD
FRUUHODWLRQZLWK7PDSSLQJDQGPRGLÀHG3ÀUUPDQQVFRUHDW7HVOD
,01RHEDXHU+XKPDQQ9-XUDV&:$3ÀUUPDQQ36]RPRODQ\L
6=E\Q$0HVVQHU-:LPPHU.)ULHGULFK67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7
=XULFK&+ LULVQRHEDXHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHVRGLXPLPDJLQJRIOXPEDULQWHUYHUWHEUDOGLVFVLQDV\PS
WRPDWLF YROXQWHHUV DW 7HVOD ZLWK TXDQWLWDWLYH 7 PDSSLQJ DQG PRUSKRORJLFDO
VFRULQJDW7HVOD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDV\PSWRPDWLFYROXQWHHUV PIPHDQDJH
\HDUVUDQJH WKHGLVFV/WR/6ZHUHH[DPLQHG$W7HVODQRUPDOLVHG
VRGLXPVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRVZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJUHJLRQRILQWHUHVWDQDO\VLV$W
7HVOD7PDSSLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKDPXOWLHFKRVSLQHFKRVHTXHQFH 75
7(DQGPVHF 7YDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
RYHUWKHQXFOHXVZLWKDSL[HOZLVHPRQRH[SRQHQWLDOQRQQHJDWLYHOHDVWVTXDUHV
ÀWDQDO\VLV0RUSKRORJLFDOJUDGLQJDFFRUGLQJWRDPRGLÀHG3ÀUUPDQQVFRUHZDV
DVVHVVHGDQG3HDUVRQҋVFRUUHODWLRQDQDO\VLVRIWKHFRYDULDWHVZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV,QWRWDOGLVFVZHUHHYDOXDWHG7KHPHDQQRUPDOLVHGVRGLXPVLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\ZDV 6' 7KH7PDSSLQJVKRZHGDPHDQYDOXHRIPV
6'PV 7KHPHGLDQPRGLÀHG3ÀUUPDQQVFRUHZDVE ZLWKF
7KH3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVKRZHGDQHDUPRGHUDWHLQYHUVHFRUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQVRGLXPLPDJLQJDQGWKH3ÀUUPDQQVFRUH U DPRGHUDWHLQYHUVH
FRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ7PDSSLQJDQGWKH3ÀUUPDQQVFRUH U DQGQRFRU
UHODWLRQEHWZHHQVRGLXPLPDJLQJDQG7PDSSLQJ U
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDW05LPDJLQJRIWKHLQWHUYHUWHEUDOGLVFXVLQJ
VRGLXPLPDJLQJDQG7PDSSLQJFKDUDFWHULVHVGLIIHUHQWPHDVXUDEOHELRFKHPLFDO
FRPSRQHQWFKDQJHVDQGWKDWERWKRIWKHVHPHWKRGVDIIHFWWKH3ÀUUPDQQVFRUH
%
05LPDJLQJRIWKHOXPEDUVSLQHFRPSDULVRQRI'LVRWURSLFWXUER
VSLQHFKR63$&(VHTXHQFHYHUVXVFRQYHQWLRQDO'VHTXHQFHVDW7
6/HH:+-HH-<-XQJ6</HH.<+D&.3DUN6HRXO.5
VXQJZRQOHH#JPDLOFRP
%
0XOWLHFKR05,IRUPXVFOHIDWTXDQWLÀFDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKORZ
EDFNSDLQFRPSDULVRQWRVSHFWURVFRS\
0$))LVFKHU5*XJJHQEHUJHU'1DQ]*$QGUHLVHN=XULFK&+
PLFKDHODOH[DQGHUÀVFKHU#XV]FK
3XUSRVH 7R SURVSHFWLYHO\ FRPSDUH IDWVLJQDOIUDFWLRQV GHULYHG IURP VSRLOHG
JUDGLHQWGXDOHFKR 63*5'( DQGPXOWLHFKR 63*50( 05,ZLWKDQGZLWKRXW
FRUUHFWLRQRI7 ELDVIRUTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIPXVFOHIDWFRQWHQW 0)& LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
ORZEDFNSDLQ /%3 XVLQJVLQJOHYR[HOVSHFWURVFRS\DVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
,QÁXHQFHRIZHLJKWEHDULQJDQGOXPEDUORUGRVLVRQWKHGXUDOVDFLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHVWHQRVLVRIWKHOXPEDUVSLQDOFDQDO
31LJJHPDQQ(6WRHW]HO-+RHIIHU+.%H\HU++6FKLOG%RQQ'(
&RORJQH'( SDVFDOQLJJHPDQQ#XNEXQLERQQGH
3XUSRVH0RGHUDWHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQFOLQLFDOFRPSODLQWVDQGLPDJLQJLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKOXPEDUVSLQDOFDQDOVWHQRVLV 6&6 FRXOGEHGXHWRWKHODFNRIDSSOLHGERG\
ZHLJKWGXULQJKRUL]RQWDOLPDJLQJ3RVLWLRQDO05,DOORZVYLVXDOLVLQJWKHVSLQHXQGHU
ZHLJKWEHDULQJFRQGLWLRQV7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRDQDO\VHWKHLQÁXHQFH
RIZHLJKWEHDULQJDQGORUGRVLVRQWKHGXUDOVDF '6 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUH6&6
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV VHJPHQWV LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK VHYHUH 6&6 ZHUH
H[DPLQHG7KHVL]HRIWKH'6DQGWKHGHJUHHRIORUGRVLVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQVXSLQH
H[WHQVLRQ VWDQGLQJ DQG QHXWUDO VLWWLQJ SRVLWLRQ 7KH ÀQGLQJV ZHUH FRPSDUHG
IRUDOOVHJPHQWVDQGIRUVHJPHQWVZLWKVWDEOHDQGXQVWDEOHVOLSV3DWLHQWVZHUH
GLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVRQHZLWKVHYHUHFODXGLFDWLRQDQGRQHZLWKOHVVVHYHUH
RUQRFODXGLFDWLRQ7KHÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGIRUWKHPRVWQDUURZHGVHJPHQW
5HVXOWV7KHVSLQDOFDQDOZDVPRVWQDUURZHGLQH[WHQVLRQZKHUHDVWKHORUGRVLV
ZDV PRVW SURPLQHQW LQ VXSLQH SRVLWLRQ 7KH GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ WKH SRVLWLRQV
ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWIRUDOOSDUDPHWHUV/RUGRVLVLVWKHPDLQIDFWRUFRQWULEXWLQJWRWKH
QDUURZLQJRIWKHVSLQDOFDQDO:HLJKWEHDULQJLVDQLPSRUWDQWIDFWRUIRUVHJPHQWV
ZLWKXQVWDEOHVOLSV6&6ZDVOHVVIXQFWLRQDOLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHFODXGLFDWLRQ
FRPSDUHGWRWKH6&6LQSDWLHQWVZLWKOHVVVHYHUHRUQRFODXGLFDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ+RUL]RQWDO05,LVUHOLDEOHWRGLDJQRVHOXPEDU6&6VLQFHQRVHJPHQW
ZLWK 6&6 ZDV PLVVHG 3RVLWLRQDO 05, VHHPV XVHIXO LQ VHJPHQW ZLWK XQVWDEOH
YHUWHEUDO VOLSV 7KH IXQFWLRQDOLW\ RI 6&6 VHHPV WR EHWWHU FRUUHODWH ZLWK FOLQLFDO
FRPSODLQWVWKDQWKHPD[LPXP6&6
%
&RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQVWUHQJWKRISDUDVSLQDOOXPEDUPXVFOHVPXVFOH
GHJHQHUDWLRQDQGGLIIXVLRQSURSHUWLHV
&&0XFK-'%XVFK66FKODPSS1')RUNHUW*$GDP&5+DEHUPDQQ
+DPEXUJ'( FPXFK#XNHGH
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQYLVLEOHGH
JHQHUDWLRQGLIIXVLRQSURSHUWLHVDQGVWUHQJWKRIWKHSDUDVSLQDOPXVFOHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV IHPDOHVPDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV
ZHUHLPDJHGZLWKD7056FDQQHU 6\PSKRQLH6LHPHQV DQGXQGHUZHQWPHDV
XUHPHQWVZLWKDVSHFLÀFPDFKLQHGHYHORSHGIRULVRODWHGOXPEDUPXVFOHVWUHQJWK
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ '(/3+(;0HGLFDO/( 7DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':,
ZKHUHSHUIRUPHGDWWKH/OHYHO)DWW\DQGÀEURWLFGHJHQHUDWLRQRIWKHPXVFOH
FRPSDUWPHQW DQG DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHV RI WKH SDUDVSLQDO
PXVFOHVZHUHPHDVXUHGXVLQJDQLQKRXVHGHYHORSHGVHPLDXWRPDWLFDOO\DQDO\VLV
PHWKRG 6SHDUPDQV UDQN FRUUHODWLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW 6&& ZDV XVHG WR GHWHUPLQH
FRUUHODWLRQV EHWZHHQ SDWLHQW VWUHQJWK 1P PXVFOH IDWÀEURXV IUDFWLRQ DQG
$'& [PPV
5HVXOWV0XVFOHVWUHQJWKVKRZHGDPRGHUDWHQHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKIDWIUDFWLRQ
6&&WRS DQGPRGHUDWHSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZLWK$'&YDOXHV
6&&WRS )DWÀEURXVIUDFWLRQFRUUHODWHVQHJDWLYHO\ZLWK$'&
6&&S
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHLVRWURSLFWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDO ' 7ZHLJKWHGWXUERVSLQ
HFKR VHTXHQFH 76(63$&( ZLWK FRQYHQWLRQDO WZRGLPHQVLRQDO ' 76(
VHTXHQFHVIRUHYDOXDWLQJWKHQHXUDOIRUDPLQDDQGQHUYHVRIWKHOXPEDUVSLQHDW
705LPDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHLQVWLWXWLRQDOHWKLFVFRPPLWWHHDSSURYHGWKLVUHWUR
VSHFWLYHVWXG\DQGZDLYHGWKHUHTXLUHPHQWRILQIRUPHGFRQVHQWSDWLHQWVZKR
KDGVSLQHVXUJHU\IRUGLVFKHUQLDWLRQDQGKDG7VSLQH05,ZHUHLQFOXGHG,Q
DGGLWLRQWRFRQYHQWLRQDO'76(VHTXHQFHVVDJLWWDO'7ZHLJKWHG76(63$&(
ZDVREWDLQHGWRSURGXFHPXOWLSODQDULQWHUPHGLDWHZHLJKWHGLPDJHVZLWKPP
LVRWURSLFUHVROXWLRQDORQJWKHD[LDOFRURQDODQGREOLTXHFRURQDOSODQHV(DFK'
DQG'76(LPDJHVZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWO\VFRUHGIRUWKHGHJUHHRIOXPEDUQHXUDO
IRUDPLQDOVWHQRVLVQHUYHFRPSUHVVLRQDQGQHUYHVZHOOLQJE\WZRUHYLHZHUV7KHVH
VFRUHVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKRSHUDWLYHÀQGLQJVDQGLQLWLDOV\PSWRPV,QWHUREVHUYHU
DJUHHPHQWVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKNDSSDVWDWLVWLFVDQGFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKHVXUJHU\
ZDVGRQHE\0F1HPDUWHVW
5HVXOWVQHXUDOIRUDPLQDOVWHQRVHVLQSDWLHQWVDQGQHUYHFRPSURPLVHLQ
SDWLHQWVZHUHIRXQGDWVXUJHU\7KHPHDQGLDJQRVWLFVHQVLWLYLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RI
'76(VHTXHQFHVYHUVXV'76(63$&(ZHUHDQGYHUVXVDQG
IRUQHXUDOIRUDPLQDOVWHQRVLVDQGYHUVXVDQGIRUQHUYH
FRPSUHVVLRQ&RURQDODQGREOLTXHFRURQDOUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJHVRI'76(63$&(
GHPRQVWUDWHGKLJKHUFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKHODWHUDOLW\RIWKHV\PSWRPWKDQ'76(
VHTXHQFHV YHUVXV 7KH LQWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQWV ZHUH VXEVWDQWLDO
ѣ RQ'76(63$&(DQGPRGHUDWH ѣ RQ'76(VHTXHQFHV
&RQFOXVLRQ,VRWURSLF'7ZHLJKWHG76(63$&(VHTXHQFHZDVFRPSDUDEOH
WRFRQYHQWLRQDO'76(VHTXHQFHVIRUGLDJQRVLQJIRUDPLQDOVWHQRVLVDQGQHUYH
FRPSUHVVLRQDW7OXPEDUVSLQH05,DQGVKRZHGEHWWHUV\PSWRPDWLFFRUUHODWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV ZRPHQ\HDUV VXIIHULQJRI/%3
XQGHUZHQWFOLQLFDOO\LQGLFDWHG05,DW7HVODLQFOXGLQJ63*5'(DQG63*50(
IRUTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIIDWW\GHJHQHUDWLRQRIWKHHUHFWRUVSLQDHPXVFOHLQDSUHGHÀQHG
UHJLRQRILQWHUHVW 52, DWWKHOHYHO/)DWVLJQDOIUDFWLRQV )6) ZHUHGHWHUPLQHG
IURPVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHV 6, RQDXWRPDWLFDOO\JHQHUDWHGIDWZDWHURQO\LPDJHVIURP
ERWK GDWDVHWV )6)'( )6)0( DV ZHOO DV IURP 7 FRUUHFWHG IDWZDWHURQO\
LPDJHV GHULYHG IURP 63*50( )6)0( DQG FRPSDUHG WR VSHFWURVFRSLFDOO\
GHWHUPLQHGIUDFWLRQV )6)63(& 6WXGHQWҋVWWHVWDQGWKHPHWKRGRI%ODQGDQG
$OWPDQZHUHXVHGWRVWXG\WKHDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ)6)GHULYHGIURP63*5'(
63*50(DQGVSHFWURVFRS\
5HVXOWV6SHFWURVFRSLFUHVXOWVZHUHREWDLQHGLQSDWLHQWVELODWHUDOO\0HDQ
)6)63(&ZDV UDQJHQ &RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ)6)
63(&DQG)6)'()6)0(ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWZLWKFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVRIU
0HDQ )6)'( )6)0( YDOXHV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHG IURP )6)63(& ERWK
S ZKHUHDVPHDQ)6)0( VKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV S DQGD
VPDOOPHDQPHDVXUHPHQWELDVRI OLPLWVRIDJUHHPHQW
FRPSDUHGWR)6)63(&
&RQFOXVLRQ)DWVLJQDOIUDFWLRQVDVREWDLQHGIURPERWK63*5'(DQGVWDQGDUG
63*50( ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ODUJHU WKDQ GHWHUPLQHG E\ VSHFWURVFRSLF DQDO\VLV
ZKHUHDV)6)IURP7 FRUUHFWHG63*50(LPDJHVPD\DOORZIDVWDQGDFFXUDWH
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQRI0)&LQSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJRI/%3
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIGHJHQHUDWHGPXVFOHDQG
GLIIXVLRQSURSHUWLHVFDQEHXVHGDVDQLQGLUHFWPDUNHUIRUPXVFOHVWUHQJWK0XVFXODU
IXQFWLRQKDVLQWXUQEHHQGHPRQVWUDWHGWREHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHGHYHORSPHQW
DQGSHUVLVWHQFHRIORZHUEDFNSDLQ4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIPXVFXODUGHJHQHUDWLRQDQG
$'&YDOXHVPD\RIIHULPSRUWDQWEHQHÀWVWR05EDVHGPRUSKRORJLF DQDO\VLVRI
WKHOXPEDUVSLQH
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJRIWKHVSLQHDW7IHDVLELOLW\
RSWLPL]DWLRQRIEYDOXHDQGXWLOLW\WRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHQLJQIURP
SDWKRORJLFDOYHUWHEUDOFRPSUHVVLRQIUDFWXUHV
*)HW]17KHXPDQQ&)HGHUDX'5LFKDUPH3+DJPDQQ-3IHXIIHU
50HXOL)%HFFH/DXVDQQH&+(UODQJHQ'(
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\GHWHUPLQHWKHRSWLPDOEYDOXHDQGDVVHVV
WKHXWLOLW\RI7GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ ':, RIWKHVSLQHLQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ
EHQLJQIURPSDWKRORJLFYHUWHEUDOFRPSUHVVLRQIUDFWXUHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\SDWLHQWVZLWKYHUWHEUDOFRPSUHVVLRQIUDFWXUHV
EHQLJQSDWKRORJLF DQGFRQWUROV WRWDOPHQZRPHQPHDQDJH
\HDUV ZHUHLQFOXGHGIURP'HFHPEHUWR0D\LQWKLV,5%DSSURYHG
SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\05LPDJLQJRIWKHVSLQHZDVSHUIRUPHGRQD7XQLWZLWK7Z
IDWVXSSUHVVHG7ZJDGROLQLXPHQKDQFHGIDWVXSSUHVVHG7ZDQG]RRPHG(3,
' 5) H[FLWDWLRQ SXOVH FRPELQHG ZLWK UHGXFHG ÀHOGRIYLHZ VLQJOHVKRW HFKR
SODQDU UHDGRXW GLIIXVLRQZ EYDOXHV DQG VPP VHTXHQFHV
7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DVVHVVHG]RRPHG(3,LPDJHTXDOLW\LQUDQGRP
RUGHUXVLQJDSRLQWVFDOH H[FHOOHQWWR SRRU7KH\VXEVHTXHQWO\PHDVXUHG
DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV $'&V LQQRUPDOYHUWHEUDOERGLHVDQGFRPSUHVVLRQ
IUDFWXUHVLQFRQVHQVXV
5HVXOWV/RZHUEYDOXHVFRUUHODWHGZLWKEHWWHULPDJHTXDOLW\VFRUHVZLWKVLJQLÀ
FDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQE PHDQ6' E DQGE
DOO S 0HDQ$'&V RI QRUPDO YHUWHEUDO ERGLHV Q ZHUH
DQGðPPVZLWKE DQGVPPUHVSHFWLYHO\,Q
FRQWUDVWPHDQ$'&VZHUHDQGðPPVIRUEHQLJQYHUWHEUDO
FRPSUHVVLRQIUDFWXUHVDQGDQGðPPVIRUSDWKRORJLFIUDFWXUHV
ZLWKE DQGVPPUHVSHFWLYHO\1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQG
EHWZHHQ$'&VRIEHQLJQDQGSDWKRORJLFIUDFWXUHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7':,RIWKHVSLQHLVIHDVLEOHDQGORZHUEYDOXHV VPP DUH
UHFRPPHQGHG +RZHYHU RXU SUHOLPLQDU\ UHVXOWV VKRZ QR DGYDQWDJH RI ':, LQ
GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHQLJQIURPSDWKRORJLFYHUWHEUDOFRPSUHVVLRQIUDFWXUHV
%
+LJKUHVROXWLRQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJRIWKHEUDFKLDOSOH[XV
XVLQJDQLVRWURSLFHQKDQFHGVFDQRI'67,5VHTXHQFH
)<DQJ'/LX</Y;.RQJ:XKDQ&1 I\DQJ#YLSFRP
3XUSRVH 7R LQYHVWLJDWH WKH IHDVLELOLW\ RI LPDJLQJ EUDFKLDO SOH[XV LQ HQKDQFHG
VFDQRI'67,5VHTXHQFHLQ05,DQGLWVGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQ
RIEUDFKLDOSOH[RSDWKLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KH'67,5VHTXHQFHVFDQQLQJDQG'67,5VHTXHQFH
RI HQKDQFHG VFDQ ZHUH XVHG LQ SDWLHQWV LQ WKH GLDJQRVLV RI EUDFKLDO SOH[XV
SDWKRORJLHVLQYROYLQJSULPDU\DQGVHFRQGDU\EUDFKLDOSOH[XVOHVLRQVDQGLQ
YROXQWHHUV$OO SDWLHQWV KDG FOLQLFDO QHUYH FRQGXFWLRQ DQG HOHFWURP\RJUDSKLF
ÀQGLQJVFRQVLVWHQWZLWKEUDFKLDOSOH[XVOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV '67,5 VHTXHQFH DQG HQKDQFHG VFDQ FDQ FOHDUO\ GLVSOD\ DOO WKH
YROXQWHHUV IURP WKH EUDFKLDO SOH[XV FRXUVH FRQWLQXLW\ VKDSH VLJQDO DQG WKH
HQKDQFHGVFDQFDQLPSURYHWKHVXSSUHVVLRQHIIHFWVRIEDFNJURXQGLWLVWKHFDVH
WKDWWUDXPDDQGWXPRXUFDQEHFOHDUO\VHHQLQYROYLQJWKHEUDFKLDOSOH[XVGXHWR
DYDULHW\RIVLJQV
&RQFOXVLRQ:HFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHHQKDQFHGVFDQRI'67,5VHTXHQFHLVDXVHIXO
WHFKQLTXHLQHYDOXDWLQJSDWLHQWVZLWKEUDFKLDOSOH[XVOHVLRQVDQGUHFHLYHDEHWWHU
VXSSUHVVLRQHIIHFWVRIWKHEDFNJURXQG0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJPD\KDYH
VLJQLÀFDQWSRWHQWLDOWRSURYLGHPRUHLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWSUREOHPVVXFKDVEUDFKLDO
SOH[XVLQMXULHVDQGSHULSKHUDOQHUYHFRPSUHVVLRQ
%
'LIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJRIWKHPHGLDQQHUYHLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
UHFXUUHQWFDUSDOWXQQHOV\QGURPHDIWHUVXUJLFDOUHOHDVH
3/LQGEHUJ$)H\G\0$0DLHU-/'UDSH3DULV)5
SDYHOOLQGEHUJ#FFKDSKSIU
3XUSRVH3UHOLPLQDU\VWXGLHVVXJJHVWWKDWGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ '7, PD\EH
RIXVHIRUWKHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIVWUXFWXUDOLQWHJULW\RIWKHPHGLDQQHUYHLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK FDUSDO WXQQHO V\QGURPH &76 +RZHYHU KRZ '7, UHODWHV WR HOHFWURP\RJ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
UDSK\ (0* DQGEHKDYLRXUDOPHDVXUHVUHPDLQVXQFOHDU:HK\SRWKHVLVHGWKDW
'7,PHDVXUHVRIWKHPHGLDQQHUYHZRXOGFRUUHODWHZLWKVORZHGQHUYHFRQGXFWLRQ
DQGLPSDLUHGJULSIRUFHFRQWUROLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSRVWRSHUDWLYHUHFXUULQJV\PSWRPV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&RKRUWSDWLHQWVZLWK(0*HYLGHQFHRIUHFXUUHQW&76
DIWHUVXUJLFDOUHOHDVH PHDQSRVWRSWLPH \HDUV 7KHPHGLDQQHUYH'7,VHTXHQFH
FRQVLVWHG RI QRQFROOLQHDU GLIIXVLRQ JUDGLHQWV E VPP $QDWRPLFDO 05
LPDJHV ZHUH DOVR FROOHFWHG )UDFWLRQDO DQLVRWURS\ )$ DQG DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHVZHUHH[WUDFWHG5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVWZHUHGUDZQRQWKH
PHGLDQQHUYHFPSUR[LPDOWRDQGLQWKHFDUSDOWXQQHO UDWLR GLVWDOSUR[LPDO
5HVXOWV 7KH PHGLDQ QHUYH ZDV LGHQWLÀHG VXFFHVVIXOO\ WKURXJK ÀEUH WUDFNLQJ
LQ DOO SDWLHQWV 'LIIXVLRQ SDUDPHWHUV IRU WKH PHGLDQ QHUYH ZHUH PHDQ6'
)$ DQG$'& 0HDQGLVWDOSUR[LPDOUDWLRVZHUH)$
DQG$'& (0*UHYHDOHGUHGXFHGPRWRUFRQGXFWLRQ PV LQDQG
UHGXFHGVHQVRU\FRQGXFWLRQLQSDWLHQWV*ULSIRUFHWUDFNLQJHUURUZDVKLJKHU
WKDQQRUPDWLYHYDOXHVLQDOOSDWLHQWV6HQVRU\QHUYHFRQGXFWLRQFRUUHODWHGZLWK
)$UDWLR 5 3 7UDFNLQJHUURUFRUUHODWHGZLWKPHDQ)$IRUWKHPHGLDQ
QHUYH 5 3 DQGZLWK)$UDWLR 5 3
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDW'7,PD\EHXVHIXOIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH
PHGLDQQHUYHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHFXUUHQW&76
5RRP)
2QFRORJLF,PDJLQJ
66
1HZDSSOLFDWLRQVIRU86DQG&7LQHYDOXDWLQJ
SDWLHQWVZLWKFDQFHU
0RGHUDWRUV
7%lXHUOH+HLGHOEHUJ'(
0%HOORPL0LODQ,7
%
0XOWLFHQWULFSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\RI'&(86IRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI
DQWLDQJLRJHQLFWUHDWPHQWVGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIFULWHULDZLWKFRUUHODWLRQ
WRRYHUDOOVXUYLYDO
1/DVVDX99LOJUDLQ-/DFURL[67DLHE$6DUUDQ5$]L]D0.LQG
$/XFLDQL6.RVFLHOQ\9LOOHMXLI)5&OLFK\)5&DHQ)5/LOOHV)5
0DUVHLOOH)57RXORXVH)5%RUGHDX[)5&UHWHLO)5 ODVVDX#LJUIU
3XUSRVH$SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\RIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG '&(86
ZLWKTXDQWLÀFDWLRQIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIDQWLDQJLRJHQLFWUHDWPHQWVZDVODXQFKHG
FHQWUHV VXSSRUWHGE\WKH)UHQFK1DWLRQDO&DQFHU,QVWLWXWH7KHREMHFWLYHVZHUH
WKHGLIIXVLRQRIWKHVWDQGDUGLVHGPHWKRGDFRVWHYDOXDWLRQDQGWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQ
RISHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVSUHGLFWLQJWXPRXUUHVSRQVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$OOSDWLHQWVKDG'&(86DWEDVHOLQH''''
DQGHYHU\WZRPRQWKV(DFKH[DPLQDWLRQLQFOXGHGDEROXVLQMHFWLRQRIVRQRYXH
%UDFFR DQGPLQXWHVRIUDZOLQHDUGDWDZLWKDQ$SOLR 7RVKLED 5DZGDWDZHUH
DQDO\VHGZLWKDPDWKHPDWLFDOPRGHO SDWHQW3&7,% WRHYDOXDWH
SDUDPHWHUV FKDUDFWHULVLQJ WKH WXPRXU SHUIXVLRQ FXUYH 5HVSRQVH WR WUHDWPHQW
ZDVHYDOXDWHGHYHU\PRQWKVZLWK5(&,67FULWHULD,QRUGHUWRKDYHVXIÀFLHQW
IROORZXSGDWDWKHVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVKDVWREHSHUIRUPHGPRUHWKDQPRQWKVDIWHU
WKHLQFOXVLRQRIWKHODVWDQDO\VHGSDWLHQW,QFOXVLRQVZHUHFORVHGLQ0DUFK
5HVXOWV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVKDYHEHHQLQFOXGHG PDLQO\5&& DQG+&&
PRUHWKDQ'&(86DQG&7VFDQZHUHSHUIRUPHG$IROORZXS
PRUHWKDQPRQWKVVKRZHGWKDWSDUDPHWHUVKDYHDVWURQJVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
3 DFFRUGLQJWRWKHUHVSRQVHDWPRQWKV7KHGHFUHDVHRIPRUHWKDQ
RI$8&DWRQHPRQWKLVFRUUHODWHGWRWKH773 3 DQG26 3
&RQFOXVLRQ )LQDO UHVXOWV FRQÀUP WKH XVHIXOQHVV RI WKLV WRRO WR PRQLWRU DQWL
DQJLRJHQLFWUHDWPHQWV7KHFULWHULDWKHGHFUHDVHRIPRUHWKDQRI$8&DW
RQHPRQWKLVSUHGLFWLYHRIUHVSRQVH
%
3DUDPHWULFPDSVRIWXPRUDOSHUIXVLRQZLWKG\QDPLFFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGYHUVXVKLVWRORJ\PXOWLPRGDOLWLHVPHOLPDJHSURMHFW
63LWUH&KDPSDJQDW-%&DVWDLJQH/&DOPHOV$/HUR\:LOOLQJ
,/HJXHUQH\-7KDOPHQVL*%RQQLDXG1/DVVDX-&RXORW9LOOHMXLI)5
2UVD\)5 VWHSKDQLHSLWUH#XSVXGIU
3XUSRVH7RLGHQWLI\FRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRQRJ
UDSK\ '&(86 DQGKLVWRORJ\LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHWXPRUDOSHUIXVLRQZLWK
VSHFLÀFPHWKRGRORJLFDOWRROVZHGHYHORSHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6WXG\ZDVFRQGXFWHGRQPHODQRPDEHDULQJQXGHPLFH
DQGRQSDWLHQWVZLWKPHWDVWDWLFQRGHRIPHODQRPD)RUSUHFOLQLFDOVWXG\'&(
86H[DPZDVUHDOLVHGDIWHUDPOEROXVLQMHFWLRQRI6RQR9XH %UDFFR,WDO\
)URPWKHOLQHDUUDZGDWDZHHVWDEOLVKHGSDUDPHWULFPDSVXVLQJWKHPDWKHPDWLFDO
PRGHORIWKHWLPHLQWHQVLW\FXUYHRIWXPRUDOSHUIXVLRQSDWHQWHGE\WKHWHDP7RZ
SDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& DQGSHDNLQWHQVLW\ 3,
+LVWRORJLFDOVWXG\HYDOXDWHGPLFURYHVVHOGHQVLW\ 09' DQGYHVVHOGLDPHWHU7KHVH
GDWDZHUHREWDLQHGZLWKLQWRGLVWLQFWVHFWLRQVLQHDFKWXPRXUDQGFRQIURQWHG
WRWKHSDUDPHWULFPDSVIURP'&(86)RUFOLQLFDOVWXG\'&(86ZDVSHUIRUPHG
EHIRUHVXUJHU\ZLWKDPOEROXVLQMHFWLRQRI6RQR9XH
5HVXOWV$PRQJWKHVWXGLHGPLFHZHUHHYDOXDEOHZLWKDQDO\VHGVHF
WLRQV 6SDWLDO GLVWULEXWLRQ RI$8& DQG 3, ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ FRUUHODWHG ZLWK 09'
UHVSHFWLYHO\5 SDQG5 S K\SHUYDVFXODULVHG
VHFWLRQVIURP'&(86FRUUHVSRQGHGWRDZHDN09'EXWZLWKODUJHYHVVHOGLDPHWHU
&RUUHODWLRQZDVDOVRVLJQLÀFDQW $895 S3,5 S
)URPWKHSDWLHQWVLQFOXGHGFRXOGEHVWXGLHGZLWKDFRQWUDVWXSWDNHEHWZHHQ
DQG+LVWRORJLFDODQDO\VHVDUHLQSURJUHVVDQGUHVXOWVZLOOEHSUHVHQWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU VWXG\ VKRZV D FRUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKH VSDWLDO GLVWULEXWLRQ RI
SHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUV $8&DQG3, DQGWKH09'DVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHYHVVHOVL]H
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIWKHUHOLDELOLW\DQGUHSHDWDELOLW\RIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJSDUDPHWHUVZLWKKLJKIUHTXHQF\
XOWUDVRXQG
'%+XVDULN5&1HOVRQ'0DULQ/:+HGOXQG*$-RKQVRQ
=XULFK&+'XUKDP1&86
%
'XDOVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\&7VFDQWRHYDOXDWHWKHPHGLDVWLQDOO\PSK
QRGHPHWDVWDVHVLQQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHUIHDVLELOLW\VWXG\
<5DR:<DQJ%/LX/&DR<%X:&KDL.&KHQ6KDQJKDL&1
UR\B#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH DFFXUDF\ RI WKH ZHLJKWHG LRGLQH FRQFHQWUDWLRQ IURP
VHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQGXDOVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\ '6'( &7VFDQLQGLDJQRVLQJPHGL
DVWLQDOO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHU 16&/&
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$ FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG GXDO HQHUJ\ &7 VFDQ ZDV SHU
IRUPHGVHFRQGVDIWHUWKHFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQ PO&0DWPOV RQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ16&/&7KHVL]HRIO\PSKQRGHVDQGWKHLRGLQH
FRQFHQWUDWLRQV PJPO RIWKHPHGLDVWLQDOO\PSKQRGHVDVZHOODVWKHDRUWDRQ
WKHVDPHLPDJHSODQHZHUHPHDVXUHGLQD'(SRVWSURFHVVLQJZRUNVWDWLRQ7KH
LRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVIURPWKHO\PSKQRGHVZHUHQRUPDOLVHGE\WKHLRGLQHFRQ
FHQWUDWLRQVRIDRUWDDFFRUGLQJWRWKHEORRGVXSSO\RIPHGLDVWLQXPWRPLQLPLVHWKH
SDWLHQWYDULDWLRQ6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHUDGLRORJLF
SDWKRORJLFFRUUHODWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
,VEORRGÁRZEORRGYROXPHPLVPDWFKLQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKDGYDQFHGGLVHDVH"
9-*RK.0LOHV%*DQHVKDQ05RGULJXH]-XVWR$(QJOHGRZ
$*URYHV/RQGRQ8.)DOPHU8.
3XUSRVH9DVRGLODWDWLRQLQWKHSUHVHQFHRIORZEORRGÁRZUHSUHVHQWVDQDGDSWD
WLRQWRK\SR[LDZKLFKLQWXPRXUPD\UHÁHFWDQDJJUHVVLYHSKHQRW\SH7KLVVWXG\
XVHVSHUIXVLRQ&7WRXQGHUWDNHDSUHOLPLQDU\DVVHVVPHQWRIZKHWKHUVXFKEORRG
ÁRZEORRGYROXPH %)%9 PLVPDWFKLQSULPDU\FRORUHFWDOFDQFHULVDVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKWKHSUHVHQFHRIDGYDQFHGGLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,5%DSSURYDODQGLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZHUHREWDLQHG3HU
IXVLRQ&7EORRGÁRZDQGEORRGYROXPHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHDFTXLUHGSURVSHFWLYHO\
LQSULPDU\FRORUHFWDOFDQFHUVIURPSDWLHQWV1RGDODQGPHWDVWDWLFGLVHDVHVWDWXV
ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGIURPSDWKRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQRIWKHUHVHFWLRQVSHFLPHQDQG)
ÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVH3(77XPRXUVZLWKEORRGÁRZYDOXHVEHORZWKHPHGLDQDQG
EORRGYROXPHPHDVXUHPHQWVDERYHWKHPHGLDQZHUHFRQVLGHUHGWRH[KLELW%)%9
PLVPDWFK7KHIUHTXHQF\RIPLVPDWFKDPRQJVWQRGHSRVLWLYHDQG0WXPRXUVZDV
FRPSDUHGWR1DQG0WXPRXUVXVLQJ)LVFKHUҋVH[DFWWHVW
5HVXOWV0HGLDQ%)DQG%9ZHUHPOPLQJDQGPOJUHVSHFWLYHO\
RIWXPRXUVGHPRQVWUDWHG%)%9PLVPDWFK0LVPDWFKZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUH
FRPPRQDPRQJVW0WXPRXUV YHUVXVS EXWQRWDPRQJVWQRGH
SRVLWLYHWXPRXUV YHUVXVS
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\SURYLGHVSUHOLPLQDU\HYLGHQFHRIDQDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQ
%)%9PLVPDWFKDQGWKHSUHVHQFHRIGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHVLQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU%)
%9PLVPDWFKPD\SRWHQWLDOO\SURYLGHDPDUNHURIWXPRXUDGDSWDWLRQWRK\SR[LD
%
'XDOVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\&7IRUOXQJFDQFHUHYDOXDWLRQFRUUHODWLRQ
VWXG\EHWZHHQZHLJKWHGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVDQGSDWKRORJLFDO
UHVXOWVRIWXPRXUOHVLRQ
<5DR:<DQJ%/LX/&DR<%X:&KDL.&KHQ6KDQJKDL&1
UR\B#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSDWKRORJLFDOVXEW\SHVRIOXQJFDQFHU
DQGWKHZHLJKWHGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQLQWKHWXPRXUOHVLRQIURPVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ
GXDOVRXUFHGXDOHQHUJ\ '6'( &7VFDQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKOXQJFDQFHUXQGHUZHQWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
GXDOHQHUJ\&7VFDQZKLFKZDVSHUIRUPHGVHFRQGVDIWHUWKHFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQ
PO&0DWPOV 7KH&7YDOXHV EOHQGHGYDOXHIURPKLJKDQGORZN9LPDJHV
DQGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQV PJPO IURPWKHWXPRXUDVZHOODVWKRVHIURPSXOPRQDU\
DUWHU\DQGDRUWDRQWKHVDPHLPDJHSODQHZHUHPHDVXUHGLQD'(SRVWSURFHVVLQJ
ZRUNVWDWLRQ7KH LRGLQH FRQFHQWUDWLRQV IURP WKH OHVLRQ ZHUH QRUPDOLVHG E\ WKH
LRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVRISXOPRQDU\DUWHU\DQGDRUWDGXHWRWKHGXDOEORRGVXSSO\
RIOXQJWXPRXUWRPLQLPLVHWKHSDWLHQWYDULDWLRQ6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
WRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHZHLJKWHGLRGLQHYDOXHRIWXPRXUDQG
FRUUHVSRQGLQJSDWKRORJLFDOUHVXOWV
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUHSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHGZLWKDGHQRFDUFLQRPDVDQG
SDWLHQWVZLWKVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPD7KHPHDQ&7YDOXHVSURYLGHGQRGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSV S +RZHYHUE\FRPSDULQJWKHZHLJKWHGLRGLQH
FRQFHQWUDWLRQVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZDVIRXQG S 7KHPHDQ
YDOXHRIZHLJKWHGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQZDVPJPOIRUDGHQRFDUFLQRPDV
JURXSDQGWKDWIRUVTXDPRXVFHOOFDUFLQRPDZDVPJPO
&RQFOXVLRQ 'XDO HQHUJ\ &7 VFDQ FRXOG EH D XVHIXO WRRO LQ GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ RI
SDWKRORJLFDOOXQJFDQFHUVXEW\SHVDVWKHZHLJKWHGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQIRUOXQJ
WXPRXUOHVLRQFRUUHODWHVZLWKWKHWXPRXUSDWKRORJLFDOVXEW\SHV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUHOLDELOLW\DQGUHSHDWDELOLW\RIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
WXPRXUSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ ZLWK KLJKUHVROXWLRQXOWUDVRXQG LQ FRORQFDQFHU
[HQRJUDIWVLQPLFH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV PLFH ZLWK VXEFXWDQHRXV FRORQFDQFHU[HQRJUDIW
WXPRXUPRGHOVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKD9HYRXOWUDVRXQGV\VWHP 9LVXDOVRQLFV
,QF7RURQWR&$ XVLQJD5090+]KLJKIUHTXHQF\WUDQVGXFHUDQGWKUHH
GLIIHUHQWPLFUREXEEOHFRQFHQWUDWLRQV [[[PLFUREXEEOHVP/
7KUHHVHSDUDWHѥ/EROXVLQMHFWLRQVRIHDFKPLFUREXEEOHFRQFHQWUDWLRQZHUH
H[DPLQHGLQHDFKWXPRXU7KHUHFRUGLQJRIHDFKG\QDPLFVWXG\ZDVWULJJHUHG
VHFRQGVSULRUWRWKHFRQWUDVWDJHQWLQMHFWLRQDQGDWRWDORILPDJHVZHUHUHFRUGHG
RYHUDVHFSHULRG7KHIROORZLQJVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVZHUH
H[WUDFWHG IURP WKH WLPHLQWHQVLW\ FXUYHV SHDN LQWHQVLW\ LQ DUELWUDU\ XQLWV $8
WLPHWRSHDNLQWHQVLW\ LQVHF DUHDXQGHUWKHWLPHLQWHQVLW\FXUYH $8& GXULQJ
ZDVKLQ LQ$8 DQGVORSHFRHIÀFLHQWRIWKHZDVKLQ LQ$8VHF 7KHFRHIÀFLHQWRI
YDULDWLRQZDVFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKG\QDPLFSDUDPHWHURIHDFKVHWRIPLFUREXEEOH
FRQFHQWUDWLRQVIRUHDFKWXPRXU
5HVXOWV3HDNLQWHQVLW\WLPHWRSHDNDVZHOODV$8&YDOXHVFRUUHODWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\
3 ZLWKPLFUREXEEOHFRQFHQWUDWLRQZKLOHVORSHFRHIÀFLHQWYDOXHVGLGQRW
3 7KHVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVIROORZLQJLQMHFWLRQVZLWK
WKH VDPH PLFUREXEEOHFRQFHQWUDWLRQ ZHUH REWDLQHG ZLWK YDU\LQJ UHOLDELOLW\ ZLWK
DFRHIÀFLHQWRIYDULDWLRQIRUSHDNLQWHQVLW\YDOXHVRIIRUWLPHWRSHDN
YDOXHVRIIRU$8&YDOXHVRIDQGIRUVORSHFRHIÀFLHQWYDOXHV
RI
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHHYDOXDWHGVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVGHPRQVWUDWH
DYDU\LQJUHOLDELOLW\DQGUHSHDWDELOLW\GXULQJG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGWXPRXU
SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJZLWKKLJKUHVROXWLRQXOWUDVRXQG
5HVXOWVPHGLDVWLQDOO\PSKQRGHVIURPWKHSDWLHQWVZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWK
SURYHGWREHPDOLJQDQWDWSDWKRORJ\H[DPLQDWLRQDQGEHQLJQ%\FRPSDULQJWKH
VL]HRIO\PSKQRGHVDQGWKHZHLJKWHGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHVZDVIRXQG ERWKZLWKS 7KHZHLJKWHGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQZDV
PJPO IRU PDOLJQDQW O\PSK QRGHV JURXS DQG WKRVH IRU EHQLJQ JURXS
ZDVPJPO
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHZHLJKWHGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQVIURP'(VFDQFRUUHODWHGZLWK
SDWKRORJLFDOUHVXOWVRIO\PSKQRGHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK16&/&7KHZHLJKWHGLRGLQH
FRQFHQWUDWLRQVFRXOGEHDQHZPHWKRGWRHYDOXDWHWKHPHGLDVWLQDOO\PSKQRGH
PHWDVWDVHVLQ16&/&
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'HYHORSPHQWRIQRQQHFURWLFWXPRXUYROXPHWU\FULWHULDIRU
HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHLQKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD
$.6LQJK9.XUUD:&DL*+DUULV'6DKDQL%RVWRQ0$86
9.855$#3$571(5625*
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHVWDWLVWLFDOYDULDEOHVGHULYHGE\H[LVWLQJ5(&,67DQGWRWDO
WXPRXU YROXPHWU\ 779 FULWHULDҋV DQG SURSRVHG QRQQHFURWLF WXPRXU YROXPHWU\
119 FULWHULDIRUDVVHVVLQJWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHLQKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDҋV +&&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVVWXG\SUHDQGSRVWWUHDWPHQW0'&7RISDWLHQWV
ZLWKSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ+&&ZHUHXVHG,QWHUYDOFKDQJHLQ779DQG119ZDV
HVWLPDWHGRQD'ZRUNVWDWLRQXVLQJ'TXDQWLÀFDWLRQWRROVRQ0'&7D[LDOVOLFHV
5(&,67PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRWKHLQWHUYDOFKDQJHLQWRWDOWXPRXU
YROXPH 779 DQGQRQQHFURWLFYROXPHFULWHULDҋV 119 ,QWHUPHWKRG.DSSDIRU
SUHGLFWLQJSDUWLDOUHJUHVVLRQVWDELOLW\DQGSURJUHVVLRQZDVGHULYHGDQGVWDWLVWLFDO
HVWLPDWHVRI.DSODQ0HLHUFXUYHVXUYLYDOFXUYHVGHULYHGE\HDFKPHWKRGZHUH
FRPSDUHG /RJLVWLF UHJUHVVLRQ DQDO\VLV ZDV XVHG WR GHULYH WKH PRVW DFFXUDWH
UHVSRQVHDVVHVVPHQWFULWHULD
5HVXOWV7KHNDSSDFRHIÀFLHQWVIRUWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHDJUHHPHQWUHPDLQHGSRRU
EHWZHHQWKHVHPHWKRGV ѣ 7KHRYHUDOOPHGLDQVXUYLYDOZDVPRQWKV
.DSODQ0HLHUFXUYHVZHUHPRUHRSWLPDOIRUSUHGLFWLQJVXUYLYDOE\SURSRVHG119
>PHGLDQVXUYLYDO PV UHVSRQVH 5 PRQWKVQRUHVSRQVH 15 PRQWKV
S@WKDQH[LVWLQJ779 PV5 P15 PS @DQG5(&,67
PV5 P15 PS FULWHULD V6WHSZLVHORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV
UHYHDOHGRGGVUDWLR 25 IRU119 DVWKHPRVWRSWLPDOLQWKHPRGHOFRPSDUHG
WR779 DQG5(&,67
&RQFOXVLRQ 4XDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI LQWHUYDO FKDQJH LQ QRQQHFURWLF WXPRXU YROXPH
PD\EHDPRUHREMHFWLYHDQGUHOLDEOHPHDVXUHIRUSUHGLFWLQJWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHLQ
+&&ҋVFRPSDUHGWRWKHH[LVWLQJWRWDOWXPRXUYROXPHDQG5(&,67FULWHULDҋV
DQGGHVHUYHVYDOLGDWLRQRQDODUJHUFRKRUW
%
$QJLRJHQHVLVLQQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHUHDUO\DVVHVVPHQW
RIWKHUDSHXWLFUHVSRQVHWRDQWLDQJLRJHQLFFKHPRWKHUDS\ZLWK
SHUIXVLRQPXOWLGHWHFWRUURZ&7 0'&7
17DFHOOL76DQWDQJHOR$6FKHUSHUHHO$/+DFKXOOD-5HP\
05pP\-DUGLQ/LOOH)5 QXQ]LDWDFHOOL#FKUXOLOOHIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWHPSRUDOFKDQJHVLQ&7SHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVXQGHUDQ
WLDQJLRJHQLFGUXJV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDUFLQRPDWUHDWHGE\
FKHPRWKHUDS\ SODWLQXPEDVHGDQGWKLUGJHQHUDWLRQGUXJV DORQH JURXSQ RU
FRPELQHGZLWKEHYDFL]XPDE JURXSQ XQGHUZHQWTXDQWLWDWLYH&7SHUIXVLRQ
H[DPLQDWLRQVZLWKVOLFH0'&7EHIRUH 7Q DQGDIWHUFKHPRWKHUDS\ 7
Q 7Q 7Q ZLWKDQLQWHUYDORIZHHNVEHWZHHQWKHUDSHXWLFVHV
VLRQV7KH&7SDUDPHWHUVHYDOXDWHGLQFOXGHG D WXPRXUEORRGYROXPH %9 DQG
FDSLOODU\SHUPHDELOLW\ &3 LQGH[HGWRWXPRXUYROXPH E 5(&,67PHDVXUHPHQWV
7KHOLQNEHWZHHQWKHUDSHXWLFUHVSRQVHDFFRUGLQJWR5(&,67FULWHULDDQGFKDQJHV
LQ&7IXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVZDVLQYHVWLJDWHG
5HVXOWV&RPSDULQJ7DQG7 D WKHPHGLDQYDOXHVRI%9DQG&3ZHUHVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\UHGXFHGLQJURXS %9DW7YV%9DW7P/S &3
DW7YV&3DW7P/PLQS ZLWKRXWDQ\FKDQJHLQWXPRXU
VL]H E IXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVGLGQRWFKDQJHLQJURXS&RPSDULQJ7DQG7
ERWKJURXSVGHPRQVWUDWHGUHGXFWLRQLQ%9 JURXSS JURXSS
DQG&3 JURXSS JURXSS ,QWKHRYHUDOOSRSXODWLRQDVLJ
QLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHLQ&3DW7ZDVIRXQGWREHVWURQJO\UHODWHGWRWKHUHGXFWLRQLQ
WXPRXUVL]H S DW7
&RQFOXVLRQ3HUIXVLRQ&7GHPRQVWUDWHVUHVWRUDWLRQRIWKHQHRYHVVHOZDOOVDIWHU
WKHÀUVWWKHUDSHXWLFVHVVLRQRIDQWLDQJLRJHQLFFKHPRWKHUDS\HQDEOLQJDVVHVVPHQW
RIWKHUDSHXWLFUHVSRQVHEHIRUHFKDQJHVLQ5(&,67FULWHULD
%
(DUO\GLDJQRVLVRIUHFXUUHQFHRISHULWRQHDOFDUFLQRPDWRVLV0'&7
FRUUHODWHGZLWKVHUXPWXPRXUPDUNHUV
070DFFDURQH5%DVLOLFR(5RGROÀQR9&DODPLWD$)HUUL0'H7XUVL
$5&RWURQHR&KLHWL,7
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRI0'&7LQWKHHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRISHULWRQHDOUHFXU
UHQFHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSHULWRQHDOFDUFLQRPDWRVLV 3& WUHDWHGE\PHDQVRIF\WRUH
GXFWLYHVXUJHU\DQG+,3(&LQFRPSDULVRQWRVHUXPWXPRXUPDUNHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\ÀYHSDWLHQWVZLWK3&IURPRYDULDQ Q FRORUHFWDO
Q WXPRXUVXWHULQHVDUFRPD Q IDOORSLDQWXEHWXPRXUV Q DQGSHULWRQHDO
OLSRVDUFRPD Q WUHDWHGE\PHDQVRIF\WRUHGXFWLYHVXUJHU\DQG+,3(&ZHUHLQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
FOXGHG7KH\XQGHUZHQWVHUXPWXPRXUPDUNHUPHDVXUHPHQWV &($&$ HYHU\
PRQWKDIWHUVXUJHU\DQG0'&7IROORZXSDWDQGPRQWKVLQWHUYDO7ZRUHDGHUV
LQFRQVHQVXVHYDOXDWHGD[LDODQGPXOWLSODQDUUHFRQVWUXFWHG0'&7LPDJHVRIWKH
DEGRPHQREWDLQHGGXULQJWKHSRUWDOYHQRXVSKDVHRIFRQWUDVWPDWHULDOHQKDQFH
PHQWZLWKDFROOLPDWLRQRI[PPDQGDVOLFHZLGWKRIPP0'&7ÀQGLQJV
ZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKWXPRXUPDUNHUVPHDVXUHPHQWVREWDLQHGZLWKLQGD\V
5HVXOWV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ZHUHUHVSHFWLYHO\
DQGIRUVHUXPWXPRXUPDUNHUVDQGDQGIRU0'&7,Q
SDWLHQWVZLWKQRUPDOWXPRXUPDUNHUV0'&7VKRZHGSHULWRQHDOQHRSODVWLF
LPSODQWVFRQÀUPHGDWSDWKRORJ\DQG0'&7IROORZXS,QSDWLHQWVZLWKQRUPDO
WXPRXUPDUNHUOHYHOV0'&7UHYHDOHGRQHSHULWRQHDOQRGXOHGHPRQVWUDWHGWREH
QHFURWLFOHVLRQDWSDWKRORJ\
&RQFOXVLRQ0'&7LVDEOHWRHDUO\GHWHFWSHULWRQHDOUHFXUUHQFHLQSDWLHQWVWUHDWHG
E\ PHDQV RI F\WRUHGXFWLYH VXUJHU\ DQG +,3(& DQG FDQ SUHGDWH ULVLQJ WXPRXU
PDUNHUVOHYHOV
%
0XOWLPRGDOLPDJLQJIRUWKHUDS\PRQLWRULQJRIORFRUHJLRQDODOSKD
WKHUDS\ %L'27$72& LQSDWLHQWVZLWKKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVHVRI
QHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUV
)/*LHVHO&=HFKPDQQ6:XOIHUW+8.DXF]RU)%UXFKHUWVHLIHU
$0RUJHQVWHUQ8+DEHUNRUQ&.UDWRZFKLO)/*LHVHO+HLGHOEHUJ'(
.DUOVUXKH'( IJLHVHO#GNI]GH
3XUSRVH5DGLRODEHOOHGVRPDWRVWDWLQDQDORJVSOD\DQHPHUJLQJUROHLQWKHWKHUDS\
RISDWLHQWVZLWKQHXURHQGRFULQHFDQFHUV7KHÀUVWLQKXPDQSHSWLGUHFHSWRUDOSKD
WKHUDS\ZLWK%L'27$72&ZDVDVVHVVHGZLWKPXOWLPRGDOLPDJLQJ 05,3(7
&7DQG86 IRULQLWLDOWKHUDS\PRQLWRULQJDQGVXUYHLOODQFHRISRVVLEOHORFDOVLGH
HIIHFWVRIWKLVQHZDSSURDFK
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q SDWLHQWV WKH UHFHQWO\ LQWURGXFHG DOSKDSDUWLFOH
HPLWWLQJ%L'27$72&ZDVDGPLQLVWHUHGORFRUHJLRQDOLQWKHOLYHU0XOWLPRGDO
LPDJLQJRIOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJ05,ZLWKVWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHVDQG
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':05, EHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHUDS\7KLVPRGDOLW\GHOLY
HUVWKHOHVLRQGLDPHWHU /' DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& DVDVXUURJDWHRI
WXPRXULQWHJULW\DVDVXUURJDWHRIWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQ,QDGGLWLRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
XOWUDVRXQG &(86 ZDVDFFRPSOLVKHGDVDQRQVLWHLPDJLQJPRGDOLW\WRDVVHVV
WXPRXUPLFURYDVFXODULVDWLRQ WLPHWRSHDN 773
5HVXOWV,QWKHHDUO\05DQDO\VLVPRVWPHWDVWDVHVGHPRQVWUDWHGRQO\DPRGHU
DWHGHFUHDVHLQ/'ZKHUHDVPHGLDQWXPRXU$'&DVDUHSUHVHQWDWLYHRIWXPRXU
LQWHJULW\ LQFUHDVHG IURP [ PPVHF WR [ PPVHF ZHHNV
DIWHUODVWORFRUHJLRQDOWKHUDS\3ULRUWRWKHUDSHXWLFLQWHUYHQWLRQ&(86SUHVHQWHG
DSURQRXQFHGHQKDQFHPHQWLQWKHOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVFRPSDUHGWRWKHDGMDFHQWOLYHU
SDUHQFK\PD PHGLDQ773PHWDVWDVLV VHFPHGLDQ773OLYHUSDUHQFK\PD
VHF PRQWKVDIWHULQWHUYHQWLRQWKHLD%LWUHDWHGSDWLHQWVVKRZHGD
GHFOLQHLQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKLVRQJRLQJVWXG\&(86GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGDQGSHUIXVLRQ05,
ZHUH DEOH WR GHPRQVWUDWH VXFK WXPRXU FKDQJHV DOVR HDUO\ DIWHU WUHDWPHQW ZLWK
DOSKDWKHUDS\7KHUHIRUH WKLV IXQFWLRQDO WXPRXU LPDJLQJ DVVHVVPHQW VHHPV WR
EHDUHOLDEOHELRVXUURJDWHRIWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHDQGPLJKWSUHGLFWLQDQHDUO\
VWDJHOHVLRQUHVSRQVHV
5RRP)
%UHDVW
66
6FUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\DQG&$'
0RGHUDWRUV
(0)DOOHQEHUJ%HUOLQ'(
36NDDQH2VOR12
%
9DULDWLRQVLQVFUHHQLQJRXWFRPHDPRQJSDLUVRIUDGLRORJLVWV
DWLQGHSHQGHQWGRXEOHUHDGLQJRIVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPVD
SRSXODWLRQEDVHGVWXG\
9YDQ%UHHVW6PDOOHQEXUJ-1HGHUHQG(*.ORPSHQKRXZHU/(0'XLMP
(LQGKRYHQ1/ /(0'XLMP#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHYDULDWLRQVLQVFUHHQLQJRXWFRPHDPRQJXQLTXHSDLUVRI
UDGLRORJLVWVDWLQGHSHQGHQWGRXEOHUHDGLQJRIVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H LQFOXGHG SDLUV RI VFUHHQLQJ UDGLRORJLVWV ZLWK D
PLQLPXPRIVFUHHQLQJH[DPLQDWLRQVSHUSDLUREWDLQHGDWD'XWFKVFUHHQLQJ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
PDPPRJUDSK\ UHJLRQ EHWZHHQ -DQXDU\ DQG$XJXVW 'XULQJ \HDU
IROORZXS EUHDVW LPDJLQJ UHSRUWV VXUJLFDO UHSRUWV DQG SDWKRORJ\ UHVXOWV ZHUH
FROOHFWHGRIDOOVFUHHQGHWHFWHGFDQFHUVDQGLQWHUYDOFDQFHUV6FUHHQLQJRXWFRPH
SDUDPHWHUVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKVFUHHQLQJFRXSOH
5HVXOWV$PLQLPXPRIVFUHHQVIRUHDFKSDLURIUDGLRORJLVWVKDGEHHQUHDG
E\XQLTXHFRPELQDWLRQVRIWZRVFUHHQLQJUDGLRORJLVWVWRWDOOLQJVFUHHQV
7KHQXPEHURIVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPVSHUSDLURIUDGLRORJLVWVYDULHGIURP
VFUHHQV WR VFUHHQV %UHDVW FDQFHU LQFLGHQFH GLG QRW GLIIHU VLJQLÀFDQWO\
DPRQJ WKHVH FRXSOHV DQG UDQJHG IURP &, WR &,
SHUVFUHHQV7KHUHIHUUDOUDWHDPRQJFRXSOHVUDQJHGIURP
&, WR &, ZKHUHDVWKHVHQVLWLYLW\IRUEUHDVW
FDQFHUGHWHFWLRQDQGWKHSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIUHIHUUDOUDQJHGIURP
&, WR &, DQGIURP &,
WR &, UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ 6FUHHQLQJ RXWFRPH YDULHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ DPRQJ SDLUV RI VFUHHQLQJ
UDGLRORJLVWV:HDGYLVHDFRQWLQXRXVPRQLWRULQJRIVFUHHQLQJRXWFRPHSDUDPHWHUV
IRUHDFKVFUHHQLQJFRXSOHWKDWSDUWLFLSDWHVDWVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\5HJXODU
IHHGEDFNRIWKLVRXWFRPHWRHDFKFRXSOHPD\DYRLGVFUHHQLQJRIZRPHQE\SDLUV
RIUDGLRORJLVWVZLWKVXERSWLPDOVFUHHQLQJSHUIRUPDQFH
%
7DLORUHGEUHDVWFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPLQHUVUHVXOWVIURP
DQ,WDOLDQVLQJOHFHQWUHSLORWVWXG\
(6FKLDQL33DQL]]D05RGLJKLHUR,)HGHOH(9HQWXULQL&/RVLR
)'H&REHOOL$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,7 VFKLDQLHOHQD#KVULW
%
3KHQRW\SLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRILQWHUYDOEUHDVWFDQFHUVGLDJQRVHGLQD
SRSXODWLRQEDVHGVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPLQ&DWDORQLD6SDLQ&RUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKUDGLRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV
'/HRQ*XHYDUD$*XPD0DUWLQH]/3ULHWR$OYDUH]52UWHJD0DUWLQH]
$9DOGLYLHOVR&9LGDO/DQFLV0*DUFLD0DUWLQH]%DUFHORQD(6
+RVSLWDOHWGH/OREUHJDW(6
3XUSRVH7RDQDO\]HLIWKHUHDUHSKHQRW\SLFGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQSUHYDOHQWLQFL
GHQWDQGLQWHUYDOFDVHVRIEUHDVWFDQFHUVGLDJQRVHGLQDEUHDVWFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJ
SURJUDPLQ&DWDORQLD6SDLQ7R&RUUHODWHWKHGDWDZLWKWKHUDGLRJUDSKLFSUHVHQWD
WLRQRIWKHVHWXPRUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSHUIRUPHGDUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\RIDOOEUHDVWFDQFHUV
GLDJQRVHGLQWKHVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPEHWZHHQDQDO\]LQJKLVWRORJLFDO
W\SHSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVDQGUDGLRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV6XEJURXSVZHUHPDGHRISUHYD
OHQWLQFLGHQWRUHDUO\LQWHUYDOFDVHV
5HVXOWV:HKDYHVWXGLHGFDVHVLQYDVLYHFDUFLQRPDVDQGLQWUDGXFWDO
FDUFLQRPDV,QWHUYDOEUHDVWFDQFHUFDVHVZHUHLQYDVLYHFDUFLQRPDVLQDQG
LQVLWX$QDO\VLVRIUDGLRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVDQGSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVZDVDFKLHYHG
LQFDQFHUFDVHV7KHWULSOHQHJDWLYHSKHQRW\SHZDVPRUHIUHTXHQWLQLQWHUYDO
LQYDVLYHFDUFLQRPDVFDVHV WKDQLQFDQFHUVGHWHFWHGDWVFUHHQLQJ
7KLVGLIIHUHQFHZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW S 3KHQRW\SLFW\SH+HU
DQGOXPLQDO$ WXPRUVZHUHPRUHIUHTXHQWLQEUHDVWFDQFHUFDVHVGHWHFWHG
LQVFUHHQLQJFRPSDUHGWRLQWHUYDOFDVHV DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ DOWKRXJK
QRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW5DGLRORJLFDOO\WULSOHQHJDWLYHWXPRUVZHUHPRUHRIWHQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
6WDJHVSHFLÀFLQFLGHQFHUDWHVRIEUHDVWFDQFHULQSDUWLFLSDQWVDQG
QRQSDUWLFLSDQWVRIDSRSXODWLRQEDVHGPDPPRJUDSKLFVFUHHQLQJ
SURJUDPPH
6+RIYLQG&,/HH-*(OPRUH2VOR12/RV$QJHOHV&$86
6HDWWOH:$86 VROYHLJKRIYLQG#NUHIWUHJLVWHUHWQR
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH VWDJHVSHFLÀF LQFLGHQFH RI EUHDVW FDQFHU LQ WKH WDUJHW
SRSXODWLRQRIWKH1RUZHJLDQ%UHDVW&DQFHU6FUHHQLQJ3URJUDPPH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H FRPSDUHG WKH LQFLGHQFH DPRQJ LQYLWHG
ZRPHQ DJHG \HDUV ZKR UHFHLYHG LQYLWDWLRQV DQG VWUDWLÀHG WKH
DQDO\VHVE\LQYLWHGSDUWLFLSDQWVDQGLQYLWHGQRQSDUWLFLSDQWV7ZRVLGHGFKLVTXDUH
WHVWVZHUHXVHGWRGHWHUPLQHVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHEHWZHHQJURXSV
5HVXOWV7KHLQFLGHQFHRIEUHDVWPDOLJQDQF\ '&,6RULQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDQFHU
ZDVWLPHVKLJKHULQLQYLWHGSDUWLFLSDQWVFRPSDUHGZLWKLQYLWHGQRQSDUWLFLSDQWV
YHUVXV S )RU LQYDVLYH EUHDVW FDQFHUV
RQO\ WKH UDWH UDWLR ZDV 7KH LQFLGHQFH RI VWDJH , FDQFHU ZDV WZR WLPHV
KLJKHUIRUSDUWLFLSDQWV LQYLWDWLRQV FRPSDUHGZLWKQRQSDUWLFLSDQWV
LQYLWDWLRQV S ZKLOH WKH LQFLGHQFH RI VWDJH ,,, FDQFHU
ZDVORZHUDQGVWDJH,9FDQFHUORZHU SIRUERWK 7KHUDWHRI
PDVWHFWRP\ZDVKLJKHULQSDUWLFLSDQWVWKDQLQQRQSDUWLFLSDQWVFRPSDUHGZLWK
LQYLWHGQRQSDUWLFLSDQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ3DUWLFLSDQWVLQDQRUJDQLVHGEUHDVWFDQFHUVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPUXQD
KLJKHUULVNRIVWDJHDQG,EUHDVWFDQFHUDQGORZHUULVNRIDGYDQFHGEUHDVWFDQFHU
FRPSDUHGZLWKLQYLWHGQRQSDUWLFLSDQWV(IIRUWVWRVXSSRUWHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIEUHDVW
FDQFHULQQRQSDUWLFLSDQWVLQRUJDQLVHGVFUHHQLQJDUHQHHGHG
%
3URSRUWLRQDOLQFLGHQFHDQGUHYLHZRI7VFUHHQGHWHFWHG
FDUFLQRPDVDQHZPHDVXUHRIGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\"
6&LDWWR'%HUQDUGL03HOOHJULQL)&DXPR$)ULJHULR0*HQWLOLQL
7UHQWR,79HURQD,77XULQ,7 VWHIDQRFLDWWR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH/DUJHVL]H 7 VFUHHQGHWHFWHGWKDWFDUFLQRPDVPLJKWEHDVVXPHG
DVVFUHHQLQJIDLOXUHVDQGPRQLWRUHGIRUTXDOLW\FRQWURODVLQWHUYDOFDQFHUV ,&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%DVHGRQ7FDQFHUVVFUHHQGHWHFWHGGXULQJ
DW7UHQWRVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPHZHD DVVHVVHGWKHSURSRUWLRQDOLQFLGHQFH
DVFRPSDUHGWRSUHVFUHHQLQJ LQFLGHQFHDQGE UHYLHZHGSUHYLRXV
VFUHHQLQJWHVWVSUHFHGLQJGLDJQRVLV%OLQGUHYLHZRIÀOPVPL[HG WRQHJDWLYH
FRQWUROVZDVSHUIRUPHGE\DSDQHORIWKUHHH[WHUQDOUHYLHZHUVVFUHHQLQJHUURUV
EHLQJGHÀQHGDFFRUGLQJWRPDMRULW\ FDQFHUVVHHQE\DWOHDVWWZRUHYLHZHUV $
VXEVHWRI,&GLDJQRVHGGXULQJZDVLQFOXGHGLQWKHUHYLHZVHW
5HVXOWV 3URSRUWLRQDO LQFLGHQFH ZRPHQ \HDU ZDV RE
VHUYHGH[SHFWHGFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDOKLJKHUDVFRPSDUHGWR
UHFHQWO\GHWHUPLQHGIRU,&LQWKHVDPHFHQWUH5HYLHZRI
7,&DQGFRQWUROVFODVVLÀHGVFUHHQLQJHUURUVDPRQJ,&
DQGDPRQJ7 S 'LIIHUHQFHVLQGHWHF
WLRQDQGUHFDOOUDWHREVHUYHGDPRQJUHYLHZHUVZHUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
&RQFOXVLRQ$VVHVVLQJ7 SURSRUWLRQDO LQFLGHQFH DQG UHYLHZ LV IHDVLEOH DV D
PRGDOLW\IRUVFUHHQLQJVXUYHLOODQFH7DVVHVVPHQWLVHDVLHUDVFRPSDUHGWR,&
EXWQRUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGVDUHDYDLODEOH\HWSDUWLFXODUO\IRUSURSRUWLRQDOLQFLGHQFH
ZKLFKZDVKLJKHUDVFRPSDUHGWR,&&RPSDUDEOHUHYLHZÀQGLQJVEHWZHHQ7
DQG,&FDVHVPLJKWVXJJHVWWRDGRSWWKH(&VWDQGDUG DOVRIRU7)XUWKHU
VWXGLHVDUHQHHGHGWRFRQÀUPWKHSUHVHQWUHVXOWV
%
,QFLGHQFHDQGUHYLHZRILQWHUYDOFDQFHUVLQDFRPPXQLW\ELDQQXDO
PDPPRJUDSKLFVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPH
/$&DUERQDUR%%DEDHL3DVNHK*%UDPELOOD30DOHUED
/0HQLFDJOL*9DGDODҋ/)DQWLQL6&LDWWR)6DUGDQHOOL
6DQ'RQDWR0LODQHVH,75R]]DQR,79L]]ROR3UHGDELVVL,7/DFFKLDUHOOD,7
3DGXD,7 OXFDFDUERQDUR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQ,WDOLDQPDPPRJUDSKLFVFUHHQLQJSUR
JUDPPHLQWHUPVRILQWHUYDOFDQFHUV ,&V REVHUYHGIURPWR
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,&VZHUHLGHQWLÀHGE\PDWFKLQJWKHVFUHHQLQJDUFKLYHV
ZLWK ORFDO FDQFHU UHJLVWU\ SDWKRORJ\ DUFKLYHV DQG KRVSLWDO GLVFKDUJH UHFRUGV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIDVFUHHQLQJSURJUDP
RQHUVXVXDOO\HUVDUHQRWLQFOXGHGLQVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPGXHWRWKH
ORZVHQVLWLYLW\DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIPDPPRJUDSK\LQWKLVSRSXODWLRQ
2XULQQRYDWLYHVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPLVWDLORUHGRQLQGLYLGXDOULVNSURÀOHDQGEUHDVW
WLVVXHGHQVLW\DQGLPSOHPHQWVPDPPRJUDSK\ZLWKIXUWKHUDVVHVVPHQW 8605,
XVXDOO\QRWLQFOXGHGLQHYDOXDWLRQRIÀUVWOHYHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP6HSWHPEHUWR0D\ZHLQYLWHG
ZRPHQIURPWKHWRZQRI6HJUDWH 0LODQ,WDO\ /RZGRVHSKRWRQFRXQWLQJGLJLWDO
PDPPRJUDSK\ 6HFWUD ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQYLHZV &&0/2 7KH86DQG05,
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGZKHQQHHGHG
5HVXOWVZRPHQZHUHHQUROOHG SDUWLFLSDWLRQUDWH 7KHDYHUDJH
JODQGXODUGRVHZDVZLWKDQDYHUDJHEUHDVWWKLFNQHVVRIPP7KHUHFDOO
UDWHIRU86ZDV7KHUHFDOOUDWHIRU05,ZDV 7KH86
HDUO\ UHFDOO UDWH ZDV 7KH FDQFHU GHWHFWLRQ UDWH ZDV Æ FDVHV
(LJKWFDQFHUVZHUHGLDJQRVHGZLWKPDPPRJUDSK\DQGWZRZHUHGHWHFWDEOHRQO\
DW86 86,&'586IDOVHSRVLWLYHV
&RQFOXVLRQ3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVGHPRQVWUDWHGDQHOHYDWHGEUHDVWFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQ
UDWH Æ LQZRPHQHUVKLJKHUWKDQWKHLQFLGHQFHUHSRUWHGE\WKH,WDOLDQ
&DQFHU5HJLVWU\ 7KH86H[DPLQDWLRQSHUIRUPHGIRUKLJKEUHDVWWLVVXH
GHQVLW\DOORZVWRGHWHFWRWKHUWZRFDVHVRIFDQFHU
FLUFXPVFULEHGDQGKDGLOOGHÀQHGPDUJLQVZLWKRXWPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVZLWKDUHDV
RIQHFURVLVDQGSRVWHULRUDFRXVWLFHQKDQFHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ$QDO\VLV RI SURJQRVWLF IDFWRUV LQ EUHDVW FDUFLQRPDV FRQÀUPV WKDW
LQWHUYDOFDVHVDUHPRUHDJJUHVVLYHWKDQWKRVHGLDJQRVHGLQVFUHHQLQJ7KHUD
GLRORJLFDOSUHVHQWDWLRQPD\SUHGLFWFOLQLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQGKLVWRORJLFDOW\SH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
3URSRUWLRQDOLQFLGHQFHZDVGHWHUPLQHGDFFRUGLQJWREUHDVWFDQFHUVH[SHFWHGLQ
WKHDEVHQFHRIVFUHHQLQJHVWLPDWHGRQWKHEDVLVRISDWLHQWV\HDUDWULVNDQGDJH
VSHFLÀFLQFLGHQFH7KUHHRIIVLWHKLJKH[SHULHQFHGUHYLHZHUVEOLQGO\HYDOXDWHGWKH
VFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPVSULRUWRWKHGLDJQRVWLFRQHVUDQGRPO\PL[HGZLWKDJH
DQGEUHDVWGHQVLW\PDWFKHGQHJDWLYHFRQWUROVZLWKDUDWLR
5HVXOWVÀUVWOHYHOPDPPRJUDPVLQFHQWHUVZHUHDFTXLUHGWKHPHDQ
UHFDOOUDWHZDVDWÀUVWVFUHHQLQJDQGDWUHSHDWVFUHHQLQJ$WRWDORI
VFUHHQGHWHFWHGFDQFHUVDQG,&VZHUHGLDJQRVHG7KH,&SURSRUWLRQDOLQFL
GHQFHZDV IRUWKHÀUVW\HDU IRUWKHVHFRQG\HDUDQG
IRUWKHWZR\HDULQWHUYDO2I&,PDPPRJUDPVDWRWDORIRI
WKHP UDQGRPO\PL[HGZLWKQHJDWLYHFRQWUROVZHUHUHYLHZHG
ZHUHUHFDOOHGE\RUUHYLHZHUV HUURUV ZHUHUHFDOOHG
E\RQO\UHYLHZHU PLQLPDOVLJQV DQG ZHUHQRWUHFDOOHG RFFXOW
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPHFDQEHFRQVLGHUHGZLWKLQ(&VWDQGDUGV
IRUZKDWFRQFHUQV,&DQDO\VLV
%
3UHVRUWLQJE\&$'DFFRUGLQJWROHVLRQW\SHLQFUHDVLQJWKHUHDGHUҋV
DZDUHQHVVRIPDPPRJUDSKLFOHVLRQVLQDVFUHHQLQJHQYLURQPHQW
5/HGHUPDQ,/HLFKWHU0*UHHQEHUJ-HUXVDOHP,/ L]KDN#KDGDVVDKRUJLO
3XUSRVH7RH[SORUHWKHFDSDELOLW\RI&$'UXQLQWKHEDFNJURXQGWRDXWRPDWLFDOO\
SUHVRUWSULRULWLVHGVXEJURXSVZLWKKLJKHUSUHYDOHQFHRIHLWKHUPDOLJQDQWPDVVHV
RUFOXVWHUV.QRZLQJWKDWSUHYDOHQFHLVLQFUHDVHGIRUHLWKHUOHVLRQW\SHUHDGHUV
VKRXOGUHYLHZWKHWDJJHGFDVHVZLWKKLJKHUVXVSLFLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6LQFHEUHDVWFDQFHUVDUHXVXDOO\YLVLEOHLQERWKYLHZV
&$'FDQSUHVRUWFDVHVZLWKPDWFKLQJ&$'PDUNVRIWKHVDPHW\SHLQERWKYLHZV
FUHDWLQJ SULRULWLVHG VXEJURXSV ZLWK LQFUHDVHG SUHYDOHQFH RI PDOLJQDQW FOXVWHUV
RU PDVVHV$OWKRXJK IDOVH PDUNV WHQG WR RFFXU UDQGRPO\ WKHVH VXEJURXSV ZLOO
DOVRLQFOXGHQRUPDOFDVHVVLQFHPDWFKLQJIDOVHPDUNVPD\DOVR EHJHQHUDWHG
LQERWKYLHZVFRLQFLGHQWO\))'0FDVHV FDQFHUVPDVVHV FXOOHG
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\IURPIDFLOLWLHVZHUHUXQZLWKDSURWRW\SH&$'DOJRULWKP 6LHPHQV
DQGSUHVRUWHGE\PDWFKLQJPDUNVDFFRUGLQJWROHVLRQW\SHWRH[SORUHWKHFDQFHU
SUHYDOHQFHLQWKHSULRULWLVHGVXEJURXSV
5HVXOWV2IQRUPDOFDVHV FDVHV KDGFRLQFLGHQWDOO\PDWFKLQJPDVV
PDUNVDQG PDWFKLQJFOXVWHUPDUNV&RQYHUVHO\RIWKHPDOLJQDQWFDVHV
KDGPDWFKLQJPDVVPDUNVDQG KDGPDWFKLQJFOXVWHUPDUNV
,QWKHVXEJURXSZLWKPDWFKLQJPDVVPDUNVFDQFHUSUHYDOHQFHWKXVLQFUHDVHG
WLPHVIURPWR RI ZKLOHIRUFOXVWHUVFDQFHUSUHYDOHQFH
LQFUHDVHGWLPHVIURPWR RI
&RQFOXVLRQ 3UHVRUWLQJ E\ PDWFKLQJ &$' PDUNV VXEVWDQWLDOO\ LQFUHDVHV WKH
EUHDVWFDQFHUSUHYDOHQFHLQWKHSULRULWLVHGVXEJURXSVRIFDVHVHVSHFLDOO\LQWKH
FOXVWHU VXEJURXS WKHUHE\ IRFXVLQJ WKH UHDGHUVҋ DWWHQWLRQ RQ FDVHV ZKLFK DUH
PRUHVXVSLFLRXV
%
&DQ&$'EHXVHGDVDSUHOLPLQDU\UHDGHULQVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\"
5/HGHUPDQ,/HLFKWHU0*UHHQEHUJ-HUXVDOHP,/ L]KDN#KDGDVVDKRUJLO
3XUSRVH 7R H[SORUH WKH SRWHQWLDO RI &$' DV D SUHOLPLQDU\ UHDGHU UXQ LQ WKH
EDFNJURXQGLQVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDSK\WRUHGXFHUHDGLQJWLPHE\FUHDWLQJIRU
WKHUDGLRORJLVWVXEVHWVRIQRUPDOFDVHVDQGRIFDVHVFRQVLGHUHGVXVSLFLRXVIRUD
VSHFLÀFOHVLRQW\SH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ))'0 FDVHV ZHUH UXQ ZLWK D SURWRW\SH &$'
GHYLFH 6LHPHQV ZLWK VHSDUDWH DOJRULWKPV IRU GHWHFWLQJ PDVVHV DQG FOXVWHUV
7KH PDOLJQDQW FDVHV LQFOXGHG PDVVHV FOXVWHUV DQG PDVVHV ZLWK
PLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQV :KHQ XVLQJ &$' DV D SUHOLPLQDU\ UHDGHU WKH DOJRULWKP LV
GHVLJQHGWRFUHDWHVXEVHWVRIFDVHVVXVSLFLRXVIRUHLWKHUPDVVHVRUFOXVWHUVGL
UHFWLQJUDGLRORJLVWVWRVHOHFWWKHDSSURSULDWHYLVXDOSURFHVVIRUÀQGLQJWKHVSHFLÀF
OHVLRQW\SH7KHUHPDLQLQJFDVHVZLWKQRPDUNVIRUWKDWOHVLRQW\SHE\SDVVUHYLHZ
5HVXOWV&$'IRXQGRQO\RIWKHQRUPDOFDVHVWREHVXVSLFLRXVIRUFOXVWHUV
DQGWREHVXVSLFLRXVIRUPDVVHV)RUPDOLJQDQWFDVHVZLWKFOXVWHUVWKH
DOJRULWKPVXVSHFWHGFOXVWHUVLQIRUPDOLJQDQWFDVHVZLWKPDVVHV
ZHUHVXVSLFLRXVIRUPDVVHVDQGIRUFDVHVRIPDVVHVZLWKFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
ZHUHVXVSLFLRXVIRUHLWKHUOHVLRQW\SHRUERWK
&RQFOXVLRQ &$' DV D SUHOLPLQDU\ UHDGHU LQ VFUHHQLQJ PDPPRJUDSK\ FRXOG
VXEVWDQWLDOO\UHGXFHWKHZRUNORDGE\QHDUO\KDOIIRUHLWKHUOHVLRQW\SH8VLQJ&$'
DVDSUHOLPLQDU\UHDGHUIRUFOXVWHUVPLJKWZDUUDQWFRQVLGHUDWLRQVLQFHRQO\DERXW
RI PDVVHV ZLWK FDOFLÀFDWLRQV DQG RI FOXVWHUV ZRXOG EH PLVVHG 5HFHQW
DOJRULWKPPRGLÀFDWLRQVWRLPSURYHGHWHFWLRQRIPDVVHVDQGFOXVWHUVVKRXOGPDNH
WKLVDSSURDFKSUDFWLFDOIRUPDVVHVDVZHOO
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
6WDQGDORQHFRPSXWHUDLGHGGHWHFWLRQFRPSDUHGWRKXPDQUHDGHUV
IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIEUHDVWFDQFHULQVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPV
1.DUVVHPHLMHU5+XSVH06DPXOVNL0/REEHV$GHQ+HHWHQ
1LMPHJHQ1/0DDVWULFKW1/ QNDUVVHPHLMHU#UDGXPFQQO
3XUSRVH :H GHYHORSHG D FRPSXWHUDLGHG GHWHFWLRQ &$' V\VWHP DLPHG DW
GHFLVLRQVXSSRUWIRUGHWHFWLRQRIPDOLJQDQWPDVVHVLQVFUHHQLQJPDPPRJUDPV,Q
FRQWUDVWWRFXUUHQW&$'V\VWHPVZKLFKKDYHPDQ\IDOVHSRVLWLYHVGXHWRWKHLUIRFXV
RQKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\WKLVV\VWHPLVDLPHGWRRSHUDWHDWKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\FRPSDUDEOH
WRWKDWRIUDGLRORJLVW7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHWKHSHUIRUPDQFH
RIWKLV&$'V\VWHPWRWKDWRIUDGLRORJLVWVDQGUHVLGHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\HLJKWFHUWLÀHGVFUHHQLQJUDGL
RORJLVWVDQGWKUHHUHVLGHQWVZLWKPDPPRJUDSK\H[SHULHQFHUHDGVFUHHQLQJ
PDPPRJUDPV ZLWKRXW WKH XVH RI &$' &DVHV LQFOXGHG VFUHHQGHWHFWHG
FDQFHUVPLVVHGFDQFHUVIDOVHSRVLWLYHVIURPVFUHHQLQJDQGQRUPDOV
0LFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQFDVHVZHUHH[FOXGHG5HDGHUVDQG&$'ZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJ
ORFDOLVDWLRQ52& /52& DQDO\VLVE\FRPSXWLQJWKHPHDQWUXHSRVLWLYHIUDFWLRQ
073) DWDIDOVHSRVLWLYHIUDFWLRQ )3) OHVVWKDQ
5HVXOWV &$' SHUIRUPDQFH 073) ZDV VLPLODU WR WKDW RI WKH UHVLGHQWV
073) EXW VWLOO VLJQLÀFDQWO\ EHORZ WKH SHUIRUPDQFH RI WKH UDGLRORJLVWV
073) +RZHYHUDWYHU\KLJKVSHFLÀFLW\ )3) DQGIRUWKHVXEVHW
RIFDVHVPLVVHGLQVFUHHQLQJ&$'VWDQGDORQHSHUIRUPDQFHZDVVLPLODUWRWKDW
RIWKHUDGLRORJLVWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQRYHO&$'V\VWHPDLPHGDWGHFLVLRQVXSSRUW
LVDSSURDFKLQJWKHOHYHORISHUIRUPDQFHRIH[SHULHQFHGKXPDQUHDGHUV7KHVH
UHVXOWVVKRZWKHSRWHQWLDORI&$'WREHXVHGDVVHFRQGRUWKLUGUHDGHULQEUHDVW
FDQFHUVFUHHQLQJ
%
5HWURVSHFWLYHFRPSDULVRQRIWKHDFFXUDF\RIWZRGLIIHUHQWFRPSXWHU
DLGHGGHWHFWLRQV\VWHPVIRUGHWHFWLQJPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVRQPDPPRJUDSK\
0/REEHV..H\PHXOHQ06PLGW5*%HHWV7DQ-(:LOGEHUJHU
&%RHWHV0DDVWULFKW1/
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHWKHDFFXUDF\RIWZRFRPSXWHUDLGHGGHWHF
WLRQ &$' V\VWHPV 6HFRQG/RRNYHUVXV$FFX'HWHFW*DOLOHR IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRI
PDOLJQDQWEUHDVWOHVLRQVRQIXOOÀHOGGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 'LJLWDO PDPPRJUDPV RI SDWLHQWV ZHUH DQDO\VHG
SDWLHQWVZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHUQHJDWLYHFDVHV 3RVLWLYHFDVHVFRQVLVWHGRI
PDVVHVFDOFLÀFDWLRQVDQGPDVVHVSOXVFDOFLÀFDWLRQV(DFKVHWRIFDVHV
ZDVUHDGE\ERWK&$'V\VWHPVDQGWUXHSRVLWLYHIUDFWLRQ 73) IRUERWKV\VWHPV
DQGSHULPDJHFDVHDQGWRWDOFDQFHUVZDVDVVHVVHG2SHUDWLQJSRLQWVIRUERWK
V\VWHPVZDVVHWDWFRPSDUDEOHIDOVHSRVLWLYHUDWHVSHULPDJHDQGFDVH2QHVLGHG
H[DFW0F1HPDUҋVWHVWVZHUHXVHGWRDVVHVVVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHRIWKHUHVXOWV
5HVXOWV :KHQ FRPSDUHG WR 6HFRQG/RRN$FFX'HWHFW *DOLOHR VLJQLÀFDQWO\ LQ
FUHDVHG73)SHULPDJHIRUPDVVHV LQFUHDVHRIWRS DQG
FDOFLÀFDWLRQV LQFUHDVHRIWRS 3HUFDVH$FFX'HWHFW*DOLOHR
GLGQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVH73)IRUPDVVHVDQGFDOFLÀFDWLRQV$FFX'HWHFW*DOLOHR
DFKLHYHGKLJKHU73)IRUDOOFDQFHUV SHULPDJHLQFUHDVHWRWRSHU
FDVHLQFUHDVHWRWR 0RVWLQWHUHVWLQJO\$FFX'HWHFW*DOLOHRXVLQJD
QHZYRWLQJPHWKRGRORJ\DOJRULWKPKDGDVLJQLÀFDQWSHUIRUPDQFHLPSURYHPHQWLQ
GHWHFWLQJPDVVHVRQH[WUHPHO\GHQVHEUHDVWVRYHU6HFRQG/RRNLQFUHDVLQJ73)
ZLWKWR S
&RQFOXVLRQ$FFX'HWHFW*DOLOHRVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHURYHUDOOSHUIRUPDQFH
WKDQ6HFRQG/RRNLQGHWHFWLQJPDVVHVPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVDQGDOOFDQFHUW\SHV
HYHQLQH[WUHPHO\GHQVHEUHDVWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP,.
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
66
3DQFUHDV
0RGHUDWRUV
.&RHQHJUDFKWV%UXJHV%(
53R]]L0XFHOOL9HURQD,7
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,RISDQFUHDVFDQFHUFRPSDULVRQRIIUHH
EUHDWKLQJUHVSLUDWRU\WULJJHUHGDQGEUHDWKKROGVHTXHQFHV
1.DUWDOLV//RL]RX1(GVERUJ56HJHUVYDUG1$OELLQ6WRFNKROP6(
QLNRODRVNDUWDOLV#PHFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHUHVSLUDWRU\WULJJHULQJ 57 IUHHEUHDWKLQJ )% DQGEUHDWK
KROG %+ GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ ':, WHFKQLTXHV UHJDUGLQJ D VXEMHFWLYH
LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGE VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ 6, FKDUDFWHULVWLFVDQG$'&PHDVXUHPHQWV
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFDGHQRFDUFLQRPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3URVSHFWLYHO\FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRSDWKR
ORJLFDOO\SURYHQGLVHDVH PHDQVL]HFP XQGHUZHQW':,DW7HVODZLWK
EYDOXHV DQGVPP ZLWKWKHGLIIHUHQWWHFKQLTXHV7ZR
UDGLRORJLVWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DQGEOLQGO\DVVHVVHGLPDJHTXDOLW\E\DVVLJQLQJDWRWDO
TXDOLW\VFRUH>VFRUHVXPRIUDWLQJGLIIXVLRQLPDJHV OHVLRQGHWHFWLRQDQDWRP\SUHV
HQFHRIDUWHIDFWV DQG$'&PDSV OHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\ @SHU
VHTXHQFHDQGE\UDQNLQJWKHP VHTXHQFHVYLHZHGVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ /HVLRQVLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\ 6, VLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 PHDQ$'&DQGFRHIÀFLHQWRIYDULDWLRQ
&9 ZHUHFRPSDUHG$SYDOXHZDVFRQVLGHUHGVLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV7RWDOTXDOLW\VFRUHIRU57)%DQG%+ZDVDQGUHVSHF
WLYHO\ 57 VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU WKDQ )% EXW QRW WKDQ %+ 57 KDG D VLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHUUDQNLQJFRPSDUHGWRERWK)%DQG%+6,RQDOOEYDOXHVDQG615RQE
DQGEZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUIRU57FRPSDUHGWR)%DQG%+0HDQ$'&V
IRU57)%DQG%+ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ %+VLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHUWKDQ)%EXWQRWWKDQ57 0HDQ&9IRU57)%DQG%+ZHUHDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 57VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQ%+EXWQRWWKDQ)%
&RQFOXVLRQ,QERWKDQDO\VHV57':,VKRZHGVXSHULRULW\DQGVHHPVWKHRSWLPDO
WHFKQLTXHIRU':,RISDQFUHDVDGHQRFDUFLQRPD
&RPSDULVRQRIDEGRPLQDO05,LQFOXGLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
VHTXHQFHVZLWK*D'27$7$7(3(7&7LQGHWHFWLQJ
QHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUVRIWKHSDQFUHDV
&06FKPLG7DQQZDOG&6FKPLG7DQQZDOG51HXPDQQ$+DXJ05HLVHU
&5LVW0XQLFK'( FKULVWRSK#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHDEGRPLQDO05,LQFOXGLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, ':05,
ZLWK *D'27$7$7(3(7&7 3(7&7 LQ GHWHFWLQJ QHXURHQGRFULQH WXPRXUV
1(7 RIWKHSDQFUHDV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHGZLWKSDQFUHDWLF
1(7 ZKR XQGHUZHQW 05, LQFOXGLQJ ':05, DQG 3(7&7 ZLWKLQ ZHHNV7ZR
EOLQGHG UHDGHU FRPSDUHG 7ZHLJKWHG 7Z 7Z':05, 7ZFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG7ZHLJKWHG &(7Z VHTXHQFHVDQG3(7&7LPDJHVIRU1(7GHWHFWLRQ
DQGFRQÀGHQFHOHYHOXVLQJDSRLQWVFDOH6HQVLWLYLW\FRQÀGHQFHOHYHODQG$'&
RI1(7DQGQRUPDOSDQFUHDWLFWLVVXHZDVFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV DQG 1(7ZHUHGHWHFWHGRQ7ZLPDJHVDQG
7Z':05,E\ERWKREVHUYHUVUHVSHFWLYHO\2EVHUYHUVDQGGHWHFWHG
DQG 1(7RQWKHLUUHYLHZRI7Z&(7ZLPDJHFRPELQDWLRQ
UHVSHFWLYHO\DQGDOO1(7 ZHUHGHWHFWHGRQ3(7&7E\ERWKREVHUYHUV
'HWHFWLRQUDWHDQGFRQÀGHQFHOHYHOLPSURYHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\E\FRPELQHGLQWHUSUH
WDWLRQRI7ZLPDJHVDQG':05,RU&(7ZLPDJHV S 7KHUHZDVQR
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKH1(7GHWHFWLRQUDWHRI7Z':05,DQG7Z&(
7 LPDJH FRPELQDWLRQV S! 'HWHFWLRQ UDWH DQG FRQÀGHQFH OHYHO RI 3(7
&7ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQ05, S 0HDQ$'&RI1(7 [
PPòV ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQPHDQ$'&RIQRUPDOSDQFUHDWLFWLVVXH
[PPòV
&RQFOXVLRQ':05,LVDYDOXDEOHDGMXQFWWR7ZDQGFRPSDUDEOHWR&(7Z
LPDJHVLQGHWHFWLRQRI1(7RIWKHSDQFUHDVDQG$'&PHDVXUHPHQWVSURYLGHD
TXDQWLWDWLYHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQ1(7DQGQRUPDOSDQFUHDWLF WLVVXH3(7&7
VHHPVWRLPSURYHVLJQLÀFDQWO\WKHGHWHFWLRQRISDQFUHDWLF1(7FRPSDUHGWR05,
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$UHSDQFUHDWLFFDOFLÀFDWLRQVSUHGLFWLYHRILPSDLUPHQWRISDQFUHDWLF
H[RFULQHIXQFWLRQ"$UHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZLWK605&3DQG
DEGRPLQDO&7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQRUVXVSHFWHGSDQFUHDWLFGLVHDVH
*5HVWDLQR00LVVHUH''LVWHIDQR5&DVDOH$3LHUUR*6DOOXVWLR
&DPSREDVVR,75RPH,7 JHQQDUHV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHVWDEOLVKFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSDQFUHDWLFFDOFLÀFDWLRQVGHWHFWHGE\&7
DQGSDQFUHDWLFH[RFULQHIXQFWLRQHYDOXDWHGZLWK605&3LQVXEMHFWVZLWKNQRZQ
RUVXVSHFWHGSDQFUHDWLFGLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV 0) PHDQDJH
\R XQGHUZHQW605&3DQGXSSHUDEGRPLQDOKHOLFDO&7IRUVXVSHFWHGRUNQRZQ
SDQFUHDWLFGLVHDVH605&3ZHUHHYDOXDWHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHDQGJUDGHRIFKURQLF
SDQFUHDWLWLVDFFRUGLQJWR&DPEULGJHFODVVLÀFDWLRQDQGIRUDVVHVVPHQWRISDQFUHDWLF
H[RFULQHUHVHUYHDFFRUGLQJWR0DWRVFODVVLÀFDWLRQ&7H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHHYDOX
DWHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRUDEVHQFHRISDQFUHDWLFFDOFLÀFDWLRQV7KHÀQGLQJVZHUH
FRPSDUHGZLWK)LVKHU VH[DFWWHVW
5HVXOWV&DPEULGJHVFRUHZDVLQSDWLHQWVLQSDWLHQWVLQLQ
DQGLQSDWLHQWV0DWRVVFRUHZDVLQFDVHVLQFDVHVLQVXEMHFWV
DQGLQSDWLHQW3DQFUHDWLFFDOFLÀFDWLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHGE\&7LQSDWLHQWV
7KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSUHYDOHQFHRIFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
DQGJUDGHRIFKURQLFSDQFUHDWLWLV S DQGSDQFUHDWLFH[RFULQHUHVHUYH
S &DOFLÀFDWLRQVZHUHREVHUYHGLQ SDWLHQWVZLWKQRUPDO
SDQFUHDWLFH[RFULQHUHVHUYH 0DWRV YHUVXV SDWLHQWVZLWKLPSDLUHG
UHVHUYH 0DWRV ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S HYHQDIWHUDGMXVWLQJ
IRUVH[DQGDJH$PRQJSDWLHQWVZLWKPLOGDQGVHYHUHFKURQLFSDQFUHDWLWLV &DP
EULGJHVFRUHDQG WKHSUHVHQFHRISDQFUHDWLFFDOFLÀFDWLRQVZDVDVLJQLÀFDQW
LQGLFDWRURILPSDLUHGH[RFULQHIXQFWLRQ S DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\S
&RQFOXVLRQ8QOLNHSUHYLRXVO\SXEOLVKHGSDSHUVRXUVWXG\VKRZVWKDWSDQFUHDWLF
FDOFLÀFDWLRQV DUH LQGHSHQGHQW SUHGLFWRUV RI LPSDLUPHQW RI SDQFUHDWLF H[RFULQH
IXQFWLRQ
%
&RPSDUDWLYHSHUIRUPDQFHRI&7DQG05,LQSURJQRVWLFDWLRQRIDFXWH
SDQFUHDWLWLVFRUUHODWLRQZLWKFOLQLFDORXWFRPH
.5DKXO.0DQGHHS%'HHSDN.*5DMHVK.1DYHHQ%$VKLVK
66XULQGHU1.KDQGHOZDO&KDQGLJDUK,1 UDKXOPRQD#UHGLIIPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDQGSURJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ &7 DQGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, LQDFXWHSDQFUHDWLWLV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q WKLV LQVWLWXWLRQ UHYLHZ ERDUG DSSURYHG SURVSHFWLYH
VWXG\ SDWLHQWV ZLWK FOLQLFDO VXVSLFLRQ RI DFXWH SDQFUHDWLWLV ZHUH HQUROOHG DIWHU
WDNLQJLQIRUPHGFRQVHQW$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWDFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7 &(&7
DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, &(05, $&7VHYHULW\LQGH[ &76, DQG05VHYHU
LW\LQGH[ 056, ZDVDVVLJQHGLQDOOFDVHVE\WZRGLIIHUHQWUDGLRORJLVWVEDVHGRQ
%DOWKD]DUVFRULQJV\VWHP7KH&76,DQG056,ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKHDFKRWKHU
DQGZLWKYDULRXVFOLQLFDORXWFRPHSDUDPHWHUV
5HVXOWV SDWLHQWV PDOHIHPDOH PHDQ DJH \HDUV DJH UDQJH
\HDUV ZHUHHQUROOHGIURP-DQXDU\WR$SULO7KHUHZDVH[FHO
OHQWLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRUDVVHVVLQJ&76, NDSSDYDOXH DQGJRRG
LQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRU056, NDSSD %RWK&76,DQG056,VKRZHG
VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW FRUUHODWLRQ ZLWK WKH QHHG IRU SHUFXWDQHRXV LQWHUYHQWLRQ
GHYHORSPHQWRILQIHFWLRQRURUJDQIDLOXUHDQGGXUDWLRQRIKRVSLWDOVWD\056,DOVR
VKRZHGDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZLWKPRUWDOLW\3DWLHQWVZLWKVLJQVRI
SDQFUHDWLFSHULSDQFUHDWLFKDHPRUUKDJHRQ05,VKRZHGDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
FRUUHODWLRQ ZLWK DOO SDUDPHWHUV RI FOLQLFDO RXWFRPH 3DQFUHDWLF GXFW GLVUXSWLRQ
FRXOGRQO\EHGLDJQRVHGRQ05KRZHYHUSRRULPDJHTXDOLW\ PRWLRQDUWHIDFWV
ZDVVHHQPRUHRIWHQRQ05,
&RQFOXVLRQ05,DQG&7DUHHTXDOO\HIÀFLHQWPRGDOLWLHVIRUDVVHVVLQJVHYHULW\
DQGSUHGLFWLQJFRPSOLFDWLRQVRIDFXWHSDQFUHDWLWLV05,LVVXSHULRULQGHPRQVWUDWLQJ
GXFWDOSDWKRORJ\DQGKDHPRUUKDJH
%
&7DVVHVVPHQWRIVDUFRSHQLDLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUDQG
FKURQLFSDQFUHDWLWLV
(%XODQRYD9/\DGRY(0HUVKLQD9(6LQLWV\Q0RVFRZ58
3XUSRVH$V PHWDEROLF GLVRUGHUV VXFK DV FDFKH[LD DQG VDUFRSHQLD PXVFOH
ZDVWLQJ DUHFRPPRQFRQGLWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUDQGFKURQLF
SDQFUHDWLWLVZHVWXGLHGWKHUROHRI&7LQDVVHVVLQJVDUFRSHQLDLQWKHVHWZRJURXSV
RISDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HHYDOXDWHG&7LPDJHVRISDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLF
FDQFHU DQGFKURQLFSDQFUHDWLWLV ZKLFKXQGHUZHQWRSHUDWLYHWUHDWPHQWLQ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
%
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
$QD[LDO&7LPDJHRQWKHOHYHORI/YHUWHEUDHZDVDVVHVVHGWRPHDVXUH
FURVVVHFWLRQDODUHDVRIVNHOHWDOPXVFOH7KHYDOXHVZHUHQRUPDOLVHGIRUKHLJKW
WRJHW/XPEDUVNHOHWDOPXVFOHLQGH[ FPP 6H[VSHFLÀFVDUFRSHQLDFXWRIIV
ZHUHFPPIRUPHQDQGFPPIRUZRPHQ 3UDGRHWDO 7KHUDQJH
RIERG\PDVVLQGH[ %0, ZDVIURPNJPòWRNJPò 09NJ
PòIRUJURXSDQGNJPòIRUJURXS
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUZHUHIRXQGVDUFRSHQLF 0HDQ
YDOXHRI/LQGH[ZDVFPPIRUPHQDQGFPPIRUZRPHQ
7KHUHZHUHVDUFRSHQLFSDWLHQWVZLWKFKURQLFSDQFUHDWLWLV PHDQYDOXHV
RI/LQGH[IRUPHQDQGIRUZRPHQZHUHFPPDQGFP
PUHVSHFWLYHO\6DUFRSHQLDZDVGLDJQRVHGQRWRQO\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKGHFUHDVHG
%0,EXWDOVRZLWKQRUPDODQGLQFUHDVHG%0,
&RQFOXVLRQ&7LVDXVHIXOWRROWRHYDOXDWHVDUFRSHQLDLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLF
FDQFHUDQGFKURQLFSDQFUHDWLWLVXVLQJ/LQGH[7KHXVHRI&7IRUERG\FRPSRVL
WLRQDQDO\VLVRSHQVXSQHZSRVVLELOLWLHVLQPHWDEROLFGLVRUGHUVUHVHDUFKLQWKHVH
JURXSVRISDWLHQWV
%
5HODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQFOLQLFRSDWKRORJLFDOIDFWRUVDQGWRWDOOHVLRQ
JO\FRO\VLVLQSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU
06KLQDJDZD+.DLGD<.XQRX08FKLGD0,VKLEDVKL1+D\DEXFKL
0<DVXPRWR<1DLWR.XUXPH-3 ERNXFHOHE#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ
ÁXRULQHÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVH )'* XSWDNH>PD[LPXPVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNHYDOXH
689PD[ WRWDOOHVLRQJO\FRO\VLV 7/* @DQGFOLQLFRSDWKRORJLFDOIDFWRUVDVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)'*SRVLWURQHPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUD
SK\ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUIRULQLWLDOVWDJLQJSULRUWR
VXUJHU\'LDJQRVLVZDVKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\FRQÀUPHGIRUDOOFDVHV7KHUHODWLRQVKLS
EHWZHHQFOLQLFRSDWKRORJLFDOIDFWRUV LHWXPRXUVL]HSDWKRORJLFDO7VWDJHO\PSK
QRGH PHWDVWDVLV SDWKRORJLFDO VWDJH WXPRXU GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ O\PSKDWLF LQYDVLRQ
YHQRXVLQYDVLRQLQWUDSDQFUHDWLFQHXUDOLQYDVLRQDQGWXPRXUJURZWKSDWWHUQ ,1)
7/*DQG689PD[ZDVLQYHVWLJDWHG7/*ZDVFDOFXODWHGE\PXOWLSO\LQJPHDQ689
DQGPHWDEROLFWXPRXUYROXPH
5HVXOWV7/*VLJQLÀFDQWO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKWXPRXUVL]H 7/*U S
689PD[U S DQGDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWXPRXUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ 7/*
S 689PD[S ZKHUHDV689PD[GLGQRW,QFRQWUDVW689PD[
DVVRFLDWHGZLWK,1)ZKHUHDV7/*GLGQRW 689PD[S 7/*S
1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVREVHUYHGEHWZHHQFOLQLFRSDWKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHVDQG
689PD[RU7/*
&RQFOXVLRQ7XPRXUVL]HDQGGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQZHUHPRUHKLJKO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK7/*
WKDQ689PD[VXJJHVWLQJWKDW7/*LVPRUHUHÁHFWLYHRIFOLQLFRSDWKRORJLFDOIDFWRUV
DQGOLNHO\WREHXVHIXOLQWKHFOLQLFDOPDQDJHPHQWRISDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU
%
7LPLQJEROXVG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHG
LPDJLQJIRUFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIVROLGIRFDOSDQFUHDWLFOHVLRQV
-/HH-.LP-+DQ,-RR%&KRL%.HLIHU6HRXO.5
(UODQJHQ'( MPVK#VQXDFNU
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG '&( 05,WLPLQJ
EROXVGDWDXVLQJDWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOUDGLDOJUDGLHQWHFKRWHFKQLTXHZLWK.VSDFH
ZHLJKWHGLPDJHFRQWUDVW 5DGLDO.:,& FDQEHSRVWSURFHVVHGIRUFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ
RIVROLGSDQFUHDWLFGLVHDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGSDQFUHDWLFGLVHDVHV
ZKRXQGHUZHQWSDQFUHDWLF05,DW7VFDQQHUZKLFKLQFOXGHGDORZGRVH P/
JDGRSHQWHWDWH WLPLQJEROXVXVLQJDUDGLDO.:,&WHFKQLTXH7KHUHZHUHSD
WLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUVZLWK31(7VZLWKFKURQLFSDQFUHDWLWLVDQG
ZLWK QRUPDO SDQFUHDV 8VLQJ WKH GHGLFDWHG SRVWSURFHVVLQJ VRIWZDUH SURJUDP
IRU'&(05,WKHVHYHUDOSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVZHUHPHDVXUHGIRUWXPRXUDQG
QRQWXPRURXVSDUHQFK\PD
5HVXOWV7KH.WUDQV.HSDQGL$8&YDOXHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU
PLQïPLQïPPROVUHVSHFWLYHO\3ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\
ORZHUWKDQWKRVHZLWKQRUPDOSDQFUHDV PLQïPLQïPPROV
UHVSHFWLYHO\3 ,QDGGLWLRQWKHNHSYDOXHVRI31(7VDQGQRUPDOSDQFUHDV
ZHUHDOVRGLIIHUHQW 3 )XUWKHUPRUHWKH.WUDQVNHSL$8&YDOXHVRI
SDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUVDQG31(7VZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW 3 7KHSUHYDOHQW
7,& SDWWHUQV RI WKH SDQFUHDWLF FDQFHU 31(7V FKURQLF SDQFUHDWLWLV DQG QRUPDO
SDQFUHDWLFSDUHQFK\PDZHUHGLIIHUHQWSDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUVVKRZHGDVORZJUDGXDO
HQKDQFHPHQWSDWWHUQ ZKLOH31(7VVKRZHGDUDSLGO\LQFUHDVLQJDQG
JUDGXDOO\GHFUHDVLQJHQKDQFHPHQWSDWWHUQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
&RQFOXVLRQ7LPLQJEROXV'&(05,XVLQJWKHUDGLDO.:,&VHTXHQFHIURPURXWLQH
H[DPLQDWLRQVFDQEHSRVWSURFHVVHGWR\LHOGSRWHQWLDOO\XVHIXOSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUV
IRUFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRISDQFUHDWLFGLVHDVHV
%
6LQJOHHQHUJ\ORZYROWDJHDUWHULDOSKDVHVFDQVIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRI
DGHQRFDUFLQRPDRIWKHSDQFUHDV
*$=DPERQL0$PEURVHWWL(=LYHORQJKL53R]]L0XFHOOL9HURQD,7
J]DPERQL#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RWHVWDVLQJOHHQHUJ\ORZYROWDJHSURWRFROIRUGHWHFWLQJDGHQRFDUFL
QRPDRIWKHSDQFUHDV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKSDWKRORJ\SURYHQSDQFUHDWLFDGHQRFDUFL
QRPDXQGHUZHQW0'&7ZLWKDUWHULDOSKDVHDWN9S JURXS$ RQDURZVFDQQHU
DQGZHUHFRPSDUHGWRDVLPLODUJURXSRISDWLHQWVVFDQQHGZLWKDN9SDUWHULDO
SKDVHSURWRFRO JURXS% ([FHSWIRUWXEHYROWDJHDOORWKHUVFDQSDUDPHWHUVZHUH
NHSWFRQVWDQW6FDQVZHUHFRPSDUHGIRUTXDQWLWDWLYHLPDJHSDUDPHWHUV DWWHQXDWLRQ
DQGVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQLQWKHOLYHUSDQFUHDVDRUWDDQGWXPRXU &7',DQG'/3
XVLQJDQXQSDLUHGWWHVW,PDJHQRLVHYDOXHVIRUHDFKSURWRFRO 6'RIWKH+8IURP
52,VGUDZQRXWVLGHWKHERG\ ZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJDQXQSDLUHGWWHVW(IIHFWLYH
GRVHIRUWKHWZRSURWRFROVZDVFDOFXODWHGZLWK7/'PHDVXUHPHQWV
5HVXOWV 0HDQ DWWHQXDWLRQ ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU LQ JURXS $ LQ WKH DRUWD
YV +8 OLYHU YV +8 DQG QRUPDO
SDQFUHDV YV+8 DOOS ZKLOHQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLI
IHUHQFHZDVREVHUYHGIRUDGHQRFDUFLQRPD YV+8S QV
&7', DQG '/3 ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU LQ JURXS$ YV P*\ DQG
YVP*\[FPUHVSHFWLYHO\DOOS 7XPRXUFRQ
VSLFXLW\ +8SDQFUHDV+8WXPRXU ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQJURXS$
YV+8S 0HDQLPDJHQRLVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQJURXS
$ YV+8S 7/'HIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHU
IRUWKHWHVWSURWRFRO YVP6YS
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH XVH RI N9S DUWHULDO SKDVH IRU DEGRPHQ &7 LQFUHDVHV WKH
FRQVSLFXLW\RIDGHQRFDUFLQRPDWKXVSRWHQWLDOO\LPSURYLQJLWVLGHQWLÀFDWLRQ
%
4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRISDQFUHDWLFIDWIUDFWLRQDQGFRQIRXQGLQJIDFWRUVLQ
DQDGXOWSRSXODWLRQEDVHGVWXG\XVLQJPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
-3.XHKQ6%DXPHLVWHU32%HKUQGW.+HJHQVFKHLG+9RHO]NH
-0D\HUOH1+RVWHQ53XOV*UHLIVZDOG'( NXHKQ#XQLJUHLIVZDOGGH
3XUSRVH7RHVWDEOLVKWKHSURSRUWLRQRISDQFUHDWLFIDWIUDFWLRQDQGWKHLUFRUUHODWHV
LQDQRQJRLQJSRSXODWLRQEDVHGFRKRUWVWXG\XVLQJ7 FRUUHFWHG'L[RQPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQD7V\VWHP $YDQWR6LHPHQV
XVLQJDZRUNLQSURJUHVV7 FRUUHFWHGWKUHHHFKR'L[RQWHFKQLTXH)DWSKDQWRP
ZDVFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJIDWIUDFWLRQVRIDQGWRWHVWWKHDFFXUDF\RI
IDWTXDQWLÀFDWLRQ,QDGGLWLRQDWRWDORIKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV PHQ
ZRPHQPHDQDJH\HDUVPHDQ%0,NJP XQGHUZHQWDQ
DEGRPLQDO05,LQFOXGLQJWKHVWXG\VHTXHQFH)DWIUDFWLRQVRIWKHSDQFUHDV KHDG
ERG\DQGWDLO ZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJDUHJLRQRILQWHUHVWEDVHGLPDJHHYDOXDWLRQ
3DQFUHDWLFIDW ORJWUDQVIRUPHG ZDVUHJUHVVHGRQGHPRJUDSKLFEHKDYLRXUDODQG
FDUGLRPHWDEROLFIDFWRUV
5HVXOWV7KHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQSUHGLFWHGIDWFRQWHQWE\05,DQGWUXHIDWFRQWHQW
LQSKDQWRPZDVYHU\KLJK U3HDUVRQ 7KHPHGLDQSDQFUHDWLFIDWIUDFWLRQ
DPRQJ YROXQWHHUV ZDV WK SHUFHQWLOH 4 WK SHUFHQWLOH 4
7KHUHDUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHVLQIDWGLVWULEXWLRQEHWZHHQKHDG
ERG\ DQG WDLO S ,Q PXOWLYDULDEOH OLQHDU UHJUHVVLRQ PRGHOV
PDOHJHQGHUDJHREHVLW\G\VOLSLGHPLDDQGWULJO\FHULGHVZHUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWK
SDQFUHDWLFIDW)RUH[DPSOHPHQKDGKLJKHUYDOXHVWKDQZRPHQWKRVHZLWK
%0,ODUJHUWKDQDQGVXEMHFWVZLWKG\VOLSLGHPLDKLJKHUSDQFUHDWLFIDW
&RQFOXVLRQ05,LVDXVHIXOWRROWRTXDQWLI\WKHSDQFUHDWLFIDWIUDFWLRQ6H[DJH
%0,G\VOLSLGHPLDDQGWULJO\FHULGHVDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKSDQFUHDWLFIDWZKHUHDV
VPRNLQJVWDWXVDOFRKROFRQVXPSWLRQK\SHUWHQVLRQGLDEHWHVDQGIDVWLQJJOXFRVH
DUHQRW
%
3UHRSHUDWLYH&7ÀQGLQJVSUHGLFWLQJWKHUHFXUUHQFHRISDQFUHDWLF
FDQFHUDIWHUVXUJLFDOUHVHFWLRQ
</HH<.LP./HH6HRQJQDPVL.5 \RRQMLQ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHXVHIXOSUHRSHUDWLYH&7ÀQGLQJVIRUSUHGLFWLQJWKHUHFXU
UHQFHRISDQFUHDWLFFDQFHUDIWHUVXUJLFDOUHVHFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP2FWREHUWR0DUFKPXOWLSKDVLFPXOWLGH
WHFWRU&7GDWDZHUHDFTXLUHGLQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJFXUDWLYHUHVHFWLRQIRUGXFWDO
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DGHQRFDUFLQRPD RI WKH SDQFUHDV )RUW\ FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZHUH GLYLGHG LQWR
UHFXUUHQFHRUUHFXUUHQFHIUHHJURXSV7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHG
WKH&7ÀQGLQJVLQFRQVHQVXVZLWKUHJDUGWRWKHVL]HRIWKHWXPRXUORFDOLQYDVLRQ
YDVFXODULQYDVLRQUHJLRQDOO\PSKQRGHHQODUJHPHQWDQGWKHSUHVHQFHRIDVVRFL
DWHGSDQFUHDWLWLV7KHUHVXOWVIURP&7ZHUHDQDO\VHGWRLGHQWLI\WKHULVNIDFWRUV
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHDIWHUVXUJHU\.DSODQ0HLHUPHWKRGDQG&R[
SURSRUWLRQDOKD]DUGVUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOZHUHXVHGIRUHYDOXDWLRQ
5HVXOWV3UHVHQFHDQGQXPEHURIUHJLRQDOO\PSKQRGHHQODUJHPHQWRQ&7ZHUH
LPSRUWDQWSUHGLFWRUVRIWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFH S DQGUHODWLYHULVNHVWLPDWH
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KHSUHVHQFHRIUHWURSDQFUHDWLFO\PSKQRGHHQODUJH
PHQWZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWSUHGLFWRU S UHODWLYHULVNHVWLPDWH LQPXOWLYDUL
DWHDQDO\VLV7KHPHGLDQWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHWLPHVZHUHPRQWKVDQGPRQWKV
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWO\PSKDGHQRSDWK\UHVSHFWLYHO\ S +RZHYHU
RWKHU&7ÀQGLQJVZHUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWSUHGLFWRUVRIWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH SUHVHQFH RI UHJLRQDO HVSHFLDOO\ UHWURSDQFUHDWLF O\PSK QRGH
HQODUJHPHQWRQ&7PD\LPSURYHSUHGLFWLQJSDWLHQWVDWKLJKULVNRIWXPRXUUHFXU
UHQFHDIWHUVXUJLFDOUHVHFWLRQRISDQFUHDWLFFDQFHU
5RRP/0
&DUGLDF
66
&DUGLRP\RSDWKLHV&705,DQG3(7
0RGHUDWRUV
$(VSRVLWR0LODQ,7
0*XWEHUOHW/HLS]LJ'(
%
0\RFDUGLDOODWHHQKDQFHPHQWLQK\SHUWURSKLFFDUGLRP\RSDWK\
VSUHDGPRUHWKDQDPRXQWSUHGLFWVHYROXWLRQWRZDUGVKHDUWIDLOXUH
0&DYD)'H&REHOOL$(VSRVLWR65DYHOOL$'DPDVFHOOL
*/LJDEXH5)DWWRUL$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,70RGHQD,7%RORJQD,7
FDYDPDULDQJHOD#KVULW
%
)HDVLELOLW\UHSURGXFLELOLW\DQGUHOLDELOLW\IRUWKH7 LURQHYDOXDWLRQ
DW7LQFRPSDULVRQZLWK7
&7XGLVFD$0HORQL*9DOHUL(&KLRGL00LVVHUH$&DUROOR
0/RPEDUGL00LGLUL$3HSH3DOHUPR,73LVD,7$QFRQD,7
)HUUDUD,7&DPSREDVVR,77UDSDQL,7
3XUSRVH:HDLPHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHIHDVLELOLW\UHSURGXFLELOLW\DQGUHOLDELOLW\RI
WKH7 PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, DW7IRUKHDUWDQGOLYHULURQEXUGHQ
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQDQGWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ7 YDOXHVDW7DQG7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV WUDQVIXVLRQGHSHQGHQW SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW 05,
6HJPHQWDODQGJOREDOFDUGLDF7 YDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGDIWHUGHYHORSLQJDFRU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
5HODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQP\RFDUGLDO7 YDOXHVDQGULJKWDQGOHIW
YHQWULFXODUYROXPHWULFDQGIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVLQWKDODVVHPLD
PDMRU 70 SDWLHQWVHYDOXDWHGE\FDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH &05
,'L*LDPSLHWUR&/LJXRUL,6DQVRQL$)HOL]LDQL3&LDQFLXOOL
%%HRPRQWH=REHO5RPH,7
3XUSRVH&05KDVEHFRPHWKHPRVWXVHIXOLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHLQ70SDWLHQWV
WKDQNWR7 DFTXLVLWLRQLQRUGHUWRTXDQWLWDWLYHO\HYDOXDWHP\RFDUGLDOLURQRYHUORDG
7KHDLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHP\RFDUGLDO7
YDOXHDQGOHIWULJKWYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVDQGWRH[DPLQHWKHDVVRFLD
WLRQVEHWZHHQWKHGHJUHHRIFDUGLDFLURQORDGDQGYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQLPSDLUPHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$UHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRISDWLHQWV 0DQG)
PHDQDJH\V ZLWK70ZDVSHUIRUPHG0\RFDUGLDOLURQORDGZDVDV
VHVVHGE\7 PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGYROXPHWULFIXQFWLRQVZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJWKH
VWHDG\VWDWHIUHHSUHFHVVLRQ 66)3 VHTXHQFHV
5HVXOWV ,Q SDWLHQWV ZLWK P\RFDUGLDO LURQ GHSRVLWLRQ 7 PV WKH PHDQ
/9()ZDVUHVXOWLQJVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUFRPSDUHGWR/9()PHDVXUHGLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKRXWLURQGHSRVLWLRQ6WDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQV
ZHUHIRXQGHGEHWZHHQERWKWKH/9YROXPHVDQGWKHP\RFDUGLDO7 YDOXHLQYHUVH
FRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQERWKWKH/9HQGV\VWROLFYROXPHLQGH[ U 3 DQG
WKHOHIWYHQWULFXODU/9HQGGLDVWROLFYROXPHLQGH[ U 3 ZHUHREVHUYHG
,QFRQWUDVWFDUGLDF7 YDOXHVZHUHQRWDVVRFLDWHGZLWKIXQFWLRQDOPRGLÀFDWLRQVLQ
WKHULJKWYHQWULFOHIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ0\RFDUGLDOLURQORDGDVVHVVHGE\&05LVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKGHWHULR
UDWLRQ/9()DQGWKHGHJUHHRIWKHRYHUORDGLVLQYHUVHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKWKH7
YDOXHV1RQFRUUHODWLRQKDVEHHQIRXQGHGEHWZHHQ7 YDOXHVDQGULJKWYHQWULFOH
IXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV
%
6HSWDOODWHJDGROLQLXPHQKDQFHPHQWDWWKHULJKWYHQWULFXODU
LQVHUWLRQVPRUHIUHTXHQWWKDQH[SHFWHGLQK\SHUWURSKLFDQGGLODWLYH
FDUGLRP\RSDWK\
3%LVFKRII5/'XVFKND6+ROOPDQQ06LPRQ$.RYDFV3:5DGNH
)09RJW-%DUNKDXVHQ3+XQROG/EHFN'(
3XUSRVH 7KH SDUWLFXODU SDWWHUQ RI VHSWDO /DWH *GHQKDQFHPHQW /*( DW WKH
ULJKWYHQWULFXODU 59 LQVHUWLRQVKDVEHHQGHVFULEHGLQFRQMXQFWLRQZLWKSXOPRQDU\
K\SHUWHQVLRQ$LPRIWKLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVWRFKDUDFWHULVHWKHGLVWULEXWLRQ
DQGSUHYDOHQFHRIVHSWDO/*(DWWKH59LQVHUWLRQVLQFDVHVRIK\SHUWURSKLFDQG
GLODWLYHFDUGLRP\RSDWK\ +&0'&0
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGFDUGLDF05,VWXGLHV
ZHUHSHUIRUPHG 7DQG7$FKLHYD3KLOLSV IRUGLIIHUHQWFOLQLFDOLQGLFDWLRQV
7KH05,SURWRFROFRQVLVWHQWO\FRQWDLQHG&LQH66)3LQORQJDQGVKRUWD[HVDQG
'7Z,5/*(LQORQJDQGVKRUWD[HVPLQDIWHUGRXEOHGRVH PPRONJ
JDGREXWURO$OOFDVHVZHUHUHYLHZHGLQDUHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLV'&0DQG+&0
SDWLHQWVZLWK/*(DWWKHDQWHULRUDQGRULQIHULRUVHSWDO59LQVHUWLRQZHUHHYDOXDWHG
DQGFRPSDUHGWRFDUGLRP\RSDWK\SDWLHQWVZLWKRXW/*(
5HVXOWV,QWRWDO'&0RU+&0ZHUHIRXQGLQSWV +\SHUWURSKLF
QRQREVWUXFWLYH FDUGLRP\RSDWK\ +1&0 ZDV GHWHFWHG SWV
K\SHUWURSKLFREVWUXFWLYH FDUGLRP\RSDWK\ +2&0 ZDV GHWHFWHG LQ SWV
7KHUHRIDQWHULRUDQGLQIHULRU/*(DWWKH59LQVHUWLRQVZDVIRXQGLQSWV
+1&0SWV+2&0SWV RQO\LQI/*(ZDVIRXQG
LQSWV +1&0SWV+2&0SWV SWV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7KLVVWXG\DLPHGWRH[SORUHE\FDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH &05 UHOD
WLYHUHOHYDQFHRIPRUSKRIXQFWLRQDODQGVWUXFWXUDOLQIRUPDWLRQVUHODWHGWRSRWHQWLDOO\
OLIHWKUHDWHQLQJFOLQLFDOHYHQWVLQK\SHUWURSKLFFDUGLRP\RSDWK\ +&0 SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV +&0 SDWLHQWV SWV PHDQ DJH XQGHUZHQW
&05 EHWZHHQ DQG SHUIRUPHG RQ D 7 PDJQHW $FKLHYD 3KLOLSV
ZLWKDVVHVVPHQWRIOHIWYHQWULFXODUHQGV\VWROLFGLDVWROLFYROXPHVHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ
HQGGLDVWROLFZDOOPDVVPD[LPXPZDOOWKLFNQHVV 0:7 RXWÁRZWUDFWREVWUXFWLRQ
PLWUDO UHJXUJLWDWLRQ GLDVWROLF IXQFWLRQ ') DQG ODWHHQKDQFHPHQW /( DIWHU LY
LQMHFWLRQRIJDGROLQLXPEDVHGFRQWUDVWPHGLXP'XULQJPRQWKVIROORZXS
FDUGLDFHYHQWV &( ZHUHUHFRUGHGDQGGLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVDUUK\WKPLF&(
>VXVWDLQHG YHQWULFXODU WDFK\FDUGLD YHQWULFXODU ÀEULOODWLRQ VXGGHQ FDUGLDF GHDWK
,&'GLVFKDUJH@DQGKHDUWIDLOXUH +) UHODWHG&(>DWULDOÀEULOODWLRQ $) XQSODQQHG
KRVSLWDOLVDWLRQSURJUHVVLRQWR1<+$FODVV,,,,9+)UHODWHGGHDWK@
5HVXOWVSWVVKRZHG/( PHDQ ZLWKPHDQQXPEHURILQYROYHGVHJ
PHQWV /(16 :HUHFRUGHG+)UHODWHGHYHQWVLQSWVQRDUUK\WKPLF&(
RFFXUUHG$FFRUGLQJWRHYHQWV ( ZHGLYLGHGSWVLQWRWZRJURXSV ( QR(
GDWDDVVHVVHGE\&05VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVDERXW0:7 ( YV
QR( S /( ( YVQR( S DQG/(16 ( YV
QR( S QXPEHURISDWLHQWVZLWK')LPSDLUPHQW ( YVQR(
S $WPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVDSDUWIURPDJH S QXPEHURI/(LQYROYHG
VHJPHQWVVHHPVWREHWKHEHVWSUHGLFWRURI+)UHODWHGHYHQWVWKHLQYROYHPHQWRI
DQ\VHJPHQWLQFUHDVHGWKHULVNRI+)UHODWHGHYHQWV S 25
&RQFOXVLRQ0\RFDUGLDO/(FRXOGSUHGLFWHYROXWLRQWRZDUGV+)LQ+&0/(VSUHDG
VHHPVVWURQJHUWKDQLWVDPRXQW
UHFWLRQPDSWRFRPSHQVDWHWKHDUWHIDFWXDO7 YDULDWLRQV7KHKHSDWLF7 YDOXH
ZDVGHWHUPLQHGRYHUDUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW
5HVXOWV7KHLQWUDDQGLQWHURSHUDWRUUHSURGXFLELOLW\DW7ZDVJRRG ,&&!
6HJPHQWDOFRUUHFWLRQIDFWRUVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUDW7 3 $VWURQJ
OLQHDUUHODWLRQVKLSZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ7DQG75 YDOXHVIRUERWKOLYHUDQG
KHDUWWKH75 YDOXHVZHUHDERXWWZLFHZLWKDQLQWHUFHSWGHSHQGLQJRQWKH
QRQLURQ WLVVXH FRPSRQHQW 7KH FRQFRUGDQFH EHWZHHQ JOREDO DQG PLGVHSWXP
YDOXHVFRQÀUPHGWKHFRQVLVWHQFHRIPHDVXUHPHQWV7KHUHOLDELOLW\IRU77 DV
VHVVPHQWZDVIXOOIRUWKHPLGVHSWXP VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\
DQGKLJKIRUJOREDOKHDUW VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\ )RUWKH
VHJPHQWDOPHDVXUHPHQWRILURQOHYHOVDW7WKHDFFXUDF\ZDVQRRSWLPDO7KH
DFFXUDF\ZDVKLJKWRLGHQWLI\SDWLHQWVZLWKPLOGWRQRLURQOLYHUEXUGHQ EXW
GURSSHGWRLQSDWLHQWVZLWKKHDY\PRGHUDWHLURQEXUGHQ7KHVHQVLWLYLW\ZDV
XQVDWLVIDFWRU\ WRGHWHFWSDWLHQWVZLWKKHDY\OLYHULURQEXUGHQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 7 TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI LURQ EXUGHQ LQ WKH PLGVHSWXP JOREDO KHDUW
DQGQRKHDY\PRGHUDWHOLYHUVUHVXOWHGWREHIHDVLEOHUHSURGXFLEOHDQGUHOLDEOHDW
7&KDOOHQJHZDVWKHVHJPHQWDOKHDUW7 DQDO\VLVGXHWRVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
VXVFHSWLELOLW\DUWHIDFWVDW7
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
SUHVHQWHG'&0WKHUHRISWV GHPRQVWUDWHGDQWDQGLQI/*(DW
WKH59LQVHUWLRQVSWV KDGRQO\DQLQIHULRU/*(
&RQFOXVLRQ/*(DWWKHVHSWDOULJKWYHQWULFXODUDQWHULRUDQGLQIHULRULQVHUWLRQVLV
DIUHTXHQWÀQGLQJLQGLODWLYHDQGK\SHUWURSKLFFDUGLRP\RSDWK\7KLVVSHFLÀF/*(
SDWWHUQ VHHPV WR EH XVHIXO LQ WKH GLIIHUHQWLDO GLDJQRVLV RI P\RFDUGLDO GLVHDVH
+RZHYHULWVFOLQLFDOUHOHYDQFHUHPDLQVXQFOHDU
%
%
3XUSRVH7R LQYHVWLJDWH WKH SURJQRVWLF YDOXH RI /*(&05 WKURXJKRXW WKH DV
VRFLDWLRQ EHWZHHQ /*( H[WHQVLRQ DQG WKH RFFXUUHQFH RI VXVWDLQHG YHQWULFXODU
WDFK\DUUK\WKPLDV 697 DQG LPSODQWDEOH FDUGLRYHUWHU GHÀEULOODWRU VKRFN ,&'6
LQ+&0SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHDQDJHPDOHV ZLWK
GRFXPHQWHG+&0XQGHUZHQW7FDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH/*(05LPDJHV
ZHUHREWDLQHGPLQDIWHULQMHFWLRQRIPPRONJRIJDGROLQLXPEDVHGFRQWUDVW
DJHQW ,QGH[HG HQGGLDVWROLF OHIW YHQWULFXODU PDVV ,('/9 PDVV ZDV DVVHVVHG
DQG P\RFDUGLDO GDPDJH H[SUHVVHG DV SHUFHQWDJH RI WRWDO ,('/9 P\RFDUGLDO
PDVV ZDVTXDQWLÀHGDQGGHÀQHGDVLQWHQVLW\6'DERYHWKHPHDQVLJQDORID
QRQHQKDQFHGP\RFDUGLXPDUHD2FFXUUHQFHRI697DQG,&'6GXULQJ
PRQWKVIROORZXSZHUHUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ,('/9PDVVZDVJP2Q/*(&05
SDWLHQWVH[KLELWHGP\RFDUGLDOVFDU7KHPHDQ/*(ZDVRI,('/9PDVV
PHGLDQUDQJH 'XULQJWKHIROORZXS SDWLHQWVSUHVHQWHG
697 SDWLHQWVLPSODQWHG,&'DQGRIWKRVHKDGRQHRUPRUH,&'6
3DWLHQWVZKRSUHVHQWHG697KDGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU/*(FRPSDUHGWRWKRVH
ZLWKRXW>@YV>@3 3DWLHQWVZKRSUHVHQWHGRQHRUPRUH
,&'6 KDG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU /*( FRPSDUHG WR WKRVH ZLWKRXW DQ\ VKRFNV
>@YV>@3
&RQFOXVLRQ([WHQVLRQRI/*(SUHGLFWVWKHRFFXUUHQFHRI697DQG,&'6LQ+&0
SDWLHQWV
9LVXDOLVDWLRQRIDP\ORLGGHSRVLWLRQLQWKHKHDUWRIIDPLOLDOV\VWHPLF
DP\ORLGRVLVXVLQJ>&@%)3(7
07DVKLUR6,NHGD.)XUXNDZD12NDPXUD6)XUXPRWR
5,ZDWD.<DQDL<.XGR+$UDL6HQGDL-30DWVXPRWR-3
PWDVKLUR#F\ULFWRKRNXDFMS
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRH[DPLQHZKHWKHUDQDP\ORLGLPDJLQJ
WUDFHU>&@%)XVXDOO\XVHGIRUHDUO\GLDJQRVLVRI$O]KHLPHUҋVGLVHDVHFDQ
YLVXDOLVH WKH ћDP\ORLG GHSRVLWLRQ LQ WKH FDUGLDF PXVFOH RI D IDPLOLDO V\VWHPLF
DP\ORLGRVLVSDWLHQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVXEMHFWZDVDPDQZLWKIDPLOLDOV\VWHPLFDP\ORLGR
VLVFRQÀUPHGE\ELRSV\RIJDVWURGXRGHQDOVSHFLPHQ&DUGLDFDP\ORLGRVLVZDV
DOVRVWURQJO\VXVSHFWHGE\HFKRFDULRJUDSK\DQG05,)RUWKLVSDWLHQW3(7ZLWK
>&@%)WKDWVHQVLWLYHO\DQGVSHFLÀFDOO\ELQGVWRDJJUHJDWHGDP\ORLGÀEULOV
ZDVFRQGXFWHG3(7LPDJLQJZDVFRQGXFWHGXVLQJ6(7: 6KLPDG]X,QF
.\RWR-DSDQ 689YDOXHVLQWKHKHDUWDQGOXQJZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHRI
QRUPDOGDWDEDVH
5HVXOWV7KH3(7LPDJHVUHYHDOHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\UREXVWUHWHQWLRQRI>&@%)
LQWKHKHDUWRIWKHSDWLHQWFRPSDUHGWRWKHQRUPDOFRQWURO+LVELRSV\VSHFLPHQV
IURPWKHGXRGHQXPDOVRVKRZHGKLJKVLJQDOVRI>&@%)689YDOXHRIWKH
KHDUWZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKHQRUPDOGDWDEDVHZKLOHWKRVHRIWKHOXQJ
VKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ7RRXUNQRZOHGJHWKLVLVWKHÀUVWUHSRUWVKRZLQJWKHXVHIXOQHVVRID
ћSOHDWHGVKHHWVWUXFWXUHVSHFLÀF3(7LQLQYHVWLJDWLQJYLVFHUDORUJDQDP\ORLGRVLV
1RQHRIWKHSUHYLRXVWUDFHUVZDVDEOHWRVSHFLÀFDOO\ELQGWRDJJUHJDWHGDP\ORLG
ZKLFKIRUPVDћSOHDWHGVKHHWVWUXFWXUH,WLVWUXO\LPSRUWDQWWRGHWHFWWKHDFFXPXOD
WLRQRIUHDODP\ORLGÀEULOVIRUHDUO\DQGDFFXUDWHGLDJQRVLVRIDP\ORLGRVLV2XUUHVXOW
PD\SURYLGHDQHZHYLGHQFHWKDWRXUDP\ORLGVSHFLÀF3(7WUDFHU>&@%)
FDQVXFFHVVIXOO\GHWHFWDP\ORLGGHSRVLWLRQLQWKHKHDUWDVZHOO
%
0XOWLGHWHFWRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ZLWKODWHHQKDQFHPHQW 0'&7
/( IRUSUHWUHDWPHQWSODQQLQJRIYHQWULFXODUWDFK\FDUGLD 97 5)DEODWLRQ
&&RODQWRQL$(VSRVLWR)'H&REHOOL$3DOPLVDQR51&DYDOOLQ
*0DFFDEHOOL6&RORPER3'HOOD%HOOD$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,7
3XUSRVH0\RFDUGLDOVFDUVDUHWKHFRPPRQVXEVWUDWHRI97UDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEOD
WLRQ 5)D JXLGHGE\HOHFWURDQDWRPLFDOPDS ($0 LVIUHTXHQWO\WKHWKHUDS\RI
FKRLFH$QLPDJLQJWRROSURYLGLQJDQDQDWRPLFDODQGVWUXFWXUDOVXEVWUDWHWRJXLGH
($0DQGVXEVHTXHQW5)DVKRXOGEHDQLPSRUWDQWKHOSWRUHGXFHSURFHGXUDOWLPH
DQGLPSURYHVXFFHVVUDWH:HDLPHGWRHYDOXDWH0'&7IRUWKLVUROHEHLQJ05,
XVHPDLQO\SUHFOXGHGIURPGHÀEULOODWRUV ,&' LPSODQWHGWRSUHYHQWVXGGHQGHDWK
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SWV ZLWK UHFXUUHQW97 XQGHUZHQW VOLFH0'&7
EHIRUH($0DQG5)DLQFOXGLQJDQDQJLRJUDSKLFVFDQDQGDORZHQHUJ\ N9
GHOD\HGVFDQ PLQXWHV DIWHU FRQWUDVWPHGLD LQMHFWLRQ 0'&7 VFDQV ZHUH
PHUJHGZLWK($0V
5HVXOWV0'&7VFDQVZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\(&*WULJJHUHGLQSWVDQGUHWURVSHF
WLYHO\JDWHGLQSWVSWVKDG,&'SWVVKRZHGVXEHSLFDUGLDO/(VXJJHVWLYHIRU
SRVWP\RFDUGLWLVVFDUV($0SHUIRUPHGZLWKHSLFDUGLDODSSURDFKFRQÀUPHGVFDUV
LGHQWLÀHGDW0'&7/( YROWDJHP9 LQDOOWKHVHSWVSWVKDG/(VXJJHVWLYH
IRUSRVWLVFKDHPLFVFDUVZLWKVXEHQGRFDUGLDO SWV RUWUDQVPXUDO SWV LQYROYH
PHQW/RZYROWDJHDUHDVDW($0SHUIRUPHGZLWKHQGRFDUGLDODSSURDFKPDWFKHG
ZLWK/(DUHDVSWGLGQRWVKRZ/(DUHDVDQGXQGHUZHQW5)DLQDUHDVZLWKYROWDJHV
EHWZHHQDQGP9 ERUGHU]RQH DW($0
&RQFOXVLRQ,QPRVWRIHQUROOHGSDWLHQWV0'&7/(DOORZHGXVWRPDSWKHVFDUV
UHVSRQVLEOHIRUHOHFWULFDOVXEVWUDWHRI970'&7/(PD\EHSURSRVHGWRSURYLGH
DQDWRPLFDQGVWUXFWXUDOVXEVWUDWHIRUJXLGLQJ($0DQG5)DLQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHFXU
UHQW97DOVRVXJJHVWLQJWKHPRUHDSSURSULDWHDSSURDFK HQGRFDUGLDOYVHSLFDUGLDO
0'&7/(LQVWHDGRI05,PD\DOORZLPDJLQJJXLGHDOVRLQSDWLHQWVZLWK,&'
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
/DWHJDGROLQLXPHQKDQFHGFDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH /*(&05
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIP\RFDUGLDOGDPDJHDVDSUHGLFWRURIDUUK\WKPLFHYHQWV
6%HUWXJQR*/LJDEXH))LRFFKL/1RFHWWL69DVDWXUR5/XJOL$%DUELHUL
37RUULFHOOL0RGHQD,7
%
,QFUHDVHGODWHJDGROLQLXPHQKDQFHPHQWRIWKHOHIWDWULXPE\
FDUGLRYDVFXODUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLQFDUGLDFDP\ORLGRVLV
)6HFFKL$-DEERXU)6DUGDQHOOL'3HQQHOO50RKLDGGLQ0LODQ,7
/RQGRQ8. IUDQFHVFRVHFFKLPG#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH2XUDLPZDVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHSUHYDOHQFHRIOHIWDWULDOODWHJDGROLQLXP
HQKDQFHPHQW /*( E\FDUGLDFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH &05 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKFDUGLDF
DP\ORLGRVLV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KH &05 VWXGLHV RI SDWLHQWV DJHG \HDUV
ZLWKNQRZQFDUGLDFDP\ORLGRVLVZHUHUHYLHZHG(&*WULJJHUHGIRXUFKDPEHUDQG
ORQJD[LVYLHZVZHUHDFTXLUHGXVLQJDQLQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\VHTXHQFHPLQXWHV
DIWHUDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIFRQWUDVW *DGRYLVWPPRONJ %DODQFHGVWHDG\VWDWHIUHH
SUHFHVVLRQFLQHLPDJHVZHUHXVHGWRGHWHUPLQHOHIWYHQWULFXODUHQGGLDVWROLFDQG
V\VWROLFLQGH[HGYROXPHV /9('9L/9(69L HMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ () VWURNHYROXPH
69 DQGPDVVLQGH[2QO\SDWLHQWVZLWKWKHFODVVLFGLIIXVHFLUFXPIHUHQWLDOSDWWHUQ
RIOHIWYHQWULFXODU/*(ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\
5HVXOWV2ISDWLHQWVZLWKFDUGLDFDP\ORLGRVLVSDWLHQWV GLVSOD\HG
OHIWDWULDO/*($OOWKUHHDWULDOZHUHLQYROYHGLQ ERWKVHSWDODQGIUHHZDOOV
LQ DQGLVRODWHGVHSWDOZDOOLQYROYHPHQWLQ 3DWLHQWVZLWKOHIWDWULDO
/*(DOVRKDGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU/9('9L P/YVP/>PHDQ6'@
S +RZHYHUQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQ/9(69L P/YVP/
S () YV S 69 P/ YV P/
S DQGPDVV JPYVJPS ZHUHREVHUYHG
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWLHQWVZLWKFDUGLDFDP\ORLGRVLVKDYHDQLQFUHDVHGSUHYDOHQFH
RIOHIWDWULDO/*(3DWLHQWVZLWKDWULDO/*(DOVRKDGPRUHGLODWHGOHIWYHQWULFOHVWKRVH
ZLWKRXWDWULDO'($WULDO/*(LQFDUGLDFDP\ORLGRVLVPD\EHDPDUNHURIGLVHDVH
VHYHULW\DQGLWVSURJQRVWLFLPSOLFDWLRQVUHTXLUHIXUWKHUHYDOXDWLRQ
%
'RHVH[LVWDFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQODWHHQKDQFHPHQWPDVVDQGOHIW
YHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQLQK\SHUWURSKLFFDUGLRP\RSDWK\"
&'H&HFFR*0XVFRJLXUL0'L*LURODPR6)LHUUR00DXUL]L(QULFL
9'DYLG5RPH,7 JPXVFRJLXUL#KRWPDLOLW
3XUSRVH7RFRUUHODWHOHIWYHQWULFXODUYROXPHVDQGIXQFWLRQZLWKODWHHQKDQFHPHQW
/( PDVVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKK\SHUWURSKLFFDUGLRP\RSDWK\ +&0
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWHG SDWLHQWV ZLWK +&0
GLDJQRVLV$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHVWXGLHGZLWKD7056WXG\SURWRFROLQFOXGHGFLQH
7UXH)LVSVHTXHQFHV 75PV7(PV)$WKLFNPPLQIRXUFKDPEHU
YHUWLFDO ORQJ D[LV DQG VKRUWD[LV IROORZHG E\ LQYHUVLRQ UHFRYHU\ 7XUER)ODVK
VHTXHQFHVIRU/(HYDOXDWLRQ 75PV7(PV7,PVWKLFNPPLQ
IRXUFKDPEHUYHUWLFDOORQJD[LVDQGVKRUWD[LV DFTXLUHGPLQXWHVDIWHULY
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIPPRONJRIJDGROLQLXP/HIWYHQWULFXODUYROXPHV ('9HQG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
GLDVWROLFYROXPH(69HQGV\VWROLF69VWURNHYROXPH HMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ () DQG
P\RFDUGLDOPDVVZHUHFDOFXODWHGE\PDQXDOSODQLPHWU\ZLWKDGHGLFDWHGVRIWZDUH
/(PDVVZDVPHDVXUHGRQVKRUWD[LVE\PDQXDOSODQLPHWU\DVDQDUHDZLWK6,!6'
IURPQRUPDOWLVVXH3DWLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRGLIIHUHQWVXEJURXSVZLWK/( JURXS
DQGZLWKRXW/( JURXS )RUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZHXVHG6SHDUPDQ VFRUUHODWLRQ
5HVXOWV,QJURXSZHREVHUYHGWKHIROORZLQJ5HVXOWV('9PO(69
PO()69PODQG/(PDVVJLQJURXSZHREVHUYHG
('9PO(69PO()69PO$VLJQLÀFDWLYHSRVLWLYH
FRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ/(PDVVDQG('9 S (69 S ZDVREWDLQHG
PHDQZKLOHDQHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZLWK() S $FRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ69DQG
/(PDVVZDVQRWUHSRUWHG S
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWLHQWVZLWK/(SUHVHQWDZRUVWOHIWYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQFRPSDUHG
WRFRQWUROJURXS/(PDVVLVFRUUHODWHGZLWKDSURJUHVVLYHV\VWROLFG\VIXQFWLRQ
7KLVÀQGLQJFRXOGEHUHOHYDQWLQWHUPVRIWKHUDSHXWLFDSSURDFKHVSHFLDOO\LQFDVH
RIHDUO\+&0RQVHW
%
%ODFNEORRGYHUVXVEULJKWEORRG7 DFTXLVLWLRQLQFDUGLRYDVFXODU
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH &05 IRUWKDODVVDHPLDPDMRU 70 SDWLHQWV
ZKLFKFDQGREHWWHU"
,'L*LDPSLHWUR&/LJXRUL,6DQVRQL3&LDQFLXOOL/0RUWDWR
%%HRPRQWH=REHO5RPH,7
5RRP3
5DGLRJUDSKHUV
66
'RVHDQGWHFKQLTXHRSWLPLVDWLRQIURPWKH
UDGLRJUDSKHUҋVSHUVSHFWLYH
0RGHUDWRUV
3%ODFNEXUQ$QGHUVHQ.ROGLQJ'.
'7DFN%DXGRXU%(
%
3DWLHQWVNQRZOHGJHDERXWUDGLDWLRQDQGUDGLRORJLFDOSURWHFWLRQ
-33LQKHLUR/395LEHLUR65RGULJXHV$)&/$EUDQWHV&$6LOYD
533$OPHLGD)DUR37 MRDRSLQKHLUR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RREWDLQDQGDQDO\VHSDWLHQWVNQRZOHGJHDQGSHUFHSWLRQVUHJDUGLQJUD
GLDWLRQH[SRVXUHIURPERWKQDWXUDODQGPDQPDGHUDGLDWLRQRIPHGLFDOSURFHGXUHV
DQGLQWHUYHQWLRQV9HULI\LISDWLHQWVZRUU\DERXWWKHLUH[SRVXUHZKHQXQGHUJRLQJ
PHGLFDOH[DPVDUHDZDUHRIDVVRFLDWHGULVNVDQGPHDQVRIUDGLRORJLFDOSURWHFWLRQ
DQGLIWKHLUNQRZOHGJHRQPHGLFDOUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHDIIHFWVWKHLURZQGHFLVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QDPHGLFDOHQYLURQPHQWDVHOIDSSOLHGTXHVWLRQQDLUH
ZDV XVHG DV LQVWUXPHQW DQG DVVLJQHG WR SDWLHQWV ZKR ZRXOG XQGHUJR PHGLFDO
LPDJLQJ H[DPV LQYROYLQJ LRQLVLQJ UDGLDWLRQ$ WRWDO RI YDOLG TXHVWLRQQDLUHV
ZHUHLQWHUSUHWHGDQGVWDWLVWLFDOO\DQDO\VHGWKURXJKGHVFULSWLYHVWDWLVWLFVDQG3KL
&UDPHUV9FRUUHODWLRQWHVWV
5HVXOWVRISDWLHQWVEHOLHYHPRVWRIWKHLUH[SRVXUHGHULYHVIURPHOHFWURQLF
DSSOLDQFHVDQGIURPPHGLFDOLPDJLQJH[DPVZKLOHSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKHUHGX
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
$VWXG\RIWKHDZDUHQHVVRI[UD\UDGLDWLRQGRVHVDPRQJ1RUZHJLDQ
VWXGHQWUDGLRJUDSKHUV
6.DGD%HUJHQ12 VXQGDUDQNDGD#KLEQR
3XUSRVH7R DVVHVV WKH OHYHO RI VWXGHQW UDGLRJUDSKHUVҋ NQRZOHGJH FRQFHUQLQJ
ERWK WKH UDGLDWLRQ GRVHV UHFHLYHG E\ SDWLHQWV XQGHUJRLQJ FRPPRQO\ UHTXHVWHG
UDGLRORJLFDOLQYHVWLJDWLRQVDQGWKHDVVRFLDWHGULVNVRIWKHVHGRVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VXUYH\ZDVVHQWWRDOOUDGLRJUDSK\SURJUDPWHDFKHUVLQ
FKDUJH Q LQ1RUZD\DORQJZLWKDUHTXHVWWRDGPLQLVWHUWKHVXUYH\WRÀQDO\HDU
VWXGHQWUDGLRJUDSKHUVLQWKHLUÀQDOWHUPRIVWXG\7KHTXHVWLRQQDLUHVSHUWDLQHGWR
UDGLDWLRQUHODWHGLVVXHVDQGGHPRJUDSKLFLQIRUPDWLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHUHVSRQVHUDWHZDV 7KHPDMRULW\RIWKHVWXGHQWUDGLRJ
UDSKHUVUHSRUWHGSRRUNQRZOHGJHRIUDGLDWLRQGRVHV7KH\ZHUHHLWKHULJQRUDQWRIRU
XQGHUHVWLPDWHGWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHVXVHGLQWKHYDULRXVLPDJLQJH[DPLQDWLRQV2QO\
VWXGHQWUDGLRJUDSKHUVDQVZHUHGPRUHWKDQRIWKHLWHPVLQDTXHVWLRQQDLUH
GHVLJQHGIRUDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHLUOHYHORINQRZOHGJHFRUUHFWO\2YHUDOO Q
RIWKHVWXGHQWUDGLRJUDSKHUVZHUHQRWDZDUHRIWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHFHLYHGIURPD
FKHVW[UD\DQG Q RIWKHVWXGHQWVZHUHLJQRUDQWRIWKHDQQXDOGRVHOLPLW
IRUWKHSDWLHQWV7KHVWXG\LGHQWLÀHGQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVDPRQJ
UDGLRJUDSK\LQVWLWXWLRQV S DQGEHWZHHQJHQGHUV S
&RQFOXVLRQ2YHUDOOÀQDO\HDUVWXGHQWUDGLRJUDSKHUVҋNQRZOHGJHUHJDUGLQJUDGLD
WLRQGRVHVDQGWKHULVNVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKLRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQLVUHSRUWHGWREHSRRU
%
5DGLRJUDSKHUҋVUROHLQGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQLQFRRSHUDWLRQZLWK
GHQWLVWVLQRUWKRSDQWRPRJUDSK\
$+HQQHU+3R\VNR$53LHWLOD2XOX),+DXNLSXGDV),
DQMDKHQQHU#RDPNÀ
3XUSRVH7RÀQGRXWFRQVHTXHQFHRIUHIHUUDOLQRUWKRSDQWRPRJUDPLFLPDJLQJRI
WKHWHHWKLQRUGHUWRGHFUHDVHSDWLHQWҋVGRVH)ROORZXS RIGRVHVZDVPDGHLQ
RUGHUWRÀQGRXWKRZSHUPDQHQWLVWKHPDQQHURIGHQWLVWVWRDVNSDUWLDO237*
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 'RVH DUHD SURGXFW '$3 RI GLIIHUHQW SURJUDPV ZDV
PHDVXUHGZLWKRXWSDWLHQW7KHYDULDWLRQLQGLIIHUHQWSURJUDPLVODUJHHJZKHQ
XVLQJSDUWLDOSURJUDPLQVWHDGRIZKROHPDQGLEOHWRVHYHQ\HDUROGFKLOGGRVHLV
RQO\RQHWKLUG IURPF*\FPòWRF*\FPò 7KHUDGLRJUDSKHUVDQGGHQWLVWV
HYDOXDWHGFULWLFDOO\WKHSUHVHQWSURFHGXUHVYHU\SRRUUHIHUUDOVZLWKRXWDQ\IRFXVHG
LQGLFDWLRQDQGGXHWRWKLVRUWKRSDQWRPRJUDPZDVDOZD\VWDNHQDVZKROHPDQGLEOH
'HQWLVWVKDYHEHHQUHPLQGHGRIWKHSRVVLELOLW\RISDUWLDO237*DOVRODWHU)RUPRI
237*ZDVDQDO\VHGIURPGLJLWDODUFKLHYHLQWZRPRQWKSHULRGV
5HVXOWV$IWHU PHHWLQJ WKH GHQWLVWV VWDUWHG WR ZULWH EHWWHU UHIHUUDOV ZLWK FOHDU
LQGLFDWLRQVDQGGHWDLOHGLQIRUPDWLRQ2QWKHEDVLVRIWKLVLQIRUPDWLRQUDGLRJUDSKHU
WDNHVZKROHRUSDUWLDOPDQGLEOHDQGVHWWKHN9DQGP$DFFRUGLQJWRWKHUHTXLUHG
LPDJH TXDOLW\7KH GHQWLVWV KDYH WR EH UHPLQGHG RI WKLV SRVVLELOLW\ WR PDNH WKH
SURFHGXUHSHUPDQHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ,WLVHDV\WRGHFUHDVHSDWLHQWGRVHLQFRRSHUDWLRQWKHUHIHUUDOGHQWLVWV
,WUHTXLUHVUDGLRJUDSKHUҋVSURIHVVLRQDODWWLWXGHDQGDFWLYLW\WRUHPLQGWKHGHQWLVWVRI
WKHLPSRUWDQFHRIUHIHUUDODQGLWVDIIHFWWRSDWLHQWҋVGRVHDQGKDUPVGXHWRLRQLVLQJ
UDGLDWLRQWRFKLOGUHQ0XOWLSURIHVVLRQDOFRRSHUDWLRQRSHQGLVFXVVLRQVDQGDZDUH
QHVVRIWKHGRVHOHYHOVDUHWKHNH\SRLQWV
%
5DGLRJUDSKLFLPDJLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVH
RSWLPLVDWLRQLQGLJLWDOLPDJLQJ
033RVVDNND9-2NVDQHQ2XOX), PLNDSRVVDNND#JPDLOFRP
'LJLWDO LPDJLQJ DSSOLFDWLRQV KDYH EHHQ LQFUHDVLQJ UDSLGO\ LQ WKH SDVW \HDUV
,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ RI GLJLWDO LPDJLQJ V\VWHPV KDV LQWURGXFHG D QHHG WR VWXG\ WKH
SRVVLELOLWLHVWKDWGLJLWDOLPDJLQJKDVWRRIIHU7UDGLWLRQDOWUDGHRIIVEHWZHHQLPDJH
TXDOLW\DQGGRVHQRORQJHUH[LVW
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVEHWZHHQEODFNEORRGDQGEULJKWEORRG7 &05DFTXLVLWLRQ
ZKLFKLVVXSHULRULQWHUPVRILPDJHVDUWHIDFWVSUHVHQFHDQGWRHVWDEOLVKLIVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHVFDQEHIRXQGHGLQWHUPVRI7 YDOXHVLQWUDDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDVHWWLQJRI70SDWLHQWVZHSHUIRUPHGERWKFRQ
YHQWLRQDOEULJKWEORRGDQGEODFNEORRG7 &05VHTXHQFHVWRGHWHUPLQHLQWUDDQG
LQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\DQGWKHSUHVHQFHRIDUWHIDFWV,QDOOSDWLHQWVVHSDUDWH
VWXGLHV RI ERWK WHFKQLTXHV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG WR DVVHVV LQWHUVWXG\ UHSURGXFLELOLW\
,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJDSRLQWJUDGLQJVFDOH RYHU\SRRUTXDOLW\
H[FHOOHQWTXDOLW\ DQGLPDJHDQDO\VLVZDVLQDOOFDVHVFRQGXFWHGE\H[SHUL
HQFHGREVHUYHUV
5HVXOWV&DUGLDF7 YDOXHVUDQJHGIURPWRPV7KHPHDQ7 YDOXHV
ZHUHQRWGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQEODFNEORRGDQGEULJKWEORRGDFTXLVLWLRQV YV
PVS &RPSDUHGZLWKWKHFRQYHQWLRQDOEULJKWEORRGGLDVWROLF
DFTXLVLWLRQWKHFRHIÀFLHQWRIYDULDQFHRIWKHEODFNEORRGWHFKQLTXHZDVVXSHULRUIRU
LQWUDREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ S LQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ S
DQGLQWHUVWXG\UHSURGXFLELOLW\ S $VVHVVPHQWRIDUWHIDFWVVKRZHGDVXSHULRU
VFRUHIRUEODFNEORRGYVZKLWHEORRGVFDQV S
&RQFOXVLRQ%ODFNEORRG7 &05KDVVXSHULRUUHSURGXFLELOLW\DQGUHGXFHGLPDJ
LQJDUWHIDFWVIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIFDUGLDFLURQLQFRPSDULVRQZLWKWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO
EULJKWEORRGWHFKQLTXHZKLFKPDNHLWWKHSUHIHUUHGWHFKQLTXHIRUFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
FDWLRQOHYHOVWHQGWRFRQVLGHULVFRPHVIURPWKHHQYLURQPHQW7KHJUHDWPDMRULW\
RISDWLHQWV FRQVLGHUWKDWRQO\FHUWLÀHGSHUVRQQHOVKRXOGRSHUDWHPHGLFDO
LPDJLQJHTXLSPHQWEXWQHYHUDVNIRUWKHLUTXDOLÀFDWLRQVRISDWLHQWV
FODLPWKDW7HFKQRORJLVWVKDYHPRUHHGXFDWLRQRQUDGLRORJLFDOSURWHFWLRQDQGDERXW
RISDWLHQWVUDUHO\RUQHYHUZRUU\DERXWUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHZKHQXQGHUJRLQJ
PHGLFDOLPDJLQJH[DPV
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWLHQWVRYHUHVWLPDWHWKHULVNVRILQGXVWULDOUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHZKLOH
WKH\ XQGHUHVWLPDWH WKH DVVRFLDWHG ULVNV RI PHGLFDO UDGLDWLRQ H[SRVXUH DQG WKH
7HFKQRORJLVWVDELOLW\WRUHGXFHWKHLQKHUHQWUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHRIPHGLFDOLPDJLQJ
H[DPV3DWLHQWVNQRZOHGJHRQUDGLDWLRQDQGUDGLRORJLFDOSURWHFWLRQLVEDVHGPRUH
RQSHUFHSWLRQVDQGEHOLHIVUDWKHUWKDQIDFWXDONQRZOHGJH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRPDNHDVWDQGDUGRIDFWLYLW\IRURSWL
PLVLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHZLWKWKH&'5$'DQDO\VHUSURJUDPDQG
FRQWUDVWGHWDLOSKDQWRP7KHSURGXFWLVLQWHQGHGIRUUDGLRJUDSKHUVVWXGHQWVDQG
SURIHVVLRQDOVZRUNLQJLQWKHÀHOGRIUDGLRJUDSKLFLPDJLQJ7KHIXQFWLRQDODLPZDV
WRFUHDWHDVWDQGDUGRIDFWLYLW\WKDWHQDEOHGXQLIRUPSURFHGXUHLQRSWLPLVLQJWKH
LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,PDJHVZHUHWDNHQXVLQJGLIIHUHQWSDUDPHWHUV P$N9S
ÀOWUDWLRQHWF 7KUHHLPDJHVZHUHWDNHQZLWKWKHVDPHSDUDPHWHUVWRDFKLHYHEHWWHU
UHOLDELOLW\7KHLPDJHVWDNHQRIWKHFRQWUDVWGHWDLOSKDQWRPZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWK
&'5$'DQDO\]HUSURJUDP7KHVWXG\UHYHDOHGKRZGLIIHUHQWLPDJLQJSDUDPHWHUV
DIIHFWHGWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\
5HVXOWV$FFRUGLQJWRWKHUHVXOWVLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVEHWWHUDQGUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUH
ZDVORZHUZKHQN9SZDVDGGHGWRIURPDQGZKHQPP$ODGGHGÀOWUDWLRQ
ZDVXVHG
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVRIWKHSURMHFWFDQEHXWLOLVHGE\UDGLRJUDSKHUVWXGHQWV
DVSDUWRIHYLGHQFHEDVHGOHDUQLQJ2XOX8QLYHUVLW\RI$SSOLHG6FLHQFHVFDQDOVR
LPSOHPHQWWKHUHVXOWVRIWKHVWXG\LQWKHFXUULFXOXP7KXVUDGLDWLRQVDIHW\FDQEH
LPSURYHGLQWKH6FKRRORI+HDOWKDQG6RFLDO&DUHLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHUHJXOD
WLRQVRIWKH0LQLVWU\RI6RFLDO$IIDLUVDQG+HDOWK
%
0DPPRJUDSK\LPDJHTXDOLW\LQ6ZLW]HUODQG
15LFKOL0H\VWUH-/%XOOLDUG/DXVDQQH&+(SDOLQJHV&+
QLFROHULFKOL#KHVDYFK
3XUSRVH$OWKRXJKLPDJHTXDOLW\LQPDPPRJUDSK\KDVEHHQSRVLWLYHO\DVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKVFUHHQLQJSHUIRUPDQFHPDPPRJUDSK\TXDOLW\KDVVHOGRPEHHQDVVHVVHG,Q
6ZLW]HUODQGUHJLRQDOVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPHVXQGHUJRVWULFWTXDOLW\PDQDJHPHQW
SURFHGXUHVZKLFKLQFOXGHFRQWLQXHGWUDLQLQJRIUDGLRJUDSKHUV7KLVVWXG\DLPHG
DWHYDOXDWLQJTXDOLW\RIPDPPRJUDPVLQ6ZLW]HUODQGLWVHYROXWLRQRYHUWLPHDQG
DWLGHQWLI\LQJLWVGHWHUPLQDQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVPDPPRJUDPVSHUIRUPHGEHWZHHQDQG
ZHUHUDQGRPO\GUDZQIURPKRVSLWDOVLQFDQWRQVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWDVFUHHQLQJ
SURJUDPDQGHYDOXDWHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKH3*0, 33HUIHFW**RRG00RGHU
DWH,,QDGHTXDWH FODVVLÀFDWLRQV\VWHP'HWHUPLQDQWVRITXDOLW\ZHUHDVVHVVHG
E\PXOWLYDULDWHORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQVIRULQGLFDWRUVRITXDOLW\
5HVXOWV 2YHUDOO WKH LQDGHTXDWH LPDJH UDWH GHFUHDVHG RYHU WLPH \HDU
&, ZKLOHWKHSURSRUWLRQRIJRRGRUSHUIHFWLPDJHVLQFUHDVHG
\HDU&, +LJKHULPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWK
DPDPPRJUDPEHLQJSHUIRUPHGUHFHQWO\IRUDFUDQLRFDXGDOYLHZLQDKRVSLWDO
ZLWKDKLJKRXWSXW !PDPPRJUDSKLFLPDJHVUDGLRJUDSKHU\HDU DQGZLWKLQ
DVFUHHQLQJSURJUDP7KHLQDGHTXDWHLPDJHUDWHZDV &, ORZHU
ZLWKDGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDPDQGDSHUIHFWRUJRRGLPDJHFODVVLÀFDWLRQWZLFHDVOLNHO\
LQWKHFDQWRQZLWKDQRUJDQLVHGVFUHHQLQJSURJUDP 25 &,
&RQFOXVLRQ0DPPRJUDSK\LPDJHTXDOLW\LVVWHDGLO\LPSURYLQJVLQFH$O
WKRXJKTXDOLW\DVVXUDQFHSURFHGXUHVIRUVFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPHVKDVFRQWULEXWHG
WRWKHKLJKHUTXDOLW\WKHGLIIHUHQFHDFURVVVHWWLQJVKDVGHFUHDVHG7KHDQQXDO
YROXPHRILPDJHVSHUIRUPHGSHUUDGLRJUDSKHUDSSHDUVWREHDVWURQJSUHGLFWRU
RILPDJHTXDOLW\
%
6WXG\RIWKHVFDWWHUHG[UD\GLVWULEXWLRQVDURXQGDPDPPRJUDSK\XQLW
3(/LPD36RXVD65RGULJXHV$)&/$EUDQWHV&$6LOYD/395LEHLUR
533$OPHLGD.%$]HYHGR)DUR37 SDWULFLDHQHVOLPD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RPHDVXUHWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIVFDWWHUHGUDGLDWLRQLQDPDPPRJUDSK\
XQLWIRUVKLHOGLQJGHVLJQSXUSRVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV0HDVXUHPHQWVZHUHFDUULHGRXWZLWKDQDQWKURSRPRUSKLF
SKDQWRPXVHGWRVLPXODWHDERG\IURPRQHDGXOWSDWLHQW7KHGRVHUDWHIRUVFDW
WHUHGUDGLDWLRQZDVUHFRUGHGE\SODFLQJDVROLGVWDWHVHQVRU 8QIRUV;L6XUYH\
'HWHFWRU HYHU\GHJUHHVDWPGLVWDQFHIURPWKH)29FHQWUHLQWKHD[LDODQG
FRURQDOSODQHVRIWKHEUHDVW7KHVFDWWHUHGUDGLDWLRQGLVWULEXWLRQZDVWUHDWHGDV
LVRGRVHFXUYHVVSHFLI\LQJWKHDPRXQWRIUDGLDWLRQWKDWZLOOEHGHOLYHUHGWRDVSH
FLÀFSRLQWLQWKHURRPDURXQGWKHHTXLSPHQW *(6HQRJUDSKH'05 0RUHWKDQ
H[SRVXUHVZHUHPDGHZLWKDWXEHYROWDJHRIN9SDQRGHÀOWHUFRPELQDWLRQ
0R0RDQGODUJHIRFXV
5HVXOWV,QWKHD[LDOSODQHUHVXOWVVKRZWKDWWKHVFDWWHUHGUDGLDWLRQLVDEVRUEHG
XSWRRQWKHEDFNRIWKHDQWKURSRPRUSKLFSKDQWRPDWWKHSRWWHUEXFN\SODQH
KHLJKW ,Q WKH FRURQDO SODQH WKH VFDWWHUHG UDGLDWLRQ VLJQLÀFDQWO\ LQFUHDVHV ZLWK
WKH DQJOH GXH WR EDFNVFDWWHULQJ HIIHFW$VVXPLQJ WKH GLUHFWLRQ RI WKH LQFLGHQFH
EHDPLVGHJUHHUHVXOWVVKRZWKDWWKHVFDWWHUHGUDGLDWLRQLVKLJKHUDW
GHJUHHVWKDQDWGHJUHHV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH W\SH RI PDPPRJUDSKLF YLHZ DQG WKH SDWLHQWV ERG\ VWURQJO\
LQÁXHQFHWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIVFDWWHUHG[UD\UDGLDWLRQ7KHVHUHVXOWVFDQEHXVHG
WRLPSURYHWKHVKLHOGLQJGHVLJQRIDPDPPRJUDSKLFXQLWZLWKOHVVUHVRXUFHVDQG
OHVVVSHQGLQJRQVKLHOGLQJEDUULHUV
%
2SWLFDOJXLGDQFHLQSHUFXWDQHRXV&7JXLGHGSURFHGXUHV
1*UHHQEDXP/$SSHOEDXP$+LUVFKHQEHLQ<$SSOEDXP</LEVRQ
-6RVQD-HUXVDOHP,/5DҋDQDQD,/
3XUSRVH$SRVWPDUNHWLQJSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGWRDVVHVVDFFXUDF\
DQGVDIHW\RID&7EDVHGYLGHRJXLGDQFHV\VWHP:HDOVRORRNHGDWVKRUWHQLQJRI
SURFHGXUHWLPHDQGUHGXFWLRQRIUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHRIWKHSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$OOSDUWLFLSDQWVVLJQHGDQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWIRUP3HU
FXWDQHRXVELRSV\5)DEODWLRQZDVFRQGXFWHGRQSDWLHQWVLQFOXGLQJERWKVRIW
WLVVXHDQGERQHOHVLRQV(LJKWSURFHGXUHVZHUH5)DEODWLRQVDQGZHUHELRSVLHV
)1$$OOSURFHGXUHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGXVLQJ$FWL6LJKWQHHGOHJXLGDQFHV\VWHP7KH
PLQLDWXUHYLGHRFDPHUDRIWKHV\VWHPÀWWHGDOOQHHGOHVXVHGIRUWKHSURFHGXUHV
**DFFRUGLQJWRFRPPRQSUDFWLFH3URFHGXUHUHODWHGGDWDLQFOXGLQJDFFX
UDF\WLPHWRUHDFKOHVLRQQXPEHURIVFDQVDQGFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHVZHUHFRPSLOHG
$FWL6LJKW1HHGOH*XLGDQFH6\VWHP $FWL9LHZV+DLID,VUDHO LVGHVLJQHGWRDVVLVW
&7JXLGHGLQWHUYHQWLRQV,WLQFRUSRUDWHVVNLQDWWDFKHGUHIHUHQFHPDUNHUVDQGD
PLQLDWXUHYLGHRFDPHUDPRXQWHGRQWKHQHHGOH5HJLVWUDWLRQRIWKHYLGHRLPDJH
ZLWKWKH&7LPDJHDOORZVVKRZLQJWKHORFDWLRQRIWKHQHHGOHLQUHDOWLPH
5HVXOWV$FFXUDWHDFFHVVZDVDFKLHYHGLQDOOOHVLRQV VXFFHVV /HVLRQ
GLDPHWHUUDQJHGPPPP PHGLDQPP 0HDQWLPHIRUFRUUHFWQHHGOHSODFH
PHQWZDVPLQ7RWDOQXPEHURI&7VFDQVXQWLOEHJLQQLQJRIDFWXDOSURFHGXUH
ELRSV\DQGRU5)$ ZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU SUHOLPLQDU\ H[SHULHQFH VKRZV WKDW$FWL6LJKWDVVLVWHG SURFH
GXUHV\LHOGDQDFFXUDWHIDVWSURFHVVZLWKOHVVFRQÀUPDWLRQVFDQVGXULQJQHHGOH
SODFHPHQW$FFXUDF\RIQHHGOHSODFHPHQWZDVLQGHSHQGHQWRIWKHOHVLRQVL]HRU
GLIÀFXOW\WRUHDFKWKHVSHFLÀFORFDWLRQ7KHUHZHUHQRV\VWHPUHODWHGFRPSOLFDWLRQV
%
$QRYHORSWLPLVDWLRQVWUDWHJ\LQ&7UHVXOWVLQVLJQLÀFDQWGRVHUHGXFWLRQV
)=DUE0)0F(QWHH/5DLQIRUG0VLGD076\GQH\$8'XEOLQ,(
IUDQFLV]DUE#XPHGXPW
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH RSWLPLVDWLRQ RI &7 SURWRFROV XVLQJ TXDOLW\ DVVXUDQFH
SKDQWRPVDQGDQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHVZLWKLQDSRUFLQHPRGHODUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQG
LPDJHTXDOLW\VWXG\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KUHHVFDQSURWRFROVZHUHDSSOLHGFXUUHQWFOLQLFDOSUR
WRFROVSKDQWRPSURWRFROV EDVHGRQWKHXVHRIORZHVWP$N9DQGKLJKHVWSLWFK
VHWWLQJVEHIRUHVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHVZHUHREMHFWLYHO\PHDVXUHGRQLPDJHVSURGXFHG
IURPD&DWSKDQ&74$SKDQWRP DQGIXUWKHURSWLPLVHGSURWRFROV7KHVH
ZHUHDSSOLHGLQ&7VXLWHVIRUDQDWRPLFDOUHJLRQVSRVWHULRUIRVVDFHUHEUXP
DEGRPHQ DQG FKHVW ,PDJH TXDOLW\ ZDV HYDOXDWHG XVLQJ UHODWLYH YLVXDO JUDGLQJ
DQDO\VLV EDVHG RQ (8 LPDJH TXDOLW\ FULWHULD JXLGHOLQHV WKHQ FULWLFDOO\ UHYLHZHG
ZLWKUHVSHFWWR&7',DQG'/3ÀQGLQJV
5HVXOWV&XUUHQWFOLQLFDOSURWRFROVZHUHUHWDLQHGLQRXWRISURWRFROV&DWSKDQ
EDVHGSURWRFROVZHUHUHWDLQHGLQFDVHVZLWKDGRVHUHGXFWLRQEHWZHHQ
DQGRYHUFXUUHQWFOLQLFDOSURWRFROV)XUWKHURSWLPLVDWLRQZDVDFKLHYHGLQWKH
UHPDLQLQJFDVHVZLWKIXUWKHUGRVHUHGXFWLRQVRI
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\GHPRQVWUDWHVWKDWGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQEDVHGRQREMHFWLYH
SKDQWRPVFDQLPSURYH&7SURWRFROVHIÀFDF\KRZHYHULIXVHGLQFRQMXQFWLRQZLWK
DQLPDOPRGHOVIXUWKHUGRVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\RSWLPLVDWLRQFDQEHDWWDLQHG7KH
XVHRIDQLPDOVLQGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVDOORZVWKHXVHRIPXOWLSOHH[SRVXUHV
ZLWKRXWUDGLDWLRQULVNVWRSDWLHQWVIDFLOLWDWLQJH[SHULPHQWDWLRQDQGHYDOXDWLRQRILP
DJHTXDOLW\XVLQJDQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHVFRPSDUDEOHWRWKRVHRISDWLHQWV
%
3DHGLDWULF&7VFDQQLQJSDUDPHWHUVXVHGLQ*UHHNKRVSLWDOV
'.RXPDULDQRV06DORQLNLGRX(=DORQL$WKHQV*5 HOL]DORQL#\DKRRJU
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHLIVSHFLÀFSURWRFROVUHODWHGZLWKFKLOGUHQDJHVDUHXVHG
LQ&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVXUYH\FRQVLVWHGRITXHVWLRQVDGGUHVVLQJVFDQQHU
GHWDLOVDQGVFDQQLQJSDUDPHWHUVXVHGIRUWKUHHH[DPLQDWLRQV EUDLQFKHVWDQG
DEGRPHQ&7 IRUIRXUDJHJURXSV \HDUVDQGDGXOWV
5HVXOWV7KHVXUYH\ZDVVHQWWRUDGLRJUDSKHUVDQGKRVSLWDOV7KHZHE
EDVHGTXHVWLRQQDLUHZDVÀOOHGRXWE\SHRSOH\HWRQO\TXHVWLRQQDLUHVZHUH
IXOO\ FRPSOHWHG 7KH VFDQQHU ZDV PDLQO\ LQ SXEOLF KRVSLWDO PXOWLVOLFH
ZLWKGHWHFWRUV 7KHSDHGLDWULF&7H[DPLQDWLRQZDVDSSOLHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ZLWKRXWDQ\SDUDPHWHUFKDQJHZLWKUHVSHFWWRDGXOWSURWRFROLQRIFDVHV
3DHGLDWULF&7SDUDPHWHUVZHUHQRWDGMXVWHGRQWKHEDVLVRIWKHDJHRIWKHFKLOGLQ
RIFDVHV)RUFKLOGUHQDQG\HDUVROGDQGIRUDGXOWVFRUUHVSRQGLQJO\
WKHWKLUG&7',TXDUWHUZDVFDOFXODWHGDWDQGP*\IRUEUDLQ
&7DQGP*\IRUFKHVW&7DQGDQGP*\
IRUDEGRPHQ&7
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHLVDFRQVLGHUDEOHSRWHQWLDOIRUGRVHUHGXFWLRQE\RSWLPLVDWLRQRI
VFDQSURWRFROVDQGEHWWHUHGXFDWLRQRIWKHSHUVRQQHO$UHGXFWLRQRI&7',LQDGXOW
SURWRFROV XSWR LVUHTXLUHGZKLFKZLOOUHVXOWLQDVLJQLÀFDQWGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
LQSDHGLDWULFSURWRFROV
%
7KHFRQWUROLQIHFWLRQLQDPDPPRJUDSK\VHWWLQJDORRNLQJRYHU
SUDFWLFHVDQGDQDO\VLVRIPLFURRUJDQLVPV
00&35LEHLUR(/GH2OLYHLUD-6*RPHV0/*RQFDOYHV
-3&RVWD//DQFD-*2ҋ1HLOO-&0DXULFLR/LVERQ377RPDU37
PDUJDULGDULEHLUR#HVWHVOLSOSW
5RRP4
3DHGLDWULF
66
+HDUWDQGFKHVW
0RGHUDWRUV
&%DODVV\9LHQQD$7
&2ZHQV/RQGRQ8.
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRIFKURQLFOXQJGLVHDVHLQLQIDQWZLWKWKLQ
VHFWLRQ&7
)7VXVKLPD62QR+)XMLWD77RNXGD6.DNHKDWD+6HLQR.6KLEXWDQL
+0LXUD<7DNDL+LURVDNL-3 IP\VWVKP#\DKRRFRMS
3XUSRVH$FOLQLFDOFKURQLFSXOPRQDU\GLVRUGHUJURXSRILQIDQWLVQDPHGZLWKFKURQLF
OXQJGLVHDVH FKURQLFOXQJGLVHDVH&/' &/'LVGHÀQHGWKDWDUHVSLUDWRU\GLVWUHVV
V\PSWRPWRQHHGR[\JHQDWLRQIROORZVLQIDQF\DKHDGRIRSHQLQJGD\LQVWDUV
:HHYDOXDWHGDERYHPHQWLRQHGWKLQVHFWLRQ&7ÀQGLQJVDQGSHUIRUPHGREMHFWLYH
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIHPSK\VHPDLQSDWLHQWVZLWK&/'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV9HU\RUH[WUHPHO\ORZELUWKZHLJKWLQIDQWVRIFDVHV
LQWKLVKRVSLWDOLQ6HSWHPEHUVLQFH0D\ZHUHOLVWHG7KHLUPHDQELUWK
ZHLJKWZDV JDQGPHDQJHVWDWLRQDODJHZDV
ZHHNV7KLQVHFWLRQ&7ZHUHSHUIRUPHGDWZHHNVFRUUHFWHGDJHLQDOOFDVHV
7KHHQWLUHOXQJZDVVFDQQHGZLWKPPVHFWLRQWKLFNQHVVZLWKD0'&7VFDQ
QHU /LJKW6SHHG*(86$ 7KHWRWDOOXQJYROXPH &7QXPEHU+8 DQG
YROXPHRIHPSK\VHPDWRXVFKDQJH &7QXPEHU+8 ZHUHPHDVXUHGXVLQJ
WKHWKUHVKROGPHWKRGRQDZRUNVWDWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&RURQDU\DUWHU\DEQRUPDOLWLHVLQ.DZDVDNLGLVHDVHFRPSDULVRQ
EHWZHHQ&7DQG05FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\
-.LP+*RR6HRXO.5 HZRR\D#HPSDOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHYLVLELOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\DE
QRUPDOLWLHVEHWZHHQ&7DQG05LQFKLOGUHQDQGDGROHVFHQWVZLWK.DZDVDNLGLVHDVH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %HWZHHQ DQG D WRWDO RI FKLOGUHQ DQG
DGROHVFHQWV PDOHVUDQJH\HDUV ZLWK.DZDVDNLGLVHDVHZKRSHUIRUPHG
&7 Q RU05 Q FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\,Q
RIWKHPERWK&7DQG05ZHUHSHUIRUPHG9LVLELOLW\ZDVJUDGHGRQDSRLQWVFDOH
H[FHOOHQWGLDJQRVWLF IRUFRURQDU\DUWHULDOVHJPHQWVRIHDFKSDWLHQW&RUR
QDU\DUWHU\DEQRUPDOLWLHV DQHXU\VPVWHQRVLVDQGRFFOXVLRQ ZHUHHYDOXDWHGRQ&7
DQG05EDVHGRQUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGREWDLQHGIURPFDUGLDFFDWKHWHULVDWLRQ Q
HFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\ Q IROORZXS &7 DQG 05 DQG FOLQLFDO KLVWRU\ &RURQDU\
DUWHU\YLVLELOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQ&7DQG05
5HVXOWV2Q&7DQG05VWXGLHVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\RIFRURQDU\DUWHULDO
VHJPHQWVZHUHDVVHVVDEOH 3 ,QSDWLHQWVZLWKERWK&7DQG05
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\RIWKHPZHUHDVVHVVDEOH 3 2Q&7DQG05
VWXGLHVVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339 QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXH 139 DQGDFFXUDF\ZHUHYV 3 YV
3 YV 3 YV 3 DQG
YV 3 UHVSHFWLYHO\,QWKHSDWLHQWVWKH\ZHUHYV
3 YV 3 YV 3 YV
3 DQGYV 3 UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ&7VKRZVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUFRURQDU\DUWHU\YLVLELOLW\VHQVLWLYLW\139
DQGDFFXUDF\LQHYDOXDWLQJFRURQDU\DUWHU\DEQRUPDOLWLHVRI.DZDVDNLGLVHDVH
%
,WHUDWLYHLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHVLQSDHGLDWULF
FDUGLRYDVFXODU&7DQJLRJUDSK\LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGSRWHQWLDOIRU
UDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
)7ULFDULFR3$SIDOWUHU86FKRHSI59OLHJHQWKDUW-56SHDUV
*6DYLQR50DUDQR/%RQRPR$+ODYDFHN&KDUOHVWRQ6&6&86
5RPH,7 IWUL[#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH:HDVVHVVHGLPDJHTXDOLW\LPDJHQRLVHDQGWKHSRWHQWLDOIRUIXUWKHU
UDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQLQFKLOGUHQXQGHUJRLQJXOWUDORZUDGLDWLRQGRVHFDUGLRYDV
FXODU&7DQJLRJUDSK\ F&7$ XVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHQW\IRXU FKLOGUHQ PHGLDQ DJH PRQWKV ZLWK
VXVSHFWHGRUNQRZQFRQJHQLWDOFDUGLRYDVFXODUDQRPDOLHVXQGHUZHQWGXDOVRXUFH
F&7$ZLWK Q RUZLWKRXW Q (&*V\QFKURQLVDWLRQ'DWDZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG
ZLWKÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQLPDJHVSDFH ,5,6
DQGVLQRJUDPDIÀUPHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 6$),5( )RU(&*V\QFKURQLVHG
VWXGLHVKDOIGRVHLPDJHDFTXLVLWLRQZDVVLPXODWHGE\GLVFDUGLQJSURMHFWLRQVIURP
RQHWXEH6LJQDOQRLVHZDVPHDVXUHGZLWKLQWKHDVFHQGLQJDQGGHVFHQGLQJDRUWD
OHIWDWULXPPDLQSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\DQGWKHWUDFKHD,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVJUDGHGIURP
QRQGLDJQRVWLF WR H[FHOOHQW IRUWKHYHQWULFXODUVHSWXPPLWUDOYDOYHDQGDOO
VWUXFWXUHVGHVFULEHGDERYH(IIHFWLYHGRVH (' ZDVHVWLPDWHGXVLQJDJHZHLJKW
VSHFLÀFFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUV5HVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJ7DQG&KLVTXDUHWHVWLQJ
5HVXOWV,PDJHQRLVHZLWK,5,6DQGIXOOGRVH6$),5(ZDVORZHUWKDQZLWK)%3
DQGYHUVXVDOOS ZKLOH615ZDVKLJKHU
DQGYHUVXVS ,PDJHTXDOLW\VFRUHVZHUHKLJKHU
IRU,5,6DQGIXOOGRVH6$),5(WKDQIRU)%3 DQGYHUVXV
S $YHUDJH('ZDVP6YZLWKRXWDQGP6YZLWK(&*V\QFKURQLVDWLRQ
,QKDOIGRVH(&*V\QFKURQLVHG6$),5(VWXGLHV HVWLPDWHGDYHUDJH('P6Y
LPDJHQRLVH ZDVVWLOOVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S ORZHUDQG615
KLJKHUWKDQLQIXOOGRVH)%3VWXGLHVZKLOHLPDJHTXDOLW\ ZDVPDLQWDLQHG
&RQFOXVLRQ$WXOWUDORZUDGLDWLRQGRVHSDHGLDWULFF&7$LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
WHFKQLTXHVLPSURYHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGKROGSRWHQWLDOIRUVXEVWDQWLDOIXUWKHUUHGXF
WLRQVLQUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
3XUSRVH7KHFOHDQLQJDQGGLVLQIHFWLRQRIPHGLFDOVXUIDFHVDQGHTXLSPHQWVDV
ZHOOWKHKDQGK\JLHQHDUHEDVLFPHDVXUHVWRJXDUDQWHHVDIHSUDFWLFHVLQWKHFRQWURO
LQIHFWLRQRIKHDOWKFDUH7KLVVWXG\DLPHGWRLGHQWLI\WKHVWHSVLQPDPPRJUDSK\
&5 FRPSXWRUL]HGUDGLRORJ\ SURFHVVFKDUDFWHULVLQJWKHPDFFRUGLQJWRWKHSUHV
HQFHRIPLFURRUJDQLVPVDQGLGHQWLI\WKHSUDFWLFHVWKDWOHDGWRWKHLUWUDQVPLVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHREVHUYDWLRQDOGDWDZHUHFROOHFWHGLQDIRUPIURP:+2
LQRUGHUWRFKDUDFWHULVHWKHK\JLHQHSUDFWLFHVDSSOLHGE\UDGLRJUDSKHUV,QDGGLWLRQ
IRUGLIIHUHQWWLPHVPLFURRUJDQLVPVZHUHFROOHFWHGIURPÀYHVXUIDFHVLQWKHPDP
PRJUDSK\URRP DQDO\WLFFRPSRQHQW %HIRUHSHUIRUPLQJHDFKH[DPLQDWLRQWKH
UDGLRJUDSKHUQHYHUZDVKHGKHUKDQGV8VLQJZDWHUDQGVRDSVKHDOZD\VZDVKHG
KHUKDQGVDIWHUWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVH[FHSWLQFDVH2QO\RQHWLPHVKHXVHGDQ
DOFRKROEDVHGDQWLVHSWLFVROXWLRQ7KHHTXLSPHQWZDVGLVLQIHFWHGLQRIWKH
FDVHV7KHPLFURRUJDQLVPVIRXQGLQWKHPDPPRJUDSK\VXUIDFHVZHUHFRDJXODVH
QHJDWLYH6WDSK\ORFRFFXV0LFURFRFFXVVSS6XVSHFWHG(QWHURFRFFXVVSS
6WUHSWRFRFFXV VSS %DFWHULDO FRQWDPLQDWLRQ RI VXUIDFHV DQG WKH
SDWKRJHQLFPLFURRUJDQLVP(VFKHULFKLD&ROL FROOHFWHGRQWKHNH\ERDUG
5HVXOWV7KHKDQGVK\JLHQHVKRXOGEHSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKHFRQWDFW
ZLWKWKHSDWLHQWXVLQJDQDOFRKROEDVHGDQWLVHSWLFVROXWLRQ7KHPDPPRJUDSK\ҋV
HTXLSPHQWDQGRWKHUPHGLFDOVXUIDFHVPXVWEHGLVLQIHFWHGEHWZHHQHDFKSDWLHQW
DWWKHEHJLQQLQJDQGHQGRIHDFKZRUNVHVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$OWKRXJK [UD\ H[DPLQDWLRQV VXFK DV PDPPRJUDSK\ DUH XQGHU
YDOXHGLQWKLVPDWWHUGXHWRWKHSURFHGXUHVPRVWO\ZLWKDPEXODWRU\SDWLHQWVWKLV
VWXG\DOORZHGWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIWKHPDQ\W\SHVRIPLFURRUJDQLVPEHLQJRQHRI
WKHVHSDWKRJHQLF
5HVXOWV(OHYHQRIDOOFDVHVWKDWZHUHFOLQLFDOO\GLDJQRVHGDV&/'$OOFDVHVKDG
&7ÀQGLQJVRIHPSK\VHPDWRXVFKDQJH7KHLUPHDQWRWDOOXQJYROXPHZDV
PODQGPHDQYROXPHRIHPSK\VHPDWRXVFKDQJHZDV PO
6L[LQIDQWVKDGDVHYHUHLQLWLDOUHVSLUDWRU\FRXUVHDQGZHQWKRPHRQR[\JHQ)LYH
RIVL[FDVHVZKRKDGODUJHDPRXQWRIHPSK\VHPDWRXVFKDQJHKDGFRQVHTXHQWO\
EHFRPHZLWKKRPHR[\JHQWKHUDS\7KHLUPHDQYROXPHRIHPSK\VHPDZDVPO
7KHUHZDVQRGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQHDFKLOOQHVVW\SHDQGOXQJYROXPHPHDVXUHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ4XDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRIHPSK\VHPDWRXVFKDQJHVFODVVLÀFDWLRQRI
SURJQRVLVLQLQIDQWZLWK&/'
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
1HZFRQYHUVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVIRUGRVHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQKLJK
UHVROXWLRQFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ +5&7 RIWKHFKHVWLQQHRQDWHV
DQGLQIDQWV
0&6HLGHQEXVFK.6FKQHLGHU
0XQLFK'( PLFKDHOVHLGHQEXVFK#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH5HFRQVWUXFWLRQRIRUJDQDQGWLVVXHGRVHVDFKLHYHGGXULQJFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSKLF &7 H[DPLQDWLRQVLVSHUIRUPHGE\DSSO\LQJFRQYHUVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV
V\QRQ\PRXVO\QRUPDOLVHGRUJDQGRVHV WREDVLFGRVHLQGLFDWRUVOLNHWKH&7',RU
WKHGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW7KHFDOFXODWLRQVRIFRQYHUVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVSXEOLVKHGVRIDU
FRQVLGHURQO\VOLFHWKLFNQHVVHVRIPRUHWKDQPP$VDFRQVHTXHQFHHVSHFLDOO\
LQVPDOORUJDQVWKHWLVVXHGRVHVDUHJUHDWO\XQGHUHVWLPDWHG$V+5&7H[DPLQD
WLRQVRIWKHOXQJVLQQHRQDWHVDQGLQIDQWVDUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKVOLFHWKLFNQHVVHVRI
PPQHZFRQYHUVLRQIDFWRUVDUHQHHGHG
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )RU WKH FDOFXODWLRQ RI QHZ FRQYHUVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQWV D
QHZDOJRULWKPQDPHG&7;ZDVGHYHORSHGE\WKHDXWKRUVLQRUGHUWRDSSO\WKH
FRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOH3&;0&0RQWH&DUORDOJRULWKPGHYHORSHGE\WKH)LQQLVK
5DGLDWLRQDQG1XFOHDU6DIHW\$XWKRULW\678.IRUGRVHFDOFXODWLRQVLQ&7
5HVXOWV1HZFRQYHUVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVIRURUJDQGRVHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQ+5&7RI
QHRQDWHVDQG\RXQJLQIDQWVDUHSUHVHQWHGZLWKDVOLFHUHVROXWLRQRIPPDQG
DQDQJXODUUHVROXWLRQRIZLWKDIRUPDOFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIYDULRXVERZWLHÀOWHUV
,QVPDOORUJDQVVXFKDVWKHWK\URLGJODQGDQGWKHPDPPDU\JODQGVRUJDQGRVHV
FDOFXODWHGE\DSSO\LQJWKHQHZPHWKRGFDQH[FHHGWKHWLVVXHGRVHVSUHGLFWHGE\
WKHFRQYHUVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVSXEOLVKHGVRIDUE\PRUHWKDQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$IWHULPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIUHDOERZWLHÀOWUDWLRQGDWDWKHQHZFRQYHUVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQWVVKRXOGDOORZDUHDOLVWLFUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIRUJDQGRVHVDFKLHYHGGXULQJ
+5&7H[DPLQDWLRQVLQQHRQDWHVDQGLQIDQWV
%
5DGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQLQFKHVW&7ZLWKWKHDGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDO
LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6,5 WHFKQLTXHLQFKLOGUHQ
6/HH6HRXO.5
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\RISHGLDWULF
FKHVW&7WDNHQZLWKDGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6,5 DQGZLWK
URXWLQHSURWRFRO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\VL[SDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWV 0) DJH
\HDUVPHDQ KDGVHSDUDWHFKHVW&7ZLWKORZGRVH$6,5DQGURXWLQHGRVH
RQGLIIHUHQWGD\VEHWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG-XQH PHDQIROORZXSLQWHUYDO
GD\V 9ROXPH&7GRVHLQGLFHV &7',YRO GRVHOHQJWKSURGXFWV '/3 ZHUH
UHFRUGHGDQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHZHUHFDOFXODWHGWRHVWLPDWHUDGLDWLRQGRVH7KHLP
DJHTXDOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHGVXEMHFWLYHO\E\WKUHHUDGLRORJLVWVIRUQRLVHVKDUSQHVV
DUWHIDFWVDQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFHSWDELOLW\ZLWKDIRXUSRLQWVFDOH 2EMHFWLYHQRLVH
DQG&7QXPEHUZHUHPHDVXUHGLQWKHGHVFHQGLQJDRUWDDQGSDUDVSLQDOPXVFOH
DWWKHOHYHORIFDULQD
5HVXOWV7KH$6,5VWXGLHVSUHVHQWHGDQGUHGXFWLRQVLQ&7',YRO
IURPWRP*\ '/3 IURPWRP*\[FP DQGHIIHFWLYH
GRVH IURPWRP6Y UHVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHGWRWKHURXWLQHGRVHVWXG
LHV7KHVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVQRWGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQWKH$6,5DQGURXWLQH
SURWRFRO7KHREMHFWLYHQRLVHZDVKLJKHULQWKHSDUDVSLQDOPXVFOHRI$6,5JURXS
YV EXWQRWGLIIHUHQWLQWKHDRUWD YV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRI$6,5ORZHUVWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHLQSDHGLDWULFFKHVW
&7PRUHWKDQZKLOHPDLQWDLQLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\
%
&RPSDULVRQRIQRQEUHDWKKHOGVLQJOHSKDVH&7DQG'
UHFRQVWUXFWHGEURQFKRVFRSLFLPDJHVZLWKEURQFKRVFRS\IRU
GLDJQRVLQJDLUZD\PDODFLDLQLQIDQWV
++RQJ6$,P6HRXO.5 GD\GUHDPHUKRQJ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVLVRIDLUZD\PDODFLDLQFKLOGUHQLVGLIÀFXOWDQGDQ
DFFXUDWHDQGQRQLQYDVLYHPHWKRGLVEHLQJUHTXLUHG7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\
LVWRFRPSDUHWKHDFFXUDF\RIIUHHEUHDWKLQJ&7VFDQVRIWKHDLUZD\LQFKLOGUHQ
IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDLUZD\PDODFLDXVLQJEURQFKRVFRS\DVWKH´JROGVWDQGDUGµ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFOXGHVFKLOGUHQZKRUH
FHLYHGERWKEURQFKRVFRS\DQG&7VFDQRIWKHDLUZD\VLQRXULQVWLWXWLRQ&7VFDQV
LQFOXGHGWKHFKHVWGLPHQVLRQ ' &7EURQFKRVFRS\QHFNDQGEUDLQ&7VFDQV
$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHVFDQQHGZLWKDQRQEUHDWKKHOGSURWRFROXVLQJDGHWHFWRU
PXOWLVOLFHKHOLFDO&7VFDQQHU$QWHURSRVWHULRU $3 DQGWUDQVYHUVH 7U GLDPHWHUV
RIWKHVXSUDJORWWLFODU\Q[JORWWLVWUDFKHDDQGEURQFKXVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQWKHD[LDO
&7VFDQV$LUWUDSSLQJDQGDLUZD\QDUURZLQJLQWKH'UHFRQVWUXFWHGLPDJHVZHUH
FKHFNHG%URQFKRVFRS\ZDVXVHGDVWKHJROGVWDQGDUGDQGDLUZD\PDODFLDZDV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
GHÀQHGDVPRUHWKDQQDUURZLQJRIWKHDLUZD\/RJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOZDV
XVHGIRUFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ&7PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGWKHEURQFKRVFRSLFÀQGLQJDQG
UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFFXUYHZDVXVHGWRÀQGFXWRIIYDOXHV
5HVXOWVFKLOGUHQXQGHU\HDUV LQIDQWV ZHUHLQFOXGHGRIZKLFKKDG
DLUZD\PDODFLD &7 PHDVXUHPHQWV ZKLFK GHPRQVWUDWHG VLJQLÀFDQW FRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKEURQFKRVFRSLFÀQGLQJVLQFOXGHGWKHVXSUDJORWWLFODU\QJHDO$3 $8&
WUDFKHDO$3 $8& EURQFKLDO$3 $8& WUDFKHDO$3WUDFKHDO7UUDWLR
$8& EURQFKXV$3GLVWDOWUDFKHDO7UUDWLR $8& DQGDLUZD\QDUURZ
LQJLQ'UHFRQVWUXFWHGLPDJHV S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDFFXUDF\RIIUHHEUHDWKLQJ&7VFDQRIWKHDLUZD\LQGHWHFWLQJ
DLUZD\PDODFLDLQFKLOGUHQLVFRPSDUDEOHWRWKHEURQFKRVFRS\ZLWKOHVVHUUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHFRPSDUHGWRGXDOSKDVHRUFLQH&7VFDQVRIWKHDLUZD\
%
&KHVW05,LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRISXOPRQDU\DOWHUDWLRQVGHWHFWHGE\&7
LQWKHIROORZXSRISDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWVZLWKPLGGOHOREHV\QGURPH
0/6 FRPSDULVRQZLWK;5
*6HUUD*&LDUOR90DVVDFFHVL$)LRUHOOL6/LEHUDOL03DROHWWL
&&DWDODQR)0DFUL))UDLROL5RPH,7
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHPRVWIUHTXHQWSXOPRQDU\DOWHUDWLRQVGHWHFWHGE\&7LQ
DJURXSRISHGLDWULFSDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\PLGGOHOREHV\QGURPH 0/6 DWWKHWLPH
RIGLDJQRVLVDQGWKHSRVVLEOHUROHRIFKHVW05,LQFRPSDULVRQZLWK;5LQWKHLU
IROORZXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK0/6 PHDQDJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQWD
FKHVW&7DWWLPHRIGLDJQRVLV N9&$5(GRVHZLWKTXDOLW\UHIHUHQFHP$V
FROOLPDWLRQ[PPURWDWLRQWLPHVHFVFDQWLPHVHF $WIROORZXS
PHDQWLPHPRQWKV DOOSDWLHQWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWKFKHVW05, UHVSLUDWRU\
WULJJHUHG'3ZHLJKWHG%/$'(VHTXHQFH757()29PPÁLS
DQJOHVOLFHWKLFNQHVVPPD[LDODQGFRURQDOSODQH DQG;57KHIROORZLQJ
OXQJ DOWHUDWLRQV ZHUH DVVHVVHG EURQFKLHFWDVLV EURQFKLDOZDOOWKLFNHQLQJ DWHO
HFWDVLVFRQVROLGDWLRQ PXFXVSOXJJLQJ /\PSKDGHQRSDWKLHV ZHUH HYDOXDWHG RQ
&7VDQG05,VIUHTXHQFLHVRIHDFKDOWHUDWLRQZHUHUHFRUGHGIRUHDFKH[DPLQDWLRQ
LQDOOSDWLHQWV
5HVXOWV&7DWGLDJQRVLVUHSRUWHGEURQFKLHFWDVLVLQRISDWLHQWVEURQFKLDO
ZDOOWKLFNHQLQJ DWHOHFWDVLVFRQVROLGDWLRQ PXFXVSOXJJLQJ
O\PSKDGHQRSDWKLHV)ROORZXS05,EURQFKLHFWDVLVLQRISDWLHQWV ;5
EURQFKLDOZDOOWKLFNHQLQJ ;5 DWHOHFWDVLVFRQVROLGDWLRQ ;5
PXFXVSOXJJLQJ ;5 O\PSKDGHQRSDWLHV7KHPRVWIUHTXHQW
ORFDOLVDWLRQZDVPLGGOHOREHIRUDOODOWHUDWLRQVERWKDWEDVHOLQHDQGIROORZXS
&RQFOXVLRQ &7 HYDOXDWLRQ VKRZHG WKDW 0/6 FDQ EH FKDUDFWHULVHG E\ YDULRXV
SDUHQFK\PDODQGDLUZD\VDOWHUDWLRQVDOUHDG\DWGLDJQRVLVDWIROORZXS;5XQGHU
HVWLPDWHGWKHQXPEHURIDOWHUDWLRQVFRPSDUHGWRFKHVW05,05,PLJKWUHSUHVHQW
DIHDVLEOHRSWLRQLQWKHIROORZXSRISDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\0/6
%
)ORZVHQVLWLYH'05,RIDRUWLFEORRGÁRZLQSDWLHQWVZLWK0DUIDQ
V\QGURPH
-*HLJHU00DUNO5$UQROG%-XQJ'+LUWOHU/+HU]HU%6WLOOHU
0/DQJHU)UHLEXUJ'(&KLFDJR,/86 MXOLDJHLJHU#XQLNOLQLNIUHLEXUJGH
3XUSRVH7RDSSO\ÁRZVHQVLWLYH'05,IRUWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIÁRZSDWWHUQ
FKDQJHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK0DUIDQV\QGURPH 0)6 FRPSDUHGWRQRUPDOFRQWUROV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)ORZVHQVLWLYH'05,RIWKHWKRUDFLFDRUWD WHPSRUDO
UHVROXWLRQaPVVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQaPPYHQF FPV ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ
SDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\ ZLWKFRQÀUPHG0)6DQGKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV PHDQDJH
\ $RUWLFKDHPRG\QDPLFVZDVYLVXDOLVHGE\'SDUWLFOHWUDFHVDQGVWUHDPOLQHV
$EQRUPDOÁRZSDWWHUQV KHOL[DQGYRUWH[ÁRZ LQWKHDVFHQGLQJDRUWD $$R DRUWLF
DUFKDQGGHVFHQGLQJDRUWD '$R ZHUHJUDGHGLQWKUHHFDWHJRULHV EOLQGHGUHDG
LQJ REVHUYHUV 4XDQWLWDWLYH HYDOXDWLRQ FRPSULVHG WKH FDOFXODWLRQ RI UHJLRQDO
WLPHDYHUDJHGDEVROXWHZDOOVKHDUVWUHVV :66 DQGSHDNYHORFLWLHVDWHLJKWVLWHV
5HVXOWV/RFDOKHOLFDOÁRZLQWKH$$RZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S LQFUHDVHGLQ
0)6 SDWLHQWV DQG ZDV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK DRUWLF VLQXV GLODWDWLRQ7KH LQFLGHQFH RI
JOREDODQGYRUWH[ÁRZLQWKH'$RZDVLQFUHDVHGLQSDWLHQWV DQG FRP
SDUHG WR YROXQWHHUV QRQH DQG ,QWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW ZDV VXEVWDQWLDO
ѣ 4XDQWLWDWLYH DQDO\VLV UHYHDOHG D VLJQLÀFDQW LQFUHDVH LQ UHJLRQDO DRUWLF
:66 1PLQSDWLHQWVYV1PLQYROXQWHHUVS DW
WKHORFDWLRQRIORFDOKHOL[ÁRZ
&RQFOXVLRQ'ÁRZDQDO\VLVUHYHDOHGPDUNHGGLIIHUHQFHVRIWKHDRUWLFÁRZSDW
WHUQVEHWZHHQ0)6SDWLHQWVDQGFRQWUROV7KHSUHVHQFHRIORFDOKHOL[ÁRZDQGWKH
LQFUHDVHG:66LQWKH0)6SDWLHQWVҋ$$RPD\EHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHLQFUHDVHG
LQFLGHQFHRIDRUWLFURRWGLODWDWLRQ7KHKLJKSUHYDOHQFHRIYRUWH[DQGKHOL[ÁRZLQ
WKHSUR[LPDO'$RPD\SURPRWH7\SH%GLVVHFWLRQRULJLQDWLQJIURPWKLVVLWH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHZKHWKHUG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJ '&(
05, RIWKHOXQJLQVXUYLYRUVDIWHU&'+UHSDLU DW7LVIHDVLEOHLQ\HDUROG
FKLOGUHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFKLOGUHQZLWKDPHDQDJH\HDUVDQGNJ
RIERG\ZHLJKWDIWHU&'+UHSDLULQFOXGLQJIHPDOHDQGPDOHFKLOGUHQXQGHUZHQW
'&(05,DW7XVLQJDWLPHUHVROYHGDQJLRJUDSK\ZLWKVWRFKDVWLFWUDMHFWRULHV
7:,67 VHTXHQFH4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIOXQJSHUIXVLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDSL[HO
E\SL[HOGHFRQYROXWLRQDSSURDFKLPSOHPHQWHGLQDQLQKRXVH2VLUL;SOXJLQ6L[
52,VZHUHFDUHIXOO\SODFHGLQWKHXSSHUPLGGOHDQGORZHUSDUWRIWKHULJKWDQGOHIW
OXQJWRDFFHVVGLIIHUHQFHVLQSXOPRQDU\EORRGÁRZZKLOHDYRLGLQJWKHLQFOXVLRQRI
ODUJHUSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHVDQGYHLQV
5HVXOWV$YHUDJHUHJLRQDOSXOPRQDU\EORRGÁRZ U3%) IRUWKHK\SRSODVWLFOXQJV
ZDV P/ P/PLQ DQG P/ P/PLQ IRU WKH FRQWUDODWHUDO
VLGH7KHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQK\SRSODVWLFDQGFRQWUDODWHUDOOXQJZDVVLJQLÀFDQW
S $OVRWKHGLIIHUHQFHVLQU3%)PHDVXUHGLQWKHDSLFDOPLGGOHDQGORZHU
OXQJZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQK\SRSODVWLFOXQJVDQGFRQWUDODWHUDOVLGHV
DSLFDOS PLGGOHS ORZS 6LJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ
XSSHUPLGGOHDQGORZHUOXQJUHJLRQVRIWKHVDPHVLGHFRXOGQRWEHGHWHFWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ '&(05, RI WKH OXQJ LQ \HDUROG SDWLHQWV LV IHDVLEOH DW 7
,SVLODWHUDOOXQJK\SRSODVLDZLWKUHGXFHGSHUIXVLRQLVUHÁHFWHGE\VLJQLÀFDQWORZHU
U3%)YDOXHVFRPSDUHGWRWKHFRQWUDODWHUDOOXQJ'&(05,RIWKHOXQJLQ&'+FDQ
KHOSFKDUDFWHULVLQJOXQJK\SRSODVLDLQLWLDOO\DQGLQORQJWHUPIROORZXSRIFKLOGUHQ
DIWHU&'+UHSDLU
&RPSXWHU$SSOLFDWLRQV
3XUSRVH (YHQ LQ LWV UG GHFDGH RI FOLQLFDO DSSOLFDWLRQ GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ RI
05PDPPRJUDSK\ 050 LV VWLOO QRW ZHOO XQGHUVWRRG DQG UHPDLQV GLVFXVVHG
FRQWURYHUVLDOO\ 7R D PDMRU SDUW WKLV LV FHUWDLQO\ GXH WR GLIIHUHQW VWDQGDUGVRI
UHIHUHQFH 625KLVWRORJLFDOYHULÀFDWLRQIROORZXSHWF DQGFRPSRVLWLRQRISDWLHQW
FROOHFWLYHVLQSUHYLRXVVWXGLHVSDUWLFXODUO\WKHJURXSRIWUXHQHJDWLYH050UHVXOWV
LVFKDOOHQJLQJWRDQDO\VHDVVXFKRIWHQGRQRWJHWKLVWRORJLFDOVDPSOLQJDQ\PRUH
DQGDUHIROORZHGXSFOLQLFDOO\UDGLRORJLFDOO\,QWKLVVFHQDULRRQO\ORQJWHUP050
IROORZXSLVDEOHWRSURYLGHDYDOLG625$FFRUGLQJO\ZHGHVLJQHGWKLVLQYHVWLJD
WLRQWRLGHQWLI\WKHDFFXUDF\RI050DVLQWHUSUHWHGE\QRQH[SHUWUHDGHUVGHÀQLQJ
KLVWRORJLFDOYHULÀFDWLRQDQGORQJWHUP050IROORZXSDV625
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2YHU\HDUVDOOFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVUHFHLYLQJ050ZLWK
VXEVHTXHQWKLVWRORJLFDOYHULÀFDWLRQRU050IROORZXS!\HDUVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWR
WKLVSURVSHFWLYHFURVVVHFWLRQDOLQYHVWLJDWLRQ H[FOXVLRQ%,5$'69,DGMXYDQW
QHRDGMXYDQW FKHPRWKHUDS\ RU DQ\ RWKHU EUHDVWWUHDWPHQW EHWZHHQ LQLWLDO DQG
IROORZXS050 ,QLWLDO050ZDVLQWHUSUHWHGE\QRQH[SHUWUHDGHUV a050
3ULPDU\ 050GLDJQRVLV DQG UHVXOWV RI WKH UHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGV KLVWRORJ\ ÀQG
LQJV XSRQ ORQJWHUP IROORZXS 625KLVWRORJ\625IROORZXS ZHUH DVVHVVHG E\
FRQWLQJHQF\WDEOHV
5HVXOWV SDWLHQWV ZHUH LQFOXGHG 625KLVWRORJ\ 625IROORZXS
3UHWHVWSUREDELOLW\ ZDV 0DLQ LQGLFDWLRQ IRU LQLWLDO050 ZDV VFUHHQLQJ IRU
UHFXUUHQFH RI EUHDVWFDQFHU RU %,5$'6 ,, ,,, DQG ,9
FODVVLÀFDWLRQLQFRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJ7KHQRQH[SHUWUHDGHUVDFKLHYHG
KLJKVSHFLÀFLW\ DQGSRVLWLYHOLNHOLKRRGUDWLR 2YHUDOODFFXUDF\UHDFKHG
H[FHOOHQWRGGVUDWLR 6HQVLWLYLW\ QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH
DQGQHJDWLYHOLNHOLKRRGUDWLR
&RQFOXVLRQ 050 SURYLGHV H[FHOOHQW RYHUDOO GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ VHQVLWLYLW\
DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYH(YHQLQQRQH[SHUWUHDGHUV050KDVDKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\
66
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHSXOPRQDU\SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJDW7RI\HDUROG
FKLOGUHQDIWHUFRQJHQLWDOGLDSKUDJPDWLFKHUQLD &'+ UHSDLU
:1HII.=DKQ76FKDLEOH626FKRHQEHUJ/56FKDG)*=RHOOQHU
0DQQKHLP'( ZROIJDQJQHII#XPPGH
5RRP=
&RPSXWHUDVVLVWHGGLDJQRVLV &$'
0RGHUDWRUV
%0HUOLQR5RPH,7
5YDQҊW.ORRVWHU/HLGHQ1/
$VLPSOHDQGUREXVWFODVVLÀFDWLRQWUHHIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQ
EHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVLQ05PDPPRJUDSK\
3$7%DOW]HU7*URHVFKHO+3%XUPHLVWHU:$.DLVHU0'LHW]HO
-HQD'( SDVFDOEDOW]HU#PHGXQLMHQDGH
3XUSRVH$PXOWLWXGHRIOHVLRQGHVFULSWRUVKDVEHHQSURSRVHGLQRUGHUWRLPSURYH
GLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVLQEUHDVW05,,QFOLQLFDOURXWLQHDSUDFWLFDODOJRULWKPIRUOHVLRQ
FODVVLÀFDWLRQLVQHHGHG6XFKDQDOJRULWKPVKRXOGEHDVVLPSOHDVSRVVLEOHDQG
LQFOXGHRQO\WKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWOHVLRQIHDWXUHVZLWKWKHKLJKHVWSRZHUWRGLIIHUHQWL
DWHEHQLJQIURPPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV7KLVLQYHVWLJDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGLQRUGHUWR
GHYHORSDVLPSOHFODVVLÀFDWLRQWUHHIRUGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVLQDODUJHGDWDEDVH
DQGHVWLPDWHLWVGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVOHVLRQVLQVWDQGDUGLVHGEUHDVW05, 7G\QDPLF
7ZDIWHUPPRO*G'73$7Z76( ZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOYHULÀFDWLRQ PDOLJ
QDQWEHQLJQ ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGFDWHJRULFDOOHVLRQGHVFULSWRUVZHUHDV
VHVVHGE\H[SHULHQFHGUHDGHUV&ODVVLÀFDWLRQDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJWKH
&KLVTXDUHGDXWRPDWLFLQWHUDFWLRQGHWHFWLRQ &+$,' PHWKRG5HVXOWVLQFOXGHWKH
SUREDELOLW\IRUPDOLJQDQF\IRUHYHU\GHVFULSWRUFRPELQDWLRQLQWKHFODVVLÀFDWLRQWUHH
5HVXOWV$FODVVLÀFDWLRQWUHHLQFRUSRUDWLQJOHVLRQGHVFULSWRUVZLWKDGHSWKRI
UDPLÀFDWLRQV URRW URRWOLNHERUGHUGHQGULWH GHOD\HGHQKDQFHPHQW 3HUVLVW
HQW3ODWHDX:DVKRXW ERUGHULQWHUQDOHQKDQFHPHQWRHGHPD DQGWHUPLQDO
QRGHVZDVFDOFXODWHGRIDOOEHQLJQDQGRIDOOPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVZHUH
FRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHGPDOLJQDQW DQGEHQLJQ OHVLRQVFRXOG
EHFODVVLÀHGZLWKDQDFFXUDF\DERYH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHFODVVLÀFDWLRQDOJRULWKPXVHGZDVDEOHWRUHGXFHWKHQXPEHURI
FDWHJRULFDOGHVFULSWRUVWREHDQDO\VHGIURPWR UHVXOWLQJLQDKLJK
FODVVLÀFDWLRQDFFXUDF\0RUHWKDQRQHWKLUGRIDOOOHVLRQVFRXOGEHFODVVLÀHGZLWK
DQDFFXUDF\DERYH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
&RPSXWHUDLGHGGLDJQRVLV &$'[ LVDIHDVLEOHSURJQRVWLFELRPDUNHU
IRUWKHQRQLQYDVLYHSUHGLFWLRQRID[LOODU\O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHV
0'LHW]HO5=RXEL++DEUHFKW0*DMGD,%5XQQHEDXP:$.DLVHU
3$7%DOW]HU-HQD'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH&RPSXWHUDLGHGGLDJQRVLV &$'[ DOORZVVHPLDXWRPDWLFDVVHVVPHQW
RIEUHDVWOHVLRQLQ05PDPPRJUDSK\ 050 3UHYLRXVLQYHVWLJDWLRQVVXJJHVWHG
WKDWVXFK&$'[GDWDPLJKWQRWRQO\EHXVHGIRUGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRIEHQLJQYV
OHVLRQVEXWFRXOGDOVRSURYLGHVRPHSURJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQ:HDLPHGWRIXUWKHU
HYDOXDWHWKLVDSSURDFKDQGHYDOXDWHGWKHSRWHQWLDORI&$'[WRSUHGLFWWKHPRVW
VLQJOHLPSRUWDQWSURJQRVWLFIDFWRULQSULPDU\EUHDVWFDQFHULHD[LOODU\O\PSKQRGH
PHWDVWDVLVE\&$'[EDVHGDQDO\VLVRI050
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\LQYDVLYHEUHDVW
FDQFHUUHFHLYLQJSUHWKHUDSHXWLFVWDJLQJ050DFFRUGLQJWR(862%,JXLGHOLQHV
ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWRWKLVSURVSHFWLYHFURVVVHFWLRQDOVWXG\6XUJLFDOD[LOODU\VWDJLQJ
ZDVGHÀQHGDVUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG%UHDVW05,ZDVDQDO\VHGXVLQJFRPPHUFLDO
&$'VRIWZDUH,WHYDOXDWHVVHPLDXWRPDWLFDOO\IXQFWLRQDOWLVVXHSDUDPHWHUVRIWKH
PRVWVXVSHFWYR[HODVZHOORIWKHZKROHWXPRXUHJLQLWLDOHQKDQFHPHQWZDVKRXW
SHDNHQKDQFHPHQWWLPHWRSHDNHQKDQFHPHQWHWF6LJQLÀFDQWDQGLQGHSHQGHQW
SUHGLFWRUVIRUO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVLVZHUHLGHQWLÀHG ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQEDFNZDUG
IHDWXUHVHOHFWLRQ DQGFRPELQHGLQWRDPXOWLYDULDWHPRGHOWRSUHGLFWQRGDOSRVLWLYH
EUHDVWFDQFHUV $8&DUHDXQGHUWKH52&FXUYH
5HVXOWV 7KHUH ZHUH QRGDOSRVLWLYH DQG QRGDOQHJDWLYH FDQFHUV %/5$
LGHQWLÀHG&$'SDUDPHWHUVDVVLJQLÀFDQWLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUVIRUWKHSUHGLF
WLRQ RI O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVLV 3 0XOWLYDULDWH DQDO\VLV UHDFKHG KLJK
DFFXUDF\ $8&VWDQGDUGHUURU DQGPRGHUDWHPRGHOÀW U WR
SUHGLFWQRGDOSRVLWLYHFDQFHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ &$'[EDVHG LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI 05PDPPRJUDSK\ LV D VLJQLÀFDQW
SUHGLFWRU RI D[LOODU\ O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVLV$FFRUGLQJO\ LW FRXOG EH XVHG DV D
SURJQRVWLFELRPDUNHUDQGVKRXOGEHIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWHGIRUSRWHQWLDOQRQLQYDVLYH
ULVNVWUDWLÀFDWLRQRIEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWVLQIXWXUHVWXGLHV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6DWXUGD\
%
´0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHPDPPRJUDSK\KDVDKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\EXWORZ
VSHFLÀFLW\µQHZWKRXJKWVDQGIUHVKGDWDRQDQROGPDQWUD
0'LHW]HO.6FKRHQ5=RXEL+3%XUPHLVWHU0*DMGD,%5XQQHEDXP
:$.DLVHU3$7%DOW]HU-HQD'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&RPSXWHUDLGHGGHFLVLRQVXSSRUWIRUWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIOLYHU
OHVLRQVLQ&7VFDQV
0+DPPRQ3'DQNHUO0&RVWD$7V\PEDO66HLIHUW06KOLQJ08GHU
$&DYDOODUR(UODQJHQ'( PDWWKLDVKDPPRQ#XNHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH'DLO\URXWLQHRIUDGLRORJLVWVLQFOXGHVGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJDYDULHW\RIOHVLRQ
W\SHVLQ&7VFDQVDFKDOOHQJLQJDQGWLPHFRQVXPLQJWDVN:HHYDOXDWHGDQLQ
QRYDWLYH7+(6(860(',&2&%,5&$' FRQWHQWEDVHGLPDJHUHWULHYDOFRPSXWHU
DLGHGGHFLVLRQ V\VWHP WKDW DVVLVWV WKH UHDGHU LQ GLVFULPLQDWLQJ OLYHU OHVLRQV E\
UHWULHYLQJVFRULQJUDQNLQJDQGGLVSOD\LQJVLPLODUOHVLRQVDFFRUGLQJWRXVHUGHÀQHG
VLPLODULW\FULWHULDLQFOXGLQJOHVLRQEHQLJQDQF\GHQVLW\DQGW\SH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VHWRI&7VFDQVFRQWDLQLQJOLYHUOHVLRQVDQ
QRWDWHGE\H[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVZHUHXVHGIRUJHQHUDWLRQDQGHYDOXDWLRQRI
WKHOHDUQLQJEDVHGPRGHOVLQWKHV\VWHP$UDQNHGOLVWRIOHVLRQVVKRZLQJVLPLODU
EHQLJQDQF\ EHQLJQPDOLJQDQW GHQVLW\ K\SRGHQVHK\SHUGHQVH RU OHVLRQ W\SH
F\VWKDHPDQJLRPDPHWDVWDVLV FDQEHUHWULHYHGIURPMXVWDUHJLRQRILQWHUHVWDV
LQSXW TXHU\$GGLWLRQDO LQSXW HJ FKDUDFWHULVLQJ VHPDQWLF IHDWXUHV KDV VKRZQ
WRLPSURYHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHHVSHFLDOO\IRULQGHWHUPLQDWHVXEFHQWLPHWHUOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV$OJRULWKPUXQWLPHLVZLWKLQDIHZVHFRQGVSHUOHVLRQ2QXQVHHQWHVWGDWD
WKHFODVVLÀFDWLRQDFFXUDF\REWDLQHGZDVIRUUHWULHYDOZLWKVLPLODUGHQVLW\
IRUVLPLODUEHQLJQDQF\DQGLQWKHOHVLRQW\SHFDVH7KHGDWDFRO
OHFWLRQXVHGLVWKHELJJHVWVDPSOHFRPSDUHGWRVLPLODUVWXGLHVDQGWKHSUHGLFWLYH
SHUIRUPDQFHDFKLHYHGLVFRPSHWLWLYHZLWKUHVSHFWWRVWDWHRIWKHDUW
&RQFOXVLRQ$V SURYHQ E\ WKLV VWXG\ WKH LQYHVWLJDWHG V\VWHP DXWRPDWLFDOO\
GLVFULPLQDWHGUHOLDEO\EHWZHHQGLIIHUHQWW\SHVRIOLYHUOHVLRQV7KHV\VWHPDVVLVWV
UHDGLQJDQGGHFLVLRQPDNLQJSURFHVVE\TXLFNUHWULHYDOUDQNLQJDQGGLVSOD\LQJ
VLPLODUOHVLRQVZLWKUHODWHGUDGLRORJLFDOUHSRUWLQIRUPDWLRQ7KLVVHUYHVDVDVHFRQG
RSLQLRQDQGSURYLGHVYDOXDEOHDGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQIRUUDGLRORJLFDOGHFLVLRQPDNLQJ
HVSHFLDOO\ZKHQ05,LVFRQWUDLQGLFDWHG
%
$XWRPDWHGGHWHFWLRQRIRVWHRO\WLFWKRUDFROXPEDUVSLQHOHVLRQVLQ
&7VFDQV
0+DPPRQ0:HOV3'DQNHUO0.HOP$7V\PEDO66HLIHUW06KOLQJ
08GHU$&DYDOODUR(UODQJHQ'( PDWWKLDVKDPPRQ#XNHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH2VWHRO\WLFVSLQDOERQHOHVLRQDVVHVVPHQWLQ&7VFDQVLVDFKDOOHQJLQJ
DQGLPSRUWDQWWDVNLQURXWLQHUDGLRORJ\:HHYDOXDWHGWKHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGQXPEHU
RIIDOVHSRVLWLYHUHVXOWVRIDQRYHOIXOO\DXWRPDWLFFRPSXWHUDLGHGGHWHFWLRQ &$'
V\VWHPIHDWXULQJDQLQQRYDWLYHDOJRULWKPIURP7+(6(860(',&2
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGWKH&$'V\VWHPRQ&7
VFDQVRISDWLHQWV LQFOXGLQJGLDJQRVLVVXFKDVRVWHRSRURVLVGHJHQHUDWLYHVSLQH
GLVRUGHUV DQG YHUWHEUDO IUDFWXUHV ZLWK RVWHRO\WLF VSLQH OHVLRQV ODUJHU WKDQ
FPó7KHVRIWZDUHLVEDVHGRQWKHSULQFLSOHVRIPDFKLQHOHDUQLQJDQGDXWRPDWL
FDOO\GHWHFWVDQGKLJKOLJKWVRVWHRO\WLFOHVLRQV'HWHFWHGGHJHQHUDWLYHSURFHVVHV
HJ6FKPRUOҋVQRGXOHVRUKDHPDQJLRPDVZHUHQRWFRQVLGHUHGDVIDOVHSRVLWLYH
ÀQGLQJV0DQXDOOHVLRQDQQRWDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGE\DQH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVW
JROGVWDQGDUG 6HQVLWLYLW\DQGIDOVHSRVLWLYHUDWHVRQXQVHHQGDWDZHUHFDOFXODWHG
IROGFURVVYDOLGDWLRQ
5HVXOWV$OJRULWKP UXQWLPH LV OHVV WKDQ PLQXWHV SHU GDWD VHW 2XU V\VWHP
DFKLHYHV D VHQVLWLYLW\ RI DW IDOVH SRVLWLYHV SHU VSLQH RQ DYHUDJH 7KH
PHGLDQVHQVLWLYLW\LVDWIDOVHSRVLWLYHVSHUVSLQH7KHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ
WKHWZRVHQVLWLYLW\YDOXHVLVGXHWRWKHGLIIHUHQWGDWDTXDOLW\ZKLFKLVFRQWULEXWLQJ
WRWKHGHJUHHRIGLIÀFXOW\RIWKHGHWHFWLRQWDVN
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQWHG&$'V\VWHPVXFFHVVIXOO\GHWHFWVRVWHRO\WLFWKRUDFR
OXPEDUVSLQHOHVLRQVHYHQLQFKDOOHQJLQJGDWDVHWV,WFDQWKHUHIRUHEHDSSOLHGDVD
IXOO\DXWRPDWLFSUHSURFHVVLQJVWHSWRLQGLFDWHVXVSLFLRXVDUHDVDQGWKXVVXSSRUWWKH
UDGLRORJLVW7KLVLVH[WUHPHO\YDOXDEOHGXULQJWKHUHDGLQJRI&7VFDQVDVRVWHRO\WLF
ERQHOHVLRQVDUHDWWKHULVNRIEHLQJPLVVHGHYHQE\H[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWV
%
&RPSXWHGDLGHGVWHQRVLVGHWHFWLRQRQFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\LQ
FKHVWSDLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQLQWHUPHGLDWHSUHWHVWOLNHOLKRRGIRUDFXWH
FRURQDU\V\QGURPH
7+HQ]OHU00H\HU3$SIDOWUHU626FKRHQEHUJ&)LQN
0DQQKHLP'( WKRPDVKHQ]OHU#PHGPDXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQDXWRPDWHGFRPSXWHGDLGHGDOJRULWKP
IRU VWHQRVLV GHWHFWLRQ RQ FRURQDU\ &7 DQJLRJUDSK\ F&7$ ZLWK H[SHUW KXPDQ
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHFKHVWSDLQDQGDQLQWHUPHGLDWHSUHWHVWOLNHOL
KRRGIRUDFXWHFRURQDU\V\QGURPH $&6
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\RXU,5%DQG
LQFRPSOLDQFHZLWK+,3$$UHJXODWLRQV$PRQJFRQVHFXWLYHF&7$H[DPLQDWLRQV
ZHUHRIDGHTXDWHTXDOLW\IRUDXWRPDWHGHYDOXDWLRQE\&25$QDO\VHU 5FDGLD
0HGLFDO,PDJLQJ+DLID,VUDHO )LQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRKXPDQH[SHUWLQWHU
SUHWDWLRQIRUGHWHFWLRQRIVWHQRVLVGHÀQHGDVYHVVHOGLDPHWHUUHGXFWLRQLQ
WKHOHIWPDLQ /0 OHIWDQWHULRUGHVFHQGLQJ /$' FLUFXPÁH[ /&[ ULJKWFRURQDU\
DUWHU\ 5&$ RUDUWHULDOVLGHEUDQFKHV
5HVXOWV$PRQJFDVHVHYDOXDWHGE\WKH&25$QDO\VHUKXPDQH[SHUWLQWHUSUH
WDWLRQLGHQWLÀHGSDWLHQWVZLWKVWHQRVLV2QDSHUSDWLHQWSHUYHVVHOOHYHO
WKH&25$QDO\VHUUHYHDOHGDVHQVLWLYLW\RIDVSHFLÀFLW\RI
D QHJDWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH RI DQG D SRVLWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH RI
:LWKUHVSHFWWRLQGLYLGXDOVHJPHQWVWKH&25$QDO\VHUGHWHFWHG
/0OHVLRQV/$'OHVLRQV/&[OHVLRQV5&$OHVLRQVDQGDUWH
ULDOVLGHEUDQFKHV)DOVHSRVLWLYHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVZHUHORFDOLVHGWRWKH/0 Q
/$' Q /&[ Q 5&$ Q DQGDUWHULDOEUDQFKHV Q DQGZHUHUHODWHG
SUHGRPLQDQWO\WRRYHUHVWLPDWLRQRIVWHQRWLFOHVLRQVZLWKOHVVWKDQGLDPHWHU
DQGFDOFLÀHGYHVVHOV
&RQFOXVLRQ$QDXWRPDWHGFRPSXWHGDLGHGGHWHFWLRQDOJRULWKPRIVWHQRWLFOHVLRQV
RQF&7$SURYLGHVDKLJKQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHWRUXOHRXW$&6LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
DFXWHFKHVWSDLQDQGDQLQWHUPHGLDWHSUHWHVWOLNHOLKRRGIRU$&6
%
$FRPSXWHUDVVLVWHGPHWKRGIRUWKHUDSLGDQGDFFXUDWHDVVHVVPHQW
RIOHIWYHQWULFXODUYROXPHVHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQDQGPDVVE\05,
00D]RQDNLV.3DJRQLGLV-'DPLODNLV,UDNOLRQ*5 PD]RQDN#PHGXRFJU
3XUSRVH7RGHYHORSDQGHYDOXDWHDFRPSXWHUDVVLVWHGVWHUHRORJLFDOPHWKRGIRU
WKHDVVHVVPHQWRIOHIWYHQWULFXODU /9 VL]HDQGIXQFWLRQIURP05,GDWD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6KRUWD[LV05,VOLFHVFRYHULQJWKHHQWLUH/9ZHUHRE
WDLQHG IURP FRQVHFXWLYH VXEMHFWV ZLWK VXVSHFWHG FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ GLVHDVH$
FRPSXWHUJHQHUDWHGV\VWHPDWLFJULGRIWHVWSRLQWVZDVUDQGRPO\VXSHULPSRVHG
RQHDFKVOLFH&URVVVHFWLRQDO/9DUHDVZHUHHVWLPDWHGXVLQJWKHVHPLDXWRPDWLF
VWHUHRORJLFDOSRLQWFRXQWLQJPHWKRG7KH/9YROXPHVHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQDQGPDVV
ZHUHFDOFXODWHGWKURXJKWKHV\VWHPDWLFVOLFHVDPSOLQJSURFHGXUH7KHUHSURGXF
LELOLW\RIVWHUHRORJLFDOPHWKRGZDVGHWHUPLQHGE\WKUHHLQGHSHQGHQWREVHUYHUV7KH
SDUDPHWHUVGHULYHGIURPPDQXDOO\WUDFHG/9FRQWRXUVVHUYHGDVUHIHUHQFHYDOXHV
5HVXOWV6WHUHRORJLFDOYROXPHDVVHVVPHQWVREWDLQHGE\VDPSOHVFRQVLVWLQJRI
HYHU\WKLUGVOLFHGHSLFWLQJ/9GLIIHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\IURPWKRVHE\PDQXDOWUDFLQJ
S 6DPSOHVRIVOLFHVDULVLQJIURPWKHV\VWHPDWLFVDPSOLQJVFKHPH
SURYLGHGYROXPHHVWLPDWLRQVZLWKDPHDQFRHIÀFLHQWRIHUURURILQOHVV
WKDQPLQ1RGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHUHIHUHQFHYDOXHVDQG/9SD
UDPHWHUVHVWLPDWHGE\WKHVDPSOLQJLQWHQVLW\ S! 7KHVHVWHUHRORJLFDO
HVWLPDWLRQVZHUHKLJKO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHUHIHUHQFHYDOXHV U 7KH
OLPLWVRIDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQWKHWZRPHWKRGVZHUHFOLQLFDOO\DFFHSWDEOH HQG
GLDVWROLFYROXPHWRFPHQGV\VWROLFYROXPHWRFPHMHFWLRQ
IUDFWLRQWRPDVVWRJ 7KHLQWUDREVHUYHUDQGLQWHUREVHUYHU
YDULDELOLWLHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHVWHUHRORJLFDOHVWLPDWLRQVZHUHDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ 6WHUHRORJLFDO DQDO\VLV RQ V\VWHPDWLFDOO\ VDPSOHG 05, VOLFHV
DOORZVWKHUHSURGXFLEOHDQGDFFXUDWHDVVHVVPHQWRI/9SDUDPHWHUVZLWKUHGXFHG
XVHULQWHUYHQWLRQ
%
$XWRPDWHGEUDQFKQDPHODEHOOLQJV\VWHPRIWUDFKHREURQFKLDOWUHH
E\FRPSXWDWLRQDODQDWRP\
+1DWRUL00RUL+7DNDEDWDNH++RQPD<1LPXUD.0RUL
6DSSRUR-31DJR\D-3 KQDWRUL#VDSPHGDFMS
3XUSRVH)RUFRPSXWDWLRQDODQDWRP\ZHSURSRVHGWKHV\VWHPWKDWDXWRPDWLFDOO\
DVVLJQHGDQDWRPLFDOQDPHVWRWKHEURQFKLDOEUDQFKHVH[WUDFWHGIURPPXOWLGHWHFWRU
&7 0'&7 GDWD'HVLJQHGV\VWHPZDVDEOHWRSURFHVVYDULDQWFDVHVRIEUDQFKLQJ
W\SHVRIWUDFKHREURQFKLDOWUHH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1HZ9(6YLHZHUGHYHORSHGE\FRDXWKRU.0ZDVXVHG
IRUYLUWXDOEURQFKRVFRS\%URQFKLDOPRGHOVEDVHGRQ0'&7GDWDVHWVZHUHPDGH
XVLQJUHFRJQLWLRQRIEUDQFKLQJSDWWHUQDQGGLUHFWLRQVRIWKRVHEUDQFKHV0DFKLQH
OHDUQLQJDSSURDFKZDVHPSOR\HGIRUWKLVV\VWHP0'&7GDWDRIFDVHVZHUH
XVHG DV WUDLQLQJ GDWD )RU HYDOXDWLRQ RI WKH DXWRPDWHG EUDQFK QDPH ODEHOOLQJ
V\VWHPQHZH[WHUQDOFDVHVRI0'&7GDWDZHUHXVHG
5HVXOWV,QYLUWXDOEURQFKRVFRS\EURQFKLDOQDPHVZHUHDXWRPDWLFDOO\RYHUODLGRQ
QDYLJDWLRQ LPDJHV %URQFKLDO QDPHV VHTXHQWLDOO\ DSSHDUHG IURP WUDFKHD PDLQ
EURQFKLOREDUEURQFKLWRVHJPHQWDOEURQFKL1DPHVRIVXEVHJPHQWDOEURQFKLZHUH
DOVRVKRZQIUHTXHQWO\DQGVXEVXEVHJPHQWDOEURQFKLZHUHVKRZQLQVRPHFDVHV
$XWRPDWHG EUDQFK QDPH ODEHOOLQJ V\VWHP ZRUNHG SURSHUO\ HYHQ IRU WKH YDULDQW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
W\SHRIEUDQFKLQJ,QVRPHFDVHVVHTXHQWLDOVKLIWRIDVVLJQHGQDPHVWRSUR[LPDO
RFFXUUHGLQWKHEHORQJLQJEURQFKLDWWKHGHOHWHGVLWHRIWKHH[SHFWHGEURQFKXVE\
SRRUUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIDEURQFKLDOLPDJHDQGE\FRQJHQLWDORURSHUDWLYHGHOHWLRQRI
WKHEURQFKXVZDVSUHVHQW6WULFWQDPHPDWFKLQJWRGRFWRUVҋLQWHUSUHWDWLRQUHYHDOHG
PDWFKHGIRUWKHWUDFKHDDQGPDLQEURQFKL)RUWKHGLVWDOEURQFKLRYHUDOO
UHVXOWVRIRIODEHOOHGQDPHVZHUHFRUUHFW
&RQFOXVLRQ$FFRUGLQJWRWKHNQRZOHGJHRIFRPSXWDWLRQDODQDWRP\DXWRPDWHGDV
VLJQPHQWRIEURQFKLDOEUDQFKQDPHVPD\KHOSGRFWRUVGXULQJYLUWXDOEURQFKRVFRS\
%
'HYHORSPHQWRIDFRPSXWHUDLGHGLQGHSHQGHQWPRQLWRUXQLW
YHULÀFDWLRQV\VWHPXVLQJ&ODUNVRQҋVVHFWRULQWHJUDWLRQURXWLQH
00DWVXVKLPD57DQDND<.LNXFKL.XUREH-3.DQD]DZD-3)XNXL-3
OLQDF#PHGNXUREHWR\DPDMS
3XUSRVH7RGHYHORSDFRPSXWHULVHGPHWKRGIRUYHULÀFDWLRQRIPRQLWRUXQLW 08
EDVHGRQJHRPHWULFDOIDFWRUVLQUDGLDWLRQWUHDWPHQWSODQQLQJDQGWRLQYHVWLJDWH
WKHFOLQLFDOHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIRXUV\VWHP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6KDSHLQIRUPDWLRQRQ;MDZ<MDZDQGPXOWLOHDIFROOLPD
WRU 0/& ZDVUHDGIURPWKHSODQQLQJGDWDDQGUDGLDOGLUHFWLRQGLVWDQFH UL RIWKH
GLYLVLRQIRULQWHJUDWLRQRIVHJPHQWVZDVFDOFXODWHG&ODUNVRQҋVVHFWRULQWHJUDWLRQ
URXWLQHZDVXVHGWRFDOFXODWHWKHPHDQSKDQWRPVFDWWHUFRUUHFWLRQIDFWRU 6S DQG
PHDQ WLVVXHPD[LPXP UDWLR 705 IRU H[WHUQDO SKRWRQ EHDPV RI LUUHJXODU DQG
FRQIRUPDOÀHOGVZLWK0/&2XUV\VWHPZLWKDXVHUIULHQGO\JUDSKLFDOLQWHUIDFHZDV
LQVWDOOHGRQDSHUVRQDOFRPSXWHU *+]&38 WRYHULI\LWVDFFXUDF\LQFDVHV
LQFOXGLQJÀYHVTXDUHÀHOGVVL[UHFWDQJXODUÀHOGVIRXUNLQGVҋZHGJHVKDSHGÀHOGV
HLJKWLUUHJXODUÀHOGVDQGWKUHHFRQIRUPDOÀHOGV
5HVXOWV$YHUDJHULGLIIHUHQFHWKHGLIIHUHQFHLQ08DQGPHDVXUHGDEVRUEHGGRVH
ZHUHPPDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\0D[LPXPYDOXHVZHUHPP
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHWLPHWRFDOFXODWHRQHÀHOGZDVV2XUV\VWHP
SURYLGHGIXOO\DXWRPDWHG08YHULÀFDWLRQZLWKRXWDQ\PDQXDOKDQGFDOFXODWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ ,W LV QHFHVVDU\ WR HQVXUH GLVDJUHHPHQW EHWZHHQ YHULÀFDWLRQ DQG
SULPDU\FDOFXODWLRQVZLWKKRPRJHQHRXVFRQGLWLRQVRUKHWHURJHQHLW\FRUUHFWLRQVLV
E\LQGHSHQGHQW08YHULÀFDWLRQDFFRUGLQJWRWKHUHSRUWRI$$307DVN
*URXS7KHUHVXOWVLQGLFDWHGWKDWRXUV\VWHPZLOODLGRSHUDWRUVLQ08YHULÀFDWLRQ
ZLWKKLJKDFFXUDF\DQGOHVVFRPSOH[LW\IRUH[WHUQDOUDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\
%
6DWXUGD\
)XOO\LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKPIRU0'&7LQLWLDOUHVXOWV
0'REULW]7.RHKOHU.0%URZQ$)LQJHUOH(-5XPPHQ\3%1RHO
0XQLFK'(+DPEXUJ'(&OHYHODQG2+86 GREULW]#URHPHGWXPGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHIXOO\LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ,5 LQ0'&7ZLWKUHVSHFWWR
LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHFRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO)%3
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGSURVSHFWLYHO\ZLWKSDWLHQWVZKR
KDGVXIIHUHGIURPPDOLJQDQWGLVHDVHVLQDWXPRXUIROORZXS'DWDZHUHDFTXLUHG
RQ D 3KLOLSV %ULOOLDQFH L&7 DQG UHFRQVWUXFWHG XVLQJ FRQYHQWLRQDO )%3 DQG ,5
,5 XVHV HGJHSUHVHUYLQJ UHJXODULVDWLRQ WR WUDGH RII QRLVH DQG UHVROXWLRQ 1RLVH
WH[WXUHLVFRQWUROOHGE\DSDUDPHWHUDQGE\IDGLQJWKH)%3LPDJHWRWKH,5UHVXOW
7RGHWHUPLQHWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRI,5H[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\
GHÀQHGSDWKRORJLFDODQGDQDWRPLFDOIHDWXUHVLQWKHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
5HVXOWV$QH[WUHPHFKRLFHRI,5SDUDPHWHUVUHVXOWHGLQDOPRVWFRPSOHWHUHPRYDO
RILPDJHQRLVHZKLOHSURGXFLQJDQXQIDPLOLDULPDJHWH[WXUH:LWKRXW)%3IDGLQJ
VKDUSQHVVRIVRPHRUJDQHGJHVZDVIRXQGWREHGLIÀFXOWWRUDWH,QRQHFDVHWKH
VXUIDFHRIWKHOLYHUVHHPVWRKDYHQRGXODUOLNHFLUUKRWLFFKDQJHV/HVVH[WUHPH
SDUDPHWHUVIRU,5OHGWRVWLOOVWURQJO\UHGXFHGQRLVHOHVVXQIDPLOLDUWH[WXUHDQGQR
DUWLÀFLDOFKDQJHV,QWKHSRUWDOYHQRXVSKDVHYDVFXODUVWUXFWXUHVDUHEHWWHUGHOLQH
DWHGLQ,5UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVFRPSDUHGWR)%3$OOSDWKRORJLFDODQGDQDWRPLFDOIHDWXUHV
FRXOGEHGHWHFWHGDQGGHÀQHGLQ)%3DQG,5LPDJHV+RZHYHUWKHVHIHDWXUHVDUH
PRUHFOHDUO\YLVLEOHLQ,5LPDJHV2YHUDOO,5ZDVDVVHVVHGWREHVXSHULRUWR)%3
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKLVVWXG\ZHLOOXVWUDWHWKHFOLQLFDOYDOXHRI,5,5KDVWKHSRWHQWLDO
WRUHGXFHSDWLHQWGRVHDQGLPSURYHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHIRUDQ\FOLQLFDOSURWRFRO
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
6XQGD\0DUFK
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP$
2QFRORJLF,PDJLQJ
66
:KROHERG\05,LQFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
0RGHUDWRUV
00D\HUK|IHU9LHQQD$7
+36FKOHPPHU+HLGHOEHUJ'(
%
%RQHPDUURZOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKP\HORPDZKROHERG\':,%6
YV7ZHLJKWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJ
(6TXLOODFL)%RODFFKL&&LFFLRҋ0$QWRQLFROL*0DQHQWL*6LPRQHWWL
5RPH,7 HWWRUHVTXLOODFL#WLVFDOLLW
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUH7ZHLJKWHGFRQWUDVWPDWHULDO
HQKDQFHG IDWVXSSUHVVHG VSLQHFKR PDJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH 05 VHTXHQFHV DQG
':,%6IRUGHSLFWLRQRIERQHPDUURZDEQRUPDOLWLHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKP\HORPD
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 2QH KXQGUHG DQG WKLUW\ÀYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK SUHYLRXVO\
GLDJQRVHG 00 XQGHUZHQW 7 :%05, IRU SUHWUHDWPHQW VWDJLQJ PRUSKRORJL
FDO 7: 'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ ZLWK EDFNJURXQG VXSSUHVVLRQ ':,%6
DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG'7:VHTXHQFHVZHUHSHUIRUPHG9ROXPHDQGVLJQDO
GLIIHUHQFHWRQRLVH UDWLR 6'15 ZHUH PHDVXUHG 6WDJLQJ GHWHUPLQHG ZLWK 05
ÀQGLQJVZLWKHDFKVHTXHQFHZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHUHVXOWVRIDUHYLHZSDQHO
5HVXOWV 5HJDUGLQJ YROXPH RI ERQH PDUURZ DEQRUPDOLWLHV D ORZ FRUUHODWLRQ
U RI ERWK VHTXHQFHV ZDV IRXQG 6'15 ZDV VXEVWDQWLDOO\ KLJKHU RQ
':,%6LPDJHVWKDQRQ'7ZHLJKWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG PHDQYV
3 7KHTXDOLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVGHPRQVWUDWHGWKHVDPHLPDJLQJSDWWHUQZLWK
ERWKVHTXHQFHVLQ NDSSD RIQRUPDODSSHDULQJPDUURZZLWKOLPLWHG
GLVHDVHLQ NDSSD RIIRFDOLQÀOWUDWLRQDQGLQ NDSSD
RIGLIIXVHLQÀOWUDWLRQ,QWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\RIWKHWKUHHLPDJLQJSDWWHUQV
ZDVVLPLODUIRUERWKVHTXHQFHV7KHNDSSDYDOXHVIRUWKHVHWKUHH]RQHVZLWK7
ZHLJKWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05VHTXHQFHZHUHDQGDQGWKRVH
IRUWKH':,%6VHTXHQFHVZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\6WDJLQJGHWHU
PLQHGZLWK05ÀQGLQJVZHUHHTXDOZLWKERWKVHTXHQFHVLQRILQYROYHGERQHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7ZHLJKWHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGIDWVXSSUHVVHG05LPDJHVDUHVX
SHULRUWR':,%6LQWKHGHPRQVWUDWLRQRIWKHGLIIXVHDQGOLPLWHGGLVHDVH+RZHYHU
VWDJLQJGHWHUPLQHGZLWKERWKVHTXHQFHVLVFRPSDUDEOH
%
:KROHERG\05,IRUUHVSRQVHDVVHVVPHQWRIPXOWLSOHP\HORPDDIWHU
VWHPFHOOWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
&:HEHU++HQWVFKHO7%OH\1.URHJHU*$GDP3%DQQDV
+DPEXUJ'( KDQQDKKHQWVFKHO#JP[GH
3XUSRVH&RPSDULVRQRIZKROHERG\05, :%05, ZLWKVHUXPDQDO\VHVWRGHWHU
PLQHZKHWKHU:%05,HQDEOHVUHOLDEOHWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHDVVHVVPHQWLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKPXOWLSOHP\HORPDDIWHUVWHPFHOOWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ 6&7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV PHQ ZRPHQ PHDQ DJH
\HDUV ZLWKPXOWLSOHP\HORPDDIWHU6&7ZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWK:%05,DWWZRWLPH
SRLQWVDIWHU6&7([WHQWRILQWUDDQGH[WUDPHGXOODU\P\HORPDPDQLIHVWDWLRQVIURP
ERWK:%05,H[DPLQDWLRQVZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKKHPDWRORJLFDOSDUDPHWHUVDQGZLWK
PHGLXPWHUPSDWLHQWRXWFRPH0F1HPDUV VWHVWZDVXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV :%05, LGHQWLÀHG QHZ RU SURJUHVVLYH OHVLRQV LQ RI SDWLHQWV
SDWLHQWV KDGRQO\LQWUDPHGXOODU\OHVLRQVDQGSDWLHQWV
KDGLQWUDDQGH[WUDPHGXOODU\O\PSKRPDPDQLIHVWDWLRQV5HVXOWVRI:%05,DQG
VHUXPDQDO\VHVDJUHHGLQRIDOOSDWLHQWV SDWLHQWV ZHUH
FODVVLÀHGFRQFRUGDQWO\DVUHVSRQGHUVDQGSDWLHQWV DVQRQUHVSRQGHUV
7KHUHPDLQLQJSDWLHQWV ZHUHFODVVLÀHGXQHTXDOO\ZLWKERWKPHWKRGV
KRZHYHUZLWKRXWEHLQJVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW S
&RQFOXVLRQ :%05, HQDEOHV UHVSRQVH DVVHVVPHQW LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK PXOWLSOH
P\HORPD DIWHU 6&7 EXW ZLWKRXW DGGLWLRQDO EHQHÀW FRPSDUHG WR URXWLQHO\ SHU
IRUPHGVHUXPDQDO\VHV+RZHYHU:%05,DOORZVH[DFWORFDOL]DWLRQRILQWUDDQG
H[WUDPHGXOODU\O\PSKRPDPDQLIHVWDWLRQVZKLFKDGYRFDWHV:%05,SDUWLFXODUO\IRU
V\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVRUSDWLHQWVZLWKQRQVHFUHWRU\P\HORPD
%
:KROHERG\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJDW7HVODÀHOGVWUHQJWKIRU
HDUO\WUHDWPHQWDVVHVVPHQWDQGWUHDWPHQWSUHGLFWLRQLQO\PSKRPD
.1GH3DHSH&%HYHUQDJH)GH.H\]HU3:ROWHU52\HQ*9HUKRHI
99DQGHFDYH\H/RXYDLQ%(
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWH7ZKROHERG\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ :%':, IRU
HDUO\DVVHVVPHQWRIFKHPRWKHUDS\LQDJJUHVVLYHQRQ+RGJNLQO\PSKRPD 1+/
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RXUWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWK1+/WUHDWHGZLWKVWDQGDUGFKHPR
WKHUDS\XQGHUZHQW7:%':,ZLWKEYDOXHV E VPP SULRUWRDQG
ZHHNVDIWHULQLWLDWLRQRIWUHDWPHQW7KHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& ZDV
FDOFXODWHGIURPUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, GUDZQRQO\PSKRPDORFDWLRQVRQWUDQV
YHUVHEDQGELPDJHV3UHWUHDWPHQW$'&$'&FKDQJHWRSUHWUHDWPHQW
$'& $'&EDVH DWZHHNV $'&UDWLRZ DQGDWZHHNV $'&UDWLRZ GXULQJ
WUHDWPHQWRIUHVSRQGLQJDQGQRQUHVSRQGLQJOHVLRQVZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJD0DQQ
:KLWQH\8WHVW7KHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI$'&EDVH$'&UDWLRZDQG$'&UDWLRZ
ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKSURJUHVVLRQIUHHVXUYLYDO 3)6 ZLWKDORJUDQNWHVWLQFOXGLQJ
WKHHIIHFWRIWKHLQWHUQDWLRQDOSURJQRVWLFLQGH[ ,3,
5HVXOWV(LJKWSDWLHQWVVKRZHGFRPSOHWHUHPLVVLRQDIWHUPRQWKVRIIROORZXS
ZKHUHDVSDWLHQWVVKRZHGSHUVLVWHQWRUUHFXUUHQWGLVHDVHZLWKLQWRPRQWKV
7KH$'&EDVH$'&UDWLRZDQG$'&UDWLRZZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWLQOHVLRQV
VKRZLQJUHFXUUHQFHYHUVXVUHPLVVLRQ $'&EDVH [PPVYHUVXV
[PPVS$'&UDWLRZ LQFUHDVHYHUVXV
S$'&UDWLRZ LQFUHDVHYHUVXVS 3HUERG\
UHJLRQWKH$'&UDWLRZGHPRQVWUDWHGKLJKHVWDFFXUDF\RIZLWKDQHJDWLYH
SUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIDQGSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI'LIIHUHQFHVLQ$'&
EDVH$'&UDWLRZDQG$'&UDWLRZEHWZHHQSDWLHQWJURXSVFRUUHODWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\
ZLWK3)6 $'&EDVHS $'&UDWLRZS DQG$'&UZS
LQFRQWUDVWWRWKH,3,
&RQFOXVLRQ:%':,PD\DOORZIRUWUHDWPHQWSUHGLFWLRQDQGHDUO\WUHDWPHQWDV
VHVVPHQWRI'/%&/XVLQJGLIIHUHQFHVLQ$'&EDVH$'&UDWLRZDQG$'&UDWLRZ
%
,VZKROHERG\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJDW7HVODÀHOGVWUHQJWK
IHDVLEOHIRUVWDJLQJO\PSKRPD"
.1'H3DHSH)'H.H\]HU3:ROWHU52\HQ*9HUKHRI99DQGHFDYH\H
/HXYHQ%(
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RI7ZKROHERG\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
:%':, IRUVWDJLQJRIQRQ+RGJNLQO\PSKRPD 1+/
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK1+/XQGHUZHQW7:%':,ZLWKE
YDOXHV VPP 5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUHGUDZQRQFRURQDOUHIRUPDW
WHGELPDJHVLQHYHU\K\SHULQWHQVHOHVLRQLQQRUPDOWLVVXH LVRK\SRLQWHQVH
DQGLQWKHVXUURXQGLQJDLUWRGHWHUPLQHEDFNJURXQGQRLVH6LJQDOWREDFNJURXQG
UDWLR 6%5 6,OHVLRQ6,EDFNJURXQG ZDV GHWHUPLQHG IRU HYHU\ 52,$GGLWLRQDOO\
DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& ZDVFDOFXODWHGIURP52,VGUDZQRQWUDQVYHUVH
EDQGELPDJHVLQK\SHULQWHQVHOHVLRQVDQGQRUPDORUEHQLJQWLVVXH6%5
DQG$'&RIPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQWLVVXHZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJ0DQQ:KLWQH\8
WHVWVZKLOHUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFFXUYHVZHUHFRQVWUXFWHGWRGHWHUPLQH
VHQVLWLYLW\ V VSHFLÀFLW\ VS DQGDFFXUDF\ DFF $JUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ:%':,DQG
3(7&7IRU$QQ$UERUFODVVLÀFDWLRQZDVDVVHVVHGE\FDOFXODWLQJNDSSDVFRUHV
5HVXOWV 6%5 DQG$'& RI EHQLJQ DQG PDOLJQDQW WLVVXH GLIIHUHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\
S ZLWK$'&EHLQJWKHEHVWGLVFULPLQDWRUIRUO\PSKQRGHV Q V
VS DFF DQG 6%5 IRU ERQH DQG VRIW WLVVXH ERQH Q V
VS DFF VRIW WLVVXH Q V VS DFF 3(7&7
DQG:%':,VKRZHGJRRGWRH[FHOOHQWDJUHHPHQW "O\PSKQRGHV "ERQH
"VRIW WLVVXH IRU OHVLRQ GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ DQG DJUHHG RQ$QQ$UERU VWDJH LQ
RISDWLHQWV:%':,FRUUHFWO\GRZQVWDJHGRQHSDWLHQW VWDJH,9WR,, DQG
LQFRUUHFWO\GRZQVWDJHGDQRWKHU VWDJH,,WR,
&RQFOXVLRQ:%':,LVIHDVLEOHIRUVWDJLQJ1+/VKRZLQJFRPSDUDEOHUHVXOWVWR
3(7&76%5LVPRVWDFFXUDWHIRUFKDUDFWHULVLQJERQHDQGVRIWWLVVXHOHVLRQVZKLOH
$'&LVSUHIHUUHGWRFKDUDFWHULVHO\PSKQRGHV
%
:KROHERG\PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
VHTXHQFHVIRUWKHIROORZXSRIVWDJH,,,PHODQRPDSDWLHQWV
*3HWUDOLD03DGUHQRVWUR6$OHVVL5'L)LOLSSL65DLPRQGL/%RQHOOR
-*DUFLD%HQQHWW0%HOORPL0LODQ,75HXV(6 JLXVHSSHSHWUDOLD#LHRLW
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH IHDVLELOLW\ DQG WKH SRWHQWLDO RI ZKROH ERG\ PDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFH LPDJLQJ :%05, ZLWK GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG ': VHTXHQFHV DV D
VXEVWLWXWHRIZKROHERG\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7 IRUWKHIROORZXSRIVWDJH,,,
PHODQRPDSDWLHQWV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVZHHYDOXDWHGVHYHQW\RQH:%05,LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
VWDJH,,,PHODQRPDSHUIRUPHGDWEDVHOLQHDQGHYHU\PRQWKVGXULQJDGMXYDQW
WKHUDS\)LQGLQJVZHUHFODVVLÀHGEHQLJQRUVXVSLFLRXVIRUPHWDVWDVLVDQGGLYLGHG
LQWRERG\UHJLRQVEUDLQQHFNWKRUD[XSSHUDEGRPHQOLYHUSHOYLVVRIWWLVVXHV
ERQHDQGO\PSKQRGHV%LRSV\RUIROORZXSZDVFRQVLGHUHGDVJROGVWDQGDUGIRU
GLDJQRVLV7KHVHQVLWLYLW\ 6( VSHFLÀFLW\ 63 SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ '$ RI:%05,ZHUH
FDOFXODWHGSHUSDWLHQWDQGSHUVLQJOHERG\UHJLRQ
5HVXOWV$OOSDWLHQWVZHOOWROHUDWHGWKHH[DP2QHKXQGUHGDQGIRUW\ÀQGLQJVZHUH
FRQVLGHUHGIRUDQDO\VLVZLWKWKHIROORZLQJSHUSDWLHQWYDOXHV6( 63
339 139 '$ 7KH'$SHUVLQJOHERG\UHJLRQZDVEUDLQ
QHFN WKRUD[ XSSHUDEGRPHQ OLYHU SHOYLV VRIW
WLVVXHV ERQH DQGO\PSKQRGHV 7KHVPDOOHVWPHWDVWDVLVGH
WHFWHGZDVPPLQWKHOLYHUWKHODUJHVWPHWDVWDVLVPLVVHGZDVPPLQWKHEUDLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ :%05, ZDV IHDVLEOH LQ WKH IROORZXS RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK VWDJH ,,,
PHODQRPD :%05, DFKLHYHG DFFHSWDEOH GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH SHU SDWLHQW
DQGSHUVLQJOHERG\UHJLRQPDNLQJLWFRPSDUDEOHWRRWKHUZKROHERG\LPDJLQJ
WHFKQLTXHVLQFOXGLQJFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQGSRVLWURQHPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\
KRZHYHUDYRLGLQJLRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQ
%
:KROHERG\05,ZLWK':,DQG'&(7ZLQWXPRXUVWDJLQJ
FRPSDULVRQZLWK3(7&7
(6TXLOODFL&&LFFL*0DQHQWL)%RODFFKL26FKLOODFL*6LPRQHWWL
5RPH,7 HWWRUHVTXLOODFL#WLVFDOLLW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIZKROHERG\PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
LPDJLQJ :%05, ZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGZKROHERG\LPDJLQJZLWKEDFNJURXQG
ERG\VLJQDOVXSSUHVVLRQ ':,%6 LQPDOLJQDQWWXPRXUGHWHFWLRQDQGWRH[SORUHWKH
SRWHQWLDOGLDJQRVWLFDGYDQWDJHVLQJHQHUDWLQJIXVHG':,%6'FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
7Z '&(7Z LPDJHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FDQFHU SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW :%05, IRU VWDJLQJ
SXUSRVH)XVHG':,%6'&(7ZLPDJHVZHUHJHQHUDWHGRIIOLQH'&(7Z
':,%6LPDJHVDORQHDQGIXVHGZLWK'&(7ZZHUHFRPSDUHGE\WZRUHDGHUV
JURXSVIRUGHWHFWLRQRISULPDU\GLVHDVHVDQGORFDOGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHV'LDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFHEHWZHHQWKHWKUHH:%05,GDWDVHWVZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJUHFHLYHU
RSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& FXUYHDQDO\VLV))'*3(7&7DQGKLVWRSDWKR
ORJLFDOUHVXOWVZHUHXVHGDVVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFHV
5HVXOWV$UHDVXQGHUWKH52&FXUYHVRI':,%6YV'&(7ZYVERWKVHTXHQFHV
LQIXVHGIDVKLRQZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUP
DQFHLQWXPRXUGHWHFWLRQRIIXVHG':,%6'&(7ZLPDJHVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\
VXSHULRUWR':,%6 3 DQG'&(7Z 3 ZKLOHWKHGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQ':,%6DQG'&(7ZGLGQRWVKRZVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHGLIIHUHQFH
7KHUH ZDV QR VWDWLVWLFDOO\ GLIIHUHQFH LQ GHWHFWLRQ UDWHV RI PDOLJQDQF\ EHWZHHQ
:%05,ZLWK':,%6DQG))'*3(7&7
&RQFOXVLRQ:%05,ZLWKIXVHG':,%6'&(7ZLPDJHVLVWREHFRQVLGHUHG
DVDYDOLGDQGHFRQRPLFDOWHUQDWLYHWRROWR3(7&7IRUWXPRXUVWDJLQJDQGIROORZXS
LQFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
%
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSRWHQWLDORILQWHJUDWHGLPDJLQJZLWK)'*3(7
&7DQGZKROHERG\05, :%05, FRPELQHGZLWKWXPRXUPDUNHUPRQLWRULQJIRU
WKHHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIDV\PSWRPDWLFWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHLQEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$IWHUFXUDWLYHVXUJHU\DV\PSWRPDWLFEUHDVWFDQFHU
SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW UHJXODU WXPRXU PDUNHU PRQLWRULQJ IRU &($ &$ DQG
&$DWZHHNLQWHUYDOVZLWKLQDQLQWHQVLÀHGGLDJQRVWLFDIWHUFDUHDOJRULWKP$
UHSURGXFLEOHSUHYLRXVO\GHÀQHGLQFUHDVH RIVLQJOHRUFRPELQHGPDUNHUV
ZDVFRQVLGHUHGDVDVWURQJLQGLFDWRURIUHFXUUHQWGLVHDVH$OOSDWLHQWVZLWKSDWKR
ORJLFPDUNHULQFUHDVHXQGHUZHQW:%05,RQD7VFDQQHUDQG)'*3(7&7LQ
DGGLWLRQIRUYHULÀFDWLRQ PHGLDQGD\V 3UHVHQFHDQGGLVWULEXWLRQRIORFDOUHFXU
UHQFHO\PSKQRGHLQYROYHPHQWDQGGLVWDQWPHWDVWDWLFGLVHDVHZHUHDVVHVVHG
$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW:%05,RU)'*3(7&7IROORZXSH[DPVZLWKLQPRQWKV
DIWHULQGLYLGXDOLVHGWKHUDS\
5HVXOWV:%05,DQG)'*3(7&7GHWHFWHGWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHLQ
RI SDWLHQWV KDG VHFRQGDU\ PDOLJQDQFLHV DQG KDG QR
GHWHFWDEOHPDOLJQDQF\/LPLWHGGLVHDVH RUJDQPHWDVWDVHV ZDVIRXQGLQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
:KROHERG\05,DQG)'*3(7&7IRUWULDJHLQSDWLHQWVSODQQHGIRU
UDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQWKHUDS\
*36FKPLGW303DSURWWND7)-DNREV57+RIIPDQQ
$%DXU0HOQ\N$+DXJ0)5HLVHU&5LVW0XQLFK'(
'UHVGHQ'( JHUZLQVFKPLGW#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORIZKROHERG\05, :%05, DQG)'*3(7
&7DVGLDJQRVWLFWULDJHPHWKRGVIRUSDWLHQWVSODQQHGIRUUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ 5(
RIOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLIRFDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVZHUHHYDOX
DWHG IRU SRWHQWLDO SDOOLDWLYH WKHUDS\ ZLWK 5( XVLQJ <WWULXP PLFURVSKHUHV$OO
SDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWK3(7&7DQG:%05,IRUH[FOXVLRQRIH[WUDKHSDWLF
WXPRXUPDQLIHVWDWLRQV$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWP7FDOEXPLQHDQJLRJUDSK\IRO
ORZHGE\VFLQWLJUDSK\WRH[FOXGHVLJQLÀFDQWKHSDWRSXOPRQDU\VKXQWLQJ
5HVXOWV2XWRIWKHSDWLHQWVLQFOXGHGLQWRWKHSUHWKHUDSHXWLFGLDJQRVWLFDOJR
ULWKPZHUHHOLJLEOHDQGUHFHLYHG5(ZKLOHFRXOGQRWEHWUHDWHG,Q
H[FOXVLRQ FULWHULD ZDV GLDJQRVLV RI VLJQLÀFDQW H[WUDKHSDWLF PHWDVWDWLF GLVHDVH
,QGLDJQRVLVZDVPDGHFRQFRUGDQWO\E\ERWK)'*3(7&7DQG:%05,LQ
E\3(7&7LQE\:%05,DORQH3DWLHQWEDVHGVHQVLWLYLW\IRUGHWHFWLRQRI
H[WUDKHSDWLFGLVHDVHZDVIRU3(7&7DQGIRU:%05,)DOVHSRVLWLYH
GLDJQRVLVRIH[WUDKHSDWLFGLVHDVHOHDGLQJWRH[FOXVLRQIRU5(ZDVPDGHLQRI
SDWLHQWVLQRQHSDWLHQWE\3(7&7DQGLQRQHSDWLHQWE\:%05,DORQH2YHUDOO
VSHFLÀFLW\IRULQFOXVLRQWR5(E\FRPELQLQJERWKPRGDOLWLHVZDV,QRI
SDWLHQWVDQJLRJUDSKLFGLDJQRVLVPDGH5(LPSRVVLEOH
&RQFOXVLRQ%RWK)'*3(7&7DQG:%05,DUHHIÀFLHQWGLDJQRVWLFWULDJHPHWK
RGVIRUSDWLHQWVSODQQHGIRU5(RIOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV2YHUDOO)'*3(7&7VKRZV
DKLJKHUGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\FRPSDUHGWR:%05,DQGPD\EHXVHGDVLPDJLQJ
PHWKRGRIFKRLFHDVDVWDQGDORQHH[DPLQDWLRQ,QFRPELQDWLRQERWKPRGDOLWLHV
H[KLELWHGKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIH[WUDKHSDWLFWXPRXUPDQLIHVWDWLRQV
DQGUHVXOWLQKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\
%
'LDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLW\RIZKROHERG\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJLQ
PDOLJQDQWWXPRXUVFRPSDUHGZLWKZKROHERG\))'*3(7&7
;<:DQJ1:X<)=KDR%HLMLQJ&1 ROLYHUZ[\B]]#VLQDFRP
3XUSRVH:HVWXGLHGWKHGLDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLW\RIZKROHERG\GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
LPDJLQJ :%':, ZLWK705VFDQQHULQPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVZLWKFRPSDULVRQWR
ZKROHERG\))'*3(7&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHGPDOLJQDQWWXPRXUV
ZHUHHQUROOHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWERWK:%':,DQG))'*3(7&7DQG
WKHQZHUHIROORZHGXSIRUPRQWKV7KUHHH[SHULHQFHG05UDGLRORJLVWVZKRZHUH
EOLQGHGWRWKHÀQDOGLDJQRVLVUHDGWKH:%':,UHVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHWKHOH
VLRQVLGHQWLÀHGE\3(7&7DQGDOOUDGLRORJLFH[DPLQDWLRQV3UREDELOLW\RIPDOLJQDQW
OHVLRQVZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJDSRLQWYLVXDOVFRULQJV\VWHP7KHUHFHLYHURSHUDW
LQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQWKH
WZRPHWKRGV.DSSDDQDO\VHVZHUHXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFFRQVLVWHQF\
EHWZHHQERWKPHWKRGV
5HVXOWV7KHDUHDXQGHUWKH52&FXUYHRI:%':,3(7&7$'&DQG689PD[
ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHLVQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ:%':,DQG3(7&7 3! 7KHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQG
DFFXUDF\ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\LQ:%':,DQG
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\LQ3(7&7.DSSDYDOXHRIWKHGLDJQRVWLFFRQVLVW
HQF\EHWZHHQ:%':,DQG3(7&7ZDV,QDQDO\VLVRIWKHLPSDFWRIOHVLRQ
VL]H RQ WKH DFFXUDF\ WKHUH ZDV VWDWLVWLFDO VLJQLÀFDQFH EHWZHHQ :%':, DQG
3(7&7LQDJURXSRIPPGLDPHWHU 3 $FFRUGLQJWRWKHORFDWLRQRI
OHVLRQVWKHDFFXUDF\RI:%':,ZDVVLPLODUWRRUVRPHWLPHVEHWWHUWKDQ3(7&7
LQVWHUQXPFODYLFOHVFDSXODYHUWHEUDOFROXPQSHOYLVDQGERQHVRIH[WUHPLWLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ:%':,KDGDKLJKHUVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\LQGHWHFWLQJ
PDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
)'*3(7&7DQGZKROHERG\05,IRUHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIWXPRXU
UHFXUUHQFHLQDV\PSWRPDWLFEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWVZLWKWXPRXU
PDUNHUNLQHWLFV
*36FKPLGW36WLHEHU''L*LRLD9+HLQHPDQQ
'1DJHO&5LVW0)5HLVHU$%DXU0HOQ\N
0XQLFK'( JHUZLQVFKPLGW#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
RISDWLHQWV:%05,DQG3(7&7HTXDOO\GHWHFWHGPHWDVWDVHV3(7&7
ZDVVXSHULRUGHWHFWLQJORFDOUHFXUUHQFH 3(7&7YV:%05, 6HFRQG
DU\WXPRXUVGHWHFWHGZHUHRYDULDQJDVWULFOXQJSDURWLGFDQFHUDQGPXOWLSOH
P\HORPD&RQFRUGDQFHEHWZHHQERWKPRGDOLWLHVZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ0RQLWRULQJRIWXPRXUPDUNHUNLQHWLFVFRPELQHGZLWKZKROHERG\LPDJ
LQJLVHIIHFWLYHIRUHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHLQFOLQLFDOO\DV\PSWRPDWLF
EUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWV%RWK)'*3(7&7DQG:%05,DUHUHOLDEOHPHWKRGVIRU
PHWDVWDVHVGHWHFWLRQ3(7&7VKRZVDGYDQWDJHVLQORFDOUHFXUUHQFH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP'
&KHVW
66
,QWHUDFWLRQOXQJKHDUWDQGFLUFXODWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
-%UHPHULFK%DVOH&+
1.DUDEXOXW'HQL]OL75
%
+LJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\LQIUHHO\
EUHDWKLQJSDWLHQWV
5:%DXHU%6FKHOO0%HHUHV-:LFKPDQQ%%RGHOOH7/HKQHUW
7-9RJO-0.HUO)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'( UDOIZEDXHU#DROFRP
3XUSRVH%UHDWKKROGPD\OHDGWR9DOVDOYDҋVPDQRHXYUHLQGXFLQJFRQWUDVWDUWHIDFWV
LQWKHSXOPRQDU\DUWHULHVVXFKDVLQKRPRJHQHRXVHQKDQFHPHQWRUORVVRIWKHFRQ
WUDVWEROXVGXULQJSXOPRQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\:HLQYHVWLJDWHGDQRYHOKLJKSLWFK
GXDOVRXUFH&7SURWRFROWKDWGRHVQRWUHTXLUHDEUHDWKKROGSKDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW&7SXOPRQDU\DQJL
RJUDSK\ &73$ LQGXDOVRXUFHKLJKSLWFKPRGH SLWFKN9P$VPO
FRQWUDVWPDWHULDO ZLWKRXWEUHDWKLQJFRPPDQG3XOPRQDU\DUWHULDO 3$ HQKDQFH
PHQWLPDJHQRLVHVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\LQFLGHQFHRIWRWDO
RUSDUWLDOLQWHUUXSWLRQRIWKHFRQWUDVWFROXPQLQWKH3$WUHHPRWLRQDUWHIDFWVRIWKH
DRUWLFURRWGLDSKUDJPDQGSXOPRQDU\VWUXFWXUHVZHUHUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV 0HDQ FHQWUDO DQG SHULSKHUDO 3$ DWWHQXDWLRQ ZDV +8 DQG
+8PHDQLPDJHQRLVH+80HDQH[DPLQDWLRQWLPHZDV
VPHDQ'/3P*\FP7KHUHZHUHQRPRWLRQDUWHIDFWVRIWKHGLDSKUDJP
RUWKHSXOPRQDU\YHVVHOVUHODWHGWREUHDWKLQJ7KHUHZDVQRFDVHRISDUWLDORUWRWDO
LQWHUUXSWLRQRIWKHFRQWUDVWFROXPQLQWKH3$WUHHQRH[DPLQDWLRQZDVUDWHGQRQ
GLDJQRVWLF,QFDVHVWKHDRUWLFURRWZDVSLFWXUHGZLWKRXWDQ\PRWLRQDUWHIDFW
DQGZLWKVDWLVI\LQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWWRUXOHRXWGLVVHFWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&73$LQIUHHO\EUHDWKLQJSDWLHQWVHIIHFWLYHO\
DYRLGVDUWHIDFWVUHODWHGWREUHDWKKROGRUEUHDWKLQJDVZHOODVWRFDUGLDFPRWLRQ
DQGWKXVUHSUHVHQWVDUHOLDEOHWRROWRUXOHRXWSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP:LWKIXUWKHU
RSWLPLVHGFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQDRUWLFGLVVHFWLRQPD\EHDGGLWLRQDOO\UXOHGRXWZLWKLQ
WKHVDPHH[DPLQDWLRQZLWKRXWWKHXVHRI(&*V\QFKURQLVDWLRQ
%
%UHDWKKROGDWHDVHDPHWKRGRILPSURYLQJWKHGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\RI
&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDP
../DX-/L1$UGOH\7/DX0HOERXUQH9LFWRULD$8
NHQNSODX#\DKRRFRPDX
3XUSRVHRI&7SXOPRQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &73$ LVLQFRQFOXVLYHGXHWRSRRU
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWRISXOPRQDU\DUWHULHV 3$ 7\SLFDOO\&73$LVXQGHUWDNHQ
DIWHUSDWLHQWWDNLQJIXOO\LQVSLUDWLRQDQGEUHDWKKROGLQJ7KHVXGGHQQHJDWLYHLQWUD
WKRUDFLFSUHVVXUHGXULQJTXLFNLQVSLUDWLRQLQFUHDVHVYHQRXVUHWXUQWRWKHKHDUWDQG
GLOXWHVWKHFRQWUDVWLQ3$ WUDQVLHQWLQWHUUXSWLRQRIFRQWUDVW 7KHYDOVDOYDDVVRFL
DWHGZLWKEUHDWKKROGLQJORZHUVWKHFDUGLDFRXWSXWDQGGHOD\VWKHSHDNFRQWUDVW
RSDFLÀFDWLRQRI3$7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHHIÀFDF\RIEUHDWKKROG
DWHDVHGXULQJ&73$RQWKHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWRI3$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&73$VZHUHXQGHUWDNHQLQFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZKR
GHHSO\ LQVSLUHG DQG EUHDWKKHOG GXULQJ VFDQQLQJ DQG FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV
ZKRVLPSO\EUHDWKKHOGDWHDVH+RXQVÀHOGXQLWV +8 LQSXOPRQDU\WUXQNPDLQ
SXOPRQDU\DUWHULHVDQGSUR[LPDOEUDQFKHVZHUHPHDVXUHGE\EOLQGHGUHDGHUV
5HVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQSDWLHQWJURXSV3(DQGFRH[LVWLQJOXQJGLV
HDVHVZHUHDOVRUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV 6XERSWLPDO FRQWUDVW HQKDQFHPHQW ZDV IRXQG LQ RI WKH GHHSO\
LQVSLUHGJURXSDQGRIWKHDWHDVHJURXS+8VUDQJHGIURPWRLQ
GLIIHUHQWSDUWRI3$VLQWKHLQVSLUHGJURXSDQGWRLQWKHDWHDVHJURXS
ZLWK PHDQ LQFUHDVH RI FRQWUDVW GHQVLW\ S ,PDJHV RI WKH OXQJ
SDUHQFK\PDLQERWKJURXSVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDGHTXDWH/HVVEUHDWKLQJDUWHIDFW
ZDVQRWHGLQWKHDWHDVHJURXS
&RQFOXVLRQ%UHDWKKROGLQJDWHDVHGXULQJVFDQQLQJLPSURYHVWKHRYHUDOOFRQWUDVW
GHQVLW\LQWKH3$DQGWKHUHIRUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\RIWKH&73$
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
(YDOXDWLRQRISXOPRQDU\EORRGÁRZXVLQJQHZPHWKRGRIG\QDPLF
[UD\H[DPLQDWLRQFRPSDULVRQZLWKP7F0$$SHUIXVLRQVFLQWLJUDSK\
7$EH7,]XND10RWRKDVKL(8HPD<$NL\DPD<6KLUDLVKL+2JDWD
0,WR6.XGRX7RN\R-3
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSXOPRQDU\EORRGÁRZXVLQJG\QDPLFFKHVW[UD\ZLWKRXW
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWLQFRPSDULVRQZLWKP7F0$$VFLQWLJUDSK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDO'\QDPLFFKHVWSXOVHG[UD\DWIUDPHVSHUVHFRQGLQ
WRWDOVHFRQGRIWLGDOEUHDWKLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSXOPRQDU\
GLVHDVH7KHLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYDODQGZULWWHQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZDV
REWDLQHGLQDOOSDWLHQWV,PDJHGDWDVHWVZHUHH[WUDFWHGE\VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\SL[HOVRI
EORRGÁRZVXVLQJDEDQGSDVVÀOWHURSWLPLVHGIRUKHDUWEHDWV'HWHUPLQHGEORRG
ÁRZVZDVGLYLGHGLQWRHLJKWÀHOGV XSSHUPLGGOHORZHUVXESKUHQLFLQULJKWDQG
OHIW LQHDFKDUWHULDODQGFDSLOODU\SKDVHVDQGZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHP7F0$$
VFLQWLJUDSK\
5HVXOWV$OO SDWLHQWV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG WHFKQLFDOO\ ZLWK WKH WRWDO H[SRVHG GRVH
RI P*\ 7KH EORRG ÁRZV LQ HDFK XSSHU PLGGOH ORZHU DQG VXESKUHQLF
ÀHOGV ZHUH DQG LQ WKH ULJKW DQG
DQGLQWKHOHIWLQDUWHULDO
SKDVH7KHFDSLOODU\EORRGÁRZVLJQDOVZHUH
DQGLQWKHULJKWDQGDQG
LQWKHOHIWLQWKLVVWXG\,QWKRVHFDVHV7KHP7F0$$XSWDNHZDV
LQWKHULJKWDQG
DQGLQWKHOHIWUHVSHFWLYHO\&RPSDULVRQRIWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVKDGJRRG
FRUUHODWLRQVZLWK5 LQDUWHULDOSKDVHDQG5 LQFDSLOODU\SKDVH
&RQFOXVLRQ'\QDPLFFKHVW[UD\EORRGÁRZVKDGJRRGFROODWLRQZLWKP7F0$$
VFLQWLJUDSK\7KLVPHWKRGPD\DOORZPHDVXUHPHQWDQGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRISXOPRQDU\
EORRGÁRZVZLWKRXWFRQWUDVW
%
Ҋ6WXQQHGOXQJҋDQRYHOREVHUYDWLRQRIUHVROYLQJSXOPRQDU\
HPEROLVPRQOXQJSHUIXVLRQ&7
-+5HLG(YDQ%HHN0:LOOLDPV0&RQQHOO-70XUFKLVRQ(GLQEXUJK8.
MRKQUHLG#ERUGHUVVFRWQKVXN
3XUSRVH3XOPRQDU\HPEROL 3( IUHTXHQWO\UHVROYHLQDQLQFRQVLVWHQWPDQQHU$
SLORWVWXG\ZDVFDUULHGRXWWRDVVHVV&7SHUIXVLRQSDWWHUQVRI3(UHVROXWLRQDQG
WRSRWHQWLDOO\LGHQWLI\YLDEOHSDUHQFK\PDH[KLELWLQJGHOD\HGSHUIXVLRQVLPLODUWRWKH
SKHQRPHQRQRIҊVWXQQHGҋP\RFDUGLXP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)ROORZLQJLQVWLWXWLRQDODSSURYDODSLORWVWXG\RISDWLHQWV
0)PHDQ\HDUV ZLWK&73$GLDJQRVLVRIPDMRU3(ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOX
DWHGE\&7OXQJSHUIXVLRQDIWHUDQDYHUDJHRIPRQWKV7KURPEXVORDG PRGLÀHG
0LOOHUVFRUH006 DQG59/9UDWLRZHUHGHWHUPLQHG3HUIXVLRQPDSVZHUHYLVXDOO\
VFRUHGDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWKUHVLGXDOHQGROXPLQDOÀOOLQJGHIHFWV'HIHFWVZHUHIXUWKHU
DVVHVVHGE\JHQHUDWLQJWLPHSHUIXVLRQFXUYHVXVLQJUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQLQLWLDOWKURPEXVORDGZDV006DQGPHDQ59/9UDWLRZDV
7KHPHDQUHVLGXDOWKURPEXVORDGZDV006 UDQJH ZLWKQRSRVW
WUHDWPHQW59GLODWDWLRQ2QO\ SDWLHQWVZHUHFOHDURIUHVLGXDOWKURPEXV
DQGRQO\SDWLHQWV KDGQRUHVLGXDOSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVDIWHUDPLQLPXPRI
WKUHHPRQWKVWUHDWPHQW3HUIXVLRQGHIHFWVUDQJHGIURPWRRIWKHDIIHFWHG
OXQJ&7SHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVPDWFKHGDUHDVVKRZLQJUHVLGXDOHPEROLFPDWHULDOLQ
RQO\SDWLHQWV,Q SDWLHQWVSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVVKRZHGGHOD\HGFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ0RVWSDWLHQWVKDYHSHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVDWWKUHHPRQWKVRIWHQVXEVWDQWLDO
DQGWKHVHPD\QRWFRUUHVSRQGZLWKWKHDUHDVRIUHVLGXDOHQGROXPLQDOPDWHULDO
6RPH GHIHFWV H[KLELW GHOD\HG HQKDQFHPHQW ZKLFK ZH KDYH WHUPHG ҊVWXQQHGҋ
OXQJ VXJJHVWLQJWKH\PD\SRWHQWLDOO\UHVSRQGWRUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQWHFKQLTXHV
%
9ROXPHUHQGHULQJUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIULJKWYHQWULFOHLPSURYHV
LQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWDQGDFFXUDF\RILQWHUYHQWULFXODUVHSWXP
ERZLQJVLJQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
*6WDVNLHZLF](&]HNDMVND&KHKDE-3U]HJDOLQVNL68KOLJ.7RUUHV
50DFLHMHZVNL$'URS/XEOLQ3/ JU]HJRU]VWDVNLHZLF]#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH%RZLQJRILQWHUYHQWULFXODUVHSWXP ,96 LVRQHRIWKHVLJQVRIVHYHUH3(
DGDSWHGIURPHFKRFDUGLRJUDSK\KRZHYHULWLVDIIHFWHGE\KLJKLQWHUREVHUYHUYDUL
DELOLW\7KHDLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHDSSOLFDWLRQRIYROXPHWULFUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
RIWKHULJKWYHQWULFOHIRULPSURYHPHQWRIUHOLDELOLW\RIWKLVVLJQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWK&73$GLDJQRVLVRIDFXWH3(
DQGHFKRFDUGLRJUDSKLFDOO\PHDVXUHGSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\V\VWROLFSUHVVXUH 3$63
ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWRWKHVWXG\,96ERZLQJZDVHYDOXDWHGZLWKPXOWLSODQDUUHIRUPD
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
WLRQV 035 DQG YROXPH UHQGHULQJ 95 UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV 7ZR UHDGHUV JUDGHG
WKHSRVLWLRQRI,96DVQRUPDOÁDWWHQHGRUERZHG,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDV
PHDVXUHGIRUERWKPHWKRGVRILGHQWLÀFDWLRQRI,96SRVLWLRQ52&DQDO\VLVZDVSHU
IRUPHGWRFRPSDUHDFFXUDF\RIERWKPHWKRGVIRULGHQWLÀFDWLRQRILQFUHDVHG3$63
5HVXOWV,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVIRXQGWREHIDLU NDSSD S
IRUWKH035EDVHGJUDGLQJRI,96SRVLWLRQDVQRUPDORUDEQRUPDO)RUWKH95EDVHG
DVVHVVPHQWNDSSDZDVJRRG S 52&DQDO\VLVIRUERWKPHWKRGV
VKRZHGLQVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUSHUIRUPDQFHRI95EDVHGPHWKRGIRULGHQWLÀFDWLRQRI
LQFUHDVHG3$63ZLWKDUHDXQGHU52&FXUYHIRU035EDVHGPHWKRGDQG
IRU95PHWKRG6HQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUHDQGIRU95PHWKRG
DQGDQGIRU035PHWKRGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ95EDVHGHYDOXDWLRQRI,96SRVLWLRQLVFKDUDFWHULVHGE\JRRGLQWHU
REVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWDQGPRGHUDWHDFFXUDF\IRULGHQWLÀFDWLRQRILQFUHDVHG3$63
5HVXOWVLQGLFDWHWKDWWKLVPHWKRGPD\LPSURYHXVHRIWKLVYDOXDEOHDGGLWLRQDOVLJQ
HYDOXDWHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWH3(
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ&7DQJLRJUDSKLFFORWORDG
VFRUHSXOPRQDU\SHUIXVLRQGHIHFWVFRUHDQGJOREDOULJKWYHQWULFXODU
IXQFWLRQE\GXDOVRXUFH&7IRUDFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
<)=KRX3+DQ<:DQJ+6KL:XKDQ&1 ]KRX\XQIHQJ#\DKRRFQ
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ&7DQJLRJUDSKLFFORWORDG &7$&/
VFRUH SXOPRQDU\ SHUIXVLRQ GHIHFW 33' VFRUH DQG WKH JOREDO ULJKW YHQWULFXODU
IXQFWLRQLQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHVHYHULW\RISXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP 3(
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\QLQHSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWH3(ZKRXQGHUZHQWGXDO
VRXUFH&7VFDQZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\&7DQJLRJUDSK\DQGSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ
ZHUHSHUIRUPHG7KHGDWDIURP(&*JDWHGFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\VFDQQLQJSURWRFRO
ZHUHXVHGIRUULJKWYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQDQDO\VLV7ZRUHDGHUVHYDOXDWHGWKH&7$&/
DQG33'VFRUHVDFFRUGLQJWRWKH4DQDGOLDQG&KDHPHWKRGVUHVSHFWLYHO\DQG
WKHLUUHVXOWVZHUHLQFRQVHQVXV
5HVXOWV7KH33'VFRUHKDGDVWURQJSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKH&7$&/VFRUH U
S DQGERWKVFRUHVLQWXUQKDGDVWURQJSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKH
ULJKWYHQWULFXODUOHIWYHQWULFXODU 59/9 GLDPHWHUUDWLR U U S
+RZHYHUWKH33'VFRUHKDGDVWURQJQHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ
() U S ZKLOHWKH&7$&/VFRUHKDGDORZQHJDWLYHFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWK() U S %HWZHHQWKH59/9JURXS Q DQGWKH59/9!
JURXS Q WKH33'VFRUH&7$&/VFRUHSXOPRQDU\DUWHU\WUXQNGLDPHWHU()
DQGUHÁX[RILQIHULRUYHQDFDYDZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWDOOZLWKS7KH
HQGV\VWROLFYROXPH S ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEXWWKHHQGGLDVWROLFYROXPH
S DQGVWURNHYROXPH S VKRZHGQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KHUHIRUH FRQVLGHULQJ 33' VFRUHV &7$&/ VFRUHV DQG FDUGLR
YDVFXODUPDQLIHVWDWLRQVWRJHWKHUPD\EHKHOSIXOLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI3(VHYHULW\
DFFHSWHGE\%-5
%
&RPSDULVRQRIKLJKVHQVLWLYHWURSRQLQ,DQGTXDQWLWDWLYH&7
SDUDPHWHUVIRUSUHGLFWLRQRIDGYHUVHFOLQLFDOHYHQWVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
DFXWHSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP
3$SIDOWUHU):HLOEDFKHU00H\HU7+HQ]OHU7:DOWHU-*UXHWWQHU
8-6FKRHSI&)LQN0DQQKHLP'(&KDUOHVWRQ6&86
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHG0'&7YVWLPHUHVROYHG05DQJLRJUDSK\
YVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGSHUIXVLRQ05,DVVHVVPHQWRIWUHDWPHQW
UHVSRQVHE\SDWLHQWVZLWKFKURQLFWKURPERHPEROLFSXOPRQDU\
K\SHUWHQVLRQ
<2KQR01LVKLR+.R\DPD7<RVKLNDZD'7DNHQDND60DWVXPRWR
.6XJLPXUD.REH-3 \RVLUDG#NREHXDFMS
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHUDSHXWLFHIIHFWDVVHVVPHQWFDSDELOLW\RI0'&7WLPH
UHVROYHG05DQJLRJUDSK\G\QDPLFSHUIXVLRQ05,DQGFRQYHQWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV
IRUFKURQLFWKURPERHPEROLFSXOPRQDU\K\SHUWHQVLRQ &7(3+ SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\IRXUFRQVHFXWLYH&7(3+SDWLHQWV PHQDQG
ZRPHQPHDQVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQDJH\HDUV WUHDWHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO
WKHUDS\XQGHUZHQWSUHDQGSRVWWKHUDSHXWLF0'&7WLPHUHVROYHG05DQJLRJUDSK\
G\QDPLFSHUIXVLRQ05,DQGFDUGLDF86DQGULJKWKHDUWFDWKHWHULVDWLRQ$OOSDWLHQWV
ZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVUHVSRQVH Q DQGQRQUHVSRQVH Q &7(3+
LQGH[HVIRU0'&7 &7(3+&7 DQG05DQJLRJUDSK\ &7(3+05$ ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
RQWKHEDVLVRIHPEROLFEXUGHQ3XOPRQDU\EORRGÁRZ 3%) SXOPRQDU\EORRG
YROXPH 3%9 DQGPHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 077 PDSVZHUHJHQHUDWHGIURPDOOSHUIXVLRQ
05GDWDIROORZHGE\GHWHUPLQDWLRQRILPSURYHPHQWVLQPHDQ3%)3%9DQG077
DW52,VIRUHDFKSDWLHQW5HFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& EDVHGSRVLWLYH
WHVWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHIHDVLEOHWKUHVKROGYDOXHVIRUGLVWLQJXLVKLQJ
UHVSRQVHIURPQRQUHVSRQVHJURXSV)LQDOO\GLDJQRVWLFFDSDELOLWLHVZHUHFRPSDUHG
E\PHDQVRIWKH0F1HPDUҋVWHVW
5HVXOWV:KHQHDFKRIWKHIHDVLEOHWKUHVKROGYDOXHVZDVXVHGVSHFLÀFLW\
S DQGDFFXUDF\ S IRULPSURYHPHQWLQ3%)ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHUWKDQWKRVHIRULPSURYHPHQWVLQ0:' VSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\
DQG&7(3+&7$ VSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\
&RQFOXVLRQ '\QDPLF SHUIXVLRQ 05, DQG WLPHUHVROYHG 05 DQJLRJUDSK\ KDYH
HTXDORUEHWWHUFDSDELOLW\IRUDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHUDSHXWLFHIIHFWRQ&7(3+SDWLHQWV
WKDQGRFRQYHQWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVDQG0'&7
%
,QFLGHQFHDQGDHWLRORJ\RIPRVDLFOXQJDWWHQXDWLRQ 0/$ LQDODUJH
FRKRUWRISDWLHQWVZLWKULJKWKHDUWFDWKHWHU 5+& FRUURERUDWHG
SXOPRQDU\K\SHUWHQVLRQ 3+
/:RRGV$1DLU'3DWHO$'HYDUDM%0DGGHQ,9ODKRV/RQGRQ8.
OLDPZRRGV#GRFWRUVRUJXN
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHH[WHQWVHYHULW\DQGDHWLRORJ\RI0/$GHWHFWHGDWWKLQ
VHFWLRQ&7LQDODUJH5+&FRUURERUDWHG3+JURXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7VFDQVRISDWLHQWVZLWK5+&FRQÀUPHG3+UHIHUUHG
WRDWHUWLDU\FHQWUHZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG,QVSLUDWRU\DQGH[SLUDWRU\LPDJ
LQJZDVUHYLHZHGIURPWKHVDPHWLPHSRLQWZKHUHDYDLODEOHWHFKQLFDOO\DGHTXDWHRU
IURPPHWDFKURQRXVVWXGLHVLIQRW7KUHHFKHVWUDGLRORJLVWVGHWHUPLQHGE\FRQVHQVXV
0/$VHYHULW\ DEVHQWPLQRUSK\VLRORJLFPLOGPRGHUDWHVHYHUH )RU
SDLUHG LQVSLUDWRU\H[SLUDWRU\ VWXGLHV SUHGRPLQDQW DHWLRORJ\ ZDV GHWHUPLQHG DV
DLUWUDSSLQJ $0/$ YDVFXODU 90/$ RUPL[HGLQGHWHUPLQDWH 00/$
5HVXOWV RISDWLHQWVKDGWHFKQLFDOO\DGHTXDWHLQVSLUDWRU\LPDJLQJ
0/$ZDVSUHVHQWLQ VHYHULW\UHVSHFWLYHO\
RI SDWLHQWV KDG SDLUHG LQVSLUDWRU\H[SLUDWRU\ LPDJLQJ ZLWK D FRPSDUDEOH
SHUFHQWDJHGHPRQVWUDWLQJDWOHDVWPLOG0/$ 7KH0/$DHWLRORJ\ZDV$0/$
LQ90/$LQDQG00/$LQ:KHQFRQVLGHULQJSDWLHQWVZLWKDWOHDVW
PLOG0/$WKHSURSRUWLRQRI90/$LQFUHDVHG 7KHSURSRUWLRQRISDWLHQWVZLWK
0/$GXHWR90/$ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQSDWLHQWVZLWKFKURQLFWKURPERHPEROLF
3+ &7(3+ WKDQRWKHUFDXVHVFRPELQHG Y)LVKHUH[DFWWHVWS
+RZHYHUYDVFXODUSUHGRPLQDQWPRVDLFLVPDOVRRFFXUUHGLQRILGLRSDWKLF3+
RIREVWUXFWLYHOXQJGLVHDVHDQGRIOHIWKHDUWGLVHDVH3+DHWLRORJLHV
2YHUDOORIYDVFXODUPRVDLFLVPZDVQRWGXHWR&7(3+
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKLVFRKRUW0/$LVFRPPRQHUWKDQSUHYLRXVO\UHSRUWHG$OWKRXJK
XVXDOO\GXHWRDLUWUDSSLQJDVLJQLÀFDQWSURSRUWLRQLVYDVFXODULQDHWLRORJ\WKRXJK
QRWQHFHVVDULO\GXHWR&7(3+
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHKLJKVHQVLWLYHWURSRQLQ, KV7Q, DQGTXDQWLWDWLYH&7SD
UDPHWHUVIRUSUHGLFWLRQRIDGYHUVHFOLQLFDOHYHQWVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHSXOPRQDU\
HPEROLVP 3(
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3XOPRQDU\&7$VWXGLHVRISDWLHQWVZHUHUHWURVSHF
WLYHO\HYDOXDWHGSDWLHQWV \HDUV>@ KDGDFXWH3(DQGKV7Q,PHDVXUH
PHQWVZLWKLQKRXUVRI&75LJKWYHQWULFXODUG\VIXQFWLRQ 59' ZDVDVVHVVHGRQ
&7E\FDOFXODWLQJWKHULJKWYHQWULFXODUOHIWYHQWULFXODU 59/9 GLDPHWHUUDWLRVRQ
WUDQVYHUVHVHFWLRQV 59/9WUDQV IRXUFKDPEHUYLHZV 59/9FK 59/9YROXPH
UDWLR 59/9YRO 3XOPRQDU\&7$REVWUXFWLRQVFRUHV 26 4DQDGOL0DVWRUD ZHUH
FDOFXODWHG+V7Q,59/9UDWLRVDQG26ZHUHFRPSDUHGIRUSUHGLFWLQJDGYHUVH
FOLQLFDOHYHQWV
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZLWK3(KDGDWOHDVWRQHDGYHUVHFOLQLFDOHYHQW LQWHQVLYH
FDUHWUHDWPHQWQ GHDWKQ WKRVHSDWLHQWVVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU59
/9UDWLRVDQG26FRPSDUHGWRWKRVHZLWKRXW 59/9WUDQVYV
59/9FKYV59/9YROXPHYV0DVWRUD
>@YV>@DQG4DQDGOL>@YV>@ S"
(OHYDWHGKV7Q,ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKDGYHUVHFOLQLFDOHYHQWV YV
SDGMXVWHG25 &,S +V7Q,VKRZHGQR
FRUUHODWLRQZLWK59/9UDWLRVRU267KH$8&IRUWKHSUHGLFWLRQRIDGYHUVHFOLQLFDO
HYHQWV RI 59/9&K 59/9YROXPH DQG KV7Q, ZHUH DQG 7KH
FRPELQDWLRQRIKV7Q,DQG59/9UDWLRVUHYHDOHGQRLQFUHDVHVLQWKH$8&
&RQFOXVLRQ+V7Q,LVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDGYHUVHFOLQLFDOHYHQWV$FRPELQDWLRQRI
KV7Q, ZLWK &7 SDUDPHWHUV VKRZHG QR IXUWKHU LPSURYHPHQW LQ WKH SUHGLFWLRQ RI
DGYHUVHFOLQLFDOHYHQWV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
8VHRISXOPRQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\WRGLDJQRVHDQDHPLD
&6/-XQJ0*URWK7$%OH\)2+HQHV$7UHV]O*$GDP3%DQQDV
+DPEXUJ'(
3XUSRVH$QDHPLDLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKLQFUHDVHGPRUWDOLW\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWH
V\PSWRPDWLFSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP 3( 7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOX
DWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\RI+RXQVÀHOGXQLW +8 PHDVXUHPHQWVRQDVLQJOHXQHQKDQFHG
WULJJHUVFDQRISXOPRQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\VFDQVIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDQDHPLDDV
DSRWHQWLDOSURJQRVWLFPDUNHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG3(XQGHUZHQW
SXOPRQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVEOLQGHGWRODERUDWRU\UHVXOWVSHU
IRUPHG+8PHDVXUHPHQWVLQWKHVLQJOHXQHQKDQFHGWULJJHUVFDQLQGHSHQGHQWO\
E\UHJLRQEDVHGDQDO\VLV 52, +8YDOXHVIURPDVFHQGLQJDQGGHVFHQGLQJDRUWD
DQGWKHFDOFXODWHGPHDQRIERWKZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKVHUXPKDHPRJORELQOHYHOV
,QWHU DQG LQWUDREVHUYHU YDULDELOLW\ ZDV GHWHUPLQHG IRU +8 PHDVXUHPHQWV DQG
UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGIRUGLDJQRVLVRI
DQDHPLD&DOFXODWHGOLQHDUPRGHOVZHUHXVHGWRDVVHVVIRUPXODVIRUHVWLPDWLRQ
RIKDHPRJORELQOHYHOVIURP+8PHDVXUHPHQWV
5HVXOWV +8 PHDVXUHPHQWV UHYHDOHG KLJK LQWUD DQG LQWHUUDWHU UHOLDELOLW\
,&&!DQG,&&!UHVSHFWLYHO\ &DOFXODWHGPHDQ+8YDOXHVVKRZHG
DPRGHUDWHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKVHUXPKDHPRJORELQOHYHOV U ZKLFKDOORZHG
JHQHUDWLRQ RI GLIIHUHQW IRUPXODV IRU FDOFXODWLRQ RI KDHPRJORELQ OHYHOV IURP +8
PHDVXUHPHQWV52&DQDO\VHVFRQÀUPHGDKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\ IRUPHQIRU
ZRPHQ DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ IRUPHQIRUZRPHQ IRUGLDJQRVLQJDQDHPLD
&RQFOXVLRQ'LDJQRVLVRIDQDHPLDDQGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIKDHPRJORELQOHYHOVXSRQ
DVLQJOHXQHQKDQFHGWULJJHUVFDQRISXOPRQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\LVIHDVLEOH:H
VXJJHVWGLVFORVLQJWKHDQDHPLFVWDWHLQWKHUDGLRORJLFDOUHSRUWLQGHSHQGHQWRIWKH
SUHVHQFHRI3(VLQFHDQDHPLDFDUULHVLQFUHDVHGULVNVRIPRUELGLW\DQGPRUWDOLW\
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
6SHFLDOLQGLFDWLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
(&ULDGR3DUHGHV6DEDGHOO(6
0-/HH'XEOLQ,(
%
3UHGLFWRUVDQGYROXPHPHDVXUHPHQWRIUHVLGXDOÁRZLQHPEROLVHG
LQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPVDWIROORZXS
=6HUDÀQ36WU]HŋQLHZVNL:/DVHN:%HXWK%\GJRV]F]3/
VHUDÀQ#FPXPNSO
3XUSRVH7KHSRVVLELOLW\RIUHFDQDOLVDWLRQDQGWKHQHHGIRUUHWUHDWPHQWDUHWKH
PRVWLPSRUWDQWGUDZEDFNVRILQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPHPEROLVDWLRQ7KHYROXPHRI
UHVLGXDOÁRZDWIROORZXSLVDNH\IDFWRUWKDWGHWHUPLQHVGHFLVLRQRQWKHDQHXU\VP
UHHPEROLVDWLRQ 7KH SXUSRVH RI WKH VWXG\ ZDV WR GHWHUPLQH IDFWRUV SUHGLFWLQJ
WKH SUHVHQFH RI UHVLGXDO ÁRZ DW IROORZXS DQG WR FRPSDUH YROXPHV RI WKH ÁRZ
PHDVXUHGZLWK'GLJLWDOVXEWUDFWHGDQJLRJUDSK\ '6$ DQGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
DQJLRJUDSK\ 05$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QFRQVHFXWLYHO\H[DPLQHGSDWLHQWVDQHXU\VPV
ZHUH IRXQG LQFRPSOHWHO\ RFFOXGHG ,QGHSHQGHQW SUHGLFWRUV RI WKH UHVLGXDO ÁRZ
ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGLQFOXGLQJDQDWRPLFDODQGFOLQLFDOIDFWRUV'LDPHWHUVDQGYROXPH
RIUHVLGXDOÁRZDUHDVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDO'6$ ''6$
WLPHRIÁLJKW05$ 72)05$ FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG72)05$ &(72)05$ DQG
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05$ &(05$
5HVXOWV$QHXU\VPQHFNVL]HDQGVDFNWRQHFNUDWLRZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUV
RIUHVLGXDOÁRZ 3 $52&FXUYHFXWRIISRLQWVZHUHPPIRUDQHXU\VP
QHFNVL]HDQGIRUVDFNWRQHFNUDWLR7KHPHDQUHFDQDOLVDWLRQYROXPHUDQJHG
IURPPPLQ72)05$WRPPLQ''6$ 3$129$ $
GLUHFWFRPSDULVRQUHYHDOHGVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHYROXPHVPHDVXUHGZLWK
''6$DQG&(05$DVFRPSDUHGWR72)05$DQG&(72)05$ 3
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQFHRIWKHUHVLGXDOÁRZZLWKLQWKHHPEROLVHGDQHXU\VPLV
SUHGLFWHGE\WKHDQHXU\VPDQDWRP\72)05$DQG&(72)05$WHQGWRXQGHU
HVWLPDWHWKHVL]HRIWKHÁRZ7KHGHÀQLWLYHGHFLVLRQRQUHHPEROLVDWLRQVKRXOGEH
PDGHEDVLQJRQ''6$
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
'LDJQRVWLFGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWLRQGDFU\RF\VWRJUDSK\FULWHULDRI
HYDOXDWLRQIUHTXHQF\DQGORFDOLVDWLRQRISDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV
'.)LOLSSLDGLV$:HLVVEDFK&0H\HU$0D]LRWL++6FKLOG
.(:LOKHOP$WKHQV*5%RQQ'( GÀOLSSLDGLV#\DKRRJU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHIUHTXHQF\DQGORFDOLVDWLRQRISDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVLQ
SDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPHSLSKRUD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIGLDJQRVWLFGDFU\RF\VWR
JUDPVLQSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPHSLSKRUD6WHQRVLVZDVGHÀQHGDVHDUO\UHÁX[
WKURXJK WKH SXQFWXP ZLWK UHVLGXDO ÁRZ RI FRQWUDVW PDWHULDO WR WKH QDVDO FDYLW\
&RPSOHWHREVWUXFWLRQZDVDVVXPHGLIQRÁRZRIFRQWUDVWPDWHULDOWRWKHQDVDO
FDYLW\ZDVVHHQHYHQDIWHUIRUFHGLUULJDWLRQ
5HVXOWV,Q FDVHVQRWHDUGXFWREVWUXFWLRQZDVIRXQG,Q
FDVHVDWHDUGXFWREVWUXFWLRQZDVVHHQ,Q FDVHVWKHUHZDVDVWHQRVLV
ZKLOVWLQ FDVHVWKHUHZDVDFRPSOHWHREVWUXFWLRQ/RFDOLVDWLRQRIWKH
VWHQRVLV LQFOXGHG MXQFWLRQ RI WKH QDVRODFULPDO VDF DQG QDVRODFULPDO GXFW DW
FDVHV SRVWVDFFDOOHYHODWFDVHV FRPPRQFDQDOLFXOXVDWFDVHV
DQGORZHUFDQDOLFXOXVDWFDVH /RFDOLVDWLRQRIFRPSOHWHREVWUXFWLRQV
LQFOXGHGMXQFWLRQRIQDVRODFULPDOVDFDQGQDVRODFULPDOGXFWDWFDVHV
FRPPRQFDQDOLFXOXVOHYHODWFDVHV SRVWVDFFDOOHYHODWFDVHV
DQGORZHUFDQDOLFXOXVDWFDVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ(SLSKRUDLVPRVWO\FDXVHGE\VWHQRVLVRUFRPSOHWHREVWUXFWLRQRI
WKHQDVRODFULPDOGXFWV\VWHP7KHPRVWFRPPRQVLWHRIREVWUXFWLRQLVWKHMXQFWLRQ
RIWKHQDVRODFULPDOVDFDQGQDVRODFULPDOGXFW&RPSOHWHREVWUXFWLRQVDUHPRUH
FRPPRQWKDQVWHQRVLV
%
(PEROLVDWLRQWHFKQLTXHVIRUSRVWWUDXPDWLFVSOHQLFLQMXU\
*UHQREOHҋVH[SHULHQFH
-)UDQGRQ2(NHU)7KRQ\05RGLHUH&6HQJHO3'XUDQG06DKLQ
$9HQGUHOO,%ULFDXOW*UHQREOH)5 MIUDQGRQ#FKXJUHQREOHIU
3XUSRVH1RQRSHUDWLYHPDQDJHPHQWRIVSOHQLFLQMXU\LVQRZWKHVWDQGDUGLQVWDEOH
WUDXPDSDWLHQW2XUREMHFWLYHLVWRFRPSDUHWKHRXWFRPHVRISUR[LPDOGLVWDORU
FRPELQHGHPEROLVDWLRQSURFHGXUHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVSOHQLFLQMXU\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %HWZHHQ DQG DOO SDWLHQWV DGPLWWHG LQ RXU
FHQWHUIRUSRVWWUDXPDWLFVSOHQLFLQMXU\UHTXLULQJHPEROLVDWLRQZHUHUHYLHZHG7KH\
XQGHUZHQWSUR[LPDO JURXS$ GLVWDO JURXS% RUFRPELQHGSUR[LPDODQGGLVWDO
JURXS & HPEROLVDWLRQ SURFHGXUHV 5HEOHHGLQJ UHTXLULQJ VSOHQHFWRP\ RU QRW
DQGFRPSOLFDWLRQVDIWHUHPEROLVDWLRQ DVVSOHQLFLQIDUFWLRQDEVFHVVSDQFUHDWLWLV
SDQFUHDWLFSVHXGRF\VWRUKHPDWRPDODUJHKHPRSHULWRQHXPSVHXGRDQHXU\VP
ÀVWXOD SOHXUDO HIIXVLRQ RU GLVWDO FRLO PLJUDWLRQ ZHUH DVVHVVHG LQ DOO JURXSV$
)LVKHUҋVH[DFWWHVWZDVXVHG
5HVXOWV)RUW\VHYHQSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWHPEROLVDWLRQVDV Q Q
DQG Q LQJURXSV$%DQG&UHVSHFWLYHO\5HEOHHGLQJZDVREVHUYHGLQ
RIDOOSDWLHQWV Q ZLWKRXWDQ\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQDOOJURXSV
Q LQ$Q LQ%Q LQ&S 6SOHQHFWRP\ZDVUHTXLUHGLQRISD
WLHQWVRQO\LQJURXS% Q ZLWKRXWDQ\VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S
7ZHQW\QLQHFRPSOLFDWLRQVDIWHUHPEROLVDWLRQZHUHREVHUYHGLQRISDWLHQWV
Q LQJURXS$ Q LQJURXS% Q DQGLQJURXS& Q ZLWKRXW
DQ\VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S
&RQFOXVLRQ 3UR[LPDO GLVWDO DQG FRPELQHG HPEROLVDWLRQ WHFKQLTXHV IRU SRVW
WUDXPDWLFVSOHQLFLQMXU\SUHVHQWHGQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\GLIIHUHQWUDWHVRIUHEOHHGLQJDQG
FRPSOLFDWLRQVDIWHUHPEROLVDWLRQ6SOHQHFWRP\ZDVQHHGHGLQIHZFDVHVRQO\IRU
SDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQWGLVWDOHPEROLVDWLRQ
%
1DVRODFULPDOSRO\XUHWKDQHVWHQWLPSURYLQJRXWFRPHVZLWKWKH
:LOKHOPW\SH:LOKHOPWHDUOHDGHUVWHQW
'.)LOLSSLDGLV$:HLVVEDFK&0H\HU$0D]LRWL++6FKLOG
.(:LOKHOP$WKHQV*5%RQQ'( GÀOLSSLDGLV#\DKRRJU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQGORQJWHUPUHVXOWVRIQDVRODFULPDOGXFW
VWHQWLPSODQWDWLRQLQWKHWUHDWPHQWRIHSLSKRUD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH>UDQJH@PDOHVDQG
IHPDOHV ZLWKVHYHUHHSLSKRUDXQGHUZHQWQDVRODFULPDOGXFWVWHQWLQJ :LOKHOP
W\SH SRO\XUHWKDQH VWHQW XQGHU ÁXRURVFRSLF JXLGDQFH DIWHU GDFU\RF\VWRJUDSK\
DVDWUHDWPHQWIRUREVWUXFWLRQVRIWKHQDVRODFULPDOV\VWHP7KHDHWLRORJ\RIWKH
REVWUXFWLRQZDVFKURQLFLQIHFWLRQ FKURQLFGDFU\RF\VWLWLV LQDOOFDVHV
5HVXOWV 7KH RYHUDOO WHFKQLFDO VXFFHVV UDWH RI VWHQW SODFHPHQW ZDV 1R
FDVHVRISDOSHEUDOKDHPDWRPDZHUHUHFRUGHGQHLWKHUZHUHWKHUHFDVHVRIDFXWH
GDFU\RF\VWLWLVIROORZLQJWKHSURFHGXUH6HFRQGDU\SDWHQF\ZDVDFKLHYHGLQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
GXULQJDPHDQIROORZXSSHULRGRIQLQHPRQWKV UDQJHPRQWKVWR\HDUV 6WHQWV
PDOIXQFWLRQRFFXUUHGLQFDVHVDQGDOOWKHVHVWHQWVZHUHHDVLO\ZLWKGUDZQLQWKH
UHVWRIWKHFDVHVWKHVWHQWVUHPDLQLQSODFHDQGIXQFWLRQDO
&RQFOXVLRQ7UHDWPHQWRIHSLSKRUDZLWKSRO\XUHWKDQHVWHQWVLVDWHFKQLTXHWKDWLV
ZHOOWROHUDWHGE\SDWLHQWVDQGDFKLHYHVDKLJKORQJWHUPVXFFHVVUDWHFRPSDUDEOH
WRVXUJLFDOGDUF\RUKLQRVWRP\
%
7KHFODVVLFDOSDSHUVRILQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\WKHHYROXWLRQ
RIDVSHFLDOW\
07&URFNHWW2%XFNOH\:7RUUHJJLDQL5%URZQH'XEOLQ,(
&52&.(7707#*0$,/&20
3XUSRVH7KHYDOXHRIDVFLHQWLÀFSDSHULVGHÀQHGE\LWVLPSDFWRQWKHELRPHGLFDO
ÀHOGLQZKLFKLWLVSXEOLVKHG3DSHUVZKLFKLPSDFWJUHDWO\RQWKHLUÀHOGDFKLHYH
FODVVLFDOVWDWXV7KLVPD\EHGHÀQHGXVLQJWKHFRQFHSWRIDFLWDWLRQFODVVLFWKH
QXPEHURIWLPHVDSDSHULVFLWHGUHÁHFWVLWVLPSDFWDQGUHOHYDQFH7KHSXUSRVHRI
WKLVVWXG\ZDVWRLGHQWLI\DQGDQDO\VHWKHPRVWFLWHGLQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\
SDSHUVRIWKHODVW\HDUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8VLQJWKH-&5GDWDEDVHWKHKLJKHVWLPSDFWIDFWRU
UDGLRORJ\MRXUQDOVZHUHVHOHFWHGIRUUHYLHZ)URPWKHVHMRXUQDOVWKHPRVWFLWHG
LQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\SXEOLFDWLRQVZHUHFKRVHQDQGIXUWKHUDQDO\VHG
5HVXOWV7KHPRVWFLWHGSDSHUUHFHLYHGQHDUO\FLWDWLRQVZKLOVWWKHDYHUDJH
QXPEHURIFLWDWLRQVZDV7KHROGHVWSDSHUZDVSXEOLVKHGLQDQGPRVW
UHFHQWLQ0RVWSDSHUVRULJLQDWHGLQWKH86$IROORZHGE\,WDO\)UDQFHDQG
*HUPDQ\7KHWKUHHPRVWSUROLÀFLQVWLWXWLRQVZHUH+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\ 86$ 2V
SHGDOH&LYLOH ,WDO\ DQG0DVVDFKXVHWWV*HQHUDO+RVSLWDO 86$ 7KHPRVWFLWHG
SDSHUVZHUHSXEOLVKHGLQMRXUQDOVZLWK5DGLRORJ\ $-5PDNLQJXSWKHPDMRULW\
)LYHDXWKRUVKDYH!ÀUVWQDPHSDSHUVLQWKHWRSZLWK61*ROGEHUJRQWRS
ZLWK!RISDSHUVZHUHSXEOLVKHGDIWHU7KHROGHUSDSHUVIRFXVPDLQO\
RQFDUGLRYDVFXODULQWHUYHQWLRQDOWHFKQLTXHVZLWKPRUHUHFHQWSDSHUVGRPLQDWHG
E\DGYDQFHVLQLQWHUYHQWLRQDOQHXURUDGLRORJ\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVDQDO\VLVLGHQWLÀHVPDQ\RIWKHODQGPDUNLQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\
SDSHUVRIODVWVL[GHFDGHVDQGSURYLGHVDIDVFLQDWLQJLQVLJKWLQWRWKHFKDQJLQJ
GLVFRXUVHZLWKLQWKHÀHOG,WDOVRLGHQWLÀHVWKHWRSLFVDXWKRUVDQGLQVWLWXWLRQVZKLFK
KDYHKDGWKHJUHDWHVWLPSDFWRQWKHVSHFLDOW\
%
3HUFXWDQHRXVDUWHULRYHQRXVVKXQWLQJLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUH
&23'DQRYHOLQWHUYHQWLRQDOWUHDWPHQW
76FKORVVHU0%XUEHONR08OULFK*$QWRFK5$GDPXV
(VVHQ'( WKRPDVVFKORVVHU#XQLGXHGH
%
7KHVDIHW\DQGHIÀFDF\RIÁRZGLYHUVLRQWUHDWPHQWRILQWUDFUDQLDO
DQHXU\VPVSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
'%DJDWWR%3HWUDOLD5*LURPHWWL0%D]]RFFKL8GLQH,7
GDQLHOHEDJDWWR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RLOOXVWUDWHPRQRFHQWULFH[SHULHQFHRIÁRZGLYHUVLRQDSSURDFKIRUHQ
GRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRILQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPV7RDVVHVWKHVDIHW\DQGHIÀFDF\RI
WKLVDOWHUQDWLYHDQGSURPLVLQJWHFKQLTXHLQFRPSDULVRQZLWKFRLODQGVWHQWDVVLVWHG
FRLOHPEROLVDWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
3RVWWUDXPDWLFHSLVWD[LVWUHDWHGZLWKHPEROLVDWLRQ
.3\UD7-DUJLHããR37URMDQRZVNL0-DU]ćEHN06]F]HUER7URMDQRZVND
/XEOLQ3/ NS\UD#SRF]WDIP
3XUSRVH (SLVWD[LV LV D FRPPRQ FRQVHTXHQFH RI FUDQLRIDFLDO LQMXU\ LQYROYLQJ
GDPDJHWRWKHH[WHUQDOFDURWLGDUWHU\EUDQFKHV'HSHQGLQJRQWKHLQWHQVLW\DQG
WKHVLWHRIEOHHGLQJDQGDOVRRQWKHH[SHULHQFHRIWKHPHGLFDOWHDPFRQVHUYDWLYH
WUHDWPHQWVXUJLFDORUHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWLVDSSOLHG,QWKLVSDSHUWKHSRVVLELOLW\
RIHQGRYDVFXODUHPEROLVDWLRQDQGLWVHIIHFWLYHQHVVLQWKHWUHDWPHQWRIHSLVWD[LV
IROORZLQJFUDQLRIDFLDOLQMXU\LVHYDOXDWHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHUHZHUHSDWLHQWV PDOHVDQGIHPDOHV LQWKH
PHDQDJH\HDUV ZLWKSRVWWUDXPDWLFHSLVWD[LV,QSDWLHQWVDQJLRJUDSK\
'LVFORVHGSVHXGRDQHXU\VPVRIWKHH[WHUQDOFDURWLGEUDQFKHVLQH[WUDYDVDWLRQ
RIFRQWUDVWPHGLDLQFDYHUQRFDURWLGÀVWXODH)ROORZLQJGLDJQRVWLFDQJLRJUDSK\
WKHULVNRIHQGRYDVFXODUHPEROLVDWLRQZDVUHJDUGHGWREHWRRKLJKLQSDWLHQWV
5HPDLQLQJSDWLHQWVZHUHHPEROLVHGXVLQJJHODWLQIRDPSRO\YLQ\ODOFRKROSDU
WLFOHVSDUWLFOHVRIDFU\OLFSRO\PHUDQGSODWLQLXPPLFURFRLOV
5HVXOWV,QDOOHPEROLVHGSDWLHQWVLPPHGLDWHDUUHVWRIHSLVWD[LVZDVDFKLHYHG,Q
FDVHV WKHEOHHGLQJUHFXUUHGDQGLQZDVFRQWUROOHGZLWKUHSHDWHGHP
EROLVDWLRQ,QSDWLHQWV WKHVLGHHIIHFWRIWKHSURFHGXUHZDVWUDQVLHQWIDFLDO
SDLQDQGVZHOOLQJSDUDHVWKHVLDWULVPXVDQGIHYHU7KRVHV\PSWRPVGLVDSSHDUHG
ZLWKLQDIHZGD\V,QSDWLHQWV VHQVRU\GLVWXUEDQFHVLQWKHFKHHNDUHDZHUH
SHUPDQHQW2QHSDWLHQWGHYHORSHGDVPDOOXOFHUDWLRQRIWKHSDODWHVXFFHVVIXOO\
WUHDWHGFRQVHUYDWLYHO\7KHUHZHUHQRVHULRXVQHXURORJLFDOFRPSOLFDWLRQVLQDQ\
RIWKHSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ(QGRYDVXODUHPEROLVDWLRQLVDQHIIHFWLYHPHWKRGRISRVWWUDXPDWLF
HSLVWD[LVDQGVKRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGLQSODQQLQJRIWKHWUHDWPHQW
%
7UDFKHREURQFKLDOVWHQWLQJIRUPDOLJQDQWDLUZD\GLVHDVHORQJWHUP
UHVXOWVIURPDVLQJOHFHQWUH
5,QFKLQJROR6&6SLOLRSRLORV0.URNLGLV,$KPHG$0F*UDWK
3*NRXW]LRV56DOWHU76DEKDUZDO5RPH,73DWUDV*5/RQGRQ8.
'XEOLQ,(
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHLPPHGLDWHDQGORQJWHUPRXWFRPHVRIFRYHUHGDQG
XQFRYHUHGVHOIH[SDQGDEOHPHWDOOLFVWHQW 6(06 LQVHUWLRQIRUWKHPDQDJHPHQW
RIWUDFKHREURQFKLDOPDOLJQDQWGLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\VHDUFKHGRXUGHSDUWPHQWGDWDEDVH
IRU SDWLHQWV WUHDWHG ZLWK FRYHUHG RU XQFRYHUHG 6(06V IRU WKH PDQDJHPHQW RI
WUDFKHREURQFKLDOSDWKRORJ\RZLQJWRORFDORUPHWDVWDWLFGLVHDVH%HWZHHQ-DQXDU\
DQG'HFHPEHULQWRWDOSDWLHQWV PDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV
XQGHUZHQW6(06LQVHUWLRQV XQFRYHUHGFRYHUHG 7KHK\EULGSURFHGXUH
ZDVSHUIRUPHGXQGHUEURQFKRVFRSLFDQGÁXRURVFRSLFJXLGDQFH7KHVWXG\ VSULPDU\
HQGSRLQWVLQFOXGHGWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVDQGV\PSWRPDWRORJ\UHFXUUHQFHUDWHVZKLOH
VHFRQGDU\HQGSRLQWVLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWV VXUYLYDODQGFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHV%DVHOLQH
GHPRJUDSKLFVDQGSURFHGXUDOGHWDLOVZHUHUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVUDWHZDV FDVHV ,QWRWDONLVVLQJ ERWK
EURQFKXV PDLQEURQFKXVGLVWDOEURQFKXVWUDFKHDODQGWUDFKHDOSOXV
PDLQEURQFKXVVWHQWLQJGHSOR\PHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHG7KHPHDQWLPHIROORZXS
ZDVPRQWKV UDQJHPRQWKV 7KHV\PSWRPDWRORJ\UHFXUUHQFHUDWH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHWHFKQLFDOIHDVLELOLW\DQGVDIHW\
RIDQHZLQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJLFDOWHFKQLTXHWRFUHDWHDVKXQWEHWZHHQWKHH[WHUQDO
LOLDFYHLQDQGDUWHU\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUH&23'7KHFUHDWLRQRIWKLVÀVWXODDLPV
LPSURYLQJ SXOPRQDU\ R[\JHQDWLRQ UHGXFLQJ V\VWHPLF YDVFXODU UHVLVWDQFH DQG
LQFUHDVLQJFDUGLDFRXWSXWLQWKHVHSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\VHYHQSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVPXOWLFHQWUH
WULDO7ZRSDWLHQWVKDGWREHH[FOXGHGIURPWKHVWXG\EDVHGRQWRRODUJHGLVWDQFH
EHWZHHQWKHLOLDFYHVVHOVRQERWKVLGHV,QSDWLHQWVWKHDUWHU\ZDVSXQFWXUHG
IURP WKH YHLQ ZLWK D QRYHO FURVVLQJ QHHGOH 8VLQJ D VSHFLDO GHOLYHU\ V\VWHP D
QRYHOQLWLQROGHYLFH DQDVWRPRWLFFRXSOLQJV\VWHP52;PHGLFDO ZDVLPSODQWHG
EHWZHHQWKHDUWHU\DQGYHLQWRPDLQWDLQDÀVWXODEHWZHHQERWKYHVVHOV$OOVKXQWV
ZHUHGLODWHGZLWKDPPEDOORRQDQGGRFXPHQWHGE\'6$
5HVXOWV6KXQWLPSODQWDWLRQZDVVXFFHVVIXOLQDOOSDWLHQWV7KHSHUIXVHGDUWHULR
YHQRXVVKXQWVFRXOGEHZHOOGRFXPHQWHGLQ'6$DQGWKHGLDPHWHUZDVPHDVXUHG
EHWZHHQDQGPPLQDOOFDVHV3HULLQWHUYHQWLRQDOGLVVHFWLRQRIWKHLOLDFDUWHU\
RFFXUUHGLQRQHSDWLHQW7KLVGLVVHFWLRQZDVQRWÁRZOLPLWLQJ3RVWLQWHUYHQWLRQDO
YHQRXVEOHHGLQJLQRQHSDWLHQWZDVWUHDWHGVXFFHVVIXOO\E\ORFDOFRPSUHVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHQHZLQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJLFDOWHFKQLTXHWRFUHDWHDQDUWHULR
YHQRXVVKXQWLQWKHLOLDFYHVVHOVSUHVHQWHGLQWKLVVWXG\KDVSURYHQWREHIHDVLEOH
DQGVDIH7KHLQWHQGHGLPSURYHPHQWRISXOPRQDU\R[\JHQDWLRQWRUHGXFHG\VSQRH
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUH&23'KDVWREHHYDOXDWHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGRQHKXQGUHGDQGIRXUWHHQ
FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUVVG ZLWK
LQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPVWUHDWHGLQRXU,QVWLWXWLRQZLWKHQGRYDVFXODUDSSURDFK
EHWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG-XO\(IÀFDF\LQGHSOR\PHQWSURFHGXUHDQGDQJL
RJUDSKLFRXWFRPHVDWIROORZXS LQWHUPVRIFRPSOHWHDQHXU\VPRFFOXVLRQ ZHUH
FRPSDUHGXVLQJ)LVFKHU VH[DFWWHVWEHWZHHQSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKDÁRZGLYHUWHU
GHYLFH 6,/.ÁRZGLYHUWHU 6)' SDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKFRLODQGWKRVHWUHDWHGZLWK
VWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOHPEROLVDWLRQ
5HVXOWV$PRQJDOOFDVHV ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWK6)' ZLWKFRLOLQJ
DQG ZLWKVWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOLQJ(QGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWZDVVXFFHVV
IXOO\SHUIRUPHGLQ DQHXU\VPV6)'FRXOGQRWEHGHOLYHUHGLQ
FDVHVZKLOHFRLOHPEROLVDWLRQIDLOHGLQ FDVHVDQGVWHQWDVVLVWHG
FRLOHPEROLVDWLRQLQFDVH S :HREWDLQHGDFRPSOHWHDQHXU\VP
RFFOXVLRQ LQ DOO FDVHV WUHDWHG ZLWK 6)' DQG QR VLJQLÀFDQW VWDWLVWLFDO GLIIHUHQFH
S! ZDVIRXQGDWPRQWKV PHDQVG DQJLRJUDSKLFIROORZXSEHWZHHQ
WKHWKUHHGLIIHUHQWJURXSV
&RQFOXVLRQ$OWKRXJKVRPHGLIÀFXOWLHVLQGHSOR\PHQWSURFHGXUHLQFRPSDULVRQZLWK
FRLODQGVWHQWDVVLVWHGFRLOHPEROLVDWLRQWKHWUHDWPHQWRILQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPV
ZLWK6)'VHHPVWREHKLJKO\HIÀFDFLRXVDQGHDUO\DQJLRJUDSKLFIROORZXSUHVXOWV
DUHTXLWHHQFRXUDJLQJ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ZDV SDWLHQWV DQGZDVDWWULEXWHGWRVWHQWRFFOXVLRQGXHWRWXPRXULQ
JURZWK VWHQWPLJUDWLRQ DQGEURQFKRVSDVP
7KH HVWLPDWHG SDWLHQWV VXUYLYDO UDWH DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH .DSODQ0H\HU VWDWLVWLFDO
DQDO\VLVZDVXSWR\HDUVRIIROORZXSZKLOHWKHRYHUDOOFRPSOLFDWLRQV
UDWHZDV VWHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7UDFKHREURQFKLDO6(06VSURYLGHVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYHPLQLPDOO\LQYD
VLYHPDQDJHPHQWRISDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPV\PSWRPDWLFPDOLJQDQWDLUZD\GLVHDVH
%
)ROORZXSRIUDGLRORJLFDOO\LQVHUWHG7&9$3RIWKHXSSHUDUPORQJ
WHUPFRPSOLFDWLRQVLQFDWKHWHUGD\V
-'%XVFK)+HOOHU-+HUUPDQQ%36FKRHQQDJHO*$GDP
&5+DEHUPDQQ+DPEXUJ'( MGEXVFK#XNHGH
3XUSRVH 7R UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWH UDGLRORJLFDOO\ SODFHG WRWDOO\ LPSODQWDEOH
FHQWUDO YHQRXV DUP SRUWV 7&9$3 LQ WHUPV RI VDIHW\ WHFKQLFDO IHDVLELOLW\ DQG
GHYLFHUHODWHGFRPSOLFDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH
\HDUV PDOHIHPDOH UDWLR ZKR UHFHLYHG D 7&9$3 EHWZHHQ
-DQXDU\ DQG -XO\ DW RXU XQLYHUVLW\ KRVSLWDO ZHUH LQFOXGHG LQWR WKLV
VWXG\7KHLQVHUWLRQSURFHGXUHZDVSHUIRUPHGLQDQLQWHUYHQWLRQDOUDGLRORJ\VXLWH
7ZRGLIIHUHQWYDVFXODUDFFHVVV\VWHPV 7LWDQLXP9LWDO3RUW0LQL&RRN0HGLFDO
,QF%ORRPLQJWRQ86$ Q 7LWDQLXP9LWDO3RUW3HWLWH&RRN0HGLFDO,QF
%ORRPLQJWRQ 86$ Q ZHUH XVHG 1R DQWLELRWLF SURSK\OD[LV RU ORQJWHUP
DQWLFRDJXODQWPHGLFDWLRQVZHUHURXWLQHO\DGPLQLVWHUHG
5HVXOWV ,Q SDWLHQWV LQ WRWDO GHYLFHV ZHUH LPSODQWHG$OO SURFHGXUHV
ZHUHFRPSOHWHGZLWKRXWPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQVZLWKDSULPDU\WHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVRI
'XULQJIROORZXSDQGDWRWDOQXPEHURIGD\V LQPHDQ
GD\VSHUSDWLHQWUDQJHGD\V RI7&9$3LPSODQWDWLRQSDWLHQWVKDGWR
EHUHYLVHGGXHWRFRPSOLFDWLRQV 7KRVHZHUHREVHUYHGDIWHUDPHDQGXUD
WLRQRIGD\V UDQJHGD\V HDUO\FRPSOLFDWLRQVDQG
ODWHFRPSOLFDWLRQV&RPSOLFDWLRQVZHUHDVIROORZVSDWLHQWV KDG
ORFDOLQIHFWLRQWZRKDGV\VWHPLFLQIHFWLRQ HLJKWSDWLHQWVGHYHORSHGYHQRXV
WKURPERVLV WKUHHKDGSDUDO\VLVRIWKHPHGLDQQHUYH RQHVXIIHUHG
IURPVNLQGHKLVFHQFHDWWKHSRUWVLWH DQGHOHYHQSDWLHQWV UHTXLUHG
UHYLVLRQRZLQJWRPHFKDQLFDOSUREOHPV
&RQFOXVLRQ5DGLRORJLFDOO\LQVHUWHG7&9$3FDQEHVDIHO\XVHGDQGKDVDORZ
FRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHGXULQJIROORZXS
5RRP(
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
66
7XPRXUV
0RGHUDWRUV
*0$OOHQ2[IRUG8.
&YDQ5LMVZLMN/HLGHQ1/
%
'&(05,LQGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRIVRIWWLVVXHPDVVHV
75REED9&OHPHQWL06WUDWWD*5HJLV$*DOOR$/LQDUL53LDQD
&)DOHWWL7XULQ,7%RORJQD,7 WL]LDQDUREED#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH7KHUROHRI'&(05, G\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
LPDJLQJ LQGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVEHWZHHQEHQLJQPDOLJQDQWVRIWWLVVXHPDVVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'XULQJVWDQGDUG05,ZHSHUIRUPHG'&(05,LQVRIW
WLVVXHPDVVXVLQJ')63*5 IDVWVSRLOHGJUDGLHQWUHFDOOHGDFTXLVLWLRQLQVWHDG\
VWDWH PXOWLSKDVHVHTXHQFHV WHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQUDQJLQJIURPVHFWRVHF
DIWHUFRQWUDVWPHGLD0XOWL+DQFHPOV DQGVDOLQH PODWPOV LQMHFWLRQ
7KHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\WLPHFXUYHVZHUHREWDLQHGIURPUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWRQDUWHULDO
DQGYHQRXVYHVVHOVVNHOHWDOPXVFOHDQGWKHDUHDVZLWKKLJKHUDQGHDUOLHVWFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHPHQW:HHYDOXDWHGWKHPRUSKRORJLFDOSDWWHUQVRIVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\WLPH
FXUYHVDQGFRUUHODWHGWKHPZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLVGDWDH[FHSWIRUDQJLRPD
P\RVLWLVRVVLÀFDQVDQGKDHPDWRPD
5HVXOWV:HREWDLQHGIRXUSDWWHUQVRIFXUYHV DQH[SRQHQWLDOFXUYHSDUDOOHOWR
DUWHULDOFXUYHIROORZHGE\DSODWHDXRUDIXUWKHULQFUHDVHRIHQKDQFHPHQWVDUFRPD
DQGP\RVLWLVRVVLÀFDQV JUDGXDOSURJUHVVLRQRIHQKDQFHPHQWZLWKWKHSHDN
EHWZHHQDUWHULDODQGYHQRXVFXUYHIROORZHGE\DSODWHDXVDUFRPD JUDGXDO
SURJUHVVLRQRIHQKDQFHPHQWZLWKWKHSHDNDIWHUWKHYHQRXVFXUYHIROORZHGE\D
IXUWKHULQFUHDVHRIHQKDQFHPHQWVDUFRPDDQGEHQLJQWXPRXUV QHXULQRPD
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
DQJLRPDGHVPRLGWXPRXU QRQHRUHTXDOWRPXVFOHHQKDQFHPHQWEHQLJQ
OHVLRQVOLSRVDUFRPDOLSRPDOLNH
&RQFOXVLRQ,QRXUH[SHULHQFHWKHSUHVHQFHRIDQH[SRQHQWLDOFXUYHSDUDOOHOWR
DUWHULDOLVKLJKO\VXVSLFLRXVIRUPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQZKLOHDQHQKDQFHPHQWHTXDOWR
WKDWRIPXVFOHH[FOXGHVWKHPDOLJQDQF\H[FHSWIRUWKHOLSRVDUFRPDOLSRPDOLNH
'&(05,PD\FRQÀUPWKHGLDJQRVLVRIQHXULQRPD
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJDVDQRQLQYDVLYHSUHGLFWRURIWXPRXU
JUDGLQJLQVRIWWLVVXHVDUFRPD
0&+HUEULN/8PXWOX-.DONPDQQ6%DXHU/3RGOHVND)*UDEHOOXV
*7DHJHU7/DXHQVWHLQ(VVHQ'( PKHUEULN#JP[GH
3XUSRVH7XPRXU JUDGLQJ LV D YDOXDEOH SUHGLFWRU ZLWK UHJDUG WR SURJQRVLV DQG
WKHUDS\ PDQDJHPHQW RI VRIW WLVVXH VDUFRPDV 676 +LVWRSDWKRORJ\ KDV EHHQ
FRQVLGHUHGWKHJROGVWDQGDUGRIWXPRXUJUDGLQJ7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRDV
VHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFSRWHQWLDORIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,DVDQRQLQYDVLYHSUHGLFWRU
RIWXPRXUJUDGLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ676ZHUHHQUROOHG
LQWKLVWULDODQGZHUHH[DPLQHGSULRUWRLVRODWHGOLPESHUIXVLRQ ,/3 RQD7HVOD
VFDQQHU%H\RQGFOLQLFDOO\DSSOLHGVHTXHQFHVDWUDQVYHUVDO(3,':,VHTXHQFH
ZDVFROOHFWHG6HTXHQFHSDUDPHWHUVLQFOXGHG757( PVVOLFHWKLFNQHVV
PPYR[HOVL]HððPPDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHPLQEYDOXHV
$OOPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\DFTXLULQJ$'& DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQW YDOXHVLQWUDQVYHUVDOSODQHE\SRO\JRQDOUHJLRQRILQWHUHVWSODFHPHQW
7KHUHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRKLVWRSDWKRORJLFJUDGLQJRISUHWKHUDSHXWLFVSHFLPHQV
*WR* $'&YDOXHVZHUHFRPSDUHGE\:LOFR[RQVLJQHGUDQNWHVW$SYDOXH
ZDVGHWHUPLQHGWREHVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV$FFRUGLQJWRKLVWRSDWKRORJ\WXPRXUVZHUHUDWHGDV*DQGWXPRXUV
ZHUHUDWHGDV*DQG*HDFK&RUUHODWLRQRIKLVWRSDWKRORJLFJUDGLQJDQG$'&
YDOXHVDOORZHGIRUDVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRI* $'& DQG
*WXPRXUV $'& S +RZHYHUDVVHVVPHQWRI$'&YDOXHVGLGQRW
VKRZDVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRI*WR*RU*WR
*WXPRXUV S!
&RQFOXVLRQ'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJFDQEHDQRQLQYDVLYHSUHGLFWRURIWXPRXU
JUDGLQJIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQ*DQG*VRIWWLVVXHVDUFRPD
%
&RPSDULVRQRIYLDEOHWXPRXUYROXPHVHVWLPDWHGRQG\QDPLF05,
E\FRPSXWHUDLGHGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQWHFKQLTXHZLWKWKHWXPRXUYLDELOLW\
VFRUHVRISDWKRORJ\IROORZLQJH[FLVLRQRIVRIWWLVVXHVDUFRPDҋV
SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\
$.6LQJK9.XUUD</(&KHQ:&DL*1LHOVHQ'+DUPRQ
)-+RUQLFHN%RVWRQ0$86 9.855$#3$571(5625*
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH DFFXUDF\ RI YLDEOH WXPRXU YROXPH HVWLPDWHG XVLQJ
FRPSXWHUDLGHGWHFKQLTXHRQG\QDPLF05,GDWDVHWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVRQJRLQJSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\YLDEOHWXPRXUHVWLPDWHV
REWDLQHGE\SDWKRORJLVWRQVOLFHVRIVRIWWLVVXHVDUFRPDVSHFLPHQVSRVWH[FLVLRQ
ZHUH FRPSDUHG WR WXPRXU YLDELOLW\ YROXPHV HVWLPDWHG E\ FRPSXWHUDLGHG SRVW
SURFHVVLQJRISRVWJDGROLQLXPG\QDPLF7ZHLJKWHGIDWVDWXUDWHG )6 VHTXHQFH
IURP05,GDWDVHWV7KH05,IRUWKHVHSDWLHQWVZDVSHUIRUPHGDIWHUXQGHUJRLQJ
SUHRSHUDWLYHFKHPRWKHUDS\RUUDGLDWLRQWUHDWPHQWDQGZLWKLQGD\VEHIRUH
H[FLVLRQ&RPSXWHUDLGHGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIYLDEOHWXPRXUZDVDLGHGE\HVWLPDWLRQ
RIFRQWUDVWZDVKLQDQGZDVKRXWFXUYHV&DUHZDVWDNHQWRPDWFKWKH05,D[LDO
LPDJHV WR WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ ORFDWLRQV RI FXWVHFWLRQV GXULQJ SDWKRORJ\ WXPRXU
VOLFLQJIRUUHSRUWLQJRIYLDEOHWXPRXUHVWLPDWHWKDWVHUYHGDVVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
3HDUVRQҋVFRUUHODWLRQDQG%ODQG$OWPDQ %$ DQDO\VLVZDVXVHG
5HVXOWV7KHYLDEOHDSSHDULQJWXPRXUYROXPHSHUFHQWDJHGHULYHGIURPG\QDPLF
05,FRQWUDVWDFTXLVLWLRQVZDVZLWKLQVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ 6' >WR@
RIWKH%$SORWLQGLFDWLQJVLPLODULW\WRSDWKRORJLFDOWXPRXUYLDELOLW\HVWLPDWHVDQG
JRRGFRUUHODWLRQ U SFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO WR
7KHUHZHUHQRRXWOLHUVLQWKH%$SORW
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHYLDEOHWXPRXUIUDFWLRQVREWDLQHGE\FRPSXWHUDLGHGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQ
PHWKRGVRQG\QDPLF05,GDWDVHWVIRUVRIWWLVVXHVDUFRPDVKRZVLPLODUUHVXOWVWR
VXUJLFDOSDWKRORJ\HVWLPDWHVRIYLDEOHWXPRXUIUDFWLRQDIWHUH[FLVLRQRIVRIWWLVVXH
VDUFRPD7KHVHÀQGLQJVZDUUDQWYDOLGDWLRQRQDODUJHUFRKRUWRISDWLHQWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
':,LQGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRIHQFKRQGURPDDQGFHQWUDOFKRQGURVDUFRPD
75REED9&OHPHQWL06WUDWWD*5HJLV$*DOOR53LDQD$/LQDUL
9&LFFRQH&)DOHWWL7XULQ,7%RORJQD,7 WL]LDQDUREED#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH7KHUROHRI':, GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ LQGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLV
EHWZHHQHQFKRQGURPDDQGFHQWUDOFKRQGURVDUFRPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSHUIRUPHG':, 1RYHPEHU-XO\ LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKDLQWUDPHGXOODU\FKRQGUDOOHVLRQRIWKHERQH'XULQJVWDQGDUG05,D
VSLQHFKRHFKRSODQDULPDJLQJ EVPP ZDVSHUIRUPHG7KH$'& DSSDU
HQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW FRORULPHWULFPDSZDVPDWFKHGDJDLQVWWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ
D[LDO)5)6(7/DUJHUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWZHUHSORWWHGRQWKHOHVLRQDWOHDVWLQ
WKUHHFRQVHFXWLYHVOLFHV7KHDYHUDJH$'&RIHDFKOHVLRQVZDVFDOFXODWHGDQG
FRUUHODWHGE\$129$ DQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFH WHVWZLWKWKHKLVWRORJLFDOGDWDLQIRXU
,,,JUDGHDQGLQVL[,,,,9JUDGHFKRQGURVDUFRPDWKHGLDJQRVLVZDVKLVWRORJLFDOO\
SURYHQZKLOHLQIRXUHQFKRQGURPDDWR\HDUIROORZXSZDVGRQH
5HVXOWV7KH$129$WHVWVKRZVDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S LQ
$'&V )FULWLFDO) RIWKHWKUHHJURXSVHQFKRQGURPD DYHUDJH$'&
[PPV ,,,JUDGHFKRQGURVDUFRPD DYHUDJH$'&[PPV
DQG,,,,9JUDGHFKRQGURVDUFRPD DYHUDJH$'&[PPV
&RQFOXVLRQ (YHQ LI VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW WKHUH LV RQO\ D VOLJKW GLIIHUHQFH
DPRQJFKRQGURPDDQGFKRQGURVDUFRPD$'&VDQGPDQ\GDWDDUHQHFHVVDU\WR
LQYHVWLJDWHWKHXWLOLW\RI':,LQGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRI,JUDGHFKRQGURVDUFRPD
DQGHQFKRQGURPD
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJIRUWKHUDS\PRQLWRULQJLQ
QHRDGMXYDQWLVRODWHGOLPSSHUIXVLRQWKHUDS\RIVRIWWLVVXHVDUFRPD
0&+HUEULN/8PXWOX-.DONPDQQ6%DXHU)*UDEHOOXV*7DHJHU
7/DXHQVWHLQ(VVHQ'( PKHUEULN#JP[GH
%
05,ZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJDQGDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQW $'& LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIUHVSRQVHWRWUHDWPHQWLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHP\HORPDSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
3$%RQDIÀQL',SSROLWR,0DFFKL)5RVVLQL$'L/HOLR66LURQL0RQ]D,7
SDERQDIÀQL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH DGGHG YDOXH RI$'& LQ WKH HYDOXDWLRQ RI UHVSRQVH WR
FKHPRWKHUDS\ &7 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOHP\HORPD 00
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK00XQGHUZHQW7:%05, $FKLHYD
3KLOLSV IURPYHUWH[WRIHHWEHIRUHDQGDIWHU&7ZLWKWKHIROORZLQJSURWRFROFRURQDO
DQGVDJLWWDOVKRUWWDXLQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\ 67,5 7776(DQGD[LDO':,%6VH
TXHQFHV EIDFWRUPPVHF ':,%6LPDJHVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK7
DQG67,5LPDJHVLQÀYHGLVWULFWV VNXOOVSLQHVWHUQXPDQGULEVSHOYLVXSSHUDQG
ORZHUOLPEV WRHYDOXDWHUHVSRQVHWRWUHDWPHQW52,ZHUHPDQXDOO\GUDZQDORQJ
FRQWRXUVRIWXPRXUVRQ$'&PDSV7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHVRIOHVLRQVDQGSHUFHQW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
'LDJQRVWLFYDOXHRITXDOLWDWLYHDQGTXDQWLWDWLYHGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
05,DQGFKHPLFDOVKLIWLPDJLQJLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIEHQLJQDQG
PDOLJQDQWYHUWHEUDOERG\IUDFWXUHVHYDOXDWLRQLQDSURVSHFWLYH
JURXSRISDWLHQWV
7*HLWK*6FKPLGW$%LIIDU2'LHWULFK+5'XHUU05HLVHU
$%DXU0HOQ\N0XQLFK'( WRELDVJHLWK#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRITXDOLWDWLYHGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
':, TXDQWLWDWLYH':,DQGFKHPLFDOVKLIWLPDJLQJLQDVLQJOHSURVSHFWLYHFRKRUW
RISDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHRVWHRSRURWLFDQGPDOLJQDQWYHUWHEUDOIUDFWXUHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVZLWKRVWHRSRURWLF ZRPHQPHQPHDQ
DJH\HDUV DQGPDOLJQDQWYHUWHEUDOIUDFWXUHV ZRPHQPHQ
PHDQDJH\HDUV 7ZHLJKWHG67,5DQG7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHV
ZHUHDFTXLUHGDW7$GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGVWHDG\VWDWHIUHHSUHFHVVLRQVHTXHQFH
36,) DWGLIIHUHQWGHOWDYDOXHVZDVHYDOXDWHGTXDOLWDWLYHO\$GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
HFKRSODQDU LPDJLQJ (3, DQG GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG VLQJOHVKRW WXUER VSLQ HFKR
VV76( VHTXHQFHDWGLIIHUHQWEYDOXHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGTXDOLWDWLYHO\DQGTXDQWL
WDWLYHO\XVLQJWKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW2SSRVHGSKDVHVHTXHQFHVZHUH
XVHGWRDVVHVVVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\TXDOLWDWLYHO\7KHVLJQDOORVVEHWZHHQLQRSSRVHG
SKDVHLPDJHVZDVGHWHUPLQHGTXDQWLWDWLYHO\7ZRWDLOHG)LVKHUҋVH[DFWDQG0DQQ
:KLWQH\WHVWVDQG52&DQDO\VLVZHUHSHUIRUPHG6HQVLWLYLWLHVVSHFLÀFLWLHVDQG
DFFXUDFLHVZHUHGHWHUPLQHG
5HVXOWV4XDOLWDWLYH':36,)VKRZHGWKHKLJKHVWDFFXUDF\ GHOWD PVVHQVLWLYLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\ 4XDOLWDWLYH':(3,DQG':VV76(LQGL
FDWHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWIUDFWXUHV S!
H[FHSW':(3,DWE VPP S 4XDQWLWDWLYH':(3,DQGTXDOLWDWLYH
RSSRVHGSKDVHLPDJLQJH[KLELWHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV S! TXDQWLWDWLYH
':VV76(DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHFKHPLFDOVKLIWLPDJLQJVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWIUDFWXUHV S
&RQFOXVLRQ':36,) GHOWD PV KDGWKHKLJKHVWDFFXUDF\LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ
EHQLJQ DQG PDOLJQDQW YHUWHEUDO IUDFWXUHV 4XDQWLWDWLYH FKHPLFDOVKLIW LPDJLQJ
DQGTXDQWLWDWLYH':VV76(KDGDORZHUDFFXUDF\LQFRPSDULVRQZLWK':36,)
EHFDXVHRIDODUJHRYHUODS4XDOLWDWLYHO\DVVHVVHGRSSRVHGSKDVH':(3,DQG
':VV76( DQG TXDQWLWDWLYH ':(3, ZHUH QRW VXLWDEOH WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH EHWZHHQ
EHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWYHUWHEUDOIUDFWXUHV
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHJXLGHGIRFXVHGXOWUDVRXQG 05J)86 IRUWKH
WUHDWPHQWRIRVWHRLGRVWHRPD
$1DSROL0$Q]LGHL%&DYDOOR0DULQFROD/0ROLVVR*&DUWRFFL)%RQL
/%HUWDFFLQL91RFH&&DWDODQR5RPH,7 DOHVVDQGURQDSROL#XQLURPDLW
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHVDIHW\DQGHIÀFDF\RIWKH05J
)86DVDQRQLQYDVLYHPHWKRGIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRISDLQFDXVHGE\RVWHRLGRVWHRPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HOHFWHGDQGLQIRUPHGSDWLHQWVZLWKOLPLWHGMRLQWIXQF
WLRQDQGUHGXFHGTXDOLW\RIOLIHGXHWRSDLQIXORVWHRLGOHVLRQFRQÀUPHGDWZRUNXS
05DQG&7H[DPXQGHUZHQW05J)86 ([$EODWH,Q6LJKWHF+DLID,VUDHO
KRXVHGLQWRD705V\VWHP *( &OLQLFDOHYDOXDWLRQZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJYLVXDO
DQDORJXHVFDOH 9$6 (DFKSDWLHQWZDVSODQQHGZLWKDPD[LPXPRIVRQLFDWLRQV
WRFRPSOHWHQLGXVDEODWLRQ&OLQLFDODQGLPDJLQJIROORZXSZDVSHUIRUPHGDQG
PRQWKVDIWHUWUHDWPHQWSDWLHQWVZLWKRVWHRLGOHVLRQXQGHUZHQW05J)86WUHDW
PHQW,QWZRSDWLHQWVZHWUHDWHGDVPDOODQGVXESHULRVWHDOORFDWHGRVWHRPDRQH
SDWLHQWKDGDODUJHUOHVLRQ RVWHREODVWRPD
5HVXOWV$IWHUWUHDWPHQW9$6TXHVWLRQQDLUHVGHPRQVWUDWHGLQWZRSDWLHQWVZLWK
W\SLFDO RVWHRPD WKH FRPSOHWH GLVDSSHDUDQFH RI SDLQIXO V\PSWRPV ZKLOH WKLUG
SDWLHQWUHIHUUHGDQLQLWLDOUHGXFWLRQRISDLQDQGDJUDGXDOUHFXUUHQFHRIV\PSWRPV
7KHUHZHUHQRREVHUYHGWUHDWPHQWUHODWHGFRPSOLFDWLRQVSHULDQGSRVWSURFHGXUH
&RQFOXVLRQ,QRXUH[SHULHQFH05J)86UHSUHVHQWVDVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYHWUHDWPHQW
IRUWKHDEODWLRQRIRVWHRLGRVWHRPD
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH$VVHVVPHQWRIWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHLVDQLQHYLWDEOHDVSHFWRIQHRDGMXYDQW
LVRODWHGOLPSSHUIXVLRQ ,/3 WKHUDS\RIVRIWWLVVXHVDUFRPD 676 0RUSKRORJLF
DVVHVVPHQW E\ PHDQV RI 5(&,67 FULWHULD KDV EHHQ VKRZQ WR SURYLGH OLPLWHG
DFFXUDF\ :H DLPHG WR HYDOXDWH GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ ':, IRU DVVHVV
PHQWRIFDQFHUUHVSRQVHLQFRUUHODWLRQZLWKPRUSKRORJLFDO5(&,67FULWHULDDQG
KLVWRSDWKRORJLFUHJUHVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ676ZHUHHQUROOHG
LQWKLVWULDODQGZHUHH[DPLQHG SULRUDVZHOODV GD\VDQG ZHHNVDIWHU
WKHLQLWLDWLRQRIQHRDGMXYDQW,/305,ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQD7HVODVFDQQHU%H\RQG
FOLQLFDO VHTXHQFHV D WUDQVYHUVDO (3,':, VHTXHQFH ZDV FROOHFWHG 6HTXHQFH
SDUDPHWHUV LQFOXGHG 757( PV VOLFH WKLFNQHVV PP YR[HO VL]H
ððPPDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHPLQEYDOXHV 0RUSKRORJLF
DQDO\VLVZDVDVVHVVHGDFFRUGLQJWR5(&,67FULWHULD)RUIXQFWLRQDODQDO\VLV$'&
YDOXHVDVZHOODV&15 LQFRUUHODWLRQWRKHDOWK\PXVFOHWLVVXH ZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJLFUHJUHVVLRQDIWHUVXUJHU\7KHFKDQJHV
LQ$'&YDOXHVZHUHFRPSDUHGE\:LOFR[RQVLJQHGUDQNWHVW
5HVXOWV$FFRUGLQJWRKLVWRSDWKRORJ\SDWLHQWVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGDVUHVSRQG
HUV:KLOHPRUSKRORJLFDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHGLGQRWVKRZVWDWLVWLFDO
VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJLFUHVSRQVHWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI':,LPDJLQJ
VKRZHGDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHRIPHDQ$'&YDOXHVLQWHUPVRIDUHJUHV
VLRQRIGLIIXVLRQGLVUXSWLRQ&15YDOXHVFRQÀUPHGSRVLWLYHSDWKRORJLFUHVSRQVH
E\PHDQVRIDVLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHXQGHUWKHUDS\
&RQFOXVLRQ':,FDQEHXVHGIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHRI676
DIWHU,/3
DJHYDULDWLRQRI$'& у$'& EHIRUH 05 DQGDIWHU 05 &7ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
DQGFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQUHVSRQGHUVDQGQRQUHVSRQGHUV
5HVXOWV$OOSULPDU\WXPRXUVZHUHFRUUHFWO\GHWHFWHGRQ05,DQGUHVSRQVHWR&7
ZDVHVWDEOLVKHGDVLQWHQVLW\VLJQDOGHFUHDVHRYHUDSHULRGRIWLPHGXULQJIROORZXS
&RPSDUHGWRQRUPDOERQHPDUURZWXPRXUVKRZHGKLJKVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RQ':,
7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHVZHUHRQ05[PPòVHFDQGRQ05
[PPòVHF7KHPHDQSHUFHQWDJHRIWXPRXU$'&FKDQJHVLQUH
VSRQGHUV у ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW S WKDQWKDWLQQRQUHVSRQGHUV
у LQUHODWLRQWRWKHKLJKHUFHOOXODULW\RIQHRSODVWLFERQHPDUURZLQYROYHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ 05 ':, LV D QRQLQYDVLYH WRRO DEOH WR SUHGLFW HDUO\ WKHUDSHXWLF
UHVSRQVHLQSDWLHQWVZLWK00E\GHWHUPLQLQJLQGLYLGXDOFKDQJHVRI$'&YDOXHV
FRUUHVSRQGLQJWRELRORJLFDOFKDQJHVLQWXPRXUWLVVXH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
3DLQSDOOLDWLRQRIERQHPHWDVWDVLVLQLWLDOFOLQLFDOH[SHULHQFHXVLQJ
KLJKLQWHQVLW\IRFXVHGXOWUDVRXQGWKHUDS\ZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
JXLGDQFH
$1DSROL0$Q]LGHL(0DURWWD*%UDFKHWWL*&DUWRFFL)%RQL
/%HUWDFFLQL91RFH&&DWDODQR5RPH,7 DOHVVDQGURQDSROL#XQLURPDLW
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH WKH HIÀFDF\ RI QRQLQYDVLYH KLJKLQWHQVLW\ 05JXLGHG
IRFXVHGXOWUDVRXQG 05J)86 WUHDWPHQWIRUSDOOLDWLRQRIERQHPHWDVWDVLVSDLQLQ
SDWLHQWVQRWFDQGLGDWHGIRUH[WHUQDOEHDPUDGLRWKHUDS\ (%57
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8QGHUWKH,5%DSSURYDOSDWLHQWVZLWKOHVLRQVXQGHU
ZHQW05J)86WUHDWPHQWXVLQJWKH([$EODWHV\VWHP ,Q6LJKWHF 7UHDWPHQWV
ZHUHGRQHLQDVLQJOHVHVVLRQLQDQDPEXODWRU\VHWWLQJSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWSULRU
(%57ZLWKDPHDQPRQWKVUHFXUUHQWSDLQ,QSDWLHQWV05J)86WUHDWPHQWZDV
SHUIRUPHGDVÀUVWWUHDWPHQWPRGDOLW\(IIHFWLYHQHVVRISDLQSDOOLDWLRQZDVHYDOXDWHG
DWIROORZXSXVLQJWKHYLVXDODQDORJSDLQVFRUH 9$6 DQGPHDVXUDEOHFKDQJHVLQ
DQDOJHVLFVLQWDNH)RUWXPRXUFRQWUROSHUIXVLRQ7ZLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGSUH
DQGSRVWWUHDWPHQWLQRUGHUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHQRQSHUIXVHGVRQLFDWLRQUHODWHGDUHD
5HVXOWV$OO SDWLHQWV DQG DOO OHVLRQV ZHUH WUHDWHG 0HDQ IROORZXS WLPH ZDV
PRQWKV$WEDVHOLQH9$6ZDVLWZDVDWGD\VDWWZRZHHNVDQG
DQGDWRQHDQGIRXUPRQWKVUHVSHFWLYHO\1RKHDWLQJUHODWHGDGYHUVHHYHQWZDV
UHFRUGHGGXULQJWKLVFOLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQSDWLHQWPHGLFDWLRQLQWDNHZDVFRQVLGHUDEO\
UHGXFHG9DULDEOHGHJUHHRQQRQSHUIXVHGYROXPHZDVREVHUYHGDIWHUWUHDWPHQW
PDLQO\ZLWKLQWKHSHULFRUWLFDOUHJLRQ'HHSHUSHQHWUDWLRQRIWKHDFRXVWLFHQHUJ\LV
DWSUHVHQWGHVLUDEOHHYHQLIWHFKQLFDOO\GLIÀFXOWWRDFKLHYHZLWKWKHFXUUHQWV\VWHP
&RQFOXVLRQ05J)86LVDSURPLVLQJQRQLQYDVLYHWUHDWPHQWPRGDOLW\IRUVXFFHVV
IXOSDOOLDWLRQRIERQHPHWDVWDVLVSDLQLQSDWLHQWVZKRDUHQRWFDQGLGDWHIRU(%57
%
,WHUDWLYHGHFRPSRVLWLRQRIZDWHUDQGIDWZLWKHFKRDV\PPHWU\DQG
OHDVWVTXDUHVHVWLPDWLRQ ,'($/ IDVWVSLQHFKRLPDJLQJRIWKH
YHUWHEUDOFROXPQPHWDVWDVLVLQLWLDOFOLQLFDOH[SHULHQFH
6/-XYHNDU$0DKDMDQ6'HVDL$3XUL0XPEDL,1 VOMXYHNDU#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRWHVWUHOLDELOLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RILWHUDWLYHGHFRPSRVLWLRQ
RIZDWHUDQGIDWZLWKHFKRDV\PPHWU\DQGWKHOHDVWVTXDUHVHVWLPDWLRQ ,'($/
PHWKRGLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWKIDVWVSLQHFKRLPDJLQJLQGHWHFWLQJYHUWHEUDOPHWDVWDVLV
DQGFRPSDULVRQRI,'($/DQGURXWLQHVHTXHQFHVLQGHWHFWLRQRIWKHPHWDVWDVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HFRPSDUHG,'($/IDVWVSLQHFKRZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO
IDWVXSSUHVVHGIDVWVSLQHFKRLPDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVZKRFDPHIRUPHWDVWDWLFZRUN
XSLQWKHYHUWHEUDOFROXPQ5RXWLQHVSLQHFKRDQG67,5VHTXHQFHVZHUHDFTXLUHG
LQDOOWKHFDVHV(DFKOHVLRQZDVGRFXPHQWHGDVEHQLJQRUPDOLJQDQWEDVHGRQ
WKHURXWLQHVHTXHQFHVDQG,'($/VHTXHQFHDQGDFRUURERUDWLYHGDWDZHUHDOVR
JHQHUDWHG6WDWLVWLFDOFRUUHODWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWVVXEMHFWVGHPRQVWUDWHGEUHDVWPHWDVWDVHVVKRZHGSURVWDWLFPHWDV
WDVLVDQGIURPXQNQRZQSULPDU\DQGRQHKDGDODUJHSUHVXPSWLYHVFKZDQQRPD
VXEMHFWVGHPRQVWUDWHGGHJHQHUDWLYHGLVFGLVHDVHZLWKDVVRFLDWHG0RGLF7\SH,
RU,,FKDQJHVDWRQHRUPRUHOHYHOV,QDOOFDVHVPDUURZVLJQDODEQRUPDOLWLHVFRXOG
EHSDUWLFXODUO\ZHOOFKDUDFWHULVHGZLWK,'($/GHULYHGLPDJHVDQGSDUDPHWULFUDWLR
PDSV0DUURZVLJQDODEQRUPDOLWLHVFRXOGEHSDUWLFXODUO\ZHOOFKDUDFWHULVHGZLWK
,'($/GHULYHGLPDJHVDQGSDUDPHWULFPDSV&RUUHODWLRQRIWKHOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQ
E\ URXWLQH VSLQHFKR VHTXHQFHV DQG ,'($/ VHTXHQFH D VLJQLÀFDQW VWDWLVWLFDO
GLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGLQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIWKHPDUURZVLJQDODEQRUPDOLWLHVDQG
OHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ,'($/VHTXHQFHSURYLGHVUREXVWZDWHUIDWVHSDUDWLRQZLWKRSWLPLVHG
615SHUIRUPDQFH,'($/LPDJLQJLVDSURPLVLQJ05,WHFKQLTXHDIIRUGLQJDUDSLG
DXWRPDWHGKLJKUHVROXWLRQKLJKFRQWUDVWVXUYH\RIWKHHQWLUHVSLQHZLWKRSWLPLVHG
WLVVXHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP(
*,7UDFW
66D
5HFWDODQGJDVWURRHVRSKDJHDOFDQFHU
0RGHUDWRUV
$'LHJXH]%XHQRV$LUHV$5
&.XOLQQD&RVHQWLQL9LHQQD$7
%
1RGDOUHVWDJLQJDIWHUFKHPRUDGLDWLRQIRUORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDO
FDQFHUSUHGLFWLYHIDFWRUV
00DDV'0-/DPEUHJWV0%HUNKRI*/%HHWV5*+%HHWV7DQ
0DDVWULFKW1/ PRQLTXHPDDV#OLYHQO
3XUSRVH5HVWDJLQJ1VWDJHDIWHU&57LVPRUHDFFXUDWHWKDQ1VWDJHSUHGLFWLRQDW
SULPDU\VWDJLQJRIUHFWDOFDQFHU$\S1VWDWXVDIWHU&57LVPDQGDWRU\WRDOORZIRU
OHVVLQYDVLYHWUHDWPHQWDIWHU&57 HJORFDOH[FLVLRQ $LPZDVWRLGHQWLI\SUHGLFWLYH
IDFWRUVZKLFKFDQKHOSDUDGLRORJLVWLQSUHGLFWLQJ\1VWDJH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUSDWLHQWVZLWKORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDOFDQFHUDOO
YLVLEOHQRGHVLQWKHPHVRUHFWXPZHUHPHDVXUHGDQGUHFRUGHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHU
&57RQD'7:*5(VHTXHQFHZLWKPPYR[HOV%DVHOLQHFKDUDFWHULVWLFV
ZHUHFROOHFWHGDQGFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWQRGDOLQYROYHPHQW
DWKLVWRSDWKRORJ\:LWKUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VHVSUHGLFWLYHIDFWRUVIRUQRGDOLQYROYH
PHQWZHUHLGHQWLÀHG52&FXUYHVZHUHFRQVWUXFWHGIRUDSUHGLFWLYHPRGHOEDVHG
RQWKHUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VHV
5HVXOWVQRGHVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGRIZKLFK GLVDSSHDUHGDIWHU&57
3DWLHQWV ZLWK \S1 KDG ODUJHU QRGHV WKDQ \S1SDWLHQWV PHDQ YV PP
EHIRUH&57DQGYVPPDIWHU&57UHVSHFWLYHO\ ERWKS 5HJUHV
VLRQDQDO\VHVLGHQWLÀHGSUHDQGSRVW&57VL]H7GRZQVWDJLQJDQGKLJKHUDJHDV
SUHGLFWLYHIDFWRUVIRU\S1$8&VIRUWKHUHJUHVVLRQEDVHGPRGHOSUH&57VL]H
DQGSRVW&57VL]HZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ 1RGDO VL]H ERWK SUH DQG SRVW&57 7GRZQVWDJLQJ DQG KLJKHU
DJHDWSULPDU\VWDJLQJDUHSUHGLFWRUVRI\S1VWDJH:LWKWKLVNQRZOHGJHDQGE\
XVHRIWKHVHFULWHULDDUDGLRORJLVWFRXOGVHOHFW\1SDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKHUVHQVLWLYLW\
WKDQZKHQVL]HLVXVHGDVDVLQJOHFULWHULRQ:LWKDKLJKHUVHQVLWLYLW\OHVVLQYDVLYH
WUHDWPHQWDIWHU&57FDQEHDSSOLHGPRUHVDIHO\
%
*DGRIRVYHVHWHQKDQFHG05,IRUQRGDOVWDJLQJLQUHFWDOFDQFHU
SLWIDOOVDQGOHDUQLQJFXUYH
/+HLMQHQ'0-/DPEUHJWV*/%HHWV00DDV0+0DUWHQV
9&&DSSHQGLMN)&+%DNHUV5*+%HHWV7DQ0DDVWULFKW1/
GODPEUHJWV#PXPFQO
3XUSRVH 1RGDO VWDJLQJ LQ UHFWDO FDQFHU UHPDLQV LQVXIÀFLHQWO\ DFFXUDWH ,Q D
UHFHQWSLORWVWXG\ZHKDYHVKRZQLPSURYHGSHUIRUPDQFHLQH[SHUWKDQGVXVLQJ
JDGRIRVYHVHWHQKDQFHG 05, VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ )RU WKH FXUUHQW
VWXG\JDGRIRVYHVHW05,ZDVLPSOHPHQWHGLQFOLQLFV DVSDUWRIRQJRLQJUHVHDUFK
DQGDVVHVVHGE\ҊQRQH[SHUWҋDEGRPLQDOUDGLRORJLVWV$LPZDVWRLGHQWLI\WKHSLWIDOOV
RIJDGRIRVYHVHW05,IRUQRGDOVWDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWVWDQGDUG 7:)6( DQGJDGR
IRVYHVHW05,7UHDWPHQWSODQQLQJZDVEDVHGRQ7:05,SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
[*\ LPPHGLDWHVXUJHU\XQGHUZHQWFKHPRUDGLDWLRQDUHVWDJLQJ05,
DQG VXUJHU\ 3DWLHQWV ZHUH VFRUHG DV F11 EDVHG RQ WKH SUHVHQFHDEVHQFH
RIQRGDOJDGRIRVYHVHWHQKDQFHPHQWRQWKHSUHVXUJLFDO05,+LVWRORJ\ZDVWKH
JROGVWDQGDUG ,Q FDVH RI )3)1 ÀQGLQJV QRGHV ZHUH UHHYDOXDWHG E\ D SHOYLF
05H[SHUWRQDSHUQRGHEDVLVDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKKLVWRORJ\WRLGHQWLI\WKHSLWIDOOV
5HVXOWV SDWLHQWV ZHUH S1 S1 7KLUW\WUHH ZHUH FRUUHFWO\ VWDJHG RQ
JDGRIRVYHVHW05, VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\ S1SDWLHQWVZHUHXQGHU
VWDJHGS1ZHUHRYHUVWDJHG)1ÀQGLQJVZHUHGXHWR1QRGHREVFXUHGE\
DGMDFHQWYHVVHO Q PLFURVFRSLFWXPRXUFHOOVWRRVPDOOWRGHWHFWZLWK05, Q
)3ÀQGLQJVZHUHGXHWRGHFUHDVHGJDGRIRVYHVHWXSWDNHLQSUHVDFUDOSHULYDVFXODU
QRGHV Q LQWHUSUHWDWLRQHUURUVWKDWZHUHFRUUHFWHGDIWHUUHHYDOXDWLRQE\WKH
H[SHUW Q DQGDEVHQFHRIJDGRIRVYHVHWXSWDNHHFL Q
&RQFOXVLRQ 3LWIDOOV PDLQO\ RFFXU GXH WR UHDGHUVҋ LQH[SHULHQFH DQG LQVXIÀFLHQW
XSWDNHRIJDGRIRVYHVHWLQQRGHVORFDWHGEHWZHHQYHVVHOV KLJKLQWKHPHVRUHF
WXP *DGRIRVYHVHW05,FDQLPSURYHUDGLRORJLVWVҋSHUIRUPDQFHIRUQRGDOVWDJLQJ
8QGHUVWDQGLQJ WKH SLWIDOOV DQG OHDUQLQJ FXUYH LV FUXFLDO WR DOORZ EURDG FOLQLFDO
LPSOHPHQWDWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
':05DQG'&(05HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHUHVSRQVHLQUHFWDOFDQFHU
EHIRUHGXULQJDQGDIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWWUHDWPHQW
5'HO9HVFRYR9'L3DROD6%DWWLVWL,6DQVRQL5*UDVVR
%%HRPRQWH=REHO5RPH,7 UGHOYHVFRYR#XQLFDPSXVLW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUHVSRQVHRIUHFWDODGHQRFDUFLQRPDWRFKHPRUDGLDWLRQ
WKHUDS\ &57 FDOFXODWLQJFKDQJHVRIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV $'&V EHIRUH
GXULQJDQGDIWHUWUHDWPHQWDQGWRFRUUHODWHZLWKWKHFKDQJHVRIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG05 '&(05 YDOXHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVZHHQUROOHGSDWLHQWV SWV ZLWKSULPDU\UHFWDOFDUFLQRPD
ZKRZHUHXQGHUJRLQJSUHRSHUDWLYH&57':,DQG'&(05ZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKD
7V\VWHPLQDOOSDWLHQWVEHIRUHGXULQJDQGDIWHUSUHRSHUDWLYH&57$OOSDWLHQWV
XQGHUZHQW KLVWRSDWKRORJLF SRVWRSHUDWLYH VWDJLQJ$'&V YDOXHV ZHUH FDOFXODWHG
WKURXJKWKHVSHFLÀFIRUPXODZKLOHWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQZDVFDOFXODWHGE\DVHPL
TXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQVRIWZDUH '<&+2 GHYHORSHGRQ0DWODE:HHYDOXDWHGWKH
FKDQJHVRI$'&VDQG'&(05GLYLGLQJSDWLHQWVLQWRWZRJURXSVQRWGRZQVWDJHG
JURXS 15 DQGGRZQVWDJHGJURXS 5 DWKLVWRORJLFSRVWRSHUDWLYHVWDJLQJ
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUH15ZKLOHSDWLHQWVZHUH53UHWUHDWPHQW$'&VYDOXHV
ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZZHREVHUYHGDSURJUHVVLYHLQFUHDVLQJRI$'&VYDOXHVGXU
LQJWUHDWPHQWLQ5ZKLOHWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQW$'&VLQFUHDVHLQWKH15 S
7KHPHDQYDOXHVRIWXPRXU$'&VFKDQJHLQWKH5ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
WKDQWKDWLQWKH15DWHDFKWLPHSRLQW S 7KH5VKRZHGLQFUHDVHRI
ORFDOSHDNLQWHQVLW\ /3, ZLWKUHVSHFWWR/3,EHIRUHWUHDWPHQWRQRSSRVLWHWKH15
VKRZHGGHFUHDVHRI/3,FRPSDUHGWR/3,EHIRUHWUHDWPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ7XPRXUUHVSRQVHPRUHOLNHO\RFFXUVLQSWVZKRUHSRUWKLJKHU/3,
YDOXHVRQ'&(05DQDO\VLVGXULQJWUHDWPHQWZLWKUHVSHFWWRSUHWUHDWPHQW
%
6WDQGDUGLVHGLQGH[RIVKDSH 6,6 DQRYHOVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH
'&(05,SDUDPHWHUEDVHGRQSDWWHUQDQDO\VLV 3$ DEOHWRGLYLGH
UHVSRQGHU 5 E\QRWUHVSRQGHU 15 DIWHUSUHRSHUDWLYHUDGLRFKHPR
WKHUDS\ S&57 LQORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDOFDQFHU /$5&
5)XVFR03HWULOOR66HWROD06DQVRQH$5RWRQGR$3HWULOOR1DSOHV,7
UREHUWDIXVFR#XQLQDLW
%
5HSURGXFLELOLW\RI'DQG'IUDFWDODQDO\VLVWHFKQLTXHVIRUWKH
DVVHVVPHQWRIVSDWLDOSDWWHUQRISHUIXVLRQ&7UHJLRQDOEORRGÁRZLQ
UHFWDOFDQFHU
9-*RK'%DQHUMHH%6DQJKHUD$.KDQ,6LPFRFN-6WLUOLQJ
5*O\QQH-RQHV/RQGRQ8.1RUWKZRRG8.
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHUHSURGXFLELOLW\RI'DQG'IUDFWDODQDO\VLVWHFKQLTXHV
IRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIVSDWLDOSDWWHUQRISHUIXVLRQ&7UHJLRQDOEORRGÁRZLQUHFWDO
FDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)ROORZLQJLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYDODQGLQIRUPHG
FRQVHQWSURVSHFWLYHSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV ZLWK
UHFWDODGHQRFDUFLQRPDXQGHUZHQWWZRUHSHDWHGYROXPHWULFKHOLFDOSHUIXVLRQ&7
VWXGLHV 'DGDSWLYHVSLUDOFP]D[LVFRYHUDJHGXDOVRXUFH&76LHPHQV
+HDOWKFDUH ZLWKRXWLQWHUYHQLQJWUHDWPHQWZLWKLQKRXUVGHULYLQJUHJLRQDOEORRG
ÁRZE\GHFRQYROXWLRQDQDO\VLV 93&76LHPHQV+HDOWKFDUH 'DQG'IUDFWDO
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
$FFXUDWHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIFRPSOHWHUHVSRQGHUVDIWHU&57IRUUHFWDO
FDQFHUZLWKHQGRVFRS\DQG05,
00DDV'0-/DPEUHJWV-:$/HLMWHQV06RVHI.:(+XOVHZH
*/%HHWV5*+%HHWV7DQ0DDVWULFKW1/5RHUPRQG1/+HHUOHQ1/
6LWWDUG1/ PRQLTXHPDDV#OLYHQO
3XUSRVH &KHPRUDGLDWLRQ &57 IRU UHFWDO FDQFHU OHDGV WR FRPSOHWH WXPRXU
UHVSRQVH &5 LQ$FFXUDWHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRID&5LVQHFHVVDU\WRDOORZ
IRUOHVVLQYDVLYHWUHDWPHQW HJORFDOH[FLVLRQRUZDLWDQGVHH 6WDQGDUGLPDJLQJ
FDQQRWDFFXUDWHO\LGHQWLI\D&5$LPZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHDFFXUDF\RIHQGRVFRS\
IRULGHQWLÀFDWLRQRID&5DQGFRPSDUHLWWR7:DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, ':,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQW&57DQG7:05,':,DQG
HQGRVFRS\ZHHNVDIWHUFRPSOHWLRQRI&57ZHUHLQFOXGHG2QHUHDGHUVFRUHGWKH
7:LPDJHVIROORZHGE\LPPHGLDWHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH':,LPDJHVZLWKWKH7:
LPDJHVDWKLVGLVSRVDO$VHFRQGUHDGHUVFRUHGWKHHQGRVFRS\LPDJHV5HDGHUV
ZHUHEOLQGHGIRUKLVWRORJ\DQGHDFKRWKHUVҋUHVXOWV6FRULQJZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKD
FRQÀGHQFHOHYHOVFRUH GHÀQLWHO\UHVLGXDOWXPRXU GHÀQLWHO\&5
5HVXOWV2IWKHSDWLHQWVKDGUHVLGXDOWXPRXUDQGKDGD&57KH$8&V
IRU 7:05, 7':, DQG HQGRVFRS\ ZHUH DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RUUHVSRQGLQJ VHQVLWLYLWLHV DQG VSHFLÀFLWLHV ZHUH DQG IRU7:
DQGIRU7':,DQGDQGIRUHQGRVFRS\
&RQFOXVLRQ (QGRVFRS\ LV PRUH DFFXUDWH LQ LGHQWLI\LQJ D &5 DIWHU &57 WKDQ
05, ':, PDLQO\EHFDXVHRIDKLJKHUVHQVLWLYLW\ZKLFKFRUUHFWVIRUWKHXQGHU
VWDJLQJRID&5ZLWK05,05,UHPDLQVFUXFLDOWRHYDOXDWHWKHSUHVHQFHRIDQ\
H[WUDPXUDOUHVLGXDOWXPRXUDQGRULQYROYHGQRGHV$FRPELQDWLRQRIHQGRVFRS\
DQG05,':,LVWKHUHIRUHUHFRPPHQGDEOHWRLGHQWLI\SDWLHQWVZLWKD&5DIWHU&57
PDNLQJOHVVLQYDVLYHWUHDWPHQWDIWHU&57IHDVLEOH
%
3UHRSHUDWLYHORFRUHJLRQDO 7DQG1 VWDJLQJRIJDVWURHVRSKDJHDO
FDQFHUV *(& FRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
05 LQFOXGLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHV ':, FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ &7 HQGRVFRSLFXOWUDVRXQG (86
)*LJDQWL)'H&REHOOL0&HOOLQD51LFROHWWL&0DUWLQHQJKL3$UFLGLDFRQR
(2UVHQLJR&6WDXGDFKHU$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,7 JLJDQWLIUDQFHVFR#KVULW
3XUSRVH3UHRSHUDWLYH*(&FDQFHUVVWDJLQJLVZLGHO\SHUIRUPHGZLWK&7DQG(86
05KDVOLPLWDWLRQV PRWLRQDUWHIDFWVORQJDFTXLVLWLRQWLPH SDUWLDOO\RYHUFRPHE\
WHFKQRORJLFDOGHYHORSPHQW:HHYDOXDWHGWKHXVHIXOQHVVRI05LQFOXGHG':,
FRPSDUHGZLWK&7DQG(86
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 'XULQJ D PRQWK SHULRG SDWLHQWV ZLWK *(&
RHVRSKDJHDOFDUGLDOJDVWULF XQGHUZHQWSUHRSHUDWLYH(86PXOWLGHWHFWRU
FKDQQHOV&7DQG705LQFOXGLQJ':, EVPP $OOWKHLPDJHVZHUH
DQDO\VHGLQEOLQGDQGWKHUHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVDIWHU
UHVHFWLRQDVVXPLQJ77DVRUJDQFRQÀQHG*(&DQG77DVLQÀOWUDWLQJ*(&
/\PSKQRGHVZHUHVWDJHGDVQHJDWLYH 1 RUSRVLWLYH 1 6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\
SRVLWLYH 339 DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\339139FDOFXODWHGIRU7ZHUHIRU05
ZKLOHIRU&7DQGIRU(86
IRU1VWDWXVIRU05IRU&7IRU(86
0HDQDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWRISULPDU\WXPRXUVZDV
[PPVRIO\PSKQRGHVZDV[PPV
&RQFOXVLRQ(86LVVOLJKWO\VXSHULRUWR&7DQG05IRU7VWDJHZKLOHUHJDUGLQJ
1VWDJH05UHVXOWVDUHVXSHULRUWRERWK&7DQG(86WKDQNVWRWKHDGGLWLRQRI
':,:HFDQFRQFOXGHWKDW05FDQEHDYDOLGGLDJQRVWLFWRROLIXVHGLQVWDQGDUG
SURWRFROVLQWKHVWDJLQJRIRHVRSKDJHDODQGJDVWULFQHRSODVPV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH05,LVFRQVLGHUHGWKHEHVWDYDLODEOHWRROIRU/$5&VWDJLQJDIWHUS&57
DOWKRXJKLQPRVWFDVHVWRWXPRXUUHVSRQVHGRHVQRWFRUUHVSRQGDVL]HUHGXFWLRQ
7RLGHQWLI\D'&(05,LQGH[EDVHGRQ3$ZKLFKFRXOGGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQUH
VSRQGHUV 575*RU75* DQGQRWUHVSRQGHUV 1575*RU75* DIWHUS&57
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW'&(05,H[DPLQDWLRQEHIRUHDQG
DIWHUS&573UHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVW7ZVFDQVZHUHDFTXLUHGDIWHU*G'27$LQMHF
WLRQ5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUHGUDZQLQVLGHWKHWXPRXUDQGDIWHUWLPHLQWHQVLW\
FXUYHV 7,& ZHUHSORWWHG%DVLQJRQ3$VKDSHGHVFULSWRUVZHUHFRPSXWHGDQG
LQGLYLGXDOSHUFHQWDJHFKDQJHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV 3HUIRUPLQJ .UXVNDO :DOOLV DQG :LOFR[RQ WHVW IRU SHUFHQWDJH FKDQJH
EHIRUHDQGDIWHUS&57LQUHVSRQGHUVPD[LPXPVORSHGHYLDWLRQ 06' ZDVKLQ
VORSHZDVKRXWLQWHUFHSWDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& $8&ZDVKRXW $8&:2
DQGKHLJKWVUDWLR +5 VKRZHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV 3 $F
FRUGLQJWRWKHKRWHOOLQJWUDFHFULWHULRQ +7& у06' у$8&:2PDWFKSURYLGHG
WKHEHVWUHVXOWVDQGDFXWRIIYDOXHFKDQJHRIGLYLGHG5IURP15ZLWK6(1
RI63(RI139RIDQG339RI
&RQFOXVLRQу06' у$8&:2PDWFKGHÀQHG´VWDQGDUGLVHGLQGH[RIVKDSHµ
6,6 VHHPVWREHDSURPLVLQJVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHQXPHULFDOSDUDPHWHUFDSDEOHWR
HYDOXDWH UHVLGXDO WXPRXU DFWLYLW\ DIWHU S&57 LQ /$5& GHÀQLQJ D UREXVW FXWRII
YDOXHRIWRVHSDUDWH5E\15
DQDO\VLVRIWKHUHFWDOWXPRXUZHUHSHUIRUPHGIROORZLQJVHJPHQWDWLRQIURPVXUURXQG
LQJVWUXFWXUHVE\WKUHVKROGLQJGHULYLQJIUDFWDOGLPHQVLRQ )' DQGIUDFWDODEXQGDQFH
)$ 'DQG'IUDFWDOSDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRPSDUHGE\WWHVWLQJ5HSURGXFLELOLW\ZDV
DVVHVVHGE\%ODQG$OWPDQVWDWLVWLFV6WDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHZDVDW
5HVXOWV0HDQ 6' EORRGÁRZZDV P/PLQP/)UDFWDOGLPHQVLRQ
DQGIUDFWDODEXQGDQFHZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRU'WKDQ'DQDO\VLVYHUVXV
S DQGYHUVXVS UHVSHFWLYHO\*RRGDJUHH
PHQWZDVQRWHGEHWZHHQWKHUHSHDWHGVWXGLHVIRUIUDFWDOGLPHQVLRQ PHDQGLIIHUHQFH
OLPLWVRIDJUHHPHQW WR DQG WR
DQGIUDFWDODEXQGDQFHPHDQGLIIHUHQFH OLPLWVRIDJUHHPHQW WR
DQG WR IRU'DQG'IUDFWDODQDO\VLVUHVSHFWLYHO\
7KHOLPLWVRIDJUHHPHQWZHUHQDUURZHUIRU'WKDQ'DQDO\VLV
&RQFOXVLRQ$VDPHDVXUHRIVSDWLDOKHWHURJHQHLW\IUDFWDODQDO\VLVFRPSOHPHQWV
SHUIXVLRQ&7DQGLVDUHSURGXFLEOHWHFKQLTXH
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
$SSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& PRGLÀFDWLRQVLQDVVHVVLQJ
JDVWURHVRSKDJHDOFDQFHU *(& UHVSRQVHWRQHRDGMXYDQWWUHDWPHQW
17 FRPSDULVRQWRWXPRXUUHJUHVVLRQJUDGH 75* DWKLVWRORJ\
0&HOOLQD)'H&REHOOL)*LJDQWL/$OEDUHOOR(2UVHQLJR'&KLDUL
$(VSRVLWR&6WDXGDFKHU$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,7 FHOOLQDPLFKDHOD#KVULW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHZKHWKHUPRGLÀFDWLRQVLQWKH$'&EHIRUHDQGDIWHU17 у
$'& IRUORFDOO\DGYDQFHG*(&DUHUHODWHGWR75*DQREMHFWLYHKLVWRORJLFDOSD
UDPHWHURIWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHVFRULQJWKHUHVLGXDOQHRSODVWLFLQJUDGHVREWDLQHG
DIWHUUDGLFDOUHVHFWLRQSUHGLFWRUIRUGLVHDVHIUHHVXUYLYDO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\DELRSV\SURYHGORFDOO\DGYDQFHG
(*&XQGHUZHQW7GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJSUHDQGSRVW170HDQOHVLRQ
$'&VOHVLRQYROXPHV 9 у$'&9FKDQJHVSUHDQGSRVW17 у9 ZHUHFDOFX
ODWHG3DWLHQWVZLWK75*ZHUHFRQVLGHUHGUHVSRQGHUV 5 SDWLHQWVZLWK75*
QRQUHVSRQGHU 15
5HVXOWV 1R FRUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ у9 DQG75* 5 ZDV IRXQG7KH GLI
IHUHQFH LQ у9 EHWZHHQ WKH WZR JURXSV ZDV QRW VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQW
3 $IWHU 17 SDWLHQWV VKRZHG DQ LQFUHDVH LQ$'& YDOXHV
SDWLHQWV GLGQRWVKRZVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHVSDWLHQWV VKRZHG
GHFUHDVLQJ$'&YDOXHV$'&VFKDQJHVVKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWLQYHUVHFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKUHVSRQVHWR17 U 5VKRZHGDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWORZHUSUH17
$'& [PPV WKDQ15 [PPV 3 DQG
KLJKHUSRVW17$'& [PPVYV[PPV 3
у$'& ZDV VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW KLJKHU IRU 5 WKDQ IRU 15 YV
3
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHRQO\GLPHQVLRQDOFULWHULDу9LVQRWDJRRGLQGLFDWRURIUHVSRQVH
$'&FDQEHFRQVLGHUHGDSUHGLFWRURIWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHHYHQEHIRUHWKHEHJLQ
QLQJRI17у$'&FDQEHXVHGWRDVVHVVWXPRXUUHVSRQVHWR17DVDUHOLDEOH
LQGLFDWRURIWKH75*FODVVLÀFDWLRQ
%
3(7JXLGHGSURJQRVLVDSURPLVLQJUROHRIPHWDEROLFLPDJLQJLQ
RHVRSKDJHDOFDQFHU
/(YDQJHOLVWD$5&HUYLQR5$OÀHUL&&DVWRUR3&0X]]LR)3RPHUUL
3DGXD,7 ODXUDHYDQJHOLVWD#LRYHQHWRLW
3XUSRVH7R HYDOXDWH WKH SURJQRVWLF YDOXH RI )'*3(7&7 DIWHU QHRDGMXYDQW
WKHUDS\LQORFDOO\DGYDQFHGRHVRSKDJHDOFDQFHU (& SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$PRQJ (& SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW )'*3(7
&7 DIWHU QHRDGMXYDQW WUHDWPHQW ZH VHOHFWHG SDWLHQWV ZLWKRXW HYLGHQFH RU
VXVSLFLRXVIRUGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVHV$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHGIRUDPHDQSHULRGRI
PRQWKVIURPQXFOHDULPDJLQJ3(7&7ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKSDWLHQW
PDQDJHPHQWDQGORQJWHUPSURJQRVLV&KLVTXDUHWHVWZDVXVHGIRUFRPSDULVRQ
RI FDWHJRULFDO YDULDEOHV DQG W6WXGHQW WHVW IRU FRQWLQXRXV GDWD 6XUYLYDO FXUYHV
ZHUHFRPSXWHGXVLQJ.DSODQ0HLHUPHWKRG$SYDOXHRIZDVFRQVLGHUHG
VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV SDWLHQWV KDG QHJDWLYH DQG SRVLWLYH YV 3(7&7 DIWHU
QHRDGMXYDQW WKHUDS\ SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW UDGLFDOLQWHQW VXUJHU\ DQG
GLGQRWZKHUHDVSHUIRUPHGVXUJHU\DQGGLGQRW S $IWHUD
PHGLDQWLPHRIPRQWKVSDWLHQWVZHUHGLVHDVHIUHHUHODSVHGDQGGLHG
7KHHYHQWIUHHVXUYLYDOZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQSDWLHQWVZLWKQHJDWLYHWKDQZLWK
SRVLWLYH 3(7&7 DIWHU QHRDGMXYDQW WUHDWPHQW YV ORJ UDQN S
&RQVLGHULQJSDWLHQWVZLWKSRVLWLYH3(7&7LQQRQVXUJHU\VXEVHWRQO\SDWLHQW
ZDVDOLYHZLWKRXWHYLGHQFHRIGLVHDVHZKLOHLQVXUJHU\VXEVHWSDWLHQWVZHUH
GLVHDVHIUHH YVS
&RQFOXVLRQ3(7&7FRXOGVWUDWLI\WKHUHFXUUHQFHULVNRI(&SDWLHQWVEDVHGRQ
WUHDWPHQWHIÀFDF\$IWHUPRQWKVIURP3(7&7RISDWLHQWVZLWKQHJDWLYH
3(7&7ZKRGLGQRWXQGHUJRVXUJHU\UHVXOWHGGLVHDVHIUHH$SRVLWLYH3(7&7
DIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWWKHUDS\VKRXOGEHIROORZHGE\VXUJHU\IRULPSURYLQJWKHHYHQW
IUHHVXUYLYDO
%
6SHFWUDOSUHVDWXUDWLRQLQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\05LPDJLQJVHTXHQFH
DIWHUJDGROLQLXPLQMHFWLRQWRLGHQWLI\PHVRUHFWDOIDVFLDLQÀOWUDWLRQ
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHFWDOFDUFLQRPDDIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRDQG
UDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\
(4XDLD98OFLJUDL/'H3DROL%&DELEER(3DQWDQR0&RYD7ULHVWH,7
TXDLD#XQLWVLW
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIVSHFWUDOSUHVDWXUDWLRQLQYHUVLRQ
UHFRYHU\ 63,5 05LPDJLQJVHTXHQFHDIWHUJDGROLQLXPLQMHFWLRQWRLGHQWLI\PHV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
RUHFWDOIDVFLDLQÀOWUDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHFWDOFDUFLQRPDXQGHUJRLQJ05UHVWDJLQJ
DIWHUQHRDGMXYDQWFKHPRDQGUDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\ &57
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIW\ÀYHFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUV
UDQJH\HDUV0) ZLWKORFDOO\DGYDQFHGUHFWDOFDUFLQRPDLQYROY
LQJWKHKLJKHUPLGGOHRUORZHUUHFWXPXQGHUZHQW&57IROORZHGE\VXUJHU\05
LPDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGEHIRUHDQGDIWHUFRPSOHWLRQRI&57XVLQJ7ZHLJKWHG
IDVW VSLQHFKR DQG 7ZHLJKWHG 63,5 VHTXHQFHV EHIRUH DQG DIWHU JDGROLQLXP
LQMHFWLRQDQG05LPDJHVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXV7KH
HYLGHQFHRIUHWLFXODU LQWHUZRYHQZLWKLQWKHPHVRUHFWDOIDWFUHDWLQJDPHVKZRUN RU
OLQHDUVKDSHG WUDYHOOLQJVHSDUDWHO\WKURXJKWKHPHVRUHFWDOIDW HQKDQFLQJVWUDQGV
ZLWKLQWKHPHVRUHFWDOIDWRQ05LPDJHVZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKWKH
KLVWRSDWKRORJLFÀQGLQJV
5HVXOWV$IWHU&57WKHGLVHDVHZDVHLWKHUOLPLWHGWRWKHUHFWDOZDOO Q SDWLHQWV
RUSUHVHQWHGPHVRUHFWDOIDWLQÀOWUDWLRQ Q RQKLVWRORJ\,QSDWLHQWVUHWLFXODU
RUOLQHDUVKDSHGPHVRUHFWDOHQKDQFLQJVWUDQGVZHUHREVHUYHG,QSDWLHQWVWKH
UHWLFXODUVKDSHGHQKDQFLQJVWUDQGVUHDFKHGWKHPHVRUHFWDOIDVFLDDQGDSRVLWLYH
FLUFXPIHUHQWLDOUHVHFWLRQPDUJLQDIWHUWRWDOPHVRUHFWDOH[FLVLRQZDVIRXQGRQWKH
KLVWRORJLFDQDO\VLV 25 &,VORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQ ZKHUHDV
OLQHDUVKDSHGHQKDQFLQJVWUDQGVHLWKHUUHDFKLQJRUQRWUHDFKLQJWKHPHVRUHFWDO
IDVFLDUHYHDOHGQRFRUUHODWLRQZLWKPHVRUHFWDOIDVFLDLQÀOWUDWLRQ 25RU
&,V
&RQFOXVLRQ5HWLFXODUVKDSHGHQKDQFLQJVWUDQGVUHDFKLQJWKHPHVRUHFWDOIDVFLD
ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHODWHGWRPHVRUHFWDOIDVFLDLQÀOWUDWLRQ
5RRP)
*HQLWRXULQDU\
66
$GUHQDODQGNLGQH\LPDJLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
05DPDOKR$OPDGD37
'+06]RODU*UD]$7
%
(YLGHQFHEDVHGPHGLFLQHGHFLVLRQPDNLQJRQUHQDOOHVLRQVEDVHG
RQPHWDDQDO\VLVRI05GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
(/DVVHO55DR&6FKZHQNH626FK|QEHUJ+-0LFKDHO\
0DQQKHLP'(*DOYHVWRQ7;86%HUOLQ'(
3XUSRVH&RPPRQO\SHUIRUPHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,FDQRQO\GLVWLQJXLVKWRD
OLPLWHGH[WHQWEHWZHHQPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQIRFDOUHQDOOHVLRQV7KHDLPRIWKLV
PHWDDQDO\VLVLVWRUHYLHZUHQDOGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJWRFRPSDUH$'&YDOXHV
IRUGLIIHUHQWUHQDOOHVLRQVZKLFKFDQEHDSSOLHGLQFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VHDUFKRQ3XE0HGZDVSHUIRUPHGWRLGHQWLI\UHOHYDQW
DUWLFOHVSXEOLVKHGRQUHQDO':,RIIRFDOUHQDOOHVLRQVEHWZHHQDQGE\
WZRLQGHSHQGHQWUHYLHZHUV7KHVHUHYLHZHUVH[WUDFWHGWKH$'&YDOXHVIURPWKH
VHOHFWHGVWXGLHVE\OHVLRQW\SHWRGHWHUPLQHWKHGLJQLW\RIDOHVLRQZLWKLQWKHNLGQH\
7KHGDWDWDEOHZDVÀQDOLVHGLQDFRQVHQVXVUHDG7KH$'&YDOXHVZHUHHYDOXDWHG
VWDWLVWLFDOO\E\DPHWDUHJUHVVLRQEDVHGRQDOLQHDUPL[HGPRGHO$WZRVLGHGS
YDOXHRIOHVVWKDQLQGLFDWHGVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFH
5HVXOWV7KHPHWDDQDO\VLVLVEDVHGRQVWXGLHVZLWKDFXPXODWLYHQXPEHURI
SDWLHQWV5HQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPDVKDYHVLJQLÀFDQWORZHU$'&YDOXHVWKDQEHQLJQ
WLVVXH VPPYVVPPSYDOXH 8URHSLWKHOLDO
PDOLJQDQFLHVFDQEHGLIIHUHQWLDWHGE\ORZHVW$'&YDOXHV VPPS
YDOXH 7KHUHLVDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKH$'&YDOXHV
RIUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPDVDQGRQFRF\WRPDV VPPYHUVXV
VPPSYDOXH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHHYDOXDWLRQRI$'&YDOXHVFDQKHOSWRGHWHUPLQHEHWZHHQEHQLJQ
DQGPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVLQJHQHUDOEXWDOVRVHHPVDEOHWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHRQFRF\WRPDV
IURPPDOLJQDQWWXPRXUVKHQFHSRWHQWLDOO\UHGXFLQJWKHQXPEHURIXQQHFHVVDULO\
SHUIRUPHGQHSKUHFWRPLHV
%
&RPSDULVRQRIPLQXWHGHOD\HGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7DQG
FKHPLFDOVKLIW05LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIDGUHQDOPDVVHV
+-.RR+-&KRL0+.LP.6&KR6HRXO.5 HOÀQ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIGHOD\HGHQ
KDQFHGFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7 DQGFKHPLFDOVKLIWPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05
LPDJLQJIRUHYDOXDWLQJDGUHQDOPDVVHV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVPLQXWHGHOD\HGDGUHQDOSURWRFRO&7 XQHQKDQFHG
VHFRQGDQGPLQXWHGHOD\HG&7 RUFKHPLFDOVKLIW05LPDJHVIRUDGUHQDO
PDVVHVLQSDWLHQWVZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGIRUWKHSHULRGIURP-DQXDU\
WKURXJK$XJXVWK\SHUDWWHQXDWLQJDGUHQDOPDVVHV !+8 RQ
XQHQKDQFHG&7LPDJHVLQSDWLHQWV PHQDQGZRPHQPHDQDJH
\HDUV DQDO\VHGXVLQJDEVROXWHSHUFHQWDJHZDVKRXW $3: DQGUHODWLYHSHUFHQWDJH
ZDVKRXW 53: IRUHYDOXDWLQJ&7DQGK\SHUDWWHQXDWLQJDGUHQDOPDVVHVZHUH
DQDO\VHGZLWKFKHPLFDOVKLIW05E\FDOFXODWLQJDGUHQDOWRVSOHHQUDWLR $65 DQG
VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQGH[ 6,, 5HFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLVZDV
SHUIRUPHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI&7DQG05
5HVXOWV$OODGUHQDOPDVVHVLQFOXGHGDGHQRPDVDQGQRQDGHQRPDV7KH
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUWKH$3:DW&7ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
DQGWKRVHIRUWKH53:ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\$QGDW05WKHVHQVLWLY
LW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUWKH6,,ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\$UHDVXQGHUWKH
52&FXUYHZHUHDQGIRUWKH$3:53:DQG6,,UHVSHFWLYHO\
+RZHYHUWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHIRUGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHEHWZHHQ
$3:53:DQG6,, 3!
&RQFOXVLRQ&KHPLFDOVKLIW05VKRZVDKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUHYDOX
DWLQJDGUHQDOPDVVHVEXWLVRIQRDGGLWLRQDOGLDJQRVWLFYDOXH FRPSDUHGWRWKH
PLQXWHGHOD\HGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIDGUHQDOPHWDVWDVHVIURPUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPDRU
KHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDXVLQJXQHQKDQFHGDQGGHOD\HGFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG&7
<&KRL&.LP%3DUN63DUN-3DUN+<RRQ$.LP6HRXO.5
\DFKRL#VDPVXQJFRP
3XUSRVH 7R UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ PHDVXUH WKH DWWHQXDWLRQ YDOXHV DQG SHUFHQWDJH
HQKDQFHPHQWZDVKRXWRIDGUHQDOPHWDVWDVHVDWGHOD\HGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7
LQSDWLHQWVZLWK5&&VDQG+&&VDQGWRFRPSDUHZLWKWKRVHRIDGUHQDODGHQRPDV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LIWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKDGUHQDOPHWDVWDVHVDQGSD
WLHQWVZLWKDGUHQDODGHQRPDVXQGHUZHQWGHGLFDWHGDGUHQDO&77KHDWWHQXDWLRQ
YDOXHVDQGSHUFHQWDJHHQKDQFHPHQWZDVKRXWZHUHFDOFXODWHG7KHFKDQJHLQVL]H
RIDGUHQDOPDVVHVZDVDOVRDVVHVVHG7KHÀQDOGLDJQRVLVZDVPDGHE\VXUJHU\
RUELRSV\DGHFUHDVHLQVL]HDIWHUWDUJHWHGFKHPRWKHUDS\ PHWDVWDVHV DQG
VWDELOLW\LQVL]HRQIROORZXSLPDJLQJDWOHDVWPRQWKV DGUHQDODGHQRPDV
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQDEVROXWHSHUFHQWDJHZDVKRXWYDOXHRIPHWDVWDVHV +8
ZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWIURPWKDWRIDGHQRPDV +8 7KHPHDQUHOD
WLYHSHUFHQWDJHZDVKRXWYDOXHRIPHWDVWDVHV +8 ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHU
WKDQWKDWRIDGHQRPDV +8 EXWRIPHWDVWDVHVKDG$3:RI!
RU53:RI!2QXQHQKDQFHG&7WKHPHDQDWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHRIPHWDVWDVHV
DQGDGHQRPDVZDV+8DQG+8UHVSHFWLYHO\DOOPHWDVWDVHV
KDG!+8$OOPHWDVWDVHVVKRZHGDPHDVXUDEOHJURZLQJLQVL]H
&RQFOXVLRQ ,Q SDWLHQWV ZLWK 5&&V DQG +&&V WKH SHUFHQWDJH HQKDQFHPHQW
ZDVKRXWRIDGUHQDOPHWDVWDVHVZDVVLPLODUWRWKDWRIDGUHQDODGHQRPDV7KXVLI
DQDGUHQDOPDVVLQWKRVHSDWLHQWVKDV&7ÀQGLQJVVXJJHVWLQJDOLSLGSRRUDGUHQDO
DGHQRPDFDUHIXOVHULDOLPDJLQJIROORZXSLVUHFRPPHQGHGWRH[FOXGHDSRVVLELO
LW\RIPHWDVWDVLV
%
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHYDOXHRIDGGLQJIXQFWLRQDOVHTXHQFHVXVLQJGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHG LPDJLQJ DQG DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW YDOXH WR FRQYHQWLRQDO 05
LPDJLQJH[DPLQDWLRQLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRIDGUHQDOOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZLWKDYDULHW\RIDGUHQDOOHVLRQV
DGHQRPDV P\HOROLSRPDV DGUHQDO PHWDVWDVLV DQG SULPLWLYH FDUFLQRPDV ZHUH
SURVSHFWLYHO\LQYHVWLJDWHGZLWK05,VFDQ 7$FKLHYD3KLOLSV 7KHVWXG\ZDV
SHUIRUPHGZLWKDSKDVHGDUUD\PXOWLFRLOXVLQJDFRQYHQWLRQDOSURWRFROWKDWLQFOXGHG
DOVRGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, ZLWKEYDOXHRIDQGPP
VHF':,LPDJHVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK7))(LQDQGRSSRVHGSKDVH7KHPHDQ
$'&YDOXHRIDGUHQDOOHVLRQVZDVFDOFXODWHGDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWK05,ÀQGLQJV
52,ZHUHPDQXDOO\GUDZQDORQJWKHFRQWRXUVRIDGUHQDOOHVLRQRQ$'&PDSVDQG
VWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV/HVLRQVZHUHSURYHGHLWKHUE\IROORZXS VL]HLQFUHDVHRIRYHUDSHULRG
RIWLPH RUELRSV\ RQFRORJLFSDWLHQWV $OODGUHQDOOHVLRQVSUHVHQWHGUHVWULFWLRQRI
GLIIXVLRQDQGPRWLRQRIZDWHUSURWRQVRQGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJHV7KHUHZDV
QRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQREWDLQHG$'&YDOXHVEHWZHHQDGHQRPDV PHDQYDOXH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
4XDQWLWDWLYH1DDQG':LPDJLQJRIWKHKHDOWK\KXPDQNLGQH\IRU
HVWDEOLVKLQJQRUPYDOXHVIRUWKH1DFRQFHQWUDWLRQVDW7
6+DQHGHU6.RQVWDQGLQ3.HWWQDNHU/56FKDG626FK|QEHUJ
+-0LFKDHO\0DQQKHLP'( KDQHGHU#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KH SXUSRVH RI WKLV SURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ ZDV WR HVWDEOLVK SK\VLRORJLFDO
UDQJHVIRUWKHUHQDOFRUWLFRPHGXOODU\1DFRQFHQWUDWLRQ >1D@ JUDGLHQWWKH
FRUUHODWLRQZLWK':LPDJLQJDW7DQGSK\VLRORJLFDOSDUDPHWHUVLQDFROOHFWLYH
RIKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV IPPHDQDJHD ZHUH
LQFOXGHG LQ WKLV ,5%DSSURYHG VWXG\ )RU 1DLPDJLQJ D 'GHQVLW\ DGDSWHG
UDGLDO *5(VHTXHQFH 7( PV 75 PV SURMHFWLRQV VSDWLDO
UHVROXWLRQ [[ PP ZDV XVHG DW 7 7LP7ULR 0DJQHWRP 6LHPHQV LQ
FRPELQDWLRQ ZLWK D GHGLFDWHG 1DFRLO DQG UHIHUHQFH 1DSKDQWRPV
ZLWKDJDURVH$[LDOGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJHV 7( PV75 PVE
YDOXHV VSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ [[PP ZHUHDFTXLUHGZLWKDVWDQGDUG
ERG\FRLO 0HDQ YDOXHV VWDQGDUG GHYLDWLRQV IRU >1D@ DQG$'&YDOXHV ZHUH
FDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKYROXQWHHUDQGDVRYHUDOOYDOXHV3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV
ZHUHFDOFXODWHGWRFKHFNIRUVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQVZLWK$'&YDOXHV
JHQGHUVHUXP>1D@ERG\PDVVLQGH[ %0, DQGJORPHUXODUÀOWUDWLRQUDWH *)5
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQFRUWLFRPHGXOODU\>1D@IRUDOOKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVLQFUHDVHG
IURPFRUWLFDOPPROOWRPHGXOODUORFDWLRQPPROO,QWHULQGL
YLGXDOGLIIHUHQFHVUDQJHGIURPFRUWLFDOPHGXOODU\PPROOWR
PPROOZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWKLJKHUYDOXHVIRUZRPHQ S
7KHPHDQFRUWLFRPHGXOODU\>1D@JUDGLHQWZDVPPROOPP7KHPHDQ
UHQDO$'&YDOXHZDV[PPVDQGUDQJHGLQWHULQGLYLGXDOO\IURP[
PPVWR[PPV1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQVZHUHIRXQG
EHWZHHQWKHUHQDOFRUWLFRPHGXOODU\1DFRQFHQWUDWLRQDQG$'&YDOXHVVHUXP
>1D@%0,DQG*)5
&RQFOXVLRQ'HVSLWHLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOGLIIHUHQFHVDUDQJHRIQRUPDOYDOXHVIRUWKH
FRUWLFRPHGXOODU\>1D@FRXOGEHGHÀQHGDQGWKHODFNLQJFRUUHODWLRQZLWKRWKHU
SK\VLRORJLFDOSDUDPHWHUVFRXOGEHVKRZQ
%
7XPRXUQHFURVLVRQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJFRUUHODWHVZLWK
DJJUHVVLYHKLVWRORJ\DQGGLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQLQFOHDUFHOOUHQDOFHOO
FDUFLQRPD
3%HGG\(*HQHJD/1JR1+LQGPDQ-:HL$%XOORFN56%KDWW
0%$WNLQV,3HGURVD%RVWRQ0$86 SEHGG\#HLUFRPQHW
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRFRUUHODWHWKH05LPDJLQJIHDWXUHVRIFOHDU
FHOOUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPD FF5&& ZLWKWKHSDWKRORJLFDODSSHDUDQFHDQGWRDVVHVV
LIWKH05LPDJLQJIHDWXUHVFRUUHODWHZLWKGLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,QLWLDO VWDJLQJ 05,V RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK FF5&& ZHUH UHW
URVSHFWLYHO\ DVVHVVHG E\ WZR UDGLRORJLVWV IRU WKH SUHVHQFH RI WXPRXU QHFURVLV
F\VWLFGHJHQHUDWLRQLQWUDYR[HOIDWKDHPRUUKDJHUHWURSHULWRQHDOFROODWHUDOYHVVHOV
DQGUHQDOYHLQWKURPERVLV4XDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRIWKH05LPDJLQJIRULQWUDFHO
OXODUOLSLGZLWKLQWKHWXPRXUVZDVDOVRSHUIRUPHG7KHVHÀQGLQJVZHUHFRUUHODWHG
ZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJLFÀQGLQJVRIFOHDUFHOOSHUFHQWDJHJURZWKSDWWHUQDQGWLPHWR
GLVHDVHSURJUHVVLRQ
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZLWKFF5&&ZHUHLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVKDGIROORZXSGDWD
DYDLODEOHIRUSURJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV7KHSUHVHQFHRIWXPRXUQHFURVLVUHWURSHULWRQHDO
FROODWHUDOVDQGUHQDOYHLQWKURPERVLVRQ05,ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK
ORZFOHDUFHOOSHUFHQWDJHIRUERWKUHDGHUV S 05,HYLGHQFHRIQHFURVLV
UHWURSHULWRQHDOFROODWHUDOVDQGUHQDOYHLQWKURPERVLVZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKGLVHDVH
SURJUHVVLRQ S 0XOWLYDULDEOH DQDO\VLV GHPRQVWUDWHG WKDW ZKHQ WXPRXU
VL]HQHFURVLVUHWURSHULWRQHDOFROODWHUDOVDQGUHQDOYHLQWKURPERVLVZHUHDQDO\VHG
WRJHWKHUQHFURVLVZDVWKHRQO\IHDWXUHWKDWUHPDLQHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK
GLVHDVH SURJUHVVLRQ S DGMXVWHG RGGV UDWLR &, IRU
UHDGHURQHDQGS DGMXVWHGRGGVUDWLR &, IRUUHDGHUWZR
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
9DOXHRIIXQFWLRQDO05,ZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJLQ
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRILQGHWHUPLQHGDGUHQDOOHVLRQVFRPSDULVRQZLWK
FKHPLFDOVKLIWLPDJLQJ
&57DOHL)UDQ]HVL',SSROLWR/0RQJX]]L&&DSUDUR$&&DGRQLFL
66LURQL0RQ]D,7 FWIGRF#KRWPDLOFRP
PPVHF P\HOROLSRPDV PHDQYDOXHPPVHF DQGSULPL
WLYHFDUFLQRPDV PHDQYDOXHPPVHF $KLJKHU$'&YDOXHZDVVHHQ
LQWKHDGUHQDOPHWDVWDVLV PHDQYDOXHPPVHF FRPSDUHGWRWKH
RWKHUDGUHQDOOHVLRQV S LQUHODWLRQWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIPRUHKRPRJHQHRXV
ZDWHUSURWRQVGLIIXVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ:HFRXOGQRWREWDLQGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQWDQG
PDOLJQDQWDGUHQDOOHVLRQVXVLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDQG$'&PDS4XDQ
WLWDWLYH':,HYDOXDWLRQE\$'&PDSVRIIHUVDIXUWKHUQRQLQYDVLYHWRROLQWHUPVRI
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRQO\RIPHWDVWDWLFOHVLRQVDJDLQVWWKHRWKHUDGUHQDOOHVLRQV7KH
FKHPLFDOVKLIWLPDJHVUHPDLQWKHPRVWKHOSIXOVHTXHQFHVLQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI
DGUHQDOOHVLRQV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ05,IHDWXUHVRIFF5&&FORVHO\FRUUHODWHZLWKWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIFOHDU
FHOOIHDWXUHVLQWKHWXPRXUDWKLVWRSDWKRORJ\05,HYLGHQFHRIQHFURVLVLVDSRRU
SURJQRVWLFLQGLFDWRULUUHVSHFWLYHRIWXPRXUVL]HDQGWKLVÀQGLQJPD\EHXVHIXOLQ
JXLGLQJWKHUDSHXWLFPDQDJHPHQW
%
'LDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7IRUGHWHFWLQJUHQDO
VLQXVLQYDVLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPD
&.LP+&KRL0K.LP.6&KR6HRXO.5 FKHUU\NLP#GUHDPZL]FRP
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHDFFXUDF\RIPXOWLGHWHFWRU
&7IRUGHWHFWLQJUHQDOVLQXVLQYDVLRQLQWKHSUHRSHUDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRISDWLHQWV
ZLWKUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKVXUJLFDOO\UHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPDSDWLHQWV
ZKR XQGHUZHQW 0'&7 ZHUH LQFOXGHG LQ WKLV VWXG\ &RQWUDVWHQKDQFHG DFTXLVL
WLRQVZHUHREWDLQHGGXULQJDUWHULDOFRUWLFRPHGXOODU\DQGQHSKURJUDSKLFSKDVH
,PDJHDQDO\VLVZDVÀUVWSHUIRUPHGZLWKRQO\D[LDO&7LPDJHV$VHFRQGDQDO\VLV
ZDVWKHQSHUIRUPHG ZLWKERWKD[LDO DQGFRURQDO &7LPDJHV3UHVHQFH RIUHQDO
VLQXVLQYDVLRQRISHULUHQDOIDWZDVHYDOXDWHGLQD[LDOLPDJHVDQGFRPELQHGD[LDO
DQGFRURQDOUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJHV+LVWRORJLFDOHYDOXDWLRQKDVEHHQWKHGLDJQRVWLF
VWDQGDUG7KHYDOXHRIDGGLWLRQRIFRURQDOLPDJHVWRD[LDOLPDJHVZDVHYDOXDWHG
E\PHDQVRIUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQWXPRXUVL]HZDVFP7KHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\
RID[LDOLPDJHVDQGFRPELQHGLPDJHVZHUHDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\7KH$8&VRI52&DQDO\VLVZHUHIRUD[LDOLPDJHVDQG
IRUFRPELQHGLPDJHV S
&RQFOXVLRQ0'&7LVDFFXUDWHLQWKHSUHRSHUDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRIUHQDOVLQXVLQYD
VLRQLQWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPDEXWWKHUHZDVQRDGGLWLRQDOGLDJQRVWLF
YDOXHRIFRURQDOUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJHWRD[LDOLPDJHV
%
8WLOLW\RI7HVODGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH ':05
LPDJLQJIRUWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIVPDOOVROLGUHQDOWXPRXUV
)$JQHOOR-&KDUWRQ0<-HXQJ*/D7RQD0*DOLD00LGLUL&5R\
3DOHUPR,76WUDVERXUJ)5
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHXWLOLW\RIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV $'&V IRUWKH
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIVPDOOVROLGUHQDOOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV *)5P/PLQ ZLWKVPDOO FP
VROLGUHQDOPDVVHV>5&&V FOHDUFHOOW\SHVRWKHUW\SHV $0/V IDW
FRQWDLQLQJPLQLPDOIDW DQGRQFRF\WRPDV@ZHUHH[DPLQHGRQD7V\VWHP
XVLQJ':66(3, EYDOXHVVPP 7KH$'&RIWKHOHVLRQVDQGWKH$'&
RINLGQH\ZHUHHYDOXDWHG5HFHLYHURSHUDWRUFKDUDFWHULVWLFDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
WRHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRI$'&IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJFOHDUFHOO5&&VIURP
RWKHUW\SH5&&V$0/VDQGRQFRF\WRPDV
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ$'&RIWKHOHVLRQV>PPVHF @ZDV
ORZHUWKDQWKDWRINLGQH\>PPVHF @ S0DQQ
:KLWQH\WHVW 7KHPHDQ$'&ZDVGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQ5&&V>PP
VHF @$0/V > PP VHF @ DQG RQFRF\WRPDV
>PPVHF @ S.UXVNDO:DOOLVWHVW 7KHPHDQ$'&RI
FOHDUFHOO5&&VZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKDWRIRWKHU5&&V>PP
VHF YV @ S6WXGHQWWWHVW 7KHUHZDV
QRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQPHDQ$'&RIIDWFRQWDLQLQJ>PP
VHF @DQGPLQLPDOIDW$0/V>PPVHF @ S
6WXGHQWWWHVW 7KHEHVWFXWRII$'&YDOXHIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJFOHDUFHOO5&&VIURP
RWKHU5&&V$0/VDQGRQFRF\WRPDVZHUHDQGPPVHFUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ ':, LV XVHIXO WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH EHQLJQ IURP PDOLJQDQW VPDOO VROLG
UHQDOOHVLRQV
765 ZHUHFDOFXODWHG7ZRH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVYLVXDOO\DVVHVVHGSUHVHQFH
DQGGLVWULEXWLRQRIODWHHQKDQFHPHQWLQFHQWUDODUHDV PHGLDQPQ6'
5HVXOWV$PRQJ WKHVH WXPRXUV WKHUH ZHUH RQFRF\WRPDV LQ SDWLHQWV
ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGSUHVHQWLQJZLWKDFHQWUDOVFDUUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPDV 5&& LQ
SDWLHQWV ZLWK D FHQWUDO QHFURVLV DQG OHLRP\RPD &RPSOHWH ODWH HQKDQFH
PHQWRIWKHFHQWUDO]RQHZDVREVHUYHGLQRQFRF\WRPDV DQGLQ5&&V
S 6,,DQG765ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW S DQGS
UHVSHFWLYHO\ EHWZHHQ RQFRF\WRPD DQG 5&& JURXSV &RPELQDWLRQ RI FRPSOHWH
HQKDQFHPHQWDQG6,,RU765SURYLGHGVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI
DQGSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIDQGDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXHRIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ&HQWUDOVFDURIRQFRF\WRPDVDQGFHQWUDOQHFURVLVRI5&&6PD\ERWK
HQKDQFHRQODWH*GHQKDQFHG05LPDJHV+RZHYHUDFRPSOHWHHQKDQFHPHQWLV
KLJKO\HYRFDWLYHRIRQFRF\WRPD
%
6WXG\RIUHQDOLURQRYHUORDGE\7 05,LQDODUJHFRKRUWRI
WKDODVVHPLDPDMRUSDWLHQWV
(*UDVVHGRQLR$0HORQL*5HVWDLQR*9DOHUL/1DWDOH*5*LXJQR
0/RPEDUGL00LGLUL$3HSH3DOHUPR,73LVD,7&DPSREDVVR,7
$QFRQD,75RPH,7&DOWDJLURQH,7 HJUDVVHGRQLR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KLVVWXG\DLPHGWRGHVFULEHWKHUHQDO7 YDOXHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKWKD
ODVVHPLDPDMRU 70 WRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQUHQDODQGFDUGLDFRU
KHSDWLFVLGHURVLVDQGELYHQWULFXODUFDUGLDFIXQFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV70SDWLHQWV PHQ\HDUV XQGHUZHQW
05,0XOWLHFKR7 VHTXHQFHVZHUHXVHGIRULURQRYHUORDGDVVHVVPHQW,QWKH
KHDUWVHJPHQWDODQGJOREDO7 YDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG7KHOLYHU7 YDOXHZDV
DVVHVVHGLQDVLQJOH52,)RUHDFKNLGQH\7 YDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGLQWKUHHGLI
IHUHQW52,VDQGZHUHDYHUDJHGWRREWDLQDUHSUHVHQWDWLYHYDOXHIRUWKHNLGQH\7KH
PHDQ7 YDOXHRYHUWKHNLGQH\VZDVDOVRFDOFXODWHG%LYHQWULFXODUPRUSKRORJLFDO
DQGIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\FLQHLPDJHV
5HVXOWV7 YDOXHVLQWKHULJKWNLGQH\ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWORZHUWKDQLQWKHOHIWNLGQH\
PVYVPV3 7KHPHDQ7 YDOXHRYHUWKHNLGQH\V
ZDVPVDQGSDWLHQWV KDGDSDWKRORJLFDOYDOXH 7 PV
0HDQUHQDO7 YDOXHVLQFUHDVHGZLWKDJH U 3 DQGZHUHVLJ
QLÀFDQWO\QHJDWLYHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKVHUXPIHUULWLQOHYHOV U 3
6LJQLÀFDQWSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQVRIWKHPHDQ7 YDOXHVZHUHGHPRQVWUDWHGIRUOLYHU
U 3 DQGJOREDOKHDUW U 3 7 YDOXHV1RFRUUHOD
WLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQUHQDOLURQRYHUORDGDQGELYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQSDUDPHWHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ6\VWHPLF7 GLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQOHIWDQGULJKWNLGQH\VZHUHIRXQG
ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWORZHUYDOXHVLQWKHULJKWRQH0HDQ7 YDOXHLQFUHDVHGZLWKDJH
5HQDOLURQGHSRVLWLRQZDVQRWYHU\FRPPRQLQ70EXWLWZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKLURQ
GHSRVLWLRQLQOLYHUDQGKHDUW
5RRP)
%UHDVW
66
,QWHUYHQWLRQDOSURFHGXUHV
0RGHUDWRUV
6$OOHQ6XWWRQ8.
0ÉOYDUH]%HQLWR&yUGRED(6
%
&HQWUDOVFDULQUHQDORQFRF\WRPDVODWHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWZLWK
05LPDJLQJ
)&RUQHOLV$6/DVVHUH77RXUGLDV&'HPLQLHUH-0)HUULHUH</H%UDV
1*UHQLHU%RUGHDX[)5 IUDQFRLVFRUQHOLV#KRWPDLOFRP
0XOWLFHQWUHFRRSHUDWLYHVWXG\RIWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIÀQHQHHGOH
DVSLUDWLRQF\WRORJ\ )1$& RID[LOODU\O\PSKQRGHVXQGHU
VRQRJUDSKLFJXLGDQFHLQWKHSUHWUHDWPHQWPDQDJHPHQWRIEUHDVW
FDQFHUSDWLHQWVUHVXOWVDIWHUFRQVHFXWLYHFDQFHUFDVHV
33DODQD-GHO5LHJR09LOODMRV07HL[LGR09LODJUDQ0'LD]5XL]
/&DQDOHV-5LEH06HQWLV6DEDGHOO(67HUUDVD(6*UDQROOHUV(6
0DQUHVD(67HUUDVVD(69LF(6 SSDODQD#WDXOLFDW
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHODWH*GHQKDQFHPHQWRI
FHQWUDODUHDRIUHQDOWXPRXUVFRPSDWLEOHZLWKÀEURXVVFDURUQHFURVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUG
DSSURYHGLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZDVZDLYHG%DVHGRQWKHWKHVDXUXVRIRXULQVWLWXWLRQDO
5,6WXPRXUVLQSDWLHQWVLPDJHGZLWKODWH*GHQKDQFHG05VHTXHQFHVEH
WZHHQDQGSUHVHQWHGZLWKKLJKVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ 6, FHQWUDODUHDRQ7Z
VHTXHQFHVFRPSDWLEOHZLWKFHQWUDOVFDU6,ZDVPHDVXUHGLQDOOUHQDOWXPRXUVDQG
VSOHHQRQLQDQGRSSRVHGSKDVHLPDJHV6,LQGH[ 6,, DQGWXPRXUWRVSOHHQUDWLR
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RI)1$&LQDFRQVHFXWLYHVHULHVRISDWLHQWV
ZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHU7RHYDOXDWHWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RI)1$&EURNHQGRZQE\WXPRXU
VL]HYROXPHDQGSKHQRW\SH7RSURSRVHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUWKHXVHRI)1$&
LQWKLVFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP$SULOWR-XQHZHVWXGLHGSDWLHQWV
ZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHUXVLQJDSURWRFROIRUO\PSKQRGHHYDOXDWLRQ)1$&ZDVSHUIRUPHG
RQ O\PSK QRGHV ZLWK PRUSKRORJLF FKDQJHV DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH %HGL FODVVLÀFDWLRQ
RUZKHQO\PSKQRGHDSSHDUHGQRUPDORQWKHQRGHFORVHVWWRWKHLQGH[WXPRXU
%
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
3DWLHQWVZHUHVWUDWLÀHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHÀQDOQRGDOVWDJLQJREWDLQHGE\D[LOODU\GLV
VHFWLRQRUVHQWLQHOQRGHELRSV\KLVWRORJ\WXPRXUSKHQRW\SHDQGSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUV
5HVXOWV)1$&ZDVSRVLWLYHLQDQGVHQWLQHOQRGHELRSV\ZDVDYRLGHGLQDOO
WKHVHFDVHV7KHSUHYDOHQFHRIO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVLQWKHVHULHVZDV
7KHVHQVLWLYLW\RI)1$&ZDVDQGWKHVSHFLÀFLW\ZDV7KHRGGVUDWLR
ZDV DQGWKHSUHWHVWQHJDWLYHOLNHOLKRRGUDWLRZDV &,
,QWXPRXUVPPLQVL]HRUPPLQYROXPHRQO\RIFDVHVZHUH
SRVLWLYH7ULSOHQHJDWLYHFDQFHUVKDGDKLJKSHUFHQWDJHRISRVLWLYHO\PSKQRGH
UHJDUGOHVVRIWXPRXUVL]H
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHQVLWLYLW\RI)1$&LVORZHUWKDQSUHYLRXVO\UHSRUWHG7ULSOHQHJD
WLYHFDQFHUVKDGDKLJKSUHYDOHQFHRIO\PSKQRGHLPSDLUPHQWUHJDUGOHVVRIWXPRXU
VL]H)1$&KDVORZVSHFLÀFLW\DQGFDQEHDYRLGHGZKHQWXPRXUVL]HPP
RUWXPRXUYROXPHPPXQVSHFLÀFO\PSKQRGHVQRQWULSOHQHJDWLYHFDQFHU
%
6WDJLQJWKHD[LOODZLWKXOWUDVRXQGDQGELRSV\PD[LPLVLQJ
GLDJQRVWLF\LHOGZKLOVWPLQLPLVLQJXQQHFHVVDU\ELRSV\
.$7D\ORU0*:DOOLV-)RUHPDQ3'%ULWWRQ&DPEULGJH8.
NDWKU\QWD\ORU#DGGHQEURRNHVQKVXN
3XUSRVH7KHXVHRIXOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGQHHGOHELRSV\RID[LOODU\O\PSKQRGHVLQ
EUHDVWFDQFHUFDQDYRLGXQQHFHVVDU\VHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHELRSV\LQQRGHSRVLWLYH
SDWLHQWV:HZLVKHGWRHVWDEOLVKDSUDFWLFDOSURWRFROIRUD[LOODU\QRGHELRSV\LQD
EXV\FOLQLFDOVHWWLQJWKDWPD[LPLVHGGLDJQRVWLF\LHOGZKLOVWPLQLPLVLQJXQQHFHV
VDU\ELRSV\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%DVHGXSRQDSUHYLRXVO\SXEOLVKHGVWXG\IURPWKLVLQ
VWLWXWLRQWKHD[LOODU\QRGHELRSV\FULWHULDIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGEUHDVWFDQFHU
ZHUHGHWHUPLQHG$[LOODU\DQGEUHDVWFRUHELRSVLHV &% ZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQWKH
VDPHFOLQLFVHVVLRQE\DQ\RQHRISUDFWLWLRQHUV7KLVSURWRFROZDVXQGHUWDNHQ
WKURXJKRXWDQGLWVHIIHFWLYHQHVVHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWVLQYDVLYHFDQFHUVSUHVHQWHGGXULQJWKHVWXG\SHULRGRIZKLFK
ZHUHO\PSKQRGHSRVLWLYHDWVXUJLFDOKLVWRORJ\&%ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ
RISDWLHQWVRIPDOLJQDQWQRGHVZLWK76GLDPHWHU!RU PPZHUH
PDOLJQDQWDW&%RIQRGHVZLWKDFRUWH[!RU PPZHUHPDOLJQDQWDW&%
RIQRGHVZLWKDQDEVHQWKLOXPZHUHPDOLJQDQWDW&%DQGRIQRGHVZLWK
DOREXODWHGFRUWH[ZHUHPDOLJQDQWDW&%2YHUDOOSUHRSHUDWLYHGLDJQRVLVRID[LOODU\
PHWDVWDVHVZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH VXJJHVWHG ELRSV\ SURWRFRO FDQ EH VXFFHVVIXOO\ LPSOHPHQWHG
LQWRDEXV\FOLQLFDOVHWWLQJXQGHUWDNHQE\DQXPEHURISUDFWLWLRQHUV$GRSWLRQRI
VXFKDSURWRFROHQDEOHGRYHURISDWLHQWVZLWKO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVWREH
GLDJQRVHGSUHRSHUDWLYHO\ZKLOVWPLQLPLVLQJWKHQXPEHURIXQQHFHVVDU\ELRSVLHV
%
3UHRSHUDWLYHVWDJLQJRIWKHD[LOOD8.DXGLWRIVFUHHQGHWHFWHG
EUHDVWFDQFHUDQG
0*:DOOLV6&KHXQJ3'%ULWWRQ2.HDULQV&DPEULGJH8.
%LUPLQJKDP8. PDWWKHZZDOOLV#DGGHQEURRNHVQKVXN
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
0DQDJHPHQWRIÁDWHSLWKHOLDODW\SLDGLDJQRVHGDWYDFXXPDVVLVWHG
EUHDVWELRSV\SHUIRUPHGRQVXVSLFLRXVPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
&RPSDULVRQEHWZHHQ*DQG*GHYLFHV
$9LOOD)&KLHVD,5RVHQEHUJ0&DODEUHVH/D6SH]LD,7*HQRD,7
FKLHVDIDELR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH:HLQWHQGHGWRHVWDEOLVKLIZRPHQZLWKGLDJQRVLVRIÁDWHSLWKHOLDODW\SLD
)($ DWVWHUHRWDFWLFYDFXXPDVVLVWHGEUHDVWELRSV\ 9$%% ZLWKRXWUHVLGXDOPL
FURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVFRXOGEHPDQDJHGZLWKPDPPRJUDSKLFIROORZXS )8 LQVWHDGRI
VXUJHU\DQGZKHWKHUEHWWHUUHVXOWVFRXOGEHDFKLHYHGZLWK*GHYLFHFRPSDUHG
ZLWK*
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV9$%%SHUIRUPHGLQWZREUHDVWXQLWVLQWKHVDPHPHWUR
SROLWDQDUHDZHUHUHYLHZHG)URP2FWREHUWR-DQXDU\)($ZHUH
IRXQGLQFHQWUHZLWK*GHYLFHDQGLQFHQWUHZLWK*3DWLHQWVZHUHVXE
JURXSHGLQWKRVHZLWKRXW JURXS$ DQGZLWK JURXS% UHVLGXDOPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
7KHXQGHUHVWLPDWLRQVUDWH 85 RIPDOLJQDQF\IRUHDFKJURXSDQGWKHSURSRUWLRQ
RIJURXS$SDWLHQWVZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQWKHWZRFHQWUHV
5HVXOWV7KH85RI)($ZDV ZLWK* FHQWUH DQG ZLWK
* FHQWUH )RUSDWLHQWVFRQVLGHUHGDVDZKROHWKH85RIJURXS$ZDV
WKH85IRUJURXS%ZDV S ,QFHQWUHWKH85IRUJURXS
$ZDV WKH85IRUJURXS%ZDV ,QFHQWUHWKH85IRUJURXS
$ZDV WKH85IRUJURXS%ZDV WKHSURSRUWLRQRISDWLHQWV
LQJURXS$ZDV LQFHQWUHDQG LQFHQWUH S
&RQFOXVLRQ:RPHQZLWK)($ZLWKRXWUHVLGXDOPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVFRXOGEHPDQ
DJHGZLWKPDPPRJUDSKLF)8*9$%%LVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDORZHUSUHYDOHQFHRI
UHVLGXDOPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVFRPSDUHGWR*
%
$FFXUDF\RIPLQLPDOLQYDVLYHEUHDVWELRSV\LQDQLQFLSLHQWVFUHHQLQJ
SURJUDPDQDO\VLVRIFRQVHFXWLYHSHUFXWDQHRXVLQWHUYHQWLRQV
6++H\ZDQJ.RHEUXQQHU-1DHKULJ++ÁHU$+DFNHU66HGODFHN
1+LQWHUPHLHU0XQLFK'( +(<:$1*.2(#DROFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRXQWHUFKHFNFRUUHODWLRQRI339DQGWXPRXUVWDJHZLWKOHVLRQW\SH
DQGELRSV\PHWKRGLQFRQVHFXWLYHPLQLPDOLQYDVLYHELRSVLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV 86JXLGHGFRUHQHHGOHELRSVLHV 86&1%
VWHUHRWDFWLFFRUHVQHHGOHELRSVLHV 0;&1%VWHUHRWDFWLFYDFXXPDVVLVWHGEL
RSLHV 0;9$% ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\GRFXPHQWHGLQDFRXQWU\ZLGHVFUHHQLQJ5,6
GDWDEDVH(YDOXDWLRQDIWHU\HDUVIROORZXSDQGFDQFHUUHJLVWU\PDWFKLQJ
5HVXOWV339FOHDUO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKOHVLRQW\SH IRUDUFKLWHFWXUDOGLVWRUWLRQ
IRUPDVVZZRPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVIRUPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVRQO\
IRU IRFDO DV\PPHWULHV7KH339ZDVKLJKHVWIRU86JXLGHG&1% IROORZHG
E\0;JXLGHG&1% DQG9$%% 7KHHDUOLHVWVWDJHVZHUHGHWHFWHGE\
9$%% '&,67D7E IROORZHGE\0;&1% '&,6
7D7E DQGE\86&1% '&,67D7E
&RQFOXVLRQ'LIIHUHQWOHVLRQVDUHH[DPLQHGE\WKHDYDLODEOHLPDJLQJPHWKRGV
'HWHFWLRQRIYHU\HDUO\PDOLJQDQF\LVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDORZHU339:HWKDQNDOO
LQWHUYHQWLRQDOLVWVIRUWKHLUFRRSHUDWLRQZLWKWKLVHYDOXDWLRQVXSSRUWHGE\(WKLFRQ
1RUGHUVWHGW
%
,VLPDJHJXLGHGELRSV\DOZD\VQHFHVVDU\LQZRPHQXQGHU\HDUV
ZLWKVROLGSDOSDEOHEUHDVWPDVVHV"
$(&RUU'0'XNH1+DPEO\-'&XQQLQJKDP'XEOLQ,( DOLFRUU#UFVLLH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHQHHGIRUSHUFXWDQHRXVQHHGOHELRSV\LQZRPHQ\UV
ZLWKV\PSWRPDWLFEUHDVWOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$FFRUGLQJWRRXUFXUUHQWSURWRFROVVROLGSDOSDEOHEUHDVW
PDVVHVDUHELRSVLHGXQGHULPDJHJXLGDQFHLUUHVSHFWLYHRISDWLHQWDJH:HUH
YLHZHGDOOFRUHQHHGOHELRSVLHVRYHUDIRXU\HDUSHULRGLQDV\PSWRPDWLFEUHDVW
VHUYLFHSDWLHQWV )0 XQGHUZHQWLPDJHJXLGHGELRSV\LQWKLVSHULRG
RIZKRP DOOIHPDOH ZHUH\UV ZHUHFDWHJRULVHG%,5$'6
D ZHUHFDWHJRULVHG%,5$'6EDQGDERYH,PDJLQJSDWKRORJLFDO
ÀQGLQJVDQGGHFLVLRQVIURPPXOWLGLVFLSOLQDU\PHHWLQJVZHUHH[DPLQHG
5HVXOWV$OOELRSVLHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGXQGHUXOWUDVRXQGJXLGDQFHZLWK*WUXFXW
FRUHQHHGOHV&RVWVH[FOXGLQJPHGLFDOPDQKRXUVIRUDQXOWUDVRXQGJXLGHGEUHDVW
ELRSV\LQRXULQVWLWXWLRQLV½ZLWKDIXUWKHU½IRUSDWKRORJLFDOSURFHVVLQJRI
VSHFLPHQ3DWKRORJLFDOUHVXOWVRIWKHSDWLHQWVVFRUHGDV%,5$'6RUD
\UV RI DJH LQFOXGHG ÀEURDGHQRPD RWKHU EHQLJQ ÀQGLQJV
LQYDVLYHFDUFLQRPD '&,6 ,Q
ÀQGLQJVVXJJHVWHGOLNHO\ÀEURDGHQRPDEXWFRXOGQRWH[FOXGHSK\OORGHV$OOXQ
GHUZHQWVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQZKHUHWKHÀQDOSDWKRORJ\GHPRQVWUDWHGÀEURDGHQRPD
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH$[LOODU\QRGDOVWDWXVLVVWLOOWKHPRVWSRZHUIXOSUHGLFWRURIEUHDVWFDQFHU
VXUYLYDO7KH LQWURGXFWLRQ RI VHQWLQHO O\PSK QRGH ELRSV\ KDV UHVXOWHG LQ UHSHDW
RSHUDWLRQVIRUGHÀQLWLYHWUHDWPHQW:HUHSRUWWKHÀUVWQDWLRQDOO\EDVHGVFUHHQLQJ
DXGLWRISUHRSHUDWLYHVWDJLQJZLWKXOWUDVRXQGDQGQHHGOHELRSV\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'DWDRQD[LOODU\VWDJLQJZHUHÀUVWLQFOXGHGLQWKHDQ
QXDO8QLWHG.LQJGRPDXGLWRIVFUHHQGHWHFWHGFDQFHUVLQDQGUHSHDWHG
LQ6FRWODQGLVXQDEOHWRSURYLGHGDWDDQG:DOHVRQO\SURYLGHGGDWDIRU
5HVXOWV2IWKHVXUJLFDOO\WUHDWHGLQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDQFHUV ZHUH
QRGHSRVLWLYH,QWKHUHZDVDQD[LOODU\XOWUDVRXQGUHFRUGIRURILQYDVLYH
FDQFHUVWKLVURVHWRLQ2IWKHDEQRUPDOXOWUDVRXQGUHFRUGV
XQGHUZHQWD[LOODU\ELRSV\2IWKHQRGHSRVLWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWK
DQXOWUDVRXQGUHFRUG ZHUHFRUUHFWO\VWDJHGSUHRSHUDWLYHO\,Q
RIZRPHQFRQÀUPHGWREHQRGHSRVLWLYHDWVXUJHU\ZHUHFRUUHFWO\VWDJHG
SUHRSHUDWLYHO\DYRLGLQJDUHSHDWRSHUDWLRQULVLQJWR LQ,QWKH
RULJLQDOGDWDIDOVHSRVLWLYHQHHGOHELRSVLHVZHUHUHSRUWHG,QGLYLGXDOUHFRUGV
ZHUHDYDLODEOHIRUSDWLHQWV'DWDHQWU\HUURUVDFFRXQWHGIRUFDVHVZLWK
WUXHIDOVHSRVLWLYHV F\WRORJ\DQGFRUHELRSV\
&RQFOXVLRQ 'DWD HQWU\ DQG FRPSOHWHQHVV KDYH LPSURYHG EXW UHTXLUH IXUWKHU
LPSURYHPHQW2XUUDWHRIVXFFHVVIXOVWDJLQJLVHTXLYDOHQWWRSXEOLVKHGGDWDZKHQ
WKHXQGHUO\LQJUDWHRIQRGHSRVLWLYLW\LVWDNHQLQWRDFFRXQW&DUHQHHGWREHWDNHQ
LQLQWHUSUHWLQJF\WRORJ\IURPWKHD[LOOD
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
RQO\ XQGHUZHQWVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQSRVWELRSV\DVDUHVXOWRISDWLHQW
RUVXUJLFDOSUHIHUHQFHZLWKDOOOHVLRQVEHQLJQRQH[FLVLRQ7KHQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXHRIXOWUDVRXQGDVVHVVPHQWDQG%,5$'6FDWHJRULVDWLRQRIV\PSWRPDWLFEUHDVW
OHVLRQVLQDSRSXODWLRQXQGHU\UVRIDJHZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QH[SHULHQFHGKDQGV86FRPELQHGZLWK%,5$'6VFRULQJRISDOSDEOH
EUHDVWOHVLRQVVDIHO\SUHGLFWVZRPHQ\UVQRWUHTXLULQJSHUFXWDQHRXVELRSV\
ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWÀQDQFLDOVDYLQJV
%
,QFLGHQFHRIFDQFHULQFRQVHFXWLYHQHJDWLYHFRUHQHHGOHEUHDVW
ELRSV\FDVHVVXEPLWWHGWRVXUJHU\
507ULPEROL(*RPERV'6LSSR,)HUQDQGH]65D]D0LODQ,7
%RVWRQ0$86 WULPEROLUP#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHLQFLGHQFHRIFDQFHULQFRQVHFXWLYHQHJDWLYHFRUHQHHGOH
EUHDVWELRSV\FDVHVVXEPLWWHGWRVXUJHU\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHYLHZHG FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK QHJDWLYH
FRUHQHHGOHELRSVLHVSHUIRUPHGXQGHUVWHUHRWDFWLFPDPPRJUDSKLFRUXOWUDVRXQG
JXLGDQFHWKDWXQGHUZHQWVXEVHTXHQWVXUJHU\GXULQJDSHULRGEHWZHHQ-DQXDU\
DQG 0DUFK ,QGLFDWLRQV IRU VXUJHU\ ZHUH KLJKULVNERUGHUOLQH
SDWKRORJLF UHVXOW +5 UDGLRORJLFSDWKRORJLF GLVFRUGDQFH 53' SDWKRORJLVWҋV
UHFRPPHQGDWLRQ 35 ÀEURHSLWKHOLDOOHVLRQ )(/ RUSDWLHQWҋVSUHIHUHQFH 33
7KHLQFLGHQFHRIFDQFHULQWKHSDWKRORJ\RIVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQVZDVFDOFXODWHGIRU
HDFKJURXSDQGRYHUDOO&KLVTXDUHWHVWZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHJURXSVZLWKDQG
ZLWKRXWFDQFHUDWH[FLVLRQ
5HVXOWV )LQDO SDWKRORJLF DVVHVVPHQW UHYHDOHG DQ RYHUDOO LQFLGHQFH RI
PDOLJQDQF\,QSDUWLFXODUWKHUHZHUH FDQFHUVLQWKH+5JURXS
LQWKH53'JURXS LQWKH35JURXS LQWKH)(/
JURXSDQG LQWKH33JURXS6LJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ
+5 53' 35 JURXSV FDQFHU LQFLGHQFH DQG )(/ DQG 33 JURXSV
FDQFHULQFLGHQFH S
&RQFOXVLRQ$QRQQHJOLJLEOHFDQFHULQFLGHQFH ZDVIRXQGDPRQJQHJDWLYH
FRUHQHHGOHELRSVLHVVXEPLWWHGIRUVXUJHU\6XEJURXSDQDO\VLVRILQGLFDWLRQVIRU
VXUJHU\ VKRZHG WKDW WKH FDQFHU LQFLGHQFH ZDV QXOO IRU WKH SDWLHQWҋV SUHIHUHQFH
DQGÀEURHSLWKHOLDOOHVLRQVJURXSVDQGPRGHUDWH IRUWKHKLJKULVNOHVLRQ
UDGLRORJLFSDWKRORJLFGLVFRUGDQFHDQGSDWKRORJLVWUHFRPPHQGDWLRQJURXSV7KHUH
IRUHWKHVHODWWHUWKUHHLQGLFDWLRQVVKRXOGSURPSWVXUJLFDOH[FLVLRQ
%
86JXLGHG*FRUHQHHGOHELRSV\RIEUHDVWPDVVHVFDWHJRULVHG
DV%,5$'6DQGFDQWKHUDGLRORJLVWSUHGLFWWKHDGHTXDF\RI
WLVVXHVDPSOLQJ"
9/RQGHUR('L*DHWDQR&=XLDQL**UD]LDQL&'L/RUHWR0%D]]RFFKL
8GLQH,7 ORQGHURYLYLDQD#DRXGVDQLWDIYJLW
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHZKHWKHUUDGLRORJLVWFDQSUHGLFWWKHҊSUREDEO\GLDJQRVWLFҋ
FRUHVDPSOHRQWKHEDVLVRIJURVVDSSHDUDQFHZKHQSHUIRUPLQJ86JXLGHGJ
FRUHQHHGOHELRSV\ 86&1%
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\FRQVHFXWLYH86&1%VZHUH
SHUIRUPHGRQ%,5$'6FDWHJRU\DQGEUHDVWPDVVHVLQZRPHQ$PHDQ
RIÀYHFRUHVDPSOHVSHUOHVLRQ UDQJH ZHUHREWDLQHGDQGWKHÀUVWVSHFLPHQ
VKRZLQJGHQVHPDWHULDOZDVSUHGLFWHGWREHGLDJQRVWLFDQGZDVDQDO\VHGVHSD
UDWHO\7KLVZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHÀQDOKLVWRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLV3RVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXHV 339V RIWKHҊSUREDEO\GLDJQRVWLFҋFRUHVDPSOHZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV'LDJQRVWLFPDWHULDOUHSUHVHQWDWLYHRIWKHOHVLRQZDVREWDLQHGZLWKWKH
GHQVHVSHFLPHQVLQ RIWKHOHVLRQV339VRIGHQVHFRUHVDPSOHV
ZDV FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO>&,@ IRU%
&, IRU% &, IRU%DQG
&, IRU%OHVLRQV7KHUHPDLQLQJ VSHFLPHQVFRQWDLQLQJ
GHQVHEXWQRQGLDJQRVWLFPDWHULDOVKRZHGIRFDOÀEURVLVDQGKDGPLVVHGWKHOHVLRQV
RIEHQLJQRI%DQGRIPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV RI%OHVLRQV
DQG RIPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVZHUHGLDJQRVHGRQO\LQWKHGHQVHVSHFLPHQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$WWKHWLPHRI86&1%VRIEUHDVWPDVVHVWKHJURVVDSSHDUDQFHRI
FRUHVSHFLPHQVKHOSHGXV SUHGLFWWKHDGHTXDF\RIWLVVXHVDPSOLQJ GHWHUPLQH
WKHQXPEHURIFRUHVDPSOHVQHHGHGIRUDUHOLDEOHGLDJQRVLV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
6WHUHRWDFWLFDOO\JXLGHGYDFXXPDVVLVWHGEUHDVWELRSV\GLDJQRVWLF
UHOLDELOLW\DQGFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWH
6.DSVLPDODNRX$:DOGPDQQ$.DWDOLQLF,*UDQGH1DJHO
$.RYDFV3+XQROG6+ROOPDQQ-%DUNKDXVHQ)09RJW
/XHEHFN'( 6PDUDJGD.DSVLPDODNRX#XNVKGH
3XUSRVH7KHXVHRIODUJHFRUHVWHUHRWDFWLFDOO\JXLGHGYDFXXPDVVLVWHGELRSV\
9$% KDVVKRZQPXOWLSOHDGYDQWDJHVRYHUFRUHQHHGOHELRSV\3XUSRVHRIWKLV
VWXG\LVWRHYDOXDWHWKHDFFXUDF\DVZHOODVWKHFRPSOLFDWLRQVRI9$%
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV9$%VZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQSDWLHQWVZLWKPLFURFDOFLÀFD
WLRQVGHWHFWHGRQPDPPRJUDPDQGUDWHGDVLQWHUPHGLDWHWRVXVSLFLRXV %,5$'6
,9 RUKLJKO\VXVSLFLRXV %,5$'69 9$%ZDVSHUIRUPHGDFFRUGLQJWRDVWULFW
TXDOLW\DVVXUDQFHSURWRFRORQDGLJLWDOSURQHWDEOHXVLQJDQGJDXJHYDFXXP
SUREHV 6SHFLPHQ UDGLRJUDSKV ZHUH REWDLQHG IRU WKH GHWHFWLRQ RI SUHVHQWDEOH
PLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
5HVXOWV,QZRPHQZLWKDPHDQDJHRI 6' \HDUVZHLGHQWLÀHG
LQYDVLYH FDUFLQRPDV GXFWDO FDUFLQRPDV LQ VLWX '&,6
DW\SLFDOGXFWDOK\SHUSODVLD $'+ DQGOREXODUFDUFLQRPDLQVLWX
$IWHUVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQVWKHÀQDOUHVXOWQHHGHGDQXSJUDGLQJLQ
SDWLHQWV IURP$'+WR'&,6DQGLQSDWLHQWV IURP'&,6WRLQYDVLYH
FDUFLQRPD+RZHYHUSDWLHQWVZLWK'&,6DIWHU9$%KDGDEHQLJQGLDJQRVLVDIWHU
VXUJHU\LQGLFDWLQJWKDW'&,6ZDVFRPSOHWHO\UHPRYHGE\9$%6LGHHIIHFWVVXFK
DVEOHHGLQJRFFXUUHGLQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK*QHHGOH
YHUVXV ZLWK*QHHGOH
&RQFOXVLRQ9$%LVDQHIIHFWLYHWRROIRUFODULÀFDWLRQRIGLJQLW\RIPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
VHHQ RQ PDPPRJUDPV DQG SURYLGHV HDUO\ FDQFHU GHWHFWLRQ 6LGH HIIHFWV ZHUH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\OHVVXVLQJ*QHHGOHIRU9$%
%
%OHHGLQJKDHPDWRPDDQGVFDUIRUPDWLRQDIWHUYDFXXPELRSV\XQGHU
VWHUHRWDFWLFJXLGDQFH0DPPRWRPH5V\VWHP**YV$7(&5
V\VWHP**
-1HHOVHQ-%LHUQDWK:XHSSLQJ3-6FKDHIHU..URM%2UGHU0+HOOHU
:-RQDW).:6FKDHIHU.LHO'( MXOLDQHHOVHQ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7R HYDOXDWH WKH FRUUHODWLRQ RI VFDU IRUPDWLRQV DIWHU YDFXXPDVVLVWHG
ELRSV\ 9$% ZLWKGLIIHUHQW9$%V\VWHPVDQGQHHGOHVL]HVDQGSHULLQWHUYHQWLRQDO
EOHHGLQJKDHPDWRPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQDQGSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW
9$%XQGHUVWHUHRWDFWLFJXLGDQFHXVLQJWKH0DPPRWRPH5V\VWHPZLWKJDXJH
DQG$7(&5V\VWHPZLWKJDXJHZKHUHDVLQFDVHVZLWKUHSUHVHQWDWLYH
EHQLJQKLVWRORJ\QRVXUJLFDOELRSV\DIWHU9$%ZDVSHUIRUPHGDQGDWOHDVWDSODQH
IROORZXSPDPPRJUDP DIWHU PRQWK SRVW9$% ZDV DYDLODEOH %OHHGLQJ GXULQJ
LQWHUYHQWLRQKDHPDWRPDSRVWLQWHUYHQWLRQDQGVFDUWLVVXHZDVVFRUHGDVPLQLPDO
DQGPRGHUDWHVHYHUH6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVLQFOXGHG&KLVTXDUHWUHQGWHVWSYDOXH
ZDVFRQVLGHUHGWREHVLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV 6LJQLÀFDQWO\ PRUH VPDOOPRGHUDWH EOHHGLQJVSRVWLQWHUYHQWLRQDO KDH
PDWRPDVIRUJDXJH0DPPRWRPH5V\VWHPYVJDXJH0DPPRWRPH5V\VWHP
YV S S QR VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV IRU WKH$7(&
V\VWHPV YV S S JDXJH0DPPRWRPH5V\VWHP
YV$7(&5JDXJHV\VWHP UHYHDOHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\ OHVV EOHHGLQJVKDHPDWRPDV
YVS S QRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVIRUWKHODUJHV\VWHPV
S S )ROORZXSRI0DPPRWRPH5JDXJHV\VWHPV\VWHPKDV
VKRZQ PLQLPDO VFDU IRUPDWLRQ DQG PRGHUDWHVHYHUH
VFDUVZKHUHDV$7(&5JDXJHV\VWHPKDVVKRZQPLQLPDOVFDU
IRUPDWLRQ DQG PRGHUDWHVHYHUH VFDUV QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV 1R
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHFRPSDULQJ0DPPRWRPH5JV\VWHPVYV$7(&5
JV\VWHPV S S
&RQFOXVLRQ8VLQJODUJHUQHHGOHVL]HVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ 0DPPRWRPH5 QRWVLJQLÀFDQW
IRU$7(&5 PRUHEOHHGLQJVDQGSRVWLQWHUYHQWLRQDOKDHPDWRPDVZHUHGHWHFWHG
RQO\DWHQGHQF\FRQFHUQLQJVFDUIRUPDWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP*+
+HDGDQG1HFN
66
/\PSKQRGHVDQGWHPSRUDOERQH
0RGHUDWRUV
+3%XUPHLVWHU-HQD'(
65RELQVRQ9LHQQD$7
%
6KHDUZDYHHODVWRJUDSK\RIFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHVSUHOLPLQDU\
H[SHULHQFHIRUGHWHFWLRQRIPDOLJQDQF\
.66%KDWLD&7RQJ&&KR</HH(<XHQ-.:RQJ$7$KXMD
6KDWLQ+. GUNEKDWLD#FXKNHGXKN
3XUSRVH 6KHDU ZDYH HODVWRJUDSK\ 6:( LV D QRYHO WHFKQRORJ\ WKDW SHUPLWV
UHDOWLPHGLVSOD\DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHHVWLPDWLRQRIVKHDUPRGXOXVHTXDWLQJWRWLVVXH
VWLIIQHVV$VWXG\ZDVFRQGXFWHGWRHYDOXDWHLWVSRWHQWLDOIRUGLVFULPLQDWLRQEHWZHHQ
PDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 6:( ZDV SHUIRUPHG LQ FHUYLFDO O\PSK QRGHV
XQGHUJRLQJ 86JXLGHG QHHGOH DVSLUDWLRQ IRU F\WRORJ\ LQ D URXWLQH XOWUDVRXQG
FOLQLF6KHDUPRGXOXVLQGLFHVZHUHPHDVXUHGRQHODVWRJUDPVDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWK
F\WRORJLFDOUHVXOW
5HVXOWV6KHDUPRGXOXVZLWKLQWKHVWLIIHVWPPGLDPHWHUFLUFXODUUHJLRQZLWKLQ
QRGHVZDVKLJKHULQPDOLJQDQWQRGHV Q PHGLDQN3DLQWHUTXDUWLOHUDQJH
N3DUDQJHN3D WKDQEHQLJQQRGHV Q PHGLDQN3D
LQWHUTXDUWLOHUDQJHN3DUDQJHN3D S0DQQ:KLWQH\
8WHVW $FXWRIIRIN3DDWWDLQHGKLJKHVWDYHUDJHRIVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀ
FLW\ZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQG$8& &,
4XDOLWDWLYHO\6:(HODVWRJUDPVRIEHQLJQQRGHVDSSHDUHGKRPRJHQHRXVZKHUHDV
PDOLJQDQWQRGHVZHUHHLWKHUKRPRJHQHRXVRUPDUNHGO\KHWHURJHQHRXVLQFOXGLQJ
DUHDVODFNLQJHODVWLFLW\VLJQDO7KLVVWXG\LVRQJRLQJDQGSUHVHQWHGGDWDZLOOEH
XSGDWHG WR HYDOXDWH GLIIHUHQW PHWKRGV RI 6:( PHDVXUHPHQW ZLWKLQ QRGHV LQ
FUHDVHGWRWDOVDPSOHVL]HH[FHHGLQJO\PSKQRGHVDQG6:(GDWDDFFRUGLQJ
WRKLVWRORJLFDOVXEW\SH
&RQFOXVLRQ6:(LVIHDVLEOHIRUFHUYLFDOQRGHVDOWKRXJKSUHOLPLQDU\GDWDVXJ
JHVWLWRIIHUVRQO\PRGHVWGLVFULPLQDWLRQEHWZHHQPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQQRGHV,W
DSSHDUVXQVXLWDEOHIRUVFUHHQLQJRIQRGDOPDOLJQDQF\EXWPD\GHWHFWDVXEVHWRI
PDOLJQDQWQRGHVZLWKKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\7KHFDXVHRIPDUNHGVSDWLDOKHWHURJHQHLW\
XVLQJ6:(LQVRPHPDOLJQDQWQRGHVLV\HWWREHGHWHUPLQHG
%
3HUFXWDQHRXV86JXLGHGLQWHUVWLWLDOODVHUDEODWLRQRIPHWDVWDWLF
O\PSKQRGHVLQWKHQHFNIURPSDSLOODU\WK\URLGFDUFLQRPDIROORZLQJ
WK\URLGHFWRP\DQGO\PSKDGHQHFWRP\
*0DXUL/&RYD7,HUDFH77RQGROR*/RPXVFLR$%DUROL
&03DFHOOD/6ROELDWL0LODQ,7%XVWR$UVL]LR,7&RPR,75RPH,7
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
&RPSDULVRQRIWKHXOWUDVRXQGÀQGLQJVRIELRSV\SURYHQWXEHUFXORXV
O\PSKDGHQLWLVDQG.LNXFKLGLVHDVH
..LP6L6XK.6RQ</HH+6HR+6HRO6HRXO.5
UXGDOV#KDQPDLOQHW
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDQDO\VHWKHVRQRJUDSKLFIHDWXUHVWKDW
FDQFRQWULEXWHLQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQWXEHUFXORXVO\PSKDGHQLWLVDQG.LNXFKL
GLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6RQRJUDSKLFÀQGLQJVRISDWLHQWVZLWKELRSV\SURYHQ
WXEHUFXORXVO\PSKDGHQRSDWK\DQGSDWLHQWVZLWKELRSV\SURYHQ.LNXFKLGLV
HDVHZHUHUHYLHZHG/\PSKQRGHVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WKHLUVL]HVKDSH VKRUWHVW
ORQJHVW D[LV UDWLR ORFDWLRQ HFKRJHQLFLW\ SUHVHQFH RI FRQJORPHUDWLRQ JURVV
QHFURVLVFDOFLÀFDWLRQHFKRJHQLFQRGDOKLOXPLQFUHDVHGSHULQRGDOHFKRJHQLFLW\
DQGYDVFXODUSDWWHUQ
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQGLDPHWHURIWKHO\PSKQRGHVZDVFPIRUWXEHUFXORXVO\P
SKDGHQLWLVDQGFPIRU.LNXFKLGLVHDVH0RVWWXEHUFXORXVO\PSKQRGHVZHUH
ORFDWHGLQOHYHOV,,DQG9PRVW.LNXFKLGLVHDVHO\PSKQRGHVLQOHYHOV,9DQG9
3DWLHQWVZLWKWXEHUFXORXVO\PSKDGHQLWLVPDQLIHVWHGJURVVQHFURVLVLQ
FDVHVDQGSDWLHQWVZLWK.LNXFKLGLVHDVHLQ FDVHV O\PSKQRGHV
VKRZHGFDOFLÀFDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKWXEHUFXORXVO\PSKDGHQLWLVDQGQRQHVKRZHG
FDOFLÀFDWLRQ LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK .LNXFKL GLVHDVH ,QFUHDVHG SHULQRGDO HFKRJHQLFLW\
ZDVVHHQLQRIWKHWXEHUFXORXVO\PSKQRGHVDQGRIWKH.LNXFKLO\PSK
QRGHV&RQJORPHUDWLRQRIO\PSKQRGHVZDVVHHQLQ RIWKHWXEHUFXORXV
O\PSKDGHQLWLVFDVHVDQG RIWKH.LNXFKLGLVHDVHFDVHV2QSRZHU'RSSOHU
VWXG\ QRUPDO KLODU YDVFXODULW\ ZDV VHHQ LQ RI WKH WXEHUFXORXV O\PSK
QRGHVDQG RIWKH.LNXFKLO\PSKQRGHV
&RQFOXVLRQ *URVV QHFURVLV FRQJORPHUDWLRQ DQG QRUPDO KLODU YDVFXODULW\ RQ
SRZHU 'RSSOHU VWXG\ VKRZHG D VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ WKH WXEHUFXORXV
O\PSKDGHQLWLVDQG.LNXFKLGLVHDVHJURXSV S
%
7XEHUFXORVLV.LNXFKL
&3DUN-+DQ6-R<<RXQ&KHRQDQ.5 SDUNVDPI#KDQPDLOQHW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVRIQHFURWLVLQJO\PSKDGHQLWLV
LQ WXEHUFXORXV O\PSKDGHQLWLV DQG .LNXFKL GLVHDVH RQ QHFN &7 WR IDFLOLWDWH WKH
GLDJQRVLVWKHGLVHDVHVZLWKRXWSHUIRUPLQJDELRSV\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ DQDO\VHG SDWLHQWV ZRPHQ
PHQPHDQDJH\HDUV ZLWK.LNXFKLGLVHDVH JURXS, DQGSDWLHQWV
ZRPHQ PHQ PHDQ DJH \HDUV ZLWK WXEHUFXORXV O\PSKDGHQLWLV JURXS
,, SHUIRUPLQJQHFN&7IURP6HSWHPEHUWR'HFHPEHU:HHYDOXDWHG
VH[DJHQRGDOLQYROYHPHQWVLWHVELODWHUDOLW\IHDWXUHVDQGVL]HRIQHFURWLFO\PSK
QRGHVIDWLQÀOWUDWLRQQRGDOGLVWULEXWLRQ:%&DQG(65LQDOOSDWLHQWVDQGDQDO\VHG
VWDWLVWLFDOO\WKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQVRIWKHLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVDQGEORRGIDFWRUVEHWZHHQ
WKHWZRJURXSVXVLQJLQGHSHQGHQW6DPSOHV7WHVWIRUFRQWLQXRXVSDUDPHWHUVDQG
&KLVTXDUHDQG0F1HPHUWHVWVIRUFDWHJRULFDOSDUDPHWHUV
5HVXOWV /\PSKDGHQRSDWKLHV RI JURXSL ZHUH PRUH FRPPRQ LQ OHYHOV ,, ,,, 9
FRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHRIJURXS,,ZHUHPRUHFRPPRQLQ
OHYHO,9 7KHLQFLGHQFHVRIIDWLQÀOWUDWLRQDURXQGO\PSKQRGH OHX
NRF\WRSHQLD LQFUHDVHG(65 RIJURXSLZHUHKLJKHUWKDQWKRVH
RIJURXS,,7KHLQFLGHQFHRILUUHJXODUWKLFNQHFURWLFO\PSKQRGHRI
JURXSL ZDVKLJKHUWKDQWKDWRIJURXS,, EXWWKHLQFLGHQFHRIUHJXODU
WKLQQHFURWLFO\PSKQRGHRIJURXS,, ZDVKLJKHUWKDQWKDWRIJURXSL
&RQFOXVLRQ1RGDOLQYROYHPHQWVLWHIDWLQÀOWUDWLRQQHFURWLFQRGDOIHDWXUH:%&
DQG(65DUHXVHIXOLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQ.LNXFKLGLVHDVHDQGWXEHUFXORXV
O\PSKDGHQLWLV
%
'XDOHQHUJ\&7GHULYHGLRGLQHFRQWHQWDQGLRGLQHRYHUOD\IRU
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIHQODUJHGFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHV
$07DZÀN1($1RXU(OGLQ111DJXLE-.HUO$$$EGHO5D]HN
7-9RJO0DQVRXUD(*)UDQNIXUW'( DKPBPBWDZÀN#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH ZKHWKHU GXDO HQHUJ\ &7 '(&7 GHULYHG LRGLQH FRQWHQW
DQGLRGLQHRYHUOD\FRXOGEHXVHGWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQHQODUJHGPHWDVWDWLFDQG
LQÁDPPDWRU\FHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(LJKWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKHQODUJHGSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHG
PHWDVWDWLFO\PSKQRGHVDQGSDWLHQWVZLWKHQODUJHGO\PSKQRGHVGUDLQLQJGHHS
FHUYLFDOLQÁDPPDWLRQVXQGHUZHQWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG'(&72QO\RQHHQODUJHG
QRGHSHUSDWLHQWZDVLGHQWLÀHG'(VRIWZDUHZDVXVHGWRUHFRQVWUXFWLRGLQHRYHUOD\
LPDJHV,RGLQHFRQWHQWDQGRYHUOD\RIWKHSUHLGHQWLÀHGQRGHZDVFDOFXODWHGE\
PHDQVRIFLUFXODUUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW,RGLQHFRQWHQWRIPXVFOHDQGLQWHUQDOMXJXODU
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH :H UHSRUW RXU H[SHULHQFH ZLWK SHUFXWDQHRXV 86JXLGHG LQWHUVWLWLDO
ODVHUDEODWLRQIRUPHWDFKURQRXVFHUYLFDOQRGDOPHWDVWDVHVIURPSDSLOODU\WK\URLG
FDUFLQRPDIROORZLQJWRWDOWK\URLGHFWRP\DQGFHQWUDOODWHURFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHQW\WKUHH PHWDFKURQRXV PHWDVWDWLF QRGHV PHDQ
VL]HFPUDQJHFP LQSDWLHQWVZHUHWUHDWHG$QP1G<$*
ODVHU (FKR/DVHU;(VDRWH*HQRD,WDO\ ZDVXVHG$OOFDVHVZHUHQHJDWLYHDW
,ZKROHERG\VFDQEXWKDGSRVLWLYH))'*3(7DQGHOHYDWHGVHUXPOHYHOV
RIWK\URJOREXOLQ8QGHUORFDODQDHVWKHVLDDPPTXDUW]ÀEHURSWLFJXLGHZDV
SODFHGLQWRWKHQRGHWKURXJKD*QHHGOH1RGHVZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKRQH FDVHV
RUWZR ÀEUHLQVHUWLRQVHDFKRQHZLWK:SRZHUIRUVHF WRWDOHQHUJ\
MRXOHV $OOFDVHVZHUHIROORZHGDWDQGPRQWKVZLWK%PRGH86
&(86))'*3(7DQGDVVHVVPHQWRIVHUXPOHYHOVRI7J
5HVXOWV/DVHUDEODWLRQZDVWHFKQLFDOO\IHDVLEOHDQGZHOOWROHUDWHGLQDOOSDWLHQWV
ZLWKQRHLWKHULPPHGLDWHRUODWHFRPSOLFDWLRQV,Q QRGHVFRPSOHWH
DEODWLRQ ODFNRIHQKDQFHPHQWDW&(86QHJDWLYH))'*3(7ZLWKQRUPDOLVD
WLRQRI689DQG!GHFUHDVHRI7JVHUXPOHYHOV ZDVDFKLHYHG,QFDVHV
UHVLGXDOXSWDNHDW))'*3(7ZLWKDEQRUPDO689ZDVIRXQGDQGODVHUDEODWLRQ
ZDVUHSHDWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ3HUFXWDQHRXV86JXLGHGLQWHUVWLWLDOODVHUDEODWLRQVHHPVWREHDQ
HIIHFWLYHORZFRVWDQGVDIHWKHUDSHXWLFWRROIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRIPHWDFKURQRXVQRGDO
PHWDVWDVHVIURPSDSLOODU\WK\URLGFDUFLQRPDLQWKHQHFNZKLFKZRXOGRWKHUZLVH
UHTXLUHRIWHQFKDOOHQJLQJIXUWKHUUHVHFWLRQV
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
YHLQZHUHDOVRREWDLQHGDVFRQWURO,RGLQHFRQWHQWDQGRYHUO\RIPHWDVWDWLFDQG
LQÁDPPDWRU\O\PSKQRGHVZHUHFRPSDUHG5HFHLYHURSHUDWRUFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52&
FXUYHZDVXVHGWRGHWHUPLQHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RILRGLQHFRQWHQWDQGLRGLQH
RYHUOD\IRUGLDJQRVLVRIPHWDVWDWLFQRGHV
5HVXOWV,RGLQHFRQWHQWZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRUPHWDVWDWLF WKDQ
LQÁDPPDWRU\O\PSKQRGHV S,RGLQHRYHUOD\ZDVDOVRVLJ
QLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRUPHWDVWDWLFWKDQLQÁDPPDWRU\QRGHVS1RVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHVZHUHREVHUYHGEHWZHHQLRGLQHFRQWHQWIRUPXVFOHDQGLQWHUQDOMXJXODU
YHLQRIERWKJURXSVS DQG52&FXUYHRILRGLQHFRQWHQWKDGODUJHU
DUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH WKDQWKDWRILRGLQHRYHUOD\ GHQRWLQJKLJKHU
GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ LQ GLDJQRVLV RI QRGDO PHWDVWDVHV 2SWLPDO WKUHVKROG YDOXH
IRULRGLQHFRQWHQWWRGLDJQRVHQRGDOPHWDVWDVHVKDGVHQVLWLYLW\DQG
VSHFLÀFLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ'(&7GHULYHGLRGLQHFRQWHQWDQGRYHUOD\PLJKWKHOSLQFKDUDFWHULVD
WLRQRIHQODUJHGFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHV
%
)LUVWH[SHULHQFHZLWKWULH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLVRI':,VLJQDO
DWWHQXDWLRQLQQRUPDOFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHVIHDVLELOLW\VWXG\
05DYDQHOOL')DULQD(%RWWXUL$0DUFRQL90D]]D50DUROGL%UHVFLD,7
PDUFRUDYDQHOOL#KRWPDLOLW
3XUSRVH%LH[SRQHQWLDOPRGHO ,9,0 SRVWXODWHVWZRGLVWLQFWFRPSRQHQWVLQÁX
HQFLQJWKH':,VLJQDODWWHQXDWLRQDYHU\VORZ GLIIXVLRQ DQGDIDVWFRPSRQHQW
EYDOXHVVPP UHODWHGWRDUWHULDOSHUIXVLRQ:KHQ':,GDWDVHWLVDFTXLUHG
ZLWKEYDOXHV!VPPWKHDFFXUDF\RIWKHELH[SRQHQWLDOPRGHOGHFUHDVHV
$WKLUGFRPSRQHQWSUREDEO\UHODWHGWRVORZÁRZVFRXOGH[SODLQPRGHOLQDFFXUDF\
7KHVWXG\SXUSRVHLVWRDVVHVVWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIWULH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLVRI':,
VLJQDOGHFD\LQFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RXUKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVKDGWKHQHFNH[DPLQHGE\7
05XVLQJ(3,':,VHTXHQFHVZLWKEYDOXHV VPP 7KH':,VLJQDO
DWWHQXDWLRQRIFHUYLFDOO\PSKQRGHVZDVDQDO\VHGE\PRQRH[SRQHQWLDO $'&
ELH[SRQHQWLDO ,9,0 DQG WKH K\SRWKHVLVHG WULH[SRQHQWLDO PRGHO 7KLV PRGHO
H[WUDFWV WKUHH SDUDPHWHUV IDVWSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ IIDVW VORZSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ
IVORZ DQG VORZSVHXGRGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW ' VORZ $OO WKUHH DQDO\VHV ZHUH
SHUIRUPHGRQVPPDQGVPPLQWHUYDOVPRQRDQGELH[SRQHQWLDO
DQDO\VHVZHUHDOVRSHUIRUPHGRQVPPLQWHUYDO$FFXUDF\RIÀWWLQJZDV
PHDVXUHGE\5FRHIÀFLHQW
5HVXOWV7KHELH[SRQHQWLDOPRGHOÀWWHGVPP':,VLJQDOVEHWWHUWKDQ
WKHPRQRH[SRQHQWLDOPRGHO 5YV ,QWKHVPPLQWHUYDOWKH
WULH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLVZDVVXSHULRUWRELH[SRQHQWLDO 5YV 7UL
H[SRQHQWLDOSDUDPHWHUVLQWKLVLQWHUYDOZHUHIIDVW IVORZ
' VORZ[PPV7KHSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQH[WUDFWHGE\
ELH[SRQHQWLDOPRGHOLQWKHVPPLQWHUYDO I DQGIVORZ
VKRZHGKLJKSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQ U
&RQFOXVLRQ7ULH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLVRIO\PSKQRGHV':,VLJQDOVLVIHDVLEOHDQG
DFFXUDWH XVLQJ YHU\ KLJK EYDOXHV ,W FRXOG SURYLGH QHZ SDUDPHWHUV SUREDEO\
OLQNHGWRYHQXODUDQGO\PSKDWLFÁRZ SRWHQWLDOO\YDOXDEOHLQWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRI
WKHWLVVXHVPLFURVWUXFWXUHDQGIXQFWLRQDOLW\
%
&RPSDUDWLYHVWXG\RI0'&7DQG&%&7RIWKHWHPSRUDOERQH
DQDWRP\RWRVFOHURVLVVXSHULRUVHPLFLUFXODUFDQDOGHKLVFHQFHHDUO\
H[SHULHQFHDQGSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
'9ROGHUV13HWHUV%'H)RHU.%DFKHU-:&DVVHOPDQ%UXJHV%(
$QWZHUS%(*HQW%( GDYLGYROGHUV#D]VLQWMDQEH
3XUSRVH0XOWLGHWHFWRU&7 0'&7 LVWKHFXUUHQWVWDQGDUGIRUUDGLRORJLFH[DPLQD
WLRQRIWKHWHPSRUDOERQH7KLVVWXG\ZDQWHGWRYHULI\WKHQRQLQIHULRULW\RUVXSHULRULW\
RIFRQHEHDP&7 &%&7 RYHU0'&7LQWKHWHPSRUDOERQHIRUGHWHFWLQJDQDWRPL
FDOVWUXFWXUHVRWRVFOHURVLVDQGVXSHULRUVHPLFLUFXODUFDQDOGHKLVFHQFH 66&'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWV SDWLHQWVHQUROPHQWLQSURJUHVV LQWKUHH
FHQWUHVZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\VWXGLHGDIWHULQIRUPHGFRQVHQWDQGHWKLFDOFRPPLWWHH
DSSURYDO%RWK&%&7DQG0'&7ZLWKDVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQRIUHVSHFWLYHO\
DQG PP ZHUH SHUIRUPHG LQ HYHU\ SDWLHQW 7ZR UHDGHUV VFRUHG VPDOO
DQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHV VFRUH RWRVFOHURVLVVWDJH VFRUH DQG66&' VFRUH
LQDEOLQGHGUDQGRPLVHGPDQQHU
5HVXOWV3UHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVVKRZHGWKDW&%&7KDVDQRYHUDOOVXSHULRULW\IRUWKH
YLVXDOLVDWLRQRIHYHU\DQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHLQWKHD[LDODQGFRURQDOSODQHRIWKHWHP
SRUDOERQHPRVWVLJQLÀFDQWLQWKHFRURQDOSODQH&%&7FRUUHFWHGDIDOVHQHJDWLYH
GLDJQRVHRI0'&7IRURWRVFOHURVLVLQ RXWRIFDVHV DQGDIDOVHSRVLWLYH
GLDJQRVHRI0'&7IRU66&'LQ RXWRIFDVHV 7KHDYHUDJHUDGLDWLRQ
GRVH &7',YRO RI&%&7DQG0'&7ZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\P*\DQGP*\
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
&RQFOXVLRQ&%&7DOORZVVWXG\LQJWKHWHPSRUDOERQHDQDWRP\LQPRUHGHWDLO
0RUHRYHUWKHVHQVLWLYLW\WRGHWHFWRWRVFOHURVLVDQGHVSHFLDOO\WKHVSHFLÀFLW\WRGHWHFW
66&'LVKLJKHUFRPSDUHGWR0'&77KHDYHUDJHUDGLDWLRQGRVHRIDQH[DPLQDWLRQ
RIWKHWHPSRUDOERQHZLWK&%&7LVOHVVWKDQKDOIWKHGRVHRIDQH[DPLQDWLRQZLWK
0'&7PDNLQJLWWKHWHFKQLTXHRIFKRLFH
%
3UHYDOHQFHRIDQWHULRULQWHUQDODXGLWRU\FDQDO´GLYHUWLFXOXPµRQ&7
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKRWRVFOHURVLV
0&+RHEHULJV--:DWHUYDO5-6WRNURRV$$56WDGOHU0DDVWULFKW1/
FKULVWLDQQHKRHEH#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH,QSDWLHQWVZLWKRWRVFOHURVLVDQRWRVFOHURWLFK\SRGHQVHFDYLWDWLQJSODTXH
DWWKHPHGLDOPDUJLQRIWKHRWLFFDSVXOHVHHQDVDQLQGHQWDWLRQRU´GLYHUWLFXOXPµRI
WKHDQWHULRUPDUJLQRIWKHLQWHUQDODXGLWRU\FDQDO ,$& PLJKWEHSUHVHQW:HDLPHG
WRGHWHUPLQHWKHSUHYDOHQFHRIWKLVHDVLO\LGHQWLÀDEOHDQWHULRU,$&LQGHQWDWLRQRQ
&7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKRWRVFOHURVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHKLJKUHVROXWLRQ&7VFDQV PP
RIWKHPDVWRLGERQHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKFRQGXFWLYHRUPL[HGKHDULQJORVVIURP-DQXDU\
WR'HFHPEHUZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGE\QHXURUDGLRORJLVWVDQG
(17VXUJHRQ$WRWDORIHDUVZHUHVFRUHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHDQGVHYHULW\RI
RWRVFOHURVLV JUDGHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKH6\PRQV)DQQLQJFODVVLÀFDWLRQIHQHVWUDO
SDWFK\SHULFRFKOHDUH[WHQVLYHSHULFRFKOHDU DQGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIDQWHULRU
,$&GLYHUWLFXOXPSODTXH GHÀQHGDVDQREYLRXVQRWFKLQWKHDQWHULRU,$&PDUJLQH
LVRGHQVHWRWKH,$&LWVHOIDIDLQWFXUYDWXUHRIWKHZDOOZDVVFRUHGQHJDWLYH
5HVXOWV$QWHULRU ,$& GLYHUWLFXOXP ZDV REVHUYHG LQ HDUV ZLWK RQO\
IHQHVWUDORWRVFOHURVLVLQ RIJUDGHSDWFK\FRFKOHDURWRVFOHURVLVDQG
LQ ZLWKJUDGHRWRVFOHURVLV2QO\SDWLHQWZLWKRXW&7VLJQVRIRWR
VFOHURVLVEXWZLWKFOLQLFDOVWDSHGLDOÀ[DWLRQGHPRQVWUDWHGELODWHUDO,$&K\SRGHQVLW\
HDUVRU
&RQFOXVLRQ(YDOXDWLRQRIWKHDQWHULRU,$&PLJKWDLGLQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIQRWRQO\
FRFKOHDUEXWDOVRLQWKHPRUHVXEWOHIHQHVWUDORWRVFOHURVLV
%
,PSURYHGLQYLYRYLVXDOLVDWLRQDQGHYDOXDWLRQRIHQGRO\PSKDWLF
K\GURSVXVLQJKLJKÀHOG05,LQ0HQLHUҋVGLVHDVHDQGFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKDXGLRYHVWLEXODUIXQFWLRQ
:+)ODW]5*XHUNRY%%(UWO:DJQHU2'LHWULFK0)5HLVHU
0XQLFK'( ZLOKHOPÁDW]#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH 7R LPSURYH GHWHFWLRQ DQG HYDOXDWLRQ RI HQGRO\PSKDWLF K\GURSV LQ
0HQLHUHҋV GLVHDVH LQ YLYR XVLQJ 05, DQG WR GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU WKH GHJUHH RI
HQGRO\PSKDWLFK\GURSVDVLWLVGHWHFWHGLQYLYRLQSDWLHQWVZLWKGHÀQLWH0HQLHUHҋV
GLVHDVHFRUUHODWHVZLWKDXGLRYHVWLEXODUIXQFWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPFOLQLFDOV\PSWRPVRI0HQLHUHҋV
GLVHDVHDFFRUGLQJWR$$2+16FULWHULDZHUHH[DPLQHGLQDSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\'L
OXWHGJDGROLQLXPZDVDGPLQLVWHUHGLQWUDW\PSDQLFDOO\KRXUVSULRUWRWKH05VFDQ
05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJD7VFDQQHUXVLQJDGHGLFDWHGFKDQQHOVXUIDFHFRLO
DQGDKHDGFRLODFTXLULQJD')/$,5VHTXHQFHD',576(VHTXHQFHDQGD
KLJKUHVROXWLRQ7UXH),63GXDOH[FLWDWLRQVHTXHQFH &,66 &RUUHODWLRQZLWKFOLQLFDO
V\PSWRPVDQGDXGLRYHVWLEXODUIXQFWLRQWHVWLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDXGLRPHWULF
KHDULQJWHVWVFDORULFVWLPXODWLRQHOHFWURFRFKOHRJUDSK\ (&RFK* DQGYHVWLEXODU
HYRNHGP\RJHQLFSRWHQWLDOV 9(03
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHGHJUHHRIK\GURSVRQ
WKHRQHKDQGDQGWKHDYHUDJHGKHDULQJOHYHODWDQGN+]DQGWKH
YHVWLEXODUHYRNHGP\RJHQLFSRWHQWLDOLQWHUDXUDODPSOLWXGHUDWLRRQWKHRWKHUKDQG
$WUHQGWRZDUGVDFRUUHODWLRQZDVQRWLFHGEHWZHHQWKHK\GURSVDQGWKHFDORULF
UHVSRQVHQRFRUUHODWLRQZDVQRWLFHGEHWZHHQWKHK\GURSVDQGWKH63$3UDWLR
7KHGHJUHHRIHQGRO\PSKDWLFK\GURSVFRUUHODWHVZLWKDSURJUHVVLYHORVVRIDXGLWRU\
DQGVDFFXOXVIXQFWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWK0HQLHUHCVGLVHDVH
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH GHJUHH RI HQGRO\PSKDWLF K\GURSV LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK GHÀQLWH
0HQLHUHҋVGLVHDVHDVLWLVGHWHFWHGE\LQYLYR05,LPDJLQJFRUUHODWHVZLWKDORVV
RIDXGLRYHVWLEXODUIXQFWLRQ7KLVXQGHUOLQHVWKHXVHIXOQHVVRIWKLVWHFKQLTXHLQWKH
HYDOXDWLRQRI0HQLHUHҋVGLVHDVH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHVRILQFUHPHQWDO05,SURWRFROVSHUIRUPHG
RQ7DQG7VFDQQHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\FRQGXFWHGRQDFRKRUWRISDWLHQWV
VXVSHFWHGZLWKDFTXLUHGRUUHVLGXDOUHFXUUHQWFKROHVWHDWRPD$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHU
ZHQW7DQG7QRQ(3':,DQGSDWLHQWVKDGDGGLWLRQDOXQHQKDQFHG
7GHOD\HGJDGROLQLXPHQKDQFHG7DQGKLJKUHVROXWLRQ7ZHLJKWHGVWDQGDUG
DFTXLVLWLRQV2QWKHEDVLVRILQLWLDOFOLQLFDODQGLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVSDWLHQWVZKHWKHU
EHQHÀWHGIURPW\PSDQRSODVW\RUIURPDVWULFWRWRVFRSLFVXUYH\,PDJLQJVXUJLFDO
DQGIROORZXSÀQGLQJVFRQFOXGHGWRDWRWDORIPLGGOHHDUOHVLRQVLQFOXGLQJ
FKROHVWHDWRPDV)RUHDFKFDVHUDGLRORJLVWVUHYLHZHGLQFUHPHQWDO05,SURWR
FROVGLIIHULQJRQWKHPDJQHWLFÀHOGRIWKH':,DFTXLVLWLRQVLQWHUSUHWHG 77
77 DQGFRPSULVLQJWKHWKUHHQRQ':RUGDLQHGVWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHV$WHDFK
VWHSGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHVZHUHH[SUHVVHGDVVHQVLELOLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYH
DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVDQGDFFXUDF\8QLYDULDWHDQGPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VHV
DVVHVVHG UHDGHU VHTXHQFH DGGLQJ DQG PDJQHWLF ÀHOG HIIHFW XSRQ GLDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFHV &KROHVWHDWRPDVҋ$'& YDOXHV DQG ':, VLJQDOV ZHUH FRPSDUHG
DFFRUGLQJWRPDJQHWLFÀHOGXVLQJSDLUHGWDQGELQRPLDOWHVWV
5HVXOWV8QLYDULDWHDQGPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VHVFRQFOXGHGWRQRVLJQLÀFDQWUHDGHU
RU VHTXHQFH DGGLQJ HIIHFW RYHU GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFHV REWDLQHG E\ QRQ(3
':,DORQH8QLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVVKRZHGQRVLJQLÀFDQWPDJQHWLFÀHOGHIIHFWHLWKHU
&KROHVWHDWRPDVҋ$'&YDOXHVDQG':,VLJQDOVGLGQRWGLIIHUVLJQLÀFDQWO\DFFRUGLQJ
WRPDJQHWLFÀHOG
&RQFOXVLRQ,Q7DQG705,DVHOIVXIÀFLHQWQRQ(3':,SURWRFROFRXOG
EHHPSOR\HGIRUFKROHVWHDWRPDGLDJQRVLV7KLVQHHGVWREHFRQÀUPHGE\IXUWKHU
VWXGLHVRYHUDZLGHUDQGOHVVKHWHURJHQHRXVFRKRUW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG86 &(86 LQWKHGHSLFWLRQRIWKHKHSD
WRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& GLDJQRVWLFYDVFXODULW\SDWWHUQ K\SHUYDVFXODULW\GXULQJ
DUWHULDOSKDVHIROORZHGE\K\SRYDVFXODULW\GXULQJSRUWDOYHQRXVODWHSKDVH LQVPDOO
+&&QRGXOHV FP LQFRPSDULVRQWRFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGURZPXOWLGHWHFWRU
&7DQG05LPDJLQJZLWK*G%237$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QHKXQGUHGDQGWZHQW\FLUUKRWLFSDWLHQWV PDOHV
IHPDOHV PHDQ DJH6' \HDUV ZLWK VPDOO +&&V ZHUH LQFOXGHG
(DFKQRGXOHZDVVFDQQHGE\&(86DIWHUVXOSKXUKH[DÁXRULGHÀOOHGPLFUREXEEOH
PXOWLSKDVH FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG URZ PXOWLGHWHFWRU &7 DQG FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
05LPDJLQJDIWHU*G%237$LQMHFWLRQ GD\VIURP&(86DQG&7 1RGXOH
YDVFXODULW\DW&(86&7DQG05LPDJLQJZDVHYDOXDWHGVLGHE\VLGHE\LQGH
SHQGHQWEOLQGHGUHDGHUV
5HVXOWV&(86YV&7GLGQRWGLIIHULQWKHGHSLFWLRQRIK\SHUYDVFXODULW\IROORZHG
E\K\SRYDVFXODULW\ UHDGHUYV&(86 YV&7 YV
QRGXOHV3!:LOFR[RQWHVW ZLWKKLJKLQWHUUHDGHUDJUHHPHQW NVWDWLVWLFV
IRU&(86DQGIRU&7 ZKLOH05LPDJLQJUHYHDOHGWKLVSDWWHUQLQQRGXOHV
IRUERWKUHDGHUV 3 2WKHUYDVFXODULW\SDWWHUQVLQFOXGHGK\SHUYDVFXODULW\
IROORZHGE\LVRYDVFXODULW\ UHDGHUYV&(86 YV&7
YV 05 QRGXOHV IRU ERWK UHDGHUV LVRYDVFXODULW\ IROORZHG E\
K\SRYDVFXODULW\ UHDGHUYV&(86 YV&7 YV
05 QRGXOHV DQGSHUVLVWHQWK\SRYDVFXODULW\ &(86 &7
DQG05 QRGXOHVIRUERWKUHDGHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ&(86GLGQRWGLIIHUIURPPXOWLSKDVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGURZPXOWL
GHWHFWRU&7LQWKHGHSLFWLRQRIGLDJQRVWLFYDVFXODULW\SDWWHUQLQVPDOO+&&VZKLOH
05LPDJLQJZLWK*G%237$UHYHDOHGWKLVSDWWHUQLQDQKLJKHUQXPEHURIQRGXOHV
%
0LGGOHHDUFKROHVWHDWRPDFRPSDUHGGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHVRI
LQFUHPHQWDO05,SURWRFROVLQFOXGLQJQRQHFKRSODQDUGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJSHUIRUPHGRQ7DQG7VFDQQHUV
-/LQFRW65LHKP1%DED\-)0DWHUQ10H\HU)9HLOORQ3DULV)5
6WUDVERXUJ)5 MXOLHQOLQFRW#JPDLOFRP
5RRP,.
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
66E
+&&GLDJQRVLV
0RGHUDWRUV
&$\XVR%DUFHORQD(6
$)XUODQ3LWWVEXUJK3$86
%
+\SHUYDVFXODUKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDVKRZLQJK\SHULQWHQVLW\RQ
JDGR[HWLFDFLGHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJDOHVVPDOLJQDQWVXEW\SHZLWK
ORZSURGXFWLRQRI$)3DQG3,9.$,,
$.LWDR20DWVXL1<RQHGD..R]DND6.RED\DVKL:.RGD7*DEDWD
<1DNDQXPD6.DQHNR.DQD]DZD-3 D]XVD#PHGNDQD]DZDXDFMS
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6SHFWUDO&7RIK\SHUYDVFXODUOLYHUOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK+&&
LQYHVWLJDWLRQRILPDJHTXDOLW\DQGVHQVLWLYLW\
3/Y;/LQ.&KHQ-*DR<6KHQ=KHQJ]KRX&16KDQJKDL&1
%HLMLQJ&1
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHPRQRFKURPDWLFLPDJLQJIURPVSHFWUDO&7RIK\SHUYDVFXODU
OLYHUOHVLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK+&&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\WKUHHSDWLHQWVZLWKVPDOOKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQR
PDVXQGHUZHQW6SHFWUDO&7VFDQQLQJGXULQJWKHODWHDUWHULDOSKDVH $3 DQGSRUWDO
YHQRXVSKDVH 33 %RWKFRQYHQWLRQDON9SSRO\FKURPDWLFLPDJHV SURWRFRO$
DQGDVHWRIPRQRFKURPDWLFLPDJHVZLWKHQHUJ\OHYHOUDQJLQJIURPNH9WRNH9
ZLWKNH9LQFUHPHQWV SURWRFRO% ZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG,PDJHQRLVHIRUQRUPDO
OLYHURUWLVVXHZDVPHDVXUHGDQGWKHFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 IRUWXPRXUVZDV
FDOFXODWHGIRUERWKSURWRFROV7KHKLJKHVW&15DQGWKHORZHVWLPDJHQRLVHZHUH
FKRVHQIURPSURWRFRO%DQGFRPSDUHGZLWKSURWRFRO$ZLWK6WXGHQWWWHVW 6366
5HVXOWV 7KH KLJKHVW &15 IURP PRQRFKURPDWLF LPDJHV GLVWULEXWHG DW NH9
NH9 DQGNH9 HQHUJ\OHYHOVIRU$3DQGNH9
DQGNH9 IRU337KH&15YDOXHVIURPWKHRSWLPDOPRQRFKUR
PDWLFLPDJHVIRU$3 DQG33 ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQ
WKRVHIURPWKHSURWRFRO$ DQGIRU$3DQG33UHVSHFWLYHO\
S ,QDGGLWLRQWKHORZHVWLPDJHQRLVHVLQWKHSURWRFRO%GXULQJWKHWZR
SKDVHVRFFXUUHGDWNH9 $3"33 ORZHUWKDQWKRVHLQSURWRFRO$
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH RSWLPDO PRQRFKURPDWLF HQHUJ\ OHYHO RI VSHFWUDO LPDJLQJ FDQ
LQFUHDVH WKH VHQVLWLYLW\ LQ GHWHFWLQJ K\SHUYDVFXODU OLYHU OHVLRQV ZLWKRXW LPDJH
TXDOLW\ORVV
%
+&&ZDVKRXWDWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ &(86
LVRHFKRJHQLFLW\RUK\SRHFKRJHQLFLW\"$FRPSDULVRQZLWK0'&7
35L]]DUGL05DYDQHOOL/6RWWRFRUQROD$*LDUGLQL50DUROGL3&DEDVVD
%UHVFLD,7 MDP#YLUJLOLRLW
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHSDWWHUQRIHQKDQFHPHQWRI+&&DW&(86DQG0'&7
IRFXVLQJRQWKH&(86ZDVKRXWIHDWXUHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2QHKXQGUHGDQGWZHQW\WKUHHSDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\+&&
XQGHUZHQW&(86DQGVXEVHTXHQW0'&7ZLWKLQPRQWK7KH+&&GLDJQRVLVZDV
EDVHGRQKLVWRORJ\LQSDWLHQWV VXUJHU\ELRSV\ RQLPDJLQJLQ
SDWLHQWV,QWKHFDVHRIPXOWLIRFDOGLVHDVHRQHWDUJHWOHVLRQIRUHDFKSDWLHQW
ZDVHYDOXDWHG&(86ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJ6RQRYXH %UDFFR,PDJLQJ0LODQR
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH7RDQDO\VHWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWXPRXUPDUNHUVSURGXFWLRQKLVWR
ORJLFDOIHDWXUHVDQGVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RQWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHRIJDGR[HWLFDFLG
HQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJLQKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDV +&&V
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6XUJLFDOO\UHVHFWHGRUELRSV\GLDJQRVHGK\SHUYDV
FXODU+&&VZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVK\SRLQWHQVH+&&V Q RUK\SHULQWHQVH+&&V
Q FRPSDUHGWRWKHEDFNJURXQGOLYHURQWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHRIJDGR[HWLF
DFLGHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJ:HDQDO\VHGWKHDOSKDIHWRSURWHLQ $)3 DQGSURWHLQ
LQGXFHG E\ YLWDPLQ . DEVHQFH RU DQWDJRQLVW,, 3,9.$,, SURGXFWLRQ E\ VHUXP
DQDO\VLVDQGLPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLFDOVWDLQLQJWKHQFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQK\SRLQWHQVH
+&&VDQGK\SHULQWHQVH+&&V:HDOVRDQDO\VHGWKHSDWKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHVVXFK
DVPDFURJURZWKSDWWHUQGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQJUDGHYHVVHOLQYDVLRQDQGLQWUDKHSDWLF
PHWDVWDVLV6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQHDFKUHVXOW
5HVXOWV7KHVHUXPOHYHOVRIWXPRXUPDUNHUVZHUHORZHULQK\SHULQWHQVH+&&VWKDQ
LQK\SRLQWHQVH+&&V7KHDYHUDJHYDOXHRI$)3ZDVQJPOWRQJPO
3 $)3/IUDFWLRQWR 3 DQG3,9.$,,P$8PO
WRP$8PO 3 7KHLPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLFDO$)3DQG3,9.$,,H[SUHV
VLRQVZHUHDOVRGHFUHDVHGLQK\SHULQWHQVH+&&VFRPSDUHGWRWKDWRIK\SRLQWHQVH
+&&V 3DQG3 3DWKRORJLFDOO\WKHJUDGHRIGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQZDV
KLJKHU 3 DQGWKHSRUWDOYHLQLQYDVLRQZDVIHZHULQK\SHULQWHQVH+&&V
WKDQLQK\SRLQWHQVH+&&V YV3
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHWXPRXUPDUNHUVSURGXFWLRQZDVUHSUHVVHGLQK\SHULQWHQVH+&&V
RQJDGR[HWLFDFLGHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJZLWKKLJKJUDGHRIGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQDQGIHZ
SRUWDOYHLQLQYDVLRQV,WLQGLFDWHGWKDWK\SHULQWHQVH+&&VZRXOGEHFODVVLÀHGLQWR
DOHVVPDOLJQDQWVXEW\SHWKDQWKDWRIK\SRLQWHQVH+&&V
&RPSDULVRQRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG86WRURZPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7
DQG05ZLWK*G%237$LQWKHGHSLFWLRQRIGLDJQRVWLFYDVFXODULW\
SDWWHUQLQKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDQRGXOHVFPLQGLDPHWHU
(4XDLD/'H3DROL63XOYLUHQWL%&DELEER0&RYD7ULHVWH,7
TXDLD#XQLWVLW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
,WDO\ 7KHHFKRJHQLFLW\RI+&&FRPSDUHGWROLYHUSDUHQFK\PDZDVDVVHVVHGLQ
WKUHHSKDVHVDUWHULDO V SRUWDO V DQGODWH V 7KHUHVXOWVZHUH
FRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHIURPPXOWLSKDVLF0'&7DQGPDWFKHGZLWKK,VWRORJLFDOJUDGH
ZKHQ DYDLODEOH 7\SLFDO SDWWHUQ 73 ZDV GHÀQHG DV DUWHULDO LSHUHFKRJHQLFLW\
GHQVLW\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKSRUWDODQGODWHLSRHFKRJHQLFLW\GHQVLW\
5HVXOWV$W&(86RQO\RI+&& VKRZHGD73 ZHUH
LVRHFKRLFLQWKHSRUWDOSKDVHDQGRIWKHVH VKRZHGLVRHFKRJHQLFLW\DOVR
LQWKHODWHSKDVH&RQYHUVHO\D73ZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGLQRI+&&
DW 0'&7 0XOWLYDULDWH DQDO\VLV LQFOXGLQJ VHYHUDO QRGXOH DQG SDWLHQWUHODWHG
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVVKRZHGWKDWRQO\K,VWRORJLFDOJUDGHLQÁXHQFHGYDVFXODULVDWLRQSDW
WHUQDW&(86ZHOOGLIIHUHQWLDWHG+&&ZHUHPRUHOLNHO\WRVKRZDVORZRUDEVHQW
ZDVKRXWDWV
&RQFOXVLRQ+&&VKRZVGLIIHUHQWHQKDQFHPHQWSDWWHUQDW&(86DQG0'&77KH
SUHVHQFHRILVRHFKRJHQLFLW\LQWKHSRUWDORUERWKSRUWDODQGODWHSKDVHLVSUHYDOHQW
LQZHOOGLIIHUHQWLDWHGOHVLRQV)RUWKLVUHDVRQWKHDVVRFLDWLRQRI&(86WR0'&7
FRXOGSURYLGHDGMXQFWLYHLQIRUPDWLRQLQWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIK\SHUYDVFXODU+&&
QRGXOHV
%
'\QDPLF&7SHUIXVLRQWHFKQLTXHLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI
QHRDQJLRJHQHVLVWXPRXUUHODWHGSKHQRPHQRQLQGLDJQRVLVDQG
WUHDWPHQWRI+&&OHVLRQLQFLUUKRWLFSDWLHQWV
',SSROLWR3%RQDIÀQL&&DSUDUR)0HORQL5&RUVR66LURQL0RQ]D,7
GDYLGHDWHQD#WLVFDOLQHWLW
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHYDOXHRISHUIXVLRQFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7S LQWKH
TXDQWLWDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUUHODWHGQHRDQJLRJHQHVLVIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI
GLDJQRVLVDQGWUHDWPHQWRI+&&OHVLRQV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$ WRWDO RI &7S VWXG\ ZHUH SHUIRUPHG LQ FLUUKRWLF
SDWLHQWVE\DQDO\VLQJELRSV\SURYHQ+&&OHVLRQVDQG+&&WUHDWHGOHVLRQ
ZLWK7$&(RU5)$'\QDPLFVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7 %ULOOLDQFH
3KLOLSV1/ E\DFTXLULQJG\QDPLFVOLFHVVFDQIRUDWRWDORIVFDQVDWÀ[HG
WDEOHSRVLWLRQGXULQJLQMHFWLRQRIPORIQRQLRQLFFRQWUDVWDJHQWDWÁRZUDWHRI
POVHF$GHGLFDWHGSHUIXVLRQVRIWZDUHZKLFKJHQHUDWHGDTXDQWLWDWLYHPDSRI
DUWHULDODQGSRUWDOSHUIXVLRQE\PHDQVRIFRORXUVFDOHZDVHPSOR\HG7KHIROORZLQJ
SHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVIRUWKHZKROHOLYHUDQG+&&OHVLRQVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGKHSDWLF
SHUIXVLRQ +3 DUWHULDOSHUIXVLRQ $3 EORRGYROXPH %9 KHSDWLFSHUIXVLRQLQGH[
+3, DQGWLPHWRSHDN 773
5HVXOWV,Q+&&VOHVLRQVHYDOXDWHGWKHIROORZLQJTXDQWLWDWLYHGDWDZHUHREWDLQHG
+3 POVHFJU %9 POPJ $3 POPLQ
+3, 773 VHF 7KHSHUIXVLRQYDOXHVFDOFXODWHGLQOHVLRQV
FRUUHFWO\ WUHDWHG ZHUH +3 POVHF JU %9 PO PJ
$3 POPLQ +3, DQG773 VHF ZKLOHLQSDUWLDOO\
RULQFRPSOHWHO\WUHDWHGOHVLRQVZHUH+3 POJUVHF %9 POJU
$3 POPLQ 773 VHF +3, $VWDWLVWLFDO
GLIIHUHQFHZDVREWDLQHGIRUDOOWKHSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVHYDOXDWHGZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQW
ORZHU S YDOXHVLQFRUUHFWO\WUHDWHGOHVLRQRULQVXUURXQGLQJSDUHQFK\PD
WKDQLQYLDEOH+&&WLVVXHLQUHODWLRQWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIDUWHULDOVWUXFWXUHVWKDW
GHYHORSLQYLDEOHQHRSODVWLFWLVVXH
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDW&7SWHFKQLTXHFDQKHOSLQQRQLQYDVLYH
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIWXPRXUEORRGVXSSO\UHODWHGWRWKHIRUPDWLRQRIQHZDUWHULDOVWUXF
WXUHV QHRDQJLRJHQHVLV ZKLFKDUHHVVHQWLDOIRUWXPRXUJURZWKDOORZLQJDOVRWKH
DVVHVVPHQWRIWKHUDSHXWLFUHVSRQVH
%
&DQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,GLIIHUHQWLDWHPDOLJQDQWIURPEHQLJQ
KHSDWRFHOOXODUWXPRXULQWKHQRQFLUUKRWLFOLYHU"
0$))LVFKHU'$5DSWLV2)'RQDWL6%UHLWHQVWHLQ3$&ODYLHQ
+$ONDGKL0$3DWDN=XULFK&+ PLFKDHODOH[DQGHUÀVFKHU#XV]FK
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHZKHWKHU05LPDJLQJÀQGLQJVFDQEHXVHGWR
GLIIHUHQWLDWHKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& IURPKHSDWRFHOOXODUDGHQRPD +$
DQGDW\SLFDOIRFDOQRGXODUK\SHUSODVLD )1+ LQQRQFLUUKRWLFSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDO,QWRWDOFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV PHQ\HDUV
ZKRXQGHUZHQWOLYHUUHVHFWLRQIRU+&& Q +$ Q DQG)1+ Q ZHUH
LQFOXGHG LQ WKLV LQWHUQDWLRQDOPXOWLFHQWUH VWXG\ 3UHRSHUDWLYH OLYHU05, ZDV
DQDO\VHG E\ WZR LQGHSHQGHQW UDGLRORJLVWV IRU WKH IROORZLQJ ,PDJLQJ )LQGLQJV
OHVLRQGLDPHWHU OHVLRQGHPDUFDWLRQ SUHVHQFH RI VDWHOOLWHOHVLRQV FHQWUDOVFDU
OHVLRQFDSVXOHIDWKDHPRUUKDJHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ 6, RQXQHQKDQFHG7DQG7
ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDUWHULDOHQKDQFHPHQWDQGFRQWUDVWPHGLDZDVKRXW'LIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQERWKUHDGHUVZHUHUHVROYHGLQDFRQVHQVXVUHDGLQJDQGLQGHSHQGHQWGLDJ
QRVWLFSDUDPHWHUVIRUGLDJQRVLVRI+&&ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGE\PXOWLYDULDQFHDQDO\VLV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5HVXOWV+&&VKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWKLJKHUIUHTXHQF\ DOOS RID 7K\SRLQ
WHQVLW\ YV E 7K\SHULQWHQVLW\ YV F SUHVHQFHRI
IDW YV G VDWHOOLWHOHVLRQV YV H ODFN RI DUWHULDO
HQKDQFHPHQW YV I FRQWUDVWPHGLDZDVKRXWLQWKHHTXLOLEULXPSKDVH
YV DVFRPSDUHGWRERWK+$DQG)1+6LJQLÀFDQWSUHGLFWRUVIRU
GLDJQRVLVRI+&& 5RGGVUDWLRS ZHUH7K\SRLQWHQVLW\ 5 SUHVHQFH
RIVDWHOOLWHOHVLRQV 5 DQGFRQWUDVWPHGLDZDVKRXW 5
&RQFOXVLRQ 05LPDJLQJ FKDUDFWHULVWLFV LQ SULPDU\ QRQFLUUKRWLF OLYHU WXPRXUV
VKRZVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV,QGHSHQGHQWSDUDPHWHUVIRUGLDJQRVLVRI+&&DUH
7K\SRLQWHQVLW\SUHVHQFHRIVDWHOOLWHOHVLRQVDQGFRQWUDVWPHGLDZDVKRXWZKLFK
PLJKWKHOSWRGLIIHUWKLVHQWLWLHVLQWKHIXWXUH
%
&RPSDULVRQRISURVSHFWLYHO\WULJJHUHG 37 )/$6+ZLWK
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\VHOIJDWHG 56* )/$6+VHTXHQFHVIRULPDJLQJRI
H[SHULPHQWDOOLYHUWXPRXUVLQUDWVDW7
3)ULHV.0DWWKHV$0XHOOHU*'HQGD$0DVVPDQQ
-6SHUOLQJ*6FKQHLGHU$%XHFNHU56HLGHO
+RPEXUJ'( GUSHWHUIULHV#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHSURVSHFWLYHO\WULJJHUHG)/$6+ 37 XVLQJUHVSLUDWRU\VLJ
QDOVPRQLWRUHGE\DQH[WHUQDOSUHVVXUHWUDQVGXFHU ZLWKUHWURVSHFWLYHO\VHOIJDWHG
)/$6+ 56* VHTXHQFHV EDVHGRQDQDYLJDWRUWHFKQLTXH,QWUD*DWH%UXNHU
*HUPDQ\ IRUXQHQKDQFHGDQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG7ZLPDJLQJRIH[SHULPHQWDO
OLYHUWXPRXUVLQUDWVDW7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVUDWV :$*5LM ZLWKH[SHULPHQWDOO\ LQGXFHGKHSDWLF
FRORQ FDQFHU PHWDVWDVHV ZHUH VXEMHFWHG WR 05, XVLQJ D 7 DQLPDO VFDQQHU
%UXNHU%LR6SHF*HUPDQ\ ZLWKDFKDQQHOYROXPHFRLO:HDFTXLUHGD37 75
7()$ )29[FPPDWUL[ [ DQGD56* 757(
)$ )29 [ FP PDWUL[ [ VOLFH WKLFNQHVV PP HDFK VHTXHQFH
DW LGHQWLFDO SRVLWLRQV$IWHU LQWUDYHQRXV LQMHFWLRQ RI PPRONJ %: *G'73$
ZHSHUIRUPHGDQDOWHUQDWLQJDFTXLVLWLRQRIHLWKHUVHTXHQFHVDWIRXUFRQVHFXWLYH
WLPHSRLQWV XSWRPLQDIWHULQMHFWLRQ 615DQG&15ZHUHFDOFXODWHGEDVHG
RQ52,PHDVXUHPHQWZLWKLQWKHWXPRXUDQGDGMDFHQWQRUPDOOLYHUWLVVXHIRUERWK
VHTXHQFHV$:LOFR[RQPDWFKHGSDLUVVLJQHGUDQNWHVWDQGDSDLUHGWWHVWZHUH
SHUIRUPHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV S
5HVXOWV1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHREWDLQHGEHWZHHQWKH37DQG
WKH56*VHTXHQFHDIWHU&0LQMHFWLRQUHJDUGLQJ615 WXPRXU56* PHDQ6'
37S 615 OLYHU56*37S DQG
WKH&15 7XOLYHU56*37S
&RQFOXVLRQ37DQG56*)/$6+VHTXHQFHVSURYLGHFRPSDUDEOH615DQG&15
RIQRUPDOOLYHUWLVVXHDQGH[SHULPHQWDOO\LQGXFHGOLYHUWXPRXUV%HLQJLQGHSHQG
HQWRIH[WHUQDOWULJJHUGHYLFHVWKHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\VHOIJDWHGDSSURDFKPD\EHD
IDYRXUDEOHDOWHUQDWLYHIRUDEGRPLQDOLPDJLQJLQVPDOOURGHQWV
%
6LQJOHHQHUJ\ORZYROWDJHDUWHULDOSKDVHVFDQQLQJLQFUHDVHV
FRQVSLFXLW\RIK\SHUYDVFXODUOHVLRQVRIWKHOLYHUDQLQWUDSDWLHQWVWXG\
*$=DPERQL0&$PEURVHWWL(=LYHORQJKL53R]]L0XFHOOL9HURQD,7
J]DPERQL#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH LQWUDSDWLHQW D VLQJOHHQHUJ\ ORZYROWDJH DUWHULDO SKDVH
SURWRFRODQGDNYSURWRFROIRUGHWHFWLQJK\SHUYDVFXODUIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV K)//
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK FKURQLF OLYHU GLVHDVH DQG K)//
XQGHUZHQWDEGRPLQDO0'&7ZLWKN9DUWHULDOSKDVH WHVWJURXS RQDURZ
VFDQQHU7KLVZDVFRPSDUHGWRDSUHYLRXVN9VFDQ7KHPHDQLQWHUVFDQLQWHUYDO
ZDVGD\VOHVLRQVZHUHQRWWUHDWHGEHWZHHQH[DPV6FDQVZHUHFRPSDUHG
IRUDWWHQXDWLRQDQGVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQLQWKHOLYHUDRUWDDQGODUJHVWK)//LPDJH
QRLVH &15 &7', DQG '/3 SDLUHG WWHVW (IIHFWLYH GRVH ZDV FDOFXODWHG ZLWK
7/'PHDVXUHPHQWV
5HVXOWV$OOVFDQVZHUHRIGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\DFFRUGLQJWRWKHUHSRUWLQJUDGLRORJLVW
0HDQDWWHQXDWLRQZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHWHVWJURXSWKDQLQWKHFRQWUROJURXS
LQWKHDRUWD YV+8 OLYHU YV+8
DQGK)// YV+8 DOOS &7',DQG'/3ZHUH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQWKHWHVWJURXS YVP*\DQGYV
P*\[FPUHVSHFWLYHO\DOOS /HVLRQFRQVSLFXLW\ +8QRGXOH
+8OLYHU ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHWHVWJURXS YV+8
S 0HDQLPDJHQRLVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHWHVWJURXSWKDQLQ
FRQWUROJURXS YV+8S /HVLRQ&15ZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\
GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQWKHWZRSURWRFROV7/'HIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRU
WKHWHVWSURWRFRO YVP6YS
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH XVH RI D N9S DUWHULDO SKDVH SURWRFRO IRU DEGRPLQDO &7
LQFUHDVHV FRQVSLFXLW\ RI K)// SRVVLEO\ LPSURYLQJ LGHQWLÀFDWLRQ ZKLOH DOORZLQJ
VLJQLÀFDQWGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
%
$FFXUDF\RIGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& IURP
G\VSODVWLFQRGXOH '1 DWJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHHQKDQFHG
KHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVH *G%237$ PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
0*LXJD/6LFLOLDQL/5LFFDUGL
$*DWWR$0
)3L]]RODQWH)09HFFKLR03RPSLOL/%RQRPR5RPH,73DYLD,7
'H*DHWDQR
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHZKHWKHU*G%237$HQKDQFHGKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVH05,
FRXOGSUHGLFWWKHKLVWRORJLFJUDGHRI+&&DQGG\VSODVWLFQRGXOH '1 LQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKFLUUKRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG05,RISDWLHQWVZLWK
+&&V ZHOOGLIIHUHQWLDWHGPRGHUDWHO\GLIIHUHQWLDWHG DQG'1V ORZJUDGH
KLJKJUDGH DOOKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHG057Z'*5(LPDJHVZHUHDFTXLUHG
EHIRUHVVVPLQDIWHUEROXVLQMHFWLRQRI*G%237$ PPRONJ (DFK
OHVLRQZDVGHÀQHGDVLVRK\SRK\SHULQWHQVHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHVXUURXQGLQJOLYHU
SDUHQFK\PD RQ WKH '3, GHOD\HGSKDVHLPDJLQJ 7KH WXPRXUOLYHU FRQWUDVWWR
QRLVHUDWLR &15 RIHDFKOHVLRQRQWKH'3,ZDVFDOFXODWHG TXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV+&&QRGXOHVZHUHK\SRLQWHQVHLQDJUHDWHUSHUFHQWDJHWKDQ'1V
+&&DQG'1VZHUHK\SRLQWHQVH +&& ZHOOGLIIHUHQWLDWHG DQG'1V
KLJKJUDGHORZJUDGH ZHUHLVRLQWHQVH7KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ+&&VDQG'1VRQWKH'3, PHDQ&15RIDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\S EHWZHHQORZJUDGHDQGKLJKJUDGH'1V PHDQ
&15RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\S DQGEHWZHHQORZJUDGH
'1VDQG+&& S 7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQKLJKJUDGH
'1VDQG+&&VDQGEHWZHHQZHOODQGPRGHUDWHO\GLIIHUHQWLDWHG+&&V PHDQ&15
RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHODWLYHK\SRLQWHQVLW\RIDOHVLRQWRQRUPDOVXUURXQGLQJOLYHURQ
WKH'3,LVKHOSIXOWRGLVWLQJXLVK+&&KLJKJUDGH'1IURPORZJUDGH'17KHUH
LV QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ KLJKJUDGH '1 DQG +&& DQG EHWZHHQ WKH
GLIIHUHQWSDWKRORJLFJUDGHVRI+&&
%
,QWUDRSHUDWLYHKLJKUHVROXWLRQOLQHDUFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG
,286 IRUGHWHFWLRQRIPLFURYDVFXODULVDWLRQRIPDOLJQDQWOLYHU
OHVLRQVEHIRUHVXUJHU\RUUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ
(0-XQJ0/RVV5HJHQVEXUJ'( HPMXQJ#JP[GH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5RRP/0
&RQWUDVW0HGLD
66
6DIHW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFYDOXH
0RGHUDWRUV
5/DJDOOD3DOHUPR,7
<:1LHOVHQ&RSHQKDJHQ'.
%
1HSKURJHQLFV\VWHPLFÀEURVLVDUHYLHZRISXEOLVKHGFDVHVDQG
UHVXOWVIURPWKUHHSURVSHFWLYHREVHUYDWLRQDOVWXGLHV
*3LURYDQR-0XQOH\&6FKXOW]-3DUNHU0$.LUFKLQ
.4XLQFH$6SLQD]]L3ULQFHWRQ1-860LODQ,7
JLDQSDRORSLURYDQR#GLDJEUDFFRFRP
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH SURÀOH RI QHSKURJHQLF V\VWHPLF ÀEURVLV 16) LQ WKH
PHGLFDOOLWHUDWXUHDQGHYDOXDWHWKHLQFLGHQFHRI16)LQWKUHHSURVSHFWLYHVWXGLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUSXEOLVKHGSHHUUHYLHZHGFDVHVRI16)
ZHUHFRUGHGFRXQWU\DJHJHQGHUUHQDOLPSDLUPHQWJDGROLQLXPEDVHGFRQWUDVW
DJHQW *%&$ H[SRVXUH W\SHGRVH GDWHRIRQVHWDQGWLPHIURP*%&$H[SRVXUH
WRRQVHW,QWKUHHSURVSHFWLYHREVHUYDWLRQDOVWXGLHVZHDVVHVVHG16)LQFLGHQFH
LQ&.'SDWLHQWVH[SRVHGWRJDGRWHULGRO * JDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH *' RU
ZLWKRXWJDGROLQLXPH[SRVXUHIRU\HDUV3DWLHQWVZHUHVWUDWLÀHGLQWRFRKRUWV
H*)5RIP/PLQP>&RKRUW@RUP/PLQP>&RKRUW@
DQGZHUHIROORZHGIRUXSWR\HDUV
5HVXOWV SXEOLVKHG 16) FDVHV IURP FRXQWULHV 1$PHULFD (X
URSH ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGLQSDWLHQWV \U FDVHVUHSRUWHGUHQDOVWDWXV
&'. FDVHV$5) FDVHV 7KHVSHFLÀF*%&$ V DGPLQLVWHUHGZDVNQRZQ
LQFDVHVLQFOXGLQJXQFRQIRXQGHGFDVHV JDGRGLDPLGH JDGRSHQWHWDWH
GLPHJOXPLQH JDGRYHUVHWDPLGH JDGREXWURO ([SRVXUHWRJDGRGLDPLGH
RUJDGRSHQWHWDWHGLPHJOXPLQHRFFXUUHGLQDOOFRQIRXQGHGFDVHV,QDERXWRI
FDVHVV\PSWRPVGHYHORSHGZLWKLQPRQWKVRIWKHODVW*%&$H[SRVXUH1RFDVH
ZDVUHSRUWHGZLWKDQ16)RQVHWGDWHRIRUODWHU,QWKHSURVSHFWLYHVWXGLHV
SDWLHQWV KDYH EHHQ HQUROOHG *' * FRQWURO $W OHDVW \U
IROORZXSKDVEHHQFRPSOHWHGLQVXEMHFWVDQG\ULQ1R16)FDVHKDV
EHHQLGHQWLÀHGWRGDWH
&RQFOXVLRQ,PSURYHGVFUHHQLQJKDVDSSDUHQWO\KDOWHGQHZ16)FDVHV,QWKH
SURVSHFWLYHVWXGLHVZLWKJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHDQGJDGRWHULGROQR16)FDVH
KDVEHHQUHSRUWHG
%
3UHYDOHQFHRIQHSKURJHQLFV\VWHPLFÀEURVLVLQGLDO\VLVSDWLHQWVWKH
3UR),1(67VWXG\
6$PHW*&KRXNURXQ9/DXQD\9DFKHU&)UDQFHV$7ULFRWHO
%6WHQJHO*'HUD\2&OHPHQW3DULV)5$PLHQV)56DLQW'HQLV)5
9LOOHMXLI)5 VDELQHDPHW#SVODSKSIU
3XUSRVH16)LVDFXWDQHRXVDQGV\VWHPLFGLVRUGHUFKDUDFWHULVHGE\ZLGHVSUHDG
WLVVXH ÀEURVLV ,W KDV EHHQ VXJJHVWHG WKDW JDGROLQLXPEDVHG FRQWUDVW DJHQWV
*%&$ PD\ EH UHVSRQVLEOH IRU 16) HVSHFLDOO\ LQ GLDO\VLV SDWLHQWV 7KH 3UR
),1(67VWXG\LVDQDWLRQDOSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\HQGRUVHGE\WKH)UHQFK'UXJ$JHQF\
$IVVDSV DQGWKH)UHQFK6RFLHWLHVRI1HSKURORJ\'HUPDWRORJ\DQG5DGLRORJ\
,WDLPVDWGHWHUPLQLQJWKHSUHYDOHQFHRI16)DIWHUDPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
05, H[DPLQDWLRQ*%&$LQGLDO\VLVSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\LVEDVHGRQDVHFWLRQSDWLHQWIRUP6HFWLRQ
GHPRJUDSKLFVDQGGLDO\VLV6HFWLRQ05,H[DPLQDWLRQ6HFWLRQDQ\GHU
PDWRORJLFDOHYHQW '( )XUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQVDUHSODQQHGLQFDVHRI'(:KHQ
D16)GLDJQRVLVLVFRQÀUPHGDQDQFLOODU\VWXG\LVWREHSHUIRUPHGZLWKUDQGRP
VHOHFWLRQRISDWLHQWV VDPHJHQGHUGLDO\VLVWHFKQLTXHFHQWUHDQGZLWKRXWDQ\
'(DIWHU05,ZLWKWKHVDPH*%&$LILQMHFWHG
5HVXOWV6LQFHSDWLHQWVKDYHEHHQLQFOXGHG FHQWUHV PHDQ
DJH\HDUVPDOHVIRUPVUHFHLYHGUHFHLYHG*%&$DPRQJ
ZKRPUHFHLYHG*DGRWHUDWH7ZHQW\SDWLHQWVUHSRUWHGD'('HUPDWRORJLFDO
GLDJQRVHVGLGQRWUHSRUWDQ\HYLGHQFHRI16)
&RQFOXVLRQ6RIDUWKXVQRFDVHRI16)KDVEHHQUHSRUWHGLQGLDO\VLVSDWLHQWV
DPRQJZKRPWKHPDMRULW\UHFHLYHGD*%&$0RVWSDWLHQWVUHFHLYHGDPDFURF\FOLF
JDGROLQLXPFKHODWHIRUZKLFKQRXQFRQIRXQGHGFDVHRI16)KDVEHHQREVHUYHG\HW
ZRUOGZLGH *DGRWHUDWH )LQDOUHVXOWVZLOOEHDYDLODEOHDWWKHWLPHRIWKHFRQJUHVV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH YDOXH RI OLQHDU FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG LQWUDRSHUDWLYH XO
WUDVRXQGWRLPSURYHGHWHFWLRQRIPDOLJQOLYHUWXPRXUVOHVLRQVEHIRUHVXUJHU\RU
UDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ 5)$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHGIRUVXUJHU\RIPDOLJQDQWOLYHU
WXPRXUV PHDQDJH\HDUV PDOHQ IHPDOHQ VXIIHULQJIURP
+&& Q FRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVLV Q &&& Q RURWKHUPDOLJQOLYHU
OHVLRQV Q 3UHRSHUDWLYH&(&7 Q &(05, Q RU3(7&7 Q FRQ
ÀUPHG KHSDWLF WXPRXU PDQLIHVWDWLRQ %HIRUH XQGHUJRLQJ VXUJHU\ LQWUDRSHUDWLYH
FRQYHQWLRQDO ,286 DV ZHOO DV &(,286 ZHUH SHUIRUPHG E\ RQH H[SHULHQFHG
H[DPLQHU LQ DOO FDVHV XVLQJ PXOWLIUHTXHQF\ OLQHDU SUREHV 0+] 0+]
/2*,4(*( &(,286ZDVSHUIRUPHGDIWHUEROXVLQMHFWLRQRIPOXSWRPO
6RQR9XH %UDFFR ,WDO\ 'LJLWDOO\ VWRUHG LPDJHV RI &(,286 ZHUH FRPSDUHG
ZLWKSUHRSHUDWLYHLPDJLQJ
5HVXOWV,QRISDWLHQWV DGGLWLRQDOOHVLRQVZHUHIRXQGXVLQJ&(,286
PHDQWXPRXUVL]HPPUDQJHPP 7KLVUHVXOWHGLQDFKDQJHRIVXUJLFDO
VWUDWHJ\RUWKHLQWUDRSHUDWLYHDSSOLFDWLRQRI5)$LQSDWLHQWV 0RGLÀFD
WLRQRIWKHUDS\GXHWRDGGLWLRQDOO\IRXQGOLYHUOHVLRQVZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
S &RPSDULQJ FRQYHQWLRQDO ,286 DQG &(,286 DGGLWLRQDO OHVLRQV
LQSDWLHQWVZHUHVHHQE\&(,286$OOOHVLRQVVHHQLQ%VFDQFRXOGDOVREH
GHWHFWHGZLWK&(,286
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVLVWKHÀUVWVWXG\XVLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGZLWKKLJK
UHVROXWLRQ OLQHDU SUREHV IRU LQWUDRSHUDWLYH GHWHFWLRQ RI PDOLJQDQW OLYHU OHVLRQV
&RPSDUHGWRSUHRSHUDWLYHLPDJLQJDQGDOVRFRQYHQWLRQDO,286PRUHWKDQ
DGGLWLRQDOOHVLRQVZHUHIRXQGOHDGLQJWRWKHUDSHXWLFFRQVHTXHQFHVRISDWLHQWV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
7ROHUDELOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIJDGRWHULFDFLGLQJHQHUDODQGLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKULVNIDFWRUVUHVXOWVLQPRUHWKDQSDWLHQWV
0+0DXUHU2+HLQH0:ROI7'XUPXV0:DJQHU%+DPP
%HUOLQ'(6XO]EDFK7DXQXV'(3WWOLQJHQ'( PDUWLQPDXUHU#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH7RUHYLHZWKHWROHUDELOLW\DQGWKHGLDJQRVWLFHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIJDGRWHULF
DFLGXQGHUGDLO\SUDFWLFHFRQGLWLRQVLQWKHJHQHUDOSRSXODWLRQDQGDWULVNSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWV PDOHIHPDOH
PHDQDJH\HDUV ZHUHVWXGLHGLQ*HUPDQFHQWUHV3DWLHQWVXQGHU
ZHQWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, XVLQJJDGRWHULFDFLG
*G'27$'RWDUHP*XHUEHW5RLVV\&G*)UDQFH DV,9FRQWUDVWPHGLXP PHDQ
YROXPHPO RIWKHSDWLHQWVKDGDWOHDVWRQHULVNIDFWRU HJDOOHUJLHV
SUHYLRXVDOOHUJLFUHDFWLRQWRDFRQWUDVWPHGLXPUHQDOLPSDLUPHQW )RUW\VL[SDWLHQWV
UHFHLYHGDQWLDOOHUJLFSUHWUHDWPHQWEHIRUHFRQWUDVWPHGLXPDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
$GYHUVHHYHQWVZHUHGRFXPHQWHGDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV$GLDJQRVLVZDVSRVVLEOHLQRIDOOFDVHV,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVUDWHG
JRRGRUH[FHOOHQWLQ$GYHUVHHYHQWV HJQDXVHDYRPLWLQJDQGXUWLFDULD
ZHUHREVHUYHGLQRIWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVDQGZHUHPRVWO\UDWHGDVPLQRU7KHUH
ZHUHSDWLHQWVZLWKVHYHUHDGYHUVHHYHQWV7KHDGYHUVHHYHQWUDWHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHULQSDWLHQWVZLWKDKLVWRU\RIDOOHUJLHV S DQGLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
D SUHYLRXV DOOHUJLF UHDFWLRQ WR FRQWUDVW PHGLXP S 7KHUH ZDV
QRHOHYDWHGULVNIRUDGYHUVHHYHQWVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHQDORUKHSDWLFLPSDLUPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ*DGRWHULFDFLGZDVVKRZQWREHDZHOOWROHUDWHG05,FRQWUDVWPHGLXP
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWULVNIDFWRUVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDORZUDWHRIDGYHUVHHYHQWV
DQGDJRRGRUH[FHOOHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\LQPRVWSDWLHQWV
%
2EVHUYDWLRQDOSRVWPDUNHWLQJVWXG\RQWKHVDIHW\RIPHJOXPLQH
JDGRWHUDWHLQWHULPVDIHW\DQDO\VLVRQSDWLHQWV
%.UHVV)UDQNIXUW'( NUHVVERGR#NKQZGH
3XUSRVH 7R SURVSHFWLYHO\ DVVHVV WKH JHQHUDO VDIHW\ SURÀOH RI PHJOXPLQH JD
GRWHUDWH *G'27$ DQGHYDOXDWHWKHRYHUDOOLQFLGHQFHRIQHSKURJHQLFV\VWHPLF
ÀEURVLV 16)
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$ZRUOGZLGHSRVWPDUNHWLQJVWXG\ 306 ZDVFRQGXFWHG
WRFROOHFWVDIHW\GDWDLQSDWLHQWVZLWKRUZLWKRXWUHQDOLQVXIÀFLHQF\ZKRKDG
URXWLQHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05 LPDJLQJXVLQJ*G'27$)RU
HDFKSDWLHQWULVNIDFWRUVDWLQFOXVLRQLQGLFDWLRQVIRU05LPDJLQJH[DPLQDWLRQDQG
FRQGLWLRQVRIXVHDQGDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIWKHFRQWUDVWPDWHULDOZHUHUHFRUGHG)RU
DQ\SDWLHQWLGHQWLÀHGDVUHQDOO\LPSDLUHGDWWKHWLPHRILQFOXVLRQ LHHVWLPDWHG
FUHDWLQLQHFOHDUDQFHRUHVWLPDWHGJORPHUXODUÀOWUDWLRQUDWHP/PLQPò
DW OHDVW D PRQWK IROORZXS HYDOXDWLRQ ZDV SHUIRUPHG LQ RUGHU WR GHWHFW DQ\
VXVSLFLRQRURFFXUUHQFHRI16)
5HVXOWV$VRI-XO\WKHFXWRIIGDWHIRUWKHLQWHULPVDIHW\DQDO\VLVWKLV
RQJRLQJ306LQFOXGHGGDWDIURPSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH
\HDUVIHPDOH 05LPDJLQJH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHPDLQO\SHUIRUPHGWR
LPDJHWKHFHQWUDOQHUYRXVV\VWHP ZKROHERG\ DQGPXVFXORVNHO
HWDO 7KHPDLQULVNIDFWRUVZHUHK\SHUWHQVLRQ DQGDOOHUJLHV
0RGHUDWHWRVHYHUHLPSDLUHGUHQDOIXQFWLRQZDVUHSRUWHGLQSDWLHQWV
$PRQJWKHP KDGQRVXVSLFLRQRI16) IROORZXSHYDOXDWLRQQRW\HW
FRPSOHWHGDWWKHWLPHGDWDZHUHFROOHFWHGIRUSDWLHQWV 7KLUW\SDWLHQWV
KDGDWOHDVWRQHDGYHUVHHYHQW PDLQO\XUWLFDULDQDXVHDYRPLWLQJ
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KLV LQWHULP VDIHW\ DQDO\VLV DOUHDG\ FRQÀUPV D YHU\ JRRG VDIHW\
SURÀOHRI*G'27$
%
6DIHW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\RIJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH
0XOWL+DQFH LQ05LPDJLQJRISDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWV
*.6FKQHLGHU+6FKXHUKRO]3)ULHV$%XHFNHU
+RPEXUJDG6DDU'( GUJXHQWKHUVFKQHLGHU#XNVHX
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHVDIHW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\RIJDGR
EHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHLQ&(LPDJLQJLQGLIIHUHQWLQGLFDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDHGLDWULFVXEMHFWV DJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQW
&(05,DVSDUWRIFOLQLFDOURXWLQH3DWLHQWVUHFHLYHGDGRVHRIHLWKHUPPRONJ
ERG\ZHLJKW OLYHUDEGRPLQDOPXVFXORVNHOHWDOEUDLQDQGRWKHUUDUHLQGLFDWLRQV RU
PPRONJERG\ZHLJKW FDUGLRYDVFXODULPDJLQJ05XURJUDSK\ <RXQJSDWLHQWV
XQGHUZHQW05,HLWKHULQVHGDWLRQRUJHQHUDODQDHVWKHVLDLQFDVHRI05$VWXGLHVLQ
&+'SDWLHQWVJHQHUDOO\XQGHUZHQWLPDJLQJLQLQWXEDWLRQZLWKFRQWUROOHGYHQWLODWLRQ
0RQLWRULQJIRUDGYHUVHHYHQWVZDVSHUIRUPHGXSWRDWOHDVWKRXUVSRVWLQMHFWLRQ
'HSHQGLQJRQWKHFOLQLFDOQHFHVVLW\ODERUDWRU\PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGLQVRPHFDVHV
YLWDOVLJQDQG(&*GHWHUPLQDWLRQVZHUHPDGHEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWKH&(H[DPLQDWLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
'HWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHVDIHW\RIJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHZDVWKHUHDIWHUPDGHE\
DJHJURXSFOLQLFDOLQGLFDWLRQDQGGRVHDGPLQLVWHUHG
5HVXOWV1RFOLQLFDODGYHUVHHYHQWVZHUHUHSRUWHGHLWKHUDPRQJVWSDWLHQWVZKR
XQGHUZHQWRQO\DVROLWDU\05RUPXOWLSOHH[DPLQDWLRQV7KHUHZHUHQRDOWHUDWLRQV
LQFUHDWLQLQHOHYHOVHYHQLQYHU\\RXQJVXEMHFWVZKRVHNLGQH\IXQFWLRQLVQRW\HW
IXOO\GHYHORSHG/LNHZLVHWKHUHZHUHQRFKDQJHVLQELOLUXELQOHYHOVGHVSLWHWKH
HOLPLQDWLRQRIRIWKHLQMHFWHGGRVHWKURXJKWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SDWKZD\
&RQFOXVLRQ*DGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHLVDVDIHDQGHIÀFLHQWFRQWUDVWDJHQWIRU
LPDJLQJRISDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWV&RQFHUQLQJWKHFXUUHQWGLVFXVVLRQRQWKHVDIHW\
RI *GEDVHG 05 FRQWUDVW DJHQWV WKH ORZHU GRVH RI JDGREHQDWH GLPHJOXPLQH
QHHGHGIRUGLDJQRVWLFDEGRPLQDOLPDJLQJ PPRONJ DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
05DQJLRJUDSK PPRONJ VHHPVEHQHÀFLDO
%
3DUVWDWLQDYHUWVGHYHORSPHQWRIFRQWUDVWLQGXFHGQHSKURSDWK\LQDQ
LQYLYRH[SHULPHQWDOPRGHO
$'LDPDQWRSRXORV..DWVDQRV66SLOLRSRXORV$.DUDW]DV'.DUQDEDWLGLV
17VRSDQRJORX'6LDEOLV3DWUD*5 DGLDPDQWRSRXORV#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RSUHVHQWWKHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVRIDQH[SHULPHQWDOVWXG\LQYHVWLJDW
LQJWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDWSDUVWDWLQWKH1WHUPLQDODPLQRDFLGSHSWLGHFOHDYHG
E\ WKURPELQ IURP WKH SURWHDVHDFWLYDWHG UHFHSWRU PD\ KROG D SURWHFWLYH UROH
DJDLQVWFRQWUDVWLQGXFHGQHSKURSDWK\ &,1 3DUVWDWLQKDVSUHYLRXVO\EHHQVKRZQ
WRSURWHFWDJDLQVWUDWP\RFDUGLDOLVFKDHPLDDQGUHSHUIXVLRQLQMXU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&,1ZDVH[SHULPHQWDOO\LQGXFHGLQ1HZ=HDODQG:KLWH
1=: UDEELWVE\LQWUDYHQRXVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIDKLJKGRVH PJ,NJ RILRGLQDWHG
FRQWUDVWPHGLXP ,RSURPLGHPJ,PO LQIXVHGRYHUDPLQSHULRG6XEMHFWV
UHFHLYHGHLWKHUSUHWUHDWPHQWZLWKѥJNJSDUVWDWLQH[DFWO\PLQXWHVEHIRUH
LQLWLDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWLQIXVLRQ JURXS3 RUDQHTXDOYROXPHRIQRUPDOVDOLQH FRQWURO
JURXS& %ORRGVHUXPFUHDWLQLQH V&U ZDVPHDVXUHGDWKRXUVLQDOOVXEMHFWV
&,1ZDVGHÀQHGDVDQLQFUHDVHRIVXEMHFWҋVV&UDERYHPJGO$QLPDOVZHUH
HXWKDQLVHG DW KRXUV NLGQH\V ZHUH UHPRYHG DQG VHFWLRQHG IRU KLVWRORJLFDO
H[DPLQDWLRQZLWKKDHPDWR[\OLQDQGHRVLQVWDLQLQJ
5HVXOWV7KLUW\WKUHHVXEMHFWVZHUHDVVLJQHGLQHLWKHUJURXS3 Q NJ
RU JURXS & Q NJ $W KRXUV &,1 ZDV GHWHFWHG LQ D VWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQW KLJKHU SURSRUWLRQ RI VXEMHFWV LQ WKH FRQWURO JURXS &
FRPSDUHGWRWKHSDUVWDWLQSUHWUHDWHGJURXS3 S+LVWRORJ\
GHPRQVWUDWHGPRUHH[WHQVLYHWXEXODUQHFURVLVLQJURXS&FRPSDUHGWRJURXS3
&RQFOXVLRQ3DUVWDWLQVXFFHVVIXOO\LQKLELWV&,1LQDQDQLPDOPRGHORIFRQWUDVW
LQGXFHG QHSKURSDWK\ )XUWKHU VWXGLHV DUH QHFHVVDU\ WR YDOLGDWH WKH SURWHFWLYH
UROHRISDUVWDWLQDJDLQVWFRQWUDVWQHSKURWR[LFLW\DQGÀQGWKHRSWLPDOGRVHIRUWKH
EHVWSRVVLEOHUHVXOW
%
&OLQLFDODQGSDWKRORJLFDOHIIHFWVDQGLQYLYRVWDELOLW\RIDOOFDWHJRULHV
RIJDGROLQLXPFKHODWHVRQDQHZPRGHORIUHQDOIDLOXUHLQUDWV
13DUPHQWLHU1)UHWHOOLHU3%UXQHYDO&:DOORQ*-HVWLQ
&+ROOHQEHFN&)DFWRU-0,GHH&&RURW5RLVV\)53DULV)5
LGHHM#JXHUEHWJURXSFRP
3XUSRVH&RPSDUHWKHFOLQLFDOSDWKRORJLFDOHIIHFWVDQGWKHLQYLYRVWDELOLW\RIDOO
FXUUHQWO\PDUNHWHGFDWHJRULHVRIJDGROLQLXPFKHODWHV *& LQUDWVZLWKDGHQLQH
LQGXFHGUHQDOIDLOXUH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :LVWDU UDWV JURXS UHFHLYHG D DGHQLQH
HQULFKHGGLHWIRUGD\VDQGUHFHLYHGGDLO\LQWUDYHQRXVLQMHFWLRQVRIJDGRWHUDWH
'RWDUHP JDGREXWURO *DGRYLVW JDGRSHQWHWDWH 0DJQHYLVW JDGREHQDWH
0XOWL+DQFH JDGRGLDPLGH 2PQLVFDQ DOO PPRONJGD\ RU VDOLQH IURP
GD\5DWVZHUHVDFULÀFHGZHHNVDIWHUWKHÀUVWLQMHFWLRQRI*&$FOLQLFDOKLV
WRSDWKRORJLFDO EOLQGHGH[DPLQDWLRQV ELRFKHPLFDODQGDQDO\WLFDO PHDVXUHPHQW
RI WRWDO *G FRQFHQWUDWLRQ LQ YDULRXV WLVVXHV ,&3PDVV VSHFWURPHWU\ IROORZXS
ZDV FDUULHG RXW DV ZHOO DV UHOD[RPHWU\ PHDVXUHPHQWV VNLQ OLYHU DQG IHPXU
0LQLVSHF0+]
5HVXOWV*UDGXDOPRUWDOLW\ZDVIRXQGLQWKHJDGRGLDPLGHWUHDWHGJURXS RXWRI
UDWV (DUO\DQGWUDQVLHQWSXQFWLIRUPVNLQOHVLRQVDSSHDUHGLQJDGRSHQWHWDWHWUHDWHG
UDWV DQLPDOV 0RGHUDWHGHUPLVLQÁDPPDWLRQRYHUH[SUHVVLRQRI7*)ћDQG
WLVVXODULQKLELWRURIPDWUL[SURWHLQDVHZHUHIRXQGLQWKHVNLQRIWKHJDGRGLDPLGH
VXUYLYRUDWVDFULÀFH*UDGXDOLQFUHDVHLQUUHOD[LYLW\YDOXHVZDVIRXQGLQWKHVNLQ
RI JDGRSHQWHWDWH UDWV DQG P0VHF DW GD\V
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\H[YLYRUHIHUHQFHUDQJH P0VHF DQG
JDGRGLDPLGH P0VHFIRUWKHVXUYLYRUDWVDFULÀFHYVP0VHF
DWGD\ DQHIIHFWFRQVLVWHQWZLWKJUDGXDOLQYLYR*&GLVVRFLDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDGHQLQHPRGHORIUHQDOIDLOXUHDOORZVWRGLVFULPLQDWHEHWZHHQ
*&VDVUHJDUGVWKHLUVNLQWR[LFLW\DQGLQYLYRVWDELOLW\SURÀOHV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
5HQDOIXQFWLRQRIRXWSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7
ZKDWKDYHZHOHDUQHGIURPXQLYHUVDOH*)5WHVWLQJ"
+&KDOLDQ+*7RUH.*KDGMDU9<DJKPDL&KLFDJR,/86
Y\DJKPDL#QRUWKZHVWHUQHGX
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHIUHTXHQF\RIDEQRUPDOUHQDOIXQFWLRQLQDOORXWSDWLHQWV
XQGHUJRLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7DQGWRFRUUHODWHWKLVZLWKWKHSDWLHQWVҋNQRZOHGJH
RIWKHLUUHQDOIXQFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVUHWURVSHFWLYH+,3$$FRPSOLDQWVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHG
E\RXU,5%H*)5 POPLQP YDOXHVIRUFRQVHFXWLYHRXWSDWLHQWVRE
WDLQHGLPPHGLDWHO\EHIRUH&7ZHUHUHFRUGHGH*)5YDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHGIRUDOO
SDWLHQWVUHJDUGOHVVRIWKHLUULVNIDFWRUV5HVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRWKHSDWLHQWVҋ
VHOIUHSRUWLQJRIWKHKLVWRU\RIUHQDOGLVHDVHH*)5YDOXHVZHUHDOVRFRPSDUHG
WRWKHVHUXPFUHDWLQLQH PJG/ OHYHOVH*)5POPLQPZDVGHÀQHG
DVDEQRUPDO
5HVXOWV SDWLHQWVZHUH\RXQJHUWKDQ\HDUVSDWLHQWV
KDGDEQRUPDOH*)5 PHDQPOPLQP 7KHDYHUDJHDQGPH
GLDQDJHIRUWKRVHZLWKDEQRUPDOH*)5ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
SDWLHQWVZLWKDEQRUPDOH*)5UHSRUWHGQRKLVWRU\RIUHQDOGLVHDVH
RIWKRVHZLWKH*)5POPLQPUHSRUWHGQRKLVWRU\RIUHQDO
GLVHDVH2IWKRVHZKRLQGLFDWHGKLVWRU\RIUHQDOGLVHDVH KDG
QRUPDO H*)5 SDWLHQWV ZLWK DEQRUPDO H*)5 KDG FUHDWLQLQH OHYHOV
EHORZPJG/
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWLHQWVUHIHUUHGIRUHQKDQFHG&7DUHIUHTXHQWO\XQDZDUHRIWKHLU
DEQRUPDOUHQDOIXQFWLRQVWDWXV&RQYHUVHO\SDWLHQWVZKRUHSRUWKLVWRU\RIUHQDO
GLVHDVHFRPPRQO\KDYHQRUPDOUHQDOIXQFWLRQ8QLYHUVDOH*)5WHVWLQJPD\EH
QHFHVVDU\WRGHWHUPLQHWKHUHQDOIXQFWLRQLQWKLVSRSXODWLRQ
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQSURWRFROVIRUWKRUDFRDEGRPLQDO
KLJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7DQJLRJUDSK\DSKDQWRPVWXG\
*'3XLSSH$:LQNOHKQHU$3ODVV7)UDXHQIHOGHU6%DXPOOHU=XULFK&+
JLOEHUWSXLSSH#XV]FK
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5RRP12
9DVFXODU
66
3HULSKHUDODQGUHQDODUWHULHV
0RGHUDWRUV
*&DUUDÀHOOR9DUHVH,7
..DWVDQRV3DWUDV*5
%
$FFXUDF\RIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGDQGWUDQVLHQW
DUWHULDORFFOXVLRQIRUGLDJQRVLVRISHULSKHUDODUWHULDOGLVHDVH
($PDUWHLÀR6:RUPVEHFKHU0.UL[6'HPLUHO6%UDXQ
6'HORUPH'%RHFNOHU+8.DXF]RU0$:HEHU
+HLGHOEHUJ'( HULFNDPDUWHLÀR#PHGXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH 7R DVFHUWDLQ WKH DFFXUDF\ RI G\QDPLF FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG XOWUDVRXQG
&(86 DQGWUDQVLHQWDUWHULDORFFOXVLRQIRUGLDJQRVLVRISHULSKHUDODUWHULDOGLVHDVH
3$'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK3$'5XWKHUIRUGFODVVLÀFDWLRQJUDGH,
FDWHJRU\,,, PHDQDJH\HDUV DQGKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV PHDQDJH\HDUV
ZHUHLQFOXGHG7KHGRPLQDQWORZHUOHJZDVH[DPLQHGZLWK&(86 0+]0,
GXULQJFRQWLQXRXVLQWUDYHQRXVLQIXVLRQRIP/PLFUREXEEOHVFRQWDLQLQJVXOSKXU
KH[DÁXRULGH7UDQVLHQWDUWHULDORFFOXVLRQDWWKHWKLJKOHYHOVLPXODWHGSK\VLFDOH[
HUFLVH5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUHSODFHGLQWKHVHOHFWHGPXVFOHDQGVHYHUDO
SDUDPHWHUVZHUHREWDLQHGIURPWLPH&(86LQWHQVLW\FXUYHV0D[LPXP&(86VLJQDO
DIWHURFFOXVLRQDQGLWVWLPH WPD[ UHVXOWLQJVORSHWRPD[LPXP P DQGYDVFXODU
UHVSRQVHDIWHURFFOXVLRQ $8&SRVW $FFXUDF\UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF
52& FXUYHVDQGFRUUHODWLRQVRIWKHVHSDUDPHWHUVZLWKDQNOHEUDFKLDOLQGH[ $%,
DQGZDONLQJGLVWDQFHZHUHDQDO\VHG
5HVXOWV$OO SDUDPHWHUV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHG IRU SDWLHQWV FRPSDUHG WR YROXQ
WHHUV S WPD[ZDVPDUNHGO\GHOD\HGLQ3$' YVV
S DQGZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\QHJDWLYHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK$%, U +LJKHVW
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ZDVIRXQGXVLQJPZKLFKZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\VPDOOHUIRUSDWLHQWV
P/V FRPSDUHGWRYROXQWHHUV P/VS ZLWKDVHQ
VLWLYLW\RIDQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIIRUGHWHFWLRQRIGLPLQLVKHGPXVFXODUPLUFR
SHUIXVLRQLQ3$' FXWRIIYDOXHPaP/V 'LVFULPLQDQWDQDO\VLVDQGUHFHLYHU
RSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& FXUYHVUHYHDOHGWKDWDSDUDPHWHUFRPELQDWLRQRI
PDQG$8&SRVWLVRSWLPDOIRUGLDJQRVLVRI3$'
&RQFOXVLRQ'\QDPLF&(86DQGWUDQVLHQWDUWHULDORFFOXVLRQTXDQWLI\LQJPXVFXODU
PLFURSHUIXVLRQLVVXLWDEOHIRUGLDJQRVLVRI3$'SURYLGLQJDFFXUDWHVHQVLWLYLW\DQG
VSHFLÀFLW\
%
&RPSUHKHQVLYH05DQJLRJUDSK\RIWKHORZHUOLPEVFRPSDULVRQ
RISHUIRUPDQFHRIJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHJDGREXWURODQG
JDGRIRVYHVHWWULVRGLXP
6&KDQGUDPRKDQ*5RGLWL*ODVJRZ8. GUVFKDQGUDPRKDQ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH&RPSUHKHQVLYHORZHUOLPE05$SURWRFROLQFRUSRUDWLQJG\QDPLFÀUVW
SDVVVWDWLRQDQGKLJKUHVROXWLRQLPDJLQJZLWKUHVXOWVFRPSDUDEOHWREORRGSRRO
FRQWUDVWDJHQWV %3&$ FRXOGEHDFKLHYHGZLWKQRQ%3&$V:HDLPWRHYDOXDWH
WKLVLQDSURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDULQJJDGRIRVYHVHWZLWKJDGREXWURODQGJDGHREHQDWH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVFODXGLFDQWV Q DQGFULWLFDOOLPELVFKDHPLFV
Q DUHUHFUXLWHGIRUWKLVVWXG\&(05$DFTXLUHGLQSKDVHVLQLWLDOG\QDPLF
05$ 7:,67 RIWKHLQIUDSRSOLWHDOYHVVHOVVWDQGDUGVWDWLRQÀUVWSDVV05$WKHQ
LPPHGLDWHO\IROORZHGE\LPDJLQJLQҊH[WHQGHGSKDVHҋZLWKKLJKUHVROXWLRQDFTXLVL
WLRQVRIWKHWKLJKDQGFDOIYHVVHOV&ULWLFDOSDWLHQWVZHUHLPDJHGRQFHRQO\ZLWK
%3&$ POJDGRIRVYHVHWSDWLHQWV RUHLWKHURIWKH(&6DJHQWVJDGREHQDWH
GLPHJOXPLQHRUJDGREXWURO POSDWLHQWV &ODXGLFDQWSDWLHQWVDUHLPDJHG
WZLFHRQVHSDUDWHDWWHQGDQFHVZLWK%3&$DQGHLWKHUJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH
RUJDGREXWURORUJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHDQGJDGREXWUROWRDOORZLQWUDLQGLYLGXDO
FRPSDULVRQ(YDOXDWLRQRILPDJHTXDOLW\IRUDUWHULHVDQGYHLQVXVLQJD/LNHUWVFDOH
DQG52,PHDVXUHPHQWVIRU&15RQKLJKUHVROXWLRQLPDJHV
5HVXOWV )RU DUWHULDO GLDJQRVLV G\QDPLF DQG ÀUVWSDVV LPDJHV REWDLQHG ZLWK
JDGREHQDWH GLPHJOXPLQH DQG JDGREXWURO DUH QRW VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHQW WR WKRVH
REWDLQHGZLWKJDGRIRVYHVHWWULVRGLXP+LJKVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQH[WHQGHGSKDVHLP
DJHVDUHDOVRFRPSDUDEOHWRDUWHULDOGLVHDVHDOWKRXJKYHQRXVVLJQDOLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
UHGXFHGLQQRQ%3&$V
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSUHKHQVLYHORZHUOLPEYDVFXODULPDJLQJLQFOXGLQJG\QDPLFDF
TXLVLWLRQVDQGH[WHQGHGSKDVHLPDJLQJFDQEHSHUIRUPHGZLWKVLPLODUGLDJQRVWLF
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH7RH[SHULPHQWDOO\HYDOXDWHWKUHHFRQWUDVWSURWRFROVIRUWKRUDFRDEGRPLQDO
KLJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ ZLWKUHJDUGWROHYHODQGKRPRJHQHLW\
RIYDVFXODUHQKDQFHPHQWDWGLIIHUHQWFDUGLDFRXWSXWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8QLSKDVLFELSKDVLFDQGWDLORUHGFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQSUR
WRFROVZHUHWHVWHGXVLQJDKXPDQYDVFXODUSKDQWRP3URWRFROVZHUHVFDQQHGDW
GLIIHUHQWFDUGLDFRXWSXWV /PLQVWHSV/PLQ XVLQJDFHQWULIXJDOSXPS
7KRUDFRDEGRPLQDO YDVFXODU HQKDQFHPHQW ZDV PHDVXUHG HYHU\ FP 2YHUDOO
PHDQHQKDQFHPHQWRIHDFKSURWRFRODQGPHDQHQKDQFHPHQWIRUHDFKFDUGLDF
RXWSXWZLWKLQHDFKSURWRFROZHUHFDOFXODWHG(QKDQFHPHQWKRPRJHQHLW\DORQJWKH
]D[LVZDVHYDOXDWHGIRUHDFKFDUGLDFRXWSXWDQGSURWRFRO$PRXQWVRIDGPLQLVWHUHG
FRQWUDVWDJHQWZHUHQRWHG
5HVXOWV2YHUDOOPHDQHQKDQFHPHQWZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHXQLSKDVLFWKDQ
LQWKHRWKHUSURWRFROV DOOS ZKHUHDVWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHELSKDVLFDQG
WDLORUHGSURWRFROZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQW S &DUGLDFRXWSXWLQYHUVHO\LQÁXHQFHG
WKHOHYHORIYDVFXODUHQKDQFHPHQW&KDQJLQJFDUGLDFRXWSXWVOHDGWRVLJQLÀFDQWO\
GLIIHUHQWPHDQYDVFXODUHQKDQFHPHQWV DOOS ZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQDWFDUGLDF
RXWSXWVRI/PLQYV/PLQ +8YV+8S DQGYV/PLQ
+8YV+8S DWWKHWDLORUHGSURWRFRO+RPRJHQHRXVHQKDQFH
PHQWZDVIHDVLEOHDWDOOFDUGLDFRXWSXWVZLWKWKHXQLSKDVLFDQGWDLORUHGEXWQRWZLWK
WKHELSKDVLFSURWRFRO$PRXQWVRIFRQWUDVWDJHQWZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUDWWKH
WDLORUHG P/ WKDQDWWKHXQL P/ RUELSKDVLF P/ SURWRFRO DOOS
&RQFOXVLRQ5HVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWKRPRJHQHRXVHQKDQFHPHQWDWWKRUDFRDEGRPL
QDOKLJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7$LVDFKLHYDEOHZLWKHLWKHUXQLSKDVLFRUWDLORUHGFRQWUDVW
SURWRFROWKHODWWHUEHLQJIDYRXUDEOHRIQHHGLQJVLJQLÀFDQWO\OHVVFRQWUDVWDJHQW
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
XWLOLW\IRUDUWHULDOGLVHDVHXVLQJDOODJHQWV9HQRXVHQKDQFHPHQWLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
OHVVFRQVSLFXRXVZLWKWKHQRQ%3&$V
%
(IÀFDF\RI'RWDUHPHQKDQFHGPUDLQWKHGLDJQRVLVRISHULSKHUDO
DUWHU\GLVHDVHFRPSDUHGWR*DGRYLVWHQKDQFHG05$
&/RHZH-$UQDL]'.UDXVH/0DUWL%RQPDWL0$VFKDXHU$7DUWDUR
0/RPEDUGL0%XUUHO5,]]LOOR9LHQQD$76DQWDQGHU(6'LMRQ)5
9DOHQFLD(6*UD]$7&KLHWL,73LVD,7%DUFHORQD(66DLQW'HQLV)5
FKULVWLDQORHZH#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI'RWDUHPHQKDQFHG05$
DQG*DGRYLVWHQKDQFHG05$DW7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVSURVSHFWLYHPXOWLFRXQWULHVUDQGRPLVHGSDUDOOHO
JURXSGRXEOHEOLQGSKDVH,9WULDOSDWLHQWV \HDUV ZLWKSHULSKHUDO
DUWHULDO GLVHDVH 3$2' VWDJHV ,,,9 /HULFKH DQG )RQWDLQH FODVVLÀFDWLRQ ZHUH
LQFOXGHG3DWLHQWVUDQGRPO\XQGHUZHQW05$RIWKHORZHUOHJVGXULQJLQMHFWLRQZLWK
PPRONJRIHLWKHU'RWDUHP P/ RU*DGRYLVW P/ $WRWDO
RIYDVFXODUVHJPHQWVZHUHH[SORUHG IURPLQIUDUHQDODRUWDWRSHURQHDODUWHU\
7KHSULPDU\FULWHULRQZDVWKHGHJUHHRIDJUHHPHQW ZLWKLQSDWLHQWDFFXUDF\ RI
HDFKW\SHRI05$H[DPLQDWLRQDVFRPSDUHGWRWKHJROGVWDQGDUG'6$XVLQJD
QRQLQIHULRULW\DQDO\VLVHYDOXDWHGLQDEOLQGHGPDQQHUE\RQVLWHUHDGLQJ0DLQ
VHFRQGDU\FULWHULDLQFOXGHGVSHFLÀFLW\VHQVLWLYLW\SRVLWLYHQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHV
339139 GLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHDQGVDIHW\
5HVXOWV7KHDJUHHPHQWLQVWHQRVLVGHWHFWLRQEHWZHHQ'RWDUHP05$DQG'6$
ZDVVLPLODUWRWKDWRI*DGRYLVW05$ YVUHVSHFWLYHO\
у DQGWKH&,H[FOXGLQJWKHQRQLQIHULRULW\OLPLW GHPRQVWUDWHGWKH
QRQLQIHULRULW\7KH05$VHQVLWLYLW\IRUGHWHFWLQJVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLV ! ZDV
ZLWK'RWDUHPDQGZLWK*DGRYLVWZKHUHDVWKHVSHFLÀFLW\
339 YHUVXV 139 DQG GLDJQRVWLF FRQÀGHQFH YV
ZHUHVLPLODULQERWKJURXSV7ZRSDWLHQWV LQHDFKJURXSH[SHULHQFHG
DGYHUVHHYHQWV PRVWO\PLOGDQGXQUHODWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ 'RWDUHP05$ FDQ EH XVHG ZLWK VLPLODU GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\ DV
*DGRYLVW05$ LQ WKH GLDJQRVLV RI 3$2' DW 7HVOD 7KLV WULDO VXJJHVWV WKDW
WKHUHLVQRGLUHFWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQKLJKHULQWULQVLFUHOD[LYLW\DQGRUJDGROLQLXP
FRQFHQWUDWLRQDQGLPSURYHGFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVLV
%
3HULSKHUDO05$DW7LQWUDLQGLYLGXDOFRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQ
QRQHQKDQFHG7R)DQG66)3VHTXHQFHVYVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05$
IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIFOLQLFDOO\UHOHYDQWVWHQRVLV
0$Q]LGHL$1DSROL)=DFFDJQD/6DED*&DUWRFFL
/%HUWDFFLQL91RFH)%RQL&&DWDODQR5RPH,7&DJOLDUL,7
PLFKHOHDQ]LGHL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIWZRQRQHQKDQFHG05$ 1(05$
VHTXHQFHV 7R)DQG66)3 YVFRQYHQWLRQDOFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05$ &(05$
DW7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKSHULSKHUDODUWHULDOREVWUXFWLYHGLVHDVH 3$2' XVLQJ&7
DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ DVUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVV\PSWRPDWLFIRU3$2'XQGHUZHQW1(05$
RI WKH IHPRUDO DQG FDOI UHJLRQV ZLWK ' (&*JDWHG7R) DQG (&*JDWHG 66)3
VHTXHQFHVIROORZHGE\&(05$ZLWK*G%237$$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW&7$DV
UHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG7KUHHEOLQGHGREVHUYHUVVHSDUDWHO\UHYLHZHGDOO05$GDWDVHWV
LQUDQGRPRUGHURQHLQGHSHQGHQWREVHUYHUHYDOXDWHG&7$LPDJHVIRUWKHDVVHVV
PHQWRIUHOHYDQWVWHQRVLV ! H[WHQWDQGORFDWLRQ,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHG
E\DQLQGHSHQGHQWREVHUYHUIRUDOO05$GDWDVHWV,QWUDREVHUYHUDQGLQWHUREVHUYHU
DJUHHPHQWIRUWKHWKUHH05$WHFKQLTXHVZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJ&RKHQNVWDWLVWLFV
6HQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ DFFXUDF\ SRVLWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH 339 DQG QHJDWLYH
SUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 ZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKWHFKQLTXH7KH0F1HPDU VWHVW
ZDVXVHGWRDVVHVVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
RIHDFK05$WHFKQLTXH
5HVXOWV ,QWUDREVHUYHU DQG LQWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW ZHUH VXEVWDQWLDO IRU VWH
QRVLV DVVHVVPHQW 7KH VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ DFFXUDF\ 339 DQG 139 YDOXHV
RI 7R)66)3&(05$ VHTXHQFHV IRU VWHQRVLV DVVHVVPHQW FRPSDUHG WR &7$
ZHUH UHVSHFWLYHO\
'LDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI&(05$ZDVVXSHULRUWR7R)DQG66)3VHTXHQFHV
S 66)3VHTXHQFHVZHUHEHWWHUIRUVWHQRVLVDVVHVVPHQWFRPSDUHGWR
7R)VHTXHQFHV S
&RQFOXVLRQ 7 &(05$ LV VXSHULRU WR 1(05$ WHFKQLTXHV IRU LPDJH TXDOLW\
DQG GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH 7KH GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH RI 66)3 VHTXHQFHV
LVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKDWRI7R)VHTXHQFHVDQGPD\EHFRQVLGHUHGDVD
SRWHQWLDODOWHUQDWLYHGLDJQRVWLFWRROLQVHOHFWHGSDWLHQWV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
+RZVKRXOGUHQDODUWHU\VWHQRVHVEHPHDVXUHG"
0$QGHUVVRQ.-lJHUYDOO3(ULNVVRQ$3HUVVRQ**UDQHUXVg6PHGE\
/LQN|SLQJ6(
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHZKLFKPRUSKRORJLFDOPHDVXUHVIURP&7$DQG05$DUHEHVW
LQSUHGLFWLQJZKHWKHUDUHQDODUWHU\VWHQRVLVDIIHFWVUHQDOKDHPRG\QDPLFVRUQRW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\VHYHQSDWLHQWVZLWKK\SHUWHQVLRQRUDQWLK\SHUWHQ
VLYHWUHDWPHQWDQGDFOLQLFDOVXVSLFLRQRIUHQRYDVFXODUK\SHUWHQVLRQZHUHH[DPLQHG
ZLWKFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\
05$ FDSWRSULOHQKDQFHGUHQRJUDSK\ &(5 DQGFDSWRSULOWHVW &WHVW 7KH&7$
DQG05$LPDJHVRIWKHUHQDODUWHULHVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\WZRUHDGHUVXVLQJIX]]\
FRQQHFWHGQHVV VHJPHQWDWLRQ 7KH PHDVXUHV XVHG ZHUH PLQLPXP GLDPHWHU
PLQLPXPDUHDGLDPHWHUUHGXFWLRQDQGDUHDUHGXFWLRQ,QDGGLWLRQWZRUDGLRORJLVWV
PHDVXUHG WKH GLDPHWHU UHGXFWLRQ ZLWKRXW XVLQJ DXWRPDWHG VHJPHQWDWLRQ 7KH
UHVXOWVZHUHWKHQFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHUHVXOWVIURP&(5FRPELQHGZLWK&WHVWXVLQJ
UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFV 52& DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV $ WRWDO RI NLGQH\V KDG DOO WKUHH LQYHVWLJDWLRQV &7$ 05$ DQG
&(5&WHVW ZKHUHNLGQH\V JRWDSRVLWLYHUHVXOWRQWKH&(5&WHVW$UHD
UHGXFWLRQRQ05$KDGWKHJUHDWHVWDUHDXQGHU52&FXUYH $852&
FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO 7KH$852&IRUWKHUDGLRORJLVWVҋPHDVXUHPHQWVRQ
&7$DQG05$ZHUH DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\1RQHRI
WKHGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
&RQFOXVLRQ 1R VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV ZHUH IRXQG EHWZHHQ WKH PRUSKRORJLFDO
PHDVXUHVLQWKHLUDELOLW\WRSUHGLFWSRVLWLYHUHQRJUDSKLFÀQGLQJVEXWDWHQGHQF\
RI05$KDYLQJKLJKHU$852&WKDQ&7$7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEH
WZHHQWKHPHDVXUHPHQWVPDGHE\WKHUDGLRORJLVWVDQGWKHPHDVXUHPHQWVPDGH
ZLWKIX]]\FRQQHFWHGQHVVVHJPHQWDWLRQ)XUWKHUVWXGLHVDUHUHTXLUHGWRGHÀQLWHO\
LGHQWLI\WKHRSWLPDOPHDVXUHPHQW
%
'XSOH[HYDOXDWLRQRIGLVWDOUHQDODUWHU\WRSUHGLFWWKHSUHVHQFHRI
SUR[LPDOVLJQLÀFDWLYHDFFHOHUDWLRQDQH[SHULHQFHRIH[SORUDWLRQV
-/HDO55RGULJXH]-3HLQDGR69LFHQWH&6DOJDGR$)ORUHV-*LO
$2UJD]0'REODV7ROHGR(6 MBLBOHDO#ZDQDGRRHV
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHDFFXUDF\RILQGLUHFWKDHPR
G\QDPLFSDUDPHWHUVREWDLQHGE\HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHVHJPHQWDORULQWHUOREDODUWHULHV
ZLWKLQWKHNLGQH\DVSUHGLFWRUVRIWKHSUHVHQFHRIKDHPRG\QDPLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDWLYH
SUR[LPDOUHQDODUWHU\VWHQRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSHUIRUPHGDUHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIDOOFRQVHFX
WLYHO\VWXGLHGSDWLHQWVDWRXUFHQWUHZLWKVXVSHFWHG5$6'LUHFWKDHPRG\QDPLFDO
PHDVXUHV UHQDO SHDN V\VWROLF YHORFLW\5369DQG HQG GLDVWROLF YHORFLW\('9
GHWHUPLQHGLQWKHSUR[LPDODQGPLGGOHVHJPHQWVRIWKHPDLQUHQDODUWHU\ZHUH
PHDVXUHG ZLWK WKH DVVRFLDWLRQ RI IRXU LQGLUHFW 'RSSOHU SDUDPHWHUV REWDLQHG LQ
WKHUHQDOKLOLXP 5HVLVWLYH,QGH[5,$FFHOHUDWLRQ,QGH[$,6\VWROLF$FFHOHUDWLRQ
7LPH$7DQG3XOVDWLOLW\,QGH[3, 7KHSRSXODWLRQZDVFODVVLÀHGE\WKHSUHVHQFH
RUDEVHQFHRIGLUHFWKDHPRG\QDPLFDOFULWHULDRI5$6 5369!FPV DQGWKH
GLVWDOLQGLUHFWSDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRPSDUHGLQWKHVHWZRSRSXODWLRQV
5HVXOWV$WRWDORIH[SORUDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZHUHDQDO\VHG$SUHGLFWLYH
ELQDU\ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOZDVGHYHORSHGLQRUGHUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHDFFXUDF\
RI GLVWDO LQGLUHFW SDUDPHWHUV WR SUHGLFW WKH SUHVHQFH RI D SUR[LPDO VLJQLÀFDWLYH
53697KHDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYHRIWKHUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFDQDO\VLV
RIWKHSUHGLFWLYHPRGHOZDV FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO>&,@
LQGLFDWLQJJRRGGLVFULPLQDWLRQSRZHUEHWZHHQWKRVHZLWKDQGZLWKRXWVLJQLÀFDWLYH
SUR[LPDO YDOXHV RI 5369 2QO\ 3, SUHYDOHQFH RGGV UDWLR >325@ &,
DQG$7 325&, ZHUHVLJQLÀFDWLYHO\DVVRFL
DWHGZLWKKLJKHVW5369
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWGLVWDOLQGLUHFWKDHPRG\QDPLFSDUDPHWHUV
3,DQG7$FRXOGSURYLGHJRRGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQWKHSUHGLFWLRQRISUR[LPDO
VLJQLÀFDWLYH 5369 YDOXHV EHLQJ XVHIXO ZKHQ PDLQYHVVHO YHORFLWLHV FDQQRW EH
GHWHUPLQHGUHOLDEO\
%
1RQHQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ 05$ RIWKHUHQDO
DUWHULHVFRPSDULVRQZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05$
'/XPLD0*$QJHUHWWL$&DQL$00DUHVFD($*HQRYHVH&)XJD]]ROD
9DUHVH,7 GRPHQLFROXPLD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIQRQHQKDQFHGVWHDG\VWDWHIUHH
SUHFHVVLRQ 66)3 PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ 1(05$ IRUGHWHFWLRQRI
UHQDO DUWHU\ VWHQRVLV 5$6 LQ FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK EUHDWKKROG FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
05DQJLRJUDSK\ &(05$ DVWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[W\WKUHHSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHV ZLWKVXVSHFWHG
UHQRYDVFXODUK\SHUWHQVLRQZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWK1(05$XVLQJD(&*JDWHG66)3
VHTXHQFH DQG D 7 05 VFDQQHU LQ SDWLHQWV D UHVSLUDWRU\ WULJJHU ZDV
XVHGLQDGGLWLRQWRFDUGLDFJDWLQJ'XULQJWKHVDPHH[DPLQDWLRQ&(05$ZDV
SHUIRUPHGLQDOOSDWLHQWVDQGLWVUHVXOWVXVHGDVUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG0,3LPDJH
TXDOLW\QXPEHURIPDLQUHQDODUWHULHVDFFHVVRU\DUWHULHVDQGSUHVHQFHRIVWHQRVHV
ZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWO\DVVHVVHGE\WZRUHDGHUV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYH 339
DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHV 139 RI1(05$LQWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIVLJQLÀFDQW
5$6ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV0,3LPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVFRQVLGHUHGEHWWHUIRU1(05$E\ERWKUHDGHUV
1(05$LGHQWLÀHGDUWHULHVGHWHFWHGE\&(05$ DFFHVVRU\PLVVHG
)RXUWHHQVWHQRVHVZHUHLGHQWLÀHGE\&(05$ DWKHURVFOHURWLFG\VSODVWLF
ZLWK VLJQLÀFDQW 5$6 6HQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ 339 DQG 139 RI 1(05$ ZHUH
UHVSHFWLYHO\DQGIRUUHDGHUDQG
DQGIRUUHDGHU2YHUHVWLPDWLRQRIWKHVWHQRVLVJUDGHRFFXUUHGLQWZRFDVHV
IRUUHDGHU YVQRUPDOLQRQHFDVHYVLQWKHRWKHUFDVH
&RQFOXVLRQ1(05$KDVEHFRPHDYLDEOHDOWHUQDWLYHWR&(05$IRUWKHVWXG\RI
WKHUHQDODUWHULHV,QFDVHRIVLJQLÀFDQWVWHQRVLVJLYHQWKHULVNRIRYHUHVWLPDWLRQ
WKHXVHRI&(05$LVVWLOOLQGLFDWHG
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIUHQDODUWHU\DQHXU\VPE\QRQFRQWUDVWPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\D6/((.VHTXHQFHFRPSDULVRQZLWK&7$
<3HL&KDQJVKD&1 WMS\J#FRP
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQHZQRQFRQWUDVWPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
DQJLRJUDSK\ 1&05$ VHTXHQFH VSDWLDOODEHOOLQJZLWKPXOWLSOHLQYHUVLRQSXOVHV
6/((. LQLWVDELOLW\WRSUHVHQWWKHUHQDODUWHU\DQHXU\VP 5$$ DQGWRLQYHVWLJDWH
ZKHWKHUDVXLWDEOHPXOWLSOHEORRGVXSSUHVVLRQLQYHUVLRQWLPH %637, FDQKHOSWR
LPSURYH5$$YLVLELOLW\LQ6/((.
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5$$VFRQÀUPHGE\&7$ZDVFDUULHGRXW1&05$
XVLQJ6/((.RQD705V\VWHPZLWKYDULRXV%637,$VXLWDEOH%637,WR
LQFUHDVH5$$YLVLELOLW\ZDVGHWHUPLQHGDQG5$$ZDVHYDOXDWHGIRUHDFKSDWLHQW
E\WZRH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVLQWKHLUFRQVHQVXVDQGZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK&7$
UHVXOWVXVLQJDMRLQWUHDGLQJSHUIRUPHGLQFRQVHQVXV
5HVXOWV5$$VFRQVLVWHGRIULJKWDQGOHIW5$$V 5$$VZHUHSHUIRUPHG
E\VXUJHU\ LQFOXGLQJ5$$VZLWKFP5$$VZLWK!FPDQGFP
5$$VZLWK!FPDQGFP5$$VZLWK!FP7KHH[FHOOHQWFRUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQ6/((.DQG&7$ZDVIRXQGLQSUHVHQWLQJ5$$VL]H 5V S
7KHVXLWDEOH%637,ZDVPVIRUGLVSOD\LQJ5$$ZLWKFPPVIRU
5$$ZLWK!FPDQGFPPVIRU5$$ZLWK!FPDQGFP
DQGPVIRU5$$ZLWK!FP
&RQFOXVLRQ$VXLWDEOH%637,LQ6/((.PD\LQFUHDVHWKH5$$YLVLELOLW\6/((.
UHSUHVHQWVDQRQUHQDOFRPSOLFDWLRQUHODWLYHO\LQH[SHQVLYHDQGUHOLDEOHGLDJQRVWLF
PHWKRGIRUHYDOXDWLQJ5$$V,WFDQEHDVDQDOWHUQDWLYHFKRLFHRI&7$IRUHYDOXDWLQJ
5$$VHVSHFLDOO\LQVXEMHFWVZLWKUHQDOLQVXIÀFLHQF\
%
6\PPHWU\RIDWKHURVFOHURWLFOHVLRQVDWWKHORZHUH[WUHPLWLHVDUWHULHV
RQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ 05$
91DUGHOOD)6HFFKL$*LDUGLQR(5HVWD*'L/HR)6DUGDQHOOL0LODQ,7
JDLDQDUGHOOD#JPDLOFRP
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
6WXG\RIWKHOHIWUHQDOYHLQYDULDWLRQVDQGLQIHULRUYHQDFDYD
YDULDWLRQVE\PHDQVRIVSLUDOFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
$'LOOL8<$\D]%+HNLPRJOXdDQND\D750HUVLQ75
XPLW\DVDUD\D]#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH$UHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVGHVLJQHGWRHYDOXDWHWKHSHUFHQWDJHVRIWKH
OHIWUHQDOYHLQYDULDWLRQVLQIHULRUYHQDFDYDYDULDWLRQVDQGWKHHIIHFWRIJHQGHURQ
WKHLUIUHTXHQFLHVXVLQJVSLUDOFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG$XJXVWWKHVWXG\SRSX
ODWLRQZDVUHFUXLWHGIURPSDWLHQWVZKRZRXOGXQGHUJRDFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
DEGRPLQDOVSLUDO&7H[DPLQDWLRQIRUYDULRXVDEGRPLQDOSUREOHPV
5HVXOWV$VWKHOHIWUHQDOYHLQYDULDWLRQVUHWURDRUWLFOHIWUHQDOYHLQ 5/59 DQG
FLUFXPDRUWLF OHIW UHQDO YHLQ &/59 ZHUH GHWHFWHG 7KH QXPEHU RI FDVHV ZLWK
WKHFRUUHVSRQGHQWSHUFHQWDJHVRIWKHWRWDOOHIWUHQDOYHLQYDULDWLRQV5/59DQG
&/59ZDV DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\
7KHUHLVDFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQIHPDOHJHQGHUDQGIUHTXHQF\RIWKHOHIWUHQDOYHLQ
YDULDWLRQV 3 5/59LVWLPHVPRUHIUHTXHQWLQIHPDOHVWKDQLQPDOHV
FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO $VWKHLQIHULRUYHQDFDYD ,9& YDULDWLRQV
GXSOLFDWLRQRI,9&DQGWUDQVSRVLWLRQRI,9&ZHUHGHWHFWHG7KHQXPEHURIFDVHV
ZLWKWKHFRUUHVSRQGHQWSHUFHQWDJHVRIWKHWRWDO,9&YDULDWLRQVGXSOLFDWLRQRI,9&
DQGWUDQVSRVLWLRQRI,9&ZDV
UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHZDVQRHIIHFWRIJHQGHURQWKHIUHTXHQFLHVRI,9&YDULDWLRQV
3
&RQFOXVLRQ$EGRPLQDO VSLUDO &7 LV XVHIXO LQ GHWHFWLQJ WKH OHIW UHQDO YHLQ YDUL
DWLRQV 5/59 &/59 DQG WKH ,9& YDULDWLRQV 5DGLRORJLFDO UHFRJQLWLRQ RI WKHVH
YDULDWLRQVLVFUXFLDOZKHQDQ,9&VXUJHU\DQGDOHIWUHQDORUUHWURSHULWRQHDOVXUJHU\
DUHFRQVLGHUHG
5RRP3
5DGLRJUDSKHUV
66
5DGLRJUDSKHUVLQWKHFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
+++MHPO\2OVR12
:+UXE\9LHQQD$7
%
'LJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\WUDLQLQJWHFKQLFDOFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFHVDQG
ZRUNÁRZLVVXHV
&5HLV/5DGX76DNHOODULV6&DUUDVTXHLUR$3DVFRDO5LRGH0RXUR37
FODXGLDUHLV#HVWHVOLSOSW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVFXUUHQWSUDFWLFHVLQGLJLWDOPDPPRJUDSK\ '0 LQ3RUWXJXHVH
KRVSLWDOVFOLQLFVWRLQYHVWLJDWHFRPSOLDQFHZLWK(XURSHDQVWDQGDUGVDQGWRLGHQWLI\
RSWLPLVDWLRQQHHGV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7KUHH TXHVWLRQQDLUHV WDUJHWHG DW EUHDVWUDGLRORJLVWV
EUHDVWUDGLRJUDSKHUV DQG FKLHIUDGLRJUDSKHU ZHUH GHVLJQHG DQG DSSOLHG LQ
LPDJLQJGHSDUWPHQWVRIIHULQJ'0,QVWLWXWLRQDQGVWDIISURÀOHVWHFKQRORJ\TXDOLW\
FRQWURO 4& WHFKQLFDOFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFHVZRUNORDGDQGFHUWLÀFDWLRQPDWWHUVZHUH
LQYHVWLJDWHG
5HVXOWV$SDUWLFLSDWLRQUDWHRIZDVDFKLHYHG SULYDWHSXEOLF
UHSUHVHQWLQJDWRWDORIUDGLRJUDSKHUVUDGLRORJLVWVDQGFKLHIUDGLRJUDSKHUV
SDUWLFLSDWLQJ 7KH WUDLQLQJ VXUYH\ UHYHDOHG RI UDGLRJUDSKHUV DQG
RI UDGLRORJLVWV ZLWKRXW VSHFLÀF WUDLQLQJ LQ '0 5HJDUGLQJ SUDFWLFHV PRVW
UDGLRJUDSKHUVHQTXLUHGXVH$(&IRUVWDQGDUGEUHDVWLPDJLQJ7KHH[LVWHQFHRI
DQH[SRVXUHLQGLFDWRUZDVLJQRUHGE\RIUDGLRJUDSKHUV0RVWVLWHV
SHUIRUPHTXLSPHQW4&5HMHFWHGDQDO\VLVZDVUDUH (85()JXLGHOLQHV
ZHUHIROORZHGLQRIWKHVLWHVZLWKPDQXIDFWXUHUUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIUHTXHQWO\
GULYLQJSUDFWLFHVRIWKHFHQWUHVVWLOOSULQWDOOLPDJHVZKLOH
QHYHUGRHV2YHUDOOWKHSDUWLFLSDQWFHQWUHVUHSUHVHQWHGDQHVWLPDWHGSURGXFWLRQRI
PDPPRJUDSKLFH[DPLQDWLRQVPRQWKZLWKQRWLFHDEOHYDULDWLRQVLQZRUNORDG
DQG ZRUNHIÀFLHQF\ WR PDPPRJUDSK\KRXU 5DGLRORJLVWV DJUHHG
ZLWKWKHQHHGIRUFHUWLÀFDWLRQLQ'0DQGWKHZRXOGMRLQDYROXQWHHUSURJUDP
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH 2XU DLP ZDV WR TXDQWLI\ WKH V\PPHWU\ EHWZHHQ ULJKW DQG OHIW ORZHU
H[WUHPLWLHVDWKHURVFOHURWLFDUWHULHVOHVLRQVRQ05$
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWHG D FRQVHFXWLYH VHULHV RI
UHSRUWVFRQFHUQLQJSDWLHQWV DJHG\HDUVIHPDOHV ZKRXQGHUZHQWORZHU
H[WUHPLWLHV05$:HSHUIRUPHGDWKUHHVWHS05$IURPDRUWLFELIXUFDWLRQWRWLELDO
DUWHULHVXVLQJD'JUDGLHQWHFKRVHTXHQFHEHIRUHDIWHULQWUDYHQRXVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
RIPPRONJRIJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH 'LVHDVHJUDGH '* ZDVHYDOXDWHG
IRUHDFKDUWHU\XVLQJDSRLQWVFRUH QRUPDO VWHQRVLV VWHQRVLV
RU DQHXULVP RFFOXVLRQ 0RUHRYHU DIWHU H[FOXVLRQ RI QRUPDO ELODWHUDO
YHVVHOVGLVHDVHV\PPHWU\ '6 ZDVHYDOXDWHGIRUHDFKDUWHU\FRPSDUHGZLWKWKH
FRQWUDODWHUDOZHFDOFXODWHG'6DVDEVROXWHGLIIHUHQFHRIOHIWDQGULJKWOHJ'*IRU
HDFKYHVVHO PD[V\PPHWU\DQG PLQV\PPHWU\ $EVROXWHPHGLDQ'6ZDV
FDOFXODWHGIRUDUWHU\DQGIRUSDWLHQW0HGLDQ'6SHUSDWLHQWVZDVZHLJKWHGIRUWKH
QXPEHURISDWKRORJLFDODUWHULHV ZHLJKWHG'6:'6 PD[DQG PLQV\PPHWU\
:HFRPSDUHGWKHOHIWOHJJOREDO'*ZLWKULJKWOHJJOREDO'*WKURXJK:LOFR[RQWHVW
5HVXOWV &RPSDULQJ WKH JOREDO '* EHWZHHQ WKH WZR OHJV QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHU
HQFHZDVIRXQG 3 0HGLDQ'6VFRUHZDVIRUWKHIHPRUDOSURIXQGDDQG
VXSHUÀFLDOSRSOLWHDDQWHULRUWLELDODQGSHURQHDODUWHULHV0HGLDQSDWLHQW'6VFRUH
ZDVZKLOHPHGLDQSDWLHQW:'6VFRUHZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ3DWLHQWVVKRZHGDV\PPHWULFDOGLVWULEXWLRQRIDWKHURVFOHURWLFOHVLRQV
LQSDUWLFXODUIRUWKHIHPRUDOSURIXQGDDQGVXSHUÀFLDOSRSOLWHDDQWHULRUWLELDODQG
SHURQHDODUWHULHV3DWLHQWҋVDQDO\VLVVKRZHGDV\PPHWULFDOOHVLRQVDQGVHYHULW\
GLVWULEXWLRQ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 2QWKHMRE GRVLPHWU\ WUDLQLQJ DQG UHMHFW DQDO\VLV PD\ FRQWULEXWH
WR LPSURYH SUDFWLFHV LQ '0 (XURSHDQ JXLGHOLQHV DUH XVHG LQ D OLPLWHG QXPEHU
RIVLWHV0DQXIDFWXUHUҋVUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVGULYHFXUUHQWSUDFWLFHVLQPRVWVLWHV
(IÀFLHQWÀQDQFLDOJDLQVPD\EHREWDLQHGIURPVWDQGDUGLVLQJGLJLWDOLPDJHRXWSXW
%
+RZWRLQFUHDVHWKHSDUWLFLSDWLRQUDWHDPRQJQRQ(XURSHDQ
LPPLJUDQWVLQWKHPDPPRJUDSK\VFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPHLQ2VOR1RUZD\
(5RVWDG5*XOOLHQ+/LQQHVWDG2VOR12 URHE#XXVQR
3XUSRVH7RLQFUHDVHWKHSDUWLFLSDWLRQDPRQJQRQ(XURSHDQLPPLJUDQWVDWWKH
PDPPRJUDSK\VFUHHQLQJ6WXGLHVVKRZVWKDWOHVVWKDQLQZRPDQIURPPLQRU
LW\JURXSVNQRZVDERXWPDPPRJUDSK\VFUHHQLQJDQGEUHDVWFDQFHUGHVSLWHWKH
IDFWWKDWEUHDVWFDQFHULVDFRPPRQFDXVHRIGHDWKDPRQJZRPHQLQWKHJURXS
1RQ(XURSHDQ LPPLJUDQWV LQ 2VOR KDYH ORZ SDUWLFLSDWLRQ UDWH LQ WKH VFUHHQLQJ
SURJUDPPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHGHSDUWPHQWIRFXVHGRQWKHODUJHVWPLQRULW\JURXSV
ZLWKZRPHQVSHDNLQJ8UGX$UDELFDQG6RPDOL3RVWHUVLQWKHVHODQJXDJHVDQG
1RUZHJLDQ ZLWK D VXPPDU\ DERXW PDPPRJUDSK\ VFUHHQLQJ ZHUH SULQWHG DQG
VHQWWRDOOJHQHUDOSUDFWLWLRQHUVLQ2VORDQGKXQJXSLQSXEOLFSODFHVDQGKHDOWK
RIÀFHVLQGLVWULFWVZLWKPDQ\ZRPHQIURPPLQRULW\JURXSV5DGLRJUDSKHUVIURPWKH
GHSDUWPHQWYLVLWHGZRPHQҋVJURXSVDQGLQIRUPHGDERXWPDPPRJUDSK\VFUHHQLQJ
DQGEUHDVWFDQFHU1RWDOOZRPHQFDQUHDGWKHLUQDWLYHODQJXDJHVRWKHUHZHUH
EURDGFDVWHGVHYHUDOUDGLRVKRZVLQ8UGX$UDELFDQG6RPDOL
5HVXOWV7KHJHQHUDOSUDFWLWLRQHUVDUHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHSRVWHUVDQGLQIRUPWKHLU
SDWLHQWV DERXW PDPPRJUDSK\ VFUHHQLQJ 7KH UHVSRQVH DW WKH PHHWLQJV LQ WKH
ZRPHQҋV JURXSV KDV EHHQ VXFFHVVIXO 7KH DWWHQGDQFHV DW WKH PHHWLQJV ZHUH
GRXEOHGWKHZRPHQZHUHLQYROYHGDQGDVNHGUHOHYDQWTXHVWLRQV'XULQJWKHUDGLR
VKRZZRPHQFDOOHGWRFRPPHQWRQWKHWRSLF7KHUHKDVEHHQLQFUHDVHGSDUWLFLSD
WLRQIURPQRQ(XURSHDQLPPLJUDQWVDWWKHPDPPRJUDSK\VFUHHQLQJ
&RQFOXVLRQ,WLVLPSRUWDQWWRFRQWLQXHWKHRQJRLQJZRUNDQGLQFOXGHQHZLQLWLDWLYHV
WRLQFUHDVHWKHSDUWLFLSDWLRQDPRQJQRQ(XURSHDQLPPLJUDQWVLQWKHPDPPRJUDSK\
VFUHHQLQJSURJUDPPH
%
(FKRHVIURP(VWRQLDLQWURGXFWLRQRIVRQRJUDSK\DVDVSHFLDOLVP
IRUUDGLRJUDSKHUV
-'RGJHRQ$/XNNHQ39DKWUDPDH6DOIRUG8.7DUWX((
-UGRGJHRQ#VDOIRUGDFXN
3XUSRVH$Q(8IXQGHGSURMHFWZDVLQLWLDWHGE\WKH(VWRQLDQ6RFLHW\RI5DGLRJ
UDSKHUVDQG7DUWX+HDOWKFDUH &ROOHJH WRWUDLQUDGLRJUDSKHUV LQRQHRIWKUHH
VSHFLDOLVWDUHDV5DGLRWKHUDS\QXFOHDUPHGLFLQHDQGGLDJQRVWLFXOWUDVRXQG7KLV
SUHVHQWDWLRQIRFXVHVRQRQHDVSHFWRIWKHSURMHFWGHVLJQHGWRFUHDWHDQHGXFDWLRQ
SURJUDPPHIRUDQHZJURXSRIUDGLRJUDSKHUVLQ(VWRQLDVRQRJUDSKHUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVRQRJUDSK\SURMHFWVWDUWHGLQWKHÀUVW\HDUEH
LQJGHYRWHGWRFXUULFXOXPGHVLJQEDVHGRQ()680%JXLGHOLQHV,QWHUQDWLRQDOOLQNV
ZHUHPDGHZLWK6ZHGHQWKH8.DQGWKH86$7KHHGXFDWLRQZDVLPSOHPHQWHG
IURP)HEUXDU\DQGWKLVSUHVHQWDWLRQH[DPLQHVWKHYLVLWE\D8.XOWUDVRXQG
HGXFDWLRQDOLVW$EHVSRNHHGXFDWLRQDOSURJUDPPHFRPSULVLQJOHFWXUHVDQGKDQGV
RQ SUDFWLFDO WUDLQLQJ VHVVLRQV ZDV GHOLYHUHG RYHU RQH ZHHN 6XEVHTXHQWO\ WKH
NQRZOHGJHRIWKHVWXGHQWVZDVWHVWHGDQGWKHWHDFKLQJHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV7KH VWXGHQWVҋ NQRZOHGJH DQG VNLOOV ZHUH HQKDQFHG E\ WKH LQSXW7KH
(VWRQLDQVWDIIDFTXLUHGWHDFKLQJUHVRXUFHVDQGZHUHDVVLVWHGLQGHYHORSLQJXO
WUDVRXQGH[DPLQDWLRQSURWRFROV6XFFHVVIXOVWXGHQWVJUDGXDWHGLQ-DQXDU\
DQGVRQRJUDSK\VSHFLDOLVPKDVEHHQDSSURYHGDVQHZRFFXSDWLRQE\WKH(VWRQLDQ
4XDOLÀFDWLRQV$XWKRULW\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHLVQRZDZRUNIRUFHRIUDGLRJUDSKHUVRQRJUDSKHUVZKRFDQ
ZRUNWRUHGXFHZDLWLQJOLVWWLPHVDQGHQKDQFHKHDOWKFDUHGHOLYHU\LQ(VWRQLD7KH
KRVWHGXFDWLRQDOLVWVKDYHDFTXLUHGFRQVLGHUDEOHUHVRXUFHVDQGVNLOOVZKLFKZLOO
HQDEOHWKHPWRGHYHORSFXUULFXODDQGFRQWLQXHWUDLQLQJUDGLRJUDSKHUVIRUDGYDQFHG
SUDFWLFHUROHV
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIWKHÀUVWUDGLRJUDSKHUVZLWKDGGLWLRQDOGHJUHHLQ
XOWUDVRXQGWRZKDWH[WHQWDUHWKHOHDUQLQJREMHFWLYHVDFKLHYHG
PRQWKVDIWHUJUDGXDWLRQ"
.*9LNHVWDG(1(LNHIMRUG%0+RIPDQQ2VOR12%HUJHQ12
X[YNDU#RXVKIQR
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHXOWUDVRXQG 86 ÀQGLQJVRI
DGYDQFHGUDGLRJUDSKHUSUDFWLRQHU $35 DQGH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWV7RVHHLI
$35 PDQDJH WR VHSDUDWH SRVLWLYH DQG QHJDWLYH H[DPLQDWLRQV IURP HDFK RWKHU
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
QXPEHURISLFWXUHVWLPHWRH[DPWHFKQLFDOLPDJHTXDOLW\VLJQLÀFDQWÀQGLQJVDQG
DELOLW\WRSHUIRUPUHSRUWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDO7KHVWXG\ZDVFRQGXFWHGDVDTXDQWLWDWLYHSURVSHFWLYH
FRQWUROOHGVWXG\LQFOXGLQJSDWLHQWVÀYH$35VDQGIRXUH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWV
$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWXOWUDVRXQGH[DPLQDWLRQVE\DQ$35DQGDUDGLRORJLVW7KH
$35ZHUHQRWJLYHQWKHRSSRUWXQLW\WRFRQVXOWDUDGLRORJLVWGXULQJWKHH[DPLQDWLRQV
DQGWKH\ZHUHEOLQGHGIRUHDFKRWKHUVÀQGLQJV7KH\VHSDUDWHO\UHJLVWHUHGWLPH
SHUH[DPLQDWLRQQXPEHURILPDJHVLQFRPSOHWHH[DPLQDWLRQVFRQÀGHQFHLQRZQ
ÀQGLQJV7KHH[DPLQDWLRQVSHUIRUPHGE\WKH$35ZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\UDGLRORJLVWV
IRUWHFKQLFDOLPDJHTXDOLW\WKHDELOLW\RIWKH$35WRPDNHVLJQLÀFDQWÀQGLQJVDQG
DGGLWLRQDOÀQGLQJVDELOLW\WRSHUIRUPGLDJQRVWLFUHSRUWVDQGDQRYHUDOOHYDOXDWLRQ
RIWKHLUH[DPLQDWLRQV6WDWLVWLFVLQWKHVWXG\&RKHQV.DSSDWHVW&KLVTXDUHWHVWV
DQGSDLUHGWWHVW
5HVXOWV7KHUDGLRORJLVWDQG$35VKRZHGÀQGLQJVFRQIRUPDW,Q
RIWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVWKHUDGLRORJLVWVJDYHWKH$35V´EHVWµRU´PHGLXPEHVWµVFRUH
LQRYHUDOOFRQÀGHQFHRIWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVKDGDWHFKQLFDOTXDOLW\VXSHULRU
RUHTXDOWRWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVSHUIRUPHGE\UDGLRORJLVWV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\LQGLFDWHVWKDW$35DUHTXDOLÀHGWRSHUIRUP86H[DPLQD
WLRQLQXSSHUDEGRPHQLQVDIHZD\LQ1RUZD\HTXDOWRUDGLRORJLVWJLYHQWKDWWKH\
XQGHUJRDTXDOLÀHGHGXFDWLRQ
%
&DQUDGLRORJLFWHFKQRORJLVWVEHWUDLQHGWRWULDJH&7FRORQRJUDSK\
IRUH[WUDFRORQLFÀQGLQJV"
71%RHOODDUG&<1LR300%RVVX\W6%LSDW-6WRNHU$PVWHUGDP1/
WQERHOODDUG#DPFXYDQO
3XUSRVH7HFKQRORJLVWVKDYHEHHQVKRZQWREHFDSDEOH&7FRORQRJUDSK\REVHUY
HUV DQG ZH HYDOXDWHG ZKHWKHU UDGLRORJLF WHFKQRORJLVWV FDQ EH WUDLQHG WR WULDJH
VFUHHQLQJ&7FRORQRJUDSK\IRUH[WUDFRORQLFÀQGLQJV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV(LJKWFRQVHQWLQJWHFKQRORJLVWVSDUWLFLSDWHGLQDVWUXFWXUHG
WUDLQLQJSURJUDPWKDWFRQVLVWHGRIVWXG\DVVLJQPHQWVDQGDKRXUFRXUVHZLWK
SUHVHQWDWLRQVREVHUYDWLRQRIH[SHUWUHDGLQJDQGUHDGLQJXQEOLQGHGFDVHV
6XEVHTXHQWO\WKH\UHSRUWHGH[WUDFRORQLFÀQGLQJVLQORZGRVH&7FRORQRJ
UDSKLHVZLWKRXWLQWUDYHQRXVFRQWUDVWPHGLXP7KLVGDWDVHWFRQWDLQHGDQG
VFDQVZLWKDSRVVLEO\ ( RUSUREDEO\LPSRUWDQW ( ÀQGLQJDVKLJKHVWFODVVLÀHG
ÀQGLQJ &5$'6 7KHÀUVWDQGODVWFDVHVZHUHLGHQWLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQFDVHV
,PPHGLDWHIHHGEDFNZDVJLYHQDIWHUHDFKFDVHIURPWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGH[FHSW
IRU H[DPLQDWLRQ FDVHV7HFKQRORJLVWV UHSRUWHG &5$'6 FODVVLÀFDWLRQ UHSRUWLQJ
WLPHDQGWKHQHHGIRUDUDGLRORJLVWWRUHDG:HFRQVWUXFWHGOHDUQLQJFXUYHVIRU
FRUUHFWVFDQWULDJLQJXVLQJDPRYLQJDYHUDJHWHFKQLTXH
5HVXOWV )RU WKH ÀQDO H[DP RI VFDQV ZLWK ( RU ( ÀQGLQJV DQG
ZLWKRXW(RU(ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRUUHFWO\WULDJHG7KHUHZDVLP
SURYHPHQWEHWZHHQWKHÀUVWDQGÀQDOH[DPLQLGHQWLI\LQJ(VFDQV
YV S 7KHUHZDVQRLPSURYHPHQWIRULGHQWLI\LQJ(VFDQV
ERWK 7KH WHFKQRORJLVWV DYHUDJH UHDGLQJ WLPH GHFUHDVHG IURP
WRPLQXWHV S
&RQFOXVLRQ7HFKQRORJLVWVKDYHDQLQFUHDVHGFDSDELOLW\LQWULDJLQJH[WUDFRORQLF
ÀQGLQJV DW &7 FRORQRJUDSK\ DIWHU WUDLQLQJ$ KLJKHU QXPEHU RI FDVHV DQGRU D
PRGLÀHGWUDLQLQJSURJUDPLVQHHGHGWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWHFKQRORJLVWVFDQUHDFK
VXIÀFLHQWFRPSHWHQFH
%
3URSRVHG&7GLDJQRVWLFUHIHUHQFHOHYHOVIRU,UHODQG
6-)ROH\0)0F(QWHH/$5DLQIRUG'XEOLQ,(6\GQH\$8
VKDQHIROH\#XFGLH
3XUSRVH&RPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7 LVUHFRJQLVHGDVWKHODUJHVWFRQWULEXWRUWR
SRSXODWLRQGRVHIURPPHGLFDOH[SRVXUHVDFFRXQWLQJIRURIWKHWRWDOGRVH
EXW RQO\ RI WKH WRWDO H[DPLQDWLRQV LQ ,UHODQG 'LDJQRVWLF UHIHUHQFH OHYHOV
'5/V DUHFUXFLDOWRGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQIDFLOLWDWLQJWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIDEQRUPDOO\
KLJKGRVHV'5/VVKRXOGEHEDVHGRQORFDOUHJLRQDORUQDWLRQDOGDWDDQGUHÁHFW
ORFDOSUDFWLFHVKRZHYHUFXUUHQW,ULVKYDOXHVDUHEDVHGRQLQWHUQDWLRQDOGDWDIURP
*LYHQWKHDGYDQFHVWKDWKDYHRFFXUUHGLQ&7WHFKQRORJ\VLQFHWKHQDQGLWV
LQFUHDVLQJDSSOLFDWLRQWKLVUHVHDUFKSURSRVHVXSGDWHG'5/VIRUWKHPRVWFRP
PRQ&7H[DPLQDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\IRXU&7VFDQQHUVLQ,UHODQGIURPYDULRXVPDQXIDF
WXUHUVDQGZLWKYDULRXVPXOWLGHWHFWRUFDSDELOLWLHVZHUHVXUYH\HG(DFK&7FHQWUH
ZDV DVNHG WR UHFRUG &7 GRVH GDWD '/3 &7',YRO WXEH YROWDJH DQG FXUUHQW
SURVSHFWLYHO\ RQ DQRQ\PLVHG DGXOW SDWLHQWV RI DYHUDJH VL]H NJ
SUHVHQWLQJIRUHLJKWFRPPRQ&7H[DPLQDWLRQV0HDQUHVXOWVIURPHDFKVLWHZHUH
SRROHGDQGWKHWKSHUFHQWLOHZDVXVHGWRVHW'5/VXVLQJERWK&7',YRODQG'/3
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV'RVHGDWDRQSDWLHQWVZHUHFROOHFWHG7KH'5/VIRUEUDLQVLQXVHV
FHUYLFDO VSLQH FKHVW +5&7 SXOPRQDU\ DQJLRJUDSK\ DEGRPHQ DQG SHOYLV DV
ZHOODVWUXQNH[DPLQDWLRQVXVLQJ&7',YROZHUHDQG
P*\DQGXVLQJ'/3ZHUHP*\FP
UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHVHDUHXSWREHORZFXUUHQW,ULVKDQG(8UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV
DQGFRPSDUHIDYRXUDEO\ZLWKRWKHULQWHUQDWLRQDOVWXGLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ'5/VVKRXOGEHUHJXODUO\XSGDWHGWRIDFLOLWDWHRSWLPLVDWLRQRIUDGLD
WLRQGRVHV
%
&RPSDULVRQRIDXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUHFRQWUROLQ&7HTXLSPHQWVOLFHV
00RQWHLUR-6DQWRV&6LOYD16DQWRV&RLPEUD37
PPRQWHLUR#HVWHVFRLPEUDSW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHLQÁXHQFHRIWKHWHFKQLFDOSDUDPHWHUVUHODWHGWRWKH$(&
LQWKHGRVHUHFHLYHGE\WKHSDWLHQWVDQGGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7VFDQVZHUHDFTXLUHGLQWZRFKHVWSKDQWRPV DGXOW
DQGSDHGLDWULF LQGLIIHUHQW&7HTXLSPHQWVZLWKFKDQJHVLQWHFKQLFDOSDUDP
HWHUVUHODWHGWRWKHLU$(&6L[GLIIHUHQWSURWRFROVZHUHXVHGIRUDGXOWDQGIRU
SDHGLDWULFDQGFKRVHQWZRLPDJHVIURPHDFKRQHWREHHYDOXDWHGXVLQJD7DEOH
VSHFLÀHGIRUWKDW7RHYDOXDWHWKHLULQÁXHQFHLQWKHÀQDOLPDJHTXDOLW\&7',ZDQG
'/3ZHUHDQDO\VHG
5HVXOWV7KHFKDQJHVPDGHLQWKHWHFKQLFDOSDUDPHWHUVGLGQRWLQGXFHVLJQLÀFDQW
FKDQJHVLQWKHGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\LPDJLQJ:LWKWKHXVHGSURWRFROVGRVHUHGXF
WLRQZDVDFKLHYHGZLWKRXWSURGXFLQJLPDJHVHQDEOHWRGLDJQRVH
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH QRLVH DQG P$V PD\ VWLOO EH KDQGOHG LQ D PRUH PHDQLQJIXO
ZD\LQRUGHUWRGHFUHDVHWKHGRVHYDOXHVZLWKRXWLQWHUIHULQJLQWKHLPDJHTXDO
LW\+RZHYHUWKLVDQDO\VLVPXVWEHDSSURSULDWHIRUWKHSDWLHQWDQGWKHDQDWRPLF
UHJLRQXQGHUVWXG\
%
,GHQWLÀFDWLRQRIVHQWLQHOQRGHVGXULQJUDGLRJUDSKHUSHUIRUPHG
O\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\SULRUWRVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHELRSV\
*&DPLOOHUL)=DUE.%RUJ*ULPD0VLGD07 IUDQFLV]DUE#XPHGXPW
%
5LQJOLNHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWLQOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVIURPUHFWDO
WXPRXUVW\SLFDOÀQGLQJV"
0.LVV%/RPED\0LVNROF+8
3XUSRVH5HFWDOFDQFHUFDQPHWDVWDVL]HWRDOPRVWDQ\ORFDWLRQLQWKHERG\PRVW
FRPPRQO\WKHOLYHUOXQJDQGSHULWRQHXP7KHORQJWHUPUHVXOWVKDYHLPSURYHG
EXWORQJWHUPVXUYLYDOUHPDLQVHOXVLYHIRUPRVW7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOWKHUDSHXWLFRS
WLRQVVXUJLFDOORFDORUV\VWHPLFFKHPRWKHUDS\WRPDQDJHPHWDVWDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQDQGZHH[DPLQHG
RQFRORJLFDOSDWLHQWVZLWKDNQRZQSULPDU\WXPRXUDQGKLVWRORJLFDOO\HVWDEOLVKHG
OLYHU PHWDVWDVHV7KHVH SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG &7 D 6LHPHQV
6RPDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ$6[GHWHFWRUURZ0'&7 DQGRUDFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
OLYHU05, D6LHPHQV0DJQHWRP6\PSKRQ\7 :HDQDO\VHGWKHYLVXDODS
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5RRP4
1HXUR
66
7XPRXUV
0RGHUDWRUV
($YGDJLF6DUDMHYR%$
):&DUWHV=XPHO]X,QQVEUXFN$7
%
5ROHRIPXOWLPRGDO05LQEUDLQJOLRPDJUDGLQJ
3$0DWWHL66DOLFH'7RUWRUD93DQDUD&%ULJDQWL$5&RWURQHR
0&DXOR$7DUWDUR&KLHWL,7 SDPDWWHL#XQLFKLW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIRSWLPLVHGFXWRIIVGHWHUPLQHGLQ
SUHHVWDEOLVKHGUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZLWKDGYDQFHG05WHFKQLTXHV SHUIXVLRQ
VSHFWURVFRS\GLIIXVLRQDQG'7, IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQJOLRPD:+2JUDGH,,
YV,,,DQG,,YV,,,DQG,9
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK FHUHEUDO JOLRPD ZHUH
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHGZLWKD705VFDQQHU*ROGVWDQGDUGZDVKLVWRORJ\LQ
ORZDQGKLJKJUDGH )RXU52,ZHUHDQDO\VHGDUHDRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFH
PHQW &( 7VLJQDOORZHUWKDQWKDWRIOLTXRU 7 7VLJQDOJUHDWHUWKDQRUHTXDO
WROLTXRU 7 DQGDUHDZLWKUHGXFHGGLIIXVLRQ 5' 6HYHUDOSDUDPHWHUVZHUH
GHWHUPLQHGIRUHDFK52,U&%9U077&KR&U&KR1$$/LS&U/DF&U$'&DQG
)$6WDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWKWWHVW S DQG52&DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV 7KH SDUDPHWHUV ZKLFK ZHUH FDSDEOH RI GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ EHWZHHQ WKH
ORZ DQG KLJK JUDGH JOLRPDV ZHUH U&%9 LQ &( FXWRII! VHQVLELOLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S 7 FXWRII! VHQVLELOLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S '5 FXWRII! VHQVLELOLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S &KR&U LQ 7 FXWRII! VHQVLELO
LW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S &KR&U LQ '5 FXWRII!
VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S $VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHLQU&%9ZDVQRWREVHUYHGEHWZHHQJUDGHV,,2'*DQG:+2JUDGH,,,
JOLRPDVRUEHWZHHQJUDGH,,2'*DQGJUDGH,,,DVWURF\WRPDV&KR&ULQ&(ZDV
KLJKHU FXWRII!VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S LQ
JUDGH,,,2'*FRPSDUHGWRJUDGH,,
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHLQWHJUDWLRQRIDGYDQFHG05TXDQWLWDWLYHELRPDUNHUVLQWKHGLI
IHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVEHWZHHQORZDQGKLJKJUDGHJOLRPDVFDQVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYH
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
%
'6&05,LQJOLREODVWRPDVFRUUHODWLRQRIZKROHWXPRXUKLVWRJUDP
DQDO\VLVRIFHUHEUDOEORRGYROXPHDQGYDVFXODUSHUPHDELOLW\ .WUDQV
ZLWKELRPDUNHUVRIWXPRXUDJJUHVVLYHQHVV
5/LVHUUH3/3ROLDQL0)HUUDUD6*ULVDQWL/%XWWROR
0%XJOLRQHGL0RQDOH5*DVSDURWWL%UHVFLD,7 UOLVHUUH#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH7RH[DPLQHWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQU&%9DQGFRQWUDVWWUDQVIHUFRHI
ÀFLHQW .WUDQV YDOXHVREWDLQHGZLWKG\QDPLFVXVFHSWLELOLW\FRQWUDVW05LPDJLQJ
'6&05, DQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWXPRXUDJJUHVVLYHQHVV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'6&05LPDJLQJ 6LHPHQV$YDQWR7 ZDVREWDLQHG
LQDFRQVHFXWLYHVHULHVRISDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOO\FRQÀUPHGJOLREODVWRPD
*%0 ZLWK D ZKROHEUDLQ 7 JUDGLHQWHFKR HFKR SODQDU VHTXHQFH GXULQJ ,9
LQMHFWLRQRIDEROXVRIJDGROLQLXP'73$3HUIXVLRQGDWDZHUHSURFHVVHGRIIOLQH
ZLWKDGHGLFDWHGVRIWZDUH 1RUGLF,FH WRFUHDWHFRORXUFRGHGPDSVRIU&%9DQG
.WUDQV5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52,V ZHUHPDQXDOO\GUDZQHQFRPSDVVLQJWKHZKROH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH7KHFRQFHSWWKDWPDOLJQDQWGLVHDVHSULPDULO\DIIHFWVWKHVHQWLQHOQRGHV
EHIRUHEHLQJGLVVHPLQDWHGLQWRWKHD[LOODU\QRGHV $/1V KDVGUDPDWLFDOO\HYROYHG
WRZDUGVPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHDSSURDFKHVLQEUHDVWFDQFHUPDQDJHPHQW5DGLRJUD
SKHUSHUIRUPHGO\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\XVLQJWKHFXWDQHRXV VXEGHUPDO SHULDUHRODU
DSSURDFKSULRUWR6/1%LVUDSLGO\HPHUJLQJDVWKHWHFKQLTXHIRUD[LOODU\VWDJLQJLQ
EUHDVWFDQFHUOLPLWLQJWKHGLVVHFWLRQWRWKHVHQWLQHOQRGHV 61 7KHREMHFWLYHRI
WKLVVWXG\ZDVWRGHÀQHWKHUROHRIUDGLRJUDSKHUSHUIRUPHGO\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\SULRU
WR6/1%DQGWRHVWDEOLVKWKHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHQXPEHUVRI61VYLVXDOLVHG
RQO\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\DQGWKHQXPEHURIVXUJLFDOO\LGHQWLÀHG61V
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV $ TXDQWLWDWLYH DSSURDFK ZDV FKRVHQ IRU WKLV QRQ
H[SHULPHQWDOFRUUHODWLRQW\SHRIVWXG\%HWZHHQ0D\DQG'HFHPEHUD
WRWDORIIHPDOHEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUV ZKRXQGHUZHQW
6/1%ZLWKSDUWLDORUWRWDOEDFNXSD[LOODU\QRGHGLVVHFWLRQ $/1' ZHUHHQUROOHGLQ
WKLVVWXG\/\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\UHSRUWVDQGKLVWRORJ\UHVXOWVZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
HYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV$PLQLPXPRIVHQWLQHOQRGHZDVYLVXDOLVHGRQO\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\LQ
RXWRISDWLHQWV 6XFFHVVIXOLPDJLQJZDVKLJKO\SUHGLFWLYH S RI
DVXFFHVVIXO6/1%5HVXOWVVKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWDVVRFLDWLRQ S EHWZHHQ
WKHQXPEHURI61VYLVXDOLVHGRQO\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\DQGWKHQXPEHURIVXUJLFDOO\
LGHQWLÀHG61VGXULQJ6/1%ZLWKDFRQFRUGDQFHUDWHRI
&RQFOXVLRQ/\PSKRVFLQWLJUDSK\SHUIRUPHGE\UDGLRJUDSKHUVZDVVKRZQWREH
LQGLVSHQVDEOHLQWKHUHOLDEOHSHUIRUPDQFHRI6/1%
SHDUDQFHWKHYDVFXODULVDWLRQRIWKHPHWDVWDVHVDQGVWXGLHGKRZWKH\FKDQJHG
GXULQJWKHFRXUVHRIWUHDWPHQW
5HVXOWV:HIRXQGOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK SDWLHQWVZKR
KDGSULPDU\UHFWDOWXPRXUV:HGLYLGHGWKHPHWDVWDVHVLQWRWZRJURXSVEDVHGRQ
WKHSDWWHUQRIWKHLUYDVFXODULW\K\SHUYDVFXODUDQGK\SRYDVFXODUPHWDVWDVHV$OO
WKHVHSDWLHQWUHFHLYHGV\VWHPLFFKHPRWKHUDS\,QWKHK\SRYDVFXODUPHWDVWDVHVZH
IRXQG UHJUHVVLRQZKHUHDVSDWLHQWV KDGXQFKDQJHGVWDWXV2Q
IXUWKHUHYDOXDWLRQDQGFRUUHODWLRQRILPDJHVZHIRXQGD´W\SLFDOULQJOLNHFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHPHQWµLQOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV(YHU\SDWLHQWZLWKWKHVHPHWDVWDVHVVXIIHUHG
SURJUHVVLRQLQGHSHQGHQWRIFKHPRWKHUDS\WUHDWPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ&7DQG05,VFDQKDVSURYHGWREHDQH[FHOOHQWDQGZLGHO\XVHG
PRGDOLW\ IRU WKH GHWHFWLRQ RI OLYHU PHWDVWDVHV7KH K\SHUYDVFXODULVHG OLYHU PH
WDVWDVHVZLWKW\SLFDOULQJOLNHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWDUHPRUHOLNHO\WRSURJUHVV
LQGHSHQGHQWRIV\VWHPLFFKHPRWKHUDS\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFLQJOHVLRQDQGQRQHQKDQFLQJSHULWXPRUDODUHD'DWDDQDO\VLVZDV
SHUIRUPHGZLWKWKHKLVWRJUDPDQDO\VLVRIQRUPDOLVHG&%9VDQG.WUDQVIURPWKH
HQWLUH WXPRXU YROXPH 7KH IROORZLQJ KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDO YDULDEOHV ZHUH LQFOXGHG
LQWRWKHVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVSUROLIHUDWLRQLQGH[ 0LE.L WXPRXUDQJLRJHQHVLV
HQKDQFHURI=HVWH(=+ HSLGHUPDOJURZWKIDFWRUUHFHSWRU (*)5 DQGS
5HVXOWV)RUZKROHWXPRXUKLVWRJUDPDQDO\VLVPHDQU&%9 SU DQG
U&%9PD[LPXPYDOXHV SU ZHUHIRXQGWREHVLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHG
ZLWK(*)5H[SUHVVLRQ0HDQDQGPD[LPXPU&%9YDOXHVWHQGHGWREHKLJKHULQ
SDWLHQWVVKRZLQJLQFUHDVHGRYHUH[SUHVVLRQRI(*)5ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQVXEJURXSVDVVKRZQE\SRVWKRFDQDO\VLV S 1RVLJQLÀFDQWDVVRFLD
WLRQVZHUHIRXQGEHWZHHQ.WUDQVDQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOPDUNHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ $FFRUGLQJ WR RXU ILQGLQJV (*)5 RYHUH[SUHVVLRQ D PROHFXODU
PDUNHUDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWXPRXULQYDVLYHQHVVDQJLRJHQHVLVDQGUDGLRUHVLVWDQFH
LVSRVLWLYHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKU&%9YDOXHVZKLFKFRXOGUHSUHVHQWDQHZSRWHQWLDO
SUHRSHUDWLYHSUHGLFWRURI*%0UHVSRQVHWRWKHUDS\
%
+LJKGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIG\QDPLFVXVFHSWLELOLW\FRQWUDVW '6&
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05 SHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJWRGLVWLQJXLVKUDGLDWLRQ
QHFURVLVIURPUHFXUUHQWWXPRXULQKLJKJUDGHJOLRPDSDWLHQWV
57MLRQJ09DQGHQ%HQW06PLWV5RWWHUGDP1/
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\DQGRSWLPDOUHODWLYHFHUHEUDOEORRGYRO
XPH U&%9 UDWLRWKUHVKROGVRIG\QDPLFVXVFHSWLELOLW\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG '6&
SHUIXVLRQWRGLVWLQJXLVKUDGLDWLRQQHFURVLVIURPUHFXUUHQWKLJKJUDGHJOLRPD +**
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP+**SDWLHQWVVFDQQHGDWPRQWKLQWHUYDOV
EHWZHHQ$SULODQG-XO\ZLWKDVWDQGDUGLVHG05LPDJLQJSURWRFRO
PDOHVPHDQDJH\ ZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHUDGLRWKHUDS\DQGVKRZHGQHZO\
GHYHORSHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFLQJOHVLRQVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\
'6&SHUIXVLRQLPDJHVZHUHREWDLQHGDW7 *(+HDOWKFDUH86 ZLWKDPO
SUHORDGDQGPO*DGRYLVW %D\HU3KDUPD EROXVDGPLQLVWHUHGDWPOVXV
LQJJUDGLHQWHFKRHFKRSODQDULPDJLQJ 75PV 5DWLRVRIPD[LPXPU&%9
LQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFLQJOHVLRQVDQGFRQWUDODWHUDOZKLWHPDWWHUZHUHFDOFXODWHG7KH
RXWFRPHPHDVXUHZDVWXPRXUSURJUHVVLRQGHÀQHGDVFOLQLFDODQGRUUDGLRORJLFDO
SURJUHVVLRQGXULQJPRQWKIROORZXS:LWKORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVWKHLQÁXHQFH
RISDWLHQWVҋDJHVH[WXPRXUW\SHDQGU&%9YDOXHVRQRXWFRPHZDVGHWHUPLQHG
$UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& FXUYHZDVFUHDWHGXVLQJVHQVLWLYLW\DQG
VSHFLÀFLW\RIGLIIHUHQWU&%9UDWLRWKUHVKROGVIRUSURJUHVVLRQ
5HVXOWV2QO\WKHU&%9UDWLRLQÁXHQFHGRXWFRPH S $WDQU&%9UDWLRRI
VHQVLWLYLW\ZDVREWDLQHGZLWKVSHFLÀFLW\RI$WDQU&%9UDWLRRI
VSHFLÀFLW\ZDVREWDLQHGZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\RI7KHDUHDXQGHUWKH52&
FXUYH GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ ZDV 6(
&RQFOXVLRQ'6&SHUIXVLRQ05LPDJLQJKDVKLJK GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\WR
GLIIHUHQWLDWHUHFXUUHQW+**IURPUDGLDWLRQQHFURVLV0D[LPXPVHQVLWLYLW\LVREWDLQHG
DWDQU&%9UDWLRWKUHVKROGRI
%
'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIPXOWLPRGDO05 056':,'7,DQG'6&
3:, WXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHDQGUDGLRQHFURVLV
93DQDUD3$0DWWHL'7RUWRUD66DOLFH&%ULJDQWL$5&RWURQHR
0&DXOR$7DUWDUR&KLHWL,7 YDOHSDQD#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH&RQYHQWLRQDO05RIWHQIDLOVLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQWXPRXUUHFXU
UHQFHDQGDOWHUDWLRQVLQGXFHGE\WKHUDS\ UDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\DQGFKHPRWKHUDS\
LQSULPLWLYHEUDLQWXPRXUV7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHFXWRIIVRI
SHUIXVLRQ 3:, VSHFWURVFRS\ '056 GLIIXVLRQ ':, DQGGLIIXVLRQWHQVRU '7,
ZLWKDKLJKÀHOGVFDQQHU 7 DQGWKHUHODWLYHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQGHWHUPLQLQJ
EHWZHHQWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHDQGSRVWDGMXYDQWWUHDWPHQWFHUHEUDOPRGLÀFDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHVXUJHU\DQGDGMXYDQW
UDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\IRUFHUHEUDOJOLRPDVZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG([DPVZHUH
DFTXLUHGZLWKD7)RXUUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUHDQDO\VHGDUHDRIFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHPHQW &( 7VLJQDOORZHUWKDQWKDWRIOLTXRU 7 7VLJQDOJUHDWHUWKDQ
RUHTXDOWROLTXRU 7 DQGDUHDZLWKUHGXFHGGLIIXVLRQ 5' 6HYHUDOSDUDPHWHUV
ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGIRUHDFK52,U&%9HU077&KR&U&KR1$$/LS&U/DF&U
$'&DQG)$'LIIHUHQFHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWKWWHVWDQG52,DQDO\VLVIRURSWLPDO
FXWRIIV*ROGVWDQGDUGIRUZDVHLWKHUKLVWRORJ\RUWZR\HDUIROORZXS
5HVXOWV3DUDPHWHUVZKLFK\LHOGHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHU&%9LQ
&( FXWRII!VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ DUHDXQGHUFXUYH $8&
S 7 FXWRII!VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S
DQG 7 FXWRII! VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ $8& S
&KR&U LQ 7 FXWRII! VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\ $8&
S DQG /LS&U LQ &( FXWRII VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
$8& S DQG 7 FXWRII VHQVLELOLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\
$8& S
&RQFOXVLRQ*LYHQWKHHOHYDWHGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\REVHUYHGIRUWKHLQGLFDWHG
FXWRIIVPXOWLPRGDO05 056DQG'6&3:, FDQEHDQLQVWUXPHQWDOPHWKRGIRU
WKHQRQLQYDVLYHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHDQGUDGLRQHFURVLV
%
1RQLQYDVLYHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIKLJKDQGORZJUDGHJOLRPDDSXOVHG
DUWHULDOVSLQODEHOOLQJVWXG\XVLQJEROXVDUULYDOWLPHV
-)XUWQHU96FKRHSI*.DVSULDQ0:HEHU*:LGKDOP
6:ROIVEHUJHU03UHXVVHU-$+DLQIHOOQHU'3UD\HU9LHQQD$7
MXOLDIXUWQHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH3XOVHGDUWHULDOVSLQODEHOOLQJ S$6/ LVDQRQLQYDVLYH05,SHUIXVLRQ
PHWKRGXVLQJWKHZDWHULQWKHDUWHULDOEORRGDVHQGRJHQRXVFRQWUDVWDJHQW7KH
SXUSRVH RI WKLV VWXG\ ZDV WR GHWHUPLQH WKH PRVW VXLWDEOH S$6/ LQYHUVLRQ WLPH
SRLQW 7, IRUWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQKLJKJUDGHDQGORZJUDGHJOLRPDXVLQJ
DPXOWL7,S$6/DSSURDFKZKLFKWUDFNVWKHODEHOOHGEROXVG\QDPLFDOO\RYHUWLPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\ÀYHSDWLHQWVZLWKJOLRPDVKLVWRORJLFDOO\FODVVLÀHG
DVORZJUDGH Q RUKLJKJUDGH Q DFFRUGLQJWRWKH:+2EUDLQWXPRXU
FODVVLÀFDWLRQZHUHLQFOXGHG$7HVOD05VFDQQHU 7ULR7LP6LHPHQV0HGLFDO
6ROXWLRQ(UODQJHQ*HUPDQ\ ZDVXVHGWRSHUIRUPS$6/VHTXHQFHVDWHLJKWGLIIHU
HQWLQYHUVLRQWLPHSRLQWV PVPVPVPVPVPV
PV PV 7KH EROXV DUULYDO WLPH UHÁHFWLQJ WKH PD[LPXP RI WXPRXU
SHUIXVLRQ IRU DOO À[HG LQYHUVLRQ WLPH SRLQWV ZDV FDOFXODWHG$ WKUHHZD\ PL[HG
$129$ZDVXVHGWRUHYHDOSRWHQWLDOGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHEROXVDUULYDOWLPHEHWZHHQ
KLJKJUDGHDQGORZJUDGHJOLRPDV
5HVXOWV7KHGLIIHUHQFHRIPHDVXUHGVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVEHWZHHQKLJKJUDGHDQG
ORZJUDGHJOLRPDVREWDLQHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWUHVXOWVH[FOXVLYHO\DWPV
S )RUDOORWKHUGHWHUPLQHGLQYHUVLRQWLPHSRLQWVWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHRIVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\EHWZHHQKLJKJUDGHDQGORZJUDGHJOLRPDV SYDOXHV
UDQJHGIURPWR
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUÀQGLQJVVXJJHVWWKDWXVLQJS$6/IRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWXPRXU
SHUIXVLRQWKHPRVWVXLWDEOHLQYHUVLRQWLPHSRLQWIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIKLJKJUDGH
IURPORZJUDGHJOLRPDLVPV8VHRIWKLVS$6/7,PD\IDFLOLWDWHDQRQLQYDVLYH
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIVXFKWXPRXUVLQWKHIXWXUH
%
6LPXOWDQHRXV>)@)(7053(7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKFHUHEUDOWXPRXUV
FRPSDULVRQZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO3(7&7
06RXYDW]RJORX6)XHUVW&.UXVFKNH61HNROOD6=LHJOHU&*DQWHU
(5XPPHQ\06FKZDLJHU$'U]H]JD0XQLFK'( PVRXYDW]#\DKRRGH
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH SHUIRUPDQFH EHWZHHQ 3(7&7 DQG UHFHQWO\ LQWURGXFHG
ZKROHERG\053(7FRQFHUQLQJHYDOXDWLRQRIEUDLQWXPRXUV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHOYH SDWLHQWV UHIHUUHG WR > )@)(73(7 IRU EUDLQ
WXPRXUGLDJQRVWLFVXQGHUZHQWDVLQJOHLQMHFWLRQGXDOLPDJLQJSURWRFROLQFOXGLQJ
D3(7&7VFDQ 6LHPHQV7UXHSRLQWPLQSLPLQ'DFTXLVLWLRQ DQGD
VXEVHTXHQW053(7VFDQ 6LHPHQVP05PLQSLPLQ'DFTXLVLWLRQ
DIWHULQMHFWLRQRI0%T>)@)(7,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWKÀOWHUHG
EDFNSURMHFWLRQ +DQQPP]RRP DWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
XVLQJORZGRVH&7IRUWKH3(7&7DQG'L[RQ05VHTXHQFHVIRU053(7,PDJHV
ZHUHLQWHUSUHWHGYLVXDOO\DQGE\VHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLV7KHUHVSHFWLYHOHVLRQ
DQG%J689VZHUHFRPSDUHGDVZHOODVWKHOHVLRQEDFNJURXQGUDWLRV 7%J XVLQJ
WKH:LOFR[RQWHVW
5HVXOWV9LVXDOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWXUQHGRXWVXVSLFLRQRIWXPRXUWLVVXHLQVFDQV
ZLWKERWK053(7DQG3(7&7SDWLHQWVZHUHUHDGDVQHJDWLYH2YHUDOO7%J
UDWLRVDVZHOODVOHVLRQDQG%J689PD[YDOXHVZHUHQRWGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQ3(7&7
DQG053(7+RZHYHUWKHPHDQOHVLRQDQG%J689VZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUIRU
3(7&7DVFRPSDUHGWRWKHUHVSHFWLYH053(7YDOXHV OHVLRQVYV
S %JYV S 7KHUH ZDV D VLJQLÀFDQW FRUUHODWLRQ
EHWZHHQWKHUHVSHFWLYHPD[DQGPHDQOHVLRQDQG%J689VDVZHOODVEHWZHHQ
WKHUHVSHFWLYH7%JUDWLRV
&RQFOXVLRQ,PDJLQJRIEUDLQWXPRXUVZLWK>)@)(7LVIHDVLEOHZLWKWKHLQWHJUDWHG
ZKROHERG\053(7VFDQQHUZLWKKLJKLPDJHTXDOLW\'HVSLWHWHFKQRORJLFDOGLI
IHUHQFHVWKHTXDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRI>)@)(73(7GDWDZLWK053(7UHYHDOV
FRPSDUDEOHUHVXOWVDVZLWK3(7&7LQGLFDWLQJWKDWHVWDEOLVKHGOHVLRQEDFNJURXQG
UDWLRWKUHVKROGVIRUGLVWLQJXLVKLQJPDOLJQDQWEUDLQWXPRXUWLVVXHFDQEHWUDQVIHUUHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&RQWULEXWLRQRIGLIIXVLRQDQGSHUIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRIVHOODUDQG
SDUDVHOODUWXPRXUVSUHOLPLQDU\UHSRUW
-%ODGRZVND$=LPQ\36]HZF]\N0*X]LQVNL37DEDNRZ
0.R]ED*RV]W\ãD:-DUPXQGRZLF]06DVLDGHN:URFODZ3/
PEODGRZ#ZSSO
3XUSRVH7KHPRVWFRPPRQSLWXLWDU\WXPRXUVDUHDGHQRPDVZKLFKKRZHYHUPD\
EHPLPLFNHGE\RWKHUWXPRXUVWKDWFDQVKRZYHU\VLPLODUDSSHDUDQFHLQSODLQ05,
7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHXVHIXOQHVVRIGLIIXVLRQ ':, DQGSHUIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ 3:, LQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRIVHOODUSDUDVHOODUWXPRXUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\HLJKWVHOODUSDUDVHOODUWXPRXUV DGHQRPDV
PHQLQJLRPDVLQWUDVHOODUKDHPDQJLREODVWRPDVXSUDVHOODUJOLRPDSLWXLWDU\
DEVFHVVDQGKDPDUWRPD XQGHUZHQWVWDQGDUG05,DVZHOODV':,DQG3:,XVLQJ
7HVOD05XQLW,QHDFKWXPRXUPLQU$'&DQGPD[U&%9PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUH
FDOFXODWHG7KHUHODWLYHSHDNKHLJKW U3+ DQGWKHUHODWLYHSHUFHQWDJHRIVLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\UHFRYHU\ U365 ZHUHDOVRHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQYDOXHVRIPLQU$'&PD[U&%9U3+DQGU365IRUGLIIHUHQW
WXPRXUW\SHVZHUHDVIROORZVDGHQRPDV PHQLQJLRPDV
KDHPDQJLREODVWRPD JOLRPD
DEVFHVV KDPDUWRPD
UHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQDGHQRPDVDQGDOO
RWKHUWXPRXUW\SHVLQSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVDQGDOVRLQPLQU$'&YDOXHV7KHUH
ZHUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQU3+DQGU365EHWZHHQDGHQRPDVDQGPHQLQJL
RPDVZKLOHRWKHUWXPRXUVUHYHDOHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWYDOXHVRIU3+DQGU365
FRPSDUHGWRSLWXLWDU\DGHQRPDV
&RQFOXVLRQ 3:, DQG ':, VHHP WR EH YHU\ XVHIXO LQ GLIIHUHQWLDO GLDJQRVLV RI
VHOODUSDUDVHOODUWXPRXUVZKDWPD\EHRIKLJKLPSRUWDQFHLQWKHFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
HVSHFLDOO\LQSURSHUFKRLFHRIVXUJLFDODSSURDFK
%
,VRODWHGFHUHEUDOVXVFHSWLELOLW\DUWHIDFWVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQW
PHODQRPDPHWDVWDVLVRUQRW"
&*UDPVFK6*RHULFNH)%HKUHQV$.UDVQ\/=LPPHU'6FKDGHQGRUI
0)RUVWLQJ06FKODPDQQ(VVHQ'( &DUROLQ*UDPVFK#XNHVVHQGH
%
6XEHSHQG\PDOQRGXOHVDQGJLDQWFHOOWXPRXUSUHYDOHQFHLQ
JHQHWLFDOO\VWXGLHGWXEHURXVVFOHURVLVFRPSOH[SDWLHQWV
&0LFKHOR]]L)*DOOL*'L/HR)6LOYD%DUERVD
)6DUGDQHOOL*&RUQDOED0LODQ,76DQ'RQDWR0LODQHVH,7
FDWHULQDPLFKHOR]]L#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HVWLPDWH WKH DVVRFLDWLRQ DPRQJ WKH SUHVHQFH RI VXEHSHQG\PDO
QRGXOHV 6(1 VXEHSHQG\PDO JLDQW FHOO WXPRXU 6*&7 DQG JHQH PXWDWLRQ LQ
WXEHURXVVFOHURVLVFRPSOH[ 76& SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGEUDLQ05,VWXGLHVRI76&SDWLHQWV
ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGE\WZRQHXURUDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXV7KHQXPEHU
RI6(1VZDVUHFRUGHG$Q\HQKDQFLQJ6(1FPLQGLDPHWHUDQGSODFHGQHDU
WKHIRUDPHQRI0RQURZDVFRQVLGHUHGDV6*&77ZREUDLQ05,IROORZXSH[DPV
IRUHDFKSDWLHQWZLWK6*&7ZHUHHYDOXDWHGWRDVVHVVWXPRXUJURZWKLQWHUPVRI
GLDPHWHUDQGYROXPH3DWLHQWVZHUHFDWHJRULVHGLQWRWKUHHVXEJURXSVDFFRUGLQJ
WRJHQHWLFDVVHVVPHQW76&76&DQGQRPXWDWLRQLGHQWLÀHG 10, SDWLHQWV
:LOFR[RQDQG&KLVTXDUHGWHVWVZHUHXVHG
5HVXOWV2XWRISDWLHQWVZHUH10,76&76&)LIW\VKRZHGDWOHDVW
RQH6(1$KLJKHUWUHQGRI6(1DQG6*&7DPRQJ76&SDWLHQWVZDVREVHUYHG
S DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDWLYHDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQ
6*&7DQG6(1DOORIWKH6*&7SDWLHQWVKDGDWOHDVWRQHIXUWKHU6(1ZKLOHQRQH
RIWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKRXW6(1VKRZHGDQ6*&7 S $WIROORZXSWKHPHGLDQ
6*&7 GLDPHWHU VLJQLÀFDQWO\ LQFUHDVHG IURP PP WR PP S ZKLOH
WKHPHGLDQYROXPHVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGIURPPPWRPP S
&RQFOXVLRQ76&SDWLHQWVZLWK6(1VDUHPRUHOLNHO\WRSUHVHQWZLWK6*&7DQGD
FORVHUIROORZXSLVVXJJHVWHGLQSDUWLFXODULIDIIHFWHGZLWK76&PXWDWLRQ9ROXPH
DVVHVVPHQWLVPRUHVHQVLWLYHWKDQGLDPHWHUWRHYDOXDWHWXPRXUJURZWK
6XQGD\
3XUSRVH$WLQLWLDOVWDJLQJSDWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQWPHODQRPDRIWHQVKRZLVRODWHG
FHUHEUDO VXVFHSWLELOLW\ DUWHIDFWV LQ 7 ZHLJKWHG6:, VHTXHQFHV ZLWKRXW FRU
UHVSRQGLQJOHVLRQLQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJHV&DYHUQRPDV
PLFURKDHPRUUKDJHVDQGPHODQLQFRQWDLQLQJPHWDVWDVHVZLWKRXWFRQWUDVWHQKDQFH
PHQWUHSUHVHQWSRVVLEOHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVHVIRUWKHVHÀQGLQJV3XUSRVHRIWKLV
VWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHLIWKHVHOHVLRQVDOUHDG\UHSUHVHQWPHWDVWDVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05LPDJHV 7 RISDWLHQWV ZP ZLWKPD
OLJQDQWPHODQRPDDQGQRKLVWRU\RIFHUHEUDOPHWDVWDVLVEXWVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ORVV
LQ7 6:,DWLQLWLDOVWDJLQJE\05,ZHUHUHYLHZHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\05,SURWRFRO
FRQVLVWHG RI D 7 6:, D )/$,5 VHTXHQFH QRQHQKDQFHG 7Z DQG FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG 035 3DWLHQWV ZHUH IROORZHG E\ 05, LQ PHDQ PRQWKV UDQJH
PRQWKV
5HVXOWV$OOSDWLHQWVVKRZHGLQPHDQ UDQJH K\SRLQWHQVHOHVLRQVLQ7
6:,1RQHRIWKHVHOHVLRQVFRXOGEHFRQÀUPHGDVFHUHEUDOPHWDVWDVHVE\IROORZXS
&RQFOXVLRQ ,VRODWHG FHUHEUDO VXVFHSWLELOLW\ DUWHIDFWV LQ 7 6:, VHTXHQFHV
ZLWKRXWFRUUHODWHLQFRQWUDVWZHLJKWHG7LPDJHVGRQRWVHHPWRLQGLFDWHFHUHEUDO
PHWDVWDVHV
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIKDHPRU
UKDJHEHWZHHQWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO05LPDJLQJDQG6:, 3 LQKLJKJUDGH
JOLRPDVEXWQRWLQ3&16/ 3! 7KHUHZDVDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
LQWKHKDHPRUUKDJHUDWHVRIWKHVHWZRWXPRXUVRQ6:, 3 7KHKDHPRU
UKDJLFYROXPHRIKLJKJUDGHJOLRPDVZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\KLJKHUWKDQ3&16/RQ6:,
1RYHVVHOVZHUHIRXQGLQDOOWKHOHVLRQVRI3&16/7KHQXPEHURILQWUDOHVLRQDO
YHVVHOVRIKLJKJUDGHJOLRPDVZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\KLJKHUWKDQ3&16/RQ6:,
&RQFOXVLRQ6:,LVPRUHVHQVLWLYHWKDQWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO05LPDJLQJLQGHWHFW
LQJKDHPRUUKDJHLQKLJKJUDGHJOLRPDV6:,LVKHOSIXOWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHKLJKJUDGH
JOLRPDVDQG3&16/
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIVXVFHSWLELOLW\ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJLQGLVWLQJXLVKLQJRI
KLJKJUDGHJOLRPDVIURPSULPDU\FHQWUDOQHUYRXVV\VWHPO\PSKRPDV
'&DR<'LQJ=;LQJ-/L0;LRQJ)X]KRX&1
FDRGU#\DKRRFRPFQ
3XUSRVH7RDQDO\VHWKHÀQGLQJVRIKLJKJUDGHJOLRPDVDQG3&16/RQ6:,DQG
FRQYHQWLRQDO05LPDJLQJDQGWRHYDOXDWH6:,LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQWKHVH
WZRWXPRXUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\WKHLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUG
DQGLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWZDVREWDLQHGIURPDOOSDWLHQWVSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKJUDGH
JOLRPDVSDWLHQWVZLWK3&16/ZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHFRQYHQWLRQDO05LPDJLQJDQG
6:,ZHUHFRQÀUPHGE\KLVWRSDWKRORJ\7KHQXPEHURIOHVLRQVZKLFKZHUHIRXQG
KDHPRUUKDJHZDVVHSDUDWHO\FRXQWHGRQWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO05LPDJLQJDQG6:,
WKHQKDHPRUUKDJHGHWHFWLRQUDWHZLWKLQWXPRXUVEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRVHTXHQFHV
ZDVVHSDUDWHO\FRPSDUHGKDHPRUUKDJHUDWHEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRWXPRXUVRQ6:,
ZDVDOVRVWDWLVWLFDOO\DQDO\VHG)XUWKHUPRUHWKHYROXPHRIKDHPRUUKDJHDQGWKH
QXPEHURILQWUDOHVLRQDOYHVVHOVRIWKHVHWZRWXPRXUVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\DQDO\VHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
0RQGD\0DUFK
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP$
1HXUR
66
9DVFXODUDQGSHUIXVLRQLPDJLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
+$URQHQ7XUNX),
-)UKZDOG3DOODPDU9LHQQD$7
%
7LPHUHVROYHGLPDJLQJRIFRQWUDVWNLQHWLFVGRHVQRWLPSURYH
SHUIRUPDQFHRIIROORZXS05$RIHPEROLVHGLQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPV
=6HUDÀQ36WU]HŋQLHZVNL:/DVHN:%HXWK%\GJRV]F]3/
VHUDÀQ#FPXPNSO
3XUSRVH7KHXVHRIFRQWUDVWPHGLDDQGWKHWLPHUHVROYHGLPDJLQJRIFRQWUDVW
NLQHWLFV 75,&.6 WHFKQLTXHKDVVRPHWKHRUHWLFDODGYDQWDJHVRYHUWLPHRIÁLJKW
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ 72)05$ LQWKHIROORZXSRILQWUDFUDQLDODQ
HXU\VPVDIWHUHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQW:HSURVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHGWKHGLDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFHRI75,&.6DQG72)05$ZLWKGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWHGDQJLRJUDSK\ '6$
LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIRFFOXVLRQRIHPEROLVHGDQHXU\VPV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQW\WZRFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKDQHXU\VPV
ZHUHH[DPLQHGPRQWKVDIWHUWKHHPEROLVDWLRQ7HVWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRI72)05$
DQG75,&.6ZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIWKHUHVLGXDOÁRZ7KHUHVXOWVRI
WKHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIWKHÁRZZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKZHLJKWHGNDSSD,QWUDREVHUYHU
DQGLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVGHWHUPLQHG
5HVXOWV7KHVHQVLWLYLW\RI72)05$ZDV &, DQGRI75,&.6
&, 7KHVSHFLÀFLW\RIERWKPHWKRGVZDV &,
$FFXUDF\RIWKHÁRZTXDQWLÀFDWLRQUDQJHGIURP 72)05$ WR
75,&.6 7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHPHWKRGVLQWKHDUHD
XQGHUWKH52&FXUYHUHJDUGLQJERWKWKHGHWHFWLRQDQGWKHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIWKH
ÁRZ7KHLQWUDREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVYHU\JRRGZLWKERWKWHFKQLTXHV NDSSD
7KHLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVPRGHUDWHIRU72)05$DQGYHU\
JRRGIRU75,&.6 NDSSD
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKLVVWXG\72)05$DQG75,&.6SUHVHQWHGVLPLODUGLDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFH7KHUHIRUHWKHXVHRIWLPHUHVROYHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05$LVQRW
MXVWLÀHGLQWKHIROORZXSRIHPEROLVHGDQHXU\VPV
%
)ROORZXSDIWHUHPEROLVDWLRQRIUXSWXUHGLQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPV
DSURVSHFWLYHFRPSDULVRQRIWZRGLPHQVLRQDOGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWHG
DQJLRJUDSK\WKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWHGDQJLRJUDSK\DQG
WLPHRIÁLJKWPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\
=6HUDÀQ36WU]HŋQLHZVNL:/DVHN:%HXWK%\GJRV]F]3/
VHUDÀQ#FPXPNSO
3XUSRVH7KHPRVWDSSURSULDWHPHWKRGIRUIROORZXSRILQWUDFUDQLDODQHXU\VPV
DIWHU HQGRYDVFXODU WUHDWPHQW LV VWLOO EHLQJ GLVFXVVHG7KH SXUSRVH RI WKH VWXG\
ZDVDSURVSHFWLYHFRPSDULVRQRIWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWHG
DQJLRJUDSK\ '6$ DQG WLPHRIÁLJKW PDJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH DQJLRJUDSK\ 72)
05$ DWIROORZXS
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDOQXPEHURIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKDQHX
U\VPVZHUHH[DPLQHGPRQWKVDIWHUWKHHPEROLVDWLRQ7KHLQGH[WHVWVLQFOXGHG
WZRGLPHQVLRQDO'6$ ''6$ WKUHHGLPHQVLRQDO'6$ ''6$ DQG72)05$
7KHUHIHUHQFHWHVWZDVDFRQVHQVXVEHWZHHQ''6$DQG''6$7KHHYDOXD
WLRQLQFOXGHGGHWHFWLRQRIWKHUHVLGXDOÁRZTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIWKHÁRZDQGYDOLGLW\
RIWKHGHFLVLRQRQWKHUHWUHDWPHQW,QWUDREVHUYHUDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\
ZDVGHWHUPLQHG
5HVXOWV6HQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIWKHUHVLGXDOÁRZUDQJHGIURP
''6$DQG72)05$ WR ''6$ DQGIURP 72)05$ WR
''6$ $FFXUDF\RIWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHÁRZGHJUHHUDQJHGIURP
''6$ WR ''6$&RKHQNDSSD ''6$SUHVHQWHGORZHUSHUIRUPDQFH
LQWKHGHFLVLRQRQUHHPEROLVDWLRQWKDQ''6$ 352&DQDO\VLV 7KH
LQWUDREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVYHU\JRRGZLWKDOOWHFKQLTXHV NDSSD
7KHLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVPRGHUDWHIRU72)05$DQGYHU\JRRGIRU
''6$DQG''6$ NDSSD
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHPRVWSUHFLVHPHWKRGRIDQHXU\VPIROORZXSLV''6$''6$
VKRZV D ORZHU GLDJQRVWLF YDOXH ZLWK UHJDUG WR WKH GHFLVLRQ RQ UHHPEROLVDWLRQ
&RQVLGHULQJWKHLQYDVLYHQHVVRI'6$DQGWKHPLQRUGLIIHUHQFHLQWKHGLDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFHEHWZHHQ''6$DQG72)05$WKHODWWHUPHWKRGVKRXOGEHWKH
EDVLFPRGDOLW\IRUIROORZXSDIWHUDQHXU\VPHPEROLVDWLRQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
3RVLWLRQDOYHQRXV05DQJLRJUDSK\DQRSHUDWRULQGHSHQGHQWWRROWR
HYDOXDWHFHUHEUDOYHQRXVRXWÁRZKDHPRG\QDPLFV
31LJJHPDQQ06HLIHUW$)RHUJ++6FKLOG+8UEDFK
7.ULQJV%RQQ'($VFKKHLP'(7RURQWR21&$
SDVFDOQLJJHPDQQ#XNEXQLERQQGH
3XUSRVH&KURQLFFHUHEURVSLQDOYHQRXVLQVXIÀFLHQF\ &&69, KDVEHHQSURSRVHG
DVDFDXVHIRUPXOWLSOHVFOHURVLV 06 $FFRUGLQJWRWKLVWKHRU\VWULFWXUHVRIWKH
LQWHUQDOMXJXODUYHLQV ,-9 DUHDPRQJVWWKHGHVFULEHGFDXVHVIRU&&69,/LWWOHLV
NQRZQDERXWWKHLULQÁXHQFHRQWKHKDHPRG\QDPLFVRIWKHFHUHEUDOYHQRXVEORRG
RXWÁRZ &9%2 :HHPSOR\HGSRVLWLRQDO05,WRGHVFULEHWKHLQÁXHQFHRISRVLWLRQDO
FKDQJHVRQWKH&9%2
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8VLQJWKH)21$58SULJKW05,DYHQRXVWLPHRIÁLJKW
DQJLRJUDSK\RIWKHFHUYLFDOUHJLRQZDVDFTXLUHGLQVXSLQHDQGVLWWLQJSRVLWLRQVLQ
ÀIWHHQKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV7KHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVUDWHGWKHSRVLWLRQDOÀQGLQJVDQG
LQWHULQGLYLGXDOYDULDQFHVLQWKH&9%2ZHUHDQDO\VHG
5HVXOWV$YHQRXVWLPHRIÁLJKWDQJLRJUDSK\RIWKHFHUYLFDOVSLQHZDVIHDVLEOH
ZLWKJRRGLPDJHTXDOLW\6WULFWXUHVRIRQHRUERWK,-9ZHUHIRXQGLQRIKHDOWK\
YROXQWHHUVLQVXSLQHSRVLWLRQKRZHYHUQRQHZDVYLVLEOHLQXSULJKWSRVLWLRQ7KH
,-9ZDVQRWWKHPDLQRXWÁRZURXWHLQWKHHUHFWSRVLWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ,-9VWULFWXUHVDUHDFRPPRQÀQGLQJLQKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVLQVXSLQH
SRVLWLRQ7KH\VHHPWREHRIQRUHOHYDQFHLQWKHHUHFWSRVLWLRQ7KLVTXHVWLRQVWKH
YDOLGLW\RIWKLVFULWHULRQIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRI&&69,5HÁX[LQWRWKHYHQRXVV\VWHP
ZDVQRWYLVXDOLVHGDQGLWUHPDLQVWREHVHHQZKHWKHULWFDQEHLGHQWLÀHGLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK063RVLWLRQDO05,HQDEOHVRSHUDWRULQGHSHQGHQWHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH&9%2
DQGPD\KHOSWRFODULI\WKHYDOLGLW\RIWKHFULWHULDIRU&&69,
%
7HVOD05,RIWKHLQWUDFUDQLDODUWHULDOYDVFXODWXUHQRQHQKDQFHG
YHUVXVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG035$*(LPDJLQJ
/8PXWOX17KH\VRKQ60DGHUZDOG.:UHGH3'DPPDQQ
0(/DGG6/*RHULFNH0)RUVWLQJ06FKODPDQQ
(VVHQ'( /DOH8PXWOX#XNHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH1RQHQKDQFHG7035$*(LPDJLQJLVNQRZQWRSURYLGHDKRPRJHQHRXV
K\SHULQWHQVHYHVVHOVLJQDORIWKHLQWUDFUDQLDODUWHULHV$LPRIWKLVWULDOZDVWRDVVHVV
DSRVVLEOHGLDJQRVWLFEHQHÀWRIWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWPHGLDLQDQLQWUDLQGLYLGXDO
FRPSDULVRQVHWWLQJRIQRQHQKDQFHGYHUVXVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG035$*(LPDJLQJ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV VXEMHFWV ZHUH H[DPLQHG RQ D 7 ZKROH ERG\ 05
V\VWHP 0DJQHWRP 7 6LHPHQV XWLOLVLQJ D FKDQQHO KHDG FRLO 1RYD )RU
LQWUDFUDQLDO YHVVHO GHOLQHDWLRQ DQ 035$*( VHTXHQFH ZDV REWDLQHG SUH DQG
SRVWFRQWUDVW PRODU*DGREXWURO%D\HU+HDOWKFDUH 7KHIROORZLQJDUWHULHVDQG
DUWHULDOVHJPHQWVZHUHDVVHVVHGXWLOLVLQJDÀYHSRLQWVFDOH DQWHULRUFHUHEUDO
DUWHU\ DUWHULDSHULFDOORVD LQWHUQDOFDURWLGDUWHU\ PLGGOHFHUHEUDODUWHU\
VHJPHQWV0 SRVWHULRUFRPPXQLFDWLQJDUWHU\ SRVWHULRUFHUHEUDODUWHU\
DQG EDVLODU\DUWHU\)RUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVD:LOFR[RQUDQNWHVWZDVXVHG
5HVXOWV9LVXDODQDO\VLVGHPRQVWUDWHGDKLJKTXDOLW\DVVHVVPHQWRIQRQHQKDQFHG
035$*(LPDJLQJIRUWKHFRPSOHWHLQWUDFUDQLDODUWHULDOYDVFXODWXUH PHDQ
GXH WR D KRPRJHQHRXV K\SHULQWHQVH YHVVHO VLJQDO7KH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI FRQWUDVW
PHGLD DOORZHG RQO\ IRU D PLOG LPSURYHPHQW RI WKH GHOLQHDWLRQ RI FHQWUDO YHVVHO
VHJPHQWV VXFK DV WKH FDURWLG 7 PHDQ QH PHDQ FH <HW WKH
FRQVSLFXLW\RIVPDOOHUYHVVHOVHJPHQWVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHGLQWKHFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG035$*(LPDJHV HJDQWHULRUFRPPXQLFDWLQJDUWHU\PHDQ QH
WRPHDQ FH S
&RQFOXVLRQ ([FOXVLYH QRQHQKDQFHG 7 035$*( LPDJLQJ SURYLGHV D KLJK
TXDOLW\DVVHVVPHQWRIWKHLQWUDFUDQLDODUWHULDOYDVFXODWXUHDQGPD\EHEHQHÀFLDO
LQDVVHVVLQJWKHLQWUDFUDQLDODUWHULDOYDVFXODWXUHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKFRQWUDLQGLFDWLRQV
WRWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFRQWUDVWPHGLD HJUHQDOLQVXIÀFLHQF\
%
$V\PPHWU\RIFDURWLGDUWHU\ZDOOWKLFNQHVVEHWZHHQFDURWLGDUWHULHV
/6DED66DQQLD(5D]*/HGGD&DJOLDUL,71HZ<RUN1<86
OXFDVDED#WLVFDOLLW
3XUSRVH 3UHYLRXV SXEOLFDWLRQV GHPRQVWUDWHG WKDW WKH &7 DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$
FDQHYDOXDWHWKHFDURWLGDUWHU\ZDOOWKLFNQHVV &$:7 7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVZRUN
ZDVWRFRPSDUHWKHDV\PPHWU\RI&$:7EHWZHHQFDURWLGVLQV\PSWRPDWLFDQG
DV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDO6L[W\FRQVHFXWLYHV\PSWRPDWLF PDOHVPHGLDQDJH
SDWLHQWVDQGVL[W\QRQV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVPDWFKHGIRUJHQGHUDQGDJHZHUH
DQDO\VHGXVLQJDGHWHFWRUURZ&7DQJLRJUDSK\(DFKSDWLHQWZDVDQDO\VHGE\
LQMHFWLQJPORIFRQWUDVWPDWHULDODWDPO?VHFÁRZUDWH&$:7ZDVFDOFXODWHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
IRUERWKFDURWLGVDQGIRUHDFKSDWLHQWWKHUDWLREHWZHHQWKHELJJHVW&$:7DQGWKH
FRQWUDODWHUDOZDVFDOFXODWHGWRREWDLQDQLQGH[%ODQG$OWPDQORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQ
DQG52&FXUYHDQDO\VLVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV7KH%ODQG$OWPDQSORWGHPRQVWUDWHVDYHU\JRRGDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ
PHDVXUHPHQWVZLWKDPHDQGLIIHUHQFHYDOXHRIRQO\DQG&,IURP
WR$VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQ$&$:7EHWZHHQV\PSWRPDWLFDQG
DV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV ZLWKDSYDOXHRI ZDVIRXQG7KH52&DUHDXQGHU
WKHFXUYHZDV S /RJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOLQGLFDWHGWKDW$&$:7
VWHQRVLV GHJUHH DQG IDWW\ SODTXHV ZHUH LQGHSHQGHQW YDULDEOHV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK
FHUHEURYDVFXODUV\PSWRPV SYDOXHUHVSHFWLYHO\DQG
&RQFOXVLRQ5HVXOWVRIRXUVWXG\LQGLFDWHGWKDWWKHLQGH[RIDV\PPHWU\LQ WKH
&$:7PD\EHXVHGDVIXUWKHUSDUDPHWHUWRVWUDWLI\WKHULVNRIV\PSWRPVUHODWHG
WRFDURWLGDUWHU\
%
'HWHFWLRQRIFHUHEUDOYDVRVSDVPXVLQJG\QDPLF&7DQDO\VLVRI
YROXPHSHUIXVLRQ&7PDSVDQG'&7DQJLRJUDSK\
36FKUDPP.'RODWRZVNL56FKUDPP$)URHOLFK(.ORW]0.QDXWK
*|WWLQJHQ'()RUFKKHLP'( SVFKUDPP#PHGXQLJRHWWLQJHQGH
3XUSRVH&HUHEUDOYDVRVSDVPZLWKDUDLVHGULVNIRUVHFRQGDU\LVFKHPLDLVDIUH
TXHQWFRPSOLFDWLRQDIWHUVXEDUDFKQRLGKDHPRUUKDJH 6$+ :HWHVWHGZKHWKHU
´ZKROH EUDLQµ YROXPH SHUIXVLRQ &7 93&7 GHOLYHUV UHOHYDQW LQIRUPDWLRQ DERXW
WKHORFDOLVDWLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIDUWHULDOYDVRVSDVPDQGWKHYROXPHDWULVN
RIVHFRQGDU\LQIDUFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSLFLRQRIFHUHEUDOYDVRV
SDVPGXHWR6$+XQGHUZHQW93&7RIWKHEUDLQ&7DQJLRJUDSKLFPD[LPXPLQWHQVLW\
SURMHFWLRQVZHUHJHQHUDWHGIURPWKLQVOLFHUHFRQVRIWKH93&7GDWDVHWDWSHDN
DUWHULDOWLPH,PDJHVZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIDUWHULDOYDVRVSDVPDQG
FRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO&7$RU'6$7KHGLVWULEXWLRQRILVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVZDV
DQDO\VHGRQ'SHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUPDSVRIFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ &%) FHUHEUDO
EORRGYROXPH &%9 PHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 077 DQGWLPHWRGUDLQ 77'
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWVIRFDODUHDVRIFHUHEUDOK\SRSHUIXVLRQZHUHGHWHFWHGRQ
FRORXUFRGHG93&7SDUDPHWHUPDSV7KHKLJKHVWVHQVLWLYLW\ZDVIRXQGIRU077DQG
77')RFDOUHGXFWLRQVRI&%9VWURQJO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKLQIDUFWLRQRQIROORZXS&7
SDWLHQWV KDGYDVRVSDVWLFOHVLRQVRILQWUDFUDQLDODUWHULHVRQ0,3UHFRQVWUXF
WLRQVRIWKH'&7$$OORIWKHVHVWHQRWLFOHVLRQVZHUHDOVRYLVLEOHRQFRQYHQWLRQDO
&7$RU'6$UHVXOWLQJLQVHQVLWLYLW\RIWKH'&7$UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ93&7LVDQRQLQYDVLYHPHWKRGWKDWDOORZVGHWHFWLQJFHUHEUDOYD
VRVSDVPLQSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURP6$+,WKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRGHPRQVWUDWHIRFDO
SHUIXVLRQ GHÀFLWV DV ZHOO DV YDVRVSDVWLF DUWHULDO VHJPHQWV DQG PLJKW WKHUHIRUH
LPSURYHGLDJQRVLVDQGWUHDWPHQWGHFLVLRQVLQWKRVHSDWLHQWV
%
5HODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKURPEXVGHQVLW\DQGGLIIHUHQWVWURNHVXEW\SHV
-1LHVWHQ,9DQGHU6FKDDI*%LHVVHOV/.DSSHOOH79DQ6HHWHUV
<9DQ'HU*UDDI:0DOL%9HOWKXLV$+RUVFK8WUHFKW1/$UQKHP1/
MQLHVWHQ#KRWPDLOFRP
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
7RWDOFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZIURPFKLOGKRRGWRHDUO\VHQHVFHQFHDV
DVVHVVHGZLWKSKDVHFRQWUDVWLPDJLQJ
,.RHUWH$3RPVFKDU53/DXEHQGHU'6WHIÀQJHU)+HLQHQ
05HLVHU1$OSHULQ%(UWO:DJQHU0XQLFK'(0LDPL)/86
LQJDNRHUWH#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH&HUHEUDOEORRGÁRZFKDQJHVZLWKLQFUHDVLQJDJHKRZHYHUQRQRUPD
WLYHYDOXHVLQFKLOGKRRGDQGDGROHVFHQWVDUHDYDLODEOHXQWLOSUHVHQW:HDLPHGWR
LQYHVWLJDWHDQGTXDQWLI\WKHWRWDOFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZLQSK\VLRORJLFDOGHYHORSPHQW
DQGDJHLQJE\SKDVHFRQWUDVW05LPDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$IWHULQIRUPHGFRQVHQWKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV PDOHV
IHPDOHVDJHWR\HDUV ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGRQD705,&LQHSKDVHFRQWUDVW
VHTXHQFHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGDWDQD[LDOSODQHSHUSHQGLFXODUWRWKHQHFNYHVVHOV
WR TXDQWLI\ DUWHULDO LQÁRZ WKURXJK WKH OHIW DQG ULJKW FDURWLG /&$ 5&$ DQG OHIW
DQGULJKWYHUWHEUDODUWHU\ /9$DQG59$ 7RWDOFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZZDVGHÀQHG
DVWKHVXPRIÁRZWKURXJKWKHVHIRXUFHUYLFRFUDQLDODUWHULHV'DWDZHUHDQDO\VHG
ZLWKOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOVUHO\LQJRQIUDFWLRQDOSRO\QRPLDOVRIVHFRQGGHJUHH
5HVXOWV 7RWDO FHUHEUDO EORRG ÁRZ VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GHFUHDVHG ZLWK LQFUHDVLQJ DJH
S LQDQRQOLQHDUIDVKLRQ UDQJHGPOPLQ 7KLVZDVDOVRWUXHIRU
WKHTXDQWLWDWLYHÁRZWKURXJKHDFKRIWKHLQYHVWLJDWHGDUWHULHV /&$5&$/9$DQG
59$ S *HQGHUKDGQRVLJQLÀFDQWHIIHFWRQDUWHULDOFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ
&RQFOXVLRQ7RWDOFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZLVDJHGHSHQGHQWDQGGHFUHDVHVZLWKDJH
7KLVGHFUHDVHDOUHDG\VWDUWVLQFKLOGKRRG*HQGHUGRHVQRWKDYHDVLJQLÀFDQWLPSDFW
RQFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZ7KHVHDJHUHODWHGFKDQJHVQHHGWREHWDNHQLQWRFRQVLGHUD
WLRQZKHQLQWHUSUHWLQJ05EDVHGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQVRIFHUHEUDOEORRGÁRZLQSDWLHQWV
5RRP'
&KHVW
66
7LVVXHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
5&HVDU*ROQLN6,
0:LHOSW]+HLGHOEHUJ'(
%
&7ÀQGLQJVRISQHXPRQLFW\SHDGHQRFDUFLQRPDFRPSDULVRQ
EHWZHHQLQYDVLYHPXFLQRXVDGHQRFDUFLQRPDDQGQRQPXFLQRXV
DGHQRFDUFLQRPD
61DNDPXUD6KLPDEDUD-3 VQDNDPXUD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH,QYDVLYHPXFLQRXVDGHQRFDUFLQRPD ,0$ IRUPHUO\FODVVLÀHGDVPXFL
QRXV%$&XVXDOO\SUHVHQWVFRQVROLGDWLYHRSDFLWLHVPLPLFNLQJSQHXPRQLDRQ&7
RQWKHFRQWUDU\VXFKSQHXPRQLFW\SHDGHQRFDUFLQRPDPD\RFFXULQQRQPXFLQRXV
DGHQRFDUFLQRPD 10$ IRUPHUO\FODVVLÀHGDVQRQPXFLQRXV%$&7KHVHWXPRXUV
VKRXOGEHVHSDUDWHGLQWRGLIIHUHQWFDWHJRULHVEHFDXVHWKH\KDYHFOLQLFDOSDWKRORJLF
DQGJHQHWLFGLIIHUHQFHV7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHWKH&7ÀQGLQJV
RISQHXPRQLFW\SHDGHQRFDUFLQRPDEHWZHHQ,0$DQG10$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\VWXGLHGWZHQW\SDWLHQWVZLWKSDWKR
ORJLFDOO\SURYHQSQHXPRQLFW\SHDGHQRFDUFLQRPDDWIRXULQVWLWXWLRQVIURPWR
7KH\FRQVLVWVRIIHPDOHVDQGPDOHVZLWKDJHVUDQJLQJIURPWR
\HDUV PHDQ\HDUV &7ÀQGLQJVRI,0$ Q DQG10$ Q ZHUHFRPSDUHG
EDVHGRQWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIFRQVROLGDWLRQSHULSKHUDOGLVWULEXWLRQORZHUOXQJ
SUHGRPLQDQFHPXOWLIRFDOGLVWULEXWLRQDLUEURQFKRJUDPFDYLWDWLRQRUF\VWKHWHURJH
QHLW\VXUURXQGLQJJURXQGJODVVRSDFLW\ **2 EXOJLQJÀVVXUHDQG&7DQJLRJUDP
VLJQ$FFHVVRU\RSDFLWLHV FHQWULOREXODUQRGXOHVFDYLWLHV**2 SOHXUDOHIIXVLRQ
DQGO\PSKDGHQRSDWK\ZHUHDOVRDQDO\VHG
5HVXOWV&7VKRZHGSHULSKHUDOGLVWULEXWLRQ FDYLWDWLRQRUF\VW EXOJ
LQJÀVVXUH DQG&7DQJLRJUDPVLJQ LQ,0$W\SHZKLOHWKRVHÀQGLQJV
ZHUHQRWVHHQLQ10$W\SH7KHIRUPHUWKUHHÀQGLQJVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWO\
GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQWKHP/RZHUOXQJSUHGRPLQDQFHPXOWLIRFDOGLVWULEXWLRQDLUEURQ
FKRJUDPKHWHURJHQHLW\VXUURXQGLQJ**2DQGFHQWULOREXODUQRGXOHVZHUHVHHQ
LQERWKW\SHVZLWKQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDEVHQFHRI&7ÀQGLQJVVXFKDVSHULSKHUDOGLVWULEXWLRQFDYLWD
WLRQRUF\VWDQGEXOJLQJÀVVXUHLQGLFDWHVWKHSRVVLELOLW\RISQHXPRQLFW\SH10$
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKURPEXVGHQVLW\DQGGLIIHUHQW
VWURNHVXEW\SHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHLVFKDHPLFVWURNH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HSURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHLVFKDH
PLFDQWHULRUFLUFXODWLRQVWURNHDQGDYLVLEOHRFFOXVLRQRQ&7$WKDWZDVSUHVXPHGWR
EHFDXVHGE\FDUGLRHPEROLVP Q ODUJHDUWHU\DWKHURVFOHURVLV /$$Q RU
GLVVHFWLRQ Q $OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWQRQFRQWUDVW&7 1&&7 &7SHUIXVLRQ
DQG &7DQJLRJUDSK\ RQ DGPLVVLRQ ZLWKLQ KRXUV DIWHU VWURNH RQVHW 3UHVHQFH
RUDEVHQFHRIDGHQVHYHVVHOVLJQ '96 ZDVDVVHVVHGRQ1&&7DQGWKURPEXV
GHQVLW\ZDVPHDVXUHGLQ+RXQVÀHOG8QLWV +8 RQ1&&76XEVHTXHQWO\'96V
DQGWKURPEXVGHQVLW\ZHUHUHODWHGZLWKVWURNHVXEW\SHV
5HVXOWV7KHSUHVHQFHRI'96VGLIIHUHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\DPRQJVXEW\SHV'96ZDV
IRXQGLQRISDWLHQWVZLWKFDUGLRHPEROLVPLQRISDWLHQWVZLWK/$$DQG
LQRISDWLHQWVZLWKGLVVHFWLRQ ;WHVWS 7KHPHDQ+8YDOXHZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQGHQVHYHVVHOVWKDQLQQRQGHQVHYHVVHOV FRQÀ
GHQFHLQWHUYDO &, YHUVXV &, 7KHPHDQ+8YDOXH
RIDOOYHVVHOVZLWKWKURPEXVZDV &, LQFDUGLRHPEROLVP
&, LQ/$$DQG &, LQGLVVHFWLRQ $1&29$WHVW
S :HIRXQGWKHVDPHVLJQLÀFDQWUDQNLQJRUGHULQWKHGHQVLW\RIWKURPEL
ZLWK'96V PHDQ+8YDOXHFDUGLRHPEROLVP &, /$$
&, GLVVHFWLRQ &, $1&29$WHVWS
&RQFOXVLRQ7KURPEXVGHQVLW\LVUHODWHGWRVWURNHVXEW\SHDQGSUREDEO\UHÁHFWV
GLIIHUHQW WKURPEXV FRPSRVLWLRQ 7KH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH RI WKURPEXV GHQVLW\ IRU
UHFDQDOLVDWLRQUDWHVKRXOGEHIXUWKHULQYHVWLJDWHG
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'\QDPLFSHUIXVLRQ05,LQSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPSULPDU\OXQJ
FDQFHUDQRYHODSSURDFKWRWXPRXUFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ"
05HJLHU)2+HQHV'6FKZDU]$/DTPDQL+.RRLMPDQ*$GDP
+DPEXUJ'( PUHJLHU#XNHGH
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH DFFXUDF\ RI G\QDPLF PDJQHWLF UHVRQDQFH SHUIXVLRQ
LPDJLQJ '&(05 LQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIKLVWRORJLFDOVXEW\SHVRISULPDU\OXQJ
FDQFHUDQGWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWXPRXUORFDOLVDWLRQHIIHFWVSHUIXVLRQNLQHWLFV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPSULPDU\OXQJFDQFHUG\QDPLF
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 05, ZDV SHUIRUPHG IRU VL[ PLQXWHV XVLQJ D 7Z '*5(
VHTXHQFH 757(PV)29PPLQSODQHUHVROXWLRQ[[PP
VFDQWLPHVHF DW7HVOD'HQVLW\WLPHFXUYHVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGE\SODFLQJ
DUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW 52, RQWKHHQWLUHWXPRXUDVZHOODVKLJKHQKDQFLQJDUHDV
7KHSHUIXVLRQDQGSHDNHQKDQFHPHQWZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJWKHPD[LPXPVORSH
PHWKRG5HVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGDFFRUGLQJWRKLVWRORJLFDOVXEW\SHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ
VL]HDQGDOORFDWLRQ7KHVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVLQFOXGHG:LOFR[RQWHVWDQG6SHDUPDQCV
FRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
5HVXOWV7XPRXU SHUIXVLRQ GHWHUPLQHG IRU ERWK WKH HQWLUH WXPRXU S
DQGWKHPD[LPXPHQKDQFLQJDUHD S ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQVPDOOHU
WXPRXUVWKDQLQODUJHURQHV3HULSKHUDOFDUFLQRPDVUHYHDOHGDVOLJKWO\KLJKHUSHU
IXVLRQWKDQFHQWUDOWXPRXUV S 7KHVPDOOFHOOFDUFLQRPDV 6&/& VKRZHG
DVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUSHUIXVLRQ S DQGSHDNHQKDQFHPHQW S WKDQWKH
DGHQRFDUFLQRPDV7KHFRPSDULVRQRI6&/&ZLWKRWKHUQRQVPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHUV
16&/& GLGQRWUHYHDODQ\VLJQLÀFDQWSHUIXVLRQGLIIHUHQFHV,QVL[SDWLHQWVWXPRXU
VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\VKRZHGDQLQFUHDVHSULRUWRDRUWLFVLJQDOLQFUHDVHDOOXGLQJWRGLVWLQFW
WXPRXUEORRGVXSSO\IURPSXOPRQDU\YHVVHOV
&RQFOXVLRQ'&(05GHSLFWVNLQHWLFGLIIHUHQFHVLQSHUIXVLRQEHWZHHQFRPPRQ
KLVWRORJLFDOVXEW\SHVRISULPDU\OXQJFDQFHU$GGLWLRQDOO\'&(05FDQUDLVHLQ
IRUPDWLRQDERXWRULJLQRIWXPRXUEORRGVXSSO\SHUIXVLRQDQGSHDNHQKDQFHPHQW
DQGPLJKWWKHUHIRUHEHFRQVLGHUHGIRUWKHUDS\UHVSRQVHPRQLWRULQJ
%
&RQYHQWLRQDO)'*3(7&7FRPELQHGZLWKÀUVWSDVV&7SHUIXVLRQ
WHFKQLTXHLQOXQJFDQFHUSDWLHQWVFOLQLFDOVWDJLQJDQGIXQFWLRQDO
LQIRUPDWLRQLQDVLQJOHVWXG\
&&DSUDUR',SSROLWR/*XHUUD('H3RQWL&0HVVD66LURQL0RQ]D,7
FULVWLQDFDSUDUR#KRWPDLOLW
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH DGGLWLRQDO IXQFWLRQDO LQIRUPDWLRQ DQG WKH UHODWLRQVKLS
EHWZHHQ SHUIXVLRQ PHDVXUHPHQWV DQG JOXFRVH PHWDEROLVP REWDLQHG LQFOXGLQJ
&7SHUIXVLRQ VWXG\ &7S LQWR ZKROH ERG\ FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 3(7&7 SURWRFRO
IRUOXQJFDQFHUVWDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZLWKELRSV\SURYHQOXQJFDQFHU
ZKRZHUHUHIHUUHGIRUFH3(7&7VWDJLQJZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGLQRXUVWXG\
/RZGRVHXQHQKDQFHG3(7&7ZDVDFTXLUHGÀUVW7KHSRVLWLRQRI&7SVWXG\ZDV
GHÀQHGRQ3(7&7DQG&7SZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKIROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUV.Y
P$VVFDQLYLQMHFWLRQRIPOFRQWUDVWDJHQWPOVHF7KHQDQRWKHUEROXV
RIFRQWUDVWPHGLD POVHFPOVHFGHOD\ ZDVDSSOLHGWRDVVXUHWKHIXOOGLDJ
QRVWLFFH&7IRUFOLQLFDOVWDJLQJ&7SGDWDZHUHXVHGWRFDOFXODWHDUDQJHRIWXPRXU
YDVFXODULW\SDUDPHWHUV %)%9DQG077 DQGWXPRXU)'*XSWDNH 689PD[ ZDV
XVHGDVDPHWDEROLFLQGLFDWRU4XDQWLWDWLYHDQGIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUVZHUHFRP
SDUHGDQGVWDWLVWLFDOO\DQDO\VHGLQUHODWLRQWRORFDWLRQKLVWRORJ\DQGWXPRXUVL]H
5HVXOWV7KHSHUIXVLRQLPDJHVZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJDFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOHVRIW
ZDUH 3HUIXVLRQ$GYDQWDJH*( ZKLFKJHQHUDWHGDTXDQWLWDWLYHPDSRIDUWHULDO
SHUIXVLRQ6LJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZLWKORZHUSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVZHUHQRWHGLQ
WXPRXUV!PPWKDQLQWXPRXUVPP S %9YVPOJ
%)YVPOPLQJ077YVVHFUHVSHFWLYHO\,QWHUHVWLQJO\KLJK
HVWFRUUHODWLRQV OLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQ ZHUHGHWHFWHGEHWZHHQ%9DQG689PD[IRU
WXPRXUVZLWKGLDPHWHU!FP1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHQRWHGDFFRUGLQJWR
ORFDWLRQDQGSDWKRORJLFDOWXPRXUW\SH7KHVHUHVXOWVPD\LQGLFDWHWKDWODUJHWXPRXUV
H[KLELWVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUSHUIXVLRQDQGKLJKHUPHWDEROLVPLQUHODWLRQWRWKHLUDJ
JUHVVLYHQHVVVKRZLQJWKDWQRWRQO\KLVWRORJLFDOW\SHEXWDOVRVL]HDQGSUHVHQFH
RIQHFURVLVFRXOGGHWHUPLQHWKHHQKDQFHPHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIOXQJFDUFLQRPDV
&RQFOXVLRQ&7SFRPELQHGZLWK3(7&7LVIHDVLEOHWHFKQLTXHWKDWFDQSURYLGH
DGGLWLRQDOIXQFWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWYDVFXODULW\DQGWXPRXUDJJUHVVLYHQHVVWKXV
KHOSLQJLQDVVHVVLQJWKHSURJQRVLVDQGSURSHUWUHDWPHQWFKRLFH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
/XQJFDQFHUSHUIXVLRQFDQZHPHDVXUHSXOPRQDU\DQGEURQFKLDO
FLUFXODWLRQVLPXOWDQHRXVO\"
;<XDQ*$R-=KDQJ%HLMLQJ&16KDQJKDL&1
\XDQ[LDRGRQJ]M#FRP
3XUSRVH7RUHSRUWDQHZ&7SHUIXVLRQWHFKQLTXHDQGLWVSULPDU\ÀQGLQJVLQDV
VHVVLQJGRXEOHEORRGVXSSO\LQDGYDQFHGEURQFKLDOFDUFLQRPDV $%&V
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%DVHGRQGHWHFWRUURZ&7DGXDOLQSXWOXQJFDQFHU
SHUIXVLRQPRGHO ',/&S ZDVHVWDEOLVKHG3XOPRQDU\WUXQNDQGGHVFHQGLQJDRUWD
UHSUHVHQWLQJEURQFKLDODUWHU\ ZHUHDSSRLQWHGLQSXWDUWHULHVIRUSXOPRQDU\DQG
EURQFKLDOFLUFXODWLRQUHVSHFWLYHO\SHDNWLPHSRLQWRIOHIWDWULXPVHUYHGDVERXQGDU\
EHWZHHQWKHWZR7KHQSXOPRQDU\ÁRZ 3) EURQFKLDOÁRZ %) DQGSHUIXVLRQ
LQGH[ 3, 3) 3)%) ZDVÀJXUHGRXWDFFRUGLQJWRPD[LPXPVORSPHWKRG$IWHU
ZULWWHQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWVZHUHDFTXLUHGFRQVHFXWLYHVXEMHFWVZLWKDGYDQFHG
EURQFKLDOFDUFLQRPDVXQGHUZHQWWKH',/&SWHVW+DHPRG\QDPLFVRI$%&VZDV
FRPSDUHGZLWKORFDOLVDWLRQ SHULSKHUDORUFHQWUDO DQGKLVWRORJ\
5HVXOWV+DHPRG\QDPLFVRIWKH$%&VZHUHDVIROORZV3)PO
PLQPO%)POPLQPO3,%RWKFHQWUDO Q
DQGSHULSKHUDO Q WXPRXUVKDYHDSUHGRPLQDQWV\VWHPLFFLUFXODWLRQ 3,
UHVSHFWLYHO\ ERWK VWDWLVWLFDOO\ OHVV WKDQ WKH ODWWHU LV ELJJHU WKDQ WKH
IRUPHUS $OONLQGVRIKLVWRORJ\RI$%&VVKRZHG3,VOHVVWKDQZLWKRXW
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQHDFKRWKHU
&RQFOXVLRQ$QHZ&7SHUIXVLRQWHFKQLTXHZDVHVWDEOLVKHGIRUDVVHVVLQJGRX
EOHEORRGVXSSO\LQOXQJFDQFHU2XUSULPDU\ÀQGLQJVVXJJHVWWKDW DGYDQFHG
EURQFKLDOFDUFLQRPDLVIHGVLPXOWDQHRXVO\E\SXOPRQDU\DQGV\VWHPLFFLUFXODWLRQ
WKHODWWHULVGRPLQDQWLQGHSHQGHQWRIORFDOLVDWLRQDQGKLVWRORJ\IXUWKHUPRUH
WKHSURSRUWLRQRISXOPRQDU\FLUFXODWLRQZLWKSHULSKHUDOWXPRXUVLVKLJKHUWKDQWKDW
ZLWKFHQWUDOWXPRXUV
%
&7ÀQGLQJVSUHGLFWLQJ(*)5JHQHPXWDWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKQRQ
VPDOOFHOOOXQJFDQFHU
035HYHO&%RUGRQQH+%ORQV$/XSR$&D]HV*&KDWHOOLHU3DULV)5
PDULHSLHUUHUHYHO#HJSDSKSIU
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ &7 ÀQGLQJV LQ QRQVPDOO FHOO
OXQJFDQFHU 16&/& SDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWHSLGHUPDOJURZWKIDFWRUUHFHSWRU
(*)5 JHQHPXWDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QLWLDO&7ÀQGLQJVLQ16&/&SDWLHQWVZLWKDQG
ZLWKRXW(*)5JHQHPXWDWLRQZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWV
LQFRQVHQVXV7KHSDWLHQWJURXSPDLQO\LQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWK77)DGHQRFDUFL
QRPDV 7KHSUHVHQFHRIJURXQGJODVVRSDFLW\ **2 RIWXPRXU
GHQVLW\KHWHURJHQHLW\RIO\PSKQRGHHQODUJHPHQWZDVDQDO\VHGWRJHWKHUZLWKWKH
SUHVHQFHRIPXOWLSOHQRGXOHV ! DVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHPDLQWXPRXU7KHPD[LPXP
GLDPHWHURIWKHWXPRXUZDVDOVRPHDVXUHG
5HVXOWV1RVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ(*)5JHQHPXWDWLRQDQG
**2 LQWKHPXWDWLRQJURXSYV S WXPRXUGHQVLW\KHWHURJH
QHLW\ YV S RUO\PSKQRGHHQODUJHPHQW YV
S 7KH PD[LPXP GLDPHWHU RI WKH WXPRXU ZDV QRW VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHQW LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKDQGZLWKRXW(*)5JHQHPXWDWLRQ YVPP S 7KHSUHV
HQFHRIPXOWLSOHVQRGXOHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHPDLQWXPRXUZDVPRUHIUHTXHQWLQ
WKHPXWDWLRQJURXS YV S 0HQSURSRUWLRQZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHULQWKH(*)5JHQHPXWDWLRQJURXS YV S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQFHRIPXOWLSOHQRGXOHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKHPDLQWXPRXU
LVWKHRQO\&7ÀQGLQJVXJJHVWLQJ(*)5PXWDWLRQDWLQLWLDOSUHVHQWDWLRQRISDWLHQWV
ZLWK16&/&
%
5DGLDWLRQGRVHWRWKHUDGLRORJLVWGXULQJFRQWLQXRXV&7ÁXRURVFRS\
JXLGHGOXQJELRSV\XVLQJGLIIHUHQW+DQG&$5(RSWLRQVKRZVDIHLVLW"
:)0'H:HYHU)=DQFD$-DFREV1%HUJDQV5%RJDHUWV-&RROHQ
-9HUVFKDNHOHQ+%RVPDQV/HXYHQ%( ZDOWHUGHZHYHU#X]OHXYHQEH
3XUSRVH&7)OXRURVFRS\JXLGHGOXQJELRSV\ &7)/% LQYROYHVGLUHFWRSHUDWRU
LUUDGLDWLRQ2FFXSDWLRQDOOLPLWV VNLQH\HOHQVP6Y\HDU ZHUHUHDFKHG
DWRXUGHSDUWPHQW6WXG\SXUSRVHZDVWRDVVHVVRFFXSDWLRQDOERG\KDQGDQGH\H
GRVHVGXULQJ&7)/%IRUURXWLQHDQGORZGRVHSURWRFROXVLQJGLIIHUHQW+DQG&$5(
+& SRVLWLRQV +DQG&$5( LQWHUUXSWV [UD\ DW VHOHFWDEOH SRVLWLRQV RU
RҋFORFN
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'DWDIURP&7)/%ELRSV\SURFHGXUHVZHUHSURVSHF
WLYHO\FROOHFWHG7ZHQW\ZHUHSHUIRUPHGXVLQJWKHURXWLQHSURWRFRO N9P$V
PPVOLFH ZLWK+& SDWLHQWV +& SDWLHQWV DQG+& SDWLHQWV $
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ORZGRVHSURWRFRO N9P$PPVOLFH ZDVXVHGZLWK+&RҋFORFNIRUODVW
SDWLHQWV2QHUDGLRORJLVWDWRҋFORFNSRVLWLRQRIWKH&7WDEOHZHDULQJDSURQ
ÀQJHUGRVLPHWHUFROODUDQGJRJJOHSHUIRUPHGDOOLQWHUYHQWLRQV%RG\KDQGDQG
H\HOHQV XQVKLHOGHG RSHUDWRUGRVHVZHUHPRQLWRUHGWRWDOÁXRURVFRSLFWLPH 7)7
DQGWRWDOKDQGWLPHHQWHULQJSULPDU\EHDP 7+7 ZHUHUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV0HGLDQ7)7ZDVV UDQJHV PHGLDQ7+7ZDVV UDQJH
V $YHUDJHRSHUDWRUGRVHVSHUSURFHGXUHDWGLIIHUHQW+&IRUURXWLQHSURWRFRO
ZHUHFRPSDUDEOH UDQJHP6YDYHUDJHP6Y ORZGRVHSURWRFRO
VKRZHGGRVHUHGXFWLRQ P6Y 0D[LPXPDYHUDJHGRVHWRKDQGVDQG
H\HV ZHUH P6Y DQG P6Y P6Y DQG P6Y P6Y DQG
P6YIRU+&DQGRҋFORFN7KH\ZHUHP6YDQGP6YIRUWKH
N9SURWRFRO
&RQFOXVLRQ &RPSOLDQFH ZLWK RFFXSDWLRQDO OLPLWV FDQ EH UHDFKHG E\ PDWFKLQJ
UDGLRORJLVWDQG+&SRVLWLRQDQGXVLQJORZGRVHSURWRFROV
%
3HUFXWDQHRXVWUDQVWKRUDFLFQHHGOHELRSV\RISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHV
ZLWK;SHU&7DQG;SHUJXLGHDQHZWHFKQLFDODSSURDFK
'/HQL)9DFLUFD',SSROLWR5&RUVR0RQ]D,7 GDOHQL#WLQLW
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHIHDVLELOLW\DQGHIÀFDF\RISHUFXWDQHRVWUDQVWKRUDFLFQHHGOH
ELRSV\RISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVZLWK;SHU&7DQG;SHU*XLGH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URPWRSDWLHQWVZHUHVFKHGXOHG
IRUSHUFXWDQHRXVWUDQVWKRUDFLFQHHGOHELRSV\RISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVXVLQJ;SHU
&7DQG;SHU*XLGHQHZVRIWZDUHDSSOLFDWLRQVSURYLGHGE\3KLOLSV$OOXUD)'
$OOSURFHGXUHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKORFDODQDHVWKHVLDLQWKHDQJLRJUDSKLFDOVXLWH
%HIRUHSXQFWXUHSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW;SHU&7VFDQWKDWDOORZVWRREWDLQLPDJHVRI
VPDOOERG\YROXPHVRIFRQLFDOVKDSHGXHWRFRQHEHDPDFTXLVLWLRQ2QWKHEDVLV
RI'UHFRQVWUXFWLRQXVLQJ;SHU*XLGHZHSODQQHGWKHSDWKRIWKHQHHGOHWRWKH
WDUJHWOHVLRQVDPSOHVZHUHREWDLQHGLQHDFKFDVHZLWKDFRD[LDOWHFKQLTXH
$IWHU WKH SURFHGXUH SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW DJDLQ D ;SHU&7 VFDQ WR DVVHVV DQ\
FRPSOLFDWLRQV6DPSOHVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVDGHTXDWH LGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIKLVWRW\SH
JUDGHDQGSURJQRVWLFDOIDFWRUV LQWHUPHGLDWH GLDJQRVLVRIEHQLJQLW\PDOLJQDQF\
KLVWRW\SH DQGLQDGHTXDWH&RPSOLFDWLRQVDQGPHDQWLPHRIH[HFXWLRQZHUH
DOVRUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWV,QSDWLHQWVVDPSOHVZHUHDGHTXDWHLQSDWLHQWVZHUHLQWHUPHGLDWH
DQGLQLQDGHTXDWH3QHXPRWKRUD[ZDVUHFRUGHGLQRISDWLHQWVEXWH[WHUQDO
GUDLQDJHZDVQHYHUUHTXLUHG3HULQRGXODUKDHPRUUKDJLFVXIIXVLRQZDVREVHUYHG
LQSDWLHQWVDQGLQRQO\RQHFDVHVHOIOLPLWLQJKHPRSW\VLVZDVUHJLVWHUHG0HDQ
WLPHRIH[HFXWLRQZDVPLQXWHV
&RQFOXVLRQ3HUFXWDQHRXVWUDQVWKRUDFLFQHHGOHELRSV\RISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVZLWK
;SHU&WDQG;SHUJXLGHLVDVDIHDQGDFFXUDWHSURFHGXUHDQGFDQEHSHUIRUPHG
LQHYHU\SDWLHQWZLWKDKLJKSHUFHQWDJHRIDGHTXDWHVDPSOHVDQGZLWKDORZULVN
RIVHYHUHFRPSOLFDWLRQV
%
5HVSRQVHPRQLWRULQJIRUOXQJFDQFHUWKHUDS\XVLQJG\QDPLF
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7VFDQDFRUUHODWLRQZLWK3(7&7
0<RR6+ZDQJ7.LP6.LP6HRXO.5
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
&OLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQRIWLVVXHSHUPHDELOLW\IDFWRUIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ
RIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWSXOPRQDU\PDVVRQG\QDPLFFRQWUDVW
PDWHULDOHQKDQFHG '&( 05,
6+%DLN*<-LQ<0+DQ-HRQMX.5 ORYHJXPDWP#KDQPDLOQHW
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWLVVXHSHUPHDELOLW\IDFWRURQG\QDPLFFRQWUDVW
PDWHULDOHQKDQFHG '&( 05,FDQKHOSWRGLVFULPLQDWHEHWZHHQPDOLJQDQWDQG
EHQLJQSXOPRQDU\PDVV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-XQHWR0D\SDWLHQWV ZRPHQ
PHQPHGLDQDJH\HDUVDJHUDQJH\HDUV ZLWKVXVSHFWHGOXQJFDQFHU
DJUHHGWRXQGHUJR'&(05LPDJLQJDW7SDWLHQWVZHUHOXQJFDQFHUDQG
SDWLHQWVZHUHEHQLJQOXQJOHVLRQV$WZRFRPSDUWPHQWNLQHWLFPRGHOZDVXVHGWR
FDOFXODWHWKHSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVLQFOXGLQJYROXPHWUDQVIHUFRQVWDQW .WUDQVLQ
PLQ H[WUDYDVFXODUH[WUDFHOOXODUVSDFHYROXPHIUDFWLRQ 9H HIÁX[UDWHFRQVWDQW
.HS LQLWLDODUHDXQGHUFXUYH L$8& $QXQSDLUHG7WHVWZDVXVHGWRFDOFXODWHWKH
VWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHRITXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVEHWZHHQPDOLJQDQF\
DQG EHQLJQ OXQJ OHVLRQV 5HFHLYHU RSHUDWLQJ FKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLV ZDV
DOVRSHUIRUPHGIRUHYDOXDWLRQRIVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RISHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUV
5HVXOWV0DOLJQDQWOHVLRQVKDGKLJKHU.WUDQVYDOXHWKDQEHQLJQOHVLRQV YV
S %XWWKHUHZHUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQRWKHUSDUDPHWHUV PHDQ
9HYVPHDQ.HSYVPHDQL$8&YVUHVSHFWLYHO\
$.WUDQVYDOXHRIPRUHWKDQ PLQ ZDVRSWLPDOIRUSUHGLFWLQJPDOLJQDQF\
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ.WUDQVYDOXHRISHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVRQ'&(05,FDQKHOSWRGLV
FULPLQDWHEHWZHHQPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOXQJOHVLRQV
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
2QFRORJ\
0RGHUDWRUV
)0HOFKLRUUH0LODQ,7
75DQG9LHQQD$7
%
6HJPHQWDOUDGLRHPEROL]DWLRQXVLQJ<WWULXPDQGLWVHIIHFWRQ
KHSDWLFYROXPHFKDQJHV
-07KH\VRKQ60XHOOHU-)6FKODDN66LSLODH$%RFNLVFK
7&/DXHQVWHLQ(VVHQ'( MHQVWKH\VRKQ#XQLGXLVEXUJHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH<WWULXPLVDEHWDHPLWWHUXVHGIRUUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQDVDQHPHUJLQJ
WKHUDS\RSWLRQIRUXQUHVHFWDEOHOLYHUPDOLJQDQFLHV$IWHUUDGLDWLRQWKHUDS\RIRQH
OLYHUOREHWKHRWKHUOREHLVH[SHFWHGWRFRPSHQVDWHWKHWKHUDS\LQGXFHGORVVRI
OLYHUIXQFWLRQ$LPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHDPRXQWRIYROXPHJDLQLQGXFHG
LQWKHXQWUHDWHGOLYHUOREH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\SDWLHQWV PIPHDQDJH\ VXIIHULQJIURP
KHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDZHUHVWXGLHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ
RIWKHULJKWOLYHUOREHZLWK<WWULXP$PHDQGRVHRI*\ZDVGHOLYHUHGWRWKH
WDUJHW KHSDWLF YROXPH UDQJH *\ $EVROXWH YROXPHV RI WKH ULJKW 5/9
DQGOHIWOLYHUOREH //9 ZHUHDVVHVVHGXVLQJ&7EHIRUHDQGPRQWKVDIWHU
UDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQRIWKHULJKWOLYHUOREH)XUWKHUPRUHWKHUHODWLYHYROXPHRIWKH
OHIWOLYHUOREH //9>5/9//9@ ZDVFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV%DVHOLQHYROXPHVRIWKHULJKWDQGOHIWOLYHUOREHDPRXQWHGWRPO 5/9
DQGPO //9 RQDYHUDJH7KHDEVROXWH//9VKRZHGDQLQFUHDVHRQDYHUDJHO\
DIWHUPRQWKV+RZHYHUWKHDEVROXWH5/9GHFUHDVHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\GXULQJ
IROORZXS PHDQFKDQJH 7KHDYHUDJHUHODWLYH//9ZDVEHIRUHDQG
VL[PRQWKVDIWHUUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&RQVWUDLQWVRIOLYHUIXQFWLRQDIWHUUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQRIRQHOLYHUOREH
FDQEHSDUWLDOO\FRPSHQVDWHVWKURXJKK\SHUWURSK\RIWKHFRQWUDODWHUDOOREH7KLV
REVHUYDWLRQPD\EHWKHEDVLVWRLQWURGXFHWKHFRQFHSWRIDUDGLDWLRQOREHFWRP\
XVLQJUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ&RQWUDODWHUDOK\SHUWURSK\RIWKHOLYHUIROORZLQJVLQJOHOREH
UDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQUHGXFHVWKHGDQJHURIOLYHUIDLOXUH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH XVHIXOQHVV RI G\QDPLF FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ '&(&7 IRUSUHGLFWLRQRIWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHDQGWRFRPSDUHWKH
UHVXOWVRI'&(&7ZLWKWKRVHRILQWHJUDWHGSRVLWURQHPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ 3(7&7 LQSDWLHQWVZLWKOXQJFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\IRXUSDWLHQWVZKRKDGFKHPRWKHUDS\RUUDGLR
WKHUDS\IRUOXQJFDQFHU ZLWK16&/&DQGZLWK6&/& ZHUHHQUROOHGLQWRWKLV
VWXG\$WRWDORIWXPRXUV PHDQVL]HFPUDQJHFP ZHUHUHYHDOHG
RQIROORZXS'&(&7REWDLQHGDWDQGVHFRQGVIROORZLQJDGPLQLVWUD
WLRQRIFRQWUDVWPHGLDDQG3(7&7OHVVWKDQZHHNVDSDUW:HPHDVXUHGUHODWLYH
HQKDQFHPHQWUDWLR 5(5 DWHDFKWLPHSRLQWRQ'&(&7DQGPD[LPXPVWDQGDUGLVHG
XSWDNHYDOXH 689PD[ RQ3(7&7$FFRUGLQJWRWKHUHVSRQVHHYDOXDWLRQFULWHULD
LQVROLGWXPRXU 5(&,67 WXPRXUVZHUHFODVVLÀHGLQWRJURXSVDVSURJUHVVLYH
GLVHDVH 3'Q VWDEOHGLVHDVH 6'Q DQGSDUWLDOUHVSRQVH 35Q
5HVXOWV5(5DWVHFRQGVRI3' PHDQ ZDVKLJKHU 3
WKDQWKRVHRI6' PHDQ DQG35 PHDQ 689
PD[UHYHDOHGVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZLWK5(5DWVHFRQGV U 3
UHVSHFWLYHO\ RIWXPRXUVFODVVLÀHGDV35RU6'VKRZHG689PD[
RIRUOHVVDQG5(5DWVHFRQGVRIRUOHVV
&RQFOXVLRQ'&(&7FDQSURYLGHWKHLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWUHDWHGWXPRXUIXQFWLRQDO
FRPSRVLWLRQ DV ZHOO DV DQDWRPLF FKDQJH LQ WKH SRVWWUHDWPHQW HYDOXDWLRQ IRU
SDWLHQWVZLWKOXQJFDQFHU
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
/RQJWHUPVXUYLYDOGDWDRISDWLHQWVZLWKOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVRI
FRORUHFWDOFDQFHUDIWHU05JXLGHGODVHULQGXFHGWKHUPRWKHUDS\ /,77
7-9RJO$'RPPHUPXWK.(LFKOHU6=DQJRV0*0DFN
)UDQNIXUW'( WYRJO#HPXQLIUDQNIXUWGH
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ ORQJWHUP VXUYLYDO RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK
FRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVWUHDWHGZLWK05JXLGHGODVHULQGXFHGWKHUPRWKHUDS\
/,77 GHSHQGLQJRQGLIIHUHQWIDFWRUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVIURPFRORUHFWDOFDUFL
QRPDWUHDWHGZLWK05JXLGHG/,77EHWZHHQDQGZHUHLQFOXGHG)RU
VXUYLYDODQDO\VLVWXPRXUORFDOLVDWLRQ710FODVVLÀFDWLRQQXPEHURIPHWDVWDVHV
GLDPHWHU DQG YROXPH RI PHWDVWDVHV DQG QHFURVLV OREXODU VSUHDG QXPEHU RI
WUHDWPHQW VHVVLRQV SHUIRUPDQFH RI DGMXYDQW FKHPRWKHUDS\ DQG WUDQVDUWHULDO
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ ZHUH FRQVLGHUHG 7KH .DSODQ0HLHU PHWKRG ZDV XVHG WR
FRQGXFWWKLVVXUYLYDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV /RJUDQN WHVW VKRZHG VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ VXU
YLYDOFXUYHVPXOWLYDULDWH&R[UHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLV S VKRZHGSURJQRVWLF
IDFWRUV UHJDUGLQJ RYHUDOO VXUYLYDO OLNH QXPEHU RI PHWDVWDVHV SUH LQWHUYHQWLRQ
DGMXYDQWFKHPRWKHUDS\GLDPHWHURIPHWDVWDVHVUDWLRRIYROXPHVRIQHFURVLVDQG
PHWDVWDVHVDQGDIIHFWHGO\PSKQRGHV0HGLDQRYHUDOOVXUYLYDOUDWHDWWKHWLPH
RIÀUVW/,77ZDVPRQWKV\HDUVXUYLYDO\HDUVXUYLYDO\HDU
VXUYLYDO\HDUVXUYLYDO\HDUVXUYLYDO1XPEHUVRIPHWDV
WDVHVSUHLQWHUYHQWLRQPHWDVWDVHVZLWKDPHGLDQVXUYLYDOUDWHRIPRQWKV
PHWDVWDVHVPRQWKVPHWDVWDVHVPRQWKV0HGLDQVXUYLYDOUDWHIRU
PHWDVWDVHVPPLQGLDPHWHUPRQWKVPPPRQWKVPP
PRQWKVDQG!PPPRQWKV$IIHFWHGO\PSKQRGHVPHGLDQVXUYLYDOUDWH
IRUSDWLHQWVZLWK1FODVVLÀFDWLRQPRQWKV1FODVVLÀFDWLRQPRQWKV11
1FODVVLÀFDWLRQPRQWKV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHPXOWLYDULDWH&R[UHJUHVVLRQPRGHOSURYLGHGWKHPLQLPDOQXPEHU
RI VLJQLÀFDQW YDULDEOHV ZLWK WKH PD[LPDO SURJQRVWLF YDOXH FRQFHUQLQJ RYHUDOO
VXUYLYDOIRU05JXLGHG/,77LHGLDPHWHUDQGQXPEHURIPHWDVWDVHVDQGSULPDU\
FODVVLÀFDWLRQRIO\PSKQRGHV
%
05JXLGHGUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQXVLQJDZLGHERUH7V\VWHP
FOLQLFDOUHVXOWVRIWUHDWHGOLYHUWXPRXUV
+5HPSS5+RIIPDQQ/:DLEHO33HUHLUD&'&ODXVVHQ6&ODVHQ
7ELQJHQ'(+HLOEURQQ'(
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRI05JXLGHGUDGLRIUHTXHQF\ 5) DEODWLRQ
RIOLYHUPDOLJQDQFLHVXVLQJDZLGHERUH705V\VWHP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QSDWLHQWV IHPDOHVPDOHV DQXPEHURI
OLYHUOHVLRQVZHUHWUHDWHGLQVHVVLRQVE\SHUFXWDQHRXV5)DEODWLRQ3DWLHQW
PHDQDJHZDV UDQJH OHVLRQVZHUHSULPDU\OLYHUWXPRXUVOHVLRQV
ZHUHOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVLQFOXGLQJFRORUHFWDOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV2WKHUSULPDU\
WXPRXUVZHUHPHODQRPDEUHDVWFDQFHUDQGQHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUV0HDQOHVLRQ
GLDPHWHUZDVPP UDQJHPP 05FRPSDWLEOHELRUPXOWLSRODULQWHUQDOO\
FRROHG5)SUREHVZHUHXVHG3ODQQLQJWDUJHWLQJDQGSRVWLQWHUYHQWLRQDOFRQWURO
LPDJLQJZHUHFDUULHGRXWLQDZLGHERUH705VFDQQHU ERUHFP 7HFKQL
FDOVXFFHVVZDVDVVHVVHGE\DFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05OLYHUH[DPLQDWLRQGLUHFWO\
VXEVHTXHQWWRWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQ7HFKQLTXHHIIHFWLYHQHVVZDVDVVHVVHGE\G\QDPLF
05OLYHUVWXGLHVPHDQIROORZXSSHULRGZDVPRQWKV UDQJHPRQWKV
5HVXOWV &RPSOHWH DEODWLRQ ZDV DFKLHYHG LQ OHVLRQV ,Q
OHVLRQV ORFDOWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHRFFXUUHGPRQWKVDIWHUWKHUDS\
OHVLRQVFRXOGEHWUHDWHGLQDVHFRQGVHVVLRQZLWKFRPSOHWHDEODWLRQRWKHUVZHUH
UHIHUUHGWRVXUJHU\2YHUDOO5)WHFKQLTXHHIIHFWLYHQHVVUDWHZDV
RYHUDOO WKHUDS\VXFFHVV LQFOXGLQJ VXUJHU\ 6XEVHTXHQW WR
LQWHUYHQWLRQVWZRPDMRUFRPSOLFDWLRQV EOHHGLQJDQGLQIHFWHGELOLRPD DQG
PLQRU FRPSOLFDWLRQV RFFXUUHG ,Q SDWLHQWV QHZ LQWUD RU
H[WUDKHSDWLFPDQLIHVWDWLRQVRIWKHGLVHDVHRFFXUUHGGXULQJWKHIROORZXSSHULRG
&RQFOXVLRQ:LGHERUH05JXLGHG5)DEODWLRQLVDVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYHWUHDWPHQW
RSWLRQIRUOLYHUOHVLRQV
%
1HZFRPELQDWLRQRIPLWRP\FLQDQGFLVSODWLQIRUWUDQVDUWHULDO
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( RIXQUHVHFWDEOHKHSDWRFHOOXODU
FDUFLQRPDGLIIHUHQWDHWLRORJLHVDQGORFDOUHVSRQVHUDWH
7-9RJO.$XHUEDFK.2FKV6=DQJRV7/HKQHUW1111DJXLE
)UDQNIXUW'( WYRJO#HPXQLIUDQNIXUWGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWRIFRQYHQWLRQDOWUDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ
7$&( RQORFDOUHVSRQVHUDWHVRIKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& SDWLHQWVZLWK
GLIIHUHQWDHWLRORJLHVRIOLYHUFLUUKRVLVXVLQJDQHZFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\SDWLHQWV PDOH
IHPDOH ZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ+&&ZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKUHSHWL
WLYH7$&( PLWRP\FLQFLVSODWLQOLSLRGRO IURP0DUFKWR0DUFK8QGHUO\LQJ
OLYHUSDWKRORJ\&KLOG3XJKVFRUHWXPRXUYROXPHQXPEHURIWXPRXUVDQGORFDO
UHVSRQVHZHUHLQFOXGHG,QLWLDODQGHQGWKHUDS\ORFDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVHZDVHYDOX
DWHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKH5(&,67FULWHULD05,DQG&7YROXPHWULFPHDVXUHPHQWV
5HVXOWV/RFDOWXPRXUFRQWUROVKRZHGFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVH &5 LQRISD
WLHQWV Q SDUWLDOUHVSRQVH 35 LQ Q VWDEOHGLVHDVH 6' LQ
Q SURJUHVVLYHGLVHDVH 3' LQ Q /RFDOUHVSRQVHUDWHVRISDWLHQWV
ZLWKXQGHUO\LQJKHSDWLWLV& +&9 Q ZHUH&5LQ Q 35LQ
Q 6'LQ Q 3'LQ Q DQGRISDWLHQWVZLWKXQGHUO\LQJ
KHSDWLWLV% +%9 Q 35LQ Q 6'LQ Q 3'LQ
Q ,QSDWLHQWVZLWKERWK+&9DQG+%9 Q ORFDOUHVSRQVHVKRZHG35LQ
Q 6'LQ Q 3DWLHQWVZLWKKDHPRFKURPDWRVLV Q VKRZHG35LQ
Q 6'LQ Q 3'LQ Q DQGSDWLHQWVZLWKQXWULWLYHWR[LFOLYHU
FLUUKRVLV Q 35LQ Q 6'LQ Q 3'LQ Q
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHQHZ7$&(SURWRFRO\LHOGVUHVSHFWDEOHUHVSRQVHUDWHVLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWK OLYHU FLUUKRVLVFDXVHG +&& LQGHSHQGHQW RI WKH XQGHUO\LQJ DHWLRORJ\ RI WKH
OLYHUFLUUKRVLV
%
$QWLDQJLRJHQHVLVHIIHFWRIDUVHQLFWULR[LGHRQV\QHUJLVLQJWKH
WUDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQHIIHFWLQWKHWUHDWPHQWRIUDEELW9;
WXPRXUV
;'DL.;X+6KDR<&KHQJ4:DQJ6KHQ\DQJ&1
GDL[XGH[#YLSVLQDFRP
3XUSRVH7RVWXG\WKHHIIHFWDQGPHFKDQLVPRIDUVHQLFWULR[LGH $V2 FRPELQHG
ZLWK WUDQVDUWHULDO FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( RQ WKH JURZWK DQG PHWDVWDVLV RI
UDEELW9;WXPRXUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$IWHUZHHNVRILQRFXODWLRQRI9;WXPRXULQWRWKHOLYHUV
UDEELWVZHUHUDQGRPO\GLYLGHGLQWRJURXSV*URXS$LVFRQWUROJURXSJURXS
%ZLWK8)/3HPEROLVDWLRQJURXS&ZLWK8)/3DQG$'0JURXS'ZLWK8)/3DQG
$V2DQGJURXS(FRPELQHG8)/3ZLWK$'0DQG$V27ZRZHHNVDIWHUWUHDW
PHQWDOOUDEELWVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7DQGWKHWXPRXUDQG
QHFURWLFZHUHPHDVXUHGDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKSDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJV9(*)DQG09'
ZHUHGHWHFWHGE\LPPXQRKLVWRFKHPLFDOVWDLQLQJDQGTXDQWLWDWLYHFRPSDULVRQRI
WXPRXU9(*)P51$LQGLIIHUHQWJURXSVZDVGRQHE\573&5
5HVXOWV &RPSDUHG ZLWK FRQWURO JURXS WXPRXUV LQ WKH RWKHU IRXU JURXSV JUHZ
VORZO\ S DQGZLWKODUJHUQHFURVLV S &RPSDUHGZLWKQR$V2
JURXSDV%DQG&JURXS'DQG(JUHZVORZO\ S 7KHUHDUHOHVVLQWUDKHSDWLF
DQGGLVWDQWPHWDVWDVLVIRXQGLQJURXS'DQG(ZLWK$V2WKDQWKHRWKHUJURXSV
S 09'DQG9(*)P51$H[SUHVVLRQLQJURXSV'DQG(ZLWK$V2DUH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHGWKDQQR$V2JURXSV S 09'LQJURXS(FRPELQD
WLRQZLWK$V2DQG$'0LVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQWKHRWKHUWZRJURXSV&DQG'
ZLWK$'0RU$V2UHVSHFWLYHO\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ &RPELQDWLRQ RI$V2 DQG URXWLQH FKHPRWKHUDSHXWLF GUXJV FDQ
V\QHUJ\ WKH DQWLWXPRXU HIIHFWV RI 7$&($V2 PD\ UHGXFH WKH H[SUHVVLRQ RI
9(*)P51$DQGSUHYHQWWXPRXUJURZWKDQGPHWDVWDVLVE\LQKLELWLQJWKHDQJLR
JHQHVLVSURFHVV
%
7UDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
XQUHVHFWDEOHFKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPDUHVXOWVDQGSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUV
7-9RJO1111DJXLE7/HKQHUW1($1RXU(OGLQ
:2%HFKVWHLQ6=HX]HP-7URMDQ7*UXEHU5RXK
)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'( WYRJO#HPXQLIUDQNIXUWGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIWUDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&(
ZLWKIRXUFKHPRWKHUDSHXWLFSURWRFROVUHJDUGLQJORFDOWXPRXUFRQWURODQGVXUYLYDORI
SDWLHQWVZLWKXQUHVHFWDEOHFKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPD &&& DQGWRLGHQWLI\WKHSURJQRVWLF
IDFWRUVGHWHUPLQLQJWUHDWPHQWVXFFHVV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PHDQ\HDUV ZLWKXQUHVHFWDEOH&&&
ZHUHUHSHDWHGO\WUHDWHGZLWK7$&(,QWRWDOVHVVLRQV PHDQVHVVLRQV
SDWLHQWUDQJH ZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQZHHNLQWHUYDOV7KHFKHPRWKHUDSHXWLF
DJHQW XVHG ZDV PLWRP\FLQ& LQ RI SDWLHQWV JHPFLWDELQH LQ
PLWRP\FLQ&JHPFLWDELQHLQ DQGJHPFLWDELQHPLWRP\FLQ&
FLVSODWLQLQ (PEROLVDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKOLSLRGRODQGHPERFHSW
/RFDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVHZDVHYDOXDWHGE\05,DFFRUGLQJWRWKH5(&,67FULWHULD
6XUYLYDOGDWDZHUHFDOFXODWHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKH.DSODQ0HLHUPHWKRG3URJQRVWLF
IDFWRUVIRUVXUYLYDOZHUHHYDOXDWHGXVLQJORJUDQNWHVW
5HVXOWV /RFDO WXPRXU FRQWUROV ZHUH SDUWLDO UHVSRQVH VWDEOH
GLVHDVH SURJUHVVLYHGLVHDVH RISDWLHQWV0HGLDQ
DQGPHDQVXUYLYDOWLPHVIURPWKHVWDUWRI7$&(ZHUHDQGPRQWKV6XUYLYDO
UDWHIURPWKHVWDUWRI7$&(ZDVDIWHU\HDUDIWHU\HDUVDQGDIWHU
\HDUV,QLWLDOWXPRXUUHVSRQVHKLJKWXPRXUYDVFXODULW\DQG&KLOG3XJKFODVV$
ZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWIDFWRUVIRUVXUYLYDODQGQXPEHURIWXPRXUOHVLRQVDQG
ORFDWLRQLQOLYHUZHUHQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWKGLIIHUHQWFKHPRWKHUDS\SURWRFROVZDVGRFXPHQWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ7$&(LVDSDOOLDWLYHDQGVDIHWUHDWPHQWRSWLRQIRUSDWLHQWVZLWKXQ
UHVHFWDEOH&&&&KLOG3XJKFODVV%WXPRXUK\SRYDVFXODULW\LQLWLDOO\SURJUHVVLYH
GLVHDVHZHUHSRRUSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVIRUVXUYLYDO
%
'&EHDGVFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQRI+&&DQGHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHUHVXOWV
XVLQJ&(86DQG0'&7DWZR\HDUVWXG\
97VDJNRXOL76ROGDWRV6.DPSDQDURX67DQWHOHV/7KDQRV.0DODJDUL
03RPRQL'$.HOHNLV$WKHQV*5 PNDPSDQDURX#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7KH SXUSRVH ZDV WR FRPSDUH WKH DFFXUDF\ RI FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
XOWUDVRXQG &(86 DQGPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7 0'&7 IRUHYDOXDWLQJWKHRXWFRPHRI
WUDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWKGR[RUXELFLQEHDGVLQSDWLHQWVZLWK+&&
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\VWXGLHGWKHIROORZXSLPDJLQJVWXG
LHV RI D WRWDO RI QRGXOHV REVHUYHG LQ SDWLHQWV PDOHV DQG IHPDOHV
WKDWUDQJHGLQDJHIURPWR ZLWKELRSV\SURYHQ+&&ZKRKDGXQGHUZHQW
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWK'&EHDGV$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKPXOWLSKDVLF
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 0'&7 DQG &(86 DSSUR[LPDWHO\ ZHHNV DIWHU '&EHDGV
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ &RQWUDVW HQKDQFHPHQW DSSHDULQJ ZLWKLQ WKH WXPRXU ZDV
LQWHUSUHWHG DV LQFRPSOHWH WUHDWPHQW RU WXPRXU UHFXUUHQFH 0'&7 ZDV XVHG DV
UHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGDQGDQJLRJUDSK\LQFDVHDGGLWLRQDO'&EHDGVWUHDWPHQWZDV
SHUIRUPHGGXHWRLQFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVH$OOH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHLQWHUSUHWHGEOLQGO\
E\WZRUDGLRORJLVWVDQGDIWHUZDUGV&(86ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK0'&7E\
DQH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWLQDEGRPLQDOLPDJLQJ
5HVXOWV,QQRGXOHVDFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHUHYHDOHGLQQRGXOHVDQGLQFRP
SOHWHLQWKHRWKHU3HUFHQWDJHRIFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHZDV3RVW'&EHDGV
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ&(86ZDVDEOHWRGHWHFWRIFDVHVZLWKUHVLGXDOWXPRXU
7KH UHVXOWV REWDLQHG ZLWK &(86 DJUHHG ZLWK WKRVH REWDLQHG ZLWK 0'&7 LQ DOO
FDVHVUHQGHULQJDGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI7KHUHZDVQRWDQ\VWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQRYHUDOOGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\EHWZHHQ0'&7DQG&(86LQ
WKHHYDOXDWLRQRIUHVLGXDOWXPRXU S!
&RQFOXVLRQ&(86UHSUHVHQWVDFRVWHIIHFWLYHDQGYDOXDEOHWRROLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQ
RIWKHRXWFRPHRIFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWK'&EHDGVLQ+&&
%
7UDQVSXOPRQDU\FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 73&( DVDUHJLRQDO
RQFRORJLFDOWUHDWPHQWIRUQRQUHVHFWDEOHOXQJPHWDVWDVHV
7-9RJO6/LQGHPD\U1(1RXU(OGLQ7'DXGD6=DQJRV
)UDQNIXUW'( WYRJO#HPXQLIUDQNIXUWGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
7UDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROL]DWLRQ 7$&( XVLQJGUXJHOXWLQJ
EHDGSUHORDGHGZLWKLULQRWHFDQ '(%,5, LQWKHWUHDWPHQWRI
PHWDVWDVHVIURPXYHDOPHODQRPD 80 FRQÀQHGWRWKHOLYHU
SUHOLPLQDU\DVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUUHVSRQVHDQGSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI
DQJLRJUDSKLFSDWWHUQDQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
LPDJLQJ ':05,
09HQWXULQL*$JRVWLQL/3LOOD&/RVLR6&DSSLR$'HO0DVFKLR0LODQ,7
YHQWXULQLPDVVLPR#KVULW
3XUSRVH80YHU\DJJUHVVLYHUDUHWXPRXUJLYHVPHWDVWDVHVFRQÀQHGWRWKHOLYHU
LQPRUHWKDQRIWKHSDWLHQWV6\VWHPLFUHJLRQDOFKHPRWKHUDS\ IRWHPXVWLQH
LVXVXDOO\LQHIIHFWLYH2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRDVVHVVIHDVLELOLW\FRPSOLFDWLRQVWXPRXU
UHVSRQVHDQGSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIDQJLRJUDSKLFSDWWHUQDQG':05,LQSDWLHQWV
VXEPLWWHGWR7$&(ZLWK'(%,5,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QSDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\80PHWDVWDVHVFRQ
ÀQHGWRWKHOLYHUKLVWRORJLFDOO\GLDJQRVHGZHUHHQUROOHGSDWLHQWVZLWK!OHVLRQV
ZHUHVXEPLWWHGWR7$&(ZLWK'(%,5,DVVHFRQGOLQHDSSURDFKLQFDVHRIGLVHDVH
SURJUHVVLRQDIWHUV\VWHPLFUHJLRQDOIRWHPXVWLQHSDWLHQWVZLWKOHVLRQVZHUH
GLUHFWO\VXEPLWWHGWR7$&(ZLWK'(%,5,DVÀUVWOLQHDSSURDFK7XPRXUUHVSRQVH
ZDVDVVHVVHGE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7 5HFLVW DWEDVHOLQHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI
DQJLRJUDSKLFSDWWHUQ K\SHUYDVFXODUQRGXODUYVK\SRYDVFXODULQÀOWUDWLYHSDWWHUQ
DQGDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& DW':05,ZDVFRQVLGHUHG
5HVXOWV7$&(ZLWK'(%,5, WRWDOSURFHGXUHVPHDQ ZDVIHDVLEOHZLWKD
ORZFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWH RQHFKROHF\VWLWLVVSRQWDQHRXVO\UHVROYHG LQDOOSDWLHQWV3'
RFFXUUHGLQDOOSDWLHQWVVXEPLWWHGWRIRWHPXVWLQH7XPRXUUHVSRQVHVWR7$&(ZLWK
'(%,5,ZHUHDVIROORZV&5356'3' VHFRQGOLQH'(%,5,356'
3'ÀUVWOLQH'(%,5,&5356'3' 3'ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKK\SRYDVFXODU
LQÀOWUDWLYHDQJLRJUDSKLFSDWWHUQDQGKLJKEDVHOLQH$'&YDOXHVRIOHVLRQV S
&RQFOXVLRQ,QRXUSUHOLPLQDU\H[SHULHQFH7$&(ZLWK'(%,5,ZDVIHDVLEOHVDIH
DQGHIIHFWLYHLQDOOSDWLHQWVLWFDQEHSURSRVHGDVÀUVWOLQHWUHDWPHQWLQSDWLHQWVDI
IHFWHGE\80PHWDVWDVHVFRQÀQHGWRWKHOLYHU+\SRYDVFXODULQÀOWUDWLYHDQJLRJUDSKLF
SDWWHUQDQGKLJKEDVHOLQH$'&DUHSUHGLFWLYHRIDORZUHVSRQVH
%
,PSDFWRIKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLVDQGÀEURVLVRQVHJPHQWDOOLYHU
K\SHUWURSK\DIWHUSUHRSHUDWLYHSRUWDOYHLQHPEROLVDWLRQ
$.RRSV(5DPFLF+,WWULFK&+DEHUPDQQ*$GDP
+DPEXUJ'( NRRSV#XNHXQLKDPEXUJGH
3XUSRVH3RUWDOYHLQHPEROLVDWLRQ 39( DOORZVWKHLQGXFWLRQRIVHJPHQWDOOLYHU
K\SHUWURSK\LQLQLWLDOO\LUUHVHFWDEOHOLYHUPDOLJQDQFLHV3XUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDV
WRGHWHUPLQHWKHLPSDFWRISUHH[LVWLQJKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLVDQGSRUWDOÀEURVLVRQWKH
UHODWLYHDQGDEVROXWHK\SHUWURSK\RIWKHOHIWODWHUDOVHJPHQWVLQSDWLHQWVVFKHGXOHG
IRUH[WHQGHGULJKWKHSDWHFWRP\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV+LVWRORJ\IURPSUHLQWHUYHQWLRQDOELRSV\RUWKHUHVHF
WLRQ VSHFLPHQ ZDV HYDOXDWHG LQ SDWLHQWV WKDW UHFHLYHG 39( EHFDXVH RI SUL
PDULO\LUUHVHFWDEOHPDOLJQDQFLHV FRORUHFWDOPHWDVWDVHVRWKHUPHWDVWDVHV
FKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPD+&& $OODFFHVVLEOHSRUWDOEUDQFKHVRIVHJPHQWV
ZHUHHPEROLVHGZLWKF\DQRDFU\ODWHJOXH&7YROXPHWU\ZDVSHUIRUPHGSULRUDQG
ZHHNVDIWHUHPEROLVDWLRQLIQHFHVVDU\UHSHDWHGHYHU\ZHHNVXQWLOWKHIXWXUH
OLYHUUHPQDQWZHLJKWH[FHHGHGERG\ZHLJKW'LDJQRVLVRIKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLV
DQGSRUWDOÀEURVLVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKK\SHUWURSK\UDWHVFDOFXODWLQJ/HYHQH7
WHVWVDQG6WXGHQWҋV7WHVWV
5HVXOWV6WHDWRVLVZDVIRXQGLQ SDWLHQWV JUDGHGPLOGPRGHUDWH
DQG VHYHUH ÀEURVLV LQ SDWLHQWV JUDGHG PLOG PRGHUDWH
VHYHUHDQGFLUUKRVLV :LWKRXWVWHQRVLVYROXPHJDLQZDVDIWHUGD\V
G ZLWKVWHQRVLVRQO\DIWHUDPHDQRIGD\V G 7KHVHDE
VROXWHDQGUHODWLYHGLIIHUHQFHVUHDFKHGVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFH S ZKHUHDV
QRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH S ZDVIRXQGLQWKHOHIWODWHUDOVHJPHQWDOYROXPH
LQFUHDVHEHWZHHQQRQÀEURWLF DQGÀEURWLF OLYHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ+HSDWLFVWHDWRVLVUHGXFHVWKHK\SHUWURSK\FDSDELOLW\DIWHU39(+RZ
HYHUWKHPRUHFKURQLFOLYHUGDPDJHRILQWKLVVWXG\PRVWO\PLOGSRUWDOÀEURVLV
GLGQRWOLPLWOLYHUK\SHUWURSK\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWXPRXUUHVSRQVHZLWKYROXPHWULFDVVHVVPHQWIRUWXPRXU
VL]HDIWHUWUHDWPHQWRIXQUHVHFWDEOHOXQJPHWDVWDVHVZLWKUHSHWLWLYHWUDQVSXOPRQDU\
FKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 73&( LQSDOOLDWLYHLQWHQWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQDQGSDWLHQWV PHDQ\HDUV
PDOHVIHPDOHV VXIIHULQJIURPXQUHVHFWDEOHOXQJPHWDVWDVHVZHUH
WUHDWHGZLWK73&( UDQJHVHVVLRQVPHDQ 7KH\IHDWXUHGDPHDQRI
PHWDVWDVHVRIGLIIHUHQWRULJLQVFRORUHFWDOFDUFLQRPD Q EUHDVWFDQFHU Q
VDUFRPD Q UHQDOFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD Q PHODQRPD Q WK\URLGHDO Q
DQGRWKHUV Q /LSLRGROPLWRP\FLQ&DQGPLFURVSKHUHV 6SKHUH[ ZHUHDGPLQ
LVWHUHGYLDEDOORRQSURWHFWLRQ$WZHHNLQWHUYDOVGLDJQRVLVDQGIROORZXSZHUH
DFFRPSOLVKHGXVLQJXQHQKDQFHGDQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\
5HVXOWV$OOSDWLHQWVWROHUDWHGWKHUHSHDWHGWUHDWPHQWVZLWKRXWDGYHUVHHIIHFWV
,Q Q PRGHUDWHWRKLJKOLSLRGROXSWDNHZDVIRXQGZKLOH Q
RIWKHWUHDWHGWXPRXUVVKRZHGDORZVWRUDJH,Q Q RIHPEROLVHGPH
WDVWDVHVWXPRXUYROXPHZDVUHVROYHGWRPORQDYHUDJHLQ Q LW
UHPDLQHGXQFKDQJHGZKLOHLQ Q LWLQFUHDVHGWRPORQDYHUDJH
$FFRUGLQJWRWKH5(&,67FULWHULDSDWLHQWVKDG´SDUWLDOUHVSRQVHµKDG´VWDEOH
GLVHDVHµDQG´SURJUHVVLYHGLVHDVHµ0HDQVXUYLYDOZDVGD\VLQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKFRORUHFWDOFDUFLQRPDGD\VLQEUHDVWFDQFHUGD\VLQVDUFRPDV
GD\VLQUHQDOFHOOFDUFLQRPDGD\VPHODQRPDGD\VLQWK\URLGFDQFHUDQG
GD\VLQRWKHUFDQFHUVXVLQJWKH.DSODQ0HLHUPHWKRG
&RQFOXVLRQ$FFRUGLQJWRWKHVHÀQGLQJV73&(PLJKWEHDZHOOWROHUDWHGSURFHGXUH
IRUWKHSDOOLDWLYHWUHDWPHQWRIQRQUHVHFWDEOHOXQJPHWDVWDVHV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP(
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
66
)URPIRRWWRKLS
0RGHUDWRUV
03$SDULVL*RPH]9DOHQFLD(6
).DLQEHUJHU9LHQQD$7
%
)HPRUDOOHQJWKDVVHVVPHQWRQSUHQDWDO05,
81HPHF6)1HPHF0:HEHU3&%UXJJHU'3UD\HU9LHQQD$7
XUVXODQHPHF#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KLVVWXG\VRXJKWWRGHPRQVWUDWHQRUPDOIHPRUDOOHQJWKGHYHORSPHQWRQ
SUHQDWDOPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, E\FRQVWUXFWLQJDIRHWDOJURZWKFKDUW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFOXGHGWKH05VFDQVRI
IRHWXVHV WRJHVWDWLRQDOZHHNV>*:@ ZLWKQRUPDODQDWRP\RUPLQRU
DEQRUPDOLWLHV2QHFKRSODQDU05,IHPRUDOOHQJWKZDVPHDVXUHGIURPWKHSUR[L
PDOWRWKHGLVWDOHQGRIWKHVKDIW GLDSK\VHDOOHQJWK DQGIURPWKHRXWHUPDUJLQ
RIWKHSUR[LPDOWRWKHRXWHUPDUJLQRIWKHGLVWDOHSLSK\VLV WRWDOOHQJWK 6WDWLVWL
FDOGHVFULSWLRQ3HDUVRQFRUUHODWLRQDQGOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVZHUHXVHGWR
HYDOXDWHIHPRUDOOHQJWKLQUHODWLRQWRJHVWDWLRQ7WHVWVZHUHFDOFXODWHGWRFRPSDUH
GLDSK\VHDOWRWDOIHPRUDOOHQJWKRQ05,ZLWKSXEOLVKHG86QRUPDWLYHGDWD
5HVXOWV0LQLPXPDQGPD[LPXPOHQJWKYDOXHVPHDQYDOXHVDQGFRQÀGHQFH
LQWHUYDOVDQGSHUFHQWLOHVZHUHGHÀQHGIRUWKHJHVWDWLRQDODJH)HPRUDOOHQJWKDVD
IXQFWLRQRIJHVWDWLRQDODJHZDVH[SUHVVHGE\WKHUHJUHVVLRQHTXDWLRQGLDSK\VHDO
OHQJWK DQGWRWDOOHQJWK *: 7KHFRU
UHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW S 7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQGLDSK\VHDOOHQJWKRQ05,DQG86GDWDZKHUHDVWRWDOOHQJWK
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORQJHUWKDQWKH86PHDVXUHPHQWV S
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUVWXG\SURYLGHV05,UHIHUHQFHGDWDRIQRUPDOIHPRUDOOHQJWKLQ
XWHURZKLFKLQDGGLWLRQWR86PD\EHKHOSIXOWRGHWHUPLQHQRUPDOORQJERQHJURZWK
DVZHOODVDEQRUPDOLWLHV'LDSK\VHDOOHQJWKRQ05,DQG86DUHHTXLYDOHQWZKHUHDV
WRWDOOHQJWKLQFOXGLQJWKHHSLSK\VHVLVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWIURP86ÀQGLQJV
%
'KLQGIRRWDOLJQPHQWPHDVXUHPHQWVEDVHGRQORZGRVHELSODQDU
[UD\VFRPSDULVRQWRVWDQGDUGUDGLRJUDSKLFPHDVXUHPHQWV
56XWWHU&:$3ÀUUPDQQ1(VSLQRVD)0%XFN=XULFK&+
UHWRVXWWHU#EDOJULVWFK
3XUSRVH7RHVWDEOLVKDUREXVWDQGUHSURGXFLEOHKLQGIRRWDOLJQPHQW +$ PHDVXUH
PHQWWHFKQLTXHEDVHGRQORZGRVHELSODQDU[UD\VDQGFRPSDUHWR+$PHDVXUH
PHQWVRQVWDQGDUGUDGLRJUDSKV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$SKDQWRPFRQVLVWLQJRIDKXPDQIRRWVNHOHWRQHPEHGGHG
LQDFU\OLFJODVVZDVLPDJHGZLWKORQJD[LDOYLHZUDGLRJUDSKVDQGLQDORZGRVH
ELSODQDU[UD\VFDQQHU (26 LQQHXWUDOSRVLWLRQDQGGLIIHUHQWURWDWLRQV IURP
LQWHUQDOWRH[WHUQDOURWDWLRQ 7ZRLQGHSHQGHQWUHDGHUVPHDVXUHG+$RQUDGLR
JUDSKVDQGSHUIRUPHG'PHDVXUHPHQWVRI+$RQ(26GDWDXVLQJDFXVWRPPDGH
0DWODEFRGHLQWZRGLIIHUHQWUHDGRXWVHVVLRQV7LPHIRU'PHDVXUHPHQWVZDV
GHWHUPLQHG,QWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV ,&& ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV0HDVXUHPHQWVRQUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGUDGLRJUDSKVDWDOOURWDWLRQVVKRZHG
DODUJHYDULDWLRQLQ+$ UDQJHYDOJXVWRYDUXVIRUUHDGHUUHDGHU
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 'KLQGIRRWDQJOH(26PHDVXUHPHQWVDWDOOURWDWLRQVUHVXOWHG
LQDPHDQDQJOHRI IRUÀUVWDQGVHFRQGUHDGRXWE\UHDGHU
)RUUHDGHUWKHVHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUH'LIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ
UHSHDWHG(26PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHRQO\IRUERWKUHDGHUV,QWHUUHDGHUDJUHH
PHQWDQGDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQGLIIHUHQWUHDGRXWVZDVKLJK ,&& ,&&
0HDQGXUDWLRQRI'PHDVXUHPHQWVZDVPLQPLQ IRUUHDGHUVDQG
&RQFOXVLRQ '+$ PHDVXUHPHQWV EDVHG RQ ELSODQDU [UD\V DUH IDVW DQG
UHOLDEOH7KH\ DUH LQGHSHQGHQW RI IRRWSRVLWLRQLQJ GXULQJ LPDJH DFTXLVLWLRQ DQG
UHDGHULQGHSHQGHQW,QWKLVSKDQWRPVWXG\WKH'PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHVXSHULRU
WRPHDVXULQJ+$ZLWKWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGUDGLRJUDSKV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
,VLWSRVVLEOHWRLGHQWLI\DSDWKRORJLFKLQGIRRWDOLJQPHQWRQQRQ
ZHLJKWEHDULQJFRURQDO05LPDJHV"$QDWWHPSWXVLQJGLIIHUHQW
PHDVXUHPHQWWHFKQLTXHV
)0%XFN$+RIIPDQQ10DPLVFK0)DUVKDG1(VSLQRVD'5HVQLFN
-+RGOHU=XULFK&+6DQ'LHJR&$86
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHDELOLW\WRGLVFULPLQDWHEHWZHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKQRUPDO
DQGSDWKRORJLFKLQGIRRWDOLJQPHQW +$ RQFRURQDOQRQZHLJKWEHDULQJ05LPDJHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,5%DSSURYDODQGLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWRIDOOSDWLHQWVZDV
REWDLQHG+$ZDVTXDQWLÀHGRQ+$YLHZUDGLRJUDSKVRISDWLHQWV PHDQDJH
\HDUV UDQJH \HDUV XVLQJ WKUHH GLIIHUHQW PHDVXUHPHQW WHFKQLTXHV
FDOFDQHDOD[LVPHGLDODQGODWHUDOFDOFDQHDOFRQWRXU 7KHVHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUH
XVHGWRGHÀQHDJURXSRISDWLHQWVZLWKDQRUPDO+$ YDOJXV DQGDJURXS
ZLWKDFOHDUO\SDWKRORJLF+$ !YDOJXVRUYDUXV +$ZDVWKHQPHDVXUHGRQ
FRURQDO05LPDJHVXVLQJVL[GLIIHUHQWPHDVXUHPHQWWHFKQLTXHV FDOFDQHDOD[LV
PHGLDO DQG ODWHUDO FDOFDQHDO FRQWRXU VXVWHQWDFXOXPWDQJHQW ÀEXORFDOFDQHDO
GLVWDQFHWDODURIIVHW 52&DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGWRÀQGWKHRQH05PHDVXUH
PHQWWHFKQLTXHZLWKRSWLPDOVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUGLVFULPLQDWLRQEHWZHHQ
QRUPDODQGSDWKRORJLF+$
5HVXOWV,IRQWKH+$YLHZUDGLRJUDSKVWKHPHDVXUHPHQWVXVLQJWKHPHGLDOFDO
FDQHDOFRQWRXUZHUHGHÀQLQJWKHDVVLJQPHQWRIWKHSDWLHQWVLQWRWKHQRUPDORUWKH
SDWKRORJLFDOJURXSDOOPHDVXUHPHQWVRQ05LPDJHVFRXOGFOHDUO\ S LGHQWLI\
WKHSDWKRORJ\05PHDVXUHPHQWZLWKWKHFDOFDQHDOD[LVKRZHYHUUHDFKHGWKHEHVW
FRPELQDWLRQRIVHQVLWLYLW\ DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ ZLWKDFXWRIIRI!YDOJXV
&RQFOXVLRQ ,W LV SRVVLEOH WR GLVFULPLQDWH EHWZHHQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK QRUPDO DQG
SDWKRORJLF+$RQFRURQDOQRQZHLJKWEHDULQJ05LPDJHVZLWKDVHQVLWLYLW\RI
DQGDVSHFLÀFLW\RI
%
6FUHZKRPHPHFKDQLVPDQGLWVLQÁXHQFHRQWLELDOWXEHURVLW\
WURFKOHDUJURRYH 777* GLVWDQFHPHDVXUHPHQWRQ05
H[DPLQDWLRQVRIWKHNQHHLQDV\PSWRPDWLFYROXQWHHUVLQIXOO
H[WHQVLRQÁH[LRQDQGÁH[LRQ
7-'LHWULFK0%HW]&:$3ÀUUPDQQ33.RFK6))XFHQWHVH=XULFK&+
WGLHW#JP[QHW
3XUSRVH,QFUHDVHGWLELDOWXEHURVLW\WURFKOHDUJURRYH 777* GLVWDQFHOHDGVWR
SDWHOODU LQVWDELOLW\ 7KH VRFDOOHG VFUHZKRPH PHFKDQLVP UHIHUV WR DQ RXWZDUG
URWDWLRQRIWKHWLELDZKHQWKHNQHHUHDFKHVIXOOH[WHQVLRQ:HK\SRWKHVLVHGWKDW
WKHVRFDOOHGVFUHZKRPHPHFKDQLVPRIWKHNQHHLQHQGVWDJHH[WHQVLRQLQFUHDVHV
WKHGLVWDQFHRIWKH777*GLVWDQFHRIWKHNQHHRQ05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7UDQVYHUVDOVSLQHFKR7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJHVRIWKH
NQHHZHUHDFTXLUHGLQIXOOH[WHQVLRQDQGÁH[LRQRIWKHNQHHLQDV\PS
WRPDWLFYROXQWHHUV SDWLHQWVCPHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH\HDUV
OHIWULJKW XVLQJDÁH[LEOHFRLO)ROORZLQJSDUDPHWHUVZHUHXVHGVOLFHWKLFNQHVV
PPPDWUL[[)29[PP7KH777*GLVWDQFHZDVPHDVXUHG
LQDOOWKUHHSRVLWLRQV7KH6WXGHQWҋVWWHVWVHUYHGIRUVWDWLVWLFV
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ777*GLVWDQFHZDVPP UDQJHPP LQ
IXOOH[WHQVLRQPP UDQJHPP LQÁH[LRQDQGPP
UDQJHPP LQÁH[LRQ7KHPHDQYDOXHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW
SYDOXH EHWZHHQWKUHHSRVLWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH777*GLVWDQFHLQFUHDVHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQWKHHQGVWDJHH[WHQVLRQ
RIWKHNQHH7KHUHIRUHWKHFRPSDUDELOLW\RISXEOLVKHG777*YDOXHVPHDVXUHGRQ
UDGLRJUDSKV&7DQG05,DWYDULRXVÁH[LRQH[WHQVLRQDQJOHVRIWKHNQHHLVOLPLWHG
%
)HPRUDODQGWLELDOWRUVLRQPHDVXUHPHQWVXVLQJ'PRGHOVEDVHGRQ
ORZGRVHELSODQDU[UD\LQFRPSDULVRQWRVWDQGDUG&7PHDVXUHPHQWV
)0%XFN5*XJJHQEHUJHU33.RFK&:$3ÀUUPDQQ=XULFK&+
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHIHPRUDODQGWLELDOWRUVLRQPHDVXUHPHQWVDQGLQWHUUHDGHU
DJUHHPHQWRIPHDVXUHPHQWVXVLQJ'PRGHOVEDVHGRQORZGRVHELSODQDU[UD\
LQFRPSDULVRQWRVWDQGDUG&7PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGHYDOXDWHLQWHUFKDQJHDELOLW\RI
WKHWZRPHWKRGV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYDOZDVREWDLQHGDQGDOO
SDWLHQWVVLJQHGDQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQW)HPRUDODQGWLELDOWRUVLRQZHUHPHDVXUHG
EDVHGRQ'PRGHOVEDVHGRQORZGRVHELSODQDU[UD\V (26LPDJLQJV\VWHP
DQG RQ D[LDO &7 LPDJHV E\ WZR LQGHSHQGHQW UHDGHUV UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KH WZR
PHDVXUHPHQW PRGDOLWLHV ZHUH FRPSDUHG E\ PHDQV RI %ODQG$OWPDQ SORWV DQG
GHVFULSWLYHVWDWLVWLFV,QWHUUHDGHUDJUHHPHQWZDVTXDQWLÀHGE\RILQWUDFODVVFRU
UHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWV ,&&
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHPD[LPDOPHDVXUHPHQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZR&7UHDGHUV IHPXU
7LELD ZDVVOLJKWO\ELJJHUWKDQWKHPD[LPDOPHDVXUHPHQWGLIIHUHQFHEH
WZHHQWKHWZRUHDGHUVXVLQJ'PRGHOVEDVHGRQELSODQDU[UD\V )HPXU7LELD
%ODQG$OWPDQSORWVVKRZHGQRUHOHYDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHUHVXOWVRIWKH
WZRPHDVXUHPHQWPRGDOLWLHV([FHSWIRURQHPHDVXUHPHQWRIWKHIHPRUDOWRUVLRQ
DQGRQHPHDVXUHPHQWRIWKHWLELDOWRUVLRQDOOUHVXOWVEDVHGRQWKH'PRGHOVZHUH
ZLWKLQWKHOLPLWRIDJUHHPHQW PHDQVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ ,QWHUUHDGHU
DJUHHPHQWZDVVLJQLÀFDQW S
&RQFOXVLRQ)HPRUDODQGWLELDOWRUVLRQPHDVXUHPHQWVXVLQJ'PRGHOVEDVHGRQ
ELSODQDU[UD\VDUHLQWHUFKDQJHDEOHZLWK&7PHDVXUHPHQWV
%
,VWKHDOSKDDQJOHDEOHWRGLVFULPLQDWHEHWZHHQV\PSWRPDWLF
SDWLHQWVZLWKIHPRURDFHWDEXODULPSLQJHPHQW )$, DQGDV\PSWRPDWLF
YROXQWHHUV"
56XWWHU7-'LHWULFK&:$3ÀUUPDQQ=XULFK&+ UHWRVXWWHU#EDOJULVWFK
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVGLDJQRVWLFFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIGLIIHUHQWDOSKDDQJOHWKUHVKROGV
LQYROXQWHHUVDQG)$,SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVLQGLYLGXDOV \HDUV ZHUHLQFOXGHG SDWLHQWV
ZLWKFDPGHIRUPLWLHVDQGDJHDQGJHQGHUPDWFKHGDV\PSWRPDWLFYROXQWHHUV
7KHSDWLHQWJURXSFRQVLVWHGRIFDPW\SH)$,DQGPL[HGW\SH)$,$OSKD
DQJOHVZHUHPHDVXUHGRQDUDGLDOO\UHIRUPDWWHG7ZHLJKWHGWUXH),63'05,
VHTXHQFHRIWKHSUR[LPDOIHPXUE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWUHDGHUV,QWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQ
FRHIÀFLHQWV ,&& DQGUHFHLYHURSHUDWRUFKDUDFWHULVWLFV 52& ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV 0HDQ DOSKDDQJOHV ZHUH KLJKHVW LQ WKH DQWHURVXSHULRU VHJPHQW ZLWK
IRU UHDGHU IRU SDWLHQWV DQG IRU
YROXQWHHUV$OSKDDQJOHV!ZHUHPHDVXUHGLQDQGRXWRIYROXQWHHUV
IRUUHDGHU 0RVWHOHYDWHGDOSKDDQJOHVLQYROXQWHHUVZHUHIRXQG
DQWHURVXSHULRUO\ DQGVXSHULRUO\ 7KHPD[LPDODOSKDDQJOH
LQ DQ\ VHJPHQW ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ GLIIHUHQW S LQ SDWLHQWV DQG YROXQWHHUV
YVIRUUHDGHUYVIRUUHDGHU DOEHLW
ZLWKDODUJHRYHUODS,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVJRRG ,&& 52&VKRZHG
WKHODUJHVWDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYHDWWKHDQWHURVXSHULRUVHJPHQW DUHD
IRUUHDGHUS DDOSKDDQJOHWKUHVKROGJDYHDVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\
RIIRUUHDGHUDQGIRUUHDGHUZKLOHDWKUHVKROGJDYH
IRUUHDGHUDQGIRUUHDGHU
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHDOSKDDQJOHLVVXERSWLPDOWRGLVFULPLQDWHYROXQWHHUVDQG)$,SD
WLHQWVZLWKFDPW\SHGHIRUPLWLHV'LVFULPLQDWLRQLVPRVWUHOLDEOHDWWKHDQWHURVXSHULRU
VHJPHQW5DLVLQJWKHDOSKDDQJOHWKUHVKROGIURPWRUHGXFHVIDOVHSRVLWLYHV
DQGPLJKWUHVXOWLQOHVVRYHUWUHDWPHQW
%
,VWKHUHDUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ7PDSSLQJRINQHHFDUWLODJHRUWKH
ZKROHRUJDQ05,VFRULQJPHWKRG :2506 IRUNQHHRVWHRDUWKULWLV
DQGWKHSDWLHQWҋVSDLQV\PSWRPVIXQFWLRQLQGDLO\OLIH $'/
IXQFWLRQLQVSRUWDQGUHFUHDWLRQ 6SRUW DQGNQHHUHODWHGTXDOLW\RI
OLIH 42/ DVJLYHQE\WKHNQHHRVWHRDUWKULWLVRXWFRPHVFRUH .226
TXHVWLRQQDLUH"
*6FKHXUHFNHU&6FKHXUHFNHU$6FKHXUHFNHU-.UDPHU/LQ]$7
JHRUJVFKHXUHFNHU#LQRGHDW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&RPSDULVRQRI'63$&(YV')6(VHTXHQFHIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI
LQWHUQDONQHHGHUDQJHPHQWDW7
39DQ'\FN-/*LHOHQ.:RXWHUV)09DQKRHQDFNHU/'RVVFKH
303DUL]HO(GHJHP%( SLHWHUYDQG\FN#X]DEH
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH RI WKH '63$&( VDPSOLQJ
SHUIHFWLRQZLWKDSSOLFDWLRQRSWLPLVHGFRQWUDVWXVLQJYDULDEOHÁLSDQJOHHYROXWLRQV
IDVWVSLQHFKR )6( VHTXHQFHDVFRPSDUHGWRURXWLQH')6(LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQ
RILQWHUQDONQHHGHUDQJHPHQWDW7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )URP -DQXDU\ WR -XO\ D VDJLWWDO LVRWURSLF IDW
VDWXUDWHG '63$&( )6( VHTXHQFH ZDV DGGHG WR D FRQYHQWLRQDO ' NQHH
05LPDJLQJSURWRFRO6HTXHQFHSDUDPHWHUVRI'63$&(ZHUH75 PV
7( PVYR[HOVL]H PP6XEVHTXHQWNQHHDUWKURVFRS\ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ
SDWLHQWV7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVEOLQGHGWRRSHUDWLYHUHVXOWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\HYDOX
DWHGPXOWLSODQDU')6(DQG'63$&(GDWDVHWVZLWKDZHHNLQWHUYDOIRUWKH
SUHVHQFHRIPHQLVFDOWHDUVDQWHULRUFUXFLDWHOLJDPHQW $&/ DQGFDUWLODJHOHVLRQV
$FFXUDFLHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKUHDGHUXVLQJDUWKURVFRS\DVWKHUHIHUHQFH
VWDQGDUG0F1HPDUҋVWHVWZDVXVHGWRLGHQWLI\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV S
EHWZHHQ'DQG'VHTXHQFHV,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVGHWHUPLQHGXVLQJ
&RKHQ VNDSSDWHVW
5HVXOWV)RUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIWHDUVRIPHGLDODQGODWHUDOPHQLVFXVDQG$&/OH
VLRQVDFFXUDF\RIERWKVHTXHQFHVUDQJHGIURPWRWRDQG
WRUHVSHFWLYHO\IRUERWKUHDGHUV)RUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIFDUWLODJHOHVLRQV
DFFXUDF\RIERWKVHTXHQFHVUDQJHGIURPWRIRUERWKUHDGHUV:HIRXQG
QRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQGLDJQRVWLF\LHOGEHWZHHQ'DQG'VHTXHQFHV,QWHU
REVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVH[FHOOHQWIRUPHQLVFXVDQG$&/OHVLRQV NDSSD!
DQGLWZDVPRGHUDWHIRUFDUWLODJHOHVLRQV NDSSD
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI'63$&(LVVLPLODUWRURXWLQH'
)6(IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIPHQLVFDODQWHULRUFUXFLDWHOLJDPHQWDQGFDUWLODJHOHVLRQV
RIWKHNQHHDW7
%
7KURXJKSODQHGLVWRUWLRQFRUUHFWLRQDQGYLHZDQJOHWLOWLQJIRU
UHGXFWLRQRIPHWDODUWHIDFWVDW05LPDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVZLWKWRWDOKLS
DUWKURSODVW\SHUIRUPDQFHRI67,5DQG7VHTXHQFHV
56XWWHU(-8OEULFK9-HOOXV01LWWND&:$3ÀUUPDQQ=XULFK&+
(UODQJHQ'( UHWRVXWWHU#EDOJULVWFK
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIWKHQHZ:$53VHTXHQFHIRUUHGXFWLRQ
RIERWKWKURXJKSODQHDQGLQSODQHDUWHIDFWVLQSDWLHQWVDIWHUWRWDOKLSDUWKURSODVW\
7+$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWK7+$ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHG6OLFH
HQFRGLQJPHWDODUWHIDFWFRUUHFWLRQ 6(0$& YLHZDQJOHWLOWLQJ 9$7 DQGLQFUHDVHG
EDQGZLGWKZHUHDSSOLHGE\WKH´:$53µ76(VHTXHQFHDW7&RURQDO67,5
:$53DQGWUDQVYHUVH7:$53LPDJHVVWDQGDUGFRURQDO67,5DQGWUDQVYHUVH
7LPDJHVRSWLPLVHGZLWKKLJKEDQGZLGWK 67,5KL%:7KL%: ZHUHDFTXLUHG
6LJQDOYRLGZDVTXDQWLÀHG4XDOLWDWLYHFULWHULD DQDWRP\GLVWRUWLRQEOXUULQJQRLVH
ZHUHDVVHVVHGRQDÀYHSRLQWVFDOH QRDUWHIDFWVQRWYLVLEOHGXHWRVHYHUH
DUWHIDFWV E\WZRUHDGHUV&OLQLFDOÀQGLQJVZHUHUHFRUGHG4XDQWLWDWLYHGDWDZHUH
DQDO\VHGZLWKDWWHVWDQGTXDOLWDWLYHGDWDZLWKD:LOFR[RQVLJQHGUDQNWHVW
5HVXOWV 6LJQDO YRLG DURXQG WKH SURVWKHVLV KHDG ZDV VPDOOHU IRU 67,5:$53
WKDQ 67,5KL%: FP FP DQG IRU 7:$53 WKDQ 7KL%:
FPFPS IRUDOO $QDWRPLFGLVWLQFWLRQZDVEHWWHURQ67,5
:$53FRPSDUHGWR67,5KL%: YVS DQGRQ7:$53
FRPSDUHGWR7KL%: YVS 'LVWRUWLRQORFDOEOXUULQJDQG
QRLVHZHUHORZHUDW:$53WKDQLQWKHVWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHV S *HQHUDOLVHG
EOXUULQJZDVKLJKHUIRU67,5:$53FRPSDUHGWR67,5KL%: S DQGIRU7
:$53FRPSDUHGWR7KL%: S $OPRVWKDOIRIWKHFOLQLFDOÀQGLQJVZHUH
PLVVHGRQ67,5KL%:FRPSDUHGWR67,5:$53 DQGÀQGLQJVS
ZKLOH7KL%:ZDVVLPLODUWR7:$53 DQGÀQGLQJVS
&RQFOXVLRQ67,5:$53DQG7:$53ZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUIRU
PRVWLPDJHFULWHULDEXWWKHFOLQLFDOO\UHOHYDQWDGYDQWDJHLQDUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQZDV
RQO\SUHVHQWIRU67,5LPDJHVDQGQRWIRU7LPDJHV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH%RWK7PDSSLQJRIFDUWLODJHDQGWKH:2506PHWKRGDUHHVWDEOLVKHG
UHVHDUFK WRROV IRU NQHH RVWHRDUWKULWLV LV WKHUH D UHODWLRQVKLS ZLWK WKH SDWLHQWV
.226TXHVWLRQQDLUH"
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$IWHULQWURGXFLQJ7PDSSLQJDQGWKH.226TXHVWLRQ
QDLUHLQRXUURXWLQHSURWRFROIRUNQHH05,ZHLQFOXGHGWKHÀUVWIHPDOHVDQG
PDOHVUHVSHFWLYHO\ IHPDOHPHDQDJH\UDQJH\PDOHPHDQDJH\
UDQJH \ :H HPSOR\HG D VDJLWWDO PXOWLHFKRVSLQHFKRVHTXHQFH IRU 7
PDSSLQJWRJHWKHUZLWKWKHURXWLQHNQHHSURWRFRO VDJLWWDO7ZDQGVDJLWWDOFRURQDO
D[LDO3GZIDWVDW RQD705,XQLW7KH7PDSVZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWK52,VZLWKD
VWDQGDUGLVHGOHQJWKRIPPIRUWKHIXOOWKLFNQHVVFDUWLODJHRQWKUHHFRQVHFXWLYH
LPDJHVRIWKHFHQWUDOPHGLDODQGODWHUDOIHPRUDOFRQG\OH 0)&/)& WKHSDWHOOD
DQGWKHWURFKOHD7KHUHSHDWHG7PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHDYHUDJHGIRUHDFKUHJLRQ
5ZHUHFDOFXODWHGZLWKOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQWRORRNIRUUHODWLRQVKLSVEHWZHHQ7YDOXHV
RUWKH:2506DQGWKH.226TXHVWLRQQDLUH 5JUDGHGDV!YHU\VWURQJ
!VWURQJ!PRGHUDWH!ZHDN!YHU\ZHDN
5HVXOWV)RUIHPDOHVWKH:2506KDGDYHU\ZHDNUHODWLRQVKLSZLWKSDLQV\PS
WRPV6SRUWDQG42/IRUPDOHVWKHUHZDVQRUHODWLRQVKLS7PDSSLQJKDGDYHU\
ZHDNUHODWLRQVKLSUHJDUGLQJWKH/)&DQGV\PSWRPVLQIHPDOHVLQPDOHVLWZDV
YHU\ZHDNIRU0)&DQGV\PSWRPVSDWHOODDQGSDLQDQGWURFKOHDDQGSDLQ%HVLGH
WKHVHUHODWLRQVKLSVWKHUHZHUHQRQHPRUH
&RQFOXVLRQ$OWKRXJK7PDSSLQJRIFDUWLODJHDQGWKH:2506DUHYDOXDEOHLQ
NQHHRVWHRDUWKULWLVUHVHDUFKERWKRIWKHPVKRZRQO\DYHU\ZHDNLIDQ\UHODWLRQVKLS
ZLWKWKHSDWLHQWVҋSDLQV\PSWRPV$'/IXQFWLRQLQVSRUWDQG42/
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
7HVODKLSLPDJLQJLQDYDVFXODUQHFURVLVXVLQJDPXOWLFKDQQHO
WUDQVPLWDUUD\DQG5)VKLPPLQJ
-07KH\VRKQ2.UDII62U]DGD6/DQGJUDHEHU0(/DGG
7&/DXHQVWHLQ(VVHQ'( MHQVWKH\VRKQ#XQLGXLVEXUJHVVHQGH
3XUSRVH 05, RI KLS MRLQWV SOD\V DQ LPSRUWDQW UROH LQ VWDJLQJ HVSHFLDOO\ \RXQJ
SDWLHQWVZLWKKLSGLVHDVH LHDYDVFXODUQHFURVLV$91 $LPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWKH
HYDOXDWLRQRIXOWUDKLJKÀHOGLPDJLQJ 7HVOD RIWKHKLSVXVLQJDQHZPXOWLFKDQQHO
WUDQVPLWWHFKQRORJ\WRFRPSHQVDWHWKHLQKHUHQW%LQKRPRJHQHLWLHVRI705,
LQFRPSDULVRQWR7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7HQSDWLHQWVZLWK$91ZHUHLPDJHGDW7 0DJQHWRP7
6LHPHQV XVLQJDVHOIEXLOWHLJKWFKDQQHOWUDQVPLWUHFHLYHFRLO$IWHU5)VKLPPLQJ
LGHQWLFDO VHTXHQFHV 0(',& '(66 3'7Z 76( 7Z 76( DQG 67,5 ZHUH
DFTXLUHGDW7DQG7 6N\UD6LHPHQV 5REXVWQHVVDJDLQVW%LQKRPRJHQHLWLHV
SRLQWVFDOH QRVWURQJGHJUDGDWLRQ DQG&15EHWZHHQFDUWLODJHFRUWLFDO
ERQHDQGÁXLGZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV2YHUDOOUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWFRXOGEHLPDJHGZLWKUHSURGXFLEOHKLJKTXDO
LW\DW7 H[FHSW67,5 :KLOHDOPRVWDEVHQWDW7 JUDGH DOO7VHTXHQFHV
VKRZHG VLJQDO YDULDWLRQV ZLWK '(66 PRVW UREXVW JUDGH DQG 67,5 OHDVW
IDYRXUDEOH JUDGH )RU 0(',& 3' 7Z DQG 7Z VWURQJ VLJQDO GURSRXWV
ZHUHVXIÀFLHQWO\VKLIWHGDZD\IURPWKH)297H[KLELWHGVWURQJHUFDUWLODJHÁXLG
FRQWUDVWVHVSHFLDOO\IRU0(',&DQG'(663DWKRORJLHVZHUHGHSLFWHGZLWKVOLJKWO\
PRUHGHWDLODW7
&RQFOXVLRQ$SSOLFDWLRQRIQHZWUDQVPLWWHFKQRORJLHV 5)6KLPPLQJ DOORZVWKH
KLJKUHVROXWLRQLPDJLQJRIWKHKLSVZLWK705,3DWKRORJLHVRIWKHIHPRUDOKHDG
FDQEHGLVSOD\HGLQPRUHGHWDLOZKLOHVDFULÀFLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\RIWKHVXUURXQGLQJ
VRIWWLVVXH7HVOD05,RIWKHKLSMRLQWPLJKWKHOSLPSURYHGLDJQRVWLFDQGVWDJLQJ
DFFXUDF\RIDYDVFXODUQHFURVLV
5RRP(
2QFRORJLF,PDJLQJ
66
3(7IRUFDQFHUSDWLHQWPDQDJHPHQW
0RGHUDWRUV
-*ULPP1HZ<RUN1<86
'0LOHWLþ5LMHND+5
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIWKHPHWDEROLFÁRZSKHQRW\SHRISULPDU\FRORUHFWDO
FDQFHUFRUUHODWLRQVZLWKPLFURYHVVHOGHQVLW\DUHLQÁXHQFHGE\WKH
KLVWRORJLFDOVFRULQJPHWKRG
9-*RK05RGULJXH]-XVWR$(QJOHGRZ06KDVWU\5(QGR]R00HDJKHU
67D\ORU6+DOOLJDQ$*URYHV/RQGRQ8.
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHKRZGLIIHUHQWPHWKRGVRIKLVWRORJLFDOVFRULQJRIPLFURYHVVHO
GHQVLW\ Ҋ+RWVSRWҋYHUVXV&KDONOH\ DIIHFWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQLQWHJUDWHG))'*
3(7SHUIXVLRQ&7SDUDPHWHUVDQG&'PLFURYHVVHOGHQVLW\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,QVWLWXWLRQDO UHYLHZ ERDUG DSSURYDO ZDV REWDLQHG IRU
WKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\SDWLHQWVZHUHHQUROOHGIURP$SULOWR2FWREHU
,QWHJUDWHG))'*3(7SHUIXVLRQ&7ZDVVXFFHVVIXOLQSDWLHQWV PDOHV
IHPDOHVPHDQ\HDUV RIZKRPXQGHUZHQWVXUJHU\ZLWKRXWLQWHUYHQLQJQHR
DGMXYDQWWUHDWPHQW7XPRXU689PD[689PHDQDQGUHJLRQDOEORRGÁRZ %) ZHUH
GHULYHGIRUWKHHQWLUHWXPRXU,PPXQRKLVWRFKHPLFDOVWDLQLQJIRU&'H[SUHVVLRQ
DQGDQDO\VLVIRUKRWVSRWVKRWVSRWVDQGWKH&KDONOH\PHWKRGZHUHSHUIRUPHG
&RUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQPHWDEROLFDQGÁRZSDUDPHWHUVDQG&'H[SUHVVLRQZHUH
DVVHVVHGE\6SHDUPDQUDQNFRUUHODWLRQZLWKVWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHDW
5HVXOWV0HDQ 6' WXPRXUVL]HZDV PP0HDQ 6' IRU689PD[
689PHDQDQG%)ZHUH DQG P/PLQJWLV
VXHUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHPHDQ 6' IRU&'PLFURYHVVHOGHQVLW\ZDV
DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\IRUKRWVSRWKRWVSRWDQG&KDONOH\
PHWKRGV7KHSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ%)DQG&'H[SUHVVLRQZDVPRGHVW
EXWKLJKHUIRU&KDONOH\WKDQKRWVSRWDQDO\VLV U S U S
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KHUHZDVQRFRUUHODWLRQZLWKKRWVSRWDQDO\VLV U S
7KHUHZHUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQPHWDEROLFSDUDPHWHUV 689PD[
RU689PHDQ DQG&'H[SUHVVLRQ UWRS
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHKLVWRORJLFDODQDO\VLVPHWKRGDIIHFWVFRUUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQWXPRXU
&'H[SUHVVLRQDQG%)EXWQRW689PD[RU689PHDQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,DQG *D'27$72&3(7IRUHDUO\
PRQLWRULQJRIUHVSRQVHWRORFRUHJLRQDO < /X'27$72&
WKHUDS\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKQHXURHQGRFULQHOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV
)/*LHVHO6:XOIHUW7.XGHU/6FKZDUW]+8.DXF]RU8+DEHUNRUQ
&.UDWRFKZLO+HLGHOEHUJ'(1HZ<RUN1<86 IJLHVHO#GNI]GH
3XUSRVH0RQLWRULQJUHVSRQVHWRWKHUDS\LVSUHGRPLQDQWO\EDVHGXSRQHYDOXDWLQJ
WXPRXUVL]HEHIRUHDQGDIWHUWUHDWPHQWIRUH[DPSOHLQWKHUHVSRQVHHYDOXDWLRQ
FULWHULDLQVROLGWXPRXUV 5(&,67 7KHUHIRUHZHHYDOXDWHGLIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
05 LPDJLQJ ':05, DQG *D'27$72& 3(7 DUH SRWHQWLDO VXUURJDWH EL
RPDUNHUVIRUSURYLGLQJHDUOLHULQIRUPDWLRQDERXWDSRVVLEOHWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHWR
LQWUDDUWHULDO'27$72&WKHUDS\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK OLYHU PHWDVWDVHV
RI JDVWURHQWHURSDQFUHDWLF QHXURHQGRFULQH FDQFHU *(31(7 ZHUH HYDOXDWHG
$OO SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW ERWK GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG DQG G\QDPLF FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ ':,'&(05, LQFOXGLQJEUHDWKKROGHFKRSODQDU
':,VHTXHQFHV EYDOXHVVPP DVZHOODV *D'27$72&3(7
EHIRUHWKHUDS\ EDVHOLQH DQGDIWHUODVWLQWHUYHQWLRQ IROORZXS /DUJHVWGLDPHWHU
/' LQWUDWXPRUDODSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& DQGPD[LPDOVWDQGDUGLVHG
XSWDNHYDOXH 689PD[ ZHUHPHDVXUHGLQDOOWDUJHWOHVLRQVDVZHOODVLQQRUPDO
OLYHUSDUHQFK\PDDQGVSOHHQ
5HVXOWV7XPRXUPHWDVWDVHVZHUHVXEFODVVLÀHGEDVHGXSRQFKDQJHLQWXPRXU
VL]H LQ UHVSRQGLQJ OHVLRQV 5/ Q DQG QRQUHVSRQGLQJ OHVLRQV 15/ Q
,Q 15/V EDVHOLQH PHGLDQ WXPRXU$'& LQFUHDVHG IURP [ PPVHF WR
[PPVHFZKLOHWKHUHVSRQGLQJOHVLRQLQFUHDVHGIURP[PP
VHFWR[PPVHFDIWHUODVWORFRUHJLRQDOLQWHUYHQWLRQ S ZKHUHDV
WKHFKDQJHLQ689PD[RI *D'27$72&ZDVQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ$IWHUORFRUHJLRQDO'27$72&WKHUDS\QRQUHVSRQGHUDQGUHVSRQGHU
VXEJURXSVERWKSUHVHQWHGDFKDQJHLQ$'&SULRUWR665UHFHSWRUH[SUHVVLRQ
FKDQJHV DQG DOWKRXJK PRUSKRORJLFDO UHVSRQVH DFFRUGLQJ WR 5(&,67 FULWHULD
ZDVRQO\PHDVXUDEOHLQIHZOHVLRQV7KHUHIRUHWKLVZRUNVXJJHVWVWKDWGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJLVDQHDUOLHUWXPRXULQWHJULW\VXUURJDWHIRUWKHUDSHXWLFLQWHUYHQWLRQ
DQGSRVVLEOHHDUO\LQGLFDWRUIRUWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVH
%
6LPXOWDQHRXVZKROHERG\053(7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKRQFRORJLFDO
GLDJQRVHVFRPSDULVRQWR3(7&7
06RXYDW]RJORX$%HHU0(LEHU6)XHUVW6=LHJOHU61HNROOD
(5XPPHQ\06FKZDLJHU$'U]H]JD0XQLFK'( PVRXYDW]#\DKRRGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHFRPSDUDELOLW\RIWKHFOLQLFDOSHUIRUPDQFHRI3(7&7DQG
053(7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKRQFRORJLFDOGLDJQRVHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KLUW\WZR SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW D VLQJOHLQMHFWLRQGXDO
LPDJLQJSURWRFROFRQVLVWLQJRID3(7&7DQGVXEVHTXHQW053(7VFDQ3(7
&7 ZDV SHUIRUPHG DFFRUGLQJ WR VWDQGDUG FOLQLFDO SURWRFROV PLQ SL RI
0%T>)@)'*PLQEHGSRVLWLRQ %3 6XEVHTXHQWO\ PLQSL
053(7ZDVSHUIRUPHG PLQ%3 3(7LPDJHVRIERWKPRGDOLWLHVZHUHUHFRQ
VWUXFWHGLWHUDWLYHO\ 26(0' DWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQDQGUHJLRQDODOORFDWLRQZDV
SHUIRUPHGXVLQJORZGRVH&7GDWDIRU3(7&7DQG'L[RQ05VHTXHQFHVIRU05
3(7053(7DQG3(7&7ZHUHFRPSDUHGYLVXDOO\E\UDWLQJQXPEHUDQGORFDWLRQ
RIVXVSLFLRXVOHVLRQVLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGDOLJQPHQW)RUTXDQWLWDWLYHFRPSDULVRQ
689EDVHGDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHGHWHFWHGOHVLRQVDQGGLIIHUHQWRUJDQVZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV6LPXOWDQHRXV053(7DFTXLVLWLRQZDVIHDVLEOH1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFH
ZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHQXPEHUVRIVXVSLFLRXVOHVLRQV Q RUOHVLRQSRVLWLYH
SDWLHQWV Q GHWHFWHG ZLWK 053(7 RU 3(7&7$QDWRPLFDO DOORFDWLRQ RI
3(7ÀQGLQJV REWDLQHG E\ 053(7 ZDV VXIÀFLHQWO\ IHDVLEOH RQ WKH EDVLV RI WKH
QRQGLDJQRVWLF'L[RQ05VHTXHQFHVZLWKFRPSDUDEOHSHUIRUPDQFHDVZLWKORZ
GRVH&7IRU3(7&74XDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQUHYHDOHGDKLJKFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ
PHDQ689PHDVXUHGLQOHVLRQVDQGRUJDQVZLWK0537RU3(7&7 ѩ ѩ
UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ6LPXOWDQHRXVZKROHERG\053(7LPDJLQJLVIHDVLEOHZLWKKLJKTXDO
LW\LQVKRUWWLPHDOORZLQJWKHGHWHFWLRQRIK\SHUPHWDEROLFOHVLRQVZLWKFRPSDUDEOH
UHOLDELOLW\ DV ZLWK 3(7&7 'HVSLWH GLIIHUHQW DWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQ DSSURDFKHV
WKHWUDFHUXSWDNHFRUUHODWHGZHOOEHWZHHQ053(7DQG3(7&77KH'L[RQ05
VHTXHQFHVDFTXLUHGIRUDWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQPD\VHUYHIRUDQDWRPLFDODOORFDWLRQ
RI3(7ÀQGLQJV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
6WDJLQJRIQHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUVFRPSDULVRQRI*D'27$72&
3(7&7DQG05,
&6FKUDPO1)6FKZHQ]HU0.:HUQHU&%UHQGOH
00XHOOHU&'&ODXVVHQ&3IDQQHQEHUJ
7ELQJHQ'( FKULVWLQDVFKUDPO#PHGXQLWXHELQJHQGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUH*D'27$72&3(7&7DQGZKROHERG\ :% 05,UHJDUG
LQJPHWDVWDWLFOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKQHXURHQGRFULQHWXPRXUV 1(7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q SDWLHQWV ZLWK KLVWRORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ 1(7 *D
'27$72&3(7&7 DQG :%05, ZHUH SHUIRUPHG 3(7&7 ZDV SHUIRUPHG DIWHU
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQRI0%T*D'27$72&&7SURWRFROFRPSULVHGPXOWLSKDVLF
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG LPDJLQJ 05, SURWRFRO VWDQGDUG VHTXHQFHV SUHSRVW *DGR
OLQLXP DW7(DFKPRGDOLW\ 3(7&73(7&7:%05, ZDVHYDOXDWHGLQGH
SHQGHQWO\E\WZRH[SHULHQFHGUHDGHUV&RQVHQVXVGHFLVLRQEDVHGRQLPDJLQJ
KLVWRORJ\VXUJHU\DQGFOLQLFDOIROORZXSVHUYHGDVVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH'HWHFWLRQ
UDWHVRIHDFKPRGDOLW\ZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJ0F1HPDUWHVW3YDOXHVZHUH
FRQVLGHUHGVLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV,QRISDWLHQWVPHWDVWDWLFOHVLRQVZHUHGHWHFWHG OXQJOLYHU
ERQHO\PSKQRGH /1 RWKHU *D'27$72&3(7ZDVIDOVH
QHJDWLYHLQSDWLHQWVGXHWRODFNRIUHFHSWRUH[SUHVVLRQ2IDOOGHWHFWHG
OHVLRQV3(7LGHQWLÀHG &7 3(7&7 DQG:%05,
2UJDQEDVHGGHWHFWLRQUDWHVRI3(7&7ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUIRU/1
YVS DQGSXOPRQDU\OHVLRQV YVS ZKLOH
:%05,KDGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUGHWHFWLRQUDWHVIRUOLYHU YVS
DQGERQHOHVLRQV YVS 2IDOOOHVLRQVZHUHIRXQGRQO\
LQ3(7RQO\LQ&7DQGRQO\LQ:%05,
&RQFOXVLRQ3(7&7DQG:%05,VKRZHGFRPSDUDEOHRYHUDOOGHWHFWLRQUDWHVLQ
1(7EXWVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHGLQRUJDQEDVHGGHWHFWLRQUDWHVZLWKVXSHULRULW\RI3(7
&7IRU/1DQGSXOPRQDU\OHVLRQVDQGRI:%05,IRUOLYHUDQGERQHPHWDVWDVHV
%
&RPSDULVRQRIOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQLQSDWLHQWZLWKFUDQLDOPHQLQJLRPDV
XVLQJ*D'27$72&3(7&7DQGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,
$$IVKDU2URPLHK&.UDWRFKZLO+/LQKDUW8+DEHUNRUQ)/*LHVHO
+HLGHOEHUJ'( IJLHVHO#GNI]GH
3XUSRVH 3(7 LPDJLQJ ZLWK VRPDWRVWDWLQ UHFHSWRU OLJDQGV VXFK DV *D
'27$72&3(7&7LVDZHOOHVWDEOLVKHGPHWKRGIRUGHWHFWLRQDQGWDUJHWYROXPH
GHÀQLWLRQRIPHQLQJLRPDVSULRUWRUDGLRWKHUDS\6LQFH'27$72&3(7DSSHDUVWR
GHWHFWPRUHPHQLQJLRPDVWKDQ05,ZHFRQGXFWHGDUHVWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVWR
FRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, &(05, ZLWK*D
'27$72&3(7&7LQSDWLHQWVZLWKFUDQLDOPHQLQJLRPDVSULRUWRUDGLRWKHUDS\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2YHUDSHULRGRIVL[\HDUVSDWLHQWV \R
LQRXUKRVSLWDOXQGHUZHQWFUDQLDO&(05,DQG*D'27$72&3(7&7SULRU
WRUDGLRWKHUDS\RIFUDQLDOPHQLQJLRPDV%RWKPHWKRGVZHUHFRPSDUHGE\DVLGH
E\VLGHUHDGFRXQWLQJWKHGHWHFWHGPHQLQJLRPDVDQGUHFRUGLQJWKHORFDOLVDWLRQ
DQGWKH689PD[RIWKRVHGHWHFWHGE\3(7&7RQO\
5HVXOWV:LWKLQWKHSDWLHQWVLQYHVWLJDWHGE\ERWKPRGDOLWLHVPHQLJLRPDV
ZHUHGHWHFWHGE\*D'27$72&3(7&7DQGRQO\E\&(05,
7KHUHIRUHPHQLQJLRPDVZHUHGHWHFWHGE\3(7&7RQO\0HQLQJLRPDVGHWHFWHG
LQ3(7&7RQO\EXWORFDWHGFORVHWRDUHDVRISUHYLRXVFUDQLRWRP\ SRVVLEOHUHODSVHV
RUUHPQDQWVRIIRUPHUPHQLQJLRPDV ZHUHH[FOXGHGIURPIXUWKHUDQDO\VLV
&RQFOXVLRQ*D'27$72&3(7&7SUHVHQWHGZLWKDKLJKHUVHQVLWLYLW\LQGH
WHFWLQJPHQLQJLRPDVZKHQFRPSDUHGWR&(05,(VSHFLDOO\WXPRXUVDGMDFHQWWR
WKHIDO[FHUHEULORFDWHGLQWKHVFXOOEDVHRUWXPRXUVREVFXUHGE\LPDJLQJDUWHIDFWV
DUHGLIÀFXOWWRGHWHFWE\05,
%
'LDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI3(705YHUVXV3(7&7LQWKHDEGRPHQ
':&URRN&0DGHU)3.XKQ$6DPDULQ7)+DQ\-+RGOHU
*.YRQ6FKXOWKHVV'6FKPLG=XULFK&+ FDHFLOLDPDGHU#XV]FK
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
6WDJLQJDQGUHVWDJLQJ+RGJNLQҋVGLVHDVHORZGRVHQRQHQKDQFHG
)'*3(7&7YHUVXVIXOOGRVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG)'*3(7&7
&&DSUDUR',SSROLWR/*XHUUD('H3RQWL&0HVVD66LURQL0RQ]D,7
GDYLGHDWHQD#WLVFDOLQHWLW
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQORZGRVHQRQHQKDQFHG3(7&7
ZLWKIXOOGRVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG3(7&7LQWKHVWDJLQJDQGUHVWDJLQJ+RGJNLQҋV
GLVHDVH +/
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ+/XQ
GHUZHQWD))'*3(7&7VWXG\WKDWLQFOXGHGORZGRVHQRQHQKDQFHG&7DQG
IXOOGRVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG&7VWXGLHVSHUIRUPHGLQDVLQJOHVWHSSURFHGXUH
VWXGLHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGIRUVWDJLQJDQGIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIUHVLGXDOGLVHDVH
DIWHU ÀUVW OLQH RI FKHPRWKHUDS\ UHVWDJLQJ )RU HYHU\ SDWLHQW HDFK PRGDOLW\ RI
3(7&7LPDJHVZDVHYDOXDWHGE\HLWKHURISDLUVRIH[SHUWUHDGHUVEOLQGHGDERXW
WKHFOLQLFDOGDWDDQGXQDZDUHRIWKHUHVXOWVRIWKHRWKHUW\SH)LQDOO\WKHVWDJHRI
WKHGLVHDVHZDVGHÀQHGDFFRUGLQJWR3(7OG&7DQG3(7FH&7IROORZLQJWKH$QQ
$UERUFODVVLÀFDWLRQ)RUUHVWDJLQJVWXGLHVLPDJHVZHUHLQWHUSUHWHGFRQVLGHULQJ
WKHSUHVHQFHRIUHVLGXDOPDVVZLWKRUZLWKRXWUHVLGXDODFWLYLW\DFFRUGLQJWRWKH
,QWHUQDWLRQDO+DUPRQL]DWLRQ3URMHFW
5HVXOWV2IVLGHVFRQVLGHUHGDVSRWHQWLDOO\LQYROYHGE\WKHGLVHDVH3(7
OG&7DQG3(7FH&7ZHUHFRQFRUGDQWLQ VLGHVLQVWDJLQJVWXGLHV
DQGLQ SDWLHQWVRIUHVWDJLQJVWXGLHV3(7OG&7DQG3(7FH&7ZHUH
FRQFRUGDQWZLWKVWDQGDUGUHIHUHQFHLQ DQGLQ SDWLHQWV
UHVSHFWLYHO\ LQ VWDJLQJ VWXGLHV ,Q UHVWDJLQJ VWXGLHV ERWK 3(7OG&7 DQG 3(7
FH&7UHVXOWVZHUHFRQFRUGDQWZLWKVWDQGDUGUHIHUHQFHLQ VWXGLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUVWXG\VKRZHGDJRRGFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ3(7OG&7DQG3(7
FH&7ERWKLQVWDJLQJDQGLQSDUWLFXODULQUHVWDJLQJVWXGLHV,IWKHVHUHVXOWVDUH
FRQÀUPHGLQDODUJHUSDWLHQWVҋSRSXODWLRQ3(7OG&7PLJKWVXIÀFHDVWKHRQO\LPDJ
LQJWHFKQLTXHIRUVWDJLQJDQGUHVWDJLQJ+'VSDULQJDGGLFWHGUDGLDWLRQEXUGHQDQG
LRGLQDWHFRQWUDVWDGPLQLVWUDWLRQWRWKHSDWLHQWDQGUHVHUYLQJFH&7IRUVHOHFWHGFDVHV
%
3URJQRVWLFYDOXHRIUHVLGXDO&7PDVVHVLQ+'SDWLHQWVZLWKD
QHJDWLYH)'*3(7DIWHUFKHPRUDGLRWKHUDS\
00DJDJQROL(/RSFL05RGDUL.0DU]R/*LRUGDQR)5/XWPDQ
$$QDVWDVLD$6DQWRUR$&KLWL5R]]DQR,7 HJHVWDORSFL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RSURSHUO\GHÀQHWKHQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIUHVLGXDO&7PDVVHV
LQ+'SDWLHQWVZLWK3(7QHJDWLYHDWWKHHQGRIWUHDWPHQWDQGGHÀQHLWVFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWKGLVHDVHIUHHVXUYLYDO ')6
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RURXUVWXG\ZHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGGDWDGHULYLQJ
IURPSDWLHQWV Q 0) PHGLDQDJH\HDUV ZKRXQGHUZHQW)'*
3(7DQG&7VFDQDWWKHHQGRIWUHDWPHQW)RUVWXG\SXUSRVHZHLGHQWLÀHGWKRVH
SUHVHQWLQJDQHJDWLYH3(7VFDQDQGDUHVLGXDOPDVVRQ&7SDWLHQWVDIWHUÀUVW
OLQHWUHDWPHQWZKLOHDIWHUVDOYDJHWKHUDS\$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHIROORZHGXSIRUD
PHGLDQSHULRGRIPRQWKV
5HVXOWV7KHÀYH\HDU')6IRU3(7&79V3(7&7SDWLHQWVZDVDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ S 7KHSURJQRVLVRIUHVLGXDOPDVVDW&7VFDQZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ZRUVHDOVRZKHQFRQVLGHULQJWKHGLPHQVLRQRIWKHPDVVHVWKHODUJHU
WKHPDVVWKHORZHUWKH')6 S $QRSWLPDOFXWRIISRLQWZDVLGHQWLÀHG
ZLWKUHJDUGWRPD[LPDOGLDPHWHUQDPHO\FP:KHQLQWURGXFLQJWKLVFXWRIIWKH
')6LQWKLVVHWWLQJRISDWLHQWVZDVYV S $OVRRWKHUSRWHQWLDO
SURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVKDYHEHHQDQDO\VHG QXPEHURIPDVVHVÀUVW9VVDOYDJHWUHDW
PHQWSURJUDPVH[EXON\GLVHDVH%V\PSWRPV EXWDPRQJWKHPQRFRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWK'6)RURYHUDOOVXUYLYDO 26 HPHUJHG
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHGDWDVXJJHVWWKDWWKHSUHVHQFHRIUHVLGXDOPDVVLQGHSHQG
HQWO\IURPWKH)'*3(7UHVXOWVKRXOGEHFDUHIXOO\IROORZHGXSDQGWKHSDWLHQWV
VKRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGDWDQLQFUHDVHGULVNIRUUHODSVHSURJUHVVLRQRIWKHGLVHDVH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI3(705YHUVXV3(7&7LQ
WKHDEGRPHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[W\VL[RQFRORJLFSDWLHQWV PHDQDJH ZHUHH[DPLQHG
RQD72)3(7&7DQG705SODWIRUP *('LVFRYHU\ UHVSHFWLYHO\ LQWH
JUDWHGE\DVKXWWOHV\VWHP8QHQKDQFHG&7DQG7Z /$9$ '*5(LPDJHVRIWKH
DEGRPHQZHUHDFTXLUHGFRUHJLVWHUHGZLWK3(7GDWDDQGDQDO\VHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\
E\WZRGRXEOHERDUGFHUWLÀHGUDGLRORJLVWVQXFOHDUSK\VLFLDQV3(7SRVLWLYHOHVLRQV
ZHUHFKDUDFWHULVHGDW&7DQG05XVLQJDSRLQWVFDOHWRJUDGHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQG
OHVLRQFRQVSLFXLW\&RKHQѣVWDWLVWLFVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIRULQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQW
DQGWKH:LOFR[RQUDQNVXPWHVWZDVHPSOR\HGIRULQWUDREVHUYHUFRQVSLFXLW\JUDGLQJ
5HVXOWV$WRWDORI3(7SRVLWLYHOHVLRQVZHUHHYDOXDWHGLQWKHOLYHU Q
ERQH Q O\PSKQRGHV Q OXQJ Q *,WUDFW Q VRIWWLVVXHV Q
SOHXUD Q DGUHQDOJODQGV Q SDQFUHDV Q VSOHHQ Q SHULWRQHXP Q
FKHVWZDOO Q DQGEUHDVW Q /HVLRQVZHUHFKDUDFWHULVHGDQGJUDGHGEDVHGRQ
FRQVSLFXLW\LQ&7DQG05ZLWKJRRG ѣ DQGPRGHUDWH ѣ LQWHUREVHUYHU
DJUHHPHQW UHVSHFWLYHO\ ,Q WKH RYHUDOO OHVLRQEDVHG FRPSDULVRQ QR VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQG+RZHYHULQWKHRUJDQEDVHGFRPSDULVRQ05SHUIRUPHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUWKDQ&7LQWKHOLYHU SIRUERWKUHDGHUV ZKLOH&7WHQGHG
WRSHUIRUPEHWWHUWKDQ05LQGHSLFWLQJEDVDOOXQJOHVLRQV SDQGS
&RQFOXVLRQ8QHQKDQFHG3(705RXWSHUIRUPVXQHQKDQFHG3(7&7LQWKHGHSLF
WLRQDQGFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIOLYHUOHVLRQV+RZHYHULQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIH[WUDKHSDWLF
DEGRPLQDOSDWKRORJ\LQRQFRORJLFSDWLHQWVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHVHV
PRGDOLWLHVLVVHHQ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&RPSDULVRQRI053(7DQG3(7&7LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRISXOPRQDU\
PDVVHV
&6FKUDPO+6FKPLGW&%UHQGOH$6DXWHU00XHOOHU&3IDQQHQEHUJ
&'&ODXVVHQ1)6FKZHQ]HU7ELQJHQ'(
3XUSRVH&RPSDULVRQRIWKHK\EULGPRGDOLWLHV053(7DQG3(7&7LQWKHDV
VHVVPHQW RI SXOPRQDU\ OHVLRQV UHJDUGLQJ )'*XSWDNH OHVLRQ FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ
DQGWXPRXUVWDJLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\ZDVDSSURYHGE\WKHORFDOHWKLFVFRPPLWWHH
7HQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGRUSURYHQEURQFKLDOFDUFLQRPDZHUHHYDOXDWHG05
3(7ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKDQHZK\EULGZKROHERG\V\VWHPFRQVLVWLQJRID705
VFDQQHUZLWKDQLQWHJUDWHG3(7V\VWHP5HVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRWKRVHJDLQHG
E\ D GLUHFWO\ SUHFHGLQJ > )@)'*3(7&7 6HJPHQWDWLRQEDVHG DWWHQXDWLRQ
FRUUHFWLRQRI3(7GDWDUHFRUGHGLQ053(7ZDVFRQGXFWHGZLWK',;21EDVHG
IDWZDWHUVHSDUDWLRQ7XPRXUDQGO\PSKQRGHVWDJLQJEDVHGRQ3(7&7DQG05
3(7VWXGLHVZDVSHUIRUPHGE\WZRUHDGHUVLQFRQVHQVXV7XPRXUWROLYHU 7/
UDWLRVFDOFXODWHGLQ053(7DQG3(7&7ZHUHFRPSDUHG6WDWLVWLFDOWHVWLQJZDV
FDUULHGRXWXVLQJ3HDUVRQҋVFRUUHODWLRQDQG%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWVGLDJQRVWLF053(7LPDJHTXDOLW\ZLWKJRRGWXPRXUGHOLQH
DWLRQZDVDFKLHYHG0RVWOHVLRQV VKRZHGDSURQRXQFHG)'*XSWDNH2QH
OHVLRQZDVPRUSKRORJLFDOO\VXVSLFLRXVIRUPDOLJQDQF\LQ&7DQG05,EXWVKRZHG
QR )'* XSWDNH 053(7 VKRZHG KLJKHU 7/ UDWLRV WKDQ 3(7&7 YV
KRZHYHUVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQUHJDUGLQJ7/UDWLRZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ
ERWKVFDQQHUV U S 710VFRUHGLVFUHSDQFLHVRFFXUUHGLQ
SDWLHQWVPDLQO\GXHWRPRGDOLW\LQKHUHQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQOHVLRQVVL]HPHDVXUHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ053(7LPDJLQJRIWKHOXQJLVIHDVLEOHDQGSURYLGHVGLDJQRVWLFLP
DJHTXDOLW\LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIOXQJPDVVHV6LPLODUOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQDQG
WXPRXUVWDJHZDVIRXQGFRPSDULQJ3(7&7DQG053(7LQWKHPDMRULW\RISDWLHQWV
%
7KHLPSDFWRIDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHRQLPDJHLQZKROHERG\))'*
3(7&7IRUFDQFHUVWDJLQJ
'+DXVPDQQ''LQWHU626FK|QEHUJ-%UDGH06DGLFN.%XHVLQJ
0DQQKHLP'( GDQLHOKDXVPDQQ#XPPGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHLPSDFWRIDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHRQLPDJHTXDOLW\OHVLRQGHWHF
WLRQUDWHVWDQGDUGXSWDNHYDOXHVDQGOHVLRQYROXPHLQ)ÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVH
SRVLWURQHPLVVLRQWRPRJUDSK\ ))'*3(7 LQFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2YHUDWLPHSHULRGRIPRQWKVFDQFHUSDWLHQWVZHUH
LQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\,QWKHVHSDWLHQWVDWRWDORIOHVLRQVZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWO\
HYDOXDWHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWV H[SHULHQFHGDQGEHJLQQHU $ZKROHERG\))'*
3(7FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\VFDQZLWKPLQDQGPLQDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHSHUEHG
SRVLWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGLQHDFKSDWLHQW/HVLRQVZHUHYLVXDOO\LGHQWLÀHGDQGOHVLRQ
ORFDWLRQV FRPSDUHG /HVLRQ YROXPHV DQG VWDQGDUG XSWDNH YDOXHV 689 RI WKH
SULPDU\WXPRXUO\PSKQRGHVDQGPHWDVWDVHVZHUHREWDLQHGDQGFRPSDUHG)RU
DOOSDUDPHWHUVLQWHUUDWHUDJUHHPHQWZDVDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV$OO UHOHYDQW OHVLRQV ZHUH LGHQWLÀDEOH DW ERWK DFTXLVLWLRQ WLPHV ,PDJH
TXDOLW\ ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ UHGXFHG LQ VFDQV ZLWK DQ DFTXLVLWLRQ WLPH RI PLQ
S 1HYHUWKHOHVVWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVUDWHGH[FHOOHQWJRRGLQRI
WKHVFDQVZLWKDQDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHRIPLQ7KHTXDOLW\RIOHVLRQYLVXDOLVDWLRQZDV
H[FHOOHQWUHJDUGOHVVRIWKHDFTXLVLWLRQWLPH/HVLRQYROXPHRQ3(7LPDJHVDQG
689PD[ZHUHQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQERWKDFTXLVLWLRQWLPHV S
,QWHUUDWHUDJUHHPHQWZDVJRRG Ƌ!
&RQFOXVLRQ'HVSLWHVLJQLÀFDQWGHFUHDVHLQLPDJHTXDOLW\DUHGXFWLRQRIDFTXLVL
WLRQWLPHSHUEHGSRVLWLRQVHHPVWREHFOLQLFDOO\IHDVLEOHZLWKRXWUHGXFWLRQRIWKH
OHVLRQGHWHFWLRQUDWHHYHQIRUOHVVH[SHULHQFHGREVHUYHUV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP)
*HQLWRXULQDU\
66
7UDQVSODQWLPDJLQJDQGVSHFLDOWRSLFV
0RGHUDWRUV
3+DOOVFKHLGW+HLGHOEHUJ'(
-c-DNREVHQ2VOR12
%
3UHRSHUDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIOLYLQJUHQDOWUDQVSODQWGRQRUVZLWK
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\YHUVXVPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
DQJLRJUDSK\LQSDWLHQWV
)(QJHONHQ))ULHGHUVGRUII%+DPP*'LHGHULFKV
%HUOLQ'( ÁRULDQHQJHONHQ#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHPRGHUQPXOWLVOLFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$
ZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ 05$ LQWKHSUHRSHUDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRI
YDVFXODUDQDWRP\RIOLYLQJUHQDOWUDQVSODQWGRQRUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVUHQDOWUDQVSODQWGRQRUVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKERWKD
PRGHUQPXOWLVOLFH&7VFDQQHU PPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV DQGD705,VFDQQHU
NLGQH\VZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKH&7$DQG05$DQDO\VLV5HQDOYDVFXODWXUHZDV
HYDOXDWHGLQGHSHQGHQWO\E\WZRUHDGHUVLQHDFKPRGDOLW\ZLWKDGHOD\RIZHHNV
EHWZHHQUHDGLQJVHVVLRQV6XUJLFDOFRUUHODWLRQRQWKHRSHUDWHGVLGHZDVDYDLODEOH
LQDOOSDWLHQWV*ROGVWDQGDUGZDVGHÀQHGE\VXUJLFDOFRUUHODWLRQDQGFRQVHQVXV
UHDGLQJRIERWKPRGDOLWLHV
5HVXOWV7KHUHZHUHUHQDODUWHULHVDQGUHQDOYHLQVLQWRWDO6HQVLWLYLW\RI
&7$IRUDUWHULHVZDVDQGIRUUHDGHUVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\6HQVLWLY
LW\RI05$IRUDUWHULHVZDV0RVWRIWKHRYHUORRNHGDUWHULHVZHUH
PPGLDPHWHU UHDGHURILQ&7$DQGRILQ05$UHDGHURI
LQ&7$DQGRILQ05$ 6HQVLWLYLW\IRUDUWHULHV! PPZDVLQ
&7$DQGLQ05$6HQVLWLYLW\IRUYHLQVZDVLQ&7$DQG
LQ05$%RWKUHDGHUVPLVGLDJQRVHGEHWZHHQDQGQRQSUHVHQW
DUWHULHVDQGEHWZHHQDQGQRQSUHVHQWYHLQVLQERWKPRGDOLWLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ 0RGHUQ PXOWLVOLFH &7 DQG 05,VFDQQHUV DOORZ KLJKO\ DFFXUDWH
HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHYDVFXODUDQDWRP\RIOLYLQJUHQDOWUDQVSODQWGRQRUVHVSHFLDOO\IRU
YHVVHOVRI! PPGLDPHWHU&7$PD\SURYLGHVOLJKWO\EHWWHUGHSLFWLRQRIYHU\
VPDOODUWHULHVKRZHYHUWKLVPD\EHUHDGHUGHSHQGHQW
%
'LDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJ
SURWRFROIRUSRWHQWLDOOLYLQJUHODWHGNLGQH\GRQRUV
*'3XLSSH6%DXPXHOOHU+$ONDGKL73IDPPDWWHU5+XQ]LNHU
06FKLHVVHU53*RHWWL=XULFK&+ JLOEHUWSXLSSH#XV]FK
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05 LPDJLQJSURWRFROIRUSUHRSHUDWLYHVFUHHQLQJRIOLYLQJ
UHODWHGNLGQH\GRQRUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\FRQVHFXWLYHVXEMHFWV PHDQDJH\HDUV
UDQJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQW05LPDJLQJZLWK7ZHLJKWHGVHTXHQFHV FRURQDO
DQGD[LDOSODQH ZLWKDQRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGUHVSLUDWRU\JDWHG'VWHDG\VWDWH
IUHH SUHFHVVLRQ 66)3 DQJLRJUDSK\ 1&(05$ VHTXHQFH DQG ZLWK FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHDQJLRJUDSK\ &(05$ VHTXHQFHVLQWKHDUWHULDO
DQG YHQRXV SKDVH 7ZR EOLQGHG UHDGHUV LQGHSHQGHQWO\ DVVHVVHG DUWHULDO DQG
YHQRXVDQDWRP\DQGSRWHQWLDONLGQH\OHVLRQV5HVXOWVRIQRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
LPDJHVZHUHFRPSDUHGWR&(05$DQGLQDVXEJURXSRIVXEMHFWVWRVXUJHU\
DVVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV 5HJDUGLQJ DUWHULDO DQDWRP\ 1&(05$ \LHOGHG VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\
DQGDFFXUDF\RIDQGFRPSDUHGWR&(05$7KUHHNLGQH\VZHUH
IRXQGWRKDYHPRUHDFFHVVRU\UHQDODUWHULHVDW1&(05$EXWQRWDW&(05$,Q
WKHVXEJURXSRIVXEMHFWVRQHVXUJLFDOO\SURYHQDFFHVVRU\DUWHU\ZDVGHSLFWHG
ZLWK1&(05$EXWQRWZLWK&(05$$FFXUDF\RI7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVUHJDUGLQJ
DFFHVVRU\YHLQVRUYDULDQWYHQRXVFRXUVHZDVZLWKRQHPLVVHGFLUFXPDRUWLF
YHLQDW7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHV7ZRVLPSOHF\VWVZHUHPLVVHGRQ7ZHLJKWHGDQG
1&(05$EXWQRWRQ&(05$LPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ$QRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJSURWRFROLQFOXGLQJ1&(05$
DQG7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDOORZVIRUWKHDFFXUDWHVFUHHQLQJRIOLYLQJUHODWHGNLGQH\
GRQRUVDQGPD\VHUYHDVDQDOWHUQDWLYHWR&(05$
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'LIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ '7, IRUIXQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQWRI
WUDQVSODQWHGNLGQH\VDW7
56/DQ]PDQ$/MLPDQL*3HQWDQJ3.URSLO3+HXVFK)50LHVH
'%ORQGLQ*$QWRFK+-:LWWVDFN'VVHOGRUI'( URWHPVKORPR#\DKRRGH
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ
'7, IRUIXQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQWRIWUDQVSODQWHGNLGQH\VDW7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVUHQDOWUDQVSODQWUHFLSLHQWV PHDQDJH
\HDUV ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\DQGH[DPLQHGRQD705VFDQQHUXVLQJDERG\
DUUD\FRLO5HFLSLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWZRJURXSVDFFRUGLQJWRDOORJUDIWIXQFWLRQ
JURXSDSDWLHQWVZLWKJRRGDOORJUDIWIXQFWLRQ *)5!POPLQPò JURXSE
SDWLHQWVZLWKSRRUDOORJUDIWIXQFWLRQ *)5POPLQPò 7KH'7,VHTXHQFH
ZDVDFTXLUHGLQWKHFRURQDOSODQHZLWKEYDOXHV VPP
DQGGLUHFWLRQ )29PPPDWUL[VOLFHWKLFNQHVVPPVOLFHV75
7(PV )$ IUDFWLRQDODQLVRWURS\ DQG$'& DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
PDSVZHUHFDOFXODWHGDQGD52,EDVHGDQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV 0HDQ )$ RI WKH UHQDO PHGXOOD ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU LQ JURXS D
DVFRPSDUHGWRJURXSE )XUWKHUPRUHPHDQ$'&YDOXHV
RIWKHUHQDOFRUWH[DQGPHGXOODZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQJURXSD
DQG PPòVUHVSHFWLYHO\ WKDQ LQ JURXS E
DQG PPòV UHVSHFWLYHO\ 0HGXOODU\ )$ YDOXHV FRUUHODWHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKDOORJUDIWIXQFWLRQDVDVVHVVHGE\*)5 U
&RQFOXVLRQ'7,LVDSURPLVLQJQRQHQKDQFHGWHFKQLTXHIRUIXQFWLRQDOHYDOXDWLRQ
RIUHQDODOORJUDIWV)$YDOXHVRIWKHUHQDOPHGXOODFRUUHODWHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKDO
ORJUDIWIXQFWLRQ)XUWKHUVWXGLHVDUHUHTXLUHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHFOLQLFDOYDOXHRI'7,
IRUPRQLWRULQJWUDQVSODQWHGNLGQH\V
%
':,ZLWKPRQRDQGELH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLVLQNLGQH\VDOORJUDIWV
HDUO\DIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
81DYDUUR05DYDQHOOL35L]]DUGL66DQGULQL50DUROGL%UHVFLD,7
QDYDUURXJR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH LI ':,UHODWHG SDUDPHWHUV REWDLQHG E\ PRQR DQG EL
H[SRQHQWLDO DQDO\VLV HDUO\ DIWHU WUDQVSODQWDWLRQ FRUUHODWH ZLWK NLGQH\ DOORJUDIWV
IXQFWLRQDQGELRSV\UHVXOWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\WZRFRQVHFXWLYHNLGQH\DOORJUDIWUHFLSLHQWVZHUH
H[DPLQHGE\05EHWZHHQDQGGD\VDIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ05SURWRFROLQFOXGHG
(3':,VHTXHQFHVZLWKEYDOXHV VPP ':,52,PHDVXUHPHQWZHUH
SHUIRUPHG E\ WZR UDGLRORJLVWV ZLWK GLIIHUHQW H[SHULHQFH LQ DEGRPLQDO 05 2QH
UDGLRORJLVWDQDO\VHGWZLFHWHQGDWDVHWVWRDVVHVVWKHLQWUDREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\':,
UHODWHGSDUDPHWHUVZHUH$'& PRQRH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLV GLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
' DQGSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ I ELH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLV )RXUWHHQDOORJUDIWVVKRZHG
QRUPDOIXQFWLRQUHFRYHU\SDWLHQWVZLWKGHOD\HGIXQFWLRQUHFRYHU\XQGHUZHQW
ELRSV\ KDG DFXWH UHMHFWLRQ $5 KDG DFXWH WXEXODU QHFURVLV $71
DQG RQH SUHVHQWHG VSHFLÀF ÀQGLQJV7WHVW ZDV XVHG WR FRPSDUH PHDQ YDOXHV
EHWZHHQ SDWLHQWV JURXSV ,QWHU DQG LQWUDREVHUYHU YDULDELOLW\ ZDV DVVHVVHG E\
%ODQG$OWPDQWHVW
5HVXOWV$'&'DQGIYDOXHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S KLJKHULQQRUPDOIXQFWLRQ
DOORJUDIWV [PPV[PPV FRPSDUHG
WRWKHLPSDLUHGIXQFWLRQJURXS [PPV[PPV
&RPSDUHGZLWKWKH$71WKH$5KDGORZHU' YV[
PPV $'& YV[PPV DQGI YV
7KHWKUHHSDWLHQWVZLWKLPSDLUHGUHQDOIXQFWLRQZLWKRXW$5RU$71KDG$'&YDOXHV
JUHDWHUWKDQWKH$71JURXS YV[PPV ,QWUDDQGLQWHU
REVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\ZDVDGHTXDWH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDW':,FRXOGUHSUHVHQWDUHOL
DEOHQRQLQYDVLYHWRROWRHYDOXDWHWKHDOORJUDIWVWDWXVHDUO\DIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
%LH[SRQHQWLDO DQDO\VLV LV IHDVLEOH DQG XVHIXO WR FRQÀUP WKH UHVXOWV RI PRQR
H[SRQHQWLDO DQDO\VLV 'LIIHUHQWLDWLRQ EHWZHHQ$5 DQG$71 FULWLFDO IRU SDWLHQWV
PDQDJHPHQWVHHPVWREHIHDVLEOH
4XDQWLWDWLYH&7LPDJLQJRIUHQDOSHUIXVLRQIRUDVVHVVPHQWRIUHQDO
DOORJUDIWG\VIXQFWLRQ
$+HOFN)6FKRHQ86FKRHQHUPDUFN0:HVVHO\0)LVFKHUHGHU
(.ORW]05HLVHU.1LNRODRX&%HFNHU0XQLFK'(
)RUFKKHLP'( DQGUHDVKHOFN#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIDTXDQWLWDWLYH&7SHUIXVLRQWHFKQLTXHIRUWKH
GLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVEHWZHHQUHQDODOORJUDIWVZLWKDFXWHWXEXODUQHFURVLV $71
DQGJUDIWUHMHFWLRQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
&RPSDULVRQRIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,DQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFÀQGLQJV
LQNLGQH\WUDQVSODQWSDWLHQWVZLWKGHWHULRUDWLQJUHQDOIXQFWLRQ
36WHLJHU0,WK0*XJJHU$.UXVH-)U|KOLFK'&KRQJ+7KRHQ\
%HUQH&+
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, ':05, FDQEHXVHG
WR VWUDWLI\ SDWLHQWV IRU ELRSV\ %, RU IROORZXS )8 EDVHG RQ YDULRXV GLIIXVLRQ
SDUDPHWHUV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KLUW\ILYH FRQVHFXWLYH NLGQH\ WUDQVSODQW SDWLHQWV
ZP ZLWKGHWHULRUDWLQJUHQDOIXQFWLRQXQGHUZHQW':05, (3,VHTXHQFHWHQ
EYDOXHVVPP RQD7HVOD05VFDQQHU 6LHPHQV6RQDWD ZLWKLQWHQ
GD\VEHIRUHRUDIWHUELRSV\':05,GDWDZHUHSURFHVVHGDSSO\LQJHLWKHUPRQR
H[SRQHQWLDO \LHOGLQJ$'&YDOXHV>[PPV@ RUELH[SRQHQWLDOÀWWLQJ \LHOGLQJ
YDOXHVIRUSXUHGLIIXVLRQ$'&'>[PPV@DQGSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ)3>@ ,IUHQDO
ELRSV\\LHOGHGDWOHDVWRQHUHVXOWZLWKDGLUHFWLPSOLFDWLRQIRUFOLQLFDOPDQDJHPHQW
HJUHMHFWLRQSDWLHQWVZHUHDVVLJQHGWRWKH%,JURXS6WDWLVWLFDOHYDOXDWLRQZDV
SHUIRUPHGXVLQJ67$7$DQGYDOXHVDUHJLYHQDVPHDQ6(08QSDLUHGWWHVWVZHUH
XVHGWRFRPSDUHWKH':05,SDUDPHWHUVEHWZHHQ%,DQG)8JURXS
5HVXOWV2IWKHSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQWUHQDODOORJUDIWELRSV\ZHUHFODVVLÀHG
LQWRWKH%,JURXSDQGLQWRWKH)8JURXS+LVWRSDWKRORJLFÀQGLQJVLQWKH%,JURXS
LQFOXGHGFHOOXODUUHMHFWLRQ Q KXPRUDOUHMHFWLRQ Q JORPHUXORQHSKULWLV Q
,*$QHSKURSDWK\ Q %.YLUXVQHSKURSDWK\ Q DFXWHWXEXODUQHFURVLV Q
F\FORVSRULQHWR[LFLW\ Q DQGFKURQLFDOORJUDIWQHSKURSDWK\ Q ZKHUHDVÀQG
LQJV LQ WKH )8JURXS LQFOXGHG FKURQLF FKDQJHV VXFK DV YDVFXODU RU JORPHUXODU
VFOHURVLVÀEURVLVDWURSK\RUPLQRULQWHUVWLWLDOLQÁDPPDWLRQ':05,SDUDPHWHUV
RIWKH%,JURXSZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUFRPSDUHGWRWKH)8JURXS$'& YV
S $'&' YVS DQGSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQ
)3 YVS UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ':05,LQNLGQH\WUDQVSODQWSDWLHQWVZLWKGHWHULRUDWHGUHQDOIXQF
WLRQPLJKWLPSURYHWKHGLDJQRVWLFZRUNXSE\VWUDWLI\LQJSDWLHQWVIRUUHQDOELRSV\
%
+LJKÀHOG05,LQDVVHVVPHQWRIPXULQHSODFHQWDOIXQFWLRQDO
PRUSKRORJ\DQGFRPSDULVRQWRKLVWRORJ\
&&0XFK(6RODQR7(UQVW-<DPDPXUD*$GDP3$UFN
8:HGHJDHUWQHU+DPEXUJ'( FPXFK#XNHGH
3XUSRVH 7R GDWH LQVLJKWV RQ SODFHQWDO DUFKLWHFWXUH DUH DFKLHYHG E\ WHGLRXV
KLVWRPRUSKRORJLFDODQDO\VLV7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWH05,DVD
WRROWRH[DPLQHSODFHQWDOPRUSKRORJ\LQDPXULQHPRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05,,PDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGRQIRUPDOLQÀ[HGDQG
JDGROLQLXPWUHDWHGPRXVHSODFHQWDVRQD7DQLPDOVFDQQHU &OLQ6FDQ%UXNHU
XVLQJD7ZHLJKWHG'76(VHTXHQFHSODFHQWDVZHUHWDNHQIURPSUHQDWDOO\
VWUHVVHG ZHOOHVWDEOLVKHGPRGHORIVRXQGFKDOOHQJH IRHWXVHVDQGSODFHQWDV
VHUYHGDVFRQWUROV7RWDOSODFHQWDOYROXPHDQGYROXPHRIIXQFWLRQDO]RQHV MXQFWLRQDO
]RQHDQGODE\ULQWK ZDVFDOFXODWHG)RUFRPSDULVRQIRUPDOLQÀ[HGDQGSDUDIÀQ
HPEHGGHGSODFHQWDV VWUHVVHGFRQWUROV ZHUHPRUSKRORJLFDOO\DVVHVVHG
IRUIXQFWLRQDO]RQHVXSRQKLVWRORJ\E\DQH[SHULHQFHGIHWRPDWHUQDOSDWKRORJLVW
DFFRUGLQJWRWKHWRGDWHҊJROGVWDQGDUGSURWRFROҋIRUSODFHQWDODQDO\VHV'LIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQJURXSVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\0DQQ:KLWQH\8WHVW
5HVXOWV3ODFHQWDOIXQFWLRQDO]RQHVFRXOGEHHDVLO\LGHQWLÀHGZLWK05,)XUWKHU
SODFHQWDOIXQFWLRQDODOWHUDWLRQVFRXOGEHGHWHFWHGDVWLVVXHIURPSUHQDWDOO\VWUHVVHG
PLFHGLVSOD\HGDELDVWRZDUGVDQLQFUHDVHGODE\ULQWK]RQH UDWLRYVFRQ
WUROV S ZKLOVW WKH RYHUDOO SODFHQWDO YROXPH UHPDLQHG XQDOWHUHG7KHVH
REVHUYDWLRQVFRXOGEHLQGHSHQGHQWO\DSSUHFLDWHGXSRQKLVWRORJLFDODVVHVVPHQW
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
%
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUG
DSSURYDOSDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJIURPDFXWHXQH[SODLQHGNLGQH\DOORJUDIWG\VIXQFWLRQ
ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\$G\QDPLFPXOWLSKDVH&7DQJLRJUDSK\SURWRFRO
VOLFH&7VFDQQHUSKDVHVWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQV LQFOXGLQJWKHHQWLUHUHQDO
JUDIWZDVSHUIRUPHGWRH[FOXGHSRVWRSHUDWLYHRUYDVFXODUFRPSOLFDWLRQV'\QDPLF
&7GDWDZHUHXVHGIRUWKHFDOFXODWLRQRISDUHQFK\PDOEORRGÁRZDQGSDUHQFK\PDO
EORRGYROXPHXVLQJGHGLFDWHGVRIWZDUH5HQDOELRSV\ Q RUFOLQLFDOIROORZXS
Q VHUYHGDVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV 5HQDO SDUHQFK\PDO EORRG ÁRZ YDOXHV ZHUH VXEVWDQWLDOO\ ORZHU LQ DO
ORJUDIWV ZLWK DFXWH UHMHFWLRQ PO POPLQ Q FRPSDUHG WR$71
POPOPLQQ ,QDGGLWLRQUHQDOSDUHQFK\PDOEORRGYROXPHZDV
UHGXFHGLQFDVHRIUHQDOJUDIWUHMHFWLRQ POPO FRPSDUHGWRVXEMHFWV
VXIIHULQJIURP$71 POPO
&RQFOXVLRQ&7SHUIXVLRQKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRLPSURYHDVVHVVPHQWRIUHQDODO
ORJUDIWG\VIXQFWLRQ
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWLQYLWURLPDJLQJRIPXULQH
SODFHQWDOIXQFWLRQDOPRUSKRORJ\ZLWK05,LVIHDVLEOHDQGUHVXOWVDUHFRPSDUDEOH
WRWLPHFRQVXPLQJKLVWRORJLFDODQDO\VLV
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJLGHQWLÀHV
KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOFKDQJHVLQDUDWPRGHORIGLDEHWLFQHSKURSDWK\
.+XHSHU'+DUWXQJ0*XWEHUOHW):DFNHU+6DQQ%+XVHQ
'5HLFKH+DQQRYHU'(%DUVEWWHO'(6DDUEUFNHQ'(,QJHOKHLP'(
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHZKHWKHUPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05 GLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ
'7, DOORZVDVVHVVPHQWRIUHQDOSDWKRORJLHVLQDUDWPRGHORIGLDEHWLFQHSKURSDWK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\RQH6SUDJXH'DZOH\UDWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWKUHH
JURXSVFRQWUROVGLDEHWHV '0 GLDEHWHVZLWKXQLQHSKUHFWRP\ '081; 81;LV
NQRZQWRDFFHOHUDWHUHQDOLPSDLUPHQW(LJKWZHHNVDIWHUGLDEHWHVLQGXFWLRQZLWK
VWUHSWR]RWRFLQ05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQD7VFDQQHUXVLQJDQFKDQQHOZULVW
FRLO0RUSKRORJLFDOLPDJHVDQGHFKRSODQDU'7,ZHUHREWDLQHG E VPP
GLIIXVLRQGLUHFWLRQV 5HQDO$'&DQGIUDFWLRQDODQLVWRWURSK\ )$ ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
IRUHDFKRIWKHGLIIHUHQWOD\HUVRIWKHNLGQH\,PDJLQJUHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGWR
ODERUDWRU\SDUDPHWHUVDQGKLVWRORJ\
5HVXOWV$OO GLDEHWLF DQLPDOV GHYHORSHG VLJQLÀFDQW K\SHUJO\FHPLD DQG K\SRLQ
VXOLQHPLD$OEXPLQXULDDQGKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOFKDQJHVZHUHPRUHSURQRXQFHGLQ
'081;$'&YDOXHVZHUHQRWGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQJURXSVH[FHSWIRUFRUWLFDO$'&
ZKLFKZDVKLJKHULQ'081;WKDQLQFRQWUROV)$RIGLIIHUHQWOD\HUVRIWKHNLGQH\
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHGLQ'081;ZKHQFRPSDUHGWRFRQWUROVDQGWR'0JURXS
,Q'0ZLWKRXW81;RQO\FRUWLFDO)$ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQLQFRQWUROV&RUWLFDO
)$QHJDWLYHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKJORPHUXORVFOHURVLV S5 ,QDQLPDOV
ZLWKWXEXORLQWHUVWLWLDOÀEURVLVDQGWXEXODUHQODUJHPHQW)$ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHG
LQFRPSDULVRQWRDQLPDOVZLWKRXWWKRVHÀQGLQJV
&RQFOXVLRQ05 '7,LGHQWLÀHG UHQDO SDWKRORJLHV RIGLDEHWLF QHSKURSDWK\ VXFK
DV JORPHUXORVFOHURVLV LQWHUVWLWLDO ÀEURVLV DQG WXEXODU GDPDJH E\ UHGXFWLRQ RI
)$'0DQG'081;DQLPDOVUHSUHVHQWLQJGLIIHUHQWVWDJHVRIGLVHDVHFRXOGEH
GLIIHUHQWLDWHG7KXV'7,PD\ EH YDOXDEOH IRUGHWHFWLRQ DQG PRQLWRULQJ RIUHQDO
QHSKURSDWK\LQGLDEHWLFSDWLHQWV
%
05J)86WUHDWPHQWIRUXWHULQHP\RPDVVDIHW\HIIHFWLYHQHVVDQG
SDWKRJHQHVLV
<.XUDVKYLOL$6WHSDQRY9%\WFKHQNR(.XODEXFKRYD2%DWDUFKLQD
,/XJLQD0RVFRZ58 OHUL#PHFRP
3XUSRVH &OLQLFDO VDIHW\ HYDOXDWLRQ RI 05J)86 WUHDWPHQW IRU XWHULQH ÀEURLGV
5HWURVSHFWLYH DQG SURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ SDWLHQWV VXIIHULQJ XWHUXV ÀEURP\RPD
KDGXQGHUZHQW05J)86WUHDWPHQWVLQFH0DUFKIRU0DUFK,JURXS
UDQGRPLVHGLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWV,,JURXSSDWLHQWVDFFRUGLQJWRSDWLHQWVHOHFWLRQ
FULWHULD)ROORZXSSHULRGXSWR\HDUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6WDQGDUGDQGVSHFLI\LQJ&OLQLFDOHIIHFWZDVPHDVXUHGLQ
VFRUHVXVLQJ7KH3LFWRULDO%ORRG$VVHVVPHQW&KDUW +LJKDP-DQVVHQ 8)642/
FKDUWDQG0F*LOOSDLQTXHVWLRQQDLUH05J)86DEODWLRQSURFHGXUHVZHUHFRQGXFWHG
XVLQJ([$EODWHV\VWHP ,Q6LJKWHF ,VUDHO JXLGHGE\05,>>8QVXSSRUWHG
&KDUDFWHU @@ *(86$
5HVXOWV5HVXOWVRIWKHVWXG\SURYHG05J)86WHFKQRORJ\WREHDVDIHHQRXJK
PHWKRGIRUWUHDWPHQWRIXWHUXVÀEURP\RPD&RPSOLFDWLRQVDQGDGYHUVHHIIHFWV
ZHUHUHYHDOHGLQWKHFRXUVHRIÀUVWWZR\HDUVRIWKHPHWKRGҋVFOLQLFDOXVHDQG
FDVHV RIWKHVHZHUHWHPSHUDWXUHLQGXFHGOHVLRQRIWKHVPDOOLQWHVWLQH
WHPSHUDWXUHLQGXFHGORFDORHGHPDRIWKHDQWHULRUDEGRPLQDOZDOO ZLWKRXW
EXUQ VFLDWLFD SDVVDJHRI)86GHWULWXVYLDXWHULQHERG\FDY
LW\ 7KHUHZHUHQRFRPSOLFDWLRQVDIWHUZDUGVSURYLGHGSDWLHQWVHOHFWLRQ
FULWHULDZHUHXVHG
&RQFOXVLRQ'HVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDWWKHPHWKRGLVVXIÀFLHQWO\VDIHDQGKDVDVKRUWOLVW
RIUDUHFRPSOLFDWLRQVLWVKRXOGEHUHPHPEHUHGWKDWFXUDWLYHDJHQWRIWKHWHFKQRO
RJ\LVIRFXVHGFRDJXODWLQJXOWUDVRXQG3DWLHQWVHOHFWLRQFULWHULDDQGUHJXODWLRQV
JRYHUQLQJWKHSURFHGXUHVKRXOGEHIROORZHGVWULFWO\LQRUGHUWRSUHYHQWFRPSOLFD
WLRQVDQGDGYHUVHHIIHFWV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
'HWHFWLRQRIORFDOLVHGSURVWDWHFDQFHUXVLQJFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,
DQG&DFHWDWH3(7&7
,-DPERU5%RUUD-.HPSSDLQHQ9/HSRPNL.'HDQ.$ODQHQ01XUPL
+-$URQHQ+0LQQ7XUNX), LYMDPE#XWXÀ
3XUSRVH :H DVVHVVHG WKH DELOLW\ RI FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 05, DW 7HVOD DQG
&DFHWDWH 3(7&7 WR GHWHFW ORFDOLVHG SURVWDWH FDQFHU ,Q DGGLWLRQ IXVLRQ RI
&DFHWDWH3(7ZLWK05,ZDVSHUIRUPHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\VL[SDWLHQWV PHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH
\HDUV ZLWKXQWUHDWHGORFDOLVHGSURVWDWHFDQFHUZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHG$SHOYLF
&DFHWDWH3(7&7VFDQZDVSHUIRUPHGLQDOOSDWLHQWVDQGDFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
05,VFDQLQSDWLHQWV H[DPLQDWLRQVXVLQJERWKHQGRUHFWDOFRLODQGVXUIDFH
FRLOVDQGH[DPLQDWLRQVXVLQJVXUIDFHFRLOVRQO\ 2EWDLQHG3(7&7DQG05,
GDWDZHUHHYDOXDWHGYLVXDOO\DQGFRPSDUHGZLWKELRSV\ÀQGLQJVRQDOREDUOHYHO,Q
DGGLWLRQ3(7GDWDZHUHIXVHGZLWK05,GDWDXVLQJLQKRXVHGHYHORSHGVRIWZDUH
7KHOREHZLWKWKHKLJKHVWSHUFHQWDJHRIFDQFHULQELRSV\VDPSOHVZDVGHWHUPLQHG
WREHWKHGRPLQDQWOREH
5HVXOWV7KHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\IRUWKHYLVXDOGHWHFWLRQRISURVWDWH
FDQFHURQDOREDUOHYHOE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,ZHUHDQG&
DFHWDWH3(7&7ZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\)XVLRQRI3(7GDWDZLWK05,
LQFUHDVHGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RI
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHDFFXUDF\RIGRPLQDQWOREHGHWHFWLRQZDV
DQGIRUFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,3(7&7DQGIXVHG3(705,UHVSHF
WLYHO\0D[LPDODQGDYHUDJH689YDOXHVQRUPDOLVHGWREHQLJQVH[WDQWVFRUUHODWHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWK36$RQO\ S DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ)XVLRQRIVHTXHQWLDOO\REWDLQHG3(7&7DQG05,GDWDZDVIHDVLEOH
DQGVXSHULRULQORFDOLVDWLRQRISURVWDWHFDQFHUFRPSDUHGWRERWKLPDJLQJPRGDOL
WLHVDORQH
5RRP)
%UHDVW
66
05,VHTXHQFHVDGYDQFHVDQGDSSOLFDWLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
(7DKHUL7HKUDQ,5
6-9LQQLFRPEH'XQGHH8.
%
,QLWLDOPD[LPXPVORSHRIWKHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWYHUVXVWLPH
FXUYHIRUG\QDPLFHYDOXDWLRQRIEUHDVWOHVLRQVRQXOWUDIDVWEUHDVW05,
500DQQ5'00XV&*HSSHUW&30)UHQW]1.DUVVHPHLMHU
++XLVPDQ%3ODWHO1LMPHJHQ1/(UODQJHQ'( UPDQQ#UDGXPFQQO
3XUSRVH 0RGHUQ YLHZVKDULQJ VHTXHQFHV DOORZ G\QDPLF ZKROH EUHDVW 05, DW
GLDJQRVWLFVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQZLWKLQVHFRQGVVKRZLQJWKHLQÁRZRIFRQWUDVWLQ
EUHDVWDEQRUPDOLWLHV:HHYDOXDWHWKHPD[LPXPVORSHRILQLWLDOFRQWUDVWHQKDQFH
PHQWDVDKHXULVWLFSDUDPHWHUIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHQLJQIURPPDOLJQDQWGLVHDVH
DQGFRPSDUHLWVYDOXHWRFODVVLFWLPHSRLQWDQDO\VLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HHPSOR\HGDELWHPSRUDOEUHDVW05,SURWRFRORQD
705,XVLQJDFKDQQHOELODWHUDOEUHDVWFRLO+LJKUHVROXWLRQ9,%(DFTXLVLWLRQV
PPWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQV ZHUHLQWHUOHDYHGZLWKDVHULHVRIXOWUDIDVW
7:,67DFTXLVLWLRQV PPWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQV GXULQJWKHLQÁRZRIWKH
FRQWUDVWDJHQW)RUW\WZRFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKHQKDQFLQJDEQRUPDOLWLHV
EHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQW SUHVHQWLQJEHWZHHQ1RYHPEHUDQG-XO\ZHUH
LQFOXGHG:HPHDVXUHGWKHPD[LPXPVORSHRIWKHUHODWLYHHQKDQFHPHQWYHUVXVWLPH
FXUYHRQWKH7:,67DFTXLVLWLRQVDQGUHFRUGHGFXUYHW\SHRIWKHOHVLRQVRQWKH9,%(
DFTXLVLWLRQV52&DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGWRFRPSDUHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
5HVXOWV7KHPD[LPXPVORSHRIWKHUHODWLYHHQKDQFHPHQWYHUVXVWLPHFXUYHZDV
VLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHULQGLVFULPLQDWLQJEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWGLVHDVHWKDQ
WKHFXUYHW\SH $]YV$]S &XWRIIYDOXHVRIVHFDQG
VHF FDQ EH XVHG WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH KLJKULVN OHVLRQV ! PDOLJQDQFLHV
IURPLQWHUPHGLDWHDQGORZULVNOHVLRQV PDOLJQDQFLHV 7KLVVLPSOLÀFDWLRQ
\LHOGVDQ$]RI
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHLQLWLDOPD[LPXPVORSHSURYLGHVPRUHGLDJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQWKDQ
WKHFXUYHW\SHVDQGFDQWKHUHIRUHEHXVHGWRDVVHVVOHVLRQG\QDPLFV7KLVFDQ
VXEVWDQWLDOO\VKRUWHQFXUUHQWVFDQSURWRFROV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'LDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIDGHGLFDWHGEUHDVW05V\VWHPXVLQJ
VSLUDODFTXLVLWLRQV
6(+DUPV%-+LOOPDQ*6WHYHQV56WRXJK$+ROOLQJVZRUWK
..R]ORZVNL/0RVV)D\HWWHYLOOH$5863KLODGHOSKLD3$86
%DVWURS7;862NODKRPD&LW\2.86.QR[YLOOH7186:RUFHVWHU0$86
VHKDUPV#HDUWKOLQNQHW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIEUHDVW05,DWGHGLFDWHGEUHDVW
LPDJLQJFHQWHUVXVLQJDGHGLFDWHG7EUHDVW05V\VWHPWKDWHPSOR\HGKLJK
UHVROXWLRQKLJKFRQWUDVWVSLUDOWUDMHFWRU\DFTXLVLWLRQV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ DVVHVVHG GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH
IRUFRQVHFXWLYHVFUHHQLQJ Q DQGGLDJQRVWLF Q FDVHVSHUIRUPHG
IURP$SULOWR'HFHPEHUIRUZRPHQDJHGIURPIRXUVLWHVIRUZKLFK
GHGLFDWHGEUHDVW05,UHSRUWVDQGJURXQGWUXWK ELRSV\IRUFDQFHUFDVHVRQH\HDU
QHJDWLYHIROORZXSIRUQHJDWLYHFDVHV 7KHVWXG\ZDV,5%DSSURYHGDQG+,3$$
FRPSOLDQW7KHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQG52&IRUWKHEUHDVW05,PDPPRJUDSK\
DQGXOWUDVRXQGZHUHFDOFXODWHGDQGFRPSDUHGWRHDFKRWKHUWRGHWHUPLQHLIWKHUH
ZHUH VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ WKH PRGDOLWLHV ZLWK UHVSHFW WR
WKHVHSDUDPHWHUV
5HVXOWV7KHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRUWKHGHGLFDWHGEUHDVW05,V\VWHPZHUH
S DQG S )RUDOOFDVHVWKHQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXH 139 ZDV IRU VFUHHQLQJ FDVHV 7KH DUHD XQGHU WKH UHFHLYHU
RSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& FXUYHZDV2IWKHIDOVHSRVLWLYHVVHHQ
RQGHGLFDWHGEUHDVW05,WKLUWHHQ ZHUHKLJKULVNKLVWRORJLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ:HGHPRQVWUDWHKLJKGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQEUHDVW05,
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIWKHDELOLW\RISDUDPHWULFG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
05,DQGGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJWRGHWHFWEUHDVWPDOLJQDQFLHV
()XUPDQ+DUDQ0)HLQEHUJ6KDSLUR1:HLVHQEHUJ11LVVDQ
7=HKDYL'*UREJHOG((\DO+'HJDQL5HKRYRW,/.IDU6DED,/
HGQDKDUDQ#ZHL]PDQQDFLO
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHDELOLW\RISHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVDQGRIGLIIXVLRQSDUDP
HWHUVREWDLQHGIURPEUHDVW'&(05,DQG'7,GDWDVHWVUHVSHFWLYHO\WRLGHQWLI\
,'&,/&DQG'&,6
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV +LJKUHVROXWLRQ '&( DQG '7, EUHDVW GDWDVHWV RI
SDWLHQWV ZLWK EUHDVW PDOLJQDQFLHV ,'& ,/& DQG '&,6 FRQÀUPHG E\
KLVWRSDWKRORJ\ ZHUH DQDO\VHG$[LDO LPDJHV RI WKH WZR EUHDVWV ZHUH UHFRUGHG
DW 7 XVLQJ KLJK VSDWLDO UHVROXWLRQ '&( [ [ PP a PLQ '7,
[[PPaPLQ
5HVXOWV$OOPDOLJQDQFLHVZHUHHQKDQFHGDQGZHUHFRUUHFWO\GLDJQRVHGXVLQJPRU
SKRORJLFDODQGG\QDPLFIHDWXUHVRIHQKDQFHPHQW0RVWRIWKHOHVLRQVH[KLELWHGKLJK
ZDVKLQUDWHLQGLFDWLQJKLJKWUDQVFDSLOODU\WUDQVIHUFRQWUDVWIROORZHGE\FRQVWDQW
HQKDQFHPHQWRUUHGXFHGHQKDQFHPHQW ZDVKRXW ,QSDUWRIWKHOHVLRQV ,'&
,/&DQG'&,6 VORZHQKDQFHPHQWSDWWHUQVZHUHREVHUYHGZLWKQRZDVKRXW
7ZR'7,SDUDPHWHUVWKHSULPHGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWDQGWKHPD[LPXPDQLVRWURS\
LQGH[ ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU LQ WKH FDQFHUV WKDQ LQ WKH QRUPDO EUHDVW WLVVXH
HQDEOLQJFDQFHUGHOLQHDWLRQ,Q,'&,/&DQG'&,6WKHWZR'7,SDUDPHWHUV
GLGQRWUHYHDOFOHDUO\WKHERXQGDULHVRIWKHOHVLRQVSULPDULO\GXHWRORZ61DQG
SDUWLDOYROXPHHIIHFWVLQIDWW\EUHDVWV,QSDUWRIWKHVORZHQKDQFLQJFDQFHUVWKH
'7,SDUDPHWHUVKHOSHGLGHQWLI\FRUUHFWO\WKHOHVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVFRQÀUPWKHKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\RI'&(05,DQGVKRZWKH
SRWHQWLDORI'7,WRSURYLGHKLJKVHQVLWLYLW\DVDVWDQGDORQHPHWKRGLQGHQVHEUHDVWV
)XUWKHUVWXGLHVDUHUHTXLUHGLQRUGHUWRLQFRUSRUDWH'7,LQWRWKHFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ
%
&RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWDQGPROHFXODU
DQGKLVWRORJLFDOSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVLQEUHDVWFDQFHUREVHUYDWLRQVLQ
SDWLHQWV
/%RQHOOR*3HWUDOLD36XPPHUV/3UHGD65DLPRQGL*5HQQH*%DUGR
*&XULJOLDQR0%HOORPL0LODQ,7 OXNHERQHOOR#LHRLW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
'LIIHUHQWLDWLQJLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDVXVLQJ
GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,DIHDVLELOLW\VWXG\
$0&KRZ9$L36<&KHXQJ5/HH6.<X**/R+DSS\9DOOH\+.
DSULOFPN#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHVWDEOLVKWKUHVKROGDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDOXHIRUGLI
IHUHQWLDWLQJLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDVXVLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
LPDJLQJ ':, DW7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVIHPDOHSDWLHQWVZLWKELRSV\SURYHQPDOLJQDQWEUHDVW
OHVLRQV 1 ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHG$OO05,H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHSHU
IRUPHG RQ D 7 05, VFDQQHU 0$*1(7207ULR 6LHPHQV XVLQJ D GHGLFDWHG
FKDQQHOSKDVHGDUUD\FRLO$VLQJOHVKRWHFKRSODQDULPDJLQJ':,SURWRFROZDV
SHUIRUPHG WR REWDLQ LPDJHV D[LDOO\ XVLQJ EYDOXHV VPP$ FLUFXODU
52, ZDV GHÀQHG LQ WKH ': LPDJHV RYHU WKH EUHDVW OHVLRQV DQG XVHG IRU$'&
PHDVXUHPHQWV7KUHVKROG$'&YDOXHVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGXVLQJUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJ
FKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV3DWKRORJLFDOUHVXOWVVKRZHGWKDWOHVLRQVZHUHLQYDVLYHFDUFLQRPDV
ZKLOH OHVLRQV ZHUH QRQLQYDVLYH FDUFLQRPDV$'& RI LQYDVLYH FDUFLQRPDV
[PPV ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHU SWZRWDLOHGSDLUHG
6WXGHQWҋVWWHVW WKDQWKDWRIQRQLQYDVLYHFDUFLQRPDV [PPV
7KHDUHDXQGHUWKHUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFFXUYHZDVLQGLFDWLQJ
DJRRGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI$'&LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYH
EUHDVWFDUFLQRPDV$Q$'&WKUHVKROGYDOXHRI[PPVZDVGHWHUPLQHG
DOORZLQJGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDVZLWK
VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ':,LVDIHDVLEOHPHWKRGWRFKDUDFWHULVHEUHDVWOHVLRQVTXDQWLWDWLYHO\
RIIHULQJSURPLVHDVDUREXVWQRQLQYDVLYHWRROWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQLQYDVLYHDQG
QRQLQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDUFLQRPDV
%
,V'SURWRQVSHFWURVFRSLFLPDJLQJDW7HVODDEOHWRGLVFULPLQDWH
EHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWEUHDVWOHVLRQV"
%%UXHFN.3LQNHU'RPHQLJ+0DJRPHWVFKQLJJ:%RJQHU+%LFNHO
7++HOELFK6*UXEHU9LHQQD$7 EHQHGLNWEUXHFN#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7R DVVHVV ZKHWKHU ' SURWRQ VSHFWURVFRSLF LPDJLQJ DW 7HVOD 7
'+056, LVDEOHWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWEUHDVWOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKDVXVSLFLRXVEUHDVWOHVLRQZHUHLQFOXGHG
LQWKLVSURVSHFWLYH,5%DSSURYHGVWXG\DQGXQGHUZHQW7'+056,XVLQJD
GHGLFDWHG EUHDVW FRLO )RU 7 '+056, D SRLQWUHVROYHG VSHFWURVFRS\ VH
TXHQFHZLWKWKHIROORZLQJVHTXHQFHSDUDPHWHUVZDVXVHG757( PV
)29ððFPPDWUL[VL]HððLQWHUSRODWHGWRðð7$
PLQ3DWLHQWVKDGWREHH[FOXGHGGXHWRLQVXIÀFLHQWTXDOLW\RIGDWDGXHWR
PRWLRQDUWHIDFWV6LJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 RIFKROLQH &KR ZDVFDOFXODWHGXVLQJ
-058,DQGDVHOIZULWWHQVRIWZDUH056,YR[HOVZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUWKHPD[LPXP
615RI&KRE\DQH[SHULHQFHGVSHFWURVFRSLVWDQGDQ615WKUHVKROGRI!ZDV
GHÀQHGDVLQGLFDWLYHRIPDOLJQDQF\$OOOHVLRQVZHUHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOO\YHULÀHG
5HVXOWVPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOHVLRQVZHUHFRQÀUPHGLQSDWLHQWV'+
056,KDGDVHQVLWLYLW\RIDQGDVSHFLÀFLW\RI139ZDV339ZDV
DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\ZDV7KHPHGLDQ615RI&KRLQZDVLQ
PDOLJQDQWDQGLQEHQLJQEUHDVWOHVLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ'056,DW7\LHOGVKLJKGLDJQRVWLFVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\IRU
GLVFULPLQDWLRQ RI EHQLJQ DQG PDOLJQDQW EUHDVW OHVLRQV ZLWKLQ FOLQLFDOO\ IHDVLEOH
VFDQWLPHV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH 7R FRUUHODWH DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW $'& ZLWK PROHFXODU DQG
KLVWRORJLFDOSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVIRUEUHDVWFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVIHPDOHSDWLHQWV PHDQDJHUDQJH\HDUV
ZLWK KLVWRORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ EUHDVW FDQFHU XQGHUZHQW FRQYHQWLRQDO LQFOXGLQJ 7
ZHLJKWHG DQG 7 G\QDPLF LPDJLQJ SRVWFRQWUDVW DQG GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG 05,
EYDOXHVDQGVPP 7KH$'&IRUEUHDVWFDQFHUDVGHÀQHG
PDQXDOO\RQWKHKLJKHVWEYDOXHLPDJHVZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKPROHFXODUDQGKLVWR
ORJLFDOSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUV$'&YDOXHVZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQJHQH
SURÀOLQJVXEW\SHV /XPLQDO$/XPLQDO%+(5WULSOHUHFHSWRUQHJDWLYH YDVFXODU
LQYDVLRQ SUHVHQWDEVHQW JUDGLQJ *** (53J5+(5H[SUHVVLRQ SRVL
WLYHQHJDWLYH .L DQG710VWDJLQJXVLQJDQDO\VLVRIYDULDQFH $129$
6SHDUPDQFRHIÀFLHQWZDVXVHGWRDVVHVVFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ$'&YDOXHVDQG
FRQWLQXRXVYDULDEOHV DJHSHUFHQWDJHRI(53J5+(5.L
5HVXOWV 7KH $'& RI EUHDVW FDQFHU YLVLEOH RQ WKH KLJK EYDOXH LPDJH ZDV
[PPVHF7KH$'&IRU7WXPRXUVZDVKLJKHUWKDQLQ7DQG7
WXPRXUV S 7KH$'&IRUO\PSKQRGHSRVLWLYHWXPRXUV 11 ZDVORZHU
WKDQO\PSKQRGHQHJDWLYHWXPRXUV S 7KH$'&YDOXHIRUWULSOHUHFHSWRU
QHJDWLYHWXPRXUVZDVKLJKHUWKDQRWKHUVXEW\SHVRQO\UHDFKLQJVLJQLÀFDQFHZKHQ
FRPSDUHGWR/XPLQDO% S
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU UHVXOWV VKRZHG GLIIHUHQFHV LQ$'& IRU GLIIHUHQW KLVWRORJLFDO
SURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVDQGJHQHWLFVXEW\SHVRIEUHDVWFDQFHU7KH$'&GLIIHUHQFHVLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKGLIIHUHQWO\PSKQRGHVVWDWXVHQFRXUDJHVIXUWKHUVWXGLHVWRH[SORUH
LWVFOLQLFDOXWLOLW\DVDQDGGLWLRQDOSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUIRUEUHDVWFDQFHU
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
5ROHRISURWRQ05VSHFWURVFRS\LQWKHKLJKÀHOGPDJQHW 7 LQ
GLDJQRVLVRILQGHWHUPLQDWHEUHDVWPDVVHV %,5'6
10$EGHO5D]HN$2$]DE*L]D(* QDJODDEGHOUD]HN#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRI05VSHFWURVFRS\XVLQJWKHVWDWHRIDUWKLJKÀHOG
PDJQHW 7HVOD DVDGLDJQRVWLFPHWKRGLQLQGHWHUPLQDWHEUHDVWOHVLRQV %,5$'6
OHVLRQV DLPLQJDWGHFUHDVLQJWKHXQQHFHVVDU\EUHDVWLQWHUYHQWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVVWXG\IHPDOHSDWLHQWVFODVVLÀHGDV%,5$'6
E\VRQRPDPPRJUDSK\ 6RQR0; ZHUHH[DPLQHGE\05,XVLQJWKHPXO
WLSKDVHG\QDPLFVHTXHQFHDQGSURWRQ05VSHFWURVFRS\XVLQJDKLJKÀHOGPDJQHW
7HVOD 6LQJOHYR[HOWHFKQLTXHDIWHUDGHTXDWHVKLPPLQJZDVXVHG7KHJUDSKV
ZHUHLQWHUSUHWHGIRUWKHSUHVHQFHRIFKROLQHSHDNLQWKHVSHFWUXPDQGWKHUHVXOWV
ZHUHFRUUHODWHGWRWKHUHVXOWVRIWKHG\QDPLF05,$OOOHVLRQVZHUHKLVWRSDWKRORJL
FDOO\SURYHQ )1%&1%9$% 2%
5HVXOWV FDVHV RI FDVHV ZHUH PDOLJQDQW EDVHG RQ WKH SUHVHQFH RI
KLJKFKROLQHSHDNLQWKHVSHFWUXP DQGFDVHV ZHUHEHQLJQ QRFKROLQH
SHDN 0DOLJQDQWFDVHVZHUH'&,6,'&PHGXOODU\FROORLGDQGOREXODUFDUFLQRPDV
%HQLJQ FDVHV ZHUH ÀEURDGHQRPD SDSLOORPD VFOHURVLQJ DGHQRVLV DQG EUHDVW
F\VWV05VSHFWURVFRS\KDVLQFUHDVHGWKHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIG\QDPLF
05PDPPRJUDSK\IRUGLDJQRVLVRISUREDEOHOHVLRQIURPWRWRWR
)DOVHSRVLWLYHUHVXOWVZHUHIRXQGLQODFWDWLQJIHPDOHVDQGLQRQO\RQHFDVH
RIDW\SLFDOÀEURDGHQRPDKRZHYHUWKHFKROLQHSHDNLQVXFKFDVHZDVVKRUWDQG
ELÀG7KHUHZDVDVWURQJDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQWKHUHVXOWVRI056DQGWKHKLVWRSD
WKRORJ\ SYDOXH
&RQFOXVLRQ05SURWRQVSHFWURVFRS\LQWKHKLJKÀHOGPDJQHW 7 RIIHUHGDG
GLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQWKDWLQFUHDVHGWKHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RIWKHFRQYHQWLRQDO
G\QDPLF05,LQHYDOXDWLQJSUREDEOHEUHDVWOHVLRQVDQGKHQFHUHGXFHGWKHQHHG
IRUXQQHFHVVDU\LQWHUYHQWLRQ
%
7RFRPSDUH05VSHFWURVFRS\DW7ZLWKWXPRXUW\SHDQGJUDGLQJRI
EUHDVWFDQFHUV
0/XFLDQL)3HGLFRQL07HOHVFD)9DVVHOOL9&DVDOL(0LJOLR&&DWDODQR
5RPH,7 PDULDODXUDOXFLDQL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH 05
VSHFWURVFRS\ DW 7 WR GHWHFW GLIIHUHQW FDQFHU W\SHV DQG SURJQRVWLF IDFWRUV LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKELRSV\SURYHQEUHDVWFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%UHDVW05VSHFWURVFRS\ZDVSHUIRUPHGDW7LQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKELRSV\SURYHQPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVPHDVXULQJPPRUODUJHUDW05LPDJLQJ
6LQJOHYR[HO05VSHFWURVFRS\GDWDZHUHFROOHFWHGIURPDVLQJOHUHFWDQJXODUYROXPH
RILQWHUHVWWKDWHQFRPSDVVHGWKHOHVLRQ05VSHFWURVFRS\ÀQGLQJVZHUHGHÀQHG
DVSRVLWLYHLIWKHVLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRRIWKHFKROLQHUHVRQDQFHSHDNZDVDQG
DVQHJDWLYHLQDOORWKHUFDVHV05VSHFWURVFRS\ÀQGLQJVZHUHWKHQFRPSDUHGZLWK
KLVWRORJLFÀQGLQJV/HVLRQVL]HKLVWRW\SHQXFOHDUJUDGHUHFHSWRUVWDWXV (53J5
DQG.LDQG+(5H[SUHVVLRQZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZLWKOHVLRQVZHUHHYDOXDWHG3DWKRORJ\FRQÀUPHG,'&
,/&DQG'&,6&KROLQHSHDNRFFXUHGLQOHVLRQV ,'&DQG,/& 7KUHH
,'&ZLWKQRFKROLQHSHDNSUHVHQWHGZLWKODUJHFHQWUDODUHDRIQHFURVLV7KXVD
FKROLQHSHDNZDVPRUHIUHTXHQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK,'&WKDQZLWK,/&'&,6DQG
QHFURVLV1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWDVVRFLDWLRQRIFKROLQHSHDNZLWKUHFHSWRUVWD
WXV (53J5 .LDQG+(5ZDVIRXQGDOWKRXJKWKHFKROLQHSHDNZDVDOZD\V
SUHVHQWLQWULSOHQHJDWLYHSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ3URWRQ05VSHFWURVFRS\DW7ZDVVXFFHVVIXOO\LQFRUSRUDWHGLQWR
EUHDVW05LPDJLQJVWXGLHVIRUOHVLRQVPHDVXULQJPPRUODUJHU05VSHFWURVFRS\
FRXOGEHDQDGGLWLRQDOWRROWRSUHGLFWWXPRXUDJJUHVVLYHQHVV5HVXOWVQHHGWREH
YDOLGDWHGLQODUJHUVFDOHVWXGLHV
%
'LDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDWLRQLQTXDQWLWDWLYH
SURWRQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHVSHFWURVFRS\RIWKHEUHDVWDW7D
SURVSHFWLYHVLQJOHFHQWUHFURVVVHFWLRQDOVWXG\
3$7%DOW]HU-6FKHOKRUQ0%HQQGRUI:$.DLVHU0'LHW]HO-HQD'(
:HLPDU'( SDVFDOEDOW]HU#PHGXQLMHQDGH
3XUSRVH$QLQFUHDVHRIFKROLQHPHWDEROLWHVLQSURWRQ05VSHFWURVFRS\ 056
LVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKPDOLJQDQF\2QHDSSURDFKIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIEUHDVWOHVLRQV
LV TXDQWLÀFDWLRQ RI WKH FKROLQH UHVRQDQFH DW SSP QRUPDOLVHG WR WKH ZDWHU
UHVRQDQFH$VSRVWSURFHVVLQJLVDVXEMHFWLYHWDVNWKLVLQYHVWLJDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHG
WRLQYHVWLJDWHLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDWLRQDQGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRITXDQWLWDWLYH
056RIEUHDVWOHVLRQV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV PHDQ DJH \ ZLWK HQKDQFLQJ OHVLRQ
!PPRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05, 7PPRO*G'73$NJ ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHG
XVLQJVLQJOHYR[HO056 35(6675PV7(PV 5HIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
56 ZDVKLVWRSDWKRORJ\RUIROORZXSRI!PRQWKV6SHFWUDZHUHDQDO\VHGDQG
SRVWSURFHVVHG E\ WZR LQGHSHQGHQW REVHUYHUV 2 2 XVLQJ 058, VRIWZDUH
)RU&KROLQHZDWHUTXDQWLÀFDWLRQWKH$0$5(6DOJRULWKPZDVDSSOLHG6WDWLVWLFDO
DQDO\VLV LQFOXGHG LQWHUREVHUYHU FRUUHODWLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW DQG UHFHLYHU RSHUDWLQJ
FKDUDFWHULVWLFV 52& DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWVPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOHVLRQVZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHG,QWHUREVHUYHUFRU
UHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWZDVKLJKZLWK$FFXUDF\IRUGLVFULPLQDWLRQEHWZHHQEHQLJQ
DQGPDOLJQDQWÀQGLQJVGHWHUPLQHGE\52&DQDO\VLVZDV26(
26(GLIIHUHQFHVQRWVLJQLÀFDQW 3! $VLJQLÀFDQWRYHUODS
RIFKROLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWÀQGLQJVZDVREVHUYHG
&RQFOXVLRQ$FFRUGLQJWRWKHSUHVHQWHGUHVXOWV056TXDQWLÀFDWLRQVKRZHGKLJK
LQWHUREVHUYHU FRUUHODWLRQ DQG QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ WKH GLDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFH RI ERWK REVHUYHUV$ TXDQWLWDWLYH DQG UHOLDEOH GLDJQRVWLF WRRO PD\
EHDEOHWRUHGXFHGLDJQRVWLFYDULDWLRQLQEUHDVW05,+RZHYHUHOHYDWHGFKROLQH
FRQFHQWUDWLRQVHHPVQRWWREHUHVWULFWHGWRPDOLJQDQWÀQGLQJVDQGLVDOVRREVHUYHG
LQEHQLJQOHVLRQVOLPLWLQJGLDJQRVWLFSRZHURI056
%
([YLYR05,RIEUHDVWVSHFLPHQDQLQQRYDWLYHWHFKQLTXHIRUWKH
PDQDJHPHQWRIRQO\RUEHWWHU05,GHWHFWHGFDQFHU
*7UHFDWH5$JUHVWL'9HUJQDJKL%9DOHUL&)HUUDULV6%RKP,0DXJHUL
0&DUFDQJLX'6FDUDPX]]D0LODQ,7 JLR#GRJKXQWHURUJ
3XUSRVH:KHQEHWWHUVWDJHGZLWK05,EUHDVWPDOLJQDQFLHVULVHWKHUDGLRORJLFDO
SUREOHPWREHORFDOLVHGDQGWKHVXUJLFDOLVVXHRIWKHLUFRPSOHWHUHVHFWLRQ7KLV
PDLQO\KDSSHQVZLWKOREXODUKLVWRW\SHVZKHUHJURZWKSDWWHUQVKRZVPLQLPDORU
DEVHQWGHVPRSODVWLFUHDFWLRQRUE\LQVLWXGLVHDVHHVSHFLDOO\LIQRWDVVRFLDWHG
ZLWKFDOFLÀFDWLRQV7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHQWDQHZVWUDWHJ\WKDWÀUVWO\
HQDEOHGWKHORFDOLVDWLRQRIFDQFHUDQGVHFRQGO\GHPRQVWUDWHGWKHLUWUXHH[FLVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HHQUROOHGFDVHVRIEHWWHURURQO\05,HPSKDVLVHG
OHVLRQV:HORFDOLVHGWKHGLVHDVHE\PHDQVRIDFDUHIXOWKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOUHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQRIEUHDVWSDUHQFK\PDPDGHZLWKDSRVWSURFHVVLQJHODERUDWLRQRILPDJHV
DQGFRPELQHGZLWKWKHPHDVXUHPHQWRIWKHGLVWDQFHVIURPWKHQLSSOHDQGVNLQ
RXWOLQHV/DWHUZHLQMHFWHGFRQWUDVWPHGLXP *G'73$ EHIRUHVXUJLFDOLQFLVLRQ
DQGÀQDOO\SHUIRUPHGH[YLYR05,RIVXUJLFDOVSHFLPHQZLWKLQҋDIWHUUHVHFWLRQE\
PHDQVRIDVXUIDFHFRLODQG63$,5VHTXHQFHV,QIRUPHGFRQVHQWZDVUHTXHVWHG
IRUERWKGLDJQRVWLFDQGH[YLYRH[DPLQDWLRQV
5HVXOWV$OOHQKDQFLQJOHVLRQVZHUHUHWULHYHGLQEUHDVWVSHFLPHQDIWHUUHVHFWLRQ
7KHQHZWHFKQLTXHUHSURGXFHVSULPDU\GLVHDVHHYHQLIDVVRFLDWHGZLWKGHQGULWLF
EUDQFKHVRUVPDOOVDWHOOLWHQRGHVDQGWKHVXUIDFHFRLOPDJQLÀHVPDOLJQDQFLHVZLWK
DUHSUHVHQWDWLRQWKDWLVYHU\VLPLODUWRWKHSDWKRORJLFDOJURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7RRXUNQRZOHGJHWKLVSURFHGXUHLVWKHÀUVWWKDWUHHQKDQFHVEUHDVW
OHVLRQV ZLWKLQ D VXUJLFDO VSHFLPHQ7KH WHFKQLTXH UHSURGXFHV PRUSKRORJ\ DQG
H[WHQVLRQ RI WKH GLVHDVH E\ PHDQV RI WKH VDPH SURFHGXUH WKDW KDG SUHYLRXVO\
SURYLGHGWKHPRVWDFFXUDWHVWDJLQJRIFDQFHUJLYLQJWKHFHUWDLQW\RILWVWUXHUHPRWLRQ
5RRP*+
+HDGDQG1HFN
66
1HZWHFKQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
+%(JJHVE¡2VOR12
5/MXPDQRYLF$PVWHUGDP1/
%
05PLFURVFRS\RIWKHKXPDQH\HFRUUHODWLRQZLWKKLVWRORJ\
3&.UJHU6/DQJQHU.)DONH5*XWKRII26WDFKV1+RVWHQ
*UHLIVZDOG'(5RVWRFN'(
3XUSRVH0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, DWDQG7HVODZLWKVPDOOVXUIDFH
FRLOVLVDZHOOHVWDEOLVKHGSURFHGXUHLQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIVSDFHRFFXS\LQJOHVLRQVRI
WKHH\HDQGRUELWDOFDYLW\8QWLOQRZKLVWRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQKDVEHHQUHTXLUHGWR
UHOLDEO\DVVHVVWXPRXUH[WHQWDQGSRVVLEOHLQÀOWUDWLRQRIVXUURXQGLQJVWUXFWXUHV:LWK
XOWUDKLJKÀHOG05,KRZHYHULWKDVEHFRPHSRVVLEOHWRHYDOXDWHWXPRXUPRUSKRO
RJ\DVZHOODVLQÀOWUDWLRQLQWRVXUURXQGLQJVWUXFWXUHVZLWKVXEPLOOLPHWHUUHVROXWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7HQKXPDQH\HVZLWKGLIIHUHQWVSDFHRFFXS\LQJPDVVHV
ZHUHH[DPLQHGH[YLYRWRFRPSDUHWKHVWDQGDUGFOLQLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQ XOWUDVRXQG
ZLWK XOWUDKLJKÀHOG PLFUR05, XVLQJ D VPDOO VXUIDFH FRLO ,PDJLQJ SDUDPHWHUV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ZHUHVOLFHWKLFNQHVVPPDWUL[VL]H[SL[HOVLQSODQHUHVROXWLRQ
[[PSL[HODFTXLVLWLRQWLPHPLQSHUSODQH)LQDOO\WKHVSHFLPHQV
ZHUHH[DPLQHGKLVWRORJLFDOO\DQGWKHKLVWRORJLFDODQG05,UHVXOWVZHUHFRUUHODWHG
5HVXOWV8OWUDKLJKÀHOG05,DW7HVODSURYLGHGLPDJHVRIDQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHV
RIWKHEXOEDVZHOODVGLIIHUHQWEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWLQWUDRFXODUPDVVHVZLWKKLJK
UHVROXWLRQHQDEOLQJUHOLDEOHDVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUPRUSKRORJ\DQGH[WHQW6XE
VHTXHQWKLVWRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQFRQÀUPHG05,ÀQGLQJVUHJDUGLQJRULJLQLQWHUQDO
VWUXFWXUHDQGH[WHQWRIWKHPDVVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\GHPRQVWUDWHVWKHSRWHQWLDORI05PLFURVFRS\IRULPDJLQJ
VPDOODQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHV7KHÀQGLQJVFRUUHODWHVWURQJO\ZLWKKLVWRORJ\PDNLQJ
05,RIFHQWUDOLPSRUWDQFHLQGHWHUPLQLQJWXPRXUPRUSKRORJ\H[WHQWDQGSRWHQWLDO
LQÀOWUDWLRQRIVXUURXQGLQJVWUXFWXUHV7KLVZRUNZDVSHUIRUPHGH[YLYREXWZLWKZLGHU
DYDLODELOLW\XOWUDKLJKÀHOG05PLFURVFRS\LVH[SHFWHGWREHFRPHDQHVVHQWLDOWRRO
QRWRQO\LQH[SHULPHQWDOVWXGLHVEXWDOVRIRUGDLO\URXWLQH
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ &(86 XVLQJHDUO\G\QDPLFLQ
PLFURFLUFXODWLRQIRUORFDOL]DWLRQRISDWKRORJLFDOSDUDWK\URLGJODQGV
ÀUVWOLQHRUFRPSOLPHQWDU\GLDJQRVWLFPRGDOLW\"
(0-XQJ$$JKD5HJHQVEXUJ'(
3XUSRVH &RQWUDVWHQKDQFHG XOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ &(86 UHSUHVHQWV D QHZ GLDJ
QRVWLFWRROWRORFDOL]HSDWKRORJLFDOSDUDWK\URLGJODQGV7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDV
WRGLIIHUHQWLDWHWKHFDSDELOLW\RI&(86DVÀUVWOLQHRUFRPSOLPHQWDU\PRGDOLW\IRU
WKHGHWHFWLRQRIK\SHUIXQFWLRQLQJSDUDWK\URLGJODQGV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKS+37ZHUHDGPLWWHGWRWKH8QLYHUVLW\
+RVSLWDO 5HJHQVEXUJ EHWZHHQ DQG &RQYHQWLRQDO DQG FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ &(86 XVLQJDOLQHDUSUREH 0+]/2*,4(*(
ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQDOOSDWLHQWVSUHRSHUDWLYHO\7KHVHQVLWLYLW\RI&(86ZDVDQDO\]HG
WRGHWHUPLQHLWVSRWHQWLDODVÀUVWOLQHRUFRPSOLPHQWDU\GLDJQRVWLFSURFHGXUH
5HVXOWV8VLQJ&(86RIDOOSDWKRORJLFDOJODQGVFRXOGEHGHWHFWHGLQWKH
FRUUHFWTXDGUDQWZKHUHDVFRQYHQWLRQDOXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ S UHYHDOHG
OHVV VHQVLWLYLW\ ,Q DOO SDWLHQWV &(86 LQGLFDWHG D FRUUHFW VLGH ORFDOL]DWLRQ RI WKH
K\SHUIXQFWLRQLQJSDUDWK\URLGJODQG7KHDGYDQWDJHRI&(86ZDVWKHGHWHFWLRQ
RI WKH HDUO\ G\QDPLF RQ WKH FDSLOODU\ OHYHO LPPHGLDWHO\ DIWHU FRQWUDVW LQMHFWLRQ
2YHUDOO&(86SHUPLWPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHYLGHRDVVLVWHGSDUDWK\URLGHFWRP\LQ
SDWLHQWVSDWLHQWVUHTXLUHGFRQYHQWLRQDOSURFHGXUHGXHWRFRQFRPLWDQWJRLWHU
$OOSDWLHQWVVKRZHGQRUPDOFDOFLXPDQGSDUDWK\URLGKRUPRQHVHUXPOHYHOVWKUHH
PRQWKVDIWHUVXUJHU\
&RQFOXVLRQ&(86UHSUHVHQWVDKLJKO\VHQVLWLYHGLDJQRVWLFPRGDOLW\IRUORFDOL]DWLRQ
RISDWKRORJLFSDUDWK\URLGJODQGVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKS+371HYHUWKHOHVVLWFDQRQO\
EHUHFRPPHQGHGDVÀUVWOLQHGLDJQRVWLFSURFHGXUHLQVSHFLDOL]HGFOLQLFDOFHQWHUV
ZLWKH[SHULHQFHGLQYHVWLJDWRUV
%
9HQWLODWLRQLPDJLQJRIWKHSDUDQDVDOVLQXVHVXVLQJ[HQRQHQKDQFHG
GXDOHQHUJ\&7
75&-RKQVRQ6)7KLHPH:0RHOOHU6%HFNHU86FKXVFKQLJ
2(LFNHOEHUJ$'+HOFN0)5HLVHU0XQLFK'(1HXKHUEHUJ'(
*UlIHOILQJ'( 7KRUVWHQ-RKQVRQ#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5HGXFLQJWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHIRUORZGRVH&7RIWKHSDUDQDVDO
VLQXVHVXVLQJRUJDQVSHFLÀFGRVHUHGXFWLRQ ;&$5( DQGLWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQIHDVLELOLW\DQGLPDJHTXDOLW\
6%XOOD*3DFKH3%ODQNH)+DVVHSDVV0/DQJHU
)UHLEXUJLP%UHLVJDX'( VWHIDQEXOOD#XQLNOLQLNIUHLEXUJGH
3XUSRVH 7R SURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWH LPDJH TXDOLW\ RI GRVHUHGXFHG &7 RI WKH
SDUDQDVDO VLQXV XVLQJ RUJDQVSHFLÀF GRVH UHGXFWLRQ ;&$5( DQG LWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXH ,5,6
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q WKLV SURVSHFWLYH VWXG\ SDWLHQWV PHDQ DJH
\HDUV XQGHUZHQWORZGRVH&7RIWKHSDUDQDVDOVLQXV 6LHPHQV'HÀQLWLRQ
)RUFKKHLP*HUPDQ\ XVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHZLWKHLWKHUVWDQGDUG
VHWWLQJV $N9P$VELVPXWKH\HOHQVVKLHOGSURWHFWLRQ RUZLWKWXEHYROW
DJHDQGWXEHFXUUHQWWLPHSURGXFWORZHULQJXVLQJRUJDQVSHFLÀFGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
;&DUH LQJURXSVRISDWLHQWVHDFK %N9P$V&N9P$V'
N9P$VDQG(N9P$V 2EMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVHYDOXDWHG
DQGVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DVVHVVHGE\WZREOLQGHGREVHUYHUV
XVLQJDVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHÀYHSRLQWJUDGLQJVFDOH SRRU H[FHOOHQW (IIHFWLYHUD
GLDWLRQGRVHZDVFDOFXODWHG0DQQ:KLWQH\8WHVWZDVXVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV%HVWLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVREVHUYHGDWN9P$V ZKHUHDVVFRUHV
IRUELVPXWKVKLHOGHGVWDQGDUGORZGRVH&7 $ DQGPD[LPXPGRVHUHGXFWLRQZLWK
;&$5( ( SURYLGHGQHDUO\WKHVDPHVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ S
0HDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHVZHUHP6Y $ P6Y % P6Y
& P6Y ' DQGP6YUHVXOWLQJLQDPD[LPXPGRVHUHGXFWLRQ
RIZLWKRXWORVVLQGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\%DFNJURXQGQRLVHZDVPRGHUDWHO\
KLJKHU LQ GRVH UHGXFHG DUHDV ZKHQ HPSOR\LQJ ;&DUH SHULQDVDO +8
YVSHULDXULFXODU+8S ,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVH[FHOOHQW
ѣYDOXHV
&RQFOXVLRQ$VFRPSDUHGZLWKELVPXWKVKLHOGHG&7DSSOLFDWLRQRILWHUDWLYHUHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQDQGRUJDQVSHFLÀFGRVHUHGXFWLRQDOORZVIRUVLJQLÀFDQWGRVHUHGXFWLRQRI
XSWRIRUSDUDQDVDOVLQXVORZGRVH&7ZLWKRXWORVVLQGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\
%
4XDQWLÀFDWLRQRIPHWDODUWHIDFWVRQFRQHEHDPFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\LPDJHV
53DXZHOV+%RVPDQV5-DFREV5%RJDHUWV+6WDPDWDNLV
.7VLNODNLV.+RUQHU/HXYHQ%($WKHQV*50DQFKHVWHU8.
KLOGHERVPDQV#VFDUOHWEH
3XUSRVH7RTXDQWLI\PHWDODUWHIDFWVREWDLQHGIURPDZLGHUDQJHRIFRQHEHDP
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &%&7 GHYLFHVDQGH[SRVXUHSURWRFROVWRFRPSDUHWKHLU
WROHUDQFH WR PHWDOV RI GLIIHUHQW GHQVLWLHV DQG WR SURYLGH LQVLJKWV UHJDUGLQJ WKH
SRVVLEOHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIPHWDODUWHIDFWDQDO\VLVLQWRD4&SURWRFROIRU&%&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$FXVWRPLVHGSRO\PHWK\OPHWKDFU\ODWH 300$ SKDQWRP
FRQWDLQLQJWLWDQLXPDQGOHDGURGVZDVIDEULFDWHG,WZDVVFDQQHGRQ&%&7
GHYLFHV DQG PXOWLVOLFH FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ 06&7 GHYLFH LQFOXGLQJ KLJK
GRVHDQGORZGRVHH[SRVXUHSURWRFROV$UWHIDFWVIURPWKHURGVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\
WZRREVHUYHUVE\PHDVXULQJWKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQRIYR[HOYDOXHVLQWKHYLFLQLW\RI
WKHURGVDQGQRUPDOLVLQJWKLVYDOXHWRWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIWKHWKHRUHWLFDOPD[LPXP
VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ
5HVXOWV)RU&%&7GDWDVHWVDUWHIDFWYDOXHVUDQJHGEHWZHHQDQGIRU
WLWDQLXPDQGEHWZHHQDQGIRUOHDG0RVW&%&7GHYLFHVSHUIRUPHG
ZRUVHWKDQ06&7IRUWLWDQLXPDUWHIDFWVEXWDOORIWKHPSHUIRUPHGEHWWHUIRUOHDG
DUWHIDFWV,QJHQHUDOQRFOHDULPSURYHPHQWRIPHWDODUWHIDFWVZDVVHHQIRUKLJK
GRVHSURWRFROVDOWKRXJKFHUWDLQGHYLFHVVKRZHGVRPHDUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQIRUODUJH
)29RUKLJKP$VSURWRFROV
&RQFOXVLRQ5HJLRQVLQWKHYLFLQLW\RIWKHPHWDOURGVZHUHPRGHUDWHO\RUJUDYHO\
DIIHFWHGSDUWLFXODUO\LQWKHDUHDEHWZHHQWKHURGV,QSUDFWLFHWKH&%&7XVHUKDV
YHU\OLPLWHGSRVVLELOLWLHVWRUHGXFHDUWHIDFWV5HVHDUFKHUVDQGPDQXIDFWXUHUVQHHG
WR FRPELQH WKHLU HIIRUWV LQ RSWLPLVLQJ H[SRVXUH IDFWRUV DQG LPSOHPHQWLQJ PHWDO
DUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQDOJRULWKPV
%
$FXVWRPLVHGGHQWDO&7VRIWZDUHIRUDXWRPDWLFFRUUHFWLRQRISDWLHQW
SRVLWLRQLQJHUURUDQGGHWHFWLRQRIMDZPLGOLQH
$/R&DVWR*3HWUXFFL3*DOOR33XUSXUD)%DUUHFD*/D7RQD
3DOHUPR,7 DQWRQLRORFDVWR#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHYHORSDGHQWDO&7UHIRUPDWWLQJVRIWZDUHIRUDXWRPDWLFFRUUHFWLRQ
RISDWLHQWSRVLWLRQLQJHUURUDQGGHWHFWLRQRIMDZPLGOLQHIRUSDQRUDPLFDQGFURVV
VHFWLRQDOUHIRUPDWLRQV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RVKRZWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIGXDOHQHUJ\&7 '(&7 DQGG\QDPLFVLQJOH
HQHUJ\&7IRUWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHYHQWLODWLRQRIWKHSDUDQDVDOVLQXVHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUDG\QDPLFTXDQWLÀFDWLRQDQGYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIVLQXV
YHQWLODWLRQ[HQRQJDVZDVDGPLQLVWHUHGWRDQDVDOFDVWZLWKDODPLQDUÁRZRI/
PLQ5HSHDWHGG\QDPLFVLQJOHHQHUJ\&7PHDVXUHPHQWVRIWKHQDVDOFDYLW\DQG
WKHVLQXVHVZHUHSHUIRUPHG7KLVSURFHGXUHZDVUHSHDWHGZLWKSXOVDWLQJ[HQRQ
ÁRZ7KH[HQRQUHODWHGHQKDQFHPHQWOHYHOLQWKHGLIIHUHQWFRPSDUWPHQWVRIWKH
PRGHOZDVTXDQWLÀHGDQGORFDO[HQRQFRQFHQWUDWLRQVZHUHGHWHUPLQHG$GGLWLRQDOO\
XVLQJ'(&7&7PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGERWKGXULQJODPLQDUDQGSXOVDWLQJ
[HQRQDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ7KH[HQRQFRQFHQWUDWLRQLQWKHGLIIHUHQWFRPSDUWPHQWVZDV
TXDQWLÀHGGLUHFWO\EDVHGRQWKHVSHFWUDOLQIRUPDWLRQ
5HVXOWV1HLWKHUZLWKVLQJOHHQHUJ\&7QRUZLWK'(&7[HQRQUHODWHGHQKDQFH
PHQWFRXOGEHGHWHFWHGLQWKHSDUDQDVDOVLQXVHVGXULQJODPLQDUDLUÁRZZKLOHWKH
[HQRQFRQFHQWUDWLRQLQWKHQDVDOFDYLW\UHDFKHG8VLQJSXOVDWLQJDLUÁRZ
WKHG\QDPLFPHDVXUHPHQWVVKRZHGD[HQRQZDVKLQDQGZDVKRXWLQWKHVLQXVHV
WKDWIROORZHGDPRQRH[SRQHQWLDOIXQFWLRQZLWKWLPHFRQVWDQWVRIDIHZVHFRQGV
$FFRUGLQJO\'(&7LPDJHVUHYHDOHG[HQRQHQKDQFHPHQWLQWKHVLQXVHVRQO\DIWHU
SXOVDWLQJ[HQRQDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ'(&7DQGG\QDPLF[HQRQHQKDQFHG&7LPDJLQJGHPRQVWUDWHGWKH
VXSHULRULW\RISXOVDWLQJJDVÁRZRYHUODPLQDUÁRZVIRUWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIJDVRU
DHURVROVWRWKHSDUDQDVDOVLQXVHV'(&7ZLWK[HQRQYHQWLODWLRQPD\UHSUHVHQWDQ
DWWUDFWLYHRSWLRQIRUWKHUDS\SODQQLQJEHIRUHPHGLFDODHURVROWUHDWPHQWRUVXUJHU\
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$[LDO&7LPDJHVRIWKHMDZVIURPDYROXPHWULFDFTXLVLWLRQ
ZHUHHODERUDWHGE\DVRIWZDUHGHYHORSHGLQ0DWODEODQJXDJH7RFRUUHFWSDWLHQW
SRVLWLRQLQJHUURUVURWDWLRQVZHUHDVVLJQHGWRWKHYR[HOFRRUGLQDWHVLQRUGHUWR
GLVSRVHWKHYR[HOUHODWLYHWRWKHVDJLWWDOSODQHSDUDOOHOWRWKHD[LDOSODQH7KLVLV
DFFRPSOLVKHGXVLQJWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIV\PPHWU\RIWKHMDZVZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKH
VDJLWWDOSODQHDOORZLQJWRGHWHUPLQHWKHFHQWUDOLQHUWLDOD[HVRIWKHMDZVWRLGHQWLI\
WKHVDJLWWDOSODQHDQGGHWHUPLQHWKHURWDWLRQDQJOHVWREHDVVLJQHGWRWKHYR[HOV
2QFHWKHSRVLWLRQLQJFRUUHFWLRQLVGRQHWKHRSWLPDOMDZPLGOLQHLVDXWRPDWLFDOO\
WUDFHGGLYLGLQJLQSDUWVDQD[LDOUHIHUUDOUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJHWRLGHQWLI\WKHPLGOLQH
HTXDWLRQE\WKHRUGLQDU\OHDVWVTXDUHVPHWKRG7KHQSDQRUDPLFUHIRUPDWWHGDORQJ
WKHFHQWUDOLQHUWLDOD[HVRIDOOFURVVVHFWLRQDOLPDJHVRIWKHMDZDQGFURVVVHFWLRQDO
LPDJHVDUHDXWRPDWLFDOO\JHQHUDWHG
5HVXOWV7KHSDQRUDPLFDQGFURVVVHFWLRQDOUHIRUPDWWHGLPDJHVREWDLQHGZHUH
MXGJHGRIJRRGTXDOLW\E\UDGLRORJLVWVZKRFRPSDUHWKHUHIRUPDWLRQVREWDLQHG
ZLWKWKRVHRQHVWKH\REWDLQHGPDQXDOO\ZLWKDFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOHGHQWDO&7
UHIRUPDWWLQJVRIWZDUH
&RQFOXVLRQ$QXVHIXOWRROZDVGHYHORSHGWRRYHUFRPHSDWLHQWSRVLWLRQLQJHUURUV
DQGFXWWLPHFRQVXPLQJSURFHGXUHRIPDQXDOO\WUDFLQJWKHMDZPLGOLQHIRUSDQRUDPLF
DQGFURVVVHFWLRQDOUHIRUPDWLRQV
%
3(7&7DQG3(705LPDJHTXDOLW\LQWKHSUHVHQFHRIGHQWDOLPSODQWV
0.:HUQHU-:LHJDQG-.XSIHUVFKODHJHU&/RLV,%H]UXNRY
+6FKPLGW&3IDQQHQEHUJ16FKZHQ]HU7%H\HU7ELQJHQ'(
6DQWLDJRGH&RPSRVWHOD(6 0DWWKLDV:HUQHU#PHGXQLWXHELQJHQGH
3XUSRVH&RPELQHG3(705LPDJLQJKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRSURYLGHGLDJQRVWLFLP
DJHTXDOLW\RIDQDWRPLFDOUHJLRQVDGMDFHQWWRGHQWDOLPSODQWVZKLFKFDXVHLQWHQVH
DUWHIDFWVLQ3(7&7DQGRIWHQKDQGLFDSSURSHUGLDJQRVLV:HHYDOXDWHG3(705
IRUKHDGDQGQHFNLPDJLQJXVLQJDGHQWDOSKDQWRPDQGSDWLHQWLPDJHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHSKDQWRP ÀOOHGZLWKXQLIRUPEDFNJURXQG FRQWDLQHG
UHDOKXPDQWHHWKVRPHZLWKGHQWDOLPSODQWVDQGRQHWRRWKJDSLQDSODVWLFFDUULHU
UHVHPEOLQJWKHMDZV3KDQWRPVFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQDFOLQLFDO3(7&7 %LR
JUDSK+L5H] DQGLQWHJUDWHGZKROHERG\3(705 %LRJUDSKP056LHPHQV
,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWKDQGZLWKRXW&7DQG05 8OWUDVKRUW(FKR7LPH
87( EDVHGDWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQ $& 3KDQWRPGDWDDQGÀYHSDWLHQWGDWDVHWV
IURPERWK3(7&7DQG3(705ZHUHHYDOXDWHGYLVXDOO\DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHO\ 52,
EDVHGDQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV05EDVHGDWWHQXDWLRQFRUUHFWLRQXVLQJ87(VHTXHQFHV\LHOGHGVLJQLÀFDQW
LQKRPRJHQHLWLHVLQ05LPDJHVDQGFRQVHTXHQWO\ELDVHGPDSVZLWKHUURQHRXV
DVVLJQPHQWRIYR[HOVWRWLVVXHHOHFWURQGHQVLWLHV$QHQODUJHGSKRWRSHQLFDUHD
DURXQGWKHORFDWLRQRIWKHLPSODQWVZDVGHWHFWDEOHLQ3(705UHJDUGOHVVRISULRU
$&7KHUHZHUHQRDGGLWLRQDODUWHIDFWVDIWHU$&HYHQZLWKKDPSHUHGPDSV,Q
FRQWUDVWVHYHUHVWUHDNLQJDUWHIDFWVLQ&7LPDJHVWUDQVODWHGLQWRQRQXQLIRUP3(7
LPDJHVLQ3(7&7DIWHU$& RQO\PLOGSKRWRSHQLDZLWKRXW$& 7KHDQDO\VLVRI3(7
05 SDWLHQW LPDJHV UHYHDOHG D VLJQLÀFDQWO\ LPSURYHG YLVXDOLVDWLRQ RI VWUXFWXUHV
VXFKDVWKHÁRRURIWKHPRXWKDQGWKHVXEPDQGLEXODUUHJLRQVXVXDOO\DIIHFWHGE\
3(7&7DUWHIDFWV
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPELQHG3(705KHDGDQGQHFNLPDJLQJSURPLVHVLPSURYHGYLV
LELOLW\DQGGLDJQRVLVIRUVWUXFWXUHVDGMDFHQWWRGHQWDOLPSODQWVFRPSDUHGWR3(7&7
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHSDUDPHWHUVDQGFOLQLFDOVFRUHVLQWK\URLG
DVVRFLDWHGRUELWRSDWK\ZKLFKRQHWRWUXVWIRUWKHH[WUDRFXODU
PXVFOHVHYDOXDWLRQ"
&*RGL6%LDQFKL0DU]ROL*&DPPDUDWD$$PEURVL$)DOLQL*6FRWWL
/63ROLWL0LODQ,7 FODXGLDJRGL#FROOHJLRGLPLODQRLW
3XUSRVH 7RÀQGWKHPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, SDUDPHWHUEHVWUHSUH
VHQWLQJH[WUDRFXODUPXVFOHVG\VIXQFWLRQDQGGLVHDVHDFWLYLW\LQWK\URLGDVVRFLDWHG
RUELWRSDWK\ 7$2 WRFRPSDUHEDVHOLQHDQGIROORZXSFOLQLFDODQG05,PHDVXUHV
RI7$2SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK 7$2 XQGHUZHQW 05, ZLWK 763,5
SRVWJDGROLQLXP763,5 7*DG DQG':, E VHTXHQFHVIROORZLQJRSK
WKDOPRORJLF HYDOXDWLRQ$FFRUGLQJ WR WKH &OLQLFDO$FWLYLW\ 6FRUH &$6 SDWLHQWV
ZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRLQDFWLYH &$6 RUDFWLYHGLVHDVH$IXQFWLRQDOVFRUH QRUPDO
VHYHUHLPSDLUPHQW ZDVDVVLJQHGWRHYHU\UHFWXVPXVFOH6LJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVDQG
DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& PHDVXUHGRQDOOUHFWLPXVFOHVDQGQRUPDOLVHG
WRWKDODPXV 6,5V ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHIURPKHDOWK\VXEMHFWVDQGZLWK
3DWLHQWV FOLQLFDOVFRUHV7KHGDWDDIWHULQWUDYHQRXVVWHURLGWUHDWPHQWZHUHDYDLO
DEOHIRUSDWLHQWV0DQQ:KLWQH\:LOFR[RQ6LJQHG5DQN7HVWDQG6SHDUPDQ
FRUUHODWLRQZHUHDSSOLHG
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5HVXOWV 3DWLHQWV KDG 7 7*DG $'& 6,5V KLJKHU WKDQ KHDOWK\ VXEMHFWV
S ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQWVLJQDOGHFUHDVHIURPDFWLYHLQDFWLYHGLVHDVHWRKHDOWK\
FRQWUROV H[FHSW RI$'& QRW GLIIHUHQW EHWZHHQ DFWLYHLQDFWLYH JURXSV 7 DQG
7*DG6,5VEXWQRW$'&VKRZHGJRRGFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKHPXVFOHG\VIXQFWLRQ
DQG&$6OHYHOVLQWKHDIIHFWHGVXEMHFWV,QDGGLWLRQ7DQG$'&6,5VRISDWLHQWV
QRUPDOO\IXQFWLRQLQJPXVFOHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKRVHRIKHDOWK\FRQ
WUROV$OO6,5VVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHGLQPXVFOHVWKDWKDGFOLQLFDOLPSURYHPHQWDIWHU
WKHUDS\LQWHUHVWLQJO\HYHQLQWKHJURXSRIFOLQLFDOO\VWDEOHIXQFWLRQLQJPXVFOHVD
VLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQLQ05,SDUDPHWHUVZDVGHWHFWHGRYHUWLPH
&RQFOXVLRQ05,VKRZVHYHQFOLQLFDOO\VLOHQWPXVFOHLQYROYHPHQWDQGFRXOGEH
PRUHVHQVLWLYHWKDQRSKWKDOPRORJLFVFRUHVWRFKDQJHVLQPXVFOHLQYROYHPHQW
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIDFKDQQHOYHUVXVDFKDQQHOKHDGFRLOIRU05,
GLDJQRVWLFVLQJLDQWFHOODUWHULWLV
3$)UDQNH00DUNO6+HLQ]HOPDQQ39DLWK0/DQJHU-*HLJHU
)UHLEXUJ'(&KLFDJR,/86 SKLOLSSIUDQNH#XQLNOLQLNIUHLEXUJGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIDFKDQQHOKHDGFRLOLQFRPSDULVRQ
ZLWKDFKDQQHOFRLOIRUHYDOXDWLRQRIVXSHUÀFLDOFUDQLDODUWHULHVҋLQÁDPPDWLRQLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKJLDQWFHOODUWHULWLV *&$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG*&$XQGHUZHQW705,
SDWLHQWVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKDFKDQQHOKHDGFRLOÀUVWDQGDFKDQQHOKHDG
FRLOVHFRQGSDWLHQWVLQWKHRWKHUFRLORUGHU7ZHLJKWHGSRVWFRQWUDVWLPDJHV
ZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\WZREOLQGHGUHDGHUVUHJDUGLQJLPDJHJUDGLQJDUWHIDFWOHYHODQG
DUWHULHVҋLQÁDPPDWLRQ615PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGIRUERWKFRLOVLQWKH
EUDLQVWHPWKHFHUHEHOOXPDQGWKHJDOHDOWLVVXH,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDV
PHDVXUHGZLWKWKH&RKHQѣWHVW&RPSDULVRQEHWZHHQWKHWZRFRLOVZDVFDOFXODWHG
ZLWK:LOFR[RQUDQNWHVWDQGWWHVW6LJQLÀFDQWOHYHOVZHUHS
5HVXOWV %RWK FRLOV LGHQWLÀHG DUWHULHVҋ LQÁDPPDWLRQ UHOLDEO\ WKH LQWHUREVHUYHU
DJUHHPHQWZDVH[FHOOHQW ѣ IRUFKDQQHOFRLOѣ IRUFKDQQHOFRLO
:HREWDLQHGDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWKLJKHU615 S ZLWKWKHFKDQQHOFRLO
LQGHSHQGHQWO\RIWKHFRLORUGHU,PDJHJUDGLQJDQGDUWHIDFWOHYHOZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHUZLWKWKHFKDQQHOFRLOLQHLWKHUH[DPLQDWLRQRUGHU5HJDUGLQJWKHLPDJH
JUDGLQJWKHLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\ZDVPRGHUDWH ѣ IRUWKHFKDQQHO
FRLODQGVXEVWDQWLDO ѣ IRUWKHFKDQQHOFRLO
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHFKDQQHOKHDGFRLOLVVXSHULRUWRWKHFKDQQHOFRLOLQGHSLFWLQJ
WKHVXSHUÀFLDOFUDQLDODUWHULHVDQGLQJHQHUDOLPDJHTXDOLW\EHFDXVHRIDKLJKHU
615ZKLFKLVLQGHSHQGHQWRIFRLORUGHUDQGGHOD\RIYHVVHOVҋFRQWUDVWHQKDQFH
PHQW)RU*&$GLDJQRVLVKRZHYHUWKHFKDQQHOFRLOVHHPVWREHVXIÀFLHQW
%
&RPSDULVRQRIWUXHUHDOWLPH05LPDJLQJZLWKUDGLDONVSDFH
VDPSOLQJWRYLGHRÁXRURVFRS\H[DPVLQWKHIROORZXSHYDOXDWLRQRI
YHORSKDU\QJHDOG\VIXQFWLRQWUHDWHGE\VXUJHU\
0&/DUVRQ0-.HUO5:%DXHU7%ORFN6=KDQJ5+DPPHUVWLQJO
6=DQJRV7-9RJO0*0DFN)UDQNIXUWDP0DLQ'((UODQJHQ'(
*|WWLQJHQ'( PD\FULVVODUVRQ#ZHEGH
3XUSRVH9HORSKDU\QJHDOG\VIXQFWLRQFDQKDYHPDQ\FDXVHVDQGLVRIWHQWUHDWHG
E\ VXUJHU\$IWHU VXUJHU\ WKH UHVXOWLQJ LPSURYHG FORVXUH RI WKH YHORSKDU\QJHDO
SRUWGXULQJVSHDNLQJDQGVZDOORZLQJLVWKHPDQRHXYUHRILQWHUHVWZKLFKLVXVXDOO\
PRQLWRUHGE\YLGHRÁXRURVFRS\7KHDLPRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRVKRZWKDWUDSLG05,
SURWRFROVXVLQJHTXDOWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQWRÁXRURVFRS\ +] LVDVDFFXUDWHDV
YLGHRÁXRUVFRS\ZLWKRXWH[SRVXUHWR[UD\V
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:LWKWKHDSSURYDORIRXULQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUG
SDWLHQWV PDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQW705IXQFWLRQDOLPDJLQJ
DQG YLGHRÁXRURVFRS\ H[DPV 2XU DSSURDFK FRQFHUQLQJ WKH 05, VFDQ SURWRFRO
ZDV WR XVH D IDVW ORZDQJOH VKRW )/$6+ JUDGLHQWHFKR VHTXHQFH ZLWK UDGLDO
NVSDFHVDPSOLQJDQGVOLGLQJZLQGRZUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ VXEIUDPHV IRUDFKLHYLQJ
DQLPDJHXSGDWHUDWHRI+] IUDPHVSHUVHFRQG 6DJLWWDOYLHZVZLWKPP
VODEVZHUHREWDLQHGGXULQJVSHHFKZLWKD7(RIPVD75RIPVDÁLS
DQJOHRIDQGDPDWUL[VL]HRISL[HOV7KHFORVXUHRIWKHYHORSKDU\QJHDO
SRUWGXULQJVSHDNLQJZDVFRPSDUHGE\UDGLRORJLVWVLQERWKGLDJQRVWLFPHWKRGV
5HVXOWV7KHREWDLQHGUHDOWLPH05FLQHPDWLFVZHUHHTXDOWRWKHYLGHRÁXRURVFRSLF
LPDJHVWRHYDOXDWHWKHFORVXUHRIWKHYHORSKDU\QJHDOSRUWGXULQJVSHHFKWRDV
VHVVWKHSRVWRSHUDWLYHUHVXOWV%RWKUDGLRORJLVWVUDWHGWKHRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\LQ
FRQVHQVXVDVGLDJQRVWLF
&RQFOXVLRQ)XQFWLRQDO05,LVWRFRQVLGHUHTXDOWRÁXRURVFRSLFLPDJLQJLQWKH
HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHFORVXUHRIWKHYHORSKDU\QJHDOSRUWGXULQJSRVWRSHUDWLYHIROORZXS
H[DPVZLWKRXWH[SRVXUHWR[UD\V
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP,.
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
66
05,RIIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV
0RGHUDWRUV
6%RKDWD%UQR&=
3+XSSHUW'DUPVWDGW'(
%
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJRIIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQVOHVLRQVL]HDQG
LPDJHWHFKQLTXHXVHGKDYHVLJQLÀFDQWLQÁXHQFHRQGLDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFH
3$7%DOW]HU-6FKHOKRUQ0%HQQGRUI:$.DLVHU0'LHW]HO-HQD'(
:HLPDU'( SDVFDOEDOW]HU#PHGXQLMHQDGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIWZRFRPPRQO\DYDLODEOHGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, WHFKQLTXHVIRUGHWHFWLRQDQGGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIIRFDOOLYHU
OHVLRQV )// VXVSHFWIRUPHWDVWDVHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KLV UHWURVSHFWLYH FURVVVHFWLRQDO VWXG\ LQYHVWLJDWHG
FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW*G
(2%'73$HQKDQFHGOLYHU05,LQFOXGLQJWZRGLIIHUHQW':,WHFKQLTXHVDVSHFWUDOO\
IDWVDWXUDWHGEUHDWKKROG(3,VHTXHQFH ':,EKWLPHRIDFTXLVLWLRQ 7$ PLQ
DQGDIUHHEUHDWKLQJVSHFWUDOO\IDWVDWXUDWHG(3,VHTXHQFH ':,IE7$PLQ
':, LPDJHV ZHUH DQDO\VHG E\ WZR UHDGHUV LQ FRQVHQVXV ,Q LGHQWLÀHG OHVLRQV
VLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHV 6, DWORZHVWDQGKLJKHVWEYDOXHVZHUHPHDVXUHGXVLQJDXVHU
GHÀQHGUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW6XEVHTXHQWO\FDOFXODWHGDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
$'& YDOXHVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFV 52& DQDO\VLV
7KHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGLQFOXGHGKLVWRSDWKRORJ\DQGIROORZXSH[DPLQDWLRQV
5HVXOWVRILQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWHGZLWK)// EHQLJQPD
OLJQDQW 2IWKHVH':,IEGHWHFWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVFRPSDUHG
WR':,EK 3 /HVLRQVL]HPPZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK)//
PLVVHGE\':,EK 3 EXWQRWZLWK':,IE 3 52&DQDO\VLVUHYHDOHG
DVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUDUHDXQGHUWKH52&FXUYHIRU$'&YDOXHVRI':,IE
FRPSDUHGWR':,EK 3
&RQFOXVLRQ'XHWRDKLJKHUOHVLRQGHWHFWLRQUDWH':,IESHUIRUPHGEHWWHUWKDQ
':,EK+RZHYHUERWK':,WHFKQLTXHVGLGQRWGHSLFWDOOPDOLJQDQW)//7KLVÀQGLQJ
DQGRYHUODSVEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQVOLPLWVWKHDSSOLFDELOLW\RIWKHVH
WHFKQLTXHVDVDVWDQGDORQHGLDJQRVWLFWRROLQLPDJLQJRIKHSDWLF)//
%
&KDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQZLWKTXDQWLWDWLYHWHFKQLTXHV
FRPSDULVRQRIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWYDOXHVDQG7
UHOD[DWLRQWLPHV
$&LHV]DQRZVNL$*URG]LFND:6]HV]NRZVNL%.DF]\QVNL(0DM
%*RUQLFND0*URG]LFNL0.UDZF]\N25RZLQVNL:DUVDZ3/
DQGU]HMFLHV]DQRZVNL#ZXPHGXSO
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHHIÀFDF\RIWZRTXDQWLWDWLYHPHWKRGVIRUGLVFULPLQDWLRQEH
WZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV )//V DSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
$'& YDOXHVDQG7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQW\WKUHHSDWLHQWVZLWKFRQÀUPHG)//VLQFOXGLQJ
EHQLJQ F\VWVKDHPDQJLRPDV)1+VDEVFHVVHVF\VWDGHQRPD
DQG PDOLJQDQW PHWDVWDVHV +&&V KDHPDQJLRHQGRWKHOLRPDV
&&$VF\VWDGHQRFDUFLQRPD XQGHUZHQW705,ZLWKUHVSLUDWRU\WULJJHUHGVLQ
JOHVKRW6(':, E DQGGXDOHFKR776( 75 PV7( PV
7( PV $'&YDOXHVDQG7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHVRI)//VZHUHFDOFXODWHGDQG
WKHQRSWLPDOWKUHVKROGYDOXHVDQGDFFXUDFLHVIRUHDFKPHWKRGZHUHDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV)ROORZLQJPHDQ$'&YDOXHVZHUHREWDLQHGIRUDOOW\SHVRI)//VF\VWV
[PPVKDHPDQJLRPDV[PPVDEVFHVVHV[PPV
)1+V [ PPV F\VWDGHQRPD [ PPV PHWDVWDVHV [
PPV+&&V[PPVKDHPDQJLRHQGRWKHOLRPDV[PPV
&&$V [ PPV F\VWDGHQRFDUFLQRPD [ PPV :LWK WKH XVH
RIRSWLPDOWKUHVKROGYDOXHRIPPVVHQVLWLYLW\IRUGLDJQRVLVRIEHQLJQ
OHVLRQ ZDV VSHFLÀFLW\ DFFXUDF\ 339 139
)ROORZLQJ PHDQ 7 WLPHV ZHUH FDOFXODWHG F\VWV PV KDHPDQJLRPDV
PV DEVFHVVHV PV )1+V PV F\VWDGHQRPD PV
PHWDVWDVHVPV+&&VPVKDHPDQJLRHQGRWKHOLRPDVPV&&$V
PVF\VWDGHQRFDUFLQRPDPV$WWKHWKUHVKROGRIPVVHQVLWLYLW\
IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIEHQLJQOHVLRQZDVVSHFLÀFLW\DFFXUDF\
339139
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQVHQVLWLYLWLHVIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIEHQLJQOHVLRQ
ZDVQRWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWEHWZHHQERWKTXDQWLWDWLYHWHFKQLTXHVZKHUHDVWKH
DQDO\VLVRI7UHOD[DWLRQWLPHV\LHOGHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUVSHFLÀFLW\ WKDQ
$'&YDOXHV
%
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHSRVVLEOHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ$'&YDOXHVRIEHQLJQDQG
PDOLJQDQW)//VDQGQRUPDOOLYHUSDUHQFK\PDLQWKHOHIWYVULJKWKHSDWLFOREHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7KLUW\VL[ SDWLHQWV PDOHV IHPDOHV PHDQ DJH
\HDUV ZLWK)//VRIWKHVDPHDHWLRORJ\LQERWKWKHOHIWDQGULJKWOREHVRIWKH
OLYHU SDWLHQWVZLWKEHQLJQ)//VDQGSDWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQW)//V
ZKRXQGHUZHQW705,LQFOXGLQJ':05, EYDOXHVRIDQGPPòV ZHUH
LQFOXGHGLQWKLV+,3$$FRPSOLDQWDQG,5%DSSURYHGVWXG\$'&YDOXHVRIQRUPDO
OLYHUSDUHQFK\PDDQG)//VLQHDFKKHSDWLFOREHZHUHFDOFXODWHGDQGFRPSDUHG
XVLQJ6WXGHQWҋVWWHVWIRUSDLUHGGDWD
5HVXOWV$'&YDOXHVRIQRUPDOOLYHUSDUHQFK\PDEHQLJQ)//VDQGPDOLJQDQW)//V
ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU SS DQGS UHVSHFWLYHO\ LQWKHOHIW
KHSDWLFOREH [[DQG[PPòVUHVSHFWLYHO\ WKDQLQ
WKHULJKWKHSDWLFOREH [[DQG[PPòVUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ$'&YDOXHVRIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQW)//VDQGQRUPDOOLYHUSDUHQ
FK\PD DUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ KLJKHU LQ WKH OHIW KHSDWLF OREH FRPSDUHG ZLWK WKH ULJKW
KHSDWLFOREH7KLVLVOLNHO\GXHWRFDUGLDFPRWLRQDQGPD\OLPLWWKHUHOLDELOLW\DQG
UHSURGXFLELOLW\RI)//$'&YDOXHHVWLPDWHVDQGWKHFOLQLFDOXVHIXOQHVVRIQRQFDUGLDF
JDWHG':05,LQFKDUDFWHULVLQJ)//V
3XUSRVH$ZRUNÁRZ DFTXLVLWLRQDQGVDPSOLQJPHWKRGVTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLV
OHVVVLWHGHSHQGHQWDVSRVVLEOHLVSURSRVHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHFRPELQDWLRQRI':,
SDUDPHWHUVWKDWPD[LPLVHVVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHQLJQDQG
PDOLJQDQW)OOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQ)OO KDHPDQJLRPDV)1+
PHWDVWDVLV XQGHUZHQWIUHHEUHDWK05'Z, EYDOXHVVWHSRIV
PP 7ZR 52,V ZHUH GHÀQHG LQFOXGLQJ WKH )OO DQG D SDUW RI WKH VXUURXQGLQJ
SDUHQFK\PDUHVSHFWLYHO\$'&3)DQG'ZHUHHVWLPDWHGLQWKH)OO $'&O3)O
'O DQGLQWKHVXUURXQGLQJSDUHQFK\PDWKHUDWLRVEHWZHHQ)OODQGSDUHQFK\PD
YDOXHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG $'&U3)U'U 7WHVWDQG52&DQDO\VLVZHUHSHUIRUPHG
WR LGHQWLI\ WKH EHVW VHW RI 'Z,UHODWHG SDUDPHWHUV LQ GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ EHQLJQ DQG
PDOLJQDQW)OOV VLJQLÀFDQFHWKUHVKROGS
5HVXOWV 7WHVW VKRZHG VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ EHQLJQ DQG PDOLJQDQW
)OOVYDOXHVIRU$'&O3)O'O$'&UDQG'UPRUHSURQRXQFHGIRU$'&O
YVSYDOXH DQG$'&U YVS
6HQVLWLYLWLHVZLWKFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO &, RI$'&ODQG$'&UFRUUHVSRQGLQJ
WRDVSHFLÀFLW\RIZHUH $'&O ÃPPV DQG
$'&U
&RQFOXVLRQ5HVXOWVLQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ)OOVZLWK'Z,DUHHQFRXUDJLQJ YHU\ORZS
YDOXHV EXWWKH&,VRI$'&ODQG$'&UVHQVLWLYLW\HVWLPDWLRQVDUHVWLOOWRRZLGHD
ODUJHUFRKRUWRI)OOVVKRXOGEHHYDOXDWHGSRVVLEO\ZLWKPXOWLFHQWULFVWXGLHVJLYHQ
WKHORZGHSHQGHQF\RQWKHVLWHRIWKHZRUNÁRZSURSRVHG
)RFDOOLYHUOHVLRQVLQWKHULJKWDQGOHIWKHSDWLFOREHVRQGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJLVWKHUHDGLIIHUHQFH"
&6FKPLG7DQQZDOG)'DKL<-LDQJ,6HWKL$2WR&KLFDJR,/86
FKULVWLQHVFKPLGWDQQZDOG#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
%
6HQVLELOLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI':,UHODWHGSDUDPHWHUVDSSDUHQW
GLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& GLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW ' DQGSHUIXVLRQ
IUDFWLRQ 3) LQGLVWLQJXLVKLQJDPRQJEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWIRFDO
OLYHUOHVLRQV )OOV
)5HJLQL)3DVTXLQHOOL&1DUGL/0D]]RQL*%HOOL6&RODJUDQGH
)ORUHQFH,7$UH]]R,7
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
&RPSDULVRQRIWKUHHPHWKRGVRIDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
HYDOXDWLRQLQDVVHVVLQJVROLGIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQVZLWKGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':,
5*LURPHWWL63XOOLQL/&HUHVHU0'HO3LQ*&RPR0%D]]RFFKL
&=XLDQL8GLQH,7 UJLURPHWWL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHLQGLDJQRVLQJVROLGIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV )//V
PDOLJQDQF\RIWKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& WKUHVKROGLQJ $'&7 PHWKRG
YVWZRYDULDQWVRIWKHOHVLRQWROLYHU$'&UDWLR $'&5
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV([DPLQDWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD7V\VWHP$QDO\VLV
ZDVDSSOLHGWR)//VSURYHQWREHPDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQLQDQGFDVHV
UHVSHFWLYHO\&\VWVDQGKDHPDQJLRPDVZHUHH[FOXGHGIURPWKHDQDO\VLV:HHV
WLPDWHGWKHSRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339 DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWYDOXH 139 IRU
PDOLJQDQF\RI$'&7DQGWZRYDULDQWVRIWKH$'&5FDOFXODWHGZLWKRXW $'&5
DQGZLWK $'&5 WKHLQFOXVLRQRIWKHSDUHQFK\PDO$'&VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQYDOXH
UHVSHFWLYHO\$Q$'&5ZDVFRQVLGHUHGDVPDOLJQDQW$UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJ
FKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLVZDVFDUULHGRXWWRHVWDEOLVKDWKUHVKROGIRUPDOLJQDQF\
DQGWRFRPSDUHWKHDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& YDOXHV
5HVXOWV7KHWKUHVKROGIRUPDOLJQDQF\RI$'&7ZDV[PPVHF7KH
339DQG139ZHUH &, DQG &, IRU
$'&7YV &, DQG &, IRU$'&5
YV &, DQG &, IRU$'&5UHVSHF
WLYHO\0RVWIDOVHQHJDWLYH)//VZHUHUHSUHVHQWHGE\KHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD
$'&7VKRZHGDQ$8& VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU S WKDQ$'&5
EXWQRWWKDQ$'&5
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH 139 IRU )//V DVVHVVPHQW ZHUH ORZ UHJDUGOHVV RI WKH$'&
HYDOXDWLRQPHWKRGZKLOHWKH339ZDVKLJKHVSHFLDOO\E\FRPSDULQJOHVLRQDQG
SDUHQFK\PDO$'&VZLWKWKH$'&5PHWKRG+RZHYHUWKHXVHRIDQ$'&WKUHVKROG
SURYLGHGKLJKHUGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHLQWHUPVRI$8&
%
&RPSDULVRQRIWKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWWKUHVKROGLQJ
PHWKRGYVOHVLRQWROLYHU$'&UDWLRLQGLVFULPLQDWLQJVROLGEHQLJQ
DQGPDOLJQDQWIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV )//V
63XOOLQL5*LURPHWWL0'HO3LQ/&HUHVHU*&RPR0%D]]RFFKL
&=XLDQL8GLQH,7 VHUHSXO#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH$WKUHVKROGLQGHSHQGHQWPHWKRGWRDVVHVVIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV )//V LV
QHHGHGEHFDXVHRIWKHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& YDULDELOLW\OLQNHGWR
HTXLSPHQWUHODWHGIDFWRUV2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
RIWKH$'&WKUHVKROGLQJ $'&7 PHWKRGYVOHVLRQWROLYHU$'&UDWLR $'&5 LQ
GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJVROLGEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQW)//V
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\WZRSDWLHQWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGRQD7V\VWHP
&RUUHVSRQGLQJ )//V LQFOXGHG KHSDWRFHOOXODU FDUFLQRPD Q PHWDVWDVHV
Q KHSDWRFHOOXODUDGHQRPD Q IRFDOQRGXODUK\SHUSODVLD Q G\VSODVWLF
QRGXOHV Q DQGDW\SLFDOKDHPDQJLRPD Q &\VWVDQGW\SLFDOKDHPDQJLRPDV
ZHUHH[FOXGHGIURPWKHDQDO\VLV/HVLRQV$'&ZDVXVHGWRHVWDEOLVKDWKUHVKROG
IRUPDOLJQDQF\ZLWKDUHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52& DQDO\VLV $'&7 DQG
WRFDOFXODWHWKH$'&5DVWKHUDWLRRIOHVLRQ$'&DQGOLYHUSDUHQFK\PD$'&$Q
$'&5ZDVFRQVLGHUHGDVPDOLJQDQW%\FRPSDULQJ$'&7DQG$'&5UHVXOWV
ZLWKWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFHZHHVWLPDWHGWKHVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQG
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHV 339139 IRUPDOLJQDQF\52&DQDO\VLVZDVXVHGWR
FRPSDUHWKHDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& RIERWKPHWKRGV
5HVXOWV$'&WKUHVKROGIRUPDOLJQDQF\ZDV[APPòVHF6HQVLWLYLW\VSH
FLÀFLW\339DQG139ZHUH &, &,
&, DQG &, IRU$'&7YV
&, &, &, DQG
&, IRU$'&5UHVSHFWLYHO\$'&7VKRZHGDVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHU$8& WKDQ$'&5 S 0DLQVRXUFHRIIDOVHQHJDWLYH
FDVHVZDVKHSDWRFDUFLQRPD
&RQFOXVLRQ$'&5KDVQRWWKHFDSDELOLW\WRUHSODFH$'&7LQDVVHVVLQJ)//V
%
6HQVLWLYLW\RIYLVXDODVVHVVPHQWYVDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQLQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJPDOLJQDQWDQGVROLGEHQLJQIRFDO
OLYHUOHVLRQVZLWKGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
5*LURPHWWL0'HO3LQ63XOOLQL/&HUHVHU*&RPR0%D]]RFFKL
&=XLDQL8GLQH,7 UJLURPHWWL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RIGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, YLVXDO
DQDO\VLV 9$ YVDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQWTXDQWLÀFDWLRQ $'&4 LQGLDJQRVLQJ
PDOLJQDQF\RIVROLGIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV )//V
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXVUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DVVHVVHG
DVEHQLJQRUPDOLJQDQW)//VRQSDWLHQWVH[DPLQHGRQD77ZRGLIIHUHQW
PHWKRGVZHUHXVHGLQVHSDUDWHUHDGLQJVHVVLRQVD YLVXDODQDO\VLVRIVLJQDOLQWHQ
VLW\RQ':,LPDJHVDWE VHFPPDQG$'&PDSE OHVLRQ$'&PHDVXUHPHQW
RQWKH$'&PDS)//VVKRZLQJDVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\SDWWHUQRIUHVWULFWHGGLIIXVLRQZHUH
DVVHVVHGDVPDOLJQDQW/HVLRQVLQFOXGHGPHWDVWDVHV Q KHSDWRFDUFLQRPDV
+&& Q G\VSODVWLFQRGXOHV Q IRFDOQRGXODUK\SHUSODVLDVRUKHSDWRFHO
OXODUDGHQRPDV )1++$ Q DQGDW\SLFDOKDHPDQJLRPD Q DVFRQÀUPHG
E\KLVWRORJ\7$&(RU\HDUIROORZXS$UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF 52&
DQDO\VLV ZDV SHUIRUPHG WR GHWHUPLQH WKH VHQVLWLYLW\ DQG WR HVWDEOLVK DQ$'&
WKUHVKROGIRUPDOLJQDQF\
5HVXOWV 7KH RYHUDOO VHQVLWLYLW\ IRU PDOLJQDQF\ ZDV &,
IRU 9$ DQG &, IRU$'&4 WKUHVKROG [ PP
VHF $FFRUGLQJWRVWUDWLÀHGDQDO\VLV9$DQG$'&4VKRZHGDVHQVLWLYLW\RI
&, DQG &, IRU+&&DQG &,
DQG &, IRUPHWDVWDVHVUHVSHFWLYHO\$ODUJH
RYHUODSLQ$'&DQG9$IHDWXUHVZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQW)//V
&RQFOXVLRQ$OWKRXJKWKHRYHUDOOVHQVLWLYLW\LVORZ$'&4VKRXOGEHSUHIHUUHG
WR9$LQDVVHVVLQJ)//V HVSHFLDOO\+&& +RZHYHU9$LVPRUHVHQVLWLYHWKDQ
$'&4IRUPHWDVWDVHV7KH7VKLQHWKURXJKSKHQRPHQRQZDVK\SRWKHVLVHGWR
FDXVHWKLVGLVFUHSDQF\E\DIIHFWLQJWKH9$RI+&&
%
,VZKLWHEORRG PLQ SKDVHLQG\QDPLFOLYHU05,XVLQJ
KHSDWRELOLDU\FRQWUDVWDJHQW *G(2%'73$ UHDOO\XVHOHVV
FRPSDUHGZLWKEODFNEORRG PLQ SKDVH"$SUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\
6.LP&/HH6&KRL..LP-&KRL&3DUN-/HH<3DUN6HRXO.5
FKOHH#NRUHDDFNU
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHYDOXHRIZKLWHEORRG PLQ SKDVH :%3 IRUGHWHFWLRQ
RIKHSDWLFPHWDVWDVLVE\FRPSDULQJZLWKEODFNEORRG PLQ SKDVH %%3 RIOLYHU
05,XVLQJ*G(2%'73$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'XULQJ0DUFKWR)HEUXDU\SDWLHQWV
PHQ ZRPHQ DJH a \HDUV ZLWK H[WUDKHSDWLF PDOLJQDQW WXPRXUV DQG
OLYHU PHWDVWDVLV KDYH XQGHUJRQH OLYHU 05, 7KUHH UDGLRORJLVWV EOLQG WR SULPDU\
WXPRXUQXPEHUDQGORFDWLRQRIOLYHUOHVLRQVUHYLHZHG05,RISDWLHQWVWZLFH
ZLWKDQLQWHUYDORIDWOHDVWWZRZHHNV'HWHFWLRQUDWHEHWZHHQ:%3DQG%%3DQG
LQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\ZDVDOVRHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV$PRQJKHSDWLFPHWDVWDWLFQRGXOHVQRGXOHVLQSDWLHQWVZHUH
FRQÀUPHGSDWKRORJLFDOO\DQGRWKHUQRGXOHVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGDVPHWDVWDVLVDIWHU
UHYLHZRIIROORZXS&7RU05,6HQVLWLYLW\RI:%3DQG%%3ZDV
DQGDQGDQGIRUWKUHHREVHUYHUVUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUH
ZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQGHWHFWLRQUDWHRIWZRSKDVHVLQDOORIWKUHH
REVHUYHUV 3 DQG $YHUDJHVHQVLWLYLW\ZDVLQ:%3DQG
LQ %%3 DQG QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH ZDV IRXQG 3 ,QWHUREVHUYHU
DJUHHPHQWZDVJRRGRUH[FHOOHQW ѣ DQGLQ:%3DQG
DQGLQ%%3 0RVWQRGXOHVPLVVHGLQ:%3DSSHDUHGLVRLQWHQVHWR
OLYHUSDUHQFK\PD2QHQRGXOHIRXQGRQO\LQ:%3E\DOOREVHUYHUVZDVVPDOO PP
DQGDGMDFHQWWREORRGYHVVHOV
&RQFOXVLRQ:%3LQOLYHU05,LVQHYHULQIHULRUWR%%3LQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIKHSDWLF
PHWDVWDVLVDQGPD\EHHYHQVXSHULRUIRUVPDOOQRGXOHVDGMDFHQWWREORRGYHVVHOV
EHFDXVHRILWVZKLWHEORRGHIIHFW
%
+RZXVHIXOLVDTXDQWLÀHGDQDO\VLVRIKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVHLPDJLQJ
IRUWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIIRFDOKHSDWLFOHVLRQV"$FRPSDULVRQRI
G\QDPLFJDGR[HWLFDFLGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG *G(2%'73$ 05,
YHUVXVDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'&
8,$WWHQEHUJHU-0RUHOOL+0LFKDHO\75XVWHPHLHU626FK|QEHUJ
0DQQKHLP'(7HPSOH7;86 XOULNHDWWHQEHUJHU#XPPGH
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH YDOXH RI TXDQWLÀHG G\QDPLF *G(2%'73$ DQG DS
SDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& LPDJLQJLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIKHSDWLFOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVUHIHUUHGIRUG\QDPLF*G(2%
'73$05LPDJLQJRIWKHOLYHUZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKLVLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUG ,5%
DSSURYHGUHWURVSHFWLYHVWXG\$WRWDORIOHVLRQVZHUHHYDOXDWHG2IWKHVH
KDHPDQJLRPDVKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDVKHSDWLFDGHQRPDVDQGFDVHV
RIIRFDOQRGXODUK\SHUSODVLDZHUHDVVHVVHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWERWK*G(2%
'73$ VFDQV DW DUWHULDO SRUWDOYHQRXV YHQRXV OLYHUVSHFLÀF SKDVH DW DQG
PLQSL DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':,EVPP DW7
ZLWK$'&FDOFXODWLRQ7KHOHVLRQFRQWUDVWUDWLR &5 ZDVFDOFXODWHGDVIROORZV&5
VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\OHVLRQSRVWFRQWUDVW VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\SDUHQFK\PDSRVWFRQWUDVW
52&DQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGDWDOOWLPHSRLQWVDVZHOODVIRUWKH$'&YDOXHV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
7KHDUHDXQGHUHDFK52&FXUYH $8& ZDVREWDLQHG7KHDELOLW\RIOLYHUVSHFLÀF
SKDVHLPDJLQJDQG$'&YDOXHVWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQWKHOHVLRQVZDVFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV,QERWKOLYHUVSHFLÀFSKDVHV)1+&5ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKDWRI
DOORWKHUOHVLRQV S $GHQRPDVGHPRQVWUDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU&5WKDQ
KDHPDQJLRPDV S EXWQRW+&& S +DHPDQJLRPDVGHPRQVWUDWHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU &5 S $'& YDOXHV DOORZHG DFFXUDWH GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ
EHWZHHQKDHPDQJLRPDVDQGDOORWKHUOHVLRQV S EXWWKHDFFXUDF\ZDVLQ
QRFDVHJUHDWHUWKDQWKDWRIOLYHUVSHFLÀFSKDVHLPDJLQJ1HLWKHUDGHQRPDVDQG
+&&QRU)1+DQG+&&FRXOGEHGLIIHUHQWLDWHGE\$'&YDOXHV
&RQFOXVLRQ *G(2%'73$ RXWSHUIRUPV$'& LQ WKH GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ RI KHSDWLF
OHVLRQV
%
&RPSDULVRQRI05HODVWRJUDSK\DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ
IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV
6.9HQNDWHVK*:DQJ.0DGKDYDQ$:HH6LQJDSRUH6*
VXGKDNDUBNBYHQNDWHVK#QXKVHGXVJ
3XUSRVH &RPSDUDWLYH HYDOXDWLRQ RI 05 HODVWRJUDSK\ 05( DQG GLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWOLYHUOHVLRQV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 05( DQG ':, ZHUH SHUIRUPHG LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK D
WRWDORIOHVLRQV EHQLJQPDOLJQDQW 7KHOHVLRQVZHUHKHSDWRPDV
KDHPDQJLRPDV IRFDO QRGXODU K\SHUSODVLD FKRODQJLRFDUFLQRPD F\VW
DQGJDOOEODGGHUFDUFLQRPD':,ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKDIUHHEUHDWKLQJWHFKQLTXH
757(PVPDWUL[[PPWKLFNQHVVE 05(ZDV
SHUIRUPHGZLWKPRGLÀHGJUDGLHQWHFKRVHTXHQFH 757( PVPDWUL[
[PPWKLFNQHVV 7KHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& PDSVDQG
HODVWRJUDPVZHUHJHQHUDWHGRQZRUNVWDWLRQ5HJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52, ZHUHSODFHG
RQWKHIRFDOOHVLRQVRQWKHHODVWRJUDPVDQG$'&PDSVH[FOXGLQJODUJHYHVVHOVOLYHU
HGJHVDQGDUWHIDFWVZKHUHYHUSRVVLEOH0HDQVWLIIQHVVYDOXHVLQNLORSDVFDOV N3D
DQGPHDQ$'&YDOXHVZHUHGHULYHGIRUHDFKOHVLRQDQGWDEXODWHG5HFHLYHURSHUDW
LQJFXUYH 52& DQDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHDUHDXQGHUFXUYH $8&
IRUDFFXUDF\RI05(DQG$'&IRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV 52& DQDO\VLV VKRZHG WKDW$8&VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\ IRU 05( FXWRII
! N3D DQG ':, FXWRII [ PPV ZHUH
S DQG S UHVSHFWLYHO\ IRU GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ
PDOLJQDQWDQGEHQLJQOHVLRQV7KHDFFXUDF\RI05(ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUWKDQ
':, S 7KHUH ZDV D QHJDWLYH FRUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ VWLIIQHVV DQG$'&
YDOXHV U S ,QWHUHVWLQJO\DFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQVL]HDQGVWLIIQHVV
RIOHVLRQV U S ZDVVHHQ
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU VWXG\ UHVXOWV VKRZ WKDW 05( LV PRUH DFFXUDWH WKDQ ':, IRU
GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIEHQLJQDQGPDOLJQDQWIRFDOOLYHUOHVLRQV
5RRP/0
&DUGLDF
66
&7DQG05,ULVNVWUDWLÀFDWLRQSURJQRVLVDQG
RXWFRPH
0RGHUDWRUV
$%HUQDUGLQL7HUDPR,7
03DVRZLF].UDNRZ3/
%
*HQGHUGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHSURJQRVWLFYDOXHRIFDUGLDF&7DQJLRJUDSK\
-:1DQFH-U86FKRHSI&/6FKOHWW-%DUUD]D)%DPEHUJ
0F&RQQHOOV6&86&KDUOHVWRQ6&86%RVWRQ0$86
0XQLFK'( )DELDQ%DPEHUJ#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
3URJQRVWLFYDOXHRI&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\LQVXEMHFWVZLWK
VXVSHFWHG&$'IRFXVRQVHYHULW\RIFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHDQG
WKHSUHVHQFHRIOHIWPDLQGLVHDVH5HVXOWVIURPWKH&21),50
5HJLVWU\ FRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\HYDOXDWLRQIRUFOLQLFDORXWFRPHV
DQLQWHUQDWLRQDOPXOWLFHQWUHUHJLVWU\
)&DGHPDUWLUL(0DIIHL66HLWXQ-.0LQ+-&KDQJ'%HUPDQ
%&KRZ6$FKHQEDFK-+DXVOHLWHU0RQDVWLHUGL7UHYLVR,7
*HQRD,7/RV$QJHOHV&$866HRXO.52WWDZD21&$*LHVVHQ'(
0XQLFK'( ÀOLSSRFDGHPDUWLUL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7R H[DPLQH WKH DVVRFLDWLRQ RI DOOFDXVH PRUWDOLW\ ZLWK WKH FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ FRURQDU\ DQJLRJUDSK\ &&7 HYLGHQFH RI FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ GLVHDVH
&$' ZLWKIRFXVRQWKHSUHVHQFHDQGVHYHULW\RIOHIWPDLQ /0 GLVHDVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWV PHQDJH\HDUV
ZLWKRXW NQRZQ KLVWRU\ RI &$' IURP DQ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO PXOWLFHQWUH &&7 UHJLVWU\
&21),50 5HJLVWU\ PHW WKH LQFOXVLRQ FULWHULD WRWDO GDWDEDVH SDWLHQWV
FRURQDU\DUWHU\VHJPHQWVDQDO\VLVZHUHSHUIRUPHG&R[SURSRUWLRQDOKD]DUG
PRGHOV ZLWK DGMXVWPHQW IRU ULVN IDFWRUV DQG DIWHU VWUDWLÀFDWLRQ DFFRUGLQJ WR /0
GLVHDVHZHUHGHYHORSHGWRSUHGLFWRXWFRPH
5HVXOWV7KHSUHYDOHQFHRIREVWUXFWLYH ! &$'ZDVZKHUHDVRI
SDWLHQWVKDGQRQREVWUXFWLYH&$'DQGKDGQRUPDOFRURQDU\DUWHULHV7KH
SUHVHQFHRIREVWUXFWLYH ! DQGQRQREVWUXFWLYH&$'LQ/0ZHUHUHVSHFWLYHO\
Q DQG Q $WRWDORIGHDWKV RFFXUUHGDIWHUDPHDQ
IROORZXSRIPRQWKV0XOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKDW&$'VHYHULW\ +5
&, S DQG WKH QXPEHU RI GLVHDVHG VHJPHQWV +5
&,S ZHUHSUHGLFWRUVRIDOOFDXVHPRUWDOLW\ZLWKLQFUHPHQWDO
SURJQRVWLFYDOXHRYHU)UDPLQJKDPULVNDQGFDOFLXPVFRUH5LVNDGMXVWHGVXUYLYDO
VKRZHGWKDWWKHSUHVHQFHRIHLWKHUQRQREVWUXFWLYHRUREVWUXFWLYH FXWRII!
/0GLVHDVHZDVQRWDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZRUVHSURJQRVLV+RZHYHUDIWHU
FRQVLGHULQJDFXWRIIYDOXH!IRUREVWUXFWLYH&$'SDWLHQWVZLWK/0GLVHDVH
IDUHGWKHZRUVW S
&RQFOXVLRQ/0FRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHSUHVHQFHDQGVHYHULW\DVGHWHFWHGE\
&&7VHHPVWREHSRRUO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKZRUVHSURJQRVLV
%
3URJQRVWLFYDOXH&7FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\LQVXEMHFWVZLWK
VXVSHFWHG&$'IRFXVRQVHYHULW\RIFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVH
DQGSUHVHQWLQJV\PSWRPV5HVXOWVIURPWKH&21),505HJLVWU\
FRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\HYDOXDWLRQIRUFOLQLFDORXWFRPHVDQ
LQWHUQDWLRQDOPXOWLFHQWUHUHJLVWU\
(0DIIHL)&DGHPDUWLUL66HLWXQ0+DGDPLW]N\3.DXIPDQQ
.1DVLU/-6KDZ*5DII79LOOLQHV0RQDVWLHUGL7UHYLVR,7
*HQRD,70XQLFK'(=XULFK&+1HZ+DYHQ&786$WODQWD*$86
5R\DO2DN0,86%HWKHVGD0'86
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRH[DPLQHWKHDVVRFLDWLRQRIDOOFDXVHPRUWDOLW\
ZLWKWKHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\FRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\ &&7 HYLGHQFHRIFRURQDU\
DUWHU\GLVHDVH &$' ZLWKIRFXVRQWKHSURJQRVWLFUROHRIV\PSWRPV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWV PHQDJH\HDUV
ZLWKRXWNQRZQKLVWRU\RI&$'IURPWKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO&21),50&&7UHJLVWU\PHW
WKH LQFOXVLRQ FULWHULD$ FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ VHJPHQWV DQDO\VLV ZDV SHUIRUPHG
6XUYLYDO DQDO\VLV DQG &R[ SURSRUWLRQDO KD]DUG PRGHOV ZLWK DGMXVWPHQW IRU ULVN
IDFWRUVDFFRUGLQJWRSUHVHQWLQJV\PSWRPVZHUHGHYHORSHGWRSUHGLFWRXWFRPH
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUHDV\PSWRPDWLFKDGQRQFDUGLDFRUDW\SLFDO
SDLQKDGW\SLFDOSDLQDQGKDGG\VSQRHD7KHRYHUDOOSUHYDOHQFHRI
REVWUXFWLYH ! &$'ZDVZKHUHDVRISDWLHQWVKDGQRQREVWUXFWLYH
&$'DQGKDGQR&$'$VLJQLÀFDQWKLJKHUSUHYDOHQFHRIREVWUXFWLYH&$'
ZDV REVHUYHG DPRQJ SDWLHQWV ZLWK W\SLFDO SDLQ ZLWK UHVSHFW WR RWKHU V\PSWRP
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHJHQGHUGLIIHUHQFHVLQSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIFDUGLDF&7$LQ
SDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJWRWKHHPHUJHQF\GHSDUWPHQWZLWKDFXWHFKHVWSDLQEXWZLWKRXW
DFXWHFRURQDU\V\QGURPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6XEMHFWVZLWKDFXWHFKHVWSDLQXQGHUZHQWFDUGLDF&7$
7KHSUHVHQFHH[WHQW QXPEHURIDIIHFWHGYHVVHOVHJPHQWV VHYHULW\ RU
VWHQRVLV DQGFRPSRVLWLRQRIDWKHURVFOHURWLFOHVLRQV FDOFLÀHGQRQFDOFLÀHG
RU PL[HG ZHUH GHWHUPLQHG 3DWLHQWV ZHUH IROORZHG IRU PDMRU DGYHUVH FDUGLDF
HYHQWV 0$&(P\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQXQVWDEOHDQJLQDUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQFDUGLDF
GHDWK +D]DUGUDWLRVZHUHGHULYHGXVLQJXQLYDULDWHDQGPXOWLYDULDWHFR[UHJUHV
VLRQ DGMXVWLQJIRUULVNIDFWRUV DQGVWUDWLÀHGE\JHQGHULIWKHUHZDVDVWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQWLQWHUDFWLRQ S
5HVXOWV2ISDWLHQWV IHPDOHPHDQDJH\UV LQFXUUHGD
0$&( FDUGLDFGHDWKVQRQIDWDO0, VUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQVDQGXQVWDEOH
DQJLQD GXULQJPHGLDQIROORZXSRI ,45 PRQWKV2QPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLV
WKHSUHVHQFHDQGH[WHQWRIREVWUXFWLYHGLVHDVHSUHGLFWHGVLPLODUULVNVLQPDOHVDQG
IHPDOHV DOOS! KRZHYHUSUHVHQFH +5YV DQGH[WHQW +5
YV RIDQ\SODTXHZDVPRUHKD]DUGRXVLQIHPDOHV S 3ODTXHFRPSRVL
WLRQDOVRSRUWHQGHGYDULDEOHULVNV S ZLWKH[WHQWRIQRQFDOFLÀHGSODTXHOHVV
KD]DUGRXVLQIHPDOHVDQGSUHVHQFHRIH[FOXVLYHO\FDOFLÀHGSODTXHPRUHKD]DUGRXV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH RI FDUGLDF &7$ ÀQGLQJV LV JHQGHUVSHFLÀF
:RPHQ ZLWK DQ\ DWKHURVFOHURVLV DUH DW LQFUHDVHG ULVN FRPSDUHG WR PHQ ZLWK
HTXLYDOHQWGLVHDVHLQDGGLWLRQFDOFLÀHGSODTXHSRUWHQGVDKLJKHUULVNLQIHPDOHV
ZKLOHPDOHVDUHDWLQFUHDVHGULVNZLWKQRQFDOFLÀHGOHVLRQVLQGLFDWLQJWKHUHPD\
EHJHQGHUGLIIHUHQFHVLQSODTXHSURJUHVVLRQVWDELOLW\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
FDWHJRULHV S $WRWDORIGHDWKV RFFXUUHGDIWHUDPHDQ
IROORZXSRIPRQWKV0XOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKDW&$'VHYHULW\ +5
&,S DQGWKHQXPEHURIGLVHDVHGVHJPHQWV S ZHUH
SUHGLFWRUVRIDOOFDXVHPRUWDOLW\ZLWKLQFUHPHQWDOSURJQRVWLFYDOXHRYHU)UDPLQJKDP
ULVNDQGFDOFLXPVFRUH5LVNDGMXVWHGVXUYLYDOGLGQRWGLIIHUVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWZHHQ
V\PSWRPFDWHJRULHVKRZHYHUWKHZRUVWSURJQRVLVZDVREVHUYHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
G\VSQRHD S
&RQFOXVLRQ &&7 LV D YDOXDEOH WRRO IRU ULVN VWUDWLÀFDWLRQ 6HYHULW\ RI &$' DQG
W\SLFDOFKHVWSDLQDSSHDUWREHWKHVWURQJHVWSUHGLFWRUVRIPRUWDOLW\ZLWKLQV\PS
WRPVJURXSV
%
&RURQDU\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\LQWKHVHOHFWLRQ
DQGHYDOXDWLRQRIRXWOLHUSDWLHQWVUHVXOWVIURPWKHLQWHUQDWLRQDO
PXOWLFHQWUH&21),50 FRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\HYDOXDWLRQIRU
FOLQLFDORXWFRPHVDQLQWHUQDWLRQDOPXOWLFHQWUHUHJLVWU\
(0DIIHL)&DGHPDUWLUL66HLWXQ-.0LQ0$O0DOODK0-%XGRII
74&DOOLVWHU9&KHQJ$'HODJR0RQDVWLHUGL7UHYLVR,7*HQRD,7
/RV$QJHOHV&$86'HWURLW0,86+HQGHUVRQYLOOH7186$OEDQ\1<86
VDUDVHLWXQ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSUHVHQFHDQGGLVWULEXWLRQRIRXWOLHUSDWLHQWVZLWKVOLFH
FRURQDU\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\ &&7 LQDODUJHLQWHUQDWLRQDOPXOWL
FHQWUHUHJLVWU\ &21),50
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URPDSRSXODWLRQRIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV
PHQPHDQDJH\HDUV XQGHUZHQW&&7ZHDQDO\VHGSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHG
FRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVH &$' IRUZKRPWKHFRPSOHWHFDUGLDFULVNSURÀOHZHUH
DYDLODEOH:HVHOHFWHGSDWLHQWRXWOLHUVLQWKHÀIWKDQGVL[WKGHFDGHVRIOLIHZLWKWKH
IROORZLQJFULWHULDULVNIDFWRUVDQGDEVHQFHRI&$']HURWRRQHULVNIDFWRUVDQG
GLVHDVHGFRURQDU\VHJPHQWV'LDEHWHVZDVH[FOXGHGEHFDXVHRIWKHGLIIHUHQW
LPSDFWRQ&$'
5HVXOWV 7KH SRSXODWLRQ FRQVLVWHG RI LQGLYLGXDOV ZLWK VXVSHFWHG &$'
PHQDJH\HDUV 7KHSUHYDOHQFHRIVLJQLÀFDQW VWHQRVLV
&$'ZDV3DWLHQWVZLWKQRUPDOFRURQDU\DUWHULHVDFFRXQWHGIRURIWKH
WRWDO PHQDJH\HDUV ZHUHLQWKHÀIWKDQGLQWKHWK
GHFDGH PHQDJH\HDUV RIWKHVHSDWLHQWVZLWKULVNIDFWRUV
DFFRXQWHGIRURIWKHWRWDO PHQZRPHQ 3DWLHQWVZLWKGLVHDVHG
FRURQDU\VHJPHQWVDFFRXQWHGIRURIWKHWRWDO PHQDJH
\HDUV ZHUHLQWKHÀIWKDQGLQWKHVL[WKGHFDGH PHQZRPHQ
RI WKHVH SDWLHQWV ZLWK ]HUR WR RQH ULVN IDFWRUV DFFRXQWHG IRU RI WKH WRWDO
PHQZRPHQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&&7LGHQWLÀHVRXWOLHUSDWLHQWVWKLVZLOOHQDEOHGHGLFDWHGWULDOVDLPHG
DWFKDUDFWHULVLQJELRPDUNHUVDQGJHQRPLFVRISURWHFWLYHDQWLSURWHFWLYHIDFWRUVZLWK
UHVSHFWWR&$'
%
,QFUHDVHGOHIWDWULDORUOHIWDWULDODSSHQGDJHYROXPHDQLQGHSHQGHQW
ULVNIDFWRUIRUFDUGLRHPEROLFVWURNHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWDWULDO
ÀEULOODWLRQ"&DUGLDFFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\VWXG\
07DLQD59DQQLQHQ0+HGPDQ3-DNDOD36LSROD.XRSLR),
0LNNR7DLQD#NXKÀ
3XUSRVH,QWUDFDUGLDFWKURPEXVLVDQHVWDEOLVKHGKLJKULVNÀQGLQJIRUFDUGLRHP
EROLFVWURNH:HVWXGLHGZKHWKHUOHIWDWULXP /$ RUOHIWDWULDODSSHQGDJH /$$
YROXPHVPHDVXUHGZLWKFDUGLDFFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ F&7 SURYLGHDGGLWLRQDO
LQIRUPDWLRQRQULVNIDFWRUVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGFDUGLRHPEROLFVWURNHZLWKRXW
DWULDOÀEULOODWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&RQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV Q PDOHVPHDQDJH
\HDUV ZLWK DFXWH VWURNH RI VXVSHFWHG FDUGLRHPEROLF RULJLQ XQGHUZHQW F&7 ,Q
F&7/$DQG/$$YROXPHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJ6LPSVRQҋVPHWKRG7KHFRQWURO
SRSXODWLRQFRQVWLWXWHGRISDWLHQWVZLWKORZSUHWHVWSUREDELOLW\RIFRURQDU\DUWHU\
GLVHDVHDQGFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQRVLVLQF&7$SDLUZLVHFRPSDULVRQZDV
SHUIRUPHGZLWKSDWLHQWVDQGFRQWUROVPDWFKHGIRUDJHDQGJHQGHU
5HVXOWV 7ZHQW\WZR SDWLHQWV SURYHG WR KDYH HVWDEOLVKHG FDUGLRJHQLF ULVN IDF
WRUV FDUGLDFRUDRUWLFWKURPEXV/9DQHXU\VPRUWXPRXU IRUVWURNH,QSDLUZLVH
FRPSDULVRQVERWK/$ POYVPOS DQG/$$ POYVPO
S YROXPHVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ODUJHULQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGFDUGLRHPEROLF
VWURNHWKDQLQFRQWUROVXEMHFWV7KHXSSHUOLPLWV PHDQ6' IRUQRUPDO/$DQG
/$$YROXPHVZHUHPODQGPOLQFRQWUROVXEMHFWV%\WKHVHFULWHULD
VWURNHSDWLHQWVKDGHQODUJHG/$$DQG SDWLHQWVKDGHQODUJHG
/$6L[W\RQHRIWKHSDWLHQWV ZLWK/$$GLODWDWLRQKDGQRQHRIWKHSUHYL
RXVO\GHVFULEHGHVWDEOLVKHGULVNIDFWRUVIRUVWURNH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
&RQFOXVLRQ/$DQG/$$YROXPHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGFDUGLRJHQLFVWURNH
DUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHG(QODUJHG/$DQGRU/$$YROXPHPHDVXUHGZLWKF&7
PD\FRQVWLWXWHDQLQGHSHQGHQWULVNIDFWRUIRUFDUGLRHPEROLFVWURNH
%
)UHTXHQWDQGZLGHVSUHDGYDVFXODUDEQRUPDOLWLHVLQKXPDQ67$7
GHÀFLHQF\GHWHFWHGE\ZKROHERG\05DQGFDUGLDF&7VFDQ
$$$]DULQH2&KDQGHVULV&3LFDUG(0RXVVHDX[3%RXWRX\ULH=0DOODW
$)LVFKHU3DULV)5 DUVKLGD]DULQH#HJSDSKSIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSUHYDOHQFHDQGFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIFDUGLRYDVFXODUDE
QRUPDOLWLHV LQ 67$7 GHÀFLHQF\ UHVSRQVLEOH IRU DXWRVRPDOGRPLQDQW K\SHU,J(
V\QGURPH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H SURVSHFWLYHO\ VFUHHQHG DGXOW 67$7GHÀFLHQW
SDWLHQWV PHGLDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH IRUYDVFXODUDEQRUPDOLWLHV7KH\
ZHUHH[SORUHGZLWKZKROHERG\PDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJDQJLRJUDSK\SURVSHF
WLYHFRURQDU\PXOWLVOLFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQGHFKRWUDFNLQJEDVHGLPDJLQJ
RIWKHFDURWLGDUWHULHV
5HVXOWV%UDLQDEQRUPDOLWLHV ZKLWHPDWWHUK\SHULQWHQVLWLHVODFXQDUOHVLRQVVXJJHV
WLYHRILVFKDHPLFLQIDUFWVDWURSK\ ZHUHIRXQGLQRISDWLHQWV3HULSKHUDODQG
FHUHEUDODUWHU\DEQRUPDOLWLHVZHUHUHSRUWHGLQRISDWLHQWVZKHUHDVFRURQDU\
DUWHU\DEQRUPDOLWLHVZHUHGHWHFWHGLQ7KHPRVWIUHTXHQWYDVFXODUDEQRUPDOL
WLHVZHUHHFWDVLDDQGDQHXU\VP7KHFDURWLGLQWLPDPHGLDWKLFNQHVVZDVPDUNHGO\
GHFUHDVHGZLWKDVXEVWDQWLDOLQFUHDVHLQFLUFXPIHUHQWLDOZDOOVWUHVVLQGLFDWLQJWKH
RFFXUUHQFHRIK\SRWURSKLFDUWHULDOUHPRGHOOLQJLQWKLV67$7GHÀFLHQWSRSXODWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&RURQDU\DQGSHULSKHUDOYDVFXODUDEQRUPDOLWLHVDUHKLJKO\SUHYDOHQW
LQ67$7GHÀFLHQWSDWLHQWV
%
$QRPDORXVFRURQDU\DUWHU\RULJLQDWLQJIURPRSSRVLWHFRURQDU\
VLQXVIUHTXHQWO\UHYHDOVPXOWLSOHKLJKULVNDQDWRP\IHDWXUHV
0.UXSLQVNL70LV]DOVNL-DPND%/DVNRZLF]%5yJ5%DQ\V
08UEDQF]\N=DZDG]ND0.RVWNLHZLF].UDNRZ3/
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHSUHYDOHQFHRIKLJKULVNDQDWRP\
IHDWXUHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDQRPDORXVRULJLQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\IURPRSSRVLWHFRURQDU\
VLQXV +LJK ULVN DQDWRP\ YDULDQWV LQFOXGH LQWHUDUWHULDO FRXUVH QDUURZHG VOLWOLNH
RULÀFHDFXWHDQJOHRIWDNHRIILQWUDPXUDOFRXUVHDQGK\SRSODVLD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZKRZHUHVFKHGXOHGIRUVOLFHRUGXDO
VRXUFH FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ FRURQDU\ DQJLRJUDSK\ &7&$ GXH WR VXVSHFWHG
REVWUXFWLYH FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ GLVHDVH ZHUH VFUHHQHG IRU WKH DQRPDORXV RULJLQ RI
FRURQDU\DUWHU\IURPRSSRVLWHFRURQDU\VLQXV3DWLHQWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGLQWHUPVRI
FRXUVHRIDQRPDORXVVHJPHQWSUHVHQFHRIREVWUXFWLYHFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVH
DQGKLJKULVNDQDWRP\
5HVXOWV $QRPDORXV RULJLQ RI FRURQDU\ DUWHU\ DW LPSURSHU VLQXV RI 9DOVDOYD
ZDVIRXQGLQ SDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV
(LJKWHHQSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWHGFLUFXPÁH[DUWHU\RULJLQDWLQJDWULJKWFRURQDU\DUWHU\
VLQXV $/&[ SDWLHQWVULJKWFRURQDU\DUWHU\RULJLQDWLQJIURPOHIWFRURQDU\VLQXV
$5&$ DQGSDWLHQWVOHIWFRURQDU\DUWHU\RULJLQDWLQJIURPULJKWFRURQDU\VLQXV
$/&$ +LJKULVNDQDWRP\ZDVIRXQGLQ RIWKHVHVXEMHFWVLQWHUDUWHULDO
FRXUVHLQVOLWOLNHRULÀFHLQDFXWHDQJOHRIWDNHRIILQLQWUDPXUDOFRXUVHLQ
DQGK\SRSODVLDLQLQGLYLGXDOV3DWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJREVWUXFWLYHFRURQDU\DUWHU\
GLVHDVHLQDQRPDORXVVHJPHQWKDGDFXWHWDNHRIIDQJOH S DQGVOLWOLNHRULÀFH
S PRUHIUHTXHQWO\WKDQRWKHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKULVNDQDWRP\LVSUHVHQWLQWKHPDMRULW\RISDWLHQWVZLWKDQRPDORXV
RULJLQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\DWRSSRVLWHFRURQDU\VLQXVDQGLVRIWHQDFFRPSDQLHGE\
REVWUXFWLYHFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHLQWKHDQRPDORXVVHJPHQW
%
,WDOLDQFDUGLDF&7UHJLVWU\SUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
)&DGHPDUWLUL0)UDQFRQH/3DWULDUFD,&DUERQH*/LJDEXH//RYDWR
('L&HVDUH0RQDVWLHUGL7UHYLVR,75RPH,7/ҋ$TXLOD,70RGHQD,7
%RORJQD,7 ÀOLSSRFDGHPDUWLUL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH&DUGLDF&7 &&7 LVDQLPDJLQJPRGDOLW\WKDWLVEHFRPLQJDVWDQGDUG
LQ FOLQLFDO FDUGLRORJ\ :H HYDOXDWHG LQGLFDWLRQV VDIHW\ DQG LPSDFW RQ SDWLHQW
PDQDJHPHQWRIURXWLQH&&7LQDPXOWLFHQWUHQDWLRQDOUHJLVWU\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 'XULQJ D SHULRG RI PRQWKV FHQWUHV LQ ,WDO\ ZH
HQUROOHGSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJ&&7IRUDQ\LQGLFDWLRQ
5HVXOWV$WRWDORIFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZHUHHQUROOHG&&7ZDVSHUIRUPHG
PDLQO\ZLWKVOLFH&7VFDQQHUV DQGZLWKUHWURVSHFWLYH(&*JDWLQJ
,Q RIWKHFDVHV&&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWK,9FRQWUDVW
PDWHULDO,Q RIWKHFDVHVSKDUPDFRORJLFDOPDQDJHPHQWRIKHDUWUDWH
ZDVSHUIRUPHG KHDUWUDWHGXULQJ&&7 ESP 0HDQ'/3ZDV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
P6Y 7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWLQGLFDWLRQIRU&&7ZDVVXVSHFWHG&$'
IROORZHGE\HYDOXDWLRQRIFRURQDU\VWHQW ,Q SDWLHQWV
WKHUHZDVDVWUHVVWHVWSULRUWR&&70RVWRIWKH&&7ZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQRXWSDWLHQW
VHWWLQJV DQGDPLQRULW\LQLQSDWLHQWVVHWWLQJV :HUHSRUWHG
FOLQLFDOHYHQWV PDLQO\UHODWHGWRFRQWUDVWPDWHULDO RIZKLFKWKHPDMRULW\
ZHUHPLOGDQGQRQHZDVVHYHUH,Q RIWKHFDVHV&&7
ÀQGLQJVLPSDFWHGSDWLHQWPDQDJHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ&&7LVSHUIRUPHGZLWKGLIIHUHQWZRUNORDGVDQGSURÀOHLQSDUWLFLSDWLQJ
FHQWUHV7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWLQGLFDWLRQIRU&&7LVGHWHFWLRQH[FOXVLRQRIVXVSHFWHG
&$' &&7 LPDJLQJ LV D VDIH SURFHGXUH DQG LWV UHVXOWV KDYH VWURQJ LPSDFW RQ
SDWLHQWPDQDJHPHQW
%
3UHYDOHQFHRI05,GHWHFWHGXQUHFRJQLVHGP\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQDQG
LWVUHODWLRQWRFHUHEUDOLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVLQERWKJHQGHUV
&(EHOLQJ%DUELHU51\ODQGHU57KHPXGR+$KOVWURP
//LQG(0/DUVVRQ7%MHUQHU/-RKDQVVRQ8SSVDOD6(
&KDUORWWH(EHOLQJB%DUELHU#UDGLROXXVH
3XUSRVH 7R LQYHVWLJDWH WKH SUHYDOHQFH RI XQUHFRJQLVHG P\RFDUGLDO LQIDUFWLRQ
80, GHWHFWHGZLWKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, DQGZKHWKHULWLVUHODWHG
WRFHUHEUDOLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVRQ05,LQDQHOGHUO\SRSXODWLRQEDVHGFRKRUW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&HUHEUDO05,DQGFDUGLDFODWHHQKDQFHPHQW /( 05,
ZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQUDQGRPO\VHOHFWHG\HDUROGVXEMHFWV ZRPHQ
PHQ ,PDJHVZHUHDVVHVVHGIRUFHUHEUDOLVFKDHPLFOHVLRQVDQG0,VFDUV0HGLFDO
UHFRUGVZHUHVFUXWLQLVHG6XEMHFWVZLWK0,VFDUVZLWKRUZLWKRXWDKRVSLWDOGLDJQRVLV
RI0,ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDV50,RU80,UHVSHFWLYHO\
5HVXOWV80,VZHUHIRXQGLQVXEMHFWV DQG50,VLQ 7KHSUHYD
OHQFHRI80,V S DQG50,V S ZDVJUHDWHULQPHQWKDQLQZRPHQ
0HQZLWK50,GLVSOD\HGDQLQFUHDVHGSUHYDOHQFHRIFRUWLFDODQGODFXQDUFHUHEUDO
LQIDUFWLRQVZKHUHDVZRPHQZLWK80,PRUHIUHTXHQWO\KDGFRUWLFDOFHUHEUDOLQIDUF
WLRQV S
&RQFOXVLRQ0,VFDUVDUHPRUHIUHTXHQWLQPHQWKDQLQZRPHQDW\HDUVRI
DJH7KHSUHYDOHQFHRI50,LVUHODWHGWRWKDWRIFHUHEUDOLQIDUFWLRQV7KLVPLJKW
RQO\DSSO\WRPHQZKHUHDVZRPHQZLWK80,GLVSOD\DQLQFUHDVHGSUHYDOHQFHRI
FRUWLFDOFHUHEUDOLQIDUFWLRQV)XUWKHUVWXGLHVDUHQHHGHGWRFODULI\JHQGHUVSHFLÀF
PRUELGLW\FRUUHODWLRQVDQGULVNV
%
$JHDQGVH[UHODWHGGLIIHUHQFHVLQRXWFRPHEDVHGRQFRURQDU\
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\SUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVIURPWKH
,WDOLDQ1DWLRQDO3525(&$'5HJLVWU\
(0DIIHL&0DUWLQL00LGLUL66HLWXQ05HQJR95XVVR
0)UDQFRQH)&DGHPDUWLUL0RQDVWLHUGL7UHYLVR,73DOHUPR,7*HQRD,7
/DWLQD,7%RORJQD,75RPH,7
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5RRP12
(PHUJHQF\5DGLRORJ\
66
$FXWHDEGRPHQ
0RGHUDWRUV
-0$UWLJDV=DUDJR]D(6
99LHWK0QVWHU'(
%
5HTXHVWLQJUDGLRORJLFDOLQYHVWLJDWLRQVGRMXQLRUGRFWRUVNQRZWKHLU
SDWLHQWV"
-&KR'&%RVDQTXHW1:LOOLDPV'*RZHU.*RZHU7KRPDV0+/HZLV
/ODQWULVDQW8. MXQFKR#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R DVFHUWDLQ FOLQLFLDQVҋ NQRZOHGJH RI WKHLU SDWLHQWV ZKHQ UHTXHVWLQJ
UDGLRORJLFDOLQYHVWLJDWLRQVDVUHTXLUHGOHJDOO\E\JRYHUQPHQWOHJLVODWLRQ´,RQLVLQJ
5DGLDWLRQ 0HGLFDO ([SRVXUH 5HJXODWLRQV µ ,50(5 IROORZLQJ WKH
LPSOHPHQWDWLRQRI(XURSHDQ:RUNLQJ7LPH'LUHFWLYH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QRXULQVWLWXWLRQDOOUDGLRORJLFDOLQYHVWLJDWLRQUHTXHVWV
H[FOXGLQJSODLQÀOPVDUHUHTXLUHGWREHGLVFXVVHGZLWKDFRQVXOWDQWUDGLRORJLVW
$OOVXFKUHTXHVWVUHFHLYHGHYHU\0RQGD\IROORZLQJWKHZHHNHQGRQFDOOZHUHFRO
OHFWHGSURVSHFWLYHO\RYHUZHHNV'DWDLQFOXGHGJUDGHRIUHTXHVWLQJGRFWRUWKHLU
VSHFLDOW\W\SHVRIPRGDOLW\UHTXHVWHGNQRZOHGJHRIWKHLUSDWLHQWDGGUHVVRJUDSK
VLJQDWXUHFRQÀUPLQJLGHQWLW\DQGDSSURSULDWHQHVVRILQYHVWLJDWLRQ7KHUHZHUHQR
H[FOXVLRQ FULWHULD 6WDWLVWLFDO DQDO\VLV XVLQJ D WZRWDLOHG )LVKHUҋV H[DFW WHVW ZDV
SHUIRUPHGIRUDOOGDWD
5HVXOWVUHTXHVWVZHUHUHFHLYHGWKHPDMRULW\ ZHUHPDGHE\)RXQGD
WLRQ3URJUDPPH )3 GRFWRUVDQGJHQHUDOPHGLFDOVSHFLDOWLHVDFFRXQWHGIRU
WKHKLJKHVWSURSRUWLRQRIUHTXHVWV 8OWUDVRXQGVFDQZDVPRVWIUHTXHQWO\
UHTXHVWHG FORVHO\IROORZHGE\FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\VFDQV $OPRVW
DRQHWKLUG RIUHTXHVWVZHUHPDGHE\GRFWRUVZKRKDGQRWVHHQWKHSDWLHQW
WREHLQYHVWLJDWHGSUHGRPLQDQWO\E\)3GRFWRUV S DQGPRUHIUHTXHQWO\
E\JHQHUDOPHGLFDOVSHFLDOWLHV S 6LJQDWXUHVZHUHDEVHQWLQRIWKH
DGGUHVVRJUDSKVDQGRYHUDOORIUHTXHVWVZHUHGHHPHGLQDSSURSULDWH
&RQFOXVLRQ,QDOPRVWDRQHWKLUGRIUDGLRORJLFDOUHTXHVWVGRFWRUVKDYHQRWVHHQ
SDWLHQWVWREHLQYHVWLJDWHGPRVWOLNHO\DUHVXOWRIVKLIWZRUNLQJSDWWHUQV7KLVGRHV
QRWIXOÀOWKH,50(5FULWHULDDQGSRWHQWLDOO\H[SRVHVSDWLHQWVWRXQQHFHVVDU\
LQDSSURSULDWHUDGLDWLRQ
%
$FXWHSDQFUHDWLWLVTXDOLWDWLYHDQGTXDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQXVLQJ':
05,ZLWKSDUDOOHOLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHDQGPXOWLSOHEJUDGLHQWIDFWRUYDOXHV
3%RUDVFKL)'RQDWL5*LJRQL)3DFFLDUGL**KHUDUGXFFL&%DUWROR]]L
))DODVFKL3LVD,7 SERUDVFKL#GRPHGXQLSLLW
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHXVHIXOQHVVRITXDOLWDWLYHDQGTXDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQ
XVLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJ ':05, ZLWKSDUDOOHOLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHDQG
PXOWLSOHEJUDGLHQWIDFWRUYDOXHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHSDQFUHDWLWLV $3
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$VHULHVRIHLJKWHHQSDWLHQWVZLWKDFOLQLFDOGLDJQRVLVRI
$3XQGHUZHQW05LPDJLQJDW7GHYLFH 6LJQD+'[W*(+HDOWKFDUH $IWHUWKH
DFTXLVLWLRQRID[LDO77ZVHTXHQFHVDQGFRURQDO05&3':05,ZDVSHUIRUPHG
XVLQJDQD[LDOEUHDWKKROGVLQJOHVKRWVSLQHFKRHFKRSODQDU 6((3, VHTXHQFH
SDUDOOHOLPDJLQJIDFWRU WKHYDOXHVRIEIDFWRUZHUHVHWDW
VPPò$OO':LPDJHVZHUHEOLQGO\LQWHUSUHWHG4XDOLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQZDV
SHUIRUPHGE\FRQVHQVXVUHDGLQJRIWZRUHYLHZHUVWKDWHYDOXDWHGWKHSUHVHQFHRU
DEVHQFHRI$3DQGFRPSOLFDWLRQV4XDQWLWDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGE\WZR
RWKHUUDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQIHUHQFHWKDWFDOFXODWHGPHDQ$'&YDOXHVIRUHDFKSDWLHQW
XVLQJDEYDOXHRIVPPò
5HVXOWV':,FRXOGGHWHFWDFXWHSDQFUHDWLWLVDVSHUVLVWHQWEULJKWVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\DW
GLIIHUHQWEJUDGLHQWIDFWRUYDOXHV7KHUHYLHZHUVZHUHDEOHWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHLQÁDP
PDWLRQIURPQHFURWLFDQGKDHPRUUKDJLFWLVVXHDQGLGHQWLÀHGSRVVLEOHFDXVHVRI$3
FKROHGRFKROLWKLDVLVDQGSDQFUHDVGLYLVXP RQ05LPDJHVLQFDVHV)XUWKHUPRUH
WKHPHDQSDQFUHDWLF$'&YDOXHLQWKH$3JURXSZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQLQWKH
QRUPDOFRQWUROJURXS S
&RQFOXVLRQ':05,ZLWKSDUDOOHOLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHDQGPXOWLSOHEJUDGLHQWIDF
WRUYDOXHVFDQDVVHVVWKHPDQLIHVWDWLRQVRIDFXWHSDQFUHDWLWLVXVLQJQRFRQWUDVW
PDWHULDODQGKDVWKHSRWHQWLDORIEHFRPLQJDSRZHUIXOWRROIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQDQG
IROORZXSRIWKHVHSDWLHQWV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHSURJQRVWLFYDOXHRIVOLFHFRURQDU\FRPSXWHGWRPRJ
UDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\ &&7$ LQUHODWLRQWRDJHDQGJHQGHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HHYDOXDWHGDFRKRUWRISDWLHQWVZLWKRXWNQRZQ
&$'ZKRXQGHUZHQWDVOLFH&&7$7KHSULPDU\HQGSRLQWZDVWKHRFFXUUHQFHRI
P\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQKRVSLWDOLVDWLRQIRUXQVWDEOHDQJLQDDQGGHDWKIURPDOOFDXVHV
8QLYDULDEOHDQGPXOWLYDULDEOH&R[SURSRUWLRQDOKD]DUGVPRGHOVZHUHGHYHORSHG
WRDVVHVVSRWHQWLDOSUHGLFWRUV
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVKDG\HDUV PDOH DQGWKHUHPDLQLQJKDG
\HDUV PDOH 7KHSUHYDOHQFHRIQRUPDOFRURQDU\DUWHULHVZDV Q
ZKHUHDV WKH SUHYDOHQFH RI QRQVLJQLÀFDQW VWHQRVLV DQG VLJQLÀFDQW
&$'ZDV UHVSHFWLYHO\Q DQGQ $WDPHDQIROORZXSRI
GD\V HYHQWV KDG RFFXUUHG ,Q ULVNDGMXVWHG DQDO\VLV RE
VWUXFWLYH S DQGQRQREVWUXFWLYH S &$'FRQIHUUHGLQFUHDVHGULVN
FRPSDUHGZLWKSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWHYLGHQW&$'7KHQXPEHURIGLVHDVHGVHJPHQWV
S DQGWKHQXPEHURIVHJPHQWV S DQGYHVVHOV S ZLWKVLJ
QLÀFDQW&$'ZHUHLQGHSHQGHQWSURJQRVWLFLQGLFDWRUV1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQ
RXWFRPHZHUHREVHUYHGEHWZHHQPDOHDQGIHPDOHSDWLHQWVLQHDFKDJHFDWHJRULHV
RU\HDUV 6LJQLÀFDQW&$'ZDVDQLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRURIHYHQWVIRUERWK
SDWLHQWVZLWK\HDUVDQG\HDUVDQGLQPDOHEXWQRWIRUIHPDOHSDWLHQWV
)RUIHPDOHSDWLHQWVLQGHSHQGHQWSUHGLFWRUVZHUHWKHQXPEHURIYHVVHOV S
DQGVHJPHQWV S ZLWKVLJQLÀFDQW&$'
&RQFOXVLRQ 3UHVHQFH RI VLJQLÀFDQW &$' LV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK D SRRU SURJQRVLV
&&7$KDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRLPSURYHULVNVWUDWLÀFDWLRQDFFRUGLQJWRDJHDQGVH[
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
(UHFWFKHVWUDGLRJUDSKLQWKHVHWWLQJRIWKHDFXWHDEGRPHQ
HVVHQWLDOWRRORUZDVWHRIUHVRXUFHVDQGXQQHFHVVDU\
6$OD]]DZL:6SUHQJHU'H5RYHU*0RUULV6WLII0+/HZLV/RQGRQ8.
1RWWLQJKDP8.&OHYHODQG2+86/ODQWULVDQW8.
3XUSRVH 7R UHYLHZ WKH TXDQWLW\ DQG TXDOLW\ RI UHTXHVWV IRU HPHUJHQF\ FKHVW
UDGLRJUDSKV &;5 LQSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJZLWKDEGRPLQDOV\PSWRPV7KH5R\DO
&ROOHJHRI5DGLRORJ\ 5&5 UHFRPPHQGVD&;5ZLWKVXVSHFWHGYLVFRXVSHUIRUD
WLRQWRH[FOXGHDLUXQGHUWKHGLDSKUDJPEXWGRHVQRWVXSHUVHGHDWKRURXJKFOLQLFDO
H[DPLQDWLRQDQGVKRXOGQRWEHGRQHURXWLQHO\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$UHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIDOOSDWLHQWVDGPLWWHGWRWKH
5R\DO*ODPRUJDQ+RVSLWDO 8. ZLWKDFXWHDEGRPLQDOSDLQZDVGRQHIRUPRQWKV
LQ,QFOXVLRQFULWHULDVXUJLFDODGPLVVLRQVZLWKDEGRPLQDOSDLQDJHGRYHU
7KHUHTXHVWVDQGUHSRUWVRIWKH&;5VZHUHHYDOXDWHGDQGFRPSDUHGWRQDWLRQ
DOO\DFFHSWHGJXLGHOLQHVSURGXFHGE\WKH5&5WRORRNDWWKHDSSURSULDWHQHVVRI
WKHUHTXHVWV
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWHGZLWKDFXWHDEGRPLQDOSDLQKDGDQHUHFW&;5
RQDGPLVVLRQ2IWKHVHZHUHFOLQLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWVKRZLQJSRVVLEOHPHGLFDO
FDXVHVIRUWKHSDLQDQGDOWHULQJPDQDJHPHQW2QO\ZHUHVXUJLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
VKRZLQJIUHHJDVXQGHUWKHGLDSKUDJP,WLVDUJXDEOHWKDW RI KDG
XQQHFHVVDU\ &;5V ZKLFK FRQWULEXWHG QR QHZ LQIRUPDWLRQ WRZDUGV WUHDWLQJ WKH
SDWLHQW ,Q IDFW LI QR ROG UDGLRORJ\ UHFRUGV ZHUH DYDLODEOH WKLV FRXOG KDYH EHHQ
PLVOHDGLQJDV RI KDGDEQRUPDOÀQGLQJVRIZKLFKQRQHZHUHQHZ
&RQFOXVLRQ 9DVW URRP WR UHGXFH XQQHFHVVDU\ &;5V EHLQJ RUGHUHG 6WULFWHU
DGKHUHQFHWRWKH5&5JXLGHOLQHV/LPLWLQJWKH&;5UHTXHVWVLQWKHSUHVHQFHRI
DEGRPLQDO SDLQ XQOHVV WKHUH DUH YHU\ FOHDU LQGLFDWLRQV RU XQOHVV ÀUVW UHYLHZHG
E\JHQHUDOVXUJHU\%\LPSOHPHQWLQJJXLGHOLQHVDQGWUXVWLQJFOLQLFDOÀQGLQJVFDQ
UHGXFHWKHÀQDQFLDOUDGLDWLRQDQGWLPHFRVWV
%
3UHGLFWLRQRIERZHOQHFURVLVH[WHQWEDVLQJRQWKHGHJUHHRIERZHO
GLODWDWLRQGHWHFWHGE\&7UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
00RVFKHWWD$$6WDELOH,DQRUD)/RUXVVR07HOHJUDIR$6FDUGDSDQH
*$QJHOHOOL%DUL,7 PDUFRPRVFKHWWD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KLVVWXG\DLPVWRFRUUHODWHWKHGHJUHHRIERZHOGLODWDWLRQGHWHFWHGE\
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7 DQGWKHH[WHQWRIERZHOQHFURVLVLQSDWLHQWVDIIHFWHG
E\PHVHQWHULFLQIDUFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\VHYHQSDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\ERZHOLQIDUFWLRQGXHWR
YDVFXODUREVWUXFWLRQZHUHDVVHVVHGE\0'&7H[DPLQDWLRQVHDUFKLQJIRUSDWKRJQR
PRQLFVLJQVRILVFKDHPLDDQGIRUWKHGHJUHHRIERZHOGLODWDWLRQ VXEGLYLGHGLQWR
JURXSVHQWLUHVPDOOERZHO 6% RI6%RI6%ODUJHERZHORQO\ 7ZR
EOLQGHGUDGLRORJLVWVHYDOXDWHGPXOWLSODQDUDQG'WUDQVSDUHQWZDOOUHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
&RKHQ VNDSSDVWDWLVWLFVZDVXVHGLQRUGHUWRDVVHVVLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQW
&7ÀQGLQJVZHUHWKHQFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHPRUWDOLW\UDWH
5HVXOWV$UWHULDO YDVFXODU REVWUXFWLRQ ZDV IRXQG LQ RI FDVHV DQG YHQRXV
WKURPERVLVLQWKHUHPDLQLQJ7KHRYHUDOOPRUWDOLW\UDWHZDVZLWKD
YDOXHIRUDUWHULDOIRUPVDQGLQFDVHRIYHQRXVLQIDUFWLRQV7KHHQWLUH6%GLODWD
WLRQRUD6%GLODWDWLRQFRUUHODWHGZLWKSRRUSURJQRVLVLQDOOFDVHVD
6%GLODWDWLRQFRUUHODWHGZLWKJRRGSURJQRVLVLQRIFDVHV$ODUJHERZHORQO\
GLODWDWLRQGLGQRWVKRZDVLJQLÀFDQWSURJQRVWLFYDOXH$OPRVWSHUIHFWDJUHHPHQW
EHWZHHQWKHWZRUHDGHUVZDVIRXQG N
&RQFOXVLRQ$OWKRXJKERZHOGLODWDWLRQGRHVQRWUHSUHVHQWDVSHFLÀFVLJQRIERZHO
LVFKDHPLDZKHQDVVRFLDWHGZLWKRWKHUSDWKRJQRPRQLF&7ÀQGLQJVLWFDQSURYLGH
XVHIXOSURJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQEHFDXVHD6%GLODWDWLRQFRUUHODWHVZLWKKLJKHU
H[WHQWRIERZHOQHFURVLVDQGZLWKSRRUSURJQRVLV
%
)LQGLQJVRIVLJPRLGYROYXOXVDW&7
$)XVWLHU0&-XOOHV0=LQV3DULV)5 DQQHIXVWLHU#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHREMHFWLYHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHIHDWXUHVRIVLJPRLGYRO
YXOXVDW&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVZDVDUHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIFDVHVRIVLJPRLG
YROYXOXVLQPHQDQGIRXUZRPHQH[SORUHGE\&7ZLWKLQKRXUVEHIRUHVXUJL
FDO Q RUHQGRVFRSLF Q WUHDWPHQW,QFDVHV&7ZDVDVVRFLDWHGZLWK
FRQWUDVWHQHPD7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVDVVHVVHGLQFRQVHQVXVWKH&7GLDJQRVWLFVLJQV
DQGWKHWRSRJUDSKLFDOW\SHRIYROYXOXV RUJDQRD[LDORUPHVHQWHULFRD[LDO 7KH
FOLQLFDO UDGLRORJLFDO DQG HYROXWLYH IHDWXUHV RI WKH SDWLHQWV ZHUH FRUUHODWHG ZLWK
WKHWRSRJUDSKLFDOW\SHRIYROYXOXV )LVKHUH[DFWWHVWDQG0DQQ:KLWQH\8WHVW
7KH&7VLJQVRIVHYHULW\ZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKLVFKDHPLFÀQGLQJVLQHQGRVFRS\RU
SDWKRORJ\ )LVFKHUH[DFWWHVW
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5HVXOWV Q RIVLJPRLGYROYXOXVKDGDQRUJDQRD[LDOFRQÀJXUDWLRQZLWK
RQHWUDQVLWLRQSRLQW7KHZKLUOVLJQZDVWKHPRVWIUHTXHQWGLDJQRVWLFVLJQVHHQLQ
RIWKHFDVHVXVLQJPXOWLSODQDUUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVDQGVWDFNPRGHYLHZLQJ7KHUH
ZDV QR VLJQLÀFDWLYH GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ WKH PHVHQWHULFRD[LDO DQG RUJDQRD[LDO
IRUPLQWHUPVRIFOLQLFDOVHYHULW\PHDQDJHVLJPRLGORRSRSDFLÀFDWLRQE\HQHPD
UHFLGLYHUDWHDIWHUFRQVHUYDWLYHWUHDWPHQW2QO\SDULHWDOLVFKDHPLFVLJQV ODFNRI
HQKDQFHPHQWSDULHWDOWKLFNHQLQJDQGSQHXPDWRVLVLQWHVWLQDOLV ZHUHFRUUHODWHG
ZLWKFOLQLFDOO\SURYHGLVFKDHPLD S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHPRVWIUHTXHQWFRQÀJXUDWLRQRIVLJPRLGYROYXOXVLVWKHRUJDQR
D[LDO W\SH 7KH ZKLUO VLJQ LV FRQVWDQWO\ IRXQG 3DULHWDO LVFKDHPLF &7 VLJQV DUH
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKSURYHGLVFKDHPLD
%
$EGRPLQDO&7LQHPHUJHQF\KRZWRDYRLGWKHPLVVHGGLDJQRVLVRI
DSSHQGLFLWLV
(3DFH$)LOLSSRQH5&LDQFL9%LDQFR*(VSRVLWR$&RWURQHR&KLHWL,7
3XUSRVH7RHVWDEOLVKWKHFDXVHVRIPLVVHGGLDJQRVLVRIDSSHQGLFLWLVRQPXOWL
GHWHFWRUURZ&7 0'&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWKSURYHQDSSHQGLFLWLVIRU
ZKRPWKHGLDJQRVLVZDVPLVVHGRQSUHRSHUDWLYH0'&7$FRQWUROJURXSRISD
WLHQWVZLWKDFRUUHFW0'&7GLDJQRVLVRIDSSHQGLFLWLVZDVVHOHFWHGIRUFRPSDULVRQ
7ZRH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWVZKRZHUHDZDUHRIWKHGLDJQRVLVRIDSSHQGLFLWLVUH
HYDOXDWHG0'&7LPDJHVRIWKHFDVHDQGWKHFRQWUROJURXSV7KHFDVHDQGFRQWURO
JURXS&7IHDWXUHVZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJWKH)LVFKHUҋVH[DFWWHVW
5HVXOWV 6LJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV ZHUH IRXQG UHJDUGLQJ WKH SRVLWLRQ RI FDHFDO
SROH S DSSHQGLFROLWK S DSSHQGLFHDOLQÁDPPDWRU\FKDQJHV
S VWUDQGLQJRISHULDSSHQGLFHDOIDW S ÁXLGFROOHFWLRQDQGRUJDV
EXEEOHV S VPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQRUFRORQLFGLYHUWLFXORVLV S
DPRXQWRISHULFDHFDOIDW S DQGFOLQLFDOKLVWRU\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ.QRZOHGJHRIWKHFDXVHVRILQFRUUHFWGLDJQRVLVRIDSSHQGLFLWLVDOORZV
WRDYRLGIDOVHQHJDWLYH&7UHSRUWV
%
$FXWHERZHOLVFKDHPLDDQDO\VLVRIGLDJQRVWLFHUURUE\SULPDULO\
RYHUORRNHGÀQGLQJVDWPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7DQJLRJUDSK\
0)LUHWWR$$/HPRV$0DULQL(&RQWHVVLQL$YHVDQL3%LRQGHWWL0LODQ,7
FULVWLQDI#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHIUHTXHQF\DQGW\SHRIÀQGLQJVWKDWZHUH
PLVVHGLQWKHRULJLQDOUHSRUWRIPXOWLGHWHFWRU&7DQJLRJUDSK\ 0'&7$ LQSDWLHQWV
ZLWKVXVSHFWHGDFXWHERZHOLVFKDHPLD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-DQXDU\XQWLO0DUFKSDWLHQWV
PDOHVIHPDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV ZKRXQGHUZHQW0'&7$ *(/LJKW
6SHHG :LVFRQVLQ 86$ DQG VXUJHU\ ZHUH LQFOXGHG LQ WKH VWXG\7KH UHSRUWV
RI WKH LQLWLDO &7 ZHUH UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ FRPSDUHG WR WKH GLVFKDUJH GLDJQRVLV DQG
RSHUDWLRQUHSRUWV'LVFUHSDQWRUPLVVLQJÀQGLQJVZHUHDQDO\VHGIRUWHFKQLFDODQG
RUGLDJQRVWLFHUURUVE\UHHYDOXDWLQJ0'&7$LPDJHVDQGGLYLGHGLQWR UHOHYDQW
DQG QRWUHOHYDQWIRUWKHGLDJQRVLV
5HVXOWV,QSDWLHQWV DOOÀQGLQJVZHUHFRUUHFWO\GLDJQRVHGLQWKHLQLWLDO
0'&7$,QWKHUHPDLQLQJSDWLHQWV OHVLRQVWKDWZHUHQRWUHSRUWHGZHUH
SUHVHQWDWVXUJHU\,Q SDWLHQWVRYHUORRNHGÀQGLQJVZHUHUHOHYDQWDQG
VXEWOH,Q SDWLHQWVZLWKERZHOGLODWLRQDQGIUHHÁXLGLQZKRPWKH0'&7$
RYHUORRNHGÀQGLQJVZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVQRQUHOHYDQWERZHOLVFKDHPLDZDVIRXQG
DWVXUJHU\:LWKUHWURVSHFWLYHLPDJHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQDOPRVWDOOSDWLHQWV ZLWK
ERZHOLVFKDHPLDZHUHFRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHGZKHUHDVWKHUHPDLQLQJSDWLHQWV
ZLWKQRQRFFOXVLYHLVFKDHPLDDWVXUJHU\VKRZHGQRQUHOHYDQWÀQGLQJVDW0'&7$
DOVRDWWKHUHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLV
&RQFOXVLRQ$ERXWRIUHOHYDQWÀQGLQJVRIERZHOLVFKDHPLDZHUHRYHUORRNHG
E\WKHLQLWLDO0'&7$LQWHUSUHWDWLRQPRVWO\ZHUHVXEWOHÀQGLQJV+RZHYHUVHFRQG
DU\UHDGLQJRI0'&7$VFDQVUHYHDOHGPRVWRIWKHVHÀQGLQJVDQGFDQVHUYHWR
LPSURYHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFH
%
&7GLDJQRVLVRIQDWXUHRIERZHOREVWUXFWLRQVPRUSKRORJLFDO
HYDOXDWLRQRIWKHWUDQVLWLRQDOSRLQW
00RVFKHWWD7&RVPR)%LQHWWL$6FDUGDSDQH$$6WDELOH,DQRUD
*$QJHOHOOL%DUL,7 PDUFRPRVFKHWWD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KLVVWXG\DLPVWRHYDOXDWHWKHPRUSKRORJ\RIWKHWUDQVLWLRQDOSRLQWLQ
GHÀQLQJWKHQDWXUHRIERZHOREVWUXFWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7H[DPLQDWLRQVRISDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\VHYHUHERZHO
REVWUXFWLRQ RIQHRSODVWLFRULJLQRIQRQQHRSODVWLFRULJLQ ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
HYDOXDWHGDQGWKHPRUSKRORJ\RIWKHWUDQVLWLRQDOSRLQWZDVFRQVLGHUHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHWUDQVLWLRQDOSRLQWZDVGHWHFWHGLQSDWLHQWV DQGLWVPRUSKRORJ\
ZDVFRQFDYHLQFDVHV OLQHDULQ FRQYH[LQ DVFRPSDUHG
ZLWKWKHSUR[LPDOORRS$FRQFDYHPRUSKRORJ\RIWKHWUDQVLWLRQDOSRLQWLQGLFDWHGD
QRQQHRSODVWLFFRQGLWLRQZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\YDOXHVRI
DQG UHVSHFWLYHO\$ OLQHDU DVSHFW SUHVHQWHG DOPRVW WKH VDPH
LQFLGHQFHDPRQJQHRSODVWLF DQGQRQQHRSODVWLF FRQGLWLRQV$FRQYH[
DVSHFWFRUUHODWHGZLWKDQHRSODVWLFSDWKRORJ\ZLWKVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\339139
DQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\YDOXHVRIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ,QFDVHRIERZHOREVWUXFWLRQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIWKHWUDQVLWLRQDOSRLQW
LQGLFDWHVWKHVLWHRIREVWUXFWLRQZKLOHLWVPRUSKRORJLFDOHYDOXDWLRQFDQFRQWULEXWH
WRGHÀQHWKHQDWXUH$FRQFDYHPRUSKRORJ\LQGLFDWHVDQRQQHRSODVWLFFRQGLWLRQ
ZLWKDKLJKSUREDELOLW\DFRQYH[PRUSKRORJ\FRUUHODWHVZLWKDQHRSODVWLFSDWKRORJ\
ZKLOHDOLQHDULW\LVQRWVLJQLÀFDQW
%
$EGRPLQDOSDHGLDWULFWUDXPDUDGLRORJLFÀQGLQJVDQGPDQDJLQJLQ
VROLGYLVFHUDLQMXU\
-*XLEHUQDX/LVLWDQR-,5LER*HURQD(6(VSOXJXHVGHO/OREUHJDW(6
5RRP3
3K\VLFVLQ5DGLRORJ\
66
'RVHRSWLPLVDWLRQDQGDVVHVVPHQWLQ&7
0RGHUDWRUV
.%DFKHU*HQW%(
-*HOHLMQV/HLGHQ1/
%
'RVHUHGXFWLRQZLWKDXWRPDWHGDWWHQXDWLRQEDVHGWXEHSRWHQWLDO
VHOHFWLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKWHVWLFXODUFDQFHU
5*QDQQW$:LQNOHKQHU'(EHUOL$.QXWK+$ONDGKL=XULFK&+
UDOSKJQDQQW#XV]FK
3XUSRVH7KHVWXG\DLPHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHPHWKRGRIPDQDJHPHQWDQGGLDJ
QRVLVRISDHGLDWULFEOXQWWUDXPDZLWKVROLGYLVFHUDLQMXU\DQGGHWHUPLQHWKHUROHRI
XOWUDVRXQGDQGFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\LPDJHRQLW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HXQGHUWRRND\HDUUHWURVSHFWLYHDXGLWRIFKLOGUHQ
DGPLWWHGWRWKH6DQW-RDQGH'qX+RVSLWDO%DUFHORQD6SDLQZLWKDKRVSLWDOFRGHG
GLDJQRVLVZKLFKLQFOXGHGKHSDWLFVSOHQLFNLGQH\SDQFUHDWLFDQGDGUHQDOLQMXU\
EHWZHHQDQG'DWDLQFOXGHGSDWLHQWGHPRJUDSKLFVUHVXOWVRIDQ\DFXWH
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQGRUXOWUDVRXQGLPDJLQJRIWKHRUJDQVUHODWHGUHVXOWVRI
DQ\VXUJLFDOÀQGLQJVDQGRXWFRPH
5HVXOWV RIWKHSDWLHQWV Q ZHUHPDOHVDQG IHPDOHVWKH
PHDQDJHZDV\HDUV UDQJH 8OWUDVRXQGZDVWKHÀUVWOLQHH[DPLQDWLRQ
LQSDWLHQWV DQGFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\LQ SDWLHQWV
ZHQWWRKDYHDFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DIWHUXOWUDVRXQGHYDOXDWLRQ IUHHÁXLGDVWKH
RQO\XOWUDVRXQGÀQGLQJ PRVWRIWKHPZKLWTXHVWLRQDEOHQRLPSDFWLQWKHUDSHXWLF
GHFLVLRQ7KHUDGLRORJLFÀQGLQJVLQFOXGHGVSOHHQLQMXU\LQRIFKLOGUHQ
NLGQH\OLYHUSDQFUHDVDQGDGUHQDOJODQGV&RQVHUYDWLYHPDQ
DJHPHQWZDVWKHFKRLFHLQFDVHVDOOWKH\KDHPRG\QDPLFDOO\VWDEOHFDVHV
ZHUHXQGHUJRLQJDFXWHLQWHUYHQWLRQERWKRIWKHKDHPRG\QDPLFDOO\XQVWDEOH
FDVHVKDGSRVWWUDXPDFRPSOLFDWLRQVVXFKDVXULQRPDDQGSDQFUHDWLFSVHXGRF\VWV
&RQFOXVLRQ 8OWUDVRXQG LV WKH ÀUVWOLQH LPDJLQJ LQ SDHGLDWULF EOXQW DEGRPLQDO
WUDXPD7KHDUHQRHVWDEOLVKHGJXLGHOLQHVWRDVVHVSDHGLDWULFFRPSXWHGWRPRJ
UDSK\DQGPRVWRIWKHVWXGLHVKDYHTXHVWLRQDEOHLPSDFWLQWKHUDSHXWLFGHFLVLRQ
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKWHVWLFXODUVHPLQRPDWKHUDGLD
WLRQGRVHVDYLQJSRWHQWLDODQGLPDJHTXDOLW\RIDQRYHODOJRULWKPZKLFKDXWRPDWL
FDOO\VHOHFWVWXEHSRWHQWLDOEDVHGRQWKHSDWLHQWVҋDWWHQXDWLRQIURPWKHWRSRJUDP
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )RUW\ FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV PHDQ %0, NJ
P ZLWK WHVWLFXODU VHPLQRPD XQGHUZHQW FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG WKRUDFRDEGRPLQDO
VHFWLRQ&7ZLWKDXWRPDWHGWXEHSRWHQWLDOVHOHFWLRQ &DUHN9 DOOKDGDIRUHJR
LQJWKRUDFRDEGRPLQDO&7VWXG\DWN9 DXWRPDWHGWXEHFXUUHQWPRGXODWLRQ
UHIP$V 7ZRLQGHSHQGHQWUHDGHUVVHPLTXDOLWDWLYHO\DVVHVVHGLPDJHTXDO
LW\ WZR RWKHUV PHDVXUHG REMHFWLYH LPDJH TXDOLW\ SDUDPHWHUV 'RVH LQIRUPDWLRQ
&7',YRO ZDVQRWHG
5HVXOWV,QWKHN9VFDQVHIIHFWLYHWXEHFXUUHQWZDVHIIP$V UDQJH
HIIP$V IRUWKHFKHVWDQGHIIP$V UDQJHHIIP$V IRUWKH
DEGRPHQ:LWK&DUHN9HIIHFWLYHWXEHFXUUHQWVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGWRHII
P$V UDQJHHIIP$V IRUFKHVWDQGHIIP$V UDQJHHIIP$V
IRUDEGRPLQDOVFDQV8VHRI&DUHN9OHGWRDWXEHSRWHQWLDOUHGXFWLRQWRN9
LQFKHVWDQGDEGRPLQDODQGWRN9LQVFDQVWXEHSRWHQWLDOLQFUHDVHGWR
N9LQRQHSDWLHQW ERWKFKHVWDQGDEGRPHQ 2YHUDOO&7',YROZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
ORZHUIRU&DUHN9 P*\P*\ FRPSDUHGWRN9 P*\
P*\S 1RQHRIWKHGDWDVHWVZDVRIQRQGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDO
LW\:LWK&DUHN9VLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRUERWKFKHVWDQG
DEGRPHQ S FRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLRVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHDEGRPHQ
S DQGVLPLODULQWKHFKHVW S
&RQFOXVLRQ$VFRPSDUHGWRDSURWRFROZLWKÀ[HGN9XVHRIWKHDXWRPDWHG
WXEH SRWHQWLDO VHOHFWLRQ DOJRULWKP IRU WKRUDFRDEGRPLQDO &7 \LHOGV FRPSDUDEOH
LPDJHTXDOLW\DWDUHGXFHGUDGLDWLRQGRVHE\
%
%
&(86XVHIXOQHVVLQWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIKDHPRG\QDPLF
DEQRUPDOLWLHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKHQGROHDNIROORZLQJHQGRYDVFXODU
WUHDWPHQWRIDEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VPV
)3LQWR&$FDPSRUD$3LQWR5)DULQD61LFRWUD/5RPDQR1DSOHV,7
ISLQWR#OLEHURLW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
3XUSRVH7RHVWLPDWHDQGFRPSDUHWKHFXPXODWLYHOLIHWLPHDWWULEXWDEOHULVN /$5
RIUDGLDWLRQLQGXFHGFDQFHUIRUSDWLHQWVHQUROOHGLQDTXLQTXHQQLDOVFUHHQLQJ&7
FRORQRJUDSK\ &7& SURJUDPWRFRUUHVSRQGLQJQRPLQDOOLIHWLPHLQWULQVLFULVN /,5
RIFDQFHUDQGWKHULVNRIQRWSHUIRUPLQJDQ\VFUHHQLQJWHVW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$0RQWH&DUORVLPXODWLRQVRIWZDUHGHGLFDWHGIRU&7GRVLP
HWU\ZDVXVHGWRGHWHUPLQHDEVRUEHGGRVHVWRSULPDULO\H[SRVHGUDGLRVHQVLWLYH
RUJDQVRILQGLYLGXDOVVXEMHFWHGWRVFUHHQLQJ&7&RQDVOLFH&7VFDQQHU
2UJDQVSHFLÀFDQGWRWDO/$5VRIFDQFHUZHUHGHWHUPLQHG7KHFXPXODWLYH/$5VIRU
\HDUVROGLQGLYLGXDOVVXEMHFWHGWRVFUHHQLQJ&7&HYHU\ÀYH\HDUVXQWLOWKHDJH
RI\HDUVZHUHHVWLPDWHG7KHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ/,5VRIFDQFHUDQGWKHULVNRIQRW
SHUIRUPLQJWKHVFUHHQLQJWHVWZHUHHVWLPDWHGXVLQJWKHODWHVWFDQFHUVWDWLVWLFVGDWD
5HVXOWV 7KH FXPXODWLYH /$5 RI UDGLDWLRQLQGXFHG FDQFHU IURP UHSHDWHG TXLQ
TXHQQLDOVFUHHQLQJ&7&EHWZHHQWKHDJHVRIDQG\HDUVZDVHVWLPDWHGWR
EHZLWKKDOIRIWKHUDGLDWLRQLQGXFHGFDQFHUVDVVXPHGWREHIDWDO7KH
FRUUHVSRQGLQJLQFUHDVHLQWKH/,5RIFDQFHULQFLGHQFHZDVLQFUHDVHGE\OHVVWKDQ
,IQRWVFUHHQHGRIWKHHQWLUH86SRSXODWLRQEHWZHHQDQG\HDUV
DUHH[SHFWHGWRGHYHORSFRORUHFWDOFDQFHUGXULQJWKHLUUHPDLQLQJOLIHDQGGLHIURP
LW7KHFRUUHVSRQGLQJYDOXHIRUWKHVFUHHQHGSRSXODWLRQPD\GURSGRZQWR
DWWKHH[SHQVHRIDGGLWLRQDOWKHRUHWLFDOUDGLDWLRQLQGXFHGFDQFHUGHDWKV
&RQFOXVLRQ5DGLDWLRQULVNGRHVQRWFRQVWLWXWHDEDUULHUIRUDFFHSWLQJ&7&DVD
ÀUVWOLQHPDVVVFUHHQLQJWRROIRUFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RUHYHDOWKHXVHIXOQHVVRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG86 &(86 LQWKHGH
WHFWLRQDQGWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIKDHPRG\QDPLFDEQRUPDOLWLHVDVVRFLDWHGZLWK
HQGROHDNLQSDWLHQWVSUHYLRXVO\VXEPLWWHGWRHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRIDEGRPLQDO
DRUWLFDQHXU\VPV (9$5
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-DQXDU\WR-XO\FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV
PDOHV DQG IHPDOHV PHDQ DJH \HDUV ROG XQGHUZHQW WUHDWPHQW RI
DEGRPLQDODRUWLFDQHXU\VPV (9$5 $WGLDJQRVWLFVXUYHLOODQFHERWKDPXOWLGHWHF
WRUFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\ 0'&7$ H[DPDQGD&(86H[DPZHUH
SHUIRUPHGLQDOOWKHSDWLHQWVDIWHUPRQWKPRQWKVDQGPRQWKVUHVSHFWLYHO\
5HVXOWV$W0'&7LQSDWLHQWVQRFRPSOLFDWLRQZDVUHYHDOHGZKHUHDVLQWKH
UHPDLQLQJFDVHVWKHSUHVHQFHRIDYDVFXODUFRPSOLFDWLRQZDVVKRZQ DW\SH
,,HQGROHDNLQFDVHVDQGDW\SH,HQGROHDNLQWKHUHPDLQLQJFDVHV
$W&(86WKHGLDJQRVLVRIDW\SH,,HQGROHDNZDVREWDLQHGLQDOOWKHFDVHV
0RUHRYHULQFDVHVZLWKW\SH,,HQGROHDN&(86RXWSHUIRUPHG0'&7$ÀQG
LQJVE\HDUO\GHSLFWLQJVLQFHWKHÀUVWRUWKHVHFRQGFRQWURODQLQFUHDVHRIWKH
LQÁRZRXWÁRZUDWLRRIWKHFRQWUDVWDJHQWLQWKHVDFIROORZHGE\DQHXU\VPGLDPHWHU
HQODUJHPHQWDWWKHVHFRQGRUWKLUGIROORZXSH[DPV
&RQFOXVLRQ&(86UHSUHVHQWVDYDOLGDOWHUQDWLYHWRROLQWKHVXUYHLOODQFHRIYDVFXODU
FRPSOLFDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVVXEPLWWHGWRHQGRYDVFXODUWUHDWPHQWRIDEGRPLQDODRUWLF
DQHXU\VPV (9$5 7KLV PHWKRG FDQ EH XVHIXO IRU EHWWHU GHSLFWLQJ HQGROHDNV
IHDWXUHVWKDWPD\QRWEHVHHQDW0'&7$H[DP
6FUHHQLQJ&7FRORQRJUDSK\ZLWKVOLFHVFDQQLQJFRPSDULVRQRI
UDGLDWLRQULVNVDQGEHQHÀWV
.3HULVLQDNLV,6HLPHQLV$(3DSDGDNLV$7]HGDNLV-'DPLODNLV
,UDNOLRQ*5$OH[DQGURXSROLV*5 SHULVLQD#PHGXRFJU
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
5HGXFWLRQRIHIIHFWLYHDQGRUJDQGRVHWRWKHH\HOHQVLQFHUHEUDO
0'&7VFDQVXVLQJLWHUDWLYHLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
-=L]ND--DQGXUD7.YDVQLFND-*UHSO+UDGHF.UDORYH&=
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHHIIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGGRVHWRWKHH\HOHQVLQ0'&7
EUDLQH[DPLQDWLRQVXWLOLVLQJHLWKHUVWDQGDUGÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 WHFKQLTXH
RULWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQLPDJHVSDFH ,5,6
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 2I 0'&7 DGXOW EUDLQ H[DPLQDWLRQV ZHUH
SHUIRUPHGXVLQJVWDQGDUG)%3DQGXVLQJ,5,6$OOVFDQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQ
6LHPHQV6RPDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ$6V\VWHPZLWKSDUDPHWHUVWXEHYROWDJHN9
)%3 ,5,6 UHIHUHQFH P$V YDOXH )%3 DQG ,5,6 SLWFK IDFWRU
URWDWLRQWLPHVHF'RVHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGIURP&7GRVHLQGH[ &7',YROP*\
DQG GRVH OHQJWK SURGXFW '/3 P*\FP YDOXHV XWLOLVLQJ ,P3$&7 VRIWZDUH WKH
RUJDQ GRVH WR WKH OHQV ZDV GHULYHG IURP WKH DFWXDO WXEH FXUUHQWWLPH SURGXFW
YDOXHDSSOLHGWRWKHOHQV
5HVXOWV7KHDYHUDJH&7',YROZDVLQ)%3DQGLQ,5,6UHVSHFWLYHO\
GHFUHDVH 7KHDYHUDJH'/3ZDV )%3 DQG ,5,6 UHVSHFWLYHO\
GHFUHDVH 7KHDYHUDJHHIIHFWLYHVFDQGRVHZDVP6Y )%3 DQG
P6Y ,5,6 UHVSHFWLYHO\ GHFUHDVH 7KHDYHUDJHRUJDQGRVHWR
WKHH\HOHQVGHFUHDVHGIURPP*\ )%3 WRP*\ ,5,6
GHFUHDVH 1RVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHLQGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVQRWHGEHWZHHQ
,5,6DQGVWDQGDUG)%3VFDQV S
&RQFOXVLRQ ,WHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ RI FHUHEUDO 0'&7 H[DPLQDWLRQV HQDEOHV
UHGXFWLRQRIWKHHIIHFWLYHGRVHE\DWOHDVWRQHWKLUG&RUUHVSRQGLQJUHGXFWLRQRIWKH
RUJDQGRVHWRWKHOHQVLVRIKLJKLPSRUWDQFHGXHWRERWKOHQVUDGLRVHQVLWLYLW\DQGWKH
IDFWWKDWWKHOHQVLVFRPPRQO\H[SRVHGWRWKHSULPDU\EHDPLQ0'&7H[DPLQDWLRQV
%
8OWUDORZUDGLDWLRQGRVHURZ0'&7PXOWLFHQWUHFOLQLFDOWULDO
WRDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFIHDVLELOLW\RIPRGHOEDVHGLWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ XOWUDORZ9HRVWXG\
5&1HOVRQ$.+DUD:')ROH\(.3DXOVRQ'6DKDQL
'%+XVDULN'XUKDP1&863KRHQL[$=860LOZDXNHH:,86
%RVWRQ0$86=XULFK&+
3XUSRVH &7 FRQWULEXWLRQ WR WKH FROOHFWLYH UDGLDWLRQ GRVH UHPDLQV D GRPLQDQW
WRSLF2XUSXUSRVHLVWRFRQÀUPWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIDIXOOPRGHOEDVHGLWHUDWLYH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 9HR WHFKQLTXHGHVLJQHGWRVLJQLÀFDQWO\UHGXFHUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQG
LPSURYHLPDJHTXDOLW\LQSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHSLORWVWXG\LQFOXGHVSDWLHQWVIURPWKUHHLQVWLWX
WLRQVLPDJHGLQRQHRIIRXUDQDWRPLFDUPV DQDWRP\SDWKRORJ\LQWKHSRVWHULRU
IRVVD OXQJ FDQFHU VWDJLQJUHVWDJLQJ GHWHFWLRQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ RI IRFDO
OLYHUOHVLRQVRU XUROLWKLDVLV)RUHDFKSDWLHQWWZRGDWDVHWVDUHDFTXLUHGRQWKH
'LVFRYHU\&7+' *(+HDOWKFDUHWULDOVSRQVRU VWDQGDUGRIFDUHUDGLDWLRQ
GRVH DQG XOWUDORZ UDGLDWLRQ GRVH %RWK DFTXLVLWLRQV DUH UHFRQVWUXFWHG ZLWK
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 DGDSWLYHVWDWLVWLFDOLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ $6L5
DQG9HR7ZRUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\DVVHVVFOLQLFDOYDOXHOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQ
GLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHDQGUHFRPPHQGHGWUHDWPHQWIRUHDFKGDWDVHW4XDQWLWDWLYH
PHDVXUHPHQWVLQFOXGH&15DQGQRLVH,QLWLDOSLORWVWXG\UHVXOWVZLOOEHSUHVHQWHG
DQGZLOOFRQÀUPGHVLJQIRUWKHSDWLHQWJOREDOPXOWLFHQWUHWULDOWRIROORZ
5HVXOWV3ULRUSKDQWRPUHVXOWV TXDQWLWDWLYHDQGREVHUYHU LQGLFDWHWKHDELOLW\WR
PDLQWDLQURXWLQHGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\DWGRVHVDVORZDVP6YXVLQJWKLV
QHZUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXH,QLWLDOVWXG\UHVXOWVGHPRQVWUDWHWUDQVODWLRQRIWKHVH
ÀQGLQJVLQWRWKHFOLQLFDOSRSXODWLRQIRUHDFKDQDWRPLFDUPHYDOXDWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KH SLORW VWXG\ GHPRQVWUDWHV GLDJQRVWLF LPDJH TXDOLW\ LQ SDWLHQW
GDWDVHWVUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWK9HRXVLQJUDGLDWLRQGRVHVGRZQWRP6Y7KHVH
UHVXOWVZLOOEHXVHGDVREMHFWLYHHYLGHQFHIRUWKHGHVLJQRIDFRPSUHKHQVLYHJOREDO
PXOWLFHQWUHWULDOWRHQFRXUDJHDSSURSULDWHLQWURGXFWLRQLQWRFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
%
)HDVLELOLW\RIGRVHUHGXFWLRQLQZKROHERG\O\PSKRPDVWDJLQJ
&7XVLQJLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
7+HQ]OHU+-DIDURY00H\HU-6KL6$.OHLQ3$SIDOWHU626FKRHQEHUJ
&)LQN0DQQKHLP'( WKRPDVKHQ]OHU#PHGPDXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH3DWLHQWVZLWKO\PSKRPDDUHDWKLJKHUULVNRIVHFRQGDU\PDOLJQDQFLHV
GXHWRUDGLRWKHUDS\DQGIUHTXHQWIROORZXSVWDJLQJ&7:HDLPHGWRV\VWHPDWLFDOO\
LQYHVWLJDWHTXDQWLWDWLYHDQGVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\RIIXOOGRVHVWDQGDUG )'6
IXOOGRVHLWHUDWLYH )', DQG KDOIGRVHLWHUDWLYH +', UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV LQ SDWLHQWV
ZLWKO\PSKRPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7RDFTXLUHIXOOGRVHDQGKDOIGRVH&7VLPXOWDQHRXVO\
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGZKROHERG\VWDJLQJ&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKD'6&7RSHUDWLQJ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
ERWKWXEHVDWN9ZLWKWKHWRWDOP$VZDVHTXDOO\GLVWULEXWHGRQERWKWXEHV&7',
DQGGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFWRIWKHVFDQZHUHHTXDOWRWKHVWDQGDUGLQVWLWXWLRQDOSURWR
FRO)RU)'6DQG)',UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVGDWDRIERWKWXEHVZHUHXVHGZKHUHDV+',
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJRQO\GDWDIURPWXEH$RIWKH'6&7V\VWHP
RIWRWDOP$V 4XDQWLWDWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGE\PHDVXULQJLPDJH
QRLVHLQGLIIHUHQWWLVVXHVRIWKHQHFNWKRUD[DQGDEGRPHQ2YHUDOOGLDJQRVWLFLPDJH
TXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWVXVLQJDSRLQW/LNHUWVFDOH'LIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHVZHUHFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV,PDJHQRLVHVLJQLÀFDQWO\GHFUHDVHGLQDOODQDWRPLFUHJLRQVZKHQ)',DQG
+', UHVSHFWLYHO\ ZDVFRPSDUHGWR)'6UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV DOOS
,PDJHTXDOLW\RI)', PHGLDQ DQG+', PHGLDQ ZDVUDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
ZKHQFRPSDUHGWR)'6 PHGLDQ UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV ERWKS )',ZDVUDWHG
DVWKHEHVWLQ+',VHFRQGEHVWLQDQG)%6DVWKHWKLUGEHVWUHFRQVWUXF
WLRQWHFKQLTXHLQUHJDUGLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\ DOOS
&RQFOXVLRQ 6XEMHFWLYH DQG REMHFWLYH LPDJH TXDOLW\ RI )', DQG +', DSSHDU WR
EHVXSHULRUWR)'6UHFRQVWUXFWLRQWKXVHQDEOLQJGRVHUHGXFWLRQLQZKROHERG\
O\PSKRPDVWDJLQJ&7
%
&7HYDOXDWLRQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\VWHQWVSRWHQWLDOIRUUDGLDWLRQGRVH
UHGXFWLRQXVLQJLWHUDWLYHLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHV
+(EHUVEHUJHU)7ULFDULFR3$SIDOWUHU59OLHJHQWKDUW7$OOPHQGLQJHU
*5RZH$/HEHU(+RIIPDQQ86FKRHSI&KDUOHVWRQ6&86
*URQLQJHQ1/)RUFKKHLP'(0XQLFK'( HEHUVEHUJHU#JP[QHW
3XUSRVH 3DWLHQWV ZLWK FRURQDU\ VWHQWV UHTXLUH IUHTXHQW IROORZXS VR WKDW ORZ
UDGLDWLRQGRVHWHFKQLTXHVDUHGHVLUDEOH:HFRPSDUHGGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\
IRUVWHQWHYDOXDWLRQLQIXOOUDGLDWLRQGRVH&7VWXGLHVUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWKWUDGLWLRQDO
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 ZLWKVWXGLHVDWKDOIWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHXVLQJVLQRJUDP
DIÀUPHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 6$),5(
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVLPSODQWHGFRURQDU\VWHQWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGE\VOLFH
GXDO VRXUFH &7 '6&7 ,PDJH GDWD ZHUH UHFRQVWUXFWHG DW IXOOGRVH ZLWK )%3
DQGDWKDOIGRVHZLWK6$),5(XVLQJFRUUHVSRQGLQJNHUQHOV+DOIGRVHGDWDZHUH
UHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJSURMHFWLRQGDWDIURPRQO\RQH'6&7WXEHGHWHFWRUFRQÀJXUD
WLRQ ,QVWHQW VLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 ZDV PHDVXUHG DQG LPDJH TXDOLW\ ZDV
JUDGHGRQDÀYHSRLQWVFDOH H[FHOOHQW QRQGLDJQRVWLF 7RREMHFWLYHO\DVVHVV
WKHHIIHFWRQEHDPKDUGHQLQJDUWHIDFWVYROXPHVRIVWHQWVZHUHPHDVXUHGXVLQJ
GHGLFDWHGYROXPHDQDO\VLVVRIWZDUH6WHQWOXPHQDWWHQXDWLRQLQFUHDVHUDWLR 6$,5
ZDV FDOFXODWHG > LQVWHQW DWWHQXDWLRQYHVVHO DWWHQXDWLRQ LQVWHQW DWWHQXDWLRQ @
6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVXVHGSDLUHGWDQGFKLVTXDUHWHVWLQJ
5HVXOWV0HDQIXOOHIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVP6Y6LJQLÀFDQWLQVWHQWVWHQRVHV
ZHUHSUHVHQWLQVWHQWVZKLFKZHUHFRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHGZLWKERWKUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
PHWKRGVFRPSDUHGZLWKFRURQDU\DQJLRJUDSK\,QVWHQW615ZDVKLJKHUIRUKDOI
GRVH6$),5(FRPSDUHGZLWK)%3 YVS ZKLOHWKH6$,5
ZDVFRQVLGHUDEO\ORZHU YVS ,QDGGLWLRQLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDV
IRXQGWREHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S EHWWHUZKHQLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQZDVDSSOLHG
YV 6WHQWYROXPHVWHQGHGWREHORZHUZKHQUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWK
KDOIGRVH6$),5( PPYVPPS
&RQFOXVLRQ'HVSLWHXVLQJKDOIGRVHLPDJHGDWDLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLPSURYHV
HYDOXDWLRQRIFRURQDU\VWHQWVE\UHGXFLQJLPDJHQRLVHDQGEHDPKDUGHQLQJDUWH
IDFWVDQGLPSURYLQJYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHLQVWHQWOXPHQ
%
'1$GDPDJHUHSDLUNLQHWLFVIURPLRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQLQWKHUDQJHRI
GRVHVH[SHULHQFHGLQ&7VWXGLHV
656D[RQ0.KDWRQDEDGL0)0F1LWW*UD\6*5XHKP.6,ZDPRWR
/RV$QJHOHV&$86 VURELQVD[RQ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RTXDQWLI\WKHNLQHWLFVRIWKHFHOOXODUUHVSRQVHWRDUDQJHRIORZ&7
UHOHYDQWGRVHVRILRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQ ,5 LQPRXVHWXPRXULQÀOWUDWLQJO\PSKRF\WHV
7LO LQYLWUR
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7LOFHOOVZHUHSODFHGLQWKHFHQWUHFKDPEHURIWKH&'7,
KHDGSKDQWRPDQGLUUDGLDWHGZLWKP*\P*\P*\P*\RUP*\
UHSRUWHG&7',YROYDOXHV XVLQJD6,(0(166RPDWRP6HQVDWLRQ&7VFDQQHU
&HOOXODUNLQHWLFVRI'1$GDPDJHDQGUHVSRQVHZHUHTXDQWLÀHGE\ÁRZF\WRPHWULF
TXDQWLWDWLRQRIJDPPD+$;IRFLDWWKUHHWLPHSRLQWV PLQKUDQGKUVSRVW
,5DWURRPWHPSHUDWXUH $QRQLUUDGLDWHGFRQWUROZDVLQFOXGHGIRUHDFKVDPSOH
&ROOHFWHGÁRZF\WRPHWU\GDWDFRUUHFWHGIRUGHEULVDQGGHDGFHOOVXVLQJVLGHDQG
IRUZDUGVFDWWHUJDWLQJZHUHDQDO\VHGZLWK&HOO4XHVW3UR6RIWZDUH)OXRUHVFHQFH
KLVWRJUDPVZHUHJHQHUDWHGDQGWKHPHGLDQÁXRUHVFHQFHRIHDFKWUHDWPHQWVDPSOH
ZDVFRPSDUHGWRLWVUHVSHFWLYHFRQWURODQGUHSRUWHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV,QFHOOVH[SRVHGWRP*\RUP*\JDPPD+$;VLJQDOUHDFKHGD
SHDNYDOXHDWDSSUR[LPDWHO\KUDQGWKHQEHJDQWRGURS,QFRQWUDVWFHOOVH[SRVHG
WRP*\P*\DQGP*\VKRZHGGLIIHUHQWUHSDLUNLQHWLFSDWWHUQV
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU UHVXOWV VXJJHVW '1$ GDPDJH PD\ EH UHSDLUHG E\ GLIIHUHQW
PHFKDQLVPV LQ D GRVHGHSHQGHQW PDQQHU 7KLV DOWHUHG NLQHWLF UHVSRQVH FRXOG
KDYH PDUNHG ELRORJLFDO HIIHFWV IRU FXUUHQW UDGLRGLDJQRVWLF SURFHGXUHV 2XU
VWXG\WKHUHIRUHXQGHUVFRUHVWKHLPSRUWDQFHRIXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKHGLIIHUHQWUHSDLU
PHFKDQLVPVDWGLIIHUHQWGRVHUHJLRQVLQRUGHUWRDFFXUDWHO\DVVHVVULVNHVWLPDWHV
DQGELRORJLFDOGRVH
%
2UJDQGRVHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKDQDWWHQXDWLRQEDVHGSDWLHQWVL]HPHWULF
0.KDWRQDEDGL$7XUQHU'=KDQJ*&KX$%DQROD'2ULD
-'H0DUFR&&DJQRQ00F1LWW*UD\/RV$QJHOHV&$86
7XFVRQ$=86 PNKDWRQDEDGL#PHGQHWXFODHGX
3XUSRVH3UHYLRXVZRUN LQFOXGLQJ$$307DVN*URXS KDYHGHVFULEHGWKH
HIIHFWRIVL]HRQSDWLHQWUDGLDWLRQGRVHIURP&7H[DPV7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\
ZDV WR LQYHVWLJDWH WKH UHODWLRQVKLS EHWZHHQ RUJDQ GRVH IURP &7 ZLWK GLIIHUHQW
SDWLHQWVL]HPHWULFVLQFOXGLQJRQHEDVHGRQSDWLHQWDWWHQXDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8VLQJ0RQWH&DUORVLPXODWLRQPHWKRGVSDWLHQWUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHIURPÀ[HGDQGWXEHFXUUHQWPRGXODWHGVFDQVZHUHHVWLPDWHGDQGQRUPDO
LVHGE\VFDQQHUUHSRUWHG&7',YROIRUDGXOWPDOHDQGIHPDOHSDWLHQWPRGHOV
7KHVHPRGHOVZHUHJHQHUDWHGIURPWXEHFXUUHQWPRGXODWHGDEGRPHQSHOYLV&7
VFDQV 'RVHV ZHUH WDOOLHG LQ WKUHH RUJDQV OLYHU NLGQH\V DQG VSOHHQ )RU HDFK
SDWLHQW VHYHUDO VL]H PHWULFV ZHUH FDOFXODWHG LQFOXGLQJ WKH VTXDUH URRW RI WKH
LPDJHDWWHQXDWLRQDUHDSHULPHWHUDQGPD[LPXPODWHUDOZLGWKDQG$3WKLFNQHVV
7KHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQQRUPDOLVHGRUJDQGRVHDQGHDFKRIWKHVHPHWULFVZDV
FDOFXODWHGDQGFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV)RUÀ[HGWXEHFXUUHQWVFDQVWKHFRUUHODWLRQZLWKRUJDQGRVHZDVJUHDWHVW
IRULPDJHDWWHQXDWLRQDQGSHULPHWHU 5 +RZHYHUIRUWXEHFXUUHQWPRGX
ODWHGVFDQVLPDJHDWWHQXDWLRQVKRZHGWKHEHVWFRUUHODWLRQZLWKGRVH 5
ZKHUHDVSHULPHWHU$3WKLFNQHVVDQGODWHUDOZLGWKSURGXFHGORZHUFRUUHODWLRQV
5RIDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ$QDWWHQXDWLRQEDVHGSDWLHQWVL]HPHWULFFDQEHXVHGWRHVWLPDWH
GRVHIURPERWKÀ[HGDQGWXEHFXUUHQWPRGXODWHGVFDQV,WLVDEHWWHUSDWLHQWVL]H
LQGLFDWRU IRU WXEH FXUUHQW PRGXODWHG VFDQV WKDQ SHULPHWHU GXH WR LWV DELOLW\ WR
WDNHLQWRDFFRXQWWKHDWWHQXDWLRQRISDWLHQWVZKLFKLVDOVRXVHGLQWXEHFXUUHQW
PRGXODWLQJDOJRULWKPV
%
7KHHIIHFWRI&7GRVHUHGXFWLRQRQSHUIRUPDQFHRIDGLDJQRVWLFWDVN
'=KDQJ0.KDWRQDEDGL&0-XGH(=DUDJR]D+.LP0/HH
'$QGUHZV7DQJ&3RRQ0'RXHN03DWHO/'RHSNH60F1LWW*UD\
&&DJQRQ-'H0DUFR00F1LWW*UD\/RV$QJHOHV&$86
VNLQWFKHQ]KDQJ#JPDLOFRP
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5DGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQZLWKPRGHOEDVHGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
HYDOXDWLRQLQGLIIHUHQWSDWLHQWVL]HVDQGWXEHYROWDJHVHWWLQJV$
SKDQWRPVWXG\
'%+XVDULN'0DULQ65LFKDUG(6DPHL7$-DIIH
7$-DIIH05%DVKLU5&1HOVRQ=XULFK&+'XUKDP1&86
GDQLHODKXVDULN#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHLPDJHTXDOLW\RIDEGRPLQDO&7VFDQVDWGLIIHUHQWUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHOHYHOVUHFRQVWUXFWHGIURPWKHVDPHUDZGDWDVHWVZLWKDVWDQGDUGFRQYROX
WLRQ ÀOWHUHG EDFN SURMHFWLRQ )%3 DQG D PRGHOEDVHG LWHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
DOJRULWKP 0%,5
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$QDQWKURSRPRUSKLFSKDQWRPLQWKUHHVL]HVZDVXVHG
ZLWKDFXVWRPEXLOWOLYHULQVHUWVLPXODWLQJODWHKHSDWLFDUWHULDOHQKDQFHPHQWDQG
FRQWDLQLQJ K\SHUYDVFXODU OLYHU OHVLRQV RI YDULRXV VL]HV ,PDJLQJ ZDV SHUIRUPHG
RQ D VHFWLRQ PXOWLGHWHFWRUURZ &7 0'&7 VFDQQHU 'LVFRYHU\ &7 +'
*(+HDOWKFDUH:DXNHVKD:, DWGLIIHUHQWWXEHYROWDJHVIRUHDFKSDWLHQWVL]H
DQGLQFUHPHQWDOO\GHFUHDVLQJWXEHFXUUHQWWLPHSURGXFWVIRUHDFKWXEHYROWDJH
4XDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVFRQVLVWHGRIFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 FDOFXODWLRQVDQG
LPDJH QRLVH DVVHVVPHQW 4XDOLWDWLYH LPDJH DQDO\VLV ZDV SHUIRUPHG E\ WKUHH
LQGHSHQGHQWUDGLRORJLVWVUDWLQJVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGOHVLRQFRQVSLFXLW\
5HVXOWV&15RQ0%,5LPDJHVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUDQGPHDQLPDJHQRLVH
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQRQ)%3LPDJHVLQDOOSDWLHQWVL]HVDWDOOWXEHYROW
DJHVHWWLQJVDQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHOHYHOV 3 2YHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGOHVLRQ
FRQVSLFXLW\ZHUHUDWHGKLJKHUIRU0%,5LPDJHVFRPSDUHGWR)3%LPDJHVDWDOO
UDGLDWLRQGRVHOHYHOV,PDJHTXDOLW\DQGOHVLRQFRQVSLFXLW\RQGRVH0%,5
LPDJHVZHUHUDWHGHTXDOWRIXOOGRVH)%3LPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSDUHGWR)%30%,5DOORZVIRUDWRUHGXFWLRQLQUDGLDWLRQ
GRVHIRUDEGRPLQDO&7LPDJLQJZLWKRXWFRPSURPLVLQJTXDQWLWDWLYHDQGTXDOLWDWLYH
LPDJHTXDOLW\
5RRP4
3DHGLDWULF
66
%RG\DQGERQHV
0RGHUDWRUV
$'&DOGHU/RQGRQ8.
+-0HQW]HO-HQD'(
%
$GGLWLRQDOYDOXHRI)'*3(7LQSDUWLDOUHVSRQGHUVRQ&7GDWD
GHULYLQJIURPDPXOWLFHQWULF,WDOLDQSDHGLDWULF+'VWXG\
(/RSFL5%XUQHOOL$&LVWDUR$3LFFDUGR/*XHUUD$&KLWL
3=XFFKHWWD6)DQWL5R]]DQR,7)HUUDUD,77RULQR,7*HQRD,7
0RQ]D,73DGXD,7%RORJQD,7 HJHVWDORSFL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH,QWKLVVWXG\ZHSUHVHQWRXUÀQGLQJVLQSDHGLDWULF+RGJNLQҋVGLVHDVH +'
SDWLHQWVHYDOXDWHGZLWKWKHDLPWRHVWDEOLVK)'*3(7UROHLQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRI
SDWLHQWVVKRZLQJDSDUWLDOUHVSRQVH 35 RQ&7ERWKDWLQWHULPDQGHQGWUHDWPHQW
HYDOXDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HDQDO\VHGSDHGLDWULF+'SDWLHQWV PHDQDJH
\HDUV XQGHUZHQW)'*3(7LQYHVWLJDWLRQVDWLQWHULPRUDIWHUFRPSOHWLRQRIWKHUDS\
DQGVKRZLQJD35RQ&73(7GDWDZHUHUHSRUWHGDVQHJDWLYH QRHYLGHQFHRI
GLVHDVHQRSDWKRORJLFXSWDNH RUSRVLWLYHIRUGLVHDVH$OOUHVXOWVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\
DQDO\VHGZLWKUHVSHFWWR3)6RQDPHDQIROORZXSRIPRQWKV
5HVXOWV$V H[SHFWHG &7 UHVSRQVH ERWK DW LQWHULP DQG DW WKH HQGWUHDWPHQW
HYDOXDWLRQGLGQRWUHVXOWVLJQLÀFDQWO\FRUUHODWHGZLWK3)6 S DQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 2QWKHRWKHUKDQGLQWKLVVDPHSRRORISDWLHQWVDOVR)'*3(7DW
LQWHULPGLGQRWUHVXOWVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW S ZKHUHDVZKHQSHUIRUPHG
DWWKHHQGRIWUHDWPHQW3(7GDWDZHUHKLJKO\SUHGLFWLYHDQGUHVXOWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\
FRUUHODWHGZLWK3)6 S 2QWKHXQLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVGDWDZHUHFRQÀUPHG
DV VR GHPRQVWUDWLQJ WKDW RQO\ HQGWUHDWPHQW 3(7 ZDV SUHGLFWLYH S
ZKHUHDVRQWKHPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLVQRQHRIWKHLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHVZDVVLJQLÀFDQW
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWWKHPRVWUHOLDEOHYDOXHLQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ
UHDOUHVSRQVHLQSDHGLDWULF+'SDWLHQWVSUHVHQWLQJZLWKD35RQ&7LV)'*3(7
SHUIRUPHGDIWHUFRPSOHWLRQRIWKHUDS\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH6HYHUDOVWXGLHVKDYHLQYHVWLJDWHGWUDGHRIIVEHWZHHQUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQG
LPDJHTXDOLW\ QRLVH LQ&7LPDJLQJ7KLVVWXG\WRRNWKHDQDO\VLVDVWHSIXUWKHUE\
LQYHVWLJDWLQJWKHWUDGHRIIVEHWZHHQUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHLQ
DFOLQLFDOWDVN GLDJQRVLVRIDSSHQGLFLWLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\ZDV,5%DSSURYHGDQGXWLOLVHGGDWD
IURPSDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQWFOLQLFDO&7H[DPVIRULQGLFDWLRQVRIDSSHQGLFLWLV
0HGLFDOUHFRUGUHYLHZHVWDEOLVKHGWUXHGLDJQRVLVRIDSSHQGLFLWLVZLWKSRVLWLYHV
DQGQHJDWLYHV2ULJLQDO DQGVLPXODWHGUHGXFHGGRVHOHYHOV
RIRULJLQDO ZHUHFUHDWHGZLWKDYDOLGDWHGVRIWZDUHWRROXVLQJUDZSURMHF
WLRQGDWDIURPHDFKVFDQ$QREVHUYHUVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKUDGLRORJLVWV
UHYLHZLQJHDFKFDVHDWHDFKGRVHOHYHOLQUDQGRPRUGHURYHUVHYHUDOVHVVLRQV
5HDGHUV DVVHVVHG LPDJH TXDOLW\ DQG SURYLGHG FRQÀGHQFH LQ WKHLU GLDJQRVLV RI
DSSHQGLFLWLVHDFKRQDSRLQWVFDOH52&FXUYHVZHUHJHQHUDWHGIRUHDFKGRVH
OHYHO$8& DUHDXQGHUFXUYH ZDVFDOFXODWHGIRUHDFKGRVHOHYHO
5HVXOWV,QWHULPUHVXOWVRIWKHVWXG\VKRZHGWKDWWKH$8&IRUHDFKRIWKHGRVH
OHYHOVZDVDQGIRUGRVHOHYHOVDW
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\2QO\RXWRIUHDGLQJVUHFHLYHG´XQDFFHSW
DEOHµLPDJHTXDOLW\UDWLQJV SDWLHQWDWGRVHOHYHO
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVSUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\GHPRQVWUDWHGWUDGHRIIVEHWZHHQUDGLDWLRQGRVH
DQGGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHDQGLQGLFDWHGWKDW D HYHQVPDOOGRVHUHGXFWLRQVPD\
DIIHFWGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHVOLJKWO\DQG E ODUJHGRVHUHGXFWLRQVPD\VWLOODOORZ
DFFHSWDEOHSHUIRUPDQFHOHYHOV
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
9RLGLQJXURVRQRJUDSK\ZLWKDVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQFRQWUDVWDJHQW
DVDÀUVWVWHSVWXG\IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVDQGJUDGLQJRIYHVLFRXUHWHULF
UHÁX[LQFKLOGUHQ
$1WRXOLD)3DSDGRSRXORX)3DSDFKULVWRX(6LRPRX.'DUJH
,RDQQLQD*57KHVVDORQLNL*53KLODGHOSKLD3$86
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIÀFDF\RIYRLGLQJXURVRQRJUDSK\ 986 ZLWKDVHFRQG
JHQHUDWLRQFRQWUDVWDJHQW &$ DVDÀUVWVWHSVWXG\IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVDQGJUDGLQJ
RIYHVLFRXUHWHULFUHÁX[ 985 LQFKLOGUHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZRKXQGUHGDQGWHQFRQVHFXWLYHFKLOGUHQ ER\V
JLUOVPHDQDJHPRQWKV ZLWKNLGQH\XUHWHUXQLWV .88 ZHUHHYDOXDWHG
ZLWK986WRUXOHRXW Q RUIROORZXS Q 985,QDOOFKLOGUHQ986ZDV
SHUIRUPHGZLWKDFRQWUDVWVSHFLÀFKDUPRQLFLPDJLQJPRGHDQGPORIDVHFRQG
JHQHUDWLRQ&$ 6RQRYXH%UDFFR0LODQ DFFRUGLQJWR(635ZRUNLQJJURXSUHF
RPPHQGDWLRQV7KH986ZDVUHFRUGHGRQGLJLWDOFOLSVDQGUHDGWZLFHE\WZREOLQGHG
UDGLRORJLVWV7KHGLDJQRVLVLQGLVFRUGDQWFDVHVZDVUHDFKHGE\FRQVHQVXV7KH
LQWUDREVHUYHUDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVFDOFXODWHGE\NDSSDFRHIÀFLHQW
5HVXOWV985ZDVGLDJQRVHGLQ.88 IURP SDWLHQWV
ER\V DQG JLUOV 7KH UDWH RI UHÁX[ ZDV QRW VLJQLÀFDQWO\ FRUUHODWHG ZLWK
WKHVH[DJHFOLQLFDOLQGLFDWLRQVDQGWKHSUHVHQFHRUVLGHRIGLODWHGSHOYLV985
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHFRPPRQLQGXSOH[WKDQLQVLQJOHNLGQH\V S 7KH
LQWUDREVHUYHUDQGLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVH[FHOOHQWIRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRI
985 N! DQGPRGHUDWHWRH[FHOOHQWIRUWKHJUDGLQJRI985 N
&RQFOXVLRQ986ZLWKDVHFRQGJHQHUDWLRQ&$LVDQHIÀFLHQWÀUVWVWHSVWXG\IRU
WKHGLDJQRVLVDQGJUDGLQJRI985LQFKLOGUHQDQGLWFDQUHOLDEO\EHXVHGDVDQ
DOWHUQDWLYHUDGLDWLRQIUHHLPDJLQJPHWKRGIRUWKLVSXUSRVH
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGYRLGLQJXURVRQRJUDSK\IRUGLDJQRVLVRI
YHVLFRXUHWHULFUHÁX[LQFRPSDULVRQWRFRQYHQWLRQDOPHWKRGVD
PHWDDQDO\VLV
)3DSDGRSRXORX((YDQJHORX05LFFDERQD$1WRXOLD.'DUJH
,RDQQLQD*5*UD]$73KLODGHOSKLD3$86 ISDSDGRSRXORX#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIYRLGLQJXURVRQRJUDSK\ 986
LQYHVLFRXUHWHUDOUHÁX[ 985 DQGXUHWKUDOSDWKRORJ\GHWHFWLRQFRPSDUHGWRFRQ
YHQWLRQDOPHWKRGVSXEOLVKHGLQPHGLFDOOLWHUDWXUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV0HGOLQHZDVVHDUFKHGE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWREVHUYHUVIRU
DOOSRVVLEOHDUWLFOHVSXEOLVKHGXSWR0D\RQ986LQQHRQDWHVLQIDQWVFKLOGUHQ
FRPSDUHGWR9&8*RU'51&DQGSHUIRUPHGZLWK/HYRYLVWRU6RQR9XH7KHELYDUL
DWHKLHUDUFKLFDOPRGHOZDVFKRVHQIRUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLV,QGLYLGXDOVWXG\UHVXOWV
ZHUHSUHVHQWHGJUDSKLFDOO\E\SORWWLQJHVWLPDWHVRIVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQ
UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFV 52& DQGH[WHQGHGVXPPDU\52&7KH
FRQÀGHQFH LQWHUYDOV &, DQG WKH SRVLWLYH /5 DQG QHJDWLYH /5 OLNHOLKRRG
UDWLRVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWVDUWLFOHVZHUHIRXQGFRQFHUQLQJ´XOWUDVRXQGFRQWUDVW985µFRP
SDUDWLYHVWXGLHVIXOÀOOHGWKHLQFOXVLRQFULWHULD986VWXGLHVLQFRPSDULVRQZLWK
9&8*DQGZLWK'51&SHUIRUPHGZLWK/HYRYLVWDQGZLWK6RQR9XH7RWDOO\
FKLOGUHQ ZLWK SHOYRXUHWHUDOXQLWV ZHUH LQFOXGHG IRU DQDO\VLV 986
FRPSDUHGWR9&8*DQG'51&KDGVHQVLWLYLW\ &, VSHFLÀFLW\
&, /5/5986SHUIRUPDQFHZDVEHWWHUFRPSDUHGWR'51&
WKDQWR9&8* VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\YHUVXVUHVSHFWLYHO\
DVZHOODVZLWK6RQR9XHFRPSDUHGWR/HYRYLVW VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\
YHUVXV UHVSHFWLYHO\ 5HJDUGLQJ XUHWKUDO SDWKRORJ\ GHWHFWLRQ
SDWLHQWV ER\V ZHUH LQFOXGHG ([FHOOHQW LPDJLQJ RI XUHWKUDO DQDWRP\ ZDV
UHSRUWHGLQ!RISDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ)URPWKHSXEOLVKHGGDWDWKHUHLVFRQYLQFLQJHYLGHQFHIRUWKHGLDJ
QRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRI986LQ985GHWHFWLRQFRPSDUHGWR9&8*DQG'51&)RU
XUHWKUDOSDWKRORJ\GHWHFWLRQDOWKRXJKUHVXOWVDUHYHU\SURPLVLQJPRUHFRPSDUD
WLYHVWXGLHVDUHQHHGHG
%
'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\DQGFOLQLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHRIPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHHQWHURJUDSK\RIWKHVPDOOLQWHVWLQHLQFRPSDULVRQZLWK
LOHRFRORQRVFRS\LQSDHGLDWULFLQÁDPPDWRU\ERZHOGLVHDVH
8)DJHUEHUJ057RUN]DG/%ORPTYLVW++LOGHEUDQG
3+HOOVWU|P88OOEHUJ9lVWHUnV6(8SSVDOD6(6WRFNKROP6(
PLFKDHOWRUN]DG#UDGLROXXVH
3XUSRVH7RVWXG\WKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHHQWHURJUDSK\
05( LQ SDHGLDWULF LQÁDPPDWRU\ ERZHO GLVHDVH ,%' LQ GLDJQRVLQJ LQWHVWLQDO
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
LQÁDPPDWLRQDQGWRHYDOXDWHWKHFOLQLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFHRIWKH05(UHVXOWVRQWKH
PDQDJHPHQWRISDHGLDWULF,%'SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\SURVSHFWLYHSDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWV PHGLDQDJH
\HDUVUDQJH ZLWKVXVSHFWHG Q RUQHZO\GLDJQRVHG OHVVWKDQIRXU
ZHHNV FRQÀUPHG,%' Q ZHUHLQFOXGHGDQGXQGHUZHQWJDVWURLOHRFRORQRVFRS\
ZLWKELRSVLHVIROORZHGE\05( PHGLDQLQWHUYDOGD\VUDQJH 7KH05(
UHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKPDFURVFRSLF JROGVWDQGDUGEDVHG3DULVFODVVLÀFD
WLRQ DQGPLFURVFRSLFDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHLOHXP7KHFOLQLFDOLPSRUWDQFHRI
WKH05(UHVXOWVZDVUHJLVWHUHGEDVHGRQSURVSHFWLYHDOWHUDWLRQLQGLDJQRVLVDQG
PDQDJHPHQW
5HVXOWV&URKQVGLVHDVH &' ZDVGLDJQRVHGLQFDVHVXOFHUDWLYHFROLWLV 8& LQ
DQG,%'XQFODVVLÀHG ,%'8 LQWKUHH0DFURVFRSLFLOHLWLVZDVGHWHFWHGLQ
RI&'FDVHVDQGLQ RI8& EDFNZDVKLOHLWLV 0LFURVFRSLFLQÁDP
PDWLRQZDVIRXQGLQDQRWKHUIRXU&'FDVHVDQGRQH,%'8SDWLHQW7KHGLVFUHSDQF\
EHWZHHQJROGVWDQGDUGDQG05(ZDVOHVVWKDQPLFURVFRS\DQGJROGVWDQGDUG7KH
VHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RI05,ZDVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\05(ÀQGLQJVOHG
WRFKDQJHVLQGLDJQRVLVLQ DQGWUHDWPHQWLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ05(LVDVSHFLÀFPHWKRGIRULPDJLQJRILQWHVWLQDOLQÁDPPDWLRQLQ
SDHGLDWULF,%'DQGFDQEHVXSSRUWLYHRUHVVHQWLDOIRUFOLQLFDOWUHDWPHQWGHFLVLRQV
05(KDVORZHUVHQVLWLYLW\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKQHZO\GLDJQRVHG,%'SHUKDSVGXHWR
OHVVDGYDQFHGFKDQJHV
%
0XOWLSKDVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,IRUFRQWURORIVXEDFXWHWUDXPDRI
DEGRPHQDQGFKHVWLQFKLOGUHQ
$3HWUDLNLQ7$NKDGRY16HPHQRYD2.DUDVHYD,0HOQLNRY66LGRULQ
0RVFRZ58 SHWUDL#UDPEOHUUX
3XUSRVH7UDXPDWLFGDPDJHRIDEGRPHQDQGFKHVWRUJDQVLQFKLOGUHQ LVRODWHG
DVZHOODVDSDUWRIPXOWLSOHLQMXULHV LVQRWUDUHLQUDGLRORJLFDOGHSDUWPHQWRIDQ
HPHUJHQF\KRVSLWDO,QRUGHUWRFRQWUROWKHWUDXPDLQVXEDFXWHSKDVHZHVXJJHVW
PXOWLSKDVHFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$Q05,XQLWZLWK7ZDVXVHGLQWKHUHVHDUFK:H
XVHG7VHTXHQFHH7+5,9(IRUSUHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVWVFDQV *GFRQWUDVWDJHQW
EROXV 7KHVFDQQLQJZDVRIEUHDWKKROGW\SHZLWKKLJKVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ [PP
LQSODQHPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVV %HIRUHFRQWUDVWLQMHFWLRQZHXVHG7VHTXHQFHV
05&3 LQ V\QFKURQLVDWLRQ ZLWK EUHDWKLQJ 1DYLJDWRU PHWKRG SDWLHQWV ZLWK
VXEDFXWHWUDXPDVFRUHGIURPWRRQLQMXU\VHYHULW\VFRUH ,66 ZHUHH[DPLQHG
5HVXOWV([DPLQDWLRQVRIVXEDFXWHWUDXPDWLFLQMXULHVLQFKLOGUHQUHYHDOHGGDP
DJHV RI SDUHQFK\PDO RUJDQV ZLWK YDULRXV GHJUHHV RI VHYHULW\ OLYHU FDVHV
NLGQH\V OXQJV VSOHHQ DQGSDQFUHDV (LJKWHHQSDWLHQWV KDG
PXOWLSOHLQMXULHV$OOSDWLHQWVGHPRQVWUDWHGSRVLWLYHG\QDPLFRIUHFRYHU\$ELOLW\RI
WKHSDWLHQWWRKROGKLVEUHDWKLVQHHGHGFRPSULVLQJRQHRIPDMRUUHVWULFWLRQVIRU
XVLQJWKLVPHWKRG7KHSDUWLFXODUVWUHQJWKRIWKLVPHWKRGLVRSSRUWXQLW\WRRYHU
FRPHXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\OLPLWDWLRQV JRRGSHUIRUPDQFHLQOXQJVVXEGLDSKUDJPDWLF
UHJLRQRIKHSDUHWF
&RQFOXVLRQ 0XOWLSKDVH FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 05, LV KLJKO\ HIIHFWLYH UDGLRORJLFDO
PHWKRGIRUFRQWURORIUHFRYHU\DIWHUFKHVWDQGDEGRPHQWUDXPDLQFKLOGUHQ,WUH
GXFHVUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHDQGPD\EHVXJJHVWHGDVDPHWKRGRIFKRLFHIRUFKLOGUHQ
ZLWKPDMRUWUDXPDXQGHUWDNLQJWUHDWPHQWLQDQHPHUJHQF\KRVSLWDO
%
7KHLPSRUWDQFHRIDGYDQFHG05,WHFKQLTXHVDVWKHGHÀQLWLYH
GLDJQRVWLFWRROLQWKHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQEHWZHHQRVWHRP\HOLWLVDQG
RVWHRQHFURVLVLQFKLOGUHQZLWKVLFNOHFHOOGLVHDVH
$$ODYL-'H/D)XHQWH/RQGRQ8. DODYLBDIVKLQ#\DKRRGH
3XUSRVH$FXWHPXVFXORVNHOHWDOSDLQGXHWRPDUURZLQIDUFWLRQLVE\IDUWKHPRVW
IUHTXHQWFOLQLFDOSUHVHQWDWLRQIRUVLFNOHFHOOEXWV\PSWRPVFDQEHVLPLODUWRRVWHR
P\HOLWLV05,KDVWKHKLJKHVWVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\LQGHWHFWLRQRIPDUURZDQG
H[WUDRVVHRXVFKDQJHVLQERWKLQIDUFWLRQDQGLQIHFWLRQ$OWKRXJKPXVFXORVNHOHWDO
FKDQJHVDUHFRQÀGHQWO\GHWHFWDEOHZLWK05,WKH\FDQEHYHU\VLPLODU7KHSXUSRVH
RIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRLOOXVWUDWHWKHLPSRUWDQFHRI05,DQGWKHDGYDQFHGSURWRFROV
LQFOXGLQJ XQHQKDQFHG G\QDPLFHQKDQFHG PXOWLSKDVH VXEWUDFWLRQ DQG ZKROH
ERG\':,VHTXHQFHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HH[DPLQHGFKLOGUHQZLWKVLFNOHFHOOGLVHDVHDFXWH
PXVFXORVNHOHWDO SDLQ DQG QRQFKDUDFWHULVWLF V\PSWRPV ZLWK RXU FRPSOHWHG 05,
SURWRFRODQGFRUUHODWHGRXUUHVXOWVZLWKWKHFOLQLFDOPLFURELRORJLFDODQGVXUJLFDO
GHWDLOVLQRUGHUWRGHWHUPLQHWKHGLDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIRXUVHTXHQFHV
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQRXUUHVXOWVDQGWKHFOLQLFDO
UHVXOWVDQGH[FHSWIHZFDVHVZLWKFOHDUGLDJQRVLVWKURXJKXQHQKDQFHGVHTXHQFHV
LQPRVWFDVHVSRVWFRQWUDVWG\QDPLFVXEWUDFWLRQDQG':,VHTXHQFHVZHUHUHTXLUHG
IRUWKHGLDJQRVLV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ :KROH ERG\ ':, VHTXHQFHV DUH WKH PRVW HIIHFWLYH IRU GHWHFWLQJ
KRWVSRWVLQPXOWLIRFDOSURFHVVZKLFKLVWKHQDWXUHRIVLFNOHFHOOGLVHDVH$OWKRXJK
XQHQKDQFHG VHTXHQFHV DUH KHOSIXO WR GHWHUPLQH WKH H[WHQW RI D ORFDO SURFHVV
LQPRVWFDVHVWKHPXVFXORVNHOHWDODEQRUPDOLWLHVDUHHLWKHULQRVWHRP\HOLWLVRULQ
PDUURZLQIDUFWLRQVLPLODUDQGG\QDPLFSRVWFRQWUDVWDQGVXEWUDFWLRQVHTXHQFHV
DUHUHTXLUHGIRUWKHGHÀQLWLYHGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ2XUUHVXOWVVKRZWKDWDGYDQFHG05,
SURWRFROLVDQXOWLPDWHGLDJQRVWLFWRROIRUFRQÀGHQWO\GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHWZHHQPDUURZ
LQIDUFWLRQDQGLQIHFWLRQLQFKLOGUHQZLWKVLFNOHFHOOGLVHDVH
%
3L[HOE\SL[HODQDO\VLVRI'&(05,FXUYHVKDSHVLQNQHHVRIMXYHQLOH
LGLRSDWKLFDUWKULWLVSDWLHQWV
5+HPNH&/DYLQL0$-YDQ5RVVXP0YDQGHQ%HUJ.0'ROPDQ
0YDQ9HHQHQGDDO'6FKRQHQEHUJ7:.XLMSHUV00DDV$PVWHUGDP1/
UKHPNH#DPFQO
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHUHODWLYHQXPEHURIWLPHLQWHQVLW\FXUYH 7,& VKDSHV
DVGHULYHGIURP'&(05,LQFOLQLFDODFWLYHDQGFOLQLFDOLQDFWLYHMXYHQLOHLGLRSDWKLF
DUWKULWLV -,$ SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'&(05,GDWDVHWVRINQHHVRI-,$SDWLHQWVZHUHSURVSHF
WLYHO\REWDLQHGXVLQJDQRSHQERUHPDJQHW 7 3DWLHQWVZHUHFODVVLÀHGLQWRWZR
FOLQLFDOVXEJURXSVDFWLYHDUWKULWLV Q DQGLQDFWLYHGLVHDVH Q (YHU\YR[HO
ZLWK LWV7,& ZDV FODVVLÀHG LQWR RQH RI VHYHQ SUHGHÀQHG7,& VKDSH FDWHJRULHV
ZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQDFRORXUFRGHGVKDSHPDS6SDWLDOLQIRUPDWLRQRIWKHV\QRYLDO7,&
VKDSHGLVWULEXWLRQSDWWHUQDQGUHODWLYHQXPEHURI7,&VKDSHVZHUHFDOFXODWHGRQD
WKUHHGLPHQVLRQDOUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW5HODWLYH7,&VKDSHQXPEHUVZHUHFRPSDUHG
XVLQJDQRQSDUDPHWULF0DQQ:KLWQH\8WHVW
5HVXOWV 1R GLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQ DFWLYH DQG LQDFWLYH -,$ SDWLHQWV ZHUH IRXQG
UHJDUGLQJWKHUHODWLYHQXPEHURIW\SH7,&VKDSHV VORZHQKDQFHPHQW DQGW\SH
7,&VKDSHV IDVWHQKDQFHPHQWIROORZHGE\SODWHDXSKDVH S S
UHVSHFWLYHO\ +RZHYHUDVLJQLÀFDQWKLJKHUUHODWLYHQXPEHURIW\SH7,&VKDSHV
IDVWHQKDQFHPHQWIROORZHGE\HDUO\ZDVKRXWSKDVH ZDVVHHQLQFOLQLFDODFWLYH
SDWLHQWVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHLQDFWLYHJURXS YVS 7\SH7,&
VKDSHV IDVWHQKDQFHPHQWIROORZHGE\VORZHQKDQFHPHQWLQFUHDVH WHQGHGWREH
PRUHSUHVHQWLQFOLQLFDOLQDFWLYHSDWLHQWVFRPSDUHGZLWKDFWLYH-,$SDWLHQWV
YVS
&RQFOXVLRQ5HVXOWVREWDLQHGXVLQJWKHSL[HOE\SL[HO'&(05,7,&VKDSHDQDO\
VLVGLIIHULQVPDOOFRKRUWVRIDFWLYHDQGLQDFWLYH-,$SDWLHQWV
%
3HUPDQHQWPXVFXODUVRGLXPRYHUORDGDQGPXVFOHRHGHPD
LQ'XFKHQQHPXVFXODUG\VWURSK\DSRVVLEOHFRQWULEXWRURI
SURJUHVVLYHPXVFOHGHJHQHUDWLRQ
0$:HEHU$01DJHO0%:ROI.-XUNDW5RWW
:6HPPOHU+8.DXF]RU)/HKPDQQ+RUQ+HLGHOEHUJ'(
8OP'( 0DUF$QGUH:HEHU#PHGXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
(YDOXDWLRQRIDUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQVWUDWHJ\IRUSDHGLDWULF
DEGRPHQ&7FRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQDXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUHFRQWURODQG
ZHLJKWEDVHGP$V
<:.LP-<-DQJ+.LP<DQJVDQ.53XVDQ.5 M\FM#GDXPQHW
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIRXUVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHHIIHFWRIDXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUH
FRQWUROV\VWHPRQUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\DWSDHGLDWULFDEGRPHQ&7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ VHOHFWHG FKLOGUHQ ZKR XQGHU
ZHQWDEGRPHQ&7IRUVOLFHVLQJOHVRXUFH&7 'HÀQLWLRQ$6 DQG
IRUGXDOVRXUFH&7 'HÀQLWLRQ)ODVK $XWRPDWLFH[SRVXUHFRQWURO &DUHGRVH'
ZDVDSSOLHGWRRIWKHSDWLHQWVDQGRIWKHUHVSHFWLYHO\)RUHDFK
H[DPLQDWLRQWKHWRWDOP$VDQGWKHWRWDOGRVHOHQJWKSURGXFW '/3 ZHUHUHFRUGHG
DQGWKHHIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVHVWLPDWHGXVLQJWKH'/3PHWKRG ['/3 $WODVW
VLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 52,6' DQGFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 52,DWDRUWD
52,DWSVRDVPXVFOH6' ZHUHFDOFXODWHGIURPWKRVHYDOXHV
5HVXOWV 7KH HIIHFWLYH GRVH P$V YDOXHV ZHUH KLJKHU LQ WKH JURXS ZKR ZHUH
DGMXVWHG$(&WKDQWKHYDOXHLQWKHJURXSZLWKZHLJKWEDVHGÀ[HGP$VDQGORZHU
WKDQWKHYDOXHLQWKHJURXSZLWKUDQGRPLVHGP$V7KHKLJKHUWKHHIIHFWLYHGRVH
ZDVWKHEHWWHU615VDQG&15ZHUH6RZKHQZHSHUIRUPWKHSDHGLDWULFDEGR
PHQ&7ZLWKKLJKP$VWKDWGRHVQRWFRQVLGHUWKHLUZHLJKWVWKHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDV
PRVWGHVLUHG+RZHYHUIRUPRVWRIFDVHVZLWK$(&RUZLWKZHLJKWEDVHGP$V
LPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDFFHSWDEOH
&RQFOXVLRQ 6LJQLÀFDQW UDGLDWLRQ GRVH UHGXFWLRQ FDQ EH DFKLHYHG IRU URXWLQH
SDHGLDWULF DEGRPHQ &7 E\ ZHLJKWEDVHG À[HG P$V 7KHUH ZDV DQ DFFHSWDEOH
WUDGHRIIEHWZHHQLQFUHDVHGQRLVHDQGGHFUHDVHGGRVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDV
FRQVLGHUHGGLDJQRVWLFDOO\DGHTXDWH
%
,PSURYHPHQWRILPDJHTXDOLW\LQSDHGLDWULFSDWLHQWVE\ORZHULQJWKH
WXEHYROWDJHWRN9DWÀ[HGHIIHFWLYHGRVHLQGLJLWDOUDGLRJUDSK\
6LPXODWLQJUDGLRJUDSK\RIH[WUHPLWLHV
-*URQDX81HLW]HO5+HVV5:ROI%HUQ&++DPEXUJ'(
3XUSRVH:LWKWKHDGYHQWRIGLUHFWUDGLRJUDSK\LPDJLQJFRQYHQWLRQDODGMXVWPHQWV
IRUSDHGLDWULFLPDJLQJKDYHRIWHQEHHQDGRSWHGZLWKRXWFKDQJH5DGLRJUDSK\RI
H[WUHPLWLHVRIYHU\\RXQJSDWLHQWVVKRZRQO\OLWWOHLQWULQVLFFRQWUDVWEHFDXVHRIWKH
VWLOOLPPDWXUHERQHGHYHORSPHQW,QGLJLWDOUDGLRJUDSK\FRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLRLV
EHWWHUDWN9FRPSDUHGWRN9:HH[DPLQHGZKHWKHUWKHUDWHRIFRUUHFWO\GH
WHFWHGVXEWOHIUDFWXUHVLPSURYHVDWN9FRPSDUHGWRN9DWÀ[HGHIIHFWLYHGRVH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$V D SDWLHQW PRGHO VXEWOH JUHHQVWLFN IUDFWXUHV ZHUH
JHQHUDWHGLQULEVIURPFDGDYHUVRIIRHWDODQGQHZERUQODPEV5LEVZHUHVXEPHUJHG
LQDFPZDWHUVXUURXQGLQJWRVLPXODWHVXUURXQGLQJWLVVXH;UD\LPDJLQJZDV
GRQHDWN9P$VDQGN9P$VEHIRUHDQGDIWHUIUDFWXULQJ3UHVHWVDW
N9DQGN9OHGWRDVLPLODUHIIHFWLYHGRVHDVFDOFXODWHGE\WKH0RQWH&DUOR
6LPXODWLRQ7KHIUDFWXUHVFRXOGRQO\EHGHWHFWHGE\LUUHJXODULWLHVLQWKHVSRQJLRVD
VWUXFWXUH [UD\V IURP ULEV ZLWK LUUHJXODULWLHV LQ WKHLU VKDSH OLNH DQJXODWLRQ ZHUH
H[FOXGHG7KUHHUDGLRORJLVWVDQDO\VHG[UD\VHDFK
5HVXOWV7KHUDWHRIFRUUHFWGLDJQRVHVDWN9YVN9ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
ZLWKYVYVDQGYV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QGLJLWDOUDGLRJUDSK\WKHLPDJHTXDOLW\FDQEHLPSURYHGDWÀ[HG
GRVHE\ORZHULQJWKHWXEHYROWDJHWRN9$OWHUQDWLYHO\WKLVPLJKWEHXVHGWR
UHGXFHSDWLHQWGRVHPDLQWDLQLQJVXIÀFLHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\ZKLFKZLOOEHH[DPLQHG
LQIROORZLQJVWXGLHV
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHSUHVHQFHDQGSHUVLVWHQFHRIPXVFXODURHGHPDDQGLQ
FUHDVHGP\RSODVPLFVRGLXP 1D FRQFHQWUDWLRQLQ'XFKHQQHPXVFXODUG\VWURSK\
'0' SUREDEO\FRQWULEXWLQJVLJQLÀFDQWO\WRLWVSURJUHVVLYHPXVFOHGHJHQHUDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H H[DPLQHG '0' SDWLHQWV PHDQ DJH
\HDUV DQGKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV PHDQDJH\HDUV RQD7HVOD05
V\VWHPZLWKSURWRQ + DQG1DGHQVLW\DGDSWHG'UDGLDOVHTXHQFHV7RHQVXUH
FRQVLVWHQF\ SDWLHQWV ZHUH UHH[DPLQHG DERXW PRQWKV ODWHU :H TXDQWLÀHG
PXVFOHRHGHPDRQ67,5LPDJHVZLWKEDFNJURXQGQRLVHDVUHIHUHQFHDQGIDWW\
GHJHQHUDWLRQRQ7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVXVLQJVXEFXWDQHRXVIDWDVUHIHUHQFH1D
ZDVTXDQWLÀHGE\DPXVFXODUWLVVXH1DFRQFHQWUDWLRQ 76& VHTXHQFHHPSOR\
LQJDUHIHUHQFHWXEHIRUVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQFRQWDLQLQJP01DZLWKDJDURVH
JHO :LWK D QRYHO LQYHUVLRQUHFRYHU\ ,5 VHTXHQFH ZKLFK XWPRVW VXSSUHVVHV
H[WUDFHOOXODU1DVLJQDOVIRULQVWDQFHIURPYDVRJHQLFRHGHPDZHGHWHUPLQHG
PDLQO\WKHP\RSODVPLF1D
5HVXOWV7KHQRUPDOLVHGPXVFXODU1D,5VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\ZDVKLJKHULQ'0'
WKDQ LQ YROXQWHHUV S DQG SHUVLVWHG DW VHFRQG
PHDVXUHPHQW Q YVS :KHQFRPSDUHGWRYROXQ
WHHUV PPROO 76&ZDVPDUNHGO\LQFUHDVHGLQ'0' PPROO
S DQG UHPDLQHG FRQVWDQW Q PPROO YV PPROO
S 2HGHPD YV S DQG PXVFXODU IDW FRQWHQW
YVS ZHUHHOHYDWHGLQ'0'PXVFOHVZKHQFRP
SDUHG ZLWK YROXQWHHUV 7KLV FRXOG DOVR EH FRQÀUPHG GXULQJ IROORZXS S
S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSHUPDQHQWPXVFXODU1DRYHUORDGLQ'0'LVOLNHO\RVPRWLFDOO\
UHOHYDQWDQGUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHSHUVLVWLQJPDLQO\LQWUDFHOOXODUPXVFOHRHGHPD
%RWKZHUHSUHVHQWLQDOO'0'SDWLHQWV
%
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP%
*,7UDFW
66D
&7FRORQRJUDSK\DQGEH\RQG
0RGHUDWRUV
3/HIHUH5RHVHODUH%(
$05LGGHOO6XWWRQ8.
%
$FFXUDF\RIFRPSXWHUDLGHGGHWHFWLRQLQGHWHFWLQJÁDWOHVLRQVLQ&7
FRORQRJUDSK\
--1DSSL+<RVKLGD'5HJJH%RVWRQ0$867XULQ,7
MQDSSL#SDUWQHUVRUJ
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQLQGHSHQGHQWO\WUDLQHGFRPSXWHUDLGHG
GHWHFWLRQ &$' V\VWHPLQGHWHFWLQJÁDWDGHQRPDVDQGFDUFLQRPDVIURPDODUJH
PXOWLFHQWUH&7FRORQRJUDSK\ &7& VFUHHQLQJSRSXODWLRQ3UHYLRXV&$'VWXGLHV
KDYH UHSRUWHG ORZ GHWHFWLRQ SHUIRUPDQFH DQG LQYROYHG FRPSURPLVHG WUDLQLQJ
WHVWLQJVFKHPHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORISDWLHQWVZLWKFDWKDUWLFSUHSDUDWLRQIURP
PHGLFDOFHQWUHVZHUHLQFOXGHG)RU&$'WUDLQLQJSDWLHQWVZHUHFROOHFWHG
IURPWZR&7&VFUHHQLQJWULDOVLQYROYLQJ86PHGLFDOFHQWUHV)DHFDOWDJJLQJZDV
XVHGLQRIFDVHV7KH&$'ZDVWUDLQHGZLWKWKH&7&FDVHVWRGHWHFW
OHVLRQVPPDWVHQVLWLYLW\)RU&$'WHVWLQJDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVDW
LQFUHDVHGULVNRIFRORUHFWDOFDQFHUZHUHFROOHFWHGIURPDUHFHQW&7&VFUHHQLQJ
WULDO LQYROYLQJ (XURSHDQ FHQWUHV ,RGLQH WDJJLQJ ZLWKRXW RU ZLWK EDULXP ZDV
XVHGLQRIFDVHV1RLQWUDYHQRXVFRQWUDVWZDVDGPLQLVWHUHG7KHSUHWUDLQHG
&$'V\VWHPUHYLHZHGWKHWHVWLQJFDVHV3HUOHVLRQDQGSHUSDWLHQWGHWHFWLRQ
VHQVLWLYLWLHVDQGIDOVHSRVLWLYHV )3V SHUSDWLHQWZHUHDVVHVVHGZLWKERRWVWUDSSLQJ
IRUELRSV\SURYHQFRORQRVFRS\FRQÀUPHGOHVLRQV
5HVXOWV7KHUHZHUHOHVLRQVLQFOXGLQJÁDWDGHQRPDVRUFDUFLQRPDV
ZHUHPPDQGZHUHPP3HUOHVLRQ SHUSDWLHQW VHQVLWLYLW\RI&$'ZDV
IRUÁDWOHVLRQVPPLQVL]HDQG IRUÁDWOHVLRQVPP
ZLWKPHGLDQRI)3VSHUSDWLHQW&$'GHWHFWHGDOOÁDWFDQFHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QGHSHQGHQWO\WUDLQHG&$'FDQGHWHFWÁDWDGHQRPDVDQGFDUFLQR
PDVIURPXQVHHQPXOWLFHQWUH&7&SRSXODWLRQVDWFOLQLFDOO\DFFHSWDEOHDFFXUDF\
FRPSDUDEOHWRWKDWIRUSRO\SRLGOHVLRQV
%
3RWHQWLDOFRPSOLFDWLRQVDW&7FRORQRJUDSK\LQDV\PSWRPDWLFDQG
V\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVQDWLRQDOVXUYH\RI,WDO\
0&LROLQD),DIUDWH*,XVVLFK'5HJJH0,DQQLWWL3%DOGDVVDUL
$3LFKL/&RUUHDOH$/DJKL5RPH,7&DQGLROR,77RULQR,7/DWLQD,7
PDULDFLROLQD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHWKHLQFLGHQFHRIFRPSOLFDWLRQUHODWHGWR&7&
SHUIRUPHGLQERWKV\PSWRPDWLFDQGDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJ&7&GXULQJ
WKHSHULRGUDQJLQJIURPDQG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:LWKDQDWLRQDOVXUYH\DQHPDLOTXHVWLRQQDLUHDERXW
VHULRXV DGYHUVH HYHQWV RI YLUWXDO FRORQRVFRS\ SDUWLFXODUO\ ODUJH ERZHO SHUIRUD
WLRQZDVVHQWWRDOO,WDOLDQ3XEOLF+HDOWK&HQWHUVSHUIRUPLQJDGDLO\&7&VHUYLFH
7HFKQLFDOSDUDPHWHUVUHODWHGWRFRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGNLQGRIWUHDWPHQWQHHGHGIRU
DGYHUVHHYHQWVZHUHDOVRLQYHVWLJDWHG7KHTXHVWLRQQDLUHZDVFRPSOHWHGE\FOLQL
FDOGLUHFWRUIURPDOOUDGLRORJ\GHSDUWPHQWV5HVSRQVHVZHUHDQDO\VHGDQGUDZ
IUHTXHQFLHVZHUHGHWHUPLQHG
5HVXOWV$OOFHQWUHV LQWHUYLHZHGDQVZHUHGSRVLWLYHO\WRWKH6XUYH\$PRQJ
FHQWHUV &7 FRORQRJUDSK\ H[DPV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG 1R GHDWKV ZHUH
UHSRUWHG SDWLHQWVH[SHULHQFHGDFRPSOLFDWLRQGXULQJWKHSURFHGXUH
YDVRYDJDOVHOIOLPLWLQJDWWDFNHSLVRGHV DQGSHUIRUDWLRQV
,Q FDVHVWKHVLWHRISHUIRUDWLRQZDVZLWKLQWKHUHFWXPLQ FDVHV
ZLWKLQ WKH VLJPRLG FRORQ 1R FDVH RI SHUIRUDWLRQ ZLWKLQ WUDQVYHUVH DVFHQGLQJ
FRORQ DQG FDHFXP7KUHH SDWLHQWV KDG WR XQGHUJR VXUJHU\7KH UHPDLQLQJ IRXU
SDWLHQWVKDGDFRQVHUYDWLYHWUHDWPHQW)RXURXWRIVHYHQFDVHVRISHUIRUDWLRQKDG
DFRQYHQWLRQDOFRORQRVFRS\LQWKHSDVWVHYHQGD\VSULRUWR&7&DQGRQWKHVDPH
GD\RIWKHH[DPUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ ,Q VXPPDU\ ZH IRXQG D ORZ UDWH RI FRORQLF SHUIRUDWLRQ
WKDW ZHUH DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK &7 FRORQRJUDSK\ 7KH UDWH RI RFFXUUHQFH RI OXPLQDO
SHUIRUDWLRQKRZHYHUZDVPRUHWKDQIRXUWLPHVORZHUWKDQZHUHHTXLYDOHQWUDWHV
SXEOLVKHGIRUFRORQRVFRS\
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
9DOXHRI&7FRORQRJUDSK\DVSUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\SULRUWRODSDURVFRSLF
VXUJHU\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKFRORQPDOLJQDQFLHVDQGFRPSOLFDWHG
GLYHUWLFXODUGLVHDVH
55L]]DWL67DUWDUL&&DYDOOLQL03ULQFLYDOOH55LJKL*$QDQLD
*%HQHD/DJRVDQWR)HUUDUD,7)HUUDUD,7 UUL]]DWL#DXVOIHLW
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHFOLQLFDOYDOXHRI&7FRORQRJUDSK\ &7& LQWKHGLDJQRVLV
DQGVWDJLQJRIFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU &5& DQGFRPSOLFDWHGGLYHUWLFXODUGLVHDVHLQ
RUGHUWRSURSHUO\SODQWKHODSDURVFRSLFVXUJHU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-DQXDU\XQWLO1RYHPEHUSDWLHQWV
VFKHGXOHGIRUVXUJHU\IRU&5&RUFRPSOLFDWHGGLYHUWLFXOLWLV NQRZQRUVXVSHFWHG
XQGHUZHQW&7&$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHSUHYLRXVO\HYDOXDWHGZLWKRSWLFDOFRORQRVFRS\
2& 6HQVLWLYLW\LQOHVLRQORFDWLRQDQGGHWHFWLRQZDVFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQ2&DQG
&7&DQGGLVFUHSDQFLHVDQDO\VHG$FFXUDF\RI&7&LQ&5&VWDJLQJZDVGHWHUPLQHG
5HVXOWV$WRWDORI&5&DQGFRPSOLFDWHGGLYHUWLFXOLWLVZHUHFODVVLÀHGE\&7&
2&ZDVLQFRPSOHWHLQ FDVHV7KHUHZHUHFDVHVRIGLVFUHSDQF\RI
OHVLRQORFDWLRQFRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHGE\&7&DQGSRO\SRLG PP OHVLRQVGHWHFWHG
E\&7&DQGPLVVHGE\2&%DVLQJRQ&7&DVVHVVPHQWFDVHVRIFRPSOLFDWHG
GLYHUWLFXOLWLVZHUHPDQDJHGPHGLFDOO\SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWFRQYHQWLRQDORSHQ
VXUJHU\IRU&5&DQG &5&DQGFRPSOLFDWHGGLYHUWLFXOLWLV ODSDURVFRSLF
VXUJHU\ 6HQVLWLYLW\ RI &7& LQ 710 SUHRSHUDWLYH VWDJLQJ RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK &5&
UHVXOWHGWREHUHVSHFWLYHO\DQG,QGLDJQRVLVRIFRPSOLFDWHG
GLYHUWLFXODUGLVHDVH&7&VKRZHGDJUHHPHQWUHJDUGLQJORFDWLRQDQGH[WHQW
RIWKHOHVLRQDQGVHQVLWLYLW\IRUFRPSOLFDWLRQV)XUWKHUPRUH&7&GHWHFWHG
H[WUDFRORQLFÀQGLQJVRIZKRPRIPDMRUFOLQLFDOUHOHYDQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ&7&SURYLGHVDFFXUDWHVWDJLQJRIFRORQFDQFHUDQGGHWDLOHGHYDOX
DWLRQ RI FRPSOLFDWHG GLYHUWLFXODU GLVHDVH DOORZLQJ DQ DSSURSULDWH PDQDJHPHQW
RISDWLHQWDQGPDNLQJWKHODSDURVFRSLFVXUJLFDOSODQQLQJPRUHSUHFLVHDQGVDIHU
%
(IIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHLQ&7FRORQRJUDSK\GLGZHPDNHSURJUHVV"
71%RHOODDUG+:9HQHPD*-6WUHHNVWUD-6WRNHU$PVWHUGDP1/
WQERHOODDUG#DPFXYDQO
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIIHFWLYHUDGLDWLRQGRVHXVHGIRU&7FRORQRJUDSK\DQGWR
FRPSDUHWKHVHZLWKSUHYLRXVLQYHQWRULHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7FRORQRJUDSK\LQVWLWXWLRQVWKDWKDGSXEOLVKHGRQ&7
FRORQRJUDSK\ ZHUH LQYLWHG WR SDUWLFLSDWH$ TXHVWLRQQDLUH ZDV VHQW FRQFHUQLQJ
&7FRORQRJUDSK\VFDQSURWRFROV0HGLDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG SURQH
VXSLQHDQGFRPELQHG IRUGDLO\SUDFWLFHDQGVFUHHQLQJSURWRFROVDQGFRPSDUHG
ZLWKHDUOLHULQYHQWRULHV6HSDUDWHDQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGIRUWKHXVHRILQWUDYH
QRXVFRQWUDVWDQGDFDGHPLFYHUVXVQRQDFDGHPLF'LIIHUHQFHVLQHIIHFWLYHGRVH
ZHUHWHVWHGIRUVLJQLÀFDQFHXVLQJD:LOFR[RQUDQNVXPRU:LOFR[RQVLJQHGUDQN
WHVWZKHUHDSSURSULDWH
5HVXOWV,QWRWDORI LQVWLWXWLRQVUHVSRQGHGSURYLGLQJSURWRFROV
0HGLDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHIRUGDLO\SUDFWLFHSURWRFROVZDVP6Y P6YDQG
P6YIRUVXSLQHDQGSURQH DQGIRUVFUHHQLQJP6Y P6YDQGP6YIRU
VXSLQHDQGSURQH S )RUGDLO\SUDFWLFHZLWKDQGZLWKRXWFRQWUDVWPHGLDQ
HIIHFWLYHGRVHVZHUHP6Y Q DQGP6Y Q S $FDGHPLF
DQGQRQDFDGHPLFLQVWLWXWLRQVXVHGVLPLODUGRVHV GDLO\SUDFWLFHYVP6Y
S! DQGVFUHHQLQJYVP6Y S! )RULQVWLWXWLRQVZKLFKDOVR
SDUWLFLSDWHGLQDLQYHQWRU\HIIHFWLYHGRVHIRUERWKGDLO\SUDFWLFHDQGVFUHHQ
LQJSURWRFROVZHUHVLPLODU S! EXWIRUGDLO\SUDFWLFHORZHUWKDQLQD
LQYHQWRU\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ0HGLDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHRIGDLO\SUDFWLFHSURWRFROVKDVGHFUHDVHGDV
FRPSDUHGWREXWQRWWR)XUWKHUUHGXFWLRQLVGHVLUDEOHWRUHGXFHUDGLD
WLRQEXUGHQLQ&7FRORQRJUDSK\DQGLQFUHDVHLWVDFFHSWDQFH
%
&RPSDULVRQRIVOLFH&7FRORQRJUDSK\ZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO
FRORQRVFRS\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKXOFHUDWLYHFROLWLV
13UDEKDNDU1.DOUD'.%KDVLQ65DQD56LQJK1.KDQGHOZDO
&KDQGLJDUK,1
3XUSRVH&OLQLFDODQGFRORQRVFRSLFÀQGLQJVDUHXVHGIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRISDWLHQWV
ZLWKXOFHUDWLYHFROLWLVDQGWKHLUIROORZXS7KHSXUSRVHRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUH
WKH ÀQGLQJV RI &7 FRORQRJUDSK\ &7& ZLWK FRQYHQWLRQDO FRORQRVFRS\ && LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKXOFHUDWLYHFROLWLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\FRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVSURYHQ
WRKDYHXOFHUDWLYHFROLWLVRQELRSV\DQGSUHVHQWO\LQFOLQLFDOO\UHPLVVLRQXQGHUZHQW
&7&DQG&&ZLWKLQRQHZHHNRIHDFKRWKHU7KH&&ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRQVLGHUHG
DVJROGVWDQGDUG7KHLQYHVWLJDWRUVSHUIRUPLQJ&7&DQG&&ZHUHEOLQGHGWRWKH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ÀQGLQJVRIWKHRWKHUVWXG\&KLVTXDUHWHVWDQGNDSSDWHVWZHUHXVHGWRFRPSDUH
WKH ÀQGLQJV RQ &7& DQG && 6HQVLWLYLW\ DQG VSHFLÀFLW\ RQ &7& IRU GHWHFWLQJ
SVHXGRSRO\SVDQGJUDQXODULW\LQDVHJPHQWZHUHDOVRFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV*RRGFRUUHODWLRQZDVVHHQEHWZHHQ&7&DQG&&IRUGHWHFWLRQRIJUDQXODU
DSSHDUDQFHDQGSVHXGRSRO\SV6HQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\RQ&7&IRUGHWHFWLQJ
SVHXGRSRO\SVZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\DQGIRUJUDQXODUDSSHDUDQFH
ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\/RVVRIKDXVWUDOIROGVSHULFRORQLFYDVFXODULW\
SHULFRORQLFO\PSKQRGHVDQGZDOOWKLFNHQLQJVHHQRQ&7&ZHUHIRXQGWRFRUUHODWH
ZLWKLQWUDOXPLQDOÀQGLQJVVHHQRQ&&7KHVHFDQEHXVHGDVDGGLWLRQDOPDUNHUV
RIGLVHDVHH[WHQWLQDVVRFLDWLRQZLWKLQWUDOXPLQDOÀQGLQJVRQ&7&
&RQFOXVLRQ&7&FDQEHXVHGDVDQDOOLQRQHWHFKQLTXHIRUHYDOXDWLQJSDWLHQWV
ZLWKXOFHUDWLYHFROLWLVZKRDUHLQUHPLVVLRQ,WSURYLGHVLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKHERZHO
OXPHQERZHOZDOODQGH[WUDOXPLQDODEQRUPDOLWLHVLQWKHVHSDWLHQWV
%
/RZGRVHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\WRGHWHFWERG\SDFNLQJVWHSZLVH
GRVHUHGXFWLRQLQDQDQLPDOPRGHO
0+0DXUHU601LHKXHV'6FKQDSDXII&*ULHVHU-5RWKH66&KRSUD
%+DPP7'HQHFNH%HUOLQ'( PDUWLQPDXUHU#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH7RGHWHUPLQHWKHYDOXHRIORZGRVHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\ &7 WRGHWHFW
ERG\SDFNLQJ LQJHVWHGGUXJSDFNHWV DVDQDOWHUQDWLYHWRSODLQUDGLRJUDSKVLQDQ
DQLPDOPRGHOZLWKVWHSZLVH&7GRVHUHGXFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHOYHSDFNHWVFRQWDLQLQJFRFDLQH SXULW\! ZHUH
LQWURGXFHGLQWRWKHLQWHVWLQHRIDQDQLPDO FURVVEUHGSLJNJ ZKLFKZDVWKHQ
UHSHDWHGO\H[DPLQHGE\DEGRPLQDO&7ZLWKVWHSZLVHGRVHUHGXFWLRQ WXEHYROWDJH
N9 WXEH FXUUHQW P$ GHWHFWRU FROOLPDWLRQ [ PP SLWFK
URWDWLRQWLPHPVVFDQOHQJWKFP 7KUHHEOLQGHGUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\
HYDOXDWHGWKH&7GDWDVHWV LPDJHVUHFRQVWUXFWHGDWPPVOLFHWKLFNQHVVLQFUH
PHQW VWDUWLQJZLWKWKHORZHVWWXEHFXUUHQWDQGQRWHGWKHQXPEHUVRISDFNHWV
GHWHFWHGDWWKHGLIIHUHQWWXEHFXUUHQWVXVHG2QHH[SHULHQFHGUHDGHUGHWHUPLQHG
WKHQXPEHURISDFNHWVGHWHFWDEOHRQSODLQDEGRPLQDOUDGLRJUDSKVDQGXOWUDVRXQG
5HVXOWV7KHWKUHVKROGIRUFRUUHFWLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIDOOGUXJSDFNHWVZDVP$
IRUUHDGHUDQGP$IRUUHDGHUVDQG$ERYHWKHVHWKUHVKROGVDOOUHDG
HUV FRQVLVWHQWO\ LGHQWLÀHG DOO SDFNHWV 7KH HIIHFWLYH GRVH RI D ORZGRVH &7
VFDQZLWKP$ LQFOXGLQJVFRXWYLHZ ZDVP6YZKLFKZDVEHORZWKDWRI
FRQYHQWLRQDODEGRPLQDOUDGLRJUDSKV P6Y 7KHUHDGHULQWHUSUHWLQJWKHFRQ
YHQWLRQDOUDGLRJUDSKVLGHQWLÀHGDWRWDORIGUXJSDFNHWVDQGGHWHFWHGSDFNHWV
E\DEGRPLQDOXOWUDVRXQG
&RQFOXVLRQ([WHQVLYHGRVHUHGXFWLRQPDNHVORZGRVH&7DYDOXDEOHDOWHUQDWLYH
LPDJLQJPRGDOLW\IRUWKHH[DPLQDWLRQRIVXVSHFWHGERG\SDFNHUVDQGPLJKWUHSODFH
FRQYHQWLRQDODEGRPLQDOUDGLRJUDSKVDVWKHÀUVWOLQHLPDJLQJPRGDOLW\
%
0DWHULDOGHFRPSRVLWLRQRIVSHFWUDO&7DQHZZD\LQWKHSUHGLFWLRQ
RIUHVSRQVHWRFKHPRWKHUDS\LQJDVWULFFDUFLQRPD"
/7DQJ;3=KDQJ<66XQ/34L<&XL6<*DR</L%HLMLQJ&1
WDQJOHL#EMFDQFHURUJ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
7KHDFFXUDF\RISUHRSHUDWLYH&7LQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHDFXWHDEGRPHQ
-:HLU0F&DOO'&KULVWRGRXORX$6KDZ$$U\D$.QLJKW'+RZOHWW
'XQGHH8./RQGRQ8.(DVWERXUQH8.
3XUSRVH:KLOHWKHUHLVDORWRIGDWDRQWKHDFFXUDF\RI&7LQGLDJQRVLQJVSHFLÀF
FDXVHVRIDQDFXWHDEGRPHQWKHUHLVYHU\OLWWOHLQIRUPDWLRQRQWKHDFFXUDF\RI
&7LQWKHDFXWHJHQHUDOVXUJLFDODGPLVVLRQVZRUNORDG:HORRNDWWKHGLDJQRVWLF
DFFXUDF\ RI &7 LQ SDWLHQWV SUHVHQWLQJ ZLWK DQ DFXWH DEGRPHQ ZKR XOWLPDWHO\
UHTXLUHGODSDURWRP\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 3DWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW HPHUJHQF\ ODSDURWRP\ IURP
WRDWRXUKRVSLWDOZLWKDSUHRSHUDWLYH&7RQWKHVDPHDGPLVVLRQZHUH
LQFOXGHG7KH&7UHSRUWZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHODSDURWRP\DQGKLVWRORJ\ÀQGLQJV
DQGZKHUHDGLVFUHSDQF\H[LVWHGWKHRULJLQDOVFDQVZHUHUHYLHZHGE\DVHQLRU
FRQVXOWDQWEOLQGHGWRWKHRULJLQDOUHSRUWDQGODSDURWRP\ÀQGLQJV
5HVXOWV HPHUJHQF\ ODSDURWRPLHV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG RYHU WKH \HDU SHULRG
ZLWKSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJDSUHRSHUDWLYH&7SDWLHQWVZHUHH[FOXGHGGXH
WRPLVVLQJQRWHV,QWKHUHPDLQLQJSDWLHQWV&7UHSRUWVFRUUHODWHGZLWKWKH
ÀQDORSHUDWLYHGLDJQRVLVJLYLQJDGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI2IWKHVHWKHRQFDOO
UHJLVWUDUZDVWKHLQLWLDOUHSRUWHULQ&7VZLWKDGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI2Q
UHYLHZRIWKH&7VFDQE\DVHFRQGFRQVXOWDQWWKLVLQFUHDVHGWRFRUUHODWLRQV
\LHOGLQJDQDFFXUDF\RI'HOD\EHWZHHQ&7VFDQDQGRSHUDWLRQGLGQRWVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\DOWHUGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\QRUZDVWKHUHDQ\VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWUHGXFWLRQ
LQDFFXUDF\LQUHSRUWVLVVXHGE\RQFDOOUHJLVWUDUV
&RQFOXVLRQ2QÀUVWUHSRUWLQJ&7PLVVHVRIGLDJQRVLVWKDWXOWLPDWHO\UHTXLUH
RSHUDWLYHLQWHUYHQWLRQ5HGXFLQJWKHWKUHVKROGIRUREWDLQLQJDVHFRQGFRQVXOWDQW
UDGLRORJLVWUHYLHZVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHVWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\WR
%
4XDQWLWDWLYHLPDJLQJELRPDUNHUVIURP3(7&7DVSRWHQWLDOFRUUHODWHV
IRUDQJLRJHQHVLVDQGK\SR[LDLQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
%*DQHVKDQ==LDXGGLQ9-*RK05RGULJXH]-XVWR$(QJOHGRZ
67D\ORU6+DOOLJDQ.$0LOHV$0*URYHV%ULJKWRQ8./RQGRQ8.
EJDQHVKDQ#VXVVH[DFXN
3XUSRVH,QWHJUDWHG3(7&7V\VWHPVDOORZPHDVXUHPHQWVRIWUDFHUXSWDNHRQ
3(7WREHFRPELQHGZLWKTXDQWLWDWLYHLPDJLQJELRPDUNHUVIURP&77KLVVWXG\DLPV
WRLGHQWLI\KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOFRUUHODWHVIRUÁXRURGHR[\JOXFRVH )'* XSWDNH&7
DWWHQXDWLRQDQG&7KHWHURJHQHLW\LQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)'*3(7ZDVSHUIRUPHGSURVSHFWLYHO\LQDVHULHV
RISDWLHQWVZLWKFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU)'*XSWDNH PD[LPDOVWDQGDUGLVHGXSWDNH
YDOXH689PD[ &7DWWHQXDWLRQDQG&7KHWHURJHQHLW\IRUXQHQKDQFHGLPDJHV
ZHUHTXDQWLÀHGLQDUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW 52, HQFRPSDVVLQJWKHSULPDU\WXPRXU
+HWHURJHQHLW\ZDVH[SUHVVHGDVWKHVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ 6' RISL[HOYDOXHVLQ&7
LPDJHVZLWKDQGZLWKRXWÀOWUDWLRQWRKLJKOLJKWLPDJHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVUDQJLQJIURPÀQH
GHWDLOWRFRDUVHIHDWXUHV DVGHWHUPLQHGE\WKHÀOWHUYDOXH 8VLQJWKH6SHDUPDQ
UDQN PHWKRG DOO LPDJLQJ SDUDPHWHUV ZHUH FRUUHODWHG ZLWK WXPRXU PLFURYHVVHO
GHQVLW\ 09' DQGH[SUHVVLRQRIYDVFXODUHQGRWKHOLDOJURZWKIDFWRU 9(*) DQG
*OXWRQKLVWRORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQRIUHVHFWHGWXPRXUV
5HVXOWV +LVWRORJLFDO GDWD ZHUH DYDLODEOH LQ FDVHV &7 KHWHURJHQHLW\ ÀOWHU
YDOXH ZDVWKHEHVWFRUUHODWHIRU09' UV S 689PD[FRU
UHODWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKH[SUHVVLRQRI9(*) UV S EXWQRW*OXW
UV S 7KHUDWLRRI689PD[WR&7KHWHURJHQHLW\ ÀOWHUYDOXH
ZDVWKHEHVWFRUUHODWHIRUH[SUHVVLRQRI9(*) UV S DQG*OXW
UV S
&RQFOXVLRQ$GGLWLRQRI&7EDVHGELRPDUNHUVKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRLQFUHDVHWKH
XWLOLW\RI3(7&7E\HQKDQFLQJWKHLPDJLQJFRUUHODWHVIRUDQJLRJHQHVLVDQGK\SR[LD
LQFRORUHFWDOFDQFHU
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHWKHXVHRIWKHLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQ ,& GHULYHGIURPPDWH
ULDOGHFRPSRVLWLRQRIVSHFWUDO&7DVDUHVSRQVHLQGLFDWRULQSDWLHQWVZLWKJDVWULF
FDUFLQRPDWUHDWHGZLWKFKHPRWKHUDS\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\WZRSDWLHQWVZLWKJDVWULFFDQFHUZHUHVFDQQHGRQ
D*('LVFRYHU\&7+'XVLQJVSHFWUDOLPDJLQJPRGHEHIRUHDQGPRQWKV
DIWHUFKHPRWKHUDS\3DWLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWKHJRRGUHVSRQVHJURXS *RRG5
DQGSRRUUHVSRQVHJURXS 3RRU5 DFFRUGLQJWR5(&,67FULWHULD7KHLRGLQHZDWHU
EDVLVPDWHULDOGHFRPSRVLWLRQLPDJHVDQGPRQRFKURPDWLFLPDJHVRQDUWHULDODQG
YHQRXVSKDVHFRYHULQJWKHHQWLUHVWRPDFKZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHG$QRYDOUHJLRQVRI
LQWHUHVW 52, ZDVSODFHGRQWKHKLJKHVWHQKDQFHGUHJLRQRIJDVWULFFDUFLQRPD7KH
LRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQV ,&PJFF LQ52,VZHUHUHFRUGHGDQGWKHGHFUHDVHUDWHRI
,&ZDVFRPSXWHGE\WKHIRUPXODу,& ,&EHIRUH,&DIWHU ,&EHIRUHð7KH
GHFUHDVHUDWHVRI,&EHWZHHQWZRJURXSVZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJLQGHSHQGHQWWWHVW
5HVXOWV :H UHFRUGHG D SRVLWLYH FRUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ у,& DQG WKH VKULQNDJH
UDWHRIWXPRXUVL]HRQERWKSKDVHV DUWHULDOSKDVHU 3YHQRXV
SKDVHU 3 7KHUHZHUHFDVHVRI*RRG5DQGFDVHVRI3RRU5
6WDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHRIу,&ZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGEHWZHHQ*RRG5DQG3RRU5DW
YHQRXVSKDVH = 3 EXWQRWDWDUWHULDOSKDVH = 3!
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUÀQGLQJVVXJJHVWWKDWLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQGHULYHGIURPVSHFWUDO
&7LPDJLQJFRXOGSURYLGHFOLQLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWHYDOXDWLRQRIJDVWULF
FDUFLQRPD3URVSHFWLYHVWXGLHVZLWKODUJHVDPSOHVDUHQHHGHGWRWHVWLWVUHSURGXF
LELOLW\DQGWRGHWHUPLQHWKHGLDJQRVWLFWKUHVKROG
%
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP&
2QFRORJLF,PDJLQJ
66
&(05,DQG':,05,IRUFDQFHUHYDOXDWLRQ
0RGHUDWRUV
6'HORUPH+HLGHOEHUJ'(
5*LURPHWWL8GLQH,7
%
,QWHUVFDQQHUFRPSDULVRQRIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,LQ
SURVWDWHFDQFHU7YHUVXV705
06HUWGHPLU''LQWHU'+DXVPDQQ+-0LFKDHO\66FK|QEHUJ$:HLGQHU
0DQQKHLP'( 0HWLQ6HUWGHPLU#XPPGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSRWHQWLDORI'&(05,WRGLIIHUHQWLDWHPDOLJ
QDQWYVQRUPDOSURVWDWHDQGSURVWDWLWLVWLVVXHZLWKVSHFLDOUHJDUGWRGLIIHUHQWÀHOG
VWUHQJWKVRIYV7HVOD
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK ELRSV\ DQGRU SURVWDWHFWRP\ RI WKH
SURVWDWHZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGDW7LQSDWLHQWVZLWK
ELRSV\SURYHQSURVWDWHFDQFHU 3& DQGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSURVWDWLWLVDW705,
ZDVXQGHUWDNHQLQSDWLHQWVEHIRUHSURVWDWHFWRP\DIWHUKLVWRORJLFDOO\SURYHQ3&
DQGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSURVWDWLWLV05,ZDVXQGHUWDNHQZLWKFRPELQHGERG\DQG
HQGRUHFWDOFRLOSURWRFROLQDOOSDWLHQWVXVLQJD'7XUER)/$6+7:*5(VHTXHQFH
WRFDOFXODWHSODVPDÁRZ 3) DQGPHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 077 YDOXHV
5HVXOWV3&VKRZHGKLJKHU3) S DQGVKRUWHU077 S DW7
DVZHOODVDW7 SIRU3)DQGS IRU077 FRPSDUHGWRQRUPDO
WLVVXH3&GHPRQVWUDWHGKLJKHU3)WKDQSURVWDWLWLV S DQGVKRUWHU077
S DW7EXWRQO\VKRUWHU077 S DW7ZLWKRXWVLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHU3)YDOXHV S ,QFRPSDULVRQZLWKQRUPDOWLVVXHSURVWDWLWLVKDGD
VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWKLJKHU3)DW7 S EXWQRWDW7 S DQG
QRVLJQLÀFDQWO\VKRUWHU077YDOXHVERWKDW7 S DQG7 S
&RQFOXVLRQ%RWKÀHOGVWUHQJWKVDUHFDSDEOHWRGLIIHUHQWLDWH3&YVQRUPDOWLVVXH
8VLQJ73&FDQEHEHWWHUGHOLQHDWHGIURPSURVWDWLWLVFRPSDUHGWR71HYHUWKH
OHVVWKHUHVXOWVDUHHTXLYRFDOIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRISURVWDWLWLVDQGQRUPDOWLVVXH
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,IHDWXUHVRIHDUO\ PLFURVFRSLF H[WUD
FDSVXODUGLVHDVHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQSURVWDWLFFDQFHU
&6LW1'LNDLRV$.LUNKDP&$OOHQ$)UHHPDQ&0RRUH0(PEHUWRQ
-.HOO\63XQZDQL/RQGRQ8. FKHUU\K\VLW#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,IRUGHWHFWLRQRIPLFURVFRSLFH[WUD
FDSVXODUGLVHDVHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQSHULSKHUDO]RQHSURVWDWHFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3UHELRSV\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05LPDJHVRISDWLHQWV
ZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOO\GLDJQRVHGSHULSKHUDO]RQHWXPRXU ZLWKRXWPDFURVFRSLFH[WUD
FDSVXODUGLVHDVHRQLPDJLQJ ZHUHUHWULHYHGIRUSURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLV+LVWRORJLFDO
FRQÀUPDWLRQRIWXPRXUZDVE\VWDQGDUGFRUH7586ELRSV\DQGRIWKH
SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWVXEVHTXHQWUDGLFDOSURVWDWHFWRP\$QH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVW
DZDUHRIWKHKLVWRORJLFDOO\FRQÀUPHGWXPRXUVLWHXQDZDUHRISUHVHQFHRUDEVHQFH
RIPLFURVFRSLFH[WUDFDSVXODUH[WHQVLRQ (&( FRQWRXUHGWKHWXPRXURQFRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHG LPDJHV UHFRUGLQJ L WRWDO WXPRXU YROXPH LL WRWDO DUHD RI FDSVXODU
DEXWPHQW LLL WXPRXUPXVFOHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\UDWLR LY V\PPHWU\RISHULSURVWDWLF
YDVFXODUHQKDQFHPHQW Y V\PPHWU\RIFDSVXODUHQKDQFHPHQW YL DUHDXQGHU
WXPRXUVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\WLPHFXUYH YLL LQLWLDOVORSHRIHQKDQFHPHQWRIWKHVLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\WLPHFXUYH YLLL PD[LPXPHQKDQFHPHQWUDWLR L[ HQKDQFHPHQWFXUYH
VKDSH W\SH,,,RU,,, 'LIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQPHDQYDOXHVRIFRQWLQXRXVYDULDEOHV
ZHUHDVVHVVHGXVLQJWWHVWDQG0DQQ:KLWQH\VWDWLVWLFVDQGGLIIHUHQFHVLQFDWHJRUL
FDOYDULDEOHVZHUHDVVHVVHGXVLQJFKLVTXDUHDQG)LVKHUҋVH[DFWWHVWVIRUSDWLHQWV
ZLWKDQGZLWKRXWKLVWRORJLFDO(&(
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVKDGKLVWRORJLFDOO\FRQÀUPHG(&(7KHUHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
LQFUHDVHGYDVFXODULW\RQWKHVDPHVLGHDVWKHSURVWDWLFWXPRXUIRUSDWLHQWVZLWK
(&( S 7KHUH ZDV QR VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK DQG
ZLWKRXW(&(IRUDQ\RIWKHRWKHUSDUDPHWHUV S WR
&RQFOXVLRQ,QFUHDVHGLSVLODWHUDOSHULSURVWDWLFYDVFXODULW\DORQHZDVDVVRFLDWHG
ZLWK(&(RQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
05,DVDQLPDJLQJVXUURJDWHWRSUHGLFWUDGLDWLRQGRVLPHWU\ERUGHUV
DPHWKRGRORJ\IHDVLELOLW\VWXG\
$.RYDFV32=LQQ)36FKZDUP)$-ROHV],5HSD55&ROHQ
.DSRVYDU+87H[DV7;86%RVWRQ0$86 NRYDFVDUSDG#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R GHYHORS D UREXVW PHWKRGRORJ\ XVLQJ 05, IRU SUHGLFWLQJ UDGLDWLRQ
GRVLPHWU\ERUGHUVRIWKHWXPRXUEH\RQGWKHDUHDRIHQKDQFHPHQWIRUUDGLDWLRQ
WUHDWPHQWSODQQLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\LGHQWLÀHGFRQVHFXWLYHJOLREODVWRPD
PXOWLIRUPHSDWLHQWV ZKRPKDG SUHVXUJLFDOSRVWVXUJLFDOSUHUDGLDWLRQ
DQG UHODSVH 05, VWXGLHV DQG XQGHUJRQH UDGLDWLRQ WUHDWPHQW 57 ' 6OLFHU
VRIWZDUH VOLFHURUJ ZDVXVHGIRULPDJHDQDO\VLVPDQLSXODWLRQDQGVHJPHQWD
WLRQ7ZRQHXURUDGLRORJLVWV 55&)$- UHYLHZHGWKHLPDJHVLQFRQVHQVXV7KUHH
VWUXFWXUHVZHUHVHJPHQWHG RHGHPDLQYDVLRQHQKDQFLQJWXPRXUDQGQHFURVLV
6XEVHTXHQWO\WKHPRGHOVTXDQWLWDWLYHYROXPHVRIRHGHPDWXPRXUDQGQHFURVLV
ZHUHFDOFXODWHG05SHUIXVLRQ 053 VFDQV 1 ZHUHUHJLVWHUHGWRVHJPHQWHG
LPDJHVDQGTXDQWLWDWLYHSHUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVREWDLQHG7KHVHZHUHWKHQUHJLVWHUHG
WRWKHUDGLDWLRQSODQQLQJ&7LPDJHVDQGWKHGRVLPHWU\FXUYHVVXSHULPSRVHG
5HVXOWV$FFXUDWHUHJLVWUDWLRQ ZLWKLQPP RFFXUUHGDPRQJWKHLPDJHVDQGWKH
UDGLDWLRQSODQQLQJ&7LPDJHVSDWLHQWVGHPRQVWUDWHGLQFUHDVHVLQSHUIXVLRQ
UHÁHFWLYHRIWXPRXULQÀOWUDWLRQ EH\RQGWKHERUGHURIHQKDQFHPHQWDQGFRUUHVSRQG
LQJWRWKHUHJLRQVRIVXEVHTXHQWUHFXUUHQFHVXJJHVWLQJWKDWUDGLDWLRQSODQQLQJ
WRLQFOXGHWKRVHDEQRUPDOUHJLRQVVHHQRQDGYDQFHLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXHV QRWRQ
FRQYHQWLRQDO05, PLJKWUHVXOWLQEHWWHUWXPRXUWUHDWPHQWDQGFRQWURORIUHFXUUHQFH
&RQFOXVLRQ:HSUHVHQWDUREXVWLPDJHDQDO\VLVPHWKRGRORJ\SODWIRUPIRUDF
FXUDWH UHJLVWUDWLRQ RI FRQYHQWLRQDO DQG DGYDQFHG 05, VHTXHQFHV DQG ZLWK WKH
UDGLDWLRQSODQQLQJ&7LPDJHV05SHUIXVLRQDEQRUPDOLWLHVVHHQRXWVLGHWKHDUHD
RIHQKDQFHPHQWSUHGLFWUHJLRQVRIVXEVHTXHQWUHFXUUHQFHDQGWKXVUHJLVWHULQJDQG
LQFOXGLQJWKHVHUHJLRQVLQWKH57DQGGRVLPHWU\SODQQLQJV\VWHPFDQEHH[SHFWHG
WRGHFUHDVHWXPRXUUHFXUUHQFHDQGLQFUHDVHVXUYLYDO
%
'LDJQRVWLFYDOXHRIIXQFWLRQDOPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJIRU
GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIEHQLJQRVWHRSRURVLVDQGPXOWLSOHP\HORPD
06XPNDXVNDLWH-+LOOHQJDVV&+HLVV0'RUQLVFK
%6WLHOWMHV+36FKOHPPHU+*ROGVFKPLGW6'HORUPH
+HLGHOEHUJ'( PLJOHV#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7KH DLP RI RXU VWXG\ ZDV WR DVVHVV WKH YDOXH RI G\QDPLF FRQWUDVW
HQKDQFHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ '&(05, DQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJ
LQJ ':, RIWKHERQHPDUURZIRUGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHQLJQRVWHRSRURVLVDQGPXOWLSOH
P\HORPD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQDQGWZHQW\SDWLHQWVZLWKXQWUHDWHG
PXOWLSOH P\HORPD DQG WZHQW\ SDWLHQWV ZLWK FOLQLFDOO\ FRQÀUPHG LGLRSDWKLF RU
SRVWPHQRSDXVDORVWHRSRURVLVZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\H[DPLQHGXVLQJD7HVOD05
VFDQQHU 0DJQHWRP 6\PSKRQ\ 6LHPHQV (UODQJHQ *HUPDQ\ ':, DQG '&(
05, RI WKH OXPEDU VSLQH ZHUH SHUIRUPHG LQ DOO SDWLHQWV '&(05, SDUDPHWHUV
DPSOLWXGH$ DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK EORRG YROXPH DQG H[FKDQJH UDWH FRQVWDQW NHS
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKYHVVHOSHUPHDELOLW\ DVZHOOWKH':,SDUDPHWHUV DFFRUGLQJWR
WKHLQWUDYR[HOLQFRKHUHQWPRWLRQ ,9,0 PRGHO SHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQIDQGGLIIXVLRQ
FRQVWDQW'ZHUHHYDOXDWHGIRUHDFKOXPEDUYHUWHEUDVHSDUDWHO\E\DUDGLRORJLVW
EOLQGHGWRWKHSDWLHQWҋVKLVWRU\
5HVXOWV$DQGNHSLQ'&(05,ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQWKHP\HORPDJURXSWKDQ
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKRVWHRSRURVLV 3:LOFR[RQ5DQN6XP7HVW )XUWKHUPRUH
DVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHGGLIIXVLRQFRQVWDQW'ZDVIRXQGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKPXOWLSOH
P\HORPD 3:LOFR[RQ5DQN6XP7HVW 1RVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQG
IRUWKHSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQI 3 :LOFR[RQ5DQN6XP7HVW
&RQFOXVLRQ'&(05,DQG':,PD\DVVLVWLQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJEHQLJQRVWHRSRURVLV
IURPPDOLJQDQWERQHGLVHDVHFDXVHGE\PXOWLSOHP\HORPD
%
(DUO\SUHGLFWLRQRIKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOUHVSRQVHWRSUHRSHUDWLYH
FKHPRWKHUDS\LQORFDOO\DGYDQFHGJDVWULFFDQFHUE\)'*3(7&7
)0DJJL//HFFLVRWWL*7UHJOLD53HUVLDQL$*LRUGDQR/%RQRPR5RPH,7
IPDJJL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH3UHRSHUDWLYHFKHPRWKHUDS\FDQLPSURYHWKHSURJQRVLVRISDWLHQWVZLWK
ORFDOO\DGYDQFHGJDVWULFFDQFHU /$*& $LPRIWKLVSURVSHFWLYHREVHUYDWLRQDOVWXG\
LVHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRI)'*3(7&7WRHDUO\SUHGLFWKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOUHVSRQVH
GXULQJSUHRSHUDWLYHFKHPRWKHUDS\LQDJURXSRIDFFXUDWHO\VWDJHG/$*&SDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVZLWKUHVHFWDEOH/$*& F7DEDQ\1RUDQ\F7
ZLWKQRGHPHWDVWDVHV ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\DQGXQGHUZHQW)'*3(7&7
DWEDVHOLQHDQGGD\VDIWHULQLWLDWLRQRIFKHPRWKHUDS\3DWLHQWVZLWKQRQDYLG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
)'*WXPRXUDWEDVHOLQH3(7&7ZHUHH[FOXGHG&OLQLFDOUHVWDJLQJZDVUHSHDWHG
SUHRSHUDWLYHO\7XPRUDOPHWDEROLFUHVSRQVHZDVDVVHVVHGDFFRUGLQJWR(257&
FULWHULD+LVWRSDWKRORJLFDOUHVSRQVHZDVDVVHVVHGTXDOLWDWLYHO\E\7GRZQVWDJLQJ
DQG TXDQWLWDWLYHO\ E\ JUDGLQJ RI WXPRXU UHJUHVVLRQ LQGXFHG E\ SUHRSHUDWLYH
FKHPRWKHUDS\DFFRUGLQJWR%HFNHUҋVFULWHULD
5HVXOWV7ZHOYH/$*&UHVHFWDEOHSDWLHQWV )0PHDQDJH\HDUV ZHUH
LQFOXGHG)LYHSDWLHQWV ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVPHWDEROLFUHVSRQGHUV UHGXFWLRQ
RI LQ WXPRUDO 689PD[ DQG VHYHQ SDWLHQWV DV PHWDEROLF QRQ
UHVSRQGHUV LQFUHDVH RI LQ WXPRUDO 689PD[ $OO PHWDEROLF UHVSRQGHUV
VKRZHG7GRZQVWDJLQJZLWKSDUWLDOVXEWRWDODQGPLQLPDOWXPRXUUHJUHVVLRQ
$OOPHWDEROLFQRQUHVSRQGHUVGLGQRWVKRZ7GRZQVWDJLQJDQGWXPRXUUHJUHVVLRQ
DQDO\VLV VKRZHG PLQLPDO UHVSRQVHV DQG SDUWLDO UHVSRQVH$GGLWLRQDOO\
PHWDEROLFUHVSRQGHUVZHUH\S1ZKLOHPHWDEROLFQRQUHVSRQGHUVZHUH\S1
&RQFOXVLRQ)'*3(7&7FRXOGEHDUHOLDEOHPRGDOLW\WRSUHGLFWKLVWRSDWKRORJL
FDOUHVSRQVHDWDQHDUO\VWDJHRIWKHSUHRSHUDWLYHWUHDWPHQWLQ/$*&SDWLHQWV
WKXVDOORZLQJDFKDQJHLQWKHWUHDWPHQWIRUPHWDEROLFQRQUHVSRQGHUVSDWLHQWV
%
$'&PDSVGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIPHWDVWDWLFIURPQRQPHWDVWDWLFO\PSK
QRGHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKHQGRPHWULDOFDQFHU
*5HFKLFKL6*DOLPEHUWL$&&DGRQLFL&7DOHL)UDQ]HVL33HUHJR66LURQL
0RQ]D,7 JLOGDUHFKLFKL#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH XVHIXOQHVV RI GLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG LPDJHV ZLWK ERG\
EDFNJURXQG VXSSUHVVLRQ ':,%6 DQG DSSDUHQW GLIIXVLRQ FRHIÀFLHQW $'& WR
GLVFULPLQDWH EHWZHHQ PHWDVWDWLF DQG QRQPHWDVWDWLF SHOYLF O\PSK QRGHV LQ HQ
GRPHWULDOFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWKKLVWR
ORJLFDOO\ SURYHQ HQGRPHWULDO FDQFHU ZKR XQGHUZHQW 05 H[DPLQDWLRQ LQFOXGLQJ
7ZHLJKWHGG\QDPLF7ZHLJKWHGDQGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJHVZLWKEDFNJURXQG
VXSSUHVVLRQ ':,%6 ZLWKEYDOXHVRIDQGVPP7KHQDOOSDWLHQWVXQGHU
ZHQWWRWDOK\VWHUHFWRP\DQGSHOYLFO\PSKDGHQHFWRP\$OOLGHQWLÀDEOHO\PSKQRGHV
RQ':,%6 Q ZHUHHYDOXDWHGDQGIRUHDFKO\PSKQRGHPHDQ$'&YDOXHV
VKRUWDQGORQJD[LVGLDPHWHUVZHUHPHDVXUHGDQGFRPSDUHG+LVWRSDWKRORJLFDO
ÀQGLQJVVHUYHGDVWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
5HVXOWV 0HDQ 6' $'& YDOXHV PPVHF RI PHWDVWDWLF O\PSK QRGHV
Q ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQWKRVHRIQRQPHWDVWDWLFO\PSK
QRGHV Q SYDOXH /RQJDQGVKRUWD[LVGLDPHWHUVRI
PHWDVWDWLFYVQRQPHWDVWDWLFO\PSKQRGHVZHUHPPYVPP
DQGPPYVPPUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ,QHQGRPHWULDOFDQFHUSDWLHQWV$'&PHDVXUHPHQWVRISHOYLFO\PSK
QRGHVDOORZWRGLVFULPLQDWHEHWZHHQPHWDVWDWLFDQGQRQPHWDVWDWLFQRGHV
%
0XOWLPRGDOLW\TXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQLQGLIIXVLRQ
ZHLJKWHG05,DQGG\QDPLF3(7LQDURGHQWPRGHO
10RUWD]DYL-HKDQQR'%DOYD\&%RXULOORQ&%DGRXDO0%HUQDUGLQL
0)DUDJJL&$&XHQRG2&OHPHQW/6)RXUQLHU3DULV)5
QLQDMHKDQQR#HJSDSKSIU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
05,EDVHGOLYHUVHJPHQWDWLRQIRUTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIIXQFWLRQDOOLYHU
YROXPHHYDOXDWLRQRIDWKUHVKROGEDVHGPHWKRGIDFLOLWDWHGE\
KHSDWRELOLDU\FRQWUDVWPHGLD *G(2%
-+5RWKH53DSHQGLHFN&*ULHVHU'6FKQDSDXII%+DPP7'HQHFNH
%HUOLQ'( MDQKROJHUURWKH#FKDULWHGH
3XUSRVH.QRZOHGJHRIWKHH[DFWWXPRXUYROXPHLVUHOHYDQWLQYDULRXVRQFRORJLFDO
VFHQDULRV DVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUORDGUDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQGRVLPHWU\IXWXUHOLYHU
UHPQDQW EHIRUH PDMRU VXUJHU\ 3XUSRVH ZDV WKH HYDOXDWLRQ RI WKLV DSSURDFK
FRPSDUHGWRPDQXDOVHJPHQWDWLRQZLWK&7DVUHIHUHQFH
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV $ WRWDO RI SDWLHQWV JDVWURLQWHVWLQDO SULPDU\
PDOLJQDQFLHV KHSDWLF SULPDU\ WXPRXUV ZHUH H[DPLQHG EHIRUH VHOHFWLYH
LQWHUQDO UDGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ ZLWK FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ DQG *G(2% 3ULPRYLVW
%D\HU6FKHULQJ HQKDQFHG05,RIWKHOLYHUZLWKLQRQHZHHN7Z'VHTXHQFHV
7+5,9( ZHUHDFTXLUHGLQWKHKHSDWRELOLDU\SKDVH7KHOLYHUYROXPHZDVPHDV
XUHGE\PDQXDOVHJPHQWDWLRQRIWKHOLYHUVLOKRXHWWHH[FOXGLQJLQWUDKHSDWLFWXPRXU
PDVVHVLQWKH&7DQG05GDWDVHWDQGE\PDQXDOO\DGMXVWHGWKUHVKROGLQJRIWKH
05GDWDVHWIROORZHGE\UHPRYDORIH[WUDKHSDWLFVWUXFWXUHV0HDQDEVROXWHHUURU
UHSURGXFLELOLW\DQGGXUDWLRQRIHDFKVHJPHQWDWLRQSURFHGXUHE\DWKUHVKROGEDVHG
YROXPHWU\DQGPDQXDOVOLFHVHJPHQWDWLRQZHUHTXDQWLÀHG
5HVXOWV$ 05,EDVHG OLYHU YROXPHWU\ XQGHUHVWLPDWHG WKH FDOFXODWHG YROXPH
EDVHGRQ&7GDWDZLWKPHDQRI PD[LPXP IRUDPDQXDOVHJPHQWD
WLRQ PD[LPXP IRUWKHWKUHVKROGEDVHGPHWKRG)RUD05,EDVHG
YROXPHWU\VHJPHQWDWLRQWLPHVEHWZHHQDQGPLQXWHVPHDQPLQXWHVZLWK
DPDQXDOVOLFHVHJPHQWDWLRQEHWZHHQDQGPLQXWHVPHDQPLQXWHVIRU
WKHWKUHVKROGEDVHGPHWKRGZHUHREVHUYHG6HJPHQWDWLRQWLPHVIRUD&7EDVHG
OLYHUYROXPHWU\UDQJHGEHWZHHQDQGPLQXWHVPHDQPLQXWHV
&RQFOXVLRQ:LWKDVPDOOPHDQDEVROXWHHUURUDQGWKHUHGXFHGVHJPHQWDWLRQWLPH
FRPSDUHGWRPDQXDOVHJPHQWDWLRQ*G(2%YROXPHWU\RIIHUVTXLFNDQGFRQYHQLHQW
VHJPHQWDWLRQRIIXQFWLRQDOOLYHUYROXPH
%
)XVLRQRIG\QDPLF&(05,PDPPRJUDSK\DW7HVODZLWK))'
PDPPRJUDSK\SLORWVWXG\XVLQJDGHGLFDWHGVHPLDXWRPDWLF
UHJLVWUDWLRQVRIWZDUH
0'LHW]HO7+RSS3.UHLVHO195XLWHU+3%XUPHLVWHU:$.DLVHU
3$7%DOW]HU-HQD'(.DUOVUXKH'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH,PDJHIXVLRQRI[UD\PDPPRJUDSK\DQG05PDPPRJUDSK\ ;50
050 DOORZVFRUUHODWLRQRISDWKRORJLFÀQGLQJVEHWZHHQWKHVHLPDJLQJPRGDOLWLHV
HJPLFURFDOFLÀFDWLRQVDUFKLWHFWXUDOGLVWRUWLRQVIRFDOHQKDQFHPHQWVHWF 7KXV
LWKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRRSWLPLVHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\DQGFOLQLFDOZRUNÁRZRIEUHDVW
LPDJLQJ7KLVSLORWVWXG\HYDOXDWHVWKHDFFXUDF\RIDGHGLFDWHGVHPLDXWRPDWLF
LPDJHIXVLRQRI;50DQGKLJKUHVROXWLRQKLJKÀHOG050
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDO050ZHUHDFTXLUHGRQDKLJKÀHOGVFDQQHU 7HVOD
7ZHLJKWHG '9,%( *DGROLQLXP ;50 ZHUH REWDLQHG ZLWK VWDWHRIWKHDUW
IXOOÀHOGGLJLWDOV\VWHPV3DWLHQWVZLWKFOHDUO\GHOLQHDEOHPDVVOHVLRQV!PPLQ
;50DQG050ZHUHHQUROOHG H[FOXVLRQFULWHULDSUHYLRXVEUHDVWVXUJHU\VXUJL
FDOLQWHUYHQWLRQEHWZHHQ;50050 ;50DQG050ZHUHPDWFKHGXVLQJRXU
LQKRXVHGHYHORSHGVRIWZDUHDOORZLQJVHPLDXWRPDWLFQRQOLQHDUGHIRUPDWLRQRI
050%DVHGRQWKH050DYLUWXDO'0DPPRJUDPZDVFDOFXODWHGWRLGHQWLI\
UHJLVWUDWLRQHUURUV 5(ZLWKDQGZR*DGRGLDPLGH*G DQGFRPSDUHGWRWKHFRU
UHVSRQGLQJ;507RTXDQWLI\5(VWKHJHRPHWULFFHQWUHRIWKHOHVLRQVLQWKHYLUWXDO
YVFRQYHQWLRQDOPDPPRJUDPZHUHVXEWUDFWHG5REXVWQHVVRIUHJLVWUDWLRQZDV
TXDQWLÀHGE\UHJLVWUDWLRQRI;05VWRERWK050VZLWKDQGZR*DGRGLDPLGH
5HVXOWV ,PDJH UHJLVWUDWLRQ ZDV SHUIRUPHG VXFFHVVIXOO\ IRU DOO SDWLHQWV Q
2YHUDOO5(ZDVPP ZR*GFRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO&,PP YVPP
VWPLQXWHDIWHU*G&,PP 0HDQGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQSUHYVSRVW
FRQWUDVWVFDQVZDVPP
&RQFOXVLRQ6HPLDXWRPDWLFLPDJHUHJLVWUDWLRQRIKLJKÀHOG05PDPPRJUDSK\
ZLWK [UD\ PDPPRJUDSK\ LV IHDVLEOH )RU WKLV VWXG\ DSSO\LQJ D KLJKUHVROXWLRQ
SURWRFRODW7HVODWKHUHJLVWUDWLRQZDVUREXVWDQGWKHRYHUDOOUHJLVWUDWLRQHUURU
ZDVVXIÀFLHQWIRUFOLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQ
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH'HYHORSPHQWRIQHZSDUDPHWHUVRIDFTXLVLWLRQDQGWUHDWPHQWIRUWKH
DVVHVVPHQWRIWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQXVLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,DQGG\QDPLF3(7
&7ZLWK))'*LQDURGHQWPRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV([SHULPHQWDWLRQVZHUHPDGHRQWZRPRGHOVRIHSLGHU
PRLGKHDGDQGQHFNFDUFLQRPDLPSODQWHGLQQXGHUDWV)D'XDKLJKO\YDVFXODULVHG
WXPRXUDQG$DSRRUO\YDVFXODULVHGWXPRXU':05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKDQ
DFTXLVLWLRQRIGLIIHUHQWEYDOXHV IRUZKLFKD´FOLQLFDO$'&µ XVLQJRQO\
E DPRQRH[SRQHQWLDODQGDELH[SRQHQWLDODQDO\VLVRI$'&DQGSHUIXVLRQ
SDUDPHWHUV I' ZHUHFDOFXODWHG'\QDPLF3(7&7ZDVSHUIRUPHGZLWKYLVXDO
DQDO\VLVRIHQKDQFHPHQWFXUYHVDQGD3DWODNDQGFRPSDUWPHQWDODQDO\VLV$OO
GDWD ZHUH FRUUHODWHG SDWKRORJ\ ZLWK VHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH HYDOXDWLRQ RI YDVFXODULW\
QHFURVLVLQÁDPPDWLRQDQGKDHPRUUKDJH
5HVXOWV ':05, GDWD ZLWK ELH[SRQHQWLDO DQDO\VLV DOORZHG VHSDUDWLRQ RI WZR
FRPSRQHQWVZLWKDSHUIXVLRQIUDFWLRQIJUHDWHUIRU)D'XWKDQ$ YV
S FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK SDWKRORJ\ 7KHUH ZDV DOVR D VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH LQ
GLIIXVLRQEHWZHHQWKHWXPRXUW\SHV 'UYVS EXWZKLFKGLGQRW
FRUUHODWHDVSHFLÀFSDWKRORJLFDOFKDUDFWHULVWLF(QKDQFHPHQWFXUYHVLQG\QDPLF
3(7VKRZHGDQDFFXPXODWLRQRIWUDFHULQWKHWXPRXUVWDUWLQJIURPWKHÀUVWPLQXWH
3HUIXVLRQSDUDPHWHUVH[WUDFWHGXVLQJ3DWODNRUFRPSDUWPHQWDODQDO\VLVGLGQRW
\LHOGDVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSV
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU VWXG\ DOORZHG RSWLPLVDWLRQ RI GDWD DFTXLVLWLRQ DQG DQDO\VLV
IRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWXPRXUSHUIXVLRQXVLQJPXOWLE':05,DQGG\QDPLF3(7
%
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP'
1HXUR
66
1HZÀHOGVDQGGHYHORSPHQWV
0RGHUDWRUV
6-%DNNH2VOR12
-5DPDOKR/LVERQ37
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIGLIIXVLYLW\LQDQWHULRUOREHRIWKHSLWXLWDU\JODQG'
WXUERÀHOGHFKRZLWKGLIIXVLRQVHQVLWLVHGGULYHQHTXLOLEULXPSUHSDUDWLRQ
$+LZDWDVKL7<RVKLXUD27RJDR.<DPDVKLWD..LNXFKL02EDUD
++RQGD)XNXRND-3
3XUSRVH ' WXUER ÀHOG HFKR 7)( ZLWK GLIIXVLRQVHQVLWLVHG GULYHQHTXLOLEULXP
'6'( SUHSDUDWLRQLVDQRYHOQRQHFKRSODQDU (3, WHFKQLTXHIRUGLIIXVLRQZHLJKW
HGLPDJLQJ ':, ZKLFKHQDEOHVKLJKUHVROXWLRQ':,ZLWKRXWÀHOGLQKRPRJHQHLW\
UHODWHGLPDJHGLVWRUWLRQ7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHIHDVLELOLW\
RIWKLVVHTXHQFHWRDVVHVVWKHQRUPDOSLWXLWDU\JODQG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)LUVWYDOLGDWLRQRI'6'(':,ZDVDWWHPSWHGE\FRP
SDULQJZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDO(3,':,)LYHKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVZHUHLPDJHGXVLQJD
'6'(':,VHTXHQFHDQGDQ(3,VHTXHQFH)RUERWKPHWKRGVDPRWLRQSURELQJ
JUDGLHQWZDVDSSOLHGLQRQHGLUHFWLRQ $3 ZLWKEYDOXHVRIDQGVPP7KH
LPDJLQJYR[HOVL]HZDV[[PPIRUWKH'6'(DQG[[PPIRUWKH
(3,7KHDSSDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& PHDVXUHGE\WKHWZRPHWKRGVLQ
UHJLRQV LQJUH\PDWWHUDQGLQZKLWHPDWWHU ZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJ3HDUVRQҋV
FRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW7KHQWKH$'&LQWKHSLWXLWDU\DQWHULRUOREHZDVPHDVXUHG
LQYROXQWHHUVXVLQJWKH'6'(':,VHTXHQFHDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKWKRVHLQWKH
SRQVDQGFHUHEHOOXPXVLQJWKHWWHVW
5HVXOWV$'&IURPWKHWZRPHWKRGVVKRZHGJRRGFRUUHODWLRQ U FRQÀUP
LQJWKHDFFXUDF\LQ$'&PHDVXUHPHQWZLWKWKH'6'(VHTXHQFH7KH$'&LQWKH
QRUPDOSLWXLWDU\JODQGZDV[PPV7KLVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU
WKDQWKDWLQWKHSRQV [PPV DQGLQWKHFHUHEHOOXP
[PPV 3UHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ:HGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDW'6'(':,LVIHDVLEOHWRDVVHVV$'&LQWKH
SLWXLWDU\JODQG
%
6RQRJUDSKLFHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHLQWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUHLQDGXOWEUDLQLQMXU\
76ROGDWRV$.DUDELQLV97VDJNRXOL6.DPSDQDURX67DQWHOHV
*(FRQRPRX/7KDQRV03RPRQL'$.HOHNLV$WKHQV*5
PNDPSDQDURX#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHRSWLFQHUYHVKHDWKGLDPHWHU 216' PD\EHLQFUHDVHGLQEUDLQ
LQMXUHGSDWLHQWVZLWKHOHYDWHGLQWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUH ,&3 :HHYDOXDWHGZKHWKHU
216'PHDVXUHPHQWVFRUUHODWHZLWKLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYH,&3PHDVXUHPHQWV
LQEUDLQLQMXUHGDGXOWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HH[DPLQHGEUDLQLQMXUHGSDWLHQWVDQGFRQWURO
VXEMHFWVZLWKRXWLQWUDFUDQLDOSDWKRORJ\%UDLQLQMXUHGSDWLHQWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGXV
LQJ*ODVJRZFRPDVFDOH *&6 DQGDVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH ,9, QHXURLPDJLQJVFDOH
0DUVKDOO6FDOH06 DQGZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRPRGHUDWHO\ 06 ,DQG*&6!Q
DQGVHYHUHO\ 06 ,,9,DQG*&6Q EUDLQLQMXUHGVXEMHFWV0HDVXUHPHQWV
RI WKH 216' DQG QRQLQYDVLYH ,&3 H,&3 XVLQJ RSWLF QHUYH VRQRJUDSK\ DQG
WUDQVFUDQLDO'RSSOHUVRQRJUDSK\UHVSHFWLYHO\ZHUHSHUIRUPHGXSRQDGPLVVLRQLQ
FRQWUROVDQGPRGHUDWHO\EUDLQLQMXUHGVXEMHFWVDQGWKUHHWLPHVGXULQJKRVSLWDOLVD
WLRQLQVHYHUHO\EUDLQLQMXUHGSDWLHQWV8SRQDGPLVVLRQVHYHUHO\EUDLQLQMXUHG
SDWLHQWVDOVRXQGHUZHQWLQYDVLYH,&3PHDVXUHPHQW
5HVXOWV ,Q VHYHUHO\ EUDLQLQMXUHG SDWLHQWV WKH 216' FRUUHODWHG ZLWK WKH 06
U DQGWKHH,&3 U LQDOOWKUHHHYDOXDWLRQVZKHUHDV216'
DQGH,&3ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHG PPDQGPP+J DVFRP
SDUHGZLWKPRGHUDWHO\EUDLQLQMXUHGVXEMHFWV PPDQGPP+J DQG
FRQWUROV PPDQGPP+J 3 ,QYDVLYH,&3PHDVXUHPHQWV
DOVRFRUUHODWHGZLWK216'PHDVXUHPHQWV U 3 7KHEHVWFXWRII216'
YDOXHIRUSUHGLFWLQJHOHYDWHG,&3ZDVPP VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ216'PHDVXUHPHQWVFRUUHODWHZLWKLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYH,&3
PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGZLWKQHXURLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVLQEUDLQLQMXUHGDGXOWV2SWLFQHUYH
VRQRJUDSK\FRXOGDOHUWFOLQLFLDQVWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIHOHYDWHG,&3ZKHQHYHULQYDVLYH
,&3HYDOXDWLRQLVFRQWUDLQGLFDWHGDQGRULVXQDYDLODEOH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
7KHKXPDQH\HDIWHUOHQVUHSODFHPHQWVXUJHU\
3&.UJHU6/DQJQHU26WDFKV5$OOHPDQQ5*XWKRII1+RVWHQ
*UHLIVZDOG'(5RVWRFN'(
3XUSRVH7RGD\OHQVUHSODFHPHQWLVDEDVLFPHWKRGRIFDWDUDFWWUHDWPHQW7KH
HYDOXDWLRQRISRVWRSHUDWLYHFKDQJHVHVSHFLDOO\LQWKHDUHDRIWKHSRVWHULRUFLU
FXPIHUHQFHLVRIWHQLQDGHTXDWHXVLQJRSKWKDOPRORJLFVWDQGDUGPHWKRGVVXFKDV
XOWUDVRXQGRURSWLFDOFRKHUHQFHWRPRJUDSK\+LJKÀHOGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
05, HQDEOHVHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHVWUXFWXUHVRIWKHDQWHULRUH\HVHJPHQWEHIRUHDQG
DIWHUFDWDUDFWVXUJHU\ZLWKKLJKUHVROXWLRQDQGIUHHRIGLVWRUWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7HQSVHXGRSKDNLFKXPDQH\HV FDWDUDFWVXUJHU\ ZHUH
H[DPLQHGH[YLYRZLWKXOWUDKLJKÀHOG05, 7HVOD&OLQ6FDQ%UXNHU%LR6FDQ
XVLQJDVPDOOVXUIDFHFRLODQG7ZHLJKWHGVSLQHFKRVHTXHQFHV'LIIHUHQWELR
PHWULFDOGLVWDQFHVRIWKHSVHXGRSKDNLFVLWXDWLRQZHUHPHDVXUHGDQGFRUUHODWHG
ZLWKWKHFU\VWDOOLQHOHQVVLWXDWLRQ
5HVXOWV8OWUDKLJKÀHOG05,DW7HVODSURYLGHGH[FHOOHQWYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIDQWHULRU
VHJPHQWGHWDLOVHVSHFLDOO\LQWKHDUHDRIWKHSRVWHULRUFLUFXPIHUHQFHRIWKHOHQV,W
ZDVSRVVLEOHWRHYDOXDWHWKHSRVWRSHUDWLYHFKDQJHVDIWHUOHQVUHSODFHPHQWZLWKRXW
GLVWRUWLRQDQGZLWKKLJKVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ2XUUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDW05PLFURVFRS\KDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRLPDJH
VPDOODQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHVDQGWRHYDOXDWHWKHUHVXOWVRIVXUJLFDOLQWHUYHQWLRQV
705,SURYLGHVDQH[WUHPHO\KLJKVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQXQGHUDEVHQFHRIGLVWRU
WLRQDUWHIDFWV:KLOHRXUVWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGH[YLYRZHH[SHFWWKDWZLWKZLGHU
DYDLODELOLW\XOWUDKLJKÀHOG05PLFURVFRS\ZLOOHYROYHLQWRDQHVVHQWLDOWRROIRUERWK
H[SHULPHQWDOVWXGLHVDQGGDLO\URXWLQH
%
8VHIXOQHVVRISHUIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05LPDJLQJLQWKHDVVHVVPHQW
RIWKHHIIHFWVRI+,9EUDLQLQIHFWLRQLQDV\PSWRPDWLF+,9SRVLWLYH
QRQWUHDWHG+,9SRVLWLYH+$$57WUHDWHGDQG+,9+&9SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWV
$.ROWRZVND-%ODGRZVND36]HZF]\N$=LPQ\%+HQGULFK%.Q\V]
06DVLDGHN:URFODZ3/ DQQDNROWRZVND#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH+,9HQWHUVWKHEUDLQHDUO\DIWHULQLWLDOH[SRVXUHDQGFDQFDXVHFHQWUDO
QHUYRXVV\VWHP &16 G\VIXQFWLRQOHDGLQJWRQHXURSV\FKRORJLFDOLPSDLUPHQW7KH
DLPRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHLPSDFWRIWKH+,9LQIHFWLRQRQWKHFHUHEUDO
PLFURFLUFXODWLRQLQDV\PSWRPDWLF+,9SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUW\WKUHH+,9SRVLWLYHDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV+,9
SRVLWLYHQRQWUHDWHG PHDQDJH\UV +,9SRVLWLYH+$$57WUHDWHG PHDQ
DJH\UV +,9+&9SRVLWLYH PHDQDJH\UV DQGQRUPDOFRQWURO
VXEMHFWV PHDQ DJH \UV ZHUH HQUROOHG LQ WKH VWXG\ 3:, ZDV SHUIRUPHG
ZLWKD705XQLWXVLQJG\QDPLFVXVFHSWLELOLW\FRQWUDVW '6& PHWKRG&HUHEUDO
EORRGYROXPH &%9 PHDVXUHPHQWUHODWLYHWRFHUHEHOOXP U&%9 ZDVHYDOXDWHG
LQWKHSRVWHULRUFLQJXODWHUHJLRQWHPSRURSDULHWDODQGIURQWDODVVRFLDWLRQFRUWLFHV
DVZHOODVLQWKHZKLWHPDWWHURIIURQWRSDULHWDODUHDV
5HVXOWV6LJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUU&%9YDOXHVFRPSDUHGWRQRUPDOVXEMHFWVZHUHIRXQG
LQ WHPSRURSDULHWDO ULJKW S OHIW S DQG IURQWDO FRUWLFHV ULJKW S
OHIWS LQDOO+,9SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWVZKLOHWKHUHZHUHQRVXFKGLIIHUHQFHVLQ
WKHSRVWHULRUFLQJXODWHUHJLRQ S DQGLQWKHZKLWHPDWWHURIIURQWRSDULHWDO
DUHDV ULJKWS OHIWS +,9SRVLWLYH+$$57WUHDWHGDQG+,9+&9SRVLWLYH
SDWLHQWVGHPRQVWUDWHGORZHUU&%9YDOXHVLQWKHULJKWIURQWDOFRUWH[FRPSDUHGWR
+,9SRVLWLYHQRQWUHDWHGVXEMHFW
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHU&%9YDOXHSDUWLFXODUO\PHDVXUHGLQWHPSRURSDULHWDODQGIURQWDO
FRUWLFHVFRXOGEHDQRQLQYDVLYHQHXURLPDJLQJELRPDUNHUIRUDVVHVVLQJWKHLPSDFW
RI+,9LQIHFWLRQRQWKHLPSDLUPHQWRIFHUHEUDOPLFURFLUFXODWLRQLQDV\PSWRPDWLF+,9
SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWV7KHVHFKDQJHVDUHWKHPRVWVLJQLÀFDQWLQ+,9SRVLWLYH+$$57
WUHDWHGDQG+,9+&9SRVLWLYHSDWLHQWV
%
$VXEMHFWLYHVFRUHIRUROIDFWRU\EXOELQMXU\LQSRVWWUDXPDDQRVPLD
66HÀGEDNKW%.KDGHPL++RVHLQLDO+DVKHPL0/RWÀ==DUH5-DOOL
06HÀGEDNKW6KLUD],5 VHSLGHKVHÀGEDNKW#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RGHVLJQDVXEMHFWLYHJUDGLQJV\VWHPIRUROIDFWRU\EXOELQMXU\LQSRVW
WUDXPDDQRVPLDDQGWRFRPSDUHLWZLWKREMHFWLYHPHDVXUHPHQWRIROIDFWRU\EXOE
YROXPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QSDWLHQWVZLWKSRVWWUDXPDDQRVPLDROIDFWRU\EXOE
YROXPHVZHUHPHDVXUHGXVLQJPDQXDOWUDFLQJRIWKHEXOELQKLJKUHVROXWLRQFRURQDO
'),(67$LPDJHV 7*(6LJQD([LWH ,QDVHSDUDWHVHVVLRQPRQWKVODWHU
WKHROIDFWRU\EXOEVZHUHVXEMHFWLYHO\DVVLJQHGWRDSRLQWVFDOHE\WZRUDGLROR
JLVWVLQFRQVHQVXVLQGHSHQGHQWO\IRU7)6(DQG),(67$FRURQDOLPDJHV%XOEV
ZHUHDVVLJQHGDVFRUHRILIQRUPDOORRNLQJLIVPDOOEXWRWKHUZLVHQRUPDOLI
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
VRPHKRZKLJKVLJQDOEXWRWKHUZLVHQRUPDOLIODUJHDQGGHIRUPHGLIVPDOODQG
GHIRUPHGLIGHIRUPHGDQGKLJKVLJQDODQGLIQRWGHÀQLWHO\LGHQWLÀHG6XEMHFWLYH
VFRUHZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKYROXPHXVLQJOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHEHWWHUDQGZRUVHEXOEVZHUHFPóDQGFPóLQYROXPH
UHVSHFWLYHO\6XEMHFWLYHVFRULQJLQ7)6(DQG),(67$LPDJHVGLGQRWFRUUHODWH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKWKHEHWWHUROIDFWRU\EXOEYROXPH6XEMHFWLYHVFRULQJLQ),(67$
LPDJHV FRUUHODWHV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ZLWK WKH ZRUVH ROIDFWRU\ EXOE YROXPH S
7KHUHZHUHUHVSHFWLYHO\OHVLRQVZLWKLQFDWHJRULHVDQG
&RQFOXVLRQ$VPDOOGHIRUPHGROIDFWRU\EXOELVWKHPRVWIUHTXHQWÀQGLQJVLQSRVW
WUDXPDDQRVPLD6XEMHFWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHROIDFWRU\EXOEFRUUHODWHVZHOOZLWK
REMHFWLYHPHDVXUHPHQWLQWKHPRUHVHYHUHO\LQMXUHGEXOE
%
6LJQDOLQWHQVLW\SURÀOHDQDO\VLVRIWKHROIDFWRU\EXOEDQGWUDFWIRU
HYDOXDWLRQRISDWKRORJLFROIDFWRU\EXOEFKDQJHVLQQHXURORJLFDODQG
VPHOOLQJGLVRUGHUVFRPSDULVRQRI7705PLFURVFRS\DQG
KLVWRORJLFDOVHFWLRQV
+3%XUPHLVWHU7%LWWHU30+HLOHU$,ULQWFKHY5)URHEHU
3$7%DOW]HU-55HLFKHQEDFK2*XQWLQDV/LFKLXV:$.DLVHU
-HQD'(0DQQKHLP'( KDUWPXWEXUPHLVWHU#PHGXQLMHQDGH
3XUSRVH 1HXURORJLFDO DQG VPHOOLQJ GLVRUGHUV HJ$O]KHLPHUҋV GLVHDVH VLQR
QDVDO GLVHDVH QHJDWLYHO\ DIIHFW WKH PLFURVWUXFWXUDO LQWHJULW\ RI ROIDFWRU\ EXOEҋV
2% SDOHRFRUWLFDO OD\HUV 5HFRYHU\ SURFHVVHV GHSHQG RQ DFWLYH UHVWRUDWLRQ RI
WKLVPLFURVWUXFWXUDOLQWHJULW\HQDEOHGE\QHXURQHRJHQHVLVLQWKH2%7KHDLPRI
WKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHODPLQDWLRQSDWWHUQVRIWKH2%DQGDGMDFHQWWUDFW 27
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\IRXUKXPDQ2%VXQGHUZHQWLQYLWURVWDQGDUGDQG
KLJKUHVROXWLRQ7ZDQG7ZLPDJLQJDW7%DVHGRQVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\GLIIHUHQFHV
2%ODPLQDWLRQSDWWHUQVZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WZRREVHUYHUVLQFRQVHQVXV5HVXOWV
ZHUHFRPSDUHGXVLQJ:LOFR[RQWHVW6LJQDOLQWHQVLW\SURÀOHVZHUHFRPSDUHGWR
UHIHUHQFHKLVWRORJLFDOVHFWLRQVDQGLPDJLQJUHVXOWVXVLQJ705PLFURVFRS\27
ODPLQDWLRQSDWWHUQVZHUHDVVHVVHGDQGGLIIHUHQWFRQÀJXUDWLRQVRIFURVVVHFWLRQDO
DUHDVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRPDFURVFRSLFUHVXOWVDQG2%ODPLQDWLRQSDWWHUQV
5HVXOWV6WDQGDUGUHVROXWLRQLGHQWLÀHGWKUHH WZR DQGRQHOD\HU
LQ+LJKUHVROXWLRQ05, OD\HUVLQOD\HUVLQ VLJQLÀFDQWO\
SHUIRUPHG EHWWHU 3 6LJQDO LQWHQVLW\ SURÀOH DQDO\VLV DW 7 DQG 7
\LHOGLQJXSWRGLIIHUHQWVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHV FRUUHODWHGZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOVHFWLRQV
705,RIWKH27UHYHDOHGWZRVHSDUDWHVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVLQ7ZLQDK\
SHULQWHQVHFRUHDQGDK\SRLQWHQVHVKHDWK&URVVVHFWLRQDODUHD FRQÀJXUDWLRQV
FRUUHODWHGZLWKPDFURVFRSLFUHVXOWV ѩ 3 DQG2%ODPLQDWLRQSDW
WHUQV ѩ 3
&RQFOXVLRQ6LJQDOLQWHQVLW\SURÀOHDQDO\VLVDW7LQGLFDWHVWKHSRVVLELOLW\WRGLI
IHUHQWLDWH2%OD\HUV7KHUHIRUHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\SURÀOHDQDO\VLVFRXOGEHXVHGDVD
IXWXUHWRROWRDVVHVV2%UHFRYHU\SURFHVVHVLQQHXURGHJHQHUDWLYHQHXURSV\FKLDWULF
DQGVPHOOLQJGLVRUGHUV
%
$JHDQGJHQGHUDOWHUDWLRQVLQVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVRISRVWHULRUSLWXLWDU\
JODQGRQGLPHQVLRQDO7ZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ
$<DPDPRWR+2ED-.RWRNX6)XUXL7RN\R-3
DVDNRQHPXULQRPRUL#\DKRRFRMS
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
7ZHLJKWHGJUDGLHQWHFKRYVVSLQHFKRVHTXHQFHVLQJDGROLQLXP
HQKDQFHGEUDLQLPDJLQJDW7FRPSDULVRQLQWHUPVRILPDJHTXDOLW\
ÁRZDUWHIDFWVDQGGHSLFWLRQRIYHVVHOV
')ORHU\6.LUFKQHU&*LQWKRHU5:XQQ)$)HOOQHU/LQ]$7
GDQLHOÁRHU\#DNKOLQ]DW
3XUSRVH :LWK 7 05 XQLWV 7ZHLJKWHG JUDGLHQW HFKR VHTXHQFHV VXFK DV
)/$6+DUHRIWHQXVHGLQVWHDGRIVSLQHFKR 6( VHTXHQFHVIRUEUDLQLPDJLQJGXH
WRZHOONQRZQGLVDGYDQWDJHVRI6(VHTXHQFHVDWWKLVÀHOGVWUHQJWK7KHSXUSRVH
RI WKLV VWXG\ ZDV WR HYDOXDWH FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG )/$6+ YV 6( VHTXHQFHV LQ
WHUPVRILPDJHTXDOLW\ÁRZDUWHIDFWVLQDUWHULDODQGYHQRXVFHUHEUDOYHVVHOVDQG
GHSLFWLRQRIVPDOOYHVVHOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QSDWLHQWVD[LDO)/$6+DVZHOODV6(VHTXHQFHV
ZDVDFTXLUHGDIWHUJDGROLQLXPDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ7ZRUDGLRORJLVWVDVVHVVHGWKHIRO
ORZLQJSDUDPHWHUVLQERWKVHTXHQFHV,PDJHTXDOLW\ÁRZDUWHIDFWVDQGTXDOLW\RI
GHSLFWLRQLQODUJHDUWHULHVVPDOODUWHULHVDQGGXUDOVLQXVHVUHVSFHUHEUDOYHLQV
HDFKDVVHVVHGZLWKDWLHUVFDOH
5HVXOWV,QDOOFDVHVRYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\RI)/$6+VHTXHQFHZDVVXSHULRUWR
6( ,Q WKH GHSLFWLRQ RI ODUJHU DUWHULHV )/$6+ ZDV DVVHVVHG VXSHULRU WR 6( LQ
RIFDVHVZKHUHDVLQWKHGHSLFWLRQRIVPDOOYHVVHOV6(ZDVVXSHULRULQ
)ORZDUWHIDFWVZHUHFRPSOHWHO\DEVHQWLQ)/$6+ZKHUHDV6(GHPRQVWUDWHGÁRZ
DUWHIDFWVLQDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\,QWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIVLQXVHVDQGFHUHEUDO
YHLQV)/$6+ZDVIRXQGWREHHTXDORUVXSHULRUWR6(LQ(TXDOO\WRDUWHULHV
ÁRZDUWHIDFWVZHUHUDUHO\IRXQGLQ)/$6+ YVRIFDVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ$W77Z*5(VHTXHQFHVGHPRQVWUDWHLPSURYHGRYHUDOOLPDJH
TXDOLW\DQGEHWWHUGHSLFWLRQRIODUJHFHUHEUDODUWHULHVDQGVLQXVHVLQFRPSDULVRQWR
6(VHTXHQFHVZKLOHVPDOOYHVVHOVDUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUVHHQZLWK6(VHTXHQFHV
%
6RQRJUDSKLFHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHLQWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUHLQDGXOWEUDLQLQMXU\
76ROGDWRV$WKHQV*5 VROGDWRV#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHRSWLFQHUYHVKHDWKGLDPHWHU 216' PD\EHLQFUHDVHGLQEUDLQ
LQMXUHGSDWLHQWVZLWKHOHYDWHGLQWUDFUDQLDOSUHVVXUH ,&3 :HHYDOXDWHGZKHWKHU
216'PHDVXUHPHQWVFRUUHODWHZLWKLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYH,&3PHDVXUHPHQWV
LQEUDLQLQMXUHGDGXOWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HH[DPLQHGEUDLQLQMXUHGSDWLHQWVDQGFRQWURO
VXEMHFWVZLWKRXWLQWUDFUDQLDOSDWKRORJ\%UDLQLQMXUHGSDWLHQWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGXV
LQJ*ODVJRZFRPDVFDOH *&6 DQGDVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH ,9, QHXURLPDJLQJVFDOH
0DUVKDOO6FDOH06 DQGZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRPRGHUDWHO\ 06 ,DQG*&6!Q
DQGVHYHUHO\ 06 ,,9,DQG*&6Q EUDLQLQMXUHGVXEMHFWV0HDVXUHPHQWV
RI WKH 216' DQG QRQLQYDVLYH ,&3 H,&3 XVLQJ RSWLF QHUYH VRQRJUDSK\ DQG
WUDQVFUDQLDO'RSSOHUVRQRJUDSK\UHVSHFWLYHO\ZHUHSHUIRUPHGXSRQDGPLVVLRQLQ
FRQWUROVDQGPRGHUDWHO\EUDLQLQMXUHGVXEMHFWVDQGWKUHHWLPHVGXULQJKRVSLWDOLVD
WLRQLQVHYHUHO\EUDLQLQMXUHGSDWLHQWV8SRQDGPLVVLRQVHYHUHO\EUDLQLQMXUHG
SDWLHQWVDOVRXQGHUZHQWLQYDVLYH,&3PHDVXUHPHQW
5HVXOWV ,Q VHYHUHO\ EUDLQLQMXUHG SDWLHQWV WKH 216' FRUUHODWHG ZLWK WKH 06
U DQGWKHH,&3 U LQDOOWKUHHHYDOXDWLRQVZKHUHDV216'
DQGH,&3ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQFUHDVHG PPDQGPP+J DVFRP
SDUHGZLWKPRGHUDWHO\EUDLQLQMXUHGVXEMHFWV PPDQGPP+J DQG
FRQWUROV PPDQGPP+J 3 ,QYDVLYH,&3PHDVXUHPHQWV
DOVRFRUUHODWHGZLWK216'PHDVXUHPHQWV U 3 7KHEHVWFXWRII216'
YDOXHIRUSUHGLFWLQJHOHYDWHG,&3ZDVPP VHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFLÀFLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ216'PHDVXUHPHQWVFRUUHODWHZLWKLQYDVLYHDQGQRQLQYDVLYH,&3
PHDVXUHPHQWVDQGZLWKQHXURLPDJLQJÀQGLQJVLQEUDLQLQMXUHGDGXOWV2SWLFQHUYH
VRQRJUDSK\FRXOGDOHUWFOLQLFLDQVWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIHOHYDWHG,&3ZKHQHYHULQYDVLYH
,&3HYDOXDWLRQLVFRQWUDLQGLFDWHGDQGRULVXQDYDLODEOH
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7KH SRVWHULRU SLWXLWDU\ JODQG XVXDOO\ VKRZV K\SHU VLJQDO LQWHQVLW\ RQ
7ZHLJKWHG05LPDJHVLQKHDOWK\SHUVRQVEXWFKDQJHVLQWKHYDOXHVFDXVHGE\
DJHLQJRUJHQGHUGLIIHUHQFHDUHQRWZHOOUHFRJQLVHG7KLVVWXG\DLPHGWRFODULI\
WKHGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKHVLJQDOVRIWKHSRVWHULRUSLWXLWDU\JODQGDFFRUGLQJWRJHQGHU
DQGDJH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV
ZKRXQGHUZHQWFHUHEUDOVDJLWWDOGLPHQVLRQDO7ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJRQD705,
XQLWEHWZHHQ-XO\DQG0D\:HH[FOXGHGSDWLHQWVZLWKDQ\HQGRFULQH
ÁXLGEDODQFHDEQRUPDOLW\RUF\VWVWXPRXUVKDHPRUUKDJHVDQGDWURSK\RISLWXLWDU\
JODQG:HLGHQWLÀHGWKHSRVWHULRUSLWXLWDU\JODQGEHWZHHQWKHSDUVLQWHUPHGLDRISL
WXLWDU\JODQGDQGGRUVXPVHOODHDQGUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWZHUHGUDZQRQWKHSRVWHULRU
SLWXLWDU\JODQGDQGWKHSRQV7KHPD[LPXPVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RIWKHSRVWHULRUSLWXLWDU\
JODQGDQGDYHUDJHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RIWKHSRQVZHUHGHWHUPLQHG:HFDOFXODWHGWKH
VLJQDOUDWLRSRVWHULRUSLWXLWDU\JODQGSRQVDQGDQDO\VHGWKHFKDQJHVLQWKHVLJQDO
UDWLREHWZHHQWKHJHQGHUVDQGDJHV
5HVXOWV)HPDOHJURXSVKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUVLJQDOUDWLRWKDQPDOHJURXS
IURPUGWRWKGHFDGHV U!S 'LVDSSHDUDQFHRIWKHKLJKVLJQDORI
WKHSRVWHULRUSLWXLWDU\JODQGZDVREVHUYHGLQSDWLHQWV PDOHVIHPDOHV
\HDUV
&RQFOXVLRQ'LIIHUHQFHVLQWKHVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\RIWKHSRVWHULRUSLWXLWDU\JODQGEH
WZHHQJHQGHUVDQGDJHVH[LVWLQWKHJHQHUDOSRSXODWLRQZLWKDSSURSULDWHPHWDEROLF
VWDWHDQGÁXLGEDODQFH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5RRP'
,QWHUYHQWLRQDO5DGLRORJ\
66
([SHULPHQWDO
0RGHUDWRUV
-+3HUHJULQ3UDJXH&=
0$$-YDQGHQ%RVFK8WUHFKW1/
%
([SHULPHQWDOIHDVLELOLW\VWXG\RQUHDOWLPHXOWUDVRXQGHODVWRJUDSK\
RIKHSDWLFWKHUPDOOHVLRQVÀUVWUHVXOWV
3:LJJHUPDQQ(0-XQJ&6WURV]F]\QVNL
5HJHQVEXUJ'( SKLOLSSZLJJHUPDQQ#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH UHOLDELOLW\ RI HODVWRJUDSK\ D QHZ XOWUDVRQRJUDSKLF
PHWKRGIRUGHOLQHDWLQJWKHUPDOOHVLRQERXQGDULHVLQSRUFLQHOLYHUWLVVXHE\FRP
SDULQJOHVLRQGLPHQVLRQVGHWHUPLQHGE\UHDOWLPHHODVWRJUDSK\ZLWKWKHÀQGLQJV
DWJURVVSDWKRORJ\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WRWDORIWKHUPDOOHVLRQVZLWKGLDPHWHUVUDQJLQJIURP
WRPPZHUHFUHDWHGXVLQJUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQ 5)$ 7KHQHZ/2*,4(
HODVWRJUDSK\LPDJLQJWHFKQRORJ\ *(+HDOWKFDUH:DXZDWRVD:, ZDVXVHGZLWKD
0+]KLJKIUHTXHQF\OLQHDUWUDQVGXFHU/HVLRQVZHUHH[DPLQHGXVLQJ%PRGH
DQGUHDOWLPHHODVWRJUDSK\ 57( /HVLRQGHWHFWLRQGHOLQHDWLRQDQGVL]HZHUHDVVHG
XVLQJ%PRGHDQG57(LPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUHDFKWKHUPDODEODWLRQ0HDVXUHPHQWV
RIWKHVHFWLRQVUHSUHVHQWLQJWKHVDPHLPDJHSODQHXVHGIRUHODVWRJUDSK\ZHUH
WDNHQDWSDWKRORJLFH[DPLQDWLRQDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHPHDVXUHPHQWVREWDLQHG
IURPWKHHODVWRJUDPV
5HVXOWV,QRXUVDPSOHDVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQLQYLWUREHWZHHQ57(
DQG SDWKRORJLFDO PHDVXUHPHQWV ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKH OHVLRQVҋ SULQFLSDO D[LV DQG
DUHD Uò ORQJD[LVUò VKRUWD[LVDQGUò DUHD 2YHUDOO
HODVWRJUDSK\VOLJKWO\XQGHUHVWLPDWHGWKHOHVLRQVL]HDVMXGJHGE\WKHGLJLWDOLVHG
SDWKRORJLFLPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHUHVXOWVVXSSRUWWKDW57(RXWSHUIRUPVFRQYHQWLRQDO%PRGHXO
WUDVRXQGDQGFRXOGSRWHQWLDOO\EHXVHGIRUURXWLQHDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHUPDOWKHUDSLHV
%
5DGLRHPEROLVDWLRQZLWK<JODVVPLFURVSKHUHVGRZHUHDOO\QHHG
63(&7&7WRLGHQWLI\H[WUDKHSDWLFVKXQWV"
7&/DXHQVWHLQ-7KH\VRKQ-6FKODDN-(UWOH60XHOOHU$%RFNLVFK
0)RUVWLQJ(VVHQ'( WKRPDVODXHQVWHLQ#XQLGXHGH
3XUSRVH5DGLRHPEROLVDWLRQ 5( XVLQJWKHEHWDHPLWWHU\WWULXP < LVDQ
HPHUJLQJWKHUDS\RSWLRQIRUXQUHVHFWDEOHOLYHUPDOLJQDQFLHV$FRPSOLFDWLRQRI5(
PD\UHSUHVHQWWKHQRQWDUJHWHPEROLVDWLRQRIH[WUDKHSDWLFWLVVXHSDUWLFXODUO\WKH*,
WUDFW:HDLPHGWRDVVHVVZKHWKHUH[WUDKHSDWLFVKXQWVFDQEHUHOLDEO\GLDJQRVHG
EDVHGRQKHSDWLFGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWLRQDQJLRJUDSK\ '6$ RULIVXEVHTXHQW63(&7
&7GDWDSURYLGHDGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK KHSDWRFHOOXODU FDUFLQRPD Q
KHSDWLF PHWDVWDVHV Q RU FKRODQJLRFHOOXODU FDUFLQRPD Q ZHUH VWXGLHG
'XULQJKHSDWLFGLJLWDOVXEWUDFWLRQDQJLRJUDSK\DUWHULHVUHSUHVHQWLQJVKXQWVWR
H[WUDKHSDWLFWLVVXHZHUHFRLOHPEROLVHG ULJKWJDVWULFDUWHU\Q IDOFLIRUPDUWHU\
Q EUDQFKHV WR GXRGHQXPSDQFUHDV Q 6XEVHTXHQWO\ 7HFKQHFWLXP
PODEHOHGPDFURDJJUHJDWHGDOEXPLQ P7F0$$ ZDVLQMHFWHGDQGSDWLHQWV
XQGHUZHQW D 63(&7&7 63(&7&7 GDWD ZHUH XVHG WR LGHQWLI\ DQ\ DGGLWLRQDO
VKXQWWRH[WUDKHSDWLFWLVVXH
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWV H[KLELWHGDQXQH[SHFWHGLQFUHDVHG0$$XSWDNH
LQH[WUDKHSDWLFWLVVXH VPDOOERZHOQ DEGRPLQDOZDOOQ VWRPDFKQ 7KHVH
SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWUHSHDWHG'6$DQGFRUUHVSRQGLQJDUWHULHVFRXOGEHLGHQWLÀHG
DQGFRLOHPEROLVHGLQSDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ 0RVW H[WUDKHSDWLF VKXQWV FDQ EH LGHQWLÀHG RQ '6$ SULRU WR <
WKHUDS\ +RZHYHU 63(&7&7 GDWD KHOS WR LGHQWLI\ DGGLWLRQDO VKXQWV WKDW ZHUH
LQLWLDOO\QRWVHHQRQ'6$
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
$QJLRJUDSKLFDQGSDWKRORJLFDOFRPSDULVRQRIK\GURJHOFRDWHGFRLOV
DQGÀEHUHGFRLOVLQDVKHHSPRGHO
$)RKOHQ-1DPXU0:DVVHI+*KHJHGLEDQ$/DXUHQW-33HODJH
&DHQ)53DULV)5 SHODJHMS#FKXFDHQIU
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHDQJLRJUDSKLFDQGSDWKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHVZLWKK\GURFRLOV
DQGÀEHUHGFRLOVDWKRXUVDQGGD\VLQWHUPVRIPHFKDQLVPRIRFFOXVLRQDQG
LQÁDPPDWRU\UHVSRQVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[VKHHSKDGERWKLQWHUQDOLOLDFDQGUHQDODUWHULHVUDQ
GRPO\HPEROLVHGXVLQJÀEHUHGFRLOVRUK\GURFRLOV5HQDODUWHULHVZHUHHPEROLVHG
XVLQJFRLOVDQGLQWHUQDOLOLDFVXVLQJFRLOV7KHQXPEHURIFRLOVDQG
WLPHWRFRPSOHWHRFFOXVLRQZDVUHFRUGHG7KUHHDQLPDOVZHUHVDFULÀFHGDIWHU
KRXUVDQGDIWHUGD\V3DWKRORJLFDOHYDOXDWLRQFRQVLVWHGLQFKDUDFWHULVLQJWKH
PHFKDQLVPRIRFFOXVLRQSHUFHQWDJHRIWKHOXPHQRFFOXGHGE\WKHHPEROLF SODWL
QXPGDFURQÀEUHVYVK\GURJHO DQGWKURPEXVSUHVHQFHRILQÁDPPDWRU\FHOOV
5HVXOWV 1R GLIIHUHQFH ZDV IRXQG EHWZHHQ K\GURFRLOV DQG ÀEHUHG FRLOV IRU WKH
QXPEHURIFRLOVDQGWLPHWRDFKLHYHYDVFXODURFFOXVLRQ$WDQJLRJUDSK\RILOLDF
DUWHULHVHPEROLVHGZLWKK\GURFRLOVZHUHRFFOXGHGYVRIWKRVHHPEROLVHGZLWK
ÀEHUHGFRLOV 16 5HFDQDOLVDWLRQRIWKHUHQDODUWHU\ZDVREVHUYHGLQERWKJURXSV
7KHSHUFHQWDJHRIWKURPEXVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUIRUK\GURFRLOVWKDQIRUÀEHUHG
FRLOVDWWKHWLPHSRLQWV)RUÀEHUHGFRLOVDWSDWKRORJ\WKURPEXVDFFRXQWHGIRU
RIWKHRFFOXVLRQYVIRUK\GURFRLOV7KHSUHVHQFHRILQÁDPPDWRU\FHOOV
ZDVPRUHIUHTXHQWZLWKÀEHUHGFRLOVWKDQZLWKK\GURFRLOV YV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSHUFHQWDJHRIWKURPEXVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\OHVVZLWKK\GURFRLOVDV
FRPSDUHGWRÀEHUHGFRLOV0DUNHGO\ORZHULQÁDPPDWRU\FHOOUHVSRQVHZDVVHHQ
ZLWKK\GURFRLOV%RWKGLIIHUHQFHVPD\WUDQVODWHLQWROHVVORQJWHUPUHFDQDOLVDWLRQ
)XUWKHULQYHVWLJDWLRQLVQHHGHG
%
0XOWLSRODUKHSDWLF5)$LQÁXHQFHRIHOHFWURGHFRQÀJXUDWLRQRQ
FRDJXODWLRQYROXPH
3%UXQHUV73HQ]NRIHU3,VIRUW$+RIPDQQ76FKPLW]5RGH&..XKO
$+0DKQNHQ$DFKHQ'( SEUXQHUV#XNDDFKHQGH
3XUSRVH)RUPXOWLSRODUKHSDWLFUDGLRIUHTXHQF\ 5) DEODWLRQLWLVNQRZQWKDWWKH
DPRXQWRIHQHUJ\DSSOLHGFRUUHODWHVZLWKWKHJHQHUDWHGFRDJXODWLRQYROXPH2XU
JRDO ZDV WR DQDO\VH ZKHWKHU WKH FRPELQDWLRQ RI HOHFWURGHV DOVR LQÁXHQFHV WKH
DEODWLRQYROXPHLIWKHDPRXQWRIDSSOLHGHQHUJ\LVNHSWFRQVWDQW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q WRWDO 5)DEODWLRQV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG LQ IUHVKO\
H[FLVHG ERYLQH OLYHU XVLQJ D PXOWLSRODU 5)V\VWHP &HORQ/DE3RZHU &HORQ$*
0HGLFDO,QVWUXPHQWV7HOWRZ*HUPDQ\ 7HQDEODWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKHDFK
RIWKHIROORZLQJ5)DSSOLFDWRUFRPELQDWLRQV[FP[FP[FP[FP
[FP[FP5)DEODWLRQVZHUHLQWHUUXSWHGDIWHUDSSOLFDWLRQRIN-'XULQJ
WKHH[SHULPHQWVWLPHWLVVXHLPSHGDQFHDQGJHQHUDWRURXWSXWZHUHPRQLWRUHGXV
LQJDGHGLFDWHGVRIWZDUHWRRO*HQHUDWHGFRDJXODWLRQ]RQHVZHUHGLVVHFWHGDQG
PDFURVFRSLFDOO\PHDVXUHGDORQJ[\DQG]D[LVIROORZHGE\FDOFXODWLRQRIWKH
DSSUR[LPDWH FRDJXODWLRQ YROXPH$Q$129$ ZDV DSSOLHG IROORZHG E\ 6WXGHQW
1HZPDQ.HXOVWHVWVWRDQDO\VHIRUVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
5HVXOWV7KHFRPELQDWLRQRI[FPUHVXOWHGLQWKHODUJHVWPHDQFRDJXODWLRQYRO
XPH FPó $OORWKHUHOHFWURGHFRPELQDWLRQVOHGWRVLJQLÀFDQWVPDOOHUFRDJXODWLRQ
YROXPHVUDQJLQJIURPFPó [FP WRFPó [FP ([FHSWIRUWKH[FP
FRPELQDWLRQ PLQ WKHUHZHUHQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVZLWKUHJDUGWRWKH
DSSOLFDWLRQWLPH PLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ %HVLGHV WKH DPRXQW RI DSSOLHG HQHUJ\ WKH FRPELQDWLRQ RI 5)
DSSOLFDWRUVVKRZVDQLQÁXHQFHRQWKHJHQHUDWHGFRDJXODWLRQYROXPHLQH[YLYR
OLYHUH[SHULPHQWV
%
0LGWHUPUHFDQDOLVDWLRQDIWHUHPEROLVDWLRQXVLQJK\GURFRLOVYV
ÀEHUHGFRLOVLQDQDQLPDOPRGHO
-33HODJH$)RKOHQ+*KHJHGLEDQ-1DPXU$/DXUHQW0:DVVHI
&DHQ)53DULV)5 SHODJHMS#FKXFDHQIU
3XUSRVH7R FRPSDUH WKH DQJLRJUDSKLF DQG SDWKRORJLFDO HIIHFWV FRPSOHWH RF
FOXVLRQRUUHFDQDOLVDWLRQ RIK\GURJHOFRDWHGFRLOVDQGÀEHUHGFRLOVLQDUWHULDO
WHUULWRULHVDIWHUGD\VPRQWKDQGPRQWKV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV VKHHS KDG RQH LQWHUQDO LOLDF DQG RQH UHQDO DUWHU\
UDQGRPO\HPEROLVHGXVLQJÀEHUHGFRLOVRUK\GURFRLOV5HQDODUWHULHVZHUHHPERO
LVHGXVLQJFRLOVDQGLQWHUQDOLOLDFVXVLQJFRLOV$OODQLPDOVKDGFRQWURO
DQJLRJUDSK\SHUIRUPHGDWGD\VPRQWKDQGPRQWKVWRDVVHVVUHFDQDOLVD
WLRQ$OODQLPDOVZHUHVDFULÀFHGDIWHUPRQWKV7LVVXHVDPSOHVZHUHHPEHGGHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
LQUHVLQVHFWLRQHGDQGVWDLQHGZLWKPHWK\OHQHDQGWROXLGLQHEOXH5HFDQDOLVDWLRQ
DQGLQÁDPPDWLRQZHUHHYDOXDWHGDWSDWKRORJ\
5HVXOWV$IWHUGD\VQRGLIIHUHQFHLQWHUPVRIUHFDQDOLVDWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ
ERWKSURGXFWV$WRQHPRQWKRIWKHDUWHULHVHPEROLVHGZLWKK\GURFRLOVZHUH
RFFOXGHGYVRIWKRVHHPEROLVHGZLWKÀEHUHGFRLOV S $WPRQWKV
RIWKHDUWHULHVHPEROLVHGZLWKK\GURFRLOVZHUHRFFOXGHGYVRIWKRVHHPEROLVHG
ZLWKÀEHUHGFRLOV S $WRWDORIRIUHQDODUWHULHVHPEROLVHGZLWKK\GURFRLOV
ZHUHRFFOXGHGYVRIWKRVHHPEROLVHGZLWKÀEHUHGFRLOV
&RQFOXVLRQ$IWHUPRQWKVRIWKHDUWHULHVHPEROLVHGZLWKÀEHUHGFRLOVZHUH
UHFDQDOLVHGYVRIWKRVHHPEROLVHGZLWKK\GURFRLOV,WPD\EHK\SRWKHVLVHGWKDW
WKHGLIIHUHQFHLVH[SODLQHGE\WKHPHFKDQLVPRILQLWLDORFFOXVLRQ PRUHWKURPEXV
ZLWKÀEHUHGFRLOV
%
3RUWDOYHLQOLJDWLRQDORQHFRPSDUHGZLWKSRUWDOYHLQDQGKHSDWLF
DUWHU\OLJDWLRQLQDURGHQWPRGHO
*-HRQ%/HH6&KXQJ-<RRQ-.LP-/HH6HRQJQDP.5
6HRXO.5%XVDQ.5
3XUSRVH2XUVWXG\FRPSDUHGWKHYROXPHFKDQJHDQGUHJHQHUDWLYHFDSDFLW\RI
SRUWDO YHLQ OLJDWLRQ HPEROLVDWLRQ 39/ DQG KHWHURFKURQRXV 39/ ZLWK KHSDWLF
DUWHU\OLJDWLRQ +$/ LQDURGHQWPRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$QLPDOVZHUHVHSDUDWHGLQWRWKUHHJURXSV)RUJURXS
,OLJDWLRQRIWKHOHIWODWHUDODQGPHGLDQSRUWDOYHLQEUDQFKHVZDVSHUIRUPHG)RU
JURXS,,OLJDWLRQRIWKHSRUWDOYHLQZDVFRPSOHWHGIROORZHGE\OLJDWLRQRIWKHVDPH
EUDQFKHVRIWKHKHSDWLFDUWHU\DIWHUK)RUJURXS,,, FRQWUROJURXS DODSDURWRP\
ZLWKRXWOLJDWLRQ VKDPRSHUDWLRQ ZDVSHUIRUPHG$WOHDVWUDWVIURPHDFKJURXS
ZHUHVDFULÀFHGDWDQGGDIWHUVXUJHU\/LYHUYROXPHFKDQJHZDVPHDVXUHG
DQGDOLYHUIXQFWLRQWHVWSHUIRUPHG8VLQJH[FLVHGUDWOLYHUVZHSHUIRUPHGLPPX
QRKLVWRFKHPLFDODQDO\VHVRIFNLWDQG0,%+LVWRORJLFIHDWXUHVZHUHDQDO\VHG
5HVXOWV7KHYROXPHRIWKHQRQOLJDWHGOREHLQFUHDVHGPRVWLQJURXS,,LQLWLDOO\EXW
WKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHDWGD\VDQG0HDQ$67DQGWRWDOELOLUXELQ
OHYHOVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHULQJURXS,,DQGDOEXPLQOHYHOVZHUHKLJKLQJURXS,
&NLWSRVLWLYHFHOOVZHUHPRUHSUHVHQWHGRQGD\VDQGLQJURXSLYHUVXVJURXS
,,ZKLFKZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW0,%VWDLQHGFHOOVZHUHPRUHQXPHURXVLQ
JURXSLRQGD\VDQG1HFURWLFFKDQJHVLQWKHOLJDWHGOREHVZHUHVKRZQLQ
ODUJHQXPEHURIJURXS,,
&RQFOXVLRQ39/DORQHLVVDIHDQGHIIHFWLYHIRUFRPSHQVDWRU\OLYHUUHJHQHUDWLRQ
3HUIRUPLQJERWK39DQG+$OLJDWLRQGRHVQRWUHVXOWLQDGGLWLRQDOEHQHÀW
%
0LFURZDYHDEODWLRQRIWKHNLGQH\HYDOXDWLRQRIFRROHGDQWHJUDGH
S\HORSHUIXVLRQIRUSURWHFWLRQRIWKHFROOHFWLQJV\VWHPLQDQLQYLYR
SRUFLQHPRGHO
3,VIRUW73HQ]NRIHU77DQDND3%UXQHUV76FKPLW]5RGH&..XKO
$+0DKQNHQ$DFKHQ'(1DUD-3 LVIRUW#XNDDFKHQGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$QH[SHULPHQWDOVWXG\RQPXOWLPRGDOYLVLELOLW\ DQJLRJUDSK\&7DQG
05, RIHPEROLVDWLRQSDUWLFOHVSHUIRUPHGLQSRUFLQHNLGQH\V
&06RPPHU86WDPSÁ1%HOOHPDQQ0+RO]VFKXK1.RUWHV
$.XHOOHU-%OXHPPHO%$5DGHOHII+8.DXF]RU+HLGHOEHUJ'(
6DQ$QWRQLR7;86 FPVRPPHU#JP[FRP
3XUSRVH7RDQDO\VHPXOWLPRGDOYLVLELOLW\RIHPEROLVDWLRQSDUWLFOHVRQDQJLRJUDSK\
&7DQG05,LQSRUFLQHNLGQH\V
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$V DQ HYROXWLRQ RI WKH FXUUHQW DYDLODEOH HPEROLVDWLRQ
SDUWLFOHV (PER]HQH0LFURVSKHUHV&HOR1RYD%LR6FLHQFHV86$ WKRVHSDUWLFOHV
ZHUHPRGLÀHGWKDWDGGLWLRQDOHPEHGGLQJRIGHQVH;UD\PDWHULDOVVKRXOGUHVXOW
LQJRRGYLVLELOLW\RQDQJLRJUDSK\DQG&7DVZHOODVDGGLWLRQDOHPEHGGLQJRIPDJ
QHWLFVXEVWDQFHVVKRXOGUHVXOWLQJRRGYLVLELOLW\RQ05,7KUHHGLIIHUHQWSURWRW\SHV
,QWHQVLW\$%DQG& DVZHOODVFXUUHQWDYDLODEOH(PER]HQ0LFURVSKHUHVZLWK
VL]HVRIPDQGPZHUHWHVWHG:LWKRXWXVLQJDQ\FRQWUDVWPDWH
ULDOUHQDODUWHULHVRIIRXUSLJVZHUHFDWKHWHULVHGDQGHDFKNLGQH\ZDVHPEROLVHG
ZLWKRQHPLOOLOLWHURIRQHW\SHRISDUWLFOH6XEMHFWLYHDQGREMHFWLYHSDUWLFOHYLVLELOLW\
ZDVHYDOXDWHGRQDQJLRJUDSK\&7DQG05,
5HVXOWV2QDQJLRJUDSK\LQWHQVLW\$%DQG&RIPSDUWLFOHVDVZHOODVLQ
WHQVLW\%RIPSDUWLFOHVZHUHGHÀQLWHO\YLVLEOH&XUUHQWDYDLODEOH(PER]HQ
0LFURVSKHUHVJLYHQDVFRQWUROJURXSZHUHGHÀQLWHO\QRWYLVLEOH2Q&7DQG05, 7
DQG7 LQWHQVLW\$%DQG&RIPSDUWLFOHVDVZHOODVPSDUWLFOHV
ZHUHGHÀQLWHO\YLVLEOH2Q&7VLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRIRULQWHQVLW\$%DQG&LQFUHDVHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ HJLQWHQVLW\$PSDUWLFOHV3 2Q05,
7DQG7 VLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLRIRULQWHQVLW\$%DQG&GHFUHDVHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\
HJLQWHQVLW\%PSDUWLFOHV73
&RQFOXVLRQ0RGLÀFDWLRQRIWKHFXUUHQWDYDLODEOH(PER]HQH0LFURVSKHUHVZDV
VXFFHVVIXOZLWKPXOWLPRGDOYLVLELOLW\RQDQJLRJUDSK\&7DQG05,
%
$EODWLRQWKHUDS\RIKHSDWLFPDOLJQDQF\DFRPSDUDWLYHVWXG\
EHWZHHQUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DQGPLFURZDYHDEODWLRQWHFKQLTXHV
7-9RJO$'DUYLVKL3)DUVKLG$$]L]L%%D]UDIVKDQ1111DJXLE
1(1RXU(OGLQ6=DQJRV-7URMDQ)UDQNIXUW'( WYRJO#HPXQLIUDQNIXUWGH
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH WKH HIIHFWV DQG RXWFRPH RI UDGLRIUHTXHQF\ 5)$ DQG
PLFURZDYH 0:$ DEODWLRQ WKHUDS\ LQ WKH WUHDWPHQW RI SULPDU\ DQG VHFRQGDU\
OLYHUPDOLJQDQF\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\DSSURYHGE\WKHLQVWLWXWLRQDO
UHYLHZERDUGSDWLHQWVZLWKOHVLRQVZHUHWUHDWHGZLWK5)$DQG0:$,QWKH
5)$JURXS SDWLHQWV SDWLHQWVVXIIHUHGIURP+&& OHVLRQV DQGSDWLHQWV
IURPOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV OHVLRQV ,QWKH0:$JURXS SDWLHQWV OHVLRQV
+&&DQGOLYHUPHWDVWDVHV ZHUHGRFXPHQWHG5HVSRQVHFULWHULDUHFXUUHQFH
UDWH 55 DQGVXUYLYDOLQGLFHVZHUHDVVHVVHGDIWHUERWKSURFHGXUHV
5HVXOWV,QJURXS+&&OHVLRQV VKRZHGFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVH
OHVLRQV KDGUHVLGXDOWXPRXUV,QJURXS+&&OHVLRQV VKRZHG
FRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHOHVLRQV KDGUHVLGXDOWXPRXUV/LYHUPHWDVWDVHV
VKRZHG FRPSOHWH UHVSRQVH ZLWK QR UHVLGXDO OHVLRQV DIWHU ERWK SURFHGXUHV$OO
+&& OHVLRQV FP VKRZHG FRPSOHWH UHVSRQVH ZLWK QR UHVLGXDO OHVLRQV LQ
ERWKJURXSV7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQUDWHVRIUHVLGXDO+&&OHVLRQV
!FPEHWZHHQERWKJURXSV 3 /RJUDQNWHVW 7LPHWRSURJUHVVLRQ 773
LQDOOSDWLHQWVWUHDWHGZLWK5)$FRPSDUHGZLWK0:$ZDVYHUVXVPRQWKV
DQG55DWPRQWKVZHUHYHUVXV
UHVSHFWLYHO\ 3
&RQFOXVLRQ +&& OHVLRQV WUHDWHG ZLWK 5)$ DQG 0:$ KDG VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLPLODU
FRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHUDWHVRIUHVLGXDOWXPRXUVUHFXUUHQFHUDWHDQGVXUYLYDOLQGLFHV
$OOOLYHUPHWDVWDVHVDQGDOO+&&OHVLRQVFPKDGFRPSOHWHUHVSRQVHZLWKQR
UHVLGXDOWXPRXUVLQERWKJURXSV
%
0LFURZDYHDEODWLRQFRPSDUHGZLWKUDGLRIUHTXHQF\DEODWLRQIRU
EUHDVWWLVVXHLQDQH[YLYRERYLQHXGGHUPRGHO
3,VIRUW77DQDND73HQ]NRIHU3%UXQHUV7%UDXQVFKZHLJ
..LFKLNDZD76FKPLW]5RGH&..XKO$+0DKQNHQ$DFKHQ'(
1DUD-3 LVIRUW#XNDDFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIPLFURZDYH 0: DEODWLRQZLWKUDGLRI
UHTXHQF\ 5) DEODWLRQIRUWUHDWLQJEUHDVWWLVVXHLQH[YLYRERYLQHXGGHUWLVVXH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV0:DEODWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGDWSRZHURXWSXWVRI:
:DQG:XVLQJD0+]IUHTXHQF\JHQHUDWRUDQGDFPDFWLYHWLSDQWHQ
QD5)DEODWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKDELSRODU5)V\VWHPZLWKDQGFPDFWLYH
WLSHOHFWURGHV7LVVXHWHPSHUDWXUHVZHUHFRQWLQXRXVO\PRQLWRUHGGXULQJDEODWLRQ
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWRIDQWHJUDGHFRROHGS\HORSHUIXVLRQIRUWKHSURWHF
WLRQRIWKHUHQDOFROOHFWLQJV\VWHPGXULQJPLFURZDYHDEODWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&7JXLGHGQHSKURVWRP\ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQRQHNLGQH\LQ
HDFKRIIHPDOHKRXVHSLJVXVLQJD)SLJWDLOQHSKURVWRP\FDWKHWHU3\HORSHU
IXVLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJDFRROHGJOXFRVHVROXWLRQWKDWZDVLQIXVHGYLDWKH
QHSKURVWRP\FDWKHWHUDWPOVHF GURSVVHF 0HDQZKLOHPLFURZDYHDEODWLRQ
ZDVSHUIRUPHGDWZDWWVIRUPLQXWHVLQWKHLUULJDWHGDQGWKHQRQLUULJDWHG
NLGQH\VFUHDWLQJDFHQWUDODQGSHULSKHUDOOHVLRQ0D[LPXPDEODWLRQGLDPHWHUVZHUH
PHDVXUHG DQG DEODWLRQ YROXPHV ZHUH FDOFXODWHG DIWHU VDFULÀFH RI WKH DQLPDOV
7KHDIIHFWLRQRIWKHUHQDOFROOHFWLQJV\VWHPZDVDVVHVVHGLQWKHVOLFHRIPD[LPDO
WKHUPDOLQMXU\ LQWHUYDOV
5HVXOWV 3HULSKHUDO OHVLRQ VL]HV LQ WKH LUULJDWHG QRQLUULJDWHG NLGQH\V ZHUH
POPO&HQWUDOOHVLRQVL]HVLQWKHLUULJDWHGQRQLUULJDWHGNLG
QH\VZHUHPOPO0D[LPXPWKHUPDOGDPDJHRIWKHFROOHFWLQJ
V\VWHPLQSHULSKHUDOOHVLRQVLQLUULJDWHGQRQLUULJDWHGNLGQH\VZHUH
0D[LPXPWKHUPDOGDPDJHRIWKHFROOHFWLQJV\VWHPLQFHQWUDOOHVLRQVLQ
LUULJDWHGQRQLUULJDWHGNLGQH\VZHUH1RVWDWLVWLFDOO\
VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQDEODWLRQYROXPHDQGDIIHFWLRQRIWKHFROOHFWLQJV\VWHPZDV
REVHUYHGLQFHQWUDODQGSHULSKHUDOOHVLRQVZLWKRUZLWKRXWFRROHGS\HORSHUIXVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ ,Q PLFURZDYH DEODWLRQ FRROHG DQWHJUDGH S\HORSHUIXVLRQ GRHV QRW
SURWHFWWKHFROOHFWLQJV\VWHPIURPWKHUPDOGDPDJH7KHUHIRUHDEODWLRQRIFHQWUDO
UHQDOVWUXFWXUHVGRHVQRWVHHPDGYLVDEOHXVLQJPLFURZDYHDEODWLRQ
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQVKRUWD[LVGLDPHWHUVRIWKHFRDJXODWLRQ]RQHVZHUH
DQGFPIRU0:DEODWLRQDW::DQG:)RU
5)DEODWLRQWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJYDOXHVZHUHDQGFPZLWK
HOHFWURGHV KDYLQJ DQG FP DFWLYH WLSV UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KH PHDQ FRDJXODWLRQ
YROXPHVZHUHDQGFPIRU0:DEODWLRQRI
::DQG:DQGDQGFPIRU5)DEODWLRQZLWK
DQGFPHOHFWURGHVUHVSHFWLYHO\0:DEODWLRQVDW:DQG:DFKLHYHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ORQJHUVKRUWD[LVGLDPHWHUVWKDQ5)DEODWLRQV S 7KHKLJKHVW
WLVVXHWHPSHUDWXUHZDVDFKLHYHGZLWK0:DEODWLRQDW: S 2QKLVWR
ORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQWKHDEODWLRQ]RQHLQ0:DEODWLRQVZDVOHVVDIIHFWHGE\WLVVXH
KHWHURJHQHLW\WKDQLQ5)DEODWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ0:DEODWLRQDSSHDUVWREHDGYDQWDJHRXVZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHYROXPH
RIDEODWLRQDQGWKHVKDSHRIWKHPDUJLQRIQHFURVLVFRPSDUHGZLWK5)DEODWLRQLQ
DQH[YLYRERYLQHXGGHU
5RRP(
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
66D
$UWKURJUDSK\DQGDGYDQFHG05WHFKQRORJ\
0RGHUDWRUV
6*'DYLHV/ODQWULVDQW8.
05XSUHKW0DULERU6,
%
05DUWKURJUDSK\RIWKHVKRXOGHUSURVSHFWLYHWROHUDQFHHYDOXDWLRQ
RIIRXUGLIIHUHQWLQMHFWLRQWHFKQLTXHV
(3HUGLNDNLV$.DUDQWDQDV,UDNOLRQ*5 SHUGLNDNLVBHY#\DKRRJU
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWHSDWLHQWGLVFRPIRUWDQGWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVRIIRXU
GLIIHUHQWDUWKURJUDSKLFWHFKQLTXHVIRUSHUIRUPLQJ05DUWKURJUDSK\RIWKHVKRXOGHU
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV PDOHV DQG IHPDOHV
DJHUDQJH\HDUVPHDQDJH ZHUHUHIHUUHGIRU05DUWKURJUDSK\RIWKH
VKRXOGHU7KHSDWLHQWVZHUHUDQGRPO\LQMHFWHGXQGHUÁXRURVFRSLFJXLGDQFH Q
ZLWK&7JXLGDQFHXVLQJDQDQWHULRU Q RUDSRVWHULRUURXWH Q DQGZLWK
XOWUDVRXQGJXLGDQFH Q )RUHDFKSDWLHQWDEVROXWHSHULSURFHGXUDOSDLQRQD
QXPHULFDOUDWLQJSDLQVFDOH µQRSDLQµ µLQWROHUDEOHSDLQµ WHFKQLFDOVXFFHVV
RIWKHPHWKRGXVHGDQGUHDVRQIRU05DUWKURJUDSK\UHIHUUDOZHUHUHFRUGHG7KH
XQSDLUHG6WXGHQWWWHVWZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHSDWLHQWҋVGLVFRPIRUWLQWKHIRXU
DUWKURJUDSKLFWHFKQLTXHV
5HVXOWV7KHWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVUDWHZDVIRUDOOPHWKRGVRILQMHFWLRQ
7KHUHVXOWVUHJDUGLQJWKHDEVROXWHSHULSURFHGXUDOSDLQZHUH
DVIROORZLQJÁXRURVFRSLFJXLGDQFHVKRZHGDPHDQQXPHULFDOUDWLQJSDLQVFRUH
RI&7JXLGDQFHXVLQJDQDQWHULRUDSSURDFKGHPRQVWUDWHGDPHDQSDLQ
VFRUHRI&7JXLGDQFHXVLQJDSRVWHULRUURXWHRILQMHFWLRQVKRZHGDPHDQ
SDLQVFRUHRIDQGXOWUDVRXQGJXLGLQJLQMHFWLRQVDPHDQQXPHULFDOUDWLQJ
SDLQVFRUHRI$VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQDEVROXWH 3 SDLQZDVRE
VHUYHGIRUWKHSRVWHULRUURXWHXQGHU&7JXLGDQFHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHRWKHUPHWKRGV
&RQFOXVLRQ1RGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHIRXQGIRUWKHWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVUDWHRISHUIRUP
LQJ05DUWKURJUDSK\XVLQJHLWKHURIWKHDIRUHPHQWLRQHGWHFKQLTXHV$&7JXLGHG
SRVWHULRUDSSURDFKVHHPVWREHWKHPRVWFRPIRUWDEOHPHWKRGIRUWKHSDWLHQW
%
6/$3WHDUVDW7VKRXOGHU05DUWKURJUDSK\GLDJQRVLVZLWKD'
LVRWURSLF9,%(VHTXHQFHYHUVXV'VWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHV
+6RQJ:+-HH-<-XQJ<6.LP6HRXO.5 K\XQ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\GHWHUPLQHWKHUHOLDELOLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RIVKRXOGHU05
DUWKURJUDSK\ ZLWK D ' LVRWURSLF7ZHLJKWHG JUDGLHQWHFKR VHTXHQFH YROXPH
LQWHUSRODWHGEUHDWKKROGH[DPLQDWLRQ9,%( IRUGLDJQRVLQJ6/$3WHDUVFRPSDUHG
ZLWK'VWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHVDW7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 6HYHQW\QLQH SDWLHQWV ZKR XQGHUZHQW VKRXOGHU 05
DUWKURJUDSK\XVLQJ7LPDJHUVDQGVXEVHTXHQWDUWKURVFRS\ZHUHLQFOXGHG,Q
DGGLWLRQWR'VWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHV'9,%(ZDVREWDLQHGWRSURGXFHPXOWLSODQDU
LPDJHV ZLWK D PP LVRWURSLF UHVROXWLRQ (DFK VHW RI 05 LPDJHV IURP HDFK
PHWKRGZDVLQGHSHQGHQWO\VFRUHGIRUWKH6/$3WHDUDQGFDWHJRULVHG'LDJQRVWLF
SHUIRUPDQFHVEHWZHHQ'VWDQGDUGDQG'LVRWURSLF9,%(ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWK
52&FXUYHV,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWVZHUHDVVHVVHGZLWKNDSSDYDOXH
5HVXOWV$WDUWKURVFRS\WKHUHZHUH6/$3WHDUVW\SH,, Q W\SH,,, Q
DQGW\SH,9 Q 9 Q 0HDQVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RQ'
VWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHVZHUHDQGZKHUHDVPHDQVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
FLW\DQGDFFXUDF\RQ'LVRWURSLF9,%(ZHUHDQG7KHVHQVLWLYLW\
ZDVGLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQ'VWDQGDUGDQG'LVRWURSLF9,%(LQERWKUHDGHUV7KH
DUHDVXQGHUWKH52&FXUYHVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\GLIIHUHQW'VWDQGDUGYV'9,%(
YVIRUUHDGHUYVIRUUHDGHU,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDV
VXEVWDQWLDOѣ ZLWK'VWDQGDUGVHTXHQFHVѣ ZLWK'LVRWURSLF9,%(
&RQFOXVLRQ7VKRXOGHU05DUWKURJUDSK\XVLQJD'LVRWURSLF9,%(KDVOHVV
GLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHIRU6/$3WHDUVFRPSDUHGZLWK'VWDQGDUG05VHTXHQFHV
%
3UHRSHUDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIDQWHULRUVKRXOGHULQVWDELOLW\
FRPSDUDWLYHVWXG\RI05DUWKURJUDSK\DQG&7DUWKURJUDSK\
6.KHGU-LGGDK6$
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHGLUHFW05DUWKURJUDSK\DQG&7DUWKURJUDSK\LQDVVHVVPHQW
RIDQWHULRUVKRXOGHULQVWDELOLW\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZRPHQ DQG PHQ DJH
UDQJH \HDUV ZKR XQGHUZHQW GLUHFW 05$ IROORZHG E\ &7$ ZLWKLQ KRXU
EHIRUHDQWHULRUVKRXOGHULQVWDELOLW\UHSDLUZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHGLQWKLVVWXG\
05$DQG&7$LPDJHVZHUHDQDO\VHGE\PXVFXORVNHOHWDOUDGLRORJLVWDQGFRPSDUHG
ZLWKDUWKURVFRSLFUHVXOWV
5HVXOWV,QGHWHFWLRQRIJOHQRLGULPIUDFWXUHVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUH
DQGIRU&7$DQGDQGIRU05$IRU+$*/OHVLRQVGLDJQRVLV
VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\ZHUHDQGIRU&7$DQGIRU05$,Q
GHWHFWLRQRIJOHQRLGDUWLFXODUFDUWLODJHOHVLRQVHQVLWLYLW\DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ZHUH
DQGIRU&7$DQGDQGIRU05$1RGLIIHUHQFHZDVREVHUYHG
IRUGHWHFWLRQRIURWDWRUFXIIWHQGRQVWHDU
&RQFOXVLRQ&7$ZDVVXSHULRUWR05$LQGHWHFWLRQJOHQRLGRVVHRXVOHVLRQVWKDW
DUHNQRZQWREHGHFLVLRQDOHOHPHQWLQWKHVXUJLFDOVWUDWHJ\&7$DQG05$:(5(
HTXLYDOHQWLQGHPRQVWUDWLQJODEUROLJDPHQWRXVDQGFDUWLODJHQRXVOHVLRQVDVVRFL
DWHGZLWKDQWHULRUVKRXOGHULQVWDELOLW\&7$PD\EHFRQVLGHUHGPHWKRGRIFKRLFH
LQSUHRSHUDWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRIDQWHULRUVKRXOGHULQVWDELOLW\
%
&7DUWKURJUDSK\ &7$ RIWKHKLSDQGVKRXOGHURSWLPLVDWLRQRI
WHFKQLTXHDQGRIUDGLDWLRQEXUGHQLQYLWURDQGLQFDGDYHUV
/6FDUFLROOD&0DUpFKDO$7URPED0(O+DFKHPL77KLULRQ
%%HRPRQWH=REHO36LPRQL5RPH,7/LHJH%(%HDXID\V%(
3XUSRVH7RRSWLPLVHWKHDFTXLVLWLRQSDUDPHWHUVRI&7$RIWKHKLSDQGVKRXOGHU
LQRUGHUWRPLQLPLVHWKHUDGLDWLRQEXUGHQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&DUWLODJHGHIHFWVZHUHDUWLÀFLDOO\FUHDWHGRQDERYLQH
IHPRUDOFRQG\OH7KHVSHFLPHQZDVVFDQQHGLQDEDWKRILRGLQDWHGFRQWUDVWPH
GLXP PHJOXPLQLHVRGLXPLR[DJDOWHPJGO FKDQJLQJSDUDPHWHUVRQHDWDWLPH
N9P$6 .9YDOXHVVSDQQHGIURPWRN9DQGP$VIURPWR8VLQJ
WKHVDPHSURFHGXUHPXOWLSOHDFTXLVLWLRQVZHUHFDUULHGRXWIRUWKHKLSVDQGWKH
VKRXOGHUVRIIUHVKFDGDYHUV$IWHULPDJLQJFDGDYHUVZHUHIUR]HQDQGPXOWLSOH
PPVOLFHVZHUHREWDLQHGLQWKHFRURQDODQGD[LDOSODQHVZLWKWKHEHQFKVDZ
$QDWRPLFVSHFLPHQVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRPXOWLSODQDUUHFRQVWUXFWLRQPPVHFWLRQ
&7$LPDJHV(DFKVHWRIYDOXHVZDVTXDOLWDWLYHO\VFRUHGE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWUD
GLRORJLVWVRQWKHEDVLVRIWKHYLVLELOLW\RIFDUWLODJHDVIROORZLQJ SRRU GLDJQRVWLF
TXDOLW\ YHU\JRRG
5HVXOWV&7$UHIRUPDWWHGLPDJHVRQD[LDOSODQHZHUHMXGJHGRIGLDJQRVWLFYDOXH
HYHQZKHQN9DQGP$VZHUHGHFUHDVHGWRDWRWDOGRVHUHGXFWLRQRIIRUWKHKLS
DQGRIIRUWKHVKRXOGHUFRPSDUHGWRWKHVWDQGDUGWHFKQLTXHV+RZHYHU035
FRURQDOLPDJHVREWDLQHGZLWKDUHGXFHGGRVHJDYHDSRRUGHSLFWLRQRIFDUWLODJH
&RQFOXVLRQ$UHGXFWLRQRIWKHVWDQGDUGGRVHFXUUHQWO\XVHGWRSHUIRUP&7$GLG
QRWLQÁXHQFHWKHTXDOLW\RIUHIRUPDWWHGD[LDO035EXWZDVLQHIIHFWLYHWRJHQHUDWH
035LPDJHVRIGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\LQRWKHUSODQHV
%
&DSVXODUOD[LW\RIWKHKLSÀQGLQJVDW05DUWKURJUDSK\
20DJHUNXUWK-$-DFREVRQ<0RUDJ(0&DRLOL')HVVHOO-6HNL\D
%DVOH&+$QQ$UERU0,86
3XUSRVH7RUHWURVSHFWLYHO\GHVFULEH05$ÀQGLQJVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKFDSVXODUOD[LW\
RIWKHKLSMRLQWIRXQGDWVXUJHU\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,5% DSSURYDO ZDV REWDLQHG 3DWLHQWV ZLWK 05$ DQG
VXUJLFDOO\DVVHVVHGSUHVHQFHRUDEVHQFHRIOD[LW\RIWKHKLSMRLQWZHUHLQFOXGHG
$[LDO7Z,PDJHVZHUHUDQGRPLVHGDQGUHYLHZHGWZLFHE\LQGHSHQGHQWEOLQGHG
UHDGHUV7KHZLGWKVRIWKHDQWHULRUMRLQWVSDFHODWHUDOWRWKH]RQDRUELFXODULVDQG
RIWKHSRVWHULRUMRLQWVSDFHZHUHDVVHVVHG7KHDQJOHEHWZHHQIHPRUDOQHFNDQG
LVFKLXPZDVPHDVXUHGWRDVVHVVKLSURWDWLRQ6WDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHFDOFXODWHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ZLWKDWWHVW,QWHUDQGLQWUDUHDGHUDJUHHPHQWDVZHOODVFRUUHODWLRQRIZLGWKVRI
MRLQWVSDFHVZLWKDQJOHVDQGYROXPHRIFRQWUDVWZDVHYDOXDWHGZLWKD3HDUVRQWHVW
5HVXOWV7KHVWXG\JURXSFRQVLVWHGRIVXEMHFWVRIZKLFKZHUHSRVLWLYHDQG
QHJDWLYHIRUKLSOD[LW\DWVXUJHU\7KHPHDQZLGWKRIWKHDQWHULRUMRLQWVSDFH
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW S LQWKHOD[LW\JURXS PP DQGLQWKHJURXS
ZLWKRXWOD[LW\ PP 7KHPHDQZLGWKRIWKHSRVWHULRUMRLQWVSDFHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\
GLIIHUHQW S LQWKHOD[LW\JURXS PP DQGLQWKHJURXSZLWKRXWOD[LW\ PP
7KHUHZDVQRGLIIHUHQFHLQPHDQIHPRUDOQHFNLVFKLXPDQJOHVEHWZHHQWKHJURXSV
S PHDQYROXPHRIFRQWUDVW S 7KHUHZDVQRFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKH
DQJOHYROXPHWRWKHZLGWKVRIWKHMRLQWVSDFHV U ,QWHUDQGLQWUDUHDGHU
DJUHHPHQWZDVKLJK U
&RQFOXVLRQ'LVWHQWLRQRIWKHDQWHULRUDQGSRVWHULRUMRLQWVSDFHZDVJUHDWHUZLWK
KLSOD[LW\LQGHSHQGHQWRILQWUDDUWLFXODUFRQWUDVWYROXPHDQGKLSURWDWLRQ
%
05WUDFWLRQDUWKURJUDSK\RIWKHKLSLQIHPRURDFHWDEXODULPSLQJHPHQW
(6FKPDUDQ]HU0.RJOHU05HLFKNHQGOHU39DYURQ6W-RKDQQ$7
VFKPDUDQ]HU#NKVMDW
3XUSRVH7KHFHQWUDOFRPSDUWPHQWRIWKHKLSLVXVXDOO\GLIÀFXOWWRDVVHVVE\GLUHFW
05 DUWKURJUDSK\ 0RVWO\ D VXIÀFLHQW LQWHUIDFH EHWZHHQ DFHWDEXODU DQG IHPRUDO
FDUWLODJH LV QRW DFKLHYDEOH ZLWK WUDFWLRQ SURFHGXUHV GHVFULEHG LQ WKH OLWHUDWXUH
:HWKHUHIRUHGHYHORSHGDGHGLFDWHGGHYLFHLQDQDORJ\WRWKHWUDFWLRQV\VWHPIRU
KLSDUWKURVFRS\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVGHGLFDWHGWUDFWLRQGHYLFHFRQVLVWVRIDPRELOHDLG
PDGHRIFKURPLXPQLFNHOVWHHOQRWGLUHFWO\FRQQHFWHGWRWKH05WDEOHSURYLGHG
ZLWKDQLQWHJUDWHGGHÁHFWLRQSXOOH\IRUDFDEOHZLQFK ZHLJKWWRNJ DQGD
VXSSRUWLQJ SODWH IRU WKH FRQWUDODWHUDO ORZHU H[WUHPLW\$ WRWDO RI FRQVHFXWLYH
SDWLHQWV PHDQ DJH \HDUV ZRPHQ ZHUH LQYHVWLJDWHG DIWHU DUWKURJUDSK\
ZLWKRXWDQGZLWKWUDFWLRQRQD7HVODXQLW
5HVXOWV :LWKRXW WUDFWLRQ WKH ODEUXP ZDV VXIÀFLHQW DVVHVVDEOH LQ SDWLHQWV
WKHDFHWDEXODUDQGIHPRUDOFDUWLODJHRQO\LQSDWLHQWV 8VLQJ
WUDFWLRQDQDGHTXDWHVHSDUDWLRQRIIHPRUDODQGDFHWDEXODUFDUWLODJHZLWKDQDYHU
DJHFRQWLQXRXVLQWHUIDFHRIPP UDQJHIURPWRPP ZDVDFKLHYHGLQ
SDWLHQWV$QGWKHUHIRUHWKHODEUXPIHPRUDODQGDFHWDEXODUFDUWLODJHZHUHVXI
ÀFLHQWGHWHFWDEOH2QO\LQRQHFDVHZHZHUHXQDEOHWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHIHPRUDOIURP
DFHWDEXODU FDUWLODJH ([FOXGLQJ WKLV SDWLHQW FKRQGUDO GHIHFWV DQG ODEUDO OHVLRQV
ZHUHDFFXUDWHO\DVVHVVDEOH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVHSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWVVKRZWKDWWKHXVHRIWKLVWUDFWLRQV\VWHP
PDUNHGO\LPSURYHVGLDJQRVWLFVWXGLHVRIWKHKLS7KHH[DFWORFDWLRQRIODEUXPDQG
FDUWLODJHOHVLRQVLVYHU\VLJQLÀFDQWDVUHJDUGVSURJQRVLVDQGRIGHFLVLYHLPSRUWDQFH
IRUVHOHFWLRQRIWKHUDS\
%
0HWDODUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQLQ05LPDJLQJDW7HVODLQFRPSDULVRQWR
7HVODXVLQJLQQRYDWLYHVHTXHQFHVWUDWHJLHV
05HLFKHUW$7DR07UHOOHV5.5DR01LWWND$3DGXD
626FKRHQEHUJ905XQJH8,$WWHQEHUJHU0DQQKHLP'(7RQJLM&1
*DOYHVWRQ7;86(UODQJHQ'(0DOYHUQ3$86 0LULDP5HLFKHUW#XPPGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
7KHDFFXUDF\RIG\QDPLFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJLQHYDOXDWLRQ
RILQWHUQDOGHUDQJHPHQWRIWKHWHPSRURPDQGLEXODUMRLQWFRPSDULVRQ
ZLWKDUWKURVFRSLFÀQGLQJV
0)$PLQ$0+DVVDQ.,%DUDNDW(OPLQ\D(*
0RKDPPHGBDPLQ#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH FRUUHODWLRQ EHWZHHQ G\QDPLF 05, DQG DUWKURVFRSLF
ÀQGLQJVLQLQWHUQDOGHUDQJHPHQWRIWKHWHPSRURPDQGLEXODUMRLQW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHFXUUHQWSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVFRQGXFWHGRQWZHQW\
ÀYHSDWLHQWV RI70-V HLJKWHHQIHPDOHVDQGVHYHQPDOHVWKHLUDJHUDQJLQJ
IURPWR\HDUV PHDQ\HDUV $FRQWUROJURXSRIDGXOWYROXQWHHUV
IHPDOHVDQGPDOHV WKHLUDJHUDQJHGIURPWR\HDUVZDVXVHGWRVWXG\
WKHQRUPDODQDWRPLFDOIHDWXUHVRIWKH70-DVZHOODVWKHG\QDPLFVRIWKHMRLQW
05,ZDVXVHGWRDVVHVVGLVFSRVLWLRQGLVFPRUSKRORJ\GLVFPRELOLW\ERQHPDUURZ
RHGHPDFRQG\ODUWUDQVODWLRQDQGMRLQWHIIXVLRQ0DLQRXWFRPHPHDVXUHV4XDOLWD
WLYHGDWDZHUHSUHVHQWHGDVIUHTXHQFLHVDQGSHUFHQWDJHV
5HVXOWV&RQFHUQLQJGLVFSRVLWLRQ05H[DPLQDWLRQUHYHDOHG70-VRXWRI
ZLWKDQWHULRUO\GLVSODFHGGLVFVZKLOH70-V VKRZHGQRUPDOGLVF
SRVLWLRQ:KHQW\SHRIGLVSODFHPHQWZDVFRQVLGHUHG05,UHYHDOHG70-V
ZLWK$'':5 ZKLOH 70-V ZLWK$'':25 05, DVVHVVPHQW RI GLVF
PRELOLW\UHYHDOHGRXWRI70-V ZLWKOLPLWHGDV\QFKURQRXVPRYHPHQWV
ZKLOH70-V ZLWKVWXFNGLVFDQG70-V ZLWKQRUPDOPRELOLW\
&RQFOXVLRQ%RWKDUWKURVFRS\DQGG\QDPLF05,DUHVWDWLVWLFDOO\FRUUHODWHGWRHDFK
RWKHULQGHWHFWLQJ70-LQWHUQDOGHUDQJHPHQW1HYHUWKHOHVVUHYLHZLQJWKHUHVXOWV
KLJKOLJKWHGWKHDGYDQWDJHVRI05,DXJPHQWHGE\G\QDPLFSURWRFRORYHUDUWKURVFRS\
LQGLDJQRVLQJGLVFSRVLWLRQDQGPRELOLW\DQGKHQFHZHUHFRPPHQGXVLQJ05,DVD
ÀUVWOLQHGLDJQRVWLFPRGDOLW\ZKHQLQWHUQDOGHUDQJHPHQWLVVXVSHFWHG
%
$VVHVVPHQWRIDUWLFXODUFDUWLODJHUHSDLUWLVVXHDIWHUPDWUL[
DVVRFLDWHGDXWRORJRXVFKRQGURF\WHWUDQVSODQWDWLRQRUWKH
PLFURIUDFWXUHWHFKQLTXHLQWKHDQNOHMRLQWXVLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG
LPDJLQJDW7HVOD
65$SSULFK67UDWWQLJ*+:HOVFK,01RHEDXHU+XKPDQQ
6'RPD\HU9LHQQD$7(UODQJHQ'( VHEDVWLDQDSSULFK#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHZDVWRFRPSDUHSDWLHQWVDIWHUPDWUL[DVVRFLDWHGDXWRORJRXV
FKRQGURF\WHWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ 0$&7 DQGPLFURIUDFWXUHWKHUDS\ 0); RIWKHWDOXV
XVLQJGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':, ZLWKPRUSKRORJLFDODQGFOLQLFDOVFRULQJ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7ZHQW\ SDWLHQWV WUHDWHG ZLWK 0$&7 RU 0); WHQ SHU
JURXS ZHUHH[DPLQHGXVLQJ705,DWDQGPRQWKVDIWHUVXUJHU\
UHVSHFWLYHO\)RUFRPSDUDELOLW\SDWLHQWVIURPHDFKJURXSZHUHPDWFKHGE\DJH
ERG\PDVVLQGH[DQGIROORZXS$2)$6VFRUHVHUYHGDVFOLQLFDODVVHVVPHQWWRRO
SUHDQGSRVWRSHUDWLYHO\':,ZDVREWDLQHGXVLQJDSDUWLDOO\EDODQFHGVWHDG\
VWDWH JUDGLHQWHFKR SXOVH VHTXHQFH DV ZHOO DV WKH 02&$57 VFRUH EDVHG RQ
D '3'Z76(VHTXHQFH DQG D 'LVR7UXH)LVSVHTXHQFH 6HPLTXDQWLWDWLYH
GLIIXVLRQ TXRWLHQWV ZHUH FDOFXODWHG DIWHU 52, DQDO\VLV RI UHSDLU WLVVXH 57 DQG
KHDOWK\FRQWUROFDUWLODJHDQGFRPSDUHGDPRQJERWKJURXSV
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ$2)$6VFRUHLPSURYHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\ 3 IRUERWKJURXSV
0$&7WR0);WR 1RGLIIHUHQFHVLQWKH
$2)$6 3 DQG02&$57 3 VFRUHZHUHREVHUYHGEHWZHHQ0$&7
DQG0);SRVWRSHUDWLYHO\':,GLVWLQJXLVKHGEHWZHHQKHDOWK\FDUWLODJHDQGFDUWLODJH
57LQWKH0);JURXS 3 EXWQRWDIWHU0$&7WUHDWPHQW 3 &RU
UHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ02&$57VFRUHDQG':, 3HDUVRQ3
DQGDWUHQGIRUDFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ%0,DQG':, 3HDUVRQ3
&RQFOXVLRQ:KHUHDVFRQYHQWLRQDOVFRUHVUHYHDODVLPLODURXWFRPHDIWHU0$&7
RU0);WUHDWPHQWLQWKHDQNOHMRLQW':,ZDVDEOHWRGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQGLIIHU
HQW57TXDOLWLHVDVUHSRUWHGKLVWRORJLFDOO\IRUWKHVHGLYHUVHVXUJLFDOSURFHGXUHV
%
)HDVLELOLW\RIJDJ&(67LPDJLQJRQDFOLQLFDO705,V\VWHPLQLWLDO
UHVXOWVDQGFRPSDULVRQZLWKVRGLXPLPDJLQJDW7HVOD
%6FKPLWW*+:HOVFK6=E\Q6*RHG67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7
EHQMDPLQVFKPLWW#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH(YDOXDWLRQRIIHDVLELOLW\WRSHUIRUPJDJ&(67LPDJLQJRQDFOLQLFDO7
05,V\VWHPLQQLQHSDWLHQWVZLWKNQHHSDLQDQGWKUHHKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 0RUSKRORJLFDO 05, DQG JDJ&(67 LPDJLQJ ZHUH SHU
IRUPHGRQDFOLQLFDO77LP7ULR6RGLXPLPDJLQJZDVFDUULHGRXWRQD6LHPHQV
7ZKROHERG\V\VWHPXVLQJDPRGLÀHG*5(VHTXHQFH6LJQDOGLVWULEXWLRQVLQ
KHDOWK\FDUWLODJHRIYROXQWHHUVZHUHGHWHUPLQHGDVDUHIHUHQFHIRUSDWKRORJLFDO
FKDQJHV6RGLXPLPDJLQJDQGJDJ&(67SHUIRUPHGLQSDWLHQWVZHUHFRPSDUHG
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRVKRZWKHIHDVLELOLW\RIPHWDODUWHIDFWUHGXF
WLRQLQ05,DW7LQFRPSDULVRQWR7XVLQJLQQRYDWLYHVHTXHQFHVWUDWHJLHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6WDWHRIWKHDUWWHFKQLTXHVIRUPHWDODUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQ
LQFOXGLQJ9$7DQG6(0$&ZHUHHYDOXDWHG773'DQG67,5LPDJHVZHUH
DFTXLUHGRQD7V\VWHPDVZHOODVRQD7V\VWHP$JDURVHSKDQWRPVZLWK
VWDLQOHVVVWHHOLPSODQWVWLVVXHSKDQWRPVZLWKPHWDOLPSODQWVDQGYROXQWHHUVZHUH
LPDJHGZLWKWKHVHWHFKQLTXHV$UWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQZDVDVVHVVHGE\PHDVXUHPHQW
RIWKHDUWHIDFWYROXPHDQGE\EOLQGHGUHDG
5HVXOWV &RPSDUHG WR FRQYHQWLRQDO DFTXLVLWLRQV ZLWK D KLJK EDQGZLGWK PHWDO
DUWHIDFWVMXGJHGE\YROXPHRIDUWHIDFWZHUHUHGXFHGE\RQ79$7
6(0$&DQG6(0$&9$7DW7DQGDQGRQ79$76(0$&DQG
6(0$&9$7DW773'DQG67,5GHPRQVWUDWHGVLPLODUDUWHIDFWUHGXFWLRQ)RU
DUWHIDFWVL]HGLVWRUWLRQRIQRUPDOVWUXFWXUHVDQGDELOLW\WRYLVXDOLVHWKHERQHPDUURZ
ERQHFRUWH[DQGVRIWWLVVXHV6(0$&9$7ZHUHUDQNHGVXSHULRUWRFRQYHQWLRQDO
DFTXLVLWLRQVDVHYDOXDWHGRQWKHEOLQGHGUHDG)RURYHUDOOLPDJHTXDOLW\LPDJHV
ZHUHUDQNHGDVIROORZV6(0$&9$7!9$7!6(0$&!FRQYHQWLRQDODFTXLVLWLRQ
NDSSD 615YDOXHVZHUHUDQNHG6(0$&!6(0$&9$7!FRQYHQWLRQDO
DFTXLVLWLRQ!9$7
&RQFOXVLRQ6(0$&9$7VXEVWDQWLDOO\UHGXFHGPHWDODUWHIDFWVIRU7DQG7
VFDQVIRUDOOHYDOXDWHGLPDJHFRQWUDVWV7KHDUWHIDFWYROXPHLVLQFUHDVHGRQ7
EXWVWLOOVXEVWDQWLDOO\UHGXFHGE\6(0$&9$7
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ZLWKUHVSHFWWRFDUWLODJHVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVIURP52,VLQKHDOWK\FDUWLODJH 17 DQG
52,VDGMDFHQWWRDSSDUHQWPRUSKRORJLFDOOHVLRQV $7PLQLPXPGLVWDQFHPP
(YDOXDWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGVHSDUDWHO\E\WZRUHDGHUV6WDWLVWLFDOUHODWLRQVEHWZHHQ
WHFKQLTXHVZHUHDVVHVVHGXVLQJQRQSDUDPHWULFWHVWV
5HVXOWV$EVROXWHJDJ&(67YDOXHVIURP52,VLQYDULRXVFDUWLODJHDUHDVRIWKH
YROXQWHHUV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ IROORZHG *DXVVLDQ GLVWULEXWLRQV DQG H[KLELWHG SRVLWLYH
PHDQYDOXHVLQWKHRUGHURIWR3DWLHQWVH[KLELWHGFRQVLVWHQWO\ORZHUDYHU
DJHJDJ&(67VLJQDOVLQ$7 FRPSDUHGWR17 7KHVH
UHVXOWV ZHUH FRQÀUPHG E\ VRGLXP LPDJLQJ ZKHUH D PHDQ VLJQDO LQWHQVLW\ RI
ZDVPHDVXUHGLQ17DQGLQ$7,QWUDFODVVFRU
UHODWLRQEHWZHHQUHDGHUV\LHOGHG5ò IRUJDJ&(67YDOXHVDQG5ò
IRUVRGLXPVLJQDOLQWHQVLWLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ:HGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDWLWZDVSRVVLEOHWRREWDLQ'JDJ&(67GDWDVHWV
LQUHDVRQDEOHVFDQWLPHZLWKWKHSUHVHQWHGWHFKQLTXH7KHUHVXOWVRIWKLVVWXG\
HVSHFLDOO\WKHVWURQJFRUUHODWLRQRIJDJ&(67ZLWKVRGLXPLPDJLQJFOHDUO\VXJJHVW
WKHIHDVLELOLW\RIJDJ&(67LPDJLQJLQDURXWLQHFOLQLFDOVHWWLQJ
5RRP(
3DHGLDWULF
66
1HXURDQGIHWDOLPDJLQJ
0RGHUDWRUV
-)&KDWHLO%RUGHDX[)5
-*HLJHU)UHLEXUJ'(
%
(IIHFWRI[UD\WXEHSDUDPHWHUVDQGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQRQ
UDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\LQSDHGLDWULFDQGDGXOWEUDLQ&7
DQJLRJUDSK\DSKDQWRPVWXG\
$(3DSDGDNLV.3HULVLQDNLV05DLVVDNL-'DPLODNLV,UDNOLRQ*5
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIIHFWRI[UD\WXEHSDUDPHWHUVDQGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQ
RQUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\LQSDHGLDWULFDQGDGXOWEUDLQ&7DQJLRJUDSK\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$QHZW\SHRIEUDLQYDVFXODUOHVLRQSKDQWRPVZDVGH
YLVHGLQRXUODE&\OLQGULFDOYHVVHOVZHUHERUHGDORQJWKHEUDLQHTXLYDOHQWSOXJVRI
SK\VLFDODQWKURSRPRUSKLFKHDGSKDQWRPVWKDWVLPXODWHWKHDYHUDJHLQGLYLGXDODV
QHRQDWH\HDU\HDU\HDUROGFKLOGDQGDGXOW7RVLPXODWHYDVFXODUOHVLRQV
RIGLIIHUHQWGLDPHWHUYHVVHOVRIPPPPPPDQGPPZHUHFUHDWHG
7KHVHYHVVHOVZHUHÀOOHGZLWKLRGLQHVROXWLRQVRIGLIIHUHQWFRQFHQWUDWLRQ3KDQWRP
KHDGVZHUHVFDQQHGXVLQJVWDQGDUGN9SDQGP$VVHWWLQJVSUHVFULEHGE\WKHURXWLQH
H[DPLQDWLRQSURWRFROIRUHDFKDJHDQGDWUHGXFHGN9SDQGP$VH[SRVXUHVHWWLQJV
$FTXLVLWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQDVOLFH&7VFDQQHUXVLQJL À[HGP$VDQGLL
DXWRPDWLFH[SRVXUHFRQWURO $(& &RQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 ZDVFDOFXODWHG
EDVHG RQ WKH +RXQVÀHOG 8QLW YDOXHV PHDVXUHG ZLWKLQ FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG DQG
XQHQKDQFHGUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW
5HVXOWV &15 YDOXHV YDULHG IURP IRU WKH \HDUROG FKLOG WR
IRUDGXOWDWVWDQGDUGH[SRVXUHVHWWLQJV&15YDOXHVLQFUHDVHGOLQHDUO\ZLWKP$V
VHWWLQJVYHVVHOGLDPHWHULRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQ 3 DQGZHUHRSWLPXPDW
N9S$(&DFWLYDWLRQUHGXFHGGRVHE\XSWRZLWKRXWVLJQLÀFDQWGHJUDGD
WLRQRI&15 3!
&RQFOXVLRQ([SRVXUHVHWWLQJVDQGLRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQFDQEHIXUWKHUUHGXFHG
GXULQJSDHGLDWULFDQGDGXOW&7DQJLRJUDSK\ZLWKRXWVLJQLÀFDQWO\DIIHFWLQJ&15
2XU ÀQGLQJV FDQ EH XVHG WR GHWHUPLQH WKHVH PLQLPXP H[SRVXUH VHWWLQJV DQG
LRGLQHFRQFHQWUDWLRQ
%
%LVPXWKVKLHOGLQJDQGDXWRPDWLFWXEHFXUUHQWPRGXODWLRQGXULQJ
SDHGLDWULFKHDG&7
05DLVVDNL$3DSDGDNLV.3HULVLQDNLV-'DPLODNLV,UDNOLRQ*5
PUDLVVDNL#\DKRRJU
3XUSRVH7RVWXG\WKHHIIHFWRIRUELWDOELVPXWKVKLHOGLQJFRPELQHGZLWK$7&0RQ
WXEHFXUUHQWDQGLPDJHQRLVH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RXUDQWKURSRPRUSKLFSKDQWRPV $720SKDQWRPV&,56
,QF1RUIRON UHSUHVHQWLQJWKHDYHUDJHKHDGRIQHZERUQDQG\HDUROG
ZHUHVFDQQHGRQD6LHPHQV6RPDWRP6HQVDWLRQVFDQQHUD ZLWKÀ[HGWXEH
FXUUHQWE ZLWK$7&0F ZLWK$7&0DQGDVKLHOGRQRUELWVEHIRUHVFRXWDFTXLVLWLRQ
G ZLWK$7&0DQGDVKLHOGRQRUELWVDIWHUVFRXWDFTXLVLWLRQ1RLVHZDVPHDVXUHG
DV6'RI+8E\GUDZLQJFPUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWLQKRPRJHQHRXVDSSHDULQJ
DUHDVDWERWKRUELWVWHPSRUDOIURQWDOSDULHWDOOREHVIRUHDFKVFDQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5HVXOWV&'7,VZHUHP*\P$VLQDOOVFDQV&XUUHQWUHGXFWLRQRYHUWKH
H\HVZDV PHDQ DQGRYHUDOO PHDQ ZLWKWKH
QHRQDWHHTXLYDOHQWVFDQVEHQHÀWLQJPRVWIURP$7&01RLVHH[KLELWHGDVWDWLVWL
FDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHZKHQ$(&ZDVHPSOR\HGFRPSDUHGWRÀ[HGP$ZLWKRU
ZLWKRXWVKLHOGLQJ1RLVHH[KLELWHGIXUWKHUVLJQLÀFDQWLQFUHDVHZKHQVKLHOGVZHUH
SRVLWLRQHGDIWHUVFRXWDFTXLVLWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ$7&0LVDUHTXLVLWHGXULQJSDHGLDWULFKHDG&7DQGZKHQHPSOR\HG
WXEHFXUUHQWLVQRWDIIHFWHGE\ELVPXWKVKLHOGSODFHPHQW6KLHOGVFDXVHLQFUHDVH
LQLPDJHGHQVLW\RYHUWKHH\HVHVSHFLDOO\LQQHRQDWHVLUUHVSHFWLYHO\RIÀ[HGRU
UHGXFHGFXUUHQW%UDLQGHQVLW\LVPLQLPDOO\DIIHFWHGE\VKLHOGSODFHPHQW
%
$ORFDOGRVHVXUYH\RIFUDQLDO&7LQFKLOGUHQFRPSDULVRQZLWK
GLIIHUHQW(XURSHDQ'5/OHYHOVDQGSRVVLELOLWLHVIRUGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQ
7+(0XONHQV3%HOOLQFN56DOJDGR/LHU%( WRPPXONHQV#VFDUOHWEH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGRVHOHYHORIRXUFUDQLDO&7SURWRFROVLQFKLOGUHQZLWK
UHFHQW(XURSHDQ'5/OHYHOVRIGLIIHUHQW(XURSHDQFRXQWULHVDQGSURSRVHREMHF
WLYHVIRUGRVHRSWLPLVDWLRQ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV &UDQLDO &7 LV WKH PRVW FRPPRQ &7 H[DPLQDWLRQ LQ
FKLOGUHQ$OWKRXJKGRVHUHGXFWLRQDQGRSWLPLVDWLRQRI&7LQFKLOGUHQLVPDQGDWRU\
WKHUHDUHFRPSDUHGZLWKDGXOW&7QRHVWDEOLVKHG(XURSHDQGRVHUHIHUHQFHOHYHOV
'5/ :HUHYLHZHGWKHGRVHYDOXHVRIRXUFUDQLDO&7SURWRFROVLQFKLOGUHQRI
Q DFFRUGLQJWRDJH7KH\ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHPHDQ'5/OHYHOVRI
GLIIHUHQW(XURSHDQFRXQWULHVSXEOLVKHGLQWKHODVW\HDUV
5HVXOWV)ROORZLQJPHDQFUDQLDOGRVHOHYHOVRI&7LQFKLOGUHQZHUHREWDLQHG
\HDU Q &7',YRORIP*\'/3RIP*\FPDQGHIIHFWLYHGRVH
P6Y\HDU Q &7',YRORIP*\'/3RIP*\FPDQGHIIHFWLYH
GRVHP6Y\HDU Q &7',YRORIP*\'/3RIP*\FP
DQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHRIP6YDQG\HDU Q &7',YRORIP*\
'/3RIP*\FPDQGHIIHFWLYHGRVHRIP6Y&RPSDUHGZLWKWKHPHDQ
'5/OHYHORIGLIIHUHQW(XURSHDQFRXQWULHVRXUSURWRFROVVKRZHGIROORZLQJGRVH
UHGXFWLRQ\HDU\HDU\HDUDQG
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU ORFDO GRVH VXUYH\ VKRZHG WKDW GRVH UHGXFWLRQ LV SRVVLEOH LQ
FUDQLDO&7RIFKLOGUHQHVSHFLDOO\LQ\RXQJHUFKLOGUHQ
%
(YDOXDWLQJWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIXOWUDVRXQGLQ
FUDQLRV\QRVWRVLVDPRQJLQIDQWVXQGHU\HDU
11DMPL7HKUDQ,5
3XUSRVH9DULRXVLPDJLQJPRGDOLWLHVKDYHEHHQVWXGLHGIRUDFFXUDWHGLDJQRVLV
RI FUDQLRV\QRVWRVLV 8OWUDVRXQG LV D QRQLQYDVLYH DYDLODEOH ORZFRVW PRGDOLW\
DQGDERYHDOOLVIUHHRIVLGHHIIHFWV FRPSOLFDWLRQV 7KHFXUUHQWVWXG\KDVEHHQ
SHUIRUPHGWRDVVHVVWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIXOWUDVRXQGFRPSDUHGWR&7VFDQ
DVDJROGVWDQGDUGLQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIFUDQLRV\QRVWRVLV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )RUW\ IRXU LQIDQWV XQGHU \HDU ZHUH LQFOXGHG LQ WKH
VWXG\$OO RI WKH LQIDQWV ZHUH FOLQLFDOO\ VXVSHFWHG WR KDYH FUDQLRV\QRVWRVLV DQG
ZHUHUHIHUUHGWRGHSDUWPHQWRIUDGLRORJ\LQ7HKUDQFKLOGUHQPHGLFDOFHQWUH'DWD
ZHUHJDWKHUHGIURPWR,QIDQWVZHUHÀUVWVRQRJUDSKLFDOO\H[DPLQHGE\
DSDHGLDWULFUDGLRORJLVWDQGZHUHODWHUUHIHUUHGWRDQRWKHUSDHGLDWULFUDGLRORJLVWWR
H[DPLQH&7VFDQZLWK'UHFRQVWUXFWHGLPDJHVRIVNXOODVJROGVWDQGDUGPRGDOLW\
7KHVHFRQGUDGLRORJLVWZDVEOLQGHGWRUHVXOWVRIWKHXOWUDVRXQG
5HVXOWV6HYHQWHHQJLUOVDQGER\VZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHVWXG\7KHUHZDVQR
GLIIHUHQFH LQ KHDG FLUFXPIHUHQFH DQG DJH EHWZHHQ ER\V DQG JLUOV 6HQVLWLYLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVRIXOWUDVRXQGYHUVXV&7VFDQ
ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLI
IHUHQFHLQGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIXOWUDVRXQGEHWZHHQJLUOVDQGER\VDQGEHWZHHQ
LQIDQWVXQGHUPRQWKVDQGLQIDQWVROGHUWKDQPRQWKV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\RIXOWUDVRXQGKHOSVWRFRUUHFWO\UXOHRXWFUDQLRV\Q
RVWRVLVLQFOLQLFDOO\VXVSHFWHGFDVHVDQGWKXVFDQSUHYHQWXQQHFHVVDU\H[SRVXUH
RIKHDOWK\LQIDQWVWR&7VFDQLRQLVLQJUDGLDWLRQ
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJRIGLIIXVHD[RQDOLQMXU\LQDFXWHSHULRG
RISDHGLDWULFFUDQLRFHUHEUDOWUDXPD
,0HOQLNRY7$NKDGRY16HPHQRYD$3HWU\DLNLQ66LGRULQ6*XUҋ\DNRY
0RVFRZ58
3XUSRVH7KHWUXHGHJUHHRIEUDLQLQMXU\ZLWK'$,FDQEHIXOO\DVVHVVHGZLWK05,
ZKLFK LV PRUH VHQVLWLYH WR DFXWH GDPDJHV WKDQ RWKHU PHWKRGV RI UDGLRORJLFDO
GLDJQRVWLFV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HKDYHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGPHGLFDOUHFRUGVDQG
LPDJLQJÀQGLQJVRIFKLOGUHQZLWK'$,DJHGIURPWR\HDUVZKRDGPLWWHG
WRRXUKRVSLWDOLQ$FFRUGLQJWR*&6LQFDVHVZHFODVVLÀHGWUDXPDDVPLOG
LQFDVHVDVPRGHUDWHDQGLQFDVHVDVVHYHUH7KHDYHUDJH*&6VFRUHRIDOO
SDWLHQWVRQDGPLVVLRQZDV,QDOOFDVHV05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGLQDSHULRGIURP
VHYHUDOKRXUVWLOOGD\VIURPWKHPRPHQWRILQMXU\)RUWKLVVWXG\ZHXVHGWKHIROORZ
LQJSURWRFROVD[LDO776(7)/$,5DQG7))(VDJLWWDO7)/$,5DQG7))(
FRURQDO7)/$,5'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ ':(3,ZLWKHQFRGLQJGLUHFWLRQV
E VPPDQGE VPP LQD[LDOSURMHFWLRQZDVSHUIRUPHGLQSDWLHQWV
5HVXOWV6PDOOKDHPRUUKDJLFOHVLRQVRQZKLWHPDWWHURIEUDLQKHPLVSKHUHVZHUH
FODVVLÀHGDVJUDGH,OHVLRQV SDWLHQWV LQFDVHZKHQDGGLWLRQDOOHVLRQVLQFRUSXV
FDOORVXPZHUHSUHVHQWWKH\ZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVJUDGH,, SDWLHQWV FRPELQDWLRQRI
DERYHPHQWLRQHGOHVLRQVZLWKRQHVORFDWHGLQEUDLQVWHPZDVFODVVLÀHGDVJUDGH,,,
SDWLHQWV 3DWKRORJLFDOFKDQJHVUHYHDOHGZLWK':,LQSDWLHQWVZHUHW\SLFDO
K\SHULQWHQVHVLJQDORQ':PDSVDQGK\SRLQWHQVHVLJQDORQ$'&PDSV
&RQFOXVLRQ ,Q SDWLHQWV ZLWK VHYHUH FOLQLFDO GHFRPSHQVDWLRQ 05, PRUH RIWHQ
UHYHDOVOHVLRQVLQFRUSXVFDOORVXPDQGEUDLQVWHPZKLFKLQGLFDWHVWKDWJUDGH,,,
'$,LVSUHVHQW'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJSHUIRUPHGLQDFXWHSHULRGRISDHGLDWULF
FUDQLRFHUHEUDOWUDXPDFDQUHYHDOHLWKHUWKHSUHVHQFHRISHULIRFDORHGHPDRUWKH
SUHVHQFHRILVFKDHPLFIRUPRI'$,LQFDVHVZKHUHWKHKDHPRUUKDJHLQWKHOHVLRQV
DUHQRWGHWHFWHG
%
,PSDLUPHQWRIWKHEUDQFKHVRIWKHGHHSFHUHEUDOYHLQVRQQHRQDWDO
JHUPLQDOPDWUL[KDHPRUUKDJHXVLQJVXVFHSWLELOLW\ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
71LZD1$LGD<)XMLL72NDEH.1R]DZD<7DFKLEDQD-6KLEDVDNL
<RNRKDPD-3 WQLZD#NFPFMS
3XUSRVH*HUPLQDOPDWUL[KDHPRUUKDJH *0+ RFFXUVZLWKDK\SR[LFLVFKDHPLF
LQVXOWLQSUHWHUPLQIDQWV7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHUHODWLRQVKLS
EHWZHHQ*0+JUDGHDQGWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHEUDQFKHVRIWKHGHHSYHLQVLQ
LQIDQWVXVLQJVXVFHSWLELOLW\ZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ 6:,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLUW\WKUHHLQIDQWV JHVWDWLRQDODJHZHHNVFRUUHFW
HGDJHDW05,ZHHNV ZLWK*0+ZKRXQGHUZHQW6:,ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
DVVHVVHG*0+ZDVJUDGHGZLWKDVVRFLDWHGÀQGLQJJUDGH,QRLQWUDYHQWULFXODU
KDHPRUUKDJH,,*0+H[WHQGLQJLQWRWKHYHQWULFOH,,,LQWUDYHQWULFXODUKDHPRUUKDJH
ZLWKYHQWULFXODUHQODUJHPHQW9,SDUHQFK\PDOKDHPRUUKDJH9LVXDOLVDWLRQRIHDFK
EUDQFKRIWKHGHHSYHLQV LHDQWHULRUVHSWDODQWHULRUFDXGDWHWKDODPRVWULDWH
PHGLDO DQG ODWHUDO DWULDO LQWHUQDO FHUHEUDO DQG EDVDO YHLQV RQ 6:, ZDV UDWHG
XVLQJ D IRXUSRLQW VFDOH E\ WZR H[SHULHQFHG SDHGLDWULF QHXURUDGLRORJLVWV *0+
JUDGHZDVFRPSDUHGWRWKHVFRUHRIWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHHDFKGHHSYHLQEUDQFK
,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVDOVRDVVHVVHG
5HVXOWV7KHJUDGHRI*0+LQFOXGHG,LQ,,LQ,,,LQDQG,9LQ7KHUH
ZDV D VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFH LQ WKH VFRUH RI YLVXDOLVDWLRQ RI WKH WKDODPRVWULDWH
YHLQDPRQJWKHLQIDQWVDFFRUGLQJWRWKH*0+JUDGHV UHDGHUS
UHVSHFWLYHO\ WKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHYHLQLQLQIDQWVZLWK*0+JUDGH,9ZDVVLJ
QLÀFDQWO\LPSDLUHGFRPSDUHGWRWKDWZLWK*0+JUDGH, UHDGHUS
UHVSHFWLYHO\ ,QWHUREVHUYHU DJUHHPHQW ZDV PRGHUDWH WR H[FHOOHQW LQWUDFODVV
FRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ *0+ ZLWK SDUHQFK\PDO KDHPRUUKDJH PD\ EH DFFRPSDQLHG ZLWK
PRUHIUHTXHQWLPSDLUPHQWRIWKHEUDQFKHVRIWKHGHHSYHLQV
%
)UDFWLRQDODQLVRWURS\RIWKHIRHWDOPLGEUDLQDQGP\HOLQDWLRQ
5:RLWHN*.DVSULDQ0:HEHU3&%UXJJHU'3UD\HU9LHQQD$7
UDPRQDZRLWHN#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
5ROHRIIRHWDO05,LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIFHUHEHOODUPRUSKRVWUXFWXUH
DQGELRPHWU\
/0DQJDQDUR$7RPHL))LHUUR6%HUQDUGR99LQFL36ROOD]]R0(6HUJL
(6LOYHVWUL00DULQL5RPH,7 VLYYLD#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH2XUVWXG\DLPHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHUROHRIIRHWDO05,LQWKHHYDOXDWLRQ
RIFHUHEHOODUPRUSKRVWXFWXUHLQRUGHUWRGHÀQHPDLQELRPHWULFDOSDUDPHWHUVZKLFK
DOORZFHUHEHOODUSDWKRORJLHVGHWHFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)URP-XQHWR$SULOZHHQUROOHGZRPHQZLWK
SUHYLRXV86VXVSHFWRISRVWHULRUFUDQLDOIRVVDDOWHUDWLRQZHSHUIRUPHGIRHWDO
05,H[DPVRIFHUHEUDOUHJLRQ:HH[FOXGHGFDVHVZLWKGLDJQRVLVRI$UQROG&KLDUL
0DOIRUPDWLRQDQGRIVSDFHRFFXS\LQJQRWF\VWLFOLNHOHVLRQ:HHYDOXDWHGPDLQ
ELRPHWULFDOSDUDPHWHUVRIWKHFHUHEHOOXPYHUPLVPRUSKRORJ\DQGELRPHWU\,9YHQ
WULFOHEUDLQVWHPFHUHEHOODUSRQWLQHDQJOHFLVWHUQDPDJQDDQGWHQWRULXPLQVHUWLRQ
5HVXOWV )RHWDO 05, GHWHFWHG DOWHUDWLRQ RI WKH SRVWHULRU FUDQLDO IRVVD LQ
FDVHVWKXVH[FOXGLQJWKH86VXVSHFWRISDWKRORJLHVLQWKHUHPDLQLQJFDVHV
:HGLDJQRVHGLQFDVHV'DQG\:DONHUPDOIRUPDWLRQLQFDVHVSDUWLDO
YHUPLVDJHQHVLVLQYHUPLVK\SRSODVLD VHFRQGDU\WRF\VWLFOLNHOHVLRQV
LQFDVHVPDOURWDWLRQLQFDVHVFLVWHUQDPDJQDGLODWDWLRQLQFDVHV
SRQWRFHUHEHOODUK\SRSODVLDLQLVFKDHPLFKDHPRUUKDJLFOHVLRQVRIWKHFHU
HEHOOXPDWODVWLQFDVHVZHGLDJQRVHGDUHGXFWLRQRIWKHFUDQLDOFHUHEHOODU
ELRPHWU\05,UHVXOWVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKDXWRSV\LQFDVHVRXUUHVXOWVZHUH
FRQÀUPHGLQFDVHV 71DQG73 ZHUHPLVFRQÀUPHG
&RQFOXVLRQ)RHWDO05,RIWKHFHUHEUDOUHJLRQUHYHDOHGXVHIXODVWKLUGOHYHOGLDJ
QRVWLFWHFKQLTXHLQFDVHVRISRVWHULRUFUDQLDOIRVVDSDWKRORJLHVLQRUGHUWRFRQÀUP
DQGFKDUDFWHULVHWKHYDULRXVPDOIRUPDWLRQWKDQNVWRWKHPXOWLSODQHVRULHQWDWLRQ
ZKLFKDOORZVWRVWXG\ELRPHWU\DQGPRUSKRORJ\RIDOOWKHVWUXFWXUHVLQYROYHG
%
05OXQJYROXPHDVVHVVPHQWDWGLIIHUHQWWLPHVRIJHVWDWLRQIRU
SUHGLFWLRQRIVXUYLYDOQHHGIRU(&02WKHUDS\DQGGHYHORSPHQWRI
FKURQLFOXQJGLVHDVHLQIHWXVHVZLWKFRQJHQLWDOGLDSKUDJPDWLFKHUQLD
$:DOOH\R$'HEXV6.HKO&:HLVV626FK|QEHUJ76FKDLEOH
.$%XHVLQJ.:1HII0DQQKHLP'( DQQDZDOOH\R#XPPGH
3XUSRVH3XUSRVHRIWKHVWXG\ZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSUHGLFWLRQRIVXUYLYDOQHHG
IRUH[WUDFRUSRUHDOPHPEUDQHR[\JHQDWLRQ (&02 DQGGHYHORSPHQWRIFKURQLFOXQJ
GLVHDVH &/' LQSDWLHQWVZLWKFRQJHQLWDOGLDSKUDJPDWLFKHUQLD &'+ UHJDUGLQJD
FODVVLÀFDWLRQLQWKUHHGLIIHUHQWWLPHVRIJHVWDWLRQ !ZHHNVJHVWD
WLRQ E\DVVHVVLQJWKHREVHUYHGH[SHFWHG05IHWDOOXQJYROXPH RH05)/9
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVIRHWXVHVZLWK&'+ZHUHLQFOXGHGIRUGDWDDQDO\VLV
05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGDWGLIIHUHQWWLPHVRIJHVWDWLRQ IRHWXVHVIRHWXVHV
IRHWXVHV!ZHHNVJHVWDWLRQ XVLQJ7ZHLJKWHGKDOI)RXULHUDFTXLUHG
VLQJOHVKRWWXUERVSLQHFKR +$67( LPDJLQJ5HFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLF
FXUYH 52& DQDO\VLVZDVDSSOLHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSURJQRVWLFTXDOLW\RIWKHDV
VHVVPHQWRIWKHRH05)/9DWGLIIHUHQWWLPHVRIIHWDOJURZWK
5HVXOWV )RU DOO UHYLHZHG WLPHV RI JHVWDWLRQ WKH RH 05 )/9 \LHOGHG DOPRVW
HTXLYDOHQW VWDWLVWLFDOO\ VLJQLÀFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV IRU QHRQDWDO VXUYLYDO DQG QRQVXU
YLYDO S QHHGIRU(&02WKHUDS\ S DQGGHYHORSPHQWRI&/'
S RUQRW&RPSOHPHQWHGZHUHWKHVHUHVXOWVE\KLJKSURJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
IRUHDUO\OLNHZLVHIRUODWHWLPHVRIJHVWDWLRQ52&DQDO\VLVVKRZHGWKHKLJKHVWDUHD
XQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& IRUQHRQDWDOVXUYLYDO
&RQFOXVLRQ,QSDWLHQWVZLWK&'+WKHRH05)/9LVDYDOXDEOHSURJQRVWLFSD
UDPHWHUWRSUHGLFWQHRQDWDOPRUWDOLW\PRUELGLW\UHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHGHYHORSPHQW
RI&/'DQGQHHGIRU(&02WKHUDS\DOUHDG\LQHDUO\ZHHNVJHVWDWLRQ ZJ
DVZHOODVLQODWHUWLPHVRIJHVWDWLRQZLWKQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH,QUDWSXSVGLIIXVLRQDQLVRWURS\LPDJLQJKDVEHHQVKRZQWRGHPRQVWUDWH
SRVWQDWDOO\LQFUHDVLQJZKLWHPDWWHUP\HOLQDWLRQRIWKHEUDLQVWHPPRUHVHQVLWLYHO\
WKDQRWKHUFRQYHQWLRQDOLPDJLQJPRGDOLWLHV 3UD\HU'1HXURUDGLRORJ\ :H
LQYHVWLJDWHGZKHWKHUGLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJ '7, LQIRHWXVHVZLWKQRUPDO&16
GHYHORSPHQWLVFDSDEOHRIVKRZLQJFKDQJHVLQIUDFWLRQDODQLVRWURS\ )$ RUDS
SDUHQWGLIIXVLRQFRHIÀFLHQW $'& LQWKHPLGEUDLQFRUUHODWHGZLWKJHVWDWLRQDODJH
$QLQFUHDVLQJ)$ZRXOGSRLQWWRRQJRLQJSUHQDWDOP\HOLQDWLRQDVP\HOLQFRQVWUDLQV
GLIIXVLRQSHUSHQGLFXODUEXWQRWSDUDOOHOWRÀEUHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 'XULQJ FOLQLFDOO\ LQGLFDWHG 05, 7 LQ IRHWXVHV
*:QRUPDO&16GHYHORSPHQW 7:)6(VHTXHQFHVLQWKUHHRUWKRJRQDO
SODQHVRIWKHIRHWDOEUDLQDQGDQD[LDOVLQJOHVKRWHFKRSODQDUGLIIXVLRQWHQVRU
VHTXHQFH QRQFROOLQHDUGLIIXVLRQJUDGLHQWHQFRGLQJGLUHFWLRQV SHUSHQGLFXODU
WRWKHORQJD[LVRIWKHIRHWDOEUDLQVWHPZHUHDFTXLUHG$IWHUFRUHJLVWHULQJ7:)6(
D[LDOLPDJHVZLWKD[LDO)$FRORXUFRGHGPDSVDUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW 52, ZDVGUDZQ
LQWKHPLGEUDLQWRFDOFXODWH)$DQG$'&
5HVXOWV$VLJQLÀFDQWSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQJHVWDWLRQDODJH *$ DQG)$
ZDVIRXQG U S EXWQRVLJQLÀFDQWFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ*$
DQG$'& U S
&RQFOXVLRQ:HFRXOGVKRZDVLJQLÀFDQWSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQRI*$ZLWK)$EXWQRW
ZLWK$'&LQWKHIRHWDOPLGEUDLQ,QFUHDVLQJ)$GXULQJJHVWDWLRQFDQEHH[SODLQHGE\
LQFUHDVLQJP\HOLQDWLRQ7KHUHIRUH)$PHDVXUHPHQWVDUHFDSDEOHRIGHPRQVWUDWLQJ
SUHQDWDOP\HOLQDWLRQLQIRHWXVHVZLWKQRUPDO&16GHYHORSPHQWDQGPLJKWVHUYHWR
LQYHVWLJDWH DE QRUPDOP\HOLQDWLRQRUEUDLQVWHPFRPSUHVVLRQLQK\GURFHSKDOXV
RU&KLDUL,,PDOIRUPDWLRQV
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
%
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHXVHH[SHULHQFHDQGYDULDWLRQRI05,IRUQHRQDWDOEUDLQ
LPDJLQJLQOHYHOQHRQDWDOXQLWVLQ(QJODQG8.
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$QHOHFWURQLFTXHVWLRQQDLUHZDVVHQWWRQHRQDWRORJLVWV
ZRUNLQJLQDOOOHYHOXQLWV3DUWLFLSDQWVZHUHDVNHGTXHVWLRQVUHODWLQJWRWKHLU
H[SHULHQFHRI05,LQGLFDWLRQVIRULWVXVHSUDFWLFDODVSHFWV VHTXHQFHVWLPLQJ
DFFHVVDQGZDLW SURFHGXUHIRUUHSRUWLQJLPDJHVDQGXVHRI05,LQFRPSDULVRQ
WRRWKHUWHVWV
5HVXOWV Q RIWKHVXUYH\SRSXODWLRQUHSUHVHQWLQJDOOVHSDUDWHXQLWV
UHVSRQGHGKDGQRORFDOUHJLRQDOJXLGHOLQHV$VLJQLÀFDQWQXPEHU
FODLPHGWKDWODFNRIFOHDUJXLGHOLQHVFRQWULEXWHVWRSURORQJHGZDLWIRU05,8OWUD
VRXQGLVVWLOOXVHGDVWKHÀUVWOLQHLQWKHPDMRULW\RIXQLWV05,LVIUHTXHQWO\VHFRQG
OLQHEDVHGRQVFDQQHUORFDWLRQVWDIÀQJLVVXHVDQGFRVWFRQVLGHUSURORQJHG
ZDLWLQJ WLPHV WR EH D SUREOHP 7KHUH LV D VLJQLÀFDQW DVVRFLDWLRQ EHWZHHQ 05,
DYDLODELOLW\DQGODFNRIJXLGHOLQHVZLWKDIDLOXUHWRXWLOLVHWKHRSWLPDOVHTXHQFHV
DQGWLPLQJDVUHFRPPHQGHGLQWKHOLWHUDWXUH
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVLPSRUWDQWVXUYH\KLJKOLJKWVDFRQVLGHUDEOHYDULDWLRQLQSUDFWLFH
DQG DYDLODELOLW\ 7KLV PD\ EH UHVXOWLQJ LQ GHOD\HG LPDJLQJ LQ FDVHV ZKHUH 05,
LVYLWDOIRUGLDJQRVWLFDQGSURJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQDVZHOODVVXERSWLPDOXVHRID
PRGDOLW\WKDWKDVEHHQZHOOHVWDEOLVKHGLQWKHUHVHDUFKOLWHUDWXUH,WLVYLWDOWRHV
WDEOLVKDPRUHXQLIRUPDQGUREXVWQHRQDWDOQHXURLPDJLQJSDWKZD\DQGWKLVZRUN
LVDSRZHUIXOWRROIRUXQGHUVWDQGLQJFXUUHQWSUDFWLFHDQGZRUNLQJWRZDUGVDVHWRI
QDWLRQDOJXLGHOLQHVIRUWKH8.
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH ZKHWKHU ':05, LPSURYHV WKH GHWHFWLRQ UDWH RI SHOYLF
O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVLQDFRKRUWRISDWLHQWVZLWKPXVFOHLQYDVLYHEODGGHUFDQFHU
VHOHFWHGIRUUDGLFDOF\VWHFWRP\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 1LQHWHHQ FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV ZLWK PXVFOH LQYDVLYH
EODGGHU FDQFHU ZHUH HQUROOHG EHWZHHQ$SULO DQG 6HSWHPEHU 3DWLHQWV SU
HRSHUDWLYHO\XQGHUZHQW705,XVLQJFRQYHQWLRQDOVHTXHQFHVFRPELQHGZLWK
':05,5DGLFDOF\VWHFWRPLHVZLWKH[WHQGHGO\PSKDGHQHFWRP\ZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQ
DOOSDWLHQWV'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI':05,ZDVFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHKLVWRSDWKRORJLF
ÀQGLQJVDFFRUGLQJWRDFKDUWZKHUHWKHIROORZLQJQRGDOVWDWLRQVZHUHUHFRUGHG
ULJKWDQGOHIWVLGHFRPPRQLQWHUQDODQGH[WHUQDOLOLDFYHVVHOVULJKWDQGOHIWVLGH
REWXUDWRU\VWDWLRQSUHVDFUDOVWDWLRQ
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQ$'&YDOXHZDVRI APPVHFLQWKHQRGDOPHWD
VWDWLFJURXSDQG APPVHFLQWKHQRGDOQRQPHWDVWDWLFJURXS 3
VWDQGDUGHUURU&,WR 7KH$'&FXWRIIYDOXHREWDLQHG
E\WKH52&FXUYHLQRUGHUWRVKRZWKHEHVWVHSDUDWLRQEHWZHHQPHWDVWDWLFDQG
QRQPHWDVWDWLFO\PSKQRGHVZDV APPVHF:LWKWKLVWKUHVKROGYDOXH
WKHSDWLHQWEDVHGVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\339DQG139RIWKH'Z05,ZHUH
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ':05,PD\EHXVHGWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHPHWDVWDWLFIURPQRQPHWDVWDWLF
O\PSKQRGHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKJUDGHEODGGHUFDQFHU
8WLOLVDWLRQRIQHRQDWDOEUDLQ05,H[SHULHQFHYDULDWLRQDQG
LPSOLFDWLRQVDVXUYH\VWXG\RI8.OHYHOQHRQDWDOXQLWV
&6D\HU/9LWWD%ULJKWRQ8.+RYH8.
5RRP)
*HQLWRXULQDU\
66
*8JHPVDQGMHZHOV
0RGHUDWRUV
0$&RYD7ULHVWH,7
'<DNDU1LMPHJHQ1/
%
7HVWLVFDQFHU0'&7VWDJLQJZLWKKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOFRUUHODWLRQ
$02VERUQH'+DOSHQQ\3%XUNH':*RRG:&7RUUHJJLDQL
'XEOLQ,(/LPHULFN,( RVERUQHD#WFGLH
3XUSRVH7R DVVHVV ZKHWKHU WHVWLV FDQFHU PHWDVWDVLVHV WR VSHFLÀF VLWHV XVLQJ
0'&7DFFRUGLQJWRVSHFLÀFSULPDU\KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDOGLDJQRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$WHQ\HDUUHWURVSHFWLYHGDWDEDVHZDVFUHDWHGLQFOXGLQJ
SDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQWRUFKLHFWRP\IRUWHVWLFXODUWXPRXULQDVLQJOHLQVWLWXWLRQ$OO
SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW0'&7WKRUD[DEGRPHQSHOYLV7KHKLVWRORJ\RIWKHSULPDU\
WXPRXUDQGWKHORFDWLRQRIDQ\PHWDVWDVHVSUHVHQWRQ0'&7ZHUHFDWHJRULVHG
DQGUHFRUGHG'DWDDUHSUHVHQWHGDVPHGLDQ LQWHUTXDUWLOHUDQJH,45 DQGORJLVWLF
UHJUHVVLRQDQDO\VLVZDVXVHGWRLGHQWLI\ULVNIDFWRUV
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUHLGHQWLÀHG7KHPHGLDQ ,45 DJHZDV \HDUV
RISDWLHQWVKDGQRGDOPHWDVWDVLVDWWKHWLPHRIGLDJQRVLVZLWK
DQGKDYLQJSHOYLFDEGRPLQDODQGVXSUDGLDSKUDJPDWLFQRGDOPHWDVWDVLV
UHVSHFWLYHO\KDGVROLGRUJDQPHWDVWDVLVDWGLDJQRVLV,QGHSHQGHQWULVNIDF
WRUVIRUDEGRPLQDOQRGDOPHWDVWDVLVLQFOXGHGKDYLQJDWHUDWRPD +5
&,3 DQGKDYLQJDQ/'+RYHUDWGLDJQRVLV +5
&,3 ,QGHSHQGHQWULVNIDFWRUVIRUVXSUDGLDSKUDJPDWLFQRGDO
PHWDVWDVLVLQFOXGHGKDYLQJDPL[HGWXPRXU +53
DQGKDYLQJDћ+&*RYHUP/P/DWGLDJQRVLV +5&,
3
&RQFOXVLRQ5HVXOWVLQGLFDWHWKDWWKHSDWWHUQRIPHWDVWDVLVFDQYDU\DFFRUGLQJ
WRKLVWRORJLFDOVXEW\SHDQGVWDJLQJRIWXPRXU5HVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWSDWLHQWVZKR
SUHVHQWZLWKPL[HGWHVWLVWXPRXUVDQGSDWLHQWVZLWKDVHUXPћ+&*RYHUP/,8
P/VKRXOGXQGHUJR&7WKRUD[DVSDUWRIVWDJLQJRIGLVHDVH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
'LIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVVHOHFWHG
IRUUDGLFDOF\VWHFWRP\GHWHFWLRQUDWHRISHOYLFO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHV
5&D]]DWR5'HO9HVFRYR()DLHOOD)'ҋ$JRVWLQR5)UDQFHVFR*UDVVR
%%HRPRQWH=REHO5RPH,7
%
'RHV863,2HQKDQFHGGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05,HQKDQFHWKH
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIO\PSKQRGHVWDJLQJLQQRUPDOVL]HGO\PSK
QRGHVRISDWLHQWVVXIIHULQJSURVWDWHRUEODGGHUFDQFHU"
-0)URHKOLFK07ULDQWDI\OORX'&KRQJ$)OHLVFKPDQQ)'%LUNKDHXVHU
+&7KRHQ\%HUQH&+ IURHKOLFK#NOXVDSRWKHNHFK
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\GHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHG05, ':05,
DIWHUWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIXOWUDVPDOOVXSHUSDUDPDJQHWLFLURQR[LGHQDQRSDUWLFOHV
863,2 LQFUHDVHVWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\IRUWKHGHWHFWLRQRIPHWDVWDVHVLQQRUPDO
VL]HGO\PSKQRGHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKEODGGHUDQGRUSURVWDWHFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6HYHQW\ÀYHSDWLHQWV IPPHDQDJH ZLWKEODGGHU
Q SURVWDWHFDQFHU Q RUERWK Q ZHUHH[DPLQHGSHURSHUDWLYHO\RQD
705XQLWEHIRUHDQGDIWHUDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRI863,2 6LQHUHP*XHUEHW 7DQG
7ZHLJKWHG'76(6SDFHVHTXHQFHVRIWKHHQWLUHSHOYLVZHUHSHUIRUPHGEHVLGHV
D[LDO(3,':05,ZLWKEYDOXHV VHFPP DIWHUVSDVPRO\VLVZLWK
PJLYJOXFDJRQ6XVSLFLRXVK\SHULQWHQVLYHVWUXFWXUHVRQWKHSRVWFRQWUDVWKLJKE
LPDJHVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKPRUSKRORJLFDOSUHFRQWUDVWLPDJHVWRFKHFNZKHWKHU
WKH\FRUUHVSRQGHGWRO\PSKQRGHV(DFKYLVXDOLVHGO\PSKQRGHGHSHQGLQJRQLWV
PRUSKRORJ\ZDVUDWHGDVPDOLJQDQWRUEHQLJQ5HDGLQJVZHUHSHUIRUPHGE\WKUHH
LQGHSHQGHQWEOLQGHGUHDGHUVDQGFRPSDUHGWRKLVWRSDWKRORJ\
5HVXOWV,QSDWLHQWVO\PSKQRGHV PHDQQXPEHUSDWLHQW ZHUHUH
VHFWHGSRVLWLYHO\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHVZHUHGHWHFWHGLQSDWLHQWVZLWK
QRGHVEH\RQGDVKRUWD[LVGLDPHWHURIPP5HDGLQJVRQDSDWLHQWOHYHO\LHOGHG
DPHDQVHQVLWLYLW\RIVSHFLÀFLW\RISRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRIDQGGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI1RPHWDVWDVLV
DERYHDVKRUWD[LVGLDPHWHURIPPZDVPLVVHG
&RQFOXVLRQ863,2HQKDQFHG':05,DOORZVIRUKLJKHUGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQ
WKHGHWHFWLRQRIPHWDVWDVHVLQQRUPDOVL]HGO\PSKQRGHVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKEODGGHU
DQGRUSURVWDWHFDQFHU
%
8OWUDVPDOOSDUWLFOHVRILURQR[LGHHQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJRILVFKDHPLF
DFXWHUHQDOIDLOXUHLQDUDWPRGHORQDFOLQLFDO7VFDQQHU
+-0LFKDHO\8%HQFN8*RHWWPDQQ75XQJH%..UDHPHU6+DQHGHU
626FK|QEHUJ0DQQKHLP'( KHQULNPLFKDHO\#XPPGH
3XUSRVH7R DVVHVV LI WKH QRYHO XOWUDVPDOOSDUWLFOHRILURQR[LGH 3 FDQ EH
XVHGWRYLVXDOLVHLVFKDHPLFDFXWHUHQDOIDLOXUH ,$5) LQDUDWPRGHO
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,Q WKLV ,5%DSSURYHG VWXG\ /HZLVUDWV XQGHUZHQW
WUDQVLHQWVXUJLFDOFOLSSLQJRIWKHOHIWUHQDODUWHU\IRUPLQKDIWHUWKHVXUJLFDO
SURFHGXUHWKHUDWVZHUHLQMHFWHGPRONJ3 *XHUEHW DQG05LPDJLQJ
ZDVSHUIRUPHGDQRWKHUKDIWHUWKH3LQMHFWLRQ,PDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGRQD
FOLQLFDO7VFDQQHU 6LHPHQV7LP7ULR ZLWKDGHGLFDWHGHOHPHQWUDWFRLO 5DSLG
%LRPHGLFDO ZLWK7Z76(VHTXHQFHVLQFRURQDO 757(PVDFTXLVLWLRQ
WLPHPLQ DQGD[LDO PVPLQ RULHQWDWLRQZLWKLGHQWLFDODFTXLUHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
VSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQRI[[PPó6LJQDOWRQRLVHPHDVXUHPHQWV 615 ZHUH
SHUIRUPHGLQWKHFRUWH[PHGXOODDQGS\HORQRIWKH,$5)NLGQH\DQGWKHFRQWUDODWHUDO
NLGQH\DVLQWHUQDOFRQWURO,PPHGLDWHO\DIWHUWKH05H[DPWKHUDWVZHUHVDFULÀFHG
IRUKLVWRORJ\DQGLPPXQRODEHOOLQJ
5HVXOWV$SSDUHQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKH,$5)NLGQH\VDQGFRQWUROVZHUHHQ
FRXQWHUHG6LJQDOGURSZDVPDLQO\VHHQLQWKHPHGXOODRIWKH,$5)NLGQH\V7KH
615RIWKH,$5)YVFRQWUROFRUWH[YV S PHGXOODYV
S DQGS\HORQYV S ,QDOO,$5)NLGQH\VWKHKLVWRORJ\
FRQÀUPHGWKHSUHGRPLQDQWO\PHGXOODU\SUHVHQFHRIDEXQGDQWLURQDQG('SRVLWLYH
PDFURSKDJHVDQGW\SLFDOFKDQJHVRI,$5)ZKLOHEHLQJQRUPDOLQWKHFRQWUROJURXS
&RQFOXVLRQ 3 VHHPV WR EH D VXLWDEOH FRQWUDVW DJHQW WR QRQLQYDVLYHO\
GHWHFW,$5)LQDUDWPRGHOZLWKJRRGFRUUHODWLRQWRKLVWRORJ\7KLVVXJJHVWVWKDW
3HQKDQFHG05LPDJLQJKROGVSURPLVHIRUQRQLQYDVLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIUHQDO
SDUHQFK\PDOGLVHDVHV
%
6RQRHODVWRJUDSK\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKHQGRPHWULRVLVRIGLIIHUHQWORFDWLRQ
1$9RURQWVRYD9(*D]KRQRYD62&KXUNLQD(%6DYLQRYD
,$3RQRPRUHQNR$9=XEDUHY0RVFRZ58 YRUQDG#ENUX
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRDVVHVVWKHXVHIXOQHVVRI6( VRQRHODVWRJ
UDSK\ IRUHYDOXDWLRQRISDWLHQWVZLWKHQGRPHWULRVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSWV ZLWKSHOYLFSDLQG\VPHQRUUKRHD
XULQDU\V\PSWRPV UDQJH\HDUVZLWKVXVSHFWHGGLDJQRVLVRIHQGRPHWULRVLV
ZHUH UHIHUUHG IRU 6($OO SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW FRQYHQWLRQDO 86 DQG 6( RQ +,
9,6,21 3UHLUXV ZLWK DQ HQGRFDYLW\ WUDQVGXFHU 0+] IUHTXHQF\ DQG OLQHDU
WUDQVGXFHU IUHTXHQF\0+] :HXVHGPRGLÀHG7VXNXED6(FODVVLÀFDWLRQ
IRUHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH6(GDWDGLDJQRVWLFELRSV\GLDJQRVWLFODSDURVFRSLHV
VHSDUDWHGLDJQRVWLFVFUDSLQJZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKPRUSKRORJLFDOVWXG\RIWKH
UHFHLYHGPDWHULDO86GDWD FRQYHQWLRQDO%PRGH86DQJLRJUDSK\DQG6( ZHUH
DVVHVVHGE\FRPSDULQJWKHÀQGLQJVZLWKVXUJHU\UHVXOWVDQG05,GDWD86GDWD
ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGE\UDGLRORJLVWV,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRUHQ
GRPHWULRVLV6(VFRUHORFDWLRQRIHQGRPHWULRVLV XWHULQHRYDULXPFHUYL[XULQDU\
EODGGHUҋVZDOOVRIWWLVVXH HQGRPHWULRVLVORFDWLRQE\ZDOOVRIWKHXWHUXV05,GDWD
5HVXOWV 3DWKRPRUSKRORJLFDO H[DPLQDWLRQ UHYHDOHG HQGRPHWULRWLF F\VWV
HQGRPHWULRVLVWKHXWHULQHZDOOHQGRPHWULDOSRO\SVHQGRPHWULRVLVRIXULQDU\
EODGGHUҋVZDOODQGHQGRPHWULDOLQÀOWUDWLRQVRISHOYLFVRIWWLVVXH(QGRPHWULRVLV
ZDVFKDUDFWHULVHGE\UHYHUVHGVFRUHVFRUHDQGVFRUHRI7VXNXEDFODVVLÀFD
WLRQIRUOHVLRQVRQ6(6(VKRZHGJRRGWRPRGHUDWHLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRU
HQGRPHWULRVLVHYDOXDWLRQE\VFRULQJ N IRUHQGRPHWULRVLVORFDWLRQVE\
ZDOOVRIWKHXWHUXV N IRUORFDWLRQVRIHQGRPHWULRVLVE\RUJDQV N
SRRUWRPRGHUDWHLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWIRUHQGRPHWULRVLVHYDOXDWLRQ
E\05,GDWD N
&RQFOXVLRQ86ZLWK6(RIIHUVDQHZSRVVLELOLW\IRUGHÀQLWLRQRIHQGRPHWULRVLV
%
3RVVLELOLWLHVRIUHDOWLPHVRQRHODVWRJUDSK\LQORFDOVWDJLQJRI
HQGRPHWULDOFDQFHU
,6%HOR]HURYD9(*D]KRQRYD62&KXUNLQD$//R]RYDWRU
76.XUJDQVND\D$9=XEDUHY0RVFRZ58 QLEHOR]HURY#\DQGH[UX
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5HDOWLPHFRPSUHVVLRQHODVWRJUDSK\RIWKHSHULSKHUDO]RQHSURVWDWLF
FDQFHUWKHLPSDFWLQLPSURYLQJWKHGLDJQRVWLFDSSURDFK
*=DFKDURSRXORV6<DUPHQLWLV0DURXVVL*5 VS\URV\DUPHQLWLV#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH WKH SHUIRUPDQFH RI UHDOWLPH FRPSUHVVLRQ HODVWRJUDSK\
57&( LQWKHGLDJQRVWLFDSSURDFKRIWKHSHULSKHUDO]RQHSURVWDWLFFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV6L[W\WKUHHPDOHLQGLYLGXDOVZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKERWKE
PRGH7UDQV5HFWDO8OWUDVRXQG 7586 DQG57&(XVLQJD+LWDFKL3UHLUXVPDFKLQH
(ODVWLFSURSHUWLHVRIWKH3HULSKHUDO]RQHZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVQRUPDOWLIIQHVV
LQKRPRJHQHRXVLQFRQFOXVLYHIRFDOOHVLRQVRI,QFUHDVHGVWLIIQHVV7KH7586
ÀQGLQJVZHUHFDWHJRULVHGDVQRIRFDOOHVLRQLOOGHÀQHGIRFDOOHVLRQDQG
GHÀQLWHIRFDOOHVLRQ,QSDWLHQWVFRUHELRSVLHVZHUHWDNHQ7KHUHVW
SDWLHQWVKDGFRUHELRSVLHV8OWUDVRXQGÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGWRWKHUHVXOWV
RIWKHFRUHELRSVLHV
5HVXOWV1LQHWHHQRISDWLHQWV ZHUHIRXQGZLWKSRVLWLYHVSHFLPHQVIRU
SURVWDWLFFDQFHU6HQVLWLYLW\RISURVWDWHFDQFHUGHWHFWLRQZDV IRUWKH
57&(DQG IRUEPRGH758657&(VFRUHZDVIRXQGLQSDWLHQWV
RIZKRPQRQHIRXQGZLWKFDQFHUVFRUHZDVGHWHFWHGLQSDWLHQWVRIZKRP
KDGFDQFHUDQGVFRUHZDVDVVHVVHGLQSDWLHQWVRIZKRPKDGFDQFHU,Q
GHWHUPLQDWHVFRUH7586FDVHVZHUHIRXQGLQSDWLHQWVRIZKRPKDG57&(
VFRUHDQGQHJDWLYHFRUHELRSV\IRUFDQFHU
&RQFOXVLRQ57&(FRQVLGHUDEO\LPSURYHVWKHGLDJQRVWLF\LHOGRI7586LQGHWHFWLQJ
SHULSKHUDO]RQHSURVWDWLFFDQFHU
%
'LDJQRVWLFUROHRI&7SHUIXVLRQLQWKHPDQDJHPHQWRISDWLHQWV
DIIHFWHGE\SURVWDWHFDQFHU
02VLPDQL'%HOOLQL'&DUXVR'*LDQVDQWH$/DJKL/DWLQD,7
3XUSRVH 7R GHÀQH WKH UROH RI &7 SHUIXVLRQ LQ WKH HYDOXDWLRQ RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK
SUREDEOHSURVWDWHFDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$OOSDWLHQWVHQUROOHGXQGHUZHQW&7SHUIXVLRQH[DP
IROORZHG E\UDGLFDO SURVWDWHFWRP\ DQG KLVWRSDWKRORJLFDO DQDO\VLV RISURVWDWH,Q
SURVWDWLFDUHDVDYDLODEOHZHFDOFXODWHGQXPHULFDOYDOXHVRISHUIXVLRQLQGLFHV
EORRGÁRZEORRGYROXPHPHDQWUDQVLWWLPHDQGSHUPHDELOLW\VXUIDFHDUHDSURGXFW
E\SHUIXVLRQDQDO\VLVDQGWKHW\SHRIOHVLRQLQHDFKDUHDVE\LPPXQRKLVWRORJLFDO
DVVHVVPHQW7KHQZHKDGFRUUHODWHGWKHGDWDZHKDGGHÀQHGWKHWKUHVKROGYDO
XHVIRUHDFKSHUIXVLRQLQGH[DQGZHKDGREWDLQHGYDOXHVRIGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\
5HVXOWV$PRQJWKHDUHDVDIIHFWHGE\FDQFHUDQGQRQQHRSODVWLFDUHDVZHRE
WDLQHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVLQ%9DQG36 S 7KHDQDO\VLVUH
YHDOHGWKDWIRUWKHWKUHVKROGYDOXHVFRQVLGHUHG&7SKDVERXJKWKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\ 6S
DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 139 6SRIDQG139RIIRU36!P/
PLQJ6SRIDQG139RIIRU%)!P/PLQJ6SRIDQG
139RIIRU%9!P/J6SRIDQG139RIIRU077! VHF
&RQFOXVLRQ5HVXOWVREWDLQHGGHPRQVWUDWHGWKDW&7SFDQEHXVHGIRUWKHH[FOX
VLRQRISURVWDWHFDQFHULQGRXEWIXODUHDV KLJK139DQG6S
%
6HOHFWLYHDUWHULDOHPEROLVDWLRQRIV\PSWRPDWLFJLDQWUHQDO
DQJLRP\ROLSRPDHIÀFDF\FRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGORQJWHUPRXWFRPHV
0$ERX(O*KDU$(O$VVP\+5HIDLH7(O'LDVW\0DQVRXUD(*
PDERHOJKDU#\DKRRFRP
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHHIÀFDF\FRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGORQJWHUPRXWFRPHRIVHOHFWLYH
DUWHULDOHPEROLVDWLRQ 6$( IRUWUHDWPHQWRIJLDQWDQJLRP\ROLSRPD $0/ !FP
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVXUJLFDOUHFRUGVRISDWLHQWVZLWKJLDQW$0/PDQ
DJHG E\ 6$( EHWZHHQ DQG ZHUH UHYLHZHG 'DWD FROOHFWHG LQFOXGHG
SUHDQGSRVWWUHDWPHQW$0/VL]HFUHDWLQLQHOHYHOWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVFRPSOLFDWLRQV
DQGORQJWHUPFOLQLFDOVXFFHVV
5HVXOWV2XUVWXG\LQFOXGHGPHQDQGZRPHQRIWKHP KDGWXEHU
RXVVFOHURVLV 76 FRPSOH[7KHWXPRXUZDVELODWHUDOLQDQGPHDQVL]HRI
$0/OHVLRQVZDVFP,QGLFDWLRQVRI6$(ZHUHSUHRSHUDWLYHWRDYRLGULVNRI
KDHPRUUKDJHGXULQJQHSKUHFWRP\LQSDWLHQWVDQGWRVWRSVHYHUHKDHPDWXULDLQ
WKHUHPDLQLQJ$PRQJSDWLHQWVZLWKSUHVHUYHGNLGQH\VHDUO\FRPSOLFDWLRQV
RFFXUUHGLQLQFOXGLQJSRVWHPEROLVDWLRQV\QGURPHLQSDWLHQWUHFXUUHQW
KDHPDWXULDQHFHVVLWDWLQJQHSKUHFWRP\LQDQGDFXWHUHQDOIDLOXUHLQ(YHQWX
DOO\ SDWLHQWVSUHVHUYHGWKHLUNLGQH\VZLWKPHDQIROORZXSSHULRGRI
\HDUV'XULQJIROORZXSUDGLRORJ\VKRZHGGHFUHDVHLQVL]HRIWKHOHVLRQVLQ
RIFDVHVUHPDLQHGVWDEOHLQDQGLQFUHDVHGLQDQRWKHU'XULQJIROORZXS
RISDWLHQWVKDGUHFXUUHQWKDHPDWXULDZKLFKPDQDJHGFRQVHUYDWLYHO\DQGDOO
SDWLHQWVKDGDVWDEOHVHUXPFUHDWLQLQH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH3RVVLELOLWLHVRIVRQRHODVWRJUDSK\ 6( LQORFDOVWDJLQJRIHQGRPHWULDO
FDQFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSWVZLWKSURYHQ(&XQGHUZHQWUHDOWLPHVRQRHODV
WRJUDSK\EHIRUHVXUJHU\ DJHUDQJH\R 86H[DPVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQ+,
9,6,213UHLUXVDQG+,9,6,21 +LWDFKL0HGLFDO&RUSRUDWLRQ :HXVHG),*2
FODVVLÀFDWLRQIRUORFDOVWDJLQJ(&86GDWDZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKÀQDOKLVWRSDWKRORJ\
7KHVWXG\ZDVUHFRUGHGDQGHYDOXDWHGE\LQGHSHQGHQWUHDGHUV,QWHUREVHUYHU
DJUHHPHQWIRUWXPRXUҋVORFDWLRQE\ZDOOV DQWHULRUSRVWHULRUIXQGXVULJKWOHIW
P\RPHWULDOLQYDVLRQ OHVVWKDQôPRUHWKDQô FHUYLFDODQGFDSVXODULQYROYHPHQW
ZHUHVWXGLHG6HQVLWLYLW\RI6(LQORFDOVWDJLQJZDVHVWDEOLVKHG
5HVXOWV$OO SDWLHQWV KDYH EHHQ RSHUDWHG WRWDO K\VWHUHFWRPLHV UDGLFDO
K\VWHUHFWRPLHV ZLWK O\PSK QRGH GLVVHFWLRQ +LVWRSDWKRORJ\ UHYHDOHG VWDJH
,$VWDJH,%VWDJH,,$,,%VWDJH,,,$VWDJH7KHVHQVLWLYLW\RI6(IRUORFDO
VWDJLQJRI(&VWDJH,$VWDJH,%VWDJH,,$VWDJH,,%
VWDJH,,,$7KH.DSSDYDOXHEHWZHHQ6(DQGORFDWLRQE\ZDOOVZDVSRRU
NUDQJHGWR EHWZHHQ6(DQGP\RPHWULDOLQYDVLRQZDVJRRG NUDQJHG
WR DQGEHWZHHQ6(DQGFHUYLFDOLQYDVLRQZDVSRRUWRR N 6(
LQFUHDVHGWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RI86 IURPWR DQGVSHFLÀFLW\ IURPWR
LQORFDOVWDJLQJ(&
&RQFOXVLRQ,QFOXVLRQRI6(LQFRPSOH[XOWUDVRXQGVFDQQLQJPD\KHOSWRHYDOXDWH
P\RPHWULDOLQYDVLRQLQSWVZLWK(&
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ6$(RIJLDQWUHQDO$0/VFDQEHGRQHVDIHO\WRVWRSEOHHGLQJLQPDQ\
FDVHV$GGLWLRQDOWUHDWPHQWPD\EHQHFHVVDU\LQRISDWLHQWVDQGSUHVHUYDWLRQ
RILQYROYHGNLGQH\VLVDPHQDEOHLQRIFDVHV
%
(YDOXDWLRQRIG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05XURJUDSK\ '&(
058 IRUWKHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHVSOLWUHQDOIXQFWLRQLQFKURQLF
DQGLQWHUPLWWHQWXULQDU\REVWUXFWLRQLQFRPSDULVRQWRGLXUHWLFUHQDO
VFLQWLJUDSK\ '56 UHVXOWVRIDSURVSHFWLYHPXOWLFHQWUHVWXG\
0&ODXGRQ('XUDQG)*XLOOHPLQ(0LFDUG1*UHQLHU
3&KDXPHW5LIIDXG&3DVTXLHU*6HEDJ.&KDXPRLWUH
9DQGRHXYUHOHV1DQF\)56WUDVERXUJ)5%RUGHDX[)5
/H.UHPOLQ%LFHWUH)53DULV)50DUVHLOOH)5 PFODXGRQ#FKXQDQF\IU
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHG\QDPLFFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05XURJUDSK\ '&(058 DQG
UHQDOVFLQWLJUDSK\IRUGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHVSOLWUHQDOIXQFWLRQ 65) LQFKURQLFDQG
LQWHUPLWWHQWXULQDU\REVWUXFWLRQ 82
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FKLOGUHQ DQG DGXOWV SUHVHQWLQJ ZLWK FKURQLF RU
LQWHUPLWWHQW82ZHUHLQFOXGHGLQFHQWUHV'&(058FRQVLVWHGRIDG\QDPLF
FRURQDO 7ZHLJKWHG VHTXHQFH UHSHDWHG IRU PLQXWHV DIWHU DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI
GLXUHWLFVDQG*GFKHODWH PONJ 'LXUHWLFUHQDOVFLQWLJUDSK\ZDVSHUIRUPHG
ZLWKLQ WZR PRQWKV 058 DQG VFLQWLJUDSK\ GDWD IURP SDWLHQWV ZHUH MXGJHG
LQDEOLQGUHYLHZE\DSDQHORISUDFWLWLRQHUVWKHQH[SHUWVRIHDFKVSHFLDOW\
UDGLRORJ\DQGQXFOHDUPHGLFLQH)RU'&(058VLJQDOLQWHQVLW\WLPHFXUYHVZHUH
REWDLQHGIURP52,VRQUHQDOSDUHQFK\PDDQGDRUWD65)ZDVFDOFXODWHGVXFFHV
VLYHO\E\WKHDUHDXQGHUWKHFXUYH $8& DQG3DWODN5XWODQG 35 PHWKRGVDIWHU
QRUPDOLVDWLRQE\SDUHQFK\PDOYROXPH5HSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGIRULQWUDDQG
LQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQW
5HVXOWV5HSURGXFLELOLW\ZDVJRRGWRH[FHOOHQWIRUERWKPHWKRGVZLWKѣYDOXHV
UDQJLQJIURPWRIRUVFLQWLJUDSK\DQGWRIRU'&(058DQGLP
SURYHGZLWKWKHH[SHUWUHYLHZ$WWKHJURXSOHYHOHTXLYDOHQFHEHWZHHQ'&(058
DQGVFLQWLJUDSK\ZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGIRUFDOFXODWLRQRI65)ZLWKERWK35 S
DQG$8& S PHWKRGV7KHGLVWULEXWLRQRIGLIIHUHQFHVIROORZHGD*DXVVLDQ
ODZ&,>@8QGHUHVWLPDWLRQRI65)E\'&(058ZDVREVHUYHGLQ
VHYHUHK\GURQHSKURVLV
&RQFOXVLRQ65)HVWLPDWHGE\'&(058LQREVWUXFWHGNLGQH\VZDVUHSURGXF
LEOHDQGHTXLYDOHQWWRWKDWRQHPHDVXUHGE\ZLWKUHQDOVFLQWLJUDSK\DWWKHJURXS
OHYHOEXWZLWKLQGLYLGXDOGLIIHUHQFHV'&(058SURYLGHVERWKPRUSKRORJLFDQG
IXQFWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQLQ82
5RRP)
%UHDVW
66
05,GLDJQRVLVDQGVXUJLFDOVHWWLQJV
0RGHUDWRUV
0/REEHV0DDVWULFKW1/
56DOYDGRU%DUFHORQD(6
%
3RWHQWLDORI05PDPPRJUDSK\IRUWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRI
LQWUDGXFWDOSDSLOORPDV
0'LHW]HO5=RXEL+3%XUPHLVWHU7*URHVFKHO
05*DMGD,%5XQQHEDXP:$.DLVHU3$7%DOW]HU
-HQD'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH (YHQ XSRQ FRUH ELRSV\ DFFXUDWH FODVVLÀFDWLRQ RI EHQLJQ LQWUDGXFWDO
SDSLOORPDV ,3 FDQEHGLIÀFXOW$FFRUGLQJO\,3DUHVWLOOIUHTXHQWO\VXUJLFDOO\UHVHFWHG
7KHUHIRUH DFFXUDWH DVVHVVPHQW RI ,3 E\ 05PDPPRJUDSK\ ZRXOG SRWHQWLDOO\
RSWLPLVH SDWLHQW PDQDJHPHQW +RZHYHU WKH IHZ LQYHVWLJDWLRQV DVVHVVLQJ 05
PDPPRJUDSK\RI,3LQFOXGHGVPDOOSDWLHQWFROOHFWLYHVDQGRYHUDOODFFXUDF\RIWKLV
PRGDOLW\UHJDUGLQJWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRI,3LVVWLOOXQNQRZQ:HSHUIRUPHG
WKLV LQYHVWLJDWLRQ WR DQDO\VH PRUSKRORJLF DQG G\QDPLF 05PDPPRJUDSK\ SUR
ÀOHVRI,3LQGHSWKDQGWRLGHQWLI\WKHRYHUDOODFFXUDF\RI05PDPPRJUDSK\IRU
GLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRI,3IURPPDOLJQDQWEUHDVWOHVLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDO&RQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVUHFHLYLQJVWDQGDUGLVHG05PDPPRJ
UDSK\ VWDQGDUGLVHGVFDQQLQJSURWRFROVG\QDPLF7Z*5(EHIRUHDIWHU*G'73$
> PPRONJ%:@ 7Z76( ZLWK VXEVHTXHQW VXUJLFRSDWKRORJLFDO YHULÀFDWLRQ
ZHUHHQUROOHG)RUWKHGHWDLOHGDVVHVVPHQWRIPRUSKRORJLFDQGG\QDPLFSURÀOHV
WZRH[SHULHQFHGUDGLRORJLVWV !H[DPLQDWLRQVEOLQGHGWRVXUJLFRSDWKRORJLFDO
YHULÀFDWLRQ SHUIRUPHGSURVSHFWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRI05PDPPRJUDSK\LQFRQVHQVXV
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
DSSO\LQJSUHGHÀQHG05PDPPRJUDSK\GHVFULSWRUV2XWRIWKLVGDWDEDVHDOO
SDWLHQWV VKRZLQJ ,3 Q RU PDOLJQDQW EUHDVWOHVLRQV Q XSRQ VXUJLFR
SDWKRORJLFDOYHULÀFDWLRQZHUHIXUWKHUHYDOXDWHGVWDWLVWLFDOO\8QLYDULDWH DVVRFLDWLRQ
RIVLQJOHGHVFULSWRUVZLWK,3EUHDVWFDQFHUFRQWLQJHQF\WDEOHVVWDWLVWLFV DVZHOODV
PXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VHVZHUHSHUIRUPHGWRLGHQWLI\DFFXUDWHGHVFULSWRUFRPELQDWLRQV
&KLVTXDUHG$XWRPDWLF,QWHUDFWLRQ'HWHFWLRQ >&+$,'@ DQG RYHUDOODFFXUDF\ RI
05PDPPRJUDSK\ IRU GLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLV RI ,3 YV PDOLJQDQW EUHDVWOHVLRQV
ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQ UHFHLYHURSHUDWLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFV >52&@ DUHDXQGHUWKH
52&FXUYH>$8&@
5HVXOWVRI05PDPPRJUDSK\GHVFULSWRUVZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHG
ZLWK,3 Q 3 $FFXUDF\RIVLQJOHGHVFULSWRUV RGGҋVUDWLR>25@
FRXOG EH IXUWKHU LQFUHDVHG E\ GHVFULSWRUFRPELQDWLRQV GRXEOHFRPELQDWLRQ
25WULSOHFRPELQDWLRQ25 :LWK$8& FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDOO
3 ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQLGHQWLÀHGKLJKRYHUDOODFFXUDF\RI05
PDPPRJUDSK\IRUWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOGLDJQRVLVRI,3
&RQFOXVLRQ 'HWDLOHG DVVHVVPHQW RI 05PDPPRJUDSK\ DOORZV SUHFLVH FKDU
DFWHULVDWLRQ RI EHQLJQ LQWUDGXFWDOSDSLOORPDV DQG DFFXUDWH GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ IURP
PDOLJQDQWEUHDVWOHVLRQV
%
5HDGLQJ05PDPPRJUDSK\EHWZHHQWKHOLQHVLVWKH´FRQVWDQW
VKDUSQHVVµDXVHIXOWRROIRUSUHGLFWLRQRIEHQLJQLW\",QWURGXFWLRQ
GLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\DQGVXEJURXSDQDO\VLVRIDQHZGHVFULSWRU
0'LHW]HO5=RXEL7*URHVFKHO+3%XUPHLVWHU0*DMGD,%5XQQHEDXP
:$.DLVHU3$7%DOW]HU-HQD'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH$FFXUDWHFODVVLÀFDWLRQRIEHQLJQOHVLRQVLQ05PDPPRJUDSK\ 050
FDQEHFKDOOHQJLQJDQGIXUWKHUGHVFULSWRUVPLJKWKHOSWRVROYHWKLVSUREOHP:H
SHUIRUPHGDUHWURVSHFWLYHFDVHUHYLHZDQGLGHQWLÀHG´FRQVWDQWVKDUSQHVVµ &6 DV
DXVHIXOQHZ050GHVFULSWRUWRSUHGLFWEHQLJQLW\3RVLWLYH&6LVGHÀQHGDVDOHVLRQ
ZLWKVPRRWKDQGVKDUSPDUJLQVZKLFKDUHFRQVLVWHQWO\SUHVHQWGXULQJWKHZKROH
G\QDPLFVHULHVIURPWKHÀUVWWRWKHODVWVFDQ7KHQZHFRQGXFWHGDSURVSHFWLYH
FURVVVHFWLRQDOLQYHVWLJDWLRQWRDQDO\VHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RI&6IRUGLIIHUHQWLDO
GLDJQRVLVRIEHQLJQYVPDOLJQDQWOHVLRQV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV H[FOXVLRQ EUHDVWWKHUDS\
PRQWKV EHIRUH 050 ZLWK KLVWRORJLFDOO\ YHULÀHG EUHDVWOHVLRQV LPDJHG E\
050DFFRUGLQJWRVWDQGDUGSURWRFROV G\QDPLF*5(7ZVFDQVDIWHUFRQWUDVW
DJHQW>PPRONJEZ*G'73$@DWPLQXWHLQWHUYDOVRYHUPLQXWHV $OO050
ZHUHUHDGSURVSHFWLYHO\E\WZRH[SHULHQFHG !050 DQGEOLQGHGUHDGHUVLQ
FRQVHQVXV)LQDOO\&6ZDVFRUUHODWHGZLWKKLVWRORJ\UHVXOWV FURVVWDEOHVѯWHVW
5HVXOWV&6ZDVDVLJQLÀFDQWSUHGLFWRURIEHQLJQLW\ 3! ,WZDVW\SLFDOO\
DVVRFLDWHGZLWKÀEURDGHQRPDVDQGSDSLOORPDV )DOVHQHJDWLYH
FDVHVZHUHUDUHDQG&6DFFXPXODWHGZLWKLQLQYDVLYHSDSLOODU\ DQGLQYDVLYH
PXFLQRXV FDQFHUV DV ZHOO DV ORZJUDGH WXPRXUV * 2YHUDOO
DFFXUDF\UHYHDOHGVHQVLWLYLW\RI FRQÀGHQFHLQWHUYDO&,
KLJK VSHFLÀFLW\ &, 2GGVUDWLR &, DQG
SRVLWLYHOLNHOLKRRGUDWLR /&,
&RQFOXVLRQ´&RQVWDQWVKDUSQHVVµVL[IROGLQFUHDVHVWKHOLNHOLKRRGRIEHQLJQLW\LQ
0507KLVDFFXUDWH050GHVFULSWRULVW\SLFDOO\VHHQLQÀEURDGHQRPDVDQGSDSLO
ORPDVZKHUHDVIDOVHSRVLWLYHVDUHXQFRPPRQDQGLQFOXGHUDUHKLVWRSDWKRORJLHV
LQYDVLYHSDSLOODU\PXFLQRXVFDUFLQRPD DQGORZJUDGHFDQFHUV *
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJIRUDVVHVVLQJD[LOODU\O\PSKQRGH
VWDWXVLQEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
(%XÀ0&RVWDQWLQL3%HOOL***LDUGLQD35LQDOGL*)UDQFHVFKLQL
50DVHWWL/%RQRPR5RPH,7 UHDJDQGXV#DOLFHLW
3XUSRVH$OWKRXJKPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, LVLQGLFDWHGIRUSUHRSHUDWLYH
EUHDVWFDQFHUVWDJLQJDVVHVVPHQWRIWKHD[LOODHLVQRWURXWLQHO\SHUIRUPHG2XU
DLPZDVWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHDELOLW\RI05,LQSUHGLFWLQJD[LOODU\O\PSKQRGHVWDWXV
LQEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:ULWWHQLQIRUPHGFRQVHQWDQGERDUGDSSURYDOZHUHRE
WDLQHG$UHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLVRIEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJ05,EHIRUH
VXUJHU\IURP-DQXDU\WR-XQHZDVSHUIRUPHG7ZRH[SHULHQFHGUDGL
RORJLVWVEOLQGHGWRWKHKLVWRSDWKRORJLFÀQGLQJVDQDO\VHGVL]H VKRUWD[LVORQJHVW
D[LVWRVKRUWHVWD[LVUDWLR DQGPRUSKRORJLFDOIHDWXUHV SUHVHQFHDEVHQFHRIIDWW\
KLOXPDEQRUPDOFRUWH[ RID[LOODU\O\PSKQRGHV3DWLHQWVZHUHGLYLGHGLQWRWZR
JURXSVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHÀQDOSDWKRORJLFD[LOODU\VWDWXVSUHVHQFHDEVHQFHRIO\PSK
QRGHVPHWDVWDVHV6HQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRI
05,LQSUHGLFWLQJO\PSKQRGHVWDWXVZHUHREWDLQHG
5HVXOWV2XWRIEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWVZHUHHQUROOHG+LVWRSDWKRORJLFUH
VXOWVUHYHDOHGQRGHSRVLWLYHSDWLHQWV/\PSKQRGHLQYROYHPHQWZDVVXVSHFWHG
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
LQRXWRIFDVHV7KHUHZHUHWUXHSRVLWLYHREVHUYDWLRQVIDOVHSRVLWLYH
IDOVHQHJDWLYHDQGWUXHQHJDWLYH7KH05,VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\SRVLWLYH
SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH DQG QHJDWLYH SUHGLFWLYH YDOXH LQ SUHGLFWLQJ D[LOODU\ PHWDVWDVHV
ZHUHDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\7KH05,SRVLWLYHSUHGLFWLYH
YDOXH UHDFKHV LI ZH FRQVLGHU WKH DVVRFLDWLRQ RI DW OHDVW WZR ÀQGLQJV DV
VXVSLFLRXVIRUQRGDOLQYROYHPHQW
&RQFOXVLRQ$OWKRXJKSDWKRORJLFHYDOXDWLRQRIO\PSKQRGHVVWLOOUHPDLQVPDQGD
WRU\LQDOOSDWLHQWVDWULVNIRUQRGDOLQYROYHPHQW05,PD\EHXVHIXOLQSUHGLFWLQJ
D[LOODU\O\PSKQRGHPHWDVWDVHV
%
3RWHQWLDOUROHRI05,LQDVVHVVLQJWKHQHHGIRUVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGH
ELRSV\LQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJFRQWUDODWHUDOSURSK\ODFWLFPDVWHFWRP\
9)UHLWDV6.XONDUQL$6FDUDQHOR.%XNKDQRY6*KDL3&U\VWDO
7RURQWR21&$
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH DFFXUDF\ RI 05, LQ GHWHFWLQJ RWKHUZLVH RFFXOW EUHDVW
PDOLJQDQF\LQZRPHQXQGHUJRLQJFRQWUDODWHUDOSURSK\ODFWLFPDVWHFWRP\ &30
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :LWK ,5% DSSURYDO ,QVWLWXWLRQDO GDWDEDVH UHYLHZ ZDV
SHUIRUPHGWRLGHQWLI\SDWLHQWVZLWKQHZO\GLDJQRVHGXQLODWHUDOEUHDVWFDUFLQRPD
ZKRXQGHUJR&30LQ6L[W\SDWLHQWVPHWLQFOXVLRQFULWHULDWKDWZHUH
UHVWULFWHGWRFDVHVZLWKPDPPRJUDSK\DQGEUHDVW05,SHUIRUPHGQRWPRUHWKDQ
VL[PRQWKVEHIRUH&305HWURVSHFWLYHUHYLHZRI05,VWXGLHVZDVSHUIRUPHGE\
WZRH[SHULHQFHGUHDGHUV$FFXUDF\RI05,LQGHWHFWLQJRWKHUZLVHRFFXOWEUHDVW
PDOLJQDQF\ZDVHYDOXDWHG05,VSHFLÀFLW\DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHV 139
ZHUHFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV7KHPHGLDQSDWLHQWDJHDWWKHWLPHRISURSK\ODFWLFPDVWHFWRP\ZDV
\HDUV UDQJH\HDUV %UHDVWFDUFLQRPDZDVGLDJQRVHGLQRISDWLHQWV
RI 7KHUHZDVRQHFDVHRILQYDVLYHGXFWDOFDUFLQRPDDQGWZRFDVHVRIGXFWDO
FDUFLQRPDLQVLWX '&,6 7KHLQYDVLYHFDQFHUZDVPP71WXPRXUDQGLWZDV
FRQÀGHQWO\LGHQWLÀHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\E\ERWKUHYLHZHUV05,LQERWKFDVHVRI'&,6
ZDVQHJDWLYH6SHFLÀFLW\RI05,IRUGHWHFWLRQRIPDOLJQDQF\ZDVDQG139
ZDV05,139IRULQYDVLYHGLVHDVHZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ05,PD\EHDUHOLDEOHWHVWLQH[FOXGLQJFRQWUDODWHUDOLQYDVLYHEUHDVW
FDUFLQRPDLQSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJ&30%DVHGRQWKHYHU\KLJK139RI05,LQ
RXUVHULHVDQ\LHOGRIVHQWLQHOO\PSKQRGHELRSV\LQSDWLHQWV XQGHUJRLQJ&30
VKRXOGEHUHHYDOXDWHG
%
%UHDVW05,DVDSRWHQWLDOQHZELRPDUNHUWRDVVHVVWKHD[LOODU\
WXPRXUORDGLQSDWLHQWVZLWKQHZO\GLDJQRVHGEUHDVWFDQFHULQLWLDO
GDWDXVLQJFRPSXWHUDVVLVWHGGLDJQRVLV &$'[
0'LHW]HO++DEUHFKW5=RXEL+3%XUPHLVWHU0*DMGD,%5XQQHEDXP
:$.DLVHU3$7%DOW]HU-HQD'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
'HWHFWLRQRILQFLGHQWDOYHUWHEUDOIUDFWXUHVE\05ORFDOLVHULQEUHDVW
LPDJLQJ
$%D]]RFFKL36SLQQDWR**DU]LOOR)&LFFDUHVH))X]]L/0LJOLR
/6DQWLOOL60LJQDQL%RORJQD,7 JJDU]LOOR#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH9HUWHEUDOIUDFWXUHV 9)V DUHWKHKDOOPDUNRIRVWHRSRURVLVDQGWKHGLDJ
QRVLVRID9)PD\EHHVVHQWLDOLQWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIZRPHQERQHKHDOWKVWDWXV
2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRUHWURVSHFWLYHO\HYDOXDWH05ORFDOLVHU 05ORF RIEUHDVW05,
H[DPLQDWLRQVDVDSRWHQWLDOWRROLQWKHGHWHFWLRQRIRVWHRSRURWLF9)V
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05ORFVDJLWWDOLPDJHVRIEUHDVW05,ZHUHUHYLHZHG
E\WKUHHH[SHUWVNHOHWDOUDGLRORJLVWVZLWKDVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHGLDJQRVWLFDSSURDFK
WR GHWHFW 9)V$QDPQHVLV DQG GDWD RI SDWLHQWV ZHUH FROOHFWHG DV ZHOO DV 05,
RULJLQDO UHSRUWV ZHUH UHDG DW WKH HQG RI WKH 05ORF HYDOXDWLRQ 2WKHU DYDLODEOH
LPDJLQJH[DPVZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGWRDVVHVVSRWHQWLDOPHWDVWDWLFLQYROYHPHQWRI
ERQHLQDOOSDWLHQWV
5HVXOWV IHPDOHSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJ05,IRURQFRORJLFUHDVRQV
DQG IRUQRQRQFRORJLFDLPVZHUHUHFUXLWHGLQWKHVWXG\ DJH
\HDUROG 05ORFZHUHFRQVLGHUHGWREHLQDGHTXDWHIRUGLDJQRVWLF
SXUSRVHDQGWKHVHZHUHH[FOXGHGIURPWKHDQDO\VLV,Q SDWLHQWV
05ORFDOORZHGWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIYHUWHEUDOERGLHVEHWZHHQ7DQGWKHXSSHUOXP
EDUVSLQH // 05ORFZDVDEOHWRGHWHFW9)VLQ SDWLHQWV9)V
ZHUHQHLWKHUUHSRUWHGQRUSUHYLRXVO\NQRZQLQWKHFOLQLFDOKLVWRU\RI
SDWLHQWV0RUHRYHUQRPHQWLRQRI9)VZDVIRXQGLQDOO05,EUHDVWUHSRUWV,Q
SDWLHQWV05ORFFRXOGDOVRLGHQWLI\YHUWHEUDOPHWDVWDVHVDVGRFXPHQWHG
E\RWKHUDSSURSULDWHLPDJLQJPHWKRGV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QWKHIHPDOHSRSXODWLRQVXEPLWWHGWREUHDVW05,DV\VWHPDWLFHYDOX
DWLRQRI05ORFFDQEHSURSRVHGWRRIIHUDGGLWLRQDOFOLQLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQLQRUGHUWR
SUHYHQWXQUHFRJQLVHG9)V
%
$UHPDPPRJUDSKLFIROORZXSÀQGLQJVLQGHHGPRUHSURQRXQFHG
DIWHULQWUDRSHUDWLYHUDGLRWKHUDS\IRUEUHDVWFDQFHU"6XEJURXS
DQDO\VLVRIDUDQGRPLVHGWULDO 7$5*,7$
'%(QJHO$6FKQLW]HU8.UDXV7LHIHQEDFKHU
(%ODQN-%UDGH):HQ]626FK|QEHUJ.:DVVHU
0DQQKHLP'( GRURWKHHHQJHO#PHGPDXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH ,QWUDRSHUDWLYH UDGLRWKHUDS\ ,257 LV LQFUHDVLQJO\ XVHG IRU EUHDVW
FRQVHUYLQJ WKHUDS\ %&7 RIIHULQJ D VDIH DOWHUQDWLYH WR FRQYHQWLRQDO %&7 IRU
VHOHFWHGSDWLHQWVZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHU$VXVLQJ,257LQFUHDVHVVWUXFWXUDOFKDQJHV
LQWKHWXPRXUEHGDVSUHYLRXVO\REVHUYHGLQQRQUDQGRPLVHGSDWLHQWJURXSVZH
DLPHGWRIXUWKHUYDOLGDWHWKHVHUHVXOWVIRUWKHÀUVWWLPHLQDUDQGRPLVHGVXEJURXS
RISDWLHQWVIURPWKHLQLWLDOLQWHUQDWLRQDO7$5*,7$WULDO
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,QFOXGLQJ SDWLHQWV SDWLHQWV UHFHLYHG %&7 ZLWK
,257 ORZHQHUJ\[UD\V DQGSDWLHQWVKDG%&7ZLWKVWDQGDUGZKROHEUHDVW
UDGLRWKHUDS\VHUYHGDVFRQWUROVIROORZXSVRISRVWRSHUDWLYHPDPPRJUDPV
PHGLDQ IROORZXS \HDUV UDQJH ZHUH UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWHG E\ WZR
UDGLRORJLVWVLQFRQVHQVXVIRFXVLQJRQFLUFXPVFULEHGFKDQJHVDQGFDOFLÀFDWLRQV
LQWKHWXPRXUEHG
5HVXOWV,QSDWLHQWVDIWHU,257IDWQHFURVLVZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHIUHTXHQW
YVSYDOXH DQGODUJHU YVVTFPPHGLDQ WKDQLQFRQWUROV
+DHPDWRPDDQGVHURPDDSSHDUHGLQWKH,257JURXSLQ VTFPPHGLDQ
YHUVXVLQFRQWUROV6FDUFDOFLÀFDWLRQVZHUHDOVRVLJQLÀFDQWO\PRUHIUHTXHQWDIWHU
,257 YVSYDOXH DQGVSHFLÀHGDVG\VWURSKLFLQYV
DQGHJJVKHOOOLNH LHW\SLFDOIRURLOF\VW LQYV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHVWXG\FRQÀUPVWKHKLJKLQFLGHQFHRIFLUFXPVFULEHGÀQGLQJVDIWHU
,257 VSHFLDOO\ ODUJH IDW QHFURVLV 7KH KLJKHU LQFLGHQFH RI FDOFLÀFDWLRQV LQ WKH
WXPRXUEHGDIWHU,257UHSUHVHQWVDQHZÀQGLQJZKLFKUHTXLUHVIXUWKHUDWWHQWLRQ
%
5DGLRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVLQPDPPDU\DXWRORJRXVIDWLQMHFWLRQVD
PXOWLPRGDOLW\HYDOXDWLRQ
3%HOOL$&LSULDQL(%XÀ5)XEHOOL35LQDOGL0&RVWDQWLQL05RPDQL
/%RQRPR5RPH,7
3XUSRVH$XWRORJRXVIDWLQMHFWLRQ OLSRÀOOLQJ KDVUHFHQWO\EHHQHPSOR\HGLQEUHDVW
SODVWLFVXUJHU\2XUDLPLVWRHYDOXDWHPDPPRJUDSKLFVRQRJUDSKLFDQGPDJQHWLF
UHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJQRUPDODQGSDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVLQEUHDVWOLSRÀOOLQJ
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV ,QIRUPHG FRQVHQW DQG LQVWLWXWLRQDO UHYLHZ ERDUG DS
SURYDOZHUHREWDLQHGSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWEUHDVWOLSRÀOOLQJIURP-DQXDU\
WR'HFHPEHUDWRXULQVWLWXWLRQ6LWHDQGDPRXQWRIDXWRORJRXVIDWLQMHFWLRQV
ZHUHNQRZQ0DPPRJUDSK\ 0; XOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 86 DQGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RVWUDWLI\WKHLQGLYLGXDOULVNRISDWLHQWVZLWKQHZO\GLDJQRVHGEUHDVW
FDQFHUQXPHURXVSURJQRVWLFIDFWRUVKDYHEHHQSURSRVHG3UHVHQFHRID[LOODU\
O\PSKQRGHV PHWDVWDVHV KDV EHHQ VKRZQ WR EH RQH RI WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW
SURJQRVWLFIDFWRUV<HWLWFDQEHIXUWKHULPSURYHGLIWKHWRWDOQXPEHURIPHWDVWDWLF
O\PSKQRGHVLVDGGUHVVHG7KLVLVXVXDOO\GRQHXVLQJWKHD[LOODU\O\PSKQRGHUDWLR
$/15 EHLQJGHÀQHGDVWKHTXDQWLW\RIPHWDVWDWLFQRGHVGLYLGHGE\WKHTXDQWLW\
RI UHVHFWHGQRGHV$FFRUGLQJO\ ZH GHVLJQHG WKLV SURVSHFWLYHFURVVVHFWLRQDO
LQYHVWLJDWLRQWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORIEUHDVW05,WRQRQLQYDVLYHO\DVVHVVHV
D[LOODU\WXPRXUORDGDQGWRSUHGLFW$/15XVLQJGHGLFDWHGVHPLDXWRPDWLFVRIWZDUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&RQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\LQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDQFHU
UHFHLYLQJSUHRSHUDWLYHEUHDVW05,DWRXULQVWLWXWLRQZHUHHQUROOHG ,5%DSSURYDO
5HIHUHQFHVWDQGDUGZDVVXUJLFRSDWKRORJLFDOVWDJLQJ EUHDVWD[LOOD DQG$/15ZDV
LGHQWLÀHG%UHDVW05,SURWRFROVZHUHVWDQGDUGLVHGDFFRUGLQJWR(862%,UHFRP
PHQGDWLRQV 7ZJUDGLHQWHFKREHIRUHDQGDIWHU>Q @DSSOLFDWLRQRI*G'73$ÁRZ
POVGRVDJHPPRONJ )RUEUHDVW05,DQDO\VHVDFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOH
&$'V\VWHPZDVXVHG FRPSXWHUDVVLVWHGGLDJQRVLV SURYLGLQJVHPLDXWRPDWLF
VHPLTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRIEUHDVWFDQFHUHQKDQFHPHQWSURÀOHV0XOWLSOHUHJUHV
VLRQZDVXVHGWRDVVHVVSRVVLEOHFRUUHODWLRQRIVXFKHQKDQFHPHQWSURÀOHVZLWK
WKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG $/15
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUHHQUROOHG PHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH\HDUV 0HDQ
$/15ZDV UDQJH 0XOWLSOHUHJUHVVLRQLGHQWLÀHGVLJQLÀFDQWSRWHQWLDO
RIEUHDVW05,WRSUHGLFWD[LOODU\WXPRXUORDG 3U
&RQFOXVLRQ$FFRUGLQJ WR RXU GDWD &$'[EDVHG LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI EUHDVW 05,
FRUUHODWHVZLWKD[LOODU\WXPRXUORDG$VWKHODWWHULVDPRQJVWWKHPRVWSRZHUIXO
SURJQRVWLF IDFWRUV LQ EUHDVWFDQFHU VXFK ÀQGLQJV DGG IXUWKHU NQRZOHGJH WR WKH
DSSOLFDWLRQRIEUHDVW05,DVDQRQLQYDVLYHSURJQRVWLFELRPDUNHU
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
LPDJLQJ 05, ZHUH SURVSHFWLYHO\ REWDLQHG SUHRSHUDWLYHO\ DQG PRQWKV DIWHU
OLSRÀOOLQJ 86 DQG 05, ZHUH UHSHDWHG PRQWKV DIWHU SURFHGXUH 1RUPDO DQG
SDWKRORJLFDOÀQGLQJVZHUHGHVFULEHG
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVEHWZHHQDQG\HDUVROG 06' ZHUHHQ
UROOHGLQWKHVWXG\EUHDVWVXQGHUZHQWOLSRÀOOLQJDIWHUPDVWHFWRP\DIWHU
OXPSHFWRP\DIWHU',(3ÁDSUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRUDV\PPHWU\DQGIRU3RODQGҋV
V\QGURPHWUHDWPHQW$XWRORJRXVIDWLQMHFWLRQVDPRXQWUDQJHGEHWZHHQDQGPO
06' 1RVHYHUHFRPSOLFDWLRQDIWHUWUHDWPHQWZDVREVHUYHG$WWKH
HQGRIWKHVWXG\OLSRÀOOLQJQRUPDORXWFRPHV ´RLOF\VWVµ ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGWLPHV
RQ86DQGRQ05,/LSRQHFURVLVZDVGHWHFWHGWLPHVRQ86DQGRQ05,
,QMHFWHGIDWDYHUDJHDPRXQWZDVPOLQSDWLHQWVZLWKIDWQHFURVLV PO
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKRXWS 2QHFDQFHUUHFXUUHQFHZDVGLDJQRVHGDW\HDU
IROORZXSE\86JXLGHGEUHDVWELRSV\
&RQFOXVLRQ/LSRÀOOLQJQRUPDORXWFRPHVDUHEHVWLGHQWLÀHGE\86SDWKRORJLFDO
DUHE\05,/LSRQHFURVLVRFFXUVZKHQODUJHDPRXQWVRIIDWDUHLQMHFWHG/LSRÀOOLQJ
GRHVQRWMHRSDUGLVHFDQFHUUHFXUUHQFHGLDJQRVLV
ZDVFDOFXODWHGLQFOXGLQJPPPDUJLQV$IWHUZDUGVWKHUDWLREHWZHHQWKHYROXPHV
ZDVFDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHGLQRXUVWXG\SDWLHQWVKDGEUHDVWSUHVHUYLQJ
VXUJHU\DQGSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWPDVWHFWRP\$YHUDJHWXPRXUWREUHDVWYROXPH
UDWLRLQWKHPDVWHFWRP\JURXSZDV ,QWKHOXPSHFWRP\JURXSDYHUDJH
WXPRXUWREUHDVWYROXPHUDWLRZDV
&RQFOXVLRQ7XPRXUWREUHDVWYROXPHUDWLRDVPHDVXUHGRQ05,LVDQDFFXUDWH
PHDVXULQJWRROWKDWFDQKHOSWKHVXUJHRQLQWKHGHFLVLRQZKHWKHUWRSHUIRUPEUHDVW
FRQVHUYLQJVXUJHU\RUPDVWHFWRP\7KLVWRROVKRXOGEHLQWURGXFHGLQWKHVXUJLFDO
SODQQLQJRISDWLHQWVGLDJQRVHGZLWKEUHDVWFDQFHU
%
7UDXPDDQGYHUWHEURSODVW\
%UHDVWFRQVHUYLQJVXUJHU\IRUQRQSDOSDEOHEUHDVWFDQFHU
UHODWLRQVKLSRIOXPSHFWRP\UHVHFWLRQPDUJLQVPHDVXUHPHQWV
EHWZHHQUHPRWHSHULRSHUDWLYHXOWUDVRXQGDQGSRVWRSHUDWLYH
KLVWRSDWKRORJ\
&/XWFKPD\D)OLFN)%HFFH/$ODPR-)'HODOR\H50HXOL-<0HXZO\
/DXVDQQH&+ OLQRXÁLFN#JP[GH
3XUSRVH7XPRXUIUHHUHVHFWLRQPDUJLQV 50V DUHPDQGDWRU\LQEUHDVWFRQVHUYLQJ
VXUJHU\2QVLWHLQWUDRSHUDWLYHXOWUDVRXQG 86 JXLGHGWXPRXUUHVHFWLRQZLWKH[
WHPSRUDQHRXVKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDODVVHVVPHQWRI50VKDVEHHQGHVFULEHG5HPRWH
LQWUDRSHUDWLYH86DVVHVVPHQWRI50VLVDQDOWHUQDWLYH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\
ZDV WR HYDOXDWH WKH UHODWLRQVKLS RI OXPSHFWRP\ 50V PHDVXUHPHQWV EHWZHHQ
UHPRWHLQWUDRSHUDWLYH86DQGSRVWRSHUDWLYHKLVWRSDWKRORJ\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QDUHWURVSHFWLYH,5%DSSURYHGUHYLHZRIFRQVHFX
WLYHOXPSHFWRPLHVSHUIRUPHGEHWZHHQ2FWREHUDQG$SULOIRUSUHVXPHG
QRQSDOSDEOH EUHDVW FDQFHU ZRPHQ PHDQ DJH \HDUV ZHUH LQFOXGHG
7ZHQW\QLQH SDWLHQWV ZHUH H[FOXGHG EHFDXVH RI DEVHQFH RI FDQFHU DW KLVWRSD
WKRORJ\DQGRULQFRPSOHWHGDWD0HDVXUHPHQWVRIOXPSHFWRP\PLQLPDO50VDQG
WXPRXUPD[LPDOGLDPHWHUREWDLQHGRQUHPRWHLQWUDRSHUDWLYH86DQGSRVWRSHUDWLYH
KLVWRSDWKRORJ\ZHUHFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV0LQLPDO50VZHUH PHDQ6' DQGFPRQUHPRWH
LQWUDRSHUDWLYH 86 DQG SRVWRSHUDWLYH KLVWRSDWKRORJ\ UHVSHFWLYHO\ 1R VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQWKHVHPHDVXUHPHQWV S 7XPRXUPD[LPDO
GLDPHWHU ZDV PHDQ6' DQG FP RQ UHPRWH LQWUDRSHUD
WLYH86DQGSRVWRSHUDWLYHKLVWRSDWKRORJ\UHVSHFWLYHO\86PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUH
VLJQLÀFDQWO\ VPDOOHU S 7KH EUHDVW FDUFLQRPD &$ FRQVLVWHG RI
LQYDVLYHFDQDODU Q LQYDVLYHOREXODU Q LQVLWX Q DQGRWKHUW\SHVRI
&$ Q 7ZHQW\QLQHSDWLHQWVKDGLQWUDRSHUDWLYHUHH[FLVLRQ ZLWKRXWUHVLGXDO
&$ ZKLOHSDWLHQWVZHUHUHRSHUDWHGGXHWRLQVXIÀFLHQWKLVWRSDWKRORJLFDO50V
ZLWKRXWUHVLGXDO&$
&RQFOXVLRQ*RRGFRUUHODWLRQRIPLQLPDO50VEHWZHHQUHPRWHLQWUDRSHUDWLYH86
DQGSRVWRSHUDWLYHKLVWRSDWKRORJ\ZDUUDQWVXVHRIERWKWHFKQLTXHVLQDFRPSOH
PHQWDU\PDQQHU5HPRWHLQWUDRSHUDWLYH86LVKHOSIXOLQWDNLQJUDSLGGHFLVLRQRI
UHH[FLVLRQDQGPDLQWDLQLQJORZUHRSHUDWLRQUDWHDIWHUEUHDVWFRQVHUYLQJVXUJHU\
IRUQRQSDOSDEOHFDQFHU
%
7XPRXUWREUHDVWYROXPHUDWLRDVPHDVXUHGRQ05,DSRVVLEOH
SUHGLFWRURIEUHDVWFRQVHUYDWLRQVXUJHU\YHUVXVPDVWHFWRP\
5)DHUPDQQ)6SHUEHU66FKQHHEDXP'%DUVXN7HO$YLY,/
UIDHUPDQQ#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KH VXUJLFDO DSSURDFK WR EUHDVW FDQFHU KDV FKDQJHG GUDPDWLFDOO\ LQ
WKHSDVW\HDUV1RZDGD\VWKHVXUJLFDOREMHFWLYHLVWRUHPRYHWKHWXPRXUZLWK
QHJDWLYHPDUJLQVDQGJRRGFRVPHWLFUHVXOWV05,RIWKHEUHDVWKDVEHFRPHDQ
LPSRUWDQW LPDJLQJ WRRO EHIRUH VXUJHU\ SURYLQJ WR GLDJQRVH DGGLWLRQDO WXPRXUV
DQGWRDVVHVVWKHWXPRXUH[WHQW7XPRXUWREUHDVWYROXPHUDWLRLVDQLPSRUWDQW
SUHGLFWRURIEUHDVWFRQVHUYDWLRQEXWZDVQHYHUDFFXUDWHO\PHDVXUHG05,HQDEOHV
WKLVUDWLRWREHPHDVXUHG2XUSXUSRVHZDVWRPHDVXUHWKLVUDWLRDQGWRDQDO\VH
LILWFDQKHOSLQWKHSODQQLQJRIEUHDVWFDQFHUVXUJHU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HFRQGXFWHGDUHWURVSHFWLYHKRVSLWDOEDVHGVWXG\RI
ZRPHQ GLDJQRVHG ZLWK EUHDVW FDQFHU ZKR XQGHUZHQW SUHVXUJHU\ 05, %UHDVW
YROXPH ZDV FDOFXODWHG ZLWK WKH$: VRIWZDUH DSSOLFDWLRQ 7XPRXU YROXPH ZDV
FDOFXODWHGZLWKWKHKHOSRI&$'VRIWZDUHDQGWKH$:DSSOLFDWLRQ7XPRXUYROXPH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP*+
0XVFXORVNHOHWDO
66E
0RGHUDWRUV
-5DSRVR/LVERQ37
$9LHLUD3RUWR37
%
7KHWLELRÀEXODUV\QGHVPRWLFLQMXU\LQDFXWHDQNOHIUDFWXUH&7HYDOXDWLRQ
<.LP<&KRL0,P./HH</HH-.LP6HRXO.5 \XQQL#HXOMLDFNU
3XUSRVH7RPHDVXUHQRUPDOWLELRÀEXODUV\QGHVPRVLVE\&7DQGLGHQWLI\&7SDUDP
HWHUVWKDWFRXOGDLGLQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIV\QGHVPRWLFLQMXU\DIWHUDFXWHDQNOHIUDFWXUH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVWXG\JURXSFRPSULVHGSDWLHQWVZLWKDFXWHDQNOH
IUDFWXUH PHDQDJH\HDUV ZKRXQGHUZHQWDQNOH&7DQGKDGV\QGHVPRWLFWHDU
DORQJZLWKQRUPDOVXEMHFWV PHDQDJH\HDUV 7KHWLELRÀEXODUFOHDUVSDFH
7)&6 DQGWLELRÀEXODURYHUODS 7)2 RQWKH$3UDGLRJUDSKZHUHPHDVXUHG,QWKH
D[LDO&7LPDJHIRXUSDUDPHWHUVZHUHPHDVXUHGLQFOXGLQJWKHDQWHULRUWLELRÀEXODU
ZLGWK $7): SRVWHULRU WLELRÀEXODU ZLGWK 37): WLELRÀEXODU DQJOH 7)$ DQG
WLELRÀEXODULQWHUYDO 7), :HFRPSDUHG&7PHDVXUHPHQWVEHWZHHQERWKJURXSV
DQGGHWHUPLQHGWKHRSWLPDOFXWRIIYDOXHVIRUGHWHFWLQJV\QGHVPRWLFLQMXU\
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQ 7)&6 DQG 7)2 ZHUH PP DQG PP IRU WKH QRUPDO
JURXSPPDQGPPIRUWKHSDWLHQWJURXSUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHPHDQ$7):
ZDVPPWKH37):ZDVPPWKH7)$ZDVGHJUHHVDQGWKH7),ZDV
PPIRUWKHQRUPDOJURXSZKLOHWKH\ZHUHPPPPGHJUHHVDQG
PPIRUWKHSDWLHQWJURXS7KHRSWLPDOFXWRIIYDOXHVIRUV\QGHVPRWLFLQMXU\ZHUH
$7):PP VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\ 37):PP VHQVLWLYLW\
VSHFLÀFLW\ 7)$GHJUHHV VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\ DQG7),PP
VHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\ UHVSHFWLYHO\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ&7PHDVXUHPHQWVRI37):DQG7)$DLGLQWKHGLDJQRVLVRIV\QGHPRW
LFGLVUXSWLRQZKLFKLVGLIÀFXOWWRGHWHFWE\SODLQUDGLRJUDSK\LQDFXWHDQNOHIUDFWXUH
%
'HWHFWLRQRIERQHPDUURZOHVLRQVZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\&7YLUWXDO
QRQFDOFLXPWHFKQLTXHLVQRWDIIHFWHGE\GRVHUHGXFWLRQ
*3DFKH6%XOOD3%ODQNH7%DXPDQQ0/DQJHU
)UHLEXUJ'( JUHJRUSDFKH#XQLNOLQLNIUHLEXUJGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHLIGRVHUHGXFWLRQDOWHUVGHWHFWDELOLW\RISRVWWUDXPDWLFERQH
PDUURZOHVLRQV %0/ RIWKHNQHHZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\ '( &7YLUWXDOQRQFDOFLXP
WHFKQLTXH 91&D
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QWKLVSURVSHFWLYHLQVWLWXWLRQDOUHYLHZERDUGDSSURYHG
VWXG\SDWLHQWVZLWKDQDFXWHNQHHWUDXPDXQGHUZHQW'(&7 6RPDWRP'HÀQLWLRQ
6LHPHQV ZLWKHLWKHUVWDQGDUG JURXS$ RUZLWKDGRVHHTXDOWRWKDWRIDVLQJOHHQ
HUJ\&7VFDQ JURXS%GRVHUHGXFWLRQ DQG05,DVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
&DOFLXPZDVYLUWXDOO\VXEWUDFWHGIURPWKHLPDJHV /LYHU91&6\QJR'XDO(QHUJ\
6LHPHQV 3UHVHQFHRIIUDFWXUHVZDVQRWHGDQGSUHVHQFHRIDEQRUPDOVRIWWLVVXH
OLNH DWWHQXDWLRQ LQ WKH ERQH PDUURZ ZDV UDWHG RQ D SRLQW VFDOH IRU IHPRUDO
DQGWLELDOUHJLRQVHDFKE\UDGLRORJLVWV+8PHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGLQ
WKHVDPHUHJLRQV,PDJHUDWLQJVDQG+8YDOXHVZHUHVXEMHFWHGWR52&DQDO\VLV
5HVXOWV0HDQDJHQXPEHURIIUDFWXUHVDQGDWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHVZHUHQRWVLJQLÀ
FDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQERWKJURXSV05,UHYHDOHG%0/ IHPRUDOWLELDO
$%S 9LVXDOUDWLQJUHYHDOHGRYHUDOO$8&YDOXHVRI
DQGIRUREVHUYHUVDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\9LVXDOMXGJHPHQWZDVVXSHULRURYHU
DWWHQXDWLRQPHDVXUHPHQWVIRUIHPRUDOUHJLRQVUHJDUGOHVVRIWKHGRVDJHDSSOLHG
$QRYDDQDO\VLVRIDOO&7YDOXHVUHYHDOHGDVLJQLÀFDQWLQÁXHQFHIRUWKHSUHVHQFH
RIRHGHPD S EXWQRGLIIHUHQFHVIRUWKHUDGLDWLRQGRVHXVHG S
,QWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDVH[FHOOHQW ѣYDOXH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ'RVHUHGXFWLRQGRHVQRWDIIHFWGHWHFWDELOLW\RISRVWWUDXPDWLF%0/
ZLWKGXDOHQHUJ\&7YLUWXDOQRQFDOFLXPWHFKQLTXHWKHUHE\SURYLGLQJSRWHQWLDODG
GLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQDVFRPSDUHGWRDVLQJOHHQHUJ\&7VFDQZLWKRXWDGGLWLRQDO
UDGLDWLRQGRVH
%
&RQHEHDP&7IRUTXDQWLWDWLYHDVVHVVPHQWRIERQHGHIHFWKHDOLQJ
DQDQLPDOVWXG\
3.URHSLO$5+DNLPL&5LHJJHU&5XEEHUW56/DQ]PDQ
$6FKHUHU3-XQJEOXWK*$QWRFK0+DNLPL
'VVHOGRUI'( 3DWULF.URHSLO#PHGXQLGXHVVHOGRUIGH
3XUSRVH &RQH EHDP &7 &%&7 LV D UDSLGO\ H[SDQGLQJ LPDJLQJ PRGDOLW\ IRU
YLVXDOLVLQJ RVVHRXV VWUXFWXUHV LQ WKH RUDO DQG PD[LOORIDFLDO 20) UHJLRQ 7KLV
VWXG\ZDVGRQHWRHYDOXDWH&%&7EH\RQGWKH20)UHJLRQIRUPRQLWRULQJRIWLELDO
ERQHGHIHFWKHDOLQJLQDQDQLPDOPRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&LUFXPVFULEHGWLELDOERQHGHIHFWVZHUHFUHDWHGLQPLQL
SLJV,PDJLQJRIWKHWLELDZDVSHUIRUPHGRQGD\XVLQJDPRGHUQ&%&7VFDQQHU
ZLWK ÁDWSDQHO GHWHFWRU 3D;'XR' 9DWHFK .RUHD 7KH H[WHQW RI RVVHRXV
FRQVROLGDWLRQZDVPHDVXUHGTXDQWLWDWLYHO\E\D&%&7YROXPHWU\WRROXVLQJFRP
PHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOHLPDJLQJVRIWZDUH 2VLUL;3L[PHR6ZLW]HUODQG 9ROXPHVRIWKH
HQWLUHGHIHFW LQFOXGLQJDOOSL[HOV DUHDVRIRVVHRXVFRQVROLGDWLRQ GHQVLW\YDOXHV
! DQGQRQFRQVROLGDWHGDUHDV GHQVLW\YDOXHV RIWKHGHIHFWZHUH
GHWHUPLQHG7KH H[WHQW RI ERQH FRQVROLGDWLRQ ZDV FDOFXODWHG DQG D FRUUHODWLRQ
ZLWK KLVWRPRUSKRPHWULFDO UHIHUHQFH VWDQGDUG ZDV SHUIRUPHG ,QGHSHQGHQWO\ D
YLVXDOVHPLTXDQWLWDWLYH&%&7VFRUHZDVDSSOLHGWRDVVHVVERQHGHIHFWKHDOLQJ
5HVXOWV 7KH PHDQ H[WHQW RI RVVHRXV FRQVROLGDWLRQ LQ &%&7YROXPHWU\ ZDV
UDQJH $VLJQLÀFDQWSRVLWLYHFRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQ
WKHH[WHQWRIRVVHRXVFRQVROLGDWLRQRQ&%&7YROXPHWU\DQGKLVWRORJLFDOO\YLVLEOH
QHZO\ IRUPHG ERQH U S 7KHUH ZDV VLJQLÀFDQW QHJDWLYH FRU
UHODWLRQEHWZHHQERQHFRQVROLGDWLRQRQ&%&7DQGKLVWRORJLFDODUHDVRISHUVLVWLQJ
GHIHFW U S 7KHYLVXDOVFRUHPDWFKHGZLWKWKHYROXPHWULFUHVXOWV
LQRIWKHFDVHV
&RQFOXVLRQ&%&7YROXPHWU\DOORZVIRUUHOLDEOHQRQLQYDVLYHTXDQWLWDWLYHPRQLWRU
LQJRIERQHGHIHFWKHDOLQJDQGFRUUHODWHVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZLWKKLVWRORJLFDOUHIHUHQFH
VWDQGDUG&%&7LVDSURPLVLQJWHFKQLTXHIRULPDJLQJRISHULSKHUDOERQHVEH\RQG
WKH20)UHJLRQ
%
6HHPLQJO\LVRODWHGJUHDWHUWURFKDQWHUIUDFWXUHVGRQRWH[LVW
''XQNHU-+*RWKOLQ0*HLMHU*RWKHQEXUJ6(/XQG6(
GHQQLVGXQNHU#YJUHJLRQVH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
2SHUDWLYHPDQDJHPHQWRILQWUDFDSVXODUIHPRUDOIUDFWXUHLVWKH
UHTXLUHPHQWIRUDGGLWLRQDOLPDJLQJDEDUULHUWRRSHUDWLQJZLWKLQWKH
KRXUWDUJHW"
5*(&OHPHQW='DYLV)3HUNV(GLQEXUJK8.
UK\VFOHPHQW#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH'HOD\LQPDQDJHPHQWRISDWLHQWVZLWKDIHPRUDOQHFNIUDFWXUHRIRYHU
KRXUVGRXEOHVPRUWDOLW\7KHLQFLGHQFHRIRFFXOWIUDFWXUHVWKDWDUHQRWHYLGHQW
RQ SODLQ UDGLRJUDSK\ LV XS WR (LWKHU &7 RU 05, FDQ EH XVHG IRU IXUWKHU
LPDJLQJEXWLWKDVEHHQVXJJHVWHGWKDWZDLWLQJIRUWKHVHLVWKHSULQFLSOH FDXVH
IRUGHOD\LQJVXUJHU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV3DWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJ&7RU05,IRUVXVSHFWHGRFFXOWKLS
IUDFWXUHVDWDPDMRU8QLYHUVLW\KRVSLWDOZHUHLGHQWLÀHGGXULQJDRQH\HDUSHULRG
7LPLQJRIWKHSDWLHQWDGPLVVLRQ&705,UHTXHVWLPDJLQJDQGVXUJHU\ZHUHDOO
UHFRUGHG
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGRFFXOWKLSIUDFWXUHZHUHUHIHUUHGIRUIXUWKHU
LPDJLQJGXULQJWKHVWXG\SHULRGXQGHUZHQW&7DQGWKHRWKHUXQGHUZHQW
05,7KHDYHUDJHZDLWIURPDGPLVVLRQWR05,ZDVGD\VZLWKDGHOD\IURPWKH
UHTXHVWRIGD\V%\FRPSDULVRQWKHDYHUDJHZDLWIRU&7IURPDGPLVVLRQZDV
GD\VZLWKWKHDYHUDJHGHOD\IURPUHTXHVWRIGD\V05,LGHQWLÀHGIHPRUDO
IUDFWXUHVRIZKLFKZHUHRSHUDWHGRQZLWKLQWKHKRXUWDUJHW&7LGHQWLÀHG
IHPRUDOIUDFWXUHVRIZKLFKZHUHRSHUDWHGRQZLWKLQKRXUV
&RQFOXVLRQ 2YHU RI SDWLHQWV UHTXLULQJ DGGLWLRQDO LPDJLQJ IRU VXVSHFWHG
IHPRUDO IUDFWXUH IDLOHG WR EH RSHUDWLYHO\ PDQDJHG ZLWKLQ KRXUV 5DGLRORJ\
GHSDUWPHQWGHOD\LVQRWRIWHQWKHFDXVHIRUWKLVDQGWKHUHIRUHFOLQLFLDQVVKRXOGEH
HQFRXUDJHGWRUHTXHVWDGGLWLRQDOLPDJLQJSURPSWO\
%
&7JXLGHGPLQLPDOO\LQYDVLYHPXVFXORVNHOHWDOSURFHGXUHV
DXJPHQWHGE\DQRYHORSWLFDOQDYLJDWLRQV\VWHP
<$SSOEDXP$+LUVFKHQEHLQ/$SSHOEDXP</LEVRQ-6RVQD
-HUXVDOHP,/5DҋDQDQD,/ DYLYK#KDGDVVDKRUJLO
3XUSRVH:HHPSOR\HGDQRSWLFDOQDYLJDWLRQV\VWHPZKLFKXVHVYLGHRDQGGL
PHQVLRQDO VRIWZDUH WR SURYLGH UHDOWLPH QHHGOH SRVLWLRQ JXLGDQFH GXULQJ ERQH
ELRSVLHV5)$:HDLPHGDWDVVHVVLQJV\VWHPDFFXUDF\DQGVDIHW\LQRUWKRSDHGLF
&7JXLGHGSURFHGXUHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,5%ZDVREWDLQHGDQGHDFKSDWLHQWVLJQHGLQIRUPHGFRQ
VHQW(LJKWSHUFXWDQHRXVELRSVLHVDQG5)$RIRVWHRLGRVWHRPDVZHUHFRQGXFWHG
RQSDWLHQWVZLWKOHVLRQVLQWKHSHOYLV VSLQH IHPXU DQGVKRXOGHU
7KH$FWL6LJKW $FWL9LHZV+DLID,VUDHO JXLGDQFHV\VWHPZDVXVHGIRUDOOFDVHV
7KHV\VWHPLVDVWHUHRWDFWLFDFFHVVRU\IRU&7JXLGHGSURFHGXUHVZKLFKGHWHUPLQHV
QHHGOHORFDWLRQLQUHODWLRQWRWKH'VSDFHRIWKH&7LPDJHVE\UHJLVWHULQJDYLGHR
LPDJHZLWKWKH&7LPDJH3URFHGXUHUHODWHGGDWDLQFOXGLQJDFFXUDF\WLPHWRUHDFK
OHVLRQQXPEHURIVFDQVDQGFRPSOLFDWLRQUDWHVZHUHFRPSLOHG
5HVXOWV3DWLHQWVZHUHRIDJHPHGLDQ7HFKQLFDOVXFFHVVZDVDFKLHYHG
LQRIFDVHV/HVLRQGLDPHWHUUDQJHGPPPP PHDQPP $YHUDJH
GLVWDQFHVNLQWDUJHWZDVPP 67' PP DQGQDYLJDWLRQEDVHGDFFXUDF\
UDQJHGEHWZHHQDQGPP DYHUDJHPP 0HDQWLPHIRUFRUUHFWQHHGOH
SODFHPHQWZDVPLQXWHV PLQIRU5)$DQGPLQIRUELRSV\ 7RWDOQXPEHU
RI&7VFDQVIRUQHHGOHSODFHPHQWDYHUDJHG UDQJH 1RFRPSOLFDWLRQV
RFFXUUHG
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRIWKHRSWLFDOQHHGOHJXLGDQFHV\VWHPLQ&7JXLGHGERQH
SURFHGXUHVLVVDIHDQGDFFXUDWH&OLQLFDOUHOHYDQFH7KHXVHRIDVWHUHRWDFWLFJXLG
DQFHV\VWHPPD\LPSURYHWKHVXFFHVVUDWHLQ&7JXLGHGSURFHGXUHVRIERQHV
UHGXFHWLPHFRPSOLFDWLRQVDQGUDGLDWLRQDVVRFLDWHGZLWKWKLVSURFHGXUH
%
,VWKHUHDQ\SUHRSHUDWLYH05,SUHGLFWRULQSDWLHQWVZLWKGHJHQHUDWLYH
OXPEDUVWHQRVLV"
%$OLFLRJOX%<LOPD]1%XODNEDVL&&RSXURJOX(<DOQL]%$\NDF
/HINRVD1RUWK&\SUXV75(GLUQH75 DOLFLRJOXE#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R LGHQWLI\ DQ\ 05, SUHGLFWRU IRU VXUJLFDO RXWFRPHV RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK
GHJHQHUDWLYH OXPEDU VSLQDO VWHQRVLV '/66 KDYLQJ LQVWUXPHQWHG SRVWHULRU GH
FRPSUHVVLRQ ,3' VXUJHU\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV ZLWK '/66 ZKR XQGHUZHQW ,3' ZHUH
UHYLHZHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\7KHFOLQLFDOVFRUHRIHDFKSDWLHQWZHUHDVVHVVHGXVLQJ
-DSDQHVH2UWKRSHGLF$VVRFLDWLRQ6FRULQJ -2$6 V\VWHPZKLFKLVPDLQO\EDVHG
RQWKHVXEMHFWLYHV\PSWRPVDQGSK\VLFDOVLJQVRIWKHSDWLHQWVEHIRUH -2$6, DQG
DIWHU -2$6,, VXUJHU\+HDOLQJUDWHZDVFDOFXODWHGDV> -2$6,, -2$6, @[
> -2$6, @7KH+5JUHDWHUWKDQZDVFRQVLGHUHGDVFOLQLFDOLPSURYHPHQW
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH 7R DVVHVV WKH IUHTXHQF\ DQG H[WHQW RI VHHPLQJO\ LVRODWHG JUHDWHU
WURFKDQWHULFIUDFWXUHVDVZHOODVREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWVLQUDGLRJUDSK\FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ &7 DQGPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ 05, RIVXFKIUDFWXUHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$UHYLHZZLWKLQWHUREVHUYHUYDULDQFHZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGKLSIUDFWXUHZLWKLQLWLDOHTXLYRFDORUQHJDWLYHUDGLRJUDSK\
IROORZHG E\&7 Q RU05, Q 7KUHHUHYLHZHUV VFRUHGH[WUDFDSVXODU
IUDFWXUHVDVHLWKHUFRPSOHWHWURFKDQWHULFDYXOVLRQRIWKHJUHDWHUWURFKDQWHUZLWK
LQFRPSOHWHWURFKDQWHULFH[WHQVLRQRULVRODWHGDYXOVLRQIURPWKHJUHDWHUWURFKDQWHU
2EVHUYHUYDULDWLRQZDVTXDQWLÀHGXVLQJOLQHDUZHLJKWHG.DSSDVWDWLVWLFV
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVWRWDODJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQWKUHHREVHUYHUVLQRIWKHFDVHV
IRUUDGLRJUDSK\IRU&7DQGIRU05,LQFODVVLI\LQJWKHFDVHVDVGHÀQLWH
IUDFWXUHVXVSHFWRUHTXLYRFDORUQRWURFKDQWHULFIUDFWXUH:KHQFODVVLI\LQJWKH
FDVHVDVKDYLQJDJUHDWHUWURFKDQWHULFDYXOVLRQIUDFWXUHZLWKRUZLWKRXWDWURFKDQWHULF
H[WHQVLRQWKHUHZDVDJUHHPHQWIRUUDGLRJUDSK\IRU&7DQGIRU
05,$JUHHPHQWVEHWZHHQWKHPRGDOLWLHVUDQJHGIRUWKHWKUHHREVHUYHUVEHWZHHQ
VXEVWDQWLDODQGQHDUSHUIHFW N :KHQFODVVLI\LQJFDVHVDVLVRODWHG
WURFKDQWHULFDYXOVLRQVWKHUHZDVDJUHHPHQWRQQRIUDFWXUHVZLWK05,
&RQFOXVLRQ 6HHPLQJO\ LVRODWHG DYXOVLRQ IUDFWXUHV RI WKH JUHDWHU WURFKDQWHU
DOZD\VKDYHDWURFKDQWHULFH[WHQVLRQ&7DQGUDGLRJUDSK\DUHRIWHQDGHTXDWHLQ
GLDJQRVLQJIUDFWXUHVRIWKHJUHDWHUWURFKDQWHUEXWQRWDOZD\VWKHH[WHQVLRQ05,
UHYHDOVWKHLQWHUWURFKDQWHULFFRPSOH[LW\EXWZLWKXQFHUWDLQFOLQLFDOYDOXHDVLWPD\
RYHUHVWLPDWHWKHQHHGIRULQWHUQDOÀ[DWLRQDQGWKXVDQXQQHFHVVDU\SURFHGXUH
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
$WWKHODPLQHFWRP\OHYHOWKHGHJUHHRIGLVFGHJHQHUDWLRQWKHFDOVDFFRPSUHV
VLRQQHUYHURRWFRPSUHVVLRQIRUDPLQDOVWHQRVLVIDFHWGHJHQHUDWLRQZHUHJUDGHG
IURPWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIDOLJQPHQWGLVRUGHUVÁDYDOOLJDPHQWWKLFNHQLQJZHUH
GHWHUPLQHGE\05,7KHUHVXOWVRISDWLHQWVZLWKZLWKRXWFOLQLFDOLPSURYHPHQWZHUH
FRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV0HDQDJHZDV WKHGXUDWLRQRIV\PSWRPVZDV\HDUV
-2$6, ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWIURP-2$6,, S 0HDQ
+5 RI WKH LPSURYHG SDWLHQWV Q ZDV +5 RI WKH XQLPSURYHG
SDWLHQWV Q ZDVWKHGLIIHUHQFHZDVVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW7KHUH
ZDVQRVWDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSVE\PHDQVRIVH[WKHSUHV
HQFHRIDOLJQPHQWGLVRUGHUVDJHDQGGXUDWLRQRIFRPSODLQWVEHIRUHWKHVXUJHU\
DQGUDGLRORJLFVWHQRVLVSDUDPHWHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ$OWKRXJKWKHGHJUHHRIUDGLRORJLFVWHQRVLVGLGQRWVKRZDQ\SUHGLFWLRQ
DERXWWKHVXUJLFDORXWFRPHVRISDWLHQWVKDYLQJ,3'LWGRHVQRWPHDQWKDWSDWLHQWV
ZLWKVHYHUHVWHQRVLVZLOOQRWEHQHÀWIURPGHFRPSUHVVLRQVXUJHU\
%
3HUFXWDQHRXVYHUWHEURSODVW\ZLWK'URWDWLRQDOÁXRURVFRS\LPDJLQJ
YV&7ZLWKPRELOH&DUPÁXRURVFRS\JXLGDQFH
$&DQQDYDOH))DQHOOL0&RURQD0$OOHJULWWL3/XFDWHOOL53DVVDULHOOR
5RPH,7 DOHVVDQGURFDQQDYDOH#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHGHYHORSPHQWRIURWDWLRQDODQJLRJUDSKLFXQLWV 5$8 ZLWKÁDWGHWHF
WRUVKDVPDUNHGO\LQFUHDVHGDQDWRPLFYLVXDOLVDWLRQFDSDELOLWLHVIRULQWHUYHQWLRQDO
UDGLRORJ\SURFHGXUHV:HHYDOXDWHGWKHUHOLDELOLW\RI5$8DVDVLQJOHWHFKQLTXH
WRJXLGHSHUFXWDQHRXVYHUWHEURSODVW\ 393 YV&7ZLWKPRELOH&DUPÁXRURVFRS\
&7&DUP
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV )LIW\ FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV YHUWHEUDO ERGLHV
OXPEDUDQGWKRUDFLF ZHUHWUHDWHGXQGHU5$8$UWLV]HHZLWK''URWDWLRQDO
DFTXLVLWLRQV 1 DQG&7FRXSOHGZLWKPRELOH&DUPÁXRURVFRS\ 1 :H
FRPSDUHGWKHWZRWHFKQLTXHVDERXWLPDJLQJTXDOLW\ÁXRURVFRS\WLPHSDWLHQWDQG
RSHUDWRUH[SRVXUHGRVHWHFKQLFDOVXFFHVVPHDQSURFHGXUHWLPHPHDQQXPEHU
RIURWDWLRQDODFTXLVLWLRQVDQGFRPSOLFDWLRQV
5HVXOWV5$8DOORZHGDVDIHDFFHVVDQGDQDFFXUDWHFRQWURORIWKHERQHFHPHQW
LQMHFWLRQLQDOOFDVHVHYHQDWWKHWKRUDFLFOHYHOVDQGLQFDVHRIYHUWHEUDSODQD1R
FHPHQWOHDNDJHVZHUHHQFRXQWHUHG7KHPHDQSURFHGXUHWLPHZDV 5$8
YVPLQXWHV &7&DUP S 0HGLDQÁXRURVFRS\WLPHZDV 5$8 DQG
PLQ &7&DUP S 0HDQQXPEHURIURWDWLRQDODFTXLVLWLRQVZDV 5$8
DQG &7&DUP 0HDQSDWLHQWGRVHZDVP6Y 5$8 YVP6Y &7&DUP
0HDQRSHUDWRUGRVH ERG\KDQGV ZDVP6Y 5$8 YVP6Y
&7&DUP S
&RQFOXVLRQ 5RWDWLRQDO ÁXRURVFRS\ FRPELQHV WKH PRVW YDOXDEOH LQWHUYHQWLRQDO
IHDWXUHVRI&7DQGÁXRURVFRS\LQWRRQHWHFKQRORJ\,WDOORZVUHDOWLPHYLVXDOLVDWLRQ
RILQWHUYHQWLRQDOSURFHGXUHVXVLQJ'&7OLNHLPDJHV393ZLWK'ÁXRURVFRS\
ZLWKURWDWLRQDODFTXLVLWLRQVLVDUHOLDEOHDQGIHDVLEOHWHFKQLTXHUHGXFLQJWLPHRIWKH
SURFHGXUHDQGDOORZLQJIDVWDQGFRVWHIIHFWLYHSURFHGXUHVZLWKKLJKUDWHRIVXFFHVV
%
&REODWLRQYHUWHEURSODVW\DVDPHDQVRIWUHDWLQJKLJKULVNSDLQIXO
YHUWHEUDOFRPSUHVVLRQIUDFWXUHV
'-:LOVRQ6(2ZHQ5$&RUNLOO2[IRUG8. GMZLOVRQ#KHUDOGR[DFXN
3XUSRVH,WKDVEHFRPHDSSDUHQWWKDWWKHUHDUHPDQ\FDQFHUSDWLHQWVZKRZRXOG
EHQHÀWIURPVSLQDOFHPHQWDXJPHQWDWLRQWRSUHYHQWSDLQDQGDOVRWRSUHYHQWFDWD
VWURSKLFFROODSVHGHVSLWHWKHULVNDVVRFLDWHGZLWKSRVWHULRUZDOOGHIHFW$WHFKQLTXH
KDVEHHQGHYHORSHGDOORZLQJWKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIWKHWXPRXULWVHOIE\FROGDEODWLRQ
YDSRULVLQJWKHWXPRXUWLVVXHDQGFUHDWLQJDFDYLW\7KLVFDYLW\FDQWKHQEHÀOOHG
ZLWKFHPHQWDWORZSUHVVXUHUHGXFLQJWKHULVNRIGLVSODFLQJWKHWXPRXUSRVWHULRUO\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HKDYHQRZFRPSOHWHGWZHQW\VHYHQSURFHGXUHV7KHVH
LQFOXGHSDWLHQWVZLWKP\HORPDZLWKPDOLJQDQF\ZLWKRVWHRSRURVLVDQG
ZLWKWUDXPD5HYLHZRIWKHRXWFRPHPHDVXUHVZDVEDVHGRQURXWLQHEDVHOLQHDQG
SRVWSURFHGXUHSDLQDQGGLVDELOLW\VFRUHVXVLQJYLVXDODQDORJXHSDLQVFDOHDQGWKH
5RODQG0RUULVSRLQWGLVDELOLW\VFRUH
5HVXOWV7KHWHFKQLTXHDGGVWRPLQXWHVWRWKHSURFHGXUHWLPH7KHHTXLSPHQW
LVPRUHFRPSOH[DQGFRVWVDURXQG(XURVPRUH:HKDYHQRWVHHQDQLQFUHDVH
LQFRPSOLFDWLRQVXVLQJWKLVWHFKQLTXHHYHQWKRXJKWKHSDWLHQWVDUHPRUHGLIÀFXOW
DQGFRPSOH[2XURXWFRPHPHDVXUHVDUHQRWDVVXFFHVVIXODVWKRVHREWDLQHGE\
FRQYHQWLRQDOYHUWHEURSODVW\LQWKHVLPSOHUSDWLHQWVZKHUHXVLQJRXUORFDODQDHVWKHWLF
DQGYHUWHEURSODVW\SURWRFROZHZRXOGH[SHFWLPSURYHPHQWLQRYHU2YHUDOO
REWDLQHGVRPHLPSURYHPHQWXVLQJFREODWLRQYHUWHEURSODVW\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVWHFKQLTXHLQFUHDVHVWKHVDIHW\RISHUIRUPLQJFHPHQWDXJPHQWD
WLRQLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSRWHQWLDOO\FDWDVWURSKLFWXPRXULQYDVLRQDQGWUHDWVSDWLHQWV
ZKRZRXOGRWKHUZLVHEHXQVXLWDEOHIRUWUHDWPHQWE\YHUWHEURSODVW\
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
'XDOHQHUJ\&7P\HORJUDSK\LQSDWLHQWVZLWKVSLQDORVWHRV\QWKHVLV
$(*UDPV-6HQGHU50RULW]76FKPLGW06WHLQ02HUWHO
*$.URPEDFK(5*L]HZVNL*LHVVHQ'( DVWULGJUDPV#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHZDVWRHYDOXDWHEHQHÀWVRI&7P\HORJUDSK\LQGXDOHQHUJ\
'( WHFKQLTXHLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSUHYLRXVOXPEDURVWHRV\QWKHVLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZHUHLQFOXGHG$IWHULQWUDWKHFDOLQMHFWLRQRI
LRGLQH FRQWUDVW DJHQW D '(&7 VFDQ 6RPDWRP 'HÀQLWLRQ 6LHPHQV ZLWK WXEH
YROWDJHVRIN9DQGN9ZDVSHUIRUPHGDQGDYLUWXDOVHULHVRIN9ZDV
JHQHUDWHG,QDOOVHULHVLPSDFWRIPHWDODUWHIDFWVRQWKHYLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHVSLQDO
FDQDODQGWKHVSLQDOIRUDPLQDZHUHHYDOXDWHG,QDGGLWLRQD957VHULHVRIWKH
GXUDOVDFZDVJHQHUDWHGZLWK´ERQHUHPRYDOµZKLFKZDVFRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDO
P\HORJUDSK\GDWD
5HVXOWV:LWKWXEHYROWDJHVRIN9DUWHIDFWVZHUHOHDVWSURQRXQFHGDQGGLGQRW
OLPLWHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHVSLQDOFDQDODQGWKHQHXUDOIRUDPLQD:LWKN9DUWHIDFWV
OLPLWHGWKHHYDOXDWLRQPRGHUDWHO\,QWKHYLUWXDON9VHULHVLPDJLQJTXDOLW\ZDV
RQO\VOLJKWO\GLPLQLVKHGFRPSDUHGWRN99LVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHGXUDOVDFLQWKH
957 ZDV FRPSDUDEOH WR WKH ´JROG VWDQGDUGµ FRQYHQWLRQDO P\HORJUDSK\ ,Q RQH
SDWLHQW ZLWK DGGLWLRQDO LQWHUYHUWHEUDO PDWHULDO YLUWXDO P\HORJUDSK\ ZDV EHWWHU LQ
YLVXDOLVDWLRQRIWKHGXUDOVDFLQDQWHULRUSRVWHULRUYLHZ
&RQFOXVLRQ&7LQ'(WHFKQLTXHSURYLGHVPLQLPDODUWHIDFWGLVWXUEDQFHZLWKWKH
N9WXEHYROWDJHLQSDWLHQWVDIWHURVWHRV\QWKHVLV,WSURYLGHVWKHSRVVLELOLW\RI
´YLUWXDOP\HORJUDSK\µZKLFKVHHPVDGYDQWDJHRXVLQSDWLHQWZLWKFRPSOH[VWDEL
OLVDWLRQ7KLVFRXOGUHGXFHWKHQHHGRIH[WHQVLYHFRQYHQWLRQDOUDGLRJUDSK\DIWHU
WKHLQMHFWLRQRIFRQWUDVWDJHQWDQGPD\VKRUWHQWKHHQWLUHH[DPLQDWLRQWLPHXQ
QHFHVVDU\SDLQIXOPRYHPHQWVIRUWKHSDWLHQWVDQGVKRUWHQWKHUDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUH
IRUWKHUDGLRORJLVW
5RRP,.
$EGRPLQDO9LVFHUD
66E
$EGRPHQ
0RGHUDWRUV
)$$UUHGRQGR*XDWHPDOD&LW\*7
2%XFNOH\'XEOLQ,(
%
7KHDPRXQWRIUHVHFWHGOLYHUWLVVXHGHWHUPLQHVYHORFLW\DQG
FRPSOHWHQHVVRIOLYHUUHJHQHUDWLRQDIWHUSDUWLDOKHSDWHFWRP\
3*.HOH07'H%RHU(-9DQGHU-DJW-$/LVPDQ5-3RUWH
*URQLQJHQ1/ SJNHOH#UDGXPFJQO
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHOLYHUUHJHQHUDWLRQIROORZLQJSDUWLDOKHSDWHFWRP\E\FRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSKLF &7 YROXPHWU\
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHW\RQHSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJSDUWLDOKHSDWHFWRP\IRU
GLIIHUHQWLQGLFDWLRQVZHUHLQFOXGHG9ROXPHWU\ZDVSHUIRUPHGVHPLDXWRPDWLFDOO\
RQ&7VFDQVE\GUDZLQJIUHHKDQGUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWVLQWKHSRUWDOYHQRXVSKDVH
RQPPWKLFNQHVVVOLFHV7RWDOOLYHUWKHSDUWWREHUHVHFWHGWXPRXU V IXWXUH
OLYHUUHPQDQW )/5 DQGOLYHUUHPQDQWV /5 ZHUHPHDVXUHG7KUHHUHJHQHUDWLRQ
YHORFLW\LQGLFHV 59,V ZHUHFDOFXODWHG 59,GD\VSRVWRSHUDWLYHO\ 59,HDUO\
GHÀQHG DV 9/5GD\V9)/5 9)/5 ZKHUH 9/5GD\V LV WKH GD\ SRVW
VXUJHU\/5YROXPHDQG9)/5LVWKH)/5YROXPH 59,EHWZHHQWKHSRVWRSHUDWLYH
DQGVXEVHTXHQWVFDQ 59,ODWH FDOFXODWHGDV 9/50RQWKV9/5GD\V 9)/5
ZKHUH9/5PRQWKVLVWKHPRQWKV/5YROXPH 59,PRQWKVSRVWVXUJLFDOO\
59,WRWDO FDOFXODWHGDV 9/5PRQWKV9)/5 9)/5 3DWLHQWVZHUHFODVVLÀHG
LQWRJURXSV SDWLHQWVZLWK DQG
UHVHFWLRQRIWKHWRWDOSUHRSHUDWLYHOLYHUYROXPH
5HVXOWV7KH59,HDUO\UDQJHGIURPDPHGLDQRILQJURXSWRLQJURXS
7KH59,ODWHUDQJHGIURPDPHGLDQRILQJURXSWRLQJURXS7KH
59,WRWDOUDQJHGIURPDPHGLDQLQJURXSWRLQJURXS$WSRVWRSHUDWLYH
GD\WKH/5UHSUHVHQWHGDQGRIWKHWRWDOSUHRSHUDWLYH
OLYHUYROXPHIRUJURXSVDIWHUDPHGLDQRIPRQWKVWKLVZDV
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\
&RQFOXVLRQ5HJHQHUDWLRQLVSURSRUWLRQDOWRWKHUHVHFWHGYROXPHZLWKKLJKHU59,V
DIWHUODUJHUUHVHFWLRQV3RVWVXUJLFDOO\WKHOLYHUGRHVQRWUHJHQHUDWHWRLWVRULJLQDO
YROXPHLQPRVWSDWLHQWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
/LYHULURQFRQFHQWUDWLRQTXDQWLÀFDWLRQE\05,DUHUHFRPPHQGHG
SURWRFROVDFFXUDWHHQRXJKIRUFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH"
-0$OXVWL]D$&DVWLHOOD-,(PSDUDQ]D(=DSDWD%&RVWHUR0,'H]
(6DOYDGRU6DQ6HEDVWLDQ(60HQGDUR(6$OFDODGH+HQDUHV(6
MPDOXVWL]D#RVDWHNHV
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVWKHTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIOLYHULURQFRQFHQWUDWLRQ /,& E\05,XVLQJ
WKH5HQQHV8QLYHUVLW\ 85HQQHV PRGHO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KH/,&FDOFXODWHGE\WKH85HQQHVPRGHOLQSD
WLHQWVZHUHFRPSDUHGWR/,&REWDLQHGE\FKHPLFDOPHDVXUHPHQWLQOLYHUELRSVLHV
5HVXOWV$FFRUGLQJWRWKHELRSV\SDWLHQWVKDGQRRYHUORDG PRO)HJ
KDGPRGHUDWHRYHUORDG PRO)HJ DQGKDGKLJKLURQRYHUORDG +,2
!PRO)HJ 7KHUHLVDFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKH/,&HVWLPDWHGZLWK05,DQG
WKH PHDVXUHPHQW REWDLQHG ZLWK D ELRSV\ U 05, FRUUHFWO\ FODVVLÀHG
SDWLHQWVLQWKHYDULRXVOHYHOVRI/,&'LDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LVZLWKDWHQGHQF\
WRRYHUHVWLPDWHRISDWLHQWVZLWKQRRYHUORDGZHUHGLDJQRVHGDVRYHUORDGHG
DQGRISDWLHQWVZLWKPRGHUDWHRYHUORDGZHUHGLDJQRVHGDVKDYLQJ+,27KH
VHQVLWLYLW\RIWKH85HQQHVPHWKRGIRU+,2LVDQGWKHVSHFLÀFLW\IRUDEVHQFH
RIRYHUORDGLV7KHHVWLPDWHGFRQFHQWUDWLRQV!PRO)HJUHYHDOHGD
339IRU+,2RIHVWLPDWHGYDOXHVPRO)HJKDGD139RIIRU
+,27KHSDWLHQWVZLWKLQWHUPHGLDWHYDOXHVUHPDLQLQXQFHUWDLQW\
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH85HQQHVPRGHOLVDEOHWRFRUUHFWO\GLDJQRVHDQGUXOHRXW+,2LQ
DERXWRISDWLHQWVZLWKYHU\VSHFLÀFFXWRIISRLQWVRIDQGPRO)HJ)RU
LQWHUPHGLDWHYDOXHVWKHGLDJQRVLVLVQRWDVFOHDUDQGDQDGGLWLRQDOWHVWWRPHDVXUH
/,&RUDQHPSLULFDOWUHDWPHQWVKRXOGEHHYDOXDWHG
%
1HZUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVWLQERG\FRPSRVLWLRQDQDO\VLVE\GXDOHQHUJ\
[UD\DEVRUSWLRPHWU\OLYHU´DGLSRVLW\µ
''LDQR$$QGUHRQH**DU]LOOR*)LORQ]L&6DVVL8$OELVLQQL*%DWWLVWD
(6DOL]]RQL$%D]]RFFKL%RORJQD,7 JLDFRPRÀORQ]L#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH +HSDWLF VWHDWRVLV LV DQ LQFUHDVLQJ ZRUOGZLGH PHWDEROLF GLVHDVH DQG
WKHHDUOLHVWELRPDUNHUIRUWKHOLYHUÀEURVLVGHYHORSPHQW7KXVLWVGHWHFWLRQDQG
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQGXULQJQRQLQYDVLYHH[DPLQDWLRQVVKRXOGEHDOZD\VFRQVLGHUHGDV
FOLQLFDOO\UHOHYDQW2XUDLPZDVWRWHVWQHZGHVLJQHGUHJLRQVRILQWHUHVW 52,V
RQ ZKROH ERG\ LPDJHV DFTXLUHG E\ GXDO HQHUJ\ [UD\ DEVRUSWLRPHWU\ ';$ LQ
FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK ';$ FRQYHQWLRQDO 52,V DQG XOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 86 LQ RUGHU WR
HYDOXDWHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVRQOLYHUVWHDWRVLVGHWHFWLRQDQGJUDGLQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV1LQHW\QLQHVXEMHFWVGLUHFWHGWRERG\FRPSRVLWLRQDVVHVV
PHQWE\';$ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHG$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHVXEPLWWHGWRZKROHERG\
';$VFDQ /XQDUL';$VRIWZDUHHQ&25( DQGXQGHUZHQW86HYDOXDWLRQRQ
WKHVDPHGD\WRDVVHVVKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLV PLOGPRGHUDWHVHYHUH 2QHYHU\';$
LPDJHWKUHHQHZOLYHUVXLWHG52,VZHUHPDQXDOO\FUHDWHGE\DVNLOOHGUDGLRORJLVW
)DWPDVV )0 DQG)0SHUFHQWDJH )0S ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHGRQZKROHERG\DQG
UHJLRQDOO\ DQGURLGDQGQHZ52,V )0DQG)0SUHVXOWVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWK86
5HVXOWV2XWRISDWLHQWV UHVXOWHGDIIHFWHGE\OLYHUVWHDWRVLVRQ86
HYDOXDWLRQ ïPLOGïPRGHUDWHDQGïVHYHUH
)0DQG)0SRIDOO52,VZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKSUHVHQFHDQGJUDGLQJRI
VWHDWRVLV S KRZHYHUWKH\ZHUHDEOHWRSUHGLFWDQGWRGLVWLQJXLVKVWHDWRVLV
DEVHQFHIURPPRGHUDWHDQGVHYHUHJUDGHEXWQRWPLOG)0SRIRQHDPRQJWKHQHZ
OLYHUVXLWHG52,VVKRZHGWKHEHVWSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHIRUOLYHUVWHDWRVLV
&RQFOXVLRQ1HZ52,VVKRXOGEHLQFOXGHGLQZKROHERG\';$H[DPLQDWLRQVWR
SURYLGHDGGLWLRQDOLQIRUPDWLRQDQGKLJKHUSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHRQOLYHUVWHDWRVLV
%
5HSURGXFLELOLW\RIWZRSRLQW',;21WHFKQLTXHIRUPHDVXULQJKHSDWLF
IDWIUDFWLRQ
$0&KRZ**/R-.)&KDQ6/DX(:RQJ6.<X+DSS\9DOOH\+.
DSULOFPN#JPDLOFRP
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
(DUO\KHSDWLFDUWHU\WKURPERVLVDIWHUOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQWKH
LPSDFWRIRQVHWDQGDGGLWLRQDOULVNIDFWRUVLQDPDWFKHGFDVHFRQWUROVWXG\
-%HNNHU9)LGOHU.3GH-RQJ5RWWHUGDP1/*URQLQJHQ1/
MDVEHNNHU#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH,QWKLVVWXG\ZHWHVWHGWKHK\SRWKHVLVWKDWHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIH+$7DQG
UHYDVFXODULVDWLRQRIWKHJUDIWLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDEHWWHUJUDIWVXUYLYDO:HDQDO\VHG
JUDIWDQGSDWLHQWVXUYLYDOLQSDWLHQWVZLWKLQWUDRSHUDWLYH+$7+$7GHWHFWHGDQG
WUHDWHGGXULQJWUDQVSODQWDWLRQYHUVXVWKRVHZLWKSRVWRSHUDWLYH+$7$GGLWLRQDOO\
ZH LGHQWLÀHG ULVN IDFWRUV IRU H+$7 E\ FRPSDULQJ H+$7 SDWLHQWV ZLWK QRQH+$7
SDWLHQWVDQGE\SHUIRUPLQJDFDVHFRQWUROVWXG\LQZKLFKSDWLHQWVZHUHPDWFKHG
IRUWKHWZRPRVWLPSRUWDQWULVNIDFWRUVIRUH+$7WUDQVSODQWDWLRQLQFKLOGUHQDQG
UHWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV%HWZHHQ-DQXDU\DQG$XJXVWGDWDRI
OLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQVLQSDWLHQWVZHUHUHWULHYHGIURPRXUSURVSHFWLYHGDWDEDVH
+$7ZDVSUHVHQWLQRI WUDQVSODQWDWLRQV
5HVXOWV7KHVXFFHVVUDWHRIUHYDVFXODULVDWLRQDWWHPSWVZDVFRPSDUDEOHLQWKH
LQWUDRSHUDWLYH+$7JURXS DQGWKHSRVWRSHUDWLYH+$7JURXS
3 0XOWLYDULDWHULVNIDFWRUVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKDQLQFUHDVHGLQFLGHQFHRIHDUO\
KHSDWLFDUWHU\WKURPERVLVDIWHUOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQZHUHFKLOGUHQUHWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
DQGUHGXFHGVL]HJUDIWV,QGHSHQGHQWULVNIDFWRUVIRUH+$7ZHUH &09 PLVPDWFK
GRQRUUHFLSLHQWFRPELQDWLRQ DORZHUSURWKURPELQWLPHDQGDKLJKHUOHYHORI
KDHPRJORELQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVXJJHVWVWKDWHDUO\GHWHFWLRQGRHVQRWUHVXOWLQDEHWWHURXWFRPH
RIH+$7LQWHUPVRIDORZHUUHWUDQVSODQWDWLRQUDWH$VDQDGGLWLRQDOSRWHQWLDOULVN
IDFWRUIRUH+$7ZHLGHQWLÀHGDKLJKKDHPRJORELQOHYHOLQWKHLPPHGLDWHSRVWRS
HUDWLYHSHULRG
%
%RG\FRPSRVLWLRQFKDQJHVDIWHUOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
$%D]]RFFKL36SLQQDWR$&HQQL3=DSSROL))X]]L*)LORQ]L
*%LDQFKL&5RVVL%RORJQD,73DUPD,7 IHGHULFDIX]]L#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7KH DLP RI WKH VWXG\ ZDV WR HYDOXDWH ERG\ FRPSRVLWLRQ FKDQJHV LQ
SDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJRUWKRWRSLFOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ 2/7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\WKUHHSDWLHQWV PDOHVDQGIHPDOHVPHDQ
DJHUDQJH\HDUV VXEPLWWHGWR2/7ZHUHSURVSHFWLYHO\HQUROOHGLQWKH
VWXG\3DWLHQWVVWDUWHGLPPXQRVXSSUHVVLYHWKHUDS\ZLWKGLIIHUHQWFRPELQDWLRQVRI
WUDFUROLPXVD]DWKLRSULQHDQGVWHURLGV,QDOOSDWLHQWVDERG\FRPSRVLWLRQDQDO\VLV
ZDVSHUIRUPHGE\DQHZGXDOHQHUJ\[UD\DEVRUSWLRPHWU\HTXLSPHQW /XQDUL';$
*(+HDOWKFDUH EHIRUHDQGDIWHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ DQGPRQWKV )DW
PDVV )0 QRQERQH OHDQ PDVV /0 ERQH PLQHUDO FRQWHQW DQG GHQVLW\ ZHUH
DVVHVVHGLQDWKUHHFRPSDUWPHQWZKROHERG\DQGUHJLRQDOPRGHO
5HVXOWV$OO SDWLHQWV FRQFOXGHG WKH IROORZXS SURJUDP )RXU RXW RI
SDWLHQWV SUHVHQWHG ZLWK GLDEHWHV EHIRUH 2/7 DQG ZHUH GLDEHWLF
DIWHUVXUJHU\7RWDODQGDQGURLG)0/0VKRZHGDVOLJKWGHFUHDVHDWPRQWKVEXW
UDWLRVURVHXSLQWKHVXEVHTXHQWPRQWKVZLWKVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHV
EHWZHHQPRQWKYDOXHVDQGEDVHOLQH S IRUWRWDOERG\IRUDQGURLG
UHJLRQ $QGURLGJ\QRLGLQGH[RIIDWGLVWULEXWLRQGLGQRWVKRZDQ\VLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJH
DIWHUWUDQVSODQW,QVXOLQWUHDWPHQWGLGQRWVLJQLÀFDQWO\DIIHFWDQ\ERG\FRPSRVL
WLRQSDUDPHWHUZKLOHVWHURLGGRVDJHZDVLQYHUVHO\FRUUHODWHGZLWKDQGURLG)0
/0UDWLR S
&RQFOXVLRQ%RG\FRPSRVLWLRQDVVHVVPHQWLVHVVHQWLDOLQWKHXQGHUVWDQGLQJRI
SK\VLRSDWKRORJ\DQGPHWDEROLFUHODWHGGLVRUGHUVDQG';$LVDYDOLGWRRODWWKLVDLP
3DWLHQWVVXEPLWWHGWR2/7VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWFKDQJHVRIWKHLUERG\FRPSRVLWLRQ
WKDWPLJKWEHUHODWHGWRGLIIHUHQWPHWDEROLFGHVWLQLHV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHUHSURGXFLELOLW\RIWZRSRLQW',;21 3' WHFKQLTXHIRU
PHDVXULQJKHSDWLFIDWIUDFWLRQ +)) LQKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVKHDOWK\VXEMHFWV 0)DJH \HDUV%0,
NJP ZHUHLQFOXGHG$OO05,H[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGRQD7
VFDQQHU 0$*1(720$HUD6LHPHQV %UHDWKKROG3'ZDVSHUIRUPHGD[LDOO\
XVLQJDJUDGLHQWHFKRVHTXHQFHZLWK7( PV RXWRISKDVH 23 DQGLQ
SKDVH ,3 UHVSHFWLYHO\ +))PDSVZHUHFDOFXODWHGDV 6,LQ6,RXW [6,LQ [
3URWRQPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHVSHFWURVFRS\ 056 ZDVDOVRSHUIRUPHGXVLQJEUHDWK
KROG67($0RYHUD[[FPYR[HOZLWK757( PVDQGDYHUDJHV
$IWHU7FRUUHFWLRQ+))ZDVWKHQFDOFXODWHGDVDUHDOLSLG DUHDZDWHUDUHDOLSLG
['XSOLFDWHPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHDFTXLUHGDIWHUUHSRVLWLRQLQJ5HSURGXFLELOLW\
ZDVDVVHVVHGXVLQJFRHIÀFLHQWRIYDULDWLRQ &9 UHSHDWDELOLW\FRHIÀFLHQW 5& DQG
LQWUDFODVVFRUUHODWLRQFRHIÀFLHQW ,&&
5HVXOWV+))PHDVXUHGXVLQJ3'DQG056IRUDOOVXEMHFWVZHUHDQG
UHVSHFWLYHO\ U S &9IRU+))XVLQJ3'
ZDV VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU S WZRWDLOHG :LOFR[RQ PDWFKHG SDLUV WHVW WKDQ
WKDWXVLQJ056 6LPLODUO\5&RI3' +)) ZDVVLJ
QLÀFDQWO\ORZHU S WKDQWKDWRI056 +)) 0RUHRYHU,&&IRU
3' ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU S WKDQWKDWIRU056
&RQFOXVLRQ3'VKRZVKLJKHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\WKDQ056LQPHDVXULQJ+))QRQ
LQYDVLYHO\:LWKRXWH[WHQVLYHSRVWSURFHVVLQJDQDO\VLV3'PD\RIIHUSURPLVHDVD
UREXVWWRROWRPHDVXUH+))IRUWKHHQWLUHOLYHUUHSURGXFLEO\LQGLDJQRVLVWUHDWPHQW
DQGIROORZXSRIKHSDWLFVWHDWRVLVDWFOLQLFDOÀHOGVWUHQJWKZLWKLQDVLQJOHEUHDWKKROG
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
3UHRSHUDWLYHO\PSKQRGHVWDJLQJLQSDWLHQWVZLWKUHFWDOFDQFHUXVLQJ
G\QDPLFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJLQLWLDOUHVXOWV
79DJ-6ORWWD+XVSHQLQD81LWVFKH55RVHQEHUJ(5XPPHQ\-*DD
0XQLFK'( WLERUYDJ#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHDFFXUDF\RIG\QDPLF05,IRUSUHRSHUDWLYHO\PSKQRGH
VWDJLQJLQUHFWDOFDQFHUXVLQJFRPSXWHULVHGDQDO\VLV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVUHFHLYHGSUHRSHUDWLYHG\QDPLF05, 7
V\VWHP9,%(VHTXHQFHVLQPLQXWHLQWHUYDOVIRUDWRWDORIPLQXWHV LGHQWLI\LQJ
O\PSKQRGHVORFDWHGLQWKHPHVRUHFWDOIDW&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHPHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFV
RILGHQWLÀHGO\PSKQRGHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGXVLQJFRPSXWHUDLGHGDQDO\VLVVRIWZDUH
7KHSURJUDPDQDO\VHVWLPHLQWHQVLW\FXUYHVYR[HOZLVHZLWKLQDPDQXDOO\VHWYROXPH
RILQWHUHVWDQGVXPPDULVHVWKHSHUFHQWXDOGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHGLIIHUHQWHQKDQFH
PHQWSDWWHUQVLQDSURÀOHPDS$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWUHFWDOUHVHFWLRQZLWKWRWDO
PHVRUHFWDOH[FLVLRQ,GHQWLÀHGO\PSKQRGHVRQ05,ZHUHFRPSDUHGWKRVHIURP
KLVWRSDWKRORJLFH[DPLQDWLRQV
5HVXOWV O\PSK QRGHV GHPRQVWUDWHG PHWDVWDWLF LQYROYHPHQW DW KLVWRSDWKR
ORJLFDOH[DPLQDWLRQO\PSKQRGHVZHUHIUHHRIPHWDVWDVLV0HDQSHUFHQWXDO
GLVWULEXWLRQRIHQKDQFHPHQWSDWWHUQVLQPDOLJQDQWO\PSKQRGHVVKRZHGUDSLGLQLWLDO
HQKDQFHPHQWIROORZHGE\GHFUHDVHLQWKHODWHSKDVH ´ZDVKRXWµ LQDQG
UDSLGHQKDQFHPHQWIROORZHGE\ÁDWWHQLQJ ´SODWHDXµ RUE\LQFUHDVHLQWKHGHOD\HG
SKDVH ´SHUVLVWHQWµ LQDQGUHVSHFWLYHO\,QFRPSDULVRQGLVWULEXWLRQ
RI HQKDQFHPHQW SDWWHUQV LQ QHJDWLYH O\PSK QRGHV GHPRQVWUDWHG ZDVKRXW SDW
WHUQLQ 3 SODWHDXSDWWHUQLQ 3 DQGSHUVLVWHQWSDWWHUQ
LQ 3
&RQFOXVLRQ'\QDPLFPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJZLWKFRPSXWHULVHGHYDOXDWLRQ
RIHQKDQFHPHQWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVPLJKWLQFUHDVHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\LQGLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ
SRVLWLYHIURPQHJDWLYHO\PSKQRGHVLQUHFWDOFDQFHU
%
6WDQGDUGLVHGFLQHORRSLQDEGRPLQDOXOWUDVRXQG\LHOGVKLJKUHOLDELOLW\
RIVRQRJUDSKLFÀQGLQJV
-'RUPDJHQ0*DDUGHU$'UROVXP2VOR12 MREDGRU#IULVXUIQR
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH DEGRPLQDO JUH\VFDOH XOWUDVRXQG ÀQGLQJV RI LPPHGLDWH
EHGVLGHUHDGLQJE\SHUIRUPLQJUDGLRORJLVWZLWKLQGHSHQGHQWRIÁLQHUHDGLQJE\D
QRQSHUIRUPLQJUDGLRORJLVW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2YHUDVL[PRQWKSHULRGWKUHHUDGLRORJLVWVSHUIRUPHG
G\QDPLFXOWUDVRXQGH[DPLQDWLRQVLQRXWGRRUSDWLHQWV([DPLQDWLRQSURWRFROV
ZHUHVWDQGDUGLVHGZLWKSUHGHÀQHGSUREHSRVLWLRQDQGVHTXHQFHVRIVKRUWFLQHORRSV
RIWKHOLYHUJDOOEODGGHUSDQFUHDVNLGQH\VDQGXULQHEODGGHUFRYHULQJWKHRUJDQV
FRPSOHWHO\LQWZRSODQV7KHVWXGLHVZHUHUHYLHZHGDQGUHDGRXWLPPHGLDWHO\E\
WKHSHUIRUPLQJUDGLRORJLVW2IÁLQHUHDGLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGEOLQGHGE\DUDGLRORJLVW
ZKRKDGQRWSHUIRUPHGWKHH[DPLQDWLRQ,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVUHJLVWHUHGIURP QR
GLDJQRVWLFYDOXH WR H[FHOOHQWFLQHORRSTXDOLW\ %HGVLGHDQGRIÁLQHUHDGLQJZHUH
FRPSDUHGZLWKHDFKRWKHUDQGZLWKFRQVHQVXVUHVXOWV
5HVXOWV,QH[DPLQDWLRQVFRQVHQVXVUHDGLQJUHYHDOHGFDVHVZLWKUHQDO
GLVRUGHUVFDVHVZLWKOLYHUDQGELOHSDWKRORJ\DQGFDVHVZLWKEODGGHUSDWKRO
RJ\2YHUDOOLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWZDV &, ZLWKORZHVW
DJUHHPHQWIRUÀQGLQJVRIWKHXULQHEODGGHU DQGKLJKHVWDJUHHPHQWLQOLYHU
H[DPLQDWLRQV 'LVDJUHHPHQWVEHWZHHQWKHWZRUHDGLQJVZHUHVHHQLQQLQH
NLGQH\VWKUHHEODGGHUH[DPLQDWLRQVWZRSDQFUHDVDQGELOHV\VWHPH[DPLQDWLRQV
HDFKDQGLQRQHOLYHUJLYLQJDQXPEHURIPLVPDWFKHVRI1HDUO\DOOFDVHV
RIPLVPDWFKZHUHRIPLQRUFOLQLFDOVLJQLÀFDQFH7KHPHGLDQLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDV
%HGVLGHFRQVHQVXV GLVFUHSDQFLHV GLG QRW GLIIHU VLJQLÀFDQWO\ IURP RIÁLQH
FRQVHQVXVGLVFUHSDQFLHV
&RQFOXVLRQ6WDQGDUGLVHGG\QDPLFFLQHORRSWHFKQLTXHLQDEGRPLQDOXOWUDVRXQG
\LHOGVKLJKUHOLDELOLW\RIÀQGLQJV,PDJHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQFDQEHSHUIRUPHGLQGHSHQG
HQWO\IURPSHUIRUPLQJEHGVLGHH[DPLQDWLRQ
%
&KDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIDGUHQDOPDVVHVXVLQJVLQJOHSKDVHGXDOHQHUJ\&7
$+HOFN1+XPPHO7-RKQVRQ05HLVHU$*UDVHU
0XQLFK'( DQGUHDVKHOFN#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHGLDJQRVWLFDFFXUDF\RIGXDOHQHUJ\&7EDVHGDWWHQXDWLRQ
PHDVXUHPHQWVLQWKHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIDGUHQDOPDVVHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H UHWURVSHFWLYHO\ LGHQWLÀHG SDWLHQWV ZLWK DGUHQDO
PDVVHVZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHVLQJOHSKDVHDEGRPLQDOFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGGXDOHQ
HUJ\&7 RUN9SN9S RQDGXDOVRXUFHVFDQQHU 6LHPHQV6RPDWRP
'HÀQLWLRQ'HÀQLWLRQ)ODVK IRUYDULRXVLQGLFDWLRQV8VLQJGHGLFDWHGSRVWSURFHVVLQJ
WHFKQLTXHV YLUWXDO QRQHQKDQFHG DQG FRORXUFRGHG LRGLQH RYHUOD\ LPDJHV ZHUH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
JHQHUDWHGZKLFKDOORZGLUHFWPHDVXUHPHQWRISUHDQGSRVWFRQWUDVWGHQVLW\RQD
VLQJOHSKDVHDFTXLVLWLRQ'LDJQRVLVRIDGUHQDODGHQRPDZDVPDGHLI&7GHQVLW\
LQ WKH YLUWXDO QRQHQKDQFHG LPDJH ZDV ORZHU WKDQ +8 /RQJWHUP IROORZXS
QRQFRQWUDVW&7LQDQGRSSRVHGSKDVH05,VHUYHGDVWKHVWDQGDUGRIUHIHUHQFH
5HVXOWV%DVHGRQIROORZXSLPDJLQJ RIWKHDGUHQDOPDVVHVZHUH
EHQLJQDGUHQDODGHQRPDV$WDFXWRIIYDOXHRI+8YLUWXDOQRQHQKDQFHGLPDJHV
DOORZHGIRUFRUUHFWGLDJQRVLVLQRIFDVHV ZKHUHDVDGUHQDODGHQRPDV
ZHUHOLSLGSRRUZLWKDGHQVLW\KLJKHUWKDQ+8
&RQFOXVLRQ9LUWXDOQRQHQKDQFHGLPDJHVIURPGXDOHQHUJ\&7DOORZIRUDFFXUDWH
FKDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIDGUHQDOPDVVHV'(&7WKHUHIRUHKHOSVWRDYRLGXQQHFHVVDU\
IROORZXSLPDJLQJ QRQFRQWUDVW&705,
5RRP/0
&RQWUDVW0HGLD
66
$SSOLFDWLRQVLQ86&7DQG05,
0RGHUDWRUV
&8+HUERUQ+DPEXUJ'(
35HLPHU.DUOVUXKH'(
%
&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGHUURUVDQGDUWHIDFWV
0-HGU]HMF]\N.76]RSLQVNL:DUVDZ3/ NV]RSLQVNL#ZXPHGXSO
3XUSRVH&RQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG &(86 LVWHFKQLFDOO\GHPDQGLQJDQG
PDQ\IDFWRUVFDQLQÁXHQFHWKHTXDOLW\RIWKHH[DPLQDWLRQ$UHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VLV
ZDV SHUIRUPHG WR DVVHVV WKH IUHTXHQF\ DQG VHYHULW\ RI HUURUV DQG DUWHIDFWV LQ
&(86H[DPLQDWLRQV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHÀOPVRI&(86H[DPLQDWLRQVRIWKHOLYHUNLG
QH\VERZHOEUHDVWWK\URLGO\PSKQRGHVVRIWWLVVXHWXPRXUVDQGPXVFOHVZHUH
UHYLHZHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\7KHH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUHSHUIRUPHGZLWKORZPHFKDQLFDO
LQGH[WHFKQLTXHXVLQJWKH6RQR9XH %UDFFR$OWDQD FRQWUDVWDJHQW &$ 7KHHUURUV
DQGDUWHIDFWVZHUHVXEGLYLGHGLQWRPDFKLQHVHWWLQJVUHODWHG LQFRUUHFWPDFKLQH
VHWWLQJV &$UHODWHG SUHSDUDWLRQ DQG DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI WKH FRQWUDVW PHGLXP
SDWLHQWUHODWHG ODUJH ERG\ KDELWXV SDWLHQW SUHSDUDWLRQ FRRSHUDWLRQ ZLWK WKH
SDWLHQW H[DPLQDWLRQWHFKQLTXHUHODWHGDQGDUFKLYLQJDQGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQHUURUV$
VHULRXVHUURUZDVGHÀQHGDVWKHRQHZKLFKFRXOGDGYHUVHO\DIIHFWWKHGLDJQRVLV
RUUHTXLUHDUHSHDWH[DPLQDWLRQ
5HVXOWV ,Q UHYLHZHG ÀOHV HUURUV ZHUH GHWHFWHG RI H[DPLQD
WLRQV $PRQJWKHHUURUVZHUHVHULRXV RIWKHH[DPLQDWLRQVRI
DOOHUURUV 0RVWHUURUVZHUHPDFKLQHVHWWLQJVUHODWHG DQGSDWLHQWUHODWHG
+RZHYHUWKHJUHDWHVWSHUFHQWDJHRIVHULRXVHUURUVZDVQRWHGLQ&$UHODWHG
DQGH[DPLQDWLRQWHFKQLTXHUHODWHG HUURUV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHHUURUVDQGDUWHIDFWVDUHFRPPRQLQ&(862IWHQWKH\FDQLPSDLU
WKHÀQDOGLDJQRVLV7KH\KDYHWREHUHFRJQLVHGDQGWDNHQLQWRDFFRXQWVLQFHWKH
SURSRUWLRQRIVHULRXVHUURUVLVVXEVWDQWLDO
%
%ROXVYHUVXVFRQWLQXRXVLQIXVLRQRIPLFUREXEEOHFRQWUDVWDJHQWIRU
OLYHU86XVLQJDQDXWRPDWLFSRZHULQMHFWRU
(4XDLD%&DELEER63XOYLUHQWL:7RVFDQR0&RYD7ULHVWH,7
TXDLD#XQLWVLW
3XUSRVH7RSURVSHFWLYHO\DVVHVVLIFRQWLQXRXVLQIXVLRQRIVXOSKXUKH[DÁXRULGH
ÀOOHGPLFUREXEEOHVFDQSURORQJWKHGXUDWLRQRIKHSDWLFHQKDQFHPHQWDWXOWUDVRQRJ
UDSK\RYHUEROXVLQMHFWLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PDOHVDQGIHPDOHVPHDQDJH6'
UHFHLYHGWZRLQMHFWLRQVRQHEROXVLQMHFWLRQ P/VHF DQGRQHFRQWLQXRXV
LQIXVLRQ P/PLQ ZLWKWKHVDPHGRVH P/ RIVXOSKXUKH[DÁXRULGHÀOOHG
PLFUREXEEOHVLQMHFWHGWKURXJKDIRUHDUPRUDQWHFXELWDOYHLQWKURXJKDQJDXJH
LQWUDYHQRXVFDWKHWHUXVLQJDQDXWRPDWLFSRZHULQMHFWRU2QHXQHQKDQFHGEDVHOLQH
VZHHSVFDQ PHFKDQLFDOLQGH[RI RIWKHULJKWOLYHUOREHZDVDFTXLUHGRQWKH
ORQJLWXGLQDOSODQHIROORZHGE\FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGVZHHSVDIWHUEROXVLQMHFWLRQDQG
FRQWLQXRXVLQIXVLRQ(DFKVZHHSZDVVDYHGDV',&20FLQHFOLSVDQGDQDO\VHG
E\ D GHGLFDWHG VRIWZDUH ZKLFK FDOFXODWHG WKH JUDGH RI FRQWUDVW HQKDQFHPHQW
H[SUHVVHGDVWKHSHUFHQWDJHLQFUHDVHRIHFKRVLJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQJUD\VFDOHOHYHOV
RYHUEDVHOLQHVFDQ
5HVXOWV 'XUDWLRQ RI HQKDQFHPHQW ZDV SURORQJHG E\ FRQWLQXRXV LQIXVLRQ IURP
PLQXWHVDWEROXVLQMHFWLRQWRPLQXWHV 3 1RGLIIHUHQFH
LQWKHPD[LPDOSDUHQFK\PDOHQKDQFHPHQWZDVREVHUYHGRQEROXVYVFRQWLQXRXV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
PLFUREXEEOHLQIXVLRQLQFUHDVHRYHUEDVHOLQH EROXVLQMHFWLRQ DQG
LQFUHDVHRYHUEDVHOLQH LQIXVLRQ3
&RQFOXVLRQ &RQWLQXRXV LQIXVLRQ RI VXOSKXU KH[DÁXRULGHÀOOHG PLFUREXEEOHV
SHUIRUPHGWKURXJKDXWRPDWLFSRZHULQMHFWRUSURORQJVWKHKHSDWLFHQKDQFHPHQW
ZLWKRXWPRGLI\QJWKHPD[LPDOSDUHQFK\PDOHQKDQFHPHQWRYHUWKHEDVHOLQH
%
3URVSHFWLYHHYDOXDWLRQRIYDVFXODUDOWHUDWLRQVLQOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
E\LQWUDRSHUDWLYH&(86FRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDO'RSSOHU86D
SLORWVWXG\
1/HR(9LEHUW2&LDFLR/5LFFD5$GDP'&DVWDLQJ0/HZLQ
9LOOHMXLI)5 XVWUH#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH RI LQWUDRSHUDWLYH PLFUREXEEOH
FRQWUDVWPDWHULDOHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ &(86 IRUDVVHVVPHQWRIYDVFXODU
DOWHUDWLRQVLQOLYHUWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ /7 FRPSDUHGZLWKLQWUDRSHUDWLYHFRQYHQWLRQDO
'RSSOHUXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 86
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV7ZHQW\ SDWLHQWV ZHUH LQFOXGHG PDOHV IHPDOHV
DYHUDJHDJH\HDUVROG /7SDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWERWKLQWUDRSHUDWLYHFRQYHQWLRQDO
'RSSOHU86DQG&(86YDVFXODUH[DPLQDWLRQVXVLQJDQ$ORND$OSKDGHYLFHDQG
LQWUDYHQRXVPLFUREXOOHVDVDFRQWUDVWDJHQW
5HVXOWV,QWZRSDWLHQWV'RSSOHU86ZDVQRUPDOZKLOHWKH&(86ZDVQRWLQRQH
FDVH&(86VKRZHGÁRZUHGXFWLRQLQKHSDWLFYHLQVDQGWKHRWKHUVKRZHGDUWHU\
ÁRZDOWHUDWLRQGXHWRDV\PSWRPDWLFDUFXDWHOLJDPHQW7KHVHUHVXOWVKDGLPPHGL
DWHPHGLFDODQGVXUJLFDOLPSOLFDWLRQV,QDQRWKHUWZRSDWLHQWV'RSSOHU86IDLOHG
WRYLVXDOLVHKHSDWLFDUWHU\ÁRZZKLOHWKLVÁRZZDVVKRZQE\&(867KXV'RSSOHU
86ZDVZURQJLQRISDWLHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ ,QWUDRSHUDWLYH &(86 FOHDUO\ LPSURYHV WKH UHOHYDQFH RI YDVFXODU
LPDJHU\LQ/7SDWLHQWVDVFRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDO'RSSOHU867KLVWHFKQLTXH
VKRXOGEHUHFRPPHQGHGIRUDEHWWHUPDQDJHPHQWRIWKHVHSDWLHQWV
%
(YDOXDWLRQLQYLWURRIQHZSRO\PHULFFRQWUDVWPLFUREXEEOHVXVLQJ
4RQWUDVWVRIWZDUH
90LJDOHGGX96DQQD'6FDQX*3LQWXV'6LULJX68]]DX00DU]R
06HFKL*9LUJLOLR6DVVDUL,7 PLJDOHGGX#VPLUJRUJ
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHLQYLWURXVLQJXOWUDVRXQGWKHUHÁHFWLYLW\RIQHZSURWRW\SHV
RIPLFUREXEEOHV 0%V FRQWDLQLQJDLUZLWKWKHVKHOORIGLIIHUHQWELRFRPSDWLEOHDQG
ELRGHJUDGDEOHFRSRO\PHUVSRO\ODFWLFDFLG 3/$ SRO\JO\FROLFODFWLFDFLG 3*/$
DQG3*/$FRQMXJDWHGZLWKSRO\HWK\OHQHJO\FRO 3*/$3(*
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV8VLQJDQH[SHULPHQWDOPRGHORIGHJDVVHGDQGGHLRQLVHG
ZDWHUHDFKVDPSOHRI0%VZDVHYDOXDWHGZLWKD0+]FRQYH[SUREH 6HTXRLD
$FXVRQ6LHPHQV 8OWUDVRXQGLPDJLQJZDVREWDLQHGXVLQJDFRQWUDVWVSHFLÀFVRIW
ZDUH &DGHQFH&RQWUDVW3XOVH6HTXHQFLQJ $TXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVRIWKHHFKRHV
LQWHQVLW\ZDVSHUIRUPHGWKURXJKWKHVSHFLÀF4RQWUDVWVRIWZDUH $GYDQFHG0HGL
FDO,PDJLQJ'HYHORSPHQW%UDFFR,WDO\ VHOHFWLQJPDQXDOO\DUHJLRQRILQWHUHVW
5HVXOWV7KHLQWHQVLW\RIVLJQDOSURGXFHGE\WKHGLIIHUHQW0%VKDVEHHQFRPSDUHG
WR WKDW RI ZDWHU (DFK 0%V SURWRW\SH GHPRQVWUDWHG D VLJQDO UHODWHG WR FRDWLQJ
FRPSRVLWLRQ6LJQDOLQWHQVLW\LQFUHDVHGLQWKHRUGHU3/$3/*$3/*$3(*
LQSDUWLFXODUHUHVSHFWLYHO\REWDLQLQJDVLJQLÀFDQW
VWDWLVWLFDOFRUUHODWLRQ S
&RQFOXVLRQ0%VZLWKVKHOORI3/*$3(*UHVXOWHGWKHPRVWHIIHFWLYHLQWHUPVRI
UHÁHFWLYLW\DIWHUH[SRVXUHWRXOWUDVRXQG6RWKH\PLJKWEHIXUWKHURSWLPLVHGDQG
XVHGDVSRWHQWLDOFDUULHUVIRUVHOHFWLYHGUXJGHOLYHU\
%
7KHHIÀFDF\RIFRQWUDVWSURWRFROLQOLYHUG\QDPLF&7PXOWLFHQWUH
SURVSHFWLYHVWXG\LQFRPPXQLW\KRVSLWDOVLQ-DSDQ
02NDGD+.RQGR+6RX70XUDNDPL0.DQHPDWVX7,FKLNDZD
.$ZDL.<RVKLPLWVX<<DPDVKLWD2VDND6D\DPD-3*LIX-3.RIX-3
+LURVKLPD-3)XNXRND-3.XPDPRW-3
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
%
'LDJQRVWLFXWLOLW\RIGRXEOHFRQWUDVW05, '&05, IRUHYDOXDWLRQ
RIWUHDWPHQWUHVSRQVHRIKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPDWRDEODWLYH
WUHDWPHQWV 7$&(3(,5)$
$&HQWROD/36WRSSLQR&%ULVWRJLDQQLV*6DQWDQJHOR30LOLOOR3/XSR
59LQFL/0DFDULQL)RJJLD,7 DQQDULWDFHQWROD#IDVWZHEQHWLW
3XUSRVH7RDVVHVVUHFXUUHQFHRIGLVHDVHLQKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD +&& QRG
XOHVDIWHUORFRUHJLRQDOWUHDWPHQWE\VHTXHQWLDOXVHRIVXSHUSDUDPDJQHWLFLURQR[LGH
63,2 DQGWKHJDGROLQLXPGLHWK\OHQHWULDPLQHSHQWDDFHWLFDFLG *G'73$ FRQWUDVW
DJHQWVFRPSDUHGZLWKXQHQKDQFHG05,DQG63,2HQKDQFHG05, 63,205,
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HHQUROOHGFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWVDIIHFWHGE\KHSDWLF
FLUUKRVLV ZLWK D WRWDO RI +&& QRGXOHV WUHDWHG E\ ORFRUHJLRQDO WUHDWPHQWV
SDWLHQWVZHUHWUHDWHGZLWKWUDQVDUWHULDOFKHPRHPEROLVDWLRQ 7$&( SDWLHQWVZLWK
UDGLRIUHTXHQF\ DEODWLRQ 5)$ DQG SDWLHQWV ZHUH WUHDWHG ZLWK SHUFXWDQHRXV
HWKDQROLQMHFWLRQ 3(, '&05,VWXG\ZDVSHUIRUPHGRQHPRQWKDIWHUWUHDWPHQW
5HVXOWV$YLDEOH+&&ZDVIRXQGLQRIQRGXOHV WUHDWHGE\7$&(LQ
RIQRGXOHV WUHDWHGE\3(,DQGLQRIQRGXOHV WUHDWHGE\
5)$,QDOOWKHVHFDVHV'&05,WHFKQLTXHFODULÀHGWKH05SLFWXUHLPSURYLQJWKH
SRVVLELOLW\WRGLDJQRVHWKHSUHVHQFHRUDEVHQFHRIYLDEOH+&&ZLWKLQSRVWWUHDWPHQW
OLYHUÀEURVLVDVZHOODVDQHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIG\VSODVWLFQRGXOHVE\FRPSDULQJ
XQHQKDQFHG05,63,2HQKDQFHGDQG'&05LPDJHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHFRPELQHGXVHRIWZRFRQWUDVWDJHQWV QHJDWLYHDQGSRVLWLYH
LPSURYHG WKH GLDJQRVLV RI YLDEOH WXPRXU LQ WUHDWHG +&& ZLWKLQ SRVWWUHDWPHQW
OLYHUÀEURVLV
%
0DJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJFRQWUDVWRIEUDLQWXPRXUVDW7HVOD
FRPSDUHGWR7HVODHQKDQFHPHQWDIWHUKDOIDQGIXOOURXWLQH
FRQWUDVWDJHQWGRVH
,01RHEDXHU+XKPDQQ36]RPRODQ\L9-XUDV&.URQQHUZHWWHU
06FKPRRN'3D\HU67UDWWQLJ9LHQQD$7 LULVQRHEDXHU#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFHIÀFDF\RIDKDOIDQGDIXOOGRVHRIJDGROLQLXP
EDVHG05FRQWUDVWDJHQWLQSULPDU\EUDLQWXPRXUVDW7HVOD05YHUVXV7HVOD
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PIPHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH
ZLWK PDOLJQDQW SULPDU\ EUDLQ WXPRXUV ZHUH H[DPLQHG RQ ERWK D 7HVOD DQG
D7HVOD05ZKROHERG\XQLW%HIRUHDQGDIWHULQWUDYHQRXVDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRI
*DGREHQDWH GLPHJOXPLQH LQ D GRVDJH RI PPRONJ DQG PPRONJ ERG\
ZHLJKWDVDJLWWDO'*5(VHTXHQFHZLWKPDJQHWLVDWLRQSUHSDUDWLRQ 035$*(
ZLWK757(7,PVHFDW7HVODDQG757(7,PV
DW7HVODZHUHSHUIRUPHG6LJQDOLQWHQVLWLHVE\UHJLRQRILQWHUHVWPHDVXUHPHQWV
LQWKHOHVLRQDQGWKHFRQWUDODWHUDOQRUPDOZKLWHDQGJUH\PDWWHUZHUHDVVHVVHG
DQGWKHEDFNJURXQGQRLVHZDVPHDVXUHG7KHWXPRXUWREUDLQFRQWUDVWZDVFDO
FXODWHG)RUVWDWLVWLFDODQDO\VLVWZRZD\$129$WHVWVIRUUHSHDWHGPHDVXUHVDQG
SDLUHGWWHVWVZHUHXVHG
5HVXOWV7KHPHDQWXPRXUWREUDLQFRQWUDVWDIWHUFRQWUDVWDJHQWDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUDW7HVODWKDQDW7HVODIRUERWKKDOIWKHGRVH
YV DQGWKHIXOOURXWLQHGRVH YV S
7KHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQKDOIDQGIXOOGRVHDWHDFKÀHOGVWUHQJWKZDVDOVRVWDWLVWL
FDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW S 7KHUHZDVQRGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQKDOIWKHGRVHDW
7HVODDQGWKHIXOOGRVHDW7HVOD S
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWLWLVSRVVLEOHWRUHGXFHWKHFRQWUDVWDJHQW
GRVHLQWKHH[DPLQDWLRQRIEUDLQWXPRXUVDW7HVOD
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH WKH HIIHFWV RI FRQWUDVW PDWHULDO &0 ZLWK IRXU GLIIHUHQW
LQMHFWLRQWHFKQLTXHVRQWKHFRQVSLFXLW\RIK\SHUYDVFXODUKHSDWRFHOOXODUFDUFLQRPD
+&& LQSDWLHQWVZLWKOLYHUGDPDJH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVXUYH\ZDVFRQGXFWHGLQLQVWLWXWLRQVDVSRVWPDU
NHWLQJVXUYHLOODQFHDQGOLYHUG\QDPLF&7GDWDRISDWLHQWVZLWK+&& FP
ZHUHREWDLQHG)RXULQMHFWLRQSURWRFROV $ERG\ZHLJKW %: WDLORUHGGRVHRI&0
PJ,P/RI,RKH[RO À[HGLQMHFWLRQGXUDWLRQ V À[HGDUWHULDOSKDVH $3
VFDQWLPLQJ%%:WDLORUHGGRVHRI&0À[HGLQMHFWLRQGXUDWLRQ V $3VFDQ
WLPLQJDGMXVWHGE\EROXVWUDFNLQJ&%:WDLORUHGGRVHRI&0À[HGLQMHFWLRQÁRZ
UDWH$3 VFDQ WLPLQJ DGMXVWHG E\ EROXV WUDFNLQJ ' P/ FRQVWDQW RI &0 DW
DQ\%:À[HGVFDQWLPLQJ ZHUHXVHG(QKDQFHPHQWRIWKHDRUWDDQGOLYHUDQG
WXPRXUWROLYHUFRQWUDVW 7/& DW$3DQGDWHTXLOLEULXPSKDVH (3 ZHUHFRPSDUHG
EHWZHHQWKHVHSURWRFROV
5HVXOWV7KUHHKXQGUHGDQGIRUW\RISDWLHQWVKDGK\SHUYDVFXODU+&&7KHUDWH
DVVHVVHG´JRRGRUEHWWHUµDV7/&DW$3ZHUH$%&DQG'
,QSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKHU%: !NJ TXDOLWDWLYH7/&DW$3DQGTXDQWLWDWLYH
DRUWLFHQKDQFHPHQWLQSURWRFRO$&ZHUHVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUWKDQWKRVHLQSURWRFRO
'ZKHUHDVTXDQWLWDWLYH7/&DW$3LQSURWRFRO$&ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUWKDQWKDW
LQSDWLHQWVZLWKORZHU%: NJ (QKDQFHPHQWRIOLYHUDQG7/&DW(3VKRZHG
QRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQSURWRFROV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJKHU%: !NJ SURWRFROVRI%:WDLORUHGGRVH
RI&0DQGRUÀ[HGLQMHFWLRQGXUDWLRQVKRXOGEHHPSOR\HGWRGLDJQRVHK\SHUYDV
FXODU+&&V
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
'RHVKLJKHUJDGROLQLXPFRQFHQWUDWLRQSOD\DUROHLQWKH
PRUSKRORJLFDVVHVVPHQWRIEUDLQWXPRXUV"5HVXOWVRIDPXOWLFHQWUH
LQWUDLQGLYLGXDOFURVVRYHUFRPSDULVRQRIJDGREXWUROYHUVXV
JDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH WKH0(5,7VWXG\
-9\PD]DO=6HLGO00HFKO0*R\DO0+HUPDQ03DVRZLF]
*6FKQHLGHU6%DVWLDQHOOR-5XVFDOOHGD3UDJXH&=%UQR&=
&DOJDU\$%&$2ORPRXF&=.UDNRZ3/+RPEXUJ6DDU'(3DYLD,7
%DUFHORQD(6 MRVHIY\PD]DO#KRPRONDF]
3XUSRVH7RLQWUDLQGLYLGXDOO\FRPSDUHDSSURYHGPPRONJGRVHVRIWKHKLJK
UHOD[LYLW\05FRQWUDVWDJHQWJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH 0XOWL+DQFH ZLWKWKHKLJK
FRQFHQWUDWLRQ DJHQW JDGREXWURO *DGRYLVW IRU FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG 05, RI EUDLQ
WXPRXUV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV$GXOWSDWLHQWVZLWKVXVSHFWHGRUNQRZQEUDLQWXPRXUV
XQGHUZHQWWZRLGHQWLFDO05,H[DPVDW7RQHZLWKJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHDQG
WKHRWKHUZLWKJDGREXWUROERWKDWDGRVHRIPPRONJERG\ZHLJKW7KHDJHQWV
ZHUHLQMHFWHGLQUDQGRPLVHGRUGHUVHSDUDWHGE\GD\V,PDJLQJVHTXHQFHV
DQG DFTXLVLWLRQ WLPLQJ ZHUH LGHQWLFDO IRU WKH WZR H[DPV7KUHH EOLQGHG UHDGHUV
HYDOXDWHGLPDJHVTXDOLWDWLYHO\IRUGLDJQRVWLFLQIRUPDWLRQ OHVLRQH[WHQWGHOLQHD
WLRQPRUSKRORJ\HQKDQFHPHQWJOREDOSUHIHUHQFH DQGTXDQWLWDWLYHO\IRUOHVLRQ
HQKDQFHPHQWFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 DQGOHVLRQWREDFNJURXQGUDWLR /%5
5HVXOWVRIHQUROOHGSDWLHQWVVXFFHVVIXOO\XQGHUZHQWERWKH[DPLQDWLRQV
)LQDOGLDJQRVHVZHUHLQWUDD[LDOWXPRXUVPHWDVWDVHVH[WUDD[LDOWXPRXUVҊRWKHUҋ
WXPRXUVDQGҊQRQWXPRXUҋ DQGVXEMHFWVUHVSHFWLYHO\ 5HDGHUV
DQGGHPRQVWUDWHGSUHIHUHQFHIRUJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHLQ
DQG SDWLHQWVUHVSHFWLYHO\FRPSDUHGZLWKDQGSDWLHQWV
IRUJDGREXWURO SDOOUHDGHUV +LJKO\VLJQLÀFDQW SDOOUHDGHUV
SUHIHUHQFHIRUJDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGIRUDOORWKHUTXDOLWDWLYH
HQGSRLQWV,QWHUUHDGHUDJUHHPHQWZDVJRRGIRUDOOHYDOXDWLRQV . ï
6LJQLÀFDQWO\VXSHULRUOHVLRQHQKDQFHPHQW&15DQG/%5ZDVGHWHUPLQHGIRU
JDGREHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQH SDOOUHDGHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKUHOD[LYLW\UDWKHUWKDQKLJKJDGROLQLXPFRQFHQWUDWLRQUHVXOWVLQ
VLJQLÀFDQWO\JUHDWHUPRUSKRORJLFLQIRUPDWLRQDQGOHVLRQHQKDQFHPHQWZKHQJDGR
EHQDWHGLPHJOXPLQHDQGJDGREXWURODUHFRPSDUHGDWHTXLYDOHQWPPRONJGRVHV
%
,URQR[LGHQDQRSDUWLFOHVIRUPDJQHWLFSDUWLFOHLPDJLQJ 03,
-+DHJHOH)09RJW-%DUNKDXVHQ70%X]XJ./XHGWNH%X]XJ
/EHFN'( KDHJHOH#UDGLRORJLHXQLOXHEHFNGH
3XUSRVH0DJQHWLFSDUWLFOHLPDJLQJ 03, LVDQHZWRPRJUDSKLFLPDJLQJPHWKRG
PHDVXULQJ WKH VSDWLDO FRQFHQWUDWLRQ RI VXSHUSDUDPDJQHWLFLURQR[LGHSDUWLFOHV
63,2V 'XH WR WKH KLJK VHQVLWLYH DQG IDVW GDWD DFTXLVLWLRQ FDSDELOLWLHV 03, LV
SHUIHFWO\VXLWHGIRUPROHFXODULPDJLQJDQGG\QDPLFPHDVXUHPHQWVHJTXDQWLWDWLYH
DVVHVVPHQWRIP\RFDUGLDOSHUIXVLRQ+RZHYHUVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQDVZHOODVVHQVL
WLYLW\KLJKO\GHSHQGRQWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIWKHQDQRSDUWLFOHV7KHUHIRUHRXUVWXG\
DLPHGWRFKDUDFWHULVHGLIIHUHQW63,2VZLWKUHJDUGWRWKHLUDSSOLFDELOLW\DV03,WUDFHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVSHFWUDOVLJQDOVWUHQJWK 666 DQGWKHWRWDOKDUPRQLF
GLVWRUWLRQ 7+' RIIRXUGLIIHUHQWFRPPHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOH63,2V 5HVRYLVW6LQHUHP
(QGRUHPDQG/XPLUHP DQGVHOIV\QWKHVLVHGGH[WUDQFRDWHG63,2VZHUHHYDOX
DWHGXVLQJDPDJQHWLFSDUWLFOHVSHFWURPHWHU 036 7KHPDJQHWLFDPSOLWXGHZDV
VHWWRP7WKHH[FLWDWLRQIUHTXHQF\ZDVN+]
5HVXOWV7KHVHOIV\QWKHVLVHG63,2VSHUIRUPHGEHVWEXWWKHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHWR5HVRYLVW 7+'YVG%DYHUDJH666[(YV[(
$P+]S 6LQHUHP 7+'G%666[( DQG(QGRUHP 7+'
G%666[( VKRZHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQIHULRUUHVXOWVZKHUHDV/XPLUHP
VKRZHGQRVLJQDODWDOO7KHGLIIHUHQFHVLQSHUIRUPDQFHFDQEHH[SODLQHGE\GLI
IHUHQWLURQFRUHVL]HVDQGWKHSUHVHQFHRI63,2DJJUHJDWHV
&RQFOXVLRQ 5HVRYLVW DQG WKH VHOIV\QWKHVLVHG 63,2V DUH ZHOO VXLWHG IRU 03,
DQGPD\EHDSSOLHGLQGLIIHUHQWFOLQLFDOVFHQDULRV+RZHYHUFRPSDUHGWRDSHUIHFW
FRPSRXQGWKHUHLVVWLOOURRPIRULPSURYHPHQWDQGWKHUHVXOWVRIWKLVVWXG\ZLOOJXLGH
WKHGHYHORSPHQWRIQHZDJHQWVZLWKRSWLPLVHGLURQFRUHVL]HDQGDJJUHJDELOLW\
%
&RQWUDVWPHGLXPLQMHFWLRQSURWRFROIRU&7DQJLRJUDSK\ZLWK&7
FRQWUDVWPHGLXPGRVHDGMXVWHGWRERG\VXUIDFHDUHDZLWKVLPXODWLRQ
.$PDNDZD)XNXRND-3 ND]XWRVKLBDPDNDZD#\EEQHMS
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVVWXG\ZDVWRHYDOXDWHWKHHIÀFLHQF\RIDFRPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ SURWRFROZLWKWKHFRQWUDVWPHGLXPGRVHDGMXVWHG
WRERG\VXUIDFHDUHD %6$ XVLQJDVLPXODWLRQPRGHO
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H SURGXFHG D SK\VLRORJLFDO SKDUPDFRNLQHWLF PRGHO
RI D FRQWUDVW HQKDQFHPHQW VLPXODWLRQ RI WKH DRUWD EDVHG RQ D FRPSDUWPHQW
PRGHO XVLQJ VRIWZDUH :H À[HG WKH FDUGLDF LQGH[ DV OPLQP 6LPXODWHG
WLPHHQKDQFHPHQWFXUYHVRI&7$DQGSHDN&7DWWHQXDWLRQYDOXHVIRUERG\ZHLJKWV
NJZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJWKUHHGLIIHUHQWSURWRFROVÀ[HGLRGLQHÁX[ J
VHF LRGLQHÁX[EDVHGRQERG\ZHLJKW PJVHFNJ DQGLRGLQHÁX[EDVHG
RQ%6$ PJVHFP $FRQWUDVWDJHQWDW PJPOZDVSRVWXODWHGWREH
LQMHFWHGIRUVHFRQGVLQWKHVHWZRH[DPLQDWLRQV
5HVXOWV8QOLNHSDVWVWXGLHVZHH[FOXGHGWKHHIIHFWVRIYDULDEOHFDUGLDFIXQFWLRQE\
À[LQJWKHFDUGLDFLQGH[,QWKLVPHWKRGWKHSURWRFRODGMXVWHGWR%6$GHPRQVWUDWHG
WKHOHDVWXQHYHQWLPHDWWHQXDWLRQFXUYHDWGLIIHUHQWERG\ZHLJKWVDQGWKHOHDVWYDUL
DWLRQLQHQKDQFHPHQWSHDNRIWKHWKUHHSURWRFROVVKRZLQJVWDWLVWLFDOGLIIHUHQFHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH FRQWUDVW PDWHULDO LQMHFWLRQ SURWRFRO DGMXVWHG WR %6$ SURYLGHG
DRUWLFHQKDQFHPHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWKDZLGHYDULHW\RIERG\ZHLJKWVPRUHFRQVLVW
HQWO\WKDQWKHRWKHUWZRSURWRFROV
5RRP12
9DVFXODU
66
&DURWLGDUWHULHV
0RGHUDWRUV
((VWHEDQ$O]LUD(6
$6SLQHOOL5RPH,7
%
&KDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIQHRYDVFXODULVDWLRQLQFDURWLGDWKHURVFOHURWLF
SODTXHVZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQG
'$&OHYHUW$+HOFN:6RPPHU76DDP05HLVHU
0XQLFK'( 'LUN&OHYHUW#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHXVHRIFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGLQWKHQHRYDVFX
ODULVDWLRQZLWKLQFDURWLGDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKNQRZQDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHVLQWKH
FDURWLGDUWHU\ZHUHH[DPLQHGZLWKFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGWRUROHRXWWKH
IHDWXUHVRIQHRYDVFXODULVDWLRQZLWKLQWKLVSODTXH$GGLWLRQDOO\WKHVHSODTXHVZHUH
DQDO\VHGDQGFRUUHODWHGZLWKSODTXHVL]HDQGHFKRJHQLFLW\)RUFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG
XOWUDVRXQGZHLQMHFWHGFFRI6RQR9XH %UDFFR,WDO\ LY7KHH[DPLQDWLRQVZHUH
SHUIRUPHGXVLQJWKH6RU6HTXRLD 6LHPHQV$FXVRQ0RXQWDLQ9LHZ
ZLWKDQ0+]RU0+]SUREHXVLQJWKH&36VRIWZDUH
5HVXOWV7KHUHZHUHDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHVRIZKLFK VRIWDQGPL[HG
HQKDQFHGDIWHULQMHFWLRQRI6RQR9XH7KHHQKDQFHPHQWRFFXUUHGIURPWKHFDURWLG
ZDOOWRWKHFHQWHURIWKHSODTXHZLWKDVKRUWOLQHSDWWHUQLQSODTXHVZKHUHDV
SODTXHVHQKDQFHGIURPERWKWKHFDURWLGZDOODQGWKHFDURWLGOXPHQZLWKMXVWD
OLWWOHVSRWSDWWHUQ7KHDUULYDOWLPHRIFRQWUDVWZDVODWHULQWKHSODTXHVWKDQLQWKH
FDURWLGDUWHU\DQGWKHWLPHWRSHDNZDVORQJHULQWKHSODTXHVWKDQLQWKHFDURWLG
OXPHQ$PRQJWKHXQHQKDQFHGSODTXHVZHUHKDUGZHUHFDOFLÀHGZHUH
VRIWDQGZHUHPL[HG7KHXQHQKDQFHGSODTXHVKDGDWKLFNQHVVRIPP
&RQFOXVLRQ,QRXUVPDOOSDWLHQWSRSXODWLRQFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGXOWUDVRXQGDOORZV
WKHG\QDPLFHYDOXDWLRQRIQHRYDVFXODULVDWLRQZLWKLQFDURWLGSODTXHVDQGQHRYDV
FXODULVDWLRQPD\FRUUHODWHZLWKSODTXHPRUSKRORJ\
%
&KDUDFWHULVDWLRQRIDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHRIFDURWLGDUWHULHV
KLJKUHVROXWLRQPXOWLVHTXHQFH05LPDJLQJYVFRORXU'RSSOHU
XOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 86
67DUWDUL55L]]DWL03ULQFLYDOOH.&DSHOOR*%HQHD/DJRVDQWR,7
/HJQDUR,7 VWDUWDUL#DOLFHLW
3XUSRVH7RLQYHVWLJDWHZKHWKHUKLJKUHVROXWLRQPXOWLVHTXHQFH05,PDJLQJRIWKH
YHVVHOZDOOFDURWLGDUWHULHVFDQGLIIHUHQWLDWHDWULVNVRIWSODTXHIURPVROLGÀEURXV
SODTXHPRUHDFFXUDWHO\WKDQFRORXU'RSSOHUXOWUDVRQRJUDSK\ 86
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KLVVWXG\LQFOXGHGFDURWLGDUWHULHVLQFRQVHFXWLYH
SDWLHQWVZKRXQGHUZHQWFDURWLGHQGDUWHUHFWRP\05, 7ZLWKQHXURYDVFXODU
DUUD\FRLO ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJPXOWLSOHVHTXHQFHVGLIIXVLRQZHLJKWHGLPDJLQJ
IDWVXSSUHVVHG7ZHLJKWHGÀUVWSDVV&(05$VWHDG\VWDWH'7KLJKUHVROXWLRQ
+5 &DURWLG SODTXHV ZHUH JURXSHG LQWR WKUHH FDWHJRULHV EDVHG RQ 05 VLJQDO
LQWHQVLW\DQG86SDWWHUQDWULVNVRIWSODTXHZLWKODUJHOLSLGQHFURWLFFRUH /1&
JURXS$ FRPSOH[ÀEURWLFFDOFLÀHGLQFOXGLQJDVHJPHQWRIOLSLGOLTXLGFRPSRQHQW
% KDUGSODTXHZLWKRXWVRIWFRQWHQW & $GGLWLRQDOYXOQHUDEOHSODTXHIHDWXUHV
OLNH,QWUDSODTXHKDHPRUUKDJH ,3+ DQGXOFHUDWLRQZHUHUHJLVWHUHG05DQG86
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
ÀQGLQJVZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKÀQGLQJVRIHQGDUWHUHFWRP\VSHFLPHQVFRQVLGHUHG
DVJROGVWDQGDUG
5HVXOWV)RXUSDWLHQWVZHUHH[FOXGHGIURPWKHVWXG\GXHWR05DUWHIDFWVRUEH
FDXVHQRW86DVVHVVDEOH,QWUDRSHUDWLYHÀQGLQJVDQGPDFURVFRSLFH[DPLQDWLRQ
RIHQGDUWHUHFWRP\VSHFLPHQVUHYHDOHGDWULVNVRIWSODTXHVFRPSOH[DQG
KDUGSODTXHV+505,FRUUHFWO\FODVVLÀHGDQGRISODTXHVRIJURXS
$%DQG&86LGHQWLÀHGDQGRIJURXS$%DQG&UHVSHFWLYHO\
,QSDWLHQWV05SLQSRLQWHGXOFHUDWHGSODTXHV RIWKHPLGHQWLÀHGE\86
DQGFDVHVRI,3+
&RQFOXVLRQ,QSDWLHQWVXQGHUJRLQJ&(05$05SODTXHFKDUDFWHULVDWLRQFRXOG
KDYHDSRWHQWLDOWRPRUHDFFXUDWHO\GLDJQRVHVRIWSODTXHZLWKODUJH/1&RUSODTXH
ZLWKIHDWXUHVRIYXOQHUDELOLW\LQFRPSDULVRQZLWKFRORXU'RSSOHU86
%
8OWUDORZGRVHGXDOVRXUFHFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\DQJLRJUDSK\RI
WKHVXSUDDRUWLFDUWHULHVXVLQJN9WXEHYROWDJHDKLJKSLWFKDQG
LWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQSUHOLPLQDU\UHVXOWV
'%HLW]NH51RO]*(GHOKDXVHU5(6FKHUQWKDQHU):ROI&3ODQN
-/DPPHU&/RHZH9LHQQD$7 GLHWULFKEHLW]NH#PHGXQLZLHQDFDW
3XUSRVH 7R HYDOXDWH LPDJH TXDOLW\ GLDJQRVWLF FRQÀGHQFH DQG UDGLDWLRQ GRVH
XVLQJN9WXEHYROWDJHDQGLWHUDWLYHLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRUKLJKSLWFKGXDO
VRXUFH&7DQJLRJUDSK\ '6&7$ RIWKHVXSUDDRUWLFDUWHULHVLQFRPSDULVRQWRD
N9VWDQGDUGSURWRFRO
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV'6&7$RIWKHVXSUDDRUWLFDUWHULHVZDVSHUIRUPHGLQ
SDWLHQWV UDQGRPO\ XVLQJ HLWKHU N9 SLWFK DQG LWHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ RU
N9SLWFKDQGÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ&RQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 DQG
VLJQDOWRQRLVH UDWLR 615 FDOFXODWLRQV ZHUH SHUIRUPHG WR REMHFWLYHO\ HYDOXDWH
LPDJHTXDOLW\LQYDVFXODUVHJPHQWV)RUVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\DIRXUSRLQW
VFDOHZDVDSSOLHGWRYDVFXODUVHJPHQWVLQHDFKSDWLHQWE\WZRUHDGHUV(IIHFWLYH
GRVHZDVXVHGWRFRPSDUHWKHGLIIHUHQFHVLQUDGLDWLRQGRVH
5HVXOWV 7KH XVH RI N9 DQG LWHUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ VKRZHG VLJQLÀFDQWO\
KLJKHU YHVVHO RSDFLÀFDWLRQ DQG UHGXFHG LPDJH QRLVH LQ DOO VHJPHQWV UHVXOWLQJ
LQVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU&15DQG615YDOXHVDWWKHOHYHORIWKHFDURWLGELIXUFDWLRQ
S DQGVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHU&15YDOXHVDWWKHOHYHORIWKHLQWHUQDOFDURWLG
DUWHU\ S FRPSDUHGWRN9DQGÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ7KHUHZDVQR
GLIIHUHQFHLQWKHVXEMHFWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\LQDOOYDVFXODUVHJPHQWV7KHHIIHFWLYH
GRVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUXVLQJN9 YVP6YS
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHXVHRIN9WXEHYROWDJHDKLJKSLWFKDQGLWHUDWLYHUHFRQVWUXF
WLRQLQ'6&7$RIWKHVXSUDDRUWLFDUWHULHVDOORZVIRUUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQGRZQ
WRP69ZLWKRXWLQÁXHQFLQJGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFH
%
&RPSDULVRQRIGLIIHUHQWHYDOXDWLRQFULWHULDRIFDURWLGDUWHU\
VWHQRVLVZLWKVOLFH&7UROHRIFURVVVHFWLRQDODUHDYHUVXVSHUFHQW
GLDPHWHUVWHQRVLV
$'$QQRQL*3RQWRQH$)RUPHQWL'$QGUHLQL(1RELOL)%HVDQD
*%DOOHULQL03HSL30RQWRUVL0LODQ,7 DQGUHDDQQRQL#FFIPLW
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
7LPHRIÁLJKWLPDJHVDYLDEOHDOWHUQDWLYHWRFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05
DQJLRJUDSK\DQGIDWVXSSUHVVHG7ZLPDJHVIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRI
FHUYLFDODUWHU\GLVVHFWLRQ"
(0&RSSHQUDWK1/XPPHO-/LQQ.1LNRODRX0)5HLVHU0'LFKJDQV
73IHIIHUNRUQ76DDP0XQLFK'( (YD&RSSHQUDWK#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RFRPSDUHWKHGLDJQRVWLFSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQRQHQKDQFHGWLPHRIÁLJKW
VHTXHQFH 72)05$ ZLWKIDWVXSSUHVVHGD[LDOFRURQDO7ZHLJKWHGLPDJHVDQG
FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGDQJLRJUDSK\ VWDQGDUG05, IRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRIFHUYLFDODUWHU\
GLVVHFWLRQ &$'
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVFRQVHFXWLYHSDWLHQWV ZRPHQPHQDJH
\HDUV ZLWKSURYHQ&$'RQVWDQGDUG05,KDGDQDGGLWLRQDO72)05$ 76LH
PHQV9HULR XVLQJGHGLFDWHGVXUIDFHFRLOV 0DFKQHW1HWKHUODQGV ZLWKLQGD\V
6HQVLWLYLW\ 6( VSHFLÀFLW\ 63 SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339139
DQGDFFXUDF\RI72)05$ZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJWKHVWDQGDUGSURWRFRODVJROG
VWDQGDUG,PDJHTXDOLW\DQGGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHZHUHDVVHVVHGE\WZRUDWHUV
LQ FRQVHQVXV GHFLVLRQ RQ D SRLQW VFDOH$ SYDOXH RI ZDV FRQVLGHUHG
VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQW
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVH[FHOOHQWDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ72)LPDJHVDQGWKHVWDQGDUG
SURWRFROIRUWKHSUHVHQFHDEVHQFHRI&$'ZLWKD&RKHQVNDSSDYDOXHRI
S 2Q72)LPDJHV&$'LQWKH9VHJPHQWRIWKHYHUWHEUDODUWHU\ZDV
PLVVHG,QDGGLWLRQ&$'ZDVIRXQGRQ72)LPDJHVZKLFKZHUHQRWVHHQZLWKWKH
VWDQGDUGSURWRFRO7KLVUHVXOWHGLQD6(63339139DQGDFFXUDF\RI
DQGUHVSHFWLYHO\,PDJHTXDOLW\GLGQRWGLIIHUVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWZHHQ
WKHWZRPHWKRGV+RZHYHUGLDJQRVWLFFRQÀGHQFHRIWKH72)VHTXHQFHZDVUDWHG
VLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUFRPSDUHGWRWKHVWDQGDUGSURWRFRO YVS
&RQFOXVLRQ)LQGLQJVRIWKLVVWXG\VXJJHVWWKDW72)LPDJLQJLVDYLDEOHDOWHUQDWLYH
WRWKHVWDQGDUGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHGSURWRFROIRUWKHGLDJQRVLVRI&$'
%
+HDGWRKHDGFRPSDULVRQRI&7$DQG7EODFNEORRG05,IRU
LGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIV\PSWRPDWLFFDURWLGSODTXHV
-0*ULPP$6FKLQGOHU)6FKZDU]&&&\UDQ
0'LFKJDQV7)UHLOLQJHU0)5HLVHU.1LNRODRX76DDP
0XQLFK'( MRFKHQJULPP#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHPXOWLGHWHFWRU
&7DQJLRJUDSK\ 0'&7$ ZLWKEODFNEORRG705, EE05, ZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHLU
DELOLW\WRLGHQWLI\V\PSWRPDWLFFDURWLGSODTXHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVZLWKXQLODWHUDOV\PSWRPDWLFFDURWLGGLVHDVH
ZKRXQGHUZHQWH[WHQVLYHFOLQLFDOZRUNXSDWRXUVWURNHXQLWWRH[FOXGHRWKHUFDXVHV
RILVFKDHPLFVWURNHXQGHUZHQWVWDQGDUG0'&7$DQGEE05,ZLWK72)SUHDQG
SRVWFRQWUDVWIV7ZIV7ZDQGIV3'ZVHTXHQFHVZLWKLQGD\VRIV\PSWRP
RQVHW%RWKV\PSWRPDWLFDQGFRQWUDODWHUDODV\PSWRPDWLFVLGHVZHUHHYDOXDWHG%\
05,SODTXHPRUSKRORJ\DQGFRPSRVLWLRQDQGSUHYDOHQFHRIFRPSOLFDWHGW\SH9,
OHVLRQV $+$/7 ZLWKKDHPRUUKDJHWKURPEXVDQGRUUXSWXUHGÀEURXVFDSZHUH
HYDOXDWHG%\0'&7$SODTXHW\SH VRIWPL[HGKDUG SODTXHGHQVLW\LQ+8DQG
SUHVHQFHRIXOFHUDWLRQDQGWKURPEXVZHUHHYDOXDWHG6HQVLWLYLW\ 6( VSHFLÀFLW\
63 SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH 339139 ZHUHFDOFXODWHGXVLQJD
IRXUE\IRXUWDEOH
5HVXOWV7RGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQV\PSWRPDWLFDQGDV\PSWRPDWLFSODTXHV$+$/7
ZDVWKHEHVW05,YDULDEOHDQGSUHVHQFHDEVHQFHRISODTXHXOFHUDWLRQZDVWKHEHVW
&7YDULDEOHUHVXOWLQJLQD6(63339DQG139RIDQGIRU
$+$/7DVDVVHVVHGE\EE05,DQGIRUSODTXHXOFHUDWLRQ
DVDVVHVVHGE\0'&7$DQGDQGIRUWKHFRPELQDWLRQRIERWK
0'&7$DQGEE05,
&RQFOXVLRQ%E05,GHOLYHUHGDEHWWHUVHQVLWLYLW\139DQG339FRPSDUHGWR
0'&7$ DW LGHQWLI\LQJ WKH V\PSWRPDWLF VLGH ZKLOH 0'&7$ RIIHUHG DQ H[FHOOHQW
VSHFLÀFLW\%HVWUHVXOWVZHUHREWDLQHGXVLQJERWKWHFKQLTXHV
%
3XOVHSUHVVXUHDVULVNIDFWRUIRU05,GHWHFWHGLQWUDSODTXH
KDHPRUUKDJHLQWKHFDURWLGDUWHULHVWKH5RWWHUGDPVWXG\
06HOZDQHVV4YDQGHQ%RXZKXLMVHQ*&9HUZRHUW$'HKJKDQ
09HUQRRLM$+RIPDQ--:HQW]HO-&0:LWWHPDQ$YDQGHU/XJW
5RWWHUGDP1/ PVHOZDQHVV#HUDVPXVPFQO
3XUSRVH,QWUDSODTXHKDHPRUUKDJH ,3+ DKLJKULVNFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIWKHYXOQHU
DEOHSODTXHLVFRQVLGHUHGWREHDQLPSRUWDQWSUHGLFWRUIRULVFKDHPLFVWURNH<HW
ULVNIDFWRUVOHDGLQJWRSODTXHYXOQHUDELOLW\DQGLQVSHFLÀF,3+DUHXQNQRZQ:H
VWXGLHGZKHWKHUKDHPRG\QDPLFSDUDPHWHUVDUHDVVRFLDWHGZLWKSUHVHQFHRI,3+
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH$LPRIWKHVWXG\LVWRYHULI\ZKLFKRIWKHGDLO\XVHGTXDQWLWDWLYHPHWKRG
RI FDURWLG VWHQRVLV HYDOXDWLRQ >&RPPRQ FDURWLG DUWHU\ &&$ 1$6&(7 (&67@
EHWWHUFRUUHODWHVZLWKFDURWLGVWHQRVLVDUHDLQGH[HGWRERG\VXUIDFHDUHD $L RIWKH
SDWLHQWWKDWLVWKHUHDOSDUDPHWHURIWKHEORRGÁRZLQWKHFDURWLGYHVVHOV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWVOLFH&7 *(9&7 ZLWKHYDOX
DWLRQRIGLDPHWHUDQGDUHDUHVSHFWLYHO\RIFRPPRQFDURWLGDUWHU\ && FDURWLG
EXOEDQGLQWHUQDOFDURWLG &, DWWKHVLWHRIVWHQRVLVDQGEH\RQGWKHEXOE6WHQRVLV
GHJUHHZDVPHDVXUHGXVLQJUHVSHFWLYHO\DVUHIHUHQFHGLDPHWHUDQGDUHDRI&&
&&G&&$ (&67PHWKRG (&67G(&67$ DQG1$6&(7PHWKRG 1$6&(7
G1$6&(7$ DQGFRUUHODWHGZLWK$LXVLQJ3HDUVRQWHVW
5HVXOWVFDURWLGSODTXHVZHUHGHWHFWHG4XDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVVKRZHGPHDQ
$L PP6WHQRVLVGHJUHHXVLQJWKHGLIIHUHQWPHWKRGZDVUHVSHFWLYHO\
&&G&&$(&67G(&67$1$6&(7G
1$6&(7$7KHDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQ$LDQGHDFKRIWKHWKUHH
GLIIHUHQWPHWKRGVZDV&&$ U (&67$ U 1$6&(7$ U
&RQFOXVLRQ &&$ PHWKRG DQG 1$6&(7$ PHWKRG EHWWHU FRUUHODWHV ZLWK$L
/HVVDJUHHPHQWUHVXOWVEHWZHHQ$LDQG(&67PHWKRGPD\EHEHFDXVHRIORZHU
UHSURGXFLELOLW\RIWKHPHDVXUHPHQWVDWWKHVLWHRIFDURWLGEXOEGXHWRDQDWRPLFDO
FKDQJHVUHODWHGWRDWKHURVFOHURVLV
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:LWKLQWKHIUDPHZRUNRIWKH5RWWHUGDPVWXG\WKHFDURWLG
DUWHULHVRIKHDOWK\SDUWLFLSDQWV\HDUVDQGROGHUDQGZLWKZDOOWKLFNHQLQJ
!PP RQXOWUDVRXQGZHUHLPDJHGZLWKD705,VFDQQHU,3+KDVEHHQ
GHÀQHGDVDK\SHULQWHQVHVLJQDORQWKH'7Z*5(05VHTXHQFH*HQHUDOLVHG
HVWLPDWLRQHTXDWLRQDQDO\VLVDGMXVWHGIRUVH[DJHLQWLPDPHGLDWKLFNQHVVDQG
RWKHUFDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNIDFWRUV VPRNLQJGLDEHWHVFKROHVWHURO%0, ZDVXVHG
WRDVVHVVWKHDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQWKHPDLQEORRGSUHVVXUHSDUDPHWHUVDQG,3+
5HVXOWV05LPDJLQJRIWKHFDURWLGDUWHULHVUHYHDOHGSUHVHQFHRI,3+LQ
SODTXHV$GMXVWHGIRUDJHDQGVH[,3+ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWK
V\VWROLFEORRGSUHVVXUH 6%3 DQGSXOVHSUHVVXUH 33 $IWHUDGMXVWPHQWIRURWKHU
FDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNIDFWRUV33\LHOGHGWKHVWURQJHVWDVVRFLDWLRQ7KHULVNRI,3+
LQFUHDVHGZLWKSHU6'LQFUHDVHLQ33 &,S YHUVXV
SHU6'LQ6%3 &,S )XUWKHUPRUHRQO\33UHPDLQHG
VLJQLÀFDQWDIWHUDGGLWLRQDODGMXVWPHQWIRURWKHUEORRGSUHVVXUHFRPSRQHQWV
&RQFOXVLRQ3XOVHSUHVVXUHSURYHGWREHWKHVWURQJHVWGHWHUPLQDQWIRULQWUDSODTXH
KDHPRUUKDJH LQGHSHQGHQW RI RWKHU EORRG SUHVVXUH SDUDPHWHUV DQG WUDGLWLRQDO
FDUGLRYDVFXODUULVNIDFWRUV7KLVDVVRFLDWLRQEHWZHHQSXOVDWLOHÁRZDQG,3+PLJKW
SURYLGHQRYHOLQVLJKWVLQWRWKHDHWLRORJ\RIWKHYXOQHUDEOHSODTXH
DUWHULHVLQWRHLWKHUDWKHURVFOHURVLVGLVVHFWLRQYDVFXOLWLVRUQRGLVHDVH)LQDOO\D
FRQVHQVXVUHDGLQJZDVSHUIRUPHG
5HVXOWV2QDSHUYHVVHOOHYHODJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQERWKUHDGHUVZDVH[FHOOHQW
ZLWK D .DSSD RI S &RPSDUHG WR WKH JROG VWDQGDUG ERWK UHDGHUV
PLVVHGRQHSDWLHQWZLWKPRGHUDWHDWKHURVFOHURVLVEXWFRUUHFWO\LGHQWLÀHGDOOFDVHV
RI VHYHUH DWKHURVFOHURVLV GLVVHFWLRQ DQG YDVFXOLWLV %\ FRQVHQVXV UHDGLQJ WKH
FRUUHFWGLDJQRVLVZDVPDGHLQRIFDVHV2QO\RQHSDWLHQWZLWKPRGHUDWH
DWKHURVFOHURVLVZDVFODVVLÀHGDVGLVHDVHIUHH)RUWKHSUHVHQFHRIGLVHDVHWKLV
UHVXOWHGLQDVHQVLWLYLW\VSHFLÀFLW\335DQG135RIDQG
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KLV VWXG\ GHPRQVWUDWHV WKDW KUEEF05, LV DEOH WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH
EHWZHHQWKHPRVWFRPPRQFHUYLFDODUWHULRSDWKLHVQRQLQYDVLYHO\ZLWKH[FHOOHQW
LQWHUUHDGHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\
%
1HZWHFKQRORJLHVDQGDOJRULWKPV
05,EDVHGTXDQWLÀFDWLRQRIDGYHQWLWLDOFRQWUDVWG\QDPLFVIRUWKH
FDURWLGDUWHU\DVDPDUNHUIRUQHRYDVFXODUL]DWLRQLQDWKHURVFOHURVLV
FRPSDULVRQRIV\PSWRPDWLFDQGDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV
)6FKZDU]0,QJULVFK0+DUWPDQQ666RXUEURQ&&&\UDQ
-*ULPP.1LNRODRX0)5HLVHU76DDP0XQLFK'(/HHGV8.
ÁRULDQVFKZDU]#PHGOPXGH
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH FRQWUDVW G\QDPLFV LQ DGYHQWLWLDO WLVVXH RI WKH FRPPRQ
DQGLQWHUQDOFDURWLGDUWHU\EHWZHHQV\PSWRPDWLFDQGDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVZLWK
DWKHURVFOHURVLVFDOFXODWHGIURPWLPHUHVROYHGFRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG05,GDWDVHWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV V\PSWRPDWLF SDWLHQWV LVFKDHPLF VWURNH ZLWK ':,
UHVWULFWLRQRQEUDLQ05, ZLWKDWKHURVFOHURWLFSODTXHVRQFDURWLGXOWUDVRXQGZHUH
LQFOXGHG ZLWKLQ K RI V\PSWRP RQVHW DV\PSWRPDWLF SDWLHQWV ZLWK IDPLOLDO
K\SHUFKROHVWHUROHPLDVHUYHGDVDFRQWUROJURXS$OOSDWLHQWVZHUHVFDQQHGRQD
705,V\VWHPXVLQJDGHGLFDWHGVXUIDFHFRLO&RQWUDVWNLQHWLFVZHUHUHFRUGHG
RQUHSUHVHQWDWLYHD[LDOVOLFHVDWWKHOHYHORIWKHFRPPRQDQGLQWHUQDOFDURWLG
DUWHU\ZLWKDWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQRIVIRUDWRWDORIPLQ52,VZLWKDWKLFNQHVV
RISL[HOVZHUHSRVLWLRQHGDURXQGWKHYHVVHOZDOO\LHOGLQJWLPHGHSHQGHQWIXQF
WLRQVRIVLJQDO7KHVHZHUHWKHQÀWWHGWRDFRPSDUWPHQWH[FKDQJHPRGHODQG
WKHSDUDPHWHUVSODVPDÁRZSODVPDYROXPHSODVPDPHDQWUDQVLWWLPH 3077
H[WUDFWLRQÁRZ () DQGLQWHUVWLWLDOPHDQWUDQVLWWLPH ,077 FDOFXODWHG
5HVXOWV&RQWUDVWG\QDPLFVZHUHDQDO\VHGIRUDQGFDURWLGVHJPHQWVLQWKH
V\PSWRPDWLFDQGDV\PSWRPDWLFJURXSUHVSHFWLYHO\7KHUHPDLQLQJZHUHH[FOXGHG
GXHWRLQVXIÀFLHQWLPDJHTXDOLW\)RUV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWVVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUYDO
XHVIRUSODVPDYROXPH YVS H[WUDFWLRQÁRZ YVS
DQG,077 YVVS ZHUHREVHUYHG7KHUHZDVDVWURQJWHQGHQF\IRU
KLJKHU3077 YVS DQGKLJKHUSODVPDÁRZ YVS
&RQFOXVLRQ 05,EDVHG TXDQWLWDWLYH DVVHVVPHQW RI FRQWUDVW G\QDPLFV LQ WKH
DGYHQWLWLDOOD\HURIWKHFDURWLGDUWHU\UHYHDOVKLJKO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ
V\PSWRPDWLFDQGDV\PSWRPDWLFSDWLHQWV)XUWKHUVWXGLHVDUHQHHGHGWRDQDO\VH
WKHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHIRUIXWXUHLVFKDHPLFFHUHEUDOHYHQWV
%
5HSURGXFLELOLW\DQGGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQRIFHUYLFDODUWHULRSDWKLHVXVLQJLQ
YLYRKLJKUHVROXWLRQ05,
)6FKZDU].1LNRODRX&&&\UDQ0+DUWPDQQ
-*ULPP0)5HLVHU0'LFKJDQV03IHIIHUNRUQ76DDP
0XQLFK'( ÁRULDQVFKZDU]#PHGOPXGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDORIKLJKUHVROXWLRQEODFNEORRGFHUYLFDOPDJ
QHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJ KUEEF05, WRGLIIHUHQWLDWHWKHPRVWFRPPRQFHUYLFDO
DUWHULRSDWKLHVDQGWRHYDOXDWHLQWHUREVHUYHUUHSURGXFLELOLW\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV SDWLHQWV XQGHUZHQW KUEEF05, DW 7HVOD ZLWK
IDWVDWXUDWHG SUH DQG SRVWFRQWUDVW 7Z 3'Z 7Z DQG 72)LPDJHV XVLQJ
VSHFLÀFVXUIDFHFRLOVSDWLHQWVSUHVHQWHGZLWKFHUYLFDODUWKULWLVDVFRQÀUPHGE\
3(7&7DQGFOLQLFDOUHVSRQVHWRVWHURLGWUHDWPHQWSDWLHQWV VKRZHGDWKHUR
VFOHURWLFGLVHDVHFDXVLQJKLJKJUDGHVWHQRVHVLQ FRQÀUPHGKLVWRORJLFDOO\DIWHU
HQGDUWHUHFWRP\ ZKLOHWKHUHPDLQLQJVKRZHGQRPRUHWKDQPRGHUDWHVWHQRVLV
FRQÀUPHGE\XOWUDVRXQG SDWLHQWVKDGDUWHULDOGLVVHFWLRQ FRQÀUPHGFOLQLFDOO\
DQGE\IROORZXSLPDJLQJDIWHUPRQWKV )XUWKHUPRUHFRQWUROVXEMHFWVZLWKQR
HYLGHQFHRIGLVHDVHZHUHLQFOXGHG7ZRH[SHULHQFHGUHDGHUVEOLQGHGWRDOOFOLQL
FDOLQIRUPDWLRQUHYLHZHGDOO05,VHULHVDQGFODVVLÀHGERWKFDURWLGDQGYHUWHEUDO
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5RRP3
3K\VLFVLQ5DGLRORJ\
66
0RGHUDWRUV
2&LUDM%MHODF%HOJUDGH56
-19DVVLOHYD6RILD%*
%
&7LPDJHTXDOLW\LPSURYHPHQWXVLQJDGDSWLYHLWHUDWLYHGRVH
UHGXFWLRQZLWKZLGHYROXPHDFTXLVLWLRQRQGHWHFWRU&7
$*HUYDLVH%2VHPRQW6/HFRFT$1RHO(0LFDUG-)HOEOLQJHU
$%OXP0HW])51DQF\)59DQGRHXYUH/HV1DQF\)5
DOEDQJHUYDLVH#KRWPDLOIU
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHLPSDFWRIDGDSWLYHLWHUDWLYHGRVHUHGXFWLRQ $,'5 RQ
LPDJHTXDOLW\DQGUDGLDWLRQGRVHLQSKDQWRPDQGSDWLHQWVWXGLHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV$ SKDQWRP ZDV H[DPLQHG LQ YROXPHWULF PRGH RQ D
GHWHFWRU&7DWGLIIHUHQWWXEHFXUUHQWVIURPWRP$V&7LPDJHVZHUH
UHFRQVWUXFWHG ZLWK$,'5 DQG ZLWK )%3 UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ DOJRULWKP ,PDJH QRLVH
FRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 VLJQDOWRQRLVHUDWLR 615 DQG VSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ
ZHUHFRPSDUHGEHWZHHQ)%3DQG$,'5LPDJHV$,'5ZDVWKHQWHVWHGRQ&7
H[DPLQDWLRQVRIWKHOXPEDUVSLQHLQDSURVSHFWLYHVWXG\$JDLQ)%3DQG$,'5
LPDJHVZHUHFRPSDUHG,PDJHQRLVHDQG615ZHUHDQDO\VHGXVLQJD:LOFR[RQ
VLJQHGUDQNWHVW
5HVXOWV ,Q WKH SKDQWRP VSDWLDO UHVROXWLRQ DVVHVVPHQW VKRZHG QR VLJQLÀFDQW
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ)%3DQG$,'5UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV,PDJHQRLVHZDVORZHUZLWK
$,'5WKDQZLWK)%3LPDJHVZLWKDPHDQUHGXFWLRQRI&15DQG615ZHUH
DOVRLPSURYHGZLWK$,'5,QSDWLHQWVTXDQWLWDWLYHDQGVXEMHFWLYHHYDOXDWLRQVKRZHG
WKDWLPDJHQRLVHZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHUZLWK$,'5WKDQZLWK)%3615ZDVDOVR
JUHDWHUZLWK$,'5WKDQZLWK)%3
&RQFOXVLRQ&RPSDUHGWRWUDGLWLRQDO)%3UHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHV$,'5VLJ
QLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHVLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGKDVWKHSRWHQWLDOWRGHFUHDVHUDGLDWLRQGRVH
%
)UHTXHQF\FRPELQHGH[WHQGHG'UHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRUPXOWLSOH
FLUFXODUFRQHEHDP&7VFDQV
5*ULPPHU-%DHN13HOF0.DFKHOULHVV(UODQJHQ'(
3DOR$OWR&$86 UDLQHUJULPPHU#LPSXQLHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH ,Q FLUFXODU FRQHEHDP &7 D VLQJOH FLUFOHVFDQ RIWHQ GRHV QRW FRYHU
WKHFRPSOHWH]UDQJHRILQWHUHVW,IWKLVLVWKHFDVHWZRRUPRUHFLUFOHVFDQVDUH
DFTXLUHG7KHVWDQGDUGFRPELQDWLRQRIWKHVHSDUDWHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVKDVWZRGLV
DGYDQWDJHV 7KHUHFRQVWUXFWDEOHYROXPHLVVPDOOHUWKDQSRVVLEOHWKXVGRVH
UHPDLQVXQXVHGDQGWKHQRLVHOHYHOLVKLJKHUWKDQQHFHVVDU\ 7KHFRQHEHDP
DUWHIDFWVDUHLQFUHDVHGDWWKHHGJHVRIWKHSDUWLDOYROXPHVZKLFKKDYHDODUJH
GLVWDQFHWRWKHPLGSODQHV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7R RYHUFRPH WKHVH GLVDGYDQWDJHV ZH GHYHORSHG D
PHWKRGWKDWVLPXOWDQHRXVO\UHFRQVWUXFWVDOOFLUFOHVFDQVDQGWKHUHE\LVDEOHWRUH
FRQVWUXFWODUJHUVHJPHQWVIURPHDFKFLUFOHVFDQDQGIXUWKHUPRUHWKDWUHGXFHVFRQH
EHDPDUWHIDFWVE\FRPELQLQJWKHVHJPHQWVLQIUHTXHQF\GRPDLQ7KHSURSRVHG
PHWKRGZDVHYDOXDWHGXVLQJDVLPXODWLRQVWXG\DVZHOODVPHDVXUHGGDWDIURP
GLIIHUHQWÁDWSDQHOFRQHEHDP&7VFDQQHUVDVIRUH[DPSOHWKH9DULDQ2%,VFDQQHU
5HVXOWV,QWKHH[DPSOHJHRPHWU\WKHPD[LPDOUHFRQVWUXFWDEOH]UDQJHFDQEH
LQFUHDVHG E\ DQG RXU DSSURDFK DGGLWLRQDOO\ OHDGV WR D QRLVH UHGXFWLRQ RI
DERXWLQWKHRYHUODSUHJLRQ5HJDUGLQJWKHFRQHEHDPDUWHIDFWVZHZHUH
DEOHWRUHGXFHWKHDUWHIDFWOHYHOWRDYDOXHDVORZDVDFKLHYDEOHE\PRUHFRPSOH[
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
DOJRULWKPV WKDW SHUIRUP D YR[HOZLVH ZHLJKWHG EDFNSURMHFWLRQ WR IDYRXU YR[HOV
VHHQXQGHUVPDOOFRQHDQJOHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSURSRVHGDOJRULWKPLVDEOHWRVLJQLÀFDQWO\LPSURYHWKHUHFRQ
VWUXFWLRQ RI VHTXHQFH VFDQV ZKLOH WKH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ WLPH LV NHSW HTXLYDOHQW WR
WKHVWDQGDUGDSSURDFK:HIXUWKHUGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWWKHPHWKRGFDQEHXVHGLQ
FOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
%
%HDPKDUGHQLQJDQGVFDWWHUUHPRYDOZLWKHPSLULFDOFXSSLQJ
FRUUHFWLRQIRUSULPDU\PRGXODWLRQ (&&3
5*ULPPHU5)DKULJ:+LQVKDZ+*DR0.DFKHOULHVV(UODQJHQ'(
3DOR$OWR&$86 UDLQHUJULPPHU#LPSXQLHUODQJHQGH
3XUSRVH[5D\&7PHDVXUHVWKHDWWHQXDWLRQRISRO\FKURPDWLF[UD\VWKURXJKDQ
REMHFW7KH[UD\VSHFWUXPPD\YDU\DVDIXQFWLRQRIWKHGHWHFWRUSRVLWLRQHJ
GXHWRWKHKHHOHIIHFWRUDERZWLHRUDSULPDU\PRGXODWRULVXVHGWRPRGXODWHWKH
SULPDU\LQWHQVLW\:HSURSRVHDQHZDSSURDFKWKDWDOORZVKDQGOLQJDOOWKHVHHIIHFWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV2XU(&&3FRUUHFWVIRUDUWHIDFWVVXFKDVFXSSLQJDU
WHIDFWVRUULQJDUWHIDFWVWKDWDUHLQGXFHGE\QRQOLQHDULWLHVLQWKHSURMHFWLRQGDWD
GXHWRVSDWLDOO\YDU\LQJÀOWUDWLRQRIWKH[UD\V7RGRVR(&&3UHTXLUHVQRWKLQJ
EXWDVLPSOHVFDQRIDKRPRJHQHRXVSKDQWRPRIDUELWUDU\VKDSH%DVHGRQWKLV
LQIRUPDWLRQFRHIÀFLHQWVRIDSRO\QRPLDOVHULHVDUHFDOFXODWHGDQGVWRUHGIRUODWHU
XVHWRSUHFRUUHFWSDWLHQWGDWD:HFRPELQH(&&3ZLWKWKHSULPDU\PRGXODWLRQ
VFDWWHUFRUUHFWLRQ 306& >,(((70, @WRGHPRQVWUDWHWKH
(&&3VDELOLW\RIFRUUHFWLQJIRUVSDWLDOO\YDU\LQJ[UD\VSHFWUDDQGWRVKRZWKDW
306&(&&3LVDKLJKO\HIÀFLHQWPHWKRGWRFRUUHFWIRUVFDWWHUDUWHIDFWV
5HVXOWV (&&3 LV DSSOLHG WR PHDVXUHPHQWV DQG FRPSOHWHO\ UHPRYHV FXSSLQJ
DQGULQJDUWHIDFWV,WIXUWKHUJXDUDQWHHVZHOOFDOLEUDWHG&7YDOXHVHYHQLQFDVHV
RIVWURQJSULPDU\PRGXODWLRQ2XUFRPELQDWLRQRI(&&3306&VXFFHVVIXOO\SHU
IRUPHGVFDWWHUDQGEHDPKDUGHQLQJFRUUHFWLRQ5LQJDUWHIDFWVZHUHQRPRUHYLVLEOH
DIWHUFRPELQLQJWKHVHWZRPHWKRGVDUWHIDFWVGXHWRVFDWWHURUEHDPKDUGHQLQJ
ZHUHUHPRYHG
&RQFOXVLRQ(&&3LVDKLJKO\HIIHFWLYHSUDJPDWLFDSSURDFKWRFRPSHQVDWHIRU
VWURQJ GHWHFWRU FKDQQHOGHSHQGHG FKDQJHV RI WKH GHWHFWHG VSHFWUXP ,Q FRP
ELQDWLRQZLWK306&ZHDFKLHYHLPDJHUHVXOWVQHDUO\IUHHRIVFDWWHUDQGEHDP
KDUGHQLQJDUWHIDFWV
%
([SRVLWLRQLQ&7DQJLRJUDSK\WKHLPSDFWRIWKHQHZ23('
DOJRULWKPLQ&7DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ DSKDQWRPVWXG\
7:HUQFNH%5HQJHU27LVFKHQNR):DFNHU%0H\HU%HUOLQ'(
0XQLFK'(1HXKHUEHUJ'(+DQQRYHU'( WKRPDVZHUQFNH#FKDULWHGH
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
5DGLDWLRQGRVHDQGLPDJHTXDOLW\DWKLJKSLWFK&7DQJLRJUDSK\
RIWKHDRUWDLQWUDLQGLYLGXDODQGLQWHULQGLYLGXDOFRPSDULVRQZLWK
FRQYHQWLRQDO&7DQJLRJUDSK\
3$SIDOWUHU(+DQQD86FKRHSI-6SHDUV*5RZH'+DUULV
66FKRHQEHUJ&)LQN59OLHJHQWKDUW0DQQKHLP'(&KDUOHVWRQ6&86
&KDUOHVWRQ6&860DQQKHLP'(*URQLQJHQ1/&KDUOHVWRQ6&86
SDXODSIDOWUHU#XPPGH
3XUSRVH/DWHVWJHQHUDWLRQ&7V\VWHPVHQDEOHDFTXLULQJWKHHQWLUHWRUVRDWKLJK
SLWFK:HHYDOXDWHGUDGLDWLRQGRVHDQGTXDQWLWDWLYHLPDJHTXDOLW\SDUDPHWHUVDW
KLJKSLWFK&7DQJLRJUDSK\ &7$ RIWKHHQWLUHDRUWDFRPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDO&7$
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWV PDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUV ZLWK
&7$RIWKHHQWLUHDRUWDZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\LQFOXGHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQW&7$
RQDQGJHQHUDWLRQGXDOVRXUFH&7V\VWHPRIZKLFKLQKLJKSLWFKPRGH0DLQ
LQGLFDWLRQVZHUHVXVSHFWHGDRUWLFV\QGURPH Q IROORZXSRIDQHXU\VP Q
RUGLVVHFWLRQ Q RUSRVWDRUWLFUHSDLU Q 0HDQDUWHULDODWWHQXDWLRQVLJQDO
WRQRLVHUDWLR 615 FRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 DQG ÀJXUHRIPHULW )20
ZHUHFDOFXODWHGDWPXOWLSOHDRUWLFOHYHOV$ÀJXUHRIPHULW )20 ZDVFRPSXWHG
WRQRUPDOLVHWKHQRLVHDQG&15IRUHDFKSURWRFROWRHIIHFWLYHGRVH$GGLWLRQDOO\
UDGLDWLRQH[SRVXUHZDVFRPSDUHG
5HVXOWV$OOVWXGLHVZHUHFRQVLGHUHGRIGLDJQRVWLFTXDOLW\$WKLJKVSHHG&7$PHDQ
N9DQGP$VZHUHDQGFRPSDUHGWRDQGIRUFRQ
YHQWLRQDO&7$ S 0HDQYROXPH&7GRVHLQGH[GRVHOHQJWKSURGXFWDQG
HIIHFWLYHGRVHZHUHP*\P*\ FPDQGP6YDWKLJKSLWFK
&7$YHUVXVP*\P*\ FPDQGP6YDWFRQYHQWLRQDO
&7$ S $WWHQXDWLRQZDVVLPLODUIRUERWKSURWRFROVZKLOHVLJQLÀFDQWO\OHVV
FRQWUDVWPHGLXPZDVLQMHFWHGIRUKLJKSLWFK&7$ P/YVP/
S 615 DQG &15 ZHUH VLJQLÀFDQWO\ ORZHU LQ WKH KLJKSLWFK&7$ JURXS
ZKLOHWKH)20ZDVQRQVLJQLÀFDQWO\KLJKHUSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWERWK
KLJKSLWFKDQGFRQYHQWLRQDO&7$UDGLDWLRQGRVHZDVUHGXFHGE\ S
&RQFOXVLRQ+LJKSLWFK&7$RIWKHDRUWD\LHOGVXSWRUHGXFWLRQRIUDGLDWLRQ
H[SRVXUHDVZHOODVFRQWUDVWPHGLXPVDYLQJVZLWKPDLQWDLQHGYHVVHODWWHQXDWLRQ
%
$WHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQLPSURYHPHQWPHWKRGIRUFDUGLDF&7XVLQJ
RISURMHFWLRQVLQLWLDOSDWLHQWH[SHULHQFH
3$SIDOWUHU+6FKRHQGXEH8-6FKRHSI$6FKLQGOHU7$OOPHQGLQJHU
69RJW.6WLHUVWRUIHU+%UXGHU+8(EHUVEHUJHU&KDUOHVWRQ6&86
)RUFKKHLP'(0DOYHUQ3$86 GUDSIDOWUHU#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH7R HYDOXDWH WKH HIIHFW RI D WHPSRUDO UHVROXWLRQ LPSURYHPHQW PHWKRG
75,0 IRUFDUGLDF&7RQGLDJQRVWLFLPDJHTXDOLW\IRUFRURQDU\DUWHU\DVVHVVPHQW
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 7KH 75,0DOJRULWKP HPSOR\V DQ LWHUDWLYH DSSURDFK
WRUHFRQVWUXFWLPDJHVIURPOHVVWKDQRISURMHFWLRQVDQGXVHVDKLVWRJUDP
FRQVWUDLQWWRSUHYHQWWKHRFFXUUHQFHRIOLPLWHGDQJOHDUWHIDFWV7KLVDOJRULWKPZDV
DSSOLHGLQREHVHSDWLHQWV PHQ\UV ZKRKDGXQGHUJRQHQGJHQ
HUDWLRQGXDOVRXUFHFDUGLDF&7ZLWKN9P$VDQGPVHFJDQWU\
URWDWLRQWLPH$OOGDWDZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWKDWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQRIPVHF
XVLQJWUDGLWLRQDOÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ )%3 DQGRIPVHFXVLQJWKH75,0
DOJRULWKP&RQWUDVWDWWHQXDWLRQDQGFRQWUDVWWRQRLVHUDWLR &15 ZHUHPHDVXUHG
LQWKHDVFHQGLQJDRUWD7KHSUHVHQFHDQGVHYHULW\RIFRURQDU\PRWLRQDUWHIDFWV
ZDVUDWHGRQDSRLQWVFDOH QRPRWLRQ QRQGLDJQRVWLF
5HVXOWV 0HDQ ERG\PDVVLQGH[ ZDV NJP$YHUDJH KHDUW UDWH ZDV
ESP0HDQHIIHFWLYHGRVHZDVP6Y:KHQFRPSDULQJ)%3DQG
75,0UHFRQVWUXFWHGVHULHVWKHDWWHQXDWLRQZLWKLQWKHDVFHQGLQJDRUWD
YV+8S DQG&15 YVS! ZDVQRW
VLJQLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQW$WRWDORIFRURQDU\VHJPHQWVZHUHHYDOXDWHG$OOVWXGLHV
ZHUHGHHPHGRYHUDOOGLDJQRVWLFKRZHYHUWKHUHZDVDVLJQLÀFDQW S GLIIHU
HQFHLQWKHRFFXUUHQFHDQGVHYHULW\VFRUHVRIFRURQDU\PRWLRQDUWHIDFWVEHWZHHQ
)%3 PHDQ DQG75,0 PHDQ UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH75,0DOJRULWKPHYDOXDWHGKHUHDOORZVFOLQLFDOO\DFFHSWDEOHLPDJ
LQJRIWKHFRURQDU\DUWHULHVGHVSLWHPVHFJDQWU\URWDWLRQ3RVVLEOHDSSOLFDWLRQV
LQFOXGHLPSURYHPHQWRIFDUGLDFLPDJLQJRQVORZHUJDQWU\URWDWLRQV\VWHPVRUPLWLJD
WLRQRIWKHWUDGHRIIEHWZHHQWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQDQGLPDJHQRLVHLQREHVHSDWLHQWV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7KHDLPRIWKLVSKDQWRPVWXG\ZDVWRFRPSDUHWKHTXDOLW\RIVWHQRVLV
TXDQWLÀFDWLRQIRUWKHQRYHO23(' RUWKRJRQDOSRO\QRPLDOH[SDQVLRQRQWKHGLVN
FRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\UHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKPZKLFKRYHUFRPHVWKHUDGLDOGH
FUHDVHRILPDJHTXDOLW\RIWKHÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQDOJRULWKP )%3 ZLWK)%3
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7RPLPLFVWHQRVHGDEGRPLQDOYHVVHOVDFU\OLFWXEHV LQ
QHUGLDPHWHUVPDOO ODUJH PP ZHUHÀOOHGZLWKSODTXHPDWHULDOWRFUHDWH
GLIIHUHQWGHJUHHVRIVWHQRVLVDQGSODTXHFRPSRVLWLRQ FDOFLÀHG>!+8@VRIW
>a+8@LQKRPRJHQHRXV>+8@ /XPHQZDVÀOOHGZLWKZDWHUGLOXWHGFRQ
WUDVWPDWHULDO ,RPHSURO%UDFFR WRHQKDQFHWKHOXPHQWR+89HVVHOSKDQWRPV
ZHUHLQVHUWHGLQDQDQWKURSRPRUSKLF$OGHUVRQSKDQWRPDQGLPDJLQJZDVFRQGXFWHG
RQDVOLFH0'&7 6HQVDWLRQ6LHPHQVFROOLPDWLRQ[PPWXEHYROWDJH
N9HIIHFWLYHWXEHFXUUHQWP$V ,PDJHVZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGXVLQJ23('
DQGWKHVWDQGDUGNHUQHO%I$JUHHPHQWRIPHDVXUHG UHDGHUVLQFRQVHQVXV
VWHQRVLVDUHDZDVFRUUHODWHGWRWKHNQRZQYDOXHXVLQJ.DSSD/LQ7HVW ѣ/LQ
5HVXOWV$WRWDORIVWHQRVLVPHDVXUHPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHG&RUUHODWLRQRIWKH
23('DOJRULWKPZDVVXSHULRUWR)%3,QODUJHYHVVHOVFRUUHODWLRQZDVSHUIHFWIRU
ERWKUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKPV 23(')%3 ,QFRPSDULVRQFRUUHODWLRQ
ZDV LQIHULRU LQ VPDOO YHVVHOV 23(' )%3 VXEVWDQWLDO 2YHUDOO EHVW
FRUUHODWLRQZDVREVHUYHGLQFDOFLÀHGSODTXHV 23('ѣ/LQ )%3ѣ/LQ
FRPSDUHG WR VRIW 23('ѣ/LQ )%3ѣ/LQ DQG LQKRPRJHQHRXV
23('ѣ/LQ )%3ѣ/LQ SODTXHV
&RQFOXVLRQ,QODUJHYHVVHOSKDQWRPVUHSUHVHQWLQJSHOYLFDQGUHQDODUWHULHVWKH
GRVHHIÀFLHQF\LVKLJKHUZLWKWKH23('UHFRQVWUXFWLRQFRPSDUHGWRWKHVWDQGDUG
ÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQ,QVPDOOHUYHVVHOSKDQWRPVUHSUHVHQWLQJLQWHVWLQDODUWHU
LHVTXDOLW\RIOXPLQDOGHOLQHDWLRQLVDOUHDG\OLPLWHGGXHWRWKHVSDWLDOUHVROXWLRQ
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
%
)XOOÀHOGLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQKLJKSLWFKGXDOVRXUFH&7
$+0DKQNHQ7$OOPHQGLQJHU06HGOPDLU65HLQDUW]&.XKO7)ORKU
$DFKHQ'()RUFKKHLP'( DQGUHDVPDKQNHQ#UZWKDDFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7KHÀHOGRIYLHZ )29 LQKLJKSLWFK'6&7LVOLPLWHGE\WKHVL]HRIWKH
VHFRQGGHWHFWRU7KHJRDORIWKLVVWXG\LVWRGHYHORSDQGHYDOXDWHDIXOO)29LPDJH
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHIRUKLJKSLWFK'6&7
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV)RUUHFRQVWUXFWLRQEH\RQGWKH)29RIWKHVHFRQGGHWHF
WRUUDZGDWDRIWKHVHFRQGV\VWHPDUHH[WHQGHGWRWKHIXOOGLPHQVLRQVRIWKHÀUVW
V\VWHPXWLOLVLQJWKHSDUWO\H[LVWLQJGDWDRIWKHÀUVWV\VWHPLQFRPELQDWLRQZLWKD
YHU\VPRRWKWUDQVLWLRQZHLJKWIXQFWLRQFRYHULQJGHWHFWRUFKDQQHOV'XULQJWKH
ZHLJKWHGÀOWHUHGEDFNSURMHFWLRQWKHGDWDRIWKHVHFRQGV\VWHPDUHDSSOLHGZLWKDQ
DGGLWLRQDOZHLJKWLQJIDFWRU7KLVZDVWHVWHGIRUGLIIHUHQWSLWFKYDOXHVIURPWR
RQDVLPXODWHGSKDQWRPDQGRQKLJKSLWFK'6&7GDWDVHWVDFTXLUHGDWSLWFK
YDOXHVRIDQG 'HÀQLWLRQ6LHPHQV)RUFKKHLP* ,PDJHV
ZHUHUHFRQVWUXFWHGZLWK)29VL]HVUDQJLQJIURP[PPWR[PP
,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDVVHVVHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWVXVLQJDSRLQW/LNHUWVFDOH
5HVXOWV,QSKDQWRPDQGSDWLHQWGDWDIXOO)29LPDJHTXDOLW\GHSHQGHGRQSLWFK
:KHUHFRPSOHWHSURMHFWLRQGDWDIURPWKHVHFRQGWXEHGHWHFWRUV\VWHPZDVDYDLO
DEOHLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVXQDIIHFWHGE\SLWFKFKDQJHV)XOO)29LPDJHTXDOLW\ZDV
QRWFRPSURPLVHGDWSLWFKYDOXHVRIDQGUHPDLQHGIXOO\GLDJQRVWLFXSWRDSLWFK
RI$WKLJKHUSLWFKYDOXHVDSURJUHVVLYHGHSUHVVLRQRILPDJHTXDOLW\RFFXUUHG
&RQFOXVLRQ:LWKWKLVQHZLPDJHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQWHFKQLTXHIXOO)29LPDJHVVKRXOG
EHXVHGXSWRDSLWFKRI
%
'HWHFWLRQRIYDVFXODUPDSDV\PPHWU\LQEUHDVWFDQFHUXVLQJQRYHO
IXQFWLRQDOLQIUDUHGLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXH
',]KDN\06NODLU/HY\$0D\HU<3IHIIHU(/LEVRQ76HOOD
$LU3RUW&LW\,/5DPDW*DQ,/-HUXVDOHP,/
3XUSRVH,QFUHDVHGYDVFXODULW\RIWKHEUHDVWGHWHFWHGE\05,KDVEHHQVXJJHVWHG
DVDPDUNHUIRUPDOLJQDQF\2EWDLQLQJDEUHDVWYDVFXODUPDSUHTXLUHVFRQWUDVWHQ
KDQFHGLQMHFWLRQGXULQJWKHH[DPLQDWLRQ+HUHZHH[DPLQHGDQRQLQYDVLYHPHWKRG
IRUDVVHVVLQJYDVFXODUPDSGHQVLW\XVLQJDQRYHOLQIUDUHGLPDJLQJWHFKQLTXH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7HQSDWLHQWVZLWKFOLQLFDOO\SURYHQFDQFHUDQGKHDOWK\
YROXQWHHUVZHUHH[DPLQHGXVLQJDSURWRW\SHV\VWHP 587+,PDJHU5HDO,PDJLQJ
/WG 0XOWLSOH ' LPDJH VHULHV ZHUH DFTXLUHG &RPSXWHULVHG LPDJH SURFHVVLQJ
JHQHUDWHG'YDVFXODUPDSV$VSHFLDODOJRULWKPZDVGHYHORSHGWRDVVLJQDVFRUH
EDVHGRQQXPEHUOHQJWKDQGGHQVLW\RIWKHYLVXDOLVHGEORRGYHVVHOV7KHVHVFRUHV
ZHUHQRUPDOLVHGIRUEUHDVWGLPHQVLRQV&RPSDULVRQEHWZHHQJURXSVZDVGRQH
XVLQJD6WXGHQWҋVWWHVW
5HVXOWV7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHLQDJHDQGDYHUDJHEUHDVWVL]HEH
WZHHQWKHWZRJURXSV)RULQYDVLYHFDQFHUWKHPHDQYDVFXODUPDSGHQVLW\VFRUH
ZDVZLWKWKHDIIHFWHGEUHDVWVKRZLQJLQFUHDVHGRYHUDOOYDVFXODULW\ PHDQ
WXPRXUVL]HPP )RUKHDOWK\YROXQWHHUVWKHPHDQYDVFXODUPDSGHQVLW\
VFRUH ZDV S $YHUDJH LPDJH DFTXLVLWLRQ WLPH RQ WKH 587+
VFDQQHUZDVVHFRQGV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHQRYHO587+LPDJHUVKRZVLQFUHDVHGYDVFXODUPDSDV\PPHWU\LQ
SDWLHQWVZLWKPDOLJQDQWEUHDVWFDQFHUZLWKUHODWLYHO\IDVWQRQLQYDVLYHDFTXLVLWLRQ
)XUWKHUVWXG\VKRXOGEHSHUIRUPHGWRHYDOXDWHWKHUROHRIPRQLWRULQJRIYDVFXODU
PDSDV\PPHWU\XVLQJWKLVWHFKQRORJ\IRUHDUO\GHWHFWLRQRIEUHDVWFDQFHU
%
/RZGRVH[UD\SKDVHFRQWUDVWFRPSXWHGWRPRJUDSK\IRUEUHDVW
FDQFHUGLDJQRVLV
(%UXQ<=KDR$6]WURND\3'LHPR]=+XDQJ$0LWWRQH
0)5HLVHU-0LDR3&RDQ*UHQREOH)5:HVWZRRG&$86
0XQLFK'(*DUFKLQJ'( HPPDQXHOEUXQ#HVUIIU
3XUSRVH0DPPRJUDSK\LVWKHVWDQGDUGLPDJLQJPRGDOLW\IRUHDUO\EUHDVWFDQFHU
GHWHFWLRQEXWVHQVLWLYLW\LVVWLOOOLPLWHGLQSDUWLFXODULQGHQVHEUHDVWV&RPSXWHG
WRPRJUDSK\ &7 KDV QRW \HW EHHQ FOLQLFDOO\ LPSOHPHQWHG EHFDXVH RI WKH KLJK
UDGLRVHQVLWLYLW\RIEUHDVW,QYLWURSKDVHFRQWUDVW&7KDVEHHQSURYHQFDSDEOHRI
SURGXFLQJKLJKFRQWUDVWLPDJHVSRWHQWLDOO\RYHUFRPLQJPDPPRJUDSK\OLPLWDWLRQV
:HGHPRQVWUDWHWKDWGRVHUHGXFWLRQIRUDJLYHQFRQWUDVWUHVROXWLRQFDQEHDFKLHYHG
XVLQJDQHZUHFRQVWUXFWLRQDOJRULWKPNQRZQDVHTXDOO\VORSHGWRPRJUDSK\ (67
5HVXOWVRIFRPSDUDWLYHH[SHULPHQWVWRH[SORUHUDGLDWLRQGRVHUHGXFWLRQLQSKDVH
FRQWUDVWPDPPRJUDSK\DUHUHSRUWHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV([SHULPHQWVZHUHSHUIRUPHGDW(XURSHDQ6\QFKURWURQ
5DGLDWLRQ)DFLOLW\7KUHHIRUPDOLQÀ[HGIXOOKXPDQEUHDVWVDPSOHVZHUHLPDJHG
XVLQJ SKDVH FRQWUDVW &7 [UD\ HQHUJ\ NH9 YR[HO VL]H PLFURQ
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
&RPSDUDWLYH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV ZHUH SURGXFHG XVLQJ WKH VWDQGDUG ÀOWHUHG EDFN
SURMHFWLRQ )%3 DOJRULWKP
5HVXOWV (67 UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ZLWK SURMHFWLRQV KDV D VLJQDOWRQRLVH UDWLR
FRPSDUDEOHWR)%3UHFRQVWUXFWLRQZLWKSURMHFWLRQV1RUHVROXWLRQRUFRQWUDVW
GHJUDGDWLRQEHWZHHQWXPRXUDQGQRUPDOJODQGXODUWLVVXHLVREVHUYHG5DGLRORJLVW
DVVHVVPHQWVEOLQGHGWRWKHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQSDUDPHWHUVFRQÀUPHGWKDWWKH(67
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQLVVXSHULRUWR)%37KHPHDQJODQGXODUGRVHZDVHVWLPDWHGWREH
P*\IRUWKHIXOOYROXPH(67UHFRQVWUXFWLRQZKLFKLVOHVVWKDQWKHDYHUDJH
GRVHLQDGXDOYLHZVFUHHQLQJURXWLQHH[DP
&RQFOXVLRQ 2XU UHVXOWV VXJJHVW WKDW WKH (67 PHWKRG HQDEOHV WR UHGXFH WKH
UDGLDWLRQGRVHLQSKDVHFRQWUDVW&7E\ZLWKRXWVDFULÀFLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\7KLV
VWXG\LVDQLPSRUWDQWVWHSWRZDUGVWKHFOLQLFDOLPSOHPHQWDWLRQ
%
+XPDQPHGLFDOLPDJLQJZLWKUHIRUPHG[UD\LQWHUIHURPHWU\XVLQJD
SUDFWLFDO[UD\WXEHDSUHOLPLQDU\VWXG\ZLWKQRUPDOYROXQWHHUV
-7DQDND01LLWVX$0RPRVH..LGR01DJDVKLPD
)7KLHOH,UXPDJXQ-3.DVKLZDFLW\-3+DFKLRXMLFLW\7RN\R-3
MWDQDND#VDLWDPDPHGDFMS
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHLPDJHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVLQQRUPDOYROXQWHHUVREWDLQHGE\
UHIRUPHG[UD\LQWHUIHURPHWU\ZKLFKXVHVDSUDFWLFDO[UD\WXEH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV5HIRUPHG[UD\7DOERWLQWHUIHURPHWU\IROORZLQJWKHWKHRU\
RI/DXLQZKLFKDSUDFWLFDOLQFRKHUHQW[UD\VRXUFHLVXVHGLH7DOERW/DXLQWHUIHU
RPHWU\ZDVFUHDWHGEDVHGRQDGHVLJQZLWKZDYHRSWLFVLPXODWLRQ,QWKLVV\VWHP
VRXUFHJUDWLQJZKLFKFRQVLVWVRIPXOWLSOHVOLWVRIѥPRUOHVVLQZLGWKDUUDQJHG
SHULRGLFDOO\LVSODFHGLPPHGLDWHO\DIWHUDQLQFRKHUHQW[UD\VRXUFH(DFKVOLWHPLWV
FRKHUHQW[UD\DQGLIWKHSLWFKRIWKHJUDWLQJLVVHWDSSURSULDWHO\DQ[UD\VRXUFH
ZLWKFRKHUHQWOLJKWDQGHQRXJKSRZHUFDQEHDFKLHYHGGXHWRWKH/DXHIIHFW6LQFH
WKLVV\VWHPGRHVQRWUHTXLUHHLWKHUDV\QFKURWURQRUDPLFURIRFXV[UD\WXEHWKH
PHGLFDODSSOLFDWLRQRI[UD\LQWHUIHURPHWU\PD\EHIHDVLEOH$IWHUFRQÀUPLQJWKDW
WKH V\VWHP ZRUNHG ZLWK SDUWV RI KXPDQ FDGDYHULF ERGLHV ZH VWDUWHG WR LPDJH
SDUWV RI QRUPDO YROXQWHHUV VXFK DV WKH ÀQJHU DQG KDQG XQGHU WKH DSSURYDO RI
WKHXQLYHUVLW\HWKLFVFRPPLWWHH7KHUHVXOWLQJLPDJHVZHUHFRUUHODWHGZLWKNQRZQ
PDFURVFRSLFDQDWRPLFDOÀQGLQJV
5HVXOWV&HUWDLQFRPSRQHQWVRIWKHÀQJHUDQGKDQGVXFKDVOLJDPHQWVWHQGRQV
DQGFDUWLODJHZKLFKDUHVFDUFHO\VHHQE\FRQYHQWLRQDO[UD\LPDJLQJZHUHFOHDUO\
GHSLFWHGE\WKLVQHZV\VWHPDVH[SHFWHGWKURXJKWKHRQJRLQJZRUNZLWKKXPDQ
FDGDYHUV
&RQFOXVLRQ 7KLV QHZ LPDJLQJ WHFKQRORJ\ PD\ EHFRPH FOLQLFDOO\ DSSOLFDEOH
)XUWKHUWULDOVVKRXOGVWXG\PRUHQRUPDOYROXQWHHUVDQGSDWLHQWVDVZHOO
5RRP4
&DUGLDF
66
&DUGLDFLPDJLQJPLVFHOODQHRXV
0RGHUDWRUV
7/HLQHU8WUHFKW1/
1+6WULFNODQG/RQGRQ8.
%
,QFLGHQWDOGHWHFWLRQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLÀFDWLRQVRQQRQJDWHG
FKHVW&7GRUDGLRORJLVWVUHSRUWWKHP"
*5LQDOGL*0LQHR36SLQQDWR95XVVR//RYDWR0=RPSDWRUL%RORJQD,7
3XUSRVH&RURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLÀFDWLRQV &$& UHSUHVHQWDFDUGLDFULVNIDFWRUZLWK
UHOHYDQWSURJQRVWLFLPSOLFDWLRQVRFFDVLRQDOO\GLVFRYHUHGRQQRQJDWHGPXOWLGHWHFWRU
FKHVW&7'HVSLWHWKHLUFOLQLFDOLPSRUWDQFHWKH\DUHYHU\RIWHQQRWUHFRJQLVHGDQG
FRUUHFWO\UHSRUWHGE\UDGLRORJLVWV7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRHYDOXDWHWKHSRVVLEOH
GHWHFWLRQRI&$&RQQRQJDWHGFKHVW&7VWXGLHVQRWSHUIRUPHGIRUFRURQDULHVRU
FDUGLDFHYDOXDWLRQDQGDOVRWRDQDO\VHWKHLUUHSRUWLQJUDWH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGQRQJDWHGFKHVW&7
PXOWLGHWHFWRU&7XQLWFRQYHQWLRQDOGRVHSURWRFRO SHUIRUPHGIURP-DQXDU\WR
'HFHPEHULQRXUKRVSLWDO$VDÀUVWDSSURDFKWKHIRXUPDLQFRURQDU\DUWHU
LHVZHUHHYDOXDWHGZLWKDYLVXDOVFRUHWRDVVHVVWKHSUHVHQFHDQGVLWHRI&$&
7KHQUDGLRORJLFDOUHSRUWVZHUHFKHFNHGWRHYDOXDWHLI&$&ZHUHUHSRUWHGDQGLI
WKHFRUUHFWOHVLRQVVLWHZDVLQGLFDWHG
5HVXOWV,QDOOSDWLHQWV IHPDOHVDQGPDOHVPHDQDJH\HDUVROG
WKHHYDOXDWLRQRI&$&ZDVIHDVLEOH:HUHFRJQLVHGWKHSUHVHQFHRI&$&LQ
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
SDWLHQWVUDGLRORJLVWVUHSRUWHG&$&RQO\LQ SDWLHQWVDQG
LQQRQHRIWKHPWKHFRURQDU\DUWHULHVLQYROYHGZHUHLQGLFDWHG
&RQFOXVLRQ1RQJDWHGFKHVW&7LVDYDOLGWRROIRUWKHHYDOXDWLRQRI&$&1RZD
GD\VUDGLRORJLVWVDUHQRWFRQÀGHQWLQUHSRUWLQJWKLVLQFLGHQWDOÀQGLQJ:KHQWKH
FRURQDULHVDUHQRWWKHDLPRI&7VWXG\WKHUHSRUWLQJUDWHRI&$&LVYHU\ORZ$
V\VWHPDWLFHYDOXDWLRQRI&$&FRXOGEHSURSRVHGLQDOOFKHVW&7VWXGLHVWRRIIHU
DGGLWLRQDOFOLQLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQFRQFHUQLQJKHDUWGLVHDVHULVN
%
3URJUHVVLRQRIFRURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLÀFDWLRQVGXULQJWKHÀUVW\HDU
DIWHUUHQDOWUDQVSODQWDWLRQ
/9)RU]HQLJR'&UHVVHUL&$OÀHUL//RQJKL0*5DFLWL0*DUDYDJOLD
0LODQ,7 ODXUDYI#OLEHURLW
3XUSRVH&DUGLRYDVFXODUGLVHDVH &9' LVWKHPRVWFRPPRQFRPSOLFDWLRQDIWHU
NLGQH\WUDQVSODQW .7[ DQGFRURQDU\DUWHU\FDOFLÀFDWLRQV &$& DUHFODLPHGWR
SOD\DNH\UROH6FDQW\DQGFRQWUDGLFWRU\UHVXOWVKDYHEHHQSURGXFHGRQWKLVWRSLF
,QWKHSUHVHQWVWXG\ZHORRNHGDWWKH&$&SURJUHVVLRQHYDOXDWHGDFFRUGLQJWR
6HYUXNRYҋVFULWHULDGXULQJWKHÀUVW\HDUDIWHU.7[
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH .7[ SDWLHQWV ZHUH HYDOXDWHG ZLWKLQ
PRQWKV DIWHU .7[ IRU &$& HYDOXDWLRQ ZLWK &7 ,Q SDWLHQWV ZH UHSHDWHG WKH
&$&HYDOXDWLRQDIWHU\HDU,QSDWLHQWVZKRGLGQRWSHUIRUPWKHVHFRQGFRQWURO
EHFDXVHRIDQ\FOLQLFDOUHDVRQ7KH$JDWVWRQHVFRUH $6 YDOXHVDQGFKDQJHV
ZHUHSXWLQWRUHODWLRQVKLSZLWKWKHPDLQELRFKHPLFDODQGFOLQLFDOYDULDEOHVXVLQJ
XQLYDULDWH 8$ DQGPXOWLYDULDWHDQDO\VLV 0$
5HVXOWV$WEDVDOHYDOXDWLRQ KDGVLJQLÀFDQW$6YDOXHV7KHEDVDO$6
YDOXHVZHUHUHODWHGRQO\WRWKHDJHRIWKHSDWLHQWDWHLWKHU8$RU0$ S
$IWHU\HDU SDWLHQWVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ZRUVHQWKHLU$6YDOXHVZKLOHWKH
UHPDLQLQJGLGQRW1RVLJQLÀFDQWUHODWLRQVKLSZDVIRXQGEHWZHHQDQ\FOLQLFDO
LQVWUXPHQWDORUODERUDWRU\GDWDDQGZRUVHQLQJRI$6QRUWKHUHZDVDQ\UHODWLRQVKLS
RIZRUVHQLQJLQ$6ZLWKDQ\FKDQJHLQUHQDOIXQFWLRQ
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSUHVHQFHRI&$&VLVDIUHTXHQWÀQGLQJDWWLPHRI.7[$ZRUVHQLQJ
RI&$&LVDOVRREVHUYHG+RZHYHUWKHFOLQLFDOPHDQLQJRIWKLVÀQGLQJLVHTXLYR
FDODQGZHQHHGODUJHUVWXGLHVEHIRUHGHFLGLQJZKHWKHUWKH&$&DVVHVVPHQWLV
ZRUWKGRLQJRQDURXWLQHEDVLV
%
6SRUWFDWHJRU\LVDQLPSRUWDQWGHWHUPLQDQWRIFDUGLDFDGDSWDWLRQDQ
05,VWXG\
7/XLMN[0-&UDPHU1+-3UDNNHQ&)%XFNHQV)-*%DFN[
:3700DOL%.9HOWKXLV8WUHFKW1/ WOXLMN[#JPDLOFRP
)XOO\DXWRPDWHGDVVHVVPHQWRIULJKWYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQDO
SDUDPHWHUVIURP(&*JDWHGFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\GDWD
HYDOXDWLRQRISURWRW\SHVRIWZDUH
5:%DXHU$:U]HVQLDN'%HUQKDUGW7/HKQHUW
)9HJD+LJXHUD7-9RJO-0.HUO)UDQNIXUWD0DLQ'(
)RUFKKHLP'( UDOIZEDXHU#DROFRP
3XUSRVH(QODUJHPHQWRIWKHULJKWYHQWULFOHLVDVLJQRI59G\VIXQFWLRQSUHVVXUH
RUYROXPHRYHUORDGRUDUUK\WKPRJHQLF59G\VSODVLDDQGDOVRDVXUYLYDOSUHGLFWRU
LQFKURQLFSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHDQGSXOPRQDU\HPEROLVP:HHYDOXDWHGWKHSHU
IRUPDQFHRISURWRW\SHVRIWZDUHIRUIXOO\DXWRPDWHGVHJPHQWDWLRQDQGYROXPHWU\
RIWKHULJKWYHQWULFOH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV,QUHWURVSHFWLYHO\(&*JDWHGFRURQDU\&7DQJLRJUDSK\
VFDQVWKHHQGV\VWROLF 599PLQ DQGHQGGLDVWROLF 599PD[ YROXPHRIWKHULJKW
YHQWULFOH ZDV FDOFXODWHG IXOO\ DXWRPDWLFDOO\ E\ SURWRW\SH VRIWZDUH 0DQXDO VOLFH
VHJPHQWDWLRQE\WZRLQGHSHQGHQWUDGLRORJLVWVVHUYHGDVWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG
0HDVXUHPHQWSHULRGVZHUHFRPSDUHGIRUWKHVHPHWKRGV
5HVXOWV5LJKWYHQWULFXODUYROXPHVFDOFXODWHGZLWKWKHSURWRW\SHVRIWZDUHZHUH
LQH[FHOOHQWDJUHHPHQWZLWKWKHUHVXOWVIURPPDQXDOVOLFHVHJPHQWDWLRQ %ODQG
$OWPDQ U S /LQ V FRUUHODWLRQ 5KR S
IRU599PD[DQG599PLQZLWKH[FHOOHQWLQWHUREVHUYHUDJUHHPHQWEHWZHHQERWK
UDGLRORJLVWV U S 7KHUHZDVQRQHHGIRUPDQXDOFRUUHFWLRQRIWKH
59ERUGHUVDVVHJPHQWHGE\WKHVRIWZDUHLQDVLQJOHFDVH0HDVXUHPHQWSHULRG
ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\VKRUWHUZLWKWKHVRIWZDUH V WKDQZLWKPDQXDOVOLFHVHJ
PHQWDWLRQ V
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSURWRW\SHVRIWZDUHZDVDEOHWRGHPRQVWUDWHH[FHOOHQWSHUIRUP
DQFHLQFRPSDULVRQWRWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG,WSURPLVHVQRWRQO\WRPLQLPLVH
SRVWSURFHVVLQJWLPHEXWDOVRWRHOLPLQDWHVXEMHFWLYHVHOHFWLRQRIVOLFHVDQGFDUGLDF
SKDVHV
%
7UXHUHDOWLPHFDUGLDF05,LQIUHHEUHDWKLQJZLWKRXW(&*
V\QFKURQLVDWLRQXVLQJUDGLDONVSDFHVDPSOLQJLQLWLDOUHVXOWV
5:%DXHU,5DGWNH6=KDQJ7%ORFN-0.HUO0*0DFN7**UDI
7-9RJO0&/DUVRQ)UDQNIXUW'(*|WWLQJHQ'( UDOIZEDXHU#DROFRP
3XUSRVH:HLQYHVWLJDWHGDQRYHO7UXH),63VHTXHQFHEDVHGRQUDGLDONVSDFH
VDPSOLQJ U7UXH),63 WKDWGRHVQRWUHTXLUH(&*V\QFKURQLVDWLRQ RUEUHDWKKROG
IRUFLQHFDUGLDF05,
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV KHDOWK\ YROXQWHHUV KHDUW UDWH ESP UDQJH
ESP XQGHUZHQW 7 FDUGLDF 05, 6LQJOHVKRW VKRUW D[LV YLHZV ZHUH
DFTXLUHGZLWKD UHWURVSHFWLYHO\(&*JDWHGVHJPHQWHGEUHDWKKROGFLQHEDODQFHG
VWHDG\VWDWHIUHHSUHFLVLRQ E66)3 DQGE ZLWKU7UXH),63VHTXHQFHVZLWKVOLGLQJ
ZLQGRZDFTXLVLWLRQ VXEIUDPHV ZLWKDWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQRIIUVDQGIUV
U7UXH),63ZHUHDFTXLUHGGXULQJIUHHEUHDWKLQJZLWKRXW(&*V\QFKURQLVDWLRQ/HIW
YHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV ('9(69() ZHUHGHWHUPLQHGDFFRUGLQJWR
WKH6LPSVRQ VUXOHZLWKE66)3UHSUHVHQWLQJWKHUHIHUHQFHVWDQGDUG&RQWUDVWWR
QRLVHUDWLR &15 RIP\RFDUGLXPEORRGSRROZDVFDOFXODWHG4XDOLW\RIZDOOPRWLRQ
GHSLFWLRQZDVDVVHVVHGE\WZRUDGLRORJLVWV JRRG IDLU QRQGLDJQRVWLF
5HVXOWV()VKRZHGVWURQJFRUUHODWLRQ U S EHWZHHQE66)3
DQGIUVU7UXH),63 EXWRQO\PRGHUDWHFRUUHODWLRQ U ZLWKIUV
U7UXH),63 7KHUHDVRQIRUWKDWZDVWKDW(69ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ S
RYHUHVWLPDWHGZLWKIUVU7UXH),63 IUVPOIUVPOE66)3
PO 0HDQ&15ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\ORZHU S ZLWKIUVU7UXH),63
FRPSDUHGWRIUVU7UXH),63DQGE66)3 YVYV +RZHYHUGXH
WRWKHIDVWHUWHPSRUDOUHVROXWLRQLPDJHTXDOLW\IRUZDOOPRWLRQDVVHVVPHQWZDV
UDWHGVLJQLÀFDQWO\EHWWHUIRUIUV
&RQFOXVLRQ/HIWYHQWULFXODUIXQFWLRQDODQDO\VLVZLWKUHDOWLPHQRQ(&*V\QFKUR
QLVHGIUHHEUHDWKLQJU7UXH),63LVLQJRRGDJUHHPHQWZLWKVWDQGDUG(&*JDWHG
EUHDWKKROGFLQHE66)3VHTXHQFHV
%
(YLGHQFHRIFRQWLQXRXVKHOLFDOVWUXFWXUHRIWKHFDUGLDFYHQWULFXODU
DQDWRP\DVVHVVHGE\GLIIXVLRQWHQVRULPDJLQJPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFH
PXOWLUHVROXWLRQWUDFWRJUDSK\
$+LGDOJR)3RYHGD(0DUWL'*LO$$QGDOX])&DUUHUDV
0%DOOHVWHU%DUFHORQD(6/OHLGD(6 DOKLGDOJRS#JPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH'HHSXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIP\RFDUGLDOVWUXFWXUHOLQNLQJPRUSKRORJ\DQGIXQF
WLRQRIWKHKHDUWZRXOGXQUDYHOFUXFLDONQRZOHGJHIRUPHGLFDODQGVXUJLFDOFOLQLFDO
SURFHGXUHVDQGVWXGLHV'LIIXVLRQWHQVRU05,SURYLGHVDGLVFUHWHPHDVXUHPHQW
RIWKH'DUUDQJHPHQWRIP\RFDUGLDOÀEUHVE\WKHREVHUYDWLRQRIORFDODQLVRWURSLF
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH3K\VLRORJLFFDUGLDFDGDSWDWLRQLQDWKOHWHVLVLQÁXHQFHGE\ERG\VXUIDFH
DUHDJHQGHUDJHWUDLQLQJLQWHQVLW\DQGVSRUWW\SH7KLVVWXG\DVVHVVHVWKHLQÁX
HQFHRIVSRUWFDWHJRU\DQGSURYLGHVDUHIHUHQFHIUDPHZRUNIRUSK\VLRORJLFOLPLWV
E\VSRUWFDWHJRU\DQGJHQGHU
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVVXEMHFWV PHDQDJH\HDUVUDQJH
PHQ XQGHUZHQWDFDUGLDF05, &05 LQYHVWLJDWLRQKHDOWK\QRQDWKOHWHV
KRXUVZHHNO\H[HUFLVH DQGKHDOWK\HOLWHDWKOHWHV PHDQKRXUVZHHNO\
H[HUFLVH $WKOHWHVSHUIRUPHGHLWKHUORZG\QDPLFKLJKVWDWLF /'+6Q KLJK
G\QDPLFORZ VWDWLF +'/6 Q RU KLJK G\QDPLFKLJK VWDWLF VSRUWV +'+6
Q
5HVXOWV 7KH OHIW YHQWULFXODU /9 HQGGLDVWROLF YROXPH ('9 POP IRU QRQ
DWKOHWHV/'+6+'/6+'+6 UHVSHFWLYHO\ ZDV LQ PDOHV
DQG LQ IHPDOHV 7KH /9 HQGGLDVWROLF PDVV ('0 JP IRU
QRQDWKOHWHV/'+6+'/6+'+6 ZDV IRU PDOHV DQG
IRUIHPDOHV$WKOHWHVҋ/9('9('0UDWLRVZHUHQRWODUJHUWKDQLQQRQDWKOHWHV
GLVSURYLQJVHOHFWLYHYHQWULFXODUZDOOWKLFNHQLQJ/959('9UDWLRVZHUHVLPLODULQ
DOOJURXSV PDOHVIHPDOHVUDQJH 0XOWLYDULDWHOLQHDUUHJUHVVLRQ
GHPRQVWUDWHGDKLJKO\VLJQLÀFDQWFRQWULEXWLRQRIVSRUWFDWHJRU\ZLWKFRHIÀFLHQWV
ODUJHUWKDQWKDWRIWUDLQLQJKRXUVJHQGHUDQGDJH S/9('9('0FRHI
ÀFLHQWVIRUVSRUWFDWHJRU\/'+6+'/6+'+6
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLVVWXG\GHPRQVWUDWHVEDODQFHGFDUGLDFDGDSWDWLRQIRUDOOVSRUW
FDWHJRULHVZLWKSUHVHUYHGUDWLRVRI/9YROXPH/9ZDOOPDVVDQG/959YROXPH
6SRUWFDWHJRU\KDVDODUJHLPSDFWRQFDUGLDFDGDSWDWLRQ+'+6VSRUWVVKRZWKH
ODUJHVWFKDQJHVZKHUHDV/'+6VSRUWVVKRZGLPHQVLRQVVLPLODUWRQRQDWKOHWHV
7KLVVWXG\ҋVUHVXOWVFDQVHUYHDVDUHIHUHQFHLQFOLQLFDOSUDFWLFH
%
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
GLIIXVLRQRIZDWHUPROHFXOHVLQELRORJLFDOWLVVXHV,QWKLVZRUNZHSUHVHQWDPXOWL
VFDOHYLVXDOLVDWLRQWHFKQLTXHEDVHGRQ'705,VWUHDPOLQLQJFDSDEOHRIXQFRYHULQJ
DGGLWLRQDOSURSHUWLHVRIWKHDUFKLWHFWXUDORUJDQLVDWLRQRIWKHKHDUW
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HVHOHFWHGWKH-RKQ+RSNLQV8QLYHUVLW\ -+8 &DQLQH
+HDUW'DWDVHWZKHUHWKHORQJD[LVFDUGLDFSODQHLVDOLJQHGZLWKWKHVFDQQHUҋV=
D[LV7KHLUHTXLSPHQWLQFOXGHGDHOHPHQWSDVVHGDUUD\FRLOHPLWWLQJD7)RU
'7,DFTXLVLWLRQD')6(VHTXHQFHLVDSSO\:HXVHGVHHGVIRUIXOOVFDOH
WUDFWRJUDSK\ZKLOHZHDSSOLHGD0,3PDSSLQJWHFKQLTXHIRUVLPSOLÀHGWUDFWRJUDSKLF
UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ,QWKLVFDVHZHUHGXFHGHDFK'7,'YROXPHGLPHQVLRQVE\RUGHU
WZRPDJQLWXGHEHIRUHVWUHDPOLQLQJ
5HVXOWV 2XU VLPSOLÀHG WUDFWRJUDSKLF UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ PHWKRG NHHSV WKH PDLQ
JHRPHWULF IHDWXUHV RI ÀEUHV DOORZLQJ IRU DQ HDVLHU LGHQWLÀFDWLRQ RI WKHLU JOREDO
PRUSKRORJLFDO GLVSRVLWLRQ LQFOXGLQJ WKH YHQWULFXODU EDVDO ULQJ 0RUHRYHU ZH
QRWLFHGDFOHDUO\YLVLEOHKHOLFDOGLVSRVLWLRQRIWKHP\RFDUGLDOÀEUHVLQOLQHZLWKWKH
KHOLFDOP\RFDUGLDOEDQGYHQWULFXODUVWUXFWXUHGHVFULEHGE\7RUUHQW*XDVS)LQDOO\
RXUVLPSOLÀHGYLVXDOLVDWLRQZLWKVLQJOHWUDFWVLGHQWLÀHVWKHPDLQVHJPHQWVRIWKH
KHOLFDOYHQWULFXODUDUFKLWHFWXUH
&RQFOXVLRQ '705, PDNHV SRVVLEOH WKH LGHQWLÀFDWLRQ RI D FRQWLQXRXV KHOLFDO
DUFKLWHFWXUH RI WKH P\RFDUGLDO ÀEUHV ZKLFK YDOLGDWHV 7RUUHQW*XDVSҋV KHOLFDO
P\RFDUGLDOEDQGYHQWULFXODUDQDWRPLFDOPRGHO
%
,QDFFXUDFLHVLQFLQH66)305/9YROXPHWULFPHDVXUHPHQWV
LQSDWLHQWVZLWK/9K\SHUWURSK\FRUUHFWLRQDSSO\LQJWKHPDVV
FRQVHUYDWLRQSULQFLSOH
.8%DXQHU0'XUDQG$&UHDQ(1JX\HQ6/H\5:DOG
+5DNRZVNL13DXO%:LQWHUVSHUJHU7RURQWR21&$
.HUVWLQ%DXQHU#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7KHVWXG\DLPZDVWRHYDOXDWHGLIIHUHQFHVRI/9PDVVDQG(69DVVHVV
PHQWLQSDWLHQWVZLWK/9K\SHUWURSK\E\FRPSDULQJVWDQGDUGFRQWRXULQJPHWKRGV
ZLWKDWRWDO/9YROXPHDSSURDFKZKLFKLQFOXGHVDSSOLFDWLRQRIWKH´FRQVHUYDWLRQ
RIPDVVµSULQFLSOHIRUP\RFDUGLDOYROXPH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOVSDWLHQWVGLDJQRVHGZLWK+&0'&0 Q XQGHU
JRLQJFDUGLDF05DW77ZHUHLQFOXGHG$OOSDWLHQWVXQGHUZHQWVWDQGDUGFLQH
66)3LQVKRUWD[LVRULHQWDWLRQIRU/9YROXPHWULFV [[PP75PV
)RUWKHWRWDO/9YROXPHDSSURDFKGDWDVHWVZHUHHYDOXDWHGXVLQJVHPLDXWRPDWHG
SRVWSURFHVVLQJ ZLWK HSL DQG HQGRFDUGLDO FRQWRXULQJ DW HQGGLDVWROH (' DQG
HSLFDUGLDO FRQWRXULQJ RQO\ DW HQGV\VWROH (6 &DOFXODWLRQ RI (69 ZDV EDVHG
RQWRWDO/9YROXPHDQGWKHP\RFDUGLDOYROXPHDVDVVHVVHGDW('DSSO\LQJWKH
PDVVFRQVHUYDWLRQSULQFLSOH 0&3 $QDO\VLVZDVSHUIRUPHGIRU'&0DQG+&0
SDWLHQWVDQGFRPSDUHGWRVWDQGDUG/9YROXPHWULFDVVHVVPHQW 67' ZLWKHSLDQG
HQGRFDUGLDOFRQWRXULQJDW('(6IRU('9(69DQGP\RFDUGLDOPDVV
5HVXOWV7KH+&0JURXSVKRZHGVPDOOHU(69XVLQJ67'DVFRPSDUHGWR0&3
POYVPOS ZKLOHQRGLIIHUHQFHVZHUHIRXQGIRUWKH
'&0JURXS POYVPOS $YHUDJH+&0()GHFOLQHG
IURP 67' WR 0&3 S /9PDVVXVLQJ67'DSSURDFKGLIIHUHG
E\J &,J EHWZHHQ('DQG(6LQ'&0SDWLHQWV
S EXWE\J &,J LQWKH+&0JURXS
S
&RQFOXVLRQ(69DQGHQGV\VWROLFPDVVDVVHVVPHQWLVFKDOOHQJLQJLQ+&0GXH
WR SUREOHPDWLF HQGV\VWROLF HQGRFDUGLDO FRQWRXULQJ DQG XQGHUHVWLPDWLRQ RI WUXH
(698WLOLVDWLRQRIWKH/9PDVVFRQVHUYDWLRQSULQFLSOHPD\LQFUHDVHDFFXUDF\
%
&DUGLDF05,XVLQJDQHZWULJJHUPHWKRG05FRPSDWLEOH'RSSOHU
XOWUDVRXQGGHYLFHWRWULJJHUWKHKHDUWIUHTXHQF\LQFRPSDULVRQWR(&*
%6FKRHQQDJHO&0XFK-<DPDPXUD.7RUQTXLVW*$GDP
8:HGHJlUWQHU+DPEXUJ'( ZHGHJDHU#XNHXQLKDPEXUJGH
3XUSRVH7KH DLP ZDV WR DVVHVV D 05 FRPSDWLEOH 'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQG GHYLFH
DVDQHZPHWKRGWRWULJJHUWKHKHDUWUDWHIRUFDUGLDF05,LQFRPSDULVRQWR(&*
WULJJHULQJ
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV05LPDJLQJZDVSHUIRUPHGRQVKHHSRQD705
VFDQQHU7KH'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQGVHQVRUZDVSODFHGRQWKHFKHVWDERYHWKHKHDUW
DQGÀ[HGJHQWO\ZLWKDEHOW7KHUHFRUGHGVLJQDOZDVWUDQVIHUUHGWRWKH(&*WULJJHU
XQLWRIWKH05,VFDQQHUDQGXVHGIRUFDUGLDFWULJJHULQJ$GGLWLRQDOO\FRQYHQWLRQDO
(&*WULJJHULQJZDVUHFRUGHG&DUGLDF05,ZDVSHUIRUPHGXVLQJERWKWULJJHULQJ
PHWKRGV FRQVHFXWLYHO\ )RU FDUGLDF 05, JUDGLHQW HFKR VHTXHQFHV LQ DQG
FKDPEHUYLHZDQGLQVKRUWD[LVYLHZZLWKFLQHVHTXHQFHV SKDVHV WRGHWHUPLQH
OHIWYHQWULFXODUYROXPHV /9 DQGHMHFWLRQIUDFWLRQ () ZHUHJHQHUDWHG05LPDJHV
DFTXLUHGZLWK'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQGDQGFRQYHQWLRQDO(&*WULJJHULQJZHUHHYDOXDWHG
VHSDUDWHO\E\WZRUDGLRORJLVWVFRQFHUQLQJLPDJHTXDOLW\DQGIXQFWLRQDODVVHVVPHQW
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
5HVXOWV&DUGLDF05LPDJLQJZDVSRVVLEOHLQDOOH[DPLQDWLRQVXVLQJWKH
'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQGGHYLFHDQGXVLQJ(&*WULJJHULQJ8VLQJ'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQG
IRUWULJJHULQJLPDJHTXDOLW\ZDVFRPSDUDEOHWR(&*$OODQDWRPLFDOVWUXFWXUHVFRXOG
EHFOHDUO\HYDOXDWHG)RUIXQFWLRQDOHYDOXDWLRQWKH/9DQGWKH()ZHUHDVVHVVHG
7KHUHZDVQRVLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQERWKPHWKRGV/9PODQG()
IRU'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQGDQG/9DQGIRU(&*
&RQFOXVLRQ7KH05FRPSDWLEOH'RSSOHUXOWUDVRXQGGHYLFHLVDQHZWULJJHULQJ
PHWKRGIRUFDUGLDF05,,WPLJKWEHIDVWHUDQGHDVLHULQWKHDSSOLFDWLRQFRPSDUHG
WR(&*
%
1RQLQYDVLYHFDUGLDFYHLQPDSSLQJUROHRI0'&7&$
50DODJR$3H]]DWR&%DUELDQL8$OIRQVL*6DOD53R]]L0XFHOOL
9HURQD,7 UREHUWRPDODJ#\DKRRLW
3XUSRVH&RURQDU\YHQRXVDQDWRP\LVRISULPDU\LPSRUWDQFHZKHQLPSODQWLQJD
SDFHPDNHURUDGHÀEULOODWRUGHYLFHEHFDXVHFRURQDU\VLQXVFDQEHHQODUJHGRU
VWHQRWLFGHSHQGLQJRQFKURQLFKHDUWIDLOXUH7KHDLPRIWKLVVWXG\LVWRHYDOXDWHWKH
XVHIXOQHVVRI0'&7&$LQGHVFULELQJWKHFRURQDU\YHQRXVWUHHDQGLQSDUWLFXODU
WKHFRURQDU\VLQXVDQGGHWHFWLQJPDLQYHQRXVV\VWHPYDULDQWV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV FRQVHFXWLYH SDWLHQWV PHDQ DJH <2
VWXGLHGIRUFRURQDU\DUWHU\GLVHDVHZLWKVOLFH0'&7&$ZHUHUHWURVSHFWLYHO\
H[DPLQHG7KHFDUGLDFYHQRXVV\VWHPZDVGHSLFWHGXVLQJ'035F035DQG
0,3SRVWSURFHVVLQJUHFRQVWUXFWLRQVRQDQRIIOLQHZRUNVWDWLRQ)RUHDFKSDWLHQW
LPDJHTXDOLW\SUHVHQFHDQGFDOLEUHRIWKHFRURQDU\VLQXV &6 JUHDWFDUGLDFYHLQ
*&9 PLGGOHYHLQ 09 DQWHULRULQWHUYHQWULFXODUYHLQ $,9 ODWHUDOFDUGLDFYHLQ
/&9 SRVWHULRUFDUGLDFYHLQ 3&9 VPDOOFDUGLDFYHLQ 6&9 DQGSUHVHQFHRI
YDULDQWRIWKHQRUPDODQDWRP\ZHUHUHFRUGHG
5HVXOWVDQG&RQFOXVLRQ&6*&909DQG$,9ZHUHYLVXDOLVHGLQRIWKH
FDVHV7KH/&9ZDVYLVXDOLVHGLQ SDWLHQWVWKH3&9LQ
SDWLHQWVDQGWKH6&9LQ SDWLHQWV0HDQGLDPHWHURIWKH&6
ZDVPPLQ SDWLHQWVZLWKRXWFKURQLFKHDUWIDLOXUHDQGPP
LQ SDWLHQWVFKURQLFKHDUWIDLOXUH
%
$FFHOHUDWHGFLQHLPDJLQJRIWKHKHDUWLQPLFHDW7FRPSDULVRQRI
UHWURVSHFWLYHO\VHOIJDWHGDQGSURVSHFWLYHO\WULJJHUHG)/$6+VHTXHQFHV
3)ULHV-6WURHGHU$0XHOOHU$0DVVPDQQ56HLGHO*6FKQHLGHU
$%XHFNHU+RPEXUJ'( GUSHWHUIULHV#JRRJOHPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH 7R FRPSDUH SURVSHFWLYHO\ WULJJHUHG )/$6+ 37 ZLWK UHWURVSHFWLYHO\
VHOIJDWHG 56* DQGDFFHOHUDWHGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\VHOIJDWHG)/$6+ DFF56* FLQH
VHTXHQFHVIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRIFDUGLDFIXQFWLRQLQPLFHDW7
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV &%/ PLFH ZHUH H[DPLQHG RQ D 7 DQLPDO
VFDQQHU %UXNHU %LR6SHF *HUPDQ\ :H DFTXLUHG FRQVHFXWLYH PP VKRUW
D[LV VOLFHV FRYHULQJ WKH OHIW YHQWULFOH /9 XVLQJ D 37 757( њ
)29 [ FP PDWUL[ [ IUDPHV 3, D 56* 757(
њ )29 [ FP PDWUL[ [ IUDPHV 3, DQG DQ DFF56*
757( њ )29 [ FP PDWUL[ [ FDUGLDF IUDPHV
3,*5$33$ 7ZRUHDGHUVLQGHSHQGHQWO\HYDOXDWHGWKHGLIIHUHQWGDWDVHWVLQD
EOLQGHGPDQQHU WZLFHVHSDUDWHGE\ZHHNV UHJDUGLQJ/9('9/9(6969()
FDUGLDF RXWSXW &2 DQG P\RFDUGLDO PDVV 0\R0 7RWDO DFTXLVLWLRQ WLPHV 7$
IRU WKH FRPSOHWH H[DPLQDWLRQ RI WKH KHDUW ZHUH DVVHVVHG IRU HDFK VHTXHQFH
6WDWLVWLFDODQDO\VHVLQFOXGHGDRQHZD\$129$ZLWK%RQIHUURQLPXOWLFRPSDULVRQ
WHVW S DQG%ODQG$OWPDQDQDO\VHVIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRILQWUDDQGLQWHU
REVHUYHUYDULDELOLW\
5HVXOWV7KHUHZHUHQRVWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLÀFDQWGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHGLIIHUHQW
LPDJLQJDSSURDFKHVIRUDOOFDUGLDFSDUDPHWHUV /9('9 3756*DFF56* PHDQ
O S /9(69 O S 69
OS () S &2 PO
PLQS DQG0\R0 PJS 7$ZDVVLJQLÀFDQWO\VKRUWHU
IRUDFF56* PLQS FRPSDUHGWR37 PHDQ6'PLQ
DQG56* PLQ
&RQFOXVLRQ&LQH05,ZLWKDFF56*DOORZVIRUDQDVVHVVPHQWRIFDUGLDFIXQFWLRQ
LQPLFHZLWKLQPLQZKLOHSURYLGLQJWKHVDPHTXDQWLWDWLYHGDWDDVFRQYHQWLRQDO37
DQG56*)/$6+VHTXHQFHV7KLVDSSURDFKDOORZVDQH[SHGLWLRQRI05VWXGLHV
LQFDUGLRYDVFXODUGLVHDVHPRGHOV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
&RPSXWHU$SSOLFDWLRQV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KLV DOVR RSHQV QHZ RSSRUWXQLWLHV IRU WKH LPSOHPHQWDWLRQ RI QHZ
EXVLQHVVSURFHVVHVVHUYLFHVVXFKDVWHOHUDGLRORJ\%\WKHVHPHDQVWKHH[HUFLVH
RIUHDOÀOPOHVVUDGLRORJ\FDQEHPRUHZLGHO\DFKLHYHG
66
%
5RRP=
,PDJLQJLQIRUPDWLFV
0RGHUDWRUV
0)DWHKL7HKUDQ,5
30F/DXJKOLQ&RUN,(
%
&RPELQDWLRQRIPDFKLQHOHDUQLQJDQGFRPSXWHUDVVLVWHGGLDJQRVLV
LQEUHDVW05,V\VWHPDWLFLQYHVWLJDWLRQLGHQWLÀHVKLJKSRWHQWLDOWR
VWUDWLI\VXUYLYDORXWFRPHLQSULPDU\EUHDVWFDQFHU
0'LHW]HO$'LHW]HO5=RXEL2&DPDUD0%RJGDQ:$.DLVHU
3$7%DOW]HU-HQD'(7ELQJHQ'( GLHW]HOPDWWKLDV#KRWPDLOFRP
3XUSRVH$SSOLFDWLRQRIEUHDVW05,DVDSURJQRVWLFELRPDUNHUUHPDLQVFKDOOHQJ
LQJ GXH WR WKH PXOWLWXGH DQG FRPSOH[LW\ RI LQIRUPDWLRQ SURYLGHG E\ RQH VLQJOH
H[DPLQDWLRQ 0DFKLQHOHDUQLQJ LV D SRWHQWLDO PHWKRG WR FODVVLI\ VXFK GDWD$F
FRUGLQJO\ZHGHVLJQHGWKLVLQYHVWLJDWLRQWRV\VWHPDWLFDOO\HYDOXDWHWKHSRWHQWLDO
RIPDFKLQHOHDUQLQJDOJRULWKPVWRSUHGLFWRYHUDOOVXUYLYDORIEUHDVWFDQFHUSDWLHQWV
EDVHGRQEUHDVW05,ÀQGLQJV
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV 3DWLHQWV UHFHLYLQJ EUHDVW05, VWDQGDUGLVHG SURWR
FRO 7Z)/$6+ PPRONJ%: *G'73$ EHIRUH VXUJHU\ %,5$'6 ,99,
QR VHFRQGDU\UHFXUUHQWFDQFHU ZHUH HQUROOHG WUHDWHG DQG IROORZHGXS DW RXU
EUHDVWFDQFHUFHQWUH´'LVHDVHUHODWHGGHDWKµZDVGHÀQHGDVHQGSRLQW$FRP
PHUFLDOO\DYDLODEOH&$'V\VWHP FRPSXWHUDVVLVWHGGLDJQRVLV ZDVXVHGWRVHPL
DXWRPDWLFDOO\HYDOXDWHHQKDQFHPHQWSDUDPHWHUVRIWKHSULPDU\EUHDVWFDQFHU
XSRQEUHDVW05,7KUHHPDFKLQHOHDUQLQJDOJRULWKPV DUWLÀFLDOQHXUDOQHWZRUNV
NQHDUHVWQHLJKERXU VXSSRUWYHFWRUPDFKLQHV ZHUH RSWLPLVHG WR SUHGLFW WKH
HQGSRLQW EDVHG RQ VXFK HQKDQFHPHQWSDUDPHWHUV 3UHGLFWLRQV RI WKH HQGSRLQW
ZHUHFRPSDUHGZLWKFRQYHQWLRQDOVWDWLVWLFV ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQ 7RDXWRPDWLFDOO\
RSWLPLVH DQG YDOLGDWH IROGFURVVYDOLGDWLRQ WKHVH FODVVLÀFDWLRQDOJRULWKPV DQ
LQKRXVHGHYHORSHGIUDPHZRUNZDVXVHG
5HVXOWVSDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\LQYDVLYHEUHDVWFDQFHUZHUHHQUROOHG PHDQDJH
\HDUV 'XULQJDPHDQIROORZXSLQWHUYDORIPRQWKV´GLVHDVHUHODWHGGHDWKµ
RFFXUUHGLQSDWLHQWV&RPSDUHGWRFRQYHQWLRQDOVWDWLVWLFV ORJLVWLFUHJUHVVLRQ
DOO PDFKLQHOHDUQLQJ DOJRULWKPV VKRZHG KLJKHU GLDJQRVWLF DFFXUDF\
ZLWK VXSSRUWYHFWRUPDFKLQHV DFKLHYLQJ WKH KLJKHVW YDOXH
0DFKLQHOHDUQLQJ VKRZHG SDUWLFXODUO\ KLJK VSHFLÀFLW\ DUWLÀFLDOQHXUDOQHWZRUNV
NQHDUHVWQHLJKERXU VXSSRUWYHFWRUPDFKLQHV DQG
QHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHWRVWUDWLI\WKHHQGSRLQW DUWLÀFLDOQHXUDOQHWZRUNV
NQHDUHVWQHLJKERXUVXSSRUWYHFWRUPDFKLQHV
&RQFOXVLRQ0DFKLQHOHDUQLQJLVDSURPLVLQJPHWKRGIRUWKHLQGLYLGXDOULVNVWUDWLÀ
FDWLRQRISDWLHQWVZLWKSULPDU\EUHDVWFDQFHU$FFRUGLQJWRRXUUHVXOWVLWLVVXSHULRU
WRFRQYHQWLRQDOVWDWLVWLFVDQGVKRZVKLJKVSHFLÀFLW\DQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXH
WRVWUDWLI\WKHHQGSRLQW´GLVHDVHUHODWHGGHDWKµ
%
5,63$&6DQGDUFKLYLQJRILPDJHVVHUYLFHVDQGEH\RQGGHOLYHUHG
IURPWKHFORXGWKHJUHDWHU3DULVDUHDH[SHULPHQWDWLRQ
9$'XVVDX[3%RLURQ3DULV)5 YDOHUHGXVVDX[#JFVGVLVLIIU
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
3XUSRVH,WLVLPSRUWDQWIRUUDGLRORJLVWVWRSUDFWLFHHYLGHQFHEDVHGPHGLFLQHDQG
LGHQWLI\LQJWKHODWHVWUHVHDUFKLVFUXFLDO:LWKWKHJURZWKLQPHGLFDOMRXUQDOVDQG
WKHERG\RINQRZOHGJHUDGLRORJLVWVQHHGWREHDZDUHRIVWUDWHJLHVWRLGHQWLI\XS
WRGDWHSXEOLFDWLRQV:HSHUIRUPDELEOLRPHWULFDQDO\VLVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHUDQJHRI
MRXUQDOVZKHUHUDGLRORJLFDOUHVHDUFKLVSXEOLVKHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHUDGLRORJLFDOMRXUQDOVZLWKWKHKLJKHVWLPSDFWIDFWRUV
ZHUHLGHQWLÀHGWKURXJKWKH-RXUQDO&LWDWLRQ5HSRUWV6\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZVRYHU
D\HDUSHULRGZHUHUHWULHYHGDQGWKHSULPDU\VWXGLHVFRQVWLWXWLQJWKHV\VWHPDWLF
UHYLHZVZHUHFRPSLOHGWRSURYLGHDGDWDEDVHRIKLJKTXDOLW\XQLTXHSXEOLFDWLRQV
7KHVH ZHUH FODVVLÀHG LQWR IRXU FDWHJRULHV UDGLRORJ\ MRXUQDOV FOLQLFDO VXE
VSHFLDOW\MRXUQDOVJHQHUDOPHGLFDOMRXUQDOVRWKHUV
5HVXOWVV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZVZHUHDQDO\VHGDQGSULPDU\VWXGLHVUHWULHYHG
7KHVHZHUHFODVVLÀHGDVIROORZV ZHUHSXEOLVKHGLQUDGLRORJLFDOMRXUQDOV
LQFOLQLFDOVXEVSHFLDOLW\MRXUQDOV LQJHQHUDOPHGLFDOMRXUQDOV
DQG LQRWKHUMRXUQDOV$PRQJVWUDGLRORJLFDOMRXUQDOVUDGLRORJ\KDGWKH
KLJKHVWQXPEHURIRULJLQDOVWXGLHVFLWHGZLWK
&RQFOXVLRQ 0RUH WKDQ KDOI RI LPSRUWDQW UDGLRORJLFDO UHVHDUFK LV SXEOLVKHG LQ
QRQUDGLRORJLFDOMRXUQDOV7KLVFDQEHH[SODLQHGE\VRPHFOLQLFDOVSHFLDOW\MRXUQDOV
KDYLQJLPSDFWIDFWRUVKLJKHUWKDQUDGLRORJ\MRXUQDOVFROODERUDWLRQEHWZHHQUHIHUULQJ
SK\VLFLDQVDQGUDGLRORJLVWVDQGLQFUHDVLQJLQYROYHPHQWRIUHIHUULQJSK\VLFLDQVLQ
GLUHFWO\DFTXLULQJLPDJLQJVWXGLHV7KHVFDWWHURIUDGLRORJLFDOUHVHDUFKDFURVVD
EURDGUDQJHRIMRXUQDOVPHDQVWKDWEURZVLQJVHOHFWHGUDGLRORJLFDOMRXUQDOVLVQRW
VXIÀFLHQWWRNHHSXSWRGDWH
%
(YDOXDWLRQRISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVRQFKHVW&7XVLQJL3DG
SUHOLPLQDU\H[SHULHQFH
/)DJJLRQL(1HUL36EUDJLD6$QJHOL/&LQL'/DXUHWWL'&DUDPHOOD
&%DUWROR]]L3LVD,7 OIDJJLRQL#VLUPRUJ
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRIWKHL3DGDVDPRELOHGHYLFHIRU'
UHDGLQJRIFKHVW&7GDWDVHWVIRUWKHDVVHVVPHQWRISXOPRQDU\QRGXOHV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV:HUHWURVSHFWLYHO\UHYLHZHGFKHVW&7H[DPLQDWLRQV
SHUIRUPHG LQ SDWLHQWV ZLWK SXOPRQDU\ QRGXOHV IRU D WRWDO RI QRGXOHV VL]HG
EHWZHHQPPDQGPP&7LPDJHVKDGEHHQDFTXLUHGXVLQJDURZ&7DQG
ZHUHZLUHOHVVO\LPSRUWHGLQ',&20IRUPDWRQDQL3DG*% $SSOH,QF&XSHU
WLQR&$ UXQQLQJ2VLUL;+' ZZZRVLUL[YLHZHUFRP IURPD0DFLQWRVKGHVNWRS
FRPSXWHU L0DF*+] FRQQHFWHGWRRXUKRVSLWDO3$&6DQGUXQQLQJ2VLUL;
7ZRH[SHULHQFHGUDWHUVUHDG&7GDWDVHWVLQGHSHQGHQWO\RQWKHL0DFDQGRQ
WKHL3DG'HWHFWLRQUDWHDQGVHJPHQWDOORFDOLVDWLRQRIOHVLRQVZHUHUHFRUGHGIRU
HDFKGDWDVHWDVZHOODVWKHWLPHQHHGHGIRUFRPSOHWHUHDGLQJRIHDFKFKHVW&7
H[DPLQDWLRQ,PDJHTXDOLW\ZDVDOVRYLVXDOO\DVVHVVHGXVLQJDWKUHHSRLQWVFDOH
SRRU IDLU JRRG
5HVXOWV$OOQRGXOHVGHWHFWHGRQWKHL0DFZHUHDOVRLGHQWLÀHGRQWKHL3DGDQG
WKHLUVHJPHQWDOORFDOLVDWLRQZDVFRUUHFWO\DVVHVVHGLQRIFDVHV,PDJHTXDOLW\
ZDVJRRGZLWKERWKGHYLFHVDQGLPDJHUHDGLQJWLPHZDVFRPSDUDEOHEHWZHHQWKHP
PLQXWHVIRUWKHL0DFYVPLQXWHVIRUWKHL3DGS!
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHL3DGFDQEHVXFFHVVIXOO\XVHGIRUSUHOLPLQDU\'UHDGLQJRI
FKHVW&7GDWDVHWVLQSDWLHQWVZLWKSXOPRQDU\QRGXOHVDVZHOODVIRULPDJHVKDULQJ
ZLWKQRQUDGLRORJ\VSHFLDOLVWVDQGIRUWHDFKLQJSXUSRVHV
%
$QRQWRORJ\RIPDJQHWLFUHVRQDQFHLPDJLQJVHTXHQFHV
-/DVEOHL]$%XUJXQ5'XYDXIHUULHU+6DLQW-DOPHV5HQQHV)5
-HUHP\ODVEOHL]#ODSRVWHQHW
3XUSRVH7KHJRDORIWKLVRQWRORJ\LVWRLPSURYHWKHVHPDQWLFLQWHURSHUDELOLW\IRU
05,VHTXHQFHV,QGHHGHYHU\FRQVWUXFWRUKDVKLVRZQVHTXHQFHQDPHWKDWFRXOG
EHXQNQRZQE\UDGLRORJLVWVRUHYHQ3$&6
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&RQFHSWVDQGGHÀQLWLRQVRI05,VHTXHQFHVKDGEHHQ
H[WUDFWHGIURPGRPDLQH[SHUWV',&20VWDQGDUG',&20KHDGHUVDQGOLWHUDWXUH
',&20KHDGHUVKDGEHHQH[WUDFWHGZLWK26,5,;$OOWKRVHGDWDKDGEHHQRUJDQLVHG
ZLWK3URWpJpRZO7KHOLQNDJHEHWZHHQFRQFHSWVKDGEHHQPDGHZLWKUHODWLRQV
DQGIRUPDOGHÀQLWLRQV
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6
0RQGD\
3XUSRVH7KH´5pJLRQ6DQV)LOPµ ´)LOPOHVV5HJLRQµ SURJUDPPHZDVODXQFKHG
LQE\WKH)UHQFK0LQLVWU\RI+HDOWKLQRUGHUWRKHOSWKHJHQHUDOLVDWLRQWRDOO
KHDOWKFDUHVWUXFWXUHVVXFKDVKRVSLWDOVRUJHQHUDOSK\VLFLDQSUDFWLFHVRI3$&6
5,6DQGV\VWHPVRIDUFKLYLQJRIPHGLFDOLPDJHV5HFHQWDFKLHYHPHQWVSURYHWKH
FRQFHSWRIWKHGHOLYHULQJRIVXFKVHUYLFHVIURPWKHFORXGDIWHUWKDWERWKEXLOGLQJRI
WKHSODWIRUPRIVHUYLFHVDQGSLORWSKDVHVRIWKHSURJUDPZHUHFRPSOHWHG0RUHRYHU
QHZVHUYLFHVRIVKDULQJRILQIRUPDWLRQDUHSURYHGSRVVLEOH
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHVHUYLFHVDUHGHOLYHUHGE\PHDQVRIDSODWIRUPZKRP
EXLOGLQJDQGUXQQLQJKDVEHHQFRQÀGHGWRDQLQGXVWULDOFRQVRUWLXP7KLVSODWIRUP
LPSOHPHQWV WKH ODWHVW WHFKQRORJLHV RI PHGLFDO LPDJH SURFHVVLQJ DQG RI FORXG
FRPSXWLQJ,WLVEXLOWLQRUGHUWRVXSSRUWVHUYLFHRULHQWHGHQWHUSULVHDUFKLWHFWXUH
5HVXOWV7KHSODWIRUPLVLQQRYDWLYHEHLQJWKHÀUVWRQHFRQWDLQLQJDOOWKHPDWHULDOV
IRUWKHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRI3$&6VHUYLFHVLQWKHFORXGDOORZLQJIRUHDFKKHDOWKFDUH
VWUXFWXUHWRRSHQWKHVHVHUYLFHVEH\RQGLWVERUGHUV7KHSODWIRUPKDVMXVWEHHQ
YDOLGDWHGE\WKHKHDOWKVWUXFWXUHVLQYROYHGLQWKHSLORWSKDVHDQGWKHSURJUDPPHKDV
HQWHUHGLQGXVWULDOGHSOR\PHQWSKDVH$GGLWLRQDOO\QHZ6XSHU3$&6OLNHVHUYLFHV
DUHSURSRVHGLQFOXGLQJDFFHVVWRWKHLPDJHVSURGXFHGLQKRVSLWDOVWRWKH*3V
DQGVKDULQJRIUDGLRORJLFDODGYLFHVVHUYLFHVZRUNOIRZV
$UH\RXNHHSLQJXSWRGDWH"2YHUKDOIRILPSRUWDQWUDGLRORJLFDO
UHVHDUFKLVSXEOLVKHGLQQRQUDGLRORJLFDOMRXUQDOV
<.ZRQJ./DWLHI1RWWLQJKDP8. GU\XQH#KRWPDLOFRP
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
5HVXOWV(YHU\VHTXHQFHLVGHÀQHGE\LWVVHTXHQFHIDPLO\DQFHVWRUWLPLQJGLDJUDP
DQGGHVFULSWLRQSDUDPHWHUVDUWHIDFWVDQGSUREOHPVFOLQLFDODSSOLFDWLRQVGXUDWLRQ
PDWKHPDWLFDOPRGHOOLQJDQGSRVVLEOHUHVXOWVDFURQ\PVDQG',&20GHVFULSWLRQ
:HFDQLQWHUDFWZLWKWKHRQWRORJ\PDNLQJTXHU\7KHRQWRORJ\FRXOGEHPRGLÀHG
DWDQ\PRPHQWDFFRUGLQJWRWKHODVWRXWFRPHV
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHREWDLQHGRQWRORJ\JLYHVDUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRI05,VHTXHQFHVWKDW
FDQEHXVHGIRUHGXFDWLRQRUFOLQLFDOH[SORLWDWLRQ
%
&RQVLGHUDWLRQVIRUVKDULQJUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWVDQGLPDJHVRQD
QDWLRQDOOHYHOLQ/X[HPERXUJ
85RWK10DFN%6FKURHGHU+=LPPHUPDQQ/X[HPERXUJ/8
XZHURWK#WXGRUOX
3XUSRVH7KHH[FKDQJHRIUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWVDQGLPDJHVRQDQDWLRQDOOHYHOGH
PDQGVLQFRPSDULVRQWRWKHH[FKDQJHLQRUGLQDU\LQKRXVHV\VWHPVDGGLWLRQDO
DQG KLJKHU VHFXULW\ UHTXLUHPHQWV FRQFHUQLQJ GDWD SURWHFWLRQ ,Q DQ\ FDVH WKH
FRPPXQLFDWLRQ VKRXOG UHO\ RQ FXUUHQW VWDQGDUGV 7KH SUREOHP WKDW KDV WR EH
IDFHGLVWKHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQRIJDSVLQWKHVHVWDQGDUGVWKDWDULVHIURPWKHVKLIWLQWR
WKHQDWLRQDOFRQWH[W
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV&RPPXQLFDWLRQZLWKWKHQDWLRQDOSODWIRUPZLOOEHPDLQO\
EDVHGRQ,+(;'6;'6,DQG3,;SURÀOHVXVLQJGRFXPHQWUHSRVLWRULHVIRUWKH
VWRUDJHRIWKHUHSRUWVDQGLPDJHPDQLIHVWÀOHVDQGDUHJLVWU\VHUYLFHIRUWKHVWRU
DJHRIGRFXPHQWUHIHUHQFHVSOXVDGGLWLRQDOPHWDGDWD7RSURWHFWGDWDLQVLGHWKH
UHSRVLWRU\DJDLQVWLQWHQWLRQDORUDFFLGHQWDOPLVXVHLWQHHGVWREHVWRUHGHQFU\SWHG
)RUWKHSURWHFWLRQRIWKHGRFXPHQWUHIHUHQFHVDQGPHWDGDWDWKLVLQIRUPDWLRQKDV
WREHVWRUHGGHLGHQWLÀHG
5HVXOWV7RGD\,+(GRHVQRWVXSSRUWGHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQDQGHQGWRHQGGRFXPHQW
HQFU\SWLRQ$VDUHVXOWWKHLQKRXVHLQIUDVWUXFWXUHLVDWWDFKHGWRWKHQDWLRQDOSODW
IRUPYLDDFRQQHFWRUWKDWFRYHUVDOODVSHFWVRIGHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQDQGHQFU\SWLRQ$
WUXVWHGWKLUGSDUW\SURYLGHVWKHGHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQ,WDOORZVWKHVHSDUDWLRQRIGHPR
JUDSKLFGDWDIURPLWVSVHXGRQ\PZKLFKLVQHYHUNQRZQLQWKHLQKRXVHV\VWHPV
,IGDWDDUHDFFHVVHGWKHWUXVWHGWKLUGSDUW\ZLOODOVRDFWDVDUHNH\VHUYLFHIRUWKH
LQGLYLGXDOO\XVHGHQFU\SWHGHQFU\SWLRQNH\V
&RQFOXVLRQ7KHSURSRVHGQDWLRQDOH[FKDQJHSODWIRUPFRPELQHVWKHXVHRI,+(
SURÀOHVZLWKDGGLWLRQDOVHFXULW\IHDWXUHVOLNHGHLGHQWLÀFDWLRQDQGHQFU\SWLRQWKURXJK
WKHXVHRIDQDGGLWLRQDOFRQQHFWRUFRPSRQHQW
%
'HGLFDWHGZRUNÁRZVROXWLRQWRIDFLOLWDWHFRQVLVWHQWUHSURGXFLEOH
DQGHIÀFLHQWSDWLHQWPRQLWRULQJLQRQFRORJLFDOWULDOVDQGURXWLQH
0%DXPKDXHU06HLWHO+HLGHOEHUJ'( PEDXPKDXHU#GNI]KHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH:HLQWURGXFHDQHZDQGGHGLFDWHGVRIWZDUHV\VWHPWRPDQDJHRQFRORJLF
ZRUNÁRZV7KHZRUNLQJFRQFHSWKDVEHHQGHYHORSHGIURPJURXQGXSDQGRSWLPLVHG
WRPHHWWKHLQFUHDVLQJO\FRPSOH[UHTXLUHPHQWVRIFDQFHUWKHUDS\PRQLWRULQJ2XU
ZRUNLVPRWLYDWHGE\WKHLQFUHDVLQJDPRXQWDQGFRPSOH[LW\RILPDJLQJFULWHULDLQ
RQFRORJLFUDGLRORJ\DQGWKHODFNRIVRIWZDUHWKDWSURYLGHVDYDLODELOLW\DQGHDV\
DFFHVVWRSUHFHGLQJLPDJHDVVHVVPHQWVDXWRPDWLFDOO\XSGDWHGVWDWLVWLFVDQGD
GHÀQHGZRUNLQJFRQFHSWWRHQVXUHFRQVLVWHQF\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV %DFNJURXQG RI WKH VRIWZDUH LV D JHQHUDO UHTXLUHPHQW
DQDO\VLVIRURQFRORJLFDOSDWLHQWPDQDJHPHQWZRUNÁRZVFRQGXFWHGLQ6WDUW
LQJ ZLWK DQ LQKRXVH GHYHORSPHQW LGHQWLÀHG GHÀFLWV RI FRPPHUFLDOO\ DYDLODEOH
VRIWZDUH ZDV DGGUHVVHG$PRQJ WKHP DUH $Q RSWLPLVHG GDWD PRGHO LQFOXGH
UHOHYDQWFRQWH[WLQIRUPDWLRQOLNHSDWLHQWWKHUDS\VFKHPHFOLQLFDOWULDODIÀOLDWLRQ
LPDJLQJFULWHULDOHVLRQFKDUDFWHULVWLFV)OH[LELOLW\LQTXDQWLWDWLYHOHVLRQDVVHVVPHQW
FRQGXFWXQOLPLWHGFRUUHODWHGPHDVXUHPHQWVLQXQOLPLWHG05&73(7VWXGLHVDQG
VHULHVIRUXQOLPLWHGIROORZXSV&RQVLVWHQF\E\DXWRPDWLQJURXWLQHSURFHGXUHV
FOLQLFDO WULDO PDQDJHPHQW DXWRPDWHG RYHUDOO UHVSRQVH HYDOXDWLRQ DQG FULWHULD
FRQIRUPDQFHYDOLGDWLRQ
5HVXOWV6LQFHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHVRIWZDUHLVDYDLODEOHXQGHUWKHODEHORIPLQW
/HVLRQDV&(PDUNHGSURGXFWLQ(XURSHE\DQHZO\IRXQGHGVSLQRIIFRPSDQ\
RI*HUPDQ&DQFHU5HVHDUFK&HQWUH0LGWHUPIHHGEDFNRIRXUUHIHUHQFHXVHUV
DWWHVWWKHV\VWHPҋVIHDVLELOLW\DQGVKRZWKHKLJKSRWHQWLDOIRUDDSSOLFDWLRQLQWULDOV
DQGURXWLQHSDWLHQWFDUH
&RQFOXVLRQ:KLOHLPSURYLQJFRQVLVWHQF\TXDOLW\DQGVDIHW\PLQW/HVLRQDLPV
DWOHYHUDJLQJWKHURXWLQHZRUNORDG)XWXUHUHVHDUFKZLOODVVHVVWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVV
RIPLQW/HVLRQLQSUDFWLFDOURXWLQH
6
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
%
0DQDJLQJ,7VHUYLFHVLQDFRPSOHWHO\GLJLWLVHGUDGLRORJLFDO
GHSDUWPHQWZLWKDQLQKRXVHGHSDUWPHQWDO,7JURXSD\HDU
IROORZXSH[SHULHQFH
+6WUXEH6:LUWK0)5HLVHU07UHLWO
0XQLFK'( KDQQDVWUXEH#PHGXQLPXHQFKHQGH
3XUSRVH7RHYDOXDWHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIDGHSDUWPHQWDOLQIRUPDWLRQWHFKQRORJ\
,7 JURXSFRPSDUHGWRKRVSLWDO,7DQGV\VWHPPDQXIDFWXUHUҋVVXSSRUWLQDFRP
SOHWHO\GLJLWLVHGUDGLRORJLFDOGHSDUWPHQWEDVHGRQVHYHQ\HDUVRIH[SHULHQFH7KH
SRWHQWLDOWRUHGXFHPDQXIDFWXUHUҋVVHUYLFHDQGWRPDQDJHXQNQRZQ,7SUREOHPV
ZHUHLQYHVWLJDWHG
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV7KHGHSDUWPHQWDO,7JURXSPDLQWDLQVWKHUDGLRORJ\LQ
IRUPDWLRQV\VWHP 5,6 DQGSLFWXUHDUFKLYLQJDQGFRPPXQLFDWLRQV\VWHP 3$&6
XVLQJDQLQWUDQHWEDVHGUHSRUWLQJV\VWHP,7SUREOHPVDUHVSHFLÀHGDFFRUGLQJWR
XUJHQF\UHVSRQVLELOLW\DQGDIIHFWHGV\VWHP$QHZ5,63$&6DQGDVSHHFKUHFRJ
QLWLRQV\VWHPZHUHLQVWDOOHG7KHSHUIRUPDQFHDQGPHDQWLPHIRUWURXEOHVKRRWLQJ
E\WKHGLIIHUHQWSURYLGHUVZHUHHYDOXDWHG
5HVXOWV,QPRQWKV,7SUREOHPVHPHUJHGZHUHVROYHGE\WKH
GHSDUWPHQWDO ,7JURXS ZLWKLQ WKH WLPH OLPLW ZLWK KLJK VROXWLRQ UDWHV IRU
EUHDNGRZQVRIWKHFOLQLFDOLQIRUPDWLRQV\VWHPV VWDQGDUGKDUG
DQGVRIWZDUH LQFOXGLQJ5,6 DQGDFFHSWDEOHVROXWLRQUDWHIRU3$&6
DQG LPDJLQJ GHYLFHV FDVHV UHTXLUHG D WURXEOHVKRRWLQJ
ZLWKLQK VROYHGZLWKLQPLQE\GHSDUWPHQWDO,7JURXS ,QRIWKH
FDVHVPDQXIDFWXUHUҋVVXSSRUWZDVLQGLVSHQVDEOH2YHUWLPHWKHWRWDODPRXQWRI
,7SUREOHPVGHFUHDVHGE\XSWRIRUHPHUJHQF\DQGYHU\XUJHQWSUREOHPV
EXWLQFUHDVHGIRUSUREOHPVRIORZHUXUJHQF\7KHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQRIQHZ5,63$&6
OHGWRDVKRUWLQFUHDVHLQWKHWRWDOQXPEHURI,7SUREOHPVWKRXJKWKRVHSUREOHPV
PRVWO\ZHUHRIORZSULRULW\
&RQFOXVLRQ$ GHSDUWPHQWDO ,7JURXS SURYLGHV IDVW WURXEOHVKRRWLQJ VROYLQJ D
FRQVLGHUDEOH SURSRUWLRQ RI RFFXUULQJ DQG HYHQ QHZ ,7SUREOHPV QHFHVVLWDWLQJ
PDQXIDFWXUHUҋVVXSSRUWRQO\LQDVPDOOQXPEHURIFDVHV
%
,WHPLVHGRUSURVHUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWV"$VXUYH\RIKRVSLWDOFOLQLFLDQV
DQGUDGLRORJLVWVҋSUHIHUHQFHV
/:*RK+67HK6LQJDSRUH6* /LQ:DK*RK#PRKKFRPVJ
3XUSRVH 7R GHWHUPLQH FOLQLFLDQVҋ DQG UDGLRORJLVWVҋ SUHIHUHQFHV UHJDUGLQJ WKH
IRUPDWRIWKHUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWDQGFRQWHQWV
0HWKRGVDQG0DWHULDOV4XHVWLRQQDLUHVZHUHVHQWRXWWRDOOFOLQLFLDQVIURPYDULRXV
GHSDUWPHQWVDQGUDGLRORJLVWVSUDFWLFLQJZLWKLQ.KRR7HFN3XDW+RVSLWDO6LQJDSRUH
7KHSDUWLFLSDQWVZHUHLQYLWHGWRUDQNDYDULHW\RIK\SRWKHWLFDOXOWUDVRXQGDQGFRP
SXWHGWRPRJUDSK\VFDQUHSRUWVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLUOHYHORIVDWLVIDFWLRQDQGSURYLGHG
UHDVRQVIRUWKHLUFKRLFHV'HPRJUDSKLFLQIRUPDWLRQUHJDUGLQJWKHSDUWLFLSDQWVZDV
REWDLQHGLQWKHTXHVWLRQQDLUH
5HVXOWV$WRWDORIUDGLRORJLVWVDQGFOLQLFLDQVUHVSRQGHGRIFOLQLFLDQV
YV RI UDGLRORJLVWV ZHUH VDWLVÀHG ZLWK WKH LWHPLVHG UHSRUW IRU DQ DEQRUPDO
XOWUDVRXQGVFDQ S RIUDGLRORJLVWVYVRIFOLQLFLDQVZHUHVDWLVÀHG
ZLWKWKHSURVHUHSRUWIRUDQDEQRUPDOXOWUDVRXQGVFDQ S ,QJHQHUDOPRVW
UDGLRORJLVWVVWLOOSUHIHUUHGWKHSURVHUHSRUWLQJVW\OHFLWLQJIDPLOLDULW\ZLWKWKLVVW\OH
RIUHSRUWLQJ0RVWFOLQLFLDQVSUHIHUUHGLWHPLVHGUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWVDVWKH\IHOWWKDW
WKHVHUHSRUWVZHUHFOHDUHUDQGHDVLHUWRFRPSUHKHQG
&RQFOXVLRQ,WHPLVHGUHSRUWVDUHPRUHSRSXODUZLWKUHIHUULQJFOLQLFLDQVGXHWRWKHLU
FODULW\3URVHUHSRUWVIRVWHUDODFNRIVWDQGDUGLVDWLRQRIFRQWHQWDPRQJGLIIHUHQW
UDGLRORJLVWV$VKLIWLQSDUDGLJPWRLWHPLVHGUHSRUWLQJZLOOPDNHIRUIDVWHUPRUH
FRQVLVWHQWUDGLRORJ\UHSRUWVWKDWIDFLOLWDWHFRPSOHWHGRFXPHQWDWLRQRILQIRUPDWLRQ
DQGPHDVXUHPHQWV&KDQJLQJWKHZD\UDGLRORJ\UHSRUWVDUHVWUXFWXUHGUHTXLUHV
DGDSWDWLRQDPRQJUDGLRORJLVWV,PSURYHGWUDLQLQJLQUHSRUWLQJGXULQJWKHUDGLRORJ\
UHVLGHQF\LVGHULJXHXUWRIDPLOLDULVHUDGLRORJLVWVZLWKDQHZVW\OHRIUHSRUWLQJ
%
$ZHEEDVHGGRFXPHQWDWLRQV\VWHPZLWKH[FKDQJHRI',&2057
GDWDIRUPXOWLFHQWHUFOLQLFDOVWXGLHVLQSDUWLFOHWKHUDS\
.$.HVVHO1%RXJDWI&%RKQ'2HW]HO8(QJHOPDQQ
5%HQGO-'HEXV6(&RPEV+HLGHOEHUJ'('RVVHQKHLP'(
+HLOEURQQ'( .HUVWLQ.HVVHO#PHGXQLKHLGHOEHUJGH
3XUSRVH&RQGXFWLQJFOLQLFDOVWXGLHVLVUDWKHUGLIÀFXOWEHFDXVHRIWKHODUJHYDULHW\
RIYROXPLQRXVGDWDVHWVGLIIHUHQWGRFXPHQWDWLRQVW\OHVDQGYDULRXVLQIRUPDWLRQ
V\VWHPVHVSHFLDOO\LQUDGLDWLRQRQFRORJ\
0HWKRGV DQG 0DWHULDOV :H GHYHORSHG D ZHEEDVHG GRFXPHQWDWLRQ V\VWHP
IRUWUDQVQDWLRQDODQGPXOWLFHQWHUFOLQLFDOVWXGLHVLQSDUWLFOHWKHUDS\SDWLHQWV
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
6FLHQWLILF6HVVLRQ
KDYH EHHQ WUHDWHG DW WKH +HLGHOEHUJ ,RQ 7KHUDS\ +,7 FHQWUH IURP 1RYHPEHU
WR$XJXVW3URWRQVFDUERQLRQVRUDFRPELQDWLRQRIERWKDVZHOODVD
FRPELQDWLRQZLWKSKRWRQVZHUHDSSOLHG7RGDWHVWXGLHVKDYHEHHQLQLWLDWHG
DQGPRUHDUHLQSUHSDUDWLRQ
5HVXOWV,WLVSRVVLEOHWRLPPHGLDWHO\DFFHVVDOOSDWLHQWLQIRUPDWLRQDQGH[FKDQJH
VWRUHSURFHVVDQGYLVXDOLVHWH[WGDWDDQ\',&20LPDJHVDQGPXOWLPHGLDGDWD
$FFHVVLQJWKHV\VWHPDQGVXEPLWWLQJFOLQLFDOGDWDDUHSRVVLEOH IRULQWHUQDODQG
H[WHUQDOXVHUV6HFXULW\DQGSULYDF\SURWHFWLRQLVHQVXUHGZLWKWKHHQFU\SWHGKWWSV
SURWRFROFOLHQWFHUWLÀFDWHVDQGDQDSSOLFDWLRQJDWHZD\)XUWKHUPRUHDOOGDWDFDQ
EHSVHXGRQ\PLVHG,QWHJUDWHGLQWRWKHKRVSLWDOHQYLURQPHQWGDWDDUHLPSRUWHGYLD
LQWHUIDFHVRYHU+/PHVVDJHVDQG',&206HYHUDOIXUWKHUIHDWXUHVUHSODFHPDQXDO
LQSXWDQGHQVXUHGDWDTXDOLW\DQGHQWLUHW\6WXGLHVFDQEHLQGLYLGXDOO\GHVLJQHG
WRÀWVSHFLÀFQHHGV%\LQFOXGLQJDOOWUHDWHGSDWLHQWV DOVRQRQVWXG\SDWLHQWV ZH
JDLQWKHSRVVLELOLW\IRURYHUDOOODUJHVFDOHUHWURVSHFWLYHDQDO\VHV
&RQFOXVLRQ+DYLQJUHFHQWO\EHJXQGRFXPHQWDWLRQRIRXUÀUVWSDWLHQWVLQVL[
FOLQLFDOVWXGLHVLWKDVEHFRPHDSSDUHQWWKDWWKHEHQHÀWVOLHLQWKHVLPSOLÀFDWLRQRI
UHVHDUFKZRUNEHWWHUVWXG\DQDO\VHVTXDOLW\DQGXOWLPDWHO\WKHLPSURYHPHQWRI
WUHDWPHQWFRQFHSWVE\HYDOXDWLQJWKHHIIHFWLYHQHVVRISDUWLFOHWKHUDS\
0RQGD\
(XURSHDQ&RQJUHVVRI 5DGLRORJ\
$
%
&
'
(
)
*
+
6